Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 348

ETKİNLİKLERLE

DEĞERLER
EĞİTİMİ
II
ZBā
ū4) /•ūƍ' -ū•ƍ&)'$ŝ$•44$)'-$• •
(@NG@FD•&DO<KG<M••

4<TŬI•4֙I@OH@ID
Dr. Fatih Kurt

"@I@G•&JJM?DI<O֙M
Bünyamin Albayrak

4<TŬI•&JJM?DI<O֙MĿ
Dr. Faruk Görgülü

+MJE@•&JJM?DI<O֙MĿ
Sedide Akbulut

?DO֙M
Doç. Dr. Ercüment Erbay

&<OFŬ?<•PGPI<IG<M
M •ƍ@MDA@•)DC<G•5@T=@F
M •'ĿOADT@•"ĿG<T•DGBDI
Kezban G. Kariparduç Gülden
Esra Erken
Tuba Güler Bozkaya
TƎ@BĿG•0T<M
HDI@•4<G?ŬU
TƎ@BĿG•"ĿM=ĿU
TƎ@BĿG•"ҚU@MD

/<NCDC
.ĿH@TT@•Ī5" )
5@TI@K•&)-

"M<ADF••/<N<MŬH
AralGroup

<NFŬ•#<UŬMGŬF
0ŞPM•GOPIOJK

<NFŬ

 •<NFŬ •IF<M<•x•

N@M•ūI>@G@H@•&JHDNTJI•&<M<MŬ•   

  4  


$.)•    
.@MODADF<•)J

j•/  •DT<I@O•ūƎG@MD•<ƎF<IGŬŞŬ

ūG@ODƎDH
DID•4<TŬIG<M•"@I@G•(Ŀ?ĿMGĿŞĿ
<NŬGŬ•4<TŬIG<M•<DM@•<ƎF<IGŬŞŬ
ĮIDQ@MNDO@G@M•(<C •PHGPKŬI<M•PGQ<MŬ
)J ••ǥ<IF<T< )&-
/@G•••••• •
!<FN•••••
@ KJNO<•?DIDT<TDIG<M?DT<I@O BJQ OM
www.diyanet.gov.tr

2
ÿ±ÿ/%&,ÿ-&3

ÿ±ÿ/%&,ÿ-&3

11. KONU: KUL HAKKI ......................................................................................... 7


 ,VM)BLL‘OB3JBZFU....................................................................................... 8
 ,VM)BLL‘OB4BZH‘M‘Z‘N .............................................................................. 24
,0/6&."/&5#ÿ-ÿ/$ÿ ............................................................................. 31
 &NBOFU ....................................................................................................... 32
 &NBOFUJO,PSVONBT‘WF(à[FMMFāUJSJMNFTJ ................................................... 37
 .àNJOJO&O½OFNMJ7BTG‘&NJO0MNBL .................................................... 44
 $BO "L‘M %JO /FTJMWF.BM&NBOFUUJS ....................................................... 52
 A0 .VIBNNFEàM&NJOEJ ........................................................................ 58
 &NBOFUJ,PSVNBL ...................................................................................... 61
 ,BNV.BM‘&NBOFUUJS ................................................................................. 67
,0/64"#*3 ................................................................................................ 75
 4BC‘S,BWSBN‘ ............................................................................................. 76
 4BC‘SWF5BIBNNàM ..................................................................................... 79
 &O#àZàL5FWFLLàM4BC‘S........................................................................... 84
,0/6ĀÃ,Ã3 .............................................................................................. 93
 ĀàLàS,BWSBN‘WF.BIJZFUJ......................................................................... 94
 /JNFUFĀàLàS ........................................................................................... 102
 /FEFOĀàLSFUNFMJZJN ............................................................................. 105
 /BT‘MĀàLSFUNFMJZJ[ ................................................................................. 108
,0/6Ã.ÿ57"30-." ............................................................................. 115
 ÃNJU,BWSBN‘ ........................................................................................... 116
 1FZHBNCFSJNJ[%BJNBÃNJUWBSE‘ ............................................................. 120
 3BCCJNJ[JO3BINFUJOF4‘þ‘ONBLÃNJU .................................................... 127
,0/6ÿ/4"/7&5"#ÿ"54&7(ÿ4ÿ ............................................................ 133
 #àUàO7BSM‘LMBS%FþFSMJEJS ......................................................................... 134
 )JÎCJSĀFZ4FCFQTJ[:BSBU‘MNBE‘ ................................................................ 140
 :BSBU‘MN‘āMBS‘O&O%FþFSMJTJ0MBOÿOTBO‘O4PSVNMVMVþV ............................ 149

3
ÿ±ÿ/%&,ÿ-&3

 ,ÉJOBUUBLJ%à[FOJ,PSVNBL ..................................................................... 160


 ÿOTBOMBSBWF5BCJBUB,BSā‘.FSIBNFU......................................................... 165
,0/6)&3,&4ÿ/ÿ:ÿ-ÿýÿ/ÿÿ45&.&,...................................................... 171
 )FSLFTJOÿZJMJþJOJÿTUJZPSVN ..................................................................... 172
 )BTFU½ODF#BOB;BSBS7FSJS ..................................................................... 178
 )BTFUUFO,VSUVMNBL.àNLàO .................................................................. 183
 (‘QUBWF)BTFU .......................................................................................... 186
 ,FOEJNEFLJ(à[FMMJLMFS ............................................................................ 194
,0/61":-"Ā."7&:"3%*.-"Ā." ....................................................... 201
 1BZMBāNBWF:BSE‘NMBāNB ......................................................................... 202
 1BZMBāNBO‘O.VUMVMVþV ............................................................................ 209
 1BZMBāBSBL±PþBMNBL ................................................................................ 219
 1BZMBāNBWF:BSE‘NMBāNB#JSMJLWF#FSBCFSMJþJ4BþMBS................................ 225
 ;FLÉUWF4BEBLB.BM‘"SU‘S‘S...................................................................... 235
 1BZMBāNBZB%BJS½[FM;BNBOMBS#BZSBNMBSWF.àCBSFL(FDFMFS .............. 240
,0/6ÿ-&5ÿĀÿ.7&ÿ-&5ÿĀÿ.&/(&--&3ÿ:-&#"Ā&5.& ....................... 245
 4FMBNMBāNBO‘O½OFNJ .............................................................................. 246
 5BUM‘%JM(àMFS:à[ .................................................................................... 251
 1FZHBNCFSJNJ[JO#FEFO%JMJ ..................................................................... 257
 0MVNTV[%VZHVMBSMB#Bā&UNF ................................................................. 260
 ½GLFNJ:FOFCJMJSJN .................................................................................. 267
 #BāLBMBS‘OB4BZH‘ ...................................................................................... 275
 (ÚSHà,VSBMMBS‘......................................................................................... 281
,0/6#"5*-ÿ/"/±-"3 ........................................................................... 285
 .FUBm[JL7BSM‘LMBS .................................................................................... 286
 #BU‘MÿOBOÎMBS ............................................................................................ 291
 #BU‘MÿOBOÎMBS‘#JMJZPSVN ........................................................................... 295
,0/6%6" ................................................................................................ 303
 %VB ÿCBEFUJO½[àEàS .............................................................................. 305
 /BT‘M%VB&EFMJN .................................................................................... 307
 5àLFONF[(àÎ,BZOBþ‘%VB ................................................................... 311

4
ÿ±ÿ/%&,ÿ-&3

,0/67"5"/WF#":3",4&7(ÿ4ÿ ........................................................... 317


 7BUBO4FWHJTJ ............................................................................................. 318
 7BUBO‘N‘±PL4FWJZPSVN .......................................................................... 322
 #BZSBþ‘N‘[WFÿTUJLMBM.BSā‘ ...................................................................... 324
 7BUBOÿÎJO$BO‘O‘0SUBZB,PZBOMBSiĀFIJUMFSWF(B[JMFSw ........................... 331

&,-&3
&,404:"-)ÿ;.&5,636.-"3*/%"%ÿ/)ÿ;.&5ÿÿ±ÿ/:"Ā
(361-"3*/"(½3&)";*3-"/.*Ā.Ã'3&%"5½3/&ýÿ .................... 339

5
11
,6-)",,*

,VMIBLL‘LBWSBN‘O‘OBOMBN‘O‘CJMJS
,VMIBLL‘OBOJÎJOSJBZFUFUNFTJHFSFLUJþJOJCJMJS
)BLMBS‘O‘OWFT‘O‘SMBS‘O‘OGBSL‘OEBPMVS
,VMIBLL‘OBOBT‘MVZHVOEBWSBOBDBþ‘O‘CJMJS
#BāLBMBS‘O‘OIBLMBS‘OBTBZH‘HÚTUFSNFZFJTUFLMJPMVS
KUL HAKKI

,6-)",,*/"3ÿ":&5
,B[BO‘N
,VMIBLL‘LBWSBN‘O‘OBOMBN‘O‘CJMJS
,VMIBLL‘OBOJÎJOSJBZFUFUNFTJHFSFLUJþJOJCJMJS
)BLMBS‘O‘OWFT‘O‘SMBS‘O‘OGBSL‘OEBPMVS

½þSFUJDJ/PUV
,VUTBMLJUBC‘N‘[,VSBO‘,FSJNJOLVMIBLL‘à[FSJOEFÚOFNMFEVSEVþV "MMBI‘OFNJS
WFZBTBLMBS‘O‘OOFSFEFZTFEÚSUUFàÎàOàOLVMIBLL‘JMFJMHJMJPMEVþVBOMBU‘M‘S#VTFCFQMF "M-
MBIBLVMMVþVO CFMMJJCBEFUMFSJZFSJOFHFUJSNFOJOZBO‘OEB JOTBOIBLMBS‘OBTBZH‘EVZNBZ‘EB
HFSFLUJSEJþJJGBEFFEJMJS"LTJUBLEJSEFJOTBOMBS‘OCJSBSBEBLBSEFāÎFZBāBNBMBS‘O‘O EFWMFUMFS
LVSNBMBS‘O‘ONàNLàOPMBNBE‘þ‘WVSHVMBO‘S5PQMVNVOLBZOBāNBT‘ LÚUàMàLMFSEFOV[BL 
LBSEFāÎF ZBāBZ‘ā‘O TBþMBONBT‘ JÎJO LVM IBLMBS‘OB TBZH‘M‘ PMNBO‘O ÚOFNJ BOMBU‘M‘S "MMBI‘O
DD  IFS UàSMà HàOBI‘ BGGFUUJþJ IÉMEF  LVM IBLL‘O‘ BGGFUNFEJþJ WVSHVMBO‘S ÿIBOFU FUNFL 
VUBOE‘SNBL LàÎàNTFNFL NBMBWFDBOB[BSBSWFSNFL BM‘āWFSJāUFBMEBUNBL EBSH‘OEVS-
NBL JGUJSBFUNFL BSLBT‘OEBOLPOVāNBL MBGUBā‘NBL EFEJLPEVZBQNBL BOBSāJΑLBSNBL 
EJOÔWFNJMMÔEFþFSMFSFTBZH‘T‘[EBWSBONBLHJCJEBWSBO‘āMBS‘OLVMIBLL‘O‘[FEFMFZFOEBWSB-
O‘āMBSPMEVþVBΑLMBO‘S

:ÚOUFNWF5FLOJLMFS
"OMBU‘N

.BUFSZBM
±BM‘āNBLÉþ‘E‘ GPUPLPQJJMFÎPþBMU‘MN‘ā

&ULJOMJL
ZBā
½þSFUJDJUBSBG‘OEBOBOMBU‘NZÚOUFNJJMFALVMIBLL‘O‘OUBO‘N‘WFALVMIBLL‘ZMBJMHJMJÚS-
OFLMFSWFSJMFDFLUJS½þSFUJDJ ÎPDVLTBZ‘T‘ODBÎPþBMUU‘þ‘ÎBM‘āNBLÉþ‘E‘O‘EBþ‘U‘SWFCFMJSMJCJS
TàSFEFEPMEVSNBMBS‘O‘JTUFS

8
զ +(ɘ, ƻ*ǔȢ(#(
,6-)",,*/*#ÿ-ÿ:036.

""āBþ‘EBÎFāJUMJEBWSBO‘āMBSWFSJMNJāUJSi,VMIBLL‘wLBQTBN‘OBHJSFOEBWSBO‘āMBS‘
CVMVQ ÚSOFLUFLJHJCJZVWBSMBLJÎJOFBM‘O‘[

1BSL EVSBL IBTUBOFHJCJZFSMFSF[BSBSWFSNFL %FEJLPEVWFH‘ZCFUZBQNBL

)BDDBHJUNFNFL    )BWBZ‘ TVZV UPQSBþ‘LJSMFUNFL

#JSJOFPOVSL‘S‘D‘TÚ[MFSTÚZMFNFL   4BΑO‘UBSBNBNBL

:FNFLUFOTPOSBFMJOJZ‘LBNBNBL   )‘ST‘[M‘LZBQNBL

# :VLBS‘EB ZVWBSMBL JÎJOF BME‘þ‘O‘[ EBWSBO‘āMBS‘ ÚSOFLUF WFSJMEJþJ HJCJ BāBþ‘EBLJ
CPāMVLMBSB ZB[‘O‘[ %FWBN‘OEB JTF P EBWSBO‘ā‘O OFEFO LVM IBLL‘OB TFCFQ PMEVþVOV
BΑLMBZ‘O‘[
)BWBZ‘ TVZV UPQSBþ‘LJSMFUNFLLVMIBLL‘E‘S±àOLàIBWB TV UPQSBLCàUàOJOTBOMB-
S‘OPSUBLMBāBLVMMBONBT‘JÎJO"MMBI‘OWFSEJþJOJNFUMFSEFOEJS#J[FþFSCVOMBS‘HFSFLTJ[ZFSF
LJSMFUJSTFL JOTBOMBSCVOMBSEBOZFUFSJODFGBZEBMBOBNB[MBS,JSMJUPQSBL TV IBWBÎFāJUMJIBTUB-
M‘LMBSBTFCFQPMBCJMJS&þFSCJ[JNLJSMFUNFNJ[EFOEPMBZ‘CBāLBCJSJOTBO[BSBSHÚSàSTF POVO
IBLL‘OBHJSNJāPMVSV[
 yyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyLVMIBLL‘E‘S
±àOLà
........................................................................................................................................
 yyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyLVMIBLL‘E‘S
±àOLà
........................................................................................................................................
 yyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyLVMIBLL‘E‘S
±àOLà
........................................................................................................................................
 yyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyLVMIBLL‘E‘S
±àOLà
........................................................................................................................................

9
KUL HAKKI

%FþFSMFOEJSNF4PSVMBS‘
,VMIBLL‘OBSJBZFUFUNFLLJāJZFOFMFSLB[BOE‘S‘S
i,VMIBLL‘wJGBEFTJOEFOOFBOM‘ZPSTVOV[

(àOàO.FTBK‘
i"SBO‘[EBCJSCJSJOJ[JONBMMBS‘O‘IBLT‘[ZFSF
ZFNFZJOÿOTBOMBS‘ONBMMBS‘OEBOCJSL‘TN‘O‘CJMF
CJMFHàOBIBHJSFSFLZFNFLJÎJO POMBS‘IÉLJNMFSF
SàāWFUPMBSBL WFSNFZJOw
#BLBSB 

,BQBO‘ā
(SVQàZFMFSJOFQBZMBā‘NMBS‘JÎJOUFāFLLàSFEJO
)FSLFTJOBLM‘OEBLBMBONFTBK‘QBZMBāNBT‘O‘JTUFZJO
,POVZMBJMHJMJWBSTBTPSVMBS‘O‘BM‘OWFDFWBQMBZ‘O
#JSTPOSBLJLPOVOVOCBāM‘þ‘O‘WFSJOWFWFEBMBā‘O

10
KUL HAKKI

½þSFUJDJ/PUV
)FS IBLL‘O  CJSUBL‘N TPSVNMVMVLMBS‘ EB CFSBCFSJOEF HFUJSEJþJ  EPMBZ‘T‘ZMB IFS JOTBO‘O
à[FSJOEFCJSÎPLIBLWFTPSVNMVMVLCVMVOEVþVJ[BIFEJMJSÿOTBO‘Oà[FSJOEFLJCVIBLMBS "M-
MBI‘OIBLMBS‘WFZBSBU‘MN‘āMBS‘OIBLMBS‘EJZFJLJL‘T‘NEBÚ[FUMFOJS"MMBI‘Oà[FSJNJ[EFLJIBL-
MBS‘O‘O 0OVOWBSM‘þ‘OBWFCJSMJþJOFJOBONBL IJÎCJSāFZJPSUBLLPāNBEBO0OBJCBEFUFEJQ
FNJSMFSJOJUVUNBLWFZBTBLMBS‘OEBOTBL‘ONBLPMEVþVCFMJSUJMJS,VMIBLL‘O‘O IBZBUUBEBIB
ÎPLJOTBOMBS‘ODBOMBS‘ CFEFOMFSJ ‘S[WFOBNVTMBS‘ NBOFWÔāBITJZFUMFSJ NBLBNWFNFWLJMFSJ 
EJOÔJOBOÎWFZBāBZ‘āMBS‘HJCJLPOVMBSEBLJLJāJMJLIBLMBS‘ZMB NBMMBS‘OBWFBJMFGFSUMFSJOFJMJāLJO
IBLMBSEBOPMVāUVþVBOMBU‘M‘S#VOMBSBZÚOFMJLPMBSBLZBQ‘MBOLÚUàMàLMFSJO WFSJMFO[BSBSMBS‘O
LVMIBLL‘LBQTBN‘OBHJSEJþJJGBEFFEJMJS

:ÚOUFNWF5FLOJLMFS
&þJUTFM0ZVO 1SPKF±BM‘āNBT‘

.BUFSZBM
3FOLMJ"LÉþ‘UMBS LàÎàLLBSUMBS

&ULJOMJL
ZBā
"āBþ‘EBÚSOFLPMBSBLWFSJMFOāFLJMFTBTBM‘OBSBL ÚþSFUJDJUBSBG‘OEBOÚODFEFO"FCBE‘OEB
ÎJGUZÚOMàIB[‘SMBOBOLBSUMBS TBL‘[ZBQ‘āU‘S‘D‘ QBUBmY ZBIVUÎJGUUBSBn‘CBOUJMFUBIUBZBZBQ‘ā-
U‘S‘M‘S,BSUMBS‘OCJSZà[àOEFAZBMBO JGUJSB H‘ZCFU I‘ST‘[M‘L IJMF BMBZFUNFL LàÎàLHÚSNFL 
Ú[FM IBZBU‘ BSBāU‘SNBL  CBāLBT‘O‘O T‘SS‘O‘ JGāB FUNFL  ZBSBMBNBL  TÚ[àOEF EVSNBNBL HJCJ
LVMIBLL‘OBTFCFQPMBOmJMMFSWBSE‘S,BSUMBS‘OBSLBZà[àOEFCVLBWSBNMBS‘OCJSJLJDàNMFMJL
L‘TBJ[BI‘WBSE‘S
5BIUBZBHFMFOÎPDVLCJSLBWSBNTFÎFSWFCVLBWSBN‘JMLPLVEVþVOEBEàāàOEàþàāFZMFSJ
L‘TBDBBOMBU‘S4‘O‘GUBOFLMFNFZBQNBLJTUFZFOCBāLBÎPDVLMBSWBSTBPOMBSEBTÚ[BM‘S4PO-
SBT‘OEBIFQCFSBCFSLBSU‘OBSLBZà[àOàÎFWJSJQLBWSBN‘OUBO‘N‘O‘TFTMJCJSāFLJMEFPLVSMBS
#VāFLJMEFUàNLBWSBNMBSà[FSJOFLPOVāVMVSWFÚþSFUJDJUBIUBEBLJUàNLBSUMBS‘ZFOJEFO
ÎFWJSJQT‘O‘GBTPSBS
iĀJNEJLBSUMBS‘N‘[‘EJLLBUMJDFJODFMFZFMJN
4J[DFCVLBSUMBSEBLJPSUBLÚ[FMMJLOFEJS
#VEBWSBO‘āMBSLJNF[BSBSWFSJS
#BāLBMBS‘OBTBZH‘EVZBOCJSJCVEBWSBO‘āMBS‘ZBQBCJMJSNJ
#VEBWSBO‘āMBS‘OZBZH‘OPMEVþVCJSUPQMVNEBJOTBOMBSBSBT‘OEBLJJMJāLJMFSOBT‘MPMVS w

11
KUL HAKKI

4PSVMBSEB BNBÎ ÚþSFUJDJOJO LVM IBLL‘ LBWSBN‘O‘ LVMMBONBEBO ÎPDVLMBSB CV LBWSBN‘
CVMEVSNBT‘ ÎPDVLMBS‘OEFSTJOLPOVTVOVCVZÚOUFNMFCVMNBMBS‘E‘SÿIUJZBDBHÚSFTPSVMBS
EFþJāUJSJMFCJMJS ZBIVU FLMFNFMFS ZBQ‘MBCJMJS  #V TPSVMBS TPSVMVSLFO T‘O‘G‘O EVSVNVOB HÚSF
ÎPDVLMBSHSVCBBZS‘MBCJMJS HSVQPMBSBLEàāàONFMFSJWFEFSTJOLPOVTVOVCFSBCFSCVMNBMBS‘
EBJTUFOFCJMJS
%FSTJO LPOVTV HFSFLUJþJOEF ÚþSFUJDJOJO EF ZBSE‘N‘ JMF CVMVOEVþVOEB UBIUBEBLJ UàN
LBSUMBSJOEJSJMJQUBIUBZBCàZàLIBSnFSMFLVMIBLL‘ZB[‘M‘S

&,

(FSÎFþF
:"-"/ VZNBZBO 
EPþSV
PMNBZBOTÚ[

,BSUMBS‘OCJSZà[àOEFZBMBO JGUJSB H‘ZCFU I‘ST‘[M‘L IJMF BMBZFUNFL LàÎàLHÚSNFL Ú[FM


IBZBU‘BSBāU‘SNBL CBāLBT‘O‘OT‘SS‘O‘JGāBFUNFL ZBSBMBNBL TÚ[àOEFEVSNBNBLHJCJLVMIBL-
L‘OBTFCFQPMBOmJMMFSWBSE‘S,BSUMBS‘OBSLBZà[àOEFCVLBWSBNMBS‘OL‘TBDBCJSJLJDàNMFMJL
J[BI‘WBSE‘S

12
KUL HAKKI

%FþFSMFOEJSNF4PSVMBS‘
,VMIBLL‘OFEJS
)BOHJEBWSBO‘āMBSLVMIBLL‘OBHJSFS
,VMIBLL‘OBSJBZFUFUNFOJOGBZEBMBS‘OFMFSEJS

(àOàO.FTBK‘
i.àTMàNBO FMJOEFOWFEJMJOEFOCBāLBMBS‘O‘O
[BSBSHÚSNFEJþJLJNTFEJSw
#VIÉSÔ ÿNBO 

,BQBO‘ā
(SVQàZFMFSJOFQBZMBā‘NMBS‘JÎJOUFāFLLàSFEJO
)FSLFTJOBLM‘OEBLBMBONFTBK‘QBZMBāNBT‘O‘JTUFZJO
,POVZMBJMHJMJWBSTBTPSVMBS‘O‘BM‘OWFDFWBQMBZ‘O
#JSTPOSBLJLPOVOVOCBāM‘þ‘O‘WFSJOWFWFEBMBā‘O

13
KUL HAKKI

½þSFUJDJ/PUV
)BLL‘O‘CJMNFZFOJOLPMBZM‘LMBCBāLBMBS‘O‘OIBLMBS‘O‘JIMBMFEFDFþJWVSHVMBOBSBLT‘O‘SMBS
WFTPSVNMVMVLMBS BZFUWFIBEJTMFSMFEFEFTUFLMFOFSFLÎPDVLMBSBBāBþ‘EBLJFULJOMJLMFLBWSB-
U‘MNBZBÎBM‘ā‘M‘S

:ÚOUFNWF5FLOJLMFS
&þJUTFM0ZVOÿÎFSJTJOEF,FāGFUNF:PMVZMB½þSFUJN

.BUFSZBM
±PDVLTBZ‘T‘ODB"LÉþ‘E‘ JTJNQVBOÎJ[FMHFTJ LVUV

&ULJOMJL
ZBā
±PDVLMBSBCJSCJSFZPMBSBLIBOHJIBLMBSBTBIJQPMEVþVNV[VEàāàONFMFSJWFiIBLwPMBSBL
EàāàOEàLMFSJāFZMFSJEBþ‘U‘MBOLÉþ‘UMBSBCJSB[EBOZB[BDBLMBS‘TÚZMFOJS ½SOFLIBLMBSMJTUFTJ
&LPMBSBLWFSJMNJāUJS )FSLFTJOJTNJOJOZB[‘ME‘þ‘CJSÎJ[FMHFIB[‘SMBO‘SWFZBGPUPLPQJÎFLJ-
MFSFLIB[‘SCVMVOEVSVMVS &L ±PDVLMBSBLÉþ‘UMBSEBþ‘U‘M‘SWFPOMBSEBOLÉþ‘UMBS‘ÚODFV[VO
LFOBS‘OEBOJLJZFLBUMBZBSBLZ‘SUNBMBS‘JTUFOJS4POSBUFLSBSJLJZFLBUMBZBSBLZ‘SUNBMBS‘JTUFOJS
#VTàSFÎCJS"LÉþ‘E‘OEBOQBSÎBLàÎàLLÉþ‘UPMVāUVSVMBOBLBEBSEFWBNFEFS)FSÎP-
DVþVOFāJUQBSÎBLÉþ‘E‘PMBDBLU‘S±PDVLMBSEàāàOEàLMFSJIFSIBLL‘CVLàÎàLQBSÎBMBSB
ZB[‘QLVUVZBBUBDBLMBSE‘S
/PU½þSFUJDJUBSBG‘OEBOUVUVMBOLVUVZBÎPDVLMBS‘OIFSBUU‘þ‘LÉþ‘UJÎJOQVBOWFSJMFDF-
þJ IBLMBS‘ZB[E‘LMBS‘LÉþ‘UMBS‘Oà[FSJOFJTJNMFSJOJZB[NBNBMBS‘ CJSCJSMFSJOEFOCBLNBNBMBS‘
HFSFLUJþJEVZVSVMVS
5VS
±PDVLMBSBEBLJLBM‘LTFSCFTUEàāàONFWFZB[NBWBLUJWFSJMJS4àSFTPOBFSEJþJOEFZB[NB
JāMFNJTPOBFSEJSJMJS½þSFUJDJ ÎPDVLMBSLÉþ‘UBUU‘LÎBJTJNMFSJOJOLBSā‘T‘OBQVBO‘UFNTJMFO
ÎFOUJLBUBS
5VS
"SE‘OEBOLVUVEBOÎPDVLMBS‘OZB[E‘þ‘IBLMBSEBOUFLFSUFLFSÎFLFSWFT‘SBZMBÎPDVLMBSB
i#VIBLN‘E‘S wāFLMJOEFTPSVZÚOFMUJS)BLPMVQPMNBE‘þ‘O‘EPþSVCJSāFLJMEFDFWBQMBZBO
IFSÎPDVþVOJTNJOJOLBSā‘T‘OBQVBO‘UFNTJMFOÎFOUJLBUNBZBEFWBNFEFS
#ÚZMFMJLMFÎPDVLMBS‘OBZO‘WFZBZBOM‘āZB[E‘þ‘ IBLPMBSBLEàāàOEàþàBODBLIBLPMNBZBO
LÉþ‘UMBSE‘āBSEBC‘SBL‘M‘SLFOIBLPMBOLÉþ‘UMBSUFLSBSEBOLVUVZBBU‘M‘S#ÚZMFMJLMFIBLPMNB-
ZBOMBSFMFONJāPMVS

14
KUL HAKKI

5VS
)BLPMBOEBWSBO‘āMBSUFLSBSÎFLJMNFZFCBāMBO‘S#VTFGFSEFÎPDVLMBSBi#VIBLL‘OT‘O‘S‘
OFEJS wāFLMJOEFTPSVZÚOFMUJMJS±PDVLMBST‘SBZMBTPSVOVOEPþSVDFWBC‘O‘UBNBNMBNBZBÎB-
M‘ā‘S4PSVJMLT‘SBEBLJÎPDVLUBOCBāMBZBSBLTPSVMVS±PDVþBDFWBC‘O‘WFSNFTJJÎJOTBOJZF
TàSFWFSJMJSÿMLT‘SBEBLJÎPDVLTPSVOVODFWBC‘O‘CJMFNF[TFJLJODJT‘SBEBLJÎPDVþBTÚ[IBLL‘
HFÎFSÿLJODJT‘SBEBLJCJMFNF[TFàÎàODàZFāFLMJOEFEFWBNFEFS4PSVZVLJNCJMJSTFPOEBO
TPOSBLJÎPDVLJÎJOZFOJCJSLÉþ‘UÎFLJMJSWFPLÉþ‘UUBLJIBLL‘OT‘O‘S‘OFEJSāFLMJOEFEFWBN
FUUJSJMJS
0ZVOVOTPOVOEBÎPDVLMBS‘OBME‘þ‘ÎFOUJLMFSTBZ‘M‘SWFCBāBS‘M‘ÎPDVLÚEàMMFOEJSJMJS
"āBþ‘EBLJTBZGBEBÚSOFLIBLMBSFLPMBSBL &L WFSJMNJāUJS

15
KUL HAKKI

&,

)",-"3*. 4*/*3-"3*.
%àāàODFTJOJÎFLJONFEFOTÚZMFZFCJMNF )BLBSFUFUNFNFL BIMBLJMLFMFSJOFVZNBL EPþSV
PMNBT‘OBEJLLBUFUNFL JGUJSBEBOTBL‘ONBL TBZH‘Z‘
LPSVNBL

,JāJTFMCJMHJMFSJOHJ[MJMJþJOJOTBþMBONBT‘

)BLT‘[M‘þBVþSBE‘þ‘O‘EàāàOEàþàOEF
IBLL‘O‘BSBNB

0LVMCBIÎFTJOEFPZVOPZOBNB

&āJUJNLÉOMBSEBOGBZEBMBONB

½[FMFāZBMBS‘O‘LPSVNB

ÿOUFSOFUJNLÉOMBS‘OEBOGBZEBMBONB

%FWMFULVSVNMBS‘OEBOJTUJGBEFFUNF

4‘O‘GCBāLBOM‘þ‘OBBEBZPMNB

4BþM‘LIJ[NFUMFSJOEFOZBSBSMBONB

,àUàQIBOFEFOLBZ‘UZBQU‘SBSBLLJUBQBMNB
WFPLVNB

:BāBNBL

7BUBOEBāM‘þBTBIJQPMNB

±PDVLMBS‘OPLVMBHJUNF PZVOPZOBNB

4BZH‘EVZVMNBL

16
KUL HAKKI

&,
563%&ý&3-&/%ÿ3.&-&3ÿ
0:6/$6/6/"%*40:"%*
563 563 563 16"/

17
KUL HAKKI

%FþFSMFOEJSNF4PSVMBS‘
ÿOTBOPMNBLUBOLBZOBLMBOBOFOUFNFMIBLMBS‘N‘[OFMFSEJS
)BLMBS‘N‘[‘OT‘O‘SMBS‘O‘CJSDàNMFJMFOBT‘MJGBEFFEFCJMJSJ[

(àOàO.FTBK‘
3FTßMJ&LSFN i.àTMàNBO .àTMàNBO‘O
LBSEFāJEJS POBIBJOMJLZBQNB[ POBZBMBO
TÚZMFNF[ POVZà[àTUàC‘SBLNB[.àTMàNBO‘O
‘S[‘ NBM‘WFLBO‘TBZH‘OE‘S POBEPLVOVMBNB[
5BLWB  "MMBIBLBSā‘TPSVNMVMVLCJMJODJ JāUF
āVSBEBE‘S LBMQUFEJS .àTMàNBO‘O .àTMàNBO
LBSEFāJOJLàÎàLHÚSNFTJ LÚUàMàLPMBSBLPOB
ZFUFSwCVZVSNVāUVS
5JSNJ[Ô #JSS 

,BQBO‘ā
(SVQàZFMFSJOFQBZMBā‘NMBS‘JÎJOUFāFLLàSFEJO
)FSLFTJOBLM‘OEBLBMBONFTBK‘QBZMBāNBT‘O‘JTUFZJO
,POVZMBJMHJMJWBSTBTPSVMBS‘O‘BM‘OWFDFWBQMBZ‘O
#JSTPOSBLJLPOVOVOCBāM‘þ‘O‘WFSJOWFWFEBMBā‘O

18
KUL HAKKI

½þSFUJDJ/PUV
,VM IBLL‘O‘O JOTBOMBS‘O CJSCJSMFSJZMF JMJāLJMFSJOEFO NFZEBOB HFMFO IBL JIMBMMFSJOJ JGBEF
FUUJþJBΑLMBO‘S#VIBLMBSEBOCBITFEJMJSLFOPOMBS‘O JOTBO‘ODBO‘ CFEFOJ OBNVTV POVSV 
JOBOÎWFZBāBZ‘ā‘HJCJLPOVMBSEBLJLJāJTFMIBLMBS‘ZMB LJāJTFMFāZBMBS‘OBWFBJMFGFSUMFSJOFJMJāLJO
IBLMBSEBOPMVāUVþVJGBEFFEJMJS,VMIBLMBS‘O‘OLBQTBN‘O‘OÎPLHFOJāPMEVþVWFSJMFOHÚSFW
WFTPSVNMVMVLMBS‘O Fā EPTU BLSBCBM‘LWFLPNāVMVLJMJāLJMFSJOJOCVLPOVEBÎPLIBTTBTBMBO-
MBSPMEVþVWVSHVMBO‘S
ÿOTBOMBS‘OLJāJMJLIBLMBS‘OBTBME‘SNBO‘O POMBS‘LàÎàNTFNFOJO WFSJMFOTÚ[MFSFWFEPTU-
MVLMBSBCBþM‘LBMNBNBO‘O ÚMÎàZFWFUBSU‘ZBÚ[FOHÚTUFSNFNFOJO BEBMFUMJEBWSBONBNBO‘O 
ZBMBO TÚZMFNFOJO  SBIBUT‘[ FEJDJ CJÎJNEF ZàLTFL TFTMF LPOVāNBO‘O  ÎFWSFZJ LJSMFUNFOJO 
H‘ZCFUWFEFEJLPEVFUNFOJO USBmLUFLVSBMJIMBMJZBQNBO‘O LVMIBLL‘OBHJSEJþJJGBEFFEJMJS

:ÚOUFNWF5FLOJLMFS
&þJUTFM0ZVO

.BUFSZBM
,POVLBSUMBS‘ CBTL‘BM‘ON‘āPMNBM‘ CJSBEFUTPNVO TPNVOà[FSJOFZBQ‘āU‘S‘MBDBL
OVNBSBMBS LBMFN PZVOÎJ[FMHFTJ CBTL‘BM‘ON‘ā "WFZBLBSFMJLÉþ‘U
ÎPDVLTBZ‘T‘ODBÎPþBMU‘MN‘ā

&ULJOMJL
ZBā
½ODFTPNVOVOà[FSJOFOVNBSBMBSZBQ‘āU‘S‘M‘S,POVMBSOVNBSBMBOE‘S‘M‘S 4PNVOCVMV-
OBNB[TBT‘SBZMBEBJāMFOFCJMJS4‘SBZMBJāMFOFDFLTF ÎPDVLMBS‘OT‘SBEBLJLPOVIBLL‘OEBCJMHJ
TBIJCJPMNBNBT‘ÚOFNMJEJS
±PDVLMBSBPZVOÎJ[FMHFMFSJEBþ‘U‘M‘S,POVCBāM‘LMBS‘ #VFULJOMJþJOLPOVMBS‘ÎPDVLMBSMB
CJSMJLUFEFCFMJSMFOFCJMJS IBMJOEFWFSJMFONFLÉOMBSJMFJMHJMJiJTJNāFIJSCJULJwPZVOVHJCJLVM
IBLL‘PMVāUVSBDBLÚSOFLMFSWFSNFFULJOMJþJZBQ‘MBDBLU‘S
0ZVOBCBāMBNBEBOÚODFPZVOVOLVSBMMBS‘CFMJSMFOJS
)FSUVSJÎJOHSVQÎBTàSFCFMJSMFOFCJMFDFþJHJCJ SFLBCFUJBSU‘S‘D‘JMLCJUJSFOJOCJUJSEJLUFO
TPOSBEBOHFSJZFEPþSVTBZNBT‘WFT‘G‘SEBLBMFNMFSJOC‘SBL‘MNBT‘āFLMJOEFEFCFMJSMFOFCJ-
MJS4àSFT‘O‘SM‘PZOBO‘ZPSTB ÚþSFUJDJ[BNBOMBZ‘D‘WFZBLVNTBBUJLVMMBOBCJMJS4àSFCJUJNJOEF
[JMÎBMBCJMJS
0ZVOBCBāM‘ZPSV[LPNVUVZMBPZVOCBāMBU‘M‘S,BMFNFHFÎJSJMFOTPNVO T‘SBZMBÎPDVLMBS
UBSBG‘OEBOÎFWSJMJSÿMLÎPDVþVOÎFWJSNFTJTPOSBT‘IBOHJOVNBSBàTUFHFMEJZTFPOVNBSBEBLJ

19
KUL HAKKI

LPOVCJSJODJLPOVPMBSBLCFMJSMFOJS4‘SBEBLJÎPDVLÎFWJSJS(FMFOOVNBSBZBLBSā‘M‘LHFMFO
LPOVJLJODJLPOVPMBSBLCFMJSMFOJS#VāFLJMEFEÚSULPOVCFMJSMFOJS
"ZO‘BOMBNBHFMFOÚSOFþJWFSFOÎPDVLMBSBQVBOWFSJMJS'BSLM‘ÚSOFLMFSWFSFOÎPDVLMBS
JTFQVBOBM‘S
4PNVOÎFWJSNFEFBZO‘LPOVUFLSBSHFMEJZTFUFLSBSZB[‘MBCJMFDFþJHJCJBUMBOBCJMJSEF
"MUFSOBUJGFULJOMJLÚOFSJTJ
,POVZMBJMHJMJÎJ[FMHFMJPZVOZFSJOFBIāBQCMPLJMFEFOHFPZVOVEB KFOHBHJCJ PZOBU‘MB-
CJMJS0ZVOPZOBO‘SLFOIFSLFTT‘SBEBLJLPOVZMBJMHJMJÚSOFLTÚZMFSWFCJSUBIUBBM‘S4‘SBEBLJ
ÎPDVL T‘SBEBLJLPOVZMBJMHJMJÚSOFLCVMVSPEBCJSUBIUBBM‘S,JNBM‘SLFOZ‘L‘ME‘ZTBPFMFONJā
PMVS

20
KUL HAKKI

&,
5VSMBS 4àSF ,POV ,POV ,POV ,POV 1VBO

 0LVMEB "M‘āWFSJāUF 5SBmLUF &WEF


½SOFL ,PQZB ,VTVSMVNBM‘ %PMNVāT‘SBT‘OEB (FÎWBLJUUF
TO T‘SBZ‘CP[VQÚOF
ÎFLNFL TBUNBL HFÎNFL HàSàMUàZBQNBL

 )BTUBOFEF ,àUàQIBOFEF 4PLBLUB JOUFSOFUUF


½SOFL TO 5BO‘āCJSJOJCVMVQ 4FTMJCJSāFLJMEF :FSFUàLàSNFL #JSLJāJIBLL‘OEB
ÚOFHFÎNFL HàMNFL ZBMBOIBCFSZBZNBL

5VS

5VS

5VS

5VS

5VS

5VS

5VS

5VS

5VS

5VS

5VS

5VS

5VS

5VS

5VS

5PQMBN1VBO

21
KUL HAKKI

&,

1 &7%&  0,6-%"

 1";"3%"  )"45"/&%&

5 40,",5" 6 1"3,5"

1 1ÿ,/ÿ,5&  "-*Ā7&3ÿĀ5&

 ,Ã5Ã1)"/&%&  53"'ÿ,5&

4103 ÿ/5&3/&5
5 6
'""-ÿ:&5ÿ/%& 035".*/%"

22
KUL HAKKI

%FþFSMFOEJSNF4PSVMBS‘
)BOHJTÚ[WFEBWSBO‘āMBSLVMIBLL‘OBHJSNFLUFEJS
,VMIBLL‘O‘JIMBMFUNFNJ[FOFEFOPMBOBT‘MVOTVSMBSOFMFSPMBCJMJS

(àOàO.FTBK‘
i"MMBI‘N'BLJSMJLUFOTBOBT‘þ‘O‘S‘N%BSM‘L
WF[JMMFUUFOTBOBT‘þ‘O‘S‘N;VMNFUNFLUFOWF
[VMNFVþSBNBLUBOEBTBOBT‘þ‘O‘S‘Nw
#VIÉSÔ FM&EFCàMNàGSFE 

,BQBO‘ā
(SVQàZFMFSJOFQBZMBā‘NMBS‘JÎJOUFāFLLàSFEJO
)FSLFTJOBLM‘OEBLBMBONFTBK‘QBZMBāNBT‘O‘JTUFZJO
,POVZMBJMHJMJWBSTBTPSVMBS‘O‘BM‘OWFDFWBQMBZ‘O
#JSTPOSBLJLPOVOVOCBāM‘þ‘O‘WFSJOWFWFEBMBā‘O

23
KUL HAKKI

,6-)",,*/"4":(*-*:*.
,B[BO‘N
,VMIBLL‘OBOBT‘MVZHVOEBWSBOBDBþ‘O‘JGBEFFEFS
#BāLBMBS‘O‘OIBLMBS‘OBTBZH‘HÚTUFSNFZFJTUFLMJPMVS

½þSFUJDJ/PUV
#VFULJOMJLUFÎPDVLMBSBCPāLÉþ‘UMBSEBþ‘U‘M‘S½þSFUJDJBāBþ‘EBLJTFOBSZPMBS‘PSBEBLJÎP-
DVLMBS‘OBE‘OBVZBSMBZBSBLTFTMFOEJSFCJMJS

:ÚOUFNWF5FLOJLMFS
½SOFL0MBZÿODFMFNFTJ

.BUFSZBM
±PDVLTBZ‘T‘ODB"

&ULJOMJL
ZBā
4FOBSZP
4FOB ÚþSFUNFO[JMJOFZBL‘OTVBMNBZ‘VOVUUVþVOVGBSLFEFSWFLPāBSBLNFSEJWFOMFSFZÚ-
OFMJS.FSEJWFOMFSEFOCJSFSJLJāFSBUMBZBSBLJOFS5BNLBOUJOFHJSFDFLLFOLBOUJOEFOBZSBO‘O‘
BMN‘āÎÚQàOÚOàOEFBÎNBZBÎBM‘āBOBSLBEBā‘4àNFZZFOJOLPMVOBÎBSQBSWF4àNFZZFOJO
ZBS‘NBΑMN‘āBZSBO‘à[FSJOFEFEÚLàMFSFLFMJOEFOEàāFS
i4FOBCVEVSVNEBOFZBQBS wEJZFTPSBSWFÎPDVLMBS‘OWFSEJþJDFWBQMBS‘UBIUBZB UBIUB
ZPLTBCJSLÉþ‘EB ZB[BS
i#VPMBZTFOJOCBā‘OBHFMNJāPMTBZE‘OBT‘MEBWSBO‘SE‘O wāFLMJOEFHÚOàMMàÎPDVLMBS‘O
EàāàODFMFSJOJÚþSFOJS
i"SE‘OEBOOFZBQNBM‘ wTPSVTVOVZÚOFMUJSWFFOÎPLUFSDJIFEJMFODFWBQMBS‘Z‘ME‘[MB
JāBSFUMFS

24
KUL HAKKI

4FOBSZPMBS‘WFEBWSBO‘āMBS‘ÎPDVLMBS‘OJIUJZBÎMBS‘OBWFZBHÚSàāMFSJOFHÚSFÎFāJUMFOEJSFCJ-
MJSTJOJ[ 4‘O‘GNFWDVEVLBMBCBM‘LJTFIFSCJSEBWSBO‘āUBOCJSEFOGB[MBÎPþBMUBCJMJSTJOJ[ 
)JÎCJSāFZPMNBN‘āHJCJTVBMNBLJÎJOLBTBZBZÚOFMNFMJ
4àNFZZFEFOÚ[àSEJMFNFMJ :‘ME‘[M‘ 
4àNFZZFZFi,BQ‘O‘OEJCJOEFBZSBON‘BΑM‘S wEJZFCBþ‘SNBM‘
4àNFZZFOJOà[FSJOFEÚLàMFOBZSBOBCBLBSBLHàMNFMJWFEBMHBHFÎNFMJ
*TMBLNFOEJMWFQFÎFUFBM‘Q4àNFZZFOJOL‘ZBGFUMFSJOJTJMNFMJ :‘ME‘[M‘ 
4àNFZZFZFA:BQBCJMFDFþJNCJSāFZWBSN‘ EJZFTPSNBM‘ :‘ME‘[M‘ 
4àNFZZFOJO àTUàOà UFNJ[MFNFTJOF ZBSE‘N FUNFMJ WF TPOSB 4àNFZZFZF BZSBO BMNBM‘
:‘ME‘[M‘ 
4àNFZZFZJOÚCFUÎJÚþSFUNFOFāJLÉZFUFUNFMJ
i"DFMFNWBSwEFZJQTVZVOVBM‘QT‘O‘GBΑLNBM‘
4FOB IFNFOBSLBEBā‘O‘OLPMVOEBOUVUBSBL i½[àSEJMFSJN IBUBN‘OGBSL‘OEBZ‘N CVāF-
LJMEF LBOUJOF HJSNFNFMJZEJNw EFS )FNFO LBTBZB ZÚOFMFSFL ‘TMBL NFOEJM WF QFÎFUF BM‘S
4àNFZZFOJOL‘ZBGFUJOJUFNJ[MFNFTJOFZBSE‘NFEFS4FOBIFNBSLBEBā‘O‘Oà[FSJOFT‘ÎSBZBO
BZSBOMFLFMFSJOJUFLUFLTJMNFZFÎBM‘ā‘SIFNEFUFLSBSUFLSBS4àNFZZFEFOÚ[àSEJMFNFZFEF-
WBNFEFS"SLBEBā‘O‘Oà[FSJOJUBNBNFOTJMEJLUFOTPOSBIFNFOLBTBZBZÚOFMJSWFCJSBZSBO
JMFCJSTVTBU‘OBM‘S4àNFZZFOJOZBO‘OBHFMFSFLi"SLBEBā‘N IBLL‘O‘IFMBMFU4FOJOEFEFSTF
HFÎLBMNBOBOFEFOPMEVN#VBZSBOTFOJOIBLL‘O"mZFUPMTVOwEJZFSFL4àNFZZFZFBZSB-
O‘O‘WFSJS4àNFZZFOJOEFUFāFLLàSFUNFTJZMFI‘[MBT‘O‘nBS‘OBHJEFSMFS
4FOBSZPOVOLBMBO‘EBPLVOBSBLÚSOFLEBWSBO‘āMBSJGBEFFEJMJS&ULJOMJLà[FSJOFL‘TBDB
TPICFUFEJMEJLUFOTPOSBEJþFSTFOBSZPZBHFÎJMJS

4FOBSZP
#FHàNWF#FSJMFWMFSJOJOCBIÎFTJOEFUPQPZOBSLFOUPQMBS‘CBIÎFMFSJOEFLJBþBD‘OEBM‘OB
UBL‘M‘S5PQVEàāàSNFLJÎJO#FHàNàOBLM‘OBZFSEFCVMEVLMBS‘UBIUBQBSÎBT‘O‘UPQBEPþSV
G‘SMBUNBL HFMJS ,BSEFāJ #FSJMF UBIUBO‘O EàāFSFL LFOEJTJOF [BSBS WFSFCJMFDFþJOJ TÚZMFZFSFL
POEBOHàWFOMJCJSZFSFHFÎNFTJOJJTUFS#FHàNUBIUBZ‘G‘SMBU‘S UPQEàāNF[ÿLJODJLF[G‘SMBU‘S
UPQEàāNF[#FSJM i"CMBWFSCJSEFCFOEFOFZFZJNwEFSWFUBIUBQBSÎBT‘O‘FMJOFBM‘S'‘SMBUU‘þ‘
HJCJUBIUBUPQBÎBSQBSWFTFLFSFLLPNāVMBS‘O‘ODBN‘OBEPþSVZÚOFMJS5PQEàāNàāUàSBODBL
DBNEBL‘S‘MN‘āU‘S
#FHàNWF#FSJMOFZBQNBM‘ 
)FNFOFUSBGBCBL‘O‘QLJNTFHÚSNàZPSTBLBÎNBM‘MBS
5PQMBS‘O‘BM‘QTBLMBONBM‘MBS
#FSJMTVÎV#FHàNFBUNBM‘

25
KUL HAKKI

ÿLJTJEFCJSCJSJOJTVÎMBNBM‘
#FHàN#FSJMJÚZMFDFC‘SBL‘QHJUNFMJ
,PNāVMBS‘OEBOÚ[àSEJMFNFMJ :‘ME‘[M‘ 
,PNāVMBS‘O‘ODBNQBSBT‘O‘IBSÎM‘LMBS‘ZMBÚEFNFMJMFS :‘ME‘[M‘ 
)JÎBME‘S‘āFUNFEFOPZVOMBS‘OBEFWBNFUNFMJMFS
#FSJMJOZFSJOEFTFOPMTBZE‘OOFZBQBSE‘O
i#FHàNWF#FSJMLBÎBSBLFWMFSJOFHJUTFTFOBSZPOBT‘MāFLJMMFOJS wHJCJTPSVMBSMBÎPDVLMBS‘O
iLVMIBLL‘JIMBMJwTPOVDVOBVMBāNBMBS‘TBþMBO‘S
"SE‘OEBOÚSOFLPMBZ‘OLBMBOL‘TN‘PLVOBSBLUBNBNMBO‘S
#FHàNWF#FSJM ZBāBE‘LMBS‘PMBZ‘OāPLVOVBUMBUU‘LUBOTPOSBUPQMBS‘O‘EBBMBSBLLPNāV-
MBS‘O‘O[JMJOFCBTBSMBS#JSTàSFCFLMFSMFSLBQ‘Z‘LJNTFBÎNB[5FLSBS[JMFCBTBSMBS#JSTàSF
CFLMFSMFSZJOFLBQ‘Z‘BÎBOPMNB[#JSLF[EBIB[JMFCBTBM‘NEBLJNTFBÎNB[TBFWFHJEFSJ[
EJZFEàāàOàSMFS5FLSBSCBTU‘LMBS‘OEBEBLBQ‘BΑMNB[.FSEJWFOMFSFEPþSVZÚOFMEJLMFSJOEF
LPNāVMBS‘O‘OJāUFOFWJOFHFMEJþJOJHÚSàSMFS#JSBOCJSCJSMFSJOFCBL‘O‘SMBSWF#FSJMTÚ[FCBāMBS
:BāBE‘LMBS‘PMBZ‘OāPLVOVIFOà[BUMBUBNBN‘ā LPNāVMBS‘)àTFZJOBNDBO‘OOBT‘MCJSUFQLJWF-
SFDFþJOEFOEFFNJOPMBNBEBOEVSBLMBZBEVSBLMBZBi)àTFZJOBNDB Ú[àSEJMFSJ[ CJ[CJSIBUB
ZBQU‘Lw EJZFCJMJS )àTFZJO BNDB i)BZ‘SE‘S L‘[‘N OF PMEV w EJZF TPSBS #FSJMJO LPOVāBDBL
IÉMJZPLUVSÃ[àMNàāWFLPSLNVāUVS#FHàNPMBZ‘PMEVþVHJCJBOMBU‘SWFLFOEJMFSJOJBGGFUNF-
MFSJOJJTUFS)àTFZJOBNDBEBi4J[FCJSāFZPMNBE‘ZB DBO‘O‘[TBþPMTVOL‘[MBS‘N"ZS‘DBTJ[J
UFCSJLFEFSJN HFMJQIBUBO‘[‘TÚZMFEJOJ[ Ú[àSEJMFEJOJ[y4J[TÚZMFNFTFZEJOJ[CFOLJNCJMJS
OF[BNBOHÚSFDFLUJNyÃTUFMJLLJNJOL‘SE‘þ‘O‘OFSEFOCJMFDFLUJN#FMLJEFCBāLBMBS‘OEBO
āàQIFMFOJQPOMBSBL‘[BDBLU‘NywEFS"SE‘OEBO i5BNBNIBEJTJ[āJNEJFWJOJ[FHJEJO CFO
EFCJSDBND‘ÎBþ‘S‘QUBLU‘SBZ‘Ny(FDFTPþVLPMVSwEFS#FHàNWF#FSJMi)àTFZJOBNDB CJ[J
BGGFUÿ[JOWFSJSTFOJ[CJ[IBSÎM‘LMBS‘N‘[EBOCJSJLUJSFSFLDBN‘OCFEFMJOJLBSā‘MBNBLJTUJZPSV[w
EFSMFS)àTFZJOBNDBi)BZEJL‘[‘NTJ[FWJOJ[FHJEJO CFOEàSàTUMàþàOà[EFOÚUàSàTJ[JBGGFU-
UJN)BSÎM‘LMBS‘O‘[MBLFOEJOJ[FCFOEFOHà[FMCJSIFEJZFBM‘OwEFS
#VOVOà[FSJOF#FHàNWF#FSJMCVSVLCJSNVUMVMVLMBFWMFSJOFHJEFSMFS

26
KUL HAKKI

%FþFSMFOEJSNF4PSVMBS‘
ÿOTBO‘OIJÎLVMIBLL‘JIMBMJZBQNBEBOZBāBZBCJMNFTJNàNLàONàEàS
,VMIBLL‘JIMBMFEJMJSTFPIBLUBOOBT‘MLVSUVMBCJMJSJ[
#BāLBMBS‘O‘OIBLMBS‘OBTBZH‘HÚTUFSNF[TFLOFMFSZBāBOBCJMJS

(àOàO.FTBK‘
i,JNLBSEFāJOFIBLT‘[M‘LFUNJāTF 
POVOMBIFMBMMFāTJOyw
#VIÉSÔ 3JLBL 

,BQBO‘ā
(SVQàZFMFSJOFQBZMBā‘NMBS‘JÎJOUFāFLLàSFEJO
)FSLFTJOBLM‘OEBLBMBONFTBK‘QBZMBāNBT‘O‘JTUFZJO
,POVZMBJMHJMJWBSTBTPSVMBS‘O‘BM‘OWFDFWBQMBZ‘O
#JSTPOSBLJLPOVOVOCBāM‘þ‘O‘WFSJOWFWFEBMBā‘O

27
KUL HAKKI

½þSFUJDJ/PUV
,VSBOEBCJSÎPLBZFUUFIBL BEBMFUWF[VMàNHJCJLBWSBNMBS‘OLVMIBLMBS‘ZMBJMHJMJPMBSBL
LVMMBO‘ME‘þ‘HÚSàMàS"ZS‘DBCJSÎPLBZFUUFJOTBOMBS‘OIBLMBS‘OBTBZH‘HÚTUFSJMNFTJHFSFLUJþJWF
LVMIBLL‘OBTBME‘S‘NBIJZFUJOEFLJUVUVNWFEBWSBO‘āMBS‘OZBTBLMBOE‘þ‘JGBEFFEJMJS
)[1FZHBNCFSJO TBT LVMIBLMBS‘O‘OJIMÉMJOJUFMJþJOEFLJUVUVNWFEBWSBO‘āMBS‘OZBOM‘ā-
M‘þ‘O‘ LÚUàMàþàOà EàOZBWFBIJSFUUFEPþVSBDBþ‘[BSBSMBS‘CJSÎPLIBEJTUFBOMBUU‘þ‘WFJOTBOMBS‘
CVUàSMàLVMIBLL‘JIMBMMFSJOEFOTBL‘OE‘SNBZBÎBM‘āU‘þ‘J[BIFEJMJSi.àTMàNBO .àTMàNBO‘O
LBSEFāJEJS POBIBJOMJLZBQBNB[ POBZBMBOTÚZMFNF[ POVZà[àTUàC‘SBLNB[.àTMàNBO‘O 
.àTMàNBOB‘S[‘ OBNVTV NBM‘WFLBO‘ DBO‘ IBSBNE‘S.àTMàNBO‘O .àTMàNBOLBSEFāJOJ
LàÎàLHÚSNFTJāFSPMBSBLPOBZFUFSw 5JSNJ[Ô #JSSWF4‘MB  IBEJTJāFSJmZMFLPOVEFTUFL-
MFOJS

:ÚOUFNWF5FLOJLMFS
½SOFL0MBZÿODFMFNFTJ 4PSV$FWBQ

.BUFSZBM
½SOFLPMBZNFUOJ

&ULJOMJL
ZBā
½þSFUJDJ  ÚSOFL PMBZ‘ T‘O‘GUBO CJS ÎPDVþB PLVUUVSVS WF JTUFZFO CJSLBÎ ÎPDVþB EB ÚSOFL
PMBZ‘OÚ[FUJOJZBQU‘S‘S0MBZEBLJLBISBNBOMBSCFMJSMFOJS½SOFLPMBZ‘OT‘O‘GUBSBG‘OEBOJZJDF
BOMBā‘ME‘þ‘OEBOFNJOPMEVLUBOTPOSBPMBZ‘OEFþFSMFOEJSNFTJOFHFÎJMJS

,VM)BLL‘ ½SOFL0MBZ
.FUF àOJWFSTJUFàÎàODàT‘O‘GUBPLVZBOCJSÎPDVLUV5VUUVþVBQBSUNBOEBJSFTJOEFBS-
LBEBā‘ZMBCFSBCFSLBMNBLUBZE‘)FNFOIFNFOIFSIBGUBTPOVZBQU‘þ‘HJCJZJOFàOJWFSTJUFEFO
BSLBEBāMBS‘O‘UPQMBN‘āFþMFOJZPSMBSE‘4BBUFQFZJMFSMFNFTJOFSBþNFO Nà[JþJOTFTJPMEVLÎB
ZàLTFLUJ(àMàāNFMFSWFCBþS‘āNBMBSCàUàOBQBSUNBOEBZBOL‘MBO‘ZPSEV"MULBUUBIBTUBPMBO
)BUJDFUFZ[FZBUBþ‘OEBEÚOàQEVSVZPSWFVZVNBZBÎBM‘ā‘ZPSEV:BOUBSBGUBLJ"ZMB)BO‘N
ZFOJEPþBOÎPDVþVOVTVTUVSNBZBÎBM‘ā‘ZPSOÚCFUUFOHFMFO&NJS#FZ CBāBþS‘T‘O‘OHFÎNFTJOJ
CFLMJZPSEV"QBSUNBOTBLJOMFSJIFSIBGUBZBāBOBOWFJMFSMFZFOTBBUMFSEFIÉMÉEFWBNFEFOCV
HàSàMUàEFOJZJDFSBIBUT‘[PMNVāMBSE‘±PDVLWFHFOÎPMEVLMBS‘JÎJOBQBSUNBOTBLJOMFSJCV
EVSVNVIFQBMUUBOBM‘ZPSMBSE‘BODBLBSU‘L&NJS#FZJOTBCS‘JZJDFUBāN‘āU‘ÿMLEFGBÎPDVLMBS‘
VZBSNBLJÎJOLBQ‘MBS‘O‘O[JMJOFCBTU‘ HàSàMUàEFOTFTJEVZNBZBOÚþSFODJMFSCJSLBÎ[JMTFTJO-
EFOTPOSBLBQ‘Z‘BÎU‘MBS&NJS#FZLJCBSCJSUBW‘SMBTBBUJOHFÎPMEVþVOV ZBS‘OJāFHJUNFTJ

28
KUL HAKKI

HFSFLUJþJOJBOMBUNBZBÎBM‘ā‘SLFO ÚþSFODJMFSBMBZM‘CJSāFLJMEF&NJS#FZFi,VMBLMBS‘OBQBNVL
U‘LBwEJZFSFLHàMàāUàMFS&NJS#FZEVZEVþVOBāBā‘SN‘āWFOFEJZFDFþJOJCJMFNFNJāUJ
½SOFL0MBZ‘O%FþFSMFOEJSNFTJ
0MBZEBLJLBISBNBOMBSLJNMFSEJS
ÿOTBOMBS‘OFþMFONFLJÎJOCBāLBMBS‘O‘SBIBUT‘[FUNFZFIBLL‘WBSN‘E‘S
.FUFWFBSLBEBāMBS‘O‘OZBQN‘āPMEVþVEBWSBO‘āEPþSVCJSEBWSBO‘āN‘E‘S
4J[.FUFWFBSLBEBāMBS‘O‘OZFSJOEFPMTBZE‘O‘[OBT‘MEBWSBO‘SE‘O‘[
&NJS#FZEBWSBO‘ā‘OEBIBLM‘N‘E‘S
4J[&NJS#FZJOZFSJOEFPMTBZE‘O‘[OFZBQBSE‘O‘[
.FUFWFBSLBEBāMBS‘O‘OZBQU‘þ‘EBWSBO‘āMBSLVMIBLL‘OBHJSFSNJ
4J[DFCVÚSOFLPMBZBCJSCBāM‘LCVMNBLJTUFTFLOBT‘MCJSCBāM‘LZB[BCJMJSJ[

%FþFSMFOEJSNF4PSVMBS‘
(àOMàLIBZBU‘O‘[EBLBSā‘MBāU‘þ‘O‘[LVMIBLL‘JMFBMBLBM‘CJSPMBZBOMBU‘O‘[
i.B[MVNVOCFEEVBT‘OEBOTBL‘O‘O‘[±àOLàPOVOEVBT‘ZMB
"MMBIBSBT‘OEBQFSEFZPLUVSw #VIÉSÔ ;FLÉU  IBEJTJāFSJmOEFBOMBU‘MNBLJTUFOFOEà-
āàODFOFEJS
i,VMIBLL‘wEFZJODFBLM‘O‘[BHFMFOLBWSBNMBS‘T‘SBMBZ‘O‘[

29
KUL HAKKI

(àOàO.FTBK‘
i.àTMàNBO .àTMàNBO‘OLBSEFāJEJSPOBIBJOMJL
ZBQBNB[ POBZBMBOTÚZMFNF[ POVZà[àTUàC‘SBLNB[
.àTMàNBO‘O.àTMàNBOB‘S[‘ OBNVTV NBM‘WFLBO‘
DBO‘ IBSBNE‘S.àTMàNBO‘O .àTMàNBOLBSEFāJOJ
LàÎàLHÚSNFTJāFSPMBSBLPOBZFUFSw
5JSNJ[Ô #JSSWF4‘MB 

,BQBO‘ā
(SVQàZFMFSJOFQBZMBā‘NMBS‘JÎJOUFāFLLàSFEJO
)FSLFTJOBLM‘OEBLBMBONFTBK‘QBZMBāNBT‘O‘JTUFZJO
,POVZMBJMHJMJWBSTBTPSVMBS‘O‘BM‘OWFDFWBQMBZ‘O
#JSTPOSBLJLPOVOVOCBāM‘þ‘O‘WFSJOWFWFEBMBā‘O

30
12
&."/&5#ÿ-ÿ/$ÿ

&NBOFULBWSBN‘O‘EPþSVMVLWFHàWFOJMJSMJLCBþMBN‘OEBBΑLMBS
&NBOFUFEJMFOāFZJOTBEFDFLPSVONBT‘EFþJM TFWHJZMF
Hà[FMMFāUJSJMNFTJHFSFLUJþJOJEFGBSLFEFS
&NJOPMNBO‘O NàNJOJOFOÚOFNMJWBTG‘PMEVþVOVCJMJS
1FZHBNCFSJNJ[JOJTNJOJOi.VIBNNFEàM&NJOwPMEVþVOVCJMJS
5. 1FZHBNCFSJNJ[F.VIBNNFEàM&NJOEFOJMNFTJOJOTFCFQMFSJOJÚSOFLMFSMFBΑLMBS
$BO‘O BLM‘O EJOJO OFTMJOWFNBM‘OFNBOFUPMEVþVOVLBWSBS
#BāLBMBS‘O‘OFNBOFUMFSJOJLPSVNBT‘HFSFLUJþJOJCJMJS
,BNVNBM‘O‘OFNBOFUPMEVþVOVCJMJSWFLPSVS
&."/&5#ÿ-ÿ/$ÿ

1. EMANET
,B[BO‘N
&NBOFULBWSBN‘O‘EPþSVMVLWFHàWFOJMJSMJLCBþMBN‘OEBBΑLMBS

½þSFUJDJ/PUV
±PDVLMBSB i&NBOFU OFEJS w TPSVTV TPSVMVS WF POMBS‘O DFWBQMBS‘ EJOMFOJS %BIB TPOSB
FNBOFU IFSIBOHJCJSāFZJOCJSLJāJZFNVIBGB[BT‘WFZBLPSVONBT‘BNBD‘ZMBC‘SBL‘MNBT‘PMBSBL
UBO‘NMBO‘Si&NBOFUNBEEJPMBCJMFDFþJHJCJ NBOFWJEFPMBCJMJSwāFLMJOEFBΑLMBO‘S
ti0OMBS FNBOFUMFSJOJWFWFSEJLMFSJTÚ[àHÚ[FUFOLJNTFMFSEJSw .FÉSJD 
t i&Z JNBO FEFOMFS "MMBI WF QFZHBNCFSMFSJOF IBJOMJL FUNFZJO  CJMF CJMF BSBO‘[EBLJ
FNBOFUMFSFEFIBJOMJLFUNFZJOw &OGÉM  
ti.àTMàNBOFMJOEFOWFEJMJOEFOFNJOPMVOBOLJNTFEJSw .àTMJN ÿNBO  IBEJTJJMF
FNBOFULBWSBN‘EFUBZMBS‘ZMBJ[BIFEJMJS

:ÚOUFNWF5FLOJLMFS
&þJUTFM0ZVO "OMBU‘N 4PSV$FWBQ

.BUFSZBM
:B[‘UBIUBT‘

&ULJOMJL
ZBā
½þSFUJDJ ZVLBS‘EBLJBZFUWFIBEJTMFSMFEJOJNJ[ÿTMBN‘OFNBOFULBWSBN‘OBWFSEJþJÚOFNJ
BOMBU‘S4POSBÎPDVLMBSBCJSPZVOPZOBZBDBLMBS‘O‘TÚZMFZFSFLPZVOVāÚZMFBΑLMBS
0ZVOEBUBIUBZBCJSLFMJNFWFZBEFZJNZB[BDBþ‘N4J[MFST‘SBT‘ZMBHFMJQPOVOMBBMBLBM‘CBāLB
CJSLFMJNFWFZBEFZJNZB[BDBLT‘O‘[WFTBOJZFCPZVODBPLBWSBN‘CJ[FBΑLMBZBDBLT‘O‘[
,POVNV[FNBOFUPMEVþVJÎJOUBIUBZBZB[BDBþ‘NLBWSBNiFNBOFUwPMBDBL

32
&."/&5#ÿ-ÿ/$ÿ

#V BΑLMBNBEBO TPOSB ÚþSFUJDJ PZVOV CBāMBU‘S 5àN ÎPDVLMBS TÚ[ BMBOB LBEBS FULJOMJL
EFWBNFEFS½þSFUJDJ PZVOPZOBO‘SLFOÎPDVLMBSBLFMJNFCVMNBZBEBIBU‘SMBUNBOPLUBT‘OEB
ZBSE‘NFEFCJMJS
½SOFLLFMJNFMFS&NBOFU HàWFO HàWFOJMJSPMNBL FNBOFUFUNFL FNBOFUFHÚ[àHJCJ
CBLNBL TÚ[WFSNFL TÚ[àOEFEVSNBL

%FþFSMFOEJSNF4PSVMBS‘
&NBOFUOFEFNFLUJS
&NBOFUMFJMHJMJTJ[JOLBWSBN‘O‘[OFZEJ
"SLBEBāMBS‘O‘[‘OFNBOFUMFJMHJMJJGBEFFUUJþJLBWSBNMBSEBOCJSUBOFTJOJTFÎFSFLCV
LBWSBNIBLL‘OEBOFEàāàOEàþàOà[àBΑLMBSN‘T‘O‘[

(àOàO.FTBK‘
i4BOBFNBOFUC‘SBLBO‘OFNBOFUJOJ
HFSJWFS TBOBJIBOFUFEFOFJIBOFU
FUNFw
&CV%ÉWVE #àZV 

,BQBO‘ā
(SVQàZFMFSJOFQBZMBā‘NMBS‘JÎJOUFāFLLàSFEJO
)FSLFTJOBLM‘OEBLBMBONFTBK‘QBZMBāNBT‘O‘JTUFZJO
,POVZMBJMHJMJWBSTBTPSVMBS‘O‘BM‘OWFDFWBQMBZ‘O
#JSTPOSBLJLPOVOVOCBāM‘þ‘O‘WFSJOWFWFEBMBā‘O

33
&."/&5#ÿ-ÿ/$ÿ

½þSFUJDJ/PUV
&NBOFULBWSBN‘UBO‘NMBOE‘LUBOTPOSBOFMFSJOFNBOFUFEJMFCJMFDFþJÎPDVLMBSMBCFMJSMFOJS
"SE‘OEBO FNBOFU FEFCJMFDFþJNJ[ āFZMFSJ LJNF FNBOFU FEJQ LJNF FNBOFU FUNFZFDFþJNJ[MF
JMHJMJÎBM‘āNBLÉþ‘E‘ &, EBþ‘U‘M‘S%FSTJOTPOVOEBÎPDVLMBSMBCJSMJLUFPMVāUVSVMBOTMPHBOMBS
JÎFSJTJOEFOFOHà[FMJTFÎJMFSFLQBOPZBBT‘M‘S

:ÚOUFNWF5FLOJLMFS
#VMEVSNB:ÚOUFNJ 4MPHBO0MVāUVSNB

.BUFSZBM
±BM‘āNBLÉþ‘E‘ ÎPDVLTBZ‘T‘ODBÎPþBMU‘MN‘ā CBMPO ÎPDVLTBZ‘T‘ODB

&ULJOMJL
ZBā
±BM‘āNB LÉþ‘E‘ &,  ÎPDVLMBSB EBþ‘U‘M‘S WF  EBLJLB JÎFSJTJOEF ZB[NBMBS‘ JTUFOJS
±PDVLMBS ÎBM‘āNB LÉþ‘UMBS‘O‘ EPMEVSNBZ‘ CJUJSEJLMFSJOEF ÚþSFUJDJ ZÚOFUJNJOEF FULJOMJL
NBEEFMFSJEFþFSMFOEJSJMJS(FSFLÎFMFOEJSNFMFSHàÎMFOEJSJMJQQFLJāUJSJMJS
)FS ÎPDVLUBO ÎBM‘āNB LÉþ‘UMBS‘O‘O BSLBT‘OB FNBOFU JMF JMHJMJ CJS TMPHBO IB[‘SMBNBMBS‘
JTUFOJS4MPHBOMBS‘O‘IB[‘SMBZBOBCBMPOWFSJMFDFþJWFPZVOPZOBOBDBþ‘ÎPDVLMBSBEVZVSVMVS
±PDVLMBSB CBMPOMBSEBþ‘U‘M‘S
"āBþ‘EBLJHJCJÎPDVLMBS HàWFOJMJSCJSJOTBOPMNBLJÎJOHFSFLMJÚ[FMMJLMFSJTÚZMFZFSFLTÚ[
WFSJSMFS
±PDVLMBS  CBMPOV FMJOF BM‘S WF IFS OFGFTUF BāBþ‘EBLJ DàNMFMFSJ TÚZMFZFSFL CBMPOMBS‘O‘
āJāJSJSMFS
&NBOFUJOIBLL‘O‘WFSFCJMNFLJÎJOi(àWFOJMJSCJSJOTBOPMBDBþ‘Nw
&NBOFUJOIBLL‘O‘WFSFCJMNFLJÎJOi:BMBOTÚZMFNFNFZFÚ[FOHÚTUFSFDFþJNw
&NBOFUJOIBLL‘O‘WFSFCJMNFLJÎJOi%àSàTUEBWSBO‘āMBSTFSHJMFZFDFþJNw
&NBOFUJOIBLL‘O‘WFSFCJMNFLJÎJOi"EBMFUMJEBWSBOBDBþ‘Nw
&NBOFUJOIBLL‘O‘WFSFCJMNFLJÎJOi%PTEPþSVPMNBZBÎBCBMBZBDBþ‘Nw
&NBOFUJOIBLL‘O‘WFSFCJMNFLJÎJOi)JMFZBQNBZBDBþ‘Nw
#BMPOMBSāJāJSJMEJLUFOTPOSBIFSLFTCBMPOVOVOà[FSJOFJTNJOJZB[BSWFÚþSFUJDJÎPDVLMBSEBO
CBMPOMBS‘O‘IBWBZBBUNBMBS‘O‘EBLJLBCPZVODBZFSFEàāàSNFEFOIBWBEBUVUNBMBS‘O‘JTUFS
EBLJLBCPZVODBCBMPOVOVZFSFEàāàSNFEFOIBWBEBUVUBOPZVOVLB[BO‘S

34
&."/&5#ÿ-ÿ/$ÿ

,ÿ.&&."/&5&%&3 /&%&/
,ÿ.&&."/&5&5.&;4ÿ/

±àOLà FNBOFUFUUJþJNāFZJLPSVNBL
4Ú[àOEFEVSBOLJāJZF
JÎJOFMJOEFOHFMFOJZBQBDBLU‘S

:BMBOTÚZMFZFOF ±àOLà

±‘LBSD‘EBWSBOBOB ±àOLà

4‘SS‘N‘LPSVZBOB ±àOLà

#BāLBMBS‘O‘OEFEJLPEVTVOVZBQBOB ±àOLà

-BGUBā‘ZBOB ±àOLà

%àSàTUEBWSBOBOB ±àOLà

"EBMFUMJPMBOB ±àOLà

½[àWFTÚ[àCJSPMBOB ±àOLà

)JMFZBQNBZBOB ±àOLà

)BLL‘TBWVOBOB ±àOLà

4BNJNJPMEVþVNUBO‘E‘þ‘NCJSJOF ±àOLà

1BSLUBZFOJUBO‘āU‘þ‘NCJSJOF ±àOLà

35
&."/&5#ÿ-ÿ/$ÿ

%FþFSMFOEJSNF4PSVMBS‘
i&NBOFUJLPSVNBLLBWSBN‘O‘CBāLBCJSLBWSBNJMFJGBEFFUNFOHFSFLTFIBOHJLBWSBNMB
JGBEFFEFSTJO wTPSVTVT‘SBZMBUàNÎPDVLMBSBZÚOFMUJMJSWFà[FSJOFLPOVāVMVS
i4Ú[WFEBWSBO‘āMBS‘EPþSVPMNBZBOLJāJZFCJSāFZMFSFNBOFUFUNFLJTUFSNJTJO /FEFO w
TPSVTVÎPDVLMBSBZÚOFMUJMFSFLà[FSJOFLPOVāVMVS

(àOàO.FTBK‘
3FTßMJ&LSFN i%PþSVMVLUBOBZS‘MNBZ‘O
±àOLàEPþSVMVL JOTBO‘ JZJMJþF JZJMJL
EFDFOOFUFHÚUàSàS,JāJEFWBNM‘EPþSV
TÚZMFSWFEPþSVMVLUBOBZS‘MNB[TB"MMBI
LBU‘OEBAEPþSVT‘EE‘LPMBSBLUFTDJMMFOJSw
CVZVSNVāUVS
.àTMJN #JSS 

,BQBO‘ā
(SVQàZFMFSJOFQBZMBā‘NMBS‘JÎJOUFāFLLàSFEJO
)FSLFTJOBLM‘OEBLBMBONFTBK‘QBZMBāNBT‘O‘JTUFZJO
,POVZMBJMHJMJWBSTBTPSVMBS‘O‘BM‘OWFDFWBQMBZ‘O
#JSTPOSBLJLPOVOVOCBāM‘þ‘O‘WFSJOWFWFEBMBā‘O

36
&."/&5#ÿ-ÿ/$ÿ

&."/&5ÿ/,036/."4*7&
(Ã;&--&Ā5ÿ3ÿ-.&4ÿ
,B[BO‘N
&NBOFUFEJMFOāFZJOTBEFDFLPSVONBT‘EFþJM TFWHJZMFHà[FMMFāUJSJMNFTJHFSFLUJþJOJGBSLFEFS

½þSFUJDJ/PUV
)FQJNJ[CVEàOZBEBFNBOFUPMNBO‘OZBO‘OEBCJSCJSJNJ[FEFFNBOFUFEJMNJāJ["MMBI
CJ[FSVIVNV[V CFEFOJNJ[J PSHBOMBS‘N‘[‘ TBþM‘þ‘N‘[‘FNBOFUWFSNJā CJ[MFSEFJāMFSJNJ[J
LPMBZMBāU‘SNBL  TPSVNMVMVLMBS‘N‘[‘ IBmnFUNFL JÎJO JMHJ WF LBCJMJZFUMFSJNJ[F VZHVO
NFTMFLMFSEFV[NBOMBāBSBLFNBOFUFUBMJQPMNVāZBEBUBMJQPMBOMBSBCVTPSVNMVMVLMBS‘FNBOFU
FUNJāJ[EJS )FSLFT LFOEJTJOF FNBOFU FEJMFO HÚSFW WF TPSVNMVMVLMBS‘ HàWFOJ TBSTNBZBDBL
āFLJMEF LPSVNBM‘ WF EBIB Hà[FM IÉMF HFUJSNFMJEJS  āFLMJOEF BΑLMBNB ZBQ‘ME‘LUBO TPOSB
SFTJNMFSÚþSFUJDJUBSBG‘OEBOUFLUFLHÚTUFSJMJS

:ÚOUFNWF5FLOJLMFS
3FTJN:PSVNMBNB5FLOJþJ

.BUFSZBMMFS
,BSUIÉMJOEFPMVāUVSVMNVāSFTJNMFS &,

&ULJOMJL
 ZBā
±PDVLMBSB &,EFLJ LBSUMBSHÚTUFSJMFSFLÚ[FMMJLMFSJ OFEFOPHÚSFWEFPMEVLMBS‘ CJ[EFO
GBSLM‘ZÚOMFSJà[FSJOFLPOVāVMVS

37
&."/&5#ÿ-ÿ/$ÿ

EK 1

,BMF LBMFDJZFFNBOFUUJS ½þSFODJ ÚþSFUNFOF


FNBOFUUJS
:FUFOFLWFLBCJMJZFUMFSJWBSE‘S
#JMHJTJWFJMHJTJWBSE‘S
3FnFLTMFSJLVWWFUMJEJS ½þSFUNFZÚOUFNWF
#FDFSJLMJEJS UFLOJLMFSJOJCJMJS
(ÚSFWWFTPSVNMVMVþVOV
ZFSJOFHFUJSJS

4BþM‘þ‘N‘[CP[VMEVþVOEB "SBD‘N‘[CP[VMEVþVOEBVTUBZB
EPLUPSBFNBOFUJ[EJS FNBOFUUJS
#JMHJTJWFUFDSàCFTJWBSE‘S #J[JNCJMNFEJþJNJ[ZÚOMFSJZMF
ÿZJMFāUJSNFLJÎJOÎBCBHÚTUFSJS BSBD‘N‘[‘CJMJS
)BTUBM‘þ‘OāJGBT‘OBWFTJMFPMBDBL "S‘[BO‘OOFSEFPMEVþVOVCVMVS
JMBÎMBS‘CJMJS WFUBNJSFEFS
:FUFOFLWFLBCJMJZFUMFSJWBSE‘S

38
&."/&5#ÿ-ÿ/$ÿ

:PMDVMVLTàSFTJODFāPGÚSF (àWFOMJþJNJ[FNOJZFU
FNBOFUJ[EJS HÚSFWMJMFSJOFFNBOFUUJS
4àSàāUFLOJLMFSJOJCJMJS &þJUJNJOJBMN‘āMBSE‘S
5SBmLLVSBMMBS‘O‘WFI‘[ ,PSVNBZÚOUFNMFSJOJCJMJSMFS
MJNJUMFSJOJCJMJS 4VÎMVMBS‘BEBMFUFUFTMJNFEFSMFS
4àSàāCFDFSJTJWFUFDSàCFTJ
WBSE‘S

±PDVLMBSMBLJNLJNFFNBOFUFULJOMJþJHFSÎFLMFāUJSJMEJLUFOTPOSBPOMBSB
)BTUBMBOE‘þ‘N‘[EBQPMJTFHJUTFLPMNB[N‘ZE‘ /FEFO
"DFNJLJāJOJOTàSàDàPMNBT‘O‘JTUFSNJZEJOJ[ /FEFO
%JOJOJ[JÚþSFONFLJÎJOPUPUBNJSDJTJOFHJEFSNJZEJOJ[ /FEFO
HJCJTPSVMBSZÚOFMUFSFL à[FSJOEFEàāàONFMFSJTBþMBO‘S
#VLJāJMFSJOLFOEJMFSJOFWFSJMFOHÚSFWWFTPSVNMVMVLMBS‘ZFSJOFHFUJSNFL LFOEJTJOF
FNBOFUFEJMFOHÚSFWJFOJZJāFLJMEFZBQNBLJÎJOÎBCBTBSGFUUJLMFSJWVSHVMBO‘S
"ZS‘DBÿTMBNNFEFOJZFUJOEFFNBOFUJLPSVNBWFHà[FMMFāUJSNFOJOTBZ‘T‘[ÚSOFþJOJOCV
MVOEVþVJGBEFFEJMFSFL &, HÚTUFSJMJS

39
&."/&5#ÿ-ÿ/$ÿ

EK 2

,VāTBSBZMBS‘ 4BEBLBWFZJUJLUBāMBS‘
LVāMBS‘OLPSVONBT‘JÎJO GBLJSMFSJOLPSVONBT‘WFLBZCPMBO
ZBQ‘MN‘ā FāZBMBS‘ONVIBGB[BT‘JÎJO
ZBQ‘MN‘āU‘S

#àUàOCVÚSOFLMFSJOÿTMBNNFEFOJZFUJOEFFNBOFUCJMJODJOJOZBZH‘OPMBSBLHÚSàMNFTJO
EFOWFHàWFOUPQMVNVPMVONBT‘OEBOLBZOBLMBOE‘þ‘ "MMBI‘OWFSEJþJFNBOFUMFSFEVZVMBO
TFWHJOJOCJSFSJGBEFTJPMEVþVÎPDVLMBSBBOMBU‘M‘S


&."/&5#ÿ-ÿ/$ÿ

%FþFSMFOEJSNF4PSVMBS‘
&NBOFUJFIMJOFWFSNFLOJÎJOÚOFNMJEJS
#J[FNBOFUFEJMFOCJSāFZJOBT‘MHà[FMMFāUJSFCJMJSJ[
(àOàNà[EFIBOHJHà[FMMJLMFSJZBāBUBSBLCJ[FFNBOFUFEJMNJāDBOM‘MBS‘LPSVZBCJMJSJ[

(àOàO.FTBK‘
i"MMBITJ[F FNBOFUMFSJNVUMBLBFIMJOFWFSNFOJ[J
WFJOTBOMBSBSBT‘OEBIàLNFUUJþJOJ[[BNBOBEBMFUMF
IàLNFUNFOJ[JFNSFEJZPS%PþSVTV"MMBI CVOVOMB
TJ[FOFHà[FMÚþàUWFSJZPSĀàQIFTJ[LJ"MMBI
IBLL‘ZMBJāJUFOEJS IBLL‘ZMBHÚSFOEJSw
/JTÉ 

,BQBO‘ā
(SVQàZFMFSJOFQBZMBā‘NMBS‘JÎJOUFāFLLàSFEJO
)FSLFTJOBLM‘OEBLBMBONFTBK‘QBZMBāNBT‘O‘JTUFZJO
,POVZMBJMHJMJWBSTBTPSVMBS‘O‘BM‘OWFDFWBQMBZ‘O
#JSTPOSBLJLPOVOVOCBāM‘þ‘O‘WFSJOWFWFEBMBā‘O

41
&."/&5#ÿ-ÿ/$ÿ

½þSFUJDJ/PUV
 i.àTMàNBO  FMJOEFO WF EJMJOEFO FNJO PMVOBO LJNTFEJSw .àTMJN  ÿNBO    IBEJTJ
PLVOVSWFi&NJOPMNBLOFEFNFLUJS wEJZFTPSVMVS&NBOFUFSJBZFUà[FSJOFCJSTàSFTPICFU
FEJMJS WF i±PDVLMBS  FNBOFUF SJBZFU FUNFL Hà[FM CJS āFZ BNB FNBOFUJ TFWHJ EVZHVTVZMB
Hà[FMMFāUJSNFL EBIB EB Hà[FM CJS EBWSBO‘ā EJZF EàāàOàZPSVN 4J[ CV LPOVEB OFMFS
EàāàOàZPSTVOV[ wEJZFTPSVMVS±PDVLMBS‘OLBU‘M‘N‘JMFLPOVà[FSJOEFTPICFUFEJMJS

:ÚOUFNWF5FLOJLMFS
3PM0ZOBNB "OMBU‘N 4PSV$FWBQ

&ULJOMJL
ZBā
i#VLPOVZMBJMHJMJPMBSBLCBL‘O1FZHBNCFS&GFOEJNJ[CJ[FOFBOMBUN‘ā wEJZFSFLBāBþ‘EBLJ
NFUJO ÎPDVLMBSMB QBZMBā‘M‘S ½þSFUJDJ NFUOJ ÎPDVLMBSB PLVZBCJMJS WFZB EBIB ÚODF LFOEJTJ
PLVZVQBOMBUBCJMJS
i#J[EFOÚODFZBāBZBOMBSEBOàÎLJāJZPMBΑLU‘MBS"LāBNPMVODB HFDFMFNFJIUJZBD‘POMBS‘
CJS NBþBSBZB T‘þ‘OE‘SE‘ WF JÎJOF HJSEJMFS "ODBL  EBþEBO ZVWBSMBOBO CàZàLÎF CJS LBZB
NBþBSBO‘OBþ[‘O‘LBQBE‘
"SBMBS‘OEB LPOVāVSLFO i#J[J CV LBZBEBO TBMJI BNFMMFSJOJ[J āFGBBUÎJ L‘MBSBL "MMBIB
ZBQBDBþ‘O‘[EVBMBSLVSUBSBCJMJSwEFEJMFS
#VOVOà[FSJOF JÎMFSJOEFOJMLJBOOFCBCBT‘OBZBQU‘þ‘CJSIJ[NFUJBOMBUU‘WFFMMFSJOJBΑQi&Z
"MMBI‘NwEFEJi&þFSCVOMBS‘TFOJOS‘[BOJÎJOZBQN‘āTBN CJ[JCVT‘L‘OU‘EBOLVSUBSw#VEVB
à[FSJOFLBZBZFSJOEFOCJSB[L‘N‘MEBE‘ÿLJODJTJJTFCJSPMBZLBSā‘T‘OEBJGGFUMJEBWSBONBT‘ZMB
BMBLBM‘CJSIBEJTFZJBOMBUU‘WFi&Z"MMBI‘Nwi&þFSCVOMBS‘TFOJOS‘[BOJÎJOZBQN‘āTBN CJ[J
CVT‘L‘OU‘EBOLVSUBSwEJZFEVBFUUJ
#V EVB à[FSJOF LBZB ZFSJOEFO CJSB[ EBIB L‘N‘MEBE‘ "NB POMBS‘O ΑLBCJMFDFþJ LBEBS
BΑMNBE‘
±BSFTJ[  NBþBSBEB CFLMFāNFZF EFWBN FUUJMFS #V FTOBEB  TPO CJS àNJU  àÎàODà āBI‘T
CBā‘OEBOHFÎFOCJSPMBZ‘BOMBUNBZBCBāMBN‘āCVMVOVZPSEV
i&Z "MMBI‘N #FO JāÎJMFS ÎBM‘āU‘S‘ZPSEVN ÃDSFUMFSJOJ EF EFSIBM WFSJZPSEVN "ODBL CJS
UBOFTJ CJSLJMPQJSJOÎUFOJCBSFUPMBOàDSFUJOJBMNBEBOHJUUJ#FOEFPOVOQBSBT‘O‘POVOBE‘OB
JāMFUJQLÉSFUUJSEJN½ZMFLJ ÎPLNBM‘PMEV%FSLFO V[VOTFOFMFSTPOSBCVJāÎJNΑLBHFMEJWF
i&Z"MMBI‘OLVMVwEFEJi#BOBPMBOCPSDVOVÚEFw#FOEF i#àUàOāVHÚSEàþàOT‘þ‘S EBWBS 
EFWFWFLÚMFMFSTFOJOEJS(JU CVOMBS‘BMHÚUàSwEFEJN
"EBN
i&Z"MMBI‘OLVMV#FOJNMFBMBZFUNFwEFEJ#FOUFLSBS w,FTJOMJLMFBMBZFUNJZPSVN(JU 
IFQTJOJBMHÚUàSwEFEJN"EBNIFQTJOJBM‘QHÚUàSEài&Z"MMBI‘N&þFSCVOVTFOJOS‘[BO

42
&."/&5#ÿ-ÿ/$ÿ

JÎJOZBQU‘ZTBN CJ[FāVIÉMEFOCJSLVSUVMVāOBTJQFUw"EBN‘OCVEVBT‘O‘OIFNFOBLBCJOEF
LBZBUBNBNFOBΑME‘±‘L‘QZPMMBS‘OBEFWBNFUUJMFS .àTMJN 3JLBL 
"OMBU‘N CJUUJLUFO TPOSB ÚþSFUJDJ ÎPDVLMBSMB IBEJTJ āFSJG à[FSJOF TPICFU FEFS &NBOFUJ
FOHà[FMāFLMJZMFLPSVNBO‘OBMU‘ÎJ[JMJS%BIBTPOSBÚþSFUJDJCVPMBZ‘DBOMBOE‘SNBUFLMJmOEF
CVMVOVSWFEVBFEFOMFSJÎJOLJāJZJWFLBZBZ‘DBOMBOE‘SNBLà[FSFEFLJāJZJTFÎFS0MBZ‘O
DBOMBOE‘S‘MNBT‘ZMBEFSTTPOBFSFS

%FþFSMFOEJSNF4PSVMBS‘
&NBOFUOFEFNFLUJS
%VBO‘OLBCVMFEJMNFTJOEFHà[FMEBWSBO‘āUBCVMVONBO‘OFULJTJWBSN‘E‘S BΑLMBZ‘O‘[
&NBOFUFSJBZFUMFJMHJMJTJ[JOWFSFCJMFDFþJOJ[CBāLBÚSOFLMFSWBSN‘

(àOàO.FTBK‘
i.àTMàNBO FMJOEFOWFEJMJOEFO
FNJOPMVOBOLJNTFEJSw
.àTMJN ÿNBO 

,BQBO‘ā
(SVQàZFMFSJOFQBZMBā‘NMBS‘JÎJOUFāFLLàSFEJO
)FSLFTJOBLM‘OEBLBMBONFTBK‘QBZMBāNBT‘O‘JTUFZJO
,POVZMBJMHJMJWBSTBTPSVMBS‘O‘BM‘OWFDFWBQMBZ‘O
#JSTPOSBLJLPOVOVOCBāM‘þ‘O‘WFSJOWFWFEBMBā‘O

43
&."/&5#ÿ-ÿ/$ÿ

.Ã.ÿ/ÿ/&/½/&.-ÿ7"4'*
&.ÿ/0-.",
,B[BO‘N
&NJOPMNBO‘O NàNJOJOFOÚOFNMJWBTG‘PMEVþVOVCJMJS

½þSFUJDJ/PUV
&NBOFUCJMJODJOJOBΑLMBONBT‘ZMBJMHJMJLPOVZBHJSJāZBQ‘M‘S&NBOFUJONàNJOJOÚOFNMJ
CJSWBTG‘PMEVþVCFMJSUJMFSFL i4BOBWFSJMFOCJSFNBOFUJ FNBOFUFEFOLJāJZFWFS4BOBIBJOMJL
FEFOFTFOIBJOMJLFUNFw 5JSNJ[Ô #àZV  IBEJTJāFSJmZMFLPOVJ[BIFEJMJS

:ÚOUFNWF5FLOJLMFS
&þJUTFM0ZVO

.BUFSZBM
3FOLMJLBSUPO ZBQ‘āU‘S‘D‘

&ULJOMJL
ZBā
½þSFUJDJ ÎPDVLMBSBIFQCJSMJLUFIBGUBM‘LCJSHB[FUFΑLBSBDBLMBS‘O‘WFCVOVOJÎJOPOMBS‘O
ZBSE‘N‘OBJIUJZBÎEVZEVþVOVCFMJSUJSWFÎPDVLMBS‘OHÚSFCJMFDFþJEVWBSBCàZàLSFOLMJLBSUPO
BTBSWFi&WFUBSLBEBāMBS TJ[JOEFHÚSEàþàOà[HJCJEVWBSBCJSLBSUPOBTU‘NÿāUFCVCJ[JN
HB[FUFNJ[wEFS½þSFUJDJEVWBSBBT‘MBOLBSUPOBCBLBSBLi"NBCJSEBLJLBIJÎCÚZMFCPNCPāCJS
HB[FUFPMVSNV 4J[EBIBÚODFIJÎCÚZMFCJSHB[FUFHÚSEàOà[Nà wEFS±PDVLMBSEBOi)BZ‘Sw
DFWBC‘ BME‘LUBO TPOSB ÚþSFUJDJ i&WFU BSLBEBāMBS  HB[FUFNJ[ āJNEJMJL CPā "ODBL TJ[F CB[‘
BSBāU‘SNBLPOVMBS‘WFSFDFþJN"SBāU‘SE‘þ‘O‘[LPOVMBSJMFJMHJMJCJMHJUPQMBZ‘QCVOVZB[BDBLWF
ÎFāJUMJSFTJNMFSCVMBSBLLPOVOV[VEFTUFLMFZFDFLTJOJ[wEFS½þSFUJDJ LPOVTVJMFJMHJMJSFTJN
CVMVOBNBE‘þ‘UBLEJSEFÎPDVLMBS‘OÎFāJUMJÎJ[JNZBEBTàTMFNFMFSJMFCVOVZBQBCJMFDFLMFSJOJ 
LVMMBO‘MBONBM[FNFMFSJONàNLàOPMEVþVLBEBSSFOLMJWFHÚSTFMBΑEBOÎBM‘āNBZB[FOHJOMJL
LBUBDBL OJUFMJLUF PMNBT‘ HFSFLUJþJOJ TÚZMFS LBZOBL WF LVMMBO‘MBDBL NBM[FNFMFS LPOVTVOEB

44
&."/&5#ÿ-ÿ/$ÿ

HFSFLUJþJOEFÎPDVLMBSBSFICFSMJLFEFSFLEFTUFLTBþMBS½þSFUJDJEBIBTPOSBÎPDVLMBSMBCJSMJLUF
LPOV QBZMBā‘N‘ ZBQBS #JS IBGUB TPOSB ÚþSFUJDJ  ÎPDVLMBS‘O IB[‘SMBN‘ā PMEVþV ÎBM‘āNBMBS‘
JODFMFS  HFSFLMJ EFþJāJLMJL WF LPOUSPMà ZBQU‘LUBO TPOSB IFQ CJSMJLUF  ZBQ‘MBO ÎBM‘āNBMBS‘O
EVWBSBBT‘MBOSFOLMJLBSUPOBZBQ‘āU‘S‘MNBT‘TBþMBO‘S±BM‘āNBTPOVOEBÎPDVLMBSUFCSJLFEJMJS
WFPSUBLCJSÎBM‘āNBZBQNBO‘ONVUMVMVþVUFāWJLFEJDJDàNMFMFSMFÎPDVLMBSBIJTTFUUJSJMJS
±PDVLMBSBWFSJMFCJMFDFLBSBāU‘SNBLPOVMBS‘iFNJOPMNBL HàWFOJMJSPMNBLLBWSBNMBS‘O‘O
BΑLMBNBT‘ FNJOPMNBL HàWFOJMJSPMNBLJMFBMBLBM‘āJJS SFTJN LBSJLBUàS FNJOPMNBLMBJMHJMJ
LàÎàLIJLÉZFw

%FþFSMFOEJSNF4PSVMBS‘
4J[FCJSBSLBEBā‘O‘[CJSFāZBT‘O‘FNBOFUC‘SBLTBOBT‘MEBWSBO‘ST‘O‘[
.àTMàNBOPMNBLJMFFNJOPMNBLBSBT‘OEBOBT‘MCJSCBþMBOU‘WBSE‘S
#J[FWFSJMFOCJSFNBOFUJLPSVNB[TBLOFPMVS

(àOàO.FTBK‘
i%ÚSUāFZTFOEFWBSTBBSU‘LEàOZBEBO
LBZCFUUJLMFSJOTBOB[BSBSWFSNF[(à[FM
BIMBL IBSBNBHÚUàSNFZFOIFMBMMPLNB 
EPþSVTÚ[ FNBOFUJLPSVNBLw
#VIÉSÔ &EFCàM.àGSFE 

,BQBO‘ā
(SVQàZFMFSJOFQBZMBā‘NMBS‘JÎJOUFāFLLàSFEJO
)FSLFTJOBLM‘OEBLBMBONFTBK‘QBZMBāNBT‘O‘JTUFZJO
,POVZMBJMHJMJWBSTBTPSVMBS‘O‘BM‘OWFDFWBQMBZ‘O
#JSTPOSBLJLPOVOVOCBāM‘þ‘O‘WFSJOWFWFEBMBā‘O

45
&."/&5#ÿ-ÿ/$ÿ

½þSFUJDJ/PUV
,VSBO BZFUMFSJOEFO WF IBEJTJ āFSJnFSEFO NàNJOMFSJO WBT‘nBS‘ EFSMFOJS ½O IB[‘SM‘L
HFSFLUJSNFLUFEJS
.àNJOMFSJOWBT‘nBS‘O‘JGBEFFEFOBZFUMFST‘O‘GBHÚUàSàMFO,VSBO‘,FSJNNFBMJBSBD‘M‘þ‘ZMB
LPOVJOEFLTJCÚMàNàOEFOWFZBEBIBÚODFEFOTVSFWFBZFUOVNBSBMBS‘CFMJSMFONJāBZFUMFS
ÎPDVLMBSMBCJSMJLUFCVMVOBSBLPLVOVS)BEJTMFSJTFJOUFSOFUJNLÉO‘WBSTB)BEJTMFSMFÿTMBNEBO
POMJOF PMBSBL ZPLTB EFSMFOFSFL ΑLU‘ ZBQ‘MNBL TVSFUJZMF T‘O‘GB HÚUàSàMFO LÉþ‘UUBO PLVOVS
.àNJOMFSJOHàWFOJMJSLJNTFMFSPMNBT‘HFSFLUJþJ WVSHVMBO‘S"SE‘OEBOFULJOMJþFHFÎJMJS

:ÚOUFNWF5FLOJLMFS
&þJUTFM0ZVO ½[%FþFSMFOEJSNF

.BUFSZBM
4àOHFSUPQ Ú[EFþFSMFOEJSNFGPSNV &, LPMJCBOE‘ PZVOLBSUMBS‘ &,

&ULJOMJL
ZBā
4"/"(Ã7&/ÿ:036.
±PDVLMBS JLJ UBL‘NB CÚMàOàS ,BSā‘M‘LM‘ PMBSBL BSBEB  NFUSF NFTBGF PMBDBL āFLJMEF
ZFSMFāUJSJMJS
ÿMLT‘SBEBLJÎPDVþVOFMJOFTàOHFSUPQWFSJMJS±PDVLCJSBSLBEBā‘O‘OJTNJOJTÚZMFZFSFL
i4BOBHàWFOJZPSVNwEFSWFUPQVBSLBEBā‘O‘OZBLBMBZBCJMFDFþJāFLJMEFG‘SMBU‘S
5PQVOHÚOEFSJMEJþJLJāJUPQVBUBOLJāJOJOZBQNBT‘NVIUFNFMIBUBZ‘UFMBmFEFSFLUPQV
ZBLBMBNBL[PSVOEBE‘S5PQVZBLBMBZBNB[TBUPQVG‘SMBUBOBSLBEBā‘  QVBOBM‘S  QVBO‘
PMBOÎPDVLPZVOEBOFMFOJS5PQVZBLBMBSTBBZO‘āFLJMEFLBSā‘T‘OEBLJBSLBEBāMBS‘OEBOCJSJOJO
JTNJOJTÚZMFZFSFLi4BOBHàWFOJZPSVNwEFSWFG‘SMBU‘S
0ZVOEBJLJLJāJLBMBOBLBEBSPZVOEFWBNFEFS,BMBOJLJLJāJJMLUVSVOHBMJQMFSJJMBOFEJMJS
WFBML‘āMBO‘S
ÿLJODJUVSJÎJOBZO‘FLJQMFSPZVOBEFWBNFEFSÿLJODJUVSVOTPOVOEBLBMBOÎPDVLMBSEB
BZO‘āFLJMEFBML‘āMBOBSBLNPUJWFFEJMJS0ZVOJLJODJUVSVOTPOVOEBTPOMBOE‘S‘M‘SWFà[FSJOEF
LPOVāVMNBZBCBāMBO‘S
"SLBEBā‘O‘[UPQVUVUNBLJÎJOZFUFSJODFÎBCBHÚTUFSNFTFZEJOFMFSIJTTFEFSEJOJ[
(àWFOEJþJOJ[CJSLJāJUPQVOV[VLBTUFOUVUNBTBZE‘TJ[OBT‘MEBWSBO‘SE‘O‘[
(JCJTPSVMBSTPSVMBSBLÎPDVLMBS‘OHàWFOJMJSPMNBO‘OÚOFNJOJLBWSBNBMBS‘TBþMBO‘S

46
&."/&5#ÿ-ÿ/$ÿ

±PDVLMBSB Ú[ EFþFSMFOEJSNF GPSNV &,  EBþ‘U‘MBSBL HàÎMà WF [BZ‘G ZÚOMFSJOJ GBSL
FUNFMFSJTBþMBO‘S
%FþFSMFOEJSNFGPSNVOVÚþSFUJDJHFSJUPQMBNB[WFIFSLFTQVBOMBS‘O‘UPQMBZBSBLUPQMBN
QVBO‘O‘CVMVS½þSFUJDJPMNBT‘HFSFLFOJāBSFUMFNFMFSJTÚZMFZFSFL ÎPDVLMBS‘OIBUBZBQU‘LMBS‘
NBEEFMFSJCVMNBMBS‘O‘TBþMBS
7FÎPDVLMBSBBāBþ‘EBLJBΑLMBNBZ‘ZBQBS
t "ME‘þ‘O‘[ QVBO  JTF IBZBU‘O‘[EB EàSàTU PMEVþVOV[ JÎJO UFāFLLàSà IBL FUUJOJ[y
,FOEJOJ[JBML‘āMBZ‘Oy
t"ME‘þ‘O‘[QVBOOJOBMU‘OEBWFZBàTUàOEFZTFEàSàTUEBWSBOE‘þ‘O‘[JÎJOUFāFLLàSàIBL
FUUJOJ[y,FOEJOJ[JBML‘āMBZ‘Oy
/PU 1VBOMBNB ÎPDVLMBS‘ JODJUNFZFDFL  POMBSMB BMBZ FEJMNFTJOF [FNJO IB[‘SMBNBZBDBL
āFLJMEFZBQ‘MNBM‘E‘S
½[EFþFSMFOEJSNFGPSNVDFWBQMBOE‘LUBOTPOSBT‘O‘GÎBIFSLFTCJSCJSJOJBML‘āMBSWFLBQBO‘ā
JÎJOPZVOFULJOMJþJOFIB[‘SM‘LMBSBCBāMBS
&ULJOMJL#JUFSLFO
,BSUMBS &, EBJSFPMVāUVSBDBLāFLJMEF&LUFLJHJCJUBIUBEBWFZBEVWBSEBVZHVOZFSF
ZBQ‘āU‘S‘M‘SPZVODVMBSNFUSFV[BLCJSZFSFZFSMFāUJSJMJS±PDVLMBSBTàOHFSCJSUPQWFSJMJS
"NBÎIFEFnFEJþJTÚ[àWVSNBLWFPSBEBZB[BOEBWSBO‘āÚSOFLMFSJZMFJMHJMJÚþSFUJDJTJOFTÚ[
WFSNFLUJS
.àNJO LJāJOJO ZBQBNBZBDBþ‘ TÚ[à WFSNFNFTJ HFSFLUJþJ  WFSEJþJ TÚ[EF EF EVSNBT‘
HFSFLUJþJBāBþ‘EBLJBZFUMFSEPþSVMUVTVOEBÎPDVLMBSBIBU‘SMBU‘M‘S
Yine onlar (o müminler) ki, emanetlerine ve ahidlerine riayet ederler. (Mü’minûn, 8)
"MMBITJ[F NVUMBLBFNBOFUMFSJFIMJPMBOMBSBWFSNFOJ[JWFJOTBOMBSBSBT‘OEBIàLNFUUJþJOJ[
[BNBOBEBMFUMFIàLNFUNFOJ[JFNSFEFS"MMBITJ[FOFLBEBSHà[FMÚþàUMFSWFSJZPSĀàQIFTJ[
"MMBIIFSāFZJJāJUJDJ IFSāFZJHÚSàDàEàS /JTÉ 
±PDVLMBSBQVBOMBNBIBLL‘OEBBāBþ‘EBLJHJCJCJMHJWFSJMJS
t)FEFnFEJþJOJWVSBOQVBO
t&OJÎEBJSFQVBO
t0SUBEBJSFQVBO
t&OE‘āEBJSFJTFQVBOPMBSBLEFþFSMFOEJSJMJS
0ZVOVOTPOVOEBNàNJOMFSJOHàWFOJMJSJOTBOMBSPMEVþV LFOEJTJOFEVZVMBOHàWFOJCPāB
ΑLBSNBNBLJÎJOIFSUàSMàÎBCBZ‘HÚTUFSNFTJHFSFLUJþJWVSHVMBOBSBL FMJOEFOHFMFOJZBQU‘LUBO
TPOSBJTF"MMBIBUFWFLLàMFUNFTJHFSFLUJþJOJOÚOFNJJGBEFWVSHVMBO‘S

47
&."/&5#ÿ-ÿ/$ÿ

EK 1

 %Ã3Ã45±&,&/%ÿ.ÿ%&ý&3-&/%ÿ3ÿ:036. &WFU #B[FO )BZ‘S

 7FSEJþJNTÚ[MFSJZFSJOFHFUJSNFZFÎBM‘ā‘S‘N   

 ,FOEJNJÎJOJTUFNFEJþJNJCBāLBT‘JÎJOEFJTUFNFN   

 4Ú[WFEBWSBO‘āMBS‘NEBUVUBSM‘PMNBZBHBZSFUFEFSJN   

 ½EàOÎBME‘þ‘NFāZBZ‘[BSBSWFSNFEFOLPSVNBZBÎBM‘ā‘S‘N   

 ÿOTBOMBS‘OBSLBT‘OEBOLPOVāNBN   

 0MBZMBS‘BCBSUNBEBOPMEVþVHJCJBLUBS‘S‘N   

 #JMNFEJþJNLPOVMBSEBCJMJZPSNVāHJCJEBWSBONBN   

 (FSÎFLMFSJTÚZMFNFLZFSJOFCBIBOFMFSàSFUUJþJNPMVS   

 4Ú[UBā‘Z‘QEFEJLPEVZBQNBN   

 :BQBNBZBDBþ‘NāFZMFSJZBQBS‘NEFNFN   

 ±‘LBSMBS‘NBUFSTEFPMTBHFSÎFLMFSJTÚZMFNFLUFOÎFLJONFN   

 (ÚSEàþàNàCJSB[BCBSUBSBLBOMBU‘S‘N   

 "SLBEBāMBS‘N‘LPSVNBLJÎJOUBSBGHJSEBWSBOBCJMJSJN   

 %PþSVZVEPþSVTÚZMFNFZFHBZSFUFEFSJN   

 4BEFDFUVUBCJMFDFþJNTÚ[àWFSJSJN   

 #BOBFNBOFUFEJMFOFāZBMBS‘LPSVSVN   

 "SLBEBāMBS‘N‘OWFSEJþJT‘SMBS‘TBLMBZBNBN   

 )BLT‘[M‘LZBQNBNBZB BEJMEBWSBONBZBÎBM‘ā‘S‘N   

 #B[FO[BSBSHÚSNFNFLJÎJOZBMBOTÚZMFSJN   

 ,BSBSWFSJSLFOBEBMFUMJEBWSBO‘S‘N   

501-".  

48
&."/&5#ÿ-ÿ/$ÿ

&,4½;-&3

7FSEJþJNTÚ[MFSJ ,FOEJMFSJOJO 4Ú[WF ½EàOÎBME‘þ‘N


ZFSJOFHFUJSJSJN ZBQNBE‘þ‘CJS EBWSBO‘āMBS‘NEB FāZBZ‘[BSBS
āFZJCBāLBMBS‘OB UVUBSM‘PMVSVN WFSNFEFO
UBWTJZFFUNF[MFS LPSVSVN

ÿOTBOMBS‘O 0MBZMBS‘ #JMNFEJþJN (FSÎFLMFSJ


BSLBT‘OEBO BCBSUNBEBO LPOVMBSEB TÚZMFNFLZFSJOF
LPOVāNBN PMEVþVHJCJ CJMJZPSNVāHJCJ CBIBOFMFS
BLUBS‘S‘N EBWSBONBN àSFUNFN

4Ú[UBā‘Z‘Q :BQBNBZBDBþ‘N ±‘LBSMBS‘NB (ÚSEàþàNà


EFEJLPEV āFZMFSJZBQBS‘N UFSTEFPMTB PMEVþVHJCJ
ZBQNBN EFNFN HFSÎFLMFSJ BOMBU‘S‘N
TÚZMFNFLUFO
ÎFLJONFN

"SLBEBāMBS‘N‘ %PþSVZVEPþSV 4BEFDF #BOBFNBOFU


LPSVNBL TÚZMFNFZF UVUBCJMFDFþJN FEJMFOFāZBMBS‘
JÎJOUBSBGHJS HBZSFUFEFSJN TÚ[àWFSJSJN LPSVSVN
EBWSBONBN

"SLBEBāMBS‘N‘O )BLT‘[M‘L )BLM‘Z‘ ,BSBSWFSJSLFO


WFSEJþJT‘SMBS‘ ZBQNBNBZB  TBWVOVSVN BEBMFUMJ
TBLMBS‘N BEJMEBWSBONBZB EBWSBO‘S‘N
ÎBM‘ā‘S‘N

49
&."/&5#ÿ-ÿ/$ÿ

EK 3

,FOEJMFSJOJO
ZBQNBE‘þ‘CJS 4Ú[WF
7FSEJþJN
āFZJCBāLBMBS‘OB EBWSBO‘āMBS‘NEB
TÚ[MFSJZFSJOF
UBWTJZF UVUBSM‘PMVSVN
HFUJSJSJN
FUNF[MFS
#JMNFEJþJN
½EàOÎBME‘þ‘N LPOVMBSEB
FāZBZ‘[BSBS 0MBZMBS‘ CJMJZPSNVāHJCJ
ÿOTBOMBS‘O BCBSUNBEBO
WFSNFEFO EBWSBONBN
BSLBT‘OEBO PMEVþVHJCJ
LPSVSVN
LPOVāNBN BLUBS‘S‘N
(ÚSEàþàNà
(FSÎFLMFSJ
±‘LBSMBS‘NB PMEVþVHJCJ
TÚZMFNFLZFSJOF
4Ú[UBā‘Z‘Q :BQBNBZBDBþ‘N UFSTEFPMTB BOMBU‘S‘N
CBIBOFMFS
EFEJLPEV āFZMFSJZBQBS‘N HFSÎFLMFSJ
àSFUNFN
ZBQNBN EFNFN TÚZMFNFLUFO
ÎFLJONFN

"SLBEBāMBS‘N‘ #BOBFNBOFU
LPSVNBL %PþSVZVEPþSV 4BEFDF FEJMFOFāZBMBS‘
JÎJOUBSBGHJS TÚZMFNFZF UVUBCJMFDFþJN LPSVSVN
EBWSBONBN HBZSFUFEFSJN TÚ[àWFSJSJN

,BSBSWFSJSLFO
"SLBEBāMBS‘N‘O
BEBMFUMJ
WFSEJþJT‘SMBS‘ )BLT‘[M‘L EBWSBO‘S‘N
TBLMBS‘N ZBQNBNBZBBEJM )BLM‘Z‘
EBWSBONBZB TBWVOVSVN
ÎBM‘ā‘S‘N


&."/&5#ÿ-ÿ/$ÿ

%FþFSMFOEJSNF4PSVMBS‘
&NBOFUJHFOJāPMBSBLEàāàOàSTFL:àDF"MMBI‘OCJ[FWFSEJþJFNBOFUMFSOFMFSEJS
&NBOFUMFSOBT‘MNVIBGB[BFEJMNFMJEJS

(àOàO.FTBK‘
3FTßMJ&LSFN i.àTMàNBO EJMJOEFOWFFMJOEFO
JOTBOMBS‘OTFMBNFUUFPMEVþVLJāJEJS.àNJO
JTFJOTBOMBS‘ODBOMBS‘WFNBMMBS‘LPOVTVOEB
LFOEJMFSJOF[BSBSWFSNFZFDFþJOEFO FNJO
PMEVLMBS‘LJāJEJSwCVZVSNVāUVS
/FTÉÔ ÿNBO 

,BQBO‘ā
(SVQàZFMFSJOFQBZMBā‘NMBS‘JÎJOUFāFLLàSFEJO
)FSLFTJOBLM‘OEBLBMBONFTBK‘QBZMBāNBT‘O‘JTUFZJO
,POVZMBJMHJMJWBSTBTPSVMBS‘O‘BM‘OWFDFWBQMBZ‘O
#JSTPOSBLJLPOVOVOCBāM‘þ‘O‘WFSJOWFWFEBMBā‘O

51
&."/&5#ÿ-ÿ/$ÿ

$"/ ",*- %ÿ/ /&4ÿ-7&


."-&."/&55ÿ3
,B[BO‘N
$BO‘O BLM‘O EJOJO OFTMJOWFNBM‘OFNBOFUPMEVþVOVLBWSBS

½þSFUJDJ/PUV
$BO‘O BLM‘O EJOJOWFNBM‘OFNBOFUPMEVþVWFPOMBS‘LPSVNBN‘[HFSFLUJþJ LJāJOJOLFOEJ
CFEFOJOF[BSBSWFSNFIBLL‘O‘OPMNBE‘þ‘JGBEFFEJMJS"ZS‘DBE‘āBS‘EBOHFMFCJMFDFL[BSBSMBSB
LBSā‘ EB CFEFOJO  DBO‘O LPSVONBT‘ HFSFLUJþJ WVSHVMBO‘S  ĀV IVTVTMBSB EFþJOJMFSFL LPOV
BOMBU‘M‘Si$BO‘N‘[ CFEFOJNJ[ BLM‘N‘[3BCCJNJ[JOCJ[FWFSEJþJCJSFNBOFUUJS.àTMàNBO‘O
FOÚOFNMJÚ[FMMJLMFSJOEFOCJSJEFFNBOFUFSJBZFUUJS½ZMFZTFCJ[EFFNBOFUJZBOJCJ[FWFSJMFO
CFEFOJ  BLM‘ FO Hà[FM āFLJMEF LPSVNBM‘Z‘[ ,FOEJNJ[F [BSBS WFSFDFL EBWSBO‘āMBSEBO V[BL
EVSNBM‘Z‘[w

:ÚOUFNWF5FLOJLMFS
"OMBU‘N 4PSV$FWBQ

&ULJOMJL
ZBā
½þSFUJDJ BāBþ‘EBLJÚSOFþJÎPDVLMBSBPLVSWFCVOVOMBJMHJMJWFSJMFOTPSVMBS‘TPSBS
#JS BSLBEBā‘O‘[ V[VO TàSFMJþJOF āFIJS E‘ā‘OB ΑLBDBþ‘ JÎJO ÎJÎFþJOJ TJ[F FNBOFU FEJZPS
#VÎJÎFLÎPLIBTTBTWFBSLBEBā‘O‘[JÎJOÎPLEFþFSMJ"SLBEBā‘O‘[ÎJÎFþFOBT‘MCBLBDBþ‘O‘[‘
BOMBU‘ZPS ±PL TV WFSJSTFO TPMBS  B[ TV WFSJSTFO LVSVS  EJZF T‘L‘ T‘L‘ UFNCJIMJZPS 4J[ EF
BSLBEBā‘O‘[BPOBJZJCBLBDBþ‘O‘[BEBJSTÚ[WFSJZPSTVOV[
±JÎFþFOBT‘MCBLBST‘O‘[
±JÎFþJOFSFZFLPZBST‘O‘[
#JSJTJÎJÎFþJOZBQSBþ‘O‘LPQBSNBLJTUFTFOBT‘MCJSUFQLJWFSJSTJOJ[
±JÎFþJOTBþM‘LM‘CàZàNFTJJÎJOOFZBQBST‘O‘[

52
&."/&5#ÿ-ÿ/$ÿ

±PDVLMBSEBODFWBQBM‘OE‘LUBOTPOSBÚþSFUJDJāVBΑLMBNBMBS‘ZBQBSi.àNJOJOTBO‘OFO
ÚOFNMJÚ[FMMJþJHàWFOJMJSPMNBT‘E‘S0OFEFOMFCJSJCJ[FHàWFOJQCJSāFZFNBOFUFUUJþJOEFPOB
HÚ[àNà[HJCJCBLNBM‘Z‘[#JS.àTMàNBOBZBL‘āBOEBWSBO‘āBODBLCVEVS#JSBSLBEBā‘N‘[‘O
CJ[FFNBOFUFUUJþJÎJÎFþFCJMFJZJCBLNBZBHBZSFUFEJZPSV[ EFþJMNJ ½ZMFZTF"MMBI‘OCJ[F
FNBOFUFUUJþJDBO‘ CFEFOJ BLM‘WFNBM‘EBLPSVNBZBÎBM‘āNBM‘Z‘[w

%FþFSMFOEJSNF4PSVMBS‘
3BCCJNJ[JOCJ[FFNBOFUJPMBOCVCFEFOFOBT‘MEBWSBONBN‘[HFSFLJS
#FEFOJNJ[FLBSā‘IBOHJNVBNFMFMFSCFEFOFNBOFUJOFI‘ZBOFUPMVS
"MMBIUBSBG‘OEBOCJ[FFNBOFUWFSJMFOCBāLBāFZMFSWBSN‘E‘S BΑLMBSN‘T‘O‘[

(àOàO.FTBK‘
i$BOMBS‘O‘[ NBMMBS‘O‘[ ‘S[MBS‘O‘[CVCFMEF
JÎJOEF CVBZEB CVHàOàOIBSBNM‘þ‘LBEBS
CJSCJSJOJ[FIBSBNE‘Sw
#VIÉSÔ ÿMJN 

,BQBO‘ā
(SVQàZFMFSJOFQBZMBā‘NMBS‘JÎJOUFāFLLàSFEJO
)FSLFTJOBLM‘OEBLBMBONFTBK‘QBZMBāNBT‘O‘JTUFZJO
,POVZMBJMHJMJWBSTBTPSVMBS‘O‘BM‘OWFDFWBQMBZ‘O
#JSTPOSBLJLPOVOVOCBāM‘þ‘O‘WFSJOWFWFEBMBā‘O

53
&."/&5#ÿ-ÿ/$ÿ

½þSFUJDJ/PUV
#J[FFNBOFUPMBSBLWFSJMFO āàLSFUNFNJ[HFSFLFOCFEFO BL‘MWFDBOOJNFUMFSJOJOÚOFNJOF
EJLLBU ÎFLJMJS &NBOFU PMBSBL CJ[F WFSJMFO CJS OFTOFOJO EBIJ [BSBS WFSJMNFEFO HFSJ JBEF
FEJMNFTJ HFSFLJSLFO CFEFOJNJ[F [BSBS WFSNF IBLL‘N‘[‘O BTMB PMNBE‘þ‘ JGBEF FEJMJS #FEFO
HJCJIBZBUEBCJ[MFSFWFSJMFOCJSFNBOFUUJSEFOJMJS IFSOFGFTJOCJSFNBOFUPMEVþVWVSHVMBO‘S
#VLPOVEBÎPDVLMBSEBOÚSOFLWFSNFMFSJUBMFQFEJMJSi"MMBITJ[F FNBOFUMFSJFIMJOFWFSNFOJ[J
WFJOTBOMBSBSBT‘OEBIàLNFUUJþJOJ[[BNBOBEBMFUMFIàLNFUNFOJ[JFNSFEJZPSyw /JTÉ  
BZFUJLFSJNFTJPLVOVMBSBLFULJOMJþFHFÎJMJS

:ÚOUFNWF5FLOJLMFS
)JLÉZF"OMBUNB 4PSV$FWBQ

.BUFSZBMMFS
)JLÉZFNFUOJ

&ULJOMJL
ZBā
½þSFUJDJT‘O‘GBHJSFS±PDVLMBSMBHà[FMCJSIJLÉZFPLVZBDBLMBS‘O‘WFPOVEJLLBUMFEJOMFNFMF
SJOJJTUFEJþJOJTÚZMFSWFIJLÉZFZJPLVNBZBCBāMBS

)JLÉZF
.FINFU CBIBS‘OHFMJāJOFÎPLTFWJONJāUJ)FSZFSZFNZFāJMPMNVāUVWFCJSCJSJOEFOGBSLM‘
SFOLWFHà[FMMJLUFZBSBU‘MBOÎJÎFLMFSJJ[MFEJþJOEFÎPLNVUMVPMVZPSEV.FINFUEPþBEBWB
LJUHFÎJSNFZJ "MMBI‘WF0OVOZBSBUU‘þ‘Hà[FMMJLMFSJ LVMMBS‘OBNFSIBNFUJOJEàāàONFZJÎPL
TFWJZPSEV#VOMBS‘EàāàOFO.FINFUJOBLM‘OBÚþSFUNFOMFSJJMFLPOVāVQCJSQJLOJLEà[FO
MFNFMFSJOJJTUFNFLHFMEJ½þSFUNFOMFSJ JLJIBGUBTPOSBQJLOJþFHJEFCJMFDFLMFSJOJTÚZMFEJWF
CFSBCFSDF JÎFSJTJOEFCàZàLZFNZFāJMBþBÎMBS‘OPMEVþVSFOHBSFOLÎJÎFLMFSMFCF[FMJCJSQJLOJL
BMBO‘OBHJUUJMFS.FINFUJOWFBSLBEBāMBS‘O‘OFOÎPLIPāVOBHJEFOāFZ BþBÎMBSBU‘SNBONBL
PMEV "SLBEBāMBS‘ WF .FINFU ÎPL FþMFOJZPSMBSE‘ BODBL BþBDB U‘SNBONBZB ÎBM‘āBO "MQFSJ 
CBDBLMBS‘OEBO UVUVQ BāBþ‘ZB ÎFLNFMFSJ "MQFSJO BþBÎUBO EàāNFTJOF TFCFQ PMEV  "MQFSJO
CBDBLMBS‘WFTBþLPMV[BSBSHÚSEàWFÚþSFUNFOMFSJ"MQFSJIFNFOCJSTBþM‘LLVSVMVāVOBHFUJS
EJMFS"SLBEBāMBS‘ POVÎFLJāUJSJQWàDVEVOB[BSBSWFSEJLMFSJJÎJOÎPLà[àMNàāMFSEJ"MQFSEFO
Ú[àSEJMFEJMFSBNBOFZB[‘LLJCVPMBZ QJLOJLMFSJOJOZBS‘EBLBMNBT‘OBOFEFOPMEV&SLFOEFO
FWMFSJOFEÚOFO.FINFU "MQFSWF0þV[ÎBM‘āNBPEBMBS‘OBHFÎUJMFS0þV[ .FINFUJOEFGUF
SJOJLBSBMBE‘.FINFUÎPLà[àMEàWFBþMBNBZBCBāMBE‘&SUFTJHàOà[àOUàTàOàÚþSFUNFOJ
JMFQBZMBāNBZBLBSBSWFSEJ½þSFUNFOJ.FINFUJOBE‘O‘WFSNFEFOT‘O‘GPSUBN‘OEBāÚZMFCJS

54
&."/&5#ÿ-ÿ/$ÿ

LPOVāNBZBQU‘i±PDVLMBS "MMBIV5FÉMÉCJ[MFSFCFEFOJNJ[J BLM‘N‘[‘ WJDEBO‘N‘[‘L‘TBDBT‘


IFSāFZJNJ[JJZJ Hà[FMWFEPþSVLVMMBONBN‘[JÎJOWFSNJāUJS&þFSCJ[BLM‘N‘[‘JOTBOMBSB[BSBS
WFSFDFLJāMFSJJDBUFUNFLJÎJOLVMMBO‘STBLCVEPþSVPMNB[ZBEBBSLBEBāMBS‘N‘[B[BSBSWFSJSTFL
CVEVSVN BL‘MWFWJDEBO‘N‘[‘EPþSVLVMMBONBE‘þ‘N‘[‘HÚTUFSJSwEFEJWFEFWBNFUUJi#JS
LÚUàMàþàOIFSLFTF[BSBS‘WBSE‘S½SOFþJOEàOBSLBEBā‘O‘[‘BþBÎUBOCJMFSFLÎFLUJOJ[WFCV
TFCFQMFIFQJOJ[QJLOJþJOJ[JZBS‘EBLFTNFL[PSVOEBLBME‘O‘[ÃTUFMJLWJDEBOFOSBIBUT‘[WF
NVUTV[PMEVOV["ZS‘DBÚ[àOEFJZJPMBOIJÎLJNTFCÚZMFCJSPMBZEBONVUMVPMNB[ PMBNB[w
EJZFSFLIJLBZFZJBOMBUNBZ‘UBNBNMBS7FTPSVDFWBQZPMVZMBT‘O‘GUBLJÚþSFODJMFSJOLBU‘M‘N‘O‘
TBþMBS

%FþFSMFOEJSNF4PSVMBS‘
4J[FFNBOFUPMBSBLWFSJMFOIFSIBOHJCJSOFTOFZJTBIJCJOFTBþMBNCJSāFLJMEFUFTMJN
FUUJþJOJ[EFOFMFSIJTTFEFSTJOJ[
#FEFOJNJ[CJ[FWFSJMFOFOÚOFNMJFNBOFUJTFPOVLPSVNBLJÎJOOFMFSZBQNBM‘Z‘[

(àOàO.FTBK‘
i&ZJNBOFEFOMFS"MMBIBWF1FZHBNCFSF
IBJOMJLFUNFZJO#JMFCJMFLFOEJ BSBO‘[EBLJ 
FNBOFUMFSJOJ[FEFIBJOMJLFUNFZJOw
&OGÉM 

,BQBO‘ā
(SVQàZFMFSJOFQBZMBā‘NMBS‘JÎJOUFāFLLàSFEJO
)FSLFTJOBLM‘OEBLBMBONFTBK‘QBZMBāNBT‘O‘JTUFZJO
,POVZMBJMHJMJWBSTBTPSVMBS‘O‘BM‘OWFDFWBQMBZ‘O
#JSTPOSBLJLPOVOVOCBāM‘þ‘O‘WFSJOWFWFEBMBā‘O

55
&."/&5#ÿ-ÿ/$ÿ

½þSFUJDJ/PUV
#J[FFNBOFUPMBSBLWFSJMFO āàLSFUNFNJ[HFSFLFOCFEFO BL‘MWFDBOOJNFUMFSJOJOÚOFNJOF
EJLLBU ÎFLJMJS &NBOFU PMBSBL CJ[F WFSJMFO CJS OFTOFOJO EBIJ [BSBS WFSJMNFEFO HFSJ JBEF
FEJMNFTJ HFSFLJSLFO CFEFOJNJ[F [BSBS WFSNF IBLL‘N‘[‘O BTMB PMNBE‘þ‘ JGBEF FEJMJS #FEFO
HJCJIBZBUEBCJ[MFSFWFSJMFOCJSFNBOFUUJSEFOJMJS IFSOFGFTJOCJSFNBOFUPMEVþVWVSHVMBO‘S
#VLPOVEBÎPDVLMBSEBOÚSOFLWFSNFMFSJUBMFQFEJMJS

:ÚOUFNWF5FLOJLMFS
4PSV$FWBQ "OMBU‘N

&ULJOMJL
ZBā
½þSFUJDJ ÚODFMJLMFÎPDVLMBSBFNBOFUCJMJODJJMFJMHJMJÚOCJMHJWFSJS"SE‘OEBOTPSVDFWBQ
UFLOJþJZMF i&NBOFU OFEJS  )JÎ FNBOFU CJS FāZB BME‘O‘[ WF JBEF FUUJOJ[ NJ w WT TPSVMBS‘O‘
ZÚOFMUJS #FSBCFS ZBQBDBLMBS‘ BLUJWJUF JTF āV āFLJMEFEJS ±PDVLMBS‘O IFSIBOHJ CJS FāZBMBS‘O‘
BSLBEBāMBS‘JMFEFþJāUPLVāFUNFMFSJWFFNBOFUBME‘LMBS‘CVFāZBZ‘ CJSHàOCPZVODBLPSVNB
MBS‘JTUFOJS±PDVLMBS CVCJSHàOMàLTàSFOJOTPOVOEBFNBOFUBME‘LMBS‘FāZBMBS‘IFSIBOHJCJS
[BSBSBVþSBUNBLT‘[‘OCJSCJSMFSJOFJBEFFEFSMFS½þSFUJDJ FNBOFUFEJMFOFāZBMBS‘OTBþMBNCJS
āFLJMEFTBIJCJOFUFTMJNFEJMEJþJOEFIFSJLJUBSBG‘OEBOFLBEBSNVUMVPMEVþVOPLUBT‘OBEJLLBU
ÎFLFS"ZS‘DBFNBOFUBM‘OBOāFZJO OFLBEBSVGBLPMVSTBPMTVO NVIBGB[BT‘FTOBT‘OEBLJāJOJO
ÚOFNMJCJSTPSVNMVMVþVOBMU‘OBHJSEJþJWVSHVMBO‘S½þSFUJDJCVSBEBOIBSBLFUMFBLM‘O DBO‘O 
EJOJO WJDEBO‘OEB"MMBIUBSBG‘OEBOCJ[MFSFFNBOFUFEJMFOVOTVSMBSPMEVþVOVOBMU‘O‘ÎJ[FS
WFCVOMBS‘OLPSVONBT‘IVTVTVOEBLJIBTTBTJZFUMFSJIBU‘SMBU‘S#FEFOJOLPSVONBT‘O‘OPOBJZJ
CBLBSBLPMBDBþ‘O‘O BLM‘OLPSVONBT‘O‘O POVJZJāFZMFSJOEàāàOàMNFTJOEFLVMMBO‘MBSBLPMB
DBþ‘O‘O‘O WJDEBO‘OLPSVONBT‘O‘OEBJNBHà[FMBIMBL‘ONVIBGB[BT‘ZMBPMBDBþ‘O‘OÚSOFLMFSMF
BOMBU‘N‘OBÎBM‘ā‘S

%FþFSMFOEJSNF4PSVMBS‘
"SLBEBā‘O‘[BFāZBO‘[‘FNBOFUFEFSLFOOFMFSIJTTFUUJOJ[
"SLBEBā‘O‘[EBOFNBOFUFUUJþJOJ[FāZBO‘[‘HFSJBM‘SLFOOFMFSIJTTFUUJOJ[
"SLBEBā‘O‘[EBOFNBOFUBME‘þ‘O‘[FāZBZ‘LPSVNBLWFBME‘þ‘O‘[HJCJHFSJUFTMJNFUNFLOBT‘M
IJTTFUNFOJ[FOFEFOPMEV
(àWFOJMJSPMNBLÚOFNMJNJEJS

56
&."/&5#ÿ-ÿ/$ÿ

(àOàO.FTBK‘
i:JOFPOMBS PNàNJOMFS LJ FNBOFUMFSJOFWF
BIJEMFSJOFVZBSMBSyw
.àNJOßO 

,BQBO‘ā
(SVQàZFMFSJOFQBZMBā‘NMBS‘JÎJOUFāFLLàSFEJO
)FSLFTJOBLM‘OEBLBMBONFTBK‘QBZMBāNBT‘O‘JTUFZJO
,POVZMBJMHJMJWBSTBTPSVMBS‘O‘BM‘OWFDFWBQMBZ‘O
#JSTPOSBLJLPOVOVOCBāM‘þ‘O‘WFSJOWFWFEBMBā‘O

57
&."/&5#ÿ-ÿ/$ÿ

A0.6)"..&%Ã-&.ÿ/%ÿ
,B[BO‘N
1FZHBNCFSJNJ[F.VIBNNFEàM&NJOEFOJMNFTJOJOTFCFQMFSJOJÚSOFLMFSMFBΑLMBS

½þSFUJDJ/PUV
)[.VIBNNFEF TBT QFZHBNCFSMJLWFSJMNFEFOÚODF.FLLFMJMFSUBSBG‘OEBOWFSJMFO
CJS MBLBQUBO CBITFEFSFL CVOVO OF PMBCJMFDFþJ IBLL‘OEB ÎPDVLMBSEBO mLJS ZàSàUNFMFSJ
JTUFOJS %BIB TPOSB .FLLFMJMFSJO )[ 1FZHBNCFSF i.VIBNNFEàM&NJOw EJZFSFL IJUBQ
FUUJLMFSJBOMBU‘M‘S0OVOIFSJāJOEFEPþSV EàSàTUWFHàWFOJMJSPMEVþVOEBO BZS‘DBLFOEJTJOF
OF FNBOFU FEJMJSTF POV FO Hà[FM āFLJMEF LPSVZVQ WBLUJ HFMEJþJOEF TBIJCJOF UFTMJN FUNFTJ
JMFUBO‘OE‘þ‘OEBOCBITFEJMJS)BUUBÿTMBNJZFUJLBCVMFUNFZFONàāSJLMFSJOCJMFPOBFāZBMBS‘O‘
FNBOFU FUUJLMFSJ WVSHVMBO‘S )[ .VIBNNFEJO TBT  IJDSFU FTOBT‘OEB BSE‘OEB )[ "MJZJ
C‘SBLNBTFCFCJOJOLFOEJTJOF.FLLFEFSBIBUWFSNFZJQPOVZVSEVOEBOΑLBSUBONàāSJLMFSJO
FNBOFUMFSJOJZFSJOFUFTMJNFUNFLPMEVþVBOMBU‘M‘S

:ÚOUFNWF5FLOJLMFS
"OMBU‘N

.BUFSZBM
±BM‘āNBLÉþ‘E‘ GPUPLPQJJMFÎPþBMU‘MN‘ā

&ULJOMJL
ZBā
½þSFUJDJZVLBS‘EBWFSJMFOÚSOFþFCFO[FSÚSOFLMFSMFLPOVZBHJSJāZBQ‘Q 1FZHBNCFSJNJ[JO
FNJO WF HàWFOJMJS PMVāVOV POVO IBZBU‘OEBO ÚSOFLMFSMF BOMBUU‘LUBO TPOSB FLUFLJ ÎBM‘āNB
LÉþ‘E‘O‘ÎPDVLMBSBEBþ‘UBSBLLPOVOVOQFLJāNFTJOJTBþMBS

,‘SN‘[‘OPLUBEBOCBāMBZBSBLPLMBS‘UBLJQFU4BLM‘LFMJNFMFSJCVM,VUVDVLMBS‘OJÎJOFZB[

58
&."/&5#ÿ-ÿ/$ÿ

զ +(ɘ, ƻ*ǔȢ(#(

#"Ā-"

D - M N
M

H 6

M
E
Ü E ÿ

59
&."/&5#ÿ-ÿ/$ÿ

%FþFSMFOEJSNF4PSVMBS‘
1FZHBNCFS&GFOEJNJ[JO TBT MBLBC‘OFEJS
ÿOTBOMBSOJÎJO)[.VIBNNFEF TBT i.VIBNNFEàM&NJOwEFNJāMFSEJ

(àOàO.FTBK‘
i/BNB[L‘MNBL EPþSVPMNBL JGGFUMJPMNBL 
TÚ[àOàUVUNBL FNBOFUJZFSJOFUFTMJN
FUNFLyÿāUFCVOMBSCJSQFZHBNCFSJO
Ú[FMMJLMFSJEJSw
#VIÉSÔ ĀFIBEBU 

,BQBO‘ā
(SVQàZFMFSJOFQBZMBā‘NMBS‘JÎJOUFāFLLàSFEJO
)FSLFTJOBLM‘OEBLBMBONFTBK‘QBZMBāNBT‘O‘JTUFZJO
,POVZMBJMHJMJWBSTBTPSVMBS‘O‘BM‘OWFDFWBQMBZ‘O
#JSTPOSBLJLPOVOVOCBāM‘þ‘O‘WFSJOWFWFEBMBā‘O


&."/&5#ÿ-ÿ/$ÿ

&."/&5ÿ,036.",
,B[BO‘N
#BāLBMBS‘O‘OFNBOFUMFSJOJLPSVNBT‘HFSFLUJþJOJCJMJS

½þSFUJDJ/PUV
)V[VSMV CJS UPQMVN JÎJO FNBOFUJ LPSVNBO‘O WF FNBOFU FEJMFCJMJS PMNBO‘O ÚOFNJ
BOMBU‘M‘S &NBOFUF TBIJQ ΑLBCJMFDFL JOTBOMBS‘O CVMVOEVþV CJS UPQMVNVO  HàWFOF EBZBM‘
ZBQ‘T‘ZMBFSEFNMJUPQMVNNPEFMJOJUFNTJMFEFDFþJWVSHVMBO‘S"MMBIV5FÉMÉO‘O NàNJOMFSJO
UFNFM Ú[FMMJLMFSJOJ T‘SBMBSLFO FNBOFUJ LPSVNBZB ZFS WFSJZPS PMEVþVOB BU‘GUB CVMVOVMVS WF
.àNJOßOTVSFTJBZFU[JLSFEJMJSi:JOFPOMBS PNàNJOMFS LJ FNBOFUMFSJOFWFBIJUMFSJOF
SJBZFUFEFSMFSw .àNJOßO 

:ÚOUFNWF5FLOJL
3PM0ZOBNB

.BUFSZBM
"LÉþ‘U

&ULJOMJL
ZBā
½þSFUJDJ PZVOJÎJOHÚOàMMàÎPDVLMBSEBOJLJLJāJTFÎFS#VSBEBÚþSFUJDJ ÎPDVLMBSBFULJOMJþJO
EFWBN‘O‘ BOMBUNBZ‘Q TBEFDF CBāMBOH‘ÎUB CFMJSUJMFO CJMHJMFSJ WFSFDFLUJS #VSBEB ÚþSFUJDJOJO
UFNFMBNBD‘ÎPDVLMBSBFNBOFUMFJMHJMJEVZHVMBS‘ZBāBUNBLU‘S
½þSFUJDJ UBSBG‘OEBO ÎPDVLMBSB ZBQ‘MBDBL BΑLMBNB TBEFDF āVEVS i4J[ JLJ BSLBEBā‘
DBOMBOE‘SBDBLT‘O‘[ ,FOEJOJ[J SPMàOà[F JZJDF WFSNFOJ[J JTUJZPSVN #JSJOJ[JO FMJOEF T‘OBW
CBāWVSVTVZBQNBLJÎJOLVMMBOBDBþ‘ÚOFNMJCJSCFMHFWBS#VCFMHFTFOJOJÎJOÎPLL‘ZNFUMJ 
POVBMNBLJÎJOLBÎHàOEàSVþSBā‘ZPSTVO#VCFMHFEFFOVGBLCJSCVSVāVLMVþVOCJMFPMNBNBT‘
MB[‘N#BāWVSVZBQNBZBHJEFDFLLFOTPOBOEB PEBEBCJSāFZVOVUUVþVOVGBSLFEJZPSTVO
0EBOBEÚOFSLFO FMJOEFLJÚOFNMJGPSNLÉþ‘E‘O‘EJþFSBSLBEBā‘OBFNBOFUPMBSBLC‘SBL‘ZPSWF

61
&."/&5#ÿ-ÿ/$ÿ

Hà[FMDFNVIBGB[BFUNFTJJÎJOPOVUFNCJIMJZPSTVO4POSBEBHFSÎFLUFOCVNFLÉOEBOE‘āBS‘
ΑL‘QLBQ‘Z‘LBQBU‘ZPSTVOWFCFOTFOJÎBþ‘SBOBLBEBSEBJÎFSJHJSNJZPSTVO)BEJCBāMBZBM‘Nw
±PDVLMBSEBOCJSJOJOFMJOFCBāWVSVGPSNVBNBD‘ZMBLVMMBO‘MNBT‘JÎJOCJS"LÉþ‘E‘WFSJMJS
:VLBS‘EB BOMBU‘MBO CJMHJMFS ‘ā‘þ‘OEB ÎPDVLMBS‘O LFOEJ BSBT‘OEB EPþBÎMBNB EJZBMPþB HJSFSFL
SPMFHFÎNFTJJTUFOJS
±PDVLMBSEBOCJSJCBāWVSVGPSNVOVBSLBEBā‘OBFNBOFUFEFSFLNFLÉOEBOE‘āBS‘ΑLBS#V
T‘SBEBÚþSFUJDJ LàÎàLCJSÎPDVLHJCJEBWSBOBSBLSPMZBQBSWFGPSNVFMJOEFUVUBOÎPDVþVOZBO‘OB
HFMJSi"BBCVOF CVOF #BLBZ‘NCJS CVOFZNJā wEFS LÉþ‘E‘ÎFLJāUJSFSFLCVSVāNBT‘OBWFZB
Z‘SU‘MNBT‘OBOFEFOPMVS0FTOBEBLFOEJTJOFFNBOFUC‘SBL‘MBOÎPDVL ÚODFEFOZBāBOBDBLMBS‘
CJMNFEJþJJÎJO ÚþSFUJDJCFLMFONFEJLāFLJMEFÎPDVLUBLMJEJZBQBSBLLÉþ‘E‘ÎFLJāUJSEJþJJÎJO 
āBāL‘OM‘LMB LÉþ‘E‘O CVSVāNBT‘OB WFZB Z‘SU‘MNBT‘OB FOHFM PMBNB[ %‘āBS‘EB CFLMFZFO ÎPDVL
JÎFSJÎBþS‘M‘S C‘SBLU‘þ‘FNBOFUJBSLBEBā‘OEBOJTUFSWFLÉþ‘E‘OLVMMBO‘MNB[IÉMEFPMEVþVOV
HÚSàS #VSBEB ÎPDVLMBSB IJÎCJS NàEBIBMFEF CVMVONBEBO CV IBEJTF HFSÎFLMFāNJā HJCJ
EPþBÎMBNBPMBSBLSPMZBQNBMBS‘JTUFOJSÿLJÎPDVLBSBMBS‘OEBLPOVāVS NFTFMBCJSJEJþFSJOF
i/FEFO FNBOFUJNJ LPSVNBE‘O w EJZF TPSBS EJþFSJ i½[àS EJMFSJN  JTUFNFEFO PMEVw EJZF
EVSVNVBΑLMBNBZBÎBM‘ā‘S
±PDVLMBSCVāFLJMEFCJSB[LPOVāUVLUBOTPOSBÚþSFUJDJEVSNBMBS‘O‘JTUFSWFāVBΑLMBNBZ‘
ZBQBSi"SLBEBāMBS CVPZVOEBCJ[LJNIBLM‘LJNTVÎMVCVOVOà[FSJOEFEVSNVZPSV[;BUFO
LBT‘UM‘CJSEVSVNZPL:BOM‘āM‘LMBPMNVāCJSIBEJTFWBS#VSBEBCJ[JNJÎJOÚOFNMJPMBOAFNBOFU
FEFOWFALFOEJTJOFFNBOFUFEJMFOPMBSBLOFIJTTFUUJþJNJ[EJSw

%FþFSMFOEJSNF4PSVMBS‘
,Éþ‘E‘FNBOFUC‘SBLBOPMTBZE‘O‘[ CVEVSVNEBOFIJTTFEFSEJOJ[
,FOEJTJOFFNBOFUC‘SBL‘MBOPMTBZE‘O‘[OFIJTTFEFSEJOJ[
,‘ZNFUMJCJSFāZBO‘[PMTBLJNFFNBOFUFEFSTJOJ[ OBT‘MEBWSBO‘MNBT‘O‘CFLMFSTJOJ[

62
&."/&5#ÿ-ÿ/$ÿ

(àOàO.FTBK‘
iÿNBOJIBOFUJCBþMBN‘āU‘S.àNJO 
JIBOFUFUNF[w
&CV%ÉWVE $JIBE 

,BQBO‘ā
(SVQàZFMFSJOFQBZMBā‘NMBS‘JÎJOUFāFLLàSFEJO
)FSLFTJOBLM‘OEBLBMBONFTBK‘QBZMBāNBT‘O‘JTUFZJO
,POVZMBJMHJMJWBSTBTPSVMBS‘O‘BM‘OWFDFWBQMBZ‘O
#JSTPOSBLJLPOVOVOCBāM‘þ‘O‘WFSJOWFWFEBMBā‘O

63
&."/&5#ÿ-ÿ/$ÿ

½þSFUJDJ/PUV
&NBOFU LFMJNFTJOJO QFL ÎPL BOMBNEB LVMMBO‘ME‘þ‘ JGBEF FEJMFSFL FNBOFUJO JÎFSJþJ
BΑLMBO‘SÿOTBO‘O HFSFL"MMBIB HFSFLTFCVMVOEVþVUPQMVNBWFIBUUBJOTBOM‘þBLBSā‘HÚSFW
WF TPSVNMVMVLMBS‘OEBO  HFÎJDJ CJS TàSF ZBO‘OEB C‘SBL‘MBO FāZBZB WBS‘ODBZB LBEBS IFQTJOF
FNBOFUEFOJMEJþJJGBEFFEJMJS
.àNJO HàWFOJMJSWFFNBOFUJLPSVZBOJOTBOE‘S:àDF"MMBI‘O DD i0OMBSFNBOFUMFSJOF
WF WFSEJLMFSJ TÚ[MFSF SJBZFU FEFSMFSw .àNJOßO    CVZVSEVþV WF LVSUVMVāB FSFDFL
NàNJOMFSJ OBT‘M WBT‘nBOE‘SE‘þ‘ [JLSFEJMJS "ZS‘DB .àTMàNBO WF NàNJO UBSJnFSJOJ FNBOFU
HàWFOJMJSMJL T‘GBU‘Ú[FMJOEFZBQBO"MMBI3FTßMàOàO NàNJOMFSFIBOHJāBSUMBSEBPMVSTBPMTVO
FNJO HàWFOJMJS PMNBMBS‘O‘UFMLJOFUUJþJWVSHVMBO‘S

:ÚOUFNWF5FLOJL
3PM0ZOBNB "OMBU‘N

.BUFSZBM
0LVNBZBQSBþ‘ TFNCPMJLZB[‘M‘T‘OBWLÉþ‘E‘

&ULJOMJL
ZBā
½þSFUJDJPZVOJÎJOHÚOàMMàÎPDVLMBSEBOJLJLJāJTFÎFS½þSFUJDJTFÎUJþJÎPDVLMBSEBOCJSJOJO
NBUFNBUJLÚþSFUNFOJEJþFSJOJOJTFÚþSFODJPMBDBþ‘O‘CFMJSUJS±PDVLMBSLFOEJBSBMBS‘OEBIBOHJ
LBSBLUFSJDBOMBOE‘SBDBþ‘OBLBSBSWFSJS½þSFUJDJÎPDVLMBS‘OJLJTJOFEFPLVNBZBQSBþ‘O‘WFSJS
WFLÉþ‘UUBZB[BOIJLÉZFZJDBOMBOE‘SNBMBS‘O‘JTUFS

64
&."/&5#ÿ-ÿ/$ÿ

0,6.":"13"ý*
½þSFODJ 0LVMVOLPSJEPSVOEBJÎJOEFOCVDàNMFMFSJHFÎJSJS
1FSāFNCF HàOà NBUFNBUJL EFSTJOEFO T‘OBW‘N WBS 4BEFDF  HàO LBME‘ /F
ZBQBDBþ‘NCFO .BUFNBUJLUFOÎPLJZJBOMBN‘ZPSVN1SPCMFNMFSJEBIBJZJÎÚ[FO
CJS BSLBEBā‘NEBO EFTUFL BMNBM‘Z‘N #JSB[EBO UFOFGGàT CJUNFL à[FSF  T‘O‘GUB
ZFSJNFHFÎFZJN
0T‘SBEBNBUFNBUJLÚþSFUNFOJOJHÚSàS
½þSFUNFOJN½þSFUNFOJN
.BUFNBUJL½þSFUNFOJ.FSIBCBOBT‘MT‘O 4‘OBWBIB[‘SN‘T‘O
½þSFODJĀFZy:BOJIB[‘SMBONBZBÎBM‘ā‘ZPSVNÚþSFUNFOJN
.BUFNBUJL½þSFUNFOJ&MMFSJNLJUBQMBSWFEPTZBMBSMBEPMV ÎBOUBN‘UBā‘NBLUB
[PSMBO‘ZPSVN½þSFUNFOMFSPEBT‘OBLBEBSCBOBZBSE‘NFEFCJMJSNJTJO
½þSFODJ5BCJLJZBSE‘NFEFSJN
.BUFNBUJL½þSFUNFOJ5FāFLLàSMFS
½þSFUNFOCVT‘SBEBBZS‘M‘SCBāLBZÚOFEPþSVJMFSMFS
½þSFODJ½þSFUNFOJNFMJOEFLJMFSJCBOBFNBOFUFUUJ CVEPTZBMBS‘ÚþSFUNFOMFS
PEBT‘OEBLJEPMBC‘OBZFSMFāUJSNFNJJTUFEJ½þSFUNFOJNJOFāZBMBS‘O‘UBā‘NBLCFOJ
ÎPLNVUMVFUNJāUJ CBOBFāZBMBS‘O‘WFSFDFLLBEBSHàWFONFTJHVSVSWFSJDJJEJ
½þSFODJLJUBQMBS‘EPMBCBZFSMFāUJSJSLFOCJSāFZGBSLFEFS
½þSFODJ"BB%PTZBO‘Oà[FSJOEFCJ[JNT‘O‘G‘ONBUFNBUJLT‘OBWTPSVMBS‘ZB[‘ZPS
&USBGUB EB LJNTFMFS ZPL  TÚZMFEJLMFSJNJ EVZBO PMNBE‘ ;JIOJNEF JLJ TBIOF
DBOMBOE‘4PSVLBþ‘UMBS‘OEBOCJSJOJBMTBN T‘O‘G‘OFOÎBM‘āLBO‘PMBOBSLBEBā‘NB
ÎÚ[EàSTFN ZB[‘M‘EBO  QVBO BMBCJMJSEJN WF CV NBUFNBUJLUFO BME‘þ‘N FO
ZàLTFL OPU PMVSEV "NB CVOV ZBQBSTBN IFN LFOEJNJ IFN EF ÚþSFUNFOJNJ
LBOE‘SN‘ā PMVSEVN 4POVÎUB ÚþSFUNFOJN FNBOFUMFSJOJ UFTMJN FEFDFL LBEBS
HàWFONJāUJ CBOB ÃTUFMJL BMBDBþ‘N OPUV EB IBL FUNFNJā PMBDBLU‘N 0G JÎJN
T‘L‘ME‘CÚZMFEàāàOàODFy
:B EB ÚþSFUNFOJNJO CBOB PMBO HàWFOJOJ CPāB ΑLBSNBZBDBL  CV TPSVMBSB IJÎ
CBLNBZBDBLWFHFSÎFLUFOIBLFUUJþJNOPUVBMBDBLU‘N
1FLJāJNEJCVJLJTBIOFEFOIBOHJTJOJZBQNBM‘Z‘N

½þSFODJCVTPSVZVTPSEVLUBOTPOSBÚþSFUJDJÎPDVLMBSBEÚOFSWFCVIVTVTàTUàOEF
mLJSMFSJOJ BM‘S  FO TPOVOEB FNBOFUJ LPSVNBO‘O .àTMàNBO PMNBO‘O ÚOFNMJ CJS WBTG‘
PMEVþVIVTVTVOVWVSHVMBZBSBLEFSTJCJUJSJS

65
&."/&5#ÿ-ÿ/$ÿ

%FþFSMFOEJSNF4PSVMBS‘
½þSFODJOJOZFSJOEFTJ[PMTBZE‘O‘[JLJEVSVNEBOIBOHJTJOJUFSDJIFEFSEJOJ[
&NBOFUJOFEFOLPSVNBM‘Z‘[

(àOàO.FTBK‘
i"MMBITJ[FFNBOFUMFSJFIMJOFWFSNFOJ[JWF
JOTBOMBSBSBT‘OEBIàLNFUUJþJOJ[WBLJUBEBMFUMF
IàLNFUNFOJ[JFNSFEJZPS"MMBITJ[FOFLBEBS
Hà[FMÚþàUWFSJZPSĀàQIFTJ["MMBIIFSāFZJ
JāJUFOWFHÚSFOEJSw
/JTÉ 

,BQBO‘ā
(SVQàZFMFSJOFQBZMBā‘NMBS‘JÎJOUFāFLLàSFEJO
)FSLFTJOBLM‘OEBLBMBONFTBK‘QBZMBāNBT‘O‘JTUFZJO
,POVZMBJMHJMJWBSTBTPSVMBS‘O‘BM‘OWFDFWBQMBZ‘O
#JSTPOSBLJLPOVOVOCBāM‘þ‘O‘WFSJOWFWFEBMBā‘O

66
&."/&5#ÿ-ÿ/$ÿ

,".6."-*&."/&55ÿ3
,B[BO‘N
,BNVNBM‘O‘OFNBOFUPMEVþVOVCJMJSWFPOVLPSVS

½þSFUJDJ/PUV
ÿOTBOMBS‘O PSUBL JTUJGBEFTJOF TVOVMNVā  JIUJZBÎ PMEVþVOEB CàUàO CJSFZMFSJO LVMMBO‘N
BNBD‘OBIJ[NFUFEFOLBNVNBMMBS‘O‘OLVMMBO‘N‘O‘OEPþSVWFBIMBLM‘CJSUVUVNJÎFSJTJOEF
HFSÎFLMFāUJSJMNFTJHFSFLUJþJBOMBU‘M‘S,BNVNBM‘O‘LPSVNBO‘OUPQMVNTBMCJSLVSBMPMNBT‘O‘O
ZBO‘ T‘SB  BIJSFU CJMJODJOF TBIJQ JOTBOMBS‘O Ú[FMMJLMF EJLLBU FUNFTJ HFSFLFO CJS EBWSBO‘ā
PMEVþVWVSHVMBO‘S,BNVIBLWFIVLVLVOB[BSBSWFSNFOJOUFMBmFEJMFNFZFDFLCPZVUMBS‘O‘O
CVMVOEVþVCFMJSUJMJS,BNVNBM‘O‘OFNBOFUPMEVþVWFPOVLFOEJNBM‘N‘[HJCJLPSVNBN‘[
HFSFLUJþJ BOMBU‘M‘S ,BNV NBM‘OB [BSBS WFSNFOJO LVM IBLL‘O‘ JIMBM FUNF BOMBN‘OB HFMFDFþJ
JGBEFFEJMJS

:ÚOUFNWF5FLOJLMFS
½SOFL0MBZÿODFMFNFTJ

.BUFSZBM
½SOFLPMBZNFUOJ

&ULJOMJL
ZBā
Örnek Olay Metni
i.FSIBCB HFOÎMFS  CFO CJS PUPCàT EVSBþ‘Z‘N A0UPCàT EVSBLMBS‘ EB LPOVāVS NV  CJ[
ÎPDVL NVZV[  TFO LJNJ LBOE‘S‘ZPSTVO  EFNFZJO MàUGFO #JS EVSBþ‘O LPOVāNBT‘ EFþJM 
BOMBUBDBLMBS‘NÚOFNMJ(àOMFSEFOCJSHàO EVSBLUBCFLMFZFOJLJÎPDVLZBSBNB[M‘LT‘O‘S‘O‘
BāU‘MBSWFÎBOUBMBS‘OEBOΑLBSE‘LMBS‘LBMFNMFPUPCàTIBSFLFUTBBUMFSJOJOZB[E‘þ‘MFWIBO‘Oà[FSJOJ
LBSBMBE‘MBS/BT‘MTJOJSMFOEJN OBT‘ML‘[E‘NBOMBUBNBN%VSVOÎPDVLMBS OFZBQ‘ZPSTVOV[
EJZFDFLPMEVN EJZFNFEJN.BMVNEVSBLMBSLPOVāBNB[0ZTBCFOEFIFSLFTJOFNFþJWBSE‘ 

67
&."/&5#ÿ-ÿ/$ÿ

CFOEFWMFUJOJOTBOMBSEBOBME‘þ‘WFSHJMFSMFZBQ‘MN‘āCJSEVSBLU‘N)FSLFTJOCFOJLFOEJNBM‘O‘
LPSVSHJCJLPSVNBT‘HFSFLJSEJ&SUFTJHàOCBā‘NBHFMFOMFSJTFEBIBGFOBZE‘0HàOJLJCàZàL
UBL‘N‘OGVUCPMNBΑWBSN‘ā#VBSBEBCFOJNCVMVOEVþVNDBEEFTUBEZVNBÎPLZBL‘O#J[JN
DBEEFUVUUVþVUBL‘N‘OGPSNBT‘O‘HJZNJāJOTBOMBSMBEPMEVUBāU‘#BāUBFþMFODFMJZEJIFSāFZIFQ
CJSMJLUF [‘QM‘ZPSMBS  āBSL‘MBS  NBSāMBS TÚZMàZPSMBSE‘ /BT‘M PMEV BOMBNBE‘N CJS BOEB PSUBM‘L
LBS‘āU‘ÿLJUBL‘N‘OUBSBGUBSMBS‘LBSā‘LBSā‘ZBHFMNJā FMMFSJOFHFÎFOIFSāFZJCJSCJSMFSJOFBUNBZB
CBāMBN‘āMBSE‘#FOEFOBTJCJNJBME‘NFMCFU,PDBNBOCJSUBāUBWBO‘NBHFMEJ ÎPLDBO‘NBD‘E‘ 
CBZBTBST‘ME‘N UBWBO‘NÎBUMBN‘āU‘ĀJEEFUUàNI‘[‘ZMBEFWBNFEJZPSEV#VDVSDVOBEBCFOJN
PUVSBLL‘TN‘NEB[BSBSHÚSNàāUà#JSB[TPOSBQPMJTPMBZBNàEBIBMFFUUJ PSUBM‘LTBLJOMFāUJ
BNBCFOJNIÉMJNIBSBQU‘#Bā‘NBþS‘ZPS JÎJNBD‘ZPSEV&SUFTJHàOIFSāFZOPSNBMFEÚONàā 
JāMFSJOF FSLFO HJEFOMFS ZBO‘NB HFMNFZF CBāMBN‘āMBSE‘ #V T‘SBEB CJS HFOÎ HFMEJ  PUPCàTàO
LBML‘āTBBUMFSJOFCBLNBLJTUFEJBNBCVMFWIBO‘OLBSBMBON‘āPMEVþVOVHÚSEà.FNOVOJZFUTJ[
CJSZà[JGBEFTJZMFLFOEJLFOEJOFTÚZMFOEJ"[TPOSBCJSBEBN‘OLPMVOBHJSNJāZBāM‘CJSBNDB
HFMEJ &MJOEF CBTUPO PMBO BNDBO‘O  FMMFSJ UJUSJZPS  BZBLUB [PS EVSVZPSEV "NDBZ‘ PUVSBþB
PUVSUNBLJTUFEJMFSBNBEàOLàPMBZEBCFOJNPUVSBþ‘NUBISJQPMNVāUV:BāM‘BNDBPUVSBNBE‘ 
UJUSFZF UJUSFZF BZBLUB CFLMFNFL [PSVOEB LBME‘  ÎPL à[àMEàN ÿMFSMFZFO TBBUMFSEF OF PMEV
CJMJZPSNVTVOV[ :BþNVS G‘SU‘OBCBāMBE‘ÿOTBOMBSEVSBþ‘OBMU‘OBT‘þ‘ONBZBHFMEJMFSBNBCV
IJÎCJSJāFZBSBNBE‘±àOLàEàOUBWBO‘NÎBUMBN‘āU‘ ZBþNVSTVZVEVSBþ‘OJÎJOFBL‘ZPSEV
ÿāUFCÚZMFHFOÎMFSÿLJHàOEàSOBT‘MEFSUMJZJN OBT‘Mà[àOUàMàZàN4J[JOMFEFSEJNJQBZMBā‘Q
CJSB[SBIBUMBNBLJTUFEJNw

%FþFSMFOEJSNF4PSVMBS‘
,BNVNBM‘OBCBāLBÚSOFLMFSWFSJSNJTJOJ[ 
,BNVNBM‘JMFFNBOFUJMJāLJTJOJBΑLMBZ‘O‘[
,BNVNBM‘JMFLVMIBLL‘BSBT‘OEBLJJMJāLJZJBΑLMBZ‘O‘[

68
&."/&5#ÿ-ÿ/$ÿ

(àOàO.FTBK‘
i,BNVNBM‘OEBOCJSāFZÎBMBO‘O ÎBME‘þ‘
NBML‘ZBNFUHàOàCJSVUBOÎU‘SWFÎBMBO
POVBUFāPMBSBLLBSā‘T‘OEBCVMBDBLU‘Sw
ÿCO.ÉDF $JIBE 

,BQBO‘ā
(SVQàZFMFSJOFQBZMBā‘NMBS‘JÎJOUFāFLLàSFEJO
)FSLFTJOBLM‘OEBLBMBONFTBK‘QBZMBāNBT‘O‘JTUFZJO
,POVZMBJMHJMJWBSTBTPSVMBS‘O‘BM‘OWFDFWBQMBZ‘O
#JSTPOSBLJLPOVOVOCBāM‘þ‘O‘WFSJOWFWFEBMBā‘O

69
&."/&5#ÿ-ÿ/$ÿ

½þSFUJDJ/PUV
,BNVNBM‘O‘OOFPMEVþVWFOFMFSJOLBNVNBM‘PMBCJMFDFþJÎPDVLMBSMBLPOVāVMVS,BNV
NBMMBS‘O‘OÚOFNJWFCJ[JNIBZBU‘N‘[‘OFLBEBSLPMBZMBāU‘SE‘þ‘à[FSJOEFEVSVMVSWFCVOMBS‘O
IFSLFTJOPSUBLNBM‘PMEVþVOBWVSHVZBQ‘M‘S

:ÚOUFNWF5FLOJLMFS
3PM0ZOBNB &þJUTFM0ZVO

.BUFSZBM
,‘SN‘[‘ NBWJ TBS‘ UVSVODV ZFāJMSFOLMFSEFLBSUPO

3FOLMJLBSUMBST‘O‘GUBLJÎPDVLTBZ‘T‘ODBÎPþBMU‘MNBM‘E‘S
,‘SN‘[‘,BU‘MN‘ZPSVN
:FāJM,BU‘M‘ZPSVN
4BS‘,BSBST‘[‘N
5VSVODV,‘TNFOLBU‘M‘ZPSVN
.BWJ#JSmLSJNWBS āÚZMFEFPMBCJMJS
NBOBT‘OBHFMNFLUFEJS

&ULJOMJL
ZBā
½þSFUJDJ ÎPDVLMBSBiĀJNEJTJ[JOMFCJSFULJOMJLZBQBDBþ‘[wEFS#VLBSUMBS‘OIFSSFOHJOEFO
ÎPDVLMBSBCJSFSUBOFEBþ‘U‘S,POVāNBZBQBDBLÎPDVLJÎJOCJSLPOVāNBLàSTàTàIB[‘SMBO‘S
,BNVNBM‘O‘LPSVNBWFLBNVNBM‘OB[BSBSWFSNFJMFBMBLBM‘ZÚOFSHFMFSCJSUBSU‘āNBCBāMBUBDBL
āFLJMEFÚODFEFOÚþSFUJDJUBSBG‘OEBOIB[‘SMBOBCJMFDFþJHJCJ mLSJOJTÚZMFNFLJTUFZFOÎPDVLMBS
EBLàSTàZFΑL‘QLPOVāBCJMJS#VFULJOMJLJÎJOPSUBNCJSNFDMJTPMBSBLLBCVMFEJMJS&MMFSJOEF
IFS SFOLUFO LBSUMBS CVMVOBO ÎPDVLMBS EB NJMMFUWFLJMJ PMVS A,BNV NBMMBS‘O‘ LPSVNB BEM‘
PUVSVNJÎJOJTUFZFOCJSÎPDVLLPOVāNBLàSTàTàOFΑLBS,POVāNBD‘PMBOÎPDVLÚþSFUJDJOJO
WFSEJþJZÚOFSHFMFSJPLVZBCJMFDFþJHJCJLFOEJmLSJOJEFTÚZMFZFCJMJS.JMMFUWFLJMJPMBOÎPDVLMBS
EB TÚZMFOFO ZÚOFSHFMFS EPþSVMUVTVOEB LFOEJ mLJSMFSJOJ CFMJSUNFL JÎJO FMMFSJOEFLJ LBSUMBS‘
LBME‘SBSBLCVmLSFLBU‘M‘QLBU‘MNBE‘LMBS‘O‘CFMJSUJSMFS
,BNVNBMMBS‘O‘LPSVNBWFPOMBSB[BSBSWFSNFJMFBMBLBM‘ZÚOFSHFMFS
%FOJ[MFSIFSLFTJOPSUBLNBM‘E‘SWFCJ[FFNBOFUUJS CVZà[EFOEFOJ[MFSJUFNJ[UVUNBN‘[
HFSFLJS
 %FOJ[MFS IFSLFTJO PSUBL NBM‘ZTB CFO EF JTUFEJþJN HJCJ LVMMBONB IBLL‘OB TBIJCJN 
LPDBNBOEFOJ[ ÎÚQMFSJEFBM‘QHÚUàSFCJMJS


&."/&5#ÿ-ÿ/$ÿ

0SNBOMBSCJSàMLFOJOBLDJþFSMFSJEJS POMBS‘LFOEJNFOGBBUJNJ[JÎJOIPSLVMMBOBNBZ‘[ 
PSNBOEBBUFāZBLBNBZ‘[ BþBÎLFTFNFZJ[
 0SNBOMBS IFSLFTJO PSUBL NBM‘ZTB CFO EF JTUFEJþJN HJCJ NFOGBBU FMEF FEFCJMJSJN 
‘T‘ONBLJÎJOPEVOUFNJOFEFCJMJSJN
ÿOTBOMBSEFþFSMJNBEFOFMEFFEFCJMNFLJÎJOJTUFEJþJHJCJLB[‘WFÎBM‘āNBZBQBCJMJS
"WMBONBLCFOJNFOTFWEJþJNIPCJN.VUMVPMNBLJÎJOIFSIBZWBO‘BWMBNBIBLL‘OB
TBIJCJN
:PMMBS‘ QBSLWFCBIÎFMFSJ QJLOJLBMBOMBS‘O‘ TQPSTBIBMBS‘O‘JTUFEJþJNHJCJLVMMBOBCJMJS 
ZFSMFSFÎÚQBUBCJMJSJN#VSBMBS‘OZBQ‘N‘WFCBL‘N‘JÎJOCFMFEJZFMFSCJ[EFOWFSHJBM‘ZPS
4PLBþ‘N‘ PLVMVNV DBNJNJUFNJ[UVUNBM‘Z‘N CVOMBSCJ[FCJSFSFNBOFUUJS JOTBOMBSB
[BSBSWFSNFZFIBLL‘NZPL
½þSFUJDJ UàNCVZÚOFSHFMFSà[FSJOEFÎPDVLMBS‘OmLJSMFSJOJCFZBOFUNFTJOFJNLÉOUBO‘S
WFFULJOMJL EFþFSMFOEJSNFTPSVMBS‘JMFTPOBFSFS

%FþFSMFOEJSNF4PSVMBS‘
,BNVNBM‘OFEFNFLUJS
,BNVNBMMBS‘O‘OJÎJOLPSVNBN‘[HFSFLNFLUFEJS
,BNVNBMMBS‘OB[BSBSWFSNFOJOUPQMVNBΑT‘OEBOOFHJCJTBL‘ODBMBS‘WBSE‘S

71
&."/&5#ÿ-ÿ/$ÿ

(àOàO.FTBK‘
i#JSCJSJOJ[JONBMMBS‘O‘IBLT‘[ZFSF
ZFNFZJOw
#BLBSB 

,BQBO‘ā
(SVQàZFMFSJOFQBZMBā‘NMBS‘JÎJOUFāFLLàSFEJO
)FSLFTJOBLM‘OEBLBMBONFTBK‘QBZMBāNBT‘O‘JTUFZJO
,POVZMBJMHJMJWBSTBTPSVMBS‘O‘BM‘OWFDFWBQMBZ‘O
#JSTPOSBLJLPOVOVOCBāM‘þ‘O‘WFSJOWFWFEBMBā‘O

72
&."/&5#ÿ-ÿ/$ÿ

½þSFUJDJ/PUV
ÿOTBOMBS‘O PSUBL JTUJGBEFTJOF TVOVMNVā  JIUJZBÎ PMEVþVOEB CàUàO CJSFZMFSJO LVMMBO‘N
BNBD‘OBIJ[NFUFEFOLBNVNBMMBS‘O‘OLVMMBO‘N‘O‘OEPþSVWFBIMBLM‘CJSUVUVNJÎFSJTJOEF
HFSÎFLMFāUJSJMNFTJHFSFLUJþJBOMBU‘M‘S,BNVNBM‘O‘LPSVNBO‘OUPQMVNTBMCJSLVSBMPMNBT‘O‘O
ZBO‘ T‘SB BIJSFU CJMJODJOF TBIJQ JOTBOMBS‘O Ú[FMMJLMF EJLLBU FUNFTJ HFSFLFO CJS EBWSBO‘ā
PMEVþVWVSHVMBO‘S,BNVIBLWFIVLVLVOB[BSBSWFSNFOJOUFMBmFEJMFNFZFDFLCPZVUMBS‘O‘O
CVMVOEVþVCFMJSUJMJS,BNVNBM‘O‘OFNBOFUPMEVþVWFPOVLFOEJNBM‘N‘[HJCJLPSVNBN‘[
HFSFLUJþJ BOMBU‘M‘S ,BNV NBM‘OB [BSBS WFSNFOJO LVM IBLL‘O‘ JIMBM FUNF BOMBN‘OB HFMFDFþJ
JGBEFFEJMJS

:ÚOUFNWF5FLOJLMFS
"OMBU‘N ½SOFL0MBZÿODFMFNFTJ

.BUFSZBM
½SOFLPMBZNFUOJ

&ULJOMJL
ZBā
½þSFUJDJ ÎPDVLMBSBBāBþ‘EBWFSJMFO i)[½NFSJO.VNVwJTJNMJL‘TTBZ‘PLVS

);½.&3ÿ/.6.6
#JSHFDF)[½NFSNBLBN‘OEBJLFOZBO‘OBBSLBEBāMBS‘OEBOCJSJHFMJS4FMBNWFSJQPUVSVS
GBLBUTFMBN‘BM‘ONB[)[½NFSJāJZMFNFāHVMEàSWFCFLMFS4BIBCJOJOZà[àOFCBLNBZBO)[
½NFSJāJOJCJUJSJQNVNVTÚOEàSàSCJSCBāLBNVNZBLBSWFTPOSBBSLBEBā‘O‘OTFMBN‘O‘BM‘S
"SLBEBā‘āBā‘S‘S/FEFOÚODFZBOBONVNVTÚOEàSàQEJþFSNVNVZBLU‘þ‘O‘TPSBS)[½NFS
i%FNJOEFWMFUJāJZBQ‘ZPSEVN.VNEBEFWMFUJONBM‘JEJ½[FMJāMFSJNJPNVNMBZBQBNB[E‘N
0NVNEFWMFUJOQBSBT‘JMFBM‘OE‘0OVOJÎJOTÚOEàSàQLFOEJNVNVNVZBLU‘Nw
½þSFUJDJCVIJLÉZFZJBOMBUU‘LUBOTPOSBBāBþ‘EBLJTPSVMBS‘ÚþSFODJMFSFZÚOFMUJS
)[½NFSOJÎJOCÚZMFEBWSBON‘āU‘S
;PSEVSVNEBPMTBO‘[ZBMBOTÚZMFNFLTJ[JLVSUBS‘SN‘
#BāLBMBS‘O‘OÚ[FMIBZBU‘O‘BSBāU‘S‘QMBLBQUBLNBLCJ[FCJSāFZLB[BOE‘S‘SN‘
,FOEJNJ[FZBQ‘MNBT‘O‘JTUFNFEJþJNJ[CJSEBWSBO‘ā‘CBāLBT‘OBZBQBSN‘Z‘[
ÿOTBOMBSB[BSBSWFSNFL TÚ[JMFmJMJMF LVMIBLL‘E‘SQFLJÎFWSFZFWFEJþFSDBOM‘MBSB[BSBS
WFSNFLLVMIBLL‘OBHJSFSNJ
½þSFUJDJCVTPSVMBSJMFLPOVZVJ[BIFEJQLVMIBLL‘OBTBZH‘HÚTUFSJMNFEJþJOEFCJSFZWF
UPQMVNVOHÚSFDFþJ[BSBSMBS‘BOMBU‘S

73
&."/&5#ÿ-ÿ/$ÿ

%FþFSMFOEJSNF4PSVMBS‘
,BNVNBM‘OB[BSBSWFSNFLWFLVMIBLL‘BSBT‘OEBLJJMJāLJZJBΑLMBZ‘O‘[
,BNVNBMMBS‘O‘LPSVNBO‘OHFMFDFLOFTJMMFSJÎJOÚOFNJWBSN‘E‘S

(àOàO.FTBK‘
i,JNJCJSJāUFHÚSFWMFOEJSJQ ZBQU‘þ‘JāJO
LBSā‘M‘þ‘PMBSBL CJSàDSFUWFSEJZTFL POVO
CVàDSFUE‘ā‘OEBBMBDBþ‘IFSāFZ LBNVZB 
IBJOMJLUJSw
&CV%ÉWVE ÿNBSF 

,BQBO‘ā
(SVQàZFMFSJOFQBZMBā‘NMBS‘JÎJOUFāFLLàSFEJO
)FSLFTJOBLM‘OEBLBMBONFTBK‘QBZMBāNBT‘O‘JTUFZJO
,POVZMBJMHJMJWBSTBTPSVMBS‘O‘BM‘OWFDFWBQMBZ‘O
#JSTPOSBLJLPOVOVOCBāM‘þ‘O‘WFSJOWFWFEBMBā‘O

74
SABIR

13SABIR

i4BC‘SwLBWSBN‘O‘CJMJS
i4BC‘SwWFiUBIBNNàMwLBWSBNMBS‘BSBT‘OEBLJGBSL‘CJMJS
4BCSFUNFOJOÎBCBJÎFSFOBLUJGCJSTàSFÎPMEVþVOVCJMJS
5FWFLLàMàOCJSTBC‘SFZMFNJPMEVþVOVCJMJS
SABIR

1. SABIR KAVRAMI
,B[BO‘N
i4BC‘SwLBWSBN‘O‘CJMJS
4BCSFUNFOJOÎBCBJÎFSFOBLUJGCJSTàSFÎPMEVþVOVCJMJS

½þSFUJDJ/PUV
4BC‘SLBWSBN‘CJSāFZJCFLMFSLFONFWDVULPāVMMBSBEBZBOBCJMNF LFOEJOJUVUNB CFLMFS-
LFOPMVNTV[EàāàONFNFWFEBZBONBHàDàPMBSBLBΑLMBO‘S,BWSBN‘OÎBM‘āLBOM‘L HBZSFU-
MJMJL LBSBSM‘M‘L UFWFLLàM NFUBOFU JTUJLSBS VNVU B[JN TFCBU ÎBCB JUBBUHJCJLBWSBNMBSMB
JMHJTJOFWVSHVZBQ‘M‘S4BCS‘OHFOFMMJLMFCFLMFOFOCJSEVSVNLBSā‘T‘OEBEBZBO‘LM‘ NàUFWB[J
WFHBZSFUMJPMNBZBJāBSFUFUUJþJBΑLMBO‘S)[&ZZVCVOTBCS‘OTFNCPMàPMBSBLBMH‘MBOE‘þ‘OEBO
CBITFEJMFSFLPOVOCVLPOVEBLJÚSOFLMJþJOJBOMBUBOi&OCJZÉwWFi4ÉEwTVSFTJOJOJMHJMJBZFUMFSJ
JāMFOJS

:ÚOUFNWF5FLOJLMFS
&þJUTFM0ZVO "OMBU‘N 4PSV$FWBQ

&ULJOMJL
ZBā
½þSFUJDJ EFSTFIFS[BNBOLJOEFOPOEBLJLBHFÎHFMFDFþJOJIBCFSWFSJS7FTBC‘SMBCFLMF-
NFMFSJEVSVNVOEBLFOEJMFSJOFCJSTàSQSJ[ZBQBDBþ‘O‘TÚZMFS(FMEJþJOEFFMJOEFCJSLVUVZBā
QBTUB WBSE‘S 1BTUBZ‘ VZHVO CJS ZFSF C‘SBL‘S 4FMBN WFSFSFL JÎFSJ HJSFS (FDJLNFEFO EPMBZ‘
à[HàOPMEVþVOVJGBEFFEFS
#VEFSTiTBC‘SwLPOVTVIBLL‘OEBLPOVāBDBLMBS‘O‘ CVOVOJÎJOHÚOàMMààÎÎPDVþVOZB-
O‘OBHFMNFTJOJJTUFS½þSFUJDJBāBþ‘EBLJUBCMPEBLJPMBZL‘TN‘O‘TÚZMFSÿMLÎPDVþBi/FIJTTF-
EFSEJO wEJZFTPSBSÿLJODJÎPDVþBi/FZBQBSE‘O wEJZFTPSBSÃÎàODàÎPDVLUBOEPþSVPMBO
EBWSBO‘āWFEàāàODFZJCVMNBT‘O‘JTUFS

76
SABIR

"āBþ‘EBLJUBCMPEBHFMFCJMFDFþJEàāàOàMFODFWBQMBSWFSJMNJāUJS#VEPþSVMUVEBÎPDVLMBS‘O
HÚSàāàJMFLFOEJUBCMPOV[VPMVāUVSVOV[
#JSEF#VSBEBO#BL5BCMPTV

0MBZ /F /FZBQBSE‘O %PþSVEBWSBO‘ā


IJTTFEFSEJO EàāàODF
.VUTV[PMEVþVN 5FEBWJNJOEà[HàO
6[VOTàSFO #‘LL‘OM‘L JÎJOFUSBG‘NEBLJ ZBQ‘MNBT‘JÎJO
CJS Ã[àOUà TBþM‘LM‘JOTBOMBSBTFSU EPLUPSLPOUSPMMFSJNJ
1.GRUP

BLTBUNB[E‘N
IBTUBM‘þB EBWSBOBCJMJSEJN %PLUPSVOJTUFEJþJ
ZBLBMBOE‘O 0OMBS‘L‘TLBOBCJMJSEJN  UFEBWJZÚOUFNMFSJOJ
OFEFOCFOJNCBā‘NB VZHVMBSE‘N
HFMEJEJZF"MMBIBāJLBZFU ĀJLBZFUFUNF[ 
FEFCJMJSEJN TBCSFEFSTFNTFWBQ
LB[BOBDBþ‘NBJOBO‘SE‘N
)JÎJZJMFāFNFZFDFþJNJ
"MMBIUBOàNJEJNJ
EàāàOàSEàN LFTNF[ UFWFLLàM
FEFSEJN
#FOEFPOBLÚUàTÚ[ "SLBEBā‘N‘O
#JS ½GLF TÚZMFSEJN TBLJOMFāNFTJJÎJO[BNBO
BSLBEBā‘O ĀJEEFU 0OBFMLBME‘SNBL WFSJSEJN
2.GRUP

TBOB Ã[àOUà JTUFSEJN 0OVOMBLPOVāVS 


LÚUàTÚ[ #JSEBIBPOVOMB CVEBWSBO‘ā‘
BSLBEBāM‘LZBQNB[E‘N UFLSBSMBNBNBT‘O‘
TÚZMFEJ
)FNFOCàZàLMFSJNF JTUFSEJN
āJLBZFUFEFSEJN

ÿÎJNFLBQBO‘SE‘N "SLBEBāFEJONFLJÎJO
Ã[àOUà #FOJLJNTFTFWNJZPS ÎBCBHÚTUFSJSEJN
0LVMEB ,‘[H‘OM‘L EJZFEàāàOàSWFCFOEF
3.GRUP

CJSBSLBEBā ÃNJUTJ[MJL POMBS‘TFWNFNFZFLBSBS *ÿOTBOMBS‘OJMHJTJOJ


,‘TLBOÎM‘L WFSJSEJN ÎFLFDFLLPOVMBSEBO
FEJOFNFEJO CBITFEFSEJN
)JÎCJS[BNBO
BSLBEBā‘NPMNBZBDBþ‘O‘
EàāàOàSEàN

4‘L‘M‘SE‘N ½þSFUNFOJNJOTÚ[àOEF
4J[FTÚ[ (àWFOTJ[MJL %FSTPMNBZBDBþ‘O‘ EVSBDBþ‘OBJOBO‘SE‘N
WFSEJþJN 4BC‘ST‘[M‘L EàāàOàSEàN
4.GRUP

WBLJUUF 4BC‘SMBCFLMFNFZF
#BāLBCJSJāMF EFWBNFEFSEJN
HFMNF VþSBāNBZBCBāMBSE‘N
TFZEJN

77
SABIR

½þSFUNFOIFSTPSVJÎJOBZS‘HSVQPMVāUVSVS 
i4FWHJMJÎPDVLMBS CBā‘N‘[BHFMFOPMVNTV[EVSVNMBSBTBCSFUNFLÎPLHà[FMCJSEBWSBO‘āU‘S
7FCVOVOLBSā‘M‘þ‘OEB"MMBINVIBLLBLCJSNàLÉGBUWFSFDFLUJS#VHàOCFOJTBC‘SMBCFLMFEJ-
þJOJ[JÎJOCFOJNEFTJ[FCJSTàSQSJ[JNWBSwEFSWFIFQCJSMJLUFQBTUBZJZFSFLTBC‘Sà[FSJOF
TPICFUFEFSMFS
±PDVLMBSMBCJSMJLUFi"TSwTVSFTJWFBOMBN‘PLVOBSBLEFSTTPOMBOE‘S‘M‘S

%FþFSMFOEJSNF4PSVMBS‘
i4BC‘SwLBWSBN‘IBLL‘OEBOFEàāàOàZPSTVOV[
4BCSFUNFOJOLJāJZFGBZEBMBS‘OFMFSEJS
i4BCSFEFOMFSF NàLÉGBUMBSIFTBQT‘[WFSJMJSw ;àNFS  BZFUJOEF
BOMBU‘MNBLJTUFOFOEàāàODFOFEJS

(àOàO.FTBK‘
i"MMBI TBCSFEFOMFSMFCFSBCFSEJSw
#BLBSB 

,BQBO‘ā
(SVQàZFMFSJOFQBZMBā‘NMBS‘JÎJOUFāFLLàSFEJO
)FSLFTJOBLM‘OEBLBMBONFTBK‘QBZMBāNBT‘O‘JTUFZJO
,POVZMBJMHJMJWBSTBTPSVMBS‘O‘BM‘OWFDFWBQMBZ‘O
#JSTPOSBLJLPOVOVOCBāM‘þ‘O‘WFSJOWFWFEBMBā‘O

78
SABIR

4"#*37&5")"..Ã-
,B[BO‘N
i4BC‘SwWFiUBIBNNàMwLBWSBNMBS‘BSBT‘OEBLJGBSL‘CJMJS

½þSFUJDJ/PUV
4BC‘S  LÚUà WF ÎJSLJO JāMFSMF NàDBEFMFZJ JÎFSFO BLUJG CJS TàSFÎ  UBIBNNàM JTF LÚUàMàþF
TFTTJ[LBMNBZ‘JÎFSFOQBTJGCJSTàSFÎPMBSBLJ[BIFEJMJS4BC‘S IFSUàSMàFOHFMFSBþNFO‘TSBSMB
IBLL‘TBWVONBL "MMBIJÎJOEPþSVPMBO‘ZBQNBLUBEJSFONFLUBIBNNàMJTF[VMàNWFBEBMFU-
TJ[MJLCJMFPMTBGBSLM‘OFEFOMFSEFO ÎFāJUMJCFLMFOUJMFSEFOEPMBZ‘CJS[PSMVþVUBā‘NBL àTUFTJO-
EFOHFMNFZFVþSBāNBLPMBSBLJ[BIFEJMJS

:ÚOUFNWF5FLOJLMFS
&þJUTFM0ZVO

.BUFSZBMMFS
#BSEBL UFQTJ TàSBIJ

&ULJOMJL
ZBā
½þSFUJDJ CJSJLàÎàLEJþFSJCàZàLJLJCBSEBLJTUFS#BSEBLMBS‘CJSUFQTJZFLPZBS#JSTàSBIJ
JMFIFSJLJTJOFEFTVEPMEVSVS#BSEBLMBSEPMEVþVIBMEFTVEÚLNFZFEFWBNFEFS ±PDVLMBS‘O
UFQLJWFSNFTJOJCFLMFS )FSJLJCBSEBLUBOGB[MBT‘ZMBTVUBāBS±PDVLMBS‘ONFSBLM‘CBL‘āMBS‘
LBSā‘T‘OEB
i,BQBTJUFTJOEFOGB[MBTVEPMEVSEVNEFþJMNJ wEFS
,àÎàLPMBOCBSEBLÚODFUBāU‘ CàZàLPMBOEBIBTPOSBUBāU‘BNBTPOVÎUBIFSJLJTJEFUBāU‘
#FOEPMEVSNBZBEFWBNFEFSLFOTJ[OFEFOCJSEFOUFQLJWFSEJOJ[
#VTPSVMBS‘ODFWBQMBS‘à[FSJOEFLPOVāVSMBS½þSFUJDJUBIBNNàMFUNFOJOCB[‘T‘L‘OU‘WF
[PSMVLMBSBLBUMBONBLPMEVþVOVWFIFSJOTBO‘OCJSUBIBNNàMT‘O‘S‘PMEVþVOV CVT‘O‘S‘Bā-
NBNBLHFSFLUJþJOJJGBEFFEFS"ODBLTBCS‘OEJSFOÎHÚTUFSNFL HBZSFUFUNFL IÉMJOEFOSB[‘
PMNBLWFTPOVOEBFTFOMJþFLBWVāNBLPMEVþVOVBOMBU‘S

79
SABIR

"āBþ‘EBLJUBCMPZVÚSOFLUFLJLBSUMBSIBMJOEFIB[‘SMBSWFÎPDVLMBSBEBþ‘U‘SĀVāFLJMEFi/FTJ
WBS wPZVOVPZOBSMBS

i/FTJ WBS w PZVOVOEB CJS LJāJ FCF TFÎJMEJLUFO TPOSB  EJþFSMFSJ IFQ CJSMJLUF TBC‘S
WFUBIBNNàMLBSUMBS‘OEBOCJSFSUBOFTFÎFSMFS&CFIFSÎPDVþBT‘SBZMBi/FTJWBS wEJZF
TPSBSBL  BME‘þ‘ EPMBZM‘ ZBO‘UMBSMB BSLBEBā‘O‘O FMJOEFLJ LBSU‘O TBC‘S N‘ UBIBNNàM Nà
PMEVþVOVBOMBNBZBÎBM‘ā‘S4BC‘SLBSU‘TFÎUJþJOJWBSTBZBM‘N

&CFTPSBS/FTJWBS
,JāJi4‘O‘S‘WBSwCJMCBLBM‘NOFEJS
&CFi5")"..Ã-wEJZFSFLLJNJOLBSU‘OBEPþSVDFWBQWFSJSTF PLJāJFCFPMVSWF
PZVOCÚZMFEFWBNFEFS&CFOJOCJMFNFNFTJEVSVNVOEB FCFMJþJTàSFS

4BC‘SWFUBIBNNàMBSBT‘OEBLJGBSLMBS‘HÚTUFSFOLBSUMBSUBCMPEBLJCJMHJMFSEPþSVMUVTVOEB
IB[‘SMBOBDBLU‘S

SABIR 5")"..Ã-

(":3&57"3%*3 Āÿ,¬:&57"3%*3

Ã.ÿ57"3%*3 Ã.ÿ54ÿ;-ÿ,7"3%*3

5&7&,,Ã-7"3%*3 ÿ4:"/7"3%*3

ĀÃ,Ã37"3%*3 .&./6/ÿ:&54ÿ;-ÿ,7"3%*3

",5ÿ'-ÿ,7"3%*3 1"4ÿ'-ÿ,7"3%*3

%ÿ3&/±7"3%*3 :*-(*/-*,7"3%*3

%&7".&%&/#ÿ34Ã3&±5ÿ3 4*/*3*7"3%*3


SABIR

%FþFSMFOEJSNF4PSVMBS‘
i4BC‘SwWFiUBIBNNàMwLBWSBNMBS‘TJ[FOFJGBEFFEJZPS
i4BC‘SwWFiUBIBNNàMwBSBT‘OEBLJGBSLMBSOFMFSEJS
4J[IBZBU‘O‘[EBTBC‘SHÚTUFSNFZFNJZPLTBUBIBNNàMHÚTUFSNFZFNJHBZSFUFEJZPSTVOV[ 

(àOàO.FTBK‘
i)JÎLJNTFZFTBC‘SEBOEBIBIBZ‘SM‘WFEBIB
CàZàLCJSOJNFUWFSJMNFNJāUJSw
#VIÉSÔ ;FLÉU 

,BQBO‘ā
(SVQàZFMFSJOFQBZMBā‘NMBS‘JÎJOUFāFLLàSFEJO
)FSLFTJOBLM‘OEBLBMBONFTBK‘QBZMBāNBT‘O‘JTUFZJO
,POVZMBJMHJMJWBSTBTPSVMBS‘O‘BM‘OWFDFWBQMBZ‘O
#JSTPOSBLJLPOVOVOCBāM‘þ‘O‘WFSJOWFWFEBMBā‘O

81
SABIR

½þSFUJDJ/PUV
4BCS‘OBD‘ ZPLTVMMVL IBLT‘[M‘LWCà[àDàEVSVNMBSLBSā‘T‘OEBTFTΑLBSNBEBOPOMBS‘O
HFÎNFTJOJCFLMFNFFSEFNJ PMBDBLWFZBHFMFDFLCJSāFZJUFMBāHÚTUFSNFEFOCFLMFNFPMEVþV
J[BIFEJMJS%BZBONBJTFLBME‘SNB LBUMBONBPMBSBLUBO‘NMBO‘S4BC‘SWFUBIBNNàMBSBT‘OEBLJ
GBSLMBSJ[BIFEJMJS

:ÚOUFNWF5FLOJLMFS
"OMBU‘N 4PSV$FWBQ

&ULJOMJL
ZBā
½þSFUJDJ ÎPDVLMBSBiĀJNEJTJ[JOMFCJSFULJOMJLZBQBDBþ‘[wEFS±PDVLMBS‘OÎFNCFSāFLMJO-
EFZBOZBOBPUVSNBMBS‘O‘TBþMBS½þSFUJDJ ÎPDVLMBSBCJSIJLÉZFPLVZBDBþ‘O‘TÚZMFSWFÎPDVL-
MBSEBOIJLÉZFZJÎPLEJLLBUMJEJOMFNFMFSJOJJTUFS)JLÉZFEFOTPOSBLFOEJMFSJOFTPSVZÚOFMUF-
DFþJOJCFMJSUJS
i"MJWF7FMJJLJ[LBSEFāMFSEJ0SUBPLVMEBPLVZPSMBSE‘"MJWF7FMJNBUFNBUJLEFSTJOJBOMB-
NBEB[PSMBO‘ZPSMBSE‘
"MJA.BUFNBUJLEFSTJOJNVUMBLBBOMBNBM‘Z‘N#VEFSTJBOMBNBLJÎJOOFHFSFLJZPSTBZBQ-
NBM‘Z‘N.BUFNBUJLEFSTJOEFCBāBS‘M‘PMBOBSLBEBāMBS‘NEBOEBZBSE‘NBMBCJMJSJN½þSFOEJ-
þJNLPOVMBSEBÎPLÎBQSPCMFNÎÚ[NFMJZJNLJLPOVJZJDF[JIOJNFZFSMFāTJO±Ú[FNFEJþJN
TPSVMBS‘UFOFGGàTUFÚþSFUNFOJNFTPSBCJMJSJNEJZFEàāàOàZPSEV
%FSTJBOMBNBTFWJZFTJBZO‘PMBOJLJ[LBSEFāJ7FMJJTFA.BUFNBUJLEFSTJOFLBEBSEB[PS
/BT‘MHFÎFDFþJNCVEFSTJCJMNJZPSVNLJ (FÎFDFLOPUVBMTBNZFUFSCBOBEJZFEàāàOàZPS-
EVw
#ÿ-#","-*.4"#*3.*5")"..Ã-.Ã
"MJNBUFNBUJLEFSTJOJÚþSFONFLJÎJOFMJOEFOHFMFOHBZSFUJHÚTUFSNFLUFEJSyyy
7FMJNBUFNBUJLEFSTJOJÚþSFOJSLFOTàSFLMJāJLÉZFUFUNFLUFEJSyyy
7FMJNBUFNBUJLEFSTJOJÚþSFOJSLFOāJLÉZFUFUUJþJJÎJOCVEFSTJÚþSFONFZFLBSā‘CJSàNJU-
TJ[MJþJWBSE‘Syyy
"MJOJONBUFNBUJLEFSTJOJÚþSFONFLJÎJOHÚTUFSEJþJHBZSFUTFCFCJZMFCVEFSTJÚþSFOFDFþJ-
OFEBJSàNJEJWBSE‘Syyy
"MJNBUFNBUJLEFSTJOJÚþSFONFLJÎJOFMJOEFOHBMFOHBZSFUJHÚTUFSEJþJJÎJOCBāBS‘CBāBS‘T‘[-
M‘LLBSā‘OEBUFWFLLàMHÚTUFSNFLUFEJSyyy
7FMJNBUFNBUJLEFSTJOJāJLÉZFUFEFSFLÚþSFOEJþJJÎJOIFSIBOHJCJSCBāBS‘T‘[M‘LEVSVNVOEB
IFNFOJTZBOFUNFLUFEJSyyy
7FMJNBUFNBUJLEFSTJOJāJLÉZFUFEFSFLÚþSFOEJþJJÎJOCBāBS‘CBāBS‘T‘[M‘LEVSVNVOEBCJS
NFNOVOJZFUTJ[MJþJWBSE‘Syyy
"MJNBUFNBUJLEFSTJOJÚþSFONFLJÎJOFMJOEFOHFMFOHBZSFUJHÚTUFSEJþJJÎJOCBāBS‘EVSV-
NVOEBāàLSFEFSyyy

82
SABIR

"MJNBUFNBUJLEFSTJOJÚþSFOFCJMNFLJÎJOBLUJGCJSāFLJMEFÎBM‘āNBLUBE‘Syyy
7FMJNBUFNBUJLEFSTJOJÚþSFONFLJTUFNFEJþJJÎJOQBTJGEBWSBONBLUBE‘Syyy
7FMJ NBUFNBUJL EFSTJOJ TFWNFEJþJ JÎJO CV EFSTJ ÚþSFONFZF LBSā‘ CJS Z‘MH‘OM‘L TFSHJMFS
yyy
"MJNBUFNBUJLEFSTJOJÚþSFONFLJÎJOEJSFOÎMJCJSāFLJMEFFMJOEFOHFMFOHBZSFUJHÚTUFSJS
yyy
"MJNBUFNBUJLEFSTJOJÚþSFOFCJMNFOJOEFWBNFEFOCJSTàSFÎPMEVþVOVOCJMJODJOEFEJS
yyy
7FMJ NBUFNBUJL EFSTJOJ TFWNFEJþJ JÎJO CV EFSTJ ÚþSFONF LPOVTVOEB CJS T‘O‘S‘ WBSE‘S
yyy

%FþFSMFOEJSNF4PSVMBS‘
4BC‘SWFUBIBNNàMBSBT‘OEBLJGBSLMBS‘TÚZMFZFCJMJSNJTJOJ[
)BZBU‘O‘[EBOCJSTBC‘SÚSOFþJWFSFCJMJSNJTJOJ[
4J[DFUBIBNNàMJOTBO‘ZPSBSN‘

(àOàO.FTBK‘
i&ZJNBOFEFOMFS4BC‘SWFOBNB[MB"MMBIUBO
ZBSE‘NJTUFZJOĀàQIFTJ["MMBITBCSFEFOMFSMF
CFSBCFSEJSw
#BLBSB 

,BQBO‘ā
(SVQàZFMFSJOFQBZMBā‘NMBS‘JÎJOUFāFLLàSFEJO
)FSLFTJOBLM‘OEBLBMBONFTBK‘QBZMBāNBT‘O‘JTUFZJO
,POVZMBJMHJMJWBSTBTPSVMBS‘O‘BM‘OWFDFWBQMBZ‘O
#JSTPOSBLJLPOVOVOCBāM‘þ‘O‘WFSJOWFWFEBMBā‘O

83
SABIR

&/#Ã:Ã,5&7&,,Ã-4"#*3
,B[BO‘N
5FWFLLàMàOCJSTBC‘SFZMFNJPMEVþVOVCJMJS

½þSFUJDJ/PUV
4BCS‘OIFSCBāBS‘Z‘FMEFFUNFLJÎJOCàZàLCJSIB[JOFPMEVþVUFWFLLàMàOJTFLJāJOJOZBQ-
NBT‘HFSFLFOJZBQU‘LUBOTPOSBTPOVDVOV"MMBIBC‘SBLBSBL0OBHàWFONFTJPMEVþVJ[BIFEJ-
MJS,JāJOJOFMJOEFOHFMFOÎBCBZ‘HÚTUFSNFEFOCFLMFNFTJOJOUFWFLLàMPMNBE‘þ‘BΑLMBO‘S

:ÚOUFNWF5FLOJLMFS
"OMBU‘N 4PSV$FWBQ

&ULJOMJL
ZBā
½þSFUJDJTFMBNWFSFSFLJÎFSJHJSFS½þSFODJMFSFIÉMIBU‘STPSEVLUBOTPOSB ÚþSFODJMFSFZB[
UBUJMJ JÎJO LÚZF HJEFO "INFUJO IJLÉZFTJOJ BOMBUBDBþ‘O‘ TÚZMFS WF LFOEJTJOJ ÎPL EJLLBUMJDF
EJOMFNFMFSJOJJTUFS
"INFUJO5FWFLLàMà½þSFONFTJ
"INFUBE‘OEBBL‘MM‘N‘BL‘MM‘CJSÎPDVLWBSE‘"INFU ZB[UBUJMJOJHFÎJSNFLJÎJOEFSFMFSJO
BLU‘þ‘ BþBÎMBS‘OÎFāJUÎFāJUNFZWFWFSEJþJ IPSP[MBS‘OÚUUàþàāJSJONJāJSJOCJSLÚZFÎJGUÎJBN-
DBT‘O‘OZBO‘OBHJUNJāUJ
"INFU CVHà[FMLÚZFIBZSBOLBMN‘āU‘±JGUÎJBNDBT‘OB
i±JGUÎJBNDBCFOEFTJ[JOMFUBSMBZBHFMFCJMJSNJZJN wEJZFTPSEV±JGUÎJBNDBJTF"INFUJO
ZPSVMNBT‘O‘IJÎJTUFNJZPSEV"INFUJFOHà[FMāFLJMEFNJTBmSFUNFLJTUJZPSEV,FOEJTJZMF
CFSBCFS"INFUJUBSMBZBHÚUàSEà
"INFUÎJGUÎJOJOUBSMBZBLBSOBCBIBSWFIBWVÎUPIVNMBS‘FLUJþJOJHÚSEà)FZFDBOMBTFTMFOEJ
i±JGUÎJBNDBD‘þ‘N/FMFSZBQ‘ZPSTVOV[ #FOEFTJ[JOHJCJZBQBCJMJSNJZJN #FOUPQSBþ‘
ÎPLTFWFSJN-àUGFO CFOEFZBQBCJMJSNJZJN w

84
SABIR

±JGUÎJBNDB"INFUJOIFZFDBO‘O‘HÚSEà"INFUJOCBā‘O‘PLāBE‘WFLFOEJTJOFZBSE‘NFU-
NFTJJÎJOPOBJ[JOWFSEJ
±JGUÎJTNDBWF"INFUCFSBCFSDFUPIVNFLFSMFSLFO ÎJGUÎJBNDB
i#BL"INFUÎJþJN5PIVNMBS‘FLJZPSV[4VJMFTVMVZPSV[#BL‘NMBS‘O‘ZBQ‘ZPSV[;BNBO‘
HFMEJþJOEFEFUPIVNMBS‘OmMJ[MFONFTJOJCFLMJZPSV[#J[ÎBM‘ā‘ZPSV[±BM‘āU‘LUBOTPOSB"MMBIB
EBZBO‘QCFLMJZPSV[ÿāUFCVUFWFLLàMEàS"MMBI DD CJ[JNÎBCBMBS‘N‘[TPOVOEBCJ[FJL-
SBNMBSEBCVMVOVZPS&þFSCFOÎJGUÎJMJLZBQNBTBZE‘N UPIVNFLNFEFO"MMBIBHàWFOTFZEJN
CVSBEBTFC[FMFSNFZWFMFSIJÎZFUJāJSNJZEJ w
"INFU i:FUJāNF[EJ ÎJGUÎJ BNDBD‘þ‘N ĀJNEJ "MMBIB EBZBONBO‘O OF EFNFL PMEVþVOV
BOMBE‘NA"MMBIOFHà[FMWFLJMEJZPSTVOV[IFQyÿāMFSJNJ[J0OBC‘SBL‘ZPSV[EFZJODFCFO
EFIJÎCJSāFZZBQN‘ZPSV[TBON‘āU‘N0[BNBOCFOEFSTMFSJNFÎBM‘āNBM‘ "MMBIBUFWFLLàM
FUNFMJ T‘OBWTPOVDVNJZJHFMEJþJOEF"MMBIBUFāFLLàSFUNFMJZJN½ZMFEFþJMNJ w
±JGUÎJBNDBi"GFSJO"INFU ÎPLEPþSVTÚZMFEJO"MMBIBUFWFLLàMFUNFOJOOFEFNFLPM-
EVþVOVBOMBE‘O(FMIBZEJ#àUàOUPIVNMBS‘CJUJSFMJNWFTFOJOMFPZVOPZOBZBM‘Nw
±JGUÎJBNDBWF"INFUÎPLNVUMVPMNVāMBSE‘"INFUIFS[BNBOUàNHBZSFUJZMFFMJOEFO
HFMFOJZBQU‘LUBOTPOSBTPOVDV"MMBIBC‘SBLNBT‘HFSFLUJþJOJ CÚZMFDFUFWFLLàMFUNJāPMBDB-
þ‘O‘ÚþSFONJāUJ


զ +(ɘ, ƻ*ǔȢ(#(

#VMBM‘N)BOHJTJUFWFLLàMEàS 5FWFLLàMJTF   JāBSFULPZBM‘N


%FþJMJTF Y JāBSFUJLPZBM‘N

&MJNEFOHFMFOFO &WFI‘ST‘[HJSNFNFTJJÎJO
Hà[FMSFTNJÎJ[EJNWF LBQ‘N‘LJMJUMFSJN
ZBS‘āNBZBLBU‘ME‘N
4POVDVCFLMJZPSVN

4‘OBW‘NJÎJOEFSTJNJ )BWVÎUPIVNVOVOFLJMFDFþJ
ÎBM‘ā‘S IB[‘SCFLMFSJN UPQSBL‘T‘T‘EFSFDFPMNBM‘E‘S
5PIVNVNVOHà[FMΑLNBT‘JÎJO
P‘T‘EBFLNFMJZJN yy

%JāMFSJNJOÎàSàNFNFTJ
JÎJOIFSHàOEJāMFSJNJ
#PZBNBZBQBS‘N
G‘SÎBMBS‘N

)BTUBMBOE‘þ‘N[BNBO 6ZVNBLJÎJO
EPLUPSBHJEFSJN QJKBNBMBS‘N‘HJZFSJN
ÿMBÎMBS‘N‘JÎFS CFLMFSJN

86
SABIR

%FþFSMFOEJSNF4PSVMBS‘
"INFU ÎJGUÎJBNDBEBOOFZJÚþSFOEJ
"INFUUFWFLLàMIBLL‘OEBEBIBÚODFEFOOFZJCJMJZPSEV
#VPLVNBNFUOJOEF"INFUUPIVNVUPQSBþBFLUJ TVMBE‘ CFMJSMJCJSTàSFCFLMFNFTJ
HFSFLUJþJOJÚþSFOEJ4J[JOEFIBZBU‘O‘[EB "INFUHJCJFMJOJ[EFOHFMFOJZBQ‘QTPOVDVOV
"MMBIUBOCFLMFEJþJOJ[ÚSOFLMFSWBSN‘

(àOàO.FTBK‘
iy,BSBS‘O‘WFSEJþJO[BNBOEBBSU‘L"MMBIB
UFWFLLàMFU±àOLà"MMBI LFOEJTJOFEBZBO‘Q
HàWFOFOMFSJTFWFSw
¬MJÿNSÉO 

,BQBO‘ā
(SVQàZFMFSJOFQBZMBā‘NMBS‘JÎJOUFāFLLàSFEJO
)FSLFTJOBLM‘OEBLBMBONFTBK‘QBZMBāNBT‘O‘JTUFZJO
,POVZMBJMHJMJWBSTBTPSVMBS‘O‘BM‘OWFDFWBQMBZ‘O
#JSTPOSBLJLPOVOVOCBāM‘þ‘O‘WFSJOWFWFEBMBā‘O

87
SABIR

½þSFUJDJ/PUV
%FST i½þSFUJDJ/PUVwEJLLBUFBM‘OBSBLJāMFOJS

:ÚOUFNWF5FLOJLMFS
"OMBU‘N 4PSV$FWBQ

&ULJOMJL
ZBā
½þSFUJDJWFÎPDVLMBSiTBC‘SwWFiUFWFLLàMwLBWSBNMBS‘IBLL‘OEBCJSTàSFTPICFUFEFSMFS
½þSFUJDJ BāBþ‘EBLJIJLÉZFZFÚODFEFOIB[‘SMBON‘āPMBSBLHFMJS ÎPDVLMBSMBÎFNCFSāFLMJOEF
PUVSVSMBSWFIJLÉZFZJBOMBU‘S
i'BLJSHFOÎCJSBEBNHFDFMFZJOLVMàCFTJOEFVZVSLFOCàZàLCJSHàSàMUàZMFVZBOE‘%‘āBS‘
ΑLU‘ CJSEFOFHÚSTàO CBIÎFLBQ‘T‘O‘OÚOàOEFLPDBNBOCJSLBZBWBS7FPLBZBPSBEBPMEVþV
NàEEFUÎFCBIÎFTJOFHJSNFTJJNLÉOT‘[#àUàOHFDFLBZBZ‘PSBEBOOBT‘MLBME‘SBDBþ‘O‘EàāàO-
Eà4BCBIPMVODBPSBEBOHFÎNFLUFPMBOCJSZPMDVPOVOIÉMJOJHÚSàODFA(FDFHàOEà[ÎBM‘āBDBL
WFCBIÎFOJOÚOàOEFLJCàZàLLBZBZ‘CàUàOHàDàOMFJUFDFLTJO)JÎWBLJULBZCFUNFIFNFOJāF
LPZVMEFEJ
(FOÎBEBNZBQBDBLCBāLBCJSāFZPMNBE‘þ‘O‘BOMBZ‘ODBLBZBZ‘JUNFZFCBāMBE‘%BIBFS-
UFTJHàOWFJ[MFZFOIBGUBMBSy(àOFāJOEPþVāVOEBOCBU‘ā‘OBLBEBSUBā‘JUUJEVSEV"ZMBSTàSFO
VþSBā‘T‘SBT‘OEBLBZBZFSJOEFOCJMFL‘N‘MEBNBE‘
 "EBN HFDF LVMàCFTJOF ZPSHVO BSH‘O EÚOFSLFO  HàOMFSJOJO CPāB HFÎUJþJOJ EàāàOàZPSEV
BSU‘LĀFWLJL‘S‘ME‘ LBMCJOFWFTWFTFMFSHFMNFZFCBāMBE‘ JÎJOEFOCJSTFT
A/FLBEBS[BNBOE‘SCVLBZBZ‘JUJQEVSVZPSTVO CJSNJMJNCJMFL‘N‘MEBNBE‘,FOEJOFCV-
OVOJÎJOOJZFZB[‘LFEJZPSTVO 0OVZFSJOEFOPZOBUNBO[BUFONàNLàOEFþJMEJZPSEV
#ÚZMFDF  HFODF LBZBZ‘ PZOBUNBO‘O JNLÉOT‘[ PMEVþV  EPMBZ‘T‘ZMB CBāBS‘T‘[M‘þB VþSBE‘þ‘
EVZHVTVZFSMFāNFZFCBāMBE‘
#VUàSEàāàODFMFSPOVOāFWLJOJEBIBEBL‘SE‘WFàNJEJOJHJUHJEFZJUJSEJ
A%PþSVZB LFOEJNJCVJāJÎJOOJZFQBSBM‘ZPSVNLJ EJZFLFOEJLFOEJTJOFTÚZMFOEJA#VO-
EBO TPOSB B[‘D‘L CJS LVWWFU IBSDBZBDBþ‘N #V EB ZFUFS EF BSUBS CJMF ,PDB LBZB ZFSJOEFO
L‘N‘MEBNBZBDBþ‘OBHÚSF
7FLBSBS‘O‘EVBT‘OEB"MMBIBCJMEJSEJA"MMBI‘N V[VO[BNBOE‘SEVSNBEBOEJOMFONFEFO
NàDBEFMFFUUJN#àUàOHàDàNMFFMJNEFOHFMFOIFSāFZJZBQU‘N)FSHàOZPSVMVZPSVN BNB
LBZBZ‘CJSNJMJNCJMFL‘N‘MEBUBN‘ZPSVN/FEFOCÚZMF /FEFOCBāBSBN‘ZPSVN 
#àUàOHFDFVZVNBEBOEàāàOEàA6[VO[BNBOÚODFCVLBZBZ‘JUNFZFCBāMBE‘N(ÚSFWJN
LBZBZ‘CàUàOHàDàNMFJUNFLUJWFCFOEFZBQN‘āU‘N0OVZFSJOEFOPZOBUNBLCFOJNWB[JGFN
EFþJMEJĀJNEJJTFHàDàNàOUàLFOEJþJOJ CBāBS‘T‘[M‘þBVþSBE‘þ‘N‘TÚZMàZPSVN)ÉMCVLJLPM-

88
SABIR

MBS‘NEBIBEBHàÎMFOEJ QB[‘MBS‘NCàZàEà4‘SU‘NBþ‘SM‘þBEBZBO‘LM‘IÉMFHFMEJ#BDBLMBS‘N
LBM‘OMBāU‘WFLVWWFUMFOEJ5Bā‘JUNFZFCBāMBE‘þ‘NEBOÎPLEBIBLVWWFUMJZJNāJNEJ&WFU LBZBZ‘
L‘N‘MEBUBNBE‘N"NBZBQNBNHFSFLFOJHàDàNàOZFUUJþJZFSFLBEBSZBQU‘N,BZBZ‘ZFSJO-
EFOPZOBUBDBLPMBOCFOEFþJMJN "MMBIU‘S"MMBIEJMFSTFEJMFEJþJ[BNBOLBZBZFSJOEFOPZOBS
EJZFSFLPMVNTV[EàāàODFMFSEFOLVSUVMEV
)BUBT‘O‘BOMBZBOHFOÎ FSUFTJHàOLFOEJHÚSFWJOJOLBZBZ‘ZFSJOEFOPZOBUNBLEFþJM POV
WBSLVWWFUJZMFJUNFLPMEVþVCJMJODJZMFHÚSFWJOJZFSJOFHFUJSEJÿLJODJHàO àÎàODàHàOEFSLFO 
LBZBCJSEFOZFSJOEFOL‘N‘MEBE‘0[BNBOLBZBZ‘ZFSJOEFOL‘N‘MEBUBO‘OLFOEJTJEFþJM"MMBI
PMEVþVOV BOMBE‘ #JSB[ EBIB VþSBāU‘þ‘OEB  LBZB CJSB[ EBIB PZOBE‘ WF LFOBSB ZVWBSMBOE‘
"MU‘OEBO EB LFOEJTJOF ÚNàS CPZV ZFUFDFL LBEBS CàZàL CJS IB[JOF ΑLU‘w ÿMIBN ÚZLàMFSJ
LJUBC‘OEBOVZBSMBON‘āU‘S5JNBā:BZ‘OMBS‘ 

%FþFSMFOEJSNF4PSVMBS‘
4J[DFHFOÎBEBN‘OLBZBZ‘JUNFLUFOWB[HFÎNFNFTJOBT‘MCJSEBWSBO‘āU‘S 
,BZBZ‘JUNFZFCBāMBE‘þ‘OEBCJSIB[JOFZMFLBSā‘MBāBDBþ‘O‘CJMJZPSNVZEV
)JÎCJSCFLMFOUJTJPMNBEBOHÚSFWJOJZFSJOFHFUJSNFTJPOBOFLB[BOE‘SE‘
,BZBZ‘JUNFTFZEJOFPMVSEV
(FOÎBEBNCVEBWSBO‘ā‘JMFTBC‘SN‘UBIBNNàMNàHÚTUFSEJ 
5FWFLLàMLBWSBN‘IBLL‘OEBOFMFSEàāàOàZPSTVOV[
4J[HFOÎBEBN‘OZFSJOEFPMTBZE‘O‘[OFZBQBSE‘O‘[

(àOàO.FTBK‘
i"MMBI TBCSFEFOMFSJTFWFSw
¬MJÿNSÉO 

,BQBO‘ā
(SVQàZFMFSJOFQBZMBā‘NMBS‘JÎJOUFāFLLàSFEJO
)FSLFTJOBLM‘OEBLBMBONFTBK‘QBZMBāNBT‘O‘JTUFZJO
,POVZMBJMHJMJWBSTBTPSVMBS‘O‘BM‘OWFDFWBQMBZ‘O
#JSTPOSBLJLPOVOVOCBāM‘þ‘O‘WFSJOWFWFEBMBā‘O

89
SABIR

½þSFUJDJ/PUV
4BCSFUNFOJOVNVUTV[MVþBEàāNFEFOEJSFOÎHÚTUFSNFLWFCBā‘OBHFMFOFSB[‘PMNBL ZB-
S‘OB VNVUMB CBLNBL  HàDàOàO ZFUUJþJ ZFSF LBEBS NàDBEFMF FUNFZF EFWBN FUNFL PMEVþV
BOMBU‘M‘S &MJOEFO HFMFOJ ZBQU‘LUBO TPOSB OFUJDFTJOJ "MMBIB C‘SBLNBO‘O JTF UFWFLLàM FUNFL
PMEVþV "MMBI‘OTBCSFEFOMFSJWFUFWFLLàMFEFOMFSJTFWEJþJJGBEFFEJMJS

:ÚOUFNWF5FLOJLMFS
"OMBU‘N

&ULJOMJL
ZBā
½þSFUJDJTFMBNWFSFSFLJÎFSJHJSFS±PDVLMBSB iTBCSFUNFLwEFZJODFBL‘MMBS‘OBOFMFSHFMEJþJ-
OJTPSBS4BC‘Sà[FSJOFCJSB[LPOVāVSMBS½þSFUJDJLPOVZVUPQBSMBSi4BCSFUNFLEJSFONFLUJS 
CBā‘OBHFMFOFSB[‘PMNBLU‘S ZBS‘OBVNVUMBCBLNBLU‘S HàDàOàOZFUUJþJZFSFLBEBSNàDBEFMF
FUNFZFEFWBNFUNFLUJS&MJOEFOHFMFOJZBQU‘LUBOTPOSBEBOFUJDFTJOJ"MMBIBC‘SBLNBLJTF
UFWFLLàMFUNFLUJS"MMBI TBCSFEFOMFSJWFUFWFLLàMFEFOMFSJTFWFSw½þSFUJDJ UFWFLLàMLPOV-
TVOEB "MMBI 3FTßMà )[ .VIBNNFEJO IBZBU‘OEBO CJS L‘TTB BOMBUBDBþ‘O‘ TÚZMFS ½ODFEFO
IB[‘SMBON‘āPMBSBLL‘TTBZ‘KFTUWFNJNJLMFSJOJVZHVOāFLJMEFLVMMBOBSBLBOMBU‘S
i"TS‘TBBEFUUFCJSBEBNV[BLCJSZFSEFO "MMBI3FTßMàOàHÚSNFLJÎJOZPMBΑLN‘āU‘#J-
OFþJOFCJOEJ ZPMMBSBEàāUà%BþMBS‘UFQFMFSJBāU‘0MEVLÎBNFāBLLBUMJCJSZPMDVMVLUBOTPOSB
.FEJOFZF VMBāU‘ BNB ÎPL ZPSVMNVāUV #JOFþJOEFO JOEJ  JQJOJ TBM‘WFSEJ (JUTJO LBSO‘O‘ CJS
ZFSMFSEFEPZVSTVOEJZFEàāàOEà
.FTDJEFHJSEJ)FNFO"MMBI3FTßMàOàOIV[VSVOBLPāUV"MMBI3FTßMàPOVOÿTMBNEJOJ
IBLL‘OEBLJTPSVMBS‘OBUFCFTTàNFEFSFLNFNOVOJZFUMFDFWBQWFSJZPSEV
1FZHBNCFSJNJ[ BEBN‘OIÉMJOEFOV[BLCJSZPMEBOHFMEJþJOJBOMBN‘āU‘/BT‘MWFOFSFEFO
HFMEJþJOJPOBTPSEV"EBNV[VOCJSZPMEBOHFMEJþJOJTÚZMFZJODF"MMBI3FTßMàTPSEV
0IBMEFTFOJOBþ‘SCJSZàLàOPMNBT‘HFSFLJS POMBS‘OFSFZFC‘SBLU‘O
)BZ‘S ZPL4BEFDFCJSCJOFþJNWBS0OVEBEJMFEJþJZFSEFOLBSO‘O‘EPZVSTVO TVZVOV
JÎTJOEJZFTBM‘WFSEJN EFZJODF1FZHBNCFS&GFOEJNJ[
:BOJPOVIJÎCJSZFSFCBþMBNBEBOTBM‘WFSEJOÚZMFNJ :BLBÎBSWFZBCJSZFSEFOZVWBSMBO‘S
WFÚMàSTF
&Z"MMBI‘O3FTßMà POVOJQJOJTBME‘NWFJāJNJ"MMBIBC‘SBLU‘N:BOJ"MMBIBUFWFLLàM
FUUJN
"MMBI3FTßMàUFCFTTàNFUUJ
ÿQJOJTBþMBNCJSZFSFCBþMBZ‘Q "MMBIBUFWFLLàMFUTFOEBIBJZJPMVSEV


SABIR

"EBNCVOVEVZVODBIFNFOE‘āBS‘ZBLPāUV#JSEFOFHÚSTàO CJOFþJC‘SBLU‘þ‘ZFSEFZPL-
UV4BþBTPMBCBLU‘ CJS[BNBOTPOSBCJOCJSHàÎMàLMFPOVCVMEVWFHFUJSEJCJSBþBDBCBþMBE‘
5FWFLLàMFUNFOJOFMJOEFOHFMFOJZBQU‘LUBOTPOSBOFUJDFZJ"MMBIBIBWBMFFUNFLPMEVþVOV
EBIBJZJBOMBN‘āU‘w 5JSNJ[Ô ÿMFM 

%FþFSMFOEJSNF4PSVMBS‘
5FWFLLàMLBWSBN‘IBLL‘OEBOFEàāàOàZPSTVOV[ 
&MJOEFOHFMFOIFSāFZJZBQNBEBOUFWFLLàMFEJMJSNJ
4BC‘SWFUFWFLLàMBSBT‘OEBOBT‘MCJSCBþLVSEVOV[
)BZBU‘O‘[EBOUFWFLLàMÚSOFLMFSJWFSFCJMJSNJTJOJ[

(àOàO.FTBK‘
i4BCSFEFOMFSF NàLÉGBUMBS‘
IFTBQT‘[WFSJMFDFLUJSw
;àNFS 

,BQBO‘ā
(SVQàZFMFSJOFQBZMBā‘NMBS‘JÎJOUFāFLLàSFEJO
)FSLFTJOBLM‘OEBLBMBONFTBK‘QBZMBāNBT‘O‘JTUFZJO
,POVZMBJMHJMJWBSTBTPSVMBS‘O‘BM‘OWFDFWBQMBZ‘O
#JSTPOSBLJLPOVOVOCBāM‘þ‘O‘WFSJOWFWFEBMBā‘O

91
SABIR

14
ĀÃ,Ã3

iĀàLàSwLBWSBN‘O‘OOFEFNFLPMEVþVOVCJMJSĀàLSàOLVMMVLWFJOTBOM‘L
WB[JGFTJPMEVþVOVBOMBS
4BIJQPMEVþVOJNFUMFSJOGBSL‘OBWBS‘S/JNFUJOOFPMEVþVOV TBþM‘L BL‘M 
CBS‘OBDBLZFS ZJZFDFL JÎFDFL FþJUJNWC WFOJNFULBSā‘T‘OEBOBT‘MCJSEVSVāB
TBIJQPMNBT‘HFSFLUJþJOJLBWSBS
"MMBIBOJÎJOāàLSFUNFTJHFSFLUJþJOJCJMJS
"MMBIBOBT‘MāàLSFUNFTJHFSFLUJþJOJCJMJS
#BāLBMBS‘ZMBLFOEJTJOJL‘ZBTMBNBEBOāàLSFUNFTJHFSFLUJþJOJCJMJS
ĀÃ,Ã3

ĀÃ,Ã3,"73".*7&.")ÿ:&5ÿ
,B[BO‘N
iĀàLàSwLBWSBN‘O‘OOFEFNFLPMEVþVOVCJMJS
ĀàLSàOLVMMVLWFJOTBOM‘LWB[JGFTJPMEVþVOVBOMBS

½þSFUJDJ/PUV
ÿOTBOLBSBLUFSJOEFLJFOHà[FMÚ[FMMJLMFSEFOCJSJOJOLFOEJNJ[EFPMBOHà[FMMJLMFSJHÚSàQ 
LBOBBUFUNFLWFTBIJQPMEVþVNV[OJNFUMFSJWFSFOFUFāFLLàSFUNFLPMEVþVBOMBU‘M‘SÿOTBO‘O
LFOEJTJOFWFSJMFOOJNFUMFSFLBSā‘NFNOVOJZFUEVZNBT‘O‘OLBOBBUJOJMLBāBNBT‘PMEVþVJGBEF
FEJMJS4BEFDFOJNFUJEFþJM OJNFUJWFSFOJEFHÚSFCJMFOJOTBO‘OāàLSFEFSFLLBOBBUJOCJSEJþFS
BāBNBT‘O‘UBNBNMBE‘þ‘WVSHVMBO‘S

:ÚOUFNWF5FLOJLMFS
4PSV$FWBQ 1BOEPNJN TÚ[Tà[PZVO 3PM0ZOBNB

&ULJOMJL
ZBā
½þSFUJDJ i#VHàOCJSPZVOPZOBNBZBOFEFSTJOJ[ wEJZFSFLCJSLBÎÎPDVþBBāBþ‘EBLJTP-
SVMBS‘TPSBS
t #VMVUMBS‘O à[FSJOEF  CJMNFEJþJO CJS āFISF EàāNFZJ CFLMFZFO CJS ZBþNVS EBNMBT‘T‘O 
BOMBUCJ[FOFMFSIJTTFEJZPSTVO
t3à[HÉSBLBQ‘MN‘āCJSZBQSBLT‘O BOMBUCJ[FOFMFSIJTTFEJZPSTVO 
t,‘[BSN‘āLÚGUFTJO TFOJUFODFSFEFVOVUUVMBS BOMBUCJ[FOFMFSIJTTFEJZPSTVO
(/PU ±PDVLMBSB TPSVMBS TPSBSBL LPOVāNBMBS‘OB ZBSE‘ND‘ PMVOVS ½SOFþJO i#VMVUMBS‘O
à[FSJOEFOBāBþ‘T‘OBT‘MHÚSàOàZPS ZFSFJONFLUFOLPSLVZPSNVTVO #VIBSPMVQLBZCPMNBZ‘
JTUFSNJZEJO w4PSVMBSàSFUJMJSLFOÎPDVLMBS‘OZBāBZBCJMFDFþJPMVNTV[EVSVNMBS‘ZBOT‘UBOTP-
SVMBSPMNBT‘OBEJLLBUFEJMTJOLJBāBþ‘EBLJLPOVZMBCBþMBOU‘LPQNBT‘O 

94
ĀÃ,Ã3

i4FWHJMJÎPDVLMBS
#JSCBāLBāFZJOZFSJOEFPMNBO‘OCJ[JOFHJCJ[PSMVLMBSMBLBSā‘MBāU‘SBCJMFDFþJOJHÚSàZPSTV-
OV[
&OHà[FMāFZLFOEJNJ[EFPMBOHà[FMMJLMFSJHÚSàQLBOBBUFUNFLWFTBIJQPMEVþVNV[OJ-
NFUMFSJWFSFOFUFāFLLàSFUNFLUJSÿOTBOLFOEJTJOFWFSJMFOOJNFUMFSFLBSā‘CJSNFNOVOJZFU
EVZBSTBLBOBBUFUNJāPMVS4BEFDFOJNFUJEFþJM OJNFUJWFSFOJEFHÚSFCJMFOāàLSFUNJāPMVS
½SOFþJOHÚ[àOāàLSàJOTBOMBS‘OLVTVSVOVHÚSNFNFLUJS,VMBþ‘OāàLSà TÚZMFOJMFOBZ‘QMBS‘
EVZNBN‘āPMNBLU‘S4J[DFEJþFSPSHBOMBS‘OāàLSàOBT‘MPMNBM‘E‘S w
±PDVLMBSEBOHFMFODFWBQMBSEPþSVMUVTVOEBāàLàSCBITJOJQFLJāUJSJSMFS 
i)BNE CàUàOOJNFUMFSJ"MMBI‘OZBSBUU‘þ‘OBWFHÚOEFSEJþJOFJOBO‘QEJMMFTÚZMFNFLEF-
NFLUJSĀàLàSJTFCàUàOOJNFUMFSJÿTMBNJZFUFVZHVOPMBSBLLVMMBONBLEFNFLUJS#JSIBNE
JGBEFTJPMBSBLi&MIBNEàMJMMBIwEFNFLTàOOFUUJSw/JUFLJN1FZHBNCFS&GFOEJNJ[ TBT āÚZMF
CVZVSNVāUVS
A&MIBNEàMJMMBI EFNFL  [JLJSMFSJO WF āàLàSMFSJO CBā‘E‘S .FāSV JāMFS i&MIBNEàMJMMBIw JMF
TPOVÎMBONB[TB IBZ‘SWFCFSFLFUJPMNB[ #FZIBLÔ ĀVBCàMÿNBO *7 
4FWHJMJÎPDVLMBS āàLSFUNFLJÎJOOFLBEBSÎPLOJNFUFTBIJCJ[ IFQCJSMJLUFHÚSFMJNNJ 
4BIJQPMEVþVOV[OJNFUMFSJJLJEBLJLBJÎJOEFEàāàOàOWFCJSUBOFTJOJTFÎJO4Ú[Tà[PZVOMB
BOMBUNBLà[FSFIB[‘SMBO‘OwEFSÿMLPMBSBLÚþSFUNFOTBIJQPMEVþVOJNFUMFSEFOCJSJOJTÚ[Tà[
PZVOMBBOMBU‘SWFCÚZMFDFOFāFLJMEFVZHVMBOBDBþ‘O‘EBHÚTUFSNJāPMVS5àNJTUFLMJÎPDVLMBS
UFLFSUFLFSBOMBU‘S½þSFUNFOBOMBU‘MBOMBS‘OPUFEFS%FSTJOTPOVOEBCàUàOCVOJNFUMFSJWF-
SFO"MMBIBUFāFLLàSJGBEFTJPMBSBLJLJSFLÉUāàLàSOBNB[‘L‘M‘O‘S

%FþFSMFOEJSNF4PSVMBS‘
iĀàLàSwLBWSBN‘TJ[JOJÎJOOFZJJGBEFFEJZPS
,BOBBUFUNFL IBNEFUNFL UFāFLLàSFUNFLOFEJS 
,BMQ EJMWFPSHBOMBSMBāàLSFUNFLOBT‘MPMNBM‘E‘S


ĀÃ,Ã3

(àOàO.FTBK‘
iÿOTBOMBSBUFāFLLàSEFCVMVONBZBO
"MMBIBEBāàLSFUNF[w
5JSNJ[Ô #JSSWF4‘MB 

,BQBO‘ā
(SVQàZFMFSJOFQBZMBā‘NMBS‘JÎJOUFāFLLàSFEJO
)FSLFTJOBLM‘OEBLBMBONFTBK‘QBZMBāNBT‘O‘JTUFZJO
,POVZMBJMHJMJWBSTBTPSVMBS‘O‘BM‘OWFDFWBQMBZ‘O
#JSTPOSBLJLPOVOVOCBāM‘þ‘O‘WFSJOWFWFEBMBā‘O

96
ĀÃ,Ã3

½þSFUJDJ/PUV
ĀàLSàO LVMMVLCJMJODJPMEVþV āàLSàEPþSVBOMBNBO‘OIBZBU‘BOMBNBZ‘LPMBZMBāU‘SE‘þ‘
ÎPDVLMBSBBOMBU‘M‘SÿOTBO‘OLFOEJTJOFWFSJMFOOJNFUMFSFLBSā‘UFāFLLàSFUNFTJHFSFLUJþJWVS-
HVMBO‘S"ZO‘EVSVNLBSā‘T‘OEBGBSLM‘EàāàODFMFSMFāàLSàOOBT‘MZPSVNMBOE‘þ‘OBEFþJOJMJS
#ÚZMFDFEPþSVEàāàODFāFLMJWVSHVMBO‘S
"MU‘āBQLBM‘EàāàONFUFLOJþJOJOOFPMEVþVWFIBOHJSFOHJOIBOHJEàāàODFZJUFNTJMFUUJþJ
ÎPDVLMBSBBOMBU‘M‘S
±PDVþVOHàOMàLIBZBUUBLJCJMJāTFMCFDFSJMFSJOJHFMJāUJSNFEF QSPCMFNÎÚ[NFFULJOMJþJLB-
[BOE‘SNBEB FþJUJNTFMEà[FOMFNFEFPMEVLÎBLVMMBO‘āM‘CJSVZHVMBNBPMBO"MU‘āBQLBM‘Eà-
āàONFUFLOJþJEàāàODFWFÚOFSJMFSJOCFMJSMJCJSEà[FOJÎFSJTJOEFTVOVMNBT‘WFTJTUFNBUJLMFā-
NFTJJÎJOLVMMBO‘MBOCJSUFLOJLUJS
ĀBQLBMBS  EàāàODFMFSJO GBSLM‘MBāNBT‘ WF CJSCJSJOEFO BZS‘MNBT‘ JÎJO CJS TFNCPMEàS ĀBQ-
LBMBS‘OSFOHJEFþJāUJLÎF SFOHJOTJNHFMFEJþJEàāàODFMFSJOCFMJSMJCJSEà[FOJÎFSJTJOEFT‘SBZMB
BLUBS‘MNBT‘CFLMFOJS
ĀBQLBMBS‘OTJNHFMFEJLMFSJEàāàODFMFSāVOMBSE‘S
#FZB[ĀBQLB 5BSBGT‘[ĀBQLB /FUCJMHJMFS TBZ‘TBMJTQBUMBSBEBZBOE‘SNB
,‘SN‘[‘ĀBQLB %VZHVTBM ,JāJTFMMFāUJSFOĀBQLB )FZFDBOM‘ TBME‘SHBO LPOUSPMTà[ 
UF[DBOM‘ IJTWFEVZHVMBS‘ZMBÎBCVLEBWSBONB
4JZBIĀBQLB ,ÚUàNTFSĀBQLB 0MVNTV[ OFHBUJG EàāàODFWFZÚOMFSJOFCBLBSBLEà-
āàONF
4BS‘ĀBQLB "WBOUBKMBSĀBQLBT‘ ÿZJNTFS BWBOUBKZBSBUNBWFHÚSNF JZJOJZFUMJPMVNMV
EàāàONF
.BWJĀBQLB %FþFSMFOEJSFOĀBQLB ,POUSPMFEFO TFSJOLBOM‘ EVSVNVÎÚ[àNMFZFSFL
BOBMJ[ FEFSFL  TPOVÎMBS CVMNBZB ÎBCB HÚTUFSFO  EFþFSMFOEJSNF ZPMVZMB TPSVOMBSB ÎÚ[àN
BSBZBO
:FāJMĀBQLB :BSBU‘D‘M‘LĀBQLBT‘ :FOJMJLÎJ àSFULFO HJSJāJNDJ EFþJāJLMJþFBΑL BMUFSOB-
UJGEàāàODFMFSBSBNB
6ZHVMBNBEB ÎPDVLMBSEBO iāàLàS WF NBIJZFUJw LPOVTV à[FSJOEF EàāàONF WF EàāàODF
àSFUNFMFSJJTUFOJS#VLPOVEBEàāàOàSLFO ÎPDVLMBSIBOHJSFOLāBQLBTFÎUJJTFPOVOUFNTJM
FUUJþJEàāàODFZJTÚZMFS'JLSJEFþJāFOÎPDVLMBSJTUFSTFāBQLBMBS‘O‘LFOEJBSBT‘OEBEFþJāUJSF-
CJMJS±PDVLMBS‘OBLUJGÎBM‘āNBMBS‘OEBÚ[FMMJLMFZFāJMāBQLBZBÚOFNWFSJMJSĀàLàSLPOVTVOEB
EPþSVEàāàODFZJBOMBNBMBS‘à[FSJOEFEVSVMVS
½þSFUJDJ ÎPDVLMBS‘OSFOLMFSFHÚSFmLJSàSFUFDFþJIVTVTVOEBFNJOEFþJMJTFFULJOMJLUFWF-
SJMFONFUJOMFSFULJOMJLUFOÚODFPLVOVSWFÎPDVLMBS‘OLFOEJMFSJOFZBL‘OEàāàODFZJTFÎNFMFSJ
JTUFOJS±PDVLMBS‘OTFÎUJþJSFOHFBJUNFUOJL‘TBTàSFJÎFSJTJOEFZB[NBT‘JTUFOJSWFPSFOHFBJU
āBQLBÎPDVþVOCBā‘OBUBL‘M‘S&ULJOMJþFCBāMBO‘S

97
ĀÃ,Ã3

:ÚOUFNWF5FLOJLMFS
"MU‘ĀBQLBM‘%àāàONF5FLOJþJ 8PSLTIPQ5FLOJþJ ±BM‘āNB"UÚMZFTJ

.BUFSZBM
#FZB[ L‘SN‘[‘ TJZBI TBS‘ NBWJWFZFāJMGPOLBSUPOMBS‘ ÚþSFODJTBZ‘T‘ODB"LÉþ‘E‘

&ULJOMJL
ZBā
½þSFUJDJ ÎPDVLMBSB CVHàO iāàLàS WF NBIJZFUJw IBLL‘OEB LPOVāBDBLMBS‘O‘ WF CVOV BMU‘
āBQLBM‘EàāàONFUFLOJþJOFHÚSFZBQBDBLMBS‘O‘TÚZMFS%BIBÚODFEFOÎPDVLMBSMBBMU‘BZS‘GPO
LBSUPOVOEBO ZBQU‘LMBS‘ āBQLBMBS‘ HFUJSJSMFS 5FLOJL IBLL‘OEB ÎPDVLMBSB CJMHJMFS WFSJS )FS-
LFTJOLFOEJTJOJEJOMFEJLUFOTPOSBiāàLàSWFNBIJZFUJwLPOVTVIBLL‘OEBLJHÚSàāMFSJOFHÚSF
āBQLBMBS‘UBLNBMBS‘O‘WFSBTUHFMFUBLNBNBMBS‘O‘JTUFS
"ZāF ,‘SN‘[‘ĀBQLB ½þSFUNFOJN#FOBSLBEBāMBS‘NBSBT‘OEBāàLSàOB[BME‘þ‘O‘Eàāà-
OàZPSVN±FWSFNJ[FCBLU‘þ‘NEBJOTBOMBSCJSCJSMFSJOFCJMFUFāFLLàSFUNJZPSMBS;BUFOJOTBO-
MBSBUFāFLLàSFUNFZFOLJāJ"MMBIBOBT‘MāàLSFEFSLJ 0LVMEBLJÚþSFUNFOJNIFQBOMBU‘ZPSEB
FTLJEFOJOTBOMBSIFQāàLSFEFSNJā7FSJMFOOJNFUMFSJOL‘ZNFUJOJCJMJSMFSNJā
)BUJDF 4BS‘ĀBQLB ½þSFUNFOJN#FO"ZāFHJCJEàāàONàZPSVNÿOTBOMBSÎPLZPþVO
PMVZPSMBS#FODFWFSJMFOOJNFUMFSFāàLSFEJZPSMBSE‘S#JSCJSMFSJOJHÚSFDFLWBLJUCJMFCVMBNB-
ZBOCVJOTBOMBSCJSCJSMFSJOFOBT‘MUFāFLLàSFUTJOMFSLJ
"TM‘ .BWJĀBQLB ½þSFUNFOJN"SLBEBāMBS‘N‘[‘OBOMBUU‘LMBS‘PSUBEB"TM‘OEBiāàLàSw
JMFJMHJMJCJSQSPCMFNPMEVþVEPþSV"ODBLEVSVNCB[‘BSLBEBāMBS‘N‘[‘OTÚZMFEJþJHJCJÎPL
LÚUàEFEFþJM&WFUIBZBU‘N‘[EBāàLàSZÚOàOEFOFLTJLMJLMFSWBSBNBCJ[āàLSàEPþSVBO-
MBZBCJMJSWFZBOM‘āEBWSBO‘āMBS‘N‘[‘Eà[FMUFCJMJSJ[½SOFþJO TJ[CVLPOVZBEBIBÎPLÚOFN
WFSFCJMJSTJOJ[ ÎFWSFNJ[EFLJMFSEBWSBO‘āMBS‘ZMBCJ[FÚSOFLPMBSBLāàLSàEBIBJZJBOMBNBN‘[‘
TBþMBZBCJMJSMFS3BEZPWFUFMFWJ[ZPOMBSEBāàLSàOÚOFNJWFNBIJZFUJJMFJMHJMJCFMHFTFMMFSWF
QSPHSBNMBSZBQ‘MBCJMJS±PDVLWFHFOÎEFSHJMFSJOEFCVLPOVOVOÚOFNJà[FSJOEFEVSVMBCJMJS
&TSB 4JZBIĀBQLB #FO"TM‘O‘OUBNBNFO[‘EE‘O‘EàāàOàZPSVNÿOTBOMBSāàLSàOOF
PMEVþVOVCJMJZPSMBSTBOFEFOFMJOEFLJMFSFLBOBBUFUNFZJQIFQEBIBGB[MBT‘O‘JTUJZPSMBS/JZF
IFSHàOUFMFWJ[ZPOMBSEBCJSCJSMFSJOJOJZJMJLMFSJOJVOVUVQLBWHBFEJZPSMBS;BUFOJOTBOMBSIFQ
IBMJOEFONVUTV[)FQTJBT‘LTVSBUM‘)FSHàOJZJDFLÚUàZFHJEJZPSV[
"ZMJO #FZB[ĀBQLB "SLBEBāMBS#J[JNàMLFNJ[EFLJāàLàSCJMJODJCFOJNPLVEVLMBS‘NB
WFEVZEVLMBS‘NBHÚSFÎPLÎPLJZJZNJā
.FSZFN :FāJM ĀBQLB  ½þSFUNFOJN #FO EF "TM‘ZB LBU‘M‘ZPSVN &WFU āàLàS JMF JMHJMJ
CJSQSPCMFNPMEVþVEPþSV"MMBIBāàLàSB[ JOTBOMBSBUFāFLLàSB[#J[NVUMBLBCJ[FJZJMJL
ZBQBOBHà[FMBIMBL‘N‘[EBOEPMBZ‘NJOOFUEVZNBM‘Z‘["NBāàLSàOOFPMEVþVOVCJMFNFZFO-

98
ĀÃ,Ã3

MFSWBSFMCFUUF"ODBLCVàTUFTJOEFOHFMJOFNFZFDFLCJSLPOVEBEFþJM#J[JNÎPLTBþMBNCJS
LàMUàSàNà[WBS4POSBEJOJNJ[EFāàLàSLPOVTVOBÎPLÚOFNWFSJZPSĀàLSàOLVMMVLCJMJODJ
PMEVþVWVSHVMBO‘ZPS4àSFLMJāàLSFUNFNJ[CFODF[PSEFþJMÿOTBOMBSBÚODFāàLàSLPOVTVWF
āàLSàOOFEFNFLPMEVþVBOMBU‘MNBM‘"TM‘O‘OTÚZMFEJþJHJCJCVLPOVEBIBML‘N‘[BWFCJ[MFSF
CJMHJMFSWFSJMNFMJEJS
ĀVMF 4BS‘ĀBQLB %VSVNPLBEBSEBLÚUàEFþJM½SOFþJOCFOJNÎPLJZJBSLBEBāMBS‘N
WBS4‘O‘GUBLJBSLBEBāMBS‘NIFQCBOBUFāFLLàSFEFS
&TSB 4JZBIĀBQLB ½þSFUNFOJN#FOāBQLBN‘EFþJāUJSFDFþJN(FSÎFLUFOEFCFOZBO-
M‘āEàāàOàZPSNVāVN&WFU HFSÎFLUFOāàLàSLPOVTVJMFJMHJMJQSPCMFNMFSWBS#FOJOTBOMBS‘
HFOFMMFNFNFMJZNJāJN"SLBEBāMBS‘NIBLM‘)ÉMÉCJSCJSMFSJOFUFāFLLàSFEFO"MMBI‘OWFSEJþJ
OJNFUMFSFāàLSFEFOPLBEBSJOTBOWBSLJyĀàLàS JOTBO‘OFOÚOFNMJJIUJZBD‘ NVUMVMVLTF-
CFCJZNJāy"SU‘L LJNTFIBLL‘OEBPMVNTV[EàāàONFZFDFþJN"MMBIBāàLSFEFOWFJOTBOMBSB
UFāFLLàSFEFOCJSJOTBOPMBDBþ‘N
½þSFUJDJ4FWHJMJÎPDVLMBS#VEFþFSMJmLJSMFSJOJ[JÎJOTJ[FUFāFLLàSFEJZPSVNĀJNEJTJ[-
EFOTJ[FWFSEJþJNCPāLÉþ‘UMBSB i4J[DFāàLàSOFEJS wJMFJMHJMJCJSLPNQP[JTZPOZB[NBO‘[‘
JTUJZPSVN EFS
½þSFUJDJ ÎPDVLMBSMBÎBM‘āNBBUÚMZFTJZBQBS)FSLFTLFOEJZB[E‘þ‘LPNQP[JTZPOVPLVS
½þSFUJDJāàLSàWFāàLSàOOFPMEVþVOVÎPDVLMBSBBOMBU‘S#VHà[FMFULJOMJLUFLJCBāBS‘MBS‘OEBO
EPMBZ‘ÎPDVLMBS‘UFCSJLFEFSWFEFþFSMFOEJSNFTPSVMBS‘TPSVMBSBLLPOVUBNBNMBON‘āPMVS

,FMJNF"OBIUBS‘ĀàLàS 5FāFLLàS&UNFL )BNE 


,BOBBU .JOOFU

99
զ +(ɘ, ƻ*ǔȢ(#(

"āBþ‘EBWFSJMFOāàLàSJMFJMHJMJLBWSBNMBS‘
UBNBNMBZBM‘N

Ā@@@S

5@@F@L@S
F@@@L
.@O@@U

)@N@
,@O@B@


ĀÃ,Ã3

%FþFSMFOEJSNF4PSVMBS‘
ĀàLàSJMFJMHJMJLBWSBNMBSEBOÚSOFLWFSJSNJTJOJ[
"MMBI‘OWFSEJþJOJNFUMFSFāàLàSOBT‘MPMVS
ÿOTBOMBSBUFāFLLàSFUNFZFOLJāJTJ[DF"MMBIBāàLSFEFSNJ

(àOàO.FTBK‘
iy:BMO‘["MMBIBJCBEFUFUWF
āàLSFEFOMFSEFOPMw
;àNFS 

,BQBO‘ā
(SVQàZFMFSJOFQBZMBā‘NMBS‘JÎJOUFāFLLàSFEJO
)FSLFTJOBLM‘OEBLBMBONFTBK‘QBZMBāNBT‘O‘JTUFZJO
,POVZMBJMHJMJWBSTBTPSVMBS‘O‘BM‘OWFDFWBQMBZ‘O
#JSTPOSBLJLPOVOVOCBāM‘þ‘O‘WFSJOWFWFEBMBā‘O


ĀÃ,Ã3

/ÿ.&5&ĀÃ,Ã3
,B[BO‘N
4BIJQPMEVþVOJNFUMFSJOGBSL‘OBWBS‘S/JNFUJOOFPMEVþVOV TBþM‘L BL‘M CBS‘OBDBLZFS 
ZJZFDFL JÎFDFL FþJUJNWC WFOJNFULBSā‘T‘OEBOBT‘MCJSEVSVāBTBIJQ
PMNBT‘HFSFLUJþJOJLBWSBS

½þSFUJDJ/PUV
ĀàLàSLBWSBN‘JZJMJLFEFOJOWFOJNFUWFSFOJOLBESJOJWFL‘ZNFUJOJCJMJQCVOVJOTBOMBSB
HÚTUFSNFL JZJMJLWFJITBOEBCVMVOBO‘ÚWNFLBOMBNMBS‘ZMBUBO‘NMBO‘S%JOÔCJSUFSJNPMBSBL
JTFāàLSàO "MMBI‘OLVMMBS‘OBWFSEJþJOJNFUMFSJOFULJTJOJOPOMBS‘OEJMJOEFÚWHàPMBSBL LBM-
CJOEFTFWHJPMBSBL PSHBOMBS‘OEBEBJUBBUFUNFCPZVOFþNFPMBSBLPSUBZBΑLNBT‘HFSFLUJþJ
JGBEFFEJMJS"MMBI‘OWFSEJþJOJNFUJO ZJOF0OVOZPMVOEBLVMMBO‘MNBT‘HFSFLUJþJ CVOFEFOMF
[FOHJOMJL  NBLBN  [FLÉ  TBþM‘L  LVWWFU HJCJ OJNFUMFSJ  "MMBI‘O FNSFUUJþJ CJÎJNEF LVMMBO-
NBO‘O WFSJMFOOJNFUJOāàLSàOàIBLL‘ZMBZFSJOFHFUJSNFLPMEVþVJ[BIFEJMJSĀàLSFEFOCJS
LVMVOFOHà[FMÚMÎàTàOàOLBOBBULÉSM‘þ‘ CBā‘OBHFMFOMFSFS‘[BHÚTUFSNFTJWFIFSEVSVNEB
NFNOVOJZFUJOJCFMJSUNFTJPMEVþVWVSHVMBO‘S

:ÚOUFNWF5FLOJLMFS
#FZJO'‘SU‘OBT‘:ÚOUFNJ

.BUFSZBM
5BIUB LBMFN

&ULJOMJL
ZBā 
5BIUBO‘OPSUBT‘OBBāBþ‘EBWFSJMFOāBCMPOEBLJOFCFO[FSCJSāFNBÎJ[JMJS0SUBT‘OBCàZàL
IBSnFSMFi/FMFSJÎJOāàLSFEFSJ[ wEJZFCàZàLÎFZB[‘M‘S TPOSBCFZJOG‘SU‘OBT‘UFLOJþJVZHVMBO‘S
#FZJOG‘SU‘OBT‘UFLOJþJOEFÎPDVLMBSEBO LFOEJMFSJOFWFSJMFOTàSFJÎJOEFHÚSàāMFSJOJCFMJSUNF-
MFSJJTUFOJSWFCVHÚSàāMFSJOIFQTJUBIUBZBZB[‘M‘S#FZJOG‘SU‘OBT‘UFLOJþJVZHVMBO‘SLFOEJLLBU
FEJMFDFLIVTVTMBSL‘TBDBāÚZMFEJS


ĀÃ,Ã3

3BIBU TFSCFTUWFEFNPLSBUJLCJSPSUBNPMVāUVSVMNBM‘E‘S
)JÎCJSÎPDVþVOmLSJTÚZMFOEJþJT‘SBEBFMFāUJSJMNFNFMJ EFþFSMFOEJSNFWFZÚOMFOEJSNF
ZBQ‘MNBEBOZB[‘MNBM‘E‘S 5BIUBZBZB[‘M‘SLFOCFO[FSmLJSMFSCJSMFāUJSJMFCJMJS
:B[NBJāMFNJOFÎPDVLMBS‘OBLM‘OEBOHFÎFOMFSJOUàNàOàJGBEFFUNFMFSJOJCJUJSFOFLBEBS
EFWBNFEJMNFMJEJS4BZ‘T‘O‘SMBOE‘SNBT‘ZPLUVS
(ÚSàāMFSJOUPQMBONBT‘UBNBNMBOE‘LUBOTPOSBUBIUBZBZB[‘MBOmLJSMFSÎPDVLMBSMBCFSBCFS
BOBMJ[FEJMJQEFþFSMFOEJSNFZBQ‘M‘S
 #FZJO G‘SU‘OBT‘ ZÚOUFNJOEF BNBÎ FO TBÎNB mLJSMFSEFO ZFOJ WF LVMMBO‘MBCJMJS CJS mLSF
VMBāNBLU‘S
5BIUBZBQFLÎPLāàLàSTFCFCJZB[‘ME‘LUBOTPOSBÚþSFUJDJ "MMBI‘OWFSEJþJOJNFUMFSJOUBI-
UBEBLJMFSMFT‘O‘SM‘PMNBE‘þ‘O‘CB[‘ÚSOFLMFSWFSFSFLCFMJSUJS#VSBEBGBSLM‘ EJLLBUÎFLJDJÚS-
OFLMFS WFSNFL JZJ PMBDBLU‘S .FTFMB āVOMBSEBO CBITFEJMFCJMJS i"SLBEBāMBS  LBU‘M‘N‘O‘[ JÎJO
UFāFLLàSFEJZPSVN#JSMJLUFQFLÎPLāàLàSOFEFOJOJUFTQJUFUUJL"NBVOVUNBNBN‘[HFSFLFO
CJS OPLUB WBS LJ "MMBI‘O WFSEJþJ OJNFUMFS CVOMBS JMF T‘O‘SM‘ EFþJMEJS (Ú[àNà[  LVMBþ‘N‘[ 
QBSNBLMBS‘N‘[ IFQTJCJSFSNBLJOFHJCJÎBM‘āBOJÎPSHBOMBS‘N‘[HJCJCàUàOV[VWMBS‘N‘[ IBUUB
IàDSFMFSJNJ[ CJMF āàLàS OFEFOJEJS 5FOFGGàT FUUJþJNJ[ IBWBO‘O CJ[JN ZBāBNBN‘[B FMWFSJāMJ
PMEVþVOV NFTFMBEJþFSHF[FHFOMFSEFLJIBWBO‘OCVZBQ‘EBPMNBE‘þ‘O‘CJMJZPSV[ CVEBāàL-
SFUNFLJÎJOCJSTFCFQUJS#J[FBU‘MBOCJSUPQBWVSNBLJÎJOCFZJO HÚ[ LPMCBDBLLBTMBS‘O‘O
OBT‘MVZVNMVWFI‘[M‘ÎBM‘āU‘þ‘ÎPLJMHJOÎWFāàLSFEJMFTJCJSEVSVNEVS WCw
½þSFUJDJOJOUBIUBZBÎJ[NFTJJÎJOÚSOFLāFLJM

(ÚSFCJMEJþJN
JÎJO
ÿZJ
%àāàOFCJMEJþJN BSLBEBāMBS‘N
JÎJO PMEVþVJÎJO

/FMFSJÎJO
āàLSFEFSJ[

)‘[M‘ (à[FM
LPāBCJMEJþJN ZJZFDFLMFS
JÎJO JÎJO
4BþM‘LM‘
PMEVþVN
JÎJO


ĀÃ,Ã3

%FþFSMFOEJSNF4PSVMBS‘
i"MMBI‘OOJNFUJOJTBZNBZBLBMLTBO‘[ POVTBZBNB[T‘O‘[)BLJLBUFO"MMBIÎPLCBþ‘āMBZBO 
QFLFTJSHFZFOEJSw /BIM  BZFUJLFSJNFTJOJBΑLMBZ‘O‘[
5BIUBZBZB[E‘LMBS‘N‘[BFLMFNFLJTUFEJþJOJ[āàLàSTFCFCJOJNFUMFSWBSN‘ 
ĀàLSàOCJ[FLB[BOE‘SE‘LMBS‘OFMFSEJS

(àOàO.FTBK‘
i%PþSVTV0 CBþ‘āMBZBOE‘S āàLSàO
LBSā‘M‘þ‘O‘CPMCPMWFSFOEJSw
'ÉU‘S 

,BQBO‘ā
(SVQàZFMFSJOFQBZMBā‘NMBS‘JÎJOUFāFLLàSFEJO
)FSLFTJOBLM‘OEBLBMBONFTBK‘QBZMBāNBT‘O‘JTUFZJO
,POVZMBJMHJMJWBSTBTPSVMBS‘O‘BM‘OWFDFWBQMBZ‘O
#JSTPOSBLJLPOVOVOCBāM‘þ‘O‘WFSJOWFWFEBMBā‘O


ĀÃ,Ã3

/&%&/ĀÃ,3&5.&-ÿ:ÿ.
,B[BO‘N
4BIJQPMEVþVOJNFUMFSJOGBSL‘OBWBS‘S
"MMBIBOJÎJOāàLSFUNFTJHFSFLUJþJOJCJMJS
#BāLBMBS‘ZMBLFOEJTJOJL‘ZBTMBNBEBOāàLSFUNFTJHFSFLUJþJOJCJMJS

½þSFUJDJ/PUV
"MMBI‘OJOTBOBCBIāFUUJþJOJNFUMFST‘O‘ST‘[PMEVþVWFCVOJNFUMFSJUFLUFLTBZNBLNàN-
LàOPMNBE‘þ‘OBHÚSFāàLSFUNFOJOEFCJST‘O‘S‘O‘OPMNBE‘þ‘BOMBU‘M‘S0IÉMEFJOTBO‘OEFWBN-
M‘ PMBSBL āàLSFUNFTJ  "MMBI‘O OJNFUJOJ BONBT‘  IBU‘SEB UVUNBT‘ HFSFLUJþJ WVSHVMBO‘S #VOV
ZBQBSLFOJOTBO‘O āàLSàOGBZEBT‘O‘OEàOZBWFBIJSFUUF"MMBIBEFþJMZJOFLFOEJOFEÚONFLUF
PMEVþVOVCJMNFTJHFSFLUJþJCFMJSUJMJS:BQU‘þ‘āàLàSJMFGBZEBHÚSFOJOZJOFLVMVOLFOEJTJPM-
EVþVWVSHVMBO‘S
,VM BTM‘OEBāàLSFEFSFLZBSBSMBOE‘þ‘OJNFUMFSJOLBSā‘M‘þ‘O‘3BCCJOFÚEFNJāPMNBNBLUB-
E‘S;BUFOCVOBEBIJÎCJSLVMVOHàDàZFUNF[ĀàLSFEFOBTM‘OEBLFOEJTJJÎJOāàLSFUNJāUJS#V
IVTVTÚþSFUJDJUBSBG‘OEBOi,JNāàLSFEFSTFBODBLLFOEJTJJÎJOāàLSFUNJāPMVS,JNEFOBO-
LÚSMàLFEFSTF CJMTJOLJ 3BCCJNIFSCBL‘NEBOT‘O‘ST‘[[FOHJOEJS DÚNFSUUJSw /FNM  
BZFUJJMFEFTUFLMFOFSFLJ[BIFEJMJS
ĀàLSFUUJLÎFOJNFUMFSJOBSU‘S‘ME‘þ‘ "MMBI‘OāàLSFEJMNFZFJIUJZBD‘O‘OPMNBE‘þ‘ LVMVOIBO-
HJāBSUMBSEBPMVSTBPMTVO3BCCJOFLPāVMTV[PMBSBLāàLSFUNFTJHFSFLUJþJJ[BIFEJMJS

:ÚOUFNWF5FLOJLMFS
3PM0ZOBNB

.BUFSZBM
0LVNBNFUOJ


ĀÃ,Ã3

&ULJOMJL
ZBā
½þSFUJDJ .FTOFWJEFHFÎFOāàLàSJMFBMBLBM‘IJLÉZFZJTFTMJCJSāFLJMEFPLVS UFLSBST‘O‘GUBO
CJSÎPDVþBPLVUUVSVSWFCJSCBāLBÎPDVþVOEBIJLÉZFZJÚ[FUMFNFTJOJJTUFS)JLÉZFOJOJZJDF
BOMBā‘ME‘þ‘OEBO FNJO PMEVLUBO TPOSB IJLÉZFEF HFÎFO LBISBNBOMBS CFMJSMFOJS  LVMMBO‘MBDBL
LPTUàNMFSTFÎJMJSWFJTUFZFOÎPDVLMBSBSPMMFSEBþ‘U‘M‘S

0LVNB.FUOJ
4","/*/&Ā&ýÿÿ-&"3"1"5-"3*
4VUBā‘ZBSBLHFÎJNJOJTBþMBZBOCJSBEBNWBSE‘#VBEBN‘OCJSEFTVUBā‘NBLUBOT‘SU‘ÎFN-
CFSHJCJJLJCàLMàNPMNVā T‘SU‘OEBBþ‘SZàLUFOBΑMN‘āZà[MFSDFZBSBT‘PMBOCJSFāFþJWBSE‘
&āFLPLBEBSQFSJāBOWFLÚUàIBMEFZEJLJBSU‘LÚMNFLCJMFPOVOJÎJOCJSLVSUVMVāUV"SQB
OFSEFy,VSVPUVCJMFCVMBN‘ZPS POVOMBCJMFLBSO‘O‘EPZVSBN‘ZPSEV#JSZBOEBOT‘SU‘OEB
ZBSBWBSE‘CJSZBOEBOEBTBIJCJEFNJSCJSÎVCVLMBPOVEàSUàQEVSVZPSEV
1BEJāBI‘O BI‘S HÚSFWMJTJ FāFþJ HÚSàQ BD‘E‘ &āFþJO TBIJCJZMF EPTUMVþV WBSE‘ 0OB TFMBN
WFSEJ i#VFāFLOFEFOCÚZMFJLJCàLMàNPMNVā wEJZFTPSEV
"EBN i#FOJNZPLTVMMVþVN CFOJNLVTVSVNZà[àOEFO CVBþ[‘EJMJCBþM‘IBZWBO ZJZF-
DFLTBNBOCJMFCVMBN‘ZPSwEFEJ
"I‘SHÚSFWMJTJ i4FOCJSLBÎHàOMàþàOFPOVCBOBWFSEFQBEJāBI‘OBI‘S‘OEBLBM‘QCFTMFO-
TJO LVWWFUMFOTJOwEFEJ
"EBN FāFþJPNFSIBNFUMJLJāJZFWFSEJ0EBPOVQBEJāBI‘OBI‘S‘OBCBþMBE‘&āFL IFS
ZBOEB UBWM‘  TFNJ[  Hà[FM WF HFOÎ "SBQ BUMBS‘O‘ HÚSEà "ZBL CBTU‘LMBS‘ ZFSMFS TàQàSàMNàā 
TVMBON‘āU‘4BNBOEBUBNWBLUJOEFHFMJZPSEV BSQBEB
"UMBS‘OU‘NBS‘O‘EBHÚSàODF CBā‘O‘HÚþFLBME‘S‘Qi&ZZàDF"MMBI‘N%JZFMJNLJCFOCJS
FāFþJN BNBTFOJOZBSBUU‘þ‘OCJSIBZWBOEFþJMNJZJN /FEFOCÚZMFQFSJāBO‘N OFEFOT‘SU‘N
ZBSBM‘  OFEFO [BZ‘G‘N  (FDFMFSJ T‘SU‘N‘O BD‘T‘OEBO  LBSO‘N‘O BÎM‘þ‘OEBO IFS BO ÚMàNàNà
JTUJZPSVN #V BUMBS‘O IÉMMFSJ JTF CÚZMF NàLFNNFM  H‘EBMBS‘ ZFSJOEF 1FLJ  OFEFO B[BQ WF
CFMBZBMO‘[CBOBNBITVT wEFSLFO BOT‘[‘OTBWBāLPQUV"SBQBUMBS‘OBFþFSMFSWVSVQTBWBāB
TàSEàMFS0OMBS EàāNBOEBOPLMBSZFEJMFS)FSZBOMBS‘OBN‘[SBLMBSTBQMBOE‘4BWBāUBOHFSJ
EÚOFCJMFOMFSJOIFQTJEFQFSJāBOCJSIBMEFBI‘SBEàāUàMFS"ZBLMBS‘TBþMBNJQMFSMFNàLFNNFM
CBþMBOE‘/BMCBOUMBST‘SBT‘SBEJ[JMEJ)BOÎFSMFSMFBUMBS‘OCFEFOMFSJOJZBS‘ZPS ZBSBMBSEBON‘[-
SBLMBS‘ PLMBS‘ΑLBS‘ZPSMBSE‘
&āFLCVOMBS‘HÚSàODFEFEJLJi:B3BCCJ#FOZPLTVMMVþVNBWFTBþM‘þBSB[‘Z‘N0Hà[FM
H‘EBMBS‘EBJTUFNFN PÎJSLJOZBSBMBS‘EB#BāLBMBS‘O‘OOJNFUMFSJOEFHÚ[àNZPL CBOBWFS-
EJþJOOJNFUMFSJÎJOTBOBTPOTV[āàLàSMFSPMTVOw .FTOFWJEFO)JLÉZFMFS DJMU7 CFZJUOP



ĀÃ,Ã3

%FþFSMFOEJSNF4PSVMBS‘
#VIJLÉZFEFBOMBU‘MNBLJTUFOFOEàāàODFOFEJS
4J[FāFþJOZFSJOEFPMTBZE‘O‘[OFZBQBSE‘O‘[
"MMBIBāàLàSOFEFNFLUJSWFOBT‘MāàLSFEFSJ[
iÿOTBOMBSBUFāFLLàSFUNFZFO "MMBIBEBāàLSFUNF[w 5JSNJ[Ô #JSSWF4‘MB  
IBEJTJāFSJmOEFBOMBU‘MNBLJTUFOFOEàāàODFOFEJS

(àOàO.FTBK‘
iĀàLSFEFSTFOJ[FMCFUUFTJ[F
OJNFUJNJ BSUU‘S‘S‘Nyw
ÿCSÉIÔN 

,BQBO‘ā
(SVQàZFMFSJOFQBZMBā‘NMBS‘JÎJOUFāFLLàSFEJO
)FSLFTJOBLM‘OEBLBMBONFTBK‘QBZMBāNBT‘O‘JTUFZJO
,POVZMBJMHJMJWBSTBTPSVMBS‘O‘BM‘OWFDFWBQMBZ‘O
#JSTPOSBLJLPOVOVOCBāM‘þ‘O‘WFSJOWFWFEBMBā‘O


ĀÃ,Ã3

/"4*-ĀÃ,3&5.&-ÿ:ÿ; 
,B[BO‘N
"MMBIBOBT‘MāàLSFUNFTJHFSFLUJþJOJCJMJS )FSOJNFUJOāàLSàLFOEJDJOTJOEFOEJS

½þSFUJDJ/PUV
½þSFUJDJ ,VSBOEBOBOMBE‘þ‘N‘[BHÚSF"MMBIBāàLSàOàÎāFLJMEFHFSÎFLMFāUJþJOJBāBþ‘EBLJ
JGBEFMFSMFJ[BIFEFS
B %JMJMFāàLàS/JNFUTBIJCJOJBONBL 0OVÚWNFL 0OVOOJNFUTBIJCJPMEVþVOB
JNBOFUNFLWFCVOVUFWIJULFMJNFTJZMFJMBOFUNFLMFPMVS#VCBTJUCJSUFāFLLàSJGBEFTJEFþJM 
EJMJMFāFIBEFUHFUJSNFL EPþSVTÚ[MàPMNBL ,VSBO‘UBTEJLFUNFL POVPLVNBLWF"MMBI‘
ÎPLÎB[JLSFUNFLWFCVOBCFO[FSEJMJMFJMHJMJLVMMVLHÚSFWMFSJOJZBQNBLMBZFSJOFHFUJSJMJS
C  ,BMQ JMF āàLàS ÿNBO‘ LBMCF ZFSMFāUJSEJLUFO TPOSB OJNFU TBIJCJOJO "MMBI PMEVþVOV
LBMQJMFUBTEJLFUNFLWFLBMCJPOVOTFWHJTJZMFEPMEVSNBLU‘S
D 'JJMJMFāàLàS/JNFUWFSFOFJUBBUFUNFLWF0OVOCàUàOFNJSMFSJOJZFSJOFHFUJSNFL
JÎJOIFSUàSMàHBZSFUWFÎBCBZ‘BLUJGPMBSBLPSUBZBLPZNBLU‘S,‘TBDBÿTMBN‘OFNJSWFZBTBLMB-
S‘O‘IFSCBL‘NEBOZBāBNBZBÎBM‘āNBLU‘S±àOLàOJNFUWFSFOJCJMJQ0OVÚWNFL CJSBOMBNEB
0OEBOHFMFOIFSāFZJLBCVMFUNFLEFNFLUJS
½þSFUJDJ ZVLBS‘EBLJBΑLMBNBMBS‘OUBNBN‘O‘LBQTBZBDBLāFLJMEF IFSOJNFUJOāàLSàOàO
LFOEJDJOTJJMFZBQ‘ME‘þ‘O‘WVSHVMBS.FTFMBTBþM‘LOJNFUJOJOāàLSàOàO LFOEJTBþM‘þ‘O‘OL‘Z-
NFUJOJCJMFSFL TBþM‘O‘ZJUJSFOMFSFZBSE‘ND‘PMBSBL POMBS‘[JZBSFUFEFSFL[FOHJOMJþJOāàLSà-
OàO NBMJJCBEFUMFSJZFSJOFHFUJSFSFLWFEàāLàOMFSJLPMMBZBSBLZFSJOFHFUJSJMEJþJOJBOMBU‘S

:ÚOUFNWF5FLOJLMFS
3PM0ZOBNB

.BUFSZBM
,BSUPO


ĀÃ,Ã3

&ULJOMJL
ZBā
#JS JOTBOEB WBS PMBO PSHBOMBS TBZ‘T‘ODB ÎPDVL BZBþB LBME‘S‘M‘S ½SOFþJO LBMQ  BLDJþFS 
CFZJO CÚCSFL HÚ[ LVMBL CVSVO Bþ‘[ LPMWFCBDBLMBS LBO LBSBDJþFSWC
½þSFUJDJ  ÚODFEFO CàZàL CJS LBSUPOB ÎJ[JMNJā CJS JOTBO WàDVEV SFTNJ HFUJSFCJMJS WFZB
ÎPDVLMBSMBCJSMJLUFNBM[FNFMFSJLVMMBOBSBLCJSJOTBOWàDVEVSFTNJOJLBCBUBTMBLCJSāFLJMEF
ÎJ[FSFL EVWBSB BTBSMBS ÿTUFOJSTF JOTBO WàDVEV EVWBSB EB ÎJ[JMFCJMJS ±PDVLMBS‘O IFS CJSJ
WàDVEVOCJSPSHBO‘PMVSWFSFTJNEFCVMVONBMBS‘HFSFLFOZFSFZFSMFāNJāHJCJLPOVNMBO‘SMBS
)FSCJSÎPDVLCJSPSHBO‘OHÚSFWMFSJOJTBZBSWFPSHBOMBS‘O"MMBIhBOBT‘MUFāFLLàSFEFCJMFDFLMFSJOJ
TÚZMFS
,BMQÿOTBOWàDVEVOVOTPMVOEBZBāBS‘N#FOWàDVEVOIBZBUPSHBO‘Z‘N IJÎEVSNBEBO
ÎBM‘ā‘STàSFLMJEJþFSPSHBOMBSBLBOQPNQBMBS‘N5BCJJ%JþFSPSHBOMBS‘OIJÎCJSJOEFPMNBZBO
ÚZMF CJS Ú[FMMJþJN WBS LJ "MMBIh‘  QFZHBNCFSJ  JOTBOMBS‘  BþBÎMBS‘  LVāMBS‘  ÎJÎFLMFSJ IFQ
TFWFSJN,ÚUàEàāàODFMFS LJO OFGSFU L‘TLBOÎM‘L ZBMBOFOTFWNFEJþJNEVZHVMBS/FPMVS
CVEVZHVMBSMBCFOJJODJUNFZJOPMVSNV "MMBICFOJHÚ[HÚ[PEBMBSEBOZBSBUN‘ā EBNBSMBSMB
CF[FNJā  CJS NBLJOF HJCJ QSPHSBNMBN‘ā  CVOEBO EPMBZ‘ "MMBIhB UFāFLLàS FEFSJN ,BMQ
SPMàOEFLJÎPDVLLBMQHJCJBUNBIBSFLFUJZBQBS IFZFDBOM‘WFEVZHVTBMLPOVāVS,BSUPOEBO
ZBQ‘MN‘āCJSLBMQSFTNJEFÎPDVþVOCPZOVOBBT‘MBCJMJS
"LDJþFS&WJNJOBESFTJHÚþàTLBGFTJDBEEFTJ,BSEFāJNMFCFSBCFSCVSBEBZBā‘ZPSV[(FDF
HàOEà[EVSNBEBOÎBM‘ā‘ZPSV[#JSHàOCJMFUBUJMāBOT‘N‘[ZPL0LTJKFOJNJ[LFTJMEJþJBOEB
JāMFWJNJ[TPOBFSFS#J[JNWàDVEBHÚOEFSEJþJNJ[PLTJKFOLBO‘UFNJ[MJZPS#J[JFOÎPLà[FOāFZ
TJHBSBEVNBO‘ZMBLJSMFONFL&þFSIBWBN‘[PMNB[TBCàUàOPSHBOMBS‘N‘[JnBTFEFS"MMBIh‘O
CJ[F WFSNJā PMEVþV CV OJNFUUFO EPMBZ‘ UFāFLLàS FEFSJN ÿLJ ÎPDVL CJSMJLUF DBOMBOE‘SNB
ZBQBSWFCFSBCFSLPOVāVS OFGFTBM‘QWFSNFIBSFLFUJZBQBSMBS
#FZJO 7àDVEVO LPOUSPM NFSLF[J CFOJN %àāàONF  NBOU‘L  TPZVUMBNB HJCJ LBSNBā‘L
FZMFNMFSJCFOZBQBS‘N#FOPMNBTBNOFLBMQOFEFEJþFSPSHBOMBSJāMFWMFSJOJZàSàUàS#FEFOJ
BZBLUBUVUBO HÚ[àOHÚSNFTJOJTBþMBZBO IBSFLFUGPOLTJZPOVOVZFSJOFHFUJSFOCFOJN:ÚOFUJN
CFOJNFMJNEF"MMBIV5FÉMÉCVZÚOFUJDJMJLJāJOJCBOBWFSEJþJJÎJOÎPLUFāFLLàSFEFSJN #FZJO
SPMàOEFLJÎPDVLCJMNJāCJMNJāLPOVāVS CJSHÚ[MàLUBLBCJMJS
#ÚCSFL #FM CÚMHFTJOEF LBSO‘O BSLBT‘OEB TBþ UBSBGUB ZBā‘ZPSVN 4PM UBSBGUB JTF EJþFS
LPNāVNCÚCSFLMFCFSBCFSLBOEBLJ[FIJSMJNBEEFMFSJUFNJ[MFSWFCVOMBS‘JESBSZPMVJMFE‘āBS‘
BUBS‘[&þFSCJ[HÚSFWJNJ[JZFSJOFHFUJSNF[TFL[FIJSMJNBEEFMFSLBOBLBS‘ā‘S WàDVUāJāFSWF
EJþFSPSHBOMBSJāMFWJOJZFSJOFHFUJSFNF[#VHÚSFWJZFSJOFHFUJSFCJMEJþJNJ[JÎJO"MMBIV5FÉMÉhZB
OFLBEBSUFāFLLàSFUTFLB[E‘S ÿLJÎPDVLCJSMJLUFLPOVāVS LàÎàLCJSÎPDVLHJCJEBWSBOBSBL
SPMZBQBSMBS


ĀÃ,Ã3

(àOàO.FTBK‘
i7F"MMBITJ[JBOBMBS‘O‘[‘OLBS‘OMBS‘OEBO
IJÎCJSāFZCJMNF[CJSIÉMEFΑLBSE‘ÚZMF
JLFOTJ[FJāJUNF HÚ[MFS LBMQMFSWFSEJLJ
āàLSFEFTJOJ[w
/BIM 

,BQBO‘ā
(SVQàZFMFSJOFQBZMBā‘NMBS‘JÎJOUFāFLLàSFEJO
)FSLFTJOBLM‘OEBLBMBONFTBK‘QBZMBāNBT‘O‘JTUFZJO
,POVZMBJMHJMJWBSTBTPSVMBS‘O‘BM‘OWFDFWBQMBZ‘O
#JSTPOSBLJLPOVOVOCBāM‘þ‘O‘WFSJOWFWFEBMBā‘O


ĀÃ,Ã3

½þSFUJDJ/PUV
"MMBI‘OWFSEJþJTBZ‘T‘[OJNFUMFSIBUS‘OBPOEBOHFMFOJNUJIBOMBSBEBOBOLÚSMàLFUNFEFO
JZJHàOMFSIBUS‘OB[PSHàOMFSEFEF"MMBIBāàLSFUNFTJHFSFLUJþJJ[BIFEJMJS

:ÚOUFNWF5FLOJLMFS
"OMBU‘N 4PSV$FWBQ

.BUFSZBM
½SOFLPMBZNFUOJ

&ULJOMJL
ZBā 
½þSFUJDJ CVEFSTUFÎPDVLMBSBi/BT‘MāàLSFEFSTJOJ[ wEJZFTPSBSWFDFWBQMBS‘O‘EJOMFS½þ-
SFUJDJEBIBTPOSB i±PDVLMBS :àDF3BCCJNJ[FWFSEJþJIFSOJNFUJÎJOāàLSFUNFMJZJ[ IBZBU‘-
N‘[EBLJÎFāJUMJT‘L‘OU‘MBSBCJ[FWFSEJþJJZJMJLMFSIBU‘S‘OBTBCSFEJQ IFSāFZEF0OBIBNEFUNF-
MJZJ[wEFS
#VBΑLMBNBEBOTPOSBÚþSFUJDJÎPDVLMBSBCJSIJLÉZFPLVZBDBþ‘O‘WFÎPDVLMBS‘OLFOEJTJOJ
EJLLBUMJCJSāFLJMEFEJOMFNFMFSJHFSFLUJþJOJTÚZMFS½SOFLPMBZNFUOJOEFOTPOSBEBÎPDVLMBSB
TPSVMBSTPSBSBLLPOVZVQFLJāUJSJS

½SOFL0MBZ.FUOJ
"$*,"76/
-PLNBO BE‘OEB  UFNJ[ LBMQMJ  FGFOEJ NJ FGFOEJ  LJNTFTJ[ CJS HFOÎ WBSE‘ ÿZJ LBMQMJ CJS
BEBNPOBTBIJQΑLU‘-PLNBO‘FWJOFBME‘&WMBE‘HJCJTFWJQCFOJNTFEJ
-PLNBO JODFSVIMV ÎBM‘āLBOCJSHFOÎUJ0EBLFOEJTJOFNFSIBNFUHÚTUFSFOCVBEBNDB-
þ‘[BHÚOàMEFOCBþMBOE‘0OVCBCBT‘HJCJTFWEJÿāMFSJOEFDBOMBCBāMBPOBZBSE‘NFUUJ#ÚZMFDF
BSBMBS‘OEBLJTFWHJCBþ‘HJEFSFLHàÎMFOEJ"EBN CVÎBM‘āLBOHFODJOFNFLMFSJOJEFLBSā‘M‘LT‘[
C‘SBLNB[OFZFTFPOBEBZFEJSJS OFHJZTFPOBEBHJZEJSJSEJ½ZMFLJCJSMJLUFTPGSBZBPUVSEVL-
MBS‘OEB-PLNBOZFNFþFCBāMBNBEBOBþ[‘OBMPLNBLPZNB[E‘
ÿāUFZJOFCÚZMFCJSHàOBEBNBIFEJZFPMBSBLCJSLBWVOHFMEJ"EBN LBWVOVBM‘Q-PL-
NBO‘ZBO‘OBÎBþ‘SE‘,BWVOEBOCJSEJMJNLFTJQÚODFPOBV[BUU‘-PLNBOLBWVOEJMJNJOJBM‘Q
JāUBIMB ZFNFþF CBāMBE‘ (FODJO LBWVOV TFWFSFL ZFNFTJ BEBN‘ NVUMV FUNJāUJ ,FOEJTJ IJÎ
UBE‘OBCBLNBEBOLFTJQCJSEJMJNEBIBWFSEJ-PLNBOPEJMJNJEFJāUBIMBZJZJQCJUJSEJ½ZMF
LJBEBN LBWVOEBOLFOEJTJZFNFZFL‘ZBNBE‘ EJMJNEJMJN-PLNBOBJLSBNFUNFZJTàSEàSEà
-PLNBOCÚZMFDFUBNPOZFEJEJMJNLBWVOZFEJ

111
ĀÃ,Ã3

(FSJZFLBMBLBMBCJSEJMJNLBMN‘āU‘"EBN i-PLNBOCÚZMFJāUBIM‘ZFEJþJOFHÚSFCBLBM‘N
OFLBEBSUBUM‘CJSLBWVONVā wEJZFSFLTPOEJMJNJEFLFOEJOFBZ‘SE‘'BLBUFMJOEFLJLBWVO
EJMJNJOJ‘T‘S‘S‘T‘SNB[PMBOMBSPMEV"EBN‘O‘T‘SE‘þ‘TBOLJLBWVOEBOEFþJM [FIJSEFOCJSMPL-
NBZE‘%JMJBMFWBMFWZBONBZB CPþB[‘BþS‘NBZB HÚ[àOEFOZBāMBSJONFZFCBāMBE‘½ZMFLJ 
Bþ[‘O‘O BD‘T‘OEBO OFSFEFZTF EàāàQ CBZ‘MBDBLU‘ "þ[‘O‘ CJSLBÎ ZVEVN TVZMB ÎBMLBMBE‘LUBO
TPOSBBD‘T‘CJSB[IBmnFZJODF -PLNBOBEÚOFSFL
i"DBO‘N CVLBEBSBD‘CJSLBWVOVOBT‘MZJZFCJMEJOwEJZFTPSEVw#VOVOOFTJHà[FMLJ
:PLTBTBOBBD‘HFMNFEJNJ w
-PLNBOCBā‘O‘ÚOFFþFSFLNBIDVCJZFUJÎJOEFHàMàNTFEJ
&GFOEJN EFEJ4FOJOFMJOEFOCVHàOFLBEBSÚZMFÎPLāFZZJZJQJÎUJNLJy#BOBFWJOJ 
PDBþ‘O‘ TPGSBO‘BÎU‘O#VODBZ‘MLPSVZVQLPMMBE‘O#FO CBOBCÚZMFTJOFJZJMJLMFSFEFOCJSJOJO
V[BUU‘þ‘MPLNBZBOBT‘MBD‘EFSJN #ÚZMFCJSāFZZBQBSTBN OBOLÚSMàLFUNJāPMNB[N‘Z‘N 
"ZS‘DBTFWHJZMFBD‘MBSCBMPMVS4J[FPMBOTFWHJNEFO LBWVOEBOBD‘CJSUBUBMNBE‘N
"EBN CVTÚ[MFSMFNVUMVPMEV-PLNBO‘OTFWHJTJZMFCJSLF[EBIBIV[VSCVMEVÿZJMJLMFSJ
VOVUNBZBOCVHFODJPHàOEFOTPOSBEBIBEBÎPLTFWEJ %JOÔ%FþFSMFS4FSJTJ i.JOOFUUBS-
M‘Lw %JZBOFUÿāMFSJ#BāLBOM‘þ‘#BTL‘ "OLBSB T 
½þSFUJDJBāBþ‘EBLJTPSVMBSMBEFSTJUBNBNMBS

ĀÃ,3Ã4&7&/ÿ/4"//"4*-0-63

,FOEJTJOFWFSJMFOUàNOJNFUMFSJO"MMBIUBOPMEVþVOVCJMJS

#JSJZJMJLHÚSEàþàOEFJZJMJLMFLBSā‘M‘LWFSJS

"MMBIBāàLSFEFS

ÿOTBOMBSBUFāFLLàSFEFS

$ÚNFSUPMVS

7FGBM‘PMVS

112
ĀÃ,Ã3

%FþFSMFOEJSNF4PSVMBS‘
-PLNBO OFEFOBD‘LBWVOVZFNJāUJS
-PLNBO‘OZFSJOEFPMTBZE‘O‘[TJ[BD‘LBWVOVZFSNJZEJOJ[
)BZBUUBLBSā‘MBāU‘þ‘N‘[T‘L‘OU‘MBSJÎFSJTJOEFHà[FMMJLMFSJHÚSNFOJOCJ[FOFMFSLBUU‘þ‘IBL-
L‘OEBLPOVāBM‘NN‘

(àOàO.FTBK‘
i½ZMFZTFZBMO‘[CFOJBO‘OLJCFOEFTJ[J
BOBZ‘N#BOBāàLSFEJO TBL‘OOBOLÚSMàL
FUNFZJOw
#BLBSB 

,BQBO‘ā
(SVQàZFMFSJOFQBZMBā‘NMBS‘JÎJOUFāFLLàSFEJO
)FSLFTJOBLM‘OEBLBMBONFTBK‘QBZMBāNBT‘O‘JTUFZJO
,POVZMBJMHJMJWBSTBTPSVMBS‘O‘BM‘OWFDFWBQMBZ‘O
#JSTPOSBLJLPOVOVOCBāM‘þ‘O‘WFSJOWFWFEBMBā‘O

113
15
à . ÿ 5 7" 3  0 - . "

iÃNJUwLBWSBN‘O‘WFNBIJZFUJOJCJMJS
)[.VIBNNFEJO TBT FO[PSEVSVNMBSEBCJMF"MMBIUBOàNJU
LFTNFEJþJOJCJMJS
ÃNJUFUNFOJO"MMBI‘OSBINFUJOFT‘þ‘ONBLPMEVþVOVCJMJS"MMBI‘O DD 
SBINFUJOJO BGG‘O‘O ZBSE‘N‘O‘OTPOTV[PMEVþVOVCJMJS
à . ÿ 5 7" 3  0 - . "

Ã.ÿ5,"73".*
,B[BO‘N
iÃNJUwLBWSBN‘O‘WFNBIJZFUJOJCJMJS

½þSFUJDJ/PUV
5BIUBZB CàZàL IBSnFSMF iàNJUw LBWSBN‘ ZB[‘M‘S WF àNJUWBS PMNBO‘O BOMBN‘ ÎPDVLMBSB
TPSVMVS#ÚZMFMJLMFTPSVDFWBQZÚOUFNJZMFLPOVZBHJSJāZBQ‘MN‘āPMVS,VSBOBHÚSF àNJUWBS
PMNBO‘O āBSUMBSOFPMVSTBPMTVO PMBZMBSOFZÚOEFHFMJāJSTFHFMJāTJO à[àOUàZFLBQ‘MNBEBOWF
LBZH‘MBONBEBO PMVNTV[EVSVNMBS‘OEBIJFOIBZ‘SM‘āFLJMEFTPOVÎMBOBDBþ‘OBJOBO‘Q "MMBIB
HàWFONFLPMEVþVBΑLMBO‘S%àOZBO‘OCJSJNUJIBOZFSJPMEVþVCVJNUJIBOJÎJOEFJOTBO‘O 
ÚNSàCPZVODBQFLÎPL[PSMVLWFT‘L‘OU‘MBSMBEFOFOEJþJBOMBU‘M‘S)BTUBMBONBL JāJOEFCBāBS‘
T‘[PMNBL BSBCBZMBLB[BZBQNBL ZBSBMBONBL ÚOFNMJCJST‘OBW‘LB[BOBNBNBL TFWEJLMFSJOJ
LBZCFUNFL JGUJSBZBVþSBNBLHJCJà[àDàIBEJTFMFSJOIFSLFTJOCBā‘OBHFMFCJMFDFþJWVSHVMBO‘S
,VSBO‘OÚþSFUJTJOEFOV[BLZBāBZBOJOTBOMBS‘OHFMJāFOCVPMBZMBSLBSā‘T‘OEBEBIBÎPLTBS
T‘ME‘þ‘ HJUUJLÎFEBIBLBSBNTBSWFàNJUTJ[CJSSVIIÉMJOFCàSàOEàLMFSJàNJUTJ[MJLOFEFOJZMF
CàUàOFOFSKJMFSJOJ HàÎMFSJOJ IFZFDBOMBS‘O‘LBZCFUUJLMFSJBOMBU‘M‘S
"ZO‘ āBSUMBSEB  "MMBIB UFWFLLàM FEFO CJS .àTMàNBO‘O JTF PMBZMBS‘O VNEVþV HJCJ HFS
ÎFLMFāNFNFTJEVSVNVOEBCJMFCJSIBEJTFOJOIBZ‘SM‘UBSBG‘O‘HÚSNFZFÎBM‘āU‘þ‘CBā‘OBHFMFO
PMVNTV[MVLMBS‘OTPOTV[SBINFUWFNFSIBNFUTBIJCJ"MMBI‘OUBLEJSJPMEVþVOVEàāàOEàþà
CFMJSUJMJSÿNBOFEFOLJNTFOJO"MMBI‘OIFSāFZJNVUMBLBCàZàLCJSIJLNFUMFZBSBUU‘þ‘OBJOBO
E‘þ‘i0MVSLJIPāVOV[BHJUNFZFOCJSāFZ TJ[JOJÎJOIBZ‘SM‘E‘Sw #BLBSB  BZFUJOEF
JāBSFUFEJMEJþJHJCJāFSHJCJHÚSàOFOCJSPMBZ‘OBSE‘OEB"MMBI‘OBTM‘OEBLFOEJTJJÎJOCJSIBZ‘S
WFHà[FMMJLZBSBUU‘þ‘O‘CJMEJþJJGBEFFEJMJS
:VTVGL‘TTBT‘OEBOàNJUWBSPMNBÚSOFLMFSJ :VTVGVO BT LVZVEBOLVSUVMNBT‘ [JOEBO
EBOΑLBSU‘MNBT‘ )[:BLVQVOHÚ[MFSJOJOZFOJEFOBΑMNBT‘ BZS‘OU‘M‘CJSCJÎJNEFBOMBU‘M‘S

116
à . ÿ 5 7" 3  0 - . "

:ÚOUFNWF5FLOJL
"OMBU‘N .BUFSZBM)B[‘SMBNB

.BUFSZBM
3FOLMJGPOLBSUPOMBS‘

&ULJOMJL
ZBā
½þSFUJDJ CVBΑLMBNBMBS‘OBSE‘OEBOi&ZPþVMMBS‘N(JEJOEF:VTVGVWFLBSEFāJOJJZJDF
BSBāU‘S‘O "MMBI‘OSBINFUJOEFOàNJULFTNFZJO±àOLàLÉmSMFSUPQMVMVþVOEBOCBāLBT‘"M
MBI‘OSBINFUJOEFOàNJULFTNF[w :ßTVG  BZFUJLFSJNFTJOJPLVSWFÎPDVLMBSMBCJSMJLUF
UBSU‘ā‘S
½þSFUJDJ ÎPDVLMBS‘FSMJHSVQMBSBBZ‘SBSBLàNJUWBSPMNBLIBLL‘OEBTMPHBOCVMNBMBS‘O‘
WFCVMEVLMBS‘TMPHBO‘ZB[BSBLBmāIB[‘SMBNBMBS‘O‘JTUFS)B[‘SMBOBOBmāMFSBT‘M‘QTFSHJMFOJS

%FþFSMFOEJSNF4PSVMBS‘
)[:VTVGVOIBZBU‘OEBàNJUWBSPMNBÚSOFLMFSJOFMFSEJS
,FOEJIBZBU‘O‘[EBOàNJUWBSPMNBÚSOFþJWFSFCJMJSNJTJOJ[
"SLBEBāMBS‘O‘[‘OIB[‘SMBE‘þ‘TMPHBOMBSJÎJOEFFOTFWEJþJOJ[IBOHJTJEJS

(àOàO.FTBK‘
i4BL‘OàNJUTJ[MJþFLBQ‘MBOMBSEBO
PMNByw
)JDS 

,BQBO‘ā
(SVQàZFMFSJOFQBZMBā‘NMBS‘JÎJOUFāFLLàSFEJO
)FSLFTJOBLM‘OEBLBMBONFTBK‘QBZMBāNBT‘O‘JTUFZJO
,POVZMBJMHJMJWBSTBTPSVMBS‘O‘BM‘OWFDFWBQMBZ‘O
#JSTPOSBLJLPOVOVOCBāM‘þ‘O‘WFSJOWFWFEBMBā‘O

117
à . ÿ 5 7" 3  0 - . "

½þSFUJDJ/PUV
½þSFUJDJTFMBNWFSFSFLT‘O‘GBHJSFSWFÎPDVLMBSJMFCJSTàSFTPICFUFEFS#VTPICFUFTOBT‘OEB
àNJULBWSBNMBS‘O‘OÎBþS‘ā‘NMBS‘à[FSJOFLPOVāVSMBS,POVJMFJMHJMJLBWSBNTBMCJMHJÚþSFUJDJ
UBSBG‘OEBOWFSJMJS%BIBTPOSBÚþSFUJDJ ÎPDVLMBSBCJSMJLUFL‘TBCJSmMNTFZSFEFDFLMFSJOJTÚZ
MFS

:ÚOUFNWF5FLOJLMFS
&þJUTFM0ZVO

.BUFSZBM
3FOLMJLBSUPO [CJMHJTBZBS WJEFPHÚSàOUàTà
IUUQTXXXZPVUVCFDPNXBUDI WPO'[:&BESFTJOEFOVMBā‘MBCJMJS

&ULJOMJL
ZBā
'JMNCJUUJLUFOTPOSBÚþSFUJDJÚODFTJOEFIB[‘SMBE‘þ‘LàÎàLSFOLMJLÉþ‘UMBS‘ÎPDVLMBSBEB
þ‘UBDBLWFTPSVMBSBDFWBQWFSNFMFSJOJJTUFZFDFLUJS)FSCJSLÉþ‘E‘Oà[FSJOEFBZO‘TPSVMBSZFS
BMBDBLU‘S
#VWJEFPEBFOÎPLFULJMFOEJþJOJ[DàNMFIBOHJTJEJS
#VLJāJZMFUBO‘āNBLJTUFSNJZEJOJ[ OFEFO 
5BO‘āNBJNLÉO‘O‘[PMTBZE‘POBTÚZMFNFLJTUFEJþJOJ[CJSāFZPMVSNVZEV
7FSJMFODFWBQMBSà[FSJOFTBNJNJCJSTPICFUPSUBN‘PMVāUVSVMVS½þSFUJDJ WFSJMFODFWBQMBS‘
EFþFSMFOEJSJSWFàNJUWBSPMNBLBE‘OBHFSFLMJZÚOMFOEJSNFZJZBQBS"ZS‘DBL‘TBmMNJMFJMHJMJ
EàāàODFMFSJOJQBZMBāNBLJTUFZFOÎPDVLMBSPMVSTBÚþSFUJDJCÚZMFCJSLPOVāNBZBEBJNLÉO
UBO‘S%BIBTPOSBÚþSFUJDJiàNJUwLBWSBN‘O‘WFNBIJZFUJOJÎPDVLMBSBBΑLMBS7JEFPEBTFZSF
EJMFOCÚMàNMFSJMFCBþMBOU‘LVSBSBL àNJUWBSLJāJOJOEBWSBO‘āÚ[FMMJLMFSJJMFJMHJMJCJMHJWFSJS
.àDBEFMFFUNFOJO B[JNMJPMNBO‘O JOBOD‘O‘LBZCFUNFNFOJOÚOFNJà[FSJOEFEVSVS

%FþFSMFOEJSNF4PSVMBS‘
ÃNJUWBSPMNBLOFEFNFLUJS
)JÎCJS[BNBOVNVEVOVLBZCFUNFZFO IFS[BNBOIBZBUBVNVUMBCBLBOJOTBOMBS‘O
LJāJMJLÚ[FMMJLMFSJOFMFSEJS
6NVEVOVLPMBZM‘LMBLBZCFEFCJMFOLJāJMFSJOIBZBUUBLBSā‘MBāBDBþ‘[PSMVLMBSTJ[DFOFMFS
PMBCJMJS


à . ÿ 5 7" 3  0 - . "

(àOàO.FTBK‘
i#JSLVMVOLBMCJOEFàNJUWFLPSLV
CJSMFāUJþJOEF "MMBIPLVMVOàNJUFUUJþJāFZJ
NVUMBLBWFSJSWFLPSLUVþVāFZEFOEFPOV
FNJOL‘MBSw
5JSNJ[Ô $FOBJ[ 

,BQBO‘ā
(SVQàZFMFSJOFQBZMBā‘NMBS‘JÎJOUFāFLLàSFEJO
)FSLFTJOBLM‘OEBLBMBONFTBK‘QBZMBāNBT‘O‘JTUFZJO
,POVZMBJMHJMJWBSTBTPSVMBS‘O‘BM‘OWFDFWBQMBZ‘O
#JSTPOSBLJLPOVOVOCBāM‘þ‘O‘WFSJOWFWFEBMBā‘O

119
à . ÿ 5 7" 3  0 - . "

1&:(".#&3ÿ.ÿ;%"ÿ."Ã.ÿ57"3%*
,B[BO‘N
)[.VIBNNFEJO TBT FO[PSEVSVNMBSEBCJMF"MMBIUBOàNJULFTNFEJþJOJCJMJS

½þSFUJDJ/PUV
4FWHJMJ1FZHBNCFSJNJ[JO TBT LBSā‘MBāU‘þ‘CàUàO[PSMVLMBSMBNàDBEFMFEFTFSHJMFEJþJUV
UVNWFEBWSBO‘ā‘O IBZBU‘OPMVNTV[ZÚOMFSJZMFNàDBEFMFFUNFEF CJ[MFSFFWSFOTFMÚSOFLMFS
WFHà[FMMJLMFSLB[BOE‘SE‘þ‘BOMBU‘M‘S#VLPOVOVOLBM‘D‘M‘þ‘WFLB[BO‘NCPZVUVBOMBN‘OEBLJ
EFþFSJOJOEBIBOFUBLUBS‘MNBT‘BE‘OB 1FZHBNCFS&GFOEJNJ[JO TBT ÎPDVLMVLWFHFOÎMJL
EÚOFNMFSJOEFZBāBE‘þ‘BJMFWJWFTPTZBM[PSMVLMBSWFCVOMBSMBCJSMJLUFA1FZHBNCFSMJLWB[JGFTJ
T‘SBT‘OEBLBSā‘MBāU‘þ‘HàÎMàLMFSEFOÚSOFLMFSWFSJMFCJMJS

:ÚOUFNWF5FLOJLMFS
½SOFL0MBZÿODFMFNF 4PSV$FWBQ

.BUFSZBM
½SOFLPMBZNFUOJ

&ULJOMJL
ZBā
½þSFUJDJ CVEFSTUFÎPDVLMBSBBāBþ‘EBLJNFUOJPLVSWFÚSOFLPMBZà[FSJOEFOCJSJODFMFNF
JMF1FZHBNCFS&GFOEJNJ[JOIBZBU‘OEBOZPMBΑLBSBLàNJULPOVTVOVBOMBU‘S
½þSFUJDJ ÎPDVLMBSBi%JOJNJ[ÿTMBNVNVUTV[MVþBEàāNFZJUBTWJQFUNFNJā JNBOPMEVþV
TàSFDFJNLÉO‘OEBPMEVþVOVWVSHVMBN‘ā 1FZHBNCFS&GFOEJNJ[EF TBT IBZBU‘ZMBCVOV
CJ[FHÚTUFSNJāUJSwEFS#VBΑLMBNBEBOTPOSBÚþSFUJDJBāBþ‘EBLJNFUOJÎPDVLMBSBPLVS
Örnek Olay Metni
i)[1FZHBNCFSPZ‘MQFLÎPLBD‘ZMBT‘OBON‘āU‘½ODFCJSJDJLFāJ)BUJDFZJ TPOSBZB
ā‘OEBOCFSJLFOEJTJOFLPMLBOBUHFSFOBNDBT‘&CV5BMJQJLBZCFUNJāUJ"ZS‘DBUàNCVOMBS
ZBāBO‘SLFO.FLLFMJNàāSJLMFSEF.àTMàNBOMBSBWF)[1FZHBNCFSF[VMNFUàNāJEEFUJZMF
EFWBNFUNFLUFZEJ

120
à . ÿ 5 7" 3  0 - . "

)[1FZHBNCFSCJSÎÚ[àNZPMVCVMNBLJTUJZPSEVÿTMBNBWF.àTMàNBOMBSBLVDBLBÎBCJ
MFDFþJEàāàODFTJJMF;FZEJZBO‘OBBMBSBL5BJGFEPþSVZPMBLPZVMEV"ODBLCVSBEBJZJCJSNV
BNFMFZMFLBSā‘MBāNBE‘LMBS‘HJCJUBāMBOBSBLāFIJSEFOΑLBS‘ME‘MBS.FLLFZFà[HàOCJSāFLJMEF
EÚOFSLFO$FCSBJMLFOEJMFSJOFHÚSàOEàWFA"MMBITJ[FZBQ‘MBOMBS‘HÚSEàWFEJMFSTFO5BJGJZFSMF
CJSFUNFNJÎJOCBOBZFULJWFSEJEFEJw
½þSFUJDJCVSBEBTVTBSWFÎPDVLMBSBT‘SBZMBi)[1FZHBNCFSOFEFO5BJGFHJUNJāUJS 5BJG
MJMFSOFEFO)[1FZHBNCFSFJZJEBWSBONBN‘āMBSE‘S 4J[CÚZMFCJSEBWSBO‘āBNBSV[LBMTBO‘[
OFZBQBST‘O‘[ 4J[DF)[1FZHBNCFSOFEFNJāUJS OFZBQN‘āU‘S wHJCJTPSVMBSTPSBS5àNÎP
DVLMBS‘ODFWBQMBS‘O‘EJOMFEJLUFOTPOSBi#BLBM‘N)[1FZHBNCFSOFZBQN‘ā wEFSWFPLVNBZB
EFWBNFEFS
i)[1FZHBNCFSA)BZ‘S#FOTBEFDFPOMBS‘OOFTJMMFSJOEFO"MMBIBJCBEFUFEFDFL 0OBIJÎ
CJSāFZJPSUBLLPāNBZBDBLJOTBOMBSHFMNFTJOJEJMFSJNEFEJWF.FLLFZFEÚOàQÿTMBNEBWF
UJOFLBME‘þ‘ZFSEFOEFWBNFUUJw
½þSFUJDJ PLVNBZ‘ UBNBNMBE‘LUBO TPOSB i(ÚSEàþàOà[ HJCJ 1FZHBNCFS &GFOEJNJ[ EF IB
ZBU‘OEBQFLÎPLPMVNTV[EVSVNMBLBSā‘MBāN‘āBNBBTMBQFTFUNFNJā àNJEJOJZJUJSNFNJāUJS
,FOEJTJOJUBāMBZBSBLāFIJSMFSJOEFOΑLBSBOJOTBOMBS‘OCJMFJNBOFUNFMFSJOPLUBT‘OEBàNJEJOJ
ZJUJSNFNJāUJS#J[MFSEFIBZBU‘N‘[EBPOVÚSOFLBMBSBL[PSEVSVNMBSEBàNJUWBSPMNBM‘Z‘[wEFS

%FþFSMFOEJSNF4PSVMBS‘
ÃNJUWBSPMNBO‘OGBZEBMBS‘OFMFSEJS
)[1FZHBNCFSJOàNJUWBSPMNBT‘ZMBJMHJMJCBāLBÚSOFLMFSCJMJZPSNVTVOV[

(àOàO.FTBK‘
)[.VIBNNFEWF&CV#FLJSNBþBSBEB
TBLMBO‘SLFO)[1FZHBNCFSiÃ[àMNF "MMBI
CJ[JNMFCFSBCFSEJSwEJZPSEV"MMBIEBPOMBSB
IV[VSWFHàWFOEVZHVTVJOEJSNJāUJ
5FWCF 

,BQBO‘ā
(SVQàZFMFSJOFQBZMBā‘NMBS‘JÎJOUFāFLLàSFEJO
)FSLFTJOBLM‘OEBLBMBONFTBK‘QBZMBāNBT‘O‘JTUFZJO
,POVZMBJMHJMJWBSTBTPSVMBS‘O‘BM‘OWFDFWBQMBZ‘O
#JSTPOSBLJLPOVOVOCBāM‘þ‘O‘WFSJOWFWFEBMBā‘O

121
à . ÿ 5 7" 3  0 - . "

½þSFUJDJ/PUV
;PSMVLMBSLBSā‘T‘OEB"MMBIUBOàNJULFTNFNFOJOWFàNJUWBSPMNBO‘OÚOFNJBΑLMBO‘S

:ÚOUFNWF5FLOJL
3PM0ZOBNB

.BUFSZBM
0LVNBQBSÎBT‘

&ULJOMJL
ZBā
½þSFUJDJT‘O‘GBHJSFS LPOVZBL‘TBCJSHJSJāZBQU‘LUBOTPOSBCJSÚZLàPLVZBDBþ‘O‘TÚZMFZF
SFLÎPDVLMBSEBOÚZLàZàEJLLBUMJDFEJOMFNFMFSJOJJTUFS½ZLàPLVOVSLFOIBmGCJSGPONà[JþJ
EFLVMMBO‘MBCJMJS½ZLàPLVOEVLUBOTPOSBBOMBā‘MNBT‘JÎJOCJSLBÎÎPDVLUBOÚZLàOàOÚ[FU
MFONFTJJTUFOJS½ZLàOàOTPOVOEBSPMMFSCFMJSMFOJS LPTUàNMFSIB[‘SMBO‘SWFJTUFZFOÎPDVLMBSB
EBþ‘U‘M‘SÿTUFOJSTFNFUOFCBþM‘LBMBSBLWFZBEPþBÎMBNBāFLMJOEFÚZLàDBOMBOE‘S‘M‘S

0LVNB1BSÎBT‘
4POCBIBSZBþNVSMBS‘CBāMBN‘ā āJEEFUJOJJZJDFBSUU‘SN‘āU‘:FOJCJSZVWBZBUBā‘ONBO‘OBS
U‘L[BNBO‘HFMEJþJOJEàāàOFO)àUIàU CJSZBOEBOZBWSVTVOV‘T‘UNBZBWFLBSO‘O‘EPZVSNBZB
ÎBM‘ā‘ZPS EJþFSZBOEBOEBPSNBO‘OJÎJOEFPSBEBOPSBZBVÎVZPSWFZFOJZVWBT‘JÎJOVZHVO
CJSBþBÎBS‘ZPSEV:‘MMBSE‘SCVPSNBOEBZBāBZBO LÚLMFSJUPQSBþ‘OEFSJOMFSJOFLBEBSJONJā 
EBMMBS‘O‘OIFSCJSJCBāLBCJSBþBÎPMNVā EJþFSBþBÎMBS‘CJSÎBE‘SHJCJÚSUFO JIUJāBN‘ IFZCF
UJZMFEVSBOZBāM‘ΑOBSBþBD‘ )àUIàUhàOEJLLBUJOJÎFLUJ6MVΑOBSBZBLMBāU‘ EBMMBS‘O‘JODFMFEJ 
HÚWEFTJOEF CVMVOBO WF V[VO [BNBOE‘S WBS PMBO CàZàL LPWVþV GBSL FUUJ ,PWVþVO JÎJOF
HJSEJ CVSBT‘IFNHFOJāIFNEFZBWSVTVZMBL‘ā‘HFÎJSFCJMFDFþJLBEBST‘DBL UBIUBLVSVMBS‘O‘O
CPMPMEVþVCJSZFSEJ#VSBT‘QMBOMBE‘þ‘ZVWBJÎJOPMEVLÎBVZHVOEV:VWBT‘O‘ZBQNBLJÎJO
IFNFOJāFLPZVMEV%VSNBEBOÎBM‘ā‘ZPS BþBÎEBMMBS‘O‘UPQMVZPS CVOMBS‘ÎBNVSMBCJSCJSJOF
CJSMFāUJSJZPSEV4BBUJMFSMFNJā HàOFāCBUNBZBCBāMBN‘āU‘)àUIàUZVWBO‘OCàZàLCJSL‘TN‘O‘
CJUJSNJāUJ"SU‘LZBWSVTVOVOZBO‘OBEÚONFTJWFLBSO‘O‘EPZVSNBT‘HFSFLUJþJOJCJMJZPSEV:V
WBO‘OLBMBOL‘TN‘O‘FSUFTJHàOUBNBNMBZBDBLWFZBWSVTVZMBZFOJZVWBZBUBā‘OBDBLU‘0HFDF
CàZàLCJSG‘SU‘OBΑLU‘ āJEEFUMJZBþNVSZBþE‘4BCBIPMEVþVOEBHàOFāBÎN‘ā IBWBBZE‘OMBO
N‘āU‘:FOJZVWBT‘OBHJUUJþJOEFHÚ[MFSJOFJOBOBNBE‘3à[HÉSWFāJEEFUMJZBþNVSZVWBZBIBTBS
WFSNJāWFSà[HÉS‘OFULJTJZMFZVWBZFSJOEFOLPQBSBLZFSFEàāNàāWFQBSÎBMBON‘āU‘)àUIàU
CVNBO[BSBLBSā‘T‘OEBÎPLà[àMEàWFOFZBQBDBþ‘O‘CJMFNFEJ#JSTàSFZVWBO‘OCBā‘OEBÚZ
MFDFCFLMFEJLUFOTPOSBLFOEJOJUPQBSMBE‘#JSHàOEFCVZVWBO‘OÎPþVOVUBNBNMBE‘ZTBāJNEJ
EFZBQBCJMJSEJ:FOJEFOZVWBT‘O‘ZBQNBZBLPZVMEV PLBEBSJTUFLMJWFB[JNMJÎBM‘āU‘LJBLāBNB

122
à . ÿ 5 7" 3  0 - . "

ZVWBZ‘ZFOJEFOUBNBNMBN‘āU‘:BWSVTVOVBM‘QUFLSBSZFOJZVWBZBHFMNFLJÎJOPSBEBOBZS‘M
E‘ :BWSVTVZMB ZVWBZB EÚOEàþàOEF HÚ[MFSJOF JOBOBNBE‘  ZVWB ZJOF QBSBNQBSÎB PMNVāUV
4FCFCJOJBOMBNBZBÎBM‘ā‘SLFOCJSLFEJOJOEBMEBOEBMBBUMBNBZBÎBM‘ā‘SLFOZVWBO‘Oà[FSJOF
EàāUàþàOàGBSLFUUJÿZJDFZPSVMNVāWFàNJEJOJZJUJSNJāUJ"SU‘LZFOJCJSZVWBZBQNBLUBO
WB[HFÎFSFLZBWSVTVZMBFTLJZVWBT‘OBEÚONFLJÎJOLBOBUMBOE‘LMBS‘OEBEFSJOEFOCJSTFTJāJUUJ
4BL‘OQFTFUNF "MMBIIFS[BNBOCJ[JNMF)àUIàUFUSBG‘OBCBL‘OE‘ TFTJOOFSFEFOHFMEJþJOJ
BOMBNBZBÎBM‘āU‘ÿMFSEFLJBþBD‘Oà[FSJOEFQBSMBZBOJLJLàÎàL‘ā‘LHÚSEàWFPZÚOFEPþSV
ZÚOFMEJ4FTJOHFMEJþJZÚOFZBLMBāU‘þ‘OEBCVTFTJOTBIJCJOJO#BZLVāPMEVþVOVBOMBE‘
#BZLVā
i4BL‘OQFTFUNF "MMBIhUBOàNJEJOJLFTNFwEJZFZJOFMFEJi4FOJJLJHàOEàSJ[MJZPSVN OF
LBEBSZFUFOFLMJ B[JNMJWFCBāBS‘M‘PMEVþVOVHÚSEàNWFTFOJOEBIBHà[FMCJSZVWBZBQBCJMF
DFþJOJCJMJZPSVNEFEJ
#VÚþàUMFS)àUIàUhFJZJDFDFTBSFUWFSNJāUJ)JÎEVSNBEBOÎBM‘āU‘WFFTLJTJOEFOEBIBHà
[FM EBIBTBþMBNCJSZVWBZBQBSBLZBWSVTVZMBZFOJZVWBT‘OBZFSMFāUJ"SU‘L#BZLVāWFΑOBS
BþBD‘ZMBLPNāVPMNVāUV,‘ā‘T‘DBLWFSBIBUCJSZVWBEBZBWSVTVZMBCFSBCFSHFÎJSEJ)àUIàU
BSU‘L "MMBIUBOàNJEJOJLFTNFZJQB[JNMFÎBCBMBNBZBEFWBNFUUJþJOEF[PSMVLMBS‘OàTUFTJOEFO
HFMFCJMFDFþJOJCJMJZPSEV

%FþFSMFOEJSNF4PSVMBS‘
4J[)àUIàUhàOZFSJOEFPMTBZE‘O‘[OFZBQBSE‘O‘[
#VÚZLàZFCJSCBāM‘LCVMNBLJTUFTFLOFPMVSEV
)àUIàULVāVOVOJÎJOEFCVMVOEVþVEVSVNTJ[FOFIJTTFUUJSEJ
#BZLVāVO)àUIàUFTÚZMFEJLMFSJIBLL‘OEBOFEàāàOàZPSTVOV[

(àOàO.FTBK‘
i"MMBI‘OEPTUMBS‘OBIJÎCJSLPSLVZPLUVS
0OMBSà[àMNFZFDFLMFSEJSEFyw
:ßOVT 

,BQBO‘ā
(SVQàZFMFSJOFQBZMBā‘NMBS‘JÎJOUFāFLLàSFEJO
)FSLFTJOBLM‘OEBLBMBONFTBK‘QBZMBāNBT‘O‘JTUFZJO
,POVZMBJMHJMJWBSTBTPSVMBS‘O‘BM‘OWFDFWBQMBZ‘O
#JSTPOSBLJLPOVOVOCBāM‘þ‘O‘WFSJOWFWFEBMBā‘O

123
à . ÿ 5 7" 3  0 - . "

½þSFUJDJ/PUV
½þSFUJDJ/PUVEFZFSBMBOCJMHJMFSEPþSVMUVTVOEBEFSTBOMBU‘M‘S

:ÚOUFNWF5FLOJLMFS
4PSV$FWBQ .FLUVQ0ZVOV "LSPTUJā5FLOJþJ

&ULJOMJL
ZBā
½þSFUJDJ ÎPDVLMBS‘JLJZFCÚMFSWFIFSHSVQUBOZBS‘T‘O‘O EJþFSZBS‘T‘OBCJSNFLUVQZB[BSBL
i1FZHBNCFSJNJ[ TBT EBJNBàNJUWBSE‘wLPOVTVIBLL‘OEBTPSVTPSBSBL CVTPSVZBBΑLM‘L
HFUJSNFMFSJOJJTUFS.FLUVQZB[‘MBOUBSBGCJMHJMFSJEà[FZJODFDFWBQWFSJSMFS7FSJMFODFWBQMBS
LPOVāVMVS%BIBTPOSBÚþSFUJDJÎPDVLMBSBCJSLPOVBOMBUBDBþ‘O‘TÚZMFSWFLPOVZVEJLLBUMJDF
EJOMFNFMFSJOJJTUFS4PSVDFWBQJMFFULJOMJLTPOCVMVS
&/Ã.ÿ5-ÿÿ/4"/);.6)"..&%
4FWHJMJ1FZHBNCFSJNJ[ TBT IBZBU‘O‘OIFSBO‘OEBàNJUWBSPMNVāUVS4‘L‘OU‘MBSJÎFSJ
TJOEFZLFO CJMF Hà[FM HàOMFSJO HFMFDFþJOEFO àNJEJOJ LFTNFNJāUJS .FLLFEF ÎPL [PS HàO
MFSHFÎJSFO1FZHBNCFSJNJ[CVT‘L‘OU‘M‘HàOMFSEFCJMF.àTMàNBOMBSBEBJNBàNJUWFSNJāUJS
.àTMàNBOMBSBTBCS‘UBWTJZFFEFO1FZHBNCFSJNJ[ JOBOÎMBS‘HFSFþJJCBEFUMFSJOJEBIBTFSCFTU
ZBQNBMBS‘ CBTL‘WF[VMàNBMU‘OEBLBMNBNBMBS‘JÎJOPOMBSBIJDSFUJUBWTJZFFUNJāUJS)JDSFU HÚÎ
FUNFLEFNFLUJS#JSÎFāJUàNJUIBSFLFUJEJS.àTMàNBOMBSÚODFJLJLF[)BCFāJTUBOBTPOSB
.FEJOFZFIJDSFUFUNJāMFSEJS)JDSFUEàāàODFTJJMFàNJUWBSPMNVāMBSE‘S;PSHàOMFSHFÎUJLUFO
TPOSBZFOJEFO.FEJOFEFUPQMBON‘āMBSE‘S
4FWHJMJ1FZHBNCFSJNJ[)[.VIBNNFEJO TBT IJDSFUZPMDVMVþVOBΑLBDBþ‘O‘ÚþSFOFO
NàāSJLMFS 1FZHBNCFSJNJ[F [BSBS WFSNFL JTUJZPSMBSE‘ "MMBIB DD  EBZBOBO WF .FEJOFZJ
LFOEJTJWF.àTMàNBOMBSJÎJOàNJUCFMEFTJPMBSBLHÚSFO1FZHBNCFSJNJ[FWJOEFOΑLNBEBO 
NàāSJLMFS1FZHBNCFSJNJ[JÚMEàSNFLJTUFEJMFS&WJOJOZBO‘OEBCFLMFEJMFS4FWHJMJ1FZHBNCF
SJNJ[ TBT "MMBI‘OJ[OJZMFNàāSJLMFSLFOEJTJOJHÚSNFEFOFWJOEFOΑLU‘4POSBNàāSJLMFS 
)[.VIBNNFEJO TBT QFāJOF4àSBLBJTNJOEFCJSJ[TàSàDàZàUBLJQFUNFTJJÎJOHÚOEFS
EJMFS
)[.VIBNNFE TBT WFPOVOTBE‘LEPTUV)[&CV#FLJS SB NàāSJLMFSEFOTBLMBO
NBLJÎJO4FWS.BþBSBT‘OBHJ[MFOEJMFS.àāSJLMFSÎPLZBLMBāN‘āMBSE‘"MMBI DD PJLJEPTUVO
àÎàODàEPTUVPMBSBLPOMBS‘LPSVEV4FWS.BþBSBT‘O‘OHJSJāJOEFCJSHàWFSDJOZVWBT‘WBSE‘#JS
EFÚSàNDFLBþ‘ÚSNàāUà4FWS.BþBSBT‘OEB)[&CV#FLJS SB FOEJāFMFONJāUJ
;PSCJSBOE‘1FZHBNCFSJNJ[ "MMBI‘OLFOEJTJOJLPSVZBDBþ‘OBWFWBSBDBLMBS‘ZFSFIBZ‘SMB
HJEFDFLMFSJOFàNJUWBSE‘.BþBSBO‘OBþ[‘OBLBEBSHFMFONàāSJLMFSFSBþNFO)[.VIBNNFE
TBT BSLBEBā‘O‘TBLJOMFāUJSEJ0OVUFTFMMJFEFSFLāÚZMFEFEJ
i&OEJāFMFONF.VIBLLBLLJ"MMBICJ[JNMFEJSw


à . ÿ 5 7" 3  0 - . "

.àāSJLMFS NBþBSBO‘OÚOàOEFLJLVāZVWBT‘WFÚSàNDFLBþ‘OEBOEPMBZ‘
i#VSBZBV[VOTàSFEJSLJNTFHFMNFNJāPMTBHFSFL&þFSHFMTFZEJ CVBþCP[VMVSWFHàWFS
DJOCVSBEBOVÎBSE‘wEJZFSFLPSBEBOV[BLMBāU‘MBS
)[.VIBNNFE TBT WF)[&CV#FLJS SB CÚZMFDFIJDSFUZPMDVMVLMBS‘OBEFWBNFUUJ
MFS,VCBEBLPOBLMBE‘MBS0OHàOEFOGB[MBCVSBEBLBME‘MBS,VCBEBCJSNFTDJUJOāBFUUJMFS
,VCB.FTDJEJ ,VSBO‘,FSJNEFi5BLWB.FTDJEJwPMBSBLHFÎNFLUFEJSÿTMBNUBSJIJOEF-
LJ JML NFTDJUUJS )[ .VIBNNFE TBT  3BOVOB EFOJMFO WBEJEF iÿML $VNB )VUCFTJwOJ
PLVEV$VNBOBNB[‘O‘L‘ME‘SE‘.FEJOFZFZBLMBā‘ZPSMBSE‘,VCB.FEJOFZFàÎLJMPNFUSF
V[BLM‘LUBZE‘)[.VIBNNFEJOFWJOEF LFOEJTJOFC‘SBL‘MBOFNBOFUMFSJTBIJQMFSJOFWFSNFTJ
JÎJO)["MJCFLMJZPSEV)["MJ SB ,VCBEB)[.VIBNNFEJO TBT ZBO‘OEBZFUJāNJāUJ
)JDSFUCJSàNJUUJ.FTDJUJOāBFUNFLCJSàNJUUJ4‘L‘OU‘MBSEBOTPOSBTFWJODFWFSBIBUBFSJ
MFDFþJEàāàODFTJCJSàNJUUJ)BOHJHàOEJþFSHàOMFBZO‘ZE‘LJ "MMBI DD IJÎLVMVOVZBMO‘[
C‘SBL‘SN‘ &MCFUUF LVMMBS‘O‘HÚSàS HÚ[FUJSWFLPSVS"MMBI DD LFOEJTJOFàNJUCFTMFZFOMFSJ
TFWFS"MMBIUBOàNJEJOJTBEFDFJOBONBZBOMBSLFTFS"MMBIBJOBOBOMBSJTF EBJNB)[.V
IBNNFE TBT HJCJ àNJUWBSPMVS

Ü…………………………………………………
M………………………………………………...
ÿyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy
5yyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy

"LSPTUJā,FMJNFMFSJOJMLIBSnFSJOJOCJSāJGSF LBWSBN TÚ[ÚCFþJWFZBDàNMFPMVāUVSBDBL


CJÎJNEFBMUBMUBT‘SBMBONBT‘E‘S,BWSBN‘OÚþSFUJMNFTJOFZBSE‘ND‘PMVS

%FþFSMFOEJSNF4PSVMBS‘
4J[JOIBZBU‘O‘[EBàNJUMFCFLMFEJþJOJ[OFMFSWBS
ÃNJUTJ[FOFZJJGBEFFEFS
ÃNJUMFIBZBUBCBLNBLTJ[DFOBT‘MCJSIJTUJS
"āBþ‘EBWFSJMFOBLSPTUJāUFiàNJUwLFMJNFTJOJOIBSnFSJLVMMBO‘MN‘āU‘S
"LSPTUJāCJSāJJSZB[BSN‘T‘O‘[

125
à . ÿ 5 7" 3  0 - . "

(àOàO.FTBK‘
iy"MMBI‘OSBINFUJOEFOàNJULFTNFZJO
±àOLàLÉmSMFSUPQMVMVþVOEBOCBāLBT‘"MMBI‘O
SBINFUJOEFOàNJEJOJLFTNF[w
:ßTVG 

,BQBO‘ā
(SVQàZFMFSJOFQBZMBā‘NMBS‘JÎJOUFāFLLàSFEJO
)FSLFTJOBLM‘OEBLBMBONFTBK‘QBZMBāNBT‘O‘JTUFZJO
,POVZMBJMHJMJWBSTBTPSVMBS‘O‘BM‘OWFDFWBQMBZ‘O
#JSTPOSBLJLPOVOVOCBāM‘þ‘O‘WFSJOWFWFEBMBā‘O

126
à . ÿ 5 7" 3  0 - . "

3"##ÿ.ÿ;ÿ/3").&5ÿ/&4*ý*/.",Ã.ÿ5
,B[BO‘N
ÃNJUFUNFOJO"MMBI‘OSBINFUJOFT‘þ‘ONBLPMEVþVOVCJMJS"MMBI‘OSBINFUJOJO BGG‘O‘O 
ZBSE‘N‘O‘OTPOTV[PMEVþVOVCJMJS

½þSFUJDJ/PUV
#àUàO TFCFQMFSJO ZFUFSTJ[ LBME‘þ‘  UàN àNJUMFSJO PSUBEBO LBMLU‘þ‘  ÎÚ[àN BE‘OB IJÎCJS
HJSJāJNJOTPOVÎWFSNFEJþJCJSBOEB CàUàOIFTBQMBS‘UFSTJOFÎFWJSFDFLZFHÉOFHàDàOTBIJ
CJPMBO:àDF"MMBI‘OSBINFUJOFT‘þ‘ONBO‘OÚOFNWFNBIJZFUJBOMBU‘M‘S"MMBI‘OSBINFUJOF
T‘þ‘ONBO‘O TBEFDF[PS[BNBOMBSJÎJOHFÎFSMJPMNBE‘þ‘OB IFSEBJN0OVOSBINFUWFNFS
IBNFUJOFNVIUBÎPMEVþVNV[BBU‘GZBQ‘M‘S"MMBI‘ONFSIBNFUJOJOT‘O‘ST‘[M‘þ‘WFTàSFTJ[MJþJ
EJLLBUMFSFTVOVMVS;àNFSTVSFTJBZFULPOVZMBJMHJMJPMBSBLBLUBS‘MBCJMJSi%FLJ&ZLFOEJ
OFmTMFSJBMFZIJOFIBEEJBāBOLVMMBS‘N"MMBI‘OSBINFUJOEFOàNJULFTNFZJO±àOLà"MMBI
CàUàOHàOBIMBS‘CBþ‘āMBSĀàQIFTJ[LJ0 ÎPLCBþ‘āMBZBO ÎPLFTJSHFZFOEJSw ;àNFS  

:ÚOUFNWF5FLOJLMFS
"OMBU‘N &þJUTFM0ZVO

.BUFSZBM
"ZFUWFIBEJTMFS SFOLMJLBSUMBS āFLFSMFNF

&ULJOMJL
ZBā
½þSFUJDJ ,VSBO‘,FSJNEFHFÎFOiàNJUWFSFOBZFUMFSwEFOCJSL‘TN‘O‘WFBZFUMFJMHJMJLP
OVZVL‘TBDBLàÎàLLÉþ‘UMBSBZB[BSWFCVLÉþ‘UMBS‘āFLFSMFNFMFSMFCJSMJLUFIFEJZFLVUVMBS‘OB
WFZBQBLFUMFSJOFLPZBS#VOMBS‘ÎPDVLMBSHÚSNFEFOT‘O‘G‘OÎFāJUMJZFSMFSJOFZFSMFāUJSJS%FST
CBāMBZ‘ODBÎPDVLMBSBi4‘O‘G‘OÎFāJUMJZFSMFSJOEFTJ[JOJÎJOIFEJZFMFSWBS IBZEJPOMBS‘CVMVOw
EFS)FEJZFQBLFUMFSJOJCVMBOÎPDVLMBS QBLFUMFSJOJÎFSJTJOEFLJBZFUMFSJPLVS CVBZFUMFSUBI
UBZB ZB[‘M‘S WF BΑLMBNB ZBQ‘MBSBL EFþFSMFOEJSJMJS #JSEFO GB[MB QBLFU CVMBO ÎPDVLMBSMB IJÎ
QBLFUCVMBNBZBOÎPDVLMBSFMMFSJOEFLJQBLFUMFSJQBZMBā‘S0ZVOTPOVOEBÎPDVLMBSBGB[MBEBO
ÎJLPMBUBWFāFLFSEBþ‘U‘M‘S

127
à . ÿ 5 7" 3  0 - . "

ÃNJUWFSFOBZFUMFSWFBΑLMBNBMBS‘
i#JSLFSWBOHFMNJā TVDVMBS‘O‘TVZBHÚOEFSNJāMFSEJ4VDVLPWBT‘O‘LVZVZBTBM‘ODB
A.àKEF.àKEF ÿāUFCJSPþMBOEFEJ0OVBM‘QCJSUJDBSFUNBM‘PMBSBLTBLMBE‘MBS0ZTB
"MMBI POMBS‘OZBQU‘LMBS‘O‘CJMJZPSEVw :ßTVG  
,àÎàL:VTVGLVZVEBàāàNFZFCBāMBN‘āU‘S#JSLFSWBOΑLBHFMJS4VDVLPWBT‘O‘TBMBSWF
IBZL‘S‘Si.àKEF#VCJSÎPDVLw%FSJOCJSOFGFTBM‘S‘[:VTVGLVZVEBOLVSUVMNVāUVS(FSÎJ
CVMBOCBCBT‘EFþJMEJSBNBPMTVO,VZVEBOLVSUVMEVZB,ÚMFMJLUFOTVMUBOM‘þBHJEFOTàSFÎ
CBāMBN‘āU‘SBSU‘L
i&ZBUFāÿCSBIJNFLBSā‘TFSJOWFFTFOMJLPMEFEJLw &OCJZÉ 
(FOÎÿCSBIJNi3BCCJN"MMBIwEFEJþJJÎJOBUFāFBU‘MN‘āU‘S,SBM/FNSVUBUFāFBU‘MNBT‘O‘
FNSFUUJþJOEFOFGFTMFSUVUVMNVāUVS,BΑāZPLHJCJEJS)FSLFTPLPSLVOÎBMFWMFSJOÿCSBIJNJ
ZVUBDBþ‘O‘EàāàOàS'BLBUPEBOF /FHà[FMCJSNàKEFi&ZBUFā TFSJOWFTFMBNFUPMÿCSB
IJNFw
iA&ZZFSZà[à:VUTVZVOV&ZHÚL5VUTVZVOVEFOJMEJ4VÎFLJMEJ JāCJUJSJMEJ
(FNJEF$VEJZFPUVSEVWFA;BMJNMFSUPQMVMVþV"MMBI‘OSBINFUJOEFOV[BLPMTVOEF-
OJMEJw )ßE 
/VIUVGBO‘LPQNVā ZFSJOWFHÚþàOTVMBS‘CJSCJSJOFLBS‘āN‘āU‘S"[H‘OEBMHBMBSJÎJOEF 
BIāBQCJSHFNJBL‘QHJUNFLUFEJSÿÎJOEFCJSBWVÎJOBON‘āJOTBO7FZàDFCJS1FZHBNCFS )[
/VI BT .àNJOMFSFOEJāFJÎJOEFLVSUVMNBZ‘CFLMFNFLUFEJSMFS4POVOEBTVMBS‘O‘ÎFLNFTJ
FNSFEJMJSZFSFWFHÚþF7FHFNJ$VEJ%Bþ‘OBPUVSVSTFTTJ[DF
iĀàQIFTJ[ 3BCCJOTBOBWFSFDFL TFOEFIPāOVUPMBDBLT‘Ow %VIÉ 
1FZHBNCFSJNJ[FWFSJMFONàKEFZàSFLMFSFTVTFSQFS%BSBME‘þ‘N‘[WFT‘L‘ME‘þ‘N‘[[BNBO
MBSEB3BCCJNJ[FEVBFEFSJ[

%FþFSMFOEJSNF4PSVMBS‘
0LVEVþVNV[BZFUMFSJOPSUBLLPOVTVOFEJSWFCJ[FOBT‘MNFTBKMBSWFSNFLUFEJS
"ZFUMFSEFHFÎFOWFàNJUMJPMNBT‘JTUFOFOLJāJMFSLJNMFSEJS HÚSFWMFSJOFEJS
±FāJUMJ[PSMVLMBSMBLBSā‘MBāBOQFZHBNCFSMFS CVOMBSLBSā‘T‘OEBOBT‘MEBWSBON‘āMBSE‘S
;PSMVLMBSMBLBSā‘MBāU‘þ‘N‘[EBCJ[JNOBT‘MEBWSBONBN‘[HFSFLJS


à . ÿ 5 7" 3  0 - . "

(àOàO.FTBK‘
i"MMBI‘OSBINFUJOEFOàNJEJOJ[J
LFTNFZJOĀàQIFTJ[LJ"MMBICàUàO
HàOBIMBS‘BGGFEFS ÎàOLà0ÎPLCBþ‘āMBZ‘D‘
WFQFLNFSIBNFUMJEJSw
;àNFS 

,BQBO‘ā
(SVQàZFMFSJOFQBZMBā‘NMBS‘JÎJOUFāFLLàSFEJO
)FSLFTJOBLM‘OEBLBMBONFTBK‘QBZMBāNBT‘O‘JTUFZJO
,POVZMBJMHJMJWBSTBTPSVMBS‘O‘BM‘OWFDFWBQMBZ‘O
#JSTPOSBLJLPOVOVOCBāM‘þ‘O‘WFSJOWFWFEBMBā‘O

129
à . ÿ 5 7" 3  0 - . "

½þSFUJDJ/PUV
ÿZJHàOEFWFLÚUàHàOEF"MMBI‘OSBINFUJOFIFS[BNBOT‘þ‘ONBLHFSFLUJþJ "MMBI‘OLFOEJ
TJOFàNJUMFCBþMBOBOLVMMBS‘O‘BTMBHFSJÎFWJSNFZFDFþJJ[BIFEJMJSÃNJEJPMNBZBOCJSJOTBO‘O
LVSVUPQSBLHJCJPMEVþVàNJUMFZBāBZBOJOTBO‘OJTFZFNZFāJMCFSFLFUMJCJSUPQSBLHJCJPMEVþV
ÎPDVLMBSMBLPOVāVMVS.àTMàNBO‘OBTMB"MMBIUBOàNJEJOJLFTNFNFTJHFSFLUJþJWVSHVMBO‘S

:ÚOUFNWF5FLOJLMFS
"OMBU‘N 4PSV$FWBQ

.BUFSZBM
)BEJTJāFSJGNFUOJ

&ULJOMJL
ZBā
½þSFUJDJÎPDVLMBS‘OZBO‘OBHJEFSWFPOMBSBFTLJ[BNBOMBSEBZBāBOBOWFHàOBILÉSEBPMTB
BTMB "MMBIUBO àNJEJOJ LFTNFZFO  CBþ‘āMBOBDBþ‘OB JOBOBO  "MMBI‘O SBINFUJOF T‘þ‘OBO CJS
BEBN‘OIJLÉZFTJOJBOMBUBDBþ‘O‘WFIJLÉZFOJOCJUJNJOEFEFÎPDVLMBSBTPSVMBSZÚOFMUFDFþJOJ
TÚZMFS
i4J[EFOÚODFZBāBZBOMBSBSBT‘OEBEPLTBOEPLV[LJāJZJÚMEàSFOCJSBEBNWBSE‘#JSBSB
ZFSZà[àOàOFOCJMHJOLJāJTJOJTPSEV,FOEJTJOFCJSSBIJCUBSJGFEJMEJ0OBLBEBSHJEJQ EPL
TBOEPLV[LJāJÚMEàSEàþàOà LFOEJTJJÎJOCJSUÚWCFJNLÉO‘O‘OPMVQPMNBE‘þ‘O‘TPSEV3BIJQ
A)BZ‘SZPLUVSEFEJ"EBNPOVEBÚMEàSàQDJOBZFUJOJZà[FUBNBNMBE‘
"EBNDBþ‘[  ZFSZà[àOàO FO CJMHJOJOJ TPSNBZB EFWBN FUUJ ,FOEJTJOF ÉMJN CJS LJāJ UBSJG
FEJMEJ0OBHFMJQ Zà[LJāJÚMEàSEàþàOà LFOEJTJJÎJOCJSUÚWCFJNLÉO‘PMVQPMNBE‘þ‘O‘TPS
EV¬MJNA&WFU WBSE‘S TFOJOMFUÚWCFOBSBT‘OBLJNQFSEFPMBCJMJS EFEJ7FJMBWFFUUJAAncak,
GBMBONFNMFLFUFHJUNFMJTJO;JSBPSBEB"MMBIBJCBEFUFEFOLJNTFMFSWBS4FOEFPOMBSMB"M-
MBIBJCBEFUFEFDFLTJOWFCJSEBIBLFOEJNFNMFLFUJOFEÚONFZFDFLTJO;JSBPSBT‘LÚUàCJSZFS
"EBN ZPMB ΑLU‘ (JEFSLFO ZBS‘ ZPMB WBS‘S WBSNB[ ÚMàN NFMFþJ HFMJQ SVIVOV LBC[FUUJ
3BINFU WF B[BQ NFMFLMFSJ POVO IBLL‘OEB JIUJMBGB EàāUàMFS 3BINFU NFMFLMFSJ ‘Bu adam
UÚWCFLÉSPMBSBLHFMEJ,BMCFO"MMBIBZÚOFMNJāUJEFEJMFS"[BCNFMFLMFSJEFA#VBEBNIJÎCJS
IBZ‘SJāMFNFEJEFEJMFS
0OMBSCÚZMFÎFLJāJSLFOJOTBOTVSFUJOEFCJSCBāLBNFMFL ZBOMBS‘OBHFMEJ.FMFLMFSPOV
BSBMBS‘OEBIBLFNZBQU‘MBS)BLFNPOMBSBA0OVOΑLU‘þ‘ZFSMF HJUNFLUFPMEVþVZFSBSBT‘O‘
ÚMÎàO IBOHJUBSBGBEBIBZBL‘OTBPOBUFTMJNFEJOEFEJ½MÎUàMFS HÚSEàMFSLJHJUNFZJBS[V
FUUJþJ JZJMFSEJZBS‘OB CJSLBS‘āEBIBZBL‘O0OVIFNFOSBINFUNFMFLMFSJBME‘MBSw

130
à . ÿ 5 7" 3  0 - . "

#JSSJWBZFUUFāV[JZBEFWBSi#JSNJLUBSZPMHJEJODF ÚMàNHFMJQÎBUU‘"EBNDBþ‘[ZÚOàOàTBMJI
LÚZFEPþSVÎFWJSEJ#ÚZMFDFPLÚZFIMJOEFOTBZ‘ME‘w<#VIÉSÔ &OCJZB.àTMJN 5ÚWCF 
 .ÉDF %JZBU   >

%FþFSMFOEJSNF4PSVMBS‘
)BUBZBQU‘þ‘N‘[EB"MMBIUBOCBāLBHJEFDFLLBQ‘N‘[WBSN‘E‘S
"MMBIUBOàNJULFTNFOJOJOBOBOCJSLJāJZFZBL‘āNBZBOÚ[FMMJLMFSEFOPMEVþVOV
CJMJZPSNVTVOV[
#VBEBN‘OBGGFEJMNFTFCFCJTJ[DFOFPMBCJMJS
"MMBI DD OFEFPMTBCFOJIFQBGGFEFSEàāàODFTJTJ[DFàNJUNJEJS
#VIBEJTJāFSJGFCJOBFO EBIBÚODFZBāBE‘þ‘N‘[QJāNBOM‘LMBS
TJ[DFàNJEFEÚOFCJMJSNJ

(àOàO.FTBK‘
i3BCCJOJOSBINFUJOEFO EBMBMFUUF
PMBOMBSEBOCBāLBLJNàNJULFTFS w
)JDS 

,BQBO‘ā
(SVQàZFMFSJOFQBZMBā‘NMBS‘JÎJOUFāFLLàSFEJO
)FSLFTJOBLM‘OEBLBMBONFTBK‘QBZMBāNBT‘O‘JTUFZJO
,POVZMBJMHJMJWBSTBTPSVMBS‘O‘BM‘OWFDFWBQMBZ‘O
#JSTPOSBLJLPOVOVOCBāM‘þ‘O‘WFSJOWFWFEBMBā‘O

131
16
ÿ / 4 " /  7 &  5" # ÿ "5  4 & 7 ( ÿ 4 ÿ

"MMBI‘OZBSBUU‘þ‘CàUàOWBSM‘LMBS‘OEFþFSMJPMEVþVOVCJMJS
"MMBI‘OZBSBUU‘þ‘CàUàOWBSM‘LMBS‘OCJSWB[JGFTJOJOPMEVþVOVCJMJS
ÿOTBO‘OZBSBU‘MN‘āMBSJÎFSJTJOEFFOEFþFSMJWBSM‘LPMEVþVOVCJMJS
ÿOTBO‘EFþFSMJL‘MBOāFZJOPOBZàLMFOFOTPSVNMVMVLMBSPMEVþVOVCJMJS
ÿOTBO‘OWB[JGFTJOJOLÉJOBUUBLJEà[FOJOEFWBNM‘M‘þ‘O‘TBþMBNBLPMEVþVOVCJMJS
ÿOTBOMBSBWFUBCJBUBLBSā‘NFSIBNFUMJPMNBT‘HFSFLUJþJOJCJMJS
ÿ / 4 " /  7 &  5" # ÿ "5  4 & 7 ( ÿ 4 ÿ

#Ã5Ã/7"3-*,-"3%&ý&3-ÿ%ÿ3
,B[BO‘N
"MMBI‘OZBSBUU‘þ‘CàUàOWBSM‘LMBS‘OEFþFSMJPMEVþVOVCJMJS

½þSFUJDJ/PUV
:BSBU‘M‘ā BNBD‘O‘O TBEFDF EàOZB HFÎJNJOJ TBþMBNBL PMNBZ‘Q  "MMBI‘ IBLL‘ZMB UBO‘NBL
WF CJMNFL PMEVþV JGBEF FEJMJS "MMBI‘ UBO‘NBO‘O FO Hà[FM ZPMVOVO 0OVO UFDFMMJMFSJ PMBO
WBSM‘LMBSBCBLNBLMBPMBDBþ‘BOMBU‘M‘S0OVOZBSBUU‘þ‘CàUàOWBSM‘LMBS‘OLFOEJBSBMBS‘OEBCJS
BIFOHJ VZVNVPMEVþV CJ[MFSJOLVMPMBSBLà[FSJOFEàāFOJOZBSBU‘MBOWBSM‘LMBSEBLJIJLNFUMFSJ
HÚSFCJMNFLPMEVþVWVSHVMBO‘S

:ÚOUFNWF5FLOJLMFS
"OMBU‘N 4PSV$FWBQ

.BUFSZBM
4PMVDBOWF‘T‘SHBOPUVGPUPþSBnBS‘

&ULJOMJL
ZBā
½þSFUJDJ āV āFLJMEF FULJOMJþF HJSJā ZBQBS i%àOZBEB ÎPL TBZ‘EB WF IFS CJSJ LFOEJOF
IBT Ú[FMMJLMFSF TBIJQ DBOM‘ ÎFāJUMFSJ WBS EFþJM NJ  #VHàO TJ[JOMF JLJ GBSLM‘ DBOM‘Z‘ ZBL‘OEBO
UBO‘ZBDBþ‘[ #JSJ IBZWBOMBS EàOZBT‘OB EJþFSJ EF CJULJMFS EàOZBT‘OB BJU PMBO CV DBOM‘MBS
ATPMVDBOMBSWFA‘T‘SHBOPUMBS‘w½þSFUJDJBāBþ‘EBZFSBMBOTPMVDBOWF‘T‘SHBOPUVGPUPþSBnBS‘O‘
HÚTUFSEJLUFOTPOSBÎPDVLMBSBāVTPSVMBS‘TPSBS
"SBO‘[EB GPUPþSBGUBOEFþJMEFHFSÎFLIBZBUUB TPMVDBOWFZB‘T‘SHBOPUVHÚSFOWBSN‘
)JΑT‘SHBOPUVOBEPLVOEVOV[NV %PLVOVSTBO‘[OFPMVSCJMJZPSNVTVOV[
4J[DFTPMVDBOOBT‘MCJSIBZWBOE‘S 
±PDVLMBSDFWBQWFSEJLUFOTPOSBÚþSFUJDJCVDFWBQMBSEBOZPMBΑLBSBLāÚZMFEFS

134
ÿ / 4 " /  7 &  5" # ÿ "5  4 & 7 ( ÿ 4 ÿ

i4PMVDBO WF ‘T‘SHBO PUV  JLJTJ EF QFL HFSFLMJ HÚSNFEJþJNJ[ IBUUB V[BL EVSNBZ‘ UFSDJI
FUUJþJNJ[ DBOM‘MBS TBO‘S‘N #BLBM‘N POMBS IBLL‘OEB EBIB BZS‘OU‘M‘ CJMHJ TBIJCJ PMVODB
EàāàODFMFSJNJ[EFCJSEFþJāJLMJLPMBDBLN‘ )BZEJPOMBS‘EBIBZBL‘OEBOUBO‘ZBM‘Nw

Okuma Metni

7&3ÿ.-ÿ5"3*.7&40-6$"/-"3
4PMVDBOMBSIBZWBOMBSEàOZBT‘OEBCFMLJEFIJÎGBSL‘OBCJMFWBSNBE‘þ‘N‘[ CB[‘LJNTFMFSJO
EFIJÎIPāMBONBE‘þ‘IBZWBOMBSE‘S)ÉMCVLJCVTàSàOHFOIBZWBO‘O"MMBI‘OZBSBUU‘þ‘EPþBM
Eà[FOJÎFSJTJOEFÚOFNMJHÚSFWMFSJWBSE‘S
5PQSBLZà[FZJOEFÎàSàNFLUFPMBOBU‘LMBSTPMVDBOMBSUBSBG‘OEBOZFOJMJSCÚZMFDFUFNJ[MJL
ZBQ‘MN‘ā PMVS 4PMVDBOMBS‘O TJOEJSJNJ FTOBT‘OEB CV NBEEFMFS EFþJāJN HÚTUFSFSFL UPQSBLUB
ÎÚ[àMFCJMJSCJSIÉMFHFMFSFLCJULJMFSUBSBG‘OEBOFNJMFCJMJSMFS
4PMVDBO HàCSFTJZMF ZBQ‘MBO àSFUJNEF EBIB B[ FNFL EBIB B[ TV EBIB B[ HàCSF HFSFLJS
4PMVDBOMBS‘OZBāBE‘þ‘UPQSBLMBSEBCJULJWFNFZWFMFSJOZBāBNMBS‘EBIB[FOHJOEJS4PMVDBOMBS‘O
UPQSBLUBBÎU‘LMBS‘UàOFMBþ‘ UPQSBþ‘OIBWBMBONBT‘OBÚOFNMJCJSLBUL‘TBþMBS#VEVSVNBZO‘
[BNBOEBZà[FZFÎPLZBL‘OPMBOLÚLÎàLMFSJO[BSBSHÚSNFEFOCFTMFONFTJOFZBSE‘ND‘PMVS
4VMBNB TàSFTJODF  ÎPL NJLUBSEB TV CV UàOFMMFS WBT‘UBT‘ZMB UPQSBþ‘O EFSJOMJLMFSJOF T‘[BS WF
TVZVOÎPþVBþBÎMBS‘OEFSJOLÚLMFSJOFLBEBSFSJāJS4PMVDBOMBSEPþBJÎJOHFSÎFLNBOBEBCJS
UPQSBLZBQ‘D‘WFEà[FOMFZJDJEJS4PMVDBOMBSCFTJO[JODJSJCBTBNBþ‘OEBEBZFSBM‘SMBS,VSCBþB 
LVā LFSUFOLFMFHJCJCJSÎPLIBZWBOPOMBS‘ZFNPMBSBLBWMBS

Āÿ'",":/"ý**4*3("/056
"SBāU‘SNBMBS  ÎBZ HJCJ EFNMFOFSFL JÎJMFO WF ZFNFþJ ZBQ‘MBO ‘T‘SHBO PUVOVO CJSÎPL
IBTUBM‘þ‘OāJGBLBZOBþ‘PMEVþVOVPSUBZBLPZNBLUBE‘S*T‘SHBOPUVDJMEFEPLVOEVþVOEBV[VO
TàSF LBā‘OE‘SE‘þ‘ JÎJO QFL TFWJMNFNFLUF WF [BSBSM‘ CJS CJULJ PMBSBL EFþFSMFOEJSJMNFLUFEJS
*T‘SHBOPUVBTM‘OEBLVMMBONBT‘O‘CJMFOMFSJÎJOHJ[MJCJSFD[BEFQPTVEVS
*T‘SHBOPUVNJEFOJO CBþ‘STBLMBS‘O LBSBDJþFSJO QBOLSFBT‘OWFTBGSBLFTFTJOJOTBMH‘MBS‘O‘
VZBSBOiTFLUFSJOwBEM‘CJSNBEEFJÎFSJS*T‘SHBOPUVOEBLJEFNJS BMZVWBSMBS‘TàSFLMJZFOJMFZFSFL
ZFOJEPLVMBSBCPMPLTJKFOTBþMBE‘þ‘OEBOCVCJULJZJÎPLEFþFSMJL‘MBS#JULJUFEBWJCBL‘N‘OEBO
EB [FOHJO OJUFMJLMFSF TBIJQUJS ÿESBS TÚLUàSàDàEàS  JTIBM LFTJDJEJS 3PNBUJ[NBM‘MBSB  HVU
SBIBUT‘[M‘þ‘PMBOMBSBÚ[FMMJLMFÚOFSJMJS#VSVOLBOBNBT‘WFLBOUàLàSNFCBāUBPMNBLà[FSFIFS
UàSMà LBOBNBMBS‘ EVSEVSVS #FEFOJ HàÎMFOEJSJS  LBO UFNJ[MFZJDJEJS *T‘SHBO PUVOVO CVSBEB
TBZNBE‘þ‘N‘[EBIBQFLÎPLGBZEBT‘WBSE‘S
½þSFUJDJ  "MMBI‘O ZBSBUU‘þ‘ CàUàO WBSM‘LMBS‘O EFþFSMJ PMEVþVOV  IFQTJOJO EàOZBO‘O
NVIUFāFNZBQ‘T‘OEBÚOFNMJCJSZFSJOJOPMEVþVOVWVSHVMBZBSBLFULJOMJþJCJUJSJS

135
ÿ / 4 " /  7 &  5" # ÿ "5  4 & 7 ( ÿ 4 ÿ

136
ÿ / 4 " /  7 &  5" # ÿ "5  4 & 7 ( ÿ 4 ÿ

%FþFSMFOEJSNF4PSVMBS‘
4PMVDBOMBS‘OOFHJCJÚ[FMMJLMFSJWBSE‘S
*T‘SHBOPUVOVOOFHJCJÚ[FMMJLMFSJWBSE‘S
:FOJÚþSFOEJþJOJ[CJMHJMFSEPþSVMUVTVOEBTPMVDBOWF‘T‘SHBOPUVIBLL‘OEBOF
EàāàOàZPSTVOV[

(àOàO.FTBK‘
iÃTUMFSJOEFLJHÚþFCBLNB[MBSN‘LJ POVOBT‘MCJOB
FUNJāWFOBT‘MEPOBUN‘ā‘[0OEBIJÎCJSÎBUMBLEB
ZPL:FSZà[àOàEFEÚāFEJLWFPOBTBCJUEBþMBS
LPZEVL0SBEBHÚOàMBÎBOIFSUàSEFO CJULJMFS 
ZFUJāUJSEJL"MMBIBZÚOFMFOIFSLVMBHÚOàMHÚ[àOà
BÎNBLWFJCSFUWFSNFLJÎJO CàUàOCVOMBS‘ZBQU‘L w
,ÉG  

,BQBO‘ā
(SVQàZFMFSJOFQBZMBā‘NMBS‘JÎJOUFāFLLàSFEJO
)FSLFTJOBLM‘OEBLBMBONFTBK‘QBZMBāNBT‘O‘JTUFZJO
,POVZMBJMHJMJWBSTBTPSVMBS‘O‘BM‘OWFDFWBQMBZ‘O
#JSTPOSBLJLPOVOVOCBāM‘þ‘O‘WFSJOWFWFEBMBā‘O

137
1&:(".#&34&7(ÿ4ÿ

½þSFUJDJ/PUV
:BSBU‘MN‘ā WBSM‘LMBS‘ UBO‘NBL CJ[MFS JÎJO "MMBI‘ UBO‘NBO‘O ZPMMBS‘OEBO CJSJEJS 0OVO
ZBSBUN‘ā PMEVþV WBSM‘LMBS‘ UBO‘E‘LÎB  EFþFSMFSJOJ  WBSM‘LMBS‘O VZVNMVMVLMBS‘O‘ HÚSEàLÎF
IJÎCJSāFZJOCPāBZBSBU‘MBNBE‘þ‘WFFOCBTJUHÚSàMFOWBSM‘LMBS‘OCJMFOFLBEBSCàZàLEFþFSJOJO
PMEVþVWVSHVMBO‘S

:ÚOUFNWF5FLOJLMFS
#VMVā:PMVZMB½þSFUJN :BāBZBSBL½þSFONF

.BUFSZBM
"ZO‘UàSEFOCJSLBÎÎFāJUNFZWF

&ULJOMJL
ZBā
#JS.FZWFN7BS#FO[FSTJ[
 (FUJSJMFO NFZWFMFS IBLL‘OEB ÚODFEFO BSBāU‘SNB ZBQ‘M‘S WF ZBSBSMBS‘ IBLL‘OEB CJMHJ
UPQMBO‘S
.FZWFOJOLBCVþVOVO TBQ‘O‘O ZBQSBþ‘O‘OÚ[FMMJLMFSJWFGBZEBMBS‘ÚþSFOJMJS,PMBZM‘LMB
CVMBCJMEJþJNJ[NFZWFMFSEFO IBOHJNFZWFTFÎJMNJāTFBE‘TÚZMFOJS ÚSOFþJOFMNB OFLBEBS
EFþFSMJEJS/FLBEBSÎPLÎFāJEJ OFLBEBSÎPLGBZEBT‘WBSE‘S#JSNFZWFÎFāJEJPMBOFMNBO‘OCJMF
Zà[MFSDFÎFāJEJ IFSÎFāJEJOJOCJSÎPLGBZEBT‘ CJSÎPLLVMMBO‘NBMBO‘WBSE‘S5àNCVOMBS"MMBI
LBU‘OEB EFþFSMJ PMBO JOTBO JÎJO ZBSBU‘MN‘ā EFþFSMJ WBSM‘LMBSEBO TBEFDF CJSJTJEJS ±PDVLMBS‘O
BLUJGPMNBMBS‘TBþMBO‘SWFCVÚ[FMMJLMFSJLFOEJMFSJOJOCVMNBT‘JÎJODFTBSFUMFOEJSJMJSMFS
 A#JS .FZWFN 7BS #FO[FSTJ[ BEM‘ FULJOMJþJNJ[F CBāM‘ZPSV[ EJZFSFL ÎPDVLMBS‘O EJLLBUJ
FULJOMJþFÎFLJMJS
(FUJSJMFONFZWFMFSPSUBZBLPOVMBSBLFULJOMJþFCBāMBO‘S
 3FOHJ  āFLJMMFSJ  FCBUMBS‘  UBU  LPLV WF GBZEBMBS‘ UFLFS UFLFS FMF BM‘OBSBL JODFMFOJS 
ÎPDVLMBS‘OEVZVPSHBOMBS‘O‘LVMMBOBSBLCVJODFMFNFZJHFSÎFLMFāUJSNFMFSJTBþMBO‘S ½þSFUJDJ
JODFMFNFZBQBSLFOIFSFMNBÎFāJEJOJOGBSLM‘GBZEBMBS‘PMEVþV LBCVþVOEBOCJMFTJSLFWFZB
L‘āÎBZ‘ZBQ‘MBCJMFDFþJ ÎFLJSEFLMFSJOJOIFNUPIVNPMEVþVIFNEFGBSLM‘Ú[FMMJLMFSJPMEVþV 
ÎÚQàOàO CJMF EPþBEB FSJZJQ JTSBG PMNBE‘þ‘ WTy GB[MB CJMJONFZFO Ú[FMMJLMFSJ ÚO QMBOB
ΑLBS‘MBSBLOFLBEBSEFþFSMJPMEVLMBS‘CVMEVSVMNBZBÎBM‘ā‘M‘S
 &O TPOVOEB "MMBIB CJ[MFSJ CV LBEBS EFþFSMJ ZBSBU‘Q CJ[F CV LBEBS EFþFSMJ WBSM‘LMBS
WFSEJþJ  CÚZMF Ú[FM NFZWFMFS ZBSBUU‘þ‘ JÎJO UFāFLLàS FEFSFL NFZWFMFS ZFOJMJS .FZWF āÚMFOJ
ZBQ‘M‘S


1&:(".#&34&7(ÿ4ÿ

%FþFSMFOEJSNF4PSVMBS‘
#VFULJOMJLUFOTPOSBFMNB LBCVþV ÎFLJSEFþJ ÎÚQàIBLL‘OEBOFEàāàOàZPSTVOV[
4J[DFFOEFþFSMJWBSM‘LOFEJS
4J[DFEFþFSTJ[WBSM‘LWBSN‘E‘S 7BSTBIBOHJTJEJS

(àOàO.FTBK‘
i#J[PIBZWBOMBS‘LFOEJMFSJOFCPZVOFþEJSEJL
0OMBSEBOCJSL‘TN‘CJOFLMFSJEJS CJSL‘TN‘O‘
EBZFSMFS0OMBSJÎJOCVIBZWBOMBSEB EBIB
QFLÎPL ZBSBSMBSWFJÎFDFLMFSWBSE‘S)ÉMÉ
āàLSFUNFZFDFLMFSNJ w
:ÉTÔO  

,BQBO‘ā
(SVQàZFMFSJOFQBZMBā‘NMBS‘JÎJOUFāFLLàSFEJO
)FSLFTJOBLM‘OEBLBMBONFTBK‘QBZMBāNBT‘O‘JTUFZJO
,POVZMBJMHJMJWBSTBTPSVMBS‘O‘BM‘OWFDFWBQMBZ‘O
#JSTPOSBLJLPOVOVOCBāM‘þ‘O‘WFSJOWFWFEBMBā‘O

139
ÿ / 4 " /  7 &  5" # ÿ "5  4 & 7 ( ÿ 4 ÿ

)ÿ±#ÿ3Ā&:4&#&14ÿ;:"3"5*-."%*
,B[BO‘N
"MMBI‘OZBSBUU‘þ‘CàUàOWBSM‘LMBS‘OCJSWB[JGFTJOJOPMEVþVOVCJMJS

½þSFUJDJ/PUV
:FSZà[àOEF NJMZPOMBSDB DBOM‘ UàSàOàO ZBāBNBLUB PMEVþV WF CV DBOM‘MBS‘O CJSCJSJOEFO
ÎPLGBSLM‘Ú[FMMJLMFSFTBIJQPMEVþVJ[BIFEJMJS#VEVSVNiy,VāMBS‘WFUFTQJIFEFOEBþMBS‘EB
%BWVUBCPZVOFþEJSEJL #VOMBS‘ #J[ZBQNBLUBZ‘[w &OCJZÉ  BZFUJZMFEFMJMMFOEJSJMFSFL 
BZFUUFCFMJSUJMFOLVāMBS‘OWFEBþMBS‘OUFTCJIJOJOPMEVþVWFPOMBS‘OZBSBU‘M‘āHBZFTJOFVZHVO
PMBSBL LÉJOBUUB HÚSNàā PMEVþV WB[JGFMFS PMEVþV CFMJSUJMJS $BOM‘MBS‘O IFS CJSJOJO LÉJOBUUB
CVMVONBT‘O‘OCJSTFCFCJPMEVþVWFIJÎCJSWBSM‘þ‘OHBZFTJ[PMBSBLZBSBU‘MNBE‘þ‘J[BIFEJMJS
:ÚOUFNWF5FLOJLMFS
4PSV$FWBQ &þJUTFM0ZVO

&ULJOMJL
ZBā
½þSFUJDJ i±PDVLMBS CJSEPLUPSVOHÚSFWJOF wEJZFTPSBSWFDFWBQMBS‘O‘EJOMFS%BIBTPOSB
i1FLJCJSJOāBBUNàIFOEJTJOJOHÚSFWJOFEJS wTPSVTVOVTPSBSWFDFWBQMBS‘EJOMFS½þSFUJDJ 
i±PDVLMBS LÉJOBUUB IFS āFZJ 3BCCJNJ[ CJS Eà[FOF IJ[NFU FUTJOMFS EJZF ZBSBUN‘āU‘S :àDF
LJUBC‘N‘[,VSBOEB3BCCJNJ[A#J[HÚLMFSJ ZFSJWFCVOMBSBSBT‘OEBCVMVOBOMBS‘ PZVOWFFþMFODF
PMTVO EJZF ZBSBUNBE‘L %VIÉO    EJZF CVZVSNVāUVS )JÎCJS āFZ BNBÎT‘[ TFCFQTJ[
ZBSBU‘MNBN‘āU‘S ¬EFUB IFS DBOM‘ CV EàOZB EBJSFTJOEF ÎBM‘āBO CJS NFNVSEVS )BTUBM‘LMBSMB
NàDBEFMF FUNFL JÎJO EPLUPSVO  JOTBOMBS‘O IBZBU‘O‘ LPMBZMBāU‘SNBL WF Hà[FMMFāUJSNFL JÎJO
FWWFZPMJOāBFEFONàIFOEJTJOHÚSFWJHJCJCJSLBS‘ODBO‘O CJSBS‘O‘O (àOFāJOWF"Z‘OEB
LFOEJOFIBTHÚSFWMFSJWBSE‘SwEFS
#V BΑLMBNBEBO TPOSB ÚþSFUJDJ i±PDVLMBS CJS TPOSBLJ EFSTJNJ[ JÎJO TJ[EFO CJS āFZ
JTUFZFDFþJN ,ÉJOBUUB WB[JGFTJ PMBO CV DBOM‘MBSB EBJS CJS BSBāU‘SNB ZBQ‘Q QBZMBāNBO‘[‘
JTUJZPSVN "Z  (àOFā  LBS‘ODB  BS‘  JOFL  LÚQFL  BU  LVā  TJWSJTJOFL  CBM‘L ZB EB TJ[JO
TFÎFDFþJOJ[ CBāLB DBOM‘MBS IBLL‘OEB PMBCJMJS ±BM‘āNBN‘[‘O EBIB LFZJnJ PMNBT‘ JÎJO EF CJS
ZÚOUFN J[MFZFDFþJ[ 4J[MFS BDBS NVIBCJSMFS PMBDBLT‘O‘[ WF TFÎUJþJOJ[ CV DBOM‘MBSMB SÚQPSUBK
ZBQN‘āPMBSBLCJMHJMFSJOJ[JCJ[JNMFQBZMBāBDBLT‘O‘[.FSBLFUNFZJO TPSBDBþ‘O‘[TPSVMBSJÎJO
TJ[FZBSE‘ND‘PMBDBþ‘NBNBEJLLBUFEFMJNLJNTFBZO‘DBOM‘ZMBSÚQPSUBKZBQNBT‘OLJEBIBÎPL


ÿ / 4 " /  7 &  5" # ÿ "5  4 & 7 ( ÿ 4 ÿ

CJMHJFEJOFMJNwEFSWFBāBþ‘EBLJTPSVMBS‘ÎPDVLMBSBWFSJS
ÿTNJOJ[JÚþSFOFCJMJSNJZJ[
,FOEJOJ[JCJ[FL‘TBDBUBO‘UBCJMJSNJTJOJ[
)PCJMFSJOJ[OFMFSEJS
4J[JOLÉJOBUUBLJEà[FOEFHÚSFWJOJ[OFEJS
#VJāJZBQN‘ZPSPMTBZE‘O‘[ CBāLBOFZBQNBLJTUFSEJOJ[
½þSFUJDJÎPDVLMBSB ZBQBDBLMBS‘SÚQPSUBKEBJTUFEJLMFSJGBSLM‘TPSVMBS‘EBTPSBCJMFDFLMFSJOJ
TÚZMFS "ZS‘DB SÚQPSUBK‘O OBT‘M ZBQ‘MBDBþ‘ JMF JMHJMJ ÎPDVLMBSB CJMHJ WFSJS #VOB HÚSF SÚQPSUBK
JLJ LJāJEFO PMVāBO HSVQMBS UBSBG‘OEBO DBOMBOE‘SNB ZÚOUFNJ LVMMBO‘MBSBL ZBQ‘MBDBLU‘S
±PDVLMBSEBOCJSJTPSVTPSBSLFOHSVQBSLBEBā‘PMBOÎPDVLDFWBQWFSFDFLUJS
#JS TPOSBLJ EFSTF ÚþSFUNFO NJLSPGPO PMBSBL LVMMBO‘MBCJMFDFL CJS NBUFSZBM JMF HFMJS WF
CVOV ÎPDVLMBSB WFSFSFL DBOMBOE‘SNBMBS‘ ZBQNBMBS‘O‘ JTUFS 5àN HSVQMBS TVOVNMBS‘O‘
UBNBNMBE‘LUBOTPOSBÚþSFUNFOSÚQPSUBK‘ZBQ‘MN‘āDBOM‘MBSWF"MMBI‘OZBSBUU‘þ‘EJþFSCàUàO
DBOM‘MBSJMFJMHJMJUFLSBSL‘TBCJSTPICFUIBWBT‘PMVāUVSBSBLWFSJMNFLJTUFOFONFTBK‘Ú[FUMFS

%FþFSMFOEJSNF4PSVMBS‘
,ÉJOBUUBLJEà[FOOBT‘MTBþMBO‘ZPS
,ÉJOBUUBIFSLFTà[FSJOFEàāFOHÚSFWJZFSJOFHFUJSNF[TFOFMFSPMVS
4J[DF"MMBIOFEFOCÚZMFCJSEà[FOLVSNVāUVS

(àOàO.FTBK‘
i3BCCJOCBMBS‘T‘OBāÚZMFJMIBNFUUJ%BþMBSEBO 
BþBÎMBSEBOWFJOTBOMBS‘OZBQU‘LMBS‘ÎBSEBLMBSEBO
LPWBOMBSEBO LFOEJOFFWMFSFEJO4POSBNFZWFMFSJO
IFQTJOEFOZFEF3BCCJOJOTBOBLPMBZMBāU‘SE‘þ‘ ZBZM‘N 
ZPMMBS‘OBHJS0OMBS‘OLBS‘OMBS‘OEBOÎFāJUMJSFOLMFSEFCBM
ΑLBS0OEBJOTBOMBSJÎJOāJGBWBSE‘SĀàQIFTJ[CVOEB
EàāàOFOCJS UPQMVN JÎJOCJSJCSFUWBSE‘Sw
/BIM  

,BQBO‘ā
(SVQàZFMFSJOFQBZMBā‘NMBS‘JÎJOUFāFLLàSFEJO
)FSLFTJOBLM‘OEBLBMBONFTBK‘QBZMBāNBT‘O‘JTUFZJO
,POVZMBJMHJMJWBSTBTPSVMBS‘O‘BM‘OWFDFWBQMBZ‘O
#JSTPOSBLJLPOVOVOCBāM‘þ‘O‘WFSJOWFWFEBMBā‘O

141
ÿ / 4 " /  7 &  5" # ÿ "5  4 & 7 ( ÿ 4 ÿ

½þSFUJDJ/PUV
"MMBIV5FÉMÉO‘O LÉJOBUUBLJCàUàOWBSM‘LMBS‘CJSIJLNFUWFEà[FOJMFZBSBUU‘þ‘CVEà[FOJO
CJS BNBD‘ IFEFnFNFLUF PMEVþV  :BSBU‘D‘O‘O CJMJONFTJOJO FO ÚOFNMJ EFMJMMFSJOEFO PMEVþV
BΑLMBO‘S
,VSBOEB 4BG TVSFTJOJO CJSJODJ BZFUJOEF JGBEF FEJMEJþJ HJCJ CàUàO WBSM‘LMBS‘O ZBSBU‘M‘ā
HBZFTJOJO "MMBIB LVMMVL PMEVþV i(ÚLMFSEF PMBOMBS EB ZFSEF PMBOMBS EB "MMBI‘ UFTQJI
FEFSMFSw 4BG  JOTBO‘O LàÎàLDBOM‘MBS‘O CJULJMFSJO EBþMBS‘O ZFSZà[àOàOWFTFNBO‘O
ZBSBU‘M‘ā‘O‘OCJSHBZFZFZÚOFMJLPMEVþVWVSHVMBO‘S#VLPOVEBāVBZFUPLVOVSWFBΑLMBO‘S
i0OMBS àTUMFSJOEFLJHÚþFCBLNB[MBSN‘LJ POVOBT‘MCJOBFUNJāWFTàTMFNJāJ[ POVOIJÎCJS
ÎBUMBþ‘ZPLUVS:FSJEFOBT‘MV[BUN‘ā à[FSJOFTBCJUEBþMBSPUVSUNVāV[0SBEBHÚSàOàāàHà[FM
IFSÎFāJUCJULJEFOÎJGUMFSZFUJāUJSEJL#VOMBS "MMBIBZÚOFMFOIFSLVMBHÚOàMHÚ[àOàBÎNBLWF
POBJCSFUWFSNFLJÎJOEJSw ,ÉG 

:ÚOUFNWF5FLOJLMFS
"OMBU‘N 4PSV$FWBQ

&ULJOMJL
ZBā 
½þSFUJDJ LBS‘ODBMBS‘OZBāBOU‘MBS‘OBEBJSBāBþ‘EBLJNFUOJÎPDVLMBSBPLVS
i,BS‘ODBMBS JOTBOMBSB PSBOMB ZBLMBā‘L  NJMZPO LBU EBIB GB[MBE‘S :BāBZ‘ā UBS[MBS‘ JTF
JOTBOB ÚSOFL PMBCJMFDFL LBEBS Hà[FMEJS #JSCJSMFSJZMF EBZBO‘āNB JÎJOEF PMBO LBS‘ODBMBS
ÚSHàUMFOFSFL UPQMVMVLMBS IBMJOEF ZBāBNBLUBE‘S #V ÚSHàUMFONF ÎPL HFMJāNJāUJS ,BS‘ODBMBS
JIUJZBD‘PMBOCFTJOMFSJàSFUJSWFEFQPMBS#VJāMFNMFSJZBQBSLFOEJþFSZBOEBOZBWSVMBS‘O‘E‘ā
UFIMJLFMFSF LBSā‘ LPSVS WF LPMPOJMFSJOF EJþFS DBOM‘MBS UBSBG‘OEBO HFMFCJMFDFL TBME‘S‘ZB LBSā‘
IB[‘SCVMVOVSMBS,PMPOJMFSJOF[BSBSWFSNFLJTUFZFODBOM‘MBSBLBSā‘TBWBā‘SMBS
,PMPOJMFS BSBT‘OEB CFMMJ CJS HÚSFW EBþ‘M‘N‘ CVMVONBLUBE‘S ,PMPOJMFSJO CB[‘MBS‘ UBS‘NMB
VþSBā‘SLFO CB[‘MBS‘JTFIBZWBOMBSMBJMHJMFOJQPOMBS‘ZFUJāUJSFCJMNFLUFEJS#VWFCFO[FSJāFLJMEF
LPMPOJMFSBSBT‘OEBJāCÚMàNàZBQ‘MNBLUBE‘S#VZBQ‘MBOJāCÚMàNàZMFCJSMJLUFLBS‘ODBMBSEB
V[NBOMBāNB BSUNBLUBE‘S :BOJ L‘TB CJS TàSF TPOSB CFMMJ CJS BMBOEB V[NBOMBāN‘ā LBS‘ODB
UPQMVMVLMBS‘PSUBZBΑLNBLUBE‘S
#V TJTUFNEF LBS‘ODBMBS BSBT‘ SFLBCFU EJZF CJS āFZ ZPLUVS )FSLFT V[NBOMBāU‘þ‘ JāJOJ
FO JZJ CJS āFLJMEF ZFSJOF HFUJSNFLUFEJS ,PMPOJMFSJO NJMZPOMBSDB àZFTJ CVMVOBCJMNFLUFEJS
#VOB SBþNFO TPTZBM Eà[FOMFSJOEF IFSIBOHJ CJS BLTBLM‘L PMNBNBLUBE‘S ,PMPOJMFS BSBT‘
EBZBO‘āNBZMB CJSMJLUF IFSLFT CV TJTUFNEFO GBZEBMBONBLUBE‘S ,BS‘ODBMBS‘O CV TJTUFNJOJ
CJSÎPL CJMJN BEBN‘  mMP[PG JODFMFNJā BODBL JOTBOMBSB VZBSMBZBNBN‘āU‘S ±àOLà JOTBOMBS

142
ÿ / 4 " /  7 &  5" # ÿ "5  4 & 7 ( ÿ 4 ÿ

LJāJTFM ΑLBS‘  ÚSHàU ΑLBS‘OEBO àTUàO UVUNVāUVS #V āFLJMEF PMEVþV JÎJO TPTZP FLPOPNJL
CJSMJLUFMJLMFSLBM‘D‘CJSIV[VSHFUJSNFNJāUJS
A'PSNJDB:FTFOTJTLBS‘ODBMBS‘O‘OLVSEVþVLPMPOJMFSEàOZBO‘OFOCàZàLLPMPOJMFSJOEFO
TBZ‘M‘S :BLMBā‘L  NJMZPO LSBMJÎF WF  NJMZPO JāÎJ LBS‘ODB CV LPMPOJEF ZBāBNBLUBE‘S
,PMPOJ JÎJOEF JTF ÚSHàUMFONF àTU Eà[FZEFEJS )FSLFT ZBQNBT‘ HFSFLFOJ FO JZJ āFLJMEF
HFSÎFLMFāUJSNFLUFEJS
,BS‘ODBMBS‘O TPTZBM Eà[FOJOEF CJS CFLÎJZF JIUJZBÎ EVZVMNBNBLUBE‘S "SBMBS‘OEB CJS
ZÚOFUJDJ HSVQ PMNBNBT‘OB SBþNFO HÚSFWMFSJOJ LVTVSTV[ ZBQNBMBS‘ NVIUFāFN CJS PMBZE‘S
,FOEJZBāBN‘N‘[BCBLBDBLPMVSTBL CJ[MFSUPQMVMVLIÉMJOFHFMEJþJNJ[EFNVUMBLBCJSMJEFSF
JIUJZBÎEVZBS‘[-JEFSPMNBE‘þ‘UBLEJSEFEà[FOLVSNBLUB[PSMBO‘S‘[#VOVOFOHà[FMÚSOFþJ
àMLFMFSWFZÚOFUJNUBS[MBS‘O‘OWBSM‘þ‘E‘Sw
½þSFUJDJNFUOJPLVEVLUBOTPOSBLBU‘M‘ND‘MBSJMFBāBþ‘EBLJCBāM‘LMBS‘UBSU‘ā‘S
:VLBS‘EBCFMJSMFOFOLB[BO‘NMBSEPþSVMUVTVOEBΑLBS‘NMBSZBQ‘O‘[
,BS‘ODBMBSÉMFNJOJOTPSVNMVMVLWFEà[FOJEFWBNFUUJSNFBOMBZ‘ā‘JMFJOTBOM‘LÉMFNJOJO
ZBQU‘LMBS‘O‘LBSā‘MBāU‘S‘O‘[
,BS‘ODBMBS‘OEà[FOJHJCJEà[FOFTBIJQCJSEàOZBO‘ONàNLàOBU‘à[FSJOEFLSJUJLZBQ‘O‘[
ÿOTBO‘O "MMBIUBSBG‘OEBOLVSVMBOCVEà[FOEFWB[JGFTJOFEJS
#JSFZTFMNFOGBBUMFSJMFUPQMVNTBMNFOGBBUMFSBΑT‘OEBOTPSVNMVMVLMBS‘EFþFSMFOEJSJOJ[

143
ÿ / 4 " /  7 &  5" # ÿ "5  4 & 7 ( ÿ 4 ÿ

%FþFSMFOEJSNF4PSVMBS‘
ÿOTBO‘OZBSBU‘M‘āBNBD‘OFEJS
#JULJMFS IBZWBOMBSOJÎJOZBSBU‘MN‘āU‘S
,ÉJOBUUBLJEà[FOJOTBþMBONBT‘OEBZBSBU‘MN‘āMBS‘OSPMàOFEJS

(àOàO.FTBK‘
i#J[HÚLMFSJ ZFSJWFCVOMBSBSBT‘OEB
CVMVOBOMBS‘FþMFONFLJÎJOZBSBUNBE‘L POMBS‘
HFSÎFLCJSTFCFQMFZBSBUU‘L'BLBUPOMBS‘O
ÎPþVCJMNJZPSMBSw
%VIÉO 

,BQBO‘ā
(SVQàZFMFSJOFQBZMBā‘NMBS‘JÎJOUFāFLLàSFEJO
)FSLFTJOBLM‘OEBLBMBONFTBK‘QBZMBāNBT‘O‘JTUFZJO
,POVZMBJMHJMJWBSTBTPSVMBS‘O‘BM‘OWFDFWBQMBZ‘O
#JSTPOSBLJLPOVOVOCBāM‘þ‘O‘WFSJOWFWFEBMBā‘O

144
ÿ / 4 " /  7 &  5" # ÿ "5  4 & 7 ( ÿ 4 ÿ

½þSFUJDJ/PUV
:BSBU‘MN‘ā UàN DBOM‘ WF DBOT‘[ WBSM‘LMBS LFOEJMFSJOF EàāFO WB[JGFMFSJ ZBQNBLUBE‘SMBS
&ULJOMJLÚODFTJCVHJCJCJMHJMFSJJÎFSFOWFÎPDVLMBS‘OBOMBZBCJMFDFþJCJSLBÎBZFUPLVONBM‘E‘S
#ÚZMFDFFULJOMJLUFOÚODFÎPDVLMBSIB[‘SMBONBM‘E‘S

:ÚOUFNWF5FLOJLMFS
#VMVā:PMVZMB½þSFUJN 5BSU‘āNB:ÚOUFNJ 0ZVO

.BUFSZBM
'PUPþSBGLBSUMBS‘

&ULJOMJL
ZBā
4FÎ#JSJOJ
±PDVLMBSBA4FÎ#JSJOJJTJNMJFULJOMJþFCBāM‘ZPSV[ EJZFSFLEJLLBUMFSJFULJOMJþFÎFLJMJS
3FTJNMFSLFTJMFSFLLBSUIBMJOFHFUJSJMJS
,FTJMFOSFTJNMFSJLJZFLBUMBOBSBLZBQ‘āU‘S‘M‘S½[FMMJLMFSJSFTNJOBSLBT‘OEBLBM‘S
,BSUMBSQXDMFOFSFLEBIBV[VOTàSFMJWFEBIBLBMJUFMJāFLJMEFLVMMBO‘MBCJMJS
"S‘ TJWSJTJOFL TPMVDBO Z‘MBO EJLFOCJULJTJ (àOFā TVZPTVOV CVþEBZSFTJNMFSJPMBO
LBSUMBSJLJHSVCBBZ‘S‘*BSBLEJ[JMJS
±PDVLMBSEBOCJSJOFCJSJODJHSVQUBLJEJ[JMNJāPMBOLBSUMBSEBOEFþFSMJHÚSEàþàOàTFÎ
CBLBM‘NEJZFSFLCJSLBSUTFÎNFTJJTUFOJS
4FÎUJþJLBSU‘OFEFOEFþFSMJHÚSEàþàà[FSJOFUBSU‘ā‘M‘S
%BIBTPOSBJLJODJHSVQLBSUMBSEBOEFþFSTJ[HÚSEàþàOLBSU‘TFÎCBLBM‘NEJZFSFLCJS
LBSUTFÎUJSJMJS
4FÎNFEJþJLBSUMBS‘OFEFOEFþFSTJ[HÚSEàþàJMFJMHJMJmLJSMFSJBM‘O‘S
4FÎJMFOLBSU‘OBSLBT‘OBCBL‘M‘S JGBEFFUNFEJþJÚ[FMMJLWBSTBPLVOVS
#VāFLJMEFUàNÎPDVLMBS‘OT‘SBZMBCJSJODJWFJLJODJHSVQLBSUMBSEBOTFÎNFTJZMFPZVOB
EFWBNFEJMJS
,BSUMBSEBLJWBSM‘LMBS‘OÚ[FMMJLMFSJIBLL‘OEBUBSU‘ā‘M‘S
½þSFUJDJLPOVZVUPQBSMBSWFFULJOMJLA#FOCVOEBOTPOSBIFSWBSM‘þBEBIBGBSLM‘CJS
CBL‘āBΑT‘ZMBCBLBDBþ‘NZBEBA)FSWBSM‘LCFOJNJÎJOāJNEJEBIBEBEFþFSMJHJCJNPUJWBTZPO
TBþMBZ‘D‘CJSTMPHBOMBCJUJSJMJS

145
ÿ / 4 " /  7 &  5" # ÿ "5  4 & 7 ( ÿ 4 ÿ

t"S‘MBSUBS‘NTBMCJULJMFSJOUP[MBāNBT‘O‘
TBþMBSMBS
tÃSFUUJLMFSJCBMWJUBNJOPMBSBLÎPL
[FOHJOEJS
t"S‘TàUà QPMFO QSPQPMJTHJCJGBSLM‘ 
GBZEBM‘àSàOMFSEFàSFUJSMFS
t"S‘O‘O[FIJSJOEFOCJMFJMBÎTFLUÚSàOEF
ZBSBSMBO‘M‘S

t5PQSBLLBMJUFTJOJBSUU‘S‘S
t4PMVDBOMBSUPQSBLUBUàOFMBÎBSBMBSWF
UPQSBLIBWBMBO‘S
t0SHBOJLBU‘LMBS‘OHFSJEÚOàāàNàOEF
ÚOFNMJCJSSPMPZOBS
t#FTJOMFSJOCFTJOEFþFSJOJBSUU‘S‘S

t5BSMBWFCBIÎFMFSEFCVMVOBOUBSMB
GBSFTJ LÚTUFCFLHJCJ[BSBSM‘LFNJSHFOMFSJ
ZFS CÚZMFDFUBSMBMBSEBWFSJNBSUBS
t:‘MBO[FISJU‘QBMBO‘OEB
LVMMBO‘MNBLUBE‘S
t"ZS‘DBLBSUBM MFZMFLHJCJLVāMBSEB
Z‘MBOMBCFTMFOJS

t4JWSJTJOFLMFSJOMBSWBMBS‘TVJÎJOEFZBāBS
WFTVFLPTJTUFNJJÎJOÎPLÚOFNMJEJS
t4JWSJTJOFLMFSJUàLFUFOCJSÎPLCÚDFLWF
LVāUàSàWBSE‘S
t4JWSJTJOFLZBSBU‘M‘āPMBSBLEB
NàLFNNFMEJS"W‘O‘LPMBZZBLBMBNBZ‘
TBþMBZBOEFEFLUÚSMFSJWBSE‘S

146
ÿ / 4 " /  7 &  5" # ÿ "5  4 & 7 ( ÿ 4 ÿ

t)BTUBM‘LMBS‘OUFEBWJTJOEFEFLVMMBO‘M‘S
t#B[‘UàSMFSJZFOJMFCJMJSWFÎBZPMBSBL
JÎJMJS
t5BāM‘CÚMHFMFSEFLFOEJMJþJOEFOCJUFS 
LJSFÎMJUPQSBþ‘TFWFS ÎFWSFZJZFāJMMFOEJSJS
t(à[FMLPLVMVEVSWFIPāÎJÎFLMFSJPMVS

t%PþBMFOFSKJLBZOBþ‘E‘S
t7àDVEB%WJUBNJOJTFOUF[JZBQBS
t4BþM‘þ‘N‘[JÎJOÎPLÚOFNMJEJS
t#JULJMFSJOOFSEFZTFCàZàLCÚMàNà
(àOFā‘ā‘þ‘TBZFTJOEFCàZàS

t" $ & , #WF#WJUBNJOMFSJ 


LBMTJZVN GPTGPS QPUBTZVNWBSE‘S
t$JMEF TBÎMBSB TJOEJSJNTJTUFNJOF HÚ[
TBþM‘þ‘OBGBZEBM‘E‘S
t7àDVEVUFNJ[MFSWFLJMPWFSNFZJ
LPMBZMBāU‘S‘S
t&LNFþJOFTBTNBEEFTJEJS

t5BS‘N U‘QWFCFTJONBEEFMFSJ
TBOBZJTJOEFLVMMBO‘M‘S
t%PLVNBD‘M‘LUBEBBSU‘LLVMMBO‘MNBZB
CBāMBON‘āU‘S
t%FOJ[EFLJCFTJO[JODJSJJÎJOÎPL
ÚOFNMJEJS
t,P[NFUJLBMBO‘OEB DJMUCBL‘N‘OEBEB
GBZEBM‘E‘S

147
ÿ / 4 " /  7 &  5" # ÿ "5  4 & 7 ( ÿ 4 ÿ

%FþFSMFOEJSNF4PSVMBS‘
4J[JFOÎPLāBā‘SUBOIBOHJWBSM‘LPMEV
#VFULJOMJLTJ[EFOBT‘MCJSEFþJāJLMJLZBEBGBSLM‘CBL‘āBΑT‘TBþMBE‘
3. ,ÉJOBUUBLJEà[FOMFWBSM‘LMBS‘OHÚSFWMFSJOJZFSJOFHFUJSNFTJBSBT‘OEBOBT‘MCJSJMJāLJCVMVOVS

(àOàO.FTBK‘
iÿLJEFOJ[BZO‘PMNB[ĀVUBUM‘E‘S TVTV[MVþVHJEFSJS
JÎJNJLPMBZE‘SĀVJTFUV[MVEVS BD‘E‘S#VOVOMBCFSBCFS
IFSCJSJOEFOUB[FFUZFSTJOJ[WFUBL‘OBDBþ‘O‘[TàTFāZBT‘
ΑLBS‘ST‘O‘["MMBI‘OMàUGVOEBOJTUFNFOJ[WFāàLSFUNFOJ[
JÎJOHFNJMFSJOPSBEBTVZVZBSBZBSBHJUUJþJOJHÚSàSTàOw
'ÉU‘S 

,BQBO‘ā
(SVQàZFMFSJOFQBZMBā‘NMBS‘JÎJOUFāFLLàSFEJO
)FSLFTJOBLM‘OEBLBMBONFTBK‘QBZMBāNBT‘O‘JTUFZJO
,POVZMBJMHJMJWBSTBTPSVMBS‘O‘BM‘OWFDFWBQMBZ‘O
#JSTPOSBLJLPOVOVOCBāM‘þ‘O‘WFSJOWFWFEBMBā‘O


ÿ / 4 " /  7 &  5" # ÿ "5  4 & 7 ( ÿ 4 ÿ

:"3"5*-.*Ā-"3*/&/%&ý&3-ÿ4ÿ0-"/
ÿ/4"/*/4036.-6-6ý6
,B[BO‘N
ÿOTBO‘OZBSBU‘MN‘āMBSJÎFSJTJOEFFOEFþFSMJWBSM‘LPMEVþVOVCJMJS
ÿOTBO‘EFþFSMJL‘MBOāFZJOPOBZàLMFOFOTPSVNMVMVLMBSPMEVþVOVCJMJS

½þSFUJDJ/PUV
ÿOTBO‘OZBSBU‘MN‘āMBSJÎFSJTJOEFFOEFþFSMJWBSM‘LPMEVþV "MMBI‘UBO‘NBZBWF0OBJOBONBZB
FMWFSJāMJCJSZBQ‘EBZBSBU‘ME‘þ‘JGBEFFEJMJSi#J[JOTBO‘FOHà[FMCJÎJNEFZBSBUU‘Lw 5ÔO  
BZFUJLFSJNFTJZMFJOTBOBWFSJMFOCVEFþFSJOWFHà[FMMJþJOPSUBZBLPOEVþVWVSHVMBO‘S
"MMBI‘OLÉJOBUUBDBOM‘DBOT‘[CJSÎPLWBSM‘LZBSBUU‘þ‘WFCVWBSM‘LMBSEBOCJSJOJOEFJOTBO
PMEVþV BOMBU‘M‘S "ODBL JOTBO‘O BL‘M WF JSBEF TBIJCJ PMNBT‘ OFEFOJZMF EJþFS WBSM‘LMBSEBO
BZS‘ME‘þ‘WFCVEVSVNVOJOTBO‘TPSVNMVCJSWBSM‘LIÉMJOFEÚOàāUàSEàþàCFMJSUJMJS
,VSBO‘,FSJNEFiĀàQIFTJ[CJ[POBEPþSVZPMVHÚTUFSEJL JTUFSāàLSFEFS JTUFSOBOLÚSMàL
FEFSw ÿOTÉO  BZFUJZMFUFSDJIJOTPSVNMVCJSWBSM‘LPMBOJOTBOBC‘SBL‘ME‘þ‘CFMJSUJMNFLUFEJS

:ÚOUFNWF5FLOJLMFS
"OMBU‘N 4PSV$FWBQ

&ULJOMJL
ZBā
½þSFUJDJ  IBCFS LBZOBLMBS‘ JMF JMHJMJ ÎPDVLMBS HFOFM CJS CJMHJ QBZMBā‘N‘ ZBQBS WF HB[FUF 
UFMFWJ[ZPO  EFSHJ HJCJ JMFUJāJN BSBÎMBS‘ WBT‘UBT‘ZMB àMLFNJ[EF WF EàOZBN‘[EB HFSÎFLMFāFO
PMBZMBSJMFJMHJMJCJMHJTBIJCJPMBCJMFDFþJNJ[JTÚZMFS%BIBTPOSBÎPDVLMBSBāVTPSVMBSTPSVMVS
iÃMLFNJ[EF WFZB EàOZBEB PMBO PMBZMBS‘ OFSFEFO ÚþSFOJSJ[ w  i)BOHJ PMBZMBSB IBCFSMFSEF
ZFS WFSJMJS w #V LPOVMBSEB CJSB[ LPOVāVMEVLUBO TPOSB ÚþSFUJDJ  ZBQ‘MBDBL FULJOMJþJ āÚZMF
BOMBU‘Si"SLBEBāMBS CVHàOCJSMJLUFIBCFSLBZOBLMBS‘N‘[EBOPMBOHB[FUFEFOJLJUBOFLVQàS
PLVZBDBþ‘[WFCVOMBSIBLL‘OEBLPOVāBDBþ‘[½ODFMJLMFHB[FUFLVQàSMFSJNJ[FCJSCBLBM‘Nw
EBIB TPOSB FMJOEFLJ LJUBQUB HB[FUF LVQàSà UBTBS‘N‘OEB WFSJMNJā ZFSMFSJ HÚTUFSJS ½þSFUJDJ
FULJOMJþJBOMBUNBZBEFWBNFEFSi"SLBEBāMBSāJNEJEJLLBUMJDFCFOJEJOMFNFOJ[JJTUJZPSVN
#BLBM‘NCVIBCFSMFSOFIBLL‘OEBZN‘ā CFOEFNFSBLFUUJNEPþSVTVw

149
ÿ / 4 " /  7 &  5" # ÿ "5  4 & 7 ( ÿ 4 ÿ

½þSFUJDJ  ÚODFMJLMF JML IBCFSJ PLVS WF ÎPDVLMBSMB IBCFS IBLL‘OEB OF EàāàOEàLMFSJ WF
OFIJTTFUUJLMFSJà[FSJOFLPOVāVMVS%BIBTPOSBJLJODJIBCFSPLVOBSBLBZO‘āFLJMEFTPICFUF
EFWBNFEJMJS#VLPOVāNBMBSEBÎPDVLMBSZVLBS‘EBWFSJMFOLB[BO‘NMBSBHÚSFZÚOMFOEJSJMJS
ÿOTBO‘OTPSVNMVMVLTBIJCJWFEFþFSMJCJSWBSM‘LPMEVþVOBWVSHVZBQ‘M‘S

.BIBMMFMJWFÿUGBJZF,FEJ,VSUBSNBLÿÎJO4FGFSCFS0MEV
ÿ[NJSF CBþM‘ ±BOLBZB TFNUJOEF   NFUSF ZàLTFLMJLUFLJ CJS
BþBDBΑLBOWFBāBþ‘JOFNFZFOLFEJJUGBJZFUBSBG‘OEBOLVSUBS‘ME‘
ÿ[NJS (B[J 0TNBO 1BāB #VMWBS‘ à[FSJOEF ZBLMBā‘L  NFUSF
ZàLTFLMJþJOEF CJS BþBD‘O UFQFTJOF ΑLBO LFEJ  àÎ HàOEàS CVSBEB
NBITVS LBME‘ ,FEJOJO ÎFWSFEFLJ FTOBG UBSBG‘OEBO CJS UàSMà BāBþ‘ZB
JOEJSJMFNFNFTJ à[FSJOF ÿ[NJS ÿUGBJZFTJOEFO ZBSE‘N JTUFOEJ 0MBZ
ZFSJOF HFMFO FLJQ  ZPMV āFSJUMF USBmþF LBQBU‘Q  LFEJ LVSUBSNB
PQFSBTZPOVOBCBāMBE‘,FEJOJOBþBD‘OUFQFTJOEFOBM‘ONBT‘PMEVLÎB
[PSPMEV&LJQFOTPOVOEBLFEJZJBāBþ‘JOEJSNFZJCBāBSE‘ÿUGBJZFOJO
LFEJ LVSUBSNB PQFSBTZPOVOV J[MFNFL JÎJO UPQMBOBO IBML CV BO‘
DFQ UFMFGPOMBS‘ JMF HÚSàOUàMFEJ ±FWSFEF UPQMBOBO WBUBOEBāMBS ÿ[NJS
ÿUGBJZFTJOFUFāFLLàSFUUJ

:PMEB1BSB#VMBO±PDVL0OV1PMJTF5FTMJN&UUJ
4BLBSZBO‘O CJS JMÎFTJOEF   ZBā‘OEBLJ ÎPDVL  ZPMEB CVMEVþV QBSBZ‘
QPMJTF UFTMJN FUUJ %àāàSEàþà QBSBZ‘ QPMJTUFO UFTMJN BMBO FTOBG  QBSBZ‘
CVMBOÎPDVþVÚEàMMFOEJSEJZBā‘OEBLJÿMLÚþSFUJNPLVMVÚþSFODJTJÎPDVL
ZPMEBZàSàSLFOCJO5-CVMEVWFCVQBSBZ‘QPMJTFUFTMJNFUUJ
#VBSBEBJMÎFFNOJZFUBNJSMJþJOFHFMFOCJSFTOBG QBSBEàāàSEàþàOà
TÚZMFZFSFL NàSBDBBUUB CVMVOEV %àāàSEàþà QBSBT‘O‘O CJS ÎPDVL
UBSBG‘OEBOCVMVOEVþVOVÚþSFOFOWBUBOEBā CàZàLTFWJOÎZBāBE‘1BSBZ‘
QPMJTUFO UFTMJN BMBO FTOBG  QBSBZ‘ CVMBO ÎPDVþB ÚSOFL EBWSBO‘ā‘OEBO
EPMBZ‘UFāFLLàSFUUJ
1BSBZ‘ EàāàSFO FTOBG i1BSBZ‘ EàāàSEàþàNà FWJNF EÚOàODF GBSL
FUUJN 1BSBZ‘ JMÎFEF EàāàSNàā PMBCJMFDFþJNEFO ZFOJEFO JMÎFZF HFMFSFL
QPMJTF CBāWVSEVN 1PMJT QBSBN‘O CVMVOEVþVOV TÚZMFZJODF SBIBU CJS
OFGFTBME‘N1BSBZ‘CVMBSBLQPMJTFUFTMJNFEFOÎPDVLÚSOFLCJSEBWSBO‘ā
HÚTUFSNJāw EFEJ 1BSBZ‘ CVMBSBL TBIJCJOF VMBāU‘S‘MNBT‘O‘ TBþMBZBO ÎPDVL
JTF ZPMEBZàSàSLFOQBSBZ‘CVMEVþVOVWFÎPLāBā‘SE‘þ‘O‘CFMJSUFSFLQBSBZ‘
QPMJTFUFTMJNFUUJþJOJLBZEFUUJ


ÿ / 4 " /  7 &  5" # ÿ "5  4 & 7 ( ÿ 4 ÿ

%FþFSMFOEJSNF4PSVMBS‘
#JSLJāJOJOWFZBCJSIBZWBO‘OTJ[JOZBSE‘N‘O‘[BJIUJZBÎEVZEVþVCJSEVSVNJMFIJÎ
LBSā‘MBāU‘O‘[N‘ #ÚZMFCJSEVSVNEBOBT‘MEBWSBONBZ‘UFSDJIFUUJOJ[ /FEFO
)ßETVSFTJBZFUUFZFSBMBOAy&NSPMVOEVþVOHJCJEPTEPþSVPMyAFNSJOJPLVOBO
HB[FUFIBCFSMFSJJMFJMJāLJMFOEJSEJþJNJ[EFOBT‘MCJSEFþFSMFOEJSNFZBQBST‘O‘[
±FāJUMJLPOVMBSJMFJMHJMJUFSDJIMFSZBQBSLFO"MMBI‘OFNJSWFZBTBLMBS‘OBHÚSFEBWSBONBO‘O
UBā‘E‘þ‘ÚOFNTJ[DFOFEJS

(àOàO.FTBK‘
i)FSLJNJZJCJSJāZBQBSTBPOVOGBZEBT‘
LFOEJTJOFEJS,JNEFLÚUàMàLZBQBSTB
[BSBS‘ZJOFLFOEJTJOFEJSy
$ÉTJZF 

,BQBO‘ā
(SVQàZFMFSJOFQBZMBā‘NMBS‘JÎJOUFāFLLàSFEJO
)FSLFTJOBLM‘OEBLBMBONFTBK‘QBZMBāNBT‘O‘JTUFZJO
,POVZMBJMHJMJWBSTBTPSVMBS‘O‘BM‘OWFDFWBQMBZ‘O
#JSTPOSBLJLPOVOVOCBāM‘þ‘O‘WFSJOWFWFEBMBā‘O

151
ÿ / 4 " /  7 &  5" # ÿ "5  4 & 7 ( ÿ 4 ÿ

½þSFUJDJ/PUV
4PSVNMVMVþVO  LJāJOJO  LFOEJOF WF CBāLBMBS‘OB LBSā‘ ZFSJOF HFUJSNFTJ HFSFLFO
ZàLàNMàMàLMFSJOJ [BNBO‘OEB ZFSJOF HFUJSNFTJ PMEVþV BΑLMBO‘S ÿOTBO‘O  ZBSBU‘M‘ā‘ JUJCBSJ
JMFTPSVNMVMVLCJMJODJOJZFSJOFHFUJSFCJMFDFLEPOBO‘NBTBIJQPMBOBL‘MM‘UFLWBSM‘LPMEVþV
WVSHVMBOBSBL JOTBO‘OTPSVNMVMVLMBS‘WFHÚSFWMFSJāVEÚSUNBEEFEFBΑLMBO‘S
 "MMBIB ,BSā‘ 4PSVNMVLMBS‘N‘[ "MMBI ZBSBUBO  JOTBO JTF ZBSBU‘MBOE‘S ÿOTBO IFS
EVSVNEB "MMBIB NVIUBÎU‘S ÿOTBOB TBIJQ PMEVþV IFS āFZJ "MMBI CBIāFUNJāUJS 0 Zà[EFO
JOTBO "MMBIB LBSā‘ TàSFLMJ IBNE WF āàLàS IÉMJOEF PMNBM‘  "MMBI‘O EJOJOJ ZàDFMUNFL JÎJO
ÎBM‘āNBM‘E‘S
 ±FWSFZF 5BCJBUB  ,BSā‘ 4PSVNMVMVLMBS‘N‘[ %PþB  "MMBI‘O JOTBOMBSB à[FSJOEF
ZBāBNBMBS‘  ZFNFMFSJ  JÎNFMFSJ JÎJO CJS BSNBþBO‘E‘S #JS JOTBO WF NàNJO PMBSBL ZBāBO‘MBO
ÎFWSFZFLBSā‘EVZBSM‘PMVONBM‘±FWSFZJLJSMFUFOWFCP[BOIFSUàSMàGBBMJZFUFLBSā‘NàDBEFMF
FEJMNFMJ"MMBI‘OFNBOFUJPMBOUBCJBULPSVOBSBLTPOSBLJOFTJMMFSFBLUBS‘MNBM‘E‘S
 ÿOTBOMBSB ,BSā‘ 4PSVNMVMVLMBS‘N‘[ .àTMàNBO  EJþFS JOTBOMBSB LBSā‘ IPāHÚSàMà 
HàMFSZà[Mà ZBSE‘NTFWFSPMNBM‘JZJWFLÚUàHàOMFSJOEFEJþFSJOTBOMBS‘OZBO‘OEBCVMVONBM‘ 
i.àNJOMFS BODBL LBSEFāUJSw )VDVSÉU    JMBIÔ CVZSVþV HFSFþJ UPQMVNVNV[EB
LBSEFāMJLCBþMBS‘O‘HàÎMFOEJSJDJGBBMJZFUMFSZBQNBM‘E‘S
 ,FOEJNJ[F ,BSā‘ 4PSVNMVMVLMBS‘N‘[ )FN CFEFOJNJ[F IFN EF SVIVNV[B LBSā‘
TPSVNMVMVLMBS‘N‘[WBSE‘S#FTMFONFLJÎJOLVMMBOE‘þ‘N‘[H‘EBMBSBEJLLBUFUNFMJ CFEFOJNJ[JO
TBþM‘þ‘ JÎJO EFOHFMJ CFTMFONFMJZJ[ 7àDVEVNV[V E‘ā FULJMFSEFO HFMFDFL IBTUBM‘LMBSEBO
LPSVNBM‘Z‘[ WF ÚOMFNMFS BMBSBL TBþM‘þ‘N‘[B EJLLBU FUNFMJZJ[ #FEFOJNJ[J QJTMJLMFSEFO
LPSVNBM‘Z‘[ WF CFEFOJNJ[J UFNJ[ UVUNBM‘Z‘[ 3VIVNV[V BT‘MT‘[ WF ZBOM‘ā EàāàODFMFSEFO
BS‘OE‘SNBM‘Z‘[ 3VIVNV[V CJ[F GBZEB TBþMBZBDBL CJMHJMFSMF EPZVSNBM‘Z‘[ ,BMCJNJ[J
LÚUàMàLMFSEFO[JIOJNJ[J[BSBSM‘mLJSMFSEFOBS‘OE‘SNBM‘Z‘[

:ÚOUFNWF5FLOJLMFS
4PSV$FWBQ .BUFSZBM)B[‘SMBNB

.BUFSZBM
,BSUPO NBLBT LBMFN

152
ÿ / 4 " /  7 &  5" # ÿ "5  4 & 7 ( ÿ 4 ÿ

&ULJOMJL
ZBā
½þSFUJDJBāBþ‘EBLJIJLÉZFZJÎPDVLMBSBPLVZBSBLCBāMBS
)&3,&4 #ÿ3ÿ4ÿ )ÿ±,ÿ.4&7&)&3)"/(ÿ#ÿ3ÿ/&%"ÿ3.
i:BQ‘MNBT‘ HFSFLFO ÚOFNMJ CJS Jā WBSE‘ WF )&3,&4  #ÿ3ÿ4ÿ/ÿ/ P JāJ ZBQBDBþ‘OEBO
FNJOEJ)&3)"/(ÿ#ÿ3ÿPJāJZBQBCJMJSEJBNB)ÿ±,ÿ.4&ZBQNBE‘#ÿ3ÿ4ÿCVOBÎPL
L‘[E‘±àOLàCV)&3,&4JOJāJJEJ)&3,&4 )&3)"/(ÿ#ÿ3ÿOJOPJāJZBQBCJMFDFþJOJ
EàāàONàāUà 'BLBU )ÿ± ,ÿ.4&  P JāJO ZBQ‘MNBZBCJMFDFþJ JIUJNBMJ à[FSJOEF EVSNBE‘
)&3)"/(ÿ #ÿ3ÿOJO ZBQBCJMFDFþJ P JāJ )ÿ± ,ÿ.4& ZBQNBZ‘ODB )&3,&4 #ÿ3ÿ4ÿ/ÿ
TVÎMBE‘w
½þSFUJDJIJLÉZFZJPLVEVLUBOTPOSBIJLÉZFOJOLPOVTVOVTPSBS(FMFODFWBQMBSà[FSJOEFO
UBSU‘āNBZ‘ IFSLFTJO ZBQNBT‘ HFSFLFOMFS  CJSJTJOJO ZBQNBT‘O‘O ZFUFSMJ PMEVþV āFZMFS  IJÎ
LJNTFOJO ZBQNBNBT‘ HFSFLFO āFZMFS à[FSJOEFO EFWBN FUUJSJS #V BSBEB ÚSOFþJO iIFSLFTJO
ZBQNBT‘HFSFLFOMFSwTÚZMFOEJLÎFOPUFEJMJS5FTQJUFEJMFOCBāM‘LMBSBāBþ‘EBLJHJCJi4PSVNMVMVL
,BSUMBS‘wOB EÚOàāUàSàMàS )FS ÎPDVL LFOEJODF FO ÎPL LVMMBOBCJMFDFþJ LBSU‘ ÚSOFLMFSEF
PMEVþVHJCJIB[‘SMBS(FSFLMJHÚSEàþàEVSVNMBSEBLBSU‘LPZBS C‘SBL‘SZBEBZBQ‘āU‘S‘S

153
ÿ / 4 " /  7 &  5" # ÿ "5  4 & 7 ( ÿ 4 ÿ

.FSIBCB
"SBD‘O‘[‘FOHFMMJZPMVOBQBSLFUNFOJ[CFOJN
HJEFDFLZPMVNVOLBMNBNBT‘BOMBN‘OBHFMJZPS
#VOEBOTPOSBLJIBTTBTJZFUJOJ[JÎJOāJNEJEFO
UFāFLLàSFEFSJN

.FSIBCB
(ÚSFNFEJþJNJÎJOÚOàNEFLJFOHFMMFS
UFIMJLFMJPMBCJMJZPS(ÚSNFFOHFMMJ
ZPMMBS‘OBHÚTUFSFDFþJOJ[IBTTBTJZFUJÎJO
āJNEJEFOUFāFLLàSFEFSJN

5VWBMFUJUFNJ[UVUUVþVOV[
JÎJOUFāFLLàSMFS

567"-&5

.FSIBCB
-àUGFOÎÚQMFSJNJ[JÎÚQLVUVTVOB
BUBM‘N±FWSFZFLBSā‘HÚTUFSEJþJOJ[
IBTTBTJZFUJÎJOUFāFLLàSFEFSJ[

154
ÿ / 4 " /  7 &  5" # ÿ "5  4 & 7 ( ÿ 4 ÿ

%FþFSMFOEJSNF4PSVMBS‘
4PSVNMVMVLOFEJS
,FOEJNJ[FLBSā‘TPSVNMVMVLMBS‘N‘[OFMFSEJS
)FSLFTTPSVNMVMVLMBS‘O‘ZFSJOFHFUJSTFOBT‘MCJSEàOZBEBZBā‘ZPSPMVSEVL

(àOàO.FTBK‘
i"MMBI IJÎCJSLJNTFZJHàDàOàOZFUNFEJþJ
CJSāFZMFZàLàNMàL‘MNB[yw
#BLBSB 

,BQBO‘ā
(SVQàZFMFSJOFQBZMBā‘NMBS‘JÎJOUFāFLLàSFEJO
)FSLFTJOBLM‘OEBLBMBONFTBK‘QBZMBāNBT‘O‘JTUFZJO
,POVZMBJMHJMJWBSTBTPSVMBS‘O‘BM‘OWFDFWBQMBZ‘O
#JSTPOSBLJLPOVOVOCBāM‘þ‘O‘WFSJOWFWFEBMBā‘O

155
ÿ / 4 " /  7 &  5" # ÿ "5  4 & 7 ( ÿ 4 ÿ

½þSFUJDJ/PUV
:BSBU‘MN‘āMBSJÎFSJTJOEFFOEFþFSMJWBSM‘LPMBOJOTBOBL‘M JSBEFHJCJÚ[FMMJLMFSJZMFEFEJþFS
WBSM‘LMBSEBO BZS‘M‘S ÿOTBOB  GBSLM‘ TPSVNMVMVLMBS EB WFSJMNJāUJS 4PSVNMVMVL  BL‘M WF JSBEF
TBIJCJPMBOWFCVOVZFSJOFHFUJSFCJMFDFLHàDàPMBOBWFSJMJS:àDF3BCCJNJ[JOEFCJ[JFOHà[FM
āFLJMEFZBSBU‘QCJ[FFOZàLTFLEFþFSJWFSEJþJWFCJSUBL‘NTPSVNMVMVLMBS‘EBZFSJOFHFUJSNFNJ[J
JTUFEJþJWVSHVMBO‘S

:ÚOUFNWF5FLOJLMFS
0ZVO

.BUFSZBM
±BM‘āNBLÉþ‘E‘ NBLBT EÚSUBEFULVUV

&ULJOMJL
ZBā
4PSVNMVMVþVOV:BLBMB
i"MMBIBw i±FWSFNJ[F 5BCJBUB w iÿOTBOMBSBwWFi,FOEJNJ[FwLBSā‘TPSVNMVMVLMBS‘N‘[
CBāM‘LMBS‘BMU‘OEBHSVQPMVāUVSVMVS
0ZVOJÎJOHFSFLMJPMBOEBWSBO‘āMBS‘OZB[‘M‘PMEVþVTBZGBIFSHSVQJÎJOBZS‘BZS‘ÎPþBMU‘M‘S
)FSHSVQJÎJOCJSCBTJULVUVBZBSMBO‘S ZPLTBQPāFUEFPMVS
 5àN TPSVNMVMVL NBEEFMFSJ FLUFLJ TBZGBEBO LFTJMFSFL ΑLBS‘M‘S  )FS HSVQ JÎJO UàN
TPSVNMVMVLMBSLFTJMJSWFLBUMBOBSBLLVUVMBSBLPOVS.BUFSZBMMFSIB[‘SMBO‘S
½þSFUJDJi4PSVNMVMVþVOV:BLBMBwFULJOMJþJOFCBāM‘ZPSV[EJZFSFLÎPDVLMBS‘OEJLLBUJOJ
FULJOMJþFUPQMBNBZBÎBM‘ā‘S
 )FS HSVCVO LFOEJ TPSVNMVMVLMBS‘ JMF JMHJMJ CFā NBEEFTJ PMEVþV TÚZMFOJS  ±PDVLMBS
JÎJOVZHVOCJSTàSFCFMJSMFOJS½SOFþJOCFāEBLJLBHJCJ7FSJMFOTàSFEFLVUVEBLBS‘ā‘LPMBSBL
CVMVOBOTPSVNMVMVLMBS‘I‘[M‘DBPLVZVQLFOEJTPSVNMVMVLNBEEFMFSJOJCVMNBMBS‘JTUFOJS
 ½SOFþJO "MMBIB LBSā‘ TPSVNMVMVLMBS‘ CVMBDBL PMBO ÎPDVþB WFSJMFO LVUVEB UàN
TPSVNMVMVLMBS LBS‘ā‘L WF LBUMBON‘ā PMBSBL EVSVS ±PDVLMBS T‘SBZMB ÎFLFS WF PLVS  "MMBIB
LBSā‘TPSVNMVMVLMBS‘N‘[EBOCJSJOJCVMVODBIFNFOBZ‘S‘S
 )FS HSVQ CVMEVþV TPSVNMVMVL NBEEFMFSJOJ PLVS ½þSFUNFO EF EPþSV CVMEVLMBS‘
NBEEFTBZ‘MBS‘O‘TBZBS#FāNBEEFZJTàSFCJUJNJOEFJMLPMBSBLUBNBNMBZBOCJSJODJJMBOFEJMJS
9. &ULJOMJL CJUJNJOEF EFþFSMFOEJSNF TPSVMBS‘ JMF LPOV UPQBSMBO‘M‘S ±PDVLMBS‘O ZFSJOF
HFUJSNFEJþJTPSVNMVMVLMBSWBSTBLFOEJLFOEJMFSJOFLBSBSBMNBMBS‘LPOVTVOEBDFTBSFUMFOEJSJMJSMFS

156
ÿ / 4 " /  7 &  5" # ÿ "5  4 & 7 ( ÿ 4 ÿ

&L

"--")","3Ā*4036.-6-6,-"3*.*;

"MMBI‘OFNJSMFSJOJZFSJOFHFUJSNFMJWFZBTBLMBS‘OBVZNBM‘E‘S

½ODFMJLMFJOTBO "MMBI‘OWBSM‘þ‘O‘WFCJSMJþJOJLBCVMFEFSFL0OVOWBSM‘þ‘OB
WFUFLPMEVþVOBJOBONBM‘E‘S

ÿOTBOMBS"MMBIBJCBEFUFUNFMJWFCÚZMFDF"MMBI‘OS‘[BT‘O‘LB[BONBZB
ÎBM‘āNBM‘E‘S

ÿZJMJLMFSWFIBZ‘SMBSJāMFZFSFL"MMBI‘OS‘[BT‘O‘LB[BONBM‘E‘S

ÿOTBOMBS1FZHBNCFS&GFOEJNJ[JÚSOFLBMNBM‘WFPOVOHJCJÚSOFLCJSJOTBO
PMNBLJÎJOÎBM‘āNBM‘E‘S

±&73&:&5"#ÿ"5","3Ā*4036.-6-6,-"3*.*;

±FWSFZFLBSā‘TPSVNMVMVLMBS‘N‘[‘OCBā‘OEBPOVLPSVNBLHFMJS

4FWHJMJ1FZHBNCFSJNJ[i5FNJ[MJLJNBO‘OZBS‘T‘E‘SwCVZVSVS#VOFEFOMF
CJS.àTMàNBO ÎFWSFTJOJEFUFNJ[UVUNBM‘E‘S

1FZHBNCFSJNJ[ZFāJMBMBOMBS‘LPSVNBZ‘WFBþBÎEJLNFZJEFUBWTJZFFUNJāUJS

±FWSFEFOGBZEBMBO‘SLFOPOB[BSBSWFSNFNFZFÎBM‘ā‘MNBM‘E‘S

%PþBEBLJIFSāFZJOL‘ZNFUJOJCJMNFMJWFEPþBEBLJIJÎCJSāFZJJTSBG
FUNFNFMJWFUBCJBUB[BSBSWFSNFNFMJZJ[

157
ÿ / 4 " /  7 &  5" # ÿ "5  4 & 7 ( ÿ 4 ÿ

ÿ/4"/*/ÿ/4"/-"3","3Ā*4036.-6-6,-"3*

#VTPSVNMVMVLMBS‘OCBā‘OEBCJSCJSJNJ[JTFWNFLWFLBSā‘M‘LM‘IBLMBS‘N‘[BTBZH‘
HÚTUFSNFLHFMNFLUFEJS

5PQMVNTBMHÚSFWMFSJNJ[EFOCJSJEFJZJMJLUFZBSE‘NMBāNBL NVIUBÎMBSB
ZBSE‘NFMJV[BUNBLU‘S

5PQMVNTBMHÚSFWMFSJNJ[EFOCJSEJþFSJEFLBNVNBMMBS‘O‘LPSVNBL IBLT‘[
ZPMMBSMBCVOMBS‘FMEFFUNFNFZFÎBM‘āNBNBLU‘S

±BM‘āNBL àSFUNFLWFLB[BONBLCJSFZTFMCJSIBLPMEVþVHJCJ BZO‘


[BNBOEBLFOEJNJ[F BJMFNJ[FWFUPQMVNBLBSā‘WB[JGFNJ[EJS

"MMBI‘OWFSEJþJOJNFUMFSWFJNLÉOMBS JIUJZBDBHÚSFFOVZHVOāFLJMEF
LVMMBO‘MNBM‘ JTSBGFEJMNFNFMJ EJOÔWFBIMBLJÚMÎàMFSFHÚSFHFSFLFOZFSMFSF 
HFSFLUJþJLBEBSIBSDBONBM‘E‘S

ÿ/4"/*/,&/%ÿ/&,"3Ā*4036.-6-6,-"3*

:FEJþJNJ[F JÎUJþJNJ[FEJLLBUFEFSFLEFOHFMJWFTBþM‘LM‘CFTMFONFMJZJ[

7àDVEVNV[VIBTUBM‘LMBSEBOLPSVNBLWFIFSIBOHJCJSIBTUBM‘þB
ZBLBMBOE‘þ‘N‘[UBLEJSEFUFEBWJPMNBLEBHÚSFWJNJ[EJS

.àTMàNBO‘OCFEFOJ àTUàCBā‘EBUFNJ[PMNBM‘E‘S5FNJ[MJþJOTBþM‘þ‘N‘[‘O
LPSVONBT‘OEBÚOFNMJSPMàWBSE‘S

3VIVNV[VBT‘MT‘[WFZBOM‘āJOBOÎMBSEBOUFNJ[MFNFLEFLFOEJNJ[FLBSā‘
HÚSFWMFSJNJ[EFOEJSÿOBOÎMBS‘N‘[EPþSVWFTBþMBNPMNBM‘E‘S

,FOEJNJ[JLÚUàEàāàODFWFPMVNTV[IVZMBSEBOBS‘OE‘SNBL JZJEàāàODFWF
Hà[FMIVZMBSMBTàTMFNFLEFHÚSFWMFSJNJ[EFOEJS


ÿ / 4 " /  7 &  5" # ÿ "5  4 & 7 ( ÿ 4 ÿ

%FþFSMFOEJSNF4PSVMBS‘
ÿOTBOBOFEFOCVLBEBSTPSVNMVMVLWFSJMNJāPMBCJMJS
/FEFOLFOEJNJ[EFOCBāLBJOTBOMBSBWFWBSM‘LMBSBLBSā‘TPSVNMVMVLMBS‘N‘[WBSE‘S
ÿOTBO‘OTPSVNMVMVLMBS‘PMNBTBOBT‘MPMVSEV

(àOàO.FTBK‘
i"OEPMTVO CJ[JOTBOPþMVOVāFSFnJL‘ME‘L0OMBS‘
LBSBEBWFEFOJ[EFUBā‘E‘L,FOEJMFSJOJFOHà[FM
WFUFNJ[āFZMFSEFOS‘[‘LMBOE‘SE‘LWFPOMBS‘
ZBSBUU‘LMBS‘N‘[‘OCJSÎPþVOEBOàTUàOL‘ME‘Lw
ÿTSÉ 

,BQBO‘ā
(SVQàZFMFSJOFQBZMBā‘NMBS‘JÎJOUFāFLLàSFEJO
)FSLFTJOBLM‘OEBLBMBONFTBK‘QBZMBāNBT‘O‘JTUFZJO
,POVZMBJMHJMJWBSTBTPSVMBS‘O‘BM‘OWFDFWBQMBZ‘O
#JSTPOSBLJLPOVOVOCBāM‘þ‘O‘WFSJOWFWFEBMBā‘O

159
ÿ / 4 " /  7 &  5" # ÿ "5  4 & 7 ( ÿ 4 ÿ

,¬ÿ/"55",ÿ%Ã;&/ÿ,036.",
,B[BO‘N
ÿOTBO‘OWB[JGFTJOJOLÉJOBUUBLJEà[FOJOEFWBNM‘M‘þ‘O‘TBþMBNBLPMEVþVOVCJMJS

½þSFUJDJ/PUV
,ÉJOBU‘ZBSBUBO"MMBI‘O IFSāFZJCJSÚMÎàZFWFEà[FOFHÚSFZBSBUU‘þ‘BOMBU‘M‘SiĀàQIFTJ[
CJ[IFSāFZJCJSÚMÎàZF CJSEà[FOWFQMBOBHÚSFZBSBUU‘Lw ,BNFS  BZFUJZMFCVIVTVT
EFMJMMFOEJSJMFSFL  ZFSZà[àOEFLJ CV Eà[FOJO LPSVONBT‘O‘O EB JOTBO‘O TPSVNMVMVþVOEB
PMEVþVWFJOTBO‘OLÉJOBUUBLJDBOM‘DBOT‘[UàNWBSM‘LMBS‘CP[NBEBO ZP[MBāU‘SNBEBOPOMBSEBO
ZBSBSMBONBT‘HFSFLUJþJWVSHVMBO‘S

:ÚOUFNWF5FLOJLMFS
"OMBU‘N 4PSV$FWBQ

.BUFSZBM
'PUPþSBnBS

&ULJOMJL
ZBā
½þSFUJDJ  JāMFOFDFL LPOVZMB BMBLBM‘ ÎPDVLMBS JMF TPICFU FEFSFL EFSTF HFÎJā ZBQBS WF āV
TPSVMBS‘ÎPDVLMBSBZÚOFMUJS
i/BT‘MCJSÎFWSFEFZBā‘ZPSV[ w
i:BāBE‘þ‘O‘[ÎFWSFOJOIBOHJÚ[FMMJLMFSJOJCFþFOJZPSTVOV[ IBOHJMFSJOJCFþFONJZPSTVOV[ w
i#FþFOEJþJNJ[ZÚOMFSJBSU‘SNBLWFZBCFþFONFEJLMFSJNJ[JB[BMUNBLJÎJOZBQBCJMFDFþJNJ[
āFZMFSWBSN‘ w
.FTFMB ÚþSFUJDJ FO ÎPL LBME‘S‘N LFOBS‘OEBLJ BþBÎMBS‘ TFWEJþJOJ  NFWTJNMFS EFþJāUJLÎF
POMBSEBLJEFþJāJNJHÚ[MFNMFNFZJ TFOFEFOTFOFZFCàZàEàLMFSJOFāBIJUMJLFUNFZJTFWEJþJOJ
TÚZMFZFCJMJS ±PL ZàLTFL CJOBMBS‘ TFWNFEJþJOJ TÚZMFZFCJMJS #ÚZMFDF ÎPDVLMBS‘ CV LPOVMBSB
ZPþVOMBāU‘S‘S
±PDVLMBSBEàāàODFMFSJOJEJMFHFUJSNFIBLL‘UBO‘OE‘LUBOTPOSBFLUFWFSJMFOWFZBÚþSFUJDJ


ÿ / 4 " /  7 &  5" # ÿ "5  4 & 7 ( ÿ 4 ÿ

UBSBG‘OEBOUFNJOFEJMFOiLJSMJWFZàLTFLCJOBMBS‘OZFSBME‘þ‘āFIJSwJMFiEPþBWFLÚZFWMFSJw
GPUPþSBnBS‘ HÚTUFSJMJS ,àÎàL HSVQMB ÎBM‘ā‘MBDBþ‘ JÎJO GPUPþSBnBS ÎPDVLMBS‘O FMJOF WFSJMJS
±PDVLMBSGPUPþSBnBS‘FMEFOFMFEFþJāUJSFSFLJODFMFS
%BIB TPOSB ÎPDVLMBSB CV GPUPþSBnBSB CBL‘ODB OF IJTTFUUJLMFSJ  IBOHJTJOEF CVMVONBZ‘
ZBāBNBZ‘UFSDJIFEFDFLMFSJHJCJTPSVMBSTPSVMVS
±PDVLMBSGPUPþSBnBSIBLL‘OEBLJEVZHVWFEàāàODFMFSJOJEJMFHFUJSJSMFS#ÚZMFDFÎPDVLMBS
"MMBI‘OWFSEJþJEPþBMOJNFUMFSJWFCVOMBS‘OJOTBOUBSBG‘OEBOUBISJQFEJMEJþJOJGBSLFEFS
4PO PMBSBL ÚþSFUJDJ āVOMBSEBO L‘TBDB CBITFEFSFL LPOVZV UPQBSMBS i"MMBI  JOTBOMBS‘O
GBZEBMBONBT‘ JÎJO QFL ÎPL OJNFUMFS ZBSBUN‘āU‘S #J[JN HÚSFWJNJ[ JTF POMBS‘ LPSVNBL WF
WBSM‘LMBS‘O‘TàSEàSNFMFSJOFZBSE‘ND‘PMNBLU‘S#ÚZMFDFIFNLFOEJNJ[IV[VSMVWFTBþM‘LM‘CJS
ZBāBNTàSFSJ[ IFNEF"MMBI‘OOJNFUMFSJOJTàSFLMJHÚSàQIJTTFEFSFL0OVEBIBÎPLBOBSWF
UFTQJIFEFSJ[w

%FþFSMFOEJSNF4PSVMBS‘
(ÚSEàþàOà[GPUPþSBnBSEBOTJ[EFHà[FMEVZHVMBSDBOMBOE‘SBOMBSIBOHJMFSJEJS
#P[VMNVāUBCJBUGPUPþSBnBS‘TJ[FOFIJTTFUUJSEJ
5BCJBUCVāFLJMEFCP[VMNBZBEFWBNFEFSTF JMFSMFZFOZ‘MMBSEBCVOVO
OFHJCJTPOVÎMBS‘PMVS
5BCJBU‘OCP[VMNBT‘OEBJOTBO‘OSPMàOFEJS

161
ÿ / 4 " /  7 &  5" # ÿ "5  4 & 7 ( ÿ 4 ÿ

'050

'050

162
ÿ / 4 " /  7 &  5" # ÿ "5  4 & 7 ( ÿ 4 ÿ

'050

'050

163
ÿ / 4 " /  7 &  5" # ÿ "5  4 & 7 ( ÿ 4 ÿ

(àOàO.FTBK‘
i,‘ZBNFULPQNBBO‘OEBCJMFPMTBFMJOEFCJS
BþBÎmEFTJPMBOPOVNVUMBLBEJLTJOw
#VIÉSÔ &EFCàMNàGSFE 

,BQBO‘ā
(SVQàZFMFSJOFQBZMBā‘NMBS‘JÎJOUFāFLLàSFEJO
)FSLFTJOBLM‘OEBLBMBONFTBK‘QBZMBāNBT‘O‘JTUFZJO
,POVZMBJMHJMJWBSTBTPSVMBS‘O‘BM‘OWFDFWBQMBZ‘O
#JSTPOSBLJLPOVOVOCBāM‘þ‘O‘WFSJOWFWFEBMBā‘O

164
ÿ / 4 " /  7 &  5" # ÿ "5  4 & 7 ( ÿ 4 ÿ

ÿ/4"/-"3"7&5"#ÿ"5","3Ā*
.&3)".&5
,B[BO‘N
ÿOTBOMBSBWFUBCJBUBLBSā‘NFSIBNFUMJPMNBT‘HFSFLUJþJOJCJMJS

½þSFUJDJ/PUV
"MMBIV 5FÉMÉO‘O CàUàO WBSM‘LMBSB LBSā‘ āFGLBU WF NFSIBNFUMF ZBLMBāNBN‘[‘  JÎJOEF
ZBāBE‘þ‘N‘[ ÎFWSFZJ LPSVNBN‘[ WF UBISJCBU‘O‘ ÚOMFNFNJ[J FNSFUUJþJ BOMBU‘M‘S 1FZHBNCFS
&GFOEJNJ[JO IBZBU‘OEB DBOM‘ WBSM‘LMBSB WF EPþBZB PMBO TFWHJTJOJ HÚTUFSFO QFL ÎPL IBEJTF
PMEVþVBāBþ‘EBLJÚSOFLMFEFTUFLMFOFSFLBOMBU‘M‘S
 i3FTßMVMMBI TBT  .FLLFZF HJUNFL JÎJO JISBNM‘ PMBSBL ZPMB ΑLU‘y 3VWFZTF JMF "SD
BSBT‘OEBLJ ÃTBCFZF HFMJODF CJS EF CBLU‘MBS LJ HÚMHFEF LBGBT‘O‘ CBDBLMBS‘ BSBT‘OB LPZNVā 
WàDVEVOB PL TBQMBON‘ā CJS DFZMBO #VOVO à[FSJOF )[ 1FZHBNCFS CJS BEBNB  LBmMFOJO
BSLBT‘LFTJMJODFZFLBEBSZBSBM‘IBZWBO‘LJNTFOJOSBIBUT‘[FUNFNFTJJÎJOCBā‘OEBCFLMFNFTJOJ
FNSFUUJw .VWBUUB )BDD 

:ÚOUFNWF5FLOJLMFS
"OMBU‘N 4PSV$FWBQ

.BUFSZBM
&LUFLJGPUPþSBnBS

&ULJOMJL
ZBā
½þSFUJDJT‘O‘GBÎPDVLMBSEBOÚODFHJSFS½ODFEFOCJMHJTBZBSEBOSFOLMJCJSāFLJMEFΑLBSUU‘þ‘
CJSUBL‘NGPUPþSBnBS‘T‘O‘G‘OÎFāJUMJZFSMFSJOFBTBS'PUPþSBnBSEBJOTBO‘OUBCJBU‘LPSVNBT‘OB 
LÉJOBUUBLJ Eà[FOJO EFWBN‘OEB JOTBO‘O SPMàOF  CJS EF JOTBO FMJ JMF UBCJBUUB NFZEBOB HFMFO
UBISJCBUB ÚSOFLMFS WBSE‘S ±PDVLMBS T‘O‘GB HJSEJLMFSJOEF GPUPþSBnBSB CBLBSMBS ½þSFUJDJ  CJS
TàSFÎPDVLMBS‘OGPUPþSBnBS‘JODFMFNFMFSJOJWFLFOEJBSBMBS‘OEBEFþFSMFOEJSNFMFSJOJTÚZMFS

165
ÿ / 4 " /  7 &  5" # ÿ "5  4 & 7 ( ÿ 4 ÿ

±PDVLMBST‘O‘GUBCJSNàEEFUTFSCFTULBMBSBLGPUPþSBnBS‘JODFMFZJQà[FSJOFLPOVāVSMBS
%BIBTPOSBÚþSFUJDJGPUPþSBnBSBHÚSFāVTPSVMBS‘TPSBS
#VGPUPþSBGTBOBOFIJTTFUUJSEJ
4J[DFCVEVSVNVOPSUBZBΑLNBT‘OEBJOTBO‘OCJSSPMàWBSN‘ 7BSTBOFEJS
#ÚZMFCJSEVSVNMBLBSā‘MBāNBNBLJÎJOOFMFSFEJLLBUFEJMNFMJEJS 
#V TPSVMBSB WFSJMFO DFWBQMBS‘O BSE‘OEBO   ÚþSFUJDJ ÎPDVLMBSB CJS PZVO PZOBZBDBLMBS‘O‘
TÚZMFS±PDVLMBS‘OGPUPþSBnBSEBOCJSJOJTFÎNFMFSJOJJTUFS&OGB[MBUFSDJIFEJMFOGPUPþSBGBPZ
CJSMJþJJMFLBSBSWFSJMJS±PDVLMBS‘OIFSCJSJOEFOT‘SBT‘JMFGPUPþSBGJMFJMHJMJCJSDàNMFLVSNBMBS‘
JTUFOJS #VOB HÚSF LVSVMBO IFS DàNMF PMVāUVSVMNBZB ÎBM‘ā‘MBO IJLÉZFOJO CJS DàNMFTJ
LPOVNVOEBE‘S#VTFCFQMFDàNMFMFSBSBT‘OEBCJSCàUàOMàLPMVāUVSVMNBZBÎBM‘ā‘M‘S±PDVLMBS
LPOVEBO CBþ‘NT‘[ PMNBNBL āBSU‘ JMF IJLÉZFZJ LVSBDBLMBS‘ DàNMFMFS JMF ZÚOMFOEJSFCJMJSMFS
½þSFUJDJ  TàSFDJ UBLJQ FEFS WF HFSFLUJSEJþJOEF LàÎàL ZÚOMFOEJSNFMFS ZBQBCJMJS ±PDVLMBS
DàNMFMFSJI‘[M‘CJSāFLJMEFLVSNBM‘WFDàNMFMFSBSBT‘OEBLJCàUàOMàþàOCP[VMNBNBT‘OBEJLLBU
FEJMNFMJEJS )JLÉZFOJO HFOFM IBUMBS‘ PSUBZB ΑLBOB LBEBS ÎPDVLMBS DàNMF LVSNBZB EFWBN
FEFSMFS ½þSFUJDJ  IJLÉZF āFLJMMFOEJþJOJ EàāàOEàþàOEF i&WFU BSU‘L CJUJSJZPSV[w LPNVUVOV
WFSJSWFÎPDVLMBSEBOTPODàNMFMFSJOJLVSNBMBS‘O‘JTUFSWFCVāFLJMEFEPþBÎMBNBPMVāUVSVMBO
IJLÉZF VZHVO CJS DàNMFZMF ÚþSFUJDJ UBSBG‘OEBO CJUJSJMJS )JLÉZF UBNBNMBOE‘þ‘OEBO ÚþSFUJDJ
WFSJMNFL JTUFOFO NFTBK‘ PMVāUVSVMBO IJLÉZF JMF JMJāLJMFOEJSFSFL HFOFM CJS UFLSBS ZBQBS WF
ÎPDVLMBSBLBU‘M‘NMBS‘OEBOEPMBZ‘UFāFLLàSFEFSFLEFSTJOPLUBMBS

%FþFSMFOEJSNF4PSVMBS‘
:VOVT&NSFOJOi:BSBU‘MBO‘TFWFSJ[:BSBUBOEBOÚUàSàwTÚ[àOà
ZBāBE‘þ‘N‘[ÎFWSF JOTBOWFUBCJBUBΑT‘OEBOOBT‘MEFþFSMFOEJSJZPSTVOV[ 
$BOM‘DBOT‘[UàNWBSM‘LMBSBWFUBCJBUBLBSā‘HFSFLMJÚ[FOJHÚTUFSNFL
.àTMàNBOPMNBO‘OCJSHFSFþJPMBSBLEàāàOàMFCJMJSNJ OFEFO

166
ÿ / 4 " /  7 &  5" # ÿ "5  4 & 7 ( ÿ 4 ÿ

167
ÿ / 4 " /  7 &  5" # ÿ "5  4 & 7 ( ÿ 4 ÿ


ÿ / 4 " /  7 &  5" # ÿ "5  4 & 7 ( ÿ 4 ÿ

(àOàO.FTBK‘
i:‘ME‘[MBS CJULJMFSWFBþBÎMBSTFDEFFEFSMFS(Úþà
"MMBIZàLTFMUUJWFNJ[BO‘ ZBOJEFOHFZJ 
0LPZEV4BL‘OCVEFOHFZJCP[NBZ‘Ow
3BINÉO 

,BQBO‘ā
(SVQàZFMFSJOFQBZMBā‘NMBS‘JÎJOUFāFLLàSFEJO
)FSLFTJOBLM‘OEBLBMBONFTBK‘QBZMBāNBT‘O‘JTUFZJO
,POVZMBJMHJMJWBSTBTPSVMBS‘O‘BM‘OWFDFWBQMBZ‘O
#JSTPOSBLJLPOVOVOCBāM‘þ‘O‘WFSJOWFWFEBMBā‘O

169
ÿ / 4 " /  7 &  5" # ÿ "5  4 & 7 ( ÿ 4 ÿ


17
)&3,&4ÿ/ÿ:ÿ-ÿýÿ/ÿÿ45&.&,

,FOEJNJ[JÎJOJTUFEJþJNJ[JCBāLBT‘JÎJOEFJTUFNFNJ[HFSFLUJþJOJCJMJS
)BTFEJOFOÎPLLFOEJOF[BSBSWFSEJþJOJLBWSBS
)BTFUUFOLVSUVMNBO‘ONàNLàOPMBCJMFDFþJOJCJMJS
(‘QUBÚ[FONFJMFL‘TLBOÎM‘LIBTFUBSBT‘OEBLJGBSL‘LBWSBS
,FOEJOEFPMBOZBOM‘āMBS‘GBSLFEFSWFHà[FMMJLMFSJOJHFMJāUJSJS
)&3,&4ÿ/ÿ:ÿ-ÿýÿ/ÿÿ45&.&,

)&3,&4ÿ/ÿ:ÿ-ÿýÿ/ÿÿ45ÿ:036.
,B[BO‘N
,FOEJNJ[JÎJOJTUFEJþJNJ[JCBāLBT‘JÎJOEFJTUFNFNJ[HFSFLUJþJOJCJMJS

½þSFUJDJ/PUV
±PDVLMBSBiÿZJMJLOFEJS wTPSVTVTPSVMVSWFPOMBS‘ODFWBQMBS‘EJOMFOJSLFO JZJMJþJOTBEFDF
LFOEJNJ[FPMNBNBT‘ CBāLBJOTBOMBSBEBZBQ‘MNBT‘HFSFLUJþJOPLUBT‘OEBÎPDVLMBSBTPSVMBSMB
ZÚOMFOEJSJMJS%BIBTPOSBi#JSLJNTFLFOEJTJJÎJOTFWJQJTUFEJþJCJSJZJMJþJLBSEFāJ BSLBEBā‘ 
JÎJO EF TFWJQ JTUFNFEJLÎF NàNJO PMBNB[ JNBOEB PMHVOMVþB FSFNF[ w #VIÉSÔ  ÿNBO   
IBEJTJÎPDVLMBSMBQBZMBā‘M‘S

:ÚOUFNWF5FLOJLMFS
ÿTUBTZPO5FLOJþJ 4PSV$FWBQ

.BUFSZBM
,Éþ‘U LBSUPO NBLBT ZBQ‘āU‘S‘D‘ FMJāJLÉþ‘E‘ CPZBMBS

&ULJOMJL
ZBā
±PDVLMBSB i,FOEJNJ[JÎJOJTUFEJþJNJ[JCBāLBT‘JÎJOEFJTUFNFMJZJ[wLPOVMVCJSÎBM‘āNB
ZBQ‘MBDBþ‘TÚZMFOJS
½þSFUJDJ  T‘O‘GUB  LÚāF CFMJSMFS WF ÎPDVLMBS‘ EB àÎF BZ‘S‘S ,ÚāFMFSEFO CJSJ iSFTJN
JTUBTZPOVw CJSJiIJLÉZFJTUBTZPOVw CJSJEFiBmāJTUBTZPOVwEVS5àNEVSBLMBSEBLVMMBO‘MBDBL
HFSFLMJ NBM[FNFMFS ÚODFEFO IB[‘S FEJMJS ½þSFUJDJ UFLOJþJ āÚZMF BΑLMBS i)FS HSVQ CV àÎ
LÚāFEFOCJSJOFHFÎFDFLWFIBOHJLÚāFEFZTFOJ[AIFSLFTJOJZJMJþJOJJTUJZPSVNLPOVTVZMBBMBLBM‘
CJSÎBM‘āNBZBCBāMBZBDBLT‘O‘[ELTPOSBCFOEJþFSLÚāFZFHFÎNFOJ[JJTUFZFDFþJNWFTJ[F
AEFþJāUJSLPNVUVWFSFDFþJN#ÚZMFDFIFSHSVQEJþFSLÚāFZFHFÎFDFL4J[MFSEFBSLBEBāMBS‘O‘[‘O
ZBS‘NLBMBOJāMFSJOJZBQNBZBEFWBNFEFDFLTJOJ[ELTPOSBEFþJāUJSLPNVUVZMBLÚāFZF
HFÎFDFLTJOJ[WFZJOFBSLBEBāMBS‘O‘[‘OJāMFSJOJEFWBNFUUJSFDFLTJOJ[)FSHSVQ IFSLÚāFEFLJ
FULJOMJþFLBUL‘EBCVMVOBDBLw

172
)&3,&4ÿ/ÿ:ÿ-ÿýÿ/ÿÿ45&.&,

'BBMJZFU CV āFLJMEF UBNBNMBOE‘LUBO TPOSB FULJOMJL TPO CVMVS %BIB TPOSB ÚþSFUJDJ IFS
JTUBTZPOEBLJGBBMJZFUJÎPDVLMBSMBQBZMBāBSBLEFSTJCJUJSJS

%FþFSMFOEJSNF4PSVMBS‘
ÿZJMJLOFEJS
#BāLBT‘OBJZJMJLZBQNBLOFEFOÚOFNMJEJS
ÿāCJSMJþJZMFÎBM‘āNBLTJ[FOFIJTTFUUJSEJ

(àOàO.FTBK‘
i#JSLJNTFLFOEJTJJÎJOTFWJQJTUFEJþJCJS
JZJMJþJLBSEFāJ BSLBEBā‘ JÎJOEFTFWJQ
JTUFNFEJLÎFHFSÎFLNàNJOPMBNB[w
#VIÉSÔ ÿNBO  

,BQBO‘ā
(SVQàZFMFSJOFQBZMBā‘NMBS‘JÎJOUFāFLLàSFEJO
)FSLFTJOBLM‘OEBLBMBONFTBK‘QBZMBāNBT‘O‘JTUFZJO
,POVZMBJMHJMJWBSTBTPSVMBS‘O‘BM‘OWFDFWBQMBZ‘O
#JSTPOSBLJLPOVOVOCBāM‘þ‘O‘WFSJOWFWFEBMBā‘O

173
)&3,&4ÿ/ÿ:ÿ-ÿýÿ/ÿÿ45&.&,

½þSFUJDJ/PUV
iÿZJMJLZBQEFOJ[FBU CBM‘LCJMNF[TF)ÉMJLCJMJSBUBTÚ[àà[FSJOFLPOVāVQJZJMJLWFÚOFNJ
IBLL‘OEBUBSU‘ā‘M‘Si.àTMàNBO .àTMàNBO‘OLBSEFāJEJS POB[VMNFUNF[ POV EàāNBO‘OB 
UFTMJNFUNF[,JN  NàNJO LBSEFāJOJOCJSJIUJZBD‘O‘HJEFSJSTF "MMBIEBPOVOCJSJIUJZBD‘O‘
HJEFSJSw #VIÉSÔ  .F[BMJN    IBEJTJ āFSJm à[FSJOF LPOVāVMVS ÿZJMJL ZBQ‘MBO UBSBG PMNBL
Hà[FMEJS CJ[FJZJMJLZBQ‘MNBT‘OEBOEBIPāMBO‘S‘[#J[JZJMJLZBQU‘þ‘N‘[EBEBCBāLBCJSJMFSJOJ
NVUMVFUNJāPMVSV[:BQBDBþ‘N‘[JZJMJLLFOEJNJ[JÎJOJTUFEJþJNJ[HJCJHà[FM IPā TBNJNJ
WCÚ[FMMJLMFSFTBIJQPMNBM‘E‘S#VHJCJCJMHJMFSMFÎPDVLMBSFULJOMJLÚODFTJIB[‘SMBO‘S

:ÚOUFNWF5FLOJLMFS
)JLÉZF:PSVNMBNB

&ULJOMJL
ZBā
i"MMBI )BMJMÿCSBIJNCFSFLFUJWFSTJOwEJZFCJSTÚZMFNEVZEVOV[NV EJZFSFLEJLLBU
ÎFLJMJS#VOVOà[FSJOFi)BZEJCVIJLBZFZJPLVZBM‘NwEJZFSFLFULJOMJþFCBāMBO‘S
)JLÉZFPLVOVSLFOEBIBFULJMJPMNBT‘JÎJO)BMJMWFÿCSBIJNFHÚSFTFTUPOVCFMJSMFOJS
"SBMBSEBLJTPSVMBS‘TPSNBLJÎJOZBS‘EBLFTJMJSWFTPSVÎPDVLMBSBTPSVMVS
 4PSVMBSEBO TPOSB WFSJMFO DFWBQMBS‘O LPOVZV EBþ‘U‘Q IJLÉZFEFO V[BLMBā‘MNBNBT‘OB
EJLLBUFEJMJS

)JLÉZF
i)BMJMÿCSBIJN#FSFLFUJw
7BLUJZMFCJSCJSJOJÎPLTFWFOJLJLBSEFāWBSN‘ā
#àZàþà)BMJM
,àÎàþàJTFÿCSBIJN
)BMJM FWMJÎPDVLMV
ÿCSBIJNJTFCFLÉSN‘ā
0SUBLCJSUBSMBMBS‘WBSN‘āJLJLBSEFāJO
/FNBITVMΑLBSTB JLJZFCÚMàQQBZMBā‘SMBSN‘ā
#VOVOMBHFÎJOJQHJEFSMFSNJā
#JSZ‘M ZJOFCVþEBZMBSCJÎJMNJā
ÿLJZFBZ‘SN‘āMBS
ÿāLBMN‘āUBā‘NBZB
)BMJM CJSUFLMJGZBQN‘ā
iÿCSBIJNLBSEFāJNCFOHJEJQÎVWBMMBS‘HFUJSFZJN4FOCVþEBZ‘CFLMFw

174
)&3,&4ÿ/ÿ:ÿ-ÿýÿ/ÿÿ45&.&,

i1FLJ BþBCFZwEFNJāÿCSBIJN
7F)BMJMHJUNJāÎVWBMHFUJSNFZF
0HJEJODF ÿCSBIJNCJSB[EàāàONàā
,FOEJQBZ‘OEBOCJSNJLUBSBM‘QLBSEFāJOJOÎVWBM‘OBBUN‘ā
½þSFUJDJ ÚþSFODJMFSF CVSBEB āÚZMF CJS TPSV ZÚOFMUJS iÿCSBIJN OFEFO LFOEJ QBZ‘OEBO
BME‘þ‘CVþEBZEBOLBSEFāJOJOÎVWBM‘OBBUN‘āPMBCJMJS w
……………………………………………………………………………………………
………………………………………………………………………………………………
………………………………………………………………………………………………..
i"CJNFWMJ ÎPDVLMVPOVOFWJOFEBIBÎPLCVþEBZMB[‘NwEFNJā
"[TPOSB)BMJMΑLBHFMNJā
i)BZEJÿCSBIJNwEFNJā i½ODFTFOEPMEVSEBUBā‘BNCBSBw
i1FLJBþBCFZ wEFNJā)BMJM
ÿCSBIJN LFOEJZ‘þ‘O‘OEBOCJSÎVWBMEPMEVSVQEàāNàāZPMB
ÿCSBIJN LFOEJ QBZ‘OEBO )BMJMF FLMFNJā  TJ[ ÿCSBIJNJO ZFSJOEF PMTBO‘[ CÚZMF ZBQBS
N‘ZE‘O‘[
……………………………………………………………………………………………
………………………………………………………………………………………………
………………………………………………………………………………………………..
0HJEJODF )BMJMEàāàONàāCVEFGB
4J[DF)BMJMOFEàāàONàāPMBCJMJS
……………………………………………………………………………………………
………………………………………………………………………………………………
………………………………………………………………………………………………..
%FNJāLJ
i±PLāàLàS CFOFWMJZJN LVSVMVCJSEà[FOJNEFWBS
"NBLBSEFāJNCFLÉS
0EBIBÎBM‘ā‘Q QBSBCJSJLUJSFDFL&WLVSVQFWMFOFDFLw
#ÚZMFEàāàOFSFL
,FOEJQBZ‘OEBOCJSLBÎLàSFLPOVOLJOFBUN‘ā
7FMIBT‘M CJSJHJUUJþJOEF ÚCàSà LFOEJQBZ‘OEBOBUN‘āPOVOLJOF
#V CÚZMFTàSàQHJUNJā
"NBCJSCJSMFSJOEFOIBCFSTJ[MFSNJā
/JIBZFUBLāBNPMNVā
,BSBOM‘LCBTN‘ā
(ÚSNàāMFSLJ CJUNJZPSCVþEBZMBSÿāUFCVOB)BMJMÿCSBIJNCFSFLFUJEFOJSIBMLBSBT‘OEB
i#JSLJNTFLFOEJTJJÎJOTFWJQJTUFEJþJCJSJZJMJþJLBSEFāJ BSLBEBā‘ JÎJOEFTFWJQJTUFNFEJLÎF
HFSÎFLNàNJOPMNB[ #VIÉSÔ ÿNBO 
4FWHJMJ1FZHBNCFSJNJ[JOEFCVZVSEVþVHJCJLFOEJNJ[JÎJOJTUFEJþJNJ[JCBāLBMBS‘JÎJOEF
JTUFZFCJMJZPSTBLUBNBOMBN‘ZMBJOTBOM‘LWB[JGFNJ[JZFSJOFHFUJSNJāPMVSV[

175
)&3,&4ÿ/ÿ:ÿ-ÿýÿ/ÿÿ45&.&,

#VSBEBOTPOSBLJÚSOFLMFSÚþSFUJDJZFLBZOBLPMNBT‘BΑT‘OEBOFLMFONJāUJS
ti,FOEJMFSJEFJIUJZBÎEVZEVLMBS‘IÉMEF ZJZFDFLMFSJOJT‘SG"MMBI‘OS‘[BT‘OBFSNFLJÎJO
GBLJSF ZFUJNFWFFTJSFJLSBNFEFSMFS7FEFSMFSLJ#J[TJ[FT‘SG"MMBIS‘[BT‘JÎJOJLSBNFEJZPSV[ 
ZPLTBTJ[EFOLBSā‘M‘LJTUFNFEJþJNJ[HJCJCJSUFāFLLàSCJMFCFLMFNJZPSV[w
tÿTMBNUBSJIJOEFCVOBEBJSQFLÎPLÚSOFLWBSE‘S&OTBS .FEJOFZFIJDSFUFEFONVIBDJSMFS
JMFZBQ‘MBONVBIBU LBSEFāMJL BOMBāNBT‘ÎFSÎFWFTJOEF NBM‘O‘OZBS‘T‘O‘NVIBDJSMFSFWFSNFLUF
UFSFEEàUFUNFNJāUJS)[½NFSJOBOMBUU‘þ‘OBHÚSF TBIBCFEFOCJSJOFCJSLPZVOFUJIFEJZF
FEJMNJā PEBi'BMBODBCFOEFOEBIBBÎU‘SwEJZFSFLCJSCBāLBLJāJZFHÚOEFSNJāUJS)FEJZF 
ZFEJLJāJZJEPMBāU‘LUBOTPOSBJÎMFSJOEFFONVIUBÎPMBOJMLLJāJZFHFSJHFMNJāUJS
t :FSNàL 4BWBā‘OEB  āFIJU PMNBL à[FSF PMBO BNDBT‘O‘O PþMVOB TV WFSNFZF ÎBM‘āBO
)V[FZGFZFBNDBPþMV TVZVZBO‘OEBLJEJþFSZBSBM‘ZBWFSNFTJOJTÚZMFNJā GBLBUPLJāJEFTVZV
ZBO‘OEBCVMVOBOCJSCBāLBT‘OBWFSNFTJOJJTUFNJāUJS
t#JSHàO)[1FZHBNCFSFPMEVLÎBGBLJSWFBÎCJSBEBNHFMJS)[1FZHBNCFSPOVFWJOF
HÚUàSàSGBLBUPT‘SBEBFWEFZJZFDFLCJSāFZZPLUVS#VOVOà[FSJOFBTIBCB i#VBEBN‘LJN
NJTBmSFEFDFL wEJZFTPSBS&OTBSEBOCJSJBEBN‘HÚUàSàSGBLBUFWJOEFÎPDVLMBS‘OBZFUFDFL
LBEBSZFNFLWBSE‘S)BO‘N‘OBi±PDVLMBS‘PZBMB4PGSBZBHFMNFLJTUFSMFSTFPOMBS‘VZVU.JTBmS
JÎFSJHJSJODFEFMBNCBZ‘TÚOEàS LBSBOM‘LPMTVO #J[EFTPGSBEBZJZPSNVāHJCJZBQBM‘NwEFS
4PGSBZBPUVSVSMBSWFTBEFDFNJTBmSLBSO‘O‘EPZVSVS
t&WMFSJOEFÎPLB[ZFNFLCVMVOEVþVCJSHàO )["MJWFBJMFTJUBNBJMFDFTPGSBZBPUVSNBL
à[FSF JLFO  LBQ‘MBS‘OB ZFNFL JTUFZFO CJS EJMFODJ HFMJS 0OMBS EB ZFNFLMFSJOJ EJMFODJZF
WFSJSMFS &SUFTJ HàO LBQ‘ZB HFMFO CJS ZFUJNF  àÎàODà HàO CJS FTJSF ZFNFLMFSJOJ WFSJSMFS
4BIBCF[BNBO‘OEBOCFSJ ÿTMBNàNNFUJBSBT‘OEBZFSMFāNJāPMBOLBSEFāMJLBOMBZ‘ā‘O‘OÎBSQ‘D‘
ÚSOFLMFSJUBSJITBZGBMBS‘OEBZFSJOJBMN‘āU‘S
t.àāUFSJMFSJOF i#FOTJGUBIZBQU‘N LPNāVNIFOà[TJGUBIZBQNBE‘ POBHJEJOwEJZFO
FTOBGÚSOFLMFSJ CVOMBSEBOTBEFDFCB[‘MBS‘E‘S

176
)&3,&4ÿ/ÿ:ÿ-ÿýÿ/ÿÿ45&.&,

%FþFSMFOEJSNF4PSVMBS‘
,FOEJOJ[JÎJOFUUJþJOJ[EVBZ‘BSLBEBāMBS‘O‘[JÎJOEFFEJZPSNVTVOV[
)BMJMÿCSBIJN#FSFLFUJJTJNMJIJLÉZFEFLJHJCJCJSPMBZMBLBSā‘MBāU‘O‘[N‘ 7FZBCÚZMFCJMEJ
þJOJ[CBāLBPMBZMBSWBSN‘
)FSLFTLFOEJTJJÎJOJTUFEJLMFSJOJCBāLBMBS‘JÎJOEFJTUFTFZEJEàOZBN‘[OBT‘MPMVSEV

(àOàO.FTBK‘
iÿLJāFZWBSE‘SLJPOEBOEBIBJZJTJZPLUVS"MMBIV
5FÉMÉZBJNBOWF0OVOLVMMBS‘OBJZJMJLFUNFL 
āFGLBUMJPMNBLÿLJāFZWBSE‘SLJPOEBOEBIBLÚUàJLJ
āFZZPLUVSĀJSLWFJOTBOMBSBLÚUàMàLFUNFLw
"TLBMÉOÔ

,BQBO‘ā
(SVQàZFMFSJOFQBZMBā‘NMBS‘JÎJOUFāFLLàSFEJO
)FSLFTJOBLM‘OEBLBMBONFTBK‘QBZMBāNBT‘O‘JTUFZJO
,POVZMBJMHJMJWBSTBTPSVMBS‘O‘BM‘OWFDFWBQMBZ‘O
#JSTPOSBLJLPOVOVOCBāM‘þ‘O‘WFSJOWFWFEBMBā‘O

177
)&3,&4ÿ/ÿ:ÿ-ÿýÿ/ÿÿ45&.&,

)"4&5½/$&#"/";"3"37&3ÿ3
,B[BO‘N
)BTFEJOFOÎPLLFOEJOF[BSBSWFSEJþJOJLBWSBS

½þSFUJDJ/PUV
)BTFEJOÎFLFNFNFL "MMBI‘OCJSLJāJZFWFSEJþJIFSIBOHJCJSOJNFUJLBCVMMFOFNFZFSFLCJS
BOÚODFPLJāJOJOCVOJNFUMFSJLBZCFUNFTJOJUFNFOOJFUNFLHJCJBOMBNMBSBHFMEJþJBOMBU‘M‘S
1FZHBNCFSJNJ[)[.VIBNNFEJOi)BTFUFUNFLUFOTBL‘O‘O‘[#JMJOJ[LJ BUFāJOPEVOVZPL
FUNFTJHJCJIBTFUEFJZJMJLMFSJZPLFEFSw &CV%ÉWVE &EFC  CVZVSBSBL.àTMàNBOMBS‘CV
LPOVEBVZBSE‘þ‘BOMBU‘M‘S#VCBþMBNEB&GFOEJNJ[JO TBT IBTFEJOLJāJOJOZBQU‘þ‘JZJMJLMFSJ
ZPLFEFOZÚOàOFEFEJLLBUÎFLFSFLCVÚ[FMMJþJUBā‘ZBOCJSLJāJOJOFOCàZàL[BSBS‘BTM‘OEB
LFOEJTJOFWFSEJþJVZBS‘T‘O‘ZBQU‘þ‘BOMBU‘M‘S#J[MFSEFOLFOEJTJJÎJOJTUFEJþJJZJWFHà[FMIFSāFZJ
CBāLBT‘JÎJOEFJTUFZFCJMNFTBNJNJZFUJOJCFLMFZFOWFCVOVFNSFEFOZàDFEJOJNJ[ÿTMBN‘O 
IBTFEJCJSBOMBNEB"MMBIUBOHFMFOFSB[‘PMNBNBāFLMJOEFZPSVNMBE‘þ‘WVSHVMBO‘S%PMBZ‘T‘ZMB
CJS.àTMàNBO‘OIBTFUEVZHVTVOEBOV[BLLBMNBZBEJLLBUFUNFTJHFSFLUJþJà[FSJOEFEVSVMVS

:ÚOUFNWF5FLOJLMFS
"OMBU‘N 3PM0ZOBNB

&ULJOMJL
ZBā
½þSFUJDJ WFSJMFOIJLÉZFZJTFTUPOMBNBMBS‘OBEJLLBUFEFSFL BOMBā‘M‘SāFLJMEFZBWBāÎBPLVS
±PDVLMBS‘OIJLÉZFZJHà[FMDFBOMBNBT‘BNBD‘ZMBIJLÉZFCJSLBÎLF[PLVOBCJMJS
&þFS ÎPDVLMBS‘O LJāJ TBZ‘T‘ VZHVOTB CV IJLÉZFOJO ÎPDVLMBS UBSBG‘OEBO DBOMBOE‘S‘MNBT‘
JTUFOFCJMJS ±PDVLMBSB āV HÚSFWMFS EBþ‘U‘M‘S NPS ÎJÎFL  TV EÚLFO UFZ[F  ÎÚQ BUBO JLJ LJāJ 
[BSBSM‘ CÚDFL  EJþFS ÎJÎFLMFS )JLÉZF CJSLBÎ LF[ PLVOEVLUBO TPOSB ÎPDVLMBS BL‘MMBS‘OEB
LBME‘þ‘LBEBSSPMMFSJDBOMBOE‘S‘SMBS

178
)&3,&4ÿ/ÿ:ÿ-ÿýÿ/ÿÿ45&.&,

.PS±JÎFþJO)JLÉZFTJ
i#JS[BNBOMBSLàÎàLCJSLBTBCBEB ZPMLFOBS‘OEBSFOHÉSFOLÎJÎFLMFSZBāBSN‘ā#VSBEB
L‘SN‘[‘HFMJODJLMFSEFWBSN‘ā TBS‘CFZB[QBQBUZBMBSEB3à[HÉSMBEBMHBMBO‘S HàOFāJOBMU‘OEB
QBSMBSMBSN‘ā:PMEBOHFÎFOMFSZBOMBS‘OBHFMJS IBZSBOM‘LMBPOMBS‘J[MFSNJā'BLBUCJSTàSFTPOSB
LàÎàL CJS NPS ÎJÎFL  IV[VSMBS‘O‘ LBΑSNBZB CBāMBN‘ā .PS ÎJÎFL TBEFDF LFOEJTJOJO Hà[FM
WF CBL‘NM‘ PMNBT‘O‘ JTUJZPSNVā :PMEBO HFÎFOMFS TBEFDF POB IBZSBO LBMT‘OMBS JTUJZPSNVā
0ODB Hà[FM ÎJÎFþJO BSBT‘OEB LJNTF L‘ZNFUJNJ CJMNJZPS  EJZF EàāàOàZPSNVā (FMJODJþJO
L‘SN‘[‘ SFOHJOJ  QBQBUZBO‘O V[VO CPZVOV L‘TLBO‘ZPSNVā 4POVOEB IBTFU EVZHVTV POV
ZBOM‘āJāMFSZBQNBZBTFWLFUNJā.PSÎJÎFL EJþFSÎJÎFLMFSJOCàZàNFTJOFFOHFMPMNBLJÎJO
IFSZPMVEFOFNFZFCBāMBN‘āÿMLÚODFLFOEJMFSJOFTVEÚLNFZFHFMFOZBāM‘UFZ[FZFEJLFOJOJ
CBU‘SN‘ā  QBSNBþ‘O‘ LBOBUN‘ā .PS ÎJÎFþJO QMBO‘OB HÚSF  TVTV[ LBMBO ÎJÎFLMFS Hà[FMMJþJOJ
LBZCFEFDFLNJā.PSÎJÎFL CVLBEBSMBEBLBMNBN‘āV[BLUBOHFÎNFLUFPMBO[BSBSM‘CÚDFLMFSJ
ÎBþ‘SN‘ā A)FZ CÚDFLMFS #VSBEB ÎPL SBIBU FEFSTJOJ[  ÎFāJU ÎFāJU ÎJÎFLMFSEFO CFTMFOJSTJOJ[ 
HFMJO CVSBEB ZBāBZ‘O EFNJā ;BSBSM‘ CÚDFLMFS IFNFO HFMJQ PSBZB ZFSMFāNJāMFS ;BNBOMB
TVTV[ LBMBO HFMJODJþJO L‘SN‘[‘ SFOHJ TPMNVā CÚDFLMFOFO QBQBUZB JTF CPZOVOV CàLNàā
4POSBCB[‘ÎJÎFLMFSZBQSBþ‘O‘EÚLNàā CB[‘T‘LVSVZVQHJUNJā#BāMBOH‘ÎUBNPSÎJÎFþJOLFZm
ZFSJOEFZNJāA"SU‘LFUSBG‘NEBCJSCJSJOEFOHà[FMÎJÎFLMFSZPL#FOJNHà[FMMJþJNFIFSLFTāBIJU
PMBDBLEJZFSFLTFWJOJZPSNVā"NBCJSTàSFTPOSBLFOEJTJEFTVTV[MVLUBOCBā‘O‘EJLUVUBNB[
IÉMF HFMNJā  IFMF P [BSBSM‘ CÚDFLMFS ZPL NV  .PS ÎJÎFþJO ZBQSBLMBS‘OB EB ZVWB ZBQNBZB
CBāMBN‘āMBS.PSÎJÎFLCVLPāVMMBSEBZBāBNNàDBEFMFTJWFSJSLFOFMMFSJOEFQPāFUMFSPMBOJLJ
LJāJBSBMBS‘OEBLPOVāBSBLPOBEPþSVZBLMBāN‘ā.BWJDFLFUMJPMBOA#VÎÚQMFSJOFSFZFBUTBL
BDBCB  EFNJā  ZBO‘OEBLJ UBN EB NPS ÎJÎFþJO PMEVþV ZFSJ HÚTUFSFSFL AÿāUF āVSBZB BUBM‘N 
LVSVNVāÎJÎFLMFSMFEPMVCBLTBOB HBMJCBCVSBT‘ÎÚQMàLEFNJā.PSÎJÎFLCJSBOEBLFOEJOJ
QJTLPLVMVÎÚQQPāFUMFSJOJOBMU‘OEBCVMNVāw
)JLÉZFOJOTPOVOEBWFSJMFOTPSVMBSTPSVMBDBLWFIJLÉZFà[FSJOFLPOVāVMBDBLU‘S

%FþFSMFOEJSNF4PSVMBS‘
.PSÎJÎFLIBOHJEVSVNEBOSBIBUT‘[PMNVāWFOBT‘MEBWSBON‘āU‘S
)BTFUEJOJNJ[FHÚSFOJÎJOLÚUàLBCVMFEJMFOIVZMBSEBOE‘S 
)BTFUFEFOLJāJOFHJCJ[BSBSMBSBVþSBS

179
)&3,&4ÿ/ÿ:ÿ-ÿýÿ/ÿÿ45&.&,

(àOàO.FTBK‘
i#JSJOTBO‘OLBMCJOEFJNBOJMF
IBTFUCJSBSBEBCVMVONB[w
/FTÉÔ $JIBE 

,BQBO‘ā
(SVQàZFMFSJOFQBZMBā‘NMBS‘JÎJOUFāFLLàSFEJO
)FSLFTJOBLM‘OEBLBMBONFTBK‘QBZMBāNBT‘O‘JTUFZJO
,POVZMBJMHJMJWBSTBTPSVMBS‘O‘BM‘OWFDFWBQMBZ‘O
#JSTPOSBLJLPOVOVOCBāM‘þ‘O‘WFSJOWFWFEBMBā‘O

180
)&3,&4ÿ/ÿ:ÿ-ÿýÿ/ÿÿ45&.&,

,B[BO‘N
)BTFEJOFOÎPLLFOEJOF[BSBSWFSEJþJOJLBWSBS

½þSFUJDJ/PUV
)BTFU  CBāLBT‘O‘O NFāSV ZPMEBO TBIJQ PMEVþV CJS JNLÉOEBO EPMBZ‘ JOTBO‘O L‘TLBOÎM‘L
EVZHVTVOVOFULJTJOFLBQ‘MBSBLLFOEJTJOFCJSZBSBS‘PMNBTBCJMFPOJNFUJOFMEFOΑLNBT‘O‘
JTUFNFTJEJS)BTFUEVZHVTVOVPSUBEBOLBME‘SNBLWFZBFULJTJOEFOLPSVONBLJÎJOÚODFMJLMF
IBTFEJEPþVSBOTFCFQMFSJOCJMJONFTJHFSFLJS #JMHJTJ[MJL BÎHÚ[MàMàL CFODJMMJLWC )BTFU
FEFO WF IBTFU FEJMFO LJāJMFS BZS‘ BZS‘ EFþFSMFOEJSJMJS )BTFU FEFO  L‘TLBOBO LJNTF FO ÎPL
LFOEJTJOF[BSBSWFSJS ÎàOLàIBTFUFEFOÚODFLFOEJTJNVUTV[PMVS&CV#FLJSFS3É[ÔJTF
IBTFEJ IFN CFEFOÔ IFN SVIÔ UBISJCBUB  [JIOÔ WF BNFMÔ WFSJNTJ[MJþF ZPM BÎBO CJS IF[FZBO
EVSVNVPMBSBLEFþFSMFOEJSJSWFCVOEBOEPMBZ‘IBTFEJOL‘TLBO‘MBOEBOÎPLL‘TLBOBOLJNTFZF
[BSBS WFSEJþJOJ TÚZMFS )BTFU EVZHVTVOVO PMVāNBT‘ WF HàÎMFONFTJOEF  LJāJOJO LFOEJOJ
CBāLBMBS‘OEBO EBIB BāBþ‘ TFWJZFEF HÚSNFTJOEFO EPþBO LPNQMFLTJO CàZàL FULJTJ WBSE‘S
#V TFCFQMF ÎBM‘āBSBL HJEFSJMFCJMFDFL [BBnBS‘O CFSUBSBG FEJMNFTJ JÎJO FMEFO HFMFO HBZSFUJO
TBSGFEJMNFTJIBTFEJOÚOFNMJUFEBWJZPMMBS‘OEBOCJSJPMBSBLLBCVMFEJMNFMJEJS ÿTMBN"OT 
DJMU IBTFU #VCJMHJMFS‘ā‘þ‘OEBFULJOMJLÚODFTJÎPDVLMBSCJMHJMFOEJSJMJS

:ÚOUFNWF5FLOJLMFS
'FO %PþB&ULJOMJþJ

.BUFSZBM
#JSJEà[HàOZBQ‘M‘EJþFSJFþSJCàþSàWFUPQSBLM‘JLJQBUBUFT TPZBDBL

&ULJOMJL
ZBā
")#6#&/
±PDVLMBS‘OEJLLBUJOJUPQMBNBLJÎJOi"ICVCFOwJTJNMJFULJOMJþFCBāM‘ZPSV[EFOJMJS
1BUBUFTMFSÎPDVLMBS‘OJODFMFNFTJJÎJOCJSNBTBZBZBEBZFSFLPOVSĀFLJMMFSJ UFNJ[PMVQ
PMNBNBMBS‘ CàZàLMàLLàÎàLMàLZÚOàOEFOJZJDFJODFMFOJS
&þSJCàþSàQBUBUFTEà[HàOZBQ‘M‘WFUFNJ[PMBOHJCJPMNBLJTUJZPSWFLFOEJIÉMJOEFO
NFNOVO EFþJM %JþFS QBUBUFTJ EF Eà[HàO WF UFNJ[ PMEVþV JÎJO TFWNJZPS 1BUBUFT EFEJþJO
Eà[HàOāFLJMMJ PSUBCPZ UFNJ[WTPMVSEàāàODFTJOEFEJS
%‘ā‘OEBLJUPQSBLMBSEBOLVSUVMNBLJTUJZPSLFOEJOJZFSMFSFWVSBSBLUPQSBLMBS‘O‘EÚLNFL
JTUJZPS±PDVLMBSEBOQBUBUFTMFSJZFSFWVSNBMBS‘JTUFOJS
&þSJCàþSàQBUBUFTEà[HàOCJSQBUBUFTPMNBLJTUJZPS#VZà[EFOCJSTPZBDBLZBSE‘N‘JMF
Eà[HàOQBUBUFTFCFO[FUNFLJÎJOFþSJCàþSàUBSBnBS‘LFTJMJQEà[FMUJMNFZFÎBM‘ā‘M‘S

181
)&3,&4ÿ/ÿ:ÿ-ÿýÿ/ÿÿ45&.&,

ĀJNEJJLJQBUBUFTEFZBOZBOBLPOVSWFÎPDVLMBS‘OEVSVNVEFþFSMFOEJSNFTJJTUFOJS
 &þSJ CàþSà QBUBUFT E‘ā‘ LFTJMEJþJ JÎJO IFN LàÎàMEà IFN EF LBSBSE‘  BZS‘DB ÎPL EB
BD‘ ÎFLNJā PMNBM‘  UPQSBLMBSEBO LVSUVMNBL JÎJO LFOEJOJ ZFSF WVSEVþV JÎJO EF ÎPL [BSBS
HÚSEà "TM‘OEB CV EVSVNEB FO ÎPL BD‘ ÎFLFO  [BSBS HÚSFO LFOEJ PMEV 1FLJ IBTFU FUUJþJ
QBUBUFTUF HÚSEàþà Hà[FM ZBOMBS‘ LFOEJTJ EPþSV CJÎJNEF VZHVMBTBZE‘ OBT‘M PMVSEV  .FTFMB
UPQSBLMBS‘OEBOLVSUVMNBLJÎJOZ‘LBOBCJMJSEJ %PþBMāFLMJOJEFþJāUJSNFZFÎBM‘āBSBLOFLBEBS
HFSJEÚOàMNF[ZBOM‘āMBSZBQU‘þ‘O‘EàāàOTFZEJCVODBT‘L‘OU‘ZBLBUMBO‘SN‘ZE‘ 
%BIBTPOSBJLJQBUBUFTEFPSUBEBOLFTJMJS JLJTJOJOEFÚ[PMBSBLBZO‘PMEVþVHÚTUFSJMJS
%JþFSJOJL‘TLBOBOLÚUàEVZHVMBSCFTMFZFOJOEFBTM‘OEBEJþFSJZMFBZO‘ZBQ‘ZBTBIJQPMEVþV
WVSHVMBO‘S
&þSJCàþSàQBUBUFTJOEJþFSJOFIBTFUFEFSFL L‘TLBOBSBL BTM‘OEBFOÎPLLFOEJOF[BSBS
WFSEJþJCFMJSUJMJS5PQSBLMBS‘OEBOBS‘ONBZ‘LFOEJOF[BSBSWFSFSFLEFþJMÚ[FOEJþJBSLBEBā‘O‘O
ZBQU‘þ‘HJCJZ‘LBOBSBLZBQTBWFCVOVÚSOFLBMTB EVSVNVOBT‘MPMVSEV HJCJTPSVMBSMBLPOV
QFLJāUJSJMJS
 ĀJNEJ CV FþSJ CàþSà QBUBUFT TBEFDF IBTFU EVZHVMBS‘ JMF IBSFLFU FUUJ WF TPOVDVOEB
NVUMVNV āFLMJOEFCJSTPSVZMBLPOVUPQBSMBO‘SWFEFþFSMFOEJSNFZBQ‘M‘S

%FþFSMFOEJSNF4PSVMBS‘
#JSJOJOTFOJOIBLL‘OEBIBTFUEVZHVMBS‘CFTMFEJþJOJGBSLFUTFOOBT‘MIJTTFEFSTJO
)BTFUFEFOOFHJCJ[BSBSMBSBVþSBS
)BTFUUFOV[BLMBāNBLJÎJOOFMFSZBQ‘MNBM‘E‘S

(àOàO.FTBK‘
i)BTFUFWWFMBIBTJEJ IBTFUFEFOJ F[FS 
NBIWFEFS ZBOE‘S‘S.BITVE IBTFUFEJMFOLJāJ 
IBLL‘OEB[BSBS‘ZBB[E‘SWFZBZPLUVSw
.FLUßCÉU‘3BCCÉOÔ

,BQBO‘ā
(SVQàZFMFSJOFQBZMBā‘NMBS‘JÎJOUFāFLLàSFEJO
)FSLFTJOBLM‘OEBLBMBONFTBK‘QBZMBāNBT‘O‘JTUFZJO
,POVZMBJMHJMJWBSTBTPSVMBS‘O‘BM‘OWFDFWBQMBZ‘O
#JSTPOSBLJLPOVOVOCBāM‘þ‘O‘WFSJOWFWFEBMBā‘O

182
)&3,&4ÿ/ÿ:ÿ-ÿýÿ/ÿÿ45&.&,

)"4&55&/,6356-.",.Ã.,Ã/
,B[BO‘N
)BTFUUFO LVSUVMNBO‘O NàNLàO PMBCJMFDFþJOJ CJMJS )BLL‘OB SB[‘ PMNBZ‘  LBOBBULÉS
PMNBZ‘CJMJS 

½þSFUJDJ/PUV
)BTFU LFMJNFTJOJO OF BOMBNB HFMEJþJ à[FSJOEF EVSVMVS WF IBTFU EVZHVTVOVO EJOÔ
IBTTBTJZFUMFSHFSFþJV[BLEVSVMNBT‘HFSFLFO BZO‘[BNBOEBLJāJZJNVUTV[MVþBNBILßNFEFO
WFCVOVOMBCJSMJLUFTPTZBMJMJāLJMFSJEF[FEFMFZFOPMVNTV[CJSEàāàODFāFLMJPMEVþVà[FSJOEF
EVSVMVS #V CJMHJMFS WFSJMJSLFO IBTFEJO L‘TLBONB WF JNSFONFOJO ÚUFTJOEF LBSā‘ UBSBG‘O
JZJMJþJOJ JTUFNFNF āFLMJOEF ZPSVNMBOBCJMFDFL WF CV IÉMJZMF L‘TLBOÎM‘þ‘O EB ÚUFTJOF HFÎFO
IFN LJāJZF IFN EF ÎFWSFTJOF [BSBS WFSFO PMVNTV[ CJS UBW‘S PMEVþV HFSÎFþJ QFLJāUJSJMJS WF
EJOJNJ[JOJOBOBOMBSEBOLFOEJMFSJJÎJOJTUFEJLMFSJJZJWFHà[FMPMBOIFSāFZJEJþFSJOTBOMBSJÎJO
EFJTUFZFCJMNFFSEFNJOJHÚTUFSFCJMNFMFSJOJCFLMFEJþJWVSHVTVZBQ‘M‘SÿNSFONF L‘TLBONBWF
IBTFUFUNFEVZHVMBS‘BSBT‘OEBLJGBSLCFMJSUJMJSWFJNSFONFOJOZBOJHà[FMWFJZJPMBOāFZMFSF
LJāJOJO LFOEJTJOJO EF TBIJQ PMNBZ‘ JTUFNFTJOJO EPþBM CJS TàSFÎ PMEVþV  CVOVOMB CJSMJLUF
CVEVZHVOVOT‘O‘SMBS‘O‘OJIMBMJEVSVNVOEBLPMBZM‘LMBIBTFUCPZVUVOBUBā‘OBCJMFDFþJCJMHJTJ
WFSJMJS

:ÚOUFNWF5FLOJLMFS
"OMBU‘N &þJUTFM0ZVO

.BUFSZBM
±BM‘āNBLÉþ‘E‘ FLGPUPLPQJPMBSBLÎPþBMU‘MBDBLU‘S

&ULJOMJL
ZBā
,POV IBLL‘OEB ZFUFSMJ CJMHJ QBZMBā‘N‘ ZBQ‘ME‘LUBO TPOSB ÚþSFUJDJ IB[‘SMBOBO ÎBM‘āNB
LÉþ‘E‘O‘UàNÎPDVLMBSBEBþ‘U‘SWFÎPDVLMBS‘OTPSVMBS‘DFWBQMBOE‘SNBT‘O‘JTUFS$FWBQMBOE‘SNB
ZBQ‘ME‘LUBO TPOSB ÚþSFUJDJ LÉþ‘UMBS‘ UPQMBS WF WFSJMFO DFWBQMBS‘ ÎPDVLMBS JMF CJSMJLUF
EFþFSMFOEJSFSFLLPOVJMFJMHJMJTPOEFþFSMFOEJSNFZJZBQBS

183
զ +(ɘ, ƻ*ǔȢ(#(
4036
)BTFU EFOJMEJþJOEF BLM‘OB HFMFO JML LFMJNF OFEJS  4BEFDF CJS LFMJNF
ZB[BDBLT‘O‘[VOVUNBZ‘O
.........................................................................................................
.........................................................................................................

4036
%JZFMJNLJCJSBSLBEBā‘N‘[ZFOJCJSBZBLLBC‘BME‘WFCJ[EFÎPLCFþFOEJL
)BZEJJUJSBGFEFMJNBZO‘T‘OBTBIJQPMNBZ‘LJNJTUFNF[LJ 1FLJTJ[DFCÚZMFCJS
EVSVNEBIBTFUNJFUNJāPMVZPSV[ %àāàODFOJ[JHFSFLÎFTJJMFCJ[JNMFQBZMBā‘S
N‘T‘O‘[
.........................................................................................................
.........................................................................................................

4036
&USBG‘OEB JOTBOMBSB LBSā‘ IFS [BNBO CV āFLJMEF EBWSBOBO  ZBOJ IBTFU FEFO
CJSBSLBEBā‘OPMTBCVEBWSBO‘ā‘OEBOWB[HFÎNFTJJÎJOPOBOFMFSTÚZMFSTJOWFOF
UBWTJZFFEFSTJO
.........................................................................................................
.........................................................................................................

4036
4J[DFIBTFUFEFSFLJOTBOMBSBZBLMBāBOCJSJQTJLPMPKJLPMBSBLLFOEJTJOFOBT‘M
[BSBSWFSJS
.........................................................................................................
.........................................................................................................

4036
1FZHBNCFSJNJ[)[.VIBNNFE TBT i)BTFUFUNFLUFOTBL‘O‘O‘[#JMJOJ[
LJBUFāJOPEVOVZPLFUNFTJHJCJIBTFUEFJZJMJLMFSJZPLFEFSw &CV%ÉWVE FEFC 
 CVZVSNVāUVS#VIBEJTJOBT‘MZPSVNMVZPSTVOV[ CJ[JNMFQBZMBā‘SN‘T‘O‘[
.........................................................................................................
.........................................................................................................

184
)&3,&4ÿ/ÿ:ÿ-ÿýÿ/ÿÿ45&.&,

%FþFSMFOEJSNF4PSVMBS‘
)BTFUOFEFNFLUJS
)BTFUFEFOCJSLJāJ BSLBEBāMBS‘WFÎFWSFTJZMFJMJāLJMFSJOFOBT‘M[BSBSWFSJS
:àDFEJOJNJ[ÿTMBN‘OCVLPOVZBZBLMBā‘N‘OFEJS

(àOàO.FTBK‘
i#àUàOLÚUàMàLMFSJOCBā‘ LBZOBþ‘àÎUàS
)BTFU SJZB HÚTUFSJā VDC LFOEJOJWF
ZBQU‘þ‘JāMFSJCFþFONF ,BMCJOJCVOMBSEBO
UFNJ[MFNFZFÎBM‘āw
(B[[ÉMÔ

,BQBO‘ā
(SVQàZFMFSJOFQBZMBā‘NMBS‘JÎJOUFāFLLàSFEJO
)FSLFTJOBLM‘OEBLBMBONFTBK‘QBZMBāNBT‘O‘JTUFZJO
,POVZMBJMHJMJWBSTBTPSVMBS‘O‘BM‘OWFDFWBQMBZ‘O
#JSTPOSBLJLPOVOVOCBāM‘þ‘O‘WFSJOWFWFEBMBā‘O

185
)&3,&4ÿ/ÿ:ÿ-ÿýÿ/ÿÿ45&.&,

(*15"7&)"4&5
,B[BO‘N
(‘QUBÚ[FONFJMFL‘TLBOÎM‘LIBTFUBSBT‘OEBLJGBSL‘LBWSBS

½þSFUJDJ/PUV
)BTFUCJSLJNTFOJO IBZ‘SM‘CJSJāJWFZBFWJ NBM‘ NàMLà JMNJPMBOCJSLJāJZJL‘TLBONBT‘ 
CVOJNFUMFSJOPLJāJEFPMNBZ‘QLFOEJOEFPMNBT‘O‘JTUFNFTJPMBSBLUBO‘NMBO‘S0OEBPMEVþV
HJCJLFOEJTJOEFEFPMNBT‘O‘JTUFNFOJOIBTFUPMNBE‘þ‘ CVOVOH‘QUBFUNFL JNSFONFLPMEVþV
CFMJSUJMJS#BāLBT‘O‘O LFOEJOEFOàTUàOZBEBGBSLM‘PMBOIFSāFZJOJL‘TLBOBO ZBOJàTUàOMàþàO
ZBMO‘[LFOEJOEFPMNBT‘O‘JTUFZFOFL‘TLBOÎEFOEJþJWFCVIÉMJOJTFFOLÚUàIVZMBSEBOCJSJ
PMEVþV BOMBU‘M‘S ,‘TLBOÎ JOTBO‘O  ÚNSà CPZVODB SBIBUT‘[ WF IV[VSTV[ PMBDBþ‘  CÚZMF CJS
JOTBO‘O LFOEJOEFO BāBþ‘ PMBO JOTBOMBS‘ HÚSNFEJþJOJ CJMBLJT LFOEJOEFO ZàLTFL WF WBSM‘LM‘
JOTBOMBS‘OIFSāFZJOJHÚSàQL‘TLBOE‘þ‘JGBEFFEJMJS
(‘QUB FUNFOJO JTF TÚ[MàLUF iJODFMFNFL  BSBāU‘SNBL  ZPLMBNBLw HJCJ BOMBNMBSB HFMEJþJ 
OJNFUF LBWVāNB BS[VTV WF TFWJOÎ EFNFL PMEVþV CFMJSUJMJS #JS BIMBL UFSJNJ PMBSBL JTF 
LJāJOJO CBāLBMBS‘O‘O TBIJQ PMEVþV NBEEÔ WFZB NBOFWÔ JNLÉO WF NF[JZFUMFSF JNSFONFTJ 
POVOFMJOEFLJOJNFUMFSJOZPLPMNBT‘O‘JTUFNFLTJ[JOLFOEJTJOJOEFBZO‘āFZMFSFLBWVāNBZ‘
BS[VMBNBT‘BOMBN‘OEBLVMMBO‘MNBLUBPMEVþVJ[BIFEJMJS
%BIBTPOSBāVIVTVTMBSEBJGBEFFEJMFSFLH‘QUBFUNFOJOIBTFUEVZHVTVOEBOGBSLM‘PMEVþV
PSUBZB LPOVMNBZB ÎBM‘ā‘M‘S ,VSBOEB H‘QUB LFMJNFTJ HFÎNF[  BODBL i "MMBIUBO 0OVO
MàUGVOVJTUFZJOw /JTÉ  NFBMJOEFLJBZFUUFH‘QUBFUNFLLBTUFEJMNJāUJS"ZS‘DBIBZ‘SEB
ZBS‘āNBZ‘ÚþàUMFZFOBZFUMFSEFEFH‘QUBUFāWJLFEJMNJāUJS #BLBSB .àNJOßO 
.VUBGmGÔO  )[1FZHBNCFSEF i"ODBLJLJLJāJZFJNSFOJMJS CVOMBSEBOCJSJ"MMBI‘O
LFOEJTJOFNBMWFSEJþJWFCVNBM‘)BLZPMVOEBUàLFUNFJSBEFTJOFTBIJQL‘ME‘þ‘LJāJ EJþFSJ
EF"MMBI‘OLFOEJTJOFJMJNWFSEJþJ IFNCVJMJNMFBNFMFEFOIFNEFPOVCBāLBT‘OBÚþSFUFO
LJāJEJSw #VIÉSÔ JMJN  CVZVSNBLTVSFUJZMF.àTMàNBOMBS‘OCBāLBMBS‘O‘OFMJOEFCVMVOBO
OJNFUMFSJ L‘TLBONBEBO LFOEJMFSJOJO EF BZO‘ āFZMFSJ FMEF FUNFL JÎJO HBZSFU HÚTUFSNFMFSJOJ
ÚþàUMFNJāUJS

186
)&3,&4ÿ/ÿ:ÿ-ÿýÿ/ÿÿ45&.&,

:ÚOUFNWF5FLOJL
&þJUTFM0ZVO 4PSV$FWBQ

.BUFSZBM
3FOLMJLBSUPO ÎBM‘āNBLÉþ‘E‘ GPUPLPQJJMFÎPþBMU‘MN‘ā

&ULJOMJL
ZBā
½þSFUJDJ  BāBþ‘EBLJ ÎBM‘āNB LÉþ‘E‘O‘ ÎPþBMUBSBL CàUàO ÎPDVLMBSB EBþ‘U‘S 0OMBSEBO
CFMJSMJCJSTàSFJÎJOEFÎBM‘āNBLÉþ‘E‘OEBWBSPMBOEVSVNMBSLBSā‘T‘OEBOFMFSIJTTFUUJLMFSJOJ
LBSā‘EBLJCPāMVþBZB[NBMBS‘O‘JTUFS±PDVLMBS‘OIJTMFSJOJSBIBUJGBEFFEFCJMNFMFSJJÎJOÎBM‘āNB
LÉþ‘UMBS‘OBJTJNZB[‘MNB[½þSFUJDJ ÎBM‘āNBLÉþ‘UMBS‘O‘UPQMBSWFZB[‘MBOMBS‘ÎPDVLMBSMBCFSBCFS
EFþFSMFOEJSJS±‘LBOTPOVÎMBSBHÚSFL‘TLBOÎM‘LIBTFUWFH‘QUBÚ[FONFBSBT‘OEBLJGBSL‘BΑLMBS
,‘TLBOÎM‘þ‘O JOTBO‘ NVUTV[ FUUJþJOF  H‘QUBÚ[FONFOJO JTF JOTBO‘ DFTBSFUMFOEJSEJþJOF WVSHV
ZBQBS#VHJCJEVSVNMBSMBIFSLFTJOLBSā‘MBāBCJMFDFþJWFCVāBSUMBSBMU‘OEBIBOHJEBWSBO‘ā‘O
EPþSVPMEVþVLPOVTVOEBÎPDVLMBSMBTPICFUFEJMJS

187
զ +(ɘ, ƻ*ǔȢ(#(

"Ā"ý*%",ÿ%636.%" 4ÿ;0-4"/*;/&)ÿ44&%&34ÿ/ÿ;

"ZMBSE‘SBMNBLJÎJOVþSBāU‘þ‘O‘[TQPSBZBLLBC‘Z‘
BSLBEBā‘O‘[‘OBZBþ‘OEBHÚSEàþàOà[EF

±PLÎBM‘āU‘þ‘O‘[CJST‘OBWEBOFOZBL‘OBSLBEBā‘O‘[
TJ[EFOEBIBZàLTFLCJSQVBOBME‘þ‘OEB

,BMBCBM‘LCJSPSUBNEB BSLBEBā‘O‘[Hà[FMMJþJ
IBLL‘OEBTJ[EFOEBIBGB[MBÚWHàBME‘þ‘OEB

,BSEFāJOJ[JOTJ[EFOEBIB[FLJPMEVþV
TÚZMFOEJþJOEF

"NDBO‘[‘OPþMVJMFCFSBCFSHJSEJþJOJ[T‘OBWEB TJ[CJS
ZFSFZFSMFāFNF[LFOPU‘QGBLàMUFTJOJLB[BOE‘þ‘OEB

0EBBSLBEBā‘O‘[IFSLFTUBSBG‘OEBOTFWJMFOCJSJZTFWF
TJ[PSUBNMBSEBOE‘āMBO‘ZPSTBO‘[

,PNāVOV[VOFWJOFHJUUJþJOJ[EFFWJOJOÎPL
Hà[FMPMEVþVOVWFÎPLHà[FMNJTBmSBþ‘SMBE‘þ‘O‘
HÚSEàþàOà[EF

188
)&3,&4ÿ/ÿ:ÿ-ÿýÿ/ÿÿ45&.&,

%FþFSMFOEJSNF4PSVMBS‘
)BTFUOFEJS
(‘QUBÚ[FONFOFEJS
,‘TLBOÎM‘LWFÚ[FONFBSBT‘OEBLJGBSLOFEJS

(àOàO.FTBK‘
i#JSCJSJOJ[FLJOCFTMFNFZJO 
CJSCJSJOJ[FIBTFUFUNFZJO CJSCJSJOJ[F
T‘SUÎFWJSNFZJO&Z"MMBI‘OLVMMBS‘
,BSEFāPMVOw
#VIÉSÔ &EFQ 

,BQBO‘ā
(SVQàZFMFSJOFQBZMBā‘NMBS‘JÎJOUFāFLLàSFEJO
)FSLFTJOBLM‘OEBLBMBONFTBK‘QBZMBāNBT‘O‘JTUFZJO
,POVZMBJMHJMJWBSTBTPSVMBS‘O‘BM‘OWFDFWBQMBZ‘O
#JSTPOSBLJLPOVOVOCBāM‘þ‘O‘WFSJOWFWFEBMBā‘O

189
)&3,&4ÿ/ÿ:ÿ-ÿýÿ/ÿÿ45&.&,

&ULJOMJL
ZBā
½þSFUJDJ  EBIB ÚODF IB[‘SMBN‘ā PMEVþV  à[FSJOF ÎFāJUMJ LFMJNFMFSJO ZB[‘ME‘þ‘ LàÎàL
LBSUPOMBS‘LBS‘ā‘LCJSāFLJMEFNBTBO‘Oà[FSJOFZBZBS#VLBSUPOMBS‘OTBZ‘T‘O‘OGB[MBPMNBT‘
PZVOVLPMBZMBāU‘SBDBLU‘S,BSUPOMBS‘Oà[FSJOEFOPSNBMIBZBUUBLVMMBOE‘þ‘N‘[TPZVUWFTPNVU
IFS āFZ PMBCJMJS ½SOFþJO LBMFN  LÉþ‘U  FMNB  CJMHJTBZBS  FLNFL  UFMFGPO  FMCJTF   ÎJLPMBUB 
MBNCB T‘OBW BM‘āWFSJā NBSLFU FW LÚQFL LVā Ià[àO TFWJOÎ NVUMVMVL ÚGLF L‘[H‘OM‘LWC
#V PZVO JÎJO ÎPDVLMBS JLJ HSVCB BZS‘M‘S 4‘SBT‘ZMB IFS HSVQUBO CJSFS ÎPDVL HFMFDFL āFLJMEF
PZVO CBāMBS )FS ÎPDVLUBO NBTBEB EBþ‘O‘L IÉMEF CVMVOBO LÉþ‘UMBSEBO JTUFEJþJ  UBOFTJOJ
BMBSBL JÎJOEF L‘TLBOÎM‘L WFZB Ú[FONF JGBEFTJ HFÎFDFL CJS DàNMFZJ  TO JÎJOEF LVSNBT‘
JTUFOJS&þFSÎPDVLCFMJSMFOFOTàSFJÎJOEFCJSDàNMFLVSBNB[TBHSVCVOBFLTJQVBOHFUJSJS
&OGB[MBDàNMFZJLVSBOUBL‘NZBS‘āNBZ‘LB[BO‘S:B[‘MBODàNMFMFSÎPDVLMBSMBCFSBCFSUFLSBS
PLVOVSWFEFþFSMFOEJSNFTJZBQ‘M‘S

%FþFSMFOEJSNF4PSVMBS‘
)BTFUFUNFLCJ[FOFHJCJ[BSBSMBSWFSJS
)BTFUFUNFLUPQMVNBOFHJCJ[BSBSMBSWFSJS
)BTFUEVZHVNV[VOBT‘MB[BMUBCJMJSJ[

(àOàO.FTBK‘
i)BTFUUFOTBL‘O‘O ÎàOLàBUFāJO
PEVOVZBL‘QUàLFUUJþJHJCJIBTFUEF
JZJBNFMMFSJZBLBS CJUJSJSw
&CV%ÉWVE &EFQ 

,BQBO‘ā
(SVQàZFMFSJOFQBZMBā‘NMBS‘JÎJOUFāFLLàSFEJO
)FSLFTJOBLM‘OEBLBMBONFTBK‘QBZMBāNBT‘O‘JTUFZJO
,POVZMBJMHJMJWBSTBTPSVMBS‘O‘BM‘OWFDFWBQMBZ‘O
#JSTPOSBLJLPOVOVOCBāM‘þ‘O‘WFSJOWFWFEBMBā‘O

190
)&3,&4ÿ/ÿ:ÿ-ÿýÿ/ÿÿ45&.&,

½þSFUJDJ/PUV
(‘QUB CJS LJNTFOJO  NBEEJ WFZB NBOFWJ JNLÉO WF NF[JZFUMFSF TBIJQ PMBO CBāLB
CJSJOF JNSFONFTJ  POVO FMJOEFLJ OJNFUMFSJO ZPL PMNBT‘O‘ JTUFNF HJCJ LÚUà CJS EàāàODFZF
LBQ‘MNBEBO LFOEJTJOJO EF BZO‘ āFZMFSF LBWVāNBZ‘ BS[VMBNBT‘ BOMBN‘OEB LVMMBO‘M‘S
#BāLBT‘O‘OTBIJQPMEVþVCJSOJNFUFCBLBSBLLJāJOJOBZO‘āFZFLFOEJTJOJOEFTBIJQPMNBZ‘
UFNFOOJFUNFTJOFH‘QUB CBāLBT‘O‘OTBIJQPMEVþVOJNFUJOPOVOFMJOEFOΑLNBT‘O‘JTUFNFTJOF
WFZBCVZPMEBÎBCBHÚTUFSNFTJOFEFIBTFUEFOJMNFLUFEJSi"MMBI‘OTJ[JCJSCJSJOJ[EFOàTUàO
L‘ME‘þ‘āFZJCBāLBMBS‘OEBPMVQEBTJ[EFCVMVONBZBO‘IBTSFUMFBS[VFUNFZJO"MMBIUBO0OVO
MàUGVOVJTUFZJOwNFBMJOEFLJBZFUJO /JTÉ  JMLL‘TN‘OEBIBTFU JLJODJL‘TN‘OEBH‘QUB
LBTUFEJMNJāUJS.àTMàNBOMBS‘O NBEEJWFNBOFWJCBL‘NEBOLFOEJMFSJOEFOEBIBJZJPMBOMBSB
JNSFOFSFL POMBS IBLL‘OEB IFSIBOHJ CJS LÚUà EVZHV WF EàāàODFZF LBQ‘MNBEBO  [BSBSM‘
EBWSBO‘āMBSB LBML‘āNBEBO  PMVNMV WF WFSJNMJ CJS SFLBCFUF HJSJāNFMFSJOJO ÚOFNJOF JāBSFU
FEJMNJāUJS)[1FZHBNCFSJO i"ODBLJLJLJāJZFIBTFUFEJMJS CVOMBSEBOCJSJ"MMBI‘OLFOEJTJOF
NBMWFSEJþJWFCVNBM‘IBLZPMVOEBUàLFUNFJSBEFTJOFTBIJQL‘ME‘þ‘LJāJ EJþFSJEF"MMBI‘O
LFOEJTJOF JMJN WFSEJþJ  IFN CV JMJNMF BNFM FEFO IFN EF POV CBāLBT‘OB ÚþSFUFO LJāJEJSw
#VIÉSÔ ÿMJN   ÿTMBN"OT DJMU (‘QUB #VCJMHJMFSWFSJMEJLUFOTPOSBFULJOMJþFHFÎJMJS
:ÚOUFNWF5FLOJL
&þJUTFM0ZVO .BUFSZBM)B[‘SMBNB

.BUFSZBM
±BM‘āNBLÉþ‘E‘ LBSUPO ZBQ‘āU‘S‘D‘ NBLBT

&ULJOMJL
ZBā
/F:BQBS/F:BQNB[
½þSFUJDJIBZEJi/FZBQBSOFZBQNB[wFULJOMJþJOFHFÎFMJNEJZFSFL ÎPDVLMBS‘OEJLLBUJOJ
FULJOMJþFÎFLFS
 ÿLJMJ HSVQMBS PMVāUVSVMVS WF ÎPDVLMBS JÎJO VZHVO CJS TàSF CFMJSMFOFSFL CV TàSFEF
ÚSOFLMFSWFSNFMFSJJTUFOJS
#FMJSMFOFOTàSFJÎJOEF ÚSOFþJOÎPDVþVOCJSJi0LVMCBāBS‘T‘OEBOEPMBZ‘BSLBEBā‘NB
H‘QUBFEFSJNHJCJPMVNMVCJSÚSOFL EJþFSJEFIBTFUJÎJOPMVNTV[CJSÚSOFLWFSJS
 ±PDVLMBSEBO PSJKJOBM WFZB FTQJSJMJ CVMEVLMBS‘ ZB EB FO ÎPL CFþFOEJLMFSJ DFWBQMBS‘
BML‘āMBNBMBS‘JTUFOJS#FþFOJMFODFWBQMBS‘OGB[MBEBOQVBOLB[BOBDBþ‘JGBEFFEJMJS
#VāFLJMEFCFMJSMFOFOTàSFJÎJOEFÚSOFLMFSBM‘O‘S DFWBQMBSZBCJSLÉþ‘EBZB[‘M‘SZBEB
ÚþSFUNFOEPþSVZBOM‘āEJZFBO‘OEBQVBOMBNBZBQBSBLCJSJODJMFSJCFMJSMFS
4FWJMFOPSJKJOBMDFWBQMBSLPOVāNBCBMPOMBS‘JÎJOFZB[‘M‘QLBSUPOà[FSJOFZBQ‘āU‘S‘MBSBL
QBOPÎBM‘āNBT‘ZBQU‘S‘M‘SWFHÚSàMFDFLCJSZFSFBT‘M‘S

191
զ +(ɘ, ƻ*ǔȢ(#(

..................................... #VLBEBSHàMNFL
.....................................
.................................... L‘S‘ā‘LMBSBTFCFQ
PMVS)‘II

.................................................
.................................................
.................................................
.................................................
.................................................
/FLBEBSÚ[FOMFTFÎJMNJā ...........................................
CJSL‘ZBGFU½[FO
Hà[FMMJLLBU‘ZPS#FOEF
CVOBEJLLBUFEFZJN.

±BOUBT‘EBQFLCJ
Hà[FMNJā,FāLF
CFOJNPMTB
....................................................
....................................................
....................................................
....................................................
....................................................
..........................................

........................................
........................................
..............................

192
)&3,&4ÿ/ÿ:ÿ-ÿýÿ/ÿÿ45&.&,

%FþFSMFOEJSNF4PSVMBS‘
,JNMFSFH‘QUBFEFSTJO 7FIBOHJLPOVMBSEBH‘QUBFEFSTJO
(‘QUBO‘OIBTFEFEÚOàāNFNFTJJÎJOOFZBQ‘MBCJMJS
#BāLBMBS‘O‘OCBāBS‘MBS‘O‘HÚSàODFPOMBSBÚGLFMFOJSNJTJOJ[ZPLTBCVEVSVNTJ[JEBIBÎPL
ÎBM‘āNBZBUFāWJLNJFEFS

(àOàO.FTBK‘
i:BMO‘[āVJLJLJāJZFH‘QUBFEJMNFMJEJS
#JSJ "MMBI‘OLFOEJTJOFWFSEJþJNBM‘IBLZPMVOEB
IBSDBZ‘QUàLFUFOLJNTF EJþFSJ "MMBI‘OLFOEJTJOF
WFSEJþJJMJNMFZFSMJZFSJODFIàLNFEFOWFPOV
CBāLBMBS‘OBÚþSFUFOLJNTFw
#VIÉSÔ ÿMJN 

,BQBO‘ā
(SVQàZFMFSJOFQBZMBā‘NMBS‘JÎJOUFāFLLàSFEJO
)FSLFTJOBLM‘OEBLBMBONFTBK‘QBZMBāNBT‘O‘JTUFZJO
,POVZMBJMHJMJWBSTBTPSVMBS‘O‘BM‘OWFDFWBQMBZ‘O
#JSTPOSBLJLPOVOVOCBāM‘þ‘O‘WFSJOWFWFEBMBā‘O

193
)&3,&4ÿ/ÿ:ÿ-ÿýÿ/ÿÿ45&.&,

,&/%ÿ.%&,ÿ(Ã;&--ÿ,-&3
,B[BO‘N
,FOEJOEFPMBOZBOM‘āMBS‘GBSLFEFSWFHà[FMMJLMFSJOJHFMJāUJSJS

½þSFUJDJ/PUV
ÿOTBO‘OZBSBU‘M‘āJUJCBSJZMFHà[FMPMEVþV G‘USBU‘JUJCBSJZMFEFJZJMJLWFHà[FMMJLMFSFZBUL‘O
PMBSBLZBSBU‘ME‘þ‘WVSHVMBO‘SÿOTBO‘OFOàTUàOWBSM‘LPMNBT‘ IJÎCJS[BNBOQBSB HàÎ LBSJZFS 
āÚISFU  HJCJ Ú[FMMJLMFSEFO EPMBZ‘ EFþJMEJS ÿOTBO‘O EJOÔ WF BIMBLJ BΑEBO TBIJQ PMEVþV EF
þFSMFSJOPOVZBSBU‘MN‘āMBS‘OFOàTUàOàZBQBOIBLJLJÚ[FMMJLMFSPMBSBLBOMBā‘MNBT‘HFSFLUJþJ
WVSHVMBO‘S

:ÚOUFNWF5FLOJLMFS
"OMBU‘N 4PSV$FWBQ

.BUFSZBM
±BM‘āNBLÉþ‘E‘ GPUPLPQJJMFÎPþBMU‘MN‘ā

&ULJOMJL
ZBā
½þSFUJDJ i#VHàOPMBþBOàTUàCJSIB[JOFZJLFāGFΑLBDBþ‘[)B[‘SN‘T‘O‘[ wEJZFSFLCBāMBS
#ÚZMFMJLMFNFSBLVZBOE‘SBSBLÎPDVLMBS‘OEJLLBUJOJUPQMBS0OMBSB
i)B[JOFOFEJS w
i&OEFþFSMJIB[JOFTJ[DFOFEJS w
i/BT‘MCJSIB[JOFZFTBIJQPMNBLJTUFSEJOJ[ w
i)B[JOFMFSIV[VSHFUJSJSNJ wHJCJTPSVMBSZÚOFMUFSFLiIB[JOFwLBWSBN‘O‘Oà[FSJOEFEVSVS
,POVZVHFMFODFWBQMBSà[FSJOEFOi(FSÎFLIB[JOFOFEJS wTPSVTVJMFJāMFNFZFEFWBNFEFS
¬MFNWFJOTBO‘OZBSBU‘M‘ā‘OEBOÚSOFLWFSFSFLJOTBO‘OZBOJCJ[MFSJOBTM‘OEBIB[JOFMFSEFO
EBIB L‘ZNFUMJ WF Hà[FM PMEVþV WVSHVTVOV ZBQBS )FS JOTBO Ú[àOEF Hà[FMEJS ±àOLà Hà
[FMMJþJOZFHÉOFTBIJCJWFLBZOBþ‘"MMBIU‘S,FOEJTJHà[FMPMEVþVJÎJOHà[FMZBSBU‘S"LM‘N‘
[BHFMFCJMFDFLIFSāFZPHà[FMMJþJOGBSLM‘DFQIFMFSEFOZBOT‘NBT‘E‘S#VZà[EFOFTBTIB[JOF

194
)&3,&4ÿ/ÿ:ÿ-ÿýÿ/ÿÿ45&.&,

JÎJOJOTBOLFOEJJÎJOFCBLNBM‘E‘S%JLLBUMFLFOEJOFCBLBOCJSJOTBOPMBþBOàTUàCJSIB[JOFZJ
LFāGFUUJþJOJOGBSL‘OBWBSBDBLU‘S)BUB LVTVSZBEBFLTJLMJLMFSJNJ[IB[JOFNJ[JLFāGFUNFNJ[F
NÉOJPMNBNBM‘E‘S
½þSFUJDJ LPOVZVBOMBUU‘LUBOTPOSBBāBþ‘EBLJÎBM‘āNBLÉþ‘E‘O‘EBþ‘U‘S±BM‘āNBLÉþ‘E‘OEB
LBU‘M‘ND‘MBS‘OLFOEJIB[JOFMFSJOJEFþFSMFOEJSNFMFSJOFLBUL‘TBþMBZBDBLDàNMFMFSCVMVONBL
UBE‘S/FT‘LM‘LMBZBQU‘LMBS‘OBCBþM‘PMBSBLLVUVDVLMBS‘JāBSFUMFZFDFLMFSEJS

195
զ +(ɘ, ƻ*ǔȢ(#(
0-"ý"/Ã45Ã)";ÿ/&:ÿ,&Ā'&±*,"-*.
"SLBEBāMBS LFOEJOJ[JEBIBZBL‘OEBOUBO‘NBZBOFEFSTJOJ[ 
"āBþ‘EBLJEBWSBO‘āMBS‘OFT‘LM‘LMBZBQ‘ZPSTVOV[ JāBSFUMFSNJTJOJ[ 
 )&3;"."/ "3"4*3" )ÿ±#ÿ3;"."/

½OZBSH‘M‘EBWSBONBNBL

%JOMFNFEFOLBSBSWFSNFNFL
#BāLBT‘OBBJUPMBOZJZFDFþJ
ZFNFNFL
4‘SBWBSTBLVZSVþBHFÎNFL

#BāLBT‘OBBJUFāZBZ‘J[JOTJ[
LVMMBONBNBL
(FSFLUJþJOEFFāZBMBS‘O‘
QBZMBāBCJMNFL
,FOEJTJZà[àOEFOLJNTFOJO[BSBS
HÚSNFTJOJJTUFNFNFL

4VÎVOVCBāLBT‘O‘Oà[FSJOF
BUNBNBL
#JSJTJJÎJOZBQBCJMFDFLMFSJOJIFSLFT
JÎJOZBQBCJMNFL
)JÎLJNTFZJLàÎàNTFNFNFL
,FOEJTJJÎJOJTUFEJþJOJCBāLBMBS‘JÎJO
EFJTUFZFCJMNFL
5BO‘NBE‘LMBS‘IBLL‘OEBZFSMJ
ZFSTJ[LPOVāNBNBL
#FODJMPMNBNBL

7FSEJþJ[BSBS‘VZHVOZPMMBUFMBm
FUNFL
5BSBn‘EBWSBONBNBL
#BāLBMBS‘OB[BSBSWFSFDFLLBSBSMBS
BMNBNBL

5PQMBN

196
)&3,&4ÿ/ÿ:ÿ-ÿýÿ/ÿÿ45&.&,

%FþFSMFOEJSNF4PSVMBS‘
(FSÎFLIB[JOFOFEJS
i 3FTßMàN 4FOZà[àOàIBOJGPMBSBLEJOF "MMBIJOTBOMBS‘IBOHJG‘USBUà[FSFZBSBUN‘āJTF
POBÎFWJS"MMBI‘OZBSBU‘ā‘OEBEFþJāNFZPLUVSÿāUFEPTEPþSVEJOCVEVSGBLBUJOTBOMBS‘O
ÎPþVCJMNF[MFSw 3ßN  BZFUJOEFCJ[EFOJTUFOFOOFEJS

(àOàO.FTBK‘
i"OEPMTVO CJ[JOTBOPþMVOVāFSFnJ
L‘ME‘L0OMBS‘LBSBEBWFEFOJ[EFUBā‘E‘L
,FOEJMFSJOJFOHà[FMWFUFNJ[āFZMFSEFO
S‘[‘LMBOE‘SE‘LWFPOMBS‘ZBSBUU‘LMBS‘N‘[‘O
CJSÎPþVOEBOàTUàOL‘ME‘Lw
ÿTSÉ 

,BQBO‘ā
(SVQàZFMFSJOFQBZMBā‘NMBS‘JÎJOUFāFLLàSFEJO
)FSLFTJOBLM‘OEBLBMBONFTBK‘QBZMBāNBT‘O‘JTUFZJO
,POVZMBJMHJMJWBSTBTPSVMBS‘O‘BM‘OWFDFWBQMBZ‘O
#JSTPOSBLJLPOVOVOCBāM‘þ‘O‘WFSJOWFWFEBMBā‘O

197
)&3,&4ÿ/ÿ:ÿ-ÿýÿ/ÿÿ45&.&,

½þSFUJDJ/PUV
ÿOTBO‘O àTUàO WF NàLFNNFM CJS āFLJMEF ZBSBU‘ME‘þ‘OB WVSHV ZBQ‘MBSBL LPOVZB HJSJā
ZBQ‘M‘S (FSFL m[JLJ CBL‘NEBO  HFSFL BIMBL WF NBOFWJZBU CBL‘N‘OEBO  JOTBO‘O FO Hà[FM
CJÎJNEF ZBSBU‘ME‘þ‘ BOMBU‘M‘S ÿOTBO‘O PSHBOMBS‘O‘O  WB[JGFMFSJOF VZHVO āFLJMEF FO Hà[FM
CJÎJNEFÎBM‘āNBLUBPMEVþV JOTBO‘ONBEEJWFNBOFWJIFSIVTVTUBHà[FMMJLMFSMFEPOBU‘ME‘þ‘
WVSHVMBOBSBL i"OEPMTVO CJ[JOTBOPþMVOVāFSFnJL‘ME‘L0OMBS‘LBSBEBWFEFOJ[EFUBā‘E‘L
,FOEJMFSJOJFOHà[FMWFUFNJ[āFZMFSEFOS‘[‘LMBOE‘SE‘LWFPOMBS‘ZBSBUU‘LMBS‘N‘[‘OCJSÎPþVOEBO
àTUàOL‘ME‘Lw ÿTSÉ  BZFUJLFSJNFTJZMFLPOVEFTUFLMFOJS

:ÚOUFNWF5FLOJLMFS
"OMBU‘N &þJUTFM0ZVO

.BUFSZBM
"LÉþ‘E‘ ÎÚQLPWBT‘

&ULJOMJL
ZBā
½þSFUJDJ  i"MMBI Hà[FMEJS  Hà[FMJ TFWFSw .àTMJN  ·NÉO    IBEJTJ āFSJmOJ CàZàL
IBSnFSMF UBIUBZB ZB[BS ±PDVLMBSB Hà[FM PMBO āFZMFSJO OFMFS PMEVþVOV TPSBS WF CJ[MFSEF
CVMVONBT‘HFSFLFOHà[FMÚ[FMMJLMFSJTPSVDFWBQZÚOUFNJJMFÎPDVLMBSBCVMEVSVS
ĀJNEJ CJS FULJOMJL ZBQBDBþ‘[  EFS WF CàUàO ÎPDVLMBSB UFNJ[ CJS " LÉþ‘E‘ EBþ‘U‘S
±PDVLMBSEBO  LFOEJMFSJOEF WBS PMBO CFþFONFEJLMFSJ EBWSBO‘āMBS‘ LJNTF HÚSNFEFO   CV
LÉþ‘EBZB[NBMBS‘O‘JTUFS%BIBTPOSBCVLÉþ‘UMBS‘Z‘SUBSBLLàÎàLQBSÎBMBSBBZ‘SNBMBS‘O‘TÚZMFS
"þ[‘LBQBLM‘CJSÎÚQLPWBT‘BZBSMBO‘SWFÎPDVLMBSQBSÎBMBE‘LMBS‘LÉþ‘UMBS‘ÎÚQLVUVTVOBBUBS
#V HFSJ EÚOàāàN NBLJOFTJEJS )FQ CJSMJLUF EàþNFTJOF CBT‘M‘S  NBLJOF ÎBM‘āNBZB CBāMBS
WFFMEFOFMFTBMMBOBSBLEPMBāU‘S‘M‘S½þSFUNFOÚODFEFOLPWBO‘OJÎFSJTJOFT‘O‘GTBZ‘T‘ODB"
LÉþ‘E‘LPZBS.BLJOFEVSVODBLBQBLBΑM‘SWFCàUàOLÚUàMàLMFSHFSJEÚOàāàNMFZFOJMFOEJ
WFUFSUFNJ[CJSFSTBZGBPMEV EFOJS5FNJ["LÉþ‘UMBS‘ÎPDVLMBSBEBþ‘U‘M‘S0ZVOVOTPOVOEB
T‘O‘GÎBEFþFSMFOEJSNFZBQ‘M‘S

%FþFSMFOEJSNF4PSVMBS‘
ÿOTBOEBPMNBT‘HFSFLFOHà[FMEBWSBO‘āMBSOFMFSEJS
,ÚUàEBWSBO‘āMBS‘N‘[EBOOBT‘MLVSUVMBCJMJSJ[
ÿZJEBWSBO‘āMBS‘OCJ[FOFHJCJGBZEBMBS‘WBSE‘S
,ÚUàEBWSBO‘āMBSCJ[FOBT‘M[BSBSWFSFCJMJS

198
)&3,&4ÿ/ÿ:ÿ-ÿýÿ/ÿÿ45&.&,

(àOàO.FTBK‘
i,PNāVOBJZJMJLFULJHFSÎFLNàNJO
PMBT‘O,FOEJOJÎJOTFWEJþJOJ
JOTBOMBSJÎJOEFTFWLJHFSÎFL
NàNJOPMBT‘Ow
5JSNJ[Ô ;àIE 

,BQBO‘ā
(SVQàZFMFSJOFQBZMBā‘NMBS‘JÎJOUFāFLLàSFEJO
)FSLFTJOBLM‘OEBLBMBONFTBK‘QBZMBāNBT‘O‘JTUFZJO
,POVZMBJMHJMJWBSTBTPSVMBS‘O‘BM‘OWFDFWBQMBZ‘O
#JSTPOSBLJLPOVOVOCBāM‘þ‘O‘WFSJOWFWFEBMBā‘O

199
18
1": - " Ā . "  7 &  :" 3 % * . - " Ā . "

i:BSE‘NMBāNBwWFiQBZMBāNBwLBWSBNMBS‘O‘ÚþSFOJS
.BEEJ ZJZFDFL FāZB IFEJZF WFNBOFWJ TFWJOÎ BD‘ WBLJU FNFL UFDSàCF 
CJMHJWC QBZMBā‘NMBS‘OJMJāLJMFSJHàÎMFOEJSEJþJOJCJMJS
.BEEJCJSHàDFTBIJQPMNBZ‘ QBZMBāNBWFZBSE‘NMBāNBLJÎJOJTUFS
:BSE‘NMBāNBWFQBZMBāNBO‘OLJāJTFMWFNBOFWJEPZVNVBSUU‘SE‘þ‘O‘CJMJS
:BSE‘NMBāNBWFQBZMBāNBO‘OUPQMVNEBLBSEFāMJL CJSMJLWFCFSBCFSMJL
EVZHVMBS‘O‘HFMJāUJSEJþJOJCJMJS
;FLÉUWFTBEBLBJCBEFUJJMFEFQBZMBāNBWFZBSE‘NMBāNBEVZHVMBS‘O‘O
HFMJāUJþJOJCJMJS
4FWJOÎMFSJOQBZMBā‘MNBT‘BE‘OBEJOÔCBZSBNMBS‘O NàCBSFLHàOWFHFDFMFSJO
CJSG‘STBUPMEVþVOVLBWSBS
1": - " Ā . "  7 &  :" 3 % * . - " Ā . "

1":-"Ā."7&:"3%*.-"Ā."
,B[BO‘N
i:BSE‘NMBāNBwWFiQBZMBāNBwLBWSBNMBS‘O‘ÚþSFOJS
.BEEJ ZJZFDFL FāZB IFEJZF WFNBOFWJ TFWJOÎ BD‘ WBLJU FNFL UFDSàCF CJMHJWC 
QBZMBā‘NMBS‘OJMJāLJMFSJHàÎMFOEJSEJþJOJCJMJS

½þSFUJDJ/PUV
.VUMVMVþVO LJNJ[BNBOCBāLBMBS‘O‘ONVUMVMVþVOBWFTJMFPMNBLMBHFSÎFLMFāFCJMFDFþJO
EFOIBSFLFUMF [PSEVSVNEBLBMN‘ā JIUJZBÎTBIJCJPMBOJOTBOMBSBLBSā‘EVZBSM‘EBWSBO‘MNBT‘
HFSFLUJþJOFWVSHVZBQ‘M‘SÿNLÉOMBSFMWFSEJþJÚMÎàEFQBZMBāNBWFZBSE‘NMBāNBO‘OJOTBOMBS
BSBT‘OEBLJNVIBCCFUJ TFWHJWFTBZH‘Z‘EJSJUVUBDBþ‘OBJāBSFUFEJMJS1BZMBāNBWFZBSE‘NMBāNB
O‘OUFNFMJOEFJTF "MMBIS‘[BT‘BNBD‘O‘OPMNBT‘HFSFLUJþJCJSΑLBSWFHFSJEÚOàāàNEàāàO
DFTJZMFZBQ‘MBOQBZMBā‘NWFZBSE‘N‘ONBOFWJCJSEFþFSJOJOPMNBE‘þ‘IBLJLBUJÚ[FMMJLMFEJMF
HFUJSJMJS4FWHJMJ1FZHBNCFSJNJ[JO TBT ÎPþV[BNBOLFOEJJIUJZBD‘PMEVþVIÉMEF CBāLBMB
S‘O‘OJIUJZBÎMBS‘OBÚODFMJLWFSEJþJ QBZMBāNBWFZBSE‘NMBāNBLPOVTVOEBJOTBOM‘þBFWSFOTFM
EFþFSMFSLB[BOE‘SE‘þ‘ÎFāJUMJÚSOFLMFSMFJ[BIFEJMJS

:ÚOUFNWF5FLOJLMFS
&þJUTFM0ZVO 4PSV$FWBQ

.BUFSZBM
'PUPþSBnBS

&ULJOMJL
ZBā
#VFULJOMJLUFBāBþ‘EBLJGPUPþSBnBSLVMMBO‘M‘S½þSFUJDJ i"SLBEBāMBSāJNEJTJ[FCB[‘GPUPþ
SBnBSHÚTUFSFDFþJNWFCVGPUPþSBnBSJMFJMHJMJEàāàODFMFSJOJ[JCFOJNMFQBZMBāNBO‘[‘JTUFZFDF
þJNwEFS#VFULJOMJþFJMLPMBSBLLJNJOLBU‘MNBLJTUFEJþJOJTPSBSWFHÚOàMMàCJSÎPDVLUFTQJU
FEJMJS

202
1": - " Ā . "  7 &  :" 3 % * . - " Ā . "

½þSFUJDJGPUPþSBnBSBSBT‘OEBOCJSUBOFTJOJTFÎFSWFCJSÎPDVLCFMJSMFOEJLUFOTPOSBÚþSFUJDJ
OFāFMJ FOFSKJLCJSTFTJMFi&WFUJāUFGPUPþSBG‘N‘[wEFSWFGPUPþSBG‘HÚTUFSJS½þSFUJDJ ÎPDVþVO
GPUPþSBG‘JODFMFNFTJJÎJOPOBL‘TBCJSTàSFUBO‘E‘LUBOTPOSBi"SU‘LIB[‘STBOTPSVMBSBHFÎFCJMJ
SJ[wEFSWFTPSVMBSBHFÎJMJS½þSFUJDJT‘SBZMBBāBþ‘EBLJTPSVMBS‘TPSBS
#VGPUPþSBGTFODFOFZJBOMBU‘ZPS 
#VGPUPþSBG‘JMLHÚSEàþàOEFOFIJTTFUUJO 
%JZFMJNLJCVGPUPþSBG‘TFOÎFLUJOWFCJSGPUPþSBGTFSHJTJBÎNBLJÎJOIB[‘SMBO‘ZPSTVO#V
GPUPþSBGBOBT‘MCJSJTJNWFSNFLJTUFSEJO 
½þSFUJDJ  IFS CJS TPSVEBO TPOSB ÎPDVþVO DFWBC‘ EPþSVMUVTVOEB L‘TB CJS TPICFU PSUBN‘
PMVāUVSNBZBÎBM‘ā‘SWFÎPDVþVOWFSEJþJDFWBQJMFJMHJMJi0MEVLÎBHà[FMCJSZBLMBā‘Nw i%FNFL
LJGPUPþSBGBWFSNFLJTUFEJþJOJTJNCV QFLJTFCFCJOJEFCJ[FBOMBUNBLJTUFSNJTJO wHJCJPMVN
MVEÚOàUMFSWFSJS'BSLM‘GPUPþSBnBSGBSLM‘ÎPDVLMBSJMFBZO‘āFLJMEFUFLSBSMBO‘S%BIBTPOSB
WFSJMFODFWBQMBSEBOZPMBΑLBSBLÚþSFUJDJZBSE‘NMBāNBWFQBZMBāNBJMFJMHJMJCJMHJWFSJS#VOVO
EJOÔCJSFNJSWFUBWTJZFOJUFMJþJUBā‘ZBOÚOFNMJCJSJCBEFUPMEVþVWVSHVTVZBQ‘M‘S:BSE‘NMBā
NBWFQBZMBāNBO‘OTBEFDFNBEEJCPZVUVOVOPMNBE‘þ‘ TFWJOÎ NVUMVMVL FNFLHJCJQBZMB
ā‘NMBS‘OEBÚOFNMJPMEVþVNFTBK‘ LVMMBO‘MBOGPUPþSBnBS‘OZBSE‘NMBS‘JMFQFLJāUJSJMJS½þSFUJDJ
TPOL‘T‘NEB CFMJSMFEJþJCBāLBCJSGPUPþSBG‘UàNT‘O‘GBHÚTUFSFSFLÎPDVLMBSEBOGPUPþSBGBHÚSF
CJSIJLÉZFZB[NBMBS‘O‘JTUFS)JLÉZFMFSJOCJSTPOSBLJEFSTFLBEBSUBNBNMBONBT‘HFSFLUJþJOJ
WFFOÎPLCFþFOJMFOIJLÉZFOJOTBIJCJOFLàÎàLCJSIFEJZFWFSJMFDFþJOJIBU‘SMBU‘S

%FþFSMFOEJSNF4PSVMBS‘
1BZMBāNBEFOJMEJþJOEFBLM‘O‘[BOFHFMJS
1BZMBāNBWFZBSE‘NMBāNBO‘OCJSFZTFMBOMBNEBOFHJCJLB[BO‘NMBS‘PMBCJMJS
1BZMBāNBWFZBSE‘NMBāNBO‘OUPQMVNTBMCJSMJLWFCFSBCFSMJþFOFHJCJLBUL‘MBS‘WBSE‘S

203
1": - " Ā . "  7 &  :" 3 % * . - " Ā . "

(àOàO.FTBK‘
i&Z"MMBI‘OLVMMBS‘LBSEFāPMVOw
#VIÉSÔ &EFC 

,BQBO‘ā
(SVQàZFMFSJOFQBZMBā‘NMBS‘JÎJOUFāFLLàSFEJO
)FSLFTJOBLM‘OEBLBMBONFTBK‘QBZMBāNBT‘O‘JTUFZJO
,POVZMBJMHJMJWBSTBTPSVMBS‘O‘BM‘OWFDFWBQMBZ‘O
#JSTPOSBLJLPOVOVOCBāM‘þ‘O‘WFSJOWFWFEBMBā‘O

204
1": - " Ā . "  7 &  :" 3 % * . - " Ā . "

205
1": - " Ā . "  7 &  :" 3 % * . - " Ā . "

206
1": - " Ā . "  7 &  :" 3 % * . - " Ā . "

207
1": - " Ā . "  7 &  :" 3 % * . - " Ā . "

208
1": - " Ā . "  7 &  :" 3 % * . - " Ā . "

1":-"Ā."/*/.65-6-6ý6
,B[BO‘N
i:BSE‘NMBāNBwWFiQBZMBāNBwLBWSBNMBS‘O‘ÚþSFOJS
.BEEJ ZJZFDFL FāZB IFEJZF WFNBOFWJ TFWJOÎ BD‘ WBLJU FNFL UFDSàCF CJMHJWC 
QBZMBā‘NMBS‘OJMJāLJMFSJHàÎMFOEJSEJþJOJCJMJS
.BEEJCJSHàDFTBIJQPMNBZ‘ QBZMBāNBWFZBSE‘NMBāNBLJÎJOJTUFS
:BSE‘NMBāNBWFQBZMBāNBO‘OLJāJOJONBOFWJEPZVNVOVBSUU‘SE‘þ‘O‘CJMJS

½þSFUJDJ/PUV
±PDVLMBSBZBSE‘NMBāNBWFQBZMBāNBEFOJODFOFBOMBE‘LMBS‘TPSVMVS±PDVLMBS‘ODFWBQMB
S‘O‘EJOMFEJLUFOTPOSB LJāJOJOLFOEJHàÎWFJNLÉOMBS‘O‘CBāLBCJSJOJOJZJMJþJJÎJOLVMMBONB
T‘OBZBSE‘NMBāNBEFOEJþJEJOJNJ[ÿTMBN‘OZBSE‘NMBāNBZ‘ÚWEàþàIBUUBÿTMBN‘OāBSUMBS‘O
EBOCJSJPMBO[FLÉUJCBEFUJZMFZBSE‘NMBāNBZ‘FNSFUUJþJJ[BIFEJMJSĀVIBEJTJāFSJGBΑLMBO‘S
i.àTMàNBO .àTMàNBO‘OLBSEFāJEJS0OB[VMNFUNF[ POV EàāNBO‘OB UFTMJNFUNF[,JN 
NàNJO  LBSEFāJOJO CJS JIUJZBD‘O‘ HJEFSJSTF "MMBI EB POVO CJS JIUJZBD‘O‘ HJEFSJSw #VIÉSÔ 
.F[BMJN  

:ÚOUFNWF5FLOJLMFS
%FOFZ "OMBU‘N 4PSV$FWBQ

.BUFSZBM
ÃÎ EÚSUBEFUNVN

&ULJOMJL
ZBā
½þSFUJDJ T‘O‘G‘OPEBO‘OCJSLÚāFTJOFCJSLBÎNVNZFSMFāUJSJSWFNVNMBSEBOCJSJOJZBLBS
±PDVLMBSBCJSEFOFZZBQBDBLMBS‘O‘TÚZMFS.VNZBONBZBEFWBNFEFSLFOÚþSFUJDJÎPDVLMBSB
i,FOEJMFSJJIUJZBÎJÎJOEFPMTBMBSCJMF CBāLBMBS‘O‘LFOEJÚ[DBOMBS‘OBUFSDJIFEFSMFSw )BāS 
 BZFUJOJPLVSWFCVBZFUJOCJSJOJāTFCFCJPMEVþVOVJ[BIFEFSFLBāBþ‘EBLJPMBZ‘BOMBU‘S

209
1": - " Ā . "  7 &  :" 3 % * . - " Ā . "

&CV)àSFZSFEFOHFMFOCJSSJWBZFUFHÚSF i#JSHàO)[1FZHBNCFSJOIV[VSVOBCJSBEBN
HFMEJ WF BÎM‘LUBO UBLBUJOJO LFTJMEJþJOJ TÚZMFEJ 3FTßMVMMBI  FW IBML‘OB CV BEBNB CJS āFZMFS
WFSNFMFSJ JÎJO IBCFS HÚOEFSEJ 0OMBS FWMFSJOEF TVEBO CBāLB CJS ZJZFDFL CVMVONBE‘þ‘O‘
TÚZMFZJODF 3FTßMJ&LSFN TBIBCFZF
i#VHFDFCVBEBN‘LJNNJTBmSFEFDFL wEFEJ
#VOVOà[FSJOFFOTBSEBO&CV5BMIB
:B 3BTßMBMMBI  CFO NJTBmS FEFSJN  EFEJ 0OV FWJOF HÚUàSEà &WEF IBO‘N‘OB ZJZFDFL
CJS āFZ CVMVOVQ CVMVONBE‘þ‘O‘ TPSEV ,BS‘T‘ EB ZBMO‘[ ÎPDVLMBS‘O ZJZFDFþJ LBEBS CJS āFZ
CVMVOEVþVOVTÚZMFEJ0EB
 i½ZMFZTF POMBS‘ CJS āFZMF BWVU  TPGSBZB HFMNFL JTUFSMFSTF VZVU .JTBmSJNJ[ FWF HFMJODF
MBNCBZ‘TÚOEàS POBLFOEJNJ[EFZJZPSNVāHJCJHÚTUFSFMJNwEFEJ4PGSBZBPUVSEVMBS.JTBmS
LBSO‘O‘EPZVSEV,FOEJMFSJLBSBOM‘LUBZJZPSNVāHJCJEBWSBOE‘MBSWFBÎZBUU‘MBS4BCBIPMVODB
FWTBIJCJ1FZHBNCFSJNJ[JO TBT ZBO‘OBHJUUJ&GFOEJNJ[POB
i#VHFDFNJTBmSJOJ[FLBSā‘ZBQU‘þ‘O‘[EBWSBO‘āUBO"MMBISB[‘PMEVwCVZVSEV"MMBIV5FÉMÉ
EBPOMBSIBLL‘OEBZVLBS‘EBLJBZFUJLFSJNFZJJOEJSEJ #VIÉSÔ 5FGTJS  )BāS  
"OMBU‘NCJUUJLUFOTPOSBÚþSFUJDJT‘O‘G‘OCBāLBCJSLÚāFTJOEFIB[‘SMBE‘þ‘CJSNVNVZBLBS
:BLU‘þ‘ NVNMB EJþFS NVNMBS‘ EB UVUVāUVSBSBL UàN NVNMBS‘O ZBONBT‘O‘ TBþMBS #V T‘SBEB
EFSTJOCBā‘OEBZBLU‘þ‘NVNBOFPMEVþVOVÎPDVLMBSBTPSBS±PDVLMBSNVNVOZBWBāZBWBā
FSJEJþJOJHÚ[MFNMFNJāMFSEJS½þSFUJDJiÿOTBOIBZBU‘CJSāFLJMEFTPOCVMVSÎPDVLMBS0NVNUFL
CBā‘OBZBOBSBLFSJEJWFCJUUJ"NBāJNEJZBLU‘þ‘NNVNBUFāJOJEJþFSNVNMBSMBQBZMBāNBT‘OB
SBþNFO LFOEJ ‘ā‘þ‘OEBO CJS āFZ LBZCFUNFEFO ZBONBZB EFWBN FUUJ #J[MFS EF IBZBU‘N‘[‘
TàSEàSàSLFOOFLBEBSÎPLJOTBOBZBSE‘NFEJQGBZEBM‘PMBCJMJZPSTBLPLBEBSÎPL‘ā‘LWFSNJā
PMVSV[w EFS  &CV 5BMIBO‘O  CV Hà[FM EBWSBO‘ā‘O‘O 3BCCJNJ[ UBSBG‘OEBO  ÚWàMEàþàOà WF
CVEBWSBO‘āBCJOBFOCJSBZFUJOEJSJMEJþJOJJGBEFFEFS½þSFUJDJ NBEEJCJSHàDFTBIJQPMNB
JTUFþJNJ[JO JIUJZBD‘ PMBOMBSB ZBSE‘N FUNFL BE‘OB PMNBT‘ HFSFLUJþJOJ  ZBSE‘N WF QBZMBāNB
TBZFTJOEFNBOFWJCJSEPZVNFMEFFEFDFþJNJ[JTÚZMFZFSFLBāBþ‘EBLJIBEJTJÎPDVLMBSMBQBZMBā‘S
WFEFSTJTPOMBOE‘S‘S
t i4J[EFO CJSJOJ[  LFOEJTJ JÎJO BS[V FEJQ JTUFEJþJ āFZJ  EJO LBSEFāJ JÎJO EF BS[V FEJQ
JTUFNFEJLÎF HFSÎFLBOMBNEBJNBOFUNJāPMNB[w #VIÉSÔ ÿNBO 

%FþFSMFOEJSNF4PSVMBS‘
1BZMBāNBWFZBSE‘NMBāNBPMNBTBZE‘ UPQMVNEBOFUàSBLTBLM‘LMBSPMVSEV
1BZMBāNBO‘OWFZBSE‘NMBāNBO‘OZBSBSMBS‘OFMFSEJS
)BZBU‘O‘[EBOZBSE‘NMBāNBWFQBZMBāNBÚSOFLMFSJWFSFCJMJSNJTJOJ[

210
1": - " Ā . "  7 &  :" 3 % * . - " Ā . "

(àOàO.FTBK‘
i,JN.àTMàNBO‘CJST‘L‘OU‘EBOLVSUBS‘STB 
CVTFCFQMF"MMBIEBPOVL‘ZBNFUHàOà
T‘L‘OU‘MBS‘O‘OCJSJOEFOLVSUBS‘S,JNCJS
.àTMàNBO‘OLVTVSVOVÚSUFSTF "MMBIEB
L‘ZBNFUHàOàPOVOLVTVSVOVÚSUFSw
#VIÉSÔ .F[BMJN 

,BQBO‘ā
(SVQàZFMFSJOFQBZMBā‘NMBS‘JÎJOUFāFLLàSFEJO
)FSLFTJOBLM‘OEBLBMBONFTBK‘QBZMBāNBT‘O‘JTUFZJO
,POVZMBJMHJMJWBSTBTPSVMBS‘O‘BM‘OWFDFWBQMBZ‘O
#JSTPOSBLJLPOVOVOCBāM‘þ‘O‘WFSJOWFWFEBMBā‘O

211
1": - " Ā . "  7 &  :" 3 % * . - " Ā . "

:ÚOUFNWF5FLOJLMFS
"OMBU‘N 3PM0ZOBNB

.BUFSZBM
3FOLMJLBSUPO UFSDJIFOZFāJM L‘SN‘[‘ NBLBT ZBQ‘āU‘S‘D‘ BEFUQMBTUJLLPWB

&ULJOMJL
ZBā
#VFULJOMJLÚODFEFOIB[‘SM‘LHFSFLUJSNFLUFEJS½þSFUJDJCJSÚODFLJEFSTJLJÎPDVþBBāBþ‘EB
ZFSBMBO)BDJWBUWF,BSBHÚ[NFUOJOJWFSJS#JSTPOSBLJEFSTUFDBOMBOE‘S‘MBDBLPMBOCVNFUOF
IB[‘SMBO‘QHFMNFMFSJOJJTUFS±PDVLMBS‘OTFTUPOV WVSHVTV TÚZMFEJLMFSJOJOBOMBā‘M‘SPMNBT‘
IVTVTVOEBÚþSFUJDJBΑLMBNBEBCVMVOVSWFQSPWBMBSBZBSE‘ND‘PMVS
½þSFUJDJ )BDJWBUWF,BSBHÚ[JÎJOāBQLBZBQNBLBNBD‘ZMBLBSUPO NBLBTWFZBQ‘āU‘S‘D‘
HFUJSJS#àUàOÎPDVLMBSMBCJSMJLUFCBTJUāFLJMEFJLJUBOFāBQLBIB[‘SMBO‘SĀBQLBMBSIB[‘SMBOE‘LUBO
TPOSBEBIBÚODFHÚSFWMFOEJSJMNJāPMBOÎPDVLMBSāBQLBMBS‘UBLBSBLSPMMFSJOFCBāMBSMBS )BDJWBU
WF,BSBHÚ[āBQLBMBS‘HFOFMMJLMFZFāJM L‘SN‘[‘SFOLMFSEFPMNBLUBE‘S

:"3%*.&%ÿ/,0.Ā6-"3
)BDJWBU,BSBHÚ[àNIFNFOHFMCVSBZBÎBCVLÎBCVL
,BSBHÚ[)BOJOFSEFÎVCVL ±PLTFWFSJNÎVCVLLSBLFSJ
)BDJWBU/FLSBLFSJ,BSBHÚ[àN BDFMFZBSE‘NBHFM
,BSBHÚ[#FOTFOEFOCàZàþàN TFOCFOJNZBO‘NBHFM
)BDJWBU,BSBHÚ[àN[PSEVSVNEBZ‘NZBSE‘NBHFMTFOF
,BSBHÚ[½ZMFEFTFOF)BDJWBU.BEFN[PSEVSVNEBT‘OHFMJSJNIFNFO
)BDJWBU0I ÎPLāàLàSCVLF[EPþSVBOMBE‘O
,BSBHÚ["SLBEBā‘N[PSEVSVNEBZTBIFNFOBOMBS‘N IFNFOZBSE‘NBLPāBS‘N
)BDJWBU"MMBISB[‘PMTVO,BSBHÚ[àN CBLOFMFSPMEV
,BSBHÚ[/FPMEV)BD‘$BWDBW OJZFQBÎBMBS‘O‘TMBLTFOJO CBM‘LBWMBNBZBN‘HJUUJO
)BDJWBU/FCBM‘þ‘JLJHÚ[àN CJ[JNPþMBOB[‘D‘LNVTMVþVBΑLC‘SBLN‘ā
,BSBHÚ[&FFy/FPMNVāNVTMVþVOV[CJSB[LBΑLTB
)BDJWBU,BΑLEFþJMFGFOEJN BΑLBΑL/FPMBDBLEBNMBZBEBNMBZBHÚMPMNVā
,BSBHÚ[%FTFOFTJ[JOFWJTVCBTU‘
)BDJWBU"ZOFOÚZMF,BSBHÚ[àN ZBSE‘NFUEFFWEFLJTVMBS‘CPāBMUBM‘N
,BSBHÚ[7BIIWBII:BSE‘NFUNF[NJZJNIJÎCV[PS[BNBO‘OEB

212
1": - " Ā . "  7 &  :" 3 % * . - " Ā . "

)FNFOFWFHJEJQCJSLFQÎFCJSmODBOHFUJSFZJN
)BDJWBU#FOTBOBFWJTVCBTU‘EJZPSVNTFOLFQÎFmODBOEJZPSTVO/FZBQBDBþ‘[POMBSMB
,BSBHÚ[4VMBS‘CPāBMUBDBþ‘[FMCFUUF%PMEVSVQEPMEVSVQCPāBMU‘S‘[
)BDJWBU,FQÎFZFUNF[FGFOEJN EBIBCàZàLCJSāFZMB[‘N
,BSBHÚ[½ZMFZTFCJ[JNIBO‘N‘OUFODFSFMFSJOJHFUJSFZJN
)BDJWBU"IFGFOEJNTFOIÉMÉBOMBNBE‘ON‘ÎPLTVWBSÎPL,PWBHFUJS
,BSBHÚ[TBIOFEFOΑLBS CJSB[TPOSBUFLSBSHJSFS
,BSBHÚ[ ÿāUF LPWBZ‘ HFUJSEJN #VOV CJS Hà[FM EPMEVSBM‘N )PPQ āJNEJ EF CPāBMUBM‘N
GPāā
)BDJWBU/FZBQ‘ZPSTVO,BSBHÚ[àN
,BSBHÚ[/FZBQBDBþ‘N)BD‘$BWDBW ZBSE‘NFUEFEJOZBSE‘NBHFMEJN,PWBHFUJSEFEJO
HFUJSEJN:JOFOFJTUJZPSTVOW‘SW‘SW‘Sy
)BDJWBU4VMBS‘OFEFOTPLBþBEÚLàZPSTVO,BSBHÚ[àN
,BSBHÚ[/FZBQTBZE‘NZB HÚUàSàQCJ[JNFWFNJEÚLTFZEJN
)BDJWBU)BZ‘SFGFOEJNÚZMFEFNFEJN
,BSBHÚ[#FOEFTFOJOHJCJIFSJGHÚSNFEJN
)BDJWBU%VSVQCJSEJOMFCFOJ,BSBHÚ[àN
,BSBHÚ[ 6ZVZVQ JOMFZJN NJ  )FN ZBSE‘NB HFM EJZPSTVO IFN VZV EJZPSTVO W‘Z W‘Z
W‘Zy
)BDJWBU#JSEBLJLBFGFOEJN CJ[JNPþMBO[BUFONVTMVþVBΑLC‘SBL‘QTVZVJTSBGFUNJāCJS
EFTFOJTSBGFUNFEJZPSVN
,BSBHÚ[ÿTSBGN‘ /BT‘MZBOJCVLF[HFSÎFLUFOBOMBNBE‘N
)BDJWBU%VSCFOTBOBBΑLMBZBZ‘NJLJHÚ[àN4VZVTPLBþBEÚLFSTFLOFPMVS
,BSBHÚ[)JJÎOFPMBDBLU‘LJ #JSāFZNJPMBDBLU‘ 
)BDJWBU0OVEJZPSVNCFOEF4PLBþBEÚLFSTFLTVZVCVEFGBEBCJ[JTSBGFUNJāPMVSV[
(FMCVTVMBS‘CBIÎFEFLJBþBÎMBSB ÎJÎFLMFSFEÚLFMJN
,BSBHÚ["BBBþBÎMBS ÎJÎFLMFSCBOZPZBQNBZ‘ÎPLNVTFWFS %FNFLPZà[EFOUFSUFNJ[MFS 
CBLTFO
)BDJWBU)BZ‘SFGFOEJN#VTVCBOZPZBQNBLJÎJOEFþJM4VPOMBS‘OH‘EBT‘0OMBSTVZMB
CFTMFOJQ CàZàZPSMBS
,BSBHÚ[ )‘‘‘N CV TVZV POMBSB EÚLFSTFL  TVZV JTSBG FUNFNJā  GBZEBM‘ CJS āFZ JÎJO
LVMMBON‘āPMVSV[PIÉMEF
)BDJWBU"IDBO‘NFGFOEJNOFHà[FMCJSEFGBEBBOMBE‘OZBIV
,BSBHÚ[4BOBEBLÚUFLHFMJZPSLBÎLPNāVIVIVVy
)BDJWBUÚOEF,BSBHÚ[BSLBEBPOVLPWBM‘ZPSWB[JZFUUFTBIOFEFOΑLBSMBS

213
1": - " Ā . "  7 &  :" 3 % * . - " Ā . "

%FþFSMFOEJSNF4PSVMBS‘
4J[JOEF[BNBO[BNBOZBSE‘NBJIUJZBD‘O‘[PMVZPSNV
#JSJTJTJ[FZBSE‘NFUUJþJOEFOFIJTTFEFSTJOJ[
#JSJOFZBSE‘NFUUJþJOJ[[BNBOOFIJTTFEJZPSTVOV[

(àOàO.FTBK‘
iÿZJMJLWFUBLWB "MMBIBLBSā‘HFMNFLUFO
TBL‘ONB à[FSFZBSE‘NMBā‘O"NBHàOBIWF
EàāNBOM‘Là[FSFZBSE‘NMBāNBZ‘Ow
.ÉJEF 

,BQBO‘ā
(SVQàZFMFSJOFQBZMBā‘NMBS‘JÎJOUFāFLLàSFEJO
)FSLFTJOBLM‘OEBLBMBONFTBK‘QBZMBāNBT‘O‘JTUFZJO
,POVZMBJMHJMJWBSTBTPSVMBS‘O‘BM‘OWFDFWBQMBZ‘O
#JSTPOSBLJLPOVOVOCBāM‘þ‘O‘WFSJOWFWFEBMBā‘O

214
1": - " Ā . "  7 &  :" 3 % * . - " Ā . "

½þSFUJDJ/PUV
±PDVLMBSBQBZMBāNBWFZBSE‘NMBāNBO‘OLJāJZJOBT‘MNVUMVFEFCJMFDFþJTPSVMVS,POVZMB
JMHJMJPMBSBLLFOEJIBZBUMBS‘OEBOÚSOFLMFSWFSNFMFSJJTUFOJS1BZMBāNBWFZBSE‘NMBāNBO‘OEJ
OJNJ[EFÎPLÚOFNMJCJSZFSFTBIJQPMEVþVWVSHVMBO‘Si4J[EFOCJSJOJ[ LFOEJTJJÎJOBS[VFEJQ
JTUFEJþJāFZJ EJOLBSEFāJJÎJOEFBS[VFEJQJTUFNFEJLÎF HFSÎFLBOMBNEBJNBOFUNJāPMNB[w
#VIÉSÔ ·NÉO IBEJTJāFSJmBΑLMBO‘S,FOEJNJ[JÎJOJTUFEJþJNJ[CJSCBāBS‘Z‘ NVUMVMVþVZB
EBNBEEJCJSPCKFZJ FW BSBCB L‘ZBGFUWT FUSBG‘N‘[EBLJMFSJÎJOEFJTUFEJþJNJ[EFQBZMBāNBO‘O
UBE‘OBWBSBDBþ‘N‘[WFEBIBNVUMVPMBDBþ‘N‘[BOMBU‘M‘S

:ÚOUFNWF5FLOJLMFS
&þJUTFM0ZVO 4PSV$FWBQ

.BUFSZBM
QBLFUGBSLM‘ÎFāJUUFCJTLàWJ EFSJOCJSLBQ

&ULJOMJL
ZBā
#VFULJOMJLUFÚþSFUJDJ T‘O‘GBGBSLM‘ÎFāJUMFSEFCJTLàWJMFSMFWFCàZàLCJSLBQMBHFMJS4‘O‘G
NFWDVEVOFLBEBSTBCVTBZ‘O‘OZBS‘T‘LBEBSCJTLàWJQBLFUJOJUFNJOFEFSWFCVCJTLàWJMFSJ
T‘O‘GNFWDVEVOVOZBS‘T‘OBLBS‘ā‘LPMBSBLEBþ‘U‘S#JTLàWJMFSJOLJNJLBLBPMVLJNJUV[MVLJNJ
JTFLSFNBM‘E‘S"SE‘OEBOÚþSFUJDJ T‘O‘GUBLJÚþSFODJMFSMFTPICFUFUNFZFCBāMBS
±PDVLMBSFOTFWEJþJOJ[CJTLàWJÎFāJEJOFEJS
±PDVLMBSEBOHFMFODFWBQMBSBHÚSFCB[‘ÎPDVLMBS‘OLFOEJMFSJOFWFSJMFOCJTLàWJÎFāJEJO
EFOIPāOVUPMNBNBMBS‘EVSVNVOBEJLLBUÎFLJMJSWFÚSOFþJOi4BOBWFSJMFOUV[MVCJTLàWJPZTB
TFOLBLBPMVCJTLàWJTFWEJþJOJTÚZMàZPSTVO#VEVSVNEBOFZBQBCJMJSJ[ wEJZFTPSBS
7FSJMFODFWBQMBSBHÚSFÚþSFUJDJBΑLMBNBZBQNBZBEFWBNFEFSi(ÚSEàþàOà[HJCJCB[‘
BSLBEBāMBS‘O‘[IJÎCJTLàWJZJZFNFZFDFLLFOCB[‘MBS‘JTFTFWNFEJþJÎFāJUUFLJCJTLàWJZJZFNFL
[PSVOEBLBMBDBLwEFS
#J[MFSFOJZJTJCVCàZàLLBC‘N‘[‘PSUBZBLPZBM‘NIFSLFTFMJOEFLJQBLFUMFSJHFUJSTJOWF
LBC‘N‘[‘OJÎJOFCPāBMUBM‘N#ÚZMFMJLMFIFSLFTJTUFEJþJÎFāJUUFLJCJTLàWJEFOZJZFCJMNFOJONVU
MVMVþVOVZBāBN‘āWFQBZMBāNBO‘OHà[FMMJþJOJUBUN‘āPMTVOwEFS

215
1": - " Ā . "  7 &  :" 3 % * . - " Ā . "

%FþFSMFOEJSNF4PSVMBS‘
#JTLàWJMFSEBþ‘U‘ME‘þ‘OEBFMJOJ[FIJÎCJTLàWJWFSJMNFNJāPMTBZE‘BSLBEBāMBS‘O‘[
CJTLàWJMFSJZFSLFOLFOEJOJ[JOBT‘MIJTTFEFSEJOJ[
 4J[FEFOLHFMFOCJTLàWJTJ[JOEBNBL[FWLJOJ[FVZNBZBOÎFāJUPMTBWFTJ[JO
DBO‘O‘[EJþFSBSLBEBā‘O‘[‘OFMJOEFLJÎFāJUUFOJTUFTF POVOTJ[JOMFCJTLàWJTJOJQBZMBāNBT‘O‘
JTUFSNJZEJOJ[
 1BZMBāNBLIBZBU‘N‘[EBOFHJCJLPMBZM‘LMBSTBþMBS

(àOàO.FTBK‘
i,JN.àTMàNBO‘CJST‘L‘OU‘EBOLVSUBS‘STB CVTFCFQMF
"MMBIEBPOVL‘ZBNFUHàOàT‘L‘OU‘MBS‘O‘OCJSJOEFOLVS
UBS‘S,JNCJS.àTMàNBO‘ OLVTVSVOV ÚSUFSTF "MMBI
EBL‘ZBNFUHàOàPOV OLVTVSVOV ÚSUFSw
#VIÉSÔ .F[BMJN .àTMJN #JSS

,BQBO‘ā
(SVQàZFMFSJOFQBZMBā‘NMBS‘JÎJOUFāFLLàSFEJO
)FSLFTJOBLM‘OEBLBMBONFTBK‘QBZMBāNBT‘O‘JTUFZJO
,POVZMBJMHJMJWBSTBTPSVMBS‘O‘BM‘OWFDFWBQMBZ‘O
#JSTPOSBLJLPOVOVOCBāM‘þ‘O‘WFSJOWFWFEBMBā‘O

216
1": - " Ā . "  7 &  :" 3 % * . - " Ā . "

½þSFUJDJ/PUV
±PDVLMBSBQBZMBāNBWFZBSE‘NMBāNBO‘OLJāJZJOBT‘MNVUMVFEFCJMFDFþJTPSVMVS,POVZMB
JMHJMJPMBSBLLFOEJIBZBUMBS‘OEBOÚSOFLMFSWFSNFMFSJJTUFOJS1BZMBāNBWFZBSE‘NMBāNBO‘OEJ
OJNJ[EFÎPLÚOFNMJCJSZFSFTBIJQPMEVþVWVSHVMBO‘Si4J[EFOCJSJOJ[ LFOEJTJJÎJOBS[VFEJQ
JTUFEJþJāFZJ EJOLBSEFāJJÎJOEFBS[VFEJQJTUFNFEJLÎF HFSÎFLBOMBNEBJNBOFUNJāPMNB[w
#VIÉSÔ ·NÉO IBEJTJāFSJmBΑLMBO‘S,FOEJNJ[JÎJOJTUFEJþJNJ[CJSCBāBS‘Z‘ NVUMVMVþVZB
EBNBEEJCJSPCKFZJ FW BSBCB L‘ZBGFUWT FUSBG‘N‘[EBLJMFSJÎJOEFJTUFEJþJNJ[EFQBZMBāNBO‘O
UBE‘OBWBSBDBþ‘N‘[WFEBIBNVUMVPMBDBþ‘N‘[BOMBU‘M‘S

:ÚOUFNWF5FLOJLMFS
&þJUTFM0ZVO 4PSV$FWBQ

.BUFSZBM
WFZBQBSÎBM‘ZBQCP[

&ULJOMJL
ZBā
½þSFUJDJUBSBG‘OEBOÚODFEFOCFMJSMFOFOWFZBQBSÎBM‘LZBQCP[ÎPDVLMBSBFāJUQBSÎB
TBZ‘T‘ HFMFDFL āFLJMEF LBS‘ā‘L EBþ‘U‘M‘S ±PDVLMBS àÎ BZS‘ HSVQ IBMJOEF PUVSUVMVS 0OMBSEBO
FMMFSJOEFLJQBSÎBMBS‘CJSMFāUJSNFMFSJJTUFOJS#VSBEBLJLVSBMCJSCJSJOEFOZBSE‘NBMNBNBLU‘S
#JSTàSFTPOSBÚþSFUJDJ i±PDVLMBSCVFLTJLQBSÎBMBSOFEFOJZMFZBQCP[UBNBNMBOBNBE‘
4J[DF OF ZBQNBN‘[ HFSFLJS w EJZF TPSBS 7FSJMFO DFWBQMBSB HÚSF ÚþSFUJDJ ZÚOMFOEJSNFMFSEF
CVMVOVS ½ODFMJLMJPMBSBLBZO‘SFOLMFSEFLJZBQCP[QBSÎBMBS‘O‘CJSBSBZBUPQMBNBLZBEBJML
FUBQUBLFOBSMBS‘ZFSMFāUJSNFLHJCJ
 ½þSFUJDJ  ÎPDVLMBSB FMJNJ[EF OF LBEBS GB[MB QBSÎB PMTB EB CJS BSBZB HFMNFEJLÎF āFLMJ
UBNBNMBNBO‘ONàNLàOPMNBE‘þ‘O‘BODBLBSLBEBāMBS‘ZMBZBQCP[QBSÎBMBS‘O‘CJSMFāUJSJSMFSTF
CVOVONàNLàOPMBCJMFDFþJOJEJMFHFUJSJS1FZHBNCFS&GFOEJNJ[JOi:BS‘NIVSNBJMFCJMFPMTB
LFOEJOJ[JBUFāUFOLPSVZVOwIBEJTJTÚZMFOFSFLOFLBTUFEJMNFLJTUFOEJþJÎPDVLMBSBTPSVMVS
#FODJMJOTBOMBS‘OCJSTàSFTPOSBBSLBEBāT‘[LBME‘þ‘IBU‘SMBU‘M‘S½þSFUJDJ i1BZMBāNBO‘OIBZBU‘
N‘[‘OBT‘MLPMBZMBāU‘SE‘þ‘TJ[JOEFHÚSEàþàOà[HJCJZBQCP[VOUBNBNMBONBT‘ZMBLBO‘UMBON‘ā
PMEVwEFS

217
1": - " Ā . "  7 &  :" 3 % * . - " Ā . "

%FþFSMFOEJSNF4PSVMBS‘
:BS‘NLBMN‘āCJSZBQCP[VUBNBNMBNBLTJ[JNVUMVFUUJNJ
&þFSFLTJLLBMBOQBSÎBMBS‘BSLBEBāMBS‘O‘[TJ[JOMFQBZMBāNBTBZE‘WFCJSBSBZB
HFMNFTFZEJOJ[LFOEJOJ[JOBT‘MIJTTFEFSEJOJ[
i#JSMJLUFOLVWWFUEPþBSwTÚ[àTJ[EFOFMFSJÎBþS‘āU‘S‘ZPS

(àOàO.FTBK‘
i,JN.àTMàNBO‘CJST‘L‘OU‘EBOLVSUBS‘STB CVTFCFQMF
"MMBIEBPOVL‘ZBNFUHàOàT‘L‘OU‘MBS‘O‘OCJSJOEFOLVS
UBS‘S,JNCJS.àTMàNBO‘ OLVTVSVOV ÚSUFSTF "MMBI
EBL‘ZBNFUHàOàPOV OLVTVSVOV ÚSUFSw
#VIÉSÔ .F[BMJN .àTMJN #JSS

,BQBO‘ā
(SVQàZFMFSJOFQBZMBā‘NMBS‘JÎJOUFāFLLàSFEJO
)FSLFTJOBLM‘OEBLBMBONFTBK‘QBZMBāNBT‘O‘JTUFZJO
,POVZMBJMHJMJWBSTBTPSVMBS‘O‘BM‘OWFDFWBQMBZ‘O
#JSTPOSBLJLPOVOVOCBāM‘þ‘O‘WFSJOWFWFEBMBā‘O

218
1": - " Ā . "  7 &  :" 3 % * . - " Ā . "

1":-"Ā"3",±0ý"-.",
,B[BO‘N
:BSE‘NMBāNBWFQBZMBāNBO‘OLJāJOJONBOFWJEPZVNVOVBSUU‘SE‘þ‘O‘CJMJS

½þSFUJDJ/PUV
"āBþ‘EBWFSJMFOāJJSFULJMJCJSTFTMFPLVOVS

1":-"Ā.",ÿ45&3ÿ.
1BZMBāNBLJTUFSJNUàNSFOLMJLBMFNMFSJNJ
3FTJNZBQNBZ‘ÎPLTFWFOÎPDVLMBSMB
7FJTUFSJNIFSLFTNVUMVPMTVOCVEàOZBEB
&MMFSJNEPLVOBNB[CJMJSJN
(ÚLUFVÎBOLVāMBSB
"NBUVUVQLBME‘SBCJMJSJNCFO
:BO‘NEBZFSFEàāFOCJSJWBSTB
(à[FML‘ZBGFUMFSJN BZBLLBC‘MBS‘NPMTVOJTUFSJN
"NBTBEFDFCFOEFþJM
)FSLFTCVOMBSBTBIJQPMTVOEJMFSJN
.BTNBWJHÚLZà[à
:FNZFāJMPSNBO
5àNHà[FMMJLMFSJCJ[JNMFQBZMBāN‘ā:àDF:BSBEBOy

ĀJJSPLVOEVLUBOTPOSB ÎPDVLMBSBāJJSJOLPOVTVOVOOFPMEVþVJMFJMHJMJmLJSMFSJTPSVMVSWF
iZBSE‘NMBāNBQBZMBāNBwDFWBC‘BM‘OE‘þ‘OEBCVLPOVJMFJMHJMJHFOFMCJSCJMHJMFOEJSNFZBQ‘M‘S
1BZMBāNBO‘OWFZBSE‘NMBāNBO‘OEJOÔCJSTPSVNMVMVLPMEVþVWFIFSEVSVNEBQBZMBā‘MBCJMFDFL
Hà[FMWFJZJāFZMFSJOPMBCJMFDFþJNFTBK‘à[FSJOEFEVSVMVS

219
1": - " Ā . "  7 &  :" 3 % * . - " Ā . "

ĀJJSPLVOEVLUBOTPOSBÚþSFUJDJ ÎPDVLMBSBāJJSJOLPOVTVOVOOFPMEVþVJMFJMHJMJmLJSMFSJOJ
TPSBSWFZBSE‘NMBāNBQBZMBāNBDFWBC‘BM‘OE‘þ‘OEBCVLPOVJMFJMHJMJHFOFMCJSCJMHJMFOEJSNF
ZBQBS 1BZMBāNBO‘O WF ZBSE‘NMBāNBO‘O EJOÔ CJS TPSVNMVMVL PMEVþV WF IFS EVSVNEB
QBZMBā‘MBCJMFDFLHà[FMWFJZJāFZMFSJOPMBCJMFDFþJNFTBK‘à[FSJOEFEVSVMVS

:ÚOUFNWF5FLOJLMFS
&þJUTFM0ZVO

.BUFSZBM
3FOLMJLÉþ‘U

&ULJOMJL
ZBā
½þSFUJDJ  ÎPDVLMBSB  ZBQBCJMFDFLMFSJ ZBSE‘NMBāNB WF QBZMBā‘N ÚSOFLMFSJ JMF JMHJMJ PSUBL
CJSMJTUFPMVāUVSBDBLMBS‘O‘TÚZMFS#VLPOVJMFJMHJMJIB[‘SMBOBOÎBM‘āNBLÉþ‘E‘O‘BMBOÚþSFUJDJ
JMLÚODFLFOEJNBEEFTJOJCJSJODJNBEEFPMBSBLLÉþ‘EBZB[BSWFDàNMFOJOTPOVOBJN[BT‘O‘
BUBS ½SOFþJO ÚþSFUJDJ i0UPCàTUF IBTUB WF ZBāM‘ CJSJOF ZFS WFSFCJMJSJN  CV CFOJ NVUMV
FEFSw i)BTUBPMBOBSLBEBā‘NMBJMHJMFOJQ POVOJÎJOZBQBCJMFDFþJNCJSāFZPMVQPMNBE‘þ‘O‘
TPSBCJMJSJN#ÚZMFMJLMFBSLBEBā‘NLFOEJOJZBMO‘[IJTTFUNF[WFCVEBWSBO‘ā‘NCBOBLFOEJNJ
JZJ IJTTFUUJSJSw āFLMJOEF CJS DàNMF JMF LFOEJ NBEEFTJOJ PMVāUVSNVā PMVS 4POSB MJTUF FMEFO
FMFEPMBā‘SWFT‘SBJMFIFSLFTLFOEJJZJMJLNBEEFTJOJMJTUFZFFLMFSWFJN[BBUBS½þSFUJDJEBIB
ÚODFCFMJSUJMFOEVSVNMBS‘OUFLSBSZB[‘MBNBZBDBþ‘O‘ÎPDVLMBSBIBU‘SMBU‘S5àNÎPDVLMBSLFOEJ
NBEEFMFSJOJZB[E‘LUBOTPOSBMJTUFZJÚþSFUJDJBM‘SWFZB[‘MBOMBS‘JODFMFS#VMJTUFOJOÎPLÚOFNMJ
WFEFþFSMJPMEVþVOVTÚZMFSWFMJTUFZJT‘O‘GUBIFSLFTJOHÚSFCJMFDFþJCJSZFSFBTBS½þSFUJDJi&WFU
TFWHJMJBSLBEBāMBS CJSBOMBNEBLFOEJNJ[JOJZJMJLMJTUFTJOJPMVāUVSEVL&MCFUUFLJZBQBDBþ‘N‘[
JZJMJLMFS WF QBZMBāBCJMFDFþJNJ[ Hà[FM āFZMFS CVOMBSMB T‘O‘SM‘ EFþJM BNB TBEFDF CV MJTUF CJMF
CJ[FZBQBCJMFDFþJNJ[OFLBEBSÎPLJZJMJLPMEVþVOVCJSLF[EBIBIBU‘SMBUU‘:BāBE‘þ‘N‘[IFS
EBLJLBZ‘ OFGFTBME‘þ‘N‘[IFSBO‘QBZMBāBSBLWFZBSE‘NMBāBSBLHà[FMMFāUJSFCJMJSJ[#ÚZMFMJLMF
IFNCBāLBMBS‘O‘IFNEFLFOEJNJ[JNVUMVFUNFOJOFOLFTUJSNFZPMVOVLFāGFUNJāPMVSV[wEFS
WFEFþFSMFOEJSNFTPSVMBS‘OBHFÎFS

220
1": - " Ā . "  7 &  :" 3 % * . - " Ā . "

4+ū'  ŝū(ū5•
) •ÇOK•"Į5 '•ƍ 4•VAR•

1.

2.

3.

4.

5.

6.

7.

8.

221
1": - " Ā . "  7 &  :" 3 % * . - " Ā . "

%FþFSMFOEJSNF4PSVMBS‘
1BZMBāNBWFZBSE‘NMBāNBEFOJMEJþJOEFOFBOM‘ZPSTVOV[
ÿOTBOOFMFSJCJSCBāLBT‘ZMBQBZMBāBCJMJS
#JSLJāJZFZBSE‘NFUUJþJOJ[EFOFIJTTFEFSTJOJ[

(àOàO.FTBK‘
i,JāJ[BMJNEFPMTB NB[MVNEBPMTBEJO
LBSEFāJOFZBSE‘NFUTJO,JāJ[BMJNTFPOV
FOHFMMFTJO±àOLà[BMJNJZBQU‘þ‘JāUFO
EÚOEàSNFLPOBZBQ‘MBDBLCJSZBSE‘NE‘S,JāJ
NB[MVNJTFPOBZBSE‘NEBCVMVOTVOw
.àTMJN #JSSWF4‘MB 

,BQBO‘ā
(SVQàZFMFSJOFQBZMBā‘NMBS‘JÎJOUFāFLLàSFEJO
)FSLFTJOBLM‘OEBLBMBONFTBK‘QBZMBāNBT‘O‘JTUFZJO
,POVZMBJMHJMJWBSTBTPSVMBS‘O‘BM‘OWFDFWBQMBZ‘O
#JSTPOSBLJLPOVOVOCBāM‘þ‘O‘WFSJOWFWFEBMBā‘O

222
1": - " Ā . "  7 &  :" 3 % * . - " Ā . "

½þSFUJDJ/PUV
:BSE‘NMBāNBWFQBZMBāNBO‘OLJāJZFLB[BOE‘SBCJMFDFþJHà[FMMJLMFSFL‘TBDBEFþJOJMJS%JOÔ
BΑEBO QBZMBāNBO‘O"MMBIUBSBG‘OEBOÎPLÚOFNTFOFOCJSEBWSBO‘āPMEVþVWVSHVMBO‘SWFi#JS
NàNJO BÎCJSNàNJOJEPZVSVSTB "MMBIEBPLJNTFZJDFOOFUNFZWFMFSJZMFEPZVSBDBLU‘S:JOF
CJSNàNJO TVTV[LBMBOCJSNàNJOFCJSāFZMFSJÎJSJQTVTV[MVþVOVHJEFSJSTF "MMBIL‘ZBNFUUF
POBNJTLJMFNàIàSMFONJāMF[[FUMJCJSJÎFDFLJÎJSFDFLUJS:JOFCJSNàNJO FMCJTFZFJIUJZBD‘
PMBO CJS NàNJOJ HJZEJSJSTF  "MMBI EB POB DFOOFUJO ZFNZFāJM FMCJTFMFSJOEFO HJZEJSFDFLUJSw
5JSNJ[Ô  ,‘ZÉNF    IBEJTJ āFSJm PLVOVS #VSBEB WFSJMNFL JTUFOFO NFTBK‘O OF PMEVþV
IBLL‘OEB ÎPDVLMBSB TPSVMBS ZÚOFMUJMJS i1BZMBāNBL CJ[J LVWWFUMJ L‘MBS N‘ w EJZF TPSVMBSBL
ÎPDVLMBS‘OmLSJBM‘O‘S

:ÚOUFNWF5FLOJLMFS
½SOFL0MBZÿODFMFNF 4PSV$FWBQ "OMBU‘N

&ULJOMJL
ZBā
½þSFUJDJPHàOÎPDVLMBSB CJSPMBZIBLL‘OEBLPOVāBDBLMBS‘O‘WFPOMBS‘OZPSVNMBS‘O‘ÎPL
NFSBLFUUJþJOJTÚZMFZFSFLTÚ[FCBāMBSWFÚSOFLPMBZ‘BOMBU‘S
i4FNB .FSWF #VSDVWF;FZOFQÎPLJZJBSLBEBāU‘SMBSWFBZO‘T‘O‘GUBE‘SMBS0HàO.FSWF
ÎPLIBTUBPMVSWFEPLUPSBHJUNFL[PSVOEBLBM‘S%PLUPS.FSWFOJOIBTUBM‘þ‘O‘OUFāIJTJOJOIF
NFOLPZVMBNBZBDBþ‘O‘WFJLJàÎIBGUBCB[‘UFULJLMFSJOEFWBNFEFDFþJOJTÚZMFS0LVMEBNB
UFNBUJLEFSTJOEF.FSWFOJOUFLCBā‘OBIBMMFEFNFZFDFþJ[PSCJSLPOVJāMFONFLUFEJS.FSWF
ZB[‘M‘EBTPSVMBS‘ZBQBNBZBDBþ‘O‘EàāàOFSFLÎPLLBZH‘MBO‘SWFBþMBS0LBEBSÎPLà[àMàSLJw
½þSFUJDJCVSBEBLPOVāNBZ‘LFTFSWFIFSLFTFLPOVāNBIBLL‘UBO‘ZBDBLāFLJMEFÎPDVLMBSB
āVTPSVMBS‘ZÚOFMUJS
1FLJ ÎPDVLMBSFþFSTJ[MFS.FSWFOJOZFSJOEFPMTBZE‘O‘[OFMFSIJTTFEFSEJOJ[ 
.FSWFCVEVSVNEBOFMFSZBQBCJMJS
:BEBTJ[MFS.FSWFOJOBSLBEBāMBS‘O‘OZFSJOEFPMTBZE‘O‘[OBT‘MEBWSBO‘SE‘O‘[
.FSWFCVEVSVNEBLFOEJOJEBIBJZJIJTTFEFCJMNFLJÎJOOFMFSZBQBCJMJS
½þSFUJDJPMBZ‘BOMBUNBZBEFWBNFEFSi.FSWFOJOà[àOUàTàOFāBIJUPMBO;FZOFQBSLBEBā
MBS‘OBUFMFGPOFEJQOFZBQBCJMFDFLMFSJOJTPSBS POMBSEBLFOEJBSBMBS‘OEBCJSHÚSFWQBZMBā‘N‘
ZBQBSMBS 4FNB WF #VSDV  .FSWFZJ IFS HàO BSBZBDBL ZB EB [JZBSFUJOF HFMFDFL  ;FZOFQ JTF
BSLBEBā‘O‘O FLTJL LBME‘þ‘ NBUFNBUJL LPOVMBS‘O‘ IFS HàO POB BOMBUBDBLU‘S WF BSBEBLJ BΑþ‘
LBQBNBT‘OBZBSE‘ND‘PMBDBLU‘S0OMBS‘OCVEFTUFLMFSJTBZFTJOEF.FSWF IBTUBM‘LEÚOFNJOJLP
MBZM‘LMBBUMBU‘SWFNBUFNBUJLT‘OBW‘OEBEBEFSTMFSFLBU‘MBNBN‘āPMNBT‘OBSBþNFOBSLBEBāMBS‘O‘O

223
1": - " Ā . "  7 &  :" 3 % * . - " Ā . "

EFTUFþJTBZFTJOEFCBāBS‘M‘PMVSw½þSFUJDJJÎFSJTJOEFCVMVOVMBOIFSEVSVNWFāBSUUBNVUMBLB
QBZMBā‘NZBQ‘MBCJMFDFþJOJTÚZMFSWFBāBþ‘EBLJTPSVMBS‘ÎPDVLMBSBZÚOFMUJS

%FþFSMFOEJSNF4PSVMBS‘
"D‘MBSQBZMBāU‘LÎBB[BM‘SN‘
4J[JOEFCVPMBZBCFO[FSIBEJTFMFSIJÎCBā‘O‘[BHFMEJNJ
1BZMBāNBJMFNVUMVPMNBO‘OBSBT‘OEBCJSCBþPMBCJMJSNJ

(àOàO.FTBK‘
i)FSLJN EàOZBEB CJS.àTMàNBO‘OT‘L‘OU‘T‘O‘
HJEFSJSTF CVTFCFQMF"MMBIPOVOL‘ZBNFUHàOà
T‘L‘OU‘MBS‘OEBOCJSJOJHJEFSJSw
&CV%ÉWVE &EFC 

,BQBO‘ā
(SVQàZFMFSJOFQBZMBā‘NMBS‘JÎJOUFāFLLàSFEJO
)FSLFTJOBLM‘OEBLBMBONFTBK‘QBZMBāNBT‘O‘JTUFZJO
,POVZMBJMHJMJWBSTBTPSVMBS‘O‘BM‘OWFDFWBQMBZ‘O
#JSTPOSBLJLPOVOVOCBāM‘þ‘O‘WFSJOWFWFEBMBā‘O

224
1": - " Ā . "  7 &  :" 3 % * . - " Ā . "

1":-"Ā."7&:"3%*.-"Ā."#ÿ3-ÿ,7&
#&3"#&3-ÿýÿ4"ý-"3
,B[BO‘N
:BSE‘NMBāNBWFQBZMBāNBO‘OUPQMVNEBLBSEFāMJL CJSMJLWFCFSBCFSMJLEVZHVMBS‘O‘
HFMJāUJSEJþJOJCJMJS

½þSFUJDJ/PUV
1BZMBāNB WF ZBSE‘NMBāNBO‘O UPQMVNEB CJSMJL WF CFSBCFSMJþJ TBþMBZBO FO ÚOFNMJ
VOTVSMBSEBOCJSJPMEVþVBOMBU‘M‘S5PQMVNVOBIFOLMJCJSCJSMJLUFMJþFVMBāNBT‘OEBQBZMBāNBWF
ZBSE‘NMBāNBO‘OFTBTPMEVþVOBEJLLBUÎFLJMJS1BZMBāBSBLÎPþBMNBO‘O ZBSE‘NMBāBSBLIV[VS
CVMNBO‘OÚOFNJOFWVSHVZBQ‘M‘S

:ÚOUFNWF5FLOJLMFS
½SOFL0MBZÿODFMFNF

.BUFSZBM
½SOFLPMBZNFUOJ

&ULJOMJL
ZBā 
#VFULJOMJLCJSi½SOFL0MBZÿODFMFNFTJwEJS%JLLBUFEJMNFTJHFSFLFOIVTVTÎPDVLMBS‘O
PLVOBOIJLÉZFZJUBNBNFOBOMBE‘þ‘OEBOFNJOPMNBLU‘S#VTFCFQMFIJLÉZFOJO CJSEFOGB[MB
PLVONBT‘BOMBā‘M‘SM‘þ‘O‘BUU‘SBDBLU‘S
±PDVLMBSBFULJOMJLāÚZMFBΑLMBO‘S
i"SLBEBāMBS āJNEJ TJ[F CJS IJLÉZF PLVZBDBþ‘N  CFOJ EJLLBUMJDF EJOMFNFOJ[J JTUJZPSVN
ÎàOLà IJLÉZFZJ ZBS‘EB LFTJQ TJ[JO UBNBNMBNBO‘[‘ JTUFZFDFþJN ĀJNEJ SBIBUÎB BSLBN‘[B
ZBTMBOBM‘NWFDBOLVMBþ‘ZMBIJLÉZFZJEJOMFZFMJNw

225
1": - " Ā . "  7 &  :" 3 % * . - " Ā . "

Örnek Olay Metni


)JLÉZF,‘T‘N
0LVMEBLJT‘O‘G‘NCàZàLWFLBMBCBM‘LU‘4‘O‘GÚþSFUNFOJNJ[CJ[MFSJÎPLTFWFS T‘O‘G‘OWFCJ[
ÎPDVLMBS‘O TPSVOMBS‘ZMB FMJOEFO HFMEJþJ LBEBS JMHJMFONFZF ÎBM‘ā‘SE‘ 4‘O‘G‘N‘[‘O EB T‘L‘OU‘T‘
CJUNF[EJEPþSVTV#JSHàO'BUNBO‘OCVSOVLBOBS CJSHàO"INFUJOLBSO‘BþS‘SE‘#àUàO
CVZPþVOMVLJÎJOEFCJSEFT‘O‘G‘OL‘SUBTJZFJIUJZBÎMBS‘PMVZPSEV#JSHàOÚþSFUNFOJNJ[T‘OBW
EÚOFNJOEFPMEVþVNV[JÎJOÎPLZPþVOPMEVþVOVTÚZMFZFSFL L‘SUBTJZFBM‘āWFSJāMFSJJÎJOT‘O‘G
CBāLBO‘O‘OLFOEJTJOFZBSE‘NFUNFTJOJJTUFEJ½þSFUNFO T‘O‘GCBāLBO‘N‘[.VTUBGBZBCJSUBOF
UBIUBLBMFNJJMFUBOFEPTZBBMNBT‘JÎJOQBSBWFSEJ&SUFTJHàOTBCBIFSLFOEFOLBML‘QPLVMVO
ZPMVOV UVUUVN 4‘O‘GB HFMEJþJNEF .VTUBGBO‘O à[àOUàMà IÉMJ JMF LBSā‘MBāU‘N /F PMEVþVOV
TPSEVþVNEB  i½þSFUNFOJO CFOEFO JTUFEJLMFSJOJ BMNBZ‘ VOVUUVN /BT‘M ZBQU‘N CÚZMF CJS
IBUBZ‘ 5BNBNFOVOVUNVāVNHFSÎFLUFOwEFEJi#VLBEBSà[àMNF.VTUBGB ÚþSFUNFOJNJ[
BOMBZ‘āM‘CJSJOTBO TBOBL‘[NB[wEFEJN.VTUBGBCBā‘O‘ÚOFFþFSFLi½þSFUNFOL‘[BSEJZF
à[àMNàZPSVNLJ ÚþSFUNFOJNFLBSā‘NBIDVQEVSVNBEàāUàN CBOBWFSJMFOHÚSFWJZFSJOF
HFUJSFNFEJNEJZFà[àMàZPSVNwEFEJ

)JLÉZFOJO,‘TN‘O‘O4POV
½þSFUJDJ IJLÉZFNFUOJOJOÎPDVLMBSUBSBG‘OEBOBOMBā‘ME‘þ‘OBFNJOPMEVLUBOTPOSBPOMBSB
āVTPSVMBS‘TPSBS

.VTUBGBO‘OZFSJOEFPMTBZE‘O‘[LFOEJOJ[JOBT‘MIJTTFEFSEJOJ[WFOBT‘MEBWSBO‘SE‘O‘[
.VTUBGBO‘OT‘O‘GBSLBEBā‘PMTBZE‘O‘[ .VTUBGBZBOBT‘MEBWSBO‘SE‘O‘[
4J[DFCVIJLÉZFOJOEFWBN‘OBT‘MPMNBM‘E‘S
±PDVLMBSEBODFWBQMBSBM‘OE‘LUBOTPOSBÚþSFUJDJIJLÉZFOJOEFWBN‘O‘PLVS

)JLÉZFOJO,‘TN‘
i#V LBEBS à[àMNF .VTUBGB  ÚþSFUNFOJNJ[ BOMBZ‘āM‘ CJS JOTBO  TBOB L‘[NB[w EFEJN
.VTUBGBCBā‘O‘ÚOFFþFSFLi½þSFUNFOL‘[BSEJZFà[àMNàZPSVN ÚþSFUNFOJNFLBSā‘NBIDVQ
EVSVNBEàāUàN CBOBWFSJMFOHÚSFWJZFSJOFHFUJSFNFEJNEJZFà[àMàZPSVNwEFEJ.VTUBGBO‘O
CVMVOEVþVEVSVNV POVOIJTTFUUJLMFSJOJBOMBZBCJMJZPSEVN,FāLFPOBZBSE‘ND‘PMBCJMTFN
EJZFEàāàOàSLFOCJSEFOBLM‘NBÎBOUBNEBLJUBIUBLBMFNJHFMEJ5BIUBLBMFNJOJZFOJBMN‘ā
WFEBIBIJÎLVMMBONBN‘āU‘N0OV.VTUBGBZBWFSFCJMJSEJNBNBEPTZBNZPLUV.VTUBGBZB
CFMMJFUNFEFOT‘O‘GUBLJEJþFSBSLBEBāMBS‘N‘OZBO‘OBHJEJQEPTZBMBS‘PMVQPMNBE‘þ‘O‘TPSEVN
WFTPOVOEBJLJUBOFEPTZBCVMNBZ‘CBāBSE‘N%BIBÚþSFUNFOT‘O‘GBHFMNFNJāUJ.VTUBGBO‘O
ZBO‘OBHJEJQiÃ[àMNFOFHFSFLLBMNBE‘"MTBOBCJSUBIUBLBMFNJ JLJEFEPTZBwEFEJN.VTUBGB

226
1": - " Ā . "  7 &  :" 3 % * . - " Ā . "

ÚODFāBāL‘OM‘LMBTPOSBHàMàNTFZFSFLi4BZFOEFÚþSFUNFOFLBSā‘[PSEVSVNEBLBMNBZBDBþ‘N
½þSFUNFOJO HàWFOJOJ [FEFMFNFZFDFþJN 4BOB OBT‘M UFāFLLàS FEFDFþJNJ CJMNJZPSVNw
EFEJWFFLMFEJi1FZHBNCFSJNJ[JOCVOVOMBJMHJMJIBEJTJOJCJMJZPSNVTVO w.FSBLMBi)BZ‘S 
CJMNJZPSVN /F EFNJā 1FZHBNCFSJNJ[ w EJZF TPSEVN i4FWHJMJ 1FZHBNCFSJNJ[ āÚZMF
CVZVSNVāA)FSLJN EàOZBEB CJS.àTMàNBO‘OCJST‘L‘OU‘T‘O‘HJEFSJSTF CVTFCFQMF"MMBI
POVOL‘ZBNFUHàOàT‘L‘OU‘MBS‘OEBOCJSJOJHJEFSJS &CV%ÉWVE &EFC  4FOCBOBZBSE‘N
FUUJO CVOBLBSā‘M‘L"MMBIEBTBOBZBSE‘NFEFSJOāBMMBIwEFEJi/FLBEBSHà[FMCJSNàKEF
CV#FOTBOBZBSE‘ND‘PMVSLFO "MMBI‘OCFOJCVEFSFDFÚEàMMFOEJSFDFþJBLM‘NBHFMNFNJāUJ
EPþSVTVwEFEJNi&MCFUUFÚEàMMFOEJSFDFLUJS±àOLà"MMBI‘OCJSJTNJEFA4FUUÉSE‘S4FUUÉS 
LVTVSMBS‘ ÚSUFO EFNFLUJS "MMBI  LVMMBS‘O‘O LVTVSMBS‘O‘ ÚSUFS #J[ EF CJSCJSJNJ[F ZBSE‘ND‘
PMVSTBL3BCCJNJ[CVOEBOIPāOVUPMVSwEFEJ.VTUBGB CVNàKEFMJIBEJTMFCFOJÎPLÎBNVUMV
FUNJāUJ%JMJNEFOi"MMBI‘NTFOOFLBEBSZàDFTJO OFLBEBSāFGLBUMJTJO4FUUÉSJTNJOMFCJ[JN
LVTVSMBS‘N‘[‘ÚSUwDàNMFMFSJEÚLàMNàāUà
)JLÉZFOJOPLVONBT‘CJUUJLUFOTPOSBEFþFSMFOEJSNFTPSVMBS‘TPSVMVS

%FþFSMFOEJSNF4PSVMBS‘
.VTUBGBO‘OZFSJOEFPMTBZE‘O‘[ BSLBEBā‘O‘[‘OCVZBSE‘N‘LBSā‘T‘OEB
LFOEJOJ[JOBT‘MIJTTFEFSEJOJ[
.VTUBGBO‘OT‘O‘GBSLBEBā‘PMTBZE‘O‘[ .VTUBGBO‘OTÚZMFEJþJIBEJTJāFSJm
EVZVODBOFIJTTFEFSEJOJ[ 
i4FUUÉSwOFBOMBNBHFMNFLUFEJS

227
1": - " Ā . "  7 &  :" 3 % * . - " Ā . "

(àOàO.FTBK‘
i)FSLJN EàOZBEB CJS.àTMàNBO‘O
CJST‘L‘OU‘T‘O‘HJEFSJSTF CVTFCFQMF"MMBI
POVOL‘ZBNFUHàOàT‘L‘OU‘MBS‘OEBOCJSJOJ
HJEFSJSw
&CV%ÉWVE &EFC 

,BQBO‘ā
(SVQàZFMFSJOFQBZMBā‘NMBS‘JÎJOUFāFLLàSFEJO
)FSLFTJOBLM‘OEBLBMBONFTBK‘QBZMBāNBT‘O‘JTUFZJO
,POVZMBJMHJMJWBSTBTPSVMBS‘O‘BM‘OWFDFWBQMBZ‘O
#JSTPOSBLJLPOVOVOCBāM‘þ‘O‘WFSJOWFWFEBMBā‘O

228
1": - " Ā . "  7 &  :" 3 % * . - " Ā . "

½þSFUJDJ/PUV
"āBþ‘EBLJMFSFCFO[FSTPSVMBSTPSVMBSBLLPOVZBHJSJāZBQ‘M‘S
±PDVLMBSTJ[DFCJSCJOBLBÎLJāJJMFZBQ‘M‘S
%àOZBEBIFSJāJOJLFOEJCBā‘OBZBQBO CàUàOJIUJZBÎMBS‘O‘LFOEJHJEFSFOCJSJWBSN‘E‘S
)BOHJNFTMFLMFSZBQ‘MNB[TBIBZBU‘N‘[[PSMBā‘S 
(JCJ TPSVMBSMB ÎPDVLMBS‘O ZBSE‘NMBāNB IBLL‘OEB mLJS ZàSàUNFMFSJ TBþMBO‘S 0 HàOLà
EFSTJOLPOVTVOVOZBSE‘NMBāNBWFQBZMBāNBPMEVþVTÚZMFOJSi:BSE‘NMBāNBEFZJODFBLM‘O‘[B
OFHFMJZPS wTPSVTVTPSVMBSBLÎPDVLMBSEBOHFMFODFWBQMBSEJOMFOJS4POSBL‘TBDBCVJLJLBWSBN
BΑLMBO‘S:BSE‘NMBāNBWFQBZMBāNBO‘ONàNJOMFSJOBZ‘SUFEJDJWBT‘nBS‘OEBOPMEVþV "MMBI‘O
CJSCJSJOFZBSE‘NFEFOLVMMBS‘O‘TFWEJþJJGBEFFEJMJS

:BSE‘NMBāNBWFQBZMBāNBZBZÚOFMJLāVÚSOFLMFSWFSJMJS
%FSTJBOMBNBZBOBSLBEBā‘OBZBSE‘NFUNFL
:BQ‘MNBT‘HFSFLFOCJSāFZJGBSLFEJQZBQNBL
(FSFLUJþJOEFT‘SBT‘O‘BSLBEBā‘JMFQBZMBāNBL
"SLBEBā‘O‘OTPSVOMBS‘O‘EJOMFNFLWFPOBÎÚ[àNÚOFSJMFSJTVONBL
 4BIJQ PMEVþV JNLÉOMBS‘ ZBMO‘[ LFOEJ JÎJO EFþJM ZFSJ HFMEJþJOEF CBāLBMBS‘ JÎJO EF
LVMMBONBL

:ÚOUFNWF5FLOJLMFS
4PSV$FWBQ #FZJO'‘SU‘OBT‘ .BUFSZBM)B[‘SMBNB

.BUFSZBM
3FOLMJGPOLBSUPOMBS‘ ÎFāJUMJSFOLUFLBMFNMFS

&ULJOMJL
ZBā
½þSFUJDJ FWEFLàÎàLSFOLMJLBSUMBSIB[‘SMBZ‘QCJSZà[àOFCàZàLIBSnFSMFi"3"/*:03w
ZB[BS LBSUMBS‘OCJSZà[àEFCPāPMBDBLU‘S:BSE‘NTFWFSMJLEBWSBO‘āMBS‘à[FSJOEFLPOVāVMEVLUBO
TPOSBLBSUMBSÎPDVLMBSBEBþ‘U‘M‘S
½þSFUJDJ iĀJNEJ TJ[JOMF CJS FULJOMJL ZBQBDBþ‘[w EJZFSFL ÚODFEFO IB[‘SMBE‘þ‘ LBSUMBS‘
ΑLBSU‘S3FOLMJLBSUMBS‘OÚOZà[àOEFi"SBO‘ZPSwZB[NBLUBE‘S½þSFUJDJIFSÎPDVþBCJSLBSU
EBþ‘U‘QZBSE‘NTFWFSCJSJOEFPMNBT‘HFSFLFOFOUFNFMÚ[FMMJLMFSJZB[NBMBS‘O‘JTUFS
:FUFSMJTàSFOJOTPOVOEBÎPDVLMBSEBOLBSUMBSUPQMBO‘S UFLUFLPLVOVS#JSCJSJOFCFO[FS
ā‘LMBSFMFOJS ZFSMFSJOFZFOJTJPMVāUVSVMVS

229
1": - " Ā . "  7 &  :" 3 % * . - " Ā . "

%BIBCàZàLCJSLBSUPOBmāIB[‘SMBNBLJÎJOLVMMBO‘M‘S,BSUPOVOà[FSJÎPDVLMBS‘OJTUFEJþJ
āFLJMEFSFTJNMFOEJSJMJSWFTàTMFOJS LBSUPOBÎPDVLMBS‘OLBSUMBSBZB[E‘þ‘TFÎFOFLMFSZB[‘MBSBL
BmāIB[‘SMBO‘S%BIBTPOSBBmāUFZFSBMBOāBSUMBSEBOFOB[CJSUBOFTJOJLFOEJOEFUBā‘E‘þ‘O‘
TÚZMFZFOÎPDVLMBS‘OBmāJOBMU‘OBJN[BMBS‘O‘BUNBMBS‘JTUFOJS
"māIFSÎPDVþVOHÚSFCJMFDFþJCJSZFSFBT‘M‘S½þSFUJDJZFSZà[àOEFLÚUàMàþàBODBLJZJMJþJO
ZFOFCJMFDFþJOJ  CV BmāUFLJ Ú[FMMJLMFSJ UBā‘NBLMB T‘O‘GUBLJ ÎPDVLMBS‘O EB JZJMFS UPQMVMVþVOB
LBU‘ME‘LMBS‘O‘JGBEFFEFS

%FþFSMFOEJSNF4PSVMBS‘
1BZMBāNBWFZBSE‘NMBāNBO‘OIBZBU‘N‘[EBLJFULJTJOFEJS
1BZMBāNBWFZBSE‘NMBāNBO‘OJOTBOMBS‘OCFSBCFSZBāBNBMBS‘à[FSJOEFLJFULJMFSJ
OFMFSEJS
,POVTVQBZMBāNBWFZBSE‘NMBāNBPMBOCJSmMNJ[MFEJOJ[NJ #BITFEFSNJTJOJ[

(àOàO.FTBK‘
i.àNJO NàNJOFLBSā‘QBSÎBMBS‘CJSCJSJOF
EFTUFLPMBOCJSCJOBHJCJEJSw
5JSNJ[Ô #JSSWF4‘MB 

,BQBO‘ā
(SVQàZFMFSJOFQBZMBā‘NMBS‘JÎJOUFāFLLàSFEJO
)FSLFTJOBLM‘OEBLBMBONFTBK‘QBZMBāNBT‘O‘JTUFZJO
,POVZMBJMHJMJWBSTBTPSVMBS‘O‘BM‘OWFDFWBQMBZ‘O
#JSTPOSBLJLPOVOVOCBāM‘þ‘O‘WFSJOWFWFEBMBā‘O

230
1": - " Ā . "  7 &  :" 3 % * . - " Ā . "

½þSFUJDJ/PUV
1BZMBāNBWFZBSE‘NMBāNBO‘OUPQMVNEBCJSMJLWFCFSBCFSMJþJOBT‘MTBþMBZBCJMFDFþJOFL‘TBDB
EFþJOJMJS)à[àOMFSJOQBZMBāBSBLB[BMBCJMFDFþJWFNVUMVMVLMBS‘OUBE‘O‘OBODBLQBZMBā‘ME‘þ‘OEB
EBIBJZJΑLBCJMFDFþJBOMBU‘Si"MMBIJÎJOTJ[FT‘þ‘OBOLJNTFZFT‘þ‘OBLPMVO"MMBIJÎJOJTUFZFO
LJNTFZFWFSJO4J[JEBWFUFEFOFJDBCFUFEJO TJ[FCJSJZJMJLZBQBOBLBSā‘M‘þ‘O‘WFSJO&þFSPOVO
LBSā‘M‘þ‘O‘WFSFDFLCJSāFZCVMBNB[TBO‘[ LBSā‘M‘LUBCVMVOEVþVOV[VLBOBBUHFUJSJODFZFLBEBS
POBEVBFEJOw &CV%ÉWVE ;FLÉU  IBEJTJāFSJmBΑLMBO‘S

:ÚOUFNWF5FLOJLMFS
:BQBSBLWF:BāBZBSBL½þSFONF 4PSV$FWBQ ½SOFLMFOEJSNF

.BUFSZBM
,VSBCJZFIBNVSV QPSUBLBMLBCVþV MJNPO ÎJLPMBUBUBOFMFSJ G‘S‘O

&ULJOMJL
ZBā
½þSFUJDJ  QBTUB ZBQ‘MBDBL LVSBCJZF IBNVSVOV WF JÎFSJTJOF LBU‘MBCJMFDFL NBM[FNFMFSJ
QPSUBLBM LBCVþV  MJNPO  ÎJLPMBUB UBOFMFSJ WC  IB[‘SMBS ½þSFODJMFSJOJ UPQMBS WF CFSBCFSDF
LVSBCJZFMFSJ IB[‘SMBNBMBS‘O‘ WF UFQTJZF EJ[NFMFSJOJ TBþMBS ½þSFODJMFS LFOEJ EJMFEJLMFSJ
āFLJMMFSEFLVSBCJZFMFSJOJIB[‘SMBSMBSWFLVSBCJZFMFSG‘S‘OBWFSJMJS
,VSBCJZFMFSQJāUJþJOEFIFSLFTLFOEJIB[‘SMBE‘þ‘LVSBCJZFZJBM‘SWF[FWLJOFHÚSFTàTMFZFSFL
QBLFUMFS ½þSFODJMFS CV IB[‘SMBE‘LMBS‘ LVSBCJZFMFSJ JTUFEJLMFSJ IFSIBOHJ CJS LJāJZF IFEJZF
FEFSMFS1BTUBMBS‘OCJSBSBEBZBQ‘ME‘þ‘OEBEBIBI‘[M‘WFFþMFODFMJCJSāFLJMEFIB[‘SMBOE‘þ‘O‘
BZO‘[BNBOEBLJāJOJOLFOEJTJUBSBG‘OEBOàSFUJMFOàSàOMFSJOEBIBEFþFSMJPMEVþVOVLBWSBSMBS
#VOMBS‘QBZMBāNBO‘OJTFLJāJZJEBIBNVUMVFUUJþJOJUFDSàCFFUNJāPMVSMBS½þSFUJDJ EVSVNV
ÚSOFLMFSMFEFTUFLMFNFZFEFWBNFEFS
i±PDVLMBS  CJS FMCJTF àSFUJMJSLFO EF Jā QBZMBā‘N‘ PMBO CJS GBCSJLBEB EBIB L‘TB TàSFEF
EBIBGB[MBàSàOFMEFFEJMFCJMJS UFLCBā‘OBPMBOCJSUFS[JOJOTFCVOVJTUFTFEFCBāBSBNBZBDBþ‘
PSUBEBE‘Sw #V WF CFO[FSJ TÚZMFNMFSMF ÎPDVLMBS‘O PSUBLMBāB ZBQU‘LMBS‘ CV BLUJWJUF ÚWàMàS
±PDVLMBS‘OCJSMJLWFCFSBCFSMJþJOÚOFNJOJBOMBNBMBS‘JÎJOi#JSFMJOOFTJWBSJLJFMJOTFTJWBSw
BUBTÚ[àOàLBWSBNBMBS‘TBþMBO‘S

231
1": - " Ā . "  7 &  :" 3 % * . - " Ā . "

%FþFSMFOEJSNF4PSVMBS‘
1BTUBMBS‘BSLBEBāMBS‘O‘[MBCFSBCFSIB[‘SMBSLFOOFMFSIJTTFUUJOJ[
#JSJāJUFLCBā‘OBZBQNBLTJ[JOBT‘MFULJMFS

(àOàO.FTBK‘
i"MMBIJÎJOTJ[FT‘þ‘OBOLJNTFZFT‘þ‘OBLPMVO
"MMBIJÎJOJTUFZFOLJNTFZFWFSJO4J[JEBWFU
FEFOFJDBCFUFEJO TJ[FCJSJZJMJLZBQBOB
LBSā‘M‘þ‘O‘WFSJO&þFSPOVOLBSā‘M‘þ‘O‘WFSFDFL
CJSāFZCVMBNB[TBO‘[ LBSā‘M‘LUBCVMVOEVþVOV[V
LBOBBUHFUJSJODFZFLBEBSPOBEVBFEJOw
&CV%ÉWVE ;FLÉU 

,BQBO‘ā
(SVQàZFMFSJOFQBZMBā‘NMBS‘JÎJOUFāFLLàSFEJO
)FSLFTJOBLM‘OEBLBMBONFTBK‘QBZMBāNBT‘O‘JTUFZJO
,POVZMBJMHJMJWBSTBTPSVMBS‘O‘BM‘OWFDFWBQMBZ‘O
#JSTPOSBLJLPOVOVOCBāM‘þ‘O‘WFSJOWFWFEBMBā‘O

232
1": - " Ā . "  7 &  :" 3 % * . - " Ā . "

½þSFUJDJ/PUV
1BZMBāNB WF ZBSE‘NMBāNBO‘O UPQMVNEB CJSMJL WF CFSBCFSMJþJ OBT‘M TBþMBZBCJMFDFþJOF
L‘TBDB EFþJOJMJS )à[àOMFSJO QBZMBāBSBL B[BMBCJMFDFþJOJ WF NVUMVMVLMBS‘O UBE‘O‘O BODBL
QBZMBā‘ME‘þ‘OEBEBIBJZJΑLBCJMFDFþJBOMBU‘M‘Si"MMBIJÎJOTJ[FT‘þ‘OBOLJNTFZFT‘þ‘OBLPMVO
"MMBIJÎJOJTUFZFOLJNTFZFWFSJO4J[JEBWFUFEFOFJDBCFUFEJO TJ[FCJSJZJMJLZBQBOBLBSā‘M‘þ‘O‘
WFSJO&þFSPOVOLBSā‘M‘þ‘O‘WFSFDFLCJSāFZCVMBNB[TBO‘[ LBSā‘M‘LUBCVMVOEVþVOV[VLBOBBU
HFUJSJODFZFLBEBSPOBEVBFEJOw &CV%ÉWVE ;FLÉU  IBEJTJāFSJmBΑLMBO‘S

:ÚOUFNWF5FLOJLMFS
&þJUTFM0ZVO 4PSV$FWBQ

.BUFSZBM
ÿQ mMNDETJ UFQTJ IFEJZFQBLFUJ QBUMBN‘āN‘T‘S LBQBLM‘LBQ GPUPþSBnBS

&ULJOMJL
ZBā
½þSFUJDJV[VOCJSJQIB[‘SMBS1BUMBN‘āN‘T‘SMBS‘Bþ[‘LBQBM‘CJSLBC‘OJÎFSJTJOFLPZBSWFCV
LBC‘IFEJZFQBLFUJZMFTBSBS#VQBLFUJWFÚODFEFOÎPDVLMBSEBOUBMFQFEJMNJāCJSmMNJO$%TJOJ
UFQTJOJOJÎFSJTJOFPUVSUBSBLUFQTJZJCVJQJOVDVOBCBþMBS±PDVLMBS‘OHÚSFNFZFDFþJCJSZFSF
UFQTJZFSMFāUJSJMJSWFÎPDVLMBSJQJOEJþFSVDVFMMFSJOEFPMBDBLāFLJMEFT‘SBMBO‘S±PDVLMBSEBO
BEFUQBZMBā‘NÚSOFþJWFSNFMFSJJTUFOJSWFWFSJMFOIFSQBZMBā‘NÚSOFþJOJOBSLBT‘OEBOJQ
LFOEJMFSJOJOCVMVOEVþVPEBZBEPþSVÎFLJMJS)FSÎPDVLUBOFOB[QBZMBā‘NÚSOFþJWFSNFTJ
JTUFOJS LBCVMHÚSFOIFSQBZMBā‘NEB QBZMBā‘NZBQBOÎPDVLJQJLFOEJOFEPþSVÎFLFS±PDVLMBS
FOTPOVOEBQBUMBN‘āN‘T‘SÎBOBþ‘OBVMBā‘SMBSWFCVOPLUBEBÚþSFUJDJBΑLMBNBMBSEBCVMVONBZB
CBāMBSi(ÚSEàþàOà[HJCJTàSQSJ[FVMBāNBO‘[CVQBZMBā‘NMBSEBCVMVONBO‘[TBZFTJOEFPMEV
"ODBLCJ[MFSQBZMBā‘ND‘CJSFZMFSPMNBZBÎBM‘āU‘þ‘N‘[EBCVTàSQSJ[MFSEFOÎPLEBIBHà[FMWF
HÚSàONFZFO NàLÉGBUMBS EB FMEF FEFSJ[ #JS āFZMFSJ QBZMBāU‘þ‘N‘[EB TFWBQ LB[BO‘S‘[ CV EB
CJ[JNEBIBNVUMVPMNBN‘[‘WFIFSBOIV[VSEVZNBN‘[‘TBþMBS1BZMBāU‘LÎBIFSāFZJOUBE‘
EBIBHà[FMΑLBS#BL‘OāVJLJGPUPþSBGIFSāFZJCJ[MFSFEBIBHà[FMBOMBUN‘ZPSNV 4J[MFSCV
GPUPþSBnBS‘HÚSEàþàOà[EFOFMFSBLM‘O‘[BHFMJZPS wTPSVMBS‘O‘ZÚOFMUFSFLFULJOMJþJUBNBNMBS

233
1": - " Ā . "  7 &  :" 3 % * . - " Ā . "

%FþFSMFOEJSNF4PSVMBS‘
1BZMBāNBWFZBSE‘NMBāNBO‘OPMNBE‘þ‘CJSEàOZBOBT‘MPMVSEV
1BZMBāNBLB[BMU‘SN‘

(àOàO.FTBK‘
i"MMBIJÎJOTJ[FT‘þ‘OBOLJNTFZFT‘þ‘OBLPMVO
"MMBIJÎJOJTUFZFOLJNTFZFWFSJO4J[JEBWFU
FEFOFJDBCFUFEJO TJ[FCJSJZJMJLZBQBOB
LBSā‘M‘þ‘O‘WFSJO&þFSPOVOLBSā‘M‘þ‘O‘WFSFDFL
CJSāFZCVMBNB[TBO‘[ LBSā‘M‘LUBCVMVOEVþVOV[V
LBOBBUHFUJSJODFZFLBEBSPOBEVBFEJOw
&CV%ÉWVE ;FLÉU 

,BQBO‘ā
(SVQàZFMFSJOFQBZMBā‘NMBS‘JÎJOUFāFLLàSFEJO
)FSLFTJOBLM‘OEBLBMBONFTBK‘QBZMBāNBT‘O‘JTUFZJO
,POVZMBJMHJMJWBSTBTPSVMBS‘O‘BM‘OWFDFWBQMBZ‘O
#JSTPOSBLJLPOVOVOCBāM‘þ‘O‘WFSJOWFWFEBMBā‘O

234
1": - " Ā . "  7 &  :" 3 % * . - " Ā . "

;&,¬57&4"%","."-*"355*3*3
,B[BO‘N
;FLÉUWFTBEBLBJCBEFUJJMFQBZMBāNBWFZBSE‘NMBāNBEVZHVMBS‘O‘OHFMJāUJþJOJCJMJS

½þSFUJDJ/PUV
½ODFLJ IBGUBMBSEB ZBSE‘NMBāNB WF QBZMBāNB LBWSBNMBS‘ BOMBU‘MN‘ā  NBEEJ WF NBOFWJ
QBZMBā‘N‘O JMJāLJMFSJ HàÎMFOEJSNFTJ à[FSJOF LPOVāVMNVā  ZBSE‘NMBāNB WF QBZMBāNBO‘O
UPQMVNEBCJSMJL CFSBCFSMJLWFLBSEFāMJLEVZHVMBS‘O‘HFMJāUJSEJþJBOMBU‘MN‘āU‘S,POVL‘TBDB
UFLSBSFEJMJS
:ÚOUFNWF5FLOJLMFS
#FZJO'‘SU‘OBT‘

.BUFSZBM
4BEBLBUBā‘SFTJNMFSJ ÎBM‘āNBLÉþ‘E‘ GPUPLPQJJMFÎPþBMU‘MN‘ā

&ULJOMJL
ZBā
½þSFUJDJ FLUFZFSBMBOTBEBLBUBā‘SFTJNMFSJOJÎPDVLMBSBHÚTUFSFSFL JODFMFNFMFSJJÎJOG‘STBU
WFSJS3FTJNMFSà[FSJOFÎPDVLMBS‘OCJSNàEEFUEàāàONFTJTBþMBO‘S
#V L‘TB BSBO‘O BSE‘OEBO ÚþSFUJDJ CV SFTJNMFSEF HÚSEàLMFSJOJO TBEBLB UBā‘ PMEVþVOV 
0TNBOM‘EB TBEBLB WFSNFL JTUFZFOMFSJO CV UBāMBS‘O JÎMFSJOEFLJ PZVLMBSB QBSB LPZEVþVOV 
JIUJZBÎTBIJQMFSJOJOEFāFISJOCFMMJZFSMFSJOEFÚ[FMMJLMFDBNJMFSEFPMBOCVTBEBLBUBāMBS‘OEBO
JIUJZBÎMBS‘LBEBSNJLUBS‘BME‘LMBS‘O‘ CVHFMFOFLTBZFTJOEFJIUJZBÎTBIJCJOJJODJUNFEFOPOB
ZBSE‘NFEJMEJþJOJBOMBU‘S
4POSBT‘OEB[FLÉUWFTBEBLBEFZJODFÎPDVLMBS‘OBLM‘OBHFMFOLFMJNFMFSCJSFSCJSFSUBIUBZB
ZB[‘M‘S

ÿOGBL%BZBO‘āNB%FTUFLPMNB1BZMBāNB:BSE‘NTFWFSMJL
#Bþ‘ā 'BLJS #FODJM .VIUBÎ$JNSJ$ÚNFSU

235
1": - " Ā . "  7 &  :" 3 % * . - " Ā . "

½þSFUJDJ  ÚODF ZVLBS‘EBLJ LBWSBNMBS‘ BΑLMBS i;FLÉUw WF iTBEBLBw LBWSBNMBS‘ BOMBU‘M‘Q 
CFO[FS WF BZS‘ ZÚOMFSJ BΑL CJS āFLJMEF J[BI FEJMJS ½þSFUJDJ LBWSBNMBS‘ BāBþ‘EBLJ CJMHJMFS
EPþSVMUVTVOEBWFSJS
;FLÉU%JOJNJ[DF [FOHJOLBCVMFEJMFO.àTMàNBOMBS‘O NBMMBS‘O‘OCFMMJCJSPSBO‘O‘JCBEFU
OJZFUJZMF,VSBOEBCFMJSUJMFOJIUJZBÎTBIJQMFSJOFWFSNFTJEJSÿTMBN‘OCFāāBSU‘OEBOCJSJEJSWF
[FOHJO.àTMàNBOMBSBGBS[E‘S
'‘U‘S4BEBLBT‘ mUSF 3BNB[BOBZ‘O‘OāàLSàPMBSBLCBZSBNOBNB[‘OEBOÚODFWFSJMNFTJ
HFSFLFOTBEBLBE‘S
4BEBLBJ $BSJZF 4FWBC‘ ÚMàODF EF ZB[‘MNBZB EFWBN FEFO TBEBLBE‘S 5PQMVNVO
GBZEBMBONBT‘JÎJOZBQ‘MBOPLVMMBS IBTUBOFMFS DBNJMFS C‘SBL‘MBOFTFSMFS ZB[‘MBOLJUBQMBSWC
TBEBLBJDBSJZFEJS
ÿOGBL"MMBIBJUBBUWFJCBEFUOJZFUJZMFZBQ‘MBO ÿTMBNBWF.àTMàNBOMBSBGBZEBM‘PMBOIFS
UàSMàNBEEJIBSDBNBE‘S
4BEBLB "MMBI‘O IPāOVUMVþVOV FMEF FUNFL BNBD‘ZMB  IFS OF āFLJMEF PMVSTB PMTVO 
CBāLBMBS‘OBZBSE‘NFUNFL JZJMJLUFCVMVONBLU‘S

%JMFSTFOJ[CJSEFBZFUWFIBEJTMFSMFLPOVZBCBLBM‘N EFOJMFSFLBāBþ‘EBLJÚSOFLBZFUWF
IBEJTNFUJOMFSJUFLFSUFLFSPLVOVS
i&ZJNBOFEFOMFS,B[BOE‘LMBS‘O‘[‘OJZJMFSJOEFOWFZFSEFOTJ[JOJÎJOΑLBSE‘LMBS‘N‘[EBO
"MMBI ZPMVOEB IBSDBZ‘O ,FOEJOJ[JO HÚ[ ZVNNBEBO BM‘D‘T‘ PMNBZBDBþ‘O‘[ CBZBþ‘ āFZMFSJ
WFSNFZFLBML‘āNBZ‘OWFCJMJOLJ"MMBI IFSCBL‘NEBO[FOHJOEJS ÚWàMNFZFMBZ‘LU‘Sw #BLBSB 

i.BMMBS‘O‘"MMBIZPMVOEBIBSDBZBOMBS‘OEVSVNV ZFEJCBāBLCJUJSFOWFIFSCBāBLUBZà[
UBOF CVMVOBO CJS UPIVN HJCJEJS "MMBI EJMFEJþJOF LBU LBU WFSJS "MMBI MàUGV HFOJā PMBOE‘S 
IBLL‘ZMBCJMFOEJSi #BLBSB 
i:BS‘NIVSNBWFSNFLTVSFUJZMFEFPMTBDFIFOOFNBUFāJOEFOLPSVOVOV[0LBEBS‘O‘EB
CVMBNBZBOMBSHà[FMCJSTÚ[MFEFPMTBLFOEJMFSJOJLPSVTVOMBSw .àTMJN ;FLÉU 

i:JOFTBOB"MMBIZPMVOEBOFIBSDBZBDBLMBS‘O‘TPSVZPSMBS%FLJAÿIUJZBÎUBOBSUBLBMBO‘
"MMBI TJ[FBZFUMFSJCÚZMFBΑLM‘ZPSLJEàāàOFTJOJ[w #BLBSB 

#VIVTVTMBSJāMFOEJLUFOTPOSBi4BEBLBWFSNFLMFNBMFLTJMNF[w 5JSNJ[Ô #JSSWF4‘MB  


IBEJTJ āFSJmOJO PMEVþV ÎBM‘āNB LÉþ‘E‘ WFSJMFSFL  ÎPDVLMBS‘O PLMBS‘ UBLJQ FEFSFL IBEJTJ
CVMNBMBS‘TBþMBO‘S

236
1": - " Ā . "  7 &  :" 3 % * . - " Ā . "

ÃTLàEBS %PþBOD‘MBS 
ÿNSBIPS$BNJJOEFLJ
TBEBLBUBā‘

237
զ +(ɘ, ƻ*ǔȢ(#(

ZEKÂT VE SADAKA

0LMBS‘UBLJQFEFSFLHJ[MJPMBO #VMEVþVOÚþàEàCVSBZBZB[
1FZHBNCFSÚþàEàOFVMBāNBL ..............................................
JTUFSNJTJOJ[
..............................................
#"Ā-"
..............................................

NF[

TB
FL
NFL

LB

MF

NBM

EB

WFS
TJM

238
1": - " Ā . "  7 &  :" 3 % * . - " Ā . "

%FþFSMFOEJSNF4PSVMBS‘
%àOZBO‘OV[BLCJSàMLFTJOEFCJSEFQSFNZBIVUTFMCBTL‘O‘PMEVWFPLVMVOV[EBCJS
ZBSE‘NPSHBOJ[BTZPOVZBQ‘MBDBL OFMFSZBQBCJMJSTJOJ[
i;FLÉUwWFiTBEBLBwLBWSBNMBS‘BSBT‘OEBLJGBSL‘BOMBUBCJMJSNJTJOJ[
;FLÉUWFTBEBLBO‘OEJþFSJCBEFUMFSEFOGBSL‘OFEJS
4J[DF[FLÉUWFTBEBLBJCBEFUMFSJOJOGBZEBT‘OFMFSEJS

(àOàO.FTBK‘
i#JS.àTMàNBO‘OEJLUJþJBþBÎUBO
WFZBFLUJþJFLJOEFOJOTBO IBZWBO
WFLVāMBS‘OZFEJLMFSJāFZMFSP.àTMà
NBOJÎJOCJSFSTBEBLBE‘Sw
.àTMJN .àTBLBU 

,BQBO‘ā
(SVQàZFMFSJOFQBZMBā‘NMBS‘JÎJOUFāFLLàSFEJO
)FSLFTJOBLM‘OEBLBMBONFTBK‘QBZMBāNBT‘O‘JTUFZJO
,POVZMBJMHJMJWBSTBTPSVMBS‘O‘BM‘OWFDFWBQMBZ‘O
#JSTPOSBLJLPOVOVOCBāM‘þ‘O‘WFSJOWFWFEBMBā‘O

239
1": - " Ā . "  7 &  :" 3 % * . - " Ā . "

1":-"Ā.":"%"ÿ3½;&-;"."/-"3
#":3".-"37&.Ã#"3&,(&$&-&3
,B[BO‘N
4FWJOÎMFSJOQBZMBā‘MNBT‘BE‘OBEJOÔCBZSBNMBS NàCBSFLHàOWFHFDFMFSJOCJSG‘STBU
PMEVþVOVLBWSBS

½þSFUJDJ/PUV
#BZSBNMBS‘O NàNJOMFS JÎJO TFWJOÎ WF QBZMBāNB HàOMFSJ PMEVþV SBNB[BO BZ‘OEB PSVÎ
UVUBSBL"MMBI‘OFNSJOJZFSJOFHFUJSFO ,VSCBO#BZSBN‘OEBLVSCBOLFTFSFL"MMBIZPMVOEB
GFEBLÉSM‘L HÚTUFSFO  CBZSBN OBNB[MBS‘O‘ UPQMVDB L‘MBO .àTMàNBOMBS‘O HÚSFWMFSJOJ ZBQN‘ā
PMNBO‘OTFWJOÎWFNVUMVMVþVOVZBāBE‘LMBS‘BOMBU‘M‘S#BZSBNMBSEBCàZàLMFSJO[JZBSFUFEJMEJþJ 
EBSH‘OMBS‘OCBS‘āU‘S‘ME‘þ‘ I‘T‘NWFBLSBCBMBSBSBT‘OEBLBSā‘M‘LM‘IFEJZFMFāNFMFSJOEPTUMVLMBS‘
QFLJāUJSEJþJOF  CV WBLJUMFSJO "MMBI‘O NàNJO LVMMBS‘OB J[[FU WF JLSBNEB CVMVOEVþV Ú[FM
[BNBOMBSPMEVþVOBEJLLBUÎFLJMJS
5‘QL‘CBZSBNMBSHJCJNàCBSFLHFDFMFSJOEF"MMBI‘ONàNJOLVMMBS‘OBCJSFS[JZBGFUWBLUJ
PMEVþV CVHàOMFSJO"MMBI‘OS‘[BT‘OBVZHVOEBWSBO‘āMBSMBEFþFSMFOEJSJMNFTJHFSFLUJþJ CVÚ[FM
WBLJUMFSJOJOTBOMBS‘OQBZMBāNBWFZBSE‘NMBāNBMBS‘JÎJOCJSFSJNLÉOWFG‘STBUPMEVþVBOMBU‘M‘S

:ÚOUFNWF5FLOJLMFS
&þJUTFM0ZVO

.BUFSZBM
3FOLMJGPOLBSUPOMBS‘ SFOLMJLBMFNMFS LàÎàL[BSnBS

240
1": - " Ā . "  7 &  :" 3 % * . - " Ā . "

&ULJOMJL
ZBā
½þSFUJDJ  i±FNCFS %ÚOTàOw PZVOVOB EBJS TPSVMBS‘ ÚODFEFO IB[‘SMBZ‘Q LàÎàL [BSnBSB
LPZBS.àCBSFLHFDFMFSWFCBZSBNMBSBEBJSÎPDVLMBS‘CJMHJMFOEJSEJLUFOTPOSBFULJOMJþJCBāMBU‘S

,BSUMBSB:B[‘MBDBL4PSV½SOFLMFSJĀÚZMFEJS ½þSFUJDJÎPDVLTBZ‘T‘OBWFT‘O‘G‘OCJMHJ
EVSVNVOBHÚSFLBSUTBZ‘T‘O‘BSUU‘SBCJMJS
,BEJS(FDFTJOJOGB[JMFUJOFEJS
$VNBHàOàOJÎJOÚOFNMJEJS
,BOEJMMFSEFOUBOFTJOJTBZBSN‘T‘O
3BNB[BO#BZSBN‘LBÎHàOEàS
)JDSJUBLWJNFHÚSF,VSCBO#BZSBN‘IBOHJBZEBE‘S
3BNB[BOBZ‘OEBNàNJOMFSJOCFSBCFSDFZBQU‘þ‘JCBEFUOFEJS
#BZSBNMBS‘OUPQMVNBLBUL‘T‘OFEJS
%JOÔHàOWFHFDFMFSEFOFMFSZBQ‘MBCJMJS
4‘O‘G‘OEVSVNVOBHÚSFÎPDVLMBS‘OZBS‘T‘JMFCJSÎFNCFSPMVāUVSVMVS#VÎFNCFSHÚOàMMà
PMBOMBSEBOTFÎJMFCJMFDFþJHJCJLVSBEBÎFLJMFCJMJS
½þSFUJDJ ÎPDVLTBZ‘T‘LBEBSIB[‘SMBE‘þ‘TPSVMBS‘LàÎàL[BSnBS‘OJÎJOFLPZBSBLÎFNCFSJ
PMVāUVSBOÎPDVLMBS‘OZBLBMBS‘OBBTBSJþOFMFS
"SE‘OEBOT‘O‘GUBOCJSÎPDVLTFÎJMJSWFÎFNCFSJOJÎJOFBM‘OBSBLHÚ[MFSJLBQBU‘M‘S±FNCFSF
BM‘OBOÎPDVþVOi±FNCFSEÚOTàOwLPNVUVZMBFUSBG‘OEBLJÎPDVLMBSEÚONFZFCBāMBSWFFO
GB[MBTOJÎJOEFHÚ[MFSJLBQBM‘PMBOÎPDVþVOi±FNCFSEVSTVOwLPNVUVJMFÎFNCFSEFLJ
ÎPDVLMBS EVSVS ±FNCFSJO PSUBT‘OEB EVSVQ LPNVU WFSFO ÎPDVL ÎFNCFS EVSEVþVOEB
UBN LBSā‘T‘OEB EVSBO ÎPDVþVO ZBLBT‘OEBLJ [BSG‘ BM‘Q JÎJOEFLJ TPSVZV T‘O‘GUBO EJMFEJþJ CJS
BSLBEBā‘OBTPSBS4PSVTPSVMBOÎPDVLEPþSVDFWBQWFSFCJMJSTFÎFNCFSJOPSUBT‘OBHFÎFSÿML
TPSVZVTPSBOÎPDVLJTF[BSG‘OEBOTPSVBME‘þ‘BSLBEBā‘O‘OZFSJOFHFÎJQÎFNCFSFEÉIJMPMVS
ĀBZFUTPSVTPSEVþVÎPDVLTPSVZVCJMFNF[TFIFNTPSVZVTPSBOIFNEFLFOEJTJPZVOE‘ā‘
LBMBCJMJS#VTPSVOVODFWBC‘O‘ÚþSFUJDJWFSJS
±FNCFS EÚOTàO LPNVUVOV WFSFDFL IFS ÎPDVþVO  TPSVTV TPSVMNBZBO BSLBEBāMBS‘O‘
CVMNBZBÎBM‘āNBT‘WFTPSVZBEPþSVDFWBQWFSFCJMFDFLPMBOMBS‘UFTQJUFUNFMFSJFTBTU‘S
UVSTPOVOEBT‘O‘GUBLJÎPDVLMBSEBOÎFNCFSFLJāJEÉIJMPMVSTBT‘O‘G BLTJIBMEFÎFNCFS
PZVOV LB[BO‘S %JO  "IMBL WF %FþFSMFS ½þSFUJNJ ÿÎJO &þJUTFM 0ZVOMBS  .BINVU ;FOHJO
/VSTFM"STMBO4FWJN6ÎBS4FMNB"ZEPþEV %&.:BZ  ÿTUBOCVM T

241
1": - " Ā . "  7 &  :" 3 % * . - " Ā . "

%FþFSMFOEJSNF4PSVMBS‘
%JOÔHàOWFHFDFMFSEFCFSBCFSZBQBCJMFDFþJNJ[āFZMFSWBSN‘E‘S 7BSTBTFODFOFMFSEJS
%JOÔHàOWFHFDFMFSJÎJOEFFOÎPLTFWEJþJOIBOHJTJEJS
%JOÔHàOWFHFDFMFSLJNUBSBG‘OEBOCFMJSMFONJāUJS

(àOàO.FTBK‘
i"SFGFWF,VSCBO#BZSBN‘HàOMFSJCJ[
.àTMàNBOMBS‘OCBZSBNHàOMFSJEJS PHàOMFS
ZFNFJÎNFHàOàEàSw
/FTÉÔ .FOÉTJLàM)BD 

,BQBO‘ā
(SVQàZFMFSJOFQBZMBā‘NMBS‘JÎJOUFāFLLàSFEJO
)FSLFTJOBLM‘OEBLBMBONFTBK‘QBZMBāNBT‘O‘JTUFZJO
,POVZMBJMHJMJWBSTBTPSVMBS‘O‘BM‘OWFDFWBQMBZ‘O
#JSTPOSBLJLPOVOVOCBāM‘þ‘O‘WFSJOWFWFEBMBā‘O

242
1": - " Ā . "  7 &  :" 3 % * . - " Ā . "

½þSFUJDJ/PUV
#BZSBNMBS‘OEJOJNJ[EFLJWFLàMUàSàNà[EFLJÚOFNJOFWVSHVZBQ‘M‘S"SE‘OEBO1FZHBNCFS
&GFOEJNJ[[BNBO‘OEBCBZSBNMBS‘O NàCBSFLHàOWFHFDFMFSJOOBT‘MLVUMBOE‘þ‘L‘TBDBBOMBU‘M‘S
#BZSBNHàOMFSJOEF)[1FZHBNCFSJOTBEBLBWFSJMNFTJOJÚOFSEJþJ Hà[FMWFUFNJ[HJZJOEJþJ 
FUSBG‘OEBLJJOTBOMBSMBTFMBNMBāU‘þ‘ POMBSBJLSBNMBSEBCVMVOEVþVWFOFāFJMFCBZSBNMBāU‘þ‘
BOMBU‘M‘S$VNBHàOMFSJOJOÚOFNJà[FSJOEFEVSVMBSBLCVHàOàONàNJOMFSJOCBZSBN‘PMEVþV
BOMBU‘M‘S.àCBSFLHàOWFHFDFMFSFL‘TBDBEFþJOJMJS ,BEJS(FDFTJà[FSJOEFEVSVMVS ,VSBO‘
,FSJNEFCVHFDFJMFBMBLBM‘CJSTVSFPMEVþVOEBOCBITFEJMJSWFL‘TBDB,BEJSTVSFTJBΑLMBO‘S
#V WF CFO[FSJ NàCBSFL HFDFMFSJO L‘SH‘OMBS‘O CBS‘āNBT‘  ZBāM‘MBS‘O [JZBSFU FEJMNFTJ WT JÎJO
Hà[FMCJSG‘STBUPMBDBþ‘WVSHVMBO‘S

:ÚOUFNWF5FLOJLMFS
1FSGPSNBOT(ÚSFWJ "OMBU‘N

.BUFSZBM
4àTFāZBMBS‘ IFEJZFMJLFāZBMBS CBZSBNBÚ[FMUBUM‘MBS

&ULJOMJL
ZBā
½þSFUJDJQBZMBā‘MBDBLPMBOÚ[FM[BNBO‘OÚþSFODJMFSUBSBG‘OEBOGBSL‘OEBM‘þ‘O‘OTBþMBONBT‘O‘
IFEFnFSCVOVOJÎJO
0HàOJÎJOÚ[FMGBSLM‘ZJZFDFLMFSUFNJOFEJMJS BāVSF JSNJLUBUM‘T‘WT
½[FMHàOLBOEJMHFDFTJJTFÎPDVLMBS‘OIPāMBOE‘þ‘NFOàMFSIB[‘SMBU‘M‘S
½þSFUJDJOJOÚODFEFOJ[JOMFSJBM‘ON‘āBSLBEBāMBS‘O‘O[JZBSFUÎJPMBSBLLBU‘M‘N‘TBþMBO‘SWF
HFMFO[JZBSFUÎJMFSEFOZBOMBS‘OEBVGBLIFEJZFMFSHFUJSNFMFSJJTUFOJS
±PDVLMBS‘OLFOEJMFSJOJÚ[FMIJTTFUNFMFSJOJTBþMBNBLJÎJOPOMBSBZFOJL‘ZBGFUMFSBM‘O‘S
&WPSUBN‘TàTMFOJSFOB[‘OEBOCJSPEBO‘OHàOàOBOMBNWFÚOFNJOFHÚSFEJ[BZOFEJMNFTJ
TBþMBO‘S
½ODFEFOCFMJSMFOFOEVBMBSÎPDVLMBSMBCFSBCFSUPQMVDBZBQ‘M‘S
±PDVLMBS‘OIPāVOBHJEFCJMFDFLJMBIJMFSPOMBS‘OEBLBU‘M‘N‘TBþMBOBSBLTÚZMFOJS

243
1": - " Ā . "  7 &  :" 3 % * . - " Ā . "

%FþFSMFOEJSNF4PSVMBS‘
%JOÔHàOWFHFDFMFSJOÚOFNJOFEJS
#VÚ[FMHàOMFSEFZBQ‘MBDBLJCBEFUMFSWBSN‘E‘S

(àOàO.FTBK‘
i,BEJS(FDFTJOJ LJNTFWBC‘OBJOBO‘QPOV
LB[BONBLàNJEJZMFJIZBFEFSTF HFÎNJā
HàOBIMBS‘BGGFEJMJSw
5JSNJ[Ô 4BWN 

,BQBO‘ā
(SVQàZFMFSJOFQBZMBā‘NMBS‘JÎJOUFāFLLàSFEJO
)FSLFTJOBLM‘OEBLBMBONFTBK‘QBZMBāNBT‘O‘JTUFZJO
,POVZMBJMHJMJWBSTBTPSVMBS‘O‘BM‘OWFDFWBQMBZ‘O
#JSTPOSBLJLPOVOVOCBāM‘þ‘O‘WFSJOWFWFEBMBā‘O

244
19
ÿ-&5ÿĀÿ.7&ÿ-&5ÿĀÿ.&/(&--&3ÿ:-&#"Ā&5.&

4FMBNMBāNBO‘OJMFUJāJNEFLJFULJOSPMàOàCJMJS
5BUM‘EJMMJWFHàMFSZà[MàPMNBO‘OLB[BOE‘SE‘LMBS‘O‘CJMJS
1FZHBNCFSJNJ[JOCFEFOEJMJOJOBT‘MLVMMBOE‘þ‘O‘CJMJS
½GLF L‘TLBOÎM‘L à[àOUàHJCJEVZHVMBS‘OJOTBOJEVZHVMBSPMEVþVOVCJMJS
½GLFIBMJOEFLFOEJOJOBT‘MLPOUSPMFEFDFþJOJCJMJS
Ã[àOUàIBMJOEFLFOEJOJOBT‘MUFTLJOFEFDFþJOJCJMJS
#BāLBMBS‘O‘OEVZHVMBS‘O‘BOMBNBT‘WFTBZH‘EVZNBT‘HFSFLUJþJOJCJMJS
ÿOTBOMBSMBPMBOJMFUJāJNEFBEBC‘NVBāFSFULVSBMMBS‘OBVZNBT‘HFSFLUJþJOJCJMJS
ÿ-&5ÿĀÿ.7&ÿ-&5ÿĀÿ.&/(&--&3ÿ:-&#"Ā&5.&

4&-".-"Ā."/*/½/&.ÿ
,B[BO‘N
4FMBNMBāNBO‘OJMFUJāJNEFLJFULJOSPMàOàCJMJS
1FZHBNCFSJNJ[JOCFEFOEJMJOJOBT‘MLVMMBOE‘þ‘O‘CJMJS

½þSFUJDJ/PUV
.àNJOMFSJOCJSCJSMFSJJMFLBSā‘MBāU‘LMBS‘OEBiTFMBNVOBMFZLàNwEFNFMFSJOJOi"MMBITFOJ
FTFOMJþF LBWVāUVSTVOw BOMBN‘OB HFMEJþJ JGBEF FEJMJS #V TFMBNMBāNB VTVMàOàO LBSā‘M‘LM‘
EVBZ‘JÎJOEFCBS‘OE‘SE‘þ‘ i"MMBI‘OTFMBN‘ SBINFUJ CFSFLFUJTFOJOà[FSJOFPMTVOwEJZFSFL
NVIBUBCBEVBFEJMEJþJTÚZMFOJS
4FMBN WFSNFOJO NàNJOMFSJO CJSCJSMFSJOF FO Hà[FM EJMFL WF UFNFOOJMFSJOJ TVONB
āFLJMMFSJOEFOPMEVþVWVSHVMBOE‘LUBOTPOSBTFMBNWFSJMFOCJSLJāJOJOPTFMBNBEBIBHà[FMJZMF
WFZB FO B[‘OEBO BZO‘T‘ZMB LBSā‘M‘L WFSNFTJOJO ,VSBOEB GBS[ L‘M‘OE‘þ‘ āV BZFUJ LFSJNFZMF
BOMBU‘M‘S
i#JSTFMBNMBTFMBNMBOE‘þ‘O‘[EB TJ[POEBOEBIBHà[FMJZMFTFMBNWFSJOZBEBBZO‘ZMBLBSā‘M‘L
WFSJOĀàQIFTJ[ "MMBI DD IFSāFZJOIFTBC‘O‘UBNPMBSBLZBQBOE‘Sw /JTÉ 

:ÚOUFNWF5FLOJLMFS
"OMBU‘N 4PSV$FWBQ 3PM0ZOBNB

.BUFSZBM
)BSFLFUMJCJSNà[JL

&ULJOMJL
ZBā
½þSFUJDJ  ÎPDVLMBSB FULJOMJL ZBQBDBLMBS‘O‘ TÚZMFZFSFL POMBS‘ JLJ HSVCB BZ‘S‘S :à[MFSJ
CJSCJSJOFEÚOàL BSBMBS‘OEBZàSàNFNFTBGFTJPMBDBLāFLJMEFPOMBS‘LPOVNMBOE‘SE‘LUBOTPOSB
IBSFLFUMJCJSNà[JLFāMJþJOEFFULJOMJþJCBāMBU‘S

246
ÿ-&5ÿĀÿ.7&ÿ-&5ÿĀÿ.&/(&--&3ÿ:-&#"Ā&5.&

i4J[MFS ZPMEB ZàSàZFO JOTBOMBST‘O‘[ WF CJSCJSJOJ[J UBO‘N‘ZPSTVOV[ #V āFLJMEF


ZàSàNFOJ[JJTUJZPSVNwEFSWFÎPDVLMBSNà[JLFāMJþJOEFCJSCJSMFSJOJUBO‘N‘ZPSNVāHJCJ
ZàSàSMFS½þSFUJDJCJSTàSFTPOSBNà[JþJEVSEVSVSWFHSVQMBS‘OCJSCJSJOJUBO‘E‘þ‘O‘BNB
UBO‘NB[M‘LUBO HFMJZPSNVā HJCJ EBWSBONBMBS‘O‘ JTUFZFSFL Nà[JLMF CFSBCFS ÎPDVLMBS‘O
ZFOJEFOZàSàNFMFSJOJTÚZMFS#JSTàSFTPOSBÚþSFUJDJNà[JþJEVSEVSVSWFIFSJLJHSVCVO
EBLBSā‘MBāU‘LMBS‘OEBCJSCJSJOJUBO‘ZBOLJāJMFSHJCJIBSFLFUFUNFMFSJOJJTUFZFSFLNà[JLMF
CFSBCFSCVZFOJLPNVUVWFSJSWFÎPDVLMBSEBOZàSàNFMFSJOJJTUFS#JSTàSFTPOSBÚþSFUJDJ
Nà[JþJEVSEVSVSWFÎPDVLMBSBUFLUFLBāBþ‘EBLJTPSVMBS‘ZÚOFMUJS

#JSCJSJOJ[JUBO‘NBEBOZàSàEàþàOà[EFOFMFSIJTTFUUJOJ[
4FOBSLBEBā‘O‘UBO‘NBOBSBþNFOTFMBNWFSNFEFOZBO‘OEBOHFÎJODFOFMFSIJTTFUUJO
4FO BSLBEBā‘OIJÎTFMBNFUNFEFOZBO‘OEBOHFÎJODFOFMFSIJTTFUUJO
#JSCJSJOJ[JUBO‘ZBSBLTFMBNMBā‘QZàSàEàþàOà[EFOFMFSIJTTFUUJOJ[
½þSFUJDJ  CV TPSVMBS‘ ÎPDVLMBS‘O IFQTJOF ZÚOFMUUJLUFO TPOSB TFMBNMBāNBO‘O JOTBO
JMJāLJMFSJOEFLJPMVNMVFULJTJOEFOCBITFEFSWFiÿNBOFUNFEJLÎFDFOOFUFHJSFNF[TJOJ[ 
CJSCJSJOJ[J TFWNFEJLÎF EF JNBO FUNJā TBZ‘MNB[T‘O‘[ 4J[F CJSCJSJOJ[J TFWFDFL CJS āFZ
ÚþSFUFZJNNJ "SBO‘[EBTFMBN‘ZBZ‘OwIBEJTJOJÎPDVLMBSMBQBZMBā‘SWFIBEJTà[FSJOEF
CJSTàSFTPICFUFEJMJS

%BIBTPOSBÚþSFUJDJ1FZHBNCFS&GFOEJNJ[JOLFOEJTJOFTFMBNWFSJMEJþJOEFBZO‘ZMB
ZBEBEBIBHà[FMJZMFLBSā‘M‘LWFSEJþJOJ LFOEJTJOFCJSJTJTFTMFOEJþJOEFCàUàOWàDVEVZMB
EÚOEàþàOà CJSJTJZMFUPLBMBāU‘þ‘OEBLBSā‘UBSBGFMJOJÎFLNFEFOFMJOJÎFLNFEJþJOJTÚZMFS
WF i1FZHBNCFSJNJ[ JOTBOMBSMB JMFUJāJN LVSBSLFO TBEFDF TÚ[MF EFþJM EBWSBO‘āMBS‘ZMB EB
HÚOàMLB[BON‘āWFCJ[MFSFÚSOFLPMNVāUVSwEFS

#V BΑLMBNBEBO TPOSB ÎPDVLMBS‘ JLJāFSMJ FāMFāUJSJQ TFMBNMBāNBMBS‘O‘  CJSCJSMFSJOF


TFTMFOJQDFWBQWFSNFMFSJOJJTUFS

%FþFSMFOEJSNF4PSVMBS‘
)[1FZHBNCFSTFMBNMBāNBJMFJMHJMJOFCVZVSVZPS
4FMBNMBāNBO‘OGBZEBMBS‘OFMFSEJS
ÿOTBOMBSMBJMFUJāJNLVSBSLFO)[1FZHBNCFSJOIBOHJEBWSBO‘āMBS‘O‘ÚSOFLBMNBM‘Z‘[

247
ÿ-&5ÿĀÿ.7&ÿ-&5ÿĀÿ.&/(&--&3ÿ:-&#"Ā&5.&

(àOàO.FTBK‘
i4J[ JNBOFUNFEJLÎFDFOOFUFHJSFNF[TJOJ[
CJSCJSJOJ[JTFWNFEJLÎFEFJNBOFUNJā
PMBNB[T‘O‘[:BQU‘þ‘O‘[[BNBOCJSCJSJOJ[J
TFWFDFþJOJ[CJSāFZTÚZMFZFZJNNJ "SBO‘[EB
TFMBN‘ZBZ‘O‘[w
.àTMJN ÿNBO 

,BQBO‘ā
(SVQàZFMFSJOFQBZMBā‘NMBS‘JÎJOUFāFLLàSFEJO
)FSLFTJOBLM‘OEBLBMBONFTBK‘QBZMBāNBT‘O‘JTUFZJO
,POVZMBJMHJMJWBSTBTPSVMBS‘O‘BM‘OWFDFWBQMBZ‘O
#JSTPOSBLJLPOVOVOCBāM‘þ‘O‘WFSJOWFWFEBMBā‘O

248
ÿ-&5ÿĀÿ.7&ÿ-&5ÿĀÿ.&/(&--&3ÿ:-&#"Ā&5.&

½þSFUJDJ/PUV
4FMBNLFMJNFTJOJOLÚLàOàO"SBQÎBPMEVþV TBþWFTBþMBNPMNB HàWFOEFPMNB CBS‘ā‘L
PMNB  TBþM‘L  TFMBNFU  CBS‘ā  HàWFOMJL HJCJ BOMBNMBSB HFMEJþJ BOMBU‘M‘S 5FTMJN  .àTMàNBO 
TFMBNFUHJCJCVLÚLUFOHFMFOLFMJNFMFSJOBOMBNMBS‘à[FSJOEFEVSVMVS.àNJOMFSJOCJSCJSMFSJ
JMF LBSā‘MBāU‘LMBS‘OEB iTFMBNVO BMFZLàNw EFNFMFSJOJO i"MMBI TFOJ FTFOMJþF LBWVāUVSTVOw
BOMBN‘OBHFMEJþJJGBEFFEJMJS4FMBNWFSNFOJOJMFUJāJNJOCBāMBOH‘D‘PMEVþVWF1FZHBNCFSJNJ[JO
TàOOFUJPMEVþVWVSHVMBOE‘LUBOTPOSBTFMBNWFSJMFOCJSLJāJOJOPTFMBNBEBIBHà[FMJZMFWFZB
FOB[‘OEBOBZO‘T‘ZMBLBSā‘M‘LWFSNFTJOJO,VSBOEBGBS[L‘M‘OE‘þ‘āVBZFUJLFSJNFJMFBOMBU‘M‘S
i#JSTFMBNMBTFMBNMBOE‘þ‘O‘[EBTJ[POEBOEBIBHà[FMJZMFTFMBNWFSJOZBEBBZO‘ZMBLBSā‘M‘L
WFSJOĀàQIFTJ["MMBI DD IFSāFZJOIFTBC‘O‘UBNPMBSBLZBQBOE‘Sw /JTÉ

:ÚOUFNWF5FLOJLMFS
"OMBU‘N 4PSV$FWBQ

.BUFSZBM
3FOLMJLÉþ‘UMBS [BSG

&ULJOMJL
ZBā
½þSFUJDJ ÚODFEFOIB[‘SMBE‘þ‘5àSLÎFWF"SBQÎBIBSJÎ FOB[GBSLM‘EJMEFTFMBNWFSNF
āFLJMMFSJOJSFOLMJLÉþ‘UMBSBZB[‘Q[BSG‘OJÎJOEFÎPDVLMBSBWFSJS;BSnBSBΑMNBEBOÚODFÚþSFUJDJ
CB[‘TPSVMBSTPSBS
ÿMLLF[LBSā‘MBāU‘þ‘O‘[CJSJZMFLPOVāBDBþ‘O‘[[BNBOTÚ[FOBT‘MCBāMBST‘O‘[ 
)FSàMLFEFCVāFLJMEFNJCBāMBO‘S 
5àN.àTMàNBOMBSBSBT‘OEBPSUBLCJSTFMBNMBāNBEJMJWBSN‘E‘S
#VTPSVMBSMBÎPDVLMBSCJSB[EàāàONFZFTFWLFEJMEJLUFOTPOSB[BSnBS‘OBΑMNBT‘JTUFOJS
WFZB[‘M‘PMBOLFMJNFMFSJOOFBOMBNBHFMEJþJOJUBINJOFUNFMFSJTÚZMFOJS±FāJUMJmLJSMFSPSUBZB
ΑLBS
%BIB TPOSB ÚþSFUJDJ  CVOMBS‘O IBOHJ EJMF BJU PMEVþVOV BΑLMBS WF IFQTJOJO TFMBNMBāNB
JGBEFTJPMEVþVOVTÚZMFS4FMBNWFSNFOJOIFSLàMUàSEFPMEVþVGBLBUCVOMBS‘OGBSLM‘āFLJMMFSEF
EJMF HFUJSJMFCJMFDFþJ TÚZMFOJS #VOVO à[FSJOF CJSB[ LPOVāVMEVLUBO TPOSB IBOHJ TFMBN
JGBEFTJOJOIPāMBS‘OBHJUUJþJTPSVMVS
.àTMàNBOMBS‘O CJSCJSMFSJZMF LBSā‘MBāU‘LMBS‘OEB TFMBN WFSNFEFO EBIB ÚUF CJS EJM
LVMMBOE‘LMBS‘ WF EàOZBO‘O OFSFTJOF HJEJMJSTF HJEJMTJO CV EJMJO PSUBL PMEVþV BOMBU‘M‘S #V
TFMBNMBāNB VTVMàOàO LBSā‘M‘LM‘ EVBZ‘ EB JÎFSEJþJ WF 1FZHBNCFS &GFOEJNJ[JO LFOEJTJOF
TFMBNWFSJMEJþJOEFBZO‘ZMBZBEBEBIBHà[FMJZMFLBSā‘M‘LWFSEJþJBOMBU‘M‘S½þSFUJDJ iTFMBNVO
BMFZLàNw LFMJNFTJOJO BOMBN‘O‘ BΑLMBS "MMBI‘O iTFMBNw JTNJOJO JÎFSEJþJ NBOBMBS‘ BOMBU‘S
4FMBN‘OVTVMàLPOVTVOEBIBEJTMFSBLUBS‘M‘S
iÿNBO FUNFEJLÎF DFOOFUF HJSFNF[TJOJ[  CJSCJSJOJ[J TFWNFEJLÎF EF JNBO FUNJā
TBZ‘MNB[T‘O‘[4J[FCJSCJSJOJ[JTFWFDFLCJSāFZÚþSFUFZJNNJ "SBO‘[EBTFMBN‘ZBZ‘Ow
i4FMBN‘JMLWFSFO"MMBIBEBIBZBL‘OE‘Sw
i#JOFLMJZàSàZFOF ZàSàZFOPUVSBOB B[ÎPþBTFMBNWFSJSw

249
ÿ-&5ÿĀÿ.7&ÿ-&5ÿĀÿ.&/(&--&3ÿ:-&#"Ā&5.&

i4J[EFOCJSJOJ[CJSNFDMJTFWBSE‘þ‘OEBTFMBNWFSTJOPUVSEVþVNFDMJTUFOLBMLNBLJTUFEJþJ
[BNBOEBTFMBNWFSTJO½ODFWFSEJþJTFMBNTPOSBLJTFMBN‘OEBOEBIBàTUàOEFþJMEJSw
#V IBEJTMFS à[FSJOEF CJSB[ TPICFU FEJMJS 1FZHBNCFS &GFOEJNJ[JO JMFUJāJN LVSBSLFO
TBEFDFTÚ[MFEFþJMEBWSBO‘āMBS‘ZMBEBLBSā‘UBSBG‘OHÚOMàOàBME‘þ‘LPOVTVà[FSJOEFEVSVMBSBL
ÚSOFLMFSMFLPOVQFLJāUJSJMJS
'BSLM‘%JMMFSEF4FMBNMBāNB
)BMMP HVUFOUBH "MNBODB
/JIJP ±JODF
/BNBTUF )JOUÎF
$JBP ÿUBMZBODB
,POJDIJXB +BQPODB
1SJWFU 3VTÎB
;ESBWP 4‘SQÎB
#POKPVS 'SBOT‘[DB
)PMB ÿTQBOZPMDB
,VNVTUB 'JMJQJODF y

%FþFSMFOEJSNF4PSVMBS‘
4FMBNVOBMFZLàNOFBOMBNBHFMNFLUFEJS
4FMBN‘BSBN‘[EBZBZNBO‘OTPOVÎMBS‘OFMFSEJS

(àOàO.FTBK‘
i#JSTFMBNMBTFMBNMBOE‘þ‘O‘[EBTJ[POEBOEBIB
Hà[FMJZMFTFMBNWFSJOZBEBBZO‘ZMBLBSā‘M‘L
WFSJOĀàQIFTJ["MMBI DD IFSāFZJOIFTBC‘O‘
UBNPMBSBLZBQBOE‘Sw
/JTÉ 

,BQBO‘ā
(SVQàZFMFSJOFQBZMBā‘NMBS‘JÎJOUFāFLLàSFEJO
)FSLFTJOBLM‘OEBLBMBONFTBK‘QBZMBāNBT‘O‘JTUFZJO
,POVZMBJMHJMJWBSTBTPSVMBS‘O‘BM‘OWFDFWBQMBZ‘O
#JSTPOSBLJLPOVOVOCBāM‘þ‘O‘WFSJOWFWFEBMBā‘O

250
ÿ-&5ÿĀÿ.7&ÿ-&5ÿĀÿ.&/(&--&3ÿ:-&#"Ā&5.&

5"5-*%ÿ-(Ã-&3:Ã;
,B[BO‘N
5BUM‘EJMMJWFHàMFSZà[MàPMNBO‘OLB[BOE‘SE‘LMBS‘O‘CJMJS

½þSFUJDJ/PUV
5BUM‘EJMMJWFHàMFSZà[MàPMNBO‘OIFS[BNBOLB[BOÎHFUJSFDFþJ 1FZHBNCFSJNJ[JOUFCFTTàN
FUNFOJOTBEBLBPMEVþVāFLMJOEFLJIBEJTJEFTÚZMFOFSFLLPOVOVOÚOFNJJ[BIFEJMJSHàMFS
Zà[Mà PMNBO‘O EJþFS JOTBOMBSMB JMJāLJ LVSBSLFO QP[JUJG CJS CBāMBOH‘Î JÎJO JML BE‘N PMEVþV
CFMJSUJMFSFLBZO‘[BNBOEBNàNJOJOWBT‘nBS‘BSBT‘OEBZFSBME‘þ‘JGBEFFEJMJS

:ÚOUFNWF5FLOJLMFS
4PSV$FWBQ .BUFSZBM)B[‘SMBNB

.BUFSZBM
3FOLMJLBSUPO SFOLMJLBMFNMFS

&ULJOMJL
ZBā
½þSFUJDJÎPDVLMBSBBāBþ‘EBLJIJLÉZFZJPLVS
i±PLFTLJ[BNBOMBSEB CBMTBUBOCJSBEBNWBSN‘ā1FUFLQFUFLCBM‘O‘ TFWJNMJFāFþJOF
ZàLMFS TPLBLMBSEBEPMBāBSBLTBUNBZBÎBM‘ā‘SN‘ā/FIJLNFUTF LJNTFLFOEJTJOEFOCBM
BMNB[N‘ā #BM‘O‘ TBUBNBZBO BEBNDBþ‘[ à[àMàS  à[àMEàLÎF LBāMBS‘O‘ ÎBUBSN‘ā 4FTJ
TFSUMFāJS Zà[àBT‘M‘SN‘ā0OV PIÉMEFHÚSFOMFSIFNFOZPMMBS‘O‘EFþJāUJSJSMFSNJā
"ZO‘ NBIBMMFEF CJS EF TJSLF TBU‘D‘T‘ WBSN‘ā 4JSLFDJ  CJS TPLBþB HJSJODF ÎPDVLMBS
BSLBT‘OEBO LPāBSMBSN‘ā .BIBMMFMJ IFNFO ÎFWSFTJOJ TBSBS  HàMàQ āBLBMBāBSBL TJSLFTJOJ
BM‘SMBSN‘ā#BMD‘ CVBEBN‘OBD‘TJSLFZJOBT‘MCÚZMFÎBCVLTBUU‘þ‘O‘CJSUàSMàBOMBZBNB[N‘ā
#JSHàO JLJTBU‘D‘CJSTPLBLUBLBSā‘MBāN‘āMBS)JÎTBU‘āZBQBNBZBOCBMD‘O‘OZà[àZJOF
BT‘LN‘ā:BWBāÎBTJSLFDJZFZBLMBāBSBLA#SFTJSLFDJLBSEFā#VODB[BNBOE‘STFOJHÚ[MFS
EVSVSVN#FOUBUM‘N‘UBUM‘CBMTBU‘ZPSVN,JNTFHFMJQCFOEFOCBMBMN‘ZPS4FOJOBD‘

251
ÿ-&5ÿĀÿ.7&ÿ-&5ÿĀÿ.&/(&--&3ÿ:-&#"Ā&5.&

TJSLFOJJTFIFSLFTLBQ‘ā‘WFSJZPS#VOVOIJLNFUJOFEJS 4ÚZMFEFCFOJCVEàāàODFEFO
LVSUBS EFNJā 4JSLFDJ  FMJOJ CBMD‘O‘O PN[VOB LPZNVā 4FWHJ EPMV CBL‘āMBS‘O‘ POVO
HÚ[MFSJOFEJLNJāWF
A#BMD‘LBSEFā TFOJOFMJOCBMTBU‘ZPS BNBZà[àOTJSLFTBU‘ZPSEFNJāw
)JLÉZFCJUUJLUFOTPOSBÚþSFUJDJ ÎPDVLMBSBIJLÉZFEFOOFMFSBOMBE‘LMBS‘O‘TPSBS5àN
ÎPDVLMBS‘O DFWBQMBS‘O‘ EJOMFEJLUFO TPOSB ÚþSFUJDJ i)JLÉZFEF PMEVþV HJCJ UBUM‘ EJMMJ WF
HàMFS Zà[Mà PMNBL IFS [BNBO JOTBOB LB[BOE‘S‘S 1FZHBNCFS &GFOEJNJ[ A5FCFTTàN
TBEBLBE‘SCVZVSBSBLHàMFSZà[MàPMNBZ‘UBWTJZFFUNJāUJSwEFS#VBΑLMBNBEBOTPOSB
ÎPDVLMBS‘  HSVCB BZ‘SBSBL CJS HSVQUBO UBUM‘ EJMMJ WF HàMFS Zà[Mà PMNBZMB BMBLBM‘ CJS
IJLÉZF CJSHSVQUBOCJSāJJS EJþFSHSVQUBOCJSBmāÎBM‘āNBT‘ZBQNBMBS‘O‘JTUFS

%FþFSMFOEJSNF4PSVMBS‘
)[1FZHBNCFSHàMFSZà[MàPMNBZMBJMHJMJOFCVZVSNVāUVS
(àMFSZà[MàPMNBO‘OJOTBOBLB[BOE‘SE‘LMBS‘OFMFSEJS
"T‘LZà[MàPMNBLJOTBOBOFLBZCFUUJSJS

(àOàO.FTBK‘
i#JSJOJ[ZBQ‘MBOIJÎCJSJZJMJþJLàÎàL
HÚSNFTJOÿZJMJLZBQNBLJÎJOIJÎCJS
āFZCVMBNB[TBLBSEFāJOJHàMFSZà[MF
LBSā‘MBT‘Ow
5JSNJ[Ô &UJNF 

,BQBO‘ā
(SVQàZFMFSJOFQBZMBā‘NMBS‘JÎJOUFāFLLàSFEJO
)FSLFTJOBLM‘OEBLBMBONFTBK‘QBZMBāNBT‘O‘JTUFZJO
,POVZMBJMHJMJWBSTBTPSVMBS‘O‘BM‘OWFDFWBQMBZ‘O
#JSTPOSBLJLPOVOVOCBāM‘þ‘O‘WFSJOWFWFEBMBā‘O

252
ÿ-&5ÿĀÿ.7&ÿ-&5ÿĀÿ.&/(&--&3ÿ:-&#"Ā&5.&

½þSFUJDJ/PUV
ÿOTBO‘OLFOEJTJOEFWBSPMBOLÚUàIVZMBS‘OEBOWB[HFÎNFTJOJOLPMBZPMNBE‘þ‘BODBL
LJāJOJOJOBOÎMBSBTBZH‘M‘PMBSBL Hà[FMCJSFþJUJNBMBSBLWFUFSCJZFTJOJHFMJāUJSFSFL[BZ‘G
WF LÚUà ZÚOMFSJOJ FO B[‘OEBO LPOUSPM FEFCJMFDFþJ BOMBU‘M‘S ÿOTBO‘O JZJMJL  IPāHÚSà
WF NFSIBNFU EVZHVMBS‘O‘ ÚO QMBOB ΑLBSBSBL  LÚUà IVZMBS‘O‘O ÚOàOà LFTFCJMFDFþJ
CFMJSUJMJS 4FWHJ WF IPāHÚSàOàO ÎBþ‘N‘[EB JOTBOMBS BSBT‘OEB FO ÚOFNMJ CBS‘āΑM FULFO
PMEVþVWVSHVMBO‘S
1FZHBNCFSJO TBT IBZBU‘CPZVODBNVIBUBQMBS‘OBCVJMLFMFSMFZBLMBāU‘þ‘WFEBJNB
CBāBS‘ZB VMBāU‘þ‘ J[BI FEJMJS &GFOEJNJ[JO JOTBOMBSB IJÎCJS [BNBO L‘S‘D‘ EBWSBONBE‘þ‘
CJMBLJT LJāJMFSJO IBTTBTJZFUMFSJOF EJLLBU FUUJþJ WF CV UBW‘SMBS‘ TBZFTJOEF JOTBOMBS‘O
HÚOàMMFSJOFLPMBZM‘LMBVMBāU‘þ‘J[BIFEJMJS

:ÚOUFNWF5FLOJL
"OMBU‘N

.BUFSZBM
4USBGPS LBSUPO SBQUJZF

&ULJOMJL
ZBā
½þSFUJDJ  T‘O‘GB HFMNFEFO ÚODF JODF TUSBGPS à[FSJOF CàZàL CJS LBMQ āFLMJ ÎJ[FS WF
LFTFS #V LBMQ āFLMJOJ JLJ CàZàL LBSUPO BSBT‘OB LPZBS WF LFOBSMBS‘OEBO [‘NCBMBS 
HÚSàOàāUF Eà[ CJS LBSUPO āFLMJ PMVS WF LBMQ āFLMJ JÎJOEF HÚSàONF[ ½þSFUJDJ CVOV
T‘O‘G‘O CJS EVWBS‘OB BTBS ½þSFODJMFSF i#V LBSUPO CJS IBGUB CVSBEB BT‘M‘ EVSBDBL  OF
[BNBO LÚUà CJS TÚ[ TÚZMFTFOJ[  TPNVSULBO EVSTBO‘[  CJSJOJO LBMCJOJ L‘STBO‘[  CJSJOF
CBþ‘STBO‘[ TFTJOJ[JZàLTFMUTFOJ[ LJNTFHÚSNFEFOCVLBSUPOBCJSSBQUJZFCBU‘S‘OwEFS
#JSIBGUBO‘OTPOVOEBLPOVZVJāMFEJLUFOTPOSBEFSTJOTPOVOEBLBSUPOBΑM‘SWFJÎJOEFLJ
LBMQΑLBS‘M‘SWFTUSBGPSVOà[FSJOEFLJSBQUJZFEFOPMVāBOEFMJLMFSFEJLLBUÎFLJMJS&þFS
TJ[CJSBSLBEBā‘O‘[‘OLBMCJOJL‘SBSTBO‘[ POBLÚUàLPOVāVSTBO‘[LBMCJOEFCÚZMFZBSBMBS
BΑM‘SWFLBQBONB[EJZFBΑLMBNBZBQBS

253
ÿ-&5ÿĀÿ.7&ÿ-&5ÿĀÿ.&/(&--&3ÿ:-&#"Ā&5.&

%FþFSMFOEJSNF4PSVMBS‘
5BUM‘EJMJOIBZBU‘N‘[EBLJÚOFNJOFEJS
A4Ú[PMBLFTFTBWBā‘ TÚ[PMBLFTUJSFCBā‘TÚ[PMBBþVMVBā‘ ZBþJMFCBMFEF
TÚ[àOEFOOFBOM‘ZPSTVOV[
5BUM‘EJMWFHàMFSZà[JMFJMHJMJTJ[JFULJMFZFOHà[FMCJSBO‘O‘[‘QBZMBā‘O‘[

(àOàO.FTBK‘
i(à[FMCJSTÚ[TBEBLBE‘Sw
.àTMJN ;FLÉU 

,BQBO‘ā
(SVQàZFMFSJOFQBZMBā‘NMBS‘JÎJOUFāFLLàSFEJO
)FSLFTJOBLM‘OEBLBMBONFTBK‘QBZMBāNBT‘O‘JTUFZJO
,POVZMBJMHJMJWBSTBTPSVMBS‘O‘BM‘OWFDFWBQMBZ‘O
#JSTPOSBLJLPOVOVOCBāM‘þ‘O‘WFSJOWFWFEBMBā‘O

254
ÿ-&5ÿĀÿ.7&ÿ-&5ÿĀÿ.&/(&--&3ÿ:-&#"Ā&5.&

½þSFUJDJ/PUV
ÿOTBO‘OG‘USBU‘OEBHà[FMWFLÚUàIVZMBS‘OWBSPMEVþVWFJOTBO‘O[BBnBS‘PMBOCJSWBSM‘L
PMEVþVBOMBU‘M‘SiJOTBO[BZ‘GZBSBU‘ME‘w /JTÉ  BZFUJÚSOFLPMBSBLWFSJMJSWFEJþFS
DBOM‘MBS‘OZBWSVMBS‘O‘O L‘TBCJSTàSFJÎFSJTJOEFIBZBUBVZVNTBþMBZ‘Q LFOEJCBāMBS‘OB
IBZBUMBS‘O‘EFWBNFUUJSFCJMFDFLTFWJZFZFHFMEJLMFSJBOMBU‘M‘SÿOTBO‘OEBCVāFLJMEFPMVQ
PMNBE‘þ‘TPSVMBSBLEàāàONFMFSJJTUFOJSi:FOJEPþBOCJSÎPDVLIFNFOLPāBCJMJSNJ #JS
CFCFLLBÎZ‘MTPOSBLFOEJZFNFþJOJZBQBCJMJS iHJCJTPSVMBSMBJOTBO‘OPMHVOMBāNBT‘O‘O
[BNBO BME‘þ‘ mLSJ [JIJOMFSEF PUVSUVMVS #FEFOTFM HFMJāJN HJCJ [JIJOTFM WF EVZHVTBM
HFMJāJNJOEF[BNBOBME‘þ‘TÚZMFOJSÿOTBO‘OÚNàSCPZVODBCJSZPMDVMVLUBPMEVþVWFIFS
[BNBOÚþSFONFZFBΑLPMNBT‘HFSFLUJþJWVSHVMBO‘S6OVULBOM‘L CFODJMMJL BDFMFDJMJL 
CBIBOFDJMJLHJCJIVZMBS‘OIFSLFTUFPMEVþVBNBJOTBO‘OCVOVLPOUSPMFUNFTJHFSFLUJþJ
BOMBU‘M‘S ÿOTBO‘O IBZBUUB JZJMJL  IPāHÚSà WF NFSIBNFU HJCJ Hà[FM IVZMBS‘ ÚO QMBOB
ΑLBSNBT‘ HFSFLUJþJ  CV āFLJMEF EBWSBOE‘þ‘OEB 1FZHBNCFS &GFOEJNJ[ HJCJ JOTBOMBS‘O
HÚOàMMFSJOEFUBIULVSNBT‘O‘ONàNLàOPMEVþVWVSHVMBO‘S

:ÚOUFNWF5FLOJL
%FOFZZBQNB

.BUFSZBM
±VLVSCJSUBCBL CBIBSBUM‘L QFUāJāF ÎFāJUMJCBIBSBUMBS TàU TV LVSVāFLFSQBSFUBUM‘T‘

&ULJOMJL
ZBā
½þSFUJDJ T‘O‘GB HFMNFEFO ÚODF NVUMBLB ÚO IB[‘SM‘L ZBQNBM‘E‘S #BIBSBUM‘LMBS‘O à[FSJOF
ÎFāJUMJEVZHVMBSLÉþ‘EBZB[‘MBSBLCBOUMBO‘S#VSBEBEJLLBUFEJMNFTJHFSFLFOāFZCBIBSBUM‘þ‘O
JÎJOEFOFPMEVþVOVÎPDVLMBS‘OHÚSNFNFTJEJS(à[FMEVZHVMBS  JMUJGBU OF[BLFU UFCFTTàN 
āFGLBU  H‘QUB  DFTBSFUy  UBUM‘ CBIBSBUMBSMB āFLFS  UBSΑO  WBOJMZB  TBIMFQ  [FODFGJM  UP[
LBSBOGJMy LÚUàEVZHVMBS IBLBSFU ÚGLF L‘TLBOÎM‘L TPNVSULBOM‘L LJOUVUNBy JTFBD‘ZB
EBUV[JÎFSFOCBIBSBUMBSMB UV[ L‘SN‘[‘UP[CJCFS LBSBCJCFS LJNZPO JTPU LÚSJy LBSā‘MBO‘S
4àUāJāFTJOJOà[FSJOFTFWHJ TVāJāFTJOJOà[FSJOFOFGSFUZB[‘M‘SĀJāFMFSJOEFBZO‘PMNBT‘OB
EJLLBUFEJMNFMJEJS
½þSFUJDJ āFLFSQBSFZJ ÎPDVLMBSB HÚTUFSFSFL CVOVO IBZBU‘N‘[EB JOTBOMBSB TVONBL
JTUFEJþJNJ[IFSIBOHJCJSāFZPMEVþVOV UàDDBSJTFLTBUNBLJTUFEJþJNJ[FāZB ÚþSFUNFOJTFL
WFSNFLJTUFEJþJNJ[CJMHJ HJCJÚSOFLMFSMFÎPþBMUBSBLIBZBMFUNFMFSJOJJTUFS,Bā‘LZBSE‘N‘ZMB
UBUM‘F[JMJS#JSJāJTFWFSFLZBQU‘þ‘N‘[EBWFHà[FMEVZHVMBS‘LBUU‘þ‘N‘[EBUBE‘O‘OOBT‘MPMBDBþ‘O‘
NFSBL FEJZPS NVTVOV[ EJZF TPSVMEVLUBO TPOSB  UBUM‘O‘O à[FSJOF TFWHJ  OF[BLFU  JMUJGBU 
UFCFTTàNyFLMFOJS/FGSFUMFZBQ‘MBOJāJOTPOVDVOVHÚTUFSNFLJÎJOEFCBāLBCJSUBCBþBUBUM‘
LPOVQ CVTFGFSà[FSJOFOFGSFU IBLBSFU ÚGLF TPNVSULBOM‘LyFLMFOJS5BSJGMFSCJUJODFUBE‘OB
CBLNBLJTUFZFOMFSFLBā‘LJMFJLSBNFEJMJS

255
ÿ-&5ÿĀÿ.7&ÿ-&5ÿĀÿ.&/(&--&3ÿ:-&#"Ā&5.&

,ÚUà EVZHVMBS BD‘ CBIBSBUMBS  JMF ZBQ‘MBO UBSJG  UBUM‘O‘O UBE‘O‘ CP[BDBþ‘OEBO ÚþSFUJDJ 
i±PDVLMBSIBZBUUBEBFþFSJāJNJ[JTFWNF[LBSā‘N‘[EBLJOFLJOWFOFGSFUMFZBLMBā‘STBLPSUBZB
ΑLBSE‘þ‘N‘[ àSàO BZO‘ CV UBSJGJNJ[ HJCJ BD‘MBā‘S WF JOTBOMBS‘ CJ[EFO V[BLMBāU‘S‘Sw HJCJ
DàNMFMFSMFLÚUàEVZHVMBS‘OPMVNTV[TPOVÎMBSEPþVSBDBþ‘O‘ UBUM‘CBIBSBUMBS‘OFLMFOEJþJUBSJGUF
JTFTFWFSFLWFUBUM‘EJMMFZBQ‘MBOJāJOIBZBU‘EBUBUMBOE‘SE‘þ‘TÚZMFOFSFLFULJOMJLUBNBNMBO‘S

%FþFSMFOEJSNF4PSVMBS‘
4J[JOEFIBZBU‘O‘[EBIJÎPMNBZBDBLCJSāFZJUBUM‘EJMMFIBMMFUUJþJOJ[PMEVNV
.BILFNFTVSBUM‘TÚ[àOEFOOFBOM‘ZPSTVOV[
i,FTLJOTJSLFLàQàOF[BSBSwBUBTÚ[àOEFOOFBOM‘ZPSTVOV[

(àOàO.FTBK‘
i4Ú[PMBLFTFTBWBā‘TÚ[PMBLFTUJSFCBā‘
4Ú[PMBBþ‘M‘Bā‘ZBþJMFCBMFEFCJSTÚ[w
:VOVT&NSF

,BQBO‘ā
(SVQàZFMFSJOFQBZMBā‘NMBS‘JÎJOUFāFLLàSFEJO
)FSLFTJOBLM‘OEBLBMBONFTBK‘QBZMBāNBT‘O‘JTUFZJO
,POVZMBJMHJMJWBSTBTPSVMBS‘O‘BM‘OWFDFWBQMBZ‘O
#JSTPOSBLJLPOVOVOCBāM‘þ‘O‘WFSJOWFWFEBMBā‘O

256
ÿ-&5ÿĀÿ.7&ÿ-&5ÿĀÿ.&/(&--&3ÿ:-&#"Ā&5.&

1&:(".#&3ÿ.ÿ;ÿ/#&%&/%ÿ-ÿ
,B[BO‘N
1FZHBNCFSJNJ[JOCFEFOEJMJOJOBT‘MLVMMBOE‘þ‘O‘CJMJS

½þSFUJDJ/PUV
#VSBEBT‘O‘GBPEBZBHJSFSHJSNF[FULJOMJþFCBāMBOBDBL LPOVJTFJMFSMFZFO[BNBOEB
BOMBU‘MBDBLU‘S

:ÚOUFNWF5FLOJLMFS
"OMBU‘N 4PSVDFWBQ

&ULJOMJL
ZBā
½þSFUJDJT‘O‘GBHJSFS IFS[BNBOLJOJOBLTJOFZà[àBT‘L LBāMBS‘ÎBU‘LU‘S½GLFMJHJCJ
EBWSBOBSBLZFSJOFHFÎFS ÎPDVLMBSBUFLUFLCBLBS±PDVLMBSāBāL‘OE‘S
i&WFU BSLBEBāMBSIB[‘SM‘þ‘N‘[‘ÎBCVDBLZBQBM‘NEFSTFCBāM‘ZPSV[ CVHàOLàLPOVNV[
JMFUJāJNWFJMFUJāJNFOHFMMFSJwEJZFSFLEFSTFHJSJāZBQBSWFJMFUJāJNLBWSBN‘O‘OUBO‘N‘O‘
ZBQBS(Ú[UFNBT‘LVSNB[
½þSFUJDJZFSJOEFOLBMLBSi"SLBEBāMBSCJSB[EBOHFMFDFþJNwEJZFSFLT‘O‘GUBOΑLBS 
ÎPDVLMBS‘CJSNàEEFUZBMO‘[C‘SBL‘S4‘O‘GBUFLSBSHJSEJþJOEFJTFPHàOEFSTFJMLEFGB
HJSJZPSNVāHJCJEBWSBO‘S)FS[BNBOLJHJCJHàMàNTFS UFLUFLHÚ[UFNBT‘LVSBS T‘SBMBS‘O
BSBT‘OEBEPMBā‘STPOSBÎPDVLMBSBOBT‘MPMEVLMBS‘O‘TPSBSBLZFSJOFHFÎFS
±PDVLMBSZJOFāBāL‘OE‘S½þSFUJDJHàMàNTFSWFÎPDVLMBSBEÚOFSFLTPSBSi4J[DFIBOHJ
JMFUJāJNāFLMJNEBIBEPþSV CJSJODJTJNJJLJODJTJNJ ÿMFUJāJNIÉMJOEFPMEVþVOV[CJSJOJO
OBT‘MEBWSBONBT‘O‘JTUFSTJOJ[ w
4PSVMBS‘OB BME‘þ‘ DFWBQMBSMB T‘O‘G‘O LPOVZB IB[‘S PMEVþVOV IJTTFEJODF i1FLJ TJ[DF
ÉMFNMFSFSBINFUPMBSBLHÚOEFSJMFO)[.VIBNNFE TBT OBT‘MEBWSBO‘SE‘ OFEFSTJOJ[
POVO IBZBU‘OB CJS CBLBM‘N N‘ w EFS WF 1FZHBNCFSJNJ[JO IBZBU‘OEBO CJSLBÎ ÚSOFLMF
POVOJOTBOMBSMBJMFUJāJNLVSBSLFOCFEFOEJMJOJOBT‘MLVMMBOE‘þ‘O‘BOMBU‘S

257
ÿ-&5ÿĀÿ.7&ÿ-&5ÿĀÿ.&/(&--&3ÿ:-&#"Ā&5.&

½þSFUJDJ CFEFOEJMJOJO LJāJTFMHFMJāJNWFJMFUJāJNJOÎPLÚOFNMJCJSBMBO‘PMEVþVOV


J[BIFEFS#FEFOEJMJOJOCJMJOÎMJPMBSBLVZHVMBONBT‘O‘OJOTBOMBSBLFOEJMFSJOJEBIBJZJ
JGBEFFEFCJMNFPMBOBþ‘TBþMBE‘þ‘WFEJþFSJOTBOMBSBLBSā‘BOMBZ‘āWFIPāHÚSàOàOHFMJāUJ
SJMNFTJOFZBSE‘ND‘PMEVþVWVSHVMBE‘LUBOTPOSB CFEFOEJMJLPOVTVOEBUàNIBZBU‘N‘[
EBNPEFMBMNBN‘[HFSFLFOÚODFMJLMJLJāJOJOāàQIFTJ[1FZHBNCFS&GFOEJNJ[PMBDBþ‘O‘
CFMJSUJS)[1FZHBNCFSJO"MMBIUBOBME‘þ‘JMBIÔNFTBKMBS‘JOTBOMBSBVMBāU‘SBCJMNFLJÎJO
ÎFāJUMJJMFUJāJNUFLOJLMFSJLVMMBOE‘þ‘O‘JIUJZBÎEVZEVþVOEB VZHVO[BNBOWFZFSEFNJ
NJLWFKFTUMFSJCJSMJLUFLVMMBOBSBLJOTBOMBSBNFTBKMBS‘O‘JMFUUJþJOJ [BNBO[BNBOTÚ[Tà[
BOMBU‘NUFLOJþJOFCBāWVSEVþVOVJGBEFFEFSFLÎPDVLMBSMBCJSMJLUFFULJOMJþJHFSÎFLMFāUJSJS

,VMMBO‘MBCJMFDFL½SOFLMFS

#JSEVBÚþSFUJSLFO"CEVMMBICJO.FTßEVOFMJOJUVUBSBLPOBDFTBSFUWFSNFTJ
)[.VIBNNFEJOÎPDVLMBSMBLPOVāVSLFOFþJMJQHÚ[IJ[BT‘OEBLPOVāNBT‘
)[.VIBNNFEJOCJSLJāJJMFLPOVāVSLFOLPOVāUVþVLJāJZFUàNWàDVEV
JMFEÚONFTJ
½þSFUJDJ 1FZHBNCFSJNJ[JOZBāBN‘OEBOÚSOFLMFSJBOMBUU‘LUBOTPOSBJMFUJāJNJOZBMO‘[
TÚ[JMFPMNBE‘þ‘O‘ BTM‘OEBIFSEBWSBO‘ā‘N‘[‘OCJSJMFUJāJNāFLMJPMEVþVOV CFEFOJNJ[JO
EVZHVMBS‘N‘[‘EPþSVJGBEFFUNFEFLVMMBO‘MBOCJSWBT‘UBPMEVþVOVJGBEFFEFS

%FþFSMFOEJSNF4PSVMBS‘
#FEFOEJMJJMFUJāJNEFÚOFNMJNJEJS ÚOFNMJJTFCVOVCJMJZPSNVZEVOV[
2. 4Ú[WFCFEFOEJMJOEFOCBāLBJMFUJāJNÎFāJUMFSJWBSN‘E‘S
3. ½þSFUJDJOJO i1FLJCFOJBT‘LZà[MàHÚSàODFOFIJTTFUUJOJ[ wTPSVTVOBOFDFWBQ
WFSJSTJOJ[

258
ÿ-&5ÿĀÿ.7&ÿ-&5ÿĀÿ.&/(&--&3ÿ:-&#"Ā&5.&

(àOàO.FTBK‘
i1FZHBNCFS&GFOEJNJ[ TBT CJSāFZFJāBSFU
FEFDFþJ[BNBO TBEFDFQBSNBþ‘ZMBEFþJM CàUàO
FMJZMFJāBSFUFUNFLUFZEJ#JSāFZFIBZSFUFEFSTF
FMJOJCVMVOEVþVIÉMEFOUFSTÎFWJSNFLUFZEJ
,POVāVSLFOFMMFSJOJKFTUPMBSBLIBSFLFU
FUUJSNFLUF TPMFMJOJOBWVDVJMFTBþFMJOJO
CBāQBSNBþ‘OBWVSNBLUBZE‘w
5JSNJ[Ô ĀFNBJM 

,BQBO‘ā
(SVQàZFMFSJOFQBZMBā‘NMBS‘JÎJOUFāFLLàSFEJO
)FSLFTJOBLM‘OEBLBMBONFTBK‘QBZMBāNBT‘O‘JTUFZJO
,POVZMBJMHJMJWBSTBTPSVMBS‘O‘BM‘OWFDFWBQMBZ‘O
#JSTPOSBLJLPOVOVOCBāM‘þ‘O‘WFSJOWFWFEBMBā‘O

259
ÿ-&5ÿĀÿ.7&ÿ-&5ÿĀÿ.&/(&--&3ÿ:-&#"Ā&5.&

0-6.46;%6:(6-"3-"#"Ā&5.&
,B[BO‘N
½GLF L‘TLBOÎM‘L à[àOUàHJCJEVZHVMBS‘OJOTBOJEVZHVMBSPMEVþVOVCJMJS
½GLFIÉMJOEFLJāJOJOLFOEJTJOJOBT‘MLPOUSPMFEFCJMFDFþJOJCJMJS

½þSFUJDJ/PUV
½GLF L‘TLBOÎM‘LWFà[àOUàHJCJEVZHVMBS‘OJOTBOJCJSFSEVZHVPMEVþVJ[BIFEJMEJLUFO
TPOSB
i0OMBS  "MMBIUBOIBLL‘ZMBLPSLBOMBS CPMMVLUBWFEBSM‘LUB"MMBIJÎJOIBSDBSMBS ÚGLFMFSJOJ
ZVUBSMBS JOTBOMBS‘BGGFEFSMFS"MMBIJZJMJLFEFOMFSJTFWFSw ¬MJÿNSÉO  BZFUJLFSJNFTJ
BΑLMBO‘S
½OFNMJ PMBO‘O  L‘TLBOÎM‘L WFZB ÚGLF EVZHVTV IJTTFEJMEJþJ EVSVNEB OBT‘M IBSFLFU
FEJMFDFþJOJOCJMJONFTJ CVOMBS‘OLPOUSPMBMU‘OBBM‘ONBT‘HFSFLUJþJBΑLMBO‘S

:ÚOUFNWF5FLOJLMFS
"OMBU‘N 3PM0ZOBNB

.BUFSZBM
3FOLMJLBSUPO UFSDJIFOZFāJM L‘SN‘[‘ NBLBT ZBQ‘āU‘S‘D‘

&ULJOMJL
ZBā
½þSFUJDJ CJSÚODFLJEFSTJLJÎPDVþBBāBþ‘EBZFSBMBO)BDJWBUWF,BSBHÚ[NFUOJOJWFSJS
#JS TPOSBLJ EFSTF CV NFUOJ DBOMBOE‘SBDBLMBS‘O‘ TÚZMFS WF ÎPDVLMBSEBO HFSFLMJ IB[‘SM‘þ‘
ZBQNBMBS‘O‘JTUFS
&ULJOMJþJOZBQ‘MBDBþ‘EFSTFÚþSFUJDJ)BDJWBUWF,BSBHÚ[JÎJOāBQLBZBQNBLBNBD‘ZMBLBSUPO 
NBLBTWFZBQ‘āU‘S‘D‘HFUJSJS#àUàOÎPDVLMBSMBCJSMJLUFCBTJUāFLJMEFJLJUBOFāBQLBIB[‘SMBO‘S
ĀBQLBMBSIB[‘SMBOE‘LUBOTPOSBEBIBÚODFHÚSFWMFOEJSJMNJāPMBOÎPDVLMBSāBQLBMBS‘UBLBSBL
SPMZBQBSMBS )BDJWBUWF,BSBHÚ[āBQLBMBS‘HFOFMMJLMFZFāJM L‘SN‘[‘SFOLMFSEFPMNBLUBE‘S

260
ÿ-&5ÿĀÿ.7&ÿ-&5ÿĀÿ.&/(&--&3ÿ:-&#"Ā&5.&

)"$ÿ7"5ÿ-&,"3"(½;(Ã3&Ā5&
)"$ÿ7"5)FMBMPMTVOTBOBLPDBQFIMJWBO JāUFCÚZMF
,"3"(½;)BZEJCSFQFIMJWBO T‘L‘UVUT‘L‘UVU
)"$ÿ7"5,BSBHÚ[àN OFJZJPMEVEBHFMEJLCVHàOHàSFāNàTBCBLBT‘O‘J[MFNFZFEFþJM
NJ 
,"3"(½;ÿZJPMEVUBCJ BNBCFOEVSBN‘ZPSVNLJCVSBEBIFZFDBOEBO āJNEJHJEJQāV
BEBN‘QBUBLMBZBDBþ‘N
)"$ÿ7"5/FEFOFGFOEJN OFPMEVLJ
,"3"(½;/FPMBDBLCFOJNUVUUVþVNQFIMJWBO‘ZFSEFOZFSFWVSVZPS#FOEFCJSLÚUFL
WVSBDBþ‘NāJNEJPOBW‘ZW‘ZW‘Z
)"$ÿ7"5 "NBO ,BSBHÚ[àN HàSFā CJS TQPS  POMBS LBWHB FUNJZPSMBS LJ  TFO OFEFO
ÚGLFMFOEJOCÚZMF 
,"3"(½;(Ú[àNàOÚOàOEFLPDBBEBN‘EÚWàZPS CFOHÚTUFSFDFþJNCJSB[EBOPOBy
)"$ÿ7"5 "NBO FGFOEJN TBL‘O CJS āFZ ZBQNB  POMBS EÚWàāNàZPS LJ #V TBEFDF CJS
NàTBCBLB½OFNMJPMBOBUBTQPSVNV[BTBIJQΑLNBL
,"3"(½;/FFCJSEFBU‘OàTUàOFNJΑLBDBL;BUFOEFNJOEFOCFSJCFOJNQFIMJWBO‘O
UFQFTJOEF
)"$ÿ7"5"UEFþJMJLJHÚ[àN BUBTQPSV:BOJEFEFMFSJNJ[EFOLBMN‘āCJSTQPSEBM‘E‘S
HàSFā
,"3"(½;)BBÚZMFEFTFOF CFOJNEFHÚ[àNFÎBSQ‘ZPSHàOFā
)"$ÿ7"5&WFU,BSBHÚ[àN IBWBEBHàOFāMJCVHàO#FOÎPLTVTBE‘NCJSTVBMBZ‘N
CBSJ4FOEFJTUFSNJTJO
,"3"(½;#FOEFTVTBE‘N)BD‘$BWDBW#BOBEBTVBM CJSEFLÚUFLBM:FUFSBSU‘LCV
BEBN‘OZBQU‘LMBS‘y
)"$ÿ7"5"I,BSBHÚ[àNTQPSEJZPSVN NàTBCBLBEJZPSVN TFOIÉMÉLÚUFLEJZPSTVO
4QPSEBZFOFOEFPMVS ZFOJMFOEF
,"3"(½;:FEJ[BUFOZFEJ FLNFLBSBT‘LÚGUFHJCJZFEJLPDBQFIMJWBO‘N‘CBLTBOB#BL
HÚSEàONàOBT‘MZFSFZBU‘SE‘CFOJNQFIMJWBO‘N‘ZJOF
)"$ÿ7"5 ,BSBHÚ[àN  OJÎJO CV LBEBS ÚGLFMFOJZPSTVO  #ÚZMF TQPS NàTBCBLBMBS‘OEB
TJOJSMFONFLIPāEFþJM
,"3"(½;#JSUFQTJCBLMBWBZ‘LPāHFUJS7‘ZW‘ZW‘Zy/FEFONJāP 
)"$ÿ7"54QPSEBZFONFLEFPMVSZFOJMNFLEF
,"3"(½;"NBOEBÎBZLBME‘N‘EFNMJLUF )BIIBBIBBy"NBCFOQFIMJWBOJÎJO
à[àMàZPSVN
)"$ÿ7"5 :BQNB ,BSBHÚ[àN  CJS P QFIMJWBO LB[BO‘S  CJS CV QFIMJWBO LB[BO‘S
½GLFMFONFLIFMFEFL‘TLBONBLJZJCJSāFZEFþJM

261
ÿ-&5ÿĀÿ.7&ÿ-&5ÿĀÿ.&/(&--&3ÿ:-&#"Ā&5.&

,"3"(½;(ÚSFNJZPSVN[BUFOB[FþJM7‘ZW‘ZW‘Z
)"$ÿ7"54FO1FZHBNCFSJNJ[JOCVOVOMBJMHJMJIBEJTJOJCJMJZPSNVTVO
,"3"(½;#JMNJZPSVNFGFOEJNIBEJTÚZMFEFÚþSFOFZJN
)"$ÿ7"51FZHBNCFSJNJ[āÚZMFCVZVSNVāi1FIMJWBO HàSFāNFZEBOMBS‘OEBCBāLBMBS‘
O‘ ZFOFOEFþJMEJS"T‘MQFIMJWBOL‘[H‘OM‘LBO‘OEBOFGTJOFIÉLJNPMBOLJNTFEJSw .VWBUUB 
)àTOVM)VML 
,"3"(½;)‘‘NNOFHà[FMEFNJāCFOJN1FZHBNCFSJN
)"$ÿ7"5ÿāUFPZà[EFOCJ[EFIFNFOÚGLFMFONFZFDFþJ[4JOJSMFIBSFLFUFUNFZFDFþJ[
,"3"(½;"IPMTBEBZFTFL DFWJ[DFWJ[)BD‘$BWDBWāBLBMBS‘NBL‘[NBTBL‘O&MCFUUF
1FZHBNCFSJNJ[JOÚþàEàOFVZBS‘N POFEFEJZTFCJ[JNJZJMJþJNJ[JÎJOEFS
)"$ÿ7"5"GFSJO,BSBHÚ[àN BL‘MM‘BEBNT‘OFWFMBMMBI
,"3"(½;#FOJNQFIMJWBOBEBNBāBMMBI PLB[BO‘SJOāBMMBI7‘ZW‘ZW‘Zy
)"$ÿ7"5/FHà[FMEVBFUUJOÚZMF
,"3"(½;:BLBMBSTBNTFOJEÚWFSJNCÚZMF
)"$ÿ7"5"[ÚODFOFLPOVāUVLFGFOEJNIBOJ ÚGLFZPLUV EÚWNFLZPLUV
,"3"(½;:PLTBHJEJQCFONBSLFUUFOBMBZ‘N7‘ZW‘ZW‘ZĀBLB)BD‘$BWDBWāBLB#FO
CVLPDBQFIMJWBOMBSEBOEBIBHàÎMàPMNBO‘OZPMVOVCVMEVNIJÎC‘SBL‘SN‘Z‘N
)"$ÿ7"5/FZNJāPZPM
,"3"(½;"[ÚODFEFEJOZB)BD‘$BWDBW TFOEFJZJDFVOVULBOPMEVOZBIVi1FIMJWBO
HàSFāNFZEBOMBS‘OEBCBāLBMBS‘O‘ ZFOFOEFþJMEJS"T‘MQFIMJWBOL‘[H‘OM‘LBO‘OEBOFGTJOFIÉ
LJNPMBOLJNTFEJSwEFNFNJāNJ1FZHBNCFSJNJ[ 
)"$ÿ7"55BNBNāJNEJBOMBE‘NFGFOEJN TFOJUFCSJLFEJZPSVN
,"3"(½;#FOEFCàZàLMFSJOFMMFSJOEFOLàÎàLMFSJOHÚ[MFSJOEFOÚQàZPSVN
#ÚZMFDFTBIOFEFOΑLBSMBS

%FþFSMFOEJSNF4PSVMBS‘
,BSBHÚ[OJÎJOÚGLFMFONJāUJS
,BSBHÚ[ ÚGLFTJOEFOEPMBZ‘OBT‘MEBWSBONBLJTUFNJāUJS
)BDJWBUPOVOFāFLJMEFVZBSN‘āU‘S
,BSBHÚ[OBT‘MEBWSBONBZBLBSBSWFSNJāUJS
4J[ÚGLFMFOJODFOBT‘MEBWSBO‘ST‘O‘[ 

262
ÿ-&5ÿĀÿ.7&ÿ-&5ÿĀÿ.&/(&--&3ÿ:-&#"Ā&5.&

(àOàO.FTBK‘
i)BTFUFUNFLUFOTBL‘O‘O [JSBBUFāJO
PEVOVZJZJQCJUJSEJþJHJCJIBTFUEF
JZJMJLMFSJZFSCJUJSJSw
&CV%ÉWVE &EFQ 

,BQBO‘ā
(SVQàZFMFSJOFQBZMBā‘NMBS‘JÎJOUFāFLLàSFEJO
)FSLFTJOBLM‘OEBLBMBONFTBK‘QBZMBāNBT‘O‘JTUFZJO
,POVZMBJMHJMJWBSTBTPSVMBS‘O‘BM‘OWFDFWBQMBZ‘O
#JSTPOSBLJLPOVOVOCBāM‘þ‘O‘WFSJOWFWFEBMBā‘O

263
ÿ-&5ÿĀÿ.7&ÿ-&5ÿĀÿ.&/(&--&3ÿ:-&#"Ā&5.&

½þSFUJDJ/PUV
ÿOTBOEB  OFGSFU  JOBU  ÚGLF  FOEJāF  L‘TLBOÎM‘L  à[àOUà HJCJ EVZHVMBS‘O ZBSBU‘M‘āUBO WBS
PMEVþV BNB JOTBO‘O  CV EVZHVMBS‘ ZBSBU‘ME‘þ‘ JTUJLBNFUUF LVMMBONBLMB TPSVNMV PMEVþV
BOMBU‘M‘S
0OMBS "MMBIUBOIBLL‘ZMBLPSLBOMBS CPMMVLUBWFEBSM‘LUB"MMBIJÎJOIBSDBSMBS ÚGLFMFSJOJ
ZVUBSMBS JOTBOMBS‘BGGFEFSMFS"MMBIJZJMJLFEFOMFSJTFWFS ¬MJÿNSÉO  BZFUJBΑLMBO‘S
ÿOTBOJÎJOÚOFNMJPMBO‘OPMVNTV[EVZHVMBS‘LPOUSPMBMU‘OBBMNBLPMEVþVWVSHVMBO‘S

:ÚOUFNWF5FLOJLMFS
"OMBU‘N 4PSV$FWBQ

.BUFSZBM
±BM‘āNBLÉþ‘E‘ GPUPLPQJJMFÎPþBMU‘MN‘ā

&ULJOMJL
ZBā
½þSFUJDJ  ÎPDVLMBSB IJTTFUUJLMFSJ EVZHVMBS‘O GBSL‘OEB PMVQ PMNBE‘LMBS‘O‘ TPSBS )BOHJ
EVSVNEB OF IJTTFUUJLMFSJ à[FSJOF CJSB[ LPOVāVMVS ±BM‘āNB LÉþ‘E‘O‘ EBþ‘U‘S ,Éþ‘UUB ZB[‘M‘
PMBZLBSā‘T‘OEBOFIJTTFUUJLMFSJOJWFOBT‘MEBWSBOBDBLMBS‘O‘ZB[NBMBS‘JTUFOJS
±BM‘āNB LÉþ‘E‘ UBNBNMBOE‘LUBO TPOSB DFWBQMBSB HFÎJMNFEFO ÚODF PMVNTV[ EVZHVMBSMB
CBāFEFCJMNFLJÎJOCB[‘TUSBUFKJMFSBOMBU‘M‘S
½ODFEVZHVMBS‘O‘[‘WFLFOEJOJ[JLBCVMFEJO
4BIJQPMEVþVOV[Hà[FMMJLMFSJCVMVO
(FÎNJāFUBL‘MNBLZBEBHFMFDFþJQMBOMBNBLUBOÎPL āJNEJLJ[BNBO‘ZBāBNBZBÎBM‘ā‘O
.àDBEFMFFUNFLZBEBQFTFUNFLBSBT‘OEBTFÎJNJOJ[JZBQ‘O
0MVNTV[MVLUBLJPMVNMVZVHÚSNFZFÎBM‘ā‘O
#BL‘āBΑO‘[‘EFþJāUJSJO
,BSBST‘[M‘LWFEFOHFTJ[MJLUFOV[BLEVSNBZBÎBM‘ā‘O
5FLSBSUFLSBSEFOFNFLUFOWB[HFÎNFZJO
 ½ODF CJ[ EàāàODFMFSF TBIJQ PMVSV[ TPOSB EB EàāàODFMFSJNJ[ CJ[F  OFZJ TàSFLMJ
EàāàOEàþàNà[F EJLLBU FEFMJN #FZOJNJ[F PMVNTV[ LPNVU WFSNFLUFO V[BL EVSNBZB
ÎBM‘āBM‘N
½þSFUJDJ CV ZÚOUFNMFSJ BOMBUU‘LUBO TPOSB ÎPDVLMBS‘O WFSEJþJ DFWBQMBS‘ EFþFSMFOEJSJS WF
EPþSVEBWSBO‘ā‘OOBT‘MPMBCJMFDFþJIBLL‘OEBmLJSMFSWFSJS1FZHBNCFS&GFOEJNJ[JOIBZBU‘OEBO
WF EJþFS QFZHBNCFSMFSJO IBZBUMBS‘OEBO ÚSOFLMFS ZB EB HàODFM IBZBUUBO CBāBS‘ IJLÉZFMFSJ
BOMBU‘MBCJMJS ½GLF JMF JMHJMJ IJLNFUMJ TÚ[MFS ½GLF Sà[HÉS HJCJEJS  CJS TàSF TPOSB EJOFS BNB
CJSÎPLEBML‘S‘MN‘āU‘SCJMF TÚZMFOJQà[FSJOEFEàāàONFMFSJJTUFOJS½GLFZMFLBMLBO[BSBSMB
PUVSVS,FTLJOTJSLFLàQàOF[BSBSHJCJBUBTÚ[MFSJJMFLPOVEFTUFLMFOJS

264
զ +(ɘ, ƻ*ǔȢ(#(

0-": /&)ÿ44&%&3%ÿ/  /&:"1"3%*/

"SLBEBā‘O‘OTBOBBJUPMBO
CJSāFZJJ[JOTJ[BMNBT‘

#JSJOJOTBOBWFSEJþJTÚ[à
UVUNBNBT‘

4BOBZBMBOTÚZMFONFTJ

"SLBEBā‘O‘OEFST
OPUMBS‘O‘OZàLTFLPMNBT‘

)BTUBMBOE‘þ‘OEBJZJMFāNF
TàSFDJOJOV[VOTàSNFTJ

/BT‘MZBQ‘ME‘þ‘O‘CJMEJþJO
IÉMEFCJSJOJOTBOBFNJS
WFSJQZÚOMFOEJSNFL
istemesi.

"SLBEBā‘O‘OPMNBNBT‘

±PLCFþFOEJþJOBNB
BMBNBE‘þ‘OCJSāFZJ
BSLBEBā‘OEBHÚSNFL

265
ÿ-&5ÿĀÿ.7&ÿ-&5ÿĀÿ.&/(&--&3ÿ:-&#"Ā&5.&

%FþFSMFOEJSNF4PSVMBS‘
½GLFNJ[FOBT‘MIÉLJNPMBCJMJSJ[
#JSJāJZBQNBLUBOT‘L‘ME‘þ‘O‘[EBOFZBQBST‘O‘[
#JSJMFSJOJL‘TLBONBLCJ[FOBT‘M[BSBSWFSJS

(àOàO.FTBK‘
i,àÎàNTFZFSFLJOTBOMBSEBOZà[ÎFWJSNFWF
ZFSZà[àOEFCÚCàSMFOFSFLZàSàNF;JSB"MMBI 
LFOEJOJCFþFONJāÚWàOàQEVSBOLJNTFMFSJ
BTMBTFWNF[w
-PLNÉO 

,BQBO‘ā
(SVQàZFMFSJOFQBZMBā‘NMBS‘JÎJOUFāFLLàSFEJO
)FSLFTJOBLM‘OEBLBMBONFTBK‘QBZMBāNBT‘O‘JTUFZJO
,POVZMBJMHJMJWBSTBTPSVMBS‘O‘BM‘OWFDFWBQMBZ‘O
#JSTPOSBLJLPOVOVOCBāM‘þ‘O‘WFSJOWFWFEBMBā‘O

266
ÿ-&5ÿĀÿ.7&ÿ-&5ÿĀÿ.&/(&--&3ÿ:-&#"Ā&5.&

½',&.ÿ:&/&#ÿ-ÿ3ÿ.
,B[BO‘N
½GLFIÉMJOEFLJāJOJOLFOEJTJOJOBT‘MLPOUSPMFEFCJMFDFþJOJCJMJS
Ã[àOUàIÉMJOEFLJāJOJOLFOEJTJOJOBT‘MUFTLJOFEFCJMFDFþJOJCJMJS

½þSFUJDJ/PUV
½GLFZMFJMHJMJBāBþ‘EBLJIBEJTMFSJ[BIFEJMJS
i#JSJOJ[BZBLUBZLFOÚGLFMFOJSTFIFNFOPUVSTVO½GLFTJHJEFSTFJZJ HJUNF[TFIFNFOZBUT‘Ow
&CV%ÉWVE &EFC 
iy#JSJOJ[L‘[E‘þ‘[BNBOTVTNBZ‘EFOFTJOw ÿCO)BOCFM * 
i½GLFāFZUBOEBOE‘SWFāFZUBOJTFBUFāUFOZBSBU‘MN‘āU‘S"UFāJTÚOEàSFOEFTVEVS0OVOJÎJO
CJSJOJ[ÚGLFMFOJODFIFNFOBCEFTUBMT‘Ow &CV%ÉWVE &EFC 

:ÚOUFNWF5FLOJLMFS
"OMBU‘N "LWBSZVN5FLOJþJ

.BUFSZBM
"LÉþ‘E‘OBÎJ[JMNJāUSBmLMBNCBT‘

&ULJOMJL
ZBā
½þSFUJDJ ÚODFEFOIB[‘SMBN‘āPMEVþVUSBmLMBNCBT‘SFTNJOJT‘O‘G‘OPEBO‘OHÚSàMFCJMFDFL
CJSZFSJOFBTBS½þSFUJDJ ÎPDVLMBSBÚGLFMFOEJLMFSJOEFOBT‘MUFQLJWFSEJLMFSJOJTPSBS±PDVLMBS
EBOHFMFODFWBQMBSEJOMFOEJLUFOTPOSBUSBmLMBNCBT‘VZHVMBNBT‘O‘ÚGLFNJ[JLPOUSPMFUNFEF
LVMMBOBCJMFDFþJNJ[JJGBEFFEFSWF‘ā‘LMBS‘OBOMBNMBS‘O‘CFMJSUJS

267
ÿ-&5ÿĀÿ.7&ÿ-&5ÿĀÿ.&/(&--&3ÿ:-&#"Ā&5.&

,‘SN‘[‘*ā‘L%VS
%VSWFIBSFLFUFUNFEFOÚODFEàāàO

4BS‘*ā‘L)B[‘SMBO
ÿÎJOEFOBLBEBSTBZWFZBQBCJMFDFLMFSJOJHÚ[EFOHFÎJS

:FāJM*ā‘L(FÎ
"LM‘OBHFMFOFOJZJÎÚ[àNàTFÎWFVZHVMB

½þSFUJDJ ÎPDVLMBSBi½GLFMFOEJþJNJ[EFBLM‘N‘[BUSBmL‘ā‘LMBS‘O‘HFUJSJZPSV[wEFSi½GLF
MFOEJþJOJ[EF L‘SN‘[‘‘ā‘LUBEVSEVþVNV[HJCJEVSVOWFIBSFLFUFUNFEFOÚODFEàāàOàO4BS‘
‘ā‘LUBIB[‘SMBOE‘þ‘N‘[HJCJJÎJOJ[EFOBLBEBSTBZ‘OWFZBQBCJMFDFLMFSJOJ[JHÚ[EFOHFÎJSJO
WFZFāJM‘ā‘LUBPMEVþVHJCJBSU‘LIBSFLFUFHFÎFMJN CJ[FWFÎFWSFNJ[F[BSBSWFSNFZFDFLFOJZJ
ÎÚ[àNZPMVOVTFÎFMJNWFVZHVMBZBM‘NwEFS½þSFUJDJ CVUFLOJþJCJSLBÎLFSFIFNLFOEJTJ
IFNEFÎPDVLMBSBUFLSBSFUUJSFSFLJZJDFÚþSFONFMFSJOJTBþMBSWFÚGLFIÉMJOEFOFSFEFPMVSMBS
TBUSBmL‘ā‘LMBS‘UFLOJþJOJBL‘MMBS‘OBHFUJSNFMFSJOJJTUFS#VVZHVMBNBEBOTPOSBÚþSFUJDJZFOJ
CJSUFLOJþJVZHVMBNBLJÎJOÎPDVLMBS‘T‘O‘G‘OPSUBT‘OBUPQMBSWFÚþSFOFDFLMFSJCVUFLOJLMFSMF
ÚGLFMFSJOJOBT‘MLPOUSPMFEFDFLMFSJOJWFà[àOUàMàIÉMMFSEFOOBT‘MLVSUVMBDBLMBS‘O‘ÚþSFONJā
PMBDBLMBS‘O‘CFMJSUJS

268
ÿ-&5ÿĀÿ.7&ÿ-&5ÿĀÿ.&/(&--&3ÿ:-&#"Ā&5.&

6ZHVMBNB
±PDVLMBSJÎJÎFJLJÎFNCFSPMVāUVSBDBLāFLJMEFPUVSUVMVS
ÿÎÎFNCFSEFLJMFSÚGLFMFOEJLMFSJOEFLFOEJMFSJOJOBT‘MLPOUSPMFEFDFLMFSJOJWFà[àMEàL
MFSJOEFOBT‘MUFTLJOFEFDFLMFSJOJUBSU‘ā‘SMBS%‘āÎFNCFSEFLJMFSJTFUBSU‘āNBZ‘J[MFSWFJÎÎFN
CFSEFLJMFSFTPSVTPSBCJMJSMFSÿÎÎFNCFSEFLJÎPDVLMBSE‘āÎFNCFSEFLJÎPDVLMBSMBZFSEFþJāUJ
SFCJMJSMFS

6ZHVMBNB
½þSFUJDJT‘O‘G‘OVZHVOZFSJOFCJSÎFNCFSÎJ[FS
±FNCFSJOPSUBT‘OBCJSCPāTBOEBMZFLPOVS
4‘O‘G‘OUàNàÎFNCFSJOE‘ā‘OEBE‘S
 ,POV IBLL‘OEB ZPSVN ZBQNBL JTUFZFO TBOEBMZFZF PUVSVS  EàāàODFTJOJ TÚZMFS WF
ÎFNCFSJOE‘ā‘OBΑLBS
±FNCFSJOE‘ā‘OEBLJEJþFSÎPDVLMBSUBSU‘āNBZ‘J[MFS EàāàOàSWFLBU‘M‘ND‘MBSBEÚOàUMFS
WFSJSMFS
 5BSU‘āNBZ‘ ZBQ‘MBOE‘SNBL WF TàSEàSNFL JÎJO ÚGLF LPOUSPMàOàO OBT‘M TBþMBOBDBþ‘ WF
à[àOUàOàOOBT‘MUFTLJOFEJMFDFþJJMFJMHJMJÚODFEFOCJSTPSVMJTUFTJIB[‘SMBONBM‘E‘S
 (Ú[MFNDJMFS UBSU‘āNB T‘SBT‘OEB OPU BMNBM‘  UBSU‘āNB TPOVOEB T‘O‘GB UBSU‘āNBO‘O Ú[FUJ
TVOVMNBM‘E‘S
6ZHVMBNBMBS TPOSBT‘OEB ÎPDVLMBS‘O LPOVZMB BMBLBM‘ mLJSMFSJZMF CJSMJLUF  ÚGLFZJ LPOUSPM
FUNFZÚOUFNMFSJāVāFLJMEFCFMJSMFOFCJMJS
 ½GLFZF ZBLBMBOE‘LUBO TPOSB EVSVO )FSIBOHJ CJS DàNMFOJO ZBS‘T‘OEBZTBO‘[ TVTVO
CFMLJ TBEFDF LBSā‘O‘[EBLJ LJāJOJO GBSL FEFCJMNFTJ JÎJO i4JOJSMFOJZPSVNw EJZFCJMJSTJOJ[ 
IBSFLFU IÉMJOEF PMBCJMJSTJOJ[  EVSVO )FS OF ZBQ‘ZPSTBO‘[ EVSVO ,FOEJOJ[F CJS EVSNB
BOBIUBS‘PMVāUVSVO
,FOEJOJ[FBMBOPMVāUVSVO#VMVOEVþVOV[PSUBNEBOV[BLMBā‘O
%FSJOEFSJOOFGFTBM‘QWàDVEVOV[BPLTJKFOHJSNFTJOJTBþMBZ‘O
"OBMJ[FEJO4BLJOMFāUJþJOJ[JIJTTFUUJþJOJ[[BNBOHFSÎFLUFOTJ[JCVLBEBSÚGLFMFOEJSFO
āFZJOOFPMEVþVOVBOMBNBZBÎBM‘ā‘O#JSLBÎDàNMFJMFTPSVOVUBO‘NMBZ‘O4PSVOBLBSā‘CBL‘ā
BΑO‘[HFSÎFLÎJPMTVO
±Ú[àNZPMMBS‘EàāàOàO QSPCMFNJLBGBO‘[EBHFSÎFLÎJCJSāFLJMEFUBO‘NMBE‘LUBOTPOSB
CVQSPCMFNFZÚOFMJLÎÚ[àNZPMMBS‘à[FSJOEFEàāàOàO
±PDVLMBSMBCFSBCFSà[àOUàIÉMJOEFLFOEJOJOBT‘MUFTLJOFEFDFþJOFEBJSZÚOUFNMFS
āVāFLJMEFCFMJSMFOJS
3BIBUWFHFWāFNJāCJSWB[JZFUUFTBOEBMZFZFPUVSVOWFWàDVEVOV[VHFWāFUJO

269
ÿ-&5ÿĀÿ.7&ÿ-&5ÿĀÿ.&/(&--&3ÿ:-&#"Ā&5.&

#JMJODJOJ[JG‘SU‘OBM‘CJSEFOJ[HJCJHÚSàOGBLBUEBMHBMBSHJUUJLÎFB[BMT‘O
ÿLJWFZBàÎEBLJLBHÚ[àOà[àOÚOàOFHà[FMCJSNBO[BSBHFUJSJO#VNBO[BSBEPþBEBO
ÎFLJMNJāSBIBUMBU‘D‘CJSGPUPþSBGHJCJHÚ[àOà[àOÚOàOEFPMNBM‘E‘S
4BLJOMJL IV[VSWFHàWFOWFSJDJLFMJNFMFSJWFZBDàNMFMFSJZBWBāZBWBāWFTBLJOCJSUPOMB
UFLSBSMBZ‘O
 Ã[àOUàMà WF FOEJāFMJ PMEVþVOV[ BOMBSEB HÚSàMNFZFO GBLBU àNJU WFSJDJ CJS FMJO TJ[F
ZBSE‘ND‘ PMBDBþ‘O‘ WF TJ[J ZPMEB C‘SBLNBZBDBþ‘O‘ EàāàOàO 7F IFS [BNBO POVO TJ[JO
ZBO‘O‘[EBPMEVþVOBJOBO‘O
,BGBO‘[‘OTBLJOMFāJQIV[VSBLBWVāNBT‘O‘TBþMBNBLJÎJOāVTÚ[MFSJZFOJMFZJOi,BGBN‘O
TàLßOFUF LBWVāNBT‘O‘  LBGBN‘O IÉMÉ TBLJO WF IV[VSMV PMNBT‘O‘ IFS [BNBO WF IFS ZFSEF
TBþMBNBM‘Z‘Nw

%FþFSMFOEJSNF4PSVMBS‘
½GLFNJ[JOBT‘MLPOUSPMFEFSJ[
Ã[àOUàMàIÉMMFSJNJ[EFLFOEJNJ[JOBT‘MUFTFMMJFEFSJ[

(àOàO.FTBK‘
i1FIMJWBO HàSFāNFZEBOMBS‘OEB
CBāLBMBS‘O‘ ZFOFOEFþJMEJS"T‘M
QFIMJWBOL‘[H‘OM‘LBO‘OEBOFGTJOF
IÉLJNPMBOLJNTFEJSw
.VWBUUB )àTOVM)VML 

,BQBO‘ā
(SVQàZFMFSJOFQBZMBā‘NMBS‘JÎJOUFāFLLàSFEJO
)FSLFTJOBLM‘OEBLBMBONFTBK‘QBZMBāNBT‘O‘JTUFZJO
,POVZMBJMHJMJWBSTBTPSVMBS‘O‘BM‘OWFDFWBQMBZ‘O
#JSTPOSBLJLPOVOVOCBāM‘þ‘O‘WFSJOWFWFEBMBā‘O

270
ÿ-&5ÿĀÿ.7&ÿ-&5ÿĀÿ.&/(&--&3ÿ:-&#"Ā&5.&

½þSFUJDJ/PUV
½GLFZMFJMHJMJBāBþ‘EBLJIBEJTMFSJ[BIFEJMJS
i#JSJOJ[BZBLUBZLFOÚGLFMFOJSTFIFNFOPUVSTVO½GLFTJHJEFSTFJZJ HJUNF[TFIFNFOZBUT‘Ow
&CV%ÉWVE &EFC 
iy#JSJOJ[L‘[E‘þ‘[BNBOTVTNBZ‘EFOFTJOwÿCO)BOCFM* 
i½GLFāFZUBOEBOE‘SWFāFZUBOJTFBUFāUFOZBSBU‘MN‘āU‘S"UFāJTÚOEàSFOEFTVEVS0OVOJÎJO
CJSJOJ[ÚGLFMFOJODFIFNFOBCEFTUBMT‘Ow &CV%ÉWVE &EFC 

:ÚOUFNWF5FLOJLMFS
"OMBU‘N 4PSV$FWBQ

.BUFSZBM
'PUPþSBnBS

&ULJOMJL
ZBā
½þSFUJDJ ÚODFEFOIB[‘SMBON‘āPMBOSFTJNMFSJÎPDVLMBSBHÚTUFSJS :BEBEÚSUHÚOàMMàÎP
DVLTFÎJMFSFLZà[NJNJLMFSJZMFÚGLFMJ TBLJO à[HàOWFNVUMVJOTBOJGBEFMFSJOFCàSàONFMFSJ
JTUFOFCJMJS  ½GLFMJWFTBLJO à[HàOWFNVUMVMVLJGBEFFEFOSFTJNMFSZBOZBOBTFSHJMFOJSTF
EBIBJZJPMVS 3FTJNEFLJJOTBOMBS‘OIBOHJEVZHVZVZBOT‘UU‘LMBS‘ IBOHJSFTNJOEBIBIV[VS
WFSJDJ PMEVþV  ÚGLFMJ CJS JOTBO‘O LBSā‘EBLJOF OF IJTTFUUJSEJþJ  à[HàO CJSJOJO ZBO‘OEB V[VO
TàSFLBMNBLJTUFZJQJTUFNFEJLMFSJTPSVMVS½þSFUJDJWFSJMFODFWBQMBSEBOTPOSBCVEVZHVMBS‘O
LPOUSPMBMU‘OBBM‘ONB[TBLFOEJNJ[FWFÎFWSFNJ[F[BSBSWFSFDFþJOJ ÎFWSFNJ[EFLJJOTBOMBS‘EB
CJSTàSFTPOSBSBIBUT‘[FUNFZFCBāMBE‘þ‘O‘WFJOTBO‘ZBMO‘[MBāU‘SE‘þ‘O‘TÚZMFS
½GLFMFOEJLUFOTPOSBOBT‘MTBLJOMFāUJLMFSJOJÎPDVLMBSBEBTPSBSBLÚGLFLPOUSPMZÚOUFNMFSJ
OJNBEEFMFSIÉMJOEFT‘SBMBS½þSFUJDJWFÎPDVLMBSCVZÚOUFNMFSJIFQCJSMJLUFEFOFSMFS
4J[JOFZJOÚGLFMFOEJSEJþJOJCVMVO
½GLFZFZBLBMBOE‘LUBOTPOSBIFNFOHFSJCJSFZMFNZBQ‘OLPOVāVZPSTBO‘[TVTVO ZàSà
ZPSTBO‘[EVSVO BZBLUBZTBO‘[PUVSVO
%JZBGSBNEBOEFSJOCJSTPMVLBM‘OHÚþàTUFOBM‘OBOTPMVLTJ[JSBIBUMBUNB[4PMVþVOV
[VOLBS‘OEBOHFMEJþJOJIBZBMFEJO/FGFTFH[FSTJ[JOJLF[UFLSBSMBZ‘O
i4BLJOPMw i3BIBUMBw i"ME‘SNBwHJCJ ZBU‘āU‘S‘D‘TÚ[DàLMFSJUFLSBSMBZ‘O
4J[JSBIBUMBUBO IV[VSCVMEVþVOV[CJSIBU‘SBO‘[‘ZBEBCJSNFLÉO‘IBZBMFEJO
ÿOTBOÚGLFMJPMEVþV[BNBOPMBZMBS‘BCBSU‘SWFEVSVNJÎJOEFOΑL‘MNB[CJSIÉMBM‘S%BIB

271
ÿ-&5ÿĀÿ.7&ÿ-&5ÿĀÿ.&/(&--&3ÿ:-&#"Ā&5.&

NBOU‘LM‘PMNBZBHBZSFUFEJO½SOFþJO i&ZWBI)FSāFZNBIWPMEVw iGFMBLFUwiSF[BMFUwiCV


IFSāFZJOTPOVwHJCJZPSVNMBSEBCVMVONBLZFSJOFi#VEVSVNCFOJCVOBM‘NBTàSàLMàZPS
QMBOMBS‘N‘BMUàTUFUUJ"ODBLCVEàOZBO‘OTPOVEFþJM½GLFMFOFSFLCFOCVEVSVNEBOΑLB
NBNwEJZFSFLLFOEJOJ[FUFMLJOEFCVMVOVO
4PSVOVOà[FSJOEFLPOVāNBLWBLJULBZCFUUJSJS ÚGLFZJBSUU‘S‘S±Ú[àNFPEBLMBO‘O
,FOEJOJ[FNPMBWFSJO.àNLàOTFPSUBN‘ ÎFWSFOJ[JEFþJāUJSJO
"MUFSOBUJnFSPMVāUVSNBZBÎBM‘ā‘O0MBCJMFDFLJIUJNBMMFSFLBSā‘GBSLM‘QMBOMBSZBQ‘O
#BL‘āBΑO‘[‘EFþJāUJSJO5FLSBSUFLSBSEFOFNFLUFOBTMBWB[HFÎNFZJO

"āBþ‘EBLJCJMHJMFSEFQBZMBā‘MBCJMJS
½GLF  IFS JOTBO‘O EPþBT‘OEB PMBO  UFIEJUMFSF LBSā‘ WFSJMFO EPþBM CJS UFQLJEJS 4BME‘S‘ZB
VþSBE‘þ‘N‘[[BNBONàDBEFMFFUNFNJ[JWFLFOEJNJ[JTBWVONBN‘[‘TBþMBZBOHàÎMàCJSEVZ
HVEVS%PMBZ‘T‘ZMBIBZBUUBLBMNBN‘[JÎJOZBāBNTBMCJSÚOFNJWBSE‘S%JþFSUBSBGUBOCJ[MFSJTJ
OJSMFOEJSFO L‘[E‘SBOIFSLFTFWFIFSāFZFm[JLTFMPMBSBLTBME‘SBNBZ‘[:BTBMBS TPTZBMOPSNMBS
WFTBþEVZVGSFOWB[JGFTJHÚSàS#J[FEàāFOHÚSFWCVEVZHVZVLPOUSPMBMU‘OBBMNBLU‘S%VZHV
MBSCBTL‘OIÉMEFZLFONBOU‘LM‘EàāàONFZFUJNJ[JLBZCFEFCJMJSJ[%VZHVMBS‘ZMBIBSFLFUFEFO
JOTBOMBS‘OG‘STBUCVMEVLMBS‘BOEBTVÎJāMFZFCJMFDFLMFSJOJBLM‘N‘[EBOΑLBSNBZBM‘N½[EFOF
UJN  UFMLJO WF CB[‘ FH[FSTJ[MFSMF HàÎMFOEJSJMFCJMJS .FTFMB CB[‘ BM‘āLBOM‘LMBSEBO WB[HFÎNFL 
LVMMBONBZBBM‘ā‘LPMEVþVOV[FMJEFþJMEJþFSFMJTPSVOZBSBUNBZBDBLJāMFSEF GBSFLVMMBONBL 
ÎBZLBS‘āU‘SNBL LBQ‘BÎNBLHJCJ LVMMBONBL Ú[EFOFUJNJNJ[JHàÎMFOEJSJQLFOEJNJ[FIÉLJN
PMNBN‘[BZBSE‘ND‘PMVS

±PDVLMBSBà[àOUàIÉMJOEFOFZBQU‘LMBS‘ LFOEJOJOBT‘MUFTLJOFUUJþJTPSVMVS#JSMJLUFZÚO
UFNMFSCFMJSMFOJS
3BIBUWFHFWāFNJāCJSWB[JZFUUFTBOEBMZFZFPUVSVOWFWàDVEVOV[VHFWāFUJO
#JMJODJOJ[JG‘SU‘OBM‘CJSEFOJ[HJCJHÚSàOGBLBUEBMHBMBSHJUUJLÎFB[BMT‘O
ÿLJWFZBàÎEBLJLBHÚ[àOà[àOÚOàOFHà[FMCJSNBO[BSBHFUJSJO#VNBO[BSBEPþBEBO
ÎFLJMNJāSBIBUMBU‘D‘CJSGPUPþSBGHJCJHÚ[àOà[àOÚOàOEFPMNBM‘E‘S
4BLJOMJL IV[VSWFHàWFOWFSJDJLFMJNFMFSJWFZBDàNMFMFSJZBWBāZBWBāWFTBLJOCJS
UPOMBUFLSBSMBZ‘O
Ã[àOUàMàWFFOEJāFMJPMEVþVOV[BOMBSEBHÚSàMNFZFOGBLBUàNJUWFSJDJCJSFMJOTJ[FZBS
E‘ND‘PMBDBþ‘O‘WFTJ[JZPMEBC‘SBLNBZBDBþ‘O‘EàāàOàO7FIFS[BNBOPOVOTJ[JOZBO‘O‘[EB
PMEVþVOBJOBO‘O
,BGBO‘[‘OTBLJOMFāJQIV[VSBLBWVāNBT‘O‘TBþMBNBLJÎJOāVTÚ[MFSJZFOJMFZJOi,BGBN‘O
TBLJOWFIV[VSMVPMNBT‘O‘IFS[BNBOWFIFSZFSEFTBþMBNBM‘Z‘Nw

272
ÿ-&5ÿĀÿ.7&ÿ-&5ÿĀÿ.&/(&--&3ÿ:-&#"Ā&5.&

%FþFSMFOEJSNF4PSVMBS‘
½GLFZFLBQ‘ME‘þ‘N‘[EBZBQ‘MBDBLJMLāFZOFEJS
%FSEJNJ[JCJSCBāLBT‘ZMBQBZMBāBNBE‘þ‘N‘[EBLFOEJNJ[JOBT‘MUFTFMMJFEFSJ[
i#FOIà[OàNàWFEFSEJNJBODBL"MMBIBBS[FEFSJNwBZFUJOEFOOFBOM‘ZPSTVOV[

273
ÿ-&5ÿĀÿ.7&ÿ-&5ÿĀÿ.&/(&--&3ÿ:-&#"Ā&5.&

(àOàO.FTBK‘
i½GLFZMFLBMLBO [BSBSMBPUVSVSw
"UBTÚ[à

,BQBO‘ā
(SVQàZFMFSJOFQBZMBā‘NMBS‘JÎJOUFāFLLàSFEJO
)FSLFTJOBLM‘OEBLBMBONFTBK‘QBZMBāNBT‘O‘JTUFZJO
,POVZMBJMHJMJWBSTBTPSVMBS‘O‘BM‘OWFDFWBQMBZ‘O
#JSTPOSBLJLPOVOVOCBāM‘þ‘O‘WFSJOWFWFEBMBā‘O

274
ÿ-&5ÿĀÿ.7&ÿ-&5ÿĀÿ.&/(&--&3ÿ:-&#"Ā&5.&

#"Ā,"-"3*/"4":(*
,B[BO‘N
#BāLBMBS‘O‘OEVZHVMBS‘O‘BOMBNBT‘WFTBZH‘EVZNBT‘HFSFLUJþJOJCJMJS

½þSFUJDJ/PUV
 %FSTJO CBā‘OEB FNQBUJ WF TBZH‘ LPOVTVOB WVSHV ZBQ‘M‘S WF OF PMEVþV BΑLMBO‘S
#BāLBMBS‘O‘OEVZHVWFEàāàODFMFSJOFTBZH‘EVZVMNBT‘HFSFLUJþJOJOÚOFNJBΑLMBO‘SWFUBIUBZB
)[.FWMBOBO‘OāVCFZJUMFSJZB[‘M‘S

/F0MVSTBO0M:JOF(FM
(FM HFM OFPMVSTBOPMZJOFHFM
ÿTUFSLÉmS JTUFS.FDVTJ
ÿTUFSQVUBUBQBOPMZJOFHFM
#J[JNEFSHÉI‘N‘[ àNJUTJ[MJLEFSHÉI‘EFþJMEJS
:à[LFSFUÚWCFOJCP[NVāPMTBOEBZJOFHFM
ĀVUPQSBþBTFWHJEFOCBāLBCJSUPIVNFLNFZJ[
ĀVUFSUFNJ[UBSMBZBTFWHJEFOCBāLBCJSUPIVNFLNFZJ[CJ[
#FSJHFM CFSJ%BIBEBCFSJ/JDFZFāVZPMWVSVDVMVL
.BEFNLJTFOCFOTJO CFOEFTFOJN OJDFZFāVTFOMJLCFOMJL
½MàNàNà[EFOTPOSBNF[BS‘N‘[‘ZFSEFBSBNBZ‘O‘[
#J[JNNF[BS‘N‘[ÉSJnFSJOHÚOàMMFSJOEFEJS

.FWMBOB

275
ÿ-&5ÿĀÿ.7&ÿ-&5ÿĀÿ.&/(&--&3ÿ:-&#"Ā&5.&

:ÚOUFNWF5FLOJLMFS
"OMBU‘N &þJUTFM0ZVO

.BUFSZBM
.à[JL "LÉþ‘U UBIUBLBMFNJ

&ULJOMJL
ZBā
½þSFUJDJ CVCFZJUMFSEFBOMBU‘MNBLJTUFOFOEVZHVWFEàāàODFOJOOFPMEVþVOVÎPDVLMBSB
TPSBSWFÎPDVLMBS‘ODFWBQMBS‘O‘L‘TBDBEFþFSMFOEJSJS
½þSFUJDJ  CV HJSJā WF BΑLMBNBMBSEBO TPOSB ÎPDVLMBSB CJS PZVO PZOBZBDBLMBS‘O‘ WF CV
PZVOMBFNQBUJWFTBZH‘LBWSBNMBS‘O‘OÚOFNJOJEBIBJZJÚþSFONJāPMBDBLMBS‘O‘TÚZMFS0ZVO
JÎJOCJSNà[JLWFZBCJSJMBIJCFMJSMFOJS
±PDVLMBSNà[JLFāMJþJOEFHFOJāCJSBMBOEBTFSCFTUZàSàNFZFCBāMBS±PDVLMBS ÚþSFUJ
DJOJOiÿLJBE‘NJMFSJ àÎBE‘NHFSJ TBþBEÚO TPMBEÚO LBSā‘OEBLJNWBSTBPOVOMBTFMBNMBā 
IÉMWFIBU‘S‘O‘TPSwZÚOFSHFMFSJZMFIBSFLFUFEFSMFS
.à[JLFāMJþJOEFTFSCFTUZàSàNFZFEFWBNFEJMJS.à[JLEVSEVþVOEBÚþSFUJDJOJOTFÎUJþJ
LJāJLBSā‘T‘OBEFOLHFMFOLJāJZFKFTUWFNJNJLMFSMFIFSIBOHJCJSEVZHVZV ½GLF TFWHJ L‘T
LBOÎM‘L āBāL‘OM‘L NVUTV[MVL ZPSHVOMVL LJOWC BOMBU‘S%BIBTPOSBEJþFSÎPDVLUBOEVZ
HVZVBOMBUBOBSLBEBā‘OBCBāLBCJSEVZHVZVBOMBUNBT‘JTUFOJSÿLJUBSBGBEBBSLBEBā‘O‘OIBOHJ
EVZHVZVBOMBUU‘þ‘TPSVMVS#VEVZHVOVOOBT‘MPMVāUVþVTPSVMBSMBBSBāU‘S‘M‘S CVEVZHVMBS‘O
OFEFOMFSJWFPMVNTV[EVZHVMBSMBOBT‘MCBāFEJMFCJMFDFþJUBSU‘ā‘M‘S
±PDVLMBSHSVQIÉMJOFHFUJSJMJS½þSFUJDJ IFSHSVCBCJSEVZHVWFSJS /FGSFU LJO TFWHJ 
à[àOUà  LBZH‘  LPSLV  NVUMVMVL  āBāL‘OM‘L  )FS HSVQ Jā CJSMJþJ ZBQBDBL WF CV EVZHVZV
IFZLFMāFLMJOEFEPOBSBLBOMBUBDBLU‘S(SVQMBST‘SBJMFLFOEJMFSJOFWFSJMFOEVZHVMBS‘KFTUWF
NJNJLMFSMFIFZLFMPMBSBLBOMBUNBZBÎBM‘ā‘S
0ZVOVOTPOBāBNBT‘OEB"LÉþ‘UMBS‘OBUBIUBLBMFNJZMFNVUMV à[HàO āBāL‘O L‘[H‘O
Zà[ JGBEFMFSJ ÎJ[FS WF T‘O‘G‘O PEBO‘O  IFS CJS LÚāFTJOF BTBS .VUMV LÚāFTJ  à[HàO LÚāFTJ 
L‘[H‘OLÚāFTJ āBāL‘OLÚāFTJWCLÚāFMFSCFMJSMFONJāPMVS,PNVUMBCJSMJLUFÎPDVLMBSBāJNEJ
IBOHJEVZHVIÉMJOEFZTFOJ[PLÚāFEFUPQMBO‘O EFOJMJS±PDVLMBSBOFEFOCVLÚāFZJTFÎUJLMFSJ
TPSVMVSWFDFWBQMBSBM‘O‘S

%FþFSMFOEJSNF4PSVMBS‘
&NQBUJWFTBZH‘OFEFNFLUJS
,FOEJNJ[JOWFCBāLBMBS‘O‘OEVZHVMBS‘O‘OGBSL‘OBWBSNBN‘[CJ[FOFHJCJCJSGBZEBTBþMBS

276
ÿ-&5ÿĀÿ.7&ÿ-&5ÿĀÿ.&/(&--&3ÿ:-&#"Ā&5.&

(àOàO.FTBK‘
i#JSCJSJOJTFWNFEF CJSCJSJOFBD‘NBEBWF
CJSCJSJOFāFGLBUHÚTUFSNFEFNàNJOMFSCJS
WàDVUHJCJEJS7àDVEVOCJSV[WVSBIBUT‘[
PMVODBEJþFSV[VWMBS‘EBPOBPSUBLPMVSw
#VIÉSÔ &EFC 

,BQBO‘ā
(SVQàZFMFSJOFQBZMBā‘NMBS‘JÎJOUFāFLLàSFEJO
)FSLFTJOBLM‘OEBLBMBONFTBK‘QBZMBāNBT‘O‘JTUFZJO
,POVZMBJMHJMJWBSTBTPSVMBS‘O‘BM‘OWFDFWBQMBZ‘O
#JSTPOSBLJLPOVOVOCBāM‘þ‘O‘WFSJOWFWFEBMBā‘O

277
ÿ-&5ÿĀÿ.7&ÿ-&5ÿĀÿ.&/(&--&3ÿ:-&#"Ā&5.&

½þSFUJDJ/PUV
5FO SFOLMFSJNJ[  EàāàODFMFSJNJ[  JOBOÎMBS‘N‘[  [FWLMFSJNJ[ GBSLM‘ PMTB CJMF BZO‘ HÚL
LVCCFBMU‘OEBZBāBE‘þ‘N‘[ BZO‘HàOFāUFOGBZEBMBO‘Q BZO‘UPQSBLUBOCFTMFOEJþJNJ[à[FSJOEF
LPOVāVMVS )FS JOTBO‘O EPþVN JMF ÚMàN BSBT‘OEB CFO[FS EVSBLMBSEBO HFÎUJþJ  CFO[FS
OPLUBMBS‘N‘[‘OPMEVþVHJCJ GBSLM‘OPLUBMBS‘N‘[‘OEBWBSM‘þ‘à[FSJOEFEVSVMVSÿOTBOMBS‘OBZO‘
PMBZLBSā‘T‘OEBGBSLM‘UFQLJMFSWFSFCJMFDFþJWFIFSJOTBO‘OCJSCJSJOJOEVZHVWFEàāàODFMFSJOF
TBZH‘EVZNBT‘HFSFLUJþJBOMBU‘M‘S
i&þFS"MMBI ZBQU‘LMBS‘Zà[àOEFOJOTBOMBS‘ IFNFO DF[BMBOE‘STBZE‘ ZFSZà[àOEFIJÎCJS
DBOM‘ZBSBU‘LC‘SBLNB[E‘'BLBU"MMBI POMBS‘CFMJSUJMNJāCJSTàSFZFLBEBSFSUFMJZPS7BLJUMFSJ
HFMJODF HFSFLFOJ ZBQBS  ,VāLVTV[ "MMBI  LVMMBS‘O‘ HÚSNFLUFEJSw 'ÉU‘S    BZFUJ
LFSJNFTJBΑLMBO‘S

:ÚOUFNWF5FLOJLMFS
4PSVDFWBQ BOMBU‘N

.BUFSZBM
3FTJN TFOGPOJLCJSFTFS

&ULJOMJL
ZBā
½þSFUJDJ EàOZBEBOFLBEBSJOTBOZBāBNBLUBE‘S ÃMLFNJ[JOOàGVTVOVCJMJZPSNVTVOV[ 
1FLJZBāBE‘þ‘N‘[āFISJOOàGVTVOVCJMJZPSNVTVOV[ #VJOTBOMBS‘OUFLCJSmLJSEFCVMVāNBMBS‘
NàNLàONàEàS TPSVMBS‘O‘ÎPDVLMBS‘OEBDFWBQWFSNFMFSJOFG‘STBUWFSFSFLTPSBS%BIBTPOSB
FLUFLJ FMNB SFTJNHÚTUFSJMFSFLCVOVOOFPMEVþVTPSVMVS'BSLM‘DFWBQMBSBM‘ONBZBÎBM‘ā‘M‘S
±FāJUMJ NFTMFL HSVQMBS‘OEBO JOTBOMBSB TPSVMNVā mLJSMFS  'PUPþSBGUBLJ āFLJM EPNBUFT  TBQ‘
LPQNVāCJSLJSB[ UFSTÎFWSJMNJāCJSBþBÎ JÎJL‘SN‘[‘ZBCPZBON‘āEBJSF UFODFSFāFLJMMFSJOF
CFO[FUJMEJ ÚODFEFOIB[‘SMBON‘āDFWBQLBSUMBS‘OBÚþSFUJDJUBSBG‘OEBOEFSTFCBāMBNBEBOÚODF
ZB[‘M‘SWFÎPDVLMBSBEBþ‘U‘M‘QPLVNBMBS‘JTUFOJS,àÎàLCJSUPQMVMVLUBOCJMFÎFāJUMJDFWBQMBS
BM‘OE‘þ‘ GBSLM‘CBL‘āBΑMBS‘O‘OPSUBZBΑLU‘þ‘EàāàODFTJOFWVSHVZBQ‘M‘S5FLWFCBTJUCJSSF
TJNEFOCVLBEBSGBSLM‘DFWBQMBS‘OBM‘ONBT‘O‘OāBā‘SU‘D‘PMVQPMNBE‘þ‘TPSVMVS
½þSFUJDJ  JOTBOMBS‘O GBSLM‘ EVZHV  EàāàODF WF mLJSMFSF TBIJQ PMBCJMFDFþJ WF CVOB TBZH‘
EVZNBN‘[HFSFLUJþJ GBSLM‘M‘LMBS‘OBTM‘OEB[FOHJOMJLPMEVþV POMBS‘OCBL‘āBΑMBS‘O‘OEBCJ[JN
EàOZBN‘[‘HFMJāUJSEJþJà[FSJOEFEVSVS)FSLFTEàOZBZ‘ PMBZMBS‘ FāZBMBS‘GBSLM‘ZPSVNMBZBCJ
MJSEFZJQ.FWMBOBO‘OLBSBOM‘LUBLJmMIJLÉZFTJOJBOMBUBCJMJS
,BSBOM‘LUBLJ'JM
)JOUMJMFSCJSmMJIBMLBHÚTUFSNFLJÎJOHFUJSJQLBSBOM‘LCJSBI‘SBLBQBUU‘MBS)BZWBO‘HÚS
NFLJÎJOPLBSBOM‘LZFSFCJSIBZMJBEBNUPQMBOE‘'JMFFMMFSJOJTàSNFZFCBāMBE‘MBS#JSJTJFMJOF
IPSUVNVOVHFÎJSEJ
'JMCJSPMVþBCFO[JZPS EFEJ#BāLBCJSJmMJOLVMBþ‘O‘ZBLBMBE‘

278
ÿ-&5ÿĀÿ.7&ÿ-&5ÿĀÿ.&/(&--&3ÿ:-&#"Ā&5.&

'JM ZFMQB[FHJCJCJSIBZWBO EFEJ'JMJOBZBþ‘O‘ZBLBMBZBOJTF


'JMCJSEJSFþFCFO[JZPS EFEJ
#JSCBāLBT‘EBT‘SU‘OBEPLVONVāUV
'JM UBIUHJCJ EFEJ
)FSLFTmMJOOFSFTJOFEPLVOEVZTBPOBHÚSFBOMBUNBZBCBāMBE‘)FSLFTJOFMJOEFCJSNVN
PMTBZE‘ TÚ[MFSJOEFBZL‘S‘M‘LLBMNB[E‘
%VZVHÚ[àFMF BWVDBCFO[FS BWVÎCàUàOmMJUVUBNB[LJ#VHÚ[àZVNEBIBLJLJHÚ[F
LFTJM
'BSLM‘M‘LMBS‘OHà[FMMJþJOJ IBZBUBSFOLLBUU‘þ‘O‘ÚSOFLMFOEJSNFLJÎJOPSLFTUSBÚSOFþJEF
WFSJMFCJMJS½þSFUJDJ ÎBMH‘BMFUMFSJOJOāFLJMMFSJOWFΑLBSE‘LMBS‘TFTMFSJOGBSLM‘PMNBT‘OBSBþNFO
CJS BSBZB HFMEJLMFSJOEF Hà[FM CJS FTFS PSUBZB LPZEVLMBS‘O‘ TÚZMFS #VOVOMB JMHJMJ ÚSOFLMFSJ
EJOMFUFCJMJS 4FOGPOJPSLFTUSBMBS‘O‘OFTFSMFSJOEFOTFÎJMNFTJEBIBVZHVOPMVS

279
ÿ-&5ÿĀÿ.7&ÿ-&5ÿĀÿ.&/(&--&3ÿ:-&#"Ā&5.&

%FþFSMFOEJSNF4PSVMBS‘
#BāLBMBS‘O‘OEVZHVMBS‘O‘OBT‘MBOMBZBCJMJSJ[
&NQBUJOFEFNFLUJS

(àOàO.FTBK‘
i4FOCBLNBT‘O‘CJMEFEJLFOEFHàMHÚS
%JLFOTJ[HàMàIFSLFTHÚSàSw
.FWMBOB

,BQBO‘ā
(SVQàZFMFSJOFQBZMBā‘NMBS‘JÎJOUFāFLLàSFEJO
)FSLFTJOBLM‘OEBLBMBONFTBK‘QBZMBāNBT‘O‘JTUFZJO
,POVZMBJMHJMJWBSTBTPSVMBS‘O‘BM‘OWFDFWBQMBZ‘O
#JSTPOSBLJLPOVOVOCBāM‘þ‘O‘WFSJOWFWFEBMBā‘O

280
ÿ-&5ÿĀÿ.7&ÿ-&5ÿĀÿ.&/(&--&3ÿ:-&#"Ā&5.&

(½3(Ã,63"--"3*
,B[BO‘N
ÿOTBOMBSMBPMBOJMFUJāJNEFHÚSHàLVSBMMBS‘OBVZNBT‘HFSFLUJþJOJCJMJS

½þSFUJDJ/PUV
iÿOTBOBUPQMVNJÎFSJTJOEFZBāBNBLJÎJOHFSFLMJPMBOOF[BLFULVSBMMBS‘O‘ÚþSFUFO JOTBOJ
JMJāLJMFSEFVZVMBDBLāFLJMWFÚMÎàMFSJPSUBZBLPZBOWFLJāJZJUPQMVNJÎFSJTJOEFTBZH‘WFIàSNFUF
MBZ‘LL‘MBOEBWSBO‘āāFLJMMFSJwPMBSBLUBO‘NMBOBOLVSBMMBS‘O HÚSHàLVSBMMBS‘PMBSBLBO‘ME‘þ‘WF
CVLVSBMMBSBÚ[FMMJLMFUPQMVZBāBNBMBOMBS‘OEBVZVMNBT‘HFSFLUJþJJGBEFFEJMJS#VLVSBMMBS‘O
ZBMO‘[DBOF[BLFUJDBC‘EFþJMJOTBOM‘þ‘OCJSHFSFþJPMEVþVWVSHVMBO‘S
(ÚSHàLVSBMMBS‘)VDVSÉUTVSFTJJāMFOFSFLUBNBNMBO‘SLPOVOVOUFLSBS‘WFQFLJāUJSJMNFTJ
JÎJONFLUVQPZVOVPZOBU‘M‘S

:ÚOUFNWF5FLOJLMFS
"OMBU‘N &þJUTFM0ZVO

.BUFSZBM
,àÎàL[BSGWFLÉþ‘UMBS QPTUBD‘ÎBOUBT‘

&ULJOMJL
ZBā
0ZVOJÎJOÎPDVLMBSHSVQMBSBBZS‘M‘S)FSHSVCVOZBS‘T‘ EJþFSZBS‘T‘OBCJSNFLUVQZB[BSBL
HÚSHàLVSBMMBS‘JMFJMHJMJCJSTPSVZBBΑLM‘LHFUJSNFMFSJOJJTUFS0ZVOVOEBIBEJLLBUÎFLJDJIÉMF
HFMNFTJJÎJO ÚþSFUNFOÚODFEFOSFOLMJLàÎàL[BSnBSBMBCJMJS;BSnBS‘OJÎFSJTJOEFLJLÉþ‘UMBS‘O
CJSZà[àOFTPSVMBSZB[‘M‘S LÉþ‘UMBS‘OBSLBUBSBG‘OBDFWBQWFSFDFLÎPDVLMBSDFWBQMBS‘O‘ZB[BS
4‘O‘GUBOCJSÎPDVLQPTUBD‘SPMàOFHJSFS CVÎPDVLJÎJOCJSEFQPTUBD‘ÎBOUBT‘BZBSMBO‘S1PTUBD‘ 
TPSVWFDFWBQ[BSnBS‘O‘HSVQMBSBSBT‘OEBEPMBāU‘SBSBLHFUJSHÚUàSJāJOJZBQBS#JSÎPDVLLàÎàL
LÉþ‘EBTPSVTVOVZB[BS LBSā‘HSVQUBOBSLBEBā‘OBHÚOEFSJS PEB[BSG‘BÎBSTPSVZVPLVSWF
CJMEJþJLBEBSDFWBQZB[BSWF[BSG‘QPTUBD‘ÎPDVþVOÎBOUBT‘OBLPZBS±BOUBEBLJ[BSnBSBΑM‘S 
TPSVMBSWFDFWBQMBSPLVOVSWFUBIUBZBZB[‘M‘S IFNTPSVOIFNEFÎÚ[àNàHSVQMBSUBSBG‘OEBO
PLVOVQUBSU‘ā‘M‘S½þSFUNFOLPOVCBāM‘LMBS‘O‘WFCB[‘TPSVMBS‘mLJSWFSNFTJBΑT‘OEBOUBIUBZB
ZB[BCJMJS

281
ÿ-&5ÿĀÿ.7&ÿ-&5ÿĀÿ.&/(&--&3ÿ:-&#"Ā&5.&

½SOFþJO:FNFLZFSLFOOFMFSFEJLLBUFEFSJ[ .JTBmSHFMEJþJOEFEJLLBUFUNFNJ[HFSFLFO
HÚSHà LVSBMMBS‘ OFEJS  ÿMFUJāJNEF EJLLBU FUNFNJ[ HFSFLFO LVSBMMBS OFMFSEJS  1FZHBNCFS
&GFOEJNJ[TVJÎFSLFO ZBUBSLFOOFMFSFEJLLBUFEFSEJ
(ÚSHà,VSBMMBS‘JMFBMBLBM‘LPOVCBāM‘LMBS‘
4FMBNWFSNFBEBC‘
:FNFLZFNFBEBC‘
,POVāNBBEBC‘
4VJÎNFBEBC‘
5VWBMFUBEBC‘
:BUNBBEBC‘
;JZBSFUBEBC‘

%FþFSMFOEJSNF4PSVMBS‘
(ÚSHàLVSBMMBS‘JMFOFLBTUFEJMJS
(àOMàLIBZBU‘N‘[EBCVLVSBMMBSBEJLLBUFEJZPSNVZV[
(ÚSHàLVSBMMBS‘JMFBMBLBM‘ 1FZHBNCFSJNJ[JOTàOOFUMFSJOEFOÚSOFLMFSWFSJOJ[
(ÚSHàLVSBMMBS‘OBVZNBLCJ[FOFMFSLB[BOE‘S‘S
(ÚSHàLVSBMMBS‘OBVZNBLUPQMVNBOFMFSLB[BOE‘S‘S

(àOàO.FTBK‘
i&ZJNBOFEFOMFS,FOEJFWMFSJOJ[EFO
CBāLBFWMFSF HFMEJþJOJ[JIJTTFUUJSJQ J[JO
BM‘Q FWTBIJQMFSJOFTFMBNWFSNFEFO
HJSNFZJO#VEBWSBO‘āTJ[JOJÎJOEBIB
IBZ‘SM‘E‘S%àāàOàQBOMBZBT‘O‘[EJZFTJ[F
CÚZMFÚþàUWFSJMJZPSw
/ßS 

,BQBO‘ā
(SVQàZFMFSJOFQBZMBā‘NMBS‘JÎJOUFāFLLàSFEJO
)FSLFTJOBLM‘OEBLBMBONFTBK‘QBZMBāNBT‘O‘JTUFZJO
,POVZMBJMHJMJWBSTBTPSVMBS‘O‘BM‘OWFDFWBQMBZ‘O
#JSTPOSBLJLPOVOVOCBāM‘þ‘O‘WFSJOWFWFEBMBā‘O

282
ÿ-&5ÿĀÿ.7&ÿ-&5ÿĀÿ.&/(&--&3ÿ:-&#"Ā&5.&

½þSFUJDJ/PUV
iÿOTBOBUPQMVNJÎFSJTJOEFZBāBNBLJÎJOHFSFLMJPMBOOF[BLFULVSBMMBS‘O‘ÚþSFUFO JOTBOJ
JMJāLJMFSEFVZVMBDBLāFLJMWFÚMÎàMFSJPSUBZBLPZBOWFLJāJZJUPQMVNJÎJOEFTBZH‘WFIàSNFUF
MBZ‘LL‘MBOEBWSBO‘āāFLJMMFSJwPMBSBLUBO‘NMBOBOLVSBMMBS‘O HÚSHàLVSBMMBS‘PMBSBLBO‘ME‘þ‘WF
CVLVSBMMBSBÚ[FMMJLMFUPQMVZBāBNBMBOMBS‘OEBVZVMNBT‘HFSFLUJþJJGBEFFEJMJS(ÚSHàMàJOTBO‘O
BZO‘[BNBOEBNàUFWB[‘ TBZH‘M‘ LFOEJOJNVIBUBC‘O‘OZFSJOFLPZBSBLEàāàOFCJMFO ZVNVāBL
IVZMV  LJCBS WF OB[JL CJSJ PMEVþV WVSHVMBO‘S (ÚSHà LVSBMMBS‘OB VZNBO‘O LJāJZF TBZH‘OM‘L
LB[BOE‘SE‘þ‘HJCJ CVLVSBMMBS‘OJOTBOMBS‘OCJSCJSMFSJOJTFWNFMFSJOF BOMBZ‘āM‘EBWSBONBMBS‘OB
WFTJMFPMBDBþ‘BOMBU‘M‘S
i:FNJOFEJQEVSBO BāBþ‘M‘L EBJNBLVTVSBSBZ‘QL‘OBZBO EVSNBEBOTÚ[UBā‘ZBO JZJMJþJ
IFQ FOHFMMFZFO  TBME‘SHBO  HàOBIB EBEBON‘ā  LBCB TBCB CàUàO CVOMBS‘O ÚUFTJOEF CJS EF
TPZTV[ PMBO LJNTFZF NBM WF PþVMMBS‘ WBSE‘S EJZF  TBL‘O CPZVO FþNFw ,BMFN   
BZFUJLFSJNFTJBΑLMBO‘S

:ÚOUFNWF5FLOJLMFS
4PSV$FWBQ %SBNB3PM0ZOBNB

.BUFSZBM
,BWBOP[ "LÉþ‘U

&ULJOMJL
ZBā
½þSFUJDJBāBþ‘EBZB[‘M‘EBWSBO‘āMBS‘LÉþ‘EBZB[‘QLBUMBZBSBLEFSTFHJSNFEFOÚODFLBWB
OP[VOJÎJOFBUBS±PDVLMBSEBOEBUPQMVNJÎJOEFIPāMBS‘OBHJEFOWFSBIBUT‘[PMEVLMBS‘EBW
SBO‘āMBS‘LÉþ‘EBZB[‘QCVLBWBOP[BBUNBMBS‘JTUFOJS½þSFUJDJ ÎPDVLMBSBUPQMVNJÎJOEFZB[‘
M‘PMNBTBEBVZVMNBT‘HFSFLFOLVSBMMBSPMEVþVOVWFCVOVOLàMUàSFMPMBSBLZFOJOFTJMMFSF
BLUBS‘ME‘þ‘O‘ BOMBU‘S %àOZBO‘O GBSLM‘ ZFSMFSJOEF CV LVSBMMBS VGBL EFþJāJLMJLMFS HÚTUFSTF EF
UFNFMLVSBM‘OiLBSā‘OEBLJOJSBIBUT‘[FEFDFLEBWSBO‘āMBSEBOV[BLEVSNBLwà[FSJOFLVSVMEV
þVOVIBU‘SMBU‘Si#FOHà[FMBIMBL‘UBNBNMBNBLà[FSFHÚOEFSJMEJNwEJZFOCJSQFZHBNCFSJO
àNNFUJPMEVþVNV[VVOVUNBNBLHFSFLUJþJWVSHVMBO‘SWF1FZHBNCFSJNJ[JOOF[BLFUJ Hà[FM
BIMBL‘JMFJMHJMJCJSLBÎÚSOFLWFSJMJS)VDVSÉUTVSFTJOEFHFÎFOHÚSHàLVSBMMBS‘JMFJMHJMJBZFUMFS
PLVUVMVS
%BIB TPOSB LBWBOP[EBO ÚþSFODJMFS T‘SB JMF LFOEJMFSJOF SPM TFÎFSMFS WF CVOV T‘O‘GB KFTU 
NJNJL TÚ[WFIBSFLFUMFSJZMFBLUBSNBZBÎBM‘ā‘SMBSi"OMBU‘MBOEVSVNLBSā‘T‘OEBOFZBQNBM‘ 
%PþSVPMBOIBSFLFUOFEJS wTPSVMBS‘ZMBÚþSFUJDJ ÎPDVLMBS‘O IBOHJEBWSBO‘āMBS‘OHÚSHàLVSBM
MBS‘OBVZHVOPMVQPMNBE‘þ‘O‘ CVMNBMBS‘O‘TBþMBNBZBÎBM‘ā‘S
:BQ‘MBCJMFDFLSPMÚSOFLMFSJ
"SLBEBā‘O‘OUBCBþ‘OBHÚ[àOàEJLJQPOVSBIBUT‘[FUNFL
4PNVSUBSBLUPQMVMVLJÎJOFHJSNFL
,BSā‘T‘OEBLJOJOLPOVāNBMBS‘O‘TàSFLMJLFTNFL

283
ÿ-&5ÿĀÿ.7&ÿ-&5ÿĀÿ.&/(&--&3ÿ:-&#"Ā&5.&

 "þ[‘OEBZFNFLWBSLFOLPOVāNBL
 .JTBmSJMFJMHJMFONFL
 5PQMVNJÎJOEFZàLTFLTFTMFUFMFGPOMBLPOVāNBL
 4FMBNWFSFSFLUPQMVMVþBHJSNFLWFIÉMIBU‘STPSNBL
 ,POVāVSLFOTàSFLMJLFOEJOJÚWNFL
 ½[FMLPOVāBOJLJLJāJZJEJOMFNFZFÎBM‘āNBL
 &NJSWFSFSFLLPOVāNBL
 :àSàZàāàOEFWFTFTJOEFEPþBMPMNBL
 "QBSUNBOEBNFSEJWFOMFSJLPāBSBLJONFL
 ,BQ‘Z‘TBLJODFÎBM‘QJÎFSJEFOTFTHFMFOFLBEBSCFLMFNFL
 #BāLBT‘OBBJUPEBMBSBJ[JOTJ[HJSNFL
 4FTMJCJSāFLJMEFCVSOVOVTJMNFL

%FþFSMFOEJSNF4PSVMBS‘
(ÚSHàTà[JOTBOJMFOFLBTUFEJMJS
(ÚSHàLVSBMMBS‘JMFJMHJMJ,VSBO‘,FSJNEFIBOHJBZFUMFSWBSE‘S
(ÚSHàLVSBMMBS‘OBVZNBLCJ[FOFMFSLB[BOE‘S‘S

(àOàO.FTBK‘
i"MMBI‘OSBINFUJTBZFTJOEFTFOPOMBSB
LBSā‘ZVNVāBLEBWSBOE‘O&þFSLBCB 
LBU‘ZàSFLMJPMTBZE‘O POMBSTFOJO
FUSBG‘OEBOEBþ‘M‘QHJEFSMFSEJyw
¬MJÿNSÉO 

,BQBO‘ā
(SVQàZFMFSJOFQBZMBā‘NMBS‘JÎJOUFāFLLàSFEJO
)FSLFTJOBLM‘OEBLBMBONFTBK‘QBZMBāNBT‘O‘JTUFZJO
,POVZMBJMHJMJWBSTBTPSVMBS‘O‘BM‘OWFDFWBQMBZ‘O
#JSTPOSBLJLPOVOVOCBāM‘þ‘O‘WFSJOWFWFEBMBā‘O

284
20
# "5 * -  ÿ / " / ± - " 3

.FUBm[JLWBSM‘LMBS NFMFL āFZUBO DJO IBLL‘OEBEPþSVCJMHJTBIJCJPMVS


#BU‘MJOBOÎMBS‘OEJOJNJ[EFZFSJPMNBE‘þ‘O‘CJMJS
#BU‘MJOBOÎMBS‘OLJāJZFWFUPQMVNB[BSBSM‘PMEVþVOVLBWSBS
# "5 * - ÿ / " / ± - " 3

.&5"'ÿ;ÿ,7"3-*,-"3
,B[BO‘N
.FUBm[JLWBSM‘LMBS NFMFL āFZUBO DJO IBLL‘OEBEPþSVCJMHJTBIJCJPMVS

½þSFUJDJ/PUV
½þSFUJDJZBāHSVCVOEBNFUBm[JLWBSM‘LMBSLPOVTVOVJāMFZFDFþJ[BNBOÎPDVLMBS‘O
CJMHJTJ WF NFSBL‘ ZÚOàOEF WF ÎPDVLMBS‘O NFSBL FUUJLMFSJ LBEBS CJMHJ WFSNFZF Ú[FO
HÚTUFSNFMJEJS
4PSVMBSMB LPOVZB HJSJā ZBQU‘LUBO TPOSB BME‘þ‘ DFWBQMBS EPþSVMUVTVOEB ZÚOMFOEJSNF WF
BΑLMBNBZBQNBM‘E‘S
½þSFUJDJÎPDVLMBS‘ODFWBQMBS‘OEBāFZUBOWFDJOMFSFEFþJOJMNFEJþJUBLEJSEFCVWBSM‘LMBSB
BJUBΑLMBNBZBQNBNBM‘E‘S

:ÚOUFNWF5FLOJLMFS
4PSV$FWBQ

&ULJOMJL
ZBā
½þSFUJDJBΑLMBNBMBS‘UBLJQFEFSFLT‘SBJMFBāBþ‘EBLJTPSVMBS‘TPSBSWFBME‘þ‘DFWBQMBSÎFS
ÎFWFTJOEFBΑLMBNBMBSZBQBS
4PSVMBS
t(Ú[àNà[MFHÚSFNFEJþJNJ[CJSWBSM‘LWBSN‘E‘S
t ÿMLTPSVZBWFSJMFODFWBCBHÚSFZÚOMFOEJSNFZBQ‘MBSBL UFMFTLPQ NJLSPTLPQHJCJZBS
E‘ND‘BMFUMFSMFCJMFHÚSFNFZFDFþJNJ[āFZMFSWBSN‘E‘S 
t(ÚSFNFEJþJNJ[CVWBSM‘LMBSOFMFSZBQBSMBS
½þSFUJDJ  ÎPDVLMBSEBO BME‘þ‘ DFWBQMBS EPþSVMUVTVOEB NFMFLMFS LPOVTVOEB #BLBSB 
 i1FZHBNCFS 3BCCJOEFOLFOEJTJOFJOEJSJMFOFJNBOFUUJ NàNJOMFSEF JNBOFUUJMFS 
)FSCJSJ"MMBIB NFMFLMFSJOF LJUBQMBS‘OBWFQFZHBNCFSMFSJOFJNBOFUUJMFSywBZFUJOJONFB
MJOJPLVS.FMFLMFSFJNBO‘O"MMBI‘OFNSJPMEVþVOVTÚZMFS±PDVLMBS‘OCJMHJTFWJZFTJEPþSVM
UVTVOEBNFMFLMFSJOZFNFJÎNF ZBā DJOTJZFU VZVNBL ZPSVMNBLHJCJTPNVUÚ[FMMJLMFSJPMNB
E‘þ‘O‘BOMBU‘S%VZHVMBSà[FSJOEFEVSBSBL"MMBI‘ÎPLTFWEJLMFSJ0OBJCBEFUFUUJLMFSJBOMBU‘M‘S
.FMFLMFSJOHÚSFWMFSJOJO"MMBI‘OFNJSMFSJOJZFSJOFHFUJSNFLPMEVþVBOMBU‘M‘S

286
# "5 * -  ÿ / " / ± - " 3

±PDVLMBS‘OāFZUBOMBJMHJMJTPSVMBSTPSNBT‘IÉMJOEFÚþSFUJDJ  "SÉG  i&þFSāFZUBOEBO


CJS L‘āL‘SUNB TFOJ EàSUFSTF  IFNFO "MMBIB T‘þ‘O ĀàQIFTJ[ 0  IBLL‘ZMB JāJUFOEJS  IBLL‘ZMB
CJMFOEJSwBZFUNFBMJOJPLVSIFSJOTBO‘OCB[FOBLM‘OBPMVNTV[LÚUàEàāàODFMFSHFMFCJMFDFþJOJ
BLM‘N‘[BHFMFOCVUàSEàāàODFMFSJOCJ[JLÚUàJOTBOMBSZBQNBZBDBþ‘O‘TÚZMFS#ÚZMFPMVNTV[
WFLÚUàEàāàODFMFSEFāFZUBO‘OQBZ‘PMEVþVCVOEBOCFTNFMFÎFLFSFL EVBFEFSFL "MMBIB
T‘þ‘O‘Q0OEBOZBSE‘NJTUFZFSFLLVSUVMNBN‘[HFSFLUJþJOJCÚZMFDFJZJWF"MMBI‘OTFWEJþJJO
TBOMBSPMBCJMFDFþJNJ[JBOMBU‘S
±PDVLMBS‘ODJOMFSIBLL‘OEBTPSVMBS‘WFNFSBLMBS‘PMNBT‘IÉMJOEFÚþSFUJDJ;ÉSJZÉUTVSFTJ 
BZFUi#FO DJOMFSJWFJOTBOMBS‘ZBMO‘[DB#BOBJCBEFUFUTJOMFSEJZFZBSBUU‘NwBZFUNFBMJOJ
PLVS 0OMBS‘O EB JOTBOMBS HJCJ "MMBIB LBSā‘ TPSVNMV PMEVþVOV  JNBO FUNFLMF WF JZJ JāMFS
ZBQNBLMBZàLàNMàPMEVLMBS‘O‘BOMBU‘S"MMBIBT‘þ‘OE‘þ‘N‘[EB IFSJāJNJ[FCFTNFMFJMFCBā
MBE‘þ‘N‘[EBWFEVBZBEFWBNFUUJþJNJ[EFIJÎCJSWBSM‘þ‘OCJ[F[BSBSWFSFNFZFDFþJà[FSJOEF
EVSBSBLÎPDVLMBS‘OWBSTBCVLPOVEBLJFOEJāFMFSJOJHJEFSJS

%FþFSMFOEJSNF4PSVMBS‘
#JSāFZJOHÚSàMFNJZPSPMNBT‘POVOWBSPMNBE‘þ‘BOMBN‘OBHFMJSNJ
 %FSTFTOBT‘OEBBE‘HFÎFOWBSM‘LMBSIBOHJMFSJJTFPWBSM‘LMBS‘OBE‘TÚZMFOFSFL #VWBSM‘LMB
S‘OHÚSFWMFSJOFMFSEJS

(àOàO.FTBK‘
i7FEFLJA±BM‘ā‘O±àOLàZBQU‘LMBS‘O‘[‘IFN"MMBI
HÚSFDFL IFN3FTßMà IFNEFNàNJOMFSWFIFQJOJ[
NVUMBLBPHJ[MJWFBΑþ‘CJMFO"MMBI‘OIV[VSVOB
HÚUàSàMFDFLTJOJ[P[BNBO0 TJ[FOFMFSZBQU‘þ‘O‘[‘
IBCFSWFSFDFLw
5FWCF 

,BQBO‘ā
(SVQàZFMFSJOFQBZMBā‘NMBS‘JÎJOUFāFLLàSFEJO
)FSLFTJOBLM‘OEBLBMBONFTBK‘QBZMBāNBT‘O‘JTUFZJO
,POVZMBJMHJMJWBSTBTPSVMBS‘O‘BM‘OWFDFWBQMBZ‘O
#JSTPOSBLJLPOVOVOCBāM‘þ‘O‘WFSJOWFWFEBMBā‘O

287
# "5 * - ÿ / " / ± - " 3

½þSFUJDJ/PUV
½þSFUJDJBāBþ‘EBWFSJMFOCJMHJMFSJLBU‘M‘ND‘MBSBBLUBS‘S

$ÿ/-&3
$JO TÚ[MàLUFHÚ[MFHÚSàMNFZFOWBSM‘LMBSBEFOJS(FOFMLBO‘ZBHÚSFDJOMFS NFMFLMFSEFO
WFJOTBOSVIMBS‘OEBOBZS‘ NBEEJZÚOMFSJCVMVOBOGBLBUSVITBMZÚOMFSJBþ‘SCBTBOWBSM‘LMBSE‘S
$JOMFSJOEFQFZHBNCFSMFSJWFVZBS‘D‘MBS‘WBSE‘S)[1FZHBNCFSJOIBCFSWFSEJþJOFHÚSFDJOMFS
BUFāUFOZBSBU‘MN‘āU‘S .àTMJN ;àIEWF3FLBJL  $JOMFS JNBOWFJCBEFUMFTPSVNMVEVSMBS
ÿOBOÎCBL‘N‘OEBONàNJOZBEBLÉmSPMBCJMJSMFS"NFMMFSJOFHÚSFDFOOFUFZBEBDFIFOOFNF
HJEFSMFS(FMFDFþJCJMFNF[MFS±àOLàHBZC‘"MMBIUBOCBāLBLJNTFCJMFNF[)[.VIBNNFE
TBT CJ[JNPMEVþVHJCJPOMBS‘OEBQFZHBNCFSJEJS
Ā&:5"/
ĀFZUBO LFMJNFTJ TÚ[MàLUF V[BL PMNBL  NVIBMFGFU FUNFL  ZBONBL WF IFMBL PMNBL HJCJ
BOMBNMBSB HFMJS "MMBI  JML QFZHBNCFS )[ ¬EFNJ ZBSBU‘ODB NFMFLMFSF  POB TFDEF FUNFMF
SJOJFNSFUUJÿCMJT āFZUBO IBSJÎIFQTJTFDEFFUUJMFS#ÚZMFDFJMLJTZBO LJCJS BZS‘M‘LWFEàā
NBOM‘LCBāMBE‘ "SÉG  "SU‘LāFZUBOJOTBOOFTMJOFLBSā‘PMBOCVUBWS‘O‘EàāNBOM‘L
'ÉU‘S  TBQU‘SNBL ,BTBT  WFTWFTFWFSNFL /ÉT  BMEBUNBL -PLNÉO 
 OBOLÚSMàLFUNFL ÿTSÉ  JTZBOFUNFL .FSZFN  āàQIFZFEàāàSNFL
4FCF    LÚUà JāMFSJ Hà[FM HÚTUFSNFL "OLFCßU    JÎLJ  LVNBS HJCJ FZMFNMFSJ
TFWEJSNFLMFTàSFLMJIÉMFHFUJSNJāUJS .ÉJEF  0OVOHàDàLFOEJTJOFEPTUPMBOMBSWF
"MMBIBāJSLLPāBOMBSBZFUNFLUFEJS /BIM  ĀFZUBO LVMMVLWFDJCFMFSJOJZFSJOFHFUJSFO
MFSMF"MMBIBT‘þ‘OBOMBSB[BSBSWFSFNF[ /BIM  :BS‘OL‘ZBNFUHàOàOEFHFSÎFLPSUBZB
ΑLU‘þ‘OEBāFZUBOBD[JOJWFJnBT‘O‘JUJSBGFEFSFLHFSÎFLMFSJPSUBZBLPZBDBL ÿCSÉIÔN  
BODBLCVHFDJLNJāCJSJUJSBGWFCFZBOPMEVþVOEBOLJNTFZFGBZEBT‘PMNBZBDBLU‘S
½[FMMJLMFāFZUBO‘OOFEFOPMEVþVEBWSBO‘āMBSà[FSJOEFEVSVMBSBLLPOVUBNBNMBO‘S

:ÚOUFNWF5FLOJLMFS
"OMBU‘N .BUFSZBM)B[‘SMBNB

.BUFSZBM
,BSUPO NBLBT ZBQ‘āU‘S‘D‘

&ULJOMJL
ZBā
½þSFUJDJ  LPOVZV BOMBUU‘LUBO TPOSB  āFZUBO‘O ,VSBOEB CFMJSUJMFO Ú[FMMJLMFSJOJ ÚOF
ΑLBSBDBLāFLJMEFCJSFULJOMJLZBQ‘MBDBþ‘O‘TÚZMFS±PDVLMBSMBCFSBCFSBāBþ‘EBLJÚSOFþF
CFO[FSCJSBmāÎBM‘āNBT‘ZBQ‘MBSBLHÚSàOFOCJSZFSEFTFSHJMFONFTJTBþMBO‘S

288
# "5 * -  ÿ / " / ± - " 3

Ā&:5"/*/7";ÿ'&-&3ÿ

7&47&4&
/¬4 

4"15*3."
,"4"4 

/"/,½3-Ã,
ÿ43¬ 

ÿ4:"/
.&3:&. 

ĀÃ1)&
#","3" 

ÿ±,ÿ
.¬ÿ%& 

,6."3
.¬ÿ%& 

289
# "5 * - ÿ / " / ± - " 3

%FþFSMFOEJSNF4PSVMBS‘
ĀFZUBOOFMFSJLFOEJOFJāFEJONJāUJS
$JOMFSHFMFDFLUFOIBCFSWFSFCJMJSNJ
)[¬EFNFTFDEFFEJMNFTJFNSJOFLJNJUBBUFUNFNJāUJS

(àOàO.FTBK‘
i#FO DJOMFSJWFJOTBOMBS‘BODBLCBOB
LVMMVLFUTJOMFSEJZFZBSBUU‘Nw
;ÉSJZÉU 

,BQBO‘ā
(SVQàZFMFSJOFQBZMBā‘NMBS‘JÎJOUFāFLLàSFEJO
)FSLFTJOBLM‘OEBLBMBONFTBK‘QBZMBāNBT‘O‘JTUFZJO
,POVZMBJMHJMJWBSTBTPSVMBS‘O‘BM‘OWFDFWBQMBZ‘O
#JSTPOSBLJLPOVOVOCBāM‘þ‘O‘WFSJOWFWFEBMBā‘O

290
# "5 * -  ÿ / " / ± - " 3

#"5*-ÿ/"/±-"3
,B[BO‘N
#BU‘MJOBOÎMBS‘OEJOJNJ[EFZFSJPMNBE‘þ‘O‘CJMJS

½þSFUJDJ/PUV
#BU‘M JOBOÎ  NBOU‘LTBM CJS UFNFMF EBZBONBZBO JOBOÎ WF EBWSBO‘āMBS PMBSBL UBO‘NMBO‘S
%JOJNJ[EFCBU‘MJOBOÎEFZJODFBLMBCJEBUWFIVSBGFMFSJOHFMEJþJJ[BIFEJMFSFLCJEBU‘O VNVNJ
LBOBBUFBZL‘S‘EBWSBO‘āUBCVMVONBLWFEBIBFWWFMCFO[FSJPMNBZBOCJSāFZJJLBNFFUNFLHJCJ
BOMBNMBSBHFMEJþJTÚZMFOJS"ZS‘DBIJÎCJSNBOU‘LJJ[BIBU‘CVMVONBZBO EJOBE‘OBJMFSJTàSàMàQ
CFOJNTFOFO EBWSBO‘āMBSB IVSBGF EFOEJþJ J[BI FEJMEJLUFO TPOSB UBSJIJO IFS EÚOFNJOEF
WBSM‘þ‘O‘ LPSVZBO IVSBGFMFSJO  JOTBO‘O SVI WF UBCJBU‘OB VZHVO EàāNFZFO  BLMB WF NBOU‘þB
BZL‘S‘ āFZMFS PMEVþV BOMBU‘M‘S ÿOTBOMBS‘O LBSā‘MBāU‘þ‘ QSPCMFNMFSJ ÎÚ[NFEF EPþSV ZPMMBS‘O
E‘ā‘OEB ZBOM‘āZPMMBSBTBQNBMBS‘O‘OIVSBGFMFSJJZJDFZBZH‘OMBāU‘SE‘þ‘ CVTFCFQMFVþVSVWFZB
VþVSTV[MVþVZBSBU‘MN‘āNBIMVLBUUBOCFLMFNFOJOEPþSVPMNBE‘þ‘J[BIFEJMJS
#JEBUWFIVSBGFMFSJOTPTZBMZBāBOU‘EBQSPCMFNMFSFTFCFQPMEVþV JOBOÎZBOM‘āM‘LMBS‘OEBO
EPMBZ‘ EJOÔ ZBāBOU‘EB TFLUFMFSJO PMBCJMFDFþJ  CJEBU WF IVSBGFMFSEFO LBΑO‘MNB[ JTF [BNBO
JÎFSJTJOEF JOTBOMBS UBSBG‘OEBO IVSBGFMFSJO EJOJO BTM‘OEBO TBZ‘MBCJMFDFþJ WVSHVMBO‘S ÿMFSJLJ
TàSFÎUFIVSBGFMFSJUFSLFUNFOJOÉEFUBHàOBIN‘āHJCJUFMBLLJFEJMFCJMFDFþJEFUBZMBS‘ZMBBOMBU‘M‘S

:ÚOUFNWF5FLOJLMFS
"OMBU‘N

.BUFSZBM
±BM‘āNBLÉþ‘E‘ GPUPLPQJPMBSBLÎPþBMU‘MBDBLU‘S

291
# "5 * - ÿ / " / ± - " 3

&ULJOMJL
ZBā
½þSFUJDJ  EFSTUFO ÚODF FLUF WFSJMFO ÎBM‘āNB LÉþ‘E‘O‘ ÎPDVLMBS‘O TBZ‘T‘ODB ÎPþBMU‘S #V
ÎBM‘āNB LÉþ‘E‘O‘O BNBD‘ ÎPDVLMBS UBSBG‘OEBO CBU‘M JOBOÎMBS‘O UFTQJU FEJMJQ  à[FSJOF ÎBSQ‘
JāBSFUJLPOVMBSBLCVOMBSEBOV[BLEVSVMNBT‘HFSFLUJþJOJOWVSHVMBONBT‘E‘S
½þSFUJDJ ÎPDVLMBS‘OÎBM‘āNBLÉþ‘E‘O‘EPMEVSNBT‘JÎJOCFMJSMJCJSTàSFWFSJS4àSFTPOVOEB
IFQ CJSMJLUF ÎBM‘āNB LÉþ‘E‘ LPOUSPM FEJMJS WF CBU‘M JOBOÎMBS‘O EJOJNJ[EF ZFSJOJO PMNBE‘þ‘
WVSHVMBO‘S

292
զ +(ɘ, ƻ*ǔȢ(#(

"SLBEBāMBS BāBþ‘EB ZFS BMBO LBWSBNMBSEBO CB[‘MBS‘ iEJOJNJ[DF ZBTBLMBOBO CBU‘M


JOBOÎMBSwE‘S4J[EFOÚSOFLUFHÚSàMEàþàHJCJiCBU‘MJOBOÎMBS‘wEJLEÚSUHFOJÎJOFBM‘Qà[FSJOF
ÎBSQ‘ ÎJ[NFOJ[J  iCBU‘M JOBOÎ PMNBZBOMBS‘w JTF EBJSF JÎJOF BM‘Q FUSBG‘OB ÎJÎFL ZBQSBLMBS‘
ÎJ[NFOJ[JJTUJZPSV[

)BD  
"CEFTU ,BSB,FEJ

"U/BM‘

5BIUBZB7VSNBL 5FTQJI 5FWIJU

$FCSBJM %VB /B[BS#PODVþV

7BIJZ  6þVSMV4BZ‘ ÿNBO

'BMD‘M‘L "IJSFU .JLBJM

293
# "5 * - ÿ / " / ± - " 3

%FþFSMFOEJSNF4PSVMBS‘
#BU‘MJOBOÎOFEFNFLUJS
#JEBUWFIVSBGFMFSFÚSOFLMFSWFSJOJ[
%JOJNJ[CBU‘MJOBOÎMBS‘OFEFOZBTBLMBN‘āU‘S

(àOàO.FTBK‘
i&þFS"MMBITBOBIFSIBOHJCJS[BSBSWFSFDFL
PMVSTB CJMLJPOV 0OEBOCBāLBHJEFSFCJMFDFL
ZPLUVS&þFSTBOBCJSIBZ‘SEJMFSTF 0OVO
MàUGVOVFOHFMMFZFCJMFDFLEFZPLUVS0CVOV
LVMMBS‘OEBOEJMFEJþJOFFSJāUJSJS0 ÎPL
CBþ‘āMBZ‘D‘E‘S ÎPLNFSIBNFUFEJDJEJSw
:ßOVT 

,BQBO‘ā
(SVQàZFMFSJOFQBZMBā‘NMBS‘JÎJOUFāFLLàSFEJO
)FSLFTJOBLM‘OEBLBMBONFTBK‘QBZMBāNBT‘O‘JTUFZJO
,POVZMBJMHJMJWBSTBTPSVMBS‘O‘BM‘OWFDFWBQMBZ‘O
#JSTPOSBLJLPOVOVOCBāM‘þ‘O‘WFSJOWFWFEBMBā‘O

294
# "5 * -  ÿ / " / ± - " 3

#"5*-ÿ/"/±-"3*#ÿ-ÿ:036.
,B[BO‘N
#BU‘MJOBOÎMBS‘OEJOJNJ[EFZFSJPMNBE‘þ‘O‘CJMJS
#BU‘MJOBOÎMBS‘OLJāJZFWFUPQMVNB[BSBSM‘PMEVþVOVLBWSBS

½þSFUJDJ/PUV
½þSFUJDJ i#BU‘MJOBOÎMBSUBNBNFOJOTBOMBS‘OLPSLVMBS‘OEBO EJOMFSJOJJZJCJMNFNFMFSJO
EFOWFHFMFDFLLBZH‘MBS‘OEBOLBZOBLMBOBOāFZMFSEJS#BU‘MJOBO‘āMBS‘OIFNFOIFQTJJOTBOMBS
UBSBG‘OEBOVZEVSVMNVāUVS,PSLVMBS‘O‘WFCFLMFOUJMFSJOJCJSPMBZBCBþMBNBJIUJZBD‘OEBO CBāB
HFMFOPMVNTV[MVLMBSBWFZBPMNBT‘O‘JTUFEJLMFSJāFZFTFCFQZBSBUNBBNBD‘ZMBPSUBZBBU‘MN‘āU‘S
i#BU‘MwBE‘àTUàOEFHFSÎFLE‘ā‘ EBZBOBþ‘PMNBZBOEFNFLUJS#VUàSJOBO‘āMBS‘OIJÎCJSNBO
U‘LTBMUFNFMJEFZPLUVS.BOU‘LE‘ā‘ ZàDFEJOJNJ[ÿTMBNMBBMBLBT‘PMNBZBOUFNFMTJ[EBWSB
O‘āMBSE‘SwEJZFSFLCBU‘MJOBOÎMBS‘OUBO‘NMBNBT‘O‘ZBQBS:JOFBZO‘āFLJMEFCB[‘PMBZMBS‘WFZB
OFTOFMFSJVþVSTV[MVLPMBSBLBEMBOE‘SNBO‘OEBCBU‘MJOBOÎPMEVþVOVCFMJSUJS
i5PQMVNMBS‘OPSUBLLàMUàSFMWFTPTZBMEFSEJPMBOCVCBU‘MJOBOÎMBS‘OLÚLTBMNBT‘OB[FNJO
IB[‘SMBZBO CJSÎPL TFCFQ WBSE‘S $FIBMFU  ÉEFU  HFMFOFL  HÚSFOFL  NFOm QSPQBHBOEB  ΑLBS
IFTBQMBS‘ LJāJTFM[BBnBS JOTBOMBS‘OTBGWFUFNJ[JOBOÎMBS‘O‘JTUJTNBS EJOJZBOM‘āBOMBUNBHJCJ
TFCFQMFS IVSBGFWFCBU‘MBOMBZ‘āMBS‘OPSUBZBΑLNBT‘OBWFZBZ‘MNBT‘OBOFEFOPMBOGBLUÚSMFS
EFOCB[‘MBS‘E‘SwEJZFSFLEJOJNJ[JOFNJSWFZBTBLMBS‘O‘OHBZFUOFUWFBOMBā‘M‘SPMEVþVà[F
SJOEFEVSVMBSBLCJEBU IVSBGFWFCBU‘MJOBOÎMBSBZFSPMNBE‘þ‘O‘LFTJOCJSEJMMFWVSHVMBZBSBL
BāBþ‘EBLJNFUJOà[FSJOEFOÚSOFLPMBZJODFMFNFTJZBQU‘S‘MBSBLEFSTUBNBNMBO‘S

:ÚOUFNWF5FLOJL
½SOFL0MBZÿODFMFNF

&ULJOMJL
ZBā 
½þSFUJDJ  ÎPDVLMBSB CJS IJLÉZF PLVZBDBþ‘O‘ TÚZMFZFSFL EJLLBUMF EJOMFNFMFSJOJ SJDB
FEFS"SE‘OEBOBāBþ‘EBLJNFUOJPLVNBZBCBāMBS

295
# "5 * - ÿ / " / ± - " 3

i;FZOFQ HàOFāMJ TBCBIMBS‘ ÎPL TFWFSEJ #ÚZMF HàOMFSEF LFOEJOJ EBIB JZJ IJTTFEFS 
HàOàOàOÎPLHà[FMHFÎFDFþJOFJOBO‘SE‘0TBCBIHÚ[MFSJOJBÎU‘þ‘OEBHàOFāPEBZBEPM
NVāUV CJMF ÿÎJOJ L‘Q‘S L‘Q‘S CJS TFWJOÎ LBQMBE‘ )FNFO LBML‘Q FMJOJ Zà[àOà Z‘LBE‘
)B[‘S CBOZPZBLBEBSHFMNJāLFOBCEFTUBMNBZ‘EBJINBMFUNFEJÃ[FSJOJHJZJOJQIBmG
CJSLBIWBMU‘ZBQU‘±BOUBT‘O‘EBBMBSBLPLVMZPMVOBEàāUà)FSāFZJOIBSJLBHJUNFTJPOB
LFOEJOJNVUMVIJTTFUUJSJZPSEV&USBG‘TFZSFEFSFLHJUNFLUFOTPOEFSFDFNFNOVOEVÿO
TBOMBS BþBÎMBS BSBCBMBS ZàSàEàþàCVLBME‘S‘N/FLBEBSEBHà[FMEJZFEàāàOàSLFO
CJSEFOLBME‘S‘NUBāMBS‘BSBT‘OEBLJÎJ[HJZFCBTU‘A"NBO"MMBI‘N/FPMBDBLāJNEJ EFEJ
FUSBGUBOEBEVZVMBCJMFDFLCJSTFTUPOVZMB%PþSVTVCVOVCFLMFNJZPSEV)FSāFZJOIB
SJLBHJUNFTJHFSFLFOCJSHàOEFOBT‘MCÚZMFCJSāFZZBQU‘þ‘OBJOBONBE‘A/BT‘MCBTBS‘N
"I EJLLBUTJ[ ;FZOFQ )FS āFZJ NBIWFUUJO EJZFSFL PLVMVOB LPāBS BE‘NMBSMB HJSEJ
4BCBILJ;FZOFQUFOFTFSLBMNBN‘āU‘0ZTBHàOFāTBCBIVZBOE‘þ‘HàOFāUJ)BWBFOB[
FWEFOΑLU‘þ‘[BNBOLJLBEBSHà[FMEJ"NB;FZOFQJOCBTU‘þ‘ÎJ[HJIFSāFZJBMUàTUFUNF
ZFZFUNJāUJyw
½þSFUJDJNFUOJPLVNBZ‘CVSBEBC‘SBLBSBL BāBþ‘EBLJTPSVMBSÎFSÎFWFTJOEFNFUJOJO
DFMFNFTJZBQU‘S‘S
t;FZOFQJOHàOàOFEFOJZJCBāMBE‘
t;FZOFQJONPSBMJOFEFOCP[VMEV
t;FZOFQOFZJVþVSMVOFZJVþVSTV[HÚSNFLUFEJS
t)BWBO‘OHà[FMZBEBLÚUàPMNBT‘HàOàNà[àOOBT‘MHFÎFDFþJOJCFMJSMFSNJ
t4J[DF;FZOFQJOCBTU‘þ‘ÎJ[HJPOVOHàOàOàOLÚUàHFÎNFTJJÎJOCJSOFEFONJEJS
t#VUJQPMVNTV[UBL‘OU‘WFCBU‘MJOBOÎMBSIBZBU‘N‘[‘OBT‘MFULJMFS
½þSFUJDJBāBþ‘EBLJNFUOJPLVZBSBLEFSTFEFWBNFEFS
i;FZOFQJODBO‘PLBEBST‘L‘ME‘LJBSLBEBāMBS‘OBTFMBNEBIJWFSNFEFOZFSJOFHFÎUJ
:BO‘OBHFMJQPUVSBOT‘SBBSLBEBā‘O‘OEBGBSL‘OEBEFþJMEJ½þSFUNFOMFS[JMJÎBM‘QEFST
CBāMBZ‘ODB A,FTJO LÚUà CJS āFZ PMBDBL EJZF EàāàOEà ÿML EFST EàāàOEàþàOàO BLTJ
OFCJSāFZPMNBN‘āU‘#JSB[SBIBUMBSHJCJPMTBEBJÎJOEFLJT‘L‘OU‘O‘OUBNPMBSBLHFÎUJþJ
TÚZMFOFNF[EJ4‘SBBSLBEBā‘4àNFZZFJMFUFOFGGàTFΑLU‘MBS0OMBSBEBIBTPOSB.FSZFN
EFLBU‘ME‘#BIÎFEFEPMBā‘SLFOEJþFSÎPDVLMBS‘OPZOBE‘þ‘UPQBMÎBME‘BMÎBME‘WF4àNFZ
ZFOJOCBā‘OBEàāUà$BO‘ZBON‘āU‘BNBBþMBNBN‘āU‘4àNFZZF;FZOFQIFNFO4àNFZ
ZFZF TBCBI LFOEJTJOJO ZBāBE‘þ‘ DJOTUFO CJS PMVNTV[MVL ZBāBZ‘Q ZBāBNBE‘þ‘O‘ TPSEV
#ÚZMFCJSTPSVZVCFLMFNFZFO4àNFZZFāBā‘SE‘,BGBT‘OBHFMFOUPQMBEBIBÚODFZBāBE‘þ‘
CJSPMBZBSBT‘OEBCBþMBOU‘LVSNBLBLM‘OBCJMFHFMNFNJāUJA4BCBIZBāBE‘þ‘NCJSāFZMFOF
JMHJTJWBS5PQPZOBZBOMBS‘OEJCJOEFEPMBāNBZMBBMBLBM‘CFODFEFEJyw
½þSFUJDJNFUOJPLVNBZ‘CVOPLUBEBC‘SBLBSBL BāBþ‘EBLJTPSVMBSà[FSJOEFONFUJO
JODFMFNFTJZBQU‘S‘S

296
# "5 * - ÿ / " / ± - " 3

t4àNFZZFOJOCBā‘OBHFMFOUPQTJ[DFOFZMFBMBLBM‘PMBCJMJS
t;FZOFQJOÚODFLJPMBZMBSMBCBþMBOU‘LVSNBZBÎBM‘āNBT‘EPþSVCJSCBL‘āBΑT‘N‘E‘S
t4àNFZZFOJOUPQVOCBā‘OBHFMNFTJZMFJMHJMJUFTQJUJTJ[DFOFLBEBSEPþSVEVS
½þSFUJDJBāBþ‘EBLJNFUOJPLVZBSBLEFSTFEFWBNFEFS
i%FST[JMJÎBM‘ODBLPāBSBLT‘O‘GBHJUUJMFS½þSFUNFOMFS[JMJOJOBSE‘OEBOEBEFSTÚþSFU
NFOJJÎFSJHJSEJ½þSFUNFOJOT‘O‘GBHJSNFTJZMF.FSZFNJOāPLBHJSNFTJCJSPMEVA"BBB
EJZFSFLEPOBLBME‘;FZOFQJOPUVSEVþVT‘SBO‘OÚOàOEF4àNFZZFBSLBEBO.FSZFNJ
TBSTBSBLA/FPMEV 0UVSTBOBBSU‘LEFEJ.FSZFNÎPLà[HàOCJSāFLJMEFBSLBT‘SBEBPUV
SBOBSLBEBāMBS‘OBEÚOFSFLA½þSFUNFOJOHFUJSNFNJJTUFEJþJLJUBC‘FWEFVOVUUVNEFEJ
"ODBLÚþSFUNFOWFSEJþJHÚSFWJVOVUNBN‘āU‘.FSZFNLJUBC‘VOVUUVþVJÎJOÚ[àSEJMFTF
EF TPSVNMVMVLMBS‘OÚOFNJOJBOMBUBOL‘TBCJSOBTJIBUEJOMFNFLEVSVNVOEBLBM‘QEBIB
EBNBIDVQPMEV;FZOFQA%FNFLLJTBCBICJSVþVSTV[MVLEBPZBāBE‘EJZFEàāàONF
EFOFEFNFEJ4BC‘ST‘[M‘LMBEFSTJOCJUNFTJOJCFLMFEJ½þSFUNFOΑLBSΑLNB[.FSZFNF
TBCBIVþVSTV[CJSPMBZZBāBZ‘QZBāBNBE‘þ‘O‘TPSEV.FSZFNA6þVSTV[CJSPMBZN‘ 5BN
UFSTJOFVþVSMVÎPSBC‘N‘HJZNJāUJN)JÎCJSJāFZBSBNBE‘CBLTBOBEFEJw
½þSFUJDJNFUOJPLVNBZ‘CVSBEBC‘SBLBSBLBāBþ‘EBLJTPSVMBSà[FSJOEFOPMBZJODFMF
NFTJZBQU‘S‘S
t6þVSMVFāZBMBSWBSN‘E‘S
t#JSFāZBZBEBEVSVNBVþVSMVZBEBVþVSTV[OJUFMFNFTJEPþSVNVEVS
t.FSZFNJOVþVSVJāFZBSBN‘āN‘E‘S
t6þVSVOVOJāFZBSBNBE‘þ‘O‘.FSZFNOBT‘MGBSLFUNJāUJS
½þSFUJDJTPSVMBSà[FSJOEFONFUOJJODFMFEJLUFOTPOSBEJOJNJ[EFVþVSMVZBEBVþVS
TV[ TBZ‘MBO CJS āFZJO CVMVONBE‘þ‘O‘ CFMJSUJS #V UJQ CBU‘M JOBOÎMBS‘O EJOF UFST PMEVþV
HJCJBLMBWFNBOU‘þBEBUFSTPMEVþVOVCFMJSUJS#BU‘MJOBOÎMBS‘OJOTBOIBZBU‘OEBWFTPTZBM
ZBāBOU‘EBQSPCMFNMFSFTFCFQPMBDBþ‘WVSHVMBOBSBLEFSTUBNBNMBO‘S

%FþFSMFOEJSNF4PSVMBS‘
#BU‘MJOBOÎOFEJS
6þVSMVZBEBVþVSTV[TBZ‘MBOāFZMFSWBSN‘E‘S
.àTMàNBOMBS‘OCBU‘MJOBOÎTBIJCJPMNBT‘IBLL‘OEBTJ[OFEàāàOàSTàOà[

297
# "5 * - ÿ / " / ± - " 3

(àOàO.FTBK‘
%FLJi:BSBUU‘þ‘āFZMFSJOLÚUàMàþàOEFO 
LBSBOM‘þ‘ÎÚLUàþà[BNBOHFDFOJOLÚUàMàþàOEFO 
EàþàNMFSFànFZFOMFSJOLÚUàMàþàOEFO IBTFU
FUUJþJ[BNBOIBTFUÎJOJOLÚUàMàþàOEFO TBCBI
BZE‘OM‘þ‘O‘O3BCCJOFT‘þ‘O‘S‘Nw
'FMBL 

,BQBO‘ā
(SVQàZFMFSJOFQBZMBā‘NMBS‘JÎJOUFāFLLàSFEJO
)FSLFTJOBLM‘OEBLBMBONFTBK‘QBZMBāNBT‘O‘JTUFZJO
,POVZMBJMHJMJWBSTBTPSVMBS‘O‘BM‘OWFDFWBQMBZ‘O
#JSTPOSBLJLPOVOVOCBāM‘þ‘O‘WFSJOWFWFEBMBā‘O

298
# "5 * -  ÿ / " / ± - " 3

½þSFUJDJ/PUV
4JISJOHÚ[CPZBNBWFIJMFZPMVZMBJOTBOMBS‘ZBO‘MUNBBOMBNMBS‘OBHFMEJþJJ[BIFEJMJS#à
ZàOàO ÿTMBNEBOÚODFLJUPQMVNMBSEBWFEJOMFSEFEFHFMFDFLUFOIBCFSWFSNF U‘MT‘NMBUFEBWJ
FUNF DJODJMJLWFGBMD‘M‘LZBQNBLTVSFUJZMFLFIBOFUUFCVMVONBHJCJEBWSBO‘āMBSCJÎJNJOEFCJS
ΑLBSWBT‘UBT‘PMBSBLLVMMBO‘ME‘þ‘BOMBU‘M‘S
,POVZMBBMBLBM‘PMBSBL1FZHBNCFS&GFOEJNJ[JO TBT iÿOTBO‘IFMBLFEFOZFEJāFZEFO
TBL‘O‘O‘[#VOMBSOFEJSEJZFTPSVMEVþVOEBāÚZMFCVZVSEV"MMBIBāJSLLPāNBL TJIJSWFCàZà
ZBQNBL JOTBOÚMEàSNFL GBJ[ZFNFL ZFUJNNBM‘ZFNFL IBSQUFOLBÎNBLWFOBNVTVOBEàā
LàO.àTMàNBOLBE‘OMBSB[JOBJGUJSBT‘BUNBLw &CV%ÉWVE 7FTBZB  IBEJTJāFSJmJāMFOJS
4JIJSWFCàZàOàOBT‘MOJUFMJþJOJO IBZBMÔCJSāFZJIBLJLBU[BOOFUUJSFDFLāFLJMEFJOTBOSVIV
à[FSJOEFBMEBU‘D‘CJSUFTJSNFZEBOBHFUJSNFTJPMEVþVBOMBU‘M‘SÿOTBOMBS‘CJSCJSJOFEàāàSFO 
UPQMVNVCàZàLmUOFMFSFTàSàLMFZFOTJISJOEJOJNJ[DFZBTBLMBON‘āPMEVþV TJIJSMFCàZàZMF
VþSBāBOMBS‘OEàOZBEBEBBIJSFUUFEFQFSJāBOPMBDBLMBS‘WVSHVMBO‘S 5ÉIÉ 
4JIJSWFCàZàZBQNBLOFLBEBSHàOBITB.àTMàNBO‘OIFSIBOHJCJSQSPCMFNJOJÎÚ[NFL
JÎJOCàZàDàZFHJUNFTJOJOEFBZO‘āFLJMEFHàOBIPMEVþVBOMBU‘M‘S4FWHJMJ1FZHBNCFSJNJ[JO
CVEVSVNBEJLLBUÎFLUJþJi#JSLJNTFCJSTJIJSCB[BJāMFSJOJIBWBMFFUNFLJÎJONàSBDBBUFEFS
TF .VIBNNFEF TBT JOEJSJMFOEJOFLàGSFUNJāPMVSw 5JSNJ[Ô 5BIBSF  IBEJTJāFSJm
BLUBS‘M‘S

:ÚOUFNWF5FLOJL
"OMBU‘N &þJUTFM0ZVO

.BUFSZBM
#BMPOMBS

&ULJOMJL
ZBā
½þSFUJDJ T‘O‘GBHFMNFEFOÚODFāJāJSJMNJāCBMPOMBS‘Oà[FSJOFCBU‘MJOBO‘āMBSEBO TJIJS CàZà
WFGBMD‘M‘LMBBMBLBM‘TÚ[MFSJMFCVLPOVEBBZFU IBEJT Ú[MàTÚ[ BUBTÚ[àWCZB[BS5FLSBSCBMPO
MBS‘OIBWBT‘O‘JOEJSJSWFT‘O‘GBHFUJSJS%FSTFCBāMBNBEBOCVCBMPOMBSEBOT‘O‘GUBLJÎPDVLMBSB
LBS‘ā‘LIÉMEFEBþ‘U‘SWFCBMPOMBS‘āJāJSNFMFSJOJJTUFS#BMPOāJāJODFPSUBZBΑLBOZB[‘MBS ÎPDVL
MBSUBSBG‘OEBOTFTMJCJSāFLJMEFPLVOVS UBIUBZBZB[‘M‘SWFÎPDVLMBSMBCJSMJLUFEFþFSMFOEJSJMJS
"ΑLMBNBMBSEBO TPOSB ÚþSFUJDJ  à[FSJOEF PMVNTV[ NBOB PMBO CBMPOMBS‘ QBUMBUNBMBS‘O‘ JTUFS
WFÎPDVLMBSBi#J[F[BSBSWFSFOCBU‘MJOBOÎMBSEBOLVSUVMNBLCVLBEBSLPMBZPMNBTBEBCJ[JN
FMJNJ[EFEJSwEFS

299
# "5 * - ÿ / " / ± - " 3

#BMPOMBSB:B[‘MBCJMFDFL#B[‘#BU‘MÿOBO‘āMBS
,BSBLFEJHÚSNFLVþVSTV[MVLUVS
.FSEJWFOJOBMU‘OEBOZàSàNFOJOāBOTT‘[M‘LHFUJSNFTJ
"ZOBL‘SNBO‘OZ‘MVþVSTV[MVLHFUJSNFTJ
5BIUBZBWVSNBL
"ΑLVDVZVLBS‘ZBHFMFDFLāFLJMEFLBQ‘ZBBUOBM‘BTNBL
&WJOJ[JOÚOàOEFOLBSBLFEJHFÎNFTJ
OVNBSBO‘OVþVSTV[MVþV
%ÚSUZBQSBLM‘ZPODBO‘OāBOTHFUJSNFTJ

#BMPOMBSB:B[‘MBCJMFDFL#B[‘'BM±FāJUMFSJ
&MGBM‘ LBIWFGBM‘ JTLBNCJMLÉþ‘UMBS‘JMFHFMFDFþJHÚSNF TVGBM‘ BZGBM‘ QBQBUZBGBM‘WC
#BMPOMBSB:B[‘MBCJMFDFL4JIJSWF#àZàJMF"MBLBM‘"ZFUMFS
:ßOVT :ßOVT ĀVBSÉ 
'FMBL   ĀVBSÉ 
#BLBSB   ĀßSÉ 
5ÉIÉ   "SÉG 

300
# "5 * -  ÿ / " / ± - " 3

%FþFSMFOEJSNF4PSVMBS‘
#BU‘MJOBOÎOFEJS
#àZàZBQNBLMBVþSBāBOJMFCàZàZBQU‘SBOBSBT‘OEBEJOFOCJSGBSLWBSN‘E‘S
4JIJSWFCàZàOFEFOCàZàLHàOBIMBSBSBT‘OEBEFþFSMFOEJSJMNJāPMBCJMJS

(àOàO.FTBK‘
i%FLJ:BSBUU‘þ‘āFZMFSJOāFSSJOEFO 
LBSBOM‘þ‘ÎÚLUàþà[BNBOHFDFOJO
āFSSJOEFO EàþàNMFSFàGàSàQCàZà
ZBQBOàGàSàLÎàMFSJOāFSSJOEFOWF
L‘TLBOE‘þ‘WBLJUL‘TLBOÎLJāJOJO
āFSSJOEFOTBCBI‘O3BCCJOFT‘þ‘O‘S‘Nw
'FMBL 

,BQBO‘ā
(SVQàZFMFSJOFQBZMBā‘NMBS‘JÎJOUFāFLLàSFEJO
)FSLFTJOBLM‘OEBLBMBONFTBK‘QBZMBāNBT‘O‘JTUFZJO
,POVZMBJMHJMJWBSTBTPSVMBS‘O‘BM‘OWFDFWBQMBZ‘O
#JSTPOSBLJLPOVOVOCBāM‘þ‘O‘WFSJOWFWFEBMBā‘O

301
21 DUA

%VBO‘OOFEFNFLPMEVþVOVCJMJS
/JÎJOEVBFEJMNFTJHFSFLUJþJOJCJMJS
/BT‘MEVBFEJMFDFþJOJCJMJS5àLFONF[CJSHàÎLBZOBþ‘PMBOEVBO‘O
IFS[BNBOWFIFSLPāVMEBZBQ‘MBCJMFDFþJOJCJMJS
%VBMBSBIFS[BNBODFWBQWFSJMEJþJOJCJMJS
DUA

%6" ÿ#"%&5ÿ/½;Ã%Ã3
,B[BO‘N
%VBO‘OOFEFNFLPMEVþVOVCJMJS
/JÎJOEVBFEJMNFTJHFSFLUJþJOJCJMJS
%VBMBSBIFS[BNBODFWBQWFSJMEJþJOJCJMJS

½þSFUJDJ/PUV
%VBO‘O"SBQÎBCJSLFMJNFPMVQ TFTMFONFL ÎBþ‘SNBL ZBSE‘NBÎBþ‘SNBL ZBSE‘NUBMFQ
FUNFL "MMBIBZBMWBSNBL 0OEBOEJMFLUFCVMVONBL 0OBZBLBSNBLEFNFLPMEVþVBOMBU‘M‘S
%JOJNJ[EFJTFEVBO‘O "MMBI‘OZàDFMJþJLBSā‘T‘OEBLVMVOBD[JOJJUJSBGFUNFTJOJ TFWHJWFUB[JN
EVZHVMBS‘JÎJOEFMàUVGWFZBSE‘N‘O‘EJMFNFTJOJJGBEFFUUJþJCFMJSUJMJS%VBO‘OLVMVO "MMBIJMF
LVSEVþV EJZBMPH WF LÚQSà PMEVþV  CV TFCFQMF JOTBO‘O UBSJIJO IJÎCJS EÚOFNJOEF EVBEBO
V[BLLBMNBE‘þ‘WVSHVMBO‘S%VBO‘OBZO‘[BNBOEBCJSJCBEFUPMEVþV1FZHBNCFS&GFOEJNJ[JO
TBT i%VBJCBEFUJOÚ[àEàS%VBJCBEFUJOUBLFOEJTJEJSw &CV%ÉWVE 5FGSJVFCWBCJMWJUS 
5JSNJ[Ô %BBWÉU  IBEJTJZMFBΑLMBO‘S
"ZS‘DB3BCCJNJ[JO,VSBOEB i%VBO‘[PMNBTB3BCCJNTJ[FOFEJZFEFþFSWFSTJO w 'VSLÉO 
 EJZFCVZVSEVþV LVMVOEVBFUUJþJLBEBSEFþFSFIBJ[PMEVþVWVSHVMBO‘S

:ÚOUFNWF5FLOJLMFS
3PM0ZOBNB 4PSV$FWBQ

&ULJOMJL
ZBā
½þSFUJDJ ÎPDVLMBSBi%VBFEFSNJTJOJ[BSLBEBāMBS wTPSVTVOVZÚOFMUJS±PDVLMBS‘ODFWBQ
MBS‘O‘EJOMFEJLUFOTPOSBi%VBOFEJSQFLJ wEFS±PDVLMBS‘ODFWBQMBS‘OEBOTPOSBLFOEJTJEVB
JMFJMHJMJJ[BIMBSZBQBS BSE‘OEBOÎPDVLMBSBi1FLJZBQU‘þ‘O‘[EVBMBSLBCVMFEJMJZPSNV wTPSV
TVOVTPSBSWFDFWBQMBS‘EJOMFS½þSFUJDJ CBL‘OCVLPOVEB1FZHBNCFS&GFOEJNJ[CJ[MFSFOF
TÚZMFNJā EJZFSFLāVIBEJTJÎPDVLMBSMBQBZMBā‘S
i)JÎCJS.àTMàNBOZPLUVSLJ JÎJOEFHàOBIWFBLSBCBZMBNàOBTFCFUJLFTNFJTUFþJPMNB
ZBOCJSāFZJ"MMBIUBOJTUFTJOEF "MMBIPOBCVOVāVàÎāFLJMEFOCJSJTJZMFWFSNFTJO

304
DUA

:BIFNFOPLVMVOJTUFþJZFSJOFHFUJSJMJS
:BIVU"MMBILVMVOJTUFþJOJBIJSFUFTBLMBS
:BEBEJMFEJþJOJOEFOHJ CJSLÚUàMàþàPOEBOTBWVāUVSVSw
0SBEBCVMVOBOMBSEFEJMFSi0IÉMEFÎPLEVBFEFMJNw)[1FZHBNCFSCVZVSEVLJi"M
MBIEBLBCVMFEFSw #VIÉSÔ &EFCàM.àGSFE 
#VIBEJTUFOTPOSBÚþSFUJDJ ÎPDVLMBSBCJSB[EàāàONFMFSJJÎJOG‘STBUWFSEJLUFOTPOSBCJSFU
LJOMJLZBQBDBLMBS‘O‘TÚZMFZFSFLÎPDVþVTFÎFS±PDVLMBSEBOCJSJOFEPLUPSSPMàWFSJS0OVO
JāJOEFV[NBOPMEVþVOVWFLFOEJTJOFHFMFOIBTUBMBSBFOJZJUFāIJTJLPZVQJIUJZBÎMBS‘OBHÚSF
JMBÎWFSNFTJHFSFLUJþJOJTÚZMFS%JþFSÎPDVLMBSBEBIBTUBSPMàWFSJS
)BTUBEPLUPSB IBTUBPMEVþVOVTÚZMFZFDFLUJS
)BTUB IBTUBPMEVþVOVWFJMBDBJIUJZBD‘PMEVþVOV 
)BTUBJTFIBTUBPMEVþVOVJGBEFFEFSFLIBOHJJMBDBJIUJZBD‘PMEVþVOV LBÎHàOOFLBEBS
EP[LVMMBOBDBþ‘O‘LFOEJTJTÚZMFZFDFLUJS
&ULJOMJLCBāMBSWFEPLUPSSPMàOEFLJÎPDVL IBTUBZBIBTUBM‘þ‘JÎJOJMBDBJIUJZBD‘PMNBE‘
þ‘O‘WFEJOMFONFTJHFSFLUJþJOJTÚZMFSIBTUBZBāVJMBD‘āVLBEBSHàOāVEP[EBLVMMBOBDBþ‘O‘
TÚZMFSIBTUBZBLFOEJTÚZMFEJþJJMBD‘OEFþJMCBāLBCJSJMBD‘OCBāLBEP[WFCBāLBHàOTBZ‘
T‘ODBLVMMBO‘MBDBþ‘O‘TÚZMFS
&ULJOMJLCJUUJLUFOTPOSBÚþSFUJDJ&ULJOMJþJNJ[EFEFHÚSEàþàOà[HJCJÎPDVLMBSIBTUBOFJT
UFSTFJTUFTJO IBOHJJMBD‘OFLBEBSEP[ LBÎHàOLVMMBONBLJTUFSTFJTUFTJOEPLUPSFOEPþSVTVOV
CJMEJþJJÎJOPOBHÚSFCJSSFÎFUFZB[E‘#J[MFSEFEVBFUUJþJNJ[[BNBO 3BCCJNJ[CJ[JCJ[EFOJZJ
CJMEJþJJÎJOJIUJZBD‘N‘[BVZHVOPMBSBLDFWBQWFSNFLUFEJS)BEJTUFLJHJCJCB[FOJTUFþJNJ[JO
UBNLBSā‘M‘þ‘PMBSBL CB[FOEBIBEPþSVCJS[BNBOBLBEBSFSUFMFOFSFL CB[FOBIJSFUFTBLMBO‘Q 
CB[FOEFCJSLÚUàMàþàOCJ[EFOV[BLMBāNBT‘āFLMJOEFEVBMBS‘N‘[BDFWBQWFSJMFCJMJS EFS

%FþFSMFOEJSNF4PSVMBS‘
%VBOFEFNFLUJS
/JÎJOEVBFUNFMJZJ[
"MMBI EVBMBSBOBT‘MDFWBQWFSJS

305
DUA

(àOàO.FTBK‘
i%VB JCBEFUJOÚ[àEàSw
5JSNJ[Ô %BBWÉU 

,BQBO‘ā
(SVQàZFMFSJOFQBZMBā‘NMBS‘JÎJOUFāFLLàSFEJO
)FSLFTJOBLM‘OEBLBMBONFTBK‘QBZMBāNBT‘O‘JTUFZJO
,POVZMBJMHJMJWBSTBTPSVMBS‘O‘BM‘OWFDFWBQMBZ‘O
#JSTPOSBLJLPOVOVOCBāM‘þ‘O‘WFSJOWFWFEBMBā‘O

306
DUA

/"4*-%6"&%&-ÿ.
,B[BO‘N
/BT‘MEVBFEJMFDFþJOJCJMJS5àLFONF[CJSHàÎLBZOBþ‘PMBOEVBO‘O
IFS[BNBOWFIFSLPāVMEBZBQ‘MBCJMFDFþJOJCJMJS

½þSFUJDJ/PUV
%VBO‘O CFMMJ CJS GPSNBUUBO [JZBEF JIMBT WF TBNJNJZFUF EBZBONBT‘ HFSFLUJþJ BOMBU‘M‘S
,VSBO‘,FSJNEFBLM‘TFMJNTBIJCJNàNJOMFSJOHÚOàMMFSJOJ:àDF:BSBEBOBBS[FUUJLMFSJOJJGB
EF FEFO i0OMBS  BZBLUB EVSVSLFO  PUVSVSLFO  ZBOMBS‘ à[FSJOF ZBUBSLFO IFS WBLJU  "MMBI‘
BOBSMBS HÚLMFSJOWFZFSJOZBSBU‘M‘ā‘IBLL‘OEBEFSJOEFSJOEàāàOàSMFS WFāÚZMFEFSMFS 3BCCJ
NJ[4FOCVOVCPāVOBZBSBUNBE‘O4FOJUFTCJIFEFSJ[#J[JDFIFOOFNB[BC‘OEBOLPSV ¬MJ
ÿNSÉO  BZFUJLFSJNFTJJMFLPOVEFUBZMBOE‘S‘MBSBLBΑLMBO‘S

:ÚOUFNWF5FLOJLMFS
"OMBU‘N 4PSV$FWBQ

&ULJOMJL
ZBā
½þSFUJDJ ÎPDVLMBSBi/F[BNBOWFOFSFEFEVBFEFSJ[ wTPSVTVOVZÚOFMUJS5àNDFWBQMBS‘
EJOMFEJLUFOTPOSBÚþSFUJDJOPUVOEBLJBZFUJPLVSWFEVBFUNFLJÎJOÚ[FMCJSZFSWFÚ[FMCJS
NFLÉOPMNBE‘þ‘LPOVTVOEBHFSFLMJBΑLMBNBMBSEBCVMVOVS%BIBTPOSBi/BT‘MEVBFUNFMJZJ[ 
EVBFEFSLFOOFMFSFEJLLBUFUNFMJZJ[ wTPSVTVOVZÚOFMUJSWFUàNDFWBQMBS‘EJOMFEJLUFOTPOSB
i3BCCJNJ[CJ[MFSFOBT‘MEVBFEFDFþJNJ[J,VSBO‘,FSJNEFÚþSFUNJā QFZHBNCFSMFSJOEVBMB
S‘OEBOÚSOFLMFSWFSNJāUJSwEFSWFBāBþ‘EBLJBZFUMFSJÎPDVLMBSMBQBZMBā‘S

ti3BCCJN#BOBIJLNFUWFSWFCFOJJZJMFSBSBT‘OBLBUw ĀVBSÉ 


ti&Z3BCCJN#FOJWFTPZVNEBOHFMFDFLMFSJOBNB[‘EFWBNM‘L‘MBOMBSEBOFZMF&Z3BCCJ
NJ[%VBN‘LBCVMFUw ÿCSÉIÔN 
ti#BāBS‘NBODBL"MMBIUBOE‘S 0OBHàWFOEJN0OBZÚOFMJZPSVNw )ßE 

307
DUA

ti3BCCJN#FOJZBMO‘[C‘SBLNB4FO WÉSJTMFSJOFOIBZ‘SM‘T‘T‘O  IFSāFZTPOVOEBTFOJO


EJS w &OCJZÉ 
ti3BCCJN(JSFDFþJNZFSFEàSàTUMàLMFHJSNFNJTBþMBΑLBDBþ‘NZFSEFOEFEàSàTUMàLMF
ΑLNBN‘TBþMB#BOBUBSBG‘OEBO IBLL‘ZMBZBSE‘NFEJDJCJSLVWWFUWFSw ÿTSÉ 
ti3BCCJN CFOJNJMNJNJBSU‘Sw 5ÉIÉ 

%BIBTPOSBCVÚSOFLEVBMBSEBOZPMBΑLBSBLIFSLFTJOTFTMJPMBSBLCJSEVBFEJQEJþFSMF
SJOJOEFBNJOEFNFTJUFLMJmOEFCVMVOVS#VVZHVMBNBEBOTPOSBÚþSFUJDJ ÎPDVLMBSBi4J[MFS
WFSFDFþJN Nà[JL TBLJO FOTUSàNFOUBM CJS Nà[JL  FāMJþJOEF T‘O‘GUB EPMBāBDBLT‘O‘[ .à[JþJ
EVSEVSEVþVNEB LBSā‘O‘[EBLJ BSLBEBā‘O‘[MB CJSCJSJOJ[F EVB FUNFOJ[J WF Nà[JþJO CBāMBNB
T‘ZMBCFSBCFSEPMBāNBZBEFWBNFUNFOJ[JJTUJZPSVNwEFS5àNÎPDVLMBSCJSCJSJOFEVBFEFOF
LBEBSVZHVMBNBEFWBNFEFS

%FþFSMFOEJSNF4PSVMBS‘
/FSFEFWFOF[BNBOEVBFEJMJS
1FZHBNCFSMFSJOEVBMBS‘OEBOÚSOFLMFSWFSJOJ[
"SLBEBā‘O‘[BEVBFUUJþJOJ[EFWFBSLBEBā‘O‘[TJ[FEVBFUUJþJOEFOFMFSIJTTFUUJOJ[
"SLBEBāMBS‘O‘[‘OEVBMBS‘OEBOÚSOFLMFSWFSJOJ[

(àOàO.FTBK‘
i"MMBILBU‘OEB EVBEBOEBIBL‘ZNFUMJ
CJSāFZZPLUVSw
ÿCO.ÉDF %VÉ 

,BQBO‘ā
(SVQàZFMFSJOFQBZMBā‘NMBS‘JÎJOUFāFLLàSFEJO
)FSLFTJOBLM‘OEBLBMBONFTBK‘QBZMBāNBT‘O‘JTUFZJO
,POVZMBJMHJMJWBSTBTPSVMBS‘O‘BM‘OWFDFWBQMBZ‘O
#JSTPOSBLJLPOVOVOCBāM‘þ‘O‘WFSJOWFWFEBMBā‘O


DUA

½þSFUJDJ/PUV
½þSFUJDJ/PUVÎFSÎFWFTJOEFEFSTBOMBU‘M‘S

:ÚOUFNWF5FLOJLMFS
#JMJOÎLPSJEPSV 3PMZBQNB

&ULJOMJL
ZBā
½þSFUJDJTÚ[MFSJOEFHà[FMEVBDàNMFMFSJPMBOCJSāBSL‘WFZBJMBIJJMFEFSTFHJSJāZBQBS±P
DVLMBS‘OEBāBSL‘ZBFāMJLFUNFTJUFāWJLFEJMJS
ĀBSL‘ CJUUJLUFO TPOSB ÎPDVLMBSMB āBSL‘O‘O TÚ[MFSJOEFLJ EVBMBS à[FSJOF LPOVāVMVS /BT‘M
EVBTÚ[MFSJLVMMBO‘ME‘þ‘ LJNMFSFEVBFEJMEJþJ CJ[JNLJNMFSJÎJOEVBFUUJþJNJ[WFOBT‘MEVB
FUUJþJNJ[TPSVMBSBLEVBLPOVTVà[FSJOFÎPDVLMBS‘OCJMHJWFmLJSMFSJEJOMFOJS
%VB LPOVTVOEB L‘TB CJS BΑLMBNB ZBQ‘MNBT‘O‘O BSE‘OEBO CJMJOÎ LPSJEPSV PMVāUVSVMVS
ÎPDVLMBSJLJHSVCBBZS‘MBSBLLBSā‘M‘LM‘PMBSBLEJ[JMJSWFÎPDVLMBSEBOCJSLPSJEPSPMVāUVSVMVS
ÿMLPMBSBLÚþSFUJDJIBTUBCJSJOTBOSPMàZBQBSBLCVLPSJEPSEBOHFÎFSLFOÎPDVLMBSEBOCVEV
SVNBVZHVODàNMFMFSMFPOBEVBFUNFMFSJOJJTUFS"SE‘OEBOÎPDVLMBSÚþSFUJDJOJOTÚZMFEJþJZB
EBLFOEJTFÎUJLMFSJCJSEVSVNVOSPMàOàZBQBSBLT‘SBZMBLPSJEPSEBOHFÎFS)FSCJSEVSVNJÎJO
LPSJEPSVPMVāUVSBOÎPDVLMBSDBOMBOE‘S‘MBOEVSVNBVZHVOEVBDàNMFMFSJTÚZMFSMFS
½þSFUJDJÎPDVLMBS‘ODBOMBOE‘S‘MBOEVSVNBVZHVOEVBDàNMFMFSJTÚZMFNFMFSJOPLUBT‘OEB
POMBS‘ZÚOMFOEJSJSWFPOMBSBZBSE‘ND‘PMVS
4‘OBWBHJSFDFLCJSJJÎJO"MMBINVWBGGBLFZMFTJO "MMBI[JIJOBΑLM‘þ‘WFSTJO "MMBIZBSE‘N
D‘OPMTVOWC
#JSZBL‘O‘ÚMNàāCJSLJāJJÎJO"MMBITBC‘SWFSTJO NFLÉO‘DFOOFUPMTVO CBā‘O‘[TBþPMTVO 
"MMBISBINFUFZMFTJO "MMBIUBLTJSBU‘O‘BGGFUTJOWC
"NFMJZBUBHJSFDFLCJSIBTUBJÎJO"MMBIBDJMāJGBMBSWFSTJO HFÎNJāPMTVO "MMBIZBSE‘ND‘O
PMTVOWC
±PDVþVPMBOLJāJMFSF"MMBICBþ‘āMBT‘O "MMBIBOBM‘CBCBM‘CàZàUTàO .BāBMMBI
:FOJFWMFOFOMFSJÎJO"MMBINVUMVFUTJO "MMBICJSZBTU‘LUBLPDBUT‘O
:PMDVMVþBΑLBDBLPMBOMBSJÎJOIBZ‘SM‘ZPMDVMVLMBS "MMBIZPMVOV[VBΑLFUTJO "MMBILB[B
EBOCFMBEBOLPSVTVOWC


DUA

%FþFSMFOEJSNF4PSVMBS‘
,àMUàSàNà[EF EJMJNJ[FZFSMFāNJāEVBDàNMFMFSJWBSN‘E‘S
ÃOJWFSTJUFZJLB[BOBOCJSÚþSFODJZJUFCSJLFUNFLJÎJOOBT‘MEVBFEFCJMJSJ[

(àOàO.FTBK‘
i,VMMBS‘NTBOBCFOJTPSBDBLPMVSTB 
CJMTJOMFSLJ CFO āàQIFTJ[POMBSBÎPL
ZBL‘O‘N#BOBEVBFEFOJOEVBT‘O‘
LBCVMFEFSJNw
#BLBSB 

,BQBO‘ā
(SVQàZFMFSJOFQBZMBā‘NMBS‘JÎJOUFāFLLàSFEJO
)FSLFTJOBLM‘OEBLBMBONFTBK‘QBZMBāNBT‘O‘JTUFZJO
,POVZMBJMHJMJWBSTBTPSVMBS‘O‘BM‘OWFDFWBQMBZ‘O
#JSTPOSBLJLPOVOVOCBāM‘þ‘O‘WFSJOWFWFEBMBā‘O

310
DUA

5Ã,&/.&;(ñ,":/"ý*%6"
,B[BO‘N
/JÎJOEVBFEJMNFTJHFSFLUJþJOJCJMJS
/BT‘MEVBFEJMFDFþJOJCJMJS5àLFONF[CJSHàÎLBZOBþ‘PMBOEVBO‘O
IFS[BNBOWFIFSLPāVMEBZBQ‘MBCJMFDFþJOJCJMJS

½þSFUJDJ/PUV
%VBO‘O :BSBU‘D‘WFZBSBU‘MBOBSBT‘OEBLJJSUJCBU‘O[BNBO NFLÉO NJLUBS EVSVN T‘O‘S 
FOHFM LPāVMUBO‘NBZBOUFNFMHàÎPMEVþVWVSHVMBO‘S,VMVO3BCCJOFLBSā‘ZÚOFMNFTJOJOWF
TBEFDF0OEBOJTUFNFTJOJO LJāJZFTBST‘MNB[CJSÚ[HàWFOIB[JOFTJLB[BOE‘SBDBþ‘OEBOCBI
TFEJMFSFL EVBO‘OJTUFNFHàDàOàWFSFO:àDF"MMBIB BZO‘[BNBOEBCJSZBL‘OMBāNBWFTJMFTJ
PMEVþVBOMBU‘M‘S

:ÚOUFNWF5FLOJLMFS
"OMBU‘N

.BUFSZBM
±BM‘āNBLÉþ‘E‘ GPUPLPQJJMFÎPþBMU‘MN‘ā

&ULJOMJL
ZBā
#VEFSTUFÚþSFUJDJUBSBG‘OEBOÚSOFþJHFUJSJMFOÎBM‘āNBLÉþ‘E‘ÎPDVLMBSBWFSJMJS#VÎBM‘ā
NBLÉþ‘E‘WFTJMFTJZMFÎPDVLMBS‘OEVBàOJUFTJOFEBJSIBOHJLB[BO‘NMBSBTBIJQPMEVLMBS‘UFTQJU
FEJMFDFLUJS±PDVLMBSJTJNZB[NBZBDBLMBSE‘SWFFULJOMJLCJUUJLUFOTPOSBLÉþ‘UMBSLBS‘ā‘LCJS
CJÎJNEFZFOJEFOEBþ‘U‘M‘QÚþSFUJDJSFGBLBUJOEFà[FSJOFLPOVāVMBDBLU‘S

311
DUA

զ +(ɘ, ƻ*ǔȢ(#(

#ÿ3%ÃĀÃ/#","-*.

 4FOJOJÎJOEVBOFEFNFLUJS
……………………………………………………………………………………………
…………………………………….......................................................................................
 %VBFUUJþJO[BNBOOFIJTTFEFSTJO
……………………………………………………………………………………………
…………………………………….......................................................................................
 ,JNMFSJÎJOEVBFEFSTJO
……………………………………………………………………………………………
…………………………………….......................................................................................
 )BOHJ[BNBOMBSEBEVBFUNFZJTFWFSTJO
……………………………………………………………………………………………
……………………………………......................................................................................
 %VBFUNFLTBOBLFOEJOJHàÎMàIJTTFUUJSJSNJ
……………………………………………………………………………………………
……………………………………......................................................................................
 %VBFUNFZJEBIBÎPLUFSDJIFUUJþJOEVSVNMBSWBSN‘
……………………………………………………………………………………………
……………………………………......................................................................................
 /BT‘MEVBFEFSTJO
……………………………………………………………………………………………
…………………………………….......................................................................................

312
DUA

%FþFSMFOEJSNF4PSVMBS‘
i%VBwLPOVTVOVUFLCJSDàNMFJMFBOMBUNBO‘[JTUFOTFOFTÚZMFSTJOJ[
%VBLBWSBN‘OBEBJSCJSSFTJN āJJSZBIVUL‘TBIJLÉZFZB[BSN‘T‘O‘[

(àOàO.FTBK‘
i#JSJOJ[JOEVBT‘ A3BCCJNFEVBFUUJNEF
LBCVMFUNFEJ EJZFSFLBDFMFFUNFEJþJTàSFDF 
NVUMBLBLBCVMPMVOVSw
&CV%ÉWVE 5FGSJVFCWBCJMWJUS 

,BQBO‘ā
(SVQàZFMFSJOFQBZMBā‘NMBS‘JÎJOUFāFLLàSFEJO
)FSLFTJOBLM‘OEBLBMBONFTBK‘QBZMBāNBT‘O‘JTUFZJO
,POVZMBJMHJMJWBSTBTPSVMBS‘O‘BM‘OWFDFWBQMBZ‘O
#JSTPOSBLJLPOVOVOCBāM‘þ‘O‘WFSJOWFWFEBMBā‘O

313
DUA

½þSFUJDJ/PUV
½þSFUJDJ/PUVÎFSÎFWFTJOEFEFSTBOMBU‘M‘S

:ÚOUFNWF5FLOJLMFS
4PSV$FWBQ"OMBU‘N

.BUFSZBM
4PSVLBþ‘E‘

&ULJOMJL
ZBā
t½þSFUJDJTPSVLÉþ‘E‘OEBLJTPSVMBS‘T‘SBT‘JMFTPSBS
t±PDVLMBS‘ODFWBQMBS‘O‘EJOMFSLFOEJLLBUMFSJOJ FOCàZàLHàÎTBIJCJOJO"MMBIPMEVþV 
[BNBOWFNFLÉOT‘O‘S‘PMNBEBOJIUJZBÎEVZVMBOIFSBOEB0OVOMBJMFUJāJNLVSBCJMFDFLMFSJ
IVTVTMBS‘OBÎFLFS
t 4PO PMBSBL  ÎPDVLMBSB "MMBIB ZÚOFMNFOJO POMBSB WFSFCJMFDFþJ HàWFO  NBISFNJZFU 
IV[VSWFHàÎà[FSJOFL‘TBCJSBOMBU‘NZBQBSBLLPOVZVCJUJSJS
t)FSCJSTPSVZVT‘SBZMBTPSBSWFDFWBQMBS‘EJOMFSLFOT‘SBEBLJTPSVZBIB[‘SM‘LPMBDBLāFLJM
EFPOMBS‘ZÚOMFOEJSJS
4PSVMBS
t"SLBEBā‘O‘[WBSN‘
t"SLBEBāMBS‘O‘[MBOFMFSJQBZMBā‘ST‘O‘[
t#JSJZMFCVOMBS‘QBZMBāBCJMJZPSPMNBLTJ[FLFOEJOJ[JOBT‘MIJTTFUUJSJZPS
t)FSJTUFEJþJOJ[ZBEBJIUJZBÎEVZEVþVOV[BOEBBSLBEBā‘O‘[BVMBāBCJMJZPSNVTVOV[
t"SLBEBāMBS‘O‘[MBCJMFQBZMBāNBLJTUFNFEJþJOJ[āFZMFSPMVZPSNV
t)FSJTUFEJþJOJ[BOEBTJ[JZBSH‘MBNBEBO BZ‘QMBNBEBODBOLVMBþ‘ZMBEJOMFZFDFLCJSBS
LBEBā‘O‘[PMTBOBT‘MPMVSEV

%FþFSMFOEJSNF4PSVMBS‘
%VBFUNFLJÎJOCFMJSMFONJāCJS[BNBOWBSN‘E‘S
%VBFEFSFLZBMO‘[M‘L Ià[àO VNVUTV[MVLHJCJEVZHVMBSB[BMU‘MBCJMJSNJ

314
DUA

(àOàO.FTBK‘
i%FLJiĀàQIFTJ[CFOBODBL3BCCJNF
JCBEFUFEFSJNWF0OBIJÎLJNTFZJ
PSUBLLPāNBNw
$JO 

,BQBO‘ā
(SVQàZFMFSJOFQBZMBā‘NMBS‘JÎJOUFāFLLàSFEJO
)FSLFTJOBLM‘OEBLBMBONFTBK‘QBZMBāNBT‘O‘JTUFZJO
,POVZMBJMHJMJWBSTBTPSVMBS‘O‘BM‘OWFDFWBQMBZ‘O
#JSTPOSBLJLPOVOVOCBāM‘þ‘O‘WFSJOWFWFEBMBā‘O

315
22
7" 5" /  7 &  # " : 3 " ,  4 & 7 ( ÿ 4 ÿ

7BUBOTFWHJTJOJOLVUTBMCJSTFWHJPMEVþVOVCJMJS
#BZSBþBWFÿTUJLMBM.BSā‘OBOFEFOTBZH‘HÚTUFSNFTJHFSFLUJþJOJCJMJS
ĀFIJUMFSJSBINFUMFBONBT‘HB[JMFSFTBZH‘EVZNBT‘HFSFLUJþJOJCJMJS.
7"5" /  7 &  # " : 3 " ,  4 & 7 ( ÿ 4 ÿ

7"5"/4&7(ÿ4ÿ

,B[BO‘N
7BUBOTFWHJTJOJOLVUTBMCJSTFWHJPMEVþVOVCJMJS

½þSFUJDJ/PUV
7BUBO‘O  CJS LJNTFOJO EPþVQ CàZàEàþà CJS NJMMFUJO IÉLJN PMBSBL à[FSJOEF ZBāBE‘þ‘ 
CBS‘OE‘þ‘ JIUJZBÎPMEVþVBOEBVþSVOEBDBO‘O‘WFSFDFþJUPQSBLCàUàOàOFEFOEJþJBOMBU‘M‘S
7BUBOTFWHJTJOJOJTF à[FSJOEFEPþVQCàZàEàþàWFIBZBU‘O‘HFÎJSEJþJCVUPQSBLMBSJÎJOHFSFL
UJþJOEFIBZBU‘O‘GFEBFEFCJMNF UàNTPTZBMWFFLPOPNJLIBLMBSEBOGFSBHBUFEFCJMNFEVZHVTV
PMEVþVUBO‘NMBO‘S

:ÚOUFNWF5FLOJLMFS
3PM0ZOBNBWF4BOBU&ULJOMJþJ

.BUFSZBM
±BM‘āNBLÉþ‘E‘ GPUPLPQJJMFÎPþBMU‘MN‘ā Nà[JLEJOMFNFTJTUFNJ

&ULJOMJL
ZBā
½þSFUJDJWBUBOTFWHJTJZMFJMHJMJHFSFLMJLPOVBOMBU‘N‘O‘UBNBNMBE‘LUBOTPOSBāVBΑLMBNBZ‘
ZBQBSi"UBMBS‘N‘[WBUBO‘N‘[‘LPSVNBLJÎJODFTBSFUMF LPSLNBEBOTBWBāNFZEBO‘OBHJEFSMFS
EJ4BWBāUBNPSBMMFSJOJOZàLTFLPMNBT‘JÎJO NFIUFSNBSā‘ZMBTBWBāBLFOEJMFSJOJIB[‘SMBSMBSE‘
.FIUFSNBSā‘O‘ODPāLVEPMVTÚ[MFSJWFNà[JþJWBSE‘SĀJNEJTJ[JOMFCVNFIUFSNBSāMBS‘OEBO
CJSJOJÚþSFOFDFþJ[w½þSFUJDJBāBþ‘EBTÚ[MFSJWFSJMFONFIUFSNBSā‘O‘ÎPDVLMBSBÚþSFUJS&LUF
WFSJMFOANFIUFSNBSā‘TÚ[MFSJÎPþBMU‘M‘QÎPDVLMBSBEBþ‘U‘M‘S&þFSNBSā‘EJOMFNFJNLÉO‘WBSTB
NVUMBLBÎPDVLMBSBEJOMFUJMNFMJEJS
%BIBTPOSBÚþSFUJDJSPMPZOBNBJÎJOHÚOàMMàPMBOàÎÎPDVLTFÎFS"āBþ‘EBLJNFUOJÎPDVL
MBSBWFSJS.FUJOL‘TBPMEVþVJÎJOÚODFEFOV[VOTàSFIB[‘SM‘LZBQNBZBHFSFLZPLUVS½þSFUJDJ
āVBΑLMBNBZ‘ZBQBSiĀJNEJIB[‘SMBONBMBS‘JÎJOàÎBSLBEBā‘N‘[BEBLJLBTàSFWFSFDFþJN
#VTàSFEFPOMBSBWFSEJþJNNFUOJHà[FMDFPLVZBDBLMBSTPOSBEBCJ[FTVOBDBLMBSw4FÎJMFOÎP
DVLMBSEBONFUOJÎBM‘āNBMBS‘BNBLFMJNFLFMJNFF[CFSZBQNBNBMBS‘JTUFOJS±PDVLMBSFTOFL
EBWSBOBSBL EPþBÎMBNBPMBSBLLFOEJDàNMFMFSJOJLVMMBOBCJMJSMFS
½þSFODJMFSJOL‘[WFZBFSLFLPMNBT‘OBHÚSFHÚSFWEFþJāFCJMJS,‘[ÎPDVLMBSJÎJOOJOF FSLFL
ÎPDVLMBSJÎJOEFEFSPMàāFLMJOEFPMBCJMJS3PMPZOBNBJÎJOàÎÎPDVLTFÎJMJS3PMMFS/JOF
WFZBEFEF .FINFU "ZāF


7"5" /  7 &  # " : 3 " ,  4 & 7 ( ÿ 4 ÿ

/JOFUFLCBā‘OB±BOBLLBMFJMFJMHJMJCJSCFMHFTFMJ[MFNFLUFEJS"þMBE‘þ‘JÎJOHÚ[MFSJOJTJM
NFLUFEJS
.FINFU/JOFDJþJNOFEFOBþM‘ZPSTVO
/JOF"[NBO%FEFOJOBOMBUU‘LMBS‘CFOJEVZHVMBOE‘SE‘ HÚ[MFSJNEPMEVCJSEFO
.FINFU"[NBO%FEFNJ 0LJN
/JOF±BOBLLBMF4BWBā‘OEBàMLFNJ[JÎJOTBWBāBOMBSEBOTBEFDFCJSJ
.FINFU"E‘CJSB[EFþJāJLNJOF )JÎCÚZMFCJSJTJNEVZNBN‘āU‘N
/JOF#PZVJLJNFUSFZJHFÎLJO JSJZBS‘CJSJJÎJOJEFBMCJSJTJNCFODF
.FINFU7BBZÿLJNFUSFIB.BāBMMBI/FBOMBUU‘EBCVLBEBSà[àMEàOWFBþMBE‘OOJOF
/JOF4FOEFOTBEFDFCJSLBÎZBāCàZàLÎPDVLMBS‘ODFQIFEFLJDFTBSFUJOJBOMBUU‘

"ZāFZBOMBS‘OBHFMJS
"ZāF/FLPOVāVZPSTVOV[CBLBZ‘NCFOTJ[ /JOFTFOBþMBE‘ON‘ZPLTB 
.FINFU(FM"ZāFHFM/JOFNUBNTBWBāBLBU‘MBOÎPDVLMBS‘BOMBUBDBLU‘TFOHFMEJO
"ZāF"BBy±PDVLMBSIJÎTBWBāBHJEFSNJ #àZàLMFSCVOBL‘[BSCJLFSF
/JOF7BUBOMBS‘UFIMJLFEFZTFHJEFS"ZāFDJþJN)FNEFCàZàLMFSLFOEJFMMFSJZMFHÚOEFSJS
±BOBLLBMFEFPLBEBSÎPLāFIJUWFSEJLLJPOàÎPOEÚSUZBā‘OEBLJÎPDVLMBS‘OCJMFDFQIFZF
HJUNFTJHFSFLUJ
.FINFU±PDVLMBSLPSLNBN‘āMBSN‘QFLJTBWBā‘SLFO
/JOF,PSLNB[PMVSMBSN‘ 5BCJJLJLPSLNVāMBS
.FINFU/FZBQN‘āMBSQFLJ 
"MMBNF/JOF,PSLUVLÎB"MMBIBEVBFEJQIFQCJSMJLUFNBSāMBSTÚZMFNJāMFS
"ZāF(FSÎFLUFONJ #JUBOFTÚZMFTFOFOJOFDJþJN
/JOF#JSMJLUFTÚZMFZFMJNÎPDVLMBS)BZEJNFIUFSNBSā‘O‘TÚZMFZFMJN BZO‘TBWBāBDPāLVZ
MBHJEFOBUBMBS‘N‘[HJCJ

&ZāBOM‘PSEV FZāBOM‘BTLFS
)BZEJHB[BOGFS VNNBO‘TBGUFS
#JSFMEFLBMLBO CJSFMEFIBOÎFS
4FSIBEEFEPþSVFZāBOM‘BTLFS

%FSZBEBPMTBIFSāFZNV[BGGFS
%JMMFSEFUFLCJS "MMBIVFLCFS
"MMBIVFLCFS "MMBIVFLCFS
0SEVNV[PMTVOEBJNNV[BGGFS

 "ZāFHàMĀBIJO(àSCà[ "MMBNF/JOF %JZBOFU±PDVL%FSHJTJ .BSU 6ZBSMBON‘āU‘S


3PMPZOBNBUBNBNMBOE‘LUBOTPOSBEFþFSMFOEJSNFTPSVMBS‘JMFLPOVUBNBNMBO‘S


7"5" /  7 &  # " : 3 " ,  4 & 7 ( ÿ 4 ÿ

զ +(ɘ, ƻ*ǔȢ(#(

.&)5&3."3Ā*
&TLJ0SEV.BSā‘

&ZāBOM‘PSEV FZāBOM‘BTLFS
)BZEJHB[BOGFS VNNBO‘TBGEFS
#JSFMEFLBMLBO CJSFMEFIBOÎFS
4FSIBEEFEPþSVFZāBOM‘BTLFS

%FSZBEBPMTBIFSāFZNV[BGGFS
%JMMFSEFUFLCJS "MMBIVFLCFS
"MMBIVFLCFS "MMBIVFLCFS
0SEVNV[PMTVOEBJNNV[BGGFS

4Ú[MàL
(B[BOGFS:JþJU LBISBNBOBEBN
6NNBO‘4BGEFS%àāNBOTBnBS‘O‘EFMFOZJþJUMFSEFOJ[J
4FSIBUÿLJEFWMFUUPQSBþ‘O‘OCJSMFāUJþJT‘O‘S
.V[BGGFS,BISBNBO [BGFSLB[BON‘ā
5FLCJSA"MMBIVFLCFSEFNFL

320
7"5" /  7 &  # " : 3 " ,  4 & 7 ( ÿ 4 ÿ

%FþFSMFOEJSNF4PSVMBS‘
7BUBOCJ[JNJÎJOOFEFOÚOFNMJEJS
7BUBO‘N‘[BPMBOTFWHJNJ[JOBT‘MHÚTUFSFCJMJSJ[
7BUBO‘N‘[JÎJOOFMFSZBQBCJMJSJ[

(àOàO.FTBK‘
#J[JTFOTFWHJTJ[ TVTV[ IBWBT‘[
7FWBUBOT‘[C‘SBLNB"MMBI‘N
.àTMàNBOM‘LMBZPþSVMBOZVSEV 
.àTMàNBOT‘[C‘SBLNB"MMBI‘N
"SJG/JIBU"TZB

,BQBO‘ā
(SVQàZFMFSJOFQBZMBā‘NMBS‘JÎJOUFāFLLàSFEJO
)FSLFTJOBLM‘OEBLBMBONFTBK‘QBZMBāNBT‘O‘JTUFZJO
,POVZMBJMHJMJWBSTBTPSVMBS‘O‘BM‘OWFDFWBQMBZ‘O
#JSTPOSBLJLPOVOVOCBāM‘þ‘O‘WFSJOWFWFEBMBā‘O

321
7"5" /  7 &  # " : 3 " ,  4 & 7 ( ÿ 4 ÿ

7"5"/*.*±0,4&7ÿ:036.
Ka[BO‘N
7BUBOTFWHJTJOJOLVUTBMCJSTFWHJPMEVþVOVCJMJS

½þSFUJDJ/PUV
7BUBO4FWHJTJLPOVTVOVO½þSFUJDJ/PUVFTBTBM‘OBSBLEFSTBOMBU‘M‘S

:ÚOUFNWF5FLOJLMFS
(ÚTUFSJ5FLOJþJ "OMBU‘N 4PSV$FWBQ

.BUFSZBM
IUUQTXXXZPVUVCFDPNXBUDI WL6LK*%E.
$VNIVSCBāLBOM‘þ‘5FNNV[%FTUBO‘JÎJOIB[‘SMBOBOLMJCJ

&ULJOMJL
ZBā
½þSFUJDJ ÎPDVLMBSB5FNNV[%FTUBO‘LMJCJOJJ[MFUJS7BUBOTFWHJTJOJOÚOFNJOEFOCBI
TFEJMJS½þSFUJDJ WBUBOTFWHJTJIBLL‘OEB4FZJU0OCBā‘EBOCBITFEFSFLTÚ[MFSJOFEFWBNFEFS
i%FþFSMJÎPDVLMBS7BUBOTFWHJTJOJOFOHà[FMÚSOFLMFSJOEFOCJSUBOFTJEF±BOBLLBMF4BWBā‘
T‘SBT‘OEBTBWBā‘OTFZSJOJEFþJāUJSFO4FZJU"MJEJS4FZJU"MJ Z‘M‘OEB#BM‘LFTJSJO)BWSBO
ÿMÎFTJOJO±BNM‘LLÚZàOEFEàOZBZBHFMFOCJSZJþJUUJS#BCBT‘"CEVSSBINBO#FZ BOOFTJJTF
&NJOF)BO‘NE‘SZ‘M‘OEB0TNBOM‘PSEVTVOBLBU‘MBO4FZJU"MJ #BMLBO4BWBā‘OEBEB
ÎBSQ‘āU‘*%àOZB4BWBā‘CBāMBE‘LUBOTPOSB±BOBLLBMF$FQIFTJOEFUPQÎVFSJPMBSBLHÚSFWF
CBāMBE‘.BSUUFNàUUFmLEPOBONBT‘±BOBLLBMF#PþB[‘O‘HFÎNFLJÎJOTBME‘S‘ZBHFÎ
UJ4FZJU"MJ CVT‘SBEB3VNFMJ.FDJEJZF5BCZBT‘OEBHÚSFWMJZEJ
/VTSFU.BZ‘O(FNJTJOJOEBIBÚODFEFOEÚLUàþàNBZ‘OMBSWFUàSLUPQÎVTVOVOEàāNBOB
ZPþVO LBSā‘ BUFāJ  CV TBME‘S‘Z‘ QàTLàSUUà %àāNBO BU‘ā‘ TFCFCJZMF UBCZBEB CVMVOBO UPQVO
NFSNJLBME‘SBOWJODJQBSÎBMBOE‘"NBUPQNFSNJMFSJOJONVUMBLBEàāNBOBBU‘MNBT‘HFSFLJ
ZPSEV7BUBOTFWHJTJWFJNBOBāL‘ZMBEPMVPMBO4FZJU"MJ0OCBā‘ LJMPHSBNBþ‘SM‘þ‘OEBLJ
UPQNFSNJMFSJT‘SU‘OEBUBā‘ZBSBLUPQLVOEBþ‘OBZFSMFāUJSEJ
4FZJU0OCBā‘O‘OBUU‘þ‘UPQNFSNJMFSJEàāNBOHFNJTJ0DFBOBBþ‘SIBTBSWFSEJ(FNJZBO
ZBUU‘WFEBIBTPOSB/VTSFU.BZ‘O(FNJTJJMFEBIBÚODFEFOEFOJ[FEÚLàMFONBZ‘OMBSEBOCJSJ
OFÎBSQU‘WFBMBCPSBPMBSBLCBUU‘,PNVUBO4FZJU"MJOJOCVLBISBNBOM‘þ‘TFCFCJZMFi0OCBā‘w
VOWBO‘O‘WFSEJ
4FZJU0OCBā‘O‘OLJMPHSBNNFSNJZJT‘SU‘OEBUBā‘E‘þ‘HàÎ WBUBOTFWHJTJOJOHàDàEàS
7BUBOTFWHJTJOJOHàDà4FZJU0OCBā‘Z‘UBSJIJOTBZGBMBS‘OBBMU‘OIBSnFSMFLB[‘N‘āU‘S4FZJU0O
CBā‘O‘OWFCàUàOWBUBOTFWHJTJZMFEPMVHÚOàMMFSJOSVIVāÉEPMTVOw
322
7"5" /  7 &  # " : 3 " ,  4 & 7 ( ÿ 4 ÿ

%FþFSMFOEJSNF4PSVMBS‘
4J[WBUBOTFWHJTJIBLL‘OEBOFEàāàOàZPSTVOV[
7BUBO‘N‘[JÎJOOFMFSZBQNBZ‘HÚ[FBM‘ST‘O‘[
7BUBOTFWHJTJLPOVTVOEBBLM‘O‘[BHFMFOCBāLBIBOHJLBISBNBOMBSWBS

(àOàO.FTBK‘
iy"MMBIS‘[BT‘JÎJOCJSHàOOÚCFU
CFLMFNFL EàOZBWFEàOZBEBLJMFSEFO
EBIBIBZ‘SM‘E‘Syw
#VIÉSÔ $JIÉE 

,BQBO‘ā
(SVQàZFMFSJOFQBZMBā‘NMBS‘JÎJOUFāFLLàSFEJO
)FSLFTJOBLM‘OEBLBMBONFTBK‘QBZMBāNBT‘O‘JTUFZJO
,POVZMBJMHJMJWBSTBTPSVMBS‘O‘BM‘OWFDFWBQMBZ‘O
#JSTPOSBLJLPOVOVOCBāM‘þ‘O‘WFSJOWFWFEBMBā‘O

323
7"5" /  7 &  # " : 3 " ,  4 & 7 ( ÿ 4 ÿ

#":3"ý*.*;7&ÿ45ÿ,-"-."3Ā*.*;
Ka[BO‘N
#BZSBþBWFÿTUJLMBM.BSā‘OBOFEFOTBZH‘HÚTUFSNFTJHFSFLUJþJOJCJMJS

½þSFUJDJ/PUV
½þSFUJDJi#BZSBLCJSVMVTVOTJNHFTJEJS#BZSBþ‘PMNBZBOCJSàMLFCBþ‘NT‘[TBZ‘MBNB[)FS
àMLFOJOCBZSBþ‘GBSLM‘E‘SÃMLFNJ[JOCBZSBþ‘CFZB[IJMBMWFZ‘ME‘[EBOPMVāVS"SLBGPOSFOHJ
JTFL‘SN‘[‘E‘S#BZSBLFOLVUTBM‘N‘[E‘S#JSCF[QBSÎBT‘EFþJMEJSĀFIJULBOMBS‘JMFTVMBOBOCBZ
SBþ‘N‘[ WBUBO‘OFOL‘ZNFUMJIB[JOFTJEJS
ÿTUJLMBM.BSā‘ CBþ‘NT‘[M‘þ‘N‘[‘OTJNHFTJEJS/JDFÎJMFWF[PSMVLMBSMBàMLFNJ[JOCBþ‘NT‘[
M‘þ‘JÎJONàDBEFMFFEFOLBISBNBO.FINFUÎJþJNJ[FWFNJMMFUJNJ[FJUIBGFOLBMFNFBM‘ON‘āU‘S
.FINFU"LJG&STPZVOZàSFþJOEFLJWBUBOTFWHJTJ LBMFNFEÚLàMNàāWFNJMMÔNBSā‘N‘[PMBSBL
LBCVMFEJMNJāUJSwEFS4POSBT‘OEBCBZSBLWFÿTUJLMBM.BSā‘IBLL‘OEBL‘TBCJSTPICFUZBQ‘M‘S

:ÚOUFNWF5FLOJLMFS
.FUJOÿODFMFNF

.BUFSZBM
)JLÉZFNFUOJ

&ULJOMJL
ZBā
½þSFUJDJÎPDVLMBS‘OSBIBUCJSāFLJMEFPUVSNBMBS‘O‘JTUFSWFāVBΑLMBNBZ‘ZBQBSi±PDVLMBS
āJNEJSBIBUÎBBSLBO‘[BZBTMBO‘Q HÚ[MFSJOJ[JLBQBNBO‘[‘WFLFOEJOJ[JL‘SN‘[‘CFZB[CJS5àSL
CBZSBþ‘HJCJIBZBMFUNFOJ[JJTUJZPSVNĀJNEJTJ[FCJSCBZSBþ‘OEJMJOEFOZB[‘MN‘āCJSIJLÉZF
PLVZBDBþ‘N(Ú[MFSJOJ[JLBQBU‘OWFCFOJEJLLBUMJDFEJOMFZJO LFOEJOJ[JIJLÉZFEFLJ5àSLCBZ
SBþ‘HJCJIBZBMFEJO)B[‘STBO‘[CBāM‘ZPSVNw½þSFUJDJFULJMFZJDJTFTUPOVZMBIJLÉZFZJPLVS
)ÿ,¬:&
#FOĀBOM‘#JS5BSJIJN
5ÚSFOCJSB[EBOCBāMBZBDBL4‘O‘nBS‘O‘CPāBMUBOÚþSFODJMFSUÚSFOBMBO‘OBEPþSVΑþM‘LΑþ
M‘þBJMFSMJZPSMBS±PDVLMBS‘OIFQTJCJSÉMFN)FSIBGUBCBā‘OEBWFTPOVOEBBZO‘NBO[BSBZMB
LBSā‘LBSā‘ZBZ‘N)FSLBGBEBOCJSTFTΑL‘ZPSĀBSL‘TÚZMFZFOMFS CBþ‘SBOMBS EFSTTPSBOMBS
)BCJSEFTFTTJ[DFUÚSFOJCFLMFZFOMFS)FQTJOJUFLUFLTà[àZPSVN#JMJZPSVN CVÎPDVL
MBS‘OIFQTJCJSCJSJOEFOL‘ZNFUMJ)FQTJOEFCBNCBāLBDFWIFSMFSWBS,JNCJMJSJÎMFSJOEFOF
CàZàLBEBNMBSWBS #VÎPDVLMBSCFOJNWFCFOCVÎPDVLMBSBFNBOFUJN

324
7"5" /  7 &  # " : 3 " ,  4 & 7 ( ÿ 4 ÿ

4FTTJ[MJLCJSUàSMàTBþMBOBNBE‘þ‘OEBOUÚSFOHFÎCBāM‘ZPS"ICVÎPDVLMBSCJSLBÎEBLJ
LBM‘þ‘OBTFTTJ[LBMTBMBS(ÚOEFSFÎFLJMEJþJNIÉMEFCFOJHÚSNF[NJāHJCJEBWSBOBOÎPDVLMBS
CFOJHFSÎFLUFOà[àZPS#FOTBEFDFL‘SN‘[‘CJSCF[QBSÎBT‘EFþJMJNLJ4‘SBEBOCJSFāZBEB
EFþJMJN
#FOāBOM‘CJSUBSJIJN LVUMV[BGFSMFSJOTFTJZJN BZE‘OM‘LHFMFDFþJN āFIJUMFSJOFNBOFUJZJN
Ú[HàSMàþàO CÚMàONF[CàUàOMàþàOTJNHFTJZJN#FOT‘SBEBOL‘SN‘[‘CJSCF[QBSÎBT‘EFþJMJN
ÿTUJLMBM.BSā‘JÎJOIFQCJSMJLUFIB[‘SPMEBZ‘[#VNVIUFāFNBO‘ZBāBNBL UFLSBSUFLSBSZB
āBNBL āBOM‘CJSNJMMFUJOCBZSBþ‘PMNBL SVIVNVDPāUVSVZPSÿTUJLMBM.BSā‘PLVOVSLFO IÉMÉ
CBāLBJāMFSMFVþSBāBOMBSHÚ[àNEFOLBÎN‘ZPS4BOLJLBSā‘MBS‘OEBÚZMFTJOFBMFMBEFCJSHÚTUFSJ
WBS (Ú[MFSJOJOUBJÎJOFà[HàOà[HàOCBL‘ZPSVN#JSEFCVāBOM‘NBSāPLVOVSLFOLBSā‘NEB
JÎMFSJUJUSFZFO āFIJUMFSJ [BGFSMFSJHÚ[MFSJOJOÚOàOFHFUJSFOHà[FMÎPDVLMBSHÚSàZPSVN.JOJ
DJLZàSFLMFSJJMFCVDFOOFUWBUBO‘OHFMFDFþJJÎJODBOMBCBāMBÎBM‘āNBZBB[NFEFOHàOFāZà[Mà
ÎPDVLMBS#JMJZPSVN LBÎÎPDVþVOJÎJOEFOZàLTFMJZPSÿTUJLMBM.BSā‘7FLBÎÎPDVþVOZàSFþJO
EFOHFÎJZPSāFIJUMFSJOBZBLTFTMFSJ)FSDVNBPLVMBWFEBFEFSLFOZà[àNFCBL‘QāFIJUMFSJOJ 
[BGFSMFSJOJ UBSJIJOJIBU‘SMBZBO ZàSFþJWBUBONJMMFUTFWHJTJJMFÎBSQBOÎPLÎPDVLUBO‘ZPSVN"Z
Z‘ME‘[ LBOSFOHJNFTFWEBMBO‘Q CBZSBþ‘O‘OHVSVSVOVUBā‘ZBOÎPDVLMBS‘HÚLMFSEFBO‘ZPSPO
MBSJÎJOOB[M‘OB[M‘EBMHBMBO‘ZPSVN ;FLJZF±PCBO #FOĀBOM‘#JS5BSJIJN %JZBOFU±PDVL
%FSHJTJ .BSU ,‘TBMU‘MN‘āU‘S
)JLÉZFCJUJODFÚþSFUJDJāÚZMFEFSi&WFUIJLÉZFNJ[CJUUJBSLBEBāMBSĀJNEJZBWBāÎBHÚ[MFSJ
OJ[JBÎBCJMJSTJOJ[ĀJNEJTJ[FCB[‘TPSVMBSTPSBDBþ‘Nw
½ODFMJLMFCJSCBZSBLPMBSBLLFOEJOJ[JOBT‘MIJTFUUJOJ[
4J[FTBZH‘WFTFWHJZMFCBLBOÎPDVLMBS‘HÚSàODFOFIJTTFUUJOJ[
#BZSBL i#FOTBEFDFL‘SN‘[‘CJSCF[QBSÎBT‘EFþJMJNwEJZPS1FLJTJ[DFCBZSBLOFEJS
#BZSBþBPMBOTBZH‘N‘[‘OBT‘MHÚTUFSJSJ[ 
ÿTUJLMBM.BSā‘O‘OCàUàONFUOJPLVOVS&þFSÎPDVLMBSEBOF[CFSFCJMFOMFSWBSTBPOMBSEBO
PLVNBMBS‘SJDBFEJMJS%BIBTPOSBÚþSFUJDJCB[‘N‘TSBMBS‘BΑLMBSWFWVSHVMBS#ÚZMFDFÿTUJLMBM
.BSā‘O‘OJÎFSJþJIBLL‘OEBLPOVāVMVS±PDVLMBSBāVTPSVZÚOFMUJMJSiÿTUJLMBM.BSā‘OEBTJ[JFO
ÎPLFULJMFZFOL‘T‘NMBSIBOHJMFSJEJS /FEFO w±PDVLMBSEBOBM‘OBODFWBQMBSà[FSJOFAÿTUJLMBM
.BSā‘N‘[‘OOJDF[PSMVLMBSTPOVDVZB[‘ME‘þ‘ CBþ‘NT‘[M‘þ‘N‘[‘OCJSTFNCPMàPMEVþV .FINFU
"LJG&STPZVOIBML‘N‘[‘OFOTBNJNJIJTMFSJOJLBMFNFBME‘þ‘LPOVMBS‘OBEFþJOJMFSFLTPICFU
FEJMJS

%FþFSMFOEJSNF4PSVMBS‘
/FEFOCBZSBþ‘N‘[BTBZH‘HÚTUFSNFMJZJ[
#BZSBþ‘N‘[BPMBOTBZH‘N‘[‘OBT‘MTFSHJMFSJ[
ÿTUJLMBM.BSā‘CJ[JNJÎJOOFEFOÚOFNMJEJS

325
7"5" /  7 &  # " : 3 " ,  4 & 7 ( ÿ 4 ÿ

ÿTUJLMBM.BSā‘PLVOVSLFOOBT‘MEBWSBONBM‘Z‘[

(àOàO.FTBK‘
%BMHBMBOE‘þ‘OZFSEFOFLPSLV OFLFEFS
(ÚMHFOEFCBOBEB CBOBEBZFSWFS
4BCBIPMNBT‘O HàOMFSEPþNBT‘OOFΑLBS
:VSEBBZZ‘ME‘[‘O‘O‘ā‘þ‘ZFUFS
"SJG/JIBU"TZB

,BQBO‘ā
(SVQàZFMFSJOFQBZMBā‘NMBS‘JÎJOUFāFLLàSFEJO
)FSLFTJOBLM‘OEBLBMBONFTBK‘QBZMBāNBT‘O‘JTUFZJO
,POVZMBJMHJMJWBSTBTPSVMBS‘O‘BM‘OWFDFWBQMBZ‘O
#JSTPOSBLJLPOVOVOCBāM‘þ‘O‘WFSJOWFWFEBMBā‘O

326
7"5" /  7 &  # " : 3 " ,  4 & 7 ( ÿ 4 ÿ

½þSFUJDJ/PUV
½þSFUJDJ/PUVÎFSÎFWFTJOEFEFSTBOMBU‘M‘S

:ÚOUFNWF5FLOJLMFS
0SBUPSZP±BM‘āNBT‘ 'PO.à[JþJ 4PSV$FWBQ ,PNQP[JTZPO:B[NB

.BUFSZBM
#BZSBLĀJJSJ "LÉþ‘E‘

&ULJOMJL
ZBā
½þSFUJDJ #BZSBLĀJJSJOJOL‘UBMBS‘O‘ÎPDVLTBZ‘T‘ODBCÚMFSWF#BZSBLĀJJSJOFVZHVOCJSGPO
Nà[JþJIB[‘SMBZBSBLPSBUPSZPÎBM‘āNBT‘OBCBāMBO‘S

327
7"5" /  7 &  # " : 3 " ,  4 & 7 ( ÿ 4 ÿ

#":3",
±PDVL
&ZNBWJHÚLMFSJOCFZB[WFL‘[‘MTàTà
,‘[LBSEFāJNJOHFMJOMJþJ āFIJEJNJOTPOÚSUàTà
*ā‘L‘ā‘L EBMHBEBMHBCBZSBþ‘N
4FOJOEFTUBO‘O‘PLVEVN TFOJOEFTUBO‘O‘ZB[BDBþ‘N

±PDVL
%BMHBMBOE‘þ‘OZFSEFOFLPSLV OFLFEFS
(ÚMHFOEFCBOBEB CBOBEBZFSWFS
4BCBIPMNBT‘O HàOMFSEPþNBT‘OOFΑLBS
:VSEBBZZ‘ME‘[‘O‘O‘ā‘þ‘ZFUFS

±PDVL
4BWBāCJ[JLBSM‘EBþMBSBHÚUàSEàþàHàO
,‘[‘MM‘þ‘OEB‘T‘OE‘L
%BþMBSEBOÎÚMMFSFEàāUàþàNà[HàO
(ÚMHFOFT‘þ‘OE‘L

±PDVL
&ZāJNEJTà[HàO Sà[HÉSMBSEBEBMHBM‘
#BS‘ā‘OHàWFSDJOJ TBWBā‘OLBSUBM‘
:àLTFLZFSMFSEFBÎBOÎJÎFþJN
4FOJOBMU‘OEBEPþEVN
4FOJOBMU‘OEBÚMFDFþJN

±PDVL
5BSJIJN āFSFmN āJJSJN IFSāFZJN
:FSZà[àOEFZFSCFþFO
/FSFZFEJLJMNFLJTUFSTFO
4ÚZMF TFOJPSBZBEJLFZJN
"SJG/JIBU"TZB

½þSFUJDJ āJJSPLVEVLUBOTPOSBÎPDVLMBSBāJJSEFOFMFSIJTTFUUJLMFSJOJTPSBS½þSFUJDJEBIB
TPOSBÎPDVLMBSEBOCBZSBLIBLL‘OEBL‘TBCJSLPNQP[JTZPOZB[NBMBS‘O‘JTUFSÿTUFZFOÎPDVLMBS
ZB[E‘LMBS‘O‘PLVS%FþFSMFOEJSNFTPSVMBS‘TPSVMBSBLEFSTTPOBFSFS


7"5" /  7 &  # " : 3 " ,  4 & 7 ( ÿ 4 ÿ

%FþFSMFOEJSNF4PSVMBS‘
#BZSBþ‘OÚOFNJOJBOMBU‘SN‘T‘O‘[
ÿTUJLMBM.BSā‘N‘[‘ZB[BO.FINFU"LJG&STPZIBLL‘OEBOFMFSCJMJZPSTVOV[
#JSWBUBO‘WBUBOZBQBOLVUTBMEFþFSMFSJOCBā‘OEBOFHFMJS

(àOàO.FTBK‘
i"MMBIZPMVOEBT‘O‘SEBCJSHàOOÚCFU
UVUNBL CBāLBZFSMFSEFCJOHàOOÚCFU
UVUNBLUBOEBIBIBZ‘SM‘E‘Sw
5JSNJ[Ô 'F[ÉJMàMDJIÉE 

,BQBO‘ā
(SVQàZFMFSJOFQBZMBā‘NMBS‘JÎJOUFāFLLàSFEJO
)FSLFTJOBLM‘OEBLBMBONFTBK‘QBZMBāNBT‘O‘JTUFZJO
,POVZMBJMHJMJWBSTBTPSVMBS‘O‘BM‘OWFDFWBQMBZ‘O
#JSTPOSBLJLPOVOVOCBāM‘þ‘O‘WFSJOWFWFEBMBā‘O


7"5" /  7 &  # " : 3 " ,  4 & 7 ( ÿ 4 ÿ

ÿ45ÿ,-"-."3Ā*
,BISBNBO0SEVNV[B
,PSLNB TÚONF[CVāBGBLMBSEBZà[FOBMTBODBL #BTU‘þ‘OZFSMFSJiUPQSBLEJZFSFLHFÎNF UBO‘
4ÚONFEFOZVSEVNVOàTUàOEFUàUFOFOTPOPDBL %àāàOBMU‘OEBLJCJOMFSDFLFGFOTJ[ZBUBO‘
0CFOJNNJMMFUJNJOZ‘ME‘[‘E‘S QBSMBZBDBL 4FOāFIJUPþMVTVO JODJUNF ZB[‘LU‘S BUBO‘
0CFOJNEJS PCFOJNNJMMFUJNJOEJSBODBL 7FSNF EàOZBMBS‘BMTBOEBCVDFOOFUWBUBO‘

±BUNB LVSCBOPMBZ‘N ÎFISFOJFZOB[M‘IJMBM ,JNCVDFOOFUWBUBO‘OVþSVOBPMNB[LJGFEB


,BISBNBO‘SL‘NBCJSHàM/FCVāJEEFU CVDFMBM ĀàIFEBG‘āL‘SBDBLUPQSBþ‘T‘LTBO āàIFEB
4BOBPMNB[EÚLàMFOLBOMBS‘N‘[TPOSBIFMBM $BO‘ DBOBO‘ CàUàOWBS‘N‘BMT‘OEB)àEB
)BLL‘E‘S )BLLBUBQBO NJMMFUJNJOJTUJLMBM &UNFTJOUFLWBUBO‘NEBOCFOJEàOZBEBDàEB

#FOF[FMEFOCFSJEJSIàSZBāBE‘N IàSZBāBS‘N 3VIVNVOTFOEFOÿMBIÔāVEVSBODBLFNFMJ


)BOHJΑMH‘OCBOB[JODJSWVSBDBLN‘ā ĀBāBS‘N %FþNFTJONBCFEJNJOHÚþTàOFOBNBISFNFMJ
,àLSFNJāTFMHJCJZJN CFOEJNJÎJþOFS BāBS‘N #VF[BOMBSLJāFIBEFUMFSJEJOJOUFNFMJ
:‘SUBS‘NEBþMBS‘ FOHJOMFSFT‘þNBN UBāBS‘N &CFEÔ ZVSEVNVOàTUàOEFCFOJNJOMFNFMJ

(BSC‘OBGBL‘O‘TBSN‘āTBÎFMJL[‘SIM‘EVWBS 0[BNBOWFDEJMFCJOTFDEFFEFSWBSTBUBā‘N
#FOJNJNBOEPMVHÚþTàNHJCJTFSIBEEJNWBS )FSDFSJIBNEBO ÿMBIÔ CPāBO‘QLBOM‘ZBā‘N
6MVTVO LPSLNB/BT‘MCÚZMFCJSJNBO‘CPþBS '‘āL‘S‘SSVIJNàDFSSFEHJCJZFSEFOOBā‘N
A.FEFOJZFUEFEJþJOUFLEJāJLBMN‘āDBOBWBS 0[BNBOZàLTFMFSFL"SāBEFþFS CFMLJ CBā‘N

"SLBEBā:VSEVNBBMÎBLMBS‘VþSBUNBTBL‘O %BMHBMBOTFOEFāBGBLMBSHJCJFZāBOM‘IJMBM
4JQFSFUHÚWEFOJ EVSTVOCVIBZBT‘[DBBL‘O 0MTVOBSU‘LEÚLàMFOLBOMBS‘N‘OIFQTJIFMBM
%PþBDBLU‘STBOBWBEFUUJþJHàOMFS)BLL‘O &CFEJZZFOTBOBZPL ‘SL‘NBZPLJ[NJIMBM
,JNCJMJS CFMLJZBS‘O CFMLJZBS‘OEBOEBZBL‘O )BLL‘E‘S IàSZBāBN‘ā CBZSBþ‘N‘OIàSSJZFU
)BLL‘E‘S )BLLBUBQBO NJMMFUJNJOJTUJLMBM
."LJG&340:
330
7"5" /  7 &  # " : 3 " ,  4 & 7 ( ÿ 4 ÿ

7"5"/ÿ±ÿ/$"/*/*035":",0:"/-"3
iĀ&)ÿ5-&37&(";ÿ-&3w
Ka[BO‘N
ĀFIJUMFSJSBINFUMFBONBT‘HB[JMFSFTBZH‘EVZNBT‘HFSFLUJþJOJCJMJS

½þSFUJDJ/PUV
7BUBO‘O‘WFEJOJOJLPSVNBLJÎJODBO‘O‘WFSFOMFSFAāFIJUEFOJS%JOJNJ[DFāFIJUMJL QFZ
HBNCFSMJLUFOTPOSBHFMFOFOZàLTFLNBLBNE‘S±àOLàāFIJUMFS FOL‘ZNFUMJWBSM‘LMBS‘PMBO
DBOMBS‘O‘ ZàLTFLCJSJEFBMJÎJOGFEBFEFOLJNTFMFSEJS(B[JMJLEFāFIJUMJLHJCJZàLTFLCJSNB
LBNE‘S(B[JMFS WBUBO‘WFEJOJJÎJOTBWBāN‘ā ÎBCBMBN‘ā CVVþVSEBZBSBMBON‘āCFMLJEFTBLBU
LBMN‘āLJNTFMFSEJS5BSJIJNJ[EFQFLÎPLLBISBNBOM‘LÚSOFþJWBSE‘S,VSUVMVāWF±BOBLLBMF
4BWBāMBS‘OEBPMEVþVHJCJHàOàNà[EFEF5FNNV[EBIBML‘N‘[‘OOBT‘MJÎUFOCJSāFLJMEF
WBUBO‘NàEBGBBFUNFZFÎBM‘āU‘þ‘HÚSàMNàāUàS)BML‘N‘[CVHàDà JNBO‘OEBOBMNBLUBE‘S&þFS
āVBOàMLFNJ[EFBMCBZSBþ‘OBMU‘OEB Ú[HàSCJSàMLFPMBSBLZBā‘ZPSTBL CVOVāFIJUWFHB[J
MFSJNJ[F CPSÎMVZV[ 0OMBS CJ[F Hà[FM àMLFNJ[J FNBOFU FUNJāUJS #J[JN EF HFSFLMJ IÉMMFSEF 
àMLFNJ[JÎJOIFSUàSMàGFEBLÉSM‘þ‘ZBQNBN‘[HFSFLJSĀFIJUMFSJNJ[JTBZH‘JMFBONBL POMBSJÎJO
EVBFUNFLHB[JMFSJNJ[JTFWJQTBZNBLHÚSFWJNJ[EJS

:ÚOUFNWF5FLOJLMFS
.FUJOÿODFMFNF )JLÉZFĀJJS:B[NB

.BUFSZBM
ĀJJSNFUOJ

&ULJOMJL
ZBā
½þSFUJDJāFIJUMJLWFHB[JMJLLBWSBNMBS‘UBO‘NMBOE‘LUBOTPOSBUBSJIUFOCB[‘ÚSOFLMFSBOMBU‘S
,VSUVMVāWF±BOBLLBMF4BWBāMBS‘OEBIBML‘N‘[‘OUàNJNLÉOMBS‘O‘WBUBOMBS‘O‘TBWVONBLJÎJO
TBSG FUUJLMFSJ WVSHVMBO‘S ĀFIJUMJL  HB[JMJL LBWSBNMBS‘O‘O Z‘MMBS ÚODFTJOEF LBMNBE‘þ‘OB  IÉMÉ
WBUBO‘N‘[‘OUFIMJLFBMU‘OEBPMNBT‘IÉMJOEFDBO‘O‘WFSNFZJHÚ[FBMBDBL WBUBOTFWFSJOTBOMB
S‘OÎPLTBZ‘EBPMEVþVOBEJLLBUÎFLJMJS½SOFLPMBSBL5FNNV[EBIFSāFZJHÚ[FBMBSBL 
UBOLMBSBLBSā‘EVSBO CÚZMFDFàMLFNJ[JPMBT‘UFIMJLFMFSEFOLPSVNVāPMBOWBUBOEBāMBS‘N‘[EBO
CBITFEJMJS
"āBþ‘EBLJāJJSÚODFÚþSFUJDJUBSBG‘OEBWVSHVMVCJSTFTUPOVZMBPLVOVS%BIBTPOSBPLVNBL
JTUFZFOCJSLBÎÎPDVþBEBIBPLVUVMVS

331
7"5" /  7 &  # " : 3 " ,  4 & 7 ( ÿ 4 ÿ

,PSLVTV[,BISBNBOMBS

0LBSBOM‘LHFDFEF
)BCFSJBM‘SBMNB[
7FEBMBā‘QIFSLFTMF
.FZEBOMBSBLPāUVMBS
,PSLVTV[LBISBNBOMBS

0HàOÚMàNCJMF
,PSLVUNBE‘POMBS‘
:BāM‘T‘ZMBHFODJZMF
"ÎU‘MBSCàUàOZPMMBS‘
,PSLVTV[LBISBNBOMBS

"ZZ‘ME‘[M‘CBZSBLMB
(ÚþTàOEFLJJNBOMB
%JNEJLEVSBSBLEàāNBOB
%àOZBZBCJSEFSTWFSEJMFS
,PSLVTV[LBISBNBOMBS

#BZSBLMBSFMMFSJOEF
5FLCJSMFSEJMMFSJOEF
"MMBI WBUBOVþSVOB
ĀFIJU HB[JPMEVMBS
,PSLVTV[LBISBNBOMBS

½NFS(ñ-à %JZBOFU±PDVL%FSHJTJ 5FNNV[

ÿOTBOMBSEBLJ FO ÚOFNMJ Ú[FMMJLMFSEFO CJSJOJO LFOEJ DBO‘O‘ LPSVNBL PMEVþV  IFSLFTJO
LFOEJOJTPþVLUBO T‘DBLUBO ZBþNVSEBOLBSEBO Z‘SU‘D‘IBZWBOEBO LB[BMBSEBOWCLPSVNBL
JÎJO ÎBCB HÚTUFSEJþJ CFMJSUJMJS #VOB SBþNFO  WBUBO‘O‘ LPSVNB EVZHVTVOVO  LFOEJOJ LPSV
NBLUBOCJMFÚOFNMJPMEVþV CÚZMFCJSEVSVNMBLBSā‘MBā‘ME‘þ‘OEBWBUBO‘OBNJMMFUJOFCBþM‘JO
TBOMBS‘OLFOEJDBO‘OEBOÚODFWBUBO‘O‘LVSUBSNBZ‘EàāàOEàþàCFMJSUJMJS
±PDVLMBSEBOiāFIJU HB[J WBUBO CBZSBL LPSVNBwLFMJNFMFSJLVMMBOBSBLCJSL‘TBIJLÉZF
WFZBāJJSZB[NBMBS‘JTUFOJS#VOVOJÎJOPOMBSBCJSB[[BNBOUBO‘O‘S%BIBTPOSBCJSLBÎÚþSFO
DJOJOZB[E‘LMBS‘PLVOBSBLLPOVUBNBNMBO‘S

332
7"5" /  7 &  # " : 3 " ,  4 & 7 ( ÿ 4 ÿ

%FþFSMFOEJSNF4PSVMBS‘
ĀFIJUMJLOFEJS /JÎJOÚOFNMJEJS
(B[JMJLOFEJS /JÎJOÚOFNMJEJS
ĀFIJUWFHB[JMFSFLBSā‘HÚSFWMFSJNJ[OFEJS

(àOàO.FTBK‘
#BTU‘þ‘OZFSMFSJAUPQSBLEJZFSFLHFÎNF UBO‘
%àāàOBMU‘OEBLJCJOMFSDFLFGFOTJ[ZBUBO‘
4FOāFIJUPþMVTVO JODJUNF ZB[‘LU‘S BUBO‘
7FSNF EàOZBMBS‘BMTBOEBCVDFOOFUWBUBO‘
.FINFU"LJG&STPZ

,BQBO‘ā
(SVQàZFMFSJOFQBZMBā‘NMBS‘JÎJOUFāFLLàSFEJO
)FSLFTJOBLM‘OEBLBMBONFTBK‘QBZMBāNBT‘O‘JTUFZJO
,POVZMBJMHJMJWBSTBTPSVMBS‘O‘BM‘OWFDFWBQMBZ‘O
#JSTPOSBLJLPOVOVOCBāM‘þ‘O‘WFSJOWFWFEBMBā‘O

333
7"5" /  7 &  # " : 3 " ,  4 & 7 ( ÿ 4 ÿ

Ka[BO‘N
ĀFIJUMFSJSBINFUMFBONBT‘HB[JMFSFTBZH‘EVZNBT‘HFSFLUJþJOJCJMJS

½þSFUJDJ/PUV
.àTMàNBOPMVQLVUTBMCJSJOBOÎVþSVOB WBUBO CBZSBL EJO ÚMFOMFSJOiāFIJUwPMEVþV
TBWBāB LBU‘MBO WF TBWBā TPOSBT‘ IBZBUMBS‘OB EFWBN FEFOMFSJO JTF iHB[Jw PMEVþV J[BI FEJMJS
7BUBO‘N‘[‘OCVHàOMFSFVMBāNBT‘OEBāFIJUMFSJOWFHB[JMFSJOÚOFNMJSPMàOàOPMEVþVBOMBU‘M‘S
ÿIUJZBÎEVZVMEVþVIFSBOWBUBO‘N‘[‘OBZBLUBLBMNBT‘JÎJOOFHFSFLJZPSTBTFWFSFLHFSFþJOJO
ZFSJOFHFUJSJMNFTJHFSFLUJþJOJOÚOFNJBOMBU‘M‘S&DEBE‘O‘OHÚ[MFSJOJL‘SQNBEBOWBUBOJÎJODBO
WFSEJLMFSJWFCJ[JNCVHàOPOMBS‘OTBZFTJOEFSBIBUZBāBE‘þ‘N‘[BOMBU‘M‘S(FSFLJSTFUPSVOMBS‘
N‘[‘OSBIBUZBāBNBT‘JÎJOBZO‘GFEBLÉSM‘þ‘CJ[JNEFTFSHJMFNFNJ[HFSFLUJþJLPOVTVà[FSJOEF
EVSVMVSĀFIJUMFSJNJ[JOSVIVJÎJO CJMFOÎPDVLMBS‘Oi'ÉUJIBwPLVNBT‘JTUFOJS&ULJOMJþFCBā
MBO‘S

:ÚOUFNWF5FLOJLMFS
"OMBU‘N ĀJJS 4PSV$FWBQ

&ULJOMJL
ZBā
½þSFUJDJ i(JUFWMBE‘NĀVZBSBM‘CBþS‘NBLBSBUBāMBSÎBMBZ‘N)BEJZBWSVNIBEJ HJUZB
HB[JPMZBāFIJUwEVBMBS‘ZMBBTLFSFVþVSMBOBOāFIJUMFSJWFHB[JMFSJTJ[FBOMBUBDBþ‘N EFS4POSB
ÎPDVLMBSBBāBþ‘EBLJNFUJOPLVOVS
"MMBIZPMVOEBNàDBEFMFFEFSLFOÚMEàSàMFOāFIJUMFSJO QFZHBNCFSMJLUFOTPOSBFOZàLTFL
SàUCFZFFSJāUJLMFSJOJCJMFOBUBMBS‘N‘[i½MàSTFNāFIJU LBM‘STBNHB[JPMVSVNwEàāàODFTJZMF
WBUBO‘ EJOJ CBZSBþ‘WFEJþFSLVUTBMEFþFSMFSJJÎJOHFSFLUJþJOEFTBWBāNBLUBOBTMBÎFLJONFNJā 
WFSFCJMFDFþJFOL‘ZNFUMJāFZPMBODBOMBS‘O‘TFWFTFWFWFSNJāMFSEJS±àOLàPOMBS,VSBOWFTàO
OFUMFBZE‘OMBOE‘LMBS‘CJMHJZPMVOEB"MMBIJÎJODBOWFSNFOJOLBSā‘M‘þ‘O‘ODFOOFUPMEVþVOV
iĀàQIFTJ[ "MMBI  NàNJOMFSEFO DBOMBS‘O‘ WF NBMMBS‘O‘  LFOEJMFSJOF WFSFDFþJ DFOOFU LBSā‘M‘
þ‘OEBTBU‘OBMN‘āU‘Sw 5FWCF  BZFUJLFSJNFTJZMFÚþSFONJāMFSEJ4BIBCFEFOCJSJTJ1FZ
HBNCFSJNJ[F TBT i"MMBIZPMVOEBÚMEàSàMàSTFNHàOBIMBS‘NBGGFEJMJSNJ wEJZFTPSNVā P
EB i&WFU LVMIBLL‘IBSJÎ CàUàOHàOBIMBS‘OBGGFEJMFDFL;JSB$FCSBJMCVIVTVTVCBOBIBCFS
WFSEJw .àTMJN ÿNBSFU  CVZVSNVāUV

334
7"5" /  7 &  # " : 3 " ,  4 & 7 ( ÿ 4 ÿ

)FS[BNBOāFIJUPMNBZ‘BS[VMBZBO4FWHJMJ1FZHBNCFSJNJ[ TBT i/FGTJNLVESFUFMJO


EFPMBO"MMBIBZFNJOFEFSJNLJ "MMBIZPMVOEBTBWBā‘QÚMEàSàMNFZJ TPOSBEJSJMUJMJQZJOF
ÚMEàSàMNFZJ TPOSB EJSJMUJMJQZJOFÚMEàSàMNFZJOFLBEBSÎPLJTUFSEJNw #VIÉSÔ $JIÉE  
CVZVSEVLUBO TPOSB āFIJUMJþJO ÚOFNJOF āÚZMF JāBSFU CVZVSNVāMBSE‘ i$FOOFUF HJSFO IJÎCJS
LJNTF ZFSZà[àOEFLJIFSāFZLFOEJTJOJOPMTBCJMFEàOZBZBEÚONFZJBS[VFUNF[4BEFDFāF
IJU HÚSEàþàBā‘S‘JUJCBSWFJLSBNTFCFCJZMFUFLSBSEàOZBZBEÚONFZJWFPOEFGBāFIJUPMNBZ‘
JTUFSw #VIÉSÔ $JIÉE .àTMJN .ÉSF 
(B[JMJL EF āFIJUMJL LBEBS ÚOFNMJ CJS NFSUFCFEJS ±àOLà HB[JMFS  "MMBI JÎJO  WBUBO JÎJO 
CBZSBLJÎJODBOMBS‘O‘PSUBZBLPZBCJMNJāNàNJOMFSEJSÃNNFUJPMNBLMBJGUJIBSFUUJþJNJ[1FZ
HBNCFSJNJ[)[.VIBNNFE.VTUBGBO‘O TBT iÿLJHÚ[DFIFOOFNBUFāJOEFZBONB[#JSJ
"MMBILPSLVTVOEBOBþMBZBOHÚ[ EJþFSJEF"MMBIZPMVOEBOÚCFUUVUBSLFOEàāNBO‘HÚ[FUMFZFO
HÚ[w 5JSNJ[Ô 'FEÉJMàM$JIÉE  i,JN"MMBIZPMVOEBDJIBEBHJEFDFLCJSHB[JZJEPOBU‘S 
DJIBEJÎJOHFSFLMJPMBOJIUJZBÎMBS‘O‘LBSā‘MBSTB CJ[[BUDJIBEBHJUNJāHJCJTFWBQLB[BO‘S$JIBEB
HJEFOHB[JOJOBJMFTJOJOJIUJZBÎMBS‘O‘LBSā‘MBZBOEBDJIBEZBQN‘āHJCJTFWBQLB[BO‘Sw #VIÉSÔ 
$JIÉE   .àTMJN  .ÉSF    NàKEFTJ  BTLFS PDBþ‘O‘O  QFZHBNCFS PDBþ‘ PMEVþVOV
CJ[MFSFÚþSFUNJāUJS
iĀàIFEBG‘āL‘SBDBLUPQSBþ‘T‘LTBO āàIFEBwNJTBMJUPQSBþ‘LBOMBS‘ZMBZPþVSBOāFIJUMFSJ
NJ[ CVDFOOFUWBUBO‘CJ[FFNBOFUFUNJāMFSEJS#J[FEàāFOEFCVUPQSBLMBS‘JNBSFUNFL LPSV
NBLWFCJ[EFOTPOSBLJOFTJMMFSFEFWSFUNFLUJS#VOVZBQNBE‘þ‘O‘[UBLEJSEFIFNWBUBO‘N‘[B
IFNEFāFIJUMFSJNJ[FLBSā‘HÚSFWMFSJNJ[JZBQNBN‘āWFPOMBS‘OSVIMBS‘O‘JODJUNJāPMVSV[
ÿTMBN‘OJMLāFIJUMFSJOEFO"NNBSCJO:ÉTJSWFFāJ4àNFZZFWBMJEFNJ[EFOEJOJJÎJO JGGFUJ
JÎJO WBUBO‘JÎJO CBZSBþ‘JÎJO TBODBþ‘JÎJO .BMB[HJSUUF ±BOBLLBMFEF #BMLBOMBSEB ,BGLBT
MBSEB 4BLBSZBEB ÿTUJLMBM)BSCJOEFDBOMBS‘O‘TFWFTFWFGFEBFEFOāFIJUMFSJNJ[F BJMFTJOFIFMBM
MPLNBLB[BONBLNBLTBE‘ZMBZFSJOBMU‘OEBÎBM‘ā‘SLFOTPOOFGFTMFSJOJWFSFO4PNBEBLJLBSEFā
MFSJNJ[FLBEBS 'JMJTUJOEF (B[[FEF 4VSJZFEF *SBLEB .‘T‘SEB %PþV5àSLJTUBOEBWFEJþFS
DPþSBGZBMBSEBDBOMBS‘O‘GFEBFEFOUàNāFIJUMFSJNJ[JWFCàUàOHB[JMFSJNJ[JSBINFUMFBO‘ZPSV[

335
7"5" /  7 &  # " : 3 " ,  4 & 7 ( ÿ 4 ÿ

½þSFUJDJ ÎPDVLMBSEBOJTUFLMJPMBOCJSJTJOJTFÎFSFLBāBþ‘EBLJāJJSJPLVNBT‘O‘JTUFSĀJJSEFO
TPOSBEBTPSVDFWBQMBLPOVUBNBNMBO‘S

Ā&)ÿ5-&3ÿ/,&37"/*/%"

)BN[BTBODBþ‘O‘ÎFLNJā
ĀFIJUMFSJOLFSWBO‘OEB
/JDFOJDFBMLBOBLN‘ā
ĀFIJUMFSJOLFSWBO‘OEB

.BMB[HJSUUFLPÎZJþJUMFS
ĀFIBEFUJDBOEBOÚ[MFS
0MNBZ‘JTUFSJ[CJ[MFS
ĀFIJUMFSJOLFSWBO‘OEB

ÿTUBOCVMVOGFUIJEFTUBO
$BOWFSJMEJ BM‘OE‘āBO
:JþJU6MVCBUM‘)BTBO
ĀFIJUMFSJOLFSWBO‘OEB

±BOBLLBMF 4BS‘LBN‘ā
/JDFMFSJDBOMBSWFSNJā
ĀFIJUMFSNVSBEBFSNJā
ĀFIJUMFSJOLFSWBO‘OEB

;BGFSMFSIFQEJ[JEJ[J
4FWJOEJSJSIFQJNJ[J
)BāSFZMF3BCCJNJ[CJ[J
ĀFIJUMFSJOLFSWBO‘OEB

ÿNSFOJSÎJÎFLMFSIFSBO
(FMJODJL HàMTBOLJBMLBO
(JSLFSWBOBPMVMVDBO
ĀFIJUMFSJOLFSWBO‘OEB

 .VTUBGB"LHàO %JZBOFU±PDVL%FSHJTJ 

336
7"5" /  7 &  # " : 3 " ,  4 & 7 ( ÿ 4 ÿ

%FþFSMFOEJSNF4PSVMBS‘
ĀFIJUMJLOFEJS
(B[JMJLOFEJS
4J[EFāFIJUWFHB[JMFSJNJ[FHFSFLFOÚOFNJWFSJZPSNVTVOV[

(àOàO.FTBK‘
i"MMBIZPMVOEBÚMEàSàMFOMFSJTBL‘OÚMàMFSTBONB
#JMBLJTPOMBSEJSJEJSMFS 3BCMFSJLBU‘OEB"MMBI‘O 
MàUGVOEBOLFOEJMFSJOFWFSEJþJOJNFUMFSJOTFWJODJOJ
ZBāBZBSBLS‘[‘LMBOE‘S‘MNBLUBE‘SMBSw
¬MJÿNSÉO 

,BQBO‘ā
(SVQàZFMFSJOFQBZMBā‘NMBS‘JÎJOUFāFLLàSFEJO
)FSLFTJOBLM‘OEBLBMBONFTBK‘QBZMBāNBT‘O‘JTUFZJO
,POVZMBJMHJMJWBSTBTPSVMBS‘O‘BM‘OWFDFWBQMBZ‘O
#JSTPOSBLJLPOVOVOCBāM‘þ‘O‘WFSJOWFWFEBMBā‘O

337
&,

404:"-)ÿ;.&5,636.-"3*/%"%ÿ/)ÿ;.&5ÿÿ±ÿ/:"Ā
(361-"3*/"(½3&)";*3-"/.*Ā.Ã'3&%"5½3/&ýÿ
:"Ā
:"Ā

)B[‘SMBOBOWFFLUFTVOVMBONàGSFEBU#BāLBOM‘þ‘N‘[‘OTPTZBMIJ[NFULVSVNMBS‘OEBTVO
EVþVEJOÔSFICFSMJLWFNBOFWJEFTUFLIJ[NFUMFSJOJOCFMMJCJSÎFSÎFWFEFTVOVMNBT‘BNBD‘ZMB
IB[‘SMBON‘āPMVQ ÚSOFLWFSFICFSBNBÎM‘E‘SÿāMFOFDFLLPOVMBSWFLPOVZVFMFBM‘āZÚOUFNJ
NVIBUBQLJUMFOJOJIUJZBÎMBS‘ JMHJMFSJ IBTTBTJZFUMFSJHÚ[ÚOàOEFCVMVOEVSVMBSBLTFÎJMNFMJEJS
.àGSFEBUÚSOFþJOEFIBZBUBJOBOÎWFàNJUMFCBLBCJMNF [PSMVLMBSMBNàDBEFMFFEFCJMNF ZBM
O‘[M‘LWFÎBSFTJ[MJLEVZHVMBS‘OEBOLVSUVMBCJMNFCFDFSJTJLB[BOE‘SBO IV[VSWFHàWFOBā‘MB
ZBO TPTZBMJMJāLJMFSJHàÎMFOEJSFOEFþFSWFLB[BO‘NMBS‘OTVOVMNBT‘ÚODFMFONJāUJS
&þJUJNJOTBþM‘LM‘WFWFSJNMJPMNBT‘JÎJOEFSTMFSJOEFWBNM‘OJUFMJLUFPMNBT‘OBHBZSFUFEJM
NFMJ WF IFEFG LJUMFOJO IB[‘SCVMVOVāMVL TFWJZFTJ EJLLBUF BM‘ONBM‘E‘S ,VSVNMBSEB WBS PMBO
HàOMàLJIUJZBÎMBSWFBOM‘LHFMJāNFMFSEFEJLLBUFBM‘OBSBLQSPHSBN‘OVZHVMBONBT‘OEBFTOFL
EBWSBO‘MBCJMJS


±0$6,&7-&3ÿ%ÿ/)ÿ;.&5ÿ±"-*Ā."130(3".*
7"5" /  7 &  # " : 3 " ,  4 & 7 ( ÿ 4 ÿ :"Ā
"/",0/6 "-5,0/6 %&ý&3 ,";"/*.-"3*

"MMBITFWHJTJOJOUàNTFWHJMFSEFOàTUàOWFZàDF
PMEVþVOVCJMJS
4&7(ÿ ÿTMBN4FWHJ%JOJEJS 4FWHJ 4BZH‘ .FSIBNFU  "MMBI‘OCJ[JTFWEJþJOJWFIFS[BNBOCJ[JNMF
"EBMFU %PTUMVL PMEVþVOVCJMJS
,FOEJOJ BSLBEBāMBS‘O‘ ÎFWSFTJOEFLJDBOM‘WFDBOT‘[
WBSM‘LMBS‘TFWNFTJHFSFLUJþJOJBOMBS
1FZHBNCFSMFSJWFÚ[FMMJLMF)[.VIBNNFEJUBO‘S 
TFWFSWFÚSOFLBM‘S

ÿTMBNCàUàO 4PSVNMVMVL 4BZH‘ 


WBSM‘LMBSBNFSIBNFUMJ %àSàTUMàL %JþFSLÉNM‘L  .FSIBNFUEBWSBO‘āMBS‘O‘OPMVNMVTPOVÎMBS‘O‘GBSL
.&3)".&5 PMVONBT‘O‘FNSFEFS FEFS
)PāHÚSà (àWFO 
,VSBO‘,FSJNEF %PþSVMVL 7JDEBOM‘0MNB ,FOEJIBZBU‘OEBONFSIBNFUÚSOFLMFSJWFSJS
WF)[1FZHBNCFSJO
4àOOFUJOEF.FSIBNFU

4BZH‘UFSJNMFSJOJOBOMBN‘O‘TÚZMFS
"MMBIWFQFZHBNCFSMFSJOJTJNMFSJHFÎUJþJOEFTBZH‘
DàNMFMFSJTÚZMFS
#BāLBMBS‘O‘OIBLMBS‘OBTBZH‘EVZVMNBT‘HFSFLUJþJOJ
,FOEJOF4BZH‘ TÚZMFS
"JMFZF4BZH‘ )[1FZHBNCFSJOÎFWSFTJOEFLJCàUàOJOTBOMBSBWF
4":(* %JþFSLÉNM‘L 4BZH‘ WBSM‘LMBSBLBSā‘TBZH‘M‘PMEVþVOVGBSLFEFS
5PQMVNB4BZH‘
%JOÔ%FþFSMFSF4BZH‘ ÿOTBOMBS‘OGBSLM‘Ú[FMMJLMFSJOFLBSā‘TBZH‘M‘PMNBO‘O
HFSFLMJPMEVþVOVBOMBS
,VSBO‘,FSJN F[BOWFEVBPLVOVSLFOEJOMFNFTJ
HFSFLUJþJOJBOMBS
/BNB[L‘MBOLJNTFMFSFTBZH‘HÚTUFSJMFDFþJOJBOMBS
,POVāBOLJāJZJTÚ[àOàLFTNFEFOEJOMFNFOJOHFSFLMJ
PMEVþVOVCJMJS

(ÚSFWWFTPSVNMVMVLUFSJNMFSJOJOBOMBN‘O‘TÚZMFS
"MMBI‘O JOTBOMBS‘OHÚSFWWFTPSVNMVMVLMBS‘O‘
ZFSJOFHFUJSNFMFSJOJJTUFEJþJOJCJMJS
(ÚSFWWF4PSVNMVMVL 4FWHJ "EBMFU  #FEFOUFNJ[MJþJOFÚ[FOHÚTUFSJS
#JMJODJ 4PSVNMVMVL±BM‘āLBOM‘L ±FWSFUFNJ[MJþJOFÚ[FOHÚTUFSJS
(½3&77& 4PTZBM4PSVNMVMVLWF
:BSE‘NMBāNB %BZBO‘āNB  ,FOEJOFWFCBāLBMBS‘OBBJUFāZBMBS‘UFNJ[UVUBSWF
4036.-6-6, (ÚSFWMFSJNJ[ "JEJZFU LPSVS
±FWSFZF,BSā‘(ÚSFW
4PSVNMVMVL &NBOFU (ÚSFWWFTPSVNMVMVLMBS‘O‘ZFSJOFHFUJSFOJOTBOMBS‘O
WF4PSVNMVMVLMBS‘N‘[
#JMJODJ 5FNJ[MJL ÿTSBG IFS[BNBOCBāBS‘M‘WFNVUMVPMEVþVOVJGBEFFEFS
#JS&NBOFU0MBSBL
±FWSF ,FOEJNJ[F UPQMVNB EPþBZB "MMBIBWF
QFZHBNCFSMFSFLBSā‘CJSUBL‘NTPSVNMVMVLMBS‘N‘[
PMEVþVOVUBO‘NMBS
ÿTSBGLBWSBN‘O‘OBOMBN‘O‘TÚZMFS
,FOEJIBZBU‘OEBO JTSBGFUNFNFZFZÚOFMJLÚSOFLMFS
WFSJS

340
±0$6,&7-&3ÿ%ÿ/)ÿ;.&5ÿ±"-*Ā."130(3".*
7"5" /  7 &  # " : 3 " ,  4 & 7 ( ÿ 4 ÿ :"Ā
"/",0/6 "-5,0/6 %&ý&3 ,";"/*.-"3*
"EBMFULBWSBN‘O‘WFBEBMFUJOJOTBOMBSJÎJOHFSFLMJ
PMEVþVOVTÚZMFS
"EBMFUJOPMEVþVZFSEFIV[VSVOPMBDBþ‘O‘BOMBS
"%"-&5 "EBMFU,BWSBN‘ )PāHÚSà .FSIBNFU  "MMBI‘OBEJMPMEVþVOVWFBEJMPMBOJOTBOMBS‘TFWEJþJOJ
:BSE‘NMBāNB  CJMJS
"EJM%BWSBO‘ā
%JþFSLÉNM‘L 1FZHBNCFSMFSJOIFSLFTFBEJMWFFāJUEBWSBOE‘þ‘O‘CJMJS
,FOEJIBZBU‘OEBO BEJMPMNBEBWSBO‘āMBS‘OBÚSOFLMFS
WFSJS
ÿOTBOMBS‘OCJSCJSMFSJOFLBSā‘BEJMEBWSBONBMBS‘
HFSFLUJþJOJTÚZMFS

i:BSE‘NMBāNBwWFiQBZMBāNBwLBWSBNMBS‘O‘ÚþSFOJS
.BEEJ ZJZFDFL FāZB IFEJZF WFNBOFWJ TFWJOÎ BD‘ 
WBLJU FNFL UFDSàCF CJMHJWC QBZMBā‘NMBS‘OJMJāLJMFSJ
:BSE‘NMBāNBO‘O
ÿTSBG &NBOFU HàÎMFOEJSEJþJOJCJMJS
½OFNJ
#JMJODJ 4PSVNMVMVL  .BEEJCJSHàDFTBIJQPMNBZ‘ QBZMBāNBWF
)[1FZHBNCFS
:"3%*.-"Ā." $ÚNFSUMJL 1BZMBāNB ZBSE‘NMBāNBJÎJOJTUFS
%ÚOFNJ:BSE‘NMBāNB
%":"/*Ā." #JMJODJ :BSE‘NMBāNBWFQBZMBāNBO‘OLJāJTFMWFNBOFWJ
½SOFLMFSJ
7& EPZVNVBSUU‘SE‘þ‘O‘CJMJS
5PQMVNTBM
1":-"Ā." :BSE‘NMBāNBWFQBZMBāNBO‘OUPQMVNEBLBSEFāMJL 
:BSE‘NMBāNBWFÃMGFU
CJSMJLWFCFSBCFSMJLEVZHVMBS‘O‘HFMJāUJSEJþJOJCJMJS
;FLÉUWFTBEBLBJCBEFUJJMFEFQBZMBāNBWF
ZBSE‘NMBāNBEVZHVMBS‘O‘OHFMJāUJþJOJCJMJS
4FWJOÎMFSJOQBZMBā‘MNBT‘BE‘OBEJOÔCBZSBNMBS 
NàCBSFLHàOWFHFDFMFSJOCJSG‘STBUPMEVþVOVLBWSBS

7BUBOWF#BZSBL
7"5"/7& 4FWHJTJ 7BUBOTFWHJTJOJOLVUTBMCJSTFWHJPMEVþVOVCJMJS
4FWHJ 4BZH‘ 
#":3", 7BUBO‘N‘±PL #BZSBþBWFÿTUJLMBM.BSā‘OBOFEFOTBZH‘HÚTUFSNFTJ
%JþFSLÉNM‘L &NBOFU HFSFLUJþJOJCJMJS
4&7(ÿ4ÿ 4FWJZPSVN #JMJODJ ĀFIBEFU ĀFIJUMJL
#BZSBþ‘N‘[WFÿTUJLMBM
.BSā‘N‘[

(àWFOJMJSMJLWFEPþSVMVLUFSJNMFSJOJOUBO‘N‘O‘
TÚZMFS
"MMBIBIFSLPOVEBWFIFS[BNBOHàWFOJMNFTJ
)FS;BNBO(àWFOJMJS HFSFLUJþJOJTÚZMFS
)PāHÚSà .FSIBNFU 
WF%PþSV0MNBL 1FZHBNCFSMFSJOHàWFOJMJSWFEPþSVJOTBOMBS
(Ã7&/ÿ-ÿ3-ÿ,7& :BSE‘NMBāNB 
(àWFOJMJSWF%PþSV %JþFSLÉNM‘L "IEF PMEVþVOVTÚZMFS
%Ã3Ã45-Ã,
ÿOTBO‘O½[FMMJLMFSJ 7FGB 4BNJNJZFU  (àWFOJMJSWFEPþSVJOTBOMBS‘OÚ[FMMJLMFSJOJTÚZMFS
%0ý36-6,
)[1FZHBNCFSWF 4BEBLBU %àSàTUMàL  %àSàTU HàWFOJMJSWFFNBOFUJLPSVZBOCJSJPMNBO‘O
4‘GBUMBS‘ )BLLBOJZFU ½SOFLMJL "MMBI‘OFNSJPMEVþVOVJGBEFFEFS
½[àOEFWF4Ú[àOEF "MMBI‘OWF)[1FZHBNCFSJOHàWFOJMJSWFEPþSV
#JS0MNBL PMBOMBS‘TFWEJþJOJTÚZMFS
.àTMàNBO‘OHàWFOJMJSJOTBOPMEVþVOVTÚZMFS
.àTMàNBO‘OEPþSVTÚ[MàPMNBT‘HFSFLUJþJOJBOMBS
%PþSVEBWSBO‘āMBSTFSHJMFNFOJOJOTBO‘NVUMV
FUUJþJOJLBWSBS

341
±0$6,&7-&3ÿ%ÿ/)ÿ;.&5ÿ±"-*Ā."130(3".*
7"5" /  7 &  # " : 3 " ,  4 & 7 ( ÿ 4 ÿ :"Ā
"/",0/6 "-5,0/6 %&ý&3 ,";"/*.-"3*
ÿZJMJLUFSJNJOJOUBO‘N‘O‘TÚZMFS
"MMBIÿZJMFSJ4FWFS "MMBI‘OJZJMJLZBQNBZ‘FNSFUUJþJOJTÚZMFS
ÿZJMJLWFÿITBO )[1FZHBNCFSJOJZJMJþJZBZNBLJÎJOHÚOEFSJMEJþJOJ
ÿ:ÿ-ÿ,WF ÿZJMJL 4FWHJ  LBWSBS
,BWSBN‘
"3,"%"Ā-*, "MÎBL(ÚOàMMàMàL  ÿOTBOMBSBHàMàNTFNFOJO TFMBNWFSNFOJOJZJMJL
ÿZJMJLUF½ODà 7FGBM‘0MNB  PMEVþVOVBOMBS
0MNBL &NQBUJ (ÚOàMMàMàL  ÿZJPMBOJOTBOMBS‘OÚ[FMMJLMFSJOJTÚZMFS
½OEFSMJL ÿZJEBWSBO‘āMBSBÚSOFLMFSWFSJS
#àUàOWBSM‘LMBSBLBSā‘JZJMJLZBQ‘MNBT‘HFSFLUJþJOJ
TÚZMFS

%VBO‘OOFEFNFLPMEVþVOVCJMJS
/JÎJOEVBFEJMNFTJHFSFLUJþJOJCJMJS
,VMMVþVO½[à%VB
/BT‘MEVBFEJMFDFþJOJCJMJS
%VBO‘O.BIJZFUJ
5àLFONF[CJSHàÎLBZOBþ‘PMBOEVBO‘OIFS[BNBOWF
%6" %VBT‘,BCVM0MBOMBS ĀàLàS )BNE (àWFO IFSLPāVMEBZBQ‘MBCJMFDFþJOJCJMJS
/BNB[4VSFWF %VBMBSBIFS[BNBODFWBQWFSJMEJþJOJCJMJS
%VBMBS‘ F[CFSWF
BOMBN‘ )BOHJOBNB[EBIBOHJTVSFWFEVBMBS‘PLVZBDBþ‘O‘
CJMJSWFF[CFSFPLVS

iĀàLàSwLBWSBN‘O‘OOFEFNFLPMEVþVOVCJMJS
"MMBIBĀàLàS
4BIJQPMEVþVOJNFUMFSJOGBSL‘OBWBS‘S
/JNFUMFSJO,‘ZNFUJOJ
"MMBIBOJÎJOWFOBT‘MāàLSFUNFTJHFSFLUJþJOJCJMJS
ĀÃ,Ã3 #JMNFL ĀàLàS )BNE 5FāFLLàS #BāLBMBS‘ZMBLFOEJTJOJL‘ZBTMBNBEBOāàLSFUNFTJ
/JNFU,àMGFU%FOHFTJ
HFSFLUJþJOJCJMJS
ÿOTBOMBSB5FāFLLàS
,FOEJTJOFJZJMJLZBQBOJOTBOMBSBUFāFLLàSFUNFTJ
HFSFLUJþJOJCJMJS

342
±0$6,&7-&3ÿ%ÿ/)ÿ;.&5ÿ±"-*Ā."130(3".*
7"5" /  7 &  # " : 3 " ,  4 & 7 ( ÿ 4 ÿ :"Ā
"/",0/6 "-5,0/6 .&4"+ ,";"/*.-"3*

A)FSOFPMVSTBPMTVO
ÿNBO&TBTMBS‘
"MMBICFOJTFWFS
"MMBIBÿNBO
BOMBZ‘ā‘HFMJāUJSJMNFMJEJS
"MMBI‘O7BSM‘þ‘WF ÿNBOFTBTMBS‘O‘CJMJS
#JSMJþJ A:BMO‘[EFþJMJN 
"MMBIBJNBOFUNFOJOJNBO‘OFTBTMBS‘OEBOPMEVþVOV
,FMJNFJ5FWIJEWF "MMBICFOJNMFNFTBK‘ CJMJS
,FMJNFJĀFIBEFU WFSJMNFMJEJS
"MMBI‘OWBSWFCJSPMEVþVOVCJMJS
"MMBI4FWHJTJOJO A#Bā‘NBHFMFOMFS
ÃTUàOMàþàWF ,FMJNFJ5FWIJEWF,FMJNFJĀFIBEFUJTÚZMFS
"--") "MMBI‘OCFOJ
:àDFMJþJ "MMBITFWHJTJOJOUàNTFWHJMFSEFOàTUàOWFZàDF
4&7(ÿ4ÿ TFWNFZJāJOEFO PMEVþVOVCJMJS
"MMBI ,VMMBS‘JMF
EFþJM JOTBOMBS‘O "MMBI‘OCJ[JTFWEJþJOJWFIFS[BNBOCJ[JNMFPMEVþVOV
#FSBCFSEJS
ZBOM‘āMBS‘OEBO CJMJS
"MMBI‘O4FWEJþJ
WF3B[‘0MEVþV LBZOBLMBO‘ZPSBMH‘T‘ "MMBI‘OTFWEJþJWFSB[‘PMEVþVEBWSBO‘āMBS‘CJMJS
%BWSBO‘āMBS PMVāUVSVMNBM‘E‘S "MMBITFWHJTJOJOJOTBO‘NVUMVWFHàÎMàL‘ME‘þ‘O‘CJMJS
"MMBI4FWHJTJOJO "MMBI‘TFWNFL
,VMMBSÃ[FSJOEFLJ
JÎJOOFÎPLTFCFCJ
&ULJTJ
PMEVþVOVGBSLFUNFTJ
TBþMBONBM‘E‘S

1FZHBNCFSJNJ[
ÎPDVLMBS‘ÎPLTFWFSEJ
CFOJEFTFWJZPS
1FZHBNCFSFÿNBO 1FZHBNCFSJNJ[
1FZHBNCFSMFSF0MBO ÎPDVLMBS‘IJÎà[NF[EJ
ÿIUJZBÎ 1FZHBNCFSJNJ[
1FZHBNCFSMFSF ÎPDVLMBSB[BNBO 1FZHBNCFSMFSFJNBOFUNFOJOJNBO‘OFTBTMBS‘OEBO
ÿNBOWFÿUBBU"MMBI‘O BZ‘S‘S POMBSMBPZVO CJSJPMEVþVOVCJMJS
&NSJEJS PZOBSE‘
"MMBI‘OOFEFOQFZHBNCFSMFSHÚOEFSEJþJOJCJMJS
1FZHBNCFSMFSJO 1FZHBNCFSJNJ[
1&:(".#&3 (ÚSFWMFSJWF 1FZHBNCFSMFSFJNBOWFJUBBUFUNFOJO"MMBI‘OFNSJ
ÎPDVLMBSBāFGLBU
4&7(ÿ4ÿ ½[FMMJLMFSJ PMEVþVOVCJMJS
HÚTUFSJSEJ
1FZHBNCFSJNJ[J 1FZHBNCFSMFSJOHÚSFWWFÚ[FMMJLMFSJOJCJMJS
1FZHBNCFSJNJ[EF
5BO‘NBL 4FWNFLWF CJ[JNHJCJBOOFTJ[WF )[.VIBNNFEJUBO‘S TFWFSWFÚSOFLBM‘S
½SOFL"MNBL CBCBT‘[CàZàNàāUà 7FEB)VUCFTJOEFLJFWSFOTFMNFTBKMBS‘CJMJS
7FEB)VUCFTJOEFLJ "NBCàZàEàþàOEF
&WSFOTFM.FTBKMBS ÎPLJZJCJSCBCB
PMNVāUV
1FZHBNCFSJNJ
TFWJZPSVNÎàOLàP
ÎPLJZJCJSJOTBOE‘

343
±0$6,&7-&3ÿ%ÿ/)ÿ;.&5ÿ±"-*Ā."130(3".*
7"5" /  7 &  # " : 3 " ,  4 & 7 ( ÿ 4 ÿ :"Ā
"/",0/6 "-5,0/6 .&4"+ ,";"/*.-"3*

.FMFLMFSFJNBOFUNFOJOJNBO‘OFTBTMBS‘OEBOCJSJ
PMEVþVOVCJMJS
.FMFLMFSJOOJÎJOZBSBU‘ME‘LMBS‘O‘WFÚ[FMMJLMFSJOJ
CJMJS
%ÚSUCàZàLNFMFþJOWFEJþFSNFMFLMFSJO
HÚSFWMFSJOJCJMJS
,VSBOCFOJNZPM ,JUBQMBSBJNBOFUNFOJO JNBO‘OFTBTMBS‘OEBOCJSJ
.FMFLMFSFÿNBO IBSJUBNE‘S POBCBLBSBL PMEVþVOVCJMJS
&EJZPSV[ IBZBU‘N‘Eà[FOMFSWF "MMBI‘O CB[‘QFZHBNCFSMFSFLJUBQHÚOEFSEJþJOJ
,VUTBM,JUBQMBS EPþSVZÚOàCVMVSVN CJMJS
.&-&,-&3ÿ ,VUTBM,JUBQMBSWF ,VSBOCBOB"MMBI‘O %JþFSLVUTBMLJUBQMBS‘OEB"MMBIUBSBG‘OEBO
5"/*:"-*. ,VSBO‘,FSJN CJSIFEJZFTJEJS HÚOEFSJMEJþJOJBODBLJOTBOMBSUBSBG‘OEBOUBISJG
,63"/* 3FICFSJN,VSBO FEJMEJþJOJCJMJS
,VSBO"MMBI‘OCFOJ
,&3ÿ.7& ,VSBOMB VOVUNBE‘þ‘O‘WFIFS ,VSBO‘OJOEJSJMJāBNBD‘O‘WFTàSFDJOJCJMJS
%ÿý&3 5BO‘ā‘ZPSVN BOCFOJNMFJSUJCBU ,VSBO‘OJOTBOMBSBHÚOEFSJMFOSFICFSCJSLJUBQ
,654"-
,VSBOB5BCJPMNBL LVSEVþVOVHÚTUFSJS PMEVþVOVCJMJS
,ÿ5"1-"3
,VSBO‘ ,VSBOBVZEVLÎBEBIB ,VSBO‘ONBIJZFUJOJWFUFNFMLPOVMBS‘O‘CJMJS
½þSFONFL NVUMV IV[VSMV CBāBS‘M‘ 5FNFMLPOVMBSIFZFUUBSBG‘OEBOUFTQJUFEJMFDFL 
WFHàWFOMJPMVSVN iIBZBULJUBC‘,VSBOw
,VSBO‘OIFEFnFEJþJJOTBONPEFMJOJO
Ú[FMMJLMFSJOJCJMJS
,VSBO‘OFNJSWFZBTBLMBS‘O‘OIFS[BNBOWF
NFLÉOEBJOBOBOMBSJÎJOCBþMBZ‘D‘PMEVþVOVCJMJS
,VSBO‘OÚþSFOJMNFTJOJOWFBOMBā‘MNBT‘O‘O
HFSFLMJMJþJOJCJMJS

"MMBIIFSāFZJCJSÚMÎàZF ,BEFSJOOFPMEVþVOVCJMJS
HÚSFZBSBUN‘āU‘S
,BEFSFJNBOMBHàÎMàCJS"MMBIJOBOD‘OBTBIJQ
,BEFS,BWSBN‘ ÿOTBOBL‘MWFJSBEFTBIJCJ PMVS
PMEVþVJÎJOÚ[HàSWF
,BEFSFÿNBOWF ÿOTBO‘OZBQ‘QFUNFMFSJOJOLFOEJJSBEFTJZMF
TPSVNMVCJSWBSM‘LU‘S
"MMBIÿOBOD‘ PMEVþVOVCJMJS
:BāBE‘LMBS‘N‘[B ÿOTBOÎBM‘āNBT‘O‘O
,"%&3 LBSā‘M‘þ‘O‘IFNCV ÿOTBO‘OZBāBE‘LMBS‘O‘OLFOEJTJOJOWFZB
±FWSFNJ[JO&ULJTJ ÎFWSFTJOJOJSBEFTJZMFPMEVþVOVCJMJS
")ÿ3&5)":"5* EàOZBEBIFNBIJSFUUF
,BWSBNMBSMB"IJSFU "IJSFUFJNBOFUNFOJO JNBO‘OāBSUMBS‘OEBOCJSJ
BMBDBLU‘S
"IJSFUFÿNBO‘O PMEVþVOVCJMJS
,B[BOE‘SE‘LMBS‘ ÿOTBOEBLJBEBMFUEVZHVTV
BIJSFUFJOBONBZ‘HFSFLMJ "IJSFUMFJMHJMJLBWSBNMBS‘CJMJS
L‘MBS "IJSFUFJNBOFUNFOJOJOTBOBLB[BOE‘SE‘LMBS‘O‘
"IJSFUFJNBOJOTBO‘O CJMJS
IBZBU‘O‘BOMBNMBOE‘S‘S

344
±0$6,&7-&3ÿ%ÿ/)ÿ;.&5ÿ±"-*Ā."130(3".*
7"5" /  7 &  # " : 3 " ,  4 & 7 ( ÿ 4 ÿ :"Ā
"/",0/6 "-5,0/6 .&4"+ ,";"/*.-"3*

#FEFOJNUFNJ[
PMNBM‘E‘S ÿTMBNEJOJOJOUFNJ[MJLLPOVTVOBZBLMBā‘N‘O‘
5FNJ[PMVSTBN BZFUWFIBEJTMFSMFLBWSBS
5FNJ[MJL LFOEJNJJZJIJTTFEFSJN 5FNJ[MJþJNBEEJWFNBOFWJZÚOàZMFLBWSBS
ÿNBOEBOE‘S WFÎFWSFNFPMVNMVCJS
FOFSKJWFSJSJN "CEFTUWFHVTàMBMNBZ‘CJMJS
.BEEJWF.BOFWJ
0EBN‘FāZBMBS‘N‘ 5ÚWCFOJONBOFWJUFNJ[MJLPMEVþVOVCJMJS
5FNJ[MJL
WFÎFWSFNJUFNJ[ ÿCBEFUJOBOMBN‘O‘CJMJSWFÎFāJUMFSJOJBΑLMBS
"CEFTUWF(VTàM UVUNBM‘Z‘N :BQ‘MNBT‘HFSFLFOJCBEFUMFSJOOFMFSPMEVþVOV
.BOFWJ"S‘ONB )FQJNJ[UFNJ[PMVSTBL
CJMJS
5&.ÿ;-ÿ,  5ÚWCF UàNEàOZBUFNJ[PMVS
"MMBI‘OS‘[BT‘O‘LB[BOE‘SBDBLIFSEBWSBO‘ā‘O
ÿ#"%&5 ÿCBEFU,BWSBN‘ 5FNJ[MJLZFNFJÎNF JCBEFUPMEVþVOVCJMJS
#ÿ-ÿ/$ÿ ÿCBEFUMFSJNJ[ HJCJ[PSVOMVCJS
JIUJZBÎU‘SWFJINBM ÿCBEFUMFSJ"MMBI‘TFWEJþJJÎJOZBQNBT‘HFSFLUJþJOJ
4BMJI"NFM3BCCJO CJMJS
3‘[BT‘OB6MBāNBL FEJMNFNFMJEJS
"MMBI UFNJ[MJþJOF ÿCBEFUJOJOTBO‘LÚUàZFZÚOFMNFLUFO
ÿCBEFUJO BM‘LPZEVþVOVWFJZJEBWSBO‘āMBS‘HFMJāUJSEJþJOJCJMJS
EJLLBUFEFOLVMMBS‘O‘
,B[BOE‘SE‘LMBS‘ TFWFS /BNB[JCBEFUJOJOJOTBO‘LÚUàMàLMFSEFO
%JOJO%JSFþJ ÿCBEFUFUNFLCFOJ BM‘LPZEVþVOVCJMJS
/BNB[ "MMBIBEBIBÎPL /BNB[‘OOBT‘ML‘M‘OE‘þ‘O‘CJMJS
,VMMVL ZBLMBāU‘S‘S
ÿCBEFUMFSJOWàDVEVNV[BTBþM‘L SVIVNV[B
4PSVNMVMVþV /BNB[IV[VSWFSJSWF
IV[VSLB[BOE‘SE‘þ‘O‘CJMJS
ÿCBEFUMFSJNJ[ IBZBU‘N‘EFOHFMFS
0SVÎBÎMBS‘OIÉMJOEFO 0SVÎJCBEFUJOJOOFmTUFSCJZFTJWFWàDVU
BOMBNBN‘TBþMBS TBþM‘þ‘OBLBUL‘TBþMBE‘þ‘O‘CJMJS
;FLÉUNVIUBÎMBSB ÿCBEFUJO"MMBIBWFLFOEJOFLBSā‘TPSVNMVMVL
ZBSE‘NFUNFNJTBþMBS CJMJODJHFMJāUJSEJþJOJCJMJS
)BDCàUàO ;FLÉUJCBEFUJOJWFUPQMVNTBMZBSBSMBS‘O‘CJMJS
.àTMàNBOMBS‘CJS )BDJCBEFUJOJO"MMBILBU‘OEBàTUàOMàþàO
BSBZBUPQMBZBOWF ZBMO‘[DBUBLWBEBPMEVþVEàāàODFTJOJZBāBUU‘þ‘O‘
TFWHJCBþMBS‘LVSBOCJS CJMJS
JCBEFUUJS
ÿCBEFUMFSJO"MMBIBLBSā‘CJSāàLàSJGBEFTJ
ÿCBEFUMFSCFOJ PMEVþVOVCJMJS
LÚUàMàLUFOLPSVS 
JZJMJþFZÚOMFOEJSJS

.BISFNJZFUCJMJODJ
LPSLVUBSBLZBEB
)FMBMWF)BSBN‘ BāBþ‘MBZBSBLEFþJM EPþBM )FMBMWFIBSBNLBWSBNMBS‘O‘OBOMBN‘O‘CJMJS
½þSFOJZPSVN WFNàāmLCJSZBLMBā‘NMB ,VSBOEBHFÎFOIBSBNMBS‘CJMJS
&EFQ )BZÉWF BOMBU‘MNBM‘E‘S )FMBMMFSJOOFLBEBSÎPLWFHà[FMPMEVþVOVCJMJS
.BISFNJZFU %PLVOVMNBT‘ &EFQ IBZÉWFNBISFNJZFULBWSBNMBS‘O‘CJMJS
)&-"-)"3". #FEFO&NBOFUJ ZBTBLCÚMHFMFSMF
JMHJMJGBSL‘OEBM‘L "MMBI‘OIFSJOTBO‘Ú[FMZBSBUU‘þ‘O‘WFCFEFOJOJO
.")3&.ÿ:&5 .BISFNJZFU4‘O‘SMBS‘ LFOEJTJOFFNBOFUPMEVþVOVCJMJS
PMVāUVSVMNBM‘E‘S
#ÿ-ÿ/$ÿ .BISFNJZFUJO
"OBIUBS‘A)BZ‘S 'J[JLTFMCBTL‘ZBEJSFONF %JþFSJOTBOMBSMBBSBT‘OEBLJCFEFOTFMT‘O‘SMBS‘OOF
%JZFCJMNFL WFJUJSB[FEFCJMNFSFnFLTJ PMNBT‘HFSFLUJþJOJCJMJS
HFMJāUJSJMNFMJEJS .BISFNJZFUCJMJODJOFTBIJQPMNBEBIBZ‘S
"MMBI‘O&EFQMJ
A#FEFOJNCFOJNEJSWF EFNFOJOÚOFNJOJCJMJS
ÿOTBO‘4FWNFTJ
BODBLJ[JOWFSJSTFN
"MMBI‘OFEFQMJWFIBZÉM‘JOTBO‘TFWEJþJOJCJMJS
EPLVOVMBCJMJSNFTBK‘
ÚþSFUJMNFMJEJS

345
±0$6,&7-&3ÿ%ÿ/)ÿ;.&5ÿ±"-*Ā."130(3".*
7"5" /  7 &  # " : 3 " ,  4 & 7 ( ÿ 4 ÿ :"Ā
"/",0/6 "-5,0/6 .&4"+ ,";"/*.-"3*

&NBOFU 1FZHBNCFSJNJ[AFNJO
&NBOFULBWSBN‘O‘EPþSVMVLWFHàWFOJMJSMJL
&NBOFUJO JEJCFOEFFNJOWF
,PSVONBT‘WF CBþMBN‘OEBBΑLMBS
HàWFOJMJSCJSJOTBO
(à[FMMFāUJSJMNFTJ &NBOFUFEJMFOāFZJOTBEFDFLPSVONBT‘EFþJM 
PMNBM‘Z‘N
.àNJOJO&O TFWHJZMFHà[FMMFāUJSJMNFTJHFSFLUJþJOJEFCJMJS
½OFNMJ7BTG‘&NJO #FEFOJNCBOB"MMBI‘O
0MNBL FNBOFUJEJSPZà[EFO &NJOPMNBO‘O NàNJOJOFOÚOFNMJWBTG‘
$BO "L‘M %JOWF CFEFOJNJWFTBþM‘þ‘N‘ PMEVþVOVCJMJS
/FTJM&NBOFUUJS LPSVNBM‘Z‘N 1FZHBNCFSJNJ[JOJTNJOJOi.VIBNNFEàM&NJOw
A0.VIBNNFEàM PMEVþVOVCJMJS
&."/&5 &NJOEJ ,FOEJFāZBMBS‘N
#ÿ-ÿ/$ÿ &NBOFUJ,PSVNBL WFPSUBLBMBOEB $BO‘O BLM‘O EJOJO OFTMJOWFNBM‘OFNBOFU
7"5"/7& ,BNV.BM‘ LVMMBOE‘þ‘N‘[ PMEVþVOVLBWSBS
#":3", &NBOFUUJS FāZBMBSFNBOFUUJS  #BāLBMBS‘O‘OFNBOFUMFSJOJLPSVNBT‘HFSFLUJþJOJ
4&7(ÿ4ÿ 7BUBOWF#BZSBL LPSVNBM‘Z‘N CJMJS
4FWHJTJ
;BNBO‘NEFþFSMJCJS ,BNVNBM‘O‘OFNBOFUPMEVþVOVCJMJSWFLPSVS
7BUBO‘N‘±PL
4FWJZPSVN FNBOFUUJS POVEPþSV
7BUBOTFWHJTJOJOLVUTBMCJSTFWHJPMEVþVOVCJMJS
#BZSBþ‘N‘[WF LVMMBONBM‘Z‘N
#BZSBþBWFÿTUJLMBM.BSā‘OBOFEFOTBZH‘
ÿTUJLMBM.BSā‘N‘[ ÿOTBOMBS‘OCBOB
7BUBOÿÎJO$BO‘O‘ HàWFOFSFLC‘SBLU‘þ‘IFS HÚTUFSNFTJHFSFLUJþJOJCJMJS
0SUBZB,PZBOMBS UàSMàFNBOFUJHÚ[àN ĀFIJUMFSJSBINFUMFBONBT‘HB[JMFSFTBZH‘
iĀFIJUMFSWF(B[JMFSw EVZNBT‘HFSFLUJþJOJCJMJS
HJCJLPSVNBM‘Z‘N

:Bā‘ZPSVN TBþM‘LM‘Z‘N 
ZBMO‘[EFþJMJN ÎPL
āàLàS
4BIJQPMEVLMBS‘NJÎJO
"MMBIBāàLSFEFSTFN i4BC‘SwLBWSBN‘O‘CJMJS
CFOJÚEàMMFOEJSJS,BOBBU i4BC‘SwWFiUBIBNNàMwLBWSBNMBS‘BSBT‘OEBLJGBSL‘
FEFSTFNāàLSFUNJā CJMJS
4BC‘S,BWSBN‘ PMVSVN
4BC‘SWF5BIBNNàM 4BCSFUNFOJOÎBCBJÎFSFOBLUJGCJSTàSFÎPMEVþVOV
"MMBI‘OCBOBWFSEJLMFSJOJ CJMJS
&O#àZàL5FWFLLàM EPþSVLVMMBONBM‘Z‘N 
4"#*3 4BC‘S 5FWFLLàMàOCJSTBC‘SFZMFNJPMEVþVOVCJMJS
JTSBGFUNFNFMJZJN
ĀÃ,Ã3 ĀàLàS,BWSBN‘WF iĀàLàSwLBWSBN‘O‘OOFEFNFLPMEVþVOVCJMJS
.BIJZFUJ ĀàLàS"MMBIB UFāFLLàS ĀàLSàOLVMMVLWFJOTBOM‘LWB[JGFTJPMEVþVOVBOMBS
JOTBOMBSBZÚOFMJLUJSWF 4BIJQPMEVþVOJNFUMFSJOGBSL‘OBWBS‘S/JNFUJOOF
/JNFUFĀàLàS
JLJTJEFCFOJZàDFMUJS PMEVþVOV TBþM‘L BL‘M CBS‘OBDBLZFS ZJZFDFL JÎFDFL 
/FEFO
ĀàLSFUNFMJZJN ĀàLSFEFSTFNCBOB FþJUJNWC WFOJNFULBSā‘T‘OEBOBT‘MCJSEVSVāBTBIJQ
/BT‘M WFSJMFOOJNFUEFWBNM‘ PMNBT‘HFSFLUJþJOJLBWSBS
ĀàLSFUNFMJZJ[ PMBSBLBSUBS"NBāJLÉZFU "MMBIBOJÎJOāàLSFUNFTJHFSFLUJþJOJCJMJS
FEFSTFN "MMBIBOBT‘MāàLSFUNFTJHFSFLUJþJOJCJMJS
FMJNEFLJMFSJEF #BāLBMBS‘ZMBLFOEJTJOJL‘ZBTMBNBEBOāàLSFUNFTJ
LBZCFEFCJMJSJN HFSFLUJþJOJCJMJS
)ÉMJNFāàLSFUNFL
JÎJOCFOEFOEBIB[PS
EVSVNEBPMBOMBSB
CBLNBNZFUFS

346
±0$6,&7-&3ÿ%ÿ/)ÿ;.&5ÿ±"-*Ā."130(3".*
7"5" /  7 &  # " : 3 " ,  4 & 7 ( ÿ 4 ÿ :"Ā
"/",0/6 "-5,0/6 .&4"+ ,";"/*.-"3*

)FSLFTJOÿZJMJþJOJ ,‘TLBOÎM‘LCBāLBT‘OB
ÿTUJZPSVN EFþJM LFOEJNFZBQU‘þ‘N ,FOEJNJ[JÎJOJTUFEJþJNJ[JCBāLBT‘JÎJOEFJTUFNFNJ[
CJSIBLT‘[M‘LU‘S HFSFLUJþJOJCJMJS
)BTFU½ODF#BOB
#FOEJþFSMFSJOEFO
;BSBS )BTFEJOFOÎPLLFOEJOF[BSBSWFSEJþJOJLBWSBS
GBSLM‘CJSZFUFOFþF
)BTFUUFO TBIJCJN L‘TLBONBL )BTFUUFOLVSUVMNBO‘ONàNLàOPMBCJMFDFþJOJCJMJS
,VSUVMNBL.àNLàO ZFSJOFCVZFUFOFþJNJ (‘QUBÚ[FONFJMFL‘TLBOÎM‘LIBTFUBSBT‘OEBLJGBSL‘
)&3,&4ÿ/ (‘QUBWF)BTFU HFMJāUJSFCJMJSJN LBWSBS
ÿ:ÿ-ÿýÿ/ÿ ,FOEJNEFLJ #JSCJSJNJ[JL‘TLBONBL
(à[FMMJLMFS ZFSJOFCJSMJLUFIBSFLFU ,FOEJOEFPMBOZBOM‘āMBS‘GBSLFEFSWFHà[FMMJLMFSJOJ
ÿ45&.&,
1BZMBāNBWF FEFSTFL CJSMJLUF HFMJāUJSJS
1":-"Ā."7&
:"3%*.-"Ā." :BSE‘NMBāNB CBāBS‘S‘[ i:BSE‘NMBāNBwWFiQBZMBāNBwLBWSBNMBS‘O‘ÚþSFOJS
1BZMBāNBO‘O 1BZMBāNBWF .BEEJ ZJZFDFL FāZB IFEJZF WFNBOFWJ TFWJOÎ BD‘ 
.VUMVMVþV ZBSE‘NMBāNBO‘O
WBLJU FNFL UFDSàCF CJMHJWC QBZMBā‘NMBS‘OJMJāLJMFSJ
1BZMBāBSBL FOZBL‘OEBO BJMF 
FāEPTU FOV[BþB HàÎMFOEJSEJþJOJCJMJS
±PþBMNBL
1BZMBāNBWF EPþSVUPQMVNVOIFS .BEEJCJSHàDFTBIJQPMNBZ‘ QBZMBāNBWF
:BSE‘NMBāNB#JSMJLWF LFTJNJOFV[BOBOCJS ZBSE‘NMBāNBJÎJOJTUFS
#FSBCFSMJþJ4BþMBS TFWHJÎFNCFSJPMEVþV :BSE‘NMBāNBWFQBZMBāNBO‘OLJāJTFMWFNBOFWJ
;FLÉUWF4BEBLB WVSHVMBONBM‘E‘S
EPZVNVBSUU‘SE‘þ‘O‘CJMJS
.BM‘"SUU‘S‘S ÿTMBN‘O[FLÉUWF
TBEBLBZ‘ QBZMBāNB :BSE‘NMBāNBWFQBZMBāNBO‘OUPQMVNEBLBSEFāMJL 
1BZMBāNBZB%BJS CJSMJLWFCFSBCFSMJLEVZHVMBS‘O‘HFMJāUJSEJþJOJCJMJS
WFZBSE‘NMBāNBZ‘
½[FM;BNBOMBS
TJTUFNBUJLIÉMF ;FLÉUWFTBEBLBJCBEFUJJMFEFQBZMBāNBWF
#BZSBNMBSWF.àCBSFL
HFUJSNFLJÎJOFNSFUUJþJ ZBSE‘NMBāNBEVZHVMBS‘O‘OHFMJāUJþJOJCJMJS
(FDFMFS
CFMJSUJMNFMJEJS
1BZMBāNBWF 4FWJOÎMFSJOQBZMBā‘MNBT‘BE‘OBEJOÔCBZSBNMBS 
ZBSE‘NMBāNBO‘OZBMO‘[ NàCBSFLHàOWFHFDFMFSJOCJSG‘STBUPMEVþVOVLBWSBS
NBEEJEFþJM TFWJOÎ 
BD‘WFIà[àOMFSJO
QBZMBā‘N‘O‘EBJÎFSFO
NBOFWJCPZVUMBS‘O‘OEB
PMEVþVWVSHVMBONBM‘E‘S
5BUM‘EJMMJWFHàMFS
Zà[MàPMNBLJÎJOÎBCB 4FMBNMBāNBO‘OJMFUJāJNEFLJFULJOSPMàOàCJMJS
4FMBNMBāNBO‘O TBSGFUNFMJZJN 5BUM‘EJMMJWFHàMFSZà[MàPMNBO‘OLB[BOE‘SE‘LMBS‘O‘
½OFNJ "SLBEBāMBS‘NMBJZJ CJMJS
5BUM‘%JM(àMFS:à[ HFÎJONFLJÎJOUBUM‘EJMFWF 1FZHBNCFSJNJ[JOCFEFOEJMJOJOBT‘MLVMMBOE‘þ‘O‘
HàMFSZà[FJIUJZBD‘NWBS CJMJS
1FZHBNCFSJNJ[JO
5BUM‘EJMMJWFHàMFSZà[Mà ½GLF L‘TLBOÎM‘L à[àOUàHJCJEVZHVMBS‘OJOTBOJ
#FEFO%JMJ
PMVSTBNEBIBLPMBZ EVZHVMBSPMEVþVOVCJMJS
ÿ-&5ÿĀÿ.7& 0MVNTV[ LBCVMHÚSàSàN
%VZHVMBSMB#Bā&UNF ½GLFIÉMJOEFLFOEJOJOBT‘MLPOUSPMFEFDFþJOJCJMJS
ÿ-&5ÿĀÿ. #JSUBUM‘UFCFTTàN CJS
Ã[àOUàIÉMJOEFLFOEJOJOBT‘MUFTLJOFEFDFþJOJCJMJS
&/(&--&3ÿ:-& ½GLFNJ:FOFCJMJSJN Hà[FMTÚ[TBZFTJOEF
#"Ā&5.& #BāLBMBS‘OB4BZH‘ ÚODFMJLMFCFOLFOEJNJJZJ #BāLBMBS‘O‘OEVZHVMBS‘O‘BOMBNBT‘WFTBZH‘EVZNBT‘
#"5*- (ÚSHà,VSBMMBS‘ IJTTFEFSJN HFSFLUJþJOJCJMJS
ÿ/"/±-"3 .FUBm[JL7BSM‘LMBS &WSFOEFm[JLÚUFTJ ÿOTBOMBSMBPMBOJMFUJāJNEFBEBC‘NVBāFSFULVSBMMBS‘OB
WBSM‘LMBSNFWDVUUVS  VZNBT‘HFSFLUJþJOJCJMJS
#BU‘MÿOBOÎMBS
CVWBSM‘LMBS‘WFHFSÎFL .FUBm[JLWBSM‘LMBS NFMFL āFZUBO DJO IBLL‘OEB
#BU‘MÿOBOÎMBS‘ Ú[FMMJLMFSJOJBODBL EPþSVCJMHJTBIJCJPMVS
#JMJZPSVN ,VSBOEBOÚþSFOFCJMJSJ[ #BU‘MJOBOÎMBS‘OEJOJNJ[EFZFSJPMNBE‘þ‘O‘CJMJS
#BU‘MJOBO‘āMBS‘OWF #BU‘MJOBOÎMBS‘OLJāJZFWFUPQMVNB[BSBSM‘
IVSBGFMFSJOIBZBU‘N‘[B
PMEVþVOVLBWSBS
IJÎCJSPMVNMVLBUL‘T‘
PMBNB[
347
±0$6,&7-&3ÿ%ÿ/)ÿ;.&5ÿ±"-*Ā."130(3".*
7"5" /  7 &  # " : 3 " ,  4 & 7 ( ÿ 4 ÿ :"Ā
"/",0/6 "-5,0/6 .&4"+ ,";"/*.-"3*

A"MMBIEVBMBS‘N‘
NVUMBLBEVZBSBMH‘T‘
PMVāUVSVMNBM‘E‘S
A"MMBIEVBMBS‘NBFS ,VMIBLL‘LBWSBN‘O‘OBOMBN‘O‘CJMJS
ZBEBHFÎDFWBQWFSJS ,VMIBLL‘OBOJÎJOSJBZFUFUNFTJHFSFLUJþJOJCJMJS
NFTBK‘WFSJMNFMJEJS
,VMIBLL‘OBOBT‘MSJBZFUFEFDFþJOJCJMJS
A%VBFEFSFL
,VM)BLL‘OB3JBZFU HàÎMFOFCJMJSJN  ,VMIBLL‘OBSJBZFUFUNFOJOJOTBOBTBZH‘O‘O
,VM)BLL‘OB IBZBU‘NEBLJ HÚTUFSHFTJPMEVþVOVCJMJS
4BZH‘M‘Z‘N PMVNTV[MVLMBS‘
%VBO‘OOFEFNFLPMEVþVOVCJMJS
,6-)",,* %VB ÿCBEFUJO EFþJāUJSFCJMJSJNBOMBZ‘ā‘
%6" ½[àEàS PMVāUVSVMNBM‘E‘S /JÎJOEVBFEJMNFTJHFSFLUJþJOJCJMJS
/BT‘M%VB&EFMJN A%VBFEFSFL"MMBI /BT‘MEVBFEJMFDFþJOJCJMJS5àLFONF[CJSHàÎLBZOBþ‘
5àLFONF[(àÎ JMFLPOVāVSVNWF
,BZOBþ‘%VB PMBOEVBO‘OIFS[BNBOWFIFSLPāVMEB
ZBMO‘[PMNBE‘þ‘N‘
/BNB[4VSFWF ZBQ‘MBCJMFDFþJOJCJMJS
IJTTFEFSJNBOMBZ‘ā‘
%VBMBS‘
PMVāUVSVMNBM‘E‘S %VBMBSBIFS[BNBODFWBQWFSJMEJþJOJCJMJS
F[CFSWFBOMBN‘
A)FSBOIFSZFSEF )BOHJOBNB[EBIBOHJTVSFWFEVBMBS‘PLVZBDBþ‘O‘
IFSUàSMàJZJWFLÚUà CJMJSWFF[CFSFPLVS
EVSVNEBEVBFEFSFL
"MMBIJMFCBþ‘N‘
HàÎMFOEJSFCJMJSJNmLSJ
WFSJMNFMJEJS



You might also like