Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 2

Confederation:

A confederation may be defined as a group or association of two or more Sovereign States


which have permanently given up part of their liberty for some specific aims and objects, such
as defence.
A confederation is stronger than an alliance between sovereign States, but weaker than a federal
union. A confederation does not put an end to the sovereignty of the confederated States, as a
federation does.
German words explain the distinction between a confederation and a federation very clearly. A
federation is a Bundes-stant, a united State, while a confederation is a Staalenbund te, the union
of States.
1. A confederation is a league of sovereign States while a federation is a single
sovereign State.

In a federation the former sovereign States become integral parts or component units of a new
State, while there is no such integration in a confederation. The confederated States retain their
identity and separate entity. The confederated States retain their sovereignties, while the
federating States renounce their individual Sovereignties when they enter into a federal union.

2. Confederation is based on contract, and federation on constitution.

In confederation States enter into an alliance based on an agreement, but the federated States
are united by a constitution. It means that any one of the confederated States can withdraw
from the alliance, but none of the federated units can do so, as they have lost their sovereign
entity in a new union. In other words, confederation recognises the right of secession, but a
federation does not. Withdrawal from a confederation is legal, while from a federation it is
revolutionary.

3. A confederation has no central government.

A confederation has only a committee or congress of delegates from various confederated


States, who meet to vote by States and under instructions from their governments. Their
decisions are not laws but only resolutions. In a federation, there is a central government with
its own powers, organisation and machinery, consisting of representatives from various
component units, who make laws, and adopt a policy, which are executed by its own officials
over the whole country.

4. Citizenship.
In a confederation, the citizens of the confederate States retain their citizenship. They do not
become citizens of the confederation, but in a federation, they become the citizens of the federal
State. Hence in a confederation, they obey only the laws of their own State and not of the
confederation, while in al federation they obey the laws of the central government also.

You might also like