Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Ruby Mcdermid - Final Draft Unit 3 Argument Essay
Ruby Mcdermid - Final Draft Unit 3 Argument Essay
Ruby Mcdermid - Final Draft Unit 3 Argument Essay
Ruby McDermid
SUPA WRT
Mrs. Mckeever
24 May 2024
As you stroll along Beirut's famous seafront, among the crowed corniche and crashing
waves, a striking art installation catches your eye: “Undress 522” by Lebanese artist Mireille
Honein. The powerful piece immediately grabs your attention and you look around to see you're
not the only one moved by its visual and emotional art. Thirty-one wedding dresses composed of
layers of translucent, paper material hung from nooses, move gently in the wind, conjuring a
sense of despair for the young women the dresses are meant to cover. The installation, in its
ghostly look, conveys a haunting reminder of Lebanese Penal Code 522, which allows rapists to
escape punishment if they marry their victims. Surrounding the installation, passersby pause,
some in quiet examination and others discussing the artwork's significance. Activists are ready to
gather support from the public through signatures on their petition to abolish Article 522. The
atmosphere is charged with a sense of reflection and newfound awareness. The installation is not
only a piece of art but also a tool to help people learn about the terrible Lebanese penal codes.
Many of the features of the art installation were deliberate when Honein was designing it.
She chose to set up the installation on Beirut's famous seafront, as its consistently crowded
location reaches the largest number of viewers. The number of dresses in the installation was
intended to point toward the idea that each day of the month a woman is raped and forced to
marry her rapist. Lastly, the material used in the composition of the dresses was a conscious
choice, as the paper was supposed to “expose the "ephemeral" nature of matrimony and the
McDermid 2
legality that surrounds it” (Kasana). Each characteristic was put in place to bring attention to the
An art installation is not the first thing that comes to mind when attempting to influence
Lebanon’s parliamentary committee to have Legislation 522 abolished. And it is not the only
Equality. However, it is with the art installation that ABBAD’s campaign to abolish Lebanese
penal code 522 falls under the category of cultural resistance. According to Stephen Duncombe,
a Professor at the Gallatin School and the Department of Media, Culture, and Communication of
New York University, cultural resistance is “culture that is used, consciously or unconsciously,
effectively or not, to resist and/or change the dominant political, economic and/or social
structure” (Duncombe 135). Culture in this sense is a very elastic term; it can range from art to
music to fashion. I’d like to point to popular events, such as the Zoot Suit Riots and the punk
movement of the 70s, to exemplify cultural resistance, as you can see culture has been a tool to
express dissatisfaction with mainstream narratives throughout history. The Zoot Riots started as
a result of the Mexican American youth wearing oversized suits to express identity when war-
time rationing of fabric was taking place. People involved in the punk movement of the 70s used
music to reject modern ideals and accept people deemed different in society. And you can see
through its continued usage that this form of activism is effective, as it brings together
marginalized groups to critique power structures and promote political, economic, and social
change.
In Lebanon, women have a long history of organizing for social sustainability, similar to
their counterparts worldwide. In 1996, Lebanon ratified the Convention on the Elimination of All
reservations perpetuate discrimination against women in areas such as family issues, nationality,
marriage, divorce, and inheritance. The government's reluctance to fully adopt CEDAW stems
from the “constitutional agreement to delegate personal status laws to sect-specific religious
courts,” which often enforce gender-discriminatory rules (Maalouf). One of the discriminating
articles that existed and remained the same when the Lebanese government ratified CEDAW was
article 522 from the Lebanese penal code. The article allowed men convicted of sexual assault,
abduction, or statutory rape to evade a minimum penalty of five years of hard labor if they
provided a valid marriage contract with the victim. In Lebanon, since rape is considered legal
within marriage, article 522 served as a means of escape for rapists to avoid punishment. On
December 7th, 2016, Lebanon’s Parliamentary Committee for Administration and Justice
announced their proposal to repeal Article 522, kick-starting ABBAD’s national campaign "A
ABBAD saw penal code 522 as a blatant discrimination against women and girls. In
response, they launched a series of creative advocacy activities aimed at repealing Article 522
and tackling the lack of knowledge surrounding it. Some of these actions included having
activists “dressed in white sheets with slogans such as ‘Rape is a Crime. Abolish 522!’” walk in
the Beirut Marathon, and organizing “sit-ins in front of the Committee of Administration and
Justice when it was drafting the law abolishing article 522 to be sent to the Parliament” (Anani).
But taking a step further, ABBAD partnered with renowned, Lebanese artist Mireille Honein to
set up “Undress 522,” an art installation that asserts the right of women survivors to reject
marriage to their rapists, combats stigma, and emphasizes that rape is a crime that should be
punished without legitimizing it through forced marriages. An art installation was a crucial
McDermid 4
addition to the traditional campaigning of ABBAD’s efforts to abolish Lebanese Penal Code 522,
as it evoked an emotional appeal in the viewers that public mobilization such as sit-ins and
marathons lacked. “Undress 522,” a political and social statement against an outdated system
that contributes to the violence and discrimination of women, effectively sensitized the public to
penal code 522 and fostered a sense of sadness for future victims of the rape law if the code was
not abolished.
puts it, “It is the directness of art, its short circuit to the emotional core of our beings, that makes
through an art installation, song, or poetry, experiencing something through art can have a much
stronger impact than receiving the same message through purely informational means. Therefore,
if the goal of a certain culture or group is to move someone to act, they need to convey their
belief or custom in a way that resonates on a more visceral level. When sensitizing the public to
Lebanese penal code 522, the art installation not only informed the public about the code but it
also highlighted how violently it can affect a woman's life, appealing to the audience’s sense of
injustice. The wedding dresses are used as a symbol of the unjust marriage coerced by Article
522. Rape can harm women’s sexual and reproductive health and leave lasting psychological
trauma, so having the loophole for rapists in the law dismisses rape as a crime and permanently
condemns a victim’s life. Honein wants the viewers to experience the sadness of the fact that
these victims are forced to live with their perpetrators against their will in an environment that
Supporters of Article 522 argue that the marriage will salvage the honor of the woman
and her family. Rothna Begum, a women’s rights researcher for the Middle East and North
Africa at Human Rights Watch, told Al Jazeera “Girls or women who have been raped,
especially if she’s a virgin, are then considered unmarriageable. So, lawmakers tend to feel that
providing her the opportunity to marry her rapist is helping to protect her” (Alabaster). Getting
the parliamentary committee to sign off on the proposal to repeal the law doesn’t address the fact
that these values are entrenched in society and family. Fortunately, Honein’s art installation is a
step toward social change because its 31 dresses, representing the 31 days in a month that a
woman can be compelled to marry her rapist, highlights how often rape occurs. In regions such
as Lebanon, the idea of rape is such a taboo topic that the victim is often blamed for causing the
incident; people connect the tragic event to shame on the victim’s family. Honein’s installation
intends to make people understand that rape is a part of everyday society and to impose laws and
unjust standards upon someone that has been raped is unfair. Reducing the social stigma
surrounding rape starts with an overhaul of sexual education across the Middle East and
“Undress 522” can be considered one of those educational tools. Once society recognizes rape is
a crime and women have sexual autonomy, there will be no need to “protect” the victims
anymore, then allowing women to regain control of their married life. The art installation is not
going to immediately prevent families from pressuring their daughters into accepting offers of
marriage from the rapist. Still, it will forever remind them that they are sentencing their daughter
to a life-long rape.
Although “Undress 522” delivered its goal to sensitize the public on Article 522, the
cultural resistance fails to address the bigger issue of women’s rights. In some way, the art
installation was just a “haven in a heartless world” (Himely and Fitzsimmons 135). It created a
McDermid 6
sanctuary where an ideal society lives and problems vanish, but outside nothing changed at all.
The art installation enlightened people about the effect of penal code 522 on young women, yet it
shielded them from witnessing the physical abuse they will be put through in marriage to their
rapist and understanding the psychological trauma the victims develop. The campaign might
have abolished the article, but a plethora of Lebanese laws still permit violence and
discrimination against women. Not only in Lebanon, but also throughout the rest of the world
laws are in place where women face the repercussions for crimes and actions that aren’t their
fault. Fixing one law should not stop ABBAD’s campaign to promote women’s basic human
rights while others persist. Furthermore, women still face stigmatization because society is not
willing to change its traditional mindsets. People need to understand that the fight for equal
rights among genders as inevitable as gender equality is persistent and new forms of cultural
“Undress 522” and its supporting protests succeeded in pressuring the Lebanese
parliamentary committee to abolish penal code 522. Because of the art installation’s location and
message, videos of the display were posted across multiple news platforms garnering mass
support from both men and women to scrap the article. The message reached such a large
audience due to its emotional appeal and the lack of public knowledge surrounding Lebanese
penal codes. In fact, “only 1% of the Lebanese public opinion knew about article 522.” This
aided in the art installation leaving a lasting impact on people because the shock of finding out
about the article coupled with the sad story each wedding dress tells is the type of art that spurs
people to action. This was easily doable with the amount of volunteers walking around near the
display asking passersby to sign in support of the “A White Dress Does Not Cover the Rape”
campaign. It can be concluded that art is an effective form of cultural resistance, as demonstrated
McDermid 7
by the art installation “Undress 522” in its achievement to abolish Article 522 and sensitize the
Work Cited
Alabaster, Olivia. “Critics Urge Repeal of Lebanon Rape Law.” Al Jazeera, Al Jazeera, 4 Jan.
2017, www.aljazeera.com/features/2017/1/4/critics-urge-repeal-of-lebanon-rape-law.
Anani, Ghida. “Abolishing Lebanon’s ‘Rape Law’: Spotlight on Abaad’s Campaign.” Girls Not
tlight-on-abaads-campaign/.
Duncombe, Stephen, introduction to "The Cultural Resistance Reader." Critical Encounters with
Texts: Finding a Place to Stand. Eds. Margaret Himley and Anne Fitzsimmons. New
Kasana, Mehreen. “Lebanese Artist Protests Marriage Rape Law by Hanging Wedding Dresses
e-rape-law-by-hanging-wedding-dresses-from-nooses-53100.
Maalouf, Donna Maria. The Abolishment of the Lebanese Marriage Loophole- Article 522,
37_1.pdf?sequence=1.
Wilcox, Emily, "An Investigation of the Intersection between Art and Activism" (2009). Honors
u/stu_ho n_theses/275