Professional Documents
Culture Documents
CE Compensators
CE Compensators
Syllabus
Series and feedback compensation
Contents
14.1 Introduction Jan.-06, 07, 10,11 Marks 4
14.2 Types of Compensation Jan.-06,10,13, July-07 Marks 10
14.3 Compensating Networks Jan-10, July-10,11,12 Marks 5
14.4 Lead Compensator Jan.-05, 06, 07, 11, 12, 13,
July-11, 12, 13 Marks 15
14.1 Introduction
specific objectives, Tho
to achieve
All the control systems are designed certain
A EO0a control system has less
are defined for the
control system.
requirements error,
relative stability, good damping whirh.
of response, good will
good accuracy, good speed performance of the system
etc. For satistactory gain is
not cause undue overshoots
alone can not provide satisfactorv
of gain ults.
adjustedfirst. In practice, adjustment
This is because when gain is increased, steady state behaviour of the svstem im
improves
in some cases may even instability. In stuch
but results into poor transiernt response,
Ihus the design of control systerns is
cases it is necessary
to redesign the entire system.
the specifications are provided interms of preise
design
a challenging job. Practically
numerical values according system is designed. The set of such
to which the
time, damping ratio, natural frequency of
specifications include peak overshoot, peak
etc.
oscillations, error coefficients, gain margin, phase margin
Key PointIn practice, ifa system redesigned so as to meet the required specifications,
is to be
device to it. Such a redesign or
it is necessary to alter the system by adding an external
a control
alterationofsystem using an additional suitable deoice is called compensation of
system
to so as
While an external device which is used to alter the behaviour of the system
whatever
achieve given specifications is called compensator. The compensator provides
is missing in a system, so as to achieve required performance.
Review Questions
1. What is compensation? Jan.-06, 07, Marks 3
2 Explain the reed for Jan.-10, 11, Marks 4
compensation.
14.2 Types of Compensation
he
An external device, compensator can be introduced in a system anywhere as
convenience and the requirement. Depending upon where the compensator is intr
in a system, the various types of
compensation are,
1. Series compensation
2. Parallel compensation
3. Series-parallel compensation
ch an
electri
lead network. Assuming Let us see what is the maximum lead angle m which lead compensator can proyvida
oaded circuit and applying KCL for
and at what frequency it provides this angle.
u n l o a d e
we can write,
he he Output node R 2
e (t)
R2 E,() a(1+Ts)
d(e + (e -eo) Ra =
eo
E,(6) S1
1(1+aTs)
dt RI
Taking Laplace transform of the Fig. 14.4.1 Lead network Replace s by jo,
equatior E,jo) a (1+joT)
1 E jo) (1+ joa T)
sCES)-sC Es) R E,(s) Es)= E)
R1
E,GO) M =-
E ,
G w ) M =l t o T 2
s+ do 0
RR2C do
R2
RR RC
(1
tan a T- tan oa T] = 0 ie. oT
his is
generally expressed as, do = 0
T
E,) sT T oaT
E, (s) =0
1+02T2 1+a02T2 * 0
i.e. T(1+aoT) -aT(1 +T)
where R2 < 1
. 1+aT -a -a uT' =0
T = RC and
a.R +R2 ie. a T (a -1) +(1 - a) =0
of a T (a - 1) = - (1 -a)
T
located
-Real
As a 1, the z e r o is
always 1 1 1
< is Om
to he right of the pole. The pole z e r o plot Ta VT aT . (14.4.3)
value
minimum
tanm (1-a).1-a =
.. (14.4.4)
0 o
va (1+1) 2a
-(
Fig. 14.4.3 Polar plot of lead compensator
Sin m 1+a . (14.4.5) So a line of 20 log a dB with
14 9
System Compensa
14-10
C o n t r o lE n g i n e e r i n g
(14.4.6)
01+E shift due to
c o m n e n c a s
m s
at @m frequency may
dB
M 10 Log
c r o s s - o v e r
as
safety
where e Margin of
Lead
Compensator t o 15°
to Design < 1 it provides e 5
= D.C. gain =
K(1+Ts)
G) (1+a Ts) This frequency m 1s,
1
Om TVa
the compensated system thus becomes, 6: Determine the two frequencies of the lead compensator.
The open loop transfer function of Step
Gs) G(s)
K+Ts) G(s) = (1+Ts).KG(s) = 1+a Ts) Gs)
K(1+TS), G(s)= (+a Ts) (1+Ts)G,(6) C1 T and
(1+a Ts) 1
where
0C2o.T
G(s)=KG(s) |
as Step 7: As K = Kç o.,
the constant is given
ey Point Generally in such design problems one of error
determine the value of Ke.
Specification. constant. Step 8:heck the gain margin of the compensated system. If it is not satista ory
the given error
O m the above
result, determine the value of K satisfying repeat the design by modifying the pole-zero location of the
till a
of G,(K0). T h i compensato
2: Using the value of K determined above, draw the Bode plot satisfactory result is obtained.
ep margin.
is but uncompensated system. Obtain the phase
Dode plot of, gain adjusted 14.4.5 Effects of Lead
Siep3: Generally P.M. is specified for the design problem. Compensation
Let The various effects of a lead
s = P.M. specified compensation are,
1. The lead compensator adds a
dominant reases
the
1 = P.M. obtained in the step 2 damping of the closed loop system.
zero and a pole. This
Thus there is improvement in the transient response. Let obtain the transfer function of such
R
us
ww
3. It improves the phase margin of the elosed loop system. an electrical lag network.
4. The slope of the magnitude plot in Bode diagram of the forward path transfer Assuming unloaded circuit and applying e,(t)
function is reduced at the gain cross over frequency(This improves gain and phase KVL to the loop we can write,
margins improving the relative stability.)
ilt)
e(0)= i(t) R, + i(t) R2 + i ) dt
5. It increases bandwidth of the closed loop system. More the bandwidth, faster is the Fig. 14.5.1 Lag network
response. transform of the equation,
Taking Laplace
6. The steady state error does not get affected.
1. Lead compensation requires an additional increase in gain to offset the attenuation e ) = i() R + ) dt
inherent in the lead network. Larger gain requirement means in most of the cases
implies larger space, more elements, greater weight and higher cost. Taking Laplace transform,
2. More bandwidth is sometimes not desirable. This is because the noise entering the
system at the input may become objectionable due to large bandwidth It makes Fs) I() . (14.5.2)
system more susceptible to the noise signals because of increase in the high
frequency gain. Substituting I(s) from (14.5.2) in (14.5.1) we get,
3. The compensated system may have a larger undershoot than overshoot. So
tendency to over compensate system may lead to a conditionally stable system.
E,(s) E, R+R2C
4. The maximum lead angle available from a single lead network is about 60. Thus if
lead of more than 70° to 90° is required a multistage lead compensators are E(s)=,(6)[(R1 +R2)sC+1]|
required (1+R2sC).
System Compensatiorn
Control Engineeing
System Compensatn
1 Imj compensator are,
frequencies of lag
Thelag compensator has zero at s = a n d
The two corner
1
a pole at s = - T As ß > 1, the pole is always
@CI Tand BT
Real
located to
located to the right of the zero. The pole-zero corner frequencies.
mean of the two
nlot is shown in the Fig. 14.5.2. Usually B is BT Thus wm is the geometric
function of a lag compensator is to provide nti
choosen greater than 10. Key Point Note that the primary The phase lag anol,
a system sujicient phase margin. does
the high frequency range give
to
Fig. 14.5.2
14.5.1 Maximum Lag Angle and B role in the lag compensation.
not play a
1) Let us see what is the maximum lag angle the compensator can provide.
14.5.2 Polar Plot of Lag Compensator
of lag compensator can
equations (14.5.5) and (14.5.6), polar plot
S+
E,() 1+Ts
1 T From the
E, () B 1+BTs achieved.
s*BT When = 0,
M = 1 and o = 0°
.2) E,jo) 1+joT . (14.5.4) So both the points, starting and terminating are on positive real axis.
E, (jo) 1+joßT
For any value of o between 0 to oo,
the magnitude is always positive while Imj
E, Go) 1+02T2
M
E Go) .(14.5.5) for B> 1, tan "oT < tan"o BT. Thus the = 0
V1+0p2T2
resultant will be always
negative for
any value of w between 0 to co, Hence 1 Real(0
While the phase angle is given by,
all the points of polar plot are
always
in the third
= tanoT-tanoßT (14.5.6) quadrant of the complex
plane.
The equation is exactly similar to the lead network, only ß > 1. To find let 1s
Thus the polar plot is as shown in 1sator
ind which maximises . the Fig. 14.5.3. Fig. 14.5.3 Polar plot of lag compe
TECHNICAL PUBLICATIO
for kn
TECHNICAL PUBLICATIONS- An up thrust for
knoweuy
ontrol Engimeening 14-15 System Compensation Control Engineering 14-16 System Compensation
Step 4 Find the frequency w, corresponding to phase margn of o 2 degrees
ha Dole is more dominating than zero. The transfer function of basic lag network is, e.
the
frequency at which phase angle of open loop transfer function is -180° +0,. Cho
oose this
1+ST
T(S) 1+ sPT -20 dB/ decade
as new gain crossover frequency.
crossover frequency, determine the attens-
O dB Step 5: To have w2 as the new gain enuation
curve up or down to 0 dB. This shift is duo
Thus as R = 1, the initial
necessary to shift the magnitude the
1 contribution of B which is 20 Log p
dB line till
line is O0
oci T
Shift to have @2 as new gain crossover = 20 Log - 20 Log B
occurs. From a0cI=
where pole
BT
Key Point Down shift must be taken negative while up shift positive. Hence determine the
toc there is a line of slope
0
Dalue ofB.
-20 dB/dec. From Oc2 '1' 1
T-45 m Step 6: Choose the upper corner frequency which isor below the o
T
onwards again the net slope is
determined in step 4.
zero due to existence of zero with -90
Log o
1
cT BT OmT V OC2
10
Fig. 14.5.4 Bode plot of lag compensator
The Bode plot is shown in the
Thus determine the value of T.
Fig. 14.5.4.
The other corner frequency for the lag compensator is,
14.5.4 Steps to Design Lag Compensator 1
E(s) +sR,C)
Ef (+sR2C2)E(en(1+sR C) (1+sR2C2)1 The
1. Derive the transfer function of lag compensator. Find the frequency at which the phase angle is sRC2 sRIC2 eque
maximum. What are the characteristics of lag compensator?
Jan.-06, July-10, Marks 15 Es) (1+sR,C1) (1 +sR2C2)
2. Write a note on lag compensator.
Jan-05,06,11.12, July-11,13, Marks 7 E, (s) sRC2 +0+sRC1) (d*sRaC2)
3. Explain the lag compensation along with their rough Bode plot. Jan.-13, Marks 6
Es) (1+sRC) (1+sR2C2) The-
14.6 Lag-Lead Compensator E, s) s RRC1C2 +s [R,CI +R2C2 +RC21+1
A combination of and lead compensators
a lag 1
is nothing bit a lag-lead compensator. Consider an
E6) RRCC2 *R,CGSRC2
electrical network which is lag-lead network, as
E,(S) 1 1
shown in the Fig. 14.6.1.
R2 R,RCC2 s+s RCRC'RCTRRCC
Let us obtain the transfer function of the t) Ihe
electrical lag-lead network.
E,(s) . (14.6.3)
Now sum of the current through Ri and Cq is
Fig. 14.6.1 Lag-Lead network E (s)
nothing but current i(t).
Now
o+Cdo= i) where T RC T2 =RC2 Whilka
Taking Laplace transform we get,
B1 1 1 Ihu
T BT2 RC RC2 R2C1
1 ... (14.6.1) an
R 6)- E,s)+ sC, E(S) -
sC E,(s) =
Is) apTT2 = RRC,C2
s =
1 while the zeros are at
The pole
are
T1'BTT2 ... (14.6.7)
1 tan1 10 tan BT2
The pole-zero plot for the lag-lead an "oT,
-
T T2 Raal
is shown in the Fig. 14.6.2.
mpensator T
and 0°
Polar Plot of Lag-Lead Compensatoor
14.6.1 Fig. 14.6.2
The transfer function
of Lag-lead compensator in the and = 0°
domain can be obtairned as,
frequency
E j) (1+Ti j ) (1+T2j)
... (14.6.5) ninating points Imj
E, (j)
1+j (1+jT2 B . But there is
The magnitude of the transfer functions,
hich it acts as
M
1+02T? 1T2 plot in third Real (0°)
... (14.66)
1+To
1+B2T32
ill it acts as
o
ne
hus the starting and terminating points
p o l a r p l o t is s a m e as 1 2 0°. But there 1s
Imj frequency i s given by,
ain frequency upto which it acts as
lag network giving polar plot in third
Reai (0) . (14.6.8)
it acts as
adrant. While for > o till
cad network giving polar plot in the first
plot, is
quadrant. Hence the entire polar
in nature. The polar plot is a s shown
Fig. .0.9
oa piot o f lag-lead compen
ular
in the Fig. 14.6.3. HNICAL
ne lag-lead n e t w o r k the frequency o
is given by, PUBLICATIONS"- An up thrust for knowledge
1
TT2 (14.68)
An u p thru
TECHNICAL
PUBLICATIONS dge
Control Engineering 14- 20 System Compensation
o dB
Wc2 for a simple zero
T1
for a simple zero
Oc3 T
1
C4 T tor a simple pole
BT2 +45°
O00
TECHNICAL PUBLICATIONS An up
thrust for knowledge