Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Pasko 2002 Naked Power The Practice of Stripping As A Confidence Game
Pasko 2002 Naked Power The Practice of Stripping As A Confidence Game
Article
Lisa Pasko
University of Hawaii at Manoa
Sexualities 5(1)
50
03 Pasko (MJ/d) 14/1/02 1:33 pm Page 51
Methodology
Because the stripper–customer interaction is an intricate exchange of sex,
power and inequality that influences experiences both inside and outside
the club, I employed several techniques in order to collect data. I gathered
the information for this study through three main methods: (1) the six-
month participant observation of one of Hawaii’s strip clubs; (2)
unstructured interviews of exotic dancers; and (3) observation of dancers’
behaviour and interactions outside the strip club setting. I attended the
club varying nights of the week and recorded my observations
qualitatively. Because the club is a public bar occasionally attended by
women, my presence as a customer was inconspicuous. As with much field
research, information was collected through informal conversations with
customers and other employees of the club.
Altogether, 13 interviews were completed with three respondents; each
informant varied in age, race and marital status. Two of the dancers were
white, single and in their late 20s and one was a Japanese-Hawaiian
divorced mother of two in her early 30s. Each of the informants in the
study reported that a desperate financial situation preceded their first
exotic dance experience; they needed to earn a lot of money quickly.
Afterwards, they could not find other opportunities that pay as well as
exotic dance or that allow them as much freedom with their time. The
informants reported that they could not afford to quit.
To acquire different levels of reflection and retrospection of their
stripping experiences, I interviewed each informant in three different
settings: immediately following their dancing experiences, before they
were about to dance and during their days off. I also accompanied each
informant on at least two separate social occasions in order to examine
interaction and understand identity outside of the exotic dance environ-
ment. My primary informant assisted in the development of relationships
with other staff and customers. In addition to accompanying her on social
excursions, I interviewed this informant in the form of weekly casual con-
versations for two months, where exhaustive notes were taken. Her
insights provided a rich understanding of the social experiences, roles and
problems that occur both inside and outside the strip club. In addition to
51
03 Pasko (MJ/d) 14/1/02 1:33 pm Page 52
Sexualities 5(1)
52
03 Pasko (MJ/d) 14/1/02 1:33 pm Page 53
lying. The cooler provides status for the mark – a redefinition of the self
along defensible lines that allow the mark to feel s/he is still a smart person
(Goffman, 1952). Once the con is over (and especially if it is realized), the
mark employs several techniques to deal with the exit from the false
relationship. The mark may joke or maintain an unserious nature to the
involvement. They may use the process of ‘hedging’, an assertion that s/he
was not completely taken by the con. Victims may also choose to keep the
involvement secret (Goffman, 1952: 460).
Goffman maintains that the risk-taking nature, structure and facades
performed by players in a confidence game also characterize ordinary
relations in everyday social life. In situations like courting, working and
dining out, social life becomes a series of manipulations, disguises and
interchangeable masks. In his look at detective work, Leo (1996) found
that the act of police interrogation closely resembles the sequence and
structure of a confidence game. Like swindlers, investigators are self-
confident, have predatory instincts, and can easily understand the infor-
mal social underpinnings of a given situation (Leo, 1996: 265). They are
able to appeal to the marks’s desires and to use their psychological and
interpersonal skills in order to obtain a confession. In the interrogation
‘con’ game, Leo witnessed the several stages that detectives use in order
to obtain a confession from a suspect. First, they ‘qualify’ the suspect by
sizing up both the facts known about the case and the suspect’s personal
qualities. They then ‘cultivate’ suspects by manipulating and persuading
them to go along with the interrogation. Investigators then ‘con’ the
suspects into a confession and ‘cool’ them out by getting them to believe
that confessing and taking responsibility for the crime was the best course
of action (Leo, 1996: 283).
As I will demonstrate, strippers also use this series of carefully
constructed interactions and manipulations. Strippers use different masks
and guises, falsify social relationships and vary social roles for monetary
gain. They are experienced emotional managers and excellent scholars of
human nature. It is through the strippers’ ability to qualify, cultivate, con
and cool out their marks that they are able to emulate many customers’
desires and keep them tipping.
53
03 Pasko (MJ/d) 14/1/02 1:33 pm Page 54
Sexualities 5(1)
54
03 Pasko (MJ/d) 14/1/02 1:33 pm Page 55
55
03 Pasko (MJ/d) 14/1/02 1:33 pm Page 56
Sexualities 5(1)
56
03 Pasko (MJ/d) 14/1/02 1:33 pm Page 57
monetary reward. The dancer, having a sixth sense or ‘grift sense’ about
men’s sex fantasies, tries different sexual poses, pulling the garter as she
finishes each movement. She analyzes the customer’s movements,
responses and demeanor in order to detect his preferences and weaknesses.
Finding a position and type of dance the customer likes, the stripper will
disguise fatigue and/or irritation and repeat those movements which
reaped her the biggest tip. Likewise, if the customer discontinues tipping,
the stripper will discontinue her act.
For the stripper and the customer, the principal significant symbol which
aids in this social interaction is the garter. When a stripper pulls her garter,
the customer must be trained that this is a signal that he is to tip her. For
the dance to continue, the customer must understand the significance of
the gesture. If the customer ignores the garter pull, the stripper may offer
an affectionate touch and pull her garter again. Or, she may stand up, put
her clothes back on, and lure another customer. One informant illustrates
the importance of the garter pull:
Knowing when to pull the garter is truly a talent. If you pull it too much or too
soon, you could turn a customer off. If you don’t pull it enough, you look easy,
and then you have to work that much harder to get your money. The key is to
show a little, you know, entice, and then pull it every time you touch yourself,
or push something in their face, or reveal something. The best customers are
those who have the stack of bills ready to go. You know they are ready and eager
to tip. Those are the good ones.
The garter also represents the symbol of success for the stripper. A
garter full of money is a symbol to other customers that the stripper per-
forms a good act and is worth watching. Having the most tip money in a
garter is the gesture strippers use to show they are the ‘best’ ones in the
club. In addition, the money-packed garter also serves as a source of
tension between strippers. One dancer explains:
We all know that showing off your tip money is the way to get customers to
think you’re good. But if you never have an off night and are always showing
off your garter of money, the girls [other strippers] will start watching, and if
you’re doing sex acts – you know, penetrating yourself or something that most
of us won’t do cause it’s gross – well, forget getting a friend in here.
57
03 Pasko (MJ/d) 14/1/02 1:33 pm Page 58
Sexualities 5(1)
importance at this stage of the strip act. The stripper will flirt, tease and
joke with the customer to see what level of emotional intimacy is required
to con this particular customer: does she merely need to display her nude
body or does this customer want a more intimate and personal experience,
one that includes emotion and conversation?
Strippers quickly decide which role will furnish them the greatest tips –
to be a sex object, devoid of facial expression or emotion, or to be the
intimate partner. The stripper reads the behaviour of the customer and acts
accordingly. Because of past emotion memories (memories that recall
feelings), strippers are able to respond appropriately to customers’ stimuli
and are able to understand a customer’s desires. Knowing when to act
seductive, when to remain still and simply be nude, when to shock a shy
customer with a sudden revelation of nudity and when to be talkative,
come from a dancer’s ability to decode men’s sexual wishes. If a customer
presents a stack of dollar bills, sits back in his seat and gives no verbal
response to the stripper’s flirtations, the stripper knows this attitude and
decides he would like a less intimate strip act to begin. In this situation,
the stripper would react to the customer’s response by performing the act
with less conversation and more concentration on the provocative removal
of her clothes. One informant illustrates:
Men come here for many reasons – some want a sexy girlfriend for the night;
some want to see a fantasy, a sex object; some want a therapist; and others just
want to stare [at your body] – they couldn’t care less what my face or anything
else looks like. They couldn’t care less if you dance . . . nothing exotic about it.
They just want to see my [nudity]. So . . . I’ll be the girlfriend, the counselor,
the playmate, the object – whatever. I don’t care. Just keep it [the money]
coming.
Although strippers are supposed to remain behind the stage’s black line
that separates the seated customer from the stripper, strippers frequently
ignore the law and increase their proximity to the customer. Illegal physical
touching is acceptable in the club as long as the strippers employ it (i.e.
are being tipped) and as long as the liquor commission is absent. The main
source of social control within the club lies with the liquor commission.
The commission, which has the power to investigate clubs and shut them
down if the club operates illegally, often sends agents to the club to investi-
gate illegal activity. If an agent is identified as he walks through the door,
the bartender sounds a bell and all strippers stop their acts and stand in
the middle of the stage behind the black line. Because of the fear that a
customer may touch them and that the agent will see it and fine the club
and the stripper, all strip dancers remain behind the black line until another
bell is sounded, so as to signal that it is acceptable for them to continue
their acts. One dancer explains:
58
03 Pasko (MJ/d) 14/1/02 1:33 pm Page 59
It is such a joke. Guys touch us all the time. That’s how we get the tips. A little
touch here. A shove in your face there. But when the liquor commission comes
in everything stops and we have to stand in the middle of the stage just so there
is no . . . chance any guy will touch us. One night I was in the middle of the
stage for two . . . hours.
In the absence of the liquor commission, strippers may touch the
customer, press their breasts or other body parts against his face, or place
their feet on his shoulders, as they lie on the stage and simulate sexual
intercourse. They may allow the customer to touch them or kiss their
personal body parts. They may perform pelvic thrusts within inches of the
customer’s face and touch themselves while doing so. Strippers carefully
use physical space, their appearance, cigarettes and sex acts – sexual
touching and masturbation – to deceive the customer into accepting the
pseudo closeness and staged attention of the strip act.
The confidence game varies, according to customer’s preferences and
vulnerabilities. Unsure of the cost, some come to see the nude bodies of
women and to be sexually aroused by the dancers’ performance of the strip
act. Some men come to acquire the attention of a beautiful woman and
to have that woman listen to his problems and his life stories. For those
customers who desire a more intimate interaction with the stripper, the
stripper creates an atmosphere of physical as well as emotional connect-
edness to the customer. The increased amount of interaction, the range of
interaction and the intensity of emotion ensure that the interaction reflects
counterfeit intimacy, an inauthentic relation (see Foote, 1954). In order
to create this environment, the stripper compliments the customer and
whispers comments in his ear which make the customer feel special and
important. All the while she physically touches the customer and main-
tains close proximity. The stripper will perform sexual poses as she com-
plements her sexual movements with hugs and light kisses. Once again,
for the act to continue, the customer has to tip.
For men who are looking for conversation, the stripper creates intimacy
in a different way. Instead of a strip act, the stripper will sit with the
customer and have a drink with him. Often the customer will furnish the
stripper with free cigarettes or an occasional token of affection, such as a
cheap bracelet. The stripper will listen to his stories and become his com-
panion and sometimes his confessor for the night. She will often create a
fictitious background for herself, which she tells all the customers. One
respondent demonstrates:
I often tell people I am a student, which I am. I will tell them I am a med student
or a law student, though. The guys who want a ‘girlfriend’ – they want you to
be more than just a stripper. They want you to be a sex object but to have an
interesting personal life, too. So I tell them something and this makes them feel
special and they keep buying me drinks.
59
03 Pasko (MJ/d) 14/1/02 1:33 pm Page 60
Sexualities 5(1)
Cooling out
Cooling out the mark becomes necessary when tipping becomes less
frequent. Strippers want the customer to believe she had genuine interest
in him, that he is worthy of her sexual display and advances. Strippers must
shy away from their dance and yet make the mark unmindful of the con:
he must stay to buy alcohol and other dances. Positive reinforcement is
often used by strippers in their exit from the con. The dancer may take a
well-paying mark to a booth for a drink and require the waiter to collect
the fee. She may also end her performance by replacing her clothing while
offering a hug and smile. She may also cool the mark out by referring him
to another dancer who will then begin attracting him to her sexual mys-
tique. Occasionally, well-paying customers are offered a back-room table
dance for an established fee. Some dancers are reluctant to exit the con
this way. The back-room is a private place and a source of vulnerability for
the dancer. She could lose the power negotiation and be victimized.
If a customer wishes to see the dancer socially outside the club, the
dancer most often refuses and the trust is violated. The confidence game
becomes obvious to the customer: the dancer is not sexually or socially
interested in him, despite the high cost paid. To cool these customers out,
the stripper pacifies the mark by stating that she does not date customers
or that it is against the law for her to go home with him. Appealing to a
legal authority or universal rule keeps the customers from feeling abused.
Other exits from the dance require a quick ending. Strippers have
freedom to cool out their marks with force. The primary ‘feeling’ offense
to a dancer is a customer’s initiation of hostility. If customers who violate
the emotional rules through a display of unfriendliness towards the
stripper, the dancer has the latitude to respond to the customer; she may
respond with anger and aggressive actions. Any indication of hostility or
rejection by the customer, either through degrading language or through
inappropriate touching (such as repeated touches which the dancer has
60
03 Pasko (MJ/d) 14/1/02 1:33 pm Page 61
warned the customer to stop), will result in the stripper terminating her
act. In some cases, the stripper may react violently or ask security to
remove the patron. Because the club is continuously busy, these actions
are performed without consequence for the stripper. Some customers may
actually be enticed by a display of ‘toughness’.
61
03 Pasko (MJ/d) 14/1/02 1:33 pm Page 62
Sexualities 5(1)
hate it and whine about why ‘you can’t give them a show’. Dancing naked is
hard work. It makes your body sore, tired and you just get burned out. . . .
62
03 Pasko (MJ/d) 14/1/02 1:33 pm Page 63
Conclusion
The stripper–customer interaction is a complicated mixture of manip-
ulation and control of emotions and communication. Strippers must ‘con
and cool out’ their customers in order to keep both pleasure and tips high.
They must realize their customers’ needs and imagine how the customer
will react to their movements. It is through the stripper’s ability to be both
subject and object that she is able to counterfeit intimacy and create herself
as a sex object. Crucial to the success of the stripper is her ability to
understand male sexual desires and to anticipate male behaviour. In order
for her to respond in numerous ways to a customer’s varying sexual
63
03 Pasko (MJ/d) 14/1/02 1:33 pm Page 64
Sexualities 5(1)
64
03 Pasko (MJ/d) 14/1/02 1:33 pm Page 65
Notes
1. See Hochschild (1983) for original discussion of ‘deep acting’ in the
emotional labour performed by flight attendants.
2. These are similar findings to Ronai and Ellis (1989) and Boles and Garbin
(1974). See these works for further explanation of counterfeit intimacy in the
strip act.
References
Boles, J. and Garbin, A. (1972) ‘Strippers and Their Customers’, paper presen-
tation at the American Sociological Association Annual Meeting, August.
Boles, J. and Garbin, A. (1974) ‘Strip Club and Stripper–Customer Patterns of
Interaction’, Sociology and Social Research 58: 136–44.
Blum, R. (1972) Deceivers and Deceived: Observations on Confidence Men and
Their Victims, Informants and Their Quarry, Political and Industrial Spies and
Ordinary Citizens. Springfield, IL: Charles Thomas.
D’Andre, A. T. (1965) ‘An Occupational Study of Stripper–Dancer Career’, paper
presentation at the Pacific Sociological Association Annual Meeting, March.
Delacoste, F. and Alexander, P. (1987) Sex Work: Writings by Women in the Sex
Industry. Pittsburgh, PA: Cleis Press.
Foote, N. (1954) ‘Sex as Play’, Social Problems 1: 159–63.
Gecas, V. and Libby, R. (1976) ‘Sexual Behavior as Symbolic Interaction’, The
Journal of Sex Research 12: 33–49.
Goffman, E. (1952) ‘On Cooling the Mark Out: Some Aspects of Adaptation to
Failure’, Psychiatry 15: 451–63.
Hochschild, A. (1983) The Managed Heart: Commercialization of Human
Feeling. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
Jones, L. (1967) Striptease. New York: Simon and Schuster.
Leff, A. (1976) Swindling and Selling. New York: Free Press.
Leo, R. (1996) ‘Miranda’s Revenge: Police Interrogation as a Confidence
Game’, Law and Society Review 30: 259–88.
Liepe-Levinson, K. (1998) ‘Striptease: Desire, Mimetic Jeopardy, and
Performing Spectators’, TDR 42: 9–38.
Mead, G. (1934[1962]) Mind, Self, and Society: From the Standpoint of a Social
Behaviorist. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
65
03 Pasko (MJ/d) 14/1/02 1:33 pm Page 66
Sexualities 5(1)
Nead, L. (1997) ‘The Female Nude: Pornography, Art, and Sexuality’, in Laura
O’Toole and Jessica Schiffman (eds) Gender Violence, pp. 374–82. New York:
New York University Press.
Prus, R. and Irini, S. (1980) Hookers, Rounders, and Desk Clerks: The Social
Organization of the Hotel Community. Salem, WI: Sheffield.
Prus, R. and Sharper, C. R. D. (1977) Road Hustler: The Career Contingencies of
Professional Card and Dice Hustlers. Lexington, MA: Lexington Books.
Ronai, C. and Ellis, C. (1989) ‘Turn-Ons for Money’, Journal of Contemporary
Ethnography 18: 271–98.
Salutin, M. (1971) ‘Stripper Morality’, Transaction 8: 12–22.
Schur, E. (1958) ‘Sociological Analysis of Swindling’, Journal of Criminal Law,
Criminology and Political Science 48: 296–304.
Segal, L. (1997) ‘Pornography and Violence: What Experts Really Say’, in Laura
O’Toole and Jessica Schiffman (eds) Gender Violence, pp. 400–13. New York:
New York University Press.
Sijuwade, P. (1995) ‘Counterfeit Intimacy: A Dramaturgical Analysis of an Erotic
Performance’, Social Behavior and Personality 23: 369–76.
Skipper, J. and McCaghy, C. (1970) ‘Stripteasers: The Anatomy and Career
Contingencies of a Deviant Occupation’, Social Problems 17: 391–405.
Skipper, J. and McCaghy, C. (1976) ‘Teasing, Flashing, and Visual Sex: Stripping
for a Living’, in James Henslin (ed.) Sociology of Sex, pp. 171–93. New York:
Appleton-Century.
Spivey, S. (2000) ‘Victimization and Agency in the Workplace: A Nude Dancing
Bar as a Site of Contestation’, paper presentation at the American Sociological
Association’s Annual Meeting, August.
Biographical Note
Lisa Pasko received her MA in sociology from the University of Nevada, Reno,
and is currently a sociology PhD candidate at the University of Hawaii at
Manoa. In addition to studies on gender and sex work, her research interests
include understanding the role of masculinities and honour in gang membership
and consequent violent activity, particularly among male youth. Address:
University of Hawaii at Manoa, Sociology Department, 2424 Maile Way #247,
Honolulu HI 96822. [email: pasko@hawaii.edu]
66