Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Optimal Management of Endometriosis and Pain.25
Optimal Management of Endometriosis and Pain.25
Camran Nezhat, MD, Nataliya Vang, MD, Pedro P. Tanaka, MD, PhD, and Ceana Nezhat, MD
processed and sent to the brain (Fig. 1).4–6 This, along descriptions of wheelchair-bound patients becoming
with multiple other factors, contributes to the pain fully ambulatory after treatment of infiltrative
syndrome that is associated with endometriosis. Peri- endometriosis.9
toneal fluid in women with endometriosis contains Central sensitization is another mechanism that
high levels of nerve growth factors that promote neu- promotes endometriosis-associated pain. Patients
rogenesis, the ratio of sympathetic and sensory nerve become highly sensitive to subsequent painful stimuli
fibers is significantly altered within endometriotic tis- because of endometriosis-induced neuroplastic
sue, and the nerve density within endometriotic nod- changes in descending pathways that modulate pain
ules is increased.7,8 Also, the cytokines and perception.10 In response to a subsequent insult (ie,
CUN3NWRbcX+glak+ on 05/01/2023
prostaglandins produced by mast cells and other nephrolithiasis or peritoneal organ injury), women
inflammatory cells attracted to ectopic endometrial- can experience pain from endometriosis as a result
like tissue can activate nerve fibers and can trigger of inability to engage descending inhibition
nearby cells to release inflammatory molecules.5,6,8,9 pathways.10
VOL. 134, NO. 4, OCTOBER 2019 Nezhat et al Endometriosis and Pain 835
MEDICAL MANAGEMENT sitivity as a result of aberrant gene expression in the
Pain management should be individualized. The goal of eutopic endometrium that leads to progesterone
medical therapy is to reduce pain by decreasing resistance.13 For those unable to tolerate oral med-
inflammation as well as ovarian and local hormone ications, the levonorgestrel-releasing intrauterine
production (Table 1). Complete estrogen suppression system can reduce pain and recurrence.4,14 How-
may not be necessary to relieve endometriosis- ever, the levonorgestrel-releasing intrauterine sys-
W+3EnkBEEZeYXgE7jRt4LDj9V96cgdX/XC/lEj875IHmmy6+yMXKsEzR1VbfLPftp0AqqFfXkLZYO1P1xI01yUsDJtVR43dSm7US
associated pain.11 Medical treatment is usually not cura- tem does not inhibit ovulation and the recurrence
Downloaded from http://journals.lww.com/greenjournal by yLTqme3WM71OrnTWkogOH26lXQE+lGZAsfUE6xZQqcwa
tive but suppressive, and symptoms will often recur after of endometriomas. For those patients for whom the
therapy discontinuation. The recurrence rate of endo- previous options have failed, we recommend using
metriosis is highly variable, ranging from 4–74%.2,3 a gonadotropin-releasing hormone (GnRH) agonist
Initial treatment is typically use of combined with add-back therapy to prevent bone loss and to
oral contraceptive pills, which are effective in ease side effects. Patients taking GnRH agonists for
decreasing pain as well as in preventing postoper- endometriosis may develop resistance, because
ative recurrence.12 For those who cannot tolerate or endometrial-like tissue expresses aromatase and
have contraindications to estrogen, progestins such produces its own estradiol.
as medroxyprogesterone acetate, norethindrone Our experience is mixed with GnRH antagonists,
CUN3NWRbcX+glak+ on 05/01/2023
acetate, or levonorgestrel are indicated. However, aromatase inhibitors, and bazedoxifene along with
there are patients who have decreased receptor sen- conjugated estrogens. Some patients obtain pain relief
prefer these compounds over opioids, and their use is associated pain. Complications of subsequent uterine
Downloaded from http://journals.lww.com/greenjournal by yLTqme3WM71OrnTWkogOH26lXQE+lGZAsfUE6xZQqcwa
associated with less nausea and constipation. The use of prolapse and intraoperative ureteral transection have
tetrahydrocannabinol or cannabidiol is especially bene- been reported with this procedure.16 In contrast, lap-
ficial for managing postoperative pain, and their use does aroscopic presacral neurectomy was 87% efficacious
not have the addictive concerns associated with opioid in reducing severe midline pelvic pain.2,4–6 We find
use. We use an enhanced recovery after surgery protocol this procedure especially effective in patients with
and highly discourage opioid use. mild or no endometriosis.17 The adverse effects asso-
Acupuncture is another potentially useful adjunct in ciated with presacral neurectomy are constipation and
treating the pain. It has been proposed to work by bladder and urinary symptoms.17 We perform presac-
activating descending inhibitory pain pathways while ral neurectomy in only about 1% of our patients.
centrally deactivating pain signals. Acupuncture also A prospective, multicenter cohort study of 981
CUN3NWRbcX+glak+ on 05/01/2023
increases the pain threshold and leads to production of women with varying degrees of disease showed
neurohumoral factors such as dopamine, nitric oxide, significant postsurgical symptom improvement over
noradrenaline, acetylcholine, and others.15 In addition, 36 months in patients who underwent laparoscopic
it increases natural killer cells, thereby modifying excision of endometriosis. The most notable improve-
immune function and decreasing estrogen production.15 ment was seen in dysmenorrhea, with a 57% reduc-
Pelvic physical therapy has been shown in tion in symptoms; chronic pelvic pain and
a retrospective study to improve endometrial pain in dyspareunia were reduced by 30%. Owing to recur-
63% of patients after at least six sessions.4 Deep pres- rent pain, a second-look surgery was performed in 9%
sure massage, stretching pelvic floor muscles, joint of patients, and histologically confirmed endometri-
mobilization, foam rollers with breathing, and relaxa- osis recurrence was documented in 5%. Of these
tion techniques are the integral elements. patients, 7% benefited from medical therapy.18
Abbott et al demonstrated significant pain relief
SURGICAL MANAGEMENT (80%) after surgery compared with a placebo group
Surgery remains the mainstay in definitive diagnosis. (32%). They report progression of disease with
High-definition video laparoscopy with or without second-look laparoscopy in 45%, no change in 33%,
robotic assistance is the standard initial approach. In and improvement in 22% of patients. Twenty percent
our extensive experience, laparotomy is seldom neces- of cases were not responsive to surgery.18
sary. Excellent illumination with enhanced video mag- Several noninvasive diagnostic tests for endome-
nification enables better recognition of subtle lesions as triosis, such as BCL6 and endometrial function tests
well as the depth of infiltrative lesions. Depending on and blood and saliva tests, are becoming available.
the patient’s desire, location of lesion, availability of These tests are especially important for asymptom-
proper instrumentation, as well as the experience and atic infertility patients and for younger patients, for
skill of the surgeon, eradication of endometriosis can be whom we recommend egg preservation if possible.
achieved with surgical management techniques that We individualize management of ovarian endome-
include excision, vaporization, and ablation. The non- triosis and endometriomas based on the patient’s age,
surgical options discussed above can be used to supple- fertility desires, family history of ovarian cancer, and
ment surgical treatment for long-term results.4 type of endometriomas.4 For many infertility pa-
The best surgical approach for the treatment of tients, restoration of anatomy along with methodical
superficial endometriosis is controversial. A meta- and meticulous treatment of endometriosis can lead
analysis of randomized controlled trials involving 335 to natural conception or increase in overall in vitro
women demonstrated that excision of endometriosis fertilization success.19 The treatment of endometri-
was superior to coagulation in reducing dysmenor- osis needs to be thorough to be effective. We recom-
rhea, dyschezia, and chronic pelvic pain when eval- mend preoperative medical suppression to inhibit
uated at 12 months of follow-up.16 Laser ablation with ovulation and to avoid removal of functional cysts
layer-by-layer vaporization of endometriosis was that might look like endometriomas and possibly
shown to be 65% effective in reducing pain, compared decrease inflammation.
VOL. 134, NO. 4, OCTOBER 2019 Nezhat et al Endometriosis and Pain 837
We prefer conservative treatment for lesions of in the cervix. Up to one quarter of patients will
the rectum and rectal bulb close to the anal verge with undergo subsequent trachelectomy owing to pelvic
associated sympathetic and parasympathetic nerve pain or bleeding after hysterectomy. Tsafrir et al21
involvement. This can be accomplished by shaving demonstrated that the most common pathologic
excision and disc resection rather than through diagnosis and indication for trachelectomy was endo-
segmental resection (Fig. 1).5 Injury to the neurovas- metriosis. In a retrospective review after supracervi-
W+3EnkBEEZeYXgE7jRt4LDj9V96cgdX/XC/lEj875IHmmy6+yMXKsEzR1VbfLPftp0AqqFfXkLZYO1P1xI01yUsDJtVR43dSm7US
cular structures could lead to gastrointestinal and gen- cal hysterectomy, 18% of patients reported pelvic
Downloaded from http://journals.lww.com/greenjournal by yLTqme3WM71OrnTWkogOH26lXQE+lGZAsfUE6xZQqcwa
itourinary (GU) complications such as severe pain and 10% reported dyspareunia related to the
constipation, urinary retention, and loss of bowel or remaining cervix. These patients ultimately under-
bladder function (Fig. 1).5,6 went trachelectomy.22 In a review of trachelectomy
Untreated endometriosis of the GU system can samples, higher cervical nerve fiber density was
have dire side effects, such as silent kidney loss.6 Rad- found in women for whom pelvic pain was the pro-
ical surgical management of problematic GU endo- cedure indication compared with the control group
metriosis may require segmental bladder resection, who had nonpain indications.22 Laparoscopic trache-
ureterolysis, ureteral resection and reanastomosis, lectomy is indicated for endometriosis patients with
and ureteroneocystostomy with or without psoas hitch persistent pelvic pain after supracervical
(Fig. 1).6 hysterectomy.23
CUN3NWRbcX+glak+ on 05/01/2023
For the perimenopausal patient who has com- Though deeply infiltrative endometriosis can
pleted childbearing but still desires conservative invade the superior and inferior hypogastric plexus,
treatment, we recommend surgical treatment of endo- as well as the sympathetic and parasympathetic nerve
metriosis as well as endometrial ablation with salpin- bundles, surgical injury can lead to even more
gectomy to prevent future pregnancy and reduce the devastating effects. We use the Tokyo method to
risk of ovarian and fallopian tube cancer. We also preserve nerves supplying the bowel, bladder, and
recommend postoperative medical therapy and long- sexual organs. This nerve-sparing technique includes
term follow-up to monitor for recurrence. For patients separation and ligation of the vascular portion of the
who do not desire future fertility and have debilitating cardinal ligament while preserving the branches of the
symptoms for which other therapies have failed, we pelvic splanchnic nerves (Fig. 1).5,6 We have previ-
discuss the risk/benefit ratio of a hysterectomy with ously suggested leaving some rectal disease behind
bilateral salpingectomy as well as postoperative med- and opting for postoperative hormonal suppression.
ical suppression to mitigate recurrence. We inform This decreases the risk of injuring the rectum or its
patients that ovarian conservation is not optimally neurovascular bundle, which would necessitate a per-
effective owing to continued hormonal stimulation of manent colostomy (Fig. 1).5
microscopic endometriotic lesions. However, in Surgical treatment of endometriosis can be chal-
a young patient, bilateral salpingo-oophorectomy in lenging owing to its highly vascularized, deeply
addition to hysterectomy without hormone therapy invasive nature. Endometriosis can distort the anat-
may lead to early-onset cardiovascular disease, oste- omy, leading to indistinct planes of dissection. To
oporosis, and urogenital atrophy. In patients with treat patients adequately, the surgeon must be com-
catamenial pneumothorax associated with thoracic fortable dissecting the retroperitoneal spaces. From
endometriosis, we recommend bilateral salpingo- our experience, it is evident that hormonal suppres-
oophorectomy when they have completed childbear- sion may decrease inflammation, allowing for less
ing and when risks of videothoracoscopy outweigh the bloody dissection and optimization of lesion excision.
benefits.4,20 Management of surgical menopause with We therefore recommend some form of temporary
estrogen alone can stimulate growth of endometriosis. hormonal suppression before surgery for patients with
Patients who have undergone hysterectomy with bilat- advanced endometriosis.24
eral salpingo-oophorectomy with subsequent adjuvant Postoperatively, these patients will still need an
combined estrogen and progesterone for endometri- individualized hormonal treatment plan to prevent
osis suppression were found to have a low risk (4%) of microscopic or residual endometriosis from flourish-
recurrence.20 On the contrary, when progesterone is ing. Gonadotropin-releasing hormone agonists and
not used, the recurrence of endometriosis is 5–15%.2,3 progestins have been shown to significantly reduce
If removal of the uterus is indicated, we favor pain.14 Postoperative hormone therapy should
a total hysterectomy over a supracervical approach. include both estrogen and progestogen, because estro-
The rationale lies in the evidence of abnormally gen alone may stimulate growth of microscopic
increased nerve density in the endometrial implants disease.
Although rare, the risk of cancer arising from endo- triosis. Clin Obstet Gynecol 2017;60:485–96.
metriosis warrants close monitoring.25 The complex 15. Xu Y, Zhao W, Li T, Zhao Y, Bu H, Song S. Effects of acu-
and multifactorial nature of endometriosis requires puncture for the treatment of endometriosis-related pain: a sys-
a multidisciplinary approach to treatment. A combi- tematic review and meta-analysis. PLoS One 2017;12:
e0186616.
nation of medical, surgical, psychotherapeutic, and
alternative treatments can improve quality of life for 16. Pundir J, Omanwa K, Kovoor E, Pundir V, Lancaster G, Bar-
ton-Smith P. Laparoscopic excision versus ablation for
women who suffer from endometriosis. Currently endometriosis-associated pain: an updated systematic review
available knowledge and advanced surgical techni- and meta-analysis. J Minim Invasive Gynecol 2017;24:747–56.
ques can be used to reduce the torment and suffering 17. Nezhat CH, Seidman DS, Nezhat FR, Nezhat CR. Long-term
of those afflicted with endometriosis. outcome of laparoscopic presacral neurectomy for the treat-
CUN3NWRbcX+glak+ on 05/01/2023
8. Anaf V, Simon P, El Nakadi I, Fayt I, Buxant F, Simonart T, 24. Meuleman C, Tomassetti C, D’Hoore A, Cleynenbreugel BV,
Penninckx F, Vergote I, et al. Surgical treatment of deeply
et al. Relationship between endometriotic foci and nerves in
infiltrating endometriosis with colorectal involvement. Hum
rectovaginal endometriotic nodules. Hum Reprod 2000;15:
Reprod Update 2011;17:311–26.
1744–50.
25. Nezhat F. The link between endometriosis and ovarian cancer:
9. Zager EL, Pfeifer SM, Brown MJ, Torosian MH, Hackney DB. clinical implications. Int J Gynecol Cancer 2014;24:623–8.
Catamenial mononeuropathy and radiculopathy: a treatable
neuropathic disorder. J Neurosurg 1998;88:827–30.
10. Morotti M. Mechanisms of pain in endometriosis. Eur J Obstet PEER REVIEW HISTORY
Gynecol Reprod Biol 2017;209:8–13.
Received April 16, 2019. Received in revised form June 3, 2019.
11. Barbieri RL. Hormone treatment of endometriosis: the estrogen Accepted June 13, 2019. Peer reviews and author correspondence
threshold hypothesis. Am J Obstet Gynecol 1992;166:740–5. are available at http://links.lww.com/AOG/B521.
VOL. 134, NO. 4, OCTOBER 2019 Nezhat et al Endometriosis and Pain 839