Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Polytetrafluoroethylene Paste Extrusion A Fibrillation Model and Its Relation To Mechanical Properties
Polytetrafluoroethylene Paste Extrusion A Fibrillation Model and Its Relation To Mechanical Properties
Polytetrafluoroethylene Paste Extrusion A Fibrillation Model and Its Relation To Mechanical Properties
net/publication/258996747
CITATIONS READS
11 6,048
3 authors, including:
All content following this page was uploaded by Savvas G Hatzikiriakos on 07 May 2015.
1 Department of Chemical and Biological Engineering, The University of British Columbia, Vancouver, BC, Canada
2
School of Mining Engineering and Metallurgy, National Technical University of Athens, Athens, Greece
306 Carl Hanser Verlag, Munich Intern. Polymer Processing XXVIII (2013) 3
Not for use in internet or intranet sites. Not for electronic distribution. H. A. Ardakani et al.: PTFE Paste Extrusion
In the present work, we study the effects of die design and reduction ratio, entrance angle and aspect ratio). The experi-
extrusion conditions on the mechanical properties of PTFE mental results and the model fits and predictions are presented
paste extrudates, and relate them to the quantity and quality of in section 4. The conclusions and a brief summary of the pres-
the fibrils formed during the extrusion. A new simple phenom- ent work are discussed in section 5.
enological model is also derived for the fibrillation, and its re-
lation to mechanical properties (tensile strength) is studied in
detail. The organization of this paper is as follows. In section 2, 2 Experimental
the materials studied in this work are described, followed by a
general description of the experimental equipment and proce- 2.1 Materials
dures. The phenomenological fibrillation model is presented
in section 3 and discussed sequentially in relation to the issue As discussed above the rheological behavior of PTFE pastes
of fibril quantity and quality, and the effects of die design (die was examined in our previous work (Ardakani et al., 2013).
Here we examine the mechanical properties of the extruded
samples and its relation to fibrillation using a phenomenologi-
cal simple mathematical model. Experiments were performed
www.polymer-process.com
2.2 Methods
0.508 350 20 15
r ¼ Ccn þ Kc_ m ; ð2Þ
0.508 350 20 30
0.508 350 20 45
where r is the shear stress, C is a consistency constant, c is the
0.508 350 20 60 shear strain, c_ is the shear rate, K is the consistency index, and
0.508 350 20 90 n and m are power-law exponents.
0.762 150 20 90 Based on the \radial-flow" hypothesis, the kinematics of
1.27 50 20 90 PTFE flow can be calculated independent of any rheological
constitutive law at a given volumetric flow rate Q. Considering
Table 1. Reservoir and die dimensions used in the present work a simple constitutive equation for PTFE paste, an analytical ex-
pression for the extrusion pressure was derived by Ardakani
et al. (2013) which can be written as follows:
A Com-Ten, Compression & Tensile Strength was used to
2013 Carl Hanser Verlag, Munich, Germany
(
measure the tensile strengths of the dried extrudates collected B Db 2B
during the extrusion process. The unit consists of a load cell Pextrusion ¼ rra ðRRÞ þ 2ð1 þ BÞ C
2sina
moving upward at a constant speed to stretch the sample up to
the point where rupture occurs. Each experiment was repeated Z D
ð3lnðrb =rÞÞn
b
rb ¼2sina
K
three to five times and the average value is reported along its dr þ
D
ra ¼ pffiffi b r2Bþ1 ð3m þ 2BÞ
standard deviation shown by means of error bars. 2 RRtana
m
)
12Qtan3 a Vþ3m=2
ðRRÞ 1 ; ð3Þ
pð1 cosaÞD3b
3 Phenomenological Model for Fibrillation
where
Phenomenological analytical flow models for calculating the rra ¼ roa ðe4f L=Da 1Þ þ rzL e 4f L=Da
ð4Þ
extrusion pressure as a function of the operating conditions
and geometrical characteristics of dies are based on the \ra- and
dial-flow" hypothesis (Snelling and Lontz, 1960; Ariawan !m
n
3 12Qsin3 aðRRÞ3=2
et al., 2002a; Patil et al., 2006a; Ardakani et al., 2013). This roa ¼ C lnðRRÞ þK ; ð5Þ
hypothesis assumes that the flow is along the radial direction 2 pð1 cosaÞD3b
where Pextrusion is the extrusion pressure, f is a Coulombic fric- fibrillation can be used to correlate the predicted degree of fi-
tion coefficient, B = fsina([2(1 – cosa)], rzL, is the shear stress brillation with the tensile strength of the extrudates. This is
Not for use in internet or intranet sites. Not for electronic distribution.
imposed at the die exit, which is negligible or zero. The first the main hypothesis and thus the main objective of the present
term in Eq. 3 represents the elastic contribution to the pressure work as discussed above.
drop, while the second term characterizes the pressure drop Formation and destruction of the material structure due to
due to the visous forces (more details in Ardakani et al., flow in complex fluids has been studied extensively in the lit-
2013). While this model satisfactorily represents the extrusion erature. In many cases, the structural build-up has been attribu-
pressure in PTFE paste extrusion, it provides no information ted to Brownian motion, which essentially results in weak
on the material structure and degree of fibrillation formed dur- structures (Coussot, 2005). Pinder (1964) and Coussot et al.
ing flow. (2002) suggested that the rate of structure build-up is always
Due to the fibril formation during the extrusion process, constant for various pasty materials. A few researchers also
PTFE extrudates have solid-like properties. It has been re- consider shear induced structure build-up in suspensions and
ported that the tensile strength of the final product is a function colloidal systems (Worral and Tuliani, 1964; Lee and Brodkey,
of many parameters such as flow rate, die geometrical parame- 1971; Dullaert and Mewis, 2005). Patil et al. (2006b) suggested
ters of the die, temperature, lubricant concentration, among that the rate of fibril formation and breakage in PTFE paste
others (Ariawan et al., 2001; 2002a; 2002b, Ochoa and Hatzi- flow can be described as a function of the deformation history
kiriakos, 2004; 2005). Certainly the tensile strength is related exerted on the material.
to the degree and quality of fibrils interconnecting the various In the present work due to the semi-solid behavior of PTFE
particles (Fig. 1). Therefore, a model predicting the degree of paste, it is assumed that the rate of fibril formation is propor-
tional to the elastic energy, which is stored in the PTFE paste
as it is being deformed during flow. It can be assumed that this
Nomenclature elastic energy is a function of the Hencky strain, e. As argued
above, squeezing of the particles and subsequent acceleration
A constant in the fibril formation kinetic equation can cause unwinding of mechanically interlocked crystallites
B model parameter defined as B = f sina/[2(1 – cosa)] to form fibrils. Therefore, a kinetic model that describes phe-
C consistency constant for the elastic term, Ludwik’s nomenologically this structure formation can be written as:
power-law model (Eq. 2) dn
Da die exit diameter ¼ AeM ð1 nÞ; ð6Þ
dt
Db barrel diameter
f Coulomb’s friction coefficient between paste and die where n is a structural parameter, which represents the percent-
age of PTFE particles interconnected with fibrils (degree of fi-
www.polymer-process.com
wall
K viscous consistency index brillation), 0 £ n £ 1, and A and M are constants.
L die length Previous experimental reports have shown that PTFE flow
M power law index for the fibril formation kinetic equa- through the conical part of the die is very similar to radial flow
tion (Snelling and Lontz, 1960; Ariawan et al., 2002a). Based on
m power law index for the viscous term the\radial-flow" hypothesis (Eq. 1), the flow parameters, such
n power law index for the elastic term as strain and strain rate, can be calculated anywhere in the
P pressure flow. In this case, the Hencky strain is the relevant quantity of
Q volumetric flow rate interest and it can be expressed by:
RR reduction ratio defined as (Db/Da)2 rb
e ¼ 3ln ; ð7Þ
r distance from die apex r
t time where rb is the distance at the die entrance from the die apex.
2013 Carl Hanser Verlag, Munich, Germany
Vp piston velocity Eq. 7 shows the rate of change of the structural parameter in
time. The time derivative of n can be written as:
Greek Letters dn dn dr
¼ : ð8Þ
dt dr dt
a half die entrance angle
Using Eq. 1, we get:
c shear strain
_ c_ A
c; shear rate, apparent shear rate dt 2pð1 cosaÞr2
: ð9Þ
e strain dr Q
r stress
Combining Eqs. 6 and 7, the following equation can be de-
rra stress at the entrance of die land (end of the conical
rived:
zone) defined by Eq. 4
dn n rb oM 2pð1 cosaÞr2
roa stress at the entrance of die land defined by Eq. 2
¼ A 3ln ð1 nÞ : ð10Þ
rzo stress at the entrance of die land (origin of the conical dr r Q
zone) defined by Eq. 4
rzL shear stress imposed at the die exit defined by Eq. 4 It can be assumed that the ultimate tensile strength should be
n structural parameter (degree of fibrillation) related with the degree of fibrillation as follows (Patil et al.,
2005).
Eq. 10 is solved by using MATLAB to calculate the degree crease in the viscous resistance of the paste (continuous lines
of fibrillation as a function of the operating conditions and the represent the model predictions of Eq. 3 using the parameters
Not for use in internet or intranet sites. Not for electronic distribution.
geometrical characteristics of the capillary dies, and it is com- listed in Table 2). The tensile strength shows a different trend
pared with corresponding experimental observations in terms and decreases with an increase in the apparent shear rate. The
of tensile strength. Eq. 10 is integrated in the domain [rb/sina, model predictions in terms of degree of fibrillation (Eq. 10)
ra/tana] or [Db/2sina, Da/2tana], which defines the distance of are consistent when compared with the experimental data in
the entry and exit from the die apex (Fig. 2) (see Ardakani terms of tensile strength (as explained before, the tensile
et al., 2013, for more details). The value of n at the entry is tak- strength should be proportional to the degree of fibrillation).
en equal to zero. Solving Eq. 10 the value of n is calculated as a
function of the apparent shear rate (through Q) and the geome-
trical characteristics of the extrusion die (through rb and a). 4.2 Effect of Contraction Angle
The constants A and M are calculated such as to provide the
best qualitative description of the tensile strength as a function Figure 5A, B show the effect of contraction angle on the extru-
of operating conditions and geometrical characteristics of the sion pressure and tensile strength for several apparent shear
dies. As discussed above the degree of fibrillation and tensile rates at 35 8C. The extrusion pressure (Fig. 5A) initially de-
strength are proportional to each other, and therefore exact fit- creases, goes through a minimum and then increases, with in-
ting to experimental data is not possible. On the other hand, creasing die entrance angle (continuous lines represent the
the constants in Eq. 3 are fitted to experimental extrusion pres- model predictions of Eq. 3 using the parameters listed in Ta-
sure data. These constants are summarised in Table 2. ble 2). Similar trends can be observed for the tensile strength
of the PTFE extrudate. At low contraction angles, PTFE paste
takes longer times to pass through the conical area compared
4 Results and Discussion to a case of flow at higher contraction angles. While the total
Hencky strain is roughly the same and almost independent of
4.1 Effect of Apparent Shear Rate the contraction angle, the longer time at low contraction angle,
which also implies smaller Hencky strain rate, forms stronger
It has been observed by previous authors (Ochoa et al., 2006; and more fibrils. Therefore, better mechanical properties can
Patil et al., 2006a) that a decrease in the apparent shear rate re- be achieved by extruding PTFE paste through dies with rela-
sults in an increase in the tensile strength of the PTFE extru- tively lower contraction angles. On the other hand, as the con-
dates. Extruding PTFE paste at lower shear rates allows more traction angle increases the rate of Hencky strain increases (to-
time for the PTFE particles to form fibrils, which are extended tal strain remains the same), which possibly breaks some of the
www.polymer-process.com
relatively slowly (thus avoiding breakage), and consequently formed fibrils, and this consequently results in extrudates with
this results into a higher tensile strength. a lower tensile strength.
Figure 4A, B depict the effects of the apparent shear rate on Figure 6 depicts the effect of contraction angle on tensile
the extrusion pressure and tensile strength of the extrudates strength. As discussed above, the tensile strength can be corre-
for three different dies having different contraction angles. lated with the degree of fibrillation. Meanwhile, the deforma-
The extrusion pressure generally increases with an increase in tion before breakage is not only a function of the degree of fi-
the apparent shear rate (volumetric flow rate), due to the in- brillation but also a function of the fibrils’ initial direction.
T C n K m f A M
8C Pa Pa · sm s–1
2013 Carl Hanser Verlag, Munich, Germany
Fig. 6. The effect of contraction angle on tensile strength and maxi- higher reduction ratios many fibrils have been formed, and
mum deformation in dies with Db = 15 mm, Da = 0.85 mm, and L/ most PTFE particles are connected to each other. On the other
Da = 20
hand, at low reduction ratios only a few fibrils have been
formed, and the arrangement of the PTFE particles is almost
Figure 7 shows that as the contraction angle increases, the ex- similar to their arrangement before extrusion.
trudates exhibit a higher extensibility before breakage. Apply-
ing strain during the tensile strain test results in alignment of fi-
brils along the strain direction (extrudates). 4.4 Effects of Barrel Size (Scale-Up)
The extrusion pressure increases with an increase in reduction tensile strength of the extudates for the larger barrel. The pre-
ratio in a nonlinear fashion (Ochoa et al., 2006, Patil et al., dicted level of fibrillation shows a good agreement with the
A) B) C)
Fig. 8. SEM images of PTFE paste: (A) RR = 50, (B) RR = 150, (C) RR = 350. For all cases L/Da = 20, = 1 600 s–1 and 2 = 908 at T = 35 8C
ters in the process as discuss before: shear rate (flow rate), con-
traction angle, and reduction ratio. Based on the proposed mod- Anvari Ardakani, H., Mitsoulis, E., Hatzikiriakos, S. G., \A Simple
el for scale-up purposes if those parameters remain the same in Improved Mathematical Model for Polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE)
Paste Extrusion", Chem. Eng. Sci., 89, 216 – 222 (2013),
the process, the fibrillation and the mechanical properties of DOI:10.1016/j.ces.2012.11.040
the PTFE extrudates will be the same independent of the barrel Ariawan, A. B., Ebnesajjad, S., Hatzikiriakos, S. G., \Preforming Be-
size. This hypothesis is shown to be consistent with the experi- havior of Polytetrafluoroethylene Paste", Powder Technol., 121,
mental findings (compare Fig. 7B for a small barrel with re- 249 – 258 (2001), DOI:10.1016/S0032-5910(01)00385-0
Ariawan, A. B., Ebnesajjad, S., Hatzikiriakos, S. G., \Properties of
sults in Fig. 9B for a larger barrel). Polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE) Paste Extrudates", Polym. Eng.
Sci., 42, 1247 – 1259 (2002a), DOI:10.1002/pen.11028
Ariawan, A. B., Ebnesajjad, S., Hatzikiriakos, S. G., \Paste Extrusion
of Polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE) Fine Powder Resins", Can. J.
5 Conclusions Chem. Eng., 80, 1153 – 1165 (2002b),
DOI:10.1002/cjce.5450800617
2013 Carl Hanser Verlag, Munich, Germany
Ochoa, I., Hatzikiriakos, S. G., \PTFE Paste Preforming: Viscosity and Acknowledgements
Surface Tension Effects", Powder Technol., 146, 73 – 83 (2004),
Not for use in internet or intranet sites. Not for electronic distribution.