Professional Documents
Culture Documents
8-6 Deuteron
8-6 Deuteron
Deuteron:
Nucleus of deuterium (heavy hydrogen) that consists of one proton and one neutron
(the notation: d or D). Deuterons are formed chiefly by ionizing deuterium (stripping the
single electron away from the atom) and are used as projectiles to produce nuclear
reactions after accumulating high energies in particle accelerators. A deuteron also
results from the capture of a slow neutron by a proton, accompanied by the emission of a
gamma photon.
1
Deuterium (heavy hydrogen, 2H): A heavy isotope of hydrogen that consists of one proton, one
neutron, and one electron; The nuclei of deuterium, called deuterons (d), consist of one proton (p)
and one neutron (n).
Fig. Deuterium (heavy hydrogen), consisting of one proton, one neutron, and one
electron.
2. Isotopic spin
The charge independence of nuclear forces allows us to consider the proton and the
neutron as different states of the same particles, or nucleon. Thus, in addition to position
and spin variables, the state of nucleon requires for its specification a “charge” variable
which can take two values. Therefore in the study of nucleon systems a formalism similar
2
to the one developed for the eigenstates of spin 1/2 can be used. It is called the isotopic
spin formalism.
The neutron and proton are very similar apart from a small mass difference (0.1%)
and of course the difference in electric charge. Both play an equally important role in
determining the properties of nuclei. Heisenberg (1932) postulates that n, p are two sub-
states of a nucleon with iso-spin 1/2 by analogy with ordinary spin s =1/2.
Briefly, the base vectors of a 2D isotopic spin space can be defined to be
1 0
p , n
0 1
and the operator representing isotopic spin and nucleon charge are then
1 1
Tˆ τˆ , Qˆ (1
ˆ3 )
2 2
where the operator of τˆ (ˆ1 ,ˆ2 ,ˆ3 ) on the base vector s can be represented by Pauli
matrices.
E (MeV)
939.6
mt = -1/2 neutron
938.3
mt = 1/2 proton
Both neutrons and protons have spin s = 1/2. s and T are independent quantum number. T
has no classical analog. It is a quantum mechanical vector, literally “like spin” (iso=like).
So it follows the same addition as s, l, j, etc.
l = 0, 2, 4, 6,...
j=l+s
where l is the relative angular momentum of the neutron and proton. s is the spin angular
momentum. For the resultant spin,
3
D1/2 x D1/2=D1+D0 s = 1 (symm) or s = 0 (antisymm)
Of the possible quantum numbers, l = 0 has the lowest energy. This value of orbital
angular momentum l = 0 combines with these spin values.
1
s = 0 (antisymm), l = 0 (symm): j=0 S0
as well as
s = 1 (symm), l = 2 (symm) : j = 3, 2, 1 3D
1,2,3
The total wave function for two identical fermions has to be antisymmetric with respect
to particle exchange
Thus the total wavefunction is antisymmetic under the exchange of neutron and proton.
The isospin of deuteron is given by 0,0 .
or
G a S 3 S1 a D 3 D1
4
As aD<<aS, for the purpose of calculating the magnetic moment of the deuteron, it
suffices to take G to be entirely an S state (l = 0).
((Note))
µdeuteron = 0.8573 µN
or
Then we have
µneutron = -1.93 µN
The negative sign shows that the direction of the magnetic moment is opposite to that of
spin.
Sn Sp
µn
µp
Deuteron
Sd µd
5
p: proton
n: neutron
Bd
M ( 2 H ) mn M (1 H )
c2
where
Bd 2.224 MeV.
We find that the atomic electron binding energy of 13.6 eV is much smaller than the
nuclear binding energy of 2.2 MeV.
This binding energy can be determined from the photodisintegration or a
photonuclear reaction. We scatter gamma rays (photons) from deuterium gas and look for
the breakup of a deuteron into a neutron and a proton;
d n p.
Bd
hf min Bd [1 ] Bd .
2 M ( 2 H )c 2
Experiment shows that a photon of energy less than 2.22 MeV cannot dissociate a
deuteron. This energy is necessary to separate the two nucleons completely. No excited
states of the deuteron have been found, and it is surmised that the deuteron has only one
bound state.
s = 2 and s = 0 (symmetric)
6
1 1 1 2 1 3 2 2 2 3 3 3
: , , , , , ,
6 states (j = 2 and 0)
s = 1 (anti-symmetric
1 1 2
2 3 3
: , , , 3 states (j=1)
m=1 m=0 m=-1
ˆ l , m Pˆ l , m (1)l l , m
leven , ml s 2, ms : 5 states
or
What is the nuclear force holding neutron and proton together? This force cannot be
electrical as the neutron is uncharged. So we must accept the nuclear force as a new type
of force and try to find out more about it. We assume a central force. The interaction
potential of neutron and proton is given by a function V (r ) , where r is the distance
between the particles. Second, the nuclear force has a short range.
7
m is the reduced mass of proton and neutron.
Mn M p M
m
Mn M p 2
2 1 1 2l (l 1)
r (rR) R V (r ) R ER
2m r r r r 2mr 2
Suppose that
u rR
2 2u 2l (l 1)
[ V (r )]u Eu
2m r 2 2mr 2
2 d 2u
V (r )u Eu
2m dr 2
with
2 2
E (bound state)
2m
8
V r
R r
- V0
Fig. Attractive square-well potential well for deuteron. V0 = 35 MeV. The binding
energy is -2.2 MeV.
We assume a square-well potential as V(r). There are two parameters, width R and the
depth of the well (-V0).
V rR
V (r ) 0
0 rR
2 d 2u 2 2
V0 u Eu u
2m dr 2 2m
or
d 2u 2mV0
2
2 u 2u
dr
or
u"( 2 k0 )u 0
2
or
u" 2u 0
9
where
2mV0
U 0 k0 ,
2
2
2 2 k0 2
u B sin(r )
r rmax .
2
rmax R
or
R .
2
u" 2u 0 ,
or
u Ae r
B sin(R ) Ae R
Then we have
10
R cot(R ) R
with
2 2 k0 2
RR
B
R 2RR 2R sin 2 (R) 2R sin( 2R)
4 R 2 r 2 dr 4 u 2 dr 1 .
In the limit of R 0 ,
2 .
A , B
2 sin(R)
x R , y R
In this case,
y x cot x , x 2 y 2 k0 R 2 a0
2 2
(circle)
where
2
a0 k0 R , U0 ,
2R
2mV0
U 0 k0
2
2
11
We make a plot of these two curves, where a0 is varied as a parameter. The intersection
of two curves is the solution of the values of x and y for the fixed value of a0. The results
are as follows.
3
(i) a0 one bound state.
2 2
3 5
(ii) a0 two bound states.
2 2
5 7
(iii) a0 three bound states.
2 2
12
y=aR
10
x=kR
p 2 3p 2 5p 2 7p 2
0
0 2 4 6 8 10 12
12
((Note))
The simplest way to determine the condition for the existence for the bound state is as
follows.
We start with
y x cot x .
When y = 0, we have
x cot x 0
or
u Ae r
with
This function is a typical exponential decay. The quantity 1/ can be taken as a measure
of the size of the deuteron. It was shown above that the radius of the deuteron is
considerably larger than the range of nuclear forces, i.e.,
1
R
2 d 2u 2l (l 1)
[ V (r )]u Eu
2m dr 2 2mr 2
where
13
2 2 2m
E , U0 2
V0 k 0
2
2m
2 l (l 1)
Veff V (r)
2mr 2
For r<R
2 d 2u 2l (l 1) 2 2
[ V0 ]u u
2m dr 2 2mr 2 2m
or
2u l (l 1)
[ U 0 ]u 2 u
r 2
r2
sin(r )
u B[ cos(r )]
r
2 U 0 2 k0 2 2
For r>R
2 d 2u 2l (l 1) 2 2
u u
2m dr 2 2mr 2 2m
or
d 2u l (l 1)
2
2
u 2u
dr r
The solution of u is
14
1
u Ae r ( 1)
r
2 R 2 sin(R ) 2R2
sin(R ) R cos(R ) 1 R
We put
x R , y R
x 2 sin( x ) y2
sin( x ) x cos( x ) 1 y
with
x 2 y 2 a0
2
(circle)
We make a plot of these two curves, where a0 is varied as a parameter. The intersection
of two curves is the solution of the values of x and y for the fixed value of a0. The results
are as follows.
15
12
y =aR
10
x=kR
0
p 2p 3p
0 2 4 6 8 10 12
From this figure, we have the bound state under the condition that x .
2m M
V0 R 2 2n V0 R 2 a0 k0 R 2 2
2 2
2
((Note-1))
This required well depth V0 is almost four times as large as the actual well depth in
the ground state
2m Mn 2
2 2 2 2 2
V0 R V0 R a0 k 0 R .
2 2 4
Note that a0 is slightly larger than /2 but definitely less than .
((Note-II))
The simplest way to determine the condition for the existence for the bound state is as
follows.
We start with
x 2 sin( x ) y2
.
sin( x ) x cos( x ) 1 y
16
When y = 0, we have
x sin x 0
or
Here we assume that the values of E and R are given. We determine the value of V0. We
show that the depth of the potential as
V0 = 33.73 MeV.
y x cot x , x 2 y 2 k0 R 2 a0
2 2
2m E
x R , y R R 0.231969 R[fm]
2
where
2 2
E = - 2.24 MeV (energy of bound state)
2m
2m M
a0 k0 R 2 V0 R 2 2n V0 R 2
2 2
2
Mn
and m is the reduced mass, m (Mn is the mass of neutron).
2
17
((Mathematica))
3.5
3.0
2.5 y=aR
2.0
1.5
1.0
0.5
x
a0 y x=kR
p 2
0.0
p
0.0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0 2.5 3.0 3.5
Fig. Graphical solution (x = R, y = R) of the bound state of deuteron. E 2.23
MeV. R 2.1 fm. The value of V0 is obtained as 33.73 MeV. The red point
denote the solution of x and y. The black thick line is y x cot x . The purple
circle is denoted by x 2 y 2 a0 with a0 = 1.89454.
2
2m | E |
y R R 0.231969 R[fm] = 0.487134.
2
18
x = 1.83084. a0 = 1.89454,
Then we have
2m
a0 V0 R 2 0.15534 V0 ( MeV ) R( fm) .
2
V0 = 33.73 MeV.
r /2 /2
0.858
R R x
where x = 1.83084. For r>R, the wave function is proportional to e r . The characteristic
distance is
1 R R
2.05R 4.3 fm.
R y
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
r R
1 2 3 4 5
Fig. The plot of u (r ) / umax as a function of r/R. R = 2.1 fm. E = -2.23 MeV
19
14. Relation between a0 and R
In order to discuss the relation between a0 and R, we use
where V0 is in the unit of MeV and R is the unit of fm. We assume that V0 is given as V0 =
35 MeV. The plot of a0 vs R is shown below. When R0 = 2.1 fm, a0 is beween /2 and .
This means that there is no bound state for l = 1, 2,.... There is only one bound state for l
= 0.
p V0=35 MeV
a0
3p
4
p
2
R=2.1 fm
Rfm
14. Pion
14.1. Yukawa’s idea ((Eisberg and Resnick))
In 1935, Yukawa proposed that a nucleon frequently emits a particle with
an appreciable rest mass, now called a n meson or pion. This particle hovers near
the nucleon in the so-called meson field for a very short time, and then is
-
absorbed by the nucleon. During the process the nucleon maintains its normal
rest mass, and so while it is happening there is a violation of the law of mass-
energy conservation because there is more rest mass present than there is
before the meson is emitted or after it is absorbed. The energy-time
uncertainty principle shows, however, that such a violation is not impossible if
it lasts for a sufficiently short time. Of course, the meson cannot permanently
escape the nucleon because that would permanently violate the mass-energy
conservation law. Such a pion is called a virtual particle because it has a very
short existence limited by its violation of mass-energy conservation. If two
nucleons are close enough for their meson fields to overlap, it is possible for a
meson to leave one field and join the other, without permanently changing the
20
total energy of the system of two nucleons. In the interaction, the momentum
carried by the meson is transferred from one field to the other, and therefore
from one nucleon to the other. But if momentum is transferred, the effect is the
same as if a force is acting between the nucleons. Thus the exchange of a virtual
pion between two nucleons leads to the nucleon force acting between them,
according to Yukawa. Yukawa was guided by two analogies available to him
at the time. One is the covalent binding in the H2+ molecule. In this process, a
force arises from the sharing, or exchange, of an electron between two atoms.
The range of the nucleon force is of the order of the radius r' of the n-meson field
surrounding a nucleon, since two nucleons experience that force only when their meson
fields overlap. To estimate the radius of the field, consider a process in which a nucleon
emits a meson of rest mass m , which travels out to the limits of the field, and then
returns to the nucleon where it is absorbed. In this process, the meson travels a distance
of the order of r'. While it is happening there is a violation of the conservation of mass-
energy. The reason is that the total energy of the system equals one nucleon rest mass
energy before and after the process, and one nucleon rest mass energy plus at least one -
meson rest mass energy during the process. But the energy-time uncertainty principle
shows that a violation of energy conservation by an amount
E m c 2 ,
is not impossible if it does not happen for a time longer than t , where
Et .
The reason is that such a violation could not be detected because the energy cannot be
measured in a time t more accurately than E . Since the speed of the pion can be no
greater than c, the time required for it to travel a distance of the order of r' is at least
r'
t .
c
m ,
r'c
or
If we take r ' 2 F = 2 x 10-13 cm, the -meson rest mass m can be evaluated as
21
m = 193.1 me.
or
m c2 = 98.66 MeV.
22
15. , 0 , and meson
15.1
ud
Rest mass: 139.56995 ± 0.00035 MeV
Mean life: (2.6033 ± 0.0005) x 10-8 s.
Spin 0 (boson)
Isospin: 1,1 ; T = 1, Tz = 1.
Electric charge: +e
Typical reactions
p p d
0 e e
15.2 0
uu , dd
Rest mass: 134.9766 ±0.0006 MeV
Spin: 0 (boson)
Isospin 1,0 ; T = 1, Tz = 0.
Intrinsic parity: odd
Electric charge: 0
23
Mean life: = (8.4 ± 0.6) x 10-17 s
Typical reaction:
0
15.3
du
Rest mass: 139.56995 ± 0.00035 MeV
The intrinsic parity: odd
Spin 0 (boson)
Isospin: 1,1 ; T = 1, Tz = -1.
Charge: -e
Typical reactions: d nn
0 e e
where e>0.
REFERENCES
H.A. Bethe, Elementary Nuclear Theory, A Short Course On Selected Topics (John
Wiley & Sons, New York, 1947).
E. Fermi, Nuclear Physics, Revised Edition (The University of Chicago Press, 1950).
S.T. Thornton and A. Rex, Modern Physics for Scientists and Engineers, 4th edition
(Cengage, 2013).
R. Eisberg and R. Resnick, Quantum Physics of Atoms, Molecules, Solids, Nuclei, and
Particles, 2nd edition (John Wiley and Sons, 1985).
M.K. Sundaresan, Handbook of Particle Physics (CRC, 2001).
________________________________________________________________________
APPENDIX
Effective range theory and scattering cross section
d 2ub
2
( 2 U 0 )ub 0 for 0<r<R
dr
ub ( r ) Ab sin( b r )
d 2ub
2
2ub 0 , for r>R
dr
ub ( r ) Bb e r
24
with
b 2 2 U 0
d 2u s
2
(k 2 U 0 )us 0 for 0<r<R
dr
us ( r ) Ab sin( b r )
d 2us
k 2u s 0 for r>R
dr 2
us ( r ) Bb sin(kr 0 )
where
b2 k 2 U0
Multiplying the first by us, the second by ub, and subtracting, gives
d 2ub d 2us
[us 2
( 2
U 0 )u u
s b ] [ub 2
(k 2 U 0 )ubus 0
dr dr
or
d 2ub d 2u s
(us ub ) ( 2 k 2 )usub 0 .
dr 2 dr 2
R R
d 2 ub d 2u s
0 s dr 2 b dr 2 )dr ( k )0 usub dr 0
2 2
(u u
or
R
du du
(us b ub s )]0R ( 2 k 2 ) usub dr .
dr dr 0
25
R
du du
(us b ub s ) r R ( 2 k 2 ) usub dr .
r r 0
( 2 k 2 )
R
1 dub 1 dus
us ( R)ub ( R) 0
( )r R usub dr
ub dr us dr
We note that
1 dub
|r R 0 b cot( b R) ,
ub dr
1 dub
|r R 0
ub dr
b cot( b R )
1 dus
|r R 0 s cot( s R)
us dr
1 dus
|r R 0 k cot(kR 0 )
us dr
leading to
s cot( s R ) k cot(kR 0 )
b cot( b R ) s cot( s R )
R
1
u s ( R )u b ( R ) 0
us ub dr
b2 s2
.
b cot( b R ) s cot( s R )
( 2 k 2 )
or
26
( 2 k 2 )
R
us ( R )ub ( R ) 0
u s ub dr b cot( b R ) s cot( s R )
Then we get
We also have
s 2 b2 s2 b2 s 2 b2 2 k 2
s b ,
b b 2 b 2 b 2 b
Finally we have
1
k cot(kR 0 ) ( 2 k 2 ) R .
2
cot( 0 )
k
27
4
2
sin 2 0
k
4 1
2
k 1 cot 2 0
4
k 2
2
2 2 1
m 2 2
E
2m
with m M n / 2 .
28