Professional Documents
Culture Documents
The Wall Street Journal - 27.02.2024
The Wall Street Journal - 27.02.2024
The Wall Street Journal - 27.02.2024
00
DJIA 39069.23 g 62.30 0.16% NASDAQ 15976.25 g 0.1% STOXX 600 495.43 g 0.4% 10-YR. TREAS. g 10/32 , yield 4.298% OIL $77.58 À $1.09 GOLD $2,028.50 g $10.10 EURO $1.0854 YEN 150.70
U.S. NEWS
U.S.WATCH MOON
Mission Is Expected Man Dies After
WASHINGTON, D.C. PENTAGON
Handling of Austin
To Be Cut Short Self-Immolation Illness Defended
A private U.S. lunar lander An active-duty U.S. Air The Pentagon found it did
is expected to stop working Force member who set himself nothing wrong in deciding to
Tuesday, its mission cut short on fire outside the Israeli em- not immediately inform Presi-
after landing sideways near bassy in Washington, D.C., on dent Biden or legislators of
the south pole of the moon. Sunday has died, officials said. Defense Secretary Lloyd Aus-
Intuitive Machines, the The man repeatedly said tin’s whereabouts when he
Houston company that built “Free Palestine” and ap- was hospitalized earlier this
and flew the spacecraft, said peared to livestream the pro- year, finding in an internal re-
Monday it would continue to test Sunday afternoon on the view that staff followed ex-
collect data until sunlight no platform Twitch, which has isting guidelines and sought
longer shines on the solar pan- since removed the video. The to protect the defense chief’s
els. Based on the position of Metropolitan Police Depart- privacy.
Earth and the moon, officials ment identified him as Aaron The handling of Austin’s
expect that to happen Tuesday Bushnell, a 25-year-old from hospitalization and illness
morning. That is two to three San Antonio. caused a political headache
days short of the week or so Bushnell died in a hospital for the White House and
that NASA and other custom- on Sunday night, the police raised concerns on Capitol
ers had been counting on. and the Air Force said. Hill about the secretary’s de-
The lander, named Odys- Bushnell appeared to say cision to wait several days
seus, is the first U.S. space- during the episode that he before sharing with Biden
craft to land on the moon in didn’t want to be complicit in that he had been hospitalized
over 50 years, carrying experi- genocide and wanted to en- following a prostate-cancer
ments for NASA, the main gage in an extreme act of pro- diagnosis. Austin’s unwilling-
sponsor. But it came in too test. He was likely referring to ness to tell the president or
fast last Thursday and the the Israel-Hamas War and the top military commanders
foot of one of its six legs humanitarian crisis in Gaza. raised questions about his
caught on the surface, causing On Oct. 7, Hamas militants judgment amid heightened
it to tumble over, according to stormed the Israeli border, tensions in the Middle East,
company officials. Based on killing over 1,200 people and Europe and Asia.
photos from NASA’s Lunar Re- abducting over 240 civilians At the time, there were
connaissance Orbiter flying and soldiers, according to Is- imprecise guidelines about
overhead, Odysseus landed raeli authorities. Since the at- how to inform other defense
within a mile or so of its in- tacks, Israel has responded officials or the White House
tended target near the Mala- with a military campaign that when the secretary can’t per-
pert A crater, just 185 miles or it has said is aimed at de- form the job, according to the
INTUITIVE MACHINES/ASSOCIATED PRESS
so from the moon’s south pole. stroying Hamas and recover- three-page summary of the
According to NASA, the ing the hostages. More than Pentagon’s 30-day review.
lander ended up in a small, de- 29,000 Palestinians have The Pentagon said it
graded crater with a 12-degree been killed since Israel began shared a classified version of
slope. That is the closest a its offensive, according to the report with Congress.
spacecraft has ever come to Palestinian health authorities, Austin is scheduled to appear
the south pole, an area of in- most of them women and Thursday on Capitol Hill to
terest because of suspected children. The numbers don’t answer questions about his
frozen water in the perma- distinguish between civilians handling of his hospitaliza-
The Odysseus lunar lander captured this image about 35 seconds after pitching over during nently shadowed craters there. and combatants. tion.
its approach to its landing site near the south pole of the moon Thursday. —Associated Press —Alyssa Lukpat —Nancy A. Youssef
CORRECTIONS AMPLIFICATIONS
High Court distinction between social-me-
dia sites focused on expression
and those that were more akin
The platforms could say any-
thing they want, even criticize
user posts, he said. Users were
they must or can’t say, Rob-
erts said.
Among other provisions, the
Considers to a service.
Different rules could apply
to different functions a com-
free to block unwanted con-
tent, he said.
“All that’s left is voluntary
Texas law prohibits platforms
from discriminating against us-
ers based on their viewpoints.
In some editions Monday,
a U.S. Watch article from the
Associated Press about a New
A Nov. 4 Off Duty article
about bird-watching in Colom-
bia incorrectly identified a
Amtrak is a common carrier Nielson said the Texas law for what they believe—to de- Readers can alert The Wall Street Journal to any errors in news articles by
Continued from Page One and can’t discriminate among simply recognized the public cide, for instance, that when it emailing wsjcontact@wsj.com or by calling 888-410-2667.
Clement said. “That should be passengers. But if Amtrak pub- function social media plays. comes to antisemites, “we’re
a nonstarter.” lishes a magazine that passen- “Today, millions of Ameri- not even going to let them post
Several justices expressed gers can read during their cans don’t visit friends or fam- cat videos.” THE WALL STREET JOURNAL
sympathy with that argument travel, it would be entitled to ily or even go to work in per- Clement said yes. If “you (USPS 664-880) (Eastern Edition ISSN 0099-9660)
but observed that ruling First Amendment protection son. Everybody is online. The are a notorious antisemite, we (Central Edition ISSN 1092-0935) (Western Edition ISSN 0193-2241)
against the states might also for the editorial decisions the modern public square,” he do not want you to participate Editorial and publication headquarters:
entitle the internet giants to company makes over what to said. But if platforms that in this conversation,” he said. 1211 Avenue of the Americas, New York, N.Y. 10036
police what messages are include, she said. “passively host the speech of The cases, Moody v. Net- Published daily except Sundays and general legal holidays.
transmitted via other services Arguing in the Texas case, billions of people are them- Choice and NetChoice v. Pax- Periodicals postage paid at New York, N.Y., and other mailing offices.
they provide, such as individ- Prelogar agreed that social me- selves the speakers and can ton, are the latest in a series Postmaster: Send address changes to The Wall Street Journal,
ual email accounts or direct dia didn’t fit neatly into Su- discriminate, there will be no that the court has used to 200 Burnett Rd., Chicopee, MA 01020.
messaging. preme Court precedents. public square to speak of.” project the First Amendment All Advertising published in The Wall Street Journal is subject to the applicable
Justice Amy Coney Barrett “It’s not necessary here to Chief Justice John Roberts, into the online world. rate card, copies of which are available from the Advertising Services
Department, Dow Jones & Co. Inc., 1211 Avenue of the Americas, New York, N.Y.
asked Clement how the court try to figure out how the First disputing the idea that the Recent years have seen the
10036. The Journal reserves the right not to accept an advertiser’s order. Only
could write an opinion saying Amendment applies to new platforms hold a monopoly court strike down a North Car- publication of an advertisement shall constitute final acceptance of the
state restrictions were uncon- technology in general or to ev- over public discourse, said olina law that barred sex of- advertiser’s order.
stitutional regarding news ery possible website or the in- Texas had gotten the First fenders from much of social Letters to the Editor: Fax: 212-416-2891; email: wsj.ltrs@wsj.com
feeds on Facebook and You- ternet in particular,” she said. Amendment backward. media, finding it unconstitu-
Need assistance with your subscription?
Tube, but not when it came to She recommended the court “What the government’s tional to banish them from By web: customercenter.wsj.com; By email: support@wsj.com
services such as the shopping rule narrowly against what she doing here is saying, You must “the modern public square,” By phone: 1-800-JOURNAL (1-800-568-7625)
platform Facebook Market- said was a singular defect in do this, you must carry these and throw out a cyberstalking Reprints & licensing:
place “or Gmail or DMs.” the Texas law: the state’s aim people; you’ve got to explain if conviction because prosecutors By email: customreprints@dowjones.com
Clement didn’t want to give of amplifying some voices on you don’t. That’s not the First hadn’t proved the defendant By phone: 1-800-843-0008
ground on that point, but U.S. the platforms “by suppressing Amendment,” he said. Rather intended his posts to be WSJ back issues and framed pages: wsjshop.com
Solicitor General Elizabeth the platform’s own protected than impose requirements on threatening or knew the victim Our newspapers are 100% sourced from sustainably certified mills.
Prelogar, who also argued speech.” private parties, the First would see them that way.
against the state laws, sug- Not so, said the Texas solic- Amendment bars the govern- Decisions in Monday’s cases GOT A TIP FOR US? SUBMIT IT AT WSJ.COM/TIPS
gested there was a legitimate itor general, Aaron Nielson. ment from telling them what are expected before July.
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. Tuesday, February 27, 2024 | A3
U.S. NEWS
Trump
Appeals
New York
Fraud
Ruling
Lawyers for Donald Trump
on Monday appealed a New
York judge’s order requiring the
former president to pay $355
million plus interest in a civil-
fraud case that puts his real-es-
tate business at risk.
By Jacob Gershman,
Corinne Ramey and
James Fanelli
will have to post a bond worth On Monday, a federal judge of dollars, had firearms in his million defamation case
upward of around half a billion in Los Angeles ordered home and has continued mak- against Rudy Giuliani say the
dollars to prevent James from Smirnov, 43, to remain behind ing misstatements. former lawyer for Donald
moving to collect. bars while he awaits trial on Smirnov’s lawyer David Trump shouldn’t be able to es-
James, a Democrat, sued charges he lied to the FBI. The Chesnoff described his client as cape the judgment because he
Trump in 2022, alleging that he decision from Judge Otis D. a financial professional with no filed for personal bankruptcy.
and his finance team systemati- Wright II overruled a magis- criminal record, loyal to the Ruby Freeman and her
cally exaggerated the value of trate judge in Nevada, who al- U.S. government through his daughter, Shaye Moss, said in
his marquee Manhattan sky- lowed Smirnov to be released work as a confidential infor- a complaint filed on Friday in
scrapers, luxury estates and last week with conditions. Alexander Smirnov has pleaded not guilty to the charges. mant. He pointed to Smirnov’s the U.S. Bankruptcy Court in
other assets. Trump’s lawyers With the ruling, Wright romantic partner of two de- the Southern District of New
have blasted the case as politi- sided with federal prosecutors risma. According to prosecu- rival aboard an international cades and a cousin in the York that a debt for “willful
cally motivated. who had argued that Smirnov’s tors, Smirnov falsely claimed to flight. Over the objections of courtroom and said they were and malicious injury” can’t be
It is unclear how Trump claimed foreign-intelligence his FBI handler that years ear- federal prosecutors, he was willing to vouch for him. If a evaded under bankruptcy law.
would pay the judgment—and contacts and access to millions lier, during the elder Biden’s freed by a federal magistrate government-issued ankle brace- Giuliani sought protection
the roughly $100,000 daily in- of dollars made him a flight vice presidency, Burisma execu- judge in Nevada last week on let didn’t give the judge enough from creditors in December
terest being added to it. His net risk. Smirnov has pleaded not tives had admitted to paying $5 the condition that he submit to comfort, Chesnoff said Smirnov after a court ordered him to
worth has been estimated at guilty to the charges. million to each of the Bidens to electronic monitoring and could pay for private security. immediately pay the pair,
around $3 billion, but the “There is nothing garden-va- protect the company from an travel restrictions. But Wright was unper- whom the former New York
amount of liquid assets he has riety about this case,” Wright investigation by the country’s But his liberty was short- suaded by Chesnoff’s assur- mayor falsely accused of med-
isn’t clear. In a deposition last said Monday, dismissing pleas then-prosecutor general. lived. Within days, Smirnov ances, saying there were too dling in the 2020 presidential
year, he testified that he had from Smirnov’s lawyer to keep The allegations were memo- was sitting in his lawyer’s of- many unresolved issues bother- election results.
$400 million in cash. him free until his trial. Federal rialized in an internal FBI re- fice in Las Vegas when U.S. ing him. Bankruptcy typically allows
The attorney general has marshals led away Smirnov, port that Republicans seized on Marshals entered to take him The Smirnov case has deliv- filers to pause many creditor
said that if necessary, she will clad in a beige jumpsuit with last year as a central part of back into custody. ered Hunter Biden an unex- actions. Last month, Giuliani
look to Trump’s properties to hands and feet shackled. their push to impeach Presi- Smirnov’s lawyers re- pected public-relations coup, won the bankruptcy court’s
satisfy the financial pen- Smirnov’s case has provided dent Biden and accuse his fam- sponded to his second arrest undermining corruption allega- limited permission to chal-
alty. Typically a party seeking a rare glimpse into the shad- ily of corruption. Since with a request for an emer- tions that Republicans have lenge the defamation verdict.
to enforce a judgment provides owy world of spycraft and un- Smirnov’s indictment, Republi- gency hearing in Nevada. In long leveled against him. That judgment is Giuliani’s
a 30-day grace period before dercut a central part of the Re- cans have removed the FBI re- Los Angeles, Wright issued a That boost came from an largest liability in his chapter
seeking to collect, lawyers said. publicans’ push to impeach port containing those allega- brief order saying that their bid unlikely source. The Smirnov 11 case. Court filings last
Engoron’s ban on borrowing President Biden. tions from a “Key Evidence” for his release was “likely to fa- case was brought by David month showed that he has
by the Trumps could affect the Prosecutors allege that section of a House webpage de- cilitate his absconding from the Weiss, the special counsel who more than $10.6 million in as-
company’s development plans Smirnov lied to the FBI in 2020 voted to the investigation into United States.” is separately prosecuting sets. He ended the month of
globally, as most large U.S. when he claimed to have the Biden family. The judge also asserted do- Hunter Biden on gun and tax January with roughly $69,000
banks are registered or have knowledge of corruption by Joe Smirnov was arrested twice minion over the case and said charges. The younger Biden has in cash, according to another
charters with New York. Trump Biden and his son related to this month, the first time at a next steps in the proceedings pleaded not guilty to those court filing Friday.
could get loans elsewhere, but Ukrainian energy company Bu- Las Vegas airport upon his ar- should unfold not in Nevada charges. Freeman and Moss sued
the process would be more bur- Giuliani in 2021. The pair said
densome and likely involve in their complaint Friday that
smaller institutions.
Trump separately owes an
$83 million defamation judg-
ment to the advice columnist E.
Medical School Is Tuition-Free After Gift Giuliani and his team person-
ally spread, or encouraged
others to spread, a “false nar-
rative” that generated hun-
Jean Carroll. His lawyers in that dreds of millions of impres-
case asked U.S. District Judge BY MELISSA KORN whom the price tag of medical A wave of medical schools sions online, and plastered
Lewis Kaplan to put the judg- school can be prohibitive. launched similar tuition- their identities and faces all
ment on hold for now. Kaplan The Albert Einstein College The median debt load na- scholarship programs in re- over the internet. That falsely
has asked both sides to submit of Medicine in New York City tionwide for medical students cent years, using the financial caused their names to become
briefs before he rules. will now be tuition-free for all who took out loans was aid as a recruiting tool for “synonymous with election
Without a stay, Trump likely students, thanks to a historic $200,000 in 2023, according their classes and as part of an fraud and treason,” subjecting
would need to pay the judg- $1 billion gift from a former to the Association of Ameri- effort to help fill shortages in them to an onslaught of
ment or secure a bond by early faculty member and board can Medical Colleges. Eighty- lower-paying fields like pedi- threats and harassment, they
March. chair. four percent of those students atrics and internal medicine. said in their complaint.
BRENT N. CLARKE/GETTY IMAGES
Separately on Monday, Man- The donation comes from borrowed at least $100,000. The medical school at New “Mr. Giuliani cannot use
hattan District Attorney Alvin Ruth Gottesman, who after Einstein’s tuition this year is York University also covers bankruptcy to escape account-
Bragg asked the judge oversee- joining the faculty at the nearly $60,000, and the school full tuition for all students, ability for his actions,” Free-
ing Trump’s criminal hush- Bronx school in 1968 devel- recommends students budget while Columbia University man and Moss said.
money trial to limit what the oped widely used tools to at least another $35,000 a year covers the full cost of atten- Gary Fischoff, a lawyer rep-
former president can say pub- screen children for learning for living expenses, books and dance for medical students resenting Giuliani, said Mon-
licly about the witnesses, jurors problems and launched an other incidentals. The program with financial need. day that “just because an alle-
and prosecutors. The filing adult literacy program. Got- Ruth Gottesman donated lasts four years. Einstein said fourth-year gation is stated in a complaint
cited several social-media posts tesman, 93 years old, and her $1 billion to the Albert “This donation radically students will be reimbursed does not make it true.”
Trump has made about Bragg, husband, the late billionaire- Einstein College of Medicine. revolutionizes our ability to for their spring-semester tu- “That is why we have
including one with an image of investor David “Sandy” Got- continue attracting students ition, and beginning in Au- judges,” Fischoff said in a
the former president wielding a tesman, were longtime donors Warren Buffett’s. Ruth Gottes- who are committed to our gust, all students will get free statement to The Wall Street
bat at the back of the district to the medical school, and man said the funds for the bil- mission, not just those who tuition. Journal.
attorney’s head. Ruth Gottesman serves as lion-dollar donation came can afford it,” said Dr. Yaron Students assembled Mon- “Causing willful and mali-
A spokesman for the Trump chair of its board of trustees. from her husband. Tomer, the medical school’s day to hear Gottesman an- cious injury to others has con-
campaign called the proposed Sandy Gottesman, who died Einstein said the gift is in- dean. Einstein is connected to nounce the gift hugged, sequences,” Moss and Freeman
gag order unconstitutional and in 2022 at age 96, was an tended to bring healthcare ca- the 10-hospital Montefiore cheered and grew tearful said. “Mr. Giuliani cannot hide
“election interference pure and early Berkshire Hathaway reers within reach for more Health System; Gottesman sits upon learning their new fi- behind bankruptcy to escape
simple.” shareholder and friend of prospective students, for on that board as well. nancial fate. those consequences.”
A4 | Tuesday, February 27, 2024 P W L C 10 11 12 H T G K R F A M 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 O I X X THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
U.S. NEWS
protest the president’s policies. this month with the was in 2012, when Barack
While Biden is all but assured United Auto Workers Obama ran for a second
victory, the outcome could au- union, which has endorsed term. Out of fewer than
gur general-election troubles him. While aides have trav- 200,000 votes cast in that
in a state where polls show he eled to the state to meet year’s Michigan Demo-
is trailing former President with Arab-American lead- cratic primary, more than
Donald Trump, his expected ers, Biden himself hasn’t 20,000 were for the un-
Republican challenger. specifically met with the committed slate.
“I do believe that no matter Above, President Biden at a UAW phone bank in Michigan this month. Below, Abbas Alawieh
what the results of Michigan, of Listen to Michigan, a group urging a protest vote against Biden’s Middle East policies.
the takeaway should not be,
‘Oh, everything’s good,’” said votes, noting that Trump took have a challenge to be met in free hostages held by Hamas, party. We are going to con-
Maryland Gov. Wes Moore in Michigan in 2016 by about that community.” though Biden hasn’t called for tinue to campaign and work
an interview. Moore, who has that margin. (Four years later, The pressure on Biden in a permanent cease-fire. for every vote,” said Rep. Ha-
supported the Biden campaign Biden won the state by more Michigan comes as the 81- Listen to Michigan esti- ley Stevens (D., Mich.). “I have
as a top surrogate, predicted than 150,000 votes.) The orga- year-old president navigates a mates that it has reached tens seen enthusiasm and energy
the primary is “going to feel nizers argue that their votes rocky stretch. He has faced of thousands of Democratic around another four years for
BASTIEN INZAURRALDE/AFP/GETTY IMAGES
like a scrimmage where the could make the difference in a scrutiny since a special-coun- voters through phone-banking Joe Biden.”
win is going to be less impor- tight general-election race and sel report raised questions and mailers. The group The White House earlier this
tant than the lesson.” are pushing Biden to change about his memory. But leading doesn’t oppose Biden’s re-elec- month dispatched a delegation
A network of grassroots or- his policies on Gaza—namely Democrats and donors have tion in November but hopes led by deputy national-security
ganizations, led by Listen to to bring forth a permanent publicly remained supportive its actions in the primary will adviser Jon Finer to discuss
Michigan, has urged the public cease-fire—to earn their sup- of his bid, and Trump has had lead to a course correction. administration policies and
to vote “uncommitted” as a port in November. a string of controversies and Abbas Alawieh, a former push for a temporary cease-fire
way of registering opposition The pivotal question is legal troubles. congressional aide who serves in Gaza. That followed a visit
to the president’s Middle East whether voters who choose Since the Oct. 7 Hamas as- as the group’s spokesman, by Biden campaign manager
policies. The push has been en- “uncommitted” as a protest sault, Biden has staunchly said Biden needed to differen- Julie Chávez Rodriguez, who
dorsed by Rep. Rashida Tlaib Tuesday will decide in Novem- supported Israel’s right to de- tiate himself from Netanyahu’s was boycotted by Hammoud
(D., Mich.), Dearborn Mayor ber to stay home, back Trump a Biden supporter, met last fend itself. He has come under policies. “If he doesn’t do it, and other officials.
Abdullah Hammoud, as well as or—as some Democrats pri- week with Michigan Arab- criticism from progressive the political consequences are Michigan State Sen. Mal-
state and local leaders around vately believe—grudgingly American leaders and resi- Democrats who condemn Is- grave for the Democratic lory McMorrow, a Democrat,
Dearborn, which is home to come back to Biden. dents during a town hall. rael’s bombardment of Gaza Party and for him,” he said. said that sending campaign
the largest Muslim population “It’s going to be very hard Khanna said he was surprised and soaring civilian casualties. Biden’s campaign advisers staffers out first was a mis-
in the U.S. and is roughly 54% or even impossible to beat by the depth of loss and hurt The frustration goes far be- said they are working to step, but stressed that the ad-
Arab-American, according to Donald Trump in Michigan if that residents expressed about yond Michigan, with protest- strengthen relationships with ministration “is already taking
census figures. Voters in Dear- President Biden doesn’t the conflict. ers targeting him at his cam- the Arab-American community. this community seriously.”
born and Dearborn Heights change course,” said former “This is not something that paign events. They also argued that some of McMorrow, whose district
heavily backed Biden in 2020, Rep. Andy Levin (D., Mich.), can be fixed by messaging. The administration has in- the backers of the uncommit- overlaps with Tlaib’s, said
when the state helped him who has endorsed the uncom- What we need is a change in creasingly clashed with Israeli ted effort still oppose Trump “people are looking for ways
capture the White House. mitted effort. He added: “It policy,” he said. Asked about Prime Minister Benjamin Ne- and stressed a broad array of to signal to the Democratic
The groups, which have seems very hard or impossible the potential “uncommitted” tanyahu over the conduct of support from key groups such Party: We’re on your side and
been holding rallies and con- to win the electoral college if vote, he said: “I don’t think it the war. And the White House as union workers, Black voters because we’re on your side,
ducting phone-banking, have we don’t win Michigan.” really matters what that num- has been working to broker a and suburban women. we want to push you to be a
set a goal of capturing 10,000 Rep. Ro Khanna (D., Calif.), ber is. I can tell you that we deal to pause the fighting and “Certainly we’re a big-tent little bit better.”
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. Tuesday, February 27, 2024 | A5
U.S. NEWS
LEAH MILLIS/REUTERS
the clock ticks toward a par- would love to see, which is the control the House with 219
tial government shutdown Fri- United States not stepping up members, a thin margin that
day night and a Ukraine aid to its responsibility.” allows Johnson to lose only
package remains stuck. But with many conserva- three votes before the mea-
The president has called tives backing him, Johnson sure fails. And if only a hand-
the meeting for Tuesday, seek- has so far refused to bring up ful of Republicans decide he House Speaker Mike Johnson, right, could need votes from Democrats.
ing to break a logjam. House for a vote a Senate-passed hasn’t done enough to ad-
and Senate leaders have been package including money for vance the conservative
working to negotiate the de- Ukraine, Israel and Taiwan. agenda, he could lose his job—
tails of 12 funding bills total- Democrats and some Republi- as McCarthy did—via a motion Some in GOP Open to Long-Term Temporary Spending Bill
ing $1.6 trillion cans are con- on the House floor.
for federal sidering fall- Johnson has already faced Some House Republi- which called for such cuts funding.
agencies, which back options, scrutiny from Republicans cans have said they are if the government was op- Democrats said such cuts
have been oper- Funding for including a dis- who said they were disap- open to another option: erating under a continuing are unacceptable, and they
ating on tempo- several U.S. charge petition, pointed that he wasn’t able to passing a long-term tempo- resolution on that date. have pledged to avoid that
rary extensions to pass the aid negotiate deep spending cuts rary spending measure that The Congressional Bud- scenario.
since Sept. 30. agencies is due without John- to the federal budget. He has would keep federal money get Office has estimated The idea would also likely
Funding for son’s support. also faced criticism from more
the Transporta-
to expire after Biden will centrist and pragmatic Repub-
flowing until Sept. 30.
Automatic spending cuts
such a scenario would lead
to federal agency budget
draw opposition from pro-
defense Republicans who
tion Depart- Friday. travel to the licans, such as Rep. Patrick would then kick in on April cuts from 5% to 9% for say spending cuts should
ment and sev- southern bor- McHenry of North Carolina, 30 under the terms of a nondefense funding and not cripple the U.S. military
eral other der Thursday, who say he is indecisive and debt deal reached last year, from zero to 1% for defense in a time of foreign conflict.
agencies ex- according to a hasn’t laid out a clear strategy
pires after Friday, which White House official, as his to lead the party.
would affect some housing, administration continues to When congressional leaders
food and veterans’ programs; face bipartisan pressure to struck a deal in January set- there are going to be some cans were aiming “to rein in cans, but that’s not the case.
the rest expires after curb illegal crossings. Biden is ting the overall federal bud- things we can’t get,” he said. Democrats’ overspending and We’re doing our job,” she said.
March 8. set to visit Brownsville, Texas, get, Johnson defended his Senate Majority Leader policies that are harming the Congressional leaders could
House Speaker Mike John- and meet with border and support for the agreement. He Chuck Schumer (D., N.Y.) on economy.” decide to abandon their plan
son (R., La.) told Republican law-enforcement officials. said that while it doesn’t “cut Sunday criticized House Re- White House press secre- to finalize the spending bills
colleagues Friday night that On the spending front, the as much spending as many of publicans for not yet releasing tary Karine Jean-Pierre said and instead propose a fourth
lawmakers should expect to House Freedom Caucus, a us would like,” he was able to the text of the four appropria- Friday that the administration temporary extension of a week
vote to finalize spending lev- group of roughly three dozen squeeze in some concessions tions bills that lawmakers are has stressed to Congress “the or longer.
els for federal agencies whose Republican members who such as the cancellation of un- expected to vote on this week. need to keep the government Even if lawmakers pass the
funding expires this week. But push for the most conserva- spent pandemic aid. “Unless Republicans get seri- open.” first round of spending bills
Republican infighting in the tive policies, has been pres- Rep. Mario Díaz-Balart (R., ous, the extreme Republican “We’ve always been very this week, they will quickly
House—which doesn’t return suring Johnson to fight to in- Fla.), who leads a subcommit- shutdown will endanger our clear: House Republicans have face another deadline to final-
to session until Wednesday— clude some of its wish-list tee handling the appropria- economy, raise costs, lower a job to do,” she told report- ize the eight remaining bills.
raises the prospect that a policy items—such as blocking tions bill that funds the State safety, and exact untold pain ers. “Their basic duty is to Money is scheduled to run out
temporary shutdown may be funding for expanding elec- Department, said he expects on the American people,” he keep the government open.” for the Environmental Protec-
unavoidable. Like his prede- tric-vehicle use and for back- the compromise bills to ad- said in a letter to his Senate Rep. Nancy Mace (R., S.C.) tion Agency, Justice Depart-
cessor as speaker, Republican ground checks for gun sales— vance the conservative agenda colleagues. said on “Fox News Sunday” ment, Defense Department
Kevin McCarthy, Johnson has in bills that he is negotiating in small but meaningful ways Johnson fired back in a that the Senate should take up and remaining agencies after
to decide whether to cut a with Senate leaders and House compared with existing law. statement, saying the House some of the spending bills March 8.
government funding deal with Minority Leader Hakeem Jef- “There are going to be was working nonstop and in passed by the House. “They —Lindsay Wise
Democrats that risks costing fries (D., N.Y.). some Republican wins, but good faith to complete the ne- want to blame everything—all and Tarini Parti
him his job. They have gotten little as- like with any negotiation, gotiations, and that Republi- of our failures—on Republi- contributed to this article.
WORLD NEWS
Navalny’s Death Followed Proposed Swap
Opposition leader’s ple, then I just need to get rid
of the bargaining chip. Then
team says he and offer someone else when the
two Americans were time comes.”
Pevchikh said possible deals
set to be traded were being discussed since last
year, and referenced a report in
BY THOMAS GROVE the Journal that said Navalny
could be part of hostage-ex-
Russian opposition leader change talks with the Kremlin.
Alexei Navalny’s death in an Pevchikh said she had informa-
Arctic penal colony followed a tion that on Feb. 15, talks were
proposal to trade him and two in “their final stage.”
unnamed American citizens The next day, Russia’s prison
held by Moscow for a Russian service said Navalny lost con-
hit man imprisoned in Ger- sciousness and later died after
many, Navalny’s foundation he had been let out of his cell.
said Monday. On Monday, Navalny
In a video posted on the of- spokeswoman Kira Yarmysh
ficial YouTube channel of Na- said they were in the process
valny’s Anti-Corruption Foun- of arranging a public memo-
dation, Maria Pevchikh, the rial event for the politician.
group’s head of investigations, After Navalny’s body was re-
said Navalny was killed after turned to his mother over the
Russian President Vladimir weekend, the question re-
Putin became aware of the po- mains whether the Kremlin
tential swap and acted to pre- will allow a public outpouring
vent it. of sentiment over his death.
Pevchikh said the founda- Navalny’s foundation said
NACHO DOCE/REUTERS
tion had been involved in ef- the proposal to swap the oppo-
forts to win Navalny’s freedom sition leader for Krasikov was
but didn’t provide evidence to taken to Putin by Roman Abra-
back her assertions in her movich, a sanctioned Russian
seven-minute statement. oligarch who has acted as a
Among the U.S. citizens be- A woman places a portrait of late Russian opposition leader Alexei Navalny on his memorial in Barcelona. middleman in other prisoner
ing held in Russia are Wall exchanges between Russia and
Street Journal reporter Evan Peskov didn’t respond to a re- either internal deliberations ment on what Navalny’s foun- Gershkovich, who was ac- Ukraine. A representative for
Gershkovich and former U.S. quest for comment about the or our work to secure the re- dation had said. credited as a foreign corre- Abramovich didn’t respond to a
Marine Paul Whelan, both of Anti-Corruption Foundation lease of people held overseas... spondent by Russia’s Foreign request for comment.
whom have been designated statement. Peskov told the Fi- We have long called for Alexei Ministry at the time he was de- U.S. officials expressed op-
as wrongfully detained by the nancial Times that he wasn’t Navalny’s release.” Swap for ‘patriot’ tained, has been held for nearly timism about possible deals
U.S. government, which has aware of any swap agreement. “I’m just not going to speak In an interview with former a year on an FSB allegation after Putin spoke in detail for
said it is working to negotiate A White House spokesman to our conversations with any Fox News host Tucker Carlson that he was engaged in espio- a full minute about Krasikov
their release. didn’t respond to a request for of our diplomatic partners earlier this month, Putin indi- nage—an accusation the Jour- after Carlson asked him to
Pevchikh said Putin comment and a spokesman for about the work that we do to cated that he was seeking a nal, the U.S. government and free Gershkovich.
couldn’t “tolerate Navalny be- the German government de- try to secure the release of swap deal that would allow his family vehemently deny. Weeks earlier, when a New
ing free.” clined to comment. Privately, wrongfully detained Ameri- the repatriation of Vadim Whelan, a corporate secu- York Times reporter asked Pu-
Navalny, who died on Feb. U.S. and German officials said cans or others held around the Krasikov, an agent of Russia’s rity executive from Novi, tin about Gershkovich at a
16, was Putin’s most ardent they made no offer to Putin. world,” he said. Federal Security Service, or Mich., has been held in Russia news conference, the presi-
critic and spent years investi- Matthew Miller, a State De- “Our work to try to secure FSB, who was convicted in since late 2018 on espionage dent sighed audibly and said
gating and exposing alleged partment spokesperson, on the release of Evan Gersh- 2021 of killing a Chechen dis- charges that he, his family and he was eager to reach a deal
corruption by the Kremlin Monday declined to comment kovich and Paul Whelan con- sident in Berlin. the U.S. government also ve- for his release.
elite. He had a large following on the assessment that Na- tinues. It’s something we are After Carlson asked about hemently deny. He was con- —Louise Radnofsky
across Russia. valny was killed because he working on every day.” the possible return of the Jour- victed of the charges in 2020 contributed to this article.
was close to being freed in a The Journal said in a state- nal’s Gershkovich, who was de- and sentenced to serve 16
prisoner exchange. ment: “We know the U.S. Gov- tained by FSB officers last year, years in a penal colony.
Wrongfully detained “As we have said, we be- ernment is taking the efforts Putin said he would consider a “Putin was clearly told that Watch a Video
President Biden has said lieve that Vladimir Putin and to free Evan seriously, and swap for an unnamed “patriot” the only way to get Krasikov is Scan this code
Putin is responsible for Na- the Russian government are we cannot comment further.” who had killed “a bandit” in a to exchange him for Navalny,” for a video on
valny’s death, but the Kremlin responsible for his death,” A Whelan family spokes- European capital, a statement Pevchikh said. She said Putin the proposed
has denied state involvement. said Miller. man said he didn’t have widely seen as describing decided: “Since they are will- prisoner swap
Kremlin spokesman Dmitry “I’m not going to speak to enough information to com- Krasikov. ing to offer Krasikov in princi- for Navalny.
©2024 Dow Jones & Co, Inc. All rights reserved. 6DJ0278
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. * * * * Tuesday, February 27, 2024 | A7
WORLD NEWS
to our forces and civilians.” Hamas-led attack on Israel. entered the enclave, U.N. offi- have grown more aggressive
But the police’s disappear- Deliveries of humanitarian cials said. about stopping the trucks and
ance has disrupted aid deliv- aid to Gaza have plunged this Col. Moshe Tetro, Cogat’s taking the contents, forcing the
eries, leaving convoys they month after Palestinian police coordinator for aid to Gaza, U.N. to suspend most convoys,
once guarded more vulnerable the U.N. counted on to protect said deliveries had increased said Scott Anderson, deputy di-
to looters, U.N. officials say. convoys stopped showing up over the weekend. About 135 rector of Unrwa in Gaza.
To get the aid flowing, U.S. for work, fearing attacks from trucks crossed on Sunday, in- —Summer Said
and Egyptian officials have Israel and gangs of looters, cluding 17 vehicles that went and Abeer Ayyoub
been discussing a possible so- U.S. and U.N. officials say. to north Gaza, he said, but he contributed to this article. Palestinians carry a body after an Israeli airstrike in Rafah.
A8 | Tuesday, February 27, 2024 THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
cause trouble. Theodore Roose- of them,” Milei recently told he was a gladiator and the dog widely reported claim Milei has
velt’s dog, Pete, killed four The Wall Street Journal. “But I Argentine President Javier Milei with his cloned dogs in was a lion, according to “El sought political counsel from
squirrels and chased down a don’t usually share them.” 2018. He calls them his ‘four-legged children.’ Loco.” Instead of fighting, the his dogs, an assertion Milei
French ambassador. Dwight D. During the interview last pair teamed up with the mis- hasn’t publicly denied.
Eisenhower sent his dog for month, Milei said he doesn’t see Milei’s dogs are a prickly never married or had children sion to one day rule Argentina. A Clarin newspaper colum-
training after it urinated on a a contradiction of having a lion topic. He appeared irritated of his own, used to spend Four of his current, cloned nist teased that Argentines
rug worth $20,000. President as his political symbol when when asked by the Journal how Christmas and New Year’s alone dogs are named after econo- should try to communicate with
Biden’s nippy German shepherd, he’s clearly a dog person. In cin- he plans to tend to five dogs with Conan, both sipping Cham- mists—Milton for Milton Fried- Milei’s dead dog, the first Co-
Commander, got banished from ema’s early days, he said, movie that weigh as much as minia- pagne, according to a popular man, Robert and Lucas for Rob- nan, considered a top adviser.
the White House. crews put wigs on English mas- ture horses while trying to fix biography on the Argentine ert Lucas and Murray for “If we really want to help
But Milei’s canine infatuation tiffs to make them resemble li- Argentina’s worst economic cri- leader called “El Loco.” Murray Rothbard. The fifth is him so that his government suc-
has raised eyebrows as people ons instead of using wild fe- sis in a generation. “What’s that In the 2018 television inter- named Conan. cessfully defeats inflation and
try to figure out what makes lines. got to do with anything?” he re- view, Milei said Conan was the Fitting all five into his small, lowers poverty, we have no
the fiery political outsider tick— “I have English mastiffs and plied. “What’s the problem with only one not to betray him dur- Buenos Aires apartment wasn’t choice but to try to speak with
as he attempts to tackle the clearly if I put a wig on each of me taking care of my dogs?” ing a difficult spell, along with easy. To make room, Milei his dog,” wrote humorist Ale-
world’s highest inflation. them I would have five lions,” Milei’s first dog was an Eng- his younger sister Karina Milei, knocked down his kitchen wall. jandro Borensztein. “Obviously,
“It’s weird,” said David said Milei, also known to Argen- lish mastiff named for “Conan now secretary-general of the The pups tore up his furniture. speaking with Conan won’t be
González, a 29-year-old in tines as “The Wig” because of the Barbarian.” “The love of my president’s office. One bit his arm while he was easy.”
Buenos Aires. “I treat my dogs his exuberant hair. “Five lions life,” he once said. After being fired from a job, trying to break up a fight with —Silvina Frydlewsky
well, but they sleep outside. of pure love.” Milei, a 53-year-old who has Milei, an economist, said he another clone. contributed to this article.
PERSONAL JOURNAL.
© 2024 Dow Jones & Company. All Rights Reserved. THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. Tuesday, February 27, 2024 | A9
Is It Ever OK to Have
BY ANN-MARIE ALCÁNTARA time. And if employees do end up
Y
taking a meeting outside of work-
our calendar is full of ing hours, she tells them to leave
meetings. There are early or arrive later the next day.
An 8 a.m. Meeting?
weekly check-ins, one- Joey Hodges, a chief executive
on-ones, hybrid plan- of a marketing and communica-
ning calls, the meeting tions agency, normally takes 8
before the meeting and a.m. meetings at least three days a
the meeting after the meeting. One week. Hodges, who is based in San
gathering inflames passions like no Francisco, sees it as a reality of
other: the 8 a.m. meeting.
Employees want flexibility; employers focus on the business needs working with global cli-
Whether an early-morn- ents while living on the
ing meeting is a must-do West Coast.
or sign of management “I developed the early-
overreach depends on your riser mentality, because
feelings about work-life so much had already hap-
boundaries, and some- pened by the time I woke
times, your rung on the up” out West, Hodges
corporate ladder. says. While he makes him-
Early-morning work self available at 8 a.m., he
hours are a hallmark of the doesn’t expect everyone
finance and healthcare in- on his team to log on
dustries as well as educa- early.
tion, and a standby of Hodges’s company lets
high-powered executives. staff work remotely, so an
Proponents of 8 a.m. con- 8 a.m. meeting doesn’t al-
fabs say they’re useful for ways mean showing up at
coordinating global teams the office.
across time zones. Others “I think if we were still
say they disrupt personal living in a world where
time and school drop-offs, you were required to get
and can throw off the rest on public transit and
of the day by upsetting travel an hour to get to
their normal routines. work and spend eight or
The reshaping of work nine hours at work and
and life wrought by the then an hour home,” he
pandemic—plus a rising says, “we’d probably have
generation of professionals a little bit less flexibility
who are more comfortable from the team.”
than previous generations
voicing their boundaries—
has intensified the debate. ‘It’s just
Jake Rudy, a human-re- about respect’
sources specialist in Min- Making an 8 a.m. meeting
neapolis, says 8 a.m. meet- can mean finding backup
ings give him sleep stress. options for school drop-
Rudy, whose workdays nor- offs, or rescheduling a
mally begin at 9 a.m., finds workout.
he doesn’t sleep as well Natalie Marshall—who
when he knows he has to is known online as Corpo-
get up earlier than usual. rate Natalie and is the co-
“If I have to push my- host of the podcast that
self to an 8 o’clock meet- inadvertently started this
ing, I really had better debate—says she some-
have a good reason for be- times had to take early
ing there,” says Rudy, 36 meetings when she
years old. worked at the consulting
A clip from the busi- firm Deloitte and the cy-
ness comedy podcast “De- bersecurity firm Palo Alto
moted” that recently made Networks. Now 26, she
the rounds on TikTok has owns her own content and
unleashed a wave of com- business-strategy com-
mentary about meeting pany. She and her employ-
times. One of the ees take 8 a.m. meetings if
hosts read a lis- clients require them and
tener email about then end their days early
FROM TOP: ELENA SCOTTI/THE WALL STREET JOURNAL, ISTOCK (2); CHRIS LENHART; CASSIDY HOLMES
a Gen Z em- Chris Lenhart meetings outside his normal work- Philadelphia designates the same when they can.
ployee missing blocks time on his ing hours. It usually works. working hours for all employees—9 “The corporate world is shift-
an 8 a.m. meet- calendar so Lenhart, 38, says he doesn’t a.m. to 5:30 p.m.—and discourages ing—employers have to offer more
ing because of a colleagues don’t mind the occasional off-hours them from sending nonurgent flexibility,” she says, adding that
workout class. schedule meetings meeting, though he’ll sometimes emails between 8 p.m. and 8 a.m., ultimately, the debate is about
The conversa- outside his regular ask for a new time if the meeting says Laura Emanuel, the firm’s whether employees and employers
tion went viral, working hours. is too early or late. managing director. Most employees have shared expectations.
with various tweets “People have always been un- are in the same time zone, but Brie Burnham says companies
sharing the clip reach- derstanding about that because their clients might not be. shouldn’t get unrestricted access
ing more than 29 million an early meeting has to hap- they in turn have their own life,” If there’s ever a need to have to workers’ days. For the 38-year-
views. On TikTok, those sharing pen, managers should notify peo- he says. an early or late meeting, old freelance graphic designer
and debating the now-deleted ple well in advance, she says, and Last year, 43% of Emanuel asks ahead of based in Bend, Ore., those bound-
video led to more than 250,000 acknowledge that it’s an unavoid- meetings logged by aries can be particularly vital:
likes, and subsequent discussion able necessity. the scheduling au- Anything that spills over its allot-
garnered millions of views. “Companies have to be very in- tomation com- Natalie Marshall ted time can encroach on another
“If the norm has been set that tentional about what conditions pany Calendly believes the early- client’s schedule, not just her per-
the workday is 9 to 5, then I don’t they set,” Hagen adds. occurred be- meeting debate sonal life.
think you can all of a sudden say, tween 2 p.m. boils down to “It’s about communication and
‘But on this day we’re going to do ‘Early-riser mentality’ and 6 p.m. Just whether the it’s about it being a mutual agree-
an 8 o’clock meeting,’” says Lorna Chris Lenhart, a senior user-expe- 3% of meetings employee and ment and it’s just about respect,”
Hagen, a managing partner of Cul- rience designer in Chicago, blocks occurred between employer have the Burnham says. “That allows us to
ture Playbook Partners, a busi- time on his calendar to prevent 8 a.m. and 9 a.m. same shared have a better conversation about
ness-process improvement firm. If colleagues from adding him to Red Thread PR in expectations. ‘Hey when are you available?’”
Why Cashiers, Economists Hate $100 Bills Earlier this month, he withdrew
100 $100s to purchase a car through
Facebook Marketplace.
The bank teller was
shocked at why he needed
BY OYIN ADEDOYIN $100 bill,” said Sage Handley, 23. the cash and asked what
Handley, who works as a market- he did for a living, said
R
ayza Sison went to a flea mar- ing and research assistant in College Jenkins, who works in
ket in New York this month Station, Texas, found a $100 bill in leadership development.
with five $100 bills. One by an old makeup bag earlier this Cash is typically re-
one, vendors refused to take her month. She posted on TikTok about served for smaller pur-
money, saying they couldn’t make the embarrassment of spending it, chases. Customers spent
change or accepted only digital pay- one of many social-media posts $39 on average when
ments through Venmo or Zelle. mocking the awkwardness of paying paying with cash, com-
Determined to break the bills, the for a small item with a $100 bill. pared with $95 when
26-year-old senior program coordi- paying with credit cards,
nator tried using them at coffee No sale according to payment
shops and then her local fruit stand. In Midtown Manhattan, cashiers data from the Fed.
She was refused again. The bills are were on alert when a Wall Street The ease of hoarding
still in her wallet. Journal reporter tried to use $100 and hiding larger bills
“I had hoped cash would be more bills to pay for small items. Some suits them to criminal ac-
convenient, particularly at a flea held the bill up to the light to spot tivity, such as tax evasion,
market,” Sison said. “USA 100” embedded in it to confirm Rogoff said. He has advo-
The $100 bill is far and away the its authenticity. Others used a coun- cated that the govern-
most common U.S. paper currency, terfeit pen, which has ink that turns ment stop printing the
dwarfing even the $1 black when in contact high-denomination note.
bill. The number of with fake currency.
bills bearing Benjamin At a bookstore, a Benjamins
Franklin’s mug more Not everyone cashier yelled “check, with benefits
than doubled be- loves Benjamin. please” and an em- The $100 bill is far and away University economics professor. The annoyance of using the $100
tween 2012 and 2022, ployee appeared from the most common U.S. paper The Fed’s most recent order for bill can make people spend less,
faster growth than Fake bills and behind a tall stack of currency, dwarfing even the $1 bill. note printing follows the same trend said Helen Colby, an assistant pro-
any other denomina-
tion, according to the
ties to crime are books to run a $100
bill through a coun- bills, a staffer said.
as before the pandemic, the central
bank has said. The notes were or-
fessor of marketing at Indiana Uni-
versity’s Kelley School of Business.
most recent Federal concerns. terfeit bill detector Some 60% of all payments are dered primarily to replace those de- Research shows that college stu-
Reserve data. before completing a made with debit or credit cards, ac- stroyed in normal processing. dents are less willing to purchase
LANNA APISUKH FOR THE WALL STREET JOURNAL
For all its preva- transaction for $3 of cording to Federal Reserve data. One reason they have become so items when they are given a $100
lence, the $100 bill is children’s books. The Cash use dropped sharply during prevalent is that they enter circula- bill compared with five $20s.
more effective for storing money store had recently caught a cus- the pandemic in 2020, and it hasn’t tion far quicker than they leave. This phenomenon has been
than spending it. Even when cashiers tomer trying to use a fake $100. fully recovered. Today, cash is the They can last over a decade longer coined “the denomination effect,”
do accept the bills, they hold up At a nearby vegan restaurant, a third-most used payment method in than $1s and $5s, partly because where the form that money comes
checkout lines to verify they aren’t $100 bill was rejected as payment the U.S. by number of transactions. people are more likely to hold than in has an impact on a person’s de-
counterfeits. Economists have called for a $4.95 bottle of kombucha. While more than half of $100s are spend them. sire to spend it.
for slowing down the printing press, The store didn’t have enough cash held abroad, there were enough in The $100 bill still holds a cultural If you spend money on a credit
due to their use in illicit activity. in the register. Another customer the U.S. for every living American to cachet. Kelvin Jenkins, 34, who lives card, you get that same card back af-
“Everyone almost questions you had walked out that day because have 55 in 2022, according to calcu- in Benicia, Calif., said big bills “feel ter the transaction. Spending a $100
and your legitimacy for using a the restaurant wouldn’t accept the lations by Kenneth Rogoff, a Harvard like status symbols.” bill essentially destroys it, she said.
A10 | Tuesday, February 27, 2024 THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
PERSONAL JOURNAL.
BY ALYSSA LUKPAT
F
orget the annual perfor-
mance review. Get ready
for constant, never-end-
ing feedback.
For now, many em-
ployees have to wait a
year for feedback, often given in a
stiff and rushed meeting. Workers
aren’t always able to respond to
the evaluation or offer their own to
their boss. Even though many em-
ployers agree there are more effec-
tive ways to deliver feedback, the
system has largely stayed the same
while companies focus on bigger
priorities like growing revenue and
reducing costs, executives say.
But in the future, firms may
change their approach to get more
efficiency from their workers,
spearheaded by a new generation
of leaders who are already trying At a meeting in San Francisco,
to make their workplaces more teams at Fountain evaluate each
transparent. Companies are start- other, ranking for helpfulness.
ing to train employees on how to
give feedback to their peers and
managers. They are pausing meet- talent development at HubSpot, a
ings to share real-time critiques. marketing software company.
Increasingly, artificial intelligence To encourage “upward feed-
could evaluate workers’ emails back,” HubSpot offers an annual
and videoconference meetings to When Fountain’s engineering survey for direct reports to evalu-
give performance assessments. and customer success team re- ate their managers, McCullough
These leaders predict candid, cently scored each other, the suc- says. Bosses are encouraged to dis-
real-time assessments could be- cess team was rated an average of cuss their results with the team
come more relevant. This kind of six while the engineers received a and share what they plan to work
feedback could allow workers to four, Behr says. The success team, on going forward. That has allowed
lose the fear of retribution for which works with the company’s managers to grow as leaders.
speaking up about their peers’ clients, said the engineers were ne- McCullough herself also asks
work, and hear the good and the glecting to fix some small bugs in for regular feedback from her
bad more often, in turn giving ev- favor of more sweeping changes. team, saying, “what is one thing I
erybody the opportunity to make Now the engineers plan to dedicate could do better or differently to
changes year-round and become five days a month to nothing but support you?” She solicits this cri-
more productive. smaller bug fixes, Behr says. tique to model how she wants
them to ask for feedback, some-
Peer-to-peer Everyday feedback thing she predicts more bosses
At the startup Fountain, the com- Personalized feedback is a part of will do one day.
pany often hands out sticky notes the culture at e.l.f. Beauty. Employ- At San-Francisco based soft-
in the middle of meetings involving ees on their first day take the My- ware-maker Atlassian, an internal
two teams. Each group evaluates ers-Briggs Type Indicator, a person- tool built by the company helps
the other by scoring them from one ality test, so their co-workers know employees share feedback to their
to 10, ranking how helpful the other how they process information, says peers, bosses and direct reports.
team has been during their collabo- Tarang Amin, chairman and chief Each person’s name is attached to
ration, says Sean Behr, chief execu- executive. The makeup company the feedback so workers can fol-
tive of Fountain, which creates expects workers to regularly give criticism. Teams are expected to nated that conversation 70%.’” low up with them, says Erika
software to hire and manage retail, each other feedback, but discovered train each new hire on the com- Ferrazzi said he is also working Fisher, chief administrative and
grocery and delivery workers. they initially didn’t always feel pany’s constant-feedback model. with companies developing another legal officer at Atlassian.
A facilitator collects the scores comfortable doing so, he says. Amin says he’s noticed younger similar technology: AI that analyzes The tool forces them to get to
and shares them aloud before lead- “Often what we find is it is be- employees are more comfortable workers’ emails and prompts work- the point within a 500-character
ing a discussion about each team’s cause the people didn’t know each sharing feedback online through ers to pitch an idea they have re- limit, because feedback is most ef-
overall effectiveness, other well enough,” direct messages, but the company peatedly written down. fective when it is specific and ac-
Behr says. He added Amin says. “Before also encourages face-to-face At executive education com- tionable, Fisher says.
that teams are some- you do any work at feedback. pany Radical Candor, AI is being
times surprised to Younger leaders e.l.f., you have to get used in the form of a chatbot that Navigating the flood
get a low average aim to make to know your peers Tech advances helps workers rehearse giving dif- With the trend toward constant
score when they be- extremely well. I As companies shift away from tra- ficult feedback to each other. feedback, employees will need to
lieved they were do- workplaces want you to know ditional performance assessments, “There is less feeling of shame learn to maintain professionalism
ing a good job. their kids’ names. I artificial intelligence could have a of getting it wrong with a chatbot,” during honest conversations and
“It is a very eye-
more want you to know big role in candid feedback. says Kim Scott, executive coach interpret feedback with a dose of
opening process,” he transparent. what’s important to Some tech companies are al- and co-founder of Radical Candor. skepticism, say company leaders.
says. “When you them.” ready experimenting with AI soft- Workers might find out from the People will have to decide
show them five ver- Amin says he ware built into virtual meeting chatbot if the feedback they gave which critiques they agree with,
sus eight, immediate wanted to create a systems and videoconferencing, was constructive or biased, Scott says David Rogier, co-founder and
changes happen.” After the sticky- more transparent company culture says Keith Ferrazzi, chairman and added. Radical Candor is also using chief executive of MasterClass, an
note break, the meeting agenda of- when he first began leading the chief executive of Ferrazzi Green- the chatbot to train workers at online education platform. “Just
CAROLYN FONG FOR THE WALL STREET JOURNAL (3)
ten shifts based on what they just company in 2014 and prepared to light, which coaches teams and is other companies on feedback, and because somebody gives it to you
discussed. take it public. Oakland-based e.l.f. working with companies develop- help people at workshops role play doesn’t mean that you have to
The past decade’s environment trains its more than 300 employ- ing the software. how to offer critiques to a defen- take that as the truth or being
of lavish corporate growth and ees on how to give feedback by Such technology can offer pow- sive employee, says Scott. right,” he says.
hiring sprees is gone, says Behr. hosting workshops and offering erful insights to employees and At e.l.f. Beauty, chief executive
That means feedback will need to sessions with a performance coach managers on what they could do Amin says continuous feedback
help companies squeeze more effi- on retainer, he says. better during meetings and other Managers on makes his workers more engaged.
ciency out of their existing work- The company doesn’t conduct interactions, says Ferrazzi. the receiving end No employee has ever cited e.l.f.’s
force, he says. Fountain worked annual performance reviews but “I want my videoconferencing Managers are already starting to feedback culture as a reason for
with an executive coach to retool instead wants people to receive system to tell me at the end of that get feedback from their direct re- leaving the company, he says.
its feedback systems and improve feedback every day, so it hires meeting, ‘Keith, you cut off Jane ports, says Becky McCullough, vice “Over time,” he says, “it gets
employee productivity. workers that will be receptive to twice,’ ” he says, “or, ‘You domi- president of global recruiting and more and more natural.”
Chef Has
Neil Fak, a hammy handyman on three weeks and a cheap thermal
the series. That show has become “that I’ve been wearing for a week
one of the most-honored TV pro- and it smells like a hockey player.”
Dressing
racked up Emmys and Golden is the co-founder of Rosa Rugosa, a
Globes. Now it’s up for even more brand of Canadian-made workwear
trophies at this weekend’s Screen that includes $265 chore jackets
Actors Guild Awards. and $145 work pants. To accommo-
“I’m sitting at a table and, like, date men of his prodigious stature,
Meryl Streep is sitting in front of the brand’s sizes go up to 4XL for
ON TREND me, Emma Stone is sitting next to jacket and 52-inch waists for pants.
JACOB me and Quinta Brunson is coming When “The Bear” started pulling
GALLAGHER up and says hi,” Matheson, who in nominations, Matheson visited
lives in Fort Erie, Ontario, said of his Harry Rosen, a Toronto department
experience at the Golden Globes. store where he had several suits
“It’s crazy. I’m such a normal person. do the work and go back to my Matty Matheson, executive made. He didn’t work with a stylist.
M
atty Matheson will tell any- I ain’t trying to live in LA, I ain’t try- farm and live with my family.” producer on ’The Bear,’ is a fashion He trusted his instincts and occa-
one who asks that he’s far ing to live in New York. I like to go He may get to the red carpet standout on the awards circuit. sionally turned to his wife, Trish
more at home behind a sim- early, before all the real stars arrive, Spencer, for an outside opinion.
mering range than on a red carpet. but Matheson has made the most swerves. “A funky little shoe is my His zestiest purchase was an ox-
But this chef turned self-de- of his time in front of the cameras. biggest move,” he said in his bubbly blood double-breasted Harry Rosen
scribed “D-rate” star has become an To some, it’s not Ryan Gosling or Canadian lilt. That black tux at the suit that he wore to the Golden
improbable suit-wearing standout even Matheson’s Calvin-Klein-ad- Globes was accompanied by a pair Globes with patent leather Gucci
of this year’s awards circuit. starring co-star Jeremy Allen White of fisherman sandals, like some- Chelsea boots. Matheson had never
There he was at the Emmys look- who deserves the title of best thing a wrinkly paisano would wear before worn a double-breasted suit
FROM TOP: GOLDEN GLOBES 2024 VIA GETTY IMAGES; PAT OZOLS
ing like a tuxedoed Colonel Sanders dressed in Hollywood right now. It’s on the Amalfi coast. At the VF and was concerned it might not
with a string tie tucked under his this tattooed-to-the-fingernails, party, he skittered across the carpet work on him. “I was, like, am I
collar. To a Vanity Fair party in Janu- would-rather-sear-a-steak-than-sit- in snakeskin boots. gonna look like a flag wrapped
ary, he threw on a pinstriped suit through-an-acting-class chef. He has long had a potent taste for around a f–ing basketball?” The
with fat peak lapels that made him To put it in cooking terms, fashion, even if most of the industry look earned him mentions on best-
look like a jaunty hitman. At this Matheson’s fashion sense is a per- isn’t catering to men of his size. “As dressed lists days after.
weekend’s SAG Awards, televised on fectly-seasoned pot roast—nothing a 300-pound man, I only got a couple Matheson claimed to be tech-in-
Netflix, he plans to wear a crisp tux. too crazy, never dry, with a smidge options,” Matheson, who described ept, but did say when he looks on
“It’s never not humbling being in of spice. “I’m just looking for, like, his build as “like a baked potato with TikTok now, he finds that most vid-
rooms like that,” said Matheson, 42, what’s Jack Nicholson wearing in some toothpicks stuck in it.” eos about him now are about his
a Canadian chef, actor and former ’78,” said Matheson. “I always just Off the crimson carpets, clothes, not cooking. “I’m so proud
travel show host, who lately has look at all those old photos of ’70s Matheson is primarily a uniform to represent my little chubby chub-
had an only-in-Hollywood pivot to De Niro and Pacino on red carpets, I dresser. He favors Vans sneakers, bys out there,” said Matheson. “I am
fame thanks to his status as execu- think they are just phenomenal.” Carhartt pants and hole-sprung vin- straight up the best-dressed 300-
tive producer of FX’s high-pressure Shoes are where Matheson tage T-shirts. During our interview, pound man on the planet.”
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. Tuesday, February 27, 2024 | A11
ARTS IN REVIEW
MUSIC REVIEW | MARK RICHARDSON
A Spellbinding,
Sly Sound
Faye Webster distills her music to its essence
on her clever, expertly played fifth album
F
or the past five years or You” begins the set with a loping
so, the most notable and groove built around piano and Ms.
commercially successful Webster’s gently strummed guitar,
singer-songwriters in the and immediately establishes a
indie-rock realm have feeling of sturdiness and ease as it
generally been women. stretches on for over six minutes.
These artists, from the trio Boyge- The track’s length almost dares
nius to Mitski to Adrianne Lenker the audience to stick with it—the
of the band Big Thief, have the repetition of the chord progres-
sort of relatability that translates sion compounded by the brevity of
well to social-media fandom and her words, just a few lines re-
the compositional rigor to impress peated over and over—but the
older listeners, including Grammy music is earthy, effortless and
voters. Atlanta-based Faye Web- easy to get lost in.
ster writes and sings rootsy rock
tunes and comes from the same
generation as these artists, but the
more one listens to her music, the
more distinctive it seems.
Ms. Webster self-released her
first album in 2013, when she was
just 16 years old. She grew up in a
musical family steeped in folk and The Atlanta-based ery and processed to sound like it “I get lost in a song / Take a walk,
country, and her early work, based singer-songwriter’s new comes from a cyborg. His tone is a call my mom,” she sings, conveying
in those idioms, was accomplished album is ‘Underdressed delightful contrast to Ms. Web- just how much music-making dom-
but forgettable. With each new re- at the Symphony.’ ster’s voice, which throughout her inates her thoughts.
lease, her songwriting became work comes across as a kind of The sheer charm of that last
sharper. She absorbed phrasing weary pout, half-whispered and track gets to the heart of Ms.
and sly humor from hip-hop and ing a light and jazzy without vibrato. Here and there, Webster’s talent: She excels at
R&B—for a time, she was signed feel rich with ambiance. as on the brief “Feeling Good To- constructing compact hooks that
to the label Awful, founded by the This quality is en- day,” she processes it into a flut- tickle the brain’s pleasure centers,
rapper Father, who contributed a hanced by a lyrical solo tering warble, but it still keeps its which she repeats until the frag-
guest verse to her third LP, 2019’s from Wilco guitarist essential conversational character. ments lodge themselves in the lis-
“Atlanta Millionaires Club.” Her Nels Cline, who plays Ms. Webster writes wry and tener’s consciousness. Her ear for
songs covered familiar topics like during a false ending clever lines and her songs unfold in hypnotic miniatures has helped
heartbreak and self-doubt, but Ms. and then returns for a unusual ways, but her lyrics aren’t her music to become a sensation
Webster delivered these senti- The following “But Not Kiss” proper coda. “I used to be self con- necessarily meant to be scrutinized on TikTok, where a memorable 10-
ments with levity and never took adds gorgeous clouds of pedal- scious / Well really I still am / I’m on the page. Their meaning comes second fragment can become a
herself too seriously, unlike some steel guitar to the mix—a recur- just better at figuring out why,” in how she sings them and how driving force for mimetic expres-
of her peers. Her fifth album, “Un- ring element through all of Ms. Ms. Webster sings, as if she’s dis- they fit with the arrangements. On sion. But with “Underdressed at
derdressed at the Symphony” (Se- Webster’s music—as she sings covering what the song is about at the hypnotic cocktail-lounge ballad the Symphony,” an expertly played
cretly Canadian), out Friday, dis- from the perspective of someone the instant we’re listening to it. “eBay Purchase History,” she sug- and smartly arranged collection of
tills her music to its heady timid, afraid of wanting too much: “Lego Ring,” a slower cut with gests a glance at her online shop- songs that seems to fly by, Ms.
MICHAEL TYRONE DELANEY
essence. “I hope you’re okay but I won’t comparatively heavy guitar, fea- ping would help us know her bet- Webster has also mastered the
A major part of the record’s ap- ask / If you’re in a good place I tures guest vocals from superstar ter, while the closing “Tttttime” larger canvas.
peal is the locked-in sound of Ms. won’t mess with that.” rapper Lil Yachty. His most recent adopts a novel spelling to convey
Webster’s band, which slides eas- On “Wanna Quit All the Time,” work has veered in the direction the percussive consonants she adds Mr. Richardson is the Journal’s
ily among country rock, jazz, and the sigh of pedal steel frames a of bright, psychedelic rock, and his to the word on the song’s relent- rock and pop music critic. Follow
chamber pop. “Thinking About dancing Fender Rhodes line, lend- singing here is in that vein, quiv- lessly catchy earworm of a chorus. him on X @MarkRichardson.
(Apple TV+, March 1) from Mariusz Treliński, the elegantly lean and visually 32 Commit O N E R O OM Y M C A
British comedian Noel company’s first in almost rich.” even more the Tuscan March” F E T C H L U N A R P S I
composer S N A K E P I T O D E L L
Fielding stars in this rollick- three decades. Yannick resolutely to coast T A R R U T MA T U R E
ing series about the English Nézet-Séguin conducts and For additional Arts Calendar a strategy 59 Rain heavily 5 Rain lightly O B T A I N F I S H B OWL
outlaw whose horse-thieving soprano Lise Davidsen head- listings visit wsj.com. Write P L A N T S E S P A R I A
and riding abilities were the lines as the heroine Leonora. to brian.kelly@wsj.com. ▶ Solve this puzzle online and discuss it at WSJ.com/Puzzles. S E N D S D O S I S S O
A12 | Tuesday, February 27, 2024 THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
SPORTS
We need to talk about JASON GAY
BY ANDREW BEATON
AND LOUISE RADNOFSKY Golf’s Hottest Young Star Vanished. other surgery, this time to repair a
ruptured Achilles tendon.
He hasn’t competed profession-
IT’S MORE THAN A DECADE now
since Anthony Kim disappeared
from professional golf.
Now He’s Finally Coming Back. ally since.
Over the following 12 years,
Kim became golf’s great enigma.
The former PGA Tour super- He made only rare public appear-
nova, who exploded into stardom ances, and whenever he was spot-
with his booming drives and a ted it invariably led to rampant
bunch of wins in his early 20s, speculation about a possible re-
hasn’t competed in a pro tourna- turn. In 2015, in his first interview
ment since 2012. And the longer in years, he said he’d had a half
he has been absent from golf, the dozen surgeries over the previous
more Kim has been mythologized. years and hadn’t played a full
His abrupt departure made him round of golf in 18 months.
the game’s enduring mystery, and Fans didn’t give up hope. When
created a new pastime for golf in- Kim appeared in an Instagram
siders: whispering about the possi- post with his longtime coach cap-
bility that he might one day return tioned “2021 is going to be spe-
to the game—or why he would cial,” it was another sign he could
never step into a tee box as a pro be on his way back.
again. The return didn’t materialize.
Now Kim is poised to make his But in Kim’s time away from
long-anticipated comeback, and he the game, the sport and its eco-
has picked somewhere far from nomics have changed radically.
the PGA Tour spotlight to emerge Saudi Arabia’s Public Investment
from the shadows: Saudi Arabia. Fund began pumping billions into
Kim, now 38 years old, is set to the game when it launched LIV in
compete this week in his first pro- 2022. Facing a new competitor,
fessional event since 2012 at LIV the Tour also had to up its prize
Golf Jeddah, according to people money and now has received an
familiar with the matter. That investment from a high-profile col-
makes him the latest splashy addi- lective of investors that promises
tion for the Saudi-backed circuit, to further line players’ pockets.
which wooed Masters champion In addition to the lucrative
Jon Rahm away from the PGA prize funds it offers to small, no-
Tour to bolster its lineup before cut fields, LIV has also offered
the season. many of its top players huge ap-
While Rahm and other A-list pearance fees. That means it may
golfers poached by LIV brought a be possible for Kim to cash in big
rush of prestige to the upstart cir- even if he struggles.
cuit, Kim brings something com- Anthony Kim is set to compete this week in his first professional event since 2012 at LIV Golf Jeddah. Regardless of where Kim has
pletely different, but perhaps chosen to play, his presence will
equally tantalizing: a guaranteed Fargo Championship, he was just 2008 season by tying for third in this day. The next April, he won be the biggest element of intrigue.
sighting of golf’s equivalent of the 22 years old and the youngest the Tour Championship, he shot his third PGA Tour event before In a way, Kim may ultimately re-
Yeti. winner on the Tour in years. His up to No. 6 in the world rankings the age of 25. semble other LIV additions whose
Fittingly, there’s a huge amount victory also set a new tournament and no longer looked like just an- But just as quickly as he as- name recognition often outpaces
of uncertainty about what exactly record by three shots—besting the other gifted up and comer. He cended, Kim started to fade their actual competitive strength
that will look like. After spending previous mark set by another looked like one of the best golfers away—almost before anyone real- at this point in their careers. Phil
so long away from the game, Kim’s young hotshot named Tiger on the planet. ized it. An operation on his thumb Mickelson, for instance, is one of
return will finally settle one of the Woods. caused him to miss a big chunk of the world’s most popular golfers,
sport’s most enduring questions: “I’m a little bit numb right the 2010 season. It was viewed at though at 53 years old he’s clearly
Is he still any good at golf? now, but that walk up 18 was the the time as a temporary fix to get past his prime.
There was a time when abso- best feeling in my entire life, and Kim’s abrupt departure him back for the Ryder Cup at the It’s now been 16 years since
lutely nobody would have doubted I’ll never forget that feeling. I had made him the game’s end of that year, but he didn’t end Mickelson and Kim were playing
the answer to that. Shortly after chills going up and down my up making the team. alongside one another as partners
the California-born golfer turned spine,” Kim said after the win. “I enduring mystery. The next year, his form only during the pairs events at the
pro in 2006, he emerged as one of want to re-create that as many got worse. In 2011, he made just 14 2008 Ryder Cup.
the brightest young talents in the times as possible now.” cuts in 26 appearances and wound “I love playing with this guy,”
JOSEPH NAIR/ASSOCIATED PRESS
sport. As a rookie, he notched four The world of golf expected that up with only two top-10 finishes. Mickelson said then. “It was fun
top-10s on the PGA Tour and fin- Kim would have no trouble doing Even though he didn’t continue To start 2012, he made only two for me to get that youthful exuber-
ished tied for 20th at his first ma- that. The kid who sported an over- winning at the same clip, Kim con- cuts in 10 starts. When he bowed ance.”
jor, the 2007 U.S. Open. sized belt buckle with his initials tinued to impress. In the second out early from the Wells Fargo, it Then, Mickelson was already
When he won his first profes- “AK” notched his second career round of the 2009 Masters, he set was the third straight tournament one of the older guys around at 38
sional event the next year, at victory just a couple months after a single-round record for the most at which he had been forced to years old. That happens to be the
what’s now known as the Wells his first. When he finished the birdies (11), which still stands to withdraw. He soon underwent an- same age Kim is right now.
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. Tuesday, February 27, 2024 | A13
OPINION
Who’s the RINO Now? BOOKSHELF | By Ian Brunskill
At a campaign
rally this year,
wealthy resident of Manhat-
tan than an aspiring Republi-
ered for the American people.
From tax cuts to deregulation
commentators, who detest Mr.
Trump, miss this because they
War Crimes and
Remembrance
Donald Trump can nominee for president. to solid conservative appoin- can’t believe anyone who un-
attacked Nikki In 2016, his challenge was tees to the federal bench, it derstands the issue could vote
Haley with a to persuade conservative vot- was an agenda rooted in clas- for him. In today’s GOP, the
term that has ers he was a genuine Republi- sic Republicanism. The part voters aren’t so much looking
become a fea- can, and he worked hard at it. that was most unique to Mr. at the policies they want and
MAIN
ture of his He became a pro-life cham- Trump—hostility to trade then choosing their candidate.
STREET
2024 cam- pion. He successfully courted deals, to multilateral security Because they trust Mr. Trump,
Out of the Darkness
By William
paign for evangelical Christians, by no agreements, to entitlement re- they defer to him on what Re- By Frank Trentmann
McGurn
president. means a natural fit. He form—not so much. publican policy should be and Knopf, 816 pages, $50
“Here in changed his language on the who is a RINO.
W
New Hampshire,” he told the Second Amendment. Nikki Haley is the RINO of hen in 1957 the city of Nuremberg erected a
crowd, “Nikki Haley has made Most important was what Trump has redefined the moment, because of her memorial to the victims of Allied bombing in
an unholy alliance with RI- he did when rival Sen. Ted wealthy donors and the Dem- World War II, it was decided to incorporate some
NOs, Never Trumpers, [and] Cruz suggested that he’d the term to mean ocrats and independent voters stones from the rubble of the city’s main synagogue,
Americans for No Prosperity.” nominate his sister, Judge someone who isn’t who are crossing over in the destroyed not by enemy bombs but by the Nazis in 1938. A
Ms. Haley isn’t the only Maryanne Trump Barry, to primaries to vote for her. Yet plaque explaining this historical detail might have given
one the former president has the Supreme Court. Barry loyal enough to him. it’s hard to identify a policy the monument a double resonance. Instead, Frank
called a “Republican in Name was a Clinton appointee to she stands for that isn’t out of Trentmann recounts, “the information was put inside the
Only.” “The real Ron is a the Third U.S. Circuit Court the Republican playbook. foundation stone. The fate of the Jews was literally buried
RINO Globalist,” he said of Appeals whom Mr. Cruz It’s plain to all that most of Still, a Monmouth Univer- in a monument to German victims.”
about Florida Gov. Ron De- described as a “radical pro- President Trump’s greatest sity Poll before the primary “Out of the Darkness: The Germans, 1942–2022” teems
Santis. “I don’t need any ad- abortion extremist.” Mr. successes came from working found South Carolinians with telling vignettes. Its 800 scholarly pages are never
vice from RINO Kayleigh Trump responded by having with the party’s congressional trusted Mr. Trump more than dull. It examines how, in coming to terms with their Nazi
McEnany on Fox,” he said Leonard Leo of the Federalist leaders to push Republican Ms. Haley on immigration, the past, modern Germans defined themselves. In the words of
about his own former press Society come up with what priorities. Mr. Trump himself economy, foreign policy and the country’s former president Joachim Gauck: “There is
secretary. Right before Vice conservatives regarded as a has drawn the opposite con- abortion—and by wide mar- no German identity without Auschwitz.”
President Mike Pence certi- dream-team list of jurists. Mr. clusion. Not unlike Louis XIV, gins. Talk to anti-Haley Re- Mr. Trentmann, however,
fied the Electoral College Trump said he would pick his who supposedly looked at publicans and the most com- has little time for the popu-
vote count in January 2021, nominees from the list. France and said, “L’État, c’est mon reason they give is “I lar view that this reckoning
Mr. Trump warned him of In short, in 2016 Mr. Trump moi,” when Mr. Trump looks don’t trust her.” with history turned German
giving in to “the RINOs and understood that if he wasn’t at the Republican Party he So who’s the RINO now? In sinners steadily into saints, a
the stupid people.” to fizzle out like so many pop- sees himself. 2016, Mr. Trump had to prove nation of moral crusaders
The insult dates from the ulists before him, he would Take Ukraine, perhaps the he wasn’t a RINO by embrac- eager to make amends. As the
1990s, when it meant a Repub- have to tether his movement sharpest area of dispute be- ing the GOP agenda. In 2020, clumsy ambiguities of
lican who was squishy on con- to a recognizable Republican tween Mr. Trump and tradi- thanks to Mr. Trump, Republi- Nuremberg’s memorial sug-
servative issues. Now it is Party agenda. That was also tional Republicanism. Before can priorities now include po- gest, the moral remaking of
shorthand for any Republican behind his choice of Mr. Mr. Trump ran for office, Re- sitions that once would have Germany is a complicated tale.
the former president deems in- Pence, a GOP governor and publicans were pressuring been regarded as selling out. It’s a tale that Mr.
sufficiently loyal personally. former congressman with a President Obama to deliver le- These include protectionism Trentmann is well placed to
The irony is that many Re- sterling conservative reputa- thal aid to Kyiv. Now Mr. for preferred industries, a re- tell. Born in Hamburg, he has
publicans originally regarded tion that reassured many Trump says he’ll solve the treat from overseas alliances taught and studied history in
Mr. Trump as a RINO. He was skeptics. They were further Russian-Ukraine war in 24 and hands off entitlements. Britain and the U.S. for almost
from deep-blue New York, reassured when Maureen Sca- hours. His voters trust him, In the process, the word 40 years. He brings to his
had donated to and supported lia, widow of the late great even if they regard the 24- RINO has lost any link to Re- challenging subject both the sympathy of a native German
Democrats before settling on justice, placed a Trump sign hour bit as typical Trump ex- publican policy. All it really and the detachment of an outsider.
the GOP, and on issues from on her lawn. aggeration for effect, so they means today is someone Mr. He takes as his starting point not the familiar zero hour
abortion to guns expressed Once in office, the Trump- demand neither details nor a Trump doesn’t like. of 1945 but the dark days of 1942, when Germans, he says,
positions more typical of a Pence administration deliv- debate. Most mainstream Write to mcgurn@wsj.com. began the painful process of redefining themselves. With
military setbacks on the Eastern Front and relentless
Allied bombing raids at home, some Germans wondered
Germany Should Have Listened to Trump for the first time what it was all for and where it might
end. To ask those questions was to confront their own
complicity. The Nazis ruled by consent as well as coercion.
The lower The news in manufacturing is It isn’t all doom and gloom. tive opposition parties have a For millions of Germans, the Third Reich “was not an
house of Ger- little better. This month the The outlook for the service blocking minority in Parlia- external stranglehold on their otherwise good selves. . . .
many’s Parlia- widely followed HCOB Ger- sector is brighter than for ment’s upper house. They were part of it.”
ment voted to man Flash Composite Pur- manufacturing, and as the This is not where Germans Mr. Trentmann shows how so many men and women
legalize the chasing Managers’ Index fell Journal reported last week, thought they would be. Six- became perpetrators or supporters of genocide by moral
recreational to 46.1, the eighth month in a the Ifo Institute’s business-cli- teen months ago, I visited sleight of hand, deluding themselves that they were acting
use of canna- row that the index has mate index improved slightly Berlin and heard from a ethically no matter what they did. Evidence comes from
GLOBAL
bis last week. pointed to decreasing eco- this month. The best that can stream of government offi- the diaries and letters of ordinary Germans. Among them
VIEW
It was a timely nomic activity. be said for the outlook? “The cials, think tankers and econo- is Reinhold Reichardt, who volunteered as an officer cadet
By Walter
move. Ger- Energy prices are a partic- German economy is stabilizing mists that everything was just before his 18th birthday in 1943.
Russell Mead
many’s leader- ular sore spot. The chemical at a low level,” according to working fine. Russia was fail- As he fought in Bosnia and Moravia, the young army
ship class is giant BASF announced €1 bil- Ifo’s president. ing in Ukraine. The energy officer knew that (as he wrote in his diary) he was
going to need all the mellow it lion in spending cuts in its transition would boost Ger- “surrounded by repulsive cruelty, badness, betrayal and
can find in a world that isn’t German operations, blaming a man competitiveness and em- cowardice.” He knew prisoners were shot and villages
going Germany’s way. mix of weak demand in the He was right about ployment. Germany’s Mittel- burned down. Yet, Mr. Trentmann shows, he “managed to
Russian advances in German market and “structur- stand would handle anything separate his own heroic war from the atrocities around
Ukraine and American paraly- ally higher energy prices.” Berlin’s self-defense China could throw at it. him.” In his educated mind, fed on a toxic diet of high
sis over the next aid package Enormous U.S. subsidies un- and risky energy Under the circumstances, German culture, romantic nationalism and heroic
are reinforcing the reality that der the so-called Inflation Re- it’s no surprise that antiestab- militarism, he was fighting a personal war of destiny,
Germany needs to defend it- duction Act are leading Ger- dependence on Russia. lishment parties are growing “leading men into the inferno but giving them a chance to
self but lacks the power to do man companies to look across in Germany. The far right Al- hold onto their moral justification.” He viewed himself,
so. So are developments in the the Atlantic. ternative for Germany (AfD) Mr. Trentmann says, as “a pure, noble knight.” The Nazis
Red Sea, where German manu- Chinese competition is an- Meanwhile, Germany’s dys- currently has more support were “marginal figures” in Reichardt’s war. “His moral
facturers must cope with ship- other massive worry. China functional three-party coali- than any of the governing par- vision was solipsistic.” He wasn’t alone in this.
ping delays as the Biden ad- long ago passed Germany as tion government is paralyzed ties, with one recent poll Solipsism survived the devastation of defeat. Many
ministration fails to keep the the world’s largest car pro- by internal struggles. The showing the AfD at 19%, the Germans saw themselves as victims; the other victims—
vital waterway clear. ducer. Increasingly, especially largest party in the coalition, Social Democrats at 14%, the their victims—could be overlooked. Division of the
Forget the 2% of gross do- in electric vehicles, it is chal- Chancellor Olaf Scholz’s So- Greens at 13%, and the Free country into communist East and capitalist West com-
mestic product that Germany lenging Germany as both a cial Democratic Party (SPD), Democrats at 4%. pounded the sense of victimhood.
has repeatedly promised and low-cost and high-quality man- is deeply divided over foreign The most bitter pill of all
failed to spend on defense. ufacturer. Beijing aims to mar- policy, with many nostalgic for Germany’s establishment
Defense Minister Boris Pisto- ginalize German capital goods for good relations with Russia may be the realization that The postwar reckoning in Germany focused on
rius shocked many observers and automobile companies in and allergic to military on the most important issues its own suffering and its own guilt. Pride in not
this month when he said that China while Chinese exporters spending. The SPD also wants facing Germany, Donald
in the new world situation, challenge German dominance Biden-like government spend- Trump was right where they being proud turned easily to self-satisfaction.
Germany may have to spend in world markets. ing initiatives to revive the were wrong. Getting in bed
as much as 3.5% of GDP for With the associations rep- German industrial machine with Vladimir Putin for
defense. resenting the small and me- and expand social benefits. cheap energy was both fool- The communist German Democratic Republic defined
The economic news is also dium-size Mittelstand firms The Greens, the next-largest ish and deeply disloyal to the itself as a new land built on the triumph of antifascism
grim. Last year Germany’s that make up the heart of the party, are by German stan- West. German defense policy over the Third Reich. Its founding citizens were Nazism’s
GDP shrank 0.3%, and last German economy warning in dards foreign-policy hawks was self-defeating and dan- enemies and victims, not responsible for crimes against
week the government slashed a rare joint open letter about but continue to press for a gerous. China wasn’t a reli- the Jews. The Federal Republic found its identity in
2024 growth estimates to a Germany’s loss of competi- rapid energy transition that able partner. continuity, as the legitimate democratic successor to the
pitiful 0.2%. Economists ex- tiveness, Economy Minister drives up costs for business “Ich bin ein Berliner,” was Reich. This status ultimately meant assuming the German
pect negative growth during Robert Habeck isn’t mincing and consumers. The third President John F. Kennedy’s nation’s guilt and paying for it. “Morality,” Mr.
the first quarter of 2024, words. The economy is in party in the coalition, the message to Germany. If Don- Trentmann argues, “took a major turn.” Private guilt gave
placing the country in reces- “rough waters.” The “compet- Free Democrats, wants to ald Trump returns to the way to public liability. The reckoning with past sins
sion. The outlook for housing itiveness of Germany as an hold the line on government White House, his message will became “a source of civic pride.”
is bleak, with business confi- industrial location” is in spending. As if this weren’t likely be “Das habe ich gleich Mr. Trentmann hails the Germans’ “moral renewal” but
dence reaching all-time lows. doubt. enough trouble, the conserva- gesagt,” or “I told you so.” notes that it was essentially introspective, whether it
focused on their own suffering or their own guilt.
Germans’ “pride in not being proud” turned easily to self-
The Day Our Tesla Deflated satisfaction. In this view, moral tensions and
contradictions—a complex interplay of idealism and self-
interest, guilt and liability, civic responsibility and
By Rikka Fountain a blown tire meant a brief de- car was still under warranty, brief side adventure. collective shame—have made Germany the nation it is
lay: Using the jack all cars had, but Tesla provided towing only, The supply chain had other today. Moral thinking—a desire to be good—has shaped
W
hen we planned our my father would quickly swap for which we had better cover- ideas. The next morning, a and colored not just German attitudes but German policy,
winter-break road the bad tire for the spare all age through our auto service. misinformed driver delivered from debt to immigration, from energy to defense.
trip, hoping to show cars had. Replacements were The tow truck’s arrival, three our tire to Medford, Ore., four As Germany thrived through five decades after the war,
our son colleges in Northern never a problem for our 1967 hours later, presented another hours away. the social, political and economic benefits of this focus on
California, we painstakingly Chevrolet Bel Air. problem: The cab couldn’t le- The tire store owner called moral reckoning seemed clear. Capture the moral high
penciled out the charging sta- gally hold all four of us. every shop he knew, then ones ground, and the heights of prosperity were within reach.
tions for our Tesla Model 3. Uber? I found no willing he didn’t. My husband found a It’s a tempting view. Four years ago, the veteran British
We left confident that we’d We mapped out all the drivers, and the spotty cell re- Tesla tire-swap program—un- journalist John Kampfner published an unlikely bestseller
averted the obvious pitfalls ception further thwarted my available until the following called “Why the Germans Do It Better.” He believed that
awaiting an electric car on re- charging stations, but hope. It was 9 miles to the week, after our kids’ classes Germany “has established a new paradigm for stability
mote highways. the car didn’t come nearest town, Weaverville, Calif. resumed. that equivalent countries, such as the US, France and the
It was a beautiful drive— “If we get pulled over, ask Just as I was perusing the UK, are for different reasons struggling to achieve. . . .
until the flat tire. with a spare tire. the highway patrol for a ride,” want ads and pricing local Germany is Europe’s best hope in this era of nationalism,
We’d considered using our the tow-truck driver directed, apartments, we scored. A spe- anti-enlightenment and fear.”
clunky, gasoline-powered SUV as my son eased his 170 cialty store 45 miles away in Today, with the German economy struggling, the far
for this rural trek. On a previ- But our high-performance pounds onto my lap. Redding could get the tire by right on the rise, and tough questions to answer on
ous trip, elevation gain unex- Tesla uses high-performance The tire wasn’t patchable. the next morning. foreign policy, asylum and energy supply, Mr. Trentmann
pectedly drained the Tesla’s tires. As we soon learned, those The only repair shop in town This time, it happened. We is more cautious, though not without hope. He concludes
battery, leaving me stranded tires can be days away outside had nothing that fit. After sev- had to skip the visit to Chico his vast, engrossing history with a caveat. Germany in the
for four hours at a remote a major population center. eral calls, the owner located State, but we made it back to past 80 years has mastered many challenges. It has, he
scout camp’s RV charger while Our car had neither a jack one for delivery the next Southern California in time for thinks, “accumulated formidable moral capital.” Now is
the car built enough power to nor a spare. We could have morning. school Monday morning. not the time to squander it. “Remembrance of the past
squeak to the nearest charging bought the car with a full-size We checked into a motel, We’ll try again over spring cannot avoid responsibility in the present. After decades
station. Yet this time, facing replacement, but that would then wandered down the break. This time, we’ll fly. of knowing what they are against—‘never again’ Hitler
mostly winding and wintry have left no room for luggage highway to a charming sa- and Auschwitz—Germans need to figure out what they
roads, we opted for the Tesla’s in the trunk. loon. Over pool, cocktails and Ms. Fountain is an attorney are for.”
superior maneuverability. My husband texted franti- excellent burgers, I reassured at Charlton Weeks LLP in
On my childhood road trips, cally with Tesla support. The my family that this was a Palmdale, Calif. Mr. Brunskill is a senior editor at the Times of London.
A14 | Tuesday, February 27, 2024 THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
OPINION
REVIEW & OUTLOOK PUBLISHER’S ANNUAL LETTER
T
he war in Ukraine has entered its third from U.S. arsenals. That would hamstring the
year, and the most crucial front for Kyiv U.S. effort to arm Ukraine with the urgency re- ties are at The Wall Street Journal, a rapid proliferation of generative AI, the
visit to our headquarters will take away Journal will persevere to cover the big-
may be in the U.S. House of Representa- quired by Russia’s advances.
any doubt: Facing our reception area is gest issues of our time—including many
tives. A bipartisan group of The bill also excludes bil- a huge collage of Journal front pages— stories and surprises yet to come our
lawmakers has rolled out a A bipartisan group lions in loans and grants for one for each day that our colleague Evan way—with the trusted and unbiased re-
fresh attempt at a compro- offers an alternative bill Ukraine, Israel and Pacific Gershkovich has been imprisoned un- porting you all expect from us, both here
mise bill to send military aid partners to purchase U.S. mili- justly by the cruel regime in Moscow. and abroad. Indeed, the Journal’s sweep-
to Ukraine, and Speaker Mike to force a floor vote. tary equipment. This is a mis- Above the collage there is one simple ing coverage of the wars in Ukraine and
Johnson can’t duck this test of take. Another provision worth message: I stand with Evan. Israel and Gaza continues unabated, in-
his leadership and beliefs. restoring is the Senate’s re- Turn to the left and down the hall- cluding a gripping story examining how
Reps. Brian Fitzpatrick (R., Pa.), Jared quirement that the Biden Administration artic- way, you’ll see a massive picture of Evan Kyiv’s forces have thwarted Russian of-
Golden (D., Maine), Don Bacon (R., Neb.) and ulate a strategy in Ukraine. House Republicans on a screen that previously was used to fensives and a detailed look at Israel’s
others have introduced the Defending Borders, have complained for two years that the Biden display key digital reader data to the struggles to destroy Hamas’s complex
newsroom below it. On your way down network of tunnels. Most recently, the
Defending Democracies Act that combines bor- Team has no plan. Here’s an opportunity to
that hallway, you’ll Journal has produced thoughtful cover-
der security with weapons to allies. Among force a change. pass our legal team age about the death of Alexei Navalny
other border-control measures, the bill stipu- But the House bill is far preferable to con- that has been work- and what it means for those who oppose
lates that migrants coming over the southern signing Ukraine to defeat, and Mr. Fitzpatrick ing around the clock Russia’s authoritarian regime.
border stay in Mexico while their asylum claims and his colleagues deserve credit for attempt- on Evan’s release. The Journal’s Opinion pages, mean-
are assessed. This is a version of Donald ing to overcome the blockade by the GOP’s iso- Turn to the right and while, warned against the dangers of iso-
Trump’s “remain in Mexico” policy. lationist wing at the urging of Donald Trump. you’ll see a small lationism and advocated for free mar-
Those provisions will send some Democrats Most Members would support aid for Ukraine conference room kets, free speech and free press. “The
running from the bill, so lawmakers will need if it reaches the floor—our sources say perhaps that doubles as the world is more dangerous than it has been
substantial GOP support for its provisions pro- two-thirds. war room for pivotal in decades, since at least the 1970s and
team meetings fo- perhaps the 1930s, and the American po-
viding military aid for Ukraine. To that end the Speaker Johnson will have to reckon with
cused on Evan’s litical class isn’t meeting the challenge,”
drafters focused their bill on providing lethal this reality sooner or later, and bringing up this plight. said Opinion Editor Paul Gigot. “Our job
aid—weapons and ammo—to Ukraine, Israel bill or something else on his prerogative is bet- Almar Latour
Switch floors and is to inform readers about the risks, no
and the Pacific. ter than the alternatives. If he doesn’t, Republi- you’ll find signs for him everywhere— matter how unwelcome the message, and
The bill includes roughly $47 billion for cans may join Democrats in signing a discharge alongside countless colleagues up and offer solutions for restoring U.S. military
Ukraine priorities, down from about $60 billion petition, which allows 218 Members to go down the ranks at the Journal, Dow deterrence and broad-based economic
in the bill that passed the Senate this month. around a Speaker to bring a measure to the Jones, News Corp and beyond, each do- prosperity.”
The House lawmakers excluded the Senate’s floor. That would make Mr. Johnson look weak ing their part in fighting for his freedom We will also persevere as new technol-
$7.8 billion in government budget aid to Kyiv, and probably wouldn’t help him with his isola- until he returns home. ogy changes the world. Not only will we
which Ukraine’s critics portray as paying sala- tionist wing in any case. If there is one word that defines The cover how this profound moment affects
ries for bureaucrats. Europe has been picking Ukraine’s recent retreat from the city of Av- Wall Street Journal right now, it is your lives, but the Journal and Dow Jones
perseverance. Perseverance in our are also embracing generative AI—insist-
up more of this tab in any case. diivka shows that Kyiv is slowly losing territory,
fight for Evan, and perseverance to de- ing on our intellectual-property rights
The bill from the backbenchers includes such and don’t rule out a Russian military break- liver you, our readers, trusted news while simultaneously harnessing the
essential needs as refilling U.S. weapons arse- through as the House dawdles. Meanwhile, the and information. power of this new technology to help you
nals; expanding production of munitions; fund- murder of opposition politician Alexei Navalny In this annual report to readers, we access our news and information via new
ing U.S. military operations in the Red Sea; and in an arctic gulag is a reminder of the brutal na- want to express our gratitude to you for products in time to come. Just as we are
spending $3 billion to help America build more ture of Vladimir Putin’s regime. turning to the Journal during these in- committed to producing high-quality
submarines. The measure would spend $4 bil- The Ukraine vote is shaping up as the most creasingly complex times. You have shown journalism, we will also make certain the
lion refilling Israel’s stocks of air defense inter- consequential for U.S. interests and the defense that, despite the ever-evolving economics Journal is meeting you, our readers,
ceptors, a critical need if Iran orders Hezbollah of Europe since the decision to deploy interme- of our industry, the thirst for trusted, ac- wherever you are today—on the phone,
in Lebanon to launch its missiles. diate-range nuclear missiles in the 1980s. Mr. curate and nonpartisan journalism is tablet, desktop, in print—and wherever
One oddity is that the bill doesn’t appear to Johnson and House leaders owe the Members greater than ever. We are grateful to see you will be tomorrow. As ever, your feed-
this trend reflected in our own business as back is essential in this endeavor as we
increase what’s called Presidential Drawdown the chance to vote their conscience rather than
demand for the Journal, its sister publica- fashion the products of today and in the
Authority, which allows the Commander in using a procedural blockade. Credit to the back- tions and all of Dow Jones continues to go years ahead.
Chief to hand over weapons to Ukraine quickly benchers for keeping the pressure on. up. In addition, Dow Jones receives tre-
mendous ongoing support from News
As our reporter Evan
New York’s Gerrymander Hijacking Corp, including Executive Chairman
Lachlan Murdoch, Chairman Emeritus Ru-
pert Murdoch and Chief Executive Robert
Gershkovich perseveres
through his unjust
D
emocrats love to denounce gerryman- Unsatisfied with fairness, Democrats went to Thomson, which, among other factors, has
ders, but watch what they actually do. court again, saying the replacement map was allowed for further expansions through incarceration in Russia, we
The New York Legislature on Monday good for one election only. They won. acquisitions.
voted down a U.S. House map Back to the bipartisan com- Led by Editor in Chief Emma Tucker, will persevere to free him.
who celebrates her one-year anniversary
approved by the state’s inde- Albany kills a bipartisan mission. In a 9-1 vote recently, this month, the Journal’s reporting
pendent redistricting commis- map to try to wring out itratifiedapproved a map that largely stands in sharp contrast to what has be- Perseverance also marks the one story
sion. Be suspicious of what’s the status quo, with come a prevailing pattern in the face of everyone at the Journal and Dow Jones
coming next, since Democrats more political gains. some tweaks that made it shocking events: speculation, cynicism thinks about every single day: the fight to
hope another gerrymandering slightly more favorable to and half-facts, bolstered by incessant rep- bring Evan back to our newsroom and
cycle will help them seize the Democrats. “This vote is ulti- etition on dopamine-geared social media. back to his family, whose unimaginable
House Speaker’s gavel in November. mately a victory for the commission process Instead, the Journal is sharpening its fo- strength is an inspiration as we together
This is the second time in as many years that and for democratic—small ‘d’ democratic—par- cus and going deeper to serve the ulti- advocate for his release.
New York lawmakers have thumbed their noses ticipation in the state of New York,” said Ken mate business reader: you. It’s appalling to think that Evan has
at voters. In 2014 the electorate amended the Jenkins, the body’s Democratic chairman. “I am “In a year in which more than 4 bil- been imprisoned for nearly 11 months,
lion people will be heading to polls locked away for doing journalism that
state constitution to ban partisan gerrymander- very proud of my colleagues and their ability
across the globe—not least here in the sheds light on one of the world’s most-
ing and set up a bipartisan redistricting com- to come together in a spirit of compromise to U.S.—it’s more important than ever for isolated countries. As Evan perseveres
mission. In its debut two years ago, the commis- work to deliver this plan.” the Journal to deliver distinctive, through his unjust incarceration, we will
sion deadlocked and offered competing maps. But the Democratic leader in the House, New trusted, revelatory reporting that helps persevere to free him and we will con-
Instead the Legislature decided to draw its own York’s own Rep. Hakeem Jeffries, doesn’t want to make sense of the world,” said Ms. tinue onward in our mission, gathering,
plan, giving Democrats an advantage in 22 of compromise. He wants to evict GOP Speaker Tucker, whose superb newsroom leader- distilling and reporting the news fairly,
the state’s 26 seats, or 85%. Mike Johnson from that big Capitol office, so ship includes advocating night and day thoroughly and impartially.
This was a partisan gerrymander so obvious he can pass progressive legislation for all 50 for Evan’s release and galvanizing her After all, attaining a true understand-
that the state judiciary couldn’t ignore it, and states. Given the slender Republican House ma- team for the year ahead. “We will con- ing of facts takes perseverance. It also
the plan was struck down. The 2022 elections jority, flipping the House in November might tinue with our relentless coverage of the requires patience, resources, dedication
took place under a map drawn by a special mas- not take much. By our deadline we hadn’t seen corporate landscape and financial mar- and sufficient time to verify and trian-
kets with journalism that gives readers gulate disparate fragments of informa-
ter, and the result was competitive. Democrats Albany’s replacement map, but given how
the information and insights they need tion. This is essential work. And it can
won about 54% of the raw votes for House can- bloody-minded Democrats have been through- to cut through the clutter and make only happen with your support. For that,
didates, which translated into 15 seats, or 58%. out, expect the worst. sound decisions on business and in their we are filled with gratitude.
daily lives.” ALMAR LATOUR
The FTC’s Gift to Walmart As we face two wars, geopolitical ten- Publisher
U
.S. antitrust policy is a politicized mess, which represents workers at both companies.
and for the latest example look at the The union often plays the supermarkets against LETTERS TO THE EDITOR
Federal Trade Commission’s vote Mon- each other in collective-bargaining to obtain
day to challenge supermarket bigger wage and benefit in-
Kroger’s $24.6 billion acquisi- Lina Khan won’t let two creases, as the FTC notes.
tion of Albertsons. It’s a giant grocery chains merge to “Today, UFCW and other Political Scientists vs. the American People
gift to Amazon, Walmart and unions leverage the fact that In “Biden Rewrites ‘An American With Covid on the decline and four
other grocery retailers. get more competitive. Kroger and Albertsons are Tragedy’” (op-ed, Feb. 21), Arthur Her- years of Mr. Trump and press crazi-
It’s hard to think of a more separate and competing man describes Joe Biden as the most ness in the rear-view mirror, the table
competitive business than companies,” the agency discredited president since Richard was set for Mr. Biden. But instead of
groceries. Traditional supermarkets have been stresses. The deal “would immediately erase Nixon. So far, Americans agree. Only pulling the country together, he has
squeezed from all directions. Most Americans aggressive competition for workers, threat- 38% approve of Mr. Biden’s job perfor- pandered to the left, led with identity
shop and buy food and household products ening the ability of employees to secure mance, while 59% disapprove. politics and left the country even
from a variety of sources, including dollar higher wages, better benefits, and improved One group that disagrees with the more divided.
“tragedy” assessment is the Presiden- Next, he will leave us with no good
stores, farmers markets, big-box retailers and working conditions.”
tial Greatness Project, which surveys options. This is his biggest failure.
online delivery services. FTC Chair Lina Khan rewrote the FTC’s long- relevant members of the American Po- Election turnout will set a new low,
Competition has driven hundreds of super- standing merger guidelines to consider how litical Science Association and calls it- and history will judge Mr. Biden
market stores to close in recent years. The deals would affect workers and labor-market self “the foremost organization of so- harshly. He will have earned it.
Kroger-Albertsons merger is intended to make competition. This is a radical departure from cial science experts in presidential RICHARD J. BRENNEN
the two more competitive by increasing their modern antitrust law, which emphasizes con- politics.” According to this august Naples, Fla.
leverage with suppliers and making their supply sumer welfare. Monopolies that are shielded group, Mr. Biden is already the 14th
chains more efficient. from competition are usually good for workers, greatest U.S. president (out of 45),
Democrats on the FTC disagree. They voted even if they hurt consumers. ahead of Ronald Reagan but still trail- Pepper ...
ing Barack Obama, who placed 7th.
3-0 to challenge the deal on the simplistic In any case, Kroger and Albertsons also com-
Dead last was Donald Trump, below
And Salt
premise that it would eliminate head-to-head pete for workers with other grocery retailers
even William Henry Harrison, who THE WALL STREET JOURNAL
competition between the two retailers and lead and businesses, including restaurants and ware-
died a month after his inauguration.
to higher prices. They’re still living in the 1970s houses. Supermarket margins are thin, and The experts must be appalled that
when there were fewer grocery options and in- higher labor costs are one reason Kroger and average Americans are so clueless
dustry consolidation was viewed by antitrust Albertsons have become less competitive about the greatness of Mr. Biden. Their
regulators as inherently bad. against non-unionized grocers. criteria must be much too complex for
“The loss of competition will also lead to Supermarket workers also increasingly com- Americans like me to comprehend.
lower quality products and services, while also pete with self check-out, in case Ms. Khan hasn’t DANA DAVIS
narrowing consumers’ choices for where to visited a store lately. If Kroger and Albertsons St. Augustine, Fla.
shop for groceries,” the FTC says. This ignores are blocked from merging, they will look to
that the merger would increase competition shave costs by using more automation. Unprof- Reading Mr. Herman, I want to
stamp on the floor and shout “Hear,
with Aldi, Dollar General, Trader Joe’s, Costco, itable stores will be closed. How does this bene-
Hear!” But my enthusiasm ebbs when
Target, Walmart, Amazon, and numerous oth- fit workers? I remember who is waiting in the
ers that have been taking market share from su- None of this matters to the Khan FTC, which wings to take Mr. Biden’s place. That
permarket chains. wants to send a message to CEOs not even to is the real American tragedy: We can’t
The main reason the FTC moved to block the try mergers lest they risk a long legal battle. If do any better than Biden vs. Trump.
deal appears to be opposition from the United consumers pay higher prices or workers lose STAN CONNELL
Food and Commercial Workers (UFCW) union, their jobs, so be it. Charlotte, N.C. “I have very close family ties.”
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. Tuesday, February 27, 2024 | A15
OPINION
P
confronting anticompetitive abuses. mance. A 2020 House Judiciary ket—such as smartwatches or smart the security and privacy of its eco-
oliticians in both parties For many years, competitors have Committee investigation cited Ap- homes—the regulators’ concern is system. But there is reason to think
broadly agree that a hand- credibly complained that Apple has ple’s treatment of Tile Inc., a com- that Apple makes hardware and soft- this security-privacy mantra is fre-
ful of tech companies hold used its dominant market position pany that makes hardware and soft- ware choices that optimize the in- quently used as a pretext when the
too much power. As attor- and heavy-handed tactics to cripple ware enabling users to track lost teroperability of its own new-market real purpose is hobbling competitors.
ney general in 2019, I competition. items. Tile told the committee that devices with Apple’s ecosystem, In 2018, after launching its own
launched an antitrust review of the More than half of the mobile de- in 2019 Apple made changes to iOS while degrading the interoperability parental-control application, Screen
problem. The Justice Department vices in the U.S. are Apple devices 13 that increased the difficulty of us- of incumbent devices. The Justice Time, Apple purged similar third-
filed suit the following year against using its proprietary iOS operating ing the Tile app and devices, while Department has reportedly been party apps from its App Store. In-
Google for monopolizing internet system. Apple has made its App at the same time rolling out and pre- studying why iPhones work better ternal Apple communications pro-
search and search advertising. Un- Store the only way for software de- installing its own competing Find with Apple smartwatches than with posed advancing the “narrative”
der Attorney General Merrick Gar- velopers to reach this vast market, My app. other smartwatches. that this was done for privacy rea-
land the department has pressed and it uses technical and contractual Smartwatches illustrate how im- sons. According to a House report,
forward with the Google case and restrictions to box out competitors. pairing interoperability can harm when the Justice Department an-
the Big Tech review and is now re- Apple does this in two ways: by pro- The Justice Department competition. Apple smartwatches, nounced it was investigating the
portedly preparing to file a major hibiting iOS users from downloading standing alone, would have no obvi- matter, Apple started reinstating
antitrust suit against Apple. This is software from any other source, and reportedly plans a major ous competitive advantage over the apps and found less-restrictive
a good development. by making developers agree not to lawsuit against the firm— those made by Garmin. But if Garmin ways of satisfying supposed privacy
Big Tech firms like Apple require distribute their apps through any watches don’t work as smoothly with concerns.
rigorous antitrust scrutiny. Today, other store as a condition of getting with good reason. the ever-present iPhone, Apple’s Apple uses an arsenal of tactics
virtually all aspects of life—finance, access to the tools necessary to product would gain an advantage. In whose anticompetitive effects, taken
commerce, entertainment, social re- make iOS-compatible apps. essence, Apple would be using its individually, may operate subtly but,
lations, news and public discourse— A significant part of Apple’s busi- Another example of Apple’s anti- power in the smartphone market as taken cumulatively, work powerfully
are conducted over a handful of digi- ness now is distributing other com- competitive behavior is how it gives leverage to capture a new market to suppress competition. To make
tal platforms. Giant tech companies panies’ applications to iOS users. preference to Apple Pay over other with a less compelling product. headway, a Justice Department chal-
have the power to snuff out chal- The App Store’s dominance allows mobile payment services. Apple in- Nor is the interoperability issue lenge must address these tactics
lenges to their dominance; collect Apple to take up to a 30% cut on stalls within its iPhones near field confined to rival devices. Two comprehensively and force Apple to
mountains of customers’ personal sales of paid apps, demand the same communication chips, or NFCs, so months ago, Apple blocked an An- demonstrate that the handicaps it in-
data, which they can exploit to ma- fee for subsequent “in-app” pur- the devices themselves can com- droid message application, Beeper flicts on rivals are essential to
nipulate users’ decisions and beliefs; chases, and insist that developers plete tap-to-pay transactions. The Mini, which allowed Android phones achieving legitimate security and
and control what we hear and read. not communicate with customers European Union has challenged Ap- to exchange secure and encrypted privacy requirements. The burden
This overwhelming economic and so- about less expensive ways to down- ple for allegedly handicapping ri- messages using Apple’s iPhone-only should be on Apple to prove that less
cial power is antithetical to the load their apps. This arrangement vals by denying the same NFC ac- iMessage service. restrictive alternatives don’t exist.
founding principles of our demo- limits competition and raises prices. cess to competing mobile payment There is little question that Apple
cratic republic. With surging sales of more than $89 services. incorporates some hardware and Mr. Barr is a co-founder of Torri-
While antitrust enforcement un- billion in 2023, the App Store by it- Apple has also long pursued a software design choices that make it don Law PLLC, a distinguished fel-
der President Biden, particularly at self would rank in the Fortune 100. strategy of weaving together an inte- difficult for customers to leave the low at the Hudson Institute and au-
the Federal Trade Commission, has Apple allegedly uses its control grated ecosystem of easily interoper- system and harder still for rivals to thor of the memoir “One Damn Thing
gone too far, the Justice Depart- over iOS and the App Store to im- able products and services. That is compete with any part of it. Apple After Another.” He served as U.S. at-
ment’s concerns about Apple are jus- pose technical limitations on com- unobjectionable, but when the com- typically claims that any anticompet- torney general, 1991-93 and 2019-20.
F
or a week following Hamas’s stroy the identity of the region, to than 4,000 of Eshkol’s 17,000 residents
Oct. 7 attack on Israel, the break the community,” Ms. Abraham are already back. She is particularly
stench of 300,000 rotting says. moved by the return of 50% of the re-
chickens rose from Kibbutz Alumim, Hamas terrorists damaged green- gion’s Thai workers. Some community
2 miles from the Gaza border. Three houses and barns, many beyond re- members visit on the weekends “just
coops were burned to the ground, but pair. They slashed crop nets and to smell their homes,” she says.
they weren’t the source of the smell. flooded orchards. They burned irriga- Today there are 250 milking cows
Terrorists had destroyed the auto- tion pipes and shot at fertigation sys- at Nahal Oz, though not as many as
mated food and water dispensers for tems. They destroyed the filtration before. Hamas killed 30 of them.
the remaining five structures housing system for the local reservoir. Soil Those that survived went unmilked
the flock, and after the attack no one compaction and pollution from Israeli for nine days. Many developed masti-
was around to tend to the chickens. tanks brought in to expel the terror- tis, a painful condition that contami-
The birds died of hunger and thirst, ists has also damaged roughly 10% of nated their milk and killed 70 of the
REGROW ISRAEL
Will Haley’s Voters Save the Day for Biden? Don’t Bet on It
H.W. Bush in 1992, Pat Buchanan the essential decency of Republi- you were governor less than a de- could be terminal to his campaign.
played the happy warrior long after cans they recently denounced as cade ago is unelectable. And there But the choice in November isn’t be-
it was clear he couldn’t win. Sen. right-wing extremists. But we can are grounds for skepticism that the tween the flawed Mr. Trump and
FREE Bernie Sanders kept a flickering expect to hear a lot more from Pres- apparent continuing resistance to some generic candidate. It’s between
EXPRESSION flame alive against Hillary Clinton ident Biden in coming months about Mr. Trump in the Republican pri- Mr. Trump and four more years of
By Gerard Baker through the summer of 2016. how the GOP is no longer the party mary renders him incapable of win- Joe Biden.
Each time, the contentious, ex- of good people like Ms. Haley. Still, ning in November. While Ms. Haley and the media
F
or hopeful Democrats, Nikki Ha- tended struggle contributed to the her Republican apostasy will end focus relentlessly—with reason—on
ley could be the latest in a long party’s eventual defeat in November. soon enough—probably after next Mr. Trump’s many significant char-
line of kamikaze candidates. Given this record, Ms Haley’s stated week’s 15 Super Tuesday primary Most of them will end up acter failings, polls indicate that vot-
The record of parties that endure intention to keep her campaign for contests. ers care more about the current ad-
a divisive primary fight after the the GOP nomination going following So the more salient question for backing Trump, especially ministration’s governing failings.
identity of their eventual presiden- her heavy defeat in South Carolina Republicans than any damage Ms. after almost four years According to the latest poll from
tial candidate has become obvious is at the weekend looks like good news Haley herself may inflict on Donald Harvard-Harris, on 10 of the most
an unhappy one. Sen. Ted Kennedy for Democrats, even as it is probably Trump is whether the one-third or of the alternative. important issues facing the country,
was repeatedly urged to drop his fatal for her long-term viability as a more of Republican primary voters Mr. Biden gets majority approval on
challenge to President Jimmy Carter leading Republican politician. who have so far withheld their sup- only one—his handling of the Covid
in 1980, but took his fight to the There are few more nauseatingly port from him augurs ill for the For one thing, the former presi- pandemic, hardly a topic of pressing
convention. After inflicting a couple familiar spectacles in politics than party in November. dent has been here before. He won concern in 2024.
of early blows on President George that of Democrats solemnly lauding In Iowa, New Hampshire and now less than half the votes when he se- Of the other nine issues on which
South Carolina, Mr. Trump failed to cured the party’s nomination in 2016 Mr. Biden is under water, for the
win a majority of the votes of inde- but still went on to pull off a narrow first time respondents cite immigra-
pendent voters and moderate Repub- win over Mrs. Clinton. In an admit- tion as the biggest challenge facing
PUBLISHED SINCE 1889 BY DOW JONES & COMPANY licans. In a close contest, if Mr. tedly much wider primary field, he the country, and they give the presi-
Lachlan Murdoch Trump can’t carry these voters in got only 45% of all votes cast in that dent the lowest approval rating of
Executive Chairman, News Corp November, his chances of success are year, and then as now it’s a mistake all, 35%, on the issue.
Rupert Murdoch Robert Thomson
Chairman Emeritus, News Corp Chief Executive Officer, News Corp vanishingly small. to think that those who didn’t vote “It’s been decades since any issue
Emma Tucker Almar Latour This is the one nagging point of for him in the primary wouldn’t rally but the economy has been the top is-
Editor in Chief Chief Executive Officer and Publisher significance in what is otherwise Ms. to the GOP candidate in the general sue affecting voters,” says Mark
Liz Harris, Managing Editor DOW JONES MANAGEMENT: Haley’s continuing exercise in futil- election. Penn, chief executive of Stagwell,
Charles Forelle, Deputy Editor in Chief Daniel Bernard, Chief Experience Officer; ity. On Saturday night, she again in- But more important, there is who runs the poll.
Elena Cherney, News; David Crow, Executive Editor; Mae M. Cheng, EVP, General Manager, Leadership;
Chip Cummins, Newswires; Andrew Dowell, Asia; David Cho, Barron’s Editor in Chief; Jason P. Conti, sisted that her showing reflected abundant reason to think that Mr. In World War II only a small num-
Taneth Evans, Associate Editor; Brent Jones, General Counsel, Chief Compliance Officer; trouble for a candidate who can’t Trump’s weakness with independent ber of kamikaze missions were suc-
Dianne DeSevo, Chief People Officer; Jared DiPalma,
Culture, Training & Outreach; Alex Martin, Print
Chief Financial Officer; Frank Filippo, Chief
win the general election. and moderate voters will be eclipsed cessful. Democrats may hope that
& Writing; Michael W. Miller, Features &
Transformation Officer; Artem Fishman, Chief “I’m an accountant,” she said. “I by his opponent’s weakness with the Ms. Haley’s campaign and the sup-
Weekend; Prabha Natarajan, Professional Products;
Bruce Orwall, Enterprise; Philana Patterson,
Technology Officer; David Martin, Chief Revenue know 40% is not 50%. But I also same voters in November. port it gets from voters who refuse
Officer, Business Intelligence; Dan Shar, EVP,
Audio; Amanda Wills, Video General Manager, Wealth & Investing; Ashok Sinha, know 40% is not some tiny group,” If the former president were run- to endorse the party’s inevitable
SVP, Head of Communications; Josh Stinchcomb, she said. “I don’t believe Donald ning against a candidate with a nominee is a zero fighter aimed
Paul A. Gigot
Editor of the Editorial Page
EVP & Chief Revenue Officer, WSJ | Barron’s Trump can beat Joe Biden.” strong governing record in a climate right at the engine room of the USS
Group; Sherry Weiss, Chief Marketing Officer
Gerard Baker, Editor at Large
EDITORIAL AND CORPORATE HEADQUARTERS:
It takes some chutzpah to say in which voters were even half-satis- Donald Trump. Don’t be surprised if
1211 Avenue of the Americas, New York, N.Y., 10036 that the man who has just beaten fied with the country’s condition, his this one falls harmlessly into the
Telephone 1-800-DOWJONES you by 20 points in the state where attenuated appeal to independents ocean.
A16 | Tuesday, February 27, 2024 * **** THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
WORLD NEWS
Ukrainian
Soldier Marks
Decade at War
Alen Dudnik has worried that waning support
from the U.S. is handing Rus-
been fighting the sia an advantage in ammuni-
Russians since he tion that is hard to counter.
But Dudnik says he is deter-
was 18 years old mined to keep fighting—so his
6-year-old son won’t have to.
BY JAMES MARSON Dudnik was born in a vil-
lage in southeastern Ukraine.
EMANUELE SATOLLI FOR THE WALL STREET JOURNAL
Participation is dwindling
1.0
in a Federal Reserve program
that has helped the U.S. gov- BY COLLIN EATON
ernment limit its borrowing 0.5 4
costs, a development that Chevron warned investors
many investors say presages Monday that Exxon Mobil and
higher interest rates and 0 China’s Cnooc are asserting
larger swings in the $26 tril- Feb. 2021 ’22 ’23 ’24 they have a right to pre-empt
lion Treasury market. the company’s bid for a stake
3
The overnight reverse re- in a prolific oil project off
purchase facility, known on Bank reserves as a share of total bank assets* Guyana, an emerging dispute
Wall Street as reverse repo, 20% that could derail Chevron’s
enables large financial firms megadeal for Hess.
such as money-market funds 18 Fed Markets Current Chevron said in a regula-
to briefly swap extra cash for starts disrupted, runoff 2 tory filing that Exxon and
high-quality securities on the runoff Fed intervenes begins Cnooc say they have the right
central bank’s balance sheet 16 to counter Chevron’s offer for
and pocket some interest. Hess’s stake in the Guyana
The Fed program has been 14 project, which Exxon operates
used heavily in recent years, 1 and is one of the largest oil
at one point hitting $2.5 tril- 12 finds in years. Chevron
lion of daily balances, but warned investors it may not
that number has shrunk 10 complete its purchase of Hess
steadily and recently fell be- “within the time frame the
low $500 billion. company anticipates or at all.”
8 0
Many analysts and portfolio Much of the value in Chev-
managers expect use of the 2017 ’18 ’19 ’20 ’21 ’22 ’23 ’24 2008 ’10 ’15 ’20 ’24 ron’s $53 billion all-stock ac-
program to continue to de- *Weekly data through Feb. 7 †Weekly data through Feb. 21 quisition of Hess proposed
cline, which they say is likely Sources: Federal Reserve (Overnight reverse repurchase transactions, bank reserves); Investment Company Institute (money-market funds) last year was tied to the
to constrain the functioning of smaller New York oil com-
an important shock absorber tility and a fresh rise in inter- night facility waiting to be de- economy. A committee that abled the government to keep pany’s 30% stake in an Exxon-
in the market for U.S. Trea- est rates in the market that ployed,” said Michael de Pass, advises the Treasury sug- long-term interest rates rela- led drilling consortium in
sury securities. The govern- underpins the global financial global head of rates trading at gested last fall that the heap tively low despite the quicken- Guyanese waters. The partner-
ment is facing higher interest system. Citadel Securities. of money-market fund cash ing drumbeat of U.S. debt is- ship has expanded oil produc-
costs as it attempts to fund a “It is undoubtedly easier Though obscure, reverse sitting at the Fed could fi- suance. tion far faster than most off-
growing deficit, and observers for the market to absorb bill repo has long been at the cen- nance a flood of short-term Sales of Treasury bills, shore oil projects and expects
say lower balances in the pro- supply if you have a large ter of the operation of the fi- bill issuance—an unusual shift which mature in a year or to pump over 1 million barrels
gram could mean higher vola- amount of cash in an over- nancial system and the U.S. that in recent months has en- Please turn to page B2 a day in coming years.
The development is a po-
tential blow to Chevron’s larg-
Investors Flock
est acquisition in years,
though it isn’t clear if Exxon
and Cnooc will make a coun-
teroffer. At this point, they are
Back to Biotech
only asserting it is their right
to do so.
Chevron spokesman Braden
Reddall said Chevron and Hess
RONEN ZVULUN/REUTERS
A Greenbaum, David.................B4 Musk, Elon...................................A8 member of the council of then Financial Services, after talk-
Altman, Sam..............................B4 Greenfield, Matthew...........B4 Nollen, Tim................................B10 Prince Charles’s Duchy of ing for years with his old
Amin, Tarang...........................A10 Guo, Sarah...................................B4 Olczak, Jacek............................B12
Gwinn, Blake..............................B2 Pass, Michael de.....................B1 Cornwall estate and as deputy friend David Rockefeller, the
Anderson, Richard.................B3
Arthur, Doug..............................B6 H R chairman of Rupert Murdoch’s scion of another wealthy fam-
B Healy, John.................................B11 Raghavan, Viswas..............B10 U.K. satellite broadcaster ily, about working together. In
Babej, Peter..............................B10
Huang, Jensen....................A1,B1 Read, Mark................................B10 BSkyB. He was close to former 1989, he backed an abortive
Barber, Jim Jr............................B3 K S U.S. Secretary of State Henry Rothschild & Sons, the family decades the Rothschilds be- $21 billion hostile bid by the
Bardon, Christiana.................B2 Krakowsky, Philippe...........B10 Sadoun, Arthur......................B10 Kissinger. bank in London, in 1963. came one of the world’s corporate raider James Gold-
Bondy, Brian...............................B4 L Sarma, Karthik........................B11 Lord Rothschild was born The Rothschild family trace wealthiest and most powerful smith for the company now
Boychuk, Jamie........................B3 Lacroix, Timothée..................B4 Saxe, Jordan................................B1 on April 29, 1936, in Berkshire, the origins of their name to a banking families, financing in- known as British American
Boyd, Eric......................................B4 Shah, Niraj.................................B12
Buffet, Warren.........................B4
Lample, Guillaume................B4 England. He attended Eton house in Frankfurt’s Jewish dustrialists, monarchs and Tobacco.
Lewis, Caroline.......................B10 Shaw, Alan...................................B3
Burns, Michael.......................B10 Lockhart, Michael...................B3 Silverman, Josh.....................B12 College before studying his- ghetto occupied by their 16th- governments. Rothschild was chairman of
C-G M-P Stagliano, Nancy.....................B2 tory at the University of Ox- century ancestors. A sign During the Napoleonic the U.K.’s National Gallery
Case, Tom......................................B1 V-Z ford. In 1961 he married Ser- hung outside of a red shield— Wars, the London branch from 1985 to 1991. He served
Maag, Peter.................................B1
Choi, Brian..................................B11 Meneret, David.......................B11 Vachhani, Aakar....................B10 ena Mary Dunn. They had zum roten Schild. smuggled gold across the Eng- for almost 30 years as chair-
Daniels, Mitchell Jr...............B3 Mensch, Arthur.........................B1 Weiner, Russell.........................B3 three daughters—Hannah, Two centuries later, Mayer lish Channel to finance the man of Yad Hanadiv, the fam-
Devnani, Nikhil.......................B12 Miles, Amy...................................B3 Wirth, Mike................................B11 Beth and Emily—and a son, Amschel Rothschild—Jacob’s Duke of Wellington’s troops. ily foundation that funded the
Ellison, Larry..............................A8 Minnihan, Erica Duignan Wren, John................................B10
Ferrazzi, Keith.........................A10 .............................................................B10 Yee, Michael................................B2
Nathaniel. His wife died in great, great, great, great In the late 1970s, Roth- building of the Israeli parlia-
Fraser, Jane..............................B10 Moore, Stephanie.................B11 Yeo, Danny................................B10 2019. grandfather—founded a bank schild clashed with his father, ment and supreme court in
Granet, Jason............................B2 Murdoch, Lachlan..................B6 Zuckerberg, Mark...................A8 Rothschild joined N.M. in Frankfurt. In the following Victor, and a cousin, Evelyn de Jerusalem.
Amid Overhaul
long-dated Treasurys by sell- of snafus in the multitrillion- funds, which now hold more
ing an unusually large amount dollar cash markets that can than $6 trillion in assets. Lim-
of bills, allaying market fears cascade into the broader fi- ited to highly rated short-term
Continued from page B1 that demand for U.S. debt was nancial system. Lehman investments such as Treasury
less, surged during the pan- waning. Brothers’ collapse in 2008, bills and repurchase transac-
demic and then again in 2023. Fed officials have viewed the Fed’s attempt at quantita- tions, money funds parked a
There is now nearly $6 trillion lower use of the reverse repo tive tightening in 2019 and chunk of those inflows at the BY SABELA OJEA after the company’s forecast
of T-bills in the market, up facility as a the onset of Fed. They now earn a 5.3% an- for travel reservations disap-
from less than $2 trillion at positive sign Covid-19 are all nualized rate overnight with Expedia is reducing its pointed the market.
the end of 2017. that excess top of mind. the safest counterparty global head count by 1,500 Expedia’s restructuring
That might seem like a cash is making Decline of the The Fed is ex- around. employees, or roughly 9%, as move follows the news of the
technical development, but it its way to more facility is seen pected to slow Blake Gwinn, RBC Capital part of its organizational and coming departure of Peter
is anything but for players in attractive op- the pace of Markets’ head of U.S. rates technological transformation. Kern, who has served as chief
the global bond market. All portunities in as a sign excess quantitative strategy, said he expects The online travel company executive since 2020, after the
this short-term debt will need the market. tightening this roughly $100 billion to $200 on Monday said it expects to company reported lower-than-
to be refinanced at higher Once reverse
cash is moving year so it can billion to remain in the Fed’s book pretax charges and cash expected gross bookings in the
rates at the same time the Fed repo has mostly elsewhere. watch for po- reverse repo facility over expenditures of $80 million to December quarter.
has been lifting benchmark in- drained, the tential strains. time. Should the Fed cut $100 million as a result of the On Feb. 8, the company
terest rates. While selling bills Fed expects the Not everyone rates, it will immediately be- cuts. posted a net profit of $132
allows the government to banking system thinks a gin paying less to reverse The company has already million, or 92 cents a share,
raise cash quickly, the bills to begin losing reserves. A smaller reverse repo cash pile repo investors. Having a started to notify employees af- from $177 million, or $1.11 a
soon come due, forcing diffi- bank uses reserves, a form of is much of an issue. source of overnight cash is fected by the restructuring share, a year earlier. Analysts
cult decisions on how to raise electronic cash, to manage “Bills can be a plug for the another plus. program. As of Dec. 31, Expe- polled by FactSet expected
funds again. transactions between itself, its government, as financing “The Treasury takes a very dia had 17,100 employees per-share earnings of $1.12.
Many bond investors say customers, other banks and needs move around based on long time horizon—they’re across more than 50 coun- Expedia’s gross bookings
the Treasury Department will the central bank. tax collections and spending thinking about how much it’ll tries. rose 6% to $21.67 billion in the
eventually have to come to While the central bank has needs,” said Jason Granet, cost to fund the government Last week, shares of com- quarter, but came below ana-
grips with how it plans to pay been trying to tighten bank- chief investment officer at over a 10- to 30-year period,” petitor Booking Holdings fell lysts’ estimates of $22 billion.
its bondholders over the long ing conditions to help cool BNY Mellon. “Even if you get a said Gwinn. “I don’t think
haul, as interest payments be- the economy and therefore recession that demands more they’re very concerned about
come one of the largest ex- inflation, money-market government spending, that’s losing demand for bills.”
BUSINESS NEWS
CLOCKWISE FROM TOP: GENE J. PUSKAR/AP; STEPHEN VOSS FOR THE WALL STREET JOURNAL; DAN KOECK FOR THE WALL STREET JOURNAL
BY LAUREN THOMAS
TECHNOLOGY WSJ.com/Tech
BYD Debuts
A $233,000
Sports Car
World’s largest EV seeking to capture more of the
high-end market even as EV
maker’s high-end sales slow globally and com-
Yangwang brand petitors in China trim prices to
attract consumers concerned
shows second model about the state of the economy.
BYD this month said it
BY SHERRY QIN plans to unveil several luxury
vehicles in 2024 and beyond.
BYD’s launch of a $233,000 A recent Normura research
sports car underscores the Chi- note said BYD guidance calls
nese electric-vehicle maker’s for 20% of revenue this year
ambitions to boost its market to come from luxury brands,
share across the buying spec- up from 12% in 2023.
trum, and its hopes that luxury BYD’s sales have been ris-
LI BO/XINHUA/ZUMA PRESS
models can lift its bottom line. ing as it rolls out new models
On Sunday the world’s larg- and cuts prices, helping it de-
est EV maker by sales rolled throne Tesla as the world’s
out the U9, its costliest model biggest EV maker in the final
yet and the second under its quarter of 2023. It has plans
premium Yangwang brand. to launch new models with
Warren Buffett-backed BYD potentially lower pricing un- Li Auto’s improvement in the latest quarter came despite a continuing price war in China with competitors. The Beijing-
targets deliveries for mid-2024. der the BYD brand this week. based automaker said it expects to deliver between 100,000 and 103,000 vehicles in the first quarter of 2024.
At a launch event, it demon- BYD’s stock has yet to ben-
BY JIAHUI HUANG utility vehicles and other cars second quarter of last year. It Li Auto quarterly revenue
nearly tripled from a year ago guided for revenue of 31.25 40 billion yuan 4Q 2023
Chinese electric-vehicle to 131,805 units. billion yuan to 32.19 billion
41.73B
maker Li Auto expects a se- Net profit was 5.66 billion yuan, down from the previous
quential drop in deliveries in yuan, up from 256.9 million quarter but up from a year
the first months of 2024, com- yuan a year ago and 2.82 bil- earlier. 30
ing after a blockbuster quarter lion yuan in the third quarter. Monday’s results also
in which sales and profit more The improvement came de- showed Li Auto’s first annual
than doubled during the tail spite a continuing price war in net profit, with a bottom line
end of 2023. China with competitors such of 11.70 billion yuan roundly 20
The Beijing-based company as Tesla, BYD, Nio and XPeng. beating expectations of 8.91
QILAI SHEN/BLOOMBERG NEWS
on Monday said its fourth- The company’s fourth-quarter yuan billion in a FactSet poll.
quarter revenue more than gross margin increased to Total revenue in 2023 more 10
doubled from a year earlier to 23.5% from 22% in the prior than doubled to 123.85 billion
41.73 billion yuan, or about quarter. yuan.
$5.8 billion, beating consensus Li Auto said it expects to Li Auto’s 2023 vehicle mar-
estimates for 40.20 billion deliver between 100,000 and gin came in at 21.5%, rising 0
yuan in a poll of analysts by 103,000 vehicles in the first from 19.1% a year earlier. Its 2021 ’22 ’23
BYD foresees beginning deliveries of the Lamborghini-esque, data provider FactSet. Deliver- quarter of 2024, which would 2023 capital expenditure was Note: 1 billion yuan = $139 million
two-door U9, its costliest model so far, in the middle of 2024. ies of Li Auto’s popular sport- be its lowest amount since the 6.51 billion yuan. Sources: S&P Capital IQ; the company
Millions to Challenges
cost “much more than” $50
million to $100 million.
In addition to Microsoft,
world’s understanding of scal-
ing laws than one of the people
who helped define them?” said
get there
Mistral also has teamed with Sarah Guo, an early investor in
and sold small stakes to other Mistral through her venture-
minutes faster?
force and Nvidia, maker of the 2022, Mensch said he was dis-
most powerful graphics pro- appointed that big, private AI
Continued from page B1 cessing units used to build AI labs started sharing less with
needed to pay for the electric- systems like Mistral’s. the wider research community.
ity those chips consume. Brave Software made a Once ChatGPT launched, there
Go inside the supercharged race between Mistral, named for a strong free, open-source model from was a race within Google to
Amazon, Target and Walmart to see how wind that blows from France, is Mistral the default to power its match it. Mensch said the team
each retail giant is competing to shave founded in part on the idea that web-browser chatbot, said he worked on went from 10
hours — even minutes — off deliveries. a lot of that money is wasted. Brian Bondy, Brave’s co- people to 30 and then 70.
With these companies investing in fast and Mensch has spent much of founder and chief technology “I think I left just before it
his life figuring out how to officer. He said Brave finds the got too bureaucratic for me,”
free shipping, we’ll unpack the different make AI and machine-learning quality comparable with pro- Mensch said. “I didn’t want to
strategies — and the challenges they will systems more efficient. Early prietary models, and Mistral’s build opaque technology from
face along the way. last year, he joined forces with open-source approach lets within big tech.”
co-founders Timothée Lacroix, Brave control the model locally. Mistral’s initial pitch docu-
WAT C H 32, and Guillaume Lample, 33, Eric Boyd, corporate vice ment to investors last spring
then at Meta Platforms’ artifi- president of Microsoft’s AI decried an “oligopoly shaping
SHIPPING WARS NOW
cial-intelligence lab in Paris. platform, said Mistral presents up” led by U.S. companies that
Together, they are betting a test of how far clever engi- sold proprietary models.
that their small team can out- neering can push AI systems. For Mensch and his co-
maneuver Silicon Valley titans Mensch attended some of founders, releasing their initial
by finding more-efficient ways France’s top schools for mathe- AI systems as open-source was
to build and deploy AI systems. matics and machine learning. A an important principle. It was
And they want to do it in part through-line has been trying to also a way to get noticed by de-
by giving away many of their make things more efficient. For velopers and potential clients
AI systems as open-source soft- his doctorate, he worked on eager for more control over the
ware. “We want to be the most scaling up software for analyz- AI they use. Mistral’s most-ad-
capital-efficient company in the ing 3-D brain images. vanced models, including the
world of AI,” Mensch said. Mensch joined the Google AI one unveiled Monday, aren’t
On Monday, Mistral unveiled unit then called DeepMind, available open source.
an AI model called Mistral where he worked on the team “We want to invent new
Large that Mensch said can per- building so-called large lan- things, new architectures,”
form some reasoning tasks com- guage models, the type of AI Mensch said, “and we still
parably with GPT-4, OpenAI’s system that would later power want to have something to sell
most-advanced language model, ChatGPT. By 2022, he was a lead extra to our customers.”
and Google’s new Gemini Ultra. author of a paper about a new
Mensch said his new model AI model, Chinchilla, that
cost less than €20 million, the changed the field’s understand- Watch a Video
equivalent of roughly $22 mil- ing of the relationship among Scan this code
lion, to train. By contrast, Ope- the size of an AI model, how to see how AI
©2024 Dow Jones & Co. Inc. All rights reserved. 3DJ8870
nAI Chief Executive Sam Alt- much data is used to build it is transforming
man said last year after the and how well it performs, air-traffic control
release of GPT-4 that training known as AI scaling laws. towers.
B6 | Tuesday, February 27, 2024 THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
BUSINESS NEWS
For Its Streaming Playbook, Fox News Nvidia Is Job applications between
September and February,
change from a year earlier
A Popular
Turns to Stars and Documentaries
175%
150
Employer 125
Semiconductor
Other
industries
BY ISABELLA SIMONETTI 100
Continued from page B1
On “The Five,” Fox News’s 2023, according to Handshake, 75
roundtable show, Jeanine Pirro an early-career jobs platform.
rips on President Biden and Being hired takes technical 50
urges Taylor Swift not to en- acumen. Among the roughly
25
dorse him. On Fox Nation, the 1,800 job openings listed by the
network’s streaming service, company are engineering roles 0
she raves about the views and in areas such as AI storage,
Internships Full-time
amenities of five-star hotels on deep learning and behavior jobs
“Life of Luxury With Judge planning for autonomous vehi- Source: Handshake
Jeanine.” cles with base pay that ranges
That contrast is all part of from $144,000 to $414,000. its dominance in AI.
the plan. Many jobs call for a Ph.D., and “I think the interest will
Fox is positioning the the company requires that grow even higher,” she said.
streaming service to comple- some applicants know multiple “It’s the uniqueness of the
DEEP IN THE HEART FILM/EVERETT COLLECTION
ment its flagship TV channel programming languages. work that they do.”
rather than be a replica of it. After four rounds of inter- People who have spent time
Fox Nation, which costs $5.99 a views in 2022, Himanshu with the company describe an
month, is veering away from Agrawal says he turned down intense but collaborative cul-
hard news and luring subscrib- an Nvidia offer that included ture with high expectations
ers with documentaries, series restricted stock units that av- even for early-career hires.
and comedy specials that ap- eraged about $150 a share. “It attracts the sort of peo-
peal to conservatives and fea- Though he has been happy as a ple who are humble, have hu-
ture Hollywood stars like Mat- software-development engi- mility, but also are almost like
thew McConaughey. neer at a competitor, the 23- rats in a maze,” said Debparna
Fox is taking a starkly dif- year-old said he can’t help but Pratiher, who worked in prod-
ferent approach from its rivals ‘Deep in the Heart,’ a series about Texas wildlife that is narrated by Matthew McConaughey. think about what he is missing. uct management at Nvidia for
as cable-news channels try to “I’m feeling a little bad that two years before co-founding
figure out the right business some news content, but of that.” about Yellowstone National I don’t have the stock in my software company Quest Labs
model to offset consumers in- doesn’t have feeds from major Fox said earlier this month Park featuring Kevin Costner, portfolio right now,” he said. AI. “Just like running around
creasingly cutting the cable TV cable-news channels. it is joining forces with Walt star of the show “Yellowstone”; looking for cheese, looking for
cord. CNN parent Warner Fox executives say the cable- Disney and Warner to launch a a series about the Boston Tea the next project, looking for the
Bros. Discovery launched a TV business is strong enough to new sports-centric streaming Party narrated by Rob Lowe; Small talent pool next way to jump on things.”
CNN-branded live news service continue powering revenue and bundle that will pool their live and a show about Revolutionary Some of the skills that Nvidia jobs come with
for its Max platform, while profit growth, but note the games. War battles hosted by “Frasier” Nvidia hires for are so niche perks, too. A new headquarters
MSNBC is making much of its company is set up to offer Fox Fox Corp. Chief Executive star Kelsey Grammer. that engineering veterans at includes a bar, and employees
TV lineup available on its par- News in a streaming form if Lachlan Murdoch told inves- Fox Nation bought “Deep in other semiconductor compa- have a take-what-you-like un-
ent’s Peacock service. that becomes necessary. “If tors the goal is to target “cord the Heart,” a series about nies can’t transfer in, said Da- limited vacation policy, plus
Fox doesn’t have a compara- there is a direct-to-consumer nevers,” people who have Texas wildlife that is narrated vid Stone, who runs MRL Con- two “free days” every quarter
ble all-encompassing subscrip- future for the linear channel, never had a traditional pay-TV by McConaughey and will de- sulting Group, which he said when the whole staff has the
tion-streaming service for its Fox Nation is a great place for it subscription. But the service but on the platform in April. has scouted new recruits for same time off to recharge.
news content. Tubi, its free to ultimately be,” said Jason could appeal to existing cable “It’s not just Hollywood,” Nvidia for the past six years.
streaming platform, offers ac- Klarman, Fox News’s chief digi- subscribers and hasten the de- Klarman said of Fox Nation’s Young professionals will be fo-
cess to entertainment and tal and marketing officer. “But cline of the traditional busi- programming choices. “It’s the cused on learning those spe- Boomerangs
sports programming, as well as again, there’s no plans for any ness, media executives said. Hollywood that Fox News cialized skills, “clamoring” to Working at Nvidia can be
The creation of this sports- viewers find aspirational and get in the door, he said. intense because of the pres-
streaming bundle raises the want to connect to.” So small is the available sure to make things work and
ADVERTISEMENT question of whether a similar There are some risks to the pool of talent for some roles deliver, said Aman Kishore, a
model could work for news— strategy of veering away from that the company will move a former senior software engi-
The Marketplace
To advertise: 800-366-3975 or WSJ.com/classifieds
something observers say is un-
likely to happen.
news.
CNN, under its previous
job elsewhere to fill it, accord-
ing to Stone. “They will not
neer who left to co-found soft-
ware company Mirage in 2022.
“The audiences are so frag- ownership, tried a similar deviate from their require- “It was a lot of responsibil-
mented,” said Doug Arthur, an strategy in 2022 with CNN+. ments,” he added. ity and a sense of urgency to
BANKRUPTCIES BUSINESS OPPORTUNITIES analyst at Huber Research. “An That $5.99-a-month service Candidates must be excited make things work and figure
audience that wants to watch mostly offered content like to innovate, “contribute to an things out and see how you can
Fox News does not want to “Jake Tapper’s Book Club” and agile environment and create move the needle,” said Kishore,
IN THE UNITED STATES BANKRUPTCY COURT
FOR THE SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS Physician Nashville Opportunity watch MSNBC and probably “Parental Guidance With An- a platform for others to do who was hired in 2020. He
HOUSTON DIVISION Physician to sell solely owned accredited the same for CNN.” derson Cooper” rather than a their life’s work,” a company added that the company has
In re CYPRESS CREEK § CASE NO.21-33733 Gyn Ambulatory Surgery Center, including Fox Nation parent Fox Corp. live feed to its highest-profile spokeswoman said, adding numerous boomerang employ-
EMERGENCY MEDICAL § very well established Gynecology practice
SERVICES ASSOCIATION § and Wall Street Journal parent programming. When new own- that Nvidia continues to grow ees, who leave and return be-
in Nashville Tennessee.
DEBTOR
§
§
CHAPTER 11
News Corp. ership came in, CNN+ was can- and hire as it expands in cause there are opportunities
§ The owner will stay to The platform is home to celed after it signed up 150,000 healthcare, automotive and to move around internally.
transition if desired.
LIQUIDATING TRUSTEE’S NOTICE OF BANKRUPTCY shows such as “Yellowstone subscribers in its first few other industries. Kishore was hired via a re-
CASE ANTICIPATED CLOSING Serious inquiries,
reply to. One-Fifty,” a documentary weeks. For college students, Nvidia ferral, which he said was typi-
This is notice of the following:
has now joined other big tech cal for the company, and in-
1. On November 18, 2021, Cypress Creek Emergency LWEB.4@me.com companies—many of which terview questions were highly
Medical Services Association (“CCEMS”) filed the
above-numbered chapter 11 bankruptcy case in Houston, have cut staff recently—as a specific. When he was in-
Texas.
2. On July 8, 2022, the Bankruptcy Court confirmed a Asset Business Sale most-wanted destination, pro- volved in hiring, Nvidia would
chapter 11 plan of liquidation.
3. Pursuant to the confirmed chapter 11 plan, J. Patrick Health Science & Medical fessors and career coaches usually wait no longer than
Magill became and remains the liquidating trustee of
Print & Digital Content say. It hired 40 Carnegie Mel- two weeks from first inter-
the CCEMS Trust ( “Trustee”).
4. Substantially all of the assets of CCEMS and the Distributor to Hospitals, Univ & Gov lon University graduates last viewing a candidate to making
CCEMS have been liquidated or abandoned.
5. Substantially all of the debts of CCEMS have been $25 mill plus revenues year, up from 12 in 2019. At a decision, he added.
paid. 34k sq ft warehouse NE location the University of Washington’s This week, Gary Fowler,
6. The Trustee estimates that the bankruptcy case of
CCEMS shall be closed within the next 30 days. kevin.ream@rittenhouse.com business school, students who has recruited in the semi-
DATED: February 23, 2024. quickly signed up for a two- conductor space for decades,
Respectfully submitted,
day tour of Bay Area compa- presented a job-seeking Nvidia
O’CONNORWECHSLER PLLC
By: ___/s/ Annie Catmull THEMARKETPLACE nies last year when the school candidate to one of his clients.
confirmed a Nvidia site visit. It couldn’t compete on pay,
Annie E. Catmull ADVERTISE TODAY Diana Marculescu, who and said the Nvidia employee
State Bar No. 00794932
aecatmull@o-w-law.com (800) 366-3975 leads the University of Texas would be crazy to leave, given
FOX NATION
MARKETS DIGEST
EQUITIES
Dow Jones Industrial Average S&P 500 Index Nasdaq Composite Index
Last Year ago Last Year ago Last Year ago
39069.23 t 62.30, or 0.16% Trailing P/E ratio 27.38 21.82 5069.53 t 19.27, or 0.38% Trailing P/E ratio * 22.85 17.82 15976.25 t 20.57, or 0.13% Trailing P/E ratio *† 34.12 24.61
High, low, open and close for each P/E estimate * 18.62 17.60 High, low, open and close for each P/E estimate * 21.25 17.92 High, low, open and close for each P/E estimate *† 30.65 24.02
trading day of the past three months. Dividend yield 1.80 2.11 trading day of the past three months. Dividend yield * 1.49 1.71 trading day of the past three months. Dividend yield *† 0.81 0.90
All-time high 39131.53, 02/23/24 All-time high 5088.80, 02/23/24 All-time high: 16057.44, 11/19/21
65-day moving average Session low 34000 4200 65-day moving average 13800
COMMODITIES wsj.com/market-data/commodities
Metal & Petroleum Futures Wheat (KC)-5,000 bu.; cents per bu. Australian Dollar (CME)-AUD 100,000; $ per AUD June 5157.75 5169.00 5137.50 5141.25 –21.25 71,167
March 569.50 585.50 t 561.50 583.75 15.00 14,034 March .6568 .6572 .6535 .6541 –.0029 201,555 Mini S&P Midcap 400 (CME)-$100 x index
Contract Open June .6589 .6589 .6554 .6559 –.0028 2,357 March 2865.90 2874.60 s 2850.90 2859.30 –3.80 38,689
Open High hi lo Low Settle Chg interest May 566.00 577.25 557.75 576.50 11.00 113,043
Cattle-Feeder (CME)-50,000 lbs.; cents per lb. Mexican Peso (CME)-MXN 500,000; $ per MXN June 2882.00 –5.10 3
Copper-High (CMX)-25,000 lbs.; $ per lb. March .05820 .05834 .05813 .05832 .00013 250,094 Mini Nasdaq 100 (CME)-$20 x index
March 252.725 254.900 s 250.925 253.050 –1.525 8,268
Feb 3.8400 3.8400 3.8240 3.8240 –0.0580 1,023 June .05740 .05751 .05732 .05750 .00013 1,362 March 17961.50 18059.50 17922.00 17977.00 –14.00 283,248
April 258.125 260.800 s 256.650 258.900 –1.075 16,155
May 3.8880 3.8880 3.8340 3.8345 –0.0660 105,056 Cattle-Live (CME)-40,000 lbs.; cents per lb. Euro (CME)-€125,000; $ per € June 18210.00 18298.25 18165.50 18215.75 –15.50 2,509
Gold (CMX)-100 troy oz.; $ per troy oz. March 1.0831 1.0869 1.0822 1.0856 .0023 696,780 Mini Russell 2000 (CME)-$50 x index
Feb 184.600 186.175 s 184.500 185.725 .125 1,688 March 2018.00 2036.70 2009.30 2032.20 11.70 509,216
Feb 2034.10 2035.40 2024.80 2028.50 –10.10 209 June 1.0870 1.0911 1.0864 1.0898 .0023 12,657
April 186.525 188.800 186.050 188.100 .200 127,269 June 2046.80 2059.20 2032.40 2055.10 12.00 2,283
March 2033.70 2036.30 2025.00 2029.10 –10.30 3,177 Hogs-Lean (CME)-40,000 lbs.; cents per lb. Mini Russell 1000 (CME)-$50 x index
April 2044.20 2046.80 2034.10 2038.90 –10.50 321,380 April 86.825 87.050 85.525 86.275 –.925 99,190 Index Futures
March 2786.10 2799.10 2782.50 2785.30 –11.10 6,184
June 2064.00 2066.50 2054.10 2058.80 –10.50 42,374 June 99.250 100.250 s 98.650 99.850 .475 45,370 Mini DJ Industrial Average (CBT)-$5 x index U.S. Dollar Index (ICE-US)-$1,000 x index
Aug 2082.40 2084.80 2073.00 2077.30 –10.40 23,550
Lumber (CME)-27,500 bd. ft., $ per 1,000 bd. ft. March 39187 39290 39070 39116 –73 104,830 March 103.89 103.95 103.63 103.75 –.11 29,216
March 565.50 567.00 562.00 567.00 2.50 4,147 June 39581 39709 39501 39544 –65 1,014 June 103.50 103.56 103.28 103.37 –.12 956
Oct 2098.20 2101.40 2090.60 2095.10 –10.30 5,890 May 586.50 589.00 584.50 587.50 1.00 3,821
Palladium (NYM) - 50 troy oz.; $ per troy oz. Mini S&P 500 (CME)-$50 x index
Milk (CME)-200,000 lbs., cents per lb. March 5095.00 5108.00 5076.25 5080.25 –21.25 2,283,422 Source: FactSet
Feb 953.70 –31.50 3 Feb 16.14 16.14 16.12 16.12 –.02 4,754
June 987.00 987.50 952.50 966.70 –30.50 19,265 March 17.31 17.63 17.31 17.58 .27 4,776
Platinum (NYM)-50 troy oz.; $ per troy oz. Cocoa (ICE-US)-10 metric tons; $ per ton.
Feb 876.80 –29.20 11 March
May
6,765
6,340
6,929 s
6,648 s
6,650
6,260
6,884
6,557
322 775
301 100,916
Bonds | wsj.com/market-data/bonds/benchmarks
April 906.60 907.90 880.20 881.10 –28.50 74,473
Silver (CMX)-5,000 troy oz.; $ per troy oz. Coffee (ICE-US)-37,500 lbs.; cents per lb.
Feb 22.595 22.595 22.595 22.517 –0.452 20
March
May
190.80
180.50
191.85
182.45
190.00
179.25
190.10
179.60
–.90 818
–.70 112,370
Tracking Bond Benchmarks
May 23.180 23.180 22.675 22.735 –0.454 93,011 Sugar-World (ICE-US)-112,000 lbs.; cents per lb. Return on investment and spreads over Treasurys and/or yields paid to investors compared with 52-week
Crude Oil, Light Sweet (NYM)-1,000 bbls.; $ per bbl. March 22.67 23.45 22.45 23.15 .53 68,015 highs and lows for different types of bonds
April 76.40 78.03 75.84 77.58 1.09 347,505 May 21.85 22.49 21.63 22.16 .34 289,948
Total Total
May 76.04 77.55 75.50 77.09 1.01 189,874 Sugar-Domestic (ICE-US)-112,000 lbs.; cents per lb. return YTD total return YTD total
May 41.80 … 2,190 Yield (%) Yield (%)
June 75.61 77.04 75.10 76.59 0.97 158,728 close return (%) Index Latest Low High close return (%) Index Latest Low High
July 75.27 76.51 74.66 76.05 0.92 99,853 Cotton (ICE-US)-50,000 lbs.; cents per lb.
March 94.78 96.13 s 94.78 96.58 1.65 46 Mortgage-Backed Bloomberg Fixed Income Indices
Sept 73.95 75.33 73.62 74.85 0.80 95,209
May 93.36 94.89 92.50 94.80 1.31 131,760
Broad Market Bloomberg Fixed Income Indices
Dec 72.53 73.68 72.14 73.24 0.69 178,380 Orange Juice (ICE-US)-15,000 lbs.; cents per lb. 1986.54 -2.4 Mortgage-Backed 5.160 4.290 6.050
NY Harbor ULSD (NYM)-42,000 gal.; $ per gal. 2020.81 -1.9 U.S. Aggregate 4.950 4.200 5.740
March 378.30 385.90 371.50 378.95 3.05 1,828
March 2.6891 2.7740 2.6642 2.7627 .0730 26,677 May 381.15 389.20 s 374.05 381.25 2.05 5,993 U.S. Corporate Indexes Bloomberg Fixed Income Indices 1961.86 -2.4 Ginnie Mae (GNMA) 5.180 4.350 6.020
April 2.6400 2.7177 2.6166 2.7073 .0662 99,998
3065.52 -1.7 U.S. Corporate 5.420 4.990 6.430 1168.00 -2.4 Fannie mae (FNMA) 5.160 4.280 6.050
Gasoline-NY RBOB (NYM)-42,000 gal.; $ per gal. Interest Rate Futures
March 2.2752 2.3458 2.2574 2.3056 .0289 26,360 2969.03 -0.8 Intermediate 5.340 4.890 6.350 1807.12 -1.9 Freddie Mac (FHLMC) 5.090 4.240 6.190
Ultra Treasury Bonds (CBT) - $100,000; pts 32nds of 100%
April 2.5070 2.5808 2.4904 2.5572 .0479 98,681 March 125-310 126-240 124-280 125-010 –25.0 902,762
Natural Gas (NYM)-10,000 MMBtu.; $ per MMBtu. 4063.64 -3.6 Long term 5.570 5.160 6.600 585.81 -0.4 Muni Master 3.216 2.801 4.311
June 127-280 128-210 126-250 126-300 –25.0 821,529
March 1.660 1.730 1.594 1.659 .056 36,033 Treasury Bonds (CBT)-$100,000; pts 32nds of 100% 584.67 -2.3 Double-A-rated 4.990 4.320 5.760 416.91 -0.4 7-12 year 2.873 2.404 4.097
April 1.750 1.834 1.716 1.744 .045 308,745 March 119-030 119-220 118-110 118-190 –15.0 828,577
May 1.903 1.962 1.862 1.891 .044 264,611 June 119-040 119-230 118-130 118-200 –15.0 655,181 825.55 -1.5 Triple-B-rated 5.630 5.250 6.700 473.84 -0.4 12-22 year 3.541 3.294 4.742
July 2.371 2.435 2.357 2.380 .046 99,727 Treasury Notes (CBT)-$100,000; pts 32nds of 100% High Yield Bonds ICE BofA -0.5 22-plus year
March 109-265 110-040 109-160 109-195 –8.5 2,308,860
446.62 4.198 4.020 5.274
Sept 2.444 2.502 2.437 2.460 .056 94,923
Oct 2.491 2.574 2.491 2.534 .057 103,770
June 110-120 110-215 110-020 110-045 –9.0 2,581,893 527.37 0.3 High Yield Constrained 7.859 7.620 9.560 Global Government J.P. Morgan†
5 Yr. Treasury Notes (CBT)-$100,000; pts 32nds of 100%
March 106-142 106-197 106-080 106-095 –5.7 3,229,179 514.37 1.5 Triple-C-rated 13.190 12.776 15.457 535.12 -1.6 Global Government 3.320 2.740 3.810
Agriculture Futures June 106-270 107-010 106-210 106-225 –6.0 2,960,008
2 Yr. Treasury Notes (CBT)-$200,000; pts 32nds of 100% 3544.52 0.1 High Yield 100 7.309 7.030 9.101 788.67 -1.7 Canada 3.530 2.880 4.260
Corn (CBT)-5,000 bu.; cents per bu.
March 101-278 101-298 101-251 101-255 –2.7 2,070,607 349.89 -1.8 EMU§ 3.134 2.669 3.790
March 399.75 407.75t 394.50 407.00 7.25 180,751
June 102-112 102-133 102-081 102-086 –2.8 1,812,797
460.47 0.9 Global High Yield Constrained 7.699 7.648 9.440
May 413.50 422.50t 408.75 421.50 8.00 603,165 30 Day Federal Funds (CBT)-$5,000,000; 100 - daily avg. -2.2 France
350.90 1.4 Europe High Yield Constrained 6.222 6.222 8.022 645.77 3.030 2.540 3.630
Oats (CBT)-5,000 bu.; cents per bu. Feb t 94.6700 94.6700 –.0025
94.6700 94.6725 564,877
March 365.00 378.75 365.00 375.00 10.50 957 April t 94.6750 94.6750 –.0050
94.6750 94.6800 461,783 U.S Agency Bloomberg Fixed Income Indices 456.37 -2.4 Germany 2.530 2.020 3.030
May 354.00 367.25 352.25 363.00 9.00 1,838 Three-Month SOFR (CME)-$1,000,000; 100 - daily avg.
Dec 94.6475 94.6475 94.6450 94.6450 1,125,753 1769.57 -0.6 U.S Agency 4.850 4.130 5.390 278.72 -0.1 Japan 1.070 0.710 1.300
Soybeans (CBT)-5,000 bu.; cents per bu.
March Dec'24 95.5000 95.5450 t 95.4550 95.4600 –.0500 1,131,801 1566.79 -0.4 10-20 years 4.840 4.120 5.370 495.59 -2.7 Netherlands 2.750 2.260 3.320
1137.00 1142.25 t 1124.75 1136.00 3.00 88,340
May 1145.00 1151.00 t 1133.50 1145.25 3.50 331,820
Soybean Meal (CBT)-100 tons; $ per ton.
Currency Futures 3348.38 -2.9 20-plus years 4.920 4.300 5.740 781.17 -3.8 U.K. 4.380 3.510 4.880
March 332.50 335.40 330.50 334.40 2.90 45,582 Japanese Yen (CME)-¥12,500,000; $ per 100¥ 2689.95 -1.3 Yankee 5.250 4.720 6.110 843.24 -0.6 Emerging Markets ** 7.472 7.206 8.842
May 328.80 331.00 t 325.50 328.60 .60 225,758 March .6669 .6677 t .6652 .6655 –.0015 304,021
*Constrained indexes limit individual issuer concentrations to 2%; the High Yield 100 are the 100 largest bonds † In local currency § Euro-zone bonds
Soybean Oil (CBT)-60,000 lbs.; cents per lb. June .6762 .6770 t .6747 .6750 –.0014 8,771
March 44.02 44.65 43.66 44.40 .38 37,132
Canadian Dollar (CME)-CAD 100,000; $ per CAD ** EMBI Global Index Sources: ICE Data Services; Bloomberg Fixed Income Indices; J.P.Morgan
March .7407 .7410 .7394 .7402 –.0008 152,255
May 44.62 45.24 44.26 45.02 .42 232,970
June .7417 .7419 .7404 .7412 –.0008 5,804
Rough Rice (CBT)-2,000 cwt.; $ per cwt.
March 18.52 18.59 18.23 18.28 –.32 1,305
British Pound (CME)-£62,500; $ per £ Global Government Bonds: Mapping Yields
March 1.2674 1.2702 1.2658 1.2680 .0003 192,275
May 18.86 18.94 18.57 18.65 –.29 8,838 June 1.2680 1.2707 1.2666 1.2687 .0004 12,202 Yields and spreads over or under U.S. Treasurys on benchmark two-year and 10-year government bonds in
Wheat (CBT)-5,000 bu.; cents per bu. Swiss Franc (CME)-CHF 125,000; $ per CHF selected other countries; arrows indicate whether the yield rose(s) or fell (t) in the latest session
March 573.50 578.75 562.00 577.25 3.75 30,936 March 1.1377 1.1404 1.1360 1.1377 .0003 62,823
May 569.75 576.25 560.00 574.75 5.75 184,261 June 1.1482 1.1516 1.1474 1.1490 .0003 628 Country/ Yield (%) Spread Under/Over U.S. Treasurys, in basis points
Coupon (%) Maturity, in years Latest(l)-1 0 1 2 3 4 5 Previous Month ago Year ago Latest Prev Year ago
4.250 U.S. 2 4.738 s l 4.687 4.365 4.803
Gold, per troy oz BMI Cobalt sulphate, EXW China, >20.5% -v,m 4448 choice 1-3,600-900 lbs.-u 284.05 0.100 Japan 2 0.160 t l 0.160 0.048 -0.022 -457.3 -451.2 -482.5
Engelhard industrial 2032.00 BMI Nickel Sulphate, EXW China, >22%-v,m 3628 select 1-3,600-900 lbs.-u 270.38 0.600 10 0.691 t l 0.721 0.720 0.506 -360.9 -353.0 -344.8
Handy & Harman base 2027.20 BMIFlakeGraphite,FOBChina,-100Mesh,94-95%-v,m 538 Broilers, National comp wtd. avg.-u,w 1.2625
Butter,AA Chicago-d 2.8500 2.800 Spain 2 3.094 s l 3.040 3.116 3.271 -164.0 -163.3 -153.2
Handy & Harman fabricated 2250.19 Fibers and Textiles Cheddar cheese,bbl,Chicago-d 167.00
LBMA Gold Price AM *2019.30 3.250 10 3.313 s l 3.274 3.204 3.516 -98.6 -97.7 -43.7
LBMA Gold Price PM *2027.45 Burlap,10-oz,40-inch NY yd-n,w 0.7775 Cheddar cheese,blk,Chicago-d 159.00
Cotton,1 1/16 std lw-mdMphs-u 0.9205 Milk,Nonfat dry,Chicago lb.-d 119.75 3.500 U.K. 2 4.595 s l 4.520 4.358 4.012 -13.9 -15.2 -79.1
Krugerrand,wholesale-e 2110.89
Cotlook 'A' Index-t *101.50 Coffee,Brazilian,Comp-y 1.8075 4.250 10 4.094 s 4.040 3.972 3.656 -21.1 -29.7
Maple Leaf-e 2131.19 l -20.5
American Eagle-e 2131.19 Hides,hvy native steers piece fob-u n.a. Coffee,Colombian, NY-y 2.0448
Wool,64s,staple,Terr del-u,w n.a. Eggs,large white,Chicago-u 3.0550 Source: Tullett Prebon, Tradeweb ICE U.S. Treasury Close
Mexican peso-e 2455.21
Flour,hard winter KC-p 18.75
Austria crown-e 1992.51 Grains and Feeds
Austria phil-e 2131.19
Bran,wheat middlings, KC-u,w 85
Hams,17-20 lbs,Mid-US fob-u
Hogs,Iowa-So. Minnesota-u
n.a.
83.18
Corporate Debt
Silver, troy oz. Pork bellies,12-14 lb MidUS-u n.a. Prices of firms' bonds reflect factors including investors' economic, sectoral and company-specific
Corn,No. 2 yellow,Cent IL-bp,u 3.8500
Engelhard industrial 22.6500 Pork loins,13-19 lb MidUS-u 1.1608
Handy & Harman base 22.5300
Corn gluten feed,Midwest-u,w 146.0 expectations
Corn gluten meal,Midwest-u,w 435.4 Steers,Tex.-Okla. Choice-u 182.71
Handy & Harman fabricated 28.1630 Cottonseed meal-u,w n.a. Steers,feeder,Okla. City-u,w 298.75 Investment-grade spreads that tightened the most…
LBMA spot price *£17.9100 Hominy feed,Cent IL-u,w 145 Spread*, in basis points
(U.S.$ equivalent) *22.7150 Fats and Oils Issuer Symbol Coupon (%) Yield (%) Maturity Current One-day change Last week
Meat-bonemeal,50% pro Mnpls-u,w 293
Coins,wholesale $1,000 face-a 18482 Oats,No.2 milling,Mnpls-u 4.2300 Degummed corn oil, crude wtd. avg.-u,w n.a. National Australia Bank NAB 4.787 4.94 Jan. 10, ’29 63 –11 73
Other metals Rice, Long Grain Milled, No. 2 AR-u,w 36.25 Grease,choice white,Chicago-h 0.3650
LBMA Platinum Price PM *904.0 Sorghum,(Milo) No.2 Gulf-u n.a. Lard,Chicago-u n.a. Citigroup C 5.300 5.54 May 6, ’44 106 –9 122
Platinum,Engelhard industrial 890.0 SoybeanMeal,Cent IL,rail,ton48%-u,w 353.00 Soybean oil,crude;Centl IL-u,w 0.4377 NYU Langone Hospitals NYUHOS 4.784 5.34 July 1, ’44 81 –7 n.a.
Palladium,Engelhard industrial 975.0 Soybeans,No.1 yllw IL-bp,u 11.0900 Tallow,bleach;Chicago-h 0.4213 John Deere Capital … 2.250 4.93 Sept. 14, ’26 22 –6 n.a.
Aluminum, LME, $ per metric ton *2157.0 Wheat,Spring14%-pro Mnpls-u 7.9575 Tallow,edible,Chicago-u n.a.
Hyundai Capital America HYNMTR 5.650 5.53 June 26, ’26 79 –4 76
KEY TO CODES: A=ask; B=bid; BP=country elevator bids to producers; C=corrected; D=CME; E=Manfra,Tordella & Brookes; H=American Commodities Brokerage Co; Protective Life Global Funding PL 1.618 5.41 April 15, ’26 70 –4 n.a.
K=bi-weekly; M=monthly; N=nominal; n.a.=not quoted or not available; P=Sosland Publishing; R=SNL Energy; S=Platts-TSI; T=Cotlook Limited; U=USDA; V=Benchmark –4 67
Mineral Intelligence; W=weekly; Y=International Coffee Organization; Z=not quoted. *Data as of 2/23 Unilever Capital UNANA 5.900 4.92 Nov. 15, ’32 68
Source: Dow Jones Market Data Goldman Sachs GS 5.150 5.44 May 22, ’45 94 –3 103
2023 than their rivals, adding team press ahead with Citi’s
that tech clients’ moves were most ambitious restructuring
hurting rivals more than them. plan in years while also work-
It is difficult to make apples- ing to modernize its technol-
to-apples comparisons of the ogy and internal controls.
tech business each ad giant His appointment also ends
holds because the companies a guessing game on Wall
break out their clients differ- Street; in its search, Citi had
ently. IPG breaks out a single Ad firms including Interpublic Group of Cos. and WPP said a slowdown in tech spending weighed on last year’s performance. reached out to some of the in-
segment that spans “tech and dustry’s most prominent in-
telecom” clients, for example, WPP has a notable concen- ally created a two-tier world a significant upturn in tech and telecommunications seg- vestment bankers.
while WPP puts its “tech and tration of technology clients, among the ad agencies we spending and marketing activ- ment, CEO Arthur Sadoun said, Peter Babej, who served as
digital services” business in a including Google and Dell track,” MoffettNathanson ana- ity, we’ve noted a more recent but a “slight one.” interim banking head during
different bucket than work for Technologies. The firm, which lysts said in a research note stabilization in that spend.” That said, tech clients aren’t the search, will now follow
“telecom, media and entertain- owns the media-buying busi- earlier this month. The company hasn’t fac- the entire story. Publicis’ solid through on his plan to retire
ment” clients. ness GroupM and ad agencies Organic revenue at IPG, tored a return to growth for performance of late can be at- from Citi.
Different tech clients spend such as VML, said its like-for- which owns agency groups the tech and telecommunica- tributed to its mix of revenue Citi shares finished Mon-
differently, moreover, and some like revenue less pass-through such as McCann Worldgroup tions sector into its plan for lines, but also to strong cus- day’s trading 1% lower at
are pulling back more heavily costs grew 0.9% last year, and IPG Mediabrands and has 2024, Krakowsky said. tomer retention and momen- $55.36.
than others. “It certainly could within its guidance ranges. big tech clients including Mi- Omnicom and Publicis fared tum in new business wins, said
be that tech company A is “The biggest delta versus crosoft, Google and Samsung, better in 2023 than their com- Danny Yeo, an equity analyst at
spending money and tech com- our budget was in technology fell 0.1% last year. Austerity in petitors. Publicis, whose agen- CFRA Research.
pany B is pulling back—so companies, which you know is tech and telecom spending con- cies include Saatchi & Saatchi “Today, the advertising mar-
whoever you happen to have at 20% of our business,” Chief Ex- tinues to weigh significantly on and Leo Burnett, reported full- ket can be characterized as a
the time is good or bad,” said ecutive Mark Read said on an the company’s overall growth, year 2023 net revenue organic zero-sum market that requires
Tim Nollen, senior media tech earnings call last Thursday. according to executives. growth of 6.3%. Omnicom, par- technology capabilities includ-
analyst at Macquarie. “We have the biggest exposure “Previously discussed bud- ent of agencies including BBDO ing data and digital transfor-
77%
market conditions in years. were closed in 2023 in the The corpo- survey said
“The diverse manager mar- U.S., the smallest number in rate call to de- they see invest-
ket, which has grown impres- almost a decade, according to carbonize is in- ment in renew-
sively over the years, has never a PitchBook-NVCA Venture tensifying, ables as essen-
been tested at this scale Monitor report. Ashurst said, Percentage of U.S. tial to the
against the type of market con- Many LPs, including with 30% of organization’s
ditions we’re facing today,” Fairview, continue to believe business lead-
business leaders who s t r a t e g i c
said Aakar Vachhani, managing that bringing new faces into ers saying the say board pressure growth.
partner at Fairview. “We could the venture industry will yield pressure from is significant Burns said
ERICA DUIGNAN MINNIHAN
see the bulk of firms weather strong results. their own the 2030 time-
the storm and emerge even At the same time, negative boards was ex- line to reach
stronger over time, or we could returns in the venture market treme, up from net zero was
see a significant setback that have made limited partners 25% in 2022. very important to the compa-
PHIL KIENE
takes longer to recover from.” stingier when it comes to “We’re seeing that the en- nies it surveyed. “We are in-
At some point this year, backing younger venture man- ergy transition is an area that creasingly seeing corporate
Fairview expects there will be Erica Duignan Minnihan and Caroline Lewis help lead funds. agers, where these firms are is firmly embedded in the and other stakeholders ac-
more than 1,000 private-equity more represented. thinking of investors, corpo- tively setting and embracing
firms owned by women and mi- institutional-quality manag- targets. In addition, some of the rates, governments and oth- trajectories to achieve net
norities in the U.S., an order of ers, those that institutional Venture funds at firms programs that were designed ers, so there is a real empha- zero. However, greater clarity
magnitude increase over the limited partners would con- owned by women and minori- specifically to help vary the sis on setting and acting on and transparency on the stan-
112 firms in 2014, when the sider backing. ties set a median target of $55 demographics of venture capi- these plans now,” said Michael dards for measuring and man-
firm began reporting its data. While there was an in- million in 2023, down from tal have run into legal and po- Burns, global co-head of en- aging these net-zero commit-
They represent roughly 10% of crease in women- and minor- $70 million in the prior year. litical challenges last year. ergy at Ashurst. “That said, ments is needed to ensure
all private-equity firms, accord- ity-owned funds overall, some Buyout funds in this category, “We didn’t think the invest- the pace of transition and the consistency in approach and,
ing to Fairview’s estimates. sub-segments saw a decline. meanwhile, were aiming for ment and interest would last stage of the journey very importantly, outcome,” he
There is also a maturation For example, the number of $325 million last year, down forever, but it’s pretty inter- much depends from business said.
of the set, with a record num- funds being raised by Black from $365 million in 2022. esting how it kind of vanished to business.” Legal battles over climate
ber of firms owned by minori- and Asian-American woman- The targets for funds at in just a couple of years,” said The shift in sentiment change and renewable invest-
ties and women raising their owned firms last year shrank women- and minority-owned Erica Duignan Minni- comes as companies ramp up ing are likely to rise, with 68%
second or later fund last year, for the first time since firms are significantly lower han, founding partner at New investment in renewable of respondents saying they ex-
Fairview found. Fairview, Fairview began keeping tabs. than the overall market. York-based Reign Ventures, spending to meet their net- pect to see an increase in legal
which has been investing in Women- and minority- The environment has led about the pullback of LPs zero goals. Ashurst found that disputes over the next five
venture funds for three de- owned funds overall have also San Antonio-based Rogue backing women- and minority- 71% of the more than 2,000 years, while 16% anticipate a
cades, tracks what it considers decreased their fundraising Women’s Fund to reduce the owned venture funds. respondents to its survey had decrease, the report said.
Continued From Page B9 52-Wk % 52-Wk % HoustonAmEner HUSA 1.27 0.8 MP Materials MP 14.32 -1.9 NewHorizAircraft HOVR 1.25 -15.4 PlaystudiosWt MYPSW 0.05 -5.4 SJW Group SJW 56.23 ... SunnovaEnergy NOVA 6.76 -6.9 VOC Energy VOC 6.22 0.6
52-Wk % Stock Sym Hi/Lo Chg Stock Sym Hi/Lo Chg VATE
INNOVATE 0.71 -5.9 MaidenHoldings MHLD 1.28 -4.7 NewPacificMetals NEWP 0.97 -8.4 Playtika PLTK 6.43 -3.5 SKYX Platforms SKYX 1.19 1.6 SyprisSolutions SYPR 1.67 -6.1 Valneva VALN 7.00 -2.6
IndependenceContr ICD 1.80 -4.2 Mangoceuticals MGRX 0.19 -6.1 NY Mortgage NYMT 7.07 -3.3 QuiptHomeMed QIPT 4.23 -4.1 SRM Ent SRM 1.12 -4.9 TeladocHealth TDOC 14.36 2.0 VenusConcept VERO 0.83 -27.4
Stock Sym Hi/Lo Chg FocusUniversal FCUV 0.34 -6.2 GreenfireResources GFR 4.71 -2.8 IndonesiaEnergy INDO Medigus MDGS 2.71 -5.7 Newmont NEM SABR VICR
GeneticTech GENE 1.80 -2.7 GreenPowerMotor GP 1.94 ...
2.35 -0.8 29.74 -4.1 RE/MAX RMAX 8.09 -5.6 Sabre 2.63 -2.2 TizianaLife TLSA 0.48 1.2 Vicor 35.00 7.4
DIH US DHAI 0.76 -30.6 InspireVeterinary IVP 0.09 -5.0 MetallaRoyalty MTA 2.32 4.2 Northann NCL 0.66 -2.8 Sasol SSL 7.31 -4.0 ViomiTech VIOT 0.70 -6.7
GlobalNetLease GNL 7.29 -4.3 GuardantHealth GH 19.08 3.7 RegencellBio RGC 6.40 -5.5 TreasureGlobal TGL 0.06 1.8
DigitalTurbine APPS 3.04 0.6 IridiumComm IRDM 27.89 0.3 Microvast MVST 0.72 0.5 OfficePropIncm OPI 2.78 -6.3 ScrippsEW SSP 4.21 6.0 Volcon VLCN 0.81 -6.2
Gogo GOGO 8.41 -0.4 HWH Intl HWH 0.89 -9.6 RenttheRunway RENT 0.39 -0.6 Tredegar TG 4.28 -1.6
KLX Energy KLXE 7.68 -10.6 MiddlesexWater MSEX 49.68 -2.3 OilStatesIntl OIS 5.46 -1.3 SemiluxIntl SELX 0.77 -22.1 WearableDevWt WLDSW 0.03 -7.8
ExactSciences EXAS 56.85 ... GogoroWt RIVN TripleFlagPrecMtl TFPM
GGROW 0.05 0.2 HalladorEnergy HNRG 6.85 -2.4 KaivalBrands KAVL 1.82 -6.2 ModivCare MODV 24.00 -4.3 OrionOffice ONL 4.29 -2.3 Rivian 10.05 6.3 Shyft SHYF 10.20 -7.7 11.75 -1.5 WheelerREIT WHLR 0.15 2.5
Fanhua FANH 5.07 -2.6 Gogoro GGR 1.52 -7.2 Hanryu HRYU 0.38 -8.8 Kennedy-Wilson KW 8.40 -9.5 MoolecScience MLEC 1.62 ... PalisadeBio PALI 0.39 -1.5 RoyaltyMgmt RMCO 1.12 ... SolGelTech SLGL 0.90 -1.7 22ndCentury XXII 0.13 0.7 WiSA Tech WISA 0.04 -2.0
FirstWesternFin MYFW 12.84 -1.8 Graphex GRFX 0.45 -7.9 HealthcareRealty HR 13.06 -2.2 LSB Inds LXU 7.21 -3.7 Movella MVLA 0.24 -16.1 PermianvilleRT PVL 1.35 -5.6 RubiconTech RBT 0.75 -8.7 SoloBrands DTC 2.56 -1.5 TwinVee VEEE 1.10 -3.7 Wolfspeed WOLF 23.54 7.6
FlexLNG FLNG 24.64 -1.7 GrayTelevision GTN 5.89 -2.8 HeliusMedical HSDT 5.59 -1.9 LightInTheBox LITB 0.92 -7.0 NWTN NWTN 6.01 -4.8 PlanetGreen PLAG 0.30 -6.2 SIMPPLE SPPL 3.70 -5.9 SturmRuger RGR 42.26 -1.5 Usio USIO 1.30 1.9 YorkWater YORW 34.98 -0.2
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. * * * * Tuesday, February 27, 2024 | B11
MARKETS
The S&P 500 fell 0.4%, while strong but quickly faded, end- Nasdaq Composite February just under 4% but has TWO-YEAR NOTES
the Dow Jones Industrial Aver- ing the day down 1.9%. Warren –0.3 climbed following hotter-than- Applications $159,709,649,500
Dow Jones Industrial Average Accepted bids $65,725,715,600
age shed roughly 62 points, or Buffett’s annual letter over the S&P 500 expected jobs and inflation " noncompetitively $640,224,300
0.2%. Both weekend divulged $8 billion of –0.4 data. It remains well below the " foreign noncompetitively $0
Auction price (rate) 99.875391
MONDAY’S were coming gains from bets on Japanese
Five-minute intervals
5% level it reached last fall. (4.691%)
MARKETS off records Fri- stocks but noted a lack of pos- –0.5 In commodities, Brent crude Interest rate
Bids at clearing yield accepted
4.625%
72.98%
day. The tech- sible acquisition targets. 10 a.m. 11 noon 1 p.m. 2 3 4 for April delivery gained 1.1%, Cusip number 91282CKB6
heavy Nasdaq Composite Meanwhile, Domino’s Pizza to $82.53 a barrel. The notes, dated Feb. 29, 2024, mature on Feb. 28,
slipped 0.1%. rose 5.8% after the delivery Source: FactSet Overseas, Japanese stocks 2026.
All three indexes are on chain reported a better-than- notched another record Mon- FIVE-YEAR NOTES
track to finish February in the expected profit and raised its Reserve’s preferred inflation have already shown inflation day, lifted by merger talks be- Applications $157,232,464,100
Accepted bids $66,768,916,600
green, which would mark their dividend. gauge. running unexpectedly hot to tween two drugstore operators " noncompetitively $197,040,300
fourth straight month of gains. Investors will gain greater The data are expected to start the year. That has scram- and praise from Buffett in his " foreign noncompetitively $0
99.688225
Last week, they each climbed insight into the economy on confirm that price pressures bled investors’ bets on when letter. At midday Tuesday, the Auction price (rate)
(4.320%)
more than 1% after chip maker Thursday when the Commerce increased in January after eas- the Fed might start cutting in- Nikkei 225 was down 0.15% and Interest rate 4.250%
Nvidia’s blockbuster earnings Department releases data on ing in previous months. Re- terest rates this year. Hong Kong’s Hang Seng Index Bids at clearing yield accepted
Cusip number
89.61%
91282CKD2
reignited enthusiasm about the household spending and in- ports on consumer and pro- Still, investors haven’t was down 0.9%. S&P 500 fu- The notes, dated Feb. 29, 2024, mature on Feb. 28,
potential of artificial-intelli- come, as well as the Federal ducer prices earlier this month shown too much concern. Many tures were down 0.1%. 2029.
created” in Guyana. Exxon to the Western Hemisphere as Exxon has assumed the
didn’t say whether it will global conflicts abound. lion’s share of the risk in the
make its own offer for Hess’s Exxon lost its stake in a ma- Guyana project, drilling there
stake. jor Russian project following for years before large amounts
The exact terms of the JOA the Ukraine war. of oil were discovered. Exxon
Avis’s stock slid sharply after the company reported a 53% drop in fourth-quarter profit. weren’t immediately clear, in- Exxon and Chevron have and its partners continue to
cluding whether pre-emption sold off billions in assets in drill for additional oil finds,
BY MATT WIRZ month [per vehicle] more than and Snap at the end of Decem-
[analysts] expected,” said John ber, according to data from S&P.
Shares of Avis Budget Healy, a stock analyst at North- That accounts for about 45% of
Group have crashed in recent coast Research. “When you the $11 billion in assets under
weeks, saddling the hedge-fund have 700,000 cars in your fleet, management the firm reported
management firm that owns al- that adds up to a couple hun- to the SEC in February.
most half the company with a dred million dollars a year.” Sarma has used activism to
paper loss exceeding $1 billion. Used-car prices are drop- raise returns. He pushed onto
The firm is SRS Investment ping, in part because higher in- Avis’s board of directors after a
Management, and its founder, terest rates have made monthly proxy campaign in 2018 and
Karthik Sarma, has tied his fate auto-loan payments too expen- urged management to boost
to the rental-car company. sive for some consumers. That share prices by changing opera-
While most hedge-fund manag- means Avis gets lower prices tions and financial strategy.
ers diversify their holdings to for cars it retires from its fleets. Sarma made one of his ana-
reduce risk, he had concen- Higher rates also increase the lysts, Brian Choi, Avis’s chief fi-
trated about one-quarter of the interest expenses it pays on nancial officer and, in mid-2021,
$11 billion his firm manages in cars it keeps. the company launched an ag-
Avis stock before the selloff, ac- Travel in the U.S. continues gressive stock buyback, retiring
cording to a Wall Street Journal to grow and the selloff in Avis 20% of its shares.
analysis of regulatory filings. shares makes them an attrac- A few months later, Avis re-
Avis has been one of SRS’s tive buy, said Stephanie Moore, ported unexpectedly high profit
biggest—and most successful— an equity analyst at Jefferies. as postquarantine travel
investments since at least 2011, Even with the recent down- surged, driving a boom in rent-
but the trade didn’t take off un- turn, SRS appears to have prof- als and lifting share prices.
til 2021. Car prices and travel ited significantly on Avis Meme-stock traders amplified
boomed after the pandemic, shares, most of which it bought the rally, urging one another to
generating billions of dollars in when they traded in the teens buy and punish short sellers
paper profit for the hedge fund. and $20s, according to data that wagered Avis stock would
Now car prices are falling and from S&P Global Market Intelli- fall.
so is the value of Avis’s fleet, gence. The stock traded at $107 With fewer shares outstand-
tanking its stock. on Friday. ing because of the buybacks,
SRS’s flagship fund has lost Sarma launched SRS in 2006 this “short squeeze” caused the
8% this year, according to a per- after working at Tiger Global stock to double in a single day.
son familiar with the matter. Management, a once-highflying SRS made about $3 billion in
The underperformance has con- hedge fund that mixed venture- paper gains in 2021. The trade
trasted with the wider stock capital investing with public put Sarma on the map, out-
rally and a 7.3% gain for 2024 stocks. stripping performance by many
on the S&P 500. The SRS fund SRS employs a narrower hedge-fund titans that year.
has generally been a solid per- strategy, typically owning fewer The following year, earnings
former, returning 25% in 2023 than 20 stocks at a time, ac- before interest, taxes, deprecia-
and an average of 12.9% since cording to filings with the Secu- tion and amortization, or
2007, the person familiar with rities and Exchange Commis- Ebitda, hit a record $4.1 billion
the matter said. sion. The firm’s total portfolio at Avis as business travel
Sarma rides his performance is closer to 50 companies after picked up. The company raced
swings calmly, cultivating the accounting for derivatives and to buy more cars even as prices
loyalty of a cadre of core ana- bets that stocks will fall, the rose because of inflation, short-
lysts who have been at the firm person familiar with the matter ages and a shift by automakers
since it launched in 2006, a for- said. toward higher-end cars.
mer employee said. SRS had a total of about $5 The purchases backfired
SRS is a holdover from the billion in shares of Avis, Netflix when interest rates jumped and
days when small teams at car prices fell. Late last year
hedge funds managed large Share-price and index Avis started cutting its losses,
pots of money and placed performance, past six months reducing its fleet by 50,000
“high-conviction” trades using 20% cars in a few months.
deep research. That model has Car prices will continue to
given way to a boom in multi- S&P 500 weaken because of high interest
manager hedge funds that em- rates, hitting Avis’s profit, said
ploy dozens of separate invest- 0 David Meneret, a hedge-fund
ment pods with different manager at Mill Hill Capital. His
trading strategies. fund is betting on that out-
In the second half of last come, but not in the stock mar-
year, SRS started selling large –20 ket. Instead, Mill Hill has been
amounts of Avis shares but still buying credit-default swaps, de-
owned about $3 billion worth at rivatives that rise in value
the end of December. The stock when investors expect Avis’s fi-
price declined 39% this month –40 nancial risk to rise.
after the company reported a Avis Budget Group “I’m not short the stock, be-
53% drop in earnings for the cause I believe there could be a
fourth quarter of 2023 and in- –60 short squeeze based on more
creased vehicle write-downs. large buybacks,” Meneret said.
Sept. 2023 Jan. ’24
“Vehicle depreciations are —Peter Rudegeair
going to be about $25 per Source: FactSet contributed to this article.
B12 | Tuesday, February 27, 2024 THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
HEARD STREET ON
THE
FINANCIAL ANALYSIS & COMMENTARY
China Stockpiles
For Next Phase
Of the Chip Wars
Bumper equipment sales original forecast in July of an
18.6% decline.
by Western companies There are a couple of reasons
are a sign of coming for China’s spending spree. First,
market disruptions Chinese chip makers have been
rushing to stockpile equipment in
Ahead of real conflicts, coun- anticipation of tougher Western
tries stockpile ammunition and export restrictions. That is partic-
fuel. Chinese companies are busy ularly true for lithography ma-
stockpiling chip-making equip- chines, which use light to print
ment parts. tiny circuits on silicon wafers.
That has brought huge bounty Japan and the Netherlands, key
CFOTO/DDP/ZUMA PRESS
to Western and Japanese ven- suppliers of such machines, have
dors—but also portends worrying rolled out their own restrictions
developments ahead. on exports to China, in concert
The latest to benefit from with the U.S.
China’s splurge is Japanese chip- China’s imports of lithography
equipment maker Tokyo Electron. machines from the Netherlands al- Net system sales to China from ASML, the market leader in lithography equipment, tripled in 2023.
Its shares gained 20% since it most quadrupled year over year in
raised its profit outlook around 2023, according to China’s cus- ASML says about 10% to 15% of its roughly the same as last year at Equipment Inc. China, or AMEC,
two weeks ago. China comprised toms data. Net system sales to sales to China could be affected around $7.5 billion. which makes etching tools to cre-
nearly half of its total net sales China from Dutch company ASML, this year. Another longer-term risk for ate circuit patterns on wafers. The
last quarter, after sales there dou- the market leader in lithography For companies, the bad news is manufacturers of chip-making company hasn’t reported 2023 full
bled from a year earlier. equipment, tripled in 2023. China that China’s stockpiling binge last gear is China’s drive to wean itself year results yet, but its latest pub-
Strong demand from China made up 29% of ASML’s total net year could dent sales growth in off Western supplies. While it will lic estimate puts revenue growth
helped offset weakness elsewhere system sales last year—up from 2024. Even so, China’s aggressive take a long time for China to catch at 32%. The company reckons
last year as capital spending from 14% in 2022. investment in semiconductor-man- up on some keystone technologies sales of its key dry etching equip-
global semiconductor companies, ASML hasn’t been able to sell ufacturing capacity is a long-term such as lithography, there are al- ment rose 49%. New orders for the
especially memory-chip makers, its cutting-edge extreme ultravio- trend. ready niches in which Chinese machine rose 60% last year, point-
slowed. Imports of semiconductor let lithography, or EUV, machines China’s effort to make the most- suppliers can replace Western ing to continued growth.
equipment to China rose 14% year to China for quite a while. But advanced chips is hampered by counterparts. Bernstein estimates For Western and Japanese chip
over year in 2023 to nearly $40 new restrictions mean it won’t be sanctions, but its companies are domestic suppliers made up about equipment makers, export restric-
billion, according to the country’s able to export some less-advanced pushing hard in more-mature 14% of China’s wafer-fabrication- tions to China are both a blessing
customs data. Industry association machines there either. The com- technologies. China’s largest con- equipment market last year, up and a curse. For now, they are rak-
SEMI reckons global semiconduc- pany said last month that the tract chip maker Semiconductor from 3% in 2018. It expects that ing in huge sales. But long-term
tor-equipment sales fell 6.1% year Dutch government revoked li- Manufacturing International share to rise to 29% in 2026. risks are multiplying, especially at
over year in 2023 to $101 billion— censes for exporting certain li- Corp., or SMIC, says its capital ex- Such local champions include the lower end of the technological
a significant improvement from its thography machines to China. penditure this year will remain Advanced Micro-Fabrication spectrum. —Jacky Wong
Bowl commercials, raked in roughly Neither platform competes on prices already languishing, inves-
$9 billion in U.S. gross merchandise speed, as Amazon does. Although tors could lose patience if sales con-
value in 2023, according to an esti- Etsy is known for being a platform tinue to stagnate. Etsy and Way-
mate from KeyBanc Capital Mar- that sells bespoke, handmade goods, fair’s shares have shed 67% and 82%
kets. it essentially sells unbranded, low- of their value over the past three
Its next move: opening up its ticket items. That puts it in direct years, respectively.
marketplace to U.S. sellers. This will competition with Temu, notes Temu’s success isn’t inevitable. If
intensify the already-high competi- Nikhil Devnani, equity analyst at the platform’s main appeal is that
tion for third-party sellers. Notably, Bernstein. Etsy Chief Executive Offi- its goods are dirt cheap, then U.S.
short-form video platform TikTok cer Josh Silverman said during an sellers may find it difficult to com-
launched its shopping feature—Tik- industry conference in December The Pinduoduo-backed marketplace spent $1.7 billion on marketing in 2023. pete on the platform to begin with.
Tok Shop—last year and was selling that, while Temu’s entrance isn’t And while Temu has been effective
about $7 million worth of products “disproportionately impacting Etsy,” ad spaces, Shah said. form allowed them to maintain at capturing U.S. customers, it
in the U.S. every day, the Journal it has ramped up competition for That could change once Temu prices and implement technology to hasn’t been as successful at luring
reported in October. online marketing. Temu spent $1.7 starts opening its doors to U.S.- help sellers migrate listings seam- them back for a second purchase.
Given that Temu sells commod- billion on marketing in 2023 and is based sellers—a move that would lessly. While over 30% of customers who
itized discretionary items—anything expected to spend $3 billion this allow it to expand its market to The Temu threat comes at an in- shopped on Temu in September re-
ranging from electronic accessories year, per JP Morgan estimates cited bulkier items such as furniture, opportune time for online market- turned a month later, only 14% of
to kitchen gadgets—its most obvi- by the Journal. Devnani notes. Temu’s deep-pock- places. Etsy’s gross merchandise them came back four months later,
ous customer overlap is with Ama- Wayfair CEO Niraj Shah said on eted parent has been willing to sub- sales—the total volume of transac- according to KeyBanc Capital Mar-
zon and Walmart. About 92% of the company’s earnings call on sidize its extravagant ad budget, tions on its platform—shrank for kets, which also found that churn
Temu’s audience also visited Ama- Thursday that low-cost sellers such and it could well offer low seller the second consecutive year in rates have been increasing over
zon, while 53% of its audience also as Temu, Shein and TikTok Shop fees to gain market share. This 2023, while Wayfair’s declined for time. And then there are also regu-
visited Walmart from September haven’t overlapped much with the could, in turn, force U.S. market- three consecutive years. Both have latory risks that could get in the
2022 to January 2024, according to company’s offerings, noting that places to adjust their take rates. At been in cost-cutting mode recently way of its growth.
Similarweb. such online stores compete for low- a recent panel discussion that Ever- with large-scale layoffs. For Etsy and Wayfair’s investors,
Temu isn’t yet a substantial end quality and small ticket sizes. core conducted with three top Etsy So far, both platforms have re- though, Temu is yet another thing
threat to Amazon, which has the As such, Wayfair isn’t seeing much sellers, two said they would be in- sisted the temptation to splurge on to add to their basket of worries.
advantage of loyal Prime members competition for the same kinds of clined to sell on Temu if the plat- advertising. Wayfair said it would —Jinjoo Lee