Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 33

Development of an Index Equation

For training purposes only. Copyright © 2016 Boeing. May be subject to export restrictions under EAR. See title page for details B-1
Index Equation Development

• When loading an airplane, summation of


moments is necessary to determine the net
center of gravity for the loaded airplane
• An Index Equation is used to simplify the
presentation of moment data on the loading
schedule
• Index is moment scaled to a convenient
magnitude that is easy to add and subtract
based on a scale which is typically offset such
that all index values are positive
• To convert from a scale of %MAC to Index, an
index equation must be developed

For training purposes only. Copyright © 2016 Boeing. May be subject to export restrictions under EAR. See title page for details B-2
Index Equation Development
Z

Balance Arm

Convert all inflection


points to weight and
X moment, instead of wt
Airplane Reference System and %MAC, then re-plot
as shown on next page…

Moment = Weight x Balance Arm

%MAC = B.A. - LEMAC (100)


MAC

Rearrange, solving for B.A.

B.A. = %MAC MAC + LEMAC


100
(known from WBM Section 1-00-xxx)
For training purposes only. Copyright © 2016 Boeing. May be subject to export restrictions under EAR. See title page for details B-3
Index Equation Development

Moment = Weight x Balance Arm


Result of graphing certified C.G.
limits as wt versus moment
Z

Balance Arm

Certified

WEIGHT
Limits

X
Airplane Reference System

Using the airplane datum as the


datum for moment calculations on
the load sheet produces very large 0.0E+00 2.0E+08 4.0E+08 6.0E+08 8.0E+08 1.0E+09

numbers, and results in a C.G. MOMENT

grid that is skewed aft


For training purposes only. Copyright © 2016 Boeing. May be subject to export restrictions under EAR. See title page for details B-4
Index Equation Development
Step 1: Select a new datum about which to calculate moments

Moment = Weight x (Balance Arm - Datum Balance Arm)


∆ Arm
Z
Datum Balance Arm

Balance Arm Arm

WEIGHT
MAC = 0% 100%

X
Airplane Reference System

This step centers and opens up the


envelope, but we would like to -3.0E+07 -2.0E+07 -1.0E+07 0.0E+00 1.0E+07 2.0E+07 3.0E+07
work with smaller values than MOMENT
those on this moment scale
For training purposes only. Copyright © 2016 Boeing. May be subject to export restrictions under EAR. See title page for details B-5
?? What was that previous step ??
Remember Calculating Moments and Determining CG Location?

Distance
- + from 100 kg
datum 50 kg
Chosen beam wt = 20 kg
Reference
Datum 2
5 .9
D
5.9
8
Weight is
(Moment about reference datum
positive
= wt x dist. from datum)
down
weight 1 = 50 moment 1 = 50 x 2 = 100
weight 2 = 20 moment 2 = 20 x 5 = 100
weight 3 = 100 moment 3 = 100 x 8 = 800
Total weight = 170 Total moment = 1000

balance location = total moment = 1000 / 170


total weight = 5.9 (or .9 to the right of the beam center)
For training purposes only. Copyright © 2016 Boeing. May be subject to export restrictions under EAR. See title page for details B-6
Also, remember that we could calculate
moments about any selected datum?
4 New
Distance
selected
- + from 100 kg
datum datum
50 kg
Original
Chosen beam wt = 20 kg
Reference
Datum 2
5 .9
D
5.9
8
Weight is
positive (Moment about NEW reference datum
down = wt x dist. from NEW datum)
weight 1 = 50 moment 1 = 50 x (2 – 4) = - 100
weight 2 = 20 moment 2 = 20 x (5 – 4) = 20
weight 3 = 100 moment 3 = 100 x (8 – 4) = 400
Total weight = 170 Total moment = 320

balance location = total moment = 320 / 170


total weight = 1.9 (or .9 to the right of the beam center)
For training purposes only. Copyright © 2016 Boeing. May be subject to export restrictions under EAR. See title page for details B-7
Index Equation Development
Step 1: Select a new datum about which to calculate moments
(same concept as previous example)
Moment = Weight x (Balance Arm - Datum Balance Arm)
∆ Arm
Z
Datum Balance Arm

Balance Arm Arm

WEIGHT
MAC = 0% 100%

X
Airplane Reference System

This step centers and opens up the


envelope, but we would like to -3.0E+07 -2.0E+07 -1.0E+07 0.0E+00 1.0E+07 2.0E+07 3.0E+07
work with smaller values than MOMENT
those on this moment scale
For training purposes only. Copyright © 2016 Boeing. May be subject to export restrictions under EAR. See title page for details B-8
Index Equation Development
Step 2: Divide moment by a constant to reduce magnitudes

Index = Weight x (Balance Arm - Datum Balance Arm)


Moment Constant
Moment
=
Moment Constant

This step provides more

WEIGHT
manageable numbers by
creating an ‘index’. Still have
‘+’ and ‘-’ values. Would like
to deal just with ‘+” values.

-100 -80 -60 -40 -20 0 20 40 60 80 100


INDEX

For training purposes only. Copyright © 2016 Boeing. May be subject to export restrictions under EAR. See title page for details B-9
Index Equation Development
Step 3: Add a constant to create only positive index values

Index = Weight x (Balance Arm - Datum Balance Arm) Datum


+
Moment Constant Constant

WEIGHT
Datum
This last step provides a Constant
convenient form for use in
a load sheet

-100 -80 -60 -40 -20 0 20 40 60 80 100


INDEX
For training purposes only. Copyright © 2016 Boeing. May be subject to export restrictions under EAR. See title page for details B-10
Index Equation Development

• Final form of the index equation:

Index = Weight x (Balance Arm - Datum Balance Arm) Datum


+
Moment Constant Constant

• This form of the index equation is only used for


calculating absolute index values
• Generally, the dry operating index of the airplane
and the C.G. limit vertices are the only index
values that must be determined using this form
of the equation

For training purposes only. Copyright © 2016 Boeing. May be subject to export restrictions under EAR. See title page for details B-11
Index Equation Development

To convert the C.G. limit vertices found in the


WBM from %MAC to Index:

B.A. = %MAC * MAC + LEMAC


100

Index = Weight x (B.A. - Datum Balance Arm) + Datum


Moment Constant Constant

For training purposes only. Copyright © 2016 Boeing. May be subject to export restrictions under EAR. See title page for details B-12
Quiz
Assume: MAC = 155.8 IN Datum B.A. = 658.3 IN.
LEMAC = 627.1 IN. Moment Constant = 80000 LB-IN
Datum Constant = 45.0

1) Weight = 138500 LB; CG = 5.0% MAC


Convert from %MAC to Index
5.0 (138500)(634.9 – 658.3)
B.A. = (155.8) + 627.1 Index = + 45.0
100 80000
= 634.9 IN. = 4.5

2) Weight = 156000 LB; CG = 36.0% MAC


Convert from %MAC to Index
36.0 (156000)(683.2 – 658.3)
B.A. = (155.8) + 627.1 Index = + 45.0
100 80000
= 683.2 IN. = 93.6

For training purposes only. Copyright © 2016 Boeing. May be subject to export restrictions under EAR. See title page for details B-13
Example
Conversion
from %MAC
to Index

737-800 Certified C.G.


limits from WBM
(weight versus C.G.
in %MAC)
MAC = 155.8 IN.
LEMAC = 627.1 IN.

For training purposes only. Copyright © 2016 Boeing. May be subject to export restrictions under EAR. See title page for details B-14
Example Conversion from %MAC to Index
BALANCE
WEIGHT ARM
(LB) %MAC (IN.) INDEX

80000 5.0 634.9 21.6


138500 5.0 634.9 4.5
143425 6.0 636.4 5.7
144000 6.1 636.6 5.9
173000 12.0 645.8 18.0
Calculated
174700 16.8 653.3 34.1
in Quiz
174700 25.5 666.8 63.6
173000 31.0 675.4 82.0
156000 36.0 683.2 93.6
144000 36.0 683.2 89.8
136000 36.0 683.2 87.3
105000 36.0 683.2 77.7
80000 32.3 677.4 64.1
80000 6.0 636.4 23.1
136000 6.0 636.4 7.9

Assume Index equation based on: Datum Balance Arm = 658.3 IN.
Moment Constant = 80000 LB-IN.
Datum Constant = 45.0
For training purposes only. Copyright © 2016 Boeing. May be subject to export restrictions under EAR. See title page for details B-15
180000 174700 174700
34.0 63.6
173000 173000
18.0 82.0
170000

Example 160000 143425


5.7 156000
Conversion 93.6

150000
from %MAC 144000 144000

GROSS WEIGHT (LB)


5.9 89.8
to Index 140000
136000
138500
4.5
136000
7.9 87.3

130000

737-800 Certified 120000

C.G. limits from


110000
WBM converted to
105000
weight versus Index 77.7
100000
(based on chosen
index equation)
90000
80000 80000 80000
21.6 23.1 64.1
80000
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
INDEX B-16
For training purposes only. Copyright © 2016 Boeing. May be subject to export restrictions under EAR. See title page for details
Example Conversion from %MAC to Index

Further, assume:
Dry Operating Weight = 100,000 LB
C.G. = 19.0 %MAC
Same Index equation: Datum Balance Arm = 658.3 IN.
Moment Constant = 80000 LB-IN.
Datum Constant = 45.0
MAC = 155.8 IN.
LEMAC = 627.1 IN.

19.0
B.A. = (155.8) + 627.1 = 656.7 IN.
100

Index = (100000)(656.7 – 658.3) + 45.0 = 43.0


80000

For training purposes only. Copyright © 2016 Boeing. May be subject to export restrictions under EAR. See title page for details B-17
180000 174700 174700
34.0 63.6
173000 173000
18.0 82.0
170000

Example 160000 143425


5.7 156000

Conversion 150000
93.6

from %MAC to 144000 144000

GROSS WEIGHT (LB)


5.9 138500 89.8
Index 140000
136000
4.5
136000
7.9 87.3

130000

120000
737-800 Certified
C.G. limits from
110000
WBM converted to 105000
weight versus Index 100000 77.7
100000
(based on chosen
index equation) with

43.0
90000
a Dry Operating 80000 80000 80000
Weight C.G. plotted 80000
21.6 23.1 64.1

on the envelope 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100


INDEX
For training purposes only. Copyright © 2016 Boeing. May be subject to export restrictions under EAR. See title page for details B-18
Index Equation Development

The change in Index due to loaded items (e.g.


passengers, crew, cargo, fuel, etc.) is calculated
with the following form of the index equation:

Index = Weight x (Balance Arm - Datum Balance Arm)


Moment Constant

** No datum constant is required when calculating ∆index


values because the constant drops out of the calculation

For training purposes only. Copyright © 2016 Boeing. May be subject to export restrictions under EAR. See title page for details B-19
Quiz
Aircraft Dry Operating Weight
327,000 Pounds (lb) at B.A. 1239.5 Inches (in)

Load Item
5,000 Pounds (lb) of Cargo at B.A. 770.0 Inches (in)

Index Equation Variables


Datum Balance Arm: 1258.0 Inches (in)
Moment Constant: 400,000 Pound-Inches (lb-in)
Datum Constant: 50 Index Units (I.U.)

1. Calculate aircraft’s Dry Operating Index (DOI)


2. Calculate index change for loaded item
3. Calculate resultant index when loaded item
is added to aircraft

For training purposes only. Copyright © 2016 Boeing. May be subject to export restrictions under EAR. See title page for details B-20
Quiz

1. Calculate aircraft’s Dry Operating index

Weight x (Balance Arm - Datum Balance Arm) Datum


Index =
Moment Constant
+ Constant

327,000 lb x (1239.5 in - 1258.0 in)


Index =
400,000 lb-in
+ 50 I.U.

Index = (-15.1 I.U.) + 50 I.U. = 34.9 Index Units

For training purposes only. Copyright © 2016 Boeing. May be subject to export restrictions under EAR. See title page for details B-21
Quiz
2. Calculate index change for loaded item

Index = Weight x (Balance Arm - Datum Balance Arm)


Moment Constant

Index = 5,000 lb x (770.0 in - 1258.0 in)


400,000 lb-in

Index = -6.1 Index Units

3. Calculate resultant index when loaded item


is added to aircraft

Aircraft Dry Operating Index: 34.9 Index Units


Load Item Index: +(-6.1) Index Units
Resultant: 28.8 Index Units
For training purposes only. Copyright © 2016 Boeing. May be subject to export restrictions under EAR. See title page for details B-22
Calculation Check

Calculation Check:
Item Weight B.A. Moment
DOW: 327,000 lb 1239.5 in 405316500 lb-in
Load Item: +5,000 lb 770.0 in +3850000 lb-in
[a]
Resultant: 332,000 lb 1232.4 in 409166500 lb-in
[a] Resultant B.A. = (Resultant Moment)/(Resultant Weight)

332,000 lb x (1232.4 in - 1258.0 in)


Index = + 50 I.U. = 28.8 Index Units
400,000 lb-in

The
Same
Result

For training purposes only. Copyright © 2016 Boeing. May be subject to export restrictions under EAR. See title page for details B-23
Choosing Index Equation Variables

• What should you select for your index equation


constants?
– Select values that create the desired CG
envelope look and scale
– Once the constants have been selected they
must also be used for all index and ∆ index
calculations that are going to be associated
with the CG envelope

For training purposes only. Copyright © 2016 Boeing. May be subject to export restrictions under EAR. See title page for details B-24
Choosing Index Equation Variables
Choice of Datum Balance Arm affects shape of certified limits

“Skewed Forward”
Datum B.A. > Mid Point

DBA = 44.0 %MAC

WEIGHT
-100 -80 -60 -40 -20 0 20 40 60 80 100
INDEX
For training purposes only. Copyright © 2016 Boeing. May be subject to export restrictions under EAR. See title page for details B-25
Choosing Index Equation Variables
Choice of Datum Balance Arm affects shape of certified limits

“Skewed Aft”
Datum B.A. < Mid Point
DBA = 14.0 %MAC

WEIGHT
-100 -80 -60 -40 -20 0 20 40 60 80 100
INDEX
For training purposes only. Copyright © 2016 Boeing. May be subject to export restrictions under EAR. See title page for details B-26
Choosing Index Equation Variables
Choice of Datum Balance Arm affects shape of certified limits

“Balanced”
Datum B.A. ~ Mid Point
DBA = 30.0 %MAC

WEIGHT
-100 -80 -60 -40 -20 0 20 40 60 80 100
INDEX
For training purposes only. Copyright © 2016 Boeing. May be subject to export restrictions under EAR. See title page for details B-27
Choosing Index Equation Variables

Moment Constant Controls Index Scale

Weight x (Arm - 1258.0 in) Weight x (Arm - 1258.0 in)


Index = + 50 I.U. Index = + 600 I.U.
500,000 lb-in 60,000 lb-in

WEIGHT
WEIGHT

0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100 100 200 300 400 500 600 700 800 900 1000
INDEX INDEX

For training purposes only. Copyright © 2016 Boeing. May be subject to export restrictions under EAR. See title page for details B-28
Choosing Index Equation Variables
Datum Constant chosen large enough to create CG
envelope based only on positive index values

WEIGHT DC

-100 -80 -60 -40 -20 0 20 40 60 80 100


INDEX

For training purposes only. Copyright © 2016 Boeing. May be subject to export restrictions under EAR. See title page for details B-29
Typical Boeing Selected Datum BA,
Moment Constant, & Datum Constant
Datum Datum Moment Moment
BA BA Constant Constant Datum
Model (IN) (% MAC) (LB-IN) (KG-IN) Constant
737-1/2/3/4/500 648.5 17.0 65000 30000 40.0
737-600/700/700C 658.3 20.0 70000 30000 45.0
737-800/900 658.3 20.0 80000 35000 45.0
747-400 1323.6 20.0 725000 300000 50.0
747-8 1323.6 20.0 725000 300000 40.0
757-200/200F 1037.8 23.0 165000 70000 50.0
757-300 1037.8 23.0 175000 80000 55.0
767-200 972.6 25.0 250000 100000 55.0
767-300/300F 972.6 25.0 300000 120000 55.0
767-400ER 972.6 25.0 350000 150000 55.0
777-
200/200ER/200LR/F
1258.0 30.0 500000 200000 50.0
777-300/300ER 1258.0 30.0 700000 300000 50.0
787-8 1079.2 20.0 400000 200000 50.0
787-9 1199.2 20.0 400000 200000 50.0
For training purposes only. Copyright © 2016 Boeing. May be subject to export restrictions under EAR. See title page for details B-30
Reverse Engineer Index Equation
Determine Datum Balance Arm and Datum Constant by
locating the %MAC line perpendicular to the index axis
Datum B.A. = %MAC x MAC + LEMAC
100
If B.A. = DBA then:
%MAC

∆Index = WT (B.A. – DBA) =0


MC

Datum Constant
WEIGHT

Index = WT (B.A. – DBA) + DC


MC

DC is the index value where


perpendicular %MAC line intersects
the index scale (it is the amount the
scale has been shifted relative to zero)

0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
INDEX

For training purposes only. Copyright © 2016 Boeing. May be subject to export restrictions under EAR. See title page for details B-31
Reverse Engineer Index Equation
Determine moment constant by selecting a
point on a non-vertical %MAC line (a %MAC
that is not the datum balance arm)
(Weight 1) x (B.A. 1 - Datum B.A.)
Moment Constant =
(Index 1 – Datum Constant)
%MAC 1

Point 1
Weight 1
WEIGHT

%MAC 1
B.A. 1 = * MAC + LEMAC
100

INDEX Index 1

For training purposes only. Copyright © 2016 Boeing. May be subject to export restrictions under EAR. See title page for details B-32
End of
Development of an Index Equation

For training purposes only. Copyright © 2016 Boeing. May be subject to export restrictions under EAR. See title page for details B-33

You might also like