Professional Documents
Culture Documents
4010 Borescope
4010 Borescope
4010 Borescope
Student Workbook
Course No. 4010
Borescope Inspection Procedures
Student Workbook
4010
Technical Training
Technical Training
Borescope Inspection
Procedures
Student Workbook
Course No. 4010
Solar, Saturn, Centaur, Mars, Mercury, Taurus, Titan, SoLoNOx, and Turbotronic are
trademarks of Solar Turbines Incorporated. Cat and Caterpillar are trademarks of Caterpillar Inc.
Specifications subject to change without notice. Printed in the U.S.A.
CONTENTS
Chapter Page
LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . xi
LIST OF TABLES . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . xv
INTRODUCTION . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . xvii
Chapter Page
Chapter Page
Chapter Page
Chapter Page
LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS
Figure Page
Figure Page
Figure Page
LIST OF TABLES
Table Page
INTRODUCTION
Lessons:
Appendices:
COURSE OBJECTIVE
OBJECTIVES
On completion of this lesson the student will be able to:
1. Describe the purpose a borescope serves when
inspecting the internal components of a gas
turbine engine
INTRODUCTION
Visual borescope inspections are one of the primary
diagnostic methods for maintaining turbo machinery.
Rigid borescopes, Flexible borescopes, and Digital
borescopes augmented with accessories such as a
camera attachment and guide tools, are used to
inspect critical components to detect early warning
signs of defects without complete disassembly of the
machine (Figure 1.1).
PRINCIPLES
A borescope is an optical device consisting of a rigid or
flexible tube with an eyepiece on one end, an objective
lens on the other, linked together by a relay optical
system in between. The optical system is typically
consists of optical fibers used for illumination of the
remote object and a rigid or flexible protective outer
sheath. The remote object is illuminated and an
internal image is formed by the objective lens. The
image is then delivered to the technician by means of
either a lens train for a rigid borescope, or a fiber optic
bundle for a flexible/digital borescope.
FIBER OPTICS
One of the general laws of physics is that light travels
in straight lines. However in the middle of the last
century, an Irish scientist named John Tyndall
made a remarkable discovery that light could be
contained within a stream of water (Figure 1.2). In his
experiment, "The Light Pipe", a container was exposed
to sunlight above a roof and a stream of water was
allowed to flow from the side of the container to a
bowl below in a darkened room. The sunlight stayed
trapped in total internal reflection within the curving
stream, seemingly traveling around a corner.
NOTE
Since only light is transmitted to the
viewing area, alignment of these fibers is
not important.
INCANDESCENT BULBS
ARC/DISCHARGE LAMPS
IMAGE COLLECTION
While the illumination system is used to deliver high
intensity light to the inspection area, there is also the
need for the borescope to relay the collected image
back to the inspector. This is accomplished by the
image collection system, which is comprised of either a
glass optic lens train or a fiber optic image bundle.
BORESCOPE COMPONENTS
While there are several models and types of borescopes
that can be used to complete a thorough inspection, the
hardware does not differ greatly from kit to kit. Many
of the same principles used in the rigid borescope apply
as well to the more current digital borescope. The
following are some of the main components used in the
operation of a borescope inspection kit (Figure 1.5).
1. Light Source
a. Supplies the light to the borescope by
means of an arc or incandescent lamp.
2. Illumination Bundle
4. Distal Tip
5. Objective Lens
BORESCOPE TYPES
Today, with the use of borescope inspection technology,
there is less costly and more reliable ways to monitor
the turbine internal components. It is possible to
inspect in place and document the condition of such
vital components as compressor vanes and blades,
combustor liners, turbine wheels, and nozzles without
disassembling the engine.
RIGID BORESCOPES
A rigid borescope (Figure 1.6) utilizes an illumination
bundle coupled with a precision glass optic lens train
to allow the technician to view the inspection area.
The glass optic lenses are encased in a stainless steel
sheath, or working length, with an attached handle
assembly that contains the eyepiece, focus control, and
scanning control for the technician. A diopter ring,
much like that on a set of binoculars, is available to
allow the technician to adjust the focus as needed to
view the inspection area more clearly.
ADVANTAGES
The advantages of the rigid borescope are that it
generally provides the best light conditions to the
inspection area providing a more superior image when
compared to the flexible/digital borescope. The costs
associated with rigid borescopes are often lower with
regards to repairs and ownership.
DISADVANTAGES
FLEXIBLE BORESCOPES
The flexible borescope (Figure 1.7) has two fiber optic
bundles, which consist of the image and illumination
systems encased in a flexible sheath or insertion tube.
The flexible sheath can be moved around corners and
into places that do not have straight-line access. The
image formed by the objective lens in the tip is relayed
back to the eyepiece, not by a series of lenses, but by a
fiber optic image bundle.
ADVANTAGES
The advantage of a flexible borescope is that it can
articulate throughout the area being inspected giving
the technician the ability to look at all aspects of a gas
turbines interior. This flexibility allows the technician
to maneuver around objects and corners inside of
the engine to inspect areas that were previously
inaccessible by a rigid borescope.
DISADVANTAGES
The disadvantage is that much like the rigid
borescope, a mounted camera will still be required in
order for the technician to capture an image of the
inspected area. The cost of ownership and repair is
also substantially higher than that of a rigid borescope
due to the implementation of the articulation controls
and the fiber optic image bundle.
DIGITAL BORESCOPES
The digital borescope (Figure 1.9) is quite similar
to flexible borescope in that it utilizes a glass fiber
optic illumination bundle to deliver light to the
inspection area. The transmitting of the image does
not require an image bundle as the image is captured
and converted into a digital signal before being sent
to the main control unit. It also has the articulation
control like the flexible borescope in that it is able
to maneuver throughout the interior of an engine
to view normally inaccessible regions. The main
components of a digital borescope are the main control
unit, technician control device, working length, distal
viewing tip, and optional display screen.
ADVANTAGES
DISADVANTAGES
NOTES:
STUDENT ACTIVITY
a. _______________________________________
b. _______________________________________
c. _______________________________________
d. _______________________________________
e. _______________________________________
f. _______________________________________
a. Rigid Borescope
(1) Advantages
(a) _____________________________
(b) _____________________________
(c) _____________________________
(2) Disadvantages
(a) _____________________________
(b) _____________________________
(c) _____________________________
b. Flexible Borescope
(1) Advantages
(a) _____________________________
(b) _____________________________
(c) _____________________________
(2) Disadvantages
(a) _____________________________
(b) _____________________________
(c) _____________________________
c. Digital Borescope
(1) Advantages
(a) _____________________________
(b) _____________________________
(c) _____________________________
(2) Disadvantages
(a) _____________________________
(b) _____________________________
(c) _____________________________
ANSWER KEY
d. Objective Lens
e. Working Length
f. Technician Control Handle
g. Light Source
h. Illumination Bundle
a. Image Bundle
a. Rigid Borescope
(1) Advantages
(a) _____________________________
(b) _____________________________
(c) _____________________________
(2) Disadvantages
(a) _____________________________
(b) _____________________________
(c) _____________________________
b. Flexible Borescope
(1) Advantages
(a) _____________________________
(b) _____________________________
(c) _____________________________
(2) Disadvantages
(a) _____________________________
(b) _____________________________
(c) _____________________________
c. Digital Borescope
(1) Advantages
(a) _____________________________
(b) _____________________________
(c) _____________________________
(2) Disadvantages
(a) _____________________________
(b) _____________________________
(c) _____________________________
OBJECTIVES
On completion of this lesson the student will be able to:
1. Define the major components of a digital
borescope
INTRODUCTION
Digital borescopes have now become one of the
standard tools required to complete in-depth and
detailed borescope inspection. Their ability to capture
images digitally for distribution by means of e-mail,
presentation, and reports has proven to be time saving
and technician friendly as opposed to rigid and flexible
borescopes. They have also allowed for more options
when viewing internal components by permitting
the technician to magnify, measure, and adjust the
lighting conditions of the viewing area.
BORESCOPE MODELS
There are 3 main digital borescope models currently
in use by Solar Turbines Field Employees in regards
to gas turbine internal inspection:
Olympus IPLEX SA II R series
OLYMPUS IPLEX SA II R
FAMILIARIZATION
MAJOR COMPONENTS
There are various parts that make up a digital
borescope. Components that range from the main
control unit to the LCD display screen can be included
with digital borescope. The following are the major
components that a technician will need to be familiar
with in order to have the knowledge and capacity to
properly operate a digital borescope.
1. Case
• Contains the central processing unit (CPU),
working length, and LCD display contained
in a rugged chassis and an impact resistant
case.
2. Scope Take-up Wheel
3. Insertion Tube
• The primary tool used by the viewer during
inspection. Contains both the image signal
wiring and light bundle, along with the
objective lens and light guide.
4. Remote Controller
5. LCD Monitor
6. Recording Card/Slot
• The slot for installing a memory card for
captured image storage.
REMOTE CONTROLLER
1. Microphone
3. Angle/Lock Joystick
• The joystick used to control the angulations
of the borescope tip.
4. Meas/Enter Joystick
5. Index Button
• The index button displays the thumbnail
screen view of all captured or stored images.
6. Power Button
8. Live/Gain Button
• Press to return to live image display. Used
to switch the GAIN mode when the live
image is displayed.
9. BRT/Mark
10. Record
• Press record to capture a still or moving
image.
11. Freeze Button
DISPLAY SCREEN
2. Title
• Allows the technician to display one line
of text detailing specific information for
inclusion in all saved/stored images or
video’s.
3. Zoom Level
4. Logo
• Displays the "Olympus" logo. Can be
turned on/off
5. Articulation Lock Mode Indication
6. Lamp Indication
7. Freezing Indicator
• Informs the technician if the image is in
frozen mode or in live view mode.
8. External Input Indicator
9. Recording Indicator
• Informs the technician if the video/voice
recording function is currently active.
ZOOM CONTROL
BRIGHTNESS CONTROL
During an inspection, the technician may find it
helpful to brighten the image in order to better discern
a possible defect or to lower the brightness to get
an overall better image of the inspection area. The
"Brightness Control" function allows the technician to
adjust the gain settings to either raise or lower the
brightness of the live or still image.
2. Boost 1
• Brightens the image slightly more than
standard gain mode, however there is the
possibility for increased noise under certain
observation conditions.
3. Boost 2
4. Boost 3
5. Low
• Low gain reduces the noise in the image,
however this mode may make the image
substantially darker than that of the
Standard mode.
12. Open the sun shade on the LCD and verify that
the unit is powered on and that the objective
view is being displayed.
MENU OPERATIONS
Prior to a borescope inspection, the technician may
need to adjust some of the default settings in the
borescope in order to perform a more complete
inspection. Some of the default options that
the technician may change include; Title, Color
Adjustment, Image Enhancement, Exposure, Scene
Adjust.
NOTE
To return to original factory conditions,
select the "Default" sub-menu to re-install all
factory default values.
NOTE
A USB cable or Memory card are not typical
items supplied with the borescope via the
manufacturer. It may be required for the
technician to obtain these items prior to
the borescope inspection depending on
availability.
STUDENT ACTIVITY
1. _______________________________________
2. _______________________________________
3. _______________________________________
3. __________________________________ references
the overall view of the inspection area in degrees
and typically encompasses 40, 80, and 120
lenses allowing the technician to specify the size
of the area to be inspected.
a. Field of View
b. Depth of View
c. Depth of Field
ANSWER KEY
3. __________________________________ references
the overall view of the inspection area in degrees
and typically encompasses 40, 80, and 120
lenses allowing the technician to specify the size
of the area to be inspected.
a. Field of View
b. Depth of View
c. Depth of Field
OBJECTIVES
On completion of this exercise the student will be
able to:
1. Demonstrate the ability to properly use a rigid,
flexible, and digital borescope
NOTE
If needed, alternate simulation containers
may be used for this exercise using suitable
boxes or containers and available components.
__________________________________________________
__________________________________________________
__________________________________________________
__________________________________________________
__________________________________________________
__________________________________________________
__________________________________________________
__________________________________________________
__________________________________________________
__________________________________________________
__________________________________________________
__________________________________________________
__________________________________________________
__________________________________________________
__________________________________________________
__________________________________________________
__________________________________________________
__________________________________________________
__________________________________________________
__________________________________________________
__________________________________________________
__________________________________________________
__________________________________________________
NOTES:
__________________________________________________
__________________________________________________
__________________________________________________
__________________________________________________
__________________________________________________
__________________________________________________
__________________________________________________
__________________________________________________
__________________________________________________
__________________________________________________
__________________________________________________
__________________________________________________
__________________________________________________
__________________________________________________
__________________________________________________
__________________________________________________
__________________________________________________
__________________________________________________
__________________________________________________
__________________________________________________
__________________________________________________
__________________________________________________
__________________________________________________
__________________________________________________
NOTES:
__________________________________________________
__________________________________________________
__________________________________________________
__________________________________________________
__________________________________________________
__________________________________________________
__________________________________________________
__________________________________________________
__________________________________________________
__________________________________________________
__________________________________________________
__________________________________________________
__________________________________________________
__________________________________________________
__________________________________________________
__________________________________________________
__________________________________________________
__________________________________________________
__________________________________________________
__________________________________________________
__________________________________________________
__________________________________________________
__________________________________________________
__________________________________________________
OBJECTIVES
On completion of this lesson the student will be able to:
1. Define the common terminology used to perform
a borescope inspection
a. Definitions/Terms to describe
INTRODUCTION
Having knowledge of how to properly operate a rigid,
flexible, or digital borescope is only the foundation to
properly conducting a detailed borescope inspection.
The technician must also have a thorough knowledge
of the area to be inspected and the terms that are used
to describe what was found during the inspection. A
borescope inspection cannot be accurately created if
the inspector is unfamiliar the parts or assemblies
and cannot explain his/her findings while inspecting
an engine.
The following sections will familiarize the technician
with the terms, definitions, and acronyms that are
commonly used during a borescope inspection.
DIRECTION OF VIEW
Direction of View defines the overall angle that a
borescope can see from the distal tip, expressed in
degrees. Typically found in 45, 90 and 180 degree view
patterns. The image is redirected internally to the
optical adapter by use of mirrors or prisms.
MAGNIFICATION
STAGING
Turbine Stage
A stage in the turbine section refers to a
stationary/nozzle segment followed by a rotating/rotor
segment.
ENGINE STATIONS
P1/T1
P2 (PCD) /T2
T3 (TRIT)
T5
P7/T7
The exhaust pressure and temperature of a
gas turbine engine is referenced as P7/T7. This
measurement is typically taken at the exit of the
package or at the last remaining measurement point
of the exhaust collector/diffuser.
ACRONYMS
Acronyms are created by typically using the first
letter of each word to create a short name of the terms
being re-phrased. For instance, the term "Quality,
Health, Safety and Environment" could be shortened
into the acronym QHSE.
At times during a borescope inspection, a technician
may need to abbreviate certain terms into smaller
expressions for use in an inspection report or for ease
of description to a customer. These shortened terms
are referred to as acronyms.
• TE = Trailing Edge
• IL = Inner Liner
• OL = Outer Liner
• IC = Inter-Cooled
• BV = Bleed Valve
• GP = Gas Producer
• HED = Hot End Drive
COMPRESSOR SECTION
Compressor Blades
Stators
Compressor Diffuser
The diffuser (Figure 4.4), while not typically
considered a part of the gas producer is the final
component in the compression process. The final
pressure increase takes place in the diffuser prior
to the air entering into the combustion or cooling
section of the turbine. The diffuser section is easy to
inspect by removing either the fuel injectors or the
torch assembly.
COMBUSTION SECTION
COMBUSTOR HOUSING
LINER
Fuel Injectors
The fuel injectors (Figure 4.8) are the means used to
deliver fuel to the combustion system. Depending on
the engine type and model the amount of injectors
used can range from 6 to 21 injectors. Standard
engines typically have more injectors that are smaller
in size compared to a SoLoNOx engine. These injectors
should be removed and inspected during any borescope
inspection, and can be an excellent means of entrance
for internal inspection of the combustion section.
Nozzles
The turbine nozzles (Figure 4.9) direct the oncoming
flow of exhaust gases resultant from the combustion
process into the subsequent turbine blades for energy
extraction. Turbine nozzles, which are separated into
segments, see the highest amount of stress of any
component internal to the engine due the extreme
pressure and temperature forces that are applied to
them from the combustion process. They are easily
inspected through the combustion liner and through
T5 temperature ports.
Cooled Nozzles
The first and second stage nozzles (Figure 4.10) receive
cooling air from Pcd air through radial tubes from the
area surrounding the combustion liner. Cooling air
is then passed along to the 2nd stage through axial
tubes. While the air delivery paths typically cannot be
inspected the cooling discharge ports on the nozzles
can be inspected while borescoping.
Turbine Blades
The turbine blades (Figure 4.11), which follow a
turbine nozzle section, are used to extract the energy
created from the combustion process in order to drive
the gas producer compressor. The turbine blades that
are mounted on a rotor can typically be inspected by
viewing past the turbine nozzle section, or by entering
through a removed T5 thermocouple probe.
Cooled
Typically the 1st stage turbine blades are cooled
(Figure 4.12) by pre-swirled Pcd air that is directed
into the base of the blades from a stationary nozzle
ring that faces the turbine disk at the blade root level.
Tip Shoes
Torch
The torch (Figure 4.15) is the assembly attached to
the combustor housing that provides the initial means
of light off for the engine. It has an attached tube,
which protrudes into the combustor liner allowing the
initial light off flame to enter the combustion area.
This assembly should be removed during a borescope
inspection to check for anomalies.
Blades
The power turbine blades are tied to a rotor, which
is not coupled to the gas turbine engine, but rather
transmits rotational torque to the attached driven
equipment. The blades extract the remaining power
from the combustion process in order for rotation of
the driven equipment.
Nozzles
STUDENT ACTIVITY
IGV = ______________________________________
EGV = ______________________________________
TE = ________________________________________
IL = ________________________________________
IC = ________________________________________
BV = _______________________________________
LCF = ______________________________________
d. Torch
e. Tip Shoes
ANSWER KEY
Leading Edge =
TE = LE
IL = Trailing Edge
IC = OL
BV = Bleed Valve
d. Torch
e. Tip Shoes
OBJECTIVE
On Completion of this lesson, the student will be
able to:
1. Describe borescope field tools and there uses
during an inspection.
FIELD TOOLS
While using a flexible or digital borescope gives you
the capability to articulate and travel deep into the
interior of a gas turbine engine, there are certain
instances were tooling is required in order to directly
deliver the tip of the borescope to critical inspection
areas. These components or aids are called field tools.
GUIDE TUBES
BORESCOPE SPRINGS
During a borescope inspection, the working length may
need to be inserted deeply into the engine. The further
a borescope is inserted the more flexible, and in turn
flimsy it becomes, thus causing sag issues. A solution
to this issue of sag is the borescope spring (Figure 5.2).
A borescope spring is a firm yet flexible piece of metal
that when used in conjunction with guide tubes, gives
the technician the capability to insert a working
length into the inspection area with slight rigidity,
thus avoiding the issue of sag. It is an excellent tool
for inserting the borescope inside and outside of the
combustion liner, and for reaching deep aspects like
the exit guide vane inspection area.
PRODUCT LINE
Solar Turbines has over 10 different engines currently
in production. Each engine has different components,
staging, and borescope access ports. This can make it
difficult to accurately perform a detailed inspection if
the technician in not familiar with the individuality of
each product.
Taurus 70 Saturn 20
T9701 T1402
T9701s T1501
T9702s T1601
T10301 T1602
T10301s
T10302
T10302s
SATURN 10/20
1. Air Inlet
a. 1st stage blades
2. Injector Port
3. Torch
a. Combustion liner & chamber
4. Exhaust
a. 3rd stage nozzles
5. T5 (If Available)
a. 2nd stage turbine blades
CENTAUR 40/50
4. Fuel Injector
a. Combustor
5. Torch
a. Combustor
6. T5 Ports
SoLoNOx Combustion
• FT21204 - Guide Tube Kit
Standard Combustion
MERCURY 50
The Mercury 50 engine was introduced in 1999. It is a
recuperated engine that is currently only offered in
the power generation application field. The Mercury
50 comes configured with a 10 stage axial compressor
(9.1:1 compression ration), an annular combustor with
8 fuel injectors, a 2-stage gas producer turbine, and
an overhead recuperator.
1. Air Inlet
a. Inlet guide vanes
a. #1 Bearing
b. #3 Bearing
a. #2 Bearing
6. T7 Port
7. Fuel Injector
a. Combustor
b. 1st stage nozzle
a. Recuperator cells
TAURUS 60
The Taurus 60 gas turbine was introduced in the
early 1990’s and now has more than 2.5 million hours
of operation among sold units. The Taurus 60 gas
turbine assembly consists of a 12-stage axial flow gas
producer, an annular combustor with 12 injectors, a
two-stage turbine assembly, and a two-stage power
turbine on H.E.D. units. There is the availability for
multiple configurations of the unit including H.E.D.
or C.E.D., SoLoNOx or Standard combustion, and
natural gas or dual fuel capabilities.
1. Air Inlet
2. Injector Port
3. Torch
SoLoNOx Combustion
• FT21204 - Guide Tube Kit
Standard Combustion
TAURUS 70
1. Air Inlet
b. 0 stage blades
c. 0 stage vanes (Obstructed)
6. Injector Port
a. Exit guide vanes
b. Combustor
c. 1st stage nozzles
7. Thermocouple Ports
SoLoNOx Combustion
• FT28301 - Guide Tube Kit
Standard Combustion
MARS 90
The Mars 90/100 product line was introduced in
1979. Since that time more than 1000 units have
been sold, with over 64 million operating hours
having been reported for those units. The Mars
engine is an extremely versatile engine with many
variations in horsepower ratings and in low emissions
configurations. The standard engine configuration has
a 15-stage axial compressor (17:1 Pressure Ratio), an
annual combustor with 21 fuel injectors for standard
and 14 injectors for SoLoNOx, a 3-stage gas producer
turbine, and a 2-stage power turbine.
1. Air Inlet
7. Fuel Injector
8. T5 Port
SoLoNOx Combustion
• FT32300 - Guide Tube Kit
Standard Combustion
TITAN 130
The Titan 130, originally released for production in
1998, is one of the larger engines produced by Solar. It
has multiple model ratings, and configurations with
reference to fuel type and emissions capabilities. The
standard configuration for the Titan 130 includes a
14-stage axial compressor with 5 variable guide vane
stages, an annular combustor with 14 SoLoNOx fuel
injectors or 21 standard fuel injectors, a 3-stage gas
producer turbine, and a 2-stage power turbine for
CS/MD applications.
c. 0 stage vanes
b. Combustor
c. 1st stage turbine blades
8. T5 Ports
SoLoNOx Combustion
• FT33303 - Guide Tube Kit
Standard Combustion
STUDENT ACTIVITY
1. ____________________________________________
_____________________________________________
_____________________________________________
_____________________________________________
_____________________________________________
2. _______________________ are typically
pre-formed metal tubes, designed to take the tip
of the borescope directly to critical inspection
points.
3. There are typically __________________ available
borescope access points on a Saturn 20 engine.
a. _______________________________________
b. _______________________________________
c. _______________________________________
d. _______________________________________
e. _______________________________________
f. _______________________________________
g. _______________________________________
h. _______________________________________
i. _______________________________________
j. _______________________________________
b. _______________________________________
c. _______________________________________
ANSWER KEY
1. Guide Tubes
Borescope Springs
a. Air Inlet
b. Fwd compressor port
h. T5 port
i. Pyrometer port
j. Power Turbine port
OBJECTIVES
On Completion of this lesson, the student will be
able to:
1. Demonstrate the ability to use borescope field
tooling to access complex regions of a gas turbine
engine.
HANDS ON EXERCISE
The instructor will lead a practical exercise
demonstrating the proper methods used to borescope
an engine, including the methods used to access
and inspect:
OBJECTIVES
On Completion of this lesson, the student will be
able to:
1. Describe the different forces applied to a gas
turbine engine during startup, normal operation,
and shutdown.
2. Describe the typical component failure modes
that can be found in a gas turbine engine.
NOTE
There is a definition section located at the
end of this lesson.
APPLIED FORCES
A gas turbine engine is subjected to many different
forces over a normal lifespan. During start-up, normal
operation, and shutdown these forces are applied to
the internal components and given specific conditions
or situations can tend to weaken or breakdown these
components.
The forces that are typically applied during operating
conditions are heat, pressure, and vibration. All
of these conditions are present whenever the
unit is operating and can be a direct cause of
early/pre-mature failure of the internal components
of a gas turbine engine.
HEAT
Heat is a force that is exerted on the engines internal
components whenever the unit is rotating or the
combustion process is active. Typically all of the
internal components of a gas turbine engine have
been designed to withstand certain temperatures
given their location in the engine. For instance 1st
stage nozzle segments are treated with a Cobalt based
coating to protect them from the intense temperatures
of the combustion flame. These extreme temperatures
generated from the combustion process can cause
certain components to pre-maturely fail if the heat is
allowed to climb higher than their set points.
PRESSURE
Pressure is a potentially damaging force that is always
present during the operation of a gas turbine engine.
The internal components of an engine are designed to
withstand high instances of pressure, however if the
design conditions are exceeded there is a potential for
weakening or failure of the components in question.
For instance, the axial thrust of the gas producer
while in normal operation is a form of pressure that
can induce strain on the thrust bearing assembly of
the engine. While the thrust bearing is designed to
accept certain thrust loads, if the design set points are
exceeded, there is a potential for component failure.
VIBRATION
Vibration is a force that can be exerted on a gas
turbine engine due to imbalance, combustion system
oscillation/rumble, or misalignment. These forces
can cause the premature failure of components due
to the high or low frequency pulsations that are
generated in the components. Typically, an oscillating
combustion liner is subjected to very high frequency
vibrations that have the potential to literally shake
the liner to pieces.
FAILURE MODES
During a borescope inspection, a technician has the
potential to find component(s) that are in a damaged
or failed condition. The primary purpose of a borescope
inspection is to find those conditions at an early stage
to provide the opportunity for repair or replacement
prior to catastrophic failure.
The following are the typical failure modes that a
technician has the possibility of viewing during a
borescope inspection.
WEAR
Wear is the depletion of a material from a solid
surface, caused by the action of another solid. There
are five principle "Wear" processes that can take place
when referencing component failure in a gas turbine
engine; adhesive wear, abrasive wear, surface wear,
fretting wear, and erosion wear. The following is a
brief description of each of these five processes.
ADHESIVE WEAR
ABRASIVE WEAR
Abrasive wear (Figure 7.3) is a failure mode that
occurs when two or more sliding surfaces operate in a
contaminated environment. The sliding surfaces are
typically damaged by particles that effectively cut
through one or both of the mating surfaces, resulting
in material damage or loss. Gouging, grinding,
or scratching of the affected surface generally
characterizes this failure mode. Abrasive wear is
identifiable in bearings, shafts, thrust collars &
washers, gears, and splines.
SURFACE WEAR
Surface fatigue (Figure 7.4) is a failure mode process
where the surface material of the components is
weakened by cyclic loading. Typically a contaminant
or particle becomes trapped between mating surfaces,
after several loading cycles the material becomes
dented or a crack is generated. During subsequent
cycles the crack or dent spreads, until finally the
surface fails and particles are released from the
material.
FRETTING WEAR
EROSION WEAR
SULFIDATION
Sulfidation, or sulfer-assisted oxidation, is caused by
the presence of sulfur in a gaseous form. Typically this
failure mode is identifiable in fuel injectors (Figure
7.5), combustion liners, turbine blades, and turbine
nozzles. Sulfidation is generally diagnosed in direct
relation to the fuel supply to the engine.
OVERLOAD
Overload is a condition that occurs when the applied
stress on a component exceeds the material strength
of that component. Deformation occurs when the yield
strength is exceeded, followed by separation of the
material when the ultimate tensile strength is passed.
Secondary or F.O.D. damage typically are caused
due to overload failure.
THERMO-MECHANICAL FATIGUE
Thermo-mechanical fatigue is a condition that exists
when temperature distributions vary with time
and produce cyclic thermal stresses on the affected
component(s). Over this time span, the component
material weakens, subsequently causing cracks,
pitting, and erosion of the material (Figure 7.8).
Typical components that are most susceptible to
these conditions are combustion liners, nozzles, and
turbine blades.
CORROSION
Corrosion is a condition where an electro-mechanical
reaction occurs between a metal and its environment.
It is typically characterized by the appearance of a
roughened surface, with possible pitting or trenching
of the affected area.
THERMAL DAMAGE
Thermal damage (Figure 7.9) is a condition that exists
when there is a chemical deterioration of a material
under very high temperature conditions. Typically
the components that are affected are subjected to
temperatures that exceed the protective coating
limits. High temperature atmospheres containing
oxygen and sulfur that are capable of oxidizing the
affected components contribute to the effects of
thermal damage.
THERMAL EROSION
Thermal erosion is a condition that exists when
the protective coating has or no longer exists on
the affected component(s). The components begin
to weaken, allowing the constant and varying
temperatures of the environment to breakdown the
material. This type of failure is typically related
to components in the combustion system and may
include turbine blades/nozzles, combustion liners,
and fuel injectors.
CREEP
STRESS RUPTURE
Stress rupture is typically the fracture of component
material as a direct result of creep in the material.
DISTORTION
Distortion is a failure mode that is represented by
a change in shape due to an applied force to the
material. While the component material may be strong
enough to not crack or otherwise fail, it is not strong
enough to support the load without change.
MELTING
Component #1
Type: ______________________________
Component #2
Type: ______________________________
Component #3
Type: ______________________________
Component #4
Type: ______________________________
Failure Mode: _______________________
Component #5
Type: ______________________________
Failure Mode: _______________________
STUDENT ACTIVITY
a. _______________________________________
b. _______________________________________
c. _______________________________________
d. _______________________________________
e. _______________________________________
e. Thermal Damage
ANSWER KEY
a. Adhesive
b. Abrasive
c. Fretting
d. Surface
e. Erosion
e. Thermal Damage
DEFINITIONS
Tensile Strength
The stress required to pull something such as rope,
wire or component to its breaking point.
Yield Strength
An applied stress causing a material begins to deform
plastically.
Plastically
The deformation of a material undergoing
non-reversible changes of shape in response to applied
forces such as heat or pressure stresses
Deformation/Distortion
Oxidation
Varnish
Contamination
The presence of foreign particles or chemicals in liquid
or solid form
Deterioration
A loss of metal as a result of environmental reactions
Discoloration
A direct indication of the formation of an oxide or
sulfide on the surface of the material being examined.
OBJECTIVES
On Completion of this lesson, the student will be
able to:
1. Define the purpose of the three main grading
scales used when borescoping a gas turbine
engine.
2. Describe the "Severity" levels associated with
failed or damaged engine components.
INTRODUCTION
Borescope inspections are performed on gas turbine
engines on a regular basis to ensure proper
operation and to document equipment condition.
Some of the reasons a borescope may be required
are for maintenance intervals, cause analysis, or a
requested/recommended inspection by Solar Turbines
engineering or the equipment owner.
During these inspections, there is the possibility that
the technician may find damaged or failed components
internally on the engine. The difficult task is to
determine the severity level of the damage and how it
affects the operation of the engine. Some damage can
appear to detrimental to the engine, yet has no affect
on the operation of the unit. Other times damage may
seem to be very slight, yet this damage has a negative
affect on the operational capabilities of the engine.
These conditions can be difficult to grade due to the
fact that all of the data gathered is done so by use of a
borescope and is not being seen by the naked eye.
SEVERITY INDEX
When borescoping the engine, there are three
distinct grading levels that are typically used by the
inspecting technician to determine the condition of the
components internal to the engine:
1. Severity Level 1
2. Severity Level 2
3. Normal Condition
SEVERITY LEVEL 1
SEVERITY LEVEL 2
"Severity Level 2" are the conditions that may be
present when borescoping an engine. These conditions
represent components that have not failed, however
show signs of deterioration or possible future failure.
These conditions typically do not give grounds to
condemn and engine, but rather mean that future
monitoring of the components in question will be
required. The engine is typically deemed safe to
operate and an immediate failure is not foreseen.
NORMAL CONDITION
STUDENT EXERCISE
The instructor will hand out several components that
are typically found internal to a gas turbine engine.
Using the knowledge learned in this lesson and in
previous lessons, the student is tasked with naming
the component, analyzing the component failure mode
if any, and assigning the component into one of the
three severity index levels.
Please list the components in the table below:
STUDENT ACTIVITY
a. _______________________________________
b. _______________________________________
c. _______________________________________
_____________________________________________
_____________________________________________
NOTES:
ANSWER KEY
a. Severity Level 1
b. Severity Level 2
c. Normal Condition
Severity Level 1
Severity Level 2
OBJECTIVES
On Completion of this lesson, the student will be
able to:
1. Describe the purpose of a borescope inspection
report.
INSPECTION REPORTS
Whenever a borescope inspection is performed,
there should always be an accompanying borescope
inspection report that is completed by the inspecting
technician. The purpose of this report is to document
the condition of the engine and all internal components
for review by the customer, district service manager,
and regional field engineer. This inspection report
should contain all of the details pertinent to describing
the equipment being inspected, all of the components
that were viewed, along with clear images detailing
the condition of the equipment.
REPORT TEMPLATES
Borescope inspection report templates (Figure 9.1)
are a simple yet effective means of creating detailed
and accurate reports. They give the technician the
capability to fill in the applicable fields with the
information and images that were gathered during the
inspection without having to generate an entire report
for each inspection. They also provide the reviewer
with a known format that is relatively easy to view
and gives the sense of familiarity.
NOTE
In order to access these templates, the user
will need Lotus Notes installed on a PC,
a valid Lotus Notes account, the FESD
database installed in Lotus Notes, and Solar
Intra-Net access.
REPORT CONTENT
The information contained in a borescope report
should list all of the relevant information for the unit
that was inspected. The report will typically be sent to
both the end user and the local Solar district office
for review. The reviewers of the report should be able
to make a decision on the operational capabilities of
the engine, based on the information contained in the
report. These decisions may have to be made without
the reviewers actually having viewed the equipment,
this presents the need for the report to be completely
detailed in listing all aspects of the inspection as
well as all relevant information regarding the unit
configuration and operation.
REPORT FORMAT
The report should be clear and concise and should
include the name of the technician performing the
inspection, the date and time of the inspection, a
conclusion section that summarizes all findings and a
recommended actions section.
ATTACHMENTS
During the inspection many images may have been
captured (especially when using a digital borescope).
1. Inspector Name
2. Date/Time
3. Package Specific Information
a. Customer Name
b. Site Information
c. Project Definition Number
5. Condition Reporting
(2) Compressor
(a) The technician should inspect
all of the stage of blades and
vanes that are available given
the borescope ports for each
unit type.
(3) Diffuser
(4) Combustor
- Part Number
- Part Number
6. Report Summary
REPORT COMPLETION
A completed report should always be provided to the
district office as well as the customer. The report
should be retained so that it can be referenced during
future inspections to compare conditions.
PRACTICAL EXERCISE
The instructor will pass out a blank digital copy of a
basic borescope inspection report. The student should
complete a borescope inspection report based off
of the information obtained in Lesson 3: Black Box
Simulation.