UMUDIKE JOURNAL OF ENGINEERING AND TECHNOLOGY (UJET)

MICHAEL OKPARA UNIVERSITY OF AGRICULTURE, UMUDIKE

MANUSCRIPT EVALUATION FORM

Reviewer’s Information
Email:
Title:
First Name:
Last Name:
Affiliation:
Phone Number:
Send completed review result to: ujet@mouau.edu.ng
Our website is www.ujetmoua.com
Manuscript Information

i. Manuscript Ref No: UJET-072

ii. Manuscript Title: Improvement of Maximum Principal Strain Yield Criterion for Plate Structures
iii. Date Received by Reviewer: 05/06/2024

Comments

Please rate the following: (1=Excellent) (2= Good) (3= Fair) (4= Poor)

i. Originality

ii. Contribution to the field

iii. Technical quality

iv. Clarity of presentation

v. Depth of research

Specific Comments

(The comments you make here will be forwarded to the author, to guide him/her to see the
deficiencies of his/her manuscript. It is hoped that if the author will be able to apply the
comments made here in his/her manuscript, the manuscript will be improved and made
publishable in any standard journal. Please be as detailed as possible.)

i. Title

ii. Abstract
 iii. Introduction

iv. Materials/Methods

v. Results

vi. Discussion

vii. Conclusion

viii. References

General Comments
(The Comments you make here will serve to guide the Editorial Board so as to take the
right decision concerning this manuscript)

Recommendation: Kindly mark X in one of the boxes below.

i. Publish as it is

ii. Publish after minor revision

iii. Publish after major revision

iv. Reject

Signature and Date