Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Digital in Mas Casualty
Digital in Mas Casualty
Adrian Stănescu, MD,1 Peter Eliot Gordon, MD,2 those duties became more complex. All respondents favored an
Sanda Maria Copotoiu, MD, PhD,3,4 optimized large-scale event electronic solution, emphasizing the
and Cristian Marius Boeriu, MD, PhD5,6 need for enhanced communications, technical equipment, co-
1
operation, and workflow mainly by integrating mobile devices,
Department of Radiology and Medical Imaging, Tı^rgu Muresx dedicated software, remote databases, and interlink capabilities.
Emergency Clinical County Hospital, Tı^rgu Muresx, Romania.
2 Conclusions: Professionals support the implementation of an
Department of Emergency Medicine, Albany Medical Center,
integrated electronic system for large-scale events if outlined
Albany, New York.
3
Department of Anesthesia and Intensive Care, Tı^rgu Muresx requirements are met to maximize user acceptance.
Emergency Clinical County Hospital, Tı^rgu Muresx, Romania.
4
Department of Anesthesia and Intensive Care, University of Keywords: mass casualty incident, disaster, opinion, elec-
Medicine and Pharmacy of Tı^rgu Muresx, Tı^rgu Muresx, Romania. tronic documentation, telemedicine, digital
5
Department of Emergency Medicine, Tı^rgu Muresx Emergency
Clinical County Hospital, Tı^rgu Muresx, Romania. Introduction
6
T
Department of Anesthesia and Intensive Care 2 and Emergency elemedicine has proven to be not only a valid alter-
Medicine, University of Medicine and Pharmacy of Tı^rgu Muresx, native within the classical healthcare process, but
Romania. also a supplementary tool, providing features and
benefits that would otherwise be unavailable locally.
Abstract This makes it useful not only for underserved geographical
Background: Despite a recognized need for improved com- areas, but also for critical cases where time is of the essence.
munications and logistics in high acuity situations, the in- Acting as a force multiplier, telemedicine can address com-
tegration of telemedicine services into the mainstream health plex issues independent of location by interlinking medicine,
services has been difficult. This study reports on the opinions public health authorities, civil services, as well as remote ex-
of Romanian professional responders to mass casualty inci- pertise, to assist overwhelmed local resources. Its application
dents and disasters regarding the use and requirements of has been demonstrated to be appropriate for real and simulated
specific electronic medical documentation solutions. mass casualty incidents and disaster (MCI-Ds) scenarios.1–3
Materials and Methods: Doctors, nurses, paramedics, and Improvements in patient triage, monitoring, medical man-
fire department officers participated in a customized online agement, remote medical assistance, and disaster recovery
structured questionnaire. To assess factors associated with support are undeniable benefits in stressful situations, con-
the current use of information technology and the willingness tributing to a structured approach in event management.4–6
to adopt an exclusive optimized electronic system, a multi- In large-scale events, the visual representation of unfolding
variate analysis was performed. Logistic regression was used processes by using object-oriented modeling tools may opti-
for free input key elements regarding the most useful tech- mize medical and operational workflows. Using a field elec-
nical and operative improvements and medical documenta- tronic medical record system makes conventional paper
tion solutions for large-scale events. methods obsolete provided the case that there are no signifi-
Results: A total of 536 respondents provided answers between cant technological challenges.7 Victim tracking and status
the second half of the year 2014 and the first half of the year 2015. evaluation are significantly improved, while documentation
Doctors and nurses were the most frequent users of documenta- standards are enhanced.4,7,8
tion techniques, especially if they were employed at a high-level Despite the potential benefit, telemedicine has not met ex-
emergency care center. Professionals’ duties were perceived as pectations in terms of in-the-field application.9 Although there
increasingly impaired by the use of current electronic systems as is an acute need to establish telemedicine programs in high-risk
areas,10 acceptance has been slow within the mainstream health nonprofit organization in Romania provided participation
services. This is true despite the fact that its perceived useful- instructions. All participants were informed of their right to
ness ought to impact the behavioral intention to use it.11 Cited opt out of the study at any time of their choosing. We obtained
reasons for unsuccessful deployment of telemedicine refer approval for the overall project, including the current study,
mainly to technology, regulations, and licensing and costs, but from the Institutional Review Board of the host institution, the
there are also concerns regarding physician buy-in and patient Tı̂rgu Muresx Emergency Clinical County Hospital.
acceptance. This brings up controversies since patients, medical
Downloaded by GRIFFITH UNIVERSITY from online.liebertpub.com at 09/08/17. For personal use only.
staff, hospital executives, and cultural issues are also cited not
INQUIRY PROCESS
to interfere with its implementation.12,13
Program enrollment was based upon personal credentials,
Given the diversity of telemedicine solutions that may be ap-
including the participants’ name, e-mail address, agency,
plied in MCI-Ds settings, as well as the multitude of factors hin-
geographical origin, and other specific information requested
dering their application, it is reasonable to investigate factors
by the organizers. The e-mail address was used as a username
impacting variations in clinical acceptance, expansion, and
for all online instructional support. Participants also gave
sustainability.13,14 Before implementing such systems, it is worth
their consent for using the registration credentials for the
investing in studies attempting to identify predictors of success or
purposes of the program, including the current study.
failure to modify their influence.15 Stakeholder participation,
A master questionnaire was developed addressing specific
particularly clinicians, early in the design process is a key element
aspects of large-scale events, interventions, as well as targeted
for success, while pilot projects should be designed with a max-
questions regarding the use of information technology in these
imum degree of integration into the existing care system.9,16–18
settings. The current study refers exclusively to the latter.
Over the last 10 years, the Romanian Ministry of Health has
The survey was implemented by using a dedicated Web-based
implemented various telemedicine initiatives designed to
application, connected to a secured database, which sent e-mail
improve specialist care in distant emergency medical centers
invitations to all trained participants, and collected individual
as well as in prehospital settings for individual selected cases.
responses. An alphanumeric unique identifier was assigned to
The current study reports on the topic of emergency person-
each subject and included in the survey URL. The researchers
nel familiarity and acceptance of electronic documentation
were blinded to personal credentials, exposing only the pro-
methods and their opinions regarding a prospective tele-
fession of the subject (doctor, nurse, paramedic, or officer). This
medicine solution proposed for the MCI-D setting in Romania.
was done for response tracking purposes to maximize response
These results can be extrapolated and integrated across the
rate by reissuing e-mail invitations in case no response was
region and Europe as well as other locations worldwide.
obtained for a certain period of time. This timeframe was set to a
week. In total, a particular subject would receive three e-mail
Materials and Methods invitations at most should no response be received.
This study is a part of a larger research project that aims to
The first invitations were sent in early 2014 and the initial
develop a customized telemedicine solution for MCI-Ds rescue
assumption was that by the end of that year the data collection
efforts as an extension of current emergency management
process would be concluded due to the absence of new input.
operations. The first phase of the project consists of inquiring
However, survey responses continued to arrive through early
upon current procedures followed by inviting study partici-
2015 when the process was terminated.
pants to point out specific requirements and features of a
future system that they would regard as beneficial to their
work and agree to utilize. The study methodology utilized in SURVEY
this study is based on similar work.19 The questionnaire included nine questions regarding partic-
ipants’ demographics, their past participation in a real MCI-D
SELECTION CRITERIA setting, the general utilization of information technology at
The current study recruited all participants to a nationwide their specific workplace, and particularly in an MCI-D setting.
comprehensive MCI-D training course, which took part for the Assessment of a subjects’ opinion regarding a certain topic in-
second half of the year 2013. Each week-long training session cluded the use of a 5-point Likert scale with the exception of a
included doctors, nurses, paramedics, and fire department single three options staged question regarding the exclusive use
officers. Participation was not mandatory but based on an of an electronic data documentation solution. We inquired on
informed opt-in process before the beginning of the program. each participant’s opinion on the implementation of new tech-
Experienced specialists from the largest emergency situations nical or operative solutions as well as their opinion on the best
Fig. 6. Input rates for the most useful technical and operative MCI-D improvements.
paper-based solution (2.3%) or to a dual electronic and paper- quested technical element was the use of mobile devices
based solution (3.45%)—p < 0.001. For this last option, all but (8.81%), doctors and paramedics having a significant higher
two elements were in favor of digitizing a previously hand- demand than officers and nurses ( p = 0.044). The remaining
written medical chart versus a simultaneous paper and elec- two technical elements included dedicated MCI-D software
tronic documentation effort. The responder groups did not (3.07%) and patient bracelets with wireless (radio-frequency
show any statistically significant differences among input identification [RFID], near field communication [NFC]) and/or
rates ( p = 0.176). optical (barcode or quick response [QR] code) tags (1.34%). All
Downloaded by GRIFFITH UNIVERSITY from online.liebertpub.com at 09/08/17. For personal use only.
In functional terms, responders requested (in descending input rates are also homogeneous among responder groups,
order of their average input rates): remote access to the patient without statistically significant differences apart from the
medical history (12.45%) and dedicated staff for the docu- specified exceptions. All medical data documentation solution
mentation effort (4.21%)—where the AMC group had a signif- input rates are illustrated in Figure 7. Controlling for age,
icant higher demand than the RMC group ( p < 0.001). In gender, and HLECCs did not expose any independent factors for
anticipation of future use of a dedicated electronic solution, any free input topic.
responders asked for an easy-to-use application interface
(4.79%), interagency software interfacing (4.6%), location- Conclusions
independent access to collected data (4.21%), real-time data The deployment of telemedicine during a mass casualty
visualization among all users (4.02%), MCI-D chart data fields incident or disaster is a challenge, not only because of infra-
essentialization (2.11%), standardized medical forms (1.92%), structure constraints but also because the available solutions
hospital prearrival medical data receival (1.53%), patient data are still immature.14,20
and user access security (1.34%), documentation redundancies Even if rescue personnel are cited as not being an obstacle
removal (1.15%), addition of visual, audio, and location data to implementation of telemedicine projects,13 omitting user
meta elements (0.77%), role-centered application interface design input and user acceptance studies in favor of technical
(0.77%), and real-time event statistics (0.38%). The most re- concerns can be pitfalls destined to negatively impact a
project. To conceive a successful and sustainable MCI-D tel- In setting up a project with the stated specifications it is vital
emedicine project,15 we started by querying professionals on to ensure organizational and technical integration into existing
their perception of current technology in use and then asked services. While pilot projects are critical, switching to main-
for specific improvements to establish a general model for the stream operations is known to be far from straightforward.9,22
proposed future project. This requires that, in addition to technical aspects and user-
Among limitations of the current study, we presumed that centered design, the implementers of the project have to plan
age is proportional to professional experience without spe- and budget for user training, protocol development, technical
Downloaded by GRIFFITH UNIVERSITY from online.liebertpub.com at 09/08/17. For personal use only.
cifically requesting this information. This may not always be support, a business model, and supporting policy and legisla-
the case, but we assumed those cases to be rare particularly tion.14 While ensuring system resilience—as an exclusive state
considering that the study population is young and that prerogative—is critical for MCI-Ds, the aforementioned com-
changing professions is infrequent in Romania. We also chose plex requirements may set the need to externalize some of the
not to suggest a list of elements to choose from as an alter- above services to private contractors. Failure to ensure an
native to free text input in an effort to encourage spontaneous overall coherent working system may lead to rescue interven-
input and to avoid social desirability bias. Evening out re- tion collapse, potentially aggravating an unfolding event. We
spondent proportions with larger professional population thus consider there will always be a need for contingency plans.
groups would ideally be preferable, especially given the rel- Finally, we advocate for the development of a user-centered
atively low input rates we obtained and which we attribute to and user/task-customized telemedicine system for MCI-Ds.
sociocultural factors. Although this may be difficult in some settings due to previ-
We observed that doctors and nurses are required to use some ously initiated projects, model design, and technical changes
form of electronic medical data documentation more often than incurred later may not only increase expenditures, but also
paramedics and officers, particularly if they originate from a decrease user perceived usefulness and acceptance, posing a
HLECC. Higher medical expertise generally relates to a per- substantial risk to the overall success of the project.
ceived increased negative effect of current electronic docu-
mentation solutions on professional duties. The magnitude of Acknowledgments
this effect is not negligible, demonstrating that the current setup This study was supported by SC Avant Maris Medical SRL
does not act as a natural extension to the staff’s medical duties. and the University of Medicine and Pharmacy of Tı̂rgu Muresx—
Not surprisingly, this leads to a significant drop in enthusiasm Research Grant No. 15897/10.11.2014.
for the implementation of a proposed improved system.
It was generally conceded that enhanced communication
Disclosure Statement
and an exclusive electronic system for MCI-D data docu- No competing financial interests exist.
mentation could streamline staff’s duties. Responders focused
mostly on functionalities that may be supported by technol-
ogy, sometimes exclusively, rather than pointing to detailed
REFERENCES
technical solutions, which may exceed their competence.
1. Piza F, Steinman M, Baldisserotto S, Morbeck RA, Silva E. Is there a role for
The ideal model centered on responders’ feedback is an up- telemedicine in disaster medicine? Crit Care 2014;18:646.
dated communication system based on modern devices, de- 2. Simmons S, Alverson D, Poropatich R, D’Iorio J, DeVany M, Doarn CR. Applying
signed to facilitate rescue effort interactions, and teamwork telehealth in natural and anthropogenic disasters. Telemed J E Health
2008;14:968–971.
while streamlining workflow, supporting a dynamic command
3. Houtchens BA, Clemmer TP, Holloway HC, Kiselev AA, Logan JS, Merrell RC,
hierarchy, delivering a larger amount of exact, reliable data et al. Telemedicine and international disaster response: Medical consultation to
taking advantage of available advanced technical features. In Armenia and Russia via a Telemedicine Spacebridge. Prehosp Disaster Med
this regard, it must compensate for technical shortages like the 1993;8:57–66.
absence of a wireless carrier signal. It must also be enabled for 4. Plischke M, Wolf KH, Lison T, Pretschner DP. Telemedical support of prehospital
emergency care in mass casualty incidents. Eur J Med Res 1999;4:394–398.
simulation and educational purposes. All of these requirements
5. Rolston DM, Meltzer JS. Telemedicine in the intensive care unit: Its role in
need to be available in an ergonomic user-friendly package.21 emergencies and disaster management. Crit Care Clin 2015;31:239–255.
The user interface has to be adapted to role requirements and 6. Rüter A, Ortenwall P, Vikström T. Staff procedure skills in management groups
demonstrate filtered data. To allow doctors and nurses to per- during exercises in disaster medicine. Prehosp Disaster Med 2007;22:318–321.
form complex and urgent medical maneuvers, where possible, 7. Yperzeele L, Van Hooff RJ, De Smedt A, Valenzuela Espinoza A, Van Dyck R, Van
de Casseye R, et al. Feasibility of AmbulanCe-Based Telemedicine (FACT) Study:
specially designated operators should provide data input into Safety, feasibility and reliability of third generation in-ambulance telemedicine.
the system rather than the healthcare provider. PLoS One 2014;24;9:e110043.
8. Chan TC, Griswold WG, Buono C, Kirsh D, Lyon J, Killeen JP, et al. Impact of 19. Stănescu A, Boeriu C, Copotoiu S. Mass casualty incidents and disasters
wireless electronic medical record system on the quality of patient participation in real versus simulated events in Romania. Acta Medica
documentation by emergency field responders during a disaster mass-casualty Marisiensis 2016;62:15–20.
exercise. Prehosp Disaster Med 2011;26:268–275.
20. Doarn CR, Merrell RC. Telemedicine and e-health in disaster response. Telemed
9. Barlow J, Bayer S, Curry R. The design of pilot telecare projects and their J E Health 2014;20:605–606.
integration into mainstream service delivery. J Telemed Telecare 2003;
21. Buck S. Nine human factors contributing to the user acceptance of
9 Suppl 1:S1–S3.
telemedicine applications: A cognitive-emotional approach. J Telemed Telecare
10. Latifi R, Tilley EH. Telemedicine for disaster management: Can it transform 2009;15:55–58.
chaos into an organized, structured care from the distance? Am J Disaster Med
22. May C, Mort M, Mair F, Williams T. Factors affecting the adoption of
2014;9:25–37.
Downloaded by GRIFFITH UNIVERSITY from online.liebertpub.com at 09/08/17. For personal use only.
telehealthcare in the United Kingdom: The policy context and the problem of
11. Rho Mj, Choi IY, Lee J. Predictive factors of telemedicine service acceptance evidence. Health Inform J 2001;7:131–134.
and behavioral intention of physicians. Int J Med Inform 2014;83:559–571.
12. Call VR, Erickson LD, Dailey NK, Hicken BL, Rupper R, Yorgason JB, Bair B.
Attitudes toward telemedicine in urban, rural, and highly rural communities. Address correspondence to:
Telemed J E Health 2015;21:644–651. Adrian Stănescu, MD
13. Rogove HJ, McArthur D, Demaerschalk BM, Vespa PM. Barriers to telemedicine: Department of Radiology and Medical Imaging
Survey of current users in acute care units. Telemed J E Health 2012;18:48–53.
Tıˆrgu Muresx Emergency Clinical County Hospital
14. Wade VA, Eliott JA, Hiller JE. Clinician acceptance is the key factor for
sustainable telehealth services. Qual Health Res 2014;24:682–694. Str. Gheorghe Marinescu nr. 50
15. Klaassen B, van Beijnum BJ, Hermens HJ. Usability in telemedicine systems—A Tı^rgu Muresx
literature survey. Int J Med Inform 2016;93:57–69. Muresx
16. Saigi-Rubió F, Jiménez-Zarco A, Torrent-Sellens J. Determinants of the Romania
intention to use telemedicine: Evidence from primary care physicians. Int J
Technol Assess Health Care 2016;32:29–36.
E-mail: adrianstanescu@email.com
17. Espinoza AV, De Smedt A, Guldof K, Vandervorst F, Van Hooff RJ, Tellez HF,
et al. Opinions and beliefs about telemedicine for emergency treatment during
ambulance transportation and for chronic care at home. Interact J Med Res Received: February 8, 2017
2016;30;5:e9.
Revised: June 27, 2017
18. Larinkari S, Liisanantti JH, Ala-Lääkkölä T, Meriläinen M, Kyngäs H, Ala-Kokko T.
Identification of tele-ICU system requirements using a content validity
Accepted: June 27, 2017
assessment. Int J Med Inform 2016;86:30–36. Online Publication Date: August 14, 2017