Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Taxation - ch-1
Taxation - ch-1
Public Finance, therefore, deals with the income and expenditure of public authorities. It deals with the
financial operations or finances of the government. Central, state and local government raises revenues from
various tax sources and non-tax sources, such as revenue from general, administrative and economic services,
borrowings from individuals, corporations and friendly foreign countries. The government raises revenue
from internal as well as external sources to incur huge expenditure on various functions the government has to
perform. The important ones being maintenance of law and order, defense, socioeconomic development,
etc...Public finance is thus concerned with the use and accomplishment of essential monetary resources of the
government. In fact, public finance deals with how and through what different sources the government gets
income, how it spends it and how it controls and administers its incomes and expenditures. These two
activities, i.e. raising of revenue through taxation and other sources, and spending it on various services plus
borrowings from internal as well as external sources, together constitute “Public Finance.” Therefore, the
subject matter of public finance deals with public revenue, public expenditure, and public debt.
The role of government in a market economy is ever changing. Remember, a market economy is a system of
trade in which businesses are free to compete with each other, thereby setting the value of products and
services and encouraging production. Evidence of a market economy can be found in ancient Mesopotamia
1|Page
and several other ancient civilizations. Economists have long theorized as to the role of government in such a
trade system. For example, Adam Smith, an 18th-century economist, suggested the role of government should
be very hands-off. Smith introduced the concept of the "invisible hand" view of the economy, in which the
phrase "invisible hand" refers to the free market itself determining prices and other aspects of the economy. It
simply states supply and demand will always determine what products and services are offered in a certain
economy. This concept of the "invisible hand" suggests government has a very small role in the free market.
In the early to middle part of the 20th century, Keynesian economics was introduced. J.M. Keynes suggested
the actions of the free market's "invisible hand" led to a major divide between the rich and poor. Keynes also
suggested Smith's approach contributed to increased monopolies and other inequities in the free market. As a
result, Keynes suggested government's role in the economy should increase in order to regulate economic
inequities and fairness to encourage greater participation in the otherwise free market.
Generally. the government has the following roles in the modern economy.
1. Maintain legal and social framework
a. Create laws and provide courts
b. Provide information and services to help the economy function better
c. Establish a system of money
d. Define and enforce property rights
e. Regulate contracts
f. This function helps ensure innovation and, as a result, economic growth
2. Maintain Competition
a. Create and enforce antitrust laws
i. Antitrust laws – rules that prevent businesses from working together to control too much of
an industry or set prices
ii. ii. Note: It is difficult and expensive to detect unfair competition
b. Regulate natural monopolies
i. Natural monopoly – an industry in which there are not enough consumers to support more
than one producer or an industry where one producer can provide all that is demanded at a
lower cost than if there were several competing producers
ii. Example: Electricity and natural gas distribution or water
c. This function keeps producers responsive to consumers
d. This function improves efficiency and competition, and as a result, innovation and economic growth
3. Providing Public Goods and Services
a. Providing goods or services that markets are unwilling or unable to provide – Example:
Infrastructures, National defense, education, health facilities, police protection/security,
environmental protection, water supply, electricity
b. There are costs and benefits of all government actions
c. Problems of free riders – people who use the product but don’t pay for it
4. Redistributing Income
a. Taxing the rich more and giving it back out to the poor section of the society in the form of services,
safety nets, and public goods, subsidies
b. Applying higher income tax rates as the level of income increases/progressive taxation
c. Provide social Security
d. Aid for dependent children
e. Medic care and Medic aid
2|Page
5. Correcting for Externalities
a. Externalities refer to the benefits or harms of an activity caused by a firm or an individual to the out
side party.
b. Externality – a side effect/spill over benefits and costs of an activity to others (something that occurs
as a result of the production process that effects those outside of the market).
c. It can be positive or negative.
d. Positive externalities:- infrastructure expansion, outcome of R & D, education, job opportunities
e. Negative externalities:- Environmental pollution
f. Government can play a role in encouraging positive externalities by providing subsidies for goods or
services that generate spill over benefits.
g. A government subsidy is a payment that effectively lowers the cost of producing a given good or
service.
h. Government can play a role in reducing negative externalities by taxing goods when their production
generates spill over costs.
6. Stabilizing the Economy
a. The gov’t use taxing and spending plans and controls the money supply to try and influence the rate
of inflation, reduce unemployment, and promote economic growth
b. If there is high unemployment the government might increase government spending, reduce taxes,
and/or increase the money supply
c. If there is high inflation the government may decrease government spending, raise taxes, and/or
reduce the money supply
1. Public Revenue
Public Revenue is an important concept of Public Finance. It refers to the income of the Government from
different sources. Dalton in his “Principles of Public Finance” mentioned two kinds of public revenue. Public
revenue includes income from taxes and goods and services of public enterprises, revenue from administrative
activities such as fees, fines etc. and gifts and grants. On the other hand public receipts include all the incomes
of the government received from formal sources.
The sources of public revenue have been broadly divided into Tax Revenue and Non-Tax Revenue
A. Tax Revenue
Taxes are the first and foremost sources of public revenue. Taxes are compulsory payments to government
without expecting direct benefit or return by the tax-payer. Taxes collected by Government are used to
provide common benefits to all. Taxes do not guarantee any direct benefit for person who pays the tax.
B. Non-Tax Revenue
Grants: Grants are made by a higher public authority to a lower one, for example, from the Central to the
State government or from the State to the local government. Grants are given so that a public authority is able
to perform certain activities at the local level. There is no repayment obligation in case of grants.
3|Page
Gifts/Aids: Gifts and donations are voluntarily made by individuals, organizations, foreign governments to
the funds of the government, e.g. Prime Minister’s Relief Fund. Such gifts are usually made at the time of
crisis like war or floods. Gifts cannot be considered a regular source of revenue.
Fees: Fees are an important source of administrative non-tax revenue to the government. The government
provides certain services and charges, certain fees for them. For example, fees are charged for issuing of
passports, granting licenses to telecom companies, driving licenses etc.
Fines and Penalties: Another source of administrative non-tax revenue includes fines and penalties. They are
imposed as a form of punishment for breaking law or non-fulfilment of certain conditions or for failure to
observe some regulations. They are not expected to be a major source of revenue to the government.
Borrowings: When government revenue is not sufficient to meet the public expenditure government borrows
either from internal or external sources. Borrowing is income of the government which creates liability
because the government has to repay the borrowings with interest.
2. Public Expenditure
Public expenditure is incurred by public authorities, Central, State and local Governments either for the
satisfaction of collective needs of the citizens or for promoting their economic and social welfare.
Technically, in the structure of a budget, most governments classify public expenditure into two:
(i) Current expenditure, and
(ii) Capital expenditure
All sorts of administrative and defense expenditure and debt services are called current expenditure. They are
also referred to as non-developmental expenditure. They are intended for continuing the existing flow of goods
and services and maintaining the capital of the country intact. On the other hand, capital expenditures
contribute to increased productive capacity of the nation and therefore, are known as development
expenditure. Expenditures on construction of dams, public works, state enterprises, agricultural and industrial
development etc., are instances of capital expenditure.
4|Page
rates to them will increase their purchasing power, standard of living, health, efficiency and hence their ability
to work and save may increase. Likewise, public expenditure on the maintenance of law and order, creates
confidence in the minds of the people and hence it encourages them to make investment in productive
activities. As production increases, income of the people also increases; hence their ability to work, save and
invest also goes up. Thus it is evident that public expenditure can promote ability to work, save and invest and
thus promote production and employment.
ii. Effects upon willingness to work, save and invest
Public expenditure also affects the willingness of the people to work, save and invest. In the absence of any
saving, the question of investment does not arise at all.
On the contrary, expectation of larger amenities and higher standard of living would stimulate people to work
hard. It is this encouragement which would encourage them to save more and to invest their savings for
production purposes. Expenditure on benefits such as sickness benefits would certainly increase the desire of
the people to work more, since they are assured of relief if they fall sick due to hard work.
iii. Effects on diversion of resources
Public expenditure also affects the diversion of resources. Government incurs public expenditure in the form
of giving financial assistance to productive sector. In the same way, if the government wishes to attract
productive resources to a particular area or region, it will start giving variety of incentives in the form of tax
holidays and other allowances or concessions etc. to the industrialists.
5|Page
4. Effects of public expenditure on economic stability
Economic stability is judged by the behaviour of prices. Price stability is related to the manner in which price
behaves in an economy. There should be a normal rise in price because normal is considered as a sign of a
healthy economy problem arises whenever there are price fluctuations. Price fluctuations may be known as
abnormal economic situations.
6|Page
employment to many individuals and increase in peoples demand for goods and services will lead to
greater production and, thus, will provide employment to large number people.
b. Secondly, in order to increase employment and production, the government should make investment in
basic and heavy industries such as iron steel, atomic power, hydro-electric multipurpose projects, heavy
electricals and engineering, which are needed for making rapid economic development. However, the
objective of public expenditure in mixed economy should not be to compete with the private sector, but
to act as supplementary and complimentary to it.
c. Thirdly, the aim of public expenditure to give fillip to private sector by providing loans, grants and
subsides, tax concessions and exemptions, market and other information and research facilities. The
government may set up special banking and financial facilities such as an industrial development bank
and financial corporation to provide finance for medium and long term loans at low interest rates to
provide adequate finance for private sector industries.
d. Lastly, for the economic development of the country the government must provide indirect fillip by
incurring public expenditure on such heads as education, public health, training and research and
development and on creating employment opportunities in backward regions etc. Besides, economic
overheads include transport and communication, water and power facilities, etc.
3. Public Debt
Public debt refers to the amounts owed by the different levels of government and used to finance public
deficits resulting from a higher level of program spending to budgeted income. Debt can be acquired within
the same country (internal debt) or abroad (external debt) and usually takes the form of bonds, paper and
government securities (although in some cases the debt is acquired directly through a supranational body like
the IMF). A public authority can obtain income through loans and public borrowings. The loans raised in a
particular year constitute receipts for that year. It is an income of a capital nature, while the provision for
repayment of the capital sum for the year constitutes expenditure of a capital nature. The study public debt
also includes:
i. Methods and objectives of public borrowings;
ii. Management of public debt; and
iii. Burden of public debt-internal and external
Methods of public debt are an important instruments of not only raising funds but also for meeting increasing
government expenditure, for securing economic stability, increasing public borrowings during the periods of
inflation and liquidation of public debt during the period of depression, borrowings from the people during
inflation and borrowings from banks during depression and so on.
On the other hand, the government’s borrowing from abroad or international is known as external debt. These
types of debts contribute to the development programmes. A few of the sources are bilateral borrowings,
multilateral borrowings, loans from the Asian Development Bank, World Bank, IMF etc.
7|Page
ii. Budget as an instrument of securing certain objectives, such as promotion of employment,
economic growth with stability, welfare of the weaker sections, infrastructural development for
promoting private investments, etc.
iii. Financial and physical controls through different fiscal tools for controlling private expenditure in
the economy to avoid the effects inflation deflation, recession etc.
5. Economic Stability and Growth
The study of public finance includes fiscal policy of the government in dealing with inflationary and
deflationary situations, instability of the price level, promotion of full employment, growth of economy,
welfare of the people, etc.
Economic stabilization is of recent origin. It has a wide scope to play especially in the less developed
countries. The main task of this section is to frame and look after the implementation of various policies
required for economic stabilization and growth.
It is a convention to look into similarities and dissimilarities between the two so as to provide an analytical
foundation for the decision making aspects of public finance
Similarities
(1) Satisfaction of Human Wants
Both the public and private finance have the same objective, i.e., the satisfaction of human wants. Public
finance is concerned with the satisfaction of social or collective wants, whereas private finance is concerned
with the satisfaction of personal or individual wants.
(3) Borrowings
Another similarity between the public and private finance is that many times both have to be obtained from
the market in the form of borrowings whenever the expenditure of either the government or any individual or
firm exceeds their income/revenue.
8|Page
(6) Problem of Adjustment of Income and Expenditure
Another similarity between public and private finance is that both the public as well as private sectors face the
problem of adjustment of income and expenditure.
Dissimilarities
(1) Motive
The motive of private finance is personal interest or benefit, whereas the motive of public finance is social
benefit or public welfare.
(2) Adjustment Approach of Income and Expenditure
Another dissimilarity between the individual’s private finance and the government’s public finance is that
every individual tries as far as possible to adjust his expenditure to his income because his expenditure
depends on his income. Conversely, the government first prepares its budget. In other words, the government
first determines its expenditure and then devises ways and means to raise the requisite revenue to meet its
expenses.
9|Page
Economic and Social Significance of Public Finance
1. Economic Significance
Economic Stability and maintenance of full employment are the two main goals of public finance in advance
countries like the U.K. and the U.S.A.
In developing countries economists were of the view that the fiscal policies should be formulated for the rapid
economic development.
Public Finance occupies great significance in an under developed or developing country. According to R.J.
Chelliah, “Public Finance has a positive and significant role in the context of economic development.” The
importance of public finance in an under developed/developing country discussed as follows:
10 | P a g e
(6) Mobilization of Resources
Mobilization of resources is another important role of public finance. The government can mobilize or raise
resources by imposing taxes on the people and industries, by encouraging savings through various saving
schemes, surplus of public enterprises and borrowings and making them available for investment for the rapid
economic development of the underdeveloped country.
2. Social Significance
Social justice or equitable distribution of income and wealth is another responsibility of the government in its
public finance operations. As already been discussed there is unequal distribution of income and wealth in
developing countries. There is a wide gap between the rich and the poor. This gap can be bridged by adopting
a rational fiscal policy, such as taxation and public expenditure. In other words luxury items purchased mainly
by the rich should be subjected to higher rates of taxation, and necessary items should be exempted from
taxation.
Social justice also requires investment expenditure on the establishment of enterprises in the public sector. By
doing so, the government would be able to produce goods of mass consumption to make available cheap
goods to the people.
c. Merit Wants
Merit wants are essential private such as food, clothing, housing etc, which are satisfied by the government at
low prices for the poor due to their low level of income. Merit wants are, thus, provided by the government
for the benefit of the poor. These wants are satisfied by the government for the upliftment and progress of the
poor. Such wants are food, clothing, low cost housing (eg. condominium), free nutritious means to school
children, free education to the children of the poor, low priced milk to the poor, old age pensions and social
security measures, maternity benefits etc. Satisfaction of these wants for the poor increases their productivity
efficiency and there by their income.
11 | P a g e
Fiscal Policy to Curb or Prevent Undesirable Wants
Another important aspect of public finance is that the government not only satisfies social wants and merit
wants, but also discourages and curbs certain undesirable wants of the people from the social point of view.
Undesirable wants are cigarette-smoking, liquor drinking, chewing of opium and tobacco etc. Such harmful
wants are discouraged and curbed by imposing heavy taxes and spending large amount on publicity, health
measures for the affected people, etc. are imposed on the people to meet expenditure for the satisfaction of
these wants.
Fiscal Federalism
The subject of fiscal federalism is an extension and basic element of the concept of federalism. It deals
basically with the division of revenue raising power and expenditure responsibilities to multiple layers of
governments formed by federalism. Political power division among the constituent units of federation without
the enabling force; financial power correlated to political power division, ends as nightmare. Hence,
theoretically fiscal decentralization in federal system follows the scope and elements of devolution of power
and functions.
Fiscal federalism deals with separation of assignment of responsibilities and taxation powers among different
levels of governments, why and how intergovernmental transfers are designed and distributed as well as the
right of sub national governments to borrow from financial institutions. Fiscal federalism concerns with the
division of public sector functions and finances among different tiers of government.
Fiscal federalism studies the respective roles and interaction of governments within federal systems, with a
particular focus on the raising, borrowing, and spending of revenues. It examines the functioning of these
systems and tries to provide a principled basis for evaluating them. The study of fiscal federalism can also be
relevant for the fiscal arrangements in devolved systems of government that are not strictly federal.
Generally, the study of fiscal federalism focuses on allocation of expenditure responsibilities, the revenue
raising power and adjusting vertical and horizontal imbalances between the federal and the states and among
the states respectively through intergovernmental fiscal transfer.
12 | P a g e