Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Cooling Towers
Cooling Towers
Training Module
COOLING TOWER
Cooling Tower
INDEX
Page No.
1.0 Introduction 1
1.2 PRINCIPLE
Cooling tower virtually is a heat exchanger that removes a certain amount of heat
from the cooling water. This heat is transmitted to the atmosphere and the water
is returned at a lower temperature that is recycled back for cooling. The air is
used as a cooling medium via the physical phenomenon of evaporation. The
transfer of heat from the water to the air is carried out by convection and
evaporation.
Water cooling consists in placing its surface in contact with air, in order that this
absorbs heat from the water. It is made in part by sensible heat transmission,
because of the temperature difference between air and water, but the amount of
heat transferred in this manner is very small. The main amount of heat transfer is
done by the evaporation of a small quantity of water that takes the necessary heat
to accomplish the change of state (latent heat of vaporisation) from the rest of the
water, cooling it in this manner. The steam formed in this process, is drawn by
the air stream humidifying it. Thus the prime function of cooling towers is to
reduce the temperature of a stream of hot water to as low a value as practicable
by exchanging it with air. The cooling water in the cooling tower can be cooled
down nearest to wet bulb temperature of air entering tower. Thus the cooling
towers have been widely used to dispose the waste heat from industrial process as
it is more convenient to reject heat to atmosphere rather than to water in a nearby
river, lake, or ocean. So large cooling towers were build depending upon the load
and type of process. Cooling towers were developed from spray ponds, in an
effort to obtain a system that takes up less space. Heat dissipation capacity per
unit area of a small pond can be increased about 20 times by installing a simple
spray system and about 1000 times by building a cooling tower. It reduces the
water
COOLING
TOWER PURGE
TO
PROCESS
DRAI
COOLIN
MAKE UP N
WATER
G WATER
COLD SYSTEM
WATER
DRAI
N
REFORMED
COLD GAS QUENCH
COOLERS
WATER
PUMPS
HEAT
EXCHANGERS
COLD WATER
OTHER
EQUIPMENT
M/C to
be
cooled
HE
fresh
air
consumption for given heat load by a factor of about 5 because they can makebe
designed to eliminate the loss of water carried off by the wind in droplet form.
up
water
Figure
1.3 MECHANISM 2: SCHEMATIC PROCESS CONTROL LOOP
OF COOLING
Taking into account the condition of air when it enters the cooling tower, only 10
to 15 % of the heat is generally removed by convection. Evaporation is thus the
pre-dominant phenomenon. Hence the exchange surface consists either of
droplets of water themselves (splashing types) or by films of water trickling over
the surfaces (film type). The enthalpy of moist air is almost solely a function of
the wet bulb temperature. i.e., only Wet Bulb Temperature lines are ordinarily
drawn on psychometric charts. The W.B.T. for the inlet and outlet gives measure
of the enthalpy rise.
The Dry bulb temperatures are mainly significant from the standpoint of water
consumption. Hence cooling tower is considered analogous to a heat transfer
matrix with a water film surface area that depends on the water and air flow rates
and on the characteristics of the packing or fill, heat will be given up the air by
two mechanisms as mentioned earlier Convection heat transfer and vaporisation
of water.
1. Air Flow: It is the total quantity of air including the associate water vapour
flowing through the tower expressed in cub. m. per sec or kg per sec.
3. Drift Loss[W]: Water loss caused by liquid drops carried away by the outlet
air stream. Drift should be minimised because the water carried by it can cause
staining on buildings at some distance from the tower. Drift is about 0.1 to 0.2%
of circulation rate. Evaporation loss[E] accounts to about 1 % of circulation rate
for each 1.00C drop.
4. Inlet Water Flow: The quantity of hot water flow measured in m3 / sec or per
minute, flowing into the water distribution system.
Depending upon the water quality, optimum operating parameters and selected
water treatment procedure, a certain maximum concentration of total dissolved
solids (TDS) of chloride ion (Cl-) or total hardness (TH) in circulation is fixed.
This in turn will determine the desired concentration cycle on which the cooling
tower is to be operated. The quantity of make up water needed for the blow down
and windage loss is then calculated using the following equation:
M = E x CR x 24/(C-1) x 100;
where, CR = Circulating rate, E= Evaporation rate, C = Concentration cycles. M
= Make up water per day for blowdown and windage loss.
7. Concentration: When water evaporates, dissolved solids and other impurities
are left behind leading to an increase in concentration of these impurities in
circulating water.
Some salts have inverse temperature solubility i.e. they are less soluble at higher
temperature and thus tend to form deposits on heat exchanger tubes. Many salts
are less soluble at higher pH. As cooling tower water is concentrated and pH
increases, the tendency to precipitate scale increases. With or without chemical
treatment of cooling water, cycles of concentration are eventually limited by an
inability to prevent scale formation.
9. Water Loading: Flow of water related to the cross sectional area of packing
normally expressed in kg/s or kg/min per m 2 of cross section of packing. It also
relates to amount of water to be handled for cooling per pass. It is also called
circulation rate which relates to amount of water pumped per unit time and an
important parameter for calculation purposes. Usually it is the designed rating of
the circulation pump or pumps in the cooling water system. Expressed in Nm 3/ hr.
10. Wet Bulb Temperature: Cooling towers are designed to cool water to a
certain temperature under a given set of conditions. The wet bulb temperature is
the lowest temperature to which water can be cooled by evaporation. It is not
practical to design a tower to cool to the wet bulb temperature. It is the
temperature as measured by a wet bulb thermometer. In dry air the wet bulb
temperature readings is always lower with the dry bulb reading. Evaporation
causes cooling, cooling tower performance is lowest when wet and dry bulb
temperature are equal. Even when air is saturated in the tower sonic cooling
occurs by convection and conduction.
11. Ambient Air Wet Bulb Temperature: Wet bulb temperature measured on
the windward side of the cooling tower and free from the influence of the tower,
or surrounding air wet bulb temperature.
12. Inlet Air Wet bulb temperature: It is the average wet bulb temperature of
the inlet air including any re circulation effect measured at the entrance of cooling
tower.
13. Nominal Inlet Air Wet Bulb Temperature: An arithmetic average wet bulb
temperature based on measurement taken within 1.5 m of the air inlets and
between 1.5 m and 2.0 m above the basin kerb elevation on the both sides of the
cooling tower.
14. Hot Water temperature: It is referred to as inlet hot water temperature inlet
to cooling tower which is distributed over top of the tower.
16. Approach: The difference between the cold sump temperature i.e. exit water
temperature and the wet bulb temperature of the inlet air to the cooling tower is
called as approach. It is impracticable to cool the water to the inlet air level WBT.
The smaller the approach the more complicated the tower design becomes. The
minimum reasonable approach temperature is 200 0C. However 4 to 6 0C is more
usual.
18. Humidity: The relative amount of heat going into increasing the temperature
of the air and into evaporating the water depends on the humidity of the air
entering the cooling tower. In order to know how much evaporation can takes
place it is necessary to know how much more water the air can absorb.
19. Recirculation: It is that portion of outlet air which re-entry the tower. The
phenomenon of recirculation is almost absent in case of natural draft towers
basically because of a tall stack and the round shape of the tower. Among the
mechanical draft towers, recirculation is more pronounced in case of forced drift
tower.
Recirculation is measured by means of inlet wet bulb temperature. This inlet wet
bulb temperature is higher than the ambient temperature by the amount of
recirculation. The rational value of inlet wet bulb temperature can be arrived at if
we are to determine the rational values of ambient wet bulb temperature and the
recirculation allowance. Usually while designing the cooling tower recirculation
allowance can not be determined so it is practice to give stress on inlet wet bulb
20. Heat Load: Rate of heat removal from the water flowing through the tower
expressed in KW.
Lot of water is used for the cooling purpose in vaious processes. In the cooling
process the water becomes hotter, its effectiveness as a coolant decreases. In order
to provide for further cooling two thingsExchanger
are possible. The hot cooling water can
be discharged and replaced with fresh water or the hot cooling water can be
cooled by some means and reusedHotfor further cooling. A cooling water system
fluid Cold fluid
comprises of heat exchange equipment, cooling tower basin, circulation pumps,
piping, valves and water supply system.
There are two types of cooling systems in use, singly or in combination. Those
are:
1. Once through cooling system.
2. Recirculating cooling system.
A) open recirculating cooling water system.
B) closed recirculating cooling water system.
Figure 3. ONCE-THROUGH SYSTEM
3.1.ONCE THROUGH COOLING SYSTEM
Closed systems meet small volume cooling needs, as diesel engines, chillers,
generators, refrigeration unit etc. These have fewer water treatment problems.
This system also provides a reliable method of industrial process temperature
control. These are totally sealed systems and therefore relatively little water is
needed for make up which is due to leakage. The most serious problem of these
systems is corrosion. In such system the heat is generally dissipated by air
cooling.
The amount of water needed in large process plants for cooling is very large. The
best way to handle hot water is to cool in small cooling towers open to
atmosphere and reuse it again and again. This type of cooling system is called
open recirculating cooling system.Refer figure 5. The basic difference between
closed and open recirculating system is that the later system is open to air in
cooling tower, where air is the heat transferring medium.
3. The longer the retention time and warmer the water in an open recirculating
system the tendency for biological growth is increasing trend.
A = Make up (m3 . h-1) t = Temperature at tower outlet (*C)
4.Airborne gases such as sulphur dioxide ammonia or1 hydrogen sulphide can be
Q = Recirculated flow (m . h )
3 -1
t = Temperature at tower inlet (*C)
absorbed from the air3 causing higher corrosion rates. 2
E = Evaporation (m . h-1) D = Total blowdown (m3 . h-1)
Ev = Drift (m3 . h-1) C = Concentration rate
5.Micro-organisms, nutrients and potential foulants can also be absorbed into the
P = Deconcentration blowdown (m3 . h-1)
water across the tower.
1. Cells.
2. Fan.
3. Drive Assembly.
4. Fan Stack.
5. Distribution basin.
6. Flow Control Valves.
4.1.1. CELLS
A complete unit consisting of all above mentioned elements in a defined
enclosure is called as cell. A Cooling tower consists of one or more cells,
depending upon the capacity of the plant and the amount of cooling water to be
handled it is divided in to compartments. Each of these compartment are termed
as multi-cell cooling tower. Each cell is further divided by partitions.
4.1.2. FANS
Fans are those equipment which increase the rate of cooling by increasing the
movement of air through the tower. Based on location of it in the orientation of
cooling tower they are called as induced draft fan or forced draft fan. Induced
draft fans are placed on the top of the cooling lower which alters the movements
of air flow by sucking air through the tower from bottom to top. In forced draft
fan is usually a blower which forcibly forces the air placed at the bottom of the
cooling tower upwards.
Various types of fans are used depending on the design of cooling tower, such as:
a. Propeller Fans,
b.Automatic Variable-Pitch Fans,
c. Centrifugal Fan.
a) Propeller type fans are very common in cooling tower industry because of their
ability to move vast quantities of air at relatively low static pressure encountered.
The rotational speed at which a propeller fan is applied is inverse proportion to its
diameter. The smaller fans turn at relatively high speeds whereas the larger ones
at slower. The applied rotational speed of propeller fans usually depends on the
efficiency and some fans operates routinely at the blade tip speeds approaching to
14,000 feet per minute. The increased emphasis on reducing cooling tower
operating costs has resulted in the use of larger fans to move greater volumes of
air more efficiently. The intent of good propeller fan design is to achieve air
velocities across the effective area of the fan, from the hub to the blade tips, that
are as uniform as possible.
·
· b) Automatic Variable - Pitch Fans:
These are propeller fans in which a pneumatically actuated hub controls the pitch
of the blades in uniform orientation to horizontal axis. These fans have ability to
vary air flow through the tower in response to a changing load or ambient
conditions. At the same time these fans does the energy savings and are having
better control.
·
· c) Centrifugal Fans:
These are usually of the double inlet type used predominantly on cooling towers
designed for indoor installations. Their capability to operate against relatively
high static pressures makes them particularly suitable for that type of
applications. However their inability to handle large volumes of air and their
characteristically high input horsepower requirement (approx twice that of a
propeller fan), limits their use to relatively small applications. Three type of
centrifugal fans are available: 1) Forward curved blade fans, 2) Radial blade fans,
3) Backward curved blade fans. The characteristics of forward curved blade fan
make it more versatile in use in most type of cooling towers service. By virtue of
the direction and wind velocity of the air leaving the fan wheel, it can be
equipped with a comparatively small size housing, which is desirable from a
structural standpoint. Also because the required velocity is generated at
comparatively low speed, forward curved blade fans tend to operate quieter than
other types of centrifugal fans.
Drift Eliminators are required for all splash packings. Film packings require
eliminators only if flow rates are high.
4.1.9. LOUVERS
Louvers are used to help direct air flow into the tower and minimise the amount
of windage loss i.e. avoiding water being splashed or blown out of the sides of
the tower. Louvers are adjustable type to have flexibility of wind flow and their
velocity.
It is the structure which supports fans and the speed reducers at the top of the
cooling towers.
4.1.15. INSTRUMENTATION
On line pH analyser and hazardous gas emission of the stack are installed to
monitor acid and alkali content , or to suspect explosive gas leak to the system.
In a cooling tower practically all the parts are exposed to water and air. Iron and
carbon steel are used to a very limited extent in cooling tower construction
because it is corroded. In considering material of construction of various elements
of cooling towers, larger emphasis had been dealt to have a balance between
durability and cost. Excluding the mechanical equipment, the main selection is
for packing material and the frame work of the structure. Initially timber was
almost the only material used for construction. It had the advantages of
convenience and flexibility of fabrication. However it is extremely prone to
attack by bacteria and alkaline water. There is also risk of fire.
The best grades of California redwood are used because they resist corrosion
caused by water and air. Metals may also be used in construction specially if it is
a small packaged tower. Mild steel is used for casings and aluminium or
galvanised steel for packings. The advantages are high surface to volume ratios in
packing, durability, and strength. However, costs are higher for metallic
constructions. Metals which resist corrosion are used in certain parts of redwood
towers. Copper coated nails are used for joining the slabs and various assemblies.
Cast Iron is used in anchoring members that hold the tower on its concrete basin,
but it does corrode and has to be replaced occasionally. Brass bolts, washers and
nuts are used because they also resist corrosion and rust. Fire wood is used as
well as redwood because it resists rot due to moisture. Like fire wood synthetic
materials such as tensile fibre glass and other plastics resist moisture rot well.
Wood continues to be widely used for the construction of the cooling tower.
Wood deterioration can shorten the life of a cooling tower from an anticipated 20
to 25 years to 10 years or even less. Cooling tower operation becomes inefficient
and repair and replacement cost are excessive. Earlier redwood was selected for
the use in cooling towers because of its high strength to weight ratio, availability,
ease of use, low cost and natural resistance to decay. Nowadays pressure treated
Douglas fir and Similar types of wood are replacing redwood due to cost and
availability factors.
4.2.2. FILLS
The two major types of packing or fill arrangements are Splash packing and Film
packings. In general, film type packing occupy less volume and require less tower
height as compared to the splash type packings, however it is subject to clogging.
Splash fills are easier to repair and replace. Each fill provides a particular
interfacial area of contact. The mass and heat transfer coefficients for the system
also depend on the type of the fill. Originally fill consists of splash bars made out
of redwood or pressure treated fir. Splash bar are mostly available in Plastic film
fill having closely packed corrugated vertical sheets is typically made of plastic.
Polyvinylchloride(PVC), is commonly used for system with a maximum water
temperature of 1300F. Chlorinated PVC (CPVC) can withstand to approximately
1650F.
4.2.3. PACKINGS
An ideal material for the packing will be one which is easy to be moulded in
desired shape, is strong durable, light in weight and low cost. Apart from more
common packing materials of ACB (Asbestos cement boards and RCC, various
kinds of plastics have now been introduced. These comprise PVC, Polypropylene,
and Polystyrene etc. among tile various kinds known of plastics so far PVC is
reported to have most popular in other countries. However since none of these
plastics is fire proof their use in Indian industry is seen to be quite limited
The intent of good propeller fan design is to achieve air velocities across the
effective area of the fan from hub to the blade tips, that are a uniform as possible.
The most effective way to accomplish this is with tapered and twisted blades
having an airfoil cross section. Cast aluminium alloys are used in production of
this blade, because of their low cost, good internal damping characteristics and
resistance to corrosion in most cooling tower. Currently lighter blades of
exceptional corrosion resistance are made of fibreglass reinforced plastic, cast in
precision moulds. These blades may be solid formed around a permanent core, or
formed hollow by the use of a temporary-core having an aerodynamically
induced vibration resonance design.
Fan hubs must be of a material that is structurally compatible with blade weight
and must have good corrosion resistance. Galvanised steel weldments, grey and
ductile iron castings, and wrought in cast aluminium are in general use as hub
materials where hub and blades are of dissimilar metals they must be insulated
from each other to prevent electrolytic corrosion. Smaller diameter fans are
customarily made of galvanised sheet metal construction with fixed pitch non
adjustable blades. These fans are matched to differing air flow requirements by
changing the design speed. Centrifugal fans are usually of sheet metal
construction having protective coating being hot dip galvanisation.
Atmospheric cooling tower working depends on the wind velocity and the
relative humidity of the air. Sonic or the wind entering the tower is carried
upward, but most of the wind blows straight through the tower that are
interrupted and changed by the louvers and splash bars. The louvers help direct
wind and also prevent water loss. The hot air and water vapours leaving the top of
the tower have to pass through the drift eliminators which are adjustable to aid in
the control of air flow. The main function of splash bars is to slow down the fall
of water and to break it up into smaller drops. The longer contact of water with
air causes quicker evaporation and faster cooling than in a spray pond. Due to
evaporation and drift, there is some water loss, which has to he replaced with
make - up water. The longer air remains in a cooling tower, the more moisture it
absorbs. The more moisture the air contains the slower it accepts moisture, thus
reducing the efficiency of cooling tower.
INDUCE FORCED
D
CROSS COUNTER
FLOW FLOW
HOT
WATER
MAKEUP
WATER
WATER COOL
BASIN WATER
Drift loss is usually about 0.2% of the water flow. Loss due to evaporation is 1
%. Cooling towers can be divided into two basic types, such as Natural draft and
Mechanical draft towers, depending on the methods used to accomplish the air
movement, through the tower. Natural draft tower relay on chimney effect to
induce air movement. The density difference between the hot air and cold air
creates the required draft for air flow. Mechanical draft towers achieve the air
movement through the cooling towers with the help of fans. Depending on the
orientation of the fan they are classified as Induced Mechanical type, and Forced
Mechanical type. In induced type the fan is placed on the top of the cooling
tower as it pulls the air from the cooling tower. In forced type the fan is placed at
the bottom of cooling tower where the sides above are enclosed, it forces the air
through the packing upward having countercurrent passage with down coming
droplets of water.
Cooling towers can also be further classified by the motion of air in relation to
hot water. Towers where air and water move in parallel with air moving vertically
upwards and water moving downwards through the tower are called counter flow
towers. Towers where air flow is at 900 to the water flow and with air flowing
horizontally are called cross flow towers. Single flow tower is one where air entry
to the tower is from one logititudinal side only. Double flow towers are those
where air entry to the tower is from both the longitudinal sides of the tower.
Natural draft cooling tower uses a chimney or a stack effect to induce air
movement through the tower. They operate on the same principle as a furnace
chimney, where heat in a furnace causes hot fine gas to flow up through the slack
causing draft. When the hot water is sprayed in above the splash bars it breaks the
falling water into fine drops in order to provide better air to water contact. Some
of heat in water transfers to the air as the air heats up when it cools the hot water
it becomes lighter, which lowers the density of air. This creates a difference in
density of warmer air inside and outside cool air entering the tower, causing the
draft.
Thus the heated air is replaced with cold air entering at the bottom and rejecting
less dense moist air at the top. Thus the tower must be tall for sufficient buoyancy
and must have larger cross sectional area, because of the flow rates at which air
Because of its design, a natural draft tower does not depend as much on the wind
direction as the atmospheric tower. The temperature of the air inside the chimney
is always higher or warmer than atmospheric temperature. This difference in
temperature causes a constant draft or flow to exists from bottom to top of
cooling tower, taking away the heat from hot water. Thus in natural draft cooling
tower primary consideration is given to the temperature characteristics of air. If
the air rises to high temperature relatively to water temperature the tower will
cease to operate.Thus tower can be designed for both cross and counter type of
flow.In cross flow design the fill is external to the shell forming a ring around the
base. In counter flow design the fill is inside the shell.
The large cooling capacity they are built with hyperbolic shape. They do not
require drift eliminators. Make up water is needed to replace water loss due to
leaks and evaporation losses. Louvers or baffles are installed around the air inlet
of the natural draft tower that can be used to regulate and control the amount of
air entering the tower, which is required for cooling by evaporation empty
chimney accounts for the most of the tower height.
In Atmospheric cooling tower, air contacting the water is at same humidity and
depends solely on prevailing wind velocity that enhances the rate of cooling. As
evaporation occurs the air in contact with the water becomes more saturated, thus
decreasing the rate of evaporation. For this reason the movement of air through
the tower should be increased and this is done by inducing and forcing the
cooling medium.
Thus cooling of water in all towers depends mainly on the amount and humidity
of air passing through it. In mechanical type of cooling towers fans are used to
move air through the tower and thus affect the mechanism of cooling. The degree
of cooling can be adjusted by controlling one or more of the fans and the rate of
water flow to it. It uses either single or multiple fans to provide flow of a known
volume of air through the tower. Thus their thermal performance tends towards
greater stability and is affected by fewer psychometric variables than that of
atmospheric towers. The presence of fans also provides a means of regulating air
flow, to compensate for changes in atmospheric conditions, by fan capacity
manipulation and or cycling. Depending on the position of the fan, these towers
are classified as
1. Forced Draft Cooling Tower.
2. Induced Draft Cooling Tower.
Forced draft tower are characterised by high air entrance velocity and low
discharge velocities. Under these conditions, the air possesses a small velocity
head and tends to settle in the path of intake stream. This means that the fresh
intake air is contaminated with partially saturated air and is known as
recirculation and reduces the performances of the tower. Forced draft fans can
become subject to severe icing (with resultant imbalance) when moving air laden
with either natural or recirculated moisture.
They are equipped with centrifugal blower types fans, which although requiring
considerably more horsepower than propeller type fans which have an advantage
of being able to operate against the high static pressures associated with duct
work. Therefore they can either be installed indoors or within a specially
designed enclosure that provides significant separation between intake and
discharge locations to minimise the effect of recirculation. The degree of cooling
can be adjusted by, controlling one or more of the fans and the rate of water flow.
Almost all the forced draft towers are counterflow designs.
The potential for recirculation on the induced draft tower is not self-initiating and
therefore can be more easily quantified purely on the basis of ambient wind
conditions. Location of the fan within the warm air stream provides excellent
protection against the formation of icing on the components. The discharged air is
driven up into natural air current which prevents it from settling at the air intake.
However in these towers the pressure drop is on the intake side of the fan which
increases the fan power requirements. The higher velocity of discharge also uses a
greater drift loss of water droplet carried away by the air stream.
In this type the largest part of the tower has enclosed sides from the top. The air
travels most of the time in an opposite direction from the falling water spray.
Their side louvers are-movable to regulate the air intake. The air volume flowing
through the tower is controlled by the speed of the fan and the amount of opening
of the side louvers. The air passes from the bottom to the falls, contacting
droplets of water spray.
The emphasis for a proper specification for a cooling tower is needed, apart from
covering all the technical requirements also provides a common basis for
comparison of all the various designs available in selecting a cooling tower. The
following are some of the important aspects which need consideration while
drawing cooling tower specification.
1. Design Parameters.
2. Space Restriction.
3. Number of Cells and Fan diameter.
4. Pumping Head.
5. Wind Velocity.
6. Evaluation Factors.
7. Fan Power Consumption.
8. Pumping Head
9. Tower Length.
10. Performance Test.
1. DESIGN PARAMETERS
2. SPACE RESTRICTIONS
The design of a cooling tower and hence its performance is governed by
availability of adequate free air space around the cooling tower. The cooling
tower will have to be located at a certain minimum distance from adjacent
cooling towers and/or buildings/structures so that its performance is not affected
by the adjacent cooling towers and/ or building/structures. Where it is not
possible to maintain this minimum distance then it will be necessary to modify
the design of cooling tower to take in to account the effect of adjacent cooling
towers. In case cooling tower which is situated very, close to a building it may be
necessary to have a single flow tower, for this, it is therefore necessary to
stipulate in the specification,the space available for installation of cooling towers
and also size of any building in the vicinity of it.
4. PUMPING HEAD
In large cooling water system as in a power plant, the pumping head forms a
major part (more than 50 %) of the total cooling water pump head. Any reduction
5. WIND VELOCITY
Wind velocity is one of the parameters that affects the performance of a cooling
tower. A cooling tower designed for zero wind velocity is not expected to give
the same performance at higher velocities. Since the cooling tower is normally
required to operate continuously throughout the year, it is necessary to take in to
account the normally occurring wind velocity in the design of the tower. These
aspects sometime indirectly govern the dimension and size of the tower.
6. EVALUATION FACTORS
In the case of large capacity induced draft cooling tower, the fan power
consumption is quite larger (of the order of about 75OKW for the cooling tower
of 210 MW unit) which leads to a continuous recurring expenditure. It is
therefore advantageous to have a cooling tower with lower fan consumption that
is dictated by the loading factor.
7. PERFORMANCE TEST
After the cooling tower is constructed normally performance test is conducted on
the tower to prove the performance of the tower thus accepting the various
required factors that are being laid down in quality assurance and terminology
list. The parameter that are measured during the test are cooling water flow rate,
temperature (inlet & outlet), Ambient air temperature, W.B.T of air entering the
cooling tower, Dry bulb temperature, Humidity, Wind Velocity, Distribution
range, drift loss, wind loss, evaporation loss and concentration ratio, quality of
cooling water, pump head, Fan power and its performance, recirculation effect,
etc. All the parameters except cooling water flow can be measured by means pilot
tube that requires provision of nozzles on the cooling water pipe line with
adequate free lengths on the upstream side and downstream side.
.
The cooling tower operations basically face following problems frequently.
1. Environmental Problems
2. Wind Loads.
3. Dry Cooling Towers
4. Corrosion.
5. Scale and Deposit formation.
6. Microbiological Fouling.
The water vapour emitted from the stacks of cooling towers may, cause
difficulties such as hazardous patches of fog on the roads, and fine droplets
entrained from the water sprays may be troublesome immediately downwind of
the tower. This plume of water vapour mainly due to temperature inversion effedt
the inlet Wet Bulb Temperature thus creating conditions towards recirculation.
In view of the fact that many competent problems of cooling tower are predicted
with limited success, it is usually suspected that unpredictable variations in flow
distribution may be responsible. It is more predominant in natural draft cooling
towers than in forced draft cooling towers, because of the dynamic head of the
wind represents a substantially greater fraction of the pressure drop through the
natural draft than forced draft. Not only can the changes in the wind velocity and
direction change both the draft and the amount of recirculation but they can also
change the flow pattern inside the cooling tower. so at large segments of the fill
may lie in eddies which make that region ineffective because of low air velocity
or even internal recirculation.Wind effects are reduced by designing optimum
stack height of natural draft ranging from 40 ft to 300 ft.For large installation
cooling towers are placed side by side in long row at right angles to the direction
of the prevailing wind.This arrangement is prevailing in coastal regions.
Cooling tower design depends upon the quantity of water to be handled. Enough
quantity of water is required for a wet cooling tosver to keep all the parts in the
soakedconditions. Normally wet cooling tower consumes about 10,000 gpm.
Based on these cooling tower is selected. Although the cost of dry cooling towers
is roughly four times that of wet cooling towers so that their use leads to an
increase in the capital cost of a steam plant by about 30%. Dry cooling towers are
basically installed where acute shortage of water even for domestic purpose, for
small installations and service.
5.4. CORROSION
2. 9000 2400
Capacity(m 3 /hr)
3. 597-9V-05 473-204
Model
4. Induced Draft Induced Draft
Type
5. 6 4
No.of cells
6. 6706 4267
Fan Dia(MM)
7. Cooling Water Supply 33 33
Temperature
8. Cooling Water Teturn 41 41
Temperature
· Pumps:
One old offsite cooling water pump is kept on auto.When old offsite
cooling water pressure drops below 3.5kg/cm2 due to excess
consumption,leakage etc, the auto standby pump will start on auto.Similarly one
old process cooling water pump is on auto.
Also one old offsite pump,one old process pump and one new process
pump are kept on HVSB-2 ,(as they are critical equipments) which is on DG
power.
· Fans:
In New cooling water system,two coling tower fans are kept on auto. One
fan will start on auto if the cooling water temperature raises above 27.5 deg C and
the other if the temperature raises above 29 deg C.
6.3.CHEMICALS USED
The compound is added to maintain the net total inorganic phosphate in the
cooling water to about 8 - 10 ppm. If river water is having phosphate then
considering the concentration cycles the phosphate due to raw water is to be
6.3.5. pH CONTROL:
PH is adjusted with NaOH and Hcl to maintain between 6.5 to 7.5.
The degree of cooling in cooling towers depends on the amount of air passing
through the tower.In addition if the air is hot and humid, the degree of cooling is
1% less than when the air is cold and dry, low air temperature may result in too
much cooling, thus in winter lot of temperature may cause broken small particles
of cooling water to freeze on parts of cooling tower. Ice formations may block the
passages between splash bars.As ice starts to build up around the fans, it may shut
off the flow of air it reduces the cooling characteristics and ice formed at the
blades may cause overloading of the fan motor.
This can be prevented by limiting the quantity of cold air entering the tower
by,
1. By adjusting the louvers in atmospheric cooling towers.
2. By selectively slowing down the speed or by slowly switching off the
fans of induced and forced draft cooling tower.
3. By decreasing the pitch of the fan blades which also reduces the air intake.
Fans which do not have variable pitch blades are usually equipped so that the
direction of rotation can be reversed, thus on reversing the pitch the force draft
fan blades causes hot air to be sucked out of the tower instead of pushing into the
tower which helps in melting an ice build-up.
The operator must check the condition of gear box, motor, fan blades, valves,
distributors on the deck for lubrication, vibration, choking, maldistribution of
water on the deck and timely corrective action to be taken. Because the water
circulate many times through pipes in exchangers, cooling towers, and basins it
picks up more solids from it, when water evaporates, it does not take the solids
with it which gets accumulated in the system where at one stage the circulating
water has more solids than the fresh make up water.If this is allowed the
suspended solid particles tends to settle out in sections of the cooling system
where the velocity of the water is slowed thus reducing the efficiency of heat
transfer of that equipment by forming scales or fouling the tubes and or build-up
of deposits.Hence to have good cooling properties of the water the solids are
removed regularly and make up done by fresh water to compensate the
requirements.
The following cleaning method is carried out for in service without shutting
down the system by adjusting the various parameters at the cooling tower itself to
increase the efficiency of the cooling water.
2. Lower the pH of the circulating water to about 5.5 and add the dispersant
to 1.00 ppm, circulate to about 8 hours, and then give heavy blowdown from
cooling tower sump.
pH : 6.5 to 7.5
(a) pH :
- If pH is less than the specified limit then suitable quantity of
Monocyclohexylamine(MCHA) is added to bring it within limits.
- If pH is higher than the specified limit then suitable quantity of
Hydrochloric Acid (Hcl) is added to bring it with in limits.
(c) Phosphate:
- If Phosphate is less than the specified limit then suitable quantity of Kem
Watreat-101 is added to bring it with in limits.
- If Phosphate is more than the specified limit then suitable quantity of
Kem Watreat-101 is reduced to bring it with in limits.
(d) Conductivity/Chloride/Hardness/TSS/Iron:
- If Conductivity/Chloride/Hardness/TSS/Iron is/are more than the
specified limits then Blowdown given to bring it within limit.
Laying down the essential design criteria in cooling tower specification helps in
effective way in developing more efficient cooling tower design. The essential
design criteria comprises orientation and the spacing of the towers, the
8.1. LOCATION
Cooling tower should be located at a place where free air access is available from
the surroundings without any restrictions from the adjoining buildings and
structures. The location of the tower should be studied with reference to the
nearby chimneys and stacks effluents gases from the process particularly if these
are of hot or oily. While locating the towers on the upwind of switchyards,
sufficient distance should be provided so that the saturated vapour plumes do not
effect the electrical conductors. Space requirements for any future towers
required to be installed as result of the expansion of the thermal plant should also
be kept in view. The location of the cooling tower should not be too far from the
circulating water pumps and the main plant so that the piping and pumping cost
does not become excessive. Care should also be taken as it should not be located
nearness to any control room. housing software and computer networks.
The size of the cooling tower for a given duty will differ depending upon the type
of the tower whether or counter flow. Water to air ratio used in the design, the
volume and characteristics of packing, approach temperature, Wet Bulb
Temperature at the inlet, prevailing wind conditions , geographical condition etc.
It is recommended to keep the ratio of length to width of the towers within 5 : 1.
No limitation should be put on the height of towers so that the selection of the
best height of tower gives best air circulation and movement through the tower,
keeping in view the plan area available. Only after selection of the tower is
complete that the pumping head of circulation water pumps should be finalised.
8.3. RECIRCULATION
This aspect of design basically depends on the wind direction so that the
recirculation is minimised. When an plant consists of many cooling towers it
may be placed side by side with a specify distance between them in a long row at
right angles to the direction of the prevailing wind . This is a particularly
effective arrangement in coastal regions where the winds predominantly on shore
orFig.8 RECIRCULATION
offshore. Some time atINthe CASE OF INDUCED
interior the towersDRAFT TOWER
are best align AND ITS
in their
EFFECT ON ADJOINING COOLING TOWER.
longitudinal axis along the wind direction. Based on the CTI code No PFM - 1
10 where(Distance betweenthat
it recommended the towers
towers isless
notthan
drawn to scale)
approximately 250 ft in length
WIND
should be aligned with the prevailing summer wind direction and tower longer
than 250 ft. In length should be aligned perpendicular to the prevailing summer
wind direction. For orientation of a new cooling tower to be installed near an
existing tower, in order to reduce the recirculation effect the spacing between the
two cooling towers widely apart should be at a minimum distance of about 100
mts, basically to reduce the recirculation effect. This is coded in CTI code and BS
- 4485.
The performance of mechanical draft tower, depends chiefly upon the wet bulb
temperature of the inlet entering air, whereas the performance of natural draft
cooling tower depends both upon the wet bulb temperature and dry bulb
temperature. The recirculation taking place in case of the mechanical draft
towers gives rise to a an important term, Inlet humidity. No recirculation takes
place in case of natural draft towers. This inlet wet bulb temperature is higher
than ambient wet bulb temperature by the amount of recirculation. In view of
this the atmospheric condition to be specified and detailed for different types of
towers. Fixing of recirculation allowance is not standardised to all type of
cooling towers as all cooling tower do not recirculate equally. Thus by adding a
Natural draft cooling towers depends both on the dry bulb temperature and wet
bulb temperature. The dry bulb temperature is measured to a high degree of
accuracy and is of major significance.
8.6.TYPE OF PACKINGS
A good packing is that which provides maximum contact surface area, maximum
retention time and causes a least pressure drop. Splash type packings generally
have less pressure drop, are less prone to clogging as compared to film flow
packings but suffer from the disadvantage of sagging and channelling. Whatever
be the type of packing, its spacing should be quite uniform so as to ensure equal
distribution of air and water. Both the water pumping requirements and the
capacity of the cooling tower per unit of base area can be improved by providing
horizontal surfaces within the cooling tower to reduce the average velocity of the
failing droplets and to increase the time that the droplets are exposed to the
cooling air stream in failing through the tower. Another advantage of this
approach is that it makes possible counterflow performance and hence a lower
temperature in the exit water stream. It has advantage by using low pressure
water sprays at the top, placing horizontal decks of latticework in the tower, and
arranging the wall , so that the air enters horizontally and is discharged vertically.
A desirable feature of this arrangement is that vertical upward movements of air
also slows down the fall of water droplets and thus increase the effective surface
area for any given water flow rate. More commonly ACB ( asbestos cement
board) and RCC , various kinds of plastics am used in modem construction of
cooling towers.
All mild steel parts should be either hot dipped galvanised or plastic coated. All
fasteners should be made of stainless steel. Since fans have to continuously work
with moist air these should be made of a good corrosion resistant material. The
conventional cast aluminum fans have now been replaced by fibre glass
reinforced plastic. A good fan design should be able to produce as far as possible
uniform air velocity from the hub to the tip of the blades.
Cooling tower specifications usually limit the fan tip speed to a velocity not
exceeding 10,000 cfm. A high tip speed is desirable front the aerodynamics stand
point of view. So cooling tower fans are normally designed for the above
maximum speed. The most effective means to produce back flow is to keep
minimum clearance between the blades and the cylinder. Back flow is also
Propeller type fans predominate tin the cooling tower industry because of their
ability to rnove vast quantity of air at relatively low static pressures encountered.
Most utilised diameters are in the range from 24 inches to 100 inches. Fans 48
inches and larger in diameter are equipped with adjustable pitch blades, enabling
the fans to be applied over a wide range of operating horse powers. Thus the fans
can be adjusted to deliver the precise required amount of air at the least power
consumption. The rotational speed at which a propeller fan is applied typically
varies in inverse proportion to the diameter. The smaller fans turn at relatively
high speeds, whereas the larger ones turn somewhat slower.However higher tip
speeds are associated with higher sound levels.
The increased emphasis on reducing cooling tower operating costs has resulted in
use of larger fans to move greater volume of air more efficiently. The nay
generation fans are light in weight to reduce the parasitic energy losses and have
fewer, but wider blades to reduce aerodynamic drag. Moreover, the characteristic
of air flow through the tower, front inlet to discharge, are analysed and
distribution adjustments to the structure are made to minimise obstructions. Fill
and distribution systems are designed and arranged to promote maximum
uniformity of air and water flow and drift eliminators are arranged to direct final
pass of air toward the fan .
Thus the intent of good propeller fan design is to achieve air velocities across the
eftecive area of the fan From hub to blade tips, that are as uniform as possible and
the most effective way to accomplish this is with tapered and twisted blades
having an aerofoil cross section.
· Centrifugal fans
These are usually of the double inlet type, used predominately on cooling towers
designed for indoor installations. Their capability to operate against towers
designed for indoor installation. Their capability to operate against relatively
high static pressure makes them particularly, suitable for that type of application.
· Fan Laws:
V = Q/A x 60
The optimum speed of a cooling tower fan depends on the most efficient speed of
the motor. This dictates that a speed reduction, power transmission unit of some
sort be situated between the motor and the fan. In addition to reducing the speed
of the motor to the proper fan speed at the least possible loss of available power,
and the power transmission unit must also provide primary support for the fan,
· V- Belt Drives
These are an accepted standard for smaller factory assembled cooling tower.
'They are much dependable in service, Belts wear and stretch and belt tension
must be periodically adjusted. Misalignment is one of the most common cause of
excessive belt wear.Manually adjustable pitch sheaves are occasionally provided
to allowe a change in fan speed .
· Drive Shaft.
The drive shaft transmits power from the output shaft of the motor to the input
shaft of the gear speed reducer. Because the drive shaft operates within the
tower, it must be highly corrosion resistant.Drive shaft are equipped ivith flexible
coupling attached at both ends. Flexible couplings transmit the load betiveen the
drive shaft and the motor or gear speed reducer, and compensate for minor
misalignment. It is very important that drive shafts be properly balanced.
Imbalance not only causes tower vibration, but also induces higher loads and
excessive wear on the mechanical equipment coupled to shaft. Cooling tower
drive shaft commonly operate at speeds approaching 1800 RPM, where at these
speeds, the shaft should be dynamically to reduce vibrational forces to a
minimum.
Cold water basins would be designed with sufficient volume to meet emergency
situations that may arise. Quality of water which will provide at least fifteen
minutes of operation after such an emergency occurs will allow the operators
enough time to shut down the cooling water pumps before damage, can occur.
Basins, with such storage facility will give additional operating reliability in
providing enough water for several hours, Should the make up water system fail.
The water available in the basin can also be used to supplement the fire fighting
system in case of emergency. Other factors to be considered in sizing of the basin
are the hydraulic losses and the effect of the operating water level in the basin on
the circulating water pump submergence, Provision should be made in the basin
to incorporate a make up line, a blowdown line, an overflow line or weir and
sludge surnp.
8.9. FOUNDATION
The following procedure are followed for preliminary estimation of size and
thereby cost of the cooling towers.
1. Choose the design conditions, that is the water inlet and outlet
teniperiture,water flow rate and the inlet air wet bulb temperature.
4. Using simpson's rule detemiine the area under the curve obtain from above
plot, and from it the required value for the tower characteristic KaV/ L
Where ,
K=Coefficient of mass transfer
a =Area of transfer surface per unit tower packed volume
V=Effective packed volume per unit plan area of packing
L=Mass water flow per unit plan area of packing
G=Mass air flow per unit plan area of packing
5. Choose a fill matrix geometry and obtain the required principal data for it
characteristics front the standard data sheets for the same type of fill.
7. Using the air enthalpy curve as derived in step 2, determine L/G from heat
balance consideration. (L/G is equal to the slope of the air enthalpy line.)
8. Substitute the values obtained for KaV/LW , L/G to obtain the number of
decks N, and hence the height of the packed portion of the tower.
9. From L/G determine the air flow rate for a water flow of 2500 lb/hr (L).lf
the resulting air flow exceeds 1600 lb / hr, determine the water flow that
corresponds to an airflow of 1600 lb/hr. ' G = L/ 1.25.
10. Determine the cross sectional area of the tower using the water flow rate
per unit of area given in above step and the total water flow rate established.
11. Select the horizontal dimensions of the tower to give the area as obtained
from above step keeping the dimension in the direction of the prevailing wind to
no less than the packed height and no more than 40 ft. The overall height should
be the packed height plus about one and one half times the depth in the direction
of the prevailing wind.
· Fan cylinders less than six feet high must be equipped with suitable fan
guards for the protection of the operating personnel. Drive shaft must
operate within retaining guards to prevent the drive shaft from
encountering the fan if the coupling should fail. The motor shaft and
outboard drive shaft coupling should either be within the confines of
the fan cylinder or enclosed within a suitable guard.
· During long shut down, cooling Towers should not be left dry at any
moment tor the danger of catching fire to the elements of tower
physically and due the deposits of chemical reactants and their
characterstics.Thus it should be always water sprayed to keep the
wooden parts rnoist.
·
·
· Hydrochloric Acid
· Sodium Hydroxide
Irritation is frequently not evident immediately after contact, injury may result
before it is realised.It dissolves human hair and wool clothing. If it comes in
contact with eyes, blindness may result. Use of rubber gloves and splash proof
goggles while handling is recommended. Wash with plenty of water.
· KemWatreat-101,301,304,1002,BD.