Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Strabo - Strabo's Geography - A Translation For The Modern World-Princeton University Press (2024)
Strabo - Strabo's Geography - A Translation For The Modern World-Princeton University Press (2024)
GEOGRAPHY
STRABO’S
GEOGRAPHY
A TRANSLATION FOR THE MODERN WORLD
P R I N C E T O N U N I V E R S I T Y P R E S S
princeton and oxford
Copyright © 2024 by Princeton University Press
press.princeton.edu
10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1
For my husband, Guy Cogan, and my daughter, Hannah
We use the term “lived-in world” for the world we live in and know; it is possible that
there are two or more lived-in worlds within the same temperate zone, especially in the
vicinity of the Athens parallel where it is drawn through the Atlantic ocean.
List of Maps ix
Foreword by Peter Frankopan xi
Acknowledgments xv
Brief Introduction xvii
A Translation for the Modern World xxi
Use This Translation in Conjunction With . . . xxv
Special Features of This Translation xxix
A User’s Guide xxxix
vii
List of Maps
The maps represent areas contained within what Strabo considers to be the “Lived-in
World” in its entirety, and the parts thereof—namely, the “Western” part of E
urope, the
“Eastern” part of Europe, and so forth. They do not represent Strabo’s own conceptual-
ization of the landmasses comprising Europe, Asia, and Libya (= Africa).
ix
Foreword
Strabo is not usually described as the “father of geography”—a label more often given
to Eratosthenes, a polymath who lived two centuries e arlier. Yet Strabo is perhaps more
deserving of this title, given the influence of his work, the way he gathered and presented
his material, and the renown of the author. Although Strabo placed himself within a
tradition that included authors and scholars who wrote before his own birth in the first
century BCE, he did not take a charitable view of the value of all of them: Eratosthenes
himself may well have been “steeped in learning,” Strabo writes, but he was not as trust-
worthy as many believed.
Geography, argued Strabo, is about understanding the world properly and fully. “The
man who describes the world must, in matters of fundamental premises, rely on geom-
eters who have calculated the m easurement of the whole earth; they, in turn, must rely
on astronomers, who in turn must rely on physicists.” Geography, therefore, is not just
a science, but a combination of sciences, a subject not only of interest but importance.
“I believe that if anything is part of the p
hilosopher’s mandate,” says the first line of his
masterpiece, “it is the science of geography.” Geography is essential, in other words.
The Geography is one of the most influential works written in any language; it offers a
sweeping, majestic overview of three continents, seen through the lens of the burgeoning
power and widening horizons of Rome during its transition from a republic to an empire.
Strabo’s work is one of the longest Greek texts in existence, filled with details, asides, and
interventions by the author that illuminate and enliven, and occasionally castigate errors
made by previous scholars.
Ironically, not everyone has been impressed by Strabo’s work: “the laxity of his meth-
ods,” concluded one leading twentieth-century historian of ancient Rome, “defies rigor-
ous argumentation.” That is rather unfair on a man who did his best to evaluate evidence
carefully and did a g reat deal of homework, too. In fact, Strabo was extraordinarily well-
read. Homer, Thucydides, Aeschylus, Herodotus, and many more are quoted liberally;
so too are more than two hundred other authors—including many that are not known
from any other source. Although Strabo’s name (which literally means “squinty-eyed”)
was probably a family name rather than one derived from his physical appearance, he
clearly took his research seriously.
Strabo is an engaging guide, especially when he interjects with his opinions on, or
experiences of, m atters that, as Sarah Pothecary notes in this magisterial new translation,
range from taming an elephant to practicing yoga, or from visiting an exhibition of sacred
crocodiles from the Nile in Rome to watching glass-blowers at work in Alexandria. His
xi
Foreword
regular interest in mining, along with the use of technical terminologies, provides an
indication of his own interests, as do the many references to art and famous artists and
diff erent kinds of wine, often shared with his own comments on their respective qualities.
He was proud of his roots in Anatolia, doing his family and fellow Anatolians a service
by commemorating the names of many (while leaving many other seemingly deserving
figures to one side, unmentioned).
The encyclopedic scope of the text has made it a reference book par excellence, with
the result that Strabo is one of the most cited authors in antiquity. Although some near
contemporaries (notably Pliny the Elder) do not appear to have been aware of the G eography,
Strabo’s work was well-known, well-regarded, and struck a chord in Byzantine Constan-
tinople where it proved influential on authors such as Procopius, who was similarly keen
to paint a picture of a world in transition in the sixth century, at a time when new op-
portunities and challenges were emerging, and when peoples on the move demanded
knowledge about the past, as well as the present.
Of course, this was central to Strabo himself. “It is evident, both from ancient tradi-
tion and from rational argument,” he writes early on, ”that all who embrace such knowl-
edge benefit greatly.” Besides, he added, the “wisest of the heroes” in the past “were t hose
who traveled afar and wandered around.” Being curious was key, in other words. Heracles,
for example, was “an expert in great deeds b ecause of his extensive practical experience
and knowledge.”
As a source of so much information, it was perhaps not a surprise that Strabo’s text
became so widely consulted during the age of E uropean expansion, a time when new
worlds were being explored, new customs and peoples encountered, and new ways of
doing t hings recorded. Strabo’s ambivalence about the age of empire also resonated with
many. He writes that many parts of the world had “been subjugated to one power,” with
the result that an age of openness had followed. He recognized too, however, that there
were downsides to cultural expansion: “our lifestyle has brought to nearly everyone a
change for the worse, introducing luxuries and sensual pleasures and a myriad of corrupt
ways to increase them. Much of this evil has been visited on native peoples, especially the
nomads.” Fine morals had been replaced by pure greed. That too was not lost on some
in the age of E
uropean empires.
Strabo was no moralist, however. His aim above all was to inform, and to do so sys-
tematically and universally. There are some places and peoples he ignores, notably those
living in the British Isles, about whom there can be “no added advantage” in wasting
ink writing about them, since “because of their isolation, [they] are capable of neither
harming nor helping us.” Those outside the “lived-in world” are likewise put to one side,
with Strabo disbelieving that life is even possible in zones that w
ere either too hot or too
cold to support human existence.
The Geography is an extraordinary work, one that deserves a sparkling translation.
Strabo has been served with distinction by Sarah Pothecary, whose glorious rendition is
xii
Foreword
matched by uniformly useful notes, apparatus, and a series of commentaries that help the
reader know what to look out for and why. The task of producing editions and transla-
tions of this huge text have often killed off the editor, so Sarah is to be congratulated too
on her stamina, as well as the lucidity of working with elaborate Greek and with terms
that can be both obscure and not simple.
The mark of a great translator, however, is the ability to capture the voice of the origi-
nal author. This edition does that better than any I’ve had the p leasure to read in the past.
I know too from experience that the ability and skill to succeed come from spending
years, decades even, getting to know a text and its creator inside out. I hope all readers of
this book enjoy reading about the world of Strabo as much as so many others have over
the centuries—and remember why it is so important not only to learn about p eoples and
places close to home, but about those far away too.
Peter Frankopan
Professor of Global History
Oxford University
Mumbai, October 27, 2023
xiii
Acknowledgments
xv
Acknowledgments
necessary, and I owe him a huge debt for the time he has spent checking the manuscript
at its various stages.
Last but not least, I am grateful to all my friends from Toronto and G rand Lake,
Canada, and from London, England, who have patiently followed the progress of this
translation over many years. Their support and companionship have been invaluable.
xvi
Brief Introduction
Strabo’s Life
Strabo lived and worked just over two thousand years ago: his life spanned the latter half
of the first century BCE and the early d ecades of the first c entury CE. We know nothing
about his father, but his mother and her family came from what is now northern Turkey.
This area, the erstwhile independent kingdom of Pontus, had fallen to the rapidly ex-
panding Roman empire just a few years before the probable date of Strabo’s birth. Strabo
went on to be educated in what is now southwestern Turkey, a far more entrenched part
of the Roman world, having been incorporated as the province of Asia nearly a century
earlier. Strabo subsequently moved to Rome, to the heart of the empire, where he pur-
sued his higher education. In his young adulthood, Strabo relocated to Egypt, Rome’s
newest acquisition, which had fallen to the Romans just a few years before Strabo’s arrival
there. Strabo spent much of his life in Egypt, taking advantage of the cultural riches and
the intellectual ambience of its metropolis, Alexandria. During this time, Strabo first
produced a historical work, which has not survived. Then, after a lifetime of research
and reading, as an old man in his late seventies and early eighties, Strabo completed the
work translated here. He died soon afterward.
Strabo’s Geography
The most immediate feature of Strabo’s geographical work is its size, weighing in at more
than a third of a million words. Ironically, in an age that lacked eyeglasses and electric
lights, let alone word-processing capabilities and computers, and at a time when writing
materials w ere expensive and difficult to come by, mega-works (many of them much
longer than Strabo’s) w ere not unusual. Most of these behemoths did not survive to be
enjoyed in the present day, their large physical bulk perhaps contributing to their demise.
Strabo’s contribution not only survived but did so almost unscathed, making it our earli-
est (almost) complete example of such a mega-work from antiquity.
While length alone makes Strabo’s work worthy of note, the sheer joie de vivre of the
narrative makes it really stand out. Strabo tells us just about everything he knew about
the world of his day. In his pages, we find instructions on how to tame elephants and
xvii
Brief Introduction
information on the production of asphalt, how saffron is collected, the treatment of old
people, the practice of yoga, the lineage of obscure eastern dynasties, religious festivals,
prostitution, and volcanic activity—to name but a few of the topics that Strabo deems
worthy of note. Geologists and seismologists, mineralogists and mining specialists,
oceanographers and meteorologists, ethnographers and anthropologists, climatologists,
and astronomers w ill all find that Strabo has material of interest to them.
Sometimes, Strabo’s attitude toward the information he presents is as valuable as the
information itself in helping to re-create the academic mindset of the times. Strabo re-
fuses, for example, to believe in a huge tsunami that was reputed to have devastated what
is now Jutland, on the grounds that he knows for a fact that tides do not operate in such
a fashion. He disbelieves a report about an inhabited island called “Thule” at the arctic
circle on the grounds that nobody e lse seems to know about it and that habitation is not
possible so far north. The privileging of what one is predisposed to believe over what the
evidence suggests is as prevalent today as it was in antiquity.
Strabo describes the whole world as it was known to the Greeks and Romans of his
day, from (in present-day terms) Bangladesh to Portugal, from G reat Britain to Somalia.
He has personal experience of some of the locations he mentions. From his home base in
what is now Turkey, Strabo had traveled to Rome; from there, he had explored parts of
the western coast of Italy. From Alexandria in Egypt, he had sailed southward up the Nile
as far as Syene (Aswan, Egypt). In describing these locations, and those that he passed
en route, Strabo sometimes makes use of his own observations.
For most of his descriptions, however, Strabo relies on the reports of o thers. While he
occasionally uses material transmitted to him orally by friends or by Roman officials, he
far more frequently turns to the plethora of literary accounts that w ere available in his day,
many of which were already hundreds of years old. Rather than a travelogue, then, Strabo’s
work is an intellectual journey through the accumulated literature of antiquity, from which
he selects information relevant to the relatively new discipline of geography. In doing so,
he offers us a fascinating insight into how the world was perceived two thousand years ago
and allows us to see how geographical perceptions have changed over time.
A New Translation
Strabo’s work is an invaluable resource for anyone interested in how the world t oday
came into being. The main challenge for would-be readers is how to approach it. Even
when translated from ancient Greek into E nglish, Strabo’s narrative can be daunting, ap-
pearing at first sight sprawling and repetitive, overly dense, and sometimes meandering.
On closer inspection, however, the work turns out to be highly structured and tightly
organized, despite its length. This translation employs chapters and subheadings to make
xviii
Brief Introduction
it easier for modern readers to appreciate the architecture of the work without being
overwhelmed by the sheer volume of material. The subheadings and chapter titles are
drawn together in “Navigating Strabo’s Geography,” immediately preceding the transla-
tion itself, designed to help readers find their way around the translation.
Another problem for readers today is that place-names used by Strabo may sound
outlandish to the modern ear, making it seem as if the world he describes is remote from
our own in terms of place as well as time. How is the average reader supposed to know
that, when describing “Iberia” (the Caucasian “Iberia,” not the Spanish one), “Albania,”
and “Atropatian Media,” Strabo is referring to areas within present-day Azerbaijan? This
translation goes some way t oward addressing the problem by providing maps that allow
twenty-first-century readers to orient themselves within the modern world and by giving
the present-day equivalents of the place-names mentioned by Strabo.
The process of relating the past to our present within the translation is illuminating,
not least b ecause it replicates what Strabo himself was doing two thousand years ago,
relating his past world to his present-day world. Moreover, Strabo writes at a time when
the world of the present is succumbing to seemingly inexorable Roman expansion. Intel-
lectuals like Strabo must incorporate into their perception and p resentation of the world
the radical changes that have taken place. Twenty-first-century students of international
affairs and geopolitics may find, in reading this translation, an unexpectedly historical
aspect to their disciplines, which are usually treated as rooted in the present.
xix
A Translation for the Modern World
This is a translation of Strabo’s Geography—but what exactly does that mean? The papy-
rus rolls that constituted Strabo’s own copy of his geographical work have not survived,
so this translation is not of the original version. For our knowledge of the contents of
Strabo’s work, we depend largely on a variety of medieval manuscripts, but an immediate
problem arises in that Strabo’s work is not uniformly represented in those manuscripts.
Over the past few hundred years, editors have done the painstaking work of comparing
manuscripts and have come up with their own versions of the (now lost) manuscript from
which the medieval manuscripts were ultimately derived. This new translation is based on
the most recent such edition, undertaken by Stefan L. Radt and published between 2002
and 2011 (see “Use This Translation in Conjunction With . . .”). It is the first English
translation based exclusively on Radt’s text.1
Radt’s major achievement is that he carefully compared manuscripts covering the
entirety of Strabo’s narrative, making him the first editor to manage this feat in more than
a hundred and fifty years. Given the amount of work involved in editing such a lengthy
text, e arlier editors either died before finishing the job or lost interest or energy before
their editions w ere completed. Radt, already advanced in years when he undertook the
project of editing Strabo’s narrative, lived to complete his work and to see it published.
Radt’s edition of Strabo’s work marks a watershed in Strabonian studies, and its publica-
tion provided the catalyst for this translation.
This translation might equally be subtitled A Translation “from” the Modern World, since it
allows readers to travel back in time and find out what Strabo says about areas of the world
now known by different names. To aid readers in this endeavor, maps are supplied at the
start of the chapters covering Western E urope, Eastern E urope, Northern Asia, Southern
Asia, and Libya (= Africa). Each map shows the geographical area on which Strabo focuses
within the chapter that follows, but it does so largely in terms of the present-day nation-
states that occupy it rather than the political entities with which Strabo was familiar.
[ 1 ] Duane Roller based his 2014 translation of Strabo’s work on an amalgam of “recent texts of the Geography, espe-
cially the editions of Radt, the Budé, and Aly, with [Roller’s] own emendations.” D. Roller, The Geography of Strabo
(Cambridge University Press, 2014), 29.
xxi
A Translation for the Modern World
Once readers interested in a particular part of the modern world have used the maps to
find the part of the translation relevant to them, they should cross over to the ancient
world with the help of the Barrington Atlas of the Greek and Roman World either in its physi-
cal form or in the form of the Barrington Atlas App for the iPad (see “Use This Translation
in Conjunction With . . .”). The maps of the Barrington Atlas (BA) show most of the
ancient places named by Strabo, and readers should ideally have this atlas by their side
as they read through Strabo’s narrative.
The BA maps show the Greek and Roman world in the sense of labeling sites and
regions u nder their ancient names. They do not show how the world was spatially con-
ceived in Greek and Roman times. Ancient concepts of the landmasses composing the
world often differed radically from reality. Strabo was typical of his time in having very
xxii
A Translation for the Modern World
distorted ideas in this respect. It is tempting for modern scholars to try to represent
these distortions graphically. Their attempts face a major obstacle in the form of the
many inconsistencies and ambiguities throughout Strabo’s work. Should Iberia (Spain
and Portugal) be depicted in the shape of an oxhide, with the Pyrenees r unning from north
to south and forming the “neck,” as Strabo initially tells us? Or should the northern side
of Iberia appear as a straight line joining the Pyrenees, as per Strabo’s l ater and more
detailed description? Is his Libya (= Africa) trapezoid, as Strabo tells us at one point? Or
is it shaped like a right-angled triangle, as he tells us later? Does the eastern end of the
Himalayas represent the easternmost point of the lived-in world, as Strabo repeatedly
suggests? Or does the southern cape of India project even farther eastward, as many
modern scholars have shown it in their “maps” of Strabo’s lived-in world?
One can tie oneself in knots trying to reconcile all Strabo’s statements, but it is better
to accept that it is an impossible task. Sketching maps of individual regions based on
individual passages of Strabo’s narrative may be helpful, but amalgamating them into an
overall map of the “Strabonian world” risks misrepresenting what Strabo says in some
passages in order to preserve what he says in others. When all is said and done, there is a
reason Strabo presents the world in narrative form. The use of words allows him to pre-
serve a degree of ambiguity that would be impossible in a cartographic representation.
Strabo’s wordy narrative is sometimes seen as a dead end in terms of the evolution of an
accurate and precise depiction of the world but, in its very ambiguity, it accurately reflects
the unanswered questions and unresolved problems of ancient geography.
xxiii
Use This Translation in Conjunction With . . .
Just about every paragraph of Strabo’s work poses challenges. There may be questions
about the reliability of the medieval manuscripts, disputes concerning the technical terms
that Strabo uses, ongoing discussion about the identification of places that he names,
controversy over the meaning of unclear references he makes or ambiguous phrases he
employs, or disagreement over the values of metrological units. Firm dates concerning
the publication of the work and its composition are the subject of much debate, as are
the precise dates of Strabo’s life and travels. None of these problems need detract from
the enjoyment and use of Strabo’s work, but readers who want to delve into these issues
will benefit from using this translation in conjunction with:
R.J.A. Talbert, ed., Barrington Atlas of the Greek and Roman World (Princeton University
Press, 2000). Also available as an App for iPad. The Barrington Atlas (BA) allows read-
ers of Strabo to follow the quasi-itineraries underlying his accounts. (Strabo has not
visited all the places he describes but often writes as if mentally journeying through
them.) Users can zoom in on the particular map in which they are interested by using
the “locator” function in the BA App or by looking at the inside back cover of the
physical atlas.
The Map-by-Map Directory, in two volumes, accompanies the BA and is an es-
sential resource (annoyingly, often shelved separately from the main atlas in librar-
ies). The Map-by-Map Directory provides the present-day equivalents of the ancient
place-names shown on the BA maps, as well as extensive bibliographic references to
the scholarly literature on which the present-day equivalents are based. The Map-by-
Map Directory is available f ree online: http://assets.press.princeton.edu/B_ATLAS
/B_ATLAS.PDF.
While most places named by Strabo are shown on the BA maps, this is not the case
for all the names he gives. Furthermore, places may be shown on the BA maps under
slightly diff erent names than those used by Strabo. This is partly because the spelling
of place-names in antiquity was not standardized, and diff erent versions of the same
name abounded. It is partly b ecause the ancient Greek names used by Strabo have
to be transliterated into English. There are two main ways of doing this, which can
result in diff erent versions of the same Greek name—for example, “Cimmericum” and
“Kimmerikon.” In this translation, the former method is generally used, while on the
BA maps both methods are used, depending on the sources through which the name
has been transmitted to us.
xxv
Use This Translation in Conjunction With . . .
Present-day place-names used in this translation, like the ancient names, have in
many cases had to be transliterated into English from other modern languages, which
may use a diff erent script or special characters. This translation generally follows the
transliterations of present-day names found in the BA Map-by-Map Directory, which
may differ from those used in other publications. There is some inconsistency within
the Map-by-Map Directory, a collaborative work with many different contributors.
A present-day name may be given entirely in its local language (e.g., Golfo di Na-
poli, Map 44), or it may be partly rendered into E nglish (e.g., Gulf of Salerno, Map
45). These inconsistencies have been allowed to stand, to make it easier for readers
glancing at the Map-by-Map Directory as they read through this translation. These
inconsistencies highlight a problem that Strabo himself faced—namely, w hether to
transliterate foreign words for geographic al features or whether to translate them;
Strabo, too, is inconsistent in his practice.
The conventions in the entries for present-day names in the Map-by-Map Directory
include the use of abbreviations for directions (N, S, etc.) and for the word “Saint” in
various languages, and the use of a slash where more than one name needs to be given.
See the “Guidelines” (particularly p. vii for modern names and p. xxi for abbrevia-
tions) at the beginning of the Map-by-Map Directory. T hese conventions are generally
imported into the present-day identifications in this translation that are derived from
the Map-by-Map Directory.
The Map-by-Map Directory also gives the names of the present-day nation-states
in which the sites on each map are located (e.g., “All place names are in Egypt u nless
otherwise noted,” at the head of the directory for Map 76). In this translation, the
name of the relevant nation-state is provided in abbreviated form in parentheses im-
mediately a fter the present-day name. Some updating has been required in this re
spect; the Map-by-Map Directory was completed before the emergence of South Sudan
as an i ndependent state and before the fragmentation of the former Yugoslavia.
xxvi
Use This Translation in Conjunction With . . .
Stefan L. Radt, ed. and trans., Strabons Geographika (Vandenhoeck and Ruprecht, 2002–
11). This is the edition of Strabo’s work on which A Translation for the Modern World
is based and to which readers should refer for all discussion of textual issues. Four
volumes (1–4) contain the Greek text with accompanying German translation. They
are followed by four volumes (5–8) of German commentary. Two further volumes
provide the edited texts of abbreviated versions of Strabo’s narrative and a collection
of indexes, respectively. The commentary, while focusing on textual and grammati-
cal m
atters, provides context and background on a wide range of issues. The list of
abbreviations of cited literature at the beginning of the first volume of commentary
(vol. 5) serves as a useful bibliography.
Within Radt’s version of the Greek text, and within his accompanying German
translation, fragment numbers are given, as are the fragment collections in which
they appear, on each occasion (and there are many) that Strabo voices the opinion or
words of an earlier writer whose work has not survived into the twenty-first c entury.
Since t hese fragment numbers are not provided in A Translation for the Modern World,
readers should refer to Radt’s edition for this information.
Radt includes “C” numbers in the left-hand margin of his edition and in his r unning
heads. The “C” stands for “Casaubon,” and the numbers reflect the pagination of the
1620 edition of Strabo’s work by Isaac Casaubon. While these C numbers have always
been printed in editions of Strabo’s text (usually in the margins or as running heads),
Radt’s innovation was to count and number the lines of text within each C page. T hese
line numbers, along with the C numbers, are shown in the left-hand margin of Radt’s
edition. Radt’s enumeration of lines within C numbers, though a simple innovation,
has tremendous benefits. It allows a more precise way of referencing Strabo. It also
releases both editor and translator from the straitjacket imposed by the older system
of paragraph divisions, “die oft unbefriedigend oder geradezu irreführend ist” (“which
is often unsatisfactory or even misleading”) and, other than as a referencing system,
“spielen . . . keine Rolle mehr” (“plays no further role”) (vol. 1, p. xvi).
Duane Roller, A Historical and Topographical Guide to the Geography of Strabo (Cambridge
University Press, 2018). Roller’s Guide, published a few years after his 2014 transla-
tion of Strabo’s Geography, is designed to be “effective with any text or translation of
xxvii
Use This Translation in Conjunction With . . .
Strabo” (p. ix) and is immensely valuable to those readers wanting more historical and
archaeological background to Strabo’s narrative. Roller provides plentiful reference
to a vast array of articles and books, as well as information on the ancient literature to
which Strabo refers and the fragment collections in which references by Strabo and
others are collected. An interactive online map, produced by the Ancient World Map-
ping Center, accompanies the Guide: http://awmc.unc.edu/awmc/applications/strabo.
Roller structures his Guide exclusively around the older-style referencing system
(see “Looking Up an Older-Style Reference to Strabo’s Geography” in this translation).
In Strabo’s “Geography”: A Translation for the Modern World, t hese older-style references
are given in the right-hand margin to facilitate cross-referral to pre-Radt editions of
Strabo’s work. They also allow readers of this translation to cross-refer to Roller’s Guide.
Daniela Dueck, ed., The Routledge Companion to Strabo (Routledge), 2017. This is a wide-
ranging survey of scholarly work covering such topics as Strabo’s sources, worldview,
interest in specific areas, and use of mathematics. It also covers the fate of Strabo’s
work in the centuries after his death and includes discussion of Strabo’s other work
(a history, which has not survived to the present day). The Companion is a useful start-
ing point for t hose who wish to know more about any aspect of Strabo, since the
individual contributions come with ample reference to further scholarly literat ure,
usefully provided in a single bibliography.
xxviii
Special Features of This Translation
This translation aims to bring readers the big picture. It clarifies the overarching struc-
ture of Strabo’s narrative, identifies some of his writerly habits, and highlights some of
the themes that r ipple through his work. Context is all-important when consulting indi-
vidual parts of Strabo’s narrative. Readers interested in a single sentence or short passage
will benefit from taking into consideration its place within the overall scheme of the work.
This translation is designed to make that process as easy as possible.
Chapters
The chapters into which this translation is divided are not a feature of Strabo’s original
work. They have been introduced by the translator to help readers appreciate the over-
all structure of Strabo’s narrative and to enable them to access more easily the parts on
which they wish to focus without having to wade through irrelevant material. Their titles
and placement are suggested by Strabo’s own comments and cross-references, and they
thus reflect natural divisions within the work, even though they are extraneous to the
original narrative.
Strabo starts with an extremely long—some might say off-putting—discussion in
which he puts his work in the scholarly context of his time. This section (chapter 1) is of
great interest to specialists wanting to know more about the works from antiquity that
Strabo consulted, directly or via intermediaries. Most of these works have not survived
to the present day, but the next best t hing to having the works themselves is having
Strabo’s long and detailed analyses of the arguments presented within them. The attrac-
tion of this chapter for nonspecialists is less obvious. A cursory reading is nevertheless
recommended, since the chapter shows the sorts of questions intellectuals were asking
themselves in antiquity, even if the minutiae of the answers can be difficult to follow.
The short section that follows (chapter 2) is, in contrast, essential reading for all who
consult Strabo’s work. After all, the “lived-in world”—the concept defined and discussed
in this section—is what Strabo’s work is all about. Yet the concept of the “lived-in world”
(often translated as the “inhabited world”) is a difficult one for modern readers to grasp.
In this chapter, Strabo succinctly shows the preconceptions and scientific deductions
on which the concept is based. Readers will find that this chapter helps to clarify many
comments made by Strabo later in his work.
xxix
Special Features of This Translation
Following these two introductory chapters, the main body of Strabo’s narrative is
divided into three chapters that mirror Strabo’s division of the lived-in world into three
continents. Strabo deals first with Europe (chapter 3), which he divides into western
Europe and eastern E urope (parts 1 and 2). The allocation of individual areas to “west”
and “east” is a conceptual exercise as much as one based on physical reality. In this respect,
it is interesting to note that, for Strabo, Greece is part of eastern Europe. Since, however,
Strabo deals with Greece at such disproportionate length, it is given its own space in this
translation (part 3).
The next continent with which Strabo deals is Asia (chapter 4), which he divides into
northern Asia and southern Asia (parts 1 and 2). For Strabo, Roman Egypt (part of
present-day Egypt) and the people whom Strabo calls “Ethiopians” (southern Egypt, Sudan,
South Sudan, present-day Ethiopia, Eritrea, Djibouti, Somalia) are part of southern Asia
rather than part of Africa. With Egypt and the Ethiopians thus allocated, Strabo’s treat-
ment of the third and final continent, Africa (or, as Strabo calls it, “Libya”) is relatively
brief (chapter 5). This brevity partly reflects how little Strabo knows of Africa beyond its
Mediterranean coast. Perhaps, too, it reflects Strabo’s advanced age and failing concen-
tration as he approaches the end of his work.
Strabo’s closing discussion (Epilogue) is even terser than his account of Africa, occupy-
ing only a c ouple of pages. This final discussion is often overlooked by readers who have
forged their way through Strabo’s entire narrative, perhaps b ecause they are so relieved
to have reached the end of such a long work. This is a shame since the Epilogue is of far
greater relevance to historians than traditionally has been appreciated. It provides an
illuminating account of how the Roman empire was perceived in its own day, as opposed
to how it is perceived retrospectively by modern scholars. Conversely, readers who go
straight to this final section of the narrative without considering its relationship to the
body of Strabo’s work risk missing its nuances.
Subheadings
Within each chapter of this translation, subheadings have been introduced that, like the
chapter titles, are extraneous to the original narrative but are nevertheless warranted by
Strabo’s own comments and cross-references. In the two introductory chapters and in
the Epilogue, the subheadings reflect topics and ideas discussed by Strabo. In the chapters
covering E urope, Asia, and Libya (= Africa), the subheadings reflect the areas into which
Strabo subdivides the continents—for example, “Masylia + Carthage (e. Algeria, Tunisia,
Italian + Tunisian islands, w. present-day Libya).” As can be seen in this example, the names
of the areas outlined by Strabo are followed by their present-day equivalents, given in
italics, in parentheses.
xxx
Special Features of This Translation
All the chapter headings and subheadings are aggregated in “Navigating Strabo’s Geog-
raphy,” a detailed breakdown of contents, which immediately precedes the translation
of Strabo’s work. This detailed breakdown shows not only how Strabo divides his nar-
rative but also how he divides the world described within that narrative. The names and
descriptions used by Strabo are followed by the corresponding names from the present
day. An accompanying map shows the relevant parts of the modern world. Consequently,
“Navigating Strabo’s Geography” acts as a sort of index to the parts of the modern world
covered in Strabo’s work.
Maps
The modern-day areas covered within Strabo’s narrative are shown in the map of Strabo’s
“Lived-in World” that accompanies “Navigating Strabo’s Geography.” In addition, each
continental chapter is accompanied by a map, showing in modern terms the territorial
area covered by Strabo in that chapter. The accuracy of Strabo’s coverage is not consistent,
with his vision getting progressively more blurred as he moves farther north and west in
Europe, farther east in Asia, and farther south in Africa. T
hese maps do not by any means
represent Strabo’s ideas concerning the shapes of the landmasses he describes. Rather,
they allow readers to relate the ancient names used by Strabo to areas in the twenty-first-
century world. Readers interested in the history of a particular part of the present-day
world—say, Uzbekistan, Kyrgyzstan, or Tajikistan—can use the maps to access the rel-
evant part of Strabo’s narrative. The maps are designed solely to aid readers in this en-
deavor and are not intended, in any way, to express support for the political entities shown.
Translator’s Introductions
While the maps and the detailed breakdown of contents presented in “Navigating Strabo’s
Geography” help readers to orient themselves within the modern world, readers also need
help in orienting themselves within Strabo’s complex narrative. Assistance is provided by
the “Translator’s Introductions” at the start of each chapter, which are designed to draw
the reader into Strabo’s narrative. In the first two chapters and in the final Epilogue, the
introductions emphasize the relevance of these chapters to Strabo’s work as a whole.
In the chapters on E urope, Asia, and Libya (= Africa), the introductions explore the
xxxi
Special Features of This Translation
relevance of Strabo’s territorial divisions to the modern world and emphasize the par
ticular a ngle from which Strabo approaches his descriptions.
Paragraphs as we use them in the modern world were not part of the regular tool kit of
scribes in antiquity. Their use in Strabo’s original (and now lost) manuscript would have
been l imited. Because modern readers are accustomed to having written works divided
into manageable units, Strabo’s work is split into paragraphs in this translation. Each
paragraph is given an identifier in the left-hand margin, which provides a means of citing
Strabo’s “Geography”: A Translation for the Modern World (see “How to Cite This Transla-
tion”). Since t hese identifiers consist of the line numbers provided in Radt’s 2002–11
edition of the Greek text on which this translation is based (see entry for Stefan L. Radt
in “Use This Translation in Conjunction With . . .”), they additionally provide a means
for specialists to cross-refer to the Greek text of Strabo’s work.
While the paragraph identifiers in the left-hand margin provide a means of citing this
translation, the numbers in the right-hand margin represent an older-style referencing
system, corresponding to the paragraphs into which scholars gradually divided Strabo’s
Greek text in the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries (see “Looking Up an Older-Style
Reference to Strabo’s Geography”). Since t hese paragraphs w ere often excessively long,
they have been superseded in this translation as a way of sectioning the narrative. Nev-
ertheless, these older-style reference numbers are provided alongside the translation to
aid readers who wish to consult pre-Radt editions of the Greek text or to compare this
translation to e arlier translations, or who have been given a reference of this older type
that they wish to follow up.
Margin Notes
The margins, as well as housing paragraph identifiers and older-style references, con-
vey information that helps readers to understand Strabo’s narrative at a glance, with-
out having to refer to a separate commentary or atlas. This information is distributed
xxxii
Special Features of This Translation
etween the left-hand and right-hand margins as follows (except where space on the page
b
is l imited, and information may bleed from one margin to the other).
Left-Hand Margin
The left-hand margin is used to identify the general area under discussion, along with
its present-day equivalent, written in italics—for example, “BRETTIA s. Italy.” The
present-day equivalents are usually given in terms of nation-states, although islands and
large peninsulas are often named separately from the nation-state to which they belong
(e.g., Sicily is differentiated from mainland Italy), as this provides a more meaningful
way of locating places mentioned by Strabo.
The left-hand margin is additionally used to provide the names and dates of the
many historians, philosophers, and poets with whom Strabo engages—for example,
“Eratosthenes (3rd c. BCE).” The c entury within which the scholar or poet was active
is given, rather than dates of birth and death, which are rarely known with precision.
The presentation of this information is intended to help modern readers appreciate
just how far back into his own past Strabo is reaching when citing t hese earlier scholars
and poets.
Strabo’s attitude t oward the scholars with whom he engages is often one of criticism.
He has a particular fondness for pointing out logical flaws or inconsistencies in their
thought processes. In cases where Strabo’s arguments are excessively convoluted, the
main point he is making may be indicated in the left-hand margin. Much work remains
to be done in clarifying the complexities of Strabo’s systems of argumentation and how
they might affect our interpretation of the various statements attributed by Strabo to
earlier scholars.
Right-Hand Margin
The right-hand margin is used for giving the present-day equivalent of individual geo
graphical features—cities, towns, harbors, headlands, straits, and rivers—named by
Strabo. The Strabonian name is followed by the present-day equivalent in italics and,
in parentheses, the abbreviated form of the nation-state in which it is located—for ex-
ample, “Nysa, Sultanhisar (Tky.).” In some cases, to make it easier for modern scholars
to locate features mentioned by Strabo, the name of an island is given in preference to
the nation-state to which the island belongs—for example, “Pelorias, Capo Peloro (Sic.).”
In the case of rivers, straits, and headlands, the present-day equivalent name is given
without reference to a nation-state, since many rivers flow through multiple states, and
straits and headlands frequently mark boundaries between states.
The present-day equivalents given in this translation are based largely on the Map-
by-Map Directory that accompanies the Barrington Atlas of the Greek and Roman World and
generally follow the style and conventions of the entries in the Directory. It is helpful to
have this Directory to hand when reading through Strabo’s narrative, since it lists the
xxxiii
Special Features of This Translation
scholarly literat ure supporting the identifications made. The Pleiades database is useful
for more up-to-date literature. Where sites mentioned by Strabo lie outside the geo
graphical area covered by the Barrington Atlas, the present-day names given in the right-
hand margins are taken from e ither Radt’s commentary or Pleiades. (All these resources
are listed in greater detail in “Use This Translation in Conjunction With . . .”). Where a
present-day equivalent has not been identified or is very contentious, it is simply omitted
from this translation.
Some place-names crop up time and time again throughout Strabo’s narrative because
he uses them as reference markers rather than—or as well as—places of interest in their
own right: for example, “Pillars of Heracles, Straits of Gibraltar.” Sometimes, identifica-
tion of these geographical markers depends on context. For example, what Strabo refers
to as “our sea” strictly comprises what we think of as three separate seas: the Mediterra-
nean Sea, the Black Sea, and the Sea of Azov. However, in contexts where Strabo locates a
Mediterranean city on the coast of “our sea,” it is more meaningful for the modern reader
simply to have “our sea” identified as the Mediterranean.
The right-hand margin is also used where Strabo’s engagement with an earlier scholar
extends over many pages. In the process, Strabo frequently refers to his would-be inter-
locutor simply as “he.” Readers consulting only a few lines of Strabo’s narrative will need
help in identifying who “he” is, so the referent is identified in the right-hand margin.
Things can get very complicated when Strabo engages with two or more writers simul
taneously, differentiating between them by referring to one as “that fellow” and the other
as “this fellow.” The probable referents are given in the right-hand margin, but some of
these identifications are contentious. This is another area where much scholarly work
remains to be done if we are to appreciate properly the statements that Strabo attributes
to the various writers he compares and contrasts.
Also noted in the right-hand margin are some of the weights and m easures used
by Strabo. These units of measurement are defined by reference to the ancient met-
rological systems to which they belong. For example, “1 cubit = 1.5 (Greek) ft.” The
exact value in modern terms of the Greek foot and units based on it is a vexed issue, so
no attempt has been made to convert these m easurements into the imperial or metric
systems.
It is often just as important to know where units stand in ancient metrological sys-
tems (e.g., whether they are the largest units or the smallest ones) as to know their exact
value in either ancient or modern terms. In many Strabonian contexts, knowing that
a “talent” consists of six thousand drachmas is probably less useful than knowing that
it is the largest unit in the ancient Greek accounting system. As such, it is often used
where we might say “thousands of pounds” or “thousands of dollars.” The marginal
notes on weights and measures therefore sometimes include their position within the
ancient systems.
xxxiv
Special Features of This Translation
Strabo often engages with e arlier scholars by entering into a sort of imaginary debate with
them. In these quasi debates, Strabo may represent the views of the scholar concerned
by using a grammatical device that school textbooks call “reported speech” or “indirect
speech”—a misnomer as far as Strabo’s practice is concerned, because he is generally pre-
senting the written word. Strabo’s use of this grammatical device can extend over many
pages, a fact that is obvious in the Greek but easily lost in E nglish translation. Italics are
used in this translation to indicate when Strabo is engaging with an earlier scholar in this
way. The use of italics is particularly important for readers consulting only a few lines of
Strabo’s narrative, who otherwise might miss the fact that the information in question is
put into the mouth of an earlier writer.
Strabo’s borrowings from earlier scholars are without doubt far more extensive than
his use of reported speech suggests. The italics do not therefore represent the totality
of Strabo’s borrowing from a given author. Rather, they reflect the texture of Strabo’s
narrative as he hops from one grammatical structure to another, from explicitly engag-
ing with an e arlier writer to providing information whose provenance is not specified.
Interestingly, historical or geographic al errors occasionally occur in t hose passages of
reported speech, raising the possibility not only that the error was made by the writer
with whom Strabo engages but that the existence of the error is precisely the point that
Strabo is making.
The obvious solution to questions concerning the extent and veracity of Strabo’s repre
sentations would be to check Strabo’s words against the works of the writers with whom he
engages. This is rarely feasible, as most of those works have not survived to the present day.
On the few occasions when a work is still available to us, we can see that Strabo’s represen
tation of the writer’s words is often quite loose. Similarly, when Strabo repeatedly refers to
a particular thought or statement in the work of a writer now lost, he may represent that
same original statement slightly differently on diff erent occasions, showing that he freely
adapts the words of others to fit in with the flow of his own narrative.
In the light of all these considerations, the passages in italics should not be understood
as “fragments” in the slightly bizarre sense in which the word is used by specialists, who
treat such passages as stand-ins for the words of writers whose works are now lost. They
are, rather, fragments of Strabo, and are highlighted in this translation to show that he is
engaging in an argument that requires representation of the views of an e arlier scholar.
These passages can get very complicated. Sometimes, Strabo writes in the voice of an
earlier writer who is, in turn, writing in the voice of a yet e arlier writer. It can be chal-
lenging to attempt to peel back the various layers of onion skin to find out which writer
said what. In t hese cases, the w
hole passage is represented in italics, and the further layers
xxxv
Special Features of This Translation
of engagement within it are contained within quotation marks, but there often remains
some uncertainty as to exactly who said exactly what.
Sometimes it is hard for modern readers to understand what Strabo is saying without extra
help. For example, where Strabo plays on the literal meaning of a name, the modern reader
needs to be told what that meaning is. To address this issue, in this translation the meaning
is inserted in parentheses after the name in question and is differentiated from Strabo’s own
words by its typography, appearing in italics and in a different font: for example, “Aphrodite
‘Apaturus’ (Trickster).” In this instance, the insertion of the literal meaning of the name helps
readers to appreciate the relevance of the story that follows, about how the goddess tricked
the Giants who wanted to kill her and how she ended up killing them instead.
Sometimes, Strabo omits words, expecting those in his audience to use their own
mental faculties to remedy the omissions. This was a common practice in ancient Greek,
but it can make life difficult for modern readers, whose m ental faculties are differently
attuned. In this translation, the omitted words are added into the narrative but placed
within square brackets and set in italics and a different font. One typical instance where a
word is added is when Strabo gives distances without specifying the unit of measurement,
as in, for example, “some forty-five thousand [stades] from the Rhodian Peraea.” Strabo’s
references to “the burnt,” “the temperate,” and “the frozen” can be bewildering to the
modern reader. In this translation, the omitted word is supplied: “burnt [zone],” “temper-
ate [zone],” and “frozen [zone].”
Footnotes
The footnotes accompanying this translation stress the coherence of Strabo’s narrative.
They clarify the backward and forward references Strabo makes, sometimes explicitly,
often implicitly. These implicit references are easily overlooked, especially where they
relate to passages appearing many pages e arlier or l ater. For example, Strabo is fond of
announcing his intention to discuss what “remains” of an area, implicitly referring to
definitions made at the outset of his descriptions of each continent or particular geo
graphical areas within each continent, or even at the outset of his overall work.
Also highlighted in the footnotes are references Strabo makes to his own presence in
some (though not many) of the places he describes. As well as these explicit references,
there are numerous passages where Strabo uses words such as “seeing” or “sight,” which
xxxvi
Special Features of This Translation
seem to refer to his own experience, and he occasionally playfully alludes to the meaning
of his own name, which is “cross-eyed” in both Latin and Greek.
Strabo has other writerly habits to which attention is drawn in the footnotes. He
continually corrects himself as he proceeds through his work, refining and clarifying
statements made e arlier. T hese corrections are sometimes treated by modern scholars
as “inconsistencies,” a term predicated on the assumption that Strabo’s overall narrative
reflects his views at a single moment in time. However, since these inconsistencies are
often improvements on, or additions to, e arlier statements, it is likely that Strabo was
updating his views in real time as he wrote (or dictated or lectured).
Strabo transliterates, and occasionally translates, Latin names into Greek. He also
enjoys playing around with language more broadly. For example, he toys with the ambi-
guities brought about by grammatical inflection. He argues that a promontory in what
is now western Turkey should be called Aiga rather than Aix—the latter of which, in the
inflected form required by his sentence structure, is also written as Aiga! These effects
are difficult to replicate in translation, but attention is drawn to them in the footnotes.
References in the footnotes to e arlier or later sections of Strabo’s narrative are made by
means of the paragraph identifiers provided in the left-hand margin of this translation.
A reference such as “8 C, 26–9 C, 7n” is to both the relevant paragraph and the footnote
accompanying it.
xxxvii
Special Features of This Translation
Idiosyncrasies
very translation has its quirks, and Strabo’s “Geography”: A Translation for the Modern
E
World is no exception, starting with the subtitle. Strabo stresses that his job is to de-
scribe the world as it is, even though he reaches far back into the past in order to do so.
This translation picks up the ball and runs with it, relating the world of the twenty-first
century to the ancient world. The subtitle, A Translation for the Modern World, indicates
both what this translation hopes to achieve and how that ambition relates to Strabo’s own.
The Greek word oikoumene is an important one for Strabo, as it is the subject of his en-
tire work. Traditionally rendered as the “inhabited world” or sometimes even the “known
world,” in this translation it is rendered as the “lived-in world.” The Greek verb from
which oikoumene is derived means not only “to inhabit” but “to manage productively,” as
in the case of a household or state. It is, in fact, the word from which our word “econom-
ics” is partially derived. The traditional rendition of oikoumene as “inhabited world” is too
passive. The term “lived-in world” better reflects an entity that is, at least in part, the
production and creation of the p eople who live in it.
The Greek word ethnos is, in this translation, rendered as “nation.” It is intended in the
sense in which the early inhabitants of Canada are referred to as the “First Nations” or the
sense in which Scotland is a nation. The traditional rendition of ethnos as “tribe” is mis-
leading in its overtones of primitiveness. The situation is similar with regard to barbaroi,
which is traditionally rendered as “barbarians” but is usually rendered in this translation
as “natives.” Strabo states that, for him, barbaroi are non-Greeks (662 C, 6-19) which,
in the context of Strabo’s work, generally means the p eople who occupied a given area
before the Greeks or Romans arrived. Hence, “natives” seems a more apt translation.
Occasionally, Strabo does use barbaroi in a pejorative sense. When this is the case, the
translation “barbarians” is sometimes used.
In describing cities, Strabo tends to use words often applied to w omen (such as
“adorn”), with the consequence that cities are not only grammatically feminine but often
metaphorically so as well. Accordingly, in this translation, the Greek feminine pronoun
used in relation to cities is often translated as the English feminine pronoun “she.”
One of the problems in translating from ancient Greek to English is that, in the Greek
language, word order is flexible. In any given sentence, the object of an active verb can
precede the verb, and the subject can follow it. This word order is commonly used by
Strabo. It is often best represented in English by converting the active verb into the
passive. This means that the object can still precede the verb, and the subject can still
follow it, which is particularly important where the subject is further qualified by a long
description. This strategy is often employed in this translation to preserve the balance
of Strabo’s sentences.
xxxviii
A User’s Guide
To cite a paragraph from this translation, use the identifier provided in the left-hand
margin—for example, “291 C, 17-22.” Broken down into its constituent elements, this
identifier refers to lines 17 to 22 of C page 291. The paragraph that comes next in this
translation is 291 C, 23–292 C, 10. To cite the content of both paragraphs, amalgamate
them as follows: 291 C, 17–292 C, 10. This method of citation is used in the footnotes; for
forward and backward references within the translation; in “A Directory for the Modern
Reader,” at the end of the translation; and in the indexes.
The line numbers within each C page are derived from Radt’s edition of Strabo’s Greek
text (see entry for Stefan L. Radt in “Use This Translation in Conjunction With . . .”).
The identifiers thus facilitate cross-reference between Radt’s edition of the Greek text
and this translation of it.
Some readers will approach this translation armed with a reference of the “7.1.4” type.
They should look for this older-style reference in the right-hand margin. The first digit in
this reference indicates the book number. A book, in this context, is one of the seventeen
units of narrative into which Strabo’s work was divided in antiquity. These units, appar-
ently originating with Strabo himself, probably reflect the number of papyrus rolls his
narrative occupied. The second and third digits give the section and paragraph numbers,
according to a system gradually imposed on the Greek text by scholars, largely through
the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries. Thus, “7.1.4” is the fourth paragraph of the first
section of the seventh book.
7.1.4-type references are given in this translation to facilitate cross-referral with pre-
Radt editions of Strabo’s Greek text and with e arlier translations of Strabo’s work in which
this referencing system was used. The end of each 7.1.4-type paragraph is marked in this
translation with a vertical bar: “|” Readers will see that these vertical bars do not necessarily
coincide with paragraph breaks in Strabo’s “Geography”: A Translation for the Modern World,
which is why t hese older-style references are not a suitable way of citing this translation.
xxxix
A User’s Guide
Strabo’s narrative does not always flow smoothly in the Greek language in which it is writ-
ten. In some places, a word or phrase needs to be imagined for the sentence to make sense.
Perhaps Strabo’s mind momentarily wandered, or perhaps Strabo was using a scribe who
accidentally missed a word during dictation. Perhaps, in l ater ages, a copyist overlooked
a word as he transcribed Strabo’s narrative from one papyrus roll or manuscript page
to another. In this translation, places where a word or phrase needs to be imagined are
marked thus: . . . *.
In other instances so marked, a word or phrase included in Strabo’s narrative has
been omitted because it appears not to make sense. Again, the error may have been
Strabo’s own, or that of his scribe or a later copyist losing concentration. Some instances
of “ . . . *,” rather than suggesting an omission or error in the narrative, may rather
represent a gap in our understanding of it. Strabo may be making a point or a joke that
eludes us, or he may be inexpertly working into his narrative a quotation from an e arlier
writer, or he may simply be expressing himself in an unusual or clumsy manner.
Identification of omissions and errors is to some extent subjective. Since Strabo’s
“Geography”: A Translation for the Modern World is based on the edition of the Greek text
by Radt (see entry for Stefan L. Radt in “Use This Translation in Conjunction With . . .”),
instances of “ . . . *” in this translation reflect words or passages identified by Radt as
problematic. For more detailed information, specialists should refer to Radt’s analysis
at the foot of each page of his Greek text or to the separate volumes of commentary that
accompany his edition.
xl
The Greek Stade as Used by Strabo
Many of the stade figures given by Strabo are estimates. Converting them
into modern units does not alter the fact that the figures thus achieved
remain estimates. This can be difficult to remember when the conversion
yields an apparently precise figure such as 462.5.
STRABO’S
GEOGRAPHY
G Denmark
re
at
Ne
th
nd
erl
and Poland
la
Brit
s
Ir e
Germany
ain
Belgium
Luxembourg Czech Rep. Ukraine
akia M
Slov ol Russia
France tria do n
Switzerland Aus Hungary va sta
ia kh
ven Romania a
Slo Croatia Crimea az
K
Se
Bosnia-
rb
Herzegovina
ia
Uzb
Ita gro Bulgaria
eki Kyrgyzstan
ly tene osovo Georgia sta
Corsica Mon K North n
Macedonia
Albania Armenia Azerbaijan
Spain Sardinia Turkmenistan
Greece Tajikistan
Turkey China
Sicily
Portugal
Cyprus Syria
Tunisia Crete Afghanistan
Lebanon
Iraq Iran
Morocco Israel
n
da
Pakistan
Jor
Kuwait
Nepal
Algeria Bhutan
Western Libya
Sahara Egypt Qatar
United Bangladesh
Arab
Saudi Arabia Emirates
India
an
Mauritania
Om
Mali
Niger
Chad
Eritrea en
Sudan Yem
Djibouti
South Ethiopia
Sri Lanka
lia
Sudan
ma
So
Translator’s Introduction 9
Describing the World 13
Geography as Philosophy 13
Homer (8th c. BCE): The First Geographer 13
Prerequisites for Geography 19
Practical Applications of Geography 20
Basic Assumptions 24
Purpose of Strabo’s Work 26
Strabo’s Own Contribution 26
The Problem of Sources 28
Eratosthenes (3rd c. BCE) 28
Hipparchus (2nd c. BCE) and Eratosthenes (3rd c. BCE) 83
Posidonius (late 2nd–1st c. BCE) 112
Polybius (2nd c. BCE) 123
3
Breakdown of the Geography
Part 3. Greece
Translator’s Introduction 393
Greece 397
The Peloponnese (s. Greece) 400
First Band: Megaris + Attica (s. cen. Greece) 460
Second Band: Boeotia (s. cen. Greece) 470
4
Breakdown of the Geography
5
Breakdown of the Geography
6
TRANSL AT I O N O F
STRABO’S
GEOGRAPHY
CH APT E R O N E Geography and Geographers
Translator’s Introduction
Readers of the twenty-first c entury who are interested in what Strabo has to say about
past conceptions of present-day regions such as Sudan or Tajikistan or Ukraine w ill be
amply rewarded in the later pages of Strabo’s work but will find little of obvious and im-
mediate interest in this first chapter. Strabo is intent in this opening section of his work
on justifying his choice of geography as a topic worthy of study. While passionately inter-
ested in his subject matter, he is nevertheless—like many an enthusiast since—strangely
inarticulate when it comes to explaining why others should find it valuable. When he
claims that the Persians, if they had studied geography, would not have panicked during
their attempted invasion of Greece and mistakenly supposed that the strait between the
island of Boeotia and the Greek mainland was a dead end, he seems to be scraping the
barrel. Possibly Strabo is not being entirely serious.
The issue is that Strabo is forced to defend the study of an essentially scientific subject
to an audience whose own education will have been largely literary. Strabo’s solution is
to stake a claim to Homer, the creator of the epic poems known as the Odyssey and Iliad,
whose study was an integral part of the ancient literary curriculum. Strabo makes the
case that, since Homer makes sweeping geographical references, one cannot properly ap-
preciate Homer’s poetry without a concomitant understanding of geography. More than
that, he argues that Homer’s own words, properly interpreted, can themselves be used as
geographical evidence. This proviso—that Homer’s words need proper interpretation—
connects the study of geography with the literary work of the Homeric commentators.
The gap between literature and science is partially bridged.
Strabo f aces a further problem, with which many a twenty-first-century geographer will
sympathize. Having defended the study of science versus literat ure, Strabo has to defend
the study of geography against the study of the pure sciences such as astronomy, physics,
and mathematics. He tries to give these scientific subjects due weight as providing useful
foundational material, but pure sciences are clearly not Strabo’s forte. Strabo does not always
seem fully to grasp the scientific concepts he presents, and his repeated statements that not
too much time should be spent on the scientific underpinnings of geography often seem
self-serving. His true strength lies in his intense curiosity about the human activities and
organizations that have influenced and continue to influence the world as he knows it. It is
this human factor that dominates the body of Strabo’s work (chapters 3–5 in this translation).
9
1. Geography and Geographers
It is by no means obvious that Strabo was successful in walking the fine line between
literature and science on the one hand and the even finer line between pure science and
geography on the other hand. As far as we can tell, Strabo’s geographical work found
little f avor immediately after his death. Then again, the evidence for this view is based
largely on the fact that few authors appear to have cited Strabo by name in the decades
following the completion of his work. Much of Strabo’s work may have entered the col-
lective subconscious as “common sense,” and it may not have been deemed necessary to
cite him by name, any more than we cite Copernicus when we say that the earth travels
around the sun.
In looking at how Strabo defends his choice of subject matter, it should be noted
that he is sometimes amazingly petty when it comes to his criticism of earlier scholars.
He takes aim not only at the findings and writings of o thers but at their personal cir-
cumstances, in ways that can only be described as vicious. Most famously, he lambasts
Pytheas, an explorer of the fourth c entury BCE, who, as far as we can tell, successfully
sailed around Britain, discovered another island that was almost certainly Iceland, and
sailed along the coast of northwestern E urope, perhaps into the Baltic Sea. Pytheas’s
discoveries should have opened Strabo’s mind. Paradoxically, b ecause those discoveries
did not fit Strabo’s preconceptions, they served to close it further.
The treatment of Pytheas, while particularly vituperative, is part of a larger process
in which Strabo engages with earlier writers as if having a conversation with them, even
though they lived and worked centuries before him. In the twenty-first c entury, when the
instantaneousness of communication is prioritized, it is interesting to see that a coun-
terbalancing virtue of the written word is its survival across hundreds of years. Homer’s
poetry, so important to Strabo, had been written down at least seven centuries before
Strabo reads and comments on it. Even some of the more recent writers with whom
Strabo engages w ere at work a century or more before his time. By virtue of their written
works, however, scholars from the long-ago past can communicate with Strabo, just as
Strabo through his work can communicate with us across a space of two millennia. It is
easy to overlook the sheer miracle of this achievement.
In his quasi conversations with e arlier writers, Strabo sometimes writes in the voice of
his interlocutors. Italics are used in this translation to indicate that Strabo is indulging in
such role-playing. The italics do not necessarily mean that Strabo is quoting the precise
words of the e arlier writers with whom he engages. In all probability, the italicized words
are neither reported precisely nor even remembered very clearly. In addition, Strabo
adapts them to the sentence structure of his narrative and sometimes twists them in order
to make it easier for him to win the imaginary argument he is having with the scholar who
wrote them. Theoretically, we could test the accuracy or otherwise with which Strabo de-
picts t hese words by comparing Strabo’s rendition of them with the words as they appear
in the works on which he draws. Regrettably, with the exception of Homer’s poems, few
of the major works with which Strabo engages (at least, not the parts of them in which
10
Translator’s Introduction
Remember
11
CH APT E R O N E Geography and Geographers
Geography as Philosophy
1 C, 1–2 C, 3 I believe that if anything is part of the p
hilosopher’s mandate 1.1.1
the claims made above—in the first place, that I and t hose be-
fore me (including Hipparchus)4 have correctly understood
Homer (8th c. BCE) Homer to be the originator of geographical empiricism.5 He
is superior to all others, both from antiquity and later, not
only in his supreme poetic skill but almost as much in his ex-
perience of political life, as a result of which he concerned
13
1. Geography and Geographers
himself not only with events (so that he might learn as many
as possible and transmit that knowledge to posterity) but also
with information about places, both individually and relative
to the entire lived-in world1 and its sea. If it were otherwise,
he would not have arrived at the farthest limits of the world,
traveling all around it in his narrative! |
2 C, 21-33 First, Homer stated that the world is bounded by the 1.1.3
ocean on all sides, as indeed it is. Then he mentioned some ocean = Atlantic Ocean + Indian
Ocean + (supposed) northern
Strabo argues that Homer localities by name, while hinting at o thers by means of cer- ocean
(8th c. BCE) refers to the ocean
in the south, west, and east. tain clues. He explicitly refers to Libya and Ethiopia, and to
Sidonians and Erembians (by which, it is reasonable to suppose,
he means the Trogodyte Arabs). He hints at places being in
the east or west, with the statement that they are bounded
by the ocean, from which he represents the sun as rising and
into which he represents the sun as setting (likewise with the
Citation of Homer (8th c. BCE) stars). Then the sun shot its new rays over the fields, / as it rose from
gently flowing, deep-streamed Ocean; and into Ocean fell the bright
orb of the sun, / drawing behind it black night. He describes the
stars as having bathed in Ocean. |
2 C, 34–3 C, 12 Homer points to the blessings enjoyed by those in the 1.1.4
islands of the Blessed lie out to sea off the westernmost part
of Maurusia (at the point where the end of Iberia also tapers
in the same place). From their name, it is clear that people
considered these islands to be “Blessed” because of their
proximity to such places.2 |
3 C, 13-19 Furthermore, he makes it clear that the Ethiopians at the he = Homer 1.1.6
Homeric references to ocean edge of the ocean are the most remote of people. He makes it
in south
clear that they are the most remote with the words Ethiopians,
split into two groups, remotest of men (where split into two groups is
14
Homer: The First Geographer
15
1. Geography and Geographers
Homer considers the world to ocean in a different way, when Hera says the following: I will
be surrounded by the ocean
go to see the limits of the bountiful earth / and Ocean, begetter of gods.
He means that the ocean is contiguous with all the limits, and
the limits form a circle. In the Making of Weapons,1 he puts the
ocean all around the rim of Achilles’s shield.
4 C, 21-28 Characteristic of this same m ental disposition is the fact
that he does not lack knowledge 2 of matters associated with he = Homer
the ocean’s high tides and low tides, referring to refluent Ocean
and saying that thrice a day she spews it forth, and thrice she sucks she = Charybdis (from Homer’s
Odyssey)
it back. If it be not thrice but twice (perhaps his information
is wrong or the text is corrupt), his meaning is nevertheless
as stated. The phrase from gently flowing [Ocean] 3 contains some
suggestion of the rising tide, the encroachment of which is
gentle and not totally overwhelming.
4 C, 28-34 Posidonius conjectures, from the statement that “the rocks are
Posidonius (late 2nd–1st c. BCE) sometimes covered and sometimes laid bare” and from the fact that he he = Homer
comments on Homer (8th c. BCE)
calls Ocean a “river,” that the current associated with the rising tide
is meant. He is correct in regard to the former but lacks reason He = Posidonius
[ 1 ] The “title” Making of Weapons refers to a part of Homer’s Iliad. Strabo often
uses “titles” for parts of Homer’s poems, most frequently for the part of the
Iliad known as the Catalogue [of Ships] or simply Ships: cf. 442 C, 35–443 C, 9n.
Other “titles”: 17 C, 22-27n; 244 C, 7-15n; 394 C, 15-28n; 432 C, 10-22n; 439 C, 5-14n.
Strabo also uses “titles” for parts of his own works and parts of the works of
others: 639 C, 15-27n.
[ 2 ] For the charge that Homer lacked knowledge: 27 C, 1–47 C, 8.
[ 3 ] The Homeric passage to which Strabo here refers is cited more fully at 2 C, 21-33.
[ 4 ] The Homeric passage to which Strabo h ere refers is cited more fully at 4 C,
34–5 C, 9.
16
Homer: The First Geographer
if you interpret it in any other way, he left Ocean and came to interpret it in any other
way = than Crates does
Ocean!
5 C, 12-22 While the foregoing requires more attention, | the fact 1.1.8
Empirical observation supports that the lived-in world is an island is to be grasped in the first
Homer’s view that the lived-in
world is surrounded by ocean place on the basis of sense perception and practical experi-
ence: in every direction in which man has been able to pro-
ceed to the farthermost parts of the earth, the sea that we
call “ocean” is encountered. What it is not possible to grasp ocean = Atlantic Ocean + Indian
Ocean + (mistakenly) Caspian
through sense perception, deduction proves: the eastern (In- Sea
dian) and the western (Iberian and Maurusian) sides are cir-
cumnavigable . . . * for a large part of both the southern and
northern parts. The section that so far remains unnavigated
by us (because those circumnavigating from different direc-
tions have not met up with each other) is not very g reat, if one
reckons from the parallel distances attained by us.
5 C, 22-31 Nor is it likely that the Atlantic sea is a “double sea” in that Atlantic sea = Atlantic
Ocean + Indian Ocean +
Strabo dismisses possible it is split in two by isthmuses so narrow, preventing circum- (mistakenly) Caspian Sea
existence of isthmuses north
and south of the lived-in world navigation; it is more likely that the sea is confluent and con-
tinuous. T hose who attempted circumnavigation, but then circumnavigation = of the
lived-in world
had to turn back, do not say that they w ere forced to retreat
because of any mainland standing in their way and preventing
their onward voyage, but rather through lack of provisions
and through desolation, even though the sea itself offered
passage. This view is also more consistent with the behavior
of the ocean as manifested in the ebb and flow of the tides. In
all places, the manner of change, of increase and decrease, is
the same or not very diff erent, as if the movement is produced
by one sea and derived from a single cause. |
5 C, 32–6 C, 4 Hipparchus is not credible in objecting to this opin- ocean = Atlantic Ocean + Indian 1.1.9
Ocean + (mistakenly) Caspian
Hipparchus (2nd c. BCE) cites ion on the grounds that the ocean does not behave in the same way Sea
Seleucus (2nd c. BCE)
everywhere—and, even w ere this to be granted, the continuous cir-
cularity of the entire Atlantic sea does not follow from it. He uses
Seleucus the Babylonian as his source for its lack of consistent
behavior.
6 C, 4-9 For further discussion on the ocean and the high tides, I
Posidonius (late 2nd–1st c. BCE) defer to Posidonius and Athenodorus and their thoroughly
Athenodorus (1st c. BCE– adequate treatment of the arguments concerning these
early 1st c. CE), Strabo’s
contemporary matters. For the present, I go so far as to say that it is better
to follow this belief in view of consistency of behavior; and the
greater the amount of surrounding water, the more strongly
17
1. Geography and Geographers
poet = Homer (8th c. BCE) remote and what encircles the lived-in world, and he does the
Homer is aware of the “inner same for the inner sea. Encircling this sea, if you start at the inner sea = Med. Sea + Black
sea” as well as the ocean Sea + Sea of Azov
Pillars, are Libya, Egypt, and Phoenicia; what comes next is the
Pillars, Straits of Gibraltar
land around Cyprus, then the Solymians, Lycians, and Carians;
after t hese is the coastline that stretches between Mycale
and the Troad, and the islands lying offshore. He mentions
all t hese, and also the regions associated with the Propontis,
with the Euxine as far as Colchis, and with Jason’s campaign.
6 C, 16-23 Furthermore, he knows of the Cimmerian Bosporus— he = Homer
Homer (8th c. BCE) since he knows of the Cimmerians. It is not the case that he Cimmerian Bosporus, Straits
of Kerch'
knows the name Cimmerians but lacks knowledge1 of the people
themselves, who, in his time or a little before his time, over-
ran all the land from the Bosporus as far as Ionia! At any rate,
he hints at the clima of their territory, at its gloominess, in clima, latitude
saying they are shrouded in mist and cloud, nor does the bright sun
/ ever shine upon them . . . / but deadly night spreads over them . . .
6 C, 24-29 He knows of the Ister, since he mentions the Mysians, a He = Homer
Thracian nation that lives along the banks of the Ister. He Ister, Danube r.
knows, too, of the coastline that comes next, which is Thra-
cian as far as the Peneius, since he mentions by name the Paeo-
nians, Athos, the Axius, and the islands lying off these. Next
is the Greek shoreline as far as the Thesprotians. All this he
mentions.
6 C, 29-31 Furthermore, he knows about the end point of Italy—
mentioning by name Temesa and the Sicilians—as well as
the end point of Iberia and the natural blessings that I just
mentioned.2
6 C, 31–7 C, 7 If some gaps appear in between, one should be forgiving:
in reality, he who describes the world passes over many de-
tails. One should also be forgiving if he adds a mythical ele
ment to what he says that is historical and instructive. T here
Eratosthenes (3rd c. BCE) is no need of criticism. What Eratosthenes says—every poet
aims to cause delight, not to be instructive—is not true. On the
contrary, the wisest of those who have something to say about
poetry claim that poetry is a sort of elementary philosophy. I
will respond to Eratosthenes later, with further argumenta-
poet = Homer (8th c. BCE) tion (in which the poet will again be discussed).3 | For now, let 1.1.11
18
Prerequisites for Geography
Hipparchus (2nd c. BCE) is a prerequisite for this endeavor. Hipparchus, too, teaches
criticizes Eratosthenes (3rd c.
BCE)
us in his Response to Eratosthenes, that it is impossible for anyone,
whether commoner or intellectual, to attain proper geographic al
knowledge without taking into account observations of celestial bodies
and eclipses. For example, it is not possible to grasp w
hether Egyptian
farther north = on a more Alexandria is farther north than Babylon or farther south, nor by
northerly parallel
how much, without consideration of the climata. Similarly, one would climata, geographical
farther south = on a more coordinates; in particular, lines
southerly parallel not be able to tell more or less how far east or west of each other they of latitude
are, other than by comparing eclipses of the sun and moon.
7 C, 23–8 C, 1 This is what he says, | and everyone who undertakes the he = Hipparchus 1.1.13
the sun and the other stars (and, furthermore, the tendency tendency t oward the
center = earth’s gravity
toward the center), forces us to look up to the heavens and
[ 1 ] 2 C, 11–6 C, 31.
[ 2 ] In this section (7 C, 7–8 C, 22; cf. 11 C, 23–13 C, 14), Strabo previews ideas later
treated at greater length: 109 C, 12–136 C, 12 (= chap. 2). Cf. 48 C, 29–49 C, 9;
62 C, 18–65 C, 12.
[ 3 ] Strabo clarifies his opening statement (1 C, 1–2 C, 3n), where he might seem to
imply that Eratosthenes includes Homer among the first geographers. Eratos-
thenes has a guarded opinion of Homer, believing that poets in general “talk
drivel”: 15 C, 1–47 C, 8.
19
1. Geography and Geographers
20
Practical Applications of Geography
21
1. Geography and Geographers
22
Practical Applications of Geography
23
1. Geography and Geographers
Basic Assumptions
11 C, 23-32 Most of all, as noted, it seems that geometry and astronomy 1.1.20
the earth, and (prior to t hese) the tendency of bodies toward tendency of bodies t oward the
center = earth’s gravity
the center, adding, if anything, only a few summary remarks
on whether something is perceived by the senses or mentally
derived from general concepts.
11 C, 32–12 C, 2 For example, that the earth is spheroid is suggested in ab-
stract terms from the tendency t oward the center and from
the tendency of each body toward its own central point, but
it is suggested in more concrete terms by the phenomena as-
sociated with the oceans and the heavens. Perception by the
senses, as well as m ental deduction from general concepts, is
capable of testifying to it.
12 C, 2-9 The curvature of the sea obviously obstructs the view of
Observations leading to belief sailors so that it is not possible to see lights in the far distance,
in sphericity of the earth
even when the lights are raised as high as the viewing eye. The
lights become visible when raised higher than the viewing eye,
even if they are farther away from it; likewise, when the view-
ing eye is raised to a higher level, it sees what was previously
concealed. (Even the poet showed this, for such is the mean- poet = Homer
Citation of Homer (8th c. BCE) ing of seeing very clearly as he was raised up by a g reat wave.) Also,
as sailors approach land, the regions by the shore become
progressively more visible, and areas that initially appeared
low-lying get higher.
12 C, 9-13 The revolution of celestial bodies is clear from several
considerations but particularly from observations of the gnomon, rod placed vertically
on the earth’s surface to cast a
gnomon.2 From these, the idea, too, immediately arises that, shadow
24
Basic Assumptions
[ 1 ] Strabo probably refers forward to his own discussion: 131 C, 26–135 C, 22. Strabo
often uses “titles” to refer to parts of works: 639 C, 15-27n.
[ 2 ] The plural “arctic circles” is used because the celestial arctic circle varies in dia
meter depending on the location of the observer. For the “arctic circle”: 3 C,
20-36nn.
25
1. Geography and Geographers
13 C, 11-14 In this way, even those who have produced works called
Harbors and Coastal Voyages render their descriptions incom-
plete by not adding what is relevant from science and the
study of the heavens. |
at the politician and useful for the p eople, in the same way as
the writing of history. In the latter case, I mean by “politician”
someone who is not totally uneducated but who has partici-
pated in the educational curriculum customary for free men
and philosophers, since the man who has not concerned him-
self with ethical virtue and practical wisdom, and the argu-
ments for these, would not be able properly to blame, praise,
or judge events that are worth recording. |
13 C, 22-29 For this reason, since I have already produced some his- 1.1.23
26
Strabo’s Own Contribution
large part of Asia and all the northern parts of Europe as far
as the Ister. The Romans revealed to us all the western parts
of Europe as far as the Elbe river, which divides Germany
in two, and the parts beyond the Ister as far as the Tyras Ister, Danube r.
river.2 The parts beyond that, as far as the Maeotians and Tyras, Dniester r.
[ 1 ] I.e., geographers of Strabo’s day have benefited from the continued expansion
of the Roman and Parthian empires, just as geographers of the late 4th and
3rd centuries BCE benefited from the campaigns of Alexander the G reat (latter
4th c. BCE). Eratosthenes’s comments, of course, refer only to the geographers
in the wake of Alexander the Great.
[ 2 ] Western Europe: see chap. 3.1. Area between the Rhine and the Elbe, and
area “beyond the Ister (north of Danube) as far as Tyras r. (Dniester)”: 290 C,
1–306 C, 21.
[ 3 ] Parts beyond “as far as the Maeotians”: 306 C, 21–312 C, 28. Coastline ending
with Colchis: 492 C, 20–499 C, 13.
[ 4 ] 506 C, 33–520 C, 21.
[ 5 ] Eratosthenes (3rd c. BCE) and Hipparchus (2nd c. BCE): 15 C, 1–94 C, 20. Posido-
nius (late 2nd–1st c. BCE) and Polybius (2nd c. BCE): 94 C, 21–109 C, 11.
27
1. Geography and Geographers
28
Eratosthenes (3rd c. BCE)
wise man is a poet. This is the reason Greek cities in the first
instance educate their c hildren by means of poetry, not pre-
sumably for the sake of mere enjoyment but for the sake of
imposing moral discipline. It is why even musicians, when
teaching stringed instruments and how to play the lyre and
flute, lay claim to this virtue: for they are, they say, educators
and builders of character.
16 C, 3-12 It is possible to learn this not only from what the Pythag-
Aristoxenus (4th c. BCE) oreans say. Aristoxenus made the same statements. Homer,
Homer (8th c. BCE) too, says that bards impose moral discipline, like Clytaemes-
tra’s guardian, on whom the heavy duty was laid / by the son of
Atreus when he left for Troy, to guard his wife; and that Aegisthus
did not seduce Clytaemestra until, taking the bard to a deserted
island, / he left him there; / and took her, who was as willing as he
was, to his h ouse.
16 C, 13-22 Quite apart from this, Eratosthenes contradicts him-
self. Shortly before the said declaration,1 at the start of his
Strabo points out that treatment of geography, he says that all strive to publicize their all = all poets
Eratosthenes recognizes
Homer’s geographical abilities knowledge about such m atters. Homer sets down in his poetry what he
learned about the Ethiopians and about places in Egypt and Libya;
as for places in Greece and nearby regions, he goes into even too much
detail (describing Thisbe as “dove-rich,” Haliartus as “grassy,” An-
thedon as “farthermost,” and Lilaea as “at Cephissus’s source”), and
utters not one epithet in vain.
16 C, 22-27 Does the creator of these descriptions seem like some- creator of these
descriptions = Homer
Strabo introduces an imaginary one who causes delight, or more like someone who provides
interlocutor, who concedes an
element of instruction in poetry
instruction?
“Well, by Zeus, he does make these statements, but he he = Homer
and others fill out what is beyond observation with stories of
mythical wonders.”
Then what he should have said is that every poet composes he = Eratosthenes
some elements only for the sake of causing delight but some elements
for the sake of instruction, but what he said was that [every poet
composes] for the sake of delight alone, not for the sake of instruction.
[ 1 ] I.e., Eratosthenes’s declaration that every poet aims to cause delight, not to be
instructive.
29
1. Geography and Geographers
Hipparchus (2nd c. BCE) Hipparchus, one w ere to make an Attican “eiresione” responsible
for apples and pears1 (which it cannot grow), in the same way
making that fellow the source of all knowledge and e very skill. that fellow = Homer
learned their mind. This man knows all sorts of tricks and many
cunning devices. This man is always called the sacker of cities and
the man who took Troy through counsel, through words, through
skill in deceit. Diomedes says, with this man as my companion, even
out of a burning fire, / we would both return.
17 C, 16-21 He is proud of his competence in agriculture, both in reap- He = Odysseus
ing (in the grass might I have a well-bent sickle, / and might you
have the same) and in plowing (then you might see me, if I cut an
unbroken furrow before me). |
17 C, 22-27 Oratorical skill is having a way with words, something Od- 1.2.5
forth from his breast his g reat voice / and words like winter snow-
flakes, / then no other mortal could compete with Odysseus.
17 C, 28-40 It cannot be that, on the one hand, Homer displays such
wisdom and that, on the other hand, educated men do not all
poet = Homer (8th c. BCE) use the poet as a source when he is correct in his statement
that such practical experience tends toward wisdom. Who,
then, would assume that the poet—who portrays other men
as having rhetorical and military skills and as displaying the
other accomplishments of excellence—is himself one of those
drivelers and showmen, a man capable only of beguiling and flat-
tering his listener, not of benefiting him? Would we describe
the excellence of a poet as anything other than the art of imitat-
ing life through composition? How would he “imitate life” if he
30
Eratosthenes (3rd c. BCE)
Strabo introduces an imaginary man who totally ignores us. What is more important to ora-
interlocutor who objects that
poetry is different from other
tory than style? What is so important to poetry as style? Who
skills is better than Homer at style?
“Yes, but poetic style is diff erent.”
Certainly it is in type, just as, within poetic style, there is
a tragic style as well as a comic style, and within prose style,
there is a historical style as well as a legal style. For surely
speech is generic, while verse and prose are types within it.
Or is speech generic, but not oratorical speech, nor style, nor
excellence in composition?
18 C, 5-13 In short, prose (at least when polished) is an imitation
of polished poetry. In the very first place, polished poetry
emerged and won approval. Then, works w ere composed in
imitation of it by those associated with Cadmus, Pherecydes,
and Hecataeus,1 who did away with meter but retained other
poetic elements. Then those who came later, continually de-
priving it of such elements, reduced it as if from a sublime
height to its current form, just as one might say that com-
edy has a form that has been brought down from tragedy
and tragedy’s sublime height into what is now called the
“vernacular.”
18 C, 13-23 The use of “to sing” rather than “to say” among the an-
cients is evidence of this same fact, that poetry was the well-
spring and start of a polished and rhetorical style. Poetry
made additional use of melody in p erformances. This was
the ode (song)—a composition set to a melody—as a result of
which people talked about “rhapsody” (recital of song), “tragedy”
(tragic song), and “comedy” (comic song). In consequence, when “to
say” was used at the very beginning in the case of poetic style,
and poetic style made use of song, “to sing” and “to say” w ere
the same t hing for p eople. When p eople used the former even
in the case of prose composition, its use shaded into the lat-
ter. The very fact that a composition without meter is called
31
1. Geography and Geographers
32
Eratosthenes (3rd c. BCE)
33
1. Geography and Geographers
Citation of Homer (8th c. BCE) he told many lies that were close to the truth—not all but many,
otherwise they would not have been close to the truth.
20 C, 23-33 He therefore started with historical tradition. People say He = Homer
that Aeolus ruled over the islands associated with Lipara; that
the islands associated with Etna and Leontina were ruled by
the Cyclopes and the Laestrygonians, inhospitable people,
which is why the area around the Strait was inaccessible to Strait, Straits of Messina
to Aea, of the myths and facts told about Circe and Medea in
connection with their knowledge of poison and their similar-
ity of character in other respects, he concocted a fictional kin- he = Homer
ship between t hese two w omen (living so far apart, one in the
innermost recess of the Pontus, the other in Italy!) and sub- Pontus, Black Sea
oceanization = literary transfer jected them to “oceanization”—and perhaps Jason did wander
to Atlantic of events that took
place in Med. Sea/Black Sea as far as Italy, given that certain indications of the wanderings
of the Argonauts are identified in the region of the Ceraunian Ceraunian mts., range incl.
Cikes mt. (Alb.)
Adria, Adriatic Sea mountains and the Adria, in the Posidonian bay and the is-
lands off Tyrrhenia. Posidonian bay, Gulf of Salerno
21 C, 8-10 A further factor was added by the Cyaneae,1 which they call
the “Symplegades” (Clashing [rocks])—certain rocks that make
rough g oing of the passage through the Byzantine mouth. Byzantine mouth = Bosporus
(Tky.)
21 C, 10-13 In consequence, Aeaea appeared plausible b ecause of Aea;
the Planctae (Wandering [rocks]) and the voyage between them ap-
peared plausible b ecause of the Symplegades; the voyage be-
tween the cliffs appeared plausible b ecause of Scyllaeum and
Charybdis.
21 C, 13-19 Simply put, men of those times thought of the Pontic Pontic sea, Black Sea
sea as like another ocean; and they thought that those who
voyaged thither had traveled as far as those who sailed a long beyond the Pillars = along the
way out beyond the Pillars. It was believed to be the largest of Atlantic coast
[ 1 ] Cyaneae = rocky islets at the northern end of the Bosporus (Tky.): 319 C, 26-31.
34
Eratosthenes (3rd c. BCE)
our seas, which was why people called it by the proper name our seas = Med. Sea + Black
Sea + Sea of Azov
“Pontus” (= Sea), just as they called Homer “the poet.” Per-
haps, then, this was also the reason he transferred events from
the Pontus to the ocean, b ecause prevailing opinion made it
easy to accept.
21 C, 19-28 I suppose that, since the Solymians inhabited the highest
peaks of the Taurus in the vicinity of Lycia stretching as far as
Pisidia, and since they represented the most famous southern
extremes for t hose within the Taurus and especially for those Pontus, Black Sea
oceanized = metaphorically in the vicinity of the Pontus, he “oceanized” t hese p eople, too, he = Homer
transferred to supposed
southern ocean because of a certain degree of congruence. He says of him, him = Odysseus
sailing on his raft, that the lord, the Earthshaker, on his way from Earthshaker = Posidon
the Ethiopians, / saw him from afar, from the mountains of the Soly-
mians. Perhaps, too, he borrowed the one-eyed Cyclopes from
Scythian history: people say that the Arimaspians—whom
Aristeas (7th c. BCE) Aristeas of Proconnesus publicized in his Arimaspian Epic—
are men such as t hese. |
21 C, 29–22 C, 3 Now that I have made these introductory remarks,1 I must 1.2.11
and of various others, not only in the vicinity of Italy but even
as far as the remotest parts of Iberia.
22 C, 3-12 The bad way is if a person were to take the embellishment
as historical fact—whereas Ocean, Hades, the cattle of He-
lius, hospitality by goddesses, shape changes, g iant Cyclopes
and Laestrygonians, Scylla’s shape, sailing distances, and
various other such things are clearly the product of marvel-
mongering. It is not worth contradicting this person, when
poet = Homer (8th c. BCE) he is so clearly falsely accusing the poet (just as it is not worth
it, if he w
ere to deny that Odysseus’s voyage home to Ithaca,
the murder of the suitors, and the Ithacans’ battle with him
in the countryside happened in this way). Nor is it justifiable
to argue with the person who understands things in a fitting
way. |
[ 1 ] 15 C, 26–21 C, 28.
[ 2 ] A statement attributed by Strabo to Polybius: 25 C, 4-10; 26 C, 15-24.
35
1. Geography and Geographers
22 C, 13-17 Eratosthenes incorrectly takes issue with both these con- 1.2.12
wanderings are of the latter type and that those who claim that Pelorias, Capo Peloro (Sic.)
they are not fictitious but that they are identifiable are proven wrong Sirenussae, Punta della
Campanella (It.)
from the very fact that they cannot agree. At any rate, some of them
Cumaean bay, Golfo di Napoli
locate the Sirens on Pelorias, others locate them on Sirenussae, more (It.)
than two thousand stades away. Sirenussae is a triple-peaked crag Posidonian bay, Gulf of Salerno
that separates the Cumaean and the Posidonian bays. (It.)
22 C, 25-31 However, this crag does not have three peaks nor, in fact,
Strabo accuses Eratosthenes of any high peak at all. Rather, it juts out as a sort of elbow-
misdescribing Sirenussae
shaped promontory, long and narrow, from the Surrentum Surrentum, Sorrento (It.)
area to the strait at Capriae, having on one side of its ridge Capriae, Capri (It. island)
the t emple to the Sirens and on the other side, the side t oward
the Posidonian bay, three little islands lying offshore, unin-
habited and rocky, which people call the “Sirens”; and on the Sirens, Li Galli (It. islands)
strait itself is the Athenaeum (temple to Athena), with which the Athenaeum
(promontory) = Sirenussae,
elbow-shaped promontory itself is homonymous.1 | Punta della Campanella (It.)
22 C, 32–23 C, 10 Even if those who hand down the tradition of historical 1.2.13
Strabo argues that research into places do not agree with each other, it is not
disagreement among sources
does not necessarily undermine necessary immediately to jettison the research in its entirety.
their credibility Sometimes, the general point is all the more to be believed,
as I say. If the question is w hether the wanderings took place
in Sicily and Italy and w hether the Sirens are placed some-
where t here, the man who places them on Pelorias disagrees Pelorias, Capo Peloro (Sic.)
with the man who places them on Sirenussae, but neither Sirenussae, Punta della
Campanella (It.)
one disagrees with the man who places them in the vicinity
of Sicily and Italy; in fact, they provide extra credibility in
that, although they do not each give the same place, they have
nevertheless not gone beyond the region of Italy and Sicily.
If someone adds that in Neapolis a memorial to Parthenope Neapolis, Napoli/Naples (It.)
36
Eratosthenes (3rd c. BCE)
Strabo points out that connection with Odysseus’s wanderings that they took place in Sicily
Eratosthenes is inconsistent in
his treatment of Hesiod (late
and Italy, trusting in this view, mentions not only places named by
8th–7th c. BCE) and Homer Homer but also Etna, Ortygia (the l ittle island off Syracuse), and
the Tyrrhenians, but Homer does not know these places, nor does he
want to set the wanderings in places that are familiar. W ere Etna
and Tyrrhenia familiar—but not Scyllaeum, Charybdis, Cir-
caeum, and Sirenussae? Was it appropriate that Hesiod did
not talk drivel but rather followed prevailing opinion, but that
Homer yelled out whatever random utterance came to his tongue?
Quite apart from what has been said about the type of myth-
making appropriate for Homer, the large number of writers
who chatter about t hese t hings and the store of local lore con-
cerning t hese places allow us to learn that t hese t hings are
not the fictions of poets and writers but are evidence for real
people and events. |
23 C, 28–24 C, 4 Polybius has the right ideas about the wanderings. He says 1.2.15
Polybius (2nd c. BCE) that Aeolus, who predicted when to make the voyage through the re-
gion of the Strait, which was tidal and difficult to sail through on ac- Strait, Straits of Messina
count of the changing tide, was called the “steward of the winds” and
considered to be king, just like Danaus (who pointed out the w ater
supply in Argos) and Atreus (who pointed out that the sun moved
in a direction opposite to that of the heavens); men who w ere seers
and diviners were appointed kings; and Egyptian priests, Chaldae-
ans, and Magi, who excelled other men in a certain type of wisdom,
had leadership and status bestowed on them by men from before our
times. So, too, each of the gods is honored as being the discoverer of
something useful.
24 C, 4-12 Having established t hese principles, he allows us to take as he = Polybius
[ 1 ] The bay is called “Crater” in Strabo’s day: 242 C, 15-21. Eratosthenes’s use of the
name Cumaean bay: 22 C, 17-25.
37
1. Geography and Geographers
region by the poet and by other writers who narrate local lore con- poet = Homer
cerning Italy and Sicily. Nor does he have any praise, he says,
for Eratosthenes’s statement that “you will discover the scene of the
wanderings of Odysseus when you find the leatherworker who sewed
up the sack of the winds.”
24 C, 13-25 The following lines concerning Scylla—“there, she fishes around
the cliff, eagerly seeking / dolphins and dogfish and, if she can, larger
/ sea creatures”—are appropriately spoken in connection with Scyl-
laeum and the catching of the “galeotae.” Tuna fish move along the galeotae, swordfish
Italian shore in schools, and when trapped and prevented from reach-
ing Sicily, they fall victim to larger creatures like “dolphins, dogfish,
and other sea creatures”; from preying on them, the “galeotae”—
which, he says, are also called “swordfish” and “dogfish”—grow fat.
The same phenomenon occurs here—and also when the Nile and other
rivers flood—as occurs in the case of conflagrations and forest fires:
animals gather together and flee from the flames (or w ater) and be-
come food for larger animals. |
24 C, 26–25 C, 3 In making t hese statements, he describes the capture of he = Polybius 1.2.16
laeum, and from the fact that what is said about Charybdis is similar
[ 1 ] 21 C, 29–22 C, 3n.
38
Eratosthenes (3rd c. BCE)
to the phenomenon at the Strait (the statement that “thrice [a day] Strait, Straits of Messina
if we assume the voyage was made over the nine days at a consistent Pillars, Straits of Gibraltar
speed, the distance sailed each day would be two thousand five hun-
dred stades. Who has recorded that anyone arrived in Alexandria
from Lycia or Rhodes—a distance of four thousand stades—on only
the second day?
25 C, 29-32 In response to those who demand how it is that Odysseus
comes to Sicily three times, yet does not once sail through
the Strait, he replies that even men of l ater times all avoided this Strait, Straits of Messina
voyage. |
25 C, 33–26 C, 15 The foregoing is what he says.3 In the main, what he he = Polybius 1.2.18
says is correct, but when he undercuts the oceanization ar- oceanization = literary transfer
to the Atlantic of events that
gument and reduces a voyage expressed in days to precise took place on the Med. Sea/
measurements and distances, he is extremely inconsistent. Black Sea
poet = Homer (8th c. BCE) On the one hand, he cites the poet’s words (for nine days I
traveled thence, blown by baneful winds); on the other hand, he
draws a veil over them. The line after the ship had left behind
the stream of river Ocean; the line on the island of Ogygia, which
is the navel of the sea (and the statement that the daughter of
39
1. Geography and Geographers
Atlas lives there); and the lines about the Phaeacians (we live
far away, on the billowing sea, / remotest of people; no other mortal
visits us)—all t hese are clear evidence of fictional placement in
the Atlantic. He, however, in drawing a veil over them, does
away with clear evidence.
26 C, 15-24 So, then, the preceding argument is not valid, but his
statement that the wanderings occurred in the vicinity of Sicily and
Italy1 is correct and is confirmed by . . . *. What poet or writer
persuaded the Neapolitans to name a memorial in honor
of Parthenope the Siren, or the inhabitants of Cumae, Di-
caearchia, and Vesuvius to speak of “Pyriphlegethon,” “lake
Acherusia,” the “oracle of the dead in Aornus,” and “Baius”
and “Misenus” (companions of Odysseus)? And similarly, in
the region of Sirenussae and the Strait, “Scylla,” “Charybdis,”
and “Aeolus”? It is necessary neither to analyze them precisely
nor yet to pass over them on the basis that they have no roots
or foundation, no element of truth nor any historical utility. |
26 C, 25-31 Eratosthenes himself senses this, one might suppose, 1.2.19
poet = Homer (8th c. BCE) when he says that the poet intends to set the wanderings of Odys-
seus in western locations but deviates from his plan, partly because his
knowledge is inaccurate and partly b ecause his priority is not to do so
but rather to represent details with a view to what is more inspiring
and marvelous, correctly understanding the fact but not the
reason he does it: he does it not for the sake of drivel but for he = Homer
as also for the statement that faraway places are depicted as more
marvelous because they are easier to fictionalize. For the marvels
told of faraway places are a tiny fraction of those set in Greece
and near Greece: for example, mythical events to do with the
labors of Heracles and Theseus, and t hose set in Crete, Sicily,
and other islands, and t hose associated with Cithaeron, Heli-
con, Parnassus, Pelium, all of Attica, and the Peloponnese.
27 C, 1-6 Nobody charges creators of myths with lack of knowledge 2
on the basis of the myths. Furthermore—since they do not
mythologize everything but (especially Homer) only add
various mythical elements—the person who inquires as to
which mythical element the ancients add, does not inquire
whether the mythical elements existed (or exist) but rather
seeks the truth about the places and p eople to which the
40
Eratosthenes (3rd c. BCE)
Citations of Homer (8th c. BCE) places are Greek or faraway. They strove to pile Ossa on Olympus
and, on Ossa, / Pelium of the trembling leaves; and Hera, swooping
down from the peak of Olympus / and coming to Pieria and lovely
Emathia, / sped over the snowy mountains of the horse-loving Thra-
cians . . . from Athos to the sea. In the Catalogue,1 he does not
name the cities in sequence (since it is not necessary), but he
does name the nations in sequence. Likewise, in the case of
faraway places: having traveled to Cyprus, Phoenicia, and Egypt, /
I reached the Ethiopians, Sidonians, Erembians, / and Libya (lines
Hipparchus (2nd c. BCE) to which Hipparchus, too, makes reference).
27 C, 27-35 They, in cases where sequence is necessary (one describing They = Euripides + Sophocles
Dionysus visiting the nations, the other describing Triptol- one = Euripides
emus traveling over the seed-sown earth), put places that are other = Sophocles
far apart close together and tear apart places that are next
Citation of Euripides’s to each other: traveling from the gold-rich lands of Lydians / and
description of Dionysus’s travels
(5th c. BCE)
Phrygians, to the sun-baked plains of Persians, / walled Bactrian
cities, the wintry land / of Medes, and Blessed Arabia. (Triptol-
emus does much the same.)
27 C, 36–28 C, 11 In the matter of climata and the winds, too, Homer illustrates climata, geographical
coordinates
the breadth of his geographical knowledge, since his topographi-
cal descriptions include these matters in many instances. It, It = island of Ithaca (Odysseus’s
home)
Citations of Homer (8th c. BCE) low-lying, lies highest up in the sea / t oward the misty gloom; the o thers
are far away toward the daylight and the sun. And . . . there are two
gates, / one to the north . . . / one to the south. And whether they go to
the right, t oward the daylight and the sun, / or to the left, t oward the
misty gloom . . . Indeed, he considers lack of such knowledge as
a state of total confusion: my friends, we know not where is the misty
gloom, nor where is the daylight, / nor where is the sun.2
41
1. Geography and Geographers
28 C, 12-24 In the passage where the poet correctly says Boreas and Boreas, north wind
poet = Homer (8th c. BCE) Zephyrus, which blow from Thrace, he does not understand it he = Eratosthenes
the fellow = Homer correctly in falsely alleging that the fellow makes a general state- Zephyrus, west wind
ment that “Zephyrus blows from Thrace,” when the fellow is not
making a general statement but is referring to the winds’ conver-
gence in the Melas gulf area of the Thracian sea, which is itself
part of the Aegaean sea. Thrace curves southward to form a
peninsula where it borders on Macedonia. Since it protrudes
into the sea, it makes it seem to people on Thasos, Lemnos,
Imbros, Samothrace, and on the sea around them, that the
Zephyri blow from t here, just as in Attica, they appear to blow Zephyri, west winds
from the west and from Iberia, and since Thrace does not extend that
far!
28 C, 27-30 Is he r eally “unaware that Zephyrus blows from the west”? he = Homer
After all, he preserves the appropriate order when he says Eurus, east wind
the following: Eurus, Notus, stormy Zephyrus, / and Boreas Notus, south wind
28 C, 31-36 Is he really “unaware that Thrace does not jut out beyond he = Homer
Citation of Homer (8th c. BCE) him, as when he says: the assembly rippled like the high waves of
the sea, / the Icarian sea. |
29 C, 3-10 There are some who say that there are two chief winds— Boreas, north wind 1.2.21
Schema of winds “Boreas” and “Notus”—and that the other winds diverge Notus, south wind
from them only slightly, “Eurus” blowing from the direction Eurus, northeast wind
of the summer sunrise, “Apeliotes” from the direction of the Apeliotes, southeast wind
winter sunrise, “Zephyrus” from the direction of summer Zephyrus, northwest wind
sunset, and “Argestes” from the direction of winter sunset. Argestes, southwest wind
42
Eratosthenes (3rd c. BCE)
Thrasyalces (?5th c. BCE) They cite, as sources for t here being only two winds, Thrasy-
poet = Homer (8th c. BCE) alces and the poet, b ecause of his combination of “Argestes”
with “Notus” (Argestes Notus) and “Zephyrus” with “Boreas”
(Boreas and Zephyrus, which blow from Thrace).
29 C, 10-16 Posidonius says that no one who is an expert in t hese m
atters— Caecias, northeast wind
Posidonius (late 2nd–1st c. BCE) such as Aristotle, Timosthenes, and Bion the astronomer—says that Lips, southwest wind
cites Aristotle (4th c. BCE),
Timosthenes (3rd c. BCE), and
the winds are so, but rather that the wind from the direction of the Eurus, southeast wind
Bion (?ca. 300 BCE) summer sunrise is “Caecias” and the wind diametrically opposite, Argestes, northwest wind
Posidonius revises schema of blowing from the direction of the winter sunset, is “Lips”; further- Apeliotes, east wind
winds
more, the wind blowing from the direction of the winter sunrise is Zephyrus, west wind
“Eurus,” the opposite one is “Argestes”; in between are “Apeliotes”
and “Zephyrus.”
29 C, 16-25 The poet means by “stormy Zephyrus” what we call Argestes; stormy Zephyrus/Argestes,
northwest wind
poet = Homer (8th c. BCE) by “clear-blowing Zephyrus” what we call Zephyrus; by “Argestes
(Brightening) Notus” what we call Leuconotus. The last produces clear-blowing Zephyrus, west
wind
few clouds, whereas Notus in the main is somewhat cloudy:
as when Zephyrus drives away the clouds / of Argestes Notus, blasting Argestes Notus/Leuconotus,
south-southwest wind
them with a deep windstorm. He means here stormy Zephyrus,
which usually scatters the wispy clouds gathered by Leucono-
tus (Notus h ere being qualified as “Argestes Notus”).
29 C, 26-27 These t hings, said at the beginning of the first of the geo
graphical [volumes],1 are subject to the foregoing revisions.2 |
29 C, 27-30 Sticking with these false assumptions about Homer, he he = Eratosthenes 1.2.22
Eratosthenes notes Homer says the following: he does not know that the mouths of the Nile
(8th c. BCE) does not mention
the number of mouths of Nile are several in number nor even know of the name “Nile” itself, but
Hesiod does (since he mentions it). Hesiod (late 8th–7th c. BCE)
43
1. Geography and Geographers
the outer sea, and the Ethiopians split into two groups but did
not mention places nearby and well known.
30 C, 5-8 That he did not mention these t hings is not evidence that
he did not have knowledge of them (since he did not mention his
own fatherland nor many other things). Rather, it is evidence
for his belief that well-known facts are not worth mentioning
to p eople who know of them. |
30 C, 9-22 People are incorrect in reproaching him for the statement him = Homer 1.2.23
concerning the island of Pharus, that it is (he says) in the open Pharus, island joined by a mole
to Alexandria (Iskandariya. Egy.)
sea, as if he is speaking through lack of knowledge. One might on in Strabo’s day
the contrary use this as evidence for the claim that nothing
of what has just been mentioned in connection with Egypt1
poet = Homer (8th c. BCE) was unknown to the poet. You might reason as follows. Every
man is boastful when describing his own travels. This includes
Menelaus, who, having sailed upstream as far as the Ethio-
pians, learned of the Nile’s floods, the amount of sediment
the river deposits on the land, and the extent to which it had
already silted up the seaway at its mouths and added them to
the mainland. (In consequence, the w hole of Egypt is justi-
Herodotus (5th c. BCE) fiably called by Herodotus a gift of the river—and, if not the
whole of it, at least the territory below the Delta, called the
“Lower Territory.”) He learned that Pharus was in the open sea
in antiquity. He added the fiction of it being in the open sea,
even though it no longer was. The poet was responsible for
perpetuating this, with the consequence that we can surmise
that he knew about the Nile’s floodings and mouths. |
30 C, 23-31 The same error is made concerning his not knowing of the isthmus, Isthmus of Suez (Egy.) 1.2.24
isthmus between the Egyptian sea and the Arabian gulf, and Egyptian sea, Med. Sea
concerning his fictitious description of the “Ethiopians, split Arabian gulf, Red Sea
into two groups, remotest of men.” Rather, while that fellow that fellow = Homer
est of all, there is a difference of opinion about the following where Hyperion goes
down = west
Aristarchus (late 3rd–2nd c. BCE) line—Aristarchus writing, some [living] where Hyperion goes down,
Crates (2nd c. BCE) some [living] where he goes up; and Crates writing, where Hyperion where Hyperion goes up = east
[ 1 ] 29 C, 27–30 C, 5.
[ 2 ] Strabo proceeds (30 C, 31–35 C, 29) to develop his idea that Homer, although
not explicitly referring to the “isthmus” (Isthmus of Suez), nevertheless knows
of it.
44
Eratosthenes (3rd c. BCE)
tenets, says that the burnt zone is occupied by the ocean, while the
temperate [zone]—both our temperate [zone] and the [temperate zone] in
the other part—is either side of it. Just as our Ethiopians are said to other part = southern
hemisphere
be t hose in the south, the “remotest of men” in the w hole of the lived-
in world in that they dwell along the ocean coast, in the same way
Crates argues for existence he thinks it is necessary to imagine Ethiopians on the far side of the
of people in the southern
hemisphere
ocean, who are the “remotest of men” in the other temperate [zone] and
who dwell along the coast of the same ocean. They are twofold and
“split into two groups” by the ocean.
31 C, 10-15 The line “where Hyperion goes down and up” is added because,
since the zodiac is always overhead the terrestrial zodiac, and since
the latter does not extend beyond the territory of both groups of Ethio-
pians in its oblique motion, it is necessary for all the sun’s path to be
imagined within this breadth, and for its “going down” and its “going
up” 1 to occur there differently for diff erent p eople, within various zo-
diacal signs.
31 C, 15-21 He said the foregoing, being rather astronomically He = Crates
Crates (2nd c. BCE) is perhaps not relevant to the present discussion. As for
[ 1 ] Crates uses the sun’s “going down” and “going up” to refer to the annual pas-
sage of the sun—i.e., from the winter tropic “up” to the summer tropic, then
“down” from the summer tropic to the winter tropic.
[ 2 ] Strabo perhaps understands Crates as referring to the sun’s daily motion—i.e.,
“going up,” or rising, in the east; “going down,” or setting, in the west. Similar
confusion: 830 C, 1-27.
[ 3 ] About the Catalogue of Ships was a commentary by Apollodorus on the part
of Homer’s Iliad that was traditionally referred to by the “title” Catalogue of
Ships. Cf. 4 C, 14-20n.
45
1. Geography and Geographers
Aristarchus (late 3rd–2nd c. BCE) Aristarchus, while I commend him for rejecting the Cratesian
hypothesis (open to many objections) and believing that the
description applies only to our Ethiopia, let me analyze his
other points. First, the fact that his micro-emendation of the his = Aristarchus’s
ans next to Egypt when he talks of the Ethiopians, split into two
groups. What then? Are they not thus split into two groups? Or
does the poet describe them in this way out of ignorance? Is
not Egypt, are not the Egyptians from the Delta to Syene, split
into two groups by the Nile, some [living] where Hyperion goes down,
some [living] where he goes up? What is Egypt, if not the river-land
that gets flooded by the river’s water? This land lies on either
side of the river, t oward sunup and sundown.
32 C, 11-16 Ethiopia is a continuum of Egypt and similar in regard to
the Nile and other aspects of its topography. It, too, is nar-
row, elongated, and subject to flooding; of the areas outside
the flood zone—empty, waterless, and able to support only a
few settlements—some are to the east and some to the west.
How, then, is it not also split into two?
32 C, 16-20 Or did it seem to those people who divide Asia from Libya
that the Nile was a worthy boundary since it stretches length-
wise for more than ten thousand stades to the south and is
wide enough to include islands populated by thousands of
people, the largest island being Meroe, the Ethiopian royal Meroe island = region along
Nile between Atbara r. and
residence and metropolis—but was the Nile not good enough Blue Nile/Bahr el Azraq
to split into two Ethiopia itself ?
32 C, 20-25 Furthermore, critics of those people who use rivers to di-
vide the continents cite the following as the most important
of the allegations against t hese p eople: they tear Egypt and
Ethiopia apart and create for each of them a Libyan section
and an Asian section; or, if this is not what they want to do,
then they do not divide the continents, at least not by means
of the river. | river = Nile
from this. All those who sailed on the ocean along the
46
Eratosthenes (3rd c. BCE)
coast of Libya—both those who started from the Erythra and Libya = Africa
those who started from the Pillars—proceeded a certain dis- Erythra, Red Sea
tance and then turned back, prevented from going on by nu- Pillars, Straits of Gibraltar
merous difficulties. In consequence, they left behind a belief
among many people that the intervening space was split by
an isthmus, although the entire Atlantic is a continuous sea,
especially in the south. All t hese men named the places at the
end of their voyages “Ethiopian” and broadcast it so. Would
it be in any way unexpected for Homer to be influenced by
such reports and to split them into two groups, meaning “those in
the east” and “those in the west” (it being unknown whether
there existed p eople in between or not)?
33 C, 3-8 Indeed, Ephorus tells another bit of ancient history, which
Ephorus (4th c. BCE) it would not be unexpected for Homer to have come across.
He says that it is related by the Tartessians that the Ethiopians
invaded Libya as far as Dyris, and that some of them stayed t here Dyris, Atlas mts. (Mor.)
Aristarchus and t hose who follow him, and also other more
poet = Homer (8th c. BCE) plausible points to exonerate the poet from the charge of
gross ignorance. I say that, in ancient Greek thought, just as
people called the known northern regions by the single name
of “Scythians” or (in the manner of Homer) “Nomads,” and
just as later on, when the western regions became known,
people w ere called “Celts” and “Iberians” or, in a hybrid
fashion, “Celtiberians” and “Celtoscythians” (different na-
tions being categorized under one name through ignorance),
in just the same way all the southern oceanic regions w ere
called “Ethiopia.”
33 C, 17-29 The evidence is as follows. Aeschylus in Prometheus
Aeschylus (5th c. BCE) Unbound says this: with its scarlet bed the sacred flow / of the
Erythran sea, / and the sea with its gleam of bronze on Ocean’s
stream / p roviding nourishment of all kinds to the Ethiopians, / where
all-seeing Helius regularly / revitalizes his immortal body and his Helius = Sun
weary horses / in the warm outpourings / of soft w ater. Since the
ocean has this function and this relationship with regard to
the sun along the entire southern clima, he clearly positions clima, band of latitude
the Ethiopians along this entire clima, too.
47
1. Geography and Geographers
[ 1 ] I.e., Scythia stretches from northeast to northwest. For “corresponds to”: 496 C,
26–497 C, 4n.
[ 2 ] The word translated as “daylight” might more normally be translated as “sun-
rise” and taken to mean the “east,” but Strabo l ater argues strenuously against
such an interpretation: 455 C, 11-23. Cf. 27 C, 36–28 C, 11n.
[ 3 ] 454 C, 4–455 C, 25.
[ 4 ] 21 C, 13-28.
48
Eratosthenes (3rd c. BCE)
rain, / they fly with a shriek to the streams of Ocean, / bringing doom
and destruction to Pygmy men. It is not that the crane is seen
flying south in Greece, but that it is never seen flying south
in Italy, Iberia, the Caspian sea, or Bactriana. Since the ocean
stretches along the entire southern coastline, and the cranes
migrate to this entire stretch, one must understand the Pyg-
mies as mythically located along the entire coastline too.
35 C, 9-12 If men of later times used “Ethiopians” and the story of
the “Pygmies” only in connection with the Ethiopians near
Egypt, that would not be relevant to antiquity. Nowadays,
we do not describe all those who campaigned against Troy
as “Achaeans” and “Argives,” but Homer uses this name for
all of them.
35 C, 12-20 What I say about the Ethiopians split into two groups is simi-
lar, that one must understand them as t hose people who ex-
tend along the entire oceanic coast, from where the sun rises
to where it sets. The Ethiopians who are thus described are
physically split into two groups by the Arabian gulf—as if by a Arabian gulf, Red Sea
which this gulf forms together with the Egyptian sea? | Egyptian sea = Med. Sea
recess of the Arabian gulf nor of the isthmus t here (which has Arabian gulf, Red Sea
49
1. Geography and Geographers
50
Eratosthenes (3rd c. BCE)
ing Pharus, the person who told him, or rather the common Pharus, island joined by a mole
to Alexandria (Iskandariya, Egy.)
rumor, that it was at that time as far away from the mainland in Strabo’s day
as he says (a voyage of a day), would not have gained currency
if it was fictitious to such a degree. It is reasonable to suppose
that the nature of the flooding and of the sedimentation was a
poet = Homer (8th c. BCE) matter of general knowledge. The poet, concluding from this
that, at the time of Menelaus’s visit, the island lay farther away
from the mainland, added on his own account a much greater
distance for the sake of the mythical element.
37 C, 13-16 Mythical creations are certainly not a sign of lack of knowl-
edge, nor are the stories of Proteus and the Pygmies, the
powerful potions, and other such poetic creations. They are
told not on the basis of lack of knowledge about places but for
the sake of p leasure and enjoyment.
37 C, 16-24 How is it, then, that he says that the island, which is in island = Pharus, island joined
by a mole to Alexandria
reality waterless, has w ater (on it is a harbor with a good anchor- (Iskandariya, Egy.) in Strabo’s day
age, whence men launch their well-balanced ships / onto the sea, after
drawing supplies of dark water)? It is not impossible that the
[ 1 ] 29 C, 32–30 C, 22.
[ 2 ] 36 C, 24-34.
51
1. Geography and Geographers
supply of water has dried up. Nor does he say that the water
is from the island, only that the ships put out to sea from the
island on account of the excellence of the harbor. It is possible
that the water was drawn from the mainland, something that
poet = Homer (8th c. BCE) the poet to some extent acknowledged through suggestion,
in that he described it as being on the open sea not with a view
to truth but with a view to hyperbole and myth. |
37 C, 25-28 Since the description of Menelaus’s wanderings appears description = by Homer 1.2.31
to support the charge that he lacks knowledge about the places he = Homer
duration that he gives (in the eighth year) with the length
of the journey; some posit a voyage across the isthmus at isthmus, Isthmus of Suez (Egy.)
the inmost recess of the Arabian gulf; some posit a voyage Arabian gulf, Red Sea
52
Eratosthenes (3rd c. BCE)
five w
ere left to him), as did stops made by choice for the pur-
pose of enrichment. Nestor says: thus, amassing much property
Citation of Homer (8th c. BCE) and gold, / t here he wandered with his ships.
38 C, 21-25 If the voyage across the isthmus or through the canals w ere
mentioned, it would be understood as mythical; if it w ere not
mentioned, its introduction would be superfluous and un-
convincing. I say that it is introduced unconvincingly, since
before Trojan times t here was no canal: p eople say that Seso-
stris, who attempted to cut one, desisted b ecause he assumed
that the level of the sea was higher. sea = ?Red Sea
38 C, 25-30 The isthmus was certainly not navigable. Rather, the con-
jecture by Eratosthenes is not true. He surmises that the out- Pillars, Straits of Gibraltar
rush at the Pillars had not yet happened so that, in this place, the inner inner sea = Med. Sea
sea was contiguous with the outer sea and, because of its higher level, outer sea = Red Sea
Casium, Ras Qasrun/Khatib el covered the isthmus; its level went down when the outrush occurred and Pelusium, Tell el-Farama (Egy.)
Gals (Egy.)
exposed the land at Casium and Pelusium as far as the Erythra. Erythra, Red Sea
into the ocean in this way (as if the outrush had already oc- ocean = Atlantic Ocean
the Elysian plain and the ends of the earth / the immortals will send
you. What kind of “ends”? The introduction of “Zephyrus” Zephyrus, west wind
53
1. Geography and Geographers
Strabo introduces an imaginary “Yes, by Zeus, but Arabia belonged to them, too, as did also
interlocutor, who argues that
the phrase “outer Ethiopians”
the regions as far as India. Of these, the former, alone of all
includes Indians and Arabs places, is given the name ‘Blessed,’ but people assume and rec
ord the latter as highly blessed, even if they do not so name it.”1
39 C, 22-32 But Homer had no knowledge of India (if he had known of
it, he would have mentioned it), only of Arabia. Men of today
call Arabia “Blessed,”2 but at that time it was not wealthy. It
was poor, much of it belonging to tent dwellers. The spice-
bearing area, because of which the territory acquired its name
(such produce being rare and precious in our parts), was nev-
ertheless small. Nowadays, the inhabitants have plenty and
grow rich because trade is plentiful and thriving, but it is
not likely that this was so at that time. Furthermore, thanks
to spices alone, some prosperity might accrue to a trader or
camel driver from such trade, but Menelaus needed booty
and gifts from kings and dynasts who had the means at their
disposal and the willingness to give them to him b ecause of
his distinction and fame.
39 C, 33–40 C, 3 The Egyptians, and the nearby Ethiopians and Arabs,
were neither completely lacking in resources nor oblivious
to the fame of the Atreids (particularly in respect to their Atreids = Agamemnon
+ Menelaus
success in the Trojan war), with the consequence that there
was an expectation of help from them, just as is said in the case
Citation of Homer (8th c. BCE) of Agamemnon’s breastplate, which once Cinyras gave to him as a
guest gift; / he had heard of his great fame in faraway Cyprus.
40 C, 4-9 The greater part of the duration of his wanderings is to be his wanderings = Menelaus’s
wanderings
understood as taking place in Phoenicia, Syria, Egypt, Libya,
the places associated with Cyprus, and in general along our our coastline = coastline of
Med. Sea
coastline and its islands. Guest gifts could be received from
these places, and also acquisitions from there made by force
and plunder, particularly from those who had fought on the
side of the Trojans. The outer barbarians3 in faraway places
gave rise to no such expectation.
40 C, 10-20 Menelaus is said to have reached Ethiopia not in the sense
Strabo implies that Menelaus that . . . * as far as the border with Egypt.4 Perhaps also the
could have traveled up the
Nile to the border between border of that time was nearer to Thebes. Even the current-
southern Egypt and Ethiopia day border is nearby—that is, the border at Syene and Phi-
lae5 (the former being part of Egypt, while Philae is a joint
settlement of Ethiopians and Egyptians). It would not be in
any way illogical for someone who has reached Thebes also
54
Eratosthenes (3rd c. BCE)
Alexander (where the embroidered robes were held, created by the Alexander = Paris
[ 1 ] “Menelaus” is on the coast of Libya (= Africa), very near the border with Egypt:
838 C, 9-19.
55
1. Geography and Geographers
eople w
p ere skilled craftsmen when he praises the bowl that
Euneos exchanged for Lycaon. He says: it was the most beautiful
in the entire world / by far, since the highly skilled Sidonians made it
well / and the Phoenicians conveyed it. |
41 C, 23-29 As for the Erembians, there has been much discussion,1 but 1.2.34
the people who are most convincing are those who suppose
Zeno (4th–3rd c. BCE) emends that the “Arabs” are meant. Our Zeno even writes it thus:
Homer (8th c. BCE)
I reached the Ethiopians, Sidonians, and Arabs. It is not necessary
to alter the wording, since it is ancient. It is better to seek the
cause in a change of name, that being a frequent and obvi-
ous occurrence amongst all nations; and indeed some people
achieve it by a change in the spelling.
41 C, 30–42 C, 2 But Posidonius would seem to give the best solution, in
Posidonius (late 2nd–1st c. BCE) this case deriving an etymology from the kinship and shared
characteristics of the nations. The Armenian nation, the Syr-
ian nation, and the Arab nation show much ethnic similar-
ity in their language, their way of life, and their bodily build,
especially where they are neighbors. This is clearly shown
in Mesopotamia, which is made up of these three nations.
The similarity is particularly marked among these people:
if there is some variation commensurate with the climata, climata, geographical
coordinates
mostly between t hose in the north and t hose in the south,
but also between t hese and the Syrians in the m iddle, nev-
ertheless common characteristics prevail. The Assyrians and
the Arimanians are also similar, both to t hese nations and to
each other.
42 C, 2-9 He conjectures also that the names of these nations are related He = Posidonius
to each other, since those people who are called by us “Syrians” are
by the Syrians themselves called “Aramaeans,” to which the names
“Armenians,” “Arabs,” and “Erembians” are similar, the Greeks of
old perhaps using the last name for “Arabs,” something that
the etymology supports—for the majority derive the name the name = “Erembians”
bian gulf (the side toward Egypt and Ethiopia). It is rea- Arabian gulf, Red Sea
poet = Homer (8th c. BCE) sonable to suppose that the poet refers to t hese people and
means that Menelaus reached them (in the way in which, as
has been said, he reached the Ethiopians),4 since these people,
[ 1 ] I.e., by other writers, as noted in the ensuing narrative (41 C, 23–42 C, 33);
cf. 784 C, 12-30.
[ 2 ] Strabo l ater distances himself from this semantic theory: 784 C, 12-20n.
[ 3 ] I follow Radt in giving “Troglodytes” here, and also at 784 C, 12-20. At all other
occurrences of the name in the mansucripts, Radt reads “Trogodyte(s)” (Radt,
vol. 3, commentary on 318 C, line 17f.). I follow Radt except at 506 C, 16-23 (where
I read troglodytae) and 828 C, 18-27 (where I read “Troglodyte-style”).
[ 4 ] 40 C, 10-22.
56
Eratosthenes (3rd c. BCE)
that those who make these claims contradict each other. Some
state that our Phoenicians and Sidonians are colonists from
those [Phoenicians and Sidonians] on the ocean,1 adding that the
reason they w ere called “Phoenicians” (Red men) was that the
sea, too, was called “Erythra” (Red). O thers state that the latter
were colonists from the former.
42 C, 33–43 C, 5 There are some who make Ethiopia into our Phoenicia and
also say that events associated with Andromeda took place in
Iope, the story being told not through lack of knowledge about Iope, Jaffa (Isr.)
[ 1 ] For the theory that Phoenician Tyrus (es-Sur, Leb.) and Aradus (Rouad, Syr.)
were colonized from Tyrus (Bahrain) and Aradus (Muharraq, Bah.) in the Persian
gulf: 766 C, 20-24n.
57
1. Geography and Geographers
in the guise of myth (for the poet must “aim at” this, too).2
Charybdis is created by him, as a myth, out of the low and
high tides. She is not entirely a fiction created by Homer, but
rather she is composed out of what is recorded in connec-
tion with the Sicilian strait. If, although the tide returns twice Sicilian strait, Straits of Messina
Citation of Homer (8th c. BCE) every day-and-night, he speaks of it returning “thrice” (thrice
a day she spews it forth, and thrice she sucks it back), one would say
the following: this should be understood not as being said out
of lack of knowledge of what is recorded but rather for the sake
of tragedy and the g reat element of terror that Circe adds to
her speech as a deterrent, with the consequence that an ele
ment of untruth is mixed in.
43 C, 30–44 C, 5 This is what Circe says in these very lines: thrice a day she
Citation of Homer (8th c. BCE) spews it forth, and thrice she sucks it back, / in fearsome manner. Do
not go t here when she sucks it back! / No one could save you from di-
saster, not even the Earthshaker. Yet Odysseus was present at the Earthshaker = Posidon
sucking back and did not perish, as he himself says: she sucked
back the salty seawater / but I was lifted up to a tall fig tree, / to which
I clung like a bat. Then he waited for the pieces of flotsam and,
holding onto them again, he survived. So Circe lied!
44 C, 5-9 Just as she lied in this respect, so she also lied in the
words thrice (instead of “twice”) a day she spews it forth, such
58
Eratosthenes (3rd c. BCE)
Homer (8th c. BCE) by Homer, his criticism is valid. If they did take place, but
in other locations, he should at the outset say where those he = Apollodorus
59
1. Geography and Geographers
the fairest of them all and her son, Eumelus, whom she bore to
Admetus—she was the noblest of women, / Alcestis, the most comely
of the daughters of Pelias, but had he not heard of the events,
acknowledged by all, associated with Jason, the Argo, and
the Argonauts? And did he make up a voyage from Aeetes
across the ocean without taking any element of it at all from
history? |
45 C, 24-28 Everyone says that the initial voyage to Phasis has an ele 1.2.39
60
Eratosthenes (3rd c. BCE)
46 C, 1-13 In the vicinity of Sinope, too, and the coastline there and
the Propontis and Hellespont as far as the area facing Lem-
nos, there is said to be much evidence for the expeditions of
Jason and Phrixus; and there is evidence, too, for Jason and
the Colchians who pursued him, even as far as Crete and Italy
Callimachus (3rd c. BCE) and the Adria. To some of these places Callimachus draws Adria, Adriatic Sea
and into the Adria), but sometimes their claims are neither
incredible nor unfounded. |
46 C, 18-25 The poet, using such starting points as these,2 is some- 1.2.40
poet = Homer (8th c. BCE) times in agreement with historical information but then adds
an element of myth to it, in accordance with a custom both
general and individual. He is in agreement with historical
information when he names Aeetes, speaks of Jason and the
Argo, creates “Aeaea” on the model of Aea, puts Euneos on
Lemnos, represents the island as well disposed to Achilles,
represents Circe—own s ister to the baleful Aeetes—as a sorceress
on the model of Medea. He adds an element of myth in the
oceanization of the wanderings that derive from the voyage. oceanization = literary transfer
to Atlantic of events that took
46 C, 25-33 Since that is the case, if these assumptions are made, the place on Med. Sea/Black Sea
Argo, widely sung about is an apt description, meaning that the
expedition took place in areas that w ere well known and well
Scepsian = Demetrius (2nd c. populated. If, however, the situation is as the Scepsian says
BCE) uses Mimnermus (7th c.
BCE) (using as his source Mimnermus, who represents the dwell-
ing of Aeetes as being on the ocean in the east, and who says
that Jason was sent to the outer sea by Pelias and brought
back the fleece),3 then the journey thither for the fleece, to
unknown and obscure places, would not be a credible story;
61
1. Geography and Geographers
others whom he himself criticizes for their nonsensical prattle. he himself = Eratosthenes
47 C, 18-24 He himself says that one of the foolish notions of this fellow is He = Eratosthenes
Strabo points out that his belief that the Arabian gulf is a lake, and also his statement that this fellow = Damastes
Eratosthenes cites statements
by Damastes that show how “Diotimus, son of Strombichus, at the head of an embassy of Athe- Arabian gulf, Red Sea
gullible Damastes is nians, sailed from Cilicia by means of the Cydnus to the Choaspes
river (which runs past Susa) and arrived at Susa on the fortieth Susa, Shush (Iran)
day.” He says, “Diotimus himself told him these things,” then expresses He = Damastes
surprise that it is possible for the Cydnus river to cut through the Eu-
phrates and the Tigris, and to join the Choaspes! |
47 C, 25–48 C, 2 One should point not only to the foregoing but also to 1.3.2
the fact that, while stating that precise details concerning certain
places are not yet known even in his own times and bidding us not
Strabo points out that to be facile in trusting random facts and setting out at length Pontus, Black Sea
Eratosthenes is guilty of
believing random facts, despite the reasons we should not trust them (e.g., concerning the regions of Adria, Adriatic Sea
bidding o
thers to treat them the Pontus and the Adria), he himself nevertheless trusted in he = Eratosthenes
with skepticism
random facts! He therefore believed that the Issian gulf is the
easternmost point of our sea, even though the one at Dioscurias, our sea = Med. Sea + Black Sea
62
Eratosthenes (3rd c. BCE)
Euxine nor to follow the Libyan, Syrian, or Cilician coast. Libyan = African
48 C, 7-19 If, by those in antiquity, he means those from before our he = Eratosthenes
63
1. Geography and Geographers
in his own time, he changes direction to discuss the shape not he = Eratosthenes
large number of mussel shells, oyster shells, and scallop shells, as well
as saltwater lagoons, are seen at a distance of two thousand or three
thousand stades from the coast, in the interior—for example (he
says), in the vicinity of the temple to Ammon and the road heading t emple to Ammon, Aghurmi/
Siwa (Egy.)
to it, which is three thousand stades long? T here is a large quantity of
oyster shells, and much salt is found there even now, and a . . . * throws
up high jets of salt water. Next to it, the wrecked pieces of seafaring
ships have been identified, which p eople said have been cast up through
the chasm; on pieces of stern-pillars are dedications in the form of
dolphins bearing the inscription “from the Cyrenaean deleg ation.”
49 C, 19-25 In discussing these matters, he praises the opinion of he = Eratosthenes
[ 1 ] In alluding in the ensuing section (48 C, 34–61 C, 31) to the sphericity of the
world, Strabo looks ahead to Eratosthenes’s 2nd volume: 62 C, 18–67 C, 6.
64
Eratosthenes (3rd c. BCE)
Strabo cites Eratosthenes’s the rivers flowing into it created pressure and opened it up, then the
report of Strato’s comments
(4th–3rd c. BCE) water flowed into the Propontis and the Hellespont” and that “the Propontis, Marmara Denizi
same t hing happened in the case of our sea—in this case, the strait our sea = Med. Sea
at the Pillars broke open when the sea was filled up by the rivers, and strait at the Pillars, Straits of
Gibraltar
when the water rushed out, what had previously been shallows were
completely exposed.”
49 C, 32–50 C, 12 He1 advances as the causes, first, that the floor of the outer outer sea = Atlantic Ocean
sea is different from that of the inner sea, and secondly, that even inner sea = Med. Sea + Black
Sea + Sea of Azov
now a sandbank stretches underwater from Europe to Libya, as if the
inner and the outer seas were not once one sea; those associated with Libya = Africa
the Pontus are the shallowest, while the Cretan, Sicilian, and Sar- t hose associated with the
Pontus = Black Sea + Sea of Azov
doan seas are very deep (the rivers r unning from the north and east
are the most numerous and the largest, filling the former with mud
while the others stay deep—which is why the Pontic sea has the freshest
water); the outrushes occur in the direction in which the floors slope; it
seems the entire Pontus might get silted up in the f uture, if the inflows
continue in the same way (the Left-Hand Side of the Pontus 2—the
Salmydessus and what are called by sailors the “Breasts” in the region Salmydessus, coastline nr.
Midye (Tky.)
of the Ister and of the Scythian desert 3—is even now full of shoals);
Ister, Danube r.
perhaps, indeed, the temple to Ammon was formerly on the coast, but
t emple to Ammon, Aghurmi/
now that the outrush has occurred, it lies in the interior. Siwa (Egy.)
50 C, 12-24 He guesses that the oracle achieved its fame and reputation with He = ?Eratosthenes
justification due to its situation on the coast (its being so very far from oracle = temple to Ammon
the coast makes its current fame and reputation odd); in antiquity,
Egypt was flooded by the sea as far as the marshes associated with
Pelusium, mount Casium, and lake Sirbonis; 4 and even now, when Pelusium, Tell el-Farama (Egy.)
salt mines are dug in Egypt, the pits are discovered to be sandy and Casium, Ras Qasrun/Khatib el
Gals (Egy.)
full of mussels, as if the territory had been covered by sea and the w hole
Sirbonis, Sabkhat el Bardawil
area associated with mount Casium and what is called “Gerrha” was (Egy.)
covered with shallow water so as to be contiguous with the gulf of the Gerrha, ?Tel Mahmudiyeh (Egy.)
Erythra; the area was exposed when the sea receded, but lake Sirbonis gulf of the Erythra, Red Sea
remained; then this lake also experienced an outflow so that it became
a marshland; in the same way, the shores of the lake of Moeris are lake of Moeris, Birket Qarun
(Egy.)
more like beaches than riverbanks.5
50 C, 25-33 Let one grant that a large portion of the continents was
flooded at certain periods and then uncovered; and, likewise,
that all the earth’s surface that is currently below the sea is
uneven, just like, by Zeus, the earth that we inhabit above
the sea, which has been subjected to all those changes that
Eratosthenes himself noted.6 In consequence, in response
65
1. Geography and Geographers
floor of the Propontis and of the sea that comes next), adding Propontis, Marmara Denizi
at the same time by way of explanation: the depths are filled up sea that comes next = Med. Sea
with the mud deposited by the rivers and become shallower, and for
this reason the flow is outward.
51 C, 25-32 He applies the same argument to our sea in its entirety (with
respect to the outer sea), that this sea also makes its floor higher than
the floor beneath the Atlantic ocean, on the grounds that this sea is
also filled by many rivers and experiences an analogous buildup of
66
Eratosthenes (3rd c. BCE)
Byzantium. Let me allow this to pass, for they will say that they = Eratosthenes + Strato
floor, before the opening up of the mouth at Byzantium, mouth at Byzantium, Bosporus
(Tky.)
even if the floor w ere lower than the floor of the Propontis
and of the sea that comes next, from being filled up by riv- Propontis, Marmara Denizi
too: Was it not that the w ater levels in it and the Propontis
were such that, while they w ere the same, they did not force an
outrush—because resistance and pressure were equal—but
that when the level of the interior one rose, it caused pressure interior one = Black Sea
and disgorged the excess water? And, from that time onward,
the exterior sea became confluent with the interior one and exterior sea = Med. Sea
had the same level as it? (Whether the interior one consisted
formerly of seawater or lake w ater, it l ater consisted of seawa-
ter that mixed with it and predominated).
52 C, 9-19 If they will concede this, the present-day outflow would they = Eratosthenes + Strato
be applied to our sea in its entirety and to the outer sea, putting the
cause of the outrush not in the seafloors and their inclinations but
in the rivers. For it is not impossible, not even according to
them, that if our sea in its entirety was formerly a lake, the lake them = Eratosthenes + Strato
level r ose as it was filled up by rivers, and the lake rushed out
through the narrows at the Pillars, as if through a cataract; narrows at the Pillars, Straits of
Gibraltar
undergoing a continual increase, it was made into a confluent
sea by it over time, with a single level; it all became seawater
through predominance.
52 C, 20-29 Nor is it at all in accordance with physics to compare the
sea to rivers. Rivers follow a sloping course, while the sea is
static and unsloping. Straits have currents of a different sort,
not because the mud from the rivers silts up the depths of the
sea. For silting occurs around river mouths themselves. For
example, around the mouths of the Ister are what are called
“the Breasts,” and the Scythian desert and the Salmydessus,1
other torrents contributing to this phenomenon; around the
67
1. Geography and Geographers
has added a large part to Cilicia, and concerning which the fol-
lowing oracle was given: it will come about, for men of f uture times, oracle, divine prophecy
that the Pyramus, with its broad stream, / will silt up the sacred shore
and reach Cyprus. Flowing as a navigable river through the
middle of the Cataonian plains and escaping through the nar-
row passes of the Taurus into Cilicia, it flows into the channel
between Cilicia and Cyprus. |
53 C, 6-15 The reason the sediment brought down by the rivers does 1.3.8
not immediately proceed into the open sea is that the sea ex-
erts a natural counterforce and shoves it back again. It is like
living creatures, and just as they continuously breathe in and
out, so too does the sea, continuously moving inward and
outward in a recurrent motion. This is apparent to anyone
who stands on the shore where the waves break: one’s feet
are at the same time covered and uncovered, then they are
covered again, and this happens continuously. Each reflux is
followed by a wave, which, even if very gentle, has a sort of
greater strength as it surges inward and flings foreign matter
Strabo cites Homer (8th c. BCE) onto the land (it deposited seaweed all along the shore).
53 C, 15-22 This happens more when the wind blows, but also hap-
pens in windless conditions and even when an offshore wind
blows. The wave is nonetheless carried toward the land in op-
position to the wind, as if it were moving together with the
Strabo cites Homer (8th c. BCE) sea according to the sea’s own peculiar motion, as in around the
headlands, / it rises with arching crest and spits the foam from the sea,
and the shores resound as the sea spews forth. |
53 C, 23-32 The surging wave, then, has such strength that foreign 1.3.9
[ 1 ] Strabo has himself observed the upper reaches of the Pyramus: 536 C, 3-29n.
68
Eratosthenes (3rd c. BCE)
various other places) are the result, as p eople say, of seismic Bizona, Kavarna (Bul.)
activity. One would also guess that Sicily was not so much
broken off from Italy as thrown up from below by an Etnaean
Liparaean islands = Aeolian eruption, and that it stayed there, as also in the case of the
islands (Isole Eolie, It.)
Liparaean islands and Pithecussae. | Pithecussae, Ischia (It. island)
[ 1 ] 49 C, 32–54 C, 3.
69
1. Geography and Geographers
would not undergo a change twice per day, as he himself says, he = Eratosthenes
70
Eratosthenes (3rd c. BCE)
ously t oward the lower level. This happens b ecause the stream
and its surface level are sloping. In consequence, they are not
backward-running nor even at rest and motionless, there being
a shared current but no single surface level, it being higher in
one case and lower in the other.
55 C, 27-32 Who would say that the surface level of the sea is slop-
ing, especially in light of the assumptions that make the four
bodies—which we also call “elements”—spherical? Water is
not like the earth, which, being solid, retains its shape so that
its indentations and projections are permanent; rather, it is
Archimedes (3rd c. BCE) held against the earth by the force of gravity and assumes the
spherical surface that Archimedes mentions. |
55 C, 33–56 C, 5 He adds to what he says about Ammon and Egypt the He = Eratosthenes 1.3.13
Ammon, Aghurmi/Siwa (Egy.) statement that it would seem that mount Casium, too, was sur- Casium, Ras Qasrun/Khatib el
Gals (Egy.)
rounded by water, as also the whole area where now what is called
“Gerrha” . . . * was a shoal that reached the gulf of the Erythra; and gulf of the Erythra, Red Sea
it was exposed when the sea receded. The statement that the said
place was a shoal that reached the gulf of the Erythra is ambiguous,
since reach means both “extend near to” and “touch” (so as, in
the case of a body of water, “to become confluent, one body
of water with another”).
56 C, 5-8 I understand it to mean that t here was a shoal that ex-
tended “near to” the Erythran sea as long as the straits at the
Pillars remained closed but receded when the breakthrough Pillars, Straits of Gibraltar
change at the same time in the sea—the Erythra—which was conflu- Erythra, Red Sea
ent with it? and why did it retain the same surface level rather than
being lowered? According to Eratosthenes himself, “the entire outer
sea is confluent, so that the western sea and the Erythra are one and
the same sea.” Saying this, he adds the corollary: the sea outside he = Hipparchus
the Pillars and the Erythra and furthermore the sea contiguous with
the latter have the same height. |
56 C, 18-25 But Eratosthenes will claim that he did not say “it became 1.3.14
confluent with” the Erythra when it was getting filled up but only
that “it extended near to,” nor that the corollary of it being one and
71
1. Geography and Geographers
the same continuous sea is that it has the same height and surface
level, as this is not the case for our sea nor, by Zeus, the sea at
Hipparchus (2nd c. BCE) Lechaeum and the sea near Cenchreae, something that Hip-
parchus himself notes in his argument against him. Knowing
this to be his opinion, let him bring that specific argument to
bear against him and let him not unhesitatingly assume that,
when he says the outer sea is one and the same, he necessarily
says that its surface level is one and the same. |
56 C, 26-31 He claims that the inscription on the dolphin by the Cyrenaean He = Hipparchus 1.3.15
time as the rising up of the ground, and flooded the area as far as the
oracle even though the area was more than three thousand stades from
the sea, he nevertheless does not agree that the rise was great
enough that the whole of Pharus and many parts of Egypt
were covered—as if a rise of such a height were not sufficient
to flood t hese areas, too!
57 C, 5-18 He says that, if our sea had been filled up to the extent claimed He = Hipparchus
by Eratosthenes before the occurrence of the breakthrough at the Pil- Pillars, Straits of Gibraltar
lars, all of Libya and much of E urope and Asia would have to have
first been covered. He adds to this that the Pontus would also have Pontus, Black Sea
been confluent with the Adria in certain areas, inasmuch as the Ister,
starting from the Pontus region, splits and flows into each sea b ecause
of the topography of the territory. However, the Ister does not
start in the Pontus region but, on the contrary, in the moun-
tains above the Adria; nor does it flow into each sea but into
the Pontus alone, and it only splits at its mouths. He shared
this piece of ignorance, common among his p redecessors,
with certain p eople who assumed that a homonymous river
“Ister” split off from it and flowed into the Adria, as a result
of which the people past whom the river flows got their name;
and that by this means Jason made his return voyage from the
Colchians. |
57 C, 19-29 With a view to not being amazed at changes of such a kind 1.3.16
72
Eratosthenes (3rd c. BCE)
fine-flowing springs. From there / stream forth the two sources of the
eddying Scamander. / One flows with tepid water . . . / the flow of the
other feels, even in summer, like hail. He forbids us to be amazed
that nowadays, while the cold-water spring still exists, the
warm-water spring is no longer seen. He says it is necessary
to allege as the cause the failure of the warm w ater, and he cites in
Democles (5th/4th c. BCE) this context the words of Democles, who records certain mas-
sive earthquakes, some occurring in antiquity in the region of Lydia
[ 1 ] 54 C, 4-15.
[ 2 ] Thera, Therasia, and similar phenomena elsewhere: 57 C, 30–58 C, 23. Egypt:
58 C, 24-32. Greece: 59 C, 1–61 C, 4.
73
1. Geography and Geographers
and made an island of the mountain, with the consequence Casium, Ras Qasrun/Khatib el
Gals (Egy.)
that one could travel by boat along the road past Casium to
Phoenicia. It should not, therefore, cause amazement if even
the isthmus that separates the Egyptian sea from the Ery- isthmus, Isthmus of Suez (Egy.)
thran sea one day splits apart or sinks down, opens up a chan-
nel, and makes the outer sea confluent with the inner sea, just
as happened in the case of the strait at the Pillar of Heracles.
58 C, 33-35 Some things were said about such matters at the beginning
of the project.2 It is necessary to aggregate them and build a
strong case for both the workings of nature and changes that
come about in other ways. |
59 C, 1-10 People say that “Piraea” (On-the-far-side) 3 was so named Piraea, Pireëfs/Pireas (Gr.) 1.3.18
[ 1 ] Strabo first visited Alexandria as a young man (early 20s BCE) and was based
there for much of his life: 101 C, 14-24n; 117 C, 35–118 C, 14n.
[ 2 ] 48 C, 29–50 C, 24.
[ 3 ] The feminine form of the adjective (“Piraea”) is used, perhaps as a witticism,
because “island” is a feminine noun in Greek. The usual form of the name, for
its mainland location, is “Piraeus”: e.g., 395 C, 18–396 C, 5.
[ 4 ] The “promontory” is mainland Attica: 391 C, 13-22.
[ 5 ] Strabo later appears to correct the name to Nericus: 451 C, 34–452 C, 7; 454 C,
4-24n.
74
Eratosthenes (3rd c. BCE)
named in the Catalogue:1 those who held vine-rich Arna, those who
held Midia. Lake Bistonis and the lake now called Aphnitis
probably submerged several cities belonging to the Thracians
(according to o thers, to the Treres, who w ere neighbors of
the Thracians).
59 C, 22-33 The island formerly called “Artemita”—one of the Echi-
nades islands—has become part of the mainland. People say
that others of the islets in the vicinity of the Achelous under-
went the same p rocess through the sedimentation of the sea
Herodotus (5th c. BCE) by the river; and the remaining ones are, as Herodotus says,
becoming connected. There are certain Aetolian headlands that
were previously islands. Asteria has undergone a change. The
poet = Homer (8th c. BCE) poet calls it “Asteris”: in the middle of the sea is a rocky island, /
Asteris, not very big; and on it are harbors safe for ships, / protected on
both sides. Now, however, it does not even have a good place to
anchor. On Ithaca, there is no cave nor Nymphaeum such as
Homer describes: it is better to look for the cause in change
rather than in ignorance or falsification of places to make
them mythical.
59 C, 34–60 C, 7 This being an unclear example, I leave it open to consider-
Myrsilus (3rd c. BCE) ation. | Antissa was, however, an island formerly, as Myrsilus 1.3.19
75
1. Geography and Geographers
76
Eratosthenes (3rd c. BCE)
Scythian, Tearcus the Ethiopian, Cobus the Treran, Sesostris Tearcus, early 7th c. BCE
and Psammetichus the Egyptians, the Persians from Cyrus Cyrus, 6th c. BCE
to Xerxes), are not so readily known to all. The Cimmeri- Xerxes, early 5th c. BCE
61 C, 31–62 C, 4 Eratosthenes says that when Herodotus claims that t here are
Herodotus (5th c. BCE) no Hyperboreans (People-beyond-the-north-wind)—on the grounds that
there are no Hypernotians (People-beyond-the-south-wind)—his ratio-
nale is laughable and is just as if one w ere to make the silly argument
that no “epichaerecaci” (rejoicers-over-the-misfortunes-of-others) exist
on the grounds that there are no “epichaeragathi” (rejoicers-over-the-
blessings-of-others); and it so happens that there are Hypernotians, since
“Notus” (south wind) does not blow in Ethiopia but in areas farther
down.4
62 C, 4-8 Since the wind blows in e very clima, and everywhere the clima, band of latitude
the equator.
62 C, 8-13 Perhaps this charge could have been laid against Herodo-
Herodotus (5th c. BCE) tus, that he understood “Hyperboreans” to mean the p eople
where boreas (north wind) does not blow. Even if the poets speak
in this rather mythical fashion, their interpreters should
understand the clear sense that “Hyperborean” means “the
most northerly of peoples.”5 The limit of northern peoples is
the pole, and the limit of southern p eoples is the equator; the
same limit applies to the winds. |
[ 1 ] The “Right-Hand Side of the Pontus” (Black Sea coast of Tky., Geo., Russ.) as a
technical term: 126 C, 3-11n.
[ 2 ] 48 C, 29–61 C, 29.
[ 3 ] In the following section (61 C, 31–62 C, 17), Strabo appears to add to and com-
plete his earlier discussion (15 C, 22–48 C, 28) of Eratosthenes’s 1st volume.
[ 4 ] In using the expression “farther down,” Eratosthenes is influenced by the direc-
tion of the Nile’s flow: “farther down” the river means farther downstream, i.e.,
farther north. In the next paragraph, “farther up” means farther upstream,
i.e., farther south.
[ 5 ] In Greek, the word for “north” means, literally, “of the north wind.”
77
1. Geography and Geographers
62 C, 14-17 Next, he addresses t hose who tell stories that are plainly he = Eratosthenes 1.3.23
62 C, 30-32 As for what comes next about its shape, he proves by vari he = Eratosthenes
ous means that the earth, with its body of water, is spherical,
as is the cosmos; and he would seem to stray into irrelevance.4
A brief account is enough. |
62 C, 33–63 C, 9 Proceeding with a determination of the width of the lived- 1.4.2
in world, he says that from Meroe (along the meridian running he = Eratosthenes
through it) to Alexandria, it is ten thousand stades; from t here to the
Hellespont, around eight thousand one hundred; then five thousand to Hellespont, Dardanelles/
Çanakkale Boğazı (Tky.)
Borysthenes; then approximately another eleven thousand five hundred
Pytheas (4th c. BCE) to the circle through Thule, which Pytheas says is a six-day sail north of Thule, ?Iceland
Brettanica and is near the frozen sea. If, then, we further add a fur- Brettanica, Great Britain
ther three thousand four hundred [stades] beyond Meroe, so that
we take into account the Island of the Egyptians,5 Cinnamon- Cinnamonland, Somalia
land, and Taprobane, it will be thirty-eight thousand [stades]. | Taprobane, Sri Lanka
Ierne describe various small islands near Brettanica but say Ierne, Ireland
nothing of Thule.
78
Eratosthenes (3rd c. BCE)
twenty thousand stades and claims that Cantium is several Cantium, South Foreland,
Kent (UK)
days’ sail from Celtica. As for the Ostidaean region, and the
Ostidaean region = Finistère
area beyond the Rhine as far as the Scythians,2 he has lied (Fr.)
about t hese regions in e very respect. He who has told such
lies about known places would scarcely be able to tell the truth
about places unknown to all. |
63 C, 24-34 Hipparchus and others estimate that the parallel through 1.4.4
Hipparchus (2nd c. BCE) Borysthenes is the same as the [parallel] through Brettanica, on Brettanica, Great Britain
the basis that the [parallel] through Byzantium is the same as Byzantium, Istanbul (Tky)
the [parallel] through Massalia. Hipparchus says that he finds Massalia, Marseille (Fr)
gnomon, rod placed vertically the ratio of gnomon to shadow that he gives for Massalia is the same in he (gives) = Pytheas
on the earth’s surface to cast a
shadow Byzantium on the identically named date.3 It is not more than five
thousand stades from Massalia to the center of Brettanica.
If, from the center of Brettanica, you proceed not more than
four thousand stades, you would find it somewhat indiffer-
ently habitable (this would be the Ierne region). In conse-
quence, the regions even farther out, in which he places far off he (places) = Pytheas
ily misses the mark in regard to the length. T hose that came
after him, as well as the most discerning of the o thers, agree
that the known length is more than double the known width
(I mean, the distance from the end of India to the end of Iberia
is more than double the distance from the Ethiopians to the
[parallel] circle through Thule). Determining the said width, he
[ 1 ] I.e., the eastern end of Brettanica is supposed to lie due north of the eastern
end of Celtica, and the western end of Brettanica due north of the western end
of Celtica: 496 C, 26–497 C, 4n.
[ 2 ] For Strabo, the “Scythians” live north of the Black Sea and in the Caspian region.
Pytheas may have been aware of transcontinental trade routes from the Baltic
to the Black Sea and Caspian: 104 C, 6-19n.
[ 3 ] Strabo refers to these words of Hipparchus again later: 71 C, 30–72 C, 3; 115 C,
4-9.
79
1. Geography and Geographers
greater by three thousand stades); from t here to the Caspian Gates, Caspian Gates, ?Sar Darreh
pass (Iran)
fourteen thousand; then ten thousand to the Euphrates; to the Nile
from the Euphrates, five thousand; another one thousand three hun-
dred to the Canobic mouth; then thirteen thousand five hundred to
Carthage; then at least eight thousand to the Pillars. This distance is Pillars, Straits of Gibraltar
eight hundred [stades] more than seventy thousand. One must further
add the bulge of E urope outside the Pillars of Heracles, which lies
opposite the Iberians but juts westward not less than three thousand
stades; various promontories including the Ostidaean promontory,
which is called “Cabaeum”; and the islands off this promontory, of Cabaeum, Pointe du Raz
(Finistère, Fr.)
Pytheas (4th c. BCE) which Pytheas says, “the most remote, Uxisame, is three days’ sail
Uxisame, Ushant (Fr.)
away.”
64 C, 20-26 These last places he describes—the promontories, the he = Eratosthenes
physics to say that the distance from east to west is greater, he says he = Eratosthenes
[ 1 ] 64 C, 8-20.
[ 2 ] 64 C, 1-8.
[ 3 ] There should probably be some reference here to the “temperate zone” (65 C,
3-9).
[ 4 ] 62 C, 22-29.
[ 5 ] Strabo replaces the a
ctual figure given by Eratosthenes with a back reference
to Strabo’s own words (64 C, 8-26, where he provides the constituent distances
given by Eratosthenes for the length of the lived-in world, amounting to 73,800
or 77,800 stades).
[ 6 ] Again, Strabo replaces the figure given by Eratosthenes with a back reference
to 64 C, 8-26.
[ 7 ] 64 C, 27–65 C, 3.
80
Eratosthenes (3rd c. BCE)
the Athenians and Boeotians over Oropus. Furthermore, the Greeks Oropus, nr. Skala Oropou (Gr.)
named the three continents not with a view to the lived-in world but
with a view to their own mainland and the Carian mainland oppo- Carian mainland, sw. Turkey
site, which the Ionians and their neighbors now occupy. As time passed
and the Greeks moved farther afield, and more and more territories
became known to them, they revised the division with this in view.
65 C, 29–66 C, 3 So, then, to begin at the end in arbitrating the dispute (not
in the manner of Democritus but in his own manner): Were the
first people who tried to differentiate their own mainland
from the Carian mainland opposite also the first to make the
division into three continents? Or were they concerned not
with “Europe” and “Asia,” nor likewise “Libya,” but only with
Greece and Caria (and a little of the neighboring territory)?
Was it others who, traveling far enough abroad as was suffi-
cient to provide the basic notion of the “lived-in world”—was
it these who made the division into three continents? How
could they not make a division of the lived-in world?
66 C, 3-7 Who, in speaking of three parts and calling each part a
“continent,” does not first have a concept of the whole, which
he then subdivides? If he has no concept of the lived-in world
but subdivides a part of it, who could say of what part of the
lived-in world Asia (or Europe or a “continent” in general)
is a subdivision?
[ 1 ] Some early Greek writers had speculated that the Nile and Tanaïs flow inward
from the outer ocean, making each continent effectively an island. Strabo,
aware that the rivers do not flow from the outer ocean, nevertheless believes
that they can be used to demarcate the continents: 66 C, 17-22n.
[ 2 ] The isthmuses: 491 C, 12–492 C, 9n.
81
1. Geography and Geographers
Melita as examples when he says that he does not see how this
inquiry into boundaries achieves anything useful—but then con-
tradicts himself! If the wars over Thyreae and Oropus came
about because of ignorance as to boundaries, the demarcation
of territory would have achieved something useful. Or does he
mean this, that in the case of small territories and, by Zeus,
individual nations, precise demarcation is useful, but that in
the case of the continents it is superfluous? Although in this
case, too, it would be in no way less useful. There might arise a
dispute over these matters between great leaders, one holding
Asia and one holding Libya, as to which of the two has a claim
to Egypt (i.e., what is called the “Lower” Territory of Egypt).2 Lower Territory, region of Nile
Delta
66 C, 17-22 Even if one w ere to ignore this case on account of it being
unlikely, it must anyway be stated that the continents are di-
vided according to a demarcation that is large-scale and rel-
evant to the lived-in world as a whole. Accordingly, we should
not worry about this fact, that p eople treating the rivers as rivers = Nile and Tanaïs (Don r.)
men who divide the mass of mankind into Greeks and barbarians,
nor for those men who counseled Alexander to treat Greeks as friends
and barbarians as enemies. He says that it is better to make the divi-
sion according to goodness and badness: many Greeks are bad, and
many barbarians are civilized—for example, Indians, Arianans,
and furthermore Romans and Carthaginians, who are so incredibly
well governed. That is why Alexander, ignoring his counselors, wel-
comed as many well-respected men as possible and did them f avors.
67 C, 1-6 As if those who thus divided men into a blameworthy
category and a praiseworthy category did so for any reason
other than that there prevails in one category lawfulness,
good governance, and what is proper for education and de-
bate, whereas in the other category the reverse is true. Alex-
ander therefore did not ignore his counselors but accepted their
opinion and did what logically followed from it, rather than
the opposite, focusing on the spirit of those who gave him
instructions. |
[ 1 ] 65 C, 13–66 C, 7.
[ 2 ] For “Asia” and “Libya” meaning, respectively, east and west of the Nile above
the Delta: 806 C, 31–807 C, 3. This division of the continents leaves “Lower
Egypt” (the Delta itself) undefined.
[ 3 ] Strabo himself treats the Nile valley above the Delta as the boundary between
Asia and Libya: 789 C, 13-22. This leaves him unsure of the boundary between
Libya and Asia in the extreme south: 839 C, 3-9. He treats the Tanaïs (Don r.)
as the boundary between Asia and E urope: 490 C, 1-3; 491 C, 12-23. His lack of
certainty over the upper course of the Tanaïs (492 C, 29–493 C, 16) makes him
unsure of the boundary in the extreme north.
[ 4 ] I.e., Eratosthenes’s 2nd volume, with which Strabo engages from 62 C, 18, to
67 C, 6. Cf. 48 C, 29–61 C, 31.
82
Hipparchus (2nd c. BCE), Eratosthenes (3rd c. BCE)
map of the lived-in world, he splits the map into two parts, by
Pillars of Heracles, Straits of
Eratosthenes establishes a means of a line drawn from west to east parallel to the equator. Gibraltar
straight-line, east–west axis for
the lived-in world He sets as its western limit the Pillars of Heracles, and as its mountain range = Himalayas
eastern limit the farthermost end of the mountain range de- Sicilian strait, Straits of Messina
fining the northern side of India. He traces this line from the Rhodia = Rhodian Peraea, sw.
Pillars through the Sicilian strait and the southern ends of the Turkey
Peloponnese and Attica, as far as Rhodia and the Issian gulf. Issian gulf, Gulf of İskenderun
67 C, 14–68 C, 5 Up to this point, he says, the said line passes across the sea and he = Eratosthenes
Eratosthenes believes the between continents, given that our sea in its entirety itself stretches out our sea = Med. Sea
Taurus mt. range lies along a
straight-line, east–west axis lengthwise as far as Cilicia. Then it extends more or less in a straight
line along the entire Taurus mountain range as far as India. The Taurus, mt. system from sw.
Turkey to ne. India
Taurus, as it continues in a straight line with the sea from the Pillars,
divides all Asia lengthwise into two parts, creating the northern part
of Asia and the southern part. The consequence is that the Taurus
sits on the parallel through Athens, as does the sea from the Pillars
up to that point. |
68 C, 6-9 Stating this, he thinks that it is necessary to correct the old he = Eratosthenes 2.1.2
geographical map on the grounds that, on the old map, the eastern
end of the mountain range deviates greatly to the north, and India is
dragged along with it, ending up farther north than necessary.
68 C, 9-17 As proof of this statement, he adduces a first argument he = Eratosthenes
Eratosthenes’s 1st proof as follows, namely that the southern end of India is agreed by rise opposite = be on the same
of straight-line, east–west parallel as
orientation of Taurus mt. range many p eople (citing as evidence climatic and astronomical data)
to rise opposite the Meroe region; and the distance from there to the from there = from s. India
and Sinope. This is also said to be the width of the mountain range. Amisus, Sinope Samsun, Sinop
(n. coast of Tky.)
If you sail t oward the equinoctial sunrise 3 from Amisus, you first
reach Colchis, then the overland passage to the Hyrcanian sea, and Colchis, Georgia
after that the route to Bactra and the Scythians beyond that,4 with Hyrcanian sea, Caspian Sea
[ 1 ] Strabo lays out the arguments in Eratosthenes’s 3rd volume together with Hip-
parchus’s criticisms of them (67 C, 7–94 C, 20). Since Strabo often disagrees with
Eratosthenes but also disagrees with Hipparchus’s criticisms of Eratosthenes,
Strabo’s arguments at times get very complicated. For a particularly convoluted
example: 76 C, 7-30.
[ 2 ] The word “volumes” is supplied by analogy with 66 C, 23-31. Cf. 29 C, 26-27n;
688 C, 25–689 C, 2.
[ 3 ] “Toward the equinoctial sunrise” = due east.
[ 4 ] Bactra (Balkh, Afg.) and the “Scythians beyond”: 516 C, 17–519 C, 3.
83
1. Geography and Geographers
the mountain range to your right. If the line through Amisus is ex-
tended westward, it passes through the Propontis and Hellespont. Propontis, Marmara Denizi
From Meroe to the Hellespont is not more than e ighteen thousand Hellespont, Dardanelles/
Çanakkale Boğazı (Tky.)
stades, which is the distance from the southern side of India toward
Meroe, region of Bagrawiya
the parts in the Bactrian region, if three thousand [stades] are added (Sud.)
to the fifteen thousand (of which the former figure accounted for the
width of the mountain range, and the latter figure accounted for the width = north–south dimension
width of India). |
68 C, 30–69 C, 7 Hipparchus disputes this statement1 by discrediting these 2.1.4
Hipparchus criticizes “proofs.”2 Patrocles is not credible, t here being two witnesses against
Eratosthenes’s 1st proof
him, Deimachus and Megasthenes, who say that the distance from Deimachus (3rd c. BCE)
the southern sea is in some places twenty thousand stades and in some Megasthenes (late 4th–early
3rd c. BCE)
Hipparchus argues that places thirty thousand. Such is what t hese men say, and the old maps
Eratosthenes uses only one
source, and not a credible one are in agreement with these men. He considers somewhat incred-
at that ible the view that we should believe a single source, namely Patrocles,
while passing over t hose whose witness against him is so strong, and
that we should rectify the ancient maps on this basis alone, rather than
leaving them be, u ntil such time as we have more credible knowledge
about them. |
69 C, 8-18 I think that this argument requires much correction. 2.1.5
In the first place, he says that Eratosthenes uses only Patrocles, he = Hipparchus
Strabo argues that Eratosthenes whereas Eratosthenes uses many witnesses. Who are the
uses many sources for his vari
ous statements people who say that the southern parts of India rise opposite the rise opposite = are on the same
parallel as
Meroe region? Who are the people who say that the distance from
Meroe to the parallel through Athens is this amount? Then again,
who are the people who give the width of the mountain range,
or who say that the distance from Cilicia to Amisus is equivalent to
it? Who is it who says that from Amisus past the Colchians and
Hyrcania, as far as the Bactrians and t hose situated beyond them
right up to the eastern sea, is a straight line g oing due east and follow-
ing the mountain range, with the mountain range on the right-hand
side? Or again, concerning the westward continuation of this line,
that it goes to the Propontis and the Hellespont? Propontis, Marmara Denizi
[ 1 ] 68 C, 6-9.
[ 2 ] 68 C, 9-29.
84
Hipparchus (2nd c. BCE), Eratosthenes (3rd c. BCE)
Hipparchus’s own words show important command, the testimony of the men who accom- Patrocles served under
that Eratosthenes’s main source, Seleucus, king of Macedonian
Patrocles, is credible panied him, and the testimony of the men (named by Hippar- Syria (ruled late 4th–early 3rd c.
chus himself!) who argued against him, since their reproaches BCE) and Antiochus (ruled
3rd c. BCE)
guarantee his statements.
69 C, 26-30 Nor is this an indication of Patrocles’s lack of credibility, that
Hipparchus’s own words show he says Alexander’s fellow campaigners kept records of each place
that Eratosthenes’s main source,
Patrocles, had access to impor through which they passed, and only Alexander himself had detailed
tant information knowledge, since his experts wrote up for him an account of the whole territory = India
territory. He says later that the written account was given to him him = Patrocles
85
1. Geography and Geographers
Deimachus (3rd c. BCE) Deimachus; second prize goes to Megasthenes; finally, One- Onesicritus, Nearchus (4th c.
BCE)
Megasthenes (late 4th–early sicritus, Nearchus, and such writers, stammer out a version
3rd c. BCE)
of the truth. I had the opportunity to see this in more detail
when I was taking notes1 on the Activities of Alexander.2
70 C, 20-27 Deimachus and Megasthenes are especially deserving of
our disbelief. It is they who record the enotocoetae (those-who-
sleep-in-their-ears), the astomi (those-with-no-mouths), the arrhines (those-
age from Amisus toward Colchis is in the direction of the equinoctial in the direction of the
equinoctial sunrise = due east
sunrise is proven by the winds, seasons, crops, and the sunrises
themselves, as likewise the overland crossing to the Caspian sea,
and the route onward from there to Bactra.
71 C, 6-11 In many instances, self-evidence and agreement of all
sources are more trustworthy than instrumental data. Hippar-
chus himself did not base his belief that the line from the Pillars Pillars, Straits of Gibraltar
to Cilicia is a straight line in the direction of the equinoctial sunrise in the direction of the
equinoctial sunrise = due east
entirely on instrumental data and geometric calculation: for all
of the distance from the Pillars to the Strait, he relied on sailors. Strait, Straits of Messina
[ 1 ] Strabo probably refers to his preparatory research on India. In the finished he uses Activities of Alexander as the “title” of a subsection of his geographical
version of his work, he does indeed describe India through the conflicting ac- work—namely, the part of his account of India that is based on the campaigns
counts of Deimachus, Megasthenes, Onesicritus, Nearchus, and o thers: 685 C, of Alexander the G reat (4th c. BCE) and their aftermath: see previous note.
11–720 C, 7, esp. 689 C, 32–690 C, 6. [3] Most of these creatures/people are mentioned by Strabo in his account of
[ 2 ] Some scholars see Strabo as referring here to a lost (and otherwise unattested) India: 711 C, 3-24.
work, entitled Activities of Alexander, which Strabo is then supposed to have [4] Myrmeces are mentioned by Strabo in his account of India: 705 C, 33–706 C, 11n.
produced. O thers think that Strabo refers rather to his historical work (lost [5] Strabo, having defended (68 C, 30–70 C, 31) the credibility of Patrocles, which is
but attested by Strabo himself, 13 C, 22-29), in which case he uses Activities vital to Eratosthenes’s 1st proof (68 C, 9-17), proceeds (70 C, 31–71 C, 23) to defend
of Alexander as the “title” of a subsection of that work. This is possible, since the credibility of the sources used in Eratosthenes’s 2nd proof (68 C, 18-29).
Strabo does indeed use “titles” to refer to subsections of his work: 639 C, 15-27n. [6] Use of the “gnomon”: 111 C, 29–112 C, 2n.
However, it is also possible that Strabo is not referring to another work but that
86
Hipparchus (2nd c. BCE), Eratosthenes (3rd c. BCE)
weirdness results if one w ere to, on the one hand, leave un-
disturbed the statement that the southern end of India rises rises opposite = is on the same
parallel as Meroe, region of
Strabo criticizes Hipparchus’s opposite the Meroe region and the statement that the distance Bagrawiya (Sud.)
premise that the north–south
dimension of India is 30,000 from Meroe to the mouth at Byzantium is around eighteen thou- mouth at Byzantium, Bosporus
stades sand stades2 but w ere, on the other hand, to make the distance (Tky.)
as the parallel through Massalia, as Hipparchus says, trusting Massalia, Marseille (Fr.)
Pytheas (4th c. BCE) Pytheas; and if the meridian through Byzantium is the same as
Hipparchus’s own data show the meridian through Borysthenes,4 as Hipparchus also believes;
that n. Celtica is on the same
parallel as Borysthenes and if he believes that the distance from Byzantium to Borys-
thenes is three thousand seven hundred stades; then that would be
the number of stades from Massalia to the parallel through
Borysthenes—and this would be the parallel through the oce- oceanic coast of Celtica, North
Sea coast of France, Belgium
anic coast of Celtica,5 since people who travel this number of
stades reach the ocean. |
72 C, 4-11 Then again, since we know that Cinnamonland is the most Cinnamonland, Somalia 2.1.13
remote part of the lived-in world to the south and that, ac-
Hipparchus’s own words show cording to Hipparchus himself, the parallel through it marks
that the distance from the
southern limit of the lived-in
the start of both the temperate [zone] and the lived-in world, and is
world to n. Celtica is 25,200 around eight thousand eight hundred stades from the equator, and
stades
since he says that the parallel through Borysthenes is thirty-four
thousand stades from the equator, the resulting number of stades,
87
1. Geography and Geographers
from the parallel between the burnt [zone] and the temperate
[zone] to the parallel through Borysthenes (and oceanic Celtica)
72 C, 28-31 If one w
ere to add this to the figure of thirty thousand
Deimachus (3rd c. BCE) that Deimachus gives for the distance to the overland passage to
the Bactrians and Sogdianans,2 then these nations would be jet-
tisoned from the lived-in world and the temperate [zone]!3
72 C, 31–73 C, 3 Who would be bold enough to make this claim when one
learns, from the words of men of old as well as from the men of
today, about the temperate climate and fertile soil primarily
Strabo argues that places north of the northern Indians, then in Hyrcania and Aria, and next
of India are fertile and cannot
lie north of lived-in world in Margiana and Bactriana? 4 All these countries are contigu-
ous with the northern side of the Taurus (and Bactriana, at
least, is close to the overland passage to the Indians) but enjoy
such blessings that they must be very far indeed from the
uninhabited [zone]!
73 C, 3-10 People say that in Hyrcania, the vine yields one metretes of metretes, largest fluid measure
in Greek system
wine, and the fig tree sixty medimni; grain grows again from
88
Hipparchus (2nd c. BCE), Eratosthenes (3rd c. BCE)
seed that drops off the stalk; bees are busy in the trees, honey medimnus, largest volume
measure in Greek metrical
dripping from the leaves. (This also happens in Median Ma- system
tiana, and in Armenian Sacasene and Araxene. It is not so
surprising here, if it is true that t hese places are farther south here = in Matiana, Sacasene,
Araxene
than Hyrcania and enjoy a climate superior to the rest of the
territory, but it is more surprising there). there = in Hyrcania
73 C, 10-15 People say that in Margiana the stem of the vine is found
oftentimes to need the outstretched arms of two men to en-
circle it, and grape clusters are twice the length of the lower
arm.1 People say that Aria is similar and produces the very
best wine, in that the wine survives into the third genera-
tion in jars not sealed with pitch; and that Bactriana, lying
alongside and near Aria, yields produce of e very sort (except
olive oil). |
73 C, 16-24 It is not surprising if there are parts of these regions— 2.1.15
73 C, 28-35 Would you find such fertility in the Borysthenes region Borysthenes region = Ukraine, s. 2.1.16
Russia
or the region of oceanic Celtica, where vines either do not
oceanic Celtica, n. France,
grow or do not bear grapes? In places farther south than these Belgium
and lying on the coast, and in places on the Bosporus, vines Bosporus = Straits of Kerch'
produce grapes, but only of small size, and the vines are bur-
ied in winter. People experience such freezing conditions at
the mouth of lake Maeotis that Mithridates’s general, in the mouth of lake Maeotis = Straits
of Kerch
very same spot where he had vanquished the barbarians in a
cavalry b attle fought on ice, fought them in a naval battle in
the summer when the ice had melted!
89
1. Geography and Geographers
thousand [stades] the distance as far as Taprobane and the Taprobane, Sri Lanka
[ 1 ] 72 C, 31–73 C, 15.
[ 2 ] The expression “those associated with Deimachus” is idiomatic, meaning simply
Deimachus (3rd c. BCE).
[ 3 ] Cf. 72 C, 18-28, where it is speculated that the distance is “not less than three
thousand” and “more than three thousand.” The figure of “not less than four
thousand” fits more neatly into Strabo’s mathematical calculation here.
[ 4 ] 72 C, 4-11.
[ 5 ] 72 C, 4-11.
[ 6 ] 72 C, 11-15.
[ 7 ] 8,800 (Bactra to Borysthenes) minus 5,000 (Ierne to parallel through Borys-
thenes) = 3,800 stades.
90
Hipparchus (2nd c. BCE), Eratosthenes (3rd c. BCE)
Patrocles (late 4th–early 3rd c. navigation from India,1 as claimed by Patrocles, who held
BCE)
command in this region.
74 C, 32–75 C, 10 Furthermore, Bactriana extends one thousand stades north-
ward. The Scythian nations inhabit a territory beyond, which
is much greater than this; they end at the northern sea, living a
nomadic life but a life nonetheless. How can this be, if Bactra al-
ready falls outside the lived-in world? This distance—from the
Caucasus through Bactra to the northern sea—would be a l ittle
more than four thousand [stades]. This figure, added to the num-
ber of stades from Ierne northward, results in a total distance
through the uninhabited [zone] along the meridian through Ierne
of seven thousand eight hundred stades.2 If one were to leave
aside the four thousand stades, the very parts of Bactriana next
to the Caucasus w ill be farther north than Ierne by three thou-
sand eight hundred stades, and farther north than Celtica and
Borysthenes by eight thousand eight hundred [stades]! |
75 C, 11-14 Hipparchus says that, at Borysthenes and Celtica, the light of 2.1.18
the sun is visible all night long in summer, as the sun moves around
from the west to the east; and, at the time of the winter solstice, the
sun rises above the horizon a maximum of nine cubits.
75 C, 14-19 In the regions six thousand three hundred [stades] from Massalia
(where he assumes t here are Celts, but where I think t here
are Britons, living two thousand five hundred stades farther
north than Celtica), this phenomenon is even more pronounced: on
winter days, the sun rises only six cubits above the horizon.
75 C, 19-24 It rises only four cubits in the regions that are nine thousand one
hundred stades from Massalia and less than three cubits in the regions
beyond—which, according to my argument, would be much
Pytheas (4th c. BCE) farther north than Ierne; but he, trusting Pytheas, makes
this a habitable region in the area farther south than B rettanica, Brettanica, Great Britain
and says that the longest day there is nineteen equinoctial hours but
eighteen where the sun rises four cubits above the horizon.
75 C, 24-31 He says that these people are nine thousand one hundred stades
He = Hipparchus (2nd c. BCE) from Massalia, so that the most southerly of the Britons are
farther north than they are. They are therefore either on They = most southerly Britons
[ 1 ] The Caspian Sea is not a gulf, so a coastal voyage from India is impossible.
Speculation that goods from India could be taken via the Oxus river (Amu
Darya) to Hyrcania (73 C, 24-27n) possibly lies behind the claims for a trade
route by boat. Cf. 518 C, 34–519 C, 3.
[ 2 ] 4,000 + 3,800 (Ierne to parallel through Bactria: 74 C, 23-32) = 7,800 stades.
[ 3 ] 74 C, 14–75 C, 10.
91
1. Geography and Geographers
Eratosthenes points out amateur and unskilled in such matters, because he believes that he = Deimachus
that Deimachus (3rd c. BCE)
contradicts himself “India lies between the autumnal equinox and the winter tropic”
and because he disagrees with Megasthenes’s claim that, in the
southern parts of India, the Bears disappear 4 and the shadows fall
in the opposite direction,5 on the grounds that “neither of these is
Eratosthenes pokes fun at true anywhere in India”; and that, when he says t hese t hings, he he = Deimachus
Deimachus for his improper
understanding of astronomical speaks in ignorance, since it is ignorant to believe that the “autumnal
terms [equinoctial circle]” differs from the “spring [equinoctial circle]” in terms
of distance from the tropics, both the circle 6 and the sunrise 7 being
Deimachus’s words better suit identical. The distance between the terrestrial tropic and the equator
Eratosthenes’s own figure for
the north–south dimension (between which that fellow places India), having been shown through that fellow = Deimachus
of India measurement to be much less than twenty thousand stades,8 the situ-
ation would be, even according to that fellow, what he himself thinks
rather than what that fellow says: whether India is twenty or thirty
thousand [stades], it would not fit within this distance, whereas if it
is the size he himself says,9 it would fit. he himself = Eratosthenes
76 C, 21-23 Equally ignorant is the claim that “nowhere in India do the Bears claim = by Deimachus, rebutting
Megasthenes
disappear nor the shadows fall in the opposite direction” (a phenom-
enon that begins to become apparent as soon as you have trav-
eled five thousand stades from Alexandria).10
76 C, 24-30 Again, Hipparchus is not justified in criticizing him for him = Eratosthenes
[ 1 ] 3,800 (distance from parallel through n. Bactrians to parallel through that India extends south of the Cinnamonland (Somalia) parallel: 132 C, 25-33.
Ierne) + 5,000 (Ierne to n. Celtica, 72 C, 11-15) + 3,700 (n. Celtica to Massalia, 71 C, Megasthenes’s work has not survived, so corroboration is impossible.
30–72 C, 3) = 12,500 stades. [ 5 ] For an observer north of the summer tropic (Tropic of Cancer), the shadow cast
[ 2 ] Persica (lit., “Stuff about Persia”) refers either to works on Persia or to the rel- by the midday sun falls north. As the observer moves south of the tropic, the
evant parts of works on broader subjects: 639 C, 15-27n. shadow falls south (i.e., “in the opposite direction”) for one or more days during
[ 3 ] 71 C, 24–76 C, 4. the year, depending on how far south the observer is.
[ 4 ] For an observer at northern latitudes in the northern hemisphere, there is a [ 6 ] The “circle” is the equator.
circle around the north celestial pole containing stars that never dip below [ 7 ] The sun rises due east at both the spring and the autumn equinoxes.
the horizon. This circle includes at least parts of the constellations of the Great [ 8 ] 16,800 stades: 114 C, 11-18.
Bear and the Little Bear. As the observer moves south, the circle diminishes in [ 9 ] 689 C, 13-17.
size, excluding first the stars of the Great Bear and then the stars of L ittle Bear; [ 10 ] A journey made by Strabo himself (early 20s BCE): 817 C, 7–818 C, 21.
by the time the observer reaches the equator, the circle is nonexistent, and [ 11 ] 76 C, 7-23.
so, by definition, the Bears are not within it. Megasthenes perhaps supposes
92
Hipparchus (2nd c. BCE), Eratosthenes (3rd c. BCE)
Hipparchus criticizes rather than “winter tropic”; secondly, he does not believe that
Eratosthenes’s ridicule of
Deimachus one should use an astrally uneducated man as a source for astronomi-
cal matters, as if Eratosthenes were prioritizing the testimony
of that fellow, rather than using a common custom in replying
to t hose who talk nonsense. When we accept whichever of
their statements supports our case, that is one way of chal-
lenging t hose who make nonsensical allegations. |
76 C, 31–77 C, 3 At this point, assuming that the southernmost parts of India 2.1.20
rise opposite the Meroe region, which many state and believe, I Meroe, region of Bagrawiya
(Sud.)
have shown what weirdness results.1 Since Hipparchus at this
point does not reject the hypothesis but later, in his second
volume, does not accept it,2 I should also consider his latter
argument.
77 C, 3-15 Now, he says that, since “rise opposite each other” means “lying on he = Hipparchus
the same parallel as,” when the distance between places is great, this fact—
Hipparchus is open to the that places are on the same parallel—cannot be ascertained without com-
possibility that India extends
farther south than the Meroe paring the climata at each place. In regard to the Meroe clima, Philo, the Meroe clima = astronomical
data for region of Bagrawiya
parallel compiler of “Voyage to Ethiopia,” records that forty-five days before the (Sud.)
summer solstice, the sun is overhead, and he gives the ratio of the gnomon
to its shadow at the solstices and equinoxes; 3 and Eratosthenes agrees very gnomon, rod placed vertically
on the earth’s surface to cast a
closely with Philo. In regard to the clima in India, no one records it, not shadow
even Eratosthenes. If both the Bears disappear there, as he sup-
poses, relying on those associated with Nearchus,4 it is not pos
sible for Meroe and the end of India to be on the same parallel.
77 C, 16-19 Now, if Eratosthenes, regarding the Bears, agrees with
Strabo points out that those who state that they both disappear, how is it that “no one
Hipparchus contradicts himself
in criticizing Eratosthenes talks about the clima in India, not even Eratosthenes”? For
this is a statement about the clima! If he does not agree with
the statement, let him be found not guilty of the charge.
77 C, 19-25 In fact, he does not agree with the statement. Rather, when he = Eratosthenes
[ 1 ] 71 C, 24–76 C, 30.
[ 2 ] Strabo (77 C, 3-15) looks ahead to Hipparchus’s 2nd volume, treated at greater
length at 92 C, 8–94 C, 8. Cf. 69 C, 31–70 C, 5n.
[ 3 ] Use of the “gnomon”: 111 C, 29–112 C, 2n.
[ 4 ] The expression “those associated with Nearchus” is idiomatic, usually meaning
simply Nearchus. However, the view that “both the Bears disappear” is attrib-
uted to Megasthenes at 76 C, 7-21, and 77 C, 19-25.
[ 5 ] For Strabo, Syene (Aswan, Egy.) marks the summer tropic.
93
1. Geography and Geographers
77 C, 26-28 Also, in what follows, testing the same matters, either he he = Hipparchus 2.1.21
the Armenian mountains two thousand one hundred [stades], it is not Thapsacus, uncertain point on
Euphrates r. (in present-day
Hipparchus puts words into a logical conclusion that from Babylon to the northern mountains Syr.)
Eratosthenes’s mouth
there are more than six thousand [stades] measured along the meridian
passing through the city.1 Nor does Eratosthenes ever say that the
distance from Thapsacus to the mountains is two thousand one hun-
dred [stades], but rather that an unmeasured section remains,2
with the result that the ensuing attack, since it is based on an
assumption that has not been made, would not be valid. Nor
did Eratosthenes anywhere declare that Thapsacus lies north of
Babylon 3 by more than four thousand five hundred stades.4 |
78 C, 5-7 Continuing his defense of the old maps, he does not pre he = Hipparchus 2.1.22
Taurus and the sea from the Pillars,7 uses this line to divide sea from the Pillars = Med. Sea
Eratosthenes divides the the lived-in world into two parts. He calls one the “northern
lived-in world into the northern
part and the southern part, part” and the other the “southern part”; and he attempts to
then subdivides each part into subdivide each of these into manageable units, which he calls
“sphragides”
sphragides. As for the southern part, calling India the “first
sphragis” and Ariana the “second sphragis” (since they are quite
well defined), he managed to give the length and breadth of
both, and in a sense the shape, as if he were a geometrician.
78 C, 15-18 He says that India is rhomboid: some of its sides are washed He = Eratosthenes
Eratosthenes’s 1st sphragis by the sea (the southern sea and the eastern sea), which does
not make many indentations on these coasts; one of its other
sides is formed by a mountain range, and the other by a river.
In this case, a straight-sided shape is more or less preserved.
78 C, 18-25 He defines Ariana as having three sides compatible with He = Eratosthenes
Eratosthenes’s 2nd sphragis forming the shape of a parallelogram but, being unable to de-
fine the western side by fixed points because the nations are
mixed up with each other, he shows it as a line that starts at
Caspian Gates, ?Sar Darreh
the Caspian Gates and finishes at the end of Carmania, which pass (Iran)
94
Hipparchus (2nd c. BCE), Eratosthenes (3rd c. BCE)
line—through Susa and Persepolis to the boundary be- Susa, Shush (Iran)
tween Carmania and Persia—on which he managed to find a Persepolis, Takht-e Jamshid
(Iran)
measured route, the whole length of which is, in stades, a little
more than nine thousand. He calls this the “southern side,”
but he does not say that it is parallel with the northern side.
79 C, 3-12 It is clear that the Euphrates, by means of which he deter- he = Eratosthenes
only in rough outline. He also says that he takes the distances from
a variety of treatises on stopping points, some of which he calls
“unattributed.”
79 C, 14-19 Hipparchus would seem to be ill-advised in rebutting
such a rough outline with geometrical precision, when we
should be grateful to those who have reported the nature of
[ 1 ] 78 C, 18-25.
95
1. Geography and Geographers
amounting to ten thousand stades from the Caspian Gates to the Eu- Caspian Gates, ?Sar Darreh
pass (Iran)
phrates. Breaking that figure down, he gives the measurements
as he found them recorded, taking his start from the Euphrates
Eratosthenes gives a and the river crossing at Thapsacus. He records two thousand Thapsacus, uncertain point on
measurement of 10,300 stades Euphrates r. (in present-day Syr.)
for northern side of 3rd sphragis four hundred stades to where Alexander made his crossing
of the Tigris; the distance from there to the places that come
next—through Gaugamela, the Lycus, Arbela, and Ecbatana Gaugamela, ?Tell Gomel (Iraq)
(in which Darius took refuge from Gaugamela) to the Caspian Lycus, ?Greater Zab r.
Gates—would fill out the ten thousand [stades], exceeding it by Arbela, Erbil (Iraq)
only three hundred. That is how he m easures the northern Ecbatana, Hamadan (Iran)
long way away from the mountains. The mountain range con-
verges with the route from Thapsacus at the Caspian Gates.
That is, the northern part of the . . . *. |
80 C, 1-8 After thus giving the northern side, he says it is not possible, he = Eratosthenes 2.1.25
Eratosthenes gives 9,200 stades owing to the intrusion of the Persian gulf, to take the southern side as
for southern side of 3rd sphragis
going along the coast, but from Babylon through Susa and Persepolis Babylon, Tell Amran (Iraq)
to the boundary between Persia and Carmania is nine thousand two Susa, Shush (Iran)
hundred stades. He calls this the “southern side” but does not say Persepolis, Takht-e Jamshid
(Iran)
the southern side is parallel to the northern side. He says the
discrepancy in the length given for the northern side as compared with
the southern one arises from the fact that the Euphrates, after running
southward to a certain point, deviates greatly toward the east. |
80 C, 9-16 As for the oblique sides, he first describes the western one. he = Eratosthenes 2.1.26
Erythra through the length of Persia roughly in the direction of Erythra, Persian Gulf
96
Hipparchus (2nd c. BCE), Eratosthenes (3rd c. BCE)
Eratosthenes describes eastern Media and the north is not less than eight thousand [stades]—but,
side of 3rd sphragis
because of certain land spurs, more than nine thousand [stades]—and
the remainder past Paraetacene and Media to the Caspian Gates, Caspian Gates, ?Sar Darreh
pass (Iran)
approximately three thousand [stades].
80 C, 20-28 The Tigris river and the Euphrates flow out of Armenia south-
ward; when they have left b ehind the Gordyaean mountains, forming
a great circle and surrounding the extensive territory of Mesopota-
mia, they bend southeastward and southward—more so the Euphra-
tes, which, getting progressively closer to the Tigris at the Cross-wall
of Semiramis and the village called “Opis” (from which village it is Opis, Tell Mujeili' (Iraq)
some two hundred stades distant), flows through Babylon and empties Babylon, Tell Amran (Iraq)
into the Persian gulf. He says that the shape of Mesopotamia and
Babylonia is like a rowboat. |
80 C, 29-31 The foregoing is what Eratosthenes said about the third 2.1.27
[ 1 ] 78 C, 26–80 C, 28.
[ 2 ] Valid criticisms of Eratosthenes: 83 C, 15–86 C, 11; 89 C, 22–90 C, 22; 92 C,
10–94 C, 8.
[ 3 ] Hipparchus argues (80 C, 31–82 C, 24) that Eratosthenes’s own data show that
India extends much farther to the north than Eratosthenes claims.
[ 4 ] More precisely, 10,300 stades: 79 C, 20-32.
[ 5 ] More precisely, 9,200 stades: 80 C, 1-8.
[ 6 ] I.e., on a more easterly meridian, as opposed to due east.
97
1. Geography and Geographers
thinks) that Babylon, according to Eratosthenes, is farther east Babylon, Tell Amran (Iraq)
sacus to Babylon, and says this line is four thousand eight hundred
[stades], the perpendicular line from Babylon to the Thapsacus merid-
ian a little more than one thousand (which was the amount by which
the line to Thapsacus exceeds the line to Babylon); as a result, the
other line associated with the right a ngle is reckoned to be many times
longer than the said perpendicular.
82 C, 12-15 He adds to this line the extension from Thapsacus northward Thapsacus, uncertain point on
Euphrates r. (in present-day Syr.)
to the Armenian mountains, one part of which Eratosthenes said
“had been m easured and was one thousand one hundred [stades],” the
unmeasured part of which he said “he would ignore.” This fellow This fellow = Hipparchus
98
Hipparchus (2nd c. BCE), Eratosthenes (3rd c. BCE)
82 C, 16-24 Adding this distance to the side of the triangle that contin-
ues in a straight line to the perpendicular from Babylon, he reck- Babylon, Tell Amran (Iraq)
ons many thousands [of stades] for the distance from the Armenian
Hipparchus points out that mountains and the Athens parallel to the perpendicular from Baby-
Eratosthenes contradicts
himself lon, which is situated on the Babylon parallel. He points out that
the distance from the Athens parallel to the Babylon parallel is not
greater than two thousand four hundred stades—if the whole me-
ridian is assumed to m easure as many stades as Eratosthenes says.
If this is so, the Armenian mountains and the Taurus mountains
would not be on the Athens parallel, as per Eratosthenes, but many
thousands of stades farther north, according to the that fellow
himself!
82 C, 25–83 C, 3 In this case, in addition to his use of assumptions that have
Strabo takes issue with been invalidated1 in connection with the layout of the right-
Hipparchus’s assumptions
angled triangle, he also assumes another fact not granted, he = Hipparchus
83 C, 3-15 It has been noted2 that even if two lines are granted as
drawn from the Caspian Gates—one line to Thapsacus, and Caspian Gates, ?Sar Darreh
pass (Iran)
the other line to the Armenian mountains corresponding to
Thapsacus, uncertain point on
Thapsacus but, according to Hipparchus himself,3 two thou- Euphrates r. (in present-day Syr.)
sand one hundred stades away from Thapsacus—it is not pos
sible for both lines to be parallel either with each other or with
the line through Babylon, which line Eratosthenes called the Babylon, Tell Amran (Iraq)
southern side. That fellow, since he is unable to say that the That fellow = Eratosthenes
are described as parallel, would seem to accuse the chap of chap = Eratosthenes
[ 1 ] 80 C, 29–81 C, 30.
[ 2 ] 81 C, 22-30.
[ 3 ] 82 C, 12-15.
99
1. Geography and Geographers
are as follows.2
83 C, 16-24 Limb-by-limb 3 dismemberment differs from other forms
of section-by-section dismemberment in that the former
takes parts that are naturally defined by the bone joint and
Citation of Homer (8th c. BCE) that have a meaningful outline—as is said, chopping him up
limb by limb—whereas the latter does nothing of the sort, and
we use each technique as appropriate for the circumstances
and purpose. In just the same way, in describing the world, I
should dismember it into sections when I go into it in detail,
imitating limb-by-limb rather than random dismember-
ment. It is thereby possible to achieve the meaningfulness
and definability that serves the geographer’s purpose.
83 C, 24–84 C, 2 A section is “well defined” when it can be defined by rivers
or mountain ranges or seas; by a nation, or by nations; and by
its size and shape when this is possible. In all cases, it is suf-
ficient to speak in s imple and general terms, rather than with
geometrical precision. For “size,” it is therefore sufficient if
you give the greatest length and breadth—in the case of the length = east–west dimension
and the sea as far as the Pillars is fine. As far as concerns the sea as far as the Pillars = Med.
Sea
southern section, India has been delineated by means of many
features—mountain range, river, sea, and its unique name,
betokening one nation; as a consequence, it is correctly said
to be four-sided and rhomboid.4 Ariana—less easily outlined,
because its western side is muddled up—has nevertheless
been defined by means of three sides, which are more or less
straight, and by its name, betokening one nation.5
84 C, 9-16 The third sphragis cannot be outlined at all, not at any rate
Strabo criticizes Eratosthenes’s as defined. The side it shares with Ariana has been muddled,
3rd sphragis
as stated earlier. Its southern side has been very incompletely
100
Hipparchus (2nd c. BCE), Eratosthenes (3rd c. BCE)
drawn and does not mark the outline of the sphragis (since it
runs through its middle and leaves many parts to the south)
nor does it represent its greatest length (since the northern
side is longer). The Euphrates is not a “western” side—nor
would it be even if it followed a straight line—since its end
points do not lie on the same meridian. How is it “western”
rather than “southern”?
84 C, 16-26 Apart from that, given the meager size of the remaining
part as far as the Cilician sea and the Syrian sea, it is not cred- Cilician, Syrian seas = e. Med. Sea
ible for the sphragis not to be extended to them. Semiramis Semiramis, a semi-legendary
figure, was Assyrian ruler,
and Ninus are said to be Syrians: the first of these two founded 9th–8th c. BCE
and used as her royal residence Babylon; the second founded Ninus, husband of Semiramis,
and used as his royal residence Ninus, as being the metropo- was legendary founder of
Assyrian empire
lis of “Syria”; and the language remains the same up to the
Babylon, Tell Amran (Iraq)
present day for t hose on “the far side of the Euphrates” and
Ninus (city), Kuyunjik (Iraq)
those on “this side of the Euphrates.”1 It would therefore not
be at all fitting to sunder—by means of such a division in this
location—this most famous of nations and to join its parts to
people of a different nationality. He cannot say that he was He = Eratosthenes
and farther to the Canobic mouth of the Nile—to speak of Pelusium, Tell el-Farama (Egy.)
this as its southern side, and the remaining western side as the
coastline from the Canobic mouth to Cilicia.2 |
85 C, 6-13 The fourth sphragis would comprise Blessed Arabia, the 2.1.32
Arabian gulf, and all of Egypt and Ethiopia.3 The length of Arabian gulf, Red Sea
this section will be the dimension defined by the two meridians length = east–west dimension
[ 1 ] Strabo argues that Syria on this side (west) of the Euphrates (749 C, 8–765 C,
11) should be treated in combination with (As)syria on the far side (east) of the
Euphrates (736 C, 13–749 C, 7, esp. 737 C, 3-19).
[ 2 ] Strabo bases his detailed account of Persia, Assyria, and Syria (727 C, 11–765 C,
11) on this enlarged version of the 3rd sphragis.
[ 3 ] Strabo bases his detailed account of Arabia, Egypt, and Ethiopia (765 C,
21–824 C, 21) on this version of the 4th sphragis.
101
1. Geography and Geographers
Strabo adapts Eratosthenes’s (one meridian through the westernmost point of the sec-
4th sphragis
tion, the other through its easternmost point), and its width width = north–south dimension
along the line through the Pillars, the Caspian Gates, and the Pillars, Straits of Gibraltar
Caucasus, assuming it to be a straight line. He m easures the Caspian Gates, ?Sar Darreh
pass (Iran)
length of the third section along the line through the Caspian
Gates and Thapsacus. He measures the length of the fourth
section along the line through Thapsacus and Heroon Polis2
to the coastline between the mouths of the Nile, a line that must
end in the region of Canobus and Alexandria, since this is
where the farthermost mouth (called both “Canobic” and
“Heracleotic”) is located.
85 C, 33–86 C, 10 Whether, then, he joins the lengths together so as to make
a straight line or so as to make a line angled at Thapsacus, it
is nevertheless obvious—from his own statements—that this
102
Hipparchus (2nd c. BCE), Eratosthenes (3rd c. BCE)
lars, using the line that passes through the Caucasus, Rhodes, Pillars, Straits of Gibraltar
and Athens. And he says that the distance from Rhodes to Al-
exandria, measured along the meridian that passes through them,
is not much less than four thousand stades. The consequence is
that this is the distance by which the parallels—the [parallel]
through Rhodes and the [parallel] through Alexandria—stand
apart from each other. The [parallel] through Heroon Polis is
approximately the same as this [parallel] or, if anything, farther this [parallel] = parallel through
Alexandria
south than it. The consequence is that a line that converges
with this and with the [parallel] through Rhodes and the Cas- Caspian Gates, ?Sar Darreh
pass (Iran)
pian Gates, w hether this line is straight or angled, is parallel
to neither.
86 C, 10-11 The lengths used are not therefore valid nor are the north-
ern sections.1 |
86 C, 12-22 However, let me first return to Hipparchus and see what 2.1.34
86 C, 25-31 Nor is his deduction valid. He says that the distance from the He = Hipparchus (citing
Eratosthenes’s figures)
Caspian Gates to Babylon is as said; 4 to Susa, it is four thousand nine
hundred stades; and from Babylon, it is three thousand four hundred. Caspian Gates, ?Sar Darreh
pass (Iran)
Starting again from these same premises, he claims that an
oblique-angled triangle is formed between the Caspian Gates, Susa, Susa, Shush (Iran)
103
1. Geography and Geographers
and Babylon, with its oblique angle at Susa and with the lengths of
its sides as set forth.
86 C, 31–87 C, 9 He then calculates that it will be the case, based on t hese prem-
ises, that the meridian line through the Caspian Gates intersects the
parallel through Babylon and Susa at a point more than four thou- Babylon, Tell Amran (Iraq)
Hipparchus calculates that the sand four hundred [stades] farther west than the intersection with the Susa, Shush (Iran)
line from the Caspian Gates to
the Carmania boundary slants same parallel by the straight line extending from the Caspian Gates
southeastward to the Carmania-Persia boundary; the straight line through the Cas-
pian Gates and the Carmania-Persia boundary makes pretty much
half of a right a ngle with the meridian through the Caspian Gates; the
line heads in a direction midway between south and the equinoctial equinoctial sunrise = due east
sunrise; the Indus river is parallel with this line, with the consequence
that this river flows from the mountains not southward, as Eratos-
thenes claims, but in a direction between south and the equinoctial
sunrise, as depicted in the old maps.
87 C, 9-15 Who will concede that the triangle just now formed1 is
oblique-angled, without conceding that the triangle that en-
compasses it is right-angled? Who w ill concede that the line
(one of those enclosing the oblique a ngle) from Babylon to Babylon, Tell Amran (Iraq)
Susa is on a parallel, without conceding the w hole line as far Susa, Shush (Iran)
as Carmania? Who will concede that the line from the Caspian Caspian Gates, ?Sar Darreh
pass (Iran)
Gates to the boundary of Carmania is parallel to the Indus?
Without t hese concessions, the reasoning is invalid.
87 C, 15-19 Without t hese concessions, he says that India is rhomboid he = ?Hipparchus
in shape; just as its eastern side has been dragged very far eastward,2
particularly at its farthest promontory (which also juts farther south
than the rest of the coast), so too has the side along the Indus. |
87 C, 20-26 In all this, he uses geometric proofs, but not convincingly. he = Hipparchus 2.1.35
104
Hipparchus (2nd c. BCE), Eratosthenes (3rd c. BCE)
105
1. Geography and Geographers
Strabo points out that through Thapsacus according to Eratosthenes? While the lat-
Hipparchus mis-cites
Eratosthenes ter does indeed say that such is the distance from Thapsacus to
Babylon,1 he does not say that it is the distance from the parallel
through one to the parallel through the other, since he does
not say that Thapsacus and Babylon lie on the same meridian.
Strabo points out that Hipparchus himself showed,2 on the contrary, that according
Hipparchus contradicts himself
to Eratosthenes, Babylon is more than one thousand stades farther
east than Thapsacus.
88 C, 30–89 C, 9 I also cite Eratosthenes’s statements 3 in which the Tigris
and the Euphrates encircle Mesopotamia and Babylonia, and the
Euphrates creates the greater part of the encirclement for, after
running from north to south, it bends around to the east and empties
southward into the sea. So, then, the route from north to south is
as if on a meridian, but its bend toward the east and toward
Babylon is a deviation away from the south and does not form
a straight line, because of the said encirclement. He says that
the route to Babylon from Thapsacus is four thousand eight hundred Babylon, Tell Amran (Iraq)
thenes, but rather the charge that, for shapes and sizes de-
scribed broadly, t here should be a standard m easure, and it
[1] 80 C, 9-16.
[2] 81 C, 8-13.
[3] 80 C, 20-28; 82 C, 25–83 C, 3.
[4] 9,200 (distance from Babylon to Carmania-Persia boundary, 80 C, 1-8) minus
4,400 (distance from Caspian Gates meridian to Carmania-Persia boundary,
86 C, 31–87 C, 9) = 4,800 stades for the distance from Babylon to Caspian Gates
meridian.
[ 5 ] 86 C, 12–87 C, 15.
[ 6 ] 86 C, 12–89 C, 21.
106
Hipparchus (2nd c. BCE), Eratosthenes (3rd c. BCE)
who takes from the Caspian Gates one line right through the Caspian Gates, ?Sar Darreh
pass (Iran)
mountain range as if it w ere drawn on the same parallel as
far as the Pillars, and he who takes another that deviates in a Pillars, Straits of Gibraltar
straight line to Thapsacus, far outside the mountain range, Thapsacus, uncertain point on
Euphrates r. (in present-day Syr.)
and which he extends with a further line going as far as Egypt
and covering so much width, and he who then measures the
length of the place by the length of this line—this man would
seem to measure a quadrilateral’s length by means of the
quadrilateral’s diameter. When the line is not even a diameter
but an angled line, he would seem to err far more (the line
[ 1 ] 89 C, 22-24.
107
1. Geography and Geographers
rected the errors (as I do). He, to the extent that he thinks
of it at all, bids us focus on the old maps—which require far
more correction than Eratosthenes’s map does!
90 C, 27–91 C, 4 His argument’s conclusion suffers from the same weak-
ness (since he bases his premise on data that have not been
granted, as I have proven),2 namely the conclusion that Babylon, Tell Amran (Iraq)
Babylon is not much more than one thousand stades farther east than
Thapsacus. In consequence, if the city’s being more than two Thapsacus, uncertain point on
Euphrates r. (in present-day Syr.)
thousand four hundred stades farther east r eally is implied
by Eratosthenes’s statements (that from Thapsacus to the Tigris
crossing used by Alexander is a shortcut of two thousand four hun-
dred stades,3 and that the Tigris and the Euphrates, a fter encircling
Mesopotamia, for a while flow east, then bend southward and at that
stage approach each other and Babylon),4 there is nothing strange
about the calculation. |
91 C, 5-8 He errs, too, in his next argument, in which he wishes 2.1.39
to prove that he gives the route from Thapsacus to the Caspian Caspian Gates, ?Sar Darreh
pass (Iran)
Hipparchus puts words into Gates (which Eratosthenes says is ten thousand stades, not
Eratosthenes’s mouth
measured along a straight line) as if m easured “along a straight
line,” even though the straight line is much shorter.
91 C, 9-15 His line of attack is as follows. He says that according to
Eratosthenes, the meridian through the Canobic mouth and the me- Canobic mouth = westernmost
mouth of Nile r.
ridian through the Cyaneae are one and the same; this meridian is
six thousand three hundred stades from the meridian through Thap-
sacus; the Cyaneae are six thousand six hundred stades from the Cas- Caspium range, Caucasus mts.
pium mountain range (which lies at the pass to the Caspian sea from
Colchis); the consequence is that, except for three hundred stades, the
distance from the meridian through the Cyaneae is the same to both
Thapsacus and the Caspium.
91 C, 15-22 In a sense, Thapsacus and the Caspium lie on the same merid- Thapsacus, uncertain point on
Euphrates r. (in present-day Syr.)
ian. It follows from this that the Caspian Gates are equidistant from
Hipparchus claims that Thapsacus and the Caspium; that they are far less distant from the Caspian Gates, ?Sar Darreh
Eratosthenes contradicts pass (Iran)
himself Caspium than the ten thousand stades that Eratosthenes claims is
their distance from Thapsacus; that they are indeed far less than ten
thousand [stades] distant along a straight line; that the ten thousand
108
Hipparchus (2nd c. BCE), Eratosthenes (3rd c. BCE)
[stades], which that fellow reckons “along a straight line” from the
Caspian Gates to Thapsacus, are measured along a circuitous route.
91 C, 22-27 Iw ill rebut him by saying that Eratosthenes uses “straight
Hipparchus treats lines” in the broad sense appropriate for geography, and uses
Eratosthenes’s general terms as
if they are exact in a broad sense, too, “meridians” and lines heading “due
east.” That fellow, however, holds him to geometric standards That fellow = Hipparchus
ates it and says that it is five thousand six hundred [stades] from the
Cyaneae to Phasis, thence to the Caspium another thousand. The
consequence is that it w ill not be according to Eratosthenes 3
that the Caspium and Thapsacus are on roughly the same
meridian—but according to himself!
92 C, 5-7 Suppose it is according to Eratosthenes: How then does it fol-
low from this that the line from the Caspium to the Caspian Gates is
equal to the line from Thapsacus to the same point?4 |
92 C, 8-10 In his second volume,5 after revisiting the same inquiry 2.1.40
lived-in world.7
92 C, 10-16 He then cites what Eratosthenes says about places coming He = Hipparchus
Hipparchus criticizes after the Pontus—he says that three promontories extend from the he (says) = Eratosthenes
Eratosthenes’s
conceptualization of Europe north, the first containing the Peloponnese, the second being the Italian Pontus = Black Sea
promontory, the third being the Ligystican; and the Adriatic and the
Tyrrhenian gulfs are formed by them. Citing this general statement,
he attempts to disprove detailed statements about these places he (attempts) = Hipparchus
[ 1 ] Cf. 71 C, 6-11.
[ 2 ] Eratosthenes uses “mouth” to mean the Bosporus (Bogaziçi, Tky.): 71 C, 24-29.
[ 3 ] Strabo uses the phrase used by Hipparchus himself, as cited at 91 C, 9-15.
[ 4 ] Strabo addresses the phrase used by Hipparchus, as cited at 91 C, 15-22.
[ 5 ] Earlier references by Strabo to Hipparchus’s 2nd volume: 69 C, 31–70 C, 5; 76 C,
31–77 C, 15n.
[ 6 ] 67 C, 7–92 C, 7.
[ 7 ] Hipparchus presumably dealt with the unsatisfactory nature of Eratosthenes’s
northern sections, as criticized by Strabo himself (86 C, 10-11).
109
1. Geography and Geographers
93 C, 14-24 For Hipparchus (who was not describing the world but 2.1.41
110
Hipparchus (2nd c. BCE), Eratosthenes (3rd c. BCE)
goes entirely astray, and the other man indicts him with good the other = Hipparchus
cause, I consider it sufficient if I correct him as I describe
things within the geography itself.3 In cases where the errors
are continuous and common, it is better not even to mention
them, except rarely and in general. That is what I s hall try to
do in my detailed description.4
93 C, 25-28 For now, let it be said that Timosthenes, Eratosthenes,
Timosthenes (3rd c. BCE) and writers yet e arlier than them w ere completely ignorant
of Iberia and Celtica but ten thousand times more ignorant
of Germany and Brettanica, as likewise the regions belonging
to the Getans and Bastarnians.
93 C, 28–94 C, 8 They managed to be greatly ignorant even of the region of
Italy and the region around the Adria and the Pontus and of Adria, Adriatic Sea
the regions that come next to them to the north—although Pontus, Black Sea
[1] 67 C, 7–92 C, 7.
[2] As introduced at 92 C, 10-16.
[3] I.e., in the bulk of Strabo’s narrative: 136 C, 18–839 C, 10.
[4] The term “detailed description”: 104 C, 1-5n.
[5] 71 C, 24–93 C, 24.
[6] A recurrent theme: 79 C, 14-19; 87 C, 20-26; 88 C, 5-8; 91 C, 22-27; 92 C, 10-16; 92 C,
29–93 C, 6; 93 C, 28–94 C, 8.
111
1. Geography and Geographers
THE ZO NE THE O RY
as the [zone] between the tropical circles and that it extends over each
of the tropical circles into the space beyond, into the temperate [zones];
but that Aristotle uses it for the [zone] between the tropical circles, it = term “burnt zone”
and calls the [zones] between the tropical circles and the arctic circles
“temperate [zones].” 3
94 C, 35–95 C, 9 He justifiably censures both men, on the grounds that the He = Posidonius
Strabo agrees with Posidonius’s “burnt [zone]” means the [zone] that is uninhabited on account of the
criticisms of Parmenides and
Aristotle burning heat, while more than half of the width of the [zone] between
the tropical circles is habitable,4 to make a guess based on the Ethio-
pians beyond Egypt. The assumptions are that one-half of this entire width = of zone between
entire width is what lies on e ither side of the equator (which tropical circles
splits [the width] in two); and that, within this [one-half width], Syene, Aswan (Egy.)
112
Posidonius (late 2nd–1st c. BCE)
that the five [zones] are applicable to the heavens. Of these, the two
[zones] under the poles (extending as far as those areas where the arc-
tic circles are the same as the tropical circles) are “periscian” (having-
revolving-shadows); the [zones] next to t hese (extending as far as t hose
[ 1 ] The figure of 8,800 stades is based on Eratosthenes’s figure of 252,000 stades [ 5 ] Posidonius seems to have applied the terms “periscian,” “heteroscian,” and
for the circumference of the earth. “amphiscian” to the zones themselves. Strabo, in representing Posidonius’s
[ 2 ] Posidonius’s statement that the burnt [zone] is something like half of the [zone] account, sometimes does the same (133 C, 18-22) and sometimes applies the
between the tropical circles is consistent with his alternative and higher figure terms to the (hypothetical) inhabitants of each zone (135 C, 23–136 C, 12).
of 240,000 stades for the earth’s circumference rather than his lower figure of [ 6 ] “Subtropical” in the sense that they lie beneath the celestial tropical circles. We
180,000 stades, which appears to be mentioned in error by Strabo. would describe them as lying on the terrestrial Tropics of Cancer and Capricorn
[ 3 ] Strabo re-cites Posidonius’s criticism of Aristotle (94 C, 26–95 C, 9). respectively. The term “subtropical” t oday has a somewhat different connota-
[ 4 ] 95 C, 28–96 C, 5. tion, usually meaning latitudes immediately north of the Tropic of Cancer or
immediately south of the Tropic of Capricorn.
113
1. Geography and Geographers
living beings are born with woolly hair, twisted horns, jutting lips,
and flat noses: their extremities turn in upon themselves. Also, these
are the zones where the ichthyophagi (fish-eaters) live. He says that
these peculiarities are characteristic of these zones, as shown by the
fact that the climate farther south is more temperate, and the land
more productive and better supplied with water. |
96 C, 6-8 Polybius makes the zones six in number: two of them being 2.3.1
Polybius (2nd c. BCE) the [zones] that fall u
nder the arctic circles, two of them being
the [zones] between the latter and the tropical circles, and two
of them being the [zones] between the tropical circles and the
equator.1
96 C, 9-14 The fivefold division seems to me both physically and
Strabo favors Posidonius’s geographically valid. It is physically valid in terms of both
5-zone division
astronomy and climate. “In terms of astronomy” because, as
well as this being the best way to define the “periscians,” the
“heteroscians,” and the “amphiscians,” it also defines the ap-
pearance of the heavenly bodies, whose appearance changes
according to a graduated system.
96 C, 14-22 “In terms of climate” because, since it is determined by
the sun, t here are three main criteria (having consequences
for the groupings of animals and plants, and the groupings
of other things beneath and within the atmosphere): namely,
excess of heat, deficiency of heat, and moderate heat. Each is
properly determined by means of the division into zones. The
two frozen [zones] suggest deficiency of heat and share one type
of climate. The temperate [zones] similarly share one moder-
ate climate. The one remaining [zone], the burnt [zone], has the
remaining type of climate.
96 C, 22-27 It is clear that the division is geographically valid. Geog-
raphy seeks to describe a portion of one of the temperate
[zones], the portion inhabited by us. While to the west and
the east, it is the sea that is the limiting factor, to the south
and the north it is the climate. The climate in the m iddle,
being temperate, is good for plants and animals, while the
climate on either side is intemperate because of an excess or
deficiency of heat.
96 C, 27-32 These three criteria necessitated the division into five
zones. The division by the equator of the s pherical earth into
two parts, the northern h emisphere (in which we live) and the
114
Posidonius (late 2nd–1st c. BCE)
sufficiently divide the whole earth into five [zones] if your con-
cept of the earth was derived from such h emispheres.
[ 1 ] 95 C, 18-23 (where Strabo cites Posidonius). For a similar sentiment: 108 C, 10-18.
[ 2 ] 94 C, 26–95 C, 17.
115
1. Geography and Geographers
neath the equator has the highest elevation, on the grounds that
there is no “high elevation” on a spherical surface, on account of its
being uniform. Nor indeed is the strip under the equator “mountain-
ous.” Rather, it is flat, lying approximately at sea level. The rainfall
that fills the Nile comes from the mountains of Ethiopia. While he
Strabo accuses Posidonius of says this in one passage, elsewhere he agrees, saying that he
inconsistency in his criticism of
Polybius (2nd c. BCE) suspects there are mountains beneath the equator, with which clouds
from the two temperate [zones] on both sides collide, causing rain. The
inconsistency is clear.
98 C, 7-12 However, another inconsistency would appear to arise, if
we grant that the strip beneath the equator is mountainous.
These same individuals claim that the surrounding ocean same individuals = Polybius and
Posidonius
is a continuum. How can they situate mountains in the
middle of it (unless they mean types of island)? W hatever
the case, inquiry into t hese matters falls outside the remit of
geography—although it is perhaps allowable for the man who man who = Posidonius
116
Posidonius (late 2nd–1st c. BCE)
second; he established himself with the king and his men, particularly Cora = Greek goddess
Persephone
in connection with voyages up the Nile, being inclined to wonder at the
Euergetes ruled Egypt, 145–116
peculiar nature of the places, and not uneducated. BCE
98 C, 21-28 It happened that an Indian man was brought to the king by the
soldiers guarding the Arabian recess, who said that they found him Arabian recess, Red Sea
half dead, having landed alone in his ship; they did not know who
he was or where he came from, as they w ere unable to understand
his language. The king handed him over to men to teach him Greek.
Once he had learned the language, he explained how, when sailing
from India, he lost his way; he managed to survive to reach this place
but lost his fellow sailors to hunger. Having been well received, he
promised that he would show, to men chosen by the king, the sailing
route to the Indians.
98 C, 28–99 C, 2 Having sailed away with gifts, he came back with a return cargo
of aromatics and precious stones (some of them washed down by rivers,
along with pebbles; others of them unearthed by digging, the product
of solidification from a liquid state, as is the case with our crystals).
His prospects were destroyed, however, when Euergetes deprived him
of all his cargo.
99 C, 3-11 When Euergetes died, his wife Cleopatra ruled as his successor. Cleopatra succeeded Ptolemy
Euergetes, 116 BCE
Eudoxus was sent off again, with a larger fleet, but on his return,
the winds drove him off course beyond Ethiopia. Putting in at some Ethiopia = Somalia
place or other, he won the trust of the local population by giving them
grain, wine, and cakes of dried fruit, which the locals did not have,
and received in exchange supplies of water and the s ervices of a p ilot.
He also noted down some of their words. He discovered, in a ship-
wreck, a wooden figurehead carved as a horse, and learned that the
ship “had belonged to some people who sailed from the west.” He took
the figurehead with him and set off on the voyage home.
99 C, 11-20 When he successfully reached Egypt, with Cleopatra no lon-
ger ruling but her son, he was again deprived of everything: he was
exposed as a thief who had stolen a great many things. He took the
figurehead with him into the market, showed it to the ships’ captains,
and learned that it must belong to Gadirans, since, while wealthy Gadirans = citizens of Gadira,
Cádiz (Sp.)
Gadirans outfitted large ships, poor Gadirans outfitted small ves-
sels, which they called “horses”—after the figurehead designs—and
in which they sailed on fishing trips around Maurusia to the Lixus Maurusia, Morocco
river. But some of the captains recognized the figurehead as belonging Lixus, ?Draa r.
to one of those who had ventured farther beyond the Lixus river and
never returned.
117
1. Geography and Geographers
board, he set sail. He visited Dicaearchia first, then Massalia and the Dicaearchia, Pozzuoli (It.)
coastline following on from there as far as Gadira. Having everywhere Massalia, Marseille (Fr.)
loudly proclaimed his story, and having raised money, he outfitted a Gadira, Cádiz (Sp.)
large vessel together with two lightweight vessels similar to pirate ships.
He loaded dancing girls, doctors, and other technicians on board, and
set sail for India on the high sea with favorable west winds.
99 C, 28–100 C, 1 When his fellow-travelers wearied of the voyage, he sailed unwill-
ingly for land, as he feared the ebb and flow of the tides—and, indeed,
what he feared came to pass. The ship ran aground, but in a gentle
enough fashion that not everything was destroyed: the cargo was suc-
cessfully brought ashore, as also most of the ship’s timbers. From t hese
timbers, he constructed a third lightweight vessel, similar to a pente-
conter, and he sailed onward u ntil he was among p eople who spoke the
same words as he had previously recorded.
100 C, 1-12 At the same time as he learned this fact (that the local p eople w
ere
of the same ethnicity as those Ethiopians),1 he also learned that they
shared a border with the kingdom belonging to Bogus. Abandoning kingdom belonging to
Bogus = Maurusia, Morocco
the voyage to the Indians, he reversed course (making a note of an
Bogus (a.k.a. Bocchus) ruled
island, ?Cabo Verde island he saw as he sailed along the coast—a deserted island with Maurusia, late 2nd c. BCE
water and trees). Having successfully reached Maurusia, he sold his
vessels, traveled overland to Bogus, and advised him to take over the
maritime expedition. Bogus’s courtiers prevailed with their counter-
arguments, raising the fear that the territory’s security might be jeop-
ardized once the route became known to outsiders with hostile intent.
When he learned that he, ostensibly being sent on the expedition that
he had proposed, in reality would be abandoned on a certain deserted
island, he fled to Roman-controlled territory and from there made
the crossing over to Iberia.
100 C, 12-17 He once more outfitted a round-bottomed vessel and a long pen-
teconter, one to be used for sailing on the open sea and the other for
exploring the coast. Taking on board agricultural tools, seeds, and
builders, he set out on the same circumnavigation, his intention being
island spotted earlier, ?Cabo (if the voyage took a long time) to overwinter on the island spotted
Verde
earlier and, sowing the seeds and reaping the harvest, to complete the
voyage as originally envisaged. |
100 C, 18-20 I have come thus far in the story of Eudoxus, he says. It is rea- 2.3.5
sonable to suppose that the men from Gadira and Iberia know what
happened afterward.
[ 1 ] I.e., Ethiopians who spoke the language he had previously recorded: 99 C, 3-11.
118
Posidonius (late 2nd–1st c. BCE)
100 C, 20-23 On the basis of all this, he says, it is proven that the lived-in
Posidonius cites an anonymous world is encircled by the ocean—“not encircled by the fetters of land /
Greek poet
but limitless in its extension, spoiled by nothing.”
100 C, 24-34 Posidonius is, in all t hese respects, to be marveled at. He
Strabo criticizes Posidonius for considers that the circumnavigation by the Magus as reported
gullibility in believing Eudoxus’s
story by Heraclides is unsupported by evidence, as was also the circum-
navigation by the individuals dispatched by Darius 1 as recounted by
Herodotus, yet he holds as trustworthy this Bergaean fable, Bergaean = false
stolen a g reat many t hings, how is it that he was not punished but
[ 1 ] An error for “Necho” (late 7th–early 6th c. BCE), repetition of an error made at
98 C, 13-17n. For other examples of such repeated errors: 517 C, 20–518 C, 4n.
119
1. Geography and Geographers
went about making inquiries of the ships’ captains and showing them
the figurehead? Isn’t the man who recognized it to be marveled man who believed
him = Eudoxus
at? And isn’t the man who believed him to be more marveled
at—returning home on the basis of such prospects, then mak-
ing the journey from there to the regions outside the Pillars? outside the Pillars = Atlantic
coast
It was forbidden for anyone to put to sea from Alexandria
without documentation—especially someone who had sto-
len royal property! Nor is it possible that he sailed out to sea
secretly, since both the harbor and other exits were protected
by a large garrison. I, living in Alexandria for a long time,1
perceived that a garrison of such size still persists t oday, even
though nowadays, u nder Roman rule, the guard is much more
relaxed.2 The royal garrisons were far stricter.
101 C, 24–102 C, 3 Since he set off for Gadira, built ships, and was under- Gadira, Cádiz (Sp.)
taking the voyage in regal style, how (when his ship was de-
stroyed) did he construct a third lightweight vessel in a desert?
How is it that, when he resumed his voyage and discovered western
Ethiopians speaking the same language as the eastern Ethiopians, he
had no desire to continue his onward voyage despite his vain-
glorious love of travel and his expectation that the remain-
ing distance was but small? How is it that he gave up t hese
plans and instead conceived a desire for a maritime expedition
through the agency of Bogus? How did he learn of the secret
conspiracy against him? How was this (the fellow’s eradica-
tion) advantageous to Bogus, when it was possible to send
him away in some other manner? Learning of the conspiracy,
how was he able to escape preemptively to places of safety?
102 C, 3-7 Each of these episodes, while not impossible, is difficult
and unlikely, requiring a certain amount of luck. It always
so happened that he had good luck, even when exposed to
continual danger. How come, having made his escape from
Bogus, he was not fearful of revisiting his voyage around
the coast of Libya, even with an outfit capable of settling an Libya = Africa
island?
102 C, 7-11 These stories are not far short of the fabrications of Py-
Pytheas (4th c. BCE) theas, Euhemerus, and Antiphanes. These latter are excused Antiphanes (?4th–3rd c. BCE)
Euhemerus (4th–3rd c. BCE) because, like entertainers, it is their business. But who would
pardon a philosopher who seeks rational proof, a contender philosopher = Posidonius
[ 1 ] Strabo arrived in Alexandria as a young man (early 20s BCE): 117 C, 35–118 C,
14nn. A note (probably a personal observation) by Strabo on the harbor in
Alexandria: 792 C, 32–793 C, 9n. Comment on Alexandrian glassmakers: 757 C,
32–758 C, 15n.
[ 2 ] The Greek word translated as “perceived” could also be translated as “know.”
Either way, Strabo’s use of “today” and “nowadays” suggests that he considers
his information still current.
[ 3 ] 98 C, 13–100 C, 23.
120
Posidonius (late 2nd–1st c. BCE)
102 C, 12-20 He is, however, correct in his statement that the earth at times He = Posidonius
who had learned from Egyptian priests that, having once existed, it
disappeared, although it was no smaller than a continent in size. He
thinks that saying this is better than saying that he who made it
poet = Homer (8th c. BCE) up caused it to vanish, as the poet did with the wall of the Achaeans.
102 C, 20-22 He also conjectures that the departure from their homeland of Cimbrians were probably
originally from the Jutland
the Cimbrians and their kin took place at a time when the sea hap- peninsula (Den.)
pened to encroach, but not all of a sudden.
102 C, 22-25 He thinks that the length of the lived-in world, being some seven length = east–west dimension
seven myriad = 70,000 myriad stades, accounts for half the entire parallel circle along which parallel circle = line of latitude
it is drawn, with the result, he says, that if you were to sail from the
west with an easterly wind, you would reach the Indians within the
same number [of stades]. |
102 C, 26-31 Starting off by castigating those who divide the continents but 2.3.7
not by means of [circles] parallel to the equator,2 with which they would
show variations in animals, plants, environments, some of them bor-
dering on the frozen [zone] and some on the burnt [zone], so that the
continents are like zones, he then reverses course, withdraws the
accusation, and supports the existing division, thus treating
the inquiry as a matter of argument with no useful purpose.
102 C, 31–103 C, 8 Such variations are not the result of providence. Nor, like-
wise, are ethnic and linguistic differences. Rather, they are
the result of chance and happenstance. Technological skills,
power structures, business dealings—once someone takes
the first step, they generally prevail in any clima. There is a
climata-derived element, with the consequence that some climata, geographical
coordinates
local characteristics are the result of nature, and some the
result of habit and training. It is not because of nature that
the Athenians are lovers of learning, while the Lacedaemo-
nians are not, nor are the Thebans, who are even closer. It is
because of habit. Thus, the Babylonians and the Egyptians
are p hilosophers, not because of nature but because of train-
ing and habit. It is not location alone that is responsible for
the excellent qualities of h orses, c attle, and other animals, but
also training. He confounds all this.
[ 1 ] 57 C, 19–61 C, 4.
[ 2 ] Posidonius probably refers to Hipparchus’s theory of climata: 131 C, 26–135 C, 22.
121
1. Geography and Geographers
103 C, 9-17 Praising the way of dividing the continents that is cur-
rently in use, he uses as an example the fact that the Indians he = Posidonius
differ from the Ethiopians in Libya, given that they are better formed
Homer (8th c. BCE) and less dried out by the climate. That is why Homer, when referring
to all the Ethiopians, splits them into two groups: “some [living] where
Crates (2nd c. BCE) Hyperion goes down, some [living] where he goes up.” 1 Crates, when
writing “where Hyperion goes down and up” and introducing a second Hyperion = sun
The whole arc from the meridian to the setting sun is called
Aratus (3rd c. BCE) “western,” just like the half circle of the horizon, as Aratus
indicates (there, where / extreme west and extreme east meet). If
this is better in the case of the Cratesian emendation, one will
Aristarchus (late 3rd–2nd c. BCE) also say that it is necessarily better in the case of Aristarchan
emendation, too.
104 C, 1-5 The foregoing is my criticism of Posidonius.6 Many t hings,
to the extent they concern geography, w ill get appropriate
treatment in my detailed description.7 To the extent that they
are more concerned with physics, they will either be treated
elsewhere or ignored. T here is a g
reat deal of etiologizing in
his work, and aristotelizing, which my school avoids on ac-
count of the causes being obscure. |
122
Polybius (2nd c. BCE)
and those places where the land itself, as well as the sea and the air,
cease to exist but where there is some admixture of them all, which
resembles sea-lung. He says that “land and sea and everything e lse He = Pytheas
are suspended in this; this is effectively what binds the whole, although
it cannot be walked over nor sailed through; he himself witnessed its
similarity to lung but as to the rest he recounts what he was told.”
These are the statements of Pytheas; also, that on his return
from t here he visited the w hole oceanic coastline of E urope oceanic = Atlantic
104 C, 19-29 Polybius says that this is what beggars belief, how such dis- 2.4.2
Polybius doubts Pytheas’s tances could be sailed or traversed by a private individual with no
credibility
resources; Eratosthenes, being at a loss to know whether he should
trust t hese statements, nevertheless did trust them where Bret- Brettanica, Great Britain
tanica and places in Gadira and Iberia are concerned. He says, He = Polybius
Messenian = Euhemerus it is much better to believe the Messenian than this man, since the this man = Pytheas
(4th–3rd c. BCE)
former at least only claims to have sailed to the one territory of
Panchaea, while the latter claims to have seen all the northern part latter = Pytheas
of Europe as far as the limits of the cosmos—something that no one
would believe, even if Hermes told them; and that Eratosthenes
calls Euhemerus a “Bergaean” but believes Pytheas, even though Bergaean = liar
[ 1 ] From a chronological point of view, Strabo’s treatment of Polybius (2nd c. BCE) north of lake Maeotis; that this is part of the sea surrounding the continen-
should have preceded his treatment of Posidonius (late 2nd–1st c. BCE). How- tal landmass; that the Tanaïs is potentially a conduit from this sea (cf. Strabo’s
ever, Strabo has dealt with Polybius largely via Posidonius’s engagement with conceptualization of the land between the Tanaïs and the Caspian sea as an
him (96 C, 6-8; 97 C, 4–98 C, 12). Strabo now proceeds with a mopping-up op- “isthmus”: 491 C, 12-23). Pytheas presumably shared these beliefs, probably
eration, criticizing those elements of Polybius’s work—primarily Polybius’s use interpreting a gulf or estuary on the Baltic Sea, or even the Baltic Sea itself,
of sources—that Strabo has not already treated via Posidonius. as the beginning of this conduit. Pytheas may also have been aware of trade
[ 2 ] A “chorography” is perhaps a description of the lived-in world as opposed to routes from the Baltic to the Black Sea and the Caspian: 63 C, 18-33n.
a description of the whole earth: 9 C, 35–10 C, 5n. See also 266 C, 6-19n; 224 C, [ 4 ] 92 C, 10–94 C, 8.
29-33. [ 5 ] Polybius’s use of the term laodogmatic: 465 C, 1-9.
[ 3 ] Mention here of the Tanaïs (Don r.), which flows into lake Maeotis (Sea of Azov),
seems bizarre to us t oday. Strabo believes that the sea is encountered not far
123
1. Geography and Geographers
ten thousand stades to the Pillars from the Peloponnese” 1 and “more Pillars, Straits of Gibraltar
than this” to the Adria (to its innermost recess).2 Of the distance to Adria, Adriatic Sea
the Pillars, the leg to the Strait he gives as three thousand stades, so he = Dicaearchus
that the remaining leg, from the Strait to the Pillars, becomes seven Strait, Straits of Messina
thousand stades. Quite apart from whether the three thousand stades
is accurately rendered or not, the seven thousand stades is inaccurate
whether you measure it along the coastline or the line through the
middle of the sea.
105 C, 8-21 The coastline looks very much like an oblique angle, with lines
Polybius corrects Dicaearchus’s heading to the Strait and the Pillars respectively, having Narbo as Strait, Straits of Messina
figure for the distance from the
Strait to the Pillars, then adds its apex. Thus, it forms a triangle that has as its base the straight line Pillars, Straits of Gibraltar
3,000 stades for the distance through the sea and has as its sides the lines that form the said angle. Narbo, Narbonne (Fr.)
from the Peloponnese to the
Strait The side from the Strait to Narbo is more than eleven thousand two
hundred stades. The remaining side is only a little less than eight thou-
sand stades. The greatest distance from Europe to Libya is agreed to Libya = Africa
be not more than three thousand stades through the Tyrrhenian sea,
shorter through the Sardonian sea. He says, let that figure of three
thousand stades be granted, and on top of this let the further assump-
tion be made that the depth (a perpendicular,3 so to speak, from the
apex to the base of the oblique angle) of the gulf at Narbo is two thou-
sand stades. It is clear, he says, from school-level geometry, that the
entire coastline from the Strait to the Pillars exceeds the straight line
through the sea only very narrowly, by five hundred stades.
105 C, 21-23 If the three thousand stades from the Peloponnese to the Strait is
added, the total number of stades along the straight line will be more
than double what Dicaearchus said.
105 C, 24-33 He says, according to that fellow it w ill be necessary for the num- that fellow = Dicaearchus
ber of stades to the Adriatic recess to be “more than this.” | But “my 2.4.3
[ 1 ] Polybius believes that the distance from the Peloponnese to the Pillars is more
than twice Dicaearchus’s figure of 10,000 stades: 105 C, 8-23. Strabo corrects
Polybius’s figure at 105 C, 33–106 C, 10.
[ 2 ] Polybius’s intermediate distances for the length of the Adriatic sea, from the
Peloponnese to the Adriatic recess, are added up by Strabo at 105 C, 24-33.
[ 3 ] Strabo corrects Polybius’s figure for the perpendicular at 106 C, 10-16.
[ 4 ] 104 C, 35–105 C, 8.
[ 5 ] 105 C, 8-23.
124
Polybius (2nd c. BCE)
from the recess of the Galatian bay), it seems to me either that Galatian bay, Gulf of Lion
but much farther west than it, so as to include within the in-
tervening space virtually the entire Ligystican sea as well as
the Sardonian sea. Also, the lengths of the coastlines have
been exaggerated, albeit not to such a great extent. |
106 C, 27-28 He then proceeds to “correct” the statements of Eratos- He = Polybius 2.4.4
[ 1 ] 105 C, 8-21, where Strabo cites Polybius as giving the length of the perpendicu-
lar as 2,000 stades.
125
1. Geography and Geographers
that it is seven thousand [stades] from Massalia to the Pillars, and Massalia, Marseille (Fr.)
Strabo disapproves of Polybius’s six thousand from the Pyrenees) he himself states that it is more Pillars, Straits of Gibraltar
correction of Eratosthenes’s
figure for the length of Iberia than nine thousand from Massalia and a l ittle less than eight thou-
sand from the Pyrenees. That fellow’s statements are nearer the That fellow = Eratosthenes
that the Tagus river alone, from its source to its outlets, is Tagus, Tejo/Tajo r.
summer sunrise and the equinoctial sunrise 3—for Asia takes up this
[segment] of the northern semicircle t oward the equinoctial sunrise.
that the mouth of the river and the mouth of the Maeotis, mouth of the Maeotis, Straits
of Kerch'
together with the course of the river itself to the extent that
it is known, lie on the same meridian. |
107 C, 22-32 What some have said is not worth discussing, that the river Ister, Danube r. 2.4.6
Strabo disapproves of the claim starts in the Ister region and the west. They fail to note that in Tyras, Dniester r.
by some that the Tanaïs (Don r.)
flows from the west the intervening space, the Tyras, Borysthenes, and Hypanis— Borysthenes, Dnieper r.
large rivers—flow into the Pontus, one of them parallel to the Hypanis, Bug r.
Ister, the others parallel to the Tanaïs. Since the sources of Pontus, Black Sea
126
Polybius (2nd c. BCE)
neither the Tyras nor the Borysthenes nor the Hypanis have
been glimpsed, regions even farther north than these would
be even more unknown. In consequence, the reasoning that
has the Tanaïs passing through t hese regions in the direction
of the Maeotis, then turning into it (given that the outlets are
clearly identified in the northern parts of the lake, which are lake = Maeotis, Sea of Azov
127
1. Geography and Geographers
Strabo approves of Polybius’s promontories: the promontory that extends to the Pillars Pillars, Straits of Gibraltar
correction of Eratosthenes’s
enumeration of 3 promontories and contains Iberia; the promontory that extends to the
in Europe but thinks Polybius’s Strait and contains Italy; and the third one which ends at Strait, Straits of Messina
account itself can be improved
Maleae and contains all the nations between the Adria, the Adria, Adriatic Sea
108 C, 24-28 This fellow represents the first two in the same way; a This fellow = Polybius
third promontory as the one ending at Maleae and Sunium, Maleae, Akra Maleas (Gr.)
Sunium, Kolonnes (Gr.)
containing all of Greece, Illyria, and some parts of Thrace; a
Thracian Cherronesus, Gallipoli
fourth as the promontory ending at the Thracian Cherrone- peninsula (Tky.)
sus, with the straits at Sestus and Abydus (this promontory straits at Sestus, Abydus,
Dardanelles (Tky.)
Polybius counts 5 promontories occupied by Thracians); a fifth as the promontory ending Cimmerian Bosporus, Straits of
in Europe
with the Cimmerian Bosporus and the mouth of the Maeotis. Kerch'
108 C, 28–109 C, 5 Let the first two be granted. They are hemmed by simple
bays: one, by the bay (on which Gadira is situated) between bay between Calpe and Sacred
Promontory = Atlantic coast of
Calpe and the Sacred Promontory, and by the sea between s. Spain and s. Portugal
the Pillars and Sicily;1 the other, by this sea and the Adria— Adria, Adriatic Sea
although the Iapygian headland has to be added, making Italy Iapygian headland, Capo S.
double-crested and providing something of a complication. Maria di Leuca (It.)
and in his descriptive journey around Libya. For now, it will Libya = Africa
[ 1 ] “Sea between the Pillars and Sicily” = western basin of the Med. Sea: 122 C,
16–123 C, 9.
[ 2 ] The term “detailed description”: 104 C, 1-5n.
[ 3 ] 15 C, 1–109 C, 5.
128
CHAPT E R TWO The “Lived-in World”
Translator’s Introduction
This chapter is required reading for everyone who is drawn to Strabo’s work, wherever
their particular interests lie. In it, Strabo provides us with a full definition of the “lived-
in world,” the many and various parts of which he describes in detail in the following
chapters (chapters 3–5). The “lived-in world” is a difficult concept for modern readers
to grasp, not least because it is based largely on fallacies. One of those fallacies is that,
heading north from the Black Sea, human habitation becomes impossible at a latitude
running through what we now think of as northern Ukraine and southern Russia, and
that, heading south down the Nile, the latitude at which life becomes impossible runs
through what we now think of as South Sudan. Despite or b ecause of these fallacies, it
is important for the twenty-first-century reader to try to understand the concept of the
lived-in world, since it provides the raison d’être of Strabo’s work.
Strabo defines the lived-in world primarily through its external relationship to the
spherical earth. Modern readers are often surprised to learn that Strabo knows of the
earth’s sphericity. In truth, that belief is already several hundred years old by Strabo’s
day. Strabo even has the capability to determine what proportion of the earth’s surface is
occupied by the lived-in world: it occupies less than half the space within one half of the
northern h emisphere. Within this space, the essential characteristic of the lived-in world
is that it is surrounded by a vast expanse of “unlived-in-ness.” This supposed expanse of
unlived-in-ness provides a justification for the concept of the lived-in world and at the
same time acts as its boundary.
To the west, Strabo considers that the immense Atlantic ocean precludes habitation.
(Strabo seems not to have considered sea creatures as agents of habitation—the lived-in
world is a concept constructed for and by man.) In the east, Strabo is misled by reports
that it is possible to sail from India northward along the coast and into the Caspian sea.
These reports are either untrue or misunderstood, perhaps reflecting knowledge of trade
routes by river from India to the Caspian. Nevertheless, they are responsible for the fal-
lacious idea that t here is an expanse of ocean to the north and east of India. Strabo’s
readiness to accept this belief is also the result of a predisposition to see the lived-in
world as symmetrical, with the Atlantic coastline in the west mirrored by an eastern
oceanic coastline.
129
2. The “Lived-in World”
To the north, Strabo determines that a line of latitude running perhaps four thou-
sand stades (just over 450 miles, just under 750 kilometers) north of the Black Sea marks the
end of human habitation. Beyond that latitude, it is considered—wrongly, of course—
that the weather is just so inhospitable that nobody can survive. To the south, Strabo
determines—again, wrongly—that a line of latitude running three thousand four hun-
dred stades (nearly 400 miles, nearly 650 kilometers) south of Meroe marks the point be-
yond which temperatures are so high that h umans simply cannot live. “Meroe” is the
name of the area along the Nile between two of its tributaries (Atbara river and Blue Nile/
Bahr el Azraq), and is also the name of a city (Bagrawiya, Sudan) in the same area. When
Strabo uses “Meroe” as a datum point, it is often unclear in which of these two senses he
uses the name.
Strabo tries to keep an open mind as to whether the areas to the north and south
of the lived-in world are covered by sea—continuations of the sea that lies to the east
and west—or w hether the continental landmass protrudes into them. Strabo’s mind is,
however, most definitively closed when it comes to the possibility of human habitation in
these areas. His axiomatic belief in the ring of unlived-in-ness surrounding the lived-in
world means that he vigorously denies the veracity of any reports of habitation in t hese
areas. T
hese reports are of course true, but had Strabo accepted them, they would have
cut the ground from under the feet of the very concept of the lived-in world.
Having defined the lived-in world by reference to its external surroundings, Strabo
proceeds to describe its inner contents. He is aware that t here are numerous ways of
looking at the landmass that constitutes the lived-in world. It can be envisaged as a
huge island, penetrated by inlets from the surrounding outer sea—these inlets being
the Mediterranean, the Persian Gulf, the Red Sea, and (according to Strabo’s incorrect
assumption) the Caspian Sea. Alternatively, it can be envisaged as three separate con-
tinents: Europe, Asia, and Libya (= Africa). It can be described as it would appear to a
navigator sailing along the inner and outer coasts of these continents. Alternatively, it
can be described as a series of two-dimensional territories or, more abstractly, as a grid
of parallels and meridians.
In the later detailed description of the lived-in world that forms the body of his nar-
rative (chapters 3–5), Strabo uses all these approaches, constantly shifting from one to
another, not always seamlessly. Chapter 2 serves as a sort of table of contents for Strabo’s
detailed description, foreshadowing the order in which continents, territories, coast-
lines, and islands w ill be presented later in the narrative (as elucidated in the footnotes
to this chapter). This foreshadowing clearly shows that Strabo from the outset has a
well-developed mental plan of what he will say later in his work.
In the event, however, Strabo w ill occasionally deviate from his initial plan. A notable
example is provided by Strabo’s treatment of nations living within the Taurus mountain
range. The range itself is conceived of as a partition dividing Asia into two parts, the north
and the south. This raises a question: Are the nations living within the Taurus mountains
130
Translator’s Introduction
Remember
131
CH APT E R TWO The “Lived-in World”
How to Be a Geographer
109 C, 12-20 Since the undertaking of my own project follows on from my 2.5.1
[ 1 ] 15 C, 1–109 C, 11.
[ 2 ] A “chorographer” is perhaps someone who describes the lived-in world, as
opposed to the earth in its entirety: 9 C, 35–10 C, 5n.
[ 3 ] 7 C, 23–8 C, 2.
133
2. The “Lived-in World”
variations. He sees the sun rise and set, and pass overhead, but
he does not ask himself why (to do so would not be advanta-
geous for dealing with his immediate concerns, just as he does
not ask himself whether he stands parallel to his neighbor
or not). Perhaps he does ask himself but holds opinions an-
tithetical to astronomical principles, just as inhabitants of a
given locality do, for each place has its own misconceptions.
110 C, 6-13 He who is concerned with describing the world does not
describe it for the inhabitant of one locality, nor for the sort
of p
olitical being who never paid attention to what is called
“mathematics” in the specific sense—no more than for a
farmhand or ditchdigger. He describes it for the man capable
of taking on trust that the earth in its entirety is as claimed
by mathematicians, and who believes the other things associ-
ated with that assumption. He bids his students that, having
previously accepted t hose beliefs, they should concentrate on
their consequences. He w ill speak of what flows from t hose
beliefs, with the consequence that his audience can use what
they learn more profitably if they listen with a view to mathe
matics. He says that his description of the world is not for
those whose beliefs are otherwise. |
110 C, 14-16 The man who describes the world must, in matters of funda- 2.5.2
134
Geography, Geometry, Astronomy, and Physics
fixed stars revolve with the sky and at the same speed as it.
The fixed stars are therefore carried along parallel circles: the
best-known parallels are the equatorial [circle], the two tropi-
cal [circles], and the arctic [circles]. The wandering stars, together wandering stars = planets
with the sun and the moon, are carried along circles, drawn
obliquely, in the zodiac.
110 C, 27-32 Relying on all or some of these principles, astronomers con-
cern themselves with what follows from them: motions, time
periods, eclipses, sizes, distances, and a myriad other matters.1
Likewise, geometers calculating the measurement of the whole
earth accept the conclusions of physicists and astronomers.2
Geographers, in turn, accept the conclusions of geometers.3 |
111 C, 1-12 We must assume that the heavens are five-zoned, and that 2.5.3
135
2. The “Lived-in World”
111 C, 29–112 C, 2 The geometer accepts these matters and, in addition, 2.5.4
136
The “Lived-in World” and the Spherical Earth
112 C, 12-16 Let it be assumed, then, that the earth (with the sea) is 2.5.5
Spherical earth spherical, with its surface being one and the same as the oceans.
The upward projection of the ground would be obscured: it is
small in the grand scale of things and can be ignored. Conse-
quently, we use the term “spherical” in this case not in the sense
of a sphere produced by a lathe, nor in the theoretical sense in
which a geometer uses it, but in an empirical and rather rough
sense.
112 C, 16-19 Imagine the sphere as five-zoned, with the equatorial circle
drawn on it and another circle (drawn parallel to the equato-
rial circle), which is the boundary of the frozen zone in the
Northern hemisphere of northern h emisphere, and a circle drawn through the poles,
spherical earth
which cuts t hese parallels at right a ngles.
112 C, 19-24 The northern hemisphere contains two of the one-quarter
Northern hemisphere contains parts formed by the equator and the circle through the poles.
two one-quarter parts of the
sphere Each of these includes a quadrilateral area whose northern
Each one-quarter part contains side is half the circle in the direction of the pole and whose
within it one quadrilateral southern side is half the equatorial circle. The remaining sides
are segments of the line through the poles; they lie opposite
each other and are equal in length.
112 C, 24–113 C, 3 We say that in one of these quadrilaterals—it would seem
“Our” lived-in world lies in not to matter which—is located our lived-in world, seagirt
one of the two quadrilaterals
composing the northern like an island. As has been stated, this is a deduction based
hemisphere on empiricism and theory. If anyone distrusts the theory, it
makes no difference from the point of geography w hether
you make it into an island or whether you agree with what
we have learned from experience, namely that there have
been coastal navigations from both directions—from the
east and from the west—with the exception of limited areas
in the m iddle. It makes no difference w hether t hese areas
are bordered by sea or by uninhabited land. The geogra-
pher seeks to describe the known parts of the lived-in world,
and ignores the unknown parts, just as he ignores the parts
outside the lived-in world. It will be sufficient to join with
a straight line the farthest points reached on the coast from
each end and to complete the overall shape of what is said
to be an “island.” |
137
2. The “Lived-in World”
113 C, 4-9 Let the island be projected onto the said quadrilateral. We 2.5.6
138
The “Lived-in World” and the Spherical Earth
the equator to the circle of the summer tropic (i.e., the parallel
drawn through Syene) is four hexecontads. Syene, Aswan (Egy.)
114 C, 1-6 The individual distances are figured out using a ctual
North–south dimension of measurements. It is the case that the tropical circle lies gnomon, rod placed vertically
lived-in world on the earth’s surface to cast a
at Syene, b ecause that is where, at the summer solstice, shadow
the gnomon casts no shadow at midday.1 The meridian Meroe, region of Bagrawiya
through Syene is drawn so that it generally follows the Nile (Sud.)
from Meroe to Alexandria, which is around ten thousand Alexandria, Iskandariya (Egy.)
stades.
114 C, 6-11 It is the case that Syene is located in the middle of this
space, with the consequence that the distance from Syene to
Meroe is five thousand stades. As you go farther south in a farther south = from Meroe
and another three thousand have been added, the total to the Meroe, region of Bagrawiya
(Sud.)
edge of the lived-in world would be eight thousand stades.
The distance from Syene to the equator is sixteen thousand
eight hundred stades (i.e., the sum of four hexecontads, each of
which is given as four thousand two hundred stades). In con-
sequence, the distance to the equator that remains, measured
from the edge of the lived-in world, would be eight thousand
eight hundred stades; twenty-one thousand eight hundred
stades m easured from Alexandria.
114 C, 18-24 Again, everyone agrees that the voyage from Alexan- Alexandria, Iskandariya (Egy.)
139
2. The “Lived-in World”
to its shadow 5 is the same as what was recorded for Massalia by Py-
theas. The parallel through Borysthenes is around three thousand
this = parallel through
eight hundred stades from this. Based on the distance from Massalia Byzantium
to Brettanica, the circle through Borysthenes would be drawn roughly
there = through Brettanica
there. (Great Britain)
115 C, 9-21 Pytheas oftentimes leads men astray, and has lied in this
respect, too. It has been agreed by all that the line from the
Pillars to the places associated with the Strait, Athens, and Pillars, Straits of Gibraltar
Rhodes, lies on the same parallel. It is agreed that the line Strait, Straits of Messina
to Byzantium is some four thousand nine hundred stades. Byzantium, Istanbul (Tky.)
[ 1 ] Farthest known parts beyond Brettanica (Great Britain) = Ierne (Ireland): 114 C,
29–115 C, 3.
[ 2 ] The term “those associated with Thule” is an idiomatic expression, meaning
simply Thule. The reference to the arctic circle (see next note) supports iden-
tification of Thule with Iceland.
[ 3 ] I.e., where the celestial circle of the summer tropic and the celestial arctic circle
appear the same to an observer on the earth’s surface. Nowadays, we would
describe such an observer as being “at the arctic circle.”
[ 4 ] Location of Ierne (Ireland) north of Brettanica (Great Britain): 201 C, 3-8n.
[ 5 ] A gnomon is a rod placed vertically on the earth’s surface to cast a shadow: 111 C,
29–112 C, 2n. The ratio of the rod to its shadow at midday gives the a
ngle at which
the sun’s rays pass over the rod, which in turn allows computation of latitude.
140
The “Lived-in World” and the Spherical Earth
[ 1 ] Byzantium does not (as Strabo believes) lie farther north than the parallel
through Massalia, nor does it (as Pytheas and Hipparchus believe) lie on the
same parallel as Massalia. It lies slightly farther south.
[ 2 ] 112 C, 24–113 C, 3.
141
2. The “Lived-in World”
which we say that the lived-in world is located. The man who
imitates reality as closely as possible must represent the earth
Crates (2nd c. BCE) as a sphere, just like the Cratetium ([Sphere] made by Crates); he
must include on the sphere the quadrilateral, and must place
the geographical map within it. However, the sphere has to
be enormous—so that the said portion, a tiny fraction of it,
is nevertheless sufficiently large to show clearly the constitu-
ent parts of the lived-in world and to give observers a proper
image. For the man with the resources to construct a sphere
of such size, it is best that he does so—and the sphere should
be not less than ten feet in diameter.
116 C, 29–117 C, 3 The man who does not have the resources to construct
a sphere of such size, or at least one not much smaller than
this, should make his drawing on a plane map measuring at
least seven feet. It makes little difference if, rather than using
circles (i.e., the parallels and meridians that we use to show
the climata, winds, other variables and the relationships of climata, geographical
coordinates
the parts of the world to each other and to the heavens),
we use straight lines—parallel straight lines for the parallel
circles, straight lines at right a ngles to them for the circles
at right a ngles to the parallel circles. The intellect is easily
capable of transferring what is perceived visually on a plane
surface, in terms of shape and size, onto the curved surface
of a sphere.
117 C, 3-4 We make an analogous statement about the oblique circles
and straight lines.
117 C, 4-9 If the individual meridians drawn through the poles all
converge at one point on a sphere, but if, on a plane map, the
meridians are represented as straight lines converging only
slightly, it will make no difference. There is no need for this
in many places, and the convergence, like the curvature, is not
apparent when the lines are transferred onto a plane map and
drawn as if straight. |
117 C, 9-11 I will talk in the ensuing narrative as if the drawing is on 2.5.11
a plane map.3
142
Direct vs Indirect Experience
117 C, 12-20 I will distinguish between the part of the earth and sea that
I have myself visited and the part for which I trust in what is
said or written. From Armenia,1 I traveled westward as far as
the places in Tyrrhenia2 opposite Sardo.3 From the Euxine, Tyrrhenia, w. Italy
I traveled southward as far as the boundary with Ethiopia.4 Sardo, Sardinia (It. island)
Not one of those who have written about the world would be Euxine, Black Sea
found to have traveled much of the said distances more than
I have. T hose who have sailed around the western parts have
not reached so many places in the east; t hose who have sailed
in the opposite parts lag behind in the west. The situation is
the same for the north and the south.
117 C, 20-27 They and I largely use reports heard from o thers to piece
together shape, size, and other aspects of its qualitative and
quantitative nature, in the same way as the mind comes up
with concepts on the basis of what is perceived. Our senses
perceive the shape, color, and size of an apple, also its fra-
grance, feel, and flavor. From these, the mind puts together
the mental concept of an apple. Where large-scale figures
are concerned, the parts are seen by the senses, but the whole
is put together by the mind on the basis of what has been
seen.
117 C, 27-34 In just this way intellectuals, using as their “sense organs”
those individuals who have seen certain places and t hose who
have variously traveled through different parts of the world,
construct a unified image of the lived-in world in its entirety.
Even generals, who do everything but are not present every-
where, achieve success through o thers, making use of mes-
sengers and sending out proper instructions based on what
they have heard. Anyone who believes that people can only
have knowledge about things they have themselves seen, that
person ignores the faculty of hearing, which is much stronger
than eyesight when it comes to science. |
117 C, 35–118 C, 14 In particular, men of today would be much better able to 2.5.12
and those outside (Getans, Tyregetans, and Bastarnians);7 outside = north of Danube r.
[ 1 ] Strabo probably means the boundary between Armenia and Cappadocia at [ 4 ] I.e., the boundary between s. Egypt and Ethiopia. The southernmost place at
the Euphrates river (526 C, 34–527 C, 15). Strabo’s nearest attested presence to which Strabo is attested is Philae (Bilaq, Egy.): 818 C, 3-21n.
this boundary is at Comana (Şar, Tky.) and the Pyramus r. (Ceyhan Nehri): 535 C, [ 5 ] Rome launched two attacks against Britain (mid-50s BCE). Strabo’s use of data
20–536 C, 20nn. derived as a result: 193 C, 9-18; 193 C, 34–194 C, 2; 199 C, 10–201 C, 2.
[ 2 ] The westernmost place at which Strabo is attested is Populonium (Populonia, [ 6 ] Rome conducted two major campaigns against Germany (12–9 BCE; 14–16 CE).
It.): 223 C, 27–224 C, 3n. It is possible that he traveled farther up the Italian Strabo’s use of data derived from the campaigns: 291 C, 11–292 C, 10.
coastline as far as Luna (Luni): 222 C, 9-22n. [ 7 ] Rome was militarily active in Danube area (29–28 BCE; after 4 CE; 11 CE). Strabo’s
[ 3 ] Tyrrhenia (w. Italy) is opposite Cyrnus (Corsica, Fr. island) rather than opposite use of the data: 303 C, 19–305 C, 15.
Sardo (Sardinia, It. island). Strabo later repeats the error (222 C, 9-22n) and then
corrects it (223 C, 24–224 C, 8nn). Sardo and Cyrnus w ere governed as one Roman
province (840 C, 13-26), which may have contributed to Strabo’s confusion.
143
2. The “Lived-in World”
118 C, 15-19 The first and foremost requirement, from the point of view 2.5.13
and the Island of the Egyptian Fugitives, and goes as far as the
[ 1 ] Rome was active in Caucasus (mid-60s; late 30s BCE). Strabo’s use of the data: [ 6 ] In the event, Strabo is rather disparaging about the quality of data thus de-
499 C, 35–503 C, 23. rived: 685 C, 20–686 C, 16.
[ 2 ] Strabo probably uses Apollodorus’s work in much of his description of Hyrcania [ 7 ] Strabo frequently refers, in his description of the Nile, to observations he made
and Bactriana: 508 C, 27–510 C, 25; 516 C, 17–518 C, 25. during this voyage: 803 C, 13–818 C, 21. The period of Gallus’s governorship
[ 3 ] The expression “those associated with Apollodorus of Artemita” is idiomatic, provides evidence for the date of Strabo’s arrival in Alexandria (early 20s BCE),
meaning simply Apollodorus of Artemita (1st c. BCE). where he was based for a “long time”: 101 C, 14-24n.
[ 4 ] See 639 C, 15-27n. [ 8 ] For the way station on the Nile at which Strabo is likely to have acquired this
[ 5 ] Strabo’s use of data acquired by Gallus in his campaign against Blessed Arabia information: 815 C, 6-27.
(mid-20s BCE): 780 C, 1–782 C, 26. [ 9 ] For the definition of a spondylus: 113 C, 9-14.
144
Shape of the “Lived-in World” on a Map
parallel through Ierne. The length is represented by the line Ierne, Ireland
Pillars, Straits of Gibraltar at right angles to this, from the west through the Pillars and
Issian gulf, Gulf of İskenderun
Sicilian strait, Straits of Messina Sicilian strait to Rhodia and the Issian gulf, continuing along
the Taurus, which, like a belt across Asia, terminates at the Rhodia = Rhodian territory
(short coastal stretch in sw.
eastern sea, between the Indians and the Scythians beyond Tky. + Rhodes)
Bactriana. eastern sea, Bay of Bengal
lel through Cinnamonland. These sides, if they are extended Cinnamonland, Somalia
145
2. The “Lived-in World”
approximately on the line through Gadira, the Pillars, the Gadira, Cádiz (Sp.)
Sicilian strait, and Rhodia. People say that the celestial ob- Sicilian strait, Straits of Messina
servations, the seasonal winds, and the lengths of the longest Rhodia = Rhodian territory
(Rhodes + short coastal stretch
days and nights (fourteen and a half equinoctial hours) are in sw. Tky.)
all in concordance; and that on the Gadiran coast also . . . *
is seen.
119 C, 24-31 Posidonius says that, from some high building in a city some
four hundred stades from t hese places, he saw a star that he concluded
was Canopus, based on the fact that people who travel only a little way
south of Iberia agree that they can see it and based also on research
Posidonius (late 2nd–1st c. BCE) done at Cnidus (given that Eudoxus’s observatory is not much higher 1 Cnidus, Tekir (sw. Tky.)
refers to observations made by
Eudoxus (4th c. BCE) than t hese strips of habitation 2 and it is said that the fellow saw the the fellow = Eudoxus
star Canopus from there, and given that Cnidus is on the Rhodian clima, parallel, or band of
clima,3 on which Gadira and its coast also lie). | latitude
119 C, 31–120 C, 3 As you sail from there, Libya lies to the south, and the Libya = Africa 2.5.15
Sailing south from westernmost most westerly parts of it jut out only a little farther than
end of lived-in world
Gadira, and then, a fter forming a narrow headland, recede Gadira, Cádiz (Sp.)
to the southeast and broaden out to some degree, u ntil they Western Ethiopians = Western
join up with the Western Ethiopians. These lie at the farthest Sahara, ?Mauritania, ?Senegal
remove from the Carthage region, linking up with the line Carthage, Carthage (Tun.)
120 C, 3-9 If you sail in the other direction from the Sacred Prom- Sacred Promontory, Cabo de
S. Vicente (Por.)
ontory as far as the p eople called “Artabrians,” the voyage is
Artabrians = Cape Touriñán (Sp.)
Sailing north from westernmost northward as long as you have Lusitania to your right, then
end of lived-in world
all the rest of the voyage is eastward, making an obtuse angle
as far as the end of the Pyrenees where they terminate at the
ocean. Due north of this lies the western part of Brettanica. Brettanica, Great Britain
Due north of the Artabrians likewise lie what are called the
“Cattiterides” (Tin islands) in the open sea, located approxi- Cattiterides, ?Cornwall
Brettanic clima = latitude of (UK)/?islands off nw. France
Great Britain mately on the Brettanic clima.
120 C, 9-11 It is consequently clear how greatly the surrounding sea
causes each end of the lived-in world to taper to a narrow point. |
120 C, 12-21 Such being the overall shape, it seems useful to take two 2.5.16
146
Role of the Sea in the “Lived-in World”
ent, and1 the size (the lines along and across it being of var-
ied dimensions); the climata will be more clearly revealed— climata, geographical
coordinates
the eastern and the western ones, likewise the southern and
northern ones.
120 C, 21-26 These straight lines are necessarily drawn through well-
known locations: some (I mean the two central lines, already
defined, representing the length and the breadth)2 were al-
ready drawn; the rest would be easily determined by reference
to the former. Using t hese as, in a way, our “measures” . . . *
the parallel parts, and the other conditions—terrestrial and
astronomical—of the strips of habitation.3 |
120 C, 27-33 It is mostly the sea that describes the world and shapes the 2.5.17
[ 1 ] The translation follows the manuscripts and ignores Radt’s emendation of the
word “and”: Radt, vol. 1, critical apparatus on 120 C, line 18.
[ 2 ] 118 C, 25-32.
[ 3 ] I.e., the climata, Strabo’s treatment of which is delayed u ntil 131 C, 26–135 C, 22.
[ 4 ] A “chorographic” map is perhaps a map of the lived-in world, rather than of the
earth in its entirety: 9 C, 35–10 C, 5n.
147
2. The “Lived-in World”
121 C, 16-21 Picking up again from the initial outline,1 I state that our 2.5.18
121 C, 21-28 The fourth gulf, which much exceeds these in size, is
formed by what is called both the “inner sea” and “our sea.”
It starts in the west with the strait at the Pillars of Heracles; strait at the Pillars of Heracles,
Straits of Gibraltar
stretches out lengthways to the east, and is of variable width;
then splits and culminates in two sea-like gulfs. One, which
we call the “Euxine sea,” goes to the left.5 The other is formed Euxine sea, Black Sea
by the Egyptian sea, together with the Pamphylian and Issian Egyptian, Pamphylian, Issian
seas = e. Med.
seas.6
121 C, 29–122 C, 4 All the said gulfs from the outer sea have narrow en-
trances, more so the Arabian one and the one at the Pillars, Pillars, Straits of Gibraltar
the other two less so. The landmass that surrounds them has
been divided into three, as I said.7 Europe is the most varied
of all; for Libya, the opposite is the case; the configuration Libya = Africa
148
Our Sea (Med. Sea + Black Sea + Sea of Azov)
ships with each other,1 so in this respect, too, the inner sea
offers more variation than the outer sea. There is far more of
the known, the temperate, the settled with cities and well-
governed nations in the case of the former than the latter.
122 C, 9-15 We seek to know about those parts where there is a tra-
dition of more action, government, technology, and other
matters conducive to practical wisdom. Utilitarian consid-
erations urge us t oward t hose places where relationships and
alliances are attainable; and t hese are places that are settled,
rather than t hose where settlement is sketchy. In all t hese re
spects, as I said, our sea is superabundant.2 It is where one
should begin one’s geographical journey. |
122 C, 16-23 It has been noted that the strait at the Pillars marks the start strait at the Pillars, Straits of 2.5.19
Gibraltar
of this gulf.3 At its narrowest point, it is said to be around
1st basin of Med. Sea, west of seventy stades. Those who sail through the narrows, which
Sicily
measure one hundred and twenty stades, see the shorelines
suddenly retreat from each other (more so in the case of the
left-hand shore), then catch sight of a great sea. The sea is
bordered on the right-hand side by the Libyan coastline as far
as Carthage.4 It is bordered on the other side by the Iberian
coastline and by the Celtic coastline at Narbo and Massalia; Narbo, Narbonne (Fr.)
after t hese, by the Ligystican coastline; finally, by the Italian Massalia, Marseille (Fr.)
coastline up to the Sicilian strait.5
122 C, 23-31 The eastern side of the sea is formed by Sicily and the straits
on either side of it. One of these is the seven-stade strait with
Italy. The other is the strait of one thousand five hundred stades
with Carthage. The line from the Pillars to the Heptastadium Carthage, Carthage (Tun.)
(Seven-stade [strait])—which line is part of the line to Rhodes and Heptastadium = Straits of
Messina
the Taurus6—cuts approximately across the middle of the said
sea and is said to m easure twelve thousand stades. This, then, is
the length of the sea. Its maximum width is some five thousand
stades, which is the distance from the Galatian bay (between Galatian bay, Gulf of Lion
149
2. The “Lived-in World”
best of the other islands in our sea),1 the largest are Sardo and Sardo, Sardinia (It. island)
Cyrnus.2 Much smaller than these are the islands of Panda- Cyrnus, Corsica (Fr. island)
taria and Pontia in the open sea;3 and, near the coast, Aethalia,
Planasia, Pithecussa, Prochyta, Capriae, Leucosia, and other
similar islands.4 In the other direction from Ligystica, the is-
lands lying off the rest of the coast as far as the Pillars are few Pillars, Straits of Gibraltar
150
Our Sea (Med. Sea + Black Sea + Sea of Azov)
far as the shoreline that follows, and, together with the Pelo-
ponnese, forms the Corinthian gulf.
123 C, 30–124 C, 3 The Ionian gulf is a part of what is now called the “Adria.” Ionian gulf/Adria, Adriatic Sea
The right-hand side of the Adria is formed by Illyria; the left- Illyria, Slovenia, Croatia, Bosnia-
Herzegovina, Montenegro,
hand side is formed by Italy as far as the recess at Aquileia. Albania
The gulf points north and west, narrow and long, its length
some six thousand stades, its maximum width one thousand
two hundred. Many of the islands there—the Apsyrtides,
Cyrictica and the Libyrnides, also Issa, Tragurium, Black
Corcyra, and Pharos—lie off the coast of Illyria.1 The Dio- Diomedian islands, Tremiti (It.
islands)
median islands lie off the coast of Italy.
124 C, 3-10 As for the Sicilian sea, people say that the distance to Crete
from Pachynus is four thousand five hundred stades, and the Pachynus, Capo Passero (Sic.)
same to Taenarum in Laconia. The distance from the Iapygian Taenarum, Akra Tainaron (Gr.)
headland to the recess of the Corinthian gulf is less than three Iapygian headland, Capo
S. Maria di Leuca (It.)
thousand stades. The distance from the Iapygian headland
to Libya is more than four thousand. The islands here are
Corcyra and the Sybota, off the Epirote coast,2 followed by
(at the mouth of the Corinthian gulf ) Cephallenia, Ithaca,
Zacynthus, and the Echinades.3 |
124 C, 11-15 Following on from the Sicilian sea are the Cretan, Sa- 2.5.21
measured from Attica, some one thousand two hundred Attica, s. cen. Greece
stades, and its length less than twice that much. In this sea
are the islands of Cythera and Calauria,4 those associated with
Aegina and Salamis,5 and some of the Cyclades.6
124 C, 16-24 What comes next is the Aegaean, with the Melas gulf and Melas gulf, Saros Körfezi
the Hellespont; the Icarian sea; and the Carpathian sea as far Hellespont, Dardanelles/
Çanakkale Boğazı
as Rhodes, Crete, Cyprus,7 and the first parts of Asia. . . . * the
first parts of Asia = w. coast of
islands are the Cyclades,8 the Sporades,9 those off the coast Turkey
of Caria, Ionia, and the Aeolid, as far as the Troad (by which
I mean Cos, Samos, Chios, Lesbos, and Tenedos),10 likewise
those off Greece, as far as Macedonia and neighboring Thrace
(Euboea, Scyros, Peparethos, Lemnos, Thasos, Imbros, Sa-
mothrace, and several o thers),11 which I s hall describe in my
detailed description.12
124 C, 24-28 The length of this sea is around four thousand stades or a
little more; the width around two thousand stades. It is sur-
rounded by the said parts of Asia, by the coastline from Sunium Sunium, Kolonnes (Gr.)
[1] Islands off Illyrian coast: 315 C, 7-12, and 24-27. [ 8 ] I.e., t hose Cyclades categorized as being in the Aegean: 485 C, 1–487 C, 31.
[2] Corcyra, the Sybota: 324 C, 11-21. [ 9 ] Sporades: 487 C, 32–489 C, 27.
[3] Cephallenia, Ithaca, Zacynthus, Echinades: 452 C, 34–458 C, 14. [ 10 ] Cos: 657 C, 15–658 C, 4. Samos: 636 C, 33–639 C, 2. Chios: 645 C, 10-31. Lesbos:
[4] Cythera: 363 C, 18-21. Calauria: 373 C, 28–374 C, 5. 616 C, 23–618 C, 27. Tenedos: 603 C, 30–604 C, 12.
[5] “Those associated with Aegina and Salamis” is idiomatic, meaning simply Ae- [ 11 ] Euboea: 444 C, 8–449 C, 30. Scyros, Peparethos: 436 C, 34–437 C, 14. The de-
gina and Salamis. Aegina: 375 C, 8–376 C, 6. Salamis: 393 C, 22–395 C, 6. scriptions of Lemnos, Thasos, Imbros, Samothrace fall primarily within the “east-
[ 6 ] I.e., those Cyclades categorized as being in the Cretan and Myrtoan seas: 484 C, ern E uropean gap”: 329 C, 15–332 C, 1.
29–484 C, 37. [ 12 ] The term “detailed description”: 104 C, 1-5n.
[ 7 ] “Cyprus” is mentioned here out of geographical context. Strabo, or his scribe, may
have intended to write “Cos,” named along with Rhodes and Crete at 488 C, 11-15.
151
2. The “Lived-in World”
coast from the mouth as far as the Dioscurias recess: with the
exception of Carambis, this whole coast has only minor pro-
jections and indentations, so that it appears as a straight line.
They compare the rest of the circumference to the curved
part of the bow, the curvature of which is split: the upper part
is more circular, the lower part is straighter. In just this way,
the sea’s perimeter forms two basins, of which the western one
is more circular than the other. |
125 C, 16-20 Lying to the north of the eastern basin is lake Maeotis, 2.5.23
Sea of Azov which has a circumference of nine thousand stades or even
a little more. Lake Maeotis flows into the Pontus at what is lake Maeotis, Sea of Azov
called the “Cimmerian” Bosporus. The Pontus flows into Cimmerian Bosporus, Straits
of Kerch'
the Propontis at the “Thracian” Bosporus: this is the name
Thracian Bosporus, Bogaziçi
people give to the mouth at Byzantium, which is a tetrasta- (Tky.)
dium (four-stade [strait]).
152
Our Sea (Med. Sea + Black Sea + Sea of Azov)
125 C, 20-23 The Propontis is said to be one thousand five hundred Propontis, Marmara Denizi
stades in length as m easured from the Troad to Byzantium; Byzantium, Istanbul (Tky.)
round the sea to the south and west as far as Alexandria. It Syria, Phoenicia, Egypt = coast
of present-day Syria, Lebanon,
happens that Cyprus 4 lies in the Issian gulf and the Pamphy- Israel, Gaza Strip, present-day
Egypt
lian gulf, connecting up with the Egyptian sea.
125 C, 31–126 C, 3 The crossing from Rhodes to Alexandria, sailing with a Alexandria, Iskandariya (Egy.)
of our sea is the recess of the Great Syrtis and, after that, Great Syrtis, bay off present-
Egyptian Alexandria and the outlets of the Nile. The north- day Libya
ernmost point is the mouth of the Borysthenes or, if one Alexandria, Iskandariya (Egy.)
were to include the Maeotis as a part of this sea, the mouth Borysthenes, Dnieper r.
strait at the Pillars, Straits of of the Tanaïs. The westernmost point is the strait at the Pil- Maeotis, Sea of Azov
Gibraltar
lars. The easternmost point is the said recess at Dioscurias.8 Tanaïs, Don r.
Eratosthenes (3rd c. BCE) Eratosthenes is not correct in saying that it is the Issian gulf, Dioscurias, Sukhumi (Geo.)
[1] Cyzicus, Artaca: 575 C, 18–576 C, 19. Proconnesus: 588 C, 33–589 C, 3. the Black Sea; it is used in contrast to the “Left-Hand Side of the Pontic sea”
[2] 124 C, 28–125 C, 23. (Black Sea coast of Eur. Tky, Bul., Rom., Ukr., Crim., Russ.): 289 C, 1-7n. Cf. the
[3] Strabo picks up the thread of his narrative from 121 C, 21-28. “Right-Hand Side of the Maeotis” (310 C, 24-29); the “Right-Hand Side” and
[4] Cyprus: 681 C, 25–685 C, 5. “Left-Hand Side” of the Caspian sea (507 C, 13-17); the “Right-Hand Side” and
[5] 111 C, 29–112 C, 2n. the “Left-Hand Side” of lake Corocondamitis (494 C, 29–495 C, 5).
[6] The “Right-Hand Side of the Pontic sea” (Black Sea coast of Tky., Geo., Russ.) as [ 7 ] 121 C, 21-28.
a technical term: 61 C, 16-29; 125 C, 7-16; 494 C, 8-14; 497 C, 4-11; 541 C, 17-27. The [ 8 ] 125 C, 2-7.
term is coined from the viewpoint of a navigator sailing from the Med. Sea into
153
2. The “Lived-in World”
126 C, 24-29 I must also provide an overview of the continents surround- 2.5.26
ing our sea, starting at the same place where I started the
overview of the sea.4 Thus, as you enter through the strait strait at the Pillars, Straits of
Gibraltar
at the Pillars, Libya5 is on your right-hand side as far as the
Libya = Africa
course of the Nile; facing it across the strait, on your left-hand
urope.6 Both these two continents
side as far as the Tanaïs, is E Tanaïs, Don r.
have a boundary with Asia.7
126 C, 30–127 C, 7 One should begin with Europe b ecause of its varied
Overview of Europe topography and its superiority in terms of its p eople and
governance and b ecause it has been able to transfer to the
other two continents most of its own benefits, being en-
tirely habitable (except for a small section that is uninhab-
ited b ecause of the cold, namely the part bordering on the
hamaxoeci (wagon-dwellers) in the region of the Tanaïs, Maeotis,
and Borysthenes).8 The part of the continent’s habitable sec-
tion that is cold and mountainous provides a meager living
if relying on nature alone, but if u nder excellent steward-
ship, even t hose areas that offer only a miserable raiding life
can be made civilized. The Greeks, for example, although
living in mountains and on rocky terrain, achieved a fine
standard of living through their political and technical fore-
sight and their other life skills. The Romans took over many
nations who w ere by nature uncivilized b ecause of their
topography—rugged, harborless, cold, or otherwise not easy
to live in . . . *, and by bringing isolated p eoples into contact
with each other, they taught men who were rather savage to
live a civilized life.
127 C, 7-8 As for the part of E urope that is flat and temperate, it has
nature as its helper in these matters.
[ 1 ] Sidene (region of Side, between Fatsa and Boloman Irmak, Tky.) and Pharnacia [ 6 ] Europe: 36 C, 18–489 C, 27 (chap. 3).
(Giresun, Tky.) lie a little farther east than Amisus and Themiscyra, albeit not [ 7 ] Asia: 490 C, 1–824 C, 25 (chap. 4).
as far east as Dioscurias. [ 8 ] Strabo is, of course, incorrect in thinking that the Tanaïs, Maeotis, and Borys-
[ 2 ] 548 C, 15-19. thenes region (Ukraine, s. Russia) represents the northern limit of the Eurasian
[ 3 ] Our sea (Med. Sea + Black Sea + Sea of Azov): 122 C, 16–126 C, 23. landmass; he is also incorrect in assuming it to be uninhabited. For Strabo’s lack
[ 4 ] I.e., the Pillars (Straits of Gibraltar). of information about this region in general: 294 C, 15–295 C, 15; 306 C, 21-24.
[ 5 ] Libya (= Africa): 824 C, 26–839 C, 10 (chap. 5).
154
Three Continents
127 C, 8-18 What lies in fertile territory is wholly given to peace, while
what lies in miserable territory is characterized by war and
machismo; and each of these two types benefits the other,
the latter type helping in terms of weapons, the former type
in terms of agricultural produce, artisanship, and character
building. The harm suffered by each type if they do not co-
operate with each other is clear, but the strength of those
with weapons prevails, u nless brought u nder the control of
the people. This continent, then, has an advantage in this re
spect, for the entire continent is interlaced with plains and
mountain ranges, with the consequence that farming, poli-
tics, and fighting coexist, although the propensity for peace
has the greater influence. This latter element prevails over
the whole, aided by those in power (the Greeks first, later the
Macedonians and Romans).
127 C, 19-25 For this reason, the continent is self-sufficient both in
times of peace and in times of war, for it has an unstinting
supply of people for fighting, for working the soil, and for
governing cities. The continent excels in this respect, too: it
yields the best crops, those that are necessary for life, and such
metals as are useful. Incense and precious stones are imported
from abroad, but w hether p eople have these or not, life is no
worse. The continent likewise has a g reat quantity of livestock
but very few wild animals.
127 C, 26 Such is this continent generally in physical terms. |
127 C, 26–128 C, 2 In detail, the first territory, starting from the west, is 2.5.27
IBERIA Iberia,1 resembling an oxhide, its neck parts (so to speak) ex-
Spain, Portugal, Andorra,
Gibraltar
tending into neighboring Celtica. These are its eastern parts,
and this side is formed by the mountain range called the
“Pyrenees.”2 Iberia is surrounded by sea: on the south side,
by our sea as far as the Pillars; on the remaining sides, by the our sea = Med. Sea
Atlantic as far as the north end of the Pyrenees. The length Pillars, Straits of Gibraltar
of this territory is around six thousand stades maximum, the length = east–west dimension
128 C, 3-16 After this territory, going east as far as the Rhine river, is 2.5.28
155
2. The “Lived-in World”
tian bay,” on which the splendid cities of Massalia and Narbo Massalia, Marseille (Fr.)
are situated. Opposite this bay is another bay with the same Narbo, Narbonne (Fr.)
name, being called “Galatian,” facing in the other direction, Galatian bay (2), Bay of Biscay
ITALY of the Alps, extending to the Adriatic recess and the nearby re-
Italy, w. Slovenia, w. Croatia
gion. The next part is a long, narrow, peninsulating headland
(along the length of which, as I said, the Apennine mountain
range runs), some seven thousand [stades] in length, uneven in
width. Italy is made into a peninsula by the Tyrrhenian sea
(starting from Ligystica), the Ausonian, and the Adria. | Adria, Adriatic Sea
128 C, 31–129 C, 3 After Italy and Celtica, what remains of Europe are its 2.5.30
EASTERN EUROPE eastern parts,5 which are split in two by the Ister river. This Ister, Danube r.
the Rhine), all of the Getan part, and the part belonging to
the Tyregetans, Bastarnians, and Sauromatians as far as the
Tanaïs river and lake Maeotis. It leaves on its right7 all of Tanaïs, Don r.
Thrace and Illyria, and the final and remaining part, Greece.8 lake Maeotis, Sea of Azov
129 C, 4-9 Lying off Europe are islands, which I mentioned.9 “Out- Outside the Pillars = in the
Atlantic
side the Pillars” are Gadira, the Cattiterides, and the Brettanic
Inside the Pillars = in the Med.
islands. “Inside the Pillars” are the Gymnesians and other Phoe- Sea
[ 1 ] Remember that Strabo thinks of the Pyrenees as running from north to south. [ 7 ] Right of Danube (Slovenia, Croatia, Bosnia-Herzegovina, Montenegro, Serbia,
[ 2 ] Strabo is unaware of the nw. bulge of France and thinks of the whole Atlantic Kosovo, w. Hungary, Bulgaria, se. Romania, E uropean Turkey, North Macedonia,
coast of France as more or less a straight line facing northward to Brettanica Albania, Greece): 313 C, 5–329 C, 15.
(Great Britain). [ 8 ] Greece: 332 C, 1–489 C, 27 (chap. 3.3).
[ 3 ] Alps: 201 C, 31–209 C, 14. [ 9 ] Strabo describes islands “inside the Pillars”: 122 C, 16–126 C, 24. He mentions
[ 4 ] Italy (+ islands): 209 C, 15–288 C, 33. Gadira (Cádiz, Sp.), Cattiterides (?Cornwall, UK/?islands off nw. France), and
[ 5 ] Eastern Europe: 289 C, 1–329 C, 15 (chap. 3.2). Brettanica (Great Britain): 119 C, 17–120 C, 9.
[ 6 ] Left of Danube (n. Netherlands, Germany, n. Austria, Czech Republic, Poland,
Hungary, n. Serbia, Romania, Moldova, Ukraine, s. Russia, Crimea): 290 C,
1–312 C, 27-28.
156
Three Continents
lia to the eastern sea among the Indians and the Scythians in eastern sea, Bay of Bengal
that direction. The Greeks call the part of the continent to the inside Taurus = n. Asia
north “inside the Taurus” and the part to the south “outside.” outside Taurus = s. Asia
129 C, 15-22 The part next to the Maeotis and the Tanaïs is the part “in- Maeotis, Sea of Azov
Overview of northern Asia side the Taurus.” Of this part, the first section2 is that between Tanaïs, Don r.
the Caspian sea and the Euxine sea, which in one direction Euxine sea, Black Sea
ends with the Tanaïs and the ocean3 (both the outer ocean
1st + 2nd sections of northern and the Hyrcanian sea); and which, in the other direction, Hyrcanian sea, Caspian Sea
Asia
ends with the narrowest stretch of the isthmus between the
recess of the Pontus and the Caspian. Then t here’s the area Pontus, Black Sea
129 C, 22-26 The one section is occupied by the Maeotians and by those
people (Sauromatians, Scythians, Achaeans, Zygans, and He-
niochans) between the Hyrcanian [sea] and the Pontus as far as
the Caucasus/Iberians/ Albanians. The other section, beyond beyond Hyrcanian sea = east of
Caspian Sea
the Hyrcanian sea, is occupied by Scythians, Hyrcanians, Par-
thians, Bactrians, Sogdianans, and by t hose occupying the re-
maining area north of the Indians.
129 C, 27–130 C, 3 South of part of the Hyrcanian sea, and south of the whole Hyrcanian sea, Caspian Sea
isthmus between that sea and the Pontus, lies the greatest part Pontus, Black Sea
3rd + 4th sections of northern of Armenia, also Colchis and all Cappadocia as far as the Eux-
Asia
ine sea and the Tibaranian nations.5 There is, furthermore,
the territory called “inside the Halys,” encompassing (in the inside Halys = west of Kızıl Irmak
[ 1 ] Asia inside the Taurus = n. Asia: 490 C, 1–685 C, 5 (chap. 4.1). Asia outside the
Taurus = s. Asia: 685 C, 6–824 C, 21 (chap. 4.2).
[ 2 ] 1st section of n. Asia (s. Russia, Georgia, n. Azerbaijan): 492 C, 20–506 C, 32.
[ 3 ] Strabo mistakenly believes in a northern ocean of which the Hyrcanian (Cas-
pian) sea is an inlet.
[ 4 ] 2nd section of n. Asia (sw. + s. Kazakhstan, Turkmenistan, Uzbekistan, Tajikistan,
Kyrgyzstan, n. A fghanistan, n. Iran, n. India): 506 C, 33–520 C, 21.
[ 5 ] 3rd section of n. Asia (n. Iran, n. Iraq, s. Azerbaijan, s. Georgia, Armenia, e. + cen.
Turkey): 520 C, 22–540 C, 29.
[ 6 ] 4th section of n. Asia (n. + w. + s. Turkey, Cyprus): 540 C, 30–685 C, 5
157
2. The “Lived-in World”
130 C, 4-6 Coming after those “inside the Taurus” are the Par- 2.5.32
sea and the southern part of the Atlantic [sea].3 Lying off the southern part of Atlantic
[sea] = Bay of Bengal, Indian
coast of India in this southern sea is Taprobane, an island no Ocean
smaller than Brettanica. A fter India, as you head west with Taprobane, Sri Lanka
the mountains on your right, t here a large territory, poorly
settled because of the miserable conditions, its population
totally barbaric and not all of the same nationality. They are
called “Arianans,” and they stretch from the mountains to
Gedrosia and Carmania.4
130 C, 14-18 Following on from them, in the direction of the sea are
the Persians, Susians, and Babylonians—reaching as far as the
Persian sea—and the minor nations living around them. In
the direction of the mountains and in the mountains them-
selves are the Parthians, Medes, Armenians, the neighboring
nations, and Mesopotamia.5
130 C, 18-24 After Mesopotamia comes the part this side of the Eu- this side of Euphrates = west of
Euphrates r.
phrates. This consists of all of Blessed Arabia (delineated by
Arabian gulf = Red Sea
the entire Arabian gulf and the Persian one); the territory
that is occupied by the Scenitae and Phylarchs, who stretch as
far as the Euphrates and Syria; then the Arabs and Ethiopians
on the far side of the Arabian gulf as far as the Nile; a fter them,
the Egyptians, Syrians, and Cilicians—including those called
“Trachiotians” (Rough-landers)—and finally the Pamphylians.6 |
130 C, 25-32 After Asia comes Libya,7 contiguous with Egypt and 2.5.33
Overview of Libya (= Africa) Ethiopia. Libya has one coastline on our sea, starting at Alex- our sea = Med. Sea
andria and running as far as the Pillars, in what is virtually Alexandria, Iskandariya (Egy.)
a straight line excepting only the Syrtes (and excepting the Pillars, Straits of Gibraltar
occasional moderate curvature of bays and the projection Syrtes, coastline of e. Tunisia,
present-day Libya
of headlands creating this curvature); and it has an oceanic
coastline,8 which runs, from Ethiopia up to a certain point,
approximately parallel to that other coastline but then devi- other coastline = Med. coast
[ 1 ] In the event, Strabo decides (490 C, 13–491 C, 5) to categorize nations dwell- in describing s. Asia (748 C, 20–749 C, 7). Strabo likewise treats Medes and
ing wholly or partially within the Taurus mts. as part of n. Asia. He includes the Armenians as part of n. Asia (520 C, 22–533 C, 4).
Paropamisadians and Parthians in the 2nd section of n. Asia; Medes, Armenians, [ 6 ] The part this side of the Euphrates (s. + w. Iraq, Syria, se. Turkey, Lebanon, Israel,
and Cataonians in the 3rd section; Cilicians and Pisidians in the 4th section. Jordan, West Bank, Gaza, Sinai, Saudi Arabia, Kuwait, Bahrain, Qatar, United
[ 2 ] Part outside the Taurus (= s. Asia): 685 C, 6–824 C, 21 (chap. 4.2). Arab Emirates, Oman, Yemen, Somalia, Ethiopia, Egypt, Sudan, South Sudan,
[ 3 ] India (India, s. A
fghanistan, Pakistan, Nepal, Bangladesh, Sri Lanka): 685 C, Eritrea, Djibouti): 749 C, 8–824 C, 25. In the event, Strabo describes Pamphylia
11–720 C, 7. and Cilicia (s. Turkey) as part of n. Asia: 667 C, 4–676 C, 33.
[ 4 ] Ariana, Carmania (w. Pakistan, s. Afghanistan, s. + e. Iran): 720 C, 8–727 C, 10. [ 7 ] Libya (= Africa): 824 C, 26–839 C, 10 (chap. 5).
[ 5 ] Persians, Susians, Babylonians, and Mesopotamians (Iran, Iraq, se. Turkey, e. [ 8 ] Strabo incorrectly assumes that the African continent truncates before it
Syria): 727 C, 11–749 C, 7. In the event, Strabo describes the Parthians as part reaches as far south as the equator.
of n. Asia (514 C, 24–515 C, 24) and thus makes only a brief reference to them
158
Three Continents
131 C, 7-11 The nations inhabiting Libya are for the most part un-
known. Not much of the continent has been visited by the
military nor by outsiders. Few of the locals make the long
journey to the coast of our sea, and everything they say is du-
bious. Nevertheless, the reports are as follows.
131 C, 11-19 To the southernmost p eople, they give the name “Ethiopi-
ans.” To most of the people below them, they give the names below = north of
[ 1 ] At the time Strabo writes this passage, Gnaeus Piso, who was e arlier the gover- andria after completing his governorship; or Strabo may have met Piso in Rome
nor of Africa, has just been appointed governor of Syria (17 CE). Strabo’s name- at some l ater date.
dropping suggests that he writes t hese words before Piso’s fall from f avor (19 [ 3 ] Cf. 133 C, 10-17.
CE), when Piso was implicated in the death of Germanicus, Tiberius’s a dopted [ 4 ] Cyrenaea + inland nations (present-day Libya): 836 C, 10–839 C, 9.
son and heir. Strabo omits Piso’s name when he refers to the same information [ 5 ] Masaesylia + inland nations (Algeria): 829 C, 20–831 C, 34. Masylians, Carchedo-
at 790 C, 29–791 C, 9. nia + hinterland (e. Algeria, Tunisia, w. present-day Libya): 832 C, 1–836 C, 10.
[ 2 ] Piso was governor of Africa at some point within 12 BCE–6 CE. It is not clear [ 6 ] Maurusians + inland nations (Morocco, sw. Algeria, Western Sahara, ?Maurita-
where Strabo’s conversation with Piso took place. Piso may have visited Alex- nia, ?Senegal): 825 C, 20–829 C, 19.
159
2. The “Lived-in World”
131 C, 26–132 C, 3 It remains for me to describe the climata 2—this too has 2.5.34
be marked on the said meridian through Meroe.6 That fellow Meroe, region of Bagrawiya
(Sud.)
starts with the p eople who live on the equator and then, grad-
ually proceeding through the successive strips of habitation—
every seven hundred stades along the said meridian—he at-
tempts to describe the celestial phenomena in each case.
132 C, 17-24 It is not, however, necessary for me to start from that
point. The reason is that even if these parts are inhabited,
as some suppose, they nevertheless form a distinct lived-in
world, a strip through the center of the uninhabited belt that
is narrow on account of the heat, a lived-in world that is not
160
The Climata
land to the south and the parallel through Ierne to the north.
Bearing in mind this geographical shape, it is not necessary to
go through as many regions as the said intervening distance1
implies, nor to give all the celestial phenomena. |
132 C, 25-33 I should, however, start from the south, as Hipparchus did. 2.5.35
Cinnamonland parallel He says that, for t hose living on the Cinnamonland parallel—which Cinnamonland, Somalia
is three thousand stades south of Meroe, with the equator being eight Meroe, region of Bagrawiya
(Sud.)
thousand eight hundred stades south of the Cinnamonland parallel—
their strip of habitation is very nearly midway between the equator
and the summer tropic, which passes through Syene, given that Syene Syene, Aswan (Egy.)
is five thousand stades from Meroe; t hese are the first p eople for whom
the L ittle Bear is contained completely within the arctic circle and
is always visible,2 given that the bright star at the end of the Bear’s
tail—the constellation’s southernmost star—sits so precisely on the
arctic circle that it brushes the horizon.
132 C, 33–133 C, 2 The Arabian gulf lies roughly parallel to—and east of—
the said meridian,3 and the gulf ’s outlet into the outer sea is
the part of Cinnamonland where, in antiquity, elephant hunt-
ing took place.
133 C, 2-4 This parallel extends in one direction as far as a l ittle far-
ther south than Taprobane, or at least than those living at its Taprobane, Sri Lanka
133 C, 5-8 As for those living in the region of Meroe and Trogodyte Meroe, Bagrawiya (Sud.) 2.5.36
Meroe parallel Ptolemaïs, the longest day consists of thirteen equinoctial Ptolemaïs, ?Aqiq/?Trinkitat
(Sud.)
hours. This strip of habitation is roughly midway between the
equator and the parallel through Alexandria, with an extra
one thousand eight hundred stades on the side of the equator.
133 C, 8-9 The parallel through Meroe extends in one direction
through parts unknown,5 and in the other direction through
the end of India.6
133 C, 10-14 In Syene, in Berenice in the Arabian gulf, and in Trogo- Syene, Aswan (Egy.)
Syene parallel dyte country, at the summer solstice the sun is overhead; Berenice, Bender el-Kebir/
Medinet el-Haras (Egy.)
the longest day is thirteen-and-a-half equinoctial hours;
Trogodyte country, Red Sea
and nearly all the G reat Bear can be seen in the arctic circle coast of Egypt
(except for its legs, the tip of its tail, and one star in the
rectangle).
[ 1 ] 132 C, 10-16.
[ 2 ] The arctic circle is the circle of stars around the celestial north pole, which never
dip below the horizon.
[ 3 ] 118 C, 25-28.
[ 4 ] I.e., Ethiopia, Sudan, South Sudan, s. Chad, n. Nigeria, n. Benin, Burkina Faso,
s. Mali, Guinea, Guinea-Bissau. Strabo thinks that there is no h uman habitation
south of this parallel. This is a theoretical deduction by Strabo, who has no real
knowledge of these areas.
[ 5 ] I.e., Sudan, s. Chad, Niger, Mali, Mauritania.
[ 6 ] Strabo underestimates the true southern extent of the Indian subcontinent.
161
2. The “Lived-in World”
133 C, 18-22 For all t hose areas lying between the circle of the tropic and 2.5.37
Coele Syria,8 upper Syria, Babylon, Susis, Persis, Carmania, Babylon, Tell Amran (Iraq)
The p eople here are farther north than Alexandria by some Tyrus, es-Sur (Leb.)
one thousand six hundred stades, farther north than Carthage
by some seven hundred stades.
134 C, 7-12 In the Peloponnese, around central Rhodia and around Rhodia = Rhodian territory
(short coastal stretch in
Peloponnese/Rhodian parallel Lycian Xanthus (or just a little farther south) and the area sw. Tky. + Rhodes)
four hundred stades farther south than the Syracusans—here, Xanthus, Kınık (Tky.)
the longest day is fourteen-and-a-half equinoctial hours.
These places are three thousand six hundred and forty stades
from Alexandria, two thousand seven hundred and forty
stades from Carthage.
[ 1 ] I.e., s. Libya, s. Algeria, n. Mali, Mauritania, Western Sahara. Strabo has no pre- [ 4 ] 94 C, 26–98 C, 12 (esp. 95 C, 28–96 C, 5).
cise knowledge of these places. [ 5 ] Strabo often uses “titles” to refer to subsections of his work: 639 C, 15-27n.
[ 2 ] Between the circle of the summer tropic (we would say “Tropic of Cancer”) and [ 6 ] A gnomon is a rod placed vertically on the earth’s surface to cast a shadow:
the equator, the midday shadow points south for at least one day a year, north 111 C, 29–112 C, 2n.
for the rest of the year: 135 C, 23–136 C, 12. [ 7 ] “Carthage” = parallel through Carthage. Strabo uses such shorthand through-
[ 3 ] The name takes into account both the zone north of the Tropic of Cancer out his account of the climata.
(where the midday shadow falls north) and the zone south of the Tropic of [ 8 ] For the sense in which “Coele Syria” is used here: 756 C, 16-18n.
Capricorn (where the midday shadow falls south). [ 9 ] I.e., Egypt, Israel, Jordan, n. Saudi Arabia, s. Iraq, s. Iran, s. Pakistan, India.
162
The Climata
through Lysimachia is a little farther north, which parallel is Massalia, Marseille (Fr.)
Eratosthenes (3rd c. BCE) said by Eratosthenes to go through Mysia, Paphlagonia, and Lysimachia, Baklaburnu (Tky.)
134 C, 31-36 If you sail into the Pontus and head north for some one Pontus, Black Sea
tis, around thirty-four thousand one hundred stades from the Maeotis, Sea of Azov
163
2. The “Lived-in World”
it is this far below the horizon before sunrise and a fter sunset,
it still lights up the eastern and western sky.) On winter days,
the maximum height of the sun is nine cubits. 1 cubit = 2°
135 C, 11-14 Eratosthenes says that these places are slightly more than twenty-
Eratosthenes (3rd c. BCE) three thousand stades from Meroe: it is e ighteen thousand stades Meroe, Bagrawiya (Sud.)
through the Hellespont, then five thousand stades to Borysthenes. Hellespont, Dardanelles/
Çanakkale Boğazı
135 C, 15-18 In the parts that are around six thousand three hundred
stades from Byzantium and farther north than the Maeotis,
the maximum height reached by the sun on winter days is
six cubits. The longest day is seventeen equinoctial hours. |
135 C, 19-22 The parts that come next, ultimately reaching the zone 2.5.43
Shadow Zones
164
Shadow Zones
135 C, 35–136 C, 2 Those people are “heteroscians” for whom the shadows
Shadow patterns in temperate e ither always point northward (as is the case for us)1 or south-
zones
ward (as is the case for t hose who live in the other temperate
zone).2 This is the experience of all t hose for whom the arctic
circle is smaller than the tropic.
136 C, 2-7 Where it is the same or greater,3 this is the start—as far as
those who live right beneath the pole—of the “periscians.”
It is clear that, when the sun remains above the earth for
Shadow patterns within the the entire revolution of the universe, that the shadow will
arctic and antarctic circles
rotate around the gnomon,4 which is why he called them he = Posidonius
136 C, 13-17 Now that I have provided an initial outline of geography,7 the 3.1.1
Strabo segues from his ensuing narrative is appropriate as a detailed description.8
description of geography
in general to his detailed This is what I promised,9 and it seems that at this point the
geographical account of the matter has been correctly sectionalized. I must begin again
lived-in world
with Europe10 and with the parts where I began earlier,11 for
the same reasons. |
[ 1 ] I.e., those who live in the temperate zone in the northern hemisphere. [ 5 ] If the regions are uninhabitable, then “periscians” applies to hypothetical
[ 2 ] I.e., in the temperate zone in the southern hemisphere. rather than a ctual observers.
[ 3 ] I.e., places on the earth’s surface where the celestial arctic circle appears to an [ 6 ] 114 C, 29–115 C, 3.
observer to be the same size as, or greater than, the celestial tropical circle. [ 7 ] 1 C, 1–136 C, 12.
[ 4 ] I.e., will rotate around the gnomon on a daily basis. This makes the term [ 8 ] 136 C, 18–839 C, 10. The term “detailed description”: 104 C, 1-5n.
“periscian” somewhat different from the terms “amphiscian” and “heteroscian,” [ 9 ] 112 C, 3-11.
which are based on shadow directions at midday over the course of a year. The [ 10 ] Prior treatment of Europe: 126 C, 30–129 C, 9.
“gnomon”: 111 C, 29–112 C, 2n. [ 11 ] Iberia (Spain, Portugal, Andorra, Gibraltar) as starting point: 127 C, 26–128 C, 2.
165
Iceland
Gre
at B
d
s
nd
lan
rla
rita
Germany
Ire
the
Ne
in
Rh
Be
lgi
ine
um
Luxembourg
2 Croatia
Italy
Spain Corsica 4
Portugal
1
ce
Sardinia
Gree
Turkey
Sicily
Algeria
Crete
Translator’s Introduction
In the previous chapter, Strabo has divided the lived-in world into three continents. He
now launches into his detailed description of those continents. He starts as he means to
go on, taking the continent of E urope and chopping it into sections and subsections,
before delving into each of those sections and subsections in detail. Thus, he first divides
Europe into its western and eastern parts. Starting with western Europe, he subdivides
it into Iberia (Spain, Portugal, Andorra, Gibraltar); Celtica (France, Belgium, Luxembourg,
western Switzerland, southern Netherlands, western Germany); the Alps (parts of Italy, France,
Germany, Switzerland, Austria, Slovenia, Croatia, and also Monaco and Liechtenstein); and
Italy (present-day Italy, with parts of Slovenia and Croatia). Taking Iberia first, he zooms in
on the promontory in its southwestern corner (Cabo de São Vicente, Portugal), his account
of which thus marks the start of his description not only of western Europe but of the
lived-in world in its entirety.
Strabo considers this promontory, which he calls the “Sacred Promontory,” to be the
westernmost point of the lived-in world. We now know that a promontory farther to
the north (Cabo de Roca, Portugal) is the westernmost point of mainland E urope and that
parts of Ireland lie on a yet more westerly longitude, while Africa bulges farther west than
any part of mainland Europe or of Ireland. Nevertheless, in Strabo’s time, it was taken
as read that no part of the lived-in world lay farther west than the Sacred Promontory,
whose ancient name is still reflected in the Portuguese town of Sagres located there.
Strabo not only believes that the Sacred Promontory is the westernmost part of the
lived-in world but also considers it to lie on the same parallel as the lived-in world’s east-
ernmost part—namely, what we now think of as northeastern India and Bangladesh. It is a
happy coincidence that the westernmost point of the lived-in world and the easternmost
point are supposed to lie due west and east of each other—in other words, on the same par-
allel. (Incidentally, although the Sacred Promontory is no longer considered the western-
most part of the Eurasian landmass, it is still considered to be the western end of the longest
line that can be drawn across the landmass along a parallel from one coast to the other—a
line now conceived as ending much farther to the east, on the eastern coast of China.)
Strabo has visited some of the places he mentions in this chapter. Most notably, he
has visited Rome and followed the coast of Italy northward from there, at least as far
as Populonium (Populonia, Italy) and quite probably as far as Luna (Luni, Italy). He
167
3.1. Western Europe
specifically tells us that this stretch of Italian coast represents the westernmost point
of his travels (“westernmost” from the perspective of his homeland in what we now
call Turkey). We can therefore deduce that Strabo has not visited the parts of Europe
farther west, namely Iberia or Celtica. Many of the descriptions of those latter areas
have the vivacity of eyewitness accounts, but they must have been witnessed by eyes
other than Strabo’s.
The coast of Italy in the region of Populonium or Luna is, in all probability, also the
northernmost latitude reached by Strabo, although Strabo himself would not have be-
lieved so. He mistakenly compresses E urope southward, u
nder the false impression that
Massalia (Marseille, France) lies on the same latitude as, or perhaps even farther south
than, Byzantium (Istanbul, Turkey). Strabo implies that he has traveled to the Black Sea
shore of what we now think of as Turkey and that it represents the northern limit of his
travels, whereas in fact it lies at a slightly more southerly latitude than Populonium.
168
Translator’s Introduction
Strabo adopts a diff erent methodology in describing the islands associated with Italy
(e.g., Elba, Corsica, Sardinia, Sicily, Malta). These islands are embedded within Strabo’s
description of the Italian coastline as if they were continuations of it, rather than added
at the end of his description of the mainland as in the case of the Iberian and Atlantic is-
lands. This stratagem leaves Strabo f ree to end his account of Italy, and of western Europe
in general, on a different note, with resounding praise for the way Rome has managed,
and continues to manage, her far-flung empire. Strabo, momentarily unfettered by the
bounds of space, extends his praise from Roman activities in E urope to Roman successes
in Africa and Asia as well.
Scale
“Western E urope,” as shown on the accompanying map, is drawn according to present-
day conceptualizations rather than reflecting how Strabo might have portrayed it had he
been cartographically inclined. In particular, the accompanying map is drawn to scale.
Were it to be scaled according to the number of words used by Strabo to describe the areas
shown rather than according to the geographic space that they occupy, the result would
be very diff erent. Italy would be more than twice the size of France, and Sicily would be
fifteen times the size of Great Britain. Strabo’s literary approach to geography achieves
something that a scaled map cannot do. It makes places loom larger in the imagina-
tion than is warranted by their physical size. For Strabo, Italy is far more important—
culturally, historically, and politically—than the rest of western Europe. Before we accuse
Strabo of being overly Italo-centric, we should note that, when he l ater comes to describe
Greece, he will devote twice as many words to it as he does to Italy, making Greece double
the size of Italy in cultural terms.
Complicating the picture is Strabo’s serious underestimation of the actual size of
mainland Celtica. In a move that does him no credit, Strabo rejects reports of the huge
northwestern projection of present-day France. T hese reports w ere derived from a
navigator called Pytheas, of whom, as we saw in the first chapter, Strabo is highly con-
temptuous. Further vitiating Strabo’s account of Celtica are his beliefs that the Pyrenean
mountain range runs from due north to due south and that the distance along the Pyr-
enees represents the maximum north–south dimension of Celtica from the Atlantic to
the Mediterranean. These misconceptions have serious repercussions for Strabo’s depic-
tion of Celtica, obfuscating it sometimes to the point of incomprehensibility, since he
still tries to fit into his account a vague awareness of what we now call the Bay of Biscay.
As always, however, the point of reading Strabo is not to get an accurate picture of the
world. Rather, we need to listen to what Strabo has to say about the history and culture
of his time. The stories he tells of the desperation with which the Cantabrians fought
to maintain their independence from Rome make sobering reading, with vignettes of
women killing their c hildren rather than have them live in captivity, and an imprisoned
169
3.1. Western Europe
f amily, unable to get hold of weapons to kill themselves, ordering a four-year-old boy to
do the deed. The history of western E urope in Strabo’s time is largely one of older cul-
tures being eclipsed by a new and technologically superior entity, namely Rome. Reading
Strabo’s account is a reminder of the intra-European colonization that took place before
the E
uropean powers expanded into other continents.
Remember
170
CH APT E R TH R E E Western Europe
PART 1
136 C, 18–137 C, 8 The first section of E urope is, as I said, the western one, 3.1.2
137 C, 15-20 Celtica and Iberia are both of uneven width, the narrowest
point of each (from our sea to the ocean) being the part in the our sea = Med. Sea
immediate vicinity of the Pyrenees at e ither end, resulting in ocean, Atlantic Ocean,
specifically Bay of Biscay and
bays on the ocean as well as bays on our sea, of which the Celtic English Channel
bays4—they also call them “Galatian”5—are larger and make a
somewhat narrow isthmus compared to the Iberian isthmus.
137 C, 20-26 So, then, the eastern side of Iberia is formed by the
Pillars, Straits of Gibraltar
Pyrenees. The southern side is formed by our sea from the
outer sea, Atlantic
Pyrenees to the Pillars, and then by the outer sea as far as
Sacred Promontory, Cabo de S.
what is called the “Sacred Promontory.” The third side is Vicente (Por.)
[ 1 ] 127 C, 26–128 C, 2.
[ 2 ] South side of Iberia outside the Pillars: 137 C, 27–151 C, 27.
[ 3 ] The “front parts” are the neck of the oxhide. Strabo’s analogy reflects his false
conceptualization of neighboring Celtica as a narrow neck of land: 137 C, 15-20;
166 C, 11-13.
[ 4 ] Celtic/Galatian bays on Med. Sea, 178 C, 24–184 C, 11 (esp. 181 C, 18-28); on Atlantic,
189 C, 25–195 C, 17 (esp. 190 C, 19-26). Strabo underestimates the nw. projection
of Celtica (Finistère, Fr.): 195 C, 13-17.
[ 5 ] “They” are Latin speakers; Strabo transliterates into Greek the Latin adjective
Galatici. Strabo’s transliteration of Latin names: 508 C, 10-18n.
171
3.1. Western Europe
Atlantic Coast
137 C, 27-34 Let me take up my detailed description, beginning with the 3.1.4
Southern side of Iberia: Atlantic Sacred Promontory. This is the most westerly point not only Sacred Promontory, Cabo de S.
coast Vicente (Por.)
s. Portugal, sw. Spain
of Europe but of the whole lived-in world. The western end of
the lived-in world is formed by two continents, the end points
of E urope and the beginnings of Libya, with the Iberians oc- Libya = Africa (chap. 5)
but this is not at all the case when Artemidorus repeats what is
merely common tattle. For example, Posidonius says that it is
Posidonius (late 2nd–1st c. commonly stated that the sun is bigger when it sets along the oceanic oceanic seaboard, Atlantic coast
BCE)—writing after
Artemidorus—refutes the seaboard and that it makes a sound like w ater hissing, as the sun,
“common tattle” accepted sinking into the depths, is extinguished; this is false, and also false is
by Artemidorus
the statement that “night immediately follows the setting of the sun,”
since it does not do so “immediately” but just a l ittle l ater, as is the
case on other great oceans; in places where the sun sets behind moun-
tains, daylight lingers for a longer period, as a result of light diffu-
sion, whereas here the daylight does not linger for so long a period but here = on Atlantic coast of Iberia
[ 1 ] “They” are Latin speakers; Strabo transliterates into Greek the Latin place-name
Nerium: 508 C, 10-18n.
[ 2 ] Eastern side (Pyrenees): 161 C, 33–162 C, 4. Southern side: 137 C, 27–151 C, 27;
156 C, 14–160 C, 35; 163 C, 14-16. Western side: 151 C, 28–154 C, 30. Northern side:
154 C, 31–156 C, 13.
[ 3 ] Strabo maybe influenced h ere by Artemidorus (late 2nd–early 1st c. BCE),
whose description of the world (no longer available) began with Libya (= Africa)
and, proceeding in a counterclockwise direction around the Mediterranean,
ended with Iberia (Spain, Portugal).
[ 4 ] “They” are Latin speakers; Strabo transliterates into Greek (Kouneos) the Latin
name Cuneus. Strabo’s transliteration of Latin names: 508 C, 10-18n.
172
Iberia: Atlantic Coast + Hinterland
138 C, 26-33 Artemidorus says that the sun is one hundred times larger at
its setting and that night falls immediately a fter sunset. We should
not assume that he himself saw this phenomenon when on he = Artemidorus
Strabo points out that the Sacred Promontory, bearing in mind his own statement. Sacred Promontory, Cabo de
Artemidorus (late 2nd–early S. Vicente (Por.)
1st c. BCE) contradicts himself He said that nobody goes there at night—so nobody would be
there at sunset e ither, given that night follows on immediately!
Nor did he see this phenomenon when he was elsewhere on
the oceanic seaboard, given that Gadira lies on the ocean, and Gadira, Cádiz (Sp.)
Posidonius (late 2nd–1st c. BCE) Posidonius and many others disprove it. | ocean, Atlantic
139 C, 1-9 As for the stretches of coastline following on from the 3.1.6
the former flows in a straight line to the sea in the west and is
much longer than the latter, while the Anas turns southward
and defines an interfluvial territory largely occupied by Celtic
peoples and by Lusitanians transferred thither by the Romans
from the far side of the Tagus. The upper reaches of the riv- far side of Tagus = north of
Tejo/Tajo r.
ers are densely populated with Carpetanian, Oretanian, and
Vettonian peoples.
139 C, 9-16 While this territory is only moderately blessed with fertil- this territory = territory
between Anas (Guadiana r.) and
TURDETANIA/BAETICA ity, the territory that comes next, to the south and east, can- Tagus (Tejo/Tajo r.)
sw. Spain
not be praised too highly in comparison to anywhere else in territory that comes
the lived-in world for its excellence and its bounty from land next = territory east of Anas
(Guadiana r.)
and sea. This is the territory through which the Baetis river
Baetis, Guadalquivir r.
runs, a river that rises in the same region as the Anas and the
Anas, Guadiana r.
Tagus, and which is intermediate between the two of them
Tagus river, Tejo/Tajo r.
in size. Like the Anas, the Baetis starts flowing in a westerly
direction and then turns south and flows out to sea along the
same coast as the Anas.
[ 1 ] West side of Iberia as far as Tagus (Tejo/Tajo r.): 151 C, 28–152 C, 26.
173
3.1. Western Europe
139 C, 16-24 They call the territory “Baetica,” a fter the river, or “Turde-
eople who live t here.1 They call the inhabit-
tania,” a fter the p
ants both “Turdetanians” and “Turdulians,”2 some believing
that they are one and the same, others that they are distinct.
Polybius (2nd c. BCE) Among the latter is Polybius, who says that the Turdulians bor-
der the Turdetanians to the north. Nowadays, there is no way to
tell them apart. They are recognized as the most intellectually
advanced of the Iberians. They are literate and possess docu-
ments of great antiquity as well as poems and laws composed
in verse, dating back (they claim) six thousand years. The
other Iberians are also literate, but do not share one script
since they do not even share one language.
139 C, 24-28 This territory—the territory this side of the Anas— this side of Anas = east of Anas
(Guadiana r.)
extends eastward as far as Oretania and southward to the
stretch of coast from the outlets of the Anas to the Pillars. Pillars, Gibraltar
with the outer one, is formed by the Atlantic ocean intrud- outer one, Atlantic Ocean
ing between that stretch of coastline, where the Baetis and
Anas flow out to sea, and the far end of Maurusia. This is the Maurusia, Morocco
location of Calpe, the mountain belonging to those Iberians Calpe (mountain), Gibraltar
outer sea, it is on your right. Nearby, at a distance of forty our sea = Med. Sea
stades, is the famous old city of Calpe, once the Iberian sea- Calpe (city), El Rocadillo,
nr. S. Roque (Sp.)
port. She is said to have been founded by Heracles, according
Timosthenes (3rd c. BCE) to some p eople, including Timosthenes, who says that she
was called “Heraclia” in antiquity, and a great wall and shipyards
are identifiable. |
140 C, 8-13 Then comes Menlaria with its fish-pickling facilities. A fter Menlaria, Valdevaqueros, nr. 3.1.8
Tarifa (Sp.)
Belo (city), Bolonia (Sp.) that comes Belo, city and river, from which there are sea cross-
Belo (river), Río del Valle ings, particularly to Tingis,5 in Maurusia. She also has trading Tingis, Tangier (Mor.)
centers and fish-pickling facilities. Zelis was once the neigh- Zelis, Dchar Jedid (Mor.)
[ 1 ] “They” are Latin speakers; Strabo transliterates into Greek the Latin names Bae-
tica and Turdetania. Baetica in the sense of the Roman province: 166 C, 21-24.
Strabo’s transliteration of Latin names: 508 C, 10-18n.
[ 2 ] “They” are Latin speakers; Strabo transliterates into Greek the Latin ethnic
names Turdetani and Turduli: 508 C, 10-18n.
[ 3 ] 139 C, 29–151 C, 27.
[ 4 ] “They” are Latin speakers; Strabo transliterates into Greek the Latin ethnic
names Bastetani and Bastuli: 508 C, 10-18n.
[ 5 ] Strabo later revises the name from “Tingis” to “Tinga” (Tangier, Mor.): 827 C,
24-28n.
174
Iberia: Atlantic Coast + Hinterland
140 C, 13-19 Then comes Gadira, an island separated by a narrow strait Gadira, Cádiz (Sp.)
inlets at Asta and Nabrissa. (“Inlets” are coastal indentations Asta, Cortijo el Rosario, Mesas de
Asta, Jérez de la Frontera (Sp.)
that fill with seawater at high tide and which provide passage
Nabrissa, nr. Lebrija (Sp.)
into the interior and to the cities along their shores, like rivers
do.) Immediately thereafter comes the divided outlet of the
Baetis. The island created by the mouths delimits a stretch Baetis, Guadalquivir r.
tis river runs—lies behind the stretch of coastline this side this side of Anas = east of
Guadiana r.
of the Anas.5 The borders of Turdetania are formed to the
west and north by the Anas river; to the east by some of the
Carpetanians and by the Oretanians; to the south by those
of the Bastetanians who inhabit the narrow stretch of coast
from Calpe to Gadira and by the coast that follows as far as Calpe, Gibraltar
the Anas. The Bastetanians whom I mentioned are treated Gadira, Cádiz (Sp.)
175
3.1. Western Europe
by Marcellus, and by the Gaditanian city, the latter b ecause Gaditanian city, Cádiz (Sp.)
His brother, Sextus, escaped from Corduba, fought for a short Gnaeus, son of Pompey, was
captured and killed, 45 BCE
while among the Iberians, and stirred Sicily into revolt; driven
Sextus was killed, 35 BCE
from there to Asia, captured by Antony’s generals, he ended
his life in Miletus.
141 C, 32-34 As for the Celtic region, Conistorgis is the most famous;
and, on the inlets, Asta, which is where the Gaditanians con- Asta, Cortijo el Rosario, Mesas
de Asta, Jérez de la Frontera
gregate, since she lies immediately (not more than one hun- (Sp.)
dred stades) b ehind their island’s seaport. |
141 C, 35–142 C, 4 It is the Baetis whose banks are inhabited by the great- Baetis, Guadalquivir r. 3.2.3
176
Iberia: Atlantic Coast + Hinterland
ally one thousand two hundred stades from the sea, as far as
Corduba and places a little farther upstream. The riverlands Corduba, Córdoba (Sp.)
142 C, 9-15 There are some mountain ridges that stretch parallel to
the river, more or less converging with it in the north. They
are full of mines. Silver is most plentiful in the Ilipa region and
in the region of Sisapo, both what is called “Old Sisapo” and Sisapo, ?Los Castillejos de La
Bienvenida (Sp.)
“New Sisapo.” At what is called “Cotinae,” both bronze and
gold are produced. As you sail upriver, these mountains are to
your left. On your right is a plain, which is extensive, elevated,
arable, forested with huge trees, and good for pasture.
142 C, 16-21 It is possible to sail up the Anas, too, albeit not in boats of Anas, Guadiana r.
such size nor for such a distance. Above this river, too, there
are mountains with mining operations; these mountains ex-
tend as far as the Tagus. Places that have mining operations
are necessarily rugged and their soil poor, as are the places
that border on Carpetania and even more so on the Celti-
berians. Such, too, is Baeturia, with its dry plains stretching
alongside the Anas. |
142 C, 22-28 Turdetania itself is exceptionally blessed. Both multi- 3.2.4
177
3.1. Western Europe
the encroaching sea fills them up, with the consequence that
they can be sailed up just as easily as rivers, indeed more easily,
for it is like sailing downriver, there being no opposing cur-
rent and the sea behaving like a river’s stream in bearing one
onward as the tide rises. The tidal increase is greater here than
in other places b ecause the sea, when forced from a g reat ex-
panse of ocean into a narrow channel between Maurusia and Maurusia, Morocco
Iberia, meets r esistance and fortuitously flows into w hatever Iberia, Portugal, Spain
178
Iberia: Atlantic Coast + Hinterland
143 C, 35–144 C, 6 All trade is carried out with Italy and Rome, since the
voyage as far as the Pillars is good (other than some slight Pillars/strait, Straits of Gibraltar
difficulty at the strait), as is the open voyage on our sea. The our sea = Med. Sea
sea routes run through a clima of good weather, particularly clima, band of latitude
when you are on the open sea, and this is an advantage for
freight-bearing ships; and the winds on the open sea provide
speed. An additional f actor is the present peacefulness now
that piracy has been eradicated, with the consequence that Romans campaigned against
piracy, 67 BCE
mariners experience total ease of mind.
144 C, 6-11 Posidonius says that he saw something peculiar on his return
Posidonius (late 2nd–1st c. BCE) from Iberia, namely that the easterly winds on that stretch of sea as
far as the Sardoan bay are seasonal, which is why he barely made
Gymnesian islands,
it back to Italy in three months, having been blown off course in the Mallorca + Menorca (Sp. islands)
region of the Gymnesian islands, of Sardo, and of other parts opposite Sardo, Sardinia (It. island)
these, belonging to Libya.1 | Libya = Africa
144 C, 12-21 Exported from Turdetania are g reat quantities of grain 3.2.6
and wine, and not only g reat quantities of olive oil but oil of
the highest quality. Wax, honey, and pitch are exported, as
also coccus and ruddle, which is in no way inferior 2 to “Sino- coccus = scarlet dye
pean earth.” 3 They build ships on the spot, out of local timber.
They mine salt, but t here is no small number of salt-bearing
rivers. T here is likewise no small quantity of pickled fish
produced from here, and indeed from all along the stretch
of shore outside the Pillars. It is not inferior to Pontic fish- shore outside the
Pillars = Atlantic shore of Iberia
pickle.4 There was formerly a lot of clothing exported, but
the preference now is for the wool—raven black and excep-
tionally fine. People pay a talent for the rams, for breeding talent, largest unit in
Greek accounting system;
purposes. Exceptional, too, are the finely woven garments 1 talent = 6,000 drachmas
made by the Saltietans.
144 C, 22-28 There is an unstinting supply of all types of domestic ani-
mals and game. T here are few harmful animals save for little little burrowing hares = rabbits
179
3.1. Western Europe
purpose. They muzzle them and send them into the burrows.
The ferrets drag out their victims with their claws or make
them flee to the surface, where people wait and catch them
as they emerge.
145 C, 1-4 The great quantity of exports from Turdetania is appar-
ent1 from the size and number of merchant ships. The freight-
ers that make the voyage from t hese p eople to Dicaearchia Dicaearchia, Pozzuoli (It.)
and to Ostia (Rome’s port) are enormous, and their number Ostia, Ostia Antica (It.)
ing a talent, two-cubit long squid, and suchlike. 1 cubit = 1.5 ft.
145 C, 18-25 A great number of big fat tuna fish are driven hither from
the rest of the outer shore. They feed on a sort of acorn, from
an oak that grows right down on the seabed and produces very
plump fruit, the land version of which is common in Iberia,
having the enormous roots of a full-grown oak but never at-
taining the height even of a low-growing shrub. So much fruit
is produced that, when it ripens, the shoreline both inside shoreline inside the
Pillars = Med. shore
and outside the Pillars gets covered with it when it gets left
outside the Pillars = Atlantic
behind by the high tide. The fruit inside the Pillars is always shore
found to be smaller.
145 C, 25-31 Polybius says that these acorns are cast ashore even as far as Latina, w. Italy
Polybius (2nd c. BCE) Latina—unless, he says, they also grow in Sardo and the neighboring Sardo, Sardinia (It. island)
[ 1 ] Probably to Strabo himself, who had in all likelihood visited Dicaearchia (245 C,
26-31n) and Ostia (231 C, 31–232 C, 5n).
[ 2 ] I.e., exports from Alexandria (Iskandariya, Egy.): 792 C, 32–793 C, 9n.
[ 3 ] 141 C, 3–145 C, 4.
180
Iberia: Atlantic Coast + Hinterland
region. Also, the nearer the tuna fish get to the Pillars on their Pillars, Straits of Gibraltar
146 C, 19-28 People say that in the gold dust sometimes are found
nuggets, called palae, weighing a half pound, requiring only
a l ittle refining. They also say that when stones are split you
find small, nipple-like nuggets; that there is a residuum of
electrum after the gold is smelted and refined with a sort of
styptic earth; that when this residuum, a mixture of silver
and gold, is further refined, the silver is burned off and the
gold remains, for its characteristics are that it is easily smelted
and oily in texture. That is why it is preferable to use chaff to
smelt gold, because its gentle flame is appropriate for a softly
181
3.1. Western Europe
the statement that the Phalerian made in connection with the Attican = from s. cen. Greece
Posidonius (late 2nd–1st c. BCE) Attican silver mines, that the men dig as strenuously as if they
cites “the Phalerian” = Demetrius
of Phalerum (late 4th–early expected to bring in Pluto himself! He notes that the zeal and work He = Posidonius
3rd c. BCE) ethic of these people is similar, in that they cut mine shafts that twist these people = Turdetanians
and turn deep into the earth, and they often reroute upward the riv-
ers they encounter in the mine shafts, by means of Egyptian screws,1
but the . . . * is not the same for t hese p eople and the Atticans, with
mining being for the latter like a riddle (“what they caught, they did
not choose,” he says,”and what they had, they got rid of”),2 whilst he = ?Demetrius of Phalerum
it is very profitable for the former, both for the copper workers (who
extract a fourth part of the earth in the form of copper) and for some
of the i ndependent silver workers (who bring up a Euboean talent talent, largest unit in Greek
system of weights
over three days).
147 C, 21-28 He says that tin is not found at the surface, as writers often claim, He = Posidonius
but it is dug up. It originates among the natives beyond Lusitania and Cattiterides, ?Cornwall
in the Cattiterides islands,3 and is also imported into Massalia from (UK)/?islands off nw. France
182
Iberia: Atlantic Coast + Hinterland
the Brettanic islands. He says that, among the Artabrians—the Artabrians = Cape Touriñán (Sp.)
most remote Lusitanians to the north and west—the soil blooms with
silver, tin, and gold, which is white (because it is mixed with silver);
the rivers carry this soil along, and the w omen dig it up with shovels
and wash it in plaited sieves . . . *.
147 C, 28-29 The foregoing is what he said about the mines.1 |
147 C, 30–148 C, 7 Polybius, in mentioning the silver mines of the New Car- New Carthage, Cartagena (Sp.) 3.2.10
Polybius (2nd c. BCE) thage region, says that they are very large; they are some twenty
stades from the city, encompassing an area four hundred stades in
circumference; a workforce of forty thousand men lives there, paying
(at that time) twenty-five thousand drachmas per day to the Roman drachma, silver coin in the
Greek monetary system,
people. As for the mining process, I omit most of it because of roughly a laborer’s daily wage
its length, except the panned silver-bearing lumps, he says, are cut
up and put through sieves into w ater; the residue is further cut up and,
having been strained and the water poured off, cut up again; the fifth
residue, when it is smelted and the lead poured off, yields pure silver.
148 C, 7-11 Even t oday the silver mines are in operation. They are
not, however, publicly owned—neither here nor elsewhere—
but have passed into private ownership. The gold mines are
mostly publicly owned. In Castulo and in other places, t here Castulo, Cortijos de S. Eufemia y
de Yangues, nr. Linares (Sp.)
are special mines for “dug-up lead,” which contains silver,
albeit in such small traces that it does not pay to refine it. |
148 C, 12-16 Not far from Castulo is the mountain range from which 3.2.11
the Baetis is said to flow; they call the mountain range “Argy- Baetis, Guadalquivir r.
Polybius (2nd c. BCE) rus” (Silver) because of the silver mines t here. Polybius says that
both the Anas and this river flow out of Celtiberia, some nine hundred Anas, Guadiana r.
stades apart from each other. As the Celiberians expanded they this river = Baetis
183
3.1. Western Europe
Artemidorus (late 2nd– contradicts him and says that this statement of his is false; likewise
early 1st c. BCE) contradicts
Eratosthenes (3rd c. BCE), who false are his statements that the Sacred Promontory is a five-day sail Sacred Promontory, Cabo de S.
Vicente (Por.)
had relied on Pytheas (4th c. from Gadira (when the distance is not more than one thousand seven Gadira, Cádiz (Sp.)
BCE)
hundred stades), that tidal fluctuations end at this point (instead of
being a phenomenon all around the lived-in world), that the journey
along the northern parts of Iberia to Celtica is more easily made by
land than by sailing on the ocean, and w hatever e lse he said u
nder the
influence of Pytheas’s bragging.1 |
149 C, 1-4 The poet, being a man of verbal felicity and a polymath, 3.2.12
poet = Homer (8th c. BCE) provides us with premises for believing that he was not obliv-
ious to t hese places, if one reasons correctly both from the
weaker argument made concerning t hese places and from the
stronger and more truthful argument.2
149 C, 4-11 The weaker argument is that he knew by hearsay of the ex- he = Homer
Weaker argument is that Homer treme west where, as he says, the bright light of the sun / drawing
has heard vaguely of Tartessus
and uses that vague knowledge black night over the wheat-giving fields falls down into the ocean.
to create the mythical Night is clearly something ill-omened and closely related to
“Tartarus”
Hades, and Hades is closely related to Tartarus. One might
surmise that the poet, hearing about Tartessus, slightly
adapted its name to “Tartarus” for the most remote part of
the underworld; and added an element of myth to preserve
its poetic quality.
149 C, 11-15 Similarly, knowing of the Cimmerians, who lived in the Cimmerians rose to power
8th c. BCE
gloomy northern regions around the Bosporus, he located
Bosporus = Straits of Kerch'
them in Hades. Perhaps it also had something to do with ha-
tred shared by Ionians for this tribe: people say that the Cim-
merian incursion, which extended into the Aeolid and Ionia, Aeolid, Ionia, w. + sw. Turkey
aneae, as part of the continual p rocess of turning fact into Cyaneae, rocks at mouth of
Black Sea
myth. He uses, as a mythical setting, certain rocks that are
dangerous, as people say is the case with the Cyaneae, which
is why they are called the “Clashing Rocks”; and he therefore
represents Jason as voyaging through them. The strait at the strait at the Pillars, Straits of
Gibraltar
Pillars and the Sicilian strait suggested to him the myth of
Sicilian strait, Straits of Messina
the Wandering Rocks.
149 C, 21-23 One might attribute to him a knowledge of the Tartes-
sus region in the weaker sense by interpreting his mythical
creation of Tartarus as a riddle, | but in the stronger sense on 3.2.13
184
Iberia: Atlantic Coast + Hinterland
149 C, 23-30 The expedition of Heracles to this area, and that of the
Stronger argument is that Phoenicians, suggested to him the wealth and easy life of the Phoenicians moved westward
Homer has solid knowledge of from Med. coast of Syria/
Iberia and consciously used it population (who w ere so utterly subjugated to the Phoeni- Lebanon to Spain/Africa, early
as setting for mythical “Elysian cians that most Turdetanian cities and nearby places w ere 1st millennium BCE
plain” and “abode of the
Blessed” in his epic poems now occupied by them). The expedition of Odysseus, which it
seems to me did reach this area and was part of his knowledge,
gave him his opportunity. In consequence, he moved the Odys-
sey, just as he did the Iliad, from the realm of fact to the realm of
poetry and mythical invention customary among poets.
149 C, 30–150 C, 6 It is not only places in Italy and Sicily and certain other
places that provide the evidence of this. In Iberia, too, a city
of “Odyssia” is identified, and a temple to Athena, and a myr-
iad of other traces of the wanderings of that fellow and other that fellow = Odysseus
survivors from the Trojan war. . . . * equally harmful to those Trojan war, late 2nd–early
1st millennium BCE
who lost the war and to those who captured Troy (since the
latter won a Cadmian victory, their homes destroyed and each
man getting little in the way of booty), it came about that
the survivors fled the danger and turned to piracy . . . * and
the Greeks, the former b ecause they lost everything and the
Strabo cites Homer (8th c. BCE) latter b ecause they were ashamed, each man assuming that it
was shameful to stay away for such a long time, far from his f amily,
and then to go back empty-handed to them.
150 C, 7-18 We hear of the wanderings of Aeneas and Antenor, and
of the Enetans; likewise, of Diomedes, Menelaus, Odysseus,
poet = Homer (8th c. BCE) and several others. The poet, having acquired knowledge of so
many expeditions to the extreme limits of Iberia, and learning
of its wealth and other advantages (which the Phoenicians
made clear),1 created there the “abode of the Blessed” and the
“Elysian plain,” to which Proteus says that Menelaus w ill go:
You will be sent to the Elysian plain and to the ends of the earth, / by
the immortal gods, to the abode of flaxen-haired Rhadamanthys. /
Life is very easy for the people there. / No snow, no violent storms, no
rain at all, / but the breezes of gently blowing Zephyrus are continu- Zephyrus, west wind
by the sun. Also appropriate is its being at the ends of the earth,
which we say is the mythical location of Hades. The men-
tion of Rhadamanthys suggests that the place is near Minos,
concerning whom he says, there I saw Minos, noble son of Zeus, /
185
3.1. Western Europe
holding his golden scepter and judging the dead. Succeeding poets
frequently make similar statements concerning the expedi-
tions in quest of the cattle of Geryones and in quest of the
golden apples of the Hesperides, referring to certain “islands
of the Blessed,” which we now know are identified as t hose
islands not far from the end point of Maurusia and not far Maurusia, Morocco
Gadira, Cádiz (Sp.) from Gadira.1 |
150 C, 30-32 I mean that the Phoenicians were the source of the infor- Phoenicians moved westward 3.2.14
to Spain and Africa, early
mation.2 These people held the best part of Iberia and Libya 1st millennium BCE; were
before Homer’s time; and they continued as masters of the conquered by Rome, 3rd–2nd c.
BCE
region u ntil the Romans put an end to their hegemony.
151 C, 1-13 The following is further evidence of Iberian wealth. The
Carthaginians who invaded alongside Barcas found (so Barcas (father of Hannibal)
assumed Carthaginian
writers tell us) the inhabitants of Turdetania using feeding command, 237 BCE
troughs and wine jars made of silver. One would assume that
the belief in the great longevity of the people here was derived
from their great prosperity, particularly in the case of their
Anacreon (6th c. BCE) leaders. That is why Anacreon says I would not wish for Amal-
thia’s / cornucopia, nor for a / hundred and fifty years / of ruling over
Herodotus (5th c. BCE) Tartessus; and Herodotus gives the name of the king, whom he
calls “Arganthonius.” One can interpret Anacreon’s statement
either as referring to this king or, more generally, as meaning
“a long period of ruling over Tartessus.” Carteia, El Rocadillo, nr. S.
151 C, 13-14 Some p eople call current-day Carteia “Tartessus.” | Roque (Sp.)
151 C, 15-27 Closely allied to the territory’s prosperity is the civilized 3.2.15
among the Turdulians, Caesaraugusta in the Celtiberian re- Augusta Emerita, Mérida (Sp.)
gion, and several other settlements—are examples of their Caesaraugusta, Zaragoza (Sp.)
[ 1 ] The “islands not far from the end point of Maurusia and not far from Gadira”
may be the Canary Islands (Sp.) or Madeira (Por.), but see 2 C, 34–3 C, 12n.
[ 2 ] Strabo expands on his earlier comments (150 C, 7-18n).
186
Iberia: Atlantic Coast + Hinterland
river access for most of the way by large ships, and by river-
boats for the remainder; it is also possible to sail even farther
upstream, beyond Moro. Using this city as a base, Brutus (to D. Junius Brutus Callaicus,
Roman statesman, fought
whom the name “Callaicus” was given) fought a war against against the Lusitanians/
the Lusitanians and conquered them. The river’s . . . * so as Callaicians, 138–136 BCE
they head off toward the coast in the south. | Baetis, Guadalquivir r.
152 C, 18-25 Lying inland from the said parts,3 the Oretanians are far- 3.3.2
thest to the south and reach in part as far as the coastline in- inside the Pillars = on Med. side
of Straits of Gibraltar
side the Pillars. North of them are the Carpetanians, then the
Vettonians and the Vaccaeans, past whom flows the Durius, Durius, Duero r.
187
3.1. Western Europe
of the Iberian nations and the one that fought the Romans
for the longest time. The southern side of this territory is
formed by the Tagus; the western and northern sides by the
ocean; the eastern side by the Carpetanians, the Vettonians,
the Vaccaeans, and the Callaicians 3 (these are the well-known
nations, the rest not warranting names b ecause they are small
and insignificant). Some people—in contrast with the men of
today 4—call the latter “Lusitanians.” In the east, the Callai- latter = Callaicians
suffer the brunt of the ocean swell and send it back with corresponding
force . . . *”; on the contrary, the headlands are low-lying and sandy.
He is correct in saying this.6 |
153 C, 11-18 The territory of which I talk is blessed by nature, with riv- territory = territory inhabited by 3.3.4
Lusitanians
ers (great and small) r unning through it, all of them rising in
the east and running parallel with the Tagus. Most provide Tagus, Tejo/Tajo r.
and likewise the Vacua. After them is the Durius, which flows Vacua, ?Vouga r.
from far away, past Numantia and a multitude of other Cel- Durius, Duero r.
[ 1 ] I.e., called by Latin speakers; Strabo transliterates into Greek the Latin ethnic
name Callaici. Strabo’s transliteration of Latin names: 508 C, 10-18n.
[ 2 ] Strabo refers to the territory inhabited by ethnic Lusitanians, whose territory
is greater than that of the Roman province of Lusitania: 166 C, 24–167 C, 10nn.
[ 3 ] These peoples are previewed at 152 C, 18-25.
[ 4 ] I.e., the Romans (508 C, 10-18n), whose province of Lusitania excluded the
Callaicians.
[ 5 ] Strabo h ere uses “length” to mean the longer side of a rectangle and “width”
the shorter side; hence, the length is the north–south dimension of Lusitania,
and the width is the east–west dimension.
[ 6 ] I.e., Posidonius is correct in saying that Aristotle is incorrect.
[ 7 ] Strabo explains the name “River of Oblivion” later: 153 C, 28-34.
188
Iberia: Atlantic Coast + Hinterland
153 C, 28-34 At the farthest extreme, the Artabrians inhabit the region 3.3.5
of the headland called “Nerium,”1 which functions as the end Nerium, ?Cape Touriñán/?Cape
Finisterre (Sp.)
point of both the western and northern sides. In the vicinity
of the headland live Celtic p eoples who are related to t hose
on the Anas. People say that these people and the Turdulians, Anas, Guadiana r.
rally blessed with crops and cattle, and with a great quantity of
gold and silver and suchlike, many of the inhabitants rejected
a lifestyle based on the land and spent their time making raids
and fighting continuously against each other and their neigh-
bors across the Tagus, u ntil the Romans s topped them, hu-
miliating them and reducing most of their cities to villages,
while improving others through amalgamation.
154 C, 11-15 It is reasonable to suppose that such lawlessness began
among the mountain p eople. Inhabiting a miserable territory
and having few possessions, they coveted what belonged to
other people. These others, in defending themselves, inevi-
tably neglected their own affairs. The consequence was that
[ 1 ] I.e., called by Latin speakers; Strabo transliterates into Greek the Latin place-
name Nerium: 508 C, 10-18n.
[ 2 ] Strabo provides background for his earlier reference to the river: 153 C, 18-23.
[ 3 ] 175 C, 25-31n.
[ 4 ] “Men of today” are Latin speakers; Strabo transliterates into Greek the Latin
ethnic name Arotrebae: 508 C, 10-18n.
189
3.1. Western Europe
ing rooms twice daily and steam baths heated by hot stones,
bathing in cold water, and eating one meal a day in a clean
and s imple manner.
154 C, 25-30 The Lusitanians practice divination. They study entrails
without excising them. They also study blood vessels in the
flanks and make prognostications on the basis of touch. They
take omens from the entrails even of men taken in war, wrap-
ping them with cloaks; then, after the man receives a mor-
tal blow beneath the intestines from the priest, they make
a divination based in the first place on the manner of their
falling. They cut off the right hands of the captives and make
dedicatory offerings of them. |
154 C, 31–155 C, 5 All the mountain p eople live s imple lives, being hydropo- 3.3.7
North side of Iberia tae (water-drinkers) and chamaeëunae (ground-sleepers),1 wearing their
n. Spain
hair thick and loose in the manner of women but binding
their foreheads when they fight. They are mostly goat eat-
ers, and sacrifice goats to Ares, as they also sacrifice war cap- Ares, Greek god of war
tives and horses; they perform hecatombs of each type in the hecatomb, large ceremonial
sacrifice
Pindar (5th c. BCE) Greek fashion—as Pindar says, offering a hundred of everything.
They hold competitions in light-armed combat, heavy-armed
combat, and combat on horseback, in boxing, running, jav-
elin throwing, and group maneuvers.
155 C, 5-14 For two seasons of the year, the mountain people eat
acorns, which they dry and chop, then grind and bake, so
that they can be stored u ntil needed. They drink beer but
[ 1 ] Hydropotae and chamaeëunae are quasi-technical terms belonging to a system The terms are sometimes used as ethnic names, with the boundary be-
of classification of peoples based on diet and lifestyle. Compare the following tween the two usages often blurred. Compare “Lotophagi” (Lotus-eaters)
list (by no means exhaustive). Chamaecoetae (ground-sleepers): 506 C, 16-23; and lotophagi: 157 C, 14-20; 829 C, 1-11; 834 C, 25-33. “Troglodytes” (Dwellers-
cf. 197 C, 2-10, and 328 C, 25-27. Polyphagi (omnivores): 506 C, 16-23. Creophagi in-holes) and troglodytae: 42 C, 2-9 n. “Ichthyophagi” (Fish-eaters) and ich-
(meat-eaters): 772 C, 32–773 C, 4; 773 C, 29–774 C, 5; cf. 829 C, 1-11. Hippemolgi thyophagi: 95 C, 28–96 C, 5; 133 C, 14-17; 513 C, 12-24; 720 C, 14–721 C, 6; 725 C,
(mare-milkers) and galactophagi (milk-eaters): 295 C, 36–303 C, 31. Chelo- 32–726 C, 5; 769 C, 1-7; 770 C, 3-13; 772 C, 32–774 C, 5.
nophagi (turtle-eaters): 773 C, 12-22. Anthropophagi (eaters-of-human-flesh)
and poephagi (grass-eaters): 201 C, 3-8. Ostophagi (bone-eaters) and derma-
tophagi (skin-eaters): 775 C, 26–776 C, 4. Rhizophagi (root-eaters): 513 C, 12-24.
190
Iberia: Atlantic Coast + Hinterland
spare the wine (what t here is, they quickly finish off at fes-
tive family gatherings). They use butter rather than olive
oil. They eat sitting down on purpose-built benches around
the walls. They are seated according to age and rank, and the
food is handed around. As well as drinking, p eople dance to
the flute and trumpet, chorus-style except for the addition of
leaps and squats. (In Bastetania, women join in with the men
and hold their hands.)
155 C, 14-24 They are clad in black, mostly in cloaks in which they also
sleep . . . * and use goatskins, as the Celts do. The women go
around clad in mantles and brightly colored clothing. Instead
of coinage . . . * they use a bartering system or cut off a piece
of beaten silver and hand that over. Those whom they con-
demn to death, they hurl from a precipice. T hose who have
committed patricide, they drive out beyond their borders1
and rivers. They marry in the same way as the Greeks do. Like
the Egyptians in ancient times, they expose sick people in the
street in order to get advice from t hose who have suffered
from the affliction. Up u ntil the time of Brutus, they used D. Junius Brutus Callaicus,
Roman statesman, conquered
boats made of animal hides b ecause of their high tides and the Lusitanians, 138–136 BCE
shallows. Nowadays, even dugout canoes are rare. Their salt
is red, white when crushed.
155 C, 25-30 This, as I said, is the way of life of the mountain people,2
by which I mean the Callaicians, Asturians, and Cantabrians,
who define the northern side of Iberia as far as the Vasconi-
ans and the Pyrenees. They all share the same mode of living,
but I shrink from giving even more names, wishing to avoid
the unpleasantness of describing them—unless anyone takes
pleasure in hearing of “Pletaurians,” “Bardyetans,” “Allotri-
gians,” and other names even worse and more forgettable than
these! |
155 C, 30–156 C, 5 It has been the case that their untamed savagery was the 3.3.8
result not only of warfare but also of their isolation: the voy-
age to them takes a long time, as does the overland journey,
and their lack of contact with outsiders has destroyed any
sense of common humanity. Nowadays, they are not subjected
to t hese influences, b ecause they are at peace and b
ecause the
Romans are present among them. In places where this is not
the case, people are even more recalcitrant and more brutish.
Such being the . . . * because of the miserable nature for some
[ 1 ] The manuscripts have “mountains” rather than “borders”; in Greek, the words
are easily confused in the genitive plural (oron vs horon). Examples of probable
manuscript confusion: Radt, vol. 1, critical apparatus on 84 C, lines 25-26, and
on 92 C, line 9; vol. 4, critical apparatus on 632 C, line 12, and on 808 C, line 14.
Examples of horon (“borders”): 117 C, line 15; 191 C, 23; 341 C, 33; 383 C, 2-3; 717 C,
25; 723 C, 33; 787 C, 24.
[ 2 ] 154 C, 11–155 C, 24.
191
3.1. Western Europe
now fight on the Roman side. Tiberius, who has succeeded Tiberius succeeded Augustus
Caesar as Roman emperor, 14 CE
him, has set over the region an army three legions strong (the
army appointed by Augustus Caesar) and has made some of
the people not only peaceable but civilized at last.2 |
Mediterranean Coast
156 C, 14-24 What remains of Iberia3 is our coastline from the Pillars to our coastline = Med. coast 3.4.1
Southern side of Iberia: Med. the Pyrenees, and all the territory lying inland from this Pillars, Straits of Gibraltar
coast
s. + e. Spain coastline,4 varying in width but with a length of just a little width = north–south dimension
more than four thousand stades. The length of the coastline length = east–west dimension
156 C, 25-37 In detail, starting from Calpe, there’s a mountain ridge be- Calpe, Gibraltar 3.4.2
fish-preserving facilities. Some think it is the same as Mae- Maenaca, ?Cerro del Peñón,
Torre del Mar (Sp.)
naca (which tradition tells us is the westernmost Phocaean
city).8 Such is not the case. The latter lies farther away from latter = Maenaca
[ 1 ] 154 C, 4-11. [ 6 ] “They” are Latin speakers; Strabo transliterates into Greek the Latin ethnic
[ 2 ] Organization of the Roman province of Hispania Tarraconensis u nder Tiberius: names Bastetani and Bastuli; cf. 139 C, 29–140 C, 7. Strabo’s transliteration of
166 C, 29–167 C, 14. Latin names: 508 C, 10-18n.
[ 3 ] I.e., “What remains” as per Strabo’s definition of Iberia at 137 C, 9-26. [ 7 ] Calpe (Gibraltar) to New Carthage (Cartagena, Sp.): 156 C, 25–158 C, 29. New
[ 4 ] Inland territory: 161 C, 1–163 C, 16. Carthage to Iber (Ebro r.): 158 C, 30–159 C, 18. Iber to Trophies of Pompey (Panis-
[ 5 ] Strabo refines and enlarges on his earlier comments (106 C, 31–107 C, 5; 137 C, sars, Sp.): 159 C, 19–160 C, 35.
9-14). [ 8 ] Phocaean = “founded by the Massaliotes.” Relationship of Massalia (Marseille,
Fr.) to Phocaea (Foça, Tky.): 179 C, 10-25.
192
Iberia: Mediterranean Coast + Hinterland
comes the Exitanian city, a fter which a type of pickled fish is Exitanian city, Almuñécar (Sp.)
said to be named. | After that comes Abdera, also founded Abdera, Adra (Sp.) 3.4.3
by the Phoenicians.
157 C, 1-14 Inland from t hese places, in the mountains, an “Odyssia”
is identified,1 with a temple to Athena within it, as noted by
Posidonius (late 2nd–1st c. BCE) Posidonius, by Artemidorus, and by Asclepiades of Myrlea, a
Artemidorus (late 2nd–early man who taught literary studies in Turdetania a fter publish-
1st c. BCE)
ing a sort of guide to the nations in the region.2 He says that He = Asclepiades
Asclepiades (late 2nd–1st c. there are memorials in Athena’s t emple commemorating Odysseus’s
BCE)
travels, in the form of shields and bowsprits that have been nailed
up; some of the men who accompanied Teucer on his expedition set- Teucer and Amphilochus were
Greek warriors in the Trojan war
tled among the Callaicians, and t here are two cities h ere, one called
“Hellenes” (Greeks) and one called “Amphilochi” (as if Amphilo-
chus died here and his companions migrated to the interior).
He says that it is recorded that some of Heracles’s companions, and
some p eople from Messene, colonized Iberia. According to him and
others, Laconians occupied a section of Cantabria. P eople say,
too, that t here is a city of “Ocela” founded by Ocelas, who had
Antenor was a Trojan councillor,
accompanied Antenor and his sons as they made the crossing whose l ater journeys feature in
into Italy. Greek myth
157 C, 14-20 In Libya, too, certain p eople (who listen to Gadiran Libya = Africa
Artemidorus (late 2nd–early merchants) 3 believe, as Artemidorus also says, that the people
1st c. BCE)
living inland from Maurusia near the western Ethiopians are called Maurusia, Morocco
“lotophagi” (lotus-eaters),4 since they live off lotus (a sort of grass and
root); they require no drink, nor do they have any, on account of the
desert; they extend as far as the regions inland from Cyrene.5 Then Cyrene, Ain Shahat (Lib.)
were told about him. Known facts lay behind the places and
other t hings that he invented, so that his inventions w ere not
without credibility. Neither should one be surprised if some
people placed their faith in this knowledge and in the poet’s
wide learning and if they used Homer’s poetry to establish
Crates (2nd c. BCE) scientific hypotheses. This is what Crates of Mallus did, as well
as certain others. . . . *7 gave this type of approach so boor-
ish a reception that they not only banished the poet from
[ 1 ] I.e., a settlement supposedly founded by Odysseus, the Greek hero of Homer’s [ 5 ] Strabo’s later and slightly different presentation of Artemidorus’s words (829 C,
Odyssey. 1-11n) illustrates how free-form Strabo’s citations can be—paraphrases rather
[ 2 ] In this paragraph (157 C, 1-14), Strabo expands upon ideas introduced at 149 C, than quotations.
30–150 C, 6. [ 6 ] Strabo revisits the ideas expressed in this paragraph later, in his description of
[ 3 ] Strabo perhaps alludes to Posidonius, who seems to have relied on merchants Maurusia and the Western Ethiopians (827 C, 12-23), L ittle Syrtis and Meninx
from Gadira (Cádiz, Sp.) for the story of Eudoxus’s attempted circumnavigation (834 C, 25-33); cf. 838 C, 24–839 C, 9.
of Africa: 98 C, 13–102 C, 11, esp. 100 C, 18-20. [ 7 ] An expression such as “Opponents of this view” seems necessary at the begin-
[ 4 ] Lotophagi is both a quasi-technical term—part of a systematic categorization of ning of the sentence for Strabo’s comment to make sense.
people according to diet and lifestyle—and an ethnic name: 154 C, 31–155 C, 5n.
193
3.1. Western Europe
and specialized. |
158 C, 7-21 One might surmise that the explanation for the movement 3.4.5
comes New Carthage, founded by the Hasdrubal who suc- New Carthage, Cartagena (Sp.)
[ 1 ] I.e., called by Latin speakers; Strabo transliterates into Greek the Latin ethnic
names Celtiberes and Verones. Strabo’s transliteration of Latin names: 508 C,
10-18n.
[ 2 ] Strabo picks up the thread of his narrative from 156 C, 25-37.
[ 3 ] By specifying that the “Hasdrubal” in question is the man who succeeded Bar-
cas (229 BCE), Strabo avoids potential confusion with the “Hasdrubal” who l ater
took over Carthaginian command (218 BCE).
[ 4 ] 147 C, 30–148 C, 11.
194
Iberia: Mediterranean Coast + Hinterland
sian” Artemis1 at its high point, used by Sertorius as his mari- Sertorius, a Roman, fought on
behalf of Lusitanians against
time base, since it had good defenses, was suitable for piracy, Rome, 80–73 BCE
and was easily visible from a long way off as you approach by
sea. It is called the “Dianium”2 (temple to Diana), which is to say,
the “Artemisium” (temple to Artemis). It has very productive iron
mines nearby, and the little islands of Planesia and Plum- Planesia, ?Isla de Portichol/?Isla
Plana (Sp.)
baria, and inland a lagoon four hundred stades in circumfer-
ence. Then, finally, near Carthage, there’s Heracles Island,
which they call “Scombroaria,”3 after the scombri (mackerel) that Scombroaria, Escombrera (Sp.)
are caught t here and from which the very best fish sauce is Carthage = New Carthage,
prepared. It is twenty-four stades from Carthage. Cartagena (Sp.)
159 C, 11-15 Back on the other side of the Sucro (as you go toward the Sucro, Júcar r.
outflow of the Iber) is Saguntum, founded by the Zacynthi- Saguntum, Sagunto (Sp.)
ans. Hannibal’s destruction of this city, in violation of the Hannibal, Carthaginian general,
destroyed Saguntum, 219 BCE;
agreement with the Romans, precipitated the second war fought 2nd Carthaginian war,
against the Carthaginians. Nearby are the cities of Cherrone- 218–202 BCE
The Iber flows southward from its beginnings among the Dertosa, Tortosa (Sp.)
where the Trophies of Pompey are situated, the first city is Trophies of Pompey, Panissars
(Sp.)
Tarraco. She has no harbor but is situated in a bay and enjoys a
Tarraco, Tarragona (Sp.)
number of advantages, including a flourishing population no
smaller these days than that of Carthage. She is a convenient Carthage = New Carthage,
Cartagena (Sp.)
place for the leaders 4 to stay and is something of a metropolis,
195
3.1. Western Europe
not only for the area this side of the Iber but also for much of this side of Iber = north + east of
Ebro r. (“this side” from a Roman
the area outside. The Gymnesians, which lie in the sea nearby, point of view)
and Ebusus—noteworthy islands—contribute to the city’s fa-
Artemidorus (late 2nd– vorable position.1 Eratosthenes says that the city also has a naval
early 1st c. BCE) criticizes
Eratosthenes (3rd c. BCE) for station and that she is not particularly favored with good moorings,
inconsistency as Artemidorus notes in criticism. |
159 C, 29–160 C, 4 The whole stretch from the Pillars suffers from a dearth Pillars, Straits of Gibraltar 3.4.8
was founded by the Rhodians. Both here and in Emporium, Rhodians = from Greek island
of Rhodes
people worship “Ephesian” Artemis; I will give the reason for
this in my Massalia account.2
160 C, 4-11 The Emporians once lived on a l ittle island off the shore,3
which they now call “Palaeopolis” (Old city). Nowadays, they
live on the mainland. Theirs is a dual city, divided by a wall,
with some of the Indicetans as their neighbors, who, though
separately governed, nevertheless wanted to share a perim-
eter with the Greeks for the purpose of security; and this was a
dual perimeter, split by a central wall. In time, they joined to-
gether under one constitution, a mixed one containing both
native and Greek laws, something that happened in many
other cases. | Nearby, a river runs out from its beginnings in 3.4.9
raco from the Trophies of Pompey, via Iuncarian Plain . . . * Trophies of Pompey, Panissars
(Sp.)
and what is called by the Latin equivalent of “Fennel Plain”7
[ 1 ] Gymnesians (Mallorca + Menorca, Sp. islands) and Ebusus (Ibiza, Sp. island):
167 C, 15-24.
[ 2 ] 179 C, 10-25; 179 C, 3–180 C, 7.
[ 3 ] The “little island” is now a peninsula; cf. 168 C, 25-27n; 169 C, 5-13n.
[ 4 ] Probably primarily the manufacture of sailcloth.
[ 5 ] “They” are Latin speakers; Strabo transliterates into Greek the Latin adjective
Iuncarius, meaning “of Rushes.” Strabo’s transliteration of Latin names: 508 C,
10-18n.
[ 6 ] I.e., called by Latin speakers; Strabo translates into Greek the Latin term [His-
pania] Ulterior (= Roman provinces of Lusitania and Baetica): 508 C, 10-18n.
[ 7 ] Strabo translates into Greek the Latin place-name Campus Foenicularius: 508 C,
10-18n.
196
Iberia: Mediterranean Coast + Hinterland
guntum and Saetabis city, and l ittle by l ittle recedes from the Saguntum, Sagunto (Sp.)
coast and connects with what is called “Spartarian Plain”1— Saetabis, Xátiva (Sp.)
that is, “Plain of Rushes.”2 This plain is large and waterless, Spartarian Plain, ?area inland
from Cartagena to Villaricos (Sp.)
and it is where the rushes are grown that are used to make
the rope exported everywhere, particularly to Italy. It was
formerly the case that the road ran through the middle of the
plain and through Egelasta, a long and arduous route, but now
they have made it follow the coast, only just touching the Plain
Castulo, Cortijos de S. Eufemia y
of Rushes 3 but extending to the same area as previously—the de Yangues (Sp.)
Castulo and Obulco region, through which the road goes on Obulco, Porcuna (Sp.)
to Corduba and to Gadira, the most important trading center. Corduba, Córdoba (Sp.)
Obulco is about three hundred stades from Corduba. Gadira, Cádiz (Sp.)
160 C, 32-35 Writers say that Caesar reached Obulco, and the army en- Julius Caesar defeated the sons
of Pompey at Munda (?Cerro de
campment t here, in twenty-seven days, starting from Rome, las Camorras, Sp.), 45 BCE
at the time he was about to embark on the war at Munda. |
161 C, 1-10 The foregoing is the coastline all the way from the Pillars Pillars, Straits of Gibraltar 3.4.10
the “Idubeda.” Another range stretches westward from the Idubeda, Sistema Ibérico (Sp.)
Celsa, where the river-crossing consists of a stone bridge. Celsa, Velilla del Ebro (Sp.)
[ 1 ] Strabo transliterates into Greek the Latin adjective Spartarius: 508 C, 10-18n. [ 5 ] Strabo thinks of the Pyrenees as r unning north–south and Iberia as being
[ 2 ] Strabo gives the meaning of Latin Spartarius (“of Rushes”). His point is prob shaped like an oxhide: 137 C, 9-14. The expression “this side of the Pyrenees” is
ably that the Latin name Campus Spartarius has the same meaning as the Latin coined from an Iberian perspective and means “west of the Pyrenees.”
name Campus Iuncarius (160 C, 12-17). The two names, however, are applied to [ 6 ] The northern flank of Iberia: 153 C, 28–156 C, 13. “This side of” means “south of”
different plains. the northern flank.
[ 3 ] Strabo translates into Greek the Latin place-name Campus Spartarius, meaning [ 7 ] I.e., the territory “this side of the Pyrenean mountains and this side of the north-
“Plain of Rushes”: 508 C, 10-18n. ern flank as far as the Asturians”: 161 C, 1-10nn.
[ 4 ] Med. coastline and immediate hinterland (s. + e. Spain): 156 C, 14–160 C, 35.
197
3.1. Western Europe
that Sertorius fought his final b attles a fter being expelled Tarraco, Tarragona (Sp.)
from among the Celtiberians. He met his end in Osca. And Hemeroscopium, Denia (Sp.)
later . . . * Ilerda, Afranius and Petreius (the generals of Sertorius, a Roman, fought on
behalf of Lusitanians against
Pompey) w ere defeated by the deified Caesar. Ilerda is one Rome, 80–73 BCE
hundred and sixty stades from the Iber (to the west), around Julius Caesar (= “deified
four hundred and sixty stades from Tarraco (to the south), Caesar”) defeated Afranius and
Petreius, 49 BCE
and five hundred and forty stades from Osca (to the north).
161 C, 25-29 Through these . . . * the route from Tarraco to the most
distant oceanic Vasconians, those in the region of Pompaelo oceanic = on Atlantic coast
and the oceanic city of . . . * is two thousand four hundred Pompaelo, Pamplona (Sp.)
stades to the Aquitanian–Iberian border.
161 C, 29-32 It is among the Iaccetanians that Sertorius sometimes bat-
tled against Pompey, and later, Pompey’s son Sextus battled
against Caesar’s generals. Lying inland from Iaccetania to the
north is the Vasconian nation, with the city of Pompaelo—
that is, “city of Pompey.” |
161 C, 33–162 C, 4 As for the Pyrenees themselves, the Iberian side is heavily 3.4.11
162 C, 11-18 North of the Celtiberians live the Beronians (who have a
Strabo defines Celtiberia by border with the Cantabrian Coniscans, and who have their
reference to surrounding
nations origins in the Celtic expedition); their city is Varia, located Varia, ?nr. Logroño (Sp.)
at the crossing over the Iber; and next to them are the Bar-
dyetans, whom men of today call “Bardyllians.”1 To the west
are some of the Asturians and Callaicians and Vaccaeans, and
[ 1 ] “Men of today” are Latin speakers; Strabo transliterates into Greek the Latin
ethnic name Vardulli. Strabo’s transliteration of Latin names: 508 C, 10-18n.
198
Iberia: Mediterranean Coast + Hinterland
162 C, 19-26 As for the Celtiberians themselves, who are divided into 3.4.13
four sections, by far the most powerful are t hose to the east
and south, the Arvacians, who reach the Carpetanians and
the sources of the Tagus. Their best-known city is Numantia. Tagus, Tejo/Tajo r.
They demonstrated their valor in the twenty-year Celtiberian Numantia, Cerro de la Muela
(Sp.)
war against the Romans. Many armies and their commanders
were destroyed, and in the end the Numantinians endured Numantinians fought Romans,
143–133 BCE
a siege to the bitter end, except for the few men who finally
surrendered the city walls. The Lusonians, too, are in the east,
reaching to the sources of the Tagus.
162 C, 26-32 Segeda is a city belonging to the Arvacians, as is Pallantia. Segeda, Poyo de Mara/Durón
(Belmonte y Mara) (Sp.)
Numantia is eight hundred and . . . * stades from Caesarau-
Pallantia, Palencia (Sp.)
gusta which, as I said, is located on the Iber.1 Segobriga is a
Segobriga, Cerro de Cabeza del
Celtiberian city, as is Bilbilis. Metellus and Sertorius fought Griego (Sp.)
Polybius (2nd c. BCE) their battles about t hese cities. Polybius, listing the Vaccaean Bilbilis, Cerro de la Bámbola (Sp.)
and Celtiberian nations and their locations, includes among Intercatia, ?Aguilar de Campos
Segesama, ?Villadiego (Sp.) the other cities Segesama and Intercatia. (Sp.)
162 C, 32–163 C, 13 Posidonius says that Marcus Marcellus taxed Celtiberia six Marcus Marcellus, Roman
statesman, defeated
hundred talents, from which it is possible to deduce that the Celtiberians, 151 BCE
Celtiberians were numerous and wealthy, despite living in a talent, largest unit in
Posidonius (late 2nd–1st c. BCE) poor territory.2 He makes the following joke, that when Poly- Greek accounting system; 1
criticizes Polybius (2nd c. BCE) talent = 6,000 drachmas
bius says, “Tiberius Gracchus destroyed three hundred of their cities,”
the fellow sucks up to Gracchus by calling mere towers “cities”—as the fellow = Polybius
happens in triumphal processions! Perhaps this statement is not
devoid of credit. Both military generals and prose writers are
easily led to falsification in their embellishment of history.
For example, those who claim that there are more than one
thousand Iberian cities seem to me to reach this conclusion by
calling large villages “cities.” The nature of the territory is not
conducive to a g reat number of cities: it is e ither of poor qual-
ity or very remote and wild. Nor do their lives and activities
(except in the case of those on our coastline) suggest anything our coastline = Med. coast
of this sort. Those who live village-style are savages, and such
are many Iberians. Cities civilize but do not easily do so when
the dominant lifestyle is to dwell in forests to the detriment
of those nearby. |
[ 1 ] 161 C, 11-15.
[ 2 ] It is not clear w
hether the clause beginning “from which” is part of Posidonius’s
statement or Strabo’s addition to it.
199
3.1. Western Europe
163 C, 14-16 Coming after the Celtiberians to the south are those who 3.4.14
trees, grapevines, and fig trees, our Iberian coast has them in our Iberian coast = Med. coast
of Spain
abundance, and they are plentiful in the interior, too. As for
the outer coast, the northern part of the oceanic coast lacks outer/oceanic coast = Atlantic
coast of Spain, Portugal
them on account of the cold, the remainder because of the
negligence of the population in general, and b ecause they
do not live for p leasure but rather for their immediate needs
and bestial instincts, with l ittle moral direction—unless one
thinks that p eople “live for pleasure” who wash with urine
aged in cisterns, and brush their teeth with it, both them-
selves and their wives, as p eople say that the Cantabrians and
their neighbors do. This custom, like ground-sleeping,3 is
shared by both Iberians and Celts.
164 C, 8-11 Some p eople say that the Callaicians are atheists; that the
Celtiberians and their neighbors to the north sacrifice to an
unnamed god by night at the time of the full moon in front of
the entrances to their homes, and that the w hole household
dances and revels all night.
200
Iberia
164 C, 11-15 The Vettonians, when they first visited a Roman encamp-
ment, seeing some of the officers walking around on the roads
while conversing, supposed they were mad and showed them
the way back to their tents, on the grounds that they should
either stay t here and sit still or fight a b attle! |
164 C, 15-26 One might also class under the category of “barbaric” the 3.4.17
Artemidorus (late 2nd–early ornamentation of some of the women, as described by Ar-
1st c. BCE)
temidorus. He says that there are some places where the women
wear iron necklets with a hook that curves above the head and way
down over the forehead; over t hese hooks, when they want to, they
draw their veil so that it spreads out to provide shade for the face (and
they consider that this is decoration!); there are other places where the
women have a tympanium wrapped around their head, curved at the
back of the neck and fitting the head tightly as far as the ear lobes, then
gradually twisted upward and outward; 1 other women depilate the
hairline so that it is shinier than the forehead; some w omen place on
their heads a support about one foot high, around which they weave
their hair, then drape it with a black veil.
164 C, 27–165 C, 2 In addition to the foregoing strange behavior, t here are
many t hings that have been witnessed, or of which stories are
told, in connection with all Iberian nations jointly but most
especially the northern ones, concerning not only their brav-
ery but also their savagery and their animal-like witlessness.
Mothers killed their c hildren before being taken captive dur-
ing the war against the Cantabrians. A small boy, four years of
age, when his parents and b rothers w
ere tied up as prisoners
of war, killed them all at his f ather’s request by getting hold
of an iron implement. A w oman killed her fellow captives.
Someone, when summoned into the presence of drunkards,
threw themselves onto the fire.
165 C, 2-4 These traits are shared by the Celtic, Thracian, and Scyth-
ian nations, as also the courage of both men and women. The
women toil in the fields; when they give birth, they put their
husbands to bed—rather than themselves—and minister to
them!
165 C, 4-6 Often, in the midst of their work . . . *, turning aside to
some small stream, they wash and swaddle.2
165 C, 6-13 Posidonius says that in Ligystica, his host Charmoleos (a
Posidonius (late 2nd–1st c. BCE) Massaliote) recounted to him that “he had hired a group of men and him = Posidonius
recounts a story told to him by
Charmoleos women for digging; one of the women went into l abor, turned aside he = Charmoleos
201
3.1. Western Europe
near her work, gave birth, and returned immediately to her work,
so that she might not lose her pay; he himself saw the woman working he himself = Charmoleos
with difficulty and, although he did not then know the cause, learned
of it later, paid her, and sent her home; she took the newborn to a small
spring, where she washed it, and swaddled it in w hatever she had to
hand, and took it safely home.” |
165 C, 13-21 The habit of riding two men per horse, with one of the 3.4.18
202
Iberia
166 C, 21-24 Now that some provinces have been allocated to the people 3.4.20
and the senate, and some provinces have been allocated to the
Roman province of Baetica Roman emperor,4 Baetica belongs to the people, and a prae-
tor is sent to it, together with a quaestor and a legate. They Castulo, Cortijos de S. Eufemia y
have established its eastern border near Castulo. de Yangues (Sp.)
166 C, 24-29 The remainder belongs to Caesar,5 and two representa- Caesar = contemporary
emperor, Tiberius Caesar
tives (one of consular rank, and one of praetorian rank) are
dispatched from him. The praetorian representative has a
legate with him, so that he can dispense justice to the people
who live alongside Baetica and who stretch as far as the Durius Durius, Duero r.
Roman province of Lusitania river and its outlets—that is, the “Lusitanians,” which is the
name by which this territory is properly known at the present
time.6 This is the location of Augusta Emerita. Augusta Emerita, Mérida (Sp.)
166 C, 29–167 C, 10 The remainder (i.e., the greater part) of Iberia7 falls under
the consular governor, who has with him a significant army
[ 1 ] Strabo thinks of Celtica as an isthmus: 137 C, 15-20n. Galatian bays: 181 C, 18-28; [ 5 ] I.e., the “remainder” of Iberia/Hispania, namely the provinces Lusitania and
190 C, 19-26. Hispania Tarraconensis.
[ 2 ] “ Men of today” are Romans; Strabo transliterates into Greek the Latin names [ 6 ] Strabo uses “properly known” h ere to indicate official Roman nomenclature.
Iberia and Hispania: 508 C, 10-18n. Strabo believes (152 C, 18-35) that the Lusitanians, as an ethnic group, extend
[ 3 ] Strabo translates into Greek the Latin names Ulterior (meaning “Outer”) and north of the Durius river, which forms the northern boundary of the Roman
Citerior (meaning “Inner”): 508 C, 10-18n. province of Lusitania.
[ 4 ] Strabo’s detailed account of the disposition of the Roman provinces under [ 7 ] I.e., the “remainder” of Iberia (after allowing for Baetica and Lusitania), namely
Tiberius: 840 C, 1-28 (esp. 13-26 for Baetica). Hispania Tarraconensis.
203
3.1. Western Europe
that is the city of Noega and a nearby inlet from the ocean, Noega, ?Campo Torres, NW
Gijón (Sp.)
which acts as the boundary between the Asturians and Can-
tabrians. The foothills that follow as far as the Pyrenees are
overseen by the second of the legates, with the other legion.
The interior is overseen by the third legate. He also controls
the parts, finally, that belong to t hose who are called togati
(toga-wearers) because they are peaceable and are in the p rocess
of adopting a civilized, Italian lifestyle, clad in their tebennic tebennic garb = the toga
garb—that is, the Celtiberians and those living near the Iber
on e ither side as far as the coastal areas.
167 C, 10-14 The governor himself winters in the coastal parts, espe-
cially in Carthage and Tarraco, where he dispenses justice. Carthage = New Carthage,
Cartagena (Sp.)
During the summer he travels around, constantly attending
Tarraco, Tarragona (Sp.)
to whatever improvement is required. T here are also procura-
tors of Caesar, men with the rank of knights who distribute
pay to the soldiers for life’s necessities. |
island’s circumference is four hundred stades, its width being Ebusus (city), Eivisa (Sp.)
about the same as its length. The other island is called “Ophi- Ophiussa, Formentera (Sp.
island)
ussa”: it is uninhabited and much smaller than Ebusus and
lies close to it.
167 C, 24-31 As for the Gymnesians, the major island has two cities, major island = Mallorca (Sp.
island)
GYMNESIANS Palma and Polentia, one of them (Polentia) in the east and
Mallorca + Menorca (Sp. islands) Palma, Palma de Mallorca (Sp.)
the other in the west. The length of the island is a little short
[ 1 ] “Men of today” are Latin speakers; Strabo transliterates into Greek the Latin
ethnic name Callaici. Strabo restates here more clearly the sentiments ex-
pressed at 152 C, 18-35.
[ 2 ] “They” are Latin speakers; Strabo transliterates into Greek the Latin name for
the islands, Balearides, ultimately derived from the Carthaginian language:
654 C, 19–655 C, 2. Strabo’s transliteration of Latin names: 508 C, 10-18n.
[ 3 ] The Pityussans in fact lie closer to the mainland. Strabo’s error is perhaps due to
his misconception that the mainland coast runs from west to east: 137 C, 9-14.
However, Strabo does juxtapose islands elsewhere: 222 C, 9-22n; 834 C, 1-8n.
204
Iberian Islands
of six hundred stades, while its width is two hundred stades. Polentia, Alcudia de Polensa (Sp.)
Artemidorus (late 2nd–early Artemidorus gave a width and length twice as great. The
1st c. BCE)
minor island is some . . . * stades from Polentia. In size, it is minor island = Menorca (Sp.
island)
considerably lacking compared to the major island; in its ex-
cellent advantages, it is in no way inferior to the major island.
Both islands are blessed with fertility and have good harbors,
albeit with reefs at their mouths, so you have to be careful
when sailing in.
167 C, 32-37 As a result of the advantageous nature of these places, the
inhabitants are peaceable (as, too, are the inhabitants of Ebu-
sus), but a few malefactors made an alliance with the sea raid-
Q. Caecilius Metellus Balearicus,
ers and discredited everyone. Metellus, who took the name Roman commander, pacified
the islands, 123–121 BCE;
“Balearicus,” led a naval attack against them. It was he who founded Palma and Polentia,
founded the cities. 122 BCE
167 C, 37–168 C, 16 The inhabitants, since the advantages of the place caused
conspiracies to be made against them, although peaceable
nevertheless . . . * they are said to be the masters at the sling-
shot. They have perfected this, p eople say, since the time
when the islands were occupied by the Phoenicians. They Phoenicians, originally from e.
Med., moved westward, early
are also said to be the first to have clothed their people in 1st millennium BCE
the tunic with a broad stripe. They went ungirt into combat
with a goatskin wrapped around the hand and a fire-hardened
spear, sometimes tipped with a small iron point. Around the
head, they had three slings made of melancranis (melancranis
Philetas (late 4th–early 3rd c. being a type of rush that is twisted into rope: Philetas, in the
BCE)
Hermenia, says a ragged and dirty tunic; twisted around his slender
/ waist a length of melancranis—that is, “he has a b elt made of
rope”), of hair, or of sinew. One was long-handled for long
shots. One was short-handled for shots over short distances.
One was midsize for shots over intermediate distances.
They practiced hard with slings even as c hildren, with the
consequence that the people would not give their c hildren
even so much as a crust of bread unless they hit it with a
slingshot. Consequently, when Metellus launched his naval
attack against the islands, he rigged up screens of animal
hide over the decks to provide protection from slingshots.
Metellus transferred colonists
Metellus transferred three thousand Romans from Iberia as when Palma and Polentia were
colonists. | founded, 122 BCE
168 C, 17-24 In addition to the fertility of the soil is the fact that it is not 3.5.2
there = on Mallorca and
easy to find any dangerous animal there. It is said that even Menorca
205
3.1. Western Europe
the little hares are not indigenous but are the progeny of a little hares = rabbits
island they inhabit is not large nor do they occupy much of outer sea = Atlantic Ocean
[ 1 ] 144 C, 22-34. [ 6 ] Strabo often uses “our” in a temporal sense (“of our times”). The census in ques-
[ 2 ] Pityussan and Gymnesian islands: 167 C, 15–168 C, 24. tion was probably that of 14 CE, which Strabo later describes as having occurred
[ 3 ] Perhaps Palomas (Sp. islands) and Peregil (Mor. island), but other identifications “recently”: 213 C, 19-26.
are possible, given that Strabo’s “little islands” may nowadays be peninsulas: [ 7 ] Strabo avoids potential confusion between this Balbus and his u ncle of the
160 C, 4-11n; 169 C, 5-13n. same name; u ncle and nephew were naturalized as Romans in 72 BCE.
[ 4 ] The identity of the “Pillars” is investigated at length: 169 C, 29–172 C, 11. [ 8 ] “They” are Latin speakers; Strabo translates into Greek the Latin place-names
[ 5 ] Strabo refines his e arlier statements (140 C, 13-25, where the distance to Gadira Nova and Gemina, meaning “New” and “Twin,” respectively. Strabo’s translation
from Calpe is indeed given but where Gadira’s proximity to the mouth of the of Latin names: 508 C, 10-18n.
Baetis river is only implied). [ 9 ] The “islet” is nowadays a peninsula: 160 C, 4-11n.
206
Iberian Islands
this shore or the seaport, which Balbus built for them on the seaport, Puerto de S. María (Sp.)
tion of Gadira, also mention an oracle, which they say the oracle, instruction from the
gods
Identity of “pillars of Heracles” Tyrians received instructing them to send forth a colony to
in the oracle Tyrians = Phoenicians from city
the pillars of Heracles.2 They say that the men who had been of Tyrus in e. Med.
sent out on reconnaissance, when they reached the strait at strait at Calpe, Straits of
Calpe—considering that the points of land that formed the Gibraltar
strait w ere the limits of the lived-in world as well as the lim-
its of Heracles’s travels, and that they w ere what the oracle
called pillars—disembarked at a spot on this side of the strait,
where the Exitanian city now is; when they made sacrifices Exitanian city, Almuñécar (Sp.)
207
3.1. Western Europe
founded Gadira, building a t emple in the east of the island Gadira, Cádiz (Sp.)
and a city in the west; for t hese reasons, some p eople think
that the pillars are the tips of land that form the strait, some
that Gadira constitutes the pillars, and some that the pillars
are farther out, beyond Gadira.
170 C, 12-20 Some have supposed that the Pillars are Calpe and Abi- Calpe, Rock of Gibraltar
Identity of “Pillars of Heracles” lyx1 (the Libyan mountain on the opposite side, situated ac-
Eratosthenes (3rd c. BCE) cording to Eratosthenes among the Metagonians, a nomadic
nation), others that they are the little islands near each
Artemidorus (late 2nd–early mountain, one of which they call “Hera’s Island.”2 Artemi-
1st c. BCE)
dorus mentions Hera’s Island and the temple on the island,
and says t here is a second island, but mentions neither mount
Abilyx nor the Metagonian nation. Some writers transfer to Abilyx, ?Monte Acho (Spanish
possession on African side of
this place the Planctae (Wandering [rocks]) and the Symplegades strait)/?Jebel Musa (Mor.)
Pindar (5th c. BCE) (Clashing [rocks]),3 in the belief that t
hese are the Pillars that Pin-
dar calls the “Gadiran Gates,” claiming they were the last place
reached by Heracles.
170 C, 20-30 Dicaearchus, Eratosthenes, Polybius, and most Greek
Dicaearchus (late 4th c. BCE) writers declare that the Pillars are in the region of the strait. strait, Straits of Gibraltar
Eratosthenes (3rd c. BCE) The Iberians and Libyans 4 say the Pillars are in Gadira, on
Polybius (2nd c. BCE) the grounds that the region of the strait in no way resembles
pillars. Some writers say that the Pillars are the eight-cubit- 1 cubit = 1.5 ft.
umn (a sort of mini-tower)6 located on the Strait; and what Strait, Straits of Messina
208
Iberian Islands
209
3.1. Western Europe
172 C, 12-20 Polybius says that there is a spring in the Gadiran Heraclium 3.5.7
(temple to Heracles) where it is only a few steps down to the water (which
Strabo reports various is drinkable); the spring has an inverse relationship with the sea tides,
explanations for behavior of
the spring in the Heraclium at losing its w ater as the tide comes in and being replenished as the tide
Gadira, starting with Polybius goes out. He gives as the explanation that air is forced from the
(2nd c. BCE)
deep interior up to the surface of the earth; when the encroaching sea
covers the earth’s surface, the air is blocked from its natural exits,
turns inward again, and obstructs the underground channels leading
to the spring, causing the w ater in it to disappear; when the earth’s
surface is uncovered, the air goes straight out, freeing up the veins
leading to the spring, which gushes forth in abundance.
172 C, 20-23 Artemidorus, who rebuts this fellow and gives some ex-
Artemidorus (late 2nd–early planation of his own, and who also recalls the opinion of the
1st c. BCE)
writer Silanus, seems to me not worth mentioning: he is a Silanus (3rd–2nd c. BCE)
[ 1 ] Strabo implicitly rejects the argument that “the region of the strait in no way
resembles pillars.” 170 C, 20-30.
[ 2 ] For the words of Pindar: 170 C, 12-20.
[ 3 ] Identification of the Pillars of Heracles with bronze plates in the Heraclium:
170 C, 20-30.
210
Iberian Islands
172 C, 32–173 C, 5 That the story is believed, is something this fellow says and this fellow = Posidonius
perceptibly on the land until the moon is at the zenith; as the celestial
body descends, the sea gradually retreats again until the moon is one
zodiacal unit above setting; the sea stays in the same static state for as
long as the moon gets near setting and even more so for as long as the
moon, moving below the earth, reaches one zodiacal unit below the ho-
rizon; the sea starts encroaching again u ntil the moon is in the below-
earth zenith; the sea then retreats u ntil the moon, having completed
211
3.1. Western Europe
its circuit eastward, is one zodiacal unit from the horizon; the sea
remains static until the moon rises above the horizon by one zodiacal
unit, when the sea again encroaches. He says that is the daily cycle. He = Posidonius
174 C, 2-6 As for the monthly cycle, he says that the tidal movements are
greatest at conjunction; the movements then decrease until half-moon;
the movements then start to increase again u ntil full moon and dimin-
ish again until the waning half-moon; there are increases in the move-
ments until conjunction; the increases are both in duration and speed.
174 C, 6-10 He says that he learned about the yearly cycles from the Gadi- He = Posidonius
rans, who told him that the sea’s retreat and encroachment were
extreme at the time of the summer solstice. He himself thought
it likely that the movements lessened from solstice to equinox and
increased again u ntil the winter solstice; they then lessened u
ntil the
spring equinox, and they increased until the summer solstice.
174 C, 10-21 These being the cycles, since the sea encroaches twice
every day-and-night (as a total period) and twice retreats, and
since the periods of day and night follow a regular pattern,
how is it possible for it often to transpire1 that replenishment of
the well—but not its diminishment—occurs at low tide? Or
for its diminishment to occur often but not equally as often?
Or for it to occur equally as often, but for the Gadirans to be
incapable of observing what happens on a daily basis while
observing annual cycles based on what happens only once a
year? That he trusts the Gadirans is clear from his additional
surmise that there is a lessening and then an increase from one sol-
stice to the other, and then the pattern is repeated. Nor is it likely
that, although they were observant, they did not see what
transpired but believed in what did not transpire. |
174 C, 22-26 He says that Seleucus, who came from the Erythran sea, de- He = Posidonius 3.5.9
Seleucus (2nd c. BCE) scribes an anomaly in these matters and a regularity according to the Erythran sea, Persian Gulf
various zodiacal units: when the moon is in the equinoctial zodiacal
units, its effects are regular, but when it is in the solstitial units, there
is an irregularity both in extent and speed, and analogously in the
case of each of the other signs, depending on their relative proximity.
174 C, 27–175 C, 10 He himself says that he was in the Gadiran Heraclium for sev- He = Posidonius
eral days at the time of the summer solstice, and when the moon was
full, but was unable to discern any annual variation, although, at the
time of conjunction during that month, he observed at Ilipa a g reat dif- Ilipa, Alcalá del Río (Sp.)
ference in the reflux of the Baetis, compared to earlier instances during Baetis, Guadalquivir r.
which it had not even risen halfway up its banks; at that time, the water
212
Iberian Islands
overflowed so much that the soldiers could draw their water on the spot.
(Ilipa is around seven hundred stades from the coast.) He says
that, although the coastal plains w ere submerged by the high tide at
least thirty stades inland, with the consequence that islands were cre-
ated, he m easured the height to which the base of the temple building
in the Heraclium and the base of the mole in front of the harbor at
Gadira were covered by water as not even ten cubits; even if one w
ere to Gadira, Cádiz (Sp.)
add double this for the increase that then occurred, it would not create 1 cubit = 1.5 ft.
such an impression as the huge high tide creates in the plains.
175 C, 10-14 While the foregoing behavior is recorded in general for
the entire circuit of the ocean coast, this fellow says that the this fellow = Posidonius
behavior of the Iber river is unusual and peculiar; it sometimes rises Iber, ?Río Tinto
even when t here is no rain or snow, whenever the north winds predomi-
nate; the reason is the lake through which it flows, for the lake w ater
is driven by the winds. |
175 C, 15-18 Posidonius also records that there’s a tree in Gadira with 3.5.10
Posidonius (late 2nd–1st c. BCE) boughs that bend down to the ground, its xiphoid leaves often being xiphoid, sword-shaped
a cubit in length but only four fingers in breadth; there’s a tree in the 1 cubit = 1.5 ft. = 24 fingers
New Carthage region that produces from its thorns a fiber from which New Carthage, Cartagena (Sp.)
CATTITERIDES to each other, north of Artabrian harbor,4 far out to sea. One
?Cornwall (UK)/?islands off nw.
France
of the islands is deserted. The other islands are inhabited by
black-cloaked people, wearing tunics that reach down to their
feet; they wear their b elts at the breast and walk around hold-
ing staffs, like the Poenae (Goddesses of vengeance) in tragic plays.
The people live off their animals, in a mostly nomadic exis-
tence. They have mines of tin and lead, giving t hese metals
and animal hides to merchants in exchange for earthenware,
salt, and bronze goods.
213
3.1. Western Europe
175 C, 31–176 C, 4 In e arlier times, the Phoenicians were the only ones to Phoenicians from e. Med.
settled Gadira (Cádiz, Sp.), early
engage in this trade from Gadira, keeping the route a secret 1st millennium BCE
from everyone. The Romans closely followed a certain naval
captain in order that they, too, might uncover the market.
The captain, with malicious intent, ran his ship onto a reef.
Leading his pursuers to the same fate—but managing to
save his own life by means of a piece of wreckage—he was
reimbursed at public expense for the value of the cargo he
had lost.
176 C, 4-8 The Romans, after repeated attempts, nevertheless man-
aged to find the way. Publius Crassus, when he made the Publius Licinius Crassus, Roman
commander in Iberia, 96–93 BCE
crossing to t hese p eople, saw that mines need only to be dug
to a l ittle depth and that the inhabitants w
ere peaceable. He
pointed out that now, at last, anyone who wished could profit-
ably trade across this sea, even though it was so much wider
than the sea that separates Brettanica. sea that separates
Brettanica = English Channel
176 C, 9-12 The foregoing was my description of Iberia and its associated
Strabo segues from his islands.1 | What comes next is Celtica beyond the Alps. I have 4.1.1
description of Iberia to his
description of Celtica beyond already briefly sketched its shape and dimensions.2 Now I will
the Alps provide a detailed description of it.3
176 C, 13-18 They used to make a three-way division, applying the names
CELTICA BEYOND THE ALPS “Aquitanians,” “Belgans,” and “Celts.” 4 The Aquitanians are
completely diff erent not only in language but also in physique
(as they resemble Iberians rather than Galatians). The others Galatians, Gauls
are Galatian in appearance, and even though they are not all Galatian, Gallic
214
Celtica
extend as far as the sea on each side (i.e., the inner sea and inner sea = Med. Sea
the outer sea), and on the eastern side by the Rhine, r unning outer sea = Atlantic Ocean
parallel to the Pyrenees; that as for the north and the south, in
the former case it is delineated by the ocean from the north- ocean = Atlantic Ocean
Alps from Ligystica to the sources of the Rhine; and that the Narbo, Narbonne (Fr.)
as the ocean, the parts this side of the Garunna river. They this side of Garunna
river = Pyrenean side of
called “Celts” t hose extending in the opposite direction as Garonne r.
far as Massalia and Narbo and reaching even as far as some
of the Alpine mountains. They called “Belgans” the rest of
oceanic, living along Atlantic
the oceanic peoples, extending as far as the outlets of the coast
Rhine, and some of those dwelling next to the Rhine and
the Alps. deified Caesar = Julius Caesar
177 C, 14-15 This is what the deified Caesar said in his volumes.1 (mid-1st c. BCE)
177 C, 16-24 Augustus Caesar, on the other hand, made a four-way Augustus Caesar drew up
new arrangement of Roman
division. He said that the Celts belonged to the province of provinces, 27 BCE
Narbonitis 2 but that the Aquitanians w ere as that other fel- other fellow = Julius Caesar
low said, except for the addition of fourteen nations living
Garunna, Garonne r. between the Garunna and the Liger river.3 Dividing the re-
Liger, Loire r. maining territory into two parts, he allocated to Lugdunum he = Augustus
the part as far as the upper reaches of the Rhine, and the
other part to the Belgans.4 The geographer must describe
the physical divisions of the world as well as national divi-
sions when they are worthy of comment. As for the divi-
sions made by the leaders 5 according to political exigency,6
it is sufficient to give these summarily; let others deal with
them in detail. |
177 C, 25–178 C, 2 This whole territory is crisscrossed with rivers, some de- territory = Celtica 4.1.2
scending from the Alps, some from the Cemmenum and the Cemmenum, Cévennes (Fr.)
Pyrenees, some flowing into the ocean, some into our sea. The ocean = Atlantic
lands through which they flow consist mostly of plains and our sea = Med. Sea
earthy hills with navigable streams between them. The river
courses are so fortuitously situated relative to each other that
215
3.1. Western Europe
tain range, the territory produces fewer olives and figs, but
other plants are grown; and as you proceed even farther, the
vine does not produce fully ripened fruit. All the rest of the
territory produces grain in great quantities, as well as millet,
acorns, and all types of livestock. There is no part of it that
has not been tilled, except where marshland and forest have
prevented it. Even h ere there are settlements, the product of
a burgeoning population rather than careful planning—the
women are good at breeding and raising c hildren. The men
are fighters rather than farmers, although now they have been
forced to put aside their weapons and turn to farming.
Mediterranean Coast
178 C, 10-12 In the foregoing, I provided a unified description of outer outer Celtica = Celtica beyond
the Alps (from an Italian point
Celtica in its entirety.2 Let me now describe separately each of view)
of the four parts that have been briefly sketched,3 beginning
with Narbonitis. |
178 C, 12-18 Its shape is something of a parallelogram. It is outlined 4.1.3
216
Celtica: Mediterranean Coast + Hinterland
boundary between Celtica and Iberia is where the Trophies Trophies of Pompey, Panissars
(Sp.)
of Pompey are.)
178 C, 27-34 From here, the distance to Narbo is sixty-three miles; from here = temple to “Pyrenean”
Aphrodite
Nemausus, Nîmes (Fr.) there to Nemausus, eighty-eight; from Nemausus via Uger-
Narbo, Narbonne (Fr.)
Ugernum, Beaucaire (Fr.) num and Tarusco to what are called the “Sextian hot springs”2
Tarusco, Tarascon (Fr.)
(which are near Massalia), fifty-three; from t here to Antipolis
Antipolis, Antibes (Fr.)
and the Varus river, seventy-three. Thus, the total number
of miles is two hundred and seventy-seven. Some people re-
corded two thousand six hundred stades from the Aphrodi-
sium (temple to Aphrodite) to the Varus; o thers give two hundred
more. T here is no consensus on t hese distances.
178 C, 35–179 C, 9 Along the alternative route (via the Vocontians and Cot- Vocontians, se. France
tius country), the road is the same from Nemausus as far as Cottius country, se. France,
nw. Italy
From there = from Nemausus Ugernum and Tarusco. From t here, via Druentia and Cabal-
Caballio, Cavaillon (Fr.)
lio, to the Vocontian border and the beginning of the ascent
into the Alps, it is sixty-three miles. Continuing from t here
toward the other Vocontian border (the border with Cottius
country), to the village of Ebrodunum, it is one mile short of a Ebrodunum, Embrun (Fr.)
hundred. Then it’s the same again via the village of Brigantium Brigantium, Briançon (Fr.)
and Ecscingomagus and the Alpine pass t oward Ocelum (the Ecscingomagus,?Exilles (It.)
end of Cottius country). Finally, Italy is said to start with Ec- Ocelum, nr. Novaretto and
Caprie (It.)
scingomagus. From t here to Ocelum, it is twenty-eight miles. |
179 C, 10-25 Massalia was founded by the Phocaeans.3 She is situated Massalia, Marseille (Fr.) 4.1.4
in a rocky spot. Her harbor lies at the foot of a theatroid cliff theatroid, shaped like a Greek
amphitheater
that faces south. This cliff is well fortified, as is the w
hole city,
which is of a significant size. Located at the acropolis are the
Ephesium and the t emple to “Delphinian” Apollo. The latter
is shared by all Ionians. The Ephesium is a temple to “Ephe-
sian” Artemis. People say that an oracle was given to the Pho- oracle, instruction from the
gods
caeans, as they set sail from their homeland, that they should
have a leader for their voyage as instructed by “Ephesian”
Artemis; putting in at Ephesus, they wondered how they
might procure from the goddess what had been commanded,
while the goddess appeared in a dream to Aristarcha—a very
respectable woman—and bade her take a replica of one of
[ 1 ] Strabo adds to his earlier statement (128 C, 16-24, where the Varus is not explic
itly mentioned).
[ 2 ] I.e., called by Latin speakers; Strabo translates into Greek the Latin place-name
Aquae Sextiae (Aix-en-Provence, Fr.): 508 C, 10-18n.
[ 3 ] Phocaea (Foça, sw. Tky.): 647 C, 1-3.
217
3.1. Western Europe
the sacred artifacts and sail away with the Phocaeans; when
this had taken place and the colony had been completed,
they founded the t emple and paid Aristarcha an exceptional
compliment by appointing her as the priestess; in e very city
colonized by Massalia, p eople primarily worship this goddess
and maintain the same cult statue and the same customs as are
established in the m other city. |
179 C, 26-32 The Massaliotes are governed along aristocratic lines in 4.1.5
218
Celtica: Mediterranean Coast + Hinterland
the hot springs (some of which, people say, have turned cold).
He h oused a Roman garrison there and drove back the na-
tives from the coast leading from Massalia into Italy, since
the Massaliotes w ere not themselves able completely to ward
them off. Even he was not strong enough to do more than
force the natives twelve stades back from the sea (where the
harbors were good), eight stades back from the sea (where it
was rocky). The areas that the natives abandoned, he handed
over to the Massaliotes.
180 C, 21-30 There are, in the city, many dedications of the fruits of war,
won in a succession of naval victories over those who unjustly
disputed mastery of the sea. Formerly, they were exceptionally
fortunate in various respects, including in their friendship with
the Romans. One might point to a multiplicity of indications
of this friendship. Furthermore, the cult statue of Artemis-
on-the-Aventine, which the Romans dedicated, has the same
shape as the Massaliote statue.1 At the time of Pompey’s civil
war against Caesar, however, they lost much of their good for- Caesar = Julius Caesar (mid-1st c.
BCE)
tune through backing the losing side. Nevertheless, among the
people, traces of their old keenness remain, particularly with
regard to instrument making and the outfitting of ships.
180 C, 30–181 C, 6 The inland natives having undergone a continuous p rocess
of domestication and having finally turned to a civil mode of
life and to agriculture because of Roman dominance, there
would not be such keenness among the people in the previ-
ously mentioned matters. This is evident from the current
situation. All cultivated men have turned to oratory and phi-
losophy, with the consequence that the city—which a short
while ago was treated as a training ground for natives and
which made the Galatians into such philhellenes that even
legal contracts w ere written in Greek—at the present time
has persuaded the most eminent Romans that, rather than
spending time in Athens, they should head there for their there = Massalia
education.
181 C, 6-13 Seeing these men and at the same time being at peace,
the Galatians willingly use their leisure for such pursuits, not
only individually but as a group: they invite sophists, some
of whom are paid privately but many of whom are paid from
public funds, in the same way as doctors are. As for the simple
lifestyles and the moderation of the Massaliotes, one might
219
3.1. Western Europe
the outlets of the Atax and the Narbonitis lake. On the Rho- Atax, Aude r.
danus, t here’s Arelate, a city and trading center of no small Narbonitis lake, ?Souyer de
Bages et de Sigean (Fr.)
importance. These trading centers are approximately equi-
Arelate, Arles (Fr.)
distant from each other and from the previously mentioned
points (from the Aphrodisium in the case of Narbo, from
Massalia in the case of Arelate). Other rivers flow past Narbo
on either side—on one side from the Cemmenan mountains, Cemmenan mountains,
Cévennes (Fr.)
on the other from the Pyrenees—with cities to which the voy-
age upstream, made in small boats, is not far.
182 C, 3-8 Flowing from the Pyrenees are the Ruscino and the Ili- Ruscino (river), Têt r.
birris, each of which has a city with the same name. T here Ilibirris (river), Tech r.
is a lake near Ruscino, and a place with underground water, Ilibirris (city), Elne (Fr.)
set back from the sea, full of salt springs—the place where Ruscino (city), Castel-Roussillon
(Fr.)
mullet fish can be dug up. If you dig down two or three feet
lake near Ruscino = Etang de
and stick a pronged implement into the muddy w ater, it is Leucate/Salses (Fr.)
220
Celtica: Mediterranean Coast + Hinterland
On one of these rivers, the safe city of Baeterra is situated, Arauris, Hérault r.
near Narbo; on the other, Agatha, a city founded by the Mas- Baeterra, Béziers (Fr.)
182 C, 14-21 The mullet fish that can be dug up are one amazing feature 4.1.7
borium (lit., black north wind), a horribly violent wind. P eople say
that some of the stones are tossed and whirled around; that
people are torn from their carriages by the blast, and their
Aristotle (4th c. BCE) weapons and clothing blown away. Aristotle says that the stones
are thrown up to the earth’s surface by earthquakes called “brastae”
Posidonius (late 2nd–1st c. BCE) (upheavals) and, as they fall, collect in the hollows. Posidonius, how-
[ 1 ] I.e., called by Latin speakers; Strabo translates into Greek the Latin place-name
Campi Lapidei: 508 C, 10-18n.
[ 2 ] Probably in the sense of “froze”—an early theory of glaciation?
221
3.1. Western Europe
sure that you, who are fast to the fight, will not complain / of battle.
It is fated that there, your arrows will run out. / You will not be able
to pick one rock from off the ground, / since the w hole place is stone-
less. / Zeus w ill see your difficulty and take pity on you. / Filling a
cloud with a storm’s worth of rounded stones, / he w ill cover the earth
with them. You, then, / using them as missiles, w ill easily fend off the
Ligyan army.
183 C, 13-27 As if it would not have been better, says Posidonius, to rain the
Posidonius (late 2nd–1st c. BCE) stones down on the Ligyans themselves and bury them all, rather than
mocks the myth as recounted
by Aeschylus (5th c. BCE) to represent Heracles as needing such a quantity of stones! There
would, however, have been a need for such a quantity, if it was
against the entire assembled horde. In this respect, at least, the
myth writer is more convincing than the myth critic. But as for
Strabo defends Aeschylus the rest, in saying that it is fated, the poet exonerates himself
against Posidonius’s criticism
from censorious criticism. In treatises about foreknowledge
and fate, one might find many such cases from the world of
men and the world of nature, in which one might say that it
would have been much “better” if this or that had happened.
For example, if Egypt got plenty of rain, rather than Ethio-
pia providing the land with w ater; or if Paris had suffered a
shipwreck on his voyage to Sparta, rather than abducting
Helen and then being punished by those he wronged when he
brought so much destruction on Greeks and barbarians—an
Euripides (5th c. BCE) outcome that Euripides attributes to Zeus, wishing evil on the
Trojans and misery on Greece, / this is what father Zeus planned. |
183 C, 28–184 C, 5 As for the mouths of the Rhodanus, Polybius admonishes Rhodanus, Rhône r. 4.1.8
Polybius (2nd c. BCE) criticizes Timaeus and says that it is not five-mouthed but only two-mouthed.
Timaeus (late 4th–early 3rd c.
BCE) Artemidorus says it is three-mouthed. L ater on, Marius, seeing
Artemidorus (late 2nd–early that the river was becoming stopped up at its mouths on ac-
1st c. BCE) count of sedimentation and that it was thus inaccessible, cut a
new channel. Diverting most of the river into this channel, he
presented it to the Massaliotes at the time of the war against
the Ambronians and Toygenans. They acquired much wealth
from this, collecting tolls from those sailing upstream as well
as downstream. Nevertheless, the mouths remain difficult to
access b ecause of the strong current, the sedimentation, and
the fact that the land is so low that it cannot be seen in bad
weather, even up close. This is why the Massaliotes erected
towers as beacons, making the territory in every way their
own. They furthermore established a t emple to “Ephesian”
222
Celtica: Mediterranean Coast + Hinterland
it “Stomalimna” (Lake-at-the-mouth). It has all sorts of shellfish Stomalimna, Etang de Berre (Fr.)
part of Italy, Nicaea remains subject to the Massaliotes and Nicaea, Nice (Fr.)
Massalia, are the Stoechades islands, three of them quite Stoechades, Iles d’Hyères (Fr.
islands)
large, two of them small. The Massaliotes farmed them. The
223
3.1. Western Europe
ing territory as far as the junction of the Isar with the Rhoda-
nus belongs to the Cavarians. This is approximately where the
Cemmenum, too, reaches the Rhodanus. The distance hither Cemmenum, Cévennes (Fr.)
flowing into the Rhodanus from the Alps. Two of them flow
around . . . *, the Cavarian city, then unite as they join the
Rhodanus. A third river is the Sulga, which enters the Rho- Sulga, Sorgue r.
224
Celtica: Mediterranean Coast + Hinterland
185 C, 28-32 At the spot where the Isar river, the Rhodanus, and the Isar, Isère r.
Maximus Aemilianus, with not as many as thirty thousand Aemilianus, Roman general,
defeated Celts, 121 BCE
men in total, cut down two hundred thousand Celts and set
up a white marble monument to their defeat, as well as two
temples, one to Ares and the other to Heracles.
185 C, 33–186 C, 8 It is three hundred and twenty stades from the Isar to
Vienna, the Allobrigan metropolis situated on the Rhoda- Vienna, Vienne (Fr.)
nus. (Not far above Vienna is Lugdunum, from which point Rhodanus, Rhône r.
the Arar and Rhodanus join with each other. It is around Lugdunum, Lyon (Fr.)
two hundred stades to Lugdunum by foot; slightly more by Arar, Saône r.
ALLOBRIGANS boat.) The Allobrigans used to take to the field with many
e. France
tens of thousands; nowadays, they farm the plains and the
Alpine valleys. They live scattered in villages, except that the
most illustrious men occupy Vienna, which though formerly
a mere village, they have built into a city called the “metropo-
lis” of their nation.
186 C, 8-21 Vienna is situated on the Rhodanus. This river flows from Rhodanus, Rhône r.
the Alps in a long course and with much force. Even when
it passes through lake Lemenna, its stream is detectable for Lemenna, Léman/Geneva l.
(Fr., Swi.)
many stades. Descending to the plains in Allobrigan and Se-
gusiavian territory, it joins the Arar at the Segusiavian city of Arar, Saône r.
186 C, 22-31 Most of the territory on the other side of the river is inhab-
ited by Volcians, whom they qualify as “Arecomician.”2 Narbo Narbo, Narbonne (Fr.)
225
3.1. Western Europe
them on the opposite side, and also the Cavarians. The name
“Cavarians” prevails, and this is the name they now give to all
the natives of that region—“natives” no longer, for they have
conformed to Roman ways, both in language and lifestyle, and
some of them even in government.
186 C, 31-32 There are other minor nations, lacking significance,
stretching alongside the Arecomicians as far as the Pyrenees.
186 C, 33–187 C, 3 The Arecomician metropolis is called “Nemausus.” In Nemausus, Nîmes (Fr.)
where the small town of Tarusco is on the opposite bank; Tarusco, Tarascon (Fr.)
and seven hundred and twenty from Narbo. Narbo, Narbonne (Fr.)
187 C, 16-21 Reaching as far as the Cemmenum mountain range, and Cemmenum, Cévennes (Fr.)
taking in its southern side as far as its summits, live those Vol-
cians called “Tectosagian,” as well as certain others. Those
others I will describe later.2 | As for those called “Tectosa- 4.1.13
gians,” they are next to the Pyrenees. They extend just a l ittle
even onto the northern side of the Cemmenan mountains,
and the land they inhabit is rich in gold.
187 C, 21-27 It is likely that they w
ere once powerful and so numerous
that, when there was civil discord, a great many of them were
[ 1 ] 178 C, 27–179 C, 9.
[ 2 ] 189 C, 25-34.
226
Celtica: Mediterranean Coast + Hinterland
are part of these people. As proof of this we have the fact that
the p eople t here are still t oday called “Tectosagians”: for of
the three nations, one of them—the nation centered on the
city of Ancyra—is called “Tectosagian.” Ancyra, Ankara (Tky.)
187 C, 27-35 The other two nations are the “Trocmians” and “Tolistobo-
gians,” whose racial kinship with the Tectosagians attests to the Tectosagians, Trocmians,
Tolistobogians, w. cen. Turkey
fact that they w ere colonists from Celtica, although I am not
able to state from which areas they originated. I have no knowl-
edge of any Trocmians or Tolistobogians living in current-day
Celtica beyond the Alps, nor in the Alps themselves, nor this
side of the Alps. It is likely that they vanished b ecause of their
frequent emigrations, as happened in the case of several o thers.
For example, some say that the second Brennus, who attacked
Delphi, was a “Prausian,” and I am likewise unable to say where
in the world the “Prausians” formerly dwelt.
188 C, 1-8 People say that the Tectosagians likewise took part in the
campaign against Delphi. They say that the treasures found Delphi, Delphi (Gr.)
among them by the Roman general Caepio, in the city of To- Tolossa, Toulouse (Fr.)
lossa, w ere part of the Delphian store; that the city folk added
to them out of their personal possessions, making dedications
and propitiating the gods; that it was because Caepio laid
hands on t hese t reasures that he ended his life in misfortune,
banished from his fatherland as a temple robber, leaving as
Timagenes (1st c. BCE) his successors female children who, according to Timagenes,
ended up as prostitutes and died in disgrace.
188 C, 8-22 The account given by Posidonius is more credible. He says
Posidonius (late 2nd–1st c. BCE) that the t reasure found in Tolossa was worth some fifteen thousand
talents, deposited partly in consecrated places and partly in sacred talent, largest unit in
Greek accounting system;
lakes; it did not include artifacts but consisted of unwrought gold and 1 talent = 6,000 drachmas
silver; the t emple at Delphi, at that late stage having been ransacked
by the Phocians at the time of the Sacred War, was devoid of such
treasure; if anything was left over, it had been shared among many
men, who probably never made it home, since they came off badly after
their retreat from Delphi, with some of them scattered in one direc-
tion and some of them in another, b ecause of internal disagreements.
On the other hand, as that fellow and several others say, the that fellow = Posidonius
[ 1 ] I.e., the part of Phrygia known as “Galatia” in Strabo’s day: 566 C, 31–568 C, 7;
cf. 571 C, 17-25.
227
3.1. Western Europe
in the narrowest part of the isthmus dividing the ocean from ocean = Atlantic Ocean
the Narbonian sea, the isthmus being less than three thousand Narbonian sea = Med. Sea
Posidonius (late 2nd–1st c. BCE) stades, according to Posidonius.
188 C, 28–189 C, 5 Above all e lse, it is worth noting again what I noted
earlier:1 the territory’s connectedness with regard to its riv- territory = Celtica
ers and with regard to both the outer sea and the inner sea. outer sea = Atlantic
Ocean + North Sea
If you think about it, you find that this is a major f actor in
inner sea = Med. Sea
the excellence of the area: I mean the ease with which all the
people exchange life’s necessities with others, and the advan-
tages that accrue to all alike, especially now that, freed from
fighting, they work the land with care and live civil lives. In
consequence, you might find evidence in these circumstances
for the work of providence, the topography arranged not ran-
domly but according to a rational plan.
189 C, 5-11 For example, the Rhodanus affords a long upstream pas- Rhodanus, Rhône r.
sage for shipments that are large and destined for many dif
ferent parts of the territory, on account of its tributaries being
navigable and accommodating freight of the greatest size. It
is succeeded by the Arar and by the Dubis, which joins the Arar, Saône r.
Arar. Then there is an overland leg as far as the Sequana river Dubis, Doubs r.
and thence, finally, a downstream passage to the ocean, to the Sequana, Seine r.
189 C, 11-17 Since the Rhodanus is fast-flowing and the upstream pas-
sage difficult, the preference is to take some of the freight off
it and transport it overland by wagon. This is the freight des-
tined for the Arvernians and the Liger. The Rhodanus does Liger, Loire r.
[ 1 ] 177 C, 25–178 C, 2.
228
Celtica: Atlantic Coast + Hinterland
easier. From the road, the Liger follows on conveniently—it Cemmenan mountains,
flows from the Cemmenan mountains to the ocean. Cévennes (Fr.)
189 C, 17-20 From Narbo, t here is a short passage up the Atax, and a Narbo, Narbonne (Fr.)
dred stades long—to the Garuna river. The Garuna flows into Garuna, Garonne r.
the ocean.
189 C, 21-24 The foregoing is what I have to say concerning the in-
habitants of the Narbonitis province,1 whom men of former Narbonitis = Lat. Gallia
Narbonensis (s. France)
times called “Keltai.” 2 I surmise that it was b
ecause of these
people that all Galatians w
ere given the name “Keltoi” by the
Greeks 3—because of their renown or, if the Massaliotes made
a contribution to the name, because of their proximity. |
Atlantic Coast
189 C, 25-34 Next to be discussed are the Aquitanians (and the fourteen 4.2.1
ritory between the Garuna and the Liger. These rivers run
roughly parallel to the Pyrenees, in respect of which they
make two small, parallelogram-shaped territories, which are
bounded on their other sides by the ocean and the Cemmenan
mountains. The sailing distance down each of the rivers, in
round numbers, is two thousand stades. The Garuna, after
being joined by three other rivers, flows out to sea at the
stretch between t hose Biturigans called “Oïscans” and those stretch between . . .
Santonians = coast of France nr.
called “Santonians,” both of whom are Galatian nations. Bordeaux
These Biturigans compose the sole nation among the Aqui-
tanians that has different racial origins and is not counted
among them. It has an entrepôt (Burdigala) on the shore of a Burdigala, Bordeaux (Fr.)
229
3.1. Western Europe
from Corbilo (these being the three most important cities in Narbo, Narbonne (Fr.)
190 C, 19-26 The Aquitanian ocean coast is mostly sandy, with a thin ocean coast = Atlantic coast
the Galatian bay with which it is homonymous on the Narbo- Galatian bay, Gulf of Lion
were added to the Aquitanians include the Elvians, who Liger, Loire r.
start at the Rhodanus; a fter them the Vellavians, who w ere Rhodanus, Rhône r.
once lumped in with the Avernians but now have their own
separate classification; then the Avernians, Lemovicians, and
Petrocorians; in addition to them, the Nitiobrigians, Cadur-
cians, and the Biturigans called “Cuban.” On the side toward
the ocean are the Santonians and Pictonians, the former—as
I said—living by the Garuna and the latter by the Liger.2
The Rutenians and the Gabalians are near Narbonitis.
191 C, 2-6 Among the Petrocorians, and also among the Cuban
Biturigans, t here are some high-quality iron mines; among
the Cadurcians, linen factories; among the Rutenians, silver
mines. The Gabalians also have silver mines. The Romans
230
Celtica: Atlantic Coast + Hinterland
have given the Latium to some of the Aquitanians—for ex- Latium = Lat. ius Latii
tropolis is Nemossus, which is located on the river. This river Nemossus, Clermont-Ferrand
(Fr.)
flows past Cenabum (the Carnutan entrepôt, which is at about
Cenabum, Orléans (Fr.)
the halfway point of the voyage) and out into the ocean. The
Arvernians offer, as g reat proof of their former power, the fact
that they frequently did battle with the Romans, sometimes
with two hundred thousand men, at other times with double
that. The latter was the number with which, u nder Vercin-
getorix, they fought against the deified Caesar; and before deified Caesar = Julius Caesar
mountain range draws near the Rhodanus. The battle against Rhodanus, Rhône r.
Domitius was farther downstream, at the confluence of the Cemmenum, Cévennes (Fr.)
Sulga and the Rhodanus. Sulga, Sorgue r.
191 C, 22-29 The Arvernians originally extended as far as Narbo and Narbo, Narbonne (Fr.)
down from its source, the Rhodanus reaches Lugdunum. Of Lugdunum, Lyon (Fr.)
231
3.1. Western Europe
ers, too, as noted earlier, come down from the Alps and then,
uniting into one stream, flow into the Rhodanus.4
192 C, 14-18 There is another river, which similarly has its sources in
the Alps,5 by the name of “Sequana.” It flows into the ocean, Sequana, Seine r.
SEQUANIANS for a long time with both Romans and Aeduans. In the case of
e. France
the Romans, this was because the Sequanians often joined the
Germans in their attacks on Italy. The strength they demon-
strated was not insignificant: they added to the greatness of
the Germans when in alliance with them, and they diminished
the Germans when they went their separate ways. They w ere
at odds with the Aeduans partly for the same reason, but their
hostility was exacerbated by strife over the river that ran be-
232
Celtica: Atlantic Coast + Hinterland
tween them, each nation claiming that the Arar was its own
and that the transport taxes were owed to it.
192 C, 29-30 Nowadays, all are subject to the Romans. |
192 C, 31-36 As for the territory on the Rhine, it is inhabited first of 4.3.3
HELVETTIANS all by the Helvettians, where the river has its sources in the
w. Switzerland
Adula mountain range. This range is a part of the Alps from
which the Adua river also flows, albeit in the other direction Adua, Adda r.
Celtica on this side = Lat. Gallia toward Celtica on this side, entering Larius lake, on which Larius lake, Como l. (It.)
Cisalpina
Comum is built, and thence joining the Padus. I will describe Comum, Como (It.)
Padus, Po r.
these parts later.1
192 C, 36–193 C, 9 The Rhine, too, opens into great marshes and a great lake,2 great lake = Bodensee/
Constance l. (Ger., Swi., Aus.)
up to which the Alpine Rhaetians and Vindolicians extend, as
Asinius (1st c. BCE) also some of the transalpine peoples. Asinius says that its length
is six thousand stades (it is not—rather, measured in a straight
line, it would be only a little more than half as much—an
addition of one thousand for the twists and turns would be
enough); it is swift-flowing, because of which it is also difficult to
bridge; and having descended from the mountains, for the rest of its
course it flows on a level through plains. How, then, would it remain
swift and forceful, if we were to add a multitude of long looping
curves to its level course? He also says that it is two-mouthed, and
reproaches t hose who say that t here are more mouths.
193 C, 9-14 This river and the Sequana enclose a certain amount of This river = Rhine r.
territory within their winding ways but not so very much. Sequana, Seine r.
193 C, 14-18 The section of the Sequana that is navigated by t hose who
transport goods from the Arar is only a little longer than that Arar, Saône r.
of the Liger and of the Garuna. From Lugdunum to the Se- Liger, Loire r.
quana is one thousand stades. It is only a little less than double Garuna, Garonne r.
this from the entry points of the Rhodanus up to Lugdunum.
193 C, 18-24 People say that the Helvettians are rich in gold but that they
nevertheless turned to raiding when they saw the Cimbrians’
wealth, and that two of their three tribes w ere destroyed dur-
ing their campaigns. However, the large number of descen-
dants from those that survived became evident during the
233
3.1. Western Europe
yond the Rhodanus and the Arar, lie alongside and north of Sequana, Seine r.
the Allobrigans and the Lugdunum region. The most famous Rhodanus, Rhône r.
of these are the Arvernian and Carnutan nations, past both of Arar, Saône r.
which the Liger flows and then issues into the ocean. ocean = Atlantic
193 C, 34–194 C, 2 The crossing to Brettanica, from the rivers in Celtica, is Brettanica, Great Britain
[ 1 ] Strabo clarifies his earlier statement (192 C, 18-21n) about the location of the
Aeduans.
[ 2 ] Strabo clarifies his e arlier statement (192 C, 14-18) about the location of the
Sequana river.
[ 3 ] Strabo l ater (199 C, 23-30) clarifies this information.
[ 4 ] Ongoing war against the Germans: 291 C, 23–292 C, 10n.
234
Celtica: Atlantic Coast + Hinterland
194 C, 18-26 The Morinians’ territory, and also that of the Atrebatians
and Eburonians, is similar to that of the Menapians. It con-
sists of a forest of trees that are not tall: the forest is extensive,
albeit not as extensive as the four thousand stades claimed
by writers. They call it “Arduenna.” When they faced hostile Arduenna, Ardennes
194 C, 29-31 The most noteworthy of the nations in the region are the
Duricortora, Reims (Fr.)
Remans: their city, Duricortora, is the best organized and is
governors = of Roman province
where the Roman governors are received. | of Gallia Belgica
194 C, 32–195 C, 9 After the aforementioned nations, what remains are the 4.4.1
VENETIANS Belgan nations on the ocean coast.1 These include the Vene-
nw. France
tians, who fought a naval battle against Caesar. They were all
ready to prevent Caesar’s voyage to Brettanica, since they used Julius Caesar attacked
Brettanica (Great Britain),
it for trading. He easily defeated them, although not by using 55 and 54 BCE
ramming tactics (as their ship timbers w ere thick). Rather,
as the Venetians bore down against him with the wind, the
Romans tore down their sails with halberds; the sails were
made of leather because of the strong winds and were hoisted
with chains rather than ropes. The Venetians construct their
ships with broad bottoms (high at the stern and bow) b ecause
of the low tides, using oakwood, of which they have plenty. For
this reason, they do not close the gaps between the timbers but
instead leave chinks. They stop up the chinks with seaweed,
so that the timbers do not dry out when the ship is hauled out
of the water and they are no longer submerged. The seaweed
naturally retains moisture, whereas the oak is dry and lacks oil.
235
3.1. Western Europe
195 C, 9-13 I think that these Venetians are the founding fathers of
t hose on the Adria.1 (Nearly all the other Celts in Italy—e.g., Adria, Adriatic Sea
come about easily: moving like a herd, they get up and leave,
236
Celtica
fighting against the latter earlier and finished later, whereas latter = Iberians
they overcame all these people (all of them between the Rhine they = Romans
and the Pyrenean mountain range) in the intervening period, these people = Celts
given that the Celts all went into battle en masse and were
conquered en masse. The Iberians husbanded their resources
and split the b attles up, diff erent groups fighting at diff erent
times in diff erent places, using raiding techniques.
196 C, 14-20 They are all warriors by nature, better on horseback than on They = Celts
foot. The best part of the Roman cavalry is drawn from among
them. The farther north they are, and the closer to the ocean,
the better warriors they are. | Of these, p eople say that the Bel- 4.4.3
gans (divided into fifteen nations between the Rhine and the
Liger, living along the ocean coast) are so superior that that, on Liger, Loire r.
237
3.1. Western Europe
197 C, 2-10 Even t hese days, many of them sleep on the ground,1 and them = Celts
they sit on beds of straw to eat their meals. Food they have in
great quantities, including milk and all kinds of meat, par-
ticularly pork, fresh and salted. The swine run wild and are
exceptionally tall, fierce, and swift. It is dangerous for an in-
experienced person to approach one, as in the case of a wolf.
They have large, round houses, constructed from timber and
wattle, on which they put thick roofs. Their flocks of sheep
and herds of swine are so plentiful as to furnish not only Rome
but most parts of Italy with an abundance of cloaks and salted
meat.
197 C, 11-20 Most of their constitutions were aristocratic. In olden
times, they used to choose one leader e very year; likewise, in they = Celts
238
Celtica
wear a lot of gold, with circlets around their necks and brace-
lets around their arms and wrists. High-ranking men wear
clothes that are dyed in colors and worked with gold. Because
of such vanity, they are observed to be unbearable in victory,
dumbstruck in defeat.
197 C, 35–198 C, 7 In addition to their witlessness, they have a strange and they = Celts
are possessed by Dionysus, the god, whom they appease with mystic
rites and other rituals. No man sets foot on the island. The women
themselves sail off to have sex with men and then return. Their custom
is, once a year, to take the roof off the t emple and, on the same day,
put it back before sunset, each carrying a bundle. She whose bundle
falls, that w
oman is torn to pieces by the o thers. They carry her limbs
around the t emple with cries of jubilation, not ceasing u ntil their
frenzy is over. It is always the case that t here is some w
oman who w ill
suffer this fate.
198 C, 25-31 Even more myth-like than the foregoing is what Artemi-
Artemidorus (late 2nd–early dorus says happens with crows. He reports that there is some
1st c. BCE)
harbor on the oceanic coast named “Two Crows,” in which two crows oceanic = Atlantic
appear with white stripes on the right-side wing. People who have
[ 1 ] If the words “he says” are correct, the reference is probably to Posidonius, cited
at 197 C, 35–198 C, 7.
239
3.1. Western Europe
disagreements over some issue come here to a high spot, lay out a
plank, and put barley cakes upon it, each putting them in a separate
position. The birds alight on the plank, eat one set of cakes and scatter
the other. He whose barley cake was eaten, that man wins the dispute.
198 C, 31–199 C, 3 While this is rather myth-like, what he says about Deme- he = ?Artemidorus
He declares that the people are philhellenes and makes many spe- Gadira, Cádiz (Sp.)
that are in regular use: from the outlets of the Rhine, the
[ 1 ] Celtica beyond the Alps: 176 C, 13–199 C, 9. Strabo now proceeds to de-
scribe Brettanica (Great Britain), Ierne (Ireland), and Thule (?Iceland): 199 C,
10–201 C, 26.
[ 2 ] The sense is that the western tip of Brettanica is supposed to lie due north
of the Pyrenees, a slight refinement of Strabo’s earlier comments at 63 C,
14-18n. For “corresponding to” meaning “lying due north or south of”: 496 C,
26–497 C, 4n.
[ 3 ] Strabo refines and adds to his earlier statement (128 C, 3-16, where he gave
5,000 stades as the east–west dimension of both Brettanica and Celtica, with-
out mentioning that this is a maximum figure for Celtica).
240
Atlantic Islands
Sequana, the Liger, and the Garuna. For t hose who set sail Sequana, Seine r.
from the Rhine area, the voyage does not start from any of Liger, Loire r.
the river’s actual mouths but from the Morinians (the people Garuna, Garonne r.
241
3.1. Western Europe
[ 1 ] Strabo had undoubtedly seen these offerings in the Capitol in Rome: 236 C, 25-28n.
[ 2 ] Strabo overstates the case. Cf. 288 C, 22-23 (where the Parthians are with similar
hyperbole represented as being on the brink of ceding their empire to the
Romans); 305 C, 11-15 (Getans and Dacians).
[ 3 ] Ireland lies on a more northerly latitude than the southern parts of Britain with
which Strabo is familiar, but its overall position is west of Britain.
[ 4 ] Anthropophagi and poephagi are technical terms belonging to a system of
classification based on diet and lifestyle: 154 C, 31–155 C, 5n.
[ 5 ] 63 C, 9-14; 104 C, 6-19; 114 C, 29–115 C, 3; 157 C, 32–158 C, 6.
[ 6 ] The gist of the missing words is probably that astronomical data (e.g., height
of sun at midday, length of longest day, e tc.) could have been computed for
Thule rather than observed there.
242
Alps
201 C, 27-30 Having dealt with Celtica beyond the Alps and the p eoples 4.6.1
Strabo segues from his who occupy that territory,1 I will now describe the Alps them-
description of “Celtica beyond
the Alps” to his description of selves and the p eople who live in them,2 then the w hole of
the Alps Italy,3 carefully preserving in my narrative the layout sug-
gested by the nature of the territory.
201 C, 31–202 C, 3 The Alps do not begin, as some writers have claimed, at Mon- Monoecus harbor, ?Monte
Carlo (Mnc.)
oecus harbor, but rather in the very place where the Apen-
nine mountains begin—at Genua (the Ligyan entrepôt) and
at what is called “Sabata Vada,”4 that is, “Shallows.” (On the Sabata Vada, Vado Ligurie (It.)
one hand, the Apennine mountain range starts at Genua; the Genua, Genoa (It.)
Alps, on the other hand, start at Sabata.) There are two hun-
dred and sixty stades between Genua and Sabata.
202 C, 3-6 After three hundred and seventy stades is the town of Al- Albingaunum, Albegna (It.)
LIGYANS bingaunum: the Ligyans who live t here are called “Ingaunan.”
Monaco, nw. Italy
From t here to Monoecus harbor, it is four hundred and eighty
stades. In the intervening space is the very large city of Al- Albium Intimilium, Ventimiglia
(It.)
bium Intimilium and her inhabitants, the “Intimilians.”
202 C, 7-14 People use t hese names as proof that the Alps start at
Sabata,5 claiming that the “Alpian” mountains w ere formerly Sabata, Vado Ligurie (It.)
called the “Albians,” just like . . . * for, even t oday, the very high
range among the Iapodes, which is roughly contiguous with
Ocra and the Alps, is called the “Albian” range, as if the Alps Ocra, Nanos mt. (Svn.)
reach this far. | Since one set of Ligyans is Ingaunan and one set 4.6.2
[1] Celtica beyond the Alps (+ Atlantic islands): 176 C, 10–201 C, 26.
[2] Alps: 201 C, 31–209 C, 14.
[3] Italy (including islands): 209 C, 15–288 C, 33.
[4] I.e., called by Latin speakers; Strabo first transliterates into Greek the Latin word
Vada, then translates it into the Greek word meaning “Shallows”: 508 C, 10-18n.
[ 5 ] The sense seems to be that, for a navigator sailing westward from Italy, the
coast is dominated by the Alps from Sabata westward.
243
3.1. Western Europe
202 C, 16-24 In general, this entire stretch of shoreline, from Mon- Monoecus harbor, ?Monte
Carlo (Mnc.)
oecus harbor to Tyrrhenia, is exposed and harborless except
for shallow roadsteads and anchorages. Looming over it are
extraordinarily high mountain ridges, leaving only a narrow
passage along the coast. The inhabitants are Ligyans, who
subsist in the main on domesticated animals, milk, and a
barley drink. They dwell in the coastal regions but mainly in
the mountains. There they have a vast amount of timber, used
for shipbuilding and derived from trees of such i mmense size
that the width of some is found to measure eight feet! Much of
this timber is, in its grain pattern, not inferior to thyum wood
for the purposes of table manufacture.1
202 C, 24-31 They export this timber, as well as animals, skins, and They = Ligyans
honey, to the Genua entrepôt. They receive in exchange olive Genua, Genoa (It.)
oil and wine from Italy (their own wine is scarce—bitter and
resinous). This region is the source of those h orses and mules
called ginni, and of Ligystinian tunics and cloaks. Also plenti-
ful among them is lyngurium, which some people call “amber.”
In battle, they use no h orses at all, but their infantry and
marksmen are excellent. Some people adduce, on the basis
of their bronze shields, that they are Greek. |
202 C, 32-35 Monoecus harbor is a roadstead for ships that are neither Monoecus harbor, ?Monte 4.6.3
Carlo (Mnc.)
large nor numerous. It has a t emple to Heracles “Monoecus,”
as he is called: it is likely, on the basis of the name, that the
Massaliote coast extended even to h ere. The distance from
Antipolis is just a little more than two hundred stades. Antipolis, Antibes (Fr.)
203 C, 1-8 From there right up to Massalia and a little farther, the
SALLYANS Sallyan nation occupies the Alps lying inland and (inter-
se. France
mingled with Greeks) part of the coastline itself. The Greeks
of ancient times called the Sallyans “Ligyans” and called the
territory possessed by the Massaliotes “Ligystica.” Men of
more recent times call them “Celto-Ligyans” and addition-
ally attribute to t hese p eople the flat territory extending to
Avenio and the Rhodanus. This explains how they managed Avenio, Avignon (Fr.)
to field an army not only of foot soldiers but of horsemen, too, Rhodanus, Rhône r.
244
Alps
and sea, and they had such power that the road was hardly
passable even by a great army. By the eightieth year of the war,
the Romans had managed only to make the road passable for a
width of twelve stades, for t hose traveling on public business.
Thereafter, however, they destroyed the lot of them, set up
governments for them, and imposed taxes. |
203 C, 16-19 After the Sallyans, in the north of the mountains live the 4.6.4
the coast are considered the same as the Italiotes, whereas to Genua, Genoa (It.)
those in the mountains a prefect of equestrian rank is sent, as prefect = of Roman province of
Alpes Maritimae
to o thers who are complete barbarians. |
203 C, 26-29 After the Vocontians are the Iconians and Tricorians; after 4.6.5
ICONIANS, TRICORIANS, these, the Medullians, who live on the highest peaks. P eople
MEDULLIANS
se. France
say that the most perpendicular of the peaks has an ascent of
one hundred stades, and the same figure again for the descent
to the Italian boundaries.
203 C, 29–204 C, 4 High up in certain concavities, t here is a g
reat lake, and
there are two springs not far distant from each other. From
one of these, the Druentia, a torrential river, rushes down- Druentia, Durance r.
ward to the Rhodanus (and the Duria goes in the opposite Rhodanus, Rhône r.
direction—it joins the Padus a fter flowing down past the Padus, Po r.
204 C, 6-8 In the opposite parts of the aforesaid mountains,3 in the 4.6.6
245
3.1. Western Europe
TAURINIANS other Ligyans. To these belongs what is called “the land of land of Donnus and Cottius, se.
se. France, nw. Italy France, nw. Italy
Donnus and Cottius.”
204 C, 8-14 After these people and the Padus come the Salassians.1
Above t hese, on the mountain peaks, are the Ceutronians,
Catorigians, Varagrians, Nantuatians, lake Lemenna, through Lemenna, Léman/Geneva l.
(Fr., Swi.)
which the Rhodanus flows, and also the source of that river.
Rhodanus, Rhône r.
Not far from h ere are the sources of the Rhine and the Adula
range, out of which the Rhine flows northward and the Adua Adua, Adda r.
flows in the other direction, joining lake Larius near Comum. Larius, Como l. (It.)
204 C, 15-18 Above Comum, which is situated at the foot of the Alps, the Comum, Como (It.)
Rhaetians and Vennones are t oward the east,2 while in the other
direction there are the Lepontians, Tridentians, Stonians, and
several other small nations, which, lacking resources and living
by raiding, in earlier times used to make incursions into Italy.
204 C, 18-21 Nowadays, some of the nations have been destroyed, and
some have been completely civilized, so that the mountain
crossings that pass by them—hitherto few in number and dif-
ficult to reach—can be accessed from many directions and
are safe from the locals, and their use has been facilitated by
construction work, as far as is possible.
204 C, 22-28 Augustus Caesar followed his destruction of the raid-
ers with a policy of road construction, to the extent that it
was feasible. It was not possible everywhere to triumph over
nature, b ecause of the precipices and extraordinarily high
peaks—the latter rising up from the road and the former
dropping away from it, so that even a minor deviation from
the road brought an inevitable risk of falling into a bottom-
less ravine. The road is so narrow . . . * as to cause vertigo in
wayfarers, both in the p eople themselves and in their beasts
of burden if unaccustomed to it—although the local animals
carry their burdens without risk.
204 C, 29-33 These problems are endemic, as are the vast slabs of ice
that slip down from above, capable of cutting off a whole party
of travelers and pushing them all into the ravines below. The
slabs are numerous, lying one atop the other, being formed
by layer upon layer of compressed snow, the surface layers
being continuously and easily separated from the inner layers
before being completely melted by the sun’s rays. |
205 C, 1-6 Much of the Salassians’ territory is in a deep valley, with the 4.6.7
246
Alps
SALASSIANS their territory extends up to the high peaks above. If you are
nw. Italy
crossing the mountains from Italy, the road lies through the
previously mentioned valley, then splits in two: one road leads one road = Great St. Bernard
pass (It., Swi.)
through what is called the “Poeninus” and does not have the
capacity at the high points of the Alps to accommodate teams of
oxen; the other road is farther west, passing by the Ceutronians. other road = Little St. Bernard
pass (It., Fr.)
205 C, 6-14 Salassian territory features gold mines. T hese were in the
possession of the Salassians when, in earlier times, they w ere
powerful, just as they likewise controlled the passes. The
Duria river was a g reat asset in their mining operations for Duria, Doire Baltée/Dora
Baltea r.
gold panning. For this reason, in many places they diverted
it into sluices and drained the main stream. This was benefi-
cial to them in their quest for gold but was grievous for those
trying to farm the plains below them, since it deprived them
of water (the river being capable of irrigating the territory
because of the raised location of its bed). For this reason, both
nations continually declared war on each other.
205 C, 14-20 With the Roman conquest, the Salassians w ere expelled
from the gold operations and from their territory. However,
since they maintained possession of the mountaintops, they
sold w ater to the leaseholders working the gold mines. There
were incessant quarrels with these men because of the greed of
the leaseholders. It thus came about that those Romans who
were always wanting to play the general and got dispatched
to these places had an abundance of pretexts on which they
could go to war!
205 C, 21-28 Until recent times, despite at times having war declared
on them, at other times ending their war against the Romans,
they remained strong, their raiding lifestyle causing much
harm to those passing through them in traversing the moun-
tains. They exacted a drachma per man from Decimus Bru- drachma, silver coin in the
Greek monetary system,
tus when he was in flight from Mutina. Messala, setting up roughly a laborer’s daily wage
his winter quarters near them, had to pay for his wood—for
burning and for the elm-wood spears used in practice. These
fellows even plundered the possessions of Caesar and chucked
huge boulders down on his soldiers, using as their excuse that
they w ere building roads or bridging rivers!
205 C, 28–206 C, 3 Subsequently, Augustus thoroughly defeated them. He
sold them all as booty after transporting them to Eropedia, Eropedia, Ivrea (It.)
247
3.1. Western Europe
Cambodunum, and the acropolis (so to speak) of the Licat- Cambodunum, Kempten (Ger.)
tians, namely Damasia. (Concerning the severity of the raids Damasia, Auerberg (Ger.)
who live near the inmost point of the Adriatic and near the
Aquileia region, namely some of the Noricans and the Car-
nians. The Tauriscans are Noricans.
206 C, 26-28 All these people were s topped from their violent raid- Tiberius and Drusus, under the
ing by Tiberius and his b rother, Drusus, in the course of one command of their father,
248
Alps
summer. The consequence is that it is already the thirty-third the Roman emperor Augustus,
campaigned in the Alps, 15 BCE
year 1 of their being at peace and paying their taxes.
206 C, 28–207 C, 3 Through the whole mountain range of the Alps, there
are hilly districts, which can be farmed to good effect, and
also valleys that have been well settled. However, the greater
part, particularly the area around the peaks where the raiders
used to congregate, is miserable and unproductive because
of the frosts and the rugged terrain. At times when food and
other things were scarce, they sometimes spared those in the
plains in order that they might have p eople to provide sup-
plies. They gave in return resin, pitch, pine, wax, cheese, and
honey. T hese t hings they had in abundance.
207 C, 4-7 Above the Carnians is the Apennine range, with its lake, Isara, Eisack/Isarco r.
which sends forth the Isara river. This river, after being joined Atagis, Etsch r.
by another river (the Atagis), empties into the Adria. An- Adria, Adriatic Sea
other river, called the “Atesinus,” flows from the same lake Atesinus, ?Inn r./?Sill r.
207 C, 7-17 The Ister has its sources in this multibranched and multi-
peaked mountain range. From Ligystica up to this point, the mountain range = Alps
and vanquished. Their cities are Metulum, Arupini, Mon- Monetium, Brinje (Cro.)
etium, and Vendon. After them, in a plain, is Segestica, past Vendon, Crkvina, nr. Brlog (Cro.)
Ister, Danube r. which runs the Saüs river, which flows into the Ister. The city Segestica, Sisak (Cro.)
is conveniently situated for the war against the Dacians. Saüs, Sava r.
249
3.1. Western Europe
207 C, 26-33 Ocra is the lowest part of the Alps, where the Alps reach Ocra, Nanos mt. (Svn.)
flowing from Illyria; it joins the Saüs, allowing easy transport Saüs, Sava r.
to Segestica and to the Pannonians and Tauriscans. Also join- Segestica, Sisak (Cro.)
ing the Saüs at this city is the Colapis. Both rivers are navi- Colapis, Kupa r.
gable and flow from the Alps.1
207 C, 34–208 C, 4 The Alps have wild h orses and c attle. Polybius says that
Polybius (2nd c. BCE) there is also a native animal with a distinctive appearance, deerlike
in shape except for its neck and coat (in t hese respects, it is like a boar);
under its chin it has a growth, around one span long, with a hairy tuft
and as thick as a foal’s tail. |
208 C, 5-8 As for the passes from Italy to outer (northern) Celtica, 4.6.11
Lugdunum, Lyon (Fr.)
the one that goes past the Salassians leads to Lugdunum. The
One fork = Little St. Bernard
pass bifurcates. One fork, past the Ceutronians, is capable of pass (It., Fr.)
accommodating wagons for most of its length; the other fork, other fork = Great St. Bernard
past the Poeninus, is sheer-sided and narrow but short. pass (It., Swi.)
208 C, 8-14 Lugdunum is at the territory’s center, like an acropolis, Lugdunum, Lyon (Fr.)
because of the confluence of rivers and its proximity to all its territory = Celtica
parts. That is why Agrippa cut his roads starting from there:
the road past the Cemmenan mountains as far as the Santo- Cemmenan mts., Cévennes (Fr.)
nians and Aquitania; the road toward the Rhine; thirdly, the
road toward the part of the ocean coast by the Bellovacians
and Ambianians. The fourth road is the one toward Narbonitis
and the Massalian coastline.
208 C, 14-19 Also, on your left as you leave Lugdunum and the territory
above it, back in the Poeninus itself, is a turnoff that takes Poeninus, Pennine Alps
you to the Helvettian plains, after crossing the Rhodanus or Rhodanus, Rhône r.
lake Lemenna; and there’s a pass from there to the Sequanians Lemenna, Léman/Geneva l.
(Fr., Swi.)
via the Jura range and to the Lingonians. Running past these
Jura, Jura mts. (Fr., Swi.)
people are crossroads that split off in either direction, toward
both the Rhine and the ocean. |
208 C, 20-29 Polybius says that still in his time at Aquileia, right among 4.6.12
Polybius (2nd c. BCE) the Norican Tauriscans, a gold mine was discovered, so efficient that
if you scraped away the top two feet of surface soil you immediately
hit gold that could be dug up. The pit was not more than fifteen feet.
As for the gold, some of it was pure right t here and then, the size of a
[ 1 ] Strabo later (313 C, 29–314 C, 14n) emends many of the statements made here
(207 C, 18-33).
250
Italy + Islands
bean or a lupine, after only an eighth part had been melted away; the
rest required longer, but more profitable, smelting. A fter two months
of the Italiotes working with the natives, gold immediately became
one-third cheaper throughout all Italy. When the Tauriscans real-
ized this, they got rid of their co-workers and established a monopoly.
Now, however, all gold mines are subject to the Romans.
208 C, 29-31 Here, as in Iberia, the rivers bring down gold dust, which
is in addition to the mined gold, but there is not so much of it.
208 C, 32–209 C, 4 This same chap, describing the size and height of the same chap = Polybius
near the Tyrrhenian sea, then the one through the Taurinians that
Hannibal used, then the one past the Salassians, and the fourth past
the Rhaetians, all of them precipitous.
209 C, 7-13 He says that there are several lakes in the mountains but only He = Polybius
three large ones. Of these, lake Benacus has a length of five hundred Benacus, Garda l. (It.)
stades and a width of thirty, and from it flows the Mincius river; the Mincius, Mincio r.
next is lake Verbanus,1 with a length of four hundred and a width
narrower than the former, and it sends forth the Adua river; the third
is Larius,2 with a length of nearly three hundred stades and a width
of thirty, and it sends forth a large river, the Ticinus. All these flow Ticinus, Ticino r.
209 C, 15–210 C, 8 The foothills of the Alps mark the beginning of current-day 5.1.1
ITALY Italy. “Italy” was the name used by the ancients for Oenotria,4 Sicilian strait, Straits of Messina
Italy, w. Slovenia, nw. Croatia
stretching from the Sicilian strait to the Tarantinian and Tarantinian bay, Gulf of Taranto
[ 1 ] “Verbanus” is a m istake for “Larius” (Como l., It.), the lake through which the
Adua (Adda) river flows. Since Strabo elsewhere gives the correct information
(192 C, 31-36; 204 C, 8-14; 213 C, 16-18), it is probable that he cites Polybius here
in order to poke fun at Polybius’s confusion.
[ 2 ] “Larius” is a mistake for “Verbanus” (Maggiore l., It.), the lake from which the
Ticinus (Ticino) river flows. See previous note.
[ 3 ] Alps: 201 C, 31–209 C, 13.
[ 4 ] Oenotria (s. Italy): 254 C, 24–265 C, 26
251
3.1. Western Europe
Posidonian bays. This name dominated and was applied to Posidonian bay, Gulf of Salerno
and a part of Istria 2 (as far as Pola). One would suppose that Pola, Pula (Cro.)
those p eople who were first called “Italians,” flourishing as
they did, transmitted the name to their neighbors; and that
the expansion continued up until the Roman conquest. At
a l ater stage, after the Romans gave the Italiotes equal citi-
zenship rights, it seemed a good idea to give the same status
to the Galatians this side of the Alps and to the Enetians, to this side of Alps = on Italian side
of Alps
call them all “Italiotes” and “Romans,” and to dispatch many
colonies, some early on and some later (it is not easy to speak
of any colonies better than these).3 |
210 C, 9-17 It is not easy to encompass all of current-day Italy within 5.1.2
we mean a line without angle, and a line has no angles when it Strait, Straits of Messina
does not bend back on itself, or at least not much. The stretch
from Ariminum to the Iapygian headland and the stretch Ariminum, Rimini (It.)
from the Strait to the same headland do very much bend back Iapygian headland, Capo S.
Maria di Leuca (It.)
on each other. And the situation is the same, I think, with the
stretch from the inmost point of the Adria and the stretch from
Iapygia: these form an angle (or, if not an angle, a significant
curve) where they join each other in the region of Ariminum
and Ravenna. Consequently, then, this part—the coast from the Ravenna, Ravenna (It.)
252
Italy + Islands
210 C, 27-30 Therefore, one could say that its shape is four-sided (rather
than three-sided), but in no sense is it a triangle, except by mis-
application of the word. But it is better to accept that nongeo-
metric shapes do not lend themselves to definition. |
210 C, 31–211 C, 4 As for the individual parts, it is possible to state the follow- 5.1.3
point of the Adria; on the other side, reaching the stretch of Adria, Adriatic Sea
Ligystican coast as far as Genua (the Ligyan entrepôt), where Genua, Genoa (It.)
Italy is compressed on both sides, on one side by the Adria, Iapygia, Capo S. Maria di Leuca
(It.)
on the other side by the Tyrrhenian sea. The Adria is similar
Adria, Adriatic Sea
in shape and size to the part of Italy that is delineated by the
Apennine mountains and by the sea on e ither side as far as
Iapygia and as far as the isthmus between the Tarantinian and Tarantinian bay, Gulf of Taranto
Posidonian bays. The greatest width of each is around one Posidonian bay, Gulf of Salerno
253
3.1. Western Europe
211 C, 26-32 The Apennine mountain range, a fter reaching the region
around Ariminum and Ancon, and thus defining the sea- Ariminum, Ancon region,
ne. coast of Italy
to-sea width of Italy in this region, makes another turn and
cuts the entire territory lengthwise. Up until the Peucetians Peucetians, se. coast of Italy
and Leucanians, the range is not far from the Adria; once it Adria, Adriatic Sea
people say that they were sent as colonists by the oceanic Celts oceanic Celts = those living on
Atlantic coast of Celtica (France,
of the same name.5 Other people say that some of the Paphla- Belgium, Netherlands)
gonian Enetians6 escaped hither from the Trojan war in the
company of Antenor, citing as evidence their enthusiasm
for the breeding of horses, which has now been completely
eclipsed but was formerly held in high regard, to judge from
their ancient zeal for getting mares to produce mules (noted
Homer (8th c. BCE) by Homer: from the home of the Enetians, where wild mules breed).
Dionysius, the tyrant of Sicily, supplied the stud for his race
horses from there, so that the “Enetian” line gained renown
even among the Greeks, and the breed was famous for a long
time. |
212 C, 18-24 While the entire territory abounds in rivers and marshes, 5.1.5
BEYOND THE PADUS this is particularly so in the case of the Enetian territory,
n. + ne. Italy, w. Slovenia,
nw. Croatia which is additionally affected by the behavior of the sea. This
part of our sea is virtually the only one that exhibits the same our sea = Med. Sea
behavior as the ocean. It creates ocean-like low tides and high ocean = Atlantic
254
Italy + Islands
tides, which fill the greater part of the plain with a lagoon.
Channels and dams have been dug throughout the territory,
as in what is called the “Lower Territory” in Egypt.1 Some
parts have dried out and are used for farming, while other
parts allow passage by boat.
212 C, 24-30 As for the cities, some are islands and others are partly
surrounded by w ater. T
hose that are situated inland from the
marshes, in the interior, are amazingly accessible by sailing
up the rivers and particularly . . . * the Padus. It is the larg- Padus, Po r.
the river.3 The largest Celtic nations were the Boïans and the
Insubrians, and also the Senones, who once assaulted and
took the Roman city, alongside the Gaesatans. The Romans
later completely wiped out the latter and drove the Boïans
away from the area. (The Boïans, relocating to the Ister area,
lived together with the Tauriscans and fought a war against
the Dacians until the entire Boïan nation was destroyed; their
territory, which was part of Illyria, was left as mere sheep
pasture for t hose inhabiting the surrounding area.)4
213 C, 5-16 The Insubrians are still in existence. Their metropolis
was Mediolanium, which was long ago a village (they all Mediolanium, Milan (It.)
Alps. Nearby is Verona, which is an important city. Smaller Verona, Verona (It.)
than these cities are Brixia, Mantua, Regium, and Comum. Brixia, Brescia (It.)
Comum was a moderately large settlement. She was resettled Mantua, Mantua (It.)
by Pompeius Strabo, the f ather of Pompey the G reat, a fter Comum, Como (It.)
(New village).5
255
3.1. Western Europe
213 C, 16-18 Near this place is the lake called “Larius.” The Adua river Larius, Como l. (It.)
flows into it and then flows out of it1 and into the Padus. The Adua, Adda r.
and near them is Patavium, the best of the region’s cities, Patavium, Padua (It.)
which was recently assessed as having five hundred horsemen, Roman census was held in 14 CE
the marshes from a great harbor. The harbor is called “Medu- Meduacus (harbor), ?nr.
Sambruson (It.)
acus,” the same as the river.
213 C, 27–214 C, 4 As for the cities in the marshes, the greatest is Ravenna, Ravenna, Ravenna (It.)
256
Italy + Islands
cepted some Umbrians, who now possess the city, whereas the
Thessalians left for home.
214 C, 14-18 The foregoing cities,1 then, are largely surrounded by the
marshes, with the consequence that they get flooded. | Opi- Opitergium, Oderzo (It.) 5.1.8
tergium, Concordia, Atria, Vicetia, and various such small Concordia, Concordia Sagittaria
(It.)
towns are less affected by the marshes and are connected to
Atria, Adria (It.)
the sea by short waterways. P eople say that Atria was a promi-
Vicetia, Vicenza (It.)
nent city and that the gulf was named after her, with a letter
gulf = Adriatic Sea
change.
214 C, 18-24 Aquileia, which is nearest to the inmost recess, was Aquileia, Aquileia (It.)
Carbo unsuccessfully attacked the Cimbrians. This place has Roman general Gnaeus Carbo
defeated by Cimbrians, 113 BCE
productive gold panning and ironworks.
214 C, 28–215 C, 4 At the very innermost point of the Adria is the Timavum, Timavus, Timavo r.
by the “Diomedian” islands and by the stories of events con- Diomedian islands, Tremiti (It.
islands)
cerning the Daunians and Argos Hippium, which I shall relate
to the extent that it is historically useful.3 But many mythical
stories, or falsehoods, must be left aside, such as the tale of
Phaetho and the Heliads, who w ere turned into poplars in the
vicinity of the Eridanus (which is said to be near the Padus,
257
3.1. Western Europe
called “Polae.” 2
216 C, 6-10 The places beyond the Padus are inhabited by Enetians beyond Padus = north of Po r.
[ 1 ] 212 C, 7-17.
[ 2 ] Callimachus’s poem is cited by Strabo earlier (46 C, 1-13) as evidence for the
historical veracity of poetry.
[ 3 ] The name is missing in the manuscripts. Editors have inserted “Istrians.” How-
ever, if Strabo is repeating information given earlier (212 C, 1-7; 212 C, 31–213 C,
5), the missing name may be “Celts.”
258
Italy + Islands
Gaesatans were once the major inhabitants. The expulsion of Sabata, Vado Ligurie (It.)
the Boïans and the disappearance of the Gaesatans and the
Senones left only the Ligyan tribes and the Roman colonies.
216 C, 15-29 The Umbrian tribe and, in some places, the Tyrrhenian tribe
have been mixed up with the Romans. Before Roman expan-
sion, both these nations were in a sort of competition with each
other for primacy. They easily attacked each other across the
Tiber river, which ran between them; if one of the nations sent
an army to campaign against a third party, then the other nation
was smitten with desire not to be left out of attacking the same
place. The Tyrrhenians, dispatching an army against the na-
tives in the Padus area, met with success, but their wanton ways Padus, Po r.
meant that they were soon forced to retreat. The other nation
then launched a campaign against the natives, who forced them
back. Then, since they squabbled over one place after another,
of the great number of settlements they made some Tyrrhenian
and others Umbrian (a greater number of them were Umbrian,
since they were nearer). When the Romans took over and sent
colonists to many places, they preserved the nationality of the
early settlers. Nowadays they are all Romans, but nevertheless
some are called “Umbrians” and “Tyrrhenians,” just like the
“Enetians,” “Ligyans,” and “Insubrians.” |
216 C, 30–217 C, 5 Famous cities this side of the Padus and in the vicinity of 5.1.11
the Padus are Placentia and Cremona (very close to the ap- Placentia, Piacenza (It.)
proximate center of the territory). Between these two and Cremona, Cremona (It.)
Mutina, Modena (It.) Ariminum are Parma, Mutina, and Bononia (already near Parma, Parma (It.)
Bononia, Bologna (It.) Ravenna) and small towns in their midst, through which runs
Ravenna, Ravenna (It.) the road to Rome1—Acara, Regium Lepidum, Macri Campi Regium Lepidum, Reggio
Macri Campi, nr. Magreta (It.) Emilia (It.)
(where an annual public festival is held), Claterna, Forum
Forum Cornelium, Imola (It.) Claterna, Ozzano (It.)
Faventia, Faenza (It.)
Cornelium. Faventia and Caesena, toward the Sapis river and
Caesena, Cesena (It.) the Rubicon, finally take us up to Ariminum. Ariminum is an Rubicon, ?Pisciatello/Fiumicino r.
Sapis, Savio r. Umbrian settlement, as is Ravenna. Each city has accepted Ariminum (city), Rimini (It.)
[ 1 ] The Via Aemilia, on which the towns mentioned by Strabo are located, runs
from Placentia to Ariminum. Rome can be reached from Ariminum by means
of the Via Flaminia: 217 C, 26-30n; 227 C, 20-24n. Rome can also be reached
from Placentia through Dertho and thence—with an option of two alternative
routes—through Genua: 217 C, 15-26nn.
259
3.1. Western Europe
Roman colonists. Ariminum has a harbor, and a river of the Ariminus (river), Marecchia r.
river of the same name (which runs past the city and joins Ticinus (river), Ticino r.
the Padus), also Clastidium, Dertho, and, on a bit of a side Clastidium, Casteggio (It.)
road,1 Aquae Statiellae. The direct route to Ocelum2 along Dertho, Tortona (It.)
the Padus and the Duria river—a route that is precipitous Aquae Statiellae, Acqui Terme
(It.)
for much of the way and takes in various rivers including the
Duria river, Doire Ripaire/Dora
Druentia—is around one hundred and sixty miles. After that, Riparia
you finally reach the Alps and Celtica. Druentia, Durance r.
217 C, 12-15 There is a city—Luca3—toward the mountains above
Luna. Some of the p eople live in villages. Nevertheless, the
territory is a good source of manpower. Much of the army
comes from h ere, and a mass of equestrians from which the
senate is constituted.
217 C, 15-19 Dertho is a significant city, lying halfway along the road Dertho, Tortona (It.)
from Genua to Placentia, and four hundred stades distant Genua, Genoa (It.)
from each. On this road is Aquae Statiellae.4 From Placentia Placentia, Piacenza (It.)
to Ariminum has been described.5 To Ravenna, it is a voyage Ravenna, Ravenna (It.)
217 C, 26-30 There’s a diff erent Aemilian road,7 the continuation of the
different Aemilian road = Lat. Flaminian. Marcus Lepidus and Gaius Flaminius w ere joint
Via Aemilia
consuls. When they subjugated the Ligyans, the latter con-
Flaminian road = Lat. Via structed the Flaminian road from Rome past the Tyrrhenians Ariminum region, ne. coast
Flaminia
and Umbria to the Ariminum region, while the former con- of Italy
structed its continuation to Bononia and thence to Aquileia Bononia, Bologna (It.)
[ 1 ] The “side road” is the Via Aemilia Scauri: 217 C, 20-26n. [ 5 ] Via Aemilia: 216 C, 30–217 C, 5n.
[ 2 ] Ocelum (nr. Novaretto/Caprie, It.) marks the border with Cottius country: 179 C, [ 6 ] Strabo corrects his earlier conflation of the two roads through Dertho (217 C,
1-9. 15-19n). Strabo himself may have traveled the Via Aemilia Scauri—if his journey
[ 3 ] Luca (Lucca, It.) is mentioned out of geographical context, perhaps because it to Populonium (223 C, 27–224 C, 3n), perhaps as far north as Luna (222 C, 9-22n),
lies near a stretch of the Via Aemilia Scauri: 217 C, 20-26n. was made by land rather than by sea.
[ 4 ] Strabo appears to conflate two roads from Dertho to Genua, one going direct [ 7 ] Via Aemilia: 216 C, 30–217 C, 5n.
and one going via Aquae Statiellae and Sabata: 217 C, 5-12n; 217 C, 20-26n. [ 8 ] 210 C, 31–211 C, 15.
260
Italy + Islands
Aesis, Esino r. the Aesis river and later the Rubicon, both rivers flowing into Rubicon, ?Pisciatello/Fiumicino r.
218 C, 1-10 Evidence of the excellent quality of these places is pro- 5.1.12
Strabo summarizes the vided by their population, the size of their cities, and their
advantages of “Celtica this side
[of the Alps]” wealth. In all t hese respects, the Romans in this region have
surpassed the rest of Italy. The arable land produces many
and multifarious crops, and the woods have such a quantity
of acorns that Rome is largely fed by the herds of swine from
here. Because it is so well supplied with water, it also yields
millet in exceptional quantities. This is the best defense
against famine, resisting all weathers and never failing, even
when t here is a scarcity of other grains. It also has wonderful
pitchworks. The wine jars attest to the quantity of wine—the
wooden ones are larger than h ouses! The ready availability of
pitch contributes to the easy sealing of them.
218 C, 10-15 Places in the region of Mutina and the Scultanna river Mutina, Modena (It.)
produce a soft wool that is far finer than any other. Coarse Scultanna, Panaro r.
lage near Ictumuli, itself a village—both are in the Placentia Placentia, Piacenza (It.)
region.)
218 C, 20 Let this be the point at which the description of the first
part of Italy is completed.1 |
218 C, 21-24 Let Ligystica—within the Apennine mountains them- 5.2.1
[ 1 ] “First part of Italy” = Celtica this side of the Alps: 212 C, 1–218 C, 20.
[ 2 ] I.e., Celtica this side of the Alps.
[ 3 ] Strabo has written quite a bit about Ligystica (201 C, 31–202 C, 35; 209 C,
15–210 C, 8n); his comment here is perhaps taken from Posidonius.
261
3.1. Western Europe
near Rome, as far as the coast. Widthwise, they extend ap- they = Umbrians, Sabines, Latins
proximately alongside the river and the Tyrrhenians. Length- Lengthwise = east–west
(approx.)
wise, they extend alongside each other, reaching the part of
the Apennine mountains near the Adria—first the Umbrians, Adria, Adriatic Sea
after them the Sabines, finally the occupants of Latina—all of
them beginning at the river.
219 C, 3-13 The Latin territory lies between the stretch of coast
from Ostia to Sinuessa city and Sabina.1 (Ostia is Rome’s Ostia, Ostia Antica (It.)
port, into which the Tiber river—which runs past Rome— Sinuessa city, Torre S. Limato
(It.)
discharges.) Lengthwise, it extends to Campania and the
Samnite mountains. Sabina lies between the Latins and the
Umbrians.2 It, too, extends to the Samnite mountains but is
rather more contiguous with the Vestinian, Paelignian, and
Marsian part of the Apennine mountains. The Umbrians lie
between Sabina and Tyrrhenia.3 They go as far as Ariminum Ariminum, Rimini (It.)
and Ravenna, across the mountains. The Tyrrhenians stop at Ravenna, Ravenna (It.)
262
Italy + Islands
nation rites and music that the Romans used for public events.
220 C, 6-10 This fellow’s son was the second Tarquinius—that is,
Superbus 1—who was also the last king and fled into exile.
Porsinas, the king of the inhabitants of Clusium, a Tyrrhe- Clusium, Chiusi (It.)
220 C, 11-19 Furthermore, t here are the deeds of the Caeretanians. Caeretanians = inhabitants of
Caere, Cerveteri (It.)
They battled with the Galatians who took Rome, attacking
them in the country of the Sabines on their return journey.
The booty that those fellows had taken from the Romans, those fellows = Galatians
[ 1 ] Strabo transliterates into Greek the Latin adjective Superbus (Proud): 508 C,
10-18n.
[ 2 ] 219 C, 15–220 C, 10.
263
3.1. Western Europe
220 C, 19-30 This city was highly respected by the Greeks for her brav- this city = Caere, Cerveteri (It.)
for the city now called “Caere” was formerly called “Agylla”
and is said to have been founded by Pelasgians arriving from
Thessaly. When the Lydians (who changed their name to
“Tyrrhenians”) were campaigning against the Agyllaeans,
someone went up to the city wall and asked for the name of
the city. Instead of replying, one of the Thessalians on the wall
addressed him with chaere (welcome). The Tyrrhenians took this
as a good omen and, when they had taken the city, changed
her name. This city of such splendor and renown now pre-
serves mere vestiges of it. The nearby hot springs, which they
call the “Caeretanian,” 1 are far more populous than the city is Caeretanian (hot springs) = Lat.
Aquae Caeretanae (Piano della
because of visitors seeking cures. | Carlotta, nr. Sasso, It.)
220 C, 31–221 C, 5 As for the Pelasgians, virtually all sources agree that they 5.2.4
[ 1 ] “They” are Latin speakers; Strabo translates into Greek the Latin name Aquae
Caeretanae: 508 C, 10-18n.
264
Italy + Islands
221 C, 22-32 As for Ephorus’s statement that this tribe was from Arca-
Ephorus (4th c. BCE) dia, Hesiod is responsible, since he says that sons were born to he = Hesiod
Hesiod (late 8th–7th c. BCE) godlike Lycaon, / whom Pelasgus once fathered. Aeschylus says (in
Aeschylus (5th c. BCE) either the Suppliant Women or the Danaïds) that they originated
in Mycenaean Argos. Ephorus says that the Peloponnese used to be
Euripides (5th c. BCE) called “Pelasgian.” Euripides (in Archelaus) says that Danaus,
the f ather of fifty d
aughters / . . . / arrived in Argos and founded
Inachus’s city / and passed a law throughout Greece that t hose who
had formerly been called “Pelasgiotes” / should be called “Danaans.”
221 C, 33-38 Anticlides says that they were the first to s ettle the region of
Anticlides (early 3rd c. BCE) Lemnos and Imbros, and some of them set sail for Italy with Tyrse- Lemnos, Lemnos (Gk. island)
Atthis, chronicles of Athenian nus, the son of Atys. The compilers of the Atthis tell the story Imbros, Gökçeada (Tk. island)
history
of the Pelasgians being at Athens and say that they w ere called
“Pelargi” (Storks) by the Atticans because they were migratory and,
like birds, went wherever fortune led them. |
222 C, 1-3 People say that the greatest length of Tyrrhenia is the 5.2.5
coastline from Luna as far as Ostia, some two thousand five Luna, Luni (It.)
hundred stades,1 and the width as far as the mountains is less Ostia, Ostia Antica (It.)
thence to Vada Volaterrana, two hundred and eighty; then Vada Volaterrana, Vada (It.)
again, from there to Populonium is two hundred and seventy; Populonium, Populonia (It.)
from Populonium to Cossa nearly eight hundred (although Cossa, Ansedonia (It.)
Polybius (2nd c. BCE) some say six hundred). Polybius is incorrect is giving a total
of one thousand four hundred and thirty.2
222 C, 9-22 Of these, Luna (Moon) is a city and a harbor. The Greeks call Luna, Luni (It.)
them “Selene’s harbor and city.”3 The city is not large, but the
harbor is both very large and very beautiful, enclosing within
itself several harbors that are deep right up to the shore,
such as would be a fitting operational base for a people that
ruled over such a large sea for such a long time. The harbor is
hemmed in by tall mountains, from which can be glimpsed4
the high sea and Sardo5 and a large part of the shoreline in Sardo, Sardinia (It. island)
[ 1 ] Strabo adds to the distance from Luna (Luni, It.) southward to Cossa (Ansedo- farther north, to Luna (Luni, It.). Faulty memory could explain why Strabo states
nia, It.)—which amounts to 1,750 stades (222 C, 3-8n)—the distance from Cossa(e) that Sardo (Sardinia, It. island) can be seen from Luna. It is from Populonium that
to Ostia (Ostia Antica, It.), which amounts to 740 stades (225 C, 29–226 C, 8). islands can be seen, and the islands most clearly seen are Cyrnus (Corsica, Fr.
[ 2 ] Strabo’s unexpressed total is 400 + 280 + 270 + 800 = 1,750 stades. island) and Aethalia (Elba, It. island). Strabo l ater corrects himself: 223 C, 24-27n;
[ 3 ] Luna is the Latin word, selene the Greek word, for “moon.” The words also func- 224 C, 3-8n; 225 C, 20-24n.
tion as the name of the goddess associated with the moon. [ 5 ] 117 C, 12-20nn.
[ 4 ] Possibly glimpsed by Strabo himself, who explicitly attests to his presence as far
north as Populonium (Populonia, It.) (223 C, 27–224 C, 3n) and may have traveled
265
3.1. Western Europe
tis (all of them being called “Pylians”). Pisa lies between two Pisatis = region of Pisa, Pisa (It.)
rivers, the Arnus and the Ausar, at the point where they join. Arnus, Arno r.
One of them flows from Arretium, for much of its course con- Ausar, Serchio r.
sisting not of one river but three streams. The other flows Arretium, Arezzo (It.)
from the Apennine mountains. When they come together
into one river, they heave each other up by their mutual force,
so much so that if people stand on both sides, neither one
can catch sight of the other.1 As a necessary consequence,
voyages upstream from the sea are difficult. The upstream
voyage is around twenty stades. According to myth, when
these two rivers first flowed down from the mountains, the
locals s topped them for fear that they might join together and
flood the territory, but the rivers promised that they would
not cause a flood—and they kept their word.
223 C, 1-7 The city appears to have once flourished, and is not with- city = Pisa, Pisa (It.)
266
Italy + Islands
223 C, 15-23 Populonium is situated on a lofty headland, which drops Populonium, Populonia (It.)
quarries in the countryside. I also saw the men who work the
iron that is brought over from Aethalia: it cannot be suffi- Aethalia, Elba (It. island)
Artemidorus (late 2nd–early correct in saying that both islands lie one thousand two
1st c. BCE)
hundred stades out to sea. In that case, they would not have
been visible to me of all people,3 nor would they have been so
clearly seen (particularly Cyrnus).4
224 C, 9-13 On Aethalia is “Argoos harbor,” named after the Argo, Argoos harbor, Portoferraio
(Elba)
AETHALIA so people say. The story is that Jason sailed t here in quest
Elba (It. island)
of Circe’s dwelling, since Medea wished to see her aunt, and
that skin scrapings left behind by the Argonauts solidified
and remain to this day as variegated pebbles on the seashore.
[ 1 ] Cf. 222 C, 9-22n, where Strabo states that it is possible to see Sardo (Sardinia, It.
island) from Luna (Luni, It.). He now admits that it is barely possible to see Sardo
even from Populonium (Populonia, It.), and that Cyrnus (Corsica, Fr. island) and
Aethalia (Elba, It. island) are nearer.
[ 2 ] Strabo was probably a youth when he visited Populonium: his confusion be-
tween Luna and Populonium and between Sardo and Cyrnus (222 C, 9-22n;
223 C, 24-27) suggests the faulty recollection of a long ago visit. Strabo’s pres-
ence in Italy: 273 C, 2-14n.
[ 3 ] Strabo perhaps plays on the meaning (i.e., “cross-eyed”) of his own name:
cf. 267 C, 10-14.
[ 4 ] Strabo implicitly corrects his e arlier statement (222 C, 9-22n, where he claims
that Sardo can be seen even from Luna).
267
3.1. Western Europe
224 C, 13-18 Such mythical fabrications are proof of what I said, that
Homer (8th c. BCE) Homer did not himself fictionalize everything1 but, hearing
many such stories bandied about, exaggerated distances and
remoteness. Just as he banished Odysseus to the ocean, it was
a similar case with Jason, since both the latter and the former
undertook a journey, just as Menelaus did.
224 C, 18-19 That is the extent of my description of Aethalia.2 |
224 C, 20-28 Cyrnus is called “Corsica” by the Romans. Living condi- 5.2.7
CYRNUS tions are bad, since the island is rocky and, in most parts,
Corsica (Fr. island)
completely impenetrable. In consequence, t hose who dwell in
the mountains and earn their livelihood by raiding are more
savage than wild animals. Whenever the Roman governors 3
have launched an attack on their strongholds and have cap-
tured a horde of them, one sees the slaves in Rome,4 and one
is struck by how beast-like and bovine they appear. E ither
they do not survive, or if they do live, the p eople who bought
them get so fed up with their apathy and listlessness that, even
though they got them for next to nothing, they still regret
the purchase!
224 C, 28-29 Some parts of the island are nevertheless habitable, and
in places t here are small towns: Blesinon, Charax, Eniconiae,
and Vapanes.
224 C, 29-33 The chorographer 5 says that the length of the island is one island = Cyrnus, Corsica
(Fr. island)
hundred and sixty miles, and its width seventy; and the length
of Sardo is two hundred and twenty, and its width ninety- Sardo, Sardinia (It. island)
are counterbalanced by defects. The island is unhealthy in the Sulci, S. Antioca (Sar.)
[ 1 ] 6 C, 31–7 C, 7; 15 C, 26–47 C, 8.
[ 2 ] 224 C, 9-18.
[ 3 ] The Greek word literally means “praetors,” a specific rank of Roman officialdom.
As Strabo later tells us (840 C, 9-29), this was the rank of those Romans who
governed the province of Sardo + Cyrnus.
[ 4 ] As probably seen by Strabo himself, during one of several stays in Rome: 273 C,
2-14n.
[ 5 ] The term “chorographer” (lit., “one who describes territories”) usually seems to
be used by Strabo to mean a geographer who describes the lived-in world rather
than the earth in its entirety: 9 C, 35–10 C, 5n. Here, however, Strabo appears to cite
“the chorographer” as a specific individual or as the holder of a specific office, as
also at 225 C, 20-24; 261 C, 27–262 C, 2; 277 C, 16-19; 285 C, 1-7. The common feature
of such citations is that distances are given in Roman miles. Cf. 266 C, 6-19n.
268
Italy + Islands
chorographer 3 says that the shortest crossing from Libya to Aethalia, Elba (It. island)
225 C, 25-29 After Populonium comes the city of Cossae, set back a Cossae, Ansedonia (It.)
little from the coast. On the bay is a high hill on which the
city is built. At its foot is the Harbor of Heracles, and nearby Harbor of Heracles, Port’Ercole
(It.)
is a lagoon. Alongside the headland beyond the bay, there’s a
tuna observatory. Tuna go after not only sea acorns but also
purplefish, and follow the mainland from the outer sea even outer sea = Atlantic
as far as Sicily.
225 C, 29–226 C, 8 As you sail along the coast from Cossae to Ostia, you come
to the small towns of Gravisci, Pyrgi, Alsium, and Fregena. Gravisci, Porto Clementino (It.)
It is three hundred stades to Gravisci. Along the way, there’s Pyrgi, S. Severa (It.)
a place called “Regisvilla.” The story is that this was the royal Alsium, Palo (It.)
residence of Maleos the Pelasgian, who, they say, a fter having Regisvilla, Le Murelle (It.)
ruled over the area, departed hence to Athens with his fellow Fregena, nr. Fregene (It.)
269
3.1. Western Europe
mentioned3 are Arretium, Perusia, Volsinii, and Sutrium. Arretium, Arezzo (It.)
Blera, Blera (It.) In addition to these, there are many small towns: Blera, Fe- Perusia, Perugia (It.)
Ferentinum, Ferento, nr. Viterbo rentinum, Falerii, Faliscum, Nepita, Statonia, and several Volsinii, Bolsena/Orvieto (It.)
(It.)
others. Some of these have been in existence since the begin- Sutrium, Sutri (It.)
Falerii, Civita Castellana/
S. Maria di Fálleri (It.) ning, some w ere settled by the Romans—or leveled by the
Nepita, Nepi (It.)
Romans, as for example Veii (which was often at war with Veii, Veio, nr. Isola Farnese (It.)
226 C, 18-23 At the foot of mount Soractus is the city of Feronia, hom- Soractus, Monte Soratte (It.)
onymous with a local female deity who is held in great honor Feronia, nr. Scorano (It.)
She is one thousand two hundred stades from Rome, and Clu- Clusium, Chiusi (It.)
sium eight hundred. Perusia is near these two. Perusia, Perugia (It.)
226 C, 27–227 C, 3 The large and numerous lakes add to the territory’s bless-
Ciminian lake = Lat. Lacus ings. They are navigable and provide habitat for many fish
Ciminius
and waterfowl. Rushes, papyrus, and many flowering reeds are
Volsinian lake = Lat. Lacus
Volsiniensis
conveyed thence to Rome by means of the rivers that flow into
Clusian lake = Lat. Lacus Clusinus
the Tiber from the lakes. T
hese include the Ciminian lake, the Ciminian lake, Lago di Vico
of Arretium is the Trasumennan lake, the location of passes Sabatine lake, Lago di Bracciano
[ 1 ] 220 C, 19-30.
[ 2 ] 222 C, 1–224 C, 8; 225 C, 25–226 C, 8.
[ 3 ] 220 C, 11-30 (Caere); 223 C, 8-14 (Volaterrae); perhaps also Luca (217 C, 12-15).
270
Italy + Islands
Trasumennan lake = Lat. Lacus that armies can use to cross over from Celtica into Tyrrhe- Trasumennan lake, Lago
Trasumennus Trasimeno
nia, which Hannibal, too, used. (There are two: this one and
the pass leading to Ariminum through Umbria. The one to Ariminum, Rimini (It.)
227 C, 7-12 Lying alongside Tyrrhenia to the east is Umbria, which Adria, Adriatic Sea 5.2.10
UMBRIA starts with the Apennines and goes farther, as far as the Sarsina, Sarsina (It.)
cen. Italy
Adria. These p eople start at Ravenna and hold the areas Ariminum, Rimini (It.)
Ravenna, Ravenna (It.)
nearby and the following areas of Sarsina, Ariminum, Sena, Sena, Senigallia (It.)
Metaurus, Metauro r. and Camarinum. The Aesis river is also here, and mount Cin- Cingulum, Monte S. Vicino (It.)
t emple to Tyche = Lat. Fanum gulum, and Sentinum, and the Metaurus river, and the temple Camarinum, Camerino (It.)
Fortunae
to Tyche. Sentinum, nr. Sassoferrato (It.)
227 C, 12-20 In this region is the seaward boundary between what was
formerly Italy and Celtica. The rulers often moved it: once
Aesis, Esino r. they made the Aesis the boundary, then the Rubicon river.
Rubicon, ?Pisciatello/Fiumicino r. The Aesis is between Ancon and Sena, the Rubicon is between Ancon, Ancona (It.)
Ariminum and Ravenna. Both flow into the Adria. Now that
all the territory as far as the Alps comes u nder the rubric of
“Italy,” we should forget about this border. Nevertheless, the
consensus is that Umbria as such goes as far as Ravenna, on
the grounds that Ravenna is inhabited by these people. these people = Umbrians
one thousand three hundred and fifty stades. length = east–west dimension
227 C, 23-24 Such is the length; 2 the width is variable. width = north–south dimension
227 C, 25-32 The following are the significant cities this side of the
Apennine mountains that are on the Flaminian road itself. In
the direction of the Tiber, there’s Ocriculi, . . . *, and Narnia, Narnia, Narni (It.)
past which runs the Nar river, which joins the Tiber slightly Nar, Nera r.
above Ocriculi and is navigable by boats of no great size. Carsuli, S. Damiano (It.)
Then there are Carsuli and Mevania; past the latter runs the Mevania, Bevagna (It.)
Tinia, which likewise conveys, in smaller boats, goods from Tinia, Topino r.
the plains to the Tiber. There are various other settlements,
271
3.1. Western Europe
well populated b ecause of the road rather than their p olitical Nuceria, ?Nocera (It.)
Forum Flaminium, S. Giovanni constitutions: Forum Flaminium, Nuceria (which produces Forum Sempronium, nr.
Profiamma, nr. Foligno (It.) Fossombrone (It.)
wooden vessels), and Forum Sempronium.
227 C, 32-36 In the area to the road’s right (as you go from Ocriculi
to Ariminum) are Interamna, Spoletium, Aesium, and Ca- Interamna, Terni (It.)
mertes, in the very mountains that border Picentina. In the Spoletium, Spoleto (It.)
Ameria, Amelia (It.) area on the other side are Ameria; the well-defended city of Aesium, Iesi (It.)
Tuder, Todi (It.) Tuder; Hispellum; and Iguvium, which brings us close to the Camertes, Camerino (It.)
Hispellum, Spello (It.) passes over the mountains. Iguvium, Gubbio (It.)
227 C, 37–228 C, 7 The entire territory is blessed with fertility, although entire territory = Umbria
ians. Their few cities have been brought low through their
incessant warfare: Amiternum and Reate (near which is the Amiternum, S. Vittorino (It.)
village of Interocrea and the cold springs of Cotiliae, from Reate, Rieti (It.)
which people drink and in which they sit to cure diseases). Interocrea, Antrodoco (It.)
Also belonging to the Sabines is Foruli—a rock better suited Cotiliae, nr. Paterno (It.)
to revolution than habitation! Cyres is now a l ittle village, but Foruli, Civitatomassa (It.)
was once a city of significance, since it was the home of the Cyres, nr. Corese Terra (It.)
272
Italy + Islands
the Tiber) by the Nomentanian road, which starts from the Nomentanian road = Lat. Via
Nomentana
same gate, the “Colline.” |
228 C, 34–229 C, 4 Latina lies next. Latina is the home of the Romans’ city, but Latina = territory of the Latins 5.3.2
LATINA it has also absorbed many cities that formerly did not belong
w. Italy
to Latina. Surrounding the Romans, at the time when the city
was first founded, were Aequans, Volscians, Hernicians; the
indigenous peoples around Rome herself; the Rutulians, who
held ancient Ardea; and other federations of greater or lesser
size. Some of them lived independently in villages and w ere
not members of any particular tribe.
229 C, 4-16 They say that Aeneas, with his father, Anchises, and his
son Ascanius, landed at Laurentum, on the shore near Ostia Ostia, Ostia Antica (It.)
and the Tiber, and founded a city inland a little way (some
twenty-four stades) from the coast; Latinus, king of the in-
digenous people living on the site of current-day Rome, made
a visit and made allies out of those associated with Aeneas1
against the neighboring Rutulians holding Ardea (it is one Ardea, Ardea (It.)
273
3.1. Western Europe
229 C, 20-28 The events associated with Amulius and his brother
Numitor—sometimes given in mythical form, sometimes
more plausibly—are placed four hundred years later. The
two b rothers inherited from Ascanius’s descendants the king-
dom of Alba, which reached as far as the Tiber. The younger
brother elbowing the older b rother aside, Amulius was the
ruler. Numitor had a son and a daughter. Amulius killed the
son during a hunt, and he appointed the daughter (they give
Hestia = Lat. Vesta her name as “Rhea Silvia”) as a priestess of Hestia so that she
might remain childless. Then, discovering—when she bore
twins—that Rhea had been violated, as a f avor to his b rother
he imprisoned rather than killed her, and exposed her twins
on the banks of the Tiber in accordance with ancestral custom.
229 C, 28–230 C, 2 The mythical version is that the twins w ere the sons of
Ares and, a fter being exposed, w ere seen being suckled by
a she-wolf; that Faustulus, who was one of the local swine-
herds, rescued and reared them—we must assume, however,
that the twins w ere retrieved and reared by one of Amulius’s
powerful subjects—and called one of them “Romulus” and
the other “Remus”; that, when they had grown to man-
hood, they attacked Amulius and his children; that, after
these people had been destroyed and the kingdom restored
to Numitor, they went home and founded Rome, in a place
determined by necessity rather than choice (as the site was
not naturally well defended, nor did its surroundings have
enough territory to support a city, let alone enough popula-
tion to s ettle it).
230 C, 2-10 The existing inhabitants w ere self-sufficient, reaching
right up to the wall of the city that was being founded, and
did not pay any attention at all to the Albans. There was
Collatia, and Antemnae, Fidenae, Labicum, and other such Collatia, Lunghezza (It.)
places—at that stage small towns, nowadays villages in the Antemnae, Monte Antenne (It.)
possession of private individuals, forty stades or slightly Fidenae, Borgata Fidene (It.)
more from Rome. At any rate, between the fifth and sixth of Labicum, Colonna (It.)
the milestones marking the distance from Rome,1 is a loca-
tion called “Festi.” They say that this marks the boundary
of the land belonging to the Romans at that time. Here and
at several other sites considered as boundaries, on one and
religious officials = Lat. the same day, the religious officials celebrate a festival, which
pontifices
they call Ambarvia.2
[ 1 ] The standard conversion rate was 8 Greek stades to 1 Roman mile. “Between
the fifth and sixth milestone” is equivalent to between 40 and 48 stades from
Rome: “forty stades or slightly more.”
[ 2 ] “They” are Latin speakers. Strabo’s transliteration into Greek suggests a Roman
name, Ambarvia, whereas the name used by Romans was Ambarvalia. Strabo’s
transliteration of Latin names: 508 C, 10-18n.
274
Italy + Islands
230 C, 11-22 So, then, they say that during the civil strife that occurred
at the time of the founding, Remus was slain. After the found-
ing, Romulus gathered together a motley crew by decreeing
that the area between the acropolis and the Capitol was an
asylum, and by declaring that any of the neighboring p eoples
who fled there w ere citizens. Since he could not provide them
with wives, he proclaimed . . . * h orse races sacred to Posidon
(held up to this day); when a g reat throng of mostly Sabine
people was assembled, he ordered any of those who needed
wives to snatch the young w omen who w ere visiting. Al-
though he sought to avenge the outrage militarily, the king
of the Cyrites—Titus Tatius—ended up sharing sovereignty
and government with Romulus. A fter Tatius was treacher-
ously slain in Lavinium, Romulus ruled alone over the Cy- Lavinium, Pratica di Mare (It.)
275
3.1. Western Europe
231 C, 6-12 The Pomentine plain, on the border with the Latins, and Pomentine plain, Agro Pontino
(It.)
Pomentine plain = Lat. the city of Apiola, which was razed by Tarquinius Priscus,
Pomptinus Ager
belonged to the Volscians. The Aequians were the closest
neighbors to the Cyrites. Priscus sacked their cities, too; and Lanuvium, Lanuvio (It.)
son = Tarquinius Superbus his son destroyed Suessa, the Volscian metropolis. The Her- Alba, Castel Gandolfo (It.)
nicians lived near Lanuvium, Alba, and Rome herself. Aricia, Aricia, Ariccia (It.)
Tellenae, and Antium w ere not far away. Antium, Anzio (It.)
231 C, 12-17 The Albans initially shared the Romans’ mindset, since
they spoke the same language and w ere Latins. Although each
people was ruled separately, t here w ere nevertheless rights
of intermarriage, and the religious rituals at Alba and other
political rights w ere shared. L
ater, when war broke out, Alba
was razed except for her t emple, and the Albans w ere decreed
to be Roman citizens.
231 C, 17-19 As for the other cities in the vicinity, some were destroyed
and others humiliated for their recalcitrance, while some grew
stronger b ecause of their right-mindedness.
231 C, 19-23 Nowadays, the shoreline from Ostia as far as the city of Ostia, Ostia Antica (It.)
Sinuessa is called “Latin.” Formerly, it extended only to Cir- Sinuessa, Torre S. Limato (It.)
caeum. The interior, too, was formerly not large but later ex- Circaeum, Monte Circeo (It.)
276
Italy + Islands
wrote a letter of accusation; then Demetrius, when he ren- Demetrius ruled Macedonia,
3rd c. BCE
dered up to the Romans the pirates who had been captured,
said that, as a f avor, he returned to them t hese individuals on ac-
count of their kinship with the Greeks but did not consider it right
that the very men in charge of Italy should at the same time o rganize
pirate raids, nor that they should set up a temple in their marketplace
to the Dioscuri and worship t hose whom everyone calls “Saviors” yet Dioscuri = Castor and Pollux
[ 1 ] The term “leaders” includes both emperors and provincial governors: 159 C,
19-28n.
277
3.1. Western Europe
232 C, 34–233 C, 7 As for the [shoreline] contiguous with this, it was once inhab-
ited by the Ausonians (who also held Campania) and after
them by the Oscans (who also had a share in Campania).
Nowadays, everything as far as Sinuessa belongs to the Latins,
as I said.1 A peculiar thing has come about in connection with
the Oscans and the Ausonian nation. On the one hand, al-
though the Oscans have disappeared, their language persists
among the Romans so that, at a certain traditional contest,
their poems are acted out on stage and mimed. On the other
hand, although the Ausonians never ever lived on the Sicil-
ian sea, that body of water is nevertheless called “Ausonian.”
233 C, 8-19 Following on from Circaeum at a distance of one hundred
stades is Tarracina, formerly called “Trachina” (Rugged) after Tarracina, Terracina (It.)
Sinuessa) and t hose at its endpoint (Taras and Brundisium). Minturna, nr. Minturno (It.)
Near Tarracina as you head toward Rome, stretching for many Sinuessa, Torre S. Limato (It.)
stades alongside the Appian road, is a canal filled with w ater Taras, Taranto (It.)
from the rivers and marshes. The voyage along the canal is
made mostly at night, so that you start in the e vening, finish
in the morning, and continue the rest of the journey by road.
(However, the voyage can also be made by day.) Towing is
done by a l ittle mule.
233 C, 20-26 Next is Formiae, a city founded by Laconians, formerly Formiae, Formia (It.)
conians call all things that curve inward kaietas (hollows) 4 (Some Caieta/Kaiatas, Gaeta (It.)
people, however, say that the bay takes its name from Ae-
neas’s nurse.) The bay is one hundred stades long, starting
from Tarracina and g oing as far as the headland of the same Caieta headland, Punta
Stendardo (It.)
name. This is where huge caves have opened up, accommo-
dating huge and luxurious dwellings. Thence to Formiae is
forty [stades].
233 C, 26-31 Between this city and Sinuessa is Minturnae, which is this city = Formiae, Formia (It.)
about eighty stades from each. Running past it is the Liris Minturnae, nr. Minturno (It.)
river (it was formerly called “Clanis”). From high in the Liris/Clanis, Garigliano r.
[ 1 ] 231 C, 19-23.
[ 2 ] I.e., “first” for a traveler starting from Rome.
[ 3 ] Strabo transliterates into Greek (Kaiatas) the name of the Roman town (Caieta)
that sits on a promontory forming the bay. He applies the name to the bay itself
and gives a torturous etymology. See next note.
[ 4 ] The uninflected form of the word would be kaietai, but Strabo gives the name
in the inflected form kaietas, as required by his sentence structure (cf. 615 C,
8-17) and perhaps to lend support to his etymology. Strabo’s understanding of
the Laconian language may not be perfect, as he later distinguishes between
the various forms of the word: 367 C, 8-14. Cf. the alleged meaning of the name
Sinuessa: 234 C, 4-6.
278
Italy + Islands
233 C, 34–234 C, 4 All t hese are places that produce excellent wine: Cae-
cuban, Fundanian, and Setinian wines are among the best
known, like Falernian, Alban, and Statanian.
234 C, 4-6 Sinuessa is situated in a bay, whence her name: sinus means Sinuessa, Torre S. Limato (It.)
“bay.” Near her, there are hot baths, which are very effective
against a number of medical conditions. |
234 C, 7 The foregoing are the Latin cities on the coast.2 5.3.7
234 C, 7-11 As for t hose in the interior,3 the first city inland from
ROME Ostia—and the only city that is situated on the Tiber—is Ostia, Ostia Antica (It.)
Rome (It.)
Rome. A description has been given of its foundation being a
matter of necessity rather than a m atter of choice.4 It remains
to add that even those who afterward incorporated certain
additional parts w ere not masters of improvement but slaves
to what already existed.
234 C, 11-19 The first men walled in the Capitol, the Palatium, and the
hill of Quirinus = Lat. Collis hill of Quirinus, which was so easily accessible to outsiders
Quirinalis
that Titus Tatius took it at the first assault when he sought
to avenge the outrage of the raped w omen. Ancus Marcius Ancus Marcius ruled Rome,
7th c. BCE
Caelian mount = Lat. Mons incorporated the Caelian and Aventine mounts (and the plain
Caelius
between them), which were separate from each other and
Aventine mount = Lat. Mons
Aventinus
from the hills that previously had been walled in. He added
them out of necessity—it was not a good idea to leave such
naturally defensive hills outside the walls as fortifications for
anyone who wanted them—but he was not strong enough
to expand the w hole circuit of the wall as far as the hill of
Quirinus.
234 C, 19-25 Servius put right the shortcoming: he completed the Servius Tullius ruled Rome,
6th c. BCE
Esquiline hill = Lat. Collis expansion with the addition of the Esquiline hill and the
Esquiliae
Viminal hill. These parts, too, were easy for outsiders to at-
tack. Therefore, digging a deep trench, they accumulated the
Viminal hill = Lat. Collis Viminalis earth on the inner side; extended an approximately six-stade
279
3.1. Western Europe
the Latin city by the Marsians, and across the plain beneath
it, to its juncture with the Tiber; then, the Nar and the Tinia Nar, Nera r.
rivers, which flow down through Umbria to the same Tiber; Tinia, Topino r.
Clusina = territory of Clusium,
Chiusi (It.) and the Clanis, which flows through Tyrrhenia and Clusina. Clanis, Chiani r.
280
Italy + Islands
235 C, 19-32 The foregoing are the advantages that the territory’s 5.3.8
physical nature gives to the city 1—but the Romans added the
advantage of intelligent design. The Greeks are considered
to have been exceptionally successful in founding cities, in
that they aimed for aesthetics and defensibility, harbors and
productive territory. The Romans, however, gave thought to
that to which the Greeks paid scant regard: road construction,
the water supply, and underground conduits capable of wash-
ing the city’s filth into the Tiber. (They constructed roads
through their territory, too, cutting through hills and making
embankments in valleys, so that their wagons can carry whole
boatloads of cargo.) As for the conduits, with their vaulted
roofs of close-fitting stone, some leave enough headroom
for the passage of hay wagons! So much water is brought in
ater channels = Lat.
w through the water channels that rivers run through the city
aquaeductus
and conduits, and just about e very h ousehold has cisterns
and water pipes and copious fountains. Marcus Agrippa paid
particular attention to these, as well as donating many other
structures for the city’s beautification.
235 C, 33–236 C, 13 In a word, the ancients paid l ittle heed to Rome’s aesthet-
ics, being occupied with larger and more pressing matters.
However, t hose who came l ater—in particular, the men of
today and of our times—did not fall short in this respect but
filled the city with the many fine structures they donated.
Pompey, the deified Caesar, Augustus and his sons, friends,
wife, and sister have outdone themselves in the trouble
taken and expense incurred with respect to buildings. Most
of these buildings are in the Campus Martius, whose natural
qualities are enhanced by intelligence of design. The campus
is incredibly large—which allows for equestrian events, par-
ticularly chariot racing, to be held at the same time as, and
unhindered by, the host of p eople practicing ball throwing,
hoops, and wrestling. The surrounding statuary, the ground
covered all year round with grass, the garland of hills loom-
ing above the river and sloping right up to it, which present
a sight as of a stage set2—these provide a spectacle that is
quite entrancing.
236 C, 13-22 For t hese reasons, the site was considered to be most sa-
cred, and this was where memorials were built to commemo-
rate the most famous men and w omen. The most significant
281
3.1. Western Europe
temples, and if one sees the Capitol and the artworks there
Livia’s colonnade = Lat. porticus and on the Palatium and in Livia’s colonnade, then one would
Liviae
forget utterly everything e lse.2
236 C, 29 So much for Rome.3 |
236 C, 29–237 C, 4 As for the other Latin cities, one might locate some by 5.3.9
to Algidus (a small town) and Pictae Inns; then it is joined by mount Albanum, Monte Cavo
(It.)
Labican [road] = Lat. Via the Labican, which starts from the Esquiline gate, where the
Labicana Algidus, Colle della Mola (It.)
Praenestine also starts but leaves the latter and the Esquiline
Praenestine [road] = Lat. Via Pictae Inns, Le Macere (It.)
Praenestina
plain to the left and goes on for more than one hundred and
twenty stades, drawing near Labicum—an ancient ruined city Labicum, Colonna (It.)
[ 1 ] Strabo writes (or dictates or delivers) these words a fter the death (14 CE) of they had been brought to Rome: e.g., 200 C, 18-28n (Brettanica); 278 C, 7-18n
the emperor Augustus. If Strabo saw the Mausoleum after the interment of (Taras); 319 C, 3-10n (Apollonia); 556 C, 25–557 C, 2n (Caenum Chorium); 636 C,
Augustus’s remains, as well as the “enclosure where he was cremated,” then 33–637 C, 12n (Samos); 657 C, 15–658 C, 4n (Cos).
Strabo was present in Rome as an older man. [ 3 ] Rome: 234 C, 7–236 C, 28.
[ 2 ] The Capitol is where the treasures of the Roman empire w ere stored. Strabo [ 4 ] Appian road and surroundings: 239 C, 21–240 C, 7. Latin road and surroundings:
probably saw these treasures in person: 273 C, 2-14n. Nevertheless, he does not 237 C, 4–238 C, 12. Valerian road and surroundings: 238 C, 13–239 C, 20.
list them h
ere. Rather, he mentions them in describing the areas from which [ 5 ] I.e., for a traveler heading away from Rome.
282
Italy + Islands
237 C, 13-18 Then, continuing on the Latin road itself, there are note-
worthy settlements and cities: Ferentinum, Frusino (past Ferentinum, Ferentino (It.)
Trerus, Sacco r.
which the Cosa river flows), Fabrateria (past which the Tre- Frusino, Frosinone (It.)
Melpis, Melfa r.
rus flows), Aquinum (a large city, past which a large river, the Fabrateria, Ceccano/Falvaterra
Interamnium, Pignataro (It.)
Interamna (It.) Melpis, flows), Interamnium (situated at the confluence of
Aquinum, Aquino (It.)
Liris, Garigliano r. two rivers—Liris and another), and Casinum.
237 C, 18-22 The latter is a significant city and the last of the Latin cit- latter = Casinum, Cassino (It.)
ies, since the city that comes next, called “Sidicinian” Tea- Sidicinian Teanum, Teano (It.)
side are the cities between it and the Appian: Setia and Sig- Setia, Sezze (It.)
nia (both wine producers—the former produces a high-class Signia, Segni (It.)
is, furthermore, Fregellae (past which the Liris flows, reach- Cora, Cori (It.)
ing the sea at Minturnae), now a village but once a significant Velitrae, Velletri (It.)
city, having previously taken control of many of those cities Aletrium, Alatri (It.)
just mentioned as dependencies, whose citizens even now Fregellae, nr. Ceprano (It.)
congregate there to hold markets and perform sacred ritu- Liris, Garigliano r.
als. She rebelled and was razed by the Romans. Very many of Minturnae, nr. Minturno (It.)
these cities, as well as the cities on the Latin [road] and the cities
beyond it, are situated in Hernician, Aequan, and Volscian
territory; they w ere founded by the Romans.
237 C, 33–238 C, 12 On the left-hand side of the Latin [road] are the cities be-
tween it and the Valerian [road]: Gabii, situated on the Prae- Gabii, Castiglione (It.)
about which I s hall speak in just a moment;1 then t here are the
cities in the mountains above Praeneste—the small Hernician Anagnia, Anagni (It.)
town of Capitulum, the significant city of Anagnia, Cerea- Cereatae, Abbazia di Casamari
Liris, Garigliano r. tae, and Sora (past which the Liris flows on its way down to (It.)
Fregellae and Minturnae); then various others including Ve- Sora, Sora (It.)
nafrum, the source of the finest olive oil—this city has a lofty Venafrum, Venafro (It.)
[ 1 ] 238 C, 26–239 C, 9.
283
3.1. Western Europe
Volturnus, Volturno r. location, and flowing past the base of the hill is the Volturnus,
which also goes past Casilinum and reaches the sea at the city
homonymous with it; finally, Aesernia and Allifae are Sam- Aesernia, Isernia (It.)
nite cities, the former destroyed during the Marsian war, the Allifae, S. Angelo d’Alife (It.)
latter still in existence. |
238 C, 13-15 The Valerian takes its start from Tibur, and then heads 5.3.11
Valerian [road] = Lat. Via Valeria toward the Marsians and Corfinium, the Paelignian metropo- Varia, Vicovaro (It.)
lis. Located along it are the Latin cities of Varia, Carseoli, and Carseoli, nr. Carsoli (It.)
Alba; nearby is the city of Cuculum. Tibur, Tivoli (It.)
238 C, 16-26 Tibur, Praeneste, and Tusculum are within sight of people Alba, Albe (It.)
in Rome.1 Tibur is the location of the temple to Heracles and Praeneste, Palastrina (It.)
the waterfall that the Anio forms as it cascades down from on Tusculum, Tuscolo (It.)
high into a deep, wooded gorge next to the city herself. From Anio, Aniene r.
that point on, the Anio is navigable and flows out across a
very fertile plain, past the quarries of Tiburtine stone and of
the stone in Gabii (also called “Red Stone”), with the con-
sequence that transport and shipping from t hese mines are
very easy. Most of the building projects in Rome are supplied
Albula [waters] = Lat. Aquae from here. On this plain flow forth, from many springs, the
Albulae
cold waters called “Albula,” which, if you drink them or sit in Albula waters, Acque Albule
(It.)
Labana [waters] = Lat. Aquae them, cure a variety of afflictions. Such, too, are the Labana,
Labanae
not far from them on the Nomentanian road in the Eretum Eretum, nr. Casacotta (It.)
Nomentanian road = Lat. Via
Nomentana region.
238 C, 26–239 C, 4 Praeneste is the location of the t emple to Tyche, well Praeneste, Palastrina (It.)
Tyche = Lat. Fortuna known for its oracles. Both cities happen to be situated in the Both cities = Praeneste + Tibur
(Tivoli, It.)
oracles, divine prophecies same mountainous area. They are some one hundred stades
apart from each other. From Rome, Praeneste is double that
distance, but Tibur is less distant. Both cities are said to be
Greek: Praeneste’s former name is “Polystephanus.” Both cit-
ies occupy good defensive sites, but Praeneste’s site is by far
the better one. She has, as her citadel, a mountain that rises
high above the city and on the far side has a land bridge from
the adjoining ridge—the mountain rises vertically above this
bridge by as much as two stades. In addition to her natural
defenses, underground passages have everywhere been bored
as far as the plains: some are used for the water supply, others
as secret escape routes (in one of which Marius was besieged
and died).
239 C, 4-9 In the case of other cities, being a natural stronghold is
considered for the most part an advantage. For the Praenes-
284
Italy + Islands
(leaving in the intervening space a valley in which Algidus Algidus, Colle della Mola (It.)
sits), which is lofty and rises up toward mount Albanum. mount Albanum, Monte Cavo
(It.)
The ridge is the location of Tusculum, a city that has been
Tusculum, Tuscolo (It.)
developed not at all badly. She is adorned with surrounding
plantations and buildings, especially those beneath her on the
side toward Rome: this is where Tusculanum is, a hill with
good soil and good w ater, which gently rises to a number of
summits and accommodates the most spectacularly palatial
buildings. Next to the hill are the areas at the foot of mount
Albanum, with the same excellent qualities and the same level
of development. Next are the plains, some of them reaching
toward Rome and her suburbs, some t oward the coast. The
plains in the direction of the sea are less healthful, but the
others are attractive to look at and similarly adorned.
239 C, 21–240 C, 3 The city of Aricia is on the Appian road after Albanum: Aricia, Ariccia (It.)
Appian road = Lat. Via Appia the distance from Rome is one hundred and sixty stades. The
site is in a recess but nevertheless has a steep-sided citadel.
Situated above Aricia on the right-hand side of the Appian
road is Lanuvium, a Roman city from which both the sea and Lanuvium, Lanuvio (It.)
Antium are within sight.1 The Artemisium (temple to Artemis), Antium, Anzio (It.)
which they call “Nemus” (Sacred grove),2 on the left-hand side Artemisium, nr. Nemi (It.)
285
3.1. Western Europe
named a fter a certain divinity. The outlets are not visible here
but are identified a long way away where they rise to the sur-
face. |
240 C, 4-7 Also near t hese places is mount Albanum, which is much Albanum, Monte Cavo (It.) 5.3.13
mount Albanum = Lat. Mons higher than the Artemisium and much higher than the ridges
Albanus
(very high and quite vertical) that surround it. This, too, has
a lake, which is much bigger than the lake at the Artemisium. lake, Albano l. (It.)
240 C, 8-9 Beyond these places are the Latin cities already mentioned.1
240 C, 9-19 The farthest inland of the Latin cities is Alba, which bor- Alba, Albe (It.)
showed their founders where to go. This is the reason for their Picentina = land of the
Picentinians
name: their name for this bird is picus, and they believe that it
[ 1 ] 233 C, 8–234 C, 7, where Strabo deals with Tarracina, Formiae, Minturna(e), and
Sinuessa—all on the Appian road—as part of his description of the Latin coast.
[ 2 ] Nations between Alps and Apennines: 210 C, 31–218 C, 24.
[ 3 ] Territory between Tyrrhenian sea and Apennines: 218 C, 25–240 C, 21.
286
Italy + Islands
cusans who were fleeing from Dionysius’s tyranny. She sits Dionysius ruled Sicily, 405–367
BCE
upon a headland embracing a large harbor within a north-
ward curve: it produces excellent wine and purple dye. Near
Septempeda, S. Severino her is the city Auxumum, a little inland from the sea; then Auxumum, Osimo (It.)
Marche (It.)
Septempeda, . . . *, Potentia, and Firmum Picenum (whose
Potentia, Porto Recanati (It.)
seaport is Castellum). Next in succession is the temple to
Firmum Picenum, Fermo (It.)
Cupra, founded and established by the Tyrrhenians. (“Cupra” Cupra, Cupra Marittima (It.)
Castellum, S. Maria a Mare (It.)
is their name for Hera.) Then there’s the Truentinus river, Truentinus (river), Tronto r.
and the city named after it; then Castrum Novum (New castle)1 city named a
fter it = [Castrum]
Truentinum, Martinsicuro (It.)
Matrinus river, ?Piomba r. and the Matrinus river, which flows from the Adrianian city
Adrianian city = Adria, Atri (It.) and has Adria’s seaport named a fter it. In the interior, there’s Castrum Novum, Giulianova (It.)
this city, and Asculum Picenum, a defensive site and . . . * on Adria’s seaport = Matrinum,
?nr. mouth of Piomba r.
which the wall is situated—and the surrounding mountains
Asculum Picenum, Ascoli Piceno
are inaccessible to armies. (It.)
241 C, 15-27 Above Picentina, inhabiting the mountain country, are
the Vestinians, Marsians, Paelignians, Marrucinians, and
Frentanians (a Samnite nation), reaching as far as the coast
in only a few places. T hese nations are small but extremely
courageous, and they have often displayed this virtuous trait
to the Romans—first when fighting against them, secondly
when fighting alongside them, and thirdly when, wanting
freedom and citizenship and getting neither, they rebelled
against them and kindled what is called the “Marsian war.” Marsian war, 91–89 BCE
They appointed Corfinium, the Paelignian metropolis, as the Corfinium/Italica, Corfinio (It.)
[ 1 ] Strabo transliterates into Greek the Latin place-name Castrum Novum, writing
or dictating Kastroum Noououm, which gets garbled in the medieval manu-
scripts (not surprisingly, as the outlandishness of the transliteration is perhaps
the point); cf. 213 C, 5-16n. Similar examples of Strabo’s transliteration of Latin
names: 508 C, 10-18n.
287
3.1. Western Europe
241 C, 27–242 C, 3 In general, they are village dwellers, but they also have
Sulmo, Sulmona (It.) cities. Inland from the seacoast, there’s Corfinium, Sulmo, Corfinium, Corfinio (It.)
Marruvium, S. Benedetto (It.) Marruvium, and Teate (the Marrucinian metropolis). On the
Teate, Chieti (It.) coast itself, t here’s Aternum, on the border with Picentina, Aternum, Pescara (It.)
with the same name as the river that divides Vestina and Mar- Aternus (river), Pescara r.
Buca, which belongs to the Frentanians and borders on Buca, ?Termoli (It.)
Apulian Teanum. Among the Frentanians is Ortonium, Apulian Teanum, nr. S. Paolo di
Civitate (It.)
cliffs belonging to pirates, whose dwellings are constructed
from shipwrecks and who are savage in other respects, too.
Between Orton and Aternum is the Sagrus river, dividing the Sagrus, Sangro r.
242 C, 15-21 I should describe Campania first. From Sinuessa, along Sinuessa, Torre S. Limato (It.)
(they call it “Crater”), which is much larger than the first, Crater, Golfo di Napoli
[ 1 ] Strabo later refines the equation of Latin Apuli with Greek “Daunians”: 277 C,
26-33n.
[ 2 ] Latina (w. Italy): 228 C, 34–240 C, 21.
[ 3 ] Campania (sw. Italy): 242 C, 15–249 C, 16; 250 C, 30–251 C, 6. Samnitis (sw. Italy
hinterland): 249 C, 17–250 C, 29.
[ 4 ] Daunians (e. Italy): 283 C, 17–285 C, 34. Other nations as far as Sicilian strait: 251 C,
7–265 C, 26.
288
Italy + Islands
the same way that they had been forced out of the territory
around the Padus, so they yielded this territory to the Sam- Padus, Po r.
Volturnus (river), Volturno r. as the city. Likewise, the Volturnus bears the same name as the
Volturnum (city), Volturno (It.) city beside it, the city that comes next in sequence; this river
flows past Venafrum and through the middle of Campania. Venafrum, Venafro (It.)
243 C, 12-17 Next after these is Cumae, the oldest city founded by the Cumae, Cuma (It.)
Chalcidians and the Cumaeans, since she is the oldest of all Chalcidians and Cumaeans
came from Euboea (Gk. island),
the Sicilian and Italiote cities. The leaders of the expedition— 8th c. BCE
Hippocles the Cumaean and Megasthenes the Chalcidian—
agreed among themselves that colonization should be the
responsibility of one group, while choice of name should be
the responsibility of the other group, which is why the city is
now called “Cumae” even though it appears that the Chalcid-
ians founded her.
243 C, 17-25 In early days, then, the city prospered (as did what was Phlegraean plain, Campi Flegrei
Phlegraean plain = Lat. Campi known as the “Phlegraean plain,” which people say is the (It.)
Phlegraei
[ 1 ] The Latin word for head is caput; cf. 248 C, 31–249 C, 11n.
289
3.1. Western Europe
[ 1 ] Underworld Rites is the “title” given to the part of Homer’s Odyssey in which
Odysseus converses with the dead. Strabo often uses “titles” for parts of Hom-
er’s poems (4 C, 14-20n), as well as for parts of his own work (639 C, 15-27n).
290
Italy + Islands
244 C, 23–245 C, 3 Ephorus associates the site with the Cimmerians. He says
Ephorus (4th c. BCE) that they live in underground h ouses, which are called “argillae,” visit
each other by means of excavated passages, and conduct outsiders to
the oracle located far belowground; they earn a living from mining,
from the oracle, and from the allowance paid to them by the king; it
is an ancestral custom for t hose associated with the oracle that none
should see the sun, but they venture out of the caverns at night; that is
poet = Homer (8th c. BCE) the reason the poet says of them, “the shining sun never looks / upon
them”; they were destroyed by a certain king when the divination given
to him did not turn out well; the oracle is still in existence but has been
relocated to a different site.
245 C, 4-9 The foregoing w ere the myths told by men before our
times.2 Now that the woodlands around Aornus have been Roman statesman Agrippa
oversaw engineering works at
cleared by Agrippa, housing has been built t here, and an Aornus, 37 BCE
underground tunnel has been cut from Aornus to Cumae, Aornus, Lago Averno (It.)
these stories have all been shown to be myth. (Cocceius, who Cumae, Cuma (It.)
built that tunnel, did so somewhat in conformity with the
story just related about the Cimmerians, and perhaps be-
lieved that it was traditional for roads in this location to be
housed in tunnels.) |
245 C, 10-18 Lucrinus bay widens out as far as Baiae, protected from Lucrinus bay, Lago Lucrino (It.) 5.4.6
[ 1 ] For Strabo’s interest in plutonia (sanctuaries dedicated to the god of the un-
derworld), his presence at one such plutonium in the Asian peninsula, and his
observation of the effect of the vapors on birds: 629 C, 22–630 C, 9n; 578 C,
31–579 C, 9n.
[ 2 ] 244 C, 7–245 C, 3.
291
3.1. Western Europe
245 C, 19-26 What comes next is the Dicaearchian coastline and the
city herself. In former times, she was the Cumaean seaport, city herself = Dicaearchia/
Puteoli, Pozzuoli (It.)
located on a ridge. At the time of Hannibal’s expedition,
however, the Romans incorporated her and named her
“Puteoli” (Little wells) after her wells—or, according to others,
after the stench of her w aters,1 since the w hole area as far
as Baiae and Cumaea is full of sulfur, fire, and hot springs. Cumaea = land around Cumae,
Cuma (It.)
Some people think that this is the reason Cumaea is called
“Phlegra” (Burning), and that the fallen g iants’ wounds, in-
flicted by thunderbolts, are what give rise to such streams
of fire and water.
245 C, 26-31 The city has become a very great trading center, with arti- city = Dicaearchia/Puteoli,
Pozzuoli (It.)
ficial docks that are the result of the type of sand found t here.
The sand, with a proportional element of lime, has strong
adhesive and solidifying qualities, so that people mix small
stones into this cement and use it to construct moles jutting
out into the sea, making what was open shoreline into bays,
with the consequence that even the biggest freight ships can
safely anchor t here.2
246 C, 1-3 Immediately above the city is the “Marketplace of Hep- Marketplace of Hephaestus,
Solfatara (It.)
Marketplace of haestus,” a plain hemmed around with volcanic cliffs, which in
Hephaestus = Lat. Forum
Vulcani many places blast out gusts of air as hot as a furnace and quite
noisy. The plain is full of sulfur drifts. |
246 C, 4-15 After Dicaearchia comes Neapolis . . . * of the Cumaeans. Neapolis, Napoli/Naples (It.) 5.4.7
292
Italy + Islands
banks of the Sarnus river, were held by the Oscans, then by Sarnus, Sarno r.
name as the settlement near Cremon) . . . * the Sarnus river, Acerrae, Acerra (It.)
247 C, 6-17 Inland from t hese sites is mount Vesuvius, with fine fields Vesuvius, Monte Vesuvio (It.)
all around except for at its peak. The peak consists largely of
a plain and is entirely unproductive. It is ashy to look at, and
features cavern-like indentations in rock faces that are soot-
colored, as if they have been consumed by fire. One would
consequently infer that the place was formerly on fire with
volcanic craters but that the flames died down when the fuel
ran out. Perhaps, too, this is the cause of the surrounding
fertility, just as they say that part of the ash thrown up by the
Etnaean volcano was deposited in Catana and made the soil Catana, Catania (Sic.)
293
3.1. Western Europe
when its moisture is removed and its flames quenched and ash
formed, it changes into productive soil.
247 C, 18-23 After Pompaea comes Campanian Surrentum, whence Surrentum, Sorrento (It.)
Athenaeum = Lat. Athenaeum juts out, called by some “Promontory of Athenaeum/Promontory
Promunturium Minervae of Sirenussae, Punta della
Sirenussae.”1 On the headland is a t emple to Athena founded Campanella (It.)
by Odysseus. (It is a short crossing from here to the island
of Capreae; and as you round the headland, t here are some Capreae, Capri (It. island)
deserted and rocky l ittle islands, called the “Sirens.”) On the Sirens, Li Galli (It. islands)
broken off from Pithecussae. Pithecussae was colonized by Ere- Pithecussae, Ischia (It. island)
Timaeus (late 4th–early 3rd c. wonders were related by the ancients, and just a l ittle before his own
BCE) Epomeus hill, Monte Epomeo
time, Epomeus hill, in the m iddle of the island, was shaken by an (It.)
294
Italy + Islands
earthquake, spewed out fire, and thrust the entire area between it and
the coast into the sea; the part of the ground that was turned to ash rose
into the air, then swirled around and down again onto the island; the
sea receded for three stades and, having receded, after no g reat time
turned back on itself and swamped the island, and the volcanic fire
there was quenched; b ecause of the sound, t hose on the mainland fled
from the shore into Campania.
248 C, 25-26 The hot springs there apparently cure those suffering with
gallstones.
248 C, 26-29 Capreae had two towns in antiquity but subsequently only Capreae, Capri (It. island)
which lead from her to Brundisium (Calatia, Caudium, and Calatia, S. Giacomo delle
Galazze (It.)
Beneventum). Casilinum lies in the direction of Rome, on
Caudium, nr. Montesarchio (It.)
Volturnus, Volturno r. the Volturnus river. This is the city where five hundred and
Beneventum, Benevento (It.)
forty Praenestinians, besieged by Hannibal when he was at his
Casilinum, Capua (It.)
strongest, held out for so long that when, b ecause of hunger,
1 mna = 100 drachmas a mouse was sold for two mnae, the vendor ended up dying
while the purchaser survived. Hannibal, when he saw the
people sowing turnips near the city wall, marveled—so it ap-
pears—at their confidence, that they expected to resist him
for long enough that the turnips would ripen! P eople say that
they all survived except for t hose few who died from hunger
or in b
attle. |
249 C, 12-16 In addition to the cities just mentioned,4 the following 5.4.11
settlements that are even less significant than t hese, some of Abella, Avella (It.)
295
3.1. Western Europe
people w ere virtually the only ones holding out and that . . . *
so as to proceed against Rome herself, he engaged with them
in front of the city walls. He cut down some of them in the
battle, ordering that none be taken alive; t hose who put down
their weapons (around three or four thousand men, so people
say), these people he took to the public encampment in the
Campus and held them there, then three days later he sent in
soldiers and killed them all. He did not cease his proscriptions
until he had killed, or expelled from Italy, all the important
Samnites. To those who questioned his excessive rage, he said
that he had learned from experience that not one Roman would live
in peace while the Samnites remained independent.
249 C, 32–250 C, 4 This is why nowadays the cities have become villages, some
of them being totally eclipsed: Bovianum, Aesernia, Panna, Bovianum, ?Boiano (It.)
Telesia (next to Venafrum), and o thers of a similar kind, not Aesernia, Isernia (It.)
one of which deserves to be called a city. I will give a descrip- Telesia, S. Salvatore Telesino (It.)
tion as far as is reasonable, because of the fame and power Venafrum, Venafro (It.)
Beneventum, Benevento (It.) of Italy. (Beneventum has nevertheless stood up well, as also
Venusia, Venosa (It.) Venusia.) |
250 C, 5-16 Some such account as the following is told about the Sam- 5.4.12
[ 1 ] In Greek, the word for “born” is the same as the word for “produced.”
296
Italy + Islands
CAMPANIA good and bad in equal m easure from the fertility of their ter-
sw. Italy
ritory. They became so indolent that they invited people to
dinners that w ere accompanied by gladiatorial duels, deciding
on the number according to the status of the dinners. Giving
Hannibal’s army its winter quarters—after Hannibal took
them without resistance—they so completely feminized the
army that Hannibal said, though victorious, he risked succumbing
to the e nemy since the soldiers he got back were women rather than
men! The Romans, when they w ere victorious, brought them
to their senses with many evil deeds and ultimately allotted
their land to colonists. Now that they are of one mind with the
colonists, they are d oing well; and they preserve their ancient
renown, both by means of the city’s size and b ecause of its city = Capua, S. Maria Capua
Vetere (It.)
flourishing population.
297
3.1. Western Europe
via Nuceria is an isthmus of no more than one hundred and Nuceria, Nocera (It.)
twenty stades.
251 C, 17-20 The Picentians stretch as far as the Silaris river, which di- Silaris, Sele r.
distance inland from the coast—against them, as a watch post. Sirenussae (promontory), Punta
251 C, 25-16 It is two hundred and sixty stades from Sirenussae to the della Campanella (It.)
252 C, 1-7 After the mouth of the Silaris comes Leucania and the 6.1.1
LEUCANIA temple to “Argonian” Hera founded by Jason and, nearby (at t emple to Argonian Hera, Foce
s. Italy del Sele (It.)
a distance of fifty stades), Posidonia. Sailing from there . . . *
Posidonia, Paestum (It.)
the island of Leucosia, with its short passage across to the
Leucosia, Licosa (It. island)
mainland. The island is named a fter one of the Sirens, who
was washed ashore h ere after the mythical Casting of the Sirens
into the Deep. Lying in front of the island is the promontory promontory, Punta Licosa
that, being opposite Sirenussae, forms the Posidonian bay. Sirenussae, Punta della
Campanella (It.)
252 C, 7-14 As you round the promontory, t here’s another contiguous
bay, in which there’s a city, called by her Phocaean founders
Hyela/Ela/Elea, Castellamare di
“Hyela” (“Ela,” according to some), after a certain spring. Velia (It.)
Men of today call her “Elea.”2 Parmenides and Zeno, the fol- Parmenides, Zeno, 5th c. BCE
298
Italy + Islands
Pyxus, there’s another bay, and “Laus” (river and city). The Laus (river), Lao r.
last of the Leucanian cities, she is set back a little from the Laus (city), Marcellina (It.)
Sybarites = inhabitants of sea, was founded by the Sybarites, and is four hundred stades
Sybaris, Sibari/Copia (It.)
distant from Ela.
253 C, 6-7 The total length of the voyage along the Leucanian coast
is six hundred and fifty stades.
253 C, 7-11 Nearby is the t emple to the hero Draco, one of Odys-
seus’s companions, concerning which an oracle was given to Italiotes, Greek inhabitants of
s. Italy
In Greek, the words “great laus” the Italiotes, stating that around Laïan Draco, great Laus will
could also mean “many people”
be destroyed. The Greeks living in Italy, misled by this oracle, oracle, divine prophecy
other side. Rather, the Greeks who held the Tarantinian bay Tarantinian bay, Gulf of Taranto
299
3.1. Western Europe
For t hese reasons, the Greeks and the natives w ere long at war
with each other.
253 C, 19-22 The rulers of Sicily, and l ater the Carthaginians, who w ere
at war with the Romans (sometimes over Sicily, sometimes
over Italy itself ), made things bad for everyone in the region
but especially the Greeks.
253 C, 22-25 . . . * starting from Trojan times, they acquired much of Trojan times, late 2nd–early
1st millennium BCE
the interior as well. They flourished to such an extent that
They = Greeks
people called this territory, and also Sicily, “Great Greece.”
253 C, 25-30 Nowadays it so happens that all parts (other than Taras, Taras, Taranto (It.)
Regium, and Neapolis) have been nativized, some parts held Regium, Reggio di Calabria (It.)
253 C, 33–254 C, 6 They and the Brettians, and the Samnites themselves They = Leucanians of the
interior
(their progenitors), have been so completely devastated that
it is difficult to define their settlements. The reason is, no joint
federation any longer exists for any of these nations; their
traditional languages, weaponry, dress, and suchlike, have
fallen into abeyance; and besides, the individual settlements
are in all respects unremarkable. | I w ill tell in a combined way 6.1.3
300
Italy + Islands
referring to Philoctetes in his About the Ships,1 states that some Crotoniatis = region of Croton,
Crotone (It.)
people say that, when he came to Crotoniatis, he settled the Crimissa
Crimissa headland, Punta Alice
headland and the city of Chona inland from it (the city from which
Aegesta, Segesta (Sic.)
the people in the region got called “Chonians”); and some of his people,
who had gone to Sicily, together with Aegestes the Trojan, fortified
Aegesta, near Eryx.
254 C, 14-18 Both Grumentum and Vertinae are in the interior, as also Grumentum, Grumento Nova
(It.)
Calasarna and other small settlements as far as Venusia, a no-
Venusia, Venosa (It.)
table city. I think that this city, and the cities that come after
her (as you head toward Campania), are Samnitic cities. The
territory called “Tauriana” is located inland from Thurii. Thurii, Sibari/Copia (It.)
254 C, 19-22 The Leucanians are Samnite by descent, but when they
were victorious against the Posidonians and their allies, they
took possession of their cities. Although they had a demo
cratic constitution the rest of the time, in wars a king was
selected by the officers of state. Nowadays, they are Roman. |
254 C, 23-24 The following stretch of coast, running for one thousand 6.1.4
BRETTIA three hundred and fifty stades as far as the Sicilian strait, is Sicilian strait, Straits of Messina
s. Italy
held by the Brettians.
254 C, 24-30 In his work About Italy, Antiochus 2 says that this is called
Antiochus (5th c. BCE) “Italy,” and Italy is his subject matter, and it was previously called
“Oenotria.” He states that the boundary on the side of the Tyr-
rhenian sea is the same as the boundary I gave for Leucania,3
Laus, Lao r.
namely the Laus river; and the boundary on the side of the Sicilian
Tarantina = region of Taras,
sea is Metapontium. He calls Tarantina, next to Metapontium, Taranto (It.)
outside Italy, and gives it the name “Iapygae.” Metapontium, Metaponto (It.)
254 C, 30–255 C, 7 In a further passage, he said that only t hose on this side of the he = Antiochus
isthmus—in the direction of the Sicilian strait—were called Sicilian strait, Straits of Messina
301
3.1. Western Europe
and the coastline of the Sicilian sea—the stretch from the Silaris Silaris, Sele r.
to the Laus in the case of the former coastline, from Metapon- Laus, Lao r.
tium to Thurii in the case of the latter coastline; and, in the inte- Metapontium, Metaponto (It.)
rior, from the Samnites to the isthmus between Thurii and Cer- Thurii, Sibari/Copia (It.)
illi (near Laus). The isthmus measures three hundred stades. Cerilli, Cirella (It.)
255 C, 13-18 The Brettians on the other hand, are beyond the Leuca-
nians. They inhabit the peninsula. (Within this peninsula is
another peninsula, with its isthmus between the Scylettian Scylletian bay, Gulf of Squillace
and Hipponian bays.) The nation was given its name by the Hipponian bay, Gulf of S.
Eufemia
Leucanians, who call defectors brettii. These p eople, so it is
said, did indeed defect: they were formerly herders for the
Leucanians but gained freedom through lack of oversight
at the time when Dio sent an army against Dionysius, and
stirred everyone up against everyone e lse.
255 C, 19 The foregoing is my general description of the Leucanians
and the Brettians1 . . . * |
255 C, 20–256 C, 2 . . . * starting from Laus, the first Brettian city is Temesa, Temesa/Tempsa, Nocera 6.1.5
Tirinese/Piano della Tirena (It.)
which men of today call “Tempsa.”2 It was founded by the
Ausonians and later also by the Aetolians (under Thoas’s
leadership). The latter were ejected by the Brettians, who
were then wiped out by Hannibal and the Romans. Near
Temesa is a temple, grown over with wild olive trees, sacred
to the hero Polites, one of Odysseus’s companions, who, it
is said, was so deeply vengeful a fter his murder by the na-
tives that the locals had to pay tribute in accordance with an
oracular pronouncement; and there’s a proverb in relation
to . . . *, people saying that the hero in Temesa bears down on
them. There is a mythical story that, when the Epizephyr-
ian Locrians captured the city, Euthymus the boxer fought
with him, vanquished him in the fight, and absolved the him = hero in Temesa
poet = Homer (8th c. BCE) locals from paying tribute. People say that the poet means
this Temesa, and not Tamassus in Cyprus: for in quest of cop- Tamassus, SE Politiko (Cyp.)
from the latter is the hill fort of Pandosia, near which Alex-
ander the Molossian was killed. He, too, was tricked by the oracle, instruction from the
oracle given out from Dodona, bidding him beware of Acheron gods
302
Italy + Islands
to bend westward. Along this stretch of coast is Medma, a Medma, Rosarno (It.)
the same name. Lying off this shore, two hundred stades from Metaurum (anchorage), Gioia
Tauro (It.)
the Strait, are the Liparaean islands (called by some the “is-
Liparaean islands/islands of
lands of Aeolus,” which are mentioned in the Odyssey by the Aeolus, Isole Eolie (It. islands)
poet = Homer (8th c. BCE) poet). They are seven in number, all of them within sight to
people looking from Sicily as well as to people looking from
the Medma area of the mainland. I will describe them when
I describe Sicily.1
256 C, 31–257 C, 8 From the Metaurus river . . . * another. Following on
from there comes Scyllaeum, a lofty cliff forming a penin- Scyllaeum, Rocca di Scilla (It.)
headland projecting from Sicily, forms the narrow channel of Pelorias, Capo Peloro (Sic.)
303
3.1. Western Europe
were tithed1 to Apollo in accordance with an oracle when their oracle, instruction from Apollo
at Delphi (Gr.)
crops failed, and who subsequently came h ere from Delphi to
form a colony, along with others from their homeland. (As
Antiochus (5th c. BCE) Antiochus tells it, the Zanclaeans sent for the Chalcidians and
made Antimnestus the colony leader.) Also sharing in the
colonization w ere exiles from Peloponnesian Messene, who
were ousted by the faction that did not want to pay repara-
tion to the Lacedaemonians for the violation of the young
women in Limnae2 (they not only raped the women, who
had been sent there to perform a religious ritual, but killed
the people who came to their aid). Retreating to Macistum,
they send a delegation to the oracle, reproaching Apollo and oracle, center for divine
prophecy/advice from Apollo at
Artemis for their troubles (when they had only been acting Delphi (Gr.)
on the god’s behalf ) and demanding to know how they might
be rescued from total ruin. Apollo bade them join the Chal-
cidians in their expedition to Regium and be grateful to his
sister: they had been not ruined but rather saved, in that they
would escape being destroyed along with their fatherland
(which would go on to be captured, only a short time l ater,
by the Spartiates). They obeyed. That is why the Reginian
leaders down to Anaxilas w ere always appointed from Mes-
senian stock.
257 C, 28-31 Antiochus says that, in antiquity, this entire site was inhabited
Antiochus (5th c. BCE) by Sicilians and Morgetans; they crossed over to Sicily later, when
they were driven out by the Oenotrians. Some p eople say that this Morgantium, ?Serra Orlando
is how “Morgantium” got its name. (Sic.)
258 C, 1-4 The Reginian city achieved g reat strength and had many Reginian city = Regium, Reggio
di Calabria (It.)
dependent cities round about her. She was a continual bul-
304
Italy + Islands
island = Sicily wark against the island, both in antiquity and recently in our
own times, when Sextus Pompeius caused Sicily to revolt.
258 C, 5-12 “Regium” (Sundered) was so named e ither,1 as Aeschylus Regium, Reggio di Calabria (It.)
Aeschylus (5th c. BCE) tells us, because of the phenomena experienced by this terri-
tory. He and o thers say that Sicily was “sundered” from the
mainland by seismic activity, from which “Regium” gets her name.
Based on the phenomena associated with Etna, and on the
phenomena in other parts of Sicily and in Lipara and on the Lipara, Lipari (It. island)
Pithecussae, Ischia (It. island) the mainland, as are also Capriae, Leucosia, the Sirens, and Leucosia, Licosa (It. island)
258 C, 20-23 Some islands emerged from the sea, as happens in many
places even now. It is credible that islands in the middle of the
sea came up from the deep, while it is more logical to suppose
that islands lying off headlands and separated from them by
narrow straits w ere sundered from the headlands.
258 C, 23-27 Whether the city got her name for these reasons, or city = Regium, Reggio di
Calabria (It.)
whether it was on account of the magnificence of the city (as
if the Samnites named her using the Latin word for “royal
residence,”2 because their forefathers shared their constitu-
tion with the Romans and used the Latin language to a con-
siderable extent)—which of these is true, one can only guess.
258 C, 28–259 C, 4 The story is that the city—herself magnificent, found-
ing many cities and producing many men noted for
their p olitical abilities or their education—was razed by
Dionysius, who gave as his excuse that, when he asked for
a young girl in marriage, the citizens presented him with
305
3.1. Western Europe
a colony from the Locrians on the Crisaean gulf, dispatched Crisaean gulf = n. shore of Gulf
of Corinth
under the command of Euanthes shortly a fter the founding
Ephorus (4th c. BCE) of Croton and Syracuse. (Ephorus is incorrect in calling them Croton, Crotone (It.)
306
Italy + Islands
259 C, 26–260 C, 4 He paid the price when he regained his kingdom and re-
turned to Sicily. The Locrians dismantled the garrison, set
themselves free, and made themselves masters of his wife and
children—two girls and the younger of his two sons, who was
now an adolescent (the other son, Apollocrates, was fighting
alongside his father for their return). Although Dionysius
himself, as well as the Tarantinians on his behalf, repeatedly
asked that these individuals be returned on whatever terms
were desired, the Locrians did not hand them over but with-
stood a siege and the pillaging of their territory. They vented
their rage mostly on the d aughters: they prostituted them,
strangled them, then burned their bodies, ground up their
bones, and threw them into the sea.
260 C, 5-17 In reference to the Locrians’ writing down of their laws
(synthesized by Zaleucus, from Cretan, Laconian, and Areop-
Ephorus (4th c. BCE) agite customs), Ephorus says that Zaleucus’s primary innovation
was this, that whereas his p redecessors had allowed the judiciary to
determine the punishment for individual misdeeds, he included the
punishment within the laws, since he believed that members of the
judiciary would not all have the same opinions about the same mis-
deeds, whereas the punishments should be consistent. Ephorus also
says that his simplification of contract law is commendable; l ater,
when the Thurians aimed for even more precision than the Locrians,
they achieved more repute but less moral standing, given that men are
governed by good laws not when they are protected against e very false
charge but rather when they are consistently subjected to laws that are
Plato (late 5th–4th c. BCE) simply set out. Plato says this, too: where t here are numerous laws
and trials, life is bad, just as it is reasonable to suppose that where
there are many doctors, there are many diseases. |
260 C, 18-34 The Alex river, which divides Regina from Locris, flows Alex, ?Melito r./?Galati r. 6.1.9
307
3.1. Western Europe
Ariston were competing at the Pythians, they squabbled about the Pythians = Pythian games,
including music contests, held
casting of lots. Ariston asked the Delphians to take his side, on the in honor of Apollo, at Delphi
grounds that his forebears were sacred to the god and that the colony (Gr.)
had been dispatched from there. Eunomus countered that they should
not even take part in singing contests: even their cicadas—the most
musical of creatures—were s ilent! Ariston was, nevertheless, the fa-
vorite and was expected to win. In the end, Eunomus was the winner
and dedicated the said statue in his fatherland, b ecause in the contest
one of the strings snapped and a cicada alighted on his cithara and
supplied the missing note.
260 C, 35–261 C, 4 The interior, inland from these cities, is held by the Bret-
tians. There’s a city there, Mamertium, as also a forest that Mamertium, ?Oppido
Mamertina (It.)
produces excellent pitch (“Brettian”). The forest is called
“Sila”: it is dense with trees and well supplied with w ater and
seven hundred stades in length. |
261 C, 5-13 After Locri comes the Sagra (the noun is feminine), on Sagra, ?Allaro r. 6.1.10
Dioscuri = Castor and Pollux whose banks are the Altars of the Dioscuri, near which ten
thousand Locrians, fighting in alliance with the Reginians,
won a victory over one hundred and thirty thousand Crotoni-
ates. It is said that this is the origin of the proverb concern-
ing disbelievers, truer than what happened on the Sagra. (Some
people have added the myth that the outcome was announced
to t hose assembled for the games at Olympia, which began on
the same day, and that the speed at which the news traveled
was found to be validated.) It is said that this catastrophe was
the reason the Crotoniates did not last much longer, so many
men falling in b attle on that day.
261 C, 13-16 After the Sagra is a city founded by Achaeans, Caulonia, Caulonia, Monasterace Marina
(It.)
formerly called “Aulonia” (Ravine) because of the ravine lying
before it. The city is deserted. Its inhabitants were forced
out to Sicily by the natives, and they founded the “Caulonia”
there.
261 C, 16-24 After this city comes Scylletium, colonized by the Athe- Scylletium/Scyllacium,
Roccelletta (It.)
nians u nder the command of Menestheus: she is now called
“Scyllacium.” Although in the possession of the Crotoniates,
she was brought within the boundaries of Locri by Dionysius.
The Scylletian bay—forming the aforementioned isthmus Scylletian bay, Gulf of Squillace
with the Hipponian bay1—takes its name from the city. Dio-
nysius tried to wall off the isthmus when he was campaigning
against the Leucanians. His stated reason was to defend those
[ 1 ] 254 C, 30–255 C, 7.
308
Italy + Islands
within the isthmus from t hose outside it. His real reason was
that he wanted to undermine the alliance of the Greeks with
each other, so that he could rule those within [the isthmus] without
fear. Incursions by those outside [the isthmus] stymied his plan. |
261 C, 24-26 After Scylletium comes Crotoniate territory and three 6.1.11
headlands belonging to the Iapygians;1 after them, Lacinium, Lacinium, on Capo Colonna
Strait to Lacinium; and seven hundred for the direct crossing from Lacinium, on Capo Colonna
there to Iapygia headland. People say that this crossing is the Iapygia headland, Capo S. Maria
di Leuca (It.)
mouth of the Tarantinian bay. The circuit of the bay itself is
Tarantinian bay, Gulf of Taranto
considerable, at two hundred and forty miles, according to
Artemidorus (late 2nd–early the chorographer 2 . . . * three hundred and eighty . . . * Ar-
1st c. BCE)
temidorus, and this many short of the width of the mouth
of the bay.
262 C, 2-5 The bay f aces southeast, and its beginning is marked by
Lacinium, immediately after rounding which, you come to Lacinium, on Capo Colonna
what w ere Achaean cities. These cities, other than that of the
Tarantinians, are no longer in existence but warrant lengthy
treatment b ecause of their fame.3 |
262 C, 6-14 First, there’s Croton, one hundred and fifty stades from Croton, Crotone (It.) 6.1.12
Lacinium; and also Aesarus (river and harbor) and another Aesarus (river), Esaro r.
river, “Neaethus” (Burnt-ships), said to be named after what hap- Neaethus, Neto r.
pened t here. The story is that some Achaeans, who had got
separated from the rest of the Trojan expedition, landed t here
and disembarked for a reconnaissance of the place; the Trojan
women on board were weary of the voyage and, when they
realized that the men had gone from the ships, set the ships on
fire; thus the men, who had anyway seen that the land was ex-
cellent, were forced to stay there; since several others arrived
soon afterward and made entreaties on the basis of kinship,
many settlements arose; several of the settlements took their
names from rivers.
262 C, 14-26 Antiochus says that when the god instructed the Achaeans to
Antiochus (5th c. BCE) found Croton, Myscellus went off to inspect the place, but when he
saw the already-founded Sybaris (with the same name as the nearby
river), he decided that the latter city was preferable; on his return, he
asked the god whether it might be more desirable to found the latter
309
3.1. Western Europe
by the Achaeans, situated between two rivers, the Crathis and Crathis, Crati r.
the Sybaris. The founder of the city was . . . *. This city was Sybaris (river), Coscile r.
310
Italy + Islands
263 C, 25-28 The Sybaris makes horses that drink its waters timid—for Sybaris (river), Coscile r.
which reason, p eople also keep farm animals away from it.
The Crathis turns the hair of men who bathe in it blond or Crathis, Crati r.
263 C, 32–264 C, 1 After Thurii is the fortress of Lagaria, founded by Epius 6.1.14
and two navigable rivers, the Aciris and the Siris. On the banks Aciris, Agri r.
of the latter, there was a Trojan city of the same name. In time, Siris, Sinni r.
when Heraclia was founded as a colony from t here by the Tar- Trojan city of same name = Siris,
nr. Policoro (It.)
antinians, this city became the Heracleote seaport. She was
twenty-four stades from Heraclia (around three hundred and
thirty from Thurii). People treat as proof of Trojan settlement Thurii, Sibari/Copia (It.)
the cult statue of “Ilias” (Trojan) Athena that stands there. Myth
has it that the statue closed her eyes when the suppliants w ere
dragged away by the Ionians who captured the city—these Io-
nians had come as settlers fleeing Lydian domination, took the
city (which belonged to the Chonians) by force, and called her
“Polieium”; the statue with her eyes closed is shown as proof! Polieium = Siris, nr. Policoro (It.)
that turned away when Cassandra was v iolated) but also that
the closed-eye statue is proof! It is far more reckless to use as
proof all the cult statues that writers say have been brought Lavinium, Pratica di Mare (It.)
from Ilium: for in Rome, Lavinium, and Luceria, as well as Luceria, Lucera (It.)
311
3.1. Western Europe
Siritis, the cult statue is called “Ilias” Athena, as if it had Siritis = territory of Siris, nr.
Policoro (It.)
been brought from there. Also, the daring deed of the Trojan
women is set in many diff erent places and appears unworthy
of belief, though possible.
264 C, 19-24 Some people claim that both Siritis and Sybaris-on-the- Sybaris-on-the-Traeis, nr.
Trionto r. (It.)
Antiochus (5th c. BCE) Traeis were founded by Rhodians. Antiochus says that the
Tarantinians, d oing b attle with the Thurians and their general
Cleandridas (an exile from Lacedaemon) over Siritis, came to an
agreement that the settlement should be a joint one but that the colony
should be considered Tarantinian; she was later called “Heraclia,” Heraclia, nr. Policoro (It.)
from her), the new arrivals w ere persuaded by the Sybarites to take Taras, Taranto (It.)
possession of Metapontium, on the grounds that if they possessed this Siritis = territory of Siris, nr.
Policoro (It.)
place, they would also possess Siritis, whereas if they betook themselves
to Siritis, they would be giving Metapontium to the Tarantinians,
who w ere right t here on its flanks; l ater on, when they w
ere at war with
the Tarantinians and the Oenotrians inland, peace was concluded in
return for a portion of the land, which became the boundary between
what was then Italy and Iapygia.
265 C, 7-13 This is the setting for the myth of Metapontus, the shackled
Melanippa, and her son Boeotus. Antiochus thinks that the city
was previously called “Metabus” and subsequently underwent a name
change; Melanippa was brought not to this man but to Dius; proof is this man = Metapontus/
Metabus
provided by the temple to the hero Metabus and by the statement of
Antiochus (5th c. BCE) cites
Asius (?6th/?5th c. BCE) the poet Asius that Boeotus “was born to beautiful Melanippa in the
312
Italy + Islands
The man sent out by the Achaeans for the colonization was
Leucippus; given the use of the site for a day and a night, he
would not return it; during the daytime, he replied to those
who demanded it back that he wanted it and would take it
for the following night; in the nighttime, he replied that he
wanted it and would take it for the following day!
265 C, 20-26 Next come Taras and Iapygia. I will deal with them1 after Taras, Taranto (It.)
Strabo segues from his first doing the circuit of the islands lying off the coast of Italy, Iapygia = “heel” of Italy
description of w. Italy to his
description of Sicily in accordance with what has been my plan from the start. I
always add, to my description of the individual nations, a de-
scription of the neighboring islands. So, too—since I have
reached the end of Oenotria, which was the only part to which
men of former times gave the name “Italy”—I am at this junc-
ture justified in maintaining the same pattern and heading off
to Sicily and the islands associated with her. |
265 C, 27-33 Sicily is triangular in shape. For this reason, it was for- 6.2.1
cilian sea, facing the Peloponnese and the Cretan seaway. The Pachynus, Capo Passero (Sic.)
third headland—Lilybaeum—is the one nearer Libya, facing Lilybaeum, Capo Boeo (Sic.)
shortest side is the one nearer the Strait and Italy, extending
from Pelorias to Pachynus, some one thousand one hundred
and thirty stades.
266 C, 6-19 Posidonius gives the circular voyage as four thousand four
hundred stades. In the Chorography,4 a greater sum is given
313
3.1. Western Europe
for the constituent distances expressed in miles. From Pelo- Mylae, Milazzo (Sic.)
rias to Mylae, twenty-five; the same number from Mylae to Tyndaris, Tindari (Sic.)
266 C, 34–267 C, 5 The sea crossing from Pachynus to the mouth of the Al- Alphius, Alpheios r. (w.
Peloponnese)
Artemidorus (late 2nd–early phius is four thousand stades. Artemidorus, in stating that it
1st c. BCE)
is four thousand six hundred stades from Pachynus to Taenarum, but Taenarum, Akra Tainaron (s.
Peloponnese)
one thousand one hundred and thirty from the Alphius to the Pamisus,3
would seem to me to provide justification for the claim that
his statements are not in accordance with the man who claims
that it is four thousand stades from Pachynus to the Alphius.
314
Italy + Islands
267 C, 5-10 As for the side from Pachynus to Lilybaeum (the latter Lilybaeum, Capo Boeo (Sic.)
of which is considerably farther west than Pelorias), this too Pelorias, Capo Peloro (Sic.)
would slant considerably toward the west from due south, and
at the same time would face east and south, washed on one
direction by the Sicilian sea, in the other by the Libyan sea, Libyan sea = Med. Sea off
Tunisia/present-day Libya
which extends from Carthage to the Syrtes.
267 C, 10-14 The shortest sea crossing to the Carthage region of Libya is Carthage, Carthage (Tun.)
from Lilybaeum, at one thousand five hundred [stades]. For this Lilybaeum (headland), Capo
Boeo (Sic.)
reason, some sharp-eyed person,1 standing on some lookout
point, is said to have announced to the people in Lilybaeum Lilybaeum (town), Marsala (Sic.)
Messene, then Tauromenium, Catana, and Syracuse. The Messene, Messina (Sic.)
cities between Catana and Syracuse—Naxos and Megara— Tauromenium, Taormina (Sic.)
Symaethus, Simeto r.
have been eclipsed. This is where the rivers Symaethus and Catana, Catania (Sic.)
Pantacias, Porcaria r.
Pantacias, flowing from Etna, join the sea through mouths Syracuse, Siracusa (Sic.)
Xiphonia’s Promontory, Porto
Megarese (Sic.) that have fine harbors. Here, too, is Xiphonia’s Promontory.
267 C, 22-33 Ephorus says that these w ere the first cities founded by the
Ephorus (4th c. BCE) Greeks in Sicily, in the tenth generation a fter the Trojan period; men Trojan period, late 2nd–early
1st millennium BCE
of earlier times so feared Tyrrhenian piracy and the savagery of the
natives in the region that they did not sail t here even for commercial
purposes; Theocles the Athenian, blown off course, landed in Sicily
and recognized that the population was sparse and the conditions ex-
cellent; when he sailed home, he could not convince the Athenians, but,
winning over many Chalcidians in Euboea, some Ionians, and even
some Dorians (of whom the majority were Megarians), he set sail;
the Chalcidians founded Naxos, and the Dorians founded Megara, Naxos, Naxos-Giardini (Sic.)
which was earlier called “Hybla.” The cities no longer exist, but Megara/Hybla, Megara
Hyblaea (Sic.)
the name of “Hybla” survives on account of the excellence of
“Hyblaean” honey. |
267 C, 34–268 C, 10 As for the cities that do survive on the said side,2 Messene Messene/Zancla, Messina (Sic.) 6.2.3
[ 1 ] Other ancient writers tell us that this man was called “Strabo” (which in Greek
literally means “cross-eyed”). Our author may h
ere be coyly alluding to the fact
that he shares the same name. Another possible example of our author drawing
attention to the literal meaning of his name: 224 C, 3-8n.
[ 2 ] 267 C, 18-22; cf. 266 C, 28-34.
315
3.1. Western Europe
ter populated, for it has absorbed Roman settlers as well. Catana, Catania (Sic.)
(Tauromenium is less well populated than either of these Tauromenium, Taormina (Sic.)
expelled the original settlers when Hiero, ruler of Syracuse, Syracuse, Siracusa (Sic.)
settled her with other people and called the city “Etna” in-
Pindar (5th c. BCE) stead of “Catana.” Pindar calls him the f ounder of this city,
saying: listen to what I say, you who share a name with the holy rites,3
/ O father, founder of Etna. Following the death of Hiero, the
Catanians returned, expelled the inhabitants, and dug up the
grave of the ruler. The Etnaeans retreated, settled on a ridge
of Etna called “Innesa,” and gave the city “Etna” to the place
(it is eighty stades from Catana), and they declared that Hiero
was the f ounder.
268 C, 33–269 C, 4 Etna4 is immediately above Catana and shares most fully
in the effects associated with volcanic craters. The streams
of lava flow down extremely close to Catanaea, which is the
setting for The pious ones—Amphinomus and Anapias, who lifted
[ 1 ] I.e., the same Naxians who founded Zancla: 267 C, 34–268 C, 10.
[ 2 ] Hybla: 267 C, 22-33.
[ 3 ] The Greek word for “holy rites,” in the inflected form used by Pindar, is hieron;
the Greek form of the name “Hiero” is Hieron.
[ 4 ] Perhaps the town of Etna (268 C, 18-32; cf. 273 C, 26–274 C, 4), rather than the
volcano.
316
Italy + Islands
their parents onto their shoulders and saved them from the
evil bearing down on them.
269 C, 4-19 Whenever . . . *1 around the mountain, the area belong-
ing to the Catanaeans gets covered with deep layers of ash.
The ash causes problems at the time but later brings benefits
to the territory, making it good for growing vines and other
crops, even though the rest of the territory is not suited for
wine production in the same way. People say that the roots
nourished by the ash-covered area make small farm animals
so fat that they choke, which is why blood has to be drawn
from their ears every four or five days, just as also happens
in the case of Erythia, as I said.2 The lava, when it solidifies,
turns the earth’s surface to stone for quite some depth, so
that you have to dig down if you want to uncover the original
surface. When the rock in the craters becomes molten and
then is thrown upward, the fluid that pours out over the peak
is a black mud, which flows down the mountainside; then it
hardens into stone that is good for millstones, preserving the
same color that it had when molten. The ash is the result of
the stone burning up in the same way as wood. Just as rue is
nourished by wood ash, so (it is reasonable to suppose) that
ash from Etna has some useful quality for vines. |
269 C, 20–270 C, 4 Syracuse was founded by Archias, who sailed from Corinth Syracuse, Siracusa (Sic.) 6.2.4
at around the time that Naxos and Megara w ere founded. It Naxos, Naxos-Giardini (Sic.)
is said that Archias visited Delphi at around the same time Megara, Megara Hyblaea (Sic.)
oracle, center for divine as Myscellus; when they consulted the oracle, the god asked
prophecy at Delphi (Gr.)
whether they preferred wealth or health; Archias chose wealth,
and Myscellus chose health, so the god granted Syracuse to the
former and Croton to the latter; this is how it came to be that Croton, Crotone (It.)
317
3.1. Western Europe
318
Italy + Islands
Pindar (5th c. BCE) Pindar says: revered resting place of the Alphius, / scion of famous
Timaeus (late 4th–early 3rd c. Syracuse, Ortygia. Timaeus, the writer, makes the same decla-
BCE)
ration as Pindar.
271 C, 2-9 Now if, before joining the sea, the Alphius fell into some
chasm, there would be some plausibility to the view that,
from there, its course continued underground—separate
from the sea and preserving its nonsaline w ater. However,
the mouth of the river where it joins the sea is plainly visible,
and nowhere in that part of the sea does t here appear to be
any mouth to swallow the river’s flow (which would thus not
remain consistently fresh but nevertheless—if it followed an
underground course—largely so). Consequently, the view is
completely untenable.
271 C, 9-17 The water of the Arethusa testifies against it, being non-
saline. The idea of the river’s current maintaining its integrity
across so great a waterway, without getting mixed with the
sea, u ntil joining the fictional stream, is complete myth. We
scarcely credit this of the Rhodanus, whose current retains its Rhodanus, Rhône r.
319
3.1. Western Europe
Centoripa, which made a g reat contribution to the downfall Catana, Catania (Sic.)
of Pompeius. Centoripa is situated above Catana, verging on Centoripa, Centuripe (Sic.)
Symaethus, Simeto r. the mountains of Etna and the Symaethus river, which flows
into Catanaea. |
272 C, 5-10 As for the remaining sides of Sicily,1 the side r unning 6.2.5
Acragas (belonging to the Geloans) and its seaport, and Acragas, Agrigento (Sic.)
Lilybaeum, remain still in existence. Since these parts were Geloans = inhabitants of Gela,
Gela (Sic.)
mostly u nder Carthaginian control, many w ere destroyed in
Lilybaeum, Marsala (Sic.)
the long series of wars.
272 C, 10-16 The remaining and longest side, although also not densely Alaesa, nr. Castel di Tusa (Sic.)
populated, nevertheless has quite a few settlements: t here Tyndaris, Tindari (Sic.)
are the small towns of Alaesa, Tyndaris, and the entrepôt of entrepôt of the Aegestans, Ca
stellammare del Golfo (Sic.)
Cephaloedis, ?Cefalù (Sic.) the Aegestans and Cephaloedis; and Panormus has a Roman
Aegestaea = territory of
Panormus, Palermo (Sic.) colony. It is said that Aegestaea was founded by those who Aegesta, Segesta (Sic.)
crossed the sea with Philoctetes to Crotoniatis (as mentioned
in my Italica),2 and who w ere dispatched by him to Sicily with
Aegestes the Trojan.
272 C, 16-22 Also settled is Eryx, a lofty hill with an exceptionally Eryx, Erice (Sic.)
Radt, following earlier editors, well-regarded temple to Aphrodite, which was, in antiquity,
places this paragraph here
full of female temple slaves, whom people from Sicily, and
many from elsewhere, dedicated in fulfillment of their vows.
Nowadays, just as the settlement is depopulated, so too is
the temple; and the great number of temple personnel has
vanished. T here is also a replica t emple to this goddess in
Rome—the temple in front of the Colline gate known as the
Erycinian Aphrodite = Lat. temple to “Erycinian” Aphrodite, with an inner shrine and a
Venus Erycina
remarkable colonnade r unning around it.3 |
272 C, 23-27 In the interior, a few p eople occupy Enna—in which Enna, Enna (Sic.) 6.2.6
320
Italy + Islands
they were besieged there and were destroyed (with some dif-
ficulty) by the Romans. The Catanaeans, Tauromenitans, and
several o thers, suffered the same fate.
272 C, 27-32 Other settlement, both inland and on the coast, has mostly
become the preserve of shepherds. I do not know w hether Hi- Himera, Himera (Sic.)
mera is still inhabited, or Gela, Callipolis, Selinus, Euboea, or Gela, Gela (Sic.)
various others. Of these, Himera was founded by the Mylaean Selinus, Selinunte (Sic.)
Zanclaeans, Gela . . . *, Callipolis by the Naxians, Selinus by Euboea, ?Licodia Euboia (Sic.)
[ 1 ] Radt (vol. 2, critical apparatus on 272 C, line 32) transposes this paragraph to
the location shown in this translation from its manuscript position a fter 273 C,
23-25.
[ 2 ] Strabo was therefore in Rome at the date of this spectacle (mid-30s BCE). Com-
ments elsewhere reinforce his presence in Rome at this time: 381 C, 7-16n; 548 C,
9-14n. Strabo was probably in Rome on at least one subsequent occasion: 236 C,
13-22n. Other attestations of Strabo’s presence in Rome or elsewhere in w. Italy:
117 C, 12-20n; 199 C, 31–200 C, 17n; 223 C, 27–224 C, 3n (cf. 222 C, 9-22n). Sugges-
tions of Strabo’s presence in Rome: 224 C, 20-28n; 236 C, 25-28n: 144 C, 12-21nn.
321
3.1. Western Europe
It is to Rome that all its products (except for the few things
consumed locally) are exported—not food products alone
but livestock, leather, wool and so on.
273 C, 23-25 Posidonius says that Syracuse and Eryx are situated like two Syracuse, Siracusa (Sic.)
Posidonius (late 2nd–1st c. BCE) acropolises on the sea; and between them lies Enna, above the encir- Eryx, Erice (Sic.)
cling plains. | Enna, Enna (Sic.)
273 C, 26–274 C, 4 Near Centoripa is a town, the aforementioned Etna,1 Centoripa, Centuripe (Sic.) 6.2.8
322
Italy + Islands
even see it, and they surmised that nothing could be hurled
down into it because of the countervailing blasts of air from
far below and b ecause of the heat (with which, it is reasonable
to suppose, one was confronted long before getting close to
the mouth of the crater).
274 C, 21-25 Even if anything w ere hurled in, it would be destroyed be-
fore being thrown back out . . . * as earlier tradition had it. It
is not irrational to suppose that at times the blasts of air and
fire would stop, as its fuel ran out, but not to the extent that
any man, faced with such a force, could make an approach.
274 C, 26-29 Etna is inland, mostly from the coast at the Strait and Cat- Strait, Straits of Messina
anaea but also from the coast on the Tyrrhenian sea near the
Liparaean islands. By night, a bright light can be seen shining Liparaean islands, Isole Eolie (It.
islands)
from its peak. By day, it is shrouded in smoke and haze. |
274 C, 29-30 The Nebrodes mountains are opposite Etna; they are Nebrodes, Monti Nebrodi, 6.2.9
Monti Peloritani, Madonie (Sic.)
lower but much wider.
274 C, 31–275 C, 5 The whole island is hollow underneath but filled with riv- island = Sicily
ers and volcanic fire (which is also the case with the Tyrrhe-
nian sea, as I said, as far as Cumaea).1 At any rate, in many
Selinuntian waters = Lat. places the island features springs of hot w ater: the Selinun- Selinuntian waters, Sciacca (Sic.)
Thermae Selinuntinae
tian waters and the waters at Himera are salty, the Aegestaean aters at Himera, Termini
w
aters at Himera = Lat. Thermae
w Imerese (Sic.)
Himeraeae
waters are fresh. In the Acragas region, t here are lakes that
Aegestaean waters, Terme
Aegestaean waters = Lat. Aquae
taste like seawater but have a remarkable quality: it happens Segestane (Sic.)
Segestanae that even t hose who cannot swim do not go under, but they Acragas, Agrigento (Sic.)
float on the surface like pieces of wood!
275 C, 5-19 The Palicians have craters from which conical geysers of Palicians = Sicilian deities
water shoot upward and then fall back into the same hole. geysers, at Lago di Naftia (Sic.)
The cave in the Mataurus region has a huge channel inside it,
in which a river flows unseen for a great distance then reap-
pears at the surface. Similarly, the Orontes in Syria disappears
into the chasm called “Charybdis”—between Apamia and
Antioch—and then, after forty stades, reemerges. The Ti-
gris in Mesopotamia and the Nile in Libya—shortly before
its sources—are comparable cases. The w ater in the region
of Stymphalus, after flowing underground for two hundred
stades, issues forth in Argia as the Erasinus river. Again, the
water at Arcadian Asea, forced underground, at some l ater
point returns to the surface as both the Eurotas and the Al-
phius, causing people to believe a mythical falsehood, that
garlands dedicated to each river and thrown into the common
[ 1 ] 248 C, 6-16.
323
3.1. Western Europe
shrouds the island so that not even Sicily can be seen from t here; when
the north wind is about to blow, pure flames arise from the aforemen-
tioned crater, and loud rumbling sounds are emitted; the situation
with the west wind is intermediate. The other two craters are similar,
but their blasts are less powerful. Based on the variation in rumbling
sounds and on the source of the blasts and flames and fiery smoke, a
[ 1 ] 214 C, 28–215 C, 4.
[ 2 ] “Men of today” are Latin speakers; Strabo transliterates into Greek the Latin
name Hiera (itself borrowed from the Greek). Strabo’s transliteration of Latin
names: 508 C, 10-18n. The Greeks themselves seem to have called the island
“Thermessa”: 275 C, 20-28; 276 C, 23-30.
324
Italy + Islands
prediction can be made as to the wind that will blow on the third day
forward. He says that, at a time when conditions on Liparae w ere
not good for sailing, certain people predicted to him the future wind,
and they w ere not mistaken: this is why the seemingly most mythical
poet = Homer (8th c. BCE) falsehood spoken by the poet is not spoken in vain but is the statement
of a man who hints at the truth, namely when he says that Aeolus is
the “steward of the winds” (which m atters I discussed at quite
some length previously).1
276 C, 21-22 I return to what comes next in sequence a fter the point
from which I turned aside.2 |
276 C, 23-30 I have described Lipara and Thermessa.3 “Strongyla” Strongyla, Stromboli (It. island) 6.2.11
islands that remain, “Ericussa” (Heathery) and “Phoenicussa” Ericussa, Alicudi (It. island)
(Date-palm) are called after plants and given over to pasturage. Phoenicussa, Filicudi (It. island)
The seventh is “Euonymus” (Left-hand-side), the farthest out to Euonymus, Panarea (It. island)
325
3.1. Western Europe
277 C, 16-19 The chorographer1 says it is ten miles from Ericodes to Ericodes, Alicudi (It. island)
277 C, 20-25 Lying off Pachynus are Melita, whence come those little Melita, Malta
dogs that people call “Melitaean,” and Gaudus: both islands Gaudus, Gozo (island in Maltese
archipelago)
are eighty-eight miles from the headland. Cossura lies off
Cossura, Pantelleria (It. island)
Lilybaeum and off Aspis (Shield)—a Carthaginian city, which
Lilybaeum, Marsala (Sic.)
they call “Clypea”2—midway between the two and the said
distance from each. Aegimurus, too, lies off Sicily and Libya, Aegimurus, Zembra (Tun.
island)
as do other small islands.3
277 C, 25 The foregoing is my description of the islands.4 |
277 C, 26-33 Now that I have journeyed across the region of ancient 6.3.1
IAPYGIA Italy as far as Metapontium,5 the area that follows should be Metapontium, Metaponto (It.)
“heel” of Italy
described. What follows is Iapygia.6 The Greeks call this area,
additionally, “Messapia.” The locals call it by its parts, calling
one part (the Iapygian headland region) the “Salentinians,”
the other part the “Calabrians.”7 North of these peoples are
the “Peucetians” and “Daunians,”8 as they are called in the
Greek language. The locals give the name “Apulia” to the en-
tire territory that comes next a fter the Calabrians. Some of
the people there, particularly the Peucetians, are also called
“Poediclians.”9
277 C, 33–278 C, 2 Messapia is rather in the shape of a peninsula, with an
isthmus of three hundred and ten stades from Brundisium Brundisium, Brindisi (It.)
to Taras. (The voyage around the Iapygian headland is, in Taras, Taranto (It.)
round numbers, . . . * stades). The distance from Metapon- Metapontium, Metaponto (It.)
harborless, t here’s a large and very fine harbor, with an Tarantinian bay, Gulf of Taranto
[ 1 ] “Chorographer”: 224 C, 29-33n. [ 7 ] “The locals” are Latin speakers; Strabo transliterates into Greek the Latin eth-
[ 2 ] “They” are Latin speakers; Strabo transliterates into Greek the Latin place-name nic names Salentini and Calabri. Strabo’s transliteration of Latin names: 508 C,
Clypea (Kelibia, Tun.). Clipeus is the Latin word for “shield.” Strabo’s translitera- 10-18n.
tion of Latin names: 508 C, 10-18n. [ 8 ] Peucetians and Daunians = Lat. Apulia: 283 C, 17–285 C, 34.
[ 3 ] Strabo’s account of Cossura and Aegimurus is confusing. For further confusion, [ 9 ] I.e., called by Latin speakers; Strabo transliterates into Greek the Latin names
followed by elucidation: 834 C, 1-18nn. Apulia and Poediculi. Strabo refines his e arlier statement (242 C, 8-10, where
[ 4 ] 265 C, 27–277 C, 25. he equates the Apulians with the “Daunians”). Strabo’s transliteration of Latin
[ 5 ] Strabo picks up the thread of his narrative from 265 C, 20-26. names: 508 C, 10-18n.
[ 6 ] Iapygia: 277 C, 33–285 C, 34.
326
Italy + Islands
[ 1 ] Strabo undoubtedly saw this bronze statue in the Capitol in Rome: 236 C,
25-28n.
[ 2 ] “Those associated with Phalanthus” is an idiomatic expression, which simply
means Phalanthus.
[ 3 ] The plural “they” may refer to “those associated with Phalanthus” and is gram-
matically required, even if the sense (i.e., “Phalanthus”) is singular. Cf. 477 C,
28–478 C, 11nn.
327
3.1. Western Europe
328
Italy + Islands
f athers to go forth and found a colony: if they were to find a site that
was satisfactory, they should stay t here; if not, they w
ere to come back
and divide the fifth part of Messene between them. They set out and
came across the Achaeans fighting with the natives, and taking a share
of the risk, they founded Taras. | Taras, Taranto (It.)
280 C, 14-20 Once upon a time, under democratic government, the 6.3.4
329
3.1. Western Europe
thirteen cities. Nowadays, apart from Taras and Brundisium, Taras, Taranto (It.)
they are merely small towns. Such is the extent to which they Brundisium, Brindisi (It.)
form—together with it—the mouth of the Ionian gulf. The Ceraunian mts., range incl. Cikes
mt. (Alb.)
distance from it to the Ceraunians, and also to Lacinium, is
some seven hundred stades.
281 C, 19-28 As for the coastal voyage from Taras to Brundisium, it is Taras, Taranto (It.)
six hundred stades as far as the small town of Baris. Men of Brundisium, Brindisi (It.)
today call Baris “Veretum.”1 She lies at the extremity of Sal- Baris/Veretum, Serra di Vereto
(It.)
entina. For the most part, it is easier to get to her from Taras
by land than by sea. It is eighty stades from t here to Leuca, a Leuca, Leuca (It.)
and fifty [stades]. From there it is four hundred to Brundisium, Brundisium, Brindisi (It.)
and an equal number to the island of Sason. The island lies Sason, Sazani (Alb. island)
approximately at the midpoint of the voyage from Epirus Epirus, Albania, nw. Greece
[ 1 ] “Men of today” are Latin speakers; Strabo transliterates into Greek the Latin
place-name Veretum. Strabo’s transliteration of Latin names: 508 C, 10-18n.
330
Italy + Islands
In the interior are Rhodiae, Lupiae, and (set back just a Rhodiae, Rugge (It.)
little from the coast) Aletia. In the middle of the isthmus Lupiae, Lecce (It.)
is Uria, in which the royal residence of some dynast can still Aletia, Alezio (It.)
be seen. We should understand either this city or Veretum Uria, Oria (It.)
Herodotus (5th c. BCE) as being referred to when Herodotus says that Hyria is in Veretum, Serra di Vereto (It.)
Iapygia, founded by t hose Cretans who w
ere dispersed a fter Minos’s
expedition.
282 C, 12-18 Cretans are said to have colonized Brundisium—either Brundisium, Brindisi (It.)
are the cities of Egnatia, Caelia, Netium, Canusium, and Canusium, Canosa di Puglia (It.)
[ 1 ] Strabo refines his earlier statement (277 C, 26-33, where he describes the pen-
insula as split between the Calabrians and Salentinians), now acknowledging
that “Calabria” and “Salentina” can be applied to the entire peninsula.
[ 2 ] 281 C, 19-35.
[ 3 ] “All” surely includes Strabo, who would have passed through Brundisium on
his way to Rome for his further education. For Strabo’s probable inclusion of
himself in the expression “all”: 663 C, 19-33n.
[ 4 ] “They” are Latin speakers; Strabo transliterates into Greek the Latin ethnic
name Poediculi: 508 C, 10-18n.
331
3.1. Western Europe
the left if you choose to make the detour of around one day’s
Appian [road] = Lat. Via Appia journey. It is called the “Appian” and is more suitable for
wagons. On it are the cities of Uria and Venusia: the former is Uria, Oria (It.)
between Taras and Brundisium, the latter on the Samnite/ Venusia, Venosa (It.)
Leucanian border. The two roads merge at Beneventum and
Campania and are called “Appian” for the final stretch to
Rome through Caudium, Calatia, Capua, and Casilinum to
Sinuessa (the road thence has been described).1 The total
distance from Rome to Brundisium is three hundred and
sixty miles.
283 C, 8-11 There is a third road from Regium past the Brettians and Regium, Reggio di Calabria (It.)
nine mountains. |
283 C, 12-16 As for the voyage from Brundisium to the opposite 6.3.8
shore, one route is to the Ceraunians and to the coast of Ceraunian mts., range incl. Cikes
mt. (Alb.)
Epirus and Greece that comes after them. The other route
is to Epidamnus. It is longer than the first route, being a Epirus, Albania, nw. Greece
distance of one thousand stades, while the first is a distance Epidamnus, Durrës (Alb.)
of eight hundred stades. This route is well used because the
city is conveniently situated with regard to the Illyrian and
Macedonian nations.
283 C, 17-23 As you sail along the Adriatic coast from Brundisium, Brundisium, Brindisi (It.)
PEUCETIANS, DAUNIANS you come to the city of Egnatia, which is a stopping place Egnatia, Egnazia (It.)
(= APULIA)
e. Italy for those heading to Barium by ship or on foot. The voyage Barium, Bari (It.)
is made with the south wind. The Peucetians extend this far
along the coast (as far inland as Silvium). The w hole coast is Silvium, Botromagno/Gravina di
Puglia (It.)
rugged and mountainous, much of it a continuation of the
Apennine mountains. It has apparently received Arcadian
settlers. The distance from Brundisium to Barium is some
seven hundred stades. Egnatia is virtually equidistant from
each.
283 C, 23-27 The following stretch is held by Daunians (then by Apu-
lians as far as the Frentanians). Since the “Peucetians” and
the “Daunians” are never—except in antiquity—referred
to by the locals, and since the entire territory is now called
“Apulia,”2 it is unnecessary for the boundaries of these na-
tions to be precisely given. T here is therefore no need for me
to make categorical statements about them. |
[ 1 ] 233 C, 8–234 C, 6.
[ 2 ] I.e., by Latin speakers. Strabo clarifies his e
arlier statement (277 C, 26-33, where
the Peucetians and Daunians are spoken of in the present tense).
332
Italy + Islands
283 C, 28-29 The distance from Barium to the Aufidus river, on which Aufidus, Ofanto r. 6.3.9
is the entrepôt of the Canusites, is four hundred [stades] (and Canusites = inhabitants of
Canusium, Canosa di Puglia (It.)
the voyage upstream to the entrepôt is ninety).
283 C, 29-34 Nearby is Salapia, the seaport belonging to the Argyrip- Salapia, ?Salpi/?Lupara (It.)
[ 1 ] 215 C, 5-18.
333
3.1. Western Europe
you round the headland, you come to a little town—Urium— Urium, in Piano di Carpino (It.)
and, off the headland, the Diomedian islands. Diomedian islands, Tremiti (It.
islands)
284 C, 23-25 This entire territory yields a wide array of bountiful pro-
territory = Apulia
duce, and it is exceptional for its horses and sheep. The wool
is softer than that from Taras but less glossy. The territory is Taras, Taranto (It.)
Artemidorus.2
285 C, 1-7 The chorographer3 gives the distance from Brundisium Brundisium, Brindisi (It.)
Artemidorus (late 2nd–early to Garganum as one hundred and sixty-five miles. Artemi- Garganum, Testa del Gargano
1st c. BCE) (It.)
dorus’s figure amounts to more than that. From t here to
Ancon, the former fellow says it is two hundred and fifty- former fellow = chorographer
four miles. Artemidorus gives the distance to the Aesis—near Ancon, Ancona (It.)
Ancon—as one thousand two hundred and fifty stades, which Aesis, Esino r.
the Adria and stating that this distance exceeds six thousand Adria, Adriatic Sea
[stades], making it much longer than the former fellow does, former fellow
= ?chorographer/?Polybius
whereas it is much shorter.
285 C, 12-20 All writers disagree among themselves in respect to all
other writers, particularly in regard to distances, as I often
note. When it is possible for me to arbitrate, I select what
seems to me to be right; when that is not possible, I believe
that I should present their different views. If I find nothing
in their work, it is not surprising if I, too, omit some detail
in such an undertaking as this. I would not omit anything
334
Italy + Islands
to a deep bay. T hose who live around it are called “Apulians” deep bay = ?Lago di Varano
lake, is “Apulian Teanum,” which shares her name with the Apulian Teanum, nr. S. Paolo di
Civitate (It.)
Sidicinian one). This is where Italy undergoes quite a con-
Sidicinian [Teanum], Teano (It.)
traction widthwise with the region of Dicaearchia, resulting
widthwise = from east to west
in an isthmus of less than one thousand stades from sea to
Dicaearchia, Pozzuoli (It.)
sea. After the lake is the coastal stretch to the Frentanians
and Buca: it is two hundred stades in either direction from Buca, ?Termoli (It.)
the lake to Buca and Garganum. What comes next after the
Buca region has already been described.2 |
285 C, 35–286 C, 8 Such is the nature and extent of Italy.3 . . . * having said 6.4.1
many things, I will now list the most important factors that
have contributed to Roman ascendancy. One factor is that,
in the manner of an island, Italy’s security is ensured by the
seas that surround it in all but a few directions, and, in those
places, it is protected by mountain ranges that are difficult to
cross. The second factor is that Italy is largely harborless, but
those harbors that it does have are large and impressive. The
former characteristic is useful against invasions from abroad,
while the latter characteristic is useful in resisting invasions
and in helping to create an abundance of trade. The third
factor is that Italy is subjected to a wide range of climates and
temperatures in accordance with which fauna and flora—and
everything, in short, that supports life—are present in very
great profusion, for better or worse.
335
3.1. Western Europe
286 C, 8-14 Italy extends lengthways largely from north to south. (Sic-
ily, being itself of such great length, is an addition to such a
lengthways extension, as a constituent part.) Temperateness
and intemperateness of climate are assessed in accordance with
low temperatures, high temperatures, and temperatures in be-
tween. It necessarily follows from this that “Italy,” as it now is,
being positioned midway between each extreme, b ecause of its
great length occupies a very great part of the temperate zone,
and does so in many diff erent forms.
286 C, 14-22 This is to Italy’s advantage in another way. Since the Apen-
nine mountains extend down its entire length, leaving both
plains and fruitful hillsides on either side, there is no part of
Italy that does not enjoy the benefits of both mountain and
plain. Add to this the size and number of rivers and lakes and,
in addition to these, the springs—both hot and cold—that
nature has provided in many places for health and well-being,
and the abundance of minerals of all sorts. One cannot ad-
equately describe the abundance of materials and food prod-
ucts for both men and animals that Italy provides nor Italy’s
fruitfulness.
286 C, 22-26 Being at the midpoint between the greatest nations1 and
Greece and the best parts of Asia, on the one hand Italy is
naturally suited to leadership because it is superior in qual-
ity and size to t hose that surround it, and on the other hand
it has benefited from readily available assistance in close
proximity. |
286 C, 27–287 C, 3 If it is necessary to add to my account of Italy a brief ac- 6.4.2
336
Italy + Islands
Polybius (2nd c. BCE) and against expectation regained it. This happened, as Poly-
bius tells us, in the nineteenth year a fter the naval engagement at
Aegospotami, during the peace concluded u nder Antalcidas. In the
process of getting rid of them, the Romans first made all the
Latins their subjects; then they stopped the Tyrrhenians,
and the Celts from the Padus area, from taking enormous Padus, Po r.
and unceasing liberties; then they conquered the Samnites, they = the Romans
after them the Tarantinians and Pyrrhus, and finally the rest
of what is now Italy, except for the territory in the Padus re-
gion. With the last territory still in a state of war, they crossed
over into Sicily and, having taken it from the Carthaginians,
returned to fight against those in the Padus region. While this
war was still proceeding, Hannibal appeared in Italy, and the
second Carthaginian war took place; and not long afterward,
the third, in which Carthage was razed and the Romans ac-
quired Libya1 and as much of Iberia as they had taken from
the Carthaginians.
287 C, 19-24 The Greeks, the Macedonians, and t hose from Asia this
side of the Halys and Taurus joined the Carthaginians in their
rebellion. They w ere thus induced to conquer all of these They = the Romans
starting out from these areas as being the most suitable, and these areas = Celtica
they have even now adorned their fatherland with some tri-
umphs from them.3
[ 1 ] Libya in the sense of the Roman province of Africa, rather than the entire con-
tinent: 840 C, 13-26.
[ 2 ] Strabo considers that the Roman war against the Germans is ongoing, since
the German leader Arminius remains at large: 291 C, 23–292 C, 10n.
[ 3 ] Strabo may include the minor triumph (called an “ovation”) awarded to
Tiberius’s son, Drusus (19 CE).
337
3.1. Western Europe
288 C, 1-4 With regard to Libya, the part not belonging to the
Carthaginians had been turned over to client kings. Any who
rebelled w ere destroyed. Currently, Maurusia and many parts
of the rest of Libya have ended up with Juba, on account of his
goodwill and friendship with the Romans.
288 C, 4-16 The situation was similar with regard to Asia. To start
with, it was managed through client kings. Since their lines
later died out (in the case of the Attalic, Syrian, Paphlago-
nian, Cappadocian, and Egyptian kings)1 or they rebelled
and were then destroyed (as happened in the case of Mith-
ridates Eupator and the Egyptian woman, Cleopatra),2 all
areas 3 this side of the Phasis and the Euphrates (except for this side of Phasis and
Euphrates = Asian
some Arabs) are subject e ither to the Romans or to the dy- peninsula + lands west of
nasts appointed by them. The Armenians, and the Albanians Euphrates r.
they are more or less on the brink of giving their entire empire
over into Roman hands.5
288 C, 24-33 As for Italy itself (which has experienced political infight-
ing many times since it fell under Roman control) and as for
Rome itself, they have been prevented by constitutional
excellence and virtuous leadership from proceeding too far
down the path of error and disaster. Nevertheless, it is difficult
to manage an empire of such size other than by turning it over
to one man alone, as a f ather. Never have the Romans and
[ 1 ] Strabo refers to the last male of the Egyptian royal line. Cf. Strabo’s reference [ 3 ] Alternatively, “nations.”
to a male of the Egyptian royal line as the “last Ptolemy” to rule Cyprus: 684 C, [ 4 ] The expression “leaders of our times” includes Tiberius (current emperor) and
17-24. Both Egypt and Cyprus were subsequently ruled by a female member Augustus (previous emperor). The specific reference here is to activities carried
of the Egyptian royal f amily—Cleopatra, s ister and niece, respectively, of the out by Tiberius as a young man, when Augustus was still emperor. “Leaders”:
last male rulers of Egypt and Cyprus. 159 C, 19-28n.
[ 2 ] Strabo, well aware that Cleopatra was a member of the Egyptian royal line, re- [ 5 ] For the sense of imminent capitulation to the Romans, see Strabo’s comments
peatedly treats her as lacking legitimacy: 684 C, 24–685 C, 5; 796 C, 19–797 C, 6. on the Getans and Dacians: 305 C, 11-15.
338
Italy + Islands
339
Netherlands
Poland
Germany
?
1 ?
Rh
?
in
kia
Slova M
ol
Austria do
France er- va
Swiatznd Hungary
l nia
Slove
Croatia
2
Romania 3 Crimea
a- ube
sni ina Dan
Italy Bozegov Serbia
r
He
Monte-
negro Kosovo Bulgaria 5
4 North
Albania
Macedonia
ce
Gree
6 Turkey
Translator’s Introduction
Having divided E urope into its western and eastern parts, and having described the west-
ern part, Strabo now moves on to eastern Europe, which he divides into the part north of
the Ister (Danube river) and the part south of it. The part north of the Ister also happens
to be east of the Rhine. Strabo starts with the area immediately east of the Rhine (1, on
the accompanying map), treating the riverbank as a quasi-coastline with a corresponding
hinterland (northern Netherlands, Germany, Czech Republic). He repeats the p rocess with
the lower Danube (2), the banks of which he similarly treats as a sort of coastline, with
areas north of the river (Hungary, northern Serbia, Romania, Moldova) acting as a sort of
hinterland. He concludes his account of the part of eastern E urope north of the Ister with
a true coastline (3)—formed by a part of the Black Sea and the Sea of Azov—together
with its hinterland (Moldova, Ukraine, Russia).
Strabo’s description of the area north of the Danube underscores one of the differ-
ences between his idea of what constitutes eastern E urope and our own. In the m iddle
of the twentieth c entury, our concept of “eastern E urope” was colored largely by the
presence of the Iron Curtain between the liberal West and the communist East, with the
latter including countries like Czechoslovakia (as it then was), Poland, and East Germany.
Nowadays, with Germany united and many of the erstwhile countries of eastern E urope
more commonly considered to be part of “central Europe,” the boundary has moved
farther east. For Strabo, in contrast, the dividing line between east and west is formed
by the river Rhine, with the corollary that nearly all of Germany and the northern part
of the Netherlands are categorized for him as part of eastern Europe.
In a further complication, much of what Strabo might have categorized as part of
eastern E urope falls into something of a hole in his knowledge. He assumes the area of
present-day Poland, Slovakia, and western Ukraine to be inhabited, but he does not know
by whom. Farther north, Strabo categorizes the space occupied by the Baltic states, by
Belarus, and by most of Russia, as existing beyond the lived-in world. His belief that
conditions t here are too severe to allow for h uman habitation renders irrelevant, for
Strabo, the question of whether the space consists of (uninhabited) land or w hether it
is covered by sea, although Strabo tends to favor the latter. In general, Strabo assumes
that the fact that nothing is known about this space means that there is nothing worth
341
3.2. Eastern Europe
knowing there, an assumption that underlies the geographical mindset of his times and
has not been entirely absent since.
As for the part of eastern Europe south of the Danube, Strabo makes a further sub-
division, treating the Dinaric Alps, the Balkans, and the Rhodope mountain range as
a continuous entity running from west to east parallel to the Danube. He announces
that he w ill first tackle the area within and north of the mountains (Slovenia, Croatia,
Bosnia-Herzegovina, Montenegro, Albania, North Macedonia, southern Serbia, Kosovo, Bulgaria,
southeastern Romania) but in the event he will go beyond his self-imposed remit by taking
his description of the Adriatic coast down to the Ceraunian mountains (southern Albania)
and his description of the Black Sea coast to Byzantium (Istanbul, Turkey) (4 and 5, on the
accompanying map).
Strabo then moves south of the mountains (6) and fills in the gap between the Medi-
terranean coastline and the Pontic sea (Black Sea). More precisely, although Strabo did fill
in this gap, most of what he wrote is now lost to us. This lost portion of Strabo’s narrative
is, in this translation, called the “eastern European gap” (329 C, 15—332 C, 1), the gap
between coastlines coinciding with an actual gap in the narrative. Only the beginning of
Strabo’s description of this part of the world survives, covering the initial stretch of the
Roman road called the Via Egnatia from its beginnings in Epidamnus (Durrës, Albania)
and Apollonia (Pojan, Albania). Strabo’s description of the subsequent stretches of this
road and his account of the surrounding territory and islands would—if we still had it—
have taken us as far as what Strabo calls “Thessalonicia” (Thessalonike/Salonica, Greece)
and Cypsela (?Ipsela, European Turkey).
After the “eastern European gap,” Strabo’s narrative resumes with his description
of Greece. Today, most commentators would probably not categorize Greece as part of
eastern Europe. In truth, Greece has been something of a moving target when it comes
to geopolitical categorization: a century ago, it was considered by Western commenta-
tors to be part of the “Middle East.” Despite Strabo’s explicit inclusion of Greece within
eastern Europe, he treats it at such length—devoting four times as many words to it as
to the rest of eastern E urope—that it is r eally in a class of its own. Strabo’s description of
Greece is, in this translation, given its own separate chapter (chapter 3.3).
342
Translator’s Introduction
the Black Sea, then switches south of the Danube to the mountainous area comprising the
Dinaric Alps and the Balkans. Strabo momentarily swoops down to earth in order to fol-
low the Adriatic coast as if voyaging along it; ditto the Black Sea coast. Switching to the
area south of the mountains, he again adopts a traveler’s point of view, as if journeying
along the Roman road—the Via Egnatia—from the Adriatic to the Aegaean.
As far as we can tell, none of this represents any actual voyage or overland journey
made by Strabo. His travels in eastern Europe appear to have been restricted to visiting
a few locations in Greece (which, as noted above, is given its own chapter in this transla-
tion), probably while journeying between Italy and what is now Turkey or between Italy
and Egypt. Just as is the case with western E urope, Strabo’s journey through eastern
Europe is an intellectual one, as he combs through the literature of the ancient world for
information relevant to his project, including information that we, from our twenty-first-
century standpoint, would consider to be beyond the purely geographical.
343
3.2. Eastern Europe
Remember
344
CH APT E R TH R E E Eastern Europe
PART 2
289 C, 1-7 I have described Iberia and also the Celtic and Italian na- 7.1.1
EASTERN EUROPE tions together with their nearby islands.1 What I should de-
n. Netherlands, Germany, Czech
Republic, Hungary, Slovenia,
scribe next, using the accepted method of division, are the
Croatia, Bosnia-Herzegovina, remaining parts of E urope.2 These remaining parts are the
Montenegro, Albania, Serbia,
Kosovo, N. Macedonia, Bulgaria, eastern ones: the parts beyond the Rhine, as far as the Tanaïs Tanaïs, Don r.
Romania, Moldova, Ukraine, and the mouth of lake Maeotis; and the parts—between the mouth of lake Maeotis, Straits
Crimea, Russia, Eur. Turkey, of Kerch'
Greece Adria and the Left-Hand Side of the Pontic sea3—which
Adria, Adriatic Sea
are south of the Ister, extending as far as Greece and the
Propontis. Propontis, Marmara Denizi
289 C, 7-21 The Ister divides very nearly all the said land area into two. Ister, Danube r.
Tyras and the Borysthenes, deviating a bit to the north. To Tyras, Dniester r.
the north of the Ister are the nations 4 beyond the Rhine and Borysthenes, Dnieper r.
[ 1 ] Iberia (+ islands): 136 C, 18–176 C, 8. Celtica beyond the Alps (+ islands of Bret- 17-32n; 541 C, 17-27n; 680 C, 25–681 C, 3n. The term is coined from the viewpoint
tanica, Ierne, and Thule): 176 C, 13–201 C, 26. Alps: 201 C, 31–209 C, 14. Italy (+ is- of a navigator sailing from the Med. Sea into the Black Sea (305 C, 25-31) and is
lands): 209 C, 15–288 C, 33. contrasted with the “Right-Hand Side of the Pontic sea” (126 C, 3-11n).
[ 2 ] I.e., “remaining” as per Strabo’s description of Europe at 126 C, 30–129 C, 9. These [ 4 ] Alternatively, “parts.”
“remaining parts” are eastern Europe (including Greece): 289 C, 7–489 C, 27. [ 5 ] Eastern Europe beyond (east of) Rhine and north of Ister (Danube r.): 290 C,
[ 3 ] “Left-Hand Side of the Pontic sea” (Black Sea coast of Eur. Tky., Bul., Rom., Ukr., 1–312 C, 28.
Crim., Russ.) as a technical term: 49 C, 32–50 C, 12n; 320 C, 29–321 C, 2n; 440 C, [ 6 ] Eastern E urope south of Ister (Danube r.): 312 C, 29–489 C, 27.
345
3.2. Eastern Europe, North of the Ister (Danube r.)
from its source to its outlets. This, the whole river valley, con-
stitutes more or less the width of the territory on the western width = north–south dimension
290 C, 17-25 The territory gets higher in the south and forms a sort of
mountain ridge following on from the Alps and extending
eastward, as if it w ere a part of the Alps. This is what some
people have claimed, on the grounds of its said orientation
and because it produces the same type of trees. However, the
parts h
ere do not achieve the same height. This is the location
of the Hercynian Forest and of the Suebian nations, some Hercynian Forest, mountainous
area from Black Forest to
of whom3 dwell within the forest—for example, the Quadian Carpathian mts.
nations, amongst whom is located Maroboduus’s royal capi- Buiaemum, Bohemia (Czech
Rep.)
tal, Buiaemum, whither Maroboduus transferred several na-
Maroboduus relocated
tions including the Marcomannians, of the same nationality Marcomannians, ca. 9 BCE; he
as himself. was overthrown, 18 CE
346
From the Rhine to the Elbe
291 C, 17-22 Knowledge was gained about these nations 2 as they en- 7.1.4
[ 1 ] See 290 C, 17-25n. As he often does, Strabo elaborates on, rather than merely
repeats, his earlier statement.
[ 2 ] I.e., the nations listed at 290 C, 8–291 C, 10.
347
3.2. Eastern Europe, North of the Ister (Danube r.)
peaceably outside the Elbe w ere left alone rather than spurred
into action by a shared hostility.
291 C, 23–292 C, 10 The Sugambrians, who lived close to the Rhine, started Sugambrians, n. present-day
Germany
the war under the leadership of Maelo. From there, different
people ended up taking over the war at diff erent times as they
rose to power and fell from it, then rebelled again, forfeiting
their hostages and renouncing their pledges. The best policy
has been to avoid putting any trust in them. T hose who w ere
trusted did the greatest damage—for example, the Cherus- Cheruscians destroyed Roman
legions u
nder command of
cians and those subject to them, who treacherously ambushed Quintilius Varus, 9 CE
and destroyed three Roman legions and their general, Quin-
tilius Varus. All of them paid the price, providing the youn
ger Germanicus with a spectacular triumph.1 Individuals Germanicus campaigned
against Germans, 14–16 CE;
from among their most illustrious men and women were in celebrated a triumph, 17 CE
the procession: the Cheruscian leader Segimuntus (son of Se-
gestes); his s ister, Thusnelda by name (wife of Arminius, who
was the military commander of the Cheruscians in their act of
treachery against Quintilius Varus, and who is continuing the
fight even now),2 and her three-year-old son, Thumelicus;
furthermore, Sesithacus (son of the Cheruscian leader Segi-
merus) and his wife, Ramis (daughter of the Chattian leader
Veromerus); Deudorix (son of Maelo’s brother, Baetorix), a
Sugambrian. Segestes (father-in-law of Arminius) was op-
posed from the outset to Arminius’s policy and changed sides
when the opportunity arose; he was an honored guest at the
parade of his closest relatives. Libes, the Chattian priest, took
part in the procession. Also paraded w ere other individu-
als from the decimated nations—Caulcians, Campsanians,
Bructerians, Usipians, Cheruscians, Chattians, Chattuarians,
Landians, and Tubantians. |
292 C, 11-16 The Rhine–Elbe distance is around three thousand stades, 7.1.5
source of the Rhine, and the lake between them both, and lake = Bodensee/Constance l.
(Ger., Swi., Aus.)
the marshes spreading out from the Rhine. The lake is more
348
From the Rhine to the Elbe
349
3.2. Eastern Europe, North of the Ister (Danube r.)
after them, meaning “Cimbrian” Bosporus (“Cimmerians” being the Cimmerian Bosporus, Straits
of Kerch'
Greek name for the “Cimbrians”). He says that Boïans were for-
merly living in the Hercynian Forest; the Cimbrians launched an at- Hercynian Forest, mountainous
area from Black Forest to
tack against this place but were repulsed by the Boïans and retreated Carpathian mts.
to the Ister and the Scordiscan Galatians, then to the Teuristians
and Tauriscans (who were also Galatians), then to the Helvettians.
The Helvettians were rich but peaceable. Yet, when they saw that
the wealth attained through raiding was in excess of what they had,
they were so inflamed (particularly the Tigyrenans and the Toygen-
ans) that they joined the invaders. They were all of them—the
Cimbrians and their allies—destroyed by the Romans, some
when they crossed the Alps into Italy, some when they were beyond the Alps = north of
beyond the Alps. | the Alps
294 C, 4-14 People describe the following custom among the 7.2.3
350
North of Lower Danube
from earlier times made the voyage east along the coast to
the mouth of the Caspian sea; 2 no Roman has yet proceeded
into the farther regions on the other side of the Elbe; nor has
anyone made the journey by foot. It is, however, clear from
the climata and parallel distances,3 that (going lengthwise lengthwise = from west to east
to the east) one links up with the Borysthenes region and Borysthenes region, Ukraine,
s. Russia
with places to the north of the Pontus. It is not easy to say
Pontus = Black Sea
what lies beyond Germany and its neighbors,4 whether one
should speak of Bastarnians, as several people suppose, or
whether t here are o
thers—Iazyges, Rhoxolanians, or other
hamaxoeci (wagon-dwellers)—who come in between. Nor is it easy
to say whether they extend as far as the ocean for the entire
length, nor whether there is some part where life is impos- length = west–east dimension
sible b
ecause of the frigid climate, or for some other reason,
nor even whether there is some other race of men between
the sea and the eastern Germans. This same ignorance about
the other northern nations that come next . . . *: we do not
know how far the Bastarnians or Sauromatians (or t hose liv-
ing above the Pontus in general) are from the Atlantic sea nor Atlantic sea = supposed
northern ocean
even w hether they reach it. |
mountain slopes of the Hercynian Forest and, in fact, occupy- mountain slopes of Hercynian
Forest = Carpathian mts.
ing a part of the mountains; then it broadens out northward
as far as the Tyregetans. Tyregetans, Moldova, Ukraine
[ 1 ] 291 C, 7-10, with expanded comments on Sugambrians (291 C, 23–292 C, 10) and
Cimbrians (292 C, 33–294 C, 14).
[ 2 ] One might ask on what basis Strabo thinks that the journey to the northern
end of the Caspian sea constitutes a “voyage,” given his acknowledgment that
no one has made such a journey. Strabo believes that the Eurasian landmass is
limited in its northward extension and is thus predisposed to assume that such
a voyage is possible.
[ 3 ] For the climata and parallel distances: 131 C, 26–135 C, 22.
[ 4 ] See 306 C, 13-33.
[ 5 ] Getans (including Mysians/Moesians): 295 C, 16–305 C, 22.
351
3.2. Eastern Europe, North of the Ister (Danube r.)
and conveyed beyond the Sea to the very ends of the earth, / to the Sea = Black Sea (in Strabo’s
understanding of Sophocles’s
sources of the night, where heaven unfurls, / to the ancient garden of lines)
Phoebus, these lines would be irrelevant to the m atter in hand
Phaedrus, written by Plato (late and should be ignored (as by Socrates in the Phaedrus). But
5th–early 4th c. BCE)
what we have learned from history, ancient and modern,1 this
is what we should stick to. |
295 C, 16-22 The Greeks supposed that the Getans were Thracian. 7.3.2
These people used to live on either side of the Ister, as did Ister, Danube r.
far distance at the land of the horse-loving Thracians / and of the he (turned back his shining
eyes) = Zeus
combative Mysians,” since if the reference were to the Asian Mysians,
the statement would be nonsense. Only someone who had mixed statement = by Homer
up their continents and ignored the context would, with re
Posidonius (or Strabo) spect to the turning back of the gaze away from the Trojans toward
paraphrases Homer
the land of the Thracians, connect with the latter the land of
those Mysians who are not in the far distance but border on
the Troad, who are situated beyond and on either side of the
Troad, and who are divided from Thrace by the broad Hel-
lespont. The phrase turned back specifically means “reversed,”
whereas to turn the gaze away from the Trojans toward “those
beyond” or “on the sides” would be to move the gaze “farther
forward”—not at all to “reverse” it!
295 C, 36–296 C, 7 Evidence for this point of view is provided by what
follows,5 given that he connected with them the hippemolgi he = Homer
[ 1 ] Ancient history: 295 C, 16–303 C, 32. Modern history: 303 C, 33–305 C, 15.
[ 2 ] “They” are Latin speakers; Strabo transliterates into Greek the Latin ethnic
name Moesi. When Strabo is writing, the Romans have incorporated the Moe-
sians/Mysians into the Roman province called Moesia: 303 C, 19-31n; 541 C,
28–542 C, 4n. Strabo’s transliteration of Latin names: 508 C, 10-18n.
[ 3 ] I.e., the Asian Mysians (sw. Turkey): 571 C, 17–581 C, 1. Cf. 586 C, 17-22; 612 C, 8-14;
613 C, 29–614 C, 4; 615 C, 18-27; 625 C, 16–626 C, 10; 628 C, 8–629 C, 11; 677 C,
33–678 C, 16.
[ 4 ] Strabo’s support for identification of Homer’s “Mysians” with European Mysians:
295 C, 36–303 C, 32.
[ 5 ] I.e., what “follows” in Homer’s Iliad, the relevant lines of which are quoted by
Strabo at 300 C, 1-6 (and by Posidonius at 296 C, 8-19).
352
North of Lower Danube
also those within the Ister, among whom also live Celtic within Ister = south of Danube r.
Posidonius (late 2nd–1st c. BCE) their piety (even from domesticated animals, for the same reason);
they live peaceably, on a diet of honey, milk, and cheese, on which
account they are called “theosebeis” (god-fearing) and “capnobatae”
(smoke-walkers); there are some Thracians who live without w omen, and
these are called “ctistes” (founders); they are dedicated to the gods as a
mark of honor and live their lives in immunity; these are all collec-
Posidonius cites Homer (8th c. tively referred to by the poet as “the glorious hippemolgi (mare-milkers),
BCE)
galactophagi (milk-eaters), and abii (without-lives), most just of men”;
he calls them “abii” mostly b ecause of their separation from w omen,
considering that a life bereft of women is incomplete (as in the “in-
complete” h ouse of the bereft Protesilaus), and he calls the Mysians
“combative” because, like good warriors, they are unconquered; one
should, in the thirteenth book, write “combative Moesians” rather
than “[combative] Mysians.” |
296 C, 20-22 Alteration of the wording after it has been accepted for 7.3.4
353
3.2. Eastern Europe, North of the Ister (Danube r.)
354
North of Lower Danube
know their Greek material but are grossly ignorant of faraway places,
having no knowledge of long overland journeys and no knowledge of
sea expeditions.
298 C, 19–299 C, 12 To prove this case, he says that Homer calls Aulis “rocky” (as he (says) = Apollodorus (citing
Eratosthenes)
indeed it is), Eteonus “multi-ridged,” Thisbe “dove-rich,” Haliartus
“grassy,” but neither he nor other poets know about faraway places. (neither) he = Homer
He does not mention even the most famous of the forty or so rivers
Borysthenes, Dnieper r. flowing into the Pontus—the Ister, Tanaïs, Borysthenes, Hypanis, Pontus, Black Sea
Hypanis, Bug r. Phasis, Thermodon,4 and Halys. Furthermore, he does not mention Ister, Danube r.
Phasis, Rioni r. the Scythians but invents some “glorious hippemolgi” (mare-milkers), Tanaïs, Don r.
Halys, Kızıl Irmak some “galactophagi” (milk-eaters) and “abii” (without-lives). He has re-
corded what he has learned about the inland Paphlagonians from
those who approached these areas overland but has no knowledge of
the coast, as is to be expected, given that this sea was at that time this sea = Black Sea
unexplored and was called “Axenus” (Unfriendly) because of its storms
and because of the ferocity of the nations living around it (particu-
larly the Scythians, who sacrificed strangers, ate their flesh, and used
their skulls as drinking cups), and was only called “Euxine” (Friendly)
later on, a fter the Ionians had founded cities along its coast. He is
similarly ignorant of matters associated with Egypt and Libya—for Libya = Africa
example, the flooding of the Nile and the silting up of the sea, neither isthmus between Erythra and
Egyptian sea, Isthmus of Suez
of which he mentions, and likewise ignorant of the isthmus between the (Egy.)
[ 1 ] The same Greek word (theos) is used by Strabo for the “god” who was the ad-
viser to the Getan king and for the “deified” Caesar in the following sentence.
[ 2 ] 295 C, 22–298 C, 12.
[ 3 ] About the Ships is the name of a commentary by Apollodorus on the part of
Homer’s Iliad traditionally referred to by the “title” Catalogue of Ships or simply
Ships. Cf. 4 C, 14-20n.
[ 4 ] The Thermodon (Terme Çay, Tky.) is not a very significant river. Apollodorus
may h ere be repeating Eratosthenes’s conflation of the Thermodon with the
Lycus (Kelkit Çay, Tky.): 529 C, 11-30.
355
3.2. Eastern Europe, North of the Ister (Danube r.)
Erythra and the Egyptian sea and of matters in Arabia and Ethiopia
Zeno (4th–3rd c. BCE) and on the ocean (unless consideration be given to Zeno, the
philosopher, when he writes “I came to the Ethiopians, the
Sidonians, and the Arabs”).1 This is not surprising in Homer’s
case, since even t hose more recent than him are ignorant of many
Hesiod (late 8th–7th c. BCE) things and invent wonders, Hesiod speaking of “hemicynes” (men-who-
Alcman (7th c. BCE) are-half-dog), “megalocephali” (big-headed men), and Pygmies; Alcman
299 C, 12-18 From these, he proceeds against writers who speak of the he = Apollodorus (citing
Eratosthenes)
“Rhipaean mountains,” the “Ogyian mountain,” the home of the
Theopompus (4th c. BCE) “Gorgons” and of the “Hesperides”; Theopompus’s “Meropian
Hecataeus (late 4th–early 3rd c. country”; Hecataeus’s city of “Cimmeris”; Euhemerus’s “Panchaean
BCE)
country” . . . * river stones that are made of sand and dissolve in the
Euhemerus (4th–3rd c. BCE)
rain, and the existence in Libya of a “Dionysus City,” which it is not Libya = Africa
possible for one man to find twice over.
299 C, 19-23 He takes issue with those who locate in Sicily the wander- He = Apollodorus
[ 1 ] I.e., in editing the Odyssey, Zeno (4th–3rd c. BCE) replaces “Erembians” with
“Arabs”: 784 C, 12-30.
[ 2 ] Greeks often pointed to (or fabricated) local place-names in order to lay claim
to mythological figures: e.g., “Gerenian” Nestor (339 C, 31–340 C, 5; 353 C, 10-12).
[ 3 ] Strabo’s disagreement with Eratosthenes’s criticisms of Homer: 15 C, 26–48 C,
28. Apollodorus’s support of Eratosthenes’s criticisms: 298 C, 13-19; 44 C, 25-34.
[ 4 ] The expression “detailed description”: 104 C, 1-5n.
[ 5 ] The “general overview” is the opening section of Strabo’s narrative (chap. 1 in
this translation), within which he deals extensively with arguments concerning
the reliability of Homer: 15 C, 26–48 C, 28.
356
North of Lower Danube
300 C, 6-10 The first point is that they have proved the opposite of they = Eratosthenes
+ Apollodorus
what was proposed. They proposed to show that men of an-
cient times displayed greater ignorance of places faraway from
Greece than men of modern times, but they in fact showed
the opposite, not only in regard to faraway places but also
to places in Greece itself. (However, as I said, let t hese other
arguments be put aside for the time being and let me concen-
trate on the m atter in hand.)2
300 C, 10-14 They claim that, because of his ignorance, he does not mention he = Homer
the Scythians nor the ferocity toward strangers (whom they sacrificed,
whose flesh they ate, and whose skulls they used as drinking cups) of
these p eople, on account of whom the Pontus was called “Axenus” (Un- Pontus, Black Sea
Hesiod (late 8th–7th c. BCE) (mare-milkers) is attested by Hesiod in the lines that Eratosthenes
Eratosthenes (3rd c. BCE) cites, Ethiopians, Ligyans, and the hippemolgi (mare-milking) Scyth-
ians. Is it surprising if, on account of the increase among us
of fraudulent contracts, he called most just of men those who he = Homer
357
3.2. Eastern Europe, North of the Ister (Danube r.)
Homer (8th c. BCE) those chronologically close to Homer, w ere of the type—and
were assumed by the Greeks to be of the type—described by
Herodotus (5th c. BCE) Homer. See what Herodotus says about the Scythian king
against whom Darius campaigned and the king’s reply. See, Darius, Persian king,
campaigned against Scythians,
Chrysippus (3rd c. BCE) too, what Chrysippus says about the kings of Bosporus as- 513/512 BCE
sociated with Leuco.2 The Persian letters, as also the remi- Bosporus = kingdom on e ither
niscences of Egyptians, Babylonians, and Indians, are full of side of Straits of Kerch'
within it (while the Getans lived on its far side); that he got that
far but was not able to disembark on the island because of a lack
of landing craft (the Triballian king, Syrmus, who had taken
refuge there, obstructed the endeavor); that he nevertheless
crossed over to the Getans, seized their city, and quickly re-
turned home, bringing gifts from the nations and from Syrmus.
301 C, 29–302 C, 4 Ptolemy (son of Lagus) says that, during this campaign, the
Ptolemy (late 4th–early 3rd c. Celts from the Adria region had meetings with Alexander to estab- Adria, Adriatic Sea
BCE)
lish friendship and hospitable relations; the king, receiving them in
[ 1 ] 301 C, 2-4.
[ 2 ] “Kings . . . associated with Leuco” is idiomatic, meaning predominantly Leuco.
358
North of Lower Danube
style and their nonuse of money, they are orderly in their internal
relations (since they share all t hings with each other, including wives,
children, and the whole f amily) and yet not belligerent in their ex-
ternal relations and not subject to aggression (since they possess noth-
ing on account of which outsiders would try to enslave them). He
[ 1 ] “Titles” are often used for subsections of larger works, as by Strabo himself:
639 C, 15-27n.
359
3.2. Eastern Europe, North of the Ister (Danube r.)
Choerilus (5th c. BCE) cites in support Choerilus for his reference, in the “Crossing of the
pontoon bridge” (which bridge was constructed by Darius), to “the
sheep-tending Sacans, Scythian by descent, dwelling / in wheat-rich
Asia—they w ere colonists from the nomads, / men of righteousness.”
303 C, 8-18 Calling Anacharsis a wise man, Ephorus says that he be-
Ephorus (4th c. BCE) longed to this race and was considered one of the Seven Wise Men
because of his frugality, self-discipline, and sagacity. He says, his
inventions included the bellows, the double anchor, and the potter’s
wheel. I mention these things in the clear realization that this this fellow = Ephorus
fellow does not tell the utter truth in all m atters—and does not
do so in the case of Anacharsis! How can the potter’s wheel be
Homer (8th c. BCE) Anacharsis’s invention, when it is known by Homer, who lived
much earlier (as when a potter takes the wheel in his hands, and so
on)? However, I mention these t hings b ecause I want to make
it clear that there has been a belief, among men of long ago as
well as men of more recent times, based on widespread report,
that those nomads who are farthest removed from other men
are galactophagi (milk-eaters) and abii (without-lives) and most just—
this is not just a fiction created by Homer. |
303 C, 19-31 As for the Mysians, Apollodorus should rightly explain 7.3.10
Apollodorus (2nd c. BCE) what is meant in the lines.1 Does he consider these people, too,
poet = Homer (8th c. BCE) to be a fiction, when the poet refers to the combative Mysians
and the glorious hippemolgi (mare-milkers)? Or does he take them as
being the Mysians in Asia? If he takes them to be the Mysians
in Asia, he misinterprets the poet, as discussed.2 If he says
they are a fiction, on the grounds that there are no Mysians
in Thrace, he contradicts the facts. At least, in our own times,
Aelius Catus transferred,3 from the far side of the Ister, fifty Roman general Aelius Catus
transferred Getans from north
thousand persons from among the Getans (a nation with the side of Ister (Danube r.) to
same language as the Thracians) into Thrace, and they now south side
[ 1 ] Strabo returns to his initial point, the identity of Homer’s Mysians in the lines
cited at 295 C, 22-36.
[ 2 ] 295 C, 22–303 C, 18.
[ 3 ] The transference took place at some point between the year in which Aelius
Catus held the consulship at Rome (4 CE) and the date on which Strabo writes
these words (probably 18/19 CE).
[ 4 ] Strabo transliterates into Greek the Latin ethnic name Moesi. The same trans-
literation is made at 295 C, 16-22; 541 C, 28–542 C, 4. Strabo’s transliteration of
Latin names: 508 C, 10-18n.
[ 5 ] Strabo resumes the thread of narrative from 295 C, 4-15.
360
North of Lower Danube
and the sources of the Ister, and I suspect that in antiquity Ister, Danube r.
they were called “Daoi.” This would explain why, among the
Attic writers, there were many “Getans” and “Daoi” as slave
names.5 This is more probable than that they are from the
Scythians, whom they call “Daans”6—for the latter are far Daans, peoples in Turkmenistan
361
3.2. Eastern Europe, North of the Ister (Danube r.)
305 C, 2-11 The Dacians use the same language as the Getans. The
Getans are better known to the Greeks because they are con-
stantly migrating across the Ister and have intermingled with
the Thracians and Mysians. The Triballian nation (also being
Thracian) has undergone the same process and has been sub-
jected to relocations, as neighbors force weaker neighbors to
move on. The Scythians, Bastarnians, and Sauromatians from Scythians + Sauromatians,
Ukraine, Russia
the other side of the river are often so dominant that they even
Bastarnians, Moldova, Ukraine
cross the river in pursuit of those who have been driven out
and stay (some of them) on the islands or in Thrace. Those
in the other direction are subject to the excessive strength of
the Illyrians.
305 C, 11-15 Although the Getans and Dacians increased their power
very greatly (so much so that they could dispatch armies of
two hundred thousand men), the number they can now mus-
ter is some forty thousand.2 They have all but submitted to
the Romans but are not quite yet u nder complete control,3
having high hopes for Rome’s enemies, the Germans. |
[ 1 ] “They” are Latin speakers; Strabo transliterates into Greek the Latin name
Danuvius. Strabo’s transliteration of Latin names: 508 C, 10-18n.
[ 2 ] Strabo refines his earlier statement (304 C, 27-29, where he implies that the
Dacians alone can muster forty thousand men).
[ 3 ] For the sense of imminent capitulation to the Romans: 288 C, 16-23.
[ 4 ] The “native” is shorthand for the “native king,” i.e., Dromichaetes.
[ 5 ] 302 C, 4-12.
362
Pontic Coast + Hinterland
here are other islands that are much smaller, some upriver
T
from Peuca and some t oward the sea.
305 C, 25-31 The Ister has seven mouths. The largest one is called the Ister, Danube r.
the coast in the direction of the Tyras. The seventh mouth is Tyras, Dniester r.
dred stades (in the intervening stretch, t here are two huge
lakes, one opening into the sea and used as a harbor, the other
having no outlet). | At the mouth of the Tyras is a tower called 7.3.16
Ophiussa. (If you go overland, it is one hundred and twenty Ophiussa, Belgorod-
Dnestrovskiy (Ukr.)
stades, according to those who live on the river.) From the
river mouth, it is a crossing of five hundred stades to the is-
land of Leuca, lying in the open sea and sacred to Achilles. | Leuca, Zmeinyi (Ukr.)
306 C, 9-13 Then, after six hundred stades, is the Borysthenes (a navi- Borysthenes, Dnieper r. 7.3.17
gable river); nearby, t here’s another river, the Hypanis, and Hypanis, Bug r.
an island (at the mouth of the Borysthenes) with a harbor. If Borysthenes (island), Berezan'
(Ukr.)
you sail up the Borysthenes for two hundred stades, t here’s
a city with the same name as the river—this same city is also Borysthenes (city)/Olbia,
Parutino (Ukr.)
called “Olbia”—a great entrepôt, founded by the Milesians.
306 C, 13-17 As for all the territory lying inland from the said stretch 2
between the Borysthenes and the Ister: first,3 there’s the
Getan desert; then come the Tyregetans, and after them, the Getan desert, Ukraine
Iazygian Sarmatians, t hose who are called the Basilii (Royals), Tyregetans, Iazygian
Sarmatians, etc., n. Romania,
and the Urgians. For the most part these are nomads, but a Moldova, Ukraine
few of them practice agriculture. (It is said that t hese latter
live mostly alongside the Ister, often on both sides.)
306 C, 17-21 As for the interior, t here are the Bastarnians, bordering on Bastarnians, Moldova, Ukraine
[ 1 ] The viewpoint is that of a navigator sailing from the Med. Sea. The “Left-Hand
Side of the Pontus” (Black Sea coast of Eur. Tky., Bul., Rom., Ukr., Crim., Russ.) as
a technical term: 289 C, 1-7n.
[ 2 ] 305 C, 25–306 C, 13.
[ 3 ] I.e., “first” if starting from the mouth of the Ister (Danube r.).
363
3.2. Eastern Europe, North of the Ister (Danube r.)
stock. They are divided into several tribes: some are called
“Atmonians” and “Sidonians”; those occupying the island of
Peuca in the Ister are called “Peucinians.” Ister, Danube r.
306 C, 21-24 Farthest north, inhabiting the plains between the Tanaïs Tanaïs, Don r.
and the Borysthenes, are the Rhoxolanians. The entire area Borysthenes, Dnieper r.
to the north, from Germany to the Caspian, consists of plains, Rhoxolanians, Ukraine, Russia
the Borysthenes and the mouth of the Maeotis, has bitter Borysthenes, Dnieper r.
winters, as do the most northerly parts of the coast itself— mouth of Maeotis, Straits of
Kerch'
the mouth of the Maeotis, and even more so the mouth of the
Borysthenes and the innermost recess of the Tamyracan (or Tamyracan/Carcinitian bay,
Karkinitsky bay
“Carcinitian”) bay, which is the location of the isthmus of the
Great Cherronesus, Crimea Great Cherronesus.
307 C, 10-14 An indication of the cold is that, even though people live
on the plains, they do not breed asses (since this animal is
sensitive to the cold); as for the c attle, while some are born
without horns, people file off the horns of o thers (since this
is the part that is sensitive to the cold); their horses are small,
their sheep and goats are large; bronze water vessels shatter,
and their contents freeze.
[ 1 ] The area “from Germany to the Caspian” (e. Germany, Poland, Belarus,
w. Ukraine, s. Russia),” unvisited by Greeks or Romans, is assumed to represent
the northern limit of the lived-in world: 294 C, 15-34.
[ 2 ] I.e., Getans, Tyregetans, Sarmatian Iazyges, Basilii, Urgians, Bastarnians, as
noted at 306 C, 13-21.
364
Cherronesus, Maeotic Coast + Hinterland
comes next as you sail east is the headland of Achilles’s Race- Achilles’s Racecourse,
Tendrovskaya Kosa (Ukr.)
course1—a place that is treeless, although called a “grove,” and
is sacred to Achilles—then the low-lying peninsula of Achil-
les’s Racecourse itself. This is a ribbonlike strip some one
thousand stades in length, going eastward; it has a maximum
breadth of two stades, a minimum of four plethra; it is sixty 1 plethrum = 100 ft.; 6 plethra =
1 stade
stades away from the mainland on either side of the neck; it
is sandy, and water can be obtained by digging. (The neck,
measuring some forty stades, is located at its midpoint.) It
ends in a headland, which is called “Tamyraca,” with an an- Tamyraca headland,
Dzharylgach (Ukr.)
chorage facing the mainland, after which is the huge Carcini-
Carcinitian [Tamyracan] bay,
tian bay, extending northward for some one thousand stades Karkinitsky bay
(some say three times that distance to its innermost point).
308 C, 5-6 . . . * are called “Taphrians.” People also call the bay Taphrians = inhabitants of
Taphrus, Perekop (Crim.)
“Tamyraca,” the same name as for the headland. |
365
3.2. Eastern Europe, North of the Ister (Danube r.)
stades. It is the western part of the Maeotis, with which it is Maeotis, Sea of Azov
of the bay), t here’s a small town, Calus Limen (Fine harbor). It be- Calus Limen, Chernomorskoye
(Crim.)
longs to the Cherronesitians. For, on the next stretch of coast,
there’s a huge southward-protruding headland,2 part of the
overall Cherronesus, and on it is situated a city belonging to Cherronesus (city), nr.
Sebastopol (Crim.)
the Heracleotes, a colony of the Heracleotes in Pontus,3 which
bears the same name, “Cherronesus.” It is four thousand four
hundred stades away from the Tyras, as measured along the Tyras, Dniester r.
the natives, was forced to take as its protector Mithridates Mithridates Eupator
campaigned in the area, late
Eupator, who was leading a campaign against the natives on 2nd c. BCE
the far side of the isthmus,7 as far as the Borysthenes and the Borysthenes, Dnieper r.
Adria. This was preparatory to an attack against the Romans. Adria, Adriatic Sea
Because he entertained these hopes, he gladly sent an army
to the Cherronesus and fought a simultaneous war against
the Scythians, and against Scilurus and Scilurus’s sons—those
associated with Palacus—of whom there w ere fifty according
366
Cherronesus, Maeotic Coast + Hinterland
vides the Euxine ocean into two seas by narrowing the strait Euxine ocean, Black Sea
city of Theodosia with its fertile plain and its harbor— Theodosia, Feodosiya (Crim.)
309 C, 33–310 C, 10 Panticapaeum is a hill, inhabited all around for a distance Panticapaeum, Kerch' (Crim.)
of twenty stades. It has a harbor to the east and docks for some
367
3.2. Eastern Europe, North of the Ister (Danube r.)
and its mouth. It has two outlets into the lake, some sixty
stades apart from each other. T here is a city with the same Tanaïs (city), Nedvigovka (Russ.)
368
Cherronesus, Maeotic Coast + Hinterland
310 C, 30–311 C, 7 The Great Cherronesus resembles the Peloponnese in Great Cherronesus, Crimea
shape and size. It is in the possession of the dynasts of Bos- Bosporus = kingdom on e ither
side of Straits of Kerch'
porus, and it has all been devastated by incessant wars. Pre-
viously, the dynasts held only the small part by the mouth
of the Maeotis and Panticapaeum as far as Theodosia. The Theodosia, Feodosiya (Crim.)
stretch along the coast as far as Theodosia, all the rest is level
and has fertile soil. It is particularly favorable for growing
grain. Furrowed with the simplest plowshare, it yields thir-
tyfold. The people, together with the Asian localities in the
Sindica region, paid to Mithridates a tax of one hundred and
eighty thousand medimni and two hundred talents of silver. medimnus, largest volume
measure in Greek metrical
In earlier times, the grain supply for the Greeks came from system
there, just as their supply of pickled fish came from the lake. talent, largest unit in Greek
It is said that Leuco sent two million one hundred thousand system of weights
369
3.2. Eastern Europe
both “just” and abii (without-lives), since if the tributes were paid
regularly, they would not resort to war.
311 C, 27-31 Tribute is not paid by t hose who rely on military strength
to ward off attackers with ease or to prevent attacks. Such
Hypsicrates (1st c. BCE) was the case, Hypsicrates tells us, with Asander: he erected a Asander usurped kingdom of
Bosporus, 47/46 BCE
wall, three hundred and sixty stades long,1 across the isthmus
of the Cherronesus toward the Maeotis and put up ten towers Maeotis, Sea of Azov
[ 1 ] Strabo perhaps corrects his e arlier statement (308 C, 7-10, where he cites some
people as giving 360 stades for a different isthmus, the isthmus (Perekop) sepa-
rating Cherronesus from the mainland).
[ 2 ] 308 C, 15–310 C, 24.
370
South of the Danube
312 C, 29–313 C, 4 The part of E urope that remains 2 is the portion inside the inside Ister = south of Danube r. 7.5.1
Ister and the encircling sea, starting from the Adriatic re-
Strabo segues from his cess and going as far as the Sacred Mouth of the Ister. Con-
description of Europe north of
Danube r. to his description of tained within this portion are Greece; the Macedonian and
Europe south of Danube Epirote nations; the nations above these reaching the Ister
and the Adriatic and Pontic seaboards on either side (i.e.,
the Illyrians on the Adriatic seaboard, the Thracians on the
Propontis, Marmara Denizi
other seaboard as far as the Propontis and the Hellespont, Hellespont, dardanelles/
and w hatever Scythian or Celtic nations are mixed in with Çanakkale Boğazı
them).3
313 C, 5-12 I should start at the Ister, describing the parts that follow on Ister, Danube r.
SOUTH OF THE DANUBE from those places through which I have already passed 4—that
Slovenia, Croatia, Bosnia-
Herzegovina, Montenegro, is, the parts next to Italy, the Alps, Germans, Dacians, and Ge-
Serbia, Kosovo, w. Hungary, tans. One could further divide these parts into two. Parallel
Bulgaria, se. Romania, European
Turkey, North Macedonia, with the Ister are the Illyrian, Paeonian, and Thracian moun-
Albania, Greece
tains, which form a more or less single line from the Adria to Adria, Adriatic Sea
the Pontus. North of this line are the parts between the Ister Pontus, Black Sea
and these mountains, whereas to the south are Greece and the
barbarian country adjacent to it and stretching as far as the
mountains.5
313 C, 12-19 On the side t oward the Pontus is the Haemus mountain Haemus, Balkan mts.
ILLYRIAN, PAEONIAN, range, the largest and highest in that region, dividing Thrace
THRACIAN MOUNTAINS
Dinaric Alps, Balkans, Rhodope roughly through the middle. Polybius says that both seas can
Polybius (2nd c. BCE) be seen from it,6 but he does not speak the truth (the distance
to the Adria is g reat, and t here are many t hings in the way). Adria, Adriatic Sea
[ 1 ] 290 C, 1–312 C, 26. [ 5 ] North of Illyrian, Paeonian, Thracian mountains (Slovenia, Croatia, w. Hungary,
[ 2 ] I.e., “remains” as per Strabo’s general definition of Europe (126 C, 30–129 C, 9) Bosnia-Herzegovina, Montenegro, Albania, Serbia, Kosovo, Bulgaria, se. Roma-
and as per his specific definition of eastern Europe (289 C, 1-21). nia): 313 C, 12–321 C, 2. South of mountains, “barbarian country” (Albania, N.
[ 3 ] Greece: 332 C, 1–489 C, 27. Macedonian, Epirote nations: 321 C, 23–332 C, 1. Illyr- Macedonia, s. Bulgaria, n. Greece): 321 C, 3–332 C, 1. Greece: 332 C, 1–489 C, 27.
ians, Thracians, Scythians, Celts: 313 C, 12–321 C, 2. [ 6 ] Strabo later seems to attribute this statement to Theopompus, implying that
[ 4 ] 201 C, 27–305 C, 15. Polybius cited Theopompus in order to criticize him: 317 C, 7-15n. The seas in
question are probably the Adriatic and the Aegean.
371
3.2. Eastern Europe, South of the Ister (Danube r.)
Ardia. In the middle is Paeonia, all of it at high elevation. As Ardia, Dinaric Alps
for either side of it, on the Thracian side is Rhodope (a high Paeonia, N. Macedonia
mountain range on the border, coming after Haemus); the Rhodope, Rhodope mts. (n.
Greece, s. Bulgaria)
other side, to the north, is Illyrian—the territory of the Au-
tariatae and Dardania.1
313 C, 19-22 Let me describe first the parts of Illyria that reach as far
ILLYRIA as the Ister and as far as t hose Alps that lie between Italy and
w. Hungary, Slovenia, Croatia,
Bosnia-Herzegovina, Monten
Germany, and which start with the lake in the region of the lake = Bodensee/Constance l.
(Ger., Swi., Aus.)
egro, Albania, Serbia, Kosovo Vindolicians, Rhaetians and . . . *. |
313 C, 23-29 A portion of this territory was devastated by the Dacians 7.5.2
313 C, 29–314 C, 5 The Pannonians hold the rest as far as Segestica and the Segestica, Sisak (Cro.)
Ister to the north and east; and for a considerable extent in the Ister, Danube r.
use the pass over Ocra, is a distance of three hundred and fifty Ocra, Nanos mt. (Svn.)
314 C, 9-14 Near Nauportus, there’s a river, the Corcoras, to which Corcoras, Krka r.
the goods are taken. This river joins the Savus, which joins Savus, Sava r.
the Dravus, which joins the Noarus at Segestica. From there, Dravus, Drava r.
372
Adriatic Coast + Hinterland
Calapis (which flows down past the Iapodes from the Albian Calapis, Kupa r.
country, falling between the sea and the Pannonian nations. Rhizonian gulf, Gulf of Kotor
(Mont.)
This should more or less mark the start of the next part of
my narrative journey, recapitulating a few of the things men-
tioned earlier.
314 C, 24-30 I said, in my descriptive journey through Italy,2 that the
people who come first on the Illyrian coastline (following
on from Italy and the Carnians) are the Istrians and that our Istrians, ne. Italy, w. Slovenia,
nw. Croatia
current-day leaders have moved the Italian boundary forward
to Pola, an Istrian city.3 These people are around eight hun- Pola, Pula (Cro.)
dred stades from the recess. (It is the same number of stades
from the headland at Pola to Ancon, keeping Enetia on your Ancon, Ancona (It.)
the Iapodian coast. The Iapodes are settled on the Albian Albian mountain range, Sneznik
(Svn.)
mountain range, which is the last part of the Alps and very
Metulum, Vinicica, nr. Ogulin
high; they extend on the one side to the Pannonians and the (Cro.)
Ister, and on the other side to the Adria. They are maniacal Arupini, Prozor (Cro.)
fighters but have been completely worn down by Augustus. Monetium, Brinje (Cro.)
Their cities are Metulum, Arupini, Monetium, and Vendon. Vendon, Crkvina, nr. Brlog (Cro.)
Since their territories are of poor quality, their diet consists
[ 1 ] In this paragraph, Strabo emends many statements made earlier (207 C, 26-33),
but he also introduces new errors.
[ 2 ] Strabo elaborates on earlier statements (215 C, 30–216 C, 10, and 209 C, 15–210 C,
8, where he makes no explicit reference to the boundary change).
[ 3 ] The boundary may have been changed by Tiberius as a young man when,
under the command of Augustus, he was fighting the Alpine tribes above Pola:
206 C, 13-28. The term “leaders”: 159 C, 19-28n.
373
3.2. Eastern Europe, South of the Ister (Danube r.)
315 C, 7-10 Along the whole coastline that I mentioned 1 are is- 7.5.5
lands . . . * the Apsyrtides, in which region Medea is said Apsyrtides, Cres + Lošinj (Cro.
islands)
to have killed her brother (Apsyrtus) when he pursued her;
then Cyrictica, opposite the Iapodes; then the Libyrnides, Cyrictica, Krk (Cro. island)
“Paros,” founded by the Parians), from which Demetrius the Pharos, Hvar (Cro. island)
Pharian originated.
315 C, 13-19 And there’s the coastline belonging to the Dalmatians and Dalmatians, Croatia, Bosnia-
Herzegovina, Montenegro
their seaport, Salon. This nation is one of those that fought for
Salon, Solin, nr. Split (Cro.)
a long time against the Romans. They had fifty sizable settle-
ments, some of them cities: Salon, Promon, Ninia, and Sino- Promon, Tepljuh (Bos.-Hrz.)
tium (both New and the Old, which were burned by Augustus). Ninia, Knin (Cro.)
Nasica (= Cornelius Scipio There’s also the defensive site of Andetrium. Dalmium . . . * a Sinotium, Balina Glavica (Cro.)
Nasica Corculum), Roman
general, conquered Dalmatia, great city, from which the nation takes its name. Nasica reduced Andetrium, Gornji Muč (Cro.)
155 BCE it to a small city, and made its plain a sheep pasture, because of Dalmium, Lib u Borčanima
(Bos.-Hrz.)
the greed of the population.
315 C, 19-22 A peculiar custom of the Dalmatians is their reallocation
of the land every eight years.3 Their nonuse of currency is an
unusual feature compared to t hose who live along this coast-
line, but compared to many other natives, it is common.
315 C, 22-23 Adrium is the mountain range that cuts through the Adrium, Dinaric Alps
aeans, and Pleraeans who live around it. Near some of these Daorizians, Ardiaeans,
Pleraeans, Croatia, Bosnia-
p eople is the island called “Black Corcyra” with its city Herzegovina, Montenegro
(founded by the Cnidians). Near the Ardiaeans is Pharos (for- Black Corcyra, Korčula (Cro.)
merly called “Paros,” since it was founded by the Parians). | Pharos, Hvar (Cro. island)
315 C, 27–316 C, 1 Men of l ater times called the Ardiaeans “Vardaeans.”4 The 7.5.6
374
Adriatic Coast + Hinterland
to till the soil. The territory is rough and of poor quality, and
not for people who want to farm. The consequence is that
they have been utterly ruined and have virtually disappeared.
This same thing has happened to other nations in this area.
People that formerly had the greatest power were completely
humbled and wiped out: Boïans and Scordistans, in the case
of the Galatians; Autariatae, Ardiaeans, and Dardanians, in
the case of the Illyrians; Triballians, in the case of the Thra-
cians. They were provoked to war initially by each other and
subsequently by the Macedonians and Romans. |
316 C, 2-12 After the Ardiaean and Pleraean coastline, t here’s the Rhi- Rhizonian gulf, Gulf of Kotor 7.5.7
(Mont.)
zonian gulf, the city of Rhizon, other small towns, and the
Rhizon, Risan (Mont.)
Drilon river, with its upstream passage eastward to Dardania.
Drilon, Drini/Drin r.
Dardania connects with the Macedonian and Paeonian na-
Dardania, Serbia, Kosovo,
tions to the south, just as the Autariatae and the Dasaretians n. North Macedonia
do, diff erent people being contiguous with each other in dif
ferent places, and with . . . *. Included among the Dardani-
ans are the Galabrians, among whom . . . * ancient city, and
the Thunatians who connect to the east with the Maedians, Maedians, North Macedonia,
Bulgaria
a Thracian nation. The Dardanians, despite being so utterly
savage as to live in caves dug out u nder their sewage tips,
were nevertheless fond of m usic, constantly playing flutes
and stringed instruments. T hese, then, are the p eople in the
interior: I w ill also mention them l ater.1 |
316 C, 13-20 After the Rhizonian gulf is the city of Lissus; also Acrolis- Lissus, Lezha (Alb.) 7.5.8
sus and Epidamnus, which was founded by the Corcyraeans Acrolissus, Mali Shelbuemit
(Alb.)
and is now called “Dyrrhachium,” with the same name as the
Epidamnus/Dyrrhachium,
peninsula on which she sits; then the Hapsus river and the Durrës (Alb.)
Aous, on which is the exceedingly well-governed city of Apol- Hapsus, Semeni r.
lonia (founded by Corinthians and Corcyraeans), ten stades Aous, Vijosë r.
Hecataeus (6th–5th c. BCE) from the river and sixty [stades] from the sea. Hecataeus calls Apollonia, Pojan (Alb.)
the Aous “Aias” and says that, from the same place—rather the
same recess—in the Lacmus region, the Inachus flows southward into
Argos, while the Aias flows toward the west and the Adria.
316 C, 20-30 In the territory of the Apolloniates is what is called the
“Nymphaeum.” It is a cliff that shoots forth fire; at its foot, Nymphaeum, ?Selenicë (Alb.)
[ 1 ] 318 C, 18-27.
375
3.2. Eastern Europe, South of the Ister (Danube r.)
Posidonius (late 2nd–1st c. BCE) is turned into asphalt, according to Posidonius. That fellow also
says that ampelitis—asphalt-like earth that is mined in Pierian Se-
leucia—is a cure for pest-ridden vines (when it is smeared on together
with olive oil, it kills the pest before it ascends from the root to the
shoots); during his prytany, a similar type of earth was discovered in prytany, state office
normus; and the Ceraunian mountains, which mark the start Panormus, ?Porto Palermo (Alb.)
of the mouth of the Ionian gulf and the Adria. | The mouth is Ceraunian mountains, range 7.5.9
incl. Cikes mt. (Alb.)
common to both. The difference is that “Ionian” is the name
of the first part of this sea, while “Adria” is the name of the Adria, Adriatic Sea
a man who ruled over these places, whose family originated in Issus,
while the “Adria” was named a fter a river. The distance from the
Libyrnians1 to the Ceraunian mountains is only slightly more
than two thousand stades.
317 C, 7-15 Theopompus says that the entire voyage from the recess takes
Theopompus (4th c. BCE) six days but journeying the length of Illyria by foot takes thirty days.
He seems to me to exaggerate. He makes other untrustworthy
statements: the seas are connected by a tunnel,2 based on the discov-
ery of Chian and Thasian pottery in the Naron; both seas 3 can be seen Naron, Neretva r.
[ 1 ] 315 C, 4-6.
[ 2 ] The seas in question are presumably the sea into which the Naron river flows
(i.e., the Adriatic) and the sea in which the islands of Chios and Thasos are
located (i.e., the Aegean).
[ 3 ] The Adriatic and the Aegean?
[ 4 ] Strabo perhaps corrects his earlier statement (313 C, 12-19, where he attributes
to Polybius the view that “both seas” can be seen from a mountain range and
where the range in question is mount Haemus, Balkans).
[ 5 ] I.e., inland from the Adriatic coast (314 C, 24–317 C, 22).
376
Adriatic Coast + Hinterland
Margus (some people say “Bargus”). The Little Scordiscans Margus/Bargus, Morava r.
lived on the other side of this river, reaching as far as the Trib- this river = Margus
earlier,1 and the marshes of what is called “Little Scythia in- inside Ister = south of Danube r.
377
3.2. Eastern Europe, South of the Ister (Danube r.)
live by raiding, but the Bessians, who live for the most part
on mount Haemus, are called “raiders” even by raiders!) They
are poverty-stricken hut dwellers, extending as far as Rho-
dope, the Paeonians, and—among the Illyrians—the Autari-
atae and Dardanians.
318 C, 24-27 Between these people and the Ardiaeans are the Dasare-
tians, Hybrianians, and other insignificant nations, whom
the Scordiscans ravaged to the point that they depopulated
the territory and left it bristling with unpassable forests for a
distance of several days’ journey. |
318 C, 28–319 C, 2 What remains of the territory between the Ister and the 7.6.1
Strabo segues from his mountains on e ither side of Paeonia1 is the Pontic coastline
description of the Adriatic coast
to his description of the Pontic from the Sacred Mouth of the Ister as far as the mountains
(Black Sea) coast in the Haemus region and as far as the mouth at Byzantium. mouth at Byzantium, Bosporus
(Tky.)
In describing the Illyrian coastline, I proceeded as far as the
Ceraunian mountains (since, although they fall outside the Ceraunian mts., range incl. Cikes
mt. (Alb.)
Illyrian mountains, they provide something of a suitable end
point); 2 into my description of these, I incorporated the na-
tions of the interior, in the belief that such a configuration
would be more meaningful, for now and for what follows.
In just the same way, the coastline here, even though it falls
outside the line formed by the mountains, will nevertheless
provide an end point, namely the mouth of the Pontus, which mouth of Pontus = Bosporus
(Tky.)
is appropriate for now and for what comes next.3
hundred and fifty stades, another small town, Tomis; then, Tomis, Constanţa (Rom.)
after two hundred and eighty stades, the city of Callatis, a col- Callatis, Mangalia (Rom.)
[ 1 ] I.e., what “remains” of the territory between the Danube and the Balkans, as
defined at 313 C, 5-12.
[ 2 ] Illyrian (Adriatic) coastline + hinterland: 314 C, 24–318 C, 27.
[ 3 ] Pontic (Black Sea) coastline: 319 C, 3–320 C, 28.
[ 4 ] Strabo probably saw this colossal statue in the Capitol in Rome: 236 C, 25-28n.
378
Pontic Coast
319 C, 32–320 C, 6 The distance from the headland forming the Pentasta- 7.6.2
379
3.2. Eastern Europe, South of the Ister (Danube r.)
320 C, 6-17 This fish breeds in the marshes of the Maeotis; when it Maeotis, Sea of Azov
and Pharnacia. This is where the “first catch”1 takes place, al- Pharnacia, Giresun (Tky.)
though it is not a large one, since the fish has not yet attained
its proper size. As it moves on toward Sinope, the fish is more Sinope, Sinop (Tky.)
and the neighboring Horn, the fish is naturally driven thither, Horn, Haliç/Golden Horn (Tky.)
oracle, Apollo told them to choose their site opposite the blind men, oracle, divine instruction
320 C, 29–321 C, 2 Those are the significant nations that are included be- 7.7.1
380
South of the Mountains
SOUTH OF ILLYRIAN, Greece was, almost in its entirety, virtually a barbarian colony
PAEONIAN, THRACIAN
MOUNTAINS in antiquity, if we reckon on the basis of what is recorded:
s. Albania, North Maecdonia, Pelops led his p eople out of Phrygia into what was named
European Turkey, Greece
after him the “Peloponnese” (Pelops’s island); Danaus led his
people from Egypt; the Dryopians, Cauconians, Pelasgians,
Lelegians,1 and such p eople divvied up among themselves the
area inside the isthmus as well as the area outside. Attica was inside the
isthmus = Peloponnese
held by Thracians who accompanied Eumolpus; in Phocis,
outside [the
Daulis was held by Tereus, and Cadmia by the Phoenicians isthmus] = mainland Greece
accompanying Cadmus; Boeotia itself was held by Aonians,
Pindar (5th c. BCE) Temmicans, and Hyantes—as Pindar tells us, t here was a time
when people called the Boeotian people Syes (Pigs)! The barbar-
ian element is evident from some of their names—Cecrops,
Codrus, Aeclus, Cothus, Drymas, and Crinacus.
321 C, 15-20 Thracians, Illyrians, and Epirotes remain up to the present
day on the flanks, although this was more the case in the past
than it is now. Even much of what is nowadays indubitably
Greece is held by barbarians: Thracians hold Macedonia and
some parts of Thessaly; 2 and Epirote nations—Thesprotians,
Cassopaeans, Amphilochians, Molossians, Athamanians—
hold upper Acarnania and Aetolia.3 |
321 C, 21-28 The Pelasgians have been described.4 Some people sup- 7.7.2
Previous barbarian inhabitants pose that the Lelegians were the same people as the Carians,
of Greece
while others suppose that they were their compatriots and
allies; that this is why, in Milesia, t here are certain settlements
called “Lelegian” and, everywhere in Caria, t here are “Lele-
gian” tombs and deserted fortifications called “Lelegian.” All
of what is now called “Ionia” was inhabited by Carians and
Lelegians; the Ionians drove them out and took possession
of the territory. Even earlier, those who captured Troy drove
the Lelegians away from the Ida region, namely Pedasus and
the Satnioeis river.
321 C, 28–322 C, 5 The very fact that these p eople w ere in alliance with the these people = Lelegians
Aristotle (4th c. BCE) Carians would be a sign that they were barbarians. Aristo-
tle’s Constitutions show that, from antiquity, they moved about
both with them and without them. He says in the “Acarnanian them = Carians
381
3.2. Eastern Europe, South of the Ister (Danube r.)
382
Mediterranean Coast + Hinterland
and thirty-five miles. Converting (as most do) on the basis of Hebrus, Evros/Martisa/Meriç r.
ian mountain range), through Lychnidus city and Pylon (a Lychnidus city, Ohrid (N. Mac.)
place on the road that marks the boundary between Illyria Pylon, nw. Resen (N. Mac.)
Barnus, Voras Kaimatsala mt.
(Gr.)
and Macedonia). From there, the road goes alongside Bar- Edessa, Edessa (Gr.)
[ 1 ] This passage is key to our understanding of the value of the stade used by ance for the different values of the Greek and Roman foot, simply dividing
Strabo. The Roman mile is equivalent to 1.4785 km. Based on a conversion rate 5,000 by 600, which gives a ratio of 8 1/3 stades to the Roman mile.
of 8 stades to the mile, the value of the stade is 185 m. [4] 323 C, 32–326 C, 14.
[ 2 ] Polybius used a ratio of 8 1/3 stades to the mile, higher than writers who came [5] 317 C, 22–318 C, 27.
after him. He “adds” 1/3 stade only from Strabo’s retrospective point of view. [6] 326 C, 14–327 C, 28.
A similar use of “add”: 690 C, 35–691 C, 8n. [7] In this paragraph, Strabo looks ahead to his description of Greece: 332 C,
[ 3 ] 1 Roman mile = 5,000 Roman feet. 1 stade = 600 Greek feet. Ratio of Greek foot 1–489 C, 27. He probably paraphrases Eudoxus: 323 C, 13-15; 390 C, 8–391 C, 3.
to the Roman foot = 25:24. Divide 5,000 by 600 and multiply by 24/25 = 8. Poly- For the boundary with Greece: 334 C, 4-6.
bius (2nd c. BCE) was probably the first Greek writer interested in converting [8] In this paragraph, Strabo looks ahead to the section of his narrative that falls
Roman miles into stades. As such, he appears initially to have made no allow- within the “eastern European gap”: 329 C, 15–332 C, 1.
383
3.2. Eastern Europe, South of the Ister (Danube r.)
most famous are the Chaonians and the Molossians because they once
EPIRUS ruled all Epirotis—first the Chaonians, then the Molossians, who
Albania, nw. Greece
flourished greatly, both because of the families from which their kings Aeacids = descendants of
Aeacus, a deity
came (they were members of the Aeacids) and because the ancient and oracle, center for divine
renowned oracle at Dodona belonged to them. prophecy
324 C, 5-11 The Chaonians, Thesprotians, and, right after these, the Chaonians, Thesprotians,
Cassopaeans, s. Albania, nw.
Maritime Epirus Cassopaeans (these, too, are Thesprotians) dwell along the Greece
Albania, nw. Greece
coast from the Ceraunian mountains as far as the Ambracian Ceraunian mts., range incl. Cikes
gulf, and their territory is blessed. Starting from the Chao- mt. (Alb.)
the mouth of what is known as “Pelodes (Mud) Harbor,” in a Buthrotum, Butrinti (Alb.)
place that forms a peninsula and has a colony of Romans), Pelodes Harbor, Gji i Butrintit
(Alb.)
and the Sybota. The Sybota are little islands, only a short
Sybota, Sivota (Gk. islands)
distance from the mainland, lying opposite the eastern end
of Corcyraea, which is called “Leucimma.” T here are other Leucimma, Akra Lefkimis
(Kerkyra/Corfu)
small islands, too, off the coast, but they are not worth
naming.
[ 1 ] Strabo conceives of the mainland coast (Albania, Greece) and the island of
Corcyra (Kerkyra/Corfu) as each running from due west to due east, and the
western end of Corcyra as lying due south of Onchesmus. For “corresponds to”
meaning “lies due south of”: 496 C, 26–497 C, 4.
384
Mediterranean Coast + Hinterland
324 C, 21-28 Then there’s a headland, Chimerium, and Glycus (Freshwa- Chimerium, ?Akra Trophale (Gr.)
Acheron, Akheron r. ter) Harbor, into which the Acheron river discharges, flowing Glycus Harbor, ?nr. Ormos Ag.
Ioannou (Gr.)
out of the Acherusian lake before being joined by several riv-
Thyamis, Thyamis/Kalamas r. ers, so that it freshens the water of the bay. (The Thyamis
flows nearby.) Inland from this bay is Cichyrus, formerly Cichyrus/Ephyra,
Mesopotamon (Gr.)
Buthrotum, Butrinti (Alb.) “Ephyra,” a Thesprotian city. (Inland from the bay at Buthro-
Phoenica, Finiq (Alb.) tum is Phoenica.) Near Cichyrus is a small town, Buchetium, Buchetium, ?Rogous (Gr.)
belonging to the Cassopaeans, only a short distance inland Elatria, ?Paliorophon (Gr.)
from the coast; and Elatria, Pandosia, and Batiae in the inte- Pandosia, ?Trikastro (Gr.)
rior. Their territory stretches as far as the bay. Batiae, Kastri (Gr.)
324 C, 28-32 Immediately after Glycus Harbor are another two har-
bors: the nearer and smaller one is Comarus, forming a Comarus, Limani Komaros (Gr.)
sixty-stade isthmus with the Ambracian gulf and Nicopolis, Nicopolis, Palaio-Preveza (Gr.)
dedicated the ten ships that were the first fruits of war, rang-
ing from ships with one bank of oars to ships with ten banks.
Both the buildings and the vessels are said to have been de-
stroyed by fire.
325 C, 8-12 On your left is Nicopolis and the Cassopaeans (who are
Epirotes), as far as the recess at Ambracia (which—founded Ambracia, Arta (Gr.)
upstream voyage from sea to city being just a few stades. The Tympha, Mavrovouni mt.
river starts from Tympha mountain and the Paroraea. Paroraea, Peristeri (Gr.)
325 C, 12-20 Even early on, this city did extremely well, with the gulf this city = Ambracia, Arta (Gr.)
taking its name from her. Pyrrhus beautified the city and
used her as his royal residence. Subsequently, the Mace-
donians and the Romans crushed both this city and o thers
in continual wars, b ecause they w
ere disobedient. In the Augustus defeated Marc
Antony and Cleopatra at
end Augustus, realizing that the cities had been completely Actium, 31 BCE
385
3.2. Eastern Europe, South of the Ister (Danube r.)
326 C, 14-20 Intermingled with t hese are the Illyrian nations in the
southern part of the mountainous region and inland from the
386
Mediterranean Coast + Hinterland
Ionian gulf. Living inland of the stretch from Epidamnus and Ceraunians, range incl. Cikes
Apollonia to the Ceraunians are the Byllionians, Taulantians, mt. (Alb.)
Parthinians, and Brygians. Somewhere nearby are the silver Byllionians, etc., Albania, North
Macedonia
mines in Damastium . . . * call them “Sesarethians.” Near
Lyncestians, etc., n. Greece,
Tripolitis Pelagonia, ?Prilepec these are the Lyncestians, Deuriopus, Tripolitis Pelagonia, North Macedonia
(N. Mac.)
the Eordians, Elimia, and Eratyra. Eratyra, nr. Kozani (Gr.)
326 C, 21-25 Formerly, each was ruled separately. The rulers of the
Encheleans were descended from Cadmus and Harmonia. Encheleans, North Macedonia
Aratthus (and the Achelous and the Euenus, which was for- Aratthus, Arachthos r.
One river . . . gulf = Aratthus merly called the “Lycormas”). One river flows into the Am- Achelous, Akheloos r.
one . . . Achelous = Inachus bracian gulf and one flows into the Achelous. (The Achelous Euenus, Phidaris r.
itself and the Euenus flow into the sea, the former through
Acarnania and the latter through Aetolia).
327 C, 12-19 The Erigon is joined by many streams from the Illyr-
Lyncestians, etc., North
Erigon, Crna r. ian mountains—from among the Lyncestians, Brygians, Macedonia, n. Greece
[ 1 ] 322 C, 28–327 C, 4.
387
3.2. Eastern Europe, South of the Ister (Danube r.)
[ 1 ] 322 C, 14-24.
[ 2 ] Tyrrhenica (lit., “Stuff about Tyrrhenia”) refers to the section of Strabo’s narra-
tive (218 C, 25–227 C, 6) in which he describes the territory of Tyrrhenia (w. Italy);
and within which he discusses the Pelasgians (220 C, 31–221 C, 38). Strabo’s use
of such “titles”: 639 C, 15-27n.
388
Mediterranean Coast + Hinterland
328 C, 11-17 Apollodorus says that people suppose the name to be derived
Apollodorus (2nd c. BCE) from the “hele” (marshes) in the neighborhood of the temple. How-
poet = Homer (8th c. BCE) ever, he supposes that the poet did not call t hose in the t emple’s vi-
cinity “Hellans” but rather “Sellans,” giving as his reason that he he = Homer
names a certain river the “Sellëeis.” Now, he uses the name when
he says far from Ephyra, far from the river Sellëeis. In the . . . *
Strabo cites Demetrius (2nd c. “Ephyra” among the Thesprotians but the one among the
BCE)
Elians, on the grounds that the “Sellëeis” is found in the latter place,
but t here’s no “Sellëeis” among the Thesprotians or Molossians.
328 C, 18-20 As for the myths told about the oak tree, the doves, and
suchlike, as in the case of the myths about Delphi, some be-
long to a more poetry-oriented study, but others are relevant
to the geographical work at hand. |
328 C, 21-24 In ancient times, both Dodona and mount “Tomarus” or Dodona, Dodone (Gr.) 7.7.11
“Tmarus” (it is spelled both ways), at whose foot the t emple Tomarus/Tmarus, Tomaros/
Olytsika mt.
lies, were under Thesprotian control: the tragic poets and
Pindar (5th c. BCE) Pindar call Dodona “Thesprotian.” Later, it fell under Molos-
sian control.
328 C, 25-27 People say that it is b ecause of Tomarus that t hose men
poet = Homer (8th c. BCE) who w ere called by the poet interpreters of Zeus—men whom
he also calls aniptopodes chamaeëunae (ground-sleepers-with-unwashed-
feet)—were named “tomuri.”
328 C, 27–329 C, 2 In the Odyssey, some p eople write what Amphinomus says
Homer’s Odyssey (8th c. BCE) when counseling the suitors not to attack Telemachus until
they have made inquiries of Zeus, as follows: If the “tomuri” of
Zeus approve, / I w ill commit murder and bid all o thers likewise. / If
the god turns us down, I bid us desist. They reason that it is better
to write tomuri than themistes (decrees) because the poet nowhere
uses themistes for oracular responses, but rather for legislative
counsels, political regulations, and lawmaking. They say that
the word tomuri is contracted, as from tomarophylakes (guardians
of Tomarus).
329 C, 2-6 While more recent commentators read tomuri, one should
more simply understand Homer as using themistes (decrees) and
“counsels” to mean oracular (as well as legislative) instruc-
tions and advice. Such is the case in the line: to hear the counsel
of Zeus from the oak tree with its lofty foliage. |
329 C, 7-10 To start with, the oracular prophets w ere male. This is 7.7.12
poet = Homer (8th c. BCE) perhaps indicated by the poet: he calls them “interpreters”
389
3.2. Eastern Europe, South of the Ister (Danube r.)
the Scotussa region of Pelasgia (Scotussa belongs to Pelasgian Scotussa, Ag. Triadi/Souphli
(Gr.)
Thessaly); it was accompanied by very many women whose descen-
dants are the prophetesses of today; and that is why Zeus is called
“Pelasgian.”
329 C, 15 . . . Cineas, in even more mythical fashion, . . . * |
Cineas (3rd c. BCE)
329 C, 15–332 C, 1 At this point (329 C, 15), there is a gap in Strabo’s narrative. It can give the
“Eastern European gap” impression that Strabo was distracted midsentence; and that, a fter being
distracted, he jumped ahead to his description of Greece, with which his
narrative resumes (332 C, 1). This is not, of course, what happened. It is an il-
lusion caused by an accident in the transmission of Strabo’s work. Although
Strabo wrote (or dictated) the missing words, a subsequent event resulted
in their physical loss. Perhaps the end of a papyrus roll got torn off. Perhaps
a medieval monk did the equivalent of spilling his Starbucks coffee over his
codex and then had to remove the damaged pages. Perhaps someone tore
out the pages on purpose. Perhaps mice nibbled the manuscript, or moths
ate it. Whatever the cause, the relevant surviving manuscripts are all derived
from this damaged version, with the possible exception of one manuscript,
which unfortunately suffered its own damage over the same pages.
Because Strabo is so orderly in his narrative, we can tell which areas of
the world he described in the missing portion. They are Paeonia, Macedo-
nia, and Thrace (North Macedonia, ne. Greece, E uropean Turkey). Further-
more, Strabo has a habit of making forward references to areas he intends
to describe later. Indeed, he has at this stage in his narrative already alerted
his readers to several locations that, in the event, fall within the “eastern
European gap.” Thus we know that, as well as Paeonia, Macedonia, and
Thrace, Strabo included in the “eastern E uropean gap” the islands of Lem-
nos (Lemnos, Gk. island), Thasos (Thasos, Gk. island), Imbros (Gökçeada, Tk.
island), and Samothrace (Samothrake, Gk. island).
390
Mediterranean Coast + Hinterland
The C-page (329 C) on which Strabo’s narrative breaks off and the
C-page (332 C) on which it resumes are numbered according to an early
seventeenth-century edition in which the relevant portion of narrative
was already absent. The jump from 329 C to 332 C reflects the number of
pages left blank by the scribes of that edition rather than the number of
pages occupied by Strabo’s missing description. A reasonable guess is that
Strabo’s account of these areas, had it survived, would have occupied some
ten C-pages.
In late antiquity and the Middle Ages, it was customary to produce ab-
breviated versions of long works. Strabo’s work was duly epitomized, and
copies of these epitomes have survived to the present day. These epitomes
(the original versions of which were written before the loss of the portion
of Strabo’s narrative dealing with Paeonia, Macedonia, Thrace, e tc.) give us
an idea of what was in the lost portion, but they are not comprehensive and
are not included in this translation.
391
Bulgaria
North Macedonia
Albania
Greece
Turkey
BANDS OF
GREECE
5th
4th •
•
CORINTH
ATHENS
3rd
PELOPONNESE
2nd
1st
CRETE
Translator’s Introduction
393
3.3. Greece
Strabo is so familiar with Homer that he often lapses into “Homer-speak,” weav-
ing citations from Homer into his own sentence structure and using Homer’s spellings
of place-names alongside the conventional spellings of his own day. In this translation,
citations of Homeric words, phrases, and place-names are shown in italics where their
Homeric origin is germane to our understanding of Strabo’s narrative. T here are prob
ably many instances of Homer-speak in Strabo’s narrative beyond those marked in this
translation. It would be an interesting project to see exactly how many oddities in Strabo’s
narrative might be explained by his insertion or use of phrases and idioms borrowed
from Homer.
394
Translator’s Introduction
Greece as an Anchor
Strabo’s description of Greece occupies three of the seventeen “books” into which his
narrative was divided. These book divisions, which probably reflect the number of pa-
pyrus rolls that Strabo used, are not much used in this translation, but it is worth paying
attention to them as concerns Greece. The three books describing Greece occupy a per-
fectly central position, with seven books preceding them and seven books coming after
them. Strabo’s account of Greece thus acts as an anchor for the overall work. As befits an
anchor, it is hefty, weighing in at over fifty thousand words and representing more than a
sixth of the overall narrative. Strabo’s account of Greece is thus wildly disproportionate
to the amount of physical space occupied by Greece. It is nevertheless consistent with its
cultural weight and a reminder that cultural considerations are far more important for
Strabo than p olitical boundaries.
Remember
Remember when reading this chapter that “. . . *” represents a gap or a pre-
sumed omission or error in the manuscripts.
In this chapter more than any other, Strabo cites Homer (eighth century
BCE), often referring to him as the “poet,” or simply as “he” or “him.”
Whereas in other chapters, instances of the “poet” or “he” meaning Homer
are noted in the margin, in this chapter they are so frequent that they are
noted only where necessary to avoid confusion. Strabo frequently expli-
cates lines from Homer’s verses at g reat length, arguing strenuously over
the meaning of individual words and phrases. These words or phrases, as
well as the longer passages of Homer cited by Strabo, are shown in italics.
Italics are also used when Strabo is writing in the voice of an earlier
scholar or a poet other than Homer. These passages should not necessar-
ily be understood as verbatim quotations as they are frequently adapted to
Strabo’s sentence structure and filtered through Strabo’s own ideas.
Dates given in the margins for the poets and scholars cited by Strabo rep-
resent the period of their literary activity. Dates of birth and death—rarely
known with certainty—may fall outside these p arameters.
Italics are used for technical terms that do not translate easily and for the
“titles” of e arlier works to which Strabo refers.
Consult “Special Features of this Translation” and “A User’s Guide” at the
start of this translation for a fuller discussion of aids provided to the reader.
395
CH APT E R TH R E E Greece
PART 3
332 C, 1-4 Starting from the western parts of Europe that are enclosed 8.1.1
Strabo segues from the between the inner and the outer seas, I worked my way inner sea = Med. Sea
northern parts of eastern
Europe to Greece
through all the barbarian nations in E urope as far as the outer sea = Atlantic
Ocean + North Sea
Tanaïs and through a part—albeit not large—of Greece.1 I
Tanaïs, Don r.
will now present what remains of the geography of Greece.
332 C, 4-13 The subject was tackled first by Homer, then by vari
GREECE ous other writers. Some of them wrote specifically entitled
Greece + Greek islands
Harbors or Coastal Navigations or Journeys Around the World or
suchlike, within which are included Helladica.2 Some writers
provided a dedicated topographical description of the con-
Ephorus (4th c. BCE) tinents within their overall histories, as did Ephorus and
Polybius (2nd c. BCE) Polybius. Others, such as Posidonius and Hipparchus, in-
Posidonius (late 2nd–1st c. BCE) corporated even matters of this sort into physics and mathe
Hipparchus (2nd c. BCE) matics. While the views of these men are easy to assess, those
of Homer require a more careful critical analysis, given that he
speaks poetically and does not describe the present but rather
the long-ago past, which has faded with time.
332 C, 13-16 Insofar as is possible, I must take the m
atter in hand, start-
ing from where I left off: my account ended with the Epirote
and Illyrian nations to the west and north and with the Mace-
donians as far as Byzantium to the east.3
332 C, 17–333 C, 3 After the Epirotes and the Illyrians, with regard to the
Greeks, there are Acarnanians, Aetolians, and Ozolian
Locrians, plus Phocians and Boeotians. Across the w ater
from these is the Peloponnese, subtending the intervening
Corinthian gulf (which it shapes and by which it is shaped).
After Macedonia, t here are Thessalians as far as the Malians outside the isthmus = north of
Peloponnese
and as far as the rest of those outside the isthmus and those inside the isthmus = within
inside the isthmus. | Peloponnese
333 C, 4-13 On one level, t here is a large number of nations, but at the 8.1.2
[ 1 ] Western Europe: 136 C, 13–288 C, 33. Eastern Europe (= barbarian nations) + small
part of Greece: 289 C, 1–329 C, 15n.
[ 2 ] Helladica (lit., “Stuff about Greece”) is the “title” of sections within the works
listed. For Strabo’s use of such “titles”: 639 C, 15-27n.
[ 3 ] 312 C, 29–329 C, 15n.
397
3.3. Greece
398
Overview of Greece
334 C, 1-3 Such are the nations of Greeks in number, and such are
their definitions, broadly speaking. Let me now describe
them in order, adopting whatever method of classification is
necessary.1 |
334 C, 4-10 Ephorus says that the start of Greece in the west is marked by 8.1.3
Ephorus (4th c. BCE) starts his Acarnania: this is the first territory that borders on the Epirote na-
description of Greece with
Acarnania tions.2 Just as he, using the seacoast as his yardstick, starts with
Acarnania (deciding on the sea as his guiding principle with
respect to the description of place, since otherwise he could
have declared the land of the Macedonians and Thracians to be
the start of Greece), so it is also appropriate for me to make the
sea my counselor in following the natural disposition of places.
334 C, 10-13 The sea, as it leaves the Sicilian ocean, flows in one direc-
tion into the Corinthian gulf, while in the other direction it
Strabo sees Peloponnese as produces a great peninsula, the Peloponnese, closed off with
start of Greece: 1st reason
a narrow isthmus.
334 C, 14-17 The two greatest federations in Greece are the one inside
the isthmus 3 and the one beyond Pylae as far as the outlet of beyond Pylae (= Thermopylae),
north of Thermopiles (Gr.)
the Peneius—that is, the Thessalian federation.4 The larger
and more famous federation is the one inside the isthmus.
2nd reason for starting with The Peloponnese is even a sort of acropolis for the whole of
Peloponnese
Greece.
334 C, 17-21 Apart from the splendor and the power of the nations
residing t here, this hegemony is underscored by the overall overall layout = layout of all
Greece
layout, richly textured with a multitude of bays and headlands
Greece consists of a series of and, most conspicuously, huge peninsulas, each incorporat-
peninsulas
ing another in continuous succession.
334 C, 21-22 The Peloponnese is the first of the peninsulas, closed by
1st peninsula an isthmus of forty stades.
334 C, 22-25 This peninsula is incorporated within the second penin-
2nd peninsula sula, whose isthmus extends from Megarian Pagae to Nisaea Pagae, Alepochori (Gr.)
to Thermopylae; the i magined straight line m easures some Thermopylae, Thermopiles (Gr.)
[ 1 ] Strabo starts his description of Greece with a classification system (334 C, 10-34)
based on 5 peninsulas. Once he has described the Peloponnese (1st peninsula,
335 C, 1–389 C, 42), he proceeds to switch to a system based on the division of
Greece into 5 bands: 390 C, 1-7nn; 400 C, 15-26n; 416 C, 11–417 C, 27; 429 C, 15-20.
[ 2 ] Epirote nations: 323 C, 32–329 C, 15n.
[ 3 ] Federation inside the isthmus (= in Peloponnese), i.e., Achaean federation:
384 C, 9–385 C, 27.
[ 4 ] Federation beyond Pylae/Thessalian federation: 429 C, 15–444 C, 7.
[ 5 ] The insertion of “Attica and” before Boeotia (Radt, vol. 2, 334 C, line 27) is
unnecessary.
399
3.3. Greece
335 C, 1-8 The Peloponnese is shaped like the leaf of a plane tree, its length 8.2.1
mus); the latter is measured from south to north (from Maleae Olympia, Archaia Olympia (Gr.)
through Arcadia to Aegium). Its circumference, if you do not Isthmus, Isthmos (Gr.)
Polybius (2nd c. BCE) hug the coast, is four thousand stades according to Polybius Maleae, Akra Maleas (Gr.)
Artemidorus (late 2nd–early (but Artemidorus adds another four hundred). If you hug the Aegium, Aigion (Gr.)
1st c. BCE)
coast, it is more than five thousand six hundred.
335 C, 8-11 It has been said that the isthmus at Diolcus (Haul-across),
across which p eople haul their ships from one side to the
other, m easures forty stades.1 |
335 C, 12-19 The western part of this peninsula is held by the Elians and 8.2.2
Preview of the Peloponnese, by the Messenians,2 who face the Sicilian sea. They possess
starting with Elia and Messenia
in addition the coast in e ither direction. Elia curves around
to the north and the start of the Corinthian gulf as far as the Araxus, Cape Araxos (Gr.)
headland Araxus, across the strait from which is Acarnania Zacynthus, Zakynthos (Gk.
island)
and the islands lying off it (Zacynthus, Cephallenia, Ithaca,
Cephallenia, Kephallenia (Gk.
Echinades, Echinades (Gk. and the Echinades, which include Dulichium). The greater island)
islands)
part of Messenia opens to the south and the Libyan sea, as far Ithaca, Ithake (Gk. island)
as what are called the “Thyrides” (Windows), near Taenarum. Thyrides, Pounta (Gr.)
[ 1 ] Strabo elaborates on his e arlier statement (334 C, 21-22, where only the distance
across the isthmus is given).
[ 2 ] Elia (w. Peloponnese): 336 C, 18–358 C, 26. Messenia (sw. Peloponnese): 358 C,
27–362 C, 26.
[ 3 ] Achaea (n. Peloponnese): 383 C, 1–388 C, 12. Sicyonia and Corinth (ne. Pelopon-
nese): 378 C, 1–382 C, 33.
[ 4 ] Laconia (se. Peloponnese): 362 C, 27–368 C, 22. Argia (e. Peloponnese): 368 C,
23–377 C, 34.
400
The Peloponnese
335 C, 23-27 The gulfs h ere are the Messenian and the Laconian gulfs;
and thirdly, the Argolic gulf; and fourth, the Hermionic and
Saronic, which people also call “Salaminian.”1 Of these, some
are inlets of the Libyan sea, others are inlets of the Cretan sea
and the Myrtoan ocean (some p eople use the name “ocean”
for the Saronic, as well).
335 C, 27-28 In the center is Arcadia, lying on the borders of all, a
Preview of Arcadia neighbor to the other nations.2 |
335 C, 29–336 C, 5 The Corinthian gulf starts at the outlets of the Euenus Euenus, Phidaris r. 8.2.3
CORINTHIAN GULF (some say, the Achelous, which divides the Acarnanians Achelous, Akheloos r.
from the Aetolians) and at Araxus. This is where the coasts Araxus, Cape Araxos (Gr.)
on each side first approach each other to a significant extent.
As they continue, they converge completely at Rhium and
Antirrhium, leaving a strait of only some five stades. Rhium Rhium, Rion (Gr.)
the rest as far as Isthmus . . . * Phocians and Boeotians, and Isthmus, Isthmos (Gr.)
Megaris, one thousand one hundred and twenty stades, less 1,120 stades minus 2 = 1,118
stades
two. The sea from Antirrhium to Isthmus . . . * is called “Al-
cyonian,” being a part of the Crisaean gulf.3 From the isthmus
to Araxus is one thousand and thirty stades.
336 C, 14-16 In general terms, such are the dimensions and character
of the layout of the Peloponnese and of the land across the
strait as far as the recess; such, too, is the gulf lying between
them both.4
336 C, 16-17 I will proceed with a detailed account, starting with Elia. |
336 C, 18-26 Nowadays, people give the name “Elia” to the entire coast- 8.3.1
ELIA line between the Achaeans and the Messenians, stretching to
w. Peloponnese
the Arcadian interior in the region of Pholoa and the Azani- Pholoa, Pholoe mt. (Gr.)
[ 1 ] Messenian gulf: 359 C, 34–362 C, 26. Laconian gulf: 362 C, 33–364 C, 3. Argolic
gulf: 368 C, 12–369 C, 2. Strabo gives the impression that the Hermionic and
Saronic gulfs are one and the same thing; cf. 368 C, 10-12. He corrects himself
in their detailed description: 369 C, 3-17; cf. 380 C, 15-19n.
[ 2 ] Arcadia (cen. Peloponnese): 388 C, 13–389 C, 24.
[ 3 ] Although Strabo sometimes uses the term “Crisaean gulf” in a narrow sense
(Iteas Gulf, 334 C, 25-28), he more often uses “Crisean gulf/sea” to mean more
generally the eastern part of the Gulf of Corinth (335 C, 29–336 C, 5; 379 C,
30–380 C, 3; 390 C, 8-21), with particular reference to its northern shore (259 C,
10-19; 400 C, 23-37; 405 C, 13–406 C, 1; 409 C, 13-34; 410 C, 22-28; 416 C, 11-30;
417 C, 18-27). Cf. 418 C, 20-28n.
[ 4 ] Peloponnese: 335 C, 1-28. Corinthian gulf and north shore: 335 C, 29–336 C, 13.
401
3.3. Greece
336 C, 33-36 The current-day city of Elis had not yet been founded in Elis, Palaiopolis/Kalyvia Elidos 8.3.2
(Gr.)
Homer’s time. The territory, however, was settled with vil-
lages. It was called “Coele Elis” after the facts of the matter:
for such was the greatest and best [part].2 At some later stage,
after the Persian war, the population came together from
many demes into the current-day city of Elis. deme, administrative district
336 C, 36–337 C, 8 In respect of nearly all the other places (with a few ex-
ceptions) in the Peloponnese that the poet catalogues, he
names not cities but territories, each with several federations
of demes, out of which, in later times, were constituted the
Mantinia, Mantineia (Gr.) now familiar cities. For example, in Arcadia, Mantinia was
Tegea, Piali/Episkopi (Gr.) founded by the Argives from five demes, Tegea from nine,
and Heraea from the same number by Cleombrotus (or Cle- Heraea, Ag. Ioannes (Gr.)
onymus); similarly, Aegium was made into one city out of Aegium, Aigion (Gr.)
Patrae, Patras (Gr.) seven or eight demes, Patrae from seven, Dyma from eight.
Dyma, Kato Achaia (Gr.) In just this way, Elis was made into one city from the outlying Elis, Palaiopolis/Kalyvia Elidos
(Gr.)
communities; one of these . . . * the Agriades.
337 C, 8-9 Running through the city is the Peneius river, near the Peneius, Peneios r.
city’s gymnasium.
337 C, 10-17 The Elians did this 3 a long time after their absorption of
places subject to Nestor. | These places were Pisatis (of which 8.3.3
Olympia is part), Triphylia, and the Cauconian territory.4 Olympia, Archaia Olympia (Gr.)
402
The Peloponnese
the tribe of the Minyans, who settled t here l ater; and the tribe
of the most recently dominant Elians. Some p eople make a
claim for the Arcadians rather than the Minyans, since the
former often disputed the territory; for this reason, one and
the same Pylos was called both “Arcadian” and “Triphylian.”
337 C, 17-20 Homer uses the name Pylos for all the territory as far as
Messene, using the same name as for the city. It is evident,
from the names of the leaders and their settlements in the
Catalogue of Ships,1 that Coele Elis 2 had been separated from
the places subject to Nestor.
337 C, 20-25 I make t hese statements 3 because I am contrasting the cur-
rent situation with the situation as described by Homer. It is
necessary to examine contradictions between the latter and the
poet = Homer (8th c. BCE) former, because of the poet’s fame and because of our long fa-
miliarity with him, each of us believing that a given argument
is correct only when it contains nothing contrary to his words
about the same places, in which we put a great deal of trust.
One must, therefore, describe what is and, citing the words of
the poet, consider them in addition, as far as is appropriate.4 |
337 C, 26-33 There is, in Elia, a north-pointing headland, Araxus, sixty Araxus, Cape Araxos (Gr.) 8.3.4
COELE ELIS stades distant from the Achaean city of Dyma. I take this to
w. Peloponnese
mark the start of the Elian coast. After this headland, head-
ing west, is the Elian seaport, Cyllena, with its route inland, Cyllena, Kyllini (Gr.)
[ 1 ] The “title” Catalogue of Ships refers to a part of Homer’s Iliad: 4 C, 14-20n; cf.
639 C, 15-27n.
[ 2 ] Coele Elis: 336 C, 33-36n; 337 C, 26–342 C, 5.
[ 3 ] 336 C, 18–337 C, 20.
[ 4 ] E.g., Strabo describes Coele Elis as it is in his day (337 C, 26–340 C, 6), then as it
appears in Homer’s poems (340 C, 6–342 C, 5).
[ 5 ] Meaning of Coele: 336 C, 33-36n.
403
3.3. Greece
Thesprotian Ephyra with the word “distant” and with the phrase Ionian Samos, Samos
(Gk. island)
“from the Sellëeis river.” This is not in accordance with the
Strabo notes Apollodorus words of the Scepsian Demetrius, from whom he borrows a
departs from his normal
practice of drawing on great deal. That fellow says that there is no “Sellëeis” river among That fellow = Demetrius
Demetrius (2nd c. BCE) the Thesprotians, but t here is one in Elia, by the Ephyra t here, as
I noted previously.2
339 C, 6-16 He lacks perception (scepsis) in saying this and also in saying He (lacks) = Demetrius
that there is only one city of Eurytus the Oechalian, when there is
not just one city. It is clear that he refers to the Thessalian city he (refers) = Homer
in the passage where he says, those who held Oechalia, the city of
[ 1 ] For Homer’s description of the Thracian island of Samos as wooded and be-
tween Samos and rugged Imbros: 457 C, 4-16n.
[ 2 ] Strabo adds to his e
arlier statement (338 C, 6-17, where he does not attribute
the information explicitly to Demetrius).
404
The Peloponnese
was on his way from Oechalia, from Eurytus the Oechalian.)1 If this
is the Thessalian city, then the Scepsian is again incorrect in the Scepsian = Demetrius
claiming that this is some city in Arcadia, the city that people now
call “Andania.” If he is correct, then the Arcadian city is also
described as belonging to Eurytus, so that t here is not just one
city—and he says there is just one! |
339 C, 17-20 Between the outlet of the Peneius and the Sellëeis, there Peneius, Peneios r. 8.3.7
was once a “Pylos” at Scollium. This was not Nestor’s city Pylos at Scollium, ?Armatova/
Agrapidochori (Gr.)
but a different one, associated neither with the Alphius nor
with the Pamisus (which latter should perhaps be called the
“Amathus”).
339 C, 20-27 Some p eople force the issue in their attempt to appropri-
ate Nestor’s fame and nobility. Three “Pyloi” are recorded
Strabo cites a proverb in the Peloponnese, whence the line, there’s a Pylos in front of
Pylos—and yet another Pylos. There are this Pylos, the Lepre- this Pylos = Pylos at Scollium
Triphylia).
339 C, 31–340 C, 5 This is the type of desire for fame that has prompted
people from Coele Elis to attach tokens of recognition to their
own Pylos. They identify a place “Geranus,” a river “Geron,”
and another river “Geranius.” They then assert that this is
why Nestor was known by the epithet “Gerenian”! The Mes-
senians have done the same t hing and appear more credible:
they say that their own “Gerena”—once highly populated—is Gerena, ?Zarnatas (Gr.)
better known.
340 C, 6 The above was my description 3 of Coele Elis 4 as it now is. |
340 C, 6-13 The poet divides the territory into four parts and says that 8.3.8
poet = Homer (8th c. BCE) they had four leaders, but his statement is not clear: those who
dwelt in Buprasium and sacred Elis, / such as was enclosed within
[1] For the Homeric passage to which Strabo refers: 349 C, 5-12n.
[2] Strabo’s own attempt: 336 C, 27-32n.
[3] 337 C, 26–340 C, 5.
[4] Meaning of Coele: 336 C, 33-36n.
405
3.3. Greece
Hyrmina and Myrsinus, on the far border, / and the Olenian Rock
and Alisium. / There w ere four chiefs of this area, and each was ac-
companied by / ten swift ships, with many Epians on board.1
340 C, 14-20 It might seem—because he uses the name “Epians” for
both Buprasians and Elians but does not yet use the name
“Elians” for Buprasians—that he does not divide Elia into
four parts but rather thus divides the territory of the Epians
(which he formerly divided into two parts); and that Bupra-
sium would not be part of Elis but rather would belong to the
Epians (for it is clear that he called the Buprasians “Epians”:
just as when the Epians buried lord Amarynceus / in Buprasium).
340 C, 21-23 Again, by his verbal joining together of Buprasium and sa-
cred Elis, and then his division into four subsections, he would
seem to categorize the parts as subject to both Buprasium and
Elis jointly.
340 C, 23-27 Probably Buprasium was a sizable settlement in Elia, albeit
one that no longer exists (the name is applied only to the ter-
ritory on the road to Dyma from the current-day city of Elis). city of Elis, Palaiopolis/Kalyvia
Elidos (Gr.)
One might suppose that, at that stage, Buprasium was more
important than Elis, as likewise the Epians than them. Later, them = Elians
bread of the Cyprians and the wheat of the Amathusians (the Ama-
Alcman (7th c. BCE) thusians are Cyprians). Alcman has, she who leaves lovely Cyprus
Aeschylus (5th c. BCE) and seagirt Paphos. Aeschylus has, she who possesses the entire land
of Cyprus and Paphos.
341 C, 4-6 If he does not describe the Buprasians as “Elians”—well, I
will say that there are many other things about the world that
he does not describe. This is not evidence that he knows noth-
ing of them but only evidence that he says nothing of them. |
341 C, 7-17 Hecataeus the Milesian says that the Epians are different 8.3.9
Hecataeus (6th–5th c. BCE) from the Elians; the Epians joined Heracles’s campaign against Au-
geas and, together with him, destroyed Augeas and Elis. He also
says that Dyma is both Epian and Achaean. The ancient com-
406
The Peloponnese
mentators say much about the world that is not true, being
steeped in falsehood through their familiarity with mythical
writings—which is also why they contradict each other in
dealing with the same events. However, it is not beyond belief
that the Epians w ere once different from the Elians and of a
distinct ethnicity, but they merged into one unit with them
when they got the upper hand and had a shared government;
poet = Homer (8th c. BCE) and that they prevailed as far as Dyma. The poet does not
name Dyma, but it is not unreasonable to suppose that Dyma
was subject at one stage to the Epians and only later to the
Ionians (or not even to them but to the Achaeans who seized
the latter’s territory).
341 C, 18-20 Of the four subsections1 (within which is Buprasium),
Hyrmina and Myrsinus belong to Elia, and the remaining
subsections are on the border with Pisatis, according to
some. |
341 C, 20-22 Hyrmina was once a small town but is no longer in exis- 8.3.10
[ 1 ] Strabo reverts to his analysis of the lines of Homer cited at 340 C, 6-13.
407
3.3. Greece
of Triphylia, and since Dyma is called “Cauconian” by some Dyma, Kato Achaia (Gr.)
eas” (masculine in gender, homonymous with one of the small Teutheas, Serdini r.
408
The Peloponnese
PISATIS town—by the walls of Pheia, near where the Iardanus flows (for
w. Peloponnese
there is a small river nearby). Some p eople say that Phea
marks the beginning of Pisatis. Lying off this headland too
are a small island and a harbor, whence the most direct route
from the coast to Olympia is one hundred and twenty stades. Olympia, Archaia Olympia (Gr.)
The place is called “Asea,” a village in Megalopolitis, with two Asea, Asea (Gr.)
springs close to each other from which the said rivers run.
They sink underground for many stades, then reemerge, one
flowing down into Laconia, the other into Pisatis.
343 C, 11-15 Eurotas reveals its stream again where Bleminatis begins, Eurotas, Evrotas r.
flows past Sparta herself, goes through a long valley, and flows
poet = Homer (8th c. BCE) out to sea at Helos (mentioned also by the poet), between Gythium, Gythion (Gr.)
Gythium (the Spartan seaport) and Acraeae. Acraeae, Kokkinia (Gr.)
343 C, 15-21 The Alphius is joined by the Ladon and the Erymanthus Ladon, Ladon r.
and other insignificant rivers; flows through Phrixa, Pisatis, Erymanthus, Erymanthos r.
and Triphylia, right by Olympia; and issues into the Sicilian Phrixa, Phixa (Gr.)
sea between Phea and Epitalium. Near its outlet is the sacred Epitalium, Epitalio (Gr.)
409
3.3. Greece
TRIPHYLIA (Cruni), and a settlement (Chalcis); and after these, Sami- Samicum, Kato Samikon (Gr.)
w. Peloponnese
cum, the location of the highly revered temple to “Samian”
Posidon. T here’s a sacred grove largely consisting of wild ol-
ives. The Macistians used to take care of it. T hese p
eople also
announced what people call the “Samian truce.” All Triphyli-
ans contribute to the upkeep of the temple. Also, the temple
to “Scilluntian” Athena, in the Scillus region (close to Olym- Scillus, Makrisia (Gr.)
little more inland from the sea, is “Triphylian” (or “Lepre- Triphylian/Lepreatic/Arcadian
Pylos = possibly a ghost site (see
poet = Homer (8th c. BCE) atic” or “Arcadian”) Pylos, which the poet describes as ema- footnote)
thoeis and presents as Nestor’s ancestral home, as one might
judge from his poem.1 Either the river running by it to the
north, which is nowadays called “Mamaus,” was previously
called “Amathus,” hence the epithet emathoeis; or this river was
called by the same name, “Pamisus,” as the two rivers in Mes-
senia, and the origin of the city’s epithet is uncertain. P eople
say that the amathode (sandiness) of the river, or of the territory,
is a fiction.
344 C, 8-12 Near Pylos to the east is a mountain named a fter Mintha. mountain named a fter Mintha,
Minthe mt. (Gr.)
In myth, she became a concubine of Hades and was trampled
on by Cora, and was turned into the garden variety of mint
(called by some people hedyosmon). On the mountain, there’s
a precinct sacred to Hades, who is also revered by the Ma-
cistians; and a grove sacred to Demeter, situated above the
Pylian plain.
344 C, 12-15 This plain has rich soil. It reaches to the sea and lies length-
wise along the w hole stretch between Samicum and the Neda Samicum, Kato Samikon (Gr.)
river. The littoral consists of a narrow sandbank, with the Neda, Bouzi r.
consequence that one should not jettison the possibility that
Pylos was called emathoeis because of it.2 |
344 C, 16-24 Bordering on Pylos to the north, there were once two 8.3.15
small Triphylian towns, Hypana and Typaneae. Of these, one Hypana, Platiana (Gr.)
was amalgamated with Elis, but the other was left alone. Two Typaneae, Vresto (Gr.)
rivers run nearby, the Dalion and the Acheron, tributaries of Acheron, Ladikon r.
the Alphius. The Acheron has been named because of its con- Alphius, Alpheios r.
410
The Peloponnese
rushes. For this reason, it happens that these areas often ex-
perience crop failures rather than great harvests. |
344 C, 25-32 On the southern side of Pylos is Lepreum. She, too, was a Lepreum, Lepreon (Gr.) 8.3.16
city lying forty stades back from the sea. Between Lepreum
and the Alphius is the temple to “Samian” Posidon, at a dis- Alphius, Alpheios r.
[ 1 ] 542 C, 4-30.
[ 2 ] Meaning of Coele: 336 C, 33-36n.
[ 3 ] 342 C, 6-37.
411
3.3. Greece
Strabo argues that some Laconia—are subject to him. On the other hand, the Cau-
Cauconians live east of
Triphylian Pylos, en route to conians are so disposed that those journeying from Pylos to
Lacedaemon Lacedaemon necessarily follow a route past the Cauconians.
345 C, 24-34 The temple to “Samian” Posidon and its anchorage, where
Telemachus moored his ship, lies to the north and west. If
Strabo argues that some this is the only place inhabited by Cauconians, the poet’s this = Triphylia
Cauconians live north of
Triphylian Pylos, that Homer statement is not valid. Whilst it is allowable for the poet to poet = Homer (8th c. BCE)
refers to them fabricate what is not real, when it is possible to harmonize
verse and facts and validate his account, restraint is more ad-
Sotades (3rd c. BCE) visable. Mentor-Athena (according to Sotades) bids Nestor
send Telemachus to the east, to Lacedaemon, with his chariot
and son. She says that she w ill herself go back west, to spend
the night on the ship. But, she says, in the morning she will go
forward again to the greathearted Cauconians to collect her debt!
345 C, 34–346 C, 6 How is this so? It would have been possible for Nestor to
say “the Cauconians are my subjects and are on your way if
you are g oing to Lacedaemon, so why not accompany t hose
associated with Telemachus,1 instead of going back?” At the
same time, it would have been proper for someone on their
way to people subject to Nestor for the purpose of collecting a
debt (not a small one, as she says) to ask him for some help if, as she = Athena
is often the case, t here was anything unfair about the contract.
But this did not happen.
346 C, 6-10 If then the Cauconians were to live only here, these para- here = in Triphylia
doxes result. If, however, a group had been sectioned off into
the Dyma region of Elia, Athena would be describing her Dyma, Kato Achaia (Gr.)
nus. Here, too, are the sacred groves, the Ionaeum and the
Eurycydaeum . . . *.
412
The Peloponnese
346 C, 18-19 Samicum is a stronghold, and formerly t here was also a Samicum, Kato Samikon (Gr.)
and lichenae.3 People say that the “Alphius” has been so named
from its use in curing alphus.
347 C, 3-16 The sluggishness of the Anigrus and the backward pressure
of the sea result in stagnant rather than flowing water. Thus
people say that it was formerly called “Mimneius” (Holding-still)
and that some people adapted the name, replacing it with
“Minyeius.” T here are other etymologies for the name. It may
have its origin in the “Minyans,” who accompanied Nestor’s
mother, Chloris, from Minyian Orchomenus.4 Or it may originate
in the “Minyans” who, being descendants of the Argonauts, fled
from Lemnos to Lacedaemon, thence to Triphylia, where they
settled in the Arena region, in the territory now called “Hypae-
sia,” although it no longer has any Minyan settlements. Some of
these people, sailing away with Theras (son of Autesion)—this
fellow was a descendant of Polynices—to the island between
Cyrenaea and Crete (“Callista” of old, then “Thera” by name, as Thera (island), Santorini
(Gk. island)
Callimachus (3rd c. BCE) Callimachus says), founded Thera as the metropolis of Cyrene
and made the island homonymous with the city. |
347 C, 17-19 Between the Anigrus and mountain range from which 8.3.20
[ 1 ] The “title” Catalogue refers to a part of Homer’s Iliad: 4 C, 14-20n; cf. 639 C,
15-27n.
[ 2 ] The relevant passage of Homer is cited in full at 349 C, 5-12.
[ 3 ] The names refer to various skin diseases.
[ 4 ] Minyian is the adjective used by Homer to describe Orchomenus: 414 C, 19-29.
413
3.3. Greece
side it. (From the Alphius, it is some seven hundred and fifty;
from Chelonatas, one thousand and thirty.)
348 C, 4-14 In between are the t emple to “Macistian” Heracles and the
Acidon river, which runs past Iardanus’s Tomb and past Chaa, Chaa, ?Kalydona (Gr.)
a city that once existed near Lepreum, and which is the loca-
tion of the Aepasian plain. Some people say that this was the
Chaa over which the war was fought (by the Arcadians against
the Pylians) that is described by Homer; and they suppose
that one should write, would that I was young again, as when, on
the banks of the swift-flowing Acidon, a b attle was fought / between
the massed Pylians and Arcadians, / by the walls of Chaa (rather
than Celadon or Pheia),3 on the grounds that this location is nearer
than the other to Iardanus’s Tomb and to the Arcadians. |
348 C, 15-20 . . . * Cyparissia, Pyrgi, the Acidon river, and the Neda, are Cyparissia, Kyparissia (Gr.) 8.3.22
Pyrgi, Ag. Elias (Gr.) on the Triphylian sea. Triphylia’s current-day boundary with Neda, Bouzi r.
[ 1 ] 346 C, 18-19.
[ 2 ] 343 C, 28-35; 344 C, 25-32; 346 C, 13-17.
[ 3 ] Pheia is the name preferred by Strabo: 342 C, 38–343 C, 5.
414
The Peloponnese
and joins the sea where the last of the Triphylians (the Pyrgi-
tans) border on the first of the Messenians (the Cyparissians).
348 C, 20-26 In antiquity, the division was made differently, so that
some of the parts beyond the Neda—Cyparisseeis1 and some
other parts on the far side—were subject to Nestor, in just the
poet = Homer (8th c. BCE) same way as the poet extends the Pylian sea as far as the seven
cities that Agamemnon promised to Achilles: all are close to
the sea, far away from “emathoeis” 2 Pylos (equivalent to near the
Pylian sea). |
348 C, 27-31 Following on from Cyparisseeis, if you sail along the coast 8.3.23
[1] The lines of Homer in which Cyparisseeis appears are cited at 349 C, 5-12.
[2] 336 C, 27-32n.
[3] 337 C, 20-25.
[4] 340 C, 6–341 C, 17.
[5] Meaning of Coele: 336 C, 33-36n.
[6] In what follows (349 C, 13–353 C, 18), Strabo provides a commentary on this
passage from Homer.
415
3.3. Greece
349 C, 19-24 As for well-built Aepy (Steep), some people wonder which was
Strabo discusses possible the epithet of the other, and which city she was, and whether
identifications of Homer’s
“Aepy” she is current-day Marganae in Amphidolia. This city is not This city = Marganae
Not called by the same name, the latter is nevertheless now Messenian Cyparissia,
Kyparissia (Gr.)
called by the name of “Cyparissia,” which is similar, albeit in
the singular and in the feminine gender; and the river is called
“Cyparissëeis.”
349 C, 36-37 Amphigenia is in the Hypsois region, also in Macistia, and
Identification of Homer’s
“Amphigenia” is the location of the t emple to Leto.
349 C, 37–350 C, 2 Pteleum was a settlement founded by colonizers from
Identification of Homer’s Thessalian Pteleum (Antron by the sea, and grassy Pteleum refers
“Pteleum”
to the latter); and there’s a wooded site, uninhabited, called
“Pteleasium.”
350 C, 2-6 Some people say that Helos (Marsh) was a territory in the Al-
Identification of Homer’s “Helos” phius region, and some even say it was a city like the Laconian
416
The Peloponnese
one (Helos, a city by the sea); others say that it was a marsh in the
region of Alorium, wherefore the temple to “Helian” (Marshy)
Artemis, under Arcadian control (they held the priesthood).
350 C, 6-12 Some people say that Dorium was a mountain, some that
Identification of Homer’s it was a plain, some that it was a town. Nothing is now iden-
“Dorium”
tified. Nevertheless, some say that Dorium was current-day
“Oluris” or “Olura,” situated in what is called the “Valley
of Messenia.” Also somewhere around h ere is Oechalia (the
city belonging to Eurytus),1 current-day “Andania,” an Ar- Andania, Kallirhoe (Gr.)
Nestor, which in its entirety he calls the land of the Pylians,3 he = Homer
lies on either side of the Alphius. The Alphius touches nei- Alphius, Alpheios r.
417
3.3. Greece
351 C, 7-15 If one were to suppose that the Elian Pylos was the one 8.3.27
Acidon, the Alphius, and places between t hese. If any places Alphius, Alpheios r.
418
The Peloponnese
352 C, 8-10 The Pylians, when they realized what was g oing on, set off
immediately to help. After spending the night in the region of
the Minyeius river near Arena, from there they arrived at the
Alphius in the fullness of day, which means “at noon.”
352 C, 10-18 They sacrificed to the gods and spent the night at the river.
As soon as dawn broke, they joined b attle. Inflicting a glori-
ous rout, they did not cease from pursuit and slaughter u ntil
they reached Buprasium / and the Olenian Rock and Alisius, what
is called / the “Hill of,” / where Athena turned the men back. And
further on: but the Achaeans / steered their swift horses back from
Buprasium to Pylos. |
352 C, 19-20 In the light of these considerations,1 how could anyone 8.3.29
352 C, 23-30 How is it that they overran and plundered their own land?
How is it that they simultaneously were ruled by Augeas and
Neleus, when t hese men w ere the enemies each of the other?
(If, at any rate, it is true that to Neleus, a large debt was owing in
sacred Elis, / four prizewinning h orses with chariots, / who went t here
for the games. They were to compete / for the tripod. However, Auge-
ias, master of men, / kept them, and sent back only the charioteer.)
[ 1 ] 352 C, 1-18.
419
3.3. Greece
352 C, 31-37 If Neleus lived there, then that is where Nestor ruled, too. there = in Elian Pylos
How is it, then, that the Elians and Buprasians had four chiefs,
and each was accompanied by / ten swift ships, with many Epians
on board ?1 How is it that the territory was divided into four
parts, over not one of which Nestor ruled (but over those who
dwelt in Pylos, and in lovely Arena, and in the succeeding areas
as far as Messene)?
352 C, 37-39 How is it that the Epians, when they “launched a retalia-
tory attack” against the Pylians, set out for the Alphius and Alphius, Alpheios r.
Thryum? How is it that, a fter the battle there, they turn and
fled to Buprasium?
352 C, 40–353 C, 3 Alternatively, if it was Messenian Pylos that Heracles Messenian Pylos,
S. Petrochorion (Gr.)
eople who lived so far
p devastated, how is it that people who lived so far away w ere
away = Epians
arrogant toward them and involved in many contractual obli- them = Pylians
353 C, 6-10 On the third day, they all came to Thryoessa and the Alphius they all = Epians
river to besiege the stronghold. How is it that these areas— Alphius, Alpheios r.
although they were held by Cauconians, Triphylians, and
Pisatans—belonged to men who ruled Messenia?
353 C, 10-12 As for “Gerena” or “Gerenia” (spelled both ways), perhaps Gerena/Gerenia, ?Zarnatas (Gr.)
but not the Alphius, whose broad stream flows through the land of
the Pylians—which land was ruled by Nestor! What account
would be believed that transports the man to a foreign terri- the man = Nestor
420
The Peloponnese
nodded with his dark brow / and the lord’s ambrosial hair streamed
in waves / from his immortal head. He shook great Olympus.
354 C, 13-20 This (particularly the brow) seems well expressed, in that
poet = Homer (8th c. BCE) the poet invites us to paint a mental picture of i mmense form
and immense power worthy of Zeus. He does likewise in the
case of Hera, albeit at the same time preserving what is ap-
propriate to each. He says, she shuddered on her throne, and shook
high Olympus. What happens in her case when she shakes her
whole body, happens in the case of Zeus merely with the nod
of his brow, with his hair being likewise affected. The state-
ment that “he is alone in seeing, or alone in representing, the
images of the gods” is nicely put.
421
3.3. Greece
354 C, 21-31 The Elians very much deserve to take credit for the mag-
nificence and prestige of the t emple at Olympia. During the Olympia, Archaia Olympia (Gr.)
Trojan period, and before it, they had not prospered, having Trojan period, late 2nd–early
1st millennium BCE
been brought low by the Pylians and later by Heracles (when
their king, Augeas, was overthrown). The proof of this is that
they sent forty ships to Troy, while the Pylians and Nestor
sent ninety. Later, after the return of the Heraclids, the op-
posite was the case. The Aetolians—who returned with the
Heraclids u nder the leadership of Oxylus and formed joint
settlements with the Epians on account of their ancient
kinship—enlarged Coele Elis1 and took over a large part of
Pisatis, and Olympia became subject to them. The Olym-
pic games w ere instituted by them; and it was they who cel-
ebrated the first Olympiads.
354 C, 31–355 C, 7 One should disregard the ancient stories about both the
foundation of the t emple and the institution of the games,
some p eople claiming that their f ounder was the “Heracles”
who was one of the Idaean dactyli, others claiming that it was
the son of Alcmena and Zeus, who was also the first competi- son of Alcmena and
Zeus = Heracles, hero of Greek
tor and the first victor. Various such tales are told, and they myth
have no credibility at all. It is more credible that, up until the
twenty-sixth Olympiad = twenty-sixth Olympiad (counting from the first, in which the first [Olympiad] = 776 BCE
676 BCE
Elian Coroebus was victorious in the foot race), the Elians
controlled both the temple and the games.
355 C, 7-9 In the Trojan period, either there were no garlanded Trojan period, late 2nd–early
1st millennium BCE
Strabo argues against the games or they w ere not famous, neither these games nor any
existence of the Olympic games garlanded = with garlands
in the Trojan period of the others that are now famous. Homer does not mention awarded as prizes
any of them but instead mentions certain funeral games.
355 C, 9-19 Some p eople think that he does mention the Olym- he = Homer
422
The Peloponnese
[ 1 ] 336 C, 27-32n.
[ 2 ] Division of Pisatis into 8 cities: 355 C, 31–356 C, 9.
423
3.3. Greece
poet = Homer (8th c. BCE) the territory called “Pisa,” just as the poet calls Lesbos city of
Euripides (5th c. BCE) Macar; just as Euripides, in the Ion, says Euboea is a city neigh-
boring on Athens and, in the Rhadamanthys, says those who hold
Sophocles (5th c. BCE) the Euboean land, the neighboring city; and just as Sophocles,
in the Mysians, says the whole land is called “Asia,” O stranger; /
“Mysia” is the name of the city of the Mysians. |
356 C, 24-31 Salmona is near the spring of the same name, from which 8.3.32
the Enipeus flows. It joins the Alphius and is now called the Enipeus, Lestenitsa r.
“Barnichius.” P eople say that Tyro fell in love with this river
(she who fell in love with the divine river Enipeus), as this was where
Euripides (5th c. BCE) her father, Salmoneus, was king, as also claimed by Euripides
in his Aeolus. People write “Elipeus” for the river in Thessaly
that flows from Othrys, and which is joined by the Apidanus,
coming down from Pharsalus.
356 C, 31–357 C, 4 Near Salmona is Heraclia, also one of the eight cities, Heraclia, Brouma/Herakleia (Gr.)
which runs the Parthenias river (or those heading in the di-
rection of Pheraea). Pheraea is part of Arcadia, lying above
Dymaea, Buprasium, and Elis, which are north of Pisatis.
357 C, 4-6 Here, too, is Cicysium, one of the eight cities; and also
Dyspontium, lying in a plain on the road from Elis to Olym-
pia. She was abandoned, and most of her citizens emigrated
to Epidamnus and Aetolia.
357 C, 7-8 Pholoa is an Arcadian mountain inland from Olympia and Pholoa, Pholoe mt. (Gr.)
[ 1 ] The “title” Catalogue refers to a part of Homer’s Iliad: 4 C, 14-20n; cf. 639 C,
15-27n.
[ 2 ] The expression “the Heraclids associated with Temenus” is idiomatic, meaning
simply “the Heraclid Temenus.”
424
The Peloponnese
425
3.3. Greece
b ecause they thought they would thus have allies in destroying Phidon,
who had deprived them of the hegemony over the Peloponnesians that
they had previously possessed; they did indeed help in the destruction
of Phidon; and those p eople assisted the Elians in establishing Pisatis
and Triphylia.
358 C, 25-26 The length of the entire voyage along the coast of current-
day Elia, if you don’t follow its indentations, amounts to a
total of one thousand two hundred stades.
358 C, 26 That was my account of Elia.1 |
358 C, 27–359 C, 2 Following on from Elia, in the direction of the south and the 8.4.1
MESSENIA Libyan sea, is Messenia. In the Trojan period, it was categorized Trojan period, late 2nd–early
sw. Peloponnese 1st millennium BCE
(since it was part of Laconia) as subject to Menelaus, and the
territory was called “Messene.” The city currently known by
the name “Messene,” whose acropolis was Ithoma, had not yet Messene (city), Mavromati (Gr.)
been founded. A fter Menelaus’s death, since his successors in Ithoma, Ithome mt.
Laconia w ere feeble, the Neleids took over Messenia.
359 C, 2-14 At the time of the Heraclids’ return and the territorial di-
visions that took place then, Melanthus was king of the Mes-
senians as a people in their own right. They were earlier sub-
ject to Menelaus, as is shown by the evidence. The seven cities
that Agamemnon promised to give to Achilles—Cardamyla,
Enopa, and grassy Hira, / sacred Pherae and deep-meadowed An-
thia, / beautiful Aepia, and vine-clad Pedasus 2—were on the
Messenian gulf and the next gulf along (called “Asinaean,”
after Messenian Asina); and he would not have promised cit- Messenian Asina, Koroni (Gr.)
poet = Homer (8th c. BCE) ies that belonged to neither him nor his brother! The poet
also has men from Pherae fighting alongside Menelaus. And
he includes Oetylus, situated on the Messenian gulf, in the
Laconian Catalogue.3
359 C, 15-21 Messenia comes after Triphylia.4 They share a common
headland, after which there’s Coryphasium. Seven stades in-
land from this and from the sea, there’s a mountain range,
Aegaleum. | Ancient Pylos (the Messenian one) lay at the foot Messenian Pylos, S. 8.4.2
Petrochorion (Gr.)
of Aegaleum. When she was destroyed, some of her inhab-
itants settled on Coryphasium. The Athenians, when they
set sail for a second time (with Eurymedon and Sophocles)
against Sicily, refounded the city as a bulwark against the
Lacedaemonians.
359 C, 21-29 Here, too, is Cyparissia (the Messenian one), . . . *, and Cyparissia, Kyparissia (Gr.)
off the coast near Pylos, the island of Sphagia, also known as
426
The Peloponnese
and Taenarum.
360 C, 4-10 In the intervening space, starting from the Thyrides,
there’s Oetylus (called “Boetylus” by some), then Leuctrum (a Oetylus, Oitylos (Gr.)
Cardamyla, Kardamyle (Gr.) colony sent out by the Boeotian Leuctrians); then, Cardamyla Leuctrum, Leontari (Gr.)
sits on top of a steep rock; then t here’s Pharae,2 bordering on Pharae, Kalamata (Gr.)
Thuria and Gerena, after which, people say, Nestor was called Thuria, Aithaia/Hellenika (Gr.)
“Gerenian” b ecause he was rescued there, as I noted earlier.3 Gerena/Gerenia, ?Zarnatas (Gr.)
In Gerenia, a temple is identified to “Triccaean” Asclepius, an
offshoot of the temple in Thessalian Tricca.
360 C, 10-16 It is said that Pelops founded Leuctrum, Charadra, and
Thalamae (now called “Boeoti”) when he gave his sister, Thalamae/Boeoti, Thalames
(Gr.)
Niobe, in marriage to Amphion and brought certain people
out of Boeotia. Next to Pharae is the outlet of the Nedon, Nedon, Nedon r.
[ 1 ] Strabo defines the name Pedasus as it appears in the lines of Homer cited at
359 C, 2-14.
[ 2 ] Strabo defines the names Cardamyla and Pherae (here called “Pharae”) as they
appear in the lines of Homer cited at 359 C, 2-14.
[ 3 ] Strabo adds to his earlier statement (339 C, 31–340 C, 5, where he does not use
the name form “Gerena” nor refer to the story of Nestor’s rescue).
[ 4 ] Possibly, Hira is meant, described as “grassy” in the lines of Homer cited at 359 C,
2-14.
[ 5 ] In the lines of Homer cited at 359 C, 2-14.
[ 6 ] Cardamyla, Pherae (under name “Pharae”), 360 C, 4-10; Pedasus, 359 C, 30-33.
427
3.3. Greece
ders on Pharae.2 She is situated on a lofty hill, whence the Pharae, Kalamata (Gr.)
the intervening Asina (since she, of all the Messenian cities, ?Asina, Koroni (Gr.)
of the Pamisus river, on the right of which are this city and Pamisus, Pamisos r.
the cities that come after it (with Pylos and Cyparissia farthest
to the west, and midway between them, Erana, which some
people have earlier wrongly supposed was called “Arena”),
and on the left of which are Thuria and Pharae. It is the largest Thuria, Aithaia/Hellenika (Gr.)
inside the isthmus = in of the rivers inside the isthmus, albeit flowing no more than Pharae, Kalamata (Gr.)
Peloponnese
one hundred stades from its sources, in a full stream through
the Messenian plain and what is called “Macaria.” The river is
fifty stades away from the current-day Messenian city. There’s
another “Pamisus,” a small mountain stream that flows near another Pamisus, Milia r.
[ 1 ] 350 C, 6-12.
[ 2 ] 360 C, 4-10.
[ 3 ] 336 C, 27-32; 339 C, 17-20; 343 C, 36–344 C, 7.
428
The Peloponnese
361 C, 22-32 The Messenian city is like Corinth. Both cities have, loom- Messenian city = Messene, 8.4.8
Mavromati (Gr.)
ing over them, a steep and lofty mountain, contained within
the city wall so that it functions as an acropolis, one mountain
called “Ithoma” and the other called “Acrocorinthus.” Con-
Demetrius of Pharus (4th–early sequently, Demetrius of Pharus seems to have given good
3rd c. BCE)
advice to Philip (son of Demetrius), when he said that the
man who wants the Peloponnese should hold both cities: he
who seizes both horns will hold down the cow (meaning, by horns,
Ithoma and Acrocorinthus; by cow, the Peloponnese). Indeed,
these two cities have always been fought over b ecause of their
good locations: Corinth was razed and then rebuilt by the Ro-
mans; Messene was conquered by the Lacedaemonians then
restored by the Thebans and, afterward, by Philip (son of
Amyntas). Neither acropolis was ever inhabited. |
361 C, 33–362 C, 6 The t emple to Artemis in Limnae is where the Messenians Limnae, ?Volimnos (Gr.) 8.4.9
429
3.3. Greece
362 C, 23-24 The second war, then, was in Tyrtaeus’s time. People say
that a third war and a fourth war took place, in which the Mes-
senians w ere utterly destroyed.
362 C, 25-26 The voyage along the entire Messenian coast, if you go in
and out of e very bay, is some eight hundred stades. |
362 C, 27-32 However, I w ill travel beyond the bounds of moderation 8.4.11
if I follow all the many stories that are told concerning ter-
ritory that has for the most part been abandoned, which is
LACONIA why Laconia has a population shortage, compared with her
se. Peloponnese
flourishing population in antiquity. Outside Sparta, t here are
only some small towns remaining, about thirty in number. It
is said that, in antiquity, Laconia was called “Hecatompolis”
(Hundred-citied), and this is why they hold the yearly “Hecatom-
430
The Peloponnese
leae, t here’s the city of Amathus; then Asina and Gythium, Amathus, harbor at Porto Kagio
(Gr.)
Sparta’s seaport, situated at a distance of two hundred and
Asina, ?Skoutari (Gr.)
forty stades. People say that it has an artificially dug-out
Gythium, Gythion (Gr.)
dock. Then the Eurotas has its outlet between Gythium and
Eurotas, Evrotas r.
Acraeae. For a while, the voyage is along a strand—for some
Acraeae, Kokkinia (Gr.)
two hundred and forty stades. Then there’s a marshy area set
back from the sea, and the village of Helos (Marsh). It was for-
merly a city, as Homer says: those who held Amyclae and Helos, a
city on the sea. It was founded by Helius, son of Perseus. There’s
Cyparissia, Boza (Gr.) a plain, too, called “Leuca”; then the city of Cyparissia, situ-
ated on a peninsula, with her harbor; then Onugnathus with Onugnathus, Ag. Maria/
Elaphonisas (Gr.)
Boea, Neapolis (Gr.) her harbor; then the city of Boea, then Maleae. It is one hun-
dred and fifty stades from Onugnathus to Maleae. Maleae, Akra Maleas
364 C, 2-3 The city of Asopus, too, is in Laconia. | Asopus, Plytra (Gr.)
364 C, 4-22 As for the places catalogued by Homer, people say that 8.5.3
Evidence that Homer’s “Messa” Messa is nowhere identified; that Messoa is not a part of the
is an abbreviated name form
territory but a part of Sparta (as are Limnaeum and Thor- territory = Laconia
poet = Homer (8th c. BCE) • the poet’s use of the words kri and do and maps and his kri = abbreviation for “krithe”
(= barley)
reference to the heroes Automedon and Alkimos (rather
do = abbreviation for “doma”
than Alkimedon) (= house)
Hesiod (late 8th–7th c. BCE) • Hesiod’s saying bri for brithu (heavy) and briaron (strong) maps = abbreviation for
Sophocles, Ion, Epicharmus, • Sophocles’s and Ion’s rha for rhadion (easy) “mapsidios” (= at random)
Empedocles (5th c. BCE)
• Epicharmus’s li for lian (very) and Syrako for Syrakoussai
• the statement in Empedocles that for the two there is one
“ops,” instead of opsis (sight).
Antimachus (late 5th–early • in Antimachus, the sacred “ops” of Eleusinian Demeter,
4th c. BCE)
and alphi for alphiton (barley meal)
Euphorion (3rd c. BCE) • Euphorion says hel for helos (marsh)
[ 1 ] 358 C, 27–359 C, 2.
431
3.3. Greece
Philitas, Simmias (late 4th–early • the statement in Philitas that the slave girls put into bas-
3rd c. BCE)
kets the white “eri,” for erion (wool)
Aratus (3rd c. BCE) • Aratus says the “peda”—for pedalia (oars) to the wind
• Simmias says Dodo for Dodona.
364 C, 22-29 As for other places mentioned by the poet, some have dis
poet = Homer (8th c. BCE) appeared completely, of o thers only traces remain, and o thers
have undergone a name change—for example, Augiae is Ae- Aegaeae, Aigiai (Gr.)
gaeae (for the one in Locris no longer exists at all). As for Las, Las, Passavas (Gr.)
the story is that the Dioscuri once took it by siege, as a result Dioscuri = Castor and Pollux
Sophocles (5th c. BCE) of which they got named the “Lapersae” (Las-sackers): Sophocles
says somewhere by the two Lapersae, and thirdly by Eurotas, / and
by the gods in Argos and those of Sparta. |
364 C, 30-39 Ephorus says that the Heraclids (Eurysthenes and Procles) who 8.5.4
Ephorus (4th c. BCE) seized Laconia divided it into six parts and citified the territory; they
chose one of the parts (Amyclae) and gave it as a choice prize to the
man who, having betrayed Laconia to them, persuaded the person in
whose possession it was to depart 1 with the Achaeans under the terms
of a treaty and go to Ionia,2 and they declared Sparta their own royal
residence; to the other parts they sent kings and, b ecause of the popula-
tion shortage, granted them the right to receive any willing foreigners
as colonists; they used Las as their dockyard because of its good harbor,
Aegys as their fortress against enemies (since they had borders with all
those around them), and Pharis . . . * (since it provided a safeguard
against t hose from the interior as well as those from abroad).
364 C, 39–365 C, 8 All the “Perioeci,” while subject to the Spartiates, nevertheless had
the same status, sharing in the citizenship and offices of state; Agis (son
of Eurysthenes) got rid of their equal status and ordered them to pay
tax to Sparta; while most obeyed, the Helians who held Helos—they
were called “Helots”—fomented a revolution, w ere forcibly subdued
in a war, and w ere decreed to be slaves, with certain conditions, namely
that it was not possible for an o wner either to free them or to sell them
outside the borders; and this was called the “War against the Helots.”
365 C, 8-11 (It is virtually the case that t hose associated with Agis 3 laid
down the rules for the subsequent helot system that persisted
up u ntil the Roman conquest: the Lacedaemonians held them
in a way as public slaves, reserving certain settlements for
them and special duties.) |
365 C, 12-20 As for Laconian government and its iterations, one might 8.5.5
[ 1 ] Strabo omits, or momentarily forgets, the name of the man who betrayed La-
conia and the name of the man who was “persuaded . . . to depart.” A few lines
later, Strabo recalls the name of the former as Philonomus (365 C, 20-23); many
hundreds of lines later, he gives the name of the latter as Tisamenus (383 C,
28–384 C, 9).
[ 2 ] For the sense in which “Achaeans” and “Ionia” are used: 383 C, 28–384 C, 3.
[ 3 ] “Those associated with Agis” is idiomatic, meaning predominantly Agis.
432
The Peloponnese
from Rome, since at that time they w ere subject to tyrants and governors = of Roman province
of Macedonia
their government was in disarray. When they had reorganized
themselves, they were held in exceptionally high respect and
preserved their freedom, rendering nothing other than their
services as friends.
366 C, 1-4 Eurycles recently caused a stir among them. He seemed to
make too much use of his friendship with Caesar in exercising Caesar = Augustus Caesar
his rule over them. The stir swiftly died down. He passed on,
and his son has distanced himself from all such ambition.2
366 C, 4-6 It also so happened that the F ree Laconians received some
sort of political status, since the Perioeci (especially the Hel-
ots) w ere the first to go over to the Romans when Sparta was
subject to tyrants.
366 C, 6-20 Hellanicus says that Eurysthenes and Procles drew up the con-
stitution. Ephorus however castigates him, noting that he no-
[ 1 ] Achaïca (lit., “Stuff about Achaea”) is the section of Strabo’s narrative (383 C,
1–388 C, 12) in which he describes Achaea and Ionia (nw. Peloponnese) and
within which he refers to the Achaean migration (383 C, 12–384 C, 3). For Strabo’s
use of such “titles”: 639 C, 15-27n.
[ 2 ] These words are probably written in the year 19 or 20 CE, when Laco (Eurycles’s
son) assumed power.
433
3.3. Greece
Ephorus (4th c. BCE) criticizes where mentions Lycurgus; he ascribes the achievements of the latter
Hellanicus (5th c. BCE)
to men who d on’t deserve it; only Lycurgus has a t emple erected to him him = Lycurgus
and sacrifices held yearly in his honor, while those fellows, although those fellows = Eurysthenes and
Procles
they were the colonizers, have not even been accorded the honor of
having their descendants called “Eurysthenids” and “Proclids” re-
spectively, but rather “Agiads” (after Agis, son of Eurysthenes) and
“Eurypontids” (after Eurypontus, son of Procles), since the latter latter men = Agis and
Eurypontus
men truly exercised power, while the former, accepting people from
former = Eurysthenes and
elsewhere, exercised their power through them, which is why they are Procles
not even give the status of “Founders,” which is given to all colonizers;
Pausanias, one of the Eurypontids, banished by the opposing h ouse,1
wrote while in exile a treatise on the laws of Lycurgus (who was a
member of the banishing house), in which he also mentions the oracu-
lar prophecies given to him in the form of a g reat many panegyrics.2 | him = Lycurgus
366 C, 21-38 As for the physical nature of these and Messenian these = Laconian localities 8.5.6
Euripides (5th c. BCE) localities,3 one should agree with t hese words of Euripides.
Regarding Laconia, he describes it having much that is arable,
but it is not easy to till: / a protected plateau, enclosed by mountains,
rocky, / difficult for enemies to invade. As for Messenia: fruitful,
/ crossed by a myriad of streams, / with good pasture for c attle and
sheep, / made neither unpleasantly cold by wintry winds / nor too hot
by Helius’s chariot and four. Further on, concerning the lots that
the Heraclids drew for the territory, he says that the first was
for lordship over Lacaenian land, with its earth of poor quality. The
second was for Messene, with more fertility than can be expressed
Tyrtaeus (7th c. BCE) in words, which is how Tyrtaeus, too, describes it.
366 C, 38–367 C, 7 One should not, however, agree with him when he says
that Laconia and Messenia are separated from each other by
the Pamisus, rushing headlong to the sea, for it runs through the
middle of the Messenia, nowhere even touching current-day
Laconia. Nor is he correct, given that Messenia is situated
on the sea just like Laconia, in saying that it is far away for
mariners. Nor is he correct in giving the boundary of Elis: as
you proceed beyond the river, you come to Elis, / neighbor of Zeus.
Either he means current-day Elia, which shares a border with
Messenia—but the Pamisus does not touch this territory,
just as it does not touch Laconia (as has been noted, it runs
through the m iddle of Messenia). Or he means ancient Elia,
called “Coele [Elis],”4 which is even further from the truth—
once you’ve crossed the river, there’s still a lot of Messenia,
[ 1 ] Ephorus errs (or Strabo errs in his citation of Ephorus): Pausanias was an Agiad,
banished by the Eurypontids.
[ 2 ] For more by Ephorus on Lycurgus’s visit to Delphi: 482 C, 19-27. For poets in
the temple who put into verse form the oracular prophecies uttered by the
priestess: 419 C, 19-26.
[ 3 ] Laconia: 362 C, 33–366 C, 20. Messenia: 359 C, 15–362 C, 32.
[ 4 ] Meaning of Coele: 336 C, 33-36n.
434
The Peloponnese
both the territory and the city (by territory, I mean to in-
clude Messenia). When he speaks thus about the bows and
arrows—beautiful bows, given to him by a friend who met him in
Lacedaemon, / Iphitus the Eurytid—and continues, the two en- Eurytid = son of Eurytus
435
3.3. Greece
ionic 3 gulfs. If you are sailing t oward the east and the Cy-
clades, the former reaches as far as Scyllaeum; the latter is Scyllaeum, Cape Spathi
Apollo homonymous with the Boeotian t emple; the Minoa Minoa, Monemvasia (Gr.)
ged for a long way, albeit with anchorages and harbors. The
remaining coastline is well supplied with harbors, and lying off
the coast are numerous small islands not worth describing. |
368 C, 23-27 Included among the Argive possessions are Prasiae and Prasiae, Paralio Leonidi (Gr.) 8.6.2
ARGIA Temenium, where Temenus lies buried; before that, the area Temenium, nr. Nea Kios
e. Peloponnese
through which runs the river called “Lerna,” homonymous
with the lake where the Hydra myth was set. Temenium is
twenty-six stades from Argos, set back from the sea. From Argos, Argos (Gr.)
Argos to Heraeum is forty stades; from t here to Mycenae, ten. Mycenae, Mykenes (Gr.)
368 C, 27–369 C, 1 After Temenium is Nauplia (Ships-sailing), the Argive dock- Nauplia, Nauplion (Gr.)
[ 1 ] The “title” Catalogue refers to a part of Homer’s Iliad: 4 C, 14-20n; cf. 639 C,
15-27n.
[ 2 ] Argolic gulf: 368 C, 12–369 C, 2.
[ 3 ] Strabo (or his scribe) perhaps meant to write “Hermionic and Saronic gulfs.”
The two gulfs are previewed jointly (335 C, 23-27, where Strabo appears to take
them as identical). See next note.
[ 4 ] “Former” is best taken as applying to the Hermionic gulf and “latter” as apply-
ing to the Saronic gulf. For their description: 369 C, 3-17; cf. 380 C, 15-19.
[ 5 ] Argive possessions: 368 C, 23–369 C, 17.
436
The Peloponnese
369 C, 1-2 Next after Nauplia are the caves and the labyrinths con-
structed within them. P eople call them “Cyclopia.” |
369 C, 3-7 Then there are various other places, and next comes the 8.6.3
HERMIONIC GULF Hermionic gulf: this section of my descriptive journey did not
appear to me . . . *, since Homer, too, categorized it as subject
Asina, Tolon/Asine (Gr.) to Argia. It starts with the town of Asina; then come Hermiona Hermiona, Ermione (Gr.)
Calauria, Poros (Gk. island) and Troizen.1 Lying off the coast is the island of Calauria, with Troizen, Damala (Gr.)
a circumference of thirty stades, separated from the mainland
by a four-stade strait. |
369 C, 8-10 Then there’s the Saronic gulf. Some people call it a “sea.” 8.6.4
SARONIC GULF According to this view, the name “Saronic ocean” is used for
the entire body of water from the Hermionic gulf and from
the sea in the isthmus region to as far as the Myrtoan ocean
and the Cretan sea.2
369 C, 10-17 Epidaurus is in the Saronic gulf, as also the island of Aegina Epidaurus, Palaia Epidauros (Gr.)
lying off it; then Cenchreae, the Corinthian dockyard, fac- Aegina, Aigina (Gk. island)
ing east; then, after sailing forty-five stades, Schoenus har- Cenchreae, Kechriai (Gr.)
bor. The total distance from Maleae is around one thousand Schoenus, Kalamaki (Gr.)
eight hundred stades. At Schoenus is Diolcus (Haul-across), the Maleae, Akra Maleas
[ 1 ] For the Homeric lines in which the names Asina, Hermiona, and Troizen are
used: 372 C, 26-31. Hermiona, Asina, 373 C, 16-25. Troizen, Calauria: 373 C, 28–
374 C, 21.
[ 2 ] Strabo corrects his e
arlier comments (335 C, 23-27, where he gives the impres-
sion that the Hermionic and Saronic gulfs are one and the same thing); cf. 368 C,
10-12n; 380 C, 15-19n.
[ 3 ] For the Homeric lines in which the names Epidaurus and Aegina are used: 372 C,
26-31. They are described in detail at 374 C, 22–376 C, 6. Cenchreae, Schoenus,
temple to “Isthmian” Posidon: 380 C, 15-19.
437
3.3. Greece
barians, the reason being that the Greeks themselves have not yet been
Apollodorus (2nd c. BCE) cites separately recognized under one name. Apollodorus claims that
Hesiod (late 8th–7th c. BCE) and
Archilochus (7th c. BCE) the Thessalians alone are called “Greeks” 1 (“they w ere called Myr-
midons and Greeks”), but Hesiod and Archilochus already knew that
“Greeks” and “Panhellenes” meant everyone together. The former says
of the Proetids that the “Panhellenes sought them in marriage,” the Proetids = daughters of Proetus
rential river with its sources on Lyrcium, the mountain on Lyrcium, Lyrkeion mt. (Gr.)
the border with Arcadia. It has already been noted that the
myths told about these sources are the fabrications of poets.2
370 C, 24-30 It is a fabrication, too, that Argos, being waterless, was ren-
Citation of Hesiod (late dered well watered by the Danaae, since its territory is a vale and Danaae = daughters of Danaus
8th–7th c. BCE)
has rivers r unning through it and features marshes and lakes,
and since the city is well supplied with w ater from many brim-
ming wells. People blame the misunderstanding on the line:
Citation of Homer (8th c. BCE) I would return in utter shame to “polydipsion” (parched) Argos. The
word stands for either polypotheton (much longed for) or, minus the
Sophocles (5th c. BCE) “d,” for polyipsion (much oppressed)—as Sophocles says, and this Pelopids = descendants of
“polyphthoron” (much destroyed) house of the Pelopids. Pelops
370 C, 30-33 The words proiapsai (to dispatch), iapsai (to mar), and ipsesthai
Strabo cites various lines of (to oppress) have a sense of some destruction and harm: now he
Homer
is practicing, soon “ipsetai” (he will oppress) the sons of the Achaeans;
and “iapsei” (she will mar) her lovely complexion; and “proiapsen” (he
dispatched [him]) to Hades.
370 C, 33-38 Besides, he uses “Argos” to mean not the city (since he he = Homer
[ 1 ] I.e., by Homer.
[ 2 ] 271 C, 18-33.
[ 3 ] Strabo continues his interpretation of the line of Homer cited at 370 C, 24-30:
I would return in utter shame to “polydipsion” Argos. The speaker is Agamem-
non, who did not reside in Argos but in Mycenae.
438
The Peloponnese
Another river in Argia is Erasinus. This latter starts from Erasinus, Kephalari r.
Stymphalus in Arcadia, and from the lake t here called “Stym- Stymphalus, Stymphalia (Gr.)
phalian,” the setting for the myth of the Birds Driven Out by the
Arrows and Drums of Heracles (and people call the birds, too,
“Stymphalian”). People say that this river, sinking below the
surface, issues into Argia and keeps the plain watered. P eople
also call the Erasinus “Arsinus.” Another river of the same
name flows from Arcadia to the coast at Bura; and there’s
another one in Eretria, and also one in Attica at Brauron. A
spring at Lerna is identified as Amymona. Lerna is a lake be-
longing to Argia and Mycenaea, the setting for the story of
the Hydra. Because of the purgings that took place in it, the
proverbial expression arose: a Lerna of ills.
371 C, 13-19 People agree, then, that the territory has a good supply
of water but the city herself lies in a waterless spot; that she
nevertheless has a good number of wells, which people attri-
Citation of Hesiod (late bute to the Danaïds as their inventors, whence the line Argos, Danaïds = daughters of Danaus
8th–7th c. BCE)
being waterless, was rendered well watered by the Danaae; that four Danaae = daughters of Danaus
the Argives, called a fter her. Thus, more recent writers say more recent = post-Homeric
[ 1 ] I.e., post-Homeric poets use “Argos” to mean all Greece. If they wish to refer
to the Peloponnese in particular, they use a qualification (“Iasian” Argos) or a
different name (“Iasians” etc.).
439
3.3. Greece
371 C, 30–372 C, 2 To show that he uses “Argos” for the Peloponnese, one can
add the following:1 Argive Helen; and Ephyra is a city in deepest
Argos; and throughout Argos; and to be lord of many islands and all
Argos. The plain, too, is called Argos by more recent writers,
but not once by Homer: people suppose that this is particu-
larly a Macedonian or Thessalian usage. |
372 C, 3-11 Sovereign rule in Argos passed to the descendants of 8.6.10
Danaus; and they were joined by the Amythaonids originat- Amythaonids = descendants of
Amythaon
ing from Pisatis and Triphylia. It should therefore come as
no surprise if these p eople, being related, initially divided
the territory into two kingdoms, in such a way that the two
cities with hegemony in the kingdoms were each made into
a metropolis, although being situated close to each other (at
a distance of less than fifty stades), namely Argos and Myce- Argos, Argos (Gr.)
nae; nor if the Heraeum (temple to Hera) in Mycenae was a joint Mycenae, Mykenes (Gr.)
temple, shared by both, in which t here w ere cult statues made
by Polyclitus, in craftsmanship superior to all o thers but in
costliness and size inferior to those made by Phidias.
372 C, 11-18 To begin with, Argos was the more powerful. Then Myce-
nae experienced greater growth, because the Pelopids joined Pelopids = descendants of
Pelops
the settlement t here. When everything devolved to the sons
of Atreus, Agamemnon, being the older son, took over power
and acquired through luck and skill a great deal of territory
over and above his existing holdings, and indeed added La-
conia to Mycenae. Menelaus got Laconia. Agamemnon took
over Mycenae and the area as far as Corinth, Sicyon, and what
was then called the “territory of Ionians and ‘Aegialians’ ” and
was subsequently called the “territory of Achaeans.”
372 C, 18-25 After the Trojan period, when Agamemnon’s rule ended, Trojan period, late 2nd–early
1st millennium BCE
Mycenae was much reduced, particularly a fter the return
of the Heraclids. When the Heraclids took control of the
Peloponnese, they expelled those who had formerly been in
power, with the consequence that those who held Argos also
held Mycenae as one unit. In later times, Mycenae was razed
by the Argives with the consequence that no trace of the
Mycenaean city can be detected t oday. Since this was the fate
of Mycenae, it should come as no surprise if some of those
places catalogued as subject to Argos, too, have nowadays
disappeared.
440
The Peloponnese
372 C, 26-31 The Catalogue1 has it as follows: those who held Argos and
walled Tiryns, / and Hermiona and Asina, deep in their gulf, / and
Troizen and Eïones and vine-rich Epidaurus, / and those who held
Aegina and Mases—Achaea’s young warriors.2 Of these, Argos has
already been discussed.3 I must now talk about the others. |
372 C, 32–373 C, 4 It is believed that Proetus used Tiryns 4 as a base of opera- Tiryns, Tirynthos (Gr.) 8.6.11
tions and walled it with the help of the Cyclopes; that t here
were seven of these, and they w ere called gasterochires (stomach-
hands) because their handiwork kept them in food; that they
came from Lycia when sent for. The caves near Nauplia,
and the works constructed inside them, are perhaps named
after them.5 The “Licymna” acropolis gets its name from
Licymnius.
373 C, 4-7 She is around twelve stades from Nauplia. She is deserted, She = Tiryns
as also the nearby Midea (which is diff erent from the Boeotian
city—the latter is pronounced “Mídeia,” like prónoia, whereas
this city is pronounced “Midéa,” like Tegéa). She is bordered
by Prosymna, also deserted, with a temple to Hera.
373 C, 8-15 Most of the cities w ere laid waste by the Argives for
being disobedient. The inhabitants of Tiryns went away to
Epidaurus, and the inhabitants of Hermiona to what is called Epidaurus, Palaia Epidauros (Gr.)
“Halieis” (Fishermen). The inhabitants of Asina—she, too, was Halieis, Porto Cheli (Gr.)
some men who earn their living from the sea, who are called
“Halieis” (Fishermen). It is a tradition among the Hermionians
that the descent to Hades is short, so they put no money into
the mouths of the dead for the ferry fare! |
373 C, 19-25 People say that Hermiona is a Dryopian habitation, as also 8.6.13
[ 1 ] The “title” Catalogue refers to a part of Homer’s Iliad: 4 C, 14-20n; cf. 639 C,
15-27n.
[ 2 ] Strabo frames the ensuing portion of his narrative (372 C, 32–376 C, 19) as a
commentary on these Homeric lines.
[ 3 ] Argos: 369 C, 18–372 C, 25.
[ 4 ] Strabo starts his commentary with an elaboration (372 C, 32–373 C, 15) on Tiryns.
[ 5 ] For these “Cyclopia”: 369 C, 1-2.
[ 6 ] Strabo continues his commentary with an elaboration (373 C, 16-19) on Herm-
iona (cf. 372 C, 26-31).
[ 7 ] Strabo continues his commentary with an elaboration (373 C, 19-25) on Asina
(cf. 372 C, 26-31).
441
3.3. Greece
442
The Peloponnese
443
3.3. Greece
[ 1 ] Illyrica (lit., “Stuff about Illyria”) is the section of Strabo’s narrative (313 C, 19–
318 C, 27) within which he describes Illyria. His specific mention of the silver
mines at Damastium (326 C, 14-20) comes within the section of narrative dealing
with Epirus (326 C, 14–327 C, 28). Strabo’s use of “titles”: 639 C, 15-27n.
[ 2 ] Strabo cites the relevant Homeric lines in full at 372 C, 26-31.
[ 3 ] See 372 C, 26-31.
444
The Peloponnese
chreae, situated on the road from Tegea to Argos through the Cenchreae, Palaio-Skaphidaki
(Gr.)
Parthenium mountain range . . . * Homer knew nothing of
them, nor of Lyrcium nor Orneae—these are villages in Argia, Lyrcium, Melissi (Gr.)
still are, Argos and Sparta.1 Because they are frequently talked Argos, Argos (Gr.)
about, they are the least necessary to describe at length—I Sparta, Sparti (Gr.)
445
3.3. Greece
377 C, 20-26 Mycenae fell to the Pelopids who had come from their base Pelopids = descendants of
Pelops
in Pisatis, then to the Heraclids who also held Argos. A fter
the naval b attle at Salamis, the Argives with the Cleonaeans
and Tegeatans attacked and utterly destroyed Mycenae and
divided up the territory between themselves. Because of the
proximity of the two cities, the writers of tragedies use the two cities = Mycenae and Argos
Euripides (5th c. BCE) names as synonyms, as if they were one—Euripides even
within one play calling the city at one point “Mycenae” and
at another point calling the same city “Argos” (e.g., in the
Iphigenia and the Orestes).
377 C, 27-32 Cleonae1 is a city lying on the route from Argos to Corinth, Cleonae, Ag. Vasileios (Gr.)
446
The Peloponnese
[ 1 ] The Greek word translated as “erections” (with the same innuendo as in E nglish)
can also mean “looms” (also, in a further twist, “ship’s masts”).
[ 2 ] The restoration of Corinth (initiated early 44 BCE) will have required several
years for completion. Strabo’s reference to the restoration as “recent” at the
time he saw it is consistent with him observing it either as he passed through
Corinth on his way (ca. 40 BCE) to Rome to start his further education or when
he passed through Corinth at a later date (29 BCE): 485 C, 30–486 C, 3.
447
3.3. Greece
Cenchreae and a harbor that is some seventy stades away from Cenchreae, Kechriai (Gr.)
the city. This is the harbor used by people coming from Asia.
For those coming from Italy, Lechaeum is the harbor that is
used.
380 C, 7-15 Lechaeum is at the foot of the city, with a settlement city = Corinth
448
The Peloponnese
are situated Oenoa and Pagae, the latter being the Megarian Oenoa, Viokastro (Gr.)
part of Megaris,2 and is the setting for the myth of the Crom-
myonian Sow (who, p eople say, was the mother of the Calydo-
nian boar). The tradition is that the slaughter of the sow was
one of Theseus’s labors.
380 C, 23-36 Tenea, too, is a village in Corinthia, with its temple to Tenea, S Chiliomodi (Gr.)
[ 1 ] Strabo perhaps corrects the impression given earlier (335 C, 23-27, where it is
implied that the Saronic and Hermionic gulf are the same).
[ 2 ] Transfer of Crommyon from Megaris to Corinthia: 392 C, 13-20; 392 C, 28–393 C,
11n.
449
3.3. Greece
fter the dispatch t here of a sizable army, the city was leveled
A
by Lucius Mummius, and the other parts as far as Macedonia Roman general L. Mummius,
took Corinth, 146 BCE
were subjected to the Romans, with various governors being
sent to various people. The Sicyonians got the greater part of
Corinthian territory.
381 C, 7-16 Polybius, speaking poignantly of the events surrounding
Polybius (2nd c. BCE) the capture, proceeds to tell of the soldiers’ heedlessness re-
garding works of art and temple offerings. He says he person-
ally saw paintings thrown to the floor, and soldiers playing
checkers on them. Of these paintings, he names the picture
by Aristides of Dionysus (the basis, according to some, of the
expression nothing compared to the “Dionysus”) and also Heracles
Tormented by Deianira’s Robe. I have not seen the latter, but I
Demetrium = temple in Rome
used to see the Dionysus—a very fine work—when it was kept to goddess Demeter (known as
in the Demetrium in Rome.1 The t emple went up in flames, “Ceres” to the Romans), which
was destroyed by fire, 31 BCE;
and the painting recently disappeared, too.2 rebuilt, 17 CE
381 C, 16-23 It is almost the case that the greatest number and the best
of the other t emple offerings in Rome also came from here. here = from Corinth
[ 1 ] The grammatical tense suggests repeated viewing by Strabo before the de-
struction of the temple (31 BCE). Comments elsewhere suggest Strabo’s pres-
ence in Rome at this period, pursuing his further studies: 273 C, 2-14n; 548 C,
9-14n.
[ 2 ] “Recently” applies grammatically to the disappearance of the painting rather
than the conflagration of the temple. Strabo had perhaps been disappointed
not to see the painting at the t emple’s reopening (17 CE), a year or two before
writing this section of his work.
450
The Peloponnese
SICYONIA her. She is now deserted but was previously a fine settlement,
ne. Peloponnese
with a much revered temple to Priapus (which is why Euphro-
nius, author of the poem Priapia, calls the god “Ornean”). She
is situated above the Sicyonian plain; her territory was held
by the Argives.
382 C, 16-25 Araethyrea 2 is the territory now called “Phliasia.” It once
included a city homonymous with the territory, beside the
Celossa mountain range. The p eople of later times emigrated
from there and founded a city thirty stades farther on, which
they called “Phlius.” Part of Celossa is Carneates, whence be- Phlius, Nemea (Gr.)
gins the Asopus, which runs alongside Sicyon and forms the Asopus, Asopos r.
phalus, which lies around her. The temple to “Dia”—this is Stymphalus, Stymphalia (Gr.)
their name for Hebe—in Phlius and Sicyon is much revered. |
382 C, 26-29 Sicyon 3 was formerly called “Mecona” and before that “Ae- Sicyon, Vasiliko (Gr.) 8.6.25
382 C, 29-33 The city was subject to tyrant rule for the longest time,
but these rulers w ere always reasonable men, with the most
famous being Aratus. He granted the city her freedom; he
ruled over the Achaeans, who willingly passed control to him;
and he expanded the confederation by adding to it his own
city and other nearby cities.
[ 1 ] Strabo comments on the lines of Homer cited at 377 C, 5-13, with an elaboration
(382 C, 12-15) on Orniae (the Homeric spelling).
[ 2 ] Strabo comments on the lines of Homer cited at 377 C, 5-13, with an elaboration
(382 C, 16-25) on Araethyrea.
[ 3 ] Strabo comments on the lines of Homer cited at 377 C, 5-13, with an elaboration
(382 C, 26-33) on Sicyon.
451
3.3. Greece
383 C, 1-6 It came about that Hyperasia, and the successive cities men- Aegialus, n. shore of
Peloponnese
ACHAEA tioned by the poet, as well as Aegialus as far as Dyma and the
n. Peloponnese Dyma, Kato Achaia (Gr.)
Elian boundaries, finally belonged to the Achaeans.1 | This ter- 8.7.1
poet = Homer (8th c. BCE) ritory was ruled in antiquity by the Ionians, who originated in
Athens. It was long ago called “Aegialia,” and its inhabitants
were called “Aegialians,” but subsequent to them it was called
“Ionia”—as was Attica—after Ion (son of Xuthus).
383 C, 7-12 It is said that Hellen was the son of Deucalion; that he held
power in the Phthia region over those areas between the Pe-
neius and the Asopus and handed the succession to his eldest
son; that he sent his other sons away to seek their own dwell-
ing place, each for himself. Of these sons, Dorus established
the “Dorians” in the Parnassus region and bequeathed his
name to them; Xuthus married the daughter of Erechtheus
and founded the Attic tetrapolis (four-city state) of Oenoa, Mara-
thon, Probalinthus, and Tricorynthus.
383 C, 12-19 As for Xuthus’s sons, Achaeus committed involuntary
murder, fled to Lacedaemon, and brought it about that the
people there were called “Achaeans.”2 Ion, however, won a vic-
tory over Eumolpus’s Thracians and was so respected that
the Athenians turned over their government to him. Ion first
divided the populace into four tribes, then into four occu-
pational groups. One group he appointed as agriculturists,
one group as artisans, one group as temple officials, and the
fourth as guardians. After making several such regulations,
he bequeathed his name to the territory.
383 C, 19-27 It happened at that time that the territory’s population
increased so much that the Athenians dispatched a colony of
Ionians to the Peloponnese, and they gave their name to the
territory they occupied, which was called “Ionia” instead of
Aegialus; 3 and the inhabitants, divided between twelve cities,
were known as “Ionians” instead of “Aegialians.” (After the
return of the Heraclids, the Ionians were driven out by the
Achaeans and went back to Athens, from where they joined
the Codrids in the Ionian colonizing expedition to Asia; and
they founded twelve cities on the coast of Caria and Lydia,
dividing themselves into the same number of parts as in the
Peloponnese.)
383 C, 28–384 C, 3 The Achaeans were Phthiotan by descent,4 but they lived
in Lacedaemon. When the Heraclids ruled supreme, the
452
The Peloponnese
began by joining together, then they absorbed others of the Dyma, Kato Achaia (Gr.)
inundated Helica and the t emple to “Heliconian” Posidon, Helica, E Aigion (Gr.)
[ 1 ] Strabo h ere adds to his earlier statement (364 C, 30-39, where he omitted the
name “Tisamenus” for the man who led the Achaeans in invading Ionia).
[ 2 ] 12 cities belonging to the Achaean federation: 385 C, 28–388 C, 12.
[ 3 ] Strabo comments on the lines of Homer cited at 377 C, 5-13, with an elaboration
(384 C, 14–385 C, 12) on Helica.
[ 4 ] Asian Ionians (sw. Turkey): 632 C, 5–647 C, 3 (esp. 639 C, 15-27 for the Panionian
festival).
453
3.3. Greece
384 C, 27-29 Those who argue the reverse transfer to Helica the stated
Strabo presents the evidence concerning the bull and the sacrifice, arguing that
counterargument
these are local customs and that the poet refers to local
sacrifices.
384 C, 29-33 The flooding of Helica took place two years before the
Eratosthenes (3rd c. BCE) battle at Leuctra. Eratosthenes says that he himself saw the
site, and that the ferrymen reported that a bronze statue of Posidon
had once stood upright in the channel, holding a sea monster in his
hand and presenting a danger to t hose fishing with nets!
384 C, 33–385 C, 9 Heraclides says that the tragedy took place one night in
Heraclides (4th c. BCE) his own times, the city being twelve stades from the coast, and all
this area being submerged along with the city. Two thousand men
sent from the Achaeans were unable to gather the corpses and allo-
cated the territory to the neighboring people. The tragedy occurred
as a result of Posidon’s anger: t hose Ionians who had been expelled
from Helica sent a delegation and requested from the Helicans the
cult statue of Posidon, ideally, or failing that, a t emple replica.
When the Helicans did not provide these things, the Ionians sent
a delegation to the Achaean confederation. Although the vote was
carried, the Helicans did not comply, and the tragedy occurred the
following winter. L ater, the Achaeans gave the t emple replica to the
Ionians.
385 C, 9-12 Hesiod mentions another “Helica,” in Thessaly: Antha,
Hesiod (late 8th–7th c. BCE) a Myrmidon city, and famous Iaolcus, / and Arna, and Helica. |
385 C, 13-24 The Achaeans continued for twenty years with a shared 8.7.3
secretary and two generals per year; a federal council was con-
vened at a single place (it was called “Hamarium”), where they
(and, before them, the Ionians) dealt with federal matters.
Then they decided to elect a single general. When Aratus was
general, he took Acrocorinthus from Antigonus and gave
it, like his native city, to the Achaeans. He acquired, in addi- native city = Sicyon
454
The Peloponnese
385 C, 24-27 Up u ntil the generalship of Philopoemen, the Achaeans Philopoemen was general,
208–182 BCE
remained quite united, but their u nion gradually fell apart,
as the Romans w ere in possession of all Greece and did not
deal with all places in the same manner, wanting to preserve
some and destroy others.
Radt excludes this paragraph Then he gives as his reason for spending so much time on
1
he = ?Polybius (2nd c. BCE)
from his edition of Strabo’s
work1
his description of the Achaeans that, although they became
so powerful that they overtook the Lacedaemonians, they are
not as famous as they should be. |
385 C, 28–386 C, 2 The sequence of places that they settled, after having 8.7.4
bring gifts for you, to Helica and Aegae. But when he says, Aegae,
where you have your famous home in the w aters deep and there
Posidon brought his h orses to a stop, it is better to take him as
meaning the one in Euboea (after which, it is reasonable to Euboean Aegae, Politika Kafkala
(Gr.)
suppose, the “Aegaean sea” got its name). That is where the
affair of Posidon in the Trojan war is depicted.
455
3.3. Greece
386 C, 23-25 Near Achaean Aegae flows the Crathis (Mingled) river, Crathis, Krathis r.
demes, so g reat was the population of the territory. deme, administrative district
386 C, 28-32 Pellena1 is a defensive stronghold sixty stades inland from Pellena, Zugra (Gr.)
the sea: it was swallowed up in an earthquake. People say that Bura, ?Kastro, nr. Diakofto (Gr.)
[ 1 ] Strabo continues with his commentary on the lines of Homer cited at 377 C,
5-13, with an elaboration (386 C, 28-32) on Pellena.
[ 2 ] Strabo seems to modify his e arlier statement (386 C, 2-8, where the place is
called “Aegae” and the inhabitants are “Aegaeans”).
[ 3 ] Strabo finishes his commentary on the lines of Homer cited at 377 C, 5-13, with
an elaboration (387 C, 2-11) on Aegium.
[ 4 ] I.e., “remain” as per the list at 385 C, 28–386 C, 2.
456
The Peloponnese
387 C, 24-28 After these comes Patrae, a city of some significance (and Patrae, Patras (Gr.)
in between are Rhium and Antirrhium, forty stades from Pa- Rhium, Rion (Gr.)
trae.) The Romans recently settled a significant part of the Antirrhium, Antirion (Gr.)
army h ere, in the wake of the victory at Actium; and the city
is exceptionally well populated, being now a Roman colony.
She has quite a good anchorage.
387 C, 28–388 C, 3 Next, and farthest west of all (whence her name) comes
Dyma (Sundown), a city without a harbor. She was formerly Dyma, Kato Achaia (Gr.)
flows from a mountain (which the locals call “Scollis,” and Scollis, Skollis mt. (Gr.)
Antimachus (late 5th–early Homer calls the Olenian Rock). Antimachus calls Dyma “Cau-
4th c. BCE)
conian.” Some people understood this name to be derived
from the Cauconians, who extended this far, as I said above.1
Others understood it to be derived from a river “Caucon,” just Caucon, Toporoviti r.
457
3.3. Greece
Methydrium, Nemnitsa/ the Caphyans, and Cynaetha, either no longer exist or scarcely Cleitor, Kleitor (Gr.)
Methydrion (Gr.)
any traces or signs of them are visible. Tegea still exists in Pheneus, Kalyvia (Gr.)
Caphyae, Chotussa (Gr.)
a moderate way, as does the temple to “Alean” Athena; also Stymphalus, Stymphalia (Gr.)
Cynaetha, Kalavryta (Gr.)
honored in a small way is the t emple to “Lycaean” Zeus on Ly- Tegea, Piali/Episkopi (Gr.)
poet = Homer (8th c. BCE) caeum . . . * mountain. Of the cities mentioned by the poet,
Rhipa and Stratia and wind-blown Enispa are difficult to find
and of no use to t hose who find them, on account of their
being deserted. |
388 C, 37–389 C, 2 Famous mountain ranges other than Cyllena are Pholoa, Pholoa, Pholoe mt. (Gr.) 8.8.3
tas has already been noted,1 as also concerning the Erasinus,2 Eurotas, Evrotas r.
which now flows from the Stymphalian lake into Argia but Erasinus, Kephalari r.
formerly had no outlet, given that the berethra (underground chan-
nels), called by the Arcadians zerethra, were dead ends that did
not allow any egress. The consequence was that the Stympha-
lian city, which is now . . . * stades away from the lake, at that
time lay on its shore.
389 C, 9-12 The Ladon suffered the reverse phenomenon. Its stream Ladon, Ladon r.
458
The Peloponnese
Artemidorus (late 2nd–early the Ister is around ten thousand stades. Artemidorus plau- Maleae, Akra Maleas
1st c. BCE) corrects Polybius
(2nd c. BCE) sibly corrects this, saying that the road from Maleae to Aegium Aegium, Aigion (Gr.)
is one thousand four hundred [stades]; the voyage from t here to Cir- Cirrha, Magoula Xeropigadas
(Gr.)
rha is two hundred; the road from there through Heraclia . . . *
five hundred; then to Larisa . . . * three hundred and forty; then Larisa, Larisa (Gr.)
through . . . * outlets of the Peneius, two hundred and forty . . . * Thessalonicia, Thessalonike/
Salonica (Gr.)
Thessalonicia six hundred and sixty, thence through Idomena,
Idomena, ?Isar-Marvinci
that fellow = Polybius Stobi, and the Dardanians, three thousand . . . *; according to that (N. Mac.)
fellow,2 the distance from Thessalonicia is six thousand five hundred; Stobi, Pustogradsko/Stobi
he = Polybius the explanation for this is that he did not measure the direct route but (N. Mac.)
459
3.3. Greece
390 C, 1-7 Having circuited the Peloponnese,2 which I said was the first 9.1.1
on the right-hand side it will leave the entire Peloponnese to the south,
while on the left-hand side and to the north it will leave the coast that
is continuous from the Ceraunian mountains as far as the Crisaean Crisaean gulf = e. end of Gulf
of Corinth
gulf7 and Megaris, and the entire Attic coast. One would not conceive
of the smooth coastline from Sunium to the isthmus as forming a gulf,
because it would have only a slight concavity, were not the places in
the Peloponnese adjacent to the isthmus—namely the region of the
Hermionic gulf and Acta—added to it. Nor, similarly, would one
conceive of the coastline from the Ceraunians to the Corinthian gulf
as having so g reat a concavity as to form a hollowed-out gulf in its own
right. The narrow convergence of Rhium and Antirrhium to form Rhium, Rion (Gr.)
a strait gives this impression, as likewise the region of the Crisaean Antirrhium, Antirion (Gr.)
dred and thirty stades from Sunium. The distance to Pagae Pagae, Alepochori (Gr.)
[1] Megaris + Attica as the “first band” of Greece: 400 C, 15-23. [ 6 ] Strabo alludes playfully to the inscription on an ancient boundary marker, which
[2] 335 C, 1–389 C, 42. put Crommyonia in Attica/Ionia (392 C, 10-20; 392 C, 38–393 C, 11). In Strabo’s
[3] Greece as a series of 5 nested peninsulas: 334 C, 17-34. own day, Crommyon belongs to Corinth (380 C, 19-22). There is some manu-
[4] Strabo uses the past tense b ecause his initial 5-peninsula model of Greece script damage: it is possible that Strabo wrote, or dictated, Crommyonia (rather
(previous note) is now superseded by a 5-band model (next note). than Crommyon) and Ionians (rather than Megarians).
[ 5 ] Strabo now transitions to a model in which Greece comprises 5 bands. 1st band [ 7 ] Crisaean gulf: 336 C, 5-13n.
(Attica + Megaris): 390 C, 8–400 C, 10. 2nd band (Boeotia): 400 C, 11–416 C, [ 8 ] I.e., the “side” from Sunium to the isthmus, specified in the preceding
10. 3rd band (Phocis): 417 C, 27–425 C, 5. 4th band (Locris): 425 C, 6–429 C, 15. paragraph.
5th band (Thessaly, Euboea, Acarnania, Aetolia): 429 C, 15–466 C, 7.
460
First Band: Megaris + Attica
391 C, 22-23 These are the regions I will cover, picking up from the
stretch of coast where I left off.3 |
391 C, 24-31 After Crommyon, the Scironian cliffs rise above the shore- Crommyon, Ag. Theodori (Gr.) 9.1.4
out, creating the harbor in Nisaea. Nisaea is the Megarian Nisaea, nr. Pachi (Gr.)
also held Attica), as Megara had not yet been founded. That
poet = Homer (8th c. BCE) is why the poet makes no specific mention of these places. In-
stead, calling all the p eople in Attica “Athenians,” he includes
these p eople too u
nder the generic name, considering them to these people = Megarians
461
3.3. Greece
392 C, 13-20 It furthermore happened that the Peloponnesians and the 9.1.6
[ 1 ] The “title” Catalogue refers to a part of Homer’s Iliad: 4 C, 14-20n; cf. 639 C,
15-27n.
[ 2 ] 392 C, 10-35.
[ 3 ] The play Strabo cites is no longer available, but the metrical conventions of
Greek poetry show that, up to this point, Strabo has rearranged the word order
to suit his own purposes.
[ 4 ] 392 C, 10-35.
462
First Band: Megaris + Attica
city, deserted, is oriented toward Aegina and Notus: as has Notus, south wind
Aeschylus (5th c. BCE) been said by Aeschylus, this is Aegina, facing the blasts of Notus.
The current-day city is situated in a bay on a cherronesoid site cherronesoid, peninsula-like
463
3.3. Greece
394 C, 1-6 The island was famous, both because of the Aeacids who
ruled there (particularly Ajax the Telamonian) and because
it was off this island that Xerxes was defeated at sea by the Persian fleet under Xerxes
defeated, 480 BCE
Greeks and fled home. The Aeginetans, being neighbors and
supplying a considerable fleet, shared in the glory associated
with this b attle.
394 C, 6-7 Bocarus is a river, now called “Bocalia,” on Salamis. |
394 C, 8-14 The island is now held by the Athenians but, in antiquity, 9.1.10
464
First Band: Megaris + Attica
ATTICA ary between Megarian and Attic territory, are two mountains
s. cen. Greece
called “Cerata” (Horns). | Then t here’s the city of Eleusis, with Eleusis, Lefsina (Gr.)
395 C, 12-18 Then there’s the Thriasian plain, and shoreline and deme 9.1.13
of the same name. Then t here’s the promontory Amphiala, Amphiala, W Korydallos (Gr.)
raeus, also listed among the demes, and Munychia. | deme, administrative district
were once connected with this wall. (These w ere the “Long
Walls,” forty stades in length, joining the city with Piraeus.)
The many wars caused the ruin of the wall and the Muny-
chian defenses, and reduced Piraeus to a meager settlement
465
3.3. Greece
around the harbors and the temple to Zeus the Savior. There
are wonderful paintings—works by renowned artists—in the
temple’s small colonnades and statues in its open courtyard.
396 C, 3-5 The Long Walls have also been ruined, pulled down first
by the Lacedaemonians and then by the Romans, when Sulla
took by siege both Piraeus and the city. | Piraeus, Pireëfs/Pireas (Gr.)
396 C, 6-9 The city consists of a rock in a plain, encircled by habitation. city = Athens 9.1.16
466
First Band: Megaris + Attica
when the Carians w ere ravaging the territory from the sea, and the
Boeotians (called “Aonians”) were ravaging it by land, Cecrops first
settled the population in twelve cities, the names of which w
ere Cecro-
pia, Tetrapolis, Epacria, Decelia, Eleusis, Aphidna (people also
use the plural form, “Aphidnae”), Thoricus, Brauron, Cytherus,
Sphettus, Cephisia, . . . *. Theseus is said to have later amalgam-
ated the twelve cities into the single city of the present day.
397 C, 27–398 C, 3 The Athenians w ere at first subject to kings, then they
changed to a democracy. A fter the imposition over them of
467
3.3. Greece
the tyrants (Pisistratus and his sons) and the subsequent ex-
istence of an oligarchy—that of the Four Hundred and that of
the Thirty Tyrants whom the Lacedaemonians set up—they
easily rid themselves of these tyrants and preserved their de-
mocracy u ntil the Roman conquest. Although they were a l ittle
troubled by the Macedonian kings and forced to obey them,
they kept the overall form of their government the same.
398 C, 3-14 Some p eople say that they were best governed during the
ten-year period when Cassander ruled the Macedonians! This
fellow, who seems to have been rather tyrannical in other
ways, was well disposed t oward the Athenians once he had
the city under his control. He put the citizens u nder the con-
Demetrius (4th–early 3rd c. BCE) trol of Demetrius of Phalerum (a follower of the philosopher
Theophrastus (4th–3rd c. BCE) Theophrastus), who not only did not put an end to the democratic
constitution but even improved it,1 as shown in the volumes he
compiled on the topic of the constitution. Feelings of ill
will were so strong, however, and so great was the hatred of
oligarchs that, a fter the death of Cassander, Demetrius was
forced to flee to Egypt. The rebels pulled down more than
three hundred statues of him and melted them down (some
add, to make chamber pots!).
398 C, 14-20 The Romans, who took over the Athenians while they
were democratically ruled, preserved their autonomy and
freedom. The onset of the war against Mithridates resulted
in the appointment over them of whichever tyrants the king
wanted. Aristion, who was extremely powerful and . . . * ter-
rorized the city, was taken by siege and punished by Sulla,
the Roman commander; he pardoned the city, and she has
her freedom and is held in respect by the Romans even now. |
398 C, 21-33 After Piraeus, on the next stretch of coastline is the 9.1.21
Phalerian deme, then the Halimusian, the Aexonian, the deme, administrative district
the Aexonians, t here’s also Hydrussa. In the Anaphlystus re- Phabra, Phleves (Gk. island)
gion is the Panium and the temple to “Colian” Aphrodite. Elaeussa, Asida (Gk. island)
This is the place where, p eople say, the last remains of the Hydrussa, Prasonisi (Gk. island)
468
First Band: Megaris + Attica
ships from the Persian sea b attle near Salamis washed ashore.
This was foretold by Apollo: Coliadian w omen w
ill use oars to
do their roasting. Also off the coast, not far from these places,
is Belbina island, and the Palisade of Patroclus. Most of the Belbina, Ag. Georgios
(Gk. island)
islands are uninhabited. |
398 C, 34–399 C, 7 As you round the Sunium headland, you come to the sig- Sunium headland, Kolonnes 9.1.22
(Gr.)
nificant deme of Sunium, then to Thoricus, then to the deme
of “Potamus” (River), as it is called—after which its population
is called “Potamians” (Riverine people)—then to Prasiae, to Stiria,
to Brauron (where there’s the temple to “Brauronian” Arte-
mis), Araphenian Halae (where there’s the temple to “[Arte-
mis] Tauropolus”), Myrrhinus, Probalinthus, and Marathon
serted, its length being some sixty stades. This is the island,
poet = Homer (8th c. BCE) people say, that the poet had in mind in the lines that Alexan-
der addresses to Helen: not even when, abducting you from lovely
Lacedaemon, / I first sailed away in my sea-faring ships, / and had
sex with you on the island of Cranaa. (He uses the name “Cranaa”
for current-day Helena b ecause that is where they had sex!)1
399 C, 22-26 After Helena, Euboea lies out to sea off the next stretch Euboea, Euboia/Evia
(Gk. island)
of coastline: it is similarly narrow and elongated, and lies
lengthways to the mainland, just as Helena does. It is a voy-
age of three hundred stades from Sunium to the southern
point of Euboea, which is called “Leuca Acta.” Concerning
Euboea 2 . . . *.
399 C, 26-27 The inland demes of Attica, because of their number, deme, administrative district
[ 1 ] Cra-is the root of a Greek word meaning “to engage in sexual relations.” Strabo
is being humorous, since cranaa is a word in its own right, meaning “rugged.”
[ 2 ] Euboea: 444 C, 8–449 C, 30.
469
3.3. Greece
399 C, 28-31 In regard to mountains, the most renowned are Hymet- 9.1.23
400 C, 11-15 Next comes Boeotia. In discussing this and the sequential na- 9.2.1
Pagae, Alepochori (Gr.) the isthmus and the Alcyonian sea at Pagae as far as . . . * in Alcyonian sea, Alkyonidon
Kolpos
Creusa, Livadostro (Gr.) the Creusa region. Its remaining sides are the stretch of coast
470
Second Band: Boeotia
Ephorus (4th c. BCE) than the neighboring nations, and also b ecause it alone is it = Boeotia
471
3.3. Greece
escendants. T
d hose descendants founded Thebes as an ad-
dition to Cadmia, and they maintained sovereignty—ruling
over most of the Boeotians—until the campaign of the Epi-
goni (Descendants). A fter abandoning Thebes for a short time
under the latter, they came back again. they = descendants of Cadmus
401 C, 19-28 When they were likewise expelled by the Thracians and
Pelasgians, they established a long-lasting sovereignty in
Thessaly in conjunction with the Arnaeans, with the con-
sequence that they w ere all called “Boeotians.” Finally,
they returned to their homeland at the time when the Ae-
olian expedition had been fitted out in the Aulis region of
Boeotia—the expedition that the sons of Orestes w ere send-
ing to Asia. They added Orchomenia to Boeotia: the two
were not previously one entity, nor did Homer catalogue the
Orchomenians as Boeotians but labeled them separately as
Minyans. In conjunction with the Orchomenians, they ex-
pelled the Pelasgians to Athens (it is after them that a part
of the city is called “Pelasgicum”—they settled at the foot of
Hymettus) and the Thracians to Parnassus.
401 C, 28 The Hyantes established the colony of “Hyampolis” in Hyampolis, Exarkhos (Gr.)
Phocis. |
401 C, 29–402 C, 3 Ephorus says that the Thracians, despite having come to terms 9.2.4
Ephorus (4th c. BCE) with the Boeotians, attacked them by night in their camp, which was
somewhat makeshift b ecause peace had been concluded. When they they = Boeotians
fended them off and reproached them for breaking the terms of the
treaty, those fellows claimed that they had not broken the terms, since those fellows = Thracians
the agreement concerned the days, whereas the attack was made by
night. This is the origin of the proverbial expression “a Thracian
excuse”!
402 C, 3-12 The Pelasgians, during the course of the war, made the journey oracle, center for divine
prophecy
to Dodona to ask questions of the oracle, and the Boeotians made the
same journey. He noted that he could not say what response He = Ephorus
the Pelasgians received but that the Boeotians w ere told by the
prophetess that “impiety would bring success.” The envoys, suspecting
that kinship had caused the prophetess to f avor the Pelasgians in her
reply (for the temple was originally Pelasgian), grabbed the woman
and threw her on a burning pyre. They considered that they were jus-
tified whether or not she was guilty—it was her punishment if she had
given a false answer, and if her answer was true, they had committed
the impiety she had ordered!
472
Second Band: Boeotia
402 C, 12-19 It did not seem right to the t emple associates to execute without
trial—in the temple, no less—those who had committed the deed,
but rather they called them to face trial before the priestesses (i.e.,
those prophetesses who remained out of the original three). When
the accused said that it was nowhere customary for women to try
cases, they appointed in addition the same number of men as women.
The men voted for acquittal but the women for conviction. Since
the votes were equal, the votes for acquittal won the day. This is
the reason that, at Dodona, Boeotians alone are given oracular
responses by men.
402 C, 19-24 The prophetesses claim, in explanation of the oracular response,
that the god’s instruction to the Boeotians was that they should steal
the tripods from their own territory and send them to Dodona on a tripods, 3-legged caldrons used
as temple offerings
yearly basis. They do in fact do this—they routinely take down under
cover of night one of the tripods they have offered up in dedication and,
covering it with cloaks, make a sort of secret tripod-carrying-off 1 to
Dodona. |
402 C, 25-26 After this, they collaborated in the Aeolian colonization, 9.2.5
these two cities are well preserved in comparison with the Thespiae, Erimokastro (Gr.)
others. |
403 C, 8-20 I should next undertake a descriptive journey through 9.2.6
the territory, beginning with the stretch of coast opposite territory = Boeotia
473
3.3. Greece
harbor that people call “Delphinium,” facing which is “Old Delphinium, Kamaraki (Gr.)
harbor), then Aulis 2—a rocky place and village belonging to the Aulis, Mikro Vathy/Ag. Nikolaos
(Gr.)
Tanagraeans. Its harbor holds fifty vessels, so that it is reason-
ships station of the Greeks = for able to suppose that the ships station of the Greeks was in the
the expedition against Troy
large harbor.
403 C, 23-29 Nearby is the Chalcidian Euripus, the distance to which
from Sunium is . . . * stades. T here’s a two-plethra bridge 1 plethrum = 100 ft.
there, as I said.3 A tower stands on either side, one in Chalcis Chalcis, Khalkis/Negroponte
(Gr.)
and one in Boeotia, and built into them is a gallery. Concern-
ing the reversal of current in the Euripus, it is sufficient to
state simply that people claim it changes seven times per day-
and-night: the cause must be investigated elsewhere. |
403 C, 30-36 Nearby, t here’s a place situated up high, Salganeus, Salganeus, Lithosoros (Gr.) 9.2.9
[ 1 ] 399 C, 7-14.
[ 2 ] For the lines of Homer in which the name Aulis appears: 376 C, 7-19; cf. 9 C,
35–10 C, 5.
[ 3 ] 400 C, 27-37.
[ 4 ] For the lines of Homer in which the name Graea appears: 376 C, 7-19; cf. 410 C,
16-21.
474
Second Band: Boeotia
araus fell whilst fighting from his chariot in the spot where his
temple now stands; and that his vacated chariot ended up in
the place of the same name. Others say that it was the chariot place of the same
name = Harma (= Chariot)
of the fleeing Adrastus that was broken into pieces here and
Philochorus (4th c. BCE) that he was saved by Arion. Philochorus says he was saved
by the villagers who, as a result of this act, received rights of
citizenship from the Argives. |
404 C, 26-30 As you go from Thebes to . . . *, Tanagra is on your left, Thebes, Thivai (Gr.) 9.2.12
while . . . * lies to your right. Hyria, formerly part of Thebaïs, Tanagra, SE Kerykeion (Gr.)
is nowadays part of Tanagraea. It is the setting for the myth Hyria, Tseloneri (Gr.)
Pindar (5th c. BCE) of Hyrieus and the birth of Orion, recounted by Pindar in his
Dithyrambs. It is situated near Aulis.
404 C, 30-35 Some p eople say that Hysiae is called Hyrie.3 A part of Hysiae, Kriekouki (Gr.)
Parasopia, at the foot of Cithaeron, near Erythrae 4 in the in- is called = by Homer
[ 1 ] For the lines of Homer in which the names Mycalessus and Harma appear: 410 C,
16-21.
[ 2 ] “Day-and-night” = period of 24 hours.
[ 3 ] For the lines of Homer in which the name Hyrie appears: 9 C, 35–10 C, 5; 376 C,
7-19.
[ 4 ] For the lines of Homer in which the name Erythrae appears: 410 C, 16-21.
475
3.3. Greece
farthermost city on the Euboea-facing coast of Boeotia ac- Anthedon, Loukisia (Gr.)
poet = Homer (8th c. BCE) cording to the poet (farthermost Anthedon). If, however, you
proceed only a l ittle farther, there are two Boeotian towns:
Larymna, where the Cephissus flows out to sea; and beyond
deme, administrative district that, Halae, homonymous with the Attic demes. People say Halae, Theologos (Gr.)
that opposite this stretch of shoreline is Euboean Aegae, with Euboean Aegae, Politika Kafkala
(Gr.)
its temple to “Aegaean” Posidon. I mentioned it earlier.2 The
crossing from Anthedon to Aegae is one hundred and twenty
stades, but much less from other places. The t emple is situ-
ated on a high mountain, and there was once a city. Near
Aegae is Orobiae. Orobiae Rovies/Ag. Ilias (Gr.)
[ 1 ] For the lines of Homer in which the name Eleon (for “Heleon”) appears: 410 C,
16-21.
[ 2 ] Strabo refines his earlier statement (386 C, 16-23, where he does not explicitly
mention a temple).
[ 3 ] About the Ships is the name of a commentary by Apollodorus on the part of
Homer’s Iliad traditionally referred to by the “title” Catalogue of Ships or simply
Ships: 4 C, 14-20n.
[ 4 ] Boeotian coastline facing Euboea: 403 C, 8–405 C, 9.
476
Second Band: Boeotia
the same place, in cases where the rise in water level is less
than would result in inundation, the cause is the high ground
on which the buildings sit. The alternative cause is removal
and rebuilding, when people face repeated danger by being
so near and assuage their fear by moving to places that are
far away or on high ground. A consequence of this rebuild-
ing, if the people preserve the same name that was previously
etymologically derived from the circumstances of the loca-
tion, is that the name is no longer appropriate. It is credible
that “Plataeae” (Blade-ish) is called a fter the flat part of oars; Plataeae, Kokkla (Gr.)
and that those who made their living by rowing were called
“Plataeans,” even though, now that they live far away from
the lake, their name is no longer etymologically appropriate.
Helos (Marsh), Heleon (Of-the-marshes), and Heilisium (Marshy)1 got Heleon, Dritsa (Gr.)
their names from their situation on marshes, but now every Heilisium = Eilesium,
Khlembotsari (Gr.)
thing is different, the places having been rebuilt or (what is
also possible) the w
ater level having been lowered as a result
of subsequent outflows. |
406 C, 27–407 C, 3 This is exemplified most clearly by the Cephissus, which 9.2.18
feeds lake Copaïs. The level of the lake rose to such an extent
[ 1 ] For the lines of Homer in which the names Heleon and Heilisium appear (as
Eleon and Eilisium): 410 C, 16-21.
477
3.3. Greece
poet = Homer (8th c. BCE) that Copae (Oars)—which the poet mentions by name1 and Copae, Topolia (Gr.)
cian mountains. They include the Cephissus, which starts Lilaea, Kato Agoriani/Pyrgos
(Gr.)
from the Phocian city of Lilaea, just as Homer says (those who
Elatia, Drakhmani/Piperis (Gr.)
held Lilaea, at Cephissus’s source); flowing through Elatia, the
Parapotamii, Belesi/Levendi
largest of the Phocian cities, and through Parapotamii and (Gr.)
past the Phanotians, towns that are likewise Phocian, it enters Phanotians = inhabitants of
Boeotian Chaeronia; then passing through Orchomenia and Phanoteus, Ag. Vlasios (Gr.)
407 C, 26-31 Both the Permessus and the Olmius, on the other hand,
are from Helicon, joining up with each other and flowing into
478
Second Band: Boeotia
the same lake, Copaïs, near Haliartus . . . * streams flow into Haliartus, Kastri Maziou (Gr.)
nearby village called “Hylae” (like lyrae and thyrae). Nor does
he mean “Hyda,” as per t hose who write, he who dwelt in Hyda.
“Hyda” is in Lydia (at the foot of snowy Tmolus, in the rich land
of Hyda), whereas Hyla is in Boeotia—at any rate, a fter fac-
ing lake Cephissis, he gives, and near him, other / Boeotians lived.
408 C, 5-6 The one lake is large, and it is not located in the Thebaïs. the one = Copaïs
The other lake is small, fed from the former through under the other = Hylica
479
3.3. Greece
408 C, 30-34 Scolus is a village in Parasopia at the foot of Cithaeron, a Scolus, Neokhorakion/ 9.2.23
Moustaphades (Gr.)
barely habitable, rocky place, whence the proverb, do not go
to Scolus alone—nor with anyone e lse. People say that Pentheus
was brought from h ere a fter being torn to pieces. Among the
cities in the Olynthus region was a “Scolus,” homonymous
with this village.
408 C, 34-37 It has been noted that there is a village called “Parasopii”
in Trachinian Heraclia,1 past which runs a river “Asopus”; and
that in Sicyon there is another river “Asopus” and a place,
“Asopia,” through which it runs. There are other rivers, too,
homonymous with this river. |
408 C, 38–409 C, 3 Eteonus had a name change, to “Scaphlae.” It, too, is in 9.2.24
Parasopia: the Asopus and the Ismenus flow across the plain
in front of Thebes. T here’s also the spring Dirce, and Potniae, Potniae, Takhi (Gr.)
the setting for the myth of Potnian Glaucus, who was torn to
pieces near the city by Potnian mares.
409 C, 3-6 Cithaeron terminates not far from Thebes: the Asopus Thebes, Thivai (Gr.)
runs along it, watering its lower slopes and making it so that
the Parasopians have been split up into several settlements,
all, however, subject to Thebes.
409 C, 6-8 Others claim that Scolus, Eteonus, and Erythrae are in Pla-
taean territory: for the river runs past Plataeae and flows out Plataeae, Kokkla (Gr.)
have a seaport, Creusa, which p eople also call “Creysis.” Creusa/Creysis, Livadostro (Gr.)
409 C, 18-24 Hesiod’s homeland, Ascra, is in the part of Thespian ter- Ascra, Pyrgaki-Episkopi (Gr.)
Hesiod (late 8th–7th c. BCE) ritory toward Helicon: it is on the right-hand side of Heli-
con, lying on a high and rocky site, some forty stades from
Thespiae. He himself joked about it, mentioning that his
father moved t here a fter Aeolian Cyme. He says: he dwelt near
Helicon, in a miserable village, / Ascra—wretched in winter, hard
in summer, and never pleasant!
[ 1 ] 382 C, 16-25.
480
Second Band: Boeotia
409 C, 25-34 Helicon borders on Phocis to the north, and also slightly
to the west, at the last Phocian harbor, which people call
“Mychus” (Inmost-recess) after the facts of the m
atter: for, lying
above the Crisaean gulf at precisely this harbor are Heli- Crisaean gulf = e. part of Gulf
of Corinth
con and Ascra and, furthermore, Thespiae and her seaport,
Thespiae, Erimokastro (Gr.)
Creusa. This section is supposed to be the inmost part of
Creusa, Livadostro (Gr.)
the Crisaean gulf, and of the Corinthian gulf as a whole. It is
ninety stades along the stretch of coast from Mychus harbor
to Creusa. (From t here, it is one hundred and twenty stades to Olmiae, Schinas
the headland called “Olmiae”; Pegae and Oenoa, which I have Pegae, Alepochori (Gr.)
described,1 are situated on the inmost section of this bay.) Oenoa, Viokastro (Gr.)
409 C, 34–410 C, 9 Helicon is not far from Parnassus and rivals it in height
and area: both mountain ranges are snowy and rocky and do
not take up much territory. This is the location of the temple
to the Muses and the Hippucrene (Horse-spring) and the cave of
the Libethrid nymphs. From this latter, one would deduce
that Helicon was consecrated to the Muses by Thracians, who
dedicated Pieris, Libethrum, and Pimplia to t hese very same
goddesses. The Thracians used to be called “Pieres”; now that
they have disappeared, these places are held by Macedonians.2
It has been noted that this territory was at one stage colonized
by Thracians (who forced out the Boeotians) and by Pelas-
gians and other natives.3
410 C, 10-14 Thespiae was formerly famous for its Eros by Praxiteles— Thespiae, Erimokastro (Gr.)
410 C, 15 Of the other places,4 only their ruins and famous names
remain. |
410 C, 16-21 After Thespiae, he catalogues Graea and Mycalessus, which he = Homer 9.2.26
road to Anthedon.)
410 C, 22-28 Ocalee lies midway between Haliartus and Alalcomenium, Ocalee/Ocalea, ?Evangelistria
(Gr.)
thirty stades from each: a small river of the same name runs
Crisaean gulf = n. part of Gulf Phocian Medeon, Ag. Theodori
of Corinth past her. The Phocian Medeon is in the Crisaean gulf, one (Gr.)
[1] Pegae (under spelling “Pagae”), Oenoa, and bay formed by Olmiae: 380 C, 7-15.
[2] I.e., the Roman province of Macedonia. Cf. 471 C, 11-18n.
[3] 401 C, 19–402 C, 24.
[4] I.e., other Boeotian cities mentioned by Homer, e.g., Haliartus (411 C, 15-16,
30-34).
[ 5 ] Graea, Mycalessus, Harma: 404 C, 1-11. Eilisium, Eleon (as “Heilisium” and “He-
leon”): 406 C, 14-26; cf. 404 C, 30-35. Erythrae: 404 C, 30-35; 409 C, 6-8. Hyla:
407 C, 36–408 C, 15.
481
3.3. Greece
hundred and sixty stades from Boeotia. The Boeotian Medeon Boeotian Medeon, ?Davlosis
(Gr.)
has been named a fter it . . . *; she is near Onchestus at the
foot of mount Phoenicium, a fter which her name has been
changed to “Phoenicis.” This mountain is said to be part of
Thebaea (though by some, part of Haliartia), as are Medeon
and Ocalea. |
410 C, 29–411 C, 7 He continues: Copae, and Eutresis, and dove-rich Thisbe. Copae, Topolia (Gr.) 9.2.27
comenae, Tilphusium, and Coronia.2 There was no universal Phoenicis, ?Davlosis (Gr.)
name for the lake in antiquity. Rather, in each of the nearby Onchestus, Kazarma (Gr.)
settlements, it was called a fter the settlement: “Copaïs” a fter Haliartus, Kastri Maziou (Gr.)
Copae, “Haliartis” after Haliartus, and so on in the case of Ocalea, ?Evangelistria (Gr.)
the others. Later, the w hole lake was called “Copaïs” because Alalcomenae, Solinarion (Gr.)
this place = Copae the name predominated: this place was at its farthest point. Tilphusium, ?Palaiothiva (Gr.)
Pindar (5th c. BCE) Pindar calls the lake “Cephissis.” At any rate, he mentions Coronia, Palaia Koroneia/Pyrgos
(Gr.)
it alongside Tilphossa spring, which emerges at the foot of
mount Tilphossium, near Haliartus and Alalcomenae, on
which is situated the Tiresias memorial. H ere, too, is the
temple to “Tilphossian” Apollo. |
411 C, 8-9 Following on from Copae, the poet places Eutresis, a Thes- Eutresis, Arkopodi (Gr.) 9.2.28
poet = Homer (8th c. BCE) pian hamlet. P eople say that Zethus and Amphion lived h ere
before ruling Thebes.
411 C, 10-14 Thisbe is now called “Thisbae.” The place is situated just a Thisbae, Kakosi (Gr.)
little inland from the sea, sharing a border with the Thespians
and with Coronia, lying at the foot of the southern side of
Helicon. It has a seaport that is full of doves: hence the poet
says dove-rich Thisbe. The voyage to Sicyon from here is one
hundred and sixty stades. |
411 C, 15-16 He catalogues next in order Coronia, Haliartus, Plataeae, 9.2.29
and Glissas.3
411 C, 16-26 Coronia lies high up, near Helicon. She was seized by the Coronia, Palaia Koroneia/Pyrgos
(Gr.)
Boeotians on their return from Thessalian Arna after the
Trojan period, at which stage they also took Orchomenus. Trojan period, late 2nd–early
1st millennium BCE
They conquered Coronia and built, on the plain before her,
a temple to “Itonian” Athena (homonymous with the Thes-
salian t emple) and named the river running past it “Cuarius”
Alcaeus (late 7th–early 6th c. (sounding like the river in Thessaly). Alcaeus calls the river
BCE)
“Coralius” when he says: Our lady Athena, goddess of war, /
482
Second Band: Boeotia
Athena, for a “mystical” (as they say) reason. P eople from Co-
ronia are called “Coronians,” whereas those from Messenian
Coronia are called “Coronaeans.” |
411 C, 30-34 Haliartus1 no longer exists, having been razed in the war Haliartus, Kastri Maziou (Gr.) 9.2.30
and Cadmia . . . * at its foot lies the “Aonian” plain, as it is Teumessus, Mesovouni (Gr.)
called, which extends to Thebes from mount Hypatum. |
412 C, 15-23 The statement those who held u nder Thebes, is understood by 9.2.32
483
3.3. Greece
412 C, 24-31 Onchestus is where the Amphictyonic league used to con- Onchestus, Kazarma (Gr.) 9.2.33
this man is Apollo’s son by Melia, and a prophet at the oracle oracle, center for divine
prophecy
same poet = Alcaeus on mount Ptoeum. The same poet describes the mountain
as having three peaks (and once he reached the redoubt of three-
peaked Ptoeum), and he calls Tenerus temple-dwelling seer, with
the same name as the plains. Ptoeum rises over the Tenerian plain
and lake Copaïs, by Acraephium. Both oracle and mountain
belong to the Thebaeans.
413 C, 9-10 Acraephium, too, is on a high spot. People say that this Acraephium, Karditsa (Gr.)
poet = Homer (8th c. BCE) place is called by the poet Arna, homonymous with the Thes-
salian “Arna.” |
413 C, 10-16 Some claim that Arna, together with Midia, was swallowed 9.2.35
Zenodotus (3rd c. BCE) emends up by the lake. When Zenodotus writes those who held vine-rich
Homer (8th c. BCE)
Ascra,1 he seems like someone who has not come across what
Hesiod (late 8th–7th c. BCE) was said by Hesiod about his fatherland, nor the even worse
Eudoxus (4th c. BCE) things said about Ascra by Eudoxus. How could anyone be-
lieve that such a place would be called vine-rich by the poet?
413 C, 16-20 Nor are t hose people correct who write “Tarna” instead
of Arna. Not one “Tarna” can be identified among the Boeo-
tians. T
here is a “Tarna” among the Lydians, mentioned also
by Homer: Idomeneus slew Phaestus, son of the carpenter / Borus,
who hailed from earth-rich Tarna.
413 C, 21-23 The remaining cities 2 of those around the lake that are
worth mentioning are Alalcomenae and Tilphossium, and of Tilphossium, ?Palaiothiva (Gr.)
the o
thers, Chaeronia, Lebadia, and Leuctra. |
413 C, 24-36 The poet mentions Alalcomenae (albeit not in the Cata Alalcomenae, Solinarion (Gr.) 9.2.36
poet = Homer (8th c. BCE) logue): 3 Argive Hera and Alalcomenian Athena. Alalcomenae has
[ 1 ] I.e., when Zenodotus represents Homer as referring to Ascra rather than Arna.
[ 2 ] I.e., “remaining” as per the list given at 410 C, 29–411 C, 7.
[ 3 ] The “title” Catalogue refers to a part of Homer’s Iliad: 4 C, 14-20n; cf. 639 C,
15-27n.
484
Second Band: Boeotia
nians in a g reat b
attle, started the p rocess of their destruction.
(From that time onward, they were no longer strong enough
to revive the hegemony over the Greeks that they previously
held, particularly after faring badly in the second engagement
in the Mantinia region, but their independence was main-
tained despite this blunder, u ntil the Roman conquest—they
are still respected by the latter for the excellence of their in-
stitutions.) The site is identified along the road from Plataeae Plataeae, Kokkla (Gr.)
414 C, 19-29 Next, the poet catalogues the Orchomenians, distinguish- 9.2.40
poet = Homer (8th c. BCE) ing them from the Boeotian nation. He calls Orchomenus Orchomenus, Skripou (Gr.)
485
3.3. Greece
486
Second Band: Boeotia
415 C, 22-24 People say that the place now covered by lake Copaïs was
dry in former times and was used for all sorts of farming,
being subject to the Orchomenians, who lived close by. People
use this as evidence of their wealth. |
415 C, 25-31 Some p eople used the name “Aspledon” without the first Aspledon/Spledon/Eudielus, 9.2.41
Avrokastro/Polyyria (Gr.)
syllable. Then the name was changed to “Eudielus” (Good-in-the-
evening), as also the name of the territory, perhaps because of
on this same sea, is itself part of Phocis; similarly, Cirrha, Crisa, Ag. Varvara (Gr.)
[ 1 ] Strabo (or his scribe) perhaps meant to write “Opuntian Locrians,” who were
named after their metropolis (425 C, 6-13). Strabo does sometimes err: 434 C,
6-15.
[ 2 ] Strabo often pluralizes individuals. He probably refers h ere to Apollodorus
(2nd c. BCE); see next note.
[ 3 ] About the Ships is the name of a commentary by Apollodorus on the part of
Homer’s Iliad traditionally referred to by the “title” Catalogue of Ships or simply
Ships: 4 C, 14-20n.
[ 4 ] 3rd band, Phocis (cen. Greece): 417 C, 27–425 C, 5.
487
3.3. Greece
488
Third Band: Phocis
The remaining sides are not parallel—that is, the western sides
with the eastern sides. This is because each coastline—the
coastline from the Crisaean gulf to Actium and the coastline Crisaean gulf = n. part of Gulf
of Corinth
facing Euboea and going as far as Macedonia—is not paral-
lel with the other; and these coastlines mark the end point of
these nations. Rather, the shape of these places must be un-
derstood as if several lines . . . * in a triangle parallel to its base.
The . . . * thus contained will be parallel with each other and
will have the . . . * sides parallel, but not the . . . *.
417 C, 27–418 C, 1 That was the general outline1 of the remaining part of my
descriptive journey that comes next.2 I will now deal with
the details,3 starting with Phocis. | The two most famous cit- 9.3.2
ies belonging to this territory are Delphi and Elatia. Delphi this territory = Phocis
is famous on account of its temple to “Pythian” Apollo and Delphi, Delphi (Gr.)
oracle, center for divine its oracle dating back to antiquity—if, at least, it is from this Elatia, Drakhmani/Piperis (Gr.)
prophecy
oracle that Agamemnon is said by the poet to have received
poet = Homer (8th c. BCE) a prophecy. The lyre player is represented as singing about
the quarrel of Odysseus and lord Peleid, / how once they strove; and Peleid = Achilles
Agamemnon, lord of men, / rejoiced . . . / for this is the prophecy that
Phoebus Apollo had given him / at Pytho.
418 C, 2-8 While Delphi is famous for t hese reasons, Elatia is famous
because she is the largest of the cities in the region and the
most dominant on account of her commanding position over
the narrow passes, and b ecause whoever controls the city,
controls the entry points into Phocis and Boeotia. For first
come the Oetaean mountains, then the mountains belong-
ing to the Locrians and Phocians, which are not everywhere
passable for armies making inroads from Thessaly. Rather,
they feature narrow but defined passes, guarded by the cit-
ies alongside them: when the cities fall, control of the passes
goes with them.
418 C, 8-11 Since the fame of the t emple at Delphi has the privilege Delphi, Delphi (Gr.)
of age, and since the location of the place also marks a physi-
cal point of departure (this being the most westerly part of
Phocis), I must start from there. |
489
3.3. Greece
418 C, 12-20 It has been noted that Parnassus is situated on the western 9.3.3
gulf takes its name).”2 Then t here’s Anticyra, homonymous Anticyra, Kastro tou Stenou (Gr.)
with the city in Oeta and on the Malian gulf.3 People say that
fine hellebore is produced t here but that it is better prepared
here, and for this reason many p eople repair hither to be
purged and cured, for a sesame-like herb is found in Phocian
territory, with which “Oetaean” hellebore is prepared. |
418 C, 29–419 C, 2 This city still exists, but Cirrha and Crisa were leveled, this city = Anticyra 9.3.4
the former more recently, the latter by Eurylochus during Cirrha, Magoula Xeropigadas
(Gr.)
the Crisaean war. The Crisaeans, who w ere d oing well on
Crisa, Ag. Varvara (Gr.)
account of the tariffs on goods from Sicily and Italy, taxed
visitors to the temple harshly—and in contravention of the
Amphictyons, representatives
of federation of cities Amphictyons’ instructions.
419 C, 2-7 The same t hing happened to the Amphissans (these people Amphissans = inhabitants of
Amphissa, Salona (Gr.)
are part of the Ozolian Locrians). They arrived, revitalized
Crisa, restored to agricultural use the plain, which the Am-
phictyons had rededicated—and w ere worse in their treatment
of visitors than the ancient Crisaeans! The Amphictyons took
vengeance on them and restored the territory to the god.
419 C, 8-11 The temple is also much diminished, although formerly it temple = at Delphi (Gr.)
[ 1 ] 416 C, 11-21.
[ 2 ] While Strabo sometimes uses the term “Crisaean gulf” in a local sense (Iteas
Gulf), as could be the case h
ere, he also uses it more generally to mean the
entire e. end of the Gulf of Corinth, with particular reference to its n. shore:
336 C, 5-13n.
[ 3 ] 434 C, 6-15.
490
Third Band: Phocis
419 C, 12-18 The same impulse lies b ehind both the founding of cities
and respect for shared sanctuaries. P eople came together in
cities and nations because they were inherently sociable and
because it was mutually beneficial. They met up at shared
sanctuaries for the same reasons, to celebrate festivals and
holidays. Friendship was engendered by all such activity,
starting with sharing a table, a drink, a roof. The more visi-
tors there w ere, from the more places, the greater the benefit
was considered to be. |
419 C, 19-26 It is said that the oracle is a hollow cave, deep underground, oracle, center for divine 9.3.5
prophecy
with a mouth of no great width; that a frenzy-inducing vapor
rises out of it; that over the mouth is a high tripod, which the
Pythia ascends and, u nder the influence of the vapor, utters
prophecies in forms both metrical and unmetrical; that the
latter are put into metrical form by poets serving the t emple.
It is said that Phemonoe was the first Pythia; that both proph- Pythia = priestess
etess and city have got their name from pythesthai (inquire); that
the first syllable has been lengthened as in the case of athana-
tos, akamatos, and diakonos. |
419 C, 27–420 C, 3 For the most part, the honor accorded to this temple re- 9.3.6
[ 1 ] The word translated as “banded” is the same word as is used for the “bands”
into which Greece is divided: 400 C, 15-26; 417 C, 6-10, 18-27.
491
3.3. Greece
when it is sacred. Nowadays, the temple at Delphi is extremely Delphi, Delphi (Gr.)
492
Third Band: Phocis
421 C, 9-14 Some people, taking aphetor to mean “treasury” and “oudos
of the aphetor” to mean “underground treasury,” say that the
wealth was buried in the t emple; that t hose associated with
Onomarchus,1 trying to dig it up by night, fled the t emple
when great seismic tremors occurred and left off their digging;
and that fear of such an undertaking has afflicted all others. |
421 C, 15-21 As concerns the temples, the one made from feathers must 9.3.9
493
3.3. Greece
After claiming that they remained ever free from invasion, at one
point he says that the Aeolians settled the place a fter expelling the
natives who possessed it; at another point he says that Aetolus, in
494
Third Band: Phocis
the company of the Epians from Elis . . . * by their enemies, and these
by Alcmaeon and Diomedes.
423 C, 10 But I should get back to the Phocians. |
423 C, 11-15 Next on the coast a fter Anticyra1 is a town, Opisthomara- 9.3.13
there; that it is the setting for the Philomela and Procne myth
Thucydides (5th c. BCE) (although Thucydides says it is set in Megara); and that the
place got its name from a copse (since their word for “copses”
is dauli). Homer talks of Daulis, later writers of Daulia. As
Citation of Homer (8th c. BCE) for who held Cyparissus, people understand it in two different
ways—some as having the same name as the tree, o thers as a
derived from a personal name—as a village below Lycoria. |
423 C, 24-29 Panopeus, the current-day Phanoteus, sharing a border Panopeus/Phanoteus, Ag. 9.3.14
Vlasios (Gr.)
with places in the Lebadia region, is the home city of Epius.
People say it is the setting for the Tityus myth. Homer, how-
ever, says that the Phaeeces led Rhadamanthys into Euboea to Phaeeces = Phaeacians (from
Homer’s Odyssey)
see Tityus, the son of the earth; and a cave, Elarium (named a fter
Elara, m other of Tityus), is identified, as are a shrine to the
hero Tityus and certain honors paid to him.
423 C, 29-31 Near to Lebadia is Trachin, a Phocian town with the same Trachin, ?Kyriaki/Palaiokastro
(Gr.)
name as the town in Oetaea. Her inhabitants are called “Tra-
chinians.” |
423 C, 32–424 C, 2 Anemoria (Windy) is so named from what is experienced 9.3.15
495
3.3. Greece
know the city (which was later than that time), but she is ad-
vantageously located with respect to inroads from Thessaly.
Demosthenes (4th c. BCE) Demosthenes gives an indication of her favorable position
when he describes the commotion that suddenly erupted in
Athens when a messenger came to the prytaneis with the an- prytaneis, state officials in
Athens
nouncement that Elatia had fallen. |
424 C, 11-22 Parapotamii is a settlement located on the Cephissus, near Parapotamii, Belesi/Levendi (Gr.) 9.3.16
Theopompus (4th c. BCE) the Phanotians and Chaeronians, and near Elatia. Theopom-
pus says that this place is some forty stades from Chaeronia and marks
the boundary between the Ambrysians, Panopeans, and Daulians; it
lies on the pass from Boeotia to Phocis, on quite a high hill, between
Parnassus and mount Hadylium, which leave almost a five-stade gap
between one other; running between them, leaving a narrow passage on
either side, is the Cephissus, which takes its start from the Phocian city
of Lilaea (as Homer says, “those who held Lilaea, at the source
of the Cephissus”) and ends in lake Copaïs; the Hadylium range ex-
tends for sixty stades as far as Hyphantium, on which lies Orchomenus.
424 C, 22-26 Hesiod, too, speaks at length about the river and its course, river = Cephissus
Hesiod (late 8th–7th c. BCE) how it twists and turns, serpentlike, through all Phocis: . . . *
past Panopeus, and past steep Glechon, / and through Orchomenus,
it coils like a serpent.
424 C, 27-29 The pass in the region of Parapotamii (or “ Parapotamia”— Parapotamii, Belesi/Levendi (Gr.)
496
Fourth Band: Locris
425 C, 6-13 What comes next is Locris, which I should now describe. It 9.4.1
has been divided into two parts. One part of it consists of the
Locrians near Euboea (whom, I noted, w ere at some stage
split on e ither side of Daphnus—one group was qualified as Daphnus, Ag. Konstantinos (Gr.)
OPUNTIAN LOCRIANS Opuntian gulf comes next a fter Halae (which marked the Halae, Theologos (Gr.)
e. cen. Greece
termination of the Boeotian stretch of coastline that faces
Euboea).3 Opus is the metropolis, as indicated by the verse Opus, Atalandi (Gr.)
inscribed on the first of the five pillars beside the mass grave
near Thermopylae: those who laid down their lives for Greece in the
face of the Medes / are honored by Opus, metropolis of the righteous
Locrians. Opus is around fifteen stades from the coast but
sixty from the seaport.
425 C, 22-28 The seaport is Cynus, a headland marking the end of the Cynus, Pyrgos/Livanates (Gr.)
497
3.3. Greece
who was king of the Opuntians but rather Aias the Locrian,
whose homeland was, they say, Narycum. They name the
man who was killed by Patroclus “Aianes”; and they identify
Aianium, a sacred precinct, and a spring, Aianis, as named
after him. |
426 C, 1-5 Next after Cynus comes Alopa; and Daphnus, which as I Alopa, Melidoni/Ag. Aikaterini 9.4.3
(Gr.)
said, has been torn down.1 In the latter place there’s a har-
Daphnus, Ag. Konstantinos (Gr.)
bor, around ninety stades from Cynus and one hundred and
twenty stades from Elatia, if you go overland into the inte-
rior. (By this stage, t hese places are in the Malian gulf, which
comes next after the Opuntian.) |
426 C, 6-11 After Daphnus is Cnemides, a natural fortification some 9.4.4
land facing west t oward the Malian gulf. (By this stage, t hese
EPICNEMIDIAN LOCRIANS places belong to the Epicnemidian Locrians.) Offshore at this
e. cen. Greece
point are three islands called the “Lichades,” named after Li-
chas. There are other islands, too, along the aforementioned
coast, which I have intentionally left aside.
426 C, 11-18 Twenty stades a fter Cnemides is a harbor, inland from
which—an equal number of stades into the interior—is Thro- Thronium, Palaiokastro eis ta
marmara (Gr.)
nium. Then there’s the outlet of the Boagrius river, which
flows past Thronium. P eople give it the additional name
“Manes.” It is fed by winter rains, with the consequence that
it is sometimes possible to walk into it without getting one’s
1 plethrum = 100 ft. feet wet, although at other times it has a two-plethra width!
Scarphia, ?Molos (Gr.)
After t hese places comes Scarphia, ten stades inland from the
Nicaea, Ag. Triada/Palaiokastro
coast and thirty stades from Thronium, a little less . . . *; then (Gr.)
Nicaea and Thermopylae. | Thermopylae, Thermopiles (Gr.)
426 C, 19-22 As for the remaining cities, they are not worth mention- 9.4.5
this name from its being “well plowed”; Bessa (Wooded glen) no
longer exists—some sort of “wooded site”—nor Augiae, the
territory of which is held by the Scarphians.
426 C, 23-26 This Bessa (Wooded glen) is to be written with a double “s”; it
has been given the same name as its woods, like Napa (Wooded
Hellanicus (5th c. BCE) valley) in the plain of Methymna, which Hellanicus igno-
rantly . . . * calls “Lapa.” The deme in Attica, whose members deme, administrative district
[ 1 ] 424 C, 34–425 C, 5.
498
Fourth Band: Locris
426 C, 26-31 Tarpha (Thicket) is situated up high, twenty stades from . . . *. Tarpha/Pharygae, Pharygae/ 9.4.6
Rhengini (Gr.)
She has territory that is fertile, with plenty of trees; she, too,
has been named after her woodlands. She is nowadays called
“Pharygae,” and a temple to “Pharygaean Hera” (named after
the Argive Hera in Pharygae)1 is located h ere. Indeed, it is
said that the p eople are Argive colonists. |
426 C, 32-35 With regard to the Western Locrians, Homer does not 9.4.7
WESTERN/OZOLIAN LOCRIANS mention them, at least not explicitly, only by seeming to dif-
w. cen. Greece
ferentiate them from those Locrians who dwell opposite sacred
Euboea (of whom I have spoken),2 as if there were others; nor
is t here much talk about them by many other authors.
426 C, 35–427 C, 3 They once held the cities of Amphissa and Naupactus. Of Amphissa, Salona (Gr.)
awarded to them by Philip. | H ere, too, is Chalcis,3 mentioned Chalcis, Kato Vasiliki (Gr.) 9.4.8
poet = Homer (8th c. BCE) by the poet in the Aetolian Catalogue,4 down below Calydon.
Here, too, is Taphiassus, a hill on which is the memorial to
Nessus and the other Centaurs. People say that the foul-
smelling and clotted w ater issuing from the base of the hill
starts from their putrefying bodies. On this account, the na-
tion is additionally called “Ozolian” (Smelly).” Also in the An-
tirrhian region is Molycria, an Aetolian town.5 Molycria, Velvina/Elliniko (Gr.)
427 C, 10-13 Amphissa is located at the end of the Crisaean plain: the Amphissa, Salona (Gr.)
Amphictyons, federal Amphictyons leveled her, as I said.6 . . . * and Eupalium be- Eupalium, Kastro Soule (Gr.)
representatives
long to the Locrians.
427 C, 13-14 The entire voyage along the Locrian coast is only a little
more than two hundred stades. |
427 C, 15-16 There is a place named “Alopa” h ere, as well as among the 9.4.9
499
3.3. Greece
DORIANS of Erineus, Boium, Pindus, and Cytinium. Pindus is above Erineus, Kastellia/Evangelistria
cen. Greece (Gr.)
Erineus; and flowing past her is the river of the same name, Boium, Gravia (Gr.)
which joins the Cephissus not far from Lilaea. Some people Pindus/Acyphas, Pyrgos (Gr.)
call Pindus “Acyphas.” Cytinium, Palaiokhori/Ag.
Georgios (Gr.)
427 C, 24-29 The king of these people was Aegimius. Having been ex-
pelled from his kingdom, he was (history tells us) reinstated
by Heracles. He repaid the f avor a fter Heracles’s death in the
Oeta region: he adopted Hyllus, Heracles’s eldest son. Suc-
cession passed to Hyllus and his descendants. Starting from
here, the Heraclids made their return to the Peloponnese. |
427 C, 29-32 For a while, the cities were of some significance, although 9.4.11
small, and their territory of little worth; then their status was
diminished. With the Phocian war and the dominance of the
Macedonians, Aetolians, and Athamanians, it is a miracle that
any trace of them has been preserved into Roman times.
427 C, 33-37 The Aenianians have suffered the same fate. They w ere
AENIANIANS/OETAEANS eradicated by the Aetolians and Athamanians. The Aetolians
e. cen. Greece
achieved great power by waging war in alliance with the Acarna-
nians. The Athamanians—who were the last of the Epirotes to
achieve distinction when the rest had already been destroyed—
built up their resources u nder their king, Amynandrus. |
428 C, 1-9 These people occupied Oeta. The mountain range extends These people = 9.4.12
?Athamanians/?Aenianians
from Thermopylae and the east, reaching t oward the Ambra-
Thermopylae, Thermopiles (Gr.)
cian gulf and the west. In a way, this range intersects at right
angles the mountainous region r unning from Parnassus as far
as Pindus and the inland natives. The section of this range that
heads toward Thermopylae is called “Oeta”: it is two hundred
stades in length, rugged and high. It is at its highest at Ther-
mopylae: it reaches its peak t here, and ends in sharp, sheer
cliffs down to the sea, leaving only a narrow passage for those
accessing the Locrians from Thessaly alongside the shore. |
428 C, 10-14 The passage is called “Pylae” (Gates), “Stena” (Narrows),1 and 9.4.13
[ 1 ] We tend to use “narrows” to mean a strait in a lake or sea; in Greek, the word
can mean a narrow stretch of land, as is the case here.
500
Fourth Band: Locris
428 C, 19-28 These localities are rendered difficult to access by their 9.4.14
held the “Keys to the Narrows” and since t hose on the far
side of the Narrows were engaged in battles for supremacy
with those on this side. Similarly, from the perspective of his
Macedonian base, Philip used to call Chalcis and Corinth the
“Fetters of Greece”; at a l ater date, men referred to t hese cities
as the “Shackles,” as also Demetrias, the city that was mistress Demetrias, Volos (Gr.)
of the Tempe pass, since she possessed both Pelium and Ossa.
At a later date, all these localities having been subjugated to
one power, everything . . . * has been opened up to all. |
429 C, 3-9 It was in this region of the Narrows that t hose associated 9.4.16
501
3.3. Greece
429 C, 15-20 As for the section outside,2 the portion toward the east and
Preview of 5th band of Greece the Malian gulf belongs to the Thessalians, while the portion
toward the west belongs to the Aetolians and Acarnanians.3
(The Athamanians are extinct.) | The Thessalian federation is 9.4.18
the largest and oldest one: some of the nations are mentioned
by Homer, some by various other writers. As for the Aetolians,
Homer always uses just the one name (cataloguing, as subject
to them, cities rather than nations), except in the case of the
Curetes,4 who must be categorized as part of the Aetolica.5
429 C, 20-23 I must start then with Thessalians, passing over (as I have
THESSALY done in other contexts) the mass of ancient, mythical, and
e. Greece
inconsistent data, but presenting what appears to me to be
relevant. |
429 C, 24-28 The seaward side of the territory is formed by the coastline 9.5.1
from Thermopylae to the outlet of the Peneius and the end Thermopylae, Thermopiles (Gr.)
of Pelium, facing toward the east and toward the northern Peneius, Peneios r.
[ 1 ] Strabo includes within the 5th band the island of Euboea to the east (444 C,
8–449 C, 30) and the islands of Ithaca, Cephallenia, Zacynthus, Taphos, and the
Echinades to the west (453 C, 16–459 C, 16).
[ 2 ] I.e., outside (= north of) Thermopylae (Thermopiles, Gr.): 334 C, 14-17.
[ 3 ] Thessaly (e. Greece): 429 C, 20–444 C, 7. Aetolia, Acarnania (sw. Greece): 449 C,
31–466 C, 7.
[ 4 ] For the Homeric lines in which the names Aetolians and Curetes appear: 463 C,
7-16.
[ 5 ] Aetolica (lit., “Stuff about Aetolia”) is the section of Strabo’s narrative (462 C,
31–466 C, 7) in which he discusses the Aetolian origin of the Curetes; cf. 444 C,
8-11n; 462 C, 28-30n. Strabo’s use of such “titles”: 639 C, 15-27n.
[ 6 ] 429 C, 24–430 C, 2.
502
Fifth Band: Thessaly, Acarnania, Aetolia
cept for Pelium and Ossa. These are quite high. They do not
encompass much territory but come to an end in the plains.
| The latter form the center of Thessaly, a territory that is 9.5.2
503
3.3. Greece
[ 1 ] Strabo frames the ensuing section of his narrative (431 C, 18–433 C, 32) around
this passage from Homer. Pelasgian Argos, 431 C, 18-22. Alus (Halus) and Alopa,
432 C, 31–433 C, 15. Trechis (Trachin), 433 C, 19-30; cf. 428 C, 14-28. Phthia and
Hellas, 431 C, 22–432 C, 30. Myrmidons, 433 C, 30-31. Achaeans, 433 C, 31-32.
[ 2 ] I.e., the 10 dynastic “parts” into which, Strabo claims (430 C, 24-32n), Homer
divides Thessaly.
[ 3 ] Strabo explains the name Pelasgian Argos as used in the Homeric passage cited
at 430 C, 33-38.
[ 4 ] Strabo explains the name Phthia as used in the Homeric passage cited at 430 C,
33-38.
[ 5 ] I.e., Phthiotis, the southern part of Thessaly, according to the 4-fold division of
Thessaly at 430 C, 16-24.
504
Fifth Band: Thessaly, Acarnania, Aetolia
431 C, 37–432 C, 7 As for those claiming that Hellas was a city, the Pharsalians
identify a ruined city (sixty stades from their own city), which
they believe was Hellas, and two nearby springs, Messeïs and
Hyperia. The Melitaeans say that Hellas was established not
far—some ten stades—from their own city, on the other side
of the Enipeus, at the time when their own city was known their own city = Melitia/Pyrrha,
Avaritsa (Gr.)
as “Pyrrha”; and that the Hellenes relocated to their city from
Hellas, which was in a low-lying area. They present as evi-
dence the tomb, in their marketplace, of Hellen, son of Deu-
calion and Pyrrha (history tells us that Deucalion ruled over
Phthiotis, and over Thessaly in general).
432 C, 8-9 The Enipeus flows from Othrys past Pharsalus and joins
the Apidanus, which then joins the Peneius. Apidanus, Pharsalitis r.
[ 1 ] Strabo explains the name Hellas as used in the Homeric passage cited at 430 C,
33-38.
[ 2 ] 431 C, 22–432 C, 9.
[ 3 ] Strabo explains the name Phthia as used in the Homeric passage cited at 430 C,
33-38.
[ 4 ] The “title” Battle at the Ships refers to a part of Homer’s Iliad. Strabo often uses
“titles” for parts of Homer’s poems (4 C, 14-20n), as well as for parts of his work
and the works of others (639 C, 15-27n).
505
3.3. Greece
and all the territory that was subject to Philoctetes; and they
consider as belonging to Phthia the territory that was subject to
Protesilaus, from Dolopia and Pindus to the Magnesian coast.
432 C, 26-30 The distance to the city subject to Protesilaus, namely An- Antron, Glypha/Akhilleion (Gr.)
433 C, 8-19 Halus is called both “Phthiotan” and “Achaean.” Like the
foothills of Othrys, she has a border with the Malians. Just as
Phylaca (which was subject to Protesilaus) belongs to the part Phylaca, Persouphli/Dervesi
(Gr.)
of Phthiotis next to the Malians, such is the case with Halus.
Halus, Alos (Gr.)
She is around one hundred stades from Thebes and is midway
between Pharsalus and the Phthiotans. Philip, having taken
her away from the Phthiotans, allocated her to the Phar-
salians. So it happens that boundaries and compositions of
nations and places undergo constant change, as I said.4 Thus,
Sophocles (5th c. BCE) too, Sophocles calls Trachin “Phthiotan.” Artemidorus puts
Artemidorus (late 2nd–early Halus on the coast outside the Malian gulf but considers her
1st c. BCE)
Phthiotan. (Going from t here in the direction of the Peneius, from there = from the Malian
gulf
he puts Pteleum a fter Antron, and then puts Halus one hun-
Pteleum, Gritsa (Gr.)
dred and ten stades from Pteleum.)
433 C, 19-30 The nature of Trachin has already been described, and the
Identity of Homer’s “Trechis” poet mentions it by name.5 | In his frequent references to the 9.5.9
506
Fifth Band: Thessaly, Acarnania, Aetolia
and the far side w ere subject to him. The Sperchius is around him = Achilles
thirty stades from Lamia, which lies above a plain that ex- Lamia, Lamia (Gr.)
He = Homer tends to the Malian gulf. He shows that the Sperchius is local
with the statement that it caused his hair to grow and with the his hair = Achilles’s hair
clia and Dryopis, which was once a tetrapolis (four-city state) like
Doris and considered to be the metropolis of the Pelopon-
nesian Dryopians. Also belonging to Oetaea are Acyphas,
Parasopias, Oeniadae, Anticyra (homonymous with the city
among the Western Locrians).3 I give these arrangements not
as having remained the same over time but rather as having
undergone various changes. T hose that are absolutely most
famous are worth mentioning. |
434 C, 16-24 The poet quite clearly shows that the Dolopians are on the 9.5.11
poet = Homer (8th c. BCE) fringes of Phthia, and that both they and the Phthiotans were
[ 1 ] Strabo explains the name Myrmidons as used in the Homeric passage cited at
430 C, 33-38.
[ 2 ] Strabo explains the name Achaeans as used in the Homeric passage cited at
430 C, 33-38.
[ 3 ] Perhaps a slip by Strabo, who elsewhere allocates Anticyra to the Phocians:
416 C, 11-21; 418 C, 20-28; 423 C, 10-15. Strabo does sometimes err, e.g., 415 C,
31–416 C, 2n.
507
3.3. Greece
Lamians’ city lies inland from Phalara, fifty stades from the Lamians’ city = Lamia, Lamia
(Gr.)
coast. A fter you sail the next one hundred stades along the
coast, Echinus lies inland. In the interior b ehind the next Echinus, Akhinos (Gr.)
stretch of coast, t here’s Larisa Cremasta, twenty stades back Larisa Cremasta, Pelasgia (Gr.)
from the coast (she’s also called “Larisa Pelasgia”). | Then 9.5.14
there’s the small island of Myonnesus, then Antron (which Myonnesus, Ag. Nikolaos (Gr.)
508
Fifth Band: Thessaly, Acarnania, Aetolia
of Athamania.
435 C, 39-43 Off Antron, in the strait with Euboea, is an underwater
reef called “Onos Antronos” (Ass-of-Antron); then Pteleum and Pteleum, Gritsa (Gr.)
Halus; then Demeter’s temple, and ruined Pyrasus, above Halus, Alos (Gr.)
which is Thebes; then a headland, Pyrrha, and two nearby Pyrasus, Nea Ankhialos (Gr.)
[ 1 ] I.e., “remaining” as per Strabo’s overview of Thessaly (e. Greece) at 430 C, 3-32.
This remaining part is described at 435 C, 21–444 C, 7.
[ 2 ] Boeotiaca (lit., “Stuff about Boeotia”) refers to the section of Strabo’s narrative
(400 C, 11–416 C, 10) in which he describes Boeotia (s. cen. Greece), and within
which he mentions Arna, “Itonian” Athena, and the Cuarius river (411 C, 16-26).
For Strabo’s use of such “titles”: 639 C, 15-27n.
[ 3 ] 4 parts of Thessaly: 430 C, 16-24.
509
3.3. Greece
436 C, 5-11 Iolcus has long been in ruins, but it was from h ere that Iolcus, Volos Kastro (Gr.)
Demetrias.
436 C, 11-19 Demetrius Poliorcetes founded Demetrias (named a fter Demetrias, Volos (Gr.)
436 C, 24-26 Near Demetrias flows the Anaurus. The next stretch of Demetrias, Volos (Gr.)
[ 1 ] 428 C, 29–429 C, 2.
[ 2 ] 374 C, 32–375 C, 7.
510
Fifth Band: Thessaly, Acarnania, Aetolia
[ 1 ] “Carystian” marble (from Greece): 446 C, 16-21. “Synnadic” marble (from Tur-
key): 577 C, 11-19, with reference to its use in Rome.
[ 2 ] Strabo probably saw Scyrian marble himself, when in Rome (30s BCE and sub-
sequently: 273 C, 2-14nn).
[ 3 ] Strabo identifies the Tricca in the Homeric passage cited at 437 C, 15-19.
[ 4 ] Strabo identifies the Ithoma in the Homeric passage cited at 437 C, 15-19.
511
3.3. Greece
[ 1 ] This information was given in the “eastern European gap”: 329 C, 15–332 C, 1.
[ 2 ] Strabo identifies the Oechalia in the Homeric passages cited at 339 C, 6-16.
[ 3 ] Peloponnesiaca (lit., “Stuff about the Peloponnese”) is the section of narrative
(335 C, 1–389 C, 42) in which Strabo deals with the Peloponnese (s. Greece),
within which he twice discusses the name Oechalia (339 C, 6-16; 350 C, 6-12).
Strabo’s use of such “titles”: 639 C, 15-27n.
[ 4 ] Creophylus (?8th–7th c. BCE) as the author of the Fall of Oechalia: 638 C, 19–
639 C, 2.
[ 5 ] Strabo frames the ensuing section of narrative (438 C, 26–439 C, 25) around
this passage from Homer: Ormenium, 438 C, 26–439 C, 14; Hyperia, Asterium,
Titanus, 439 C, 22-25.
[ 6 ] 436 C, 11-19.
512
Fifth Band: Thessaly, Acarnania, Aetolia
overland. The site of Iolcus lies on the route, seven stades from
Demetrias and the remaining twenty stades from Ormenium.
438 C, 35–439 C, 5 The Scepsian says that Phoenix came from Ormenium, fleeing
Scepsian = Demetrius (2nd c. thence from his “father, Amyntor the Ormenid,” to Phthia “to lord Ormenid = descendant of
BCE) Ormenus
Peleus.” He explains that the place had been founded by Ormenus
(son of Cerphius, who was the son of Aeolus); Ormenus’s sons w ere
Amyntor and Euaemon; the son of the former was Phoenix, the son
of the latter Eurypylus; their joint legacy was reserved for Eurypylus,
Demetrius of Scepsis emends given that Phoenix had departed from his homeland. He writes, as
the text of Homer
when I first left Ormenium with its many flocks, rather than . . .
I left Hellas with her fair w
omen.
439 C, 5-14 Crates represents Phoenix as a Phocian, using as evidence
Crates (2nd c. BCE) the helmet of Meges—used by Odysseus in the “Night Waking” 1—
concerning which the poet says, “from Eleon, from Amyntor the Or-
menid, / it was stolen by Autolycus, penetrating the well-defended
home”: “Eleon” is a small town on Parnassus; “Amyntor the Or-
menid” means none other than Phoenix’s f ather; and Autolycus,
a resident of Parnassus, must have burgled his neighbors’ property
(since this is the universal practice of e very burglar!) rather
than property far away.
439 C, 15-21 The Scepsian says that no site on Parnassus is identified as
Scepsian = Demetrius (2nd c. “Eleon”—although there is a “Neon,” which was founded after the
BCE)
Trojan period—nor are burglaries committed only by neighbors! Trojan period, late 2nd–early
1st millennium BCE
One could say other things, too, but I hesitate to spend any
more time on this. Some people write from “Heleon” (which
is part of Tanagra). This is proved even more absurd by the
statement, then I fled far away, through . . . Hellas, / and I came statement = by Homer
to Phthia.
439 C, 22-25 Hyperia is a spring in the middle of the Pheraeans’ city,
which . . . *. It is absurd, therefore . . . *. Titanus (Chalk) is so
named a fter the facts of the m atter: the place has white soil,
being near Arna and . . . *. Nor is Asterium far from those
places.2 |
439 C, 26-28 Next to this part are listed the people subject to Polypo- 9.5.19
[ 1 ] The “title” Night Waking refers to a part of Homer’s Iliad. “Titles” are often used
for parts of Homer’s poems: 4 C, 14-20n. Cf. Strabo’s use of “titles” for parts of
his own work: 639 C, 15-27n.
[ 2 ] Strabo identifies the Hyperia, Titanus, and Asterium in the Homeric passage
cited at 438 C, 23-25.
[ 3 ] Strabo frames his ensuing section of narrative (439 C, 29–441 C, 8) around
this passage from Homer: Argisa, Ortha, 440 C, 4-8; Gyrtona/Gyrton, 439 C,
29–440 C, 3; Elona, Oloosson, 440 C, 33–441 C, 8.
[ 4 ] Strabo identifies the Gyrtona (Gyrton) in the Homeric passage cited at 439 C,
26-28.
513
3.3. Greece
Atrax lies forty stades inland from her, also near the river. The Atrax, Aliphaka/Koutsokhero
(Gr.)
intervening riverlands were once held by the Perrhaebians.
Some say that Ortha was the acropolis of the Phalannaeans.1
Phalanna is a Perrhaebian city on the Peneius near Tempe. Phalanna, Damasi (Gr.)
440 C, 9-17 Many of the Perrhaebians, when they lost power to the
Lapithians, left for the mountainous territory in the region
of Pindus, the Athamanians, and the Dolopians. Their terri-
tory, and the Perrhaebians who stayed b ehind, fell under the
control of the Larisaeans. The latter lived near the Peneius Larisaeans = inhabitants of
Larisa, Larisa (Gr.)
and were the Perrhaebians’ neighbors but lived in the parts
of the plains blessed with the greatest fertility (except for a
deep concavity by lake Nessonis, into which the river, when in
flood, used to put a portion of the arable land taken from the
Larisaeans—but the Larisaeans later solved the problem by
means of embankments). These people held Perrhaebia and
exacted tribute until such time as Philip established himself
as lord of the region.
440 C, 17-32 There is also a “Larisa” that is a place in Ossa; a [Larisa]
Cremasta, called “[Larisa] Pelasgia” by some; a city in Crete, now
amalgamated with Hierapytna (to which belongs the plain
below, now called “Larisium”); in the Peloponnese, the Argive
citadel and a “Larisus” river that separates Elia from Dyma
Theopompus (4th c. BCE) (Theopompus says that t here’s also a city of “Larisa” situated
in the same border territory). In Asia, t here’s a “Phriconian
[Larisa]” in the Cyme region, and a city at Hamaxitus in the
[ 1 ] Strabo explains the names Argisa and Ortha as used in the Homeric passage
cited at 439 C, 26-28.
514
Fifth Band: Thessaly, Acarnania, Aetolia
lines that follow when he says: Guneus brought two and twenty
ships from Cyphus. / His followers were the Enienians and the battle-
resolute Peraebians, / who built their homes around wintry Dodona /
and dwelt in the fields on either side of lovely Titaresius.
441 C, 9-20 He means that these sites, partly belonging to Hestiaeotis, He = Homer
these places, on account of their not yet being settled or only Scotussa, Ag. Triadi/Souphli (Gr.)
thinly settled, as a result of flooding in various parts at vari Mopsium, Stenon Rhodias (Gr.)
ous times. In truth, he does not mention even lake Nessonis, Atrax, Aliphaka/Koutsokhero
(Gr.)
only Boebeïs, which is much smaller but is the only perma-
nent lake, while the former (it is reasonable to suppose) was
sometimes unpredictably full, sometimes nonexistent.
[ 1 ] Perhaps observed by Strabo himself, who probably visited this village: 663 C,
19-33n.
[ 2 ] “Left-Hand Side of the Pontus (Black Sea coast of Eur. Tky., Bul., Rom., Ukr., Crim.,
Russ.)”: 289 C, 1-7n.
[ 3 ] Strabo identifies the Oloosson and Elona in the Homeric passage cited at 439 C,
26-28.
515
3.3. Greece
“Phlegyans” (after Phlegyas, the brother of Ixion) and called Gyrton, Mourlari (Gr.)
516
Fifth Band: Thessaly, Acarnania, Aetolia
as Heraclia and Echinus. Some of them, however, remained in Echinus, Akhinos (Gr.)
stretch of coast subject to Philoctetes and Eumelus. This will Erymnae, Kokkino Nero (Gr.)
have to remain unclear.
443 C, 10-18 Likewise, the order of the succeeding places as far as
Pelium is not clearly expressed; nor, since they are without
repute, w ill I spend much time on them. The Sepias headland Sepias headland, Ag. Georgios
(Gr.)
has featured in tragedies . . . * and, a fter this, is celebrated on
account of the destruction there of the Persian fleet. The
headland itself is rocky but, between the headland and the
village of Casthanaea at the foot of Pelium, there is a beach Casthanaea, Keramidi (Gr.)
where Xerxes’s fleet was lying in wait when Apeliotes started Apeliotes, east wind
blowing with great force. Some ships were blown onto dry
land right there and immediately wrecked; the rest w ere car- Persian fleet under Xerxes
shipwrecked, 480 BCE
ried to Ipni (a rocky place in the Pelium region), to Meliboea,
or to Casthanaea, and foundered.
443 C, 18-23 The entire shoreline of Pelium is rugged, for some . . . *
eighty stades. The shoreline of Ossa is of a similar nature and
for a similar distance. In between is a bay of more than two
hundred stades, in which Meliboea is situated. The entire
voyage as far as the Peneius, if you follow the coastal in-
dentations, is more than a thousand [stades] if you start from
Demetrias; a further eight hundred if you start from the
[ 1 ] Strabo uses the “title” Catalogue for the part of the Iliad in which Homer lists
the forces fighting at Troy: 4 C, 14-20n. Within it, the Thessalian Catalogue
deals specifically with the Thessalian forces. Cf. Laconian Catalogue (359 C, 2-14);
Aetolian Catalogue (427 C, 3-10; 460 C, 12-18; 462 C, 15-19; 462 C, 31–463 C, 7);
Paphlagonian Catalogue (544 C, 26–545 C, 2); Trojan Catalogue (603 C, 24-28;
609 C, 23–610 C, 7).
[ 2 ] Macedonica (lit., “Stuff about Macedonia”) is the section of Strabo’s narrative in
which he describes Macedonia (North Macedonia, ne. Greece, E uropean Tur-
key). Unfortunately, the section falls within the “eastern European gap”: 329 C,
15–332 C, 1. Strabo’s use of such “titles”: 639 C, 15-27n.
517
3.3. Greece
Pherae, Mopsium, Boebeïas, Ossa, Homola, Pelium, and Magnetis. Gyrtona = Gyrton, Mourlari (Gr.)
“Mopsium” is named not a fter Mopsus (son of Manto, who Pherae, Velestino (Gr.)
was the daughter of Tiresias) but after the Lapithian who Mopsium, Stenon Rhodias (Gr.)
sailed with the Argonauts; and there’s another “Mopsus”
after whom Attican “Mopsopia” is named. |
443 C, 32 That was my detailed account of Thessaly.1 9.5.23
443 C, 32–444 C, 7 In terms of the overall picture, it was previously called “Pyr-
rhaea” a fter Pyrrha (wife of Deucalion), “Haemonia” a fter Hae-
mon, and “Thessaly” after Thessalus (son of Haemon). Some
people, dividing it into two, say that the southern half fell to
Deucalion, and he called it “Pandora” a fter his m
other; and that
the other half fell to Haemon, after whom it was called “Haemo-
nia.” The former had its name changed to “Hellas” a fter Hellen
(son of Deucalion); and the latter to “Thessaly” a fter the son of
Haemon. Some people say that the descendants of Antiphus
and Phidippus, the sons of Thessalus (son of Heracles), arriving
from Thesprotian Ephyra, named the territory a fter Thessalus,
their own ancestor. It is also said that it was once, like the lake,
called “Nessonis” after Nesson (son of Thessalus). |
444 C, 8-11 Since Euboea lies lengthways facing this whole stretch of 10.1.1
sand two hundred stades from Cenaeum to Geraestus, but its Cenaeum, Cape Lichada
width is variable, some one hundred and fifty stades for the Geraestus, Cape Mandelo
most part. Cenaeum is opposite Thermopylae and the area a
little beyond Thermopylae; Geraestus and Petalia are at the Petalia, Megalonisi Petalion (Gk.
island)
Sunium end. The island thus f aces Attica, Boeotia, Locris,
and the Malians, across the strait. Because of its narrowness
and its aforementioned length, it was called “Macris” (Long [is-
land]) by people of long ago.
518
Fifth Band: Thessaly, Acarnania, Aetolia
445 C, 25-29 The Hellopians relocated to Histiaea and enlarged the city,
after they were forced out by the ruler Philistides following the
Demosthenes (4th c. BCE) battle of Leuctra. Demosthenes says that Philistides was also set
up as ruler of the Oritians by Philip; this is the name the Histiaeans
later took, and their city was named “Oreus” instead of Histiaea.
445 C, 29-33 Some people say that Histiaea was colonized by Athe-
nians from the “Histiaean” deme (as Eretria was colonized deme, administrative district
519
3.3. Greece
Theopompus (4th c. BCE) by those from the “Eretrian” deme). Theopompus says that,
when Pericles subdued Euboea, the Histiaeans relocated, under the
terms of an agreement, to Macedonia; two thousand Athenians, who
had previously belonged to the Histiaean deme, came and took up
Oreus/Histiaea, Kastro/Oreoi
residence in Oreus. | (Gr.)
445 C, 33–446 C, 8 The city lies at the foot of mount Telethrium in what is 10.1.4
Athens, an Athenian establishment overlooking the strait at Dium, ?Likhas Kastri (Gr.)
Cynus. (Canae in the Aeolid was sent as a colony from Dium.) Diadic Athens, Yialtra Kastelli/
Loutra (Gr.)
These places are in the Histiaea region, as is Cerinthus, a small
Cerinthus, Kria Vrisi/Ag. Ilias
city on the coast. Nearby is “Budorus” river (having the same (Gr.)
name as the mountain in Attica at Salamis). |
446 C, 16-21 Carystus is at the foot of mount Ocha. Nearby is Styra, and Styra, Nea Styra (Gr.) 10.1.6
[ 1 ] 437 C, 20-26.
[ 2 ] Strabo may have seen the finished pillars in Rome: 437 C, 8-14nn.
[ 3 ] The “title” Catalogue of Ships refers to a part of Homer’s Iliad: 4 C, 14-20n;
cf. 639 C, 15-27n.
520
Fifth Band: Thessaly, Acarnania, Aetolia
after Chalcis) and then Chalcis, which is in some sense the Chalcis, Khalkis/Negroponte
(Gr.)
island’s metropolis, situated right on the Euripus. Both cit-
ies are said to have been founded by the Athenians before the
Trojan period. After the Trojan period, Aeclus and Cothus set Trojan period, late 2nd–early
1st millennium BCE
out from Athens, the former colonizing Eretria, Cothus colo-
nizing Chalcis. Some Aeolians from Penthilus’s army stayed
behind on the island, as also, in antiquity, some Arabs who
had crossed the sea with Cadmus.
447 C, 4-13 These cities did exceptionally well and sent colonies of
significant size to Macedonia. Eretria colonized the cities in Eretria, Eretria (Gr.)
the region of Pallene and Athos; Chalcis colonized the cit- Chalcis, Khalkis/Negroponte
(Gr.)
ies subject to Olynthus, which w ere thoroughly ravaged by
Philip. Many places in Italy and Sicily, too, are Chalcidian.
Aristotle (4th c. BCE) These colonies were sent out, according to Aristotle, when
what was called the “Hippobatian” government was in power;
men headed the government on the basis of their assets, rul-
ing in an aristocratic fashion. They also, at the time of Alex-
ander’s sea crossing, increased the circumference of the city,
taking within the walls Canethus and the Euripus, and put-
ting towers, gates, and a wall on the bridge. |
447 C, 14-25 Inland from the Chalcidian city is what is called the “Lelan- 10.1.9
tum” plain. On this plain, there are springs of hot water useful
for curing diseases (which were even used by Cornelius Sulla,
the Roman general); and t here was once an amazing mine of
copper and iron together, a phenomenon not documented
elsewhere (nowadays both metals have been exhausted). All
of Euboea is prone to seismic activity, particularly in the re-
gion of the strait, and it is subject to volcanic blasts, as is the
case also with Boeotia and other places, as I described earlier
at length.1 The city homonymous with the island is said to
have been swallowed up by some such tragedy. The city is also
Aeschylus (5th c. BCE) mentioned in the Glaucus Pontius by Aeschylus: Euboea’s turn-
ing point, around the headland of “Cenaean” Zeus, / right by the
grave of poor Lichas.
521
3.3. Greece
stades from the city wall. The Persians destroyed the ancient Amarynthus, Palaiokhoria/Kato
Vathia (Gr.)
Herodotus (5th c. BCE) city after netting (as Herodotus says) its population, with the
barbarians en masse surrounding the walls. People point out the
foundations even now and call it “Old Eretria” (the city of today
has been founded anew). Bearing witness to the power that the
Eretrians once held is a stone tablet, which they once dedicated
as an offering in the t emple to “Amarynthian” Artemis. It is
written on the tablet that they made the ceremonial procession with
three thousand hoplites, six hundred h orsemen, and sixty chariots. They
held sway over Andrians, Tenians, Ceians, as well as other is-
lands. They received additional settlers from Elis, as a result of
which they have been represented in comedy as frequently using
the letter “r,” not only at the end of words but also in the middle.
448 C, 12-14 Also in Eretrian territory is a village, “Oechalia,” the rem- Oechalia, ?Kastri/Ano Potamia
(Gr.)
nants of the city destroyed by Heracles. It shares its name
with the Trachinian city, the city in the Tricca region, the Ar-
cadian city that people of later times called “Andania,” and the
Aetolian city in the region of the Eurytanians. |
448 C, 15-21 Chalcis is nowadays unanimously considered to be Chalcis, Khalkis/Negroponte 10.1.11
(Gr.)
the number-one city—and she is said to be the Euboean
metropolis—with Eretria ranking second. Even in former Eretria, Eretria (Gr.)
522
Fifth Band: Thessaly, Acarnania, Aetolia
448 C, 22-25 In general, these two cities acted in concert with each 10.1.12
523
3.3. Greece
AETOLIA, ACARNANIA call the latter “Greek”) are to the west of the Thessalians and
sw. Greece
Oetaeans. What remains, so that we will have described the
complete circuit of all Greece,2 is to talk about t hese p
eople
and to add an account of those islands lying near Greece, and
inhabited by Greeks, which I have not yet traversed.3 |
449 C, 36–450 C, 13 The Aetolians and Acarnanians share a border, with the 10.2.1
Achelous river between them, flowing from the north and Achelous, Akheloos r.
[ 1 ] 263 C, 25-28.
[ 2 ] I.e., what “remains” of Strabo’s account of Greece, as defined at 332 C, 1–333 C,
3; 416 C, 11–417 C, 27.
[ 3 ] Acarnania, Aetolia: 449 C, 36–466 C, 8. Islands: Ithaca, Cephallenia, Zacynthus,
Echinades, Taphos: 452 C, 34–459 C, 16. Crete, Cyclades, Sporades: 474 C, 21–
489 C, 27.
[ 4 ] “Achelous” river in Peloponnese: 342 C, 10-18.
[ 5 ] “Achelous” river in Thessaly: 433 C, 33–434 C, 6.
[ 6 ] Strabo somewhat refines his earlier statement (335 C, 29–336 C, 5, where the
Euenus is said to mark the start of the Corinthian gulf, with the Achelous as an
alternative marker).
524
Fifth Band: Thessaly, Acarnania, Aetolia
Stratus, which is reached by voyaging up the Achelous for Stratus, Sourovigli (Gr.)
more than two hundred stades; Oeniadae, which is also Oeniadae, Trikardo (Gr.)
Corax, Ghiona mt. (Gr.) Oeta. Of the other mountains, Aracynthus is somewhat
Aracynthus, Zygos mt. (Gr.) more central. Newer Pleuron was built near this mountain Newer Pleuron, Kato Retsina
(Gr.)
by her founders, who left Old Pleuron (near Calydon), even
Old Pleuron, Gyphtokastro/
though it was fertile and level, when the territory was sacked Petrovouni (Gr.)
by the man known as “Aetolian Demetrius.” Taphiassus and
Chalcis, Barasovon mt. (Gr.) Chalcis are above Molycria. T hese are mountains of quite a Molycria, Velvina/Elliniko (Gr.)
height, and on them are situated the little towns of Macynia Macynia, Kato Mammakou (Gr.)
and Chalcis, which has the same name as the mountain and Chalcis/Hypochalcis, Kato
Vasiliki (Gr.)
which people also call “Hypochalcis” (Under-Chalcis). Curium is
near Old Pleuron: some have supposed that the Pleuronian
Curetes take their name from this mountain.1 |
451 C, 8-16 The Euenus river starts at the Bomians 2 (among the Euenus, Phidaris r. 10.2.5
525
3.3. Greece
after the return of the Heraclids!), illustrating his extreme Molycria, Velvina/Elliniko (Gr.)
the mainland, by which he means Acarnania, with the conse- Cephallenia, Kephallenia (Gk.
island)
quence that, whenever he says promontory of the mainland, one
should understand promontory of Acarnania. Nericus,4 which
Laertes says he took (since I took the well-built city of Nericus, / a
promontory of the mainland, when I was lord of the Cephallenians),
and the cities referred to in the Catalogue 5 (they dwelt in Cro-
cylia and steep Aegilips), were part of Leucas.
452 C, 8-15 The Corinthians, dispatched by Cypselus, and . . . *,
took possession of the promontory and proceeded as far as
the Ambracian gulf (both Ambracia and Anactorium w ere
settled). Digging across the isthmus of the peninsula, they
Leucas (island), Lefkada Nericus/Leucas (city), Kalligoni
(Gk. island) made Leucas into an island. Transferring Nericus over what (Gr.)
[1] Strabo identifies the Olenus in the Homeric passage cited at 386 C, 9-15.
[2] 449 C, 31–451 C, 25.
[3] 451 C, 29–460 C, 11.
[4] Strabo possibly corrects his earlier citation of the name: 59 C, 1-10n. Cf. 454 C,
4-24n.
[ 5 ] The “title” Catalogue refers to a part of Homer’s Iliad: 4 C, 14-20n.
526
Fifth Band: Thessaly, Acarnania, Aetolia
ing out from Leucas into the sea toward Cephallenia. So, this
is where the name comes from. |
452 C, 15-24 It has the temple to “Leucatas” Apollo, and also the Leap 10.2.9
that has been believed to put an end to love affairs, where Sap-
Menander (late 4th–early 3rd c. pho is said to have been the first, according to Menander, chasing
BCE)
proud Phaon, / passion spurring her on, to hurl herself from the rock
/ seen from far away. But, according to your prayer, / O lord and
master. Although Menander says that Sappho was the first
to make the jump, those looking further back in history say
that it was Cephalus (son of Deioneus), who was in love with
Pterelas.
452 C, 24-29 It used to be a tradition among the Leucadians that, at the
yearly sacrifices to Apollo, an accused man was hurled from
the rock, in order to ward off evil (all sorts of feathers were
fastened to him, as well as birds, who were able to alleviate his
fall by their flight); a group of men, gathering at the bottom
in their little fishing boats, picked him up and saved his life,
if they could, by taking him beyond the borders.
452 C, 30-33 The author of the Alcmaeonis says that Icarius (father of
Penelope) had two sons—Alyzeus and Leucadius—who ruled
Ephorus (4th c. BCE) in Acarnania with their father. Ephorus seems to say that the
cities w ere named a fter t hese p
eople. |
452 C, 34–453 C, 6 By “Cephallenians,” people nowadays mean “those from 10.2.10
the island of Cephallenia,” whereas Homer means “all t hose Cephallenia, Kephallenia (Gk.
island)
under the command of Odysseus,” including the Acarna-
nians. He says, but Odysseus led the Cephallenians, / who held
Ithaca and Neritum (Ithaca’s conspicuous mountain) of the
quivering leaves, just as he says, those from Dulichium and the sa-
cred Echinades, when Dulichium is itself one of the Echinades,
and those who held Buprasium and Elis, when Buprasium is in
Elis, and those who held Euboea and Chalcis and Eiretria, when
the latter are in Euboea, and Trojans, Lycians, and Dardanians,
when the latter are Trojans.
453 C, 6-15 However, after Neritum, he continues, who dwelt in Crocylia he = Homer
and steep Aegilips, / who held Zacynthus and were spread through
Samos, / and who held the mainland and dwelt on the shore across
the water. By mainland, he means the part opposite the islands,
527
3.3. Greece
Apollodorus (2nd c. BCE) for disambiguation (saying “rugged Samos” to mean the island), and
at another point that what should be written is “Dulichium and
Samos,” rather than “Same,” he clearly works on the assumption
that, whereas the city is called synonymously “Samos” and
“Same,” the island is called only “Samos”; for it is clear that the
poet = Homer (8th c. BCE) city is called “Same” when the poet enumerates the suitors and says,
“there are four and twenty men from Same” and tells the story of
Ctimene, “whom they sent to Same.”
454 C, 1-3 There is some logic to this. The poet does not express him-
self clearly in regard to Cephallenia nor in regard to Ithaca and Cephallenia, Kephallenia (Gk.
island)
other places in the area, which leads to disagreement between
Ithaca, Ithake (Gk. island)
both commentators and historical researchers. |
454 C, 4-9 For example, in the case of Ithaca, when he refers to those he = Homer 10.2.11
ITHACA who held Ithaca and Neritum of the quivering leaves, he makes
Ithake (Gk. island)
it clear by his use of the epithet that he means Neritum the
mountain. In other passages, he explicitly uses the word
“mountain”: I dwell in bright Ithaca. On it is a mountain, / Neri-
tum of the quivering leaves, conspicuous from afar.
454 C, 10-15 However, in the line who held Ithaca and Neritum, it is
not clear whether he means Ithaca the city or Ithaca the is-
land. From a grammatical point of view, someone hearing
this would take it as meaning the city, just as if one were to
say, “Athens and Lycabettus,” or “Rhodes and Atabyris,” or
“Lacedaemon and Taygetus.” From the point of view of poetic
usage, the opposite would be the case.
528
Fifth Band: Thessaly, Acarnania, Aetolia
529
3.3. Greece
(uncle of Marc Antony) founded another city when, being in Pronesus, Poros (Gr.)
exile following the consulship that he shared with Cicero the Cranii, Argostolion (Gr.)
530
Fifth Band: Thessaly, Acarnania, Aetolia
456 C, 9-18 Nor is Hellanicus Homeric in saying that Cephallenia is Cephallenia, Kephallenia
(Gk. island)
Hellanicus (5th c. BCE) Dulichium. The latter is said to be subject to Meges, as are
also the other Echinades, and their inhabitants to be Epians
who came from Elis, which is why he calls Otus the Cyllenian
Strabo rejects theory that
“Dulichium” was the name comrade of the Phyleid and ruler of the greathearted Epians . . . but
used by Homer to refer to the
island known in Strabo’s day as
Odysseus led the greathearted Cephallenians. Therefore, on the
Cephallenia basis of what Homer says, Cephallenia is not Dulichium. Nor,
Andron (4th c. BCE) as Andron claims, is Dulichium part of Cephallenia: the Epi-
ans were in possession of it, while all of Cephallenia was in it = Dulichium
(some say forty) stades from Leucatas, around eighty stades Leucatas, Akra Doukato
from Chelonatas. The island is roughly three hundred [stades] Chelonatas, Akra Kyllinis
[ 1 ] For difficulties with the text, see Radt, vol. 3, critical apparatus on 457 C, line 6.
531
3.3. Greece
name. Nor, formerly, did it even have the same name: it was
called “Melamphyllos,” then “Anthemis,” then “Parthenia” (after
the Parthenius river, whose name was changed to “Imbrasus”).
457 C, 16-23 Since both Cephallenia and Samothrace w ere called Samos Cephallenia, Kephallenia
(Gk. island)
in Trojan times (otherwise he would not have represented Hec-
Samothrace, Samothrake
abe as saying in respect of her sons that he would take whichever (Gk. island)
one he captured . . . to Samos and Imbros as merchandise), and since
the Ionian island had not yet been colonized, it is clear that the Ionian island = Samos, Samos
(Gk.)
latter took the homonym from one of the two former islands.
Strabo rejects theory that island From this, it is also clear that ancient history does not support
known to Homer as “Samos”
and to Strabo as “Samothrace” the claim that, after the Ionian colonization and the arrival
was colonized from Ionian of Tembrion, colonists from Samos went to Samothrace and
Samos
named it “Samos.” The Samians made this up for the sake of
their greater glory.
457 C, 23-33 Those p eople are more credible who claim that the island
acquired its name from the fact that lofty places w ere called
samoi—thence all Ida could be seen, / and Priam’s city, and the
ships of the Achaeans. Some say that she was called “Samos”
from the “Saians,” the Thracians who formerly lived t here and
who also held the neighboring mainland—whether they are
poet = Homer (8th c. BCE) identified with the Sapaeans or Sintans (called by the poet
Archilochus (7th c. BCE) Sintians) or whether they were different. (Archilochus men-
tions the “Saians”: one of the Saians rejoices in my shield, which by
a bush, / a blameless weapon, I left behind, not willingly. |
457 C, 34–458 C, 5 Of the islands allocated to Odysseus’s control, the one 10.2.18
ZACYNTHUS that remains to be described is Zacynthus, located a little to
Zakynthos (Gk. island)
the west of the Peloponnese, more so than Cephallenia, and
largely adjacent to it. The circumference of Zacynthus is one
hundred and sixty stades. It is some sixty stades from Ceph-
allenia, wooded but lush; and has a sizable city of the same
name. The distance from t here to the Libyan Hesperides is
three thousand three hundred stades. |
458 C, 6-14 East of this island and of Cephallenia are the Echinades. 10.2.19
532
Fifth Band: Thessaly, Acarnania, Aetolia
ECHINADES lands called “Oxians,” which the poet called Thoae. Dolicha Oxians, Oxia (Gk. island) and
Echinades (Gk. islands) Koutsilaris (Gr.)
faces Oeniadae and the outflow of the Achelous, and is one
Oeniadae, Trikardo (Gr.)
hundred stades from Araxus, the Elian headland. The rest
Achelous, Akheloos r.
of the Echinades (there are several, all of them miserable and
Araxus, Cape Araxos (Gr.)
rocky) lie in front of the Achelous’s outlet, the farthest island
being fifteen stades from it, the nearest five. Previously they
lay out to sea, but the large amount of sediment carried down
by the river has already caused some to become part of the
mainland and w ill cause o thers to become so.
458 C, 14-27 The sedimentation made the territory called “Parache-
loïtis” (which the river floods) a m atter of contention, b ecause
it was always obliterating the boundaries proclaimed by the
Acarnanians and the Aetolians. T hese people, since they had
no arbiters, used to decide the matter by resorting to arms,
with the strongest side generally winning. This was the origin,
too, of a myth in which Heracles fought a long and hard b attle
against Achelous and won, as a prize for his victory, marriage
Sophocles (5th c. BCE) to Deianira (daughter of Oeneus), whom Sophocles has rep-
resented as saying the following: the river was my suitor, I mean
Achelous, / who in three different guises asked my f ather for my hand
in marriage, / showing up in the shape of a bull, then as a shimmering
/ serpent with twisted coils, then with the body of a man but the face of
an ox. Some p eople add the statement that Achelous’s horn,
broken off by Heracles and given to Oeneus as a gift for his
daughter’s hand, is the “Horn of Amalthia.”
458 C, 27–459 C, 2 Some people, rationalizing these things, claim that the
Achelous (as also other rivers) is said to be “like a bull” Achelous, Akheloos r.
533
3.3. Greece
he quarreled with his father. The father was Augeas, who ruled
over Elia and the Epians, so that the Epians who held these
islands were t hose who accompanied Phyleus on his expedi-
tion to Dulichium. |
459 C, 8-15 The islands belonging to the Taphians (earlier, “Telebo- 10.2.20
TAPHOS ans”), which included Taphos (now called “Taphius”), were
Meganisi (Gk. island)
separate from the aforementioned, not in terms of distance
(given that they lie close by) but in terms of being treated as
subject to other (Taphian and Teleboan) leaders. In e arlier
times, Amphitryon campaigned against them with Cepha-
lus (son of Deioneus), a fugitive from Athens, to whom he
poet = Homer (8th c. BCE) granted sovereignty over them. The poet says they w ere sub-
ject to Mentes, calling them “pirates,” which is what everyone
calls the Teleboans.
459 C, 16 The foregoing concerns the islands off Acarnania.1 |
459 C, 17-18 Between Leucas and the Ambracian gulf is a lagoon, 10.2.21
Myrtuntium, Limni Voulkaria
known as “Myrtuntium.” (Gr.)
459 C, 18-25 Next after Leucas are the Acarnanian cities of Palaerus Palaerus, Kekhropoula (Gr.)
and Alyzia. Of these, Alyzia is fifteen stades from the coast, Alyzia, Kandila (Gr.)
which has the same name, albeit singular as well as plural, as Astacus, Astakos (Gr.)
the city in the region of Nicomedia and the Astacenian bay.
(Crithota has the same name as one of those small towns on
the Thracian Cherronesus.) All the intervening stretch has
good harbors.
459 C, 25-31 Then there’s Oeniadae and the Achelous, then Oenidae’s Oeniadae, Trikardo (Gr.)
lake, called “Melita,” thirty stades long and twenty wide; an- Achelous, Akheloos r.
other lake, Cynia, twice as long and twice as wide; and a third
lake, Uria, much smaller than them. Cynia flows out into the
sea; the other two lie a half stade or so inland. Then there’s
the Euenus, the distance to which from Actium is six hundred Euenus, Phidaris r.
534
Fifth Band: Thessaly, Acarnania, Aetolia
Then there’s Taphiassus, the mountain; then the city of Mac- Macynia, Kato Mammakou (Gr.)
ynia; then Molycria and, nearby, Antirrhium (the boundary Molycria, Velvina/Elliniko (Gr.)
between Aetolia and Locris, the distance to which from the Antirrhium, Antirion (Gr.)
crossing.
460 C, 22-23 Pylene has suffered a fate similar to Olenus.3 Pylene, ?Magoula/Aiolikon (Gr.)
460 C, 23-26 When he describes Calydon as steep and rocky, his state- he = Homer
[ 1 ] Strabo adds to his e arlier statement (450 C, 32–451 C, 7, where the information
about Chalcis and Taphiassus is not attributed specifically to Apollodorus, and
the location of Calydon between Pleuron and Chalcis is not specified).
[ 2 ] 427 C, 3-10n; 442 C, 35–443 C, 9n.
[ 3 ] For the Homeric names Olenus and Pylene: 386 C, 9-15; 451 C, 17-25.
[ 4 ] Strabo adds to his e
arlier statement (450 C, 23-31, where the division of Aetolia
is noted, but the allocation to Calydon and Pleuron is not explicitly stated).
535
3.3. Greece
460 C, 31-35 Since Homer, as well as other poets and writers, men-
tions them at length, in some places clearly and consistently,
in other places less recognizably, just as this has been pointed
out in what has already been said about them,1 I must provide
in addition some of those more ancient accounts, both those
that are authoritative and those that are dubious. |
461 C, 1-4 First off, the case of Acarnania: I have already noted that 10.2.24
536
Fifth Band: Thessaly, Acarnania, Aetolia
537
3.3. Greece
some claiming that he came as successor to his brother’s dy- brother’s = Alcmaeon’s
nasty, o
thers making diff erent claims.
462 C, 28-30 The foregoing might be a specific description of the
Acarnanians.1 I s hall now discuss jointly what is interwoven
with the Aetolica,2 meaning the ensuing account of Aetolian
matters that I have decided to add to what I have already said. |
462 C, 31–463 C, 7 Some people assign the Curetes to the Acarnanians; some 10.3.1
Strabo classifies the “Curetes” assign them to the Aetolians. Some claim that their stock
as Aetolians
originated in Crete; some claim that it originated in Eu-
boea. Since Homer mentions them, I should first investigate
what he says. People assume that he means they are Aetolian
(rather than Acarnanian), on the basis that Agrius and Melas,
and the third was the h orseman Oeneus were the sons of Porthaon,
and they dwelt in Pleuron and steep Calydon. Both of the latter are
Aetolian cities and are listed in the Aetolian Catalogue.3 Since,
Homer (8th c. BCE) according to Homer, the Curetes apparently dwelt in Pleuron,
they would be Aetolians.
463 C, 7-16 Opponents of this view are led astray by his manner of
Strabo discredits the grounds expression when he says, the Curetes and the staunch Aetolians he = Homer
for denying that the Curetes are
Aetolian did battle / around the city of Calydon, their reasoning being
that one could not properly say “the Boeotians and Thebans
fought against each other” nor “the Argives and the Pelo-
ponnesians.” However, it has been shown earlier in this work
that this type of expression is Homeric and also much used by
other poets.4 This, then, is easily explicable. Let them, how- them = those who deny that
Curetes are Aetolian
ever, explain how come he catalogued the Pleuronians among
the Aetolians if they were not of the same nationality and
were not Aetolian! |
463 C, 17-25 Ephorus, although he says that the Aetolians are a nation 10.3.2
Ephorus (4th c. BCE) that has never been subjected to o thers but has, throughout recorded
time, remained unravaged, because of their difficult topography and
Strabo points out that Ephorus their military skill, nevertheless claims that the Curetes originally
contradicts himself
held the whole territory, but when Aetolus (son of Endymion) arrived
from Elis and overcame them in battle, the Curetes withdrew into
what is now called Acarnania, while the Epians, who had accom-
panied Aetolus, laid the foundations of the first Aetolian cities. In
the tenth subsequent generation, Elis was founded by Oxylus (son of
Haemon), who crossed over the water from Aetolia.
538
Fifth Band: Thessaly, Acarnania, Aetolia
463 C, 25–464 C, 2 He cites epigrams as evidence of these events. One epi- He = Ephorus
with each other on the basis of the epigrams, both epigrams being
in agreement, not only concerning their kinship but also in saying that
each founded the other; he thereby quite rightly proves those
people to be liars who claim that the Elians w ere colonizers
of the Aetolians but that the Aetolians were not colonizers
of the Elians.
464 C, 7-14 However, he clearly shows the same self-contradiction in he = Ephorus
aged from the time when, after Aetolus’s arrival, it was thus
Strabo points out that, even named. However, he precludes this interpretation of his
after Aetolia was so named, it
was subjected to an influx of words by g oing on to say that the greatest part of the people who
Aeolians and Boeotians remained among the Aetolians was this one (meaning the Epians)
but that when later the Aeolians (who migrated from Thessaly at
539
3.3. Greece
the same time as the Boeotians) w ere mixed in with them, they held
the territory in common with these people. Is it plausible that these t hese people = Aeolians +
Boeotians
people arrived and, without battle, took a portion of a for-
eign land from those who possessed it and had no wish to
share it? Or is it the case that it is not this that is plausible but
rather that those who were subdued by force of arms came to
terms with them on the basis of equality? What does ravaged
Apollodorus (2nd c. BCE) mean if not “subdued by force of arms”? Also, Apollodorus
says, it is recorded that the Hyantes left Boeotia and settled among
the Aetolians.
464 C, 32-34 He finishes, as if having settled the matter: it is my custom to He = Ephorus
540
Fifth Band: Thessaly, Acarnania, Aetolia
since their enemies used to grab hold of them by their forelocks and pull
them to the ground, allowed their hair to grow long at the back but cut
off their forelocks; they were called “Curetes” (Shorn-ones) because of
their hairstyle; when they migrated into Aetolia and took possession
of the Pleuron region, they called those who lived on the far side of the
Achelous “Acarnanians” (Unshorn-ones) because they did not cut their Achelous, Akheloos r.
hair!
465 C, 26–466 C, 7 Some p eople say that each tribe was named a fter a hero.
Others say that the “Curetes” got their name from mount
“Curium,” which looms over Pleuron, and that they are an
Aetolian tribe, like the Ophians, the Agraeans, Eurytanians,
and several o thers. People say, as noted,1 that when Aetolia
had been split into two parts, Oeneus possessed one part
(the Calydon region), but that the Porthaonids associated
with Agrius2 held a part of Pleuronia, too (since they dwelt
in Pleuron and steep Calydon); Pleuronia was, however, ruled
by Thestius, Oeneus’s father-in-law (Althaea’s father), who
was the Curetes’ leader; since war was declared by the Thes- Thestiads = descendants of
Thestius
tiads against Oeneus and Meleager (over the head and skin of a
pig, says the poet in accordance with the myth About the Wild
Boar—but probably over a portion of territory), this is the
meaning of the Curetes and the staunch Aetolians did battle.
466 C, 8 The foregoing is the “more relevant” material.3 |
466 C, 9-18 There is also material “less relevant” to this discussion, 10.3.7
Strabo disambiguates the but which historians have treated equally b ecause of the
nation of “Curetes” from the
“curetes” in the sense of mystics shared name. Their treatments are called Curetica 4 and
from Crete and Phrygia About the Curetes—as if they were About the Inhabitants of
Aetolia and Acarnania! The former treatments differ from former treatments = Curetica
and About the Curetes
the latter, and are more like the stories about satyrs, si-
leni, bacchi, and tityri. The curetes are said to be just such
demonic spirits or divine spokesmen by t hose writers who
have transmitted to us Cretica5 and Phrygian Matters, into
which are woven certain sacred rituals (mystic or otherwise)
associated with Zeus’s Cretan upbringing or with the orgi-
astic rites of the Mother of the Gods in Phrygia and in the
region of Trojan Ida.
466 C, 18-27 Such is the variety in their stories. Some declare that the
corybantes, the cabiri, the Idaean dactyli, and the telchinians
are the same as the curetes, others (identifying small differ-
ences between them) that they are related to each other. But
541
3.3. Greece
that those in Aetolia got their name from their wearing of fe-
male dress—that is, as if they were corae (girls)—on the grounds
that there was such a fad among the Greeks, and the Iaones are
described as tunic-trailing.3
467 C, 2-10 It is also said that, when those associated with Leonidas 4
appeared for battle with their hair carefully dressed, the
Persians sneered at them—but were awestruck when battle
was joined! To put it simply, the art of dressing hair involves
tending it and cura (cutting the hair), both of which are a concern
to corae (girls) and cori (boys), so that various etymologies for cu-
retes are easily found. It is reasonable to suppose that the war
dance, being first introduced by t hose who were thus decked
out with regard to their hair and clothing (these p eople being
called curetes), provided a rationale for t hose men who w ere
more warlike than others and who followed a military life to
be called by the same name, “Curetes” (I mean those in Eu-
boea, Aetolia, and Acarnania).
467 C, 10-16 Homer, too, used the name for young soldiers: choosing the
best “curetes” from among all the Achaeans, / bring from the swift
ship all the gifts / which yesterday we promised to Achilles; and again,
the Achaean “curetes” brought the gifts.
467 C, 17-19 The foregoing was my account of the etymology of cu-
retes. That the war dance originated with soldiers is shown
542
Fifth Band: Thessaly, Acarnania, Aetolia
543
3.3. Greece
[ 1 ] 468 C, 10-34.
[ 2 ] Pessinus, Dindymum, Cybela: 567 C, 24–568 C, 7; 470 C, 25-30. Sipylus: 571 C,
26–572 C, 1.
544
Fifth Band: Thessaly, Acarnania, Aetolia
545
3.3. Greece
(the products of the lathe’s hard work), / and fills them with the fin-
gered song / that inspires the onset of frenzy; another plays the brass-
bound “cotylae.” Again: The cithara cries; / bull-like voices bellow / cotylae, cymbals
[ 1 ] I.e., included in the Roman province of Macedonia. Cf. 409 C, 34–410 C, 9n.
546
Fifth Band: Thessaly, Acarnania, Aetolia
monic spirits and the variety of their names, that they w ere
Hesiod (late 8th–7th c. BCE) called not only “celebrants of the gods” but also “gods.” He-
siod says . . . * and . . . * (daughter of Phoroneus) had five
daughters, who gave birth to the divine mountain-dwelling nymphs
/ and the race of the satyrs, worthless ne’er-do-wells, / and the curetes,
gods who like to play and dance.
472 C, 1-6 The author of the Phoronis describes the curetes as “Phry-
gian flute players”; others describe them as “earthborn”
and “of brazen shields.” Some say that it is not the curetes
but rather the corybantes who are Phrygian; that the curetes
are Cretan; that they were the first in Euboea to don bronze
armor,1 on which account they are also called “Chalcidians”
(Of-bronze). Some say that the corybantes came from Bactriana
547
3.3. Greece
both a place in Scepsian territory and a mountain in Crete; “Pytna,” Hierapytna, Ierapetra (Kriti/
Crete)
after which the city of Hierapytna is named, is one of Ida’s peaks;
Cretan Hippocoronium,
there’s a “Hippocorona” in Adramyttene and a “Hippocoronium” in Drapano-Kephala mt.
Crete; “Samonium” is both the eastern promontory of the island and Cretan Samonium, Cape Sideros
Acusilaus (6th–5th c. BCE) Camillus, and the latter begat the three “cabiri” to whom . . . * the
Pherecydes (early 5th c. BCE) “cabirid” nymphs. Pherecydes says that Apollo and Rhetia begat
the nine “cyrbantes” who lived in Samothrace; Cabiro (daughter
of Proteus) and Hephaestus begat the three “cabiri” and the three
“cabirid” nymphs; sacred rites were held for both the former and the
latter. It has come about that the cabiri are revered particularly
on Imbros and Lemnos, but also in several cities in Trojan
Herodotus (5th c. BCE) territory. Their names are mystic secrets. Herodotus says that
there was also a temple to the “cabiri” in Memphis, just as to Hepha-
estus, but the t emples w
ere destroyed by Cambyses.
548
Fifth Band: Thessaly, Acarnania, Aetolia
473 C, 5-9 There are places where these demonic spirits w ere wor-
shipped that are now uninhabited. T here is the “Coryban-
tium” in Hamaxitia (belonging to what is now the territory
of the Alexandrians, near the Sminthium); and “Corybissa”
(in Scepsia, near the Eureeis river and the village of the same
name, and also near the Aethaloeis, a winter stream).
473 C, 9-16 The Scepsian says that it is credible that the “curetes” and
Scepsian = Demetrius (2nd c. BCE) the “corybantes” are the same . . . * who happen to be chosen as the
young men and “cori” (boys) for the war dance in connection with the
holy rituals of the M other of the Gods; and “corybantes” from the
fact that they “coryptontes bainein” (walk butting their heads) in their
poet = Homer (8th c. BCE) dance moves. In just the same way, the poet refers to betarmones
(rhythm-movers): come hither, you who are the best of the Phaeecian
of Ida w ere called Idaean dactyli (toes), because the lower parts
of mountains are called “feet” and the peaks “heads.” At any
rate, each and every one of Ida’s flanks is sacred to the Mother
Sophocles (5th c. BCE) of the Gods. Sophocles supposes that the first settlers con-
sisted of five males—who were the first to discover and work
iron as well as many other t hings that are useful in life—and
their five s isters, and because of this number they w ere called
dactyli (fingers).
473 C, 23-30 Different p eople tell different myths, piling difficulty on
difficulty, using a variety of names and numbers, calling a
certain person “Celmis” or “Damnamenes” or “Heracles” or
“Acmon.” Some say the dactyli are indigenous to Ida, other say
they are settlers. All say that iron was first worked by t hese
men on Ida, and all have assumed that they were wonder-
workers, connected with the Mother of the Gods, who had
lived in Phrygia around Ida. They called the Troad “Phrygia”
because the Phrygians, who lived nearby, conquered it after
the sack of Troy.
473 C, 30-34 People suppose that the curetes and corybantes are the off-
spring of the Idaean dactyli; at any rate, that the first hundred
men born on Crete w ere called “Idaean dactyli.” They say that
nine offspring, curetes, were born to them; each of these sired
ten sons, called . . . * |
549
3.3. Greece
Crete.
474 C, 21-30 Eudoxus says that Crete is situated in the Aegaean. One should
CRETE not make such a statement. One should say, rather, that it
Kriti/Crete (Gk. island)
lies between Cyrenaea and the part of Greece stretching from Cyrenaea, e. present-day Libya
Eudoxus (4th c. BCE) Sunium to Laconia, being parallel lengthwise with t hese Sunium, Kolonnes (Gr.)
[ 1 ] With t hese words, Strabo signs off from his account not only of the Cretan
curetes but also his account of Acarnania and Aetolia (449 C, 31–474 C, 15).
[ 2 ] 452 C, 34–459 C, 16.
[ 3 ] Crete and Greek islands: 474 C, 21–489 C, 27.
550
Crete + Greek Islands
(Ram’s-forehead), and the northern one “Cimarus.” The eastern Cimarus, Cape Vouxa
end is marked by Samonium, marginally farther east than Samonium, Cape Sideros
Sunium.1 |
474 C, 31–475 C, 5 As to its size, Sosicrates (whom Apollodorus says is cor- 10.4.3
Apollodorus (2nd c. BCE) rect in matters concerning the island) makes it more than
approves of Sosicrates (2nd c.
BCE) two thousand three hundred stades in length, and . . . * in
breadth, on which basis its perimeter would be more than five
Artemidorus (late 2nd–early thousand stades [stades]. Artemidorus gives the figure of four
1st c. BCE)
thousand one hundred [stades]. Hieronymus, claiming that
Hieronymus (4th–3rd c. BCE)
it has a length of two thousand [stades] and a varying width,
would imply a greater figure for its perimeter than Artemi-
dorus does.
475 C, 5-12 For a third of its length . . . *; then t here’s an isthmus of
approximately one hundred stades with settlements, Am- Amphimalla, ?Georgoupolis
(Kriti/Crete)
phimalla on the northern coast and Lampian Phoenix on
Lampian Phoenix, ?Sellia:
the southern coast. It is widest at its midpoint. From t here, Phoinikias (Kriti/Crete)
the shorelines converge to form an even narrower isthmus
Lyctian Minoa, Pakheia Ammos
(at around sixty stades) than the aforementioned, stretch- (Kriti/Crete)
ing from Lyctian Minoa to Hierapytna and the Libyan sea, Hierapytna, Ierapetra (Kriti/
with the city being in a bay; then they form a sharp promon- Crete)
tory, Samonium, pointing toward Egypt and the Rhodian Samonium, Cape Sideros
islands. |
475 C, 13-19 The island is mountainous and bushy, but it has some 10.4.4
days and nights. From Cimarus . . . * the number of stades is Criu Metopum, Cape Krios
seven hundred, with Cythera in between. From Samonium Cimarus, Cape Vouxa
to Egypt is a voyage of four days and nights (some say three). Samonium, Cape Sideros
551
3.3. Greece
Some have said that the voyage is five thousand stades; o thers
Eratosthenes (3rd c. BCE) that it is still less. Eratosthenes says that from Cyrenaea to Criu
Metopum is two thousand [stades] and from there to the Peloponnese
less . . . *. |
475 C, 27-35 Different languages exist side by side (says the poet); there are 10.4.6
poet = Homer (8th c. BCE) Achaeans here, / and stouthearted Eteocretans, and Cydonians, /
and threefold Dorians, and noble Pelasgians. Of these, according
Staphylus (?3rd c. BCE) to Staphylus, the Dorians occupy the eastern part, the Cydonians
occupy the western part, the Eteocretans (who have the small town
of Praesus, with the temple to “Dictaean” Zeus) occupy the south-
ern part, and the remaining peoples, being stronger, are settled in the
plains.
475 C, 35–476 C, 5 It is reasonable to assume that the Eteocretans and the Cy-
donians are indigenous and that the o thers are immigrants.
Andron (4th c. BCE) The latter, according to Andron, came from Thessaly, from
what was once called “Doris” and is now called “Hestiaeotis.”
From here, as he says, those “Dorians” set out who settled in the Par-
nassus region and founded there the cities of Erineus, Boium, and Cy- Erineus, Kastellia/Evangelistria
(Gr.)
tinium, which is how they come to be called “trichaean” (threefold) by
Boium, Gravia (Gr.)
poet = Homer (8th c. BCE) the poet. People do not accept Andron’s story at all, given that
Cytinium, Palaiokhori/Ag.
he represents the tetrapolis (four-city state) of Doris as a tripo- Georgios (Gr.)
lis (three-city state), and the Dorian metropolis as a Thessalian
colony! They understand trichaean as derived from trilophia
(three-crested [helmet]) or from the fact that the crests were trichi-
the Libyan sea; Lyttus lies eighty [stades], also from the Libyan
552
Crete + Greek Islands
sea. Cnossus has Heraclium as her seaport. | Minos is said to Heraclium, Irakleion (Kriti/ 10.4.8
Crete)
have used Amnisus as his seaport, where t here’s a t emple to
Eileithyia. Cnossus was once called “Caeratus” after the river Caeratus (river), Sylamianos/
Katsampas r.
running nearby.
476 C, 20-32 History tells us that Minos was a zealous lawmaker and the
Ephorus (4th c. BCE) first person to establish dominion over the sea; that, dividing
the island into three parts, he founded a city in each. Cnos-
sus in the . . . * opposite the Peloponnese (which lies to the
north). According to Ephorus, Minos was a follower of a certain
man from long ago, Rhadamanthys, who was the most just of men
(with the same name as his brother) and who seems to have been the his brother = Minos’s brother,
Rhadamanthys
first to civilize the island, by establishing l egal systems, amalgamating
cities, and setting up governments; he claimed that the promulgations
that he made public were received from Zeus. In emulation of this
man, Minos apparently ascended to the cave of Zeus e very nine years,1
lingered there, and came away with a list of certain commandments,
poet = Homer (8th c. BCE) which he said were the proclamations of Zeus. This is why the poet
says, “here it was that Minos / was king, conversing every nine years
with g reat Zeus.”
476 C, 33–477 C, 2 The foregoing is what he says, but the ancients give dif he = Ephorus
ferent accounts of him, which are contrary to what has been him = Minos
[ 1 ] The Greeks included in the span “every 9 years” both of the years in which
Minos made the ascent. We would say that Minos made the ascent “every
8 years.”
[ 2 ] The “title” Europe refers to a section of Ephorus’s work, just as the section of
Strabo’s work presented as chap. 3 in this translation might be considered
Strabo’s Europe: 639 C, 15-27n.
553
3.3. Greece
477 C, 16-28 The foregoing was my account of Cnossus, a city not alien 10.4.10
554
Crete + Greek Islands
479 C, 2-8 People say that Callimachus is not correct when he states
Callimachus (3rd c. BCE) that Britomartis, in her flight from Minos’s violence, leapt from
Dicta into the fishermen’s “dictya” (nets); this is why she is called “Dic-
tynna” by the Cydoniates and why the mountain is called “Dicta.”
Cydonia is not in the vicinity of these places at all, but lies Cydonia, Khania (Kriti/Crete)
555
3.3. Greece
479 C, 9-16 Cydonia is situated on the sea oriented t oward Laconia. 10.4.13
Gortynians leveled the one that remains1—that is, Phaestus, Phaestus, Phaistos/Ag. Ioannis
(Kriti/Crete)
which is sixty [stades] from Gortyn, twenty from the sea, and
forty from the seaport of Matalum. The territory is held by
those who leveled it. The Gortynians also hold Rhytium to- Rhytium, Rotasi (Kriti/Crete)
Strabo cites Homer (8th c. BCE) gether with Phaestus (Phaestus and Rhytium). People say that
Epimenides, who created the epic poem Catharmi (Purifications),
is from Phaestus. Lissen, too, is part of Phaestia.
479 C, 23-26 What is called “Cherronesus,” with her temple to Brit- Cherronesus, Limin Khersonisos
(Kriti/Crete)
omartis, is a seaport belonging to Lyttus, which I mentioned
Strabo cites Homer (8th c. BCE) earlier.2 The cities catalogued alongside her—Miletus and
Lycastus—no longer exist. The Lyttians occupied the one
territory, the Cnossians the other after they had leveled the
city. |
479 C, 27-31 The poet at one time refers to Crete as of the hundred cit- 10.4.15
poet = Homer (8th c. BCE) ies, at another time as of the ninety cities. Ephorus says that ten
Ephorus (4th c. BCE) cities were founded later, after the Trojan period, by the Dorians Trojan period, late 2nd–early
1st millennium BCE
who were the followers of Althaemenes the Argive, noting that it is
Odysseus who calls it “Crete of the ninety cities.” This explanation
is plausible.
479 C, 31–480 C, 2 Others say that the ten cities w ere leveled by the enemies
poet = Homer (8th c. BCE) of Idomeneus. However, the poet does not describe Crete as
of the hundred cities in Trojan times but rather in his own times:
for he speaks in the first person. If the words w ere spoken
by someone living contemporaneously—as is the case in the
Odyssey, when he says, of the ninety cities—it would be fine to
take it this way.
480 C, 2-14 Furthermore, even w ere we to allow the premise, the rest The speaker of these lines is
Nestor
of the explanation would not stand. Neither during Idome-
neus’s expedition nor after his homecoming is it likely that
556
Crete + Greek Islands
Ephorus (4th c. BCE) should be enough to run through its most salient characteris-
lawgiver = Minos tics. He says2 that the lawgiver3 seems to have assumed that freedom
is the highest good for cities, because freedom alone makes goods the
personal belongings of those who acquire them (whereas what is ac-
quired in slavery belongs to the rulers, not to the ruled), and that t hose
who have freedom need to safeguard it; that this is achieved through
harmony, after the removal of discord, which comes about through
avarice and extravagance—if everyone lives modestly and simply,
there arises neither envy nor pride nor hatred t oward others who are
of a similar kind.
480 C, 23–481 C, 3 For this reason, he gave o rders that young boys should join what he = Minos
are called “agelae” (companies) and adult males should attend com-
munal dining halls called “andria” ([halls] for men), so that the poor
might partake of the same as the rich, being fed at public expense.
So that courage rather than cowardice dominates, their upbringing
should involve weapons and hardship from boyhood, to make them
scornful of heat and cold, of rough and uphill ascents, and of blows
received during athletic contests and pitched battles. They should
practice archery and the war dance, as demonstrated first by the
“curetes” and later by . . . * who arranged the “Pyrrhic” war dance
that was named a fter him, so that not even their boyish games might
be without utility in respect of war. In the same way, they should
make use, in their songs of the extremely intense Cretan rhythms in
vented by Thaletas, to whom they also ascribe their victory chants
and other native songs, as well as many of their customs. They should
557
3.3. Greece
wear military garb and footwear, and the gifts most valued by them
should be weapons. |
481 C, 4-12 It is said by some that much of what is considered “Cretan” should 10.4.17
Strabo continues his citation/ be thought of as “Laconian”; and that, in truth, while these things Laconian = Spartan
paraphrase of Ephorus (4th c.
BCE) were invented by them, the details w ere worked out by the Spar- them = Cretans
tiates. The Cretans paid little heed to military matters, and their
cities were devastated, especially that of the Cnossians. Some of their
laws persisted among the Lyttians, Gortynians, and other small cities
for longer than they did among themselves. Indeed, Lyttian laws are
used as evidence by t hose who claim that Laconian laws are older, on
the grounds that colonists preserve the customs of the metropolis (since
it would, in general, be facile to claim that the better o rganized and
constituted were emulating the worse).
481 C, 12-20 This argument is not valid. The situation in antiquity should
not be assessed on the basis of things as they stand now: both parties
Strabo continues his citation/ have undergone reversals. For example, the Cretans once ruled the
paraphrase of Ephorus (4th c.
BCE) sea—giving rise to the proverbial saying in respect of those who affect
not to know what they know, “the Cretan does not know the sea”—
but now their fleet is n onexistent. Although some of the cities in Crete
are colonies of Spartiates, they have not been forced to stick with the
customs of the latter: many colonies do not preserve the customs of
their fatherland, and many cities in Crete that are not colonies have
the same customs as the colonies. |
481 C, 20-24 The lawgiver of the Spartiates, Lycurgus, came five generations 10.4.18
Strabo continues his citation/ later than Althaemenes, who established the colony in Crete. History
paraphrase of Ephorus (4th c.
BCE) tells us that the latter was the son of Cissus, who founded Argos at
around the same time as Procles established Sparta. Sources agree
that Lycurgus came six generations after Procles.
481 C, 24–482 C, 3 Replicas cannot precede their originals, nor can what is more
Strabo continues his citation/ recently established precede what is longer established. The dance
paraphrase of Ephorus (4th c.
BCE) popular among Lacedaemonians, the rhythms, the victory songs
chanted to a melody, as well as many other customs—all are called
“Cretan” by them, as if derived from that place. As far as public
offices are concerned, some have the same responsibilities and the
same names, for example, the offices of the “gerontes” (elders) and the
“hippeis” (horsemen), except that the “hippeis” in Crete actually have
horses, which is used as evidence that the office of the “hippeis” in Crete
is the longer-established one, since they preserve the meaning of the
word, while the former do not keep h orses. former = Spartans
558
Crete + Greek Islands
482 C, 3-10 As for the ephors, although they have undergone a name change,
Strabo continues his citation/ they have the same responsibilities as the “cosmi” (regulators) in Crete.
paraphrase of Ephorus (4th c.
BCE)
The communal dining halls are even now called “andria” ([halls] for men)
by the Cretans but are no longer given that name by the Spartans, even
Alcman (7th c. BCE) though they once w ere (as in the passage from Alcman: at feasts and
festivals, / t hose who dine in the “andria” / should lead the victory
chants). |
482 C, 11-19 It is said by the Cretans that Lycurgus visited them, too, and for 10.4.19
Strabo continues his citation/ the following reason. Polydectes was Lycurgus’s older b rother. He
paraphrase of Ephorus (4th c.
BCE) died, leaving his wife pregnant. For a while, Lycurgus ruled in his
brother’s place but, a fter the birth of the child, became the child’s
guardian, since power passed to the child. Someone slandered
him, claiming certain knowledge that he would become king. He him/he = Lycurgus
559
3.3. Greece
bare cloaks (dressed in the same way in both winter and summer);
and they act as servers, both to themselves and the men. Fights are
held, either between those belonging to the same hall or against other those = younger boys
560
Crete + Greek Islands
custom, so that if any force was used against him during the abduc-
tion, he can avenge himself and distance himself from the relationship.
484 C, 2-9 It is considered shameful in the extreme for good-looking boys from
Strabo continues his citation/ illustrious families to have no admirers, as if this outcome w ere a re-
paraphrase of Ephorus (4th c.
BCE) sult of their character. The “parastathentes” (surrenderers)—for this is
what the abducted are called—receive honors: in dance performances
and at the races, they get the best places; they are allowed to wear
better clothes—as given to them by their admirers—than the o thers
are, and it is not only at that time but even when grown men that they
wear splendid clothing, as a result of which, each is recognized as being
“famous” (for the one who is loved is called “famous,” while the one
who does the loving is called “dear heart”).
484 C, 9-10 The foregoing concerns their customs regarding sexual
desire.1 |
484 C, 11-14 Ten “archontes” (rulers) are chosen . . . * On important matters, 10.4.22
Strabo ends his citation/ they use as advisers those men called the “gerontes” (elders). Appointed
paraphrase of Ephorus (4th c.
BCE) to this body are those who are deemed worthy of the office of “cosmos”
(regulator) and who are judged worthy in other respects, too.
484 C, 15-18 I thought that the Cretan constitution was worth record-
ing on account of its peculiarity and its repute. Not many of
these customs persist. Most t hings are arranged according to
Roman dictate, as is the case in other provinces. |
484 C, 19-28 Associated with Crete are the islands of Thera—the Cyre- Thera, Santorini (Gk. island) 10.5.1
ISLANDS IN AEGEAN SEA naeans’ mother city and a Lacedaemonian colony—and the
Callimachus (3rd c. BCE) nearby Anaphe, with its temple to “Aegletan” Apollo. Cal- Anaphe, Anaphe (Gk. island)
which is near Cnossian Heraclium, but it is seven hundred Cnossian Heraclium, Irakleion
(Kriti/Crete)
this island = Thera stades distant from Crete. (Near this island are Anaphe, Th-
Therasia, Therasia (Gk. island)
erasia, and a small island that was thrust upward by an erup-
tion and is held sacred, as I said.)3
484 C, 29-32 At a distance of one hundred stades from this is the l ittle this = Thera
ISLANDS IN CRETAN SEA island of Ios, where some say the poet Homer is buried. If Ios, Ios (Gk. island)
Sicinos, Sikinos (Gk. island)
you go west from Ios, you come to Sicinos, Lagussa, and
Lagussa, Kardiotissa
Aratus (3rd c. BCE) Pholegandros, called iron-hard by Aratus b ecause of its
Pholegandros, Pholegandros
rockiness. (Gk. island)
484 C, 32-37 Near these is Cimolos, the source of “Cimolian earth.” Cimolos, Kimolos (Gk. island)
From t here, it is possible to see Siphnos, which has given rise Siphnos, Siphnos (Gk. island)
[ 1 ] 483 C, 14–484 C, 9.
[ 2 ] The sense is that Thera is on the same meridian as Dia: 496 C, 26–497 C, 4n.
[ 3 ] 57 C, 30-36. The words “and a small island . . . as I said” are missing from the
medieval manuscripts of Strabo’s work. Scholars learned of them only in the
19th century, when a dismantled pre-medieval (5th c. CE) codex was discovered
in which the words are present. One wonders how many other clauses are miss-
ing from our version of Strabo’s narrative.
561
3.3. Greece
the Hermionic promontory of Scyllaeum, and somewhat the Scyllaeum, Cape Spathi
(Peloponnese)
same distance from the Dictynnaeum).1 The Athenians once
Dictynnaeum, in Menies bay
sent an army there and killed the majority of its men, adoles- (Kriti/Crete)
cents and older.
485 C, 1-3 These islands 2 are in the Cretan sea. Delos itself, the Cy-
clades around it, and the nearby Sporades (including those is-
lands already mentioned in association with Crete)3 lie rather
more in the Aegaean. |
485 C, 3-20 Delos has a city lying in a plain and a temple to Apollo and Delos, Delos (Gk. island) 10.5.2
ISLANDS IN AEGEAN SEA the Letoium (temple to Leto). Looming over the city is a moun-
tain, Cynthus, which is treeless and rocky. Running across the
island is the Inopus river, not very large—for the island itself
is small. It has been revered since ancient times, starting with
the heroic period, because of its gods. This is the mythical
setting for Leto’s birthing of Apollo and Artemis. The island
Pindar (5th c. BCE) was in former times carried along, says Pindar, on the waves, and
buffeted by winds from all directions. / But when Coeus’s d aughter, /
racked with the pains of labor, landed / there, four pillars rose straight
up / from their subterranean bases / and held as if on their capitals /
the rock, with adamantine footings; / and there she gave birth and /
gazed at her blessed offspring.
485 C, 21-23 The surrounding islands, called the “Cyclades” (Encircling is-
CYCLADES lands), made this island famous, sending in her honor, at public this island = Delos
562
Crete + Greek Islands
in at Gyaros, I saw a small village populated by fishermen.1 Oliaros, Antiparos (Gk. island)
When we set sail, we took on board one of the fishermen, Gyaros, Gyaros/Yiura (Gk.
island)
who had been chosen as an ambassador to Caesar. Caesar was
at Corinth, en route to the celebration of his Actian triumph. Caesar (= Augustus), having
My fellow voyager told questioners that his mission con- defeated Marc Antony at
Actium in Greece in 31 BCE,
cerned a reduction in tax. They paid one hundred and fifty headed via Corinth to Rome,
where he celebrated his
drachmas in tax, whereas they could scarcely afford to pay one triumph, 29 BCE
Aratus (3rd c. BCE) hundred drachmas. Aratus demonstrates their poverty in his
Catalepton (Trifles): O Leto, since I am like iron-hard Phologendros /
or wretched Gyaros, will you soon pass me by? |
486 C, 4-14 Delos, already so famous,2 flourished even more a fter 10.5.4
(Iulis and Carthaea) are left. The other two were amalgam- Iulis, Khora (Ceos)
ated with these, Poiëessa with Carthaea, and Coresia with Carthaea, Poles (Ceos)
Simonides, Bacchylides, Iulis. Simonides (the lyricist), his nephew Bacchylides, and Poiëessa, Poiesses/Pisses (Ceos)
6th–5th c. BCE
later Erasistratus (the physician) and Ariston (of the Peri- Coresia, Livadi (Ceos)
Erasistratus, Ariston, Bion,
3rd c. BCE patetic school of philosophy, a follower of Bion the Borys-
thenite) all came from Iulis.
486 C, 24-31 It seems that t here was once a law among t hese p eople,
Menander (late 4th–early 3rd c. mentioned by Menander: O Phanias, admirable is the Ceian cus-
BCE)
563
3.3. Greece
tom: / may he who is unable to live well not live badly. Apparently,
the law enjoined that those over sixty years of age should dose
themselves with hemlock, so as to make sure that t here was
enough food for everyone e lse.1 It is said that once, when the
place was u nder siege by the Athenians, it was voted that an
age limit be set and that the oldest of them should die—but
then the Athenians ceased the siege.
486 C, 31–487 C, 4 The city is situated on a mountain, some twenty-five stades city = Iulis, Khora (Ceos)
back from the sea. Her seaport is the place where Coresia was Coresia, Livadi (Ceos)
founded by the Parians, as also the city of Parium in the Pro- Paros, Paros (Gk. island)
pontis. In this city, it is said, the altar with its stade-long sides
is worth seeing, and in Paros what is called “Parian stone,”
excellent for making marble sculptures. |
487 C, 10-14 Then Syros—the first syllable is long—whence came Syros, Syros (Gk. island) 10.5.8
caught in his dictya (fishing nets) the chest holding Perseus and
his m other, Danaë, which had been cast into the sea by Acri-
sius, the father of Danaë. It is said that Perseus grew up h ere
and, when he got the Gorgon’s head and showed it to the
Seriphians, turned them all to stone; that he did so to avenge
his m other, b ecause king Polydectes intended to make her
marry him against her wishes with the help of the Seriphians.
[ 1 ] Strabo’s advanced age at the time of writing—he was probably turning 80 years
old—gives this statement extra resonance.
564
Crete + Greek Islands
of Simonides, the composer of iambic verse), Lebinthos, and Simonides, 7th c. BCE
Probably the verse is by Leros . . . * this, too, Phocylides said: “the Lerians are evil, not just Lebinthos, Lebintha (Gk. island)
Demodocus (?6th c. BCE) rather
than Phocylides (?6th c. BCE) one but not one who is not, / all of them, except Procles—Procles, Leros, Leros (Gk. island)
too, is a Lerian.” Men from here are denigrated as having an
evil disposition. |
488 C, 2-8 Nearby are Patmos and the Corassian islands, lying west Patmos, Patmos (Gk. island) 10.5.13
ISLANDS IN ICARIAN SEA of Icaria, which is itself west of Samos. Icaria is deserted but Corassians, Phournoi (Gk.
islands)
has pastures that are utilized by the Samians. Despite its
Icaria, Ikaria (Gk. island)
condition, it is famous, and the sea lying off it is called “Icar-
ian” after the island. In this sea lie the island itself, Samos,
Cos, and the islands just mentioned—the Corassians, Pat-
mos, and Leros. The mountain on the island, Cerceteus, is
also famous, more famous than Ampelus, which rises over
the Samian city.
488 C, 8-10 Merging with the Icarian sea to the south is the Carpathian
sea (with which the Egyptian sea merges), and to the west, the
Cretan and Libyan seas. |
488 C, 11-15 Many of the Sporades lie in the Carpathian sea—those in 10.5.14
ISLANDS IN CARPATHIAN SEA particular between Cos, Rhodes, and Crete, which include
Astypalaea, Astypalaia (Gk.
Astypalaea, Telos, Chalcia, and those named in the Cata island)
logue 2 by Homer—those who held Nisyros, Crapathos, Casos, / Telos, Telos (Gk. island)
Cos (Eurypylus’s city), and the Calydnae islands.3 Chalcia, Khalki (Gk. island)
488 C, 16-23 Except for Cos and Rhodes, which I shall describe later,4
I categorize the rest of the islands as belonging to the Spo-
rades. I mention them h ere (although they are next to Asia
rather than Europe) b ecause the order of my narrative some-
how persuades me to include the Sporades with Crete and
the Cyclades. In my geographical description of Asia, I will
additionally cover the most significant islands right next to
Asia: Cyprus, Rhodes, Cos, and those lying off the succeed-
ing coastline (Samos, Chios, Lesbos, Tenedos).5 For now,
[ 1 ] I.e., the islands categorized as among the Sporades but considered by Strabo
to lie in the Cretan sea: 484 C, 19-28; 485 C, 1-3n.
[ 2 ] The “title” Catalogue refers to a part of Homer’s Iliad: 4 C, 14-20n; cf. 639 C, 15-27n.
[ 3 ] This citation of Homer acts as a partial index for Strabo’s ensuing description of
the Sporades, which in turn doubles as a commentary on Homer’s lines: Nisyros,
Crapathos (as “Carpathos”), Casos, Calydnae: 488 C, 30–489 C, 27.
[ 4 ] As part of the 4th section of n. Asia: Cos (657 C, 15–658 C, 4); Rhodes (652 C,
10–655 C, 28).
[ 5 ] Strabo looks ahead to his description of the Aegean and Med. coast of the
4th section of n. Asia (592 C, 1–685 C, 5), which includes Cyprus (681 C, 25–685 C,
5), Samos (636 C, 33–639 C, 2), Chios (645 C, 10-31), Lesbos (616 C, 23–618 C, 27),
and Tenedos (603 C, 30–604 C, 12). Rhodes and Cos: see previous note.
565
3.3. Greece
Telos, four hundred from Carpathos, around twice that from Carpathos, Karpathos
(Gk. island)
Astypalaea. It has a settlement of the same name, a temple to
Apollo, and a harbor. |
488 C, 30–489 C, 5 Nisyros1 is north of Telos and some sixty stades distant Nisyros, Nisyros (Gk. island) 10.5.16
and fifty from Samonium, the end point of Crete. It has a cir- Samonium, Cape Sideros
489 C, 16-20 People say that the poet, by the Calydnae, means the Spo- 10.5.19
rades, one of which is Calymna.6 It is reasonable to suppose Calymna, Kalymna (Gk. island)
that, just as the islands that are nearby and subject to the Ni-
syrians and Casians are called after them, such was the case,
too, with the islands around Calymna (perhaps at that time
[ 1 ] The name Nisyros is used by Homer in the lines cited by Strabo at 488 C, 11-15.
[ 2 ] The name Crapathos is used by Homer in the lines cited by Strabo at 488 C,
11-15.
[ 3 ] The sense is that Carpathos lies due north of Leuca Acta: 496 C, 26–497 C, 4n.
[ 4 ] Strabo generally uses the name “Libya” to refer to the part of the African con-
tinent east of Egypt; sometimes, as h ere, he uses it to mean the part east of
the Nile. Leuca Acta (Ras el-Abiad, Egy.): 799 C, 6-12.
[ 5 ] The name Casos is used by Homer in the lines cited by Strabo at 488 C, 11-15.
[ 6 ] Strabo explains the ambiguity of the name Calydnae in the lines of Homer cited
at 488 C, 11-15.
566
Crete + Greek Islands
489 C, 20-24 The Scepsian says that the island’s name, “Calymnae,” is
Scepsian = Demetrius (2nd c. pluralized like “Athenae” (Athens) and “Thebae” (Thebes); and that
BCE)
we should understand the poet as using hyperbaton, meaning not
the “Calydnae islands” but, rather, referring to those who held “the
islands—Nisyros, Crapathos, Casos, Cos (Eurypylus’s city), and
Calydnae.”
489 C, 25-27 All honey from the islands is very good, equal in quality
to Attic honey, but the honey in t hese islands—particularly
Calymnian honey—is exceptionally delicious. |
567
Kazakhstan
Russia
Ca
1st Section
sp
Black Sea
ian
Bulgaria
Uzb Kyrgyzstan
S
Georgia eki
sta
n
ea
Armenia Azerbaijan
Turkmenistan China
Greece 4th Turkey 3rd Section Tajikistan
Section
Cyprus
2nd Section
Syria
Crete Afghanistan
Lebanon Iraq
Mediterranean Sea Iran
Israel
Jordan
Pakistan
Nepal
Bhutan
Egypt Persian Gulf
India Bangladesh
Saudi Arabia Arabian
Sea
Translator’s Introduction
Strabo imagines the continent of Asia as being divided into two parts by a chain of moun-
tains running from west to east, from what we now call southern Turkey to Bangladesh.
In reality, although the relevant area is indeed mountainous, the mountains do not form
a line as straight nor as uniform as Strabo believes; nor is the mountain system oriented
due east. Nonetheless, it is a cardinal part of Strabo’s belief system that t hese mountains,
which he knows as the “Taurus mountain range,” form a band that cuts latitudinally
across Asia. This band is i magined to be a continuation of the line drawn from the strait
of Gibraltar through the Mediterranean sea and along the southern coastline of Turkey.
Just as the line through the Mediterranean is considered to separate the continent of
Europe from Libya (= Africa), so the Taurus mountain range separates northern Asia
from southern Asia.
Strabo has no knowledge of the true eastern extent of Asia. Much of what we now
know as Russia is beyond his ken, as are Mongolia, most of China, the Korean peninsula,
Japan, and all parts east of India. In the absence of certain knowledge about these areas,
Strabo’s supposition is that India lies at the eastern edge of the lived-in world, and that
the eastern coastline of the lived-in world roughly mirrors the Atlantic coast in the west.
The eastern end of the Taurus mountains is considered to be the easternmost point of
the lived-in world and is supposed coincidentally to lie on the same parallel as the Sacred
Promontory in Iberia, as noted in the introduction to chapter 3.1. This coincidence makes
the lived-in world a neatly symmetrical figure.
Having established to his own satisfaction that the Taurus mountain range cuts lati-
tudinally across Asia, creating a northern part and a southern part, Strabo begins his
account of Asia with the northern part. He justifies his decision by pointing out that the
northern part of Asia borders on Europe; and since he has already described Europe,
northern Asia is the logical next step. Just as we have seen Strabo do in the case of Europe,
he divides northern Asia into sections, which he then proceeds to work through in se-
quence, as shown on the accompanying map.
The first section of northern Asia (southern Russia, Georgia, northern Azerbaijan) lies
between the Pontus (Black Sea) and the Caspian sea. It is envisaged as projecting t oward
the northern sea, which is in turn envisaged as part of the sea encircling the lived-in world
as a whole. This cannot be accurately replicated on the accompanying map, as the sea
569
4.1. Northern Asia
surrounding the Eurasian landmass lies much farther north than Strabo realizes. The
second section (southwestern and southern Kazakhstan, Turkmenistan, northern Iran, Uzbeki-
stan, Kyrgyzstan, Tajikistan, northern Afghanistan, northern India) lies east of the Caspian sea
and extends to what Strabo considers to be the easternmost point of the lived-in world.
Strabo famously says that this section looks like a “cook’s knife.” The sort of shape that
Strabo may have had in mind is shown on the map. However, this representation is mis-
leading. Strabo considers that the southern edge of the “knife” runs due east–west; and
several areas included within the “blade” as depicted on the map—such as Pakistan—are
actually described later by Strabo as part of southern Asia. The third section (northern
Iraq, northern Iran, southern Azerbaijan, southern Georgia, Armenia, eastern and central Tur-
key) is more or less south of the first section. The fourth section is the Asian peninsula
(Turkey and associated islands).
Scale
The question of scale, which we have seen in relation to Strabo’s description of Italy and
Greece, also arises in connection with the fourth section of northern Asia. Strabo devotes
nearly three times as many words to the fourth section as he does to the other sections
of northern Asia combined. His description of it occupies far more narrative space than
Italy does and almost as much as Greece. This is not coincidental. By treating the fourth
section at such length, Strabo emphasizes the cultural heft of Asia Minor. He may also
be influenced by his own f amily ties, since Asia Minor is where his relatives had lived
570
Translator’s Introduction
for generations. Despite the fact that Strabo had traveled quite extensively within the
fourth section of Asia, his personal journeys do not shape his narrative. As we have seen
in previous chapters, Strabo’s journey is an intellectual one, through the literature of the
past. This approach f rees him to go beyond his own experience. The result is a curious
but compelling blend of the observed and the learned, the real and the imagined, the past
and the present, which makes Strabo’s description of this part of the world at once both
deeply challenging and deeply rewarding.
Remember
571
CH APT E R FOU R Northern Asia
PART 1
490 C, 1-3 Asia comes next a fter E urope and is contiguous with it at 11.1.1
Strabo segues from Europe to the Tanaïs, so it is Asia that I must describe next, dividing it Tanaïs, Don r.
his description of Asia
into parts by means of certain natural boundaries, in order to
make t hings clearer.
490 C, 3-9 What Eratosthenes did for the lived-in world as a w hole, Eratosthenes (3rd c. BCE)
TAURUS then, I must do for Asia. | The Taurus as it stretches from 11.1.2
mt. system from sw. Turkey to
ne. India west to east forms a sort of belt across the m
iddle of the con-
tinent, leaving one part to the north and one part to the south.
The Greeks call the first part “inside the Taurus,” the second inside Taurus = northern Asia
“outside the Taurus.” I mentioned t hese things earlier,1 but I outside Taurus = southern Asia
aea to the extreme end of India and Scythia in the east. | It has extreme end . . . Scythia, ne. 11.1.4
India
been divided into many parts and into many names, assigned
to areas that are both large and small.
490 C, 13–491 C, 5 Since the mountain range, with so great a width, cuts
off certain nations within it (some insignificant, others ex-
tremely well known, e.g., Parthia, Media, Armenia, some
Cappadocians, and Cilicians and Pisidians), nations spilling
over into the northern part must be classified as “northern,”
and nations spilling over into the southern part must be clas-
sified as “southern”; nations contained within the mountain
range should really be treated as “northern” on the basis that
they have similar climatic conditions (the conditions are cold,
while conditions in the south are warm).
491 C, 5-12 Nearly all the rivers running from the Taurus flow in one
of two directions, toward either the north or the south (at
least initially, even if some subsequently curve to east or
west), making it c onvenient to use the mountain range as the
573
4.1. Northern Asia
ividing line that splits Asia into two parts—in just the same
d
way as the sea inside the Pillars (which largely lies in more or sea inside the Pillars = Med. Sea
less a straight line with the mountain range) has been utilized
to make two continents out of E urope and Libya, being a sig- Libya = Africa (chap. 5)
Euxine coastline as far as Colchis; to the north, by the ocean as Bosporus = Straits of Kerch'
latter sea = Caspian far as the inlet to the Caspian sea; 3 to the east, by this latter sea Euxine, Black Sea
up to the borderlands of Albania and Armenia, where the
latter = Araxes river Cyrus and the river Araxes join the sea (the latter after Araxes, Aras r.
Cyrus as far as Colchis, which m easures some three thousand Colchis, w. Georgia
stades from sea to sea (via the Albanian and Iberian p eoples) sea to sea, Caspian to Black Sea
Strabo dismisses and thus acts as the isthmus. Those who minimize this
underestimates by earlier
writers of distance between isthmus—like Clitarchus, describing it as flooded on both sides
Caspian and Black Sea, citing by the sea—should not be treated seriously. Posidonius says the
in particular Clitarchus (late
4th–3rd c. BCE) and Posidonius isthmus is one thousand five hundred [stades], the same as the isthmus
(late 2nd–1st c. BCE)
from Pelusium to the Erythra. Nor do I think, says Posidonius, that Pelusium, on Med. coast of
Egypt
the distance from the Maeotis to the ocean is very diff erent.4 | I really 11.1.6
Erythra, Red Sea
do not know how anyone can trust Posidonius’s description
of the unexplored when he has nothing plausible to say about
it and tells such fibs concerning the well known!
491 C, 32–492 C, 9 He furthermore made these claims despite being a friend He = Posidonius
Rhodes, in the process of prosecuting his war on piracy, when Rhodes = Posidonius’s place of
residence
he was about to launch his attack against Mithridates and the
Pompey campaigned against
nations extending to the Caspian, he attended a lecture by piracy, 67 BCE; defeated
Posidonius and, as he took his leave, asked Posidonius if he Mithridates of Pontus (n. Tky.),
66 BCE; campaigned against
Posidonius (late 2nd–1st c. BCE) had any words of advice; and Posidonius said, always be the Iberians and Albanians (Geo.,
quotes Homer’s Iliad (8th c. BCE) Aze.), 66–64 BCE
best you can, be better than all o thers. Add to these points that
[ 1 ] 1st section: 492 C, 20–506 C, 32. [ 4 ] Posidonius’s work has not survived to the present day. From what Strabo says,
[ 2 ] Strabo is vague because he does not believe that the Tanaïs (Don r.) flows Posidonius calculates the distance between the Caspian Sea and Black Sea to be
from the supposed outer ocean—as would be required for the section to be the same as the distance between the Med. Sea and the Red Sea, and supposes
a true peninsula—but rather that the river has its source in the interior: 492 C, that each of these is the same as the distance from the Sea of Azov northward
29–493 C, 16; cf. 65 C, 13–66 C, 22. to the supposed outer ocean. For the width of the isthmus between the Med.
[ 3 ] Strabo imagines an outer ocean lying not far north of the Black Sea and the and Red Seas (Isthmus of Suez, Egy.): 803 C, 3-12. Cf. Posidonius’s interest in the
Caspian sea as an inlet from it. Celtic isthmus from the Med. Sea to the Atlantic: 188 C, 22-27.
574
First Section
he wrote up his research on it,1 and as a result one might have it = isthmus between Caspian
and Black Seas
expected greater adherence to the truth. |
492 C, 10-16 The second section would be the one beyond the Hyr- beyond Hyrcanian sea = east of 11.1.7
Caspian Sea
Preview of 2nd, 3rd, 4th sections canian (we say “Caspian”) sea, as far as the Scythians near
of northern Asia
India.2 The third section comprises the part next to the
isthmus just described, as well as the areas, successively con-
tiguous with this part and with the Caspian Gates, belong- Caspian Gates, ?Sar Darreh
pass (Iran)
ing to what is inside the Taurus and nearest to Europe—that
inside Taurus = in n. Asia
is, Media, A rmenia, Cappadocia, and what lies between.3
The fourth section consists of the country inside the Halys, inside Halys = west of Kızıl Irmak
plus areas within the Taurus itself, plus areas that are out-
side the Taurus but nevertheless fall within the penin- Pontic sea, Black Sea
sula formed by the isthmus that separates the Pontic and
Cilician seas.4 Cilician sea, Med. Sea
492 C, 16-19 I include within the other part, the part outside the outside Taurus = in southern
Asia (chap. 4.2)
Preview of southern Asia Taurus: India and Ariana, as far as the nations that reach to
(chap. 4.2)
the Persian sea, to the Arabian gulf, to the Nile, and to the
Egyptian sea and the Issian sea.5 |
492 C, 20-28 Of the sections thus defined, the first section is inhabited 11.2.1
1st section of northern Asia in its northern and oceanic regions by some of the Scyth-
ians, who are nomadic and wagon dwelling; farther inland farther inland = from supposed
location of northern ocean
than these, by Sarmatians (who are Scythian), Aorsians, and
Siracians, stretching as far south as the Caucasian moun-
tains, some of them nomadic, others tent-dwelling farmers; lake = Maeotis, Sea of Azov
around the lake, by Maeotians. As for the parts on the sea, sea, Black Sea
there’s the Asian side of the Bosporus, and Sindica; after Sin- Bosporus = Straits of Kerch'
dica, there are Achaeans, Zygans, and Heniochans, as well
as Cercetians and Macropogones; inland from these are the
passes of the Phthirophagi (Lice-eaters); after the Heniochans,
Moschian mountains, ne.
lying at the foot of the Caucasian and Moschian mountains, Turkey, s. Georgia
is Colchis.6
492 C, 29–493 C, 8 Since the Tanaïs river is used as the boundary between Tanaïs, Don r.
[ 1 ] Some scholars translate as “him” rather than “it,” and assume that the person [3] 3rd section: 520 C, 22–540 C, 29.
in question is Pompey. It is more likely that Strabo refers h
ere to the isthmus [4] 4th section: 540 C, 30–685 C, 5
between the Caspian and the Black Sea, which has been the focus of discussion [5] . Southern Asia: 685 C, 6–824 C, 21.
(491 C, 23-32). In the following paragraph (492 C, 10-16), Strabo refers to “the [6] Scythians, Sarmatians (Russia): 507 C, 13-17. Aorsians, Siracians (Russia): 506 C,
isthmus just described.” Cf. 497 C, 11-18; 497 C, 34–498 C, 6; 499 C, 28-34. The 16-32; Maeotians, Asian Bosporus, Sindica (Russia): 493 C, 28–495 C, 27. Achae-
importance of this isthmus as a possible demarcation between E urope and Asia: ans, Zygans, Heniochans, Cercetians, Phthirophagi (Russia): 495 C, 28–497 C, 18.
65 C, 13-17. Colchis (w. Georgia): 497 C, 27–499 C, 13.
[ 2 ] 2nd section: 506 C, 33–520 C, 21.
575
4.1. Northern Asia
than the Nile,1 although similar to the Nile in that its sources
are unknown. However, the explored portion of the Nile is
sizable, as it passes through territory that is wholly accessible
and offers long upriver passages. As for the Tanaïs, we know
of its outlets (there are two, flowing into the extreme north
of the Maeotis, sixty stades apart), but the known part of it Maeotis, Sea of Azov
those from Bosporus who plied the lake. The former supplied former = nomads
slaves, animal skins, and assorted nomadic wares; the latter ex- latter = traders from Bosporus
changed them for clothing, wine, and whatever other accoutre-
ments there are of civilized life. Lying offshore, one hundred
stades from the entrepôt, is the island of Alopecia (a multiracial Alopecia, ?Yelizavetovskoye
Gorodische (Russ.)
settlement); and t here are other small islands nearby in the lake.
493 C, 25-27 Tanaïs is two thousand two hundred stades from the Tanaïs (city), Nedvigovka (Russ.)
mouth of the Maeotis if you sail directly northward; if you mouth of Maeotis, Straits of
Kerch'
hug the coast, the distance is not much greater. |
493 C, 28–494 C, 4 As you follow the shore,2 first of all (if you start from Tanaïs), 11.2.4
576
Maeotic Coast of First Section
494 C, 15-18 Then it is twenty [stades] to the village of Achillium, with its 11.2.6
temple to Achilles. H ere, the strait at the mouth of the Maeo- strait, Straits of Kerch'
494 C, 18-28 From there, it is ninety stades to the Satyrus memorial: there = Achillium 11.2.7
situated on a headland, this is the burial mound of one of the Satyrus, 5th–4th c. BCE
Bosporus = kingdom on either most famous dynasts of Bosporus. | Nearby is the village of 11.2.8
side of Straits of Kerch'
Patrasys, and from t here it is one hundred and thirty [stades] Patrasys, Garkushi (Russ.)
to the village of Corocondama, which marks the end of what Corocondama, Tuzla (Russ.)
[ 1 ] The site of the village of Cimmerica (as opposed to the city of Cimmericum; see sailing into the Black Sea from the Med. Sea; it is used h ere even though “as far
next note) is not certain, but it is presumably in the nw. of the Taman’ peninsula as Ionia” implies the reverse viewpoint, of a navigator sailing from the Black Sea.
(Russia). [ 4 ] Strabo mirrors comments made e arlier (310 C, 20-24, describing the “European”
[ 2 ] Strabo rectifies the omission of the city of Cimmericum (Opuk, Crim.) from his side of the strait).
description of the Cherronesus (Crimea) at 309 C, 21-26. Strabo distinguishes [ 5 ] The “Cimmerian” Bosporus (Straits of Kerch’, between Black Sea and Sea of
this city of Cimmericum on the Cherronesus from the village of Cimmerica on Azov) is to be distinguished from the “Thracian” Bosporus (Bogaziçi, between
the Asian side of the Cimmerian Bosporus: see previous note. Marmara Denizi and Black Sea): 125 C, 16-20; 566 C, 6-18.
[ 3 ] For the term “Right-Hand Side of the Pontus” (Black Sea coast of Tky., Geo., [ 6 ] Strabo rectifies the omission of Acra (Zavetnoya, Crim.) from his description of
Russ.): 126 C, 3-11n. The term is coined from the point of view of a navigator the European side of the strait (310 C, 11-24).
577
4.1. Northern Asia
494 C, 29–495 C, 5 Inland from Corocondama is a sizable lake, which is called 11.2.9
“Corocondamitis” a fter it, and which flows into the sea at Corocondamitis, Gulf of Taman'
(Russ.)
a distance of ten stades from the village. A branch of the
Anticites river flows into the lake and creates something of an Anticites/Hypanis, Kuban r.
495 C, 6-15 All the people subject to the dynasts of Bosporus are called Bosporus = kingdom on e ither
side of Straits of Kerch'
“Bosporans.” The metropolis of the European Bosporans is Panticapaeum, Kerch' (Crim.)
Panticapaeum; the metropolis of the Asian Bosporans is Phanagoras [City]/Phanagoria,
“Phanagoras [City],” as the city is also called. The entrepôt for Sennaya (Russ.)
goods transported down from the Maeotis and from the bar- the city = Phanagoria
barian interior is apparently Phanagoria; for goods brought Maeotis, Sea of Azov
up from the sea, it is Panticapaeum. In Phanagoria is the fa- sea, Black Sea
stades), whom king Polemo attacked under cover of a sham Gorgippia, Anapa (Russ.)
alliance. His tactics were used against him, and he was taken
alive and killed. In regard to all the Asian Maeotians, some
were subject to those in control of the entrepôt in Tanaïs, Tanaïs, Nedvigovka (Russ.)
[ 1 ] The terms “Left-Hand Side” and “Right-Hand Side” reflect the viewpoint of a
navigator sailing into lake Corocondamitis (Gulf of Taman’) from the Bosporus
(Straits of Kerch’): 126 C, 3-11n.
[ 2 ] “Past” is used from the viewpoint of a navigator sailing clockwise around lake
Corocondamitis.
578
Pontic Coast of First Section
it is said that Pharnaces once diverted the Hypanis toward Hypanis, Kuban r.
ACHAEANS, ZYGANS, Achaean, Zygan, and Heniochan shoreline, for the most part
HENIOCHANS
e. seaboard of Black Sea harborless and rugged, being part of the Caucasus. These
people make their living from piracy at sea, using boats that sea, Black Sea
579
4.1. Northern Asia
kingdom toward Bosporus, was traversing their territory. Bosporus = kingdom on e ither
side of Straits of Kerch'
He found he could pass through theirs, but he despaired of
Zygan territory, with its harsh and inhospitable conditions,
and made his way with difficulty along the coast, taking to the
sea for much of the distance, until he reached the territory of
the Achaeans, with whose help he completed his journey from
Phasis (not far short of four thousand stades). |
496 C, 26–497 C, 4 Immediately after Corocondama, the voyage is east- Corocondama, Tuzla (Russ.) 11.2.14
Artemidorus (late 2nd–early gard to Criu Metopum (Ram’s-forehead).1 Artemidorus says that, Criu Metopum, Cape Sarych
1st c. BCE) (Crim.)
starting from Bata, the Cercetian coastline with its anchorages and
villages lasts for some eight hundred and fifty stades; the Achaean
coastline for five hundred stades; then the Heniochan coastline for one
thousand stades; then Pityus, the great . . . * three hundred and sixty, Pityus, Bichvinta/Pitsunda (Geo.)
as far as Dioscurias. Writers of Mithridatica 2 have more cred- Dioscurias, Sukhumi (Geo.)
ibility: they put the Achaeans first, then the Zygans, then the
Heniochans, then the Cercetians, Moschians, and Colchians,
and inland from them, the Phthirophagi (Lice-eaters), Soanians,
and various micro-nations associated with the Caucasus.
497 C, 4-11 So then, the coastline starts off trending eastward, as I
said, and f aces south. At Bata, it begins to curve a l ittle, then Bata, Novorossiysk (Russ.)
becomes west-facing as far as Pityus and Dioscurias (these Dioscurias, Sukhumi (Geo.)
the Pontic and the Caspian seas and forms a wall along the
isthmus that separates them. It borders on Albania and Ibe- Albania, Iberia, n. Azerbaijan,
e. Georgia
ria to the south, and the Sarmatian plains in the north. It is
Sarmatian plains, s. Russia
densely forested and supplies a range of timber for various
uses, including shipbuilding.
[ 1 ] The sense is that Sinope (Sinop, n. Tky.) is supposed to lie due south of Bata [ 3 ] I.e., what “remains” of 1st section of n. Asia, as defined at 491 C, 12-23; 492 C,
(Novorossiysk, Russ.), just as Carambis (Kerembe burnu, n. Tky.) is supposed to 20-28. Cf. 498 C, 7-15.
lie due south of Criu Metopum (Cape Sarych, Crim.). Other examples of the [ 4 ] Strabo had a family connection with Colchis (w. Georgia) through his mother’s
expression: 34 C, 4-10n; 63 C, 14-18n; 199 C, 10-22n; 309 C, 12-21n; 511 C, 9-17n; uncle, Moaphernes, who had been the local representative of king Mithridates:
513 C, 30–514 C, 7n; cf. 545 C, 2-13n; 124 C, 32–125 C, 2. 498 C, 26–499 C, 9; 557 C, 21-29.
[ 2 ] Mithridatica are works (or sections of works) dealing with Mithridates, king of [ 5 ] For the term “Right-Hand Side of the Pontus” (Black Sea coast of Tky., Geo.,
Pontus + Bosporus (ruled 120–63 BCE). Strabo’s use of “titles”: 639 C, 15-27n. Russ.): 126 C, 3-11n. The “north-facing part” is the coast of Turkey.
580
Pontic Coast of First Section
497 C, 18-26 Eratosthenes says that the Caucasus is called the “Caspium” by
Eratosthenes (3rd c. BCE) the locals, perhaps being named a fter a “Caspian” p eople. It has exten-
sions that project southward, containing Iberia within them-
selves, and that link up with the Armenian mountains and with Moschians, mts. in ne. Turkey,
s. Georgia
what are called the “Moschians,” also with the Scydises and the
Scydises, Paryadres, mt. ranges
Paryadres. (These are all parts of the Taurus, the range that of ne. Turkey
forms the southern side of Armenia, being in a way northern Taurus = mts. of se. Turkey
branches of it that reach as far as the Caucasus and the stretch Euxine, Black Sea
of Euxine coast r unning from Colchis to Themiscyra.) | Themiscyra, nr. Terme (Tky.)
497 C, 27-34 Dioscurias, lying in such a bay1 and occupying the eastern- Dioscurias, Sukhumi (Geo.) 11.2.16
COLCHIS most point of the entire sea, is said to be the innermost part of
w. Georgia
the Euxine and its farthest sailing destination. The proverbial Euxine, Black Sea
mus between the Caspian and the Pontus,3 and is an entrepôt Pontus, Black Sea
Through Colchis runs the Phasis, a huge river that starts in Phasis, Rioni r.
Armenia and takes in the waters of the Glaucus and Hippus as Glaucus, Tekhuri r.
they flow down from the nearby mountains. There is passage Hippus, ?Tskhenistsquali r.
upstream as far as Sarapana, a stronghold with the capacity Sarapana, Shorapani (Geo.)
sis is a city with the same name, the Colchian entrepôt, which
has as her defense, on one side the river, on another side the
lake, and on another side the sea. It is a two-or three-day sail
from t here to Amisus and Sinope . . . * because of the soften- Amisus, Samsun (Tky.)
[ 1 ] 497 C, 4-11.
[ 2 ] The composer of the iambic verse was correct. Phasis (at mouth of Rioni r.) lies
on a more easterly meridian than Dioscurias (Sukhumi, Geo.).
[ 3 ] Strabo refines his e
arlier statement (491 C, 23-32, where Colchis in general is
said to mark the isthmus between the Caspian and Black Sea).
[ 4 ] I.e., what “remains” of 1st section of n. Asia: 497 C, 4-11n.
[ 5 ] A reference to the silting of the Black Sea coast: 52 C, 20-29.
581
4.1. Northern Asia
498 C, 15-25 The territory is excellent, in terms of its produce (ex- territory = Colchis (Geo.)
cept for the honey, which is generally b itter) and all t hings
related to shipbuilding. It produces (and provides trans-
port downstream on its rivers) a great deal of timber; and
it manufactures sailcloth, hemp rope, wax, and pitch. Their
cloth making has been much talked about, given that they
used to export the cloth to foreign parts. T hose who want to t emple to Leucothea, Atsquri
(Geo.)
show a kinship between the Colchian people and the Egyp-
Phrixus, a hero of mythical
tians base their belief on this. Situated in Moschia (above the times, is supposed to have
rivers just described)1 is the temple to Leucothea (founded traveled from Greece to Colchis
on a golden ram
by Phrixus) and also Phrixus’s oracle (at which no ram is sac-
oracle, center for divine
rificed), which once was wealthy but was plundered in our prophecy
times by Pharnaces and again a little later by Mithridates of Pharnaces ruled Bosporus,
Euripides (5th c. BCE) Pergamum. When a country is devastated, says Euripides, 63–ca. 47 BCE; Mithridates of
Pergamum attacked Bosporus,
religion suffers and cannot command respect. | ca. 47 BCE
498 C, 26–499 C, 9 The fame of this territory in antiquity is evident from territory = Colchis (Geo.) 11.2.18
myths that speak vaguely of the expedition of Jason (who Jason, Greek hero of mythical
times, retrieved fleece of
got as far as Media)2 and the expedition of Phrixus before golden ram from Colchis
him. Thereafter, kings took over, dividing the territory into
sceptuchies; and they achieved moderate success. Meanwhile,
however, the power of Mithridates Eupator had increased Mithridates, king of Pontus
(n. Tky.), acquired Colchis,
enormously, and the territory ended up with him. One or 104/3 BCE; Romans defeated
other of his friends (among them, Moaphernes, my mother’s Mithridates, 66 BCE
interior (about whom I shall have more to say later).3 Pharnacia, Giresun (Tky.)
499 C, 10-13 Moschia (where the temple is)4 has three parts: the Col-
chian people hold one part, the Iberians hold one part, and
the Armenians hold one part. In Iberia is a town, Phrixus’s
City, the current “Ideëssa,” a well-fortified l ittle place on the Chares, Khobi r.
border with Colchis. The river Chares is in the Dioscurias Dioscurias, Sukhumi (Geo.)
region. |
499 C, 14-27 Among the nations who frequent Dioscurias are the Phthi- 11.2.19
SOANIANS rophagi (Lice-eaters), who get their name from their squalor and
Svaneti (Geo.)
filth. Nearby are the Soanians, no better than the former in
[ 1 ] 498 C, 7-15: Phasis (Rioni r.), Glaucus (Tekhuri r.) and Hippus (?Tskhenistsquali r.).
[ 2 ] For the variant of the Jason myth in which he continues onward from Colchis to
Media (n. Iran) and for its origin (late 4th c. BCE) as a retrospective precedent
for Alexander the Great: 530 C, 18–531 C, 26n.
[ 3 ] 548 C, 27–549 C, 10.
[ 4 ] I.e., the temple to Leucothea (498 C, 15-25).
582
Pontic Coast of First Section
part with cities and dwellings, with the consequence that the
roofs are tiled, the h
ouses are constructed by master builders,
and t here are marketplaces and other public spaces. |
499 C, 35–500 C, 11 As for the territory, the outer perimeter is contained territory = Iberia 11.3.2
[ 1 ] The isthmus between the Caspian and the Black Sea is defined at 491 C, 23–
492 C, 9.
[ 2 ] 497 C, 18-26.
583
4.1. Northern Asia
Access into Iberia from west is via Sarapana, the Colchian fortress, and the accompany- Sarapana, Shorapani (Geo.)
ing pass through which the Phasis—crossed by one hundred Phasis = tributary of upper
Rioni r.
and twenty bridges b ecause of its winding course—flows
with wild turbulence down toward Colchis, the landscape
etched with ravines in full spate after heavy rains. It begins
high in the mountains, fed with the waters of many springs.
It is joined in the plains by other rivers, amongst them the
Glaucus and the Hippus. It expands and becomes navigable, Glaucus, Tekhuri r.
then flows into the Pontus, with a city of the same name on Hippus, ?Tskhenistsquali r.
its banks and a lake nearby. Such is the approach to Iberia Pontus, Black Sea
from C olchis, hemmed in by cliffs, natural fortifications, and Phasis (city), at mouth of Rioni r.,
now submerged
rivers in r avines. |
500 C, 27–501 C, 4 From the northern nomads there is a difficult three-day 11.3.5
Access from north ascent, and a fter that the narrow gorge of the Aragus river, Aragus, ?Aragvi r.
the Cyrus, Seusamora on the Aragus. Pompey initially, and Seusamora, Tsitsamuri (Geo.)
most is the class from which they appoint their kings, choos-
ing the most senior in terms of kinship and age (the next
most senior administers justice and commands the army).
Second is the class of the priests, who also look after claims
against neighboring peoples. Third is the class of soldiers and
farmers. Fourth is the class of the people, who are the king’s
584
Pontic Coast of First Section
slaves and look a fter life’s necessities. They hold their posses-
sions in common within their family group, each of which is
ruled and controlled by the most senior. Such are the Iberian
people and their territory. |
501 C, 13-21 The Albanians are more likely to herd sheep and are closer 11.4.1
ALBANIA to the nomadic type, except they are not savage. The people
n. Azerbaijan
here are warriors to a degree. They live between the Iberians
and the Caspian sea (extending to the sea in the east and bor-
dering on the Iberians in the west). Of the remaining sides,
the northern one is protected by the Caucasian mountains
rising up from the plains, t hose closest to the sea being called
the “Ceraunians.” The southern side is formed by Armenia Ceraunians, Daghestan mts.
(Russ.)
as it stretches out with its many plains and mountains (e.g.,
Cambisene, where the Armenians have a border with the Ibe-
rians and Albanians). |
501 C, 22-34 The Cyrus (which runs across Albania), with the various Cyrus, Kura/Mtkvari r. 11.4.2
other rivers that join it, adds to the excellence of the land
but does quite the reverse to the sea. A g reat deal of sedi-
ment sinks down and silts up its channel—so that the l ittle
islands located in it become part of the mainland—forming
uneven and unpredictable shallows, whose uneven nature is
accentuated when the waters draw back after high tide. It is
said that its outflow is split among twelve mouths, some of
which are blind alleys while others have absolutely no depth
and no place to anchor; that, although the coast is washed on
all sides (by the sea and by the rivers) for a distance of more
than sixty stades, every part of it is inaccessible; that deposits
of silt stretch out for more than five hundred stades, creating
a sandy shoreline. The nearby Araxes, as it makes its way out Araxes, Aras r.
[ 1 ] “Those who were on the campaign,” despite the plural, probably refers to
Theophanes, the Greek writer from Roman Asia, who accompanied Pompey
on his Caucasus campaign (66–64 BCE). Similar pluralization: 416 C, 2-10nn.
585
4.1. Northern Asia
being fiftyfold), despite never being left fallow nor plowed with an iron
blade (but only one made completely of wood). The w hole plain is
irrigated (more so than the Babylonian and Egyptian plains)
by rivers and other streams, thus always presenting to the eye
a grassy appearance, and as a result, it is good for grazing (an
added benefit is that it has a more temperate climate than
those plains). The vines, which survive their whole life with-
out having trenches dug around them, and which need prun-
ing only e very five years, nevertheless produce fruit already
at only two years old and, when mature, yield so much that a
great deal gets left on the plants.
502 C, 13-26 Domesticated and wild, their animals are well formed, |
as also the p eople, being of exceptional beauty and size. They 11.4.4
are s imple folk, who do not buy and sell (they do not have
much use for coinage, nor are they familiar with any number
beyond one hundred) but make payment in kind. In various
other ways, they lead an easygoing life, being unfamiliar with
precise weights and measures and unschooled in war, govern-
ment, and agriculture. Nevertheless, they go into b attle on
foot and on horseback, either lightly equipped or (like the
Armenians) heavily armed. | They field an army larger than 11.4.5
hunt, with less skill than enthusiasm in this respect. | The 11.4.6
586
Pontic Coast of First Section
587
4.1. Northern Asia
Mermadalis river flowing there splits the latter from the Amazons.
Metrodorus (2nd–1st c. BCE) Others (including Metrodorus of Scepsis and Hypsicrates,
Hypsicrates (1st c. BCE) neither of them unacquainted with the region) say that the
women share a border with the Gargarians and live in the northern
foothills of the Caucasian mountains called the “Ceraunians”; for Ceraunians, Daghestan mts.
(Russ.)
most of the time, they work at their own tasks, doing all that is neces-
sary for plowing, planting, and rearing livestock, particularly horses
(with the bravest w omen branching out into hunting and military
exercises); all the w omen have the right breast cauterized in infancy so
that they can use their arms freely—for any purpose but especially for
javelin throwing; they use the bow, the “sagaris,” and a small shield, sagaris, machete or battle-ax
and fashion animal hides into helmets, clothing, and b elts; they set
aside two months e very spring, during which they ascend a nearby
mountain that separates them from the Gargarian men.
504 C, 13-17 The men, too, ascend the mountain, according to ancient
custom, in order to make sacrifices and to sleep with the
women (anonymously and secretly, any man with any w oman)
for the purpose of reproduction. When they have impreg-
nated the women, the men send them away. The women keep
for themselves any female c hildren they bear but send male
children to be looked a fter by the men. E very man accepts
every boy into his f amily, assuming (since he cannot know)
that the boy is his son. |
504 C, 18-24 The Mermadalis crashes down from the mountains, flow- 11.5.2
that the Gargarian men came up from Themiscyra to t hese Themiscyra, nr. Terme (n. Tky.)
588
Pontic Coast of First Section
Thermodon plains, and the mountains above them, as “be- Thermodon [river], Terme Çay
(n. Tky.)
longing to the Amazon w omen”; and say that this is the
place from which the women w ere ousted. As to where they
are now—few venture an opinion, and those who do offer no
convincing proof !
505 C, 10-18 Another example is the story of Thalestria, with whom, Alexander the G
reat, late 4th c.
BCE
it is said, Alexander slept when he visited her in Hyrcania, so
that he might have children with her, the Amazonian chief-
tainess. This story is not told by everyone. Out of the whole
mass of historians, those most concerned with reality do not
say anything about it, nor do the most reliable among them
mention any such t hing; and, among t hose who do, the tale
Clitarchus (late 4th–3rd c. BCE) varies. (Clitarchus says that Thalestria came to Alexander from
the Caspian Gates and the Thermodon—yet it is more than six Caspian Gates, ?Sar Darreh
pass (Iran)
thousand stades from the Caspian to the Thermodon!) |
505 C, 19-28 The oft-repeated stories that glorify his exploits, even if his = Alexander’s 11.5.5
from Colchis and the Euxine, which are called by the Greeks Colchis, w. Georgia
“Caucasus” and are more than thirty thousand stades this side Euxine, Black Sea
of India! T hese latter are where the Greeks set the myth of
Prometheus and his chains, given that they w ere the eastern-
most mountains known to mankind at the time. (The expedi-
tion of Dionysus and Heracles to the Indian p eople belongs
[ 1 ] Cyme (Nemrut Limanı, Tky.), Myrina (nr. mouth of Koca Çay): 622 C, 28–623 C,
9. Ephesus (Selçuk, Tky.), Smyrna (Izmir, Tky.): 633 C, 20–634 C, 18.
589
4.1. Northern Asia
tion and the name of the mountain range, and the belief that
the expedition undertaken by those associated with Jason1 Jason, Greek hero of mythical
times, voyaged in Argo to
to the Caucasus region was the longest that had ever been Colchis
undertaken, and the tradition that Prometheus was bound
in chains at the ends of the earth in the Caucasus . . . * they
assumed they would somehow find royal favor by transferring
the name of the mountain range to India. |
506 C, 4-15 The loftiest parts of the true Caucasus are the most south- 11.5.6
erly, next to Albania and Iberia and to the Colchians and Albania, Iberia, n. Azerbaijan,
e. Georgia
Heniochans. Living h ere are the p
eoples whom I described as
frequenting the market at Dioscurias (they go primarily for
the salt).2 Some occupy the mountaintops, o thers make their
homes in the valleys; generally, they live off the flesh of un-
domesticated animals, forest fruits, and milk. The peaks are
impassable in winter. In the summer, they climb the peaks by
strapping under their feet (because of the snow and ice) spiked
rawhides stretched out like drum tops; and they make their
way down again by lying on animal skins and sliding down, to-
gether with their loads. (This is the practice, too, in Atropatian Atropatian Media, nw. Iran, s.
Azerbaijan
Media and the Masium mountain range in Armenia, and the
Masium, mt. range in s. Turkey,
men t here also attach round wooden frames, with spikes, to the Karaca Dağ to Tigris r.
bottoms of their shoes.) Such are the heights of the Caucasus. |
506 C, 16-23 As you descend into the foothills, the climata become climata, bands of latitude 11.5.7
who live in caves because of the cold (at this point it is still
not possible to grow barley); a fter the troglodytae come the
chamaecoetae (ground-sleepers) and the polyphagi (omnivores), as they
are called; and the villages of the Isadicians, who are able to
engage in farming since they are not wholly “under the
Bears”; 4 | even farther on are the nomads between the Maeo- Maeotis, Sea of Azov 11.5.8
tis and the Caspian—Nabianians, Panzanians, and ultimately
Siracian and Aorsian tribes.
506 C, 23-32 The Aorsians and Siracians are apparently refugees Aorsians, Siracians, s. Russia
from the tribes higher up, with the Aorsians being the more
590
Second Section
2 myriads = 20,000 ortherly. Abeacus, the Siracian king, was able to field two
n
myriads of h orsemen at the time when Pharnaces held Pharnaces ruled Bosporus
(= kingdom on e ither side of
20 [myriads] = 200,000 Bosporus; Spadines, the Aorsian king, as many as twenty Straits of Kerch'), 63–ca. 47 BCE
[myriads]; and the upper Aorsians even more. They used to
506 C, 33–507 C, 2 The second section begins where the former section ended, 11.6.1
2nd section of northern Asia at the Caspian sea (this same sea also being called the
“Hyrcanian”). I will start with a description of this sea and
the nations that border it.
Caspian Coast
507 C, 3-6 This gulf is a southerly intrusion of the ocean,1 narrow enough gulf = Caspian Sea
at the start but getting wider the farther in it goes and being being widest = having greatest
east–west dimension
widest—some five thousand stades—at its innermost recess.
innermost = southernmost
The voyage from its entrance (which borders approximately
only slightly longer = than its
on the unlivable zone) to its innermost part would be only east–west dimension of some
slightly longer. 5,000 stades
507 C, 6-13 Eratosthenes says that the sailing distance along the coastline of
Eratosthenes (3rd c. BCE) this sea known to the Greeks is five thousand four hundred [stades] for the
Albanian and Cadusian coastlines and four thousand eight hundred Albanian, Cadusian coast,
Azerbaijani coast of Caspian sea
[stades] for the Anariacan, Mardian, and Hyrcanian coastlines to the
Anariacan . . . Hyrcanian
mouth of the Oxus river; 2 from there to the Iaxartes 3 is two thousand four coastlines, Iran + Turkmenistan
hundred [stades]. However, one should understand only in rather coast of Caspian Sea
general terms what is said about places in this section and in Iaxartes, Syr Darya
who come next after the European parts, and the Sarmatians
[ 1 ] Strabo believes that just north of the Caspian sea lies the outer ocean and that
the Caspian has a mouth at its northern end through which the outer ocean
enters it to form a gulf.
[ 2 ] The mouth of the Oxus (Amu Darya) opens into the Aral Sea, not (as Eratos-
thenes erroneously believes) into the Caspian. There may be some conflation
of the Amu Darya with the Ural and/or Volga rivers.
[ 3 ] I omit Radt’s addition to the text (vol. 3, critical apparatus on 507 C, line 11).
[ 4 ] The names “Right-Hand Side” (Caspian coast of Russia, Azerbaijan, Iran) and
“Left-Hand Side” (Caspian coast of Kazakhstan, Turkmenistan, Iran) are used
from the viewpoint of an imaginary navigator supposedly sailing into the Cas-
pian from the outer ocean; cf. the terms “Right-Hand Side” and “Left-Hand
Side” applied to the Pontic sea (Black Sea): 126 C, 3-11n.
591
4.1. Northern Asia
between the Tanaïs and this sea. They are largely nomadic, Tanaïs, Don r.
507 C, 18-26 Greek writers of long ago used to call all northern people
indiscriminately “Scythians” and “Celto-Scythians.” Still
earlier, some made a distinction, using the names “Hyper-
boreans” and “Sauromatians” and “Arimaspians” for t hose
people who lived inland from the Euxine, from the Ister, and Euxine, Black Sea
from the Adria; and using “Sacans” for some, and “Massag- Ister, Danube r.
etans” for o thers of those beyond the Caspian sea—although Adria, Adriatic Sea
they w ere unable to say anything accurate about them, de- beyond Caspian sea = east of
Caspian Sea
spite telling the story of Cyrus’s war against the Massagetans.
Cyrus founded Persian empire,
Nothing accurate in terms of truthfulness was said about 6th c. BCE
these p eople, nor was the ancient history of the Persians, Persians held power, 6th–4th c.
nor of the Medes or Syrians, related with much credibility, BCE; Medes, 7th–6th c. BCE;
(As)syrians, 10th–7th c. BCE
because of the writers’ lack of detail and love of myth. |
507 C, 26–508 C, 9 Writers observed that those who w ere clearly mythogra- 11.6.3
Left-Hand Side of the Caspian sea (as you sail in) 3 “Daans,” Left-Hand Side = sw.
Kazakhstan, Turkmenistan, Iran
with the additional qualification “Parnian”; then a desert
intervenes; next is Hyrcania, where the sea spreads out as far
as the mountains of Media and of the Armenians, the foothills
592
Second Section
593
4.1. Northern Asia
508 C, 27–509 C, 3 So, then, while the foregoing are miserable places, |
HYRCANIA/NESAEA Hyrcania is exceedingly blessed by nature, large in extent, 11.7.2
sw. Turkmenistan, n. Iran,
?w. Uzbekistan, ?s. Kazakhstan mostly flat, and divided into cities of some significance, such
as Talabroca, Samariana, Carta, and the royal residence of Carta, ?Sari (Iran)
Tapa (which is said to be set only a little back from the sea
and is one thousand four hundred stades from the Caspian Caspian Gates, ?Sar Darreh
pass (Iran)
Gates). . . . * evidence of its natural blessings . . . * 2 The vine
yields one metretes of wine, and the fig tree, sixty medimni; metretes, largest fluid measure
in Greek metrical system
grain grows from seeds that dropped from the stalks; bees are
medimnus, largest volume
busy in the trees, honey dripping from the leaves. This also measure in Greek metrical
happens in Matiana in Media, and in Sacasene and Araxene system
in Armenia.
509 C, 4-11 Hyrcania has not been properly developed, nor has the
sea that shares its name, being unexplored and unexploited
(there are islands, some have said, which could be settled and
that have gold dust in their soil).3 The reason is that it has
been ruled by barbarians, both originally (the Medes and the Medes, 7th–6th c. BCE
Persians) and most recently (the Parthians, worse than the Persians, 6th–4th c. BCE
Medes and Persians). All the neighboring territory is full of Parthians, regional power,
from 3rd c. BCE, still current in
raiders, of nomads, and of desert. The Macedonians were in Strabo’s time
control for only a short time, being at war and unable to keep Macedonians, 4th–3rd c. BCE
an eye on t hese remote parts. |
509 C, 11-25 Aristobulus says that in densely forested Hyrcania, oak trees 11.7.3
Aristobulus (late 4th c. BCE) grow but not “peuca” pines nor fir trees nor “pitys” pines, although
India abounds in them. Nesaea is part of Hyrcania; some say it
[ 1 ] “Parnian” Daans (Turkmenistan) and desert (Karakum, Tkm.): 511 C, 17-27; 515 C,
4-23. Hyrcania (sw. Turkmenistan, n. Iran): 508 C, 27–510 C, 25. Gelans, etc. (Azer-
baijan, n. Iran): 507 C, 6-13; 508 C, 18-26; 513 C, 30–514 C, 7; 523 C, 26-34.
[ 2 ] Strabo repeats information given earlier at 73 C, 3-10.
[ 3 ] Strabo perhaps confuses the Hyrcanian (Caspian) sea and the Aral sea (“Aral”
means “islands”).
594
Second Section
ported by means of the Cyrus and successive places into the Euxine. Cyrus, Kura/Mtkvari r.
Apollodorus (1st c. BCE) The Ochus is not mentioned at all by the ancients, but Apol- Euxine, Black Sea
lodorus (author of the Parthica)2 repeatedly mentions it as
being very close to the Parthians. |
509 C, 26–510 C, 3 Many false beliefs about this sea arose through glorifica- sea = Caspian Sea 11.7.4
tion of Alexander. It had been agreed by all that the Tanaïs Alexander the G
reat, late 4th c.
BCE
river cuts Asia off from Europe and that the area between
Tanaïs, Don r.
this sea and the Tanaïs, despite being a sizable portion of
Asia, did not fall to the Macedonians; and it had been recog-
nized that the campaigns w ere such that Alexander seemed
(at least according to rumor) to control even t hese parts.
People consequently treated, as one and the same, lake lake Maeotis, Sea of Azov
Maeotis (into which the Tanaïs flows) and the Caspian sea,
calling this latter a lake, too, and claiming that the lakes w ere
connected with each other and that each was a part of the
Polyclitus (late 4th c. BCE) other. Polyclitus proffers evidence that this sea is a lake (it
contains water snakes, and its w ater is fresh) and concludes that
it is none other than the Maeotis, on the basis that the Tanaïs
flows into it.3
510 C, 3-14 The Iaxartes flows from the same Indian mountains as the
Ochus, the Oxus, and several o thers; like them, it opens into
the Caspian sea, but is the farthest north of them all.4 People
called this river the “Tanaïs” and took as additional proof of
it being the Tanaïs of which Polyclitus spoke the fact that fir
trees grow on the far bank of the river, that the local Scythians
use arrows made from them, and that this shows that the far
side is E
uropean territory rather than Asian, b ecause fir trees
Eratosthenes (3rd c. BCE) do not grow in the upper and eastern parts of Asia. Eratos-
thenes, however, says that fir trees grow even in India; Alexander
built the ships for his fleet from them. Eratosthenes attempts to
tackle many such fallacies, but let that be enough for me to
have said on t hese m atters. |
[ 1 ] The names “Ochus” and “Oxus” are perhaps h ere used to denote the Amu Darya
and Syr Darya respectively (more commonly, “Oxus” is used for the Amu Darya
and “Iaxartes” for the Syr Darya). Cf. 518 C, 9-20n.
[ 2 ] See 639 C, 15-27n.
[ 3 ] The name “Tanaïs” is usually applied to the Don r. but is perhaps here conflated
with the Volga r. (or Ural r.).
[ 4 ] The name “Iaxartes” is usually applied to the Syr Darya but is perhaps here
conflated with the Volga r. (or Ural r.).
595
4.1. Northern Asia
510 C, 15-25 One of the wonders reported about Hyrcania by Eudoxus 11.7.5
Eudoxus (4th c. BCE) and others is this. Facing the sea are some cliffs with caves at their
base; between them and the sea, t here’s a low-lying shore. Rivers flow
with so great a force from the crags above that, when they reach the
cliffs, they shoot their waters out into the sea, leaving the shore so dry
that w hole armies could march along it and be screened by the falling
water. The locals often travel down to this spot to celebrate festivals
and hold sacrifices, sometimes reclining at the foot of the caves and
sometimes basking at the foot of the waterfall, diff erent p eople enjoy-
ing it in diff erent ways, with the sea being visible from both locations,
as also the shore, verdant with grass and flowers as a result of the
moist conditions. |
510 C, 26–511 C, 8 As you proceed from the Hyrcanian sea in an easterly di- Hyrcanian sea, Caspian Sea 11.8.1
TAURUS rection, on your right-hand side is the mountain range called right-hand = south
mts. from n. Iran to ne. India
by the Greeks the “Taurus.” It stretches lengthwise as far as the
Indian sea, reaching that point—from its start in Pamphylia
and Cilicia—in a continuous line from the west, various parts
of it being given diff erent names. Living in its northern parts
are, first, Gelans, Cadusians, and Amardians, as has been said,1
and some of the Hyrcanians; then the Parthian nation and the
Margianan and Arian nations.2 Also, there is a desert, which desert, Karakum (Tkm.)
the Sarnius river separates from Hyrcania, as you go east in the Sarnius, ?Atrek r.
direction of the Ochus.3 The stretch from Armenia up to this
point (or stopping a little short) is called the “Parachoathras”; Parachoathras, Alburz + Talish
mts.
it m easures around six thousand stades from the Hyrcanian
sea to the Arians. Then there are Bactriana and Sogdiana; and
finally the nomadic Scythians.4 The Macedonians called all
the mountains from the Arians onward the “Caucasus”; ac-
cording to the natives . . . * “Emoda,” “Imaum,” and other Emoda, Imaum, Himalayas
Scythian and nomadic nations who fill out and complete the
northern side.6 The majority of the Scythians that start off
at the Caspian sea are labeled “Daans.”7 They give the names
“Massagetans” and “Sacans” to those farther east than these
people.8 They call the rest by the generic name “Scythians”
but also by specific names. In all cases, they are nomadic
most of the time. The best known of the nomads are t hose Bactria was overrun, 2nd c. BCE
who took Bactria from the Greeks—the Asians, Pasianians, far side of Iaxartes = ne. of Syr
Tocharians, and Sacaraucians—who hailed from the far side Darya (s. Kaz., Kyr., ?China)
[ 1 ] 507 C, 6-13; 508 C, 10-26. [ 6 ] Daans (Turkmenistan and Kazakhstan region): 511 C, 17-27. Massagetans
[ 2 ] Parthia (s. Turkmenistan, n. Iran): 514 C, 24–515 C, 29; Margiana (se. Turkmeni- (Uzbekistan and Turkmenistan region): 512 C, 26–513 C, 29. Sacans (Tajikistan,
stan): 515 C, 30-33; 516 C, 12-16; Aria (n. Afghanistan): 515 C, 30–516 C, 11. Kyrgyzstan, and Kazakhstan region): 511 C, 28–512 C, 25.
[ 3 ] The name “Ochus” may here be applied to the Amu Darya: 509 C, 11-25n. [ 7 ] I.e., labeled by Latin speakers; Strabo transliterates into Greek the Latin ethnic
[ 4 ] Bactriana + Sogdiana (n. Afghanistan, s. Uzbekistan, Tajikistan region): 516 C, name Dahae. Strabo’s transliteration of Latin names: 508 C, 10-18n.
17–518 C, 25; Scythians (Himalayan region): 518 C, 26–519 C, 9. [ 8 ] “They” are Latin speakers; Strabo transliterates into Greek the Latin names
[ 5 ] “Corresponding to” here means “north of”: 496 C, 26–497 C, 4n. Massagetae and Sacae.
596
Second Section
far as the territory parallel to Aria. | Lying between them and neighboring sea, Caspian 11.8.3
Hyrcania and Parthia, as far as the Arians, is a huge w aterless Aria, n. Afghanistan
desert. A fter crossing the desert by means of lengthy jour- desert, Karakum (Tkm.)
overthrow of Mithridates. |
512 C, 11-22 While this is the account of the “Sacaea” given by some, 11.8.5
others say that Cyrus, in his campaign against the Sacans, was Cyrus founded Persian empire,
6th c. BCE
worsted in b attle and fled. Cyrus made camp in a place where
he had left full and unstinting supplies of everything, but espe-
cially wine; a fter giving his men a short rest, he (as if deciding
[ 1 ] Probably Latin (or Latinized) epithets: 508 C, 10-18n. “Parnian” Daans: 515 C,
4-23n.
[ 2 ] “They” are Latin speakers; Strabo provides a Greek transliteration of the Latin
name Pontici. Strabo’s reference is to the inhabitants of the Roman province of
Pontus. Strabo’s transliteration of Latin names: 508 C, 10-18n.
597
4.1. Northern Asia
on flight) got them to depart but left the tents fully supplied;
going only so far as seemed expedient, he brought them to a
halt. When the Sacans attacked the camp and found it empty
of men but full of things to enjoy, they drank unstintingly.
Cyrus returned to find them drunk out of their minds: some
were butchered as they lay unconscious and asleep; others,
dancing and reveling without their weapons, fell victim to
their enemies’ swords; almost all of them w ere killed. Cyrus
believed that his success was the result of divine influence, ded-
icated the day to his native goddess, and named it the “Sacaea.”
512 C, 22-25 Wherever t here is a t emple to this goddess, it is customary
to celebrate the Sacaea—a sort of Bacchic festival that lasts
through the day and the night, in which the participants don
Scythian garb and get together to drink and indulge in amo-
rous activity with each other and with the women drinking
with them. |
512 C, 26–513 C, 1 The Massagetans showed their courage in the war against 11.8.6
MASSAGETANS Cyrus. There are many who tell stories about t hese t hings—
Uzbekistan and Turkmenistan
region we should learn from them. The following is said about the
Massagetans, that some dwell on the mountains; some of
them dwell in the plains; some dwell in the marshes formed
by the rivers; some dwell on the islands in the marshes. It is
said that the Araxes river,1 in particular, spreads across the
territory, branching out in all direction, flowing through sev-
eral different mouths into the other sea in the north,2 and
through one mouth alone into the Hyrcanian gulf. Hyrcanian gulf, Caspian Sea
513 C, 2-11 The Massagetans believe in one god, Helius (Sun), and sac-
rifice horses to him. Each man marries one w oman, although
they openly enjoy the wives of other men: he who has sex with
another man’s wife does so after hanging his quiver in plain
view outside the wagon. They believe that the best death, on
reaching old age, is to be slaughtered with the sheep for meat
and to be eaten mixed in with it. People who die of disease
are cast out, as being impure and fit to be eaten only by wild
animals. They are good horsemen and foot soldiers. They use
the bow and arrow, swords, breastplates, and sagareis made sagareis = machetes or
battle-axes
of bronze. The belts and headgear worn in b attle are golden.
Their h orses have gold-embossed reins and girths made of
gold. They have no silver, a small amount of iron, masses of
copper and gold. |
[ 1 ] The name “Araxes” may here be applied to the Amu Darya, or to a conflation
of the Amu Darya and the Syr Darya.
[ 2 ] The “other sea” may be the Aral Sea, to which Strabo makes no explicit refer-
ence elsewhere.
598
Second Section
513 C, 12-24 The island dwellers (since they have no place to sow grain) 11.8.7
are rhizophagi (root-eaters) and live off wild fruits; they use tree
bark for clothing, as they keep no animals; they get juice from
tree fruits for drinking. The marsh dwellers are ichthyophagi
(fish-eaters) and wear the skins of seals that swim upriver from
the sea. The mountain dwellers eat wild fruits and also keep
animals, but only a few, so that they do not slaughter them
but keep them for their wool and their milk; they decorate
their clothing by applying dyes whose color does not fade.
The plain dwellers possess territory but do not farm it, living
instead off their sheep and fish, in the nomadic and Scyth-
ian way. All such people share this lifestyle, as I often note:
their burial rites and customs are similar, and their whole
way of life, which is on the one hand ingenuous but on the
other hand difficult and savage and violent, and they have a
straightforward simplicity in their business dealings. |
513 C, 25-29 Included as part of the Massagetan and Sacan nation are 11.8.8
513 C, 30–514 C, 7 Eratosthenes says that the Arachotians and Massagetans lie
Eratosthenes (3rd c. BCE) parallel to, and west of, the Bactrians, along the banks of the Oxus. Oxus, Amu Darya
other direction from the Hyrcanians live the Derbicans. The Ca-
dusians link up with the Medes and Matianans at the foot of the
Parachoathras, Alburz +
Parachoathras. | Talish mts.
514 C, 8-14 He gives the following distances: He = Eratosthenes 11.8.9
Cyrus, Kura/Mtkvari r. • from the Caspium to the Cyrus, approximately 1,800 stades; Caspium = Caucasus
Caspian Gates, ?Sar Darreh
• from t here to the Caspian Gates, 5,600; pass (Iran)
• thence to Arian Alexandria, 6,400; Arian Alexandria, Herat (Afg.)
[ 1 ] The sense is that the Sacans and Sogdianans lie due north of India: 496 C,
26–497 C, 4n.
599
4.1. Northern Asia
• thence to the city of Bactra, also called “Zariaspa,” 3,870; Bactra/Zariaspa, Balkh (Afg.)
Iaxartes, Syr Darya • thence to the Iaxartes river (which Alexander reached),
approximately 5,000;
• all together, 22,670.
514 C, 14-22 Eratosthenes gives the following distances from the Cas-
pian Gates to India. They say that:
One should imagine the length of India—from the Indus length = east–west dimension
to the eastern sea—as a straight-line continuation of this eastern sea, Bay of Bengal
distance.
514 C, 23 The foregoing was my account of the Sacans.1 |
514 C, 24-31 Parthia is not large: for a long time, under the Persians Persians, 6th–4th c. BCE 11.9.1
PARTHIA and afterward when the Macedonians were in power, it used Macedonians, late 4th–mid-
s. Turkmenistan, n. Iran 3rd c. BCE
to pay tribute jointly with the Hyrcanians. As well as being
small, it is densely forested and mountainous, and yields little
produce. The consequence is that even the kings pass through
their own country at g reat speed for this reason, given that the
territory cannot sustain a large crowd even for a short time.
These days, however, it has become more powerful. Included
as parts of Parthyene are Comisene and Chorene and the Caspian Gates, ?Sar Darreh
region—reaching nearly to the Caspian Gates and Rhagae and pass (Iran)
and Heraclia are cities in the Rhagae region.) Apamia, ?nr. Aradan (Iran)
514 C, 31-36 It is five hundred stades from the Caspian Gates to Rhagae, ac-
Apollodorus (1st c. BCE) cording to Apollodorus, and one thousand two hundred and
sixty to Hecatompylus, the Parthian royal residence. It is said that Hecatompylus, ?Shahr-i Qumis
(Iran)
“Rhagae” (Sundered) was given its name because of an earth-
Posidonius (late 2nd–1st c. BCE) quake in which, according to Posidonius, a huge number of cities
and two thousand villages were toppled.
600
Second Section
514 C, 36–515 C, 3 The Tapyrians are said to live between the Derbicans and
the Hyrcanians. It is recorded of the Tapyrians that it is their
custom to give their wives away in marriage to other men,
once they have had two or three children with them, just as
in our time, according to an ancient Roman custom, Cato
handed over Marcia to the needy Hortensius! |
515 C, 4-18 When there was unrest outside the Taurus, because the outside Taurus = north of Taurus 11.9.2
kings of Syria and Media (who held these places, too) were kings of Syria + Media =
Macedonian kings, who held
otherwise engaged, their officials first of all caused Bactri- Parthia late 4th–mid-3rd c. BCE
ana to revolt, and t hose associated with Euthydemus1 caused
all the territory near it to revolt; then Arsaces, a Scythian,
together with those of the Daans called “Parnian” (nomads
living on the banks of the Ochus),2 attacked and took con-
trol of Parthia. To begin with, Arsaces was weak, constantly
fighting with those whose territory he had taken—he and
his successors likewise. Then they gained so much power
by successively acquiring lands through military successes
that they ended up in possession of all the land this side of this side of Euphrates = east of
Euphrates r.
the Euphrates.3 They even appropriated part of Bactriana,
overcoming by force the Scythians and, before them, those
associated with Eucratidas.4 Now they rule over so much
land and over so many nations that the size of their empire
is in a way on a par with Rome. The cause is their way of life
and their culture, which is barbarian and Scythian in many
ways but extremely conducive to hegemony and military
success. |
515 C, 19-23 The “Parnian” Daans are said to be emigrants from those 11.9.3
Daans inland from the Maeotis, whom they call “Xandian” Maeotis, Sea of Azov
[ 1 ] “Those associated with Euthydemus” is idiomatic, meaning simply Euthydemus. the geographical work, Strabo’s historical work would have been over twice as
Bactriana had already (mid-3rd c. BCE) freed itself from Macedonian rule before long as his geographical one.
Euthydemus took control (late 3rd c. BCE). [ 8 ] What Strabo refers to as After Polybius probably comprises the greater part
[ 2 ] “Parnian” Daans: 511 C, 17-27nn. of Strabo’s Historical Volumes. Strabo often uses “titles” to designate sections
[ 3 ] Strabo temporarily adopts a Parthian point of view. of his work: 639 C, 15-27n.
[ 4 ] “Those associated with Eucratidas” is idiomatic, meaning simply Eucratidas. [ 9 ] The Greek historian Polybius ended his work with the events of 146/145 BCE.
Eucratidas seized the Bactrian throne in early 2nd c. BCE. The Greek writer Posidonius, some three-quarters of a century later, wrote a
[ 5 ] “They” may be Latin speakers: 511 C, 17-27n; 508 C, 10-18n. historical work that started where Polybius left off and brought it up to his own
[ 6 ] “Those associated with Diodotus” is idiomatic, meaning simply Diodotus. times. Another half c entury later, Strabo wrote a historical work, the bulk of
Diodotus established Bactrian independence in mid-3rd c. BCE. which (After Polybius) similarly covered events after those covered by Polybius,
[ 7 ] Strabo’s Historical Volumes are no longer available to us. A 10th c. CE lexicon right up to Strabo’s times. Strabo must have therefore covered some of the
informs us that the work consisted of more than 40 books. Assuming that each same material as Posidonius.
of these books was, on average, as long as each of the 17 books that make up
601
4.1. Northern Asia
516 C, 1-11 Aria has a border with Bactriana and was subject to
ARIA Stasanor,2 who also held Bactriana. It is around six thou- Stasanor acquired
n. Afghanistan Aria + Bactriana, late 4th c. BCE
sand stades distant from Hyrcania. Drangiana (as far as
Carmania)—lying largely at the foot of the mountains on
the southern side but possessing some parts approaching
the northern side in the region of Aria—used to pay tribute
jointly with Aria. Arachosia is not far distant from it, also
lying at the southern foot of the mountains and extending
as far as the Indus river; it is part of Ariana. Aria’s length is length = east–west dimension
some two thousand stades, and the width of its plateau, three width = north–south dimension
hundred. Its cities are Artacaëna, Alexandria, and Achaea, [Arian] Alexandria, Herat (Afg.)
named for their f ounders. The land produces very good wine,
which keeps into the third generation, even in jars that are not
sealed with pitch. |
516 C, 12-16 Margiana is similar, although its plain is surrounded by 11.10.2
MARGIANA deserts. Antiochus Soter, impressed by its favorable location, Antiochus Soter, Macedonian
se. Turkmenistan king of Media + Syria, early
enclosed it within a wall one thousand five hundred stades in 3rd c. BCE
perimeter and founded the city of Antioch. This land is also Antioch, Erk Kala, Gyaur Kala
good for growing vines. They say that it is often found that (Tkm.)
the stem needs two men to encircle it, and that the clusters
are twice the length of the lower arm.3 |
516 C, 17-28 As for Bactria, part of it is north of Aria, but a large part 11.11.1
602
Second Section
In general, that fellow claims that Bactriana is the jewel of all that fellow = Apollodorus
Ariana. They furthermore extended their rule to the Seres Seres, ?Chinese
603
4.1. Northern Asia
Aristobulus (late 4th c. BCE) “Polytimetus” (the Macedonians coming up with the name just as, Polytimetus, Zeravshan r.
in the case of many other names, they came up with new ones or altered
existing ones); it provides the territory with water, then emerges into
the sandy desert and is swallowed into the sand, just like the Arius Arius, Hari-Rūd/Tedjen r.
[ 1 ] An error for “Darius” (Persian king, late 6th–early 5th c. BCE), repeated at 634 C,
22-32. Other such repeated errors: 98 C, 13-17n and 100 C, 24-34n; 587 C, 24–
588 C, 2n and 636 C, 10-18n.
[ 2 ] In this paragraph, the names “Ochus,” “Oxus,” and “Iaxartes” are probably
applied to the Amu Darya, Syr Darya, and Volga r. (or Ural r.), respectively:
509 C, 11–510 C, 14. The name “Ochus” is perhaps also applied to a fourth river
(?Sangalak r.). Strabo is probably trying to reconcile several sources that use
the same names for different rivers.
[ 3 ] The mouths of the Amu Darya and Syr Darya are both located on the Aral Sea.
Could this be what Strabo means by “sea in Hyrcania”? Or does he take the
“sea in Hyrcania” to refer to the Caspian? See 510 C, 3-14n; 512 C, 26–513 C, 1n;
cf. 509 C, 4-11n.
604
Second Section
tions outside the Taurus became known at first to the Persians, outside Taurus = north of Taurus
mts.
then to the Macedonians and Parthians. Nations farther on
Persians, 6th–4th c. BCE
in the same direction are considered, on the grounds of their
Macedonians, late 4th–mid-
appearance, to be Scythian. To my knowledge, however, there 3rd c. BCE
have been no military campaigns against them; nor similarly Parthians, regional power
against the nomads farthest north, against whom Alexander from mid-3rd c. BCE, current in
Strabo’s day
undertook a campaign, going a fter Bessus and Spitamenes,
but gave up the attempt when Bessus was brought back alive
and Spitamenes was killed by the natives.
518 C, 34–519 C, 3 There is no consensus as to w hether p eople have sailed
Patrocles (late 4th–early 3rd c. from India to Hyrcania, but Patrocles said it was possible.2 Hyrcania, sw. Tkm., n. Iran
BCE)
| It is said that the final part of the Taurus (which they call 11.11.7
“Imaeum” and which ends with the Indian sea) neither pro- Imaeum, e. Himalayas
of Asia currently being dealt with (the section contained width = north–south dimension
within the Taurus with respect to the ocean that feeds into
the Caspian sea) appears to taper in the east. The greatest
length of this section, from the Hyrcanian sea to the ocean Hyrcanian sea, Caspian Sea
at Imaeum, is some thirty thousand stades (the route being ocean at Imaeum = Bay of
Bengal
along the mountain ridge of the Taurus); its greatest width
is less than ten thousand.4
519 C, 9-16 As has been noted, the distance from the gulf of Issus to gulf of Issus, Gulf of İskenderun
the Indian ocean in the east is around forty thousand stades, Indian ocean = Bay of Bengal
Calculation of 30,000 stades and it is another thirty thousand from the western point at
for east–west dimension of
2nd section of northern Asia the Pillars to Issus.5 The recess of the gulf of Issus is only a
little farther east (if at all) than Amisus.6 The distance from Amisus, Samsun (n. Tky.)
Amisus to the Hyrcanian country is around ten thousand Hyrcanian country, n. Iran
stades, parallel with the said line from Issus to the Indians.
What is left is the said length,7 going eastward, of the section length = from n. Iran to Bay of
Bengal
now being described, namely thirty thousand stades.
519 C, 16-26 Again, the greatest width of the lived-in world is around
thirty thousand stades. Given that the lived-in world is
[ 1 ] Strabo’s voyage on the Nile (early 20s BCE): 117 C, 35–118 C, 14n. [ 5 ] 87 C, 29–88 C, 5; 105 C, 33–106 C, 10 (where 70,000 stades is given as the total
[ 2 ] Patrocles’s work is no longer available to us. It seems possible that Patrocles east–west dimension of the lived-in world, and 30,000 from the westernmost
was referring to the feasibility of making the journey by river (rather than by point to Issus).
sea): Patrocles is cited by Eratosthenes (509 C, 11-25) for the information that [ 6 ] “Farther east than” = “on a more easterly meridian than.”
the Oxus river allows imports from India to the Hyrcanian (Caspian) sea. [ 7 ] I.e., from Hyrcanian sea to eastern ocean (519 C, 3-9).
[ 3 ] Northern side of 2nd section: 511 C, 9-17.
[ 4 ] Length (east–west dimension): 519 C, 9-16. Width (north–south dimension):
519 C, 16-26.
605
4.1. Northern Asia
Calculation of 10,000 stades c hlamydoid in shape, this would be near enough the distance chlamydoid, cloak-shaped
for north–south dimension of
2nd section along the meridian drawn through the Hyrcanian sea and Hyrcanian sea, Caspian Sea
the Persian sea (if the length of the lived-in world is seventy Persian sea, Persian Gulf
from t here to the mouth of the Persian sea, another stretch of Artemita, ?Karastel (Iraq)
the same distance; the same again (or only a l ittle less) to the
region opposite the end of Ethiopia;1 then the remainder of
the said width of the lived-in world,2 from the inmost point of
the Hyrcanian sea to its mouth,3 would be as much as I said.4
519 C, 26-31 Given that this section of the world tapers to the east,
its shape might be likened to a cook’s knife, with the moun-
tain range following a straight line and being conceived of as
the upper edge of the knife, and with the coastline from the
mouth of the Hyrcanian as far as Tamarum5 being conceived
of as the other edge, ending with a curved and tapering line. |
519 C, 32–520 C, 10 Mention must be made of some strange tales told about 11.11.8
606
Third Section
520 C, 22-32 Since I opted to describe the northern parts of Asia first (as Taurus, mt. system from sw. 11.12.1
Turkey to ne. India
formed by the Taurus and called “inside the Taurus”),1 and
these parts include [nations] wholly or mostly within the moun-
tains themselves,2 and since the ones farther east than the Cas- Caspian Gates, ?Sar Darreh
pass (Iran)
pian Gates are easier to describe because of their savagery, and
it does not matter whether they are categorized with this clima clima, band of latitude
side the Antitaurus, which h ouses Comana among the “Upper Antitaurus, mts. in cen. + e.
Turkey
Cappadocians” (as they are called).6 This latter ends in Cata-
onia, but the Amanus range continues to the Euphrates and
to Melitene, where Commagene lies parallel to Cappadocia.7
521 C, 6-12 The ranges on the far side of the Euphrates river are exten- far side of Euphrates = east of
Euphrates r.
sions (although interrupted by the river) of the ranges just
mentioned, but they are more pronounced in terms of height
607
4.1. Northern Asia
521 C, 13-20 The Euphrates is the larger river and, with its meander-
ing course, passes through more territory. From its sources
in the northern part of Taurus, the Euphrates flows west-
ward through what is called “Great” Armenia until it reaches
“Little” Armenia, which the river has on its right, while it
has Acilisene on its left. Then it turns southward, coinciding
with the Cappadocian border as it curves around. Leaving the
Cappadocian and Commagenian borders on the right, and
Acilisene and Sophene (of Great Armenia) on the left, it flows
into Syria and makes another turn, toward Babylonia and the Syria, n. + e. present-day Syria
the Euphrates, with which it forms Mesopotamia. Then it, Mesopotamia, e. Syria,
se. Turkey, n. Iraq
too, issues into the same gulf. The sources of the Euphrates
and Tigris are some two thousand five hundred stades apart. |
521 C, 26–522 C, 4 There are many subdivisions of the Taurus to the north. 11.12.4
One of them belongs to what is called the “Antitaurus” (it Antitaurus, mts. in cen. +
e. Turkey
is given this name where it encloses Sophene in a gorge,
which lies between it and the Taurus). The next range north
of the Antitaurus—on the far side of the Euphrates and in far side of Euphrates = north of
Euphrates r.
the region of Little Armenia—is large and has a multiplicity
of parts: one section is called the “Paryadres,” another sec- Paryadres, mts. in ne. Turkey
tion the “Moschian mountains,” and other sections by other Moschians, mts. in ne. Turkey,
s. Georgia
names. This range contains all Armenia as far as the Iberians
and Albanians. Then, to the east, t here are other mountains
looming over the Caspian shore, taking us up to Atropatian
Media and Great Media. They call all this part of the moun-
Caspian Gates, ?Sar Darreh
tain range (and its continuation to the Caspian Gates and still pass (Iran)
farther east. where it reaches Aria) “Parachoathras.” Such are Parachoathras, Alburz + Talish
the names of the northern ranges. mts.
far side of Euphrates = east of
522 C, 4-14 The southern mountains on the far side of the Euphrates Euphrates r.
are t hose stretching east from Cappadocia and Commagene. Taurus/Gordyaeans, mts. in
The first part is called in its own right “Taurus,” cutting off se. Turkey
608
Third Section
Tigranocerta.) Then the range gets steeper and is called the Nisibis, Nuysaybin (Tky., on
border with Syr.)
“Niphates” (somewhere on the southern edge of these moun-
Tigranocerta, Arzan (Tky.)
tains are the sources of the Tigris). Then, from the Niphates,
Niphates, mts. south of Van
the mountain ridge goes on farther and farther, forming the l. (Tky.)
Zagrium range, which cuts Media off from Babylonia. A fter Zagrium, Zagros, mts. in n. Iraq,
Zagrium, above Babylonia, are the mountains belonging to w. Iran
for the part containing the metropolis of Ecbatana, a g reat Ecbatana, Hamadan (Iran)
city and the capital of the Median empire. She is now used
by the Parthians as their capital—although their kings spend
only the summer there (for Media is cold) and have their win-
Seleucia-on-Tigris, Tell Omar
ter capital at Seleucia-on-the-Tigris, near Babylon. (Iraq)
522 C, 32–523 C, 19 The other part is Atropatian Media,4 which takes its
ATROPATIAN MEDIA name from its leader, Atropates. Atropates prevented this
nw. Iran, s. Azerbaijan
territory (although part of G reat Media) from falling u nder
Macedonian sway; he was proclaimed king, and claimed the
independent territory as his own. Even today, the royal line
[1] Classification of Media and Armenia as “inside the Taurus”: 490 C, 13–491 C, 5.
[2] I.e., the parallel running through the Caspian Gates?
[3] The full description of Great Media is postponed u ntil 524 C, 9–526 C, 33.
[4] The present-d ay name “Azerbaijan” is derived from the ancient name
“Atropatian.”
609
4.1. Northern Asia
Media, north of both; and it lies parallel to the region around both = ?Matiana + Great Media
the recess of the Hyrcanian sea (and, in the south, Matiana). Hyrcanian sea, Caspian Sea
the plain . . . *1 in the rock fortress of Vera, which Antony M. Antony besieged Vera
(?Zohak Qal'eh, Iran), 36 BCE
besieged during his campaign against the Parthians. This
fortress is two thousand four hundred stades distant from the
Araxes river, which marks the boundary between Armenia Araxes, Aras r.
Dellius (1st c. BCE) and Atropatene. This is according to Dellius, the friend of
Antony, who wrote up Antony’s campaign against the Par-
thians and who was present on the campaign as a commander.
523 C, 26-34 While the rest of the territory is naturally blessed, the territory = Atropatian Media
[ 1 ] Radt (vol. 3, critical apparatus on 523 C, line 20) hypothesizes two gaps in the
text ( . . . *) partly to get around the problem that Gazaca (?Leilan, Iran) was
in fact the winter residence. Strabo may simply have erred: he similarly but
inversely gives the summer residence of the Parthian kings as their winter one:
524 C, 9-14n.
[ 2 ] Strabo implies that some nations in Atropatian Media originated in Great
Media and Great Armenia.
610
Third Section
Armenian king Artavasdes. Antony made Artavasdes (who Artavasdes was M. Antony’s
ally in unsuccessful Roman war
was conspiring against him) his adviser and head of military against Parthia, 36–34 BCE;
strategy. Antony meted out punishment but only later on, blamed by Antony for Roman
defeat and taken captive, 34
that fellow = Artavasdes after both he himself and that fellow had caused the Romans BCE; held in Alexandria and
executed after Antony’s defeat
much woe. That fellow made it a journey of eight thousand in civil war against Octavian
stades (more than twice the straight-line distance), via moun- (future Augustus), 31 BCE
REAT MEDIA
G domination, ruled all Asia. Later on, under the rule of Asty-
w. Iran
ages, it was itself deprived of its extensive power by Cyrus and
the Persians. It nevertheless preserved much of its traditional
significance, with Ecbatana being used as a winter capital by Ecbatana, Hamadan (Iran)
ing Laodicia, Rhagian Apamia, and Rhagae itself, founded by Rhagae, Ravy (Iran)
[ 1 ] Strabo slips. Ecbatana was the summer capital, as he is well aware: 522 C, 28-32;
524 C, 15-23.
[ 2 ] 523 C, 26-34.
611
4.1. Northern Asia
climate: this is the case with the mountains above Ecbatana, Ecbatana, Hamadan (Iran)
the region of Rhagae and the Caspian Gates, and the north in Caspian Gates, ?Sar Darreh
pass (Iran)
general from t here to Matiana and Armenia. Below the Cas-
pian Gates, in the flatlands and valleys, Media is extremely
fertile and produces everything except olives (any place they
do grow, they are hard and dry). Media, like Armenia, pro-
vides excellent h orse pasture. There is a meadow t here called
“Hippobotus” (Horse-pasture), which is crossed by t hose making
the journey from Persia and Babylon to the Caspian Gates. Persia, w. + cen. Iran
It is said that, in the Persian era, fifty thousand mares grazed Babylon, Tell Amran (Iraq)
there—they comprised the royal herds. Some say that Nesaean
horses, preferred by the kings because of their size and quality,
originate from h ere (others say they originated in Armenia).
These horses, and the h orses now called “Parthian,” share
characteristics that distinguish them from Helladic horses
and other h orses with which we are familiar. We give the name
“Median” to the type of grass that gives the horses such excel-
lent nourishment (because it is abundant in Media). The juice
from silphium produced in the territory is also called “Median.”
It can at times be not much inferior to and at times can surpass
Cyrenaean juice, e ither because of the better environment, or
because it is a different species, or b
ecause people extract and
prepare it in such a way that it can be laid down and kept for
when needed. | Such is the nature of the territory.2 territory = Great Media, w. Iran 11.13.8
called the “Median Gate,” via Sigriana, to the Caspian Gates, Zagrus, Zagros, mts. in n. Iraq,
w. Iran
a distance of four thousand one hundred stades. Reports of
Median Gate, ?Taq-i Girra pass
its tribute payments are consonant with this size and with (Iran)
the territory’s resources. While Cappadocia made annual pay- Caspian Gates, ?Sar Darreh
ment to the Persians of one thousand five hundred h orses, pass (Iran)
[ 1 ] Seleucus Nicator (Conqueror) became king over much of the eastern territory
originally acquired by Alexander the G
reat (late 4th c. BCE). His successors lost
territory progressively throughout the 2nd c. BCE.
[ 2 ] 524 C, 9–525 C, 15.
612
Third Section
t erritory being similar, but that the Medes w ere the role
models, both for these p eople and still e arlier for the Per- these people = Armenians
sians who overthrew them and succeeded to the dominion of them = Medes
nians and the Susians. When they overthrew the Medes, they
acquired some parts that w ere attached to Media. However,
the customs of the conquered appeared so venerable to the
conquerors, and so suited to royal estate, that they decided,
instead of going about in lightweight and scanty clothing, to
dress like women in swaths of clothing. |
526 C, 12-20 Some say that Medea spread this dress style when she— Medea, Colchian princess of 11.13.10
Greek myth
just like Jason—ruled the area, covering her face when she
went out in lieu of the king; that the Jasonia, hero shrines
much revered by the natives, are memorials to Jason (also,
there is a huge mountain above the Caspian Gates on the left Caspian Gates, ?Sar Darreh
pass (Iran)
called “Jasonium”), while the dress and the name of the ter-
Jasonium mountain, Kuh-i
ritory are memorials to Medea (although it is also said that Damavand
Medus, her son, succeeded to the empire and that the ter-
ritory was named a fter him). Corroboration is provided by
the Jasonia in Armenia, by the name of that territory, and by
several other t hings that I will discuss.1 |
526 C, 21-30 It is Median custom to choose the bravest man as king. 11.13.11
(However, this is not for all the p eople but only t hose who live
in the mountains.) It is rather more the custom for the kings
to have many wives. The latter is a custom for t hose Medes
who live in the mountains and indeed for all the people. It is
not permitted to have fewer than five. In the same way, p eople
say that the women count it an honor that very many . . . *,2
and a catastrophe to have fewer than five. While the rest of
Media is naturally blessed, the mountainous region in the
north is miserable. P eople subsist on tree fruit. They make
cakes out of chopped-up dried apples and loaves out of
[ 1 ] In the traditional version of the Greek myth, Medea helps Jason defeat her
father in Colchis, then returns with Jason to Greece. The traditional version
was reworked a fter the conquests of Alexander the Great (late 4th c. BCE) to
represent Jason and Medea as continuing eastward: 530, 18–531 C, 26n.
[ 2 ] The words in the manuscripts (see Radt, vol. 3, critical apparatus on 526 C, line
25) seem to say something like “the women count it an honor to have multiple
husbands”—but scholars have balked at this notion and emended the text.
613
4.1. Northern Asia
ARMENIA Taurus, which cuts it off from the w hole region called “Meso- Taurus, mts. of se. Turkey
e. Turkey, s. Georgia,
w. Azerbaijan, nw. Iran,
potamia” (Between-rivers) between the Euphrates and the Tigris.
present-day Armenia The eastern parts reach G reat Media and Atropatene. In the
north are the Parachoathras mountains (inland from the Cas- Parachoathras, Alburz + Talish
mts.
pian sea), the Albanians and the Iberians, and the Caucasus,
which encircles t hese nations and connect with the Arme-
nians, and also with the Moschian and Colchian mountains, Moschians, mts. in ne. Turkey,
s. Georgia
taking us up to the “Tibaranians,” as they are called. In the
west are these nations 2 and the Paryadres and Scydises, which Paryadres, Scydises, mt. ranges
of ne. Turkey
take us down to Little Armenia and to the Euphrates river
basin, separating Armenia from Cappadocia and Comma-
gene. |
527 C, 9-15 The Euphrates has its sources in the north of the Taurus. 11.14.2
614
Third Section
Gordyene, is the Niphates, then there’s the Abus, whence the Niphates, mts. south of Van l.
(Tky.)
Euphrates and the Araxes flow (the Euphrates toward the
Abus, Bingöl Dağ (Tky.)
west, the Araxes t oward the east). Then the Nibarus stretches
Araxes, Aras r.
as far as Media. |
527 C, 29-33 The course of the Euphrates has been described.1 The 11.14.3
Araxene plain and flows into the Caspian sea.2 | Artaxata, Artašat (Arm.)
528 C, 1-9 Within Armenia itself there are many mountain ranges; 11.14.4
Cyrus river, and then Gogarene. All this territory abounds in Cyrus, Kura/Mtkvari r.
crops, cultivated trees, evergreens, even olive trees. Phauene Gogarene, Gugark' (s. Geo.,
n. Arm.)
is a district of Armenia, as also Comisene and Orchistene,
with its many cavalry horses.
528 C, 9-20 Chorzene and Cambisene lie farthest north and (given that
they reach the Caucasus mountains, Iberia, and Colchis) they
have the highest snowfall. It is said that frequently, when the
snowfall is heavy in the high mountain passes, entire bands of
travelers can become trapped in the snow; that, with a view
to just such a catastrophe, people carry sticks that they push
through to the surface to get air and to alert passersby and
obtain help. It is said that hollow balls of ice are formed in the
snow and that t hese contain good w ater, which, if the coating
is cracked open, can be drunk; that there are creatures that
Apollonides (early 1st c. BCE) self-generate under the snow, creatures that Apollonides calls
Theophanes (1st c. BCE) “worms” and Theophanes calls “larvae.” They say that such
self-generation of creatures is like the self-generation of gnats
from the burning embers in mineworks. |
528 C, 21-31 History tells us that Armenia, once small, was enlarged 11.14.5
615
4.1. Northern Asia
being the Phasis and Lycus, which flow into the Pontic sea Phasis, Rioni r.
“Lycus”); the Cyrus and Araxes, which flow into the Caspian; Cyrus, Kura/Mtkvari r.
and the Euphrates and Tigris, which flow into the Erythra. | Araxes, Aras r.
There are also large lakes throughout Armenia. One of them Erythra, Persian Gulf 11.14.8
is “Mantiana,” which, translated, means “Blue.” P eople say Mantiana, Urmia l. (Iran)
that it is the biggest lake after the Maeotis; its water is salty; it
stretches as far as Atropatia and has salt flats. Arsene, which Arsene/Thonitis, Van l. (Tky.)
they also call “Thonitis,”3 contains nitron and causes clothes nitron = natron (sodium
chloride)
to rip and tear; its w ater is consequently non-potable. The
Tigris starts out from the Niphates mountains and flows Niphates, mts. south of Van l.
(Tky.)
through Arsene, maintaining a distinct stream b ecause
of the swiftness (from which it takes its name, the Medes
calling an arrow a tigris). The Tigris has many types of fish,
whereas the fish in the lake are of one type only. At the far
end of the lake, the river enters a cleft and drops a consider-
able distance underground, rising again at Chalonitis. From
[ 1 ] Strabo perhaps emends his earlier statement (527 C, 29-33n, where he gives
the name as “Azara” rather than as “Arxata”).
[ 2 ] Augustus Caesar initiated the war in which Artagerae was besieged (3–4 CE).
Gaius Caesar (Augustus’s a dopted son) was entrusted with the war and was
present at the siege but died from wounds sustained there (early 4 CE).
[ 3 ] Strabo later corrects the name (746 C, 23-29, where he gives the name as
“Thopitis”). Emendation h ere of the name is unnecessary: Radt, vol. 3, critical
apparatus on 529 C, line 18.
616
Third Section
t here, the T
igris flows forthwith t oward Opis and t oward what Opis, Tell Mujeili' (Iraq)
Hipparchus (2nd c. BCE) flows through Babylon, as I said in my critique of Eratosthenes Babylon, Tell Amran (Iraq)
and Hipparchus.1 |
529 C, 31–530 C, 12 In Hyspiratis at Caballa, there are the gold mines to which 11.14.9
Alexander sent Meno with his soldiers . . . * by the locals. Armenia was controlled
by Persia, 6th–4th c. BCE;
There are other mines, including mines of what is called san- conquered by Alexander the
dyx, which they also call “Armenian color” (like purple). The Great, late 4th c. BCE
resources that, when Pompey imposed on Tigranes (father of Pompey subjugated Tigranes,
king of Armenia, to Rome,
talent, largest unit in Artavasdes) a tax of six thousand talents of silver, Tigranes 66 BCE
Greek accounting system;
1 talent = 6,000 drachmas paid it to the Roman forces forthwith, at the rates of fifty
drachmas per soldier, a thousand drachmas per centurion,
and one talent per each cavalry officer and army commander. |
530 C, 13-17 Theophanes gives the size of the territory as one hundred territory = Armenia 11.14.11
Theophanes (1st c. BCE) “schoeni” in breadth and double that in length, assuming forty
stades per schoenus. He exaggerated. It would be nearer the
truth to take as its length the figure he gave for its breadth and
to take as its breadth half of that or only a l ittle more. Such is
the disposition, and power, of Armenia. |
530 C, 18–531 C, 1 The story about the origin of this people is as follows. 11.14.12
Armenus, from the city of Armenium in Thessaly, between Armenus, Jason, heroes of
Greek myth, voyaged in Argo
Pherae and Larisa on the Boeba, accompanied Jason on his from Greece to Colchis
campaign into Armenia, as I have said.2 Those associated with
Cyrsilus the Pharsalian and with Medius the Larisaean3 (men
who were present on Alexander’s campaign) say that Armenia
is named a fter him; some of Armenus’s companions settled Acilisene,
[ 1 ] 80 C, 20-28.
[ 2 ] 503 C, 24-30.
[ 3 ] “Those associated with Cyrsilus the Pharsalian and with Medius the Larisaean”
is an idiomatic expression, meaning simply Cyrsilus and Medius. Cyrsilus and
Medius (late 4th c. BCE), and probably other writers under Alexander, were
responsible for the variant of the myth in which Jason, instead of stopping at
Colchis, continues into the Caucasus and farther north and east, establishing
a precedent for Alexander the Great: 495 C, 28–496 C, 3; 498 C, 26–499 C, 9;
503 C, 24-30; 505 C, 28–506 C, 3; 526 C, 12-20.
617
4.1. Northern Asia
settled Vitia and one group is said to have settled inland from
the Armenians, above the Abus and the Nibarus, which are Abus, Bingöl Dağ (Tky.)
part of the Taurus. Of these two, Abus is near the road leading
into Ecbatana past the temple to Baris. It is said that certain Ecbatana, Hamadan (Iran)
618
Third Section
the Euphrates and, using all his might, even took Syria and
Phoenicia. After reaching such exalted heights, Tigranes
founded a city near Iberia, between it and the Euphrates
crossing. He called the city “Tigranocerta” and assembled
there the population of twelve Greek cities. Lucullus (who Lucullus attacked Tigranocerta,
69 BCE
fought the war against Mithridates) moved against him pre-
emptively, sent each settler back to his own home, attacked Artavasdes succeeded, ca. 55
BCE; allied with M. Antony in
and razed the half-completed city, leaving a tiny hamlet, and unsuccessful Roman war against
Parthia, 36–34 BCE; taken
drove Tigranes out of Syria and Phoenicia. Artavasdes suc- captive by Antony, 34 BCE;
ceeded Tigranes and did well for a while, as long as he was a executed, 31 BCE
Antony lost civil war against
friend of the Romans, but he betrayed Antony to the Parthi- Octavian (future Augustus) at
ans during the war against them and paid the price. He was Actium, 31 BCE
619
4.1. Northern Asia
of the Halys; to the west by the nations of the Paphlagonians Halys, Kızıl Irmak
[ 1 ] At the time that Strabo writes, Rome has just (18 CE) installed a new Armenian which the w hole of Cappadocia has become Roman. While Strabo has had time
king. to adjust his mindset in connection with Pontic Cappadocia (540 C, 30–541 C,
[ 2 ] Scholars have seen Strabo’s switch to Cappadocia as too abrupt and have hy- 14n), the recent date of events in G reat Cappadocia means that Strabo still
pothesized an introductory passage in Strabo’s original manuscript that was largely deals with its historical incarnation as an independent kingdom, al-
later omitted by a copyist. The jarring transition may, however, simply reflect though aware (534 C, 8-20n) that it is now politically linked with the rest of the
sudden changes at the time of writing, namely the death of the king of G reat Asian peninsula.
Cappadocia (17 CE) and the absorption (18 CE) of the kingdom into the Roman [ 4 ] Eastern border with Colchis/Little Armenia, Great Armenia: 548 C, 27-34; 526 C,
provincial system. 34–527 C, 9. Western border with Paphlagonians, etc.: 566 C, 23-30. Euxine (Black
[ 3 ] Roman absorption of Great Cappadocia, together with the fall of Pontic Cap- Sea) coast: 546 C, 30–548 C, 27.
padocia to the Romans more than 80 years e arlier, completes the p
rocess by
620
Third Section
by Ariarathes, the first man to be called “king of the Cap- Ariarathes ruled ca. 255–ca.
220 BCE
padocians.” |
534 C, 8-20 Cappadocia is effectively the isthmus of a huge peninsula 12.1.3
confined between two seas: the Issian gulf (as far as Rough Issian gulf, Gulf of İskenderun
(Med.)
Cilicia) and the Euxine (as far as Sinope and the Tibarenian
Euxine, Black Sea
coastline). We label the w hole peninsula west of the Cappado-
Herodotus (5th c. BCE) cians as being “this side of the isthmus.” Herodotus labels the
peninsula as being “this side of the Halys,” all of it ruled by this side of Halys = west of Kızıl
Irmak
Croesus, called by Herodotus king of the nations this side of the
Halys river. (Men of today, however, call the area within the Croesus ruled Lydia, 6th c. BCE
Taurus “Asia,” giving it the same name as the overall
continent.)1 Included within it, beginning with the nations it = peninsula
When the Macedonians took over, they oversaw (willingly Macedonians, late 4th c. BCE
[ 1 ] “Men of today” are the Romans, who refer to the Asian peninsula as “Asia” (e.g., Mysians, 628 C, 8–628 C, 30. Troad, Aeolians, Lydians, Ionians, Carians, and
540 C, 14-26n; 561 C, 33–562 C, 9n; 594 C, 2-8) or sometimes as “Asia within the others: 581 C, 1–681 C, 24. Strabo frequently laments that the boundaries
Taurus” (e.g., 577 C, 1-10n; 641 C, 24–642 C, 1n); or sometimes simply use the between t hese n
ations are porous, making his account difficult to structure.
expression “within the Taurus” (e.g., 624 C, 9-22n). T hese terms include the [ 3 ] Pontus, or Pontic Cappadocia (n. Turkey): 540 C, 30–562 C, 20.
isthmus comprising Cappadocia, as well as the peninsula proper. The expres- [ 4 ] Melitene, Cataonia: 535 C, 4–537 C, 5. Cappadocian Cilicia, Mazaca: 537 C, 29–
sion “men of today”: 508 C, 10-18n. 539 C, 26. Tyanitis, Tyana: 537 C, 18-22. Garsauritis: 537 C, 11-17.
[ 2 ] Paphlagonians, 544 C, 5–546 C, 25; 561 C, 33–563 C, 3. Phrygians, Lycao-
nians, 566 C, 31–569 C, 30; 576 C, 26–581 C, 1. Bithynians, 563 C, 10–566 C, 22.
621
4.1. Northern Asia
and Cybistra2 as far as Derbe, which belonged to Antipater Cybistra, Ereğli (Tky.)
the pirate. Granted to Archelaus was the Elaeussa region of Derbe, Kerti Hüyük (Tky.)
Rough Cilicia and the whole area that had supported piracy.3 | Elaeussa, Ayaş (Tky.)
535 C, 4-11 Melitene is similar to Commagene in that it—alone in 12.2.1
is situated Comana, with its temple to Enyo (the deity that Comana, Şar (Tky.)
those p eople call “Ma”). Comana is a significant city, with a those people = Cataonians
Sarus river runs past this city and crosses, through the con- Sarus, Seyhan Nehri
622
Third Section
all rocky, with a fissure running through it, quite deep, and
narrow enough for a dog or hare to jump across. This is the
river’s channel, full to the brim and looking like a wide ditch.
Because of its twists and turns, its extreme contraction and
the depth of its gully, a sound like thunder is the first thing
that strikes you from afar.
536 C, 20-29 The Pyramus, in its descent through the mountains, car- Pyramus, Ceyhan Nehri
ries so much silt (some from Cataonia and some from the Cili-
cian plains) into the sea that there was even an oracle issued
about it, which is given as follows: it will come about, for men of
future times, that the Pyramus, with its broad stream, / w ill silt up
the sacred shore and reach Cyprus. What happens here is similar
to what happens in Egypt, where the Nile with its sediment
Herodotus (5th c. BCE) continually creates dry land out of the sea. Herodotus accord-
poet = Homer (8th c. BCE) ingly called Egypt a gift of the river, and the poet described
Pharus as being in the open sea (this was the situation formerly,
but it now lies close to Egypt). |
536 C, 30-34 See 537 C, 17 ff. | 12.2.5
537 C, 1-5 The Cataonian plain has no city (nor does Melitene), but 12.2.6
[ 1 ] Strabo probably accessed the upper reaches of the Pyramus (Ceyhan Nehri)
via the Euphrates–Ephesus road: 663 C, 19-33nn.
623
4.1. Northern Asia
which in our times was the t reasury of Sisines, who seized the Sisines fought to establish claim
to Cappadocia, 41–36 BCE
Cappadocian throne. Cadena—a royal residence constructed
like a city—was also a possession of Sisines.
537 C, 11-17 On the borders with Lycaonia is the villageopolis of
Garsauira (said to have once been the territory’s capital). In Garsauira, Aksaray (Tky.)
Morimene is the temple to Zeus-in-Venasa, with its popu- Venasa, Avanos (Tky.)
the priest at Comana, and ranks second to him in honor. | Comana, Şar (Tky.)
This passage is traditionally The third priesthood is that of Zeus . . . *, inferior to this 12.2.5
removed by scholars from its
manuscript position (536 C, 30- but nevertheless of some importance. There is a reservoir
34) and inserted here the size of a lake in circumference, containing salt w ater and
rimmed with cliffs so sheer that the descent is by ladder. It
is said that neither does the water level rise nor is there any-
where an obvious outlet. |
537 C, 18-22 Only two administrative districts have cities. Tyanitis has 12.2.7
TYANITIS Tyana, lying at the foot of the Taurus by the Cilician Gates Tyana/Taurean Eusebia,
Kemerhisar (Tky.)
(which provide very easy access, used by all alike, into Cilicia
Cilician Gates, Gülek Bogazi
and Syria). Tyana is called “Taurean” Eusebia.2 While Tya- (Tky.)
nitis is good and level in most parts, Tyana herself sits atop a
beautifully walled Semiramis mound.3
537 C, 22-28 Not far from Tyana, and closer in to the mountains, are the
CASTABALA, CYBISTRA towns of Castabala and Cybistra. In Castabala is the t emple to Castabala, Bodrum Kalesi (Tky.)
“Perasian” Artemis, where priestesses are said to walk bare- Cybistra, Ereğli (Tky.)
foot through hot embers without feeling any pain. Some
people set in this location the same story4 of Orestes and the
goddess Tauropolus, arguing that the goddess was called “Pera- Tauropolus = Artemis
sian” b
ecause she was brought perathen (from afar).
537 C, 29–538 C, 5 While the city of Tyana is in the administrative district of
Tyanitis, one of the ten mentioned above5—I do not include
624
Third Section
in this number the later acquisitions of Castabala and Cy- Elaeussa, Ayaş (Tky.)
bistra and the places in Rough Cilicia, where the lush little Augustus granted Elaeussa to
Archelaus, king of Cappadocia,
island of Elaeussa was made into a significant settlement by 20 BCE
Archelaus, who spent a great deal of time there—Mazaca (the Mazaca/Eusebia, Kayseri (Tky.)
CAPPADOCIAN CILICIA nation’s capital)1 is in what is called “Cilicia.” She, too, is called She = Mazaca
“Eusebia,” with the further qualification “Argaean,”2 since she Argaeus, Erciyes Dağ (Tky.)
lies at the foot of Argaeus, the highest of all mountains, whose Pontic sea, Black Sea
peak—from which both the Pontic and Issian seas are visible Issian sea, Gulf of İskenderun
on clear days, according to t hose few who make the climb—is (Med.)
[ 1 ] Mazaca (Kayseri, cen. Tky.) is on the long road from the Euphrates to Ephesus:
663 C, 19-33nn.
[ 2 ] As opposed to “Taurean” Eusebia (Kemerhisar, Tky.): 537 C, 18-22n.
625
4.1. Northern Asia
inland sea and creating within it some small islands like the Halys, Kızıl Irmak
626
Third Section
539 C, 27–540 C, 1 In size, the territory is some one thousand eight hundred territory = Great Cappadocia 12.2.10
stades in width, from Pontus to the Taurus; and around three width = north–south dimension
thousand [stades] in length, from Lycaonia and Phrygia to the length = east–west dimension
their victory over Antiochus, they made friendships and al- Romans forced Antiochus,
Macedonian king of Syria, to
liances with nations and kings. While this honor was given withdraw from Asian peninsula,
to other kings in their own right, it was given to the Cap- 188 BCE
padocian jointly with his nation.2 When the royal line was
extinguished, the Romans agreed, in accordance with the
treaty of friendship and alliance with the nation, that the
people should be autonomous; but the people sent ambassa-
dors asking that they be excused from their freedom (saying
that they were not able to bear it) and requesting that a king
be appointed for them. The Romans w ere amazed that any
people would refuse freedom in this way, but nevertheless left
it up to the Cappadocians to elect from among themselves Ariarathes’s line died out,
96/95 BCE; Ariobarzanes ruled
whoever they wanted. They chose Ariobarzanes. When his 96/95–63/62 BCE; his line died
line was extinguished after three generations, Archelaus3 was out, 42 BCE
627
4.1. Northern Asia
540 C, 30–541 C, 14 Mithridates Eupator established himself as king of Pontus.3 Mithridates Eupator ruled 12.3.1
Pontus, 120–66 BCE
PONTUS He possessed the territory defined by the Halys, as far as the
n. Turkey, Georgia
Tibaranians and Armenians; and, of the territory that lay inside Halys = west of Kızıl Irmak
“inside the Halys,” that which stretched to Amastris and Amastris, Amasra (Tky.)
ing the region of Armenia and the region around Colchis to Armenia = Little Armenia,
ne. Turkey
the powerful overlords that had fought at his side, and split-
ting the rest into eleven states, which he added to Bithynia,
so as to form one province out of two. (Meanwhile, Pompey
handed over some of the inner Paphlagonians to be ruled
by the scions of Pylaemenes, just as he handed the Gala-
tians over to the hereditary tetrarchs).5 Subsequently, the
Roman rulers made various other arrangements, setting up
kings and overlords, freeing some cities, putting some into
the hands of overlords and granting o thers to the Roman
people.
541 C, 14-16 As I go through each place in turn, let me state conditions
as they now are, touching a little on former conditions where
to do so is appropriate.6 Let me start with Heraclia, which is
the westernmost of these places.7 |
left is the coast following on from Byzantium. It belongs Euxine, Black Sea
to the Thracians and is called the “Left-Hand Side of the
[ 1 ] Archelaus, having been appointed to the Cappadocian throne (41 BCE), secured [ 4 ] Pontic coastline (n. Turkey): 542 C, 31–548 C, 25. Colchis (w. Georgia): 497 C,
his claim a few years later (36 BCE). 27–499 C, 13. Region of L ittle Armenia (ne. Turkey): 548 C, 26–556 C, 10. Pontic
[ 2 ] Cilicia as a w
hole: 668 C, 7–676 C, 28 (see esp. 671 C, 8-20). interior (e. + n. Turkey): 556 C, 11–561 C, 32.
[ 3 ] Roman absorption (after 66 BCE) of the kingdom of Pontus, the heart of which [ 5 ] Inner Paphlagonia (n. Turkey): 561 C, 33–563 C, 3. Galatia (w. cen. Turkey): 566 C,
lay east of the Halys river (Kızıl Irmak), made the river redundant as a boundary. 31–569 C, 30.
Despite Strabo’s e arlier claim that the 4th section of n. Asia lies west of the Halys [ 6 ] Some of the provinces, kingdoms, and territories that feature in Strabo’s ensu-
(492 C, 10-16), he now proceeds to include within this section all of Pontus, on ing description were no longer current as Strabo was writing.
both sides of the Halys. Cf. 533 C, 5–534 C, 7nn. [ 7 ] The description of Heraclia (Ereğli, Tky.) and places to its east is postponed
until 542 C, 31–543 C, 6.
628
Pontic Coast of Fourth Section + Hinterland
MARITIME BITHYNIA viously being Mysians) got this name when the Thracian
nw. Turkey
Bithynians and Thynians sent out colonies t here. The evi-
dence given for the Bithynian nation is that even now t here
are said to be some “Maedobithynians” in Thrace. The evi-
dence for the Thynians is the rugged coast of Thynias near Thynias, coastline nr. İğneada
(Tky.)
Apollonia and Salmydessus. I surmise, too, that the Bebry-
Apollonia, Sozopol (Bul.)
eople = Bithynians and
p cians, who colonized Mysia before these people, were Thra-
Thynians Salmydessus, Midye (Tky.)
cian. It has already been noted4 that the Mysians were them-
selves sent as colonists from t hose Thracians now known as
“Moesians.”5 | That is what is said about them. 12.3.4
629
4.1. Northern Asia
542 C, 17-30 Historians say that the Cauconians lived along the stretch 12.3.5
nius river, with Tieium as their city. Some say they were Scyth- Tieium, Hisarönü (Tky.)
in other ways, too, since she has sent out colonies (Cher-
ronesus is one of them, as also Callatis). Heraclia used to be
independent, then she was ruled for some time by tyrants, Heraclia independent
6th–4th c. BCE; under tyrants,
then she won back her freedom and was l ater ruled by kings. 4th–3rd c. BCE; free, 3rd–1st c.
When Heraclia came under Roman control, a Roman colony BCE; subject to king of Pontus,
73–65 BCE; to Romans, 65–ca.
was housed in a section of the city and its territory. Adiatorix 40 BCE (took in a Roman colony,
46/45 BCE); to Adiatorix, ca.
(son of the Galatian tetrarch, Domneclius) was given by Ant- 40–31 BCE (colonists massacred,
ony the section of the city that belonged to the Heracliotes. 32/31 BCE)
Not long before the Actian war, Adiatorix attacked the Ro-
mans by night and killed them (with Antony’s permission,
or so he claimed). After the victory at Actium, Adiatorix was
paraded in triumph and then killed, together with his son.
The city is part of the province of Pontus, which has been
joined to Bithynia. |
543 C, 7-19 Between Chalcedon and Heraclia are several rivers, includ- 12.3.7
ing the Psillis and the Calpas, and the Sangarius (which the Psillis, Göksu
poet = Homer (8th c. BCE) poet mentions). The Sangarius has its sources at the village Calpas, Ilaflı Dere
of Sangia, some one hundred and fifty stades from Pessinus; Sangarius, Sakarya r.
it passes through much of Phrygia Epictetus and a part of
Bithynia, so that it is only a little more than three hundred
stades from Nicomedia at the point where the Gallus river Gallus, Mudurnu Çayı
flows into it, from its sources at Modra in Phrygia-on-the- Modra, Mudurnu (Tky.)
630
Pontic Coast of Fourth Section + Hinterland
outlet marks the border with Bithynia. The island of Thynias Thynias, Kefken Adası (Tk.
island)
lies off this stretch of coast. Aconite is found in Heracliotis.
Heracliotis = region of Heraclia
The city itself is some one thousand five hundred stades dis- (Ereğli, Tky.)
tant from the Chalcedonian T emple, and five hundred [stades]
from the Sangarius. |
543 C, 20-24 Tieium is a small settlement not worth mentioning except Tieium, Hisarönü (Tky.) 12.3.8
flows through fields full of flowers, hence its name; its sources
are actually in Paphlagonia. Then there’s Paphlagonia and the
Enetians.
543 C, 25–544 C, 4 There is speculation over whom the poet means by
poet = Homer (8th c. BCE) Enetians when he says: Pylaemenes of rugged heart led forth the
Paphlagonians / from the Enetians, where wild mules breed. It is
said that t here is now no evidence of Enetians in Paphlago-
nia, although some claim that t here is a village in Aegialus,
Zenodotus (3rd c. BCE) ten schoeni from Amastris. Zenodotus, who writes from Eneta, Amastris, Amasra (Tky.)
claims that modern-day Amisus is indicated. Others claim Amisus, Samsun (Tky.)
PAPHLAGONIA the Halys river, which, flowing from the south between the Syrians
n. Turkey
and Paphlagonians, according to Herodotus, issues into what is
Herodotus (5th c. BCE)
called the “Euxine” sea. By Syrians, Herodotus means Cappa- Euxine sea, Black Sea
[ 1 ] Philetaerus founded (3rd c. BCE) the kingdom of Pergamum (w. Turkey), which
lasted u ntil 133 BCE.
[ 2 ] Italica (lit., “Stuff about Italy”) is the section of Strabo’s work (209 C, 15–288 C,
33) in which he describes Italy; and within which he mentions Antenor (212 C,
7-17). Strabo’s use of such “titles”: 639 C, 15-27n.
[ 3 ] More on the name “Syrians”: 736 C, 13–737 C, 8.
631
4.1. Northern Asia
divided into the interior part and the maritime part, each of
which stretches from the Halys to Bithynia. Eupator held Eupator = Mithridates Eupator
(ruled 120–66 BCE)
the coast as far as Heraclia. He also held the immediately ad-
jacent part of the interior (some of which extended beyond
the Halys); the Pontic province, too, has been defined by the
Romans as including this part.3 The remainder was controlled
by warlords even after the overthrow of Mithridates. I will
describe later the Paphlagonians of the interior who were not
subject to Mithridates.4 At this stage, the task before me is
to describe the territory, called “Pontus,” that was subject to
him. |
544 C, 26–545 C, 2 After the Parthenius river comes Amastris (named for Amastris, Amasra (Tky.) 12.3.10
rum, and Cromna (which Homer mentions in his Paphlago- Cromna, Tekeönü (Tky.)
632
Pontic Coast of Fourth Section + Hinterland
“Erythrini” (Rust-colored [rocks]) because of their color. (They Erythrini, Çakraz (Tky.)
are twin lookout points.) After Aegialus is Carambis, a huge Carambis, Kerembe burnu (Tky.)
633
4.1. Northern Asia
which takes its name from the halae (saltworks) past which
it flows. From its sources in G reat Cappadocia, near the
Camisene region of Pontic Cappadocia, it flows west for a
long time, then, where it turns northward past the Galatians
and Paphlagonians, it acts as the border between these people
and the Leucosyrians.
546 C, 25-29 Sinopitis, together with all the mountainous territory ex- Sinopitis = region of Sinope,
Sinop (Tky.)
tending to Bithynia and lying inland from the coastline that
has been described,3 produces shipbuilding lumber that is
of good quality and easy to export. The maple tree and the
mountain-nut tree, from which tables are carved, grow in
Sinopitis. All the agricultural land slightly inland from the
sea is also planted with olive trees. |
546 C, 30–547 C, 6 After the outlet of the Halys, and extending as far as Halys, Kızıl Irmak 12.3.13
[ 1 ] Chalcedonian Temple (Anadolu Kavak, Tky.): 563 C, 16-25; cf. 548 C, 15-19.
[ 2 ] See 639 C, 15-27.
[ 3 ] 542 C, 31–546 C, 25.
634
Pontic Coast of Fourth Section + Hinterland
city of Amisus (around nine hundred stades from Sinope). Amisus, Samsun (Tky.)
Theopompus (4th c. BCE) Theopompus says that the Milesians were the first to establish the
city as a colony; . . . * the Cappadocian ruler enlarged her; thirdly,
Athenocles and the Athenians settled her and changed her name
to “Peraea.” The kings took possession of the city. Eupator Eupator = Mithridates Eupator
(ruled 120–66 BCE)
adorned her with sanctuaries and added a new part. She was
successfully besieged by Lucullus, then later by Pharnaces,
crossing over from Bosporus. She was set free by the deified Bosporus = kingdom on e ither
side of Straits of Kerch'
Caesar, handed over to kings by Antony, then ill-treated by
deified Caesar = Julius Caesar
Strato (the tyrant), then freed again by Caesar Augustus after
the Actian war. The city is now under good governance. She
has some fine territory, including Themiscyra (home of the
Amazons) and Sidene. |
547 C, 19-32 Themiscyra is a plain, on the one side bordered by the sea Themiscyra, nr. Terme (Tky.) 12.3.15
(at a distance of some sixty stades from the city), and on the
other side by mountainous territory, which is densely forested
and crossed by rivers that arise there and all feed into one river,
called “Thermodon,” which flows out across the plain. A sepa- Thermodon, Terme Çay
comes one with the Iris; then its course is through Themiscyra Armenia = Little Armenia,
ne. Turkey
and to the Pontic sea.
547 C, 32–548 C, 8 As a result, the plain is permanently moist and grassy, ca-
pable of feeding herds of c attle and h orses; and it is planted
[ 1 ] 561 C, 5-23n.
635
4.1. Northern Asia
then Trapezus, a Greek city. The sailing distance from Ami- Trapezus, Trabzon (Tky.)
sus to Trapezus is around two thousand two hundred stades; Amisus, Samsun (Tky.)
636
Pontic Coast of Fourth Section + Hinterland
the seaward side is well positioned for pelamys-fishing (this pelamys = young tuna fish
being the spot where the very first catch of this delicacy is
made),2 while on the landward side it is well situated for min-
ing operations (currently iron, formerly silver too). The coast
here is generally very narrow (because the mountains start
immediately, with their abundant mining and forestry), and
not much land is farmed. That leaves making a living out of
the mining operations, in the case of the mineworkers; and, in
the case of seafarers, out of fishing, particularly for pelamydes
and dolphins. (The dolphins, which prey on the schools of
fish—cordylae, tuna, and pelamydes themselves—become fat
and easy to catch as they are enticed dangerously close to the
shore.) These people alone slaughter the dolphins, and use
the plentiful fat for all sorts of purposes. |
549 C, 23-30 These are, I think, the Halizonians, whom the poet lists in 12.3.20
poet = Homer (8th c. BCE) the Catalogue 3 after the Paphlagonians: but Odius and Epistro-
phus led the Halizonians / from far away, from Alybe, birthplace
of silver. Either the wording from far away, from Chalybe was
changed; or the inhabitants were formerly called “Alybians”
rather than “Chalybians.” It cannot be that it is possible now
for the name “Chaldaeans” to have replaced “Chalybians” but
[ 1 ] An alternative translation for “heights” is “end point.” Cf. “end point of the
Pyrenees”: 159 C, 19-28.
[ 2 ] 2nd and 3rd catches at Sinope (Sinop, Tky.) and Byzantium (Istanbul, Tky.):
320 C, 6-17n; 545 C, 14–546 C, 2n.
[ 3 ] The “title” Catalogue refers to a part of Homer’s Iliad. Strabo often uses “titles”
for parts of Homer’s poems (4 C, 14-20n), as well as for parts of his own work
(639 C, 15-27n).
637
4.1. Northern Asia
ated with Lemnos.2 Similarly, Brygians, Brigians, and Phry- Lemnos, Lemnos (Gk. island)
writes it thus: but Odius and Epistrophus led the Amazons, / com-
ing from Alope, whence the race of the Amazonids. But in solving
these problems, he has met up with another fiction: no Alope
is found anywhere t here. And the new wording—so lacking in
corroboration from ancient copies—seems like a wild guess.
[ 1 ] Strabo emends slightly his earlier statement (457 C, 28-33, where he is ambiva-
lent about identifying “Saians” with Sintians/Sintans/Sapaeans, and where he
cites the lines of Archilochus slightly differently).
[ 2 ] “The islands associated with Lemnos” is idiomatic, meaning simply Lemnos.
Strabo described Lemnos (and Abdera) in the “eastern European gap”: 329 C,
15–332 C, 1.
638
Pontic Coast of Fourth Section + Hinterland
550 C, 26-32 The Scepsian accepts neither this theory nor the theory
Scepsian = Demetrius (2nd c. of those who assume that t here are Halizonians in the Pallene
BCE)
region (I mentioned them in the Macedonica);1 he is similarly
perplexed as to how anyone could believe that military help could
arrive for the Trojans from the nomads beyond Borysthenes! He
reserves his greatest praise for the views of Hecataeus the
Milesian, Menecrates the Elaean (a student of Xenocrates),
and Palaephatus.
550 C, 32–551 C, 4 The first of these, in his Circuit of the Earth, says . . . then
first of these = Hecataeus the city of Alazia. The Odrysses river, flowing from the west out of Dascylitis, Manyas Gölü
(6th–5th c. BCE)
Dascylitis lake, through the Mygdonian plain, joins the Rhyndacus. Rhyndacus, Orhaneli/Koca Dere
He says that, nowadays, Alazia is deserted, but many Alazonian
villages, past which the Odrysses flows, are populated; in these villages,
Apollo is held in exceptional reverence, particularly on the borders
with the Cyzicenes.
551 C, 4-9 Menecrates, in his Circuit of the Hellespontian [sea], says that
Menecrates (?4th c. BCE) inland from the Myrlia region lies a continuous stretch of mountain-
ous land, which the Halizonian nation once inhabited. One should,
he says, write it with two “l”s but the poet writes it with one “l”
Palaephatus (?4th c. BCE) because of the meter. Palaephatus says that Odius and Epistrophus
set out from the Alazonians, who lived in Alope (current-day Zelia). Zelia, Sariköy (Tky.)
551 C, 9-13 Why is it worth praising the views of these men? Quite
apart from the fact that they, too, change the original word-
Strabo disagrees with
Demetrius (2nd c. BCE) ing, they do not show where in Myrleatis the silver mines were
that views of Hecataeus,
Menecrates, Palaephatus
or are; nor how it is that men from there arrived in Ilium from
deserve praise far away, even if it were granted that an Alope or Alazia existed.
551 C, 13-17 These places are much nearer to the Troad than the Ephe-
Strabo points out that sus region is. Yet Demetrius says that those who place the Ama-
Demetrius (2nd c. BCE) is
inconsistent in interpretation zons in the vicinity of Pygela—between Ephesus, Magnesia, and
of “from far away” Priene—talk drivel, since the expression “from far away” is not ap-
propriate for the place. How much more inappropriate it is for
the region of Mysia and Teuthrania! |
551 C, 18-25 However—by Zeus!—he says that one should understand he = Demetrius 12.3.23
Demetrius cites various that some expressions are applied improperly, such as “from far-off
inelegant expressions from
Homer (8th c. BCE)
Ascania,” and “Arnaeus was his name—his noble mother gave it to Ascania, territory around İznik
Gölü (Tky.)
him,” and Penelope “took the well-turned key in her thick hand.”
551 C, 25-34 Even were this to be granted, t hose arguments are not to
be granted that Demetrius applies to his unconvincing con-
tradiction of those who think one should read from far away,
from Chalybe. He agrees that, even if there are currently no
639
4.1. Northern Asia
pleads. In locating places in the region of Scepsis, his father- Scepsis, Kurşunlu Tepe (Tky.)
land, he puts near Scepsis and the Aesepus the village of Aenea, Aesepus, Gönen Çay
as also Arguria and Alazonium. T hese, if they exist, would
Hecataeus (6th–5th c. BCE) be t oward the sources of the Aesepus. Hecataeus, however,
Palaephatus (?4th c. BCE) places them beyond its outlets; Palaephatus, who says that they
lived formerly in Alope (current-day Zelia), says nothing like the Zelia, Sariköy (Tky.)
Menecrates (?4th c. BCE) same as these men. As for Menecrates—he does not explain
the meaning of Alope or Alobe (or whatever people want to
write), nor does Demetrius himself. |
552 C, 9-13 Much has been said earlier1 in response to Apollodorus’s 12.3.24
Apollodorus (2nd c. BCE) treatment of the same matters in the Trojan Battle Order,2 and
it must be discussed now too. He thinks that one should not
understand the “Halizonians” to be outside the Halys, since no forces outside/far side of Halys = east
of Kızıl Irmak
allied with the Trojans came from the far side of the Halys.
552 C, 13-19 First, then, I w
ill ask him: Who are t hese Halizonians from him = Apollodorus
inside the Halys, who are also from far away, from Alybe, birth-
place of silver? He will be unable to answer. Second, I will ask
him for what reason he does not concede that some allied
forces came from the far side [of the Halys]. Even if it happens
that all the other allied forces, with the exception of the Thra-
cians, came from inside [the Halys], nothing prevents this one inside [Halys] = west of Kızıl
Irmak
force from having come from far away, from the land beyond
[the Halys] belonging to the Leucosyrians. Leucosyrians = Cappadocians
552 C, 19-30 Or was it the case that their enemies were able to cross over
from these places and from places still farther away (as people
say the Amazons, Treres, and Cimmerians did), but that their
640
Pontic Coast of Fourth Section + Hinterland
all agree that no one from the far side of the Halys took part far side of Halys = east of Kızıl
Irmak
in the Trojan war. Rather, one might find evidence for the
Maeandrius (?4th c. BCE) contrary. Maeandrius says that the Enetians, setting out from
the Leucosyrians, fought in alliance with the Trojans; from there,
they went away with the Thracians and settled around the recess of
the Adria; those of the Enetians who did not share in the expedition Adria, Adriatic Sea
553 C, 12-21 It is also said by him somewhere that the poet got his infor- him = Apollodorus 12.3.26
poet = Homer (8th c. BCE) mation about the interior Paphlagonians from p eople who traversed
the territory on foot, and that he lacked knowledge of the coastline,
as of the rest of the Pontic coastline (otherwise he would have named
it). It is possible to turn this on its head and, based on the
descriptive circuit just now provided, state the opposite: that
he traversed the entire coastline and omitted nothing of what
was at the time worthy of mention (it is not surprising if he
does not mention Heraclia, Amastris, and Sinope—which Amastris, Amasra (Tky.)
[ 1 ] 544 C, 5-14.
[ 2 ] The Introduction is the opening section of Strabo’s narrative (chaps. 1–2 in this
translation), within which Strabo attacks the theory that, if Homer does not
mention places, he must lack knowledge of them: 27 C, 1–47 C, 8; cf. 3 C, 20-31n;
4 C, 21-28n; 6 C, 16–7 C, 7n. Strabo’s use of “titles” to refer to parts of his work:
639 C, 15-27n.
641
4.1. Northern Asia
553 C, 21-31 He said that he was ignorant of much of what was famous He = Apollodorus
around the Pontus, such as rivers and nations (otherwise he would he = Homer
have named them). One might grant this in the case of certain Pontus, Black Sea
significant ones, such as the Scythians, the Maeotis, and the Maeotis, Sea of Azov
Ister. He would not on the one hand have described the no- Ister, Danube r.
553 C, 31–554 C, 5 But in the case of places that w ere e ither less significant 12.3.27
than that it marks the boundary between Asia and Europe. Tanaïs, Don r.
People of that time did not yet use the names “Europe” or
“Asia”—nor was the lived-in world thus divided into three
continents—otherwise he would have named them based
Strabo cites the Homeric “Libya” on something very significant, as in the case of Libya and the
“lips” (the wind blowing from the western parts of Libya).
Since the continents had not yet been defined, there was no
need to mention the Tanaïs.
554 C, 5-7 Many are the things that are worthy of mention but that
did not occur to him: there is a large degree of chance in him = Homer
words, as in deeds.
554 C, 8-12 From all t hese considerations, it is clear that anyone who
poet = Homer (8th c. BCE) argues that, b ecause something is not mentioned by the poet,
therefore that t hing was unknown to him, uses evidence that
is invalid. I should prove that it is invalid through several ex-
amples, since many people have made much use of this evi-
dence. I should refute them, when they adduce such things,
even though I w ill end up repeating myself.
554 C, 12-24 In the case, for example, of rivers, if anyone w ere to say
that they w ere unknown because they w ere not mentioned, I
would say that their argument is silly. He does not mention He = Homer
642
Pontic Coast of Fourth Section + Hinterland
LITTLE ARMENIA barenians and Chaldaeans, inland from the places associated
ne. Turkey
with Pharnacia and Trapezus, take us up to Little Armenia.
Little Armenia is quite a prosperous territory, which, like So- Sophene, in Great Armenia
643
4.1. Northern Asia
water at Dastira (also the Euphrates, forming the border Dastira, ?Eskişehir (Tky.)
[ 1 ] Mithridates fled after his defeat by the Roman general Pompey (66 BCE). He
escaped to Bosporus (Russia, Ukraine), the part of his kingdom that had not yet
fallen to Rome, where he committed suicide (63 BCE).
644
Pontic Coast of Fourth Section + Hinterland
556 C, 8-10 She married Archelaus and stayed with him to the She = Pythodoris
PONTIC INTERIOR land from t hese that Phanaroea lies, comprising the best part Phanaroea, Taşoya (Tky.)
n. + e. Turkey
of Pontus. It produces olives and good wine, and enjoys many
other benefits besides. To the east, it is shielded by the Pary- Paryadres, mts. in ne. Turkey
length and breadth, through which the Lycus flows out of Ar- Ophlimus, mt. SW Erbaa (Tky.)
menia, and through which the Iris flows out of the Amasian Lycus, Kelkit Çay
gorge. The two merge approximately in the middle of the val- Iris, Yeşil Irmak
557 C, 3-13 Pythodoris controls all this territory, which is adjacent to this territory = Phanaroea
the barbarian region also under her control.5 Cabira was built Cabira, Niksar (Tky.)
645
4.1. Northern Asia
[1] Albanian temple: 503 C, 7-19. Phrygian temples: 577 C, 1-10; 580 C, 6-10.
[2] Comana (Şar) in Great Cappadocia (cen. Turkey): 535 C, 20–536 C, 3.
[3] 477 C, 16–478 C, 11.
[4] Dorylaus → Lagetas → female, name unknown → female, name unknown → Strabo.
[5] The loyalty shown to Mithridates by Moaphernes probably left Strabo’s family
with little future in Roman-controlled Pontus. Strabo left Pontus early in his life
and spent his youth in Roman Asia.
[ 6 ] I add “[mother]” and understand “her father” to mean the father of Strabo’s
mother (cf. the description of Moaphernes as the “uncle of my mother” in the
previous paragraph). I depart from Radt (vol. 3, critical apparatus on 557 C, line
29), who deletes “father.”
646
Pontic Coast of Fourth Section + Hinterland
[ 1 ] 557 C, 14-20.
[ 2 ] I.e., as well as in Cappadocian Comana: 535 C, 20–536 C, 3.
[ 3 ] This “son of Archelaus” was the father, or uncle, of the Archelaus who later ruled
Great Cappadocia: 796 C, 12-16n.
[ 4 ] Adiatorix, given the city of Heraclia by M. Antony (ca. 40 BCE), massacred its
Roman colonists (32/31 BCE). After Antony’s defeat by Augustus, Adiatorix was
himself executed, and Heraclia became part of the Roman province of Pontus
(ca. 30 BCE): 542 C, 31–543 C, 6.
647
4.1. Northern Asia
includes Phanaroea, Zelitis, and Megalopolitis. Phanaroea Zelitis = region of Zela, Zile
(Tky.)
has been described.1 Zelitis contains the city of Zela, built on
Megalopolitis = region of
a Semiramis mound with a temple dedicated to Anaïtis. Al- Megalopolis, Sivas (Tky.)
though Anaïtis is worshipped by the Armenians, too,2 the sa-
cred rites are performed with even greater ceremony in Zela,
and this is where all Pontics take their oaths when the subject
is really important.
559 C, 26-28 When the kings were in power,3 the number of temple
slaves and the honors accorded to the priests w ere as I out-
lined above.4 Now, everything depends on Pythodoris.
559 C, 28–560 C, 5 There w ere many who, by acting in bad faith, reduced the
number of temple slaves and its other assets. The territory
alongside it, called “Zelitis,” was reduced too, being divided
up to form several dynastic regions. In the olden days, the
kings did not administer Zela as a city but as a temple to the Zela, Zile (Tky.)
648
Pontic Coast of Fourth Section + Hinterland
Gadilotus and Amisenian territory enclose the territory on Roman general Pompey reor
ganized conquered territories,
its northern side; the Halys, its western side; Phanaroea, its 65–63 BCE
eastern side; my own territory (that of the Amasians, much
the best and biggest of all), its remaining side.
560 C, 19–561 C, 4 The part of Phazemonitis toward Phanaroea includes a toward Phanaroea =
e. Phazemonitis
lake the size of a sea. It is called “Stiphana,” is good for fishing,
Stiphana, Lâdik Gölü (Tky.)
and is surrounded by extensive pastures of e very sort. On the
lake is the now-deserted fortress of Ikizari, with the ruined Ikizari, SW Lâdik (Tky.)
649
4.1. Northern Asia
[ 1 ] I.e., Amasia, also called “my fatherland”: 547 C, 19-32. Strabo’s mother’s family had
lived in Amasia for generations (at least from late 2nd c. BCE). Strabo, perhaps with
his immediate family, moved away: he received his education in the Roman prov-
ince of Asia in the city of Nysa (Sultanhisar, sw. Tky., 649 C, 18–650 C, 32). The date
of the move to Nysa is not known with certainty (?50 BCE or a few years e arlier).
Some connection between Nysa and the Roman province of Pontus is implied by
a letter written (50 BCE) by the Roman statesman Cicero to the Roman governor
of Pontus and Bithynia: D. R. Shackleton-Bailey, Cicero. Epistulae ad Familiares 1
(Cambridge University Press, 1977), no. 138. This letter is available in English transla-
tion in Shackleton-Bailey, Cicero’s Letters to His Friends (Harvard University Press,
2001), where, however, the name of the addressee has been changed.
[ 2 ] Diacopene = region of Diacopa (?Gümüşhaciköy, Tky.); Pimolisene = region of
Pimolisa (Osmancık, Tky.).
650
Pontic Coast of Fourth Section + Hinterland
INNER PAPHLAGONIA of the Pontic province,2 namely, the Olgassys region, next to Olgassys, Ilgaz Dağlari (Tky.)
sandaraca, realgar, or arsenic City.” In this city is the sandaraca mine, not far from the ru-
sulfide, used as orange pigment
ined royal fort of Pimolisa (as a result of which the territory Pimolisa, Osmancık (Tky.)
on either side of the river is called “Pimolisene”). The sanda- river = Halys, Kızıl Irmak
651
4.1. Northern Asia
562 C, 21-31 After Pompey City (heading west t oward Bithynia) comes 12.3.41
it as his base when he established Pontus u nder his dominion. Cimiata, Kurmalar, Ilgaz (Tky.)
The final ruler of Paphlagonia was Deiotarus (son of Castor), Mithridates “Ctistes”
(= Founder) ruled 302–266 BCE
known as “Philadelphus,” who made use of Morzeus’s royal
residence (namely Gangra, a small city as well as a fort). | Gangra, Çankırı (Tky.)
562 C, 31–563 C, 3 Eudoxus, who mentions among dry places the dug-up fish 12.3.42
Eudoxus (4th c. BCE) in Paphlagonia, does not specify the place; he describes among
wet places the region associated with the Ascanian lake, subject to Ascanian lake, İznik Gölü (Tky.)
563 C, 16-25 Situated h ere, at the mouth of the Pontus, are Chalcedon Chalcedon, Kadıköy (Tky.) 12.4.2
(founded by the Megarians) and the village of Chrysopolis Chrysopolis, Üsküdar (Tky.)
and the Chalcedonian Temple. The territory has, a little in- Chalcedonian Temple, Anadolu
Kavak (Tky.)
land from the sea, a spring—Azaritia—where small croco-
diles breed. Then, following on from the Chalcedonian shore
is what is called “Astacenian bay,” a part of the Propontis, Astacenian bay, İzmit Körfezi
where Nicomedia was founded, named after one of the Propontis, Marmara Denizi
Bithynian kings who was its f ounder. (Many kings bore the Nicomedia, İzmit (Tky.)
[ 1 ] The “remainder” of inner Paphlagonia was the part not subject to Mithridates
Eupator: 544 C, 14-25.
[ 2 ] Strabo seems to refer to independent rulers in power u ntil Roman reorganiza
tion (65–63 BCE).
[ 3 ] 544 C, 5-14.
[ 4 ] 563 C, 10–566 C, 22.
[ 5 ] 566 C, 23–571 C, 178.
[ 6 ] Paphlagonians, etc.: 544 C, 5–546 C, 29; 561 C, 33–563 C, 3. Pontic sea (Black
Sea): 543 C, 7-24. Propontis (Marmara Denizi): 563 C, 16–564 C, 11. Mysia, Phrygia
Epictetus: 564 C, 12–565 C, 27; 566 C, 23-30n; 571 C, 17–576 C, 25.
652
Pontic Coast of Fourth Section + Hinterland
intruding more toward the east. It is the location of Prusias, Prusias/Cius, Gemlik (Tky.)
563 C, 32-35 This is the Prusias who received Hannibal (when Hannibal
fled thither a fter the defeat of Antiochus) and who gave up
his claim to Phrygia-on-the-Hellespont in favor of the Attalic Phrygia-on-the-Hellespont
joined Attalic kingdom of
[kings]. It was called “Little Phrygia” by men of former times, Pergamum, early 2nd c. BCE
but the Attalic [kings] called it “Phrygia Epictetus (Annexed).”
563 C, 35–564 C, 7 Inland from Prusias is a mountain that they call “Argan- Arganthonium, Samanli Daği
(Tky.)
thonium.” This is the setting for the myth in which Hylas,
one of Heracles’s companions who sailed with him on the
Argo, when he set out to look for water was snatched away by
nymphs; and Cius, who was also a companion of Heracles and
fellow shipmate, on the way back from the Colchians, s topped
here and founded the city named after himself. Even now,
there is a festival celebrated by the Prusians and a procession
to the mountain in which revelers call out “Hylas” as if mak-
ing an exodus into the woods in search of him.1
564 C, 7-9 The Prusians established friendly diplomatic relations
with the Romans and as a result won their freedom. The
Apamians got a Roman colony.
564 C, 9-11 Prusa is situated on Mysian Olympus. It is a well-governed Prusa, Bursa (Tky.)
city, bordering on both the Phrygians and the Mysians, and Mysian Olympus, Ulu Dağ (Tky.)
was founded by the Prusias who went to war with Croesus. |
564 C, 12-21 It is difficult to define the boundaries between Bithyn- 12.4.4
[ 1 ] An erudite joke by Strabo, who plays on the name “Hylas” and the Greek word
for “woods” which, in its grammatically required inflected form, is hylas.
653
4.1. Northern Asia
would place Mysia between Bithynia and the outlet of the Ae- Aesepus, Gönen Çay
sepus, following the coastline and reaching as far as Olympus Olympus, Ulu Dağ (Tky.)
the same name as the lake, and one part of it is Phrygian, the
other Mysian (with the Phrygian part being farther away
from Troy).
564 C, 27–565 C, 6 This is how the poet should be understood when he says,
poet = Homer (8th c. BCE) Phorcys led the Phrygians, as did godly Ascanius, / from far off
Ascania—that is, in Phrygia near the current-day Nicaea— Nicaea, İznik (Tky.)
poet = Homer (8th c. BCE) boundary. After cataloguing the Trojan mountainside above
Ilium, which was subject to Aeneas and which he called “Dar-
dania,” g oing northward he places Lycia next, which was sub-
ject to Pandarus and in which lies Zelia. He says, those who dwelt Zelia, Sariköy (Tky.)
654
Pontic Coast of Fourth Section + Hinterland
Tieium, with its territory around Salon being excellent for Tieium, Hisarönü (Tky.)
Ascania. She is surrounded by a large plain, blessed with fer- Ascania, İznik Gölü (Tky.)
tility but not at all healthy in the summer. She was founded
initially by Antigonus (son of Philip), who gave her the name
“Antigonia”; then by Lysimachus, who changed the name to
“Nicaea,” a fter his wife (she was the d aughter of Antipater).
The sixteen-stade perimeter of the city forms a four-sided
figure; it is also four-gated and located on a flat plain, with
the streets laid out at right angles to each other, so that the
four gates are visible from a single stone set up in the center
of the gymnasium.
566 C, 3-5 A little inland from lake Ascania is the small town of Otroea, Otroea, nr. Hayriye (Tky.)
655
4.1. Northern Asia
566 C, 19-22 Bithynia has produced men famous for their learning: the 12.4.9
656
Pontic Coast of Fourth Section + Hinterland
residence and one of which was his treasury. | Peium, Tabanlıoğlu Kale (Tky.)
567 C, 24–568 C, 7 The largest entrepôt in the region is Pessinus, with its Pessinus, Ballıhisar (Tky.) 12.5.3
Phrygian settlements on its banks (belonging to Midas, even Gordius and Midas w ere
Phrygian kings, 8th–7th c. BCE
earlier to Gordius, and to certain o thers) preserve no traces
of having been cities, but are only villages that are slightly
larger than others. Examples are Gordium and Gorbeus, Gordium, Yassıhüyük (Tky.)
which was the royal residence of Castor Saocondarius. It was Gorbeus, nr. Oğulbey (Tky.)
here that Deiotarus killed Castor (his son-in-law) and his own
daughter, then destroyed the fort and left most of the settle-
ment in ruins. |
568 C, 8-15 South of Galatia is lake Tatta, which, though lying along- Tatta, Tuz Göl (Tky.) 12.5.4
657
4.1. Northern Asia
LYCAONIA tain plateaus of the Lycaonians are cold, treeless, and fit only
sw. cen. Turkey
for grazing wild mules. The water supply is very limited. In
places where there is any water to be found, the wells are ex-
tremely deep, as in Soatra, where there is a trade in water. Soatra, Yağlibayat (Tky.)
larger one, and Trogitis the smaller. Somewhere in the locality Trogitis, Suğla Göl (Tky.)
is Iconium, a small and well-settled town, with territory that Iconium, Konya (Tky.)
Cappadocian town of Garsaura, the distance between t hese Garsaura, Aksaray (Tky.)
[ 1 ] Coropassus and Garsaura lie on the long road from the Euphrates to Ephesus
(Selçuk, Tky.), which was at least partially traveled by Strabo: 663 C, 19-33n.
[ 2 ] The young Strabo may have seen the elderly Isauricus in Asia (early 40s BCE).
Scholars often assume, however, that Strabo must have seen Isauricus in Rome
and, on this basis, put Strabo in Rome before the death of Isauricus (44 BCE).
658
Pontic Coast of Fourth Section + Hinterland
In the same place, he constructed a city wall but did not live
to see its completion, being killed by the Cilicians (ambushed
by them during his attack on the Homonadians). |
569 C, 10-23 Amyntas held Pisidian Antioch as far as Apollonias (near Pisidian Antioch, Yalvaç (Tky.) 12.6.4
Apamia Cibotus), and parts of Parorian Phrygia, as well as Apollonias, Uluborlu (Tky.)
Lycaonia.1 He tried to eradicate the Cilicians and Pisidians Apamia Cibotus, Dinar (Tky.)
who w ere coming down from the Taurus and overrunning this
territory, which belonged to the Phrygians and Lycaonians.
Amyntas razed many previously impregnable sites, includ-
ing Cremna. (He did not, however, even attempt to force Cremna, Girme, Çamlık (Tky.)
him = Amyntas into submission, took four thousand men captive, moved
them to nearby cities, and left the territory destitute of men
of fighting age. It lies in the heights of the Taurus, consisting Taurus, mts. of s. Turkey
PISIDIA the Selgians, who are the best known of them. Many of them Selgians = inhabitants of Selga,
sw. Turkey Zerk (Tky.)
occupy the Taurus mountain peaks. Some occupy the hills—
all planted with olives—above the Pamphylian cities of Sida Sida, Selimiye (Tky.)
and Aspendus. The mountains immediately above the hills Aspendus, Belkis (Tky.)
are occupied by the Cotennians, who share a border with the Cotenna, Gödene (Tky.)
659
4.1. Northern Asia
570 C, 4-13 Artemidorus lists, as the cities belonging to the Pisidians, 12.7.2
Artemidorus (late 2nd–early Selga, Sagalassus, Petnelissus, Adada, Timbriada, Cremna, Petnelissus, Kozan (Tky.)
1st c. BCE)
Tityassus, Amblada, Anabura, Sinda, Aarassus, Tarbassus, Adada, Karabaulo (Tky.)
Tityassus, Bademli (Tky.)
and Termessus. Some of the Pisidians are true mountain Timbriada, Asar (Tky.)
Amblada, Hisartepe (Tky.)
dwellers, while o thers spread down into the foothills in each Cremna, Girme, Çamlık (Tky.)
Anabura, Enevre (Tky.)
direction, to Pamphylia and Milyas, bordering on the Phry- Sinda, Gölhisar (Tky.)
gians, Lydians, and Carians, all of them peace-loving nations Aarassus, ?Uçkapı, Bademağaç
(Tky.)
despite being northerly, while the Pamphylians, with their
strong affinity to the Cilician race, have not completely aban- Termessus, Güllük Dağ (Tky.)
660
Pontic Coast of Fourth Section + Hinterland
Selgian mountains and into the Pamphylian sea; and t here Cestrus, Asku
are bridges on the roads. Protected by nature, the Selgians
never once (neither early on nor later) answered to others,
but enjoyed the benefits of most of their territory without
fear, except that in the lower parts (in Pamphylia and inside inside Taurus = south of Taurus
mts.
the Taurus), they were engaged in continual warfare against
the kings. They sent deleg ations to Alexander and said that
they would concede to his demands on the basis of friend-
ship, but in the case of the Romans they held their territory
on certain conditions. Now completely subjugated, they have
been allocated to the territory formerly subject to Amyntas. |
571 C, 17-25 Bordering on the Bithynians to the south are, as I said,1 the 12.8.1
MYSIA, PHRYGIA Mysians—associated with what is called “Mysian” Olympus— Mysian Olympus, Ulu Dağ (Tky.)
nw. + w. Turkey
and the Phrygians. Each nation is divided. In respect of Phry-
gia, one part is called “Great Phrygia,” where Midas reigned, reat Phrygia (w. cen. Tky.)
G
ruled by Midas, ?8th–7th c. BCE;
and some of which was occupied by Galatians. The other part partly settled by Galatians, late
is called “Little Phrygia”: it is on the Hellespont in the Olym- 270s BCE
often mentioned,4 that the ancients also call the Sipylus re- Sipylus, Manisa Dağı (Tky.)
[ 1 ] 566 C, 23-30.
[ 2 ] Galatian territory (w. cen. Turkey): 566 C, 31–569 C, 30. G reat Phrygia (w. cen.
Turkey): 576 C, 26–581 C, 1. Phrygia Epictetus (nw. Turkey): 571 C, 17-25; 575 C, 9-17;
576 C, 20-25.
[ 3 ] Olympene (nw. Turkey): 574 C, 20–575 C, 9. Pergamene (w. Turkey): 623 C, 12–
625 C, 24.
[ 4 ] 564 C, 12–565 C, 27.
[ 5 ] Tantalus was known in Greek myth as both a Mysian and a Phrygian king; Pelops
and Niobe were his children.
661
4.1. Northern Asia
Caecus flows out to sea), and between them Teuthrania (the Caecus, Bakır Çay
different p
eople. As for being mixed up with t hese p eople,
some say that the Mysians are Thracians. Others say that
the Mysians are Lydians and refer to the ancient explanation
Xanthus (5th c. BCE) given in the writings of Xanthus the Lydian and Menecrates
Menecrates (?4th c. BCE) the Elaean, who give as the etymology of the name “Mysian”
that the Lydians use this name for the beech tree; there are many
beech trees on Olympus, which is where, they say, “one in ten” were Olympus, Ulu Dağ (Tky.)
laid out;3 their descendants became the l ater “Mysians,” who w ere
named after the beech tree. Their language, too, provides proof, since
it is to some extent hybridized Lydian and to some extent hybrid-
ized Phrygian: they lived in the vicinity of Olympus for a time, but
when the Phrygians crossed over from Thrace . . . * the ruler of Troy
and the neighboring country, the Phrygians settled t here, whereas the
Mysians settled above the sources of the Caecus, near the Lydians. |
572 C, 15-21 Underlying such mythologizing is the confusion of na- 12.8.4
tions there, and the desirability of the territory inside the inside Halys = west of Kızıl Irmak
[ 1 ] Teuthras was known in Greek myth as a Mysian king who raised his new wife’s
son, Telephus, as his own.
[ 2 ] 564 C, 12-27.
[ 3 ] Dedication of 1 in 10 (?of newborns) as an expiatory offering to a god: cf. 257 C,
13-28n.
[ 4 ] Invasions and migrations after the Trojan period: 573 C, 27-32.
[ 5 ] Wanderings in Europe: 220 C, 31–221 C, 38; 321 C, 4–322 C, 13; 345 C, 6–346 C, 12.
[ 6 ] Strabo believes that Homer’s representation of these tribes as Trojan allies
means that they w ere already resident in the Asian peninsula in Homer’s day:
611 C, 3-23; cf. 542 C, 17-30; 605 C, 15–606 C, 4.
662
Pontic Coast of Fourth Section + Hinterland
the “Lycians” near Caria, or vice versa.1 The same t hing pos-
sibly happened in the case of the “Cilicians,”2 there being two
sets of them, too. (We have no such evidence that the current-
day Cilicians already existed before the Trojan period.)3
572 C, 30-32 Telephus might be supposed to have arrived from Arcadia
with his m other. By virtue of this woman’s marriage, he won
over Teuthras (who accepted him) and was treated as the lat-
ter’s son, inheriting the Mysian kingdom. |
573 C, 1-13 The Carians and, so it is said, the Lelegians w ere previ- 12.8.5
[ 1 ] Trojan Lycians (nw. Turkey): 565 C, 7-19; 585 C, 20-32; 586 C, 30–587 C, 5. Carian
Lycians (sw. Turkey): 664 C, 5–667 C, 13.
[ 2 ] Two sets of Cilicians (nw. Turkey) of Trojan times: 586 C, 8-11; 605 C, 15–606 C,
4n; 611 C, 24–613 C, 18.
[ 3 ] Cilicians “outside the Taurus” (s. Turkey): 668 C, 7–676 C, 33.
663
4.1. Northern Asia
573 C, 27-32 After the Trojan period, colonizations by the Greeks and Greek colonizations, late 12.8.7
2nd millennium BCE;
incursions by Treres, Cimmerians, and Lydians—and after- Cimmerians, Trerians, late
ward by Persians, Macedonians, and finally Galatians—threw 8th–7th c. BCE; Lydians, 7th c.
BCE; Persians, 6th c. BCE;
everything into confusion and mixed things up. This lack of Macedonians late 4th c. BCE;
Galatians, early 3rd c. BCE
clarity is the result not only of changes but also of inconsis-
tencies between writers, who describe the same events differ-
ently, calling the Trojans “Phrygians” (as do the tragedians),
calling the Lycians “Carians,” and so on.
573 C, 32–574 C, 13 The Trojans, who grew from such small beginnings to be-
poet = Homer (8th c. BCE) come “kings of kings,” provided a problem to the poet and
to his interpreters as to what exactly should be called “Troy.”
He uses the name Trojans indiscriminately for all the allies,
just as he uses the names Danaans and Achaeans for their op-
ponents. (We will not, however, call Paphlagonia, Caria, nor
the adjacent Lycia “Troy,” by Zeus.) I mean, when he says the
Trojans advanced, whooping and yelling, while on the other side
the Achaeans advanced in silence, breathing menace, and when he
expresses himself in many other ways. Although such is the
case, I must nevertheless try to clarify particulars as far as I
can. Where matters of ancient history elude me, this should
be passed over (for the task of the geographer does not lie
therein), and the current state of affairs must be described. |
Olympus and Ida. The Bithynian region lies at the foot of Ida, Kaz Dağ
Olympus; but between Ida and the coast, right up against the
mountain, lies Troy. I will describe Troy and adjacent areas to
the south l ater.1 For now, let me describe the Olympenians
and those areas that come next as far as the Taurus, which are
parallel to the areas already traversed.2
574 C, 20-30 Olympus is well settled on all sides, with incredible forests Olympus, Ulu Dağ
OLYMPENE on its peaks and well-defended places that are home to bands
nw. Turkey
of raiders, amongst which tyrants often establish themselves,
capable of staying in power for a long time, as in the case of
Cleon, in our times the chief of these bands of raiders. | This 12.8.9
664
Propontic Coast of Fourth Section + Hinterland
the Rhyndacus and lake Dascylitis; “Mygdonians” for their Dascylitis, Manyas Gölü
575 C, 18-24 Cyzicus is an island in the Propontis, linked to the main- Propontis, Marmara Denizi 12.8.11
CYZICUS land by two bridges. The island is very fertile and is some
Kapu Dağ (Tky.)
five hundred stades in size, measured around her circumfer-
ence. The island has a city with the same name, right by the Cyzicus (city), Belkiz Kale (Tky.)
bridges, and two harbors that can be sealed off, and more than
[ 1 ] 574 C, 20–575 C, 8.
665
4.1. Northern Asia
two hundred shipyards. Part of the city lies in the plain, part
toward the mountain. It is called “Arcton (Bear) mountain,” Arcton mountain/Dindymum,
Kapu Dağ
but looming over it is another single-peaked mountain, Din-
dymum, with a temple to Dindymene, the Divine Mother,
established by the Argonauts.
575 C, 24-30 The city rivals the foremost cities in Asia in terms of size,
beauty, and good governance in times of both war and peace.1
It seems that she is embellished in a manner similar to the city
of the Rhodians, the city of the Massaliotes, and the city of
the ancient Carthaginians. While I leave much aside, the city
possesses three master builders (responsible for the public
buildings and equipment) and three storage vaults (one for
arms, one for equipment, and one for grain—an admixture of
Chalcidian earth keeps the grain from spoiling).
575 C, 30–576 C, 4 They demonstrated the utility of these preparations dur-
ing the war against Mithridates. The king, with one hundred
and fifty thousand men and a large troop of cavalry, attacked
them and caught them unawares; he took possession of the
mountain (which they call “Adrastia”) opposite, and of the Adrastia, Delikli Bayir
suburbs; he crossed onto the neck of land above the city and
engaged them by land and by sea, with four hundred boats.
The Cyzicenes withstood him so successfully on all fronts that
they came close to taking the king alive in the tunnel (digging
through it as a countervailing tactic). He, however, took pre-
emptive action and got himself out of the tunnel.
576 C, 4-16 Later, the Roman general Lucullus prevailed by sending in
an auxiliary force under cover of night. Further help came in
the form of a famine, which, unforeseen by the king, beset his
large army; he consequently withdrew with heavy losses. The
Romans bestowed honors on the city. It remains f ree to this day
and has an extensive territory, part of it dating back to antiq-
uity, part of it added by the Romans. They hold the Zelia region Zelia, Sariköy (Tky.)
of the Troad beyond the Aesepus, and the plain of Adrastia. Aesepus, Gönen Çay
They hold part of lake Dascylitis (the Byzantians hold the other Dascylitis, Manyas Gölü
which takes its start in Azanitis. Joined by several rivers from Rhyndacus, Orhaneli/Koca Dere
Ancyra in Abaeitis, Boğaz Mysian Abrettene, including the Mecestus from Ancyra in Mecestus, Simav Çayı
(formerly Kilise) Köy (Tky.)
Abaeitis, it flows into the Propontis near the island of Besbicus. Besbicus, İmrali (Tk. island)
666
Propontic Coast of Fourth Section + Hinterland
from it. Nearby is the promontory called “Melanus,” which is Artaca (islet), Tavsan Adası (Tk.
island)
passed by those making the coastal voyage to Priapus from
Melanus, Murat Bayır
Cyzicus. |
576 C, 20-25 To Phrygia Epictetus belong the cities of Azani, Naco- 12.8.12
GREAT PHRYGIA sinus and the regions of Orcaorci and Lycaonia on the left, the
w. cen. Turkey
Maeonians, Lydians, and Carians on the right.1 Great Phry-
gia includes what is called “Parorian Phrygia” and “Phrygia- Amorium, Hisar Köy (Tky.)
Apamia Cibotus, Dinar (Tky.) toward-Pisidia,” and the region of Amorium, Eumenia, and Eumenia, Isıklı (Tky.)
Laodicia, Eski Hisar (Tky.) Synnada; then t here are “Apamia Cibotus” (as it is called) and Synnada, Şuhut (Tky.)
Aphrodisias, Geyre (Tky.) Laodicia, the greatest of the Phrygian cities.2 Around these Metropolis, Tatarlı (Tky.)
Colossae, nr. Honaz (Tky.) are towns and . . . * Aphrodisias, Colossae, Themisonium, Apollonias, Uluborlu (Tky.)
Sanaus, Sarı Kavak (Tky.) Sanaus, Metropolis, and Apollonias. More distant than these Tabae, Davas Kale (Tky.)
posite side, what is called “Pisidian Antioch,” the former Pisidian Antioch, Yalvaç (Tky.)
is what the Romans call it, but the locals call it “Docimite” or
“Docimaean”). To start with, only small nuggets were mined.
[ 1 ] “Left” and “right” are used from the perspective of someone facing south.
Pessinus, Orcaorci, Lycaonia (sw. cen. Turkey): 566 C, 31–568 C, 25. Maeonians/
Lydians, Carians (w. + sw. Turkey): 625 C, 25–630 C, 25.
[ 2 ] Parorian Phrygia/Phrygia-toward-Pisidia (w. cen. Turkey), including Synnada:
577 C, 1-19. Apamia Cibotus, 577 C, 20–578 C, 7. Laodicia, 578 C, 8-19.
[ 3 ] “Asia within the Taurus” = Asian peninsula: 534 C, 8-20n. Eumenes’s acquisition:
624 C, 9-22.
667
4.1. Northern Asia
cally so called),1 second only to Ephesus: she receives goods Ephesus, Selçuk (Tky.)
der after the Maeander has been joined by another river, the
Orgas, which flows gently and quietly through level terrain. Orgas, Norgaz Çay
ing that the city be named after his mother, Apama (daughter
of Artabazus, given in marriage to Seleucus Nicator). This is
the setting for the myth about Olympus and Marsyas, and
the quarrel that Marsyas had with Apollo. Above Celaenae
is a lake that produces a reed used for the making of flute
mouthpieces. It is said that the sources of the Marsyas and
the Maeander both trickle forth from this lake. |
578 C, 8-19 Laodicia,2 formerly a small city, underwent expansion Laodicia, Eski Hisar (Tky.) 12.8.16
668
Propontic Coast of Fourth Section + Hinterland
578 C, 19-24 This is where the Maeander is joined by the Caprus and Caprus, ?Başlı Çay
by the Lycus, a huge river from which the city takes its name Lycus, Çürük Su
mountain, out of which flow the Lycus and also another river Cadmus (river), Gökpinar/
Çukur Su
with the same name as the mountain. This river, in flowing
underground for a considerable distance then rising to the
surface before entering the main stream at the same spot as
the other rivers, illustrates both the porosity and the seismic-
ity of the territory—for if anywhere is prone to earthquakes,
it is Laodicia.
578 C, 24-30 This is the case, too, with Carura in the neighboring ter- Carura, Tekke (Tky.)
walls of the houses are safe, but are almost daily shaken and
riven with cracks. The people continually attend to the con-
dition of the earth and design their buildings accordingly.
[ 1 ] Carura is on the long road from the Euphrates to Ephesus: 663 C, 19-33nn.
[ 2 ] Plutonium—a sanctuary dedicated to Pluto, god of the underworld, and ac-
companied by a charonium—in Hierapolis (Pamukkale, Tky.): 629 C, 22–630 C,
9n. Charonium in Acharaca (Salavatlı, Tky.): 649 C, 25–650 C, 9n. Charonium in
Myus (Afşar, Tky.), 636 C, 10-18n.
669
4.1. Northern Asia
Of the other cities, Apamia often suffered from earthquakes, Apamia, Dinar (Tky.)
579 C, 27–580 C, 5 We can also learn from ancient historians, for example, 12.8.19
Xanthus (5th c. BCE) from the sort of thing said by Xanthus, who wrote Lydian
Matters and described the changes that frequently character-
ized this territory—changes that I, too, mentioned in the
Introduction.1 Indeed, people say that this is the setting for
the myth of Typhon’s sufferings and the Arimians; and they
describe this territory as “Burnt” (Catacecaumene). They have
no hesitation in supposing that, b ecause of the large number
of lakes and rivers and the frequency of holes in the ground,
the w hole region between the Maeander and the Lydians is
of the same type. The lake between Laodicia and Apamia,
which is as large as a sea, gives off a foul and . . . * vapor. They
say that t here are law cases brought against the Maeander for
changing the territory, whenever the river bends are messed
around; when the Maeander is found guilty, the fines are paid
out of the ferry tolls! |
580 C, 6-10 Between Laodicia and Carura, there’s what is called the 12.8.20
[ 1 ] The Introduction is the opening section of Strabo’s narrative (chaps. 1–2 in this
translation), within which he deals extensively with changes to the landscape
of the lived-in world: 48 C, 29–61 C, 31, with particular reference to Xanthus at
49 C, 19-25. Strabo’s use of “titles” to refer to parts of his work: 639 C, 15-27n.
670
Propontic Coast of Fourth Section + Hinterland
my account of Phrygia.3
581 C, 1-12 Let me return to the Propontis and the coastline following Propontis, Marmara Denizi
TROAD on from the Aesepus, and revert to my standardized system.4 Aesepus, Gönen Çay
nw. + w. Turkey
The first territory along this coast is the Troad. Although Troad = region around Troy
Granicus, as far as Abydus and Sestus, it happens that the Granicus, Biga Çayı
671
4.1. Northern Asia
t here’s the region of Cyme as far as the Hermus and Phocaea Hermus, Gediz Çay
[ 1 ] 4th stretch of Troad, Canae to the Hermus (Gediz Çay, w. Tky.): 621 C, 28–623 C,
12.
[ 2 ] 582 C, 4-14.
672
Propontic Coast of Fourth Section + Hinterland
place on the island of Cyzicus opposite Priapus), making its Artaca, Erdek (Tky.)
Damastes (5th c. BCE) boundaries smaller. Damastes makes it even smaller, starting
after Parium: he extends it only as far as Lectum, while o thers Parium, Kemer (Tky.)
Charon (5th c. BCE) vary in their views. Charon the Lampsacenian, making the
Troad start with Practius, deducts another three hundred Practius, ?Ulu Dere
mountain range, facing the west and the sea in that region,
curving slightly as it goes toward the north and the coastline
there (i.e., the stretch on the Propontis from the strait in the
Abydus region as far as the Aesepus and Cyzicene). The sea
to the west is the outer Hellespont and the Aegaean sea. Ida
is scolopendroid in shape and has many foothills and ends with scolopendroid,
centipede-shaped
the most extreme of these, namely the Zelian spur and the one
called “Lectum.” The former ends in the interior, somewhat Lectum, Bababurnu
inland from Cyzicene (Zelia now belongs to the Cyzicenes): Zelia, Sariköy (Tky.)
583 C, 34–584 C, 11 Between Lectum and Zelia, starting from the Propontis Propontis, Marmara Denizi
end, you come first to the strait at Abydus and then, outside Abydus, Maltepe (Tky.)
673
4.1. Northern Asia
round Lectum, a great bay opens up formed by Ida (as it Ida, Kaz Dağ
recedes from Lectum t oward the interior) and by Canae (a Canae, Kara Dağ
poet = Homer (8th c. BCE) basis of the poet’s statements, that this whole coastline was
under Trojan control: it was divided into nine chiefdoms, but it
was under the overall command of Priam at the time of the Tro- time of Trojan war, late 2nd–
early 1st millennium BCE
jan war, and it was called “Troy.” This is clear from his specific
remarks. Namely, t hose associated with Achilles,4 seeing at the
start that the Ilians were protected by their walls, endeavored
to fight the war outside the walls and to go about picking off the
Strabo cites Homer (8th c. BCE) surrounding areas: twelve cities of men I destroyed with my ships, / and
eleven by land, I say, in earth-rich Troy. By “Troy,” he means the
mainland that was sacked. These sacked locations included the
parts opposite Lesbos, namely the region of Thebe, Lyrnessus,
and Pedasus (a Lelegian possession), and even the land belong-
ing to Telephus’s son Eurypylus: Neoptolemus struck down with
his bronze spear the son of Telephus, what a man, / the hero Eurypylus,
and he sacked Lyrnessus and Pedasus, and having sacked Lyrnessus and
the walls of Thebe. He says that these were sacked, as also Lesbos
itself: when you yourself took lovely Lesbos.
584 C, 31–585 C, 19 Briseïs was taken from Lyrnessus—he carried her away from
Strabo cites Homer (8th c. BCE) Lyrnessus—in the capture of which city he says that Mynes and he = Homer
[ 1 ] 582 C, 4-14.
[ 2 ] The Introduction is the opening section of Strabo’s narrative (chaps. 1–2 in this
translation), within which he alludes to Byzantium and Caria lying on a straight
(north–south) line: 114 C, 18-24. Strabo’s use of “titles” to refer to parts of his
work: 639 C, 15-27n.
[ 3 ] “Asian coastline” = coastline of the Asian peninsula: 534 C, 8-20n.
[ 4 ] “Those associated with Achilles” is idiomatic, meaning simply Achilles (= “I” in
the following quotation by Strabo of Homer’s lines).
674
Propontic Coast of Fourth Section + Hinterland
[ 1 ] The “title” Catalogue refers to a part of Homer’s Iliad. Strabo often uses “titles”
for parts of Homer’s poems (4 C, 14-20n), as well as for parts of his own work
(639 C, 15-27n).
675
4.1. Northern Asia
586 C, 12-16 That Priam ruled over all of these is clearly shown by what
Achilles says to Priam: I hear that you, old man, once were blest: /
all that is enclosed by Lesbos on high, city of Macar, / and by Phrygia
from above and by the boundless Hellespont. |
586 C, 17-22 That was then. All sorts of changes followed later. The 13.1.8
Cyzicus region as far as Practius was settled by the Phry- Cyzicus, Belkiz Kale (Tky.)
gians, and the Abydus region was settled by the Thracians; Practius, ?Ulu Dere
mus to the coast at Cyzicus, and since they founded cities, Cyzicus, Belkiz Kale (Tky.)
[ 1 ] With t hese words, Strabo introduces his description of the 1st stretch of
the Troad (586 C, 30–591 C, 34), as per his earlier division of the Troad into 4
stretches (581 C, 13–582 C, 3n).
[ 2 ] Strabo weaves into his ensuing description places mentioned in this citation
of Homer’s lines. Adrestia/Adrastia: 588 C, 3-18n. Apaesus/Paesus: 589 C, 9-23n.
Pitya: 588 C, 19-32n. Teria’s . . . mountain: 589 C, 4-8n. The precise location of
these places was probably as uncertain for Strabo as it is for us.
676
Propontic Coast of Fourth Section + Hinterland
river, crossed twenty times by the same road in the same way
poet = Homer (8th c. BCE) as the Heptaporus, which the poet mentions. |
587 C, 15-23 Nearly . . . * stades inland from the mouth of the Aesepus is Aesepus, Gönen Çay 13.1.11
cus (between the Aesepus and Priapus) runs largely across the
Adrastian plain. This is where Alexander clashed with Dari-
us’s satraps, inflicting a crushing defeat on them and ending
up in possession of all the land inside the Taurus and this side
of the Euphrates.1 On the Granicus is the city of Sidene (now
in ruins), her extensive territory bearing the same name. In
the borderlands between Cyzicene and Priapene is Harpagia
(Snatched), whence mythographers say that Ganymedes was
plain of the same name, where there was a temple to “Actian” Parium, Kemer (Tky.)
Apollo and Artemis at . . . *. When the temple was torn
down, the entire structure and stonework were transferred
and used to build an altar in Parium (a work by Hermocreon,
very much admired for its size and beauty). The oracle, like
[ 1 ] “Inside” and “this side of” are used from a E uropean viewpoint, to mean north
of the Taurus mt. range and west of the Euphrates.
[ 2 ] “Xerxes” is an error for “Artaxerxes” (Persian king, 5th c. BCE), repeated at 636 C,
10-18. For other such repeated errors: 517 C, 20–518 C, 4n.
[ 3 ] Adrastia is mentioned (as Adrestia) by Homer, as cited by Strabo at 587 C, 5-14n.
[ 4 ] The goddess Nemesis was also known as “Adrastia.” At the end of this para-
graph, Strabo attributes to Antimachus the statement that king Adrastus was
the first man to establish a temple to her.
677
4.1. Northern Asia
Proconnesus and current-day Proconnesus, with its city and “current-day” Proconnesus,
Marmara (Tk. island)
its huge and much-praised white marble quarry.3 The most
beautiful of the structures in this region’s cities (in Cyzicus Cyzicus (city), Belkiz Kale (Tky.)
in Pirossus (in Cyzicene possession, next to Zelia) where Zelia, Sariköy (Tky.)
royal hunts w ere held by the Lydians and later by the Per-
sians. Others identify Teria’s mountain with a hill, forty stades
outside Lampsacus, on which there is a temple to the Mother
of the Gods, who has the name “Teria.” |
589 C, 9-23 Lampsacus, too, is a coastal city. She has a good harbor Lampsacus/Pityussa, Lapseki 13.1.18
(Tky.)
and is worthy of note. Like Abydus (from which she is some
678
Propontic Coast of Fourth Section + Hinterland
city of Paesus was between Lampsacus and Parium, as also Paesus (city), nr. Çardak (Tky.)
the river.1 The city was torn down, and the Paesenians (who Paesus (river), Bayram Deresi
as the “Glossographer”). From Lampsacus came the writer Lampsacus, Lapseki (Tky.)
679
4.1. Northern Asia
ercota and Practius, / and held Sestus and Abydus and noble Arisbe,
P
/ these men w ere ruled by Asius the Hyrtacid (he says), . . . whose
horses brought him from Arisbe, / his great gleaming horses, from the
Sellëeis river. In saying this, he probably means to indicate that
Arisbe, the place from which he says Asius arrived, was Asius’s Arisbe, ?Musakoy (Tky.)
Sellëeis is near Arisbe (given that Asius came both from Arisbe
and from the river Sellëeis). T here is a “Practius” river, but no Practius (river), ?Ulu Dere
of Gyges, the Lydian king: this area, and the whole Trojan
region, belonged to Gyges. (There is a promontory near
Dardanus called “Gygas.”) Abydus lies at the mouth of the
Propontis and Hellespont, equally distant (about one hun- Propontis, Marmara Denizi
dred and seventy stades) from both Lampsacus and Ilium. Hellespont, Dardanelles/
Çanakkale Boğazı
The Heptastadium (Seven-stade [strait]) between Europe and
Asia, across which Xerxes made a bridge, is at Abydus. The
European headland, forming the strait where the bridge
Cherronesus, Gallipoli peninsula
is, is called the “Cherronesus” (Almost-island) because of its (Eur. Tky.)
[ 1 ] Strabo refers to a part of his narrative now lost, called in this translation the
“eastern European gap”: 329 C, 15–332 C, 1.
[ 2 ] As opposed to the Asian Cebrenians: 596 C, 24–597 C, 7; 606 C, 6-18.
680
Propontic Coast of Fourth Section + Hinterland
shape. Sestus, the best of the Cherronesian cities, is opposite Sestus, ?Yalikabat (Eur. Tky.)
but in the opposite direction (in the case of Sestus). The place in the opposite
direction = downstream
near Sestus where the pontoon bridge was attached is called
“Apobathra” (Landing-place). Since Sestus is farther inland rela-
tive to the Propontis, lying upstream relative to the Propon-
tis’s outgoing current, sailors find it easier to start out from
Sestus, picking their way along the coast a short distance as
far as Hero’s Tower and letting the current carry their ves-
sels from t here across to the other side. Sailors starting from
Abydus have to pick their way along the coast in the opposite Abydus, Maltepe (Tky.)
591 C, 30-33 Astyra, lying inland from Abydenian territory in the Astyra, nr. Haliloglu (Tky.) 13.1.23
to the Aesepus (less, if you sail in a straight line). | Aesepus, Gönen Çay
[ 1 ] Homer allocates both Abydus and Sestus to king Asius: 590 C, 3-22.
[ 2 ] Strabo refers to a part of his narrative now lost, called in this translation the
“eastern European gap”: 329 C, 15–332 C, 1.
681
4.1. Northern Asia
2nd stretch of Troad tum) coastal, part of it on the Trojan plain, and part of it on
the slopes of mount Ida that were under Aeneas’s control.1 Ida, Kaz Dağ
poet = Homer (8th c. BCE) The poet uses two names for this latter part. At one point
(saying the Dardanians were ruled by Anchises’s noble son) he calls
them “Dardanians,” but elsewhere “Dardanans” (Trojans and
Lycians and combative Dardanans). This is likely to have been
the location in antiquity of the city called by the poet “Darda-
nia” (Cloud-gathering Zeus was the father, first, of Dardanus, who
founded Dardania), even though these days no traces whatso-
ever of the city remain. |
592 C, 12-25 Plato hypothesizes that, after the floods, t here were three 13.1.25
Plato (late 5th–4th c. BCE) types of social structure; the first type was high among the mountain
peaks, unsophisticated and uncouth, with p eople living in fear of the
water that still covered the plains; the second type was on the lower
mountain slopes, with people at last gradually gaining confidence as
the plains began to dry out; the third type was on the plains. One
might equally well add a fourth type, a fifth type, and so on,
ending with a coastal and island-based type, in which all such
fear was washed away: the degree of confidence in venturing
nearer the sea would underscore still more differences in
social structures and manners, just as . . . * the uncouth yet
also somewhat s imple manners had been transformed into
the gentility of the people of the second type. These are paral-
leled by a distinction between “wild,” “semi-wild,” and “civi-
lized,” from which finally emerged the “refined” and supreme
culture brought about by the gradual transformation of . . . *
in accordance with the improvement of culture in line with
changes in location and lifestyle.
592 C, 26–593 C, 4 Plato says that the poet illustrates these developments by provid- poet = Homer
Plato (late 5th–4th c. BCE) ing an example of the first type of p olitical organization in the lifestyle
alludes to Homer’s Odyssey
(8th c. BCE)
of the Cyclopes, whose food is self-generated and whose homes are in
caves, high among the mountaintops (he says, “but, unsown and un-
plowed, everything grows” for them, and “they have neither advisory
councils nor established laws / but dwell among the high mountain
peaks / in hollow caves, and each man presides / over his children and
wives”); an example of the second type through the way of life in the
time of Dardanus (“he founded Dardania when sacred Ilius had not
yet / been built on the plain, a city for men gifted with speech, / and
[ 1 ] Strabo introduces his description of the 2nd stretch of the Troad (592 C,
1–605 C, 14), as per his e arlier division of the Troad into 4 stretches (581 C,
13–582 C, 3). For the coast in particular: 595 C, 9–596 C, 23; 603 C, 30–605 C, 14.
682
Aegean Coast of Fourth Section + Hinterland
wish that their city be the ancient one, have had to argue against
those whose evidence is derived from Homer’s poetry, for it is
not likely that their city is the Homeric one. O thers have con-
cluded that the city changed her location several times, her final
resting place being achieved in the time of Croesus. Croesus, Lydian king, 6th c. BCE
593 C, 16-18 These past migrations to the lower areas1 coincided, I be-
lieve, with advances in ways of making a living and in p olitical
structures—but this is a subject for another time. |
593 C, 19–594 C, 1 It is said that the city of the current-day Ilians was for city of “current-day” Ilians, 13.1.26
Hisarlık (Tky.)
some time a mere village, with a small and tawdry t emple to
Athena; that Alexander made an expedition to the t emple
after his victory on the Granicus, adorned it with dedicatory Granicus, Biga Çayı
which w ere old and in the final stages of decrepitude. This Lysimachus defeated
Antigonus, controlled much of
was at the time when Lysimachus also conferred favors on Asian peninsula, 301–281 BCE
Alexandria, which had already been expanded by Antigonus Alexandria/Antigonia,
Eskistanbul (Tky.)
and named “Antigonia,” but had undergone a change of name,
because it seemed proper for the successors of Alexander to
establish cities named after him first, then after themselves.
Alexandria survived and flourished. She now houses a colony
of Romans and is among the most illustrious of cities. |
683
4.1. Northern Asia
594 C, 2-8 Current-day Ilium was a sort of villageopolis when the Ilium, Hisarlık (Tky.) 13.1.27
obvious claims to kinship with the Ilians, strove with the zeal
of youth to be charitable to them. (His claims were “more
[ 1 ] The story about the arrival of the Galatians (278 BCE) is inconsistent with the
attribution (593 C, 19–594 C, 1) of the walls to Lysimachus (died 281 BCE).
[ 2 ] “Those associated with Callisthenes and Anaxarchus” is idiomatic, meaning
simply Callisthenes and Anaxarchus.
684
Aegean Coast of Fourth Section + Hinterland
spot seen from all around, followed by lake Pteleos; | then 13.1.30
Rhoetium, a city perched on a hill; following on from Rhoe- Rhoetium, Baba Kale (Tky.)
plain, and their w aters contain a lot of mud, which they Simoeis, Dümruk Su
deposit on the shore, forming a blind mouth, lagoons, and
685
4.1. Northern Asia
marshes. Opposite the Sigian headland on the Cherronesus Sigian headland, Kumkale
side are Protesilaeium and Elaeussa, which I described in the Elaeussa, E Tekke Burnu (Tky.)
Thracia.1 |
595 C, 35–596 C, 5 The length of this stretch of coastline, from Rhoetium to 13.1.32
it was he who sacked their city. But one might c ounter that
he “sacked” their city in such a way as to leave it for others to
complete the job—in a sorry state, but a city nevertheless. It
poet = Homer (8th c. BCE) is for this reason that the poet states: he stormed Ilius’s city, and
widowed the streets. To “widow” is to destroy the males, not to
annihilate completely. The individuals to whom they sacrifice
and whom they revere as gods—it is t hose who annihilated
the city completely!
596 C, 11-17 But they might cite as their reason that the latter carried latter = Achilles, Patroclus, etc.
they = Ilians out a just war, the former an unjust one on account of Laom- former = Heracles
Tenedian Peraea.4 |
596 C, 24-31 The preceding are maritime locations, inland from which 13.1.33
the Trojan plain reaches for many stades as far as Ida in the Ida, Kaz Dağ
[ 1 ] Thracia (lit., “Stuff about Thrace”) refers to the section of Strabo’s narrative
in which he describes the territory of Thrace (ne. Greece). Loss of this part of
Strabo’s narrative, 329 C, 15–332 C, 1. Strabo’s use of such “titles”: 639 C, 15-27n.
[ 2 ] Strabo refines his e arlier comment (573 C, 32–574 C, 13, where he calls the Trojans
“kings of kings”).
[ 3 ] I.e., the stretch to Sigium: 595 C, 20–596 C, 5.
[ 4 ] Strabo postpones discussion of the Tenedian Peraea—the mainland coast op-
posite the island of Tenedos (Bozcaada, Tk. island)—until 603 C, 30–604 C, 12.
686
Aegean Coast of Fourth Section + Hinterland
east. In regard to this plain, the part along the mountain slope
is narrow, stretching in one direction southward as far as the
Scepsis region, and in the other direction northward as far Scepsis, Kurşunlu Tepe (Tky.)
his name to the territory or, more credibly, the city); Cebrenia
reaches as far as Scepsia, and the Scamander flowing between them Scamander, Menderes Çay
forms the boundary; there was continual hatred and war between the
Cebrenians and the Scepsians u ntil Antigonus amalgamated them
into what was then “Antigonia” and is now “Alexandria”; therefore, Alexandria/Antigonia,
Eskistanbul (Tky.)
the Cebrenians remained with the others in Alexandria, but Lysima-
chus allowed the Scepsians to return to their own territory. |
597 C, 8-14 He says that, starting from the mountainous Idaean region, two He = Demetrius 13.1.34
spurs extend toward the sea, one directly to Rhoetium, the other to
Sigium, together forming a semicircular line; they end in the plain,
at the same distance from the sea as current-day Ilium; this Ilium lies “current-day” Ilium, Hisarlık
(Tky.)
midway between the ends of the said spurs, the ancient site midway
between their beginnings; enclosed within the spurs are the Simoei-
sian plain, through which the Simoeis courses, and the Scamandrian
plain, through which the Scamander flows.
597 C, 14-25 This latter plain has the proper name “Trojan,” and this is
poet = Homer (8th c. BCE) where the poet places most of the fighting—for it is broader.
Here we see the most famous sites identified: Erineus, Aesy-
etes’s burial mound, Batieia, Ilus’s tomb. The Scamander and Scamander r., Menderes Çay
Simoeis rivers—the one drawing near Sigium, the other near Simoeis r., Dümruk Su
687
4.1. Northern Asia
597 C, 25–598 C, 6 A little inland from this is Ilian Village, which is supposed Ilian Village, on Karatepe (Tky.) 13.1.35
to have once been the site of ancient Ilium, thirty stades from
the current-day city. Ten stades inland from Ilian Village is “current-day” city = Ilium,
Hisarlık (Tky.)
Callicolona (Hill-of-beauty), a hill from which the Simoeis is five
Callicolona, Karatepe (Tky.)
stades distant. This makes sense, first, of the statement con-
Simoeis r., Dümruk Su
Strabo cites Homer (8th c. BCE) cerning Ares: Ares rose up on the other side like a dark and furious
The Greek god Ares is depicted
storm, / shouting shrill orders to the Trojans from the city’s heights / in the Iliad as fighting on the
at other times racing along by the Simoeis, to Callicolona. Since the Trojan side
through the plain and joining the Scamander at the t emple Scamander r., Menderes Çay
of spirit on the other side. “Absence of intelligence” in that other side = Trojans
they left it unwalled for so long a time, despite its proximity they = Greeks
to the city and to the multitudinous host within the city and
he = Homer (8th c. BCE) among the allies: for he says that the wall had only recently been
built (although it perhaps did not exist but was fabricated by
Aristotle (4th c. BCE) the poet and then made to disappear, as suggested by Aristotle).
“Absence of spirit” in that, although they broached the wall
[ 1 ] Presumably, “Erineus” received its name only to give credence to the claim that
Ilian Village was the Homeric Ilium. Ditto for “Phegus” (further below).
688
Aegean Coast of Fourth Section + Hinterland
a fter it had been built, attacking the Ships Station and taking
the battle to the ships, they never dared to go and besiege the
Ships Station while it was unwalled. This, despite the fact that
it was not far away: for the Ships Station is near Sigium, with Sigium, Yenişehir (Tky.)
the Scamander’s mouth—only twenty stades from Ilium— Scamander, Menderes Çay
close by.
598 C, 31-36 If anyone says that what is even now called “Harbor of the
Achaeans” was used as the ships station, then he is talking
about an even closer location—it is only some twelve stades
from the city, even taking into account the coastal plain in city = Ilium, Hisarlık (Tky.)
away (i.e., a long way away from their own wall), or cityward
/ will retrace their steps. And consider well, my friends. I, at any
rate, bid you / go now to the city, says Pulydamas, we are a long
way from our wall.
599 C, 17-30 Demetrius cites as a witness Hestiaea of Alexandria who, in
Demetrius (2nd c. BCE) cites writing about Homer’s Iliad, questions whether the war was fought
Hestiaea (2nd c. BCE or earlier)
around the current-day city and . . . * the Trojan plain, understood “current-day” city = Ilium,
Hisarlık (Tky.)
by the poet as being between the city and the sea, on the grounds that
“the plain that can be seen in front of the current-day city was formed
later, out of sediment deposited by the rivers.” | And Polites, who was 13.1.37
the Trojan lookout, sat / trusting in his swiftness of foot / on the very
top of the tomb of old Aesyetes, was a fool. Even if he was sitting
on the very top, he nevertheless could have kept watch from
the much greater height of the acropolis over virtually the
same distance—without having to rely on his swiftness of foot
for safety! (What is now identified as the tomb of Aesyetes is five
stades away along the road to Alexandria.) Nor does Hector’s
race around the city make any sense: it is not possible to race
around the current-day city b ecause of the adjacent ridge, but
it is possible to race around the ancient city. |
599 C, 31-34 The fact that no trace remains of the ancient city is ex- 13.1.38
689
4.1. Northern Asia
stones removed from the ancient city. Sigium was taken by the
Athenians who sent out Phrynon the Olympian, when Lesbos
was laying claim to virtually the entire Troad (the majority of
settlements—some still remaining, others now vanished—
were founded by Lesbos). Pittacus of Mitylene, one of what
are called the “Seven Sages,” sailed against Phrynon and, as
general, carried out a prolonged war and suffered badly. This
Alcaeus (late 7th–early 6th c. was the time when the poet Alcaeus says that he, faring badly
BCE)
in b attle, threw down his weapons and fled. He addresses a
herald, bidding him announce to t hose back home: Alcaeus is
safe . . . * / has been dedicated in the t emple to “Bright-eyes” by the
Atticans. Later, when Phrynon challenged him to single com-
bat, Alcaeus grabbed his fishing gear and ran out to meet him,
tangled him in the fishing net, stabbed him with the harpoon
and the knife, and killed him!
600 C, 10-17 The war still continued, however, and it was Periander,
Demetrius (2nd c. BCE) cites chosen as an arbiter by both sides, who concluded the war. |
Timaeus (4th–3rd c. BCE)
Demetrius says that Timaeus is lying when he records that “Peri- 13.1.39
ander, using t hese stones from Ilium, fortified Achillium against the
Athenians and thus aided those associated with Pittacus.” 1 This place
was fortified against Sigium by the Mitylenaeans—that is, not with
such stones and not by Periander, for why would they choose their
enemy as arbiter?
600 C, 17-22 Achillium, a tiny settlement, is the spot where Achil-
les’s memorial is located. And Sigium, too, was leveled by Sigium, Yenişehir (Tky.)
600 C, 22-23 Thucydides says that Troy was taken from the Mitylenaeans by
Thucydides (5th c. BCE) the Athenians during the Peloponnesian war when it was conducted
by Paches. |
600 C, 24–601 C, 4 The current-day Ilians say this, too, that their city was 13.1.40
690
Aegean Coast of Fourth Section + Hinterland
Homer (8th c. BCE) to the city’s erasure: the day will come when sacred Ilius is de-
stroyed; and we have utterly sacked Priam’s city on high; and through
counsel and words;1 and Priam’s city was sacked in the tenth year.
Other such things are cited as evidence of the same thing.
For example, the cult statue of Athena shows her standing
up, whereas Homer represents her as sitting down. He gives
instructions to lay upon Athena’s knees a robe, in the same sense
as never to have a beloved son sitting upon his knees. It is better to
understand it thus, than to take it as meaning, as some do,
“to lay beside Athena’s knees” (citing she sits upon the hearth in
the light of the fire as meaning “she sits beside the hearth”). How
are we to imagine the positioning of the robe beside the knees?
Those who change the accentuation (gounásin, like thyiásin),
in whichever sense they understand it, are talking aimlessly,
whether . . . * suppliants . . . *. Many ancient cult statues of
Athena show her sitting down—for example, in Phocaea,
Massalia, Rome, Chios, and various other cities.
601 C, 24-27 There is consensus about the city’s annihilation among
Lycurgus (4th c. BCE) more recent individuals, including Lycurgus, the public
speaker: he says, in reference to the Ilians’ city, who has not
heard that once it was leveled by the Greeks, and is uninhabited? |
601 C, 28-33 It is surmised that people who later wanted to refound the 13.1.42
[ 1 ] Fuller citation of the relevant line from Homer: 17 C, 6-16, with reference to
Odysseus’s part in the sack of Troy.
691
4.1. Northern Asia
on a site by the Simoeis, which was not well defended and as Simoeis, Dümruk Su
it lies some hundred and twenty stades above Scepsis—from which Scepsis, Kurşunlu Tepe (Tky.)
flow the Scamander, the Granicus, and the Aesepus. The latter two, Scamander, Menderes Çay
each formed from the merging of several sources, flow northward to Granicus, Biga Çayı
the Propontis; the Scamander flows westward from one source. The Aesepus, Gönen Çay
sources are all close together, within a distance of twenty stades. The Propontis, Marmara Denizi
end of the Aesepus lies at the greatest distance from its source, virtu-
ally five hundred stades
602 C, 16-31 A problem arises with the poet’s statement that they came
poet = Homer (8th c. BCE) to the two fair-flowing springs. From there / stream forth the two
sources of the eddying Scamander. / One flows with w ater that is
tepid—that is to say, warm. He continues, and, around it, a
vapor / rises off it, as if from a fire. / The other flows, even in summer,
with w ater like hail / or cold snow. No warm waters are found at
that place now; the source of the Scamander is not there but Scamander, Menderes Çay
692
Aegean Coast of Fourth Section + Hinterland
603 C, 13-21 In the Aesepus valley itself, on the left of the river, first t here’s 13.1.45
693
4.1. Northern Asia
603 C, 24-28 While in these matters he is open to such objections, I sup- he = Demetrius
Peraea, Achaeium, and Tenedos itself (not more than forty Tenedian Peraea = coast
opposite Tenedos, Bozcaada
stades from the mainland). With a perimeter of some eighty (Tk. island)
stades, Tenedos has an Aeolian city, two harbors, and a t emple Achaeium, Hantepe (Tky.)
poet = Homer (8th c. BCE) to “Sminthian” Apollo (to which the poet bears witness, when
he says, you mighty lord of Tenedos, / O Sminthian). T here are
several small islands around Tenedos, including two called
the “Calydnians,” lying on the sailing route to Lectum. Some Calydnians, Tavşanadası
(Tk. islands)
people said that Tenedos itself was “Calydna” (others, that
it was “Leucophrys”). The myth of Tennes, a fter whom the
island is named, is set in Tenedos; also the myth of Cycnus,
Thracian by descent (and the father, according to some, of
Tennes) and king of Colonae. |
604 C, 13-19 Following on from Achaeium, t here used to be Larisa Larisa, Limantepe (Tky.) 13.1.47
and Colonae (on the mainland coast that formerly belonged Colonae, Beşiktepe (Tky.)
to Lesbos) and current-day Chrysa4 (built on a rocky out- Chrysa, Göztepe (Tky.)
crop above the sea), and Hamaxitus (under and adjacent Hamaxitus, Beşiktepe, Gülpınar
(Tky.)
to Lectum). Nowadays, Alexandria comes after Achaeium,
Alexandria, Eskinstanbul (Tky.)
and these towns5 (together with several other forts, includ-
ing Cebrene and Neandria) have been amalgamated with
Alexandria; and Alexandrians control the territory. The
site on which Alexandria is now situated used to be called
“Sigia.” |
604 C, 20-36 In the aforementioned Chrysa is the temple to “Smin- 13.1.48
[ 1 ] The Catalogue is the part of the Iliad in which Homer lists the forces fighting
at Troy (4 C, 14-20n), within which the Trojan Catalogue deals with the Trojan
forces: 442 C, 35–443 C, 9n. Strabo later (607 C, 6–621 C, 28) engages more
extensively with Demetrius of Scepsis.
[ 2 ] E.g., the “Palaescepsis” mentioned at 607 C, 6-19?
[ 3 ] Strabo reprises the thread of his narrative from 596 C, 22-23.
[ 4 ] Strabo distinguishes “current-day” Chrysa (Göztepe, Tky.), which he elsewhere
calls “Hamaxitan Chrysa,” from what he believes to be the site of Homer’s
Chrysa (Mağara Tepe, Tky.), elsewhere called “Cilician Chrysa.” Strabo locates
Homer’s Chrysa farther along the coast: 612 C, 15–613 C, 15.
[ 5 ] I.e., Larisa, Colonae, Chrysa, and Hamaxitus.
694
Aegean Coast of Fourth Section + Hinterland
an oracle that they should halt wherever they were attacked by oracle, instruction from the
gods
the “earthborn.” This is said to have happened in the Hamaxi-
tus region. A g reat swarm of field mice sprang up in the night
and chomped through the leather parts of the men’s weap-
ons and equipment; and the Teucrians halted t here (naming
Heraclides (4th c. BCE) “Ida” after the Ida in Crete). Heraclides of Pontus says that
the swarms of mice around the temple were believed to be sacred, and
that this was why the statue was shown stepping on a mouse. Others
say that a certain Teucer of the Trojan deme (now called the deme, civic division of Athens
3rd stretch of Troad nificent Aeolian cities and the Adramyttenian bay, where the Adramyttenian bay, Gulf of
Edremit
poet appears to place most of the Lelegians and the two sets
of Cilicians.4 Here also is the stretch of shoreline belonging to
the Mitylenaeans (the Mitylenaeans possess several villages
on the mainland). The bay is additionally called “Idaean”:
the mountain ridge that stretches from Lectum to Ida lies
inland from the first part of the bay. This is where the poet
695
4.1. Northern Asia
from her and closer to Ilium, from which they are one hun-
dred and thirty stades away; farther inland from these are
the Cebrenians; and farther above the Cebrenians are the
Dardanians as far as Palaescepsis and as far as Scepsis itself. Scepsis, Kurşunlu Tepe (Tky.)
Alcaeus (late 7th–early Alcaeus calls Antandrus Lelegian city (as in, first of all, Antan- Antandrus, Devren/Avcılar
6th c. BCE) (Tky.)
drus, Lelegian city). The Scepsian categorizes her among the
Scepsian = Demetrius
(2nd c. BCE) neighboring cities, which would mean that she should be in-
cluded in the territory of the Cilicians. The latter are next to
the Lelegians, more or less defining the southern flank of Ida,
but they are nevertheless at a low level, linking up rather more
Adramyttium, Karataş, Ören
with the coastline at Adramyttium. (Tky.)
606 C, 18-27 Forty stades after Lectum is a small place, Polymedium; Polymedium, Asarlık (Tky.)
then, eighty stades farther on, set back a l ittle from the coast,
is Assus; and one hundred and forty stades farther on is Assus, Beyramkale (Tky.)
Gargara. Gargara is situated on a headland forming the bay Gargara, nr. Arkılı (Tky.)
696
Aegean Coast of Fourth Section + Hinterland
serted city with harbor. Above her, in the interior, are the cop-
Perperena, Aşagı Beyköy (Tky.) per mine, Perperena, Trarium, and other such settlements.
Trarium, Assarkaya, nr. Yukarı On the coastline beyond her are the Mitylenaean villages of
Beyköy (Tky.)
Coryphantis and Heraclia, followed by Attea, then Atarneus, Coryphantis, nr. Keremköy (Tky.)
near Polichna, on the highest part of Ida, and was at that stage
called “Scepsis”—perhaps for other reasons but perhaps (if
one has to seek in the Greek language the etymology of names
in use among the natives at that time) because the place was
perisceptus (with an all-around view). Her residents were later trans-
ferred sixty stades lower down, to current-day Scepsis, by “current-day” Scepsis, Kurşunlu
Tepe (Tky.)
Scamandrius (Hector’s son) and Ascanius ( Aeneas’s son). It
is said that, for a long time, t here w ere two ruling families
here. Afterward, t here was a changeover to an oligarchy and
then, when the Milesians joined the citizen body, they lived
in a democracy (although the ruling families’ descendants
were still called “kings” and enjoyed certain privileges);
Antigonus campaigned for then Antigonus moved the Scepsians to Alexandria; then
control of Alexander the Great’s Lysimachus defeated
empire, 323–301 BCE
Lysimachus discharged them, and they moved back home. | Antigonus, controlled much of
Asian peninsula, 301–281 BCE
[ 1 ] “These places” = Atarneus (Gavurgör, Tky.), Pitana (Çandarlı, Tky.), and the out- [ 3 ] Strabo’s statement concerning Canae (Kara Dağ) is not true for a sailor follow-
lets of the Caecus (Bakır Çay). Strabo may have confused this “Atarneus” (Ga- ing an overall southward course (previous note). Strabo has perhaps confused
vurgör) with the inland “Atarneus” (Kale Tepe, Tky.), which perhaps contributes himself by temporarily adopting a reverse (northward) perspective: 606 C,
to his mislocation of Canae (following notes). He later distinguishes between 18-27n. A northward direction is used for the 4th stretch of the Troad:
the two places called “Atarneus”: 614 C, 25–615 C, 2. 622 C, 1-15n.
[ 2 ] Elaea (Kazıkbağları, Tky.) is “on the far side” of the Caecus river (Bakır Çay) from [ 4 ] The reader might be forgiven for thinking it unlikely that Strabo has “over-
the point of view of a sailor following an overall southward course, which is the looked” anything in his already extensive description of the Troad: 581 C,
perspective a dopted by Strabo throughout his description of the Troad so far: 1–607 C, 6. Strabo is perhaps picking up on his comments regarding Demetrius
581 C, 13–582 C, 3. of Scepsis: 603 C, 24-30n.
697
4.1. Northern Asia
607 C, 20-27 The Scepsian thinks that Scepsis was a royal residence of 13.1.53
Scepsian = Demetrius eneas, as it lies midway between Aeneas’s territory and Lyrnessus,
A Lyrnessus, Ala Dağ (Tky.)
(2nd c. BCE), who cites
Homer (8th c. BCE)
to which Aeneas is said to have fled when pursued by Achilles (for
Achilles says, “Do you not remember when, from the solitary tending
of your c attle, / swift of foot, I drove you down the Idaean moun-
tains? . . . Thence you fled to Lyrnessus, and I / pursued you and
sacked the city”).
607 C, 28–608 C, 6 Inconsistent with the account just given about the
founders of Scepsis1 are the stories that are spread about Ae-
neas: that he lived on after the war (thanks to his ill will toward
Strabo cites Homer (8th c. BCE) Priam: he always hated noble Priam, / who never granted him any
honors, though he was valiant among men), as did Aeneas’s fellow
rulers, namely Antenor’s sons and Antenor himself (thanks
to the hospitality Antenor had shown toward Menelaus—
Sophocles (5th c. BCE) Sophocles says, in The Fall of Ilium, that a leopard skin was
put in front of Antenor’s door as a sign that the household
was not to be sacked); and that, while Antenor and his sons
together with the surviving Enetians crossed over to Thrace
and from there dispersed through what is called “Adriatic En-
etia,” Aeneas together with his f ather, Anchises, and his son,
Ascanius, assembled his people and put to sea.
608 C, 7-14 Some say that Aeneas settled in the region of Macedonian
Olympus; o thers that he founded Capyae in the region of Ar-
cadian Mantinia (naming the settlement a fter Capys). Yet
others say that he landed, together with the Trojan Elymus,
in Sicilian Aegesta; took possession of Eryx and Lilybaeum;
named rivers near Aegesta “Scamander” and “Simoeis”;
thence proceeded into Latin country, where he stayed put, in
accordance with an oracle bidding him stay wherever he might oracle, instruction from the
gods
eat his table. This came to pass near Lavinium in Latina—no
table was available, but a huge loaf of bread was used instead
and consumed along with the meat set upon it.
608 C, 14-27 Homer appears to provide support for none of these, nor
Homer (8th c. BCE) even for the account of the founders of Scepsis given above.2
Homer has Aeneas staying in Troy and, with the extinction
of Priam’s line, inheriting the kingdom and passing on the
succession through his son’s sons: Cronus’s son already showed
his hatred of Priam’s line. / Now, the Trojans w
ill be ruled by Aeneas’s
might / and by sons born to his sons in times to come. So not even
the succession of Scamandrius can be preserved! T here’s an
698
Aegean Coast of Fourth Section + Hinterland
699
4.1. Northern Asia
[ 1 ] In this account, Strabo looks back over decades, first to the acquisition of the
Aristotle/Theophrastus papyrus rolls by dealers (80s BCE); then to Tyrannio’s in-
volvement with the papyrus rolls, probably as described to Strabo by Tyrannio
himself (30s BCE); finally, to Strabo’s own experience with papyrus-roll dealers
in Alexandria (early 20s BCE and l ater). Strabo’s presence in Rome: 273 C, 2-14n.
Strabo’s presence in Alexandria: 101 C, 14-24n.
[ 2 ] The Catalogue is the part of the Iliad in which Homer lists the forces fighting
at Troy (4 C, 14-20n), within which the Trojan Catalogue deals with the Trojan
forces: 442 C, 35–443 C, 9n.
700
Aegean Coast of Fourth Section + Hinterland
610 C, 18-30 Cleanthes was from Assus—he was the Stoic philosopher Cleanthes, 3rd c. BCE
who inherited the school of Zeno of Citium and bequeathed it Zeno, 4th–3rd c. BCE
to Chrysippus of Soli. Aristotle spent some time at Assus on Chrysippus, 3rd c. BCE
account of his connection by marriage to Hermias, its ruler. Hermias, 4th c. BCE
on his return, ruled at first jointly with his o wner (who had Aristotle, Xenocrates, 4th c. BCE
attacked the places around Atarneus and Assus), and then
succeeded him. Hermias sent for Aristotle and Xenocrates,
taking good care of them and arranging for the marriage of
his brother’s d aughter to Aristotle. Memnon of Rhodes was
working at the time for the Persians. As military commander,
Memnon feigned friendship and invited Hermias to visit, the
pretence being that it was for reasons of hospitality and busi-
ness, but he arrested Hermias and sent him up to the king,
where Hermias was strung up and killed. The p hilosophers
saved themselves by fleeing from the places, which the Per-
sians seized. |
610 C, 31–611 C, 3 Myrsilus says that Assus was founded by the Methymnaeans; Assus, Beyramkale (Tky.) 13.1.58
Myrsilus (3rd c. BCE) Hellanicus says that Assus is Aeolian, too, so that Gargara and Gargara, nr. Arkılı (Tky.)
Hellanicus (5th c. BCE) Lamponia would also be Aeolian, since Gargara was founded Lamponia, Kozlu Dağ (Tky.)
[ 1 ] With the expression “these places,” Strabo picks up the thread of his narrative
from 610 C, 8-18, where Andira, Pioniae, the Gargarid, and Assus are mentioned.
[ 2 ] Strabo deduces that t here must have been such a city in Homeric times, on the
basis of its mention by Homer in the Iliad: 605 C, 15–606 C, 4.
701
4.1. Northern Asia
[ 1 ] 572 C, 21-30.
[ 2 ] Chryseïs is the Trojan w
oman (daughter of the priest of Apollo) whose abduc-
tion by the Greeks precipitates much of the action in Homer’s Iliad.
[ 3 ] Strabo argues that the Homeric Chrysa is to be identified with Cilician Chrysa
(Mağara Tepe, Tky.) (612 C, 24–613 C, 15), as opposed to Hamaxitan Chrysa
(604 C, 13–605 C, 3).
702
Aegean Coast of Fourth Section + Hinterland
[ 1 ] The argument for Hamaxitan Chrysa being the Homeric Chrysa may have been
that the t emple in Hamaxitan Chrysa to “Sminthian” Apollo (604 C, 20-36) was
originally to “Cillian” Apollo.
[ 2 ] Why then does Strabo believe that t here was once a town and t emple there?
See 605 C, 1-3.
[ 3 ] Hamaxitan Chrysa (Göztepe, Tky.): 604 C, 13-36. Strabo has to explain the exis-
tence there of a temple to Apollo, which is essential to the plot line in the Iliad
and would seem to support Hamaxitan Chrysa as the Homeric Chrysa.
[ 4 ] Strabo argues that Cilician Chrysa (Mağara Tepe, Tky.) is the Chrysa mentioned
by Homer, rather than Hamaxitan Chrysa: 604 C, 13-19n.
703
4.1. Northern Asia
Pelops and held command over the region, and that Cilicia
possibly gets its name from him, or vice versa. |
613 C, 19-28 We should transfer to this location1 the story of the Teu- 13.1.64
tium. Misfortune dogged Adramyttium in the war against Adramyttium, Karataş, Ören
(Tky.)
Mithridates. The council of citizens was murdered by Dio-
dorus, a general who was in the king’s favor and who claimed
to be one of the philosophers from the Academy, a dispenser
of justice and a teacher of rhetoric! He went off to Pontus
with the king, but when the king fell, Diodorus paid his just
[ 1 ] I.e., to Cilician Chrysa (Mağara Tepe, Tky.) from Hamaxitan Chrysa (Göztepe, Tky.).
[ 2 ] Strabo believes that the t emple to “Sminthian” (Mousy) Apollo, which in his day
stands in Hamaxitan Chrysa (604 C, 20-36), originally stood in Cilician Chrysa.
[ 3 ] “Ancient Chrysa”—or Cilician Chrysa—and its temple are probably hypothetical
constructions by Strabo: 612 C, 24-28nn.
[ 4 ] In the Greek language, names take different endings according to the role they
play in a sentence. Plakoi could be formed from e ither the name “Plax” or the
name “Plakos.”
[ 5 ] Strabo refers to the part of his narrative (611 C, 10–614 C, 4) dealing with the
Lelegian and Cilician (to use Homeric nomenclature) coastline. His discussion
has so far largely centered on hypothetical Homeric sites. This coastline coin-
cides with what, in Strabo’s day, is called the region of Adramyttium, and it is
this latter city that Strabo now proceeds to describe.
704
Aegean Coast of Fourth Section + Hinterland
and thirty stades from Andira. The cave was brought to light
by a young goat, when it fell into the cave at its mouth and
was found the following day at Andira by the goatherd, who
by chance had gone t here to make a sacrifice!
614 C, 25–615 C, 2 Atarneus is the capital of the tyrant Hermias. Then t here’s Atarneus, Kale Tepe, nr. Dikili
(Tky.)
Pitana, an Aeolian city with two harbors; r unning past it is the
Pitana, Çandarlı (Tky.)
river Euenus, which feeds the aqueduct built by the Adramyt-
tenians. From Pitana comes Arcesilaus of the Academy, who Arcesilaus, 3rd c. BCE
studied alongside Zeno of Citium u nder Polemo. T here is a Zeno, Polemo, 4th–3rd c. BCE
called the “Elaïtic bay.” On the far side of the Caecus,1 twelve
stades away from the river, is the Aeolian city of Elaea, which Elaea, Kazıkbağları (Tky.)
hundred stades, is Cana, the promontory across from Lectum Cana, Kara Dağ
that forms the Adramyttenian bay, of which the Elaïtic bay Lectum, Bababurnu
is part.2
615 C, 8-17 Canae is a town belonging to Locrians from Cynus, and Canae, Acan Limanı (Bademli)
(Tky.)
it lies in Canaea, opposite the southernmost end of Lesbos.
Canaea stretches to the Arginusae and to the headland above Arginusae, Makronisi (Tk.
islands)
them, which some p eople call Aiga (Goat),3 like the animal, but
Aiga headland, s. Gulf of
one should make the second syllable long—Aigan,4 like aktan Edremit
[ 1 ] Elaea (Kazıkbağları, Tky.) is “on the far side” of the Caecus river from the point
of view of a sailor following the coast in an overall southward direction.
[ 2 ] For Strabo’s mislocation of Cana (Kara Dağ) relative to the Elaïtic bay: 606 C,
18-27n.
[ 3 ] The name is actually Aix (= Goat), but Strabo gives the name in the grammati-
cally inflected form Aiga, as required by his sentence structure.
[ 4 ] This alternative version of the name is Aiga, but Strabo gives it in the grammati-
cally inflected form Aigan. Strabo plays with his audience, punning on inflected
and uninflected forms of the names.
705
4.1. Northern Asia
and archan. This name was once applied to the whole moun-
tain that they now call “Cana” or “Canae.” The mountain is Cana(e) (mountain), Kara Dağ
surrounded at its base by the sea to the south and west, by the
Caecus plain to the east, and by the Elaïtis to the north. The
mountain is in itself quite compact but juts into the “Aegaean”
sea, from which it takes its name. Later, only the actual prom-
Sappho (7th c. BCE) ontory was called Aiga (as by Sappho) and the rest was called
“Cana” or “Canae.” |
615 C, 18-27 Lying between Elaea, Pitana, Atarneus, and Pergamum— 13.1.69
that Teuthras was a king of the Cilicians and Mysians. inside the Caecus = north of
Bakır Çay
Euripides (5th c. BCE) Euripides says that Auge and her son, Telephus, were shut in a chest
and thrown into the sea by Aleus (Auge’s father), when he discov-
ered that she had been violated by Heracles; the chest, floating across
the sea under the providence of Athena, washed up at the mouth of
the Caecus; Teuthras rescued t hese individuals, making the w oman
his wife and treating the boy as his own son. That is the mythical
account: there must have been some other coincidence by
means of which the Arcadian’s daughter married the Mysian
king and her son inherited his kingdom.
615 C, 27–616 C, 10 It is believed, then, that both Teuthras and Telephus
reigned over the territory in the region of Teuthrania and
poet = Homer (8th c. BCE) the Caecus. The poet makes only this reference to the story:
with his bronze, he slew the son of Telephus, / the hero Eurypylus.
The many comrades around him, / the Cetians, were killed as a
result of a woman’s gifts. Rather than speaking clearly, he leaves
us guessing: we do not know who is to be understood by
Cetians nor the meaning of as a result of a woman’s gifts, but
the literary experts, by comparing mythical details, come
up with ingenious explanations rather than offering the re-
quired solution. | Let these matters be left aside, and let me 13.1.70
706
Aegean Coast of Fourth Section + Hinterland
616 C, 11-22 The Caecus does not flow from Ida, as Bacchylides claims; Caecus, Bakır Çay
bian island begins with Sigrium, its northern promontory. Sigrium, Sigri (Lesbos)
Somewhere around t here lies Methymna, a L esbian city sixty Methymna, Methymna (Lesbos)
707
4.1. Northern Asia
708
Aegean Coast of Fourth Section + Hinterland
618 C, 8-16 Pyrrha has been demolished, but its suburb is inhabited Pyrrha, Megale Limne (Lesbos) 13.2.4
avoid the name’s connotations, say that the place there should
be called “Poroselene” (Narrows); that rocky and bare mount
Aspordenum in the Pergamum region should be called
709
4.1. Northern Asia
Strabo returns to his description Trojans being such as described,2 an explanation is required
of the 3rd stretch of the Troad
as to why the Lelegians and Cilicians are not included with
them in the Catalogue.3 It is reasonable to assume that, since
their leaders had been killed and their cities sacked, those
few Cilicians who survived came under Hector’s control.
Eëtion and his sons are said to have been killed before the
Strabo cites Homer (8th c. BCE) Catalogue: Noble Achilles killed my f ather / and sacked the Cili-
cian city . . . / Thebe with her gates so high . . . / . . . I had seven
brothers in my home / and, in one day, all of them went to Hades’s
realm. / Noble Achilles, swift of foot, killed them all. Likewise,
Mynes’s men have lost both their leaders and their city:
he slew Mynes and Epistrophus; and he sacked the city of godlike
Mynes.
619 C, 30-41 As for the Lelegians, on the one hand, he represents them he = Homer
710
Aegean Coast of Fourth Section + Hinterland
people, on the basis of both what Homer says and other re-
search. Homer says this: Hippothous led the spear-loving Pelas-
gian tribes / who dwelt in Larisa of the fertile soil. / They were ruled
by Hippothous and by Pylaeus, a scion of Ares, / both of them the sons
of Pelasgian Lethus, the son of Teutamus. He thus indicates that
there was an impressive horde of Pelasgians (he did not say
tribe, but tribes) and shows that they resided in Larisa.
620 C, 22-27 While there are many “Larisas,” one has to understand the
reference as being to one of those in the vicinity and would
most correctly assume the reference as being to the city in
the Cyme region. Of the three “Larisas,” the Hamaxitan one Cyme, Nemrut Limanı (Tky.)
is within sight of Ilium and very close to it, only some two Hamaxitan Larisa, Limantepe
(Tky.)
hundred stades away. Hippothous could not plausibly be said
to have fallen in the contest with Patroclus far from Larisa,
meaning this one, but rather the “Larisa” in the Cyme region, Larisa in Cyme region, Buruncuk
(Tky.)
since t here was some thousand stades in between.
620 C, 27-33 The third “Larisa” is a village in Ephesian territory, on the Larisa in Ephesian territory,
nr. Çatal (Tky.)
Caystrian plain, which is said to have once been a city with
a temple to “Larisenian” Apollo. She is nearer to Tmolus
than Ephesus, from which city she is one hundred and eighty
stades distant, so that one would categorize her as subject to
the Meionians. (The Ephesians later increased in power and
appropriated much of the territory of the Meionians—whom
we now call “Lydians”). So she would not be the Pelasgian
“Larisa,” but the other city would be a better fit. other city = Larisa in Cyme
region, Buruncuk (Tky.)
620 C, 33–621 C, 10 We have no good evidence that the “Larisa” in Caystrian
territory (nor even, for that m atter, Ephesus) had even come
into existence in t hose days, whereas the “Larisa” in the Cyme “Larisa” in Cyme region,
Buruncuk (Tky.)
region is attested throughout Aeolian history, which started
Trojan period, late 2nd–early
only a little a fter the Trojan period. | It is said that t hose 1st millennium BCE
13.3.3
who set out from Phricium, the Locrian mountain above “current-day” Cyme, Nemrut
Thermopylae, made landfall at the site of current-day Cyme; Limanı (Tky.)
711
4.1. Northern Asia
tains that rise up over Cymaea and the country of the Phocae- Hermagoras, late 2nd c. BCE
ans and Smyrnaeans, through which the Hermus runs. (Not Hermus, Gediz Çay
This area experienced far from t hese cities is Magnesia-under-Sipylus, classified as Magnesia-under-Sipylus,
earthquakes, 17 CE Manisa (Tky.)
a free city by the Romans—she, too, suffered from the recent
earthquakes.)
712
Aegean Coast of Fourth Section + Hinterland
622 C, 1-15 Going in the opposite direction,1 toward the Caecus, Larisa, Buruncuk (Tky.)
an equal number from there to Grynium and from Grynium Myrina, at mouth of Koca Çay
(Tky.)
Artemidorus (late 2nd–early to Elaea.2 According to Artemidorus, Adae comes after Cyme;
1st c. BCE) Grynium, Termaşalık Burnu
forty stades farther on is a headland called “Hydra” (which together
Elaea, Kazıkbağları (Tky.)
with the opposite headland, Harmatus, forms the Elaïtic bay, the
Elaïtic bay, Gulf of Çandarlı
mouth of which is around eighty stades wide); 3 at a distance of sixty
stades as m
easured along the coast, there’s the Aeolian city of Myrina,
with a harbor; then t here’s Achaean Harbor, with its altars to the Achaean Harbor, Haci Ahmet
Ağa (Tky.)
twelve gods; then a small Myrinaean town (Grynium), and a t emple
to Apollo—an ancient center of prophecy and an extravagant t emple
made of white marble; it is forty stades to t here; then it is seventy
stades to Elaea (with her harbor, and seaport belonging to the Attalic Attalic kings ruled Pergamum
(w. Tky.) early 3rd c. BCE–late
kings), founded by Menestheus and the Athenians who accompanied 2nd c. BCE
him on the expedition against Ilium. The places that come next— Menestheus, Greek hero of
the region of Pitana, Atarneus, and other places there—have Trojan war (late 2nd–early
1st millennium BCE)
already been dealt with.4 |
622 C, 16-28 The largest and best Aeolian city is Cyme, which, like Cyme, Nemrut Limanı (Tky.) 13.3.6
[ 1 ] Strabo, having described the 1st, 2nd, and 3rd stretches of the Troad from the
point of view of a sailor following an overall southerly course (586 C, 30–621 C,
28), reverses direction and describes the 4th stretch as if traveling northward
from its southernmost point—the Hermus river (Gediz Çay)—to the Caecus river
(Bakır Çay).
[ 2 ] These distances are probably m easured along a road: cf. 663 C, 8-19.
[ 3 ] Strabo’s citation of Artemidorus corrects his e arlier mislocation of the Elaïtic
bay: 606 C, 18-27n.
[ 4 ] Pitana, Atarneus, etc.: 606 C, 33–607 C, 6; 614, 25–615 C, 2.
713
4.1. Northern Asia
Hesiod (late 8th–7th c. BCE) Hesiod, who himself told the story of how his f ather, Dius,
relocated to the Boeotians, leaving Aeolian Cyme . . . and made
his home near Helicon in a wretched village, / Ascra, terrible in win-
ter, hard in summer, and never pleasant. (Not indisputably from
Homer (8th c. BCE) this city is Homer, to whom many lay claim!)1 It is said that
the city was named after an Amazon woman, as likewise the
city of Myrina was named after the “Myrina” who lies buried Myrina, at mouth of Koca Çay
(Tky.)
under Batieia, in the Trojan plain (called by mankind “Batieia,”
/ by immortals the “Tomb of Sprightly Myrina” ). The joke about
Ephorus (4th c. BCE) Ephorus is that he was unable to point to any of his home
city’s activities in his enumeration of historical events but,
being unwilling to overlook her, said: at this time, the Cymaeans
were at peace!
623 C, 10-12 Since I have now traversed the Trojan and Aeolian
shorelines,2 the next thing to do is to run through the interior
as far as the Taurus, still maintaining the same methodologi-
cal approach. |
623 C, 12-16 Pergamum, a famous city and one that for a long time Pergamum, Bergama (Tky.) 13.4.1
PERGAMUM shared in the good fortune of the Attalic kings, holds some Attalic kings ruled Pergamum
w. Turkey early 3rd–late 2nd c. BCE
sort of hegemony over t hese places, and it is from this city
that I must start the next stage of my geographical journey,
starting with a brief explanation of whence these kings came
and how they ended up.
623 C, 17-34 Pergamum was the t reasury of one of Alexander’s succes- Alexander the G
reat died,
323 BCE
sors (Lysimachus, son of Agathocles), with only the summit
Lysimachus controlled much of
strobiloid, pinecone-shaped of the mountain being settled. The mountain is strobiloid and Asian peninsula, 301–281 BCE
ends in a sharp peak. The safekeeping of the stronghold and
its treasure—comprising nine thousand talents—had been talent, largest unit in
Greek accounting system;
entrusted to Philetaerus, a Tian man who had been a eunuch 1 talent = 6,000 drachmas
from childhood. What happened was that, at a funeral where
a spectacle was being staged and many people were present,
the nursemaid who was carrying the infant Philetaerus was
caught in the crowd and crushed so badly that the boy was
castrated! So Philetaerus was a eunuch, but one who, with his
excellent upbringing, appeared to warrant the trust placed in
him. Philetaerus remained loyal for some time to Lysimachus, Philetaerus rebelled against
Lysimachus, 282/281 BCE
but fell out with Arsinoe (Lysimachus’s wife) as a result of her
slandering him. Having caused the place to rebel, Philetae-
rus governed it in accordance with the times, for he saw that
those times w ere conducive to revolution: Lysimachus, beset
[ 1 ] E.g., Colophon (643 C, 9-21); Smyrna (645 C, 36–646 C, 11); Chios (645 C, 22-30).
[ 2 ] 581 C, 1–623 C, 9.
714
Aegean Coast of Fourth Section + Hinterland
by domestic troubles, was forced to kill his son (Agathocles); Lysimachus killed Agathocles,
282/281 BCE
Seleucus Nicator launched an attack on Lysimachus and an-
Seleucus Nicator (Macedonian
nihilated him; then Seleucus himself was annihilated, mur- king of Asia) killed Lysimachus,
dered by Ptolemy Ceraunus. The eunuch survived through 281 BCE; Seleucus killed by
Ptolemy Ceraunus, later in
this chaos and confusion by staying put in his stronghold, 281 BCE
retaining control by making promises and dispensing favors
toward whoever was the strongman of the moment and the
vicinity! Philetaerus’s overlordship of the fort and t reasure Philetaerus died, 263 BCE
[ 1 ] The present tense is used, perhaps for vividness; cf. 624 C, 22-30n.
[ 2 ] “Within the Taurus” = in the Asian peninsula: 534 C, 8-20n.
715
4.1. Northern Asia
624 C, 22-30 This Attalus, after ruling for twenty-one years, dies1 an Attalus (Philadelphus), brother
of Eumenes, ruled 159–138 BCE
old man, having achieved much: he fought on the side of
Alexander (son of Antiochus) in the defeat of Demetrius
(son of Seleucus); fought on the Roman side in the battle
against Pseudo-Philip; while campaigning in Thrace, gained
the upper hand over Diegylis, king of the Caenians; killed
Prusias, having incited Prusias’s son (Nicomedes) to rebel
against him. He left the kingdom to the Attalus whose guard-
ian he had been. This Attalus ruled for five years, was called Attalus Philometor, ruled
138–133 BCE
“Philometor,” and died of disease. He left the Romans as his
heirs. The Romans organized the territory into a province,
which they named “Asia,” like the continent.
624 C, 31-33 The Caecus flows past Pergamum, across what is called the Caecus, Bakır Çay
to the city of Apollonia, perched up high; proceeding south- Apollonia, between Yerenice
and Duvarlar (Tky.)
ward, you come to a mountain ridge. Crossing the mountain
(in the Sardis direction), on your left is the city of Thyatira, a Thyatira, Akhisar (Tky.)
[ 1 ] The present tense is used, perhaps for vividness; cf. 623 C, 34–624 C, 9n.
[ 2 ] The rulers of Galatia were called “tetrarchs”: 566 C, 31–567 C, 10.
[ 3 ] The word “names” is not in Strabo’s narrative but is implied by the content of
his statement.
716
Aegean Coast of Fourth Section + Hinterland
LYDIA with a well-defended citadel. It was the royal city of the Lyd-
w. Turkey
ians, who are called Meionians by the poet, and “Maeonians”
poet = Homer (8th c. BCE)
by later writers (some claiming the Maeonians and Lydians
are one and the same, o thers claiming they are d ifferent—
it is best to say they are the same). Looming over Sardis is
Tmolus, a mountain blessed by nature. At its peak t here is Tmolus, Boz Dağ
a lookout, an edifice of white marble made by the Persians, Persians, 6th–4th c. BCE
with a view over all the surrounding plains, especially the Cay-
strian plain. All around live Lydians, Mysians, and Macedo-
nians. The Pactolus river runs down from Tmolus. Long ago, Pactolus, Sart Çay
from Mysia (from a mountain sacred to Dindymene), flow- mountain sacred to Dindymene,
Murat Daği (Tky.)
ing across the Catacecaumene (into the Sardian region and
connecting plains, as noted) 3 and out to sea. Situated below
the city is the Sardian plain, also the plain of the Cyrus and
the plain of the Hermus, and the Caystrian plain. All connect
with each other and are the most fertile of plains.
626 C, 10-19 At a distance of forty stades from the city is a lake called
poet = Homer (8th c. BCE) Gygaea by the poet, the name of which was later changed Gygaea/Coloe, Marmara Gölü
717
4.1. Northern Asia
Cayster plain, you come to the city of Hypaepa. | Hypaepa, Datbey (Tky.)
[ 1 ] Typhon was a monster from Greek myth, associated with storms and volcanic
eruptions.
[ 2 ] Pithecussae (Ischia) lies off the w. coast of Italy; the Tyrrhenians were the early
inhabitants of Italy.
718
Aegean Coast of Fourth Section + Hinterland
627 C, 23-30 Callisthenes says that Sardis was conquered first by Cimme- Sardis attacked by Cimmerians, 13.4.8
7th c. BCE
Callisthenes (late 4th c. BCE), rians, and then by Trerians and Lycians, which is something that
citing Callinus (7th c. BCE)
Callinus (the elegiac poet) shows; she was most recently conquered in
Scepsian = Demetrius (2nd c. the time of Cyrus and Croesus. Those associated with the Sceps- Croesus’s Lydian kingdom fell
BCE), citing Callinus to Cyrus, Persian king, mid
ian1 conjecture that when Callinus says “the Cimmerian incursion, 6th c. BCE
during which Sardis was conquered, took place against the Esioni-
ans,” the Ionian form “Esionians” means “Asionians.” He says that He = Demetrius
perhaps Meionia was called “Asia,” given that Homer says, “in the
Asian meadow, by the waters of the Caystrius.”
627 C, 31-35 Sardis, b
ecause of her territorial strength, made a remark-
able comeback and was unsurpassed by any of her neighbors,
but recently she lost much infrastructure through earthquake hese earthquakes occurred
T
in 17 CE
activity. The consideration of Tiberius, the leader of our
times, enabled the restoration of Sardis through his gener-
ous donations, and the restoration of many other cities that
shared in the same calamity at around the same time. |
627 C, 36–628 C, 7 Eminent individuals from here are the two Diodori, from here = Sardis, Sart (Tky.) 13.4.9
the same f amily and both of them public speakers. The elder
Diodorus, who made many a speech in support of Asia, was
called “Zonas.” At the time of king Mithridates’s attack,
Zonas was accused of inciting the cities to rebel against him,
defended himself against the charges, and was acquitted. As
for the younger Diodorus (a friend of mine), his historical
researches, songs, and other poems are rather good examples
of the antique style. The Xanthus who engaged in historical Xanthus, 5th c. BCE
MYSIA adelphia, with its constant earth tremors. There are always
sw. Turkey
cracks in the walls of the h ouses, and one part or another of
the city is always suffering trauma. Consequently, few people
live within the city. Most earn their livelihood by farming in
the countryside, taking advantage of the fertile soil. In the
case of the few who do stay on, in houses that are liable to fall
down, one marvels at their love of the place—and one marvels
even more at the p eople who founded the city! |
628 C, 14-30 After this comes what is called the “Catacecaumene” terri- 13.4.11
tory (as much as five hundred stades in length and four hun-
dred in width), which we can designate either “Mysian” or
“Meionian”—both labels being in use. It is completely bare
719
4.1. Northern Asia
part toward Celaenae and Apamia) is occupied by Phrygians, Celaenae/Apamia, Dinar (Tky.)
aries between some nations but flow right through the middle
of other nations, making precise distinctions difficult.
629 C, 11-21 It is the same with the plains on e ither side of the moun-
tain and of the riverland. It is perhaps not for me to focus on
this as much as . . . * “chorometers” (territory-measurers). I need
only outline what has been transmitted by earlier writers. |
Immediately east of the Caystrian plain (which falls between 13.4.13
[ 1 ] The mythical monster Typhon lived in the land of the “Arimians”: 626 C, 20–
627 C, 14.
720
Aegean Coast of Fourth Section + Hinterland
tween the Carians and the Nysaïd (i.e., the territory on the
“far side of the Maeander” as far as Cibyratis and Cabalis),
the cities include Hierapolis-toward-Mesogis 2 (opposite Hierapolis, Pamukkale (Tky.)
Laodicia), with her hot springs and a plutonium,3 both of plutonium, sanctuary sacred to
Pluto, god of underworld
which have amazing phenomena associated with them. The
springwater quickly solidifies into stone, so people channel it
through trenches to create seamless walls. The plutonium is an
opening beneath a small overhang of the mountain above: it
is large enough to admit a man and extremely deep. In front
of it, t here’s a four-angled wooden guardrail (some half-cubit 1 cubit = 1.5 ft.
[ 1 ] Presumably t hese include Peltae and Tabae: 570 C, 13-15; 576 C, 26-33.
[ 2 ] Strabo visited Hierapolis (Pamukkale), as evident from his comments later in
this paragraph. Hierapolis lies just off the Euphrates–Ephesus road: 663 C, 19-
33nn. Cities other than Hierapolis: 630 C, 15-19n.
[ 3 ] See 578 C, 31–579 C, 11.
721
4.1. Northern Asia
630 C, 15-19 After Hierapolis, the far side of the Maeander—the re- far side of Maeander = south of 13.4.15
Menderes r.
gion of Laodicia and Aphrodisias, and as far as Carura—has
been described.1 The next parts are, to the west, the city of the
Antiochans on the Maeander (counted as part of Caria); to
the south, Great Cibyra, Sinda, and Cabalis as far the Taurus
and Lycia.
630 C, 19-25 Antioch is a moderately large city, situated right on the Antioch, Aliağaçiftliği (Tky.)
Maeander near Phrygia. A bridge has been built, and the city
holds much territory—all of it truly blessed—on e ither side
of the river. It produces large quantities of what are called
“Antiochian” dried figs; some call them “Triphyllian” (Three-
leafed) figs. This is another area that is subject to a lot of seismic
erate being called a tetrapolis. (Each city had one vote, except Balbura, Çölkayaği (Tky.)
that Cibyra had two votes, since she fielded thirty thousand Oenoanda, İncealiler (Tky.)
722
Aegean Coast of Fourth Section + Hinterland
632 C, 5-17 The distance along Ionia’s coast is—because of the bays 14.1.2
IONIA and the fact that the territory consists largely of peninsulas—
sw. Turkey
some three thousand four hundred and thirty stades. If
measured along a straight line, however, its length is not very
great: the road from Ephesus to Smyrna6 goes in a straight Ephesus, Selçuk (Tky.)
line for three hundred and twenty stades (one hundred and Smyrna, Izmir (Tky.)
twenty stades to Metropolis, the remaining two hundred to Metropolis, Yemiköy (Tky.)
people say, why Ephesus was the Ionian royal city. Even now, Ephesus, Selçuk (Tky.)
723
4.1. Northern Asia
724
Aegean Coast of Fourth Section + Hinterland
634 C, 5-18 The Smyrnaeans left the Ephesians and journeyed to the
place where current-day Smyrna is located. They drove out “current-day” Smyrna, Izmir
(Tky.)
the Lelegians who occupied the place and founded the old
city of Smyrna (around twenty stades away from current-day
Smyrna). L ater on, they w ere driven out by the Aeolians, took
refuge in Colophon, and with the aid of the inhabitants of
Colophon, attacked and took back their city. This is just as
Mimnermus (7th c. BCE) Mimnermus says in his Nanno, noting that Smyrna was for-
ever being fought over: leaving Neleus’s city, Pylos, / when our
ships arrived in longed-for Asia, / with overweening might in lovely
Colophon / we set ourselves down, but unsurpassed in arrogant pride,
/ from t here we set off from the . . . * river and, / as was the w
ill of the
gods, we took Aeolian Smyrna.
634 C, 18-21 That’s enough about t hese m atters. I must revert to my
detailed description, starting with the preeminent places
(which are also the ones that w ere founded first)—I mean Miletus, Balat (Tky.)
Miletus and Ephesus, the best and most famous of the cities. | Ephesus, Selçuk (Tky.)
634 C, 22-32 What comes next after Milesian Posidium (if you go in- Milesian Posidium, Tekagaç 14.1.5
Burnu
land some eighteen stades) is the prophetic shrine of “Did-
Didymian = in Didyma, Didim
ymian” Apollo, among the Branchidians. It was set on fire by (Tky.)
Xerxes,1 as were the other temples, except the one at Ephesus.
The Branchidians, having surrendered the god’s t reasure to
the Persian, went away with him to avoid punishment for
their sacrilege and betrayal. L ater on, the Milesians con-
structed a temple, the largest of all (although it had to remain
without a roof because of its size!). Within the confines of
its precinct, a village has been built; and there is an exquisite
sacred grove both inside and out. Other precincts h ouse the
prophetic shrine and t emple possessions. This is the setting
for the myth Branchus and the Love of Apollo. The temple has a
most exquisite display of ancient artworks.
634 C, 32–635 C, 12 Thence to the city is not far, by road or sea. | Ephorus says city = Miletus, Balat (Tky.) 14.1.6
Ephorus (4th c. BCE) that she was originally a Cretan foundation; she was built overlook-
ing the sea, where Palaemiletus (Old Miletus) now is; Sarpedon, who
led the settlers from Miletus in Crete, named the new city after the
old; the place had originally been inhabited by Lelegians; those as-
sociated with Neleus2 later built the city as she is today. The city
today has four harbors, one of them large enough to hold a
fleet. The city’s achievements are many, the greatest being
the large number of colonies she has dispatched. The Euxine Euxine sea, Black Sea
[ 1 ] An error for “Darius” (Persian king, late 6th–early 5th c. BCE), as also at 517 C,
20–518 C, 4. Other such repeated errors: 517 C, 20–518 C, 4n.
[ 2 ] “Those associated with Neleus” is idiomatic, meaning simply Neleus.
725
4.1. Northern Asia
says the Milesians colonized Icarus island and Leros; Limnae (on
the Cherronesus side of the Hellespont), and Abydus, Arisba, and
Paesus (on the Asian side); Artaca and Cyzicus (on the island of
the Cyzicenes); Scepsis (in the interior of the Troad).1 I mention
other cities that were missed by Anaximenes as I describe
each place in turn.
635 C, 13-19 The Milesians and Delians have an Apollo called “Ulian”
since he is concerned with health and healing: ulein means “to
be healed,” from which come the word ule (scar) and the greeting
“ule (health) and g
reat joy.” Apollo is a god of healing. “Artemis”
comes from the fact that she makes people artemeis (safe). The
sun and moon, since they are responsible for keeping the envi-
ronment in balance, are closely associated with them. Epidem-
t hese gods = Apollo and
ics and sudden deaths are attributed to these gods. | Artemis
635 C, 20-24 Eminent Milesians included Thales (one of the Seven Sages, 14.1.7
635 C, 31–636 C, 4 Next, t here is the Latmian bay, in which is situated what is 14.1.8
above Latmus; others, however, make a claim for Grium, Grium, Ilbir Dağ (Tky.)
[ 1 ] Strabo has described, or will describe later, the places listed, albeit without
reference (except in the case of Abydus and Paesus) to their Milesian coloni-
zation. Icarus/Icaria (Ikaria, Gk. island): 639 C, 3-14; 488 C, 2-8. Leros (Leros, Gk.
island): 487 C, 32–488 C, 1. Abydus (Maltepe, Tky.): 590 C, 34–591 C, 25. Arisbe/
Arisba: 590 C, 3-33. Paesus (nr. Çardak, Tky.): 589 C, 9-23. Cyzicus (Belkiz Kale,
Tky.), Artaca (Erdek, Tky.): 575 C, 18–576 C, 19. Scepsis (Kurşunlu Tepe, Tky.):
607 C, 6–610 C, 7. It is likely that Strabo described Limnae (nr. Eçeabat, Tky.) as
part of his now-lost description of northern Greece and Macedonia, called in
this translation the “eastern European gap”: 329 C, 15–332 C, 1.
726
Aegean Coast of Fourth Section + Hinterland
range.) Not far away, across a little river near Latmus, there
lies within a cave a tomb identified as Endymion’s.
636 C, 5-9 Then, if you hug the coast, it is a voyage of some one hun-
dred stades from Heraclia to the small town of Pyrrha; | it Pyrrha, ?Sarıkemer (Tky.) 14.1.9
its lack of population, been made part of the city of Miletus. Miletus, Balat (Tky.)
soon speak.4 |
636 C, 19-25 After the outlet of the Maeander is the Priene shoreline. Priene/Cadma, Güllübahçe 14.1.12
(Tky.)
Above it is Priene, and Mycale mountain with its many wild
Mycale, Samsun Dağ (Tky.)
animals and trees. It overlooks the Samian island and forms,
together with the island, on the far side of the headland called
“Trogilius,” a strait of some seven stades in width. Priene is Trogilius, Dip Burnu
Pactyes is another mountain (part of Ephesia) joining My- Pactyes, Ovacık Dağ (Tky.)
[ 1 ] The tone is grumpy and sarcastic. Pyrrha was hardly a “well-known place.”
The Greek word periskeles, translated here as “tortuous ins and outs,” literally
means “something that winds in and out around the legs” or “loincloth” (in
modern parlance, “underwear”). The Greek word geographia, translated h ere
as “coastal depiction” (in line with ge meaning “coast” in the preceding sen-
tence), could equally well apply to Strabo’s work. Double entendres abound.
[ 2 ] An error for “Artaxerxes” (Persian king, 5th c. BCE), as at 587 C, 24–588 C, 2. Other
such repeated errors: 517 C, 20–518 C, 4n.
[ 3 ] Similar effects on birds elsewhere: 244 C, 15-23; 629 C, 22–630 C, 9. Charonia:
578 C, 31–579 C, 11n.
[ 4 ] 647 C, 7–648 C, 28.
727
4.1. Northern Asia
636 C, 33–637 C, 12 From Trogilius, it is forty stades to Samos. The city faces 14.1.14
SAMOS south, as does her harbor with its shipyard. Although the
Samos (Gk. island)
city lies mostly on the seagirt plain, a part is on the moun-
tain slope behind. On your right as you sail t oward the city
is Posidium (a headland that, together with Mycale, creates Posidium, Posidonio (Samos)
[ 1 ] Strabo has undoubtedly seen this colossal statue in the Capitol in Rome: 236 C,
25-28n.
728
Aegean Coast of Fourth Section + Hinterland
seeing how the tyranny was going, left the city and traveled
to Egypt and to Babylon in his quest for knowledge; when
Pythagoras returned, he realized that the tyranny was still
going strong and sailed on to Italy, where he spent the rest
of his life. That’s enough about Polycrates. |
638 C, 14-18 Syloson was left by his b rother as an ordinary citizen. 14.1.17
729
4.1. Northern Asia
gift): I am the labor of the Samian who once welcomed into his house
the divine Homer. / I tell of Eurytus, whose sufferings w
ere many, / and
of flaxen-haired Iolia. I am described as “written / by Homer.” Dear
Zeus, what g reat praise for Creophylus! Some say that this man was this man = Creophylus
639 C, 3-14 The island of Icaria lies alongside Samos. The “Icarian” Icaria, Ikaria (Gk. island) 14.1.19
sea is named after the island. The island is itself named after
Icarus (son of Daedalus). This is said to be where Icarus—
when both he and his father, with whom he was escaping,
took winged flight from Crete—lost control and fell to earth.
Icarus flew too close to the sun, and his wings disintegrated
when the wax melted. The total circumference of the island is
three hundred stades. It has no harbors but some anchorages,
the finest of which is called “Histi” (Ship-masts), where t here’s
a westward-jutting headland. On the island there’s a temple
(called the “Tauropolium”) to Artemis, a very small town
called “Oenoe,” and another one called “Dracanum”1 (with
a mooring place), bearing the same name as the headland
on which it sits. The distance between this headland and the
Samos headland called “Cantharium” is eighty stades, which
is the shortest crossing. Now that the island is depopulated,
it is largely used by the Samians as animal pasture. |
639 C, 15-27 After the strait between Samos and Mycale, on your right 14.1.20
[ 1 ] Strabo corrects his earlier statement (637 C, 13-23, where he gives the name as
“Drepanum”).
[ 2 ] See “Note (639 C, 15-27)” on next page.
[ 3 ] “Agamemnon construction”: 605 C, 9-14n.
730
Aegean Coast of Fourth Section + Hinterland
639 C, 28–640 C, 9 On the same shoreline and slightly inland from the sea is
Ortygia, a sacred grove of striking beauty, containing trees of all Ortygia, nr. Kirazlı (Tky.)
kinds but particularly cypresses. Running through it is the Cen- Cenchrius, Değirmendere r.
In Greek myth, Leto was the
mother of Apollo and Artemis chrius river, where Leto is said to have bathed a fter giving birth.
731
4.1. Northern Asia
This is where p eople set the myth of the l abor, the nurse Ortygia,
the sacred place where the labor occurred, and the nearby olive
tree—against which they say the goddess first rested a fter giv-
ing birth. Above the grove is Solmissus mountain, on which the
Curetes are said to have stood; clashing their weapons together,
they scared away Hera, jealously lying in wait, and helped Leto
to keep her labor secret. T here are several t emples at the site,
some ancient, some more recent. In the ancient t emples, t here
are ancient cult statues. In the newer t emples, t here are works
by Scopas: Leto, holding a scepter; Ortygia, standing alongside, Scopas, 4th c. BCE
732
Aegean Coast of Fourth Section + Hinterland
ing to the king that “it was not right for a building to be dedicated
by a god to the gods.” |
641 C, 5-14 After the completion of the t emple, which, he says, was the work he = Artemidorus 14.1.23
of Chirocrates, who was the same man who was responsible for the New t emple to Artemis
completed, late 4th c. BCE
design of Alexandria1 (and the same man who promised Alexan-
der that he would develop Athos in his image as if he were pouring
a ceremonial offering from a jug into a receptacle, by building two
cities, one on the right-hand side of the mountain and one on the
left-hand side, with a river running between them)—so then, a fter
the t emple, a host of dedications was acquired out of reverence for
their creators, but the altar was full to overflowing with the works Praxiteles, Athenian craftsman
(4th c. BCE)
of Praxiteles. Also pointed out to me 2 were some works by
Thrason, including the Hecatesium, the . . . * Penelope, and
the Old Euryclia.
641 C, 14-23 The Ephesians had, as priests, eunuchs whom they called
megabyxi (the practice being to send abroad for individuals
worthy of such distinction) and held in the highest honor. It
was stipulated that young unmarried girls w ere to help the
eunuchs in performing the rites. Currently, some of these cus-
toms are preserved, and o thers not. The t emple remains now,
as earlier, a place of asylum. It often happened that the limits
of the asylum w ere altered. Alexander extended the limits by
one stade. Mithridates shot an arrow from the corner of the Ephesus came u nder control
of Mithridates, king of Pontus,
roof, seemingly exceeding the one stade by a l ittle. Antony 89/88 BCE; given to M. Antony,
doubled the distance and incorporated part of the city within 42 BCE; came u nder Augustus’s
control, 30/29 BCE
the asylum, but when it became clear that this was a really bad
idea (since it turned the city over to rogues), Augustus Caesar
reversed the decision. |
641 C, 24–642 C, 1 The city has shipyards and a harbor. The builders of the city = Ephesus 14.1.24
733
4.1. Northern Asia
deceived, as was the king who gave the order, namely Atta- Ephesus was u nder control of
kings of Pergamum, 188–133
lus Philadelphus. Attalus thought that if a mole w ere built BCE; Attalus ruled 159–138 BCE
in the (extremely wide) harbor entrance, the entrance would
in f uture be deep enough to accommodate huge cargo ships,
as would the harbor (which had been shallow up until then
because of the sediment brought down by the Cayster). So
Attalus gave o rders for the construction of the mole. In the
event, the reverse was true. The sediment was trapped inter-
nally, turning the w hole harbor including its mouth into a
shallow reef (whereas, previously, the tidal ebb and flow had
carried away the sediment and taken it out to sea). That’s
enough about the harbor. The city nevertheless grows big-
ger by the day b ecause of its opportune situation in other re
spects. It is the largest of the trading centers in Asia within
the Taurus.1 |
642 C, 2-11 With regard to eminent men from the city, those from city = Ephesus, Selçuk (Tky.) 14.1.25
734
Aegean Coast of Fourth Section + Hinterland
city of Colophon. In front of the city is the grove of “Clar- Colophon, Degirmendere (Tky.)
735
4.1. Northern Asia
between them is the island of Aspis, sometimes called “Ar- Aspis/Arconnesus, Doganbey
Adası (Tk. island)
connesus”; and Myonnesus is situated on some heights that
Myonnesus, Çıfıt Kale (Tky.)
form a peninsula. |
644 C, 1-8 Teos, with its harbor, is also situated on a peninsula. Ana- Anacreon, 6th c. BCE 14.1.30
[ 1 ] The Greek word pankoinon (“universal”) plays on the idea of the Ionian koinon
(“federation”): 633 C, 20-31.
[ 2 ] 609 C, 3-15.
736
Aegean Coast of Fourth Section + Hinterland
town of Aerae, then Corycus (a lofty mountain at whose foot Aerae, Aşağı Demirci (Tky.)
is the harbor of Casystes, and another harbor called “Erythras Corycus, Kiran Dağ
inspired woman of prophetic gifts. In the time of Alexander, time of Alexander, late 4th c.
BCE
there was another w oman (called “Athenaïs”), who was simi-
larly gifted in prophecy, from the same city; and in my own
time, Heraclides, a Herophilian doctor and a fellow student Heraclides, Apollonius, 1st c.
BCE–?early 1st c. CE
of Apollonius Mys (Mouse). |
645 C, 10-21 The sailing distance around Chios is nine hundred stades 14.1.35
CHIOS (if you hug the coast). Chios has a city with a good harbor and Chios (city), Khios (Khios)
Khios (Gk. island)
a dock for eighty ships. As you sail from the city (keeping the
737
4.1. Northern Asia
which (fifty stades from the headland) sits the lofty island of
Psyra, with its city of the same name; the island has a circum- Psyra, Psara (Gk. island)
Clazomenae was formerly situated. Then there’s the current- “current-day” city = Clazomenae,
Klazümen (Tky.)
day city, with eight small but arable islands lying offshore.
Anaxagoras (a natural p hilosopher, student of Anaximenes Anaxagoras, Euripides, 5th c.
BCE
of Miletus) was a famous Clazomenian; Archelaus (natural
philosopher) and Euripides (poet) studied under him.
645 C, 36–646 C, 11 Then t here’s a t emple to Apollo, and hot springs, and the
Smyrnaean bay and city. | This is followed by another bay, Smyrnaean city = Smyrna, Izmir 14.1.37
(Tky.)
where Palaea (Old) Smyrna is located, some twenty stades from
Palaea Smyrna, Bayraklı (Tky.)
the current-day city. When Smyrna was razed by the Lydians,
her inhabitants lived village-style for around four hundred
years. Then the city was rebuilt by Antigonus and later by Antigonus, controlled much
of Asian peninsula, 323–301
Lysimachus. Now, she is the most beautiful of all cities, with BCE; Lysimachus controlled it,
a walled section on the mountain but the greater part on the 301–281 BCE
laid out with straight lines as far as possible; the roads are
738
Aegean Coast of Fourth Section + Hinterland
Aristonicus caused to rebel after the death of Attalus Philome- Rome inherited Pergamum from
its king, Attalus Philometor,
tor. Aristonicus, supposedly of royal birth, intended to bring 133 BCE
the kingdom under his control. Driven from Leucae after
being defeated by the Ephesians in a sea battle off Cymaea,
Aristonicus headed into the interior. He quickly assembled
an army of destitutes and slaves (bound to him in exchange
for their freedom), whom he called “Heliopolitans” (Citizens of
the Sun). He swooped down on Thyatira, then took Apollonis,
and then attacked various other forts. He did not last long.
The cities immediately dispatched an army; the Bithynian
Nicomedes, and the Cappadocian kings,1 supported them. Nicomedes ruled Bithynia,
149–128/127 BCE
Next, five Roman representatives arrived, then an army
under the consul, Publius Crassus, and then Marcus Peperna, Crassus arrived, 131 BCE; was
defeated and killed, 130 BCE
who brought the war to a close, took Aristonicus prisoner,
and sent him to Rome. (Aristonicus died in prison; Peperna
succumbed to disease; Crassus fell in battle after being at-
tacked near Leucae.) Manius Aquillius arrived as consul with Aquillius organized the new
province of Asia, starting 129
ten state officials; he set up the province in the political for- BCE
mat it enjoys to this day.
647 C, 1-3 After Leucae, there’s Phocaea in its bay (I have already Phocaea, Foça (Tky.)
739
4.1. Northern Asia
and rises on the Ephesian mountain of Pactyes. (The “Le- Pactyes, Ovacık Dağ
[ 1 ] For this famous road, running all the way from Ephesus to the Euphrates: 663 C,
19-33n. Strabo is interested h
ere in the stretch from Ephesus to Antioch, in order
to round out his description of Ionia.
[ 2 ] Strabo’s comparison of the temple at Magnesia (Tekke, Tky.) with the temple at
Ephesus (Selçuk. Tky.), which Strabo visited (641 C, 5-14n), seems to be derived
from personal experience and suggests that he visited the Magnesian temple
as well: 663 C, 19-33nn.
[ 3 ] “Asia” = Roman province of Asia. Cf. 840 C, 13-26n.
740
Aegean Coast of Fourth Section + Hinterland
recent than Callinus. A different, and older, Cimmerian in- Cimmerians took Sardis (Sart,
Tky.), mid-7th c. BCE
cursion is referred to by Callinus when he says: now the mighty
Cimmerian army draws near (in reference to the fall of Sardis). |
648 C, 6-15 Famous men from Magnesia have included Hegesias Hegesias, 4th–3rd c. BCE 14.1.41
741
4.1. Northern Asia
and there are always some of her citizens who are among the
foremost in the province (they call them “Asiarchs”). These
included Pythodorus, originally from Nysa, who relocated to Pythodorus supported Pompey,
probably 60s BCE; assets
Trallis b ecause of its distinctive reputation. He achieved rare confiscated by Julius Caesar
eminence in his friendship with Pompey, and built up assets (= deified Caesar), ?50s BCE
fit for a king, valued at more than two thousand talents. The talent, largest unit in
Greek accounting system;
deified Caesar confiscated the assets, but Pythodorus man- 1 talent = 6,000 drachmas
aged, through his friendship with Pompey, to buy them all
back and bequeathed them undiminished to his children.
(Pythodoris—reigning monarch in Pontus, whom I have de-
scribed1—is the d aughter of this man.)
649 C, 10-17 Pythodorus flourished in our times; also Menodorus,
an erudite man and generally well respected and dignified,
holding the priesthood of “Larisian” Zeus. Menodorus was a
victim of the faction supporting Domitius Ahenobarbus; this Ahenobarbus, opponent of
Julius Caesar, commanded fleet
man killed him, believing the informers who said that he was in Asia on behalf of Caesar’s
behind the naval revolt. There were also famous public speak- assassins, 44–42 BCE
ers from Trallis: Dionysocles and then Damas Scombrus (Mack- Damas Scombrus, 1st c. BCE
649 C, 18-24 Nysa is situated by the Mesogis, largely on the mountain Nysa, Sultanhisar (Tky.) 14.1.43
the city, is the Nysaean village of Acharaca, in which are Acharaca, Salavatlı (Tky.)
a plutonium (with its exquisite sanctuary and its temple to plutonium, sanctuary sacred to
Pluto, god of the underworld
Pluto and Core) and a charonium (a cave—a natural wonder—
charonium, cave sacred to
lying above the sanctuary). It is said that p eople afflicted Charon (in myth, ferryman to
by disease, believing in the healing abilities of these gods, the underworld)
make a pilgrimage t here and stay in the village near the cave
with priests, whose skill lies in staying overnight on the pil-
[ 1 ] Pythodoris: 498 C, 26–499 C, 9; 555 C, 31–556 C, 10; 557 C, 3-13; 559 C, 20–560 C, 11.
742
Aegean Coast of Fourth Section + Hinterland
procession during the festival. Not far from Limon is the en-
trance to a cave (sacred to the same gods) said to run as far as
Acharaca. P eople say that Limon is the “meadow” to which
poet = Homer (8th c. BCE) the poet refers when he says, in the Asian meadow; they identify
shrines to the heroes Caystrius and Asius and point to the
Cayster r unning nearby. |
650 C, 17-23 History tells us that t here were three brothers (Athym- 14.1.46
significance—Coscinia and Orthosia on the far side of the Orthosia, Ortas (Tky.)
Maeander; inside the Maeander, Briula, Mastaura, Acha- Mastaura, Mastavra (Tky.)
raca, and (on the mountain above Nysa) Aroma, which is the Acharaca, Salavatlı (Tky.)
source of the best Mesogitan wine, the Aromean. | Aroma, Kavaklı (Tky.)
650 C, 24-32 Famous men from Nysa include Apollonius (Stoic Apollonius, Menecrates, 14.1.48
2nd–1st c. BCE
philosopher, the best of Panaetius’s students); Menecrates,
disciple of Aristarchus; Aristodemus (Menecrates’s son), Aristodemus, Sostratus,
Aristodemus (cousin), 1st c. BCE
under whom in his extreme old age I studied for the w hole
period of my youth in Nysa.3 Sostratus (Aristodemus’s Pompey shared power with
brother) and another Aristodemus (his cousin, who taught Julius Caesar, 50s BCE; was
involved in civil war with Caesar
Pompey the Great) w ere also eminent teachers of literature. and defeated by Caesar, 48 BCE.
[ 1 ] Presumably, the gymnasium at Nysa (649 C, 18-24), with the corollary that t hese
“young men” included the young Strabo, who attended school in Nysa (650 C,
24-32n).
[ 2 ] Compare Strabo’s description of similar events (in which he personally took
part) at Hierapolis (Pamukkale, Tky.): 629 C, 22–630 C, 9.
[ 3 ] Strabo’s studies in Nysa (probably 40s BCE) preceded his sojourn in Rome (30s
BCE): 273 C, 2-14n.
743
4.1. Northern Asia
islands (lying offshore at the Pamphylia/Lycia boundary) are Chelidonians, Beş Adalar
(Tk. islands)
said to represent the start of the Taurus, since this is where
Strabo argues that Taurus range they rise to g reat height. In truth, however, the Taurus moun-
begins farther west than was
traditionally assumed to be tain range runs through the w hole of Lycia and walls off, into
the case the outside (and southern) part, the stretch from Cibyratica
to the Rhodian Peraea. What comes next, although moun-
tainous, is much lower. It is no longer considered part of the
Taurus, nor are places considered to be “outside” or “inside”
it, since the troughs and peaks are scattered throughout the
entire territory (which is equal in terms of width and length),
and they in no way resemble a dividing wall.
651 C, 14-24 While the entire sailing distance is four thousand nine
RHODIAN PERAEA hundred stades (following the coast the entire way), the Rho-
sw. Turkey
dian Peraea accounts for nearly one thousand five hundred
Rhodia = Rhodian Peraea stades. | It begins with Daedala, a place in Rhodia; it ends with Daedala, İnlicı Asarı (Tky.) 14.2.2
the mountain called “Phoenix,” also part of Rhodia; offshore Phoenix, Karayüksek Dağ
lies Elaeussa, an island one hundred and twenty stades from Elaeussa, Kızıl Ada (Tk. island)
cellent harbors, then to Artemisium (headland and temple), Artemisium, ?Akça Burnu
then a sanctuary sacred to Leto (and sixty stades inland from Calynda, Kozpınar (Tky.)
it and from the coast, the city of Calynda), then Caunus and Caunus, Dalyan (Tky.)
the nearby Calbis (a deep river, which can be sailed up) and, Calbis, Dalyan Çay
in between them, Pisilis. | Pisilis, Babadağ (Tky.)
651 C, 25–652 C, 5 The city has shipyards and an enclosed harbor; perched city = Caunus, Dalyan (Tky.) 14.2.3
[ 1 ] Gnaeus, elder son of Magnus (= Pompey), was born in 80–76 BCE. Sextus, the
younger son, was once believed by scholars to have been born ca. 75 BCE but
is now believed to have been born in 68–66 BCE. Sextus’s studies under Aris-
todemus probably took place in the 50s BCE.
[ 2 ] The far side of the Maeander has been described piecemeal: 576 C, 26–581 C,
1; 628 C, 31–631 C, 21; 647 C, 4–650 C, 32 (continuing to 663 C, 33).
744
Aegean Coast of Fourth Section + Hinterland
territory is naturally blessed, all agree that the city’s air is fetid
in summer and autumn, as a result of the heat and overabun-
dance of seasonal produce. The following anecdote is told.
Stratonicus (4th c. BCE) cites Stratonicus, the lyre player, seeing that the Caunians w ere
Homer (8th c. BCE)
sickly green in color, quoted the poet’s comment: men are like
the leaves on the trees! When people objected to the city being
made fun of for its sickliness, Stratonicus replied, Would I dare
call this city sickly, where even the corpses can walk? The Caunians
at one time rebelled against the Rhodians but, after Roman
arbitration, w ere reinstated; t here is a speech by Molon,
Against the Caunians. It is said that, although they speak the
same language as the Carians, they originated in Crete and
have their own customs. |
652 C, 6-9 Next, there’s Physcus (small town with harbor) and a Physcus, Marmaris (Tky.) 14.2.4
745
4.1. Northern Asia
arms manufacturing, and stockpiling weapons, and so forth, Cyzicus (city), Belkiz Kale (Tky.)
has been taken very seriously (in fact, even more so than else-
where). |
653 C, 9-33 The people—like the people of Halicarnassus, Cnidus, 14.2.6
they were settled in three places, one per tribe. He names the cities
at that time as Lindus, Ielysus, and white-shining Camirus, the
Rhodian city being as yet unfounded. He makes no mention
of Dorians but rather, so it seems, Aeolians and Boeotians (if
that was where Heracles and Licymnius dwelt). If, as some
say, Tlepolemus hailed from Argos and Tiryns, colonization
from t here would not be considered Dorian (since it hap-
pened before the return of the Heraclids). With regard to
the people of Cos, their leaders were Phidippus and Antiphus, / the
746
Aegean Coast of Fourth Section + Hinterland
successful at sea, not only from the time when they founded
the current city but from many years before the institution
of the Olympics, when they ventured far from home to en-
sure the safety of the people. Thus they sailed as far as Iberia,
where they founded Rhoda (later occupied by the Massali-
otes); among the Opicians, they founded Parthenope; among
the Daunians, together with the p eople of Cos, they founded
Elpiae.2 Some say that the Rhodians, after departing from
Timaeus (4th–3rd c. BCE) Troy, settled the Gymnesian islands. Timaeus says that the Gymnesian/Balearic islands,
Mallorca and Menorca (Sp.
larger of the two is next biggest after the seven—Sardo, Sicily, Cy- islands)
prus, Crete, Euboea, Cyrnus, and Lesbos. (Timaeus is wrong, as
there are o thers that are larger.) It is said that baleareis is the
Phoenician word for gymnetes (light-armed soldiers), which is why
the Gymnesians were called the “Balearic” islands.3 Some of
[ 1 ] 472 C, 6-12
[ 2 ] Rhoda (Ciutadella de Roses, Sp.): 159 C, 29–160 C, 4. Parthenope =?Neapolis
(Napoli/Naples, It.): 246 C, 4-15. Elpiae (Lupara, It.): 283 C, 29-34 (if “Elpiae” is
to be identified with “Salapia”).
[ 3 ] Strabo adds information omitted at 167 C, 15-18.
747
4.1. Northern Asia
your right), you come first to Lindus (a city on a mountain), Lindus, Lindos (Rhodos)
lage of Ialysus (and above it, there’s an acropolis called “Ochy- Ialysus, Ielysos (Rhodos)
[ 1 ] ?Sybaris (Sibari/Copia, It.): 264 C, 19-24. ?Or Sybaris (on-the-Traeis) (nr Trionto
r., It).
[ 2 ] The “Sporades associated with Chalcia” is an idiomatic expression, meaning
simply Chalcia (Khalki, Gk. island). Strabo describes the Sporades at 488 C,
11–489 C, 17 (esp. 488 C, 24-29 for Chalcia).
748
Aegean Coast of Fourth Section + Hinterland
is a sharp bend to the north, starting at Elaeussa and Lor- Elaeussa, Kızıl Ada (Tk. island)
land of Syme, | and then Cnidus, with its two harbors (one Syme, Syme (Gk. island) 14.2.15
of them, suitable for triremes, can be closed) and a naval Cnidus, Tekir (Tky.)
station for twenty ships. Lying offshore is an elevated and theatroid, shaped like a Greek
amphitheater
theatroid island, approximately seven stades in perimeter,
which is joined to the mainland by a spit, making Cnidus in
some sense a double city: a large part of the city occupies the
island, which overlooks both harbors. Facing Cnidus, in the
open sea, is Nisyros. Men of note from Cnidus include, in the Nisyros, Nisyros (Gk. island)
first place, Eudoxus (the mathematician, one of Plato’s fol- Eudoxus, 4th c. BCE
towns back from the sea), then Halicarnassus, the capital of Bargasa, Gökbel (Tky.)
749
4.1. Northern Asia
656 C, 24–657 C, 11 This city suffered a setback when Alexander took it by city = Halicarnassus, Bodrum 14.2.17
(Tky.)
force. The Carian king, Hecatomnus, had three sons (Mau-
solus, Idrieus, and Pixodarus) and two daughters. The el-
dest brother (Mausolus) was married to the elder sister
(Artemisia); the second brother (Idrieus) to the other sister
(Ada). Mausolus became king; d ying without issue, he be-
queathed the kingdom to his wife (who constructed the
aforementioned tomb). After she died, wasting away in grief
for her husband, Idrieus succeeded. When he succumbed
to a disease, his wife Ada inherited the kingdom. She was
overthrown by Pixodarus (last of Hecatomnus’s sons), who
Persified and sent for a satrap with whom to share his king-
dom. When Pixodarus departed this life, the satrap seized
Halicarnassus and, upon the arrival of Alexander, withstood
the siege together with his wife, Ada (the d aughter of Pixo-
darus by Aphneis, a Cappadocian woman). The Ada who was
Hecatomnus’s daughter (whom Pixodarus had overthrown)
makes overtures to Alexander and presses him to restore her
to the kingdom taken from her, promising him help against
those areas in revolt, on the grounds that they are under the
control of her relatives. (She also handed over Alinda, where
she was staying.) Alexander was much obliged and made her
queen; when the city (in two parts) had been taken except
for the citadel, he entrusted her with the siege. Shortly af-
terward, the citadel was taken, the siege engendering much
anger and hatred. |
657 C, 12-14 Next, t here’s a headland—Termerium—belonging to the Termerium, Koca Burun 14.2.18
people of Myndus; opposite it, forty stades from the main- Scandarian headland, Skandari
land, is the Scandarian headland in Cos. There is also a small (Kos)
place, Termerum, set back from the headland. | Termerum, Asarlık (Tky.)
657 C, 15–658 C, 4 The Coans’ city was called in antiquity “Astypalaea” and 14.2.19
750
Aegean Coast of Fourth Section + Hinterland
(who ruled over the Coans and was the student and successor
of Ariston the Peripatetic). T here was also Theomnestus (the
renowned harpist), who opposed Nicias politically. |
658 C, 4-12 On the mainland coast, in the region of Myndus, there’s Myndus, Gümüslük (Tky.) 14.2.20
thereafter, Myndus (with harbor); a fter that, Bargylia (an- Bargylia, Varvıl (Tky.)
other city). In between, t here’s Caryanda—a harbor, a city, Caryanda (city), Göl (Tky.)
and an island (with the same name as the city) where the Caryanda (island), Karybağlar
Adasi (Tk.)
Scylax (6th c. BCE) Caryandians used to live. Scylax (the historical writer from
antiquity) was from there. Next to Bargylia is the temple to
“Cindyas” Artemis upon which, p eople believe, it never rains
(and there was once a place, “Cindya”). An eminent man from
Bargylia was the Epicurian Protarchus (the teacher of the De-
metrius surnamed “Laco”). |
658 C, 13-25 Then there’s Iasus, on an island near the mainland. It has Iasus, Asınkalesi (Tky.) 14.2.21
a harbor, and the locals earn their living largely from the sea,
which abounds with fish; its territory is of rather poor quality.
Apocryphal stories are told about it, such as the following. A
certain lyre player was giving a show. Everyone listened for
a while, but as soon as the bell for the fish market rang, off
they all went to get their fish—except for one man, who was
hard of hearing. The lyre player went up to him and said, I
am very thankful to you, sir, for the honor you have shown me and
for your appreciation of my m usic—the others all got up and left as
soon as they heard the sound of the bell! The man said, What’s that?
Has the bell already rung? When the lyre player affirmed it had,
[ 1 ] Strabo had undoubtedly seen this artwork when he was in Rome: 236 C, 25-28n.
751
4.1. Northern Asia
the man bid him farewell and left. The logician Diodorus was
from Iasus. He was surnamed “Cronus”: at first, this was done
in error, since this fellow’s teacher (Apollonius) was called
“Cronus”; the name was, however, transferred to him because
of the true Cronus’s lack of repute. |
658 C, 26 After Iasus, there’s Milesian Posidium.1 14.2.22
658 C, 26–659 C, 5 In the interior are three significant cities—Mylasa, Stra- Mylasa, Milas (Tky.)
from Alabanda to Mylasa and is far away from the city. There
is an ancient temple there, and a carved image of “Stratian”
Zeus, which is revered both by t hose who live around about
and by the Mylasians. A road has been laid out, nearly sixty
stades long, reaching the city and called the “Sacred Road,”
along which the sacred artifacts are carried in procession. The
most distinguished citizens oversee the sacred rituals, hold-
ing the office for life. (While t hese temples belong to the city,
there is a third temple—to “Carian” Zeus—which belongs to
all Carians jointly and is shared by the Lydians and Mysians as
their brothers.) History tells us that, in antiquity, Mylasa was
a village, the ancestral home and royal seat of those associated
with Hecatomnus.4 The sea is nearest to the city at Physcus,
which provides the Mylasians with a naval base. |
659 C, 17-32 Eminent men produced by Mylasa in our times included 14.2.24
[ 1 ] Strabo describes the coastline north of Milesian Posidium (Tekagaç Burnu, Tky.)
at 634 C, 22–647 C, 3.
[ 2 ] Mylasa (Milas, Tky.): 658 C, 26–660 C, 14. Stratonicia (Eskihisar, Tky.): 660 C, 15-29.
Alabanda (Araphisar, Tky.): 660 C, 30–661 C, 4.
[ 3 ] I.e., governors of the Roman province of Asia.
[ 4 ] “Those associated with Hecatomnus” is idiomatic, meaning primarily Hecatom-
nus but including in this context his descendants: 656 C, 24–657 C, 11.
752
Aegean Coast of Fourth Section + Hinterland
[ 1 ] “Asia” = Roman province of Asia (840 C, 13-26n), where the post of “Asiarch” was
the highest honor: 648 C, 29–649 C, 10.
753
4.1. Northern Asia
660 C, 15-29 Stratonicia is a Macedonian settlement. This city was Stratonicia, Eskihisar (Tky.) 14.2.25
ated that they appear like a laden pack ass. Apollonius Ma-
lacus, making fun of the city because of this feature and also
because of her infestation of scorpions, said she was a pack
ass laden with scorpions! (Alabanda and the Mylasians’ city are
full of these creatures, as also the mountainous area between
them.) She is a city of pleasure-loving debauchees; many of
the w omen are harp players. Noteworthy men from Alabanda
included two brothers who were public-speaking experts—
Menecles (whom I just mentioned)1 and Hierocles—as well
as Apollonius and Molon, who moved to Rhodes. |
661 C, 5-16 Many stories are told about the Carians, but the story 14.2.27
[ 1 ] 655 C, 17-28.
754
Aegean Coast of Fourth Section + Hinterland
755
4.1. Northern Asia
is where the limits of Caria are, where you cross the Maeander Trallis, Aydın (Tky.)
[ 1 ] 850 + 250 + 80 = 1,180 stades. Strabo halves Artemidorus’s figure of 160 for
Alabanda to Trallis, in order to arrive at the distance from Alabanda to the
Maeander river. The resulting total of 1,180 stades represents the distance from
Physcus to the Maeander river, which Strabo takes as the north–south dimen-
sion of Caria.
756
Aegean Coast of Fourth Section + Hinterland
663 C, 14-19 Again, if you go along the length of neighboring Ionia, from the
Strabo uses Artemidorus to Maeander along the same road, it is eighty [stades] from the river to river = Maeander, Menderes r.
establish the north–south
dimension of Ionia Trallis; then one hundred and forty to Magnesia; one hundred and Magnesia, Tekke (Tky.)
twenty to Ephesus; three hundred and twenty to Smyrna; less than Smyrna, Izmir (Tky.)
two hundred to Phocaea (and the end of Ionia). So, the length Phocaea, Foça (Tky.)
of Ionia measured in a straight line would be—according to
him—only a l ittle more than eight hundred stades.1 him = Artemidorus
663 C, 19-33 Since there is a shared road, well trodden by all 2 who make
the journey to the east starting from Ephesus,3 he proceeds
along this, too:
[ 1 ] 80 + 140 + 120 + 320 + less than 200 = “a little more than 800 stades.” Strabo
takes this to represent the distance from the Maeander to Phocaea, which he
treats as the “length” (north–south dimension) of Ionia.
[ 2 ] Including, in all likelihood, Strabo (Pothecary, “A Road Trip with Strabo,” Mne-
mosyne 69 [2016], 202–225). Another probable example of Strabo’s use of “all”
to include himself: 282 C, 26–283 C, 8n.
[ 3 ] Strabo’s presence in Ephesus (Selçuk, Tky.): 641 C, 5-14n.
[ 4 ] Strabo’s presence in Magnesia (Tekke, Tky.): 647 C, 18-30n.
[ 5 ] Strabo’s presence in Nysa (Sultanhisar, Tky.): 650 C, 24-32n.
[ 6 ] Samosata lies farther down the Euphrates than Tomisa.
[ 7 ] I.e., the place to cross the Euphrates r. (?Kavunlu/Belkis, Tky.): 747 C, 3-10; 749 C,
21-27.
757
4.1. Northern Asia
Sinope),3 is nevertheless outside the Taurus, on the narrow Amisus, Samsun (Tky.)
littoral stretching from Lycia to the region of Soli, current-day Soli/Pompey City, Viranşehir
(Tky.)
“Pompey City.” Starting at Soli and Tarsus, the littoral of the
Tarsus, Tarsos (Tky.)
Issian gulf eventually flattens out to form plains. A fter going
along this shore, I will have completed my verbal tour of the
outside Taurus = southern Asia
entire peninsula.4 Then I will switch to the other part of Asia, (chap. 4.2)
the part outside the Taurus; last of all, I w ill deal with Libya. | Libya = Africa (chap. 5)
664 C, 16-27 After Rhodian Daedala, t here’s the Lycian mountain with 14.3.2
LYCIA the same name as it, Daedala. The total sailing distance from Daedala (mountain), Kızıldağ
sw. Turkey
here is one thousand seven hundred and twenty stades along
the Lycian coast—rugged and rocky but with good harbors.
The p eople are very decent, given that their territory is
like that for the inhabitants of Pamphylia and Rough Cili-
cia. However, the latter used their localities as pirate bases,
either acting as pirates themselves or providing pirates with
markets and shipyards—for example, the Cilicians built ship-
yards in the Pamphylian town of Sida, where they auctioned
off their captives, all the while conceding that they w ere f ree
individuals. The Lycians, in contrast, conducted their lives
in a civilized and reasonable manner, with the consequence
that (although the former thrived and gained mastery over former = Pamphylians, Cilicians
the sea as far as Italy), they w ere unmotivated by base profit they = Lycians
[ 1 ] Strabo picks up the thread of his narrative from his description of the Rhodian
Peraea (sw. Turkey): 651 C, 14–652 C, 9.
[ 2 ] Lycia (sw. Turkey): 664 C, 16–667 C, 13. Pamphylia (s. Turkey): 667 C, 14–668 C,
6. Rough Cilicia (s. Turkey): 668 C, 7–671 C, 25. Level Cilicia (s. Turkey): 671 C,
26–676 C, 25.
[ 3 ] 534 C, 8-20. Strabo early on gives Tarsus rather than Issus as the southern
terminus of the isthmus: 126 C, 3-11. See 673 C, 5-16n.
[ 4 ] Definition of the peninsula: 492 C, 10-16; 534 C, 8-20; 632 C, 1-4.
758
Mediterranean Coast of Fourth Section + Hinterland
gress, first the Lyciarch, then other federal officers are elected,
and joint law courts are established. It used to be that matters
of war, peace, and treaty making w ere also on the agenda, but
this is no longer appropriate given that these necessarily lie
within Roman jurisdiction—except when the Romans, if it is
to their advantage, hand it over to them. Judges and officers
are similarly elected by proportional voting from each city.
665 C, 9-16 The Lycians, since they w ere so well governed, w ere allowed
by the Romans to live in freedom on their ancestral lands. They
saw the pirates totally annihilated: first by Servilius Isauricus,
when he razed Isaura; later by Pompey the Great, who burned
more than one thousand three hundred ships, laid waste the
pirate quarters, and settled some of those who survived these
battles in Soli (which he named “Pompey City”), some in de-
populated Dyma (which now h ouses a Roman colony).
665 C, 16-19 The poets (particularly the tragedians) confuse nations;
just as they use the name “Phrygians” for Trojans, Mysians,
and Lydians, so they call Lycians “Carians.” |
665 C, 20-30 Soon after Daedala (the Lycian mountain), there are Daedala (mountain), Kızıldağ 14.3.4
Telmessus (a Lycian town) and Telmessis (headland with Telmessus, Fethiye (Tky.)
harbor). Eumenes received this area from the Romans dur- Telmessis (headland), Çamlı
Burun
ing their war against Antiochus; on the kingdom’s dissolu-
tion, the Lycians got it back again. | Following on from there, 14.3.5
from the shore, is not far away.) Lying at the foot of Cragus
on the inland side is Pinara, one of the largest cities in Lycia. Pinara, Minare (Tky.)
stades inland from the sea, sitting high on a hill. Then there’s
759
4.1. Northern Asia
666 C, 8-10 In between, on the said coast,1 there are many islands and
harbors, including the island Megista, with its city of the same Megista (island), Megiste (Gk.)
name . . . * Cisthena. Places in the interior include Phellus, Megista (city), Kastellorizon
(Megiste)
Antiphellus, and Chimaera (which I mentioned above).2 |
666 C, 11-19 Then t here are the Hiera headland and the Chelidonians— Hiera headland, Gelidonya 14.3.8
Burnu
three rugged islands of equal size (some five stades distant
Chelidonians, Beş Adalar (Tk.
from each other, six stades offshore), one of them with a islands)
mooring place. Many people assume that the Taurus starts
from here, owing to the height of the headland (an exten-
sion of the Pisidian mountains, which loom over Pamphylia)
and the way in which the offshore islands, lying in the open
sea, provide the mountain range with an obvious end point.
In actual fact, the mountain ridge runs in a continuous line
from the Rhodian Peraea to Pisidia, and this, too, is called the
“Taurus.” It is estimated that the Chelidonians are roughly
opposite Canobus—the distance between the two is said to Canobus, Abukir (Egy.)
is three hundred and sixty seven stades. This includes Cram- Crambusa, Sula Ada (Tk. island)
busa, Olympus (a large city and a homonymous mountain, Olympus (city), Deliktaş (Tky.)
[ 1 ] 665 C, 20–666 C, 8.
[ 2 ] 665 C, 20-30.
760
Mediterranean Coast of Fourth Section + Hinterland
667 C, 2-4 This city is Lycian, although situated on the Pamphylian this city = Phaselis, Tekirova
(Tky.)
side of the mountains. She does not, however, belong to the
Lycian federation but is autonomous. |
667 C, 5-13 The poet represents the Solymians as being diff erent people 14.3.10
poet = Homer (8th c. BCE) from the Lycians (since Bellerophontes, sent off by the Ly-
cian king on his second challenge, did b attle with the illustrious
Strabo argues against the Solymians). Some claim that the Lycians w ere early on called
identification of Homer’s
“Solymians” with Lycians “Solymians”; later named “Termilians,” a fter the Termilians
who accompanied Sarpedon out from Crete; later still were
named “Lycians,” a fter Lycus (son of Pandion), who, having
been banished from his home, was established by Sarpedon in
part of his kingdom. Their claim is inconsistent with Homer.
The better claim is that the p eople now known as “Milyans”
(about whom I have spoken)1 were called Solymians by the
poet. |
667 C, 14-33 After Phaselis, there’s Olbia, a huge fort marking the be- Olbia, Koruma (Tky.) 14.4.1
PAMPHYLIA ginning of Pamphylia; after Olbia, what is called the “Cata- Cataractes, Düden Çay
s. Turkey
ractes” (Crashing-down), a huge river, swollen with w ater, that
crashes down from a high cliff so that the din can be heard
from far away; then the city of Attalia, named a fter her Attalia, Antalya (Tky.)
stades up the river, you come to the city of Perga and, on an Perga, Aksu (Tky.)
elevated site nearby, the t emple to “Pergaean” Artemis, the
site of an annual festival; and some forty stades back from the
sea, the lofty city of Syllium, visible from Perga. Then t here’s Syllium, Asar Köy (Tky.)
Capria (a large lake), and a fter that the Eurymedon river. Sail- Eurymedon, Köprü Çay
ing sixty stades up the river, you come to the city of Aspendus, Aspendus, Belkis (Tky.)
river, and many small islands off the coast. Then t here’s Sida, Sida, Selimiye (Tky.)
ratans; then the Melas river with its anchorage; then the city
of Ptolemaïs; after that, the borderlands of Pamphylia and— Ptolemaïs, nr. Fiğla Burnu (Tky.)
marking the start of Rough Cilicia—Coracesium. The total Coracesium, Alanya (Tky.)
761
4.1. Northern Asia
Herodotus (5th c. BCE) peoples who left Troy in the retinue of Amphilochus and Calchas;
most of them stayed put in Pamphylia, although there were some who
Callisthenes (late 4th c. BCE) dispersed worldwide. Callisthenes says, although Calchas died in
Clarus, his people followed Mopsus across the Taurus, some settling
in Pamphylia, with splinter groups in Cilicia and in Syria as far as
Phoenicia. |
668 C, 7-14 As for Cilicia outside the Taurus, one part is called “Rough outside Taurus = south of Taurus 14.5.1
mts.
CILICIA Cilicia,” and one part is called “Level Cilicia.” Rough Cilicia
s. Turkey
is the one whose littoral is narrow, with none or hardly any
of it flat. Since the Taurus is immediately above her, she of-
fers a poor quality of life up to her northern side, which ex-
tends from the region of Isaura and the Homonadians far as
Pisidia. She also goes by the name of “Trachiotis” (Rough-land),
and her inhabitants by the name of “Trachiotes.” Level Cilicia
goes from Soli and Tarsus to Issus and t hose places imme- Soli, Viranşehir (Tky.)
diately above which are the Cappadocians (on the northern Tarsus, Tarsos (Tky.)
side of the Taurus); she has more by way of plains and fertile Issus, Yesil Hüyük (Tky.)
territory.
668 C, 14-16 Since some part of each is inside the Taurus and some inside Taurus = in n. Asia
part outside the Taurus, and since I have described the in- outside Taurus = in s. Asia
ROUGH CILICIA/TRACHIOTIS steep cliff. It was used as a base by Diodotus (surnamed “Try-
s. Turkey
phon”) when he initiated Syria’s dissent from the kings and
fought a long war against them, sometimes gaining ground,
sometimes losing it. Antiochus (son of Demetrius) trapped
him in a certain location and forced him to commit suicide.
Tryphon was one reason that the Cilicians turned to piracy;
another reason was the incompetence of the kings who suc-
ceeded in both Syria and Cilicia at that time. When Tryphon
rebelled, o thers did too, and the dissension of brother against
brother made the territory vulnerable to attack.
668 C, 26–669 C, 5 The export of slaves, proving most profitable, was the
driver of such criminal activity. Slaves were easy to capture.
There was a huge and lucrative market for them not far away
at all, in Delos, which made possible the import and export
[ 1 ] Strabo classifies the mountainous part of Cilicia as belonging “inside the Tau-
rus”: 490 C, 13–491 C, 5. Strictly, therefore, only this mountainous part should
be categorized as part of n. Asia: 537 C, 29–539 C, 26. For Strabo’s inclusion of
Rough and Level Cilicia here: 664 C, 5-15.
762
Mediterranean Coast of Fourth Section + Hinterland
763
4.1. Northern Asia
of shore called “Platanistus.” Then t here’s Anemurium head- Anemurium, Eski Anamur (Tky.)
sinoe, with its anchorage; then the site of Melania, and the city Arsinoe, Maraş Harabeleri (Tky.)
of Celenderis with its harbor. Some make Celenderis, rather Celenderis, Aydıncık (Tky.)
Artemidorus (late 2nd–early than Coracesium, the start of Cilicia. T hese include Artemi-
1st c. BCE)
dorus. He says that from the Pelusiac mouth it is three thousand six
hundred and fifty stades to Orthosia; one thousand one hundred and
thirty to the Orontes; next, five hundred and twenty to the Gates;1 one
thousand nine hundred to the Cilician border.2 |
670 C, 9-12 Then there’s Holmi, the former home of the current-day Holmi, nr. Taşucu (Tky.) 14.5.4
other headland.
670 C, 12-30 The river offers passage upstream to Seleucia, which, in a Seleucia-on-the-Calycadnus,
Silifke (Tky.)
radical departure from the Cilician and Pamphylian norm, is
a well-managed city. Eminent individuals from Seleucia have
Peripatetic = Aristotelian
included, in our times, the Peripatetic p hilosophers Athenaeus
Athenaeus, Xenarchus, 1st c.
and Xenarchus. Of these, Athenaeus was a politician and, for BCE
some time, a populist leader in his home city. Then he got em-
broiled with Murena and was captured with him as he fled into
exile (a plot against Caesar Augustus having been uncovered).
Found to be not guilty, Athenaeus was acquitted by Caesar.
When, on his return from Rome, the first well-wishers greeted
Euripides (5th c. BCE) him with questions, Athenaeus quoted Euripides: I am here, the
vaults of the dead and the gates of darkness / behind me.4 But Ath-
enaeus lived only a short time longer, killed when the house in
which he was living collapsed in the night. On the other hand,
Xenarchus, under whom I studied 5 and who spent little time
at home but pursued a life of teaching in Alexandria, Athens,
and finally Rome, enjoying the friendship of Arius and, a fter
that, of Caesar Augustus, lived in honor to a ripe old age,
afflicted by blindness just before dying from a disease. |
[ 1 ] The (Cilician) Gates (nr. Sarıseki, Tky.): 676 C, 20-28n. [ 3 ] Zephyrium = ?Ovacık Adası (Tky.). Cf. 671 C, 33–672 C, 9n.
[ 2 ] Artemidorus’s distances are along the Med. coast from the Pelusian mouth of [ 4 ] This “quoted” quotation contains a rare criticism of Augustus. Murena, a Roman
the Nile (Egypt) anticlockwise to the border between Cilicia and Pamphylia (s. aristocrat, was absent from the trial at which he was found guilty of treason; he
Turkey) Strabo’s point seems to be that, when Artemidorus uses the term “Cili- was captured in the process of leaving Italy and killed. Athenaeus’s quotation
cian border,” he means Celenderis (Aydıncık, Tky.) rather than Coracesium (Al- of Euripides implies horror at the manner of Murena’s death.
anya, Tky.). Strabo later (760 C, 11-16n) re-cites (with slightly different wording) [ 5 ] Xenarchus, like Strabo, led an international life. Strabo may have been edu-
the same passage by Artemidorus, giving Melania/Melaena as the terminus. cated by Xenarchus in Alexandria or, more probably, Rome (548 C, 9-14n; 609 C,
Variations in the manuscripts suggest that successive scribes have altered the 16-22n).
distance figures given here to be consistent with those given by Strabo in the
later re-citation.
764
Mediterranean Coast of Fourth Section + Hinterland
670 C, 31–671 C, 7 After Calycadnus, there’s what is called “Poecila cliff,” into 14.5.5
765
4.1. Northern Asia
t hose pirates who had survived and who, in his opinion, de-
served safety and a degree of care. He changed its name to
Pompey City. Famous men from there are Chrysippus (the Chrysippus, Aratus, 3rd c. BCE
near the Calycadnus).1 Then, a little inland, there’s Anchiala. Anchiala, Yümüktepe (Tky.)
Aristobulus (late 4th c. BCE) Aristobulus says, Anchiala was founded by Sardanapallus; Sar-
danapallus’s tomb is there, and a marble relief in which the fingers
of his right hand are brought together as if he is snapping them; and
the following inscription in Assyrian script—“Sardanapallus, son of
Anacyndaraxes, built Anchiala and Tarsus in one day; eat, drink,
and be merry; the rest is not worth this” (meaning a snap of the fin
?Choerilus (5th c. BCE) gers). Choerilus, too, records t hese words. This verse also sur-
vives: These I possess—the food I savored, the lusts I gratified, the
love / I felt. My many worldly goods are left behind. |
672 C, 10-22 Inland from Anchiala is Cyinda, a fortress once used as 14.5.10
seaport. | Up to this point, the w hole coastline (starting with this point = outlets of Cydnus r. 14.5.11
766
Mediterranean Coast of Fourth Section + Hinterland
the Rhodian Peraea) runs from due west to due east; then it
bends to the southeast as far as Issus, whereupon it immedi- Issus, Yesil Hüyük (Tky.)
673 C, 5-16 In truth, from h ere (Tarsus and the outlet of the Cydnus)
to Amisus is the isthmus of the peninsula that has been tra- Amisus, Samsun (Tky.)
[ 1 ] The Asian peninsula forms the framework of Strabo’s description of the 4th sec-
tion of n. Asia: 492 C, 10-16; 534 C, 8-20; 632 C, 1-4; 664 C, 5-15.
[ 2 ] I.e., from Amisus to Tarsus, as stated by Strabo at 126 C, 3-11. Cf. 676 C, 34–677 C,
15n.
[ 3 ] E.g., by Strabo himself, who gives “Issus,” the “Cilician sea,” the “Issian sea/gulf”
as the southern marker of the isthmus: 492 C, 10-16; 534 C, 8-20; 632 C, 1-4; 664 C.
5-15. “Issus” is also used by Apollodorus, for which he is taken to task by Strabo:
676 C, 34–677 C, 15.
[ 4 ] “Any place you care to name” = Rome.
[ 5 ] I.e., in Athens and Rome. With his comment on the lack of scholarly aptitude
among the locals, Strabo is perhaps making a jibe at Rome’s youth.
767
4.1. Northern Asia
sentenced them to exile, and sent them away. Before this, they
Boethus and partners parody had written the following graffiti on Athenodorus’s wall: young
a line from Hesiod (late 8th–
7th c. BCE): “young men work, men work, middle-aged men counsel, old men fart!1 Athenodorus
middle-aged men counsel, old took this in good humour and gave orders for the follow-
men pray”
ing response: old men thunder. Someone, however, with no
768
Mediterranean Coast of Fourth Section + Hinterland
decency but with loose bowels, going past the house in the
middle of the night, liberally shat all over the door and wall.
Athenodorus, laying the charge of intrigue against them in
front of the assembly, said: you can see the city’s sickness and evil
constitution everywhere, but particularly in her shit!
675 C, 7-18 While the foregoing were Stoics, my Nestor 1—who
taught Marcellus, the son of Octavia (Caesar’s sister)—was
an Academic. Taking over as head of the city government
after Athenodorus, Nestor continued to merit honor, from
both state officials and the citizen body. | Other p hilosophers 14.5.15
Strabo cites Homer (8th c. BCE) whom I might know and name include, among t hose who trav-
eled widely and w ere good at setting up schools, Plutiades
and Diogenes; 2 Diogenes also composed poems (usually
tragic ones) as if by inspiration, on any topic handed to him.
Literary experts who left b ehind them written works include
Artemidorus and Diodorus. T here was also Dionysiades, the Artemidorus, 1st c. BCE
[ 1 ] “My” (which can also be translated as “our”) implies that Strabo was an admirer
of Nestor, perhaps a student or friend. Cf. Strabo’s reference to “my” (or “our”)
Aristodemus, his teacher from Nysa: 650 C, 24-32.
[ 2 ] Strabo implies that he knew Plutiades and Diogenes personally.
[ 3 ] 536 C, 3-20, where Strabo describes the upper reaches of the Pyramus from
personal experience.
[ 4 ] 642 C, 21–643 C, 9.
769
4.1. Northern Asia
676 C, 5-6 Crates, the literary expert, said to have been a disciple of Crates, 2nd c. BCE
age). Then there’s the Amanian Gates (with anchorage). Amanian Gates, Karanlıkkapı
(Tky.)
This marks the end of the Amanus mountain range (which
Amanus, Nur Dağları (Tky.)
stretches from the Taurus and lies inland from the eastern part
of Cilicia). This mountain range always used to be ruled by a
plethora of petty kings with their strongholds. In our times,
however, one celebrated man established himself as supreme
commander of all, and obtained the title of “king” from the
Romans in return for his good s ervice. This was Tarcondimo-
tus; and he handed the succession on to his descendants. |
676 C, 20-28 After Aegaeae, there’s Issus (a small town, with an anchor- Issus, Yesil Hüyük (Tky.) 14.5.19
age) and the Pinarus river. This is where the b attle between
Alexander and Darius took place. The gulf, too, is called
“Issian.” On the gulf are the cities of Rhosus, Myriandrus, Rhosus, Uluçınar/Arsuz (Tky.)
Alexandria, Nicopolis, Mopsu Hestia, and what are called Myriandrus, Ada Tepe (Tky.)
the “Gates,”1 marking the border between the Cilicians and Alexandria, Esentepe, in town
of İskenderun (Tky.)
oracle, both a center for divine Syrians. Also in Cilicia are the t emple and oracle of “Sarpe-
prophecy and a prophecy given Nicopolis, nr. Yesil Hüyük (Tky.)
in such a place donian” Artemis; the oracles are delivered by people in the
Mopsu Hestia, Yakapınar (Tky.)
grip of divine inspiration. | After Cilicia, the first Syrian city 14.5.20
676 C, 29-33 The Trojan Cilicians 2 that are mentioned by Homer are 14.5.21
very far away from the Cilicians outside the Taurus. Some say
that the latter have their origins among the Trojan Cilicians;
they adduce certain places in Cilicia, such as Pamphylian
Thebe and Lyrnessus. O thers, taking the opposite view, ad-
duce an “Aleian plain” in Troy.
[ 1 ] Usually referred to as the “Cilician Gates” (nr. Sarıseki, Tky.); cf. 669 C, 32–670 C, 8.
[ 2 ] Trojan Cilicians: 572 C, 21-30n.
770
Overview of Asian Peninsula
676 C, 34–677 C, 15 Now that the part1 of the said peninsula2 lying outside the
Taurus has been traversed, I must add the following. | In his 14.5.22
ing up to Sinope missed touching each other by only a small Sinope, Sinop (Tky.)
771
4.1. Northern Asia
Issus to the Chelidonians. This leaves out the whole of the Ly- Issus, Yesil Hüyük (Tky.)
cian coast (which provides a straight-line continuation of this Chelidonians, Beş Adalar (Tk.
islands)
side) and the Rhodian Peraea as far as Physcus, which is where
the mainland coast makes a turn to form the beginning of the
second (western) side as far as the Propontis and Byzantium. | Propontis, Marmara Denizi
677 C, 33–678 C, 16 Ephorus says that sixteen tribes inhabited this peninsula, three 14.5.23
Ephorus (4th c. BCE) lists tribes of them Greek, the rest (except for the hybrids) native. The Cilicians,
in Asian peninsula
Pamphylians, Lycians, Bithynians, Paphlagonians, Mariandynians,
Trojans, and Carians w ere coastal tribes; the Pisidians, Mysians,
Chalybians, Phrygians, and Milyans w ere interior tribes. In his
Apollodorus (2nd c. BCE) analysis of this description, Apollodorus says, there is a seven-
contrasts situation in his day
with situation described by teenth tribe, that of the Galatians, of more recent date than Ephorus.
Ephorus (4th c. BCE); and Of the tribes mentioned, the Greek ones had not yet been settled in the mentioned = by Ephorus
situation described by Ephorus
with the situation described by Trojan period, while the native tribes have become hybridized over
Homer (8th c. BCE)
time. The poet lists the tribes of the Trojans and of the (still so-named)
“Paphlagonians,” “Mysians,” “Phrygians,” “Carians,” and “Lycians”;
the “Meionians” (for the Lydians); other unknown tribes, such as the
“Halizonians” and “Cauconians”; and—outside the Catalogue1—the
“Cetians,” “Solymians,” “Cilicians” (from the plain of Thebe), and
“Lelegians.” He does not mention by name Pamphylians, Bithynians,
Mariandynians, Pisidians, Chalybians, Milyans, or Cappadocians—
some, because they had not yet settled these places, others because they
were included with other tribes (e.g., the Idrians and Termilians with
the Carians, the Dolionians and Bebrycians with the Phrygians). |
678 C, 17-31 Apollodorus is clearly insufficiently critical of Ephorus’s 14.5.24
Strabo claims Apollodorus statements (at the same time falsifying what the poet says and
should have objected
to Ephorus’s inclusion of throwing it into confusion).2 In the first instance, Apollodorus
Chalybians in Asian peninsula should have asked Ephorus why he locates the Chalybians
inside the peninsula (given how far east of Sinope and Amisus Sinope, Sinop (Tky.)
they are). T hose who draw a line from Issus to the Euxine Amisus, Samsun (Tky.)
as the isthmus of this peninsula treat this line as a meridian. Issus, Yesil Hüyük (Tky.)
Some consider it to be the Sinope meridian, some the Ami- Euxine, Black Sea
sus meridian, but no one considers it to be the Chalybian me-
ridian—it would be totally skewed. The Chalybian meridian
should be drawn through Little Armenia and the Euphrates,
and would leave all of Cappadocia—as well as Commagene, Amanus [mountains], Nur
Dağları (Tky.)
the Amanus, and the Issian gulf—inside. Were we to concede
inside = within Asian peninsula
that the skewed line demarcates the isthmus, most of these
places—in particular, Cappadocia and what is now known by
the specific name of “Pontus” (the part of Cappadocia on the
[ 1 ] The “title” Catalogue refers to a part of Homer’s Iliad. Strabo often uses “titles”
for parts of Homer’s poems (4 C, 14-20n), as well as for parts of his own work
(639 C, 15-27n).
[ 2 ] Apollodorus’s misuse of the poet (= Homer): 679 C, 28–681 C, 24.
772
Overview of Asian Peninsula
yond t hose stated to have been named by him (or not named him = Ephorus
tribes? If it is b
ecause in antiquity the Ionians and Athenians
were one and the same, then let Dorians and Aeolians be said
to be one and the same, too, in which case there would be two
tribes. If divisions are to be made in accordance with later cul-
ture (in accordance with, for example, language) then there
would be four tribes, just as there are four languages. This
peninsula is inhabited, specifically according to Ephorus’s
division, not only by Ionians but also by Athenians, as has
been shown in my detailed description.2
679 C, 23-27 It is worth raising such questions as these with regard to
Apollodorus (2nd c. BCE) Ephorus. Apollodorus, however, raised none of them, but adds
to the sixteen nations the seventeenth tribe, that of the Galatians, in
many ways a useful addition but irrelevant to the discussion of
[ 1 ] 549 C, 11-30.
[ 2 ] Athenian origin of some Ionian cities: 632 C, 17–633 C, 19. Cf. Adramyttium:
606 C, 27-33. Elaea: 622 C, 1-15.
773
4.1. Northern Asia
679 C, 28–680 C, 9 Moving on to the poet,1 he correctly states that changing poet = Homer 14.5.27
774
Cyprus
680 C, 25–681 C, 3 One might blame Apollodorus even more for this reason: 14.5.29
Apollodorus (2nd c. BCE) although usually very critical of later writers whose innova- later = post-Homeric
of the same name, out of which flows the Ascanius river. The
Euphorion (3rd c. BCE) river is also mentioned by Euphorion (by the w aters of Mysian
Alexander (3rd c. BCE) Ascanius) and by Alexander of Aetolia (who have their dwellings
by the Ascanian stream, / on the banks of lake Ascania, where Do- Ascanius (river), Gemlik Dere
lion / lived, the son of Silenus and Melia). He says that “Dolionis” He = Apollodorus
and “Mysia” are names given to the Cyzicus region in the direction
of Miletus City. If all this is so, and the evidence is provided by
places identified in the current-day and by the poets, what is
there to prevent Homer from having meant this “Ascania”
rather than the one referred to by Xanthus? These matters
have been already dealt with, in the section on the Mysians
and Phrygians,2 so let me end h ere. |
681 C, 25-33 What remains 3 is the island of Cyprus, which lies alongside 14.6.1
CYPRUS this peninsula4 to the south. As has been noted, the part of the
Kypros
sea that is contained by Egypt, Phoenicia, Syria, and by the
remaining stretch of coastline to Rhodia, is more or less made Rhodia = Rhodian Peraea, sw.
Turkey
up of the Egyptian sea, the Pamphylian sea, and the sea in the
[ 1 ] “Left-Hand Side of the Pontus” (Black Sea coast of Eur. Tky, Bul., Rom., Ukr.,
Crim., Russ.): 289 C, 1-7n.
[ 2 ] 564 C, 27–565 C, 6.
[ 3 ] I.e., what “remains” to be described of 4th section of n. Asia, as adumbrated at
492 C, 10-16.
[ 4 ] “Peninsula” = Asian peninsula.
775
4.1. Northern Asia
pathian sea to the west; to its south and east are Egypt and the
coastline following on from there as far as Seleucia and Issus; Issus, Yesil Hüyük (Tky.)
to its north are Cyprus and the Pamphylian sea. This other sea other sea = Pamphylian sea
hundred stades if you travel overland by road from east to Acamas, Cape Arnaoutis/
Akamas (Cyp.)
west. The Cleides are two small islands lying off Cyprus at
the eastern end of the island, seven hundred stades from
the Pyramus. Acamas is a headland, with two hills and lots
of trees, located in the west of the island, stretching north-
ward. It is closest to Selinus in Rough Cilicia (a crossing of Selinus, Kale Tepe (Tky.)
one thousand stades); the crossing to Sida in Pamphylia is one Sida, Selimiye (Tky.)
thousand six hundred [stades]; the crossing to the Chelidonians Chelidonians, Beş Adalar (Tk.
islands)
is one thousand nine hundred [stades]. The overall shape of the
island is oblong, with occasional isthmuses along the sides
that define its breadth.
682 C, 12-27 The following is a summarized place-by-place description,
starting with the point nearest the mainland. | I said elsewhere 14.6.3
that a Cyprian promontory, the Crommyum headland, lies op- Crommyum, Kormakitis (Tk.
Cyp.)
posite the Anemurium headland (part of Rough Cilicia) at a
Anemurium, Eski Anamur (Tky.)
distance of three hundred and fifty stades.2 From Crommyum,
keeping the island to your immediate right and the mainland
to your left, your course lies northeast t oward the Cleides, a Cleides, Kleides (Tk. Cyp.)
straight-line sailing distance of seven hundred stades. In the
interim, there’s the city of Lapathus—with its anchorage and Lapathus, N Karavas (Tk. Cyp.)
[ 1 ] 121 C, 21-28.
[ 2 ] 669 C, 20-32.
776
Cyprus
lands. Then t here are the Carpasian islands and, a fter them,
Aristus, ?3rd c. BCE Salamis (the writer Aristus is from Salamis); then Arsinoe, Salamis, NW Ammokhostos
(Tk. Cyp.)
city and harbor; then Leucolla, another harbor; then Pedalium
Pedalium, Cape Gkreko (Cyp.)
trapezoid, table-shaped headland, overlooked by a rugged and steep trapezoid hill, sa-
cred to Aphrodite, to which the distance from the Cleides is six
hundred and eighty stades. Then the coastline is indented and
rocky as far as Citium, which has a harbor whose entrance can Citium, Larnaka (Cyp.)
be closed (Zeno, founder of the Stoic sect, and Apollonius, the Zeno, 4th–3rd c. BCE
physician, are from Citium); thence to Berytus is one thousand Apollonius, early 1st c. BCE
five hundred stades. Then t here’s the city of Amathus (with Berytus, Beirut (Leb.)
mastoid, breast-shaped a town called “Palaea” in the interim and a mastoid mountain, Amathus, NE Lemesos (Cyp.)
Olympus); then Curias headland, almost an island (the distance Curias, Akrotiri (Br. Cyp.)
from the Cilician shore to the Curiad shore; and declares it a mani-
fold wonder for men to know how, o’er the untraveled / deep, with a
spring wind from the west, we coursed ! From Corycus to the Cu-
riad shore is a sea voyage, not a channel crossing! Nor do you
make it with a westerly wind, nor with the island on your right
but rather on your left.
683 C, 17-27 Curium marks the start of the western coast, which f aces Curium, SW Episkopi (Br. Cyp.)
777
4.1. Northern Asia
778
Cyprus
[ 1 ] Strabo may refer to “our” Cleopatra b ecause she was his contemporary (born
69 BCE); or because he identifies with the people of Alexandria in Egypt (Is-
kandariya), where Strabo describes himself as “living . . . for a long time” (101 C,
14-24). Cf. “our Auletes”: 795 C, 28-33n.
[ 2 ] Roman “provinces of the people” were either praetorian (i.e., governed by a
man previously a praetor at Rome) or consular (i.e., governed by a man previ-
ously a consul): 840 C, 13-26.
779
Ca
spia
Azerbaijan
n
Turkmenistan China
Se
Tajikistan
a
Turkey
Syria
Cyprus
5
Lebanon Afghanistan
Iraq Iran
1
Israel 4
Jordan 2
Kuwait
6 3 Pakistan Nepal
Pe Bhutan
rsi
an
Egypt Gu
lf
Qatar Bangladesh
Saudi Arabia
Nile
UAE
Arabian
7 Oman Sea India
Re
d
Se
a
Sudan
Eritrea Yemen
Djibouti
Ethiopia Somalia
Sri
Lanka
?
Translator’s Introduction
Strabo’s “southern Asia” includes areas that would hardly be considered part of the
southern world t oday. We are as guilty as Strabo in using a nomenclature that reflects our
vantage point rather than an objective standard. “North,” “south,” “east,” and “west” are
directions rather than places, and when used in geographical discourse, they tell us more
about the location of the speakers than about the areas of which they speak. Thus, a large
part of Strabo’s southern Asia is occupied by what we today refer to—using nomenclature
coined by western Europeans and reflecting their perspective—as the “Middle East.”
A further complication for the modern reader is that several of the names used by
Strabo in connection with southern Asia (e.g., “India,” “Egypt,” and “Ethiopia”) are still
in use t oday, albeit no longer denoting exactly the same areas as their Strabonian counter
parts. It is difficult to rid ourselves of the present-day connotations of such names as
nation-states, but this we must do, putting ourselves in Strabo’s shoes and adopting the
much wider connotations that t hese names have for him.
781
4.2. Southern Asia
and Syria (5), approximating what we call the “Middle East” (sometimes, “Near East”).
Strabo’s Arabia (6) is vast, including Saudi Arabia, Kuwait, parts of southern Iraq, Bah-
rain, Qatar, United Arab Emirates (UAE), Yemen, Oman, Jordan, southern Israel, and
parts of eastern Egypt. Strabo’s description is complicated by the nomadic nature of
many Arabic groups in his day, making it difficult for him to fit them into rigidly defined
territories. The boundaries of the Arabs—as opposed to the boundaries of Arabia—are
fluid and include areas otherwise considered part of Syria or Assyria.
Strabo inserts into his account of Arabia descriptions of the Persian Gulf and of what
he calls the “Arabian gulf ” (Red Sea). The former is described from the point of view of
a navigator sailing anticlockwise from its mouth. As for the latter, Strabo only briefly
adumbrates the Arabian side, from what is now the Gulf of Aqaba to the mouth. He
focuses his attention on what he calls the Trogodyte side, from the Gulf of Suez to the
mouth, as well as the coastline beyond the mouth.
Strabo finishes his journey through southern Asia with a description of the Nile region
(7), which consists of present-day Egypt as far upstream as Syene (Aswan), and beyond
that Ethiopia (southern present-day Egypt, Sudan, South Sudan, present-day Ethiopia, Soma-
lia). The western seaboard of the Red Sea (Egypt, Sudan, Eritrea, Djibouti) and the coast of
what Strabo calls Cinnamonland (Somalia) form something of a transitional area between
Egypt and Arabia, inhabited by Trogodytes.
Strabo’s inclusion of what he calls “Egypt” and “Ethiopia” within the continent of Asia
is striking. Do these countries not lie firmly on the African continent? And should they
not therefore be included in that continent, which Strabo calls “Libya” and with which
he concludes his world description (chapter 5)? The Asian status of these areas well il-
lustrates the mindset of Strabo’s day. His inclusion of them within Asia reflects a cultural
attitude rather than a geographic al reality. In the twenty-first century, we might agree
with Strabo to the extent of seeing Egypt as at least ambiguous, but we would generally
categorize places such as Somalia, Sudan, and present-day Ethiopia as part of Africa.
Differences between Strabo’s mindset and our own illustrate the fluidity over time of
geographical categories.
India
It is worth looking in a l ittle more detail at why Strabo’s account of India is so backward-
looking and its tone so otherworldly. Strabo’s focus is on the conquests of Alexander the
Great, who, in what was partly an exploration and partly a military campaign, defeated
the Persian king and continued marching eastward, opening up parts of the world hith-
erto little known to the west. In 327–325 BCE, Alexander led his army through southern
Afghanistan and eastern Pakistan before famously turning back at the Hypanis (Beas,
Sutlej rivers), a tributary of the Indus. It is the Indus river basin that constitutes “India”
as far as Alexander is concerned. It was in nobody’s interest at the time to emphasize how
much land remained unconquered to the east.
782
Translator’s Introduction
More than three hundred years later, in Strabo’s day, connections between India and
the western world have been reestablished, with the arrival at Augustus’s court of a spec-
tacular embassy from India. Indeed, Strabo ends his account of India with a powerful
picture of this embassy and its retinue of unusual gifts. By this stage, power in India has
shifted from the north, where it had been located in Alexander’s day, to the south and
east. Strabo’s account makes little of this fact. As far as Rome is concerned, there is more
political mileage to be gained from emphasizing continuity with the glorious past than
in stressing new developments. This partly explains why Strabo makes so much use of
writers who accompanied Alexander on his campaign as far as the Hypanis river, and of
writers who went beyond the Hypanis and visited northern India in the following years,
even though their accounts are centuries out of date by the time Strabo cites them.
The writers used by Strabo in his account of India are primarily Nearchus, Onesicritus,
and Aristobulus (late fourth century BCE); Patrocles and Megasthenes (late fourth–early
third c entury BCE); and Deimachus (third c entury BCE). None of their works is available
today. Strabo, in citing them frequently and sometimes at g reat length, has done us a f avor
by preserving at least some of their content. This f avor is somewhat marred by Strabo’s
tendency to switch between references to “this fellow” and “that fellow,” without making
it clear which writer he means. Perhaps, if Strabo w ere delivering his narrative orally in a
lecture hall, his gestures would make his statements clearer. Readers in the twenty-first
century have to accept some ambiguity as to what content belongs to which writer.
Some of Strabo’s borrowings are by modern standards excessive. In one section,
Strabo uses Megasthenes as the basis of his narrative for some eleven pages. Admittedly,
further content by other writers is inserted, accounting for around two of these eleven
pages. (The inserted information contains instructions on how to hunt an elephant and is
provided in such a poignant and vivid manner that it should be required reading for any-
one studying Strabo.) Excluding this insertion, Strabo’s borrowing from Megasthenes in
this one section amounts to some three thousand words, or one percent of the total length
of Strabo’s work. It would be unthinkable, or unpardonable, for writers t oday to include
such a large excerpt from someone else’s work. Strabo perhaps considers that he is doing
his bit to ensure the future enjoyment of Megasthenes’s work by subsequent generations.
In an age when written works had to be constantly recopied from papyrus roll to papyrus
roll (or, for mega-works like Strabo’s own, from one set of such rolls to another), extensive
quotation helped to ensure at least the partial transmission of works that otherwise might
not survive into the future—as indeed the work of Megasthenes did not.
Stories derived from Megasthenes and other writers who visited northern India in the
immediate wake of Alexander’s conquests betray glimmers of knowledge about China.
Strabo refers, for example, to a people called the “Seres” (the name by which the Chinese
were known in l ater times). However, there is no room in Strabo’s lived-in world for the
physical landmass of China, and the Seres are implicitly placed vaguely in some part of
northern India.
783
4.2. Southern Asia
Remember
784
CH APT E R FOU R Southern Asia
PART 2
685 C, 6-10 What remains of Asia1 are the parts outside the Taurus outside Taurus = s. Asia 15.1.1
Strabo segues from his (with the exception of Cilicia, Pamphylia, and Lycia),2 the
description of northern Asia to
his description of southern Asia parts stretching from India to the Nile, between the Taurus
and the outer sea in the south. (Libya, which I will describe Libya = Africa (chap. 5)
685 C, 11-19 At this point, I will start with India, since it is the first
territory (starting in the east) and the largest. | One should 15.1.2
Parthica,3 mentioning the Greeks who incited Bactriana to rebel Bactrian kings (n. Afghanistan)
invaded India, late 3rd–early
from the kings of Syria, who w
ere descended from Seleucus Nicator, 2nd c. BCE
says that once they had grown strong, they attacked India. Apol-
lodorus adds nothing to what was already known. He even
contradicts it, claiming they conquered more of India than the
Macedonians did, with Eucratidas alone holding one thousand cities
[ 1 ] I.e., what “remains” of Strabo’s description of Asia, as per his division of n. and
s. Asia at 490 C, 1–492 C, 19.
[ 2 ] Cilicia, Pamphylia, Lycia (s. Turkey): 664 C, 16–676 C, 33.
[ 3 ] See 639 C, 15-27n.
785
4.2. Southern Asia
those people = Macedonian in subjection. Yet those p eople say that, between the Hydaspes and
writers accompanying Porus, a Punjab king, was
Alexander the Hypanis alone, t here were nine nations, with five thousand cities, defeated by Alexander in 326
BCE, then administered his
none of them smaller than Meropian Cos; Alexander conquered this former kingdom as Alexander’s
whole territory and handed it over to Porus. | representative
686 C, 10-16 As for those merchants currently plying the route from 15.1.4
Egypt, via the Nile and the Arabian gulf, to India—only a few Arabian gulf, Red Sea
have sailed around the coast as far as the Ganges, and they are
commoners,1 who contribute nothing to our understanding
of these areas. Sent from there (from a single place and from from there = from the Ganges
region
a single king, Pandion—a second Porus)2 to Caesar Augustus
Augustus received embassy
were gifts, and ambassadors, and the Indian philosopher who from Pandion, end of 20 BCE
self-immolated in Athens (just like Calanus, who created such
a spectacle for Alexander).3 |
686 C, 17-25 Leaving these matters aside, if you focus on events prior to 15.1.5
his men safely to victory past the same nations and places.
686 C, 25–687 C, 8 Alexander believed t hese stories | but, as for us, how could 15.1.6
Tearcon got that far as well, but this fellow led his forces onward from this fellow = ?Nabocodrosorus
Iberia into Thrace and the Pontus. Idanthyrsus of Scythia overran
Asia as far as Egypt. Not one of them, however, reached India; even
Semiramis died before she could make the attempt. The Persians sent
for mercenaries—the Hydracians 4—from India but did not cam-
paign t here, although they came close when Cyrus launched a strike
on the Massagetans. |
[ 1 ] The Greek word for “commoners” (idiotai) is the root of the English word “idiot”
and, in Strabo’s usage, has much the same connotation.
[ 2 ] This translation follows the manuscript reading rather than Radt’s emendation
(vol. 4, critical apparatus on 686 C, lines 13-14). Strabo’s presentation of Pandion
as a “second Porus” mirrors the usage of Strabo’s contemporary the writer Nico-
laus, who refers to Pandion as “Porus” (719 C, 21-29n).
[ 3 ] Strabo draws parallels between the relationship of Alexander the Great with
the Indian king Porus (late 4th c. BCE) and the relationship of Augustus with
Pandion (late 1st c. BCE).
[ 4 ] Probably the same as the “Sydracians”: 687 C, 31–688 C, 14; 701 C, 2-9.
786
India
687 C, 9-30 Megasthenes and a few o thers consider the stories told 15.1.7
Megasthenes (late 4th–early about Heracles and Dionysus to be credible. Most other
3rd c. BCE)
writers (including Eratosthenes) consider them devoid of
Eratosthenes (3rd c. BCE)
credibility and the product of myth, as likewise the stories
Euripides (5th c. BCE) told by the Greeks. In Euripides’s Bacchae, Dionysus says,
with swagger: traveling from the gold-rich fields of Lydians / and
Phrygians, to the sun-baked plains of Persians, / walled Bactrian
cities, the wintry land / of Medes, and blessed Arabia /—to the
Sophocles (5th c. BCE) whole of Asia. Sophocles has someone praise “Nysa” as being
a mountain sacred to Dionysus: whence I saw Nysa—filled with
the spirit of Bacchus / and famous among mortals—which the bull-
horned / Iacchus cherishes as his much-loved nurse. / What bird does
not sing there? and so on. He is also called “Merotraphes.” The He = Dionysus
their city of Nysa “founded by Dionysus,” and the mountain Nysaeans, lower Kunar valley
(Afg.)
above the city “Merus.” (Their reasoning was that ivy grows
there, and vines, albeit ones that produce no fruit—excessive
rains cause the grapes to drop off before they ripen.) They
called the Sydracians “descendants of Dionysus” because of
their vines and flamboyant processions—their kings march
out to b attle and hold other processions in a bacchic frenzy,
accompanied by drumbeats and brightly colored clothes (a
practice found among other Indians, too). When Alexan-
der took, at his first attempt, the cliff of Aornus (at the base Aornus, ?Pir Sar (Pak.)
787
4.2. Southern Asia
ers is clear, first of all, from the fact that writers do not agree
with each other (while some relate these events, others do not
even mention them, yet it is unlikely that they knew nothing
of such famous and contrived exploits, or that they knew of
them but considered them not worth mentioning, especially
when t hese are precisely the writers who are the most trust-
worthy); and, secondly, from the fact that the p eople in be-
tween (past whom t hose associated with Dionysus and Her-
acles would necessarily have traveled to get to the Indians)2
have no evidence of such passage through their lands. Also,
the Heraclian paraphernalia mentioned above postdates what
is written about the Trojan war and is a fiction created by the
Pisander (7th–6th c. BCE) authors of the Heraclia (Deeds of Heracles)—perhaps Pisander,
perhaps someone e lse. The ancient cult statues are not so
adorned. |
688 C, 25–689 C, 2 In such matters, one has to accept what is the most cred- 15.1.10
is bounded to the north, from Ariana to the eastern sea, by eastern sea, Bay of Bengal
[ 1 ] 505 C, 19–506 C, 3.
[ 2 ] “Those associated with Dionysus and Heracles” is idiomatic, meaning simply
Dionysus and Heracles.
[ 3 ] General discussion concerning sources: 14 C, 5–109 C, 11.
[ 4 ] Strabo discusses Eratosthenes as a source: 15 C, 1–94 C, 20, with particular
reference to Eratosthenes’s 3rd geographical volume (which Strabo defends
against the criticisms of Hipparchus, 67 C, 7–94 C, 20). For India in particular:
68 C, 9–78 C, 18; 84 C, 3-9.
[ 5 ] From 689 C, 3 to 690 C, 35, Strabo seems to use Eratosthenes as his main source.
788
India
689 C, 32–690 C, 6 From this, it can be seen how different the assertions of 15.1.12
Ctesias (late 5th c. BCE) other writers are. Ctesias says that India is no smaller in size than
Onesicritus, Nearchus (late the rest of Asia; Onesicritus says that India amounts to a third of
4th c. BCE)
the lived-in world; Nearchus says that it is a four-month march
Megasthenes (late 4th–early through the plain alone. Megasthenes and Deimachus are more
3rd c. BCE)
moderate, in that they give as more than twenty thousand stades
Deimachus (3rd c. BCE)
the distance from the southern sea to the Caucasus (with Deima-
chus saying it is more than thirty thousand in some places). These
writers have been countered in my introduction.3 It suffices
now to say that their statements validate the claim for for-
giveness by those who cannot be sure of anything they say
about India! |
690 C, 7-18 All India is traversed by rivers. Some of them are tribu- 15.1.13
taries of the largest two rivers, the Indus and the Ganges;
[ 1 ] Strabo perhaps corrects his earlier figures of 12,000 stades (w. side of India) and
15,000 stades (e. side of India): 68 C, 9-17; 69 C, 31–70 C, 5.
[ 2 ] Strabo’s words are ambiguous. See “Translator’s Note on Strabo’s ‘India,’ ” at end
of chap. 4.2.
[ 3 ] 67 C, 7–77 C, 25 (esp. 70 C, 16-20).
789
4.2. Southern Asia
thers have their own outlets to the sea. All of them rise
o
in the Caucasus and flow south to begin with. Some then
continue onward in that direction, particularly t hose that
feed into the Indus; o thers, like the Ganges, curve eastward.
The Ganges comes down from the mountains; reaching the
plains, it curves to the east and flows past Palibothra (a very Palibothra, Patna (Ind.)
Delta.
690 C, 19-21 According to Eratosthenes, it is because of evaporation from
Eratosthenes (3rd c. BCE) these rivers, combined with the Etesian winds, that India has heavy Etesian winds = summer
monsoon
rainfall in the summer and her plains get flooded.1
690 C, 21-27 The rainy season sees the sowing of flax, millet, sesame,
rice, and bosmorum; wintertime sees the sowing of wheat,
barley, pulses, and other edible crops of which we have no
experience. What is grown in India is virtually the same as
in Ethiopia and Egypt; and as for river animals, Indian rivers
Onesicritus (late 4th c. BCE) feature all but hippopotami (although Onesicritus says there
are hippos).2
690 C, 27-30 As for the people, those in the south resemble Ethiopians
in the color of their skin but resemble o thers in their facial
features and hair (because of the humidity, their hair is not
woolly); t hose in the north resemble the Egyptians.3 |
690 C, 31-34 Taprobane is said to be an island lying out to sea, a seven Taprobane, Sri Lanka 15.1.14
790
India
691 C, 9-17 Nearchus, in discussing the sediment deposited by the riv- 15.1.16
Nearchus (late 4th c. BCE) ers, draws the following parallels, noting that the plain “of the
Hermus,” the plain “of the Cayster,” the plain “of the Maeander,” Hermus, Cayster, Maeander,
Caecus, rivers in w. Turkey
and the plain “of the Caecus” are similarly so labeled because the sedi-
ment that is carried into the plains c auses them to expand, or rather
the sediment brought down from the mountains—since it is earthy
and friable—creates them; since the rivers carry the sediment, the
plains are their offspring, so to speak, and it is well said that the plains
Herodotus (5th c. BCE) “belong to them.” This is the same as what is said by Herodo-
tus in the case of the Nile and the land on its banks, that it is
the river’s gift. Nearchus says, this is the reason the Nile is correctly
known by the same name as Egypt. |
691 C, 18-25 Aristobulus1 says, it rains and snows only in the mountains and 15.1.17
Aristobulus (late 4th c. BCE) hill country; in the plains, it neither rains nor snows, and the plains
flood only b ecause the rivers overflow; in the mountains, it snows dur-
ing the winter and begins to rain with the onset of spring, the rain
getting heavier and heavier as time progresses; during the Etesians, Etesians = summer monsoon
the rain pours down incessantly and violently, day and night, u ntil
the rising of Arcturus; 2 the rivers, now swollen by snow and rain,
water the plains.
691 C, 25-34 He says that these observations were made by himself and others, He = Aristobulus
for they set out for India from the Paropamisadians, but after the set-
ting of the Pleiades,3 they spent the winter in the mountainous coun-
try of the territory of the Hypasians and of Assacanus, and then,
when spring began, they descended to the plains and to the huge city of
Taxila, and thence to the Hydaspes and to Porus’s territory; during
the winter, no rain was seen, only snow, but it first rained in Taxila, Taxila, Taxila (Pak.)
and during the descent to the Hydaspes and the conquest of Porus, Hydaspes, Jhelum r.
when their route was eastward to the Hypanis and thence back to the Hypanis, Beas, Sutlej r.
Hydaspes, it rained continuously (particularly during the Etesians) Etesians = summer monsoon
and only let up at the rising of Arcturus.4
691 C, 34–692 C, 9 After spending some time on the Hydaspes constructing ships, they
began their voyage not many days before the setting of the Pleiades;5
with the voyage occupying the entire autumn, winter, following
spring, and summer, they arrived at Patalene around the time of the
rising of the Dog Star;6 in the ten months of the voyage, no rain was
ever seen, not even at the height of the Etesians, yet the rivers r ose and Etesians = time of summer
monsoon
flooded the plains; it was impossible to voyage across the sea in the face
Nearchus (late 4th c. BCE) of opposing winds, with no offshore breezes to help them. | Nearchus 15.1.18
says the same things but does not agree about the summer
[ 1 ] Strabo uses Aristobulus as his main source, 691 C, 18–693 C, 13. below the western horizon just before the sun rises above the eastern horizon.
[ 2 ] The “[dawn] rising” of the star Arcturus was used in antiquity to denote the time The exact date was different in antiquity than now, and also depended on the
of year when, a fter a short period of being invisible in the night sky, Arcturus latitude of the observer. For Aristobulus, the date is in November.
first becomes visible again, rising over the eastern horizon shortly before [ 4 ] [Dawn] rising of Arcturus: 691 C, 18-25n.
sunrise. The exact date was different in antiquity than now, and also depended [ 5 ] [Dawn] setting of the Pleiades: 691 C, 25-34n.
on the latitude of the observer. For Aristobulus, the date is in September. [ 6 ] The “[dawn] rising” of a star: 691 C, 18-25n. For Aristobulus, the “rising of the
[ 3 ] The “[dawn] setting” of the Pleiades star cluster refers to the time of year when Dog Star” denotes a date in July.
the constellation, having been visible all night, can first be observed to sink
791
4.2. Southern Asia
rains—he says, it does rain on the plains in the summer, but there
is no rain in the winter.
692 C, 9-19 Both writers refer to the rivers overflowing. Nearchus says Both writers = Aristobulus,
Nearchus
that when they set up camp near the Acesines, they were forced to
Acesines, Chenab r.
move to another site higher up b ecause the river r ose; this occurred at
Aristobulus (late 4th c. BCE) the time of the summer solstice. Aristobulus gives the amount of
the rise as forty cubits: twenty cubits, the amount by which the river 1 cubit = 1.5 ft.
rose above its previous level to the tops of its banks, and twenty the
amount by which it overflowed into the plains. Both writers agree
that the cities, built on high points of land, become islands (as also
happens in Egypt and Ethiopia); after Arcturus,1 the flooding stops,
and the w ater recedes; the earth, a fter being furrowed by the simplest
plowshare, is seeded while still only half-dry—but the crop ripens,
and the yield is good.
692 C, 19-29 Aristobulus says, the rice plant stands in a watery enclosure;
Aristobulus (late 4th c. BCE) it is contained within beds; the plant has a four-cubit height, is 1 cubit = 1.5 ft.
Egypt and Ethiopia. He asks: Given that the rise in the level of
the Nile is caused by rainfall in the south, and given that the rise in
the level of the Indian rivers is caused by rainfall in the north, why
is t here is no rainfall in the places between—neither in the Thebaïs Thebaïs as far as Syene . . .
Meroe = s. present-day Egypt,
as far as Syene and places near Meroe, nor in the part of India from n. Sudan
Patalene to the Hydaspes? He said, the territory above t hese parts, part of India from Patalene to
where it both rains and snows, supports farming just like any other Hydaspes = s. Pakistan
place outside India; it gets water from both rain and snow.
693 C, 6-13 It is reasonable to assume, on the basis of what this fellow this fellow = Aristobulus
says, that the ground, hollowed out and fractured by the great
quantity of water, suffers from seismic activity so that even riv-
ers change their course. He says that once, dispatched on some
mission, he saw a territory containing more than a thousand cities
792
India
(with their villages) that had been abandoned when the Indus left its
customary course and had been diverted into a diff erent channel on the
left that was much deeper and like a cataract; the abandoned territory
on the right no longer benefited from floodwater, being higher not only
than the new river course but also than its flood levels! |
693 C, 14-18 Also consistent with the flooding of rivers and with the 15.1.20
did not fall in both seasons, with the result that growing conditions
are good since the ground is never unproductive; much tree-borne
fruit is produced, as also roots (especially the roots of the g reat reed)
that are sweet by nature and by “hepsesis” (being boiled), since the
water is warm, whether it is sent from Zeus or whether it is river
water. He sort of means to say that what other p eople refer He = ?Eratosthenes,
?Megasthenes
to as pepsis (ripening) of fruit and its juice, they call hepsesis (being
boiled)—since it contributes as much to the flavor as does
cooking over the fire. It is the same thing, he says, that enables he = ?Eratosthenes,
?Megasthenes
the branches of trees from which wheels are made to be bent into a
curve; and for the same reason, some trees are able to sprout wool.
Nearchus (late 4th c. BCE) Nearchus says, fine cottons are woven from this wool; the Mace- wool = cotton wool
donians use it instead of stuffing and for pack saddles. Such, too,
Serian material = Chinese silk is “Serian material,” fine material carded from some type of
reeds = bamboo fiber. He also says, in connection with reeds, that they produce He = ?Nearchus ?Eratosthenes,
?Megasthenes
honey even though there are no bees: for there is a tree that produces
fruit, and honey is concocted from the fruit; people who eat the raw
fruit become intoxicated. |
694 C, 5-14 Many amazing trees grow in India, including one tree 15.1.21
ing downward until, bent over, they touch the ground; then, spreading
underground, they form roots like sunken piles; then, heading upward
[ 1 ] From 694 C, 7–696 C, 13, Strabo uses Onesicritus as his main source.
[ 2 ] I.e., the most southerly part of India reached by Alexander the Great: see 690 C,
31-34n.
793
4.2. Southern Asia
again, they form a trunk, from which again the branches, similarly
bending over as they grow, form another sunken pile, and another,
and so on; thus, from one tree, a long shaded canopy is produced, like
a tent with many supports.
694 C, 14-26 He also talks of giant trees so large that the trunks can scarcely He = Onesicritus
Aristobulus (late 4th c. BCE) be encircled by five men. Aristobulus, too, describes trees on the
Acesines, and where it joins the Hyarotis, with branches that bend Acesines, Chenab r.
over and are of such size that fifty cavalrymen can spend the noon hour Hyarotis, Ravi r.
in the shade of one tree (whereas this fellow says four hundred!). this fellow = Onesicritus
Aristobulus says, there is another tree, not big, but with large pods
(like the bean), ten fingers long and full of honey; those who ingest
the honey rarely survive. With regard to trees of giant size, no-
body beats those who claim to have seen, on the far side of the
Hyarotis, a tree that casts at noon a shadow five stades long!
This fellow says, too, concerning the wool-bearing trees, that This fellow = Onesicritus
the flower contains a seed and, once this is removed, the rest can be
combed in the same way as fleece. |
694 C, 27-35 He says that, in Musicanus’s territory, there is also a wild grain He = Onesicritus 15.1.22
(similar to wheat) and vines, so that wine is produced. Other au- Musicanus’s territory = s.
Pakistan
thorities say India produces no wine, with the consequence,
as described by Anacharsis, that there are no flutes nor any
other type of musical instrument except cymbals, drums, and clap-
pers, which are the perquisites of showmen. This fellow says, as do This fellow = Onesicritus
others, that India is rich in medicinal herbs and roots, curative and
otherwise, and likewise in dyes. This fellow adds that it is the law
for anyone who discovers a fatal poison to be put to death, unless they
additionally discover the cure; if they do discover the cure, they receive
high honor from the kings!
695 C, 1-9 Cinnamon, nard, and other aromatic spices are found in southern
India, as similarly in Arabia and Ethiopia, which India somewhat
resembles in respect of the sun’s rays. India, however, is exceptionally
well supplied with w ater, with the result that the atmosphere is humid
and consequently more nourishing and fecund, and so too are the soil
and water, with the result that animals in India, both those that
live on land and those that live in the sea, are larger than those in
other places. The Nile, too, is more fecund than other rivers, produc-
ing various mega-creatures, including amphibians; and Egyptian
women sometimes give birth to quadruplets.
695 C, 9-21 Aristotle records that one woman gave birth to septuplets;
Aristotle (4th c. BCE) and he even calls the Nile multi-generative and nourishing, as a
794
India
result of the sun’s rays having quite a “hepsesis” (boiling) effect, burning
off what is superfluous and leaving behind the essential nutrients. | It 15.1.23
only half as much flame as water from other rivers. He says that to
the extent that the w ater of the Nile flows in a straight line over an
extensive and narrow territory and passes through many different
climata and climatic conditions, whereas Indian rivers spread over climata, bands of latitude
plains that are wider and flatter, and they spend a long time pass-
ing through the same climata—to this extent, those rivers are more those rivers = Indian rivers
nourishing than this river; therefore, the creatures in them are larger this river = Nile
and more plentiful; also, the rain that falls from the clouds is already
Aristobulus (late 4th c. BCE) heated. | Those associated with Aristobulus1—who say that the 15.1.24
ans do not have woolly hair and do not have such extremely
sunburnt skin, b ecause they enjoy a humid climate). Babies
in the womb are already like their progenitors, because of the
transfer of sperm; these characteristics, and other similarities,
are thus said to be hereditary.
696 C, 8-13 The statement that the sun is an equal distance away from Strabo argues that the sun
feels stronger in Ethiopia than
all people is made not by deduction but by perception. This in places farther north, even
“perception” is not of things as they are, but it is in accor- though it is not technically closer
795
4.2. Southern Asia
to Egypt and Ethiopia, namely that where the plains are not
Nearchus (late 4th c. BCE) flooded they are barren through lack of water. Nearchus says,
rivers in India provide the answer to the question asked e arlier, in
connection with the Nile, as to the cause of its flooding—namely, the
flooding is caused by summer rains; Alexander, seeing crocodiles in the
Hydaspes and Egyptian beans in the Acesines, believed he had discov- Hydaspes, Jhelum r.
ered the sources of the Nile and prepared for an expedition to Egypt, Acesines, Chenab r.
on the assumption that he could sail all the way t here by means of this
river; shortly thereafter he learned that his hopes were not justified.
Citation of Homer (8th c. BCE) “For t here are huge rivers in between, and mighty streams, /
and first there’s Ocean,” into which flow the rivers of India,
then there’s Ariana, and the Persian gulf, the Arabian gulf, Arabian gulf, Red Sea
India via the Arianans, he then (with India to his right) crossed
796
India
the Paropamisus into the north and into Bactriana. Destroy- Paropamisus, Hindu Kush (n.
Afg.)
ing everything there that was subject to the Persians and more
besides, he now set his sights on India—the subject of much
discussion but l ittle certainty. He turned around and recrossed
the same mountains (with India on his left), using diff erent and
shorter passages; then turned directly t oward India and her
western borders, toward the Cophes river and the Choaspes, Cophes, Kunar-Kabul r. system
which joins the Cophes at the city of Plemyrium, flowing past Choaspes, ?Swat r.
habitable and fertile; part of the south was waterless, and part
was watered by rivers but was searing hot, better suited to
wild beasts than men. He set out to take possession first of
the region that was desirable, at the same time taking into ac-
count that rivers had to be forded (since, lying at right a ngles,
they cut off the country to which he was headed) and could
be crossed more easily near their sources. At the same time,
he heard that many rivers merged into one, and that this hap-
pened again and again, with the consequence that the farther
one went, the more difficult the crossing, especially without
ships. Fearing this, he crossed the Cophes and proceeded to Cophes, Kunar-Kabul r. system
698 C, 3-7 After the Cophes comes the stream of the Indus. Between
Between Cophes (Kunar-Kabul r.) these two rivers, the area is occupied by Astacenians, Masian-
and upper Indus
e. Afghanistan, n. Pakistan
ians, Nysaeans, and Hypasians. Then there’s the territory be-
longing to Assacanus, the location of the city of Masoga (the
territorial capital), and, right next to the Indus, yet another
city, Peucolaïtis, where he took his army across at a preexist-
ing crossing point. |
797
4.2. Southern Asia
698 C, 8-14 Between the Indus and the Hydaspes is the city of Taxila, Taxila, Taxila (Pak.) 15.1.28
Between Indus and Hydaspes which is large and well governed; the surrounding territory is
(Jhelum r.)
n. India, e. Pakistan
extensive and extremely productive, reaching right down to
the plains. The populace and their king, Taxiles, gave Alexan-
der a warm welcome. The gifts these people received exceeded
those they gave; consequently, the Macedonians w ere jealous,
saying that Alexander apparently had no one on whom to be-
stow his favors—until he crossed the Indus! It is said by some
that this territory is larger than Egypt.
698 C, 14-23 In the mountains above Taxila is the territory belonging to Taxila, Taxila (Pak.)
Onesicritus (late 4th c. BCE) and forty cubits long! This is according to Onesicritus, whom
one might call the chief p ilot of natural wonders rather than
of Alexander! All of Alexander’s associates preferred what
was amazing to what was true, but Onesicritus seems to stand
out from the rest in his tales of marvelous things. Neverthe-
less, some of what he says has sufficient credibility and merit
that one should not omit it, even if one is skeptical. As for
serpents, others, too, say that p eople hunt them in the Emoda Emoda mountains, w. Himalyas
699 C, 3-17 Reference is made to the excessive number and size of cer-
copitheci (apes-with-tails) in the abovementioned forest, such that
on one occasion the Macedonians, seeing a host of them on
some bare hilltops in a line facing them (this creature is no less
human in its thought process than the elephant) and mistak-
798
India
ing them for an army, were all set to go into battle against
them as if against e nemy troops, and s topped only when Tax-
iles (at that time in the king’s retinue) informed them of the
true state of affairs. The hunting of this creature takes place in
two ways (given that the creature is a mimic and takes refuge
in trees). The huntsmen, if they see one sitting up in the trees,
put down within the creature’s sight a bowl containing water,
with which they anoint their own eyes; then, putting down a
bowl of birdlime instead of water, they retreat quite a distance
and lie in wait; the creature, jumping down and anointing its
eyes with birdlime, closes its eyes, and its eyelids stay shut;
then the huntsmen come and take it alive. That’s one way of
hunting it. The other way is this: wearing sacks as trousers,
they go away, leaving behind other sacks that are rough and
smeared inside with birdlime; the creatures put them on and
are easily captured. |
699 C, 18-21 Some put Cathaea,1 and the territory of Sopithes (a state 15.1.30
Beyond Acesines (Chenab r.) official),2 in this interfluvial area. Others put it beyond the
and Hyarotis (Ravi r.)
n. India, e. Pakistan Acesines and the Hyarotis, next to the territory belong-
ing to the other Porus (the cousin of the Porus captured by “Other” Porus, defeated by
Alexander the G reat, fled in
Alexander)—they give the name “Gandaris” to the territory 326 BCE
subject to this man. Gandaris, Afghanistan, Pakistan
699 C, 21-30 In Cathaea, the strangest report is that beauty is held in
Onesicritus (late 4th c. BCE) exceptionally high esteem, as with horses and dogs. Onesicri-
tus says, the most handsome man is chosen to be king; two months
after birth, a baby is subjected to public judgment as to w hether or
not he has the beauty legally required for his continued existence;
after judgment by the appointed magistrate, the baby is allowed to
live or is killed; men dye their beards with the brightest colors with the
same aim of beautification; many other Indians—the territory yields
amazing dyes—assiduously do the same thing with their hair and
clothes; the p eople are thrifty in other ways but are adornment-loving.
699 C, 31–700 C, 2 The following Cathaean peculiarities are also reported: a
bride and groom choose each other; the reason women are
burned along with their husbands when their husbands die, is
that w omen, taking young lovers, might leave or poison their
husbands; this law is in place to prevent poisoning. (Neither
the law nor its justification is credibly described.)
700 C, 2-16 They say that in Sopithes’s territory, there is a moun-
tain containing rock salt capable of supplying all India. It is
799
4.2. Southern Asia
from there to the Hypanis, it was rather more to the east. The Hypanis, Beas, Sutlej r.
700 C, 28–701 C, 2 Alexander got this idea after abandoning the east, in the
first place because he was prevented from crossing the Hypa- Hypanis, Beas, Sutlej r.
[ 1 ] 697 C, 17-26.
800
India
Meropian Cos, city on Kos no smaller in size than Meropian Cos (although their number
(Gk. island)
seems to be exaggerated).
701 C, 2-9 An approximate description has been given of the sig-
nificant nations inhabiting the area between the Indus and
the Hydaspes.1 Next in order below them are p eoples known
as the “Sibans” (whom I previously mentioned),2 the “Mal-
lians” and the “Sydracians”—all great nations. It was among
the Mallians that Alexander nearly died a fter being wounded
during the capture of a small town. I mentioned the Sydra-
cians as being related in myth to Dionysus.3 It is said that,
right next to Patalene, there’s the territory of Musicanus and territory of Musicanus =
s. Pakistan
of Sabus . . . * Sindomana, and the territory of Porticanus and
others.
701 C, 9-20 Alexander conquered all the nations in the Indus river-
lands and last of all Patalene, formed by the Indus as it splits Patalene, in s. Pakistan
Aristobulus, Nearchus, into two mouths. Aristobulus says that the mouths are one thou-
Onesicritus (late 4th c. BCE)
sand stades apart from each other; Nearchus adds another eight
hundred [stades]. Onesicritus says that each side of the enclosed,
triangle-shaped island, formed in this way, measures two thousand
[stades], and the width of the river where it splits into the two mouths
is some two hundred [stades]. He calls the island Delta and says
that it is equal in size to the Egyptian Delta (incorrectly, since the
Egyptian Delta is said to have a base of one thousand three
hundred stades, and each of the other sides is shorter than
the base). In Patalene t here is a significant city, Patala, after Patala, ?Bahmanabad (Pak.)
[ 1 ] 698 C, 8-23.
[ 2 ] 687 C, 31–688 C, 14.
[ 3 ] 687 C, 31–688 C, 14. Cf. 686 C, 25–687 C, 8n.
801
4.2. Southern Asia
on Alexander’s campaign.1
702 C, 5-10 There has also been published a certain letter by Craterus
Craterus (late 4th c. BCE) to his mother, Aristopatra, describing many strange phe-
nomena uncorroborated by anyone e lse and also stating that
Alexander advanced as far as the Ganges. He says that he himself
saw the river and the creatures in it . . . * in length, width, and
depth a long way away from being credible, not approaching
credibility at all!
702 C, 10-26 There is general agreement that the Ganges is the larg-
est of the known rivers on the three continents; that it is fol-
lowed by the Indus, with the Ister and Nile in third and fourth Ister, Danube r.
river lies Palibothra, a city eighty stades long and fifteen stades wide, Palibothra, Patna (Ind.)
parallelogram-shaped, surrounded by a wooden palisade that is per-
forated so that arrows can be discharged through the apertures; in
front of the palisade is a ditch used both for defense and as a receptacle
for the city’s waste; the nation in which this city is situated is by far
most highly developed of them all—they are called “Prasians”; the Prasians = inhabitants of ne.
India
reigning king is required to take the name of the city, being called
“Palibothrus” in addition to his individual f amily name, as was the
case with Sandracottus, to whom Megasthenes was sent on
an ambassadorial visit. The same thing happens among the
Parthians, who are all called “Arsaces,” but individually called
“Orodes,” “Phraates,” and so on. |
702 C, 27-33 There is a consensus view that all the territory beyond the 15.1.37
BEYOND THE HYPANIS Hypanis is excellent. It is not, however, described accurately. Hypanis, Beas, Sutlej r.
present-day India, Nepal,
?Bhutan, ?s. China, Bangladesh
Incomplete knowledge and extreme remoteness mean that
stories get exaggerated or are fictional—for example, stories
[ 1 ] 690 C, 35–702 C, 4.
802
India
the face (which is black, while the reverse is the case elsewhere), have
tails measuring more than two cubits, and are very tame, with no 1 cubit = 1.5 ft.
[ 1 ] The word myrmeces means “ants” but is applied by Strabo to a variety of fan-
tastical beings: 705 C, 33–706 C, 11n.
[ 2 ] From 703 C, 1 to 714 C, 4, Strabo uses Megasthenes as his main source, with
selections from other writers at 704 C, 15–707 C, 9.
[ 3 ] 1st group: 703 C, 28–704 C, 1. 2nd group: 704 C, 2-8. 3rd group: 704 C, 9-14.
4th group: 707 C, 10-17. 5th–7th groups: 707 C, 18-27.
803
4.2. Southern Asia
804
India
and darts under one of the wild beasts and hobbles it. When
this has been done, the hunters command the tame beasts to
beat the hobbled ones u ntil they fall to the ground.
704 C, 26–705 C, 1 Then the hunters yoke the necks of the fallen beasts to the fallen beasts = captured wild
elephants
necks of the tame ones with leashes of raw oxhide. To pre-
vent the beasts from shaking off anyone attempting to get
up onto them, the hunters make incisions around the beasts’ beasts’ necks = necks of
captured wild elephants
necks just where the leash rests, so that the beasts tolerate
their bonds out of pain and are submissive. The hunters reject
beasts that are too old or too young to be useful. They take
the remaining ones away into stalls, where they tie the beasts’
feet together and their necks to a well-secured column, and
subdue them by hunger; then they revive them with the fresh
shoots of reeds and with grass.
705 C, 2-9 Then the beasts are taught to obey commands, some of beasts = captured wild
elephants
which are word commands, others commands in the form
of chanting and drumming. T hose that c an’t be tamed are
few indeed. They are by nature so gentle and mild that they
are almost a rational animal. If their riders are wounded
while fighting and fall to the ground, the beasts pick them
up and carry them away from the b attle to safety; and when
their riders sought cover between the beasts’ front feet, the
beasts continued to fight on their behalf and saved them. If
the beasts ever kill one of their feeders or trainers in anger,
they feel the loss so keenly that their grief keeps them from
eating—sometimes they even starve themselves to death. |
705 C, 10-20 The beasts mount and copulate like h orses do, mostly dur- 15.1.43
ing the spring season. The time is ripe (for the male) when
he is seized by a wild frenzy, at which time he also secretes an
oily substance through an opening on his forehead. The time
is ripe (for females) when their corresponding orifice opens
up; they are pregnant for a maximum of eighteen months, a
minimum of sixteen months; a mother nurses for six years.
Many of them live as long as the most long-lived of men, some
for as long as two hundred years! They are prone to many
diseases that resist treatment. The remedy for eye disease is
for cow’s milk, to be used as a wash. The remedy for most af-
flictions is a drink consisting of black wine. For battle wounds,
a drink . . . * butter (it draws out the pieces of iron); festering
wounds are treated with a poultice of pig meat.
805
4.2. Southern Asia
705 C, 20-32 Onesicritus says that they live u ntil they are three hundred
Onesicritus (late 4th c. BCE) years old (a few, until five hundred years old); they are in top condi-
tion at two hundred years old; gestation lasts for ten years. He says
(as do o thers) that they are bigger and stronger than Libyan ones;
standing on their back legs and using their trunks, they tear down
Nearchus (late 4th c. BCE) defenses and uproot trees. Nearchus says that, in the hunt, traps are
put in places where the beasts congregate; the wild beasts are corralled
into them by the tame ones, who are stronger and driven by riders;
they are so readily trained that they learn to throw stones at a target
and use weapons; they are very fine swimmers; a team of elephants is
considered a very great possession, and they are yoked together . . . *
camels; a woman is held in high honor if she receives from her lover the
gift of an elephant. The latter statement is inconsistent with the
claim that h orses and elephants are owned only by kings.1 |
705 C, 33–706 C, 11 This fellow says that he saw the hides of gold-mining “myr- This fellow, ?Onesicritus, 15.1.44
?Nearchus
Megasthenes (late 4th–early meces,” 2 which are similar to t hose of leopards. Megasthenes says the
3rd c. BCE)
following about the myrmeces: that, among the Derdians, who are
a great nation of Indians dwelling in the eastern mountains, t here is a
plateau approximately three thousand stades in circumference; beneath
the plateau there are gold mines, and the “myrmeces” are the workers in
them; they are animals no smaller than foxes and possessed of extraordi-
nary speed, and they live by hunting. Like moles, they dig into the
ground in the winter and leave mounds at the entrances. This is
gold dust, requiring little in the way of smelting. Neighboring
people come searching for the gold dust with their beasts of
burden, but they do so clandestinely. If they do it openly, the
myrmeces fight the p eople vigorously and pursue them if they
flee; when the myrmeces catch them, they kill the people along
with their animals. In order not to be seen, people scatter pieces
of wild-animal meat about; the myrmeces are enticed away by
the meat, and the people snatch the gold dust and dispose of it
unwrought (since they do not know how to smelt it) to mer-
chants for a pittance. |
706 C, 12-24 Since I have mentioned in this account of hunters and 15.1.45
806
India
around the size of the snake brought from there that I saw in from there = from India
Egypt),1 but he says that he saw many much smaller vipers and
asps, and also large scorpions; none of these is as troublesome as the
slender l ittle snakes, m
easuring no more than one span in length, since
they are found in tents, among equipment, and in reeds, and since
victims of their bite bleed painfully from every orifice then die, unless
someone comes to their aid forthwith; helping them is, however, easy
because of the excellent qualities of Indian roots and cures. He says
that crocodiles (neither numerous nor harmful to man) are found in
the Indus; the other animals that breed t here are also mostly the same
as those that live in the Nile, except the hippopotamus (although
Onesicritus (late 4th c. BCE) Onesicritus says that it breeds t here, too). Aristobulus says
that, because of the crocodiles, no creatures from the sea (except the
“thrissa,” “cestreus,” and dolphin) swim up the Nile, but many do in
the Indus; small crustaceans get up as far as . . . * while large ones go
as far up as the confluence of the Indus and the Acesines. Acesines, Chenab r.
707 C, 9-10 That was my account of the wild animals.2
707 C, 10-17 Returning to Megasthenes, let me pick up where I left
Megasthenes (late 4th–early off.3 | Megasthenes says that, after the hunters and herdsmen, 15.1.46
3rd c. BCE)
there’s a fourth group comprising skilled artisans, s hopkeepers, and
4th group
manual laborers, some of whom pay tax and perform designated
public services, while weapons makers and shipbuilders receive wages
and upkeep at a set rate from the king, since they work for him alone.
The army chief supplies the soldiers with weapons; the com-
mander of the fleet rents and supplies ships to sailors and
merchants. |
707 C, 18-27 The fifth group is that of the warriors, who spend the 15.1.47
5th, 6th, and 7th groups rest of their time in leisure and drinking, living . . .* at the
treasury’s expense so that when the need arises they can
[ 1 ] The snake seen by Strabo “in Egypt” and brought “from [India]” is probably the
“ten-cubit-long serpent” sent from India (via Egypt) as a gift to Augustus (20
BCE): 719 C, 29-34nn; 775C, 16-25.
[ 2 ] 704 C, 15–707 C, 9.
[ 3 ] 704 C, 9-14.
807
4.2. Southern Asia
Indian state magistrates: nomi 1 and military officials. Of these, the first take care of the
“agronomi” (country
magistrates)
rivers; make new measurements (as in Egypt) of the land; and
inspect the gated canals through which the w ater is meted
out into conduits in order that everyone has an equal share
of it. T hese same officials look a fter the hunters, and have
the authority to decide who deserves to be rewarded and
who punished; they collect tax and oversee the skilled, land-
based work done by tree cutters, carpenters, metalworkers,
and miners; they construct roads, erecting stone pillars every
ten stades showing turnoffs and distances. |
708 C, 6-20 The astynomi have been divided into six pentads. One pentad, group of five people 15.1.51
[ 1 ] Strabo uses familiar Greek terms (agronomi, astynomi, etc.), and applies them
to India.
808
India
the king, as does the armory: the soldier hands in his equip-
ment to the armory, his horse (and likewise his beast) to the
stable. They ride without reins. During marches, the chariots
are drawn by oxen while the horses are led by their halters, so
that their legs are not chafed nor their enthusiasm for chariots
dulled. In each chariot, t here are two combatants in addition
to the driver. The elephant driver is the fourth person, with
three archers shooting from the elephant. |
709 C, 8-20 All the Indians—particularly when on campaign—lead 15.1.53
INDIAN CUSTOMS frugal lives and have no interest in too big a retinue, with the
result that their conduct is orderly. They show most restraint
Megasthenes (late 4th–early in regard to theft. Megasthenes says that, when he was in San-
3rd c. BCE)
dracottus’s camp, with its mass of forty thousand men, on no day did
he see the value of reported thefts exceed two hundred drachmas—
and this among p eople using only unwritten laws—for they have no
knowledge of letters and memorize each regulation; they nevertheless
do well as a result of their simplicity and frugality, drinking no wine
unless at sacrifices (their drink is made from rice instead of barley,
and their food consists largely of rice gruel); their simplicity in laws
and contractual obligations is evident from the small number of
lawsuits—there are no court cases concerning mortgages or deposits;
809
4.2. Southern Asia
they put no faith in witnesses or seals but assume risk based on trust;
they leave their household possessions unguarded.
709 C, 20-24 These habits are sensible, but others of their customs
could not be called acceptable: their custom of always liv-
ing solitary lives, with breakfast and dinner not eaten at one
communal hour but according to individual preference. The
former is better for social and political life. |
709 C, 25–710 C, 5 Their favorite form of bodily care is massage; they rub 15.1.54
are purchased from their fathers; outside the court are the
bodyguards and the rest of the army. If one of his wives kills
the king while he is drunk, she has the right to marry his suc-
cessor, and their children become the heirs. The king does not
sleep a fter daybreak; even during the night, he is compelled to
810
India
change the place where he sleeps from time to time, for fear of
conspiracies. One of the (nonmilitary) reasons for the king to
venture out is to attend the law courts, where he spends long
days in hearings, even if the time comes for his bodily therapy,
consisting of massage by means of rollers; during the hearing,
he is massaged by four therapists standing around him! The
second reason for venturing out is to make sacrifices. The third
is somewhat bacchic, namely hunting, surrounded by a throng
of women and, outside them, spear bearers; the route is roped
off, death the penalty for anyone passing within the ropes as far
as the women. The procession is headed by drum players and
bell ringers. The king hunts in enclosed areas by standing on a
platform to shoot his arrows, with two or three armed women
in attendance; in unenclosed hunting grounds, he hunts from
the back of an elephant, with some of the women riding in
chariots, and some on horses or elephants, as when they join
him on campaign, decked out with all sorts of weapons. |
710 C, 26–711 C, 2 The foregoing are very different from our customs, the 15.1.56
following even more so. He says that the occupants of the Cau- He = Megasthenes
casus1 have sex with their w omen in the open, and eat the flesh of their
relatives; there are rock-rolling “cercopitheci” (apes-with-tails) who,
from their haunts on high, send stones rolling down on their pursu-
ers; most of the creatures that we have domesticated are still wild in
their country. He talks of deer-headed and one-horned horses; reeds,
some reaching straight up for thirty orguiae, others creeping along the 1 orguia = 6 ft.
ground for fifty, and with so g reat a width that some have a three- 1 cubit = 1.5 ft.
cubit diameter, o thers a diameter of double that amount. |
711 C, 3-10 Entering the realm of myth, he talks of five-span men and he = Megasthenes 15.1.57
even three-span, some of whom lack noses, having only two breathing 1 span = 0.75 ft.
holes above the mouth; against t hese three-span men, a war is con-
Homer (8th c. BCE) ducted by cranes (a war that features even in Homer) and by par-
tridges the size of geese; these men steal and destroy their eggs, for this
is where cranes lay their eggs, which explains why neither crane eggs
nor fledglings are found anywhere else; very often a crane escapes with
a bronze spear tip from the shooting there.
711 C, 10-17 Similar is what he says of enotocoetae (those-who-sleep-in-their-
ears) and of wild men and other wonders: the wild men could not
811
4.2. Southern Asia
being tame men; they lived at the sources of the Ganges and drew
nourishment from the odor of roasting meat and the aromas of fruits
and flowers, having breathing holes in the place of mouths; bad odors
caused them pain, and for that reason they survived with difficulty,
especially in the army camp.
711 C, 17-24 The philosophers describe various others, mentioning ocy-
podes (those-who-are-swift-footed) . . . * more than h orses; enotocoetae
(those-who-sleep-in-their-ears), who, because their ears reach down
to their feet, can sleep in them and are so strong they can up-
root trees and tear apart bowstrings; o thers are monommati
(one-eyed), who have the ears of a dog, one eye in the m iddle of
the forehead, bristles, and shaggy breasts; the amycteres (those-
who-are-noseless) are pamphagi (omnivorous), omophagi (eaters-of-raw-
[ 1 ] Strabo uses the name “Iberia” both for territory in the west (Spain, Portugal)
and in the Caucasus (e. Georgia, w. Azerbaijan). Gold is panned in both places:
146 C, 10-17; 499 C, 12-27.
[ 2 ] Brachmanes: 712 C, 9–713 C, 18. Sarmanes: 713 C, 19-30.
812
India
in some respects they show their gullibility (they are better with regard they = Brachmanes
to action than logical arguments) and put a lot of trust in myths, but
813
4.2. Southern Asia
on many topics they agree with the Greeks, in that they too claim that
“the universe is subjected to creation and destruction, is spheroid, and spheroid, ball-shaped
is wholly permeated by the god who controls and creates it,” that “the
basic matter constituting the whole is varied but that water is the basic
matter underlying the creation of the universe,” that “in addition to
the four elements there is a fifth substance, the material from which the
heavens and the stars are made,” and that “the earth is at the center of
everything.” Similar statements, and o thers besides, are made
about the seed and the soul. They use myth in the same way as
Plato (late 5th–4th c. BCE) Plato does for the eternal soul, the judgments of Hades, and
so on. That is what he says about the Brachmanes. |
713 C, 19-30 As for the Sarmanes, he says that the most revered of them are he = Megasthenes 15.1.60
814
India
whomsoever they approached, that person poured sesame oil over them so
that it ran down into their eyes; with an abundance of honey and sesame
available to them, they made cakes and lived without expense; even when
they came to Alexander’s table, they dined standing up!
714 C, 13-24 They practiced endurance by retreating to a nearby place, where
the older one lay flat on his back and put up with the sun and the rain
(it was already raining, spring having arrived), while the younger
one stood on one leg, holding aloft with both hands a log some three 1 cubit = 1.5 ft.
cubits in length, and when one leg got tired, transferring his weight
to the other leg, continuing in this way for the w hole day; the younger
one showed far greater self-discipline in that he accompanied the king king = Alexander
for a little while but soon went back home and, when the king sent for
him, bade him, “come himself if there was anything he wanted”!; the
other stayed on for life and, being in the king’s company, changed his
manner of dress and way of life; when he was reproached by certain
people, he replied that “he had fulfilled his forty years of asceticism as
promised”; Alexander gave presents to his c hildren. |
714 C, 25-33 With regard to customs in Taxila, he says, they are strange Taxila, Taxila (Pak.) 15.1.62
and unusual: men who are unable through poverty to marry off their he = Aristobulus
daughters bring them in the full flower of their youth to the market-
place, where a crowd is summoned by means of trumpet and drums
(which they also use to signal b attle); if a man approaches, the girl pulls
up her clothes to expose first her hind parts up to the shoulders, then her
front parts; if she is found pleasing and is amenable to the conditions he
sets, she is married to him; the dead are thrown to vultures; the taking
of more than one wife is a custom shared by others. He says that he
learned from some sources that women are willingly burned on
their husbands’ funeral pyres; women who do not acquiesce are held in
contempt. These customs are described by o thers, too. |
714 C, 34–715 C, 15 Onesicritus says that he himself was dispatched to engage in 15.1.63
Onesicritus (late 4th c. BCE) dialogue with these sophists, as Alexander had learned that these
fellows—who always went about lightly clad, who practiced endur-
ance, and who w ere held in the greatest honor—would not visit o thers
when summoned but rather would bid those who sent the summons,
if they wished to take part in what the sophists did and said, to visit
them! He said that, since t hese t hings w ere so, and since it did not
seem fitting for him to visit them nor for them to be forced to do any- him = Alexander
thing against their w ill, in contravention of their traditions, he was he = Onesicritus
himself dispatched; he came upon fifteen of these men, at a distance of
twenty stades from the city, all standing or sitting or lying in diff erent
815
4.2. Southern Asia
positions, lightly clad and unmoving u ntil dusk, at which time they
returned to the city; it was extremely difficult to stay out in the sun, city = Taxila, Taxila (Pak.)
which was so hot that no one else could easily manage to walk barefoot
on the ground at midday; | he engaged in dialogue with one of them, 15.1.64
Calanus, who followed the king as far as Persia and ended his life by
being put on a funeral pyre in the traditional manner, but who hap-
pened at that moment to be lying on some stones.
715 C, 15-28 He said that, approaching them and giving them greetings, he He = Onesicritus
announced that he had been dispatched by the king “to learn their
wisdom and report back to him,” and if no one minded, he was ready
for his lesson; this fellow, on seeing him clad in cloak, hat, and boots, this fellow = Calanus
laughed out loud and said, “long ago, there w ere barley groats and
wheat meal everywhere, as now t here is dust; some springs ran with
water, o thers with milk and honey, or wine, or olive oil; b ecause of
this satiety and indolence, men fell into prideful ways; Zeus, hating
this state of affairs, destroyed the lot and decreed a life of toil; now
that virtue, including self-control, has made its reappearance, there
is again an abundance of good things, but we are approaching satiety
and pride, and t here is a danger that everything w ill be destroyed,”
and after speaking thus, bade him—if he wanted to learn—to take off him = Onesicritus
his garb, lie down lightly clad on the same stones, and start his lesson!
715 C, 28–716 C, 4 While he was wondering what to do, Mandanis, the oldest and he = Onesicritus
an extensive kingdom to govern (for he saw that the king was singu- he = Mandanis
lar in pursuing wisdom while at arms); the best situation of all was
when t hose men were wise who had the power to persuade the willing
to be moderate, and to compel the unwilling; he begged forgiveness he = Mandanis
if, speaking through three interpreters who, except for their linguistic
ability, knew no more than the general public, he lacked the facility to
set out the benefits; it was as if someone expected that w ater running
through mud would be clear!” |
716 C, 5-11 He said that what was stated was, in essence, this: “The high- He = Onesicritus 15.1.65
est doctrine is that which aims at removing p leasure and pain from what was stated = by Mandanis
the soul; pain and toil are different, the former destructive, the latter
desirable, at least for t hose training their bodies through toil in order
to strengthen their minds, with the result that they might cease from
strife and give good counsel to everyone in public and private, and that
they would counsel Taxiles to receive Alexander, on the grounds that,
816
India
if the man received was his superior, then it would be well to comply,
while if the man received was his inferior, then he could treat him well.”
716 C, 11-18 After speaking thus, he inquired w hether such doctrines w
ere held he = Mandanis
by the Greeks. In response to his statement that “Pythagoras taught his = Onesicritus’s
broad sword. Instead of bits, they use nose bands, which are only a little
different from muzzles; and the lips are pierced with studs. |
717 C, 9-16 He says, in illustration of their craftsmanship, that the In- He = Nearchus 15.1.67
dians copied the sponges that they saw in use among the Macedonians,
by piercing bits of wool with hairs and fine cords and threads, and
817
4.2. Southern Asia
a fter compressing it, by drawing some of these out and d yeing some
of them with many colors; there were soon “stlengis makers” and stlengis, skin scraper used by
Greeks after bathing or exercise
“lecythus makers” in large numbers; they write their missives on fine,
lecythus, oil flask used by
closely woven cloth (although other writers claim that they d on’t Greeks
use writing); they use bronze that has been cast rather than ham-
mered out. He gave no reason but noted the strange corollary
that, if the vessels fell, they shattered like earthenware.
717 C, 17-20 The following statement is also made about India, that it
is the custom to adopt an attitude of prayer, rather than pros-
tration, before kings and all who hold rank and power. The
territory also yields up precious stones, consisting of crystals anthraces = carbuncles, rubies,
and all kinds of anthraces . . . * as also pearls. | garnets
717 C, 21-34 Let the story of Calanus be an example of the lack of agree- 15.1.68
818
India
he did not have the least need of Alexander’s “gifts” (of which there
were never enough), nor did threats scare him—India would suffice
as his nurse while he lived, and when he died, he “would be f ree of flesh
that was wasted by old age and would pass on to a better, purer life.”
Alexander thought him praiseworthy, and acquiesced. |
718 C, 15-28 It is also said by writers that the Indians worship “Om- 15.1.69
819
4.2. Southern Asia
the “urban” wear muslin clothes and live in the city, or even in 15.1.71
had been brought were displayed by eight servants, lightly clad in loin-
cloths and bedewed with aromatic oils; the gifts included a “Hermes”
(a man whose arms had been cut off at the shoulder in infancy,
and whom I too saw),3 large vipers, a ten-cubit-long serpent,4 a 1 cubit = 1.5 ft.
[ 1 ] In a typically Strabonian moment, the embassy is described through the eyes earlier, was still resident: 101 C, 14-24n; 117 C, 35–118 C, 14n. The embassy’s pas-
and words of Strabo’s contemporary Nicolaus, even though Strabo himself saw sage through Alexandria may also have provided the occasion for Strabo to
at least some of the embassy’s gifts and perhaps the embassy itself: 719 C, 29- see an Indian rhino: 774 C, 23–775 C, 2n.
34nn, Cf. 686 C, 10-16nn; 706 C, 24–707 C, 9. [ 4 ] This is probably the snake “from [India]” that Strabo says he “saw in Egypt” and
[ 2 ] “Porus” is the name attributed by Nicolaus to the Indian king Pandion, perhaps that was “around the size” of the snake “nine cubits and one span long” seen by
in order to flatter Augustus: 686 C, 10-16nn. Aristobulus in India: 706 C, 24–707 C, 9n. “Egypt” is often used by Strabo as a
[ 3 ] Where did Strabo see this odd gift? It is likely that the embassy passed through synonym for Alexandria; if that is the case h ere, Alexandria is likely to be where
Alexandria (20 BCE), where Strabo, who had arrived in Alexandria some years Strabo also saw the armless man (previous note).
820
India
[ 1 ] 689 C, 3-31; cf. 78 C, 15-18. [4] 67 C, 7-14 (following Eratosthenes); 116 C, 12-19.
[ 2 ] 689 C, 26-31 (specifically, line 27). [5] 116 C, 29–117 C, 11.
[ 3 ] E.g., frontispiece of H. L. Jones, The Geography of Strabo, vol. 1 (Harvard Uni- [6] 689 C, 7-12.
versity Press, 1917); map at end of G. Aujac, Strabon: Géographie, vol. 2, Budé [7] 113 C, 25–114 C, 1.
ed. (Les Belles Lettres, 1969); map on p. xvii of D. Roller, The Geography of
Strabo (Cambridge Univeristy Press, 2014).
821
NORTH POLE
35,200
16,000
16,000
13,000
INDIA
3,000
11,800 EQUATOR
Key
α = 19,906 stades
β = 20,131 stades
Ariana and Carmania
720 C, 8-14 fter India comes Ariana, the initial section of Persian-
A Persian-controlled, ?6th–4th c. 15.2.1
BCE
controlled territory a fter the Indus, and included among the
upper satrapies outside the Taurus. Ariana is delineated by outside Taurus = south of Taurus
mts.
the same sea and the same mountains as India to the south
and the north, and by the same Indus river between it and
India, and stretches from there westward to the line drawn
from the Caspian Gates to Carmania, so as to make a four- Caspian Gates, ?Sar Darreh
pass (Iran)
sided figure.
720 C, 14-24 The southern side begins with the outlets of the Indus
ARIANA and with Patalene, and ends with Carmania and the mouth Patalene, area enclosed by two
w. Pakistan, s. Afghanistan, principal mouths of Indus r.
s. + e. Iran
of the Persian gulf, with a considerable southern projection, (Pak.)
after which it curves around into the gulf toward Persia. The
inhabitants are, first, the Arbians—bearing the same name as
the Arbis river, which is the boundary between them and the Arbis, ?Hab r.
823
4.2. Southern Asia
ICHTHYOPHAGI largely devoid of trees other than the date palm, the thorn
s. Pakistan, s. Iran
tree, and the tamarisk. It has little in the way of water and
cultivated food, but they (and their animals) make use of fish
and also of water from the rain and from wells. The meat of
their animals gives off a fishy odor. They make their dwellings
largely by using whale bones and oyster shells, using ribs for
beams and supports, and jawbones for doorways. Vertebrae
serve them as mortars, on which they pound fish that they
have dried in the sun. Then they make bread by adding to the
mixture a small amount of flour: they have grindstones, even
in the absence of iron. What is surprising is not this (since they
could have imported them from elsewhere) but the means by
which they whet the grindstones when they get worn down
(with stones, they say, by means of which they also sharpen
their arrows and spears a fter hardening them by fire). They
bake some of their fish in earthenware ovens but eat most of
it raw. They catch fish in nets made out of date-palm fiber. |
721 C, 7-17 Gedrosia is situated inland from these people. Gedrosia, 15.2.3
GEDROSIA not as hot as India, is nevertheless hotter than the rest of Asia:
w. Pakistan, e. Iran
it lacks crops and water (except in the summer), being little
better than the territory of the Ichthyophagi. It does produce
spices, particularly nard and myrrh—so much so that Alexan-
der’s army, on its way through, made use of these for shelter
and bedding, thereby enjoying an atmosphere of considerable
fragrance as well as healthiness! It happened that the return
march from India was specifically planned for the summer,
which is when the rains fall in Gedrosia, and the rivers and
cisterns are full (although they run dry in the winter); the
rain falls in the upper (northern) regions, which are near the
mountains; then, as the rivers swell, even the plains near the
coast get irrigated, and there is plenty of water in reserve.
721 C, 17-28 The king sent men into the desert ahead of him to dig cis- king = Alexander the Great
terns and prepare naval stations for him and his fleet. | Divid- 15.2.4
ing his forces into three, he himself set out with one division
[ 1 ] Area next to Indus (by Strabo’s day, part of India): 724 C, 9-16. Ichthyophagi
(s. Pakistan, s. Iran): 720 C, 25–721 C, 6. Gedrosia (w. Pakistan, e. Iran): 721 C,
7–732 C, 14. Carmania (s. Iran): 726 C, 18–727 C, 10.
824
Ariana and Carmania
sented by the heat and the depth of the sand and the high
temperatures. In some places, the sand dunes were so high
that, as well as making it difficult to lift one’s legs (as when
walking through deep w ater), ascents and descents had to be
made. B ecause of the watering places, long marches had to
be made of two hundred or three hundred stades (sometime
even six hundred), generally by night. Camp was struck at a
distance (often thirty stades) from the water, so that the men
might not overdrink in their thirst. Many w ere t hose who,
falling in while fully armored, drank . . . * as underwater; their
825
4.2. Southern Asia
826
Ariana and Carmania
ARIANA the coast combined with the Gedrosian and Oritian country
w. Pakistan, s. Afghanistan,
s. + e. Iran
just inland. However, Gedrosia is large and stretches into the
interior, linking up with the Drangians, Arachotians, and Drangians, Arachotians,
Paropamisadians, w. + n.
Eratosthenes (3rd c. BCE) Paropamisadians. Eratosthenes gives the following account Afghanistan
of these areas (I can say it no better). He says, Ariana is de-
lineated to the east by the Indus; to the south, by the great sea; to the
north, by the Paropamisus and by the mountains that continue as far Paropamisus, Hindu Kush
(n. Afg.)
as the Caspian Gates; to the west by the same boundary as that which
Caspian Gates, ?Sar Darreh
divides Parthyene from Media, and Carmania from Paraetacene pass (Iran)
and Persia.
723 C, 24-26 The width of the territory is equivalent to the length of the width = north–south dimension
roads from Bactra meet (this is among the Paropamisadians). Bactra, Balkh (Afg.)
The other branch turns from Aria a little toward the south,
toward Prophthasia in Drangiana, and then finishes by turning Prophthasia, ?Farah (Afg.)
back toward the Indian boundary and the Indus. This road,
running through the Drangians and the Arachotians, is slightly
the longer one, at fifteen thousand three hundred stades in
total. If you subtract one thousand three hundred [stades], you
could consider the balance—fourteen thousand [stades]—as the
straight-line length of the territory. The distance along the
coast is not much less, although some augment it by adding, to
the ten thousand [stades], Carmania’s six thousand [stades]. They
apparently include in their reckoning either the coastal inlets
or the part of the Carmanian coastline inside the Persian gulf.
724 C, 6-8 The name “Ariana” is extended as far as some of the Per- Persians, Medes, Iran
sians and Medes, and even as far as the Bactrians and Sogdi- Bactrians, Sogdianans,
n. A
fghanistan, s.
anans in the north, since they all speak more or less the same Uzbekistan,Tajikistan
language with minor variants. |
724 C, 9-16 The nations are disposed as follows. Along the Indus are 15.2.9
the Paropamisadians (above whom rises the Paropamisus); Paropamisus, Hindu Kush (n.
Afg.)
then, to the south, the Arachotians; then, south of them, the
Gedrosenians along with the other occupants of the coastline.
827
4.2. Southern Asia
In all cases, the Indus runs down the width of each of their width = north–south dimension
are the Parthians and the region of the Caspian Gates. South Caspian Gates, ?Sar Darreh
pass (Iran)
of them is the Carmanian desert, then the rest of Carmania
and Gedrosia. |
724 C, 24-32 One would get a better understanding of the aforemen- 15.2.10
tra from Parthyene. He came to Aria, then to the Drangians, Parthyene, n. Iran,
s. Turkmenistan
where he killed Philotas, son of Parmenio, a fter uncovering
Drangians, e. Iran,
his conspiracy. He sent men to Ecbatana to kill the f ather, too, w. Afghanistan
on the grounds that he was complicit in the conspiracy; it is Ecbatana, Hamadan (Iran)
said that the men completed on only the eleventh day what
was a thirty-day or even forty-day camel trek, and carried out
their task. The Drangians, who in other respects follow a Per-
sian lifestyle, lack wine; tin is found in their territory.
724 C, 32–725 C, 6 Leaving the Drangians, he came to the Euergetians he = Alexander
[ 1 ] 723 C, 15–724 C, 6.
[ 2 ] “[Dawn] setting of the Pleiades” = November: 691 C, 25-34n.
[ 3 ] The sense appears to be that the northern part of the Paropamisus range is
held to the west by the Bactrians, to the east by the natives next to the Bactri-
ans. Strabo considers Bactria part of n. Asia (516 C, 17–518 C, 4, with reference
to the neighboring Sogdians and nomads). Aria is also described by Strabo as
part of n. Asia: 516 C, 1-11.
828
Ariana and Carmania
that were bare except for a few prickly terebinths. Food was
so short that they had to eat the flesh of their own animals—
and had to eat it raw, b ecause of the lack of firewood. The
silphium that grew everywhere aided in the digestion of this
raw food. On the fifteenth day a fter leaving his newly founded
city and his winter quarters, he came to Adrapsa, a city in Adrapsa, Qunduz (Afg.)
[1] Strabo updates the information in his source. Cf. 720 C, 14-24n.
[2] 724 C, 24-32n.
[3] “Those associated with Nearchus” is idiomatic, meaning simply Nearchus.
[4] An example of a navigator with local knowledge is Mazanes: 767 C, 3-14.
829
4.2. Southern Asia
726 C, 6-17 Nearchus says, one t hing that was quite readily believed by the
Nearchus (late 4th c. BCE) crew—namely, that there was an island en route that caused those who
anchored there to disappear—was shown to be false; a small boat sailing
there, on reaching the island, disappeared from view; a search party was
sent out but dared not put in at the island; staying offshore, they called
out loudly to the men, and came back a fter getting no response. He said
that, although everyone blamed the island, he sailed up to it, anchored,
disembarked with some of his fellow sailors, and walked around the is-
land; finding no trace of the men being looked for, he gave up, came back,
and announced to the men that the island had been falsely accused—
otherwise, he and those who had disembarked along with him would
similarly have been lost—and that the small boat had disappeared in
some other way, there being ten thousand possible explanations. |
726 C, 18-28 Carmania forms the last stretch of the coastline that begins 15.2.14
CARMANIA with the Indus, but it is much farther north 2 than the outlet of
s. Iran
the Indus (its first point 3 juts southward into the great sea).
Forming, together with the promontory that can be seen ex- promontory, Ras Musandam
(Oman)
tending from Blessed Arabia, the mouth of the Persian gulf, it
bends around toward the Persian gulf and joins up with Persia.
A large part of Carmania is in the interior, stretching between
Gedrosia and Persia, and exceeding Gedrosia in its northern ex-
tent, as is apparent from its fertility—everything grows t here,
and it has large trees (except for the olive tree) and is crossed by
rivers. (Gedrosia is so little different from the territory of the
Ichthyophagi that its crops frequently fail, which is why they
guard the annual harvest closely, eking it out over several years.)
726 C, 28-35 Onesicritus says, there is a river in Carmania that brings down
Onesicritus (late 4th c. BCE) gold dust; gold is mined, as is silver, copper, and ruddle; t here are
two mountains, one of arsenic and one of salt. It has, too, a desert
reaching ultimately to Parthia and Paraetacene. It has various
crops similar to Persian ones, include vines. The vine that we
call “Carmanian” comes from this place: it frequently yields
two-cubit-long bunches, thick with large grapes. It is reason- 1 cubit = 1.5 ft.
830
Persia and Susis
727 C, 11-21 Persia1 comes a fter Carmania, much of it lying on the coast of Carmania, s. Iran 15.3.1
from Susa to Persepolis; from Persepolis to the Carmanian Susa, Shush (Iran)
border, another one thousand six hundred. The tribes that in- Persepolis, Takht-e Jamshid
(Iran)
habit the territory are the “Patischorians,” as they are called,
the Achaemenidae, and the Magi. These live a life of religious
devotion, while the Curtians and Mardians are brigands, and
others are farmers. |
727 C, 30–728 C, 3 Susis, too, is virtually a part of Persia. Lying between Per- 15.3.2
sia and Babylonia, it has a very famous city, Susa. When the Susa, Shush (Iran)
[ 1 ] For Strabo, Persia and Susis are part of Eratosthenes’s 3rd sphragis: 78 C,
26–85 C, 5.
[ 2 ] Strabo re-cites a passage by Eratosthenes, first cited at 80 C, 16-20.
831
4.2. Southern Asia
SUSIS Persians and Cyrus, having conquered the Medes, saw that
Khuzistan, in sw. Iran
their own country was rather marginal and that Susis was
both more centrally located and nearer Babylonia and other
nations, they established the imperial capital t here, realizing
that the territory shared a border with them, that the city
was well known, and thirdly, that Susis had achieved no g reat
deeds in her own right but had always been subject to o thers
and part of a greater federation.
728 C, 3-13 The exception was the heroic period of ancient history.
The city is said to have been originally founded by Titho-
nus, father of Memnon, with a perimeter of one hundred
and twenty stades and an elongated shape. Her acropolis was
called “Memnonium.” The Susians are also called “Cissians”;
Aeschylus (5th c. BCE) and Aeschylus says that Cissia was the mother of Memnon.
Memnon is said to be buried in the Paltus region of Syria, Paltus, Arab el-Moulk (Syr.)
Simonides (6th–5th c. BCE) on the Badas river according to Simonides in his dithyramb
Memnon, part of the Deliaca. The city wall, as also the temples
and the royal residence, were constructed in a manner similar
to those of the Babylonians, namely out of baked brick and as-
Polyclitus (4th c. BCE) phalt, according to some. Polyclitus says, the perimeter m easures
two hundred [stades] and is unwalled. |
728 C, 14-19 Although they particularly focused on the embellishment 15.3.3
of the royal residence in Susa, they paid no small attention to Susa, Shush (Iran)
the residences at Persepolis and Pasargadae. H ere, the Per- Persepolis, Takht-e Jamshid
(Iran)
sians had their treasures, their storage vaults, and tombs—in
places easier to defend as well as hallowed by tradition. There
were other royal residences: in Gabae, somewhere in the Gabae, Isfahan Shahristan
district (Iran)
upper part of Persia; on the coast, at what is called “Taoca.”
728 C, 19-24 The foregoing was the situation at the time of the Persian
empire. T hose who came later used various other residences
because—it is reasonable to assume—they were less expen-
sive, Persian power having been diminished by the Macedo-
nians and, even more so, by the Parthians. Even though the
Persians are still now subject to monarchical rule and have
their own king, their power is much diminished, and they pay
service to the Parthian king. |
728 C, 25-33 Susa lies in the interior on the Choaspes river, on the far- Susa, Shush (Iran) 15.3.4
832
Persia and Susis
sians, and the canals cut through from the Euphrates, form
one stream, that of the Tigris; on this account, it is called “Pa-
sitigris” (All-Tigris) at its outlets. |
729 C, 6-18 Nearchus says, the voyage along the coast of Susis is full of shoals 15.3.5
Nearchus (late 4th c. BCE) and ends with the Euphrates river; at its mouth, a village is estab-
lished, which receives imports from Arabia, given that the Arabian
coastline starts after the mouth of the Euphrates and the Pasitigris;
all the intervening space is occupied by the lake into which the Tigris
flows; if you sail up the Pasitigris for one hundred and fifty stades,
you come to a pontoon bridge, which leads to Susa from Persia, and Susa, Shush (Iran)
which is sixty stades from Susa; the Pasitigris is around two thousand
stades from the Oroatis; the voyage through the lake to the mouth Oroatis, ?Zoreh r.
of the Tigris is six hundred stades, and near the mouth, a village is
established belonging to Susiana and five hundred stades distant
from Susa; the voyage upstream from the mouth of the Euphrates to
Babylon, through countryside with good living conditions, is more Babylon, Tell Amran (Iraq)
833
4.2. Southern Asia
rivers that run through the territory and flow into the Persian
gulf. A fter the Choaspes come the Copratas and the Pasiti- Copratas, ?Ab-i Diz
gris—it too flows out of Uxia. T here is a river Cyrus, which Pasitigris, ?Karun r.
flows through what is called “Coele Persia,” 1 in the Pasargadae Cyrus, ?Kur r.
region (the name of which the king took instead of his own, king = Cyrus, who founded
Persian empire, 6th c. BCE
calling himself “Cyrus” instead of “Agradates”).
729 C, 31–730 C, 7 He crossed the Araxes at Persepolis itself. Persepolis was, He = Alexander
after Susa, the most beautifully embellished city and the Araxes, ?Pulvar r.
largest, with a palace that was superb, especially in terms of Persepolis, Takht-e Jamshid
(Iran)
the lavish furnishings it contained. The Araxes flows from
Susa, Shush (Iran)
the Paraetacians and is joined by the Medus from its source
in Media; they pass through a fertile valley, which links up
with Carmania and the eastern parts of the territory, as does
Persepolis herself. Alexander set fire to the palace in Perse-
polis to avenge the Greeks, whose own temples and cities had
been thoroughly sacked by the Persians using both fire and
sword. | Then he came to Pasargadae—this, too, was an old- 15.3.7
834
Persia and Susis
also crammed full of treasure and stuff. However, he consid- Susa, Shush (Iran)
ered as his royal capital not Susa but Babylon; and he thought Babylon, Tell Amran (Iraq)
and because of this weight, people have to make their houses narrow
but long; they lack long roof beams but need large houses because of
[ 1 ] ?Aristus of Salamis, the last writer to whom Strabo has referred by name (730 C,
28-31).
835
4.2. Southern Asia
the stifling heat; lumber from the date palm has the peculiar quality
that, as it stiffens with age, it does not sag down but is forced into an
upward curve by the weight and provides the roof with better support.
731 C, 24-30 The cause of the heat is said to be the high mountains that
rise up in the north and provide shelter from all the north
winds. Blowing from the mountain peaks at a g reat height,
they do not touch the plains but pass them by on their way
to regions farther south than Susis. Susis itself is windless,
particularly at that time of year, when other land that suffers
from scorching heat is cooled by the Etesians. | Etesians = seasonal winds
731 C, 31–732 C, 2 It is so excessively rich in grain that it regularly yields both It = Susis 15.3.11
732 C, 18-28 There are the same Persian customs for t hese people and
PERSIAN CUSTOMS for the Medes and various other p eoples. Several writers have
[ 1 ] 729 C, 22–732 C, 2.
[ 2 ] Macedonian use of local navigators: 725 C, 22-32n.
[ 3 ] Strabo elaborates on Sitacene (e. Iraq), Elymaea (e. Iraq, sw. Iran), Paraetacene
(w. Iran) at 744 C, 3–745 C, 4.
[ 4 ] 727 C, 11–732 C, 17.
836
Persia and Susis
of Fire, they offer up dry wood without the bark, placing some
fat on its upper side; then they pour olive oil over it and kindle
it (by using a fan rather than blowing on it—they execute any-
one who blows on it and anyone who puts a corpse or dung
onto Fire). In the case of Water, they visit a lake, a river, or a
spring; they dig a pit into which they slaughter the sacrificial
victim, taking care not to get blood in the nearby W ater, as
this would be pollution; then, spreading the meat on leaves
of myrtle or laurel, they touch it with slender wands, all the
while reciting incantations and pouring libations of olive oil
mixed with milk and honey—into neither Fire nor Water but
onto the ground; they continue their incantations for a long
time, holding a bunch of slender myrtle wands. |
733 C, 7-16 In Cappadocia, where the tribe of the Magi (also called 15.3.15
837
4.2. Southern Asia
are taught how to shoot with a bow, throw the javelin, ride
on horseback, and tell the truth. They learn their lessons
from the wisest of teachers, who weave in mythical material,
making it useful and reciting the deeds of gods and heroes,
both without song and with it. The teachers assemble them
in one place, having woken them before dawn with an instru-
ment made of bronze as if for weapon practice or hunting,
and divide them into groups; appointing one leader per fifty
(the leader being one of the sons of the king or of a satrap),
they issue an order to follow him as he runs, having marked
out a course of thirty or forty stades. They demand an ac-
count of e very branch of learning, as well as practicing voice-
strengthening, breathing, and chest exercises, endurance
of heat and cold and rain, crossing torrential rivers without
getting weapons or clothing wet, tending flocks, living in
the open, and foraging for fruits that grow wild—terebinth,
acorns, pear. These individuals, who live by foraging, are
called cardaces (carda meaning “manly” and “warlike”).
734 C, 8-16 After their physical exercise e very day, they eat bread, bar-
ley cake, cress seed, granulated salt, and meat—either roasted
or boiled in w ater; they drink w ater. They hunt by shooting
javelins and arrows from horseback and slinging stones; in
the afternoon, they cultivate gardens, and they are trained
in root cutting, weapon making, and crafting linen and nets.
838
Persia and Susis
The boys do not touch what they have caught; the custom is
to convey it home. Prizes are awarded by the king for r unning
and for the pentathlon. The boys wear gold, since people
value its fiery appearance highly, which is why people do not
use it (nor likewise fire) to honor the dead. |
734 C, 17-26 From twenty years to fifty, they serve in the army—and 15.3.19
[ 1 ] 732 C, 18–735 C, 3.
839
4.2. Southern Asia
wealth, the kings fell into luxurious ways, seeking out wheat drachma, very small meaure of
weight in Greek metrical system
from Assus (in the Aeolis), Chalybonian wine from Syria, (equivalent to just over 4 g)
water from the Eulaeus—the lightest of all w aters, so light cotyla, small measure of volume
in Greek metrical system
that it is less heavy by the amount of one drachma per Attic (equivalent to a modern 1-cup
cotyla. | measure)
735 C, 21-28 The Persians were the barbarians best known to the 15.3.23
PERSIAN HISTORY Greeks. This is because none of the other barbarians who
ruled over Asia ruled over the Greeks—the former had not
even known anything of the latter, while the Greeks had
known nothing of the barbarians, except for snippets based
Homer (8th c. BCE) on long-distance rumor. (Homer knew nothing of the Syrian Syrian, Median empires,
9th–6th c. BCE
or Median empire—otherwise, when he mentioned Egyptian
Thebes, with its wealth, and the wealth in Phoenicia, he would
not have kept s ilent about the wealth in Babylon, Ninus, and
Ecbatana.)
735 C, 28–736 C, 2 The Persians were the first1 who ruled over the Greeks as
well. (The Lydians ruled over the Greeks, but they did not
rule all Asia—only a small portion of the region this side of
the Halys and only for a short time during the reigns of Croe- Croesus and Alyattes ruled
Lydia, 6th c. BCE
sus and Alyattes—and when they succumbed to the Persians
Persians defeated Medes, 550
were deprived by them of any glorious history they had.) The BCE, then Lydians, 547 BCE
Persians, a fter destroying the Medes, conquered the Lydians
and held the Asian Greeks in subjection, too. The Persians
even subsequently made the crossing to Greece, and w ere Darius (1) attacked Greece, 490
BCE; Xerxes attacked Greece,
worsted in many and frequent b attles, but they nevertheless 480/479 BCE
continued to hold Asia as far as its seaboard u ntil their con-
quest by the Macedonians. |
736 C, 3-11 The man who established their hegemony was Cyrus. He Cyrus, ruled 559–530 BCE; 15.3.24
Cambyses, 530–522 BCE
was succeeded by his son Cambyses, whose rule was ended by
[ 1 ] The first, i.e., of those barbarians who ruled over all Asia.
840
Assyria
736 C, 13–737 C, 2 Next to Persia and Susiana are the Assyrians.1 This is the name 16.1.1
737 C, 3-8 It appears that the name “Syrians” extended in antiquity 16.1.2
on the one hand from Babylonia to the Issian gulf but on the
other hand from there to the Euxine. After all, both sets of Euxine, Black Sea
841
4.2. Southern Asia
The city, much larger than Babylon, lay in the Aturian plain.
(Aturia borders on the Arbela region, with the Lycus river Arbela, Erbil (Iraq)
between them, but while Arbela is an autonomous prov- Lycus, ?Greater Zab r.
gamela, where it came to pass that Darius was conquered and Alexander the G reat conquered
Persian king Darius (3), 331 BCE
lost his empire. This is a famous place with a famous name,
which translates as “House of the Camel.” It was so named
by Darius, son of Hystaspes, when he donated the property Darius (1), son of Hystaspes,
ruled Persia, 522–486 BCE
to provide for the upkeep of the camel, which had been so
very helpful in carrying the baggage (including the king’s
provisions) on the march through the Scythian desert. The
Macedonians, seeing that it was a shabby l ittle village, while
Arbela was a noteworthy settlement (founded, so they say, Arbela, Erbil (Iraq)
842
Assyria
ers are sixty cubits high. The passage along the top of the
wall is such that carriages drawn by four horses can easily
pass each other. That is why the wall is said to be one of the
Seven Wonders, as is the Hanging Garden, the sides of which
form a quadrilateral, each side m easuring four plethra. It is 1 plethrum = 100 ft.
843
4.2. Southern Asia
The doors are high, like the houses, all of which are vaulted
because wood is lacking, given that much of the territory
is bare of trees and scrubby, except for the date palm. The
date palm is very common in Babylonia, and there’s a lot of
it, too, in Susa, on the Persian coast, and in Carmania. They Susa, Shush (Iran)
739 C, 9-19 A sector has been set aside in Babylon for the native Babylon, Tell Amran (Iraq) 16.1.6
739 C, 29–740 C, 4 The territory is crossed by several rivers, the largest being 16.1.9
the Euphrates and the Tigris. These rivers are said to rank
second in southern Asia only to the rivers of India. They
provide upriver passages—the latter to Opis and what is now Opis, Tell Mujeili ' (Iraq)
Seleucia (the village of Opis being a center of trade for the Seleucia, Tell Omar (Iraq)
surrounding places), the former to Babylon—of more than Babylon, Tell Amran (Iraq)
[ 1 ] Chaldaeans (s. Iraq, Kuwait): 739 C, 23-28; 765 C, 12-21; 767 C, 15-21.
[ 2 ] Susians, Elymaeans, Paraetacenians (e. Iraq, w. Iran): 727 C, 30–732 C, 17; 744 C,
4–745 C, 4. Chaldaeans, Alasenian Arabs (s. Iraq, Kuwait): 739 C, 9-19n. Scenitae
Arabs (e. Syria, se. Turkey, Iraq): 747 C, 24–748 C, 24; 765 C, 12-21n. Adiabene (n.
Iraq): 745 C, 8-18. Gordyaea (se. Turkey): 747 C, 10-23. Armenians, Medes (e.
Turkey, n. Iran, s. Azerbaijan): 522 C, 14–533 C, 4.
844
Assyria
845
4.2. Southern Asia
741 C, 1-10 Aristobulus says that Alexander himself, piloting the vessel on 16.1.11
Aristobulus (4th c. BCE) the voyage upriver, inspected the canals and cleaned them out with
the help of his hordes of followers; likewise, he closed off some outlets
with sluice gates and opened up others. When he observed how one he = Alexander
canal (the canal r unning most directly to the marshes and the lakes
on the way to Arabia) had an outlet that required a lot of work
and was not easily barricaded because of its soft and yielding soil,
he opened up another outlet, a new one, having come across a place
thirty stades away that was rocky, and diverted the stream t here.
When he did t hese things, he was at the same time planning ahead,
so that Arabia would not be rendered completely inaccessible by lakes
and even by marshes, ultimately being made into an island by the
mass of water.
741 C, 10-22 He had in mind possession of this territory and had already He = Alexander
prepared fleets and bases. He had some ships built in Phoenicia territory = Arabia
[ 1 ] These “lakes toward Arabia” may be the “marshes associated with Pelusium”
(50 C, 12-24n) and the “lakes called ‘Marsh-side’ . . . lying on the left-hand side
of the great river, above Pelusium, in Arabia” (804 C, 10-18n). For “Arabia” mean-
ing on the eastern side of the Nile: 806 C, 31–807 C, 3n. Strabo has perhaps
misunderstood Eratosthenes’s “lakes toward Arabia” as referring to lakes near
the mouth of the Euphrates. Cf. 759 C, 33–760 C, 10n.
[ 2 ] For ambiguity in the term “Coelosyrians”: 756 C, 16-18.
[ 3 ] It is probable that Eratosthenes speculated that water from the lakes near the
Nile feeds lake Sirbonis in Egypt (Sabkhat el Bardawil, Egy.), near which are
located Rhinocorura (el Arish, Egy.) and mount Casium (Ras Qasrun/Khatib el
Gals, Egy.): 38 C, 25-33; 50 C, 12-24; 55 C, 33–56 C, 5; 58 C, 24-32; 758 C, 16-30;
759 C, 9-18; 759 C, 33–760 C, 10; 760 C, 17-23.
846
Assyria
742 C, 4-10 Polyclitus says, the Euphrates does not flood, since the plains
Polyclitus (4th c. BCE) through which it flows are immense; as for the mountains, some are
two thousand stades away, while the Cossaeans, although scarcely one
thousand stades away, are not at all high, are not covered with much
snow, and do not produce snowmelt in any large amount. The high
mountain peaks are in the northern regions above Ecbatana, whereas Ecbatana, Hamadan (Iran)
in the south the mountains, diverging and flattening out, are very low.
Then again, the Tigris receives much of the water.
742 C, 10-26 The last statement is clearly absurd: the latter river flows latter river = ?Tigris
Strabo points out that down into the same plains. The said high mountain peaks betrays
Polyclitus’s rationale is faulty
ambiguity, in that in one place they are high (in the north) and
in another place flattening out (in the south), but snowfall is
determined not only by height but also by climata; and one and climata, bands of latitude
dred times as much, they say), and its other needs are met
by the date palm, which is used for bread, wine, vinegar,
honey, groats, and all sorts of woven material. Their metal-
smiths use date kernels instead of charcoal. The kernels are
847
4.2. Southern Asia
soaked and used as feed for herds and flocks. (They say that
there’s a Persian song in which three hundred and sixty uses
are enumerated!) For oil, they generally use sesame. There
grows in Artemita . . . * called . . . *, but this is rare in other Artemita, ?Karastel (Iraq)
locations. |
743 C, 3-11 A large amount of asphalt is found in Babylonia. Concern- 16.1.15
Eratosthenes (3rd c. BCE) ing asphalt, Eratosthenes says the following. The liquid kind
(which they call “naphtha”) is found in Susis, while the dry and po-
tentially solid kind is found in Babylonia. The source of the latter is
near the Euphrates and, when the snowmelt causes the river to flood,
the asphalt source likewise floods and overflows into the river, where
it hardens into great lumps that can be used for houses built of baked
brick. Other writers, however, say that the liquid kind, too, is
found in Babylonia. The fact that the dry kind is extremely
useful for building has already been noted.1
743 C, 11-20 They also say that boats are made of wicker and, when
Citation of the words of plastered with asphalt, become impermeable; 2 the liquid
Eratosthenes
kind (which they call “naphtha”) has an amazing characteristic—
namely, that when naphtha is brought near a flame, it attracts
the flame, and if you smear somebody with naphtha and
bring them near the flame, they catch fire; it is not possible
to quench the fire with water (it just burns more strongly)
unless in very g reat quantities, but if the fire is smothered
with mud, vinegar, alum, or birdlime, it goes out. They say
that Alexander, by way of experiment, poured naphtha over
a boy taking a bath and then brought a lamp close to him; that
the boy caught fire and nearly died. However, the bystanders,
dousing the boy with a huge amount of water, extinguished
the fire and saved his life.
743 C, 20-24 Posidonius says, the naphtha sources in Babylonia are, some of
Posidonius (late 2nd–1st c. BCE) them, sources of “White,” and some are sources of “Black”; of these,
some (I mean the sources of “White”) are sources of liquid sulfur,
and these attract flame; the sources of “Black” are sources of liquid
asphalt, which people burn in lamps instead of oil. |
743 C, 25-34 Long ago, Babylon was the Assyrian metropolis. Nowa- Babylon, Tell Amran (Iraq) 16.1.16
days, the metropolis is Seleucia, the one called “on-the- Seleucia-on-the-Tigris, Tell
Omar (Iraq)
Tigris.” Nearby is a large village called “Ctesiphon.” The
Ctesiphon, al-Ma'aridh (Iraq)
Parthian kings established their winter quarters h ere out of
consideration for the Seleucians, to save the latter from being
overwhelmed by having the tribe of Scythian soldiers quar-
848
Assyria
East of Babylonia lon and Susis, so that, for travelers going from Babylon to Susis, sw. Iran
e. Iraq, s. + w. Iran
Susa through Sitacene, the entire journey is eastward.
744 C, 7-9 Eastward, too, is the journey for travelers from Susa into Susa, Shush (Iran)
the Persian interior through Uxia, and for travelers from Uxia, sw. Iran
Persia into the interior of Carmania. Persia, being extensive, Carmania, Persia, s. Iran
encircles Carmania.
744 C, 10-13 Bordering this to the north as far as the Caspian Gates are Caspian Gates, ?Sar Darreh
pass (Iran)
Paraetacene and Cossaea, mountain-dwelling nations who
live by raiding; bordering on Susis is Elymais, also largely
mountainous and inhabited by raiders; bordering on Elymais Zagrus, Zagros, mts. in n. Iraq,
is the Zagrus region and Media.1 | w. Iran
744 C, 14-20 The Cossaeans fight largely with bow and arrow, as do the 16.1.18
849
4.2. Southern Asia
he heard that they had sacred treasures but saw how insub- they = Elymaeans
Media and the Zagrus region, the way is through Massa- Zagrus, Zagros, mts. in n. Iraq,
w. Iran
batica; from Susis, through Gabiana. (Gabiana and Massa-
batica are provinces of Elymaea.) The third pass leads from
Persia. Corbiana, too, is an Elymaean province. Bordering on
these p eople are the Sagapenians and the Silacenians, small
chiefdoms.
745 C, 5-7 Such are the size and the nature of the nations beyond
Babylonia to the east.1 To the north, as I said, are Media and
Armenia.2 To the west are Adiabene and Mesopotamia. |
745 C, 8-17 Most of Adiabene consists of flatlands and is part of 16.1.19
ADIABENE Babylonia, albeit with its own ruler; in places, however, it be-
n. Iraq
longs to Armenia. The Medes, the Armenians, and thirdly
the Babylonians—the greatest nations in the region—were
from the outset constituted in such a way that they continu-
ally attacked each other, at moments opportune to each, and
then reconciled. Such was the situation that prevailed up u ntil
the Parthian conquest. The Parthians have sovereignty over
the Medes and Babylonians, but they have never once had
sovereignty over the Armenians. There have been frequent
incursions, but they were never taken by force. Instead, Ti- they = Armenians
[ 1 ] 744 C, 4–745 C, 4.
[ 2 ] 739 C, 23-28. Media and Armenia are described in full at 522 C, 14–533 C, 4.
[ 3 ] Armeniaca (lit., “Stuff about Armenia”) is the section of Strabo’s work (526 C,
34–533 C, 4) in which he describes Armenia, and within which he mentions Ti-
granes (532 C, 7-25). Strabo’s use of such “titles”: 639 C, 15-27n.
[ 4 ] 746 C, 14–747 C, 31.
850
Assyria
745 C, 21-32 In most respects, their customs are similar to Persian ones, 16.1.20
ASSYRIAN CUSTOMS but one peculiarity is that three wise men are appointed to rule
over each tribe. T hese men present in public the marriageable
virgins, auctioning them off to their future husbands, always
starting with the ones who fetch the highest price. The fore-
going is how marriages are brought about. Every time that the
couple has sex, however, each one of them individually gets
up to make an offering of incense, and at daybreak they wash
themselves before touching any vessel. (Just as it is customary
to wash after touching the dead, so too a fter having sex.) It is
the custom for all Babylonian w omen, in accordance with an
oracle, to have sex with a stranger, going to some Aphrodis- oracle, instruction from the
gods
ium (temple to Aphrodite) with a large retinue and crowd of people.
Each w oman wears a corded wreath. The stranger approaches
her, deposits in her lap as much silver as is appropriate, takes
her far away from the t emple, and has sex with her. The silver
is considered to be sacred to Aphrodite.
745 C, 32–746 C, 3 There are three groups of officials: one group of those who
have already done military service, one group of the most em-
inent individuals, and one group of elders (separate from the
group appointed by the king). It is the job of this last group
to give young girls in marriage and to judge cases involving
adultery . . . * involving violence.
746 C, 3-13 They lay out their sick at places where three roads meet
and inquire of passersby w hether they know any cure for the
affliction. T here is no passerby who is so horrible that he does
not, when he chances to fall in with them, suggest a remedy if
he knows one. Their dress is a linen tunic down to their feet,
an outer garment made of wool, a white cloak, long hair, and
slipperlike footwear. They carry both a seal and a staff, not
a plain one but one topped with a device such as an apple,
rose, lily, and so on. They use sesame oil to anoint themselves.
They sing dirges for the dead (as do the Egyptians and many
others), bury them in honey after smearing them with wax.
There are three clans composed of people who do not use
grain: these are marsh dwellers and ichthyophagi (fish-eaters), who
live lives similar to those in Gedrosia. |
746 C, 14-23 Mesopotamia (Between-rivers) is named after the facts of the 16.1.21
851
4.2. Southern Asia
only the eastern side, the Euphrates the western side and
the southern side.1 To the north is the Taurus, which sepa- Taurus, mts. of se. Turkey
746 C, 23-29 The Tigris flows through the lake known as “Thopitis”3— Thopitis, Van l. (Tky.)
cuts through the lake with such force that, although the lake
water is salty and has no fish, in this part the water is fresh,
flowing, and full of fish.4 |
746 C, 30–747 C, 2 The lengthwise contraction of Mesopotamia extending a 16.1.22
areas around Carrhae and Nicephorium, and Chordiraza and Carrhae, Altınbaşak (Tky.)
Sinnaca, where Crassus was tricked into being captured by Nicephorium, Raqqa (Syr.)
Surenas (the Parthian general) and slain. | Chordiraza, ?nr. Qalaat Nadjm
(Syr.)
747 C, 10-20 Toward the Tigris is the region belonging to the Gordy- 16.1.24
strong fortress with three citadels; since each citadel is en- Sitalca, Çağlayan (Tky.)
circled by its own wall, it is something of a triple city. Even Pinaca, Eski Yapı (Tky.)
[ 1 ] 79 C, 3-12; 80 C, 20-28; 521 C, 6-25; 526 C, 34–527 C, 15; 529 C, 11-30. [ 6 ] Strabo has cited Eratosthenes for the same distance at 80 C, 9-16.
[ 2 ] Strabo has cited Eratosthenes for the same distance at 79 C, 20-32. [ 7 ] This “current-day” crossing (?Kavunlu/Belkis, Tky.) had probably assumed more
[ 3 ] Strabo h ere corrects his statement 200 C-pages e arlier (529 C, 11-30, where importance following the Roman annexation of Commagene (17 CE).
he calls the lake “Thonitis”). The (mis)spelling in the earlier passage should be [ 8 ] “They” = Macedonians, whose various kings bearing the name “Antiochus”
allowed to stand, as a genuine Strabonian error. founded numerous cities in Asia named a fter themselves: Antioch in Margiana,
[ 4 ] Strabo’s belief that the Tigris runs through Lake Van is incorrect. 516 C, 12-16; Pisidian Antioch, 577 C, 1-10; Antioch-on-the-Maeander, 630 C, 15-
[ 5 ] Strabo may include Babylonia (s. + cen. Iraq) with Mesopotamia (e. Syria, se. 25; Antioch-by-Daphne, 750 C, 5–751 C, 4.
Turkey, n. Iraq) in comparing it to a boat: 79 C, 3-12; 80 C, 20-28.
852
Assyria
so, the Armenian [king] subjugated the city; then the Romans Tigranes, king of Armenia, ruled
95–ca. 55 BCE
took it from him, even though the Gordyaeans had a repu-
tation as exceptionally good engineers and experts in the
use of siege weapons, and this was what Tigranes had used
them for. The Romans subjugated the rest of the riverlands,
too. Pompey apportioned much of it—as much as was worth
having—to Tigranes. The territory has good pasture and is territory = Gordyaea (se. Tky.)
SCENITAE ARABS and farther away from the mountains, being waterless and
e. Syria, se. Turkey, Iraq
wretched, are inhabited by the Scenitae (Tent-dwelling) Arabs.2
They spend their lives making raids and tending their flocks,
ready to move on to new places when the pastures and plun-
der dry up. It so happens that the mountain inhabitants
suffer from the depredations of both these p eople and the these people = Scenitae Arabs
Tigris, called “Basilios”; and one, Aborras, in the vicinity of Aborras, Habur r.
Anthemusia. The route from Syria to Seleucia and Babylon Anthemusia, ?Suruc region
(Tky.)
passes among the Scenitae, whom some now call “Malians,”
and through their desert; t here is a place for them to cross place . . . to cross
Euphrates = ?Kavunlu/Belkis
the Euphrates at Anthemusia, in Mesopotamia. At a distance (Tky.)
of four schoeni away from the river is Bambyca, which people 1 schoenus = 40 or 60 stades
also call “Edessa” and “Hiera (Sacred) City,”3 where the Syrian
goddess Atargatis is worshipped.
748 C, 6-19 After they have made the crossing, the journey is through they = those en route to
Seleucia and Babylon
the desert as far as Scenae, a city of significance near the Bab-
ylonian border, situated on a canal. The journey from the
crossing to Scenae takes twenty-five days. T here are camel
drivers whose rest stops sometimes have a good supply of
[ 1 ] Syriaca (lit., “Stuff about Syria”) is the section of Strabo’s work (749 C, 8–765 C, 11)
in which he describes Syria; and within which he tells the story of Triptolemus
and Gordys (750 C, 5-24). Strabo’s use of such “titles”: 639 C, 15-27n.
[ 2 ] Cf. 765 C, 12-21n.
[ 3 ] Bambyca (or “Hiera City”) and Edessa are probably separate cities. Bambyca
(Membidj, Syr.) might be described as four schoeni from the Euphrates; Edessa
(Şanlıurfa, Tky.) as four schoeni from the Balissus r. (Balikh r). The latter is per-
haps the “Basilios” river to which Strabo refers at the start of this paragraph.
853
4.2. Southern Asia
748 C, 20-24 The boundary of the empire of the Parthians is formed 16.1.28
by the Euphrates and its far bank. The area on this side as far on this side = west of Euphrates r.
they who started the fighting (namely, when they sent Pa- Parthian general Pacorus
invaded Syria and Asian
corus to attack Asia), they suffered similar consequences, peninsula, 40 BCE; defeated by
Romans, 39 BCE; invaded Syria
even though Antony, with the Armenian [king] as his coun- again, defeated by Romans, and
selor, was betrayed and fared badly in the war. killed, 38 BCE
748 C, 28–749 C, 7 Phraates, taking over from him, was so keen on friendly Phraates succeeded as Parthian
king, ca. 37 BCE
relations with Augustus Caesar that he returned the tro-
phies set up by the Parthians at the Roman defeat.2 Invit-
ing Titius, who was at that stage in charge of Syria,3 to a
conference, he delivered into his hands as hostages his four
legitimate sons (Seraspadanes, Rhodaspes, Phraates, and
Vonones), along with two of their wives and four of their
sons.4 He did this out of fear of insurrections and p eople
attacking him, having appreciated that no one would be
strong enough to defeat him without bringing an Arsacid
onside, given that the Parthians were true philarsacae. He
therefore got his sons out of the picture in order to deprive
evildoers of this opportunity. Those of his sons who survive
[ 1 ] For the Scenitae (Tent-dwellers) close to the Euphrates: 765 C, 12-21n. For sceni-
tae (tent-dwellers) in Blessed Arabia: 767 C, 31–768 C, 6.
[ 2 ] Phraates returned the trophies—Roman standards taken by the victorious Par-
thians (53, 36 BCE)—to the young Tiberius, sent by the emperor Augustus to
Armenia for the purpose (20 BCE).
[ 3 ] Strabo h ere uses “Syria” to mean the Roman province of Syria. Elsewhere,
Strabo uses it to mean Assyria in general (737 C, 3-33), or the part of Assyria
west of the Euphrates (749 C, 8-13).
[ 4 ] Phraates delivered his sons into Roman safekeeping at some point between 13
and 8 BCE.
854
Syria
Amanus: Commagene and what is called “Seleucid” Syria; Amanus [mountains], Nur
Dağları (Tky.)
then Coele Syria;6 finally, Phoenicia on the coast and Judaea
in the interior.7 Some people, dividing all Syria between
the Coelosyrians, Syrians, and Phoenicians, say that four
nations—Judaeans, Idumaeans, Gazans, and Azotians—are
mixed in with these; that some (e.g., Syrians and Coelosyr-
ians) practice agriculture, while others (e.g., Phoenicians) are
traders. | So much for the overview. 16.2.3
SELEUCIS indeed is, a tetrapolis (four-city state) because of the outstanding Antioch-by-Daphne, Antakya
se. Turkey, w. present-day Syria (Tky.)
cities within it. Although t here are several, the four largest
are Antioch-by-Daphne, Seleucia-in-Pieria, Apamia, and Seleucia-in-Pieria, Kapısuyu/
Kaboussié (Tky.)
Laodicia, which are said to be each other’s “sisters” b ecause
Apamia, Qalaat el-Moudiq (Syr.)
of their commonality. All w ere founded by Seleucus Nica-
Laodicia, Lattaquié (Syr.)
tor. The largest city was named after his father; the city that
Seleucus Nicator, Macedonian
was the most natural fortress was named after himself; of the king of Syria, late 4th–3rd c. BCE
[ 1 ] Vonones had died in 19/20 CE. s. Iraq, Saudi Arabia, s. Jordan, Oman, Yemen, Bahrain, Qatar, UAE, s. Israel, Sinai,
[ 2 ] Phraataces, Orodes, Vonones, and Artabanus. Egypt): 765 C, 12–824 C, 21.
[ 3 ] Parthian deleg ations: 1 CE; in or before 9 CE (to request the return of Vonones); [ 6 ] For the meaning of “Coele”: 336 C, 33-36n. “Coele Syria” has two senses: 756 C,
19 CE. 16-18n.
[ 4 ] Strabo’s concept of Syria is based on an enlarged version of Eratosthenes’s [ 7 ] Commagene and Seleucid Syria (se. Turkey, w. Syria): 749 C, 21–754 C, 32. Coele
3rd sphragis: 84 C, 9–85 C, 5. Syria (Syria, Lebanon): 754 C, 32–756 C, 18. Phoenicia (coast of Lebanon, Israel,
[ 5 ] Cilicia/Amanus (s. Turkey): 535 C, 12-19; 671 C, 26–676 C, 28. Scenitae Arabs on Gaza, e. Egypt): 756 C, 22–760 C, 16. Judaea (Israel, W. Bank, Jordan): 760 C,
this side of Euphrates (e. Syria): 765 C, 12-21n. Blessed Arabia and Egypt (Kuwait, 17–765 C, 11.
855
4.2. Southern Asia
close by that city, it flows out to sea at Seleucia. Previously Seleucia, Kapısuyu/Kaboussié
(Tky.)
called “Typhon,” its name was changed to that of the man
856
Syria
small towns once subject to the tyrant Dionysius (son of Beroea, Alep (Syr.)
Orontes, and the Labotas. On this plain is Meleager’s Palisade Orontes r., Asi Nehri/Nahr el-Asi
and the Oenoparas river, where Ptolemy Philometer, although Labotas r., upper Kara Su
victorious in b attle against Alexander Balas, was wounded and Oenoparas r., Nahr Afrin
857
4.2. Southern Asia
751 C, 31-35 While Apamia is south of the Antiochans and lies inland
Casium, Jebel el-Akra (Tky.) from them, mount Casium and the Anticasium are south of
Anticasium, Kara Douran Dağ the Seleucians (even before t hese, following on from Seleucia,
(Syr.)
are the outflows of the Orontes, then the Nymphaeum—a Nymphaeum, el-Hammam,
S Miyadun (Tky.)
sacred cave—and then Casium). Next is the small town of
Posidium, and Heraclia.1 | Posidium, ?on Ras el-Bassit (Syr.)
751 C, 35–752 C, 7 Then there’s Laodicia-on-Sea, a beautifully located city Laodicia-on-Sea, Lattaquié (Syr.) 16.2.9
858
Syria
and Arethusa (belonging to Sampsiceramus and his son Iam- Apamian lake, Behiret et-Taqa
(Syr.)
blichus, phylarchs of the Emisenian nation). Not far away are
Arethusa, Restan (Syr.)
Heliu Polis (Sun city) and the Chalcis subject to Ptolemy (son
Heliu Polis, Ba'albek (Leb.)
of Mennaeus),1 who also held Massyas and the mountains of
Massyas, Biqa' (Syr., Leb.)
the Ituraeans. Included among Bassus’s allies was Alchaedam-
Ituraeans = Lebanon
nus, the king of the Rhambaeans—the nomads on this side
of the Euphrates. He used to have a friendly policy toward
the Romans but, considering himself to have been wronged
by the leaders 2 and withdrawing into Mesopotamia, at that
point he entered Bassus’s service.
753 C, 11-12 Posidonius the Stoic—the most erudite of our p hiloso-
phers 3—is from Apamia. |
753 C, 13-19 Bordering Apamian territory on the eastern side is the 16.2.11
the Apamians belongs for the most part to the Scenitae (Tent-
dwelling) p eople—they are similar to the nomads in Meso-
potamia, but the closer they are to the Syrians, the more
civilized they become and the less Arabian and scenitae (tent-
dwelling),4 having better o rganized governments, like t hose of
Sampsiceramus, Gambarus, Themellas, and other such men. |
859
4.2. Southern Asia
753 C, 20-28 The voyage from Laodicia along the remaining coast 2 is as
follows. Near Laodicia are the small towns of Posidium, Hera- Posidium, ?on Ras el-Bassit (Syr.)
clium, and Gabala.3 Immediately thereafter is the stretch of Heraclium, ?on Ras Ibn Hami
(Syr.)
Paltus, Arab el-Moulk (Syr.) mainland coast belonging to the Aradians: Paltus, Balanaea,
Gabala, Jebele (Syr.)
Balanaea, Baniyas (Syr.) and Caranus (the Aradian seaport with a small harbor). Then
Caranus, Tell Qarnoun (Syr.) comes Enydra, and Marathus (an ancient Phoenician city, in Enydra, Tell Ghamqe (Syr.)
ruins). The Aradians divided this territory up among them- Marathus, 'Amrit (Syr.)
selves, as they also did with Ximyra, the next place along. Ximyra, ?Tell Kazel (Syr.)
Orthosia, Khan ard Artuşi (Leb.) Next to these is Orthosia and also the nearby river Eleutherus
Eleutheru s, Nahr el-Kebir (which some p eople take as the boundary of Seleucis with
Phoenicia and Coele Syria).4 |
753 C, 29–754 C, 9 Aradus lies off a stretch of coast with many reefs and no Aradus, Rouad (Syr.) 16.2.13
harbor (i.e., the coastal stretch between her seaport and Mara- seaport = Caranus, Tell Qarnoun
(Syr.)
thus) and is twenty stades from the mainland. It is a rocky
outcrop with a circumference of some seven stades, packed
with dwellings: it has enjoyed such population growth, up to
and including the present, that the inhabitants live in h ouses
many stories high. People say that it was founded by refugees
from Sidon. The inhabitants get water partly from rainfall
and cisterns, partly from the mainland opposite. In w artime,
people get w ater from the sea channel, a l ittle distance in front
of the city, which is fed by a spring that has an unstinting sup-
ply of fresh water. An upside-down funnel is inserted into the
spring, made of lead and lowered down from the boat that
collects the water. The funnel is wide-mouthed but tapers to
a narrow base with quite a small hole. Tightly fitted around
the base is a leather pipe (perhaps one should say “hose”),
which acts as a conduit for the w ater forced up from the spring
through the funnel. What gets forced through at first is sea-
water, but p eople wait and collect the flow of pure and potable
water in specially designed vessels and deliver it to the city. |
754 C, 10-27 In antiquity, the Aradians w ere ruled by their own king, in 16.2.14
860
Syria
Orthosia, Khan ard Artuşi (Leb.) city), named after the fact, as it was founded by the three cit-
Eleutherus (river), Nahr el-Kebir ies of Tyrus, Sidon, and Aradus. A fter Tripolis comes Theu Theu Prosopum, Ras Shaqqa
(Leb.)
Libanus, Jebel Lubnan (Leb.) Prosopum (Face of God), where the Libanus mountain range
terminates. Between the two is a place, Trieres.1 | Trieres, el Heri (Leb.)
754 C, 32–755 C, 6 These are the two mountain ranges forming what is 16.2.16
balsam.
[ 1 ] Strabo gets ahead of himself here. He later categorizes the stretch of coastline
from Orthosia to Theu Prosopum as part of Phoenicia: 756 C, 18-21.
[ 2 ] The meaning of “Coele”: 336 C, 33-36n. “Coele Syria” has two senses: 756 C,
16-18n.
[ 3 ] By including this description of the Jordan valley here, Strabo perhaps con-
flates the two senses in which the name “Coele Syria” is used (756 C, 16-18n). For
Judaea: 760 C, 17–765 C, 11.
861
4.2. Southern Asia
755 C, 10-13 As for the rivers, the Chrysorrhoas (which starts in the Chrysorrhoas, Nahr Barada
city and territory of the Damascenians)1 is virtually drained city of Damscenians, Damascus
(Syr.)
by irrigation channels, for the territory it irrigates is extensive
and has deep soil. People—particularly the Aradians—sail up
the Lycus and the Jordan with merchandise. |
755 C, 14-19 As for the plains, the first (starting from the sea) is called 16.2.17
Posidonius (late 2nd–1st c. BCE) the “Macras,” or the “Plain of Macras.” This is where Posido- Macras, ?Buqeia plain (Syr.)
nius reports that a slain dragon was on view, its corpse nearly one
plethrum long and so bulky that horsemen standing on either side 1 plethrum = 100 ft.
of it could not see each other, its mouth gaping wide enough to admit
a man on horseback, each platelet of its scaly skin bigger than a
shield. |
755 C, 20-29 After the Macras is the Massyas, with some mountainous Massyas, Biqa' (Syr., Leb.) 16.2.18
parts in which is located Chalcis, something of an acropolis Chalcis, ?Husn esh-Shadur (Leb.)
for the Massyas. The plain starts with Laodicia-near-the- Laodicia-near-the-Libanus, Tell
Nebi Mend (Syr.)
Libanus. The whole of the mountainous region is occupied
by Ituraeans and Arabs, all of whom are troublemakers (while
the plains dwellers engage in agriculture and, harassed by the
former, need help of various kinds at various times). They They = Arabs, Ituraeans
and the fortress built on Theu Prosopum (Face of God)—places Gigarta, Zgharta, nr. Tripoli
(Leb.)
that Pompey razed to the ground. From these bases, they
Theu Prosopum, Ras Shaqqa
once used to descend on Byblus and Berytus (next to Byblus), (Leb.)
cities that are located between Sidon and Theu Prosopum.
755 C, 30–756 C, 4 Byblus, the royal residence of Cinyras, is sacred to Adonis. Byblus, Jebeil (Leb.)
Adonis river and Climax (Ladder) mountain and Palaebyblus Adonis, Nahr Ibrahim
(Old Byblus). Then comes the Lycus river and Berytus. This city Climax mountain, nr. Junie (Leb.)
was razed by Tryphon and has now been restored by the Ro- Lycus, Nahr el-Kelb
mans. The city accommodates two legions, positioned t here Berytus, Beirut (Leb.)
by Agrippa, who added to the city much of the Massyas as Massyas, Biqa' (Syr., Leb.)
far as the sources of the Orontes (which are near the Libanus,
Paradisus (Pleasure garden), and the Egyptian Fort in the area Paradisus, ?Jusiye (Syr.)
[ 1 ] Strabo perhaps conflates the “Chrysorrhoas” that flows from Damascus with a
different “Chrysorrhoas” (nr. Gerasa, Le Basi Jerash, Jor.). This may be a f actor
in his confusion of the Jordan valley (755 C, 6-13) with Coele Syria. For other
examples of name conflation in this region: 741 C, 25–742 C, 3n; 759 C, 9-18n;
760 C, 17-23n; 764 C, 29-31n; perhaps also 752 C, 31–753 C, 10n.
[ 2 ] Again (cf. 754 C, 28-32), Strabo gets ahead of himself. He later categorizes the
coastline from Byblus (Jebeil, Leb.) to Berytus (Beirut, Leb.) as part of Phoenicia:
756 C, 18-21.
862
Syria
756 C, 5-15 Inland from Massyas is what is called the “Royal Valley,” 16.2.20
the interior above this, between Gaza and the Antilibanus, as Pelusium, Tell el-Farama (Egy.)
stretch, there’s the Tamyras river, and the Grove of Asclepius Tamyras, Nahr ed-Damur
and Leonton Polis (Lion city). After Sidon comes Tyrus, the larg- Grove of Asclepius, Bustan esh-
Sheikh (Leb.)
est and oldest of the Phoenician cities, rivaling Sidon in size,
Tyrus, es-Sur (Leb.)
reputation, and antiquity (as betokened in many a myth).
Homer (8th c. BCE) Whereas the poets talk rather of Sidon, and Homer does not
mention Tyrus at all, Tyrus is praised by the colonies she sent
to Libya and to Iberia, even to the parts beyond the Pillars.7
756 C, 31–757 C, 16 Both were in antiquity—and are still now—cities of great
splendor and renown. In both, there is an argument as to
which should be called the Phoenician metropolis. Whereas
Sidon is located in a natural harbor on the mainland, | Tyrus Sidon, Saida (Leb.) 16.2.23
consists of an entire island, nearly all of which is treated as a Tyrus, es-Sur (Leb.)
single p olitical entity, in a manner similar to Aradus. It is con- Aradus, Rouad (Syr.)
[ 1 ] Meaning of “Coele”: 336 C, 33-36n. Strabo uses “Coele Syria” in the sense of the [ 3 ] Phoenicia (coast of Lebanon, Israel, Gaza, e. present-day Egypt): 756 C,
territory between the Libanus and Antilibanus (Syria, Lebanon) in the forego- 22–760 C, 10.
ing (754 C, 32–756 C, 15); he seems to use it in the broader sense, including the [ 4 ] Judaea (Israel, W. Bank, Jordan): 760 C, 17–765 C, 11.
territory (Israel, West Bank, Jordan, e. Egypt) toward “Egypt and Arabia,” e
arlier [ 5 ] “Coele Syria” in the specific sense: 756 C, 16-18n.
(133 C, 32–134 C, 2). Eratosthenes probably used the term “Coelosyrians” in the [ 6 ] Orthosia (Khan ard Artuşi, Leb.)–Berytus (Beirut, Leb.): 754 C, 28-32; 755,
broader sense, although Strabo may be unaware of this when citing him (741 C, 30–756 C, 4.
25–742 C, 3). T here often seems to be some ambiguity in Strabo’s usage: 765 C, [ 7 ] For Tyrian/Phoenician colonies in Libya (= Africa) and Iberia (Spain, Portugal):
12-21; 749 C, 14-21. 170 C, 20-30nn.
[ 2 ] I.e., what “remains” to be described of Syria as previewed at 749 C, 8-21.
863
4.2. Southern Asia
864
Syria
and then, near Tyrus, the outlet of a river. Thirty stades after
Tyrus, there’s Palaetyrus (Old Tyrus), | then comes the great city 16.2.25
of Ptolemaïs, formerly called “Ace,” used by the Persians as Ptolemaïs/Ace, Tell Acco (Isr.)
recorded in connection with this beach between Tyrus and Tyrus, es-Sur (Leb.)
Ptolemaïs. When the people of Ptolemaïs were defeated in Ptolemaïs/Ace, Tell Acco (Isr.)
this place, having joined battle against the general Sarpedon,
there was an utter rout, and a wave from the sea washed over
the fugitives like a flood tide. It carried some of the men out
to sea and caused their death. Some of the corpses stayed
in low-lying parts: the subsequent ebbing of the tide laid
things bare again and revealed men’s bodies scattered among
the dead fish. A similar event occurs near Egyptian Casium,
when the ground suffers a single sharp convulsion and experi-
ences a temporary shift in either direction, so that the raised
part loses the sea, and the lowered part gains it; then, when
it undergoes a reverse, the place reverts to its original state.
Sometimes the change is permanent but sometimes not. Per-
haps such activity is connected with certain cycles that are not
clear to us, as is said in the case of the Nile floodings, which
vary in nature but whose variations have no clear principle. |
758 C, 31–759 C, 9 After Ace comes Strato’s Tower, with its anchorage. In Strato’s Tower, Qesaria/ 16.2.27
Quaisariye (Isr.)
between are: Mount Carmel; towns of which there is nothing
Sycaminon Polis, Shiqmona, Tell other than the names—Sycaminon Polis (Mulberry city), Bouco- Boucolon City, 'Atlit (Isr.)
es Samak (Isr.)
lon City (Herdsman city), Crocodilon Polis (Crocodile city), and such-
Crocodilon Polis, Tell Tanninim/
Tell el Malat (Isr.) like; then a great forest. | Then there’s Iope, where the stretch great forest = Sharon (Isr.) 16.2.28
of coastline from Egypt makes a significant turn to the north Iope, Jaffa (Isr.)
[ 1 ] Strabo first visited Alexandria (Iskandariya, Egy.) in the early 20s BCE, and was
based t here for much of his life: 101 C, 14-24n; 117 C, 35–118 C, 14n.
[ 2 ] The comment on the low cost of crystalware in Rome is the result of Strabo’s
own observation. He appears to have recently revisited Rome at the time of
writing: 236 C, 13-22n.
865
4.2. Southern Asia
Judaeans), then Azotus and Ascalon. It is some two hundred Azotus, Tel Ashdod (Isr.)
stades from Iamnia to Azotus and Ascalon. The territory of Ascalon, Ashkelon (Isr.)
and lying seven stades inland is their city. The city was once city = Gaza, el Ghazze/Gaza
(Gaza)
splendid but was razed by Alexander and remains abandoned.
Alexander the G
reat, late 4th c.
From there, it is said to be a passage of one thousand two BCE
hundred and sixty stades to Aelana, a city at the head of the Aelana, Aqaba (Jor.)
Arabian gulf. The head of the gulf is forked, one gulf (called Arabian gulf, Red Sea
“Aelanites” after the city located on it) leading to the part Aelanites, Gulf of Aqaba/Eilat
in Arabia and Gaza, and the other gulf leading to the Egyp-
tian part at Heroon Polis, with the overland crossing from Heroon Polis = Gulf of Suez
nal settlers t here, men whose noses had been lopped off. A
certain Ethiopian,3 invading Egypt, did not kill malcontents
but instead cut off their noses and allowed them to settle
there, on the basis that their shameful aspect would prevent
them from being bold enough to cause further trouble. |
[ 1 ] Strabo conflates the Gadara (Umm Qeis, Jor.) that is the home of Philodemus,
etc., with the Gadara (Tell Jezer, Isr.) after which the region of Gadaris is named.
Strabo’s account of this area is rife with name conflation: 755 C, 9-13n.
[ 2 ] The expression “rhetorician of our times” could equally be translated as “our
rhetorician,” suggesting that Strabo in some sense follows Theodorus’s system
of public speaking. For competition between different systems of speaking:
625 C, 1-15. Cf. “our Zeno” (784 C, 20-30); “our philosophers” (753 C, 11-12n).
[ 3 ] I.e., an Ethiopian ruler (probably female): 770 C, 31–771 C, 4; 786 C, 15-19; 820 C,
15–821 C, 11.
866
Syria
759 C, 33–760 C, 10 The entire stretch of coast starting from Gaza is of poor 16.2.32
quality and sandy; and the stretch thereafter is even more so,
with lake Sirbonis, lying inland roughly parallel to the sea, Sirbonis, Sabkhat el Bardawil
(Egy.)
leaving a narrow passage between, as far as what is called
the “Ecregma” (Outlet), some two hundred stades in length
and with a maximum width of fifty. The Ecregma has been
blocked up. Then t here’s another contiguous stretch—the
stretch to Casium and thence to Pelusium—of the same qual- Casium, Ras Qasrun/Khatib el
Gals (Egy.)
ity. | Casium is a dry and sandy hill forming a promontory. It 16.2.33
Pelusium, Tell el-Farama (Egy.)
is where the body of Pompey Magnus (Pompey the Great) lies, and
there’s a temple to “Casian” Zeus; and nearby is where Mag-
nus was treacherously slaughtered by the Egyptians. Then
there’s the road to Pelusium, on which is situated Gerrha, and Gerrha, ?Tel Mahmudiyeh (Egy.)
Artemidorus (late 2nd–early thousand six hundred and fifty stades, if you hug the coast; from Orthosia, Khan ard Artuşi (Leb.)
1st c. BCE)
Cilician Melaena (or Melania), near Celenderis, to the border
between Cilicia and Syria, one thousand nine hundred; thence to the
Orontes, five hundred and twenty; then one thousand one hundred
and thirty to Orthosia.3 |
760 C, 17-23 The western end of Judaea toward Casium is occupied by Casium, Ras Qasrun/Khatib el 16.2.34
Gals (Egy.)
JUDAEA Idumaeans and by the lake.4 The Idumaeans are Nabataeans
Israel, West Bank, Jordan
who, driven out from there by civil strife, went over to the from there = from Nabataea
their customs = Nabataean Judaeans and imparted a share of their customs to those people. those people = Judaeans
customs
On the seaward side, much of it is occupied by Sirbonis5 and
by the territory contiguous with it as far as Jerusalem. (This,
too, is toward the sea: it has been said that it can be seen from
the seaport of Iope.)6 This is the northern side.
760 C, 23-31 There are many individual parts, inhabited by tribes of
mixed descent that are blended from the Egyptian, Arabian,
and Phoenician nations. Such are the inhabitants of Galilaea, Galilaea = Galilee (Isr.)
Hiericus, Philadelphia, and Samaria (whose name Herod Hiericus, Jericho (W. Bk.)
changed to “Sebasta”). Despite this mixing, the most widely Philadelphia, 'Amman (Jor.)
accepted of the credible reports about the temple in Jeru- Samaria/Sebasta, Sebastiya
(W. Bk.)
salem states that the progenitors of the p eople now called
“Judaean” w ere Egyptian. | For Moses, an Egyptian priest, 16.2.35
[ 1 ] 741 C, 25–742 C, 3nn. give Melaena as the terminus and to present its correct spelling; and possibly
[ 2 ] 756 C, 22–760 C, 10. to correct some of the distance figures. Strabo’s two separate citations of the
[ 3 ] Strabo cites the same passage from Artemidorus earlier (669 C, 32–670 C, 8n), same passage of Artemidorus well illustrate how free-form his citations can be.
for the same stretches of coast. In the e arlier citation, the stretches are listed Cf. 829 C, 1-11n.
in the order they appear for a sailor traveling anticlockwise around the Med. [ 4 ] Strabo has earlier (759 C, 33–760 C, 10) called this lake “Sirbonis” (Sabkhat el
Sea. Here, at 760 C, 11-16, after first giving the stretch from Pelusium to Orthosia, Bardawil, Egy.).
Strabo reverses the order for the stretches from Cilician Melaena to Orthosia, [ 5 ] Strabo now applies the name “Sirbonis” to a different lake (Dead Sea) (763 C,
listing them in the order in which they appear for a sailor traveling clockwise. 24-33). Strabo’s account of this region is rife with name conflation: 755 C, 9-13n.
Strabo’s second citation of Artemidorus may be intended to correct the im- [ 6 ] 758 C, 31–759 C, 9.
pression given e arlier that Artemidorus uses Celenderis as the terminus; to
867
4.2. Southern Asia
there = Egypt with the situation, left there and came here; and many wor- here = Judaea
pict divinity with images of wild and domesticated animals, nor are
the Libyans, nor are the Greeks correct in giving divinity a h uman
form. For “god” is one thing alone, including all of us people and the
land and the sea, what we call “heaven” and “cosmos” and “physical
reality.” What sensible man would dare to make of this an image
resembling anything with which we are familiar? People should leave
image making b ehind. Marking out a precinct with an important
inner sanctum, they should engage in worship without the help of a
statue; rather, they should spend the night t here on their own behalf
(and other men with auspicious dreams should spend the night there
on behalf of o thers). Men who live in an upright and just manner
should always expect to receive a blessing from god and a gift—always
at least a sign—but o thers should not expect it. |
761 C, 9-17 With such statements, this fellow won over not a few men this fellow = Moses 16.2.36
of good sense and led them away to the place where currently
Jerusalem is located. He took this place easily, as it was not
a desirable spot nor one that anyone would be keen to fight
over, given that it is rocky and, although itself well supplied
with water, has poor and waterless territory on its perim-
eter and, within that for a distance of sixty stades, a rocky
substratum. At the same time, he relied for defense not on
weapons but on sacraments and divine power, believing that
it was worth seeking out a place for this and promising that
he would deliver the type of worship and sacramental ritual
that does not trouble its practitioners with high costs, divine
frenzies, or other weird things.
761 C, 18-30 This fellow was well regarded, and he established for his This fellow = Moses
stayed the course for a while, acting honestly and being god-
fearing in the true sense of the word. Then the priesthood
was assumed, at first by men who were overly fearful of god,
then by men who were tyrannical. Out of fear of god, there
arose abstinences from foods that are still the custom today;
male and female circumcision; and other such customs. Out
of tyranny, t here arose bands of robbers. Some men seceded
868
Syria
869
4.2. Southern Asia
870
Syria
[ 1 ] 316, 20-30.
871
4.2. Southern Asia
764 C, 18-27 Many other proofs of the territory’s vulcanicity are ad- 16.2.44
drops of pitch that trickle down smooth rock faces, the bad
odor of rivers detectable from far away, the buildings here
and t here that have been upended. In consequence, people
believe the local gossip, that thirteen cities t here w ere once
inhabited; the metropolis of these was Sodom, and the area
centered on it was preserved for a distance of sixty stades or
so; because of earthquakes, and volcanic eruptions of fire
and hot, asphalt-bearing, sulfurous w aters, the lake burst
its bounds, rocks w ere vulcanized, and as for the cities, some
were engulfed, although people escaped from others if they
had the capacity to flee.
764 C, 27-29 Eratosthenes says, in contrast, that the territory, having been
Eratosthenes (3rd c. BCE) covered by water, was laid bare for the most part by a Thessalian-style
outrush of water.1 |
764 C, 29-31 In Gadaris, also, the lake water is foul: 2 livestock that drink 16.2.45
[ 1 ] The theory was that the Thessalian plain (Greece) had been covered by an
inland sea, which then broke through the surrounding mountains, causing an
outrush of water and exposing what had previously been the seabed: 430 C,
9-15.
[ 2 ] “Gadaris” may h ere be the territory of Gadara (Umm Qeis, Jor.), in which case
the lake water to which Strabo refers is that of Gennesaritis (Sea of Galilee),
mentioned by Strabo earlier (755 C, 6-9). For Strabo’s conflation of two places
called “Gadara”: 759 C, 9-18n. There is a third “Gadara” (Tell Jadur, Jor.) north
of the Dead Sea. If Strabo’s “Gadaris” h ere refers to this third Gadara, the lake
water to which he refers may be that of the Dead Sea.
[ 3 ] The “lake” to which Strabo here refers is Gennesaritis (Sea of Galilee).
872
Arabia
765 C, 12-21 Above Judaea and Coele Syria,1 to the south as far as Babylonia 16.3.1
gulf; its southern side by the great sea outside these two gulfs, Erythra, Arabian Sea/Indian
called in its entirety the “Erythra.” | Ocean
nia), it is possible to see the promontory among the Macaeans (part Macaeans (part of Arabia), UAE,
Oman
RIGHT-HAND (NE.) COAST OF of Arabia). From the mouth, the right-hand coastline—being
PERSIAN GULF
Iran curved—initially heads slightly eastward from Carmania,
then northward and, a fter that, westward, as far as Teredon
and the outflow of the Euphrates. It includes the coastlines outflow of Euphrates, s. Iraq
[ 1 ] For the meaning of “Coele”: 336 C, 33-36n. For “Coele Syria”: 756 C, 16-18n.
[ 2 ] Strabo’s concept of Arabia is based on Eratosthenes’s 4th sphragis: 85 C, 6-13.
[ 3 ] Scenitae (Tent-dwellers) in Mesopotamia (e. Syria, se. Turkey, n. Iraq): 747 C,
24–748 C, 24.
[ 4 ] 746 C, 14–748 C, 19.
[ 5 ] 739 C, 9-28 (esp. 739 C, 12-14).
[ 6 ] Scenitae (Tent-dwelling) Arabs west of Euphrates (cen. Syria): 748 C, 20-24;
749 C, 8-13; 753 C, 13-19.
[ 7 ] 765 C, 29–766 C, 36.
[ 8 ] Origin of present-day name “Straits of Hormuz” (Iran, Oman).
[ 9 ] 726 C, 18–744 C, 9.
873
4.2. Southern Asia
account. It is consequently clear that this sea is only slightly this sea = Persian Gulf
766 C, 6-19 He says that this individual, who sailed with a fleet around the this individual = Androsthenes
Eratosthenes cites coast of the gulf, claims that, “as you voyage onward from Teredon
Androsthenes (late 4th c. BCE)
with the mainland on your right, you come to an island—Icarus—off Icarus (island), Failaka (Kuwaiti
island)
the coast and on the island a t emple sacred to Apollo and an oracle
oracle, center for divine
ARABIAN COAST OF belonging to Tauropolus.” | After coasting along Arabia for a prophecy
16.3.3
PERSIAN GULF
s. Iraq, Kuwait, Saudi Arabia, distance of two thousand four hundred stades, you reach, in
Bahrain, Qatar, UAE + Oman a deep bay, the city of Gerrha, consisting of Chaldaean refu- deep bay, ?Jubayl Harbor
(Saud.)
gees from Babylon. Their land is salty, and their houses are
Gerrha, ?Thaj (Saud.)
made of salt. Since the burning heat of the sun c auses flakes
of salt continually to peel off their h ouses, they frequently
sprinkle the houses with water to keep the walls intact. The
city is two hundred stades from the sea. The Gerrhaeans trade
Aristobulus (late 4th c. BCE) in Arabian goods, largely overland, although Aristobulus says
the opposite: the Gerrhaeans conduct much of their trade by raft
Thapsacus, uncertain point on
to Babylonia, and convey their wares from t here up the Euphrates to Euphrates r. (in present-day
Thapsacus; then head off overland in all directions to trade them. | Syr.)
766 C, 20-24 As you sail farther on, there are other islands—Tyrus and Tyrus (island), Bahrain 16.3.4
Aradus—which have temples similar to Phoenician ones. The Aradus (island), Muharraq
(Bahraini island)
inhabitants of the islands claim that the Phoenician islands
and cities of the same name were colonized by them!1 These
islands are a ten-day sail from Teredon and a one-day sail Macaean headland, Ras
from the headland among the Macaeans at the mouth. | Musandam (Oman)
766 C, 25-32 Nearchus and Orthagoras state that lying out to sea, two thou- 16.3.5
Nearchus, Orthagoras sand stades south of Carmania, is the island of Tyrina, on which a huge
(late 4th c. BCE)
mound, planted with wild date palms, is identified as the tomb of Ery-
thras; this man was the king of the region and left the sea named a fter
He = Eratosthenes him. He says, these things were explained to them by Mithropastes (son
of Arsites, the satrap of Phrygia), who, having fled from Darius, lingered Darius, king of Persia (late 4th c.
BCE), defeated by Alexander
a long time on the island and, having met with them when they sailed
into the Persian gulf, requested that they give him passage back home. |
766 C, 33-36 All along the Erythran shore, trees grow on the seabed. Erythran shore = coast of Persian 16.3.6
Gulf, Arabian Sea
Similar to laurel trees and olive trees, they are wholly visible
at low tide, while at high tide they are at times completely
covered—even though the mainland has no trees, which
makes it all the more peculiar.
767 C, 1-2 The foregoing, then, is what Eratosthenes said about
the Persian gulf,2 which, as I said, forms the eastern side of
Blessed Arabia.3 |
[ 1 ] Phoenician Tyrus (es-Sur, Leb.): 756 C, 22–757 C, 16. Phoenician Aradus (Rouad,
Syr.): 753 C, 29–754 C, 27. Cf. 42 C, 24-33n; 784 C, 12-20n.
[ 2 ] 765 C, 29–766 C, 36.
[ 3 ] 765 C, 21-26.
874
Arabia
767 C, 3-14 Nearchus says that Mithropastes met up with them in the com 16.3.7
Nearchus (late 4th c. BCE) pany of Mazenes;1 Mazenes was the ruler of one of the islands in the
Persian gulf; the island was called “Doracta”; Mithropastes fled to Doracta, ?Queshm (Iranian
island)
this island and was treated as a guest there a fter his departure from
Ogyrus; he accompanied Mazenes with a view to joining up with the
Macedonian fleet; Mazenes also became the navigator for the voy-
age.2 He says, too, that, at the start of the voyage along the Persian He = Nearchus
marked by Mesene. From this territory, the Arabian des- Mesene, s. Iraq
ert stretches out in one direction; in another direction are Chaldaean marshes, s. Iraq,
the Chaldaean marshes, created from the overflow of the Kuwait
Polis (i.e., the recess of the Arabian gulf near the Nile) to Nabataean Heroon Polis, Gulf of Suez
Petra is . . . * stades, and from Petra to Babylon is five thousand Nabataean Petra, Wadi Musa
(Jor.)
six hundred [stades], all of it in the direction of the summer sunrise,
summer sunrise = northeast
through a series of Arabic nations—the Nabataeans, Chaulotaeans,
and Agraeans.
767 C, 31–768 C, 6 Above these is the Blessed, stretching out twelve thou-
BLESSED ARABIA sand stades southward to the Atlantic sea. The first to oc- Atlantic sea = Indian Ocean
Saudi Arabia, s. Jordan,
Oman, Yemen
cupy it, coming a fter the Syrians and Judaeans, are p eople
who practice agriculture. After them, the soil becomes sandy
and poor, with a few date palms, the prickly-thorn, and the
tamarisk; water is from wells, as in Gedrosia; and the territory
[ 1 ] The following version of the Mithropastes story differs from the one just given
(766 C, 25-32). The latter is part of a section of narrative (765 C, 27–766 C, 36)
derived from Eratosthenes. It is possible that Strabo is now directly citating
Nearchus, in order to correct Eratosthenes’s mis-citation of “Nearchus and
Orthagoras” (766 C, 25-32). The loss of the relevant works by Eratosthenes,
Nearchus, and Orthagoras makes verification impossible.
[ 2 ] Macedonian use of local navigators: 725 C, 22-32; 732 C, 2-6.
[ 3 ] A causia is a type of Macedonian hat, presumably used as a volume measure.
[ 4 ] 767 C, 22–769 C, 19.
[ 5 ] For the meaning of “Coele”: 336 C, 33-36n. “Coele Syria” has two senses: 756 C,
16-18n.
875
4.2. Southern Asia
these are the Sabaeans, whose metropolis is Mariaba. Third Carna, Qarnawu (Yem.)
are the Cattabanians, who extend to the strait and the cross- Mariaba, Ma'rib (Yem.)
ing point of the Arabian gulf; their royal capital is called
“Tamna.” Farthest east are the Chatramotitans, and their city Tamna, Hajar Kuhlan (Yem.)
is Sabata. | All the cities are ruled by a monarch and blessed Sabata, Shabwah (Yem.) 16.4.3
[ 1 ] 759 C, 19-27.
876
Arabia
TROGODYTE COAST site Deira, is called “Acila”; t hose living around Deira are “colobi” 6 Acila, Khor Ghurayrah (Yem.)
Red Sea coast of Egypt, Sudan,
(mutilated) at the tip of the penis. If you sail from Heroon Polis along Heroon Polis = Gulf of Suez
Eritrea + coast of Djibouti and
Somalia the Trogodyte coast, you come to the city of “Philotera,” named after
the sister of Ptolemy the second and founded by Satyrus, who was sent
Artemidorus (late 2nd–early to explore the Elephant Hunt and Trogodyte country; then to another
1st c. BCE) Arsinoe, Kum el-Qolzum/Suez
city, Arsinoe; then to streams of hot, bitter, salty water, descending (Egy.)
from a high cliff and flowing into the sea (and nearby t here’s a Myus Hormus/Aphrodite
mountain, Miltodes, in a plain); then to Myus Hormus (Mouse Harbor, ?Quseir al-Qadim (Egy.)
877
4.2. Southern Asia
770 C, 3-13 After this bay comes an island, called “Ophiodes (Snaky) Is- Ophiodes Island, Jazirat 16.4.6
Zabarjad (Egy.)
land” because of the facts of the matter. The king freed the
island of snakes, both b ecause of the harm done by the l ittle
beasts to sailors when they anchored there and because of the
topaz. Topaz is a translucent gemstone that sparkles with a
golden light, difficult to see by day (when it is outshone) but
visible at night by those who gather it—marking it with an
upturned bowl, they dig it up during the day. T here used to be
a body of people appointed to the job of guarding and gath-
ering t hese gems, maintained at the expense of the Egyptian
sovereigns. | After this island, there are many tribes of ichthy- 16.4.7
ophagi (fish-eaters) and nomads; then Sotira (Deliverance) Harbor, Sotira Harbor, ?Port
Sudan/?Suakin (Sud.)
which certain leaders named thus after the facts of the matter,
when they w ere saved from great danger.
770 C, 13-27 After these, there’s a major change in the coastline and
bay: the coast that you sail along is no longer rough, and it
almost connects with Arabia; the sea is as l ittle as two orguiae 1 orguia = 6 ft.
deep, and its surface is grassy, and seaweed and sea wrack are
visible through it; this is even more the case in the channel,
where trees grow under the water among the plants there.
The channel also has a large number of sea dogs. Then come
the Tauri (Bulls), two mountains that, from a distance, look
like those animals; then another mountain with a temple
dedicated to Isis, one of Sesostris’s replicas; 2 then an island,
olive trees = mangroves flooded by the sea and full of olive trees; after the island,
Ptolemaïs-by-the-Elephant-Hunt, founded by Eumedes, Ptolemaïs, ?Aqiq/?Trinkitat
(Sud.)
who was sent by Philadelphus on a mission to the Hunt and
Ptolemy Philadelphus ruled
clandestinely enclosed a peninsula with a ditch and a wall, Egypt, 283/282–246 BCE
then courted t hose who objected and made them into friends
rather than enemies. | In between is the outflow of one branch 16.4.8
of the river called “Astaboras,” which starts in a lake and flows Astaboras, Atbara r.
along one branch out to sea and along the other into the Nile.
[ 1 ] The word translated as “mouse” can also mean a type of shellfish or fish.
[ 2 ] Replicas—attributed to Sesostris—of Egyptian temples: 769 C, 1-7.
878
Arabia
770 C, 27-31 Then there are six islands called the “Latomiae”; after
that, what is known as the “Sabaitic” mouth; inland, a for-
tress, founded by Tosuchus; then a harbor called “Elaea” and
Strato’s Island; then a harbor, Saba, and an elephant-hunting
ground of the same name.
770 C, 31–771 C, 4 The territory deep inland from these is called “Tenessis.”
It is occupied by the Egyptians exiled by Psammetichus and
known as Sembritae (which means “Outsiders”). They are
ruled by a woman, to whom Meroe (an island near to these Meroe, region of Bagrawiya
(Sud.)
places, in the Nile) is also subject. Above this (not far away)
is another island in the river, a settlement of these same fugi-
tives. The journey from Meroe to this sea takes fifteen days
for a well-equipped person.
771 C, 5-12 In the Meroe region, the Nile is joined by the Astaboras, Astaboras, Atbara r.
the Astapus, and also by the Astasobas. | Living along these Astapus, White Nile/Bahr el 16.4.9
Abiad
rivers are the rhizophagi (root-eaters) and heliae (marsh-people), so
Astasobas, Blue Nile/Bahr el
called because they cut roots from the marsh alongside them, Azraq
pound them with stones, and form them into patties, which
they bake in the sun and then eat. These locations act as feed-
ing grounds for lions. In the days coinciding with the rising of
the Dog Star,1 the lions are driven out of these places by large
mosquitoes. Nearby are the spermophagi (seed-eaters), who, when
seeds are not available, live off acorns, which they prepare in
the same way as the rhizophagi prepare roots.
771 C, 13-21 After Elaea come the “Lookouts of Demetrius” and the
“Altars of Conon.” In the interior, a g reat quantity of Indian Indian reed = bamboo
[ 1 ] The “rising of the Dog Star” denotes July: 691 C, 34–692 C, 9n.
879
4.2. Southern Asia
cunamolgi (dog-milkers), who, with their long hair and beards, are
called by the locals agrii (savages). They rear dogs of quite some
size and use them to hunt the Indian c attle, which, impelled
by wild beasts or lack of pasture, come from the neighboring
territory. The c attle arrive from the summer solstice u ntil the
middle of winter.
771 C, 31–772 C, 11 Next a fter Antiphilus’s Harbor comes a harbor called
the “Grove of the colobi (mutilated ones)”;2 the Sabaean city of
Berenice; Sabae, a considerable city; then Eumenes’s Grove. Sabae, ?Assab (Eritrea)
880
Arabia
for clothing and lie u nder them as blankets. The Simi (Snub-
nosed), as they are called—Ethiopians who use oryx horns as
lies and let it smolder, for a short time . . . *; for the locusts, as Zephyrs, west winds
they fly over the smoke, are blinded and fall down. The people
chop the locusts up and mix them with salt to form patties,
which they eat. Inland from t hese p eople is a large desolate
region. Although rich in pasture, it was deserted because of
the huge number of scorpions and venomous spiders, called
tetragnatha (four-jaws), that at one time overran the place and
resulted in its complete depopulation. |
772 C, 32–773 C, 4 The stretch from Eumenes’s Harbor to Deira and to the Deira, Ras Siyan (Djib.) 16.4.13
881
4.2. Southern Asia
882
Arabia
no longer have any record of the harbors and places b ecause noth-
ing is known . . . * | There are both stone tablets and altars to 16.4.15
the same height, judging from the one observed by me.2 Nor
is it the case that its skin is the color of boxwood, but rather it is
the same color as an elephant.
774 C, 30–775 C, 2 It is the size of a bull, but in shape it most closely resembles It = rhino
883
4.2. Southern Asia
with the face of a lion but with the body of a leopard and the size of
a gazelle,1 and bulls that are undomesticated and carnivorous, sur-
passing our bulls in size and swiftness, and with a yellowish-red hide.
There’s the hyena, a wolf-dog hybrid according to this fellow.
Metrodorus (2nd–1st c. BCE) (What is said by Metrodorus of Scepsis in his book On Custom
is mythical and is not to be believed of them.) Artemidorus
mentions monstrous snakes thirty cubits long, which overpower el- 1 cubit = 1.5 ft.
884
Arabia
ARABIAN COAST following on from Posidium, there’s a date-palm grove with a good Aelanites recess, Gulf of Aqaba/
Red Sea coast of Sinai, s. Israel, Eilat
Jordan, Saudi Arabia, Yemen supply of water; the grove is highly revered, owing to the fact that
all around is hot and lacks water and shade; the grove produces a
marvelous crop of dates. In charge of the grove are a man and a
woman appointed by descent, clad in skins, living on dates.
They build a hut in the trees and sleep there, b ecause of the
hordes of wild animals.
776 C, 28–777 C, 3 Next comes Phocon Island (Seal island), named after the huge Phocon Island, ?Tiran (Saudi
island)
numbers of those creatures. Near this island is a promon-
promontory, ?Ras Mohammed
tory stretching toward Petra (belonging to the Arabs called (Sinai)
“Nabataean”) and toward Palestinian territory, into which Petra, Wadi Musa (Jor.)
territory the Minaeans, the Gerrhaeans, and all their neigh-
bors send cargoes of spices. Then there’s the rest of the coast-
line, which was previously called “of the Maranites” (some of
whom engaged in agriculture, o thers of whom lived in tents)
but is now called “of the Garindaeans,” who treacherously de-
They = Garindaeans, uncertain
stroyed the former. They attacked them as they celebrated location on Sinai Peninsula
some quinquennial festival,3 killing them and shamelessly them = Maranites, uncertain
location on Sinai Peninsula
mistreating the other attendees.
Aelanites gulf, Gulf of Aqaba/
777 C, 4-15 Then there’s the Aelanites gulf; and Nabataea, a populous Eilat
territory, rich in pasture. The p eople also live on islands near
Nabataea, s. Israel, Jordan,
the shore. They were formerly peaceable, but then they took Saudi Arabia
885
4.2. Southern Asia
886
Arabia
the Sabaeans, a very g reat nation. They have myrrh, frankin- Sabaeans, s. Yemen
887
4.2. Southern Asia
778 C, 33–779 C, 14 In other matters, he says some things that are similar to he = Artemidorus
NABATAEA Blessed Arabia above Syria. They used to make frequent in-
Jordan, s. Israel, Saudi Arabia
cursions into Syria before the advent of the Romans. Now,
they (and the Syrians) are subject to the Romans.2
779 C, 21-27 The Nabataean metropolis is called “Petra” (Rock): the spot Petra, Wadi Musa (Jor.)
888
Arabia
other foreigners staying t here and noticed that the foreigners engaged
in frequent lawsuits against each other and against the locals, but
that none of the locals laid charges against each other, living instead
in total harmony with one another. |
780 C, 1-11 We learn a great deal about the distinctive characteris- 16.4.22
dicrota, triremes, and phaseli at Cleopatris, on the ancient canal dicrota, ships with two banks of
oarsmen
from the Nile. Realizing that he had been tricked, he built
triremes, ships with three banks
one hundred and thirty transport carriers, on which he set of oarsmen
sail with around ten thousand foot soldiers—Romans from phaseli, lightweight ships
Egypt and allies, among whom w ere five hundred Judaeans Cleopatris, Kum el-Qolzum/
and one thousand Nabataeans, who accompanied Syllaeus. Suez (Egy.)
889
4.2. Southern Asia
780 C, 29–781 C, 11 On the fifteenth day, after great hardship and suffering, he
arrived at the g reat trading center of Leuca Coma, in Naba- Leuca Coma, ?Aynunah (Saud.)
taean country. He had lost many ships, some with crew, owing
to the difficulties of the voyage rather than encounters with
the e nemy. This was the result of the treachery of Syllaeus,
who said, “there was no overland route by which an army
would reach Leuca Coma”—although camel traders travel
safely and without problem, out of and into Leuca Coma, on
their way to Petra and back, with such a multitude of men Petra, Wadi Musa (Jor.)
and camels that they differ little from an army. | These t hings 16.4.24
came to pass because the king, Obodas, paid little attention Obodas ruled Nabataea,
30–9 BCE
to affairs of state, especially military affairs—a characteristic
common among all Arab kings—but entrusted everything to
the . . . * of his administrator, Syllaeus; and because this man this man = Syllaeus
afflicted by the local ailments of stomacaca (mouth-disease) and Leuca Coma, ?Aynunah (Saud.)
890
Arabia
the territory, which supplied him with grains, a few dates, and
butter instead of olive oil.
781 C, 29–782 C, 8 The next country he came to belonged to nomads, and he = Gallus
much of it was true desert: it was called “Ararene,” and Sabos Ararene, Saudi Arabia, Yemen
was its king. B ecause of its lack of roads, he spent fifty days
traversing it, until he reached the city of Agrana and a ter-
ritory that was both peaceable and prosperous. The king
fled, and the city succumbed to assault. Six days from t here,
he came to the . . . * river. The natives fought a battle t here.
Around ten thousand of them (and two Romans) fell; being
truly unwarlike, they w ere inexperienced in the use of their
weapons—bows and arrows, spears, swords, and slings—and
most of them used two-headed axes. He immediately took the He = Gallus
city called “Asca,” which was abandoned by the king. From Asca, al-Bayda’ in Jawf (Yem.)
there, he came to the city of Athrula, conquering it without a Athrula, Baraqish (Yem.)
Myus Hormus on the eleventh day. Then, crossing over the Myus Hormus, ?Quseir el-
Qadim (Egy.)
pass to Coptus along with t hose who could benefit from
Coptus, Qift (Egy.)
Alexandria, Iskandariya (Egy.) being helped, he ended his voyage at Alexandria. He lost the
891
4.2. Southern Asia
[ 1 ] Strabo adds to his previous statements (768 C, 7-26, where he never actually
calls the territory in question “Aromatophorus”). For a different “Aromatopho-
rus”: 773 C, 29–774 C, 5n.
892
Arabia
staff like it; once, when all the brothers happened to be in the
marketplace, one of them approached her door and saw the
staff; from that, he surmised that someone was with her, but
since all the brothers w ere in the marketplace, he suspected
an adulterer; running to his father and dragging him along,
he was shown to have falsely accused his sister! |
783 C, 23–784 C, 2 The Nabataeans are prudent, and so acquisitive that the 16.4.26
poet = Homer (8th c. BCE) and the Erembians, t here is controversy as to whether one
should understand by “Sidonians” certain inhabitants of
the Persian gulf, from whom “our” Sidonians are colonists “our” Sidonians = inhabitants of
Sidon, Saida (Leb.)
(just as p
eople record that certain “Tyrians” and “Aradians”
were inhabitants of the islands there, and say that our own there = in Persian Gulf
893
4.2. Southern Asia
Zeno (4th–3rd c. BCE) and Arabs. Posidonius writes (more compellingly, and with less
Posidonius (late 2nd–1st c.
BCE) suggest emendations to
textual alteration) the Sidonians and the Arambians, on the
Homer’s Odyssey (8th c. BCE) grounds that the poet used this name for the p eople now
called “ Arabs,” as did others of his time. He says that the three
nations situated here, one a fter the other, display kinship with each
other and are therefore called by the related names “Armenians,”
“Aramaeans,” and “Arambians.” Just as it is possible to suppose that
there was a division into three nations from one nation, in accordance
with the gradations of climata, which successively change, so they use
several names instead of one name. Those who write Eremnians
(Blacks) are not compelling, since that is more appropriate for
785 C, 13-19 In traversing Arabia, I included the Persian and Arabian gulfs, Arabian gulf, Red Sea 17.1.1
[ 1 ] Strabo earlier mentions speculation that Mediterranean Tyrus (es-Sur, Leb.) and
Aradus (Rouad, Syr.) were colonies from Tyrus (Bahrain) and Aradus (Muharraq,
Bah.) in the Persian gulf (766 C, 20-24).
[ 2 ] Strabo seems to suggest (here, and earlier, at 42 C, 2-9) that the spelling “Trog-
lodyte” arose from a desire to identify t hese people semantically with Homer’s
Erembians. See 42 C, 2-9n.
[ 3 ] 741 C, 1-24.
894
Nile Region
Strabo segues from his necessary to deal with the remaining region,2 which is con-
description of Arabia to his
description of the Nile region tiguous with these nations—namely, the Nile region. I will
tackle Libya later,3 which is what remains of my description
of the entire world.4 |
785 C, 20–786 C, 9 We must here lay out the statements made by Eratosthenes.5 17.1.2
Eratosthenes (3rd c. BCE) He says that the Nile is nine hundred, or a thousand, stades west of
the Arabian gulf; it is similar in its morphology to a reversed letter Arabian gulf, Red Sea
“N.” For, he says, it flows from Meroe northward for approximately Meroe, Bagrawiya (Sud.)
two thousand seven hundred stades; then it turns and heads south and
southwest for approximately three thousand seven hundred stades;
when it is virtually opposite the Meroe region6 and well into Libya, it
makes another turn northward and flows for five thousand three hun-
dred stades to the Great Cataract (swerving slightly eastward), then Great Cataract, in Sudan
one thousand two hundred stades to the Lesser Cataract at Syene, Lesser Cataract at Syene, Aswan
(Egy.)
then the remaining five thousand three hundred stades to the sea.
786 C, 9-15 The Nile is joined by two rivers, flowing from certain lakes
certain lakes in the east, ?Tana l. in the east and enclosing the huge island of Meroe. The river island of Meroe = region of
(present-day Ethiopia) Bagrawiya (Sud.)
on the eastern side is called the “Astaboras”; the other river is
Astaboras, Atbara r.
called the “Astapus.” But some people call it the “Astasobas,”7
Astapus/Astasobas, Blue Nile/
claiming that the Astapus is a separate river, flowing out of Bahr el Azraq
certain lakes in the south, certain lakes in the south, and that it pretty much forms the Astapus, White Nile/ Bahr el
?Albert l. (Uganda, DRC)/
?Victoria l. (Uganda, Kenya, straight-line shape of the Nile,8 and that the summer rains Abiad
Tanzania) cause this river to flood.
786 C, 15-19 Seven hundred stades above the juncture of the Astaboras and city of Meroe, Bagrawiya (Sud.)
Strabo continues his citation of the Nile, there’s the city of Meroe, having the same name as the is-
Eratosthenes (3rd c. BCE)
land. There’s a second island above Meroe, inhabited by the Egyp-
tian fugitives who rebelled from Psammetichus. These p eople are
called Sembritae, which means “Outsiders.” They are ruled by
aw oman and are subject to those in Meroe.9
786 C, 19-26 As for the stretch farther downstream from Meroe on
side of Nile toward
either bank, on the one hand, along the side of the Nile Erythra = side toward Red Sea;
toward the Erythra, there are Megabarians and Blemmyans, i.e., on e. bank of Nile
[ 1 ] Trogodytes and Cinnamonland: 768 C, 27–776 C, 17. [ 5 ] Strabo’s account of the Nile region, like his account of Ethiopia, is based on
[ 2 ] I.e., the region “remaining” to complete Strabo’s description of s. Asia, as out- Eratosthenes’s 4th sphragis: 85 C, 6-13.
lined at 685 C, 6-10, and of the land west of the Euphrates, as outlined at 736 C, [ 6 ] The sense is “when it is as far south again as the parallel that runs through the
13–737 C, 2. Meroe region.”
[ 3 ] Libya (= Africa): 824 C, 26–839 C, 9 (chap. 5). [ 7 ] Including Strabo: 771 C, 5-12; 821 C, 26–822 C, 3.
[ 4 ] I.e., what “remains” of Strabo’s description of the entire world, as outlined at [ 8 ] For the importance of this straight line in determining the shape of Libya
126 C, 24–131 C, 26. (= Africa): 825 C, 5-10.
[ 9 ] I.e., queens of Meroe (770 C, 31–771 C, 4).
895
4.2. Southern Asia
Eratosthenes (3rd c. BCE) on, in the first place as concerns the region of Egypt, so that I
can proceed from what is better known to what comes next.2
786 C, 30–787, 5 The Nile produces the same effects in this territory and in this territory = Egypt
896
Nile Region
[ 1 ] 757 C, 16-27.
[ 2 ] 1 cubit = 1.5 ft. The cubit used in this particular calculation may, however, have
been the Egyptian cubit (10–15% larger than the Greek cubit).
[ 3 ] 787 C, 12–788 C, 9.
897
4.2. Southern Asia
Plato (late 5th–4th c. BCE) as Plato says, meaning that it makes this place function as the
apex of a triangle; it makes the two streams that result from
the split (flowing on e ither side down to the sea—the right-
hand branch to the sea at Pelusium, the left-hand branch to Pelusium, Tell el-Farama (Egy.)
898
Nile Region
diversion that w aters the Arsinoite District and the lake of lake of Moeris, Birket Qarun (Egy.)
Moeris, and in the case of those that feed into the Mareotis). Mareotis, Mariout l. (Egy.)
789 C, 13-22 In short, only the riverland on e ither side of the Nile is
“Egypt”: it spreads out only rarely as much as three hundred
stades, in terms of its continuously inhabited width, start-
ing from the Ethiopian border up to the apex of the Delta. It
has been likened—if one ignores its longer diversions—to a
swaddling band . . . * lengthwise. The shape of the aforemen-
tioned riverland, and its territory, is the result of the moun-
tain ranges on e ither side that stretch from the Syene region Syene, Aswan (Egy.)
to the Egyptian sea. T hese ranges approach and recede from Egyptian sea = Med. Sea
each other, and proportionally the river narrows and expands,
creating variations in the shape of the inhabitable territory.
The territory beyond the mountains is uninhabited for a g reat
distance. |
789 C, 23-32 Men of ancient times surmised largely through conjecture, 17.1.5
sent t here to hunt elephants—or w hatever e lse impelled the Cinnamonland, Somalia
Ptolemaic kings of Egypt to dispatch men thither. Such were
the matters that these kings pondered, particularly the one
surnamed “Philadelphus,” who loved intellectual inquiry and
who, on account of his bodily infirmity, was always looking for
new and p leasurable pastimes.
789 C, 32–790 C, 8 The kings of olden times did not concern themselves at all
with such matters, although both they and the priests with
whom they spent most of their lives were addicted to wis-
dom. This is surprising not only for the reason stated but also
because Sesostris invaded the whole of Ethiopia as far as Cin-
namonland: stone tablets and inscriptions are pointed out
to this day as commemorations of his campaign. Also, Cam
byses occupied Egypt and proceeded as far as Meroe with the
Egyptians. It is said that he gave, to both island and city, its Meroe city, Bagrawiya (Sud.)
name, since “Meroe”—his sister or, according to others, his Meroe island = region along
Nile between Atbara r. and Blue
wife—died there. To honor the woman, he favored it with Nile/Bahr el Azraq
her name.
899
4.2. Southern Asia
790 C, 9-21 It is therefore surprising, given this background, that the rain
theory was not perfectly obvious to men of that time, especially
when the priests w ere rather zealous in recording in their sacred
writings and handing down to posterity evidence of their very
advanced learning! If anything, the question to be asked (and
still asked, even now) was why the rains fall in the summer and
not in the winter, and why they fall in the southernmost parts
and not in the Thebaïs and the Syene region. It was necessary
neither to ask w hether the flooding was the result of rainfall nor
Posidonius (late 2nd–1st c. BCE) to list witnesses, as Posidonius does. He claims that Callisthenes
cites Callisthenes (late 4th c.
BCE), who cites Aristotle (4th c. says that the cause is the summer rains, Callisthenes using Aristotle as
BCE), who cites Thrasyalces his source, Aristotle using Thrasyalces of Thasos (one of the ancient
(?5th c. BCE), who cites an
unnamed source, who cites physicists), Thrasyalces using someone e lse, that person using Homer,
Homer (8th c. BCE)
who calls the Nile “heaven-fed,” in “back to Egypt, heaven-fed river.”
790 C, 22-28 Let me, however, leave t hese m atters aside, as they have
been discussed by many men. It will suffice to mention only
Eudorus, Ariston (?1st c. BCE) two of them, Eudorus and Ariston the Peripatetic, who both
wrote, in our times, the book On the Nile. Apart from the struc-
ture, everything else they say is the same in terms of style and
argument. (I, not having access to their mutual allegations of
copying, compared one work with the other. Which one passed
the other’s work off as his own? You would find the answer in
Ammon’s temple! Eudorus blamed Ariston, but the style was
rather Aristonian.)
790 C, 29–791 C, 9 Men of ancient times gave the name “Egypt” only to the
part that was inhabited and that was irrigated by the Nile,
making it start in the region of Syene and g oing to the coast. Syene, Aswan (Egy.)
Men of more recent times (up u ntil the present day) included,
on the eastern side, nearly everything between the Arabian Arabian gulf/Erythran sea,
Red Sea
gulf and the Nile1 (the Ethiopians make no use of the Ery-
thran sea); on the western side, the regions as far as the oases
and, on the coast, the area from the Canobic mouth to Cata- Catabathmus, Sollum (Egy.)
900
Nile Region
is some one thousand three hundred stades to the Canobic Canobic mouth, nr. Abukir (Egy.)
[ 1 ] 787 C, 12–791 C, 9.
[ 2 ] 791 C, 14–824 C, 21.
[ 3 ] Strabo arrived in Alexandria in the early 20s BCE and was based there for much
of his life: 101 C, 14-24n; 117 C, 35–118 C, 14n. He has therefore seen many of the
places that he now goes on to describe.
[ 4 ] 788 C, 10-21; cf. 786 C, 26-27.
[ 5 ] Cf. 140 C, 25-30, where Strabo (describing a lighthouse in Iberia) probably al-
ludes to this same inscription. The inscription is lost so verification is impossible.
901
4.2. Southern Asia
just now in his war against the Alexandrians who had aligned
themselves with the kings; there are just a few mariners living
near the tower. The G reat Harbor, as well as being beauti-
fully closed off by the mole and by nature, is deep near the
shore—with the result that the largest ship can nevertheless
moor within gangplank distance—and is split into several
berths.
792 C, 16-23 The earlier Egyptian kings were content with what they
had and did not need any imported goods at all, and they were
hostile to all mariners, particularly to Greeks, who w ere plun-
derers and who were envious of other men’s land through the
inadequacy of their own. The kings set up a watch post in this
region with o rders to repel visitors, providing the guards with
a settlement named “Rhacotis,” now a part of the Alexandri-
ans’ city set back from the shipyards, but at that time a village;
and they gave the area around the village to herdsmen, who
were similarly empowered to prevent foreign arrivals.
792 C, 24-31 When Alexander arrived and saw the natural advantages
of the site, he decided to build a walled city on the site of the
harbor. T here is a story that an indication of the blessings
that would later fall on the city was provided when its planned
construction was being outlined. The master builders were
using chalk to mark its circumference, but the chalk ran out
just as the king arrived. The stewards offered up a portion of
the barley that had been provided for the workmen, and with
this barley most of the roads w ere also marked out. P eople are
said to have taken this as an omen of future success. |
792 C, 32–793 C, 9 Its natural advantages are many. The site is “washed by 17.1.7
also called the “Mareotis.” This lake—b oth in its upper lake Maria/Mareotis, Mariout l.
(Egy.)
reaches and at its sides—is fed by the Nile through a great
number of canals. The quantity of goods imported through
these canals is far greater than the quantity imported from the
sea, with the result that the lake harbor has grown more pros-
perous than the sea harbor. This explains how Alexandrian
exports exceed imports, as one would realize when, whether
in Alexandria or Dicaearchia, one sees the freight ships Dicaearchia, Pozzuoli (It.)
902
Nile Region
c oming into harbor and putting out to sea, and notices how
much heavier or lighter they are in their voyages to and fro.1
793 C, 9-20 In addition to the wealth of goods imported into each, both
the sea harbor and the lake harbor, the excellent climate also
deserves mention. This, too, is the result of being “washed by
water on both sides,” as well as the fortuitous circumstance
of the Nile’s flooding. Other cities that are situated on lakes
have a heavy and suffocating atmosphere in the heat of sum-
mer, for the edges of the lakes are turned into swamps because
of evaporation caused by the sun, and so many filthy vapors
are given off that the air is diseased and causes sickness. In
Alexandria, by contrast, the flooding of the Nile at the start of
summer means that the lake, too, is flooded and that t here are
no swamps to give off disgusting vapors. At the same time, the
Etesians blow from the north from such an expanse of sea that Etesians = seasonal winds
this shape are t hose that are “washed by water on both sides,”
with a distance across of some thirty stades. The short sides
are the isthmuses, each one of seven or eight stades, com-
pressed by the sea on one side and the lake on the other side.
The whole t hing is crisscrossed with roads, on which horses
can be ridden and carriages driven, and by two roads in par
ticular that are very broad (more than a plethrum in width). 1 plethrum = 100 ft.
794 C, 5-18 Also included in the royal buildings is what is called the
“Sema” (Tomb), which was an enclosed precinct encompassing
[ 1 ] Strabo, who was based for a long time in Alexandria (101 C, 14-24), surely ob-
served in person the heavily laden freight ships leaving the Alexandrian harbor
and noted the contrast with the more lightly laden ships arriving. He probably
also observed the reciprocal situation in Dicaearchia in Italy (245 C, 26-31n):
heavily laden ships arriving from Alexandria, more lightly laden ships leaving.
[ 2 ] The description in turn of the lived-in world as chlamydoid (113 C, 14-21) is per-
haps an attempt to make it reflect the shape of Alexandria.
903
4.2. Southern Asia
was killed, run through with sarissae when the soldiers at-
tacked him, but with him . . . * and the royals (Aridaeus, and
the children of Alexander, and Alexander’s wife, Rhoxana)
sailed away to Macedonia. Ptolemy carried off the body of
Alexander and buried it in Alexandria, where it still lies. It is
no longer, however, in the same sarcophagus: this one is made
of glass, but that fellow interred him in a sarcophagus made
out of gold, which was plundered by the Ptolemy known as
“Cocces” and “Parisactus,” who arrived from Syria and was
immediately expelled, so that his loot profited him not. |
794 C, 19-34 On the right-hand side as you enter the G reat Harbor are 17.1.9
the island and tower of Pharus; on the other side, there are the
reefs, and the headland “Lochias” with its royal quarters. As
you sail farther in, on the left are the inner royal quarters—
next to t hose on Lochias—boasting a multitude of elaborate
buildings and groves. Below t hese is the artificial, closed-off
harbor—privately owned by the royal family—and Antirrho-
dos (an islet in front of the artificial harbor, likewise with a
palace and small harbor—it was so named as being an equal
match for Rhodes).1 Above this is the theater, then Posidium,
an elbow of land projecting from what is called “Emporium,”
with a temple to Posidon. Antony added to it a mole, which
projected even more into the center of the harbor, and he
built at its end point a royal residence, which he called
“Timonium.” He did this in his final days when, abandoned
by his friends in the wake of the debacle at Actium, he set
sail for Alexandria; he was of the opinion that the rest of his
life, spent bereft of such friends, would be “Timonian.” Then
there’s the Caesarium, the Emporium, the warehouses, and
after them the shipyards as far as the Heptastadium. That was
my description of the Great Harbor. |
795 C, 1-9 Next a fter the Heptastadium is Eunostus Harbor, and 17.1.10
904
Nile Region
canal, t here’s only a small remaining part of the city; and then
the suburb of Necropolis, with its many gardens, graves, and
facilities for embalming the dead. On this side of the canal
is the Sarapium (temple to Sarapis), and other ancient precincts
that are more or less abandoned b ecause of the construction
of new ones in Nicopolis; an amphitheater and a stadium are Nicopolis, ?Bulkeley/?Ramley
(Egy.)
there, and the quinquennial 1 games are held t here, while the
ancient buildings have fallen into neglect.
795 C, 10-15 In short, the city is packed full of dedicated buildings and city = Alexandria, Iskandariya
(Egy.)
temples. The gymnasium is particularly fine, with porticoes
more than a stade long. In the city center, t here’s the court
house, and sacred groves. T here’s also the Panium (temple to
Pan), a hill made by the hand of man into a strobiloid shape, strobiloid, pinecone-shaped
905
4.2. Southern Asia
796 C, 1-6 All t hose who came a fter the third Ptolemy w ere cor-
rupted by luxury and ruled badly, but the worst rule was by
the fourth, the seventh, and the last—Auletes (Flute-player),
who, quite apart from his other shocking activities, played
the flute in theatrical productions and was so proud of his
playing that he did not shrink from holding contests in his
royal quarters and from putting himself forward to vie with
the contestants.
796 C, 6-12 The Alexandrians expelled this fellow. He had three
daughters, one of whom, the eldest, was legitimate. The Al- eldest = Berenice
Gabinius, kills Archelaus and the daughter but has not long the daughter = Berenice
[ 1 ] Strabo adds to his earlier statement (558 C, 8-23, where the imposter’s relation-
ship to the Cappadocian king is not mentioned). Based on what Strabo says
(558 C, 23–559 C, 7), the last Cappadocian king was e ither the son or the nephew
of the second Roman-appointed priest at Pontic Comana.
[ 2 ] In fact, the first Roman-appointed priest: 558 C, 8-23.
906
Nile Region
796 C, 28–797 C, 6 Meanwhile, Pompey arrives in flight from Palaepharsalus Palaepharsalus, Xylades (Gr.)
to Pelusium and mount Casium. Pompey is assassinated by Pelusium, Tell el-Farama (Egy.)
the king’s party; but then Caesar arrives, kills the young lad, Casium, Ras Qasrun/Khatib el
Gals (Egy.)
and sets up Cleopatra as queen of Egypt, sending for her to
come out of exile. He appointed the remaining b rother, still
very young, as her co-ruler. A fter the death of Caesar and
after Philippi, Antony crossed over into Asia and bestowed
even more honors on Cleopatra, making her his wife and
having children by her; and he made common cause with
her at Actium and joined her in flight. After this, Augustus
Caesar pursued and destroyed both of them and put an end
to Egypt’s abuse by drunkards. |
797 C, 7-13 It is now a province, paying a significant amount in taxa- It = Egypt 17.1.12
over the area, and three elsewhere in the territory. There are
also three squadrons of cavalry, likewise arrayed where they
are needed.
797 C, 18-24 As for the local city officials, t hese include the exegetes (inter-
preter)—he wears purple, has hereditary privileges, and looks
907
4.2. Southern Asia
had taught them to rule rather than be ruled. The third class con-
sisted of the Alexandrians, who similarly lacked p olitical
judgment, for the same reasons, but were nevertheless bet-
ter than the others since, even if they were mixed race, they
were nevertheless primarily Greek and retained a memory
of shared Greek customs. But even this body of population
had been decimated, particularly by Euergetes Physcon, in
whose time Polybius arrived in Alexandria: Physcon, facing
opposition, often destroyed the citizens by delivering them
up to the soldiers. Such, he says, being the state of affairs in the he = Polybius
poet = Homer (8th c. BCE) city, the words of the poet remained true: “to go to Egypt, a long and
difficult journey.” |
798 C, 4-8 Affairs w ere the same, if not worse, u nder the rulers who 17.1.13
straits. Nowadays, immense fleets make the voyage as far as straits, Bab el-Mandeb
India and to the far end of Ethiopia, whence the highly valu- far end of Ethiopia = Somalia
[ 1 ] 797 C, 18-24.
908
Nile Region
and the native Marmaridans who live in the vicinity.) | Cyrenaea, e. present-day Libya
798 C, 32–799 C, 5 It is a run of nine hundred stades, if you sail in a straight 17.1.14
MED. COAST OF EGYPT line, from Catabathmus to Paraetonium, a city with a large Paraetonium/Ammonia, Marsa
Matruh (Egy.)
harbor measuring some forty stades. Some call it “Paraeto-
nium,” others “Ammonia.” In between is the Egyptian Village;
Tyndarian Lookouts, Ishaila the headland of Aenesisphyra; and the Tyndarian Lookouts— Aenesisphyra, Sidi Barrani (Egy.)
rocks (Egy.)
four small islands with a harbor. Then comes a headland
Aenesippia, nr. Ras Abu Laho (Drepanum); an island (Aenesippia) with harbor; and a village Drepanum, ?Ras Gargub (Egy.)
(Egy. island)
(Apis), whence it is one hundred stades to Paraetonium—and
Apis, Zawiet Umm el-Rakham
(Egy.) a five-day journey to the temple to Ammon. t emple to Ammon, Aghurmi/
Siwa (Egy.)
799 C, 6-12 From Paraetonium, it is some one thousand three hundred
stades to Alexandria. In between is, first of all, a headland
formed of white earth and called “Leuca Acta” (White headland); Leuca Acta, Ras el-Abiad (Egy.)
then Phoenicus (a harbor) and Pnigeus (a village); then Sido- Phoenicus, ?Bir el-Genefis (Egy.)
Sidonia (island), Samra reef nia (an island with harbor); then, a l ittle farther away from the Pnigeus, ?el-Gotta (Egy.)
(Egy.)
sea, Antiphrae. This entire territory lacks good wine—wine
Sidonia (harbor), Marsa Abu
Samra (Egy.) jars contain a greater amount of seawater than of the wine
called “Libyan,” which is why the populous tribe of Alexan-
drians drinks beer—but Antiphrae is particularly scorned.
799 C, 12-20 Then there’s Derrhis (Animal-hide) Harbor, so named
because of the nearby black cliff, which looks like an animal
hide—the adjacent region is also called Zephyrium; then
another harbor (Leucaspis) and several more; then Cynos
Sema; then, not on the coast, Taposiris, which hosts a great Taposiris, Abu Sir (Egy.)
909
4.2. Southern Asia
rus and the Egyptian bean (from which ciborium comes), the
stems of each being virtually the same height, some ten feet.
The papyrus stem is, however, bare, with a tuft at the top;
the bean stem has leaves and flowers sprouting out all over,
and its fruit is similar to our bean, differing only in size and
taste. The bean fields therefore offer a pleasing vista and an
enjoyable opportunity for anyone wishing to be pleasurably
entertained. People are entertained on barges; they go in
among the dense bean plants, where shade is provided by the
plants’ leaves—these leaves are so large that they can be used
as cups and bowls, their concavity making them suitable for
this purpose. Indeed, the workshops in Alexandria are full
of them, p eople using them as vessels; and the country folk
use the income from the leaves as one source of revenue. That
is my account of the bean plant.
800 C, 7-13 As for papyrus, t here is not much grown h ere, since it is
not cultivated; but much papyrus, some of lesser quality and
some of greater (i.e., the “Hieratic”), is grown in the lower
Delta, where certain folks, wanting to expand their revenues,
have adopted the method employed by Judaeans in respect of
the date palm (especially the caryotic) and the balsam. That is
to say, they do not allow it to be grown everywhere; through
this scarcity, they add to its value and thus increase their rev-
enue but make widespread usage difficult. |
800 C, 14-20 On the right-hand side as you exit the Canobic Gate is the 17.1.16
canal leading to Canobus and connecting with the lake. You Canobus, Abukir (Egy.)
great river = Nile can sail, via this canal, both to Schedia and the great river, Schedia, ?Kom el-Gizah (Egy.)
910
Nile Region
acles; then, the Canobic mouth, which marks the start of the
NILE DELTA Delta. To the right of the Canobic mouth is the Menelaitic
District, named a fter the b rother of the first Ptolemy (and
not, by Zeus, after the hero, as is claimed by some, including
Artemidorus (late 2nd–early Artemidorus). After the Canobic mouth comes the Bolbi-
1st c. BCE)
tine mouth, then the Sebennytic one and the Phatnitic—the
third-largest mouth a fter the two principal ones that define
the Delta, it splits off into the interior of the Delta not far
from the apex. Near the Phatnitic is the Mendesian mouth,
then the Tanitic, and finally the Pelusiac. (There are others
in between these, of little significance, inasmuch as they are
pseudo-mouths.)
911
4.2. Southern Asia
801 C, 24-27 The mouths provide entry points but not perfect ones,
and not for large vessels but only for tenders, owing to the fact
that they are shallow and marshy. P eople used the Canobic
mouth in particular for trade when the Alexandrian harbors
had, as I said, been closed off.1
801 C, 28-34 After the Bolbitine mouth, a low and sandy headland proj
ects out a considerable extent. It is called Agnu Ceras. Then Agnu Ceras, Cape Rosetta (Egy.)
802 C, 1-6 After the Milesian fortification, if you head toward the Se-
bennytic mouth, t here are two lakes (one of which is called
“Butic,” after Butus, the city), the Sebennytic city, and Sais, Butus, Kom el-Farain (Egy.)
the metropolis of the Lower Territory, where Athena is wor- Sebennytic city, Sammanud
(Egy.)
shipped. In her t emple lies the tomb of Psammetichus. In the
Sais, Sa el-Hagar (Egy.)
Butus region, there’s Hermu Polis, situated on an island. In
Butus, there is an oracular temple to Leto. |
802 C, 7-17 In the interior above the Sebennytic and Phatnitic mouths 17.1.19
is Xois (island and city), in the Sebennytic District. There’s Xois, Sakha (Egy.)
also Hermu Polis (Hermes city); Lycon Polis (Wolf city); and Hermu Polis, Baklia (Egy.)
Mendes, where the p eople worship Pan and, in terms of ani- Mendes, Tell el-Ruba (Egy.)
Pindar (5th c. BCE) mals, the goat. As Pindar says, goats copulate with women
there: Mendes, on the margin of the sea, / the farthest horn of the
Nile, where rutting goats / copulate with w omen. Near Mendes is
Dios Polis (City of Zeus) and the lakes associated with her; Leon- Dios Polis, Tell el-Balamun (Egy.)
Busiris, Cynon Polis, Abu Sir ton Polis (Lion city); then, farther along, the city of Busiris (in Leonton Polis, Tell el-Yahoudiyeh
Bana (Egy.) (Egy.)
the Busirite District) and Cynon Polis (Dog city).
802 C, 17-28 Eratosthenes says that “xenelasia” (exclusion of foreigners) is
Eratosthenes (3rd c. BCE) a custom common to all native peoples, but the charge against the
Egyptians is laid on the basis of the Busiris myth, because later people
wished to lay a charge of xenophobia against the place, even though,
Eratosthenes cites Homer by Zeus, there was no “Busiris,” king or tyrant! The statement “to go
(8th c. BCE)
to Egypt, a long and difficult journey” is also cited, Egypt’s scarcity of
harbors being a major contributing factor, as also the inaccessibility of
the one existing harbor at Pharus, because of its garrison of herdsmen-
robbers ready to attack those anchoring there. The Carthaginians
912
Nile Region
ere in the habit of sinking the ship of any foreigner who sailed to
w
Sardo or to the Pillars, and for this reason much of the lore about the Sardo, Sardinia (It. island)
west should not be believed. The Persians purposely misled foreign Pillars, Straits of Gibraltar
802 C, 35–803 C, 3 Between the Tanitic and Pelusiac [mouths], t here are lakes 17.1.21
and large interconnecting swamps, with many villages. Pelu- Pelusium, Tell el-Farama (Egy.)
measures one thousand stades (less than one thousand five hun- recess at Heroon Polis = Gulf
of Suez
Posidonius (late 2nd–1st c. BCE) dred, according to Posidonius); 4 in addition to being arid and
sandy, it is infested with sand-dwelling reptiles. |
803 C, 13-24 On your right as you sail upstream from Schedia to Mem- 17.1.22
Start of Strabo’s own voyage up phis, there are myriad villages reaching as far as lake Maria; lake Maria/Mareotis, Mariout
the Nile l. (Egy.)
among them is what is called “Chabrias village.” On the river,
there’s Hermu Polis (Hermes city); then Gynaecon Polis (Women Hermu Polis, Damanur (Egy.)
city) and the Gynaecopolite District, succeeded by Momem- Momemphis, Kom el-Hisn (Egy.)
there are two nitrum pits containing a g reat deal of nitrum, nitrum = sodium carbonate
913
4.2. Southern Asia
river, while Sais is at a two-schoenus distance from the river, Sais, Sa el-Hagar (Egy.)
Arabian gulf at the city of Arsinoe, which some call “Cleopa- Arsinoe/Cleopatris, Kum el-
Qolzum/Suez (Egy.)
tris.” The canal flows through what are called the “Picrae (Bitter)
Lakes.” Their waters w ere once bitter, but when the aforesaid
canal was dug, they were transformed by the admixture of
river water. Now they have plenty of fish and are full of aquatic
914
Nile Region
birds. The canal was initiated before the Trojan period by Trojan period, late 2nd–early
1st millennium BCE
Sesostris (according to others, by the son of Psammetichus),
who only made a start and then died; it was subsequently
excavated by Darius the First, who took over the project’s
continuation. He, too, stopped work on the project, even
though it was at last near completion, swayed by false sci-
ence. He was persuaded that the Erythran sea was higher than Erythran sea, Red Sea
the Egyptian, and that if the neck of land between them was
sliced through, Egypt would be submerged u nder the sea.1
The Ptolemaic kings, however, dug through, creating a closed
passage such that they could sail unhindered to the outer sea
and back in again whenever they wanted to. The question of
sea levels has been discussed in my first volumes.2 |
804 C, 33–805 C, 4 Near Arsinoe is Heroon Polis (City of heroes), in the recess of Heroon Polis, ?Abu Suwayr, Tell 17.1.26
el-Maskhuta (Egy.)
the Arabian gulf toward Egypt; t here are also harbors, settle-
ments, and several canals and lakes near these places. Here
also is the Phagroriopolite District and its city, Phagrorian
Polis.
805 C, 4-6 The beginning of the canal opening into the Erythra is at
the village of Phacussa, next to which is Philo’s village. The Phacussa, Fakus (Egy.)
width of the canal is one hundred cubits, and it is deep enough 1 cubit = 1.5 ft.
the apex are the city of Bubastus and the Bubastite District; Bubastus, Tell Basta (Egy.)
above that, the Heliopolite District, where Heliu Polis (Sun city) Heliu Polis, Matariya (Egy.)
[ 1 ] Strabo corrects his earlier statement (38 C, 21-25, where he attributes to Seso-
stris, rather than to Darius, a belief in the higher level of the Red Sea).
[ 2 ] 49 C, 10–61 C, 4.
[ 3 ] Perhaps ships capable of transporting 10,000 foot soldiers: 780 C, 20-28.
915
4.2. Southern Asia
[ 1 ] Strabo’s voyage on the Nile (early 20s BCE): 117 C, 35–118 C, 14nn.
916
Nile Region
[ 1 ] 803 C, 13-24.
917
4.2. Southern Asia
in his enclosure through its window but want to see him out-
side it). When he has skipped around in the courtyard for a
bit, they take him back to his own place.
807 C, 21-27 So, the t emple to Apis lies alongside the Hephaestium
(temple to Hephaestus). The Hephaestium itself is a lavish con-
[ 1 ] Strabo’s voyage on the Nile (early 20s BCE): 117 C, 35–118 C, 14nn.
[ 2 ] Often translated as “tombs of kings.” One of the pyramids, however, was built
for a queen: 808 C, 9-25.
918
Nile Region
and the river, called “Troia,” settled long ago by the Trojan
prisoners of war who accompanied Menelaus and who stayed
there. |
809 C, 7-10 After Memphis, and likewise in “Libya,” comes the city 17.1.35
of Acanthus; the t emple to Osiris; and the grove of Theban Acanthus, Kafr Ammar/Kafr
Tarkhan (Egy.)
acacia (from which gum is made). Then, in “Arabia,” are the
Aphroditopolite District and the city of the same name, Aphrodite (city), Atfih (Egy.)
[ 1 ] Strabo’s voyage on the Nile (early 20s BCE): 117 C, 35–118 C, 14n.
[ 2 ] Strabo presumably refers to a site in Pontic Cappadocia.
919
4.2. Southern Asia
(indeed, they are not far from each other, nor from Paraeto- Paraetonium, Marsa Matruh
(Egy.)
nium). Just as it can be conjectured, on a wealth of evidence,
that the t emple t here once lay on the coast, might not these
lake Sirbonis, Sabkhat el
places likewise have once been on the coast, and might not Bardawil (Egy.)
Lower Egypt and the region as far as lake Sirbonis have been Erythra, Red Sea
part of a sea that was perhaps contiguous with the Erythra in
Aelanites recess, Gulf of Aqaba/
the region of Heroon Polis1 and the Aelanites recess? | Eilat
809 C, 30-31 These phenomena are described at length in the first vol- 17.1.36
[ 1 ] Strabo often uses “Heroon Polis” to mean the Gulf of Suez (e.g., 759 C, 19-27;
767 C, 22-30; 768 C, 27-34; 769 C, 20–770 C, 2; 803 C, 3-12), rather than the city
itself (804 C, 33–805 C, 4).
[ 2 ] 49 C, 10–57 C, 18.
920
Nile Region
810 C, 5-13 She granted heaven to the gods and the earth to mankind,
t hese being the extreme limits of the universe (the extreme
limits of a ball being the center and its outermost surface).
Since w ater surrounds the earth, and since man is not an
aquatic creature but rather one that lives on land, breathes
air, and shares with many o thers a need for light, she created
many concavities and convexities on the earth. The con-
cavities contain all or much of the water, with the earth sub-
merged beneath it. The convexities project upward so that the
water—except as much as is useful to the h uman race and to
the animals and plants associated with that race—is restricted
to the areas at their base.
810 C, 13-24 Since the whole universe is characterized by motion and
large-scale changes—otherwise it would not be possible for
things in the universe to be differentiated as to quality, quan-
tity, or size—it must not be assumed that the earth or the sea
remain permanently unaltered, in such a way that they never
gain anything nor are ever diminished, nor that each one stays
in its own abode (especially given that exchange between the
two is very natural and easy), but rather that large expanses
of earth become sea, and large expanses of water become dry
land, in the same way as the earth varies within itself. (Earth
can be crumbly, or it can be solid, or stony, or rich in iron, and
so on. Likewise in the case of liquid m atter: it can be salt w
ater,
or fresh and drinkable, or it can have healing properties, or be
life-saving or deadly, cold or warm.)
810 C, 25-29 Why, then, should one be surprised if some currently in-
habited parts of the earth were once sea, or if what is now
sea was once inhabited (just as erstwhile springs may dry up,
and new ones appear—and rivers, too, and lakes—and simi-
larly mountains and plains may change one into the other)?
I have described t hese m atters at length e arlier on;1 let that
be enough for now. |
810 C, 30–811 C, 4 The lake of Moeris, then, is sufficiently large and deep lake of Moeris, Birket Qarun 17.1.37
(Egy.)
that it can cope with flooding when the waters rise, and the
inhabited and cultivated areas do not suffer from inundation.
When the waters recede, the excess is returned by means of
the same canal, through each of its two mouths; both lake
and canal keep the remainder, which is useful for irrigation
purposes. This occurs naturally. There are, however, gates at
[ 1 ] 49 C, 10–61 C, 4.
921
4.2. Southern Asia
922
Nile Region
“Suchus.” It is fed on bread and meat and wine, which the visi-
tors who come to the spectacle always provide. My host—one
of the highly respected locals who acted as my “initiator”—
accompanied me to the lake with provisions from dinner: a
little cake, some roast meat, and a miniature flask containing
a honey drink.1 We found the creature lying on the shore. The
priests approached it: some held its jaws open, while one of
them popped in the cake and the meat and then poured in the
honey drink. The creature jumped into the lake and darted
across to the opposite bank. Another visitor arrived similarly
provisioned. The priests grabbed the offerings, set off at a run
around the lake and, catching up with the crocodile, similarly
gave to it what had been brought. |
812 C, 10-21 After the Arsinoite District and the Heracleotic Dis- 17.1.39
trict is Heracles City, where the ichneumon is revered by the Heracles City, Ihnasya el-
Medina (Egy.)
inhabitants—quite diff erent from the case of the Arsinoitans,
who revere crocodiles and whose canal is, as a result, packed
with crocodiles (as is the lake of Moeris), since p eople wor- lake of Moeris, Birket Qarun
(Egy.)
ship them and leave them alone. The inhabitants of Heracles
City, in contrast, revere the ichneumon, which is deadly to croc-
odiles and likewise to asps. The ichneumon destroys both the
eggs and the beasts themselves, making for itself a defensive
coat of mud by rolling in it and then letting the mud dry in
the sun. Then, in the case of asps, it seizes them by the head
or tail, drags them into the river, and kills them. In the case
of crocodiles, it bides its time and then, when the crocodiles
are basking in the sun with their jaws open, it enters through
their gaping mouths, eats through their intestines and stom-
achs, and emerges from their corpses. |
812 C, 22–813 C, 2 Next comes the Cynopolite District and Cynon Polis (Dog Cynon Polis, el-Qeis (Egy.) 17.1.40
[ 1 ] Strabo’s voyage on the Nile (early 20s BCE): 117 C, 35–118 C, 14n.
923
4.2. Southern Asia
city in the Thebaïs, no smaller than Memphis; she has a Greek Panon Polis, Akhmim (Egy.)
813 C, 10-17 Above Ptolemaïs is Abydus, the site of the Memnonium, Abydus, el-Araba el-Madfuna
(Egy.)
a palace wonderfully constructed out of whole slabs of stone,
built in the same manner as I described in the case of the
Labyrinth,1 albeit not as complicated; and a spring lying so
deep down that it requires a spiral descent via single stone
slabs of incredible size and construction. A canal leads to this
place from the great river; near the canal is a grove—sacred to great river = Nile
924
Nile Region
813 C, 26-31 Having already described Ammon at length,1 I wish to add Ammon, Aghurmi/Siwa (Egy.) 17.1.43
assent with his dark brows, the oracle giver being the equivalent
of Zeus), nevertheless the oracle giver explicitly told the king that he he = Alexander
[ 1 ] 49 C, 10–55 C, 32.
[ 2 ] For Erythrae (Ildır, Tky.) as home to the prophetesses Sibylla and Athenaïs:
645 C, 6-9.
[ 3 ] 813 C, 31–814 C, 6.
925
4.2. Southern Asia
814 C, 23-31 In Abydus, the p eople revere Osiris. At the t emple to Abydus, el-Araba el-Madfuna 17.1.44
(Egy.)
Osiris, it is not permitted (as is customary in the case of
other gods) for a singer, a flautist, or a harpist to lead off the
sacrifices to the god. A fter Abydus, t here’s Little Dios Polis Little Dios Polis, Hiw (Egy.)
(Little city of Zeus); then the city of Tentyra, where the crocodile Tentyra, Dendera (Egy.)
by the Egyptians and the Arabs. | There’s a neck of land be- 17.1.45
tween that place and the Erythra, where the city of Berenice Erythra, Red Sea
is located, with no harbor but with landing places, which Berenice, Bender el-Kebir/
Medinet el-Haras (Egy.)
are useful because of their convenient location on the nar-
row strip of land. It is said that Philadelphus, with his army,
was the first to cut this road, even though there was no water
supply, and to build resting places . . . *; and that he did so
because the Erythra was difficult to sail, particularly for those
voyaging from its innermost recess.
815 C, 14-17 Experience proved its utility. Now, all Indian and Arabian
wares, and w hatever Ethiopian goods are imported via the
Arabian gulf, are brought to Coptus, which acts as the en- Coptus, Qift (Egy.)
926
Nile Region
815 C, 17-20 Not far from Berenice is the city of Myus Hormus, with its Myus Hormus, ?Quseir
el-Qadim (Egy.)
stopping off point for sailors. Not far from Coptus is what is
called “Apollonos Polis” (Apollo city). Thus, the neck of land is Apollonos Polis, Qus (Egy.)
known, and t hese are the places that are used.1 It used to be Myus Hormus, ?Quseir
el-Qadim (Egy.)
that the camel d rivers traveled by night, finding their way
by the stars and taking their w ater with them like sailors do.
Now, however, they have constructed watering places by dig-
ging down very deep, and have made tanks that hold rainwa-
ter, even though it falls infrequently. The journey takes six or
seven days. On this narrow strip of land, there are emerald
mines—the Arabs having dug deep shafts—and mines of
other precious stones. |
815 C, 28–816 C, 5 After Apollonos Polis is Thebes, now also called Dios Polis Thebes/Dios Polis, Luxor, 17.1.46
Karnak (Egy.)
(City of Zeus), which is one-hundred-gated; and through each gate,
Homer (8th c. BCE) two hundred men / go forth, with h orse and chariot. Thus Homer,
who also refers to its wealth—not as rich as Egyptian Thebes, /
where possessions are piled high in every h ouse. Other writers also
say as much and describe this city as the metropolis of Egypt.
Even now, traces of its large size are identified over a length of
eighty stades; and t here are several t emples, many of which
suffered mutilation at the hands of Cambyses. Nowadays,
it is inhabited village-style, part of it in Arabia (the site of
the city) and part of it on the opposite bank (the site of the
Memnonium). Memnonium, Medinet Habu
(Egy.)
816 C, 5-17 In the Memnonium, t here are two monolithic colossal
statues next to each other: one of them is intact; the upper
part of the other (from the seat upward) was toppled in an
earthquake, so it is said.2 There is a belief that, once each
day, a sound—as of a faint banging—emanates from the part
that remains on the throne and pedestal. When, at the first
hour, I was present at this place with Aelius Gallus and with
the throng of friends and soldiers accompanying him, I heard
the sound.3 Whether it came from the pedestal or from the
colossus (or whether one of the men conveniently seated
around the pedestal made the noise!), I cannot state with cer-
tainty. Given the uncertainty of the cause, one is inclined to
believe anything rather than that the echo issued with such
regularity from the stones. Above the Memnonium, there are
[ 1 ] Militarily as well as commercially: Aelius Gallus, Strabo’s “dear friend and com-
panion” (117 C, 35–118 C, 14nn), used this route to return to Alexandria a fter his
Arabian campaign (782 C, 19-26).
[ 2 ] Two additional colossal statues of the same king, probably toppled in the same
earthquake (13th c. BCE), were restored in 2014.
[ 3 ] Strabo’s voyage on the Nile (early 20s BCE): 117 C, 35–118 C, 14nn.
927
4.2. Southern Asia
the wealth of the rulers of that time, the extent of their power
(reaching as far as the Scythians, Bactrians, Indians, and what
is now Ionia), the amount of tribute and size of their army
(around a million men). The priests there are said to be also
astronomers and p hilosophers. They are responsible for the
reckoning of days according not to the moon but to the sun,
intercalating five days into the twelve thirty-day months per
year. Since an additional fraction of a day is required to com-
plete an entire year, they figure out the period of whole days
and whole years such that the total of the additional fractions
equals one day.
816 C, 28-33 They attribute all this type of learning to Hermes. The
priestess who serves Zeus—whom they hold in the highest
reverence—is a very beautiful young girl from an extremely
good f amily (the Greeks call these young girls pallades). She
is a concubine and goes with whatever men she wants, until
the natural cleansing of her body occurs. A fter this cleans-
ing, she is given to a man (but before she is given, a fter her
concubinage, a lament is held for her). |
816 C, 34–817 C, 6 After Thebes comes the city of Hermonthis, where both Hermonthis, Armant (Egy.) 17.1.47
bull = a sacred bull Apollo and Zeus are revered; and a bull is tended t here.
Then there’s Crocodilon Polis (Crocodile city), which reveres Crocodilon Polis, Rizeiqat (Egy.)
that beast; then Aphrodites Polis (Aphrodite city) and, a fter that, Aphrodites Polis, Gebelen (Egy.)
Laton Polis (Perch city), which reveres Athena and the perch; Laton Polis, Esna/Isna (Egy.)
Eileithyias Polis, el-Kab (Egy.) then, Eileithyias Polis (City of Eileithyia) and temple, and on the
Eileithyia, Greek goddess of opposite bank, Hieracon Polis (Falcon city), which reveres the
childbirth
Hieracon Polis, Kom el-Ahmar
falcon; then Apollonos Polis (Apollo city), which is hostile to Apollonos Polis, Edfu/Idfu (Egy.)
(Egy.) crocodiles. |
817 C, 7-20 Syene and Elephantine: the former is a city on the borders Syene, Aswan (Egy.) 17.1.48
of Ethiopia and Egypt; the latter is an island in the Nile, half a Elephantine, Geziret Aswan
(Egy.)
stade from Syene, and also a city on the island, with a temple
to Knuphis and, as at Memphis, a Nilometer. The Nilometer
is a well, built from square-cut stone, on the bank of the Nile.
In it, p
eople mark the Nile’s risings—the highest levels, low-
est levels, and median levels—for the well’s w ater level rises
and falls in unison with the river. So, t here are marks on the
wall of the well, measurements of the risings at their greatest
928
Nile Region
Southern limit of Strabo’s shared by Ethiopians and Egyptians, built up like Elephantine
voyage up the Nile
and of the same size, with its temples being Egyptian. Here,
too, the p eople revere a bird, which they call a “falcon”—
although it seemed to me to have nothing in common either
with our falcons or with falcons in Egypt, being much big-
ger and with a very diff erent plumage. They said that it came
from Ethiopia and that, when one bird died, another was
brought from t here (and indeed the bird shown to me at the
time was close to expiring from disease).5 |
818 C, 11-17 We went to Philae from Syene by wagon, across a very Philae, Bilaq (Egy.) 17.1.50
level plain, some one hundred stades or so.6 Along the entire Syene, Aswan (Egy.)
[ 1 ] Strabo envisages parallels as drawn across the sky, rather than on the earth’s [ 5 ] I.e., “at the time” of Strabo’s voyage on the Nile (early 20s BCE): 117 C, 35–118 C,
surface. Hence, where we talk about a place lying on a parallel, Strabo describes 14n.
a place as being beneath a parallel. [ 6 ] Strabo was probably given the distance in the local metrological unit, the
[ 2 ] Strabo’s statement is true only for the day on which the summer solstice occurs. schoenus. If he was told that the distance was around 1.5 schoeni, and if he
[ 3 ] Use of the gnomon: 111 C, 29–112 C, 2n. converted at the rate of 60 stades to 1 schoenus (the conversion rate in use
[ 4 ] The European Space Agency gave the name “Philae” to the craft that made the along the upper Nile) rather than at the more normal rate of 30 stades to
first ever comet landing, in November 2014. 1 schoenus (803 C, 33–804 C, 9), this would explain why the distance he gives
is double the a ctual one.
929
4.2. Southern Asia
Herodotus (5th c. BCE) up their story with fantasies as if with songs and music, stat-
ing, for example, that the sources of the Nile are in the vicinity
Syene, Aswan (Egy.) of the islands (of which there are several) toward Syene and
Elephantine and that the river channel has a bottomless depth Elephantine, Geziret Aswan
(Egy.)
in this place.
819 C, 4-6 The Nile has numerous islands scattered around in it,
some of them completely covered when the river rises, o thers
only partly so; those parts that are too far above the w
ater are
irrigated by means of screws. |
819 C, 7-17 Egypt was largely peaceable from the start, because of 17.1.53
930
Nile Region
ETHIOPIA the Egyptian forces to accompany Aelius Gallus in his Ara- Syene, Aswan (Egy.)
s. Egypt, Sudan, South Sudan,
present-day Ethiopia bian war, attacked the Thebaïs and the garrison of three co- Elephantine, Geziret Aswan
(Egy.)
horts at Syene; succeeded in taking Syene, Elephantine, and
Philae, Bilaq (Egy.)
Philae through the swiftness of their ambush; enslaved the
inhabitants; and tore down the statues of Caesar. Petronius, Caesar = Augustus Caesar
[ 1 ] Strabo expands on his earlier statements (803 C, 3-12; cf. 802 C, 17-28, where
he mentions Egypt’s harborless shore). For “Libya” and “Arabia” meaning the
western and eastern sides of the Nile respectively: 806 C, 31–807 C, 3.
[ 2 ] 32 C, 11-16; 785 C, 20–786 C, 9.
[ 3 ] Part of the garrison had been withdrawn by Aelius Gallus: 819 C, 29-32n. There
had also been some attrition as the result of the Ethiopian attack against the
Roman forces at Syene (mid 20s BCE): 819 C, 33–820 C, 9.
[ 4 ] Ethiopian attack: 819 C, 33–821 C, 11.
[ 5 ] E.g., the Arabs: 819 C, 29-32.
[ 6 ] 780 C, 1–782 C, 26 (esp. 780 C, 20-28); 819 C, 18-22n.
931
4.2. Southern Asia
they asked for three days to deliberate but did nothing that
had been asked of them, Petronius took the initiative and
forced them into b attle and routed them easily, as they w ere
badly organized and ill equipped. (They had large shields—
but made only of rawhide—and axes to defend themselves;
some had pikes, others even had swords.)
820 C, 15-23 Some of them were penned up in the city; o thers fled into
the desert. A nearby island provided a refuge for some, who
ventured into the river channel (in a place where there were
not many crocodiles because of the current). T hese included
the generals of queen Candace: she ruled the Ethiopians in
our times and was a masculine sort of woman, blind in one
eye. Petronius, sailing over with lighter vessels as well as ships,
takes everyone captive and sends them forthwith to Alexan-
dria; and he attacks and takes Pselchis. If the numbers of Pselchis, Dakar (Egy.)
crossing over the sand dunes in which Cambyses’s army had Premnis, Kasr Ibrim (Egy.)
been buried when the wind got up. He ambushes and takes
the fortress t here. After this, he set off for Napata. This was Napata, Barkal (Sud.)
the royal residence of Candace: her son was there, and she
was in a place nearby. While Candace makes overtures of
friendship and returns the prisoners and statues taken at
Syene, Petronius attacks and takes Napata, too (the son hav- Syene, Aswan (Egy.)
ing fled), and levels it. After enslaving the inhabitants, he re-
treats to the rear with his spoils, judging that what lay ahead
was impassable.
820 C, 31–821 C, 7 After strengthening the fortifications at Premnis, p utting
in a garrison with enough food for four hundred men for
two years, he departed for Alexandria. As for the captives,
932
Nile Region
sar was and where they might find him, Petronius provided
them with escorts; and they went to Samos, since Caesar
was there and intended to proceed to Syria from there, after
dispatching Tiberius to Armenia. The Ethiopians got every
thing they wanted; and Caesar even remitted the tributes he
had imposed on them. |
821 C, 12-25 I said a great deal about Ethiopian matters earlier, so that 17.2.1
these, they also make a drink. Butter and suet are their olive
oil. They have no fruit trees other than a few date palms in
the royal gardens. Some of these p eople also feed on herbs,
shoots, lotus, and reed roots; and they eat meat, blood, milk,
and cheese.
821 C, 26–822 C, 3 Their rulers are generally kept shut up at home and are
thyroid, shield-shaped worshipped as divinities. Their most important royal resi-
dence is Meroe, a city with the same name as the island. The Meroe (city), Bagrawiya (Sud.)
island is said to be thyroid in shape. In size, it is said (perhaps Meroe (island) = region along
Nile between Atbara r. and Blue
with exaggeration) to be some three thousand stades long and Nile/Bahr el Azraq
933
4.2. Southern Asia
Arabian side by continuous cliffs; upstream (to the south) by Arabian side = eastern side
the confluences of the rivers Astaboras,1 Astapus, and Asta- Astapus, White Nile/Bahr el
Abiad
sobas. The course of the Nile continues northward, as far as
Astasobas, Blue Nile/Bahr el
Egypt, following the winding pattern of the river described Azraq
earlier.2
822 C, 3-13 In the cities, the dwellings are made from intertwined
pieces of date-palm wood . . . * Salt is mined, as among the
Arabs. As for flora, t here is abundant date palm, persea,
ebony, and ceratia; and as for animals, abundant elephants,
lions, and leopards. T here are also snakes—the elephantoma-
chi (elephant-hunters)—and many other beasts: they migrate
from the hot and arid regions to the wetlands and marshes.
| Above Meroe is Psebo, a large lake with a quite populous Psebo, ?Tana l. (present-day 17.2.3
Ethiopia)
island . . . * It so happens that, the west side of the Nile being
occupied by the Libyans and the other side by the Ethiopi-
ans, control of the islands and riverlands passes from one
to the other as each in turn is forced out by the growing
strength of the others.
822 C, 14-22 The Ethiopians use bows made of wood and four cubits 1 cubit = 1.5 ft.
[ 1 ] The Astaboras (Atbara r.) is included mistakenly, since it joins the Nile down-
stream from (i.e., north of) Meroe.
[ 2 ] 785 C, 20–818 C, 21.
934
Nile Region
marshes. The inhabitants of Meroe worship Heracles, Pan, Meroe, region of Bagrawiya
(Sud.)
and Isis, in addition to another native god. Some dispose
of their dead in rivers; others keep them at home encased
in crystal. There are some who bury the dead around their
holy places in clay urns. They demand that oaths be sworn
over the dead, and deem that oaths thus sworn are the most
sacred of all.
822 C, 31–823 C, 7 They appoint, as monarchs, people who have superior
beauty, skill in cattle breeding, courage, or wealth. In olden
days, the priests reigned supreme in Meroe. They sometimes
even ordered the monarchs to kill themselves, and then ap-
pointed a successor. L ater on, one of the monarchs put an end
to this practice, making an armed advance into the holy place
where the golden t emple stands, and slaughtering all the
priests! The following, too, is an Ethiopian custom: if one of
their monarchs is maimed in any part of the body whatsoever,
their closest companions must suffer the same injury, to the
extent of sometimes even sharing their death. For this reason,
they take very great care in guarding the monarch.
823 C, 8 The foregoing w ill be a sufficient description of the Ethio-
pians.1 |
823 C, 8-14 The following should be added to my account of Egypt, 17.2.4
large tree that produces a large and sweet fruit, is found only
here and among the Ethiopians; also the sycaminus, yield-
ing a fruit that, b ecause it is similar to a sycus (fig), is called
sycomorus—but it is not valued for its taste. There’s corsium,
too; and a delicacy something like a pepper but a little big-
ger than it.
823 C, 14-23 There are many fish in the Nile that have a peculiar local
character, but the best known are the oxyrhynchus, lepidotus,
latus, alabes, coracinus, choerus, phagrorius (also called phagrus),
and the silurus, citharus, thrissa, cestreus, lychnus, physa, and bus.
As for shellfish, there are large conchliae that make a sound
like the croaking of frogs. Indigenous animals include the
ichneumon and the Egyptian asp, with its own peculiarities
compared to asps elsewhere. T here are two types: the one- 1 span = 0.75 ft.
span asp, which c auses a quicker death; and the asp that is
[ 1 ] 821 C, 12–823 C, 7.
935
4.2. Southern Asia
Nicander (2nd c. BCE) nearly one orguia in length, as noted by the writer Nicander 1 orguia = 6 ft.
Herodotus (5th c. BCE) to knead clay with their hands but to knead bread dough with their
feet. Another peculiarity is caceis—a type of bread for stop-
ping the bowels; also cici, a crop that is sown in the fields and
pressed to produce the oil used by nearly all countryfolk in
their lamps and by the poorer laborers, both male and female,
as an unguent. Cucina, Egyptian wickerwork, is made from
a plant and similar to woven rush or date palm. Beer is pro-
duced by them in a peculiar way: many produce it, but each them = Egyptians
936
Nile Region
824 C, 22-25 Let me describe Libya next, which is what remains of my de- 17.3.1
Strabo segues from his scription of the entire world.2 Much has already been said
description of southern Asia
to his description of Libya
about it, but I must now add further commentary as neces-
(= Africa) sary, adding material that was not included before.
937
Italy
Spain
Portugal
ce
3
Gree
Turkey
2
4
Tunisia
5
1 Crete
c co
o ro
M Algeria
Libya
Egypt
Nile
ha rn
ra
Sa este
?
W
? ?
Mauritania ?
Mali Sudan
Niger
Senegal Chad
Burkina
Faso
Guinea Nigeria
Translator’s Introduction
Libya (= Africa) is the third and last of the continents into which Strabo divides the
lived-in world. More accurately, since continents are not in themselves ordinal, Libya is
described by Strabo in third place, after Europe and Asia. The name “Libya” is confusing
for the twenty-first-century reader. In 1934, a classically minded Italian administrator
used the name, which the ancient Greeks had applied to the entire continent, and gave it
to what was then an Italian province and is now a nation-state. As in the cases of “Egypt,”
“Ethiopia, and “India,” it is difficult for modern readers to shed the present-day conno-
tations of the names used by Strabo, but such we must do for “Libya,” which for Strabo
generally denotes an entire continent (although to complicate m atters further, as we s hall
see in the next chapter, Strabo also uses the name for a Roman province).
The equation of Strabo’s “Libya” with our “Africa” is not quite precise. Strabo excludes
from Libya several parts of what we might consider to be part of Africa. More specifically,
Strabo excludes Egypt (part of present-day Egypt) and parts of Ethiopia (southern present-day
Egypt, Sudan, South Sudan, present-day Ethiopia, Eritrea, Djibouti, Somalia). As we have seen
in the previous chapter, Strabo considers t hese areas to be part of Asia and has already
described them as such. Strabo’s conception of what constitutes the continent of Africa
is thus somewhat diff erent from the twenty-first-century conception, when we are more
likely to take the neck of land crossed by the Suez Canal as the continental divide (as
indeed did some writers in antiquity other than Strabo).
Even allowing for his sundering of the continents at the Nile, Strabo severely under-
estimates the size of Libya. To the south, he draws a theoretical boundary by reference to
a place called “Meroe.” This is the name Strabo gives to the area of land between two of
the Nile’s tributaries (Atbara river and Blue Nile/Bahr el Azraq), an area that Strabo calls
an “island,” even though it is not an island in the literal sense. Strabo also sometimes uses
the name “Meroe” to refer to a city (Bagrawiya, Sudan), situated on this quasi-island.
Strabo’s usage of the name is ambiguous in the e arlier section of his narrative (chapters 1
and 2). In chapter 5, Strabo specifically uses the name in the sense of the city, and puts the
southern boundary of Libya three thousand stades to the south of it. However, he also
refers back to t hose e arlier discussions, in which he has given the distance variously as
“three thousand four hundred,” “not less than three thousand,” and “three thousand or
four thousand” stades.
939
5. Libya (= Africa)
Strabo takes the parallel running through this point south of Meroe as the southern
boundary of Libya (at least, of the part of the continent contained within the lived-in
world). He believes that this is the same as the parallel running through Cinnamonland
(Somalia). If we follow this parallel westward, we can imagine the southern boundary
of Strabo’s Libya as r unning, very approximately, through the northern tip of South
Sudan and the southern parts of Sudan, southern Chad, northern Nigeria, Burkina Faso,
southern Mali, Guinea, and Guinea-Bissau. Although Strabo has no detailed knowledge
of these places, he feels confident in asserting that h
uman habitation south of this parallel
is impossible; that the continental landmass, if it projects south of this line at all, does so
only for a short distance. In consequence, most of what we would call “central Africa” and
all of what we would call “southern Africa” simply do not exist for Strabo.
Drawing the southern boundary of Libya as he does, Strabo severely underestimates
the “width” (north–south dimension) of the continent. He calculates that it is just over half
of its maximum “length” (east–west dimension). To complicate m atters, he also under-
estimates the latter dimension, which he measures from a headland called “Coteis” (Cap
Spartel, Morocco) eastward to Egypt. Strabo wrongly believes that Coteis is the western-
most point of all Libya and is unaware of the huge westward bulge of Africa into the
Atlantic. Thus, even allowing for Strabo’s inclusion of what he calls Egypt and Ethiopia
in Asia rather than Africa, and even allowing for his ignorance of the true southern extent
of the continent, he seriously fails to appreciate the true size of Africa.
940
Translator’s Introduction
After introducing each stage, Strabo swoops down in his narrative as if to get a
Google Street View or, more precisely, a coastal-cruising view, since it is actually the
coast concerning which Strabo has the most to say. Many of the locations he describes
rose to prominence in the modern Western consciousness in the early years of this
century. Tynis (Tunis) is the place where a street vendor famously set himself on fire
in protest against the Tunisian government at the beginning of the Arab Spring; Ber-
enice (Benghazi, Libya) is familiar as the place to which the protests spread; near Cape
Cephalae (Misuarata, Libya), there was a fierce b attle between Libyan government
forces and rebels.
As Strabo describes each stage of this imagined journey along the Mediterranean
coast, he lets his gaze travel southward to what he conceives of as the Libyan interior (in
reality, still what we would call “northern” Africa). Strabo has much less knowledge about
these areas but is aware of the immense distances traveled by the indigenous p eoples as
they cross the Sahara. He exhibits a non-nomad’s amazement at journeys of ten and fif-
teen days, and notes details such as how the journeys are managed by tying water-filled
skins beneath the horses’ bellies. Interestingly, Strabo is vaguely aware that, south of
these desert regions, rain may be more plentiful.
While the caravans across the desert represent actual journeys regularly made by the
nomadic p eoples, Strabo’s own travels in Libya appear to have been limited to a cruise
along part of the northern coast. This voyage plays no part in shaping the narrative and
is known to us only by a throwaway line concerning Cyrene (Ain Shahat, Libya), stating
that it is situated on a plain that “looked trapezoid to me when I saw it from the sea.”1
Nothing else is known about Strabo’s voyage, although it was presumably associated with
his long stay in Egypt. Possibly, he was sailing along the Cyrenaean coast before sailing
northward to Crete, which was part of the same Roman province as Cyrenaea and where
Strabo had f amily connections. Strabo’s p resentation of the Mediterranean coastline gets
increasingly erratic the farther west of Cyrene he goes, so it seems unlikely that his cruise
extended much farther along the coast.
When Strabo gives us an eyewitness description of the plain on which Cyrene sits, he
has just a l ittle e arlier remarked on the many reefs along the coastline, which make sailing
along it so dangerous: “it happens in the case of some people that they run aground in
the shallows and get stuck t here. Rare is the vessel that survives! Because of this, people
making the voyage keep their distance from the coast, taking precautions lest they get
driven into the bays, caught off guard and blown t here by the wind. Man’s venturesome
spirit makes him have a go at all things, coastal navigations in particul ar!”2
There seems to be a play on the phrase “coastal navigations,” which can just as easily be
translated as “coastal descriptions”—and a “coastal description” is precisely what Strabo
is engaged in. The latent sense of fear (in antiquity, shipwrecks w ere e very man’s worst
nightmare) was also perhaps born from Strabo’s own experience. Had his ship perhaps
misjudged what was a safe distance from the coast? If so, it is possible that the point of
941
5. Libya (= Africa)
his eyewitness account is that the ship’s captain should not have steered so close to shore
to enable Strabo to make the observation about the table-shaped plain.
942
Translator’s Introduction
Remember
943
CH APT E R F I V E Libya (= Africa)
824 C, 26–825 C, 5 hose who divided the lived-in world into continents did so
T 17.3.1 cont.
unequally. The threefold division implies three equal parts, but
Libya falls so far short of being one-third of the lived-in world
that, even taken together with Europe, it would seem not to be
as large as Asia. It is perhaps even smaller than E urope and, in
respect of its power, greatly so. A great part of the interior and
of the oceanic coast is desolate, with just a sprinkling of settle- oceanic coast = Atlantic + Indian
Ocean coasts
ments, which are small and scattered and belong mostly to no-
mads; besides its desolation, the fact that it is a haunt of wild
animals drives people away even from areas that are capable of
supporting habitation; and it greatly encroaches into the burnt
zone.1 In contrast, the whole of the coast on our sea, from the coast on our sea = Med. coast
Nile to the Pillars, and especially the part subject to the Cartha Pillars = Straits of Gibraltar
from Egypt and the Nile to Maurusia and the Pillars; at right Maurusia, Morocco
angles to this, the side formed by the Nile to Ethiopia (I ex- Pillars = Straits of Gibraltar
tend this line to the ocean); as its hypotenuse, the entire oce- Ethiopians = Western
Ethiopians, Western Sahara,
anic coast between the Ethiopians and Maurusians. ?Mauritania, ?Senegal
825 C, 11-19 What lies at the tip of the shape as described, already falling
somewhat under the burnt zone, I speak of only from conjec-
ture, as it has not been visited. I am therefore unable to state the
territory’s greatest width. However, I did say in my introduc- width = north–south dimension
tory remarks that, if you head south from Alexandria to Meroe Alexandria, Iskandariya (Egy.)
(the Ethiopian royal residence), it is a journey of around ten Meroe, Bagrawiya (Sud.)
[ 1 ] The “burnt zone” is the uninhabited area south of the lived-in world. For the
zones: 111 C, 1-12.
[ 2 ] Strabo refines his e arlier view (130 C, 25-32, where Libya is described as
“table-shaped”).
[ 3 ] 62 C, 33–63 C, 9; 72 C, 18-28; 115 C, 22-30; 132 C, 25-33.
[ 4 ] Strabo m easures the width (north–south dimension) only of the part of the
continent north of the burnt zone—i.e., the part of the continent within the
lived-in world.
[ 5 ] 824 C, 26–825 C, 19.
945
5. Libya (= Africa)
825 C, 20-25 For my detailed description, I should start with the western
and better-known parts. | Living here are the “Maurusians,” 17.3.2
left) t here is a mountain range that the Hellenes call “Atlas,” Atlas/Dyris, Atlas mts. (Mor.)
and the natives “Dyris.” Projecting out from its foot is the
most westerly point of Maurusia, called “Coteis”; and t here Coteis, Cap Spartel (Mor.)
[ 1 ] Strabo provides a transliteration into Greek of the Latin ethnic name Mauri: [ 5 ] 825 C, 5-10.
508 C, 10-18n. [ 6 ] I.e., the Atlantic coast of the continent.
[ 2 ] 169 C, 30–172 C, 11. [ 7 ] Strabo is unaware that the Atlantic coast of Africa trends southwest (from the
[ 3 ] Strabo writes the name “Trinx” in the grammatically inflected form “Tringa,” point of view of a sailor departing from Lixus/Coteis), before turning and head-
which is similar to the (uninflected) name “Tinga” (Tangier, Mor.), used at 827 C, ing southeast.
24-28n. It is possible that Strabo is playing with his audience. For similar gram- [ 8 ] Further description: 829 C, 31-34; 835 C, 16-30.
matical confusion/punning: 615 C, 10-11. [ 9 ] 47 C, 25–48 C, 2; 98 C, 13–102 C, 11.
[ 4 ] For the variation “Lixus/Lynx”: 829 C, 1-11n.
946
Coast of Outer Sea
seven stades; that there lies in front of it a low and level spot
with an altar to Heracles, which, it is said, does not get covered
by the tide. This is, I think, one of the fictions; likewise, the
story that in the bays that come next t here are ancient Tyrian
settlements, now abandoned, consisting of no fewer than three
hundred cities, which the Pharusians and Nigritans sacked— Lynx, Tchemmisch (Mor.)
these are described as being thirty days from Lynx. | these = ?bays
826 C, 23-30 All agree that Maurusia is blessed (except for a small des- 17.3.4
there so thick that it is difficult for two men to join their arms
around it, producing cubit-long grape clusters; that all the 1 cubit = 1.5 ft.
Posidonius (late 2nd–1st c. BCE) Gadira to Italy, he was blown t oward the Libyan coast and saw a
wooded area on the shore that was full of these animals, some of them
up in the trees, some on the ground, and some suckling their young;
he therefore laughed when he saw them with their ponderous breasts,
some bald-headed, some maimed, and some showing other such dis-
figurements. |
827 C, 12-20 Above this, situated on the outer sea, is the territory of the above this = farther south 17.3.5
WESTERN ETHIOPIANS “Western Ethiopians,” as they are called, which for the most outer sea = Atlantic Ocean
Western Sahara, ?Mauritania,
?Senegal part offers terrible living conditions. Iphicrates says that it is a
breeding ground for giraffes, elephants, and what are called “rhizeis,”
947
5. Libya (= Africa)
Seven Brothers 3 and the mountain b ehind it, named “Abila,”4 Tinga, Tangier (Mor.)
with its many animals and huge trees. The length of the strait Abila, ?Monte Acho (Spanish
possession)/?Jebel Musa (Mor.)
at the Pillars is said to be one hundred and twenty stades; its
minimum width, at Elephas, is sixty.5
in putting it opposite Massalia:8 from New Carthage to Meta- Massalia, Marseille (Fr.)
[ 1 ] The journey was probably undertaken in the late 2nd c. BCE: 100 C, 5-9. [ 6 ] Strabo’s “Metagonium” is part of the headland (?Ras Tleta Madari/Cap des Trois
[ 2 ] Strabo revises his earlier statement (140 C, 8-13, where the name is given as Fourches, Mor.) near the river, which marks the boundary between Maurusia
“Tingis”; cf. 825 C, 25-33n). For variations: Radt, vol. 4, critical apparatus on 827 C, and Masaesylia. The name “Metagonium” is used by other ancient authors to
line 25; 825 C, line 30. denote the boundary between Masaesylia and Masylia, farther to the east:
[ 3 ] Strabo probably refers to the town of Seven Brothers (Ceuta, Sp. possession). 829 C, 20-25n; 832 C, 1-7.
Strabo e arlier notes that sites sometimes take on the name of memorials t here: [ 7 ] The sense is that Metagonium (?Ras Tleta Madari/Cap des Trois Fourches, Mor.)
171 C, 14-28. The “Seven Brothers” itself is a mountain range (Jebel Musa, Mor.). is supposed to lie due south of New Carthage (Cartagena, Sp.). See 834 C, 14-18;
[ 4 ] Strabo revises his earlier statement (170 C, 12-20, where the mountain is called 836 C, 29–837 C, 15; 838 C, 9-19. Cf. 496 C, 26–497 C, 4n.
“Abilyx”). [ 8 ] The place referred to as “Metagonium” by Timosthenes appears to be the
[ 5 ] Strabo refines his earlier statement (122 C, 16-23, where the minimum width is headland marking the eastern boundary of Masaesylia: 829 C, 20-25.
given as “around 70 stades”). [ 9 ] Maurusian fertility: 826 C, 23–827 C, 5.
948
Inner Sea Coast of Maurusia
use lion skins, leopard skins, and bear skins for clothes and
bedding.
828 C, 12-18 These p eople (and the neighboring Masaesylians, and These people = Maurusians
MAURUSIAN INTERIOR near the Western Ethiopians, use the bow and arrow (as the Western Ethiopians, Western
sw. Algeria, ?n. Mauritania, Sahara, ?Mauritania, ?Senegal
?Mali Ethiopians do) and have scythe-bearing chariots. The Pha-
rusians even have social relations with the Maurusians, albeit
rarely (because of the desert): they hang water-filled skins be-
neath their horses’ bellies. Sometimes they even reach Cirta, Cirta, Constantine (Alg.)
and Bocchus 3 gained possession of it, being allies of the Ro- Bogus and Bocchus took
possession of Maurusia, mid-
mans. After the extinction of their line, Juba took over the 1st c. BCE; Bocchus died, 33 BCE
kingdom, which was granted to him along with his patrimony Juba was granted Maurusia,
by Augustus Caesar.4 (This Juba was the son of the Juba who 25 BCE; died, 23 CE
fought with Scipio against the deified Caesar.) Juba recently deified Caesar = Julius Caesar
Artemidorus (late 2nd–early “there is some city called ‘Lixus’ at the extreme west of Maurusia Lixus (name used by
1st c. BCE) cites Eratosthenes Eratosthenes) or Lynx
(3rd c. BCE) (rather than ‘Lynx’)”; 5 that “there are numerous ruined Phoenician (name preferred by
cities of which no visible trace remains”; that “among the Western Artemidorus) = Tchemmisch
(Mor.)
Ethiopians,6 the atmosphere is thick and foggy in the early morn-
ing and late afternoon.” How can this be, in places that are dry and
Strabo points out hot? He himself, however, says far worse t hings about the He himself = Artemidorus
inconsistencies in Artemidorus’s
own account same l ocalities. He reports that there are wandering lotophagi
( lotus-eaters), desert dwellers who feed on lotus (a sort of grass and
[ 1 ] 828 C, 10-11.
[ 2 ] I depart from Radt (vol. 4, critical apparatus on 828 C, line 24) h
ere in reading
“Troglodyte-” rather than “Trogodyte-,” because the context requires it. See
42 C, 2-9n.
[ 3 ] “Those around Bogus and Bocchus” is idiomatic, meaning simply Bogus and
Bocchus.
[ 4 ] Juba’s “patrimony” would be Numidia. For the possibility that Juba received
a portion of Numidia, alongside the newly bestowed kingdom of Maurusia:
840 C, 13-26; “Translator’s Introduction” to Strabo’s Epilogue.
[ 5 ] 825 C, 25-33n.
[ 6 ] Western Ethiopians = Western Sahara, ?Mauritania, ?Senegal.
949
5. Libya (= Africa)
exposed and then covered with earth again. What he says about 1 cubit = 1.5 ft.
elephants is also the stuff of myth. He says that, while other
animals flee from fire, elephants fight it and ward it off because it
destroys the trees; they contend with men by sending out scouts, and
when they see them retreating, they too retreat; when wounded, they
hold out a peace offering of sticks, grass, or soil. |
Masaesylia (Algeria)
829 C, 20-25 fter the land of the Maurusians comes the land of the Ma-
A 17.3.9
saesylians, which begins at the Molochath river and ends at a Molochath r., Oued Moulouia
headland called “Tretum,”2 marking the border between the Tretum, Cap Bougaroun (Alg.)
829 C, 31-34 The deep interior of the territory consists of mountains territory = Masaesylia
MASAESYLIAN INTERIOR and deserts . . . * scattered h ere and t here, occupied by the
s. Algeria
Gaetulians up to the Syrtes; the parts t oward the sea and Syrtes, bays off e. Tunisia,
present-day Libya
the plains are blessed with fertility, with many cities, rivers,
and lakes. |
830 C, 1-10 I am not sure that Posidonius is correct in saying that 17.3.10
Posidonius (late 2nd–1st c. BCE) Libya is traversed by only a few small rivers, since those of which
[ 1 ] Strabo has earlier (157 C, 14-20n) cited the same passage from Artemidorus,
using slightly different wording. Cf. 760 C, 11-16n.
[ 2 ] For “Tretum” as the headland called by other ancient authors “Metagonium”:
832 C, 1-7.
[ 3 ] For “Metagonium” as Strabo’s name for an area near the river that marks the
boundary between Maurusia and Masaesylia: 827 C, 28–828 C, 3.
[ 4 ] Juba (junior) died in 23 CE.
950
Masaesylia
Artemidorus (late 2nd–early rtemidorus speaks, between Lynx and Carthage, he de-
A Lynx, Tchemmisch (Mor.)
1st c. BCE)
scribes as many and large. It is truer to say this of the inte- Carthage, Carthage (Tun.)
rior, and he gives the explanation for this himself: it does not
rain heavily in the northern parts just as, they say, it does not rain
in Ethiopia, with the result that there are frequent outbreaks of pes-
tilence brought on by droughts, and the lakes fill up with mud, and
locusts abound. He further says that the eastern (lit., “sunup”) parts
are humid, since the sun passes over quickly on its way up; that the
western (lit., “sundown”) parts are dry, since there the sun turns back.1
830 C, 10-16 . . . * are described as “humid” or “dry,” some on account
of the abundance of water (or lack thereof ), some on account
of the abundance of sunlight (or lack thereof ). He refers to
the effect of sunlight. Everybody defines this effect by means
of northerly and southerly climata. On the other hand, “east” climata, bands of latitude
[ 1 ] The original theory probably referred to the annual motion of the sun from
the winter tropic (Tropic of Capricorn) to the summer tropic (Tropic of Can-
cer), and back again. The area between the tropics, over which the sun passes
on its way “up” (from winter tropic to summer tropic) is more humid than the
area at the tropics themselves, where the sun lingers for a longer period and
creates drier conditions. At some point a fter the formulation of the theory,
there seems to have been confusion between “sunup” referring to this annual
motion and “sunup” in the sense of the sun’s daily motion (i.e., sunrise). The
confusion is compounded by taking the “turning back” of the sun to refer to its
daily motion (i.e., sunset) rather than its annual motion (i.e., when it appears to
linger overhead at the summer tropic before “turning back” t oward the winter
tropic). In Greek, the term “sunup” (i.e., sunrise) is also used to mean “east,” and
“sundown” (i.e., sunset) to mean “west.” Similar confusion: 30 C, 31–31 C, 21.
951
5. Libya (= Africa)
boundary between Juban and Roman territory.4 There have Salda, Béjaia (Alg.)
Zama and Zincha; also, those cities where Caesar wore Scipio Thala, Thala (Tun.)
Ruspinum, Henchir-Tenir (Tun.) down, defeating him at Ruspinum, then Uzita, then Thapsus Capsa, Gafsa (Tun.)
Uzita, Henchir-el-Makrceba and its nearby lake and saltworks; also, the nearby free cities Zama, Jama (Tun.)
(Tun.)
of Zella and Acholla. Caesar took by surprise the island of Acholla, Ras Botria (Tun.)
Thapsus, Ras-Dimas (Tun.)
Cercinna and the little seaside town of Thena. All of these Cercinna, Grand Kerkenna
Zella, Zouila (Tun.) (Tun. island)
were e ither completely wiped out or left in a semi-ruined
Thena, Henchir-Thina (Tun.)
state. Scipio’s cavalry set fire to Phara. |
[ 1 ] 49 C, 10-18.
[ 2 ] Strabo resumes his description of the coastline of Masaesylia (Med. coast of
Algeria) from 829 C, 31.
[ 3 ] Ptolemy succeeded his father (Juba), 23 CE.
[ 4 ] I.e., the boundary between, on the one hand, Maurusia + Masaesylia (the king-
dom that had been ruled by Juba) and, on the other hand, the Roman province
of Africa.
952
Masylia + Carthage
832 C, 1-7 After Tretum1 comes the territory of the Masylians and Tretum, Cap Bougaroun (Alg.) 17.3.13
832 C, 7-13 Ityca, second only to Carthage in terms of size and pres- Ityca, Henchir-bou-Chateur
(Tun.)
tige, was a sort of metropolis for the Romans after Carthage
was destroyed, and a base for their activity in Libya. It is situ-
ated in the same bay as Carthage, toward the second of the bay = Gulf of Tunis
two promontories that form the bay: the promontory toward Apollonium, Ras Sidi-Ali-el-
Ityca they call “Apollonium,” and the other one “Hermaea.” Mekki (Tun.)
The two cities stand in view of each other. The river Bagradas Hermaea, Cap Bon (Tun.)
832 C, 13-24 From Tretum to Carthage is two thousand five hundred Carthage, Carthage (Tun.)
from Tyrus. The colonization by the Phoenicians of Carthage Phoenicians colonized Carthage
and Iberia, early 1st millennium
part beyond the Pillars = and as far as Iberia—the part beyond the Pillars as well as BCE
Atlantic coast of Spain, Portugal
the rest of it—was so successful that, even now, Phoenicians
[ 1 ] The headland Tretum (Cap Bougaroun, Alg.), which marks the end of Masae-
sylia and the beginning of Masylia, is called “Metagonium” by other ancient
authors. Strabo, however, uses the name “Metagonium” for a different place:
829 C, 20-25n; 827 C, 28–828 C, 3n.
953
5. Libya (= Africa)
occupy the best part of the European mainland and its as-
sociated islands;1 and they took possession of all that part of
Libya = Africa Libya that could be settled in a non-nomadic way. With t hese
resources, they established a city that was a rival to Rome and
fought three great wars against them. Carthage and Rome fought
three wars, mid-3rd–mid-2nd c.
832 C, 32–833 C, 9 Evidence of Carthaginian resources can be clearly seen BCE
in their final war, in which Scipio Aemilianus finished them Final war between Carthage
off, and their city was utterly annihilated. When they began and Rome, 149–146 BCE
to wage this war, they had three hundred cities in Libya and
a population of seven hundred thousand in the city. Under city = Carthage
833 C, 17-29 Masanasses was assiduously courted by the Romans, on Masanasses ruled Masylia
from 212 BCE, expanding into
account of his loyalty and friendship: it was he who civilized Masaesylia and creating the
the nomads and made them into farmers, and furthermore kingdom of Numidia, which he
ruled with Roman support, ca.
taught them how to fight military campaigns rather than 201 BCE onward; Micipsas ruled
Numidia, 148–118 BCE
engage in petty raids. A peculiar t hing had happened in the
case of these folk. Living in a territory that was blessed (apart
from t here being too many wild animals), they passed up the
opportunity to exterminate the animals and to work the land
[ 1 ] Phoenicia was no longer a political power in Strabo’s day. However, the inhabit-
ants of parts of Iberia that had been Phoenician colonies—in particular Gadira
(Cádiz, Sp.)—may still have been referred to in Strabo’s day as “Phoenicians” or
“Libyans”: 170 C, 20-30nn.
[ 2 ] The expression “descendants associated with Micipsas” is idiomatic, meaning
simply Micipsas.
954
Masylia + Carthage
834 C, 1-8 The island of Cossura is in the m iddle of the entrance to Cossura, Pantelleria (It. island) 17.3.16
the Carthaginian bay.2 The Lilybaeum region of Sicily lies Lilybaeum, Capo Boeo (Sic.)
hot springs and some stone quarries; then the rugged head-
land of Hermaea, home to the city of the same name; then Hermaea (headland), Cap Bon
Neapolis. Then t here’s the headland of Taphitis: it has a hill, Hermaeum (city), ?el-Haouaria
(Tun.)
called “Aspis” (Shield), because that’s what it looks like,3 which
Neapolis, Nabeul (Tun.)
was settled by the Sicilian tyrant Agathocles when he sailed
Taphitis, Ras Mostafa (Tun.)
against the Carthaginians. These cities were demolished by
the Romans at the same time as Carthage.
834 C, 14-18 The island of Cossurus is four hundred stades from Cossurus, Pantelleria (It. island)
of Cossurus.
834 C, 18-22 Then comes the city of Adrymes, where t here used to be Adrymes, Sousse (Tun.)
[ 1 ] Strabo provides a transliteration into Greek of the Latin name Numidae: see
508 C, 10-18n. The Latin name is itself borrowed from Greek nomades, meaning
“those who roam about for pasture.”
[ 2 ] In this paragraph, Strabo mistakenly juxtaposes Cossura (Pantelleria, It. island),
which lies out to sea, and Aegimurus (Zembra, Tun. island), which lies in the
mouth of the Carthaginian bay.
[ 3 ] Strabo e arlier refers to Aspis/Clypea (Kelibia, Tun.) as a city: 277 C, 20-25n.
[ 4 ] Strabo now corrects his earlier mistaken juxtaposition (834 C, 1-8) of Cossurus
and Aegimurus.
[ 5 ] The sense is that Cossurus (Pantelleria, It. island) lies due south of the mouth
of the Selinus (Modione r., Sic.): 827 C, 31–828 C, 3n.
955
5. Libya (= Africa)
ITTLE SYRTIS
L Syrtis.” The circumference of the bay is one thousand six hun-
bay in Med. Sea off e. Tunisia
dred stades, and the width of its mouth is six hundred [stades].
At each of the promontories forming the mouth, t here are
islands close to the mainland: Meninx, as well as the afore- Meninx, Gerba (Tun. island)
there’s a river; a fter that, some sort of wall built by the Cartha
ginians as a bridge over some chasms that go inland. T here are
some harborless stretches in this region, although the rest of
the coastline has harbors; then, t here’s a steep, wooded head-
land, which marks the start of the G reat Syrtis. They call it
“Cephalae.” From Carthage to this headland it is a little more Cephalae, Cape Misuarata
[ 1 ] “They” are Latin speakers; Strabo gives the Roman name Leptis [Magna] as well
as the Greek name “Neapolis.” Cf. 508 C, 10-18n.
956
Masylia + Carthage
835 C, 16-24 Inland from this stretch of coast, from Carthage to Cepha- 17.3.19
MASYLIAN, CARTHAGINIAN lae and to the Masaesylians, is the country of the Libyphoeni-
INTERIOR
e. Algeria, s. Tunisia, w. present- cians, g oing up into the mountainous territory of the Gaetu-
day Libya lians (which by this stage is Libyan territory). The country
above the Gaetulians belongs to the Garamantians, parallel
to that territory; it is from here that “Carthaginian stone”
is exported.1 It is said that the Garamantians are a journey
of nine—or even ten—days from the oceanic Ethiopians,2
and fifteen days from Ammon. Between the country of the Ammon, Aghurmi/Siwa (Egy.)
Gaetulians and the coastline of our sea are many plains, many coastline of our sea = Med.
coastline
mountain ranges, and huge lakes and rivers (some of which
disappear underground).
835 C, 24-29 The people are very simple in lifestyle and dress, with mul-
tiple wives and children; in other respects, they are similar to
Arabian nomads. Their horses and cattle have longer necks
than those found elsewhere. H orse breeding is taken excep-
tionally seriously by their rulers, so much so that the number
of foals is assessed annually at one hundred thousand. Sheep,
particularly in the vicinity of the Ethiopians, are fed on milk
and meat.
835 C, 30 That was the interior. |
835 C, 30–836 C, 5 The Great Syrtis 3 has a circumference of some . . . * 17.3.20
GREAT SYRTIS stades. The dimension to its innermost point is one thou-
bay in Med. Sea off present-
day Libya
sand five hundred stades, and the width at its mouth is
around the same. The problem, both with this Syrtis and the
Little Syrtis . . . * that the water is everywhere full of reefs,
whether the tides are low or high; it happens in the case of
some p eople that they run aground in the shallows and get
stuck there. Rare is the vessel that survives! Because of this,
people making the voyage keep their distance from the coast,
taking precautions lest they get driven into the bays, caught
off guard and blown there by the wind. Man’s venturesome
spirit makes him have a go at all things, coastal navigations
in particular!4
836 C, 6-10 As you sail into the G reat Syrtis, on your right a fter
Cephalae is a lake, some three hundred stades long and sev- Cephalae, Cape Misuarata
enty wide, opening into the bay, with some small islands and
an anchorage at its entrance. After the lake is a place, Aspis, Aspis, Buerat el-Hsun (Lib.)
957
5. Libya (= Africa)
836 C, 10-19 Next comes the Tower of Euphrantas, marking the boundary Tower of Euphrantas, Sirte/
Marsa Zaafran (Lib.)
GREAT SYRTIS cont. between what was earlier the land of the Carthaginians and
Ptolemaic Cyrenaea;1 then another place, called “Charax,” Charax, Medina Sultan/Sort
(Lib.)
which the Carthaginians used as a center for the export of
wine and the import of juice and silphium from t hose who
smuggled it out from Cyrene; then the Altars of Philaenus 2 Altars of Philaenus, Graret Gser
et-Trab (Lib.)
and, after them, situated at the innermost point of the whole
bay, the fortress of Automala with its garrison. The paral- Automala, Bu Sceefa (Lib.)
lel through this innermost point is a little more to the south parallel = line of latitude
called “Borium,” which, together with Cephalae, forms the Borium, Ras Taiunes
836 C, 29-34 Berenice lies opposite the end of the Peloponnese, at what
is called “Ichthys,”5 and furthermore opposite Zacynthus,6 Ichthys, Akra Katakolon (Gr.)
three thousand six hundred stades across the w ater. Start- Zacynthus, Zakynthos (Gk.
island)
ing from this city, Marcus Cato completed on the thirtieth
day an overland journey around the Syrtis, leading an army of
more than ten thousand men, dividing the journey into stages
for the sake of obtaining w ater supplies; he traveled on foot,
through deep sand and searing heat.
836 C, 35–837 C, 4 After Berenice is the city of Tauchira, which is also called Tauchira/Arsinoe, Tocra (Lib.)
“Arsinoe”; then what was formerly “Barca” and is now Barca, el-Merg/al-Marj (Lib.)
958
Cyrenaea
Phycus (headland), Ras Aamer/ “Ptolemaïs”; then the headland of Phycus, low-lying but
Ras Sen (Lib.)
protruding farther north than the rest of the Libyan coast- Ptolemaïs, Tolmeta/Tulmeitia
(Lib.)
line. Phycus is opposite Taenarum in Laconia,1 two thousand
Taenarum, Akra Tainaron (Gr.)
Phycus (town), Zaviet
eight hundred stades across the w ater. There is also a small
el-Hamama (Lib.) town with the same name as the headland.
837 C, 4-15 Not far from Phycus, at a distance of some one hundred
and seventy stades, is the Cyrenaean sea port of Apollonia, Apollonia, Marsa Susa (Lib.)
when I saw her from the sea.2 | The city was founded by the city = Cyrene 17.3.21
inhabitants of the Laconian island of Thera, called “Callista” Thera, Santorini (Gk. island)
Callimachus (3rd c. BCE) in ancient times, according to Callimachus: “Callista” of old,
then “Thera” by name, / m other of my horse-rich fatherland. The
Cyrenaean seaport lies opposite the western end of Crete Cyrenaean seaport = Apollonia
(Criu Metopum),3 two thousand stades across the sea. The Criu Metopum, Cape Krios
(Kriti/Crete)
Leuconotus, south wind voyage is made with Leuconotus.
837 C, 15-23 Cyrene is said to have been founded by Battus, whom
Callimachus describes as an ancestor of his. She flourished
as a result of the superb quality of her territory, which is
tremendously conducive to horse-breeding and very fertile.
She has produced many men of renown, signally capable of
standing up for freedom and holding out against the natives
of the interior. Long ago, the city was self-ruled. Then the
Macedonians who controlled Egypt, having grown strong,
attacked her inhabitants when she was u nder the rule of those
around Thibro,4 the destroyer of Harpalus. A fter a period of
monarchical rule, the inhabitants fell under Roman domina-
tion. Now the city is ruled provincially, together with Crete.
837 C, 23-28 Apollonia, Barca, Tauchira, Berenice, and some further
towns nearby, are dependencies of Cyrene. | On the border 17.3.22
[ 1 ] The sense is that Phycus (Ras Aamer/Ras Sen, Lib.) is supposed to lie due south
of Taenarum (Akra Tainaron, Gr.): 827 C, 31–828 C, 3n.
[ 2 ] Strabo’s voyage is presumably associated with his long stay in Egypt (early 20s
BCE onward): 101 C, 14-24n; 117 C, 35–118 C, 14nn.
[ 3 ] The sense is that Apollonia (Marsa Susa, Lib.) is supposed to lie due south of
Criu Metopum (Cape Krios, Kriti/Crete): 827 C, 31–828 C, 3n.
[ 4 ] “Those around Thibro” is idiomatic, meaning simply Thibro.
[ 5 ] Or possibly “Nomades” as a proper name: 833 C, 17–29n.
959
5. Libya (= Africa)
stathmus; Zephyrium, with its anchorage; another Zephy- Zephyrium, Ras Bu Meddad
rium; the headland of Cherronesus, with a harbor, lying op- Cherronesus, Ras et-Tin
Caudus, Gavdos (island off Kriti/ posite Cretan Caudus1 (which is one thousand five hundred
Crete)
stades across the w
ater, with Notus); then Hera’s t emple and,
with Notus = with south wind—
i.e., heading north
above it, the village of Paliurus; then a harbor, Menelaus, and Paliurus, Wadi et-Tmimi (Lib.)
the headland of Ardanixis, low-lying and with an anchorage; Menelaus, ?Marsa Ahora (Lib.)
then G reat Harbor,2 opposite which is situated the Cretan Ardanixis, Ras el-Milah
Cherronesus, leaving a space of some two thousand stades be-
tween the two. The w hole of Crete, being narrow and long,
lies virtually opposite and parallel to this stretch of coastline.
838 C, 19-23 After Great Harbor, there’s another harbor, Plynus and, Plynus/Catabathmus, Sollum
(Egy.)
above it, a four-towered fortification. The place is called
“Catabathmus.” Cyrenaea reaches this point. The final re-
maining stretch to Paraetonium and onward to Alexandria
is described in my Aegyptiaca.3 |
838 C, 24-32 The miserable and drought-stricken territory in the deep 17.3.23
CYRENAEAN INTERIOR interior above the Syrtis and Cyrenaea is occupied by Liby-
s. present-day Libya, s. present-
day Egypt, ?n. Chad ans: initially, by Nasamonians, then by Psyllians, some Gaetu-
lians, and Garamantians, and farther east by Marmaridans,
who border for the most part on Cyrenaea and stretch as far
as Ammon. It is said that, if you walk in the direction of the Ammon, Aghurmi/Siwa (Egy.)
winter sunrise from the Automala region of the Great Syrtis, Automala, Bu Sceefa (Lib.)
you reach Augila on the fourth day. This place is similar to Augila, Giala (Lib.)
Ammon, with date palms and plenty of water, and lies inland
and south of Cyrenaea.
960
Cyrenaea
838 C, 32–839 C, 3 For one hundred stades, the land is tree-covered; for an-
other one hundred stades, seed has to be sown—the land is
too dry to support root growth; above this is the land that
produces silphium, then land that is uninhabited and the land
belonging to the Garamantians. The country where silphium is
produced is narrow, long, and arid. Its length, as you go east,
is some one thousand nine hundred stades; its width is three
hundred or slightly more, as far as is known.
839 C, 3-9 It is possible to conjecture that all adjacent territory lying
on the same parallel is such as this, in regard to climate and
produce. Since several deserts intervene, we do not know all
the places. Similarly unknown are the regions above Ammon
and the oases as far as Ethiopia; nor would I be able to state
the boundaries of Ethiopia nor of Libya, not with any cer-
tainty in the parts t oward Egypt, and not at all in the parts
toward the ocean. |
839 C, 10 Such is the way in which the sections of the lived-in world 17.3.24
are disposed.1
[ 1 ] With these words, Strabo concludes his description of the three continents of
the lived-in world, as previewed (126 C, 24–131 C, 26) more than 700 C-pages
earlier.
961
E PILO G UE The Roman Empire
(late 1st c. BCE–early 1st c. CE)
Translator’s Introduction
By the time Strabo reaches this concluding section of his work, he has written (or dic-
tated, or delivered in lecture form) some three hundred thousand words, over a period
of some six or seven years. He is probably in his mid-eighties, and he may be in ill health.
These facts alone might explain why his work ends with less of a bang than a whimper.
The brevity of this final section, in which Strabo provides a terse account of the Roman
empire, may also reflect Strabo’s distaste for politics, the ephemeral nature of which he
laments throughout his work.
Strabo claims that the three continents constituting the lived-in world are largely
under the control of Rome. To make his case, he treats as being under Roman control
territories belonging to kings, dynasts, and priests acting as proxies for Rome, as well as
provinces under direct Roman administration. Even so, Strabo has to make extensive
exceptions. Europe is subject to the Romans—except the area east of the Rhine and north
of the Danube. As for Libya (= Africa), the part bordering on the Mediterranean Sea is
subject to the Romans—and the rest is not worth having. Nearly all of Asia on the coast
of “our sea” (coast of Mediterranean Sea + Black Sea + Sea of Azov), together with much
of what Strabo calls the Asian “interior,” is subject to the Romans—but Strabo admits
that large parts of the Asian interior are excluded—not least, India, Parthia, and Arabia.
Narrowing his focus to areas u nder direct Roman administration, Strabo notes the
important distinction made by the first Roman emperor, Augustus, who categorized one
part of the empire as “belonging to Caesar” and the provinces within it as “Caesar’s prov-
inces.” Augustus categorized the other part of the empire as “belonging to the people”
and the provinces within it as the “people’s provinces.”
Strabo proceeds to list the “people’s provinces.” It is at this point that the brevity
of Strabo’s account becomes problematic. The first people’s province named is “Libya”
(eastern Algeria, Tunisia, western present-day Libya), the province sitting on the northern
shore of the continent known in Strabo’s day by the same name. Strabo then qualifies
his statement with the phrase “the part subject to Roman control.” He seems to have
implicitly switched from understanding the name “Libya” in a provincial sense to under-
standing it in a continental sense. Moreover, Strabo goes on to make a further exclusion,
specifically the territory “formerly subject to Juba” and “now subject to his son, Ptolemy.”
Although Strabo does not name the territory in question, the reference would naturally
963
Epilogue
964
Translator’s Introduction
We could, just about, construe Strabo’s grammar to make an implied contrast between
the European praetorian provinces, on the one hand, and the non-European provinces
listed in eighth, ninth, and tenth positions, on the other hand. Strabo’s careful enumera-
tion of the ten praetorian provinces, however, gainsays such a construction. Rather, it
seems to be the case that Strabo is forfeiting geographical exactitude for literary sym-
metry. He fits his description of the p eople’s provinces into a continental framework that
mirrors his preceding narrative, neatly distributing them between Libya and Asia (in
the case of the consular provinces) and E urope (in the case of the praetorian provinces).
Nor is it only geographic al exactitude that Strabo forfeits. Strabo’s account is temporally
imprecise as well. Some of the praetorian provinces listed as belonging to the people
were not transferred to the p eople’s portion of the empire u ntil after Augustus’s initial
organization; o thers were subsequently removed from the people’s portion. Strabo’s list
is therefore valid only for a period of ten years or so within Augustus’s reign.
There is further evidence for temporal dislocation in Strabo’s account of the prov-
inces. In discussing Libya and excepting from the part subject to Roman control the ter-
ritory “formerly subject to Juba,” Strabo could mean Numidia, the territory immediately
west of the Roman province of Libya, which may have temporarily belonged to Juba at
the time of Augustus’s initial organization. However, this would make a nonsense of
Strabo’s description of the territory as “now subject to [Juba’s] son, Ptolemy,” which is
very clearly a reference to Maurusia. Could Strabo mean that a portion of Numidia was
added to the kingdom of Maurusia?1 If so, the phraseology is misleading: the territory
“now subject to Ptolemy” would naturally be understood by Strabo’s audience to refer
to Maurusia as a w hole.
Strabo’s final account of the provinces is unsatisfactory in so many ways that it seems
probable that Strabo—as well as being in a hurry to finish his work—is following some
official and doctored version of events, one that is rhetorically striking rather than geo
graphically or temporally exact. The attempt to create the impression that Rome controls
(almost) all the world is not quite in keeping with Strabo’s work as a w hole, in which it
is clear that large areas remain unconquered. More in keeping with the tenor of Strabo’s
work are the lines that introduce his brief final account. The part of the lived-in world
that is controlled by the Romans is, says Strabo, the “best and most famous part.” This
is a statement with which Strabo can agree and to which his whole work is testament.
965
E PILO G UE The Roman Empire
(late 1st c. BCE–early 1st c. CE)
839 C, 10-16 Since the best and most famous part of the lived-in world 17.3.24 cont.
• they possess nearly all of E urope, except for the part they = Romans
beyond the Ister and except for the oceanic coast be- beyond Ister = north of
Danube r.
tween the Rhine and the Tanaïs; 2
Tanaïs, Don r.
• the entire coastline of Libya on our sea is subject to
Libya = Africa
them 3—the rest of Libya is either uninhabited or sup-
ports only a miserable and nomadic lifestyle;
• with regard to Asia,4 its entire coastline on our sea 5 is
similarly in their hands (if one ignores the bits belong-
ing to the Achaeans, Zygans, and Heniochans, who live
piratical and nomadic lives in their miserable and re-
stricted l ittle territories), while as for the deep interior,
they hold part, while part is held by the Parthians and they = Romans
by the natives living beyond them to the east and north
(Indians, Bactrians, and Scythians), and then by Arabs
and Ethiopians 6—but t here is always some piece or
other being transferred from t hese people to them.
839 C, 26-31 Of all the territory that is subject to the Romans, part is
ruled by kings, and part they hold in their own right u nder they = Romans
967
Epilogue
Caesar’s provinces governed by are called “Caesar’s provinces,” and some “provinces of the
appointees of Caesar
people.” To “Caesar’s provinces,” governors and procurators
Provinces of the people are sent out by Caesar, who divides the territories differently Caesar at the time when Strabo
governed by officials sent by is writing is the emperor
the senate and p
eople
at different times and governs them in accordance with cir- Tiberius
cumstance. To the “provinces of the people,” praetors or con-
suls are sent out by the p eople.
Consular provinces of the • two “consular” provinces, namely “Libya”4 (the part
people
subject to Roman control,5 except for what was for-
merly subject to Juba and is now subject to his son,
Ptolemy)6 and “Asia”7 (the part within the Halys
and the Taurus,8 excluding the Galatians and nations
subject to Amyntas,9 also excluding Bithynia and the
Propontis);
[ 1 ] Dynasts as Roman appointees: 288 C, 4-16; 322 C, 14-21. [ 7 ] I.e., the Roman province called “Asia.” References to the province: 575 C, 24-30n;
[ 2 ] Phylarchs (lit., “tribal chiefs”), a term used of Arab leaders: 748 C, 6-24; 752 C, 577 C, 20-31n; 631 C, 5-18n; 647 C, 18-30n; 648 C, 29–649 C, 10n; 659 C, 17-32n.
31–753 C, 20. [ 8 ] I.e., the part of the continent called “Asia.”
[ 3 ] E.g., priests at Pontic Comana (Kılıçlı, n. Tky.): 558 C, 8–559 C, 7. [ 9 ] Galatia and nations subject to Amyntas: 566 C, 31–571 C, 17. By the time Strabo
[ 4 ] I.e., the Roman province called “Libya.” writes, Galatia is a Roman province, belonging to Caesar.
[ 5 ] I.e., the part of the continent called “Libya”?
[ 6 ] Strabo updates his e arlier statement (288 C, 1-4, written when Juba was still
alive and king of Maurusia); cf. 828 C, 27-34; 829 C, 25-31. Maurusia: 825 C, 20–
831 C, 19.
968
The Roman Empire and Provinces
Praetorian provinces of the • and ten “praetorian” provinces—in Europe and its
people
associated islands: “Outer Iberia,” as it was called (the
part associated with the Baetis river and the Anas) and
“Narbonitis” in Celtica; third, “Sardo plus Cyrnus”; Sardo, Sardinia (It. island)
fourth, “Sicily”; fifth and sixth, the part of Illyria “by Cyrnus, Corsica (Fr. island)
Caesar’s Provinces
840 C, 26-28 Caesar holds the other provinces. To look a fter them, he
Caesar’s portion of empire sends men of consular rank to some, men of praetorian rank
to some, and men of equestrian rank to others.
969
A Directory for the Modern Reader
This directory allows readers to approach Strabo’s narrative via familiar names that are
in use today. The present-day names are given first; they are followed by a selection of
ancient names used by Strabo for the peoples or lands that spanned, lay within, or en-
compassed the areas denoted by the present-day names. The correlation between ancient
and modern names is only approximate, given that Strabo is often vague about the loca-
tion of the peoples and lands he discusses. Nor is the list of ancient names exhaustive,
representing only a sprinkling of the names used by Strabo.
The second column lists the passages where the relevant lands or peoples are de-
scribed. This directory differs from a traditional index in that it does not include all the
passages where the ancient names occur. It restricts itself to the most informative pas-
sages, with particularly salient passages marked in bold.
The chosen system of reference within the directory—through the paragraph iden-
tifiers provided in the left-hand margin of the translation—means that the references
are more targeted than would be the case with page numbers and additionally allows
specialist readers to use the directory to refer to the Greek text by S. L. Radt on which
the translation is based.
Modern and ancient names are given in the forms used throughout the translation.
A
AFGHANISTAN 516 C, 1–518 C, 20; 723 C, 15–725 C, 21.129 C, 15-26; 130 C,
2nd section of northern Asia, southern Asia, Bactria(na), 6-14; 514 C, 8-22; 687 C, 31–688 C, 14; 697 C, 4–698 C, 7;
Aria(na), Paropamisus mts. 720 C, 8-14
971
A Directory for the Modern Reader
AUSTRIA. See also ALPS 206 C, 5–207 C, 17.128 C, 16-24; 128 C, 31–129 C, 3; 214 C,
Rhaetians, Vindolicians, Noricans 24-28; 292 C, 16-32
B
BAHRAIN 765 C, 21–767 C, 2.121 C, 16-21; 130 C, 18-24
(Blessed) Arabia, Tyrus, Aradus, Persian gulf
C
?CANARY ISLANDS (Sp. islands) 150 C, 19-29n.2 C, 34–3 C, 12n
islands of the Blessed
CASPIAN SEA 506 C, 33–511 C, 27; 518 C, 34–519 C, 3n.121 C, 16-21; 509 C,
Caspian sea, Hyrcanian sea, Hyrcanian gulf 4-11; 512 C, 26–513 C, 1; 518 C, 9-20
CORSICA (Fr. island) 224 C, 20-33.117 C, 12-20n; 122 C, 34–123 C, 9; 222 C, 9-22n;
Cyrnus 223 C, 24–224 C, 8nn; 225 C, 20-24; 840 C, 13-26
972
A Directory for the Modern Reader
D
?DENMARK 292 C, 33–293 C, 8
Cimbrians
E
EGYPT 759 C, 9–761 C, 8; 768 C, 27–770 C, 13; 785 C, 13–824 C, 21.
southern Asia, Egypt, Arabian gulf, Nile region, 130 C, 18-24; 133 C, 10-17; 133 C, 29–134 C, 2; 518 C, 20-25;
Ethiopians, Phoenicia, Aelanites gulf, Arabian gulf, 685 C, 6-10; 776 C, 21–777 C, 3; 780 C, 1–782 C, 26; 838 C,
Trogodytes, Nasamonians, ?Maranites, ?Garindaeans 9–839 C, 9
ELBA (It. island) 224 C, 9-19.122 C, 34–123 C, 9; 222 C, 9-22n; 223 C, 24–224
Aethalia C, 3; 225 C, 20-24
F
FORMENTERA (Sp. island) 167 C, 19-22
Ophiussa, Pityussans
FRANCE. See also CORSICA; PYRENEES 176 C, 13–199 C, 10; 203 C, 1–204 C, 33; 208 C, 5-19.63 C,
Celtica (beyond the Alps), outer Celtica, Aquitanians, 14-34; 64 C, 8-26; 71 C, 24–72 C, 15; 105 C, 8-21; 106 C,
Belgans, Celts, Narbonitis, Sallyans, Alps, Massalia, 10-21; 115 C, 4-21; 122 C, 16-23; 128 C, 3-24; 137 C, 15-20;
Cyrnus, ?Cattiterides 146 C, 17-19; 175 C, 25–176 C, 8; 200 C, 28–201 C, 20; 205 C,
1-6; 840 C, 13-26
G
GAZA STRIP 759 C, 19-27.756 C, 18-21; 759 C, 33–760 C, 10
Gaza, Phoenicia
GREAT BRITAIN 199 C, 10–201 C, 2.63 C, 14-23; 115 C, 22–116 C, 6; 120 C, 3-9;
Brettanica, Cantium, Brettanic Isles, ?Cattiterides 129 C, 4-9; 147 C, 21-28; 175 C, 25–176 C, 8; 193 C, 9-14; 193
C, 34–194 C, 2
973
A Directory for the Modern Reader
GREECE and islands. See also KHIOS; KOS; KRITI; 323 C, 3–489 C, 27; 616 C, 23–618 C, 27; 636 C, 33–639 C,
LESBOS; PELOPONNESE; RHODOS; SAMOS 14; 645 C, 10-31; 652 C, 10–655 C, 28; 657 C, 15–658 C, 4.
eastern Europe, 5 bands of Greece, Peloponnese, 123 C, 21–124 C, 28; 128 C, 31–129 C, 9; 840 C, 13-26
Megaris, Attica, Boeotia, Phocis, Locris, Thessalians,
Aetolians, Acarnanians, Euboea, Cyclades, Sporades,
Crete, Cos, Rhodes, Samos, Chios, Lesbos, Epirus,
Macedonians, Thracians
H
HIMALAYAS 510 C, 26–511 C, 8; 518 C, 34–519 C, 31; 689 C, 3-7; 710 C,
2nd section of northern Asia, northern India, Caucasus, 26–711 C, 2.67 C, 7–68 C, 9; 129 C, 15-22
Taurus, Emoda, Ima(e)um
I
IBIZA (Sp. island) 167 C, 19-22.122 C, 34–123 C, 9
Ebusus/Ebysus, Pityussans
IRAN and islands 506 C, 33–511 C, 8; 514 C, 24–515 C, 29; 520 C, 22–533 C,
2nd and 3rd sections of northern Asia, southern Asia, 4; 720 C, 8–736 C, 12; 744 C, 4–745 C, 7; 765 C, 27–766 C,
Hyrcania, Nesaea, Parthia, (Great) Media, Atropatian 6; 767 C, 3–767 C, 14.78 C, 8–85 C, 5; 129 C, 15-22n; 129 C,
Media, Armenia, Ariana, Carmania, Gedrosia, Persia, 27–130 C, 3n; 130 C, 4-18nn; 492 C, 10-19
Susis, Cossaea, Paraetacene, Elymaea, Ichthyophagi,
Persian gulf, Doracta, 2nd and 3rd sphragides
ITALY and islands. See also ELBA; SARDINIA; SICILY 201 C, 31–288 C, 33.122 C, 34–123 C, 9; 123 C, 21–124 C, 10;
Celtica this side of the Alps, beyond the Padus, this side 128 C, 16-30; 129 C, 4-9; 834 C, 1-22nn
of the Padus, Italy, Ligyans, Salassians, Tyrrhenia, Umbria,
Sabina, Latina, Campania, Rome, Leucania, Brettia, Sicily,
Aethalia, Sardo, Lopadussa, Cossura/Cossurus
J
JORDAN 760 C, 17-31; 762 C, 30–764 C, 31; 779 C, 19-35.755 C, 6-13n;
Nabataea, Judaea, Aelanites, Arabia, Syria 759 C, 9-18n; 759 C, 19-27; 767 C, 22-30; 768 C, 21-34; 776 C,
21–777 C, 15; 803 C, 3-12
974
A Directory for the Modern Reader
K
KAZAKHSTAN and region 506 C, 33–514 C, 23.129 C, 15-26; 516 C, 17–518 C, 34
2nd section of northern Asia, Daans/Dahae, Left-Hand
Side of Caspian Sea, Massagetans, Sacans, Sogdians
KOSOVO 316 C, 2-12; 318 C, 18-27.128 C, 31–129 C, 3n; 289 C, 1-21; 295
Dardanians, Moesians, Illyrians C, 16-22; 303 C, 19-31; 313 C, 5-22
KRITI/CRETE (Gk. island) 474 C, 21–484 C, 18.124 C, 11-24; 466 C, 9–474 C, 15; 488 C,
Crete 11-23; 840 C, 13-26
KYPROS/CYPRUS, KIBRIS 681 C, 25–685 C, 5.124 C, 16-24n; 125 C, 25-31; 488 C, 16-23;
Cyprus 840 C, 13-26
L
LEBANON 754 C, 28–758 C, 30.760 C, 11-16
Coele Syria, Phoenicia
M
?MADEIRA (Port. island) 150 C, 19-29n.2 C, 34–3 C, 12n
islands of the Blessed
MALLORCA and MENORCA (Sp. islands) 167 C, 15–168 C, 24.122 C, 34–123 C, 9; 129 C, 4-9; 654 C,
Gymnesians, Balearics 19–655 C, 2
975
A Directory for the Modern Reader
N
NEPAL. See also HIMALAYAS 702 C, 27–703 C, 27; 710 C, 26–711 C, 2
beyond the Hypanis, Ima(e)um, Caucasus
NETHERLANDS 194 C, 3-9; 290 C, 1-17; 291 C, 7-10.128 C, 3-16; 128 C, 31–129
Celtica, Belgans, Menapians, Germans C, 3
NORTH MACEDONIA 316 C, 2-12; 322 C, 28–323 C, 13; 326 C, 14–327 C, 19.128 C,
Paeonians, Maedians, Dardanians 31–129 C, 3; 289 C, 1-21; 313 C, 5-19; 329 C, 15–332 C, 1
O
OMAN 765 C, 21–768 C, 6.726 C, 18-28
(Blessed) Arabia, Macaeans
P
PAKISTAN 685 C, 11–726 C, 17.78 C, 8-25; 130 C, 6-14; 133 C, 14-17;
India, Gedrosia, Ariana, Patalene, Brachmanes, Sarmanes, 492 C, 16-19; others?
1st and 2nd sphragides
PERSIAN GULF 765 C, 27–767 C, 21.?729 C, 6-21; ?732 C, 2-6; 121 C, 16-21
Persian gulf, Persian sea
Q
QATAR 765 C, 21–767 C, 2.121 C, 16-21; 130 C, 18-24
(Blessed) Arabia, Persian gulf
R
RED SEA 768 C, 27–773 C, 28; 776 C, 21–779 C, 18.121 C, 16-21
Arabian gulf, Erythra
976
A Directory for the Modern Reader
S
SAMOS (Gk. island) 636 C, 33–639 C, 2.124 C, 16-24; 457 C, 16-23; 488 C, 2-23
Samos
SARDINIA (It. island) 224 C, 34–225 C, 24.122 C, 34–123 C, 9; 222 C, 9-22 + note;
Sardo 223 C, 24–224 C, 8; 225 C, 20-24
SAUDI ARABIA 765 C, 12–769 C, 19; 776 C, 18–785 C, 19.85 C, 6-13; 130 C,
(Blessed) Arabia, 4th sphragis, ?Tiran, Arabian gulf, 18-24
Persian gulf
SERBIA 289 C, 1-21; 294 C, 34–295 C, 36; 303 C, 19-31; 316 C, 2-12;
Moesians, Pannonia, Illyrians, Dacians, Triballians, 317 C, 22–318 C, 27.128 C, 31–129 C, 3; 289 C, 1-21; 301 C,
Scordiscans, Dardanians 21-28; 304 C, 16–305 C, 15; 313 C, 5–314 C, 5; 316 C, 2-12
SICILY (It. island) 265 C, 27–275 C, 19.23 C, 28–25 C, 32; 54 C, 4-15; 54 C, 31–55
Sicily C, 10; 122 C, 23–123 C, 9; 248 C, 6-16; 840 C, 13-26
SOUTH SUDAN 786 C, 15–787 C, 11; 819 C, 33–823 C, 8.114 C, 6-11; 118 C,
Ethiopians, southern limit of lived-in world 36–119 C, 8; 133 C, 2-4n
SPAIN and islands. See also FORMENTERA; IBIZA; 136 C, 18–176 C, 2.127 C, 26–128 C, 2; 129 C, 4-9; 286 C,
MALLORCA and MENORCA 22-26n; 827 C, 24-28; 832 C, 25-31; 840 C, 13-26
Iberia, Celtiberia, Gadira, Baetica, Turdetania,
Lusitanians, Gymnesian islands, Pityussan islands
SUDAN 768 C, 27–772 C, 31; 785 C, 20–787 C, 11; 819 C, 7–823 C, 8.
Trogodytes, Ethiopians, Libyans, Blemmyans, Nubians, 62 C, 33–63 C, 9; 77 C, 3-15; 114 C, 6-11; 130 C, 18–131 C, 19;
Megabarians, Meroe, southern limit of lived-in world 780 C, 1-11; 789 C, 23–790 C, 8; 825 C, 11-19
SWITZERLAND. See also ALPS 192 C, 31–193 C, 30.128 C, 3-24; 204 C, 8-14; 205 C, 1-6; 206
Helvettians, Rhaetians C, 5–207 C, 17; 208 C, 14-19; 292 C, 16-31
977
A Directory for the Modern Reader
T
TAJIKISTAN and region 510 C, 26–514 C, 23; 516 C, 17–520 C, 21.129 C, 15-26
2nd section of northern Asia, Sogdians, Sacans
TUNISIA and islands 831 C, 19–835 C, 30.123 C, 13-21; 277 C, 20-25; 840 C, 13-26
Masylia, Carthage, Numidians, Libyphoenicians,
Gaetulians, Garamantians, Aegimurus
TURKEY and islands 319 C, 20–321 C, 2; 322 C, 28–323 C, 21; 520 C, 22–522 C, 27;
3rd and 4th sections of northern Asia, inside the Taurus, 526 C, 34–685 C, 5; 746 C, 14–748 C, 6; 749 C, 8–75 C, 35.
eastern Europe, southern Asia, Armenia, Cappadocia, 117 C, 12-20 + note; 124 C, 16–126 C, 11; 128 C, 31–129 C, 3n;
Cilicia, Pontus, Bithynia, Paphlagonia, Galatia, Pisidia, 129 C, 10-15; 129 C, 27–130 C, 6; 130 C, 14-24 + notes; 329 C,
Lycaonia, Mysia, Phrygia, Caria, Troad, Troy, Aeolid, Lydia, 15–332 C, 1; 490 C, 3–491 C, 5; 492 C, 10-16; 736 C, 13–737 C,
Lycia, Ionia, Pamphylia, Thracian Bosporus, Hellespont, 8; 840 C, 13-26
Thracian Cherronesus, Sestus/Abydus straits, Propontis,
Greece, north Mesopotamia, Gordyaea, Seleucis,
Commagene, Rhodia, Rhodian Peraea, Tenedos
U
UKRAINE. See also CRIMEA 305 C, 16–312 C, 28.126 C, 30–127 C, 7; 128 C, 31–129 C, 3;
Tyregetans, Bastarnians, Sauromatians, Iazyges, 289 C, 1-21
Scythians, Cherronesus
UNITED ARAB EMIRATES (UAE) 765 C, 21–767 C, 2.121 C, 16-21; 130 C, 18-24
(Blessed) Arabia, Macaeans, Persian gulf
UZBEKISTAN and region 508 C, 27–514 C, 23; 516 C, 17–519 C, 3.129 C, 15-26; 724
2nd section of northern Asia, Massagetans, Bactria, C, 6-8
Sogdians, Sacans
W
WEST BANK 760 C, 17-31; 762 C, 30–764 C, 17.749 C, 14-21; 755 C, 6-13n
Judaea, Jordan r.
Y
YEMEN 768 C, 7–769 C, 12; 769 C, 20–770 C, 2; 777 C, 31–779 C, 18;
(Blessed) Arabia, Minaeans, Sabaeans, Cattabanians, 781 C, 29–782 C, 8; 782 C, 27–783 C, 22.130 C, 18-24; 765
Chatramotitans, Aromatophorus C, 21-26
978
Index of Ancient Names
The chosen system of reference within the index—through the paragraph identifiers
provided in the left-hand margin of the translation—means that the references are more
targeted than would be the case with page numbers and additionally allows specialist
readers to use the index to refer to the Greek text by S. L. Radt on which the translation
is based.
979
Index of Ancient Names
980
Index of Ancient Names
981
Index of Ancient Names
Agraea, Agraeans (Aetolia):338 C, 31-32; 449 C, Alexander (Balas):624 C, 22-30; 751 C, 18-26
36–450 C, 13; 451 C, 8-16; 465 C, 26–466 C, 7 Alexander (Jannaeus):762 C, 30–763 C, 5
Agraeans (Arabia):767 C, 22-30 Alexander (Lychnus):642 C, 2-11
Agrianians:317 C, 29–318 C, 5 Alexander (of Aetolia):566 C, 6-18; 648 C, 6-15; 681 C, 3-24
Agrians:495 C, 16-27 Alexander (?of Epirus):232 C, 6-19
Agrippa:194 C, 3-9; 208 C, 8-14; 235 C, 19-32; 245 C, 4-18; Alexander (?of Myndus):768 C, 27-34
359 C, 30-33; 589 C, 33–590 C, 2; 755 C, 30–756 C, 4 Alexander (Philalethes):580 C, 6-10
Agrius:462 C, 31–463 C, 7; 465 C, 26–466 C, 7 Alexander (?the Great):232 C, 6-19
Agylla:220 C, 19-30; 225 C, 29–226 C, 8 Alexander (the Great):14 C, 10-21; 48 C, 29-34; 66 C,
Aianis:425 C, 31-38 23–67 C, 6; 69 C, 26-30; 79 C, 20-32; 171 C, 1-14;
Aianium:425 C, 31-38 232 C, 6-19 (?);301 C, 21–302 C, 4; 447 C, 4-13; 505 C,
Aias (river):271 C, 33-37; 316 C, 13-20 10–506 C, 3; 507 C, 26–508 C, 9; 509 C, 26–510 C, 14;
Aias (the Locrian):425 C, 31-38; 600 C, 24–601 C, 4 513 C, 25-29; 514 C, 8-14; 516 C, 17-28; 517 C, 5–518 C, 4;
Aiga:615 C, 8-17 518 C, 26-34; 524 C, 15-23; 529 C, 31–530 C, 12; 530 C,
Ajax (son of Telamon):394 C, 1-33; 408 C, 6-15; 595 C, 18–531 C, 1; 569 C, 10-23; 571 C, 6-17; 579 C, 10-21;
20-27; 595 C, 35–596 C, 5 587 C, 15-23; 593 C, 19–594 C, 1; 594 C, 18–595 C, 5;
Ajax (son of Teucer):672 C, 10-22 623 C, 17-34; 635 C, 25-28; 640 C, 10–641 C, 23; 644 C,
Alabanda:655 C, 17-28; 658 C, 26–659 C, 5; 660 C, 15-22; 656 C, 24–657 C, 11; 666 C, 20–667 C, 2; 676 C,
30–661 C, 4; 663 C, 8-14 7-13; 676 C, 20-28; 685 C, 11–687 C, 8; 687 C, 31–689 C,
Alaesa:266 C, 6-19; 272 C, 10-16 2; 696 C, 14-26; 697 C, 4–702 C, 10; 714 C, 5-13; 714 C,
Alalcomenae:410 C, 29–411 C, 7; 413 C, 21-36 34–715 C, 15; 716 C, 5-11; 717 C, 21–718 C, 14; 721 C,
Alalcomenium:410 C, 22-28 17–723 C, 14; 724 C, 9–725 C, 16; 729 C, 22–730 C, 18;
Alasyaeum:341 C, 29–342 C, 5 730 C, 35–731 C, 24; 736 C, 3-11; 737 C, 34–738 C, 4;
Alazia:550 C, 32–551 C, 13 738 C, 19-25; 739 C, 29–740 C, 17; 741 C, 1-24; 743 C,
Alazonians:550 C, 9-15; 550 C, 32–551 C, 9 11-20; 746 C, 14-23; 752 C, 8-22; 756 C, 31–757 C, 16;
Alazonium:551 C, 37–552 C, 8; 603 C, 13-21 759 C, 19-27; 785 C, 6-12; 792 C, 24-31; 795 C, 28-33;
Alazonius:499 C, 35–500 C, 11; 502 C, 27–503 C, 6 813 C, 31–814 C, 22
Alba (Fucens):235 C, 6-12; 238 C, 13-15; 240 C, 9-21 Alexander (the Molossian):256 C, 3-13; 280 C, 20-30
Alba (Longa):229 C, 4-16; 229 C, 20-28; 230 C, 2-10; 231 C, Alexandria (Aria):514 C, 8-22; 516 C, 1-11; 723 C, 26–724 C, 6
6-17 Alexandria (Egypt):58 C, 24-32; 62 C, 22-29; 62 C,
Albania, Albanians:117 C, 35–118 C, 14; 129 C, 22-26; 288 C, 33–63 C, 9; 76 C, 21-23; 85 C, 27–86 C, 10; 92 C,
4-16; 491 C, 12–492 C, 9; 497 C, 11-26; 499 C, 28–500 C, 29–93 C, 6; 101 C, 14-24; 114 C, 1-24; 117 C, 35–118 C, 14;
11; 500 C, 27–501 C, 4; 501 C, 13–504 C, 13; 506 C, 4-15; 125 C, 25–126 C, 3; 126 C, 12-23; 130 C, 25-32; 133 C, 5-8;
507 C, 6-13; 508 C, 10-18; 509 C, 11-25; 513 C, 30–514 C, 133 C, 26-32; 134 C, 15-24; 213 C, 27–214 C, 4; 489 C,
7; 521 C, 26–522 C, 4; 526 C, 34–527 C, 9; 529 C, 6-11; 532 C, 7-25; 609 C, 16-22; 641 C, 5-14; 670 C, 12-30;
31–530 C, 12; 531 C, 26–532 C, 7; 557 C, 3-13 673 C, 23–674 C, 6; 675 C, 7-18; 683 C, 17-27; 750 C,
Albanum:229 C, 4-16; 237 C, 4-13; 239 C, 9-20; 239 C, 11-24; 757 C, 32–758 C, 15; 774 C, 23-30; 781 C, 16-21;
9–240 C, 3; 240 C, 4-7 782 C, 19-26; 791 C, 10–798 C, 27; 799 C, 6–801 C,
Albian mountain range:314 C, 9-14; 314 C, 31–315 C, 3 27; 803 C, 33–804 C, 9; 806 C, 31–807 C, 3; 807 C,
Albians:202 C, 7-14; 203 C, 16-19 32–808 C, 2; 809 C, 10-21; 818 C, 22-32; 819 C, 22-29;
Albingaunum:202 C, 3-14 823 C, 23-32; 825 C, 11-19; 836 C, 10-19; 838 C, 19-23
Albioecans:203 C, 16-19 Alexandria (Issian gulf):676 C, 20-28
Albium Intimilium:202 C, 3-6 Alexandria (mountain):606 C, 27-33
Albula waters:238 C, 16-26 Alexandria/Antigonia (Troad):134 C, 15-24; 472 C,
Alcaeus:36 C, 34–37 C, 4; 411 C, 16-26; 412 C, 32-35; 599 C, 20–473 C, 9; 581 C, 13–582 C, 3; 593 C, 19–594 C, 1;
34–600 C, 10; 606 C, 6-18; 617 C, 14-30; 618 C, 16-27 596 C, 31–597 C, 7; 599 C, 17-30; 604 C, 13-19; 607 C,
Alcestis:45 C, 10-23 6-19; 612 C, 28–613 C, 9
Alchaedamnus:752 C, 31–753 C, 10 Alexandrium (Chalcidis):644 C, 15-22
Alcmaeon:325 C, 29–326 C, 7; 423 C, 5-10; 461 C, 34–462 C, Alexandrium (Judaea):763 C, 5-10
15; 462 C, 20-27 Algidus:237 C, 4-13; 239 C, 9-20
Alcman:43 C, 5-13; 298 C, 19–299 C, 12; 340 C, 37–341 C, 3; Alinda:656 C, 24–657 C, 11
446 C, 21-25; 460 C, 12-18; 482 C, 3-10; 580 C, 11–581 C, 1 Alisium:340 C, 6-13; 341 C, 29–342 C, 5
Alcomenae:327 C, 12-19; 327 C, 19-24 Alisius:341 C, 29–342 C, 5; 352 C, 10-18
Alcyonian sea:393 C, 17-21; 400 C, 15-23 Allifae:237 C, 33–238 C, 12
Aleian plain:554 C, 24–555 C, 2; 676 C, 7-13; 676 C, 29-33 Allobrigans:185 C, 33–186 C, 21; 193 C, 30-34; 203 C, 16-22;
Alesia:191 C, 14-22 764 C, 34–765 C, 11
Aletes:389 C, 37-42 Allotrigians:155 C, 25-30
Aletia:282 C, 6-11 Alobe:550 C, 15-20; 551 C, 37–552 C, 8
Aletrium:237 C, 23-33 Alopa (Epicnemidian Locris):427 C, 15-16
Aleus:615 C, 18-27 Alopa (Opuntian Locris):60 C, 16-35; 426 C, 1-5; 430 C,
Alex:260 C, 18-34 33-38; 432 C, 31-37
Alexander (= Paris):40 C, 35–41 C, 15; 399 C, 14-22; 596 C, Alopa (Phthiotis):427 C, 15-16
31–597 C, 7. See also Paris Alopa (Western Locris):427 C, 15-16
982
Index of Ancient Names
Alope (Troad):550 C, 15-26; 551 C, 4-13; 551 C, 37–552 C, 8; Ambracian gulf:123 C, 21-29; 323 C, 9-15; 323 C, 21-31;
603 C, 21-24 324 C, 5-11; 324 C, 28–325 C, 8; 325 C, 12-20; 334 C, 28-
Alopecia:493 C, 17-24 33; 428 C, 1-14; 451 C, 29-33; 452 C, 8-15; 459 C, 17-18
Alorium:350 C, 2-6 Ambronians:183 C, 28–184 C, 5
Alphius:266 C, 34–267 C, 5; 270 C, 25–271 C, 9; 271 C, 18- Ambrysians:424 C, 11-22
33; 275 C, 5-19; 336 C, 18-32; 339 C, 27-31; 343 C, 6-11; Ambrysus:423 C, 11-15
343 C, 15-21; 344 C, 16-32; 346 C, 29–347 C, 3; 348 C, Amenanus:240 C, 9-19
1-4; 349 C, 5-12; 349 C, 14-19; 349 C, 24-31; 350 C, 2-6; America (Pontus):557 C, 3-13
350 C, 13-19; 351 C, 15-22; 352 C, 5-10; 352 C, 37-39; America (Umbria):227 C, 32-36
353 C, 6-10; 353 C, 12-23; 356 C, 24-31; 357 C, 7-8; Amichotrades:70 C, 27-30
389 C, 3-9; 389 C, 12-22; 463 C, 25–464 C, 2 Amisenians:544 C, 5-14; 546 C, 30–547 C, 6; 560 C, 12-19
Alponus:60 C, 16-35 Amisus:68 C, 18-29; 69 C, 8-18; 70 C, 31–71 C, 6; 73 C,
Alps:71 C, 15-20; 128 C, 3-30; 177 C, 25–178 C, 2; 178 C, 16-24; 74 C, 8-13; 126 C, 3-11; 126 C, 12-23; 498 C, 7-15;
12-18; 178 C, 35–179 C, 9; 179 C, 33–180 C, 7; 185 C, 519 C, 9-16; 543 C, 25–544 C, 4; 544 C, 5-14; 547 C, 7-18;
20-28; 185 C, 33–186 C, 22; 187 C, 3-15; 187 C, 27-35; 548 C, 15-25; 553 C, 6-11; 664 C, 5-15; 673 C, 5-16; 676 C,
192 C, 8-18; 192 C, 31–193 C, 9; 195 C, 9-13; 201 C, 34–677 C, 15; 678 C, 17-31
27–209 C, 14; 209 C, 15–210 C, 17; 210 C, 31–211 C, 4; Amiternina:241 C, 27–242 C, 3
211 C, 12-15; 211 C, 33–212 C, 7; 213 C, 5-16; 214 C, 24-28; Amiternum:228 C, 9-19
216 C, 11-15; 217 C, 5-12; 217 C, 26-30; 218 C, 15-19; Ammon:55 C, 33–56 C, 5; 813 C, 20-31; 830 C, 28–831 C, 10;
227 C, 12-20; 240 C, 22-27; 290 C, 17-25; 292 C, 25-31; 835 C, 16-24; 838 C, 24-32
293 C, 23–294 C, 3; 313 C, 5-12; 313 C, 19-22; 313 C, Ammon Balithon:834 C, 18-22
29–314 C, 9 Ammonia:798 C, 32–799 C, 5
Alsium:225 C, 29–226 C, 8 Amnias:561 C, 33–562 C, 9
Altars of Conon:771 C, 13-30 Amnisus:476 C, 12-20
Altars of Philaenus/Altars of the Philaeni:171 C, 1-21; Amorgos:487 C, 32–488 C, 1
836 C, 10-28 Amorium:576 C, 26-33
Altes:584 C, 31–585 C, 19; 605 C, 15–606 C, 4; 619 C, Ampelus:488 C, 2-8; 637 C, 13-23
30–620 C, 7 Amphiaraeium:399 C, 7-14
Althaemenes:479 C, 27-31; 653 C, 9-33 Amphiaraus/Amphiareos:399 C, 7-14; 404 C, 1-11; 404 C,
Altinum:214 C, 5-13 19-25; 762 C, 18-30
Alus:430 C, 33-38 Amphidolia:349 C, 19-24
Alyattes:420 C, 19-23; 627 C, 15-22; 680 C, 9-24; 735 C, Amphidolis:341 C, 29–342 C, 5
28–736 C, 2 Amphigenia:349 C, 5-12; 349 C, 36-37
Alybe:550 C, 15-20; 552 C, 13-19; 603 C, 21-24 Amphilochi:157 C, 1-14
Alybians:549 C, 23-30; 550 C, 4-8 Amphilochian Argos:271 C, 33-37; 325 C, 29–326 C, 14;
Alyzeus:452 C, 30-33 450 C, 14-22; 462 C, 20-27
Alyzia:450 C, 14-22; 459 C, 18-25 Amphilochians:271 C, 18-37; 321 C, 15-20; 429 C, 33–430 C,
Amanian Gates:676 C, 14-19; 751 C, 18-26 2; 449 C, 36–450 C, 13; 462 C, 20-27
Amanus:520 C, 32–521 C, 6; 535 C, 12-19; 676 C, 14-19; Amphilochus:157 C, 1-14; 462 C, 20-27; 642 C, 21–643 C, 9;
678 C, 17-31; 737 C, 3-8; 749 C, 8-21; 751 C, 5-26 668 C, 1-6; 675 C, 19–676 C, 5; 676 C, 7-13
Amardians:508 C, 10-18; 510 C, 26–511 C, 8; 513 C, Amphimalla:475 C, 5-12
30–514 C, 7; 523 C, 26-34 Amphinomus:328 C, 27–329 C, 2
Amarynthium:448 C, 22-25 Amphion:360 C, 10-16; 411 C, 7-9
Amarynthus:448 C, 1-11 Amphipolis:134 C, 15-24
Amasia (river):290 C, 13-17; 291 C, 11-16 Amphissa, Amphissans:419 C, 2-7; 426 C, 35–427 C, 3;
Amasia, Amasians:547 C, 19-32; 556 C, 11-25; 560 C, 427 C, 10-13
12–561 C, 4; 561 C, 5-32; 614 C, 4-17 Amphissene:528 C, 21-31
Amastris:309 C, 12-21; 540 C, 30–541 C, 14; 543 C, Amphistratus:495 C, 28–496 C, 3
25–544 C, 4; 544 C, 26–545 C, 2; 553 C, 12-21 Amphitryon:455 C, 35–456 C, 9; 459 C, 8-15; 461 C, 5-13
Amathus (Cyprus):682 C, 27–683 C, 5 Amphius:587 C, 5-14
Amathus (Elia):336 C, 27-32; 339 C, 17-20; 343 C, Amphrysus:433 C, 1-7
36–344 C, 7; 361 C, 4-14 Amulius:229 C, 20–230 C,2
Amathus (Laconia):363 C, 23–364 C, 2 Amyclae:362 C, 34–363 C, 6
Amazonian plain:126 C, 3-11 Amyclaeum:278 C, 27–279 C, 2
Amazons:52 C, 20-29; 503 C, 31–504 C, 13; 504 C, Amymona:371 C, 1-12
18–505 C, 18; 544 C, 5-14; 547 C, 7-18; 550 C, 9-26; Amynandrus:427 C, 33-37
551 C, 13-17; 552 C, 19-30; 554 C, 24–555 C, 2; 573 C, Amyntas (Galatian king):566 C, 31–567 C, 10; 568 C, 8-15;
14-26; 622 C, 28–623 C, 9; 633 C, 20-31 568 C, 15-25; 569 C, 3-30; 571 C, 6-17; 577 C, 1-10; 671 C,
Ambarvia:230 C, 2-10 8-20; 840 C, 13-26
Ambianians:194 C, 15-18 Amyntor:438 C, 35–439 C, 14
Amblada:570 C, 4-15 Amyzon:658 C, 26–659 C, 5
Ambracia:325 C, 8-20; 325 C, 29–326 C, 7; 450 C, 14-22; Anabura:570 C, 4-13
452 C, 8-15 Anacharsis:301 C, 12-21; 303 C, 8-18; 694 C, 27-35
983
Index of Ancient Names
984
Index of Ancient Names
Antipater (of Tarsus):674 C, 7-13 Aphnians:565 C, 7-19; 585 C, 20-32; 586 C, 30–587 C, 5
Antipater (of Tyre):757 C, 27-31 Aphnitis:59 C, 10-22; 586 C, 30–587 C, 5
Antipater (son of Sisis):555 C, 6-14 Aphrodisias:576 C, 26-33; 630 C, 15-19
Antiphanes:102 C, 7-11 Aphrodisium (Cyprus):682 C, 12-27
Antiphellus:666 C, 8-10 Aphrodisium (Pyrenees):178 C, 27-34; 181 C, 18–182 C, 2;
Antiphilus’s Harbor:771 C, 22–772 C, 11 182 C, 8-13
Antiphrae:799 C, 6-12 Aphrodite:272 C, 16-22; 343 C, 22-24; 378 C, 22-30;
Antiphus:443 C, 32–444 C, 7; 653 C, 9-33 379 C, 13-25; 398 C, 21-33; 437 C, 36–438 C, 8; 494 C,
Antipolis:178 C, 27-34; 179 C, 33–180 C, 7; 184 C, 11-18; 29–495 C, 5; 495 C, 6-15; 559 C, 8-20; 606 C, 18-27;
184 C, 25–185 C, 4; 202 C, 32-35 682 C, 27–683 C, 5; 683 C, 17-27; 683 C, 27-33; 732 C,
Antirrhium:335 C, 29–336 C, 13; 387 C, 24-28; 390 C, 8-21; 18-28; 745 C, 21-32; 800 C, 26–801 C, 1; 803 C, 13-24;
426 C, 35–427 C, 10; 459 C, 31–460 C, 3 807 C, 27-32; 815 C, 6-14; 836 C, 20-28
Antirrhodos:794 C, 19-34 Aphrodite City (Aphroditopolite district):809 C, 7-10
Antissa:59 C, 34–60 C, 7; 618 C, 16-27 Aphrodite City (Prosopite district):802 C, 28-34
Antitaurus:521 C, 26–522 C, 4; 527 C, 17-29; 528 C, 21-31; Aphrodite Harbor (Arabian gulf):769 C, 20–770 C, 2
535 C, 12–536 C, 3 Aphrodites Polis (nr Crocodilon Polis):816 C, 34–817 C, 6
Antium:231 C, 6-12; 231 C, 24-30; 232 C, 6-19; 232 C, Aphrodites Polis (nr Ptolemais):813 C, 3-9
27-33 Apidanus:356 C, 24-31
Antonius (Gaius):455 C, 26-34 Apiola:231 C, 6-12
Antony (Marc):141 C, 22-32; 325 C, 12-20; 359 C, 30-33; Apis (god in form of bull):803 C, 13-24; 805 C, 7-19;
523 C, 20-25; 524 C, 1-8; 529 C, 31–530 C, 12; 532 C, 807 C, 11-27
7-25; 540 C, 14-26; 542 C, 31–543 C, 6; 547 C, 7-18; Apis (place):798 C, 32–799 C, 5
574 C, 20-30; 578 C, 8-19; 595 C, 20-27; 636 C, Apobathra:591 C, 8-18
33–637 C, 12; 641 C, 14-23; 648 C, 15-28; 669 C, Apollo:257 C, 13-28; 275 C, 20-28; 319 C, 3-10; 320 C, 17-23;
20-32; 672 C, 10-22; 674 C, 13-26; 684 C, 24–685 C, 5; 324 C, 33–325 C, 8; 325 C, 20-26; 362 C, 34–363 C, 6;
748 C, 24-28; 764 C, 34–765 C, 11; 795 C, 16-27; 796 C, 368 C, 12-19; 373 C, 28–374 C, 5; 380 C, 23-26; 398 C,
28–797 C, 6; 828 C, 27-34 21-33; 403 C, 8-20; 410 C, 29–411 C, 7; 412 C, 24-31;
Antron:349 C, 37–350 C, 2; 432 C, 26-30; 435 C, 5-14; 412 C, 35–413 C, 8; 417 C, 27–418 C, 1; 420 C, 24-32;
435 C, 21-32; 435 C, 39-43 421 C, 28–423 C, 10; 435 C, 32-39; 445 C, 19-25; 446 C,
Anubis:805 C, 20-31; 812 C, 22–813 C, 2 16-21; 447 C, 31-26; 449 C, 36–450 C, 13; 452 C, 15-29;
Aonians:321 C, 3-14; 401 C, 13-19 459 C, 31–460 C, 3; 468 C, 3-20; 472 C, 31–473 C, 5;
Aornum:636 C, 10-18 484 C, 19-28; 485 C, 3-20; 486 C, 31–487 C, 4; 488 C,
Aornus (India):687 C, 31–688 C, 14 24-29; 537 C, 1-5; 550 C, 32–551 C, 4; 588 C, 3-18;
Aornus bay:243 C, 29–244 C, 15; 245 C, 4-18 598 C, 6-20; 603 C, 30–604 C, 12; 604 C, 20-36; 611 C,
Aorsians:492 C, 20-28; 506 C, 16-32 24–612 C, 8; 612 C, 15-23; 613 C, 16-28; 618 C, 28–619 C,
Aous:316 C, 13-20 10; 620 C, 27-33; 634 C, 22-32; 635 C, 13-19; 642 C,
Apaesus:587 C, 5-14 21–643 C, 9; 645 C, 10-21; 645 C, 36–646 C, 11; 665 C,
Apama:577 C, 32–578 C, 7; 749 C, 28–750 C, 4 31–666 C, 8; 676 C, 7-13; 683 C, 17-27; 739 C, 20-22;
Apamia (nr Rhagae):514 C, 24-31; 524 C, 23–525 C, 2 750 C, 25-29; 766 C, 6-19; 813 C, 10-17; 814 C, 14-22;
Apamia, Apamians (Bithynia):563 C, 26-32; 564 C, 7-9 816 C, 34–817 C, 6
Apamia, Apamians (Phrygia):569 C, 10-23; 576 C, 26-33; Apollocrates:259 C, 26–260 C, 4
577 C, 20–578 C, 7; 579 C, 10-21; 579 C, 27–580 C, 5; Apollodorus (historian):61 C, 5-15; 117 C, 35–118 C, 14;
628 C, 31–629 C, 11; 631 C, 19-21; 663 C, 19-33 509 C, 11-25; 514 C, 31-36; 516 C, 17-28; 519 C, 16-26;
Apamia, Apamians (Syria):275 C, 5-19; 749 C, 28–750 C, 4; 524 C, 23–525 C, 2; 685 C, 20–686 C, 9
750 C, 30–751 C, 4; 751 C, 31–753 C, 19; 755 C, 30–756 C, 4 Apollodorus (Homeric commentator):31 C, 22-29;
Apamian lake:752 C, 31–753 C, 10 42 C, 33–43 C, 5; 44 C, 25–45 C, 10; 254 C, 6-14;
Apassiacans:513 C, 25-29 298 C, 13–300 C, 14; 303 C, 19-31; 328 C, 11-17; 338 C,
Apaturum:494 C, 29–495 C, 5 33–339 C, 5; 368 C, 12-19; 370 C, 4-12; 405 C, 13-30;
Apeliotes:29 C, 3-16; 443 C, 10-18 453 C, 25-34; 456 C, 32–457 C, 3; 460 C, 12-18; 464 C,
Apelles (painter):642 C, 2-11; 657 C, 15–658 C, 4 21-32; 474 C, 31–475 C, 5; 552 C, 9–555 C, 6; 661 C,
Apelles (philosopher):15 C, 6-17 28–662 C, 6; 676 C, 34–677 C, 24; 677 C, 33–678 C, 31;
Apellicon:609 C, 3-22; 644 C, 1-8 679 C, 23–681 C, 24
Apennines (above Carnians):207 C, 4-17 Apollodorus (public speaker):625 C, 1-15
Apennines (Italy):128 C, 16-30; 201 C, 31–202 C, 3; 211 C, Apollonia (Black Sea):319 C, 3-18; 319 C, 20-25; 541 C,
15-23; 211 C, 26-32; 212 C, 1-7; 216 C, 11-15; 217 C, 30-33; 28–542 C, 4
218 C, 21-24; 218 C, 28–219 C, 3; 222 C, 25–223 C, 1; Apollonia (Ionian gulf):134 C, 15-24; 271 C, 33-37; 316 C,
227 C, 7-12; 227 C, 25-32; 227 C, 37–228 C, 7; 231 C, 19- 13–317 C, 6; 322 C, 28–323 C, 3; 323 C, 9-13; 326 C, 14-20;
23; 233 C, 26-31; 240 C, 22-27; 259 C, 5-10; 283 C, 8-11; 327 C, 5-6; 424 C, 29-33; 764 C, 8-17
283 C, 17-23; 286 C, 14-22 Apollonia (nr Cyrene):837 C, 4-15; 837 C, 23-28; 838 C,
Aphamiotes:701 C, 21–702 C, 4 9-19
Aphetae:436 C, 5-11 Apollonia (nr Pergamum):625 C, 16-24
Aphidna:362 C, 13-22; 396 C, 18-30; 397 C, 19-27 Apollonia (Syria):752 C, 23-31
Aphneis:656 C, 24–657 C, 11 Apollonia-on-Rhyndacus:575 C, 9-17
985
Index of Ancient Names
986
Index of Ancient Names
987
Index of Ancient Names
988
Index of Ancient Names
Asclepius:74 C, 1-7; 360 C, 4-10; 374 C, 22-32; 386 C, 2-8; Astacus (Bithynia):563 C, 16-25
567 C, 24–568 C, 7; 647 C, 7-17; 832 C, 13-24 Astae:319 C, 20-25; 320 C, 24-28
Ascra:409 C, 18-34; 413 C, 10-16; 423 C, 11-15; 622 C, Astapus:771 C, 5-12; 786 C, 9-15; 821 C, 26–822 C, 3
28–623 C, 9 Astasobas:771 C, 5-12; 786 C, 9-15; 821 C, 26–822 C, 3
Asculum Picenum:241 C, 3-14 Asteria/Asteris:59 C, 22-33; 456 C, 32–457 C, 3
Asea:275 C, 5-19; 343 C, 6-11 Asterium:438 C, 23-25; 439 C, 22-25
Asia (= Asian peninsula):124 C, 32–125 C, 2; 126 C, 3-11; Astigis:141 C, 22-32
141 C, 22-32; 282 C, 26–283 C, 8; 286 C, 22-26; 287 C, Asturia, Asturians:152 C, 27-35; 155 C, 25-30; 161 C, 1-10;
19-24; 303 C, 19-31; 378 C, 1-12; 380 C, 23-26; 401 C, 162 C, 11-18; 166 C, 29–167 C, 10
19-28; 486 C, 4-14 Astyages:524 C, 9-14; 730 C, 31-34
Asia (continent):32 C, 16-25; 35 C, 20-29; 57 C, 5-18; 65 C, Astypalaea (Attica):398 C, 21-33
29–66 C, 17; 67 C, 14–68 C, 5; 103 C, 17-24; 107 C, 11-18; Astypalaea (Cos):657 C, 15–658 C, 4
118 C, 25-32; 121 C, 29–122 C, 4; 124 C, 16-28; 126 C, 24- Astypalaea (island):488 C, 11-15; 488 C, 24-29
29; 129 C, 10–130 C, 24; 288 C, 4-16; 309 C, 33–310 C, Astypalaea (promontory):658 C, 4-12
24; 311 C, 8-15; 319 C, 26-31; 440 C, 17-32; 471 C, 18-24; Astypalaeans:601 C, 33–602 C, 5
488 C, 16-23; 490 C, 1–824 C, 21; 824 C, 26–825 C, 5; Astyra (Abydus):591 C, 30-33
839 C, 16-26; 840 C, 13-26 Astyra (Adramyttium):606 C, 27-33; 613 C, 29–614 C, 4;
Asia (Roman province):575 C, 24-30; 577 C, 20-31; 624 C, 614 C, 18-24; 680 C, 9-24
22-30; 631 C, 5-18; 646 C, 18-33; 647 C, 18-30; 648 C, Atabyris:655 C, 11-16
29–649 C, 10; 658 C, 26–659 C, 5; 659 C, 17-32; 840 C, Atagis:207 C, 4-7
13-26 Atalanta (Euboea):60 C, 35–61 C, 4; 425 C, 28-29
Asiarchs:648 C, 29–649 C, 10 Atalanta (Psyttalia):395 C, 18-21
Asina (Argive village):373 C, 8-15 Atargatis:747 C, 32–748 C, 6; 784 C, 30–785 C, 5
Asina (Homeric, nr Hermiona):359 C, 34–360 C, 4; 369 C, Atarneus:581 C, 13–582 C, 3; 606 C, 33–607 C, 6; 614 C,
3-7; 372 C, 26-31; 373 C, 8-15; 373 C, 19-25; 376 C, 7-19 25–615 C, 2; 615 C, 18-27; 622 C, 1-15; 680 C, 9-24
Asina (Laconia):363 C, 23–364 C, 2 Atarneus-under-Pitana:614 C, 25–615 C, 2
Asina (nr Acritas):359 C, 2-14; 359 C, 34–360 C, 4; 360 C, Atarnites:611 C, 24–612 C, 8
23-30; 373 C, 8-15 Atax:181 C, 28–182 C, 2; 182 C, 8-13; 189 C, 17-20
Asinaean gulf:359 C, 2-14; 359 C, 34–360 C, 4 Ategua:141 C, 22-32
Asinius:192 C, 36–193 C, 9 Atella:249 C, 12-16
Asionians:627 C, 23-30 Ateporix:560 C, 5-11
Asius (hero):650 C, 10-16 Aternum:241 C, 27–242 C, 8
Asius (poet):265 C, 7-13 Atesinus:207 C, 4-7
Asius (son of Hyrtacus):585 C, 33–586 C, 11; 590 C, 3-22 Athamania, Athamanians:321 C, 15-20; 326 C, 8-14;
Asopia:379 C, 30–380 C, 3; 408 C, 34-37 427 C, 29-37; 429 C, 15-20; 429 C, 33–430 C, 2; 434 C,
Asopus (Boeotia):382 C, 16-25; 408 C, 38–409 C, 3; 409 C, 16-24; 435 C, 32-39; 440 C, 9-17; 442 C, 17-26; 449 C,
3-6; 411 C, 35–412 C, 10 31–450 C, 13; 450 C, 23-31
Asopus (Laconia):364 C, 2-3 Athamas (founder of Halus):433 C, 1-7
Asopus (Paros):382 C, 16-25 Athamas (founder of Teos):633 C, 10-19
Asopus (Sicyon):271 C, 18-33; 382 C, 16-25; 408 C, 34-37 Athara:784 C, 30–785 C, 5
Asopus (Trachinian Heraclia):382 C, 16-25; 383 C, 7-12; Athena:232 C, 27-33; 247 C, 18-23; 264 C, 1-11; 281 C,
408 C, 34-37; 428 C, 19-28 11-18; 283 C, 34–284 C, 10; 338 C, 18-30; 342 C, 18-26;
Aspaneus:606 C, 27-33 342 C, 27-37; 343 C, 28-35; 345 C, 24–346 C, 10; 352 C,
Aspendus:569 C, 31–570 C, 4; 667 C, 14-33 10-18; 360 C, 10-16; 388 C, 28-36; 393 C, 28-34; 394 C,
Aspiones:516 C, 32–517 C, 4 34–395 C, 5; 396 C, 6-9; 411 C, 16-29; 413 C, 24-36;
Aspis (island):643 C, 32-35 438 C, 9-15; 470 C, 14-24; 486 C, 31–487 C, 4; 593 C,
Aspis (nr Carthage):277 C, 20-25; 834 C, 8-13 19–594 C, 1; 600 C, 24–601 C, 24; 611 C, 10-23;
Aspis (Syrtis):836 C, 6-10 640 C, 10-20; 654 C, 19–655 C, 2; 655 C, 3-10; 667 C,
Aspledon:415 C, 25-31 14-33; 744 C, 20-33; 751 C, 5-18; 802 C, 1-6; 816 C,
Aspordenum:618 C, 35–619 C, 10 34–817 C, 6
Aspurgianans:495 C, 16-27; 555 C, 31–556 C, 8 Athenaeum: 59 C, 34–60 C, 7; 242 C, 15-21; 247 C,
Assacanus:691 C, 25-34; 698 C, 3-7 18-28
Assians:606 C, 6-18 Athenaeus (of Seleucia):670 C, 12-30
Assus:581 C, 13–582 C, 3; 606 C, 18-27; 610 C, 12–611 C, 3; Athenaeus (son of Attalus):624 C, 9-22
614 C, 4-17; 616 C, 27–617 C, 3; 735 C, 17-20 Athenaïs:645 C, 5-9; 814 C, 14-22
Assyria, Assyrians:41 C, 30–42 C, 2; 671 C, 33–672 C, 9; Athenocles:547 C, 7-18
736 C, 13–749 C, 7; 762 C, 18-30 Athenodorus (Cordylion):674 C, 7-13
Asta:140 C, 20-25; 141 C, 32-34; 143 C, 26-34 Athenodorus (son of Sandon):6 C, 4-9; 55 C, 11-19; 173 C,
Astaboras:770 C, 13-27; 771 C, 5-12; 786 C, 9-19; 821 C, 5-18; 674 C, 7-13; 674 C, 26–675 C, 18; 779 C, 27-35
26–822 C, 3 Athens (on-the-Triton):407 C, 3-11
Astacenian bay:459 C, 18-25; 563 C, 16-32 Athens, Athenians:64 C, 27–65 C, 9; 65 C, 17-28; 67 C, 14–68 C,
Astacenians:698 C, 3-7 5; 68 C, 9-17; 69 C, 8-18; 79 C, 20-32; 82 C, 16-24; 85 C,
Astacus (Acarnania):459 C, 18-25 33–86 C, 10; 87 C, 29–88 C, 5; 102 C, 31–103 C, 8; 115 C,
989
Index of Ancient Names
990
Index of Ancient Names
4; 741 C, 10-22; 742 C, 10-26; 743 C, 25-34; 744 C, 4-7; Barium:283 C, 17-23; 283 C, 28-29
746 C, 14-23; 746 C, 30–747 C, 2; 747 C, 32–748 C, 6; Barnichius:356 C, 24-31
766 C, 6-19; 794 C, 5-18 Barnus:323 C, 3-8
Babylon, Babylonians (Egypt):807 C, 3-10; 812 C, Basgoedariza:555 C, 14-21
22–813 C, 2 Basilios:747 C, 32–748 C, 6
Babylonia, Babylonians (Assyria):84 C, 26–85 C, 5; 88 C, Basoropaeda:528 C, 21-31
30–89 C, 9; 102 C, 31–103 C, 8; 130 C, 14-18; 301 C, 12- Bastarnians:93 C, 25-28; 117 C, 35–118 C, 14; 128 C,
21; 501 C, 35–502 C, 12; 519 C, 16-26; 521 C, 6-20; 522 C, 31–129 C, 3; 289 C, 7-21; 294 C, 15-34; 295 C, 36–296 C,
4-14; 524 C, 15-23; 525 C, 30–526 C, 11; 617 C, 14-23; 7; 305 C, 2-11; 305 C, 23-25; 306 C, 17-21
692 C, 19-29; 727 C, 30–728 C, 3; 728 C, 3-13; 732 C, Bastetania, Bastetanians:139 C, 29–140 C, 7; 141 C, 3-9;
7-17; 736 C, 13–737 C, 2; 736 C, 13–749 C, 7; 763 C, 155 C, 5-14; 156 C, 14-37; 162 C, 11-18; 163 C, 14-16
11-23; 765 C, 12-21; 765 C, 27–766 C, 19; 767 C, 15-30; Bastulians:139 C, 29–140 C, 7; 156 C, 14-24
807 C, 3-10 Bata:496 C, 26–497 C, 11
Babyrsa:528 C, 32–529 C, 10 Batiae:324 C, 21-28
Bacchides:546 C, 2-20 Batieia:597 C, 14-25; 622 C, 28–623 C, 9
Bacchylides:486 C, 19-24; 616 C, 11-22 Bato (historian):546 C, 2-20
Bactra:68 C, 18-29; 70 C, 31–71 C, 6; 74 C, 14-23; 134 C, 15- Bato (leader of Daesitiatians):314 C, 17-20
24; 514 C, 8-22; 516 C, 28-31; 517 C, 5-19; 724 C, 16-32; Battus:837 C, 15-23
730 C, 8-18 Bear, Plough, Great Bear:3 C, 20-36–4 C, 6; 13 C, 7-11;
Bactria, Bactriana, Bactrians:14 C, 10-21; 27 C, 27-35; 69 C, 76 C, 7–77 C, 25; 132 C, 25-33; 133 C, 10-15
8-18; 72 C, 28–73 C, 15; 73 C, 24-27; 74 C, 32–75 C, 10; Bebrycians:295 C, 16-22; 541 C, 28–542 C, 4; 554 C,
75 C, 24–76 C, 4; 93 C, 28–94 C, 8; 117 C, 35–118 C, 14; 24–555 C, 2; 586 C, 17-22; 677 C, 33–678 C, 16
118 C, 25-32; 129 C, 22-26; 472 C, 1-6; 510 C, 26–511 C, 8; Belbina:375 C, 15-22; 398 C, 21-33
511 C, 9-17; 511 C, 28–512 C, 10; 513 C, 25–514 C, 7; 513 C, Belgans:176 C, 13–177 C, 24; 191 C, 30–192 C, 14; 194 C,
30–514 C, 7; 515 C, 4-18; 516 C, 1-11; 516 C, 17–518 C, 20; 32–195 C, 9; 196 C, 14-26
685 C, 20–686 C, 9; 687 C, 9-30; 692 C, 19-29; 697 C, Belio:153 C, 18-23
4-17; 723 C, 26–724 C, 6; 724 C, 6-8; 724 C, 16-23; Bellerophon, Bellerophontes:379 C, 25-30; 573 C, 1-26;
725 C, 6-16; 816 C, 18-27; 839 C, 16-26 630 C, 26–631 C, 4
Badas:728 C, 3-13 Bellovacians:194 C, 15-18; 196 C, 14-20; 208 C, 8-14
Baenis:153 C, 18-27 Belo:140 C, 8-13
Baeterra:182 C, 8-13 Belus:42 C, 18-23; 738 C, 19-25; 744 C, 20-33
Baetica:139 C, 16–151 C, 27; 157 C, 1-14; 160 C, 12-17; 162 C, Bembina:377 C, 27-32
5-11; 166 C, 21-29 Benacus:209 C, 7-13
Baetis:139 C, 9–140 C, 7; 140 C, 20–142 C, 15; 148 C, 12-27; Beneventum:248 C, 31–249 C, 11; 249 C, 32–250 C, 4;
151 C, 15-27; 152 C, 14-17; 162 C, 5-11; 168 C, 28–169 C, 5; 282 C, 26–283 C, 8
174 C, 27–175 C, 10; 840 C, 13-26 Berecyntia, Berecyntians:469 C, 1-9; 472 C, 13-20; 580 C,
Baetis (town):141 C, 18-21 11–581 C, 1; 680 C, 25–681 C, 24
Baeturia:142 C, 16-21 Berenice (Arabian gulf):133 C, 10-14; 815 C, 6-14; 815 C,
Bagadania:73 C, 16-24; 539 C, 27–540 C, 1 17-20
Bagas:552 C, 31–553 C, 6 Berenice (Cyrenaea):836 C, 20–837 C, 4; 837 C, 4-15;
Bagoos:736 C, 3-11 837 C, 23-28
Bagradas:832 C, 7-13 Berenice (daughter of Salome):764 C, 34–765 C, 11
Baiae:227 C, 4-6; 243 C, 29–244 C, 6; 245 C, 10-26; 246 C, Berenice (nr Sabae):771 C, 31–772 C, 11
15-23; 248 C, 6-16 Bermium:680 C, 9-24
Balanaea:753 C, 20-28 Beroea:751 C, 5-18
Balarians:225 C, 9-12 Beronians:158 C, 7-21; 162 C, 11-18
Balbura:631 C, 5-18 Berytus:682 C, 27–683 C, 5; 755 C, 20–756 C, 4; 756 C,
Balbus:169 C, 5-13 22-31
Balearic islands:167 C, 15-18; 654 C, 19–655 C, 2 Besaeans:426 C, 23-26
Balliaca:316 C, 30–317 C, 6 Besbicus:576 C, 4-16
Bambyca:747 C, 32–748 C, 6; 751 C, 5-18 Bessa:426 C, 19-26
Bandobene:697 C, 4-17 Bessians:318 C, 18-24
Barbarium:151 C, 28-33 Bessus:513 C, 25-29; 518 C, 26-34; 724 C, 24-32
Barca:836 C, 35–837 C, 4; 837 C, 23-28 Bias:636 C, 19-25
Barcas:151 C, 1-13; 158 C, 21-29 Biasas:552 C, 31–553 C, 6
Bardyetans:155 C, 25-30; 162 C, 11-18 Bibracta:192 C, 18-21
Bardyllians:162 C, 11-18 Bilbilis:162 C, 26-32
Bargasa:656 C, 12-23 Billarus:546 C, 2-20
Bargosa:719 C, 34–720 C, 7 Bion (astronomer):29 C, 10-16
Bargus:318 C, 6-13 Bion (philosopher):15 C, 6-17; 486 C, 19-24
Bargylia:611 C, 10-23; 658 C, 4-12 Bisa:356 C, 9-23
Baris (goddess):531 C, 16-23 Bistonis:59 C, 10-22
Baris (place):281 C, 19-28; 282 C, 6-11 Bisurgis:291 C, 11-16
991
Index of Ancient Names
Bithynia, Bithynians:129 C, 27–130 C, 3; 295 C, 16-22; 534 C, 28–308 C, 5; 308 C, 31–309 C, 10; 310 C, 30–311 C, 7;
8-20; 541 C, 17-27; 541 C, 28–542 C, 16; 542 C, 31–543 C, 494 C, 29–495 C, 5; 550 C, 9-15; 550 C, 26-32
19; 544 C, 14-25; 546 C, 25-29; 554 C, 24–555 C, 2; 561 C, Bosporenans:762 C, 18-30
33–562 C, 9; 562 C, 21-31; 563 C, 4–564 C, 27; 565 C, Bosporus, Cimmerian Bosporus:6 C, 16-23; 20 C, 23-33;
28–567 C, 23; 571 C, 17-25; 574 C, 14-19; 575 C, 9-17; 594 C, 73 C, 28-35; 74 C, 8-13; 108 C, 24-28; 125 C, 16-20;
9-18; 625 C, 16-24; 677 C, 33–678 C, 16; 840 C, 13-26 149 C, 11-15; 288 C, 4-16; 293 C, 23–294 C, 3; 301 C,
Bithynium:565 C, 28–566 C, 2 12-21; 307 C, 14-22; 308 C, 31–309 C, 10; 309 C,
Bituitus:191 C, 22-29 21-26; 309 C, 21-33; 310 C, 11-14; 310 C, 20-24; 310 C,
Biturigans:190 C, 1-12; 190 C, 30–191 C, 2 30–311 C, 7; 491 C, 12-23; 492 C, 20-28; 493 C, 17–495 C,
Bizona:54 C, 4-15; 319 C, 10-18 15; 494 C, 15-28; 496 C, 3-25; 506 C, 23-32; 547 C, 7-18;
Blaëne:561 C, 33–562 C, 9 553 C, 21-31; 555 C, 21-29; 625 C, 1-15
Bleminatis:343 C, 11-15 Bosporus, Thracian Bosporus:125 C, 16-20; 566 C, 6-18
Blemmyans:786 C, 19-26; 819 C, 7-17 Botrys:755 C, 20-29
Blera:226 C, 10-18 Bottiaea, Bottiaeans:279 C, 3-11; 282 C, 12-18
Blesinon:224 C, 28-29 Boucolon City:758 C, 31–759 C, 9
Blucium:567 C, 11-23 Bovianum:249 C, 32–250 C, 4
Boagrius:60 C, 16-35; 426 C, 11-18 Boxus:778 C, 33–779 C, 14
Bocalia:394 C, 6-7 Brachmanes:712 C, 9–713 C, 18; 714 C, 5-24; 716 C,
Bocarus:394 C, 6-7 28–717 C, 8; 718 C, 34–719 C, 14
Bocchus:828 C, 27-34 Branchidae:814 C, 6-22
Boea:363 C, 23–364 C, 2 Branchidians:517 C, 20–518 C, 4; 634 C, 22-32
Boeba:436 C, 11-19; 436 C, 19-22; 438 C, 23-33; 530 C, Branchus:421 C, 15-21
18–531 C, 1 Brauron:371 C, 1-12; 397 C, 19-27; 398 C, 34–399 C, 7
Boebeïas:443 C, 23-31 Brennus:187 C, 27-35
Boebeïs:430 C, 9-15; 436 C, 19-22; 438 C, 23-33; 441 C, Brettanic channel:128 C, 3-16
21-30; 442 C, 17-26; 503 C, 24-30 Brettanic isles, islands:114 C, 29–115 C, 3; 129 C, 4-9; 147 C,
Boenoa:338 C, 6-11 21-28
Boeoti:360 C, 10-16 Brettanica:62 C, 33–63 C, 34; 63 C, 24-34; 72 C, 11-15; 75 C,
Boeotia, Boeotians:65 C, 17-28; 321 C, 3-14; 321 C, 14-31; 93 C, 25-28; 104 C, 6-29; 114 C, 25–116 C, 6; 117 C,
28–322 C, 5; 332 C, 17–333 C, 3; 334 C, 25-28; 335 C, 35–118 C, 14; 120 C, 3-9; 128 C, 3-16; 189 C, 5-11; 190 C,
29–336 C, 13; 338 C, 33–339 C, 5; 360 C, 10-16; 379 C, 13-17; 193 C, 9-14; 193 C, 34–194 C, 2; 194 C, 32–195 C, 9;
30–380 C, 3; 390 C, 1-7; 391 C, 8-22; 393 C, 17-21; 397 C, 199 C, 10–201 C, 8
19-27; 399 C, 7-14; 400 C, 11–417 C, 27; 418 C, 2-8; Brettia, Brettians:211 C, 15-23; 211 C, 26-32; 228 C, 25-30;
423 C, 11-15; 424 C, 2-10; 424 C, 11-22; 424 C, 34–425 C, 251 C, 20-25; 253 C, 25-30; 253 C, 33–254 C, 6; 254 C,
5; 425 C, 13-22; 432 C, 10-22; 444 C, 12–445 C, 9; 447 C, 23–256 C, 20; 260 C, 35–261 C, 4; 283 C, 8-11
14-25; 463 C, 7-16; 464 C, 21-32; 471 C, 11-18; 622 C, Breucians:314 C, 17-20
28–623 C, 9; 633 C, 10-19; 636 C, 19-25; 653 C, 9-33 Breunians:206 C, 7-13
Boeotus:265 C, 7-13 Brigantians:206 C, 13-26
Boethus (of Sidon):757 C, 27-31 Brigantium (Brigantian city):206 C, 13-26
Boethus (of Tarsus):674 C, 7–675 C, 6 Brigantium (Cottius country):178 C, 35–179 C, 9
Boetylus:360 C, 4-10 Brigians:295 C, 16-22; 549 C, 30–550 C, 4
Bogus:100 C, 1-12; 101 C, 24–102 C, 7; 827 C, 20-23; 828 C, Brilessus:399 C, 28-31
27-34 Briseïs:584 C, 31–585 C, 19; 611 C, 24–612 C, 8
Boïans:195 C, 9-13; 206 C, 13-26; 212 C, 31–213 C, 5; 216 C, Britomartis:479 C, 2-8; 479 C, 23-26
6-15; 292 C, 25-31; 293 C, 23–294 C, 3; 295 C, 36–296 C, Briula:650 C, 17-23
7; 303 C, 33–304 C, 6; 313 C, 23-29; 315 C, 27–316 C, 1 Brixia:213 C, 5-16
Boium:427 C, 20-24; 475 C, 35–476 C, 5 Brogitarus:567 C, 11-23
Bolbitine mouth:801 C, 14-34 Bromius:469 C, 20–470 C, 13
Bomians:451 C, 8-16 Bructerians:290 C, 13-17; 291 C, 7-16; 291 C, 23–292 C, 10
Bononia:216 C, 30–217 C, 5; 217 C, 26-30 Brundisium:233 C, 8-19; 248 C, 31–249 C, 11; 277 C,
Boos Aula:445 C, 9-18 33–278 C, 2; 281 C, 6-10; 281 C, 19–282 C, 5; 282 C,
Boosura:683 C, 17-27 12–283 C, 23; 285 C, 1-7; 324 C, 11-16
Boreas:28 C, 12-24; 28 C, 27-30; 29 C, 3-10; 295 C, 4-15 Brutus (D. Junius Brutus Callaicus):152 C, 5-14; 153 C,
Borium:836 C, 20-28 23-27; 155 C, 14-24
Borrama:755 C, 20-29 Brutus (Decimus):205 C, 21-28
Borsippa:739 C, 20-22 Bryanium:327 C, 12-19
Borsippeni:739 C, 9-19 Brygians:326 C, 14-20; 327 C, 12-19; 549 C, 30–550 C, 4
Borysthenes:62 C, 22-29; 62 C, 33–63 C, 14; 63 C, 24-34; Bubastus:805 C, 7-19
71 C, 30–72 C, 11; 73 C, 28-35; 74 C, 8-23; 74 C, 32–75 C, Bubon:631 C, 5-18
14; 107 C, 22-32; 114 C, 18-28; 115 C, 4-9; 115 C, 22-30; Buca:242 C, 3-8; 285 C, 28-34
116 C, 7-12; 125 C, 2-7; 126 C, 12-23; 126 C, 30–127 C, 7; Bucephalia:698 C, 24–699 C, 2
134 C, 37–135 C, 14; 289 C, 7-21; 294 C, 15-34; 298 C, 19– Buchetium:324 C, 21-28
299 C, 12; 306 C, 9-17; 306 C, 21-24; 307 C, 6-10; 307 C, Budorus:446 C, 8-15
992
Index of Ancient Names
993
Index of Ancient Names
994
Index of Ancient Names
26–724 C, 6; 724 C, 16-23; 725 C, 16-21; 726 C, 18–727 C, 497 C, 34–498 C, 6; 499 C, 35–500 C, 11; 501 C, 13-21;
27; 729 C, 31–730 C, 7; 739 C, 1-8; 744 C, 7-9; 765 C, 503 C, 24-30; 506 C, 16-32; 506 C, 33–520 C, 21; 512 C,
27–766 C, 6; 766 C, 25-32 26–513 C, 1; 522 C, 32–523 C, 19; 524 C, 23–525 C, 2;
Carmel:758 C, 31–759 C, 9 526 C, 34–527 C, 9; 527 C, 29–528 C, 9; 529 C, 11-30;
Carmenta:230 C, 23-33 531 C, 1-15
Carmo:141 C, 22-32 Caspiana:502 C, 27–503 C, 6; 513 C, 30–514 C, 7; 528 C, 21-31
Carmylessus:665 C, 20-30 Caspians:517 C, 5-19; 520 C, 14-21
Carna, Carana:768 C, 7-14 Cassander:398 C, 3-14
Carneades:837 C, 29–838 C, 8 Cassandra:264 C, 12-18; 600 C, 24–601 C, 4
Carneates:382 C, 16-25 Cassiopa:324 C, 11-16
Carnians:206 C, 13-26; 207 C, 4-7; 207 C, 26-33; 216 C, Cassiopia:134 C, 31–135 C, 11
6-10; 292 C, 25-31; 314 C, 24-30 Cassius:751 C, 35–752 C, 7
Carnutans:193 C, 30-34 Cassopaeans:321 C, 15-20; 324 C, 5-11; 324 C, 21-28; 325 C,
Carpasia:682 C, 12-27 8-12
Carpasian islands:682 C, 27–683 C, 5 Castabala:534 C, 25–535 C, 3; 537 C, 22–538 C, 5
Carpathian sea:124 C, 16-24; 488 C, 8-15; 681 C, 33–682 C, 1 Castalian spring:418 C, 12-20
Carpathos:488 C, 24-29; 489 C, 6-11 Castellum:241 C, 3-14
Carpetania, Carpetanians:139 C, 1-9; 141 C, 3-9; 142 C, Casthanaea:443 C, 10-18
16-21; 152 C, 14-25; 152 C, 27-35; 162 C, 11-26 Castor Saocondarius:567 C, 24–568 C, 7
Carrhae:747 C, 3-10 Castrum:240 C, 27–241 C, 3
Carseoli:238 C, 13-15 Castrum Novum:241 C, 3-14
Carsuli:227 C, 25-32 Castulo:142 C, 4-9; 148 C, 7-16; 152 C, 25-26; 160 C, 18-32;
Carta:508 C, 27–509 C, 3 166 C, 21-24
Cartalia:159 C, 11-15 Casystes:644 C, 23-36
Carteia:141 C, 22-32; 145 C, 5-18; 151 C, 13-14 Catabathmus:790 C, 29–791 C, 9; 798 C, 28–799 C, 5;
Carthaea:486 C, 19-24 824 C, 26–825 C, 5; 838 C, 9-19; 838 C, 19-23
Carthage, Carthaginians:10 C, 6-20; 64 C, 8-20; 66 C, Catacecaumene:576 C, 20-25; 579 C, 10-21; 625 C,
23-31; 92 C, 29–93 C, 13; 119 C, 31–120 C, 3; 122 C, 16-23; 25–626 C, 10; 626 C, 33–627 C, 14; 628 C, 14-30
122 C, 23-31; 130 C, 35–131 C, 7; 131 C, 19-25; 133 C, Catana:240 C, 9-19; 247 C, 6-17; 266 C, 6-19; 266 C, 28-34;
29–134 C, 12; 151 C, 1-13; 158 C, 7-21; 224 C, 34–225 C, 267 C, 18-22; 267 C, 34–268 C, 10; 268 C, 18–269 C, 19;
8; 253 C, 19-22; 267 C, 5-14; 267 C, 34–268 C, 10; 270 C, 272 C, 1-4; 272 C, 23-27; 274 C, 26-29
15-24; 272 C, 5-10; 278 C, 7-18; 287 C, 4-24; 288 C, Catanaea:628 C, 14-30
1-4; 385 C, 13-24; 387 C, 11-15; 575 C, 24-30; 668 C, Cataonia, Cataonians:130 C, 4-6; 134 C, 12-14; 520 C,
26–669 C, 5; 802 C, 17-28; 824 C, 26–825 C, 5; 830 C, 32–521 C, 6; 528 C, 21-31; 533 C, 5–534 C, 7; 534 C,
1-10; 831 C, 19-26; 832 C, 1–834 C, 13; 836 C, 10-19 25–535 C, 3; 535 C, 12– 537 C, 5; 675 C, 19–676 C, 5;
Carura:578 C, 24-30; 580 C, 6-10; 663 C, 19-33 678 C, 17-31; 679 C, 28–680 C, 9
Caryanda:658 C, 4-12 Cataractes:667 C, 14-33
Carystus (Euboea):416 C, 2-10; 446 C, 16-21 Cathaea:699 C, 18–702 C, 2
Carystus (Laconia):446 C, 21-25 Cato (Marcus):514 C, 36–515 C, 3; 674 C, 7-13; 684 C,
Casiana:752 C, 23-31 24–685 C, 5; 836 C, 29-34
Casilinum:236 C, 29–237 C, 4; 237 C, 18-22; 237 C, Catopterius:423 C, 32–424 C, 2
33–238 C, 12; 248 C, 31–249 C, 11; 282 C, 26–283 C, 8 Catorigians:204 C, 8-14
Casinum:237 C, 13-22 Cattabanians:768 C, 7-26
Casium (Pelusium):38 C, 25-30; 50 C, 12-24; 55 C, 33–56 C, Cattiterides:120 C, 3-9; 129 C, 4-9; 147 C, 21-28; 175 C, 25-31
5; 58 C, 24-32; 741 C, 25–742 C, 3; 758 C, 15-30; Catus (Aelius):303 C, 19-31
759 C, 9-18; 759 C, 33–760 C, 10; 760 C, 17-23; 796 C, Caucasus:68 C, 9-17; 74 C, 32–75 C, 10; 75 C, 24-31; 85 C,
28–797 C, 6 27–86 C, 10; 91 C, 9-15; 107 C, 22-32; 117 C, 35–118 C,
Casium (Seleucia):750 C, 11-24; 751 C, 31-35 14; 129 C, 22-26; 134 C, 12-14; 182 C, 34–183 C, 12;
Casos:488 C, 11-15; 489 C, 12-20; 489 C, 20-24 492 C, 20-28; 493 C, 8-16; 495 C, 28–496 C, 3; 496 C,
Caspian Gates:60 C, 7-15; 64 C, 8-20; 78 C, 18-30; 79 C, 26–497 C, 4; 497 C, 11-26; 497 C, 34–498 C, 6; 499 C,
20-32; 80 C, 16-20; 80 C, 31–81 C, 30; 83 C, 3-15; 85 C, 14–500 C, 11; 500 C, 27–501 C, 4; 503 C, 31–504 C, 13;
27–86 C, 10; 86 C, 12–87 C, 15; 89 C, 14-21; 90 C, 11-21; 505 C, 19–506 C, 15; 506 C, 23-32; 510 C, 26–511 C, 8;
91 C, 5-8; 91 C, 15-22; 92 C, 5-7; 134 C, 12-14; 492 C, 10- 519 C, 32–520 C, 10; 526 C, 34–527 C, 9; 528 C, 9-20;
16; 505 C, 10-18; 508 C, 27–509 C, 3; 514 C, 8-22; 514 C, 687 C, 31–688 C, 14; 689 C, 3-17; 689 C, 32–690 C, 18
24-36; 520 C, 22-32; 521 C, 26–522 C, 4; 522 C, 14-27; Caucians:291 C, 7-10
524 C, 23–525 C, 15; 526 C, 12-20; 720 C, 8-14; 723 C, Caucon:342 C, 6-18; 387 C, 28–388 C, 3
15-24; 723 C, 26–724 C, 6; 724 C, 16-23; 727 C, 21-27; Caucon (person):345 C, 1-5
744 C, 10-13 Cauconia, Cauconians (Asia):541 C, 17-27; 542 C, 4-30; 572 C,
Caspian sea, Hyrcanian sea:65 C, 13-17; 68 C, 18-29; 70 C, 21-30; 619 C, 30-41; 677 C, 33–678 C, 16; 680 C, 9-24
31–71 C, 6; 74 C, 23-32; 91 C, 9-15; 91 C, 27–92 C, 7; Cauconia, Cauconians (Greece):321 C, 3-14; 322 C, 5-13;
93 C, 28–94 C, 8; 119 C, 10-17; 121 C, 16-21; 129 C, 16-22; 337 C, 10-17; 342 C, 6-10; 342 C, 18-37; 345 C, 1-5; 345 C,
129 C, 16–130 C, 3; 294 C, 15-34; 306 C, 21-24; 491 C, 6–346 C, 10; 353 C, 6-10; 366 C, 38–367 C, 7; 387 C,
12-23; 491 C, 32–492 C, 16; 492 C, 10-16; 497 C, 11-18; 28–388 C, 3
995
Index of Ancient Names
996
Index of Ancient Names
997
Index of Ancient Names
Cilicia, Cilicians (Homeric):221 C, 5-21; 572 C, 21-30; 586 C, Clanis (Alps):207 C, 7-17
8-11; 605 C, 15–606 C, 18; 611 C, 3-10; 611 C, 24–612 C, Clanis (river):235 C, 6-12
8; 612 C, 24-28; 613 C, 16-18; 615 C, 18–616 C, 10; 619 C, Clanis = Liris:233 C, 26-31
13-29; 626 C, 20–627 C, 14; 667 C, 14-33; 676 C, 29-33; Clarus:642 C, 21–643 C, 9; 668 C, 1-6
680 C, 9-24 Clastidium:217 C, 5-12
Cilicia Trachiotis, Trachiotians, Rough Cilicia:130 C, Claterna:216 C, 30–217 C, 5
18-24; 533 C, 5–534 C, 20; 534 C, 25–535 C, 3; 537 C, Claudius Pulcher (Publius):684 C, 24–685 C, 5
29–538 C, 5; 540 C, 27-29; 568 C, 25–569 C, 2; 664 C, Clautenatians:206 C, 13-26
5-27; 667 C, 14-33; 668 C, 7–671 C, 20; 672 C, 10-22; Clazomenae:58 C, 24-32; 633 C, 10-19; 645 C, 32-36
681 C, 25–682 C, 27 Clazomenians:494 C, 4-7; 644 C, 11-15
Cilician Gates:537 C, 18-22; 539 C, 16-26 Cleandria:602 C, 38–603 C, 12
Cilician sea:84 C, 16-26; 492 C, 10-16; 535 C, 12-19 Cleandridas:264 C, 19-24
Cilician Taurus:533 C, 5–534 C, 7; 535 C, 12-19 Cleanthes (painter):343 C, 24-27
Cilla:612 C, 15-23; 612 C, 28–613 C, 9 Cleanthes (philosopher):610 C, 18-30
Cillaeum (Lesbos):612 C, 15-23 Cleides:682 C, 2-27; 682 C, 27–683 C, 5; 683 C,
Cillaeum (mount):612 C, 15-23 34–684 C, 7
Cillaeus:612 C, 15-23 Cleitor:388 C, 28-36
Cillanian plain:629 C, 11-21 Cleobulus:655 C, 3-10
Cillas:613 C, 16-18 Cleomachus:648 C, 6-15
Cimarus:474 C, 21-30; 475 C, 20-26 Cleombrotus:336 C, 36–337 C, 8
Cimbria, Cimbrians:102 C, 20-22; 193 C, 18-24; 196 C, 14-20; Cleon:574 C, 20-30
214 C, 24-28; 291 C, 7-10; 292 C, 33–294 C, 34 Cleonae, Cleonaeans:377 C, 5-13; 377 C, 20-34; 379 C,
Cimiata, Cimiatene:562 C, 21-31 30–380 C, 3; 382 C, 16-25
Ciminian lake:226 C, 27–227 C, 4 Cleonymus (founder of Heraea):336 C, 36–337 C, 8
Cimmeria, Cimmerians:6 C, 16-23; 20 C, 23-33; 61 C, 16-29; Cleonymus (general):280 C, 20-30
149 C, 11-15; 244 C, 23–245 C, 9; 309 C, 21-26; 494 C, Cleopatra:288 C, 4-16; 325 C, 12-20; 595 C, 20-27; 669 C,
8-14; 511 C, 28–512 C, 10; 552 C, 19-30; 553 C, 21-31; 20-32; 671 C, 8-20; 672 C, 10-22; 684 C, 17–685 C, 5;
573 C, 27-32; 627 C, 23-30; 647 C, 30–648 C, 5 795 C, 16-27; 796 C, 19–797 C, 6
Cimmerica:494 C, 4-7 Cleopatra (Selene):749 C, 21-27; 828 C, 27-34
Cimmericum:494 C, 8-14 Cleopatra (wife of Euergetes):99 C, 3-20
Cimmeris:299 C, 12-18 Cleopatris:780 C, 20-28; 804 C, 19-33
Cimmerium:309 C, 21-26 Cleophanes:566 C, 19-22
Cimolos:484 C, 32-37; 485 C, 23-30 Cleues:582 C, 14-29
Cinaethium:359 C, 34–360 C, 4 Climax (Lycia):666 C, 26–667 C, 2
Cindya:658 C, 4-12 Climax (Syria):755 C, 30–756 C, 4
Cineas:329 C, 15 Clitarchus:223 C, 27–224 C, 3; 293 C, 8-22; 491 C, 23-32;
Cingulum:227 C, 7-12 505 C, 10-18; 718 C, 28-33
Cinnamomophorus:774 C, 6-18 Clusian lake:226 C, 27–227 C, 4
Cinnamonland:62 C, 33–63 C, 9; 72 C, 4-11; 72 C, 18-28; Clusium, Clusina:220 C, 6-10; 226 C, 23-26; 235 C, 6-12
74 C, 14-23; 94 C, 35–95 C, 9; 114 C, 6-11; 118 C, 25-32; Clymene:33 C, 29–34 C, 3
118 C, 36–119 C, 8; 119 C, 10-17; 119 C, 31–120 C, 3; Clypea:277 C, 20-25
132 C, 17–133 C, 2; 779 C, 14-18; 785 C, 13-19; 789 C, Clytaemestra:16 C, 3-12
23–790 C, 8 Cnemides:426 C, 6-18
Cinolis:545 C, 2-13 Cnemis:416 C, 22-30; 425 C, 6-13; 425 C, 22-28
Cinyras:39 C, 33–40 C, 3; 755 C, 30–756 C, 4 Cnidians:275 C, 20-28; 315 C, 24-27
Circaeum:231 C, 19-30; 232 C, 27-33; 233 C, 8-19 Cnidus:119 C, 24-31; 653 C, 9-33; 655 C, 29–656 C, 23;
Circe:21 C, 1-8; 43 C, 21–44 C, 9; 46 C, 18-25; 224 C, 9-13; 806 C, 31–807 C, 3
232 C, 27-33; 395 C, 12-18 Cnopia:404 C, 1-7
Cirphis:416 C, 11-21; 418 C, 12-28 Cnopus:633 C, 10-19
Cirrha:389 C, 25-36; 416 C, 11-30; 418 C, 20–419 C, 2 Cnossus, Cnossians:282 C, 12-18; 476 C, 6&478 C, 20;
Cirta:828 C, 18-27; 832 C, 1-7 479 C, 9-16; 479 C, 23-26; 481 C, 4-12
Cisamus:479 C, 9-16 Cobialus:545 C, 2-13
Cissia:728 C, 3-13 Cobus:61 C, 16-29
Cissians:728 C, 3-13 Cocalus:272 C, 34–273 C, 2; 279 C, 3-11
Cissus:389 C, 37-42 Cocceius:245 C, 4-9
Cisthena (on Megista):666 C, 8-10 Codrus:321 C, 3-14; 392 C, 38–393 C, 11; 653 C, 9-33
Cisthene (Troad):606 C, 33–607 C, 6 Coele Elis:337 C, 33–340 C, 6; 339 C, 31–340 C, 5; 345 C,
Cithaeron:26 C, 31-37; 379 C, 30–380 C, 3; 393 C, 17-21; 12-18; 350 C, 13-19; 354 C, 21-31; 366 C, 38–367 C, 7
404 C, 30-35; 405 C, 13-30; 405 C, 32–406 C, 1; 408 C, Coele Syria, Coelosyrians:133 C, 32–134 C, 2; 741 C,
30-34; 409 C, 3-6; 411 C, 35–412 C, 10 25–742 C, 3; 749 C, 14-21; 749 C, 28–750 C, 4; 753 C,
Citium:682 C, 27–683 C, 5 20-28; 754 C, 32–756 C, 31; 765 C, 12-21; 767 C, 22-30
Cius:562 C, 31–563 C, 3; 563 C, 26-32 Cogaeonum:298 C, 5-12
Cius (person):563 C, 35–564 C, 7 Colapis:207 C, 26-33
998
Index of Ancient Names
999
Index of Ancient Names
1000
Index of Ancient Names
Cybela (place):469 C, 1-9; 567 C, 24–568 C, 7 Cyrene:56 C, 26-31; 57 C, 19-29; 133 C, 14-17; 133 C, 26-28;
Cybele (goddess):469 C, 1-9; 469 C, 20–470 C, 13; 475 C, 133 C, 32–134 C, 2; 157 C, 14-20; 347 C, 3-16; 836 C,
25-30; 567 C, 24–568 C, 7 10-19; 837 C, 4–838 C, 8
Cybelia:644 C, 37–645 C, 5 Cyres:228 C, 9-19
Cybistra:534 C, 25–535 C, 3; 537 C, 22–538 C, 5; 539 C, Cyrictica:123 C, 30–124 C, 3; 315 C, 7-10
16-26 Cyrites:230 C, 11-22; 231 C, 6-12
Cychreus:393 C, 28-34 Cyrnus:122 C, 34–123 C, 9; 223 C, 24-27; 224 C, 3-8;
Cychria:393 C, 28-34 224 C, 20-33; 225 C, 29–226 C, 8; 252 C, 14-18; 654 C,
Cyclades:58 C, 1-9; 124 C, 11-24; 368 C, 10-12; 474 C, 16-21; 19–655 C, 2; 840 C, 13-26
485 C, 1-3; 485 C, 21-30; 488 C, 16-23; 538 C, 31–539 C, Cyrrhestia:751 C, 5-18
9; 636 C, 25-33 Cyrsilus:530 C, 18–531 C, 1
Cyclopes:20 C, 23-33; 21 C, 19-28; 22 C, 3-12; 40 C, 10-20; Cyrtians:523 C, 26-34
372 C, 32–373 C, 4; 592 C, 26–593 C, 4 Cyrus:61 C, 5-15; 61 C, 16-29; 507 C, 18-26; 512 C, 11-22;
Cyclopia:369 C, 1-2 512 C, 26–513 C, 1; 524 C, 9-14; 686 C, 17–687 C, 8;
Cycnus:589 C, 24-33; 603 C, 30–604 C, 12 721 C, 34–722 C, 8; 724 C, 32–725 C, 6; 727 C, 30–728 C,
Cydippa:654 C, 9-18 3; 729 C, 31–730 C, 7; 730 C, 18-34; 736 C, 3-11
Cydnus:47 C, 18-24; 672 C, 23–673 C, 22; 675 C, Cyrus (plain):625 C, 25–626 C, 10; 629 C, 11-21
19–676 C, 5 Cyrus (river):491 C, 12-32; 498 C, 7-15; 499 C, 35–500 C, 11;
Cydonia, Cydoniates:376 C, 2-6; 476 C, 6-12; 478 C, 12-20; 500 C, 27–501 C, 4; 501 C, 22-34; 509 C, 11-25; 514 C,
479 C, 2-16 8-14; 528 C, 1-9; 528 C, 21-31; 529 C, 11-30
Cydonians:221 C, 5-21; 475 C, 27–476 C, 5 Cyrus (river in Persia):729 C, 22-31
Cydrelus:633 C, 10-19 Cythera:124 C, 11-15; 363 C, 10-21; 368 C, 12-19; 475 C,
Cydriae:327 C, 12-19 20-26
Cyinda:672 C, 10–673 C, 5 Cytherius:356 C, 31–357 C, 4
Cyllena (harbor):337 C, 26–338 C, 11 Cytherus:397 C, 19-27
Cyllena (mountain):388 C, 13-15; 388 C, 37–389 C, 2 Cythnos:485 C, 23-30
Cymaea:589 C, 24-33; 621 C, 28-33; 646 C, 18-33 Cytinium:427 C, 20-24; 475 C, 35–476 C, 5
Cyme:409 C, 18-24; 440 C, 17-32; 505 C, 5-10; 550 C, 9-15; Cytorum:542 C, 17-30; 544 C, 26–545 C, 2
550 C, 15-20; 581 C, 13–582 C, 3; 582 C, 14-29; 600 C, Cyzicus, Cyzicenes:44 C, 34–45 C, 10; 125 C, 20-23; 550 C,
17-22; 620 C, 22–621 C, 10; 622 C, 1–623 C, 9 32–551 C, 4; 564 C, 12-21; 565 C, 7-19; 575 C, 9–576 C,
Cynaetha:388 C, 28-36 19; 581 C, 13–583 C, 33; 586 C, 17–588 C, 2; 588 C,
Cynia:459 C, 25-31 3-18; 588 C, 33–589 C, 8; 634 C, 32–635 C, 12; 652 C,
Cynon Polis (nr Busiris):802 C, 7-17 34–653 C, 8; 655 C, 29–656 C, 11; 681 C, 3-24
Cynon Polis (nr Oxyrhynchus):812 C, 22–813 C, 2
Cynos Sema (Caria):655 C, 29–656 C, 11
Cynos Sema (Egypt):799 C, 12-20
Cynos Sema (Thracian Cherronesus):595 C, 9-20
Cynthus:485 C, 3-20
D
Cynuria:376 C, 20-24 Daans:304 C, 16-27; 508 C, 10-18; 511 C, 9-27; 515 C,
Cynus:60 C, 16-35; 425 C, 22-28; 426 C, 1-5; 446 C, 8-15; 4-23
615 C, 8-17 Dacians:207 C, 18-25; 212 C, 31–213 C, 5; 313 C, 5-12; 313 C,
Cyparisseeis (Homeric):349 C, 5-12; 349 C, 32-35 23-29
Cyparisseeis (river in Messenia):349 C, 32-35 Dacians, Daoi:304 C, 16–305 C, 15
Cyparissia (Laconian gulf):363 C, 23–364 C, 2 Daedala (mountain):664 C, 16-27; 665 C, 20-30
Cyparissia, Cyparissians (Messenia):345 C, 1-5; 348 C, Daedala (town):651 C, 14-24; 664 C, 5-27
15-20; 349 C, 32-35; 359 C, 21-29; 361 C, 4-14 Daës:612 C, 15-23
Cyparissus:423 C, 16-23 Daesitiatians:314 C, 17-20
Cyphus:440 C, 33–441 C, 20; 442 C, 17-26 Dalion:344 C, 16-24
Cyprus, Cyprians:6 C, 10-16; 8 C, 26–9 C, 7; 27 C, 13-27; 37 C, Dalmatia, Dalmatians:314 C, 17-20; 315 C, 4-6; 315 C, 13-23;
29–38 C, 5; 39 C, 33–40 C, 3; 40 C, 4-9; 40 C, 23–41 C, 317 C, 22-28
4; 52 C, 29–53 C, 5; 124 C, 16-24; 125 C, 25-31; 255 C, Dalmium:315 C, 13-19
20–256 C, 2; 340 C, 37–341 C, 3; 400 C, 27-37; 488 C, Damas Scombrus:649 C, 10-17
16-23; 536 C, 20-29; 653 C, 34–654 C, 8; 654 C, 19–655 C, Damascene:754 C, 32–755 C, 6; 756 C, 5-15
2; 668 C, 26–669 C, 5; 669 C, 20-32; 681 C, 25–685 C, 5; Damascus, Damascenians:755 C, 10-13; 756 C, 5-15
741 C, 10-22; 790 C, 29–791 C, 9; 840 C, 13-26 Damasia:206 C, 13-26
Cypsela:322 C, 28–323 C, 3 Damastes:47 C, 9-24; 582 C, 30–583 C, 7; 683 C, 34–684 C, 7
Cypselus:353 C, 23-34; 378 C, 12-19; 452 C, 8-15 Damastium:326 C, 14-20; 375 C, 26–376 C, 1
Cyra:517 C, 20–518 C, 4 Damathus:633 C, 10-19
Cyrbas:472 C, 6-12 Danaae, Danaïds:371 C, 13-19; 579 C, 10-21; 655 C, 3-10
Cyrenaea:57 C, 19-29; 123 C, 10-21; 130 C, 35–131 C, 7; 131 C, Danaans:371 C, 26-30; 431 C, 1-8; 573 C, 32–574 C, 13
11-19; 347 C, 3-16; 363 C, 10-21; 474 C, 21-30; 475 C, Danaë:487 C, 20-27
20-26; 484 C, 19-28; 790 C, 29–791 C, 9; 798 C, 28-31; Danaus:23 C, 28–24 C, 4; 221 C, 22-32; 321 C, 3-14; 371 C,
814 C, 31–815 C, 6; 836 C, 10–839 C, 9; 840 C, 13-26 20-26; 654 C, 9-18
1001
Index of Ancient Names
Dandarians:495 C, 16-27 Delphi, Delphians:187 C, 27–188 C, 22; 214 C, 5-13; 257 C, 13-
Dantheletians:318 C, 18-24 28; 260 C, 18-34; 264 C, 25-29; 269 C, 20–270 C, 4; 275 C,
Danube:304 C, 30–305 C, 2; 314 C, 9-15 20-28; 328 C, 18-20; 347 C, 26-34; 404 C, 11-19; 416 C,
Daorizians:315 C, 24-27 11-21; 416 C, 30–417 C, 6; 417 C, 27–424 C, 2; 464 C, 7-14;
Daphitas:647 C, 7-17 482 C, 19-27; 647 C, 18-30; 761 C, 31–762 C, 17; 814 C, 6-14
Daphne:750 C, 25-29 Delphinium:403 C, 8-20
Daphnus:60 C, 16-35; 416 C, 11-21; 424 C, 34–425 C, 13; Delta:701 C, 9-20; 788 C, 10–789 C, 22; 791 C, 14-21; 800 C,
426 C, 1-11 7-13; 801 C, 14–806 C, 30; 818 C, 22-32
Daphnus’s Harbor:774 C, 6-18 Delta (India):701 C, 9-20
Darada:771 C, 31–772 C, 11 Demaratus:219 C, 28–220 C, 6; 378 C, 19-22
Darapsa:516 C, 28-31 Demeter:198 C, 31–199 C, 3; 272 C, 23-27; 344 C, 8-12;
Dardania, Dardanians:313 C, 12-19; 315 C, 27–316 C, 1; 344 C, 16-24; 393 C, 28-34; 395 C, 7-12; 429 C, 10-14;
316 C, 2-12; 318 C, 18-24; 389 C, 25-36; 452 C, 34–453 C, 435 C, 21-32; 435 C, 39-43; 468 C, 10-20; 632 C,
6; 565 C, 7-19; 585 C, 20-32; 592 C, 1-11; 595 C, 9-20; 17–633 C, 10
596 C, 24-31; 602 C, 6-16; 602 C, 31-37; 606 C, 5-18; Demetrias:428 C, 29–429 C, 2; 436 C, 5-19; 436 C, 24-29;
661 C, 28–662 C, 6 438 C, 23-33; 441 C, 21-30; 443 C, 18-23
Dardanium:587 C, 15-23 Demetrias (Mesopotamia):737 C, 34–738 C, 4
Dardanus:587 C, 15-23; 590 C, 34–591 C, 8; 592 C, Demetrium:435 C, 21-32
26–593 C, 16; 595 C, 9-20; 600 C, 17-22 Demetrius (mathematician):548 C, 9-14
Dardanus (person):592 C, 1-11 Demetrius (of Callatis):60 C, 16-35
Darieces:784 C, 30–785 C, 5 Demetrius (of Phalerum):147 C, 10-21; 398 C, 3-14
Darius I:98 C, 13-17; 100 C, 24-34; 301 C, 12-21; 302 C, Demetrius (of Pharus):315 C, 10-12; 361 C, 22-32
26–303 C, 7; 305 C, 16-22; 305 C, 25-31; 591 C, 18-25; Demetrius (of Scepsis):44 C, 34–45 C, 10; 46 C, 25-33;
638 C, 14-18; 730 C, 21-28; 736 C, 3-11; 737 C, 20-33; 58 C, 10-23; 338 C, 33–339 C, 16; 344 C, 16-24; 374 C,
737 C, 20–738 C, 4; 784 C, 30–785 C, 5; 804 C, 19-33 32–375 C, 7; 438 C, 35–439 C, 21; 456 C, 32–457 C,
Darius III:79 C, 20-32; 587 C, 15-23; 676 C, 7-13; 676 C, 3; 472 C, 13-30; 473 C, 9-16; 489 C, 20-24; 550 C,
20-28; 697 C, 4-17; 766 C, 25-32 4-8; 551 C, 13–552 C, 8; 594 C, 2-8; 596 C, 31–597 C,
Dasaretians:316 C, 2-12; 318 C, 24-27 14; 599 C, 17-30; 600 C, 10-17; 602 C, 6-16; 602 C,
Dascylitis:550 C, 32–551 C, 4; 575 C, 9-17; 576 C, 4-16; 38–603 C, 30; 606 C, 6-18; 607 C, 20-27; 609 C,
582 C, 14-29; 586 C, 30–587 C, 5 23–610 C, 7; 610 C, 31–611 C, 3; 626 C, 33–627 C, 14;
Dascylium:575 C, 9-17 627 C, 23-30; 680 C, 9-24
Dasmenda:540 C, 9-13 Demetrius (Poliorcetes):54 C, 23-31; 232 C, 6-19; 382 C,
Dastarcum:537 C, 1-5 26-29; 436 C, 11-19
Dastira:555 C, 21-29 Demetrius (son of Euthydemus):516 C, 17-28
Datis:398 C, 34–399 C, 7 Demetrius (son of Seleucus):624 C, 22-30
Daulians:424 C, 11-22 Democles:58 C, 10-23
Daulis:321 C, 3-14; 416 C, 11-21; 423 C, 16-23 Democoon:585 C, 33–586 C, 7
Daulius:265 C, 14-19 Democritus:1 C, 1–2 C, 3; 61 C, 5-15; 65 C, 17-28; 65 C,
Daunia, Daunians:215 C, 5-12; 242 C, 8-10; 242 C, 11-14; 29–66 C, 3; 703 C, 19-27
277 C, 26-33; 279 C, 3-11; 281 C, 1-5; 282 C, 26–283 C, 8; Demodocus. See Phocylides (?= Demodocus)
283 C, 23-27; 283 C, 34–284 C, 19; 285 C, 21-28; 654 C, Demosthenes:121 C, 3-15; 374 C, 9-16; 424 C, 2-10; 445 C,
19–655 C, 2 25-29; 471 C, 25-31
Dazimonitis:547 C, 19-32 Demus:299 C, 24-25
Debaeans:777 C, 24-30 Derbe:534 C, 25–535 C, 3; 569 C, 3-10
Decaeneus:298 C, 5-12; 304 C, 7-11; 762 C, 18-30 Derbicans:513 C, 30–514 C, 7; 514 C, 36–515 C, 3; 519 C,
Decelia:396 C, 18-30; 397 C, 19-27 32–520 C, 10; 520 C, 14-21
Decietans:202 C, 14-15 Derceto:784 C, 30–785 C, 5
Degmenus:357 C, 13-28 Derdians:705 C, 33–706 C, 11
Deianira:451 C, 8-16; 458 C, 14-27 Derrhis Harbor:799 C, 12-20
Deimachus:68 C, 30–69 C, 7; 70 C, 16-30; 72 C, 28-31; Dertho:217 C, 5-12; 217 C, 15-19; 217 C, 20-26
74 C, 14-23; 75 C, 24-31; 76 C, 7-21; 77 C, 19-25; 689 C, Dertosa:159 C, 15-18; 160 C, 18-32
32–690 C, 6 Deucalion:322 C, 5-13; 425 C, 22-28; 443 C, 32–444 C, 7
Deiotarus:546 C, 30–547 C, 6; 566 C, 31–568 C, 7 Deucalion (island):435 C, 39-43
Deiotarus (Philadelphus):562 C, 21-31 Deudorix:291 C, 23–292 C, 10
Deiphontes:389 C, 37-42 Deuriopians:327 C, 12-19
Deira:769 C, 1-12; 769 C, 20–770 C, 2; 772 C, 32–773 C, 4; Deuriopus:326 C, 14-20
773 C, 23–774 C, 5; 774 C, 18-23 Dia:777 C, 4-15
Delians:635 C, 13-19 Diacopene:561 C, 5-23
Delium (Boeotia):403 C, 8-20 Diadic Athens:446 C, 8-15
Delium (Laconia):368 C, 12-19 Diagesbeis:224 C, 34–225 C, 8
Dellius:523 C, 20-25 Dicaearchia:26 C, 15-24; 99 C, 21-27; 145 C, 1-4; 245 C, 19–
Delos:271 C, 18-33; 373 C, 28–374 C, 5; 485 C, 1-23; 486 C, 246 C, 23; 248 C, 6-16; 285 C, 28-34; 792 C, 32–793 C, 9
4-18; 668 C, 26–669 C, 5 Dicaearchus:1 C, 1–2 C, 3; 104 C, 6–106 C, 10; 170 C, 20-30
1002
Index of Ancient Names
1003
Index of Ancient Names
1004
Index of Ancient Names
Elbe:14 C, 10-21; 290 C, 13-17; 290 C, 32–291 C, 7; 291 C, Epaminondas:388 C, 28-36; 400 C, 37–401 C, 7; 402 C,
17-22; 292 C, 11-16; 294 C, 15-34; 294 C, 34–295 C, 4 27–403 C, 7; 414 C, 11-18
Elea:252 C, 7–253 C, 6 Epaphus:445 C, 9-18
Electrides islands:215 C, 5-12 Ephesium:179 C, 10-25
Eleon:410 C, 16-21; 439 C, 5-21 Ephesus, Ephesians:179 C, 10-25; 387 C, 11-15; 440 C, 17-
Elephant Hunt:768 C, 27-34; 769 C, 20–770 C, 2 32; 505 C, 5-10; 550 C, 15-20; 551 C, 13-17; 577 C, 20-31;
Elephantine:786 C, 30–787, 5; 803 C, 24-32; 813 C, 3-9; 620 C, 27-33; 632 C, 5–633 C, 10; 634 C, 18-32; 639 C,
817 C, 7-20; 817 C, 29–818 C, 10; 818 C, 33–819 C, 4; 15-27; 640 C, 10–642 C, 11; 643 C, 21-32; 646 C, 18-33;
819 C, 33–820 C, 9 647 C, 4–648 C, 5; 663 C, 8-14; 663 C, 19-33
Elephas:774 C, 6-18; 827 C, 24-28 Ephialtes:10 C, 20-24
Eleusinian gulf:380 C, 15-19 Ephorus:1 C, 1–2 C, 3; 33 C, 3-8; 34 C, 4-10; 137 C, 34–138 C,
Eleusis (Alexandria):800 C, 14–801 C, 1 9; 199 C, 4-9; 220 C, 31–221 C, 5; 221 C, 22-32; 244 C, 23–
Eleusis (Attica):393 C, 28-34; 395 C, 7-12; 396 C, 10-30; 245 C, 3; 259 C, 10-19; 260 C, 5-17; 262 C, 14-26; 265 C,
397 C, 19-27 14-19; 266 C, 21-22; 267 C, 22-33; 270 C, 8-15; 279 C,
Eleusis (Boeotia):407 C, 3-11 12-21; 280 C, 1-13; 302 C, 13–303 C, 18; 305 C, 31-34;
Eleutherae:375 C, 26–376 C, 1; 411 C, 35–412 C, 10 325 C, 29–326 C, 7; 327 C, 29–328 C, 1; 332 C, 4-13; 334 C,
Eleutherus:753 C, 20-28; 754 C, 28-32 4-10; 357 C, 7–358 C, 24; 361 C, 15-21; 364 C, 30–365 C,
Elia, Elis, Elians:328 C, 11-17; 333 C, 24-29; 335 C, 12-22; 8; 366 C, 6-20; 373 C, 28–374 C, 5; 376 C, 2-6; 389 C,
336 C, 16–359 C, 2; 362 C, 7-13; 366 C, 38–367 C, 7; 383 C, 37-42; 400 C, 27–401 C, 12; 401 C, 29–402 C, 24; 422 C,
1-6; 387 C, 11-15; 387 C, 28–388 C, 3; 388 C, 9-12; 389 C, 4–423 C, 10; 426 C, 35–427 C, 3; 452 C, 30-33; 461 C,
37-42; 423 C, 5-10; 425 C, 29-31; 440 C, 17-32; 447 C, 26- 34–462 C, 27; 463 C, 17–465 C, 9; 476 C, 20&477 C, 15;
30; 448 C, 1-11; 452 C, 34–453 C, 6; 456 C, 9-18; 458 C, 479 C, 27-31; 480 C, 15&484 C, 14; 544 C, 26–545 C,
6-14; 459 C, 3-8; 463 C, 17–464 C, 7; 464 C, 14-20 2; 550 C, 9-15; 582 C, 30–583 C, 7; 600 C, 17-22; 622 C,
Elimia:326 C, 14-20; 326 C, 28–327 C, 4 28–623 C, 9; 634 C, 32–635 C, 12; 677 C, 33–680 C, 9
Elimiotians:434 C, 16-24 Ephyra (= Cichyrus):324 C, 21-28; 328 C, 11-17; 338 C, 6-11;
Elisa:337 C, 33–338 C, 5 443 C, 32–444 C, 7
Elison:337 C, 33–338 C, 5 Ephyra (Aetolia):338 C, 31-32
Elixus:486 C, 31–487 C, 4 Ephyra (Elia):328 C, 11-17; 338 C, 6–339 C, 5; 371 C,
Elona:439 C, 26-28; 440 C, 33–441 C, 8 30–372 C, 2
Elpiae:654 C, 19–655 C, 2 Ephyra (nr Corinth):338 C, 6-11
Elymaea, Elymaeans:522 C, 4-14; 524 C, 15-23; 524 C, Ephyra (Sicyon):338 C, 31-32
23–525 C, 2; 732 C, 7-17; 736 C, 13–737 C, 2; 739 C, Ephyra (Thessaly):338 C, 6-11
23-28; 744 C, 14–745 C, 4 Ephyrians:442 C, 9-17
Elymais:744 C, 10-13 Epians:336 C, 18-26; 337 C, 10-17; 338 C, 18-30; 340 C,
Elymus:608 C, 7-14 6–341 C, 17; 345 C, 12-18; 354 C, 21-31; 357 C, 13-28;
Emathia:27 C, 13-27 423 C, 5-10; 432 C, 10-22; 456 C, 9-18; 459 C, 3-8;
Emisenians:752 C, 31–753 C, 10 463 C, 17-25; 464 C, 21-32
Emoda:510 C, 26–511 C, 8; 698 C, 14-23 Epicharmus:364 C, 4-22
Emodum:689 C, 3-7; 719 C, 15-20 Epictetians:563 C, 10-15
Empedocles:274 C, 4-21; 276 C, 4-9; 364 C, 4-22 Epictetus:129 C, 27–130 C, 3; 450 C, 23-31; 534 C, 8-20;
Emporicus Bay:825 C, 33–829 C, 22 564 C, 21-27; 571 C, 17-25; 575 C, 9-17; 625 C, 16-24
Emporium (Iberia):159 C, 29–160 C, 17 Epicurus:589 C, 33–590 C, 2; 638 C, 19–639 C, 2
Emporium (Italy):256 C, 21-30 Epidamnus:92 C, 29–93 C, 6; 106 C, 28-31; 283 C, 12-16;
Encheleans:326 C, 21-25 316 C, 13-20; 322 C, 28–323 C, 3; 323 C, 9-13; 326 C,
Endera:771 C, 13-21 14-20; 327 C, 5-6; 357 C, 4-6
Endymion:635 C, 31–636 C, 4 Epidauria:368 C, 10-12
Enetians (Adriatic):209 C, 15–210 C, 8; 211 C, 4-12; 212 C, Epidaurus:369 C, 10-17; 372 C, 26-31; 373 C, 8-15; 374 C,
1-24; 214 C, 24-28; 215 C, 12-18; 216 C, 6-10; 216 C, 15- 6-9; 374 C, 22–375 C, 7; 375 C, 15-22; 375 C, 26–376 C, 1;
29; 283 C, 34–284 C, 10; 284 C, 25-32; 314 C, 24-30 567 C, 24–568 C, 7
Enetians (Paphlygonia):48 C, 19-28; 61 C, 5-15; 543 C, Epidaurus Limera:368 C, 12-19
7–544 C, 4; 552 C, 31–553 C, 11; 607 C, 28–608 C, 6 Epigoni:325 C, 29–326 C, 7
Eniconiae:224 C, 28-29 Epiphanes:795 C, 28-33
Enienians:440 C, 33–441 C, 8 Epirotis:129 C, 4-9
Enipeus (Peloponnese):356 C, 24-31 Epirus, Epirotes:123 C, 21-29; 124 C, 3-10; 221 C, 5-21; 281 C,
Enipeus (Thessaly):431 C, 37–432 C, 7; 432 C, 8-9 28-35; 283 C, 12-16; 312 C, 29–313 C, 4; 321 C, 15-20;
Enna:272 C, 23-27; 273 C, 2-14; 273 C, 23-25 322 C, 14-24; 323 C, 9-13; 323 C, 32–324 C, 11; 325 C,
Ennius:281 C, 28-35 8-12; 326 C, 8-14; 326 C, 25-28; 327 C, 24-28; 332 C,
Enopa:359 C, 2-14; 360 C, 17-23 13–333 C, 3; 334 C, 4-10; 417 C, 6-10; 427 C, 33-37;
Enydra:753 C, 20-28 429 C, 28-33; 429 C, 33–430 C, 2; 434 C, 16-24; 453 C,
Enyo:535 C, 20–536 C, 3 6-15; 764 C, 8-17; 840 C, 13-26
Eordians:323 C, 3-8; 326 C, 14-20 Epistrophus:549 C, 23-30; 550 C, 21-26; 551 C, 4-9; 584 C,
Eos:33 C, 29–34 C, 3 31–585 C, 19; 611 C, 24–612 C, 8; 619 C, 13-29
Epacria:397 C, 19-27 Epitalium:343 C, 15-21; 349 C, 14-19; 349 C, 24-31
1005
Index of Ancient Names
Epius:263 C, 32–264 C, 1; 423 C, 24-29 Erythrae, Erythraea, Erythraeans (Ionia): 404 C, 30-35;
Epomeus:248 C, 17-25 588 C, 19-32; 589 C, 24-33; 613 C, 19-28; 633 C, 10-19;
Erana:361 C, 4-14 644 C, 8–645 C, 9
Erasinus (Arcadia):371 C, 1-12 Erythran sea (= Arabian Sea):765 C, 21-26
Erasinus (Argia):371 C, 1-12 Erythran sea (= Persian Gulf):174 C, 22-26; 525 C,
Erasinus (Argolid):275 C, 5-19; 389 C, 3-9; 389 C, 12-22 30–526 C, 11
Erasinus (Attica):371 C, 1-12 Erythran sea (= Persian Gulf, Arabian Sea):766 C, 33-36;
Erasinus (Eretria):371 C, 1-12 778 C, 33–779 C, 14
Erasistratus:486 C, 19-24 Erythran sea (= Red Sea, Arabian Sea):790 C, 29–791 C,
Erastus:608 C, 28–609 C, 3 9; 804 C, 19-33
Eratosthenes:1 C, 1–2 C, 3; 6 C, 31–7 C, 22; 14 C, 10–94 C, Erythran sea (Red Sea):58 C, 24-32
20; 95 C, 9-11; 97 C, 24-29; 104 C, 6-34; 106 C, 27–107 C, Erythras:778 C, 33–779 C, 14
11; 108 C, 19-24; 113 C, 25–114 C, 1; 123 C, 13-21; 125 C, Eryx:254 C, 6-14; 272 C, 16-22; 273 C, 23-25; 608 C, 7-14
31–126 C, 3; 126 C, 12-23; 132 C, 3-10; 134 C, 12-24; 135 C, Esopis:259 C, 10-19
11-14; 148 C, 27-36; 159 C, 19-28; 170 C, 12-20; 170 C, Esquiline:234 C, 19-25; 237 C, 4-13
20-30; 224 C, 3-8; 298 C, 13–299 C, 18; 299 C, 25–301 C, Estiones:206 C, 13-26
1; 317 C, 7-15; 384 C, 29-33; 389 C, 12-22; 475 C, 20-26; Eteocles:414 C, 30–415 C, 10
490 C, 3-9; 497 C, 18-26; 507 C, 6-13; 509 C, 11-25; Eteocretans:221 C, 5-21; 475 C, 27–476 C, 5; 478 C,
513 C, 30–514 C, 22; 522 C, 14-27; 529 C, 11-30; 663 C, 28–479 C, 2
33–664 C, 4; 683 C, 34–684 C, 17; 687 C, 9-30; 688 C, Eteonus:298 C, 19–299 C, 12; 408 C, 38–409 C, 3; 409 C,
25–689 C, 7; 689 C, 17-26; 690 C, 19-35; 693 C, 19–694 C, 6-8
4; 723 C, 15-24; 727 C, 21-27; 741 C, 25–742 C, 3; 743 C, Etesians:690 C, 19-21; 691 C, 18–692 C, 9; 731 C, 24-30;
3-20; 746 C, 14–747 C, 2; 764 C, 27-29; 765 C, 27–766 C, 776 C, 4-13; 777 C, 16-24
6; 767 C, 1-2; 767 C, 22-30; 769 C, 18-19; 778 C, 33–779 C, Ethiopia, Ethiopians:2 C, 21-33; 3 C, 13-19; 7 C, 23–8 C, 1;
14; 785 C, 20–786 C, 26; 786 C, 28-29; 802 C, 17-28; 8 C, 26–9 C, 7; 16 C, 13-22; 27 C, 13-27; 29 C, 32–30 C,
825 C, 25-33; 829 C, 1-11; 837 C, 29–838 C, 8 5; 30 C, 9–35 C, 20; 37 C, 29–38 C, 13; 39 C, 11-22; 39 C,
Eratyra:326 C, 14-20 33–40 C, 3; 40 C, 10-22; 40 C, 35–41 C, 4; 42 C, 33–43 C,
Erembians:2 C, 21-33; 8 C, 26–9 C, 7; 27 C, 13-27; 29 C, 32–30 C, 5; 61 C, 5-15; 61 C, 31–62 C, 4; 62 C, 4-8; 64 C, 1-8; 72 C,
5; 37 C, 29–38 C, 5; 41 C, 23–42 C, 33; 784 C, 12-20 18-28; 85 C, 6-13; 94 C, 9-20; 94 C, 35–95 C, 9; 97 C,
Eressus:618 C, 8-16 34–98 C, 7; 99 C, 3-11; 100 C, 1-12; 101 C, 24–102 C, 3;
Eretria (Athens):447 C, 31-36 103 C, 9-24; 117 C, 12-20; 130 C, 18-32; 131 C, 11-19; 157 C,
Eretria (Thessaly):433 C, 33–434 C, 6; 447 C, 31-36 14-20; 183 C, 13-27; 298 C, 19–299 C, 12; 300 C, 20–301 C,
Eretria, Eretrians (?Euboea):371 C, 1-12 1; 519 C, 16-26; 554 C, 24–555 C, 2; 686 C, 25–687 C, 8;
Eretria, Eretrians (Euboea):40 C, 23-34; 247 C, 29–248 C, 690 C, 21-34; 692 C, 9-19; 692 C, 30–693 C, 5; 695 C, 1-9;
6; 433 C, 33–434 C, 6; 445 C, 29-33; 446 C, 21-25; 695 C, 22–696 C, 26; 759 C, 28-33; 767 C, 31–768 C, 6;
446 C, 33–447 C, 4; 447 C, 31–448 C, 25; 747 C, 20-23 769 C, 1-7; 772 C, 12-21; 776 C, 4-13; 776 C, 18-21; 778 C,
Eretrieus:447 C, 31-36 17-32; 780 C, 1-11; 784 C, 12-30; 785 C, 13-19; 786 C,
Eretum:228 C, 9-19; 228 C, 30-33; 238 C, 16-26 19-26; 786 C, 30–787, 11; 788 C, 10-21; 789 C, 13–790 C, 8;
Erginus:414 C, 19-29 797 C, 13-18; 798 C, 13-27; 808 C, 9-25; 812 C, 22–813 C,
Ericodes:277 C, 16-19 2; 815 C, 14-17; 817 C, 7-20; 818 C, 3-10; 819 C, 7-17; 819 C,
Ericthonius:604 C, 20-36 29–823 C, 14; 825 C, 5-19; 828 C, 18-27; 830 C, 1-10;
Ericussa:276 C, 23-30 835 C, 16-29; 839 C, 3-9; 839 C, 16-26
Eridanus:215 C, 5-12; 397 C, 9-18 Etna:20 C, 23-33; 23 C, 14-27; 54 C, 4-15; 247 C, 6-17; 248 C,
Erigon:327 C, 12-19 6-16; 267 C, 18-22; 268 C, 18–269 C, 4; 272 C, 1-4; 273 C,
Erineus:362 C, 13-22 2-14; 273 C, 26–274 C, 4; 273 C, 26–274 C, 30; 275 C,
Erineus (Doris):427 C, 20-24; 429 C, 28-33; 475 C, 32–276 C, 4; 626 C, 33–627 C, 14
35–476 C, 5 Etruscans:219 C, 15-22
Erineus (Thessaly):433 C, 33–434 C, 6 Euaemon:438 C, 35–439 C, 5
Erineus (Troad):597 C, 14-25; 598 C, 6-20 Euanthes:259 C, 10-19
Eropedia:205 C, 28–206 C, 3 Euboea (Argia):449 C, 25-30
Erpha:663 C, 19-33 Euboea (Corcyra):449 C, 25-30
Erycinian Aphrodite:272 C, 16-22 Euboea (Lemnos):449 C, 25-30
Erymanthus:343 C, 15-21 Euboea (Macedonia):449 C, 25-30
Erymnae:442 C, 35–443 C, 9 Euboea (Sicily):272 C, 27-32; 449 C, 25-30
Erysichaeans:460 C, 12-18 Euboea, Euboeans:40 C, 23-34; 58 C, 1-9; 60 C, 7-15;
Erythia:148 C, 16-36; 169 C, 21-28; 269 C, 4-19 60 C, 35–61 C, 4; 124 C, 16-24; 267 C, 22-33; 328 C,
Erythini/Erythrini:542 C, 17-30; 545 C, 2-13 2-10; 350 C, 6-12; 356 C, 9-23; 386 C, 9-23; 395 C,
Erythra (= Persian Gulf):80 C, 16-20; 529 C, 11-30 18-21; 399 C, 22-26; 400 C, 23-37; 403 C, 8-20; 405 C,
Erythra (Red Sea):32 C, 26–33 C, 3; 38 C, 25–39 C, 11; 50 C, 30-31; 417 C, 18-27; 423 C, 24-29; 425 C, 6-13; 425 C,
12-24; 55 C, 33–56 C, 25; 65 C, 13-17; 298 C, 19–299 C, 13-28; 426 C, 6-11; 429 C, 24-28; 435 C, 39-43; 437 C,
12; 491 C, 23-32; 768 C, 7-14; 786 C, 19-26; 809 C, 21-29; 20-26; 438 C, 16-21; 444 C, 8–449 C, 30; 452 C,
815 C, 6-14 34–453 C, 6; 467 C, 2-10; 472 C, 1-6; 504 C, 18-24;
Erythrae (Boeotia):404 C, 30-35; 409 C, 6-8; 410 C, 16-21 654 C, 19–655 C, 2
1006
Index of Ancient Names
1007
Index of Ancient Names
1008
Index of Ancient Names
1009
Index of Ancient Names
Gyges:420 C, 32–421 C, 9; 590 C, 34–591 C, 8; 680 C, 9-24 Harma (Boeotia):404 C, 8-25; 405 C, 13-30; 410 C, 16-21
Gymnesian islands:122 C, 34–123 C, 9; 129 C, 4-9; 144 C, Harmonia:46 C, 1-13; 326 C, 21-25
6-11; 144 C, 22-28; 159 C, 19-28; 167 C, 15–168 C, 27; Harmoza:765 C, 27–766 C, 6
654 C, 19–655 C, 2 Harmozica:500 C, 27–501 C, 4
Gymnosophists:762 C, 18-30 Harpagia:587 C, 15-23
Gynaecon Polis:803 C, 13-24 Harpagus:252 C, 14-18
Gyrton/Gyrtona:439 C, 26-28; 439 C, 29–440 C, 3; 441 C, Harpalus:837 C, 15-23
21-30; 441 C, 36–442 C, 17; 443 C, 23-31 Harpina:356 C, 31–357 C, 4
Gythium:343 C, 11-15; 363 C, 23–364 C, 2 Hasdrubal:158 C, 21-29
Hebe:382 C, 16-25
Hebrus:322 C, 28–323 C, 3; 590 C, 23-33
1010
Index of Ancient Names
Hellopia, Hellopians (= Euboea):328 C, 2-10; 445 C, 19-29; Heraclium (Cimmerian Bosporus):494 C, 15-18
445 C, 33–446 C, 15 Heraclium (Crete):476 C, 12-20; 484 C, 19-28
Hellopia, Hellopians (Epirus):328 C, 2-10 Heraclium (Egypt):788 C, 10-21; 801 C, 14-23
Hellopia, Hellopians (Histaeotis):445 C, 19-25 Heraclium (Gadira):169 C, 13-20; 170 C, 20-30; 172 C, 3-20;
Hellops:445 C, 19-25 172 C, 24-31
Helos (Boeotia):406 C, 14-26 Heraclium (nr Neapolis):246 C, 29–247 C, 5
Helos (Laconia):343 C, 11-15; 349 C, 5-12; 349 C, 19-24; Heraclium (Sicily):266 C, 6-19
350 C, 2-6; 364 C, 39–365 C, 8 Heraclium (Syria):751 C, 5-18; 753 C, 20-28
Helots:701 C, 21–702 C, 4 Heraea:336 C, 36–337 C, 8; 388 C, 28-36
Helvettians:192 C, 31-36; 193 C, 18-30; 196 C, 21-26; 206 C, Heraeum:368 C, 23-27
13-26; 208 C, 14-19; 292 C, 25-31; 293 C, 23–294 C, 3 Hera’s Island:168 C, 25-27; 170 C, 12-20
Hemeroscopium:159 C, 1-11; 161 C, 18-25 Hercynian Forest:207 C, 7-17; 290 C, 17-25; 292 C, 11-25;
Heniochia, Heniochans:129 C, 22-26; 492 C, 20-28; 495 C, 292 C, 31-32; 293 C, 23–294 C, 3; 294 C, 34–295 C, 4
28–496 C, 25; 496 C, 26–497 C, 4; 506 C, 4-15; 839 C, 16-26 Herdonia:282 C, 26–283 C, 8
Heorta:318 C, 6-13 Hermaea (headland):832 C, 7-13; 834 C, 8-13
Hephaestium:807 C, 21-27 Hermaeum:834 C, 8-13
Hephaestus:41 C, 4-22; 472 C, 31–473 C, 5 Hermagoras:621 C, 28-33
Hepta Phreata:782 C, 8-18 Hermes:42 C, 18-23; 104 C, 19-29; 343 C, 22-24; 816 C, 28-33
Heptacometae:548 C, 27-34; 549 C, 1-10 Hermias:610 C, 18-30; 614 C, 25–615 C, 2
Heptaporus:554 C, 12-24; 583 C, 8-33; 587 C, 5-14; 595 C, Hermion(a):369 C, 3-7; 372 C, 26-31; 373 C, 8-25; 374 C,
9-20; 602 C, 31–603 C, 12 6-9; 374 C, 22-32; 376 C, 7-19; 385 C, 13-24
Hera:215 C, 12-18; 252 C, 1-7; 261 C, 24-26; 354 C, 12-20; 372 C, Hermionic gulf:59 C, 10-22; 335 C, 23-27; 368 C, 10-12;
3-11; 373 C, 4-7; 380 C, 7-15; 426 C, 26-31; 583 C, 8-33; 369 C, 3-10; 380 C, 15-19; 390 C, 8-21
636 C, 33–637 C, 12; 639 C, 28–640 C, 9; 838 C, 9-19 Hermocreon:588 C, 3-18
Heracleotes:308 C, 15-23; 319 C, 3-10 Hermodorus:642 C, 2-11
Heracleotic mouth:85 C, 27-33; 788 C, 22-28 Hermonassa (Cimmerian Bosporus):494 C, 29–495 C, 5
Heracleotis:642 C, 12-20 Hermonassa (Pontus):548 C, 19-25
Heracles:2 C, 34–3 C, 12; 9 C, 8-12; 26 C, 31-37; 48 C, 7-19; Hermonax:305 C, 34–306 C, 8
139 C, 29–140 C, 7; 157 C, 1-14; 170 C, 20-30; 171 C, 1-21; Hermonthis:816 C, 34–817 C, 6
172 C, 3-11; 182 C, 34–183 C, 27; 185 C, 28-32; 202 C, Hermopolitans:812 C, 22–813 C, 2
32-35; 219 C, 15-22; 230 C, 23-33; 238 C, 16-26; 245 C, Hermopolite Watch-post:813 C, 3-9
10-18; 278 C, 7-18; 281 C, 19-28; 338 C, 11-17; 341 C, 7-17; Hermu Polis (nr Butus):802 C, 1-6
348 C, 4-14; 351 C, 23-36; 352 C, 20-23; 352 C, 37-39; Hermu Polis (nr Chabrias):803 C, 13-24
354 C, 21–355 C, 7; 358 C, 9-19; 363 C, 10-21; 373 C, Hermu Polis (nr Mendes):802 C, 7-17
19-25; 414 C, 19-29; 425 C, 22-28; 427 C, 24-29; 428 C, Hermundurians:290 C, 32–291 C, 7
19-28; 438 C, 16-21; 448 C, 12-14; 451 C, 8-16; 458 C, Hermus:554 C, 12-24; 581 C, 13–582 C, 3; 583 C, 34–584 C,
14–459 C, 2; 459 C, 18-25; 487 C, 15-19; 495 C, 6-15; 11; 586 C, 23-29; 621 C, 21-24; 621 C, 28-33; 625 C, 16-24;
505 C, 19-28; 563 C, 35–564 C, 7; 582 C, 14-29; 596 C, 625 C, 25–626 C, 10; 632 C, 5-17; 691 C, 9-17
5-22; 613 C, 19-28; 686 C, 25–688 C, 24; 711 C, 30–712 C, Hernicians:228 C, 34–229 C, 4; 231 C, 1-12; 237 C, 23–238 C, 12
4; 813 C, 31–814 C, 6; 826 C, 10-22; 828 C, 27-34 Herod:760 C, 23-31; 764 C, 34–765 C, 11
Heracles City:812 C, 10-21 Herodotus:30 C, 9-22; 35 C, 29–36 C, 2; 43 C, 13-20; 59 C,
Heracles Harbor:256 C, 21-30 22-33; 61 C, 31–62 C, 4; 62 C, 8-13; 98 C, 13-17; 100 C,
Heracles Island:159 C, 1-11 24-34; 151 C, 1-13; 282 C, 6-11; 301 C, 12-21; 428 C,
Heraclia (?= Salbaca):658 C, 26–659 C, 5 19-28; 448 C, 1-11; 472 C, 31–473 C, 5; 507 C, 26–508 C,
Heraclia (Aeolid):606 C, 33–607 C, 6 9; 531 C, 1-15; 532 C, 26–533 C, 4; 534 C, 8-20; 536 C,
Heraclia (beneath Latmus):635 C, 31–636 C, 9 20-29; 544 C, 5-14; 550 C, 9-15; 573 C, 1-13; 611 C, 10-23;
Heraclia (Brettia):264 C, 1-11; 264 C, 19-29; 281 C, 1-5 618 C, 16-27; 625 C, 25–626 C, 10; 627 C, 15-22; 656 C,
Heraclia (Macedonia):323 C, 3-8 12-23; 668 C, 1-6; 691 C, 9-17; 818 C, 33–819 C, 4; 823 C,
Heraclia (nr Bambyca in Syria):751 C, 5-18 33–824 C, 11
Heraclia (nr Posidium in Syria):751 C, 31-35; 753 C, 20-28 Heroon Polis:85 C, 27-33; 759 C, 19-27; 767 C, 22-30;
Heraclia (nr Rhagae):514 C, 24-31 768 C, 27-34; 769 C, 20–770 C, 2; 803 C, 3-12; 804 C,
Heraclia (Pontus):540 C, 30–541 C, 27; 542 C, 4–543 C, 33–805 C, 4; 809 C, 21-29; 819 C, 22-29; 836 C, 10-19
19; 544 C, 14-25; 546 C, 2-20; 553 C, 12-21 Hero’s Tower:591 C, 8-18
Heraclia (Trachinian):60 C, 16-35; 382 C, 16-25; 389 C, Herostratus:640 C, 21–641 C, 5
25-36; 408 C, 34-37; 428 C, 14-18; 429 C, 10-14; 434 C, Herpa:537 C, 5-11; 538 C, 31–539 C, 9
6-15; 442 C, 27-34 Hesiod:23 C, 14-27; 29 C, 27-30; 42 C, 18-23; 42 C, 33–43 C,
Heraclian promontory:548 C, 19-25 13; 221 C, 22-32; 298 C, 19–299 C, 12; 300 C, 20–301 C,
Heraclides:98 C, 13-17; 100 C, 24-34; 384 C, 33–385 C, 9; 1; 302 C, 13-26; 322 C, 5-13; 327 C, 29–328 C, 1; 342 C,
540 C, 30–541 C, 14; 604 C, 20-36 10-18; 364 C, 4-22; 370 C, 4-12; 371 C, 13-19; 385 C, 9-12;
Heraclides (doctor):645 C, 5-9 393 C, 28-34; 409 C, 18-24; 413 C, 10-16; 424 C, 22-26;
Heraclids:333 C, 18-29 442 C, 17-26; 471 C, 32-38; 507 C, 26–508 C, 9; 587 C,
Heraclitus:3 C, 31-36; 642 C, 2-11; 656 C, 12-23; 784 C, 2-11 24–588 C, 2; 622 C, 28–623 C, 9; 642 C, 21–643 C, 9;
Heraclium (Brettia):259 C, 5-10; 259 C, 10-19 647 C, 18-30; 676 C, 7-13
1011
Index of Ancient Names
Hesperides (Cyrenaea):123 C, 13-21; 457 C, 34–458 C, 5 70 C, 20-27; 83 C, 16-24; 102 C, 12-20; 103 C, 9-24;
Hesperides (lake):836 C, 20-28 111 C, 19-28; 149 C, 1–150 C, 18; 157 C, 21-32; 212 C, 7-17;
Hesperides (mythical divinities):150 C, 19-29; 182 C, 221 C, 5-21; 224 C, 13-18; 244 C, 7-15; 255 C, 20–256 C, 2;
34–183 C, 12; 299 C, 12-18 256 C, 21-30; 271 C, 18-33; 295 C, 22–296 C, 19; 298 C,
Hesperus:416 C, 22-30 13–300 C, 14; 301 C, 12-21; 302 C, 13-26; 303 C, 8-18;
Hestia:220 C, 11-19 328 C, 2-17; 328 C, 27–329 C, 10; 332 C, 4-13; 336 C, 18–
Hestiaea:599 C, 17-30 337 C, 8; 337 C, 17–338 C, 11; 339 C, 6-16; 340 C, 6-37;
Hestiaeotis (Thessaly):431 C, 16-24; 441 C, 9-20; 475 C, 341 C, 7-17; 342 C, 18-26; 343 C, 36–344 C, 7; 345 C,
35–476 C, 5. See also Histiaeotis (Thessaly) 6-11; 345 C, 19-24; 346 C, 19-29; 348 C, 4-14; 348 C,
Hicesias:580 C, 6-10 20–355 C, 19; 354 C, 2-20; 355 C, 7-9; 356 C, 9-23; 359 C,
Hiera (headland):666 C, 11-26 30-33; 360 C, 17-30; 363 C, 23–364 C, 2; 364 C, 4-2;
Hiera (island):275 C, 20–276 C, 30; 277 C, 1-15 365 C, 12-20; 367 C, 8-14; 367 C, 19-29; 368 C, 27–369 C,
Hiera City:747 C, 32–748 C, 6 1; 369 C, 3-7; 369 C, 18–370 C, 38; 371 C, 26–372 C, 2;
Hieracon:773 C, 23-28 372 C, 26-31; 375 C, 8-15; 376 C, 7-24; 376 C, 24-28;
Hieracon Polis:816 C, 34–817 C, 6 377 C, 5-13; 384 C, 16-26; 387 C, 28–388 C, 3; 388 C,
Hierapolis (Phrygia):578 C, 31–579 C, 9; 629 C, 22–630 C, 19 28-36; 392 C, 3-13; 394 C, 8-14; 394 C, 28-33; 399 C,
Hierapytna:440 C, 17-32; 472 C, 6-12; 472 C, 20-30; 475 C, 14-22; 401 C, 19-28; 404 C, 30–405 C, 9; 405 C,
5-12 13-30; 406 C, 27–407 C, 3; 407 C, 11–414 C, 29; 417 C,
Hierapytnians:478 C, 28–479 C, 2 27–418 C, 1; 420 C, 24–421 C, 9; 423 C, 16-29; 424 C,
Hiericus:760 C, 23-31; 763 C, 5-23; 779 C, 21-27 2-10; 424 C, 11-22; 425 C, 31-38; 426 C, 19-22; 426 C,
Hiero (of Laodicia):578 C, 8-19 32-35; 427 C, 3-10; 429 C, 15-20; 430 C, 24–443 C, 9;
Hiero (of Syracuse):268 C, 18-32 445 C, 9-18; 446 C, 26-32; 448 C, 32–449 C, 16; 451 C,
Hierocepia:683 C, 17-27; 683 C, 34–684 C, 7 17-23; 451 C, 34–452 C, 7; 452 C, 34–455 C, 13; 455 C,
Hieronymus (historian):378 C, 31–379 C, 2; 443 C, 23-31; 35–456 C, 24; 456 C, 32–457 C, 33; 459 C, 3-8; 460 C,
474 C, 31–475 C, 5 12-18; 460 C, 22-26; 460 C, 31-35; 461 C, 5-34; 462 C,
Hieronymus (philosopher):655 C, 17-28 20-27; 462 C, 31–463 C, 16; 467 C, 10-16; 473 C, 9-16;
Himera:272 C, 27-32; 274 C, 31–275 C, 5 475 C, 27–477 C, 6; 478 C, 12-20; 479 C, 27&480 C, 2;
Himeras:266 C, 6-19 482 C, 19-27; 484 C, 29-32; 487 C, 10-14; 488 C, 11-15;
Hipparchus:2 C, 11-20; 5 C, 32–6 C, 4; 7 C, 14-23–8 C, 501 C, 35–502 C, 12; 507 C, 26–508 C, 9; 536 C, 20-29;
1; 14 C, 22-32–15 C, 1-6; 16 C, 31–17 C, 2; 27 C, 13-27; 543 C, 25–544 C, 4; 544 C, 26–545 C, 13; 549 C, 23-30;
55 C, 11-19; 56 C, 8–57 C, 18; 62 C, 22-29; 63 C, 24-34; 552 C, 19-30; 553 C, 12–555 C, 2; 564 C, 27–565 C, 19;
67 C, 7–94 C, 20; 106 C, 10-16; 113 C, 25–114 C, 1; 131 C, 572 C, 2-14; 573 C, 1–574 C, 13; 581 C, 1-12; 582 C, 4-14;
26–132 C, 33; 332 C, 4-13; 529 C, 11-30; 566 C, 19-22 582 C, 30–583 C, 33; 584 C, 12–587 C, 14; 589 C, 9-23;
Hippi:644 C, 15-22 590 C, 3-33; 592 C, 1-11; 592 C, 26–593 C, 16; 594 C, 18-
Hippo (near Ityca):832 C, 1-7 29; 595 C, 6-20; 596 C, 17-22; 597 C, 14-25; 598 C, 21-31;
Hippo (toward Tretum):832 C, 1-7 599 C, 1-30; 600 C, 24–601 C, 24; 602 C, 16-37; 603 C,
Hippobotus:525 C, 3-15 30–604 C, 12; 605 C, 1-3; 605 C, 15–606 C, 4; 607 C,
Hippocles:243 C, 12-17 28–608 C, 6; 608 C, 14-27; 611 C, 3-10; 611 C, 24–612 C,
Hippocoon:461 C, 23-29 8; 612 C, 28–613 C, 9; 613 C, 29–614 C, 4; 615 C,
Hippocorona:472 C, 20-30 27–616 C, 10; 619 C, 13–620 C, 21; 622 C, 28–623 C, 9;
Hippocoronium:472 C, 20-30 626 C, 10-19; 627 C, 23-30; 630 C, 26–631 C, 4; 635 C,
Hippocrates:657 C, 15–658 C, 4 31–636 C, 4; 638 C, 19–639 C, 2; 643 C, 9-21; 645 C,
Hipponax:340 C, 37–341 C, 3; 633 C, 31–634 C, 5; 636 C, 22-30; 645 C, 36–646 C, 11; 650 C, 10-16; 653 C, 9-33;
19-25; 642 C, 2-11 654 C, 19–655 C, 2; 661 C, 17-28; 667 C, 5-13; 674 C, 13-
Hipponian bay:254 C, 30–255 C, 7; 255 C, 13-18; 261 C, 26; 676 C, 29-33; 677 C, 33–678 C, 16; 678 C, 32–679 C,
16-24 10; 679 C, 28–680 C, 9; 696 C, 14-26; 711 C, 3-10; 735 C,
Hipponium:256 C, 14-20 21-28; 756 C, 22-31; 757 C, 16-27; 761 C, 31–762 C, 30;
Hippothous:620 C, 8-21; 620 C, 22-27 784 C, 12–785 C, 5; 790 C, 9-21; 793 C, 27–794 C, 4;
Hippucrena:379 C, 25-30 797 C, 24–798 C, 4; 802 C, 17-28; 814 C, 6-14; 815 C,
Hippus:498 C, 7-15; 500 C, 18-27 28–816 C, 5; 834 C, 25-33
Hira:359 C, 2-14; 360 C, 17-23 Homola/Homolium:442 C, 35–443 C, 9; 443 C, 23-31
Hirpini:250 C, 26-28 Homonadians:569 C, 3–570 C, 4; 678 C, 32–679 C, 10
Hispellum:227 C, 32-36 Hormiae:233 C, 20-26
Histi:639 C, 3-14 Horn of the Byzantines:319 C, 32–320 C, 17
Histiaea, Histiaeotis (Euboea):437 C, 20–438 C, 21; Hortensius:514 C, 36–515 C, 3
445 C, 19–446 C, 15 Hyamitis:361 C, 15-21
Histiaeotis (Thessaly):446 C, 33–446 C, 8. See also Hyampia:424 C, 2-10
Hestiaeotis (Thessaly) Hyampolis:401 C, 28; 415 C, 31–416 C, 2; 424 C, 2-10
Holmi (Cilicia):670 C, 9-12 Hyantes:321 C, 3-14; 401 C, 13-28; 424 C, 2-10; 464 C,
Holmi (Parorius):663 C, 19-33 21-32
Homer:1 C, 1–7 C, 13; 8 C, 18-22; 8 C, 26–9 C, 7; 9 C, Hyarotis:694 C, 14-26; 697 C, 27–698 C, 2; 699 C,
35–10 C, 5; 12 C, 2-9; 12 C, 14-29; 16 C, 3–48 C, 28; 53 C, 18-21
6-22; 58 C, 10-23; 59 C, 1-22; 59 C, 22-33; 65 C, 10-12; Hybla:267 C, 22-33; 268 C, 18-32
1012
Index of Ancient Names
1013
Index of Ancient Names
Icos:436 C, 34-39 117 C, 35–118 C, 14; 119 C, 10-17; 129 C, 10-26; 130 C,
Ictinus:395 C, 7-12 6-14; 133 C, 8-9; 133 C, 14-17; 133 C, 32–134 C, 2; 134 C,
Ida (Crete):472 C, 20-30; 478 C, 28–479 C, 2; 604 C, 20-36 12-14; 223 C, 27–224 C, 3; 301 C, 12-21; 471 C, 18-24;
Ida (Troad):40 C, 23-34; 59 C, 34–60 C, 7; 321 C, 21-28; 490 C, 9-13; 492 C, 10-19; 505 C, 19–506 C, 3; 510 C,
457 C, 23-33; 466 C, 9-18; 469 C, 1-9; 470 C, 14-24; 3-14; 514 C, 14-22; 516 C, 17-28; 518 C, 34–519 C, 16;
472 C, 20-30; 473 C, 17-34; 565 C, 7-19; 574 C, 14-19; 663 C, 33–664 C, 4; 685 C, 6–720 C, 7; 685 C, 6–720 C,
576 C, 20-25; 581 C, 13–582 C, 3; 583 C, 8–584 C, 11; 14; 721 C, 7-17; 721 C, 34–722 C, 8; 723 C, 26–724 C, 16;
585 C, 20-32; 586 C, 30–587 C, 5; 592 C, 1-11; 592 C, 724 C, 32–725 C, 16; 725 C, 32–726 C, 5; 730 C, 8-18;
26–593 C, 16; 596 C, 24-31; 602 C, 6-16; 604 C, 20-36; 732 C, 2-6; 739 C, 29–740 C, 4; 762 C, 18-30; 767 C,
605 C, 15–606 C, 4; 606 C, 6-18; 606 C, 27-33; 607 C, 31–768 C, 6; 781 C, 16-21; 782 C, 27-30; 785 C, 6-12;
6-27; 612 C, 15-23; 613 C, 29–614 C, 4; 616 C, 11-22 815 C, 14-17; 816 C, 18-27; 828 C, 27-34; 839 C, 16-26
Idanthyrsus:686 C, 25–687 C, 8 Indian ocean, Indian sea:510 C, 26–511 C, 8; 519 C, 9-16
Ideëssa:499 C, 10-13 Indicetans:160 C, 4-11
Idomena:389 C, 25-36 Indus:64 C, 8-20; 689 C, 13-17; 689 C, 26-31; 690 C, 7-18;
Idomeneus (Homeric character):394 C, 15-28; 413 C, 697 C, 27–698 C, 14; 701 C, 2-20; 702 C, 10-26; 706 C,
16-20; 479 C, 31&480 C, 14 24–707 C, 9; 720 C, 8-24; 723 C, 15–724 C, 6; 724 C,
Idomeneus (of Lampsacus):589 C, 33–590 C, 2 9-16; 726 C, 18-28
Idrians:677 C, 33–678 C, 16 Ingaunans:202 C, 3-14
Idrieus:656 C, 24–657 C, 11 Innesa:268 C, 18-32
Idubeda:161 C, 1-15; 162 C, 5-11; 162 C, 11-18 Inopus:271 C, 18-33
Idumaeans:749 C, 14-21; 760 C, 17-23 Insubrians:212 C, 31–213 C, 16; 216 C, 6-10; 216 C, 15-29;
Ielysus:653 C, 9-33 218 C, 10-15; 292 C, 25-31
Ierne:63 C, 9-14; 63 C, 24-34; 72 C, 11-15; 75 C, 19-31; 118 C, Interamna:227 C, 32-36
25-32; 118 C, 36–119 C, 8; 119 C, 10-17; 132 C, 17-24; Interamnium:237 C, 13-18
201 C, 3-8 Intercatia:162 C, 26-32
Iguvium:227 C, 32-36 Interocrea:228 C, 9-19
Ikizari:560 C, 19–561 C, 4 Intimilians:202 C, 3-14
Ilasarus:781 C, 29–782 C, 8 Io:673 C, 17-22; 750 C, 11-24
Ilerda:161 C, 15-25 Iol:831 C, 11-19
Ilergetian region:161 C, 15-18 Iolaans:224 C, 34–225 C, 8
Ilian Village:593 C, 5-16; 595 C, 35–596 C, 5; 597 C, Iolaus:224 C, 34–225 C, 8; 377 C, 14-20
25–598 C, 20 Iolcus:436 C, 1-19; 436 C, 24-26; 438 C, 23-33
Ilibirris:182 C, 3-8 Ion (dramatist):60 C, 7-15; 364 C, 4-22; 645 C, 22-30
Iliocolona:589 C, 24-33 Ion (river):327 C, 19-24
Ilipa:141 C, 22-32; 142 C, 4-9; 174 C, 27–175 C, 10 Ion (son of Xuthus):383 C, 1-6; 383 C, 12-19
Ilium. See Troad, Troy, Trojans Ionia, Ionians (Asia):58 C, 10-23; 61 C, 16-29; 65 C, 17-28;
Ilium (Hisarlik):594 C, 2-18; 595 C, 35–596 C, 5; 597 C, 114 C, 18-24; 124 C, 16-24; 126 C, 3-11; 129 C, 27–130 C,
14–599 C, 30; 601 C, 33–602 C, 5 3; 149 C, 11-15; 264 C, 1-11; 321 C, 21-28; 338 C, 33–339 C,
Illyria, Illyrians:46 C, 1-13; 71 C, 15-20; 105 C, 24-33; 108 C, 5; 384 C, 14-16; 404 C, 30-35; 494 C, 8-14; 534 C,
24-28; 123 C, 30–124 C, 3; 128 C, 31–129 C, 3; 206 C, 8-20; 550 C, 15-20; 554 C, 12-24; 565 C, 20-27; 581 C,
7-13; 207 C, 7-17; 207 C, 26-33; 212 C, 31–213 C, 5; 214 C, 13–582 C, 3; 628 C, 31–629 C, 11; 632 C, 1–633 C, 31;
18-24; 283 C, 12-16; 287 C, 19-24; 289 C, 7-21; 303 C, 636 C, 10-18; 639 C, 15-27; 644 C, 15-22; 647 C, 1-6;
33–304 C, 6; 305 C, 2-11; 312 C, 29–313 C, 4; 313 C, 5-12; 648 C, 29–649 C, 10; 655 C, 29–656 C, 11; 661 C, 5-16;
313 C, 12–314 C, 5; 314 C, 24–315 C, 3; 315 C, 27–316 C, 662 C, 19-31; 663 C, 14-19; 679 C, 16-22
1; 317 C, 7–318 C, 16; 318 C, 18-24; 318 C, 28–319 C, 2; Ionia, Ionians (Attica):171 C, 1-14; 267 C, 22-33; 333 C, 4-13;
320 C, 29–321 C, 2; 321 C, 15-20; 323 C, 3-13; 326 C, 8-14; 333 C, 18-24; 384 C, 33–385 C, 9; 392 C, 3-20; 392 C,
327 C, 12-19; 327 C, 24-28; 332 C, 13–333 C, 3; 375 C, 38–393 C, 11
26–376 C, 1; 449 C, 25-30; 840 C, 13-26 Ionia, Ionians (Peloponnese):333 C, 18-24; 383 C, 1-6;
Ilus:592 C, 26–593 C, 4; 597 C, 14-25 383 C, 19–384 C, 3; 385 C, 28–386 C, 8
Imaum, Imaeum:129 C, 15-22; 510 C, 26–511 C, 8; 518 C, Ionian colonization:10 C, 6-20; 61 C, 5-15; 298 C, 19–299 C,
34–519 C, 3; 689 C, 3-7 12; 621 C, 11-20
Imbrasus:457 C, 14-16; 636 C, 33–637 C, 12 Ionian gulf:123 C, 21–124 C, 3; 259 C, 5-10; 316 C, 30–317 C,
Imbros:28 C, 12-24; 124 C, 16-24; 221 C, 33-38; 338 C, 6; 326 C, 8-20
33–339 C, 5; 457 C, 5-14 Iope:42 C, 33–43 C, 5; 758 C, 31–759 C, 9
Inachus (Argolid):271 C, 18-37; 370 C, 18-23; 371 C, 1-12 Ios:484 C, 29-32
Inachus (Epirus):325 C, 29–326 C, 7; 327 C, 6-12 Iphicrates:827 C, 12-20
India, Indians:7 C, 23–8 C, 1; 34 C, 4-10; 38 C, 6-13; 39 C, Iphigenia:535 C, 20–536 C, 3
22-32; 64 C, 1-20; 64 C, 27–65 C, 3; 66 C, 23-31; 67 C, Iphitus (Homeric character):367 C, 19-29
7–68 C, 29; 69 C, 8-18; 69 C, 31–70 C, 20; 71 C, 11-15; Iphitus (king of Elia):357 C, 28–358 C, 9
71 C, 24-29; 72 C, 18-28; 72 C, 31–73 C, 3; 73 C, 24-27; Iris:52 C, 20-29; 547 C, 19-32
74 C, 23-32; 76 C, 7–77 C, 25; 78 C, 8-18; 80 C, 31–81 C, Isadicians:506 C, 16-23
8; 84 C, 3-9; 84 C, 16-26; 87 C, 15-19; 98 C, 21-28; 99 C, Isamus:516 C, 17-28
21–100 C, 12; 100 C, 24-34; 101 C, 6-13; 103 C, 9-24; Isar:185 C, 11-32; 191 C, 14-22; 204 C, 4-5
1014
Index of Ancient Names
1015
Index of Ancient Names
1016
Index of Ancient Names
1017
Index of Ancient Names
Ligystica:92 C, 10-16; 122 C, 16-23; 122 C, 34–123 C, 9; 426 C, 32–427 C, 19; 449 C, 36–450 C, 13; 459 C,
128 C, 16-30; 165 C, 6-13; 176 C, 18–177 C, 8; 187 C, 31–460 C, 3
3-15; 204 C, 6-8; 207 C, 7-17; 209 C, 15–210 C, 8; 210 C, Locrus:322 C, 5-13
31–211 C, 12; 212 C, 1-7; 218 C, 10-15; 218 C, 21-24; 219 C, Lookouts of Demetrius:771 C, 13-21
3-13; 222 C, 23-24; 287 C, 25-34 Lookouts of Eudoxus:806 C, 31–807 C, 3
Ligystican sea:106 C, 21-26; 122 C, 31–123 C, 9 Lopadussa:834 C, 18-22
Lilaea:16 C, 13-22; 407 C, 19-26; 424 C, 11-22; 427 C, 20-24 Loryma:652 C,