Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Reading Comprehension Test
Reading Comprehension Test
Reading Comprehension Test
COMPRESSION TEST
YO. GENERAL DATA
Instrument name: Tapia & Silva Reading Comprehension Test
Authors: Violeta Tapia Mendieta & Maritza Silva Alejos
Year: 1982
Aim: Measure general reading comprehension ability
expressed in specific sub-skills.
Areas:
Fact Information: Items
Definition of Meaning
Definition of Meaning
Identification of the central idea of the text
Interpretation of facts
Inference about the author
Inference about the content of the fragment
Label
Addressed to: Students from 12 to 20 years old who attend
Secondary Education and I Cycle of Higher
Education
Reading constitutes one of the basic instruments of school learning; this is how its
optimal development makes better academic performance possible. It is
considered an essential pillar for the acquisition of knowledge and also enables an
understanding and interpretation of the world.
In our context, during the 40s and 50s the school was oriented towards reading
and then abandoned us to memorization. The school of 1970 made an attempt to
develop the “critical spirit” but without developing optimal methodologies that could
achieve this objective, contenting itself with emphasizing that it was necessary for
the child to analyze not only the texts he read but also his source of inspiration;
that is, the social context that produced them. However, neither in one case nor in
the other was the effort of the educational task oriented towards the development
of the “scholar's thinking” (Rosales, 1984, cited by Grimaldo, 1998).
Reading in and of itself is meaningless. Its reason depends on the value it takes on
the life of a people. It is not simply about learning or teaching to read, but
discovering how through reading the written and spoken word acquires its strength.
Learning to read is learning to say your word (Parent, Esquivel & Heras, 1997,
cited by Grimaldo,1998).
In addition, reading stimulates thought and creativity processes, allows the
assimilation of a greater amount of verbal information and enables maximum
organization of the information.
Allende (1990) points out that the most important functions of language constitute:
the appellative, expressive and representative functions. These three functions
take on their own modalities in reading. This is how from them you can understand
the importance of reading for personal and social life. (Cited by Grimaldo, 1998).
The appellative function uses the imperative mood and in the various ways of
giving orders or indications. It is found in every written text, which asks the reader
to develop their reading activity. Allende (1990) also points out that some texts
perform normative, interactional, instrumental and heuristic functions. (Cited by
Grimaldo, 1998).
The expressive function constitutes the influence of reading on the emotional and
imaginative world of the reader. Halliday (cited by Grimaldo, 1998), refers to
personal and imaginative functions.
The representative function refers to the transmission of cultural heritage and is
reflected in most educational texts. Allende (1990, cited by Grimaldo, 1998) also
points out another function called metalinguistics, which refers to the ability of the
language to refer to itself. Here we find the lexical, orthographic and
morphosyntactic functions.
Within the ways of reading we find formative reading, which seeks to awaken
questioning, analysis and confrontation in the reader; and the informative one,
which tries to provide general information on various economic, social, cultural,
political, artistic aspects, among others.
In addition to these forms, there are other types of reading, such as: research,
structural and analytical reading, which is the most complete and comprehensive.
The interpretive and/or synthetic, whose objective is communication between the
author and the reader through a common language; and critical and/or
evolutionary, whose purpose is to enable the reader to make a judgment about the
reading or the reality being judged. This reading demands complete information,
analysis and impartiality of judgment.
The habit of reading is an acquired ability that predisposes the subject to reading,
but it is important to note that in this acquisition process there are agents or factors
that sometimes favor, and in others, constitute an obstacle to its development. The
most important are considered to be: home, school, community, socioeconomic
situation and other factors such as the environment, type of school, sex and
personal interest.
Tapia & Silva (1982) point out that the test development process has included a
series of steps that are described below:
a) Text Selection: Reading texts with different contents were collected, both
humanities and scientific in nature and by Peruvian authors. The texts were
consulted with educators and specialists in various areas, and fifteen of them were
selected for the preparation of the original test.
b) The measurement of specific reading comprehension skills was carried out
through the items whose required responses were related to the selection of the
best definition, information on specific facts, questions answered in a paragraph
with different words, inferences about the content of a paragraph, selection of the
main meaning of a paragraph, information about the author's intention.
Below in Table 1 each of the areas is presented with the respective items that
make them up.
Table 1
Organization of items by Areas
AREAS ITEMS
Fact information 1,2,13,24,27,29
Definition of meanings 5,16
ORIGINAL VERSION
The original version is composed of 10 reading fragments organized into 38 items.
The items were mostly multiple choice with three distractors and one correct
answer, as seen in Appendix A. In the same way, one completion item and two
ranking items were included.
The forms of administration can be individual and collective and are aimed at people
between 12 and 20 years old who are studying Secondary Education and I cycle of
Higher Education. It generally takes between 50 to 60 minutes including the
instruction period. The correction is done by hand, using the answer key, where one
point is assigned for a correct answer, with the maximum score being: 38 points.
SHORT VERSION
The abbreviated version is made up of four reading fragments, as presented in
Appendix B.
VALIDITY
To determine empirical validity, the authors took the California Mental Ability Test
(Intermediate Series) as a criterion measure. The validity index obtained was 0.58,
with a variation of 33.64%.
RELIABILITY
Regarding reliability, the authors used the test - retest, whose correlation index was
0.53 and the internal consistency index through Kuder Richardson's formula 21,
whose value was 0.58. The standard error of measurement was 3.01, meaning that
the upper or lower limit values in which the score can vary is three points. The
reliability indices are equally moderate and are related to the validity indices.
RULES
Regarding the normative aspects, the authors constructed a Peruvian Scale, in a
representative sample (men and women) of Secondary Education and I Cycle of
Higher Education (ESEP), as seen in table 2. Norms were included according to
degree of study, semester and age. The score interpreted based on the percentile
scales allows us to appreciate the level of overall performance of the person,
expressing their position within the group, which is assessed through ranges.
Table 2
Scales for educational centers in Metropolitan Lima
Punctuation Percentiles
Direct First year Second year Third year
38
37
36
35
34
33
32
31 100
30 99
29 99
28 100 98
27 100 98 96
26 99 96 93
25 98 93 89
24 93 84 77
23 93 84 77
22 89 77 69
21 84 75 60
20 75 69 50
19 69 60 40
Continued Table 2
Punctuation Percentiles
Direct First year Second year Third year
18 60 50 40
17 50 40 31
16 40 25 23
15 40 23 16
14 31 16 11
13 23 11 7
12 16 7 4
11 11 4 1
10 11 2 1
9 7 2
8 2 1
7 2
6 1
5
4
3
2
1
0
Average 16,98 18,30 19,36
Standard deviation 4,33 4,09 4,19
RELIABILITY
Grimaldo (2002) studied the reliability of the abbreviated version in a group of 142
female students, whose ages ranged between 14 and 16 years, from a state
daytime educational center.
Initially, Cronbach's Alpha coefficient was calculated on all the items of the original
version and subsequently an analysis of the items by fragments was carried out.
Table 3 presents the results of the reliability of the original scale.
Table 3
Reliability of the original version
Fragments- Items Correlation: Item-Total Alpha
F1I1 ,2162 ,5811
F1I2 ,2679 ,5799
F1I3 ,3741 ,5626
F1I4 ,2311 ,5772
F2i5 ,0129 ,5965
F2I6 ,2316 ,5770
F2I7 ,0425 ,5967
F2I8 ,2771 ,5720
F3I9 ,2271 ,5777
F3I10 ,0757 ,5912
F3I11 -,0840 ,6099
F3I12 ,2953 ,5700
F4I13 ,1362 ,5870
F4I14 ,3047 ,5706
F4I15 ,0722 ,5940
F5I16 ,1330 ,5873
F5I17 -,0588 ,6050
F5I18 ,1626 ,5845
F5I19 ,0147 ,5993
F6I20 ,2193 ,5785
F6I21 -,0996 ,5959
F6I22 ,2427 ,5774
F6I23 ,1646 ,5842
F7I24 ,1630 ,5844
F7I25 ,2140 ,5792
F7I26 -,1047 ,6076
F8I27 ,2640 ,5781
F8I28 ,2849 ,5720
F8I29 ,3596 ,5653
F8I30 -,0105 ,5963
F9I31 ,1517 ,5856
F9I32 ,2812 ,5716
F9I33 ,2050 ,5800
F9I34 ,2010 ,5804
F10I35 ,1208 ,5885
F10I36 -,0561 ,6008
F10I37 ,0177 ,5979
F10I38 -,1652 ,6105
Source: Grimaldo (2002)
The item analysis of the fragments reveals that the reliabilities are quite low, as
presented in Table 4. In the case of fragments 1 and 8 they are medium and in the
case of fragments 2 and 6 they are very low. For this reason, it is proposed that these
are the fragments that constitute the short version of the test.
Table 4
Analysis of the Items of the fragments of the Tapia & Silva Reading
Comprehension Test
Coefficient
Fragments Alpha
1 ,0628
2 ,0403
3 ,1088
4 ,0629
5 ,0403
6 ,1088
7 -,1504
8 ,4501
9 ,0038
10 -,0244
Source: Grimaldo (2002)
One way to verify this short version was to find the reliability and item analysis of
just these fragments, as shown in Table 5; where it is observed that the reliability
of this short version is acceptable. The item analysis reveals that items 21 and 30
are “strange” even 15. For this reason, the distractors of the aforementioned
questions were reformulated. Finally, the test was made up of the items
corresponding to the fragments: 1, 2, 6 and 8.
Table 5
Analysis of the Reliability of the Shortened Version of the Silva & Tapia Reading
Comprehension Test
In the same way, the categories were established for both male and female
students, as seen in table 6.
Table 6
Silva & Tapia Reading Comprehension Test Score Categories (Short Form)
Categories Criteria
Men Women
Very high 12.5 or more 13.7 or more
High 10,5 - 12,4 10,9 - 13,6
Half 6,5 - 10,4 5,6 - 10,8
Low 5 - 6,4 2,8 - 5,5
Very Low less than 4 Less than 2.8
Source: Grimaldo (2002)
Instructions
This booklet contains ten reading fragments, each followed by four questions.
After reading each passage carefully, identify the correct answer among those that appear after each
question. On the Answer Sheet, circle the letter that corresponds to the correct answer or write the numbers
according to the instructions that appear in the text.
The incomplete combustion of coal, oil and tobacco, for 18. Tobacco is presumed to be a potential carcinogen
example, can give rise to carcinogens that we can breathe. because:
Substances have recently been discovered in tobacco smoke that a) There are experimental tests with human beings.
under certain conditions have been shown to be carcinogenic to b) Artificial cancer is experimentally produced in
some species of animals (presumably they are also carcinogenic certain kinds of animals.
to humans) but there is no direct experimental evidence of this, c) There is a higher incidence of lung cancer in
since obviously , experiments to produce artificial cancers by smokers.
means of potential carcinogens cannot be done in man. In any d) Radiation affects the body.
case, the possible relationship between smoking and the increase
in the incidence of lung cancer is currently being vigorously 19. Through reading you can deduce:
discussed. a) Incomplete combustion of coal causes cancer.
b) Modern technology increases chemical dangers in
relation to cancer.
c) Carcinogenic elements are found in the
atmosphere.
d) There is no definitive evidence on the relationship
between substances and human cancer.
FRAGMENT Nº 6
16. A carcinogen refers to:
a) Cell mutations.
We will point out in the first place – with reference to the b) Economy
population that lives within our borders, to which we refer all the c) Ecology
time when we mention Peru or Peruvians – that it is difficult to d) Social sciences
speak of Peruvian culture in the singular. Rather, there are a
multiplicity of separate cultures, also disparate in level and breadth
of diffusion, corresponding to various human groups that coexist in 21. For the author, Peruvian culture means:
the national territory. a) Subcultures of limited expression.
b) Multiplicity of separate cultures
Think, for example, of Spanish-speaking communities and c) Cultural uniformity of human groups
communities with other languages; in coastal Westernity, d) Subcultures of the same level of development.
mountain Indianness and jungle regionalism, in the Indian, the
white, the cholo, the black, the Asian, the European, as 22. The polarization of the national community refers to:
contrasting groups and in many reciprocally exclusive; in the man a) Exclusive reciprocity of human groups
from the countryside, the urban man and the primitive man from b) Differentiated sectors of workers
the jungle, in the rustic man from the most remote areas of the c) Contrasted human groups
country and the refined intellectual of Lima, to which are added, d) Dual character of the national community.
like so many other differentiated sectors, the artisan, the
proletarian, the petty bourgeois, the professional and other sectors 23. The central idea of the text is about:
of the middle class, the peasant, the provincial landowner and the a) Cultural pluralism of Peru
modern industrialist, not to mention the religious and political b) The coexistence of human groups in Peru
differences that, intersecting with the previous ones, contribute to c) The uniqueness of Peruvian culture
the polarization of the national community. This cultural pluralism, d) The dualism of Peruvian culture.
which in an effort of simplification some seek to reduce to a
duality, is therefore a typical feature of our current life.
FRAGMENT Nº 7
20. The topic presented would be located within:
a) Literature.
Life appeared on our planet more than three billion years a) Biologists and anthropologists
ago and since then it has evolved to reach the wonderful set of b) Paleontologists and naturalists
existing organic forms. More than one million animal species and c) Naturalists and geologists
more than two hundred thousand plant species have been d) Anthropologists and paleontologists
identified through the efforts of naturalists and systematists in the
19th and 20th centuries. Additionally, paleontologists have 25. An appropriate conclusion would be:
unearthed a multitude of extinct forms. In very general terms, it a) All species have been classified
has been calculated that the number of species of organisms that b) Birds and mammals are already cataloged
have existed since there has been life on Earth is greater than one c) A larger number of classified forms are found in
billion. There may still be some four hundred and fifteen million in insects.
existence. Although certain classes of organisms, such as birds d) There are species not yet discovered and classified.
and mammals, are well catalogued, there is no doubt that many
other species have not yet been discovered or formally 26. Choose the best title for the fragment from the following
recognized, especially among insects, the class in which the expressions:
largest number of classified forms is found. . a) Scientific investigations
b) Formation of species
c) Number of living beings on the planet
d) Evolution of species.
FRAGMENT Nº 8
FRAGMENT Nº 9
FRAGMENT Nº 10
31. According to the author, in Latin America there
remains: The agrarian problem is presented, above all, as the
a) The predominance of the colonial aristocracy problem of the liquidation of feudality in Peru. This liquidation
b) The oligarchy of castes had to be carried out by the bourgeois-democratic regime
c) Privilege of the ruling class formally established by the independence revolution. But in
d) Foreign influences. Peru we have not had, in a hundred years of republic, a true
bourgeois class, a true capitalist class. The old feudal class,
camouflaged or disguised as the republican bourgeoisie, has b) His ideas were liberal.
preserved its positions. c) They were not landowners.
d) They were capitalists.
The policy of confiscation of agrarian property initiated by
the Revolution of Independence, as a logical consequence of 36. The policy of confiscation of agricultural property
its ideology, did not lead to the development of its small meant:
property. The old landowning class had not lost its a) Develop the capitalist economy.
dominance. The survival of a latifundia regime produced in b) Strengthen large agrarian property.
practice the maintenance of the latifundium. It is known that c) Affect the development of communities.
the confiscation attacked more in the community. And the fact d) Suppress the landowning regime.
is that, during a century of republic, large agrarian property
has been strengthened and enlarged despite the theoretical 37. The agrarian problem in republican Peru is a problem
liberalism of our constitution and the practical needs of our of:
capitalist economy. a) Elimination of the capitalist class.
b) Maintenance of feudalism.
c) Elimination of private property.
d) Maintenance of the capitalist regime.
APPENDIX B
INSTRUMENT PROTOCOL
SHORT VERSION
INSTRUCTIONS
This booklet contains four reading fragments, each followed by four questions.
After reading each passage carefully, identify the correct answer among those that appear after each question.
On the Answer sheet, circle the letter that corresponds to the correct answer or write the numbers according to
the instructions that appear in the text.
3. From the following six expressions, select one that could be the
best title for each of the three paragraphs of the reading. On the
answer sheet, where the same expressions appear, place the
number “1” on the line to the right of the expression you select as
the title for the first paragraph and the numbers “2” and “3” for the
second paragraphs. and third, respectively:
a) Countries d) Latex extraction
b)Location of e) Transformation of
rubber tree latex
c) Collecting the gum f) Emptying it into vessels
FRAGMENT Nº 2
In the spring of 1844, when the political parties were holding their
conventions, the telegraph was ready for practical application. This instrument
was able to notify the candidates and the people of Washington of the results
of the convention, before information could be obtained from other means. This
event sparked public interest and there was a general consensus that an
important event was happening. In this way the telegraph system grew rapidly
in thirty years, and spread throughout the world.
The development of the telegraph has brought the entire world closer
together, providing a method where ideas and messages from around the
world can be carried and reached everyone in a minimum of time. This fact has
been greatly accelerated by the improvement of wireless telegraphy.
8. From the following expressions, choose the best title for the entire
fragment:
a) The effects of the telegraph
3
b) The Telegraph
c) The improvement of the telegraph
d) Wireless telegraphy
4
FRAGMENT Nº 3
We will point out in the first place – with reference to the population that
lives within our borders, to which we refer all the time when we mention Peru
or Peruvians – that it is difficult to speak of Peruvian culture in the singular.
Rather, there are a multiplicity of separate cultures, also disparate in level and
breadth of diffusion, corresponding to various human groups that coexist in the
national territory.
10. For the author, when Peru or Peruvians are mentioned it should be
understood:
a) Subcultures of limited expression.
b) Multiplicity of separate cultures
c) Cultural uniformity of human groups
d) Subcultures of the same level of development.
FRAGMENT Nº 4
Over a huge sea of muddy water, this strange vegetation has grown. It
is exclusively made up of the renaco, a plant that thrives especially in
places or in swamps, where it forms compact forests. When it sprouts
isolated, it grows quickly. Adventitious roots emerge from its first branches,
which develop downwards seeking the earth, but if a tree of another
species rises near one of them, it extends until it reaches it, one or more
twists around the stem and continues its path. journey to the earth, into
which it goes deeply. Since then, the renaco, coiled like a long snake,
adjusts its rings in a relentless process of strangulation that ends up
splitting the tree and throwing it to the ground. As this operation is carried
out with all the trees nearby, he ends up being left alone. From each of the
roots that served for strangulation sprout shoots that over time become
independent of the mother stem. And it frequently happens that, when they
do not find other species to attach themselves to, they form among
themselves a strange group that could be said to be a tree with multiple
deformed stems and layers that do not coincide with the trunks. Little by
little, developing its murderous property, the renaco is forming forests
where it does not allow the existence of any type of trees.
16. The description of the plant has been made in the form:
a) Biological
b) Genetics
c) Botany
d) Literary.
- SHORT FORM –
FRAGMENT 1
FRAGMENT 3
1. abcd 9. abcd
2. abcd
3. a) Countries _______ 10. abcd
b) Location of the
rubber tree _______ 11. abcd
c) Collecting the rubber _______
d) Extraction of latex _______ 12. abcd
e) Transfer Latex _______
f) Emptying into _______ vessels
4. a) Collecting the latex _______
b) Mixing the latex with
water _______
c) Latex coagulation _______
d) Extraction of latex _______
FRAGMENT 2
FRAGMENT 4
13.abcd
5. abcd
6. abcd 14.abcd
7. a) The practical demonstration
of the telegraph _______ 15.abcd
b) The expansion of use
of the telegraph _______ 16. abcd
c) The effects of
Telegraph _______
d) The efforts of
inventor _______
8. abcd
7