Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 75

IRS

Integrated Reading & Speaking

Habits of Communication Grade 6


For Leaders

Q2 Name: ________________________________

Team Projects Class: ________________________________


News Journal
Presentation
Debate Teacher: _________________________________
Created by Habit 9

i


Habits of Communication for Leaders

Purpose & Goals


The aim of this program is to nurture the forthcoming generation of leaders by
enhancing their communication skills. Each week, students will focus on
mastering di erent skills and studying various topics to equip themselves with
the necessary tools to become future leaders capable of making a positive
impact on a global scale. By improving their reading comprehension, students
will not only deepen their understanding of various texts but also gain
knowledge of pressing contemporary issues. Through analyzing and critically
thinking about these topics and exposing themselves to multiple sources,
students will form their own judgments and opinions. Once students complete
the rst two phases, they will be well-prepared to deliver an e ective and
informative presentation, an essential skill for any leader. By combining the rst
three phases, students will be able to con dently debate these topics due to
their vast knowledge and information acquired throughout the quarter.

By actively participating in these four phases, students can develop


communication habits that are typical of leaders, making the goal of this
program increasingly achievable.

ii


fi
ff
fi
ff
fi
Habit 9 Leadership Values
All leaders at Habit 9 follow these 9 important values.
Incorporating these values is essential to being a good leader, a good person, and a good student.
Remember them well and put them into practice to become the best version of yourself.

Honesty · Respect · Cooperation · Communication


Gratitude · Love · Kindness · Creativity · Passion

iii 
Homework Manual
Use the guides below to know what you have to do for homework

Week 1: Background Information

1 Watch the WARM-UP video at home.


• All videos can be found on Youtube.
• Watch carefully and answer the questions listed below.

2 After that, you will read the INTRODUCTION on the next page.
• Thoroughly read the passage and look up the words that you don’t understand.

3 Lastly, you will read the passage labeled THINK AS A LEADER.


• Thoroughly read the passage and provide a thoughtful response to the leadership question.

Week 2: News Journal

1 FIND an article RELATED TO THE TOPIC BEING COVERED THAT MONTH, using a reliable news
source that you know. There is a list of sources on the next page.
• READ it throughly, LOOK UP the words you don’t know, PRINT it, and PASTE it in the box.
• It should be a recent news article that is related or closely related to the topic.

2 Then, you will SUMMARIZE the passage on the next page.


• IN YOUR OWN WORDS, you will summarize the passage in the space provided.
• Your summary should be at least 8-10 sentences long. No less.
• Do not copy word-for-word, or select-and-combine a few sentences from the passage. Some
students do this and think that the teacher won’t know. That is cheating and you will get three
strikes.

3 Finally, you will write your CRITICAL THINKING ARGUMENT or CTA.


• This means to create a debatable argument. Then you will prove your argument with three
reasons. Each of these reasons will have to be supported with details, explanations, and examples.
• The purpose of CTA is to prove your thoughts with well-supported and detailed reasoning.

Week 3: Presentation

1 Choose one topic from the list of presentation topics.


• Fill out the outline so that you can organize your thoughts.
• Then, make a 4 to 5 minute PPT presentation by following the Habit 9 Presentation Guidelines.

Week 4: Debate: Homework will depend on class and teacher.

1 You will follow the directions that will be explained by your teacher as well as the directions in the
Debate section.

If you are absent for any of these weeks, you still have to do it and show the teacher when you
return. Skipping homework--simply because you were absent--is not helpful to you.

iv 
News Article Sources
Below are some useful websites to find your news articles.
Feel free to use any other reliable sources.

Domestic News Sources

koreaherald.com
koreatimes.co.kr
en.yna.co.kr
dongA.com/en
english.hani.co.kr
koreajoongangdaily.joins.com/

Global News Sources

nytimes.com
bbc.com
cnn.com
washingtonpost.com
huffpost.com
reuters.com
scmp.com
usatoday.com
theguardian.com
thediplomat.com
restofworld.org
wired.com
newscientist.com
ft.com
voanews.com
euronews.com

Great Websites for Kids


http://gws.ala.org/category/social-sciences/
news-current-events
*managed by the American Library Association

Debate Sources
Search for arguments to help you with debate ideas.

ProCon.org
www.procon.org

You can search debate topics by category or


list in the website above.

v 
How to search for reliable sources
(for Presentations)

1. Search Method
a. Think about what information or details you want to nd.
b. Come up with some keywords that are related to your desired search.
c. Then browse the web with those keywords through search engines like Google.

*Always check whether the information you found is from reliable sources.

If you are unsure where to begin your search,


try searching your presentation topic on Google or Major News Websites.

2. Reliable Sources
Here are examples of reliable sources:

a. Major News Websites


Several credible news websites are listed on page v. Below are a few of them:

bbc.com
cnn.com
nytimes.com
theguardian.com
cnbc.com
forbes.com
washingtonpost.com
usatoday.com
scmp.com
reuters.com

b. Websites that end with .gov


These websites are government websites, so the information posted on them can be
trusted.

c. Websites that end with .org


A lot of these websites are usually run by organizations;
many nonpro t organizations (NGO) have useful information available online.

*Do not use Wikipedia as it is edited and created by volunteer writers.

d. websites that end with .edu


These websites are run by educational institutions, such as schools and universities.

3. Unacceptable Sources
Some unacceptable sources are Youtube videos, Wikipedia, and blog posts.

vi


fi
fi
Presentation Guide
Use the 9 guides below to make an awesome presentation

1 Always outline the three main points you want to deliver.


Use the presentation outline underneath the list of topics.
Having clear points will make your presentation better prepared.

2 Hooks: Always introduce each slide with a hook.


Don’t just show the slide and explain.
Make everyone interested and engaged in each slide.
Every slide, including the cover slide and the ending slide should have a hook.

3 Use simple words.


Your audience will quickly lose focus if you use extremely hard words.
Keep your words simple or make sure to explain the hard concepts.

4 Use relevant pictures and contrasting colors.


Pictures can simplify content on the screen so your audience can listen to your
explanations and not your slides.
You must not write full sentences on your slides and read from them.
Contrasting colors, such as black and white, blue and orange, can make the slides appear
bolder and pleasing to the eye.

5 Don’t use animations.


Animations can be distracting and take up some of your presentation time.
Creating animations can also be time consuming when doing your homework.

6 Don’t include irrelevant content, like a meaningless table of contents.


If your table of contents is, Introduction, Reason 1, Reason 2, Reason 3, Conclusion, don’t
include it in your slides. We already know you are going to tell us three reasons.
Instead, create an informative table of contents so that the audience can raise their levels of
expectations.

7 Incorporate knowledge learned in class such as content and vocab.


Why waste all of the valuable and useful content we learned in class?
Use everything you learned and include them in your presentation.

8 Practice at home. At least twice.


Don’t embarrass yourself by being unprepared. Practice makes perfect.
No script during your real presentation.
Remember to include gestures.
Don’t forget about eye contact and proper posture.

9 Make it fun.
If you make it fun, you will have fun making it and the audience will have fun listening to it.
Also, remember to time yourself. If it goes over 5 minutes, your listeners will lose attention.
A boring topic can be fun. A fun topic can be boring. It all depends on you.

Always ask your teacher for more help and information!

vii


Debate Guide: Motion and Brainstorming
Asian Parliamentary Debate Format

Debate Motions
There will always be three di erent types of topics. After agreement from both sides, one topic will be
chosen for that day’s debate. Opposition will cross one o . Government will cross another o . The
remaining will be the topic of debate.

MF: Motion of Fact: Something is or is not


MV: Motion of Value: Something is worthy or not
MP: Motion of Policy: Something should be done or not

Role Assignment
Roles will be determined on the day of the debate, randomly, by the teacher. Your team and partners
will be the ones you will collaborate and work together with. Class will be divided into speakers and
adjudicators.

Brainstorming
De ne the Motion and Create Arguments using AREL. Speakers and Adjudicators will all do this in their
teams. Adjudicators will brainstorm so that they can know what to expect in the debate as well.

DTM: De ne the Motion


A de nition is an interpretation or understanding of the motion. The PM needs to provide this in the
beginning of his speech, in order to set a clear parameter or boundary of the debate.
Simply, a de nition is describing the motion with very speci c details that explain what the teams would
exactly be debating about and to which direction the debate should go.
This is done because opposing teams might understand the same topic in di erent ways.

Example Motion: This house supports capital punishment for drug dealers.

De nition Breakdown:
This house = The government
Capital punishment = A maximum jail punishment, also known as the death penalty
Drug Dealers = People who sell illegal drugs that are not allowed by the government

DTM: We, the government, support the death penalty for people who sell, distribute, and
commit illegal drug activities.

Create Arguments using AREL


An argument that has logos=logic is the most important part of the debate.

Assertion: A statement of claim or premise


Reasoning: An explanation as to why that claim is true. The ‘because’ of your statement.
Evidence: Give supporting facts to strengthen the reasoning.
Link: A conclusion of the entire argument as to why it proves the given motion.

Example AREL Argument: Topic: This house believes in a liar’s good intentions.
A: Truth can hurt people.
R: Truth is not always a happy truth.
E: People compliment others when they don’t mean it.
L: Therefore, it’s better to lie to prevent someone from getting hurt.

viii


fi
fi
fi
fi
fi
ff
ff
fi
ff
ff
Debate Guide: Roles & Script
Asian Parliamentary Debate Format

Speaker Roles
There will always be eight speaker roles. Listed below are the roles, in order of speech. Note that the
OR will speak before the GR. Speech times are listed as well. This is the maximum time limit for each
speaker.

PM: Prime Minister: 1st speaker of the government (5 min)


Provide de nition
Provides a little background info
Announce team split
Provide main arguments for government

LO: Leader of Opposition: 1st speaker of the opposition (5 min)


Accept, Challenge, or Broaden de nition given by government
Provide rebuttals towards PM’s main arguments
Provide main arguments for opposition

DPM: Deputy Prime Minister: 2nd speaker of the government (5min)


Provide rebuttals towards LO’s main arguments while defending PM’s main arguments
Provide extension arguments, which are new arguments not mentioned by PM

DLO: Deputy Leader of Opposition: 2nd speaker of the opposition (5 min)


Provide rebuttals towards DPM’s new arguments while defending LO’s main arguments
Provide extension arguments, which are new arguments not mentioned by LO

GW: Government Whip: 3rd speaker of the government (5 min)


Only provides rebuttals towards the opposition without introducing any new arguments
Create a logical map to rebut both LO and DLO’s arguments and rebuttals while defending PM
and DPM’s position

OW: Opposition Whip: 3rd speaker of the opposition (5 min)


Same as GW but rebut PM and DPM’s arguments with more details while defending oppostion

OR: Opposition Reply: last speaker of the opposition (3 min)


Provide a convincing story that highlights and summarizes the opposition’s arguments
Explain why opposition should win

GR: Government Reply: last speaker of the government (3 min)


Provide a convincing story that highlights and summarizes the government’s arguments
Explain why government should win

Adjudicator Roles
After speaker roles have been lled, the remaining students will be the adjudicators for that day. This is
extremely important as well, as you are judging the debate. You will determine who wins or loses.

AD: Adjudicator: Judges

Total brainstorming time: 20 min Total speech time: 36 min Adjudication: 4 min
Total time for debate: 60 min

ix


fi
fi
fi
Follow your script
Every debater has his/her own roles to ful ll. Follow these scripted prompts to make a smooth delivery
of speech. Feel free to elaborate, improve, and enhance these scripts.

Good afternoon adjudicators and teachers. The motion for today’s debate is that ___. We de ne the
topic as ___. We, the a rmative team, believe that this statement is true. As rst speaker, I will be
talking to you about ___. Our second speaker will talk to you about ___. Our third speaker will
PM provide rebuttals and clarify any clashes. Our last speaker will sum up our case to end this debate. I
am going to discuss __ points. [Insert your AREL arguments here and conclude with a very
persuasive ending].

Thank you Mr./Ms. Prime Minister. The motion for today is that ___. We, the opposition, strongly feel
that this resolution will fall. Before moving on to our points, I would rst like to refute some of the
points introduced by the Prime Minister. [Refute the points from the PM now]. Now I would like to
LO move on to some of the opposition’s points. We strongly believe that this resolution should fall for
these fundamental reasons: ____, and ____. Our DLO will further explain additional points. [Explain
your two main points now and conclude with a very persuasive ending].

To rea rm, the government strongly stands on the position that ____. The LO has provided some
interesting points and I would like to begin with my refutations. [Refute the points from LO now]. To
strengthen the points presented by our PM, I would like to provide two additional arguments to fortify
DPM our government’s position on the motion. The resolution must stand because ____, and ____.
[Explain your two additional main points]. For the reasons I have presented, that ____ and ____, and
for the reasons presented by our PM, that ____ and ____, the resolution will stand!

The resolution before the house today is ____. We, the opposition, stand rm in our belief that this
resolution will fall. Before moving on, I would rst like to refute the points introduced by the DPM.
[Refute the points from DPM now]. Now I would like to move on to my points that will strengthen the
DLO cause presented by my colleague. The resolution must fall because ____, and ____. [Explain your two
additional main points]. For the reasons I have presented, that ____ and ____, and for the reasons
presented by the LO, that ____ and ____, the resolution before the house today must and will fall!

The LO and DLO have shown great e orts in trying to logically prove their points. In short, what they
said was that ____, but their points greatly contradict with the arguments of our government. To
refute the previous speaker, the DLO, I say that the arguments made are awed because ____.
GW [Refute the DLO’s arguments]. The points stated by our PM and DPM show a stronger position on
the motion because ____. [Add extra details and support to strengthen government’s arguments but
you must not add any new arguments]. Therefore, the government’s position is clearly superior.

The GW has shown a very biased analysis of the points presented. I would like to prove why the
points stated by our opposition have greater merit and consistency to the motion being debated
today. The government stated that ____, _____, _____, and _____, but they do not present a stronger
OW position to the opposition. Our LO and DLO have stated that ____. To provide extensions, ____. [Add
extra details and support to strengthen opposition’s arguments but you must not add any new
arguments]. For these reasons, the opposition stands rm against the resolution today.

To o er a recap of the points explained by our LO, DLO, and further explained by our OW, the
opposition believes that ____. [Use the repeating, regrouping, or reframing method to organize your
summary.]. Thus, as the points given by the opposition have been clearly and logically provided, we,
OR the opposition, take this debate home. Thank you dear adjudicators and honorable teachers.

After careful analysis of the points presented by both our government and the opposition, I would
like to prove why our team takes home this motion by highlighting the key points discussed in
today’s debate. [Use the repeating, regrouping, or reframing method to organize your summary].
GR Thus, as our points clearly and logically prove the motion, I strongly believe that we, the government,
win the debate. Thank you honorable judges.

x


ff
ffi
ffi
ff
fi
fi
fi
fi
fl
fi
fi
fi
What you do has far greater impact than what you say.

- Stephen Covey

xi


Table of Contents

Quarter 1

I. Global Warming

II. Big Data

III. E-Commerce

Quarter 2

I. A.I.

II. Autonomous Vehicles

III. IoT

Quarter 3

I. Innovations for Environmental


Restoration

II. Consumerism & Customer Behavior

III. The Future of Food

Quarter 4

I. Educational Technology

II. Augmented Reality

III. Medical Technology

xii


Arti cial Intelligence

arti cial intelligence (n.): the


study and development of
computer systems that can copy
intelligent human behaviour

Warm up: Youtube Video Discussion


Video: What is Artici cial Intelligence (or Machine Learning)? (06:15)
By: HubSpot Marketing

1. How is AI or Machine Learning similar to teaching a baby?

2. What is the rst thing that comes to mind when you hear the word AI?

3. In what ways do we already interact with AI?

4. What jobs and how will AI help improve?

5. What do you think will be the “next big thing” after the development of AI?

1


fi
fi
fi
fi
Arti cial Intelligence

Introduction
What is arti cial intelligence (AI)?
Arti cial intelligence is the simulation of human intelligence processes
by machines, especially computer systems. Speci c applications of AI
include expert systems, natural language processing, speech
recognition, and machine vision.

In the exciting realm of arti cial intelligence (AI), computer science


takes center stage. AI is dedicated to the creation of systems capable
of independent thinking, problem-solving, and continuous learning.
Unlike automated systems with pre-programmed tasks, AI aspires to
mimic human intelligence, adapting and evolving over time.

Algorithms, fundamental to AI, play a pivotal role, especially in the training process. Today's AI algorithms
dive into vast datasets, identifying patterns in information to describe historical data and predict future
outcomes. Kasia Kozdon, a Ph.D. student specializing in bio-inspired AI at University College London, sheds
light on three fundamental methods for training AI systems.

Supervised learning, the rst method, involves a person providing known


answers to the AI, essentially teaching it to align with prede ned solutions.
Unsupervised learning, the second method, requires the AI to independently
discover answers by recognizing patterns and relationships within datasets.
The third, reinforcement learning, incentivizes the AI without explicit
instructions, promoting curiosity and self-learning. An exemplary instance of
reinforcement learning is Google's AI mastering the intricate Atari game
Montezuma's Revenge, showcasing the machine's ability to decipher game
rules and progress autonomously.

E ectiveness of AI in Practical Applications


Despite AI's remarkable progress, achieving arti cial general intelligence
(Strong AI) – machines thinking on a human level and solving diverse
tasks – remains an unattained goal. Kozdon describes Strong AI as the
industry's holy grail, eagerly sought after by companies.

Present-day AI excels in speci c tasks such as targeted marketing,


defeating human opponents in games like chess, and powering everyday
applications. Siri answers questions, Gmail lters out spam, Net ix and
Spotify suggest personalized content, and LinkedIn proposes new
connections, showcasing the diverse applications of AI in our lives.

AI's Quirky Ingenuity: Akin to Training Dolphins


Engaging with AI is akin to training a dolphin – intelligent, adaptable, and capable of nding unique solutions.
Analogous to the story of Kelly the dolphin at the Institute for Marine Mammal Studies, AI often surprises by
devising unconventional approaches. Kelly, tasked with picking up trash for a reward, ingeniously stashed
paper under a rock, exchanging tiny slivers with trainers for sh. This highlights the unexpected and creative
ways in which AI tackles goals, adding an element of surprise and ingenuity to its capabilities.

Current Trends and Future Prospects in AI


In recent developments, AI continues to reshape industries, contributing to advancements in healthcare,
nance, and autonomous systems. The ongoing exploration of ethical considerations and the responsible use
of AI underscores the need for a balanced approach to harness its potential. As AI evolves, it holds the
promise of creating more e cient and innovative solutions, while addressing ethical concerns will ensure a
harmonious integration of this transformative technology into our daily lives.

2


fi
ff
fi
fi
fi
fi
ffi
fi
fi
fi
fi
fi
fi
fi
fl
fi
Arti cial Intelligence

Highlight the words that you don’t know. Look up the de nitions and ll them
Vocabulary out in the box below.

달성되지 않은, 이루어지지 않


ingenuity (n.) 독창성, 창의력 unattained (adj.)

prede ned (adj.) 미리 정의된(설정된) harmonious (adj.) 조화로운, 조화를 이룬

autonomously (adv.) 자체적으로, 독자적으로 contribute (v.) 기여하다

pivotal (adj.) 중추적인, 핵심적인

exemplary (adj.) 모범적인, 본보기가 되는

Comprehension Questions
1. What is arti cial intelligence (AI)?
_________________________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________________________

2. How do people teach AI in supervised learning, and what is the goal of this method?
_________________________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________________________

3. Can you give an example of something present-day AI is good at doing? Provide at least one
example from the article.
_________________________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________________________

4. Why is engaging with AI compared to training a dolphin? Explain in simple terms and share one
example from the article.
_________________________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________________________

Discuss with your team


Work together with your partners to come up with a detailed answer

1. How does AI bene t us? How is it impacting our world?


2. How can AI be detrimental?
3. If you could use AI in any way, how would you use it?
4. What is the most intriguing AI development you have come across?

3


fi
fi
fi
fi
fi
fi
Arti cial Intelligence

Data Analysis
Find 1 graph and 2 statistical facts related to any of the debate topics

Explain the graph in your own words


__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________

1st Statistical Fact (Source: _________________________________________________)


__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________

2nd Statistical Fact (Source: _________________________________________________)


__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________

4


fi
Arti cial Intelligence

Think as a Leader
Consumers are always searching for a better customer experience – and they are willing to spend
money for the bene ts that experience provides. This is evident by the success of companies like
Apple, which o ers a customer service center (known as the Genius Bar) at every store.
The customer experience is especially important in building brands that attract and maintain
customer loyalty, which is becoming increasingly di cult to do in this super competitive and ultra-
personalized landscape. Consumers want brands that remember their preferences and can provide a
unique and individualized experience.

This is irrespective of the privacy concerns of AI, which are broad but not enough to dissuade
customer desires. As a result, brands are now expected to demonstrate that they can accurately
customize the experience for everyone, adding a personal touch to a world dominated by impersonal
communication, repetition and ubiquity. Brands are also trying to reconcile costs by relying on
automation to perform a growing number of tasks. AI chatbots are a terri c example, as they have
become a common toolset for any company looking to simplify their processes. They can provide a
modern alternative to the old click-through approach, in which customers clicked an endless display
of links to achieve the desired results. But is it enough?

Whether looking for more information on booking a vacation or inquiring about new products or
services, consumers are more likely than ever to encounter a chatbot. In some instances, the bot
might be the only point of contact outside of email and/or a hotline with limited hours. With AI being
applied to those technologies as well, some customers might wonder if there are any humans left to
service their needs.

While automation is certainly an important part of any industry – today and especially tomorrow – it
should not be implemented at the expense of the customer experience. Instead of relying on bots
that attempt to handle everything automatically, customers would be better served by businesses
that nd a happy medium between human and machine.
AI is, after all, arti cial intelligence. “Intelligence” is what we need to improve productivity, e ciency
and deliver better results internally within the organization as well as externally with customers and
clients. The “arti cial” part, however, can be a bit lacking – even downright underwhelming. It can
only be overcome, enhanced and smoothed out with the touch of human employees, who bring
knowledge and expertise no AI can match.
Thus, AI should be used in a way that enhances the work we do, not as a sole replacement.

What Would You Do: Human service vs automated service. Who wins?
___________________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________________

Team Project
Work with your team to make a creative project.

1. Hold an interview debating the pros and cons of using AI vs human employees.
2. Present ways AI could develop your school: Education, relationships, and oppotunities.
3. Make a list of jobs that could be better completely with an AI workforce.
4. You are the CEO of a company. How would you justify to an employee that will be red to be
replaced by AI?
5


fi
fi
ff
fi
fi
fi
ffi
fi
fi
ffi
Arti cial Intelligence

News Journal
Find and paste a news article related to Arti cial Intelligence.

TOPIC:
ARTIFICIAL
INTELLIGENCE

Paste article here

Sample News Websites

How AI is helping to prevent three buses turning up at once


(BBC, bbc.com)

Delivery rm’s AI chatbot swears at customer and criticises


company (The Independent, independent.co.uk)

Parents worry AI-generated in uencers are promoting


u n re a l i s t i c b e a u t y s t a n d a rd s t o k i d s ( N B C N E W S ,
nbcnews.com)

6


fi
fi
fi
fl
Arti cial Intelligence

Summary
Write a 8-10 sentence summary of the article in your own words. Do not copy from the article.

___________________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________________

Critical Thinking Argument


Create a debatable argument based on the article or topic, supported by three detailed reasons.

Bad argument: AI is smarter than humans. (Lack of objective evidence)


Good argument: AI can make our lives more convenient by automating tasks and reducing speci c
workloads.

___________________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________________

7


fi
fi
Arti cial Intelligence

Self Refutation
Rebut your own C.T.A. with at least one detailed reason. This is to broaden your points of views.

__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________

Peer Refutation
Rebut the C.T.A.s of the presenters with at least one evidence for support. Use keywords for notes.

Presenter 1: Presenter 2: Presenter 3:

C.T.A CTA: CTA: CTA:

Reason 1: R1: R1:

R2: R2: R2:

R3: R3: R3:

Flaws

Final
Rebuttal

8


fi
Arti cial Intelligence

Presentation Topics
Choose a topic for presentation from the choices below. Then organize your thoughts below.

1. Build a perfect AI friend. Describe in detail and explain how it would help you as a person.
2. Defend an opposing view towards the development of AI, as it cuts down the human workforce.
3. Explain some jobs that AI will never be able to replace.
4. Design your own AI innovation. Explain how this will bene t the future of mankind.
5. Suggest a company to use AI. How will it help their business functions?
6. How can restaurants and the food industry use AI to provide comfort and service?
7. Research the best and most impressive AI innovations of the past decade.
8. Compare the advantage and disadvantages of AI in the medical industry.
9. If AI is becoming smarter than people, what jobs and skills will be worth pursuing in the future?
10. Will AI ever overtake humankind?
11. What is beyond AI? What great new system do you think will come up in the future after AI?
12. How can your family bene t from AI?
13. Create a lifestyle based on AI? How will it be di erent? How will it be better than life now?

Presentation Brainstorming
Write down your presentation topic, then organize your thoughts below.

Presentation Topic: ________________________________________________________________


keywords related to the topic:
1.
2.
3.
4.

possible sources to nd details:


1.
2.
3.
hook:_____________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________

possible call-to-action: _____________________________________________________________________


__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________

conclusion: _______________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________

*Please refer to pages v and vi for searching information.

9


fi
fi
fi
ff
fi
Arti cial Intelligence

Presentation Outline
Create an outline of the main focus and content of your presentation. Then make your PPT.

Presentation Topic:

Reason 1 (R1) Reason 2 (R2) Reason 3 (R3)

R1 Support R2 Support R3 Support

Source 1 Source 2 Source 3

*Please check page vi of the IRS textbook on how to search for reliable sources.

10


fi
Arti cial Intelligence

Peer Evaluation
Judge your peers and leave a comment that would bene t the speaker

Presenter 1: Presenter 2:

Organization of Ideas /5 Organization of Ideas /5

Delivery and Posture /5 Delivery and Posture /5

Knowledge of Material /5 Knowledge of Material /5

Neatness and Design /5 Neatness and Design /5

Total Score /20 Total Score /20

Comments: Comments:

Presenter 3: Presenter 4:

Organization of Ideas /5 Organization of Ideas /5

Delivery and Posture /5 Delivery and Posture /5

Knowledge of Material /5 Knowledge of Material /5

Neatness and Design /5 Neatness and Design /5

Total Score /20 Total Score /20

Comments: Comments:

11


fi
fi
Arti cial Intelligence

Peer Evaluation
Judge your peers and leave a comment that would bene t the speaker

Presenter 5: Presenter 6:

Organization of Ideas /5 Organization of Ideas /5

Delivery and Posture /5 Delivery and Posture /5

Knowledge of Material /5 Knowledge of Material /5

Neatness and Design /5 Neatness and Design /5

Total Score /20 Total Score /20

Comments: Comments:

Presenter 7: Presenter 8:

Organization of Ideas /5 Organization of Ideas /5

Delivery and Posture /5 Delivery and Posture /5

Knowledge of Material /5 Knowledge of Material /5

Neatness and Design /5 Neatness and Design /5

Total Score /20 Total Score /20

Comments: Comments:

12


fi
fi
Arti cial Intelligence

Peer Evaluation
Judge your peers and leave a comment that would bene t the speaker

Presenter 9: Presenter 10:

Organization of Ideas /5 Organization of Ideas /5

Delivery and Posture /5 Delivery and Posture /5

Knowledge of Material /5 Knowledge of Material /5

Neatness and Design /5 Neatness and Design /5

Total Score /20 Total Score /20

Comments: Comments:

Presenter 11: Presenter 12:

Organization of Ideas /5 Organization of Ideas /5

Delivery and Posture /5 Delivery and Posture /5

Knowledge of Material /5 Knowledge of Material /5

Neatness and Design /5 Neatness and Design /5

Total Score /20 Total Score /20

Comments: Comments:

13


fi
fi
Arti cial Intelligence

Debate Motion & Brainstorming


Asian Parliamentary Debate Format

Debate Motions:
Motion of Fact (MF): This house believes AI can replace human jobs.
Motion of Value (MV): This house believes AI restricts human freedom.
Motion of Policy (MP): This house would require the government to support the
development of AI technology.

Debate Motions: Opposition will strike o one motion rst. Then government will strike o another. The
remaining topic that is not struck o will be the topic of the day. Highlight the topic that is chosen.

Role Assignment for Today’s Debate: Random

Government Side Opposition Side Adjudicators

PM LO

DPM DLO

GW OW

GR OR

Brainstorming: You will have twenty minutes to prepare your side’s argument with your team. Build as
many arguments as your team can with support, details, evidence that you have collected for homework
or learned over the previous weeks. (4 arguments)

De ne the Motion (DTM)

Assertion:

Reasoning:

Evidence:

1
Link:

*Please check page vii of the IRS textbook on instructions for Debate Motion & Brainstorming.

14


fi
fi
ff
ff
fi
ff
Arti cial Intelligence

Debate Motion & Brainstorming


Asian Parliamentary Debate Format

Assertion:

Reasoning:

Evidence:

Link:
2
A:

R:

E:

L:
3
A:

R:

E:

L:
4
15


fi
Arti cial Intelligence

Follow your script


Every debater has his/her own roles to ful ll. Please refer to the scripted prompts below to make a
smooth delivery of speech. Feel free to elaborate, improve, and enhance these scripts.
Good afternoon adjudicators and teachers. The motion for today’s debate is that _MF/MV/MP_. We
de ne the topic as _DTM_. We, the a rmative team, believe that this statement is true. As rst
speaker, I will be talking to you about _A1/A2_. Our second speaker will talk to you about _A3/A4_.
PM Our third speaker will provide rebuttals and clarify any clashes. Our last speaker will sum up our case
to end this debate. I am going to discuss _AREL 1+2_ points. [Insert your AREL arguments here and
conclude with a very persuasive ending].

Thank you Mr./Ms. Prime Minister. The motion for today is that _MF/MV/MP_. We, the opposition,
strongly feel that this resolution will fall. Before moving on to our points, I would rst like to refute
some of the points introduced by the Prime Minister. [Refute the points from the PM now]. Now I
LO would like to move on to some of the opposition’s points. We strongly believe that this resolution
should fall for these fundamental reasons: _A1_, and _A2_. Our DLO will further explain additional
points. [Explain your two main points now and conclude with a very persuasive ending].

To rea rm, the government strongly stands on the position that _MF/MV/MP_. The LO has provided
some interesting points and I would like to begin with my refutations. [Refute the points from LO
now]. To strengthen the points presented by our PM, I would like to provide two additional arguments
DPM to fortify our government’s position on the motion. The resolution must stand because _A3_, and
_A4_. [Explain your two additional main points]. For the reasons I have presented, that _A3_ and
_A4_, and for the reasons presented by our PM, that _A1_ and _A2_, the resolution will stand!

The resolution before the house today is _MF/MV/MP_. We, the opposition, stand rm in our belief
that this resolution will fall. Before moving on, I would rst like to refute the points introduced by the
DPM. [Refute the points from DPM now]. Now I would like to move on to my points that will
DLO strengthen the cause presented by my colleague. The resolution must fall because _A3_, and _A4_.
[Explain your two additional main points]. For the reasons I have presented, that _A3_ and _A4_, and
for the reasons presented by the LO, that _A1_ and _A2_, the resolution before the house today must
and will fall!
The LO and DLO have shown great e orts in trying to logically prove their points. In short, what they
said was that _[Quick summary of opposition's AREL (1, 2, 3, 4)]_, but their points greatly contradict
with the arguments of our government. To refute the previous speaker, the DLO, I say that the
GW arguments made are awed because _[Rebut the DLO’s arguments]_. The points stated by our PM
and DPM show a stronger position on the motion because ____. [Add extra details and support to
strengthen government’s arguments but you must not add any new arguments]. Therefore, the
government’s position is clearly superior.
The GW has shown a very biased analysis of the points presented. I would like to prove why the
points stated by our opposition have greater merit and consistency to the motion being debated
today. The government stated that _A1_, _A2_, _A3_, and _A4_, but they do not present a stronger
OW position to the opposition. Our LO and DLO have stated that _[short summary of opposition
ARELS]_. To provide extensions, ____. [Add extra details and support to strengthen opposition’s
arguments but you must not add any new arguments]. For these reasons, the opposition stands rm
against the resolution today.
To o er a recap of the points explained by our LO, DLO, and further explained by our OW, the
opposition believes that ____. [Use the repeating, regrouping, or reframing method to organize your
OR summary.]. Thus, as the points given by the opposition have been clearly and logically provided, we,
the opposition, take this debate home. Thank you dear adjudicators and honorable teachers.
<3 MINUTES>

After careful analysis of the points presented by both our government and the opposition, I would
like to prove why our team takes home this motion by highlighting the key points discussed in
today’s debate. [Use the repeating, regrouping, or reframing method to organize your summary].
GR Thus, as our points clearly and logically prove the motion, I strongly believe that we, the government,
win the debate. Thank you honorable judges.
<3 MINUTES>

16


fi
fi
ff
ffi
fl
ffi
ff
fi
fi
fi
fi
fi
fi
Arti cial Intelligence

Debate Scoring Sheet Class: ____________ Date: _____________


Asian Parliamentary Debate Format

MOTION: ______________________________________________________________

PM - _________________________________(_____/2)___ LO - ( /4)

A1: R1:

A2: R2:

DPM - _________________________________(_____/4)___ A1:

R1:

A2:

R2:

DLO - ( /4)

A3: R3:

A4: R4:

GW - _________________________________(_____/6)___ A3:

R3:
A4:

R4:
OW - ( /4)

A1+: A1+:

A2+: A2+:

A3+: A3+:

A4+: A4+:

GR - _________________________________(_____/1)___ OR - ( /1)

RECAP A1~A4: RECAP A1~A4:

TOTAL: TOTAL:

17


fi
Arti cial Intelligence

Adjudicator’s Card: As a judge, you will score the speakers with total fairness and honesty. Your
scores will greatly a ect the outcome of the debate, so judge with care. You will present the winners.

Manner: Speed, volume, intonation, eye contact, body language, humor, and eloquence
Matter: Arguments, analysis, evidence, rebuttals, POIs, logic, and knowledge of materials
Method: Organization of thoughts, material, and time

Scoring Guide

Needs Does not make


Excellent 10 Very Good 8 Pass 6 4 2
Improvement sense

G Manner Matter Method Total


O Manner Matter Method Total

PM LO
/10 /10 /5 /25 /10 /10 /5 /25

DPM DLO
/10 /10 /5 /25 /10 /10 /5 /25

GW OW
/10 /10 /5 /25 /10 /10 /5 /25

GR OR
/10 /10 /5 /25 /10 /10 /5 /25

Final Government Score /100 Final Opposition Score /100

*After nalizing your scores, judges will either vote, use averages, or add up the scores to decide the winning team. Decision
is up to you as long as it is fair. Teacher will disagree if it is not fair and just.

Adjudicator’s Notes: All adjudicators take notes to write down key points presented by the speakers.
This will help you judge with a more accurate view and understanding. Take down your notes here.

PM LO

DPM DLO

GW OW

GR OR

18


fi
fi
ff
Arti cial Intelligence

Debate Notes
Take notes of the opposing team arguments here or use it as extra space for brainstorming

NOTES
Food for Thought
Discuss the following video with your classmates

YouTube Video: How China is using Arti cial Intelligence in the classroom (05:44)
By: The Wall Street Journal

1. Do you think this device can help your


learning?
2. How do you think your parents would react to
this headband?
3. Prove a better technological solution that will
improve education in Korea.

19


fi
fi
Autonomous Vehicles

classi er (n.): an a x or word that


indicates the semantic class to which a
word belongs / a person or thing that
classi es something

Warm up: Youtube Video Discussion


Video: How computers learn to recognize objects instantly | Joseph Redmon (07:37)
By: TED

1. What device has AI improved?

2. Why is object detection so important for self-driving cars?

3. Why is speed of data so crucial for technology such as AI object detection?

4. How else would you use this technology other than in vehicles?

5. How would this technology assist law enforcement and keep our society safe?

20


fi
fi
ffi
Autonomous Vehicles

Introduction
The Curious Case of Autonomous Vehicles: Revolution or Reality Check?
Autonomous vehicles, often called self-driving cars, have captured our imaginations with promises of a
transportation utopia. These futuristic machines, envisioned as gliding smoothly through cityscapes and rural
highways, seem poised to transform our lives. However, beneath the alluring gleam of this vision lies a
landscape of technological hurdles, regulatory roadblocks, and ethical quandaries. Before we buckle up for a
self-driving future, it's crucial to peel back the layers of hype and assess the true state of autonomous
vehicles.

The allure of these automobiles is undeniable. Proponents paint a picture of roads devoid of accidents,
thanks to machines programmed to follow rules awlessly. Tra c congestion, they assure us, will become a
relic of the past, as eets of coordinated vehicles optimize their movements. Accessibility for the elderly and
disabled would soar, granting them newfound freedom and independence. These promises, while enticing,
require cautious scrutiny.

The technological challenges loom large. Complex algorithms must contend with a dynamic, unpredictable
world. Navigating dense urban environments with their labyrinthine streets and bustling pedestrians demands
an almost omniscient awareness. Unexpected weather conditions, sudden mechanical failures, and even
unpredictable human behavior can stymie even the most advanced systems. Ensuring the reliability and
safety of autonomous vehicles necessitates relentless technological advancement and rigorous testing in
diverse real-world conditions.

Beyond the technical, a web of regulatory and ethical knots awaits untangling. Governments must grapple
with crafting comprehensive regulations that govern the behavior of these intelligent machines. Who bears
responsibility for accidents? How do we ensure data privacy and cybersecurity as vehicles collect and
transmit vast amounts of data? Ethical dilemmas abound – what if an autonomous vehicle faces an
unavoidable collision, forced to choose between harming passengers or pedestrians? Navigating these
ethical mine elds demands open dialogue and responsible development, prioritizing human safety and
societal well-being.

While the road ahead for autonomous vehicles appears paved with both promise and peril, a de nitive
destination remains unclear. Technological breakthroughs could propel us towards a self-driving future sooner
than anticipated, yet regulatory and ethical obstacles may force us to apply the brakes. The journey towards
realizing the true potential of autonomous vehicles hinges on a balanced approach – relentless innovation
coupled with cautious progress, informed by ethical considerations and public trust. Only then can we
determine whether this futuristic vision will become a revolution or a mere reality check for our transportation
dreams.

21


fi
fl
fl
ffi
fi
Autonomous Vehicles

Highlight the words that you don’t know. Look up the de nitions and ll them
Vocabulary out in the box below.

(특히 앞으로 바라는 일을) 마음 유물, 유적, (종교적으로 의미


envision (v.) relic (n.)
속에 그리다[상상하다] 가 있는) 유물, 성유물

alluring (adj.) (신비롭고) 매혹적인 enticing (adj.) 유혹적인

gleam (n.) 번득[언뜻] 비치는 것 labyrinthine (adj.) 미로 같은

quandary (n.) 진퇴양난 (=dilemma) omniscient (adj.) 모든 것을 다 아는, 전지의

proponent (n.) (어떤 사상·행동 방침의) 지지자 necessitate (v.) ~ 을 필요하게 만들다

수그러들지 않는, 끈질긴


devoid (adj.) ~이 전혀 없는 relentless (adj.)
(=unrelenting), 가차 없는

awlessly (adv.) 흠 없이, 완전하게

Comprehension Questions
1. Self-driving cars are said to have many bene ts. What are some of these bene ts?
__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________
2. Self-driving cars also face some challenges. What are some of these challenges?
__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________

3. What are some of the ethical issues that need to be considered before self-driving cars are widely
adopted?
__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________
4. Do you think self-driving cars will be a revolution or a reality check for our transportation future?
__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________

5. What are some of the positive and negative consequences of widespread adoption of self-driving
cars?
__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________

Discuss with your team


Work together with your partners to come up with a detailed answer

1. What do you think transportation will be like in another 50 years?


2. What industries bene t from the innovation of autonomous vehicles?
3. Make a list of all concerns people will have regarding self-driving vehicles.
4. What are some ethical problems AI vehicle companies will face?

22


fl
fi
fi
fi
fi
fi
Autonomous Vehicles

Data Analysis
Find 1 graph and 2 statistical facts related to any of the debate topics

Explain the graph in your own words


__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________

1st Statistical Fact (Source: _________________________________________________)


__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________

2nd Statistical Fact (Source: _________________________________________________)


__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________

23


Autonomous Vehicles

Think as a Leader
What started out as a temporary pilot project to test a robotaxi service in Las Vegas has turned into a
multi-year partnership between self-driving software company Aptiv and Lyft and a new milestone
that suggests the operation is ramping up. The companies announced Tuesday that they’ve given
100,000 paid rides in Aptiv’s self-driving vehicles via the Lyft app.
“To our knowledge, this is the largest open-to-the-public commercial pilot,” Aptiv Autonomous
Mobility President Karl Iagnemma said in a recent interview. “To me this partnership is a great
example of the next-generation ecosystem at work.”

The milestone has a few important caveats. Aptiv’s self-driving vehicles — which initially began with
BMW 5 series — have a human safety driver behind the wheel to take over if needed. The human
driver operates the vehicle manually in parking lots and hotel lobby areas. The program, even if with
those human safety drivers behind the wheel, has proven invaluable to the companies, according to
Iagnemma and Jody Kelman, who leads the self-driving platform team at Lyft. “We’ve got something
here,” Kelman said. “This is really a blueprint for what future mobility partnerships can look like.”

Companies in this so-called “race” to commercially deploy on-demand ride-hailing services using
self-driving vehicles must master more than the technical bits. Fleet management, real-time routing
and designing an approachable user interface are just a few critical components needed to operate a
pro table robotaxi service. The program has taught Aptiv how to “get and keep a eet of
autonomous vehicles on the road and keep them highly utilized,” Iagnemma said, later adding that
this project positions Lyft and Aptiv to be major winners in this space. The companies also learned
how to work with various regulatory bodies, in this case, with the city of Las Vegas, Clark County and
the region’s transit authority.

Lyft and Aptiv rst launched the pilot in January 2018 as a one-week experiment and then
announced plans to extend the program. The program surpassed 5,000 self-driving rides by August
and jumped to more than 25,000 paid autonomous rides by December 2018, all while maintaining an
average passenger rating of 4.95 out of ve stars, Aptiv said at the time. By May 2019, the
companies reported they had given more than 50,000 paid self-driving rides in Las Vegas. Aptiv’s
investment in Las Vegas expanded as those ridership numbers grew. The company opened in
December 2018 a 130,000-square-foot technical center in the city to house its eet of autonomous
vehicles as well as an engineering team dedicated to research and development of software and
hardware systems, validation and mapping.

What Would You Do: How can this case be implemented in Korea?
______________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________

Team Project
Work with your team to make a creative project

1. Create a company that pro ts from autonomous vehicles.


2. You are a lawmaker. Propose new laws and regulations to maintain control of AI vehicles.
3. Report on the negative aspects of autonomous vehicles. Your team is a news crew.
4. You are the CEO of a car company. Persuade all of your employees to use AI vehicles.
5. As the government of Korea, deal with the loss of jobs created by these vehicles.

24


fi
fi
fi
fi
fl
fl
Autonomous Vehicles

News Journal
Find and paste a news article related to Autonomous Vehicles.

TOPIC:
AUTONOMOUS
VEHICLES
Paste article here

Sample News Websites

Autonomous Vehicles Are Driving Blind (The New York Times,


nytimes.com)

Self-driving cars could be on UK roads by 2026, says transport


secretary (The Guardian, theguardian.com)

Tired of waiting for driverless vehicles? Head to a farm (AP


News, news.com)

25


Autonomous Vehicles

Summary
Write a 8-10 sentence summary of the article in your own words. Do not copy from the article.

__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________

Critical Thinking Argument


Create a debatable argument based on the article or topic, supported by three detailed reasons.

Bad argument: Autonomous vehicles will take all jobs. (Excessive speculation)
Good argument: Autonomous vehicles can reduce driver fatigue and errors to prevent accidents.

___________________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________________

26


Autonomous Vehicles

Self Refutation
Rebut your own C.T.A. with at least one detailed reason. This is to broaden your points of views.

__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________

Peer Refutation
Rebut the C.T.A.s of the presenters with at least one evidence for support. Use keywords for notes.

Presenter 1: Presenter 2: Presenter 3:

C.T.A CTA: CTA: CTA:

R1: R1: R1:

R2: R2: R2:

R3: R3: R3:

Flaws

Final
Rebuttal

27


Autonomous Vehicles

Presentation Topics
Choose a topic for presentation from the choices below. Then organize your thoughts below.

1. Research and present a pioneer of the self-driving car.


2. Other than the trucking, taxi, and delivery industries, come up with another industry that will
bene t from autonomous vehicles.
3. Boycott and oppose the continual development of these autonomous vehicles.
4. Compare and contrast standard vehicles, hybrid vehicles, and fully autonomous vehicles.
5. The potential for autonomous vehicles to be used for military or surveillance purposes
6. Lifestyle changes as a result of autonomous vehicles
7. Research and present the most amazing autonomous vehicle out there today.
8. What jobs will be created as a result of using autonomous vehicles? What jobs will be lost?
9. Why is it necessary to make all vehicles autonomous?
10. How can cities bene t from using autonomous public transportation?
11. Besides vehicles, what other areas should become automated?
12. The impact of autonomous vehicles on the environment

Presentation Brainstorming

Presentation Topic: ________________________________________________________________


keywords related to the topic:
1.
2.
3.
4.
possible sources to nd details:
1.
2.
3.
hook:_____________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________

possible call-to-action: _____________________________________________________________________


__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________

conclusion: _______________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________

*Please refer to pages v and vi for searching information.

28


fi
fi
fi
Autonomous Vehicles

Presentation Outline
Create an outline of the main focus and content of your presentation. Then make your PPT.

Presentation Topic:

Reason 1 (R1) Reason 2 (R2) Reason 3 (R3)

R1 Support R2 Support R3 Support

Source 1 Source 2 Source 3

*Please check page vi of the IRS textbook on how to search for reliable sources.

29


Autonomous Vehicles

Peer Evaluation
Judge your peers and leave a comment that would bene t the speaker

Presenter 1: Presenter 2:

Organization of Ideas /5 Organization of Ideas /5

Delivery and Posture /5 Delivery and Posture /5

Knowledge of Material /5 Knowledge of Material /5

Neatness and Design /5 Neatness and Design /5

Total Score /20 Total Score /20

Comments: Comments:

Presenter 3: Presenter 4:

Organization of Ideas /5 Organization of Ideas /5

Delivery and Posture /5 Delivery and Posture /5

Knowledge of Material /5 Knowledge of Material /5

Neatness and Design /5 Neatness and Design /5

Total Score /20 Total Score /20

Comments: Comments:

30


fi
Autonomous Vehicles

Peer Evaluation
Judge your peers and leave a comment that would bene t the speaker

Presenter 5: Presenter 6:

Organization of Ideas /5 Organization of Ideas /5

Delivery and Posture /5 Delivery and Posture /5

Knowledge of Material /5 Knowledge of Material /5

Neatness and Design /5 Neatness and Design /5

Total Score /20 Total Score /20

Comments: Comments:

Presenter 7: Presenter 8:

Organization of Ideas /5 Organization of Ideas /5

Delivery and Posture /5 Delivery and Posture /5

Knowledge of Material /5 Knowledge of Material /5

Neatness and Design /5 Neatness and Design /5

Total Score /20 Total Score /20

Comments: Comments:

31


fi
Autonomous Vehicles

Peer Evaluation
Judge your peers and leave a comment that would bene t the speaker

Presenter 9: Presenter 10:

Organization of Ideas /5 Organization of Ideas /5

Delivery and Posture /5 Delivery and Posture /5

Knowledge of Material /5 Knowledge of Material /5

Neatness and Design /5 Neatness and Design /5

Total Score /20 Total Score /20

Comments: Comments:

Presenter 11: Presenter 12:

Organization of Ideas /5 Organization of Ideas /5

Delivery and Posture /5 Delivery and Posture /5

Knowledge of Material /5 Knowledge of Material /5

Neatness and Design /5 Neatness and Design /5

Total Score /20 Total Score /20

Comments: Comments:

32


fi
Autonomous Vehicles

Debate Motion & Brainstorming


Asian Parliamentary Debate Format

Debate Motions:
Motion of Fact: This house believes autonomous vehicles are safer than
human-driven vehicles.
Motion of Value: This house believes autonomous vehicles can help to
protect the environment.
Motion of Policy: This house would require all new vehicles to be
autonomous.
Debate Motions: Opposition will strike o one motion rst. Then government will strike o
another. The remaining topic that is not struck o will be the topic of the day. Highlight the topic
that is chosen.
Role Assignment for Today’s Debate: Random

Government Side Opposition Side Adjudicators

PM LO

DPM DLO

GW OW

GR OR

Brainstorming: You will have twenty minutes to prepare your side’s argument with your team. Build
as many arguments as your team can with support, details, evidence that you have collected for
homework or learned over the previous weeks. (4 arguments)

De ne the Motion (DTM)

Assertion:

Reasoning:

Evidence:

1
Link:

*Please check page vii of the IRS textbook on instructions for Debate Motion & Brainstorming.

33


fi
ff
ff
fi
ff
Autonomous Vehicles

Debate Motion & Brainstorming


Asian Parliamentary Debate Format

Assertion:

Reasoning:

Evidence:

Link:
2
A:

R:

E:

L:
3
A:

R:

E:

L:
4
34


Autonomous Vehicles

Follow your script


Every debater has his/her own roles to ful ll. Please refer to the scripted prompts below to make a
smooth delivery of speech. Feel free to elaborate, improve, and enhance these scripts.
Good afternoon adjudicators and teachers. The motion for today’s debate is that _MF/MV/MP_. We
de ne the topic as _DTM_. We, the a rmative team, believe that this statement is true. As rst
speaker, I will be talking to you about _A1/A2_. Our second speaker will talk to you about _A3/A4_.
PM Our third speaker will provide rebuttals and clarify any clashes. Our last speaker will sum up our case
to end this debate. I am going to discuss _AREL 1+2_ points. [Insert your AREL arguments here and
conclude with a very persuasive ending].

Thank you Mr./Ms. Prime Minister. The motion for today is that _MF/MV/MP_. We, the opposition,
strongly feel that this resolution will fall. Before moving on to our points, I would rst like to refute
some of the points introduced by the Prime Minister. [Refute the points from the PM now]. Now I
LO would like to move on to some of the opposition’s points. We strongly believe that this resolution
should fall for these fundamental reasons: _A1_, and _A2_. Our DLO will further explain additional
points. [Explain your two main points now and conclude with a very persuasive ending].

To rea rm, the government strongly stands on the position that _MF/MV/MP_. The LO has provided
some interesting points and I would like to begin with my refutations. [Refute the points from LO
now]. To strengthen the points presented by our PM, I would like to provide two additional arguments
DPM to fortify our government’s position on the motion. The resolution must stand because _A3_, and
_A4_. [Explain your two additional main points]. For the reasons I have presented, that _A3_ and
_A4_, and for the reasons presented by our PM, that _A1_ and _A2_, the resolution will stand!

The resolution before the house today is _MF/MV/MP_. We, the opposition, stand rm in our belief
that this resolution will fall. Before moving on, I would rst like to refute the points introduced by the
DPM. [Refute the points from DPM now]. Now I would like to move on to my points that will
DLO strengthen the cause presented by my colleague. The resolution must fall because _A3_, and _A4_.
[Explain your two additional main points]. For the reasons I have presented, that _A3_ and _A4_, and
for the reasons presented by the LO, that _A1_ and _A2_, the resolution before the house today must
and will fall!
The LO and DLO have shown great e orts in trying to logically prove their points. In short, what they
said was that _[Quick summary of opposition's AREL (1, 2, 3, 4)]_, but their points greatly contradict
with the arguments of our government. To refute the previous speaker, the DLO, I say that the
GW arguments made are awed because _[Rebut the DLO’s arguments]_. The points stated by our PM
and DPM show a stronger position on the motion because ____. [Add extra details and support to
strengthen government’s arguments but you must not add any new arguments]. Therefore, the
government’s position is clearly superior.
The GW has shown a very biased analysis of the points presented. I would like to prove why the
points stated by our opposition have greater merit and consistency to the motion being debated
today. The government stated that _A1_, _A2_, _A3_, and _A4_, but they do not present a stronger
OW position to the opposition. Our LO and DLO have stated that _[short summary of opposition
ARELS]_. To provide extensions, ____. [Add extra details and support to strengthen opposition’s
arguments but you must not add any new arguments]. For these reasons, the opposition stands rm
against the resolution today.
To o er a recap of the points explained by our LO, DLO, and further explained by our OW, the
opposition believes that ____. [Use the repeating, regrouping, or reframing method to organize your
OR summary.]. Thus, as the points given by the opposition have been clearly and logically provided, we,
the opposition, take this debate home. Thank you dear adjudicators and honorable teachers.
<3 MINUTES>

After careful analysis of the points presented by both our government and the opposition, I would
like to prove why our team takes home this motion by highlighting the key points discussed in
today’s debate. [Use the repeating, regrouping, or reframing method to organize your summary].
GR Thus, as our points clearly and logically prove the motion, I strongly believe that we, the government,
win the debate. Thank you honorable judges.
<3 MINUTES>

35


fi
ff
ffi
fl
ffi
ff
fi
fi
fi
fi
fi
fi
Autonomous Vehicles

Debate Scoring Sheet Class: ____________ Date: _____________


Asian Parliamentary Debate Format

MOTION: ______________________________________________________________

PM - _________________________________(_____/2)___ LO - ( /4)

A1: R1:

A2: R2:

DPM - _________________________________(_____/4)___ A1:

R1:

A2:

R2:

DLO - ( /4)

A3: R3:

A4: R4:

GW - _________________________________(_____/6)___ A3:

R3:
A4:

R4:
OW - ( /4)

A1+: A1+:

A2+: A2+:

A3+: A3+:

A4+: A4+:

GR - _________________________________(_____/1)___ OR - ( /1)

RECAP A1~A4: RECAP A1~A4:

TOTAL: TOTAL:

36


Autonomous Vehicles

Adjudicator’s Card: As a judge, you will score the speakers with total fairness and honesty. Your
scores will greatly a ect the outcome of the debate, so judge with care. You will present the winners.

Manner: Speed, volume, intonation, eye contact, body language, humor, and eloquence
Matter: Arguments, analysis, evidence, rebuttals, POIs, logic, and knowledge of materials
Method: Organization of thoughts, material, and time
Scoring Guide

Needs Does not make


Excellent 10 Very Good 8 Pass 6 4 2
Improvement sense

G Manner Matter Method Total


O Manner Matter Method Total

PM LO
/10 /10 /5 /25 /10 /10 /5 /25

DPM DLO
/10 /10 /5 /25 /10 /10 /5 /25

GW OW
/10 /10 /5 /25 /10 /10 /5 /25

GR OR
/10 /10 /5 /25 /10 /10 /5 /25

Final Government Score /100 Final Opposition Score /100

*After nalizing your scores, judges will either vote, use averages, or add up the scores to decide the winning team. Decision
is up to you as long as it is fair. Teacher will disagree if it is not fair and just.

Adjudicator’s Notes: All adjudicators take notes to write down key points presented by the speakers.
This will help you judge with a more accurate view and understanding. Take down your notes here.

PM LO

DPM DLO

GW OW

GR OR

37


fi
ff
Autonomous Vehicles

Debate Notes
Take notes of the opposing team arguments here or use it as extra space for brainstorming

NOTES
Food for Thought
Discuss the following video with your classmates.

YouTube Video: The ethical dilemma of self-driving cars - Patrick Lin (04:16)
By: TED-Ed

1. If you were driving the boxed car in manual


mode, how would you react? Why?
2. What are the three bene ts of self-driving cars?
3. If an autonomous car gets into an accident, is
it your fault or the car’s fault?

38


fi
Internet of Things

Internet of Things (n.): the connection of


devices within everyday objects via the
internet, enabling them to share data

Warm up: Youtube Video Discussion


Video: The internet of things | Jordan Du y (09:34)
By: TEDx Talks

1. What are the four sections of the internet of things?

2. As we can say more with less, what has data become as a language?

3. What are some things the Smart House system allows us to do?

4. If all our tasks were replaced by automated systems, what would life be like?

39


ff
Internet of Things

Introduction
Unveiling the Internet of Things: A Symphony of Connected Devices
Imagine a world where your co ee maker brews a
fresh pot upon sensing your wakefulness, your
thermostat adjusts to your preferred temperature
as you approach, and your refrigerator alerts you
when your favorite milk is running low. This
seamless orchestration of everyday objects isn't a
scene from a science ction movie – it's the reality
promised by the Internet of Things (IoT).

At its core, the IoT refers to the vast network of


physical devices embedded with sensors,
software, and internet connectivity. These "smart"
devices collect and exchange data, creating a
symphony of communication that transforms how
we live, work, and interact with the world around
us. From tness trackers monitoring our health to
smartwatches streamlining our schedules, the
IoT's tendrils reach into every aspect of our lives.

The impact of this interconnected ecosystem is profound. In smart homes, lights adjust to our moods,
appliances optimize energy consumption, and security systems provide real-time monitoring, o ering
enhanced comfort, convenience, and peace of mind. In cities, intelligent tra c lights manage congestion,
smart meters track energy usage, and connected waste bins optimize collection routes, fostering a more
e cient and sustainable urban environment.

Yet, the potential of the IoT extends far beyond individual devices and conveniences. In industries like
agriculture, sensors monitor soil conditions and optimize irrigation, leading to increased crop yields and
resource conservation. In healthcare, wearable devices track vital signs and transmit data to doctors,
enabling remote patient monitoring and early intervention in potential health issues. The possibilities seem
endless, promising advancements in elds ranging from manufacturing and logistics to environmental
protection and disaster management.

However, as with any emerging technology, challenges and


concerns accompany the promise of the IoT. Security
vulnerabilities in connected devices raise concerns about
data privacy and hacking risks. The ever-expanding network
of devices raises questions about the ethical implications of
data collection and usage. Regulatory frameworks need to
evolve to keep pace with technological advancements,
ensuring responsible development and deployment of IoT
solutions.

Despite these challenges, the potential of the IoT to


revolutionize our lives remains undeniable. As technology
continues to evolve, and societal concerns are addressed, the
interconnected symphony of the IoT will continue to grow,
composing a new chapter in human progress and innovation.
Whether it becomes a harmonious masterpiece or a cacophony of discord depends on our ability to harness
its power responsibly and ethically. The choice, like the melody of the future, lies in our hands.

40


ffi
fi
fi
ff
fi
ffi
ff
Internet of Things

Highlight the words that you don’t know. Look up the de nitions and ll
Vocabulary them out in the box below.

thermostat (n.) 온도 조절 장치 intervention (n.) 간섭, 개입

(중간에 끊어짐이 없이) 아


seamless (adj.) emerge (v.) 드러나다, 알려지다
주 매끄러운

통합, 결집, 편성; 조직화;


orchestration (n.) deployment (n.) 전개, 배치
(솜씨 있는) 조정 ((of))

embed (v.) (단단히) 박다, 끼워 넣다

Comprehension Questions
1. What is the Internet of Things?
__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________

2. What are some examples of IoT devices?


__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________

3. The passage says the IoT can help cities be more e cient. How? Give one example.
__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________

4. Besides homes and cities, the passage mentions two other areas where the IoT can be helpful.
What are they?
__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________

5. The passage says there are also some challenges with the IoT. What are two concerns
mentioned?
__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________

Discuss with your team


Work together with your partners to come up with a detailed answer

1. What smart systems do you have in your home? Has it improved your life?
2. What are some of the most intriguing smart systems you have seen or heard of?
3. What are some potential dangers of smart systems?
4. How is the development of smart systems related to unemployment?

41


ffi
fi
fi
Internet of Things

Data Analysis
Find 1 graph and 2 statistical facts related to any of the debate topics

Explain the graph in your own words


__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________

1st Statistical Fact (Source: _________________________________________________)


__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________

2nd Statistical Fact (Source: _________________________________________________)


__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________

42


Internet of Things

Think as a Leader
Where does the IoT go next?
A report from Samsung says the need to secure every connected device by 2020 is "critical". The
rm's Open Economy document says "there is a very clear danger that technology is running ahead
of the game". The rm said more than 7.3 billion devices will need to be made secure by their
manufacturers before 2020. “We are looking at a future in which companies will indulge in digital
Darwinism, using IoT, AI and machine learning to rapidly evolve in a way we’ve never seen before,"
Brian Solis, from Altimeter Group, who helped on the research said.

But aren't there any privacy issues?


Everything that's connected to the internet can be hacked, IoT products are no exception to this
unwritten rule. Insecure IoT systems led to toy manufacturer VTech losing videos and pictures of
children using its connected devices.

There's also the issue of surveillance. If every product becomes connected then there's the potential
for unlimited observation of users. If a connected fridge tracks food usage and consumption,
takeaways could be targeted at hungry people who have no food. If a smartwatch can detect when
you're in the bathroom, these hackers might even be able to blackmail the watch wearer.

We need reliable standards


At the center of creating a vast, reliable IoT network lies one signi cant issue: compatible standards.
Connected objects need to be able to speak to each other to transfer data and share what they are
recording. If they all run on di erent standards, they struggle to communicate and share. The
Institute of Electrical and Electronics Standards Association lists a huge number of standards being
developed and worked on for di erent applications. "Additional needs are emerging for
standardization," the Internet Society says. If standardization happens it will let more devices and
applications be connected.

To try and tackle this issue on a business scale, Microsoft has introduced its own system for IoT
devices. Called IoT Central, TechCrunch, reports the system gives businesses a managed central
platform for setting up IoT devices. Microsoft claims the system will simply the creation of IoT
networks. "Ultimately what makes it exciting is that we don’t yet know the exact use cases and just
that it has the potential to have a major impact on our lives."

What Would You Do: Why is standardization so important in all industries?


______________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________

Team Project
Work with your team to make a creative project

1. Make a TV commercial about a new smart home device. Persuade the viewer to buy.
2. Make a list of some old products that people use today that should be replaced by IoT.
3. Present a standard product that is better than its smart replacement.
4. Imagine you are a teacher. Why should your students NOT use smart systems?
5. What trends do you see in the development of IoT systems?

43
fi


fi
ff
ff
fi
Internet of Things

News Journal
Find and paste a news article related to Internet of Things.

TOPIC:
I.o.T.

Paste article here

Sample News Websites

Have we fallen out of love with voice assistants? (BBC,


bbc.com)

Securing the Digital Frontier: Enhancing Security in the IoT


Devices (News Name, news.com)

Article Title 3 (News Name, news.com)

44


Internet of Things

Summary

__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________

Critical Thinking Argument


Create a debatable argument based on the article or topic, supported by three detailed reasons.

Bad argument: IoT will take away human jobs. (Excessive speculation)
Good argument: IoT can provide personalized services, making our lives more convenient.

___________________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________________

45


Internet of Things

Self Refutation
Rebut your own C.T.A. with at least one detailed reason. This is to broaden your points of views.

__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________

Peer Refutation
Rebut the C.T.A.s of the presenters with at least one evidence for support. Use keywords for notes.

Presenter 1: Presenter 2: Presenter 3:

C.T.A CTA: CTA: CTA:

Reason 1: R1: R1:

R2: R2: R2:

R3: R3: R3:

Flaws

Final
Rebuttal

46


Internet of Things

Presentation Topics
Choose a topic for presentation from the choices below. Then organize your thoughts below.

1. Explain what genetically modi ed crops are, and some of its bene ts and concerns.
2. Share why food security is important and give a historical example of when it crumbled.
3. Present a sample meal plan with three dishes that may exist in the year 2050.
4. Why are omega-3 and iron essential for our diet, and why might they become scarce?
5. Present about what a food scientist does for work.
6. Research what aquaponics is, and how it works.
7. Present about how di erent climate change can a ect crop production, such as rice and wheat.
8. Present about how di erent climate change can a ect fruit production, such as mangoes and
avocados.
9. Compare and contrast 3D-printed meat and lab-grown meat. Mention their pros and cons.
10. Share what super grain crops are, and their bene ts for food production.
11. Present about a 3D-printed meat company and its products.
12. Present about a lab-grown meat company and its products.
13. Present about the bene ts of underwater farming is, and one example of how it works.

Presentation Brainstorming
Write down your presentation topic, then organize your thoughts below.

Presentation Topic: ________________________________________________________________


keywords related to the topic:
1.
2.
3.
4.

possible sources to nd details:


1.
2.
3.
hook:_____________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________

possible call-to-action: _____________________________________________________________________


__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________

conclusion: _______________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________

*Please refer to pages v and vi for searching information.

47


fi
ff
ff
fi
fi
fi
ff
ff
fi
Internet of Things

Presentation Outline
Create an outline of the main focus and content of your presentation. Then make your PPT.

Presentation Topic:

Reason 1 (R1) Reason 2 (R2) Reason 3 (R3)

R1 Support R2 Support R3 Support

Source 1 Source 2 Source 3

48


Internet of Things

Peer Evaluation
Judge your peers and leave a comment that would bene t the speaker

Presenter 1: Presenter 2:

Organization of Ideas /5 Organization of Ideas /5

Delivery and Posture /5 Delivery and Posture /5

Knowledge of Material /5 Knowledge of Material /5

Neatness and Design /5 Neatness and Design /5

Total Score /20 Total Score /20

Comments: Comments:

Presenter 3: Presenter 4:

Organization of Ideas /5 Organization of Ideas /5

Delivery and Posture /5 Delivery and Posture /5

Knowledge of Material /5 Knowledge of Material /5

Neatness and Design /5 Neatness and Design /5

Total Score /20 Total Score /20

Comments: Comments:

49


fi
Internet of Things

Peer Evaluation
Judge your peers and leave a comment that would bene t the speaker

Presenter 5: Presenter 6:

Organization of Ideas /5 Organization of Ideas /5

Delivery and Posture /5 Delivery and Posture /5

Knowledge of Material /5 Knowledge of Material /5

Neatness and Design /5 Neatness and Design /5

Total Score /20 Total Score /20

Comments: Comments:

Presenter 7: Presenter 8:

Organization of Ideas /5 Organization of Ideas /5

Delivery and Posture /5 Delivery and Posture /5

Knowledge of Material /5 Knowledge of Material /5

Neatness and Design /5 Neatness and Design /5

Total Score /20 Total Score /20

Comments: Comments:

50


fi
Internet of Things

Peer Evaluation
Judge your peers and leave a comment that would bene t the speaker

Presenter 9: Presenter 10:

Organization of Ideas /5 Organization of Ideas /5

Delivery and Posture /5 Delivery and Posture /5

Knowledge of Material /5 Knowledge of Material /5

Neatness and Design /5 Neatness and Design /5

Total Score /20 Total Score /20

Comments: Comments:

Presenter 11: Presenter 12:

Organization of Ideas /5 Organization of Ideas /5

Delivery and Posture /5 Delivery and Posture /5

Knowledge of Material /5 Knowledge of Material /5

Neatness and Design /5 Neatness and Design /5

Total Score /20 Total Score /20

Comments: Comments:

51


fi
Internet of Things

Debate Motion & Brainstorming


Asian Parliamentary Debate Format

Debate Motions:
Motion of Fact: This house believes alternative food sources bring more
social happiness than traditional agriculture.
Motion of Value: This house values food security for all over pro t for
agricultural corporations.
Motion of Policy: This house is for the policy that all schools must serve
mediterranean meals (mostly veggies, fruits and whole
grains) to students.
Debate Motions: Opposition will strike o one motion rst. Then government will strike o another. The
remaining topic that is not struck o will be the topic of the day. Highlight the topic that is chosen.

Role Assignment for Today’s Debate: Random


Government Side Opposition Side Adjudicators

PM LO

DPM DLO

GW OW

GR OR

Brainstorming: You will have twenty minutes to prepare your side’s argument with your team. Build as
many arguments as your team can with support, details, evidence that you have collected for
homework or learned over the previous weeks. (4 arguments)
De ne the Motion (DTM)

Assertion:

Reasoning:

Evidence:

1
Link:

*Please check page vii of the IRS textbook on instructions for Debate Motion & Brainstorming.

52


fi
ff
ff
fi
fi
ff
Internet of Things

Debate Motion & Brainstorming


Asian Parliamentary Debate Format

Assertion:

Reasoning:

Evidence:

Link:

2
A:

R:

E:

L:
3
A:

R:

E:

L:
4
53


Internet of Things

Follow your script


Every debater has his/her own roles to ful ll. Please refer to the scripted prompts below to make a
smooth delivery of speech. Feel free to elaborate, improve, and enhance these scripts.

Good afternoon adjudicators and teachers. The motion for today’s debate is that _MF/MV/MP_. We
de ne the topic as _DTM_. We, the a rmative team, believe that this statement is true. As rst
speaker, I will be talking to you about _A1/A2_. Our second speaker will talk to you about _A3/A4_.
PM Our third speaker will provide rebuttals and clarify any clashes. Our last speaker will sum up our case
to end this debate. I am going to discuss _AREL 1+2_ points. [Insert your AREL arguments here and
conclude with a very persuasive ending].

Thank you Mr./Ms. Prime Minister. The motion for today is that _MF/MV/MP_. We, the opposition,
strongly feel that this resolution will fall. Before moving on to our points, I would rst like to refute
some of the points introduced by the Prime Minister. [Refute the points from the PM now]. Now I
LO would like to move on to some of the opposition’s points. We strongly believe that this resolution
should fall for these fundamental reasons: _A1_, and _A2_. Our DLO will further explain additional
points. [Explain your two main points now and conclude with a very persuasive ending].

To rea rm, the government strongly stands on the position that _MF/MV/MP_. The LO has provided
some interesting points and I would like to begin with my refutations. [Refute the points from LO
now]. To strengthen the points presented by our PM, I would like to provide two additional arguments
DPM to fortify our government’s position on the motion. The resolution must stand because _A3_, and
_A4_. [Explain your two additional main points]. For the reasons I have presented, that _A3_ and
_A4_, and for the reasons presented by our PM, that _A1_ and _A2_, the resolution will stand!

The resolution before the house today is _MF/MV/MP_. We, the opposition, stand rm in our belief
that this resolution will fall. Before moving on, I would rst like to refute the points introduced by the
DPM. [Refute the points from DPM now]. Now I would like to move on to my points that will
DLO strengthen the cause presented by my colleague. The resolution must fall because _A3_, and _A4_.
[Explain your two additional main points]. For the reasons I have presented, that _A3_ and _A4_, and
for the reasons presented by the LO, that _A1_ and _A2_, the resolution before the house today must
and will fall!
The LO and DLO have shown great e orts in trying to logically prove their points. In short, what they
said was that _[Quick summary of opposition's AREL (1, 2, 3, 4)]_, but their points greatly contradict
with the arguments of our government. To refute the previous speaker, the DLO, I say that the
GW arguments made are awed because _[Rebut the DLO’s arguments]_. The points stated by our PM
and DPM show a stronger position on the motion because ____. [Add extra details and support to
strengthen government’s arguments but you must not add any new arguments]. Therefore, the
government’s position is clearly superior.
The GW has shown a very biased analysis of the points presented. I would like to prove why the
points stated by our opposition have greater merit and consistency to the motion being debated
today. The government stated that _A1_, _A2_, _A3_, and _A4_, but they do not present a stronger
OW position to the opposition. Our LO and DLO have stated that _[short summary of opposition
ARELS]_. To provide extensions, ____. [Add extra details and support to strengthen opposition’s
arguments but you must not add any new arguments]. For these reasons, the opposition stands rm
against the resolution today.
To o er a recap of the points explained by our LO, DLO, and further explained by our OW, the
opposition believes that ____. [Use the repeating, regrouping, or reframing method to organize your
OR summary.]. Thus, as the points given by the opposition have been clearly and logically provided, we,
the opposition, take this debate home. Thank you dear adjudicators and honorable teachers.
<3 MINUTES>

After careful analysis of the points presented by both our government and the opposition, I would
like to prove why our team takes home this motion by highlighting the key points discussed in
today’s debate. [Use the repeating, regrouping, or reframing method to organize your summary].
GR Thus, as our points clearly and logically prove the motion, I strongly believe that we, the government,
win the debate. Thank you honorable judges.
<3 MINUTES>

54


fi
ff
ffi
fl
ffi
ff
fi
fi
fi
fi
fi
fi
Internet of Things

Debate Scoring Sheet Class: ____________ Date: _____________


Asian Parliamentary Debate Format

MOTION: ______________________________________________________________

PM - _________________________________(_____/2)___ LO - ( /4)

A1: R1:

A2: R2:

DPM - _________________________________(_____/4)___ A1:

R1:

A2:

R2:

DLO - ( /4)

A3: R3:

A4: R4:

GW - _________________________________(_____/6)___ A3:

R3:
A4:

R4:
OW - ( /4)

A1+: A1+:

A2+: A2+:

A3+: A3+:

A4+: A4+:

GR - _________________________________(_____/1)___ OR - ( /1)

RECAP A1~A4: RECAP A1~A4:

TOTAL: TOTAL:

55


Internet of Things

Adjudicator’s Card: As a judge, you will score the speakers with total fairness and honesty. Your
scores will greatly a ect the outcome of the debate, so judge with care. You will present the winners.

Manner: Speed, volume, intonation, eye contact, body language, humor, and eloquence
Matter: Arguments, analysis, evidence, rebuttals, POIs, logic, and knowledge of materials
Method: Organization of thoughts, material, and time
Scoring Guide

Needs Does not make


Excellent 10 Very Good 8 Pass 6 4 2
Improvement sense

G Manner Matter Method Total


O Manner Matter Method Total

PM LO
/10 /10 /5 /25 /10 /10 /5 /25

DPM DLO
/10 /10 /5 /25 /10 /10 /5 /25

GW OW
/10 /10 /5 /25 /10 /10 /5 /25

GR OR
/10 /10 /5 /25 /10 /10 /5 /25

Final Government Score /100 Final Opposition Score /100

*After nalizing your scores, judges will either vote, use averages, or add up the scores to decide the winning team. Decision
is up to you as long as it is fair. Teacher will disagree if it is not fair and just.

Adjudicator’s Notes: All adjudicators take notes to write down key points presented by the speakers.
This will help you judge with a more accurate view and understanding. Take down your notes here.

PM LO

DPM DLO

GW OW

GR OR

56


fi
ff
Internet of Things

Debate Notes
Take notes of the opposing team arguments here or use it as extra space for brainstorming

NOTES
Food for Thought
Discuss the following video with your classmates

YouTube Video: Anatomy of an IoT Attack - By Cisco (03:37)


By: ConXioN

1. What are the dangers of using the internet?


2. How do you think the internet of things a ects
one’s privacy?
3. How does the internet already control us?

57


ff
Note Taking
Extra Notes for Discussions and Debate

Notes
Use the space provided to take notes for team discussions, debates, presentations, etc.

Notes
Use the space provided to take notes for team discussions, debates, presentations, etc.

Notes
Use the space provided to take notes for team discussions, debates, presentations, etc.

We Change Habits and Design Life through English Learning

You might also like