Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Ancient Warfare Magazine - Vol XVI, Issue 1, 2022
Ancient Warfare Magazine - Vol XVI, Issue 1, 2022
Ancient Warfare Magazine - Vol XVI, Issue 1, 2022
US $12.75
CAD $14.99
PIRACY AND
0 1
0
29074 07412
Subscriptions
38 In the wake of Alexander 46 Raids across the Danube
Wars of the Mauryan Empire The impact of the Getae and Dacians
Subscriptions can be purchased at www.kp-shop.com,
via phone or by email. For the address, see above.
44 The Persian akinakes 50 Upholding military standards
Distribution An emblem of distinction 3\JP\Z+\JJP\Z9\ÄU\Z[VTIZ[VUL
Ancient Warfare is sold through retailers, the internet
and by subscription. The exclusive distributor for the UK
and the Republic of Ireland is Seymour Distribution Ltd,
2 East Poultry Avenue, London, EC1A 9PT, United King-
DEPART S
dom. Phone: +44 (0)207 429 4000. 4 Preliminaries 56 Book reviews
Copyright Karwansaray B.V. All rights reserved. Noth- News and updates A few recent ancient warfare titles
ing in this publication may be reproduced in any form
without prior written consent of the publishers. Any 52 The decurion's deputies
individual providing material for publication must en- 6MÄJLYZVM[OL9VTHUJH]HSY`
sure that the correct permissions have been obtained
before submission to us. Every effort has been made
to trace copyright holders, but in few cases this proves
impossible. The editor and publishers apologize for
26 46
any unwitting cases of copyright transgressions and
would like to hear from any copyright holders not
acknowledged. Articles and the opinions expressed
herein do not necessarily represent the views of the
editor and/or publishers. Advertising in Ancient War-
fare does not necessarily imply endorsement.
ISSN: 1874-7019
)QNMਡB@S@OTKSਡANKSਡRS@LODCਡVHSGਡ,%'ਡ8)8 ਡNMDਡ
NEਡSGDਡUDQXਡQ@QDਡOHDBDRਡNEਡDUHCDMBDਡNEਡSGHRਡKD
x
FHNMRਡOQDRDMBDਡHMਡSGDਡ'DQL@MHBਡB@LO@HFMR
©ਡ-ਡ%ADQKDHM ਡ#NTQSDRXਡNEਡSGDਡ!QBG@DNKNFHRBGDਡ3S@@SRR@LLKTMF ਡ
Ancient Warfare XVI-1
4 -TMHBG ਡ'DQL@MX
measured some 25.0m x 25.0m (82 ft x 82 ft). by five military camps, such as at Tocolosi- The foundations of a watch tower
Shaped blocks of stone were found in two tri- da Ain Chkour, as well as watchtowers and measuring 5.0 x 5.5m near the city
al trenches. The shapes of several blocks indi- a defensive ditch (fossa). Towards the close of Volubilis, Morocco. The remains
cated that they were part of a rounded corner of the second century AD, a 2.5km (1.6 mi) of an unidentified circular building
can also be seen.
of an as-yet unknown building. Tentatively, the circuit wall with eight gates and forty tow-
© Karol Bartczak
archaeologists believe that this structure was ers was constructed around the city. Despite
erected and used by Roman troops. the installations, Volubilis was taken by local
The research team from University of tribes around AD 285. Rome never again re-
Warsaw and Université Hassan II de Casa- established control.
blanca have been working together in Mo- The first phase of the excavations was
rocco to answer the question about the ap- preceded by two seasons of ground surface
pearance and functioning of the border surveys. The results are published as ‘Tingi-
defence system (limes) of the province of tana Frontier Project. Rapport préliminaire
Mauritania Tingitana, the westernmost Ro- de recherche de la mission polono-maro- MORE ONLINE
man territory in North Africa. caine dans la région de Volubilis au Maroc Read the original ar-
chaeological report:
The Roman province’s southernmost pendant la saison 2018’ in Polish Archaeol-
https://bit.ly/3V8zrJ3
city was Volubilis. It was protected from raids ogy in the Mediterranean volume 29/2.
x
ਡ© 4GDਡ6HMCNK@MC@ਡ4QTRS
A reenactor representing a cornicen, the hornblower, while allowing for some of watches are called by
with his cornu. Complete versions of its weight to be held on his shoulder. the trumpeter [tubicen] and at
the instrument are exceedingly rare. The brassy sound of a cornu was produced the end of their time by the hornblower [cor-
© Carole Raddato / Flickr
by the vibrations of the player’s lips through the nicen]” (Vegetius, On Military Matters 3.8). He
mouthpiece. There were no keys or valves. also mentions that the cornu was one of the in-
Cornua are depicted in use in military, struments used to play the classicum or fanfare
ceremonial and entertainment contexts, in the presence of the commander, or at the ex-
such as on Trajan’s Column in Rome. A com- ecution of a soldier indicating it was being car-
plete instrument was found in Pompeii; it ried out under his authority.
was played during gladiatorial combats. An auxiliary cohort, like Cohors I Tungro-
The Roman army used the cornu to trans- rum milliaria peditata, which was stationed at
mit orders to troops on the march and in bat- Vindolanda during the Hadrianic-period, had
tle. The instrument was used in concert with a cornu for each of its ten centuriae.
the movement of the unit’s standard (sig- The mouthpiece is a first-of-its-kind in
num). The cornu announced advances the Vindolanda collection. It has been con-
and retreats. Vegetius writes: “all the served and is now undergoing further study.
in Syracuse and Agrigento; seven of the mass Their findings are published as ‘The di-
graves are associated with this battle. It lost verse genetic origins of a Classical period MORE ONLINE
the subsequent battle of 409 BC, when Hi- Greek army’ in Proceedings of the National Read the researcher's
original findings:
merans fought unassisted; two of the graves Academy of Sciences of the United States of
https://bit.ly/3Eembfa
are associated with this battle. America (PNAS), volume 119, number 42.
By studying genome-wide data from 54
individuals dated to the eighth-to-fifth centu-
ries BC, the scientists gained new insights into
π HAVE YOU READ? By Tristan Hughes
Opporni iders
Understanding piracy at the end of the Bronze Age is fraught with controversy.
There is no contemporary word for the concept, yet archaeological evidence
and even some minimal textual references make it possible to speak of pirati-
cal activity in the Late Bronze Age. Numerous discussions of ancient seaborne
tribes collectively referred to as ‘Sea People’ in modern studies frequently
describe them as raiders or pirates. That said, applying the label does not re- A thirteenth-century BC cuneiform tab-
let from an official in Lebanon to the
place an explanation of what it meant to be a pirate in the twelfth century BC. king of Ugarit concerning a boat-load
of timber. Now in the Louvre, Paris.
© Livius.org
n a series of articles, my colleague Aren about later piracy in that pirates of various
I
Maeir and I sought to develop an expla- time periods are known to use hit-and-run
nation of what it meant to be a pirate tactics and to desolate coastlines at night, but
in the Late Bronze Age. We did this by were usually unsuccessful in direct combat.
constructing an anthropological mod- Such tactics were effective in achieving the
el of what a culture of piracy might consist of aims of pirates in terms of acquiring ‘booty’ as
through examination of our sources from the well as minimizing casualties.
classical era through to the eighteenth century Finally, a Linear B tablet written in an early
(AD!) to see which features remained constant form of Greek from the Mycenaean palace at
through time, while excluding features that Pylos informs us of a tense situation develop-
were culturally and temporally specific. The ing at the end of the Bronze Age, stating that
model we developed was also constrained by “watchers are guarding the coast”, suggesting
the evidence: fragmentary textual accounts or threats from the sea, possibly pirates. There
references (pirates tended not to write their own were certainly foreigners arriving in the king-
histories), weapons, depictions of their panoply dom of Pylos. The lawagetas, leader of the peo-
and ships, Mediterranean geography, feasting ple, whose rank was second to that of the king, A typical bronze Mycenean pe-
remains, and what we know of the consump- may have functioned as a type of minister of riod helmet (from Mycenae) with
tion habits of the era. migration, helping to integrate foreign workers punched geometric decoration, ca.
into Mycenaean society. If migrants could trav- 1400-1300 BC, now in the Ash-
Textual references el to Pylos, so too could pirates.
molean Museum, Oxford. Such hel-
Our earliest textual information that suggests mets can be seen in Mycenean art
throughout the Aegean.
piratical activity comes from Hittite accounts, Social order © Gts-tg / Wikimedia Commons
which mention a captive escaping the Shek- Regarding the social order of pirates, most
elesh (Sicels?), while other texts mention on- (early-modern) accounts view their society as
going raids by individuals from Ahhiyawa egalitarian, with seized goods and food being
(Achaean or Mycenaean Greece) and Mill- equally shared, with maybe a bit extra for a
awanda (Miletus), a Mycenaean colony. doctor and the captain. Typically, the captain
Inscriptions from Egypt, most famously might be someone who demonstrated supe-
from Medinet Habu, where the Sea Peo- rior skill. We cannot speculate about medi-
ple are also depicted in reliefs in the
cine aboard a ship in the twelfth century
temple of Rameses III, provide us with
BC; however, regarding a captain, there is
the tribal names of the Sea People, men-
nothing in the Medinet Habu depictions
tion that some of them served as mer-
of the Sea People that makes one person
cenary soldiers in the Egyptian army,
stand out among others as a captain, with
and claim success in repulsing various
the exception of one individual that has
tribes of them. This fits what we know
his hands bound and is facing forward.
4GHRਡSVDKESG BDMSTQXਡ"#ਡ#XOQHNSਡ
x
AQNMYDਡROD@QGD@CਡV@RਡOQNA@AKXਡO@QSਡ
NEਡ@ਡI@UDKHMਡVHSGਡ@ਡਡBLਡAK@CD
© 4GDਡ-DSQNONKHS@Mਡ-TRDTLਡNEਡ!QS Ancient Warfare XVI-1
9
Biblical accounts of the We might conceive of the various tribes
Philistines refer to their of Sea Peoples in a similar way, with the tribal
king as a seren, a word name being more of an administrative desig-
that seems to derive from nation than an actual ethnic one. We know
the Luwian (an Anatolian that not all Cilician or Barbary pirates came
language) term tarwanis. The from a single origin but they were melded into
title tarwanis is understood a cultural group through their ship-borne ex-
as war lord, a fitting title for a istence. Their different ethnic origins might be
pirate captain, and is attested in seen as reflected in their ship design, weap-
later Greek as tyrannos or tyrant. ons, ritual items, and drinking practices as
Pirate groupings are typi- discussed below. It is also possible to suggest
cally not large, although Cilician and that they came from the non-elite classes, and
Chinese pirate groupings seem to have that these were happy to throw off the yoke
been exceptions. By contrast, in Villains of All of kings that pressed them into hard labour to
Nations, Marcus Rediker discusses how North maintain their elite lifestyles.
Atlantic piracy expanded from just two origi-
The 'Warrior Krater' from Mycenae nal ships to a total number of about 3,500 pi- Food, feasting, and plundering
has been dated to the twelfth cen- rates. This occurred as these initial ships took Feasting is mentioned second only to fighting
tury BC or as late as the eighth cen- more and more prizes and attracted more and in Homer’s Iliad, where a new term for feast-
tury. Mycenaean warriors have been ing – δαíς (dais), "to share" – comes into use.
more followers. We have compared this pro-
associated with the Sea Peoples.
cess and subsistence strategies to hunter-gath- If we are correct in regarding the shipboard
The bundles attached to the spear
shafts suggest travel. er tribes, whereby as groups grew too large for life of the Sea Peoples as egalitarian, this rep-
© Dan Lundberg / Flickr the catchment zone or local habitat, segments resents a marked change from the activity of
might split or fission off into new groups oc- feasting in Mycenaean Greece. The Linear B
cupying a new catchment zone. texts along with animal bone remains indicate
Pirate tribes frequently attracted new fol- that feasts were provisioned by the palaces
lowers through dissatisfaction among state- and that such feasts were ‘diacritical’. This re-
sponsored groups of sailors or workers. Such fers to hierarchical access to enjoying the best
persons were attracted by the lesser workload, food, wine, and access to the king. A domi-
greater autonomy, and better access to food. nant cultural feature among the various tribes
Occasionally, a prisoner might improve their of Sea Peoples was a preference for Mycenae-
status by joining a pirate tribe. Membership in an Greek drinking culture, whereby a drinking
such a tribe might be attained through what an- set consisted of a large bowl known as a krater
Detail of an ivory panel game board thropologists call rites of transmission. This is – coming from the Greek krasis, meaning to
from Enkomi, Cyprus (either made mix wine and water – and smaller bowls that
also a rite of transition whereby the new mem-
locally or in Syria). The figure be-
bers might be required to engage in an ordeal, could be used both for drinking wine and for
hind the chariot may represent a
such as killing an enemy or some other activity eating stews or porridges. Mycenaean styles of
Sea People mercenary.
© Paul Hudson/ Wikimedia Commons that might serve to bind them to the tribe. pottery were popular throughout the Mediter-
ranean by the end of the Bronze Age and were
familiar products from Cyprus to Sardinia.
What is interesting is that in the final century
of the Mycenaean civilization, the thirteenth
century BC, the deep bowl, resembling a min-
iature krater, replaced the stemmed kylix as
the preferred drinking vessel. This might
be another example of the growing dis-
tance between palatial elites and rural
populists. Drinking activities were
popular and served to bind people
together, becoming symbolic of
Sea Peoples’ identities, much as
the Jolly Roger became a rallying
symbol in North Atlantic piracy.
4VNਡ.TQ@FHBਡAQNMYDਡV@QQHNQਡ
RS@STDSSDRਡAQNMYDSSH ਡEQNLਡ
3@QCHMH@ ਡENTMCਡHMਡ@Mਡ%SQTRB@Mਡ
x
SNLAਡ ਡODQG@ORਡDUHCDMBDਡNEਡ
OHQ@SHB@KਡQ@HCHMF
© 3@HKJNਡਡ7HJHLDCH@ਡ#NLLNMR
Ancient Warfare XVI-1
10
&HFTQHMDਡNEਡSGDਡGNQMDCਡ)MFNSਡ'NCਡ mestic, burial, and ritual contexts. These imple- Evidence of piracy in the Late
EQNLਡ%MJNLH ਡ#XOQTR ਡB@ਡ
x
ਡ"# ਡCDOHBSDCਡ@Rਡ@ਡV@QQHNQਡ@MCਡVHSGਡ ments may have been introduced by the spread Bronze Age is widespread through-
NAUHNTRਡRHLHK@QHSHDRਡSNਡSGDਡ.TQ@FHBਡAQNMYDR of Italian slaves and pirates in the Mycenaean out the Mediterranean. Several ar-
© ,HUHTRNQF eas became 'infested' with pirates.
world. In addition, we know that the Mycenae-
We know that in the eighteenth cen- ans were present in Italy by the thirteenth cen-
© Richard Thomson
tury AD, greater access to food and tury BC as indicated by the local production of A Mycenaean terracotta long-
drink, along with reduced work hours, Mycenaean pottery. stemmed kylix (drinking cup) deco-
were a major motivation of luring reg- The Italian presence in Greece is credited rated with vertical whorl shells, ca.
ular sailors into piracy. What pirate for the appearance of these Italian-style groom- 1300-1190 BC, found at Zygouries
consumption habits also tell us is that ing implements, as well as a type of poorly ren- near Corinth, Greece. Many such cups
bright and shiny objects are no more dered handmade pottery known as Handmade have marine-themed decorations.
interesting to pirates than they are to © Metropolitan Museum of Art
Burnished Ware and, most importantly for
magpies, as recent research on both this article, the Naue II sword. The Naue II
indicates a preference for stealing food sword is a double-tanged cut-and-thrust
rather than a bauble. If pirates did sword, which made for a very effective
steal objects, it might have been combat weapon. Reinhard Jung has pin-
to barter for food or other ship- pointed its origins in Italy, and it seems to have
board necessities such as wood or bronze. quickly spread throughout the Mediterranean.
In fact, in the destruction at Ugarit, many valu- It has been suggested that the development
able ivory objects were found smashed. of iron technology for production of weapon-
ry was prompted as a response to this sword.
Pirate ‘Tacticool’ However, at present the temporal gap between
The age of piracy at the end of the Bronze Age the two different types of weapons seems to
also introduced the concept of warrior beauty, be too great. Seventeen examples of Naue II
which was already detectable in European war- swords have been found in Greece, Crete, and
rior burials. Italian-style razors and tweezers, other islands during the
sometimes accompanied by swords and even Bronze to Iron
amber beads, turn up in Late Bronze Age do-
x
ਡ4DKKਡ&@Q@
0GHKHRSHMDਡCDDOਡANVKਡEQNLRGDCਡ7@QDR
3HLHK@Qਡ(@MCL @CDਡ"T QMH
GQNTFGNTS
VDQDਡL@CDਡ@MCਡSQ@CDCਡS ਡ!DFD@M Ancient Warfare XVI-1
SGDਡ"QNMYD !FD
© :TMJHQਡਡ7HJHLDCH@ਡ#
NLLNMR 11
Drawing of a relief on Rameses Age transition. Although this may not seem like together but grouped separately as on the fa-
III's Mortuary Temple at Medinet very many, we must assume that bronze was mous Warrior Krater from Mycenae. Similar
Habu, ca. 1178 BC, depicting the Sea recycled meaning that their discovery is de- panoplies with horned helmets are found in
People and their distinctive ships, pendent on finding un-looted tombs or a hast- the famous bronze statuettes of the Ingot God
headdresses, and weapons.
ily abandoned house. and Horned God from Enkomi. Both statuettes
© New York Public Library
The panoply of the pirates seems to have are depicted wearing horned helmets, and the
included a corselet, a small round shield with Ingot God also brandishes a round shield and
boss, occasionally greaves, and a sword and/or a spear. In the past, attempts have been made
spear. The main distinction among them seems to link the iconography of these statuettes to
to be in their helmet style, which was either Aegean iconography; however, they find their
a horned helmet or a feathered or spiky closest parallels in the bronzetti warrior figu-
helmet with the feathers coming from a rines from Sardinia.
metal ring encircling the Readers knowledgeable about Mycenae-
head. The meaning of an art or those who have closely read Homer’s
the helmet distinction is
Iliad will be familiar with the mention of the
unclear as both are worn
boars’ tusk helmet, famously depicted in the
by warriors brandishing
Aegean on fresco paintings, on pottery, and
weapons. In some cases, they
found in tombs. No early Iron Age iconograph-
might be depicted separately; in
ic or tomb evidence has been found for the
others they might be depicted
existence of the much-vaunted boars’ tusk hel-
.@TSHB@Kਡ@QBG@DNKNFHRS ਡ3GDKKDXਡ7@BG
VNNCDMਡLNCDKਡNEਡ@ਡ-XBDM@D@MਡF@KKDXਡRL@MM ਡ@QFTDCਡSG@SਡSGHRਡ
x
EQNLਡ!ATਡ'TQNAਡL@XਡG@UD
ADDMਡHMSDMSHNM@KKXਡCDOHBSDCਡVHSGਡVGDDKR
@QDਡJMNVMਡEQNLਡSGDਡK@SDQਡBTKSਡNEਡ$HN ਡ3TBGਡRGHORਡNMਡB@QSRਡ
MXRNRਡ@RਡVDKKਡ@RਡEQNLਡBK@R
RHB@Kਡ@BBNTMSRਡNEਡSQ@MRONQSHMFਡRGHORਡNUDQ
Ancient Warfare XVI-1 ਡ@ਡM@QQNVਡHRSGLTR
12 © 4GDਡ*ਡ0@TKਡ'DSSXਡ-TRDTL
met, and in fact Richard Janko suggested it may as a safe place to spend the non-
be known through tomb robbery. As a result, sailing season. Pirate tribes may
its mention in the Iliad may be anachronistic, have also made effective use of
representative of an elite that were overthrown sites where there were maritime
at the end of the Bronze Age. Recently the connections such as Millawan-
bronze headpiece of a so-called ‘hedgehog’ or da (Miletus) in coastal Anatolia
‘feathered’ helmet was found in Greece at the and various Canaanite sites,
cemetery at Portes in Arcadia. where some eventually settled,
We know ships from this period mainly resulting in the Philistine cul-
through iconography. The preferred ship was ture as an outcome.
the Mycenaean galley with fighting platform
and a bird head device adorning the prow and A pirate’s life for me?
stern. To this was added the brailed sail, a series Piracy was a dangerous activity, and pi-
rates adapted to hit-and-run or surprise tactics. Fragment of a decorated pithos,
of rings attached to the mast, which made the
ca. 1225-1200 BC, found at of Maa-
ship more manoeuvrable. A ring at the top of Wounded warriors could not row or fight, thus
Palaiokastro on Cyprus. This loca-
the mast seems to have been borrowed from there was a motivation to choose battles care- tion may have been (one of many)
Sardinia, as it's seen on Sardinian bronze ships. fully. Piracy in the Mediterranean was an activ- pirate hideouts along the coasts of
ity that waxed and waned over time, as we see the Greek islands.
Habitat with the later emergence of the Cilician pirates © Livius.org
Our understanding of preferred geography and again later of the Barbary pirates. Thus, we
by the Sea Peoples as pirates might be can think of piracy as a fluid concept, also af-
understood through a combination fected by circumstance. Moreover, the era of
of modern studies and the archaeo- Bronze Age piracy was short lived. As entrepre-
logical evidence. Peter Galvin studied neurs, pirates seem to be opportunists, and we
modern-era Mediterranean geography cannot be certain whether the desire to settle
as well as the North Atlantic and ar- was based upon diminished habitat – that is,
rived at some very practical observa- a decrease in the number of sites available to
tions regarding pirate geography. plunder – or was due to the fact that piracy and
Among these, he discusses choke plague caused the Hittites and the Egyptians to
points where the sea lanes become loosen their grip on their furthest possessions,
narrow enough that a group of ships making these regions desirable for settling. 0
The 'Gorge of the Dead' near Kato
might be spread out making them more Zakros, eastern Crete, is believed to
vulnerable to attack, projecting promon- Louise Hitchcock is Professor of Archaeol-
have been a pirate hideout. Origi-
tories that were easily defended and could ogy at the University of Melbourne. The re- nally it was a Minoan burial site,
serve as convenient places to spot passing search for this article was supported by the hence the name.
ships, and river valleys that could function National Endowment for the Humanities. © Louise Hitchcock
"QNMYDਡ.@TDਡ))ਡSXODਡRVNQC ਡSVDKESGਡ
x
BDMSTQXਡ"# ਡMNVਡHMਡ,XNMਡ3TBGਡRVNQCR
VDQDਡVHCDKXਡDWONQSDCਡSGQNTFGNTSਡSGD ਡ
ਡ
-DCHSDQQ@MD@Mਡ@MCਡTRDCਡNUDQਡ@ਡODQHNCਡ
NEਡRDUDMਡBDMSTQHDR
© 2@L@ਡਡ7HJHLDCH@ਡ#NLLNMR Ancient Warfare XVI-1
13
THEME: Ancient pirates
A unit of Assyrian soldiers, including
archers and cavalry is dispatched to
deal with an Iauna pirate raid but
arrives too late to prevent the sack-
ing of a seaside village.
© Seán Ó'Brógáin
GREEK PIRATES IN THE EIGHTH-CENTURY LEVANT? By Owain Williams
e Iaa he
In the late eighth century BC, the Assyrian governor of Phoenicia, Qurdi-Aššur-
lamur, wrote to Tiglath-Pileser III of a seaborne raid upon a place called Danabu.
These raiders, the Iauna, are thought to be Ionian Greeks. While this identifica-
tion is not definite, raiding was certainly important to Iron Age Greek culture.
uring the late ninth and early of Samsimuruna and Harişŭ and […]. A
D
eighth centuries, the territo- cavalryman came to the city of Dana[bu]
rial expansion of the Assyrian (to report this). I gathered up the available Some of the earliest
Empire stalled, with power- men and went (after them). (The Iauna) types of Corinthian helmet,
ful magnates increasing their did not get anything. When they saw my like this example from the British Mu-
own power at the expense of the king. One troops, they got into their boats and [dis- seum, were made from an upper and
such magnate was Šamši-ilu, field marshal of appeared] into the middle of the sea. lower half riveted together. Dated to
king Adad-nirari III, who increasingly portrayed the early seventh century BC.
(Adapted from Parker, 2000)
© Karwansaray Publishers
himself as acting independently of the office
of the king. Šamši-ilu’s power may have even While this letter is clear about where the raid
been a motivation for the revolt of several As- happened and who the raiders were, to a
syrian cities in the mid-eighth century. More- modern audience, the names Qurdi-Aššur-
over, during this period of stagnation, Assyria lamur uses are meaningless: we do not know
faced external threats, most notably from Urar- precisely where Samsimuruna and Harişŭ
tu, Assyria’s northern neighbour, who won a are, nor who the Iauna were.
number of significant victories against Assyria That said, there are hints that suggest a
in the mid-eighth century. general location of the raid and identity of
The accession of Tiglath-Pileser III marked the raiders. Unfortunately, this is the only
surviving reference to Harişŭ, meaning it will This relief from the North Gate of the
a reversal of Assyrian fortunes. He reduced the
Hittite fortress in Karatepe may depict
power of the magnates, dividing the territories likely remain unknown. However, Samsimu-
an Aegean-style ship. Alternately, it
they controlled into smaller individual units; runa appears in the annals of several Assyrian
may be a vessel from the local area,
he defeated Urartu, forcing the king to flee; kings, always in connection to the Phoeni- an ancestor of the Cilicians.
and he expanded Assyria’s power towards the cian coast. Thus, as Qurdi-Aššur- © Klaus-Peter Simon/ Wikimedia Commons
!ਡRG@QCਡEQNLਡ@MਡD@RSDQMਡ'QDDJਡ
NHMNBGNDਡC@SDCਡSNਡSGDਡRDUDMSGਡ
x
BDMSTQXਡ"#ਡ&QNLਡ!Kਡ-HM@ ਡ3XQH@
© 5MHUDQRHSXਡNEਡ0DMMRXKU@MH@ਡ-TRDTL
Ancient Warfare XVI-1
15
Pots and penteconters The spread of North Syrian goods across
the Mediterranean similarly suggests that it
The identification of the Iauna
with the Ionians is somewhat sup- was Greeks who were the primary carriers.
ported by the archaeological evi- The Phoenicians were undoubtedly active in
dence, which attests to a Greek North Syria, but North Syrian goods do not
presence in the eastern Mediter- appear in regions of the Mediterranean associ-
ranean in this period. Several sites ated with the Phoenicians in this period, such
along the Levantine coast have as North Africa, Sardinia, and Spain. On the
yielded Greek pottery fragments. other hand, as much as one quarter of eighth-
Al Mina, the port at the mouth of century and early seventh-century finds from
the river Orontes, possibly that of the Samian Heraion and Olympia are North
the Syro-Anatolian state of Kunulua, Syrian, and Greek art of the Orientalizing Pe-
has yielded more finds than any other riod bears closer similarities to North Syrian
site. So many, in fact, that the original work than Phoenician. There is even evidence
excavator thought it had been a Greek to suggest that there was a permanent Greek
settlement. However, the modern con- presence in North Syria. In Karatepe, a relief
sensus is that Al Mina was a trading depicting what has been described as an Ae-
port frequented by Greeks, Cypriots, gean-style ship has been found in the city’s
Phoenicians, and North Syrians. North Gate, and there may have been a Greek
Neo-Assyrian Period relief (ca. 744-
Up to ca. 700 BC, Greek pottery at Al Mina royal dynasty based in Adana.
727 BC) depicting an Assyrian sol-
is Euboean in character, with some Attic wares
dier returning (from a raid?) with Traders and raiders
his booty in tow. also present. This is confirmed by analysis of
the clay in the pottery finds. Of course, just be- The fact that Greek goods have been found in
© Osama Shukir Muhammed Amin /
Wikimedia Commons cause the finds are Greek, this does not mean the East, regardless of the quantity, does not
the traders who brought them were Greeks. The prove that the Iauna who raided the Phoeni-
Phoenicians, in particular, are renowned for cian coast were Ionian Greeks. When com-
being traders, and Phoenician goods from the bined with the literary and epigraphic record
tenth century BC and later have been found in for Greek raiding, however, the archaeological
Many of the states of the Northeast- significant quantities in Euboea and Attica. That evidence does reinforce such a conclusion.
ern Mediterranean were relatively pottery only appears in such numbers at those The Homeric epics contain many ref-
small, and so could mount no con- erences to raiding (see also issue XV.3). In
two sites for this early period, suggesting that it
certed resistance to pirate raids. Thus, modern scholarship, based largely upon
coastal communities and shipping was the Greeks who were the carriers, as Phoe-
nician traders would invariably have travelled comparing the archaeological record with
would remain vulnerable for many
centuries. to as great a number of markets as possible, not the material culture depicted in the epics,
© Richard Thomson restricted themselves to a small few. the Homeric epics are dated between 750
and 650 BC, making the poems, and their
references to raiding, roughly contempora-
neous with the raid of Nimrud Letter 69.
The cattle raid is the most common of its
kind in Homer. Andromache’s brothers were
killed by Achilles when he came for their cat-
tle (Iliad 6.424), Achilles forced Aeneas from his
cattle upon Mount Ida (Il. 20.91–92), and Od-
ysseus seeks to replace his livestock eaten by
the Suitors through raiding (Odyssey 23.356–
358). Such raids were reason enough for war
(Il. 1.152–156), as was the case in Nestor’s tale
of the war between Pylos and Elis (Il. 11.669–
682). Yet cattle and other livestock are a rather
cumbersome spoil to transport, and cattle raids
were likely confined to overland raids. Homer-
ic seaborne raids instead primary sought to cap-
ture slaves. Odysseus’ raid upon the Cicones of
4DQQ@BNSS@ਡRBTKOSTQDਡNEਡ@ਡAN@SਡEQNLਡ%QDSQH@ ਡ
x
ENTMCDCਡ@RਡSGDਡG@QANTQਡNEਡ,DEJ@MCH ਡSGDਡ
SNVMਡNEਡQNVDQRਡMNVਡHMਡSGDਡ!QBG@DNKNFHB@Kਡ
-TRDTLਡNEਡ%QDSQH@ ਡ%TAND@ ਡ'QDDBD
© /R@L@ਡ3GTJHQਡ-TG@LLDCਡ!LHMਡ7HJHLDCH@ਡ#NLLNMR
Ancient Warfare XVI-1
16
!ਡSXOHB@Kਡ!RRXQH@MਡRVNQC ਡB@RSਡHMਡ can even make a specific guess as to where in Limestone Orthostats, ca. 738 BC,
x
e pi te cw
at work
When northern Europeans and North Americans think of
piracy, the cultural blueprint that comes quickly to mind is
that of piracy in the Early Modern Caribbean. However, Car-
ibbean piracy is rather a misleading analogy when it comes
to approaching ancient Greek piracy, at least in its earlier
phases. A better analogy is Viking raiding of the early Mid-
dle Ages. Here, longship-owning elites who dominated so-
ciety crewed their ships with followers bonded to them by
reciprocal obligations and went roving abroad for summer
slaving and plundering raids, but also settled new lands.
By David Lewis
S
the Homeric poems – we find small, pre-state societies
dominated by wealthy galley-owners, who take their com-
panions (hetairoi) with them on summer plundering voy-
ages; these raiders sometimes settled in distant lands too.
We have seen (see Owain William’s article) that the first mention of
Greeks in cuneiform sources aligns very much with this model. The
ships used by these raiders were literally ‘longboats’ (ploia makra
in Greek), though they differed in numerous respects from Vi-
king longboats. Early Greek raiders typically used ships such
as penteconters (‘fifty-oared’ galleys) and triaconters
(‘thirty-oared’ galleys).
As time went by, most Greek communi- complex fiscal systems. In most places, the pri-
ties grew into states, with all that this term vate ownership of raiding galleys by wealthy
implies – public finances, written laws, men became a thing of the past … but not
and so on. The informal position of ‘Big everywhere. In his History of the Peloponne-
Man’ or Chief (basileus) of the early ar- sian War, Thucydides (1.5) noted that in some
chaic period eventually morphed into the northern parts of Greece such as Aetolia, peo-
formalized magistracies of the emergent ple still acted like Homeric raiders. Thucydides
Greek states, and by the 520s, large may as well have added Crete to this compari-
publicly owned trireme fleets (with son. Even after the death of Alexander and the
crews of around 200 per vessel) had beginning of what we now call the Hellenistic
appeared in the Aegean, funded by period, individuals from various regions of the
Greek world still practised private sea-raiding
Large white-on-red Etruscan pyxis, ca. 670-650
(leisteia, conventionally translated as ‘piracy’)
BC, decorated with what is identified as a 'cor-
sair' ship. From tomb 1 of the tumulus of San along rather archaic lines. Some non-Greeks
Paolo, Cerveteri (Caere), Italy.
© Sailko / Wikimedia Commons
such as Illyrians and Tyrrhenians (i.e. Etrus- to enslave or ransom, and any other booty that
cans) pursued similar practices into Aegean could be seized.
waters, and from the 130s onwards we have
the remarkable outbreak of so-called ‘Cilician’ Tools of the trade A hoard of 158 silver Corcyraean
piracy. Although referred to as ‘Cilician’ from In writing of the Trojan War, Thucydides re- coins now in the Archaeological
Museum of Corfu. Dating to
its main base in Cilicia, this phenomenon in- marks that the ships used by the Homeric he-
the late sixth – early fifth
volved mariners of multiple ethnicities operat- roes were not like triremes, but small and old century BC, the hoard
ing out of a network of bases and landfalls, fashioned like the pirate galleys of his own day. is believed to have
possibly in concert with Cretan pirates. Down For most of the period discussed here, Thucy- been deposited
to Pompey’s campaign against the pirates in dides’ remark rings true: Greek pirates tended around 480 BC.
67 BC (and even beyond), ancient Mediter- to favour small galleys with 50 or fewer oars- © Lauren van
Zoonen
ranean history was therefore marked by the men and usually no bronze ram to cap the cut-
violent exploits of small crews of men aboard water bow – after all, rams were expensive
galleys haunting the seas in search of captives and heavy, and the aim was to capture,
x
Mediterranean in the sixth century the wind was favourable, but which could be 4GDਡNAIDBSਡV@Rਡ@ਡUNSHUDਡ
BC. Some 20 men were required to NEEDQHMFਡSNਡSGDਡFNCCDRRਡ
stowed or left ashore on calm days. !QSDLHRਡ/QSGH@
man the oars. Built in Foça (ancient © ,@TQDMਡU@Mਡ:NNMDM
Several variants of the small, undecked,
Phokaea), just outside modern-day
oared galley were popular among pirates
Izmir, Turkey. is’ article on the lembos in AW XII.4). The
© Nejdet Duzen / Shutterstock during the Hellenistic period. The hemiolia
lembos eventually became popular among
was notorious. According to Theophrastus,
the cowardly man is one who, when at sea, Greek pirates, and with state navies too. An-
mistakes the outline of headlands for hemio- other common type of vessel used by pirates
liai – that is, pirate galleys bearing down upon was the myoparon, which likewise had a sin-
him. The word itself means “one-and-a-half- gle level of oarsmen; in his speech Against
er”, which must derive from the configuration Verres, Cicero lambasts the former Sicilian
of the oarsmen (just as trireme, trieres, got its governor for allowing a flotilla of four myopar-
name from its three-file-a-side rowing arrange- ones led by the pirate chief Heracleo into the
ment). The hemiolia probably had a full longi- harbour of Syracuse. The efflorescence of ‘Cili-
tudinal file of oarsmen either side of the vessel, cian’ piracy began, according to Appian, with
and an extra half file on each side amidships, the use of hemioliai and myoparones before
A pirate galley is shown about to
squeezed in where the vessel’s beam was these pirates graduated to using decked war-
board a merchantman on this Athe-
nian kylix made in the late sixth greatest – this would maximise the galley’s oar ships such as triremes. He writes that Pompey’s
century BC. power without adding wasteful superstructure. campaign of 67 BC netted some 377 vessels;
© Karwansaray Publishers In the Adriatic, Illyrian pirates typically used if Plutarch’s claim that 90 of the captured ves-
a small galley called a lembos, which seems sels had rams can be credited, then even at the
normally to have had a single level of height of ‘Cilician’ piracy, most of their ships
oarsmen, about 25 each side – in were small, ramless galleys of the traditional
other words, this vessel was sort. These ships were not the sole preserve of
not dissimilar to the archaic pirates, however: many states had such units in
penteconter (see their navies too, so we cannot think of Greek
George Topalid- pirate ships as a distinct class.
from them do evil to others” (7.3). Of the vari- pirates would put to sea in winter. As Casson
ous pirate bases known from antiquity, few are noted, we can see an attempt by a small galley
better attested than Myonnesos, ‘Mouse to run down a merchantman under a stiff wind
Island’, on the coast of Asia Mi- depicted in two stages on a late-archaic Attic
nor between Teos and Samos cup now kept in the British Museum (see page
(modern Çifitkalesi Adası). We 20). In the first scene we see a merchant ship
know from Livy that in 190 BC riding under shortened sail, whilst a two-level
it was being used by a gang of pi- galley bears down upon it with a full sail and
rates with a flotilla of fifteen galleys, every man to an oar. In the next scene, how-
keletes (a kind of merchant galley) and ever, we can see that the merchant has noticed
the danger and unfurled his sail in a vain at- The island of Antikythera served as
lemboi, who raided the island of Samos and
a pirate stronghold from the fourth
were chased back to their bolthole by a Roman tempt to escape as the attackers close in; one
– first century BC. Controlled by the
fleet. By the time of ‘Cilician’ piracy’s apogee, man aboard the galley is taking in sail, some of Phalasarnians, notorious pirates
many such landfalls and bases were occupied. the oarsmen have shipped their oars, and an- from Crete, this wall of the pirates'
other figure positions himself on the bow ready fort is well preserved.
In pursuit of a prize to board the merchantman. © Andronos Haris / Shutterstock
%SQTRB@Mਡ@LADQਡODMC@MS ਡ
B@ਡ ਡ"# ਡCDOHBS
x
HMFਡ@ਡB@QFNਡRGHOਡVHSGਡSGQDDਡ
R@HKNQRਡGD@CRਡUHRHAKD
© 4GDਡ*ਡ0@TKਡ'DSSXਡ-TRDTL
Ancient Warfare XVI-1
21
(DKKDMHRSHB DQ@ਡKD@CਡBTQRDਡS@AKDSRਡVHSGਡKDES ਡSGDਡM@HKRਡRSHKKਡHMਡOK@BDਡ
4@AKDSRਡEQNLਡSGDਡ+XQDMH@ਡRGHOਡVDQDਡTMHMRBQHADC ਡATSਡENKCDCਡ@MCਡM@HKDCਡ
x
CNVM ਡRTFFDRSHMFਡ@MਡHKKHSDQ@SDਡODQRNMਡODQG@ORਡSQHDCਡSNਡ@BSHU@SDਡSGDL
© ,@TQDMਡU@Mਡ:NNMDM
'QDDJਡBG@KBDCNMXਡRB@Q@ANHC ਡ
B@ਡ ਡ"# ਡRGNVHMFਡ@ਡ
x
RGHOਡVHSGਡRSDDQRL@M ਡN@QR
LDMਡ@MCਡV@QQHNQR
© -DSQNONKHS@Mਡ-TRDTLਡNEਡ!QS
Ancient Warfare XVI-1
22
Alexandros, since he was buried under this tophylakika ploia, “anti-pirate vessels”. But the Dated to ca. 450 BC, this detail of a
earth short-lived and childless, having quit biggest threat was from large naval states: Ath- fresco from the "Tomb of the ship" in
the breath of life aged twenty-seven – wise ens in the Classical period, Rhodes in the Hel- the Monterozzi necropolis near Tar-
in schooling, splendid with the bow, with lenistic period; these states not only organized quinia depicts an Etruscan ship.
© Chiar / Wikimedia Commons
which he once killed man-slaying pirates convoys for merchants but sent expeditions
upon the briny Strophades. But go now, against pirates, such as the expedition against
traveller, having bid farewell to he who Antikythera described in an early Hellenistic
comes from the land of Alkinoös, the noble Rhodian honorific inscription. As Gabrielsen
son of noble Satyros. has shown, these naval prostatai (“protectors”)
– Inscriptiones Graecae IX 12 4, 928 never aimed at eliminating piracy entirely, as
their protection services drew in money from
Like many young citizen men in Hellenistic mercantile states which would soon dry up if
Greece, Alexandros had trained in the use of the ‘problem’ was decisively solved. But Rome
weapons; he seems to have taken part in an ex- did, for a while, come close to complete sup-
pedition to clear the Strophades islands (south pression. By 67 BC, the Cilician menace had
of Zakynthos) of pirates. Evidence for the ephe- become so bad that Pompey was empowered
beia (“cadet training”) is widespread in this era, to sweep the Mediterranean of pirates. Divid- An Attic kylix, ca. 570-550 BC, depict-
and the presence of armed citizens in target ing the sea into zones, his fleet worked from ing the transformation of Tyrrhenian
communities meant that pirate crews had to be west to east and eventually cornered the pirates pirates into dolphins.
careful. An inscription from Ephesus describes © Sailko/ Wikimedia Commons
in Cilicia and defeated their fleet. It took cen-
a successful rescue operation: pirates raided its turies before Mediterranean piracy once again
territory and carried off people and plunder, but reached the intensity that it had held prior to
an expedition from the nearby island of Astyp- Pompey’s campaign. 0
alaia hunted down and captured the pirates,
liberating the captives and punishing the pirates David Lewis is Senior Lecturer in
“as befitted their wickedness”. Greek coastal Greek History and Culture at
communities were not soft targets. the University of Edinburgh
Pirates also had to reckon with active naval and member of Eskmuthe
opposition – some cities had their own units. Rowing Club’s under 40s
Hellenistic Chios, for instance, had its own leis- men’s crew.
THey thought he The question arises: who was the original source of the
story? Undoubtedly, it was Julius Caesar himself. In shap-
s joking
ing the first draft of his history, he controlled the narrative,
deciding which details to include or to exclude, and plac-
ing himself squarely as the hero of the tale. In later life,
Caesar would become an expert self-publicist, writing fa-
Just into his twenties, Julius Caesar was captured and mous – and still extant – accounts of his military exploits
in Gaul and against Pompeius Magnus. His adventure with
ransomed by pirates. The kidnapping did not turn out the pirates is thus an early example of his self-promotion.
the way his renegade maritime captors had planned.
Cilician pirates
In the first century BC, travelling by sea was a dangerous
n 80 BC, C. Julius Caesar (b. 12/13 July 101/100
I
undertaking. Passengers and crew not only had to contend
BC) was a young man rising up the cursus hono-
with the capriciousness of the wind and the sea, but the
rum, the career ladder of official civil and military
menace of piracy was ever present – and nowhere more so
positions for which politically ambitious Romans
than off the coast of Anatolia. Plutarch writes, “With him
competed. He was then serving on the staff of M.
[Nicomedes] he [Caesar] tarried a short time, and then, on
Minucius Thermus, praetor of Asia Minor, who sent Cae-
his voyage back, was captured, near the island Pharmacusa
sar to the court of Nicomedes IV Philopator of Bithynia (r.
[Farmakonisi], by pirates” (Plutarch, Julius Caesar 1.8).
94–74 BC) on a diplomatic mission to bring back a fleet
In the Roman world, a pirate (praedo) was a robber.
of ships owned by the king.
He was considered part of the wider social problem of
Spending so much time at court, however, rumours
brigandage (latrocinium), which encompassed banditry,
circulated that the 20-year-old Roman had had a sexual af-
armed street robbery, uprisings, and even slave rebellions.
fair with the much older ruler – M. Calpurnius Bibulus later
The Cilicians were regarded as “the most murderous of
joked that his consular colleague for 59 BC was the queen
men” (Plutarch, Julius Caesar 2.2). In the 80s BC, the Cili-
of Bithynia. It may have been just a made-up story; Caesar
cians “already at that time controlled the sea” (Plutarch,
denied the rumour all his life.
Elsewhere, Caesar acquitted himself well when, in 81 Julius Caesar 1.8). The territory of Cilicia (now the south-
BC, “During the rest of the campaign he enjoyed a better eastern region of Turkey) was bordered by Pamphylia, Ga-
reputation, and at the storming of Mytilene Thermus award- latia, Cappadocia, and Syria. It was home to a community
ed him the corona civica” (Suetonius, Divus Julius 2). This of particularly active pirates. Strabo explains:
was a crown of oak leaves awarded to a soldier who had It was Tryphon [Diodotus r. 142–138 BC], together with
saved the lives of his fellow citizens by killing an enemy the worthlessness of the kings who by succession were
combatant at a location held by the opponent. Even at that then reigning over Syria and at the same time over Ci-
early age, Caesar revealed a penchant for acts of derring-do. licia, who caused the Cilicians to organize their gangs
Completing his assignment in 75 or 74 BC, he set sail of pirates; for on account of his revolutionary attempts
for Rome. Just days from port, his ship was boarded by pi- others made like attempts at the same time, and thus
rates. What happened next is recorded in several accounts the dissensions of brethren with one another put the
of the story, each of which has slightly different details. country at the mercy of any who might attack it.
(Strabo 14.5.2)
Sources
Writing closest in time to the event was Velleius Paterculus Cilician pirates sailed the seas “with large armaments and
(19 BC–AD 31) in his Roman History, but even this work was countless small vessels” (Plutarch, Julius Caesar 1.8). These
published over a century later. Next was Velleius' contem- were liburnae or liburnicae, apparently named after the
porary Valerius Maximus, compiling his Memorable Deeds Liburni, a seafaring and piratical people living along the
and Sayings, a collection of historical anecdotes, around AD Adriatic Sea who perfected a type of compact seaworthy
30. Plutarch (ca.AD 46–after AD 119) gives the longest and ship. The Cilicians’ choice of equipment was significant.
liveliest account in his Julius Caesar. Suetonius (ca.AD 69– Powered by one or two rows of oarsmen or by sail, the rela-
after AD 122) relates the episode in his gossipy Divus Julius. tively small but agile and manoeuvrable ships were ideal
Each biographer or historian shares a basic storyline embel- for purpose: they could be kept in hidden, natural harbours
lished or stripped of detail to suit his purpose. and then launched quickly to intercept maritime traffic. In
Limestone frieze depicting soldiers embarked on a galley, ready to board an enemy ship. Now in the Narbo Via museum, Narbonne, France.
A-pi cy ie a sm
In 67 BC, one of the Roman Republic’s leading generals, istocracy, Pompey lusted after military glory,
which was the principal route to political suc-
Gnaeus Pompeius Magnus, Pompey the Great, was cess. His campaign lasted less than a year and
given an extraordinary, three-year, Mediter- was portrayed as a resounding success by his
ranean-wide command by a law of the Ro- political ally Marcus Tullius Cicero in a speech
to the Roman people in 66 BC, arguing that
man people, to rid the seas of ‘pirates’. only Pompey could win Rome’s long-running
war with Mithridates VI, king of Pontus (Cic-
nder the terms of the lex Gabinia,
U
ero, On the Command of Gnaeus Pompeius).
Pompey was allocated huge re- This spectacular defeat of the ‘pirates’ did in-
sources of men, ships, and mon- deed pave the way for Pompey to take com-
ey. He was also granted imperi- mand against Mithridates, who was eventually
um maius, the power to override defeated in 63 BC. But there is another way of
the authority of all other Roman magistrates, for up to viewing at Pompey’s ‘Pirate War’. If we look
50 miles inland, much to the dismay of his political
behind the image of a heroic Roman leader
rivals, who felt that this amounted to almost monarchi-
freeing the seas of evil ‘pirates’ for the good of
cal status. Like all members of the Roman senatorial ar-
all, we can see how the opponents of Rome
have been demonized and how aggressive
Bust of Pompey the Great now in the Louvre, Paris. Roman imperialism has been justi-
Though the recognized busts of Pompey show some
fied as the suppression of piracy.
variation in the rest of the face, the hairstyle and
shape of the forehead are consistent in all of them.
© Pierre André / Wikimedia Commons
x
© :CDਡਡ7HJHLDCH@ਡ#NLLNMR
Ancient piracy and the raid mentality and cities in search of both plunder
and prisoners to be ransomed or sold
Piracy can be defined as ‘armed robbery in-
as slaves. The numerous coastal set-
volving the use of ships’. It can be distinguished
from banditry, not only because of its maritime tlements of the Aegean and Eastern
aspect, but also because ships give pirates the Mediterranean were especially vul-
capacity to raid over much longer distances. nerable to the sudden appearance of
Maritime raiding was widespread in the ancient ‘pirate’ ships, whose crews could eas-
Mediterranean by the late Bronze Age. There is, ily bypass or overwhelm local defences
however, no specific word in the sources de- and plunder at will. The ancient sources re-
scribing those raids that equates to the word fer in particular to the Illyrians, Cretans, Pam-
‘piracy’, so it is impossible to distinguish pi- phylians, and Cilicians as habitual ‘pirates’, but
racy from warfare. Indeed, maritime raids pro- this does not necessarily mean that their actions (Top) Ruins of the outer city walls
and motivations were very different to those of of the Pamphylian city of Side. The
vided a means for the leaders to maintain and
main gate (Megale Pyle) dates to
enhance their military status, to obtain plunder other states, rather that they were the objects of
the Hellenistic Period.
from which to reward their followers and allies, pejorative labelling by their enemies. © Dosseman / Wikimedia Commons
and to inflict both material and moral losses on
(Bottom) Remains of a Roman naval
their enemies. Vincent Gabrielsen has argued Romans vs ‘pirates’
monument in the harbor of Miletus,
that this “raid mentality” remained an essential The rise of Rome in the Mediterranean was ac- possibly erected to Pompey after his
form of warfare throughout antiquity. companied by a gradual realization among the defeat of the Cilician pirates in 67 BC.
It is only in the late fifth and fourth centu- senatorial aristocracy that one way to legitimize © Livius.org
)QNMਡ2NL@MਡAN@SਡGNNJਡEQNLਡ
#@RSQ@ਡ!KA@MH@MTLਡNMਡSGDਡ
x
RNTSGDQMਡA@MJਡNEਡSGDਡ2GHMD
© 0QNUHMBHDਡ:THC (NKK@MCਡ7HJHLDCH@ਡ#NLLNMR
4GHRਡAQNMYDਡRVNQCਡV@RਡNMBDਡ@SS@BGDCਡSNਡ@ਡ
x
RS@STDਡENTMCਡHMਡSGDਡ!MSHJXSGDQ@ਡRGHOVQDBJ ਡ
Ancient Warfare XVI-1 VGHBGਡC@SDRਡSNਡ ਡ"#ਡ4GDਡ)RK@MCਡNEਡ!M
32 SHJXSGDQ@ਡRDQUDCਡ@Rਡ@ਡOHQ@SDਡRSQNMFGNKC
© '@QXਡ4NCCਡਡ&KHBJQ
3KHMFRSNMDRਡENTMCਡHMਡ3@KNM@ਡ
x
LNCDQMਡ3NKHM ਡ#QN@SH@ ਡB@ਡ
ਡ"# !$ਡਡ
© ,HUHTRNQF
of Cilicia. The alternative way to see it the Romans’ real interest lay in expanding their
is as a manifesto for Roman imperialism. empire and increasing their own wealth.
By claiming the right to send a senatorial com- Three centuries later, Cassius Dio wrote
mander and his army to the region in order to that the Romans displayed very little interest
suppress piracy, the Romans were justifying the in suppressing the supposedly endemic pi-
expansion of their empire in a way that made racy. He sums up their attitude thus: “But
them look good to their allies and simultane- they used to send out fleets and gener-
ously demonized their enemies as pirates. als, as and when they were prompted by
After 100 BC, several Roman generals specific reports. Nothing was achieved,
campaigned in the Eastern Mediterranean and except that the allies had to suffer even
especially Cilicia, but very little of their activity greater hardship as a result of these at-
can be described as suppression of piracy. From tempts, until their situation became
78 to 74, Publius Servilius Vatia defeated sever- quite desperate” (Dio 36.23.2).
al local rulers in Eastern Lycia and Pamphylia, If what the Romans labelled ‘pi-
including one Zeniketos. He is described as a racy’ was such a big problem at this
‘pirate’ by the Greek geographer Strabo, writ- time, but very little had been done
ing about 100 years later (Geography 14.5.7). about it, why was such drastic action tak-
Servilius’ priority, however, was to extend Ro- en in 67? The principal reason for the change
man control over the inland areas, especially in attitude was self-interest. By then, piratical Copper-alloy Roman helmet, second-
attacks were not just troubling Rome’s subjects first century BC, from a shipwreck
the mountains of Isauria. He was awarded a
near Narbonne, France and now in
triumph for his victories and took the surname and allies. Maritime raiders had struck the coast
the Narbo Via museum there.
‘Isauricus’. As Servilius passed through the ter- of Italy, even sinking some ships in the harbour
© Skopien / Wikimedia Commons
ritory of Rome’s friends and allies, he displayed of Ostia, just a few miles from Rome itself. The
his prisoners in chains and labelled as ‘pirates’, Greek biographer Plutarch, writing in the sec-
thus providing evidence of Rome’s success in ond century AD, picked out the threat to the
clearing the region and making the seas safe. city’s food supply as the most urgent problem
Many of those designated as ‘pirates’ by (Plutarch, Life of Pompey 24):
the ancient sources were allies or friends of King
The pirates’ power was felt in all parts of the
Mithridates, who fought against Rome from 89
Mediterranean, so that it was impossible to
to 63 BC. In his struggle against Roman impe-
sail anywhere and all trade was brought to
rial expansion, he recruited substantial forces
a halt. It was this which really made the Ro- This marble frieze from the late
from the autonomous communities of Cilicia
mans sit up and take notice. With their mar- first century BC shows Roman
and Pamphylia, either as allies or as mercenar- soldiers on the protected deck of
kets short of food and a great famine loom-
ies. In 88 BC, he captured the island of Delos, a galley, ready to send a volley of
ing, they commissioned Pompey to clear
a major commercial port for Roman and Italian pila at an opponent.
the seas of pirates.
merchants. By presenting Mithridates © Karwansaray Publishers
4VNਡAQNMYDਡ(DKKDMHRSHBਡRS@STDSSDRਡNEਡANTMCਡ
x
In e ke of
Axander
The shock of the Macedonian invasion of northwestern India exposed the weakness-
es of divided tribal states and small kingdoms. When the army of Alexander left, a
network of satraps and vassals remained. The chaos after his death reached all the A Roman marble bust of Alexander
the Great based on a Greek orginal
way to India and allowed a driven sage and his chosen pupil to create an empire that from the third century BC. Now in the
Ny Carlsberg Glyptotek, Copenhagen.
stretched across most of the subcontinent and lasted into the second century BC.
© Richard Mortel / Flickr
hen Alexander the and put Porus to rout. The spirited resistance
W
A Yavana (Greek) warrior, from
Great’s army had sparked in Alexander an admiration for Porus, Bharhut Stupa, Satna district of
conquered Bactria in and the Indian king became one of his vassals. Madhya Pradesh. The relief dates
Central Asia, his army Alexander did not advance deeper into the roughly to the second century BC,
swept through the subcontinent. Beyond Porus’ small kingdom lay and depicts a man with short curly
Gandhara and the Punjab, in the area of mod- the Ganges River, and beyond that lay the terri- hair, a headband, and tunic. He is
ern Afghanistan and Pakistan. Most famously, tory of the Nanda Empire, at the time the most holding a sword and a grape plant.
© Michael Gunther/ Wikimedia Commons
he faced a Punjabi king named Porus at the powerful state in the subcontinent. The Nandas
Battle of Hydaspes in 326, in a hard-fought ruled from the city of Pataliputra in the Magad-
and costly victory that tempered the appetite ha region of eastern India and were backed by a
of the Macedonian army for further conquest. strong military, which ancient authors claimed
The battle was especially hard-fought could muster some 200,000 infantrymen and
because Porus’ forces fought with markedly thousands of trained elephants. Although Alex-
different tactics than their Macedonian coun- ander was eager to invade these lands, his army
terparts. The Indian king used trained war el- refused to proceed deeper into the subconti-
ephants as shock troops to break enemy lines nent, and he pulled back the bulk of his forces
and reinforce the army’s infantry backbone, to Babylon, where he would die in 323.
while cavalry and chariots harassed the ene- Alexander’s withdrawal was not the end
my’s flanks. Because elephants were so wide- of the Greek presence in India; he left behind
spread in ancient Indian warfare, infantry for- a small contingent of satraps – a title for pro-
mations tended to be less compact than those vincial governors inherited from the Persian
employed by Greek armies; this lessened the Achaemenid Empire – to rule over the Indian
risk of mass casualties from trampling but territories he had secured, alongside Indian vas-
made it easier for them to be scattered. At the sals such as Porus. With their king’s death, noth-
Hydaspes, Alexander’s army discovered the ing remained to unify these rulers, and some
hazards of tight formations when many men of the satraps Alexander left behind proclaimed
were trampled by charging elephants or im- their own independence and took to fighting
paled on tusks that were reinforced by steel their former comrades. Alexander’s incursions
cladding. As the battle progressed, the Mac- had highlighted the weakness of divided gov-
edonians learned to target the elephant driv- ernment in north-west India, making it an at-
ers, causing the elephants, in the words of tractive target for any army strong enough to
the Roman historian Arrian, to rush “forward unify it. Such a force was about to emerge in the
at friends and foes alike”. Out of this chaos, form of a sage named Chanakya and his young
the Macedonian army managed to regroup protégé, Chandragupta Maurya.
An exiled sage of his empire, Chanakya and Chandragupta
saw an opportunity. As a former royal minis-
Chanakya was a former minister of the Nanda
ter, Chanakya was wealthy, and the two used
kings who had fled the court following a dis-
that wealth to raise a small army of mercenar-
pute with the king, the details of which are un-
ies, bandits, and anyone else willing to follow
clear. After this humiliation, Chanakya burned
them. Both Indian and Greco-Roman sources
with a determination to see the Nanda dynasty
state that Chandragupta’s first actions were to
overthrown. He was a sage of extraordinary
seize the territories held by the Greek satraps
wit, wisdom, and wealth, but he was no mil-
and vassals in the north-west, and establish a
itary leader; that was a role he groomed the
base of operations. Scattered and divided by in-
young Chandragupta to fill. Both men were
fighting, the warlords were an easy target, and
probably from eastern India, but they are first
Chandragupta was able to build a more formi-
recorded at Taxila, an ancient city-state that
dable army after consolidating their territories.
was located in present-day Pakistan, where
Chanakya taught at one of the world’s earli-
Chandragupta’s army
est universities. Taxila had been an early ally of
There are no detailed accounts of the course
Alexander, and Chandragupta may have served
of this initial conquest, and it was probably not
in the army, exposing him to Greek tactics and
a conventional war. During this period, Chan-
military thought. Most stories emphasize that
A Roman bronze bust of Seleucus I dragupta’s army may have operated very dif-
he came from a family of low status, but not
Nicator, from the Villa of the Papyri ferently from the disciplined force adopted by
much else can be said with certainty.
in Herculaneum, ca. 100 BC-AD 100. Porus’ army against Alexander; descriptions of
© Sailko / Wikimedia Commons Like many other ambitious young men the early Mauryan army refer to its soldiers as
in the ancient world, Chandragupta dreamt bandits or mercenaries, some of them Greeks
of accomplishing what Alexander could not. and other foreigners, and give the impression of
It was said that Chandragupta often remarked guerrilla warfare. Chanakya is often attributed
Long before Alexander's adventures that Alexander could have easily toppled the
in the Indus Valley, the Achaemenids as the author of the Arthashastra, an ancient
Nanda Empire, had his army been willing to handbook on warfare and governance, which
already had contact with various peo-
ples in the region. After their own war advance. If the duo’s ultimate goal was to top- treats subterfuge and assassination not as dis-
of conquest, Indian soldiers began ple the Nandas, however, they were in no honourable but as ideal, exemplars of achiev-
serving in the Persian army, fighting position to do that. They did recognize that ing military goals with fewer casualties. Some
in some of the Achaemenids' most fa- if the peoples of the north-west, along with historians believe that Chanakya may have
mous battles with the Greeks. Dating the Greeks who had settled there, could be instigated uprisings among Greek troops and
to 340 BC, this relief from Artaxerxes
united under a single leader, then they could engineered the assassination of the Macedo-
III's tomb shows warriors from the ter-
present a formidable fighting force. nian satraps Philip and Nicanor. Through these
ritories of Sattagydia, Gandhara, and
Hindush respectively. As the region sank into chaos follow- methods, Chandragupta’s army grew quickly as
© Martin Yhlén/ Wikimedia Commons ing Alexander’s death and the disintegration the cities of the north-west fell under his control
over the course of several months.
With the north-west united under his rule,
Chandragupta’s ambition shifted towards the
Nandas on the other side of the Ganges. In
the early part of the Nanda campaign, Chan-
dragupta is said to have advanced rapidly on
the Nanda capital at Pataliputra, intent on cut-
ting off the head of the empire, but this initial
attack was repulsed. After losing much of the
territory gained in the initial assault, the Mau-
ryan army settled into a difficult campaign.
Chanakya and Chandragupta decided on a
slow but steady advance on the Nanda borders,
consolidating the governance of captured cit-
ies before advancing towards Pataliputra. Texts
from later centuries record the deaths of tens
of thousands of elephants, horses, charioteers,
x
RSQ@SDRਡANSGਡ(DKKDMHRSHBਡ@MCਡ!BG@DLDMHCਡHMEKTDMBDRਡNMਡ-@TQX@Mਡ@QS
© .@K@MC@ਡ7HJHLDCH@ਡ#NLLNMR
became highly efficient, even estab- Seleucus subdued several Greek satraps
lishing a branch dedicated to ensuring a in what is now Afghanistan before crossing the
dependable supply chain. Chandragup- Indus and advancing towards Taxila. With the
ta’s military successes finally met their limit north-west now united under Mauryan rule,
when he tried to invade the state of Kalinga, Seleucus, a veteran of Alexander’s Indian cam-
along India’s eastern coast. Formerly part of paign, was confronted by far more organized
the Nanda domain, the now-independent resistance than had existed before. The inva-
kingdom resisted his efforts of conquest, and sion was short-lived, and the result must have
he was forced to withdraw from its borders. been a clear Mauryan victory. In an agreement
that ended the conflict, Seleucus surrendered
(Top) The easternmost 'Pillar of A new clash with Macedonians vast tracts of land on the western bank of the
Ashoka' at Vaishali, India. Erected Around 305, Chandragupta’s empire was con- Indus, extending Mauryan power into mod-
by Ashoka all over the empire and ern Afghanistan and Iran. In exchange, Chan-
fronted by an outside threat in the form of the
inscribed with edicts, twenty such
Seleucid Empire. It had originated in from Alex- dragupta provided Seleucus with 500 trained
pillars survive today.
© Thanes.Op / Shutterstock ander’s army in the east and was led by one of war elephants; with access to thousands, this
his generals, Seleucus I Nicator. His army had was no great blow to Mauryan military power.
(Bottom) Rock inscribed with an These elephants provided an important advan-
edict of Ashoka at Shahbazgarhi, Pa-
spent years fighting to subdue former Macedo-
nian territories from Babylon to Bactria before tage to the Seleucids, who used them to great
kistan. Fourteen such edicts survive.
© Raza Shah Khan / Wikimedia Commons shifting its attention towards the subcontinent. effect against the army of their Macedonian ri-
val Antigonus at the Battle of Ipsus in 301. War
elephants soon spread to other Greek armies,
though they never became so widespread as in
India. To seal the treaty, the two parties agreed
to an arranged marriage between Chandragup-
ta Maurya and a Seleucid princess, referred to
in some accounts as Berenice.
After Chandragupta
This victory was Chandragupta’s last great ac-
complishment. He simply disappears from our
accounts, while a much later but oft-repeated
tradition has him abdicating his throne to be-
come a Jain monk. Accounts of Chandragup-
ta’s succession are dominated by gruesome
stories of sibling rivalry, which would become
hallmarks of Mauryan dynastic succession. He
was ultimately succeeded by his son Bindusara
Maurya. Bindusara maintained good relations
with the Seleucids and expressed an interest in
Greek philosophy, and his reign seems to have
been focused on consolidating the territories
captured by his father. Bindusara’s favoured
son, Ashoka, ensured his place as his father’s
successor by proving himself a capable mili-
tary leader in the suprression of a rebel-
lion at Taxila and, according to some,
by having all of his siblings murdered.
Determined to continue his grand-
father’s legacy, Ashoka was more ambi-
tious than his father. The Mauryan Empire
reached its greatest extent during his reign,
and its infrastructure was improved. It was
also a period of great cultural and artistic
4DQQ@BNSS@ਡRBTKOSTQDਡNEਡ@MਡDK
x
DOG@MSਡVHSGਡRDUDQ@KਡQHCDQR ਡ
SGHQCਡNQਡRDBNMCਡBDMSTQXਡ"# ਡ
EQNLਡ5SS@Qਡ0Q@CDRG ਡ)MCH@
© ,NRਡ!MFDKDRਡ#NTMSXਡ-TRDTLਡNEਡ!QS
Ancient Warfare XVI-1
43
THE WEAPON
Relief on the southern wall of the east stairway of the Apadana Palace in Persepolis. The swords attached to the soldiers' belts are akinakes.
e Persian akinakes
By March 480 BC, two floating causeways bridging the Hellespont were ready to convey the Persian king
Xerxes and his army across into Europe. Their construction had not been without its difficulties; an ear-
lier storm had torn apart the structures mid-construction. Xerxes’ irate reaction to this setback was to
order the water to be whipped 300 times, a pair of fetters to be thrown in, and the waves themselves
to be branded with red-hot irons. Those in charge of the construction project were also beheaded.
ow, in June, on the morning of his crossing and being perplexed as to whether this gesture
N
with better weather, Xerxes approached the wa- was an offering directed to the sun or some
ters of the Hellespont, but with an evidently dif- sort of contrition for his previous abuse of the
ferent intention. As the sun rose, Xerxes poured a Hellespont, the choice of weapon to commit
libation into the sea from a golden bowl, praying to the waters at this moment might provide
that “misfortune would not prevent him conquering Europe”, before some clarity of Xerxes’ intentions.
casting the golden bowl into the waters of the Hellespont. This of-
fering was promptly supplemented by a golden Sign of allegiance
mixing bowl and a short sword, the type the Although not much shorter than the smaller
Persians refer to as an akinakes, according to known examples of Greek xiphoi swords, the
Herodotus (7.53). Whilst Herodotus admits to straight, double-edged akinakes, typically
35–45 cm in length, is generally thought of
A silver Achaemenid rhyton (a ceremonial as more of a dagger from both modern and
vessel for drinking or pouring from) shaped
ancient perspectives alike. This was not a pri-
as a rider on a horse, wearing an akinakes
on his right hip, ca. 550 – 330 BC. Found mary weapon to be utilized in battle by Per-
near Arin-Berd, Yerevan, Armenia.
© EvgenyGenkin/ Wikimedia Commons
sian troops. Indeed, Quintus Curtius (3.3) dis- a thrusting weapon, intended to
paragingly questions the serviceability of the be drawn with the blade facing
akinakes, listing it amongst the “attire of the down, as Valerius Flaccus’ ref-
king noteworthy of luxury”, adorned as it was erence (Argonautica 6.701) to
with a golden belt and bejewelled scabbard. the weapon being worn typi-
Yet at the same time as Quintus Curtius’ cally on the right suggests.
accusations of feminine el- Our one account of an akinakes in action
egance comes a recognition again comes from Herodotus’ account of In- An ornate ivory
that the akinakes played a taphrenes’ death (3.118). Being one of the six akinakes scabbard, fifth-
crucial role in the recognition aristocrats who helped Darius claim the Persian fourth century BC, from the Temple of
throne in 522 BC, Intaphrenes held exalted sta- the Oxus, Takht-i Sangin, southern Ta-
of individuals of high status
jikistan. Its design matches the others
within Persian aristocracy. Of tus, including the privilege to enter the palace
found and depicted on several reliefs.
particular note were the ‘King’s unannounced at any time, except when the © ALFGRN/ Flickr
Kinsmen’, known as the ‘Huva- king was in bed with a woman. A night came
ka’ in Old Persian. The practice of when he chose to enact this privilege, only to be
their being presented with a gold- refused entry by the gatekeeper and a message-
en akinakes perhaps harkens back to bearer, who claimed that the king was indeed
Elamite origins whereby the wearing of occupied. Suspecting this to be a deceit, Inta-
© Lukiyanova Natalia frenta / Shutterstock
phrenes drew his akinakes and cut off the gate- !ਡRB@Q@ANHCਡCDOHBSHMFਡ@ਡ0DQ
such daggers identified the best warriors. RH@MਡJHMFਡEHFGSHMFਡ@ਡM@JDCਡ
keepers’ ears and nose. When word reached 'QDDJਡGNOKHSD ਡB@ਡਡ"#ਡ
x
However, the presentation of akinakes
was not limited to members of the Persian Darius, he feared a conspiracy amongst the 0NRRHAKXਡL@CDਡHMਡ3@QCHRਡ@MCਡ
ENTMCਡHMਡ#@QH@
aristocracy. Xenophon (Anabasis I.3.27) Six, but after investigation he was satisfied © *ਡ0@TKਡ'DSSXਡ-TRDTL
describes how Cyrus demonstrated his that it was simply the overreaching pride
honour and respect for Syennesis, king of Intaphrenes, and so put him to death.
of the Cilicians, by presenting him with From Cyrus down to Darius III, the
a ‘gold akinakes’, along with a Nisaean akinakes symbolized status and privi-
horse with golden bridle, a purple kan- lege within the Persian court. Whether
tus (Persian robe), and a gold torque as a gift to the King’s Kinsmen, adorning
and bracelets. Likewise, on his return the body of a king like Cyrus in his golden
journey from Greece, Xerxes stopped sarcophagus, or being plundered in the after- Bas-relief from Persepolis depict-
math of battle and sent by Alexander as a gift to ing ambassadors bearing gifts to the
at the town of Abdera, where he pre-
king, including an akinakes. Several
sented the citizenry with a gilded the goddess of the Parthenon; the akinakes was
akinakes presentation reliefs survive,
akinakes and a tiara, thus sealing a a defining Persian weapon. 0
suggesting the importance of such
bond of alliance and probably rec- ceremonies, and reinforcing the pic-
ognizing some particular logistical Mark McCaffery is a regular contributor to ture we're given in literary sources.
support crucial to his campaign. Ancient Warfare magazine. © MAVRITSINA IRINA / Shutterstock
Practical weapon
That said, Quintus Curtius appears excessive-
ly harsh in his questioning of the functional-
ity of the akinakes. Plutarch makes reference
to the “wielding of akinakes” amongst the
ranks of the Persian army at Plataea in 479
BC, although whether this may be interpreted
as evidence for the presence of Persian kins-
men is debatable. Still, the straight, short na-
ture of the weapon seems to suggest it being
!Mਡ@JHM@JDRਡVHSGਡRB@AA@QC ਡB@ਡ
ਡ"# ਡENTMCਡHMਡ-HQRHC ਡ
x
2NL@MH@ਡMNVਡHMਡSGDਡ-TRDTLਡ
NEਡ:@K@T ਡ2NL@MH@
© ,HUHTRNQF
T e af
Th afte
term
te rmat
rmath
at h of a Daaccia
iann ra
raid
id on a
Rooma
man n to
town
wn:: lo
wn loot
ot tak
a en and cap apti
tiive
vess
asse
as semb
se mb
m ble
l d fo
forr ex
exec
e ut
ecutio
ion,
io n, or too be
soold
ld int
n o sl
s aver
avver
ery.
y.
y.
© Cata
Cata
atalin
lin
n Dragh
Drragh
aghici
ici
ci
An
A
Ancient
ncciieen
nt Warfare
Waarffaarre XVI-1
W XXVVI-
I-1
46
46
THE TACTICS AND IMPACT OF THE GETAE AND DACIANS By Andrei Pogacias
ncient Greek and Roman sources record ing the supply bases of the Romans would ensure the
A
how the Getae and Dacians – the pre- delay of such actions at least. The Romans also crossed
cise distinction was unclear to Roman the Danube a few times into what is now the Romanian
authors – used to cross the Danube and Plain, defeating local rulers and moving tens of thou-
plunder south all the way into Greece, sands of barbarians south of the river, in order to increase
from where they returned rich with loot. They were also the number of taxpayers in the Republic and then the
hired as mercenaries, especially by the Romans, to fight Empire, and also to weaken the northern rulers. Perhaps
against other barbarians, or in Roman civil wars. Their at- some raids were undertaken in order to liberate some of
tacks were usually swift and bloody, and they managed the people who had been taken. Political crises between
to instil fear even into the hearts and minds of the peo- the Dacians and Romans, perhaps when negotiating new
ple living in Rome. Unfortunately, many relevant ancient stipendia (payments, usually to ensure a quiet border),
sources have been lost, so we have only a few hints re- also led to such actions from time to time.
garding these raids, but no detailed accounts. The Dacian kingship might not have been based on
a hereditary system, but on prowess in battle in a system
The raiding lifestyle of ‘military democracy’ where the most skilled high com-
Plunder was the main reason for these attacks. The Greek mander would take the crown, especially if the king in of-
cities on the Black Sea, in the case of the Getae, and fice was old or deemed unworthy. We don’t have details
the Roman territories in the Balkans, in the case of the on how the Dacian leadership worked, but we know that,
Dacians, were their targets: rich places filled with vari- after the raid in AD 85/86 south of the Danube, the old king
ous precious goods, weapons, and slaves. The Dacians Duras granted the throne and the Dacian defences against
launched their raids based on information regarding the Domitian’s troops to the commander of the raid, Diurpa-
presence or absence of troops in the area, and they were neus, better known as Decebalus (perhaps a nickname, "the
immensely successful. Valiant", or title). Based on this, it is obvious that raids were
Some of these actions might have occurred when needed in order for new leaders to emerge and prove them-
provisions were scarce north of the Danube, perhaps due selves. Victory, as always, meant power and the right to rule.
to bad crops or other reasons. The population could grow
quickly and there was a need to ensure their relative wel- Great raids and equipment
fare. Kings or commanders had to prove their courage We do not have much information on the subject, but we
and skill by leading these raids and returning home in know from ancient sources that the king of Pontus, Mith-
glory. Another cause, especially when the numbers of ridates VI Eupator (135–63 BC), negotiated an alliance
warriors grew and there was the risk of political unrest, with the Getae when attempting to outflank the Romans
could actually be to lose some problematic commanders through the Balkans. Perhaps the idea was that the Getic
in the heat of the campaign. The troops also had to gain cavalry was supposed to raid Roman territory and disrupt
experience through such military actions and earn per- the Roman army’s supply lines, provide a vanguard for
sonal glory and loot. Some raids would be undertaken if the Pontic armies, or at least relieve Roman pressure from
the Roman presence grew more menacing or if there was Asia Minor. This was a strategy that never became reality.
news of a planned attack north of the river – information Burebista was one of the most famous Getic kings.
was of course flowing across the Danube in both direc- Between 60 and 48 BC he managed to impose his pow-
tions through merchants, spies, and fugitives. Destroy- er on a large territory, stretching from today’s Slovakia
Detail of a scene on Trajan's Column showing the emperor leading the army across a pontoon bridge with various standards at the front.
T
have died at some point in the later first cen-
1688 in the grounds of Holy Trinity tury or early second century AD. Although no
Church in the centre of York, from cause of death is given, the fact that he had a
where it was uncovered during the formal burial makes it unlikely that he died in
course of building works. It had battle with enemy warriors.
been broken in two, and it was nearly lost forever
when workers planned to reuse the stone, but for- Signifer insignia
tunately, its value was recognized. As a standard-bearer, Rufinus was responsible
The tombstone was dedicated to a legion-
for carrying the standard (signum) of his as-
ary named Lucius Duccius Rufinus, who had died
signed century, including in battle. Standard-
bearers had to rely on the soldiers around them
Limestone tombstone, ca. AD 71-120, found in 1688. It
for their survival, being a target of the enemy
reads "Luciius Duccius Rufinus, son of Lucius, of the Vol-
tinian tribe, from Vienne, a standard bearer of the Ninth
and having little ability to defend themselves.
Legion, 28 years old. He is laid here".
© The York Museums Trust
Losing the standard was a great source of Presumably, Rufinus would have
shame for a Roman unit; the standard-bearer been contented with the character por-
had the ultimate responsibility for preserving trait his tombstone would evoke. The
the security of the standards and was expected inscription does not record who com-
to give his life if necessary to preserve them. missioned the stone, suggesting that it
Outside battle, the standard-bearer was also may have been organized by a military
responsible for the financial administration of burial club that Rufinus had paid into,
his legion, including managing the savings ac- to ensure that he received a proper fu-
counts of legionaries in the unit and distribut- neral and tombstone. He consequently
ing pay. This was an important responsibility received a burial and a monument that
and necessitated that standard-bearers have a highlighted his rank and role in the Ro-
3HKUDQਡOG@KDQ@ਡONRRH level of competence man army. The tombstone, however,
AKXਡCDOHBSHMFਡ4HADQHTR ਡ in both administra- may not have been made specifically
x
NMBDਡLNTMSDCਡNMਡSGDਡ tion and accountan- for him but chosen from a pre-made se-
RG@ESਡNEਡ@ਡRS@MC@QC ਡ
@MCਡC@SDCਡSNਡਡ cy. Unsurprisingly, a lection and then personalised with an
!$ਡਡ ਡਡ standard-bearer was inscription and perhaps some now-lost
© +@QV@MR@Q@Xਡ"6
paid double the rate painted details. This was not an unusual
of an ordinary legionary soldier, phenomenon in Roman funerary practice, This tombstone for a Roman infantry-
as one of the duplicarii, ‘dou- and it was likely much cheaper than getting a man was apparently left un-inscribed,
ble-pay men’. It was certainly a fully personalised stone. suggesting studios created them,
ready to be bought and used for a de-
rank to be proud of holding. It is not even clear whether the now-lost
ceased soldier. Of course, we should
The tombstone bears a full- face of the figure in the tombstone would have note the text may have been painted
length portrait of Rufinus, depict- looked like Rufinus, although a superficial re- on as well. Now in the Rheinisches
ed alongside symbols of his military semblance at least could be achieved through Landesmuseum, Bonn, Germany.
rank. In his right hand, he holds a ma- the colouration of hair, eyes, and skin. Nev- © Karwansaray BV
niple standard, decorated with five phaler- ertheless, the selection of this tombstone in
ae medallions, topped with a hand – one of the particular indicates the way that Rufinus was
more common standards used by the Roman remembered by his fellow soldiers and buri- Dating to ca. AD 300, this fresco of
army. In his left hand, Rufinus carries a small al club, emphasizing his status as a legionary a military standard can be found
box, almost certainly intended to represent a standard-bearer. It can only be hoped that Rufi- painted on the wall of the luxuri-
ous Villa Romana del Casale, Piazza
box of writing-tablets, probably the codex ansa- nus would have approved of their choice. 0
Armerina, Sicily. Military standards
tus or volume of records, likely in reference to
had not altered a great deal since
his role managing the finances of the Legio IX. Jo Ball is a regular contributor to Ancient the second century.
In the portrait Rufinus does not have any other Warfare magazine. © Becc Repper / Flickr
military equipment, and he is shown wearing a
tunic and pointed cloak rather than armour.
0@QSH@KKXਡOQDRDQUDCਡ
M@LDOK@SDਡENQਡSGDਡ
x
RS@MC@QCਡNEਡ#NGNQRਡ6))ਡ
2@DSNQTL ਡMNVਡHMਡSGDਡ
2GDHMRHRBGDRਡ,@MCDRLT
RDTL ਡ"NMM ਡ'DQL@MX Ancient Warfare XVI-1
© +@QV@MR@Q@Xਡ"6 51
ROMAN ARMY IN DETAIL
A relief on the Mausoleum of Glanum shows Roman cavalry in combat. The monument was perhaps built for a member of the Julii, ca. 30-20 BC.
e decion’s depues
The Roman army included, at one time or another, 70 or hierarchy of command was similar to that of
the equites singulares Augusti (see AW XIII.3).
80 cavalry units, each with its own staff of officers and In fact, the only difference, as far as he could
promoted men. Many of these individuals are known see, was that musicians, present in the em-
peror’s horse guard, were unknown in the
from their tombstones, but the hierarchy that governed
regular cavalry units – an odd state of affairs,
their day-to-day life isn’t often discussed. So what exact- given that the horse guard was modelled on
ly do we know about the officers of the Roman cavalry? the auxiliary alae. But, in fact, this was just an-
other reminder of the vagaries of the archaeo-
logical record, for we now know of several
ur knowledge of the
O
cavalry musicians (and see also AW XIV.1).
different ranks and
functions in the Ro- Cavalry command
man imperial army Domaszewski’s doctoral thesis in 1881 had
derives, in large part, been a study of Hyginus’ Book about the For-
from Alfred von Domaszewski’s study tifications of a Camp, so he was well aware
of the Rangordnung (‘hierarchy’). of the command structure of the ala, since
When he came to study the alae, or Hyginus (ch. 16) tells us:
cavalry squadrons, he noted that the
A milliary cavalry squadron consists of
24 troops, in which there are decurions,
A copper-alloy cavalry mask dated to AD 80- double-pay men, and pay-and-a-half men,
125, found in Leiden, the Netherlands. An en-
in the same number as there are troops.
tire unit of cavalrymen wearing polished masks,
glittering in the sun must have been an impres-
(…) A quingenary cavalry squadron has
sive sight indeed, as undoubtedly intended.
© Karwansaray BV
visit to the famous Memnon colossus at Egyp- ala II Pannoniorum by the deified Trajan”, and Graffiti visible on one of the Colossi
tian Thebes (Luxor), where tourists (including subsequently “appointed as decurion by him of Memnon (the mortuary temple of
in the same ala”. He claims that the reason for pharaoh Amenhotep III). These two
the emperor Hadrian) carved their names
statues were considered tourist attrac-
into the stone. Audimus Memnonem (“we his promotion was “because he had captured
tions in the Roman Imperial period.
heard Memnon”), they wrote (CIL III, 30), Decebalus and had brought his head to him Some of surviving inscriptions were
alluding to the eerie sound caused when [Trajan] at Ranisstorum” in AD 106, but we left by cavalrymen stationed nearby.
the sandstone gradually expanded in the may think it was perhaps overdue for a thrice- © Carole Raddato / Flickr
#NOODQਡ@KKNXਡ2NL@MਡG@Q
MDRRਡLNTMSਡ)SਡHRਡO@QSਡ
x
NEਡSGDਡ&QDLHMFSNMਡ(@FFਡ
#@U@KQXਡ(N@QC ਡVGHBGਡBNM
S@HMDCਡ@ਡVHCDਡU@QHDSXਡNEਡ
2NL@MਡGNQRDਡEHSSHMFR Ancient Warfare XVI-1
© 9NQJਡ-TRDTLRਡ4QTRS 53
Reenactors of a Hadrianic period decorated soldier (once by Domitian and
Roman cavalry turma, with Roman twice by Trajan himself). As it seems probable π DID YOU KNOW?
equipment and horse fittings, and that Maximus had enlisted in around AD 80, The inscription on a silver ring found at Xanten
including several officers, wait to in the nineteenth century states that the veteran
we may suggest that he achieved the rank of
display their skills at Bitts Park, Flavius Simplex, formerly a duplicarius in the ala
decurion at around 40 years of age.
Carlisle, UK, in 2017. Afrorum veterana, gave it as a gift to the other
© M.C.Bishop / Flickr It seems that the duplicarius was the sec- duplicarii and sesquiplicarii of the unit (CIL XIII,
ond-in-command of the troop, mirroring the 10024.34). This is presumably the sole surviving
role of the optio in the legions and cohorts, example from a set of several dozen rings.
with a sesquiplicarius as his deputy. With only
a decurion’s post to aspire to, many of these town council of his native Thelepte (Tunisia).
principales must have retired without achiev- Dexter had served as curator turmae, armorum
ing promotion. The tombstone of the sesqui- custos, and signifer turmae. The last of these
plicarius Longinus Muleruna states that “he posts, ‘standard-bearer of a cavalry troop’, is
served for 21 years in the troop of Peticus” vividly depicted on a figural tombstone found
(CIL VIII, 21029) and died aged 40, just at the at Hexham (England) (RIB 1172). (For the post
stage of life when men like Victorinus and of armorum custos, see AW XV.2.)
Maximus finally became decurions. Another Dexter had also served as curator (‘su-
“pay-and-a-half man”, Fuscus, son of Lucius, pervisor’), a post that Domaszewski linked
Fragment of the four-metre-long pa- was honourably discharged from the ala I Fla- with the stables without fully explaining his
pyrus roll from Fayum covering the via Britannica on 9 October AD 148 (CIL XVI, reasoning. Interestingly, at Vindolanda,
career of the veteran Lucius Iulius
180), having served out his 25 years. the fort of a part-mounted cohors equi-
Serenus (P. Hamb. graec. 184.H).
tata, the daily reports (e.g. Tab. Vindol.
Within the record are preserved
receipts for hay that were purchased
Other ranks 127) carried the formula “the optiones
for horses belonging to the Ala vet- Domaszewski listed fifteen distinct functions and curatores have reported”, suggest-
erana Gallica in Alexandria. within the ala, though several were clerical ing that the curator was the cavalry
© Staats- und Universitätsbibliothek posts on the decurion’s staff. Three of them equivalent of the infantry optio and
Hamburg
came from the tombstone of Gaius Julius Dex- thus second-in-command of the turma.
ter (CIL VIII, 2094), a veteran cavalryman who Domaszewski was perhaps familiar
was honourably discharged after 26 years and with a huge roll of papyrus, some four
who died aged 85, having sat on the metres long, that had been discovered in
the Fayum and published in 1911, under the ignation? Some light is shed on the prob-
title “Official receipt of hay money for the ala lem by the Dura-Europos duty roster of
veterana Gallica” (P. Hamb. 39). The papyrus AD 219, which lists the complete per-
comprised dozens of receipts, each of which sonnel of the cohors XX Palmyrenorum
was addressed to an officer called the summus equitata (P. Dura 100). It shows that the
curator, or ‘head supervisor’, of the cavalry decurions Zebidas and Octavius were
squadron, and the complete set covered the first each assisted by a duplicarius and a ses-
three months of AD 179. All of the cavalrymen quiplicarius, just as Hyginus says, but the
signed their own receipt for the sum of 25 de- decurion Tiberini, for some reason, had
narii; occasionally, a man required the troop’s two duplicarii and a sesquiplicarius. Fur-
signifer to write on his behalf, in one case “on thermore, Zebidas’ troop logged a total of
account of Heliodorus writing so slowly”, and five “double-pay men”, one of whom was
in several others because the cavalrymen in the signifer, while Octavius’ troop logged
question “claimed not to know how to write”, six. (Tiberini’s total has been lost.) So, it
whereas the signifer’s job required him to be lit- seems that certain men could be desig-
erate. Unfortunately, each man identified him- nated as the decurion’s deputies, regard-
self simply as a “cavalryman of the ala Gallica less of their day-to-day function, though, as
in the troop of Julius Nepotianus” (or one with so many features of the Roman army, The tombstone of Tiberius Claudius
of the other fifteen decurions), rather the details remain elusive. 0 Saturninus (duplicarius, and vetera-
than divulging a rank or function. nus alae Astur(um) from the first
century AD – (AE 1988, 998).
We cannot be sure of the pre- Dr. Duncan B. Campbell is a regular contribu-
© Sailko / Wikimedia Commons
cise relationship between Hygi- tor to Ancient Warfare magazine.
nus’ duplicarii and sesquiplicarii
and the range of functions car- FURTHER READING
ried out, for example, by Julius • Welles, C.B., R.O. Fink, and J.F.
Dexter. Was the curator always Gilliam. The Excavations at Dura-
the duplicarius? And if so, Europos: Final Report V, Part 1:
wasn’t the signifer, who also The Parchments and Papyri. New
appears to have drawn double Haven: Yale University Press, 1959.
pay, entitled to the same des-
!ਡEHQRS RDBNMCਡBDMSTQXਡ!$ਡHMRBQHOSHNMਡ
EQNLਡ4G@LTF@CHਡQDBNQCHMFਡSGDਡB@QDDQਡ
NEਡ-@QBTRਡ!MMHTRਡ-@QSH@KHR ਡVGNਡV@Rਡ
x
CTOKHB@QHTRਡ@MCਡSGDMਡCDBTQHNMਡNEਡ!K@ਡ)ਡ
0@MMNMHNQTLਡ#),ਡ6))) ਡ
© ,"-ਡ7HJHLDCH@ਡ#NLLNMR Ancient Warfare XVI-1
55
REVIEWS
ANCIENT PIRATES AND RAIDERS Want to learn more about the groups that made their living attacking
by sea during antiquity? Here are some books and articles to check out.
The meticulous scholarship makes this the go-to volume on an- Omerod's classic study brings the treachery of the ancient high
cient piracy; A historical study examining its origins and growth, seas alive. Drawing on the works of Homer and Thucydides and
impact on trade, and the relationship between warfare and piracy. the historical records, Ormerod reconstructs the dangers of coastal
It evaluates attempts to suppress piracy by the states and rulers living and seafaring and the attempts to protect against the threat
of the ancient world and discusses the way pirates are portrayed. of invasion from the seas until the formation of the Roman Empire.
Originally published in 1971, this encyclopaedic study was the Rauh combines trade, maritime travel, Roman expansion and pira-
first to use underwater archaeological data to refine an area of cy into one concise study. Exploring the origins, possible alliances,
scholarship that had, up to that point, relied on ancient texts and and history of the pirates who sailed the coast of the ancient Medi-
graphic representations. Casson describes the ships, crews, weap- terranean, the most important trading centres, pirates’ coves and
onry, cargo stowage, navigation, harbor facilities, and ship names. strongholds, and Roman forts that were built to counteract them.
A Call To Arms
The Day War Was Invented
By Anne Lehoërff
Through the sword, the Bronze
Age brought war into being. The
warrior became an important
figure. Societies were
transformed, and came to revolve
politically and economically
around warfare.
SIDESTONE PRESS
9789464261042 • PAPERBACK • 226 PAGES • NOVEMBER 2022 • £30.00
SPECIAL OFFER: £25.00
@OXBOWBOOKS /OXBOWBOOKS
RoMa Ns
R om A n s