Professional Documents
Culture Documents
6 Questions To Help You Avoid Repetitive Scenes
6 Questions To Help You Avoid Repetitive Scenes
6 Questions To Help You Avoid Repetitive Scenes
Weiland Site
Novel
Outlining
Structure
Character
Arcs 6 Questions to Help You
Archetypal
Characters
Avoid Repetitive Scenes
Scene Email Share 79 Tweet Save 52 SHARE
At a certain point, most writers will receive critiques or edits in which whole
Write Your
SUBSCRIBE
Best Book scenes are circled in red with notes that read “nothing happens” or “they
already had this conversation” or “this doesn’t advance the plot” or “feels like
you’re padding the word count”—all of which are code for “repetitive scenes.” SIGN UP FOR K.M. WEILAND’S E-LETTER
AND GET A FREE E-BOOK
Recognizing repetitive scenes can be tricky for authors (hence, the big red
circles from critique partners and editors). Our deep immersion in our own
stories inevitably causes a certain lack of objectivity. We may think a scene is
full of new info when really the characters have already been there done that.
Readers may not think too much about one or two repetitive scenes. But at a
certain point, they will grow increasingly restless and frustrated with the
story’s lack of progress.
(affiliate link)
A while back, I received an email from Wordplayer Sarah K. with an insightful
question:
My response was that there’s nothing wrong with keeping the conflict mostly CATEGORIES
interpersonal and expressed in dialogue. Many novels operate this way (and,
indeed, I’d argue this is often the most interesting type of conflict). But Sarah Select Category
still raises an excellent point: how do you know whether the scenes you’re
(affiliate link) writing are simply leisurely and character-driven scenes or whether they are
truly repetitious?
Today, I’m going to dive a little deeper into this subject and examine what
defines repetitive scenes, as well as strategies for recognizing and avoiding
them in your own fiction.
(affiliate link)
Thematic motifs also require repetition to become effective. For instance, one
2014-2022 confrontation with authority does not a rebel make. But if your character has
repeated run-ins with authority figures, then the entire story begins to take
on a specific thematic shape. This is not only okay, it’s necessary to the
FREE E-BOOK
formation of a cohesive and resonant story.
Of course sometimes what the author intends as thematic repetition will still
come across as boring and unnecessary to readers. Fortunately, there are
several questions you can ask yourself to analyze whether your scenes are
truly advancing the story or whether they are repetitive—and should probably
be cut.
And what if your story is more relational with a less obvious plot goal? What
if, like Sarah’s story, yours is primarily focused on lots of conversations
between characters with a vaguer destination of something like “coming to
peace with a complicated parent’s passing”? Ultimately, the same guideline
applies. Examine how well the characters’ goals are evolving from scene to
scene. Are they getting closer to what they want—or farther away? (Either will
provide a sufficient movement of the plot circumstances.) If the talking isn’t
achieving any movement for any of the characters then examine how you
might adjust that from scene to scene.
It could be that the character’s goal doesn’t change too much for multiple
scenes, and that’s okay, as long as the obstacles are changing. If your
protagonist is a detective trying to get a conversation with a mob boss, he
might have to try several different tactics before he gets what he wants. But if
he faces the same obstacle (or a familiar variation on the same obstacle) in
every one of those scenes, the action will quickly feel repetitious.
Sometimes realism and pacing demand characters won’t get what they want
on the first try. In these instances, you’ll need to evolve their goal subtly from
scene to scene by focusing on how they systematically work through various
obstacles on their way to the goal.
This could be information that is new to the protagonist, but it could also
simply be new insights for the readers. For instance, the protagonist might
reveal a personal secret to another character. This might not directly advance
the plot or immediately change the scene goal or conflict, but as long as it
deepens the characterization context, it can serve to justify the scene’s
existence.
This is a tricky one, since writers must be able to accurately judge whether the
new information is truly adding something to the story. If the character’s
secret is about how he broke his brother’s bike when they were kids, that
secret must either become crucial to the development of the plot later on or
offer significant insight into the character’s own personality and motivation.
Even genre books need variety. In fact, the contrast offered by varied scenes
can create powerful opportunities for thematic subtext. For example, one of
my favorite scenes in the Band of Brothers miniseries is one in which a
French nurse eats a chocolate bar with the company medic in a bombed-out
village. She dies shortly after and he never sees her again. But the quiet
relational moment within a heavy war story created both poignant contrast
and welcome variety.
Not only will this change up the “scenery,” it should also give you the
opportunity to deepen any given scene’s complexity by bringing in the
motives, desires, goals, grudges, etc., of many different personalities. A three-
way conversation between your protagonist, her mother, and the local vicar
will be a completely different conversation from one between your
protagonist, her father, and the local sheriff—even if the topic under
discussion is the same.
***
Sometimes recognizing repetitive scenes is the toughest part. After that, the
solution (although not fun) is usually pretty easy. Either delete the scene you
don’t need and/or combine its important bits with a more comprehensive and
important scene. The result will be a much tighter and more interesting story.
Ep. #568: 6 Questions to Help You Avoid Repetitive Scenes
00:00:00
___
SIGN UP TODAY
Sign up to receive K.M. Weiland’s e-letter and receive her free e-
book Crafting Unforgettable Characters: A Hands-On
Introduction to Bringing Your Characters to Life.
CAPTCHA
SUBSCRIBE
Related Posts
Here Are Two Your Story How to Pull Off 7 Tips for How
Ways to Write Isn’t Working? a Plot Twist to Add
Organic Here Are 6 Complexity to
Themes Problems to Your Story
Troubleshoot
Comments
Ooo. Good post! I was just reading Robert McKee’s “Story” over the
weekend and have been pondering his take on Scenes and Beats. I
found the passage below enlightening. Your post helps expand on
that.
REPLY
REPLY
Amy says
OCTOBER 25, 2021 AT 7:30 PM
REPLY
Great post! I have a question but I don’t know if it’s related to this or
not.
I’ve read about scene structure and I think I understand it, but it’s
always very difficult for me to figure out when one scene ends and
another begins. I can make a goal, conflict, and disaster to some
extent, but I always get stuck when it comes to the decision part. I
can show in Action the goal and conflict and disaster occurring, but
how do I “show” the decision that leads to the next goal? And how
does the sequel come in between? You may have already answered
this somewhere, but I’m just not sure I fully understand how to
execute the scene-sequel stuff in my stories.
Thanks for everything!
REPLY
REPLY
REPLY
Yay! Go you!
REPLY
I’m reading Roy Peter Clark’s The Art of x-ray reading. He makes the
distinction between redundancy and repetition – redundancy is
unintentional and adds nothing, repetition is intentional and builds
an effect, or a theme. That fits well with your post, I think, and both
have been a useful clarification.
REPLY
REPLY
Grant says
OCTOBER 25, 2021 AT 10:05 AM
REPLY
REPLY
REPLY
REPLY
Sara K. says
OCTOBER 25, 2021 AT 12:40 PM
I have not run into this particular problem, probably because I’m
vulnerable to underwriting. I sometimes get feedback which is the
equivalent of ‘another scene needs to be added here.’ I’m still
repetitious at the micro-level, such as by overusing certain words.
REPLY
REPLY
REPLY
REPLY
REPLY
REPLY
80smetalman says
OCTOBER 25, 2021 AT 3:03 PM
REPLY
REPLY
Jobie says
OCTOBER 25, 2021 AT 5:48 PM
REPLY
REPLY
theandyclark says
OCTOBER 25, 2021 AT 6:27 PM
Ok, this is a bit bold of me, but I want to suggest a couple of other
things that might not kill particularly scenes, but might shoot a story.
If the story keeps repeating the exact same type of conflict, it will get
boring. So even in a dialog heavy story, it shouldn’t all be straight
argument. There can be false agreement, thinly veiled insults,
dismissal, interruptions, unwanted agreement, and a massive pile of
internal disagreements. Frankly, I try to have multiple types of
conflict afoot in each scene,
I’ve also looked at works were the scenes all end the same way, and I
get bored with this. Now, a fast action story can often get away with
this, but for most stories ending on exactly the same type of “OMG
the MC can’t get out of this one!” twist, gets to be repetitious,
particularly when the scenes are longish. There are interesting ways
to end a scene that don’t involve a cliffhanger (hint, hint: there might
be an article in there – effective ways to end a scene). Cliffhangers
are great, but they’re not the only game in town and your
plot/character/world should be interesting enough to end on a point
where the MC faces a non-life threatening dilemma or is upset about
something or even (shudder) has something unexpectedly good
happen to them.
May your words cascade off your fingers and bring you joy and
delight.
Andy
REPLY
REPLY
This came at a great time for me, as I’m currently working on the 2nd
draft of my WIP. What I’ve found incredibly helpful with
repetitive/boring scenes is similar to point #6 on this post. I already
had enough characters, so I didn’t want to create any new ones. But I
did have all of these characters with clashing goals and personalities
that I wasn’t utilizing nearly enough. So I took some of these minor
characters, and put them in the boring scenes.
(I think I pulled this trick from one of your blog posts from several
years ago… I believe it was “An Easy Way to Notch Up Your Scene
Conflict.” This post in particular really helped me fix boring and
repetitive scenes!)
REPLY
REPLY
MAL says
OCTOBER 26, 2021 AT 11:37 AM
REPLY
REPLY
strackdennis@yahoo.com says
OCTOBER 26, 2021 AT 12:31 PM
REPLY
REPLY
Dennis says
OCTOBER 30, 2021 AT 2:04 PM
REPLY
Dana says
OCTOBER 29, 2021 AT 7:03 PM
Way late comer to the party, but I wanted to pop in and say thanks
for this post! This was the perfect article for me this week; I have a
tendency for too many “coffee in the kitchen” moments in my
writing, and I’ve been working on ways to weed them out of my
historical WIP. You’re my favorite writing mentor, and I love reading
all the comments here and getting to hear about all the fabulous
stories in progress.
REPLY
REPLY
REPLY
REPLY
Oh, man. I like to spreadsheet each scene and note its type (where?
who? what activity is happening?) to call attention to my repetitive
scenes. By doing this I learned that my WIP has a meeting problem.
So many meetings. I’m combining as many of them as I can,
changing their settings, and of course eliminating as many as
possible. One of the remaining meeting scenes was refreshed by
moving it outside and adding a strutting, aggressive peacock who
screeches while my MC is trying very hard be taken seriously.
REPLY
tracivw says
NOVEMBER 26, 2021 AT 11:49 AM
This post is perfect for me right now as I just got an editorial letter
back from my agent explaining how many of my scenes are repetitive
with so much running away in a cat and mouse scenes of almost
getting caught and running again. You have helped me find a path
forward through my running quagmire! Thank you!
REPLY
Leave a Reply
Enter your comment here...
This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.
Site Policy
Return to top of page Copyright © 2016 · Helping Writers Become Authors · Built by Varick Design
This website uses cookies to ensure you get the best experience on our website. Please read our privacy policy for more information Got it!