Professional Documents
Culture Documents
2020-03-19 ETH BioDiv - Mission Report 1 EBI Needs Assessment - Final
2020-03-19 ETH BioDiv - Mission Report 1 EBI Needs Assessment - Final
2020-03-19 ETH BioDiv - Mission Report 1 EBI Needs Assessment - Final
MISSION REPORT 1
ASSESSMENT OF THE TECHNICAL AND CAPACITY NEEDS OF
FOREST AND ANIMAL GENETIC RESOURCES DIRECTORATES OF
THE ETHIOPIAN BIODIVERSITY INSTITUTE (EBI)
Deliverable: Mission Report 1: Assessment of the Technical and Capacity Needs of the Forest and
Animal Genetic Resources Directorate of the Ethiopian Biodiversity Institute (EBI)
TABLE OF CONTENTS
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
1 INTRODUCTION 1
2 ASSESSMENT OF EDI’S CAPACITY IN STORING FOREST GENETIC
RESOURCES 2
2.1 The current status of forest genetic resources ex situ conservation at EBI 2
2.2 Laboratory equipment and personnel 3
2.3 Challenges with Facilities 4
2.4 Installation of a new seed drying room 5
2.5 Cold seed storage room 5
2.6 Seed germination test 5
2.7 Personnel 6
2.8 Staff training 7
2.9 Power supply 7
2.10 Working space 7
3 ASSESSMENT OF EDI’S CAPACITY IN ANIMAL GENETIC RESOURCE
CONSERVATION 8
3.1 Techniques for animal genetic resources conservation by gene banks 8
3.2 Main objectives of conserving animal genetic resources 8
3.3 Current status of animal genetic resources conservation at EBI 9
3.4 Planned activities by Animal Genetic resources Directorate at EBI 9
3.4.1 Farm Animal Genetic Resources (FAnGR) maintenance 9
3.4.2 Ex situ maintenance of genetic materials from animal genetic resources in the wild 10
3.5 Physical structures required for animal genetic resources gene banking 10
3.6 Space and facilities required for gene banks of different sizes 10
3.6.1 Small repositories 10
3.6.2 Medium-sized repositories 11
3.6.3 Large-sized repositories 11
3.7 Main equipment, materials and tools for animal genetic resources gene banking 11
3.8 Main qualified personnel essential for animal genetic resources gene banking 12
4 STRATEGIC RECOMMENDATIONS 12
4.1 Forest genetic resource program 12
4.1.1 Technical 12
4.1.2 Links to local communities 13
4.1.3 Organizational issues 13
4.2 Animal genetic resource program 13
4.3 Equipment and facilities 14
4.4 Organization of activities 14
5 CONCLUSION 14
5.1 Results 14
5.2 Next steps 14
5.3 Forest and Rangeland Directorate 15
5.4 Animal Biodiversity Directorate 15
5.5 Collaboration 16
GITEC i
Consulting Services for the Conservation and Sustainable Use of Biodiversity
in Priority Protected Areas in Ethiopia GITEC-IGIP GmbH
ANNEXES
Figure 1: Malfunctioning units of the seed storage and seed drying rooms 4
Figure 2: Seed storage (-10°C) and seed drying room (< +20°C and 17-20% RH)
sharing the same compartment 4
Figure 3: Model of the seed drying chamber 5
Figure 4: Forest germplasm materials kept in crop gene bank facility 5
Figure 5: Design of the animal genetic resources laboratories under construction 9
GITEC ii
Consulting Services for the Conservation and Sustainable Use of Biodiversity
in Priority Protected Areas in Ethiopia GITEC-IGIP GmbH
GITEC iii
Consulting Services for the Conservation and Sustainable Use of Biodiversity
in Priority Protected Areas in Ethiopia GITEC-IGIP GmbH
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
I would like to thank and acknowledge colleagues for the support they provided me with and for
their contributions. I am grateful to Hailu Nugussei, a technician at the Forest and Rangeland
Biodiversity Directorate who had consistently been in place to arrange visits of laboratories and
other facilities including coordination with other staff members. I am also grateful to Abayneh, an
expert at the Forest and Rangeland Directorate, Abreham the Head of Animal Biodiversity
Directorate, Mengistu an expert at the Animal Directorate and Dr. Debisa, the Head of Forest and
Rangeland Biodiversity Directorate.
Last but not least, I am grateful to Dr Hugh Gibbon, Team leader/Chief Technical Advisor for German
FC for Conservation and Sustainable use of Biodiversity in Priority Protected Areas in Ethiopia for his
great support and ideas in the process of the technical assessment.
GITEC iv
Consulting Services for the Conservation and Sustainable Use of Biodiversity
in Priority Protected Areas in Ethiopia GITEC-IGIP GmbH
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
This mission report concludes the Assessment of the Technical and Capacity Needs of the Forest and
Animal Genetic Resources Directorate of the Ethiopian Biodiversity Institute (EBI) by a short-term EBI
Needs Assessment Expert (the Consultant). The Assessment was commissioned to scientifically and
technically assess the current and immediate infrastructure, equipment, and directly associated
capacity gaps in EBI for ex situ conservation work. The assessment was undertaken as activity of the
German FC-funded Conservation and Sustainable Use of Biodiversity in Priority Protected Areas
Project1 of which the Ethiopian Wildlife Conservation Authority (EWCA) is Project Executing Agency.
Implementation Support Consulting Services are provided by GITEC-IGIP GmbH (IC).
The role of EBI in the implementation of the Project is strengthening of ex situ conservation of
genetic materials of endangered, endemic and rare animals in the wild. This also involves the
strengthening of ex situ conservation of forest, alpine, rangeland, and animal genetic resources to
supplement the in situ conservation programs promoted by other partners to the project (i.e. EWCA).
One of the main aims of this assessment was to look into EBI’s forest and rangeland and animal
genetic resources conservation strategies and practices as identified by the Project; assess the
progress being made and identify the challenges being faced, as well as the capacity required to
effectively implement the set strategies. This includes procedures followed by the responsible
Directorate to implement the tasks suggested by the project, through facilities and equipment put in
place for this purpose, and the capacity of the available personnel (in number and training) to carry
out the tasks projected.
Hence, the assessment was focussed on the technical and capacity needs of these two out of the four
EBI directorates, i.e. on the Forest and Rangeland and the Animal Biodiversity Conservation
Directorate whereby the forest genetic resources program covers natural forests and vegetation in
the rangelands and in other ecologies including those that are within the protected areas and the
animal genetic resources program is designed to deal with livestock and wildlife.
Emphasis was on identifying the capacity and the technical needs, including the needs for upgrading
facilities such as seed drying room and cold chambers and the essential laboratory equipment and
materials that are necessary for the safe conservation of the collected and stored genetic materials.
According to the observation made, both Directorates are trying their best in performing their duties
regardless of shortcomings of facilities, unavailability of some necessary equipment, and with
limitation in space and qualified personnel to conduct routine technical activities at the level that is
needed.
At present, the forest and rangeland genetic resources program lacks the necessary equipment for
treating and testing forest species that are mainly endemic and for which storage behaviour is barely
known or have not been studied at all. Essential and required equipment such as; seed germination
and seedling growing chambers functioning at an alternating temperature are not in place. An
assortment of necessary equipment and facilities, knowledge of the storage behaviour of seeds of
the species collected, the technical knowhow to research and establish methods for testing seeds
and storage conditions are prerequisites for any ex situ conservation action. These requirements are
not fully met at forest and rangeland biodiversity conservation program of EBI.
The animal genetic resources program Directorate has no full-fledged laboratories, nor proper space
and equipment for collecting, processing and maintaining the collected genetic materials. A few
samples collected from some breeds of livestock and from the endemic fox are maintained at the
facility of the Kaliti Animal Research Center under the Ministry of Agriculture. The Directorate has
some collaborative links with Debrezeit Animal Research Center with the aim to promote captive
breeding for endangered species. However, no practical work on captive breeding has been done so
far.
1
Hereafter referred to in a shortened form as ‘the biodiversity project’.
GITEC v
Consulting Services for the Conservation and Sustainable Use of Biodiversity
in Priority Protected Areas in Ethiopia GITEC-IGIP GmbH
The assessment estimates that a total of approximately Euro 454,000 will be required for equipment
and facility upgrading in the two targeted Directorates in EBI. This amounts to approximately Euro
113,000 for support to the Forest & Rangeland Directorate, and approximately Euro 340,000 for
support to the Animal Biodiversity Directorate. These figures do not include: logistical costs,
proposed on-site training, international forex/pricing variations, or the mandatory two year
maintenance plan which will be a requirement for companies wishing to bid for this work under a
goods and services supply contract.
GITEC vi
Consulting Services for the Conservation and Sustainable Use of Biodiversity
in Priority Protected Areas in Ethiopia GITEC-IGIP GmbH
1 INTRODUCTION
This mission report concludes the Assessment of the Technical and Capacity Needs of the Forest and
Animal Genetic Resources Directorate of the Ethiopian Biodiversity Institute (EBI). The assessment
was commissioned as one activity of the Conservation and Sustainable Use of Biodiversity in Priority
Protected Areas Project2. The Project is funded by German Financial Cooperation through KfW
German Development Bank. Project Executing Agency is the Ethiopian Wildlife Conservation
Authority (EWCA). Implementation Support Consultancies are provided by GITEC-IGIP GmbH (IC).
The assessment of EBI is as per the terms of the agreement of KfW financial support to the Ethiopian
Biodiversity Institute (EBI) which is stipulated in the Separate Agreement between KfW and the
Ethiopian Wildlife Conservation Authority (EWCA), Reference No. 2014 67 133, and dated 23 June,
2017.
The agreement between EBI and EWCA is for EWCA to support EBI by providing investments and
maintenance costs with the support from GITEC IGIP GMBH. The support through the agreement
includes assessment of technical needs of the Animal Directorate with particular reference to the
collection and maintenance of semen of threatened wild animals as well as laboratory equipment
and materials that are required for the ex situ maintenance of animal genetic materials. In order to
identify the technical needs, GITEC has commissioned a sub-consultant for a capacity and need
assessment of EBI for ex situ conservation of forest, alpine, rangeland and animal genetic resources.
The commissioned short-term EBI Needs Assessment Expert (the Consultant) carried out a number of
short visits to the EBI headquarters in order to make (i) technical assessments of the existing
facilities, (ii) hold detailed focus group discussions with EBI researchers and technicians, and finally,
(iii) organised a series of presentations and planning meetings in order to situate the proposed
project support interventions within a framework which is well understood by all relevant EBI
stakeholders.
Accordingly, the assessment has been conducted with the aim to identify the capacity and the
technical needs, including the needs for upgrading facilities such as seed drying room and cold
chambers and the essential laboratory equipment and materials that are necessary for the safe
conservation of the collected and stored genetic materials. The assessment involved evaluation of
the system in place and procedures for collecting, storing, testing, documenting and replenishing of
genetic materials by both Directorates. The evaluation process was made through discussions with
relevant EBI scientists and technicians and by examining all procedures of operation within each
Directorate according to their set objectives. Facilities and equipment available and their
functionality were examined through checking all facilities and equipment available. Based on each
Directorate’s objectives and plan, necessary equipment and materials in need for the tasks of each of
them were identified.
The Consultant undertook initial meetings at EBI and further meetings with the DG EWCA. A formal
joint meeting was held with both the EBI and EWCA Director Generals. The outcome from this
meeting was a signed Letter of Agreement (LoA) between the EWCA and EBI which established the
foundation for the start of this component in the Project. Additional discussions were held between
the IC and the GIZ-funded project for Supporting Sustainable Agricultural Productivity in Ethiopia
(SSAP) about crop gene bank support in relation to issues such as EBI staff capacity building,
equipment and infrastructure maintenance and project troubleshooting.
The results of assessment are presented in Chapters 2 – 5.
2
Hereafter referred to in a shortened form as ‘the biodiversity project’.
GITEC 1
Consulting Services for the Conservation and Sustainable Use of Biodiversity
in Priority Protected Areas in Ethiopia GITEC-IGIP GmbH
The forest genetic resources programme at EBI is dealing mainly with indigenous species. Storage
behaviour of most of these species is not well known or little studied, and it is very essential to
research and develop techniques for testing and storing seeds of such species for longer term
sustainability. This involves (i) identification of storage behaviour, (ii) developing techniques for
treating seed dormancy and (iii) seed germination testing, which require an assortment of equipment
and competent knowledge and practices in seed physiology and seed technology.
Knowledge about the seed storage behaviour, physiological nature of the dormancy of the collected
seed and techniques for breaking dormancy and testing germination are essential before the
materials are removed from its natural system for ex situ maintenance. A well designed exploration
and inventory system to set priorities for collecting, and, appropriate knowledge techniques and
facilities for maintaining the collected samples are prerequisites. The task of exploration is required
to understand the taxonomy of the forest species, the species population structure and association
in order to plan and set priorities for collecting and conserving such genetic materials. Collecting
genetic materials without adequate facility and knowledge for handling the collected materials
would not fully serve the purpose of conserving, and may even contribute to genetic erosion
especially as regards to rare and unique types.
2.1 The current status of forest genetic resources ex situ conservation at EBI
The EBI forest genetic resources program has so far collected 148, 112, and 110 species of forest,
medicinal and forage germplasm materials respectively. The forest species are represented by 1,172
accessions of which about 35% of the collections is represented by one sample, and about 31% of the
species is represented by 2 - 5 samples (Table 1). Species represented with limited number of
accessions need more representation based on the range of the diversity for such species. The
number of accessions collected per species as of present seems to be small and the diversity
captured and areas covered are also limited.
Table 1: Current status of forest germplasm collections at EBI
No. species No. samples/ % total holding
% total species No. accessions
collected species of species
52 35 1 51 4.4
21 14.2 2 42 3.6
8 5.4 3 24 2
6 4.1 4 24 2
10 6.8 5 50 4.3
22 14.8 6 to 10 162 13.8
8 5.4 11 to 20 109 9.3
18 12.2 21 to 50 531 45.3
3 2.1 > 50 179 15.3
148 100 1172 100
The total holding of the medicinal plant species is about 1,258 accessions of 112 species of which
about 39% is represented by a single sample (Table 2). Similar to forest species, medicinal plant
species are represented by a few accessions is even bigger (about 68%) and may require more
collections in order to capture the available diversity over locations.
Table 2: Current status of medicinal plant germplasm collections at EBI
No. species No. samples/ %total holding
%total species No. accessions
collected species of species
44 39.2 1 44 3.5
9 8 2 18 1.4
11 9.8 3 33 2.6
5 4.5 4 20 1.6
GITEC 2
Consulting Services for the Conservation and Sustainable Use of Biodiversity
in Priority Protected Areas in Ethiopia GITEC-IGIP GmbH
GITEC 3
Consulting Services for the Conservation and Sustainable Use of Biodiversity
in Priority Protected Areas in Ethiopia GITEC-IGIP GmbH
Due to the above mentioned problems, the seed drying room which is about 60m³ in volume is
without use at present. It is recommended that the seed drying room be converted into a cold room
that operates at a temperature range of 4 to 10°C and can be used as a short-term storage facility for
samples that need processing. Moreover, a temperature range between 5 to 10°C is necessary for
storage of some tree species as they could not survive low temperature below 0°C, and in this case,
the chamber meant as a drying room would provide a dual service: i.e. as a short-term storage room
with temperature above 0°C and, as a storage for samples of which longevity would be short under
sub-zero temperatures.
GITEC 4
Consulting Services for the Conservation and Sustainable Use of Biodiversity
in Priority Protected Areas in Ethiopia GITEC-IGIP GmbH
For the above mentioned reasons the collected, processed, dried and packed genetic materials of
forest and rangeland species are temporally being maintained in the crop gene bank facilities (but
without sufficient space).
GITEC 5
Consulting Services for the Conservation and Sustainable Use of Biodiversity
in Priority Protected Areas in Ethiopia GITEC-IGIP GmbH
2.7 Personnel
The Directorate of Forest and Rangeland Biodiversity conservation has some 26 technical and 4
support staff (Table 5). The technical staff includes; 11 biologists (with backgrounds in ecology,
botany and genetics and with either BSc, MSc, or PhD qualification), 2 foresters, an economist, an
ethno botanist and GIS expert. Expertise on genetic resources and gene bank management including
on seed technology is lacking. However, some of the junior (graduate and under graduate) personnel
can be oriented to some of these missing fields through short-term trainings and MSc training on
genetic resources management and on seed technology.
Table 5: Personnel at forest and rangeland gene bank
No. of
No. Area of expertise Qualification Remarks
experts
1 Ecologist PhD 1 On job
2 Botanist PhD 2 On job
Botanist M.Sc 4 On job
3 Ethno botanist PhD 1 On job
4 Forester M.Sc 4 On job
5 Forster BSc. 1 On job
6 Rangeland ecology M.Sc 3 3 staff on job and 1 in PhD training at AAU
Biologist M.SC 1 On job
7 Biologist BSc. 5 4 staff on M.Sc training
8 Plant physiologist M.Sc 1 On PhD training at AAU
9 Geneticist M.Sc 1 On job
10 Economist M.Sc 1 On job
11 GIS expert M.Sc 1 On job
12 Support staff 4
Considering the huge and diverse tasks the Directorate is involved in, and taking into account the
future germplasm collection tasks and research required for establishing protocols for seed testing
and tissue culture; and for seed storage behaviour research of many of the indigenous species, it is
essential for the Directorate to plan for a proper division of tasks and staff trainings, and for creating
teams staff to work on clearly defined mutually beneficial tasks.
Equally important is to have well trained and equipped technicians in the fields of cooling systems,
electricity and equipment maintenance. The available person at present is a general electrician who
is not familiar with the functions of the equipment units and parts, and is unable to fix some of the
technical challenges that require expertise in such fields. Training ‘on the job’, especially for cooling
system technicians and electricians, during the installation of the proposed new facilities and during
maintenance services by contracted experts should be prioritized. There could also be a possibility of
training equipment maintaining technicians locally in Addis, through collaboration with institutions
such as the Ministry of Science and Technology of Ethiopia3, in areas where they can provide such
services.
3
Federal Democratic Republic of Ethiopia, Ministry of Science and Technology of Ethiopia. www.most.gov.et
GITEC 6
Consulting Services for the Conservation and Sustainable Use of Biodiversity
in Priority Protected Areas in Ethiopia GITEC-IGIP GmbH
GITEC 7
Consulting Services for the Conservation and Sustainable Use of Biodiversity
in Priority Protected Areas in Ethiopia GITEC-IGIP GmbH
GITEC 8
Consulting Services for the Conservation and Sustainable Use of Biodiversity
in Priority Protected Areas in Ethiopia GITEC-IGIP GmbH
of new lines or breeds, or to quickly modify or reorient the evolution or selection of an animal
population. Gene banks can serve as the primary source of such genetic materials for the purpose of
restoration, introduction of genetic diversity and for developmental research.
GITEC 9
Consulting Services for the Conservation and Sustainable Use of Biodiversity
in Priority Protected Areas in Ethiopia GITEC-IGIP GmbH
3.4.2 Ex situ maintenance of genetic materials from animal genetic resources in the wild
The main focus of the task is the collecting and maintaining of semen of species that are endangered
and of those close to extinction. The plan at the field level is collecting samples through close
collaboration with the Ethiopian Wildlife Conservation Authority (EWCA). This is important because
the information on the status of animals in the wild comes from the EWCA, and priorities for ex situ
conservation measures to be taken depend on this information.
The task of preserving wild animal genetic materials also requires facilities and equipment to
maintain the collected samples in vitro. As of now it does not seem practical to collect semen as
necessary conditions for preserving the collected genetic materials are not yet in place.
Captive breeding strategy that the EBI animal genetic resources program aims for is one other
important practical approach to save threatened species. However, collecting of semen from animals
in the wild or captive breeding of the same, would be problematic to the EBI program without
collaboration with EWCA and other stakeholder institutions that have the knowhow and the capacity
in animal breeding.
3.5 Physical structures required for animal genetic resources gene banking
The physical structure of a gene bank for ex situ preservation of animal genetic materials depends on
the objectives of the gene bank, on the range of species and breeds to be covered, and on the
financial resources available for the conservation program. The types of facilities and equipment
could be small, medium, or large but would have common features necessary for the smooth
functioning of the gene bank regardless of its size. The facilities include the physical plant (the actual
building and other structures) and durable functional equipment.
The actual collection and banking of animal germplasm comprises of three main activities:
a. Collection of the germplasm;
b. Processing and freezing of the germplasm;
c. Storage of the germplasm.
Although these activities may be undertaken at the same location, they are distinct and each
requires its own separate facilities. In theory, a gene bank for animal genetic materials operates as a
place for storage of germplasm, provided that the germplasm is accessed from elsewhere. In most
situations, a gene bank would have the infrastructure for at least the two, if not for all the three
activities. The EBI animal genetic resource program plan is to accommodate all the three activities.
3.6 Space and facilities required for gene banks of different sizes
The space required for gene banks vary and depend on the gene banks’ missions and changes as the
collection grows. However, the space requirements are relatively minor as compared to space
required for seed handling gene banks. The size and the capacity can be categorized as small,
medium, or large repositories.
GITEC 10
Consulting Services for the Conservation and Sustainable Use of Biodiversity
in Priority Protected Areas in Ethiopia GITEC-IGIP GmbH
About 500 straws4 could be processed and cryopreserved in a day with facilities of this size.
3.7 Main equipment, materials and tools for animal genetic resources gene banking
The following is a list of basic equipment needed for cryopreserving and storing samples. It is
important to remember that the purchase of multiple liquid nitrogen tanks for long term storage
need not occur at the same time. Liquid nitrogen is a hazardous substance that requires safe storage
and transportation. Some liquid nitrogen containers are bulky and therefore, number of containers
handled should be in a manageable size in terms of safe storage space, costs and risks.
Basic equipment:
Microscope (phase-contrast – for semen; stereo scope – for embryos);
Centrifuge;
Cooling samples (Styrofoam or plastic cooler, cooler cabinet);
Osmometer;
pH meter;
Equipment for determining sperm concentration (one or more of the following):
o Spectrophotometer (fixed or portable),
4
Straw – Small storage device made of inert materials resistant to ultra-low temperatures and specifically designed for
cryogenic storage of biological materials (liquid samples) such as semen, embryo, tissues, etc. at temperatures as low as -
190°C.
GITEC 11
Consulting Services for the Conservation and Sustainable Use of Biodiversity
in Priority Protected Areas in Ethiopia GITEC-IGIP GmbH
3.8 Main qualified personnel essential for animal genetic resources gene banking
Specialized human resources are critical component for successful animal genetic materials gene
banking activities. The number of type of personnel needed to operate the gene bank will vary with
the size of the repository. Common to all sizes, however, is the need for following different
disciplines:
Genetics;
Reproductive physiology and cryobiology;
Information systems and database development.
Minimally, a gene bank requires:
i. A curator (with genetics background);
ii. Technical support to cryopreserve germplasm, and;
iii. Technical support to develop database and input information into the database about the
samples in the collection.
The task of the curator is to develop targeted collection goals for each species and breed within
species of interest. The task is a significant responsibility for one person for developing germplasm
collecting plans. As gene bank activities increase in size and scope there will be need for increased
staffing. Much of this increase is dependent upon the flow of germplasm into the repository.
Additional technical needs arise with the increased size and the need to employ a broader range of
reproductive and cryopreservation technologies on different species. The need to quantify and
understand the genetic diversity which may include the utilization of molecular genetics techniques
also requires additional expertise. With additional requirements comes the need for additional
scientific and support staff and the size of the facility. Many of these additions may be addressed by
integrating conservation activities with pre-existing laboratories that have the additional expertise.
However, the gene bank should have a reasonable level of competency to execute its conservation
mission.
4 STRATEGIC RECOMMENDATIONS
Sustainable conservation is a product of well set priorities and action planning, organized
institutional capacity and coordination of efforts. A range of social, cultural, economic and
environmental benefits that can contribute toward sustaining the conservation efforts can be
generated from both forest and animal genetic resources management. The benefits can directly and
indirectly incentivize conservation efforts. Some organizational and technical approaches that would
be of use for the sustainability of the forest and animal genetic resources conservation program of
EBI may include the following:
4.1.1 Technical
The forest genetic resources program is mainly about ex situ gene banking of forest, forage and
medicinal plants germplasm. Management and utilization aspects of each of these require experts in
the field and the teaming up of these experts. There could be technical challenges of handling the
GITEC 12
Consulting Services for the Conservation and Sustainable Use of Biodiversity
in Priority Protected Areas in Ethiopia GITEC-IGIP GmbH
germplasm especially of the lesser known species. Therefore a strong team composed of plant
physiologist, seed technologist, pathologist, taxonomist/botanist, and a forester is important for a
sound program of forest and rangeland biodiversity conservation.
Unlike agricultural crops that are grown seasonally, producing seeds from naturally occurring forest
species is about decades in terms of a timeframe. Therefore, the tasks of any forest ex situ gene bank
should closely be linked to the natural system to make the conservation effort meaningful. The
program should not be limited to collecting and storing samples. It should extend itself to the natural
system for restoration of threatened species and ecologies. The main focus should be on
backstopping the diversity in the natural system. In this regard, production of seedlings and planting
them in their natural systems, based on the information on the species status and the overall species
population structure in their natural system, would be one of the important activities of the forest
gene bank. It is important to note at this point that it is worthy to use seedlings developed during
seed germination test for this purpose instead of discarding them as it is done during seed
germination tests for agricultural crops. Due to lack of seedlings of indigenous tree species, the
current tree planting initiatives in the country have access mainly to exotic species. This could be a
good incentive for the forest gene bank to focus on indigenous tree seedlings development.
GITEC 13
Consulting Services for the Conservation and Sustainable Use of Biodiversity
in Priority Protected Areas in Ethiopia GITEC-IGIP GmbH
It is recommended that the Directorate to start with preparing skilled professional staff in the field of
genetics/cytology, animal reproductive physiology, cryobiology, laboratory technicians and personnel
for information system and data base development while the laboratories are still under
construction.
5 CONCLUSION
5.1 Results
It may not be feasible for an institution to assign professionals and equipment for each and every
laboratory or lines of activities. The teaming up of professional staff according to thematic areas and
research problems of institutional interest as well as organizing general research facilities and
equipment in a way that it is accessible to all, is necessary. It is also important to have conditions for
collective efforts through team based specific division of tasks that eventually would enable enriched
outputs within reasonable cost, time and effort.
According to the observation made, both Directorates are trying their best in performing their duties
regardless of shortcomings of facilities, unavailability of some necessary equipment, and with
limitation in space and qualified personnel to conduct routine technical activities at the level that is
needed.
The assessment estimates that a total of approximately Euro 454,000 will be required for equipment
and facility upgrading in the two targeted Directorates in EBI. This amounts to approximately Euro
113,000 for support to the Forest & Rangeland Directorate, and approximately Euro 340,000 for
support to the Animal Biodiversity Directorate. Detailed lists of upgrading facilities in need and for
procuring various laboratory, analytical and field equipment are appended as Annex 4 and 5.
These figures do not include; logistical costs, proposed on-site training, international forex/pricing
variations, or the mandatory two year maintenance plan which will be a requirement for companies
wishing to bid for this work under a goods and services supply contract.
GITEC 14
Consulting Services for the Conservation and Sustainable Use of Biodiversity
in Priority Protected Areas in Ethiopia GITEC-IGIP GmbH
drying and cold rooms are not functional due to some technical problems. Spaces that can be used
for laboratories are also occupied by staff from other Directorates. However, both Directorates have
to make progress and the following would be some of the approaches suggested.
GITEC 15
Consulting Services for the Conservation and Sustainable Use of Biodiversity
in Priority Protected Areas in Ethiopia GITEC-IGIP GmbH
Personnel to be trained may identify stages of activities to start with, and necessary
equipment during their trainings.
5.5 Collaboration
The main task of the animal genetic resources program would be to conserve genetic materials and
to provide users with access to the genetic materials. It is useful for the Animal Biodiversity
Directorate to link its program to stakeholders such as EWCA for the collecting of genetic materials
from the wildlife and to research centers that deal with livestock improvement. EWCA is the lead
stakeholder in in situ wildlife conservation while others such as Debrezeit Animal Research Center
are engaged in livestock improvement. The advice is for the Animal Biodiversity Conservation
Directorate to consider possible collaborative areas of work with such partners while planning for its
program activities. Activities such as captive breeding would be one those activities to be considered
with the aim to minimize genetic erosion in both wildlife and livestock.
GITEC 16
APPENDIX
1
Annex 1: List of Forest Species Germplasm
2
Annex 1: List of Forest Species Germplasm
3
ANNEX 2: FORAGE GERMPLASM
MAINTAINED BY THE FOREST
GENE BANK
Annex 2: Forage Germplasm maintained by the Forest Gene Bank
1
Annex 2: Forage Germplasm maintained by the Forest Gene Bank
2
ANNEX 3: MEDICINAL PLANTS GERMPLASM
MAINTAINED BY FOREST GENE
BANK
Annex 3: Medicinal Plants Germplasm maintained by Forest Gene Bank
1
Annex 3: Medicinal Plants Germplasm maintained by Forest Gene Bank
2
ANNEX 4: LIST OF EQUIPMENT FOR
FOREST GENETIC RESOURCES
Annex 4: List of Equipment for Forest Genetic Resources
Unit price/
No. Item Specification/Purpose Supplier Quantity Total
Euro
A Cold room and Cooling System
Hermatic compressor Compressors with condensing unit for two cold rooms cooler (r404 compressor). 2 Bitzer 4 1,500 6,000
as spare
2 Evaporators Evaporators ( 1 as spare ) Bitzer 2 600 1,200
3 High density mobile shelves Mechanical assisted or manual for 2 chambers with 5mX4.25m storage area each Grainger, RANA mobile 8 2,000 16,000
(with metal rack) storage system
4 System control uint Electric control panel with spare gudgets (spare parts), with cold room temperature BMIL International, Inc. 2 300 600
display
5 Thermohygrometer Data logging terhmhygrometer with calibration, 1.5V battery, traceable, 99%RH, to BRUNE 2 200 400
monitor temperature and RH of clod rooms
6 Data loggers Continuous logging of temperature and RH data in cold rooms and freezers and to OAKTON Instruments 2 150 300
record field observations
7 Freezer (chest type) Standard domestic freezers providing -20°C for long-term seed conservation 1 8,000 8,000
Foster Refrigerator
8 Storage trays (metal/plastic) Should withstand below freezing temperatures Foster Refrigerator 20 5 100
B Seed drying
1 Seed drying chamber/room A drying room of polyurethane panel (PU) on 5mX5m area (3mX3m drying room; Bitzer 1 22,000 22,000
2mX2m sealing and packaging room)
2 Light mobile shelves Note:Shelves in the existing cold rooms can be used for the new drying room. Racks Bitzer
can be perofrated to make holes for seed mositure release from all sides
3 Dehumidifier Rotary descicant absorption dehumidifier with secondary refrigeration equipment Munters Limited 3 1,200 3,600
to provide an environment of 15°-20°C and 15%-20% RH for seed drying (2 as
spare)
4 System control unitit Electric control panel with spare gudgets (spare parts), with cold room temperature BMIL International, Inc. 1 300 300
display
5 Plastic seed mesh bag Used for seed drying – lets moisture flow through all sides 500 0 100
6 Psychrometer Useful for prediction of seed drying period of diferent species. Meter displays Cole-Parmer 1 280 280
psychrometric chart and measures relative humidity in the dryin groom
7 Thermohygrograph Thermohygrograph for simultaneous recording of both temperature and humidity. BRUNE 2 800 1,600
Time scale: 7 days,
Spare charts, pack of 300 2 300 600
Cartirage pen (pack) 2 180 360
8 Evaporators Evaporators ( 1 as a spare ) Bitzerr 2 600 1,200
1
Unit price/
No. Item Specification/Purpose Supplier Quantity Total
Euro
Moisture testers:
1 Quick mositure meter For quick assessment of moisture content Seedburo Equipment Co. 1 500 500
3 Grinder Grinding small quantities of seeds for moisture determination Locally available 1
4 Oven Gravity convection - Temperature range 30°–200°C, with fan convection and Fisher scientific 1 600 600
temperature controller with adjustable thermostat and timer
Mecanical convection: - Temperature range 30°–200°C, with fan convection and Fisher scientific 1 600 600
temperature controller with adjustable thermostat and timer
5 Seed divider To prepare representative samples from composite samples Seedburo Equipment Co 1 3,000 3,000
6 Balance, for moisture Combining heating with highly accurate weighing technology to deliver a fast and Sortorius, Metler-Toledo 1 1,900 1,900
determination precise method of moisture analysis - (0.001g balance)
7 Sealing machine (for aluminum foil Constant heat machines that use thermostatic controllers to maintain the element 1 750 750
Audion Elektro BV
bags) bar at a selected temperature to seal laminated aluminum bags
Containers:
1 Aluminum foil bags Aluminum foil bags - laminated, made of three layers: polyester on the outside, Barrier Foil Products Co. 20,000 0 2,000
aluminum in the middle and polyethylene on the inside, and puncture resistant
2 Aluminum cans Cans with screw caps fitted with rubber gasket - (500g) Barrier Foil Products Co. 1000 1 600
3 Glass bottles Glass bottles fitted with polypropylene lids, Dark - brown ( 250 -500gm volume) Fisher scientific 250 6 1,500
5 Stereo microscope With LED and Digital Display Olympus 1 500 500
6 Dissecting microscope Am Scope 20x 40x 80x Binocular Stereo Microscope Olympus 1 350 350
7 Magnifier lamp Seed cleaning Hoffman Manufacturing Olympus 2 150 300
8 Digital room thermostat 16A Touch Screen Digital LCD Floor Heating control Thermostat Programmable 2 120 240
Fisher Scientific
temperature controller Room Warm Temperature Controller
9 Two chamber Temperature Chamber Size : 550 × 950 × 550 mm ( L×B×H); Display : 2 x16 col LCD display; Temp. Seedburo Equipment Co. 1 8,000 8,000
controller incubator/ Germinator Range : 10˚C - 50˚C ±1˚C; Humidity Range : up to 95 % RH±5%; Power : 220v 50Hz
A.C
10 Horizontal Laminar air flow hood Stainless-steel, BZ- 8SSRX.. 94`` wide. 22``deep.34``high Fisher Scientific 1 2,600 2,600
11 Lath-house For growing tree seedlings under controlled light (can locally be built)
2
Unit price/
No. Item Specification/Purpose Supplier Quantity Total
Euro
Laboratory supplies:
1 Germination paper Sigma Lump sum 1,000
2 Lab-ware Petridishes, forceps, desiccators, pip[petes, dispensors, other glassware etc. Sigma Lump sum 700
3 Chemicals Tetrazolium chloride, Agar, desiccants, carmines, etc. for seed dormancy and Sigma Lump sum 1,200
viability testing
4 Magnetic stirrer Lab Magnetic Mixer and Hotplate with Stirring Bar (with 4 spare bars) Fisher Scientific 1 350 350
D Seed processing
1 Thresher ( mechanical) Designed for threshing different plants and heads of forest species Seedburo Equipment Co. 1 1,500 1,500
2 Electronic scale Weighing up to two decimal places – required at various stages of seed-handling Sortorium 1 900 900
3 Seed blower Seed cleaning – separation of light weight material from seeds Seedburo Equipment 1 700 700
4 Seed counter For counting a predetermined number of seeds or registering a count on a pre- 2 500 1,000
Seedburo Equipment
weighed or volumetrically measured portion
Balance digital For weighing cleaned samples before packing - (0.01g balance) Sortorium 2 700 1,400
5 Seed-counting boards For counting and spacing large seeds in planting medium Seedburo Equipment 4 45 180
6 Shelving (static) Locally available Seedburo Equipment
7 Sieves, graded Seed cleaning and separation (of different hole size in mm) in sets Seedburo Equipment 2 35 70
8 Purity work-board Seed cleaning - in sets Seedburo Equipment 4 125 500
9 Paper bags Brown (100 pieces per pack) Seedburo Equipment 50 5 250
10 Clothe bags Locally available
Field tools/equipment
1 Digital camera Sony a7 III Full-frame Mirrorless Interchangeable-Lens Camera with 28-70mm Lens Sony 1 1,900 1,900
Optical with 3-Inch LCD, Black (ILCE7M3K/B)
2 Binocular Image Stabilized Binocular - Cleaning Kit - Soft CASE-MED (SLR + Lenses) Canon 1 600 600
3 Field materials Seed envelops, pollination bags, labels, etc. Locally
4 Global Positioning System (GPS) Handheld GPS (For germplasm collectiona and exploration mission) Samsung 1 450 450
Total 113,530
3
ANNEX 5: LIST OF EQUIPMENT AND
MATERIALS FOR ANIMAL GENETIC
RESOURCES PROGRAM (EBI
PROPOSAL)
Annex 5: List of Equipment and Materials for Animal Genetic Resources Program
30 Electronic digital vernier Lewiswear stainless steel calipar 150mm per 0-6 inch with LCD screen 1 Amazon 25
31 Labnet D1200 ACCUBLOCK, Digital dry bath ABSINSTOCK.COM D1200 1 ABSINSTOCK.COM 76 Genialia preparation
32 Storage Boxes Model Size
33 Insect Storage BoxSize53x45x9 cm RI-61-01 125 Rescholar Equipment /Bioquip 5,000 Lepidoptera speciman storage
34 Insect Storage BoxSize 45x30x7.5 cm RI-61-02 125 Rescholar Equipment /Bioquip 5,000 Lepidoptera speciman storage
35 Insect Storage BoxSize 38x25x7.5 cm RI-61-03 125 Rescholar Equipment /Bioquip 5,000 Lepidoptera speciman storage
36 Insect Storage BoxSize 30x23x7.5 cm RI-63-01 125 Rescholar Equipment /Bioquip 5,000 Lepidoptera speciman storage
37 Insect Pins - Stainless Steel 20 Paradox Company 80
Insect Pins - Stainless Steel No 000
length 38 mm, Ø 0,25 mm, 100 pcs. For pinning the specimen for identification and storage
20 Paradox Company 80
Insect Pins - Stainless Steel No 00
length 38 mm, Ø 0,30 mm, 100 pcs. For pinning the specimen for identification and storage
40 Paradox Company 160
Insect Pins - Stainless Steel No 0
length 38 mm, Ø 0,35 mm, 100 pcs. For pinning the specimen for identification and storage
50 Paradox Company 200
Insect Pins - Stainless Steel No 1
length 38 mm, Ø 0,40 mm, 100 pcs. For pinning the specimen for identification and storage
10 Paradox Company 40
Insect Pins - Stainless Steel No 2
length 38 mm, Ø 0,45 mm, 100 pcs For pinning the specimen for identification and storage
5 Paradox Company 20
Insect Pins - Stainless Steel No 4
length 38 mm, Ø 0,55 mm, 100 pcs. For pinning the specimen for identification and storage
Insect Pins - Stainless Steel No 7 5 Paradox Company 20
length 52 mm, Ø 0,70 mm, 100 pcs For pinning the specimen for identification and storage
1
No Item Specification Quantity Example Supplier Price (EURO) Purpose/ Justification
38 Lepidoptera Spreading Boards/setting boards Groove mm. 5, width mm 65, length mm. 420 100 Paradox Company 1,450 For relaxing and identifying the specimen
39 Lepidoptera Spreading Boards/setting boards Groove mm. 3, width mm 53, length mm. 420 50 Omnes artes 725 For relaxing and identifying the specimen
40 Lepidoptera Spreading Boards/setting boards Groove mm. 7, width mm 87, length mm. 420 100 Omnes artes 1,600 For relaxing and identifying the specimen
41 Lepidoptera Spreading Boards/setting boards Groove mm. 15, width mm 200, length mm. 420 100 Omnes artes 2,000 For relaxing and identifying the specimen
42 Ultra Sonic Bath (water bath) Grant XUBA3, 5-10L, 10 - 100 °C 1 Wolf Laboratories / Advantage-Lab 250 For heating samples
43 Electro-ejaculator with probe Standard 1 Alibaba 3,430 Semen collection
44 Pesola hanging scale balance 1kg and 0.5 kg 1 Alibaba 100 For measuring weight
45 Computer Automated Sperm Analysis (CASA) Standard 1 Ivf1.com 5,000 For check semen motility and concentration
46 Straw filling and sealing machine Automatic, 4 straws at a time 1 iMV/ Minitube 50,000 For straw filling and sealing
47 Spectrophotometer Uv Vis. Double Beam 1 IndiaMART/ Daigger 7,000 To measure semen concentration
48 Tranquilizer gun For antelopes 2 Amazon 572
49 Tranquilizer dart 20 Amazon 115
50 Artificial Bovine vagina Rubber band 4 IMV Technologies/ Nasco 1,000 Semen collection
51 Artificial Stallion vagina Colorado 2 All Veterinary Supply, Inc. 1,300 Semen collection
52 Artificial Sheep and Goat vagina Rubber band 4 Minitube 800 Semen collection
53 Microscope slide warmer/Warming plate Digital (20°C to 50°C) 1 Thomas Scientific / Glass Laboratory 350 To heat microscope slides and cover slip
54 Pipettes Automatic, 5 -10 mL 5 86 Sample measuring
55 Polymerase chain reaction, PCR machine Thermo Fisher Scientific 1 Thermofisher/ IndiaMART 15,000 Molecular identification
56 PCR multi-well plates 96 well 2 pack Fisher Scientific 500
57 Thermo-shaker BioSan 1 Fisher Scientific, ProfiLab24 600 Shaking and tempreture control
58 FIREPol DNA Polymerase Solis Biodyne 10 Solisbiodyne/ Integrated Sciences 500
59 Ultrasound/endoscope 1.5–15 megahertz 1 veterinary ultrasonic scanner 800 Examining female reproductive tract
60 Plastic embryos straws Cryo-tip (0.25-0.5 ml) Nasco 515 Embryo storage
61 Portable Incubator Darwin Chambers 1 Darwinchambers.com 900 Equipment heating in the field
62 Micro-centrifuge tubes 1.5 ml 1 345
63 Gel staining trays Plastic 10 Dulova 1,000 Staining
64 Liquid nitrogen plant 1 Alibaba/ IMV Technologies 130,000 Produce liquid nitrogen
65 Illumina Hiseq/Genetic analyzer 2500 sequencer 1 Illumina/ Mrdnalab 30,000 Gene sequencing
66 Electrophoresis System (UVP) 2D PROTEAN 1 Cole-Parmer/ Lap. equipment 2,000 Gel documentation
67 Electro-Eluter Model 422 1 Bio-Rad/ News Medical 400 Electro-elution cell for preparative recovery
68 Sherman trap (Alumunim foldable) 5.08 x 6.35 x 16.51 cm Pcs Forestry suppliers 5,000
69 Range finder Nikon forestery pro laser range finder 100 pc Amazon 450
70 Bat sound detector SSFbat2detector 1 nhbs 220
71 Compound Heated Stage Phase-Contrast Microscope LW Scientific i4 Semen Analysis Microscope with Heated Stage 1 New York Microscope Company 4,000 Check sperm Motility
72 Wooden rat trap 7'Lx3.25'w. 100 Alibaba 50
73 Automatic Straw printer Computer programmable 1 Minitube/ IndiaMART 4,000 Output data printing on straw
74 Centrifuge chargeable Automatic, 100 - 4000rpm 1 Alibaba/ onrochemical.com 300 Sample separation on field work
75 Straw positioning device Plastic 4 IMV Technologies 80 Straw adjustment
76 Straw distributor block Stainless steel, for 175 straws 10 IMV Technologies 1,000 Straw distributor
77 Goblets Plastic 25 IMV Technologies 500 Semen straw storage
78 Cooling cabinet Bio-freezer 1 IMV Technologies 400 Liquid nitrogen vapour freezing
79 Refrigerator Horizontal +4/5 semen Cooling Castle 1 Minitube 3,000 Processing semen at 4/5 degree centigrade
80 Sterilizing oven Dry Heat 1 Microbeonline/ JP SELECTA 2,000 Sterilization of grasswares
81 Autoclave Sterilizer Low pressure 1 Microbeonline/ iMV 1,000 Sterilization of rubberwares
82 Collection Vials Graduated Borosilcate 10 pack LAB Comercial 800 Semen collection
83 Cylinders or beakers Graduated glass 10 LAB Comercial 700 Measuring solutions
84 Vaginal/cervical Speculum Stainless steel 2 50 Examine female reproductive tracts
85 Water distiller/Deionizer machine Thermo scientific 1 Spectrum Chemical 1,500 Distilled water production
86 Petridishes Glass 5 pack 250 Sample examination
87 Digital semen Thaw unit Standard 1 Nasco 240 Semen activation
88 Embryo dishes Plastic 10 ProSciTech/ agarscientific 45 Embryo processing
89 Laminar flow hood Horzontal station 1 Terra Universal 4,000 Safety specimen processing
90 Manual straw filling device 0.25 and 0.5 ml plastic straws 1 Nasco 525 Semen fillin in the field
91 Deep freezer NuAire Glacier 1 Nuaire/ Labrepco 8,000 Sample preservation at lower temperature
Total 340,432
2
ANNEX 6: LIST OF EQUIPMENT AND
SOME SUPPLIERS
Annex 6: List of Equipment and some Suppliers1
1
This list of suppliers is not for endorsement
1
No. Item Suppliers
14 Sealing machine (aluminium foil bags/Cans) Aluminium foil bags Audion Elektro BV, The
Netherlands
Hulme-Martin Tavak, UK
Can sealer: Embarcadero Home Cannery,
USA
15 Seed blower Hoffman Manufacturing Co., USA
16 Seed counter Seedburo Equipment Co., USA
Hoffman Manufacturing Co., USA
Seedburo Equipment Co., USA
17 Seed-counting boards Hoffman Manufacturing Co., USA
Seedburo Equipment Co., USA
16 Seed divider Hoffman Manufacturing Co., USA
Seedburo Equipment Co., USA
17 Shelving (mobile/static) Crown Industrial, USA
Montel, Canada
18 Sieves, graded Hoffman Manufacturing Co., USA
Seedburo Equipment Co., USA
19 Stereo microscope Cole-Parmer Instruments Co., USA
Fisher Scientific, USA
20 Supplies, General (Germination paper, Lab. Hoffman Manufacturing Co., USA
ware (petrishes, forceps, desiccator, other Seedburo Equipment Co., USA
glassware, chemicals etc.)
Whatman plc., UK
21 Thermo hygrometer, hygro-thermograph Fisher Scientific, USA
Cole-Parmer Instruments Co., USA
Thomas Scientific, USA
22 Thresher, mechanical Hoffman Manufacturing Co., USA
Seedburo Equipment Co., USA
2
selected memberships: