The text and the illustrations The text and the illustrations are The text and the illustrations are Appearance/ are visually appealing, clear, clear and colorful. No more than adequate and clear. More than Neatness and colorful. The book is free a few smudges or stray marks are three smudges or stray marks are from smudges and stray marks. visible. visible. Satisfactory idea development Unclear, incorrect, or limited Exceptional idea development Content with some supporting details idea development with lack of with supporting details written written mainly in the author’s details. Author’s own words are Knowledge in the author’s own words, or own words, or correctly credited not used, or quotes are not correctly credited if quoted. if quoted. correctly credited. Image Images detract from or are Images are highly engaging for Images are appropriate to content inappropriate for content and Communication content and audience. and audience. audience. The book contains some The book contains only minor Mechanical errors distract the Mechanics mechanical errors. mechanical errors, but does not reader. distract the reader. Factual All letters are represented with All letters are represented with Letters are missing from the accurate information, minor errors in information, book, or information is largely Information interesting information, and undeveloped information, or incorrect, or illustrations are not (A-Z) relevant illustrations. irrelevant illustrations. accurate.