Professional Documents
Culture Documents
23 - 02 - 14 Latest Developments in Claim Substantiation Methods Ver 1 - OCR
23 - 02 - 14 Latest Developments in Claim Substantiation Methods Ver 1 - OCR
23 - 02 - 14 Latest Developments in Claim Substantiation Methods Ver 1 - OCR
1 sec
~
LATEST DEVELOPMENTS
HAIR CONDITIONING TESTS
IN HAIR CLAIM
Dr. Paul Cornwell
SUBSTANTIATION
Business Development Director, TRI Princeton
METHODS
Paul Cornwell and Eleanor Lehman, TRI Princeton
Pictured (l-r) are Xuzi Kang, Muriel Mason, Vanessa Castro, Amy Jarosz, David Graham (TRI President),
Ernesta Malinasukyte, Matt Jarosz, Alison Robinson, Jessica Turner, Guilherme Fratassi, Marcella
Gabarra
mi
Purchased by unknown, nofirst nolast
From: TRI Princeton (library.triprinceton.org)
~
Hair and scalp care - $80 billion category IFSCC
~
No.1
Bond Multiplier.
OLAPLEX
UGIHHIHG THE REIUllDING
RESTORE•
This concentroted first so Ion step rebuilds HAIR SERUM
StRUMPO<,R
broken disulfide bonds and begins the CfiEVEUX
process of preventing damage and REPARA110••
BR/l(ANCE
repairing hair.
JOml/1.011.~
~
co
¨ Uses;
• New product development
• Formulation changes
• Performance versus competitors
• Validation of product claims
2. Outline considerations
4. Operation
6. Conclusions
Consumer Fibre
(sensory) Array tests Fibre tests composition
tests tests
Consumer Fibre
(sensory) Array tests Fibre tests composition
tests tests
450
400
350
No.1
BondMultipt,e,. i
cl:
300
250
~
co
0
200
~
--■--1111
E
:, 150
z
b ' 100
._......
p-oceacl ~rl:rgcbnagear.d
50
0
2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021
Yeot
• Search on Mintel GNPDfrom 2012 • 2021, searching for shampoos, conditioners, hair styling products and
hair treatments containing the term 'bond' OR 'bonds' ond A D NOT 'bonding' In the product description.
Excludes co/oront$.
4. Cornwell, P.A., Marsh, J. (2023) Bond Builders: Do They Really Repair Hair? Cosmetics & Toiletries Magazine, in press
5. Cornwell, P.A. (2022, Oct 12) Do bond builders really repair the hair? TRI Talks 2023, Presented live and on-line on October 12th !Bi
Library
i ..
I....
I
.._.
....
ftllNIPr(ftCWWltliMl 1t•>1
OntM C 14711 "C
Patampan111re. 15tT1'C
..
I .._. .,
.... y,-
~
.....•• 50 75
,_
100 ,,.
re,
150 ,,. zoo
. - ·- ,_
~"~ ·-
4. Cornwell, P.A., Marsh, J. (2023) Bond Builders: Do They Really Repair Hair? Cosmetics & Toiletries Magazine, in press
6. Figure (i) from - Malinauskyte, E., Shrestha, R., Cornwell, P.A., Gourion-Arsiquaud, S., Hindley, M. (2021) Penetration of different
molecular weight hydrolysed keratins into hair fibers and their effects on the physical properties of textured hair. Int J Cosmet Sci 43(1)
26-37
Copyright © 2023 TRI Princeton
Unauthorised reproduction or distribution prohibited without prior written consent mi
Purchased by unknown, nofirst nolast
From: TRI Princeton (library.triprinceton.org)
~
New Thinking – Hair Porosity IFSCC
~
¨ New methods for investigating the lateral diffusion of water and actives in
single hair fibres5
I , .
I ., 11 C ~
I ' •I
u [
I
; ·, "> 'i I ' C
5. Senak, L. (2022, Dec 7) Innovative method to evaluate hair structure and chemistry by investigating the diffusion of actives.
Presentation at TRI Talks, live and on-line Dec 7th
mi
Library
0 cm 0.5 cm 1 cm 1.5 cm 2 cm
0 0
5. Senak, L. (2022, Dec 7) Innovative method to evaluate hair structure and chemistry by investigating the diffusion of actives.
Presentation at TRI Talks, live and on-line Dec 7th
mi
Library
6. Evans, T.A., and Park, K. (2010) A statistical analysis of hair breakage. II. Repeated grooming experiments. Journal of Cosmetic Science
61(November/December), 439-455
7. Evans, T. (2014) Measuring Hair Strength, Part II: Fiber Breakage. Cosmetics & Toiletries Magazine, Vol. 128, 12(December), 854-859
Copyright © 2023 TRI Princeton
Unauthorised reproduction or distribution prohibited without prior written consent mi
Purchased by unknown, nofirst nolast
From: TRI Princeton (library.triprinceton.org)
~
New Protocols – Repeated Grooming + IA IFSCC
~
¨ New protocol and apparatus developed together with Newtone uses IA to
measure number and lengths of broken hairs
Correlation between manual and instrument counts of broken hairs (n=300 trays)
250
150
100
50
0
0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 200
•
•
-
Copyright © 2023 TRI Princeton
Unauthorised reproduction or distribution prohibited without prior written consent mi
Purchased by unknown, nofirst nolast
From: TRI Princeton (library.triprinceton.org)
~
New Protocols – Repeated Grooming + IA IFSCC
~
¨ Measurement of broken hair lengths creates new possibilities
8
between treatments – a second ‘bite at the cherry’ if --
6
numbers of broken hairs show no difference 4
* In the data shown here, amount of hair lost by use Log mean Log std dev Geo mean + geo s.d. - geo s.d. Confl.
Groups
Mean s.d. Confl.
Groups
of S+C is 5-fold lower than the control, whereas the (p<0.05) (p<0.05)
Cell 4 SLES Control 0.80 0.32 6.24 6.80 3.25 A 8.20 7.43 A
number of hairs list is reduced only 3-fold Cell 5 Shampoo
Cell 6 Shampoo + Conditioner I
0.71
0.66 I 0.30
0.31 I 5.12
4.53 I 5.14
4.67 I 2.57
2.30 I B
C I 6.58
6.20 I 5.77
9.41 I B
B
¨ Key aspects 90
c Mean
OMearttSE
~
M•anctSD
•
type, rehydrating hair every 20
: 70
~
0
~ 60
passes to maintain wetness of tress ~
38%·
~ 50
~
I!!
• Hand bound 0.25g mini-tresses •
.0
.: 40 48%·
C
g:i 64%. l
!
(Walker Type 4, L’Oreal Type VII
64%"
~
iii
~
30
Advantages
+ LeaveIn Condilloner Mask Conditioner
¨ Treatment
8. C. Reich and C. R. Robbins (1993) Light Scattering and Shine Measurements of Human Hair: A Sensitive Probe of the Hair
Surface, J. Soc. Cosmet. Chem., 44 (1993), pp. 221-234.
mi
Purchased by unknown, nofirst nolast
From: TRI Princeton (library.triprinceton.org)
~
New Protocols – Shine + Type 4 Hair IFSCC
~
¨ New protocol has been developed for Walker Type 4 hair
Key aspects
3000
¨ 2800 0 ~:
SE
!SO
.,...,. f 0
¢
2600
¢ ~
• Custom-made light box 2400 70'II·
.i 2200
• 1g hand bound tresses (Walker Type ja:.. 2000
1800 0.5'11,•t
0
4, L’Oreal Type VII hair) .8 E
1600
1400
1°'6-'l
-l
• Careful control of illumination and 1200
1000
¢471'1·1
mi
Purchased by unknown, nofirst nolast
From: TRI Princeton (library.triprinceton.org)
~
New Protocols – Wet Combing + Type 4 Hair IFSCC
~
¨ Existing combing protocol is used to measure wet and dry combability9
Scope Determines the level of wet or dry
conditioning on hair by measuring the
force to drag a wet hair tress
through a comb
Hair 8”/3g tresses, flat crimped, treated
and blotted-dry, hair types selected
as required
WetCombingGraph Method Instron, 10N Load Cell, fine-toothed
comb.
Measurement Peak combing force also known as
parameters ‘maximum load’ (gf)
Extension(irdES)
9. Evans, T. (2013) Evaluating Hair Conditioning with Automated Combing. Cosmetics & Toiletries Magazine, Vol. 126, 8(August), 558-563
mi
Purchased by unknown, nofirst nolast
From: TRI Princeton (library.triprinceton.org)
~
New Protocols – Wet Combing + Type 4 Hair IFSCC
~
¨ New protocol has been developed for Walker Type 4 hair
¨ Key aspects
J
220
o Mean
180
cp QMoantSe
I MtantSD
u~ 47%"
120
¨ Advantages
• Now possible to differentiate combing
forces following different treatments
on Type 4 Hair
mi
Purchased by unknown, nofirst nolast
From: TRI Princeton (library.triprinceton.org)
~
New Protocols – Curl Elongation + Type 4 Hair IFSCC
~
¨ New protocol has been developed for Walker Type 4 hair
~~----------------~--------
¨ Key aspects ~ -a 51.9%. I 55.7%. I
qp
59.0%. l
~
59.0%. I
= @
,..:Sc
Lj:-1
.c -10
ti,
C¥J 38.6%. j 63.8%" t 64.8%. l
• Hand bound 0.25g mini-tresses i -12
_,
.!: -14 ciJ
(Walker Type 4, L’Oreal Type VII 2
& -16
-18
u
hair) -20
-22
2
~
u
:.
.!:
.::
..
u
:, ..
ti>
Ii
~
N
'ii
..
0
N
E
j,
E
i
Shampoo i() ~ X
..
E
0,
C
_,
0
.::
u
:,
()
f a Mean
□ Mean:SE
b
_
X
I Mean±SD Treettnenlol CtJ~lype VII 0 25 g Tress
... ...
_,._, Advantages
I
.. tftt ... toll
mi
Purchased by unknown, nofirst nolast
From: TRI Princeton (library.triprinceton.org)
~
New Protocols – Hair Lipid Analysis IFSCC
~
¨ Hair lipid analysis and analysis of hair oil treatments by chromatography
mi
Purchased by unknown, nofirst nolast
From: TRI Princeton (library.triprinceton.org)
~
New Protocols – Hair Lipid Analysis IFSCC
~
¨ Hair lipid analysis and analysis of hair oil treatments by chromatography
¨ Key aspects
• Protocols developed for sebum
sampling from the scalp, extraction of
lipids from hair samples and for the
analysis of hair oil products All four stages pooled
Hexane
• HPTLC being used in research projects C:M=2:1
C:M=1:1
to investigate differences in lipids C:M=1:2
Diglycerols
Monoglycerols
Cholesterol
• For the latest data see Ernesta’s TRI
Talk from November10
10. Malinauskyte, E. (2022, Nov 30) What kind of lipids do we seek for hair? Presented at TRI Talks 2022, live and on-line Nov 30th
mi
Purchased by unknown, nofirst nolast
From: TRI Princeton (library.triprinceton.org)
~
Call for sponsors IFSCC
~
mi
Purchased by unknown, nofirst nolast
From: TRI Princeton (library.triprinceton.org)
~
New Protocols – Scalp Imaging System IFSCC
~
¨ In-situ analysis of scalp scaling and skin redness
mi
Purchased by unknown, nofirst nolast
From: TRI Princeton (library.triprinceton.org)
~
New Protocols – Scalp Imaging System IFSCC
~
¨ In-situ analysis of scalp scaling and skin redness Validation tests showed that Majority of panelists
identified as having dandruff by dermatologists also had
scales identified by the image analysis (P<0.05, Chi-
¨ Key aspects squared)
70
Number of panellists
50
Analysis System developed by 40
10
imaging system (SkinCamTM) to 0
Yes No
visualise and characterise scalp
scaling and skin colour changes Validation tests also showed that the number of scales
recorded related well with dermatologist defined dandruff
associated with inflammation severity (n=150)
700
500
Number of scales
400
100
++
+
gn
++
e+
+
i ld
++
e+
i ld
Si
at
e+
M
i ld
er
at
M
o
at
M
er
N
od
er
od
M
od
M
M
mi
Purchased by unknown, nofirst nolast
From: TRI Princeton (library.triprinceton.org)
~
New Protocols – Scalp Imaging System IFSCC
~
¨ In-situ analysis of scalp scaling and skin redness
Increased skin darkness in subjects with scalp
¨ Key aspects scaling (p<0.05 for all hair types)
With scales
50
• Recent studies showed that scaling
was associated with a darkening
Mean L value
40
Symposium (live and on-line, June Hair Type No scales With scales Two tailed T-test, equal
5-6, Redbank, NJ) Hair Type 2
Number
45
Mean
47.45
Std Dev
7.12
Number
35
Mean
43.60
Std Dev
9.24
variances (p value)
0.0382
Hair Type 3
Hair Type 4
29
19 I 44.95
31.10 I 8.57
11.60
49
66 I 37.59
22.82 I 8.84
10.10
0.0006
0.0031
mi
Purchased by unknown, nofirst nolast
From: TRI Princeton (library.triprinceton.org)
~
Method validation IFSCC
~
¨ Repeated grooming and hair damage
mi
Purchased by unknown, nofirst nolast
From: TRI Princeton (library.triprinceton.org)
~
Method validation IFSCC
~
¨ Repeated grooming and hair damage
Cysteic Creation after Bleaching Asian and Chinese Hair
Tresses- Combined Data
¨ ATR-FTIR measurement of cysteic acid 0.250
;:;--
levels suggested that damage levels 41
.
C
t,.
....•··•·····
~ 0.050 ••
41
>
·.:;
{l 0.000
~ 0 20 40 60 80
Total Bleached Minutes - TBMs
mi
Purchased by unknown, nofirst nolast
From: TRI Princeton (library.triprinceton.org)
~
Conclusions & next steps IFSCC
~
¨ “If you can not measure it, you can not improve it” Lord Kelvin (1824-1907)
¨ In order to make new or stronger claims, you always need better measurement
techniques
mi
Purchased by unknown, nofirst nolast
From: TRI Princeton (library.triprinceton.org)