Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Effectiveness of Williams Exercises For Treatment of Patients With Low Bak Pain in Elderly
Effectiveness of Williams Exercises For Treatment of Patients With Low Bak Pain in Elderly
KARNATAKA
DATE OF
4. ADMISSION 31/05/2023
INTRODUCTION
Low back pain (LBP) is a prevalent complaint in the productive and geriatric age group. The
estimated global prevalence of LBP is about 31%, and it is common in women aged 40– 80
years old [1]. The prevalence of specific chronic LBP in Japan is 9.3% and of non-specific
chronic LBP is 15.4% [2]. Meanwhile, in Thailand, the prevalence of LBP is 30%, nearly the
same with global prevalence [3]. In Indonesia, there was only one study regarding the
prevalence of LBP. The prevalence of LBP among the productive age group was nearly 40%
[4]. The disability caused by LBP is the highest compared to any other condition globally [1].
In the USA, more than 100 million USD is spent each year treating LBP. Cases of LBP are
expected to rise to an estimated 843 million by 2050 globally (WHO guidelines)
The most common treatments for LBP are pain medication with NSAID or oral/intra-articular
steroid [5]. Other forms of treatment such as physiotherapy or physical exercise are still rarely
advised to patients with LBP, especially to the elderly. About 75% of all LBP patients never
get treatment other than oral medication.
Although physiotherapy had proven to reduce the economic burden of LBP by 20%, it is
regrettable that most general practitioner rarely recommends physiotherapy to treat LBP. The
reluctance to prescribe physical activity stemmed from the lack of education regarding non-
pharmaceutical therapy [6].
A systematic review regarding the cost-effective analysis of LBP therapy found that exercise
or referral to such service by GPs may improve the cost-effectiveness of their treatment [7]
Among the available exercises, Williams flexion exercise (WFE) is one of the simplest and
most commonly used physiotherapy exercises to treat LBP patients. It is proven to reduce
pain and improve spinal range of motion (ROM) in LBP patients by strengthening the para
spinal muscles to support the degenerated facet joints [8]
RESEARCH QUESTION
Will William's Flexion Exercise be helpful to treat Low Back Pain in Elderly?
HYPOTHESIS:
NULL HYPOTHESIS:
William's Flexion Exercise will be ineffective in treating Low Back Pain in Elderly.
ALTERNATIVE HYPOTHESIS:
William's Flexion Exercise will be effective in treating Low Back Pain in Elderly.
6.2 REVIEW OF LITERATURE
1. William Putera Sukmajaya1*, Firas Farisi Alkaff2, Alina Oen3, Alverina Cynthia
Sukmajaya4(2020)
This study aimed to evaluate the effects of Williams flexion exercise (WFE) in patients with
low back pain. Study design, Java, Indonesia, June 2018 to July 2018. Participants' basic
medical information and Oswestry Disability Index (ODI) were obtained through a self-
administered questionnaire. Introduce WFE to attendees through demonstrations, videos and
live demonstrations. After 1 month, participants were re-evaluated at ODI. There was a
significant difference in ODI before and after WFE use (31.05 ± 17.40 vs.14.10 ± 11.78, p =
0.019). More exercise (>1 exercise/day) was associated with a greater reduction in ODI
compared to the lower group (1 exercise/day) (22.09 ± 19.09 vs. 7.38 ± 12.58, p = 0.017).
There was no significant difference in the reduction of ODI between elderly and non-elderly
subjects (p = 0.24). The study concluded that these activities could be used in primary care in
the future to reduce the cost of low back pain treatment. [9]
The aim of the study was to determine the effect of the addition of william flexion exercise on
functional abilities in patients with myogenic low back pain at Banyumas General
Hospital.This type of research was one group pre-test & post test with control design, subjects
were randomly selected into the treatment group and the control group. The subjects were 31
patients at the Banyumas General Hospital who included the inclusion criteria.The paired t-
test and independent t-test which were carried out in both groups after receiving the
intervention obtained a value of p = 0.000 (p <0.05) which means that there was an increase in
functional ability and there was a significant difference in the two groups. Difference in mean
pre-post test treatment group 7.5 and control 2.4.The study concluded that the addition of
William's flexion exercise has an effect on increasing functional ability in patients with
myogenic low back pain.[11]
4. Stefani A. Nelvin1*, Anderias Umbu Roga2 , Jacob Ratu3, Noorce Ch. Berek4 ,
Imelda F.
E. Manurung5(2021)
The purpose of this study was to determine the effectiveness of the William flexion exercise in
reducing low back pain. This study was a quasi-experimental study using a group pretest-
posttest design. William flexion exercise is done as abdominal strengthening for 30-40
minutes. The sample of the study consisted of 23 individuals identified through random
sampling technique from rice farmers in Lembor Selatan District of West Manggarai District.
Lumbar pressure levels were measured using the Oswestry Questionnaire before and after the
intervention. Differences between pre- and post-intervention data were tested using the
Wilcoxon signed-rank test. The results showed that the William flexion exercise was able to
reduce the farmer's lumbar score from an average of 64.26 points to 47.96 points, a 25.36%
reduction, p = 0.000. This study concluded that the William flexion exercise can reduce back
pain.[12]
6. A Akbar1,R Zainuddin2(2020)
The purpose of this literature review was to determine the effectiveness of the use of
William's flexion exercises in patients with back pain. Using the search strategy, we identified
32 articles related to potential and research targets, but only reviewed 5 articles in this
literature. We can see that the participant's pain decreased after taking William's flexion
exercise. Conclusion: The results of this study, which reviewed many articles in the literature,
concluded that William's flexion exercise program is effective in reducing pain in patients
with back pain.[14]
7. W Hasmar1, AS Junaidi2(2020)
Conducted a study that, Education William flexion exercises to quantify back pain in the
community. The method used was the Gift leaflet Core Stability Exercise performed at
Mayang Manurai Community. Citizens then answer and discuss the benefits expected from
using the service so that citizens can carry out the application correctly and independently.
There were 3 stages.
a) Stage of implementation, where permission was obtained,
b) Stage of preparation where William's flexion exercises were taught. WFE which consists
of pelvic tilting, single knee to chest, double knee to chest , repeated 8 times, demonstrated
and corrected if the movement were incorrect.
c) Stage of socialisation and education about WFE.
They evaluated William's community service through discussion and response about mobility
and back pain. Public Awareness was created. This would increase awareness of IRT and
William's flexion exercises that can be done independently at home to reduce back pain.
Permission to send paper was obtained. The results of the exercise were shown and how to fix
problems if problems arise during the exercise and a demonstration of William's flexion
exercises, followed by a Q&A session, in the hope that Batik could perform these exercises
correctly, independently, and accurately to reduce back pain. Physical therapy was performed
by a team of 2 instructors and supported by 3 students studying D-III physical therapy
STikesBaiturrahim Jambi. They received a gift leaflet and demonstration to perform the
William's Bend exercise and increase understanding and awareness of the William's Bend
exercise to reduce back pain.[15]
o Conducted a study to check for the effectiveness of William Flexion Exercise method to decrease low
back pain level. Analysis of data from various databases (PubMed, Science Direct, Web of Science).
Searches related to the terms "low back pain associated with William's flexion" or "myogenic low back
pain and William's flexion" or Medical Summary (MESH) using multiple keywords along with medical
and "low income". Criteria for inclusion in articles were patients with myogenic back pain and all
clinical studies published in English between 2000 and 2021. The quality of the included studies was
assessed using CASP (Critical Appraisal Skills Programme). William flexion exercises may improve
function, reduce pain and effort, and improve quality of life in patients with low back pain; and this is
the Benefits of Physical Therapy Treatment for the Prevention of Myogenic Low Back Pain. Several
products were selected from our warehouse and each survey received an 80% quality score. Research
shows that a three-times-per-week exercise using techniques such as hamstring stretching, pelvic tilt,
knee-to-chest, and hip flexor stretching can improve performance, reduce pain and exertion, and
improve the quality of life of patients with back pain.The study concluded that the William’s flexion
exercise is effective method to reduce the level of low back pain.[20]
This study aimed to examine the reliability, validity, and magnitude of the Chinese version of
the ODI version 2.1 in a sample of 225 elderly orthopedic outpatients with low back pain
[mean age (SD): 40.7 (11.4) years].We conducted a reliability test, explanatory two-factor
analysis, validity analysis, and Moken test on the ODI. We used the Short Form 36 (SF-36)
and the Visual Analogy Scale (VAS) to validate the ODI.The ODI has good reliability,
discriminant and construct validity.The fit statistics of the ODI unidimensional model were
inadequate.ODI is the Mokken scale (Hs =0.31).The ODI is a reliable and valid tool for
assessing disability in patients with back pain.However, ODI appears to be highly variable,
which argues against the use of ODI raw score as a measure of disability.[21]
Conducted a study based on the principle that effective treatment must address the root cause
of symptoms. The NeuroHAB® 8-week exercise therapy is designed to correct dysfunction by
reactivating the central nervous system through movement based on spinopelvic skill
biomechanics for activities of daily living. . Over the 8 weeks, all participants hone their
skills, develop new preliminary training and improve biomechanics, work to reduce pain,
improve injury and increase performance, creating a foundation for further progress. The main
question of this study is "How does therapeutic exercise affect chronic back pain?" Subject
participants in 10 groups were randomly selected and recruited from the NeuroHAB® 8-
week service database for 2020. Two oswestry Disability Index (ODI) scores were recorded –
the first after the 8-week program and the second score after the NeuroHAB® intervention.
ODI scores were collected and pre- and post-study results were measured and compared
through a paired test to determine the significance of improvement. The results showed a two-
tailed P = 0.05; this shows that there is a significant difference between before and after data
(0.0024). Ø The mean ODI values of the group before and after the intervention were 25.80
and 13.30, respectively, with a difference of 12.50 (95% CI: 5.73~19.27); 48.4496% yes. The
results of this study support another hypothesis, concluding that an 8- week intervention with
physical therapy represented by NeuroHAB® leads to a reduction in LBP ODI scores.[22]
6.3 OBJECTIVES
To check the effectiveness of William’s Flexion Exercise for the treatment of Low Back Pain in
Elderly.
EXPERIMENTAL STUDY
3 Months
7.3 Does study require any investigations to be conducted on patients or other humans or
animals?
Yes
MATERIALS USED
Exercise mat
Goniometer
Marker
VAS scale
INCLUSION CRITERIA:
EXCLUSION CRITERIA:
IVDP
Spondylolisthesis
Spondylosis
Nerve root compression
Spinal surgeries
Spinal fractures
PROCEDURE:
30 subjects will be recruited based on inclusion and exclusion criteria. Subjects will be
explained about the Williams exercises that are to be performed. The following are the
exercises and written consent will be taken from the subject who will participate in the study.
EXERCISES
1. PELVIC TILT
The patient will lie on their back with their hands at their side and their knees bent
The patient will be then instructed to tighten the muscles of their abdomen as well as
buttocks by flattening their back against the floor
Hold for 2 to 3 minutes, relax
4. HAMSTRING STRETCH
The patient will lie on their back with hands on the side with one knee bent and the other
knee straight
The patient will be then asked to pull their foot of their straight leg towards himself, and
then asked to raise their leg till they feel the stretch at their back of the thigh
Hold for 2 to 3 minutes, relax.
5. SQUATTING
The patient will stand with feet just wider than hip width apart toes pointed slightly out,
clasp hands at their chest for balance, send hip, back and bend at knees to lower down as far
as possible with their chest lifted
They can swing their arms for momentum. Press through heels back up to explode up,
jumping vertically in the air
Hold for 2 to 3 minutes, relax.
6. SEATED LUMBAR FLEXION
The patient should sit in an upright chair
The patient is urged to slowly bend forward until they feel tension in their back
In contrast standing lumbar flexion starts exercise as follows
The patient should slowly bend forward sliding their hand down to their legs until they
feel tension in their back
Hold for 2 to 3 min, relax
The patient must do the above Exercises – 10 Repetitions for 10 to 20 min everyday and then advised
for follow up over a period of one week.
OUTCOME MEASURE
Visual Analogue Scale (VAS)
Lumbar Range of Motion
Oswestry disability index
STASTISTICAL ANALYSIS
The analysis is based on qualitative data descriptive statistics used to describe the data
To see the effect of William’s exercises for the treatment of patients with low back pain in
elderly we can use non parametric Wilcoxon Signed Rank test which is equal to parametric
t –test.
8. REFERENCES:
7. Lin CWC, Haas M, Maher CG, MacHado LAC, Van Tulder MW. Cost-
effectiveness of general practice care for low back pain: A systematic review. Eur Spine J.
2011;20(7):1012–23. https:// doi.org/10.1007/s00586-010-1675-4 PMid:212038908.
22. Brogan Samuel Williams1, David Johnson2, Low Back Pain Oswestry Disability Index
changes Following 8-week movement proficiency exercise program-A retrospective study,
1Department of Sports Science, The Strength Science Clinic, Auckland,New Zealand,
Department of NeurosurgeryCity to Coast Neurosurgery,Brisbane,Australia,Published-30th
May 2023,Available from brogan.s.williams@gmail.com, DOI
Oswestry disability index
0.32892/JMRI.290.
ANNEXURE
INFORMED CONSENT FORM FOR SUBJECTS
Title
Subjects consent;
I Mr / Miss / Mrs....................................................................agree to participate in the study.
I have understood the procedure of the study and explained to me by the investigator of the
study. This study will help the health care professional to know about the extent of difficulty
faced by the patients.
Investigator: Date:
I confirm that Mr. Rajat has explained me the purpose of this research, the study procedure
and the possible risks and benefits associated that I may experience. I have read and
understood the consent form let myself participate as a subject in this research project and I
am giving the consent wilfully.
Subject: Date:
Signature of witness:
I have been made aware of the purpose for this study. I understand that I have to co-operate
with the researcher for this study and a copy of the consent form has been given to me for
my reference.
Place: