Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Steele, David Ramsay - The Mystery of Fascism
Steele, David Ramsay - The Mystery of Fascism
uk
The First World War began in The Fascists adopted the black shirtsviii of
August 1914 without Italian the anarchists and Giovinezza (Youth),
involvement. Should Italy join Britain the song of the front-line soldiers.
and France against Germany and Austria, Apart from its ardent nationalism
or stay out of the war?iv All the top and pro-war foreign policy, the Fascist
leaders and intellectuals of the Socialist program was a mixture of radical left,
Party, Mussolini among them, were moderate left, democratic, and liberal
opposed to Italian participation. measures, and for more than a year the
In October and November 1914, new movement was not notably more
Mussolini switched to a pro-war position. violent than other socialist groupings.ix
He resigned as editor of Avanti!, joined However, Fascists came into conflict
with pro-war leftists outside the Socialist with Socialist Party members and in
Party, and launched a new pro-war 1920 formed a militia, the squadre
socialist paper, Il Popolo d’Italia (People (squads). Including many patriotic
of Italy).v To the Socialist Party veterans, the squads were more efficient
leadership, this was a great betrayal, a at arson and terror tactics than the
sell-out to the whoremasters of the violently disposed but bumbling
bourgeoisie, and Mussolini was expelled Marxists, and often had the tacit support
from the Party. It was as scandalous as of the police and army. By 1921 Fascists
though, 50 years later, Guevara had had the upper hand in physical combat
announced that he was off to Vietnam, to with their rivals of the left.
help defend the South against North The democratic and liberal
Vietnamese aggression. elements in Fascist preaching rapidly
Italy entered the war in May diminished and in 1922 Mussolini
1915, and Mussolini enlisted. In 1917 he declared that “The world is turning to the
was seriously wounded and hospitalized, right.” The Socialists, who controlled
emerging from the war the most popular the unions, called a general strike.
of the pro-war socialists, a leader without Marching into some of the major cities,
a movement. Post-war Italy was hag- blackshirt squads quickly and forcibly
ridden by civil strife and political suppressed the strike, and most Italians
violence. Sensing a revolutionary heaved a sigh of relief. This gave the
situation in the wake of Russia’s blackshirts the idea of marching on
Bolshevik coup, the left organized Rome to seize power. As they publicly
strikes, factory occupations, riots, and gathered for the great march, the
political killings. Socialists often beat up government decided to avert possible
and sometimes killed soldiers returning civil war by bringing Mussolini into
home, just because they had fought in the office; the King “begged” Mussolini to
war. Assaulting political opponents and become Prime Minister, with emergency
wrecking their property became an powers. Instead of a desperate uprising,
everyday occurrence. the March on Rome was the triumphant
Mussolini and a group of celebration of a legal transfer of
adherents launched the Fascist authority.
movementvi in 1919. The initiators were The youngest prime minister in
mostly men of the left: revolutionary Italian history, Mussolini was an adroit
syndicalists and former Marxists.vii They and indefatigable fixer, a formidable
took with them some non-socialist wheeler and dealer in a constitutional
nationalists and futurists, and recruited monarchy which did not become an
heavily among soldiers returning from outright and permanent dictatorship until
the war, so that the bulk of rank-and-file December 1925, and even then retained
Fascists had no leftwing background. elements of unstable pluralism requiring
intellectuals.xvi When the Soviet Union In more than a dozen thoughtful books
and People’s China had a falling out in from The Remaking of a Mind (1919),
via The Socialist Idea (1933), to Après
the 1960s, they each promptly discovered Coup (1941) de Man left a detailed
that the other fraternal socialist country account of the theoretical odyssey which
was not merely capitalist but “fascist.” led him, by 1940, to acclaim the Nazi
At the most vulgar level, “fascist” is a subjugation of Europe as “a deliverance.”
handy swear-word for such hated figures His journey began, as such journeys so
as Rush Limbaugh or John Ashcroft often did, with the conviction that
who, whatever their faults, are as remote Marxism needed to be revised along
from historical Fascism as anyone in “idealist” and psychological lines.xix
public life today. Two avant-garde artistic
The consequence of 70 years of movements which contributed to the
indoctrination with a particular leftist Fascist worldview were Futurism and
view of fascism is that Fascism is now a Vorticism. Futurism was the brainchild
puzzle. We know how leftists in the of Filippo Marinetti, who eventually lost
1920s and 1930s thought because we his life in the service of Mussolini’s
knew people in college whose thinking regime. You can get some idea of the
was almost identical, and because we Futurist pictorial style from the credits
have read such writers as Sartre, for the Poirot TV series. Its style of
Hemingway, and Orwell. poetry was a defining influence on
But what were Fascists thinking? Mayakovsky. Futurist arts activities
were permitted for some years in the
Soviet Union. Futurism held that
Some Who Became Fascists modern machines were more beautiful
than classical sculptures. It lauded the
Robert Michels was a German Marxist esthetic value of speed, intensity, modern
disillusioned with the Social Democrats. machinery, and modern war.
He became a revolutionary syndicalist. Vorticism was a somewhat milder
In 1911 he wrote Political Parties, a variant of Futurism, associated with Ezra
brilliant analytic work,xvii demonstrating Pound and the painter and novelist
the impossibility of “participatory Wyndham Lewis, an American and a
democracy”––a phrase that was not to be Canadian who transplanted to London.
coined for half a century, but which Pound became a Fascist, moved to Italy,
accurately captures the early Marxist and was later found mentally ill and
vision of socialist administration.xviii incarcerated by the occupying
Later he became an Italian (changing Americans. The symptoms of his illness
“Robert” to “Roberto”) and one of the were his Fascist beliefs. He was later
leading Fascist theoreticians. released, and chose to move back to Italy
Hendrik de Man was the leading in 1958, an unreprentant Fascist.
Belgian socialist of his day and In 1939 the avowed fascist
recognized as one of the two or three Wyndham Lewis retracted his earlier
most outstanding socialist intellects in praise for Hitler, but never renounced his
Europe––many in the 1930s believed basically fascist political worldview.
him to be the most important socialist Lewis was, like George Bernard Shaw,
theoretician since Marx. He is the most one of those intellectuals of the 1930s
prominent of the numerous Western who admired Fascism and Communism
European Marxists who wrestled their about equally, praising them both while
way from Marxism to Fascism or insisting on their similarity.
National Socialism in the interwar years. Fascism must have been a set of
Fascist intellectuals did not consider him of Volume III of Marx’s Capital in 1894
a major contributor to the body of Fascist revealed that Marx simply had no serious
theory, more a leader of genius who solution to the “great contradiction”
could distil theory into action. between Volumes I–II and the real
Fascists were radical behavior of prices. Böhm-Bawerk’s
modernizers. By temperament they were devastating critiques of Marxian
neither conservative nor reactionary. economics (1884 and 1896) were widely
Fascists despised the status quo and were read and discussed.
not attracted by a return to bygone The Crisis of Marxism gave birth
conditions. Even in power, despite all its to the Revisionism of Eduard Bernstein,
adaptations to the requirements of the which concluded, in effect, that the goal
immediate situation, and despite its of revolution should be given up, in favor
incorporation of more conservative social of piecemeal reforms within
elements, Fascism remained a conscious capitalism.xxiii This held no allure for
force for modernization.xxi men of the hard left who rejected
existing society, deeming it too
loathsome to be reformed. Revisionists
Two Revisions of Marxism also began to attack the fundamental
Marxist doctrine of historical
Fascism began as a revision of Marxism materialism––the theory that a society’s
by Marxists, a revision which developed organization of production decides the
in successive stages, so that these character of all other social phenomena,
Marxists gradually stopped thinking of including ideas.
themselves as Marxists, and eventually At the beginning of the twentieth
stopped thinking of themselves as century, leftists who wanted to be as far
socialists. They never stopped thinking left as they could possibly be became
of themselves as anti-liberal syndicalists, preaching the general strike
revolutionaries. as the way to demonstrate the workers’
The Crisis of Marxism occurred power and overthrow the bourgeois
in the 1890s. Marxist intellectuals could order. Syndicalist activity erupted across
claim to speak for mass socialist the world, even in Britain and the United
movements across continental Europe, States. Promotion of the general strike
yet it became clear in those years that was a way of defying capitalism and at
Marxism had survived into a world the same time defying those socialists
which Marx had believed could not who wanted to use electoral methods to
possibly exist. The workers were negotiate reforms of the system.
becoming richer, the working class was Syndicalists began as
fragmented into sections with different uncompromising Marxists, but like
interests, technological advance was Revisionists, they acknowledged that key
accelerating rather than meeting a tenets of Marxism had been refuted by
roadblock, the “rate of profit” was not the development of modern society.
falling, the number of wealthy investors Most syndicalists came to accept much
(“magnates of capital”) was not falling of Bernstein’s argument against
but increasing, industrial concentration traditional Marxism, but remained
was not increasing,xxii and in all countries committed to the total rejection, rather
the workers were putting their country than democratic reform, of existing
above their class. society. They therefore called
In high theory, too, the themselves “revolutionary revisionists.”
hollowness of Marxism was being They favored the “idealist revision of
exposed. The long-awaited publication Marx,” meaning that they believed in a
more independent role for ideas in social movement) was too rationalistic and too
evolution that that allowed by Marxist materialistic. Bergson and James were
theory. also read, however, as contending that
humans did not work with an objectively
existing reality, but created reality by
Practical Anti-Rationalism imposing their own will upon the world,
a claim that was also gleaned (rightly or
In setting out to revise Marxism, wrongly) from Hegel, Schopenhauer, and
syndicalists were most strongly Nietzsche. French intellectuals turned
motivated by the desire to be effective against Descartes, the rationalist, and
revolutionaries, not to tilt at windmills rehabilitated Pascal, the defender of faith.
but to achieve a realistic understanding In the same spirit, Italian intellectuals
of the way the world works. In rediscovered Vico.
criticizing and re-evaluating their own Practical anti-rationalism entered
Marxist beliefs, however, they naturally pre-Fascism through Georges Sorelxxv
drew upon the intellectual fashions of the and his theory of the “myth.” This
day, upon ideas that were in the air influential socialist writer began as an
during this period known as the fin de orthodox Marxist. An extreme leftist, he
siècle. The most important cluster of naturally became a syndicalist, and soon
such ideas is “anti-rationalism.” the best-known syndicalist theoretician.
Many forms of anti-rationalism Sorel then moved to defending Marx’s
proliferated throughout the nineteenth theory of the class struggle in a new
century. The kind of anti-rationalism way––no longer as a scientific theory,
which most influenced pre-fascists was but instead as a “myth”, an
not primarily the view that something understanding of the world and the future
other than reason should be employed to which moves men to action. When he
decide factual questions (epistemological began to abandon Marxism, both because
anti-rationalism). It was rather the view of its theoretical failures and because of
that, as a matter of sober recognition of its excessive “materialism,” he looked
reality, humans are not solely or even for an alternative myth. Experience of
chiefly motivated by rational calculation current and recent events showed that
but more by intuitive “myths” (practical workers had little interest in the class
anti-rationalism). Therefore, if you want struggle but were prone to patriotic
to understand and influence people’s sentiment. By degrees, Sorel shifted his
behavior, you had better acknowledge position, until at the end of his life he
that they are not primarily self-interested, became nationalistic and anti-semitic.xxvi
rational calculators; they are gripped and He died in 1922, hopeful about Lenin
moved by myths.xxiv and more cautiously hopeful about
Paris was the fashion center of Mussolini.
the intellectual world, dictating the rise A general trend throughout
and fall of ideological hemlines. Here, revolutionary socialism from 1890 to
anti-rationalism was associated with the 1914 was that the most revolutionary
philosophy of Henri Bergson, William elements laid an increasing stress upon
James’s Pragmatism from across the leadership, and downplayed the
Atlantic, and the social-psychological autonomous role of the toiling masses.
arguments of Gustave Le Bon. Such This elitism was a natural outcome of the
ideas were seen as valuing action more revolutionaries’ ardent wish to have
highly than cogitation and as revolution and the stubborn
demonstrating that modern society disinclination of the working class to
(including the established socialist become revolutionary.xxvii Workers were
Communists continued to employ the Fascist leaders had spent years trying to
Marxist rhetoric of world socialist get the workers to become revolutionary.
revolution in the most advanced As late as June 1914, Mussolini took part
countries, but this was all a ritual enthusiastically, at risk of his own life
incantation to consecrate their attempt to and limb, in the violent and
accelerate the development of a confrontational “red week.” The
initiators of Fascism were mostly
backward country. Fascists deliberately seasoned anti-capitalist militants who
turned to nationalism as a potent myth. had time and again given the working
Communists defended Russian class the benefit of the doubt. The
nationalism and imperialism while working class, by not becoming
protesting that their sacred motherland revolutionary, had let these
was an internationalist workers’ state. revolutionaries down.
Fascists proclaimed the end of In the late 1920s, people like
democracy. Communists abolished Winston Churchill and Ludwig von
democracy and called their dictatorship Mises saw Fascism as a natural and
democracy. Fascists argued that equality salutory response to Communist
was impossible and hierarchy violence.xxxv They already overlooked
ineluctable. Communists imposed a new the fact that Fascism represented an
hierarchy, shot anyone who advocated independent cultural phenomenon which
actual equality, but never ceased to predated the Bolshevik coup. It became
babble on about the equalitarian future widely accepted that the future lay with
they were “building”. Fascists did with either Communism or Fascism, and
their eyes open what Communists did many people chose what they considered
with their eyes shut. This is the truth the lesser evil. Evelyn Waugh remarked
concealed in the conventional formula that he would choose Fascism over
that Communists were well-intentioned Marxism if he had to, but he did not
and Fascists evil-intentioned. think he had to.
It’s easy to see that the rise of
Communism stimulated the rise of
Disappointed Revolutionaries Fascism. But since the existence of the
Soviet regime was what chiefly made
Though they respected “the irrational” as Communism attractive, and since
a reality, the initiators of Fascism were Fascism was an independent tradition of
not themselves swayed by wilfully revolutionary thinking, there would
irrational considerations.xxxiii They were doubtless have been a powerful Fascist
not superstitious. Mussolini in 1929, movement even in the absence of a
when he met with Cardinal Gasparri at Bolshevik regime. At any rate, after
the Lateran Palace, was no more a 1922, the same kind of influence worked
believing Catholic than Mussolini the both ways: many people became
violently anti-Catholic polemicist of the Communists because they considered
pre-war years,xxxiv but he had learned that that the most effective way to combat the
in his chosen career as a radical dreaded Fascism. Two rival gangs of
modernizing politician, it was a waste of murderous politicos, bent on establishing
time to bang his head against the brick their own unchecked power, each
wall of institutionalized faith. drummed up support by pointing to the
Leftists often imagine that horrors that the other gang would
Fascists were afraid of a revolutionary unleash. Whatever the shortcomings of
working-class. Nothing could be more any such appeal, the horrors themselves
comically mistaken. Most of the early were all too real.xxxvi
Fascist rhetoric increasingly voiced bourgeois liberal order which had created
explicit hostility to the individual ego. his opposite.
Fascism had always been strongly Even as late as 1922 it was not
communitarian but now this aspect clear to Fascists that Fascism, the “third
became more conspicuous. Fascist anti- way” between liberalism and socialism,
individualism is summed up in the would set up a bureaucratic police state,
assertion that the death of a human being but given the circumstances and
is like the body’s loss of a cell. Among fundamental Fascist ideas, nothing else
the increasingly histrionic blackshirt was feasible. Fascism introduced a form
meetings from 1920 to 1922 were the of state which was claustrophobic in its
funeral services. When the name of a oppressiveness. The result was a
comrade recently killed by the Socialists population of decidedly unheroic
was called out, the whole crowd would mediocrities, sly conformists scared of
roar: “Presente!” their own shadows, worlds removed from
Man is not an atom, man is the kind of dynamic human character the
essentially social––these woolly clichés Fascists had hoped would inherit the
were as much Fascist as they were Earth.
socialist. Anti-individualism was As for Fascism’s economic
especially prominent in the writings of performance, a purely empirical test of
official philosopher Giovanni Gentile, results is inconclusive. In its first few
who gave Fascist social theory its years, the Mussolini government’s
finished form in the final years of the economic measures were probably more
regime.xxxix liberalizing than restrictive. The
subsequent turn to intrusive corporatism
was swiftly followed by the world slump
and then the war. But we do know from
The Failure of Fascism numerous other examples that if it is left
to run its course, corporatist
Fascist ideology had two goals by which interventionism will cripple any
Fascism’s performance may reasonably economy.xl Furthermore, economic
be judged: the creation of a heroically losses inflicted by the war can be laid at
moral human being, in a heroically moral Fascism’s door, as Mussolini could
social order, and the accelerated easily have kept Italy neutral. Fascism
development of industry, especially in both gave unchecked power to a single
backward economies like Italy. individual to commit such a blunder as to
The fascist moral ideal, upheld by take Italy to war in 1940 and made this
writers from Sorel to Gentile, is more likely by extolling the benefits of
something like an inversion of the war.
caricature of a Benthamite liberal. The In the panoramic sweep of
fascist ideal man is not cautious but history, Fascism, like Communism, like
brave, not calculating but resolute, not all forms of socialism, and like today’s
sentimental but ruthless, not preoccupied greenism and anti-globalism, is the
with personal advantage but fighting for logical result of specific intellectual
ideals, not seeking comfort but errors about human progress. Fascism
experiencing life intensely. The early was an attempt to pluck the material
Fascists did not know how they would fruits of liberal economics while
install the social order which would abolishing liberal culture.xli The attempt
create this “new man,” but they were was entirely quixotic: there is no such
convinced that they had to destroy the thing as economic development without
free-market capitalism and there is no
xxi
The Fascist government imposed measures tremendous. Freud was steeped in Le Bon. The
which were intended to promote modernization. discussion of propaganda in Hitler’s Mein Kampf,
They were not necessary and their effectiveness which strikes most readers as more entertaining
was mixed. Italian output grew rapidly, but so it than the rest of the book, echoes Le Bon.
xxxi
had in earlier years. Gregor, Young Mussolini. This was precisely
xxii
Many would not yet have acknowledged that the view of many Communists in the early years
there was no falling rate of profit and no of the Comintern. Payne, History, p. 126.
xxxii
concentrating trend in industry, but all had to Ludwig von Mises, Omnipotent Government:
agree that these were proceeding far more slowly The Rise of the Total State and Total War (New
than earlier Marxists had expected. Rochelle: Arlington House, 1969 [1944]), pp. 55–
xxiii
Before the 1890s, there was no more 58.
xxxiii
impeccable a Marxist than Bernstein. He had “If by mysticism one intends the recognition
been a friend of Marx and Engels, who of truth without the employment of reason, I
maintained a confidence in his ideological would be the first to declare myself opposed to
soundness that they placed in very few every mysticism.” Mussolini, quoted in Gregor,
individuals. His 1899 book, known in English as Contemporary Radical Ideologies, p. 331.
xxxiv
Evolutionary Socialism (New York: Schocken, Mussolini was openly an atheist prior to
1961), is put together from controversial articles 1922, when his conversion was staged for
he began publishing in 1896. transparently political reasons. In addition to his
xxiv
The impact of anti-rationalism on socialism many articles and speeches criticizing religion,
not only helped to form Fascism, but also had a Mussolini wrote a pamphlet, Man and Divinity,
broad influence on the left. Like Fascism, the attacking the Church from a materialist
thinking of leftist writers such as Aldous Huxley standpoint and also wrote a strongly anti-Catholic
and George Orwell arises from the impact on book on Jan Hus, the fifteenth-century Czech
nineteenth-century socialism of the fin de siècle victim of Catholic persecution. Until it became
offensive against rationalism, materialism, politically inexpedient, Mussolini gave a speech
individualism, and romanticism. every year on the anniversary of the murder by
xxv
The strong influence of Sorel on the formation the Church of the freethinker Giordano Bruno in
of Fascism has now been heavily documented. 1600. In office, Mussolini worked with the
See, for example, Sternhell, Birth. In earlier Church, generally gave it what it wanted, and was
years, some writers used to minimize this rewarded with its enthusiastic endorsement.
xxxv
influence or deny Sorel’s close affinity with On Churchill’s fulsome praise of Fascism
Fascism. throughout the late 1920s and early 1930s, see
xxvi
Sorel’s was the old-fashioned kind of Ridley, Mussolini, pp. 187–88, 230, 281. For
antisemitism, which always made room for some Mises’s more guarded praise in 1927, see Mises,
good Jews. Among these Sorel counted Henri The Free and Prosperous Commonwealth
Bergson. Sternhell, Birth, p. 86. (Irvington-on-Hudson: Foundation for Economic
xxvii
It was also inferred from experience. It could Education, 1962), pp. 47–51.
xxxvi
be observed that if the one or two strongest The Fascist government was appallingly
personalities behind a strike were somehow oppressive compared with the democratic regime
neutralized, the strike would collapse. which preceded it, but distinctly less oppressive
xxviii
In What Is to Be Done?, Lenin maintained than Communism or National Socialism. Payne,
that the working class, left to itself, could develop History, pp. 121–23.
only “trade union consciousness.” To make the xxxvii
Karl Marx, Speech on the Question of Free
working class revolutionary required the Trade. Karl Marx, Frederick Engels, Collected
intervention of “professional revolutionaries.” Works (New York: International, 1976), vol. 6,
xxix
See Gregor, Young Mussolini, ch. 4. pp. 450-465.
xxx
The Crowd (New Brunswick: Transaction, xxxviii
The word “totalitarian” (totalitario) was
1995). The early nineteenth century had seen a first used against Fascism by a liberal opponent,
fascination with hypnosis (then called Giovanni Amendola. It was then taken up
Mesmerism). The late nineteenth century proudly by Fascists to characterize their own
witnessed an extrapolation of the model of form of state. Later the term was widely
hypnosis onto wider human phenomena. Le Bon employed to refer to the common features of the
argued that, in groups, individuals become Fascist, Soviet, and Nazi dictatorships or to
hypnotized and lose responsibility for their denote an ideal type of unlimited government. In
actions. Scholars, other than French ones, now this sense, the word was in common use among
believe that Le Bon was a dishonest self- Anglophone intellectuals by 1935, and in the
promoter who successfully exaggerated his own popular media by 1941. Ironically, Fascist Italy
originality, and that his claims about crowd was in practice much less “totalitarian” than the
behavior are mostly wrong. His influence was
This article is written by David Ramsay Steele
For further details please visit www.libertarian-alliance.org.uk
fascism.pdf Page 15 of 16
The Libertarian Alliance is an independent, non-party group, with a shared desire to work for a free society.