Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Intercultural Trust Among Christians and Muslims in Cotabato City
Intercultural Trust Among Christians and Muslims in Cotabato City
INTRODUCTION
1
Statement of the Problem
The study seeks to determine the intercultural trust among Muslims and
Christians in Cotabato City. Specifically, it sought to answer the central problem:
1. What is the profile of the respondents in terms of:
Sex;
Age;
Educational Attainment; and
Years of residency in Cotabato City.
2. How do the respondents define trust?
3. What is the level of trust between Christians and Muslims?
4. How is the relationship between Muslims and Christians?
5. What factors contribute to the full trust of Muslims and Christians?
2
Definition of Terms
For clarification, the important terms used in this study have been
operationally defined.
Christian refers to an individual who follows the doctrine of Christianity either
Protestant, Jehova, or other sect. they are also known as Christian settlers who
came to Mindanao since the time of immemorial.
Muslim refers to an individual who follows the teachings of Islam. Sometimes
they are called a Bangsamoro people because they are the natives of Mindanao.
Intercultural Trust is a reciprocal trust of both Muslims and Christians.
Trust refers to someone who can rely on and depend on in times of need.
Level of trust is a degree of trust which can measure trustworthiness and
truthfulness.
3
Chapter II
LITERATURE REVIEW
This chapter presents a summary of related readings and studies found most
4
University in Cotabato City. Many young Muslims have interactions with Christian
seminaries and some form close bonds with Christian friends. Interfaith marriages,
often between Muslim men and Christian women, are not rare. Additionally, many
young Muslims participate, to some extent, in the celebrations of Christian holidays
such as Christmas, New Year's Eve, and Saint Valentine's Day (Cabrera, 2016).
Theoretical Lens
The study is anchored through the lens of Social Identity Theory which was
developed by Henri Tajfel and John Turner. This theoretical perspective suggests
that people classify others into social groups which influences their perceptions,
actions, and attitudes. Shaping individual relationships and associations between
different groups stresses the importance of group identity and social categorization.
The study of how individuals from different religious groups define trust within their
communities can be linked to this theory by way of a question as to how respondents
define trust. Another is in the level of trust, how group identities shape perceptions of
trust between Christians and Muslims which results in in-group favoritism or out-
group derogation that may impact their level of trust. Furthermore, in terms of the
5
relationship between Muslims and Christians considering how groups perceive
similarities and differences influences their interactions and relationships. In the last
question what are the factors that contribute to the full trust of the respondents, by
this theoretical lens we can examine how shared identities, common goals and
positive intergroup experiences contribute to building trust between Muslims and
Christians in Cotabato City.
Conceptual Frameworks
The schematic diagram shows the level of trust is the dependent variable
which is the outcome or result that is being observed and measured. On the other
hand, the independent variables are first, the profile of the respondents which
includes their sex, age, educational attainment, and years of residency. Second, the
meaning of trust is based on the respondents' shared values, past experiences,
mutual respect., understanding, and communication. Third, the relationships between
Christians and Muslims in terms of social interactions, historical events, conflicting
beliefs, and stereotypes can influence the level of trust between the two groups.
Finally, factors that contribute to the full trust of the respondents such as consistency
in words and actions, honesty and transparency, reliability and dependability, mutual
respect and understanding, shared values, and beliefs, positive past experiences,
effective communication, and active listening can contribute to the full trust of the two
groups are the factors that are being manipulated or controlled to see how they affect
the dependent variable.
6
CHAPTER III
METHODOLOGY
This chapter covers the research design, locale of the study, respondents,
data gathering procedure, sampling techniques, and research instruments.
Research Design
This study employed a mixed-method approach (both quantitative and
qualitative research methods). Surveys were used to collect quantitative data on the
demographic profile of the respondents, the level of trust between Christians and
Muslims, and the factors that contribute to the full trust of Muslims and Christians.
Also, the researcher conducted an in-depth key Informant Interview.
Figure 1
Map showing the barangays of Cotabato City
7
Note: Map generated from Google Map
Respondents of the Study and Sampling Procedure
The respondents of the study were Muslim and Christian residents of the
following barangay in Cotabato City namely: Mother Barangay Bagua, Rosary
Heights III, Rosary Heights VI, Bagua III, and Poblacion IV. The study utilized quota
and snowball sampling techniques. Snowball techniques were used in selecting the
Muslim and Christian respondents in each barangay There were one hundred
respondents in this study comprised of fifty Christians and fifty Muslims. The key
informants were the council of elders or former or current barangay officials who
resided in Cotabato for more than ten years and are knowledgeable about the history
of Cotabato City.
Research Instrument
The instruments of the study were a survey questionnaire, interview on the
respondents and a key informant interview. The questionnaire has five parts: Part I –
the profile of the respondents, Part II – defining trust, Part III – level of trust, Part IV –
the relationship between Muslims and Christians, and Part V – factors influencing the
full trust.
To validate the results of the survey questionnaires key informants were
interviewed to make the study more reliable. The key informant interviews were
selected council of elders or former or current barangay officials who resided for
more than ten years and who are knowledgeable about the history of the place.
Data Analysis
8
The researcher used frequency, percentage, and a 5-point Likert scale for
parts I, III, and V. On the other hand, a thematic analysis was employed to analyze
parts II and IV of the study.
Ethical Considerations
The researcher ensures the protection and confidentiality of the respondent’s
personal information. This would involve obtaining informed consent from the
respondents before they agree to take part in the research, explaining the purpose of
the study, and ensuring that their identities are not disclosed without their
permission. The researcher asked permission from the respondents to take photos
during the interview.
9
Chapter IV
This chapter presents the results of the data gathered from the study. It
includes the analysis and interpretation of the data gathered on the intercultural trust
between Christians and Muslims in Cotabato City.
10
10 -20 years 64 64%
21- 30 years 25 25%
31- 40 years 10 10%
41-50 years 1 1%
Mean:17 years 100 100%
The table shows the demographic data of the participants: Thirty- three
representing (33%) of the respondents were Male, and sixty-six representing (66%)
were Female. The \majority of the respondents (58%) of the total falls within the age
ranges 31-40 and 41-50. The mean age of the group is 41 years old. The majority
were high school graduates at 30% of the total followed by college graduates at 24%.
Most respondents have lived for 10-20 years with 64% of the total. The mean number
of years of residency is 17.
11
at secure ka sa secure.
lahat ng bagay.”
8 “Salig para sa laki Trust for me is R1
na katabangan someone who can
endu gasuportahan help and support you
ka nin sa in any problem.
problema.”
9 “Someone who can Someone who can R3
rely on sa anumang rely on times of need.
problema.”
10 “Taw a maubay A person who can R7
nengka entuba I count on that is trust
salig para sa laki.” for me.
11 “Trust is reliable Trust is relied in R8
and dependable.” various
circumstances.
12 “Tao na pwede Someone you can turn R9
mong malapitan sa to in times of need.
oras ng
pangangailangan.”
13 “Pwede mong Someone you can R13
pagsabihan ng share your secrets.
sikreto iyon ang
ibig sabihin ng trust
sa akin.”
14 “Tiwala para sa Someone you can R16
akin pwede mong share your secrets.
pagsabihan ng
sikreto.”
15 “May malalapitan You can turn to in R17
ka sa oras ng times of need.
kagipitan.”
16 “Malalapitan mo in Someone you can turn R25
times of need.” to in times of need.
17 “Taong Someone who can R31
masasandalan mo lean on times of
sa kalungkutan.” sadness.
18 “Salig sa laki a Someone you can R32
gaubay nengka sa approach at any time.
uras a kasengitan.”
19 “Someone who can Someone supportive R41
rely on and depend in times of need.
on.”
20 “Someone who can Supporting both R43
share your ups and successes and
downs.” challenges.
21 “May confidence ka A person who is P18
mag open ng confident to open
problema sa iba problems.
iyon ang trust para
sa akin.”
22 “Ang pagsalig sa A person you can P40
akoa ay tao nga share your secrets.
masultihan nimo sa
12
imoang problema.”
23 “Kung komportable A person who is P47
ka nga ipaambit comfortable to share
ang imong mga secrets with others.
sekreto sa uban.”
13
37 “Someone whom A person whom you P28
you share your can open your secrets.
secrets.”
38 “Someone who is Someone consistent in P10
showing their actions.
consistency in
action.”
39 “A person know Someone gives value P38
how to value to others.
someone or
something.”
40 “Taong may Someone show P21
respeto sa respect to individual
pagkakaiba ng tao.” differences.
41 “Having complete Someone who is P7
confidence to believing other's
someone that is integrity.
trust for me.”
42 “Usa ka tawo nga Someone who shows P39
naghatag kanimo respect.
ug respeto kato
ang salig.”
14
53 “May mabuting A person with good P15
intensyon sa intention to others.
kapwa, hindi
nanlalamang.”
54 “Taong may isang A person who keeps P16
salita, walang their words, without
tinatago na sikreto.” hiding secrets.
55 “Pagsalig kanang A person who upholds P25
tao nga matinuoron their principles and is
ug mapugsanon.” honest.
15
73 “Something that is Built on mutual effort, R44
earned, shared, shared experience,
and respected.” respect.
74 “When you are Respect your privacy R47
comfortable to and keep your secrets.
share your
secrets.”
75 “Shows integrity, Treating others with R49
and respect.” dignity.
76 “Matapat na Honest and respectful R22
pakikisama sa with others.
kapwa mo.”
77 “Something that Something that R30
acts responsible behaves responsibly.
and dependable
manner.”
78 “May mabuting pag With good manners. R20
uugali.”
79 “Hindi ka kayang Someone who does R18
idiscriminate.” not judge others.
80 “Tao na may Willing to believe in R21
magandang ugali at their good intentions.
honest.”
81 “Showing Committed to work R10
consistency in and deeds.
action.”
82 “Personal bond Willing to help without R46
who shared expecting in return.
genuine
connections.”
83 “Marunong Who can keep R33
magkeep ng secrets.
secrets.”
84 “Siguro ang tiwala Keeping promises. R35
ay iyong ginagawa
yun pangako.”
85 “Taong marespeto A person who is R38
sa kapitbahay.” respectful to his
neighbors.
86 “Knows how to give Consistent in fulfilling R42
and take.” commitment.
87 “Builds commitment Knows reciprocity. R45
to someone.”
88 “Someone who is Strong dedication and R48
telling the truth.” loyalty.
89 “Tao na may A person with good R5
magandang ugali at manners and honest.
honest.”
90 “Trust ay isang tao Trust is someone Empathy and R19
na marunong shows empathy. positive
makiramay sa interactions
kasama nya.”
91 “A person with Someone who is R15
genuine care for sincere or concern to
16
someone” others.
92 “A person who Willing to listen to R28
provides a listening others without
ear and judgment.
compassionate
heart.”
93 “Something that Someone with mutual R50
has positive understanding.
interactions.”
94 “Salaki na salig Trust means someone R12
manan nin na who can understand
gasabutan na isa I others.
mangiginawa na
kapidin.”
95 “May mutual Someone with mutual R24
understanding sa understanding.
bawat isa.”
96 “Ang mga tawo nga Someone who is P27
nagsulti sa telling the truth.
kamatuoran tungod
97 sa sugo sa Dios.” Someone who is God- Faith and P33
“Pagbaton ug fearing. Truthfulness
pagtuo ug pagsalig
sa giya sa Diyos.”
17
reliable and supportive without expecting in return. In times of happiness and
sadness, they can be relied on.
18
Strongly disagree/No trust 1 1.00-1.80
Disagree/low trust 2 1.81-2.60
Neutral/moderate trust 3 2.61-3.40
Agree/High Trust 4 3.41-4.20
Strongly agree/Complete 5 4.21-5.00
Trust
The table showed that the highest mean score of 4. 14 indicating a high level
of trust is for the statement “I believe my Muslim neighbors are respectful and
understanding” and the lowest mean score of 3.06 suggesting a neutral or moderate
level of trust in sharing personal information with Muslim neighbors among Christian
respondents. Overall, the mean score for all statements combined is 3.60,
19
representing the category of “Agree/High level of Trust” indicating the overall positive
level of trust towards Muslim neighbors. This showed that Christian respondents
generally have a positive perception and high level of trust towards their Muslim
neighbors, particularly in terms of respect and understanding, while feeling slightly
less comfortable sharing personal information with them.
The table presented that the highest mean score of 4.56 indicating a very
high level is for the statement “I believe my Christian neighbors are respectful and
understanding” while 2.86 is the lowest mean score for the statement “I feel
20
comfortable sharing personal information with my Christian neighbors” suggesting a
lower level of trust. Overall, 3.56 is the mean score indicating a high level of trust.
Overall, the mean score for all statements is 3.56, under the category of
"Agree/High Trust," which indicates an overall positive level of trust towards Christian
neighbors among Muslim respondents in terms of respect and understanding, while
feeling less comfortable sharing personal information with them.
According to Gibb's Theory of Group Development examining how groups
work together. His premise is quite simple: as trust increases, defensive and
unproductive behavior decreases. The greater the degree of trust, the easier it is for
people to shed roles and give up postures that inhibit the flow of vital information. As
trust increases, people are free to offer opinions, critiques, and praise. Ironically, few
work groups ever address the issue of trust in any direct way and are condemned to
hours of frustrating and non-productive meetings. His theory examines how trust is
formed, how it can be broken, and the impact it has on relationships and interactions.
Trust is typically built through consistent and reliable behavior, effective
communication, and the perception of shared values and intentions
21
nakaasawa ang mga anak through personal
ko ng Muslim. Marunong experiences,
silang mag give and take such as children
at marespeto kahit na marrying
dating kristiyano ang mga Muslims, and the
anak ko. May mga importance of
kaugalian sila na hindi ko compromise,
maintindihan katulad ng respect, and
pagsuot ng hijab at hindi communication
pagkain ng buong araw in bridging
mas nauunawaan ko dahil cultural
pinapaintindi ng mga in differences.
laws ko ano ang dahilan ng
mga iyon.”
4 “Binibigyang halaga namin Christian P20
ang bawat isa dahil sa highlights the
magkakamaganak din ang importance of
mga lolo namin. Kung may valuing each
gulo o may hindi other within the
pagkakaunawaan family circle, by
hinahayaan naming na ang resolving
mga nakakatanda ang conflicts and
umaayos.” misunderstandin
gs through the
guidance of
elders.
5 “Dati akong kristyano na The challenges R3
nakapagasawa ng Muslim and eventual
na ngayon balik Islam, sa acceptance
una napakahirap para sa faced by an
akin pakisamahan ang individual who
mga muslim dahil transitioned from
naninibago ako sa Christianity to
kaugalian nila malayo sa Islam through
nakasanayan ko. marriage
Napakachallenging part sa struggled with
akin kapag magfasting na adapting to
dahil hindi ako sanay sa Muslim customs,
madaling araw gigising at but in time
kakain, pag pray ng five embraced and
times sa isang araw at yun learned to
babasahin mong Arabic understand the
during prayer pero hindi traditions of their
nagtagal nakasanayan ko spouse's faith.
na din. Acceptance lang
talaga ang kailangan at
matututunan mo din ang
kaugalian nila.”
6 “Dito sa bahay namin Initial difficulties R8
dalawang pamilya ang experienced by
naninirahan, kami na two families
muslim at mga bayaw kung living together
kristiyano, hindi naging due to confusion
Madali sa una dahil nalillito among the
22
ang mga anak ko pero children, which
hindi nagtagal naintindihan were overcome
din ng bawat isa. Respeto through mutual
lang talaga kasi kung may understanding
respeto kahit iba kayo ng and respect.
paniniwala mauunawaan
mo sila.”
7 “We are close kahit na Close R35
magkaiba kami ng religion. relationships and
Sa tagal na siguro ng strong bonds
pagsasama bilang formed despite
magkapitbahay kaya different
masasabi kong close kami. religious
Nung hindi pa naasawa ni differences.
papa si mama kristiyano si
mama. Karamihan ng
kapitbahay namin na
kristiyano kamaganak ni
mama. Si mama dating
katoliko pinapaintindi nya
sa amin yun practices
meron ang mga kristyano.”
8 “Wala masyadong Christian had Respect and P21
interaction with them kasi I limited understanding
have may work outside the interaction due beyond religious
city but wala namang to work differences
problema kasi here in our commitments
barangay we show respect despite religious
sa isat isa kahit we are differences
different in terms of mutual respect is
religion.” upheld.
9 “We give the same Equal treatment P41
treatment to them, mga towards
respetadong tao. religion is neighbor’s
not a barrier to unity and despite of
friendship.” religious
differences.
10 “Marespeto sila sa Muslim P16
kapitbahay Hindi showcase a
nakikialam sa buhay ng sense of mutual
may buhay.” respect and
privacy in the
community.
11 “Masasabi kong marespeto The respect R6
sila lalo na kapag araw ng shown by others,
pagsamba namin tuwing particularly
Friday walang ingay sa during their
lugar namin.” Friday worship.
12 “Although we are different Appreciates R10
in terms of beliefs, I respect shown
appreciate my Christian by their Christian
neighbors because they neighbors,
know how to show respect especially during
to us, especially during the Ramadan.
23
month of Ramadhan.”
13 “Marespeto lalo pa na alam The neighbors R13
nila na muslim kami kasi preventing any
dito may nagpapabenta sa discomfort or
unahan namin ng bawal sa offense.
amin, hindi nila hinahayaan
na maamoy namin ang
pinapabenta nila.”
14 “Our house is beside the Despite the loud R20
chapel and every Sunday Sunday worship
nagsisimba sila na halos services at the
magigising ka sa lakas ng nearby chapel,
pagsasamba nila pero both
hindi yun nagiging dahilan communities
ng hindi pagkakaunawaan show respect for
dahil kapag kami naman each other's
ang nagpipray makikita mo prayer practices,
kung paano sila rumespeto fostering
sa amin.” understanding
and harmony.
“Namumuhay naman kami We avoid things R23
15 dito na may respeto sa isat when we know
isa kapag alam namin na that is forbidden
hindi pwede o bawal para for others.
sa iba iniiwasan namin
yon.”
16 “Sa likod ng bahay namin There is a R38
dito sa Fatima may chapel, chapel behind
wala naman akong our house, I see
nakikitang masama dahil nothing wrong
mas nauna sila dito kaysa with my
sa akin kaya dapat ko iyon Christian
intindihin. Ang mahalaga neighbors, I
naniniwala ako na iisa ang should
Panginoon.” understand that.
What is
important there
is only one God.
24
20 “Maayos naman kami ng Maintains good P2
mga kapitbahay kong relationship and
muslim, may pagkakataon often seeking for
na kapag may problema help with their
sila pa ang una kong Muslim
nalalapitan. Pero huwag neighbors.Dont
mong sagarin ang test the patience
pasensya nila dahil iba sila of a Muslim as
kung magalit.” they have
different way of
expressing their
anger.
21 “Masaya dahil welcome The hospitable P14
kaming manood sa bahay nature of the
nila ng palabas sa TV, Muslim
nakakautang kami sa neighbors,
tindahan kahit na hindi nurturing a
namin sila kaano ano.” sense of
camaraderie
within the
neighborhood.
25
bumaha dito sa amin wala times of disaster
kaming kamaganak dito sa even without
purok bagong silang hindi blood relations.
sukat akalain ng pamilya
ko na kahit nabahaan din
sila hindi sila nagdalawang
isip na tulungan kami.
Naiyak na lang ako dahil
hinndi ko ito kadugo pero
handang tumulong ng
walang kapalit.”
25 “As a teacher sa Brgy. Regardless of R40
Guiawa, Northern religious
Kabuntalan, lagi ako wala differences, it
sa bahay, noong bago pa shows support
kami dito sa tinitirhan and protection
namin may doubt ako na on each
what if pasukin at neighbors.
pagnakawan kami dahil
iilan pa lang ang muslim na
nakatira dito pero ang
pagdududa na iyon ay
napalitan ng tiwala dahil
ngayon iniiwan ko lang ang
susi sa kapitbahay namin
na kristiyano. When we're
not home, we can always
rely on our neighbors to
monitor our property and
let us know about any
strange activity. Panatag
ako kahit wala ako sa
bahay.”
26 “Minsan mahiya man ako Feel hesitant to Social Barriers P12
makipagusap sa mga engage in and Interpersonal
muslim ko na kapitbahay conversations dynamics
dahil professional sila na with their Muslim
ako nagatinda ng isda. neighbors.
Pinipili ko lang yun
kinakausap ko kasi minsan
yun professional hindi ako
makasabay sa usapan nila
mahiya din ako.”
27 “Minsan nahihiya kami A feeling of P42
makipagusap dahil mga shyness desire
professional sila at respeto to maintain a
na lang talaga lalo na respectful
kapag may mga okasyon distance,
sila.” particularly in
formal events.
28 “Nahihiya sa kanila dahil Difference in P27
karamihan sa kanila may terms of
mga kaya sa buhay.” socioeconomic
leading to
26
inferiority.
29 “Wala ako gaanong Simple greetings R33
interaction sa kanila kasi of hi and hello
nahihiya ako dahil mga then I don’t have
professional itong sa tabi much interaction
namin may pinagaralan pa. because I feel
Hanggang hi and hello shy, they are
Maam and Sir lang.” professionals.
30 “Magpansinan din kung sense of hesitant P39
makasalubong natin sa and inferiority
labasan pero bihira lang due to social
kay mahiya din tayo status.
minsan mga professional
man sila kesa sa atin ba.”
31 “ Walang gulo dahil kilala Living over the Building Strong P22
na namin ang bawat isa, years lead to Interpersonal
sa tagal ba naman ng mutual Connections
pagtira namin dito simula understanding through Cultural
pa ng isinilang ako and familiarity. Understanding
nakamulatan ko na ang
mga Muslim. May mga
anak na rin akong
nakapangawa ng Muslim.
Unti nti ko na rin
nauunawaan ang kanilang
kaugalian.”
32 “Sa lugar namin Frequent P1
magkakatabi ang bahay, conversation
bakod lang ang pagitan. and interaction
Halos araw –araw sila ang lead to
kausap ko dahil nasa harmonious and
bahay lang lagi ako friendly
nagbabantay ng mga anak. relationship.
Maganda ang relasyon ko
sa mga kapitbahay kong
muslim, akakalain mong
kabisado ko na ang
kanilang salita hanggang
sa paguusap
nagmamaguindanaon na
ako. May mga anak na din
ako na inembrace ang
Islam.”
33 “Dati hindi masyado ako Embracing P3
nakikipagusap sa kanila cultural
naninibago ako dahil ang differences
mga sabi sa akin ng mga leading to a
kakilala ko na taliwas sa deeper
paniniwala ko ang appreciation and
paniniwala nila pero hindi respect for
nagtagal unti ko din na diverse beliefs
iintindihan ang kanilang and practices.
paniniwala lalo pa na
muslim ang napangasawa
27
ko.
34 “Kasundo ko sila kasi dati I get along with R14
ng magkakaibigan ang them because
mga magulang namin our parents were
hanggang sa mga anak friends and now
namin. Walang gulo dahil our children. We
alam namin ang bawat know how to set
limitasyon ng bawat isa.” our limitations.
35 “Karamihan sa kaibigan ko Most of my R28
Christian sila yun friends are
pinagsasabihan ko ng Christians and I
sikreto kasi Madali nila confide them my
akong naiintindihan walang secrets and
bahid na judgement sa easily inderstand
pagkatao ko.” and never judge
my personality.
36 “Matulungin sila lalo na Offer support Community P40
kapag may emergency dito and assistance Solidarity and
sa lugar namin may within the Mutual Support
namatay may bigay din sila community in
ng abuloy sa namatayan at times of grieving
makiramay sa namatayan.” family by offering
contributions
and expressing
their
condolences.
28
walang alinlangan
tumulong sila pati mga
kamaganak nil ana
maghakot ng gamit.”
41 “Mabuti naman kapag may When there is an R48
emergency wala pang emergency, in
isang minuto nandyan sila less than a
para tumulong. Kapag may minute they are
binibigay mula sa there to
barangay hindi nila help.When the
kinakalimutan na isali barangay
kami.” provide
smething they
never forget to
include us.
42 “Maganda ang samahan There is unity P33
kahit na hindi kami and cooperation
magkakaano ano at kahit despite of
iba kami ng panniniwala differences.
nagkakaisa kami dito at
nagtutulungan.”
43 “Nakikisama sila lalo na Show P13
kapag fiesta dito sa willingness to
Manday, dito kasi sa purok cooperate and
naming tuwing fiesta share generous
nagpapalaro kami sa mga financial
bata at ang ginagawa contributions.
namin humihingi kami ng
kaunting donasyon sa mga
bahay-bahay at iyon ang
ginagamit namin sa prizes,
pagkain ng mga bata.
Hindi sila nagdadalawang
isip na magabot ng pera sa
amin at iyon ang na
appreciate namin sa kanila
dahil naiintindihan nila
kami.”
44 “Ang lugar namin halo halo We live in a R2
na ang nakatira may place where a
Muslim, Christian at Bajao mixture of
pero ganoon pa man wala residents
akong nararamdamang including
takot dahil sanay na kami Muslim,
sa bawat isa. Kapag may Christians, and
programa ang barangay Bajao people,
asahan mo lahat nakikisali but despite this
lalo na kapag ito ay diversity, I do not
makakabuti sa aming fear, we are
lugar.” accustomed to
each other. You
can expect that
everyone to
participate
29
whenever there
is an activity or
program in our
place.
45 “Marunong makisama kahit Muslim P23
na minsan nadadaanan neighbors
kami na nagiinuman lalo respect and
na kapag fiesta sa amin understand the
naiintindihan nila kami.” customs and
practices of the
Christians.
46 “Sa tagal ko dito sa lugar Having various P49
namin at nagkaroon ng ibat kind o Christian
ibang klase ng christian na neighbors, I
kapitbahay wala ako cannot describe
madescribe na masama sa anything
kanila kasi marunong negative about
silang makisama. them, they know
Naiintindihan nila yun mga how to get
paniniwala meron ako at along. They
nirerespeto nila ito. understand my
Napakasarap sa beliefs and
pakiramdam na respect them
nauunawaan ka ng and it feels great
kapitbahay mo kahit na to understood by
alam mo na magkaiba others.
kayo ng paniniwala.”
47 “Okay naman naiintindihan Muslim display P37
nila kami lalo na kapag tolerance and do
may mga okasyon ang not become
mga kristiyano katulad ng agitated and
fiesta at Christmas and have a good
new year hindi sila understanding of
nagagalit sa amin kung the Christians
maingay kami.” customs and
practices.
48 “Hindi mahirap There is a P47
pakisamahan kaya cooperation with
masasabi kong healthy each other and
and peaceful ang easy to get
environment namin may along with
pakikisama sa bawat isa.” Muslim
neighbors.
49 “Mabuti man kasi itong Like me, R4
mga kristiyano na Christian
kapitbahay ko umiiwas din neighbors avoid
sa gulo gusto lang din nila trouble and like
katulad ko na tahimik na a peaceful life.
buhay.”
50 “Marunong silang Christian R16
makiramay lalo na kapag neighbors know
may namatay. Hindi mo how to
makikita na iba sila dahil sympathize
marunong sila when someone
30
makisimpatya.” dies.
51 “Marunong silang Christian R47
makiramay lalo na kapag neighbors know
may namatayan hanggang how to
sa pag libing andun sila. sympathize
Yan ang hindi mawawala when someone
sa mga kristiyano.” dies until the
burial.
52 “Nagtutulungan ang mga Muslims and R32
tao dito lalo na kapag may Christians help
sakuna lalo pa noong each other in
nagkaroon ng sunog sa times of need.
may night market, Christians are
karamihan na nakatira sa sincere to help.
night market mga muslim
wala akong masabi sa
pagtulong ng mga
Christian dito sa amin dahil
makikita mo sa kanila yun
sincerity ng pagtulong.”
53 “They are open- minded Christian R34
person kasi hindi issue sa neighbors are
amin dito ang religion open-minded
Kapag nagpapray kami people, religion
they give respect and is not an issue.
same way too. Tulong They give
tulong kami sa respect to each
pagpapaganda ng lugar other. Both work
namin kasi naniniwala together
kami na ang makikinabang believing that
ay ang mga anak namin.” their children
can benefit to
the community.
54 “Maappreciate ko sa kanila I appreciate my R42
na tuwing Ramadhan hindi Christian
sila nag iingay lalo pa kung neighbors
tumatawag ng Bang sa during
masjid. Pinapatay nila ang Ramadhan, they
pinapatugtog nila.” turn off what
they are playing
during prayer
time at the
mosque.
55 “Wala ako problema sa I don’t have R45
mga kapitbahay ko problems with
marunong silang my Christian
makisama at mapagbigay.” neighbors, they
know how to get
along and they
are generous.
56 “Napakaconcern ng mga Christian R46
kapitbahay kong Christian neighbors are
dahil hindi nila kami concerned on
nakakalimutan kapag may their Muslim
31
binibigay na tulong mula sa neighbors. They
barangay. Sinasali nila don’t forget their
kami kung sila ang unang Muslim
nakakaalam na may neighbors to
ibibigay na tulong. include when
Ramdam din nila yun hirap giving
ng buhay namin.” assistance from
the
barangay.Christi
ans understand
the hardship of
life.
57 “Sa tagal ko dito sa lugar Having different R49
namin at nagkaroon ng ibat Christian
ibang klase ng christian na neighbors, I
kapitbahay wala ako cannot say
madescribe na masama sa negative
kanila kasi marunong comments to
silang makisama. them. They
Naiintindihan nila yun mga understand and
paniniwala meron ako at respect my
nirerespeto nila ito. beliefs.
Napakasarap sa
pakiramdam na
nauunawaan ka ng
kapitbahay mo kahit na
alam mo na magkaiba
kayo ng paniniwala.”
58 “Mas gusto ko pa na Christian prefers Interfaith P18
maging kapitbahay ang having Muslim Respect and
Muslim dahil mas madali neighbors Understanding
silang makaunawa at because they
marunong rumespeto at are respectful
hindi nakikialam sa buhay and do not
ng iba.” meddle others’
lives
59 “Sa gilid ng simbahan Muslim P28
namin may mga muslim na neighbors
nakatira, wala man silang showed
reklamo sa tuwing may understanding
simba o fiesta dahil mga and acceptance
teachers sila at kami na on the customs
lang nahihiya dahil naiisip and practices of
namin na masamok na sila Christians
sa ingay.”
60 “Okay naman wala Muslim P37
gaanong problema dito sa understand and
amin hindi nagiging issue respect each
ang religion kasi limitation
naiintindihan ng bawat isa
ang limitasyon ng kada isa
at nirerespeto ito ng bawat
isa.”
61 “Walang pakialamanan ng Both Christian R19
32
buhay basta manirahan ka and Muslims
lang ng tama at walang mind their own
naaagrabyado kahit iba business.
man kami ng estado okay
lang.”
62 “Okay man, dito sa lugar Both Christian R36
namin iba iba man kami and Muslim
ang importante understand each
nagkakaintindihan.” other.
63 “Marunong silang humingi Christian R37
ng sorry kapag makagawa neighbors knows
sila ng ingay katulad ng how to apologize
may kasiyahan sa bahay when they
nila kung gabi.” disturb their
Muslim
neighbors.
64 “Maganda ang samahan Both Christian R39
namin dito wala naman and Muslim has
may gusto ng magulong a smooth
lugar, tulad nila hangad ko relationship.
rin na tahimik at peaceful
yun titirhan ko.”
65 “Mapagbigay sila dahil Muslims are Community P15
kapag may kanduli willing to share Generosity and
iniimbitahan kami. May what they have Inclusivity
tulong mula sa BARMM with others
makatanggap din kami.”
66 “Mapagbigay sila lalo pa Muslim P45
kung Ramadhan na nila neighbors are
dahil malapit kami sa generous during
masjid tuwing sasapit ang Ramadhan, they
Iftar pati kaming mga share foods.
kristiyano nabibigyan ng
pagkain mula sa masjid at
masaya kami dahil
masasarap ang binibigay
sa amin.”
67 “We give and take talaga. Both Christian P25
Just like what we did with and Muslim has
our Christian brothers and give and take
sisters.” relationship.
68 “Mabuti naman we share Muslims share P35
foods kung may occasion food and they
sa amin iniinvite naming treat Christian
sila and ganun din sila sa neighbors like a
amin. Sa tagal na ng family.
pagiging magkapitbahay
hindi na sila iba sa amin.”
69 “Mabubuti sila sa Muslims invited P28
kapitbahay nila dahil kapag Christians when
may okasyon sa kanila there is occasion
iniimbitahan nila kami lalo like Ramadhan.
na kapag Ramadhan.”
70 “Masaya naman dito sa Christian R18
33
amin dahil kilala na namin neighbors are
ang bawat kapitbahay, kind, invite
ugali nila nagbibigayan Muslim
kapag merong salo-salo.” neighbors to
their parties.
71 “Wala akong masabing Muslims R22
masama sa mga appreciated their
kapitbahay kong Christian Christian
dahil napakamabuti nila sa neighbors who
amin, binibigyan kami ng are kind, they
ulam, iniimbitahan kapag gave food, and
may handaan sa kanila at willing to help.
kapag may emergency
handa silang tumulong.”
72 “Mabuti ang pakikitungo Christian treated R26
nila sa amin mapagbigay well their Muslim
at may concern sa neiighbors, are
kapitbahay lalo na kapag generous, and
may okasyon sa bahay nila show concern
magpapaalam ng konteng for their
inuman kaya naiintindihan neighbors.
naming sila.”
73 “Masaya kami dito sa Both Christian R30
purok namin hindi mo and Muslim
makikita ang kanya kanya. neighbors has a
Kapag may handaan sense of
nagbibigayan. Kapag community.
Fiesta nila binibigyan kami They share
ng pagkain at sinisigurado foods during
nila na hindi haram ang gatherings, they
maibigay nil ana pagkain see to it that the
sa amin. Kapag food is not
magsambayang every against on our
Friday wala kang maririnig belief. They
na nagpapatugtog ng show respect
karaoke nila. Napakalapit during prayer
ng masjid sa bahay nila times.
pero andun ang respeto ng
mga Christian.”
74 “Madami akong kaibigan Muslim neighbor R44
na Christian open ako sa have many
bahay nila. Kapag may Christian friends
salo salo orccasion invited who are not
talaga ako. Sila yun mas judgemental.
nasasabihan ko ng
problema ko sa pag-ibig
man o sa pamilya kasi
hindi ko nakikita na
judgmental sila.”
75 “Madalas lang Occasional Respectful P32
magpansinan kasi may conversation Coexistence and
mga trabaho ang bawat isa due to work. Understanding
pero ganun man okay
naman hindi sila
34
nakakagulo sa lugar
namin.”
76 “Lagi naman ako sa Occasional P25
trabaho sa buong araw conversation
minsanan lang din kami due to work.
magkaroon ng paguusap
dahil nagtatrabaho din
sila.”
77 “We love our Muslim Value the love P35
neighbors kasi we grown and care we
up here, they are my good have for each
friends. They treated us other.
like brothers and sisters
and same with them.”
78 “Bihira lang kung Occasional P6
makausap ko sila kasi conversation
nakabakod itong bahay due to work at
namin. Mas nakafocus ako home.
sa trabaho sa bahay pero
okay man din ang relasyon
namin sa kanila.”
79 “Batian lang kapag Limited P7
nagkasalubong sa daan conversation
pag nagkasabay sa labas with each other.
ng sasakyan hi hello po
yun lang.”
80 “Nagkakaintindihan kami We understand P27
dito sa barangay namin. each other and
Walang pakialamanan mind our own
dahil may kanya kanya business.
tayong buhay.”
81 “Peaceful naman dito sa Both live P37
barangay namin peacefully and
magkaintindihan ang tao understand each
dito.” other.
82 “Okay lang man madalas Limited P8
sa tindahan kung may conversation
bibilhin nagakamustahan. with Muslim
Madaliang paguusap lang neighbors due to
kay hindi rin ako msyadong language barrier.
lumalabas ng bahay kay
mahiya din tayo minsan sa
kanila kay hindi ako
gaanong marunong
magsalita ng tagalog kay
Cebuano ang ginagamit
namin sa bahay.”
83 “Minsanan lang Limited P49
nagkakausap dahil busy sa conversation,
trabaho sa palengke.Wala Muslim
naman problema sa mga neighbors can
kapitbahay kong Muslim understand
makaintindi man sila.” easily.
84 “Hindi ko gaanong Muslim doesn't R9
35
nakakahalubilo itong mga interact much
kapitbahay ko dahil sa with their
Monday to Friday nasa neighbors
trabaho ako siguro kapag because they
nagkakasalubong sa daan are always at
magpapansinan tulad ng work from
pagtaas ng kamay or hi Monday to
and hello pero yun matagal Friday. They
na paguusap walang may exchange
ganoon.” greetings when
they cross paths
on the street, but
they don't have
long
conversations
with them.
85 “Hindi ko sila gaanong Muslim often talk R12
nakakausap dahil lagi ako to their Christian
nasa trabaho pero maayos neighbors
naman ang samahan dito because they
sa barangay namin kahit are always at
iba iba ang nakatira dito.” work but they
have good
relationship in
their community.
86 “Bihira lang kung Muslim rarely R24
makipagusap sa kanila talks to their
hindi naman ako Christian
tumatambay sa labasan neighbors. They
kung bibili lang sa tindahan interact when
or maghatid ng anak sa they need to buy
school nakakasalamuha ko something from
sila.” the store or drop
off their child at
school.
87 “Pansinan din kung may Don’t ignore R29
time pangit naman na your neighbor,
kapitbahay mo hindi mo na as they are the
papansinin dahil maniwala first ones who
ako na dapat maganda can help you in
ang relasyon mo sa times of need.
kapitbahay dahil sa oras
ng pangangailangan sila
ang unang makakatulong
sa iyo.”
88 “Madalas lang kung We often talk, R43
magusap usap lalo na sometimes
kung may meeting sa brgy. during meeting
Namin regarding sa 4ps.” regarding 4Ps.
89 “Wala akong masabi sa Good things to Neighborly P16
mga kapitbahay kong say about Bonds and
muslim para ko na silang Muslim Mutual Respect
kapatid dahil sa tagal ng neighbors,
pinagsamahan ng pamilya grown to each
36
namin, kilala na naming other as family.
ang bawat isa.”
90 “Mababait sila dahil una Muslim P43
may pinagaralan silang neighbors are
tao, mapagbigay sa kapwa kind, families
at nakasanayan na ng have become
pamilya namin dahil sa accustomed to
matagal na pagiging each other due
magkapitbahay.” to long-standing
relationship as
neighbors.
91 “Sa tinagal namin Muslim P44
nanirahan dito sa Cotabato neighbors are no
parang masabi mo na din different from us
na hindi na iba ang mga Christians.
Muslim sa amin. Dati sila Sharing of
ang kasama naming practices in the
maligo ng ilog ngayon mga community.
anak naman namin ang
gumagawa nun.”
92 “Sa 20 years na pagtira ko Muslims are P50
sa barangay namin wala religious people
akong nakaaway na who strive to
muslim dahil mga religious avoid disputes.
sila umiiwas sa gulo.”
93 “Napakawelcome nila lalo Both Muslim and R17
na sa amin, dito kasi sa Christian treated
purok manuel turingan each other like a
namin dito magkakaibigan family.
dahil sa tagal na naming
nakatira dito.”
94 “Hindi ako nakikipagusap I don’t engage in Fear and P8
sa mga kapitbahay naming conversation Intimidation
Muslim umiiwas ako sa with my Muslim
gulo. Mahirap pa naman neighbors to
sila kausap hindi avoid conflict, I
magpatalo. Hindi naman find it difficult to
lahat yun iba walang communicate
pakialam sa kalinisan dito because they
sa lugar namin. are stubborn.
Pinapabayaan ang kalat Some of them
kaya minsan isa yan sa do not care
kinaiinisan ko sa kanila.” about
cleanliness.
95 “Minsan natatakot sa mga Scared of P10
Muslim dahil kapag may Muslim
gulo at sangkot sila neighbors due to
nagbabanta sila at troublemaker,
nagdadala pa ng mga make threats
kamag anak na taga ibang and bring
lugar para manakot. relatives from
Sasabihin na madami other places to
silang makakalaban mo intimidate.
kapag kinalaban mo
37
sila.Minsan ko na kasi
itong nakitang sitwasyon
sa mga kamaganak kong
Christian din.”
96 “As a Muslim, I am more As a Muslim, I R5
comfortable socializing am more
with my Christian friends in comfortable
our community rather than socializing with
my Muslim friends kasi my Christian
strict and parents nila than friends in our
with my Christian friends.” community
rather than my
Muslim friends
because they
have strict
parents than
with my
Christian friends.
97 “Iniiwasan ko sila dahil I can still R7
hindi pa rin mawala ang remember the
alaala ko noong 1972 time during
nagkaMartial Law, Martial Law in
madaming Moro ang 1972 when
sinaktan, namatay, palipat many Moros
lipat ng tirahan. Kami na were killed, hurt
taga Kampo Muslim and displaced.
pinaghihinalaan na We were
masasama ng mga suspected by
Kristiyanong sunndalo. Christian
Naranasan ko ang soldiers as bein
matadyakan kaya sinasabi evil. I
ko sa mga anak ko wag experienced
magtiwala sa mga being kicked, so
kristiyano.” I tell to my
children not to
trust Christians
38
kaya hindi ako family conflicts
nakikipagusap sa kanila. as they tend to
Ang sabi ng Lolo ko nung inquire and
panahon ng Martial law gossip about
pinahirapan sila ng mga them. According
Kristiyanong sundalo, to my
sinasaktan sila tulad ng grandfather,
sinusuntok, binabatukan during Martial
kaya dati nagpapanggap law, they were
sila na Christian para hindi oppressedby
sila saktan.Kaya hindi na Christian
gaano kaming nagtitiwala soldiers, who
sa kanila.” hurt them by
punching and
slapping them.
They used to
pretend to be
Christians so
they wouldn’t get
hurt. That is why
we don’t trust
them.
1OO “Hindi maiwasan na Muslims R27
minsan naiinis tayo sa sometimes feel
ating kapitbahay na annoyed with
Christian lalo na dito sa Christian
purok namin na neighbors who
magkakatabi ang bahay drink alcohol
dahil may mga ginagawa which results to
sila na hindi naayon sa disruptive
aming nakaugalian katulad behavior like
ng pagiinom ng alak na shouting,
minsan iyon ang sanhi ng causing
gulo dahil kapag nalasing disturbances
sila nagsisisigaw, during midday.
nakakapirwisyo lalo na sa
tanghali.”
The table above reveals that from initial discomfort and uncertainty of the
Christians and Muslims transformed into acceptance of cultural differences. Through
willingness to learn and adapt, cultural experiences such as seeing children marrying
Muslims or Christians and personal connections like cousins lead to a harmonious
relationship. Despite the limited interaction with each other due to work
commitments, the Christian and Muslim neighbors uphold equal treatment towards
each other regardless of religious differences. Both maintain a good relationship with
each other, Christians acknowledge the importance of not testing the patience of a
Muslim neighbor due to their different way of expressing their anger. Some of the
respondents said that there are social barriers in conversation due to feelings of
shyness and socioeconomic status that may lead to feelings of inferiority and
39
hesitation in interacting with neighbors. On the other hand, both Christians and
Muslims come together to offer a helping hand without hesitation, cooperation in
times of need such as maintaining cleanliness and grieving, and acts of sharing
demonstrated by Muslims towards their Christian neighbors particularly during
occasions like Ramadhan while in Christians during Christmas and New Year.
However, despite this, various statements revolve around the two groups facing
issues such as avoidance of conflict, discomfort in socializing, differences in cultural
practices leading to misunderstanding, and the impact of disruptive behaviors on
relationships resulting in social distancing, fear and frustration among the groups.
This was confirmed by the key informants, Christians and Muslims are said to
come together and help one another at difficult times, such as natural disasters, or
family problems. Generally, there is a spirit of mutual respect and collaboration even
though there are occasional cases of feeling inferior or hesitant to interact with each
other due to perceived differences in terms of education or status of living. Interaction
and communication may be limited in some barangays due to work schedules or
gated residences, while in certain barangays where houses are close to one another,
allowing for free dialogue between the Christian and Muslim neighbors.
As quoted in the book of Diaz,(2003) when Muslims and Christians live as
close neighbors, they respect and trust each other. This is the reality at the inter-
personal level. Respect, cooperation, and sharing are emphasized as important
aspects of the relationship between Christians and Muslims.
There is proof of mutual participation in each other's religious celebrations
where Muslims join Christians in celebrating Christmas or New Year or Christians
attending Muslim gatherings like Kanduli or during Eid Ul Fitr and Eid Ul Adha
(Islamic Festivities). In times of mourning, sympathy and support are also extended
between the two groups. Intermarriage or mixed marriage is acknowledged as
another factor that contributes to the good relationship between Christians and
Muslims. The sharing of customs, values, and beliefs is made possible by the
existence of mixed marriages between Christians and Muslims. The link between the
two groups is strengthened by this intermarriage, which helps to foster a better
appreciation and understanding of one another's cultures. Then, In Cotabato City, the
local government made sure that a group of leaders from various religious groups
and sectors in the city came together to form the Cotabato City Inter-Faith Council of
Leaders. Its goal is to provide the city government with assistance during decision-
making. To further lessen misunderstandings and prejudices, the council also hosts
interfaith discussions, workshops, and seminars based on the information revealed
by the key informants.
40
Results and Discussion for Statement of the Problem 5
Table 5. Factors that contribute to the full trust of Muslim and Christian
FACTORS THAT CONTRIBUTE TO THE Frequency Percentage
FULL TRUST
Consistency in words and actions 75 32.96%
Honesty and transparency 91 40.01%
Reliability and dependability 64 28.15%
Mutual respect and understanding 100 43.96%
Shared values and beliefs 36 15.83%
Positive past experiences 60 26.36%
Effective communication and active
listening 24 10.55%
Other (please specify): empathy 5 2.19%
The table shows the factors that contribute to the full trust among Christians
and Muslims in Cotabato City, it reveals that mutual respect and understanding
(43.96%) is the most valued factor in building full trust between the two groups. One
unique aspect revealed in the data is the factor of empathy, which is specified
separately from the other factors. Though empathy may not have the highest
percentage with other factors, its inclusion as a distinct category suggests its
significance in building trust between the two groups.
41
Chapter V
Generalizations
Different forms of trust represent different aspects of human relationships and
human interactions. It can be generalized that trust among Christians and Muslims in
Cotabato City encompasses aspects, first, reliance and support where they can lean
on each other without asking anything in return. Second, sharing and openness allow
open thoughts and feelings without worrying about criticism and betrayal. Third,
associated with integrity and respect keeping promises, treating others with dignity,
and upholding principles. Then for some, trust is rooted in empathy and positive
interactions. Lastly, trust can be connected to faith and truthfulness where there is a
deep sense of fear in God as a fundamental aspect of one’s beliefs and actions.
The study reveals, that both Christian and Muslim respondents in Cotabato
City show a positive perception and a high level of trust with both groups in terms of
mutual respect and understanding. However, both groups have a slight hesitation in
sharing personal information with their neighbors indicating a lower trust in this
aspect.
The study reveals that from the initial discomfort and uncertainty among
Christians and Muslims into acceptance of cultural differences. Despite the limited
interaction with each other due to work commitments, both groups uphold equal
treatment towards each other regardless of religious differences. However, despite
this, various statements revolve around the two groups facing issues that include
social barriers, feelings of inferiority in terms of socioeconomic status, and
misunderstandings based on cultural differences can still create tension leading to
42
misunderstanding, and the impact of disruptive behaviors on relationships resulting in
social distancing, fear, and frustration among the groups. Despite this, both groups
cooperate in times of need.
For the respondents, the most contributing factors are mutual respect and
understanding. Furthermore, the inclusion of empathy as a separate factor
emphasizes its importance in fostering trust together with other key factors in
promoting intergroup relations.
Recommendations
To build a strong relationship and understanding, the local official leaders
should implement programs and initiatives like interfaith dialogues, cultural exchange
programs, and community events to encourage opportunities between Christians and
Muslims in Cotabato City to interact and engage with each other to address social
barriers, feelings of inferiority, and misunderstanding to reduce tension and promote
cultural sensitivity and mutual respect among the two groups. Muslims and Christians
in the community, extend their understanding and trust toward their neighbors. It is
also recommended to conduct future research on the factors that contribute to
building trust between Christians and Muslims in Cotabato City.
43
References
Cabrera, F. B. (2016, June 19). Young Christians join Muslims in Cotabato City for
Iftar. MindaNews. https://mindanews.com/top-stories/2016/06/young-
christians-join-muslims-in-cotabato-city-for-iftar/#gsc.tab=0
Hofstede, G., and Hofstede, G.J., 2005. Cultures and organizations: Software of the
mind. 2nd Ed. New York: McGraw Hill. (book)
Jack Gibb’s Theory of Trust Formation and Group Development. (2018, February
12). studylib.net. https://studylib.net/doc/8605290/jack-gibb-s-theory-of-trust-
formation-and-group-development
44
45