QUESTION 1: Briefly explain the functions of a financial manager in modern corporate framework.

In a modern corporate framework, a financial manager plays a crucial role in ensuring the financial
health and growth of the company. Their key functions include:
1. Financial Planning and Forecasting: Developing short-term and long-term financial plans,
budgeting, and forecasting cash flows to ensure liquidity and support business strategy.
2. Capital Budgeting: Evaluating and selecting investment projects (like expansions or new
product lines) that maximize shareholder value, using techniques like NPV, IRR, and payback
period.
3. Capital Structure Decisions: Determining the optimal mix of debt and equity financing to
minimize the cost of capital while balancing financial flexibility and risk.
4. Working Capital Management: Managing short-term assets (cash, inventory, receivables) and
liabilities (payables) to ensure operational efficiency and liquidity.
5. Risk Management: Identifying, assessing, and mitigating financial risks like currency
fluctuations, interest rate changes, or credit risks.
6. Financial Reporting and Stakeholder Communication: Overseeing the preparation of financial
statements, ensuring compliance with regulations, and communicating financial performance
to investors, creditors, and other stakeholders.
7. Corporate Governance: Ensuring financial decisions align with ethical standards, corporate
social responsibility, and sustainability goals.
8. Mergers, Acquisitions, and Corporate Restructuring: Evaluating potential M&A targets,
negotiating deals, and managing post-merger integration or divestiture processes.
9. Treasury Management: Managing cash flows, banking relationships, and short-term
investments to optimize returns on excess cash.
10. Technology and Data Analytics: Leveraging financial technology and data analytics for better
decision-making, forecasting, and risk management.
In today's dynamic business environment, financial managers are strategic partners in driving business
growth and resilience.
__________________________________________________________________________________
QUESTION 2: "The profit maximization is not an operationally feasible criterion" do you agree?
Illustrate.

Yes, I agree that profit maximization alone is not an operationally feasible criterion for a business.
While profit is a vital measure of a company's success, using it as the sole objective can lead to
suboptimal decisions. Here's why:
1. Time Value of Money: Profit maximization ignores when the profits are earned. A strategy
that yields $1 million profit now may be better than one yielding $1.1 million in 5 years, due
to the opportunity to reinvest current profits.
2. Risk Ignorance: Higher profits often come with higher risks. A project with $500,000 profit
and low risk might be preferable to one with $1 million profit but high risk of failure.
3. Cash Flow vs. Profit: Profits (an accounting measure) don't always reflect cash availability. A
company can show high profits but face a cash crunch if sales are on credit or if there are high
non-cash expenses like depreciation.
4. Short-termism: Focusing solely on profits can lead to short-term decisions (like cutting R&D)
that harm long-term value and sustainability.
 5. Stakeholder Neglect: Profit maximization might lead to decisions that harm employees,
communities, or the environment, damaging the company's reputation and long-term viability.
6. Imprecise: "Maximize profit" doesn't specify which profit measure (gross, operating, net) or
timeframe (quarterly, annually, over project life).
7. Legal and Ethical Issues: Extreme profit focus can lead to unethical or illegal practices (e.g.,
Enron), risking legal penalties and reputational damage.
Illustration: Consider a pharmaceutical company. A profit-maximization approach might lead it to
price a life-saving drug exorbitantly high. This could maximize short-term profits but lead to public
backlash, regulatory scrutiny, loss of goodwill, and reduced long-term value.
Instead, the modern view emphasizes wealth maximization (increasing shareholder value) which
considers the timing, risk, and sustainability of cash flows. It aligns better with stakeholder interests
and long-term success.
__________________________________________________________________________________
QUESTION 3: What is time value of money? How valuation of different securities is made while
taking a financial decision?

Time Value of Money (TVM) is a foundational concept in finance stating that money available now is
worth more than the same amount in the future. This is because present money can be invested to earn
returns, making it more valuable. Key components of TVM are:
1. Present Value (PV): The current value of a future sum of money.
2. Future Value (FV): The value of a present sum at a future date.
3. Interest Rate (r): The rate of return used to discount future cash flows.
4. Time (t): The number of periods (often years) between the present and future.
The basic TVM formula is: FV = PV * (1 + r)^t
Valuation of securities using TVM:
1. Bonds:
 Value is the PV of all future cash flows (coupons and principal).
 PV(Bond) = Σ(Ct / (1+r)^t) + (F / (1+r)^n)
 Ct: Coupon payment at time t
 F: Face value (principal)
 r: Required yield (often YTM)
 n: Years to maturity
2. Stocks:
3. Dividend Discount Model (DDM): PV(Stock) = Σ(Dt / (1+r)^t)
 Dt: Expected dividend at time t
 r: Required return (e.g., from CAPM)
 For constant growth (Gordon Growth Model): P0 = D1 / (r - g)
 D1: Next year's dividend
 g: Constant growth rate
4. Projects/Capital Budgeting:
 Net Present Value (NPV): NPV = -Initial Investment + Σ(CFt / (1+r)^t)
 CFt: Cash flow at time t
 r: Discount rate (often WACC)
 Accept projects with positive NPV.
 5. Annuities and Perpetuities:
 Annuity: Fixed payments for a set time. PV(Annuity) = PMT * [(1 - (1+r)^-n) / r]
 Perpetuity: Fixed payments forever. PV(Perpetuity) = PMT / r
In all these, the discount rate (r) is crucial. It's the required return that compensates for risk and
opportunity cost. Higher risk or longer time horizons demand higher rates, reducing PV.
TVM is vital because it allows comparing cash flows occurring at different times on a common basis
(present value), enabling better financial decisions.
__________________________________________________________________________________
QUESTION 4: Define cash flow. How it is different from profit? Explain the meaning of incremental
cash flow.

1. Cash Flow: Cash flow is the net amount of cash and cash equivalents moving into (inflows)
and out of (outflows) a business. It represents the actual liquidity of the company.
 Cash inflows: Sales revenue (if in cash), loans, equity investments, asset sales.
 Cash outflows: Operating expenses, capital expenditures, loan repayments, dividends.
2. Difference between Cash Flow and Profit: Profit (specifically net income) is an accounting
measure of a company's financial performance, while cash flow measures liquidity. Key
differences:
a. Timing:

 Profit: Recognized when earned/incurred (accrual basis), regardless of cash receipt/payment.

 Cash Flow: Recorded only when cash changes hands.
b. Non-cash items:

 Profit: Includes non-cash expenses like depreciation, amortization, and impairments.

 Cash Flow: Excludes non-cash items.
c. Working Capital:

 Profit: Not directly affected by changes in receivables, payables, or inventory.

 Cash Flow: Directly impacted. E.g., a sale on credit increases profit but not immediate cash
flow.
d. Capital Expenditures:

 Profit: Major purchases (like equipment) are capitalized and expensed over time via
depreciation.
 Cash Flow: The entire purchase price reduces cash flow when paid.
Example: A company buys $1M equipment, depreciates $200K/year, and sells $800K on credit. This
year:

 Profit: $600K (Revenue $800K - Depreciation $200K)

 Cash Flow: -$1M (Equipment purchase)
3. Incremental Cash Flow: This is the additional cash flow generated by a specific decision or
project. It's the difference in cash flows with and without the decision.
Key points: a. Relevance: Only cash flows that change because of the decision are relevant.
b. Sunk Costs: Past expenditures (sunk costs) are ignored because they don't change with the current
decision.
c. Opportunity Costs: Lost cash flows from the next-best alternative are included.
d. Cannibalization: If a new project reduces cash flows from existing operations, this reduction is an
incremental cash outflow.
Example: A company considers a new product line:

 Investment: $500K
 Annual Revenue: $300K
 Annual Expenses: $150K
 Cannibalization of existing product: $50K/year
Incremental Cash Flow: Year 0: -$500K (Investment) Year 1, 2, ...: $100K (Revenue $300K -
Expenses $150K - Cannibalization $50K)
Incremental cash flow is crucial in capital budgeting (NPV, IRR calculations) because it focuses on
the true cash impact of a decision, leading to more accurate financial evaluations.
__________________________________________________________________________________
QUESTION 5: What are the major type of financial management decision that business firm makes.
Describe briefly each one of them and highlight the inter-relationship among these decisions.

A business firm primarily makes three types of financial management decisions, often referred to as
the "trio of financial decisions." These are:
1. Investment Decisions (Capital Budgeting):
 What: Deciding which long-term projects or assets to invest in.
 How: Using techniques like NPV, IRR, payback period, and real options analysis.
 Examples: New product lines, expansion, acquisition, equipment purchase.
 Goal: Maximize shareholder wealth by selecting projects with positive NPV.
2. Financing Decisions (Capital Structure):
 What: Determining the optimal mix of debt and equity to fund investments.
 How: Balancing factors like cost of capital (WACC), financial leverage, tax benefits of debt,
and bankruptcy risk.
 Examples: Issuing bonds, taking loans, equity offerings, using retained earnings.
 Goal: Minimize cost of capital while maintaining financial flexibility and acceptable risk.
3. Dividend Decisions (Payout Policy):
 What: Deciding how much of the profit to retain for reinvestment vs. distribute to
shareholders.
 How: Considering factors like growth opportunities, cash needs, investor preferences, and
signaling effects.
 Examples: Cash dividends, share buybacks, stock dividends.
 Goal: Balance between rewarding shareholders and funding growth.
Interrelationship among these decisions:
1. Investment → Financing:
 Investment needs determine financing requirements.
  The risk profile of investments affects the choice of financing (e.g., risky projects might
prefer equity).
2. Financing → Investment:
 The cost of capital (WACC) from financing decisions is the discount rate for evaluating
investments (NPV).
 High leverage can limit future borrowing capacity, constraining investments.
3. Investment & Financing → Dividend:
 Cash needs for investments and debt servicing reduce funds available for dividends.
 High-growth firms (many +NPV projects) tend to pay lower dividends.
4. Dividend → Investment & Financing:
 High dividends reduce internal funds (retained earnings) for investments.
 To fund growth, dividend-paying firms may need more external financing.
5. Financing → Dividend:
 Debt covenants may restrict dividend payments.
 Interest payments reduce cash available for dividends.
6. Dividend → Financing:
 Dividend policy signals firm health, affecting stock price and thus the cost of equity.
 Regular dividends create a "sticky" cash outflow, influencing debt levels.
Example:
 Apple (AAPL) identifies a new AI project (Investment) with high returns but high risk.
 It chooses to finance primarily with equity (Financing) to avoid increasing financial risk.
 This equity issuance dilutes earnings per share, so Apple reduces its dividend growth
(Dividend) to preserve cash for the project.
In summary, these decisions are interdependent. Investment choices drive financing needs and impact
dividends. Financing decisions affect the cost and risk profile of investments. Dividend decisions
influence the need for external financing and funds available for investments. Balancing these
decisions is key to maximizing firm value.
__________________________________________________________________________________
QUESTION 6: Explain the short term and long term sources of raising finance.

Businesses use a mix of short-term and long-term financing to manage their operations and growth.
Let's break down these sources:
Short-term Sources (maturity < 1 year):
1. Trade Credit:
 Suppliers allow delayed payment for goods/services.
 Advantage: Often interest-free, preserves cash flow.
 Example: Net 30 terms (pay within 30 days).
2. Short-term Bank Loans:
 Include overdrafts, lines of credit, working capital loans.
 Advantage: Flexible, can be secured (inventory) or unsecured.
 Example: Seasonal business using a 6-month loan to buy inventory.
3. Commercial Paper:
 Unsecured, short-term debt issued by large, creditworthy firms.
 Advantage: Lower rates than bank loans due to high credit quality.
 Example: Apple issuing 90-day notes to fund operating expenses.
 4. Factoring Receivables:
 Selling accounts receivable to a factor at a discount.
 Advantage: Immediate cash, transfer of collection risk.
 Example: A textile firm factoring invoices to pay workers.
5. Working Capital from Operations:
 Managing inventory, receivables, and payables to optimize cash flow.
 Advantage: Reduces need for external financing.
 Example: Just-in-time inventory to reduce holding costs.
Long-term Sources (maturity > 1 year):
1. Equity: a. Common Stock: Represent ownership, have voting rights.
 Advantage: No repayment obligation, can enhance public image. b. Preferred Stock: Fixed
dividends, preference in liquidation.
 Advantage: No voting rights dilution, tax-deductible dividends in some cases.
 Example: Tesla's public offerings to fund expansion.
2. Debt: a. Bonds: Fixed-income securities issued by companies.
 Advantage: Lower rates than equity, tax-deductible interest. b. Long-term Bank Loans: For
major investments.
 Advantage: Can be tailored (e.g., amortizing vs. balloon payments).
 Example: Amazon issuing 10-year bonds for AWS infrastructure.
3. Retained Earnings:
 Profits reinvested in the business.
 Advantage: No issuing costs, signals confidence to investors.
 Example: Berkshire Hathaway rarely pays dividends, using earnings for acquisitions.
4. Leasing:
 Using assets without ownership (operating lease) or as a form of financing (finance lease).
 Advantage: Preserves capital, often tax advantages.
 Example: Airlines leasing aircraft rather than buying.
5. Hybrid Securities:
 Combine features of debt and equity (e.g., convertible bonds).
 Advantage: Lower interest rates, potential equity upside.
 Example: Netflix issuing convertible notes.
6. Private Equity and Venture Capital:
 Investments from PE firms or VC funds in exchange for equity.
 Advantage: Bring expertise, connections; suitable for high-risk ventures.
 Example: VC funding for startups like Uber in early stages.
7. Government Grants and Subsidies:
 For specific sectors or activities (e.g., green energy).
 Advantage: Non-repayable, can signal government support.
The choice between these sources depends on factors like:

 Cost of capital
 Financial flexibility and risk
 Asset-liability matching (e.g., long-term assets funded by long-term sources)
 Market conditions
 Company's life cycle stage and risk profile
Effective financial management often involves a strategic mix of these sources to optimize cost, risk,
and growth.
__________________________________________________________________________________
QUESTION 7: What is Yield to maturity? How does it helps in determining the price of the debt
security?

Yield to Maturity (YTM) is crucial for bond investors and issuers.

Yield to Maturity (YTM): YTM is the total return anticipated on a bond if it is held until its maturity
date. It's a comprehensive measure that takes into account:
1. Coupon payments (interest)
2. Capital gain or loss (if the bond is bought at a discount or premium)
3. Time value of money
Mathematically, YTM is the discount rate that makes the present value of all future cash flows from
the bond (coupons and principal) equal to its current market price.
Formula (simplified for annual coupons): P = Σ(Ct / (1+YTM)^t) + (F / (1+YTM)^n)
Where:
 P: Current market price
 Ct: Coupon payment at time t
 F: Face value (principal)
 n: Years to maturity
 YTM: Yield to Maturity (what we solve for)
How YTM Helps in Determining Bond Prices:
1. Market Mechanism:
 In efficient markets, bonds trade at prices that provide a YTM competitive with similar-risk
investments.
 If market interest rates rise, new bonds offer higher yields. Existing bonds must adjust (price
down) to offer a competitive YTM.
 Conversely, if rates fall, existing bond prices rise to lower their YTM to market levels.
2. Inverse Relationship:
 YTM and bond price move inversely. When YTM increases, price decreases, and vice versa.
 This is because higher YTM means future cash flows are discounted more heavily, reducing
their present value (price).
3. Example:
 Consider a 5-year, $1000 face value bond with 6% annual coupons.
 If market YTM is 6%, it trades at par ($1000).
 If market YTM rises to 8%:
 P = 60/(1.08) + 60/(1.08)^2 + ... + 1060/(1.08)^5 ≈ $924
 Price falls to make YTM = 8%.
 If market YTM drops to 4%:
 P = 60/(1.04) + 60/(1.04)^2 + ... + 1060/(1.04)^5 ≈ $1,084
 Price rises to make YTM = 4%.
4. New Issues and Pricing:
 When companies or governments issue new bonds, they set coupon rates based on current
market YTMs to price at or near par.
 A highly-rated company issuing a 10-year bond when 10-year Treasury YTM is 3% might set
a 3.5% coupon (Treasury rate + credit spread).
 5. Valuation Tool:
 Investors use YTM to compare bonds with different coupons, maturities, and prices on a
common basis.
 It's more comprehensive than just comparing coupon rates.
6. Risk Assessment:
 Higher risk (e.g., lower credit rating) means higher required YTM.
 If two bonds have the same maturity and coupon but one is riskier, the riskier one will have a
lower price (higher YTM).
7. Interest Rate Expectations:
 Expected future rate changes impact long-term bond YTMs and prices.
 If rates are expected to rise, long-term bonds might have higher YTMs (lower prices) in
anticipation.
In summary, YTM is the market's way of equalizing bond returns across different structures. It
ensures that, given risk levels, investors are indifferent between a high-coupon bond trading at a
premium or a low-coupon bond at a discount. When market rates change, bond prices adjust to
maintain the required YTM, making it a fundamental tool in bond pricing and investment decisions.
__________________________________________________________________________________
QUESTION 8: What do you mean by capital structure? Explain net operating income approach to
capital structure? How it is different from net income approach.

Let's dive into capital structure and two key approaches to understanding its impact on firm value.
Capital Structure: Capital structure refers to the mix of debt and equity that a company uses to finance
its operations and growth. It's represented on the right side of the balance sheet:
1. Debt: Borrowed money (bonds, loans) that must be repaid with interest. Interest is tax-
deductible.
2. Equity: Funds from shareholders (common stock, preferred stock, retained earnings). No
repayment obligation but shareholders expect returns (dividends, capital appreciation).
Key metrics:
 Debt-to-Equity ratio (D/E)
 Weighted Average Cost of Capital (WACC)
The optimal capital structure minimizes WACC and maximizes firm value.
Net Operating Income (NOI) Approach:
Proposed by Franco Modigliani and Merton Miller (M&M), this approach argues that in perfect
markets (no taxes, transaction costs, or bankruptcy costs), a firm's value is independent of its capital
structure.
Assumptions:
1. No taxes
2. No transaction or bankruptcy costs
3. Symmetric information
4. Investors can borrow at the same rate as firms
Key propositions:
 1. Proposition I (without taxes):
 Firm value (V) = Market value of debt (D) + Market value of equity (E)
 V = (EBIT * (1-T)) / k0 = (NOI) / k0
 EBIT: Earnings Before Interest and Taxes
 T: Tax rate (assumed 0 in this case)
 k0: Overall cost of capital (independent of leverage)
 Implication: Changing D/E doesn't change V because k0 remains constant.
2. Proposition II:
 Required return on equity (ke) = k0 + (D/E) * (k0 - kd)
 kd: Cost of debt
 As D/E increases, ke increases to compensate for higher financial risk.
3. With Taxes (more realistic):
 V = (EBIT * (1-T)) / k0 + TD
 TD: Tax shield (interest tax deduction)
 More debt increases value due to tax shield.

Net Income (NI) Approach:

Developed by traditionalists, it argues that capital structure does affect firm value.
Key points:
1. Optimal Capital Structure: There's a level of debt that minimizes WACC and maximizes
value.
2. WACC Behavior:
 Initially, as D/E increases, WACC decreases because debt is cheaper (due to tax shield and
lower risk).
 Beyond an optimal point, WACC increases because higher leverage increases bankruptcy risk
and ke rises sharply.
3. Value Behavior:
 V = (NI + I(1-T)) / WACC
 NI: Net Income
 I: Interest
 As WACC decreases, V increases, and vice versa.

Differences:
1. Market Perfection:
 NOI: Assumes perfect markets.
 NI: Acknowledges market imperfections (taxes, bankruptcy costs).
2. Impact of Leverage:
 NOI: No optimal D/E ratio. Firm value is constant (without taxes) or increases linearly with
debt (with taxes).
 NI: There's an optimal D/E that maximizes value. Beyond this, value decreases.
3. Cost of Capital:
 NOI: Overall cost of capital (k0) is constant regardless of leverage.
 NI: WACC varies with leverage, initially decreasing then increasing.
4. Risk Perception:
 NOI: Investors can "undo" corporate leverage by borrowing or lending personally, so
corporate leverage doesn't matter.
 NI: Corporate leverage matters because personal borrowing is often more costly and risky
than corporate borrowing.
 5. Real-world Applicability:
 NOI: More theoretical, highlights tax benefits of debt.
 NI: More aligned with observed corporate behavior, as most firms target an optimal capital
structure.
In practice, the truth lies between these approaches. The tax benefits of debt are real (as per NOI), but
so are bankruptcy costs and agency issues (as per NI). Modern theories like Trade-off Theory and
Pecking Order Theory build on these foundations to guide capital structure decisions.
__________________________________________________________________________________
QUESTION 9: What factors influence composition of capital structure?

The composition of a company's capital structure is influenced by various factors, both internal and
external. Understanding these can help managers make optimal financing decisions. Key factors
include:

1. Business Risk:
 Higher business risk (volatile earnings) -> less debt capacity.
 Stable industries (utilities) can afford more debt than cyclical ones (luxury goods).
2. Tax Considerations:
 Interest tax deductibility makes debt attractive.
 Firms with high tax rates benefit more from debt's tax shield.
 Non-debt tax shields (depreciation, R&D credits) reduce debt's relative advantage.
3. Financial Flexibility and Control:
 Debt obligations reduce flexibility during downturns.
 Equity dilutes control; family-owned or founder-led firms might prefer debt.
4. Growth Opportunities:
 High-growth firms (tech startups) often use more equity because:
 Future growth is an intangible asset, poor collateral for debt.
 They need flexibility for uncertain projects.
 Mature firms (consumer staples) use more debt due to stable cash flows.
5. Profitability:
 Pecking Order Theory: Profitable firms prefer internal financing (retained earnings) over
debt, then equity.
 Counterpoint: Profitable firms might use more debt to discipline management (reduce free
cash flow).
6. Asset Structure:
 Tangible assets (real estate, equipment) -> more debt capacity (good collateral).
 Intangible-heavy firms (pharma R&D) -> less debt capacity.
7. Industry Norms:
 Firms often mimic successful peers' capital structures.
 E.g., tech firms generally have less debt than utilities.
8. Market Conditions:
 Bull markets -> equity is cheaper (high stock prices).
 In recessions -> quality firms can issue debt cheaply.
9. Firm Size and Age:
 Larger, established firms -> more debt (lower bankruptcy risk).
 Small, young firms -> more equity (information asymmetry makes debt costly).
10. Management Preferences:
  Risk-averse managers -> less debt.
 Optimistic managers ("hubris hypothesis") -> more debt.
11. Agency Costs:
 Debt as discipline: Forces managers to be efficient (less free cash flow).
 But high debt can lead to underinvestment or risk-shifting.
12. Signaling:
 Debt issuance can signal confidence (managers believe cash flows can cover it).
 Equity issuance can signal overvaluation (why sell if undervalued?).
13. Financial Distress Costs:
 Direct costs: Legal fees, restructuring costs.
 Indirect costs: Lost sales, brain drain, distracted management.
 Higher potential costs -> less debt.
14. Competitor Strategies:
 In oligopolies, firms might limit debt to have dry powder for price wars.
15. Macroeconomic Factors:
 Interest rates: Lower rates -> more debt.
 Inflation: High inflation can make debt attractive (repay with devalued currency).
 Exchange rates: Impact for firms with foreign operations or debt.
16. Regulatory Environment:
 Banking regulations can limit debt.
 Some sectors (utilities) have regulated capital structures.
17. Credit Ratings:
 Higher ratings -> cheaper debt, but also pressure to maintain ratings.
18. Investor Clientele:
 Some investors (pension funds) prefer dividend-paying stocks.
 Others (hedge funds) might prefer leveraged firms.
19. Merger & Acquisition Activity:
 Debt-financed acquisitions can drastically change capital structure.
20. Historical Accident:
 Past decisions, economic conditions, or leadership can cast a long shadow.
In practice, firms consider many of these factors simultaneously. The Trade-off Theory suggests firms
balance the tax benefits of debt against financial distress costs. The Market Timing Theory argues
firms issue securities when market conditions are favorable. The key is that capital structure is a
dynamic decision, constantly adjusted based on these evolving factors.
__________________________________________________________________________________
QUESTION 10: “New issue of capital is costlier than the retained earning”, how and what makes
these two to differ.

This statement touches on a key insight from the Pecking Order Theory of capital structure. Let's
break down why new issues (especially equity) are often costlier than retained earnings and what
causes this difference.
1. Cost of Retained Earnings:
 Retained earnings are profits that are reinvested in the business rather than distributed as
dividends.
 Cost: The opportunity cost of equity (ke), which is the return shareholders expect given the
firm's risk.
 Advantage: No transaction costs. The money is already within the firm.
 2. Cost of New Issues: a. New Equity:
 Direct Costs:
 Underwriting fees (2-7% for IPOs, less for seasoned offerings)
 Legal, accounting, and registration fees
 Roadshow expenses
 Indirect Costs (more significant):
 Underpricing: IPOs often priced below true value (avg. 10-15% "pop" on first day)
 Signaling Costs: Market may interpret equity issue as a sign the stock is overvalued (why sell
if it's undervalued?). This can depress stock price.
 Dilution: New shares reduce EPS and control for existing shareholders.
b. New Debt:

 Direct Costs:
 Underwriting fees (lower than equity, maybe 1-3%)
 Legal fees, especially for complex covenants
 Indirect Costs:
 Restrictive Covenants: Can limit financial flexibility
 Financial Distress Costs: Higher debt increases these potential costs
1. Information Asymmetry (key reason):
 Management knows more about the firm's prospects than outside investors.
 Investors, aware of this gap, demand a "lemons premium" on new issues (especially equity).
 This asymmetry is less severe for debt (fixed returns make firm value less critical) and non-
existent for retained earnings.
2. Adverse Selection:
 Managers are more likely to issue equity when they believe it's overvalued.
 Knowing this, investors discount new equity issues.
 Retained earnings don't suffer from this problem; they're not actively "sold" to the market.
3. Tax Considerations:
 Interest on new debt is tax-deductible, lowering its effective cost.
 Dividends (alternative to retaining earnings) are generally not tax-deductible for the firm.
 But for shareholders, dividends might be taxed more favorably than capital gains from
retained earnings, complicating the picture.
4. Flotation Costs:
 These are the total direct costs of issuing new securities.
 Higher for equity than debt, and zero for retained earnings.
 Can significantly increase the cost of small issues.
5. Control and Voting Rights:
 New equity dilutes control; managers and large shareholders often prefer retained earnings.
 Debt doesn't dilute control (unless converted or in bankruptcy).
6. Financial Flexibility:
 Retained earnings provide the most flexibility. They can be used without restrictions.
 New debt comes with covenants and repayment schedules.
 New equity, while not requiring repayment, can pressure for dividends or buybacks.
7. Speed and Convenience:
 Using retained earnings is faster and simpler than new issues.
 Speed can be crucial for time-sensitive investments.
8. Market Timing:
  Firms might delay new issues during market downturns, but retained earnings are always
available.
9. Maturity and Risk:
 Mature, profitable firms have more retained earnings and face less asymmetry, making them
cheaper.
 High-growth, risky firms rely more on new issues and face higher costs.
Example: Consider a firm with a cost of equity (ke) of 12%. It needs $10 million for expansion.

 Option A: Use retained earnings. Cost = $10m * 12% = $1.2m/year.

 Option B: New equity. With 5% flotation cost and 10% underpricing, it needs to raise $11.6m.
Cost ≈ $11.6m * 12% = $1.39m/year, plus signaling costs.
In summary, retained earnings are often the cheapest source because they avoid the transaction costs,
information asymmetry penalties, and strategic complications of new issues. This insight underpins the
Pecking Order Theory, which suggests firms prefer internal financing (retained earnings), then debt, and
equity as a last resort. However, the optimal choice depends on the firm's specific circumstances, including
growth opportunities, current capital structure, and market conditions.
__________________________________________________________________________________
QUESTION 11: What is NPV? How it is different from IRR?

Both Net Present Value (NPV) and Internal Rate of Return (IRR) are fundamental tools in capital
budgeting, but they approach project evaluation differently.
Net Present Value (NPV):
Definition: NPV is the difference between the present value of cash inflows and the present value of cash
outflows over a period of time.
Formula: NPV = -C₀ + Σ(Cₜ / (1+r)ᵗ)

 C₀: Initial investment (cash outflow)

 Cₜ: Cash flow in period t
 r: Discount rate (often WACC)
 t: Time period
Interpretation:

 NPV > 0: Accept project (increases shareholder wealth)

 NPV = 0: Indifferent (meets required return)
 NPV < 0: Reject project (decreases wealth)
Advantages:
1. Considers time value of money
2. Directly measures value creation
3. Additive (can sum NPVs of independent projects)
4. Uses firm's cost of capital, reflecting risk
Internal Rate of Return (IRR):
Definition: IRR is the discount rate that makes the NPV of all cash flows equal to zero. It's the project's
"break-even" rate of return.
Formula (implicit, solved iteratively): 0 = -C₀ + Σ(Cₜ / (1+IRR)ᵗ)
Interpretation:

 IRR > r (cost of capital): Accept project

 IRR = r: Indifferent
 IRR < r: Reject project
Advantages:
1. Easy to understand (similar to interest rates)
2. Useful for comparing projects of different scales
3. Doesn't require predetermining a discount rate
Differences between NPV and IRR:
1. What They Measure:
 NPV: Absolute value creation in today's dollars
 IRR: Percentage return (profitability index)
2. Decision Criteria:
 NPV: Maximizing NPV maximizes shareholder wealth
 IRR: Highest IRR doesn't always maximize wealth
3. Reinvestment Assumption:
 NPV: Assumes intermediate cash flows reinvested at the discount rate (r)
 IRR: Implicitly assumes reinvestment at the IRR itself
4. Multiple IRRs:
 NPV: Always gives a single value
 IRR: Can have multiple values if cash flows change sign more than once (e.g., -100, +230, -
140)
5. Mutually Exclusive Projects:
 NPV: Choose the project with higher NPV
 IRR: Can lead to wrong decisions
Example: Project A: C₀ = -$1000, C₁ = $1200, r = 10% NPV_A = -1000 + 1200/1.1 = $90.91 IRR_A =
20%
Project B: C₀ = -$10000, C₁ = $11500, r = 10% NPV_B = -10000 + 11500/1.1 = $454.55 IRR_B = 15%

 IRR suggests A (20% > 15%), but NPV shows B creates more value.
6. Capital Rationing:
 NPV: Optimal for ranking projects when capital is constrained
 IRR: Can lead to suboptimal decisions (favors smaller projects)
7. Changing Discount Rates:
 NPV: Can handle changing rates by adjusting r in each period
 IRR: Single rate, struggles with varying costs of capital
8. Loan Evaluation:
 NPV: Less intuitive (negative NPV might be good for borrower)
 IRR: More intuitive (compare to loan rate)
9. Theoretical Foundation:
 NPV: Directly linked to shareholder wealth maximization
 IRR: Not as firmly grounded in financial theory
In practice:
  Most firms use both. NPV for decision-making, IRR for intuition and communication.
 When they conflict (rare in simple cases), NPV is preferred by financial theorists.
In summary, NPV directly measures value creation and is more theoretically sound, especially for
comparing mutually exclusive projects. IRR is useful for its intuitive percentage return and when
comparing to hurdle rates. Understanding both, and their differences, is crucial for effective capital
budgeting.
__________________________________________________________________________________
QUESTION 12: Write a short note on decision tree analysis?

Decision tree analysis is a powerful visual tool used in decision-making under uncertainty, particularly in
areas like finance, management, and data science. It's especially useful when decisions have sequential
components or when outcomes are contingent on prior decisions or events.
Key Components:
1. Decision Nodes (squares): Points where the decision-maker chooses an action.
2. Chance Nodes (circles): Points where outcomes are uncertain, with probabilities assigned.
3. Branches: Represent actions (from decision nodes) or outcomes (from chance nodes).
4. Probabilities: Assigned to branches from chance nodes, must sum to 1.
5. Payoffs: Values (often monetary) at the end of each path.
Process:
1. Structure the Problem: Draw the tree from left to right, starting with the initial decision.
2. Assign Probabilities: Use historical data, expert opinion, or models.
3. Determine Payoffs: Often NPV for financial decisions.
4. Analyze ("Roll Back"):
 At chance nodes: Calculate expected value (EV = Σ probability × payoff).
 At decision nodes: Choose the branch with the best EV or payoff.
Advantages:
1. Visual Clarity: Makes complex decisions easier to understand.
2. Incorporates Uncertainty: Explicitly deals with probabilistic outcomes.
3. Sequential Decisions: Ideal for multi-stage problems.
4. Flexible Payoffs: Can use NPV, utility, or other metrics.
5. Scenario Analysis: Easy to see impact of changing probabilities or payoffs.
Applications in Finance:
1. Capital Budgeting: Deciding whether to expand a project based on initial success.
2. Real Options: Valuing flexibility (e.g., option to abandon a project).
3. Portfolio Management: Deciding asset allocation based on market scenarios.
4. Mergers & Acquisitions: Modeling outcomes of a bid or negotiation.
Limitations:
1. Complexity: Trees can become unwieldy for many decisions/outcomes.
2. Subjectivity: Probabilities and payoffs can be subjective.
3. Independence: Assumes outcomes are independent (not always true).
Extensions:
 1. Influence Diagrams: Add information nodes for a richer model.
2. Sensitivity Analysis: Test how changes in inputs affect decisions.
3. Risk Profiles: Use to visualize risk-return tradeoffs.
Example: A firm decides whether to launch a product (D1: Launch, Don't). If launched, the market could
be favorable (C1: 70%, +$1M) or unfavorable (30%, -$200K). If favorable, they can expand (D2: Expand,
Don't). Expansion in a good market yields +$2M (80%) or +$500K (20%).
Analysis:
1. D2 (if reached): Expand (EV = 0.8×$2M + 0.2×$500K = $1.7M) > Don't ($1M)
2. D1: Launch (EV = 0.7×$1.7M + 0.3×(-$200K) = $1.13M) > Don't ($0)
Decision: Launch, then expand if the market is favorable.
In summary, decision tree analysis is a versatile tool for making sequential decisions under uncertainty. It's
particularly valuable in finance for its ability to model complex scenarios, incorporate the time value of
money, and provide clear insights into optimal strategies.
__________________________________________________________________________________
QUESTION 13: Explain the techniques of capital budgeting?

Capital budgeting is the process of evaluating and selecting long-term investments, which is crucial for a
firm's growth and profitability. There are several techniques used, each with its own strengths and
weaknesses. Let's go through the main ones:
1. Net Present Value (NPV):
 Concept: PV of cash inflows minus PV of cash outflows.
 Formula: NPV = -C₀ + Σ(Cₜ / (1+r)ᵗ)
 C₀: Initial investment, Cₜ: Cash flow at time t, r: Discount rate (often WACC)
 Decision Rule: Accept if NPV > 0 (increases shareholder wealth)
 Pros: Considers TVM, directly measures value, additive for independent projects
 Cons: Sensitive to discount rate estimation, less intuitive than some methods
2. Internal Rate of Return (IRR):
 Concept: Discount rate that makes NPV = 0
 Formula (implicit): 0 = -C₀ + Σ(Cₜ / (1+IRR)ᵗ)
 Decision Rule: Accept if IRR > r (cost of capital)
 Pros: Easy to understand, useful for comparing projects of different scales
 Cons: Multiple IRRs possible, assumes reinvestment at IRR, can conflict with NPV
3. Payback Period:
 Concept: Time required to recover initial investment
 Formula: Find t where Σ(Cₜ) = C₀
 Decision Rule: Accept if payback < predetermined time
 Pros: Simple, focuses on liquidity and risk
 Cons: Ignores TVM and cash flows after payback, arbitrary cutoff
4. Discounted Payback Period:
 Concept: Time to recover initial investment using discounted cash flows
 Formula: Find t where Σ(Cₜ / (1+r)ᵗ) = C₀
 Pros: Considers TVM, still simple
 Cons: Ignores cash flows after payback, arbitrary cutoff
5. Profitability Index (PI) or Benefit-Cost Ratio:
  Concept: PV of inflows per dollar of initial investment
 Formula: PI = [Σ(Cₜ / (1+r)ᵗ)] / C₀
 Decision Rule: Accept if PI > 1
 Pros: Useful in capital rationing, shows "bang for the buck"
 Cons: Can conflict with NPV for mutually exclusive projects
6. Accounting Rate of Return (ARR):
 Concept: Ratio of average accounting profit to average investment
 Formula: ARR = (Average Annual Profit) / (Average Investment)
 Pros: Uses readily available accounting data
 Cons: Ignores TVM, cash flows, and project duration
7. Real Options Analysis:
 Concept: Values managerial flexibility (options to expand, abandon, etc.)
 Methods: Decision trees, binomial models, Black-Scholes
 Pros: Captures value of flexibility, especially in uncertain environments
 Cons: Can be complex, relies on estimating volatility
8. Scenario and Sensitivity Analysis:
 Concept: Examines how changes in inputs affect outcomes
 Examples: Best/worst/base cases, one-variable-at-a-time changes
 Pros: Highlights critical variables, helps manage risk
 Cons: Can be time-consuming, doesn't capture interactions well
9. Monte Carlo Simulation:
 Concept: Simulates many possible outcomes based on probabilistic inputs
 Pros: Captures complexity, provides probability distributions of outcomes
 Cons: Requires software, depends on accuracy of input distributions
10. Economic Value Added (EVA):
 Concept: Profit after deducting cost of all capital
 Formula: EVA = NOPAT - (WACC × Capital Employed)
 Pros: Encourages efficient use of capital, aligns with shareholder value
 Cons: Can lead to short-termism, sensitive to accounting policies
In Practice:

 NPV is widely considered the best single measure, as it directly ties to shareholder value.
 IRR and Payback are often used alongside NPV for their simplicity and intuitive appeal.
 More advanced techniques (real options, Monte Carlo) are gaining traction, especially in tech
and R&D-heavy industries.
 Many firms use multiple methods, as each offers different insights.
Example: A firm considers a $1M project with cash flows: Year 1: $400K, Year 2: $500K, Year 3: $600K.
WACC is 12%.
1. NPV = -1M + 400K/1.12 + 500K/1.12² + 600K/1.12³ ≈ $212K (Accept)
2. IRR (found iteratively) ≈ 22.1% (Accept, > 12%)
3. Payback: 2.2 years (Accept if cutoff > 2.2 years)
4. PI = (PV of inflows) / 1M ≈ 1.21 (Accept)
In summary, capital budgeting is a critical process that uses various techniques to evaluate long-term
investments. While NPV is theoretically superior, using a combination of methods provides a more
comprehensive understanding of investment opportunities. The choice of techniques depends on the nature
of the project, industry norms, and the firm's specific concerns (e.g., risk, liquidity, flexibility).
__________________________________________________________________________________
QUESTION 14: What is working capital? What factors are taken into consideration while estimating the
amount of working capital?
Working capital is a fundamental concept in corporate finance, crucial for a company's day-to-day
operations and short-term financial health.
Working Capital:
Definition: Working capital is the capital used to finance a company's short-term operations and is
calculated as:
1. Gross Working Capital: Total current assets
 Cash and cash equivalents
 Marketable securities
 Accounts receivable
 Inventory
 Prepaid expenses
2. Net Working Capital (more common): Current assets - Current liabilities
 Current Liabilities include:
 Accounts payable
 Short-term debt
 Current portion of long-term debt
 Accrued expenses
Importance:

 Liquidity: Ensures the firm can pay short-term obligations.

 Operational Efficiency: Smooth day-to-day operations.
 Profitability: Efficient WC management reduces financing costs.
 Solvency: Buffer against cash flow interruptions.
 Growth: Needed for expanding operations.
Factors Considered in Estimating Working Capital:
1. Nature of Business:
 Manufacturing: Higher WC (inventory, receivables)
 Services: Lower WC (less inventory)
 Retail: Varies (fast-fashion low, luxury high)
2. Scale of Operations:
 Larger scale generally requires more WC.
 But economies of scale can reduce WC needs per unit of sales.
3. Production Cycle:
 Longer cycles (like shipbuilding) need more WC.
 Just-in-Time (JIT) inventory reduces WC needs.
4. Credit Policy:
 Liberal credit (to boost sales) increases receivables and WC needs.
 But too strict can lose sales.
5. Growth and Expansion Plans:
 Growth requires more inventory, receivables.
 New markets might have different payment terms.
6. Profit Margin and Turnover:
  High margins can support more liberal credit.
 High turnover (sales/assets) reduces WC needs.
7. Seasonality:
 Peak season needs more WC (like retailers before holidays).
 Off-season might allow WC reduction.
8. Supply Chain:
 Reliable suppliers might offer better credit terms.
 Global sourcing can increase lead times and WC.
9. Inventory Management:
 Safety stock levels (for demand spikes)
 Perishability (food needs quicker turnover)
10. Payment Terms:
 To suppliers: Longer terms reduce WC needs.
 From customers: Shorter terms reduce WC needs.
11. Operating Leverage:
 High fixed costs (like utilities) need more WC as a buffer.
12. Economic Conditions:
 Recession: Conservative credit, more cash buffer.
 Boom: Might need more WC for growth.
13. Industry Benchmarks:
 Comparing to peers can guide "normal" WC levels.
14. Technology:
 ERP systems can optimize inventory.
 E-commerce can reduce receivables (instant payment).
15. Inflation and Interest Rates:
 High inflation: Need more nominal WC.
 High interest: Costlier to hold excess WC.
16. Regulatory Environment:
 Tax policies (e.g., inventory valuation methods)
 Environmental regulations (holding certain inventories)
17. Foreign Operations:
 Exchange rate fluctuations
 Different payment cultures
18. Access to Capital:
 Easy access (like for blue-chips) allows lower WC.
 Startups might need more buffer.
19. Management Philosophy:
 Aggressive: Lower WC, higher returns but riskier.
 Conservative: Higher WC, safer but lower returns.

21. Black Swan Events:

 COVID-19 showed the value of robust WC buffers.
Methods of Estimation:
1. Percentage of Sales: WC as a % of forecasted sales.
2. Operating Cycle Method: Based on inventory, receivables, and payables periods.
3. Regression Analysis: Using past data to predict WC needs.
4. Cash Budget: Detailed cash inflow/outflow projections.
Example: A toy manufacturer estimates next year's sales at $10M. Industry average WC is 20% of sales.
But they're launching a new line, extending credit to boost sales, and it's Q4 (pre-holiday). They estimate
they'll need 30% of sales as WC: 0.3 * $10M = $3M.
In summary, working capital is the lifeblood of day-to-day operations. Estimating it involves a nuanced
understanding of business operations, finance, and external factors. Too little can stifle growth and risk
insolvency; too much ties up funds unproductively. The art is in striking the right balance.
__________________________________________________________________________________
QUESTION 15: What are the objectives of inventory management? How are they similar to objectives of
cash management?

Both inventory and cash are crucial current assets that require careful management to ensure operational
efficiency and financial health.
Objectives of Inventory Management:
1. Minimize Costs:
 Holding costs (storage, insurance, obsolescence)
 Ordering costs (administrative, shipping)
 Stockout costs (lost sales, production halts)
2. Ensure Continuity of Operations:
 Avoid stockouts that can halt production or lose sales
 Maintain safety stocks for demand spikes or supply disruptions
3. Optimize Investment:
 Balance between tying up too much capital in inventory and risking stockouts
 High turnover (sales/avg. inventory) is generally good
4. Quality Control:
 Proper storage to maintain quality
 First-In-First-Out (FIFO) for perishables
5. Economies of Scale:
 Bulk purchases can reduce per-unit costs
 But must balance with holding costs
6. Supply Chain Efficiency:
 Just-In-Time (JIT) to reduce holding costs
 Vendor-Managed Inventory (VMI) for collaboration
7. Demand Forecasting:
 Accurate forecasts reduce over/understocking
 Consider seasonality, trends, promotions
8. Technology Integration:
 ERP systems for real-time tracking
 RFID for automated tracking
9. Customer Satisfaction:
 Quick order fulfillment
 Wide product availability
10. Adaptability:
 Flexibility to adjust to market changes
 Product life cycle management
Objectives of Cash Management:
 1. Ensure Liquidity:
 Always have cash for operational needs (payroll, suppliers)
 Avoid costly short-term borrowing
2. Optimize Cash Holdings:
 Minimum cash for operations (like inventory's safety stock)
 Excess in interest-bearing accounts (like marketable securities)
3. Accelerate Cash Inflows:
 Prompt invoicing
 Offer discounts for early payment
 Electronic payments
4. Decelerate Cash Outflows:
 Negotiate longer payment terms with suppliers
 Time payments to maximize float
5. Invest Idle Cash:
 Short-term, liquid investments (T-bills, CDs)
 Balance safety, liquidity, and yield
6. Minimize Transaction Costs:
 Consolidate bank accounts
 Use efficient payment methods
7. Manage Currency Risk:
 For international operations, use hedging tools
8. Cash Flow Forecasting:
 Predict cash needs to avoid shortfalls
 Plan for seasonal fluctuations
9. Banking Relationships:
 Negotiate favorable terms (interest rates, services)
 Ensure access to credit lines
10. Technology Use:
 Cash management software
 Real-time monitoring
Similarities in Objectives:
1. Optimization: Both aim to optimize a current asset - neither too much (opportunity cost) nor
too little (operational risk).
2. Cost Minimization:
 Inventory: Holding, ordering, stockout costs
 Cash: Opportunity cost of idle cash, transaction costs, borrowing costs
3. Operational Continuity:
 Inventory: Avoid stockouts
 Cash: Maintain liquidity for daily operations
4. Forecasting:
 Inventory: Demand forecasting
 Cash: Cash flow forecasting
5. Technology Integration: Both use software for real-time tracking, analytics.
6. Balancing Acts:
 Inventory: Bulk discounts vs. holding costs
 Cash: Liquidity vs. investment returns
7. Efficiency Metrics:
 Inventory: Turnover ratio
  Cash: Cash conversion cycle
8. Supply Chain/Banking Relationships:
 Inventory: Supplier terms, VMI
 Cash: Bank services, credit lines
9. Risk Management:
 Inventory: Obsolescence, damage
 Cash: Liquidity, currency risks
10. Strategic Impact:
 Both directly impact firm value, operational efficiency, and strategic flexibility.
In essence, both involve the delicate balance of having just enough of a vital resource to ensure smooth
operations while minimizing the costs of holding too much. The difference is in the nature of the asset
(physical inventory vs. liquid cash) and the specific tactics used, but the overarching goals of efficiency,
risk management, and value optimization are strikingly similar.
__________________________________________________________________________________
QUESTION 16: Explain briefly the factors which influence the dividend policy of a firm.

Dividend policy is a critical financial decision that impacts shareholder returns, firm value, and financial
flexibility. It's influenced by various factors:
1. Profitability and Cash Flow:
 Higher profits and cash flows generally allow for higher dividends.
 But cash flow (not just accounting profit) is key, as dividends are paid in cash.
2. Investment Opportunities:
 Firms with many positive NPV projects (growth companies) tend to pay lower dividends,
retaining earnings for investment.
 Mature firms with fewer opportunities often pay higher dividends.
3. Access to Capital Markets:
 Firms with easy, cheap access to equity or debt markets are more flexible with dividends.
 Smaller or riskier firms might retain more earnings to avoid costly external financing.
4. Legal Restrictions:
 Some jurisdictions restrict dividends based on profitability or solvency tests.
 Bond covenants might limit dividend payouts.
5. Tax Considerations:
 In some tax regimes, dividends are taxed higher than capital gains, favoring share buybacks.
 Conversely, when dividends are tax-advantaged, firms might prefer them.
6. Shareholder Preferences:
 Institutional investors (like pension funds) often prefer steady dividends.
 High-net-worth individuals might prefer capital gains for tax reasons.
 "Dividend clientele" suggests firms attract investors who like their payout policy.
7. Signaling Effect:
 Dividend changes signal management's view of future prospects.
 Increases suggest confidence; decreases can signal distress.
8. Stability and Growth:
 Many firms aim for stable, growing dividends to signal health.
 The "sticky dividend" hypothesis: firms are reluctant to cut dividends.
9. Industry Norms:
 Some sectors (utilities, REITs) are known for high dividends.
  Tech firms historically paid low/no dividends, though this is changing.
10. Control Concerns:
 High retention (low dividends) increases internal equity, reducing dilution.
 But it can also attract activist investors demanding higher payouts.
11. Inflation:
 Higher inflation might push for higher nominal dividends to maintain real value.
12. Business Lifecycle:
 Startups: No dividends, reinvest all cash.
 Growth: Low/no dividends, focus on expansion.
 Maturity: Higher, stable dividends.
 Decline: High payout or special dividends.
13. Agency Issues:
 Dividends can reduce free cash flow, limiting managerial empire-building.
 But they can also force more external financing, increasing monitoring.
14. Macro Factors:
 Recessions: Firms might cut dividends to preserve cash.
 Low interest rates: Investors may seek dividends for income.
15. Share Repurchases:
 An alternative to dividends, offering tax advantages and flexibility.
 But doesn't commit to ongoing payments like dividends.
16. Behavioral Factors:
 Mental accounting: Some investors "spend" dividends but not capital gains.
 Bird-in-hand fallacy: Preference for sure dividends over possible capital gains.
Theories:
1. Dividend Irrelevance (Modigliani-Miller): In perfect markets, dividend policy doesn't affect
firm value.
2. Bird-in-hand: Investors prefer dividends due to certainty.
3. Tax Preference: Capital gains are tax-advantaged, so low/no dividends are better.
4. Signaling: Dividends convey information about future prospects.
5. Agency Theory: Dividends reduce agency costs by limiting free cash flow.
In practice, firms balance these factors to craft a dividend policy that supports long-term value creation.
The trend is towards a holistic view, considering financial health, growth opportunities, and stakeholder
expectations.
__________________________________________________________________________________
QUESTION 17: Write a short note on management of inventory.

Inventory management is a critical aspect of working capital management and supply chain efficiency.
Here's a concise overview:
Inventory Management: The process of ordering, storing, and using a company's inventory efficiently and
economically. It involves raw materials, work-in-progress (WIP), and finished goods.
Objectives:
1. Minimize total costs (holding, ordering, stockout)
2. Ensure production continuity and sales fulfillment
3. Optimize working capital investment
 4. Maintain quality and reduce waste
Key Components:
1. Types of Inventory:
 Raw materials
 WIP (partially completed goods)
 Finished goods
 MRO (Maintenance, Repair, Operating supplies)
2. Costs:
 Holding (storage, insurance, obsolescence)
 Ordering (admin, transport)
 Stockout (lost sales, idle capacity)
3. Inventory Control Systems:
 Economic Order Quantity (EOQ): Optimal order size balancing holding and ordering costs.
 Reorder Point (ROP): Inventory level that triggers new order.
 ABC Analysis: Categorizing items by value and criticality (A: high-value, tightly controlled;
C: low-value, loose control).
4. Just-In-Time (JIT):
 Receiving goods only as needed, reducing holding costs.
 Requires reliable suppliers, precise forecasting.
5. Safety Stock:
 Extra inventory to handle demand spikes or supply delays.
 Level depends on demand variability, lead times, and service level.
6. Inventory Turnover:
 Ratio of COGS to average inventory.
 Higher is generally better (but balanced with stockout risk).
7. Technology:
 Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP) for integrated management.
 RFID, barcodes for tracking.
 AI/ML for demand forecasting.
8. Supply Chain Collaboration:
 Vendor-Managed Inventory (VMI)
 Collaborative Planning, Forecasting, and Replenishment (CPFR)
9. Special Considerations:
 Perishables: FIFO (First-In-First-Out)
 Fashion/Tech: Managing obsolescence
 Global sourcing: Longer lead times, currency risks
10. Lean Inventory:
 Minimize waste, optimize flow.
 But balance with resilience (COVID-19 highlighted risks of extremely lean systems).
In today's dynamic markets, effective inventory management is about balancing efficiency (cost reduction)
with resilience and agility. It's a key driver of profitability, cash flow, and customer satisfaction.
__________________________________________________________________________________
QUESTION 18: Explain and distinguish between relevance and irrelevance dividend theories.
The debate over dividend policy's impact on firm value is one of the most enduring in finance, with
relevance and irrelevance theories offering contrasting views.
Dividend Irrelevance Theory:
Proponents: Merton Miller and Franco Modigliani (M&M) in their 1961 paper.
Key Points:
1. Perfect Market Assumptions:
 No taxes or transaction costs
 Symmetric information (all have same info)
 No agency costs
 Investors can borrow/lend at risk-free rate
2. Main Argument: In such a perfect market, firm value depends solely on the quality of its
investments (cash flows generated), not on how those cash flows are split between dividends
and retained earnings.
3. Homemade Dividends:
 If a firm doesn't pay dividends, investors can create their own by selling shares.
 If a firm pays too much, investors can use dividends to buy more shares.
 Thus, investors are indifferent to the firm's payout policy.
4. Investment Policy Primacy:
 What matters is the NPV of projects, not how they're financed.
 A $1 dividend now or $1 capital gain later are equivalent (given time value adjustments).
5. Simplified Example:
 Firm A: $100 value, no dividend. Investor sells $10 worth for "homemade dividend."
 Firm B: $100 value, $10 dividend. Same result for investor.
Dividend Relevance Theories:
These argue that in the real world (imperfect markets), dividend policy does affect firm value:
1. Bird-in-the-Hand Theory (Gordon, Lintner):
 Investors prefer certain dividends over uncertain capital gains.
 Higher dividends reduce risk perception, lowering cost of equity.
 Critics argue this ignores that future dividends are also uncertain.
2. Tax Preference Theory:
 If capital gains are taxed lower than dividends, investors prefer lower payouts.
 But some investors (tax-exempt entities) prefer dividends.
 Leads to "dividend clientele" effect.
3. Signaling Hypothesis:
 Dividend changes signal management's view of future earnings.
 Increases suggest confidence; decreases signal trouble.
 Supports "sticky dividend" policy (reluctance to cut).
4. Agency Theory:
 High dividends reduce free cash flow available for managerial perks or empire-building.
 But they also force more external financing, increasing monitoring.
5. Transaction Costs:
 Selling shares for "homemade dividends" incurs costs.
 Regular dividends can be more cost-efficient for income-seeking investors.
6. Information Asymmetry:
 Managers know more than investors. Dividends can bridge this gap.
 7. Behavioral Finance:
 Mental accounting: Some investors "spend" dividends but not capital gains.
 Regret avoidance: Dividends prevent regret of selling at a loss for income.
8. Life-cycle Theory:
 Young firms (high growth, cash-constrained) pay low/no dividends.
 Mature firms (stable cash flows, fewer projects) pay more.
Distinction:
1. Market Perfection:
 Irrelevance: Assumes perfect markets.
 Relevance: Recognizes market imperfections (taxes, costs, asymmetry).
2. Investor Behavior:
 Irrelevance: Investors are rational, indifferent to dividend form.
 Relevance: Acknowledges psychological factors, preferences.
3. Information Content:
 Irrelevance: No signaling role of dividends (all have same info).
 Relevance: Dividends convey management's private information.
4. Value Driver:
 Irrelevance: Only investment decisions (cash flows) matter.
 Relevance: Dividend policy itself can impact cost of capital and value.
5. Applicability:
 Irrelevance: More theoretical, provides a benchmark.
 Relevance: More aligned with observed corporate behavior and empirical studies.
In practice, most finance professionals recognize elements of both. M&M's work is foundational,
highlighting that in perfect conditions, it's cash flows that drive value. But real-world frictions mean
dividend policy does matter. The challenge is balancing these factors to maximize shareholder value.
__________________________________________________________________________________
QUESTION 19: “The best way to value equity shares is that based on dividend”. Explain this statement.
How would you value a share on which dividend is being paid?

This statement aligns with the fundamental principle that the value of any financial asset is the present
value of its future cash flows. For equity shareholders, these cash flows are primarily dividends. This
view underpins the Dividend Discount Model (DDM), which many argue is the theoretically soundest
way to value shares.
Why Dividends are Key:
1. Ultimate Cash Flow: While share prices fluctuate based on various factors, dividends
represent actual cash investors receive.
2. Shareholder Primacy: In corporate finance theory, the firm's goal is to maximize shareholder
value. Dividends are a direct way to transfer value to shareholders.
3. Long-term View: Share prices can be influenced by short-term market sentiments or
speculation. Dividends reflect long-term, fundamental business performance.
4. Intrinsic Value: DDM focuses on intrinsic value (based on cash flows) rather than market
value, which can be distorted by bubbles or panics.
5. Terminal Value: Even for firms that don't pay dividends now, their value ultimately comes
from expected future dividends. As Gordon said, "A cow for her milk, bonds for their interest,
and stocks for their dividends."
Valuing Dividend-Paying Shares:
The primary tool is the Dividend Discount Model (DDM). It has several forms:
1. Gordon Growth Model (Constant Growth DDM):
 Assumes dividends grow at a constant rate (g) forever.
 P₀ = D₁ / (ke - g)
 P₀: Current stock price
 D₁: Expected dividend next year (D₀ * (1+g))
 ke: Required return on equity (from CAPM: ke = rf + β(rm - rf))
 g: Constant growth rate (should be < ke)
 Example: A stock with D₀ = $2, g = 5%, ke = 10%
 D₁ = $2 * 1.05 = $2.10
 P₀ = $2.10 / (0.10 - 0.05) = $42
2. Multi-stage DDM:
 For firms with non-constant growth rates.
 Often a two-stage model:
 Initial high-growth phase
 Terminal stable-growth phase
 Formula:
 P₀ = Σ(Dₜ / (1+ke)ᵗ) + (Dₙ₊₁ / (ke - g)) / (1+ke)ⁿ
 First part: PV of dividends during high-growth
 Second part: PV of terminal value (using Gordon model)
 Example: 5 years high growth (20%), then 3% forever, D₀ = $1, ke = 10%
 P₀ = 1.2/(1.1) + 1.44/(1.1)² + ... + 2.49/(1.1)⁵ + (2.56/(0.10-0.03))/(1.1)⁵
 High growth: 1.2, 1.44, 1.73, 2.07, 2.49
 Terminal: 2.56 / (0.10-0.03) = 36.57 (at t=5)
3. H-Model (for smoother transition):
 Assumes linear decline from short-term to long-term growth.
 P₀ = (D₀ * (1+gn)) / (ke - gn) + (D₀ * H * (gs - gn)) / (ke - gn)
 gn: Long-term growth rate
 gs: Initial short-term growth rate
 H: Half-life of high growth period
4. Adjustments for Risk and Payout:
 Adjust ke for company-specific risk (e.g., using Fama-French factors).
 For firms not paying full FCF as dividends, use payout ratio or model dividend growth.

Advantages of DDM:

1. Theoretically Sound: Based on cash flows to shareholders.

2. Forward-Looking: Uses expected dividends.
3. Intrinsic Value: Less affected by market sentiment.

Challenges:

1. Forecasting: Estimating future dividends and growth rates.

2. Non-payers: Many firms (e.g., Amazon) don't pay dividends.
 Solution: View price as PV of potential future dividends.
3. Constant Growth Assumption: Rarely true in reality.
 Solution: Multi-stage models.

In Practice:
 1. DM is widely used for stable, dividend-paying firms (utilities, consumer staples).
2. For growth or non-dividend firms, analysts might:
 Project when dividends will start.
 Use Free Cash Flow to Equity (FCFE) models, assuming FCFE will eventually be paid out.

Remember, while DDM is theoretically the best (all value comes from cash flows), in practice,
analysts use a toolkit (DDM, DCF, multiples) to triangulate value. Each method offers insights, and
their synthesis often provides the most robust valuation.
__________________________________________________________________________________