Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 6

Patient Satisfaction With

Telephone Nursing
A Call for Calm, Clarity, and Competence
Silje Gustafsson, PhD, RN; Britt-Marie Wälivaara, PhD, RN;
Sebastian Gabrielsson, PhD, RN

ABSTRACT
Background: Studies of patient satisfaction with telephone nursing can provide a better understanding of
callers’ needs and inform the improvement of services.
Purpose: This study described patients’ experiences and perceptions of satisfaction with telephone nursing.
Methods: The design was nonexperimental and descriptive, with an inductive approach. Data were collected
using open-ended questions in a questionnaire that was dispatched to 500 randomly selected callers to the
Swedish Healthcare Direct in Northern Sweden.
Results: Patients’ satisfaction with telephone nursing was related to calm, clarity, and competence. Calm re-
ferred to the nurse remaining calm and composed during the call. Clarity was described as distinct, concrete,
and practical advice on how to act, what to observe, and where to seek further assistance. Competence
referred to both health care knowledge and caring skills.
Conclusion: These aspects of nursing are dependent on each other and on-call telephone nursing services,
which value patient satisfaction need to target all 3.
Keywords: nursing care, patient satisfaction, telenursing, telephone nursing, telephone triage nurse

M any countries have seen the introduction


of telephone nursing call centers expected
to provide accessible, trusted, quality health in-
Compliance increases when the recommendation
is a high care level, for example, the emergency
department, or when the recommended care level
formation, and advice. According to Kaminsky is higher than the caller expected.2,6,7
et al,1 the aim of telephone nursing is to sup-
port, strengthen, and teach the callers and guide SATISFACTION
care seekers to the correct level of care. Tele- In relation to telephone nursing, feeling safe and
phone nursing reduces costs and the number of secure after the call is the primary factor that
patients seeking care for minor conditions.2 The influences patient satisfaction.3 The convenience
frequency of recommendations to self-care is ap- and simplicity of telephone nursing have been de-
proximately 30% for persons calling on their scribed as important factors influencing satisfac-
own behalf.2-4 Compliance to telephone nurses’ tion, as the direct and effective contact and ad-
recommendations is high2,3,5 but dependent on vice replace long waiting times and unnecessary
the level of care recommended by the nurse. journeys to the health care clinic.4,8,9 Satisfaction
is a multidimensional concept, and a single, uni-
Author Affiliation: Division of Nursing, Department of Health versally accepted definition of satisfaction is still
Science, Luleå University of Technology, Luleå, Sweden.
lacking. For the purpose of this study, patient sat-
This study was funded by Luleå University of Technology. The
authors gratefully acknowledge Robert Lundqvist at the county
isfaction was understood as the congruence be-
council of Norrbotten for the help received with this study. tween health care service and patient need, de-
The authors declare no conflicts of interest. sire, or expectation.
Supplemental digital content is available for this article. Direct URL Studying patient satisfaction provides impor-
citation appears in the printed text and is provided in the HTML and tant information about service factors that need
PDF versions of this article on the journal’s Web site
improvement and creates a better understanding
(www.jncqjournal.com).
Correspondence: Silje Gustafsson, PhD, RN, Division of Nursing,
of patients’ needs.10 This is important informa-
Department of Health Science, Luleå University of Technology, tion that enables organizations and health care
SE-971 87 Luleå, Sweden (Silje.gustafsson@ltu.se). providers to improve services to better match the
Accepted for publication: January 2, 2019 needs of the population. Because of the effec-
Published ahead of print: February 25, 2019 tive and interpersonal component of patient sat-
DOI: 10.1097/NCQ.0000000000000392 isfaction, qualitative evaluations can contribute

E6 www.jncqjournal.com J Nurs Care Qual • Vol. 35, No. 1, pp. E6–E11 • Copyright © 2019 Wolters Kluwer Health, Inc. All rights reserved.

Copyright © 2019 Wolters Kluwer Health, Inc. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
January–March 2020 • Volume 35 • Number 1 www.jncqjournal.com E7

to the body of knowledge by creating a deeper isfied, they were asked to describe the reason
and more varied understanding of experiences of for dissatisfaction (n = 7) and provide sugges-
satisfaction, as well as validating the findings of tions for improvement (n = 66). A panel of 4
larger, quantitative surveys. The aim of this study experienced multidisciplinary senior researchers
was to describe patients’ experiences and percep- and 2 statisticians critically reviewed the ques-
tions of satisfaction with telephone nursing. tionnaire, including the open-ended questions.
A total of 123 different persons responded to
METHODS the questions, and 171 written answers were re-
This was a nonexperimental and descriptive ceived. Median length of the written answers was
study with an inductive approach. The Swedish 11 words (interquartile range, 4-23).
Healthcare Direct (SHD) is the largest health
care provider in Sweden and was made fully op- Data analysis
erational in all counties in 2013. The SHD com- Participants’ answers were analyzed using qual-
prises 3 services—an on-call telephone nursing itative content analysis. This is a method for
service, a state-owned Web site, and a platform systematic analysis of written and verbal com-
for e-services where patients can manage their munication that allows for making replicable
health care contacts. The on-call telephone nurs- and valid abductive inferences from texts.13 Fol-
ing service consists of nurses providing an assess- lowing Krippendorff,13 content was understood
ment of care needs, advice, and guidance to the as being created during the process of reading
correct level of care. The Web site contains peer- and analyzing the text in a specific context that
reviewed medical information and advice and is continuously reconceptualized, directing and
has 90 million visits per year, a number that in- redirecting the analysis.
creases by 10% every year. The platform for e- We thus performed the analysis as a system-
services enables patients to contact their health atic, stepwise, iterative process. First, partici-
care providers and receive digital care, as well as pants’ answers were read as a whole with the
gathering information about all of their health aim in mind. The material generated 220 textual
care contacts.11 units. These were then coded and organized
into categories independently by the first and
Participants and setting last authors, respectively, and the 2 sets were
A random selection was made of 500 callers to compared, discussed, and synthesized, forming
the SHD in Northern Sweden during the first a third set. The original answers were then read
week of March 2014, a third of the total number again, and additional revisions made to the
of callers in that week (n = 1500). Participants wording and content of categories and codes.
received a questionnaire by post with an infor- Graneheim et al14 suggest that qualitative con-
mational letter enclosed, and a reminder was sent tent analyses differ in degree of abstraction and
2 weeks after primary dispatch. A total of 225 interpretation. This analysis resulted in 3 main
persons returned a completed questionnaire, giv- categories and 12 subcategories on a descriptive
ing a response rate of 45.6%. Five questionnaires level. The main categories reflect some level
were returned unopened because of the wrong of abstraction, whereas the subcategories are
address, and 2 study participants were deceased concrete and closer to the original text. After
after the call to the SHD. The regional ethical re- categorization, a quantitative word frequency
view board of Umeå reviewed and approved this count was performed to identify the number of
study (DNR: 2010-225-31). positive and negative statements relating to each
main category.
Data collection
Data were collected using open-ended questions RESULTS
in a questionnaire. The construction of the ques- Following patients’ experiences and suggestions,
tionnaire has been described elsewhere.3 The patients’ satisfaction with telephone nursing can
open-ended questions follow the exact wording be described as dependent on engaging with
of the modified Quality from the Patient Per- calm, clear, and competent nurses (Table). A to-
spective questionnaire for telephone nursing.12 tal of 127 positive statements were made about
Participants were asked to describe what they the SHD, and 44 statements commented on the
found satisfactory (n = 98); if they were unsat- SHD in negative terms (see Supplemental Digital

Copyright © 2019 Wolters Kluwer Health, Inc. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
E8 Patient Satisfaction With Telephone Nursing Journal of Nursing Care Quality

about their symptoms and not just read from the


Table. Analysis of Patients’ Experiences
hospital records.”
and Perceptions of Satisfaction With Tele-
phone Nursing Clear
Main Callers appreciated nurses offering clear, con-
Subcategories Categories crete, and practical advice delivered in a confi-
That the nurse dent manner. Information received when calling
listens before asking questions Calm telephone nurses was expected to be trustworthy
and giving advice and was of high quality. Callers described being
gives time and inspires calm satisfied when being instructed how to act, what
gives clear and concise advice on Clarity to observe, and where to seek further assistance.
what to do and what to observe For example, patients stated: “The nurse made
facilitates and coordinates care us feel calm and gave clear instructions on how
to monitor our child during the night until the
is easily accessible
primary care clinic would open.”
is knowledgeable and professional Competence
Patients wanted the information to be straight-
with great medical competence
forward and the advice to be personalized and
gives a correct medical
action-oriented. They wanted more information
assessment and advice
about self-care interventions so that they could
takes symptoms seriously and
be self-reliant instead of simply being sent some-
avoids risks
where else. Receiving more information about
is welcoming and supporting and medications, particularly side effects, was also
strives to help
mentioned: “[I] would like to get more infor-
is committed and compassionate mation/tips about what to do to relieve my
shows warmth and understanding symptoms instead of just being sent somewhere
respects the patients’ knowledge else.”
Callers expressed satisfaction when the nurse
facilitated and coordinated care, for instance,
Content, Table, available at: http://links.lww.
by connecting them with other health care
com/JNCQ/A549).
providers. This could include calling for an
Calm ambulance and calling ahead to the emergency
Participants found it positive when the nurses department to give information. Accessibility of
tuned in and listened first before they started the SHD was not only highly valued but also a
asking questions and giving advice. Participants source of dissatisfaction. Callers described being
found it reassuring to know that there was some- frustrated when they had been put on hold.
one at hand to consult when needed, without Participants expressed satisfaction with short
feeling that they were taking up someone else’s waiting times and a rapid service that was easily
time. Callers described that, when the nurse accessible. A need was found for improvements
spoke calmly, it would inspire confidence and in the organization of the telephone nursing, in-
ease distress. When the nurse remained calm and cluding reducing waiting time, improving the in-
composed, callers felt reassured and safe: “The structions for redialing, and making sure the tele-
welcoming reception and the feeling of reassur- phone call was actually connected. Participants
ance after the call with what felt like knowl- suggested the opportunity of sending a picture
edgeable and calm staff” and “Being able to re- by MMS to the nurse for assessment, as they
ceive advice without feeling that you are stealing found it sometimes hard to explain in detail
someone else’s time.” what they saw over the telephone.
The assessment received could sometimes be
perceived as overly dramatic, causing fear and Competence
concern. Some callers had experience of talking Participants expressed satisfaction with receiv-
to nurses who did not listen and stressed the im- ing a careful examination and an accurate as-
portance of allocating enough time for conversa- sessment by a skilled nurse with high medical
tion. They also called for a greater focus on lis- competence, which produced a feeling of com-
tening to the callers: “Listen better to the caller fort and safety after the call. The respondents

Copyright © 2019 Wolters Kluwer Health, Inc. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
January–March 2020 • Volume 35 • Number 1 www.jncqjournal.com E9

wanted some kind of “diagnosis”; they wanted DISCUSSION


to hear the nurse’s opinion about their symp- The aim of this study was to describe patients’
toms, possible cause of their symptoms, and rea- experiences and perceptions of satisfaction with
soning underlying the recommendation to either telephone nursing. The results describe the im-
seek medical care or practice self-care. One pa- portance of calm, clarity, and competence. Ar-
tient commented: “I would like nurses to ex- guably, all these aspects of nursing are dependent
plain what causes the symptoms, like receiving a on each other and thus on-call telephone nursing
diagnosis.” services need to target all 3.
Many praised the nurses’ clinical skills and Participants described that a nurse who con-
found them competent, knowledgeable, and veys calm made them feel reassured and safe.
professional. Yet, respondents pointed out the A common reason for calling telephone nursing
need for nurses’ skills to be increased to improve services was a need for reassurance related
confidence, as it was seen as negative when the to uncertainty and concern about symptoms.
nurse seemed insecure or faltering. Some people The severity of symptoms, new and unfamiliar
had experienced receiving a wrong assessment symptoms, or persisting or worsening symptoms
and advice, causing difficulty in relying on generate feelings of uncertainty and stress.8,15
the expertise and assessments of the nurses. It A trusting relationship was reassuring, and
was important for the nurse to consult with personal presence in the encounter with the
someone if unsure, and respondents stressed telephone nurse was identified as an important
the importance that telephone nurses should factor that promoted feelings of safety and secu-
be registered nurses with specialist competence. rity. Distance technology imposes demands on
One patient stated: “They should recommend the nurse to convey a sense of personal presence
that you seek emergency care if there is any and togetherness during the conversation with
doubt about anything…. Neither the nurse the caller.8,9 According to Kaminsky et al,16
nor the patient should feel that they are doing speaking slowly and listening carefully facilitate
something wrong if the patient seeks medical communication and inspire calm. The presence
care.” of a nurse is reassuring, and the presence need
Callers were satisfied when they were received not be physical.17 Patients are reassured when
in a kind and friendly manner and the nurse was nurses have a quiet, warm tone to their voices.17
welcoming and supporting. Callers stressed the In relation to our findings, this implies that
importance of being met with compassion and the nurse reassures the care seeker through a
described feeling safer when they felt that the calm presence and clear communication and
nurse genuinely cared about them and wanted to by displaying competence and care. Thus, tele-
help. Compassion from the nurse inspired con- phone nurses “being calm” demonstrate how
fidence, and taking the time to follow up their fundamental interpersonal aspects of nursing
situation was appreciated. The importance of remain relevant regardless of context.
nurses respecting the callers’ knowledge about Our findings demonstrated a need for clear,
their own bodies and conditions was stressed, concrete, and practical advice delivered in a
and it was important that the nurses listened to confident manner. Callers requested information
the patients and trusted their knowledge about and advice about their situation and wanted to
their own health: “I think you have to be care- know what to do, what to observe, and where
ful, taking every call seriously; no symptom can to go if the symptoms worsened. According to
be too small to be taken into account.” Kaminsky et al,1 telephone nursing comprises an
Some described having experienced a lack of important function to teach the caller about
compassion from the nurse and that their con- health matters and facilitate learning. The nurse’s
cerns were not understood. This made them per- pedagogical role is carried out with the intention
ceive the nurse as being cold and uninterested of empowering callers to perform self-care and
in their situation, resulting in feelings of rejec- encouraging them to seek further information
tion. Being shifted further to other caregivers was when needed, thus contributing to their learn-
frustrating: “My feeling is that they will do just ing. Thus, the emphasis on the importance of
about anything to keep the patient from going to clear advice might reflect an expectation that
the primary care clinic or hospital.” telephone nursing should facilitate learning and

Copyright © 2019 Wolters Kluwer Health, Inc. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
E10 Patient Satisfaction With Telephone Nursing Journal of Nursing Care Quality

autonomous decision-making rather than simply Our results specifically describe nurses taking
telling callers what to do. the time to follow up on a patient’s situation
The results describe patients valuing the clin- as a caring act. Offering monitoring calls has
ical competence of telephone nurses and call- been described by parents of children with gas-
ing for a higher level of knowledge among these troenteritis as comforting, as they generate a feel-
nurses. This underlines the importance of tele- ing of shared responsibility. According to Kvilén
phone nurses having specialist education tar- Eriksson et al,9 monitoring calls creates a sense
geted at telephone nursing. Although perceiving of personal contact and connectedness and en-
the nurse as unsure or unaware of the partic- ables parents to share their worries and concerns
ular circumstances of their situation can result with a nurse. The feeling of not being alone, and
in reduced trust from patients, the emphasis on the security of having someone to talk to, has
nurses’ competence should not be interpreted as been found to engender feelings of confidence
patients expecting nurses to have all the answers. and reassurance.8,9
On the contrary, participants described that the Our findings illustrate how the telephone
nurse consulting colleagues for advice and de- nurse’s gatekeeping function might shine
cision support generated trust in nurses’ assess- through in the encounter. Telephone nurses
ments, consistent with the findings of Kaminsky are exposed to criticism, and their competence
et al.18 In this regard, our results also point to the and referrals can be questioned by both callers
importance of what Roland et al19 label “safety- and colleagues in other sectors of the health
netting,” that is, providing the caller with infor- care system.24 Understanding how patients per-
mation on warning symptoms and how further ceive and value telephone nurses’ competence is
health care can be accessed, as well as follow- especially important, as previous research has
ing up the outcome of care. Our findings sug- shown that the tendency to seek health care
gest that, from the perspective of patients, safety- increases when callers feel unsecure or when
netting might increase trust in the competence of they feel unsatisfied with the care received.8,16
telephone nurses and in the advice given. Partic- Consequently, satisfaction with the interper-
ipants also stressed the importance of not being sonal interaction with the nurse is positively
made to feel that they were wrong to seek medi- correlated with self-care behavior.2,5 Our results
cal care. not only stress the importance of telephone
The interpersonal aspects of telephone nurs- nurses being competent but also demonstrate
ing are further emphasized. Our results describe how this competence must be about putting
how compassion from the nurse inspired confi- patients’ needs first—even if that means having
dence and indicated a caring competence. It has to admit your own limitations by seeking advice
been argued that the emotional understanding from colleagues or dealing with uncertainties by
of nursing, “to care for,” has been devalued in “safety-netting” or referring patients.
the modern society.20 Previous research describes
that, when the design of telephone nursing ser-
vices focuses on somatic symptoms, telephone Strengths and limitations
nurses are left without support in dealing with Validity in qualitative research assesses whether
callers’ emotional and mental health needs.21 the research findings represent a credible in-
According to Ström et al,4 callers might actu- terpretation of the original data.25 To reduce
ally prefer emotional interaction before seeking the risk of confirmation bias, the authors per-
knowledge from the telephone nurse. In our re- formed the first step of analysis separately, thus
sults, participants also stressed the importance of triangulating the analysis. The data collected
nurses trusting the patients’ stories and knowl- were written down by the respondents, which
edge of their own bodies. This is consistent with meant that the text was relatively condensed, fa-
the findings of Murray and McCrone,22 who cilitating the striving to stay close to the original
found that seeing the patient as a person rather text.
than a case and listening to the patient’s con- Reliability pertains to the stability of data
cerns developed trust between the patient and the collection.25 The sampling of study participants
caregiver. Conveying caring competence reduces in this study was random, and 123 different re-
worry and feelings of vulnerability and leads to spondents contributed data that formed the ba-
increased trust.23 sis of the analysis. The questions that formed the

Copyright © 2019 Wolters Kluwer Health, Inc. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
January–March 2020 • Volume 35 • Number 1 www.jncqjournal.com E11

basis for data collection were obtained from a 3. Gustafsson S, Vikman I, Wälivaara BM, Sävenstedt S, Mar-
validated and tested questionnaire.12 A limita- tinsson J. Influences of self-care advice on patient satisfac-
tion and health care utilization. J Adv Nurs. 2016;72(8):
tion in satisfaction research is the phenomenon 1789-1799.
of positively skewed ratings of satisfaction. To 4. Ström M, Baigi A, Hildingh C, Mattsson B, Marklund B. Pa-
reduce the risk of social desirability bias and to tient care encounters with the MCHL: a questionnaire study.
Scand J Caring Sci. 2011;25(3):517-524.
gain a broader view, we also sought experiences 5. Williams B, Warren S, McKim R, Janzen W. Caller self-
of dissatisfaction and thus asked for sugges- care decisions following teletriage advice. J Clin Nurs. 2012;
tions for improvement. The questionnaire was 21(7/8):1041-1050.
6. Martinsson J, Gustafsson S. Modelling the effect of tele-
anonymous, and no personal information could phone nursing triage. Int J Med Inform. 2018;113:98-105.
be linked to the answers. Experiences and per- 7. Rahmqvist M, Ernesäter A, Holmström I. Triage and patient
ceptions of satisfaction from respondents with satisfaction among callers in Swedish computer-supported
telephone advice nursing. J Telemed Telecare. 2011;17(7):
a language other than Swedish are not repre- 397-402.
sented in the material, as non-Swedish speak- 8. Gustafsson S, Sävenstedt S, Martinsson J, Wälivaara BM.
ers would not have been able to understand Need for reassurance in self-care of minor illnesses. J Clin
Nurs. 2018;27(5/6):1183-1191.
the questions in the questionnaire. The ques- 9. Kvilén Eriksson E, Sandelius S, Wahlberg AC. Telephone ad-
tionnaire was distributed within 2 weeks of vice nursing: parents’ experiences of monitoring calls in chil-
the call to the SHD, which implies a low risk dren with gastroenteritis. Scand J Caring Sci. 2015;29:333-
339.
of recollection bias. However, the callers al- 10. Batbaatar E, Dorjdagva J, Luvsannyam A, Savino M,
ready knew the outcome of care, which could Amenta P. Determinants of patient satisfaction: a systematic
have affected their experiences with the nurse review. Perspect Public Health. 2017;137(2):89-101.
11. Inera AB. 1177 Vårdguiden på telefon [1177 Health-
both positively and negatively, depending on the care guide by phone]. https://www.inera.se/tjanster/
outcome. 1177-vardguiden-pa-telefon. Accessed October 10, 2018.
12. Improveit AB. KUPP—Validerad patientenkät som mäter
patientupplevd kvalitet [QPP—Validated patient question-
CONCLUSIONS naire that measures patients’ experiences of quality]. http://
www.improveit.se/kupp. Accessed October 10, 2018.
This qualitative study adds to a limited but grow- 13. Krippendorff K. Content Analysis: An Introduction to Its
ing body of knowledge on telephone nursing Methodology. 3rd ed. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE; 2013.
building on patients’ experiences and percep- 14. Graneheim UH, Lindgren BM, Lundman B. Methodological
challenges in qualitative content analysis: a discussion paper.
tions. Our findings suggest that satisfaction in- Nurse Educ Today. 2017;56:29-34.
creases when engaging with nurses who are calm, 15. Watson M, Ferguson J, Barton G, et al. A cohort study of
clear, and competent. In the clinical setting, this influences, health outcomes and costs of patients’ health-
seeking behaviour for minor ailments from primary and
implies that the nurse needs to convey a sense of emergency care settings. BMJ Open. 2015;5(2):e006261.
calm, as well as communicating with the caller 16. Kaminsky E, Röing M, Björkman A, Holmström I. Tele-
in a clear and understandable manner. Nurses phone nursing in Sweden: a narrative literature review. Nurs
Health Sci. 2017;19:278-286.
need a high level of medical knowledge, as well 17. Fareed A. The experience of reassurance: patients’ perspec-
as a caring competence to adequately address tives. J Adv Nurs. 1996;23(2):272-279.
patients’ needs. To identify and meet patients’ 18. Kaminsky E, Carlsson M, Röing M, Holmström I. If I
didn’t trust Swedish Healthcare Direct, I would never call’—
needs, nurses should embrace the relational and views of making pediatric health calls. Clin Nurs Stud.
emotional aspects of care. Competent nurses al- 2013;1(3):57-69.
low themselves to acknowledge and act when 19. Roland D, Jones C, Neill S, Thompson M, Lakhanpaul M.
Safety netting in healthcare settings: what it means, and for
unsure by consulting colleagues or safety-netting whom? Arch Dis Child Educ Pract Ed. 2014;99:48-53.
through referral to other services. The findings of 20. Herdman EA. Nursing in a postemotional society. Nurs Phil.
this study validate the quantitative findings from 2004;5(2):95-103.
21. Björkman A, Salzmann-Erikson M. When all other doors
previous studies and provide an understanding are closed: telenurses’ experiences of encountering care
of the nuances of callers’ experiences of satisfac- seekers with mental illnesses. Int J Ment Health Nurs.
tion with telephone nursing. 2018;27(5):1392-1400.
22. Murray B, McCrone S. An integrative review of promoting
trust in the patient-primary care provider relationship. J Adv
REFERENCES Nurs. 2015;71(1):3-23.
1. Kaminsky E, Rosenqvist U, Holmström I. Telenurses’ under- 23. Fredriksson L, Eriksson K. The ethics of the caring conver-
standing of work: detective or educator? J Adv Nurs. 2009; sation. Nurs Ethics. 2003;10(2):138-148.
65(2):382-390. 24. Ström M, Marklund B, Hildingh C. Nurses’ perceptions
2. Marklund B, Ström M, Månsson J, Borgquist L, Baigi A, of providing advice via a telephone care line. Br J Nurs.
Fridlund B. Computer-supported telephone nurse triage: an 2006;15:1119-1125.
evaluation of medical quality and costs. J Nurs Manag. 25. Long T, Johnson M. Rigour, reliability and validity in qual-
2007;15(2):180-187. itative research. Clin Effectiveness Nurs. 2000;4(1):30-37.

Copyright © 2019 Wolters Kluwer Health, Inc. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.

You might also like