Because PbCl2 is soluble on hot. Why do we use dilute HCl? Because PbCl2 is soluble in conc HCl forming a soluble complex: PbCl2 + 2Cl- → [PbCl4]2- Why do we avoid large excess HCl? Because PbCl2 is soluble in excess HCl forming a soluble complex: PbCl2 + 2Cl- → [PbCl4]2-