Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Corporate Financial Risk Management Notes
Corporate Financial Risk Management Notes
Corporate Financial Risk Management Notes
Defined-Contribution Plans
Risk aversion – is the tendency to avoid risk and have a low risk tolerance.
Risk-averse investors prioritize the safety of principal over the possibility of a
higher return on their money. That is, their money can be accessed when needed,
regardless of market conditions at the moment. Risk-averse investors typically
invest their money in savings accounts, certificates of deposit (CDs), municipal
and corporate bonds, and dividend growth stocks. They regularly pay their
investors a dividend. They want their investments to be highly liquid. That is, that
money must be there in full when they're ready to make a withdrawal. No waiting
for the markets to swing up again. The greatest number of risk-averse investors can
be found among older investors and retirees.
One way is through diversification of your portfolio. Diversification means
including assets and asset classes that are not highly correlated with one another.
This way you are not putting all of your eggs into one basket, and if some
securities fall in a given day, others may rise to offset those individual losses.
Mathematically, diversification allows you to maximize your expected return while
minimizing your overall portfolio risk.
Investing in low-risk products like fixed-income securities can also mean
guaranteed cash flows and constant positive returns over time.
Risk-seeking – is one's acceptance of greater risk. Risk seekers are more
interested in capital gains from speculative assets than capital preservation from
lower-risk assets. Risk-seeking can be contrasted with risk-averse.
Examples of asset types that might attract a risk-seeking investor include
options, futures, currencies, penny stocks, alternative investments,
cryptocurrencies, and emerging market equities.
Risk-seeking might also describe entrepreneurs who are willing to give up
the stability of salaried employment at an established company to start their own
companies in the hope of a greater financial and emotional payoff.
To be successful in these strategies requires investors to be well-educated in
trade execution and research. Investors need to monitor these investments closely
and be able to develop an exit strategy to preserve capital and gains.
Diversification in Business
Diversification Strategies:
Present Value
Present value states that an amount of money today is worth more than the
same amount in the future. In other words, present value shows that money
received in the future is not worth as much as an equal amount received today.
Unspent money today could lose value in the future by an implied annual rate due
to inflation or the rate of return if the money were invested.
Receiving $1,000 today is worth more than $1,000 five years from now.
Why? Because an investor can invest that $1,000 today and presumably earn a rate
of return over the next five years. Present value takes into account any interest rate
an investment might earn. For example, if an investor receives $1,000 today and
can earn a rate of return of 5% per year, the $1,000 today is certainly worth more
than receiving $1,000 five years from now. If an investor waited five years for
$1,000, there would be an opportunity cost or the investor would lose out on the
rate of return for the five years.
Inflation is the rise in prices of goods and services over time. If you receive
money today, you can buy goods at today's prices. As inflation causes the price of
goods to rise in the future, your purchasing power decreases. Consequently, money
that you don't spend today could be expected to lose value in the future by some
implied annual rate (which could be the inflation rate or the rate of return if the
money were invested).
Determining the Discount Rate
The discount rate is the investment rate of return that is applied to the
present value calculation. In other words, the discount rate would be the rate of
return if an investor choose to accept an amount in the future versus the same
amount today. The discount rate that is chosen for the present value calculation is
highly subjective because it's the expected rate of return you'd receive if you had
invested today's dollars for a period of time.
FV
Present Value = ( 1+ r ) n
FV – future value;
r – interest rate;
n(power) – number of periods(mainly years). Input the time period as the
exponent "n" in the denominator. So, if you want to calculate the present value of
an amount you expect to receive in three years, you would plug in the number
three.
Let's say you have the choice of being paid $2,000 today earning 3%
annually or $2,200 one year from now. Which is the best option?
Using the present value formula, the calculation is $2,200 / (1 + 0.03) 1 =
$2,135.92
PV = $2,135.92. So, if you were paid $2,000 today and it could earn a 3%
interest rate, but the amount would not be enough to give you $2,200 one year
from now.
Future Value vs. Present Value
Future value is the value of a current asset at a specified date in the future
based on an assumed rate of growth. The FV calculation allows investors to
predict, with varying degrees of accuracy, the amount of profit that can be
generated by different investments.
Present value is the current value of a future sum of money. Present value
takes the future value and applies a discount rate or the interest rate that could be
earned if invested. Future value tells you what an investment is worth in the future
while the present value tells you how much you'd need in today's dollars to earn a
specific amount in the future.
Present value is calculated by taking the future cash flows expected from an
investment and discounting them back to the present day. To do so, the investor
needs three key data points: the expected cash flows, the number of years in which
the cash flows will be paid, and their discount rate. The discount rate is a very
important factor in influencing the present value, with higher discount rates leading
to a lower present value, and vice-versa. Using these variables, investors can
calculate the present value using the formula:
FV
Present Value = ( 1+ r ) n
*n is power.
Consider a scenario where you expect to earn a $5,000 lump sum payment in
five years' time. If the discount rate is 8.25%, you want to know what that payment
will be worth today. So you calculate the PV: $5,000/(1 + 0.0825)5 = $3,363.80.
Present value is a way of representing the current value of future cash flows,
based on the principle that money in the present is worth more than money in the
future. Present value is used to value the income from loans, mortgages, and other
assets that may take many years to realize their full value. Investors use these
calculations to compare the value of assets with very different time horizons.
Financial Exposure
Financial exposure is the potential loss of the total amount invested. For
example, if an individual invests $2,000 into a stock, their financial exposure is
$2,000, and if the stock drops, they could lose the entire $2,000 value.
Risk Exposure
There are two primary categories of risk exposure: pure risk and speculative
risk.
Pure risk exposure – is a risk that cannot be wholly foreseen or controlled,
such as a natural disaster or global pandemic that impacts an organization's
workforce. Most organizations are exposed to at least some pure risks, and
preemptive controls and processes can be created that minimize loss, to some
degree, in these pure risk circumstances.
Speculative risk – is a type of risk that occurs based on actions an
organization takes and their subsequent consequences. Examples of speculative
risk might be the choice of a software platform that is later susceptible to critical
vulnerabilities or a choice to keep all backups on-site, which are later infected by
ransomware.
There are many different types of risk exposure, but the most common
include the following:
Brand damage. Organizations incur brand damage when the image of the
brand is undermined or made obsolete by events. These events range from
customer service failures to outages, breaches or other types of cybersecurity
issues.
Compliance failures. Compliance risk is an organization's potential exposure
to legal penalties, financial forfeiture and material loss, resulting from its failure to
act in accordance with industry laws and regulations, internal policies or prescribed
best practices.
Security breaches. Security breaches are significant avenues of risk
exposure, especially if sensitive stolen data is posted online for others to access.
Liability issues. Organizations can be liable legally for a wide range of
transgressions. These could include cybersecurity issues like breaches, data
exposure, failure to meet service-level agreements and many more.
Risk is not necessarily a bad thing in the investment world. The riskier the
security, the greater potential it has for payout.
When using standard deviation to measure risk in the stock market, the
underlying assumption is that the majority of price activity follows the pattern of a
normal distribution. In a normal distribution, individual values fall within one
standard deviation of the mean, above or below, 68% of the time. Values are within
two standard deviations 95% of the time.
For example, in a stock with a mean price of $45 and a standard deviation of
$5, it can be assumed with 95% certainty the next closing price remains between
$35 and $55. However, price plummets or spikes outside of this range 5% of the
time. A stock with high volatility generally has a high standard deviation.
Because investors are most often concerned with only losses when prices fall
as a measure of risk, the downside deviation is sometimes employed, which only
looks at the negative half of the distribution.
The standard deviation is the square root of the variance. By taking the
square root, the units involved are effectively standardizing the spread between
figures in a data set around its mean. As a result, you can better compare different
types of data using different units in standard deviation terms. The greater the
standard deviation, the greater the investment's volatility(oynaklığı).
Example of Calculation
Risk Thresholds
1. Calculate Price Change: First, determine the price change of the asset
from the previous day's closing price(today’s opening price) to the current day's
closing price. This is calculated as:
Price Change
Daily Return ¿ ' ' x 100%
Yesterday s Closing Price(Today s opening price)
Suppose that oranges that cost $1 a piece off the tree in Florida sell for $5 on
the street in New York City because they can only be grown in Florida (and
additional places where weather permits it). If the transportation, storage,
marketing, and other related costs to bring each orange to market from Florida to
New York come to $4, then in both places the respective market price ($1 in
Florida or $5 in New York) is equal to the arbitrage-free valuation of the orange
($1 to grow the orange in Florida vs. $1 to grow the orange + $4 in associated costs
to bring it to market in New York).
Now suppose that transportation costs fall due to technological improvement
or lower fuel prices, and as a result, the cost of bringing a Florida orange to market
in New York falls from $4 to $3. Now the arbitrage-free valuation of the orange in
New York is $4 ($1 cost to grow the orange in Florida and $3 to bring it to market
in New York).
Savvy businesspeople would take advantage of this and utilize the resulting
arbitrage to make money by buying oranges off the truck from Florida at the lower
price of $4 and re-selling them at $5. However as they do so, they will have to
compete against and against new orange resellers will be attracted into the market
by the arbitrage profit opportunity, by offering lower prices. This competition will
eventually drive the market price closer to its arbitrage-free valuation of $4.
1. Linear Instruments:
- Linear instruments have payoffs that are directly proportional to the change
in the underlying variables;
- The payoff of a linear instrument can be represented as a straight line when
plotted against the underlying variable.
Examples of linear instruments include:
Forward & Future contracts: The payoff of a forward contract is linear with
respect to the price of the underlying asset at maturity.
2. Non-linear Instruments:
- Non-linear instruments have payoffs that are not directly proportional to
the change in the underlying variables;
- The payoff of a non-linear instrument cannot be represented as a straight
line when plotted against the underlying variable.
Examples of non-linear instruments include:
Options with non-linear payoffs: Exotic options, such as barrier options,
Asian options, and rainbow options, have non-linear payoff structures that are
dependent on various factors such as the path of the volatility and time to
expiration.
Convertible bonds: Convertible bonds have non-linear payoffs because their
value is influenced by both the fixed-income characteristics of the bond and the
equity conversion feature.
In summary, linear instruments have payoffs that are directly proportional to
changes in the underlying variables and can be represented as straight lines, while
non-linear instruments have payoffs that are not directly proportional and exhibit
more complex payoff structures. Investors and traders use both linear and non-
linear instruments to hedge risk, speculate on market movements, and manage
their investment portfolios.
Negative interest can exist in certain economic climates; this can complicate
calculating the risk-free rate o f return and its impact on investors. In Japan,
stubborn deflation has led the Bank of Japan to pursue a policy of ultra-low, and
sometimes negative, interest rates to stimulate the economy. Negative interest rates
essentially push the concept of risk-free return to the extreme; investors are willing
to pay to place their money in an asset they consider safe.
Variance
Statisticians use variance to see how individual numbers relate to each other
within a data set. The advantage of variance is that it treats all deviations from the
mean as the same regardless of their direction. One drawback to variance, though,
is that it gives added weight to outliers. These are the numbers far from the mean.
Squaring these numbers can skew the data.
Standard Deviation
1. Calculate the mean of all data points. The mean is calculated by adding
all the data points and dividing them by the number of data points.
2. Calculate the variance for each data point. The variance for each data
point is calculated by subtracting the mean from the value of the data
point.
3. Square the variance of each data point (from Step 2).
4. Sum of squared variance values (from Step 3).
5. Divide the sum of squared variance values (from Step 4) by the number
of data points in the data set less 1.
6. Take the square root of the quotient (from Step 5).
There are some downsides to consider when using standard deviation. The
standard deviation does not actually measure how far a data point is from the
mean. Instead, it compares the square of the differences.
Outliers have a heavier impact on standard deviation. This is especially true
considering the difference from the mean is squared, resulting in an even larger
quantity compared to other data points. Therefore, be mindful that standard
observation naturally gives more weight to extreme values.
This indicates that the data observed is quite spread out around the mean. A
small or low standard deviation would indicate instead that much of the data
observed is clustered tightly around the mean.
If you look at the distribution of some observed data visually, you can see if
the shape is relatively skinny vs. fat. Fatter distributions have bigger standard
deviations. Alternatively, Excel has built in standard deviation functions depending
on the data set.
Key Differences
Standard deviation measures how far apart numbers are in a data set, the
spread between numbers in a data set. Variance, on the other hand, gives an actual
value to how much the numbers in a data set vary from the mean, the average
degree to which each point differs from the mean.
Standard deviation is the square root of the variance and is expressed in the
same units as the data set. Variance can be expressed in squared units or as a
percentage (especially in the context of finance).
Value at Risk (VaR) has been called the "new science of risk management,"
and is a statistic that is used to predict the greatest possible losses over a specific
time frame. Commonly used by financial firms and commercial banks in
investment analysis, VaR can determine the extent and probabilities of potential
losses in portfolios. Risk managers use VaR to measure and control the level of risk
exposure. VAR is determined by three variables: period, confidence level, and the
size of the possible loss. There are three methods of calculating Value at Risk
(VaR) including the Historical method, the Analytical method(variance-covariance
method), and the Monte Carlo simulation. Using the data provided by VaR
modeling, financial institutions can determine whether they have sufficient capital
reserves in place to cover losses.
Expected Shortfall(ES)
Since ES values are derived from the calculation of VaR itself, the
assumptions that VaR is based on, such as the shape of the distribution of returns,
the cut-off level used, the periodicity of the data, and the assumptions about
stochastic volatility, will all affect the value of ES. Calculating ES is simple once
VaR has been calculated. It is the average of the values that fall beyond the VaR:
V aR
1
E S=
1−c
∫ x p ( x ) dx
−1
where:
p(x)dx = the probability density of getting a return with value “x”;
c = the cut-off point on the distribution where the analyst sets the VaR
breakpoint;
VaR = the agreed-upon VaR level.
Backtesting
The ideal backtest chooses sample data from a relevant time period of a
duration that reflects a variety of market conditions. In this way, one can better
judge whether the results of the backtest represent a fluke or sound trading. The
historical data set must include a truly representative sample of stocks, including
those of companies that eventually went bankrupt or were sold or liquidated. The
alternative, including only data from historical stocks that are still around today,
will produce artificially high returns in backtesting.
A backtest should take into account all transaction costs, no matter how
insignificant; because these can accumulate over the backtesting period and greatly
affect the outlook for a strategy's profitability. Traders should ensure that their
backtesting software accounts for these costs.
Out-of-sample testing and forward performance testing provide further
confirmation regarding a system's effectiveness and can show a system's true
colors before real cash is on the line. A strong correlation between backtesting, out-
of-sample, and forward performance testing results is vital for determining the
viability of a trading system.
Example
Pros:
Cons:
Banks and financial institutions often use the Federal Reserve's Dodd-
Franklin Act Stress Test (DFAST) and Comprehensive Capital Analysis and Review
(CCAR) stress test.
The Federal Reserve administers the Comprehensive Capital Analysis and
Review stress test annually for banks with at least $100 billion in assets. This test
identifies whether banks have sufficient capital to operate during economic
downturns and plans in place to address such events and other associated risks.
Specifically, the Federal Reserve looks at the bank's capital, its plans for its capital
(e.g., dividends), and how it assesses capital needs.
Model Risk
Model risk is a type of risk that occurs when a financial model is used to
measure quantitative information such as a firm's market risks or value
transactions, and the model fails or performs inadequately and leads to adverse
outcomes for the firm. A model is a system, quantitative method, or approach that
relies on assumptions and economic, statistical, mathematical, or financial theories
and techniques. The model processes data inputs into a quantitative-estimate type
of output. While models can be useful tools in investment analysis, they can also
be prone to various risks that can occur from the usage of inaccurate data,
programming errors, technical errors, and misinterpretation of the model's
outputs.
In finance, models are used to identify potential future stock values and help
company managers make business decisions. Model risk can be reduced with
model management such as testing, governance policies, and independent review.
Model risk mostly affects the firm that creates and uses the model. Traders or other
investors who use a given model may not completely understand its assumptions
and limitations, which limits the usefulness and application of the model itself. A
model can incorrectly predict the probability of an airline passenger being a
terrorist or the probability of a fraudulent credit card transaction. This can be due
to incorrect assumptions, programming or technical errors, and other factors that
increase the risk of a poor outcome.
Any model is a simplified version of reality and there is the risk that
something will fail to be accounted for. Assumptions made to develop a model and
inputs into the model can vary widely. The use of financial models has become
very prevalent(geniş) in the past decades, in step with advances in computing
power, software applications, and new types of financial securities. Before
developing a financial model, companies will often conduct a financial forecast,
which is the process by which it determines the expectations of future results.
Some companies, such as banks, employ a model risk officer to establish a
financial model risk management program aimed at reducing the likelihood of the
bank suffering financial losses due to model risk issues. Components of the
program include establishing model governance and policies. It also involves
assigning roles and responsibilities to individuals who will develop, test,
implement, and manage the financial models on an ongoing basis.