Download as docx, pdf, or txt
Download as docx, pdf, or txt
You are on page 1of 51

ILOCOS SUR POLYTECHNIC STATE COLLEGE

Republic of the Philippines

Ilocos Sur polytechnic State College

Tagudin Campus

College of Teacher Education

HRM practices and challenges of Tagudin National High School

Researchers:

Garlejo,Ericka G.

Aquilod, Marielle S.

BSED 3- Social Studies


ILOCOS SUR POLYTECHNIC STATE COLLEGE

RESEARCH ABSTRACT

TITLE: Human Resource Mangement practices


and challenges of Tagudin National
High School

Total No. of Pages: 46

Author: ERICKA G. GARLEJO


MARIELLE S.AQUILOD

Adviser: ROSEMARIE J. PASCUA, PhD.

Institution: Ilocos Sur Polytechnic State College


College of Teacher Education

Location: Quirino, Tagudin, Ilocos Sur

KEYWORDS: Training and Career Development, Practices


and Challenges, Seminars and Workshops,
and Lack of trainings and development
ILOCOS SUR POLYTECHNIC STATE COLLEGE

Abstract. This interpretative phenomenological research entitled “Human Resource


Management practices and challenges of Tagudin National High School” assessed and analyzed
the practices and challenges of the institution. There were two (2)Head departments and two
(2)Administrators of Tagudin National High School who served as the participants of the study.
The questions focused on these concept/layer of human experience: practices and
challenges/problems encountered. The thematic analysis was employed to interpret the findings
of the interviews, which resulted into four themes Implementing People Management ,
Budgetary constraints on employee development and reward
programs ,Workload Issues, and Behavior Issues, which answered the question on the
Human Resouce Manangement practices and challenges . The researchers’ recommendations
focused on the implementation of a more through training and career management strategy for
the Human Resource Managemnt
ILOCOS SUR POLYTECHNIC STATE COLLEGE

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Page

TITLE PAGE…………………………………………………………………………………...i

ABSTRACT…………………………………………………………………………………….ii

TABLE OF CONTENTS……………………………………………………………………...iv

CHAPTER I

Introduction……………………………………………………………………………………..1

Theoretical Framework...……………………………………………………………………….2

Conceptual Framework...……………………………………………………………………….4

Research Paradigm…......……………………………………………………………………….5

Review of Related Literature...………………………………………………………………….6

Statement of the Problem...……………………………………………………………………...8

Significance of the Study………………………………………………………………………..9

Definition of terms…………………………………….………………………………………..9

CHAPTER II

Research Design………………………………………………………………………………...11
ILOCOS SUR POLYTECHNIC STATE COLLEGE

Research Environment………….………………………………………………………………12

Respondent of the Study………………………………………………………………………..13

Data Measure…………………………………………………………………………...………13

Instrumentation and Data Collection Procedure…………………………………………...…...14

Data Analysis Procedure………………………………………………………………………..14

Ethical Considerations…………………………………………………………………..............15

CHAPTER III

Results…………………………………………………………………………………………..16

Implementing People Management ………………………………………………………..16

Budgetary constraints on employee

Development and reward programs …………………………………………………..19

Workload issues ………………………………………………………..16

Behavior issues ………………………………………………………..16

CHAPTER IV

Summary………………………………………………………………………………………..23

Findings…………………………………………………………………………………………23
ILOCOS SUR POLYTECHNIC STATE COLLEGE

Conclusion………………………………………………………………………………………24

Recommendations……………………………………………………………………………….24

REFERENCES…………………………………………………………………………………25

APPENDICES

APPENDIX A. LETTER OF REQUEST……………………………………………………….29

APPENDIX B. WAIVER……………………………………………………………………..30

APPENDIX C. THEMATIC ANALYSIS REPERTORY GRID……………………………..32

APPENDIX D. INTERVIEW GUIDE DEVELOPMENT……………………………………36

Curriculum Vitae………………………………………………………………………............39

CHAPTER 1
INTRODUCTION
Background of the Study

In English, Human Resource Management (HR) is called "Human Resource man


agreement" which in short becomes HRM. Human beings are part of the resources needed by the
company/organization. However, there are still many management policies that do not pay
ILOCOS SUR POLYTECHNIC STATE COLLEGE

attention to the importance of the role of human resources, so from this understanding, I can
analyze that the policy company still does not pay attention to the interests of human resources.
Human resource management is a very important aspect in the education process in general.
Therefore, functions in the management of human resources must be carried out optimally so
that the needs relating to individual, organizational or institutional goals can be achieved.
Besides that, with good human resource management procedures, it is expected that the
shortcomings and problems faced by the Indonesian people, who are related to competitiveness,
can be overcome
Human Resource Management is a process of dealing with various problems within the
scope of employees, employees, laborers, managers and other employees to be able to support
the activities of an organization or company in order to achieve predetermined goals. Human
resource management is management that specializes in the field of personnel. Human Resource
Management (HRM) is a form of recognition of the importance of organizational members
(personnel) as resources that can support the achievement of organizational goals, the
implementation of functions and activities of the organization to ensure that they are used
effectively and fairly for the benefit of organizations, individuals and society.
HRM is a fundamental function of management that identify and manage the
performance of staff in any organization. This simply infers that when a staff in the educational
organization are selected and recruited, inducted and properly rewarded, properly developed,
appraised and promoted, they will be committed to the job, remain dedicated and productive in
the educational institutions. This means that human resource management is the co-ordination
of the activities and efforts of people associated in educational institutions so that educational
goals could be achieved. Hence, human resource management in education is the process of
motivating staff to maximize their performance in order to obtain maximum output starting from
the day they are recruited.

Theoretical Framework

This was anchored on different theories and concepts that serve as

pillars in the persuit of the investigation.

Relevant Theories:
ILOCOS SUR POLYTECHNIC STATE COLLEGE

Organizational Theory: This theory explores how organizations function and

manage their resources. Concepts like leadership styles, organizational

structures, and communication patterns can be applied to understand the

dynamics within a school setting. Applying organizational theory to schools

provides valuable insights into how the complex systems function. By

understanding the relationships between various organizational components,

schools can make informed decisions, improve their efficiency, and ultimately

create a better learning environment for their students.

Resource-base view

Resource-base view Although Birger wernerfelt originally coined the term "resource-based view" as
a useful alternative to product-based strategic analysis, it was Jay Barney who most fully developed
and formalized RBV theory and proposed its significance for business strategy. Firm resources are
defined broadly in the RBV and include all physical resources, human resources, informantion,
resouarces, oraganizational processes, and even organizational capital resources (internal and
external relations) that can be leveraged by a firm for competitive advantage. Certain resources may
represent unique firm strengths that can be leverage for competitive advantage. the RBV, therefore,
served to recognize HR function and employees themselves as key strategic players in developing
and maintaing sustainable competitive advantage.

Contingency Theory:Contigency Theory developed by Fred Fiedler (1967) this

theory states that a leader’s effectiveness depends on the match between their

leadership style and their situation. Contingency theory is one of the main

theoretical underpinnings of innovative HRM approaches. It focuses on how

organizations adapt their HR practices and policies to internal and external

circumstances.The functional imperative of aligning HRM with strategy served

as one of the key factors differentiating HRM from personnel management,


ILOCOS SUR POLYTECHNIC STATE COLLEGE

while a current stream of research examines industry, firm size and

environmental intensity as the moderating or boundary conditions informing

the HRM–performance relationship.Attention has also turned to differentiating

HRM within firms so that, contingent on the value and uniqueness of employee

groups in realizing strategy, certain types of HR practices are said to be more

optimal than others (Lepak and Snell, 1999).

Path-Goal Theory

The path–goal theory, also known as the path–goal theory of leader

effectiveness or the path–goal model, is a leadership theory developed by

Robert House and John Antonakis(1996), the task-oriented elements of the

path–goal model can be classified as a form of instrumental leadership.Path–

goal theory assumes that leaders are flexible and that they can change their

style, as situations require. The theory proposes two contingency variables,

such as environment and follower characteristics, that moderate the leader

behavior-outcome relationship. Environment is outside the control of the

follower-task structure, authority system, and work group. Environmental

factors determine the type of leader behavior required if the follower outcomes

are to be maximized.

Human Capital theory


ILOCOS SUR POLYTECHNIC STATE COLLEGE

Human Capital theory, initially formulated by Garry Becker (1962) and Rosen (1967), argues that

individual workers have a set of skillsor abilities that can improve or accumulate through training and

education. The human capital theory (HTC) asserts that people possess a wide range of competences,

abilities, and personalities that can be tapped to dictate the human capital in an organization.

individuals who possess specific skills and knowledge, skills and experience. It includes the

employee's skills and knowledge gained through formal and informal learnings.

Understandinghuman capital is important for hrm in order to outline its strategies for talent

acquisition, training, and skills development amongst many other things. Human capital is even

moreimportant when it comes to employee learning and career development in the workplace. in this

study, the theory served as a guide for human resource management practices of City Government of

Candon, indicating thet training and development could improve performance as needed by HR

Personnel to be more valuable in the oraganization. Investing in human capital allows the

management to see growth - measured through the staff's abilities, values, and skillset. This will

increase productivity, and in time, and revenue.

CONCEPTUAL FRAMEWORK

RESEARCH PARADIGM

INPUT PROCESS OUTPUT

1. What are the


human resource
management Analysis on:1. What are
practices of the human resource
TAGUDIN National management practices
of TAGUDIN National Suggested interventions
High School? in establishing an
High School?
effective human resource
2. What are the 2. What are the human management
human resource resource management
management challenges of TAGUDIN
ILOCOS SUR POLYTECHNIC STATE COLLEGE

FEEDBACK

Figure 1. Research Paradigm

In order to have a better picture of the conceptual boundary of this study, a paradigm is

presented in Figure 1 which presents the Input-Process Output (IPO) Model of the study. The

input presents the Human Resource Manangement practices encountered of Tagudin National

High School. The process simplifies the challenges encountered of Human Resource
ILOCOS SUR POLYTECHNIC STATE COLLEGE

Manangement. And the output presents the suggested interventions in establishing an human

resource management.

REVIEW OF RELATED LITERATURE

Human resource management (HRM) includes all management decisions

and practices that affect the employee of an organization (Bhatt and Reddy,

2011). There have been many definitions of human resource management used

by different scholars. Daud (2006) defined HRM as a system, policy, and

practices that can affect folks that work in an organization. In addition,

Shahnawaz and Juyal (2006) defined Human resources management (HRM) as

all decisions and practice that influence worker within organizations. De Cieri,

et al. (2008) explained HRM as “the policies, practices and systems that

influence employees' behavior”. While Hussain and Ahmad (2012)considered

HRM to be a system that attempts to realize an active balance between the

personal interests of people and their economic added value. Lastly, Burma

(2014) viewed HRM is a strategic and clear approach for the organization’s

most valued assets behind on the employees.


ILOCOS SUR POLYTECHNIC STATE COLLEGE

HRM practices are defined as “organizational activities directed at

managing the pool of human resources and ensuring that the resources are

employed towards the fulfillmentof organizational goals” (Pankaj and Saxena,

2012).

According to Mark (2011), HRM practices of an organization can be an

important source of competitive advantage through cost leadership and

product differentiation. The competitive advantage realized through HRM

practices can be more sustainable than that achieved by other means.

Therefore, a company should continuously improve its HRM practices to retain

its competitive advantage. For this reason, human Resources seek to achieve

this by aim the supply of skilled and qualified individuals and the capabilities

of the current staff, with the organization’s current and future business plans;

this is done in order to maximize the return on investment, knowledge

management and electronic systems .

Statement of the Problem

This study aims to identify the HRM practices and challenges of Tagudin

National High School. Specifically, it sought answers to the following sub

problem:

1.What are the human resource management practices of TAGUDIN

National High School?


ILOCOS SUR POLYTECHNIC STATE COLLEGE

2.What are the human resource management challenges of TAGUDIN

National High school?

Significance of the study

The result of this study will be beneficial to the following:

Human Resource Management : it helps them to understand the

challenges and practices under which human resources may become scarce,

valuable, organisation-specific.It builds up existing HRM knowledge and helps

in finding solutions to the problems of HRM.

Human resource management in schools:It leads to starting and

operating a school. It helps in using human resources of school in the best

way. The important people can be the principal, teachers, administrator and

heads of department. Hence human resource in schools is very important to

focus on.

Researchers:This study will satisfied what their desire for essential

information needed to look deeper into an organization’s human resource

practices and challenges.Also, It would help other researchers as input to

conduct study.
ILOCOS SUR POLYTECHNIC STATE COLLEGE

Other interested parties: This will serve as a guide or reference in their future

studies on the subject matter. This study will serve as a basis for some

researchers that have related concerns and might provide answers to their

inquiries.

Definitions of key terms

Human Resource Management (HRM). This is a set of practices and methods

of integrating and maintaining the teaching staff in the school so that the

school can achieve their purpose and as well as meet the goals for which they

were established.

HRM Practices. This practices is to manage the people within a workplace to

achieve the organization's mission and reinforce the corporate culture.

HRM Challenges. The foundation of any organization. The definition of HRM

encompasses a broad range of activities at workplaces. It is the practice of

managing people to achieve better performance. These HR challenges might be


ILOCOS SUR POLYTECHNIC STATE COLLEGE

environmental challenges, organizational challenges and individual challenges,

etc.

Leadership.Leadership is a process by which a person influences others to

accomplish an objective and directs the organization in a way that makes it

more cohesive and coherent.

Decisions. When we refer to decision making in HR, it means all people

processes are involved. The decisions taken within this function or by it, cover

the entire employee lifecycle from the time potential talent is identified, to the

hiring, performance management, compensation and exit.

CHAPTER II

METHOD AND PROCEDURES

METHODOLOGY

In this chapter the researcher discusses the research design, research

environment, respondent of the study, data gathering tools.

Research Design

In this study, the qualitative research paradigm proves more appropriate

than the quantitative paradigm to investigate the kinds of research questions

provided in the study. Furthermore, words rather than numbers or quantified


ILOCOS SUR POLYTECHNIC STATE COLLEGE

data for a counting exercise form the basis of this qualitative inquiry (Babbie,

2007, p. 23; Creswell, pp. 1-2, p. 5; Punch, p. 3).The words, which formulate

the ideas and responses of interviewees, were obtained by conducting indepth

and open-ended interviews with them.3 This data is then put through a

rigorous inductive analysis in the process of concept building and formulating

themes.

Stake (1995) purports that qualitative researchers seek to understand a

case –to appreciate the uniqueness and complexity of it, its embeddedness and

interaction with its contexts (p. 16). Stake contends that the real business of

case study is particularization, not generalization -- we take a particular case

and come to know it well. He says qualitative study capitalizes on “ordinary

ways of making sense” (p. 72). According to Stake, cases seldom exist alone, if

there are phenomena in one, there are probably more somewhere else.

Creswell (2009) says “often the distinction between qualitative and

quantitative research is framed in terms of using words (qualitative) rather

than numbers (quantitative)” (p. 3). That being the case, my use of the

qualitative research method to determine a teacher’s affective acumen as

opposed to evaluating her by her students’ test scores would seem like a ‘best

fit’.

Research Environment
ILOCOS SUR POLYTECHNIC STATE COLLEGE

This study is conducted at Tagudin National High School. The Tagudin

High School established in 1916 by the Department of Public Instruction, in

line with and as part of the “Filipinization” program of the government under

the American regime. It opened in June of that year, but offered merely first

year high school instruction. It was only in 1930 that the school offered a

complete first to fourth year of high school education. TNHS did not only serve

students from the municipality but also those in neighboring towns such as

Sudipen, Bangar, Balaoan, and Luna, as well as Santa Crus, Alilem, Sugpon

and Cervantes, Ilocos Sur. In 2002 Republic Act 8928 signed into law to

establish a national high school in the Municipality of Tagudin and now named

the Tagudin National High School.

Respondent of the Study

The target respondents of the study were the two (2) heads departments

and two (2) administrators from Tagudin National High School. They were

chosen as respondents because they were part of HRM of school.

Instrumentation and Data Collection Procedure

The researchers employed level-appropriate reading material and guided

questions for interviews to collect data for this study. The interview process

may involve the addition of follow-up questions to the semi-structured


ILOCOS SUR POLYTECHNIC STATE COLLEGE

instruments. The researchers provided a sample questionnaire for the validator

to review, and the instruments were validated under the guidance of a

language-inclined instructor.

In order to collect data, the researchers strictly follow the following steps:

I. The researchers made an interview guide and questionnaire that was

validated by language-inclined instructor.

II. The researchers prepared a level-appropriated reading material to be used in

the observation of the Human Resource Manangement.

III. The researchers set a schedule and oriented the participants about the

place and time to avoid conflicts.

IV. The researchers administered the interview and observation process.

V. The researchers retrieved the answers of the participants. Some materials

used by the researcher include: recorder and note taking.

Data Analysis Procedure

In order to analyse the gathered data, the researchers used the thematic

analysis procedure.

Thematic analysis is a method of analyzing qualitative data. It is usually

applied to a set of texts, such as an interview or transcripts. The researcher

closely examines the data to identify common themes – topics, ideas and
ILOCOS SUR POLYTECHNIC STATE COLLEGE

patterns of meaning that come up repeatedly. There are various approaches to

conducting thematic analysis, but the most common form follows a six-step

process:

I. Build comprehension of the information first.

II. Code for describing the content

III. Themes must be developed.

IV. Themes should be reviewed.

V. Themes should be defined and named.

VI. Finally, data must be written.

Ethical Considerations

The consideration of ethical is issues is crucial throughout all stages of

qualitative study to keep the balance between the potential risks of research

and the likely benefits of the research.Researchers are legally responsible for

their study,and it may need to be amended or even stopped in the light of

ethical considerations.It is therefore,it is crucial that these ethical concerns be

addressed both before and during study.Before conducting the

survey,permission and authorization were obtained from the respective offers

through a letter.A letter consent to participate in the research linked to the

interview guide questions informed participant of the purpose and nature of

the research.Participants identifies were kept confidential.


ILOCOS SUR POLYTECHNIC STATE COLLEGE

The researchers took all of the information gathered into account and

examined it critically.The researchers re-evaluate the perceptions and replies

on a regular basis to ensure that pre-existing preconceptions are avoided.This

paperwork was mateculously documented,and sources of reference

materialssuch as authors,must identified.The researchers also observe proper

citation and copyrights in mind.

CHAPTER III

FINDINGS AND DISCUSSION

This chapter is based on the results of the interview conducted.The

examination of qualitative data used a thematic analysis centered on codes and

themes .The analysis of findings is explained in the context of the responses of

the participants.

RESULTS

Based on the gathered data information from the perspectives of set of

participants regarding the HRM practices and challenges of Tagudin National

High School.

Implementing people management

Ghosh (2021) characterizeds people management as aset of avtivities that

encompasses the end-to-end processes of talent acquisition, talent

optimization, and talent retention, while also providing omgoing assistance to

the organization's personnel.


ILOCOS SUR POLYTECHNIC STATE COLLEGE

The interview question, " What are the human resource management practices

of Tagudin National High School?”along with the probing question " Can you

share more of these practices? were inquired to obtain answers focused on the

human resource management practices of Tagudin National High School.

Training and development

Human resources are one of the most significant assets a firm must have.

Consequently, the need for human resource training and development must be

considered. The success and effectiveness of an organization depends on how

far the efforts of the employees of the organization are recognized by the

company (Eliphas & S, 2017). As stated by HR personnel 1 ,HR personnel 3,HR

personnel 4, “Training and development is one of our practices this will improve

the employees' performance,boost their self confidence, innovation, addressing

employee weaknesses and builds a skilled workforce.”also added by HR

Personnel 2,”Performance Management also is one of our practices it helps to

boost employee engagement and productivity.”Suchh finding confirms with the

statement of Dessler (2020) training is a process of pursuing the skills needed

by employees in carrying out their work, in which employee training provides

practical knowledge and its application in the company's work world to

increase work productivity in achieving the goals desired by the company

organization.The findings also conforms to the study Kurniawati (2020), HR

development is a planned effort by the organization to improve HR competence

which is carried out continuously in the long term, which is carried out to
ILOCOS SUR POLYTECHNIC STATE COLLEGE

ensure the availability of HR in accordance with the needs of the position, and

is aimed at improving individual performance which leads to organizational

performance.

Recruitment and Selection

The general purpose of recruitment according to Gamage (2014) is to provide

the organization with a pool of potentially qualified job candidates. The quality

of human resource in an organization highly depends on the quality of

applicants attracted because organization is going to select employees from

those who were attracted. As stated by HR personnel 2,” Recruitment and

Selection (Staffing)these two will eventually result in the ideal employee for our

organization. If done properly, your organization can thrive the objectives and

goals.”HR personnel 3 and Hr personnel 4 also stated “Recruitment and

selection is very important for the continuation of the success of the entire

organization” The study of Gamage (2014) the selection practices will

determine who is hired. If properly designed, it will identify competent

candidates and accurately match them to the job. The use of the proper

selection device will increase the probability that the right person is chosen to

fill a slot. When the best people are selected for the job, productivity

increases.Such findings agrees with the study of Hamza et al. (2021) found

that there is a positive relationship between recruitment and selection with

organizational performance.Such finding also agrees of Ekwoaba, Ikeije and

Ufoma (2015) in a study of the impact of recruitment and selection criteria on


ILOCOS SUR POLYTECHNIC STATE COLLEGE

organizational performance revealed that recruitment and selection criteria have

significant effect on organization’s performance that the more objective the

recruitment and selection criteria, the better the organization’s performance. In

the same vein, Henry and Temtime (2009) construed recruitment as the entry

point of manpower into an organization and the path an organization must

follow from there on in order to make sure that they have attracted the right

individuals for their culture and vibes so that the overall strategic goals are

achieved

Budgetary constraints on employee development and reward programs

Inadequate local government financing is one of the issues of public of pubic

sector.Towns tends to be caught in the dilemma that,while central government

(due to the economic situation or to ideological reasons)is unable or unwilling

to obligations .Each budget decision that is made impacts various sectors of

society that rely on governmental programs.At any point in time,may public

services can be sacrificed when budgetary constraints force

cuts(Zucchi,2022).As stated by HR Personnel “Teachers and students relation,

partnership and linkages to stakeholders and to our LGU’s, Financial stability

and others.Less are limited involvement of individuals ,not enough budget or

financial support or maybe improper budget allocation and lastly more on

criticism and objection rather than obedient and participation” Such finding

confirms with two researchers Kehoe and Wright (2013) conducted statistical
ILOCOS SUR POLYTECHNIC STATE COLLEGE

tests and found significant relationship between reward system and

performance recognition, as well as with motivation and job satisfaction.

According to their study, employee motivation and job satisfaction change

correspondently with the changes in recognition and rewards. For instance,

increase in rewards leads to increase in employee performance.Such findings

also agrees with the study of Kulchmanov and Kaliannan (2014) motivation of

employees is the most influential factor in employee performance. The

performance of employees can be maximised by creating a perception among

them that that their hard work and effort is valuable for the company and

management recognise and reward high performers. Further, A recent study by

Anitha (2013) defined employee performance as an indicator of financial or

other outcomes of the employee that has a direct connection with the

performance of the organization as well as its achievement. The organization

needs employees with high performance to meet goals, deliver products and

services and to achieve competitive advantage in the market (Ojeleye, 2016).

Performance is very crucial same as to reward system because when employees

achieve their high level of performance, they want an adequate reward in

return. If they cannot achieve the goals and show low performance in the

organization, it will result in dissatisfaction (Ojeleye, 2016).

Workload issues

Workloads cause performance to decline This means that the intensity of the

workload of an employee can have an impact on the performance of the


ILOCOS SUR POLYTECHNIC STATE COLLEGE

employee. The higher the workload, especially when the workload creates

difficulties for employees to solve it, then the employee's performance will tend

to decline.This can be gleaned on the statements of HR Personnel 3,

“Professional growth of teachers but teaching time is sacrificed because most of

the time scheduled on a school day.Also challenge on recruitment and selection

affects workload for employees because of additional load coming from the

vacant position”HR Personnel 2 also added “One of the Challenges is

overflowing work, the work will not be all done. Some factors, we encounter

those not approachable individual because of many opinion that turns to some

misunderstanding.” Such finding agrees to the study of Reni (2017), the

workload has a negative and significant effect on employee performance, which

means that the lower the workload, the higher the employee's performance,

and vice versa, the higher the workload, the lower the resulting

performance.Organisational systems are made up of many interdependent and

interrelated subsystems that work together to complement one another to

facilitate the attainment of organisational goals in all categories, whether large

or small. Employees in each organisation have various degrees of workload that

they contend with on a daily basis. If for any reason the workload changes,

such change alters the stress level of employees as well as their perception of

fairness in workload balance, especially when the change is positive. But

whether positive, as in the case of an increase in workload; or negative, as is

the case in a reduction in workload; it has implications on employee job

satisfaction and ultimately, job performance (Ali and Farooqi, 2014).


ILOCOS SUR POLYTECHNIC STATE COLLEGE

Behavior issues

Everyone brings their own personality, values and communication style to a

workplace environment. The interaction of employees with work and with one

another is perhaps the most important element in a work

environment.Guidance and training managers are an integral role that HR

professionals play to minimize the effects of difficult, and or disruptive

employee behavior in the workplace. Organizational behavior researches have

facilitated HRM to manipulate the behaviors of the individual in line with firm

purposes. Organizational behavior aims to have information about the different

characteristics and attitudes of employees to implement HRM practices that

look towards organizational effectiveness (Yıldız, 2013).As stated by HR

Personnel 2 “Crab mentality the source of slow progress from low

performance”Also,HR Personnel 4 stated that “ Division it is divided by

the personnel, it will not meet the aim of the school because of difference

of ideas, there is misunderstanding in doing the objectives of the

school.”Such as finding agrees to the study of Pandey (2017) investigated the

effect of work environment on job performance of employees in Jordan and

their study also forwarded the similar finding that works environment influence

job performance and productivity of employees. The concept of work

environment has broadened and is not limited to the physical work

environment. Further,in the researches it is stated that there are many hidden

reasons behind the apparent reasons for employees to leave their jobs (Chang
ILOCOS SUR POLYTECHNIC STATE COLLEGE

et al., 2013). These include the workplace that does not meet expectations,

mismatches between the business and the person, too little coaching and

feedback, too few growth and development opportunities, feeling unworthy and

unrecognized, overwork and stress from a work-life imbalance, and loss of faith

and trust in senior leaders. Most of these reasons are behaviorally manageable

(Torrington et al., 2014).

CHAPTER IV

FINDINGS,CONCLUSION, AND RECOMMENDATION

This chapter presents the summary of the study,findings,conclusions

drawn from the findings,and recommendations offered by researchers.

Summary

This descriptive phenomenological research entitled “HRM practices and

challenges of Tagudin National High School” that aims to determine the

practices and challenges encountered by the Human Resource Management of

Tagudin National High School. The thematic analysis was employed to interpret

the findings of the interview, which resulted to four themes: Implementing


ILOCOS SUR POLYTECHNIC STATE COLLEGE

People Management, Budgetary Constraints on Employee Development and

Reward Programs, Workload Issues, Behavior Issues.

FINDINGS

Based ;on the data analysis,the findings nof the study are summarized as
follows:

There are three (4)themes identified in the study .They are as


follows:Implementing People Management , Budgetary constraints on employee
development and reward programs ,Workload Issues,Behavior Issues.

The theme Implementing People Management practices includes:training and


development and recruitment and selection.

The theme Budgetary constraints on employee development and reward


programs ,Workload Issues,Behavior Issues are the challenges encountered by
the Human Resource Manangement.

CONCLUSION

Based on the results,the following conclusions were drawn: The themes:

Implementing People Management , Budgetary constraints on employee

development and reward programs ,Workload Issues,Behavior Issues,provide a

deeper understanding on the current Human Resource Manangement

practices and challenges of Tagudin National High School.

The theme implementing people manangement practiced of the organization

which is composed of various process on recruitment and selection ,training

and development were practiced to manange people in the organization.These

practices lead to maintaining and following the standards of the institutions.


ILOCOS SUR POLYTECHNIC STATE COLLEGE

The Human Resource Management faced of Budgetary constraints on

employee development and reward programs ,Workload Issues, and Behavior

Issues.These types of challenges faced by Human Resource Manangement of

Tagudin National High School tend to mitigate the human resource

manangement functions of the organization.

Recommendations

Based on the conclusions,the following was recommended:

1. The themes and can be used by the HR Personnel of the Tagudin National High School as a basis for
developing human resource management policies, programs, and other initiatives in line with HRM.

2. The Tagudin National High School should strengthen the implementation of the people management
practices aiming towards maintaining and achieving higher level of HRM.

3. The Tagudin National High School should strengthen quality of implementation of their employee
evaluation mechanism to gather fair and consistent insights from multiple levels of the organization to
give an employee feedback on their performance at work.

4. The Tagudin National High School should develop and manage a strategic staffing plan used to
document the type of resources(manpower) needed and the timing for those resources; the plan
includes how the resources will be acquired, timeline, training requirement, and budget that allows the
agency to analyze and implement long-term strategies for the type, cost and volume of employees
required to meet organization objectives versus only filling short-term slots.

5.Human Resource Management should recognize the need of establishing an effective training and
development policy with the aspecific rules for mananging the training programs.

6. Tagudin National High School should be assist teams in working efficiently to handle their excessive
workload. Human resource management should versatile, sensible, and a great communicator throughout
the process. Additionally, HRM should delegate responsibilities to inside and outside employees and
create a tracking system to assess how well the work is being done.

REFERENCES LIST

Ghosh (2021) What is Human Resources (HR)? [definition and more] - Workable
ILOCOS SUR POLYTECHNIC STATE COLLEGE

Baired and Meshoulam (1998) Good human resource management procedures,

it is expected that the shortcomings and problems faced by the Indonesian

people, who are related to competitiveness, can be overcome - Search

(bing.com)

Tiwari and Saxena (2012) https://www.bing.com/search?

q=The+way+principals+perceive+and+practice+HRM+functions+within+their+ro

le+and++responsibility.

Osman,Ho and Galang, (2011) https://www.bing.com/search?

q=Applying+organizational+theory+to+schools+provides+valuable+insights.

Fied Friedler (1967)Home/Journals/International Journal of Innovation

Science/ /Volume 12 Issue 3/ /Innovative human resource management:

measurement, determinants and outcomes.

John Antonakis (1961) The+path%E2%80%93goal+theory

%2C+also+known+as+the+path

%E2goal+theory+of+leader+effectiveness+or+the+path%E2%80%93goal+model.

Lepak and Snell (1999) https://www.google.com.ph/search?

tbm=bks&hl=en&q=Attention has also turned to differentiating HRM within

firms so that%2C contingent on the value and uniqueness of employee groups

in realizing strategy%2C certain types of HR practices are said to be more

optimal than others.


ILOCOS SUR POLYTECHNIC STATE COLLEGE

Robert Hause (1971) The path–goal theory, also known as the path–goal theory

of leader effectiveness or the path–goal model, is a leadership theory developed

by Robert House, an Ohio State University graduate.

Elton Mayo (1932) https://testbook.com/question-answer/human-relations-

theory-of-management//Human Relations management theory originated

between1924and, the Harvard Business School popularized the subject.

Miranda, N. and Fernando, W.R.P.K (2020) The Impact of Human Resource

Management Practices of the Managers on Perceived Organizational

Performance—A Study on Ceylon Fisheries Corporation in Sri Lanka. Open

Access Library Journal, 7, 1-21. doi: 10.4236/oalib.1107034.

Daud (2006)

https://www.researchgate.net/publication/277215159_Human_Resource_Man

agement_Practices_And_Firm_Performance_The_Moderating_Roles_Of_Strategie

s_And_Environmental_Uncertainties_HF5549_N844_2006_

Mark (2011) (PDF) Gaining Competitive Advantage through Human Resource

Practices’ (researchgate.net)

Stake (1995) (PDF) Qualitative Case Study Methodology: Study Design and

Implementation for Novice Researchers (researchgate.net)

Cresswell (2009) https://psycnet.apa.org/record/2008-13604-000


ILOCOS SUR POLYTECHNIC STATE COLLEGE

https://www.bing.com/ck/a?!&&p= Thematic analysis is a method of

analyzing qualitative data. It is usually applied to a set of texts such as an

interview or transcripts. The researcher closely examines the data to identify

common themes topics ideas and patterns of meaning that come up repeatedly.

(Zucchi,2022)

https://www.investopedia.com/articles/personal-finance/022315/how-

government-budgetary-decisions-impact-public-sector.asp

Kehoe and Wright (2013) https://www.bing.com/ck/a?!

&&p=df440fd8d1849e1fJmltdHM9MT

Kulchmanov and Kaliannan (2014)= Motivation of employees is the most

influential factor in employee performance.


ILOCOS SUR POLYTECHNIC STATE COLLEGE

APPENDICES A. LETTER OF REQUEST

Appendix B
ILOCOS SUR POLYTECHNIC STATE COLLEGE

WAIVER

APPENDICES C

THEMATIC ANALYSIS STRUCTURED INTERVIEW

1.What are the human resource manangement practices of Tagudin

National High School?

*Can you share more of these practices?

2.What are the human resource manangement challenges of Tagudin

National High School?

*Can you share more of these ?


ILOCOS SUR POLYTECHNIC STATE COLLEGE

Thematic Analysis (Reportory Grid)

A Prior codes Identification of Identification Theme Theme

significant Development
of Data
statements
Categories

recruitment,sel HRM Practices Implemen

ection and of TNHS; ting

appointment of people
HR Personnel
performance Performance
personel to managem
1: HRM
management, management
positions in the ent
practices of
first and second employee
TNHS are
levels based on relations
training and Employee
their relative likewise
development, relations
qualifications parents and
performance
and competence teachers .
management,
to perform the
employee
duties and
relations
responsibilities
likewise
of the position.
parents and

teachers .

Practices :Rec

ruitment and
ILOCOS SUR POLYTECHNIC STATE COLLEGE

Recruitment selection

and Selection
HR Personnel
(Staffing)
2:

- Recruitment

and Selection

(Staffing) These

two will

eventually

result in the
Also
ideal employee Training
Performance
for our development
Management
organization. If
in this way it
done properly,
helps to boost
your
employee
organization
engagement
can thrive the
and
objectives and
productivity.
goals.

Also

Performance Practices :Rec

Management in ruitment and

this way it selection is


ILOCOS SUR POLYTECHNIC STATE COLLEGE

helps to boost very

employee important for

engagement the

and continuation

productivity. of the

success of

the entire

HR Personnel organization

3:

Practices :Recr

uitment and
Training
selection is
development
very important
it addressing
for the
employee
continuation of
weaknesses
the success of
and builds a
the entire
skilled
organization
workforce.

Training

development it

addressing

employee
ILOCOS SUR POLYTECHNIC STATE COLLEGE

Recruitment
weaknesses
& selection
and builds a
and Also
skilled
Training and
workforce.
development

Hr Personnel

4: Training and

development

This will

improve the

employees'

performance

and boost their

self confidence,

and

innovation.

Engaging the HRM Financial Budgetary

workforce, challenges ; Problem constraint

leadership s on
HR Personnel
development, employee
1: Teachers and
recruiting developme
ILOCOS SUR POLYTECHNIC STATE COLLEGE

talented Teachers and students nt and

employees, students relation, reward


Lack of
training and relation, partnership programs
Compensatio
development partnership and linkages
n and
strategies and and linkages to to
Benefits Workload
understanding stakeholders stakeholders
issues
benefits and to our and to our

package LGU’s, LGU’s,


Crab
Financial Financial
mentality Behavior
stability and stability and
issues
others. others.

Less are

limited

Less are involvement


of individuals
limited

involvement of ,not enough

individuals ,not budget or

enough budget financial

financial support or
or

support or maybe
improper
maybe
ILOCOS SUR POLYTECHNIC STATE COLLEGE

improper budget

budget allocation

allocation and and lastly

lastly more on more on

criticism and criticism and

objection objection

rather than rather than

obedient and obedient and


Time and
participation participation
workload

misunderstan

ding

HR Personnel Lack of
2: Compensatio

n and
Lack of
Benefits
Compensation

and Benefits Crab

mentality the
Crab mentality
ILOCOS SUR POLYTECHNIC STATE COLLEGE

the source of source of

slow progress slow progress

from low from low

performance performance

HR Personnel

3:

Compensation Compensatio

and benefits n and

challenges like benefits

With the challenges

organizational

structure if

TNHS (under

the schools

Division of

Ilocos Sur), all

processes/prog

rams need to

be submitted
ILOCOS SUR POLYTECHNIC STATE COLLEGE

to the Division

Office and

approved by

the Schools

Division

Superintendent

. Due to this,

there are

sometimes

delay. For

example, in the

recruitment

and selection

process, while

applicant

ranking occurs

at the school

level, it must

be

subsequently

submitted to teaching time

the Division in sacrificed


ILOCOS SUR POLYTECHNIC STATE COLLEGE

because most
office for
of the time
approval and
scheduled on
review. This
a school day.
occasionally

results in

delays in the workload for


timely filling of employees

vacant because of
positions that additional

means Vacant load coming


position means from the
additional vacant
workload to position

some teachers.

Training and

development:

professional

growth of

teachers but

teaching time

in sacrificed

because most
ILOCOS SUR POLYTECHNIC STATE COLLEGE

of the time

scheduled on a

school day. Challenges is

Challenge on overflowing

recruitment work, the


and selection work will not

affects be all done.


workload for

employees

because of

additional load
it is divided
coming from
by the
the vacant
personnel, it
position.
will not meet

the aim of the

school

because of
HR Perssonnel
difference of
4:
ideas, there is

One of the misunderstan

Challenges is ding in doing

overflowing the objectives


ILOCOS SUR POLYTECHNIC STATE COLLEGE

work, the work of the school.

will not be all

done. Some

factors, we

encounter

those not

approachable

individual

because of

many opinion

that turns to

some

misunderstand

ing.

Division: it is

divided by the

personnel, it

will not meet

the aim of the

school because

of difference of

ideas, there is
ILOCOS SUR POLYTECHNIC STATE COLLEGE

misunderstand

ing in doing

the objectives

of the school.

Appendix D
HRM practices and challenges of Tagudin National High School
SEMI-STRUCTURED INTERVIEW GUIDE QUESTION

HRM Human Resource Deped order The systematic 1. What are

PRACTICES Management no.007,s-2023 process of your human

Practices includes; Guidelines on recruitment,selection resource

The systematic recruitment and appointment of management

process of selection and personel to positions practices?

recruitment,selection appointment in the first and

and appointment of second levels based

personel to positions on their relative Probing:

in the first and qualifications and *Can you share more

second levels based competence to of these practices?


ILOCOS SUR POLYTECHNIC STATE COLLEGE

on their relative perform the duties

qualifications and and responsibilities

competence to of the position

perform the duties

and responsibilities

of the position.

HRM Human Resource Kukreja, S. (2021, Engaging the 1. What are

CHALLENGES Management August 20). workforce, your human

Challenges Today’s 10 leadership resource

includes; Human Resource development, management

Engaging the Management recruiting challenges?

workforce, Challenges talented

leadership Management employees,

development, Challenges training and Probing:

recruiting Management development *Can you share more

talented Study HQ. strategies and of these challenges?

employees, understanding

training and benefits package.

development

strategies and

understanding

benefits package.
ILOCOS SUR POLYTECHNIC STATE COLLEGE

CURRICULUM VITAE

ERICKA G. GARLEJO
Address: Cabaroan, Tagudin, Ilocos Sur
Contact No.: 09301763930
Email Address: garlejoericka4@gmail.com

PERSONAL DATA_________________________________________________________
Date of birth : May 14, 2003
Place of Birth : Cabaroan, Tagudin, Ilocos Sur
Age : 20 years old
Civil Status : Single
Citizenship : Filipino
Height : 4’’11
Weight : 40
Religion : Roman Catholic
Special Skills : Active listening and communication skills
ILOCOS SUR POLYTECHNIC STATE COLLEGE

EDUCATIONAL BACKGROUND_____________________________________________
Elementary Education : Cabulanglangan Integrated School
Cabulanglangan, Tagudin, Ilocos Sur
2013-2014
Secondary Education : Tagudin National High School
Quirino, Tagudin, Ilocos Sur
2020-2021
Tertiary Education : Ilocos Sur Polytechnic State College Bachelor in
Secondary Education

TRAINING AND SEMINARS ATTENDED_____________________________________

Sangguniang Kabataan Mandatory Training (SKMT)

WORK EXPERIENCE_______________________________________________________

Restaurants

CURRICULUM VITAE

MARIELLE S. AQUILOD
Address: Man-atong, Suyo, Ilocos Sur
Contact No.: 09453711485

Email Address: marielleaquilod@gmail.com

PERSONAL DATA_________________________________________________________
Date of birth : July 11, 2003
Place of Birth : Suyo
Age : 20 years old
Civil Status : Single
Citizenship : Filipino
Height : 5”3
Weight : 57
Religion : CDCC
ILOCOS SUR POLYTECHNIC STATE COLLEGE

Special Skills : Time Management skill

EDUCATIONAL BACKGROUND_____________________________________________
Elementary Education : Man-atong Elementary School
Man-atong, Suyo, Ilocos Sur
2013-2014
Secondary Education : Suyo National High School
Urzadan, Suyo, Ilocos Sur
2020-2021
Tertiary Education : Ilocos Sur Polytechnic State College Bachelor in
Secondary Education

TRAINING AND SEMINARS ATTENDED_____________________________________

Gil-Ayab Leadership Training

WORK EXPERIENCE_______________________________________________________

Special Program For the Employment of Students (SPES)


Suyo, Ilocos Sur

Work immersion

You might also like