Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Zachary Neal Methageographys
Zachary Neal Methageographys
Summary. This paper explores the role of restaurants, as consumption spaces, in defining the
consumptional identity of 243 American cities. Specifically, it is asked whether, and how, US
cities can be classified on the basis of the local prevalence of specific types of restaurants—are
some cities culinary deserts, while others are gastronomic oases? A two-stage cluster analysis
reveals four distinct city types, which fall along two intersecting dimensions: a quantitative
dimension of restaurant availability and a qualitative cultural dimension. These four city types
are characterised and connected to the existing literature on consumption spaces, with particular
attention to a strong parallel between these city types and the communities discussed by Richard
Florida. Several directions for future research using the city classification as a conceptual
framework are offered. Additionally, these analyses involve the development and application of a
new method of measuring a city’s number of consumption spaces, which is theoretically superior
to traditional per capita measures and which is described in a methodological appendix.
Without bread, all is misery (William desert’ is used in the public health literature
Cobbett (1763—1835)). to refer to places with limited access to
In the Phoenix New Times “Best of Phoenix reasonably priced nutritious foods (Wrigley,
2003” issue, readers identified Olive Garden 2002). However, food is not only a functional
as the city’s best Italian restaurant, P. F. good, but also a cultural object—consumed
Chang’s as the best Chinese restaurant and not only for its nutrients, but also for its sym-
La Madeleine as the best French restaurant. bolic and aesthetic value. Thus, areas with
Other national chains were also named as limited culturally satisfying restaurant
Phoenix’s best in a number of other categories options might be described by a similar
and, in fact, they have been so recognised by term: ‘culinary desert’. For those who
Phoenix New Times readers for years (see believe that “dining at a spectacular restaurant
Rentschler, 2003). What does it mean when is essential to the claim that one is cultured
the most popular restaurants in Phoenix—the and civilized”, Phoenix just may be a ‘culin-
6th largest city in the US—are the same stan- ary desert’ (Finkelstein, 1989, p.76).
dardised eating-places available in nearly Crewe and Lowe (1995, p. 1877) have
every other large American city? argued that “through their organisation of
Perhaps Phoenix is a desert in more than consumption retailers are creating particular
just the climatic sense. The term ‘food urban landscapes and that qualitative
Zachary Paul Neal is in the Department of Sociology, University of Illinois at Chicago, 1007 West Harrison Street, Chicago, Illinois
60607, USA. Fax: 312 996 5104. E-mail: zneal2@uic.edu. The author would like to thank (alphabetically) William Bridges, Anthony
Orum, Pamela Popielarz and Jennifer Watling-Neal, and also three anonymous referees for their comments on earlier drafts.
0042-0980 Print=1360-063X Online=06=010001 –21 # 2006 The Editors of Urban Studies
DOI: 10.1080=00420980500388728
2 ZACHARY PAUL NEAL
differences are emerging between areas of material needs are increasingly easily satisfied
consumption centres”. Hence ‘microgeogra- in the developed world, attention has shifted
phies of consumption’ emerge and individuals to individuals’ ability to cultivate their
have increasingly differential levels of access desired identities. A significant part of indi-
to specific types of consumption spaces, vidual identity—what Corner (1994) has
which can have important consequences for termed ‘consumptional identity’—is construc-
their quality of life (Mullins et al., 1999; ted and expressed through consumption
Zukin, 2004). Given the highly urbanised choices (Bourdieu, 1984; Zukin, 1995,
nature of both the American population and 2004). Limited access to the desired kind of
American consumption activity, to begin consumption spaces translates into a corre-
mapping these microgeographies we might spondingly limited ability to self-actualise
ask: What kind of cities contain what kind of and therefore into a lower quality of life.
consumption spaces? Because restaurants are Thus, the number and variety of local con-
among the most varied and common, yet sumption spaces has the potential to impact
understudied, consumption spaces, in this directly on one’s quality of life.
study I aim to develop an understanding of The specific collection of consumption
cities in terms of their restaurants. In particu- spaces in an area can also impact on quality of
lar, I ask whether, and how, US cities can be life to the extent that it serves as a marker of
classified on the basis of the local prevalence the social and demographic character of a
of specific types of restaurants—are some place, demarcating a sort of metageography.
cities culinary deserts, while others are gastro- Certainly, such markers not only help us to navi-
nomic oases? gate the social world, but they also indicate
In the first section, I examine the key where we belong and where we do not. For
concepts and prior work that motivate and example, the boutiques of Beverly Hills commu-
inform this study—the roles of consumption nicate not only that it is an up-scale area, but also
spaces and, more narrowly, the restaurant as that if we are not a member of the social élite, we
a consumption space. In the second and third should proceed to the nearest suburban shopping
sections, I detail the methodology and data mall. As Zukin has suggested
employed and describe the city classification
the debate about which kinds of goods and
scheme they reveal. Finally, by characterising
stores belong on the street is also a debate
each of the identified city types, I consider
about who belongs in the city (Zukin,
their theoretical implications.
2004, p. 284).
Lacking access to consumption spaces in
The Mise en Place which an individual ‘fits in’, can render him/
her an outsider, inviting disapproving glances
Consumption and the City
and inspiring feelings of social isolation.
Quality of life. Mullins et al. (1999) note that While discussing consumption spaces in
terms of quality of life may seem overblown,
because consumerism is a core component of
the increasingly dominant role of consump-
contemporary culture, any consideration of a
tion and consumerism in advanced societies
household’s quality of life must therefore
means that such phenomena cannot be
take into account . . . ease of access to con-
ignored or marginalised. However, as these
sumption spaces (Mullins et al., 1999, p. 49).
are new and evolving phenomena, they
The connection between quality of life and remain difficult to understand and I do not
access to consumption spaces rests on the intend to test empirically the claims of
post-materialist shift from a “focus on mate- Mullins et al. (1999) or Zukin (2004).
rial necessities to issues of self-actualisation” Instead, my aim is to provide a preliminary
(Mullins et al., 1999, p. 49; citing Abrahamson mapping of the ‘microgeographies of con-
and Inglehart, 1995). That is, because basic sumption’ which Crewe and Lowe (1995)
CULINARY DESERTS, GASTRONOMIC OASES 3
argue are emerging, which can then serve as a near the lakefront. It is through these consump-
conceptual framework and methodological tion spaces that the city (re)produces its ‘urbs
tool for future explorations of the role(s) of in horto’ (city in a garden) identity.
consumption spaces in cities and their The development of these specific types of
impact on individuals’ quality of life. consumption spaces suggests that Chicago is a
city that values music, art and architecture. It
Urban consumptional identities. Corner’s also suggests that it values recreational ame-
(1994) notion of consumptional identity is nities, especially those that draw on Lake
useful not only when discussing individuals, Michigan as a natural resource. Together,
as above, but also when discussing cities. these values, as expressed through consump-
Using the term ‘symbolic economy’, Zukin tion spaces, point to a city interested in captur-
(1995) has suggested that a city’s collection ing and holding the attention of a
of broadly consumption-oriented institutions demographic sub-segment that includes at
helps to specify its identity or image. By once a bohemian-outdoorsy element and a
examining the kind and number of consump- bourgeois-high culture component. That is,
tion spaces a city contains, it becomes possible by constructing a specific consumptional iden-
to understand and define its consumptional tity through its consumption spaces, Chicago
identity and to know what ‘kind’ of city it is casts itself as a specific kind of city in a
(Crewe and Lowe, 1995). This, in turn, broad social and demographic sense.
makes it possible to identify patterns in urban While a city’s consumptional identity fre-
consumptional identities which both define a quently serves to differentiate it from other
microgeography of consumption and create cities, it is not necessarily so. Scott (1997,
the differential levels of access to consumption p. 324) distinguishes between urban cultures
spaces which impact on quality of life. that are place-bound and those that are
This type of interplay between consumption instances of “non-place globalized occur-
spaces and urban identity has been observed in rences and experiences”. Italo Calvino
many places. The West Edmonton Mall in (1974) captured the experience of the non-
Canada—the largest of its kind at the time— place place when he observed that the shops,
asserted a “new urban identity of centrality signs and even hotels do not change as
for Edmonton” (Shields, 1989, p. 161). one travels from city to city; “Only the
York’s image as a repository of British heri- name of the airport changes” (p. 102).
tage was cultivated through the development Numerous instances of this phenomenon
of—for example, historically themed shop- have been offered, among which Ritzer’s
ping centres (Meethan, 1996). Similarly, (1996) explorations of society’s increasing
Nottingham’s Lace Market has recently been ‘McDonaldisation’ may be the most promi-
renewed through retail growth and is, as it nent. Even microbreweries, which Schnell
once was in the early 20th century, a centre and Reese (2003) have specifically identified
for British fashion (Crewe and Lowe, 1995). as a mode of local identity construction,
Chicago’s Millennium Park provides a have recently been franchised and mass dis-
particularly clear and current example in tributed. In the wake of these and other obser-
America. Like many other urban entertain- vations, Zukin (1998, p. 837) concludes
ment districts, this one offers an opportunity that the “multiplicity of standardised attrac-
to consume music, art and food. What is tions . . . reduce[s] the uniqueness of urban
crucial is the specific type of consumption identities”.
space in which each is offered. The city did Clearly, cities can construct (whether inten-
not build a concert hall, but an open-air tionally or not) many possible consumptional
amphitheatre; not a gallery, but two massive identities, ranging from the vibrant and
outdoor installations; not simply a restaurant, unique to the utterly featureless. Thinking
but a vast al fresco café—all of which are situ- about cities in terms of their specific con-
ated within a meticulously landscaped 25 acres sumptional identities, as Crewe and Lowe
4 ZACHARY PAUL NEAL
(1995) have suggested, brings a new perspec- of a century old. Moreover, both were nar-
tive to urban studies to the extent that it rowly focused—the former on business-
reveals previously obscured geographies. oriented site selection issues, the latter exclu-
Moreover, when these microgeographies of sively on ethnic restaurants. This study is an
consumption have consequences for individ- opportunity to update the record, widen the
uals’ quality of life, identifying them allows scope and improve upon the methodology
for a fuller understanding of the social pro- (see below and Appendix).
cesses involved in consumption. (For a more Mullins et al. (1999) used more recent data
thorough review of the growing literature on and adopted a much wider scope, but the
the roles and landscapes of consumption breadth of their study led to the consideration
spaces, see Jackson and Thrift, 1995; of restaurants as consumption spaces only to
Wrigley and Lowe, 1996, 2002). the extent that they “essentially arouse taste
and smell” (Mullins et al., 1999, p. 48). This
conception neglects a wide range of other
The Restaurant as Consumption Space
senses restaurants aim to arouse. Since the
Although a city’s consumptional identity cer- “semiarchitectural confections” of Antonin
tainly has many components, this study Carême, haute cuisine has focused as much
focuses specifically on the role of food con- on the visual as on the olfactory or gustatory
sumption spaces—restaurants. This raises senses (Ferguson, 1998, p. 614). More recently,
two important questions, one conceptual and an entirely new mode of food consumption has
one methodological. First, among the myriad been identified, in which entertainment—
other kinds of consumption spaces, why through audio and visual displays, and oppor-
study restaurants? Secondly, how can tunities to buy non-food items—is the primary
restaurant-focused research deal with the focus (Bell and Valentine, 1997; Gottdiener,
extreme variety among restaurants? I 2000; Miele and Murdoch, 2002). Beyond
respond to the first question here, while the exciting the senses, restaurants have also
latter question, as a methodological issue, is been identified as serving important social
dealt with in the following section. functions ranging from ordinary socialising
(Oldenberg, 1989; Gaudio, 2003) to enforcing
Why study restaurants?. The most straight- social norms and hierarchies (Gottlieb, 1957;
forward reason restaurants warrant exclusive Finkelstein, 1989) and might be considered
consideration in a study of consumption as a “symbolic space or theater for thinking
spaces is that “the geography of dining [that] is connected to self-fashioning”
out . . . seems to be a neglected area of (Shelton, 1990, p. 507). Crang, for example,
research” (Johns and Pine, 2002, p. 126). has offered a detailed participant-observer
First, much work on the locational patterns account of one restaurant in which
of restaurants has been conducted outside the
the function of the dining out experience . . .
US, focusing primarily on Canada (Smith,
is not just about the biological necessity
1985), Australia (Mullins et al., 1999) and
of eating but about social and cultural
the UK (Clarke et al., 2002), Zelinsky’s
positionings, interactions, and experiences
(1985) study of North American ethnic food-
(Crang, 1994, p. 699).
ways being a notable exception. Secondly,
several recent books which address the claim Moreover, food consumption spaces—in par-
that ‘You are where you eat’ have examined ticular, the English coffeehouse and German
restaurants from a cultural and historical, but Tischgesellshaft (table societies)—have been
not explicitly geographical, viewpoint (Fine, recognised by Habermas (1989, ch. 5) as
2001). Finally, while Smith (1985) and some of the most transformative institutions
Zelinsky (1985) have offered the most direct in the public sphere. Restaurants are, there-
examination of restaurant location patterns to fore, more than just places to taste and
date, their data are now more than a quarter smell, and restaurant-focused consumption
CULINARY DESERTS, GASTRONOMIC OASES 5
research will help to situate them more cen- important, as he suggests that “fast food
trally among consumption spaces. outlets are an automobile-related phenom-
Finally, while not specifically aimed at enon, catering to a mobile population of
issues of consumption, Freeman and Hannan workers and shoppers” (Smith, 1985, p. 597).
(1983) have identified several methodological Zelinsky’s (1985) examination of ethnic
advantages to studying restaurants. First, restaurants in North America is of only
because even moderately sized cities contain partial relevance to the present study
some restaurants, research is not restricted to because, whereas he focused on specific ethni-
a focus on only the largest cities. Secondly, cities of cuisine, and Mexican, Italian and
to the extent that restaurant success depends Chinese in particular, I examine ethnic
on local visibility, the Yellow Pages provides cuisine as a unitary category and, moreover,
a ready sampling frame. Finally, there is a one which excludes Mexican, Italian and
great deal of variability among restaurants. Chinese (see below). Nonetheless, he offers
Freeman and Hannan (1983, p. 1131) alone three observations which are sufficiently
noted that restaurants are distinguishable in general to apply in this case. First, he suggests
terms of “type of cuisine, style of service, that “the higher the mean level of affluence,
hours of operation, price range, diversity of education, and associated characteristics the
menu items, and range of services”. This more likely we are to find more eating
variability allows restaurant-focused research places offering ethnic specialties” (Zelinsky,
to consider a wide and nuanced range of insti- p. 68). Secondly, the “turnover of tourists
tutions within the broad category of and other affluent transients” (p. 68) is also
‘restaurant’. expected to be positively associated with the
presence of ethnic restaurants. Finally,
although less easily observed, “the general
Some Expectations
cultural-cum-socioeconomic character of a
In this study, I seek to uncover patterns in the region . . . helps determine its receptivity to
way that restaurants are distributed in cities exotic dishes” (Zelinsky, p. 68).
across the US. Can US cities be grouped on Mullins et al. (1999) also offer some poten-
the basis of their populations of specific types tially useful insights. First, they found that the
of restaurants and what can these groupings majority of consumption spaces are located in
tell us about their consumptional urban identi- recently gentrified urban communities charac-
ties and their broader social and demographic terised by high socioeconomic status and
character? Beyond this relatively exploratory ethnic diversity. Secondly, urban commu-
aim, previous studies offer a number of theor- nities located at the periphery of the metropo-
etically driven preliminary expectations. litan area experience a ‘locational
Examining restaurant locational patterns in disadvantage’ because they contain relatively
Canadian cities, Smith found that cities with few consumption spaces. Finally, and surpris-
larger populations inevitably have a greater ingly, they found that this ‘locational disad-
number and diversity of restaurants, which vantage’ is uncorrelated with poverty. That
he attributes to “small town traditions of is, both affluent and poor communities can
relying on family and friends for entertain- be found in areas with limited concentrations
ment”, or what might now be called ‘social of consumption spaces. These findings
capital’ (Smith, 1985, p. 590). More specifi- suggest that socioeconomic features and a
cally, he found that smaller towns contain place’s proximity to an urban centre will be
fewer ‘regular restaurants’, but more ‘pizza influential although not dispositive.
parlors’ and ‘fast food outlets’ than larger Finally, Florida’s (2003) typology of com-
towns. Thus, I expect that population size munities, derived from his popular ‘creative
will play a significant role in the consump- class’ construct (2002), provides a specific
tional identities of American cities. Urban classificatory scheme against which this
modes of transport are also likely to be study’s results may be compared. Although
6 ZACHARY PAUL NEAL
Table 1. Summary of existing restaurant classifi- efforts, but which also aims to capture those
cation schemes types that have been prominently featured in
Authors Categories recent academic work involving restaurants.
Each of the categories discussed below
Smith (1985) Pizza parlours serves both as a conceptual type and as an
Regular restaurants operationalised count variable.
Ice cream and frozen dessert stores
Fast food restaurants
Doughnut stores Elite restaurants. Highly regarded and
Finkelstein Fête spéciale expensive restaurants might be described as
(1989) Formal élite in two ways: with respect to the quality
Informal of the food served and with respect to the
Amusement
Parodic status they confer on diners. This dichotomy
Bistro mondain is captured by Finkelstein’s (1989) formal
Convenience and informal ‘Fête spéciale’ categories,
Café mundane respectively. Restaurants adopting Miele and
Fast-food chain Murdoch’s (2002) ‘gastronomic aesthetic’
Local ethnic
Cherulnik Luncheonette/Sandwich shop also belong to the former group, but other
(1991) Inexpensive dinner restaurant classifications have dealt with élite restaurants
Family dining without making such a distinction (Cherulnik,
Expensive dinner restaurant 1991; Muller and Woods, 1994). Because the
Muller and Quick service question of whether a restaurant is élite on
Woods Moderate upscale
(1994) Business dining account of its food or status is primarily the
Midscale domain of food critics, this category includes
Upscale both types.
Beardsworth Modes of Theming Because judging a restaurant to be élite is
and Bryman Reliquary (e.g. sports autographs) an inherently subjective task, the operationali-
(1999) Parodic (e.g. Wild West)
Reflexive (e.g. branding) sation of such a variable is difficult and subject
Ethnic to a level of imprecision. The most obvious
Mullins et al. Ethnic restaurants sources of such information are travel guide-
(1999) International fast food books, because they typically employ some
Café/Coffee shop scheme of distinguishing restaurants on the
Other types of restaurant
National (Australian) fast food basis of the quality of the food, service and
Warde et al. Pizza, Fast food, Fish and chip, dining experience. While many such guide-
(1999) Wine bar, Roadside diner, In books exist, those published by the American
store/Shopping mall, Café or Automobile Association (AAA) are superior
teashop, Steakhouse, Pub (bar for the present purposes for several reasons.
meal), Pub (restaurant), Hotel
restaurant, Other British, Indian, First, they cover the widest number of cities,
Chinese, Italian, American- rather than focusing only on the largest or on
style, French, Greek, Other top tourist destinations (for example,
ethnic, Vegetarian, Other Zagat’s). Secondly, they consider the widest
Miele and Restaurants may subscribe to: range of restaurants, rather than focusing
Murdoch an Aesthetic of entertainment or a
(2002) Gastronomic aesthetic only on the most exclusive (for example,
Michelin). Thirdly, they employ a longstand-
ing system of awarding restaurants 1– 5
diamonds based on well-defined objective
example, Fish and chips) or too difficult to and subjective criteria (see AAA, 1997).
operationalise (for example, ‘formal’ versus Because a three-diamond establishment is
‘informal’ Fête spéciale). Thus, I compiled a described as “the entry level into fine
hybrid classification scheme that draws on dining” which aims at providing “an experi-
the individual strengths of these earlier ence rather than just a meal”, (AAA, 1997)
8 ZACHARY PAUL NEAL
this variable counts the total number of estab- tacos) and Italian (pizza and pasta) food
lishments that have been awarded three or (Zelinsky, 1985). Thus, in an attempt to
more diamonds, as indicated in the AAA capture only restaurants serving ethnic
TourBook’s on-line edition (accessed 2004). cuisine that is still somewhat exotic to the
American palate, Chinese, Mexican and
Coffee shops. Although the coffee shop Italian restaurants are excluded. This variable,
appears explicitly in only two prior classifi- then, counts the number of establishments
cations (Mullins et al., 1999; Warde et al., specialising in the 14 varieties of ethnic
1999), it has been the subject of much recent cuisine (excluding Chinese, Mexican and
scholarship. Oldenberg (1989) identified the Italian) distinguished in the ReferenceUSA
coffee shop as an example of a ‘third database.
place’—a place outside home and work/
school where people can interact socially. Fast food. Fast food dining is a ubiquitous
Others have examined coffee houses and part of American life and nearly every classi-
their effect on local culture (Thompson and fication scheme includes at least one fast food
Arsel, 2004), social behaviours (Gaudio, category. Moreover, even the two papers that
2003) and modernity (Örs, 2002). do not directly classify fast food restaurants
Data on this, and the remaining restaurant still include discussions of such establish-
types, were obtained from the ReferenceUSA ments. Beardsworth and Bryman (1999,
database (Version 2004.10) of American p. 243) identify reflexive theming in fast food
businesses. While many prior studies have chains through “corporate décor, logos, and
noted the usefulness of Yellow Pages tele- architectural motifs” (such as McDonald’s
phone directories for identifying restaurants golden arches), while Miele and Murdoch
(Freeman and Hannan, 1983; Smith, 1985; (2002) discuss fast food as antithetical to the
Zelinsky, 1985; Mullins et al., 1999), they slow food movement. Finally, Ritzer (1996)
have also noted some problems. Using the secured fast food’s position as a permanent
ReferenceUSA database avoids a number of object of social scientific interest by placing
these problems: it is compiled from multiple it at the centre of his work on rationalisation.
sources to avoid undercounting, verified Because the fast food segment of the res-
through telephone screening to avoid over- taurant industry is concentrated in a few
counting and produced by a single firm very large firms (US Bureau of the Census,
using consistent cataloging standards which 2004b) and because fast food restaurants
reinforce intercity reliability. This variable often “locate close together to create highly
counts the number of establishments defined visible fast food strips” (Smith, 1985,
as ‘Coffee shops’ by ReferenceUSA. p. 598), a measure of the number of locations
operated by the largest firms is a reasonable
Exotic ethnic restaurants. Many of the exist- proxy for the size of an area’s total fast
ing restaurant classifications include one or food restaurant population. Thus, this variable
more categories for ethnic restaurants. counts the number of locations operated
However, the classification of restaurants as by the 20 fast food chains with the most
ethnic is uniquely problematic in America. locations in the US. Pizza concepts are
Because “Americans have often suspended excluded because many operate both
traditional racial prejudices and opened them- quick-service and full-service units. For
selves to a range of diverse culinary and cul- example, some Pizza Hut locations offer
tural experiences” (Barbas, 2003, p. 669), takeout/delivery only, while others feature
certain ‘ethnic’ cuisines have become so dining rooms.
fully Americanised that their identification
as ethnic is misleading. Barbas (2003) offers Casual dining. This category is meant to
the example of Chinese food, but a similar include those establishments which have
claim can be made of Mexican (nachos and been termed Café mundane (Finkelstein,
CULINARY DESERTS, GASTRONOMIC OASES 9
1989), Inexpensive dinner restaurant (Cherul- number of units in the US) and prominence
nik, 1991) or Midscale/Moderate upscale in the academic literature.
(Muller and Woods, 1994). Finkelstein These categories and variables (summar-
(1989, p. 92) describes such restaurants as ised in Table 2) are intended to be neither
establishments where “hybrid fare is pre- mutually exclusive nor exhaustive. For
sented as more gastronomically respectable example, an individual restaurant may have
than it is” to local suburban patrons who are the properties of multiple types (for
“not disturbed by a sauce too strong . . . or example, an élite ethnic restaurant) and no
the use of inexpensive ingredients”, but also category is provided for ice cream shops
notes that they are ideal for “an undemanding (such as Dairy Queen). This latter case
evening”. Relying on the same logic of con- points to an important caveat and limitation
centration, this variable measures the of this study. The data upon which the ana-
number of locations operated by the 10 lyses are conducted are not wholly descriptive
casual dining chains with the most locations of an area’s restaurant industry, as many indi-
in the US. Concepts identified as ‘family vidual restaurants are not counted by any of
dining’ by the industry publication Restau- these variables. Certainly, a more complete
rants and Institutions are excluded because or more accurate classification (if one is
they do not typically maintain the same pre- even possible), and data that constitute a true
tences of casual dining establishments, census of restaurants rather than just a proxy
aiming rather at serving a more utilitarian sample, would yield better results. Nonethe-
function in a more ‘down-scale’ atmosphere less, the present categories and variables do
(for example, Denny’s, IHOP). begin to capture the variability among res-
taurants, while relying on the most salient
categories in prior classifications and in the
‘Eatertainment’ restaurants. While nearly all wider academic literature.
restaurants aim at providing the diner with an
enjoyable and entertaining experience, this
Results
category includes only that sub-group of res-
taurants for which the provision of an enter- These data can be used to describe two
taining experience is the primary focus. important and differing aspects of cities’ res-
Described as having an aesthetic of entertain- taurant populations: the relative number (i.e.
ment, Miele and Murdoch (2002, p. 314) proportion) and absolute number (i.e. magni-
suggest that this is where “people go . . . for tude) of each type of restaurant. Thus, the
the ambience, to buy clothing, and to see original data were transformed to produce
music and movie memorabilia”. Others have two sets of variables—one reflecting pro-
approached this type of restaurant more nar- portions, another reflecting magnitudes—
rowly through a discussion of theming as a upon which separate two-stage cluster ana-
mechanism of creating an entertaining experi- lyses were conducted. The separate analyses
ence (Finkelstein, 1989; Beardsworth and were then combined and the resulting clusters
Bryman, 1999). The emergence of entertain- are profiled.
ment and theme restaurants has recently The ‘proportion’ data were obtained simply
been dealt with by, among others, Bell and by dividing each original variable by the sum
Valentine (1997) and Gottdiener (2000). of all original variables for each city, such that
However, unlike fast food or casual dining the resulting transformed variables indicate
restaurants, theme and entertainment-focused the relative presence of each type of restaurant
restaurants are both less common and less within the city. The ‘magnitude’ data, by com-
concentrated. Thus, this variable measures parison, required a slightly more complex
the number of units operated by 10 themed transformation. Because it is trivial to
or entertainment-focused restaurant concepts observe that larger cities have more restau-
selected on the basis of size (i.e. total rants, it is necessary to compare cities on the
10 ZACHARY PAUL NEAL
basis of measures of the number of their res- and ‘magnitude’ data. First, all variables
taurants which are not sensitive to population were standardised to range between 0 and 1,
size. However, the most obvious solution—to which Milligan and Cooper (1988) demon-
compare cities on the basis of restaurants per strated is superior, for the purposes of cluster
capita—is also inappropriate because restau- analysis, to more traditional standardisation
rant populations do not increase linearly using z-scores. A hierarchical cluster analysis
with human populations (see Zelinsky, was then performed, using squared Euclidean
1985). For example, while the needs of a distance as a measure of similarity and
city of 10 000 people may be met by a Ward’s method as the clustering algorithm.
single McDonalds, it is not necessarily the The resulting cluster solutions and their corre-
case that a city of 100 000 requires or could sponding agglomeration coefficients were
support 10 McDonalds outlets. Therefore, a inspected and, in each separate analysis, the
pseudo-per-capita transformation based on a two-cluster solution was selected as optimally
set of power functions was used which homogeneous and interpretable (see Hill et al.,
accounts for the unique non-linear relation- 1998). Finally, using the cluster centroids gen-
ship between each restaurant type and popu- erated by the hierarchical clustering as start-
lation (see Appendix). ing-points, the cities were reclustered using
The same clustering techniques were the iterative k-means algorithm to fine-tune
applied, separately, to both the ‘proportion’ cluster memberships (Punj and Stewart, 1983).
CULINARY DESERTS, GASTRONOMIC OASES 11
and Burger King are still common in these only to the well-heeled, but also to gastro-
cities, stylish haute cuisine, hip coffee nomes and ‘foodies’ who want to eat at the
houses and exotic ethnic fare are also easy culinary cutting edge; the coffee houses
to find. The élite restaurants here cater not provide a culture of ‘café cool’ sought by a
CULINARY DESERTS, GASTRONOMIC OASES 13
well. While they have similarly large popu- deserts—the men work in factories and the
lations, they are not nearly as dense. Instead, women care for the children at home. Further-
they are the models of urban sprawl, designed more, the small student population indicates
for a driving public. Both classic socioeco- that these are not small college towns, but
nomic status indicators—educational attain- rather exemplify ‘small town’ America.
ment and income—are lower. The
population is more ethnically homogeneous, A comment on political geography. A brief
despite many of the cities being located in glance at the cluster memberships reveals
some of the country’s primary points of that the Urbane/McCulture divide roughly
entry—Texas and Florida. There are more parallels the 2004 ‘Red’ state/‘Blue’ state
households with children and, relative to dichotomy (i.e. states whose electoral votes
these cities’ lower per capita income, the went to George Bush (Republican) and John
gender earnings gap is wider. Finally, there Kerry (Democrat) respectively, in the 2004
are many fewer people employed in pro- presidential election). Although such obser-
fessional occupations—only service, sales vations are especially fashionable at the time
and office occupational categories have of writing, some have suggested that the
above average employment levels. As a ‘red’ state/‘blue’ state mentality is misleading
sprawling agglomeration of housing develop- (Gastner et al., 2004; Vanderbei, 2004).
ments filled with homogeneous families, and Mapping election outcomes, especially when
an economic landscape of service industry the election is so divisive and contentious, is
and office parks, McCulture oases seem to highly sensitive to choices of measurement
be typical of American suburbia. (for example, winner-take-all vs pro-
portional), unit of analysis (for example,
The deserts. While Urbane and McCulture state vs county), and scaling (for example,
deserts share the same proportional distri- land size vs population size). To be sure, pol-
bution of restaurant types as their oasis itical alignments are likely to differ systemati-
counterparts above, overall they have few cally between the four clusters identified by
restaurants of any type. For example, in a this study, but the methodological difficulties
McCulture desert, there may be only one or involved in connecting such a phenomenon
two fast food establishments, and no coffee to a mapping of 2004 presidential election
houses at all. Similarly, a family may find a outcomes places it beyond the scope of this
cluster of ethnic restaurants or a single paper.
stylish bistro in an Urbane desert, but have
to drive to the next town for a meal the kids
Examining the Classification
will eat.
In many respects, Urbane and McCulture The above characterisations indicate that there
deserts differ socially and demographically are at least a few easily recognisable types of
in the same way as their oasis counterparts, cities, consumptionally speaking. This
although the differences are narrower. As a suggests that Ritzer’s (1996), Zukin’s (1998)
result, they are more difficult to characterise and others’ warning that America is becoming
individually. As a group, however, the culin- increasingly standardised and homogenised
ary deserts are easily distinguished from the may be premature. There are still cities with
gastronomic oases. Three features in particu- unique place-bound identities. Moreover,
lar come together to suggest a coherent Urbane cities, with their more eclectic mix
image for these places: a high level of employ- of consumption opportunities, are nearly as
ment in manufacturing, a large number of common as McCulture cities. On the other
households with children and a wide gap in hand, the most fully ‘McDonaldised’ city
median earnings between men and women. type—the McCulture desert—is more
These seem to suggest that traditional gender common than the other three types combined.
roles still have currency in culinary And, in more than two-thirds of the cities,
CULINARY DESERTS, GASTRONOMIC OASES 15
there are more fast food chains than all while Urbaneness tends to be a bi-coastal
other restaurant types combined. Thus, the phenomenon.
role of such consumptional isomorphism in While Mullins et al. (1999) found that con-
these city types remains somewhat sumption spaces of all kinds are concentrated
ambiguous. in areas of high socioeconomic status and
There are, however, a number of unambigu- diversity, I found that such places—urbane
ous connections between this classification cities—tend to have concentrations of a par-
and the preliminary expectations identified ticular type of consumption space. Findings
earlier. Smith’s (1985) relatively obvious concerning ‘locational disadvantage’ were
observation that larger cities have more res- more consistent. The culinary deserts—those
taurants is confirmed, but also expanded by places lacking in consumption spaces—seem
the finding that populous gastronomic oases to be largely peripheral to or distant from
have more restaurants than their smaller major urban centres. Detroit, however, is a
desert counterparts even after adjusting for notable exception—although highly urba-
the inflationary effects of population size. nised, its residents still experience a locational
This study did not directly confirm that disadvantage. Also confirmed was the finding
small towns have few regular restaurants and that locational disadvantage has little to do
many fast food restaurants, but did find that with poverty, since the culinary deserts span
culinary deserts, which tend to be small, are a range of socioeconomic conditions.
also often McCulture cities dominated by Among the elements expected to emerge in
fast food. Finally, his observation that “fast this classification, the clearest was the role of
food outlets are an automobile-related Florida’s creative class. The four city types
phenomenon” (Smith, 1985, p. 597) helps to profiled above seem to correspond closely
explain why cities with more disperse popu- with Florida’s (2003) four community types.
lations that must commute tend to be in the Moreover, in a recent expansion of his
McCulture groups. theory, which appeared after the inception of
Returning to the hypotheses offered by this study, Florida notes that
Zelsinky (1985), the results are mixed. It is
The industrial economy emphasized big-
confirmed that cities with a greater proportion
ticket amenities like professional sports,
of ethnic restaurants—urbane cities—contain
the fine arts, and cultural destinations. Crea-
populations of greater affluence and edu-
tive economy amenities typically revolve
cational attainment. However, it does not
around outdoor recreational activities and
seem that such ‘affluent’ places also have
lifestyle amenities. While there is not
the highest tourist turnover. Although not
much in the way of systematic and compar-
directly measured, there is significant facial
able data that allows one to examine these
validity (see Table 3) to a connection
differences (Florida, 2005, p. 70).
between high levels of tourism and cities
with large restaurant populations generally The results of this study provide the kind of
(for example, oases), rather than only with systematic and comparable data Florida
ethnic restaurant populations. This inconsis- believes is necessary to understand a pivotal
tency may be due in part to the fact that difference between cities that can and cannot
Zelinsky (1985) conflates ‘tourist’ and ‘afflu- attract members of the creative class.
ent transient’. Finally, while defining a Florida’s (2003) classic social capital com-
region’s ‘cultural-cum-socioeconomic char- munity shares a number of features with the
acter’ is a thorny task indeed, the categories McCulture desert. Both are non-diverse and
divide cities into cultural geographical have lower levels of educational attainment.
regions roughly similar to those identified by One key feature of this type of community
Zelinsky (1973, 1985), albeit with numerous for Florida is the importance of Putnam’s
exceptions—McCulture cities are dominant (2000) conception of social capital, which
in the South, Southwest and Middle West, includes such elements as faith-based
16 ZACHARY PAUL NEAL
institutions, social clubs, volunteerism and university campuses” (Florida, 2005, p. 81),
civic leadership. While not measured here, the significant student population denotes
levels of social capital are likely to be high (the necessary conditions for) the presence
in the small, largely rural, manufacturing of technology. Finally, a large immigrant
cities common among McCulture deserts. As population and the narrowest (relative to per
expected, places with these features have capita income) gender earnings gap indicate
few restaurants and are particularly lacking a clear climate of tolerance and diversity.
in ethnic establishments. The parallel structure of this classification
The parallels between the organisational- with Florida’s supports one of his central
age community and the Urbane desert are claims: members of the creative class prefer
more difficult to identify. However, consistent to live in areas with many lifestyle amenities,
with their characterisation as older, corporate- especially participatory ones. As culinary
dominated areas, the population is densely deserts, social capital and organisational-age
concentrated and slightly more educated, and communities cannot attract these ‘creatives’
employment is dominated by a mix of both and may be nearing the end of their urban
manufacturing and management occupations. life cycle. The McCulture oasis offers more
The striking presence of Californian cities in amenities in the form of an abundance of
this category may obscure a clearer connec- restaurants and thus may be slightly more
tion. Nonetheless, as expected these areas attractive. However, few experiences are
offer limited dining options, but show a more mundane and less participatory than
slight tendency towards more upscale obtaining food at a fast food chain.
restaurants. It is, instead, the particular kind of amenities
The McCulture oasis seems to correspond to available in an Urbane oasis that are sought by
Florida’s unceremoniously labelled ‘Nerdistan’. the creative class. Coffee houses can be partici-
Both have been characterised as big, sprawling patory venues when they feature music by local
regions with economies focused on the service artists, when they become social gathering
sector. As places that concentrate on building spots or when WI-FI (wireless internet
“sports stadiums, freeways, urban malls, and access) is available for getting work done.
tourism-and-entertainment districts that Ethnic restaurants are participatory to the
resemble theme parks”, it is certainly not sur- extent that they engage the diner in a gastro-
prising to find a dominant presence of ‘eatertain- nomic voyage. Finally, although the more
ment’ venues and unpretentious casual dining bohemian factions of the creative class may
chains. However, as these regions have been not frequent élite establishments, they still
“lauded by some as models of rapid economic provide a desirable “external symbol of [the]
growth”, some may be incubating a handful of region’s vibrancy” (Florida, 2005, p. 84).
more Urbane consumption spaces (Florida, The relationship between a city’s consump-
2005, p. 44). For example, in the 2004 tion spaces and the desires of the creative class
Phoenix New Times “Best of Phoenix”, a more underscore the ideas at which this study was
élite establishment had unseated the La Made- initially aimed. Consumption spaces allow
leine chain as the city’s best French restaurant. us to map the world socially, providing hints
The connection appears strongest between about whether a city is upscale or industrial,
the Creative centre and Urbane oasis. Florida’s yuppie-friendly or family-friendly, on its
three Ts of economic development—talent, way up or down. These metageographies
technology, and tolerance—can be found pro- demarcate specific regions within which
minently in both places. A highly educated certain types of people may or may not have
public employed primarily in a professional access to the kinds of consumption spaces
and managerial capacity suggests high levels that are constitutive of their consumptional
of talent. Because “fledgling high-technology identities. That is, to the extent that post-
enterprises are typically incubated in and materialism binds quality of life to consump-
around the districts surrounding major tion space access, these social maps are
CULINARY DESERTS, GASTRONOMIC OASES 17
MILLIGAN , G. W. and COOPER , M. C. (1988) A places over 100,000, ranked by July 1, 2003
Study of Standardization of Variables in population. SUB-EST2003-01. US Bureau of
Cluster Analysis. Journal of Classification 5, the Census, Washington, DC.
pp. 181–204. US BUREAU OF THE CENSUS (2004b) Food services
MULLER , C. C. and WOODS , R. H. (1994) An and drinking places: 2002. 2002 Economic
expanded restaurant typology, The Cornell Census Industry Series (ECO2-721-02). US
Hotel and Restaurant Administration Quarterly, Bureau of the Census, Washington, DC.
35, pp. 27 –37. VANDERBEI , R. (2004) 2004 election maps.
MULLINS , P. (1991) Tourism urbanization, Inter- Princeton University, Princeton, NJ. (http://
national Journal of Urban and Regional www.princeton.edu/rvdb/JAVA/election2004/
Research, 15, pp. 326–342. accessed 23 May 2005).
MULLINS , P., NATALIE , K., SMITH , P. and WARDE , A. and MARTENS , L. (1998) Eating out
SMEATON , B. (1999) Cities and consumption and the commercialisation of mental life,
spaces, Urban Affairs Review, 35, pp. 44 –71. British Food Journal, 100, pp. 147– 153.
OLDENBERG , R. (1989) The Great Good Place: WARDE , A., MARTENS , L. and OLSEN , W. (1999)
Cafes, Coffee Shops, Community Centers, Consumption and the problem of variety:
Beauty Parlors, General Stores, Bars, Hang- cultural omnivorousness, social distinction and
outs, and How They Get You Through the Day. dining out, Sociology, 33, pp. 105–127.
New York: Paragon House. WRIGLEY , N. (2002) ‘Food deserts’ in British
ÖRS , I. (2002) Coffeehouses, cosmopolitanism, cities: policy context and research priorities,
and pluralizing modernities in Istanbul, Urban Studies, 39, pp. 2029–2040.
Journal of Mediterranean Studies, 12, pp. WRIGLEY , N. and LOWE , M. (1996) Retailing,
119–145. Consumption, and Capital: Towards the New
PUNJ , G. and STEWART , D. W. (1983) Cluster Retail Geography. Harlow: Longman Group.
analysis in marketing research: review and sug- WRIGLEY , N. and LOWE , M. (2002) Reading
gestions for application, Journal of Marketing Retail: A Geographical Perspective on Retailing
Research, 20, pp. 134–148. and Consumption Spaces. New York: Oxford
PUTNAM , R. (2000) Bowling Alone: The Collapse University Press.
and Revival of American Community. ZELINSKY , W. (1973) The Cultural Geography of
New York: Simon and Schuster. the United States. Englewood Cliffs, NJ:
RENTSCHLER , K. (2003) Breaking the chains, Prentice-Hall.
Gourmet, 63(10), pp. 192, 194. ZELINSKY , W. (1985) The roving palate: North
RITZER , G. (1996) The McDonaldization of America’s ethnic restaurant cuisines, Geoforum,
Society. Thousand Oaks, CA: Pine Forge Press. 16, pp. 51–77.
SCHNELL , S. M. and REESE , J. F. (2003) Micro- ZUKIN , S. (1991) Landscapes of Power. Berkeley,
breweries as tools of local identity, Journal of CA: University of California Press.
Cultural Geography, 21, pp. 45–69. ZUKIN , S. (1995) The Cultures of Cities.
SCOTT , A. J. (1997) The cultural economy of cities, Cambridge, MA: Blackwell.
International Journal of Urban and Regional ZUKIN , S. (1998) Urban lifestyles: diversity and
Research, 21, pp. 323–339. standardisation in spaces of consumption,
SHELTON , A. (1990) A theater for eating, looking, Urban Studies, 35, pp. 825–839.
and thinking; the restaurant as symbolic space, ZUKIN , S. (2004) Point of Purchase. New York:
Sociological Spectrum, 10, pp. 507–526. Routledge.
SHIELDS , R. (1989) Social spatialization and ZUKIN , S. and MAGUIRE , J. S. (2004) Consumers
the built environment: the west Edmonton and consumption, Annual Review of Sociology,
Mall, Environment and Planning D, 7, pp. 30, pp. 173–197.
147–164.
SMITH , S. L. J. (1985) Location patterns of urban
restaurants, Annals of Tourism Research, 12,
pp. 581–602. Appendix. Power-based Transformation of
THOMPSON , C. J. and ARSEL , Z. (2004) The Star- ‘Magnitude’ Data
bucks brandscape and consumers’ (anticorpo-
rate) expectations of globalization, Journal of Restaurants enjoy an economy of scale with regard
Consumer Research, 31, pp. 631–642. to the number of establishments that are necessary
US BUREAU OF THE CENSUS (2000) Census 2000 to serve a population. While larger populations
Summary Files 1 and 3. US Bureau of the require more restaurants to satisfy their needs, the
Census, Washington, DC. specific number of restaurants necessary per
US BUREAU OF THE CENSUS (2004a) Annual capita decreases for each additional person (i.e. at
estimates of the population for incorporated the margin). Moreover, the rate at which it
CULINARY DESERTS, GASTRONOMIC OASES 21
decreases depends in part on the type of restaurant. group of status-seekers and tourists. To oversim-
Thus, it was first necessary to understand how plify, perhaps each new coffee-drinker wants his
restaurant population size and human population own seat in a place where ‘everybody knows
size are related for each type of restaurant under your name’, while patrons of theme restaurants
consideration. To do so, a trial-and-error search are less likely to have the same sort of personal affi-
method was employed to identify (to two decimal nity for any particular establishment.
places) the power to which a city’s human Whatever the explanation of the specific expo-
population size must be raised to maximise its nent values that correspond to certain types of res-
linear correlation with each restaurant type’s popu- taurant, they indicate the rate at which each type of
lation size (see Gujarati, 2003, p. 566). A unique restaurant might be expected to grow as a city’s
exponent value was obtained for each restaurant human population increases. Put another way,
type: Coffee shops (0.74), Exotic ethnic (0.64), they indicate the degree to which each additional
Casual dining (0.41), Fast food (0.36), Elite person necessitates an additional restaurant of a
(0.31) and Eatertainment (0.19). specific type (i.e. the diminishing marginal utility
Apart from their role in this transformation, of people to restaurants). Therefore, through a
these exponent values hold some interesting series of six equations parallel in form to
substantive information. As a city’s population
grows, in order to keep pace with consumer Number of élite restaurants elite
needs, its population of coffee shops must grow ¼
at nearly the same rate, while a city’s population city population0:31 magnitude
of élite restaurants must grow at only a fraction
of the human population growth rate. That is, the six ‘magnitude’ values were obtained that are con-
economy of scale enjoyed by coffee shops is ceptually parallel to per capita measures, but which
minimal because each additional coffee shop accord lesser weight to each additional person at a
meets the needs of nearly the same number of cus- rate which corresponds to the specific restaurant
tomers as the previous one, while eatertainment type. While the resulting values are difficult to
venues enjoy a dramatic economy of scale. interpret substantively, higher values indicate
Although its confirmation is beyond the scope of more restaurants per person and lower values indi-
this study, one possible explanation is that coffee cate fewer restaurants per person considering the
shops and ethnic restaurants cater to and depend restaurant type and city size. Hence, these values
on a loyal group of regulars who consume most are employed as pseudo-per-capita measures of
of their output, while élite and themed restaurants restaurant population suitable for making compari-
diffuse their output through a constantly circulating sons across cities of different sizes.