Week 10 Reading

You might also like

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 10

WEEK 10 READINGS

New Social Media and Global


Self-Representation


Different Stages In the first, oral stage the self
is constituted as a position of

of Human enunciation through its


embeddedness in a totality of

Communication •
face to face relations.
In the second, print stage the
self is constructed as an
Mark Poster has suggested that the agent centred in
classic periodization of history needs
New Media, to be reconsidered to take into •
rational/imaginary autonomy.
In the third, electronic stage
account historical developments
New Spaces, in the structure of symbolic
the self is decentred,
dispersed, and multiplied in
New Identities exchange. In a historical era when
the culture imparts a ‘fetishistic
continuous instability.
(Poster, 1990:6).
importance’ to information (Poster:
The technological innovations of 1990: 6) the mode of production is In each stage the means of
the late twentieth and early twenty- superseded by the mode of signification correspond to
first century have made possible information as a key organizing stages in the relations between
the storage and transfer of vast principle of society. He describes the self and other.
amounts of information; they have historical stages:
also been the catalyst for the
expansion of social connections
and a globally shared culture that
surpass in volume and reach any in
human history. In his discussion of television in the In the first decade of the twenty-first
1960s, Marshall McLuhan argued century a technological shift of
that any medium is an extension of immense significance occurred
Paul Virilio has highlighted one of when the Internet platform known
ourselves and that the personal and
the most significant aspects of as Web 2.0 became available.
social consequences of media result
these new media: the possibility for from the new scale that is introduced Moving from Web 1.0 (an early
the creation of affective worlds, into our affairs by each extension version of the World Wide Web) to
more potent and seductive than (1994 [1964]: 7). Web 2.0 in the early 2000s afforded
any created by old media such as an expanded realm of possibilities
radio or television. Rather than In Mark Poster's account, McLuhan's for user agency, in particular, self-
major limitation was that he inserted representation.
merely seeing or hearing at a
distance, we can now ‘feel at a media into the Enlightenment
paradigm of the rational, unified In Web 1.0 the majority of users
distance’ (Virilio, 2001 [1995]: 24). acted as consumers of content; in
human and failed to recognize the
destabilization of the subject as a Web 2.0 any participant can create
corollary of the interaction with content (see Cormode and
technology (Poster, 2006: 123). Krishnamurthy, 2008).
Social media demands interaction, so
much so that people become ‘distributed If we remember Dick Hebdige's This change is connected to
actors’ on a multitude of channels premise that postmodern society several cultural and economic
(Lovink, 2011: 147). Subjects are means, if nothing else, a loss of shifts, like the end of one big story
constituted through their interaction with wholeness and the disintegration and the rise of many personal
media, but interactive media also allow of the unitary subject. In past eras stories online. It's also related to
them to actively constitute themselves. the producer could feel her or how consumerism influences our
Poster conceptualizes the Internet as a himself part of an epic master- identities, the importance of
planetary public sphere, an electronic
narrative (Hebdige, 1993: 80), information in our economy, and
agora, in which subject positions can be
constituted through the material but: ‘Capitalism these days has how technology affects how we
specificity of the global computer absolutely no stake whatsoever in see ourselves and the world. Plus,
network (Poster, 2006, 40–41). the idea of individuals being tied the internet makes it feel like we
to fixed and stable identities’ can be everywhere at once,
If in the late modern era the individual is
(Hebdige, 1993: 82). changing how we experience time
compelled to reflect on and define
identity (Bauman, 2001; Beck and Beck- and space. These ideas shape
Gernsheim, 2001), and the self has The omnipresence of electronic how we narrate and perform our
become a reflexive product (Giddens, screens saturating our lives in the identities online in the 21st
1991: 32), the mediating space of the twenty-first century has century, all within the context of
Internet has provided new possibilities meant a proliferation of sites of what's often called "late
for the narrative and performative self-representation. capitalism."
production of self.

In the wake of the explosion of


Digital Selves in the Google, Siva Vaidhyanathan
I Blog and Tweet,
Information Economy argues that while we feel the Therefore I Am
excitement of finding previously
Castells argued that the network society unimaginable amounts of data at In today's globalized world,
of the 1990s was increasingly structured our fingertips, we should not extensive networks of culture,
around a bipolar opposition between the overlook the consequences of the images, capital, and power
net and the self (Castells, 1996: 3). It is ‘googlization of everything’. shape our environment. This has
now commonly acknowledged, however, led to the fragmentation of
that social media and the possibility for If we cannot avoid using Google in communities and a reordering of
the creation of multiple identities in an the twenty-first century, we can traditional institutions like the
online world of the twenty-first century also not avoid being turned into a nation and the family. As a
have blurred this distinction. commodity. Consumer profiling is result, individual identity has
a form of surveillance (Elmer, become a central source of
The explosion of blogging and 2004) in a ‘personal information social meaning.
microblogging, through services such as economy’ (Lace, 2005).
Twitter, in the last Brian Massumi's study on fear in
decade of the twentieth century has The practice of 'like farming' postmodern society sheds light
precipitated excessive narration of self. exemplifies how information has on this phenomenon. He
Self-representation is a mediated become commercialized and suggests that fear, far from
event requiring textual and performative consumers commodified. Every being just an emotion, reflects
articulation. Identity production and 'like' on Facebook carries the subjective experience under
management are monetary value, which can be sold late capitalism. Fear of losing
carried out in ‘networked publics’ (boyd, to marketers and companies. one's identity is alleviated
2010) that exist on social network sites Users often click 'like' on through consumerism, where
such as Facebook, Friendster and emotionally charged posts, such our sense of self is tied to our
MySpace. as those related to illnesses or purchases.
parenting, contributing to the
illusion of widespread support.
Youtube CONCLUSION
and the With the emergence of the
interactive digital technologies
In Poster's terms,
‘postmodernity or the mode of

Global Self the Internet has become the site


of new modes of self-promotion.
information indicates
communication practices that
The proliferation of social media constitute subjects as
YouTube is a subsidiary of sites inviting users to find their unstable, multiple and diffuse’
Google and is a video sharing voice, promote individual opinion, (Poster, 2012 [1995]: 447).
website where people can recreate themselves as avatars
upload user-generated content or online identities, represent While switching in and out of
such as short themselves as they are or as they identities in conformity with
videos. As a social networking want to be seen, disclose social context in the real world
site and a space for personal details, share is hardly new, social media
participatory culture (Burgess knowledge about themselves and offer the self- obsessed, the
and Green, 2009), it is also a engage in emotionally fraught opportunistic and those
prime site for the representation discourse with immense publics merely seeking reaffirmation
of self with global reach. of strangers demonstrates the of their existence, hitherto
huge number of possibilities for unimagined potential for the
YouTube has turned ordinary creation of multiple selves and construction of self on a
individuals into overnight new forms of global self- global scale.
sensations, known as representation.
"celetoids," who capture fleeting
fame through viral moments.
For example, Corey Discussion Questions
Worthington's antics at a party
quickly propelled him to 1. How does Chris Hudson explore the impact of new social media on
celebrity status, showcasing the global self-representation in his article?
2. What are some key findings or insights presented by Hudson
power of online platforms for
regarding the intersection of social media and self-representation on
self-representation. a global scale?
3. In what ways does Hudson discuss the role of new social media
Similarly, Psy's "Gangnam Style" platforms in shaping cultural identities and fostering cross-cultural
video became a global interactions?
sensation, surpassing even
HOW DO YOU REPRESENT YOURSELF IN SOCIAL MEDIA?
Justin Bieber's record for most-
watched YouTube video. The LINKS :
widespread influence of social
media is evident in the real https://youtu.be/inQrcFytHJ0
world, with figures like Boris https://youtu.be/inQrcFytHJ0
Johnson and David Cameron
embracing the Gangnam craze.
Numerous parodies and
adaptations of Psy's video
further highlight the pervasive
impact of online self-expression.
WEEK 10 READINGS

Globalization and Media: Creating the


Global Village

Globalization and Etymologically, globalization


falls into the family of -ization
Media: words, indicating a process or
outcome. This ambiguity often
Etymologies leads to debates, with some
dismissing globalization due to
Globalization, or globalisation in the its inconclusive nature.However,
scholars like Peter J. Taylor
Queen's English, is a term that
What is seems to elude comfort in any
caution against this, urging us to
consider both meanings: as an
language. From la mondialisation in
Globalization??? French to quan qiu hua in Chinese,
it retains a chilly and distant aura.
ongoing process and a potential
outcome.
Its origins are murky, with 'globalize'
Globalization is a vague, opaque, only dating back to 1944 in the This chapter asserts that
and difficult word. Indeed, many Merriam-Webster dictionary. globalization is not a fixed
people have trouble defining outcome but a continuous
process, encompassing
globalization. The word seems to Theodore Levitt, a former Harvard
economic, political, and cultural
mean many things – a global Business School professor,
dimensions.
economy, international trade, popularized it in a 1983 article.
growing prosperity in China and
India, international travel and
communication, immigration,
migration, more foreign films and
foods, McDonald's in Paris, Histor(ies) of Globalization Yale's Nayan Chanda embraces this
Starbucks in Africa, mosques in view. He says globalization ‘is a
New York, an increase in ‘global’ The cultural anthropologist Arjun process that has worked silently for
Appadurai feels there was a ‘rupture’ millennia without having been given
problems such as climate change within social life in the late twentieth a name’ and that, as a trend,
and terrorism. The word can mean century. Those two ‘diacritics’ – globalization ‘has been with us
everything and nothing. media and migration fundamentally since the beginning of history’. He
changed human life, Appadurai says, argues that a multitude othreads
and gave rise to this entity now called ‘connect us to faraway places from
Globalization and media have globalization (Appadurai, 1996: 1– an ancient time’ (Chanda, 2007: x–
created the conditions through 11). xi).
which many people can now
imagine themselves as part of Still others feel that globalization has No right answer exists, of course, as
been going on since the beginning of to when globalization began. Writers
one world. It is this global
humanity, when the first Homo – and readers – simply must make
imaginary that brings to fruition sapiens departed from other Homo clear what they believe and why.
what Marshal McLuhan called the sapiens in an African village and set This chapter embraces the concept
‘global village’ (McLuhan, out in search of food or water or that there is a fundamental human
adventure. impulse toward globalization.
1962: 16; 1964: 80).
Media Though the word is relatively This chapter makes the claim that
modern, humans have used developments in media
In contrast to globalization, media do not media of communication from technology are crucial to
seem hard to identify or define. The word
their first days on earth, and, we globalization. Many scholars do
is plural for medium – a means of
conveying something, such as a channel will argue, those media have been not give such prominence to
of communication. The plural form – essential to globalization. media. They might make passing
media – only came into general reference to media, but we are
circulation, however, in the 1920s. Like Globalization arguing that media were, and are,
globalization, the word ‘media’ came into essential to globalization. The
popular usage because a word was We are maintaining that historical,
following section will further make
needed to talk about a new social issue. political, cultural, and economic
that case.
In the 1920s, people were talking about forces, now called globalization,
their fears over the harmful influence of have worked in concert with
comic books, radio, and film. They were media from the dawn of time to And, lastly, we are suggesting that
worried about young people reading our present day, and that the globe itself can be understood
violent comics, voters hearing globalization and media – two as an ‘imagined community’. That
propaganda over th radio, couples words that only came into usage in is a concept within a long,
disappearing into dark movie theaters. thoughtful tradition, a tradition
the twentieth century – capture
They grouped these phenomena that can further enrich
together with debates over ‘the mass practices that have roots deep in
the history of humanity. understanding of globalization and
media’
media.

Evolution of Media and Oral Communication Script


Globalization Speech is often the most overlooked Some histories of media technology
medium in histories of globalization. skip this stage or give it brief mention
Scholars have found it logical and Yet the oral medium – human speech as a transition between oral cultures
helpful to organize the historical study of – is the oldest and most enduring of and cultures of the printing press. But
media by time periods or stages. Each all media. Over hundreds of the era was crucial for globalization
thousands of years, despite and media. Language was essential
period is characterized by its dominant
numerous changes undergone by but imperfect. Distance causes
medium. For example, the Canadian trouble for oral communication. It
humans and their societies, the very
theorist Harold Innis (1950), Marshall takes elaborate systems to
first and last humans will share at
McLuhan's teacher, writing in the 1940s least one thing – the ability to speak. communicate with language over
and 1950s, divided media into three Speech has been with us for at least great expanses. Time also causes
periods: oral, print, and electronic. 200,000 years, script for less than difficulties. Language relies on
7,000 years, print for less than 600 human memory, which is limited
Terhi Rantanen (2005) places script years, and digital technology for less in capacity and not always perfect.
than 50 years. \Script – the very first writing –
before the printing press and breaks
allowed humans to communicate and
down the electronic period into wired share knowledge and ideas over
Language helped humans move, but
and wireless, for six periods. For our much larger spaces and across much
it also helped them settle down.
purposes, five time periods usefully Language stored and transmitted longer times. Script allowed for the
capture the study of globalization and important agricultural information written and permanent codification of
media: oral, script, print, electronic, and across time as one generation economic, cultural, religious, and
digital. Media – and globalization as well passed on its knowledge to the next, political practice.
– have developed sporadically, leading to the creation of villages and
towns. If globalization is considered the
erratically, in fits and starts, driven by
economic, cultural, and political
human needs, desires, and actions, integration of the world, then surely
resulting in great benefits and Language also led to
markets, the trade of goods and script – the written word
sometimes greater harm. The history of – must be considered an essential
services, and eventually into cross-
media and globalization is the history of continental trade routes. Organized, medium.
humanity itself. permanent, trading centers grew,
giving rise to cities.
The Printing Press In a masterful, 750-page treatise, A second consequence: print
All histories of media and globalization historian Elizabeth Eisenstein encouraged the challenge of
acknowledge the consequential role of (1979) surveyed the many political and religious authority
the printing press. Many begin with the profound influences of the printing because of its ability to circulate
printing press. press. Two overarching competing views. Eisenstein notes
It's easy to see why. consequences, however, can be that ‘fear of disapproval, a
suggested from her work. First, sense of isolation, the force of
Prior to the printing press, the production the printing press changed the local community sanctions, the
and copying of written documents was very nature of knowledge. It habit of respectful submission
slow, cumbersome, and expensive. The
preserved knowledge, which had to traditional authority – all might
papyrus, parchment, and paper that
spread civilizations were the province of been more malleable in oral be weakened’ (1979: 148).
a select, powerful few. Reading and cultures. It also standardized
writing, too, were practices of the ruling knowledge, which had become The printing press, however,
and religious elite. The rich and powerful more variable as it spread orally encouraged the literacy of the
controlled information. With the advent across regions and lands. Script public and the growth of schools.
of the printing press, first made with and papyrus had begun the Too, the rise of inexpensive, easily
movable wooden blocks in China and process of preservation and obtained magazines and daily
then with movable metal type by
standardization, but not nearly to newspapers brought news from
Johannes Gutenberg in Germany,
reading material suddenly was cheaply the extent allowed by printing around the world to people.
made and easily circulated. presses.

Electronic Media Digital Media


For many people, television is considered the most Digital media are most often electronic media that
powerful and pervasive mass medium yet created. rely on digital codes – the long arcane
Though television programming existed back in the combinations of 0s and 1s that represent
1920s, the years after World War II saw the explosion information. Many of our earlier media, such as
in the production and penetration of television into phones and televisions, can now be considered
homes around the digital. Indeed, digital may even be blurring
world. According to the US Census Bureau's the lines among media. If you can watch
Statistical Abstract, for example, before 1950, fewer television, take photographs, show movies, and
than 10 per cent of US homes had televisions. In five send e-mail on your smart phone or tablet, what
years, the number grew to 64.5 per cent. By 1960, does that mean for our neat categorization of
87.1 per cent of US homes had television. Worldwide media into television, film, or phone? The
growth was rapid too. computer, though, is the usual representation of
digital media. The computer comes as the latest
By the end of the 1960s, half the countries in the and, some would argue, most significant
world had television stations. Television brought medium to influence globalization.
together the visual and aural power of film with the
accessibility of radio: people sat in their living rooms In the realm of politics, computers allow citizens
and kitchens and viewed pictures and stories from access to information from around the world,
across the globe. The world was brought into the even information that governments would like to
home. The amount, range, and intensity of conceal. Blogs, social media, Twitter, text
communication with other lands and cultures messaging, and more allow citizens to
occurred in ways simply not possible before. For communicate among themselves. And computers
some scholars, the introduction of television was a have transformed cultural life. Access to
defining moment in globalization. Marshall McLuhan information around the globe allows people to
proclaimed the world a ‘global village’, largely adopt and adapt new practices in music, sports,
because of television. education, religion, fashion, cuisine, the arts, and
other areas of culture. People talk with friends,
In summary, electronic media, from the telegraph to relations, and even strangers around the world
television, have played a crucial role in shaping through Skype, Google Chat, and other programs.
global communication, connecting people and Digital media have revolutionized daily life.
cultures in ways previously unimaginable.
No Globalization Media and Economic The media foster the conditions
for global capitalism. The role of
without Media Globalization the media in this process cannot
The purpose of this section has been to The media have been essential to be overstated.
track the development of the growth of economic
communication media over time and globalization in our world. Indeed, As media scholar Robert
show how those media were essential to McChesney reminds us,
the media have made economic
the ongoing processes of globalization. ‘Economic and cultural
Our starting point was that the human globalization possible by creating
the conditions for global globalization arguably would be
impulse to globalize and the human
need to communicate over distance capitalism and by promoting the impossible without a global
have proceeded together through conceptual foundation of the commercial media system to
history, each driving and influencing world's market economy. promote global markets and to
theother. Even in a condensed summary, Economic globalization, from this encourage consumer values’
the partnership of globalization and perspective is not just dollars and (McChesney, 2001).
media is clear. Each of the eras – oral,
cents, but story and myth
script, print, electronic, and digital – saw McChesney and co-author Edward
marked influences of media on – narratives that make natural the
buying and selling of products Herman (Herman and McChesney,
globalization.
across borders and boundaries 1997) call global media ‘the new
It is difficult to imagine globalization missionaries of global capitalism’.
and mythic celebrations of
occurring without the media that are so
crucial to human life. products and consumption.

Global Imaginary and Communication media have


played a crucial role in shaping
Oligopoly
Global Village what scholar Manfred Steger
terms the "rising global imaginary" The rise of global media
The media are helping to bring about a – the conception of the world as a conglomerates has transformed
fundamentally new imaginary, what unified community. These media the landscape of the media
scholar Manfred Steger (2008) has not only physically connect the industry, giving birth to what is
called a rising global imaginary – the globe through networks but also often referred to as a media
globe itself as imagined community. In foster a shared understanding oligopoly. This oligopoly,
the past, only a few, privileged people through stories, images, and characterized by the dominance
thought of themselves as ‘cosmopolitan’ metaphors. of a few large corporations, has
– citizens of the world. Cosmopolitanism seen small, local media
is now a feature of modern life. People Despite their differing companies being acquired and
imagine themselves as part of the world. consolidated into global giants.
perspectives, globalization and
media have intertwined to create
But in the 1960s, media scholar a hybrid of Mumford's and Moreover, critical theorists like
Marshall McLuhan anticipated this McLuhan's visions. While Adorno and Horkheimer have
phenomenon with his argument that McLuhan foresaw a connected long warned about the
media have connected the world in ways world akin to a village, the reality implications of a "culture
that create a ‘global village’. The global has been far from harmonious. industry" that produces mindless
village, McLuhan felt, would bring about Instead, globalization and media entertainment, diverting
a utopia. Drawn closely together by have contributed to a dystopian attention away from critical
media, people would be like neighbors, landscape marked by economic, thinking and social and political
living in ‘a Pentecostal condition of political, and cultural challenges. action. They argue that such
universal understanding and unity’ This fusion of visions highlights entertainment can effectively
(1964: 80). From its introduction, the complex and often distract audiences, consuming
though, the metaphor of the global contradictory nature of the their time and energy and
village has been a source of controversy. modern globalized society. hindering their involvement in
meaningful social and political
discourse.
No The impact on international news
reporting has been particularly
News Today severe. Foreign news bureaus are
This profit-centric approach also costly to maintain, and many
Transnational conglomerates, in this
translates into the production of media organizations have
view, are much less interested than local
media outlets in providing news and mass content over local content. downsized or closed them
information necessary for citizens. Local media outlets often prioritize altogether. As a result,
People are encouraged to think of reruns of popular US shows, global international news coverage has
products not politics. sporting events, and celebrity declined globally, despite
entertainment programs, advancements in technology that
They are consumers not citizens. The
conglomerates have little incentive to neglecting programming on public should theoretically make
invest in local talk shows, news affairs and issues. reporting more accessible. Even
channels, documentaries, or other social significant events like the 9/11
and political content. The global As a result, news and political attacks and subsequent wars
oligopoly of media thus helps create a content become softer, lighter, have failed to generate the
passive apolitical populace that rises and less challenging, with less expected surge in international
from the couch primarily for news coverage, leaving many to
attention given to substantive
consumption.
issues and more focus on question why so much media
The oligopoly's single-minded interest in sensationalism and output produces so little
profits results in mass content rather entertainment. informative content..
than local content.

Media and Political They die covering earthquakes,


floods, and hurricanes. They die in
Media and Cultural
Globalization drug raids. Many though are Globalization
specifically targeted, hunted
An essential process of globalization is down, and murdered because of The media, on one level, are the
political. Globalization has transformed their work. primary carriers of culture.
world politics in profound ways. It led to
Through newspapers,
the formation and then the overthrow of Journalists must bear some of the magazines, movies,
kingdoms and empires. It led to the responsibility for lax coverage of advertisements, television,
creation of the nation-state. And now government and society. radio, the Internet, and other
some argue that the nation-state is Bribery of journalists, for example, forms, the media produce and
being weakened as people and borders remains a fact of life in many display cultural products, from
become ever more fluid in our globalized countries. pop songs to top films. They also
world. Some argue that transnational
generate numerous and ongoing
political actors, from NGOs (non- Such circumstances show the interactions among cultures,
governmental organizations) like political possibilities – and such as when American hip hop
Greenpeace to corporations to the obstacles – facing new media in music is heard by Cuban youth.
United Nations, now rise in prominence modern civil society. Though
in our age of globalization. When we add sometimes slow at first to Yet, the media are much more
the media to the admixture of recognize the possibility – and than technology, more than
globalization and politics, we touch upon threat – posed by new media, mechanical conveyors of culture,
some key features of modern life. established political and economic more than simple carriers of
forces have moved quickly to editorial cartoons or McDonalds'
The International Federation of assert control. advertisements. The media are
Journalists (IFJ) estimates that on
people. These people are active
average close to 100 journalists and Globalization complicates but economic agents and aggressive
media workers are killed in the line of does not lessen political political lobbyists on matters of
duty each year. They die in war zones. intimidation and control of media. culture. They market brands
They die from car bombs.
aggressively.
Dark Contours
CONCLUSION In conclusion, while
globalization and media have
of the Global The globalization of media has contributed to the creation of
undeniably played a pivotal role a global village marked by
Village in shaping what Marshall interconnectedness and
cultural exchange, they also
McLuhan termed the "global
Globalization and media have village," a concept that refers to pose challenges related to
done wondrous deeds. They the interconnectedness of the information integrity, access,
have succeeded in bringing the world through communication and governance.
world closer together. They have technologies. Globalization has
removed the shackles of time facilitated unprecedented As we navigate the
and space. They have given interconnectedness among complexities of an increasingly
us the ability to truly imagine the people worldwide. Media interconnected world, it is
world as a global village. When platforms such as the internet, essential to harness the
McLuhan first conceived the social media, and satellite potential of media
term, he had the highest hopes television have bridged globalization while addressing
and, even today, the term global geographical gaps, allowing its shortcomings to foster a
village still evokes community, individuals to communicate and more inclusive and informed
kinship, cooperation, and share information across borders global society.
fraternity. But Lewis Mumford instantaneously.
was not fooled. His cold, clear
vision of human weakness saw
emerging the dark contours of Discussion Questions
the global village. He saw media
technology used not to better 1. How has the globalization of media platforms transformed the
the world but to exploit the concept of the "global village," and what are some key examples of
its impact on interconnectedness among diverse communities?
world in pursuit of property,
profit, and power. 2. In what ways has media globalization facilitated cultural exchange,
and what are the implications for cultural diversity and identity in the
globalized landscape?
Our discussion here shows
globalization and media too 3. What are the main challenges posed by media globalization,
often have fulfilled Mumford's particularly regarding misinformation, regulatory issues, and the
worst fears. They have built a digital divide, and how can these challenges be addressed to foster
a more inclusive and informed global society?
village with large tracts of
economic injustice, political
repression, and cultural conflict.
They have sewn seeds of bitter
and deadly discord between
nations, classes, political
parties, ethnic groups, religions,
and neighbors. They have pit
humans against nature. They
have despoiled the very globe
they encircle. We should expect
better.
WEEK 10 READINGS

The Affective Labor and


Performance of Live
Streaming on Twitch.tv

In this article, we examine the affective dimensions of video game


streaming labor, which involves being compelling to watch and friendly
to viewers, soliciting donations, building parasocial intimacy with
spectators, and engaging audiences through humor. Our analysis pays
particular attention to the extent to which streamers broadcast as
“themselves” or as a “character.” This disjunction is a tactic of self-
branding (Hearn 2008; Marwick 2013) in an increasingly crowded
marketplace. We also examine these kinds of labor within the
dynamics of the platform, shedding light on the stresses and
INTRODUCTION challenges for streamers.
CONCLUSION
Live streaming and game The article delves into the intricacies
commentary are important for Twitch and Live Streaming of labor involved in streaming on the
critical media studies for two Twitch platform, highlighting the
The Twitch platform can be compared
reasons. First, live streaming is importance of being presentable,
with YouTube, and Hector Postigo’s
funny, engaging, and in character.
a major global phenomenon (2016) study of video game
These aspects of labor are essential
and expanding in scope and commentary on YouTube is a
for streamers to navigate the
particularly important reference for
reach. our analysis. Hector Postigo (2016,
complex relationships between
themselves, the game being played,
332) focuses on the technical and
the Twitch platform, and the
The scale of the audience is social affordances of the platform,
audience.
now impressive enough to rival examining how “the hybridity of play
and production” provide the
many The authors argue that the labor
opportunity for transforming leisure
television channels and involved in streaming is not just
into a Form of work.
about playing games but also about
traditional sports broadcasts,
being socially active and emotionally
whereas it is also becoming an Affective Labor on Twitch responsive. Despite the seemingly
increasingly central element of casual nature of streams, the article
digital gaming culture more Twitch is a deeply social platform for emphasizes the significant amount
content production and distribution. of affective labor that streamers
broadly.
Beyond a simple broadcast relation, invest in their content.
streamers and viewers communicate
Second, streaming represents a to one another through the platform’s Moreover, the article calls attention
career path that many young chat system. The browser presents to the new pressures professional
the user with three interactions : first, streamers face, indicating the need
people—disproportionately
the live-streamed gameplay for urgent attention to understand
impacted by the financial (mirroring what the streamer sees); the evolving landscape of streaming
crisis—are pursuing, finding the second, an embedded live stream of as a profession. With Twitch's rapid
apparent opportunity to play the streamer, showing them narrating and continuous growth and the
games for a living and playing the game; and third, a diverse forms of affective labor
chat window to the side that the involved, the authors assert that
understandably compelling audience can use to type messages comprehending these forms of work
(Johnson and Woodcock 2019). to the streamer and each other. is crucial for developing theories
around digital game labor.

You might also like