Professional Documents
Culture Documents
2002 Branthwaite
2002 Branthwaite
2002 Branthwaite
Very often in qualitative market research, stimulate our facial muscles; while a gory
advertising has been investigated in focus image seems to strike at our own.
groups, and much less often in individual Equally, we can imagine objects or places
interviews (Branthwaite and Swindells, and project them outwards as if they were
1997). However, a strong case can be made physical, real and external. In this way, we can
that group discussion is biased towards the view products and packaging from different
social and rational responses to advertising. sides and manipulate them in our
Verbal interaction focuses on judgements and imagination, or give directions as to where to
cognitive interpretations, and largely find them in a supermarket. Extensive
overlooks the personal, idiosyncratic and research has demonstrated that viewing real
intuitive effects by which brands build objects, pictures or scenes, and the same
associations and character in the consumer’s imagined objects have almost identical
mind. properties in the workings of the mind
This paper looks for alternative tools to (Eysenck and Keane, 2000; Richardson,
investigate the influences of imagery, which 1999). On a very different basis, the same
capture the richness of the effects from conclusion has been drawn by Greenfield
advertising. In particular, techniques that are (2000, p. 73) using neurophysiological
grounded in knowledge and theory will have evidence that we use the same areas of the
greater validity and credibility as to their brain for vision and visual imagination –
effectiveness, and can give clients more ‘‘imagination is vision running backwards’’.
confidence when buying qualitative research Some illustrations will indicate the effects of
(as Shankar and Goulding (2001) have visual imagery and the mechanisms involved.
argued in relation to the interpretation of
verbal accounts). This case is built here Thinking
primarily on psychological evidence and Imagery is used in problem solving, creativity
theory. and feats of remembering. Many scientific
As an aside, it is worth acknowledging that discoveries were produced as a result of
imagery is not only a target for market imagery, such as Faraday’s understanding of
research (which is the focus here), but magnetism: ‘‘An image of invisible lines of
imagery can also be a tool in market research force as narrow tubes curving through space
to act as a vehicle that enables consumers to which rose up before him like things’’. These
express their ideas, intuitive perceptions and images are now accepted routinely as part of a
feelings about brands. Indeed, we frequently shared culture in the way we think of abstract
use pictures, collages, drawing and even clay physical phenomena.
modelling to facilitate the expression of brand Einstein arrived at his theory of relativity
personalities and subjective images (see not by abstract thought or mathematical
Branthwaite et al., 2001; Toiati, 2001, for calculation, but by ‘‘visualising effects,
illustrations of the techniques and analysis). consequences and possibilities’’, which he
These have a role in surfacing unconscious claimed to be his particular ability (Shepard,
ideas and enabling comparisons across 1978). He did this by performing a mental
different cultures. However, this would be the experiment where he imagined himself
topic of a different paper (Branthwaite, 1995; travelling alongside a beam of light (at
Branthwaite and Holme, 1999). 186,000 miles per second!). This enabled him
‘‘to confront the paradox that the stationary
spatial oscillation that he saw corresponded
The power of imagery neither to anything that could be perceptually
experienced as light, nor to anything
The potency of imagery from the point of described by Maxwell’s mathematical
view of communication and persuasion is that equations’’.
it has the capacity to transcend the boundary Extraordinary feats of memory are achieved
between the outside world and what is by visualising objects and placing them in
happening inside us. External objects and sequence around familiar places (Hunter,
events can impinge on us as if they are inside 1964). The famous Russian mnemonic,
of us – the sound of a dentist’s drill in another Shereshevskii, could remember lists of a
room sets our teeth on edge; another’s sneeze, hundred and more objects, words in a foreign
cough or a yawn seems to irritate our lungs or language, lists of geometrical figures, lengthy
165
Investigating the power of imagery in marketing communication Qualitative Market Research: An International Journal
Alan Branthwaite Volume 5 . Number 3 . 2002 . 164±171
formulae, musical motifs. He could recall the the imagery has to engage the reader and
sequence in the order it was given, reverse initiate thought processes (fantasies). It is this
order, or if given an item at random he could cognitive processing that brings about
readily say what came before or after in the arousal. Giving increasingly difficult mental
sequence. He could recall certain series of tasks to do at the same time as exposing
words up to 20 years later. He achieved this participants to erotic materials (which
through imagery, by taking a walk in his progressively blocked their capacity for other
imagination starting from Pushkin Square thoughts) meant that they became
and going down Gorky Street, placing the progressively less aroused (Przybyla, 1983).
objects in notable positions – against a white
wall, beside a street lamp, on top of a wall. Sports performance
Visualisation like this has the particular It is said that sport is played with the body,
benefit of easily preserving sequencing and but it is largely won in the mind. Visualisation
chaining of objects (because, as described is recommended as a technique for
later, it involves episodic memory). concentration by athletes based on their
In hypnosis, it is important to find the right experience in using them in tennis (Jim
imagery to engage the patient and enable Courier), basketball (Michael Jordan) and
them to relax and focus their minds (Heap, figure skating (Nancy Kerrigan). This
1996). Neuro-physiological recordings during involves seeing and feeling a skill in one’s
induction of hypnosis indicate a transition imagination before actually executing it
from frontal, possibly left-biased, hemispheric (Moran, 2000). The technique improves
activation to more posterior right-brain, skilled performance by chunking the sequence
suggesting more imaginal and holistic of movements required, then rehearsing them
processing (Oakley et al., 1996). It is possible to make them more automatic and smoother.
to observe whether children are responding to It is also beneficial to develop the habit of
hypnotic suggestion by observing their positive visualisation by imagining what needs
narrowed, focussed attention and absorption to be done for success, rather than to avoid
in the images and fantasies (even though they mistakes. The secret of effective visualisation
may be still opening and closing their eyes or is to focus on specific actions, that are
fidgeting). The imagery provides an relevant to winning, and under your own
‘‘empathy bridge’’ (McKellar, 1957) between control. The effect is to raise confidence,
patient and hypnotist, which enables them to boost effort and put the mind and muscles
have control, through suggestions, over the into direct synchrony.
subject’s mind and feelings or to change and
implant memories, ideas and attitudes. Medicine and healing – mind/body
interaction
Feelings Images can induce changes in blood sugar
Seeing images of sadness, anger, or fear can level, white blood cell activity and immune
be differentiated by cardiovascular changes in function (Walker, 1997). The use of imagery
the viewer (Graham, 1990). Imagery of in shrines serves to alter the perceptions and
various kinds produces physiological effects expectations believers have of their state of
on heart rate, pupil dilation, blood sugar health, and this serves to bring about
levels, blister formation, etc. Imagining eating physiological effects (Achterberg, 1985). The
a lemon has a direct effect on output from pack imagery and branding of some well-
salivary glands. That images can play a strong known medicines can increase pain relief by
role in the control of autonomic and affective half as much again as the analgesic ingredient
states has been used extensively in procedures (Branthwaite and Cooper, 1981).
for treating stress and phobias. In Cognitive Behavioural Therapy, people
Research reported by the Commission on are introduced to the source of their phobia in
Obscenity and Pornography, set up by the US the form, for example, of a plastic spider or
Congress and President, documented more picture of a snake, and encouraged to move as
precisely than ever before, the potential of close to it as they can. These images still have
static visual images, movies and literature to tremendous power to induce fear or anxiety
arouse feelings. Research shows that there is and the corresponding autonomic reactions
not an automatic reflex response to pictures (heart rate, blood pressure, dry mouth).
or symbols portraying erotic activity. Instead Using this therapy, patients are given help to
166
Investigating the power of imagery in marketing communication Qualitative Market Research: An International Journal
Alan Branthwaite Volume 5 . Number 3 . 2002 . 164±171
reframe the image so that, by altering their distinction has been incorporated into many
perception and expectations of the object, theories of perception and information
they are enabled to control their fears. processing (Branthwaite and Swindells, 1995;
Imagery is a very successful way of assisting Richardson, 1999). In particular, images have
insomniacs to get to sleep. Picturing a a more direct connection to feelings and
pleasant and relaxing scene enabled them to unconscious ideas. Some of these differences
fall asleep 20 minutes sooner (on average) in the way images and language are processed
than if they did nothing. Vivid and engaging are summarised in Figure 1.
scenes that were also relaxing, such as a Images have an immediate impact, as they
waterfall, beach, breaking waves or a favourite are perceived holistically rather than in the
holiday destination were more effective than linear-sequential fashion of verbal accounts.
counting sheep, which delayed the onset of Whereas verbal messages are processed
sleep (Harvey and Payne, 2002). Using rationally and consciously, visual imagery is
imagery blocks out the repetitive verbal perceived and partially processed pre-
ruminations of practical thought. It enables consciously.
detachment from reality and present concerns There is evidence that pre-conscious
as well as transference of mood from the processing is very powerful by evading critical
imagery. scrutiny through conscious, rational appraisal
The number of white blood cells in (Eysenck and Keane, 2000):
circulation, levels of thymosin-alpha1 (a Images affect our impressions of people
hormone especially important to T-helper and places without awareness, as
cells) and other indices of improved immune illustrated by the following experiment.
function are enhanced through imagery Happy or angry faces were flashed on a
(Graham, 1999). These included humorous screen for four milliseconds (subliminally)
movies and a compassionate film about or one second (when they would be
Mother Teresa’s work caring for the sick and consciously seen) while people were
poor. Reporting on this study, Pelletier and looking at Chinese ideographs which they
Herzing (1989) comment that information were rating for liking (a form of projective
and suggestions may enhance immune technique). The liking ratings were
function regardless of whether we are influenced by the facial images only with
outwardly aware of an effect or emotional the shorter exposure, when they were
reaction – ‘‘visualisation translates an abstract ‘‘seen’’ unconsciously so there was no
idea into a concrete experience’’ that opportunity for conscious, rational
produces emotions within us. These, and evaluation or control over feelings.
other findings, prompted awareness that it The affective qualities of an image
may be possible to control physiological
(mood, feelings) are processed much
functions, formerly thought to be involuntary
faster than the cognitive meanings we
or autonomic, by means of imagery.
derive. There is evidence for two distinct
processing systems – the affective and
semantic.
The mechanism of imagery The fast, non-conscious emotion circuit
links sensory information about
Imagery is a powerful tool for changing the
emotional properties of an image
state of mind and body, and obviously much
(analysed in the thalamus) directly to the
used in advertising for this reason. We see
amygdala – ‘‘the brain’s emotional
from these examples that imagery has a strong
computer’’ (LeDoux, 1996). The slow,
role in control of autonomic and affective
cortical emotional circuit, sends
states and can have effects on ideas, attitudes
information from the thalamus to the
and feelings. This is not surprising in the
amygdala via the cortex, where more
evolution of human psychology, as the face
detailed analysis of the emotional
and non-verbal gestures are critically
meaning is conducted.
important for perceiving emotions, inferring
reactions to our actions and words, and Imagery is processed episodically
anticipating others’ responses. (Branthwaite and Swindells, 1997) in terms of
The mechanism for processing images is situations, participants, what is happening, an
different to that for verbal material, and this on-going event, the emotions and experiences
167
Investigating the power of imagery in marketing communication Qualitative Market Research: An International Journal
Alan Branthwaite Volume 5 . Number 3 . 2002 . 164±171
Research tools should tap into episodic ‘‘Metaphysical thinking’’ to force non-
processing at lower levels of consciousness, rational expression of inner personal and
and avoid raising rational scrutiny. To achieve intuitive reactions to the images. For
this, imagery itself is more likely to provide an example, if the advertisment had some
effective tool, as it is more closely related to magical spell, what would it be?
the expression of the unconscious than words.
These techniques for assessing advertising
So responses are less likely to be filtered
imagery are better conducted in individual
through the conscious critical apparatus
interviews rather than group discussion
because language has to be consciously
(Branthwaite and Swindells, 1997).
understood before it can expressed. Also, the
However, to examine more directly the
‘‘mindless’’ commentaries that often parallel
effects of visual imagery there is another
our actions (e.g. talking aloud while working)
approach that may be even more fruitful,
as well as rapid word-associations that are
based on synaesthesia. This literally means
unconnected and disjointed, are less
‘‘experiencing together’’ and people who have
consciously controlled than introspective,
strong imagery often experience this overlap
reflective discourse, and so partially evade
in sensations across different senses. For
semantic censorship.
example, listening to music may give rise to
In part, these criteria can be achieved by the
sensations of colour or images of patterns.
way questions are posed when applying
Shereshevskii, the mnemonist we met earlier,
classical projective techniques, for example:
The use of bubble drawings representing had particularly pronounced synaesthesia.
the consumer in the shopping situation or For him, visual forms were experienced as
using a particular product. By emitting characteristic sounds and having
encouraging respondents to imagine taste; sounds had colour, taste and tactile
themselves in that situation, and to qualities (Hunter, 1964; McKellar, 1997).
spontaneously note down what is running Not everyone has such strong experiences, so
through their mind there, we can look at in some circumstances it may be desirable to
how imagery from an advertisment is recruit specifically for this aptitude, although
going to echo in the consumer’s mind at that raises questions about the
the point of sale or when using that brand. representativeness of the findings.
Laddering is also valuable as a tool to There are eight sensory modes: sight,
probe the symbolism and associations of hearing, touch, taste, smell, pain, temperature
advertising imagery for the individual. and kinaesthesia (the sense of bodily posture
Laddering involves a chain of questions and orientation). These give us many
that, in effect, ask the respondent: what possibilities to explore perceptions and
are the key features of the advertisment associations to imagery by translating
(pictures, words, etc.) and then experiences from the visual modality into
repeatedly probing these to find out what other channels. For example, we can ask
each means to the individual, and why respondents to describe visual imagery in
that is important/interesting to them. terms of other senses:
Systematically repeating these questions, What is the smell of this image? What
reveals the hierarchy of associations and scent or perfume does it have?
attractions to the consumer in terms of What sound does it emit? What music
consequential benefits and ultimately would go with it? What musical
their intangible life values. To be effective instrument does the image evoke?
(while not becoming intrusive, tedious or What bird or animal sound does this
boring) requires good rapport with the image emit?
respondent, where the interviewer What is the texture that fits the image.
becomes a collaborator or accomplice to Find something in this room that has the
investigate the significance of the same feel?
elements in a spontaneous and What feelings on your skin or inside your
uncensored way. This probing reveals the body do you get when seeing this image?
linkages between the advertising imagery, Make a gesture, with your hands, face or
the ideas and feelings conveyed, body, to fit with the advertisement (this is
perceived product benefits and sometimes known as ‘‘Sculpture’’ in
consumers’ motives and values. counselling work).
169
Investigating the power of imagery in marketing communication Qualitative Market Research: An International Journal
Alan Branthwaite Volume 5 . Number 3 . 2002 . 164±171
Jung, C.G. (1977), The Symbolic Life, Routledge & Kegan Przybyla, D.P.J., Byrne, D. and Kelley K. (1983), ``The role
Paul, London. of imagery in sexual behaviour’’, in Sheikh, A.A.
Lannon, J. (1991), ``Developing brand strategies across (Ed), Imagery: Current Theory, Research and
borders’’, Marketing and Research Today, pp. 160-7. Applications, Wiley, New York, NY.
LeDoux, J.E. (1996), The Emotional Brain, Simon & Richardson, J.T.E. (1999), Imagery, Psychology Press,
Schuster, New York, NY. Hove.
McKellar, P. (1957), Imagination and Thinking, Cohen & Segar, A. and Brehm, H. (2000), ``One global Mercedes-
West, London. Benz language’’, Esomar Automotive Conference,
Mckellar, P. (1997), ``Synaesthesi a and imagery: Fantasia Lausanne, pp. 135-49.
rivisited’’, Journal of Mental Imagery, Vol. 21 No. 3/4, Shankar, A. and Goulding G. (2001), ``Interpretiv e
pp. 41-54. consumer research: two more contributions to
Moran, A. (2000), ``Improving sporting abilities’’, in theory and practice’’, Qualitative Market Research:
Hartley, J. and Branthwaite, A. (Eds), The Applied An International Journal, Vol. 4, pp. 7-16.
Psychologist, Open University Press, Buckingham, Shepard, R.N. (1978), ``The mental image’’, American
pp. 92-110. Psychologist, Vol. 33, pp. 125-37.
Oakley, D., Alden, P. and Mather, M.D. (1996), ``The use Toiati, L. (2001), ``Semiotics and new age: old roots, new
of hypnosis in therapy with adults’’, The shoots’’, Esomar Worldwide Qualitative Conference,
Psychologist, Vol. 9, pp 502-5. Budapest, pp. 49-62.
Pelletier, K.R. and Herzing, D.L. (1989), ``Psycho- Walker, L. (1997), ``Relaxing imagery in women receiving
neuroimmunology : towards a mind-body model’’, in treatment for locally advanced breast cancer’’,
Sheikh, A.A. and Sheik, K.S. (Eds), Eastern and European Journal of Social Oncology, Vol. 23,
Western Approaches in Healing, Wiley, Chichester. pp. 93-5.
171