Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Development Challengesand Prospects Odisha Centurion Journal 12 Feb 2017
Development Challengesand Prospects Odisha Centurion Journal 12 Feb 2017
net/publication/324477167
CITATIONS READS
2 12,065
1 author:
Haribandhu Panda
Centurion University of Technology and Management
6 PUBLICATIONS 13 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
All content following this page was uploaded by Haribandhu Panda on 12 April 2018.
Centurion Journal of
Multidisciplinary Research
ISSN: 2395 6216 (PRINT
VERSION)
At - Ramchandrapur
P.O. - Jatni, Bhubaneswar
Dist: Khurda – 752050
Haribandhu Panda1 Odisha, India
Abstract
The development challenges faced by Odisha and possible strategies to address them are
discussed in this article. The collapse of public education system, both at school and
university level, results not only creation of socio-economically inappropriate manpower, but
also ever-corroding foundation over which it is not easy to establish a healthy society.
Increasing dependence on the private health system for perceptible high-quality service is
adding further misery to the large segment of the population belonging to middle class and
those below. Extraction based economic development, associated environmental degradation
and job-less growth, and declining agriculture and allied sector result in distress migration of
people. The situation is aggravated by the populist measures of political parties and recurrent
natural calamities in the form of cyclone, flood, drought and heat wave and absence of
climate resilient long term strategies of effective management of forest, water, land, minerals
through right type of local value addition and local market creation. There is an urgent need
for socio-political empowerment of excluded (scheduled tribes, scheduled castes, other
backward castes, women, disabled, landless and slum dwellers) for realising their right to
high quality education; health; and sustainable and dignified livelihood security through
appropriate technology introduction, market intervention, large scale employability and
entrepreneurship development, ownership and access to land and other natural resources and
public institutions.
Keywords
Introduction
Development challenges in Odisha, like in any other state in the country, are
multidimensional: physical, economic, social, political, technological and ecological.
However, there are specific challenges and their underlying factors which make Odisha‟s case
unique. The purpose of this paper is to explore the factors that are responsible for Odisha‟s
position as one of the under-developed states in the country despite special attention it has
1
Haribandhu Panda, Vice Chancellor, Centurion University of Technology and
Management, Gajapati, Odisha, Email: haribandhu.panda@cutm.ac.in, Mobile:
9337388801
received from central government, and international and national agencies. The study is
primarily based on discussion with development practitioners, informed citizens and existing
literature as well as the author‟s grass-root level observation and understanding of the issues.
The article, first, presents the key development indicators of the state in comparison to other
states in the country. Next, it covers the resources available in Odisha. Subsequently,
objectives of development, strategies followed in the state and challenges faced are discussed.
Finally, before the concluding remarks in the last section, a possible way to move forward is
outlined.
Water Resource
Odisha has the notoriety of being the fourth in the country in water pollution load (Pandey &
Ghosh, 2002). All major rivers of the state, i.e. Mahanadi, Brahmani and Baitarani are highly
polluted due to mining activity along the banks, industries and domestic effluents from
habitations (Choudhury & Satapathy, 2010). Urban local bodies release sewage directly to the
rivers, as none of the 103 bodies of the state have treatment systems in place. Water in
different parts of the state is contaminated by hexavalent chromium (Sukinda valley), fluoride
(Nuapada, Nayagarh and Angul), nitrate (Ganjam), iron (Mayurbhanj, Koraput, Puri, Anugul,
Rayagada, Keonjhar, Sundergarh and Cuttack) and chloride (Puri, Balasore, Jajpur and
Kendrapara) (Rath, 2010). Between 1950 and 2009, the fish variety in Mahanadi came down
from 104 to 43 (Pati & Biswal, 2009). Perennial streams and tube wells either start yielding
less water or get completely dried up because of destruction of aquifers.
Air Resource
Ambient air quality (suspended particulate matter and SOx) is at an unlivable level in the
mining and industrial belts and transportation corridors because of poor management of
dumping areas, blasting, mechanization of mining operations, ore benefaction, large scale
movement of trucks, lack of dust suppression systems and absence of tree cover (Vasundhara,
2008).
2004-06); 64% deaths are attributed to neo-natal mortality and premature deliveries result in
38.5% infant deaths (SRS, 2011). Pneumonia, respiratory diseases, tetanus, diarrhea and
malaria are major causes of deaths in Odisha (GOO, 2010-11).
d. Administrative Deficit
Political power in Odisha, currently, tends to be controlled by mine owners, real estate
developers, contractors, private educational entrepreneurs, media barons, national and
multinational companies. In addition, populist policies such as highly subsidised food for
able-bodied people delinked from work; liberal relief during recurring natural calamities;
patronage of a cadre of unemployed youth for supporting political parties; lack of shared
vision among the dispossessed and absence of their institutions; sub-critical long term
investment in agriculture, land and infrastructure development and human resource creation;
and unaccountable administration, have all contributed to unequal distribution of power in
Odisha (Padel & Das, 2010 and Sainath, 1996).
Government policy of open arm invitation to mega national corporates and
multinational companies for mining, trading and extraction based industry regardless of
significant value addition or adequate implementable mechanisms for ensuring adherence to
the rule of law and agreed conditions of license have also been significant deterrents for
irreversible environmental degradation and consequent social friction. The decline in
environmental assets is primarily due to unsustainable extraction and use triggered by mining
and other natural resource processing activities. Additionally, weak state policies, poor
technology, mismanagement of resources, linkage to national and global market, and
increasing poverty have led all to degradation in quality and quantity of natural resource base
of the state (Roy, 2009; CSE, 2008 & Bhaduri, 2010).
Alienation
The alienation in Odisha is visible in the form of demand for separate states from different
quarters. They include - Koshal in Western Odisha, Kalinga in South Odisha and Kherwal in
Northern Odisha. Concentration of development initiatives and location of national level
institutions in and around Bhubaneswar; lack of infrastructure and reluctance of public
servants to move out of coastal districts have created a sense of alienation among the people
of different regions.
decades, Odia is yet to be used as the state language in its official transaction. There seems to
be a reluctance on the part of the people to speak in Odia outside the state. There is no pride
in the language spoken by the masses and the gulf between class and mass is difficult to
bridge. Brand Odia/Odisha is very weak. It is not surprising that the struggle to start an Odia
University in the state is mired with controversy.
controlled because of lack of long-term strategy and investment in infrastructure and human
capacity.
Distress out-migration from the state is rampant, especially from western Odisha and
tribal areas. They face extreme form of marginalization in their new place of work. Hence,
there is an urgent need to develop an enabling environment for local value addition and local
market creation that will help the excluded from indignity and vulnerability they face. Such
measures can possibly contain disintegration of indigenous community in terms of erosion of
culture and identity.
Most drops out, rejected and dejected are labeled as failures. This is not just
catastrophic for the individual but detrimental to all of us as a society. The
tragedy is that even those who get through the system with the right degrees
are mere survivors, many of them don‟t enjoy the journey, and most cannot
state how their years of grind enabled them to be responsible citizens in
society. There is no point in arming a rural student with a degree that does
not help him find a job in a city nor prepare him to help his father at their
farm – we must create an educational system that empowers and increases
opportunities rather than constrains or demotivates. The need for society is to
create an equitable system that provides education to all, education as a tool
for empowerment, not a weapon to judge and cast aside.
Concluding Remarks
Attempt is made in this article to understand the development challenges of Odisha and
possible strategies to overcome them. The collapse of public education system, both at school
and university level, results not only creation of socio-economically inappropriate manpower,
but also ever-corroding foundation over which it is not easy to create a healthy society. The
ever-increasing dependence on the private health system for perceptible high-quality service
is adding further misery to the large segment of the population belonging to middle class and
those below.
Disempowered community, unrealistic aspiration of the population, job-less growth,
ever-increasing unemployed educated youth and visible social friction, in spite of a stable
government, are the symptoms of a systemic failure of the development strategies followed
by the state. The missing link is the distorted political connect between the mass and the
ruling class which cannot drive the development agenda in a virtuous cycle of sustainable
human development and good governance system. At present, it is a vicious cycle of poor
governance and unsustainable development.
Environmental insecurity out of a de-stabilised natural resource-based livelihood
system (reflected in degradation of land, forests and water, in many cases causing irreversible
damage to the ecosystem) is leading to social friction. What is significant to note is that loss
of natural resource base for livelihoods has led to unemployment, underemployment of
people dependent on such resources, increasing morbidity, distress migration and, social
disharmony and conflicts at family and community levels. Furthermore, there is
transformation of the local social environment with the emergence of an elite group in the
form of company officials, contractors, journalists, traders and police/government officials
who begin to encroach and control the future of the local communities.
Here lies the role of civil society, people‟s institutions, people‟s journalism and caring
individuals in creating an enabling social movement for churning the minds of the masses to
understand the present situation and visualize a state of „shared dream‟. Inspiration can be
drawn from the people‟s science mass movement in Kerala (Kerala Sasthra Sahitya Parishad
or KSSP that started in 1962).
In 1972, KSSP decided to become a People's Science Movement and adopted
"Science for Social Revolution'' as its motto. Over the past four decades it has
grown into a massive people's science movement, with a membership of about
40,000 drawn from all walks of life and distributed in about 2000 units within
the state of Kerala. Over these years, it has also expanded its fields of interests
and activities to almost all fields of human endeavor. The KSSP is involved,
broadly in three types of activities: educate, agitate and construct, in areas like
environment, health, education, energy, literacy, micro-planning and
development in general. (www.kssp.in)
The starting point will be just demand and contribution in ensuring provision of right
education and health services for all and creating livelihood opportunities and social
securities for the „genuinely‟ underprivileged. Systemic institutional support to old,
differently abled, single women and children for meaningful life with dignity needs to be pro-
actively followed.
Acknowledgements
Sections on Resources (section 3), Disparity (section 4.1) and Social friction (section 4.2) are
adapted from a co-authored paper (Panda, H., Panda, S.M. and Lund, R. (2013),
Environmental Insecurity and Social Friction: Links in Rural Odisha, International Journal of
Rural Management, Sage, 9(1) 17-43).
Notes
i
According to Tendulkar Committee, for the purpose of estimating Poverty Head Count
Ratio, Rs 632/month/person for rural and Rs 1006/month/person for urban area in 2009-10
were considered.
ii
Nabakalebara is a symbolic recreation of wooden forms of the three deities at the Jagannath
Temple, Puri. The occasion occurs every 8th or 12th or 19th year of the previous Nabakalebara.
References
ASER, (2016). Annual Survey of Education Report (Rural), Mumbai. PRATHAM.
Banerjee, Kalyan. (2014). How you can transform the education landscape? Centurion
University of Technology and Management, Bhubaneswar, Odisha, (mimeo)
Bhaduri, A. 2010. Why an alternative model of economic development. In M. Mohanty
(Ed.) India Social Development Report 2010 (297-300). Council for Social
Development. New Delhi: Oxford University Press.
CAG report 22 of 2012-13 on Integrated Child Services Scheme 2011, page 76,
http://www.cag.gov.in/sites/default/files/audit_report_files/Union_Performance_Civil
_ICDS_Scheme%20_Ministry_Women_Child%20Development_22_2012_Chapter_6
.pdf
Center for Environmental Studies, Forest and Environment Department, Government
Chaudhury, S. and Gupta, N. (2009). Levels of living and poverty patterns: A district-wise
analysis for India. Economic and Political Weekly, 44(9), 94-110.
Choudhury, P. R. & Satapathy, P. (2010). 'From Localised Contestations to Terrains of
Around Odisha's Landscapes, Odisha Environment Congress 2010, CED, HDF and
RMNH, Bhubaneswar, pp 128.
Pati, B. & Biswal, M. (2009). Hirakud Dam: Fifty Mournful Years, Dams, Rivers and People,
7-11. Bhubaneswar: RCDC.
Rath, N. (2010). Articles in Sambad, Bhubaneswar 15th to 17th September and 20th to 22nd
September 2010.
Rath, P. C. (2010). 'Water and Sanitation of Odisha: An Overview', Odisha Environment
Congress 2010, CED, HDF and RMNH, Bhubaneswar, pp 40-51.
Roy, A. (2009). Listening to the Grasshoppers: Field Notes on Democracy. New Delhi:
Penguin.
Sainath, P. (1996). Everybody Loves a Good Drought. New Delhi: Penguin Books.
SFIF. (2013). Proceeding of the State Financial Inclusion Forum of Odisha, 18th
December 2013. (mimeo)
Vasundhara, (2008). Impact of mining in scheduled area of Orissa: A Case Study from
Keonjhar, 43. Bhubaneswar: Vasundhara.