Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Allen Indonesia's
Allen Indonesia's
gration program has been resettling some shifting cul- tion is the responsibility of the State Forest Enterprise.
tivators (Rao and Chandrasekharan 1983). In Java, provincial forest management is under the su-
pervision of the State Forest Enterprise. On'the other
islands, forest management is carried out by private or
Education and Research joint-venture companies through government con-
Professional forestry education is provided by the tracts and concessions.
Ministry of Education by eight public universities. The All forest organizations in Indonesia are under the
yearly output of these universities is approximately control of the Directorate General of Forestry. Man-
200 (BS) graduate foresters; total enrollment is about agement activities are carried out by the Directorate of
600 students. All of these universities require a min- Forest Inventory and Planning, the Directorate of
imum four-year curriculum, and some require up to Forest Management, the Directorate of Marketing and
six years for the BS degree. All students, including un- Distribution of Forest Products, and the State Forest
dergraduates, are required to complete a thesis, and Enterprise.
graduates are granted the title of Forest Engineer. Indonesian forest management is based on the In-
Graduate programs are offered at Bogor Agricultural donesian selective cutting system. This cutting system
University and Gajahmada University, but many In- specifies a minimum felling limit of 50 cm DBH, re-
donesians pursue graduate education at foreign uni- tention of at least 25 trees of 3 0 - 3 5 cm DBH/ha
versities, especially in the United States, Japan, and yielding future commercial value, and enrichment
Canada. A master's degree program in Indonesia plantings in logged-over areas. Despite the policy es-
usually requires an additional two years of study, and a tablished by the selective cutting system, some 200,000
program leading to the PhD lasts 3 - 4 years (Lantican ha of forest are still being destroyed annually by addi-
and del Castillo 1982). tional tree felling that occurs with shifting cultivation
Short vocational programs are available at several (Djarwo 1983.
training centers organized by the State Forest Enter- Forest mangement shows a great diversity in Indo-
prise. At the technical level a three-year program is nesia; Java and Madura are intensely managed for
offered by the Academy of Forestry at Bandung, West forest production, forest management is moderately
Java. In addition, two international centers contribute intense on Sumatra and Celebes, and it is just devel-
to forest manpower development: the Regional Center oping on the other islands. T h e harvesting and mar-
for Tropical Biology (BIOTROP) and the Southeast keting of teak (Tectona grandis) is carried out by the
Asian Regional Center for Agriculture (SEARCA). State Forest Enterprise. Utilization of the teak forest is
The three government forest research institutes are well regulated, and most teak harvesting is accom-
located in Bogor, West Java. Research is carried out by plished manually, owing to the abundance of labor on
the Forest Research Institute, the Forest Products Re- Java. The harvesting and planting of nonteak species,
search Institite, and the Forest Engineering Research especially outside of Java, is carried out by private con-
Institute. Most of the forestry research is directed at tractors, who are mostly concession holders using
developing management and silvicultural systems. large-scale, mechanized logging. Waterways are the
Current research is in the areas of watershed manage- most important means of log transportation outside
ment, forest plantings in logged-over areas, utilization Java.
of waste timber, and forest operations. Intensity of forest management is evident from the
Wildlife management in Indonesia is the responsi- amount of existing forest road network used to trans-
bility of the Directorate of Natural and Wildlife Con- port logs and other forest products. Java and Madura
servation. About 3.4 million ha of natural reserves, 4.2 have the closest network, with road spacing 30 times
million ha of wildlife areas, and 400,000 ha of recre- closer than on the other islands.
ational areas were established by 1980. Natural re-
serves are fully protected from exploitation; however, Forest Production and Industries
wildlife areas may be logged (Myers 1980).
Indonesian forest product industries are still devel-
oping. With over 2700 million m 3 of standing com-
Ownership and Administration
mercial timber, Indonesia could biologically sustain a
All forests in Indonesia are nationally owned and potential annual yield of 50 million m 3. The main
managed at the provincial level (Sebire 1980b). Several product of the forest is logs, either for domestic use or
government agencies share the administration of the for conversion into processed wood products for ex-
public forest. On the national level, forest administra- port. Indonesia's forest industry i s primarily con-
756 R.C. Allen and others
5O
og & Veneer Log Production
~ 20 ~_ 6 Sow
i i i i i i i I i i i
-~ 2 ~ Production/
1972 1974 1976 1978 1980 1982 = "-----.-/- sownwood /" I~'~
= Export,~..~_Z.~xZ~_._~---
YEAR
t---1---t"--~_--~-----d v'" , expl~ ,
Figure 2l Sawlog and veneer log production and log exports,
1972 1974 1976 1978 1980 t982
Indonesia, 1972-1983. From FAO (1985). YEAR
Figure 3. Production and export of sawnwood and plywood,
cerned with increasing plywood production, but also Indonesia, 1972-1983. From FAO (1985).
includes sawmilling, particle board, furniture parts,
and pulp and paper. T h e local people also collect
minor forest products, such as rattan, resin, and naval domestic wood-processing industries by ensuring a
stores. constant supply of essential raw materials. Figure 3
The Indonesian policy on the utilization of the shows the dramatic impact of the new policy on sawn-
forest has two major thrusts. First, log exports were wood and plywood exports.
deliberately phased out (ended completely on 1 Jan- In 1984, the new government regulations decreed a
uary 1985), with the maximum domestic processing of dramatic cutback in log exports (limited to 6 million
logs being encouraged. The overall objective is to en- ma/yr), and in 1985 log exports were banned. The
sure that 60% of all log production will be processed volume of sawn timber exports increased over 25%
domestically (Djarwo 1983). Figure 2 illustrates the annually from 1975 to 1979. In 1980 sawn timber ex-
sharp decline in both log production and export since ports declined 7% to only 1200 thousand m 3 (FAO
1978. Government policy favors increased supplies of 1985). This decline was caused by a sharp reduction in
domestically processed timber to meet needs for devel- demand from Italy and Singapore. The most signifi-
oping procured products markets. Second, a massive cant markets for Indonesian sawn timber are Italy,
reforestation and conservation program is in effect. Singapore, Malaysia, Japan, and Taiwan (during
Logged forest areas and areas deforested by shifting 1975-1980 they accounted for over three-quarters of
cultivation are being planted, and forest areas repre- sawn timber exports).
senting various natural ecosystems are being pre- The Indonesian plywood industry began in 1973.
served. The goal is to maximize biological forest pro- Plywood production increased from 9000 m 3 in 1973
ductivity while considering the social impact of the to 3.1 million m 3 in 1983 (FAO 1985). Despite devel-
forest, especially the development of rural communi- opment problems, particularly in regard to infrastruc-
ties adjacent to the forest (Djarwo 1983). ture, the plywood industry has been steadily growing
As of January 1981, Indonesian timber concessions since it began exporting in mid-1975. About 70% of
had been granted for 47 million ha of forest land. plywood production in the mid-1970s was consumed
About 90% of the total forest area authorized for com- domestically, but by 1982 plywood exports accounted
mercial timber production has been opened up for for over half of production. The plywood exports now
logging operations through direct forest concessions. exceed national consumption, and a constant effort is
The remainder has been exploited via a system of gov- being exerted to utilize a greater amount of less well-
ernment levies on forest production. known species available in the Indonesian forest. The
The severe decline in production, starting in 1978, industry expects a gradual expansion in the variety of
was mainly due to new government regulations aimed products introduced into the market.
at reducing the volume of log exports. Industrial Indonesia produces about 57% of the paper
roundwood production was in the 2 5 - 3 0 million m 3 needed for domestic consumption, so there is ample
range during the late 1970s. By 1983, it was down to opportunity for foreign capital investment in devel-
just over 8 million m 3 (FAO 1985). The intent of the oping Indonesia's pulp and paper industry. Indo-
new regulations is to encourage the development of nesia currently imports substantial amounts of pulp,
domestic wood-processing industries, obtain a higher and the establishment of large-scale pulp and paper
and more stable price for timber exports, and aid the mills has been given a high priority by the central
Indonesia's Developing Forest Industry 757
government. In 1983 paper and paperboard produc- tion range from two to six years for priority projects.
tion was 374,000 t, paper and paperboard imports Investments in pulp and paper mills qualify for the
were 277,000 t, and 157,000 t of wood pulp was im- maximum tax holiday of six years. Exemptions from
ported (FAO 1985). dividend taxes and stamp duty, investment allowances,
Some pulp and paper capacity is in place in the and accelerated depreciation are also available.
country. Lontar Papyrus Paper Industry was estab- Second, the entry of all fixed assets, such as machinery
lished in 1974 in the Aceh province. It is staffed by and equipment for operation of the enterprise, is ex-
Indonesian and Taiwanese technicians, with equip- empt from import duties. Third, profits can be trans-
ment from Taiwan and West Germany. Raw material, ferred abroad in foreign currency at the current ex-
in the form of boxed pulp, is imported from Scandi- change rate in proportion to the shareholding of the
navia, Canada, and the United States. Integrated foreign participant, allowances for depreciation, and
wood-processing projects are planned for East Kali- proceeds from the sale of shares of Indonesian partici-
mantan. These projects include pulp and paper mills. pants. Fourth, the investor is required to train Indon-
Indonesia had 34 pulp and paper mills in 1978, and esian personnel gradually to take over the manage-
this number increased to 51 in 1983. From 1978 to ment, but has full authority to determine his own
1983, paper and paperboard capacity increased from management and to use foreign managerial and tech-
284 to 877 t, and pulp capacity increased from 148 to nical employees not available in Indonesia.
300 t. Djarwo (1983) describes the four phases to the ap-
plication procedure: preapplication, application-eval-
uation, project licensing, and project implementation.
Forest Industry Investment Policy
Preapplication calls for potential investors to deter-
The Indonesian government offers a wide range of mine which industrial sectors are open for investment
incentives and guarantees to investors in priority areas. and which attract incentives. Applications to Indo-
Priority is given to labor-intensive industries, indus- nesia' Investment Coordinating Board are evaluated
tries that generate significant foreign exchange for compliance with government investment policy
earnings from exports, and industries that will locate and priority, and if they are in compliance with policy,
in underdeveloped areas. Investments in pulp and they are granted provisional approval. After the re-
paper mills have the highest investment priority in the quired information is furnished to the board, and
forestry sector. The types of products envisaged in- after presidential approval is obtained, a "permanent
clude pulp, paper, and Kraft paperboard. The gov- letter of approval" is issued by the board. The letter of
ernment has specified the locations of potential raw approval allows the investor to procure the required
materials: Aceh, North Sumatra, Palembang, South licenses (import and purchasing licenses, a letter of
Sumatra, Sungai Kayan, East Kalimantan, Central Ka- credit from Bank Indonesia, an import clearance
limantan, South Kalimantan, Cilacap, Central Java, permit, permanent operating license, and regional li-
and West Java. censes). Once the project is implemented, a project re-
These raw materials include pine (Pin~s merhusii), port is required every six months and the Investment
mixed tropical hardwoods, mangrove, and other vari- Coordinating Board must approve all project changes
eties. Investment allowances are provided for expan- and modifications.
sion or product diversification of ordinary paper, spe-
cialty paper, building paper, and roofing paper plants.
All foreign investments must be undertaken
Operational Realities
through joint ventures with an Indonesian partner. The brief description of Indonesian investment
The choice of the investor's Indonesian partner will policy above summarized official central government
have a major effect on the success of the venture. A policy, but ignored several "real life" impediments to
joint-venture company engaged in an integrated profitable investment. The operational realities of any
project may conduct logging operations as a contractor government policy often differ from official pro-
of the concessionnaire. This policy was adopted to en- nouncements.
sure a continuous supply of raw material for the in- The central government control over provincial
dustry. The holder of the forest concession must be and local government policies, regulations, and restric-
the Indonesian participant. tions is loose. This is especially true in the provinces
T h e r e are four main benefits granted by the central remote from the island of Java, where most of the
government available to priority projects. First, there available timber is located. Local customs officials can
are tax advantages. Tax holidays from corporate taxa- impose constant roadblocks, slowing the import of
758 R.C. Allen and others
needed tools, machinery, operational supplies, and the per mile is not an unusual cost for main-line, all-rock,
personal effects of employees. In many instances, all-weather logging road construction.
much needed equipment, the personal effects of man- Theft of timber near rivers and streams has de-
agers, and the supplies necessary to keep an operation pleted the cheapest logging sites. Costly constant sur-
productive are held for months in customs yards or veillance is necessary. Helicopter patrol is usually the
warehouses awaiting assessment of duties, paperwork, only effective means to patrol a large concession with
and payment of "expediting fees" for release. numerous waterways.
Local immigration officials, provincial governors, Investors in Indonesian forest industry are ex-
city mayors, army officials, and village chiefs can pected to develop and finance programs of reforesta-
hinder an effective operation. At the provincial or tion through plantings of logged forest areas, usually
local level one can expect red tape, paperwork, extra to pine. Brush or hardwood competition is usually
local taxes and duties, expediting payments to local controlled immediately around the planted seedling by
customs personnel, and travel restrictions. Besides the hand labor using machetes. However, shifting cultiva-
numerous licenses and permits required at the na- tion often moves into logged areas and makes planta-
tional level, five main regional licenses are required: a tions difficult to establish or maintain as forest.
location approval license, a right to buy or lease the Lastly, while the central government insists on pro-
land, a building permit, an industrial permit, and a cessing plants, many obstacles can be expected to im-
land certificate. pede this requirement. T h e same local government re-
Tax and customs duty holidays only pertain to cen- straints and regulations apply to processing plant
tral government levies. Local taxes and customs duties operations as to logging operations--plus the added
far exceed central government aid. All forests in Indo- problem of training Indonesian labor to safely operate
nesia are publicly owned, and are managed by the pro- dangerous and complicated converting equipment.
vincial governments, and this presents a major impedi- These demands have resulted in many concession-
ment to forest resource development. aires' terminating operations in Indonesia. The gap
The "freedom to manage" guaranteed by the cen- caused by the exodus of concessionaires is being filled
tral government can be diminished by restrictions and by Chinese investors (Guppy 1984).
regulations that delay or make this authority costly.
The investor, Indonesian partner, and the govern-
ment may differ on the qualifications and training
schedule of Indonesian personnel. Also, joint-venture
companies must market their product through a local
Summary
distributor, which results in a major markup if there is Indonesia continues to be a large exporter of trop-
competition from a domestic company. The loose re- ical hardwood. T h e country's goal to establish inte-
lationship between the central and local governments grated wood industries, utilizing millions of cubic
often makes the application procedure more lengthy meters of raw material and wood wastes, has produced
and costly. a major change in its forest products exports, indo-
A prospective investor should carefully investigate nesia has eliminated sawlog exports. In 1978, Indo-
employment policies dealing with work permits, nesia accounted for one-half of Asia's hardwood
training, labor agreements, and employer responsi- sawlog exports. By 1983, Indonesia accounted for 13%
bility. In practice, the employer assumes full responsi- of Asian hardwood sawlog exports. However, over the
bility for health, food, shelter, transportation, and same period, hardwood sawnwood exports (as a per-
well-being of his employees. centage of Asia's total), increased from 13% to 21%,
The forests of Indonesia are extensive, but the most and plywood exports increased from 6% to 38%.
accessible and desirable concessions are made to local From 1978 to 1983, domestic paper and paperboard
and national officials (particularly army generals). production more than doubled. Indonesia's invest-
Construction and maintenance of road systems will be ment policies have increased the domestic processing
a major cost requirement for pulp and paper invest- of forest products. While high-priority investments
ment. Roads are nonexistent and heavy rainfall often enjoy many benefits, there are operational problems in
makes rock roads necessary for log transport. Suitable implementing central government incentive policies.
rock quarries are difficult to find and develop, and Certainly, Indonesia's abundant tropical forests should
usually are located several miles from main-line log- guarantee long-term opportunities to develop a forest
ging road locations. Fifteen to twenty thousand dollars industry base.
Indonesia's DeveLoping Forest Industry 759