,277DEDQOÕ*HUoHN=DPDQOÕ9HUL7DNLEL<DSDQ
$NÕOOÕ%HEHN%HúL÷L
,27%DVHG%DE\&UDGOH6\VWHPZLWK5HDO7LPH'DWD7UDFNLQJ
hON'XPDQ
(OHNWULN(OHNWURQLN0KHQGLVOL÷L
øVWDQEXO0HGHQL\HWhQLYHUVLWHVL
øVWDQEXO7UNL\H
XONXGPQ#RXWORRNFRP
. ,,,)
#(33
,"
/"/

3,,
$///
,(,
+*,
"$/3$/"
%
$//
"* 


2
 2%%

"
(3

"

#,"*$

///
$(

$
#!"
3/

$"
"
$!
#
"

+

$+""
$$

)
($
 #( "

(2)
2""
&,%$
#//2/
&
%(%
,)"

2
%(%
#/"#/
#//2/
+",
 "
"

"$/3
$3
"
 !#( 
 

+,,

#" %



+
$+""
3/

$"
%

2
"*
)/
#//2//

!
$/
/)//
$//
/#/2//
&
##
$!


#"
$"$
$/
"

)
)#/
(

//
3
(!/#/
+"3
%!
##+""
/
&""

 
"//2/

"
'
!$ "%
$"//!
"*
)/

"
 $" 
$"
2/
%2%
%"%
$  

"
3
#$/"
2"
2
%")#
&(
+*,

&,%$
#//2/
!
$/
/)/
&

#&(#
 "

"
"$/3
+)"#
"
&"(
"$"
"

#(#
&(
&(

//
# "%%
3

%"%
)/
,
$#

2
$(/


/
/)/
"
3
&%3#/
#2$/"

"

2
32
("3$"


("//(
3

,)"

"
&"!
&"#
+)$"

 
 .//

32
"*
)/

#(
3
#"
$"$
 %


. 
$ (#
%#$")
 %$"#
' #

!"$!$ 

$
' " "
#
"$(
"#
#

!"$!$ 
#


$

"# #
$$
$
(
"


(
#
" 
$
"$

$
(
$

"$



 #$
! "$$
$ "#
$$
# %

  '

$#
"

&%#
 (
$!"$%"

#!
!$$"#
'
'


# $#

&$
%$ #

 "
"#

$

$!"$%"

$
(
%"
#!
#


$
 #$
"$

$ "#
%#
#%
$
$
#(" 

"

 !$ 

$#
"$

$"$

$#
 
#

(
 $ "
#
(

#"$
"
#$"%$%"

'
$"#
$
"$
$!"$%"
"$
"$
'$##


# %

$
(
#
!" ! #

$
$
"&
" 

$
## "#
'

$"#""
$

'
!$ "
&
 




"$

$
#

"(
$
"
'
#'

%$   %#(

"
'

$&$

"(
 #
 $

#$ !
"


 "
"#

$
#%"
 (

$!"$%"
"$
"$

%$(
&
#
#"&
#

$
$
"
$
'

#%"
$$
$
!"# 
"#! #
 "

$
"

$
!"$
"
(
'
"#! 
$
$
"
$$
$

(
#


$(
"

$ 
$

'


!

$
"

$
'

 $ "
'$"
"
 $


"
#
&
&"
$
"

  . "$
(
"
#(#$
"$

#
!" ##
$"$

$#
 
 %

ϵϳϴͲϭͲϳϮϴϭͲϳϱϲϱͲϮͬϮϬͬΨϯϭ͘ϬϬΞϮϬϮϬ/
8%0.  WK,QWHUQDWLRQDO&RQIHUHQFHRQ&RPSXWHU6FLHQFHDQG(QJLQHHULQJ
Authorized licensed use limited to: Carleton University. Downloaded on October 27,2020 at 06:02:23 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
(UGR÷DQ$\GÕQ
(OHNWULN(OHNWURQLN0KHQGLVOL÷L
øVWDQEXO0HGHQL\HWhQLYHUVLWHVL
øVWDQEXO7UNL\H
HUGRJDQD\GLQ#PHGHQL\HWHGXWU
, *ø5øù
6RQ ]DPDQODUGD VDQD\LQLQ YH WHNQRORMLQLQ KÕ]OD DUWWÕ÷Õ
ONHOHUGH NDGÕQODUÕQ LúJFQH NDWÕOÕPÕ E\N |OoGH
DUWPÕúWÕU %X NDWÕOÕP LOH DQQH YH EDEDQÕQ EHUDEHU oDOÕúWÕ÷Õ
ELUoRN DLOHGH EHEHN EDNÕPÕ YH VD÷OÕ÷Õ GR÷UXGDQ
HWNLOHQPHNWHGLU +HU LNL HEHYH\QLQ GH HNRQRPLN úDUWODU
\NVHN \DúDP NDOLWHVL JHoLP VÕNÕQWÕODUÕ QHGHQL\OH ELU
\DQGDQ oDOÕúPDVÕ JHUHNPHNWH YH GL÷HU \DQGDQ GD
EHEHNOHULQH EDNPDODUÕ JHUHNPHNWHGLU $LOHGH EX GXUXP
|]HOOLNOH DQQHQLQ Lú \NQ YH VWUHVL DUWWÕUPDNWDGÕU
*HQHOOLNOH oDOÕúDQ HEHYH\QOHU EHEHNOHULQH NHQGLOHUL
EDNDPDPDNWDGÕU %XQGDQ GROD\Õ DQQH YH EDED \D
EHEHNOHULQL NHQGL HEHYH\QOHULQH J|QGHULU \D GD oDOÕúÕUNHQ
ELUEHEHNEDNÕFÕVÕWXWPDN]RUXQGDNDOÕU
.RORPEL\D GD WDQÕQPÕú ELU EHEHN PDUNDVÕ WDUDIÕQGDQ
\DSÕODQ ELU DUDúWÕUPD\D J|UH EHEHNOHULQH EDúNDODUÕQÕQ
EDNPDVÕ GXUXPXQGD EDNÕP HNVLNOLNOHUL YH\D EHEHN
JYHQOL÷L NRQXVXQGD HQGLúH GX\DQ HEHYH\QOHULQ DQD
NRUNXODUÕQGDQ ELULQLQ DQL EHEHN |OP VHQGURPX VXGGHQ
LQIDQW GHDWK V\QGURPH 6,'6  ROGX÷X EXOXQPXúWXU >@
*|UQUGH VD÷OÕNOÕ RODQ ELU EHEH÷LQ  D\  KLoELU |Q
EHOLUWLJ|VWHUPHGHQX\NXVÕUDVÕQGDEHNOHQPHGLNELUELoLPGH
YFXWVÕFDNOÕ÷ÕQÕQ\NVHOPHVL\]QGHQ|OPHVL6,'6RODUDN
WDQÕPODQÕU %X VHQGURPD \DNDODQDQ EHEH÷LQ YFXW
VÕFDNOÕ÷ÕQÕQ \NVHOPH QHGHQL WDP RODUDN ELOLQPHPHNOH
ELUOLNWH oHYUHVHO HWNLOHU JHQHWLN \DWNÕQOÕN YH ED÷ÕúÕNOÕN
VLVWHPLQLQ LOWLKDSODQPDVÕ JLEL IDNW|UOHU WDUDIÕQGDQ
WHWLNOHQGL÷L |QJ|UOPHNWHGLU >@ 6,'6 |OPOHULQLQ oR÷X
JHQHOOLNOHD\OÕNWDQNoNEHEHNOHUGHJ|UOU%XVHQGURP
OLWHUDWUGHEHúLN|OPRODUDNELOLQLUdQN6,'6 WHQ|OHQ
ELUoRN EHEHN KD\DWÕQÕ ND\EHWWL÷L VÕUDGD EHúLNOHULQGH
EXOXQXU <DSÕODQ DUDúWÕUPDODU VRQXFX \HQL GR÷DQ 
EHEHNWHQWDQHVLQLQEXVHQGURPD\DNDODQGÕ÷ÕIDNDWJHUHNOL
|QOHPOHULQ DOÕQPDVÕQÕQ YDND RUDQÕQÕQ E\N |OoGH
D]DOWWÕ÷ÕQÕ RUWD\D NR\PXúWXU %HEH÷LQ VD÷ODP ELU \]H\GH
EHúLN \DWDN  X\XPDVÕQD L]LQ YHUHUHN EX ULVN D]DOWÕODELOLU
$\UÕFD EHEHNOHULQ X\NX G]HQL X\NXVX VÕUDVÕQGD DQRUPDO
ELU VROXQXP KÕ]Õ \DúD\ÕS \DúDPDGÕ÷ÕQÕ YH YFXW VÕFDNOÕ÷Õ
JLEL KD\DWL GH÷HUOHUL VUHNOL RODUDN WDNLS HGLOPHOLGLU >@
.LPL ]DPDQ HEHYH\Q EHEH÷LQL WDNLS HWVH ELOH ELOLPVHO
DQODPGDGR÷UXYHULHOGHHGHPHPHNWHGLUOHU>@
6RQ]DPDQODUGDDNÕOOÕEHEHNVLVWHPLELUoRNDUDúWÕUPDFÕ
WDUDIÕQGDQ LOJL RGD÷Õ KDOLQH JHOPLúWLU %X oDOÕúPDODUGD
oHúLWOLVHQV|UOHUVLVWHPHHNOHQPLúROXSYHNRQWURO\D]ÕOÕPODUÕ
LOH WDNLS HGLOPLúWLU >@ 7DEOR ,¶GH EX PDNDOHGH
NXOODQÕODQ VHQV|UOHU YH \D]ÕOÕPÕQ GL÷HU oDOÕúPDODU LOH
NDUúÕODúWÕUÕOPDVÕ VXQXOPXúWXU 6WQ EDúOÕNODUÕ ³$´ VHV
|OoP³%´YFXWVÕFDNOÕ÷Õ|OoP³&´NDOSDWÕPÕ|OoP
³'´EHEH÷LQQHP|OoP³(´EHúLNVDOODPD³)´ZHE
 7$%/2,g1(5,/(16,67(0,1',ö(5d$/,ù0$/$5/$ EHEH÷LQ KD\DWL GH÷HUOHUH VDKLS RODQ YFXW VÕFDNOÕ÷Õ YH NDOS
.$5ù,/$ù7,5,/0$6,
DWÕPKÕ]ÕLOHDOWÕQÕQÕVODNOÕ÷Õ|OoOPúWU(OGHHGLOHQYHULOHU
QHVQHOHULQ LQWHUQHW LQWHUQHW RI WKLQJV ,27  WHNQRORMLVL











DUDFÕOÕ÷Õ LOH DQDOL] HGLOPHN LoLQ :L)L LOHWLúLPL \ROX\OD
>@



 WDUDIÕPÕ]GDQWDVDUODQDQZHEVLWHVLQHLOHWLOHFHNWLU7DVDUODQDQ
>@



 ZHE VLWHVLQGH JHOHQ YHULOHQ DQOÕN RODUDN
>@



 
 GH÷HUOHQGLULOPHNWHGLU (÷HU EHEH÷LQ D÷ODPDVÕ GXUPD] LVH
>@


 


 YH\DYFXWVÕFDNOÕ÷ÕQGDEHNOHQPHGLNELUDUWÕúJ|]OHPOHQLUVH
>@



 ZHE VLWHVL ]HULQGHQ DODUP VLQ\DOL J|QGHULOHFHNWLU (PDLO
DGUHVLQH J|QGHULOHFHN X\DUÕ VLQ\DOOHUL VD\HVLQGH HEHYH\Q
>@





YH\D EHEHN EDNÕPÕQGDQ VRUXPOX RODQ NLúLQLQ GXUXPD
>@




 ]DPDQÕQGD PGDKDOH HWPHVL LOH EHEH÷LQ LKWL\DFÕ RODQ
>@
 


  EDNÕPD KÕ]OÕ ELU úHNLOGH NDYXúPDVÕ VD÷ODQDFDNWÕU $\UÕFD
>@
   

 EHEH÷LQ GXUXPXQGD DQRUPDO ELU GH÷LúLP ROGX÷XQGD EHúLN
]HULQGH \HU DODQ OHG NÕUPÕ]Õ \DQDFDN ROXS EX VD\HGH
EHEH÷LQ GXUXPX EHúLN ]HULQGHQ GH J|]OHPOHQPHVL
VD÷ODQPÕúWÕU :HE VLWHVL ]HULQGHQ HEHYH\Q YH GRNWRU
NXOODQÕFÕODUÕWDQÕPODQODQPÕúWÕU(EHYH\QEHEH÷LQDQOÕNYH\D
X]XQ VUH ]DUIÕQGD |OoOPú YHULVLQH HULúHELOPHNWHGLU (N
RODUDN EHúL÷L PDQXHO RODUDN DoÕS NDSDWÕOPDVÕ VD÷ODQPÕúWÕU
'RNWRU LVH VDGHFH EHEH÷LQ X]XQ VUH ]DUIÕQGD UHWLOPLú
YHULOHULQHHULúLPVD÷OD\DELOHFHNWLU
,, $.,//,%(ùø.6ø67(0ø1ø17(0(/<$3,6,
%X E|OPGH DNÕOOÕ EHúLN VLVWHPLQL PH\GDQD JHWLUHQ
WHPHO GRQDQÕPODU YH \D]ÕOÕPODU VXQXODFDNWÕU ùHNLO ¶GH
|QHULOHQVLVWHPLQSURWRWLSEORNGL\DJUDPÕVXQXOPXúWXU
$
.XOODQÕODQ6HQV|UOHU
ùHNLO,27WDEDQOÕDNÕOOÕEHúLNVLVWHPLQLQSURWRWLSEORNGL\DJUDPÕ

 6ÕFDNOÕN 6HQV|U 6ÕFDNOÕN VHQV|U VÕFDNOÕ÷Õ HOHNWURQLN
SODWIRUPXQD HULúLP ³*´ DODUÕP PHVDMÕ J|QGHULPL ³+´ HNLSPDQODUOD LúOHQHUHN HOHNWULN VLQ\DOOHULQH G|QúWUHELOHQ
DODUÕPODPEDVÕ³,´GRNWRUNXOODQÕFÕVÕQÕQHULúLPLEDúOÕNODUÕQÕ FLKD]GÕU/0LVLPOLVÕFDNOÕNVHQV|UNXOODQÕODUDNWHPDVLOH
WHPVLO HWPHNWHGLU gQHULOHQ VLVWHPGH EDúOÕNODUGD \HU DODQ DQDORJ VÕFDNOÕN |OoP \DSÕOPÕúWÕU%X oDOÕúPDGD DODUP
WP |]HOOLNOHU \HU DOÕUNHQ NDUúÕODúWÕUÕODQ oDOÕúPDODUGD EX PH\GDQD JHOHFHN VÕFDNOÕN DUDOÕ÷ÕQÕ EHOLUOHPHN LoLQ ELU
|]HOOLNOHULQ ELU NÕVPÕ \HU DOPDNWDGÕU 6,'6¶Õ |QOHPHQLQ HQ EHEH÷LQ QRUPDO YFXW VÕFDNOÕ÷ÕQÕQ ƒ& LOH ƒ& ROGX÷X
WHPHO \|QWHPL YFXW VÕFDNOÕ÷Õ YH NDOS DWÕPÕQÕQ VUHNOL GLNNDWH DOÕQPÕúWÕU >@ ƒ& VWQGHNL VÕFDNOÕN WÕEEL
RODUDN NRQWURO HGLOPHVLGLU %HQ]HU VLVWHPOHULQ oR÷X NDOS EDNÕP JHUHNWLUHQ NULWLN VÕFDNOÕNWÕU %XQGDQ GROD\Õ ƒ&
DWÕPÕQÕ |OoHPHGL÷L LoLQ 6,'6¶Õ |QOHPHN LoLQ \HWHUOL VWQGH ELU YFXW VÕFDNOÕ÷Õ J|]OHPOHQGL÷LQGH X\DUÕ VLQ\DOL
ROPD\DFDNWÕU J|QGHULOHFHNWLU
*HOHQHNVHO EHúLNOHU GúN PDOL\HW YH VDGHOLNOHULQGHQ  6HV 6HQV|U 6HV VHQV|U RUWDPGDNL VHV GDOJDODUÕ
GROD\Õ N|\OHUGH YH\D NHQWVHO ROPD\DQ DODQODUGD NXOODQÕOÕU VD\HVLQGHELURUWDPÕQVHV\R÷XQOX÷XQXWHVSLWHWPH\LVD÷ODU
%XQXQOD ELUOLNWH PDQXHO RODUDN VDOODQÕOÕU YH LQVDQ JF .< NRGOX VHV VHQV|U NXOODQÕODUDN DQDORJ VHV |OoP
JHUHNWLULU 2WRPDV\RQGDQ \RNVXQ YH HOHNWURQLN RODUDN \DSÕOPÕúWÕU gOoOHQ GH÷HUOHU GHFLEHO G%  GH÷HULQH
GRQDQÕPOÕGH÷LOGLUOHU%XPDNDOHGH|QHULOHQEHúLNEHEH÷LQ G|QúWUOHUHN LúOHP \DSÕOPÕúWÕU 6HQV|UQ RUWDPGDNL
GXUXPXQX JHUoHN ]DPDQOÕ RODUDN L]OHPHGH GDKD UDKDW JUOWGHQ GH HWNLOHQGL÷L YDUVD\ÕODUDN RUWDPGDNL VHV
JYHQOL YH YHULPOL RODFDN úHNLOGH DNÕOOÕ KDOH JHWLULOHUHN VHYL\HVLQLQ  G% LOH  G% DUDVÕ ROPDVÕ GXUXPXQGD
RWRPDWLNOHúWLULOPLúWLU gQHULOHQ DNÕOOÕ EHúLN VDGHFH HY EHEHN D÷OÕ\RU ELOJLVL UHWLOHFHN ROXS DODUP ELOJLVL
RUWDPÕQGDNL NXOODQÕPD GH÷LO D\QÕ ]DPDQGD KDVWDQH LOHWLOHFHNWLU
RUWDPÕQGDNL EHEHN EDNÕP QLWHOHULQH GH NXOODQÕPD X\JXQ
RODUDNWDVDUODQPÕúWÕU  '& 0RWRU YH 0RWRU 6UFV '& PRWRU HOHNWULN
%X PDNDOHGH DQL ELU GXUXPGD ELU EHEH÷LQ LKWL\Do HQHUMLVLQL PHNDQLN HQHUML\H G|QúWUHQ PDNLQHGLU %X
GX\GX÷XEDNÕPDKÕ]OÕELUúHNLOGHXODúÕODELOPHVLLoLQEHEH÷L oDOÕúPDGD PDNVLPXP 9 JHULOLP LOH oDOÕúDQ '& PRWRU
WDNLS HWPHN YH EHEHNWH ROXúDELOHFHN 6,'6 VHQGURPXQX /1 PRWRU VUF HQWHJUHVL LOH NRQWURO HGLOPHNWHGLU
|QOHPHN DPDoODQPÕúWÕU %XQX JHUoHNOHúWLUPHN LoLQ oHúLWOL .XOODQÕODQEXPRWRUVD\HVLQGHD÷ODPDDOJÕODQGÕ÷ÕGXUXPGD
VHQV|UOHUQRGHPFXYHDUGXLQREHUDEHUNXOOQÕOPÕúWÕU%HúL÷L EHúL÷LQRWRPDWLNRODUDNVDOODQPDVÕVD÷ODQDFDNWÕU
KHP DNÕOOÕ KDOH JHWLUPHN KHP GH RWRQRP ELU VLVWHPH  1DEÕ] gOoHU 6HQV|U 1DEÕ] |OoHU VHQVRU NDOS DWÕú KÕ]ÕQÕ
G|QúWUPHN LoLQ \DSÕODFDN LON DGÕP VHV VHQV|UQ EHOLUOHPHN YH WDNLS HWPHN LoLQ NXOODQÕOÕU .< LVLPOL
\HUOHúWLUPHN ROPXúWXU 6HV VHQV|U VD\HVLQGH ELU EHEH÷LQ QDEÕ] |OoHU VHQV|U NXOODQÕOPÕúWÕU 1DEÕ] |OoHU WHPDV LOH
D÷ODPD GXUXPX VUHNOL RODUDN NRQWURO HGLOPHNWHGLU (÷HU DQDORJQDEÕ]|OoP\DSPDNWDGÕU%HEHNOHUGHQDEÕ]KÕ]Õ
D÷ODPD YDUVD LON RODUDN D÷ODPD\Õ GXUGXUPDN LoLQ EHúL÷LQ ESV LOH  ESV DUDOÕ÷ÕQGD ROXS YH RUWDODPD  ESV
RWRPDWLN RODUDN VDOODQPDVÕ VD÷ODQPÕúWÕU 'DKD VRQUD ROPDOÕGÕU>@%HEHNWHQRNXQDQQDEÕ]GH÷HULQLQROPDVÕ

8%0.  WK,QWHUQDWLRQDO&RQIHUHQFHRQ&RPSXWHU6FLHQFHDQG(QJLQHHULQJ

Authorized licensed use limited to: Carleton University. Downloaded on October 27,2020 at 06:02:23 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.

ùHNLO3URWRWLSGHYUHLoLQHOHNWURQLNED÷ODQWÕúHPDVÕ
QDEÕ] \RN  ESV LQ DOWÕQD GúPHVL GúN QDEÕ] YH 
ESV¶QLQ VWQH oÕNPDVÕ LVH \NVHN QDEÕ] GH÷HUL RODUDN
WDQÕPODQDFDNWÕU 1RUPDO ROPD\DQ EX GXUXPODUGD DODUP
ELOJLVLLOHWLOHFHNWLU
 1HP6HQV|U1HPVHQV|USUREODUÕQÕQLoLQHEXOXQGX÷X
\]H\LQ QHP PLNWDUÕQÕ |OoHU %X oDOÕúPDGD </ LVLPOL
QHP VHQV|U LOH DQDORJ RODUDN EHEH÷LQ DOWÕQÕQ ÕVODNOÕ÷Õ
NRQWURO HGLOPHNWHGLU gOoOHQ GH÷HU \]GH RODUDN
KHVDSODQPÕúWÕU(÷HUQHPVHYL\HVL¶GHQGDKD\NVHNLVH
DODUPELOJLVLLOHWLOHFHNWLU
 øNL 5HQNOL /HG 0RGO /HG
HOHNWULN HQHUMLVLQL ÕúÕ÷D
G|QúWUHQ\DUÕLOHWNHQELUGHYUHHOHPDQÕGÕU.<LVLPOL
OHGPRGO\HúLOYHNÕUPÕ]ÕUHQNWHÕúÕNUHWLU/HGLQNÕUPÕ]Õ
\DQPDVÕ VRQXFX YHULQLQ DQRUPDO ROGX÷X \HúLO \DQPDVÕ
VRQXFXLVHYHULQLQQRUPDOROGX÷XELOJLVLQLZHEVLWHVLQH
%.XOODQÕODQ.RQWURO'HYUHOHUL
 1RGHPFX %X oDOÕúPDGD WHPHO NRQWUROOHU RODUDN
1RGHPFX WHUFLK HGLOPLúWLU 1RGHPFX ILUPZDUH \NO
(63:L)LPRGOEDUÕQGÕUDQELUJHOLúWLUPHNDUWÕGÕU>@
%X PRGO VHQV|UOHUGHQ YHULQLQ JHUoHN ]DPDQOÕ RODUDN
DOÕQPDVÕDQDOL]HGLOPHVLYHLVWHQPH\HQGXUXPROXúWX÷XQGD
DODUPVLQ\DOOHULQLQJ|QGHULOPHVLQGHQVRUXPOXGXU
 $UGXLQR 8QR %X oDOÕúDPGD NXOODQÕODQ GL÷HU DNÕOOÕ NDUW
$UGXLQR8QR]HULQGH$7PHJDPLNURLúOHPFLVLEXOXQDQ
DoÕN ND\QDN NRGOX GRQDQÕPÕGÕU $UGXLQR 8QR NXOODQÕODUDN
ED]Õ VHQV|UOHUGHQ DOÕQQ YHULQLQ JHUoHN ]DPDQOÕ RODUDN
DOÕQPDVÕ YH VHUL LOHWLúLP \DUGÕPÕ\OD 1RGHPFX¶\D
J|QGHULOPHVLVD÷ODQDFDNWÕU
&.RQWURO'HYUHOHUL$UDVÕøOHWLúLP
$UGXLQRLOH1RGHPFXDUDVÕQGDELUVHULLOHWLúLPSURWRNRO
RODQ VHQNURQ VHUL KDEHUOHúPH SURWRNRO LQWHULQWHJUDWHG
FLUFXLW,& NXOODQÕOPÕúWÕU9HULDNWDUÕPÕLoLQVHULYHULKDWWÕ
VHULDO GDWD OLQH 6'/  NXOODQÕOÕUNHQ VHQNURQL]DV\RQ LoLQ
VHUL ]DPDQ KDWWÕ VHULDO FORFN OLQH 6&/  NXOODQÕOPÕúWÕU %X
\|QWHP LOH $UGXLQR 8QR WDUDIÕQGDQ HOGH HGLOHQ YHULOHU
NDEOROXED÷ODQWÕ\DUGÕPÕ\OD1RGHPFX¶\DLOHWLOHFHNWLU
8%0.  WK,QWHUQDWLRQDO&RQIHUHQFHRQ&RPSXWHU6FLHQFHDQG(QJLQHHULQJ
Authorized licensed use limited to: Carleton University. Downloaded on October 27,2020 at 06:02:23 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
D  E 
ùHNLO D $NÕOOÕEHúLNVLVWHPLSURWRWLSJ|VWHULPL E DNÕOOÕEHúLNVLVWHPL
SURWRWLSLQHVDOODPDVLVWHPLQLQPRQWHHGLOPLúJ|VWHULPL
1RGHPFX IL]LNVHO ELU ED÷ODQWÕ KDWWÕ ROPDGDQ :L)L
]HULQGHQ YHULQLQ LOHWLPL YH DOÕPÕ \DSDUDN ZHE VLWHVL LOH
LOHWLúLPLQL VD÷ODPDNWÕU :HE VLWHVLQH LOHWLOHQ YHUL VRQ
NXOODQÕFÕODU LoLQ VDNODQÕU YH JUDILNVHO RODUDN
J|UVHOOHúWLULOHUHNRNXQPDVÕNROD\ODúWÕUÕOÕU
'%HVOHPH9H(OHNWURQLN7DVDUÕP
ùHNLO¶GHgQHULOHQVLVWHPLQSURWRWLSHOHNWURQLNED÷ODQWÕ
úHPDVÕ YHULOPLúWLU %X ED÷ODQWÕ úHPDVÕQGD 1RGHPFX YH
$UGXLQR8QR¶QXQWRSUDNODPDSLQLRODQ*1'SLQLEUHDGERUG
]HULQGH ELUOHúWLULOLU %X VD\HGH $UGXLQR YH 1RGHPFX¶\D
ED÷ODQDFDNRODQJoND\QDNODUÕPRWRUVUFYHVHQV|UOHULQ
*1'SLQOHULELUOHúWLULOPLúROXUùHNLO¶GH*1'VL\DKUHQNOL
NDEOR LOH WHPVLO HGLOPLúWLU $UGXLQR 9LQ SLQLQGHQ 9¶OXN
'& Jo ND\QD÷ÕQD ED÷ODQÕUNHQ 1RGHPFX 9LQ SLQLQGHQ
9 ¶OXN '& Jo ND\QD÷ÕQD ED÷ODQÕU 0RWRU 6UF
EHVOHPHVL 9¶OXN '& Jo ND\QD÷ÕQD ED÷ODQÕU $UGXLQR
\DUGÕPÕ\ODEUHDGERDUG¶D9¶OXNJHULOLPVD÷ODQÕUùHNLOGH
9&&NÕUPÕ]ÕUHQNWHNDEORLOHWHPVLOHGLOPLúWLU1RGHPFXYH
$UGXLQR DUDVÕQGD YHUL DNWDUÕPÕQÕ VD÷ODPDN LoLQ 6'$ KDWWÕ
NDKYHUHQJLNDEORLOHJ|VWHULOLUNHQ6&/KDWWÕJULUHQNOLNDEOR
LOHWHPVLOHGLOPHNWHGLU1HPVHQV|UEH\D]UHQNOLNDEORLOH
QDEÕ] VHQV|UQQ SHPEH UHQNOL NDEOR LOH VÕFDNOÕN VHQV|U
WXUXQFXNDEORLOHYHVHVVHQV|ULVHWXUNXD]UHQNOLNDEORLOH
J|VWHULOPLúWLU %X VHQV|UOHU ]HULQGHQ DQDORJ YHUL
RNXQDFDNWÕU  UHQNOL OHG PRGO PDYL UHQNOL NDEORODU LOH
LIDGH HGLOLUNHQ PRWRU VUF PRU UHQNOL NDEORODU LOH
J|VWHULOPLúWLU %X VHQV|UOHU ]HULQGHQ GLMLWDO YHUL
J|QGHULOPHNWHGLU '& PRWRUXQ DUWÕ XFX VDUÕ NDEOR LOH '&
PRWRUXQ HNVL XFX \HúLO NDEOR LOH J|VWHULOPLúWLU 7P
VHQV|UOHULQ9&&YH*1'ED÷ODQWÕODUÕEUHDGERDUG]HULQGHQ
VD÷ODQPDNWDGÕU
'%HúLN7DVDUÕPÕ
ùHNLO D¶GD SURWRWLSL VXQXODQ VLVWHPLQ LoLQH \HUOHúWLULOHFH÷L
EHúLN GL]D\QÕ JHOHQHNVHO EHúLNOHU GLNNDWH DOÕQDUDN
ROXúWXUXOPXVWXU *HOHQHNVHO EHúLNOHU WDKWDGDQ
\DSÕOPDNWDGÕU 7DKWDQÕQ HQ WHPHO |]HOOL÷L GR÷DO ROPDVÕ YH
LQVDQ VD÷OÕ÷ÕQD ]DUDU YHUPHPHVLGLU 7DKWD EHúLNOHU KLoELU
]DPDQ GHPLU EHúLNOHU JLEL SDVODQPD] YH X]XQ VUHOL
NXOODQÕPD X\JXQGXU (N RODUDN WDKWD \DOÕWNDQ ELU PDO]HPH
ROGX÷X LoLQ VLVWHPGH ROXúDELOHFHN RODVÕ ELU HOHNWULN
NDoD÷ÕQGDQ EHEH÷LQ ]DUDU J|UPHVLQL HQJHOOHQPLú
ROPDNWDGÕU 7DKWD EHúLNOHU GúN PDOL\HWOHUL YH
VDGHOLNOHULQGHQGROD\ÕKHU]DPDQHEHYH\QOHULQRGDNQRNWDVÕ
KDOLQHJHOPHNWHGLU

ùHNLO6LVWHPLQLúDNÕúÕúHPDVÕ
%HúL÷LROXúWXUPDNLoLQLON|QFHND\ÕQD÷DFÕQGDQNHVLOHQ
SDUoDODUÕQNHUHVWHKDOLQHG|QúWUOPHVLGDKDVRQUDNHUHVWH
PDO]HPHVL JHUHNOL E\NONOHUGH NHVLOHUHN DPDFD X\JXQ
RODUDN ELUOHúWLULOPHVL VD\HVLQGH EHúLN KDOLQH
G|QúWUOPúWU %HúLN [[ FP ER\XWODUÕQGDGÕU
%HúL÷LQ GÕú FHSKHVLQH YHUQLN VUOS DKúDS úHNOLQH
G|QúWUOPúWU hUHWLOHQ PDQXDO EHúL÷L DNÕOOÕ KDOH
G|QúWUPHN LoLQ LON RODUDN VLVWHPLQ G|QPHVLQL VD÷OD\DFDN
oJHQH ED÷OÕ GLNG|UWJHQ GHPLU VLVWHPL WDVDUODQPÕúWÕU
'HPLULQ ELU XFX '& PRWRUD ND\QDN \DUGÕPÕ LOH ED÷ODQÕS
'& PRWRU VLVWHPH PRQWH HGLOPLúWLU 'HPLULQ GL÷HU XFX LVH
EHúL÷LQ NDIDVLQLQ DOWÕQD PRQWH HGLOPLúWLU '& PRWRU
G|QHUNHQ oJHQLQ N|úHOHU DUDVÕQGDNL X]XQOXN IDUNÕ
VD\HVLQGH EHúL÷LQ VDOODQPDVÕ VD÷ODQÕU %HúL÷LQ VDOODPD
VLVWHPLPRWHHGLOPLúVRQKDOLùHNLOE¶GHYHULOPLúULU
(6LVWHP<D]ÕOÕP0LPDULVL
(OHDOÕQDQWDVDUÕPGDVHQV|UOHU]HULQGHQYHUL\LRNXPDN
LoLQ 1RGHPFX YH $UGXLQR 8QR $UGXLQR ,GH SURJUDPÕ
\DUGÕPÕ\ODSURJUDPODPD\DSÕOPÕúWÕU'DKDVRQUDHOGHHGLOHQ
YHULOHUL ZHE RUWDPÕQD J|QGHULOPHVL LoLQ ELU ZHE VLWHVL DODQ
DGÕ VDWÕQ DOÕQGÕ $OÕQDQ DODQ DGÕ VD\HVLQGH 3KSVWRUP ,GHVL
]HULQGH-DYDVFULSW3URJUDPODPDGLOLNXOODQÕODUDNZHEVLWHVL
WDVDUODQGÕ $UGXLQR ,GH ]HULQGHQ KWWS KRVW LVWH÷L
J|QGHULOHUHNZHEVLWHVLYH1RGHPFXELUELUL\OHKDEHUOHúPHVL
VD÷ODQPÕúWÕU
)6LVWHP2SHUDV\RQ0HNDQL]PDVÕ
ùHNLO ¶GH DNÕOOÕ EHEHN EHúL÷L VLVWHPLQLQ JHQHO Lú DNÕúÕ
úHPDVÕQÕ J|VWHUPHNWHGLU 0LNURGHQHWOH\LFLOHULQ JF
DoÕOGÕ÷ÕQGD1RGHPFX QXQ|QFHGHQD\DUODQPÕú:L)LD÷ÕQD
ED÷ODQPDVÕ JHUHNLU 6LVWHP VHV VHQV|UQGHQ DOJÕODQDQ
YHUL\L NRQWURO HGHUHN oDOÕúPD\D EDúODU gOoOHQ VHV YHULVL
U]JDU YH\D JUOW QHGHQL\OH GDOJDODQDELOLU %|\OHFH
GDOJDODQPD WHVSLWL LoLQ ELU GL]L HúLN GH÷HUL EHOLUOHQPLúWLU
$÷ODPD WHVSLW HGLOGL÷LQGH |OoOHQ GH÷HU 6R  HúLN GH÷HULQL
6W  DúDU YH '& PRWRU G|QPH\H EDúOD\DUDN EHúL÷L VDOODU
%HúLNVDOODQPDVUHVL %G %W GDNLNDJHoWLLVH %G!%W 
8%0.  WK,QWHUQDWLRQDO&RQIHUHQFHRQ&RPSXWHU6FLHQFHDQG(QJLQHHULQJ
Authorized licensed use limited to: Carleton University. Downloaded on October 27,2020 at 06:02:23 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
D E
F G
ùHNLO$NÕOOÕEHúLNVLVWHPLQLQPRQWHHGLOPLúVRQKDOL
D\QÕ ]DPDQGD NXOODQÕFÕ\D HPDLO \ROX\OD ELOJL VLQ\DOL
J|QGHULOLUYHNÕUPÕ]ÕOHGDNWLIHGLOLU'DKDVRQUDEHEH÷HDLW
VÕFDNOÕN YHULVL 6ÕR  NDOS DWÕPÕ YHULVL 1DR  QHP YHULVL 1V 
NRQWURO HGLOLU gOoOHQ YHUL HúLN GH÷HULQL 1W 1W  
DúDUVD YH\D GDKD GúNVH 1W !1DR  NXOODQÕFÕ\D HPDLO
\ROX\OD DODUP ELOJLVL J|QGHULOLU YH NÕUPÕ]Õ OHG DNWLI HGLOLU
(OGH HGLOHQ WP YHULOHU QRUPDO LVH \HúLO OHG DNWLI HGLOLU YH
VLVWHPWHNUDUGDQD\QÕLúOHPLVRUJXODPDNLoLQEDúDG|QHU
($NÕOOÕ%HEHN%HúL÷LQLQøPSOHPHQWDV\RQX
hUHWLOHQ PDQXDO EHúL÷LQ DOWÕQD LON RODUDN '& PRWRU
PRQWH HGLOPLúWLU 'DKD VRQUD EHúLN ]HULQH 1RGHPFX
$UGXLQR8QRYHVHQV|UOHUPRQWHHGLOHUHNVLVWHPLQGR÷UXELU
úHNLOGH oDOÕúWÕ÷Õ J|]OHPOHQPLúWLU 7P VLVWHPLQ ELUELULQH
ED÷ODQGÕ÷Õ GHYUH \DSÕVÕ ùHNLO D¶GD YHULOPLúWLU 'DKD VRQUD
6LVWHPLQ $NÕOOÕ EHEHN EHúL÷L SURWRWLSLQLQ HNOHQPLú VRQ KDOL
LVHùHNLO¶GDVXQXOPXúWXU
,,, %8/*8/$5
%XE|OPGHDNÕOOÕEHúLNVLVWHPLQGHQHOGHGLOHQEXOJXODU
VXQXODFDNWÕU
$6HQV|U7HVWOHUL
 6ÕFDNOÕN6HQV|U6ÕFDNOÕNVHQV|ULoLQ\DSÕODQWHVWOHUHWLN
JHUHNOLOLNOHU QHGHQL\OH FDQOÕODU ]HULQGH \DSÕOPD\ÕS ELU VX
GROX EHKHULQ VÕFDNOÕN GH÷LúLPL ]HULQGHQ J|]OHPOHQPLúWLU
%X DúDPDGD VÕFDNOÕN VHQV|UQ WHVW HWPHN LoLQ ƒ &
VÕFDNOÕ÷ÕQGD VX LOH GROX ELU EHKHULQ LoLQH GLMLWDO WHUPRPHWUH
NRQXOPXúWXU /0 VHQV|U LVH EHKHULQ GÕúÕQD
VDELWOHQPLúWLU'LMLWDOWHUPRPHWUHYH/0LOHD\QÕ
 7$%/2,,6,&$./,.9(1$%,=6(16g5hød,1g/dh06218d/$5,



&
!

!#
 



"


$

&
&

$


    
    
    
    
    
    
    
    
    
    

]DPDQGD|OoOHQVÕFDNOÕNGH÷HUOHULND\ÕWHGLOPLúWLUgOoP
VRQXoODUÕ7DEOR,, GHYHULOPHNWHGLU
 6HV 6HQV|U 6HV VHQV|U LOH LOJLOL RODUDN \DSÕODQ WHVWOHU
LoLQ LON RODUDN VHV VHQV|U WULPSRWXQXQ KDVVDVL\HW D\DUÕ HQ
GúN GH÷HU RODFDN úHNLOGH D\DUODQGÕ %LU ND\GÕQ VHV
ùHNLO:HEVLWHVLDQDVD\IDDUD\]
VHYL\HVLNDGHPHOLRODUDNDUWÕUÕOGÕ÷ÕQGD|OoOHQVHVGH÷HULQLQ
\NVHOGL÷L YH D]DOWÕOGÕ÷ÕQGD LVH VHV GH÷HULQLQ GúW÷
J|]OHPOHQPLúWLU 'DKD VRQUD VHV VHQV|UQQ WULPSRWX
KDVVDVL\HWD\DUÕHQ\NVHNRODFDNúHNLOGHD\DUODQGÕ.D\ÕW
LúOHPLQLQ VHV VHYL\HVLQL NDGHPHOL RODUDN DUWWÕUGÕ÷ÕPÕ]GD
|OoOHQ VHV GH÷HULQLQ \NVHOGL÷LQL YH D]DOWÕOGÕ÷ÕQGD LVH VHV
GH÷HULQLQ GúW÷ J|]OHPOHQGL  gOoP VRQXFXQGD OLQHHU
ROPD\DQ VHV GH÷HUOHUL HOGH HGLOGLOPLúWLU %XQXQ VHEHEL
|OoOHQ YHULQLQ U]JDU YH\D JUOW QHGHQL\OH
GDOJDODQPDVÕQGDQND\QDNODQPDNWDGÕU
 1DEÕ] gOoHU 6HQV|U 1DEÕ] VHQV|U SDUPDNWDQ QDEÕ]
RNX\DFDN úHNLOGH LúDUHW SDUPD÷ÕQD VDELWOHQPLúWLU %LU
WDQVL\RQPDNLQDVÕQDEÕ]|OoHFHNúHNLOGHNRODED÷ODQGÕ$\QÕ
DQGD LNL FLKD]GD oDOÕúWÕUÕODUDN ELU LQVDQÕQ QDEÕ] GH÷HUOHUL
|OoOGøON|OoPGLQOHQPHHVQDVÕQGDRNXQPXúWXU6RQ
|OoP LVH HJ]HUVL] \DSÕOGÕNWDQ VRQUD RNXQPXúWXU %X
GH÷HUOHU 7DEOR ¶\H ND\GHGLOPLúWLU gOoOHQ GH÷HUOHU
DUDVÕQGD%SV¶OLNGH÷LúLPROGX÷XJ|]OHPOHQPLúWLU
 1HP 6HQV|U 1HP VHQV|U LOH \DSÕODQ WHVWOHU LoLQ LON
RODUDNWDQHEHKHUDOÕQGÕEHKHUHVXGROGXUXOGXEHKHUH
oDPXU GROGXUXOGX YH  EHKHUH LVH WRSUDN GROGXUXOGX ùHNLO:HERUWDPÕQGDDQOÕN|OoPGH÷HUOHUL QRUPDOGXUXP 
$UGÕQGDQ QHP VHQV|U VÕUDVÕ\OD  EHKHUH GH VRNXOXS WÕNODGÕ÷Õ ]DPDQ EHúLN VDOODQDFDN YH EXWRQXQ GXUXPX
oÕNDUÕOGÕ  EHKHUGH RUWDODPD  DUDVÕ GH÷HU DOGÕ÷Õ  ³NDSDOÕ´ RODUDN GH÷LúHFHNWLU (÷HU NDSDOÕ EXWRQD EDVÕOÕUVD
EHKHUGH  DUDVÕ GH÷HU DOGÕ÷Õ YH  EHKHUGH RUWDODPD VDOODQDQ EHúLN GXUDFDNWÕU (N RODUDN DQDVD\ID E|OPQQ
DUDVÕGH÷HUDOGÕ÷ÕJ|]OHPOHQGL RUWDVÕQGD DQOÕN VHV DQOÕN VÕFDNOÕN DQOÕN QHP YH DQOÕN NDOS
%:HE6LWHVLQLQ7HVW'H÷HUOHUL DWÕPÕ GH÷HUOHUL \HU DOPDNWDGÕU %|\OHFH NXOODQÕFÕ DQDVD\ID
\DUGÕPÕ\OD EHEH÷LQLQ DQOÕN YHULOHULQH XODúDELOLU ùHNLO ¶GH
ùHNLO ¶GD ZHE VLWHVLQLQ DQDVD\ID DUD\] VXQXOPXúWXU ZHEVLWHVLQLQJUDILNOHUDUD\]YHULOPLúWLU*UDILN]HULQGH
:HE VLWHVLQLQ LVPL ³$%%6´ RODUDN NÕVDOWÕOPÕúWÕU %X LVPLQ GDNLNDOÕN|OoPVRQXFXQGDHOGHHGLOHQYHULoL]GLULOPLúWLU
DoÕOÕPÕ ³$NÕOOÕ %HEHN %HúL÷L 6LVWHPL´ GLU 5HVPLQ VRO <HUDODQJUDILNOHULQ\DWD\HNVHQLYHULQLQ|OoOG÷]DPDQÕ
NÕVPÕQGDPDYLPHQoXEX÷XQGD³$QDVD\ID´³+DNNÕPÕ]GD´
³*UDILNOHU´ ³.XOODQÕFÕ 7DQÕPODPD´ YH ³'RNWRU J|VWHULUNHQ GLNH\ HNVHQL LVH VHV VHQV|U LoLQ G% FLQVLQGHQ
7DQÕPODPD´ EXWRQODUÕ \HU DOPDNWDGÕU 5HVPLQ VD÷ VW VHV GH÷HULQL VÕFDNOÕN VHQV|U LoLQ ƒ& FLQVLQGHQ YFXW
N|úHVLQGH NXOODQÕFÕ UHVPL J|UQPHNWHGLU $QDVD\ID VÕFDNOÕ÷ÕQÕ QDEÕ] |OoHU VHQVRU LoLQ ESV FLQVLQGHQ QDEÕ]
E|OPQQRUWDE|OPQGHLVHWDNYLPFLKD]GXUXPXEHúLN GH÷HULQL YH QHP VHQV|U LoLQ \]GH RODUDN |OoOHQ QHP
VDOODPDYHOHGLoLQDQOÕNELOJLOHUEXOXQPDNWDGÕU(÷HUFLKD] GH÷HULQL LIDGH HWPHNWHGLU *UDILNOHULQ VW WDUDIÕQGD |OoOHQ
LQWHUQHWH ED÷OÕ LVH FLKD] GXUXPX ³ED÷ODQWÕ YDU´ RODUDN DQOÕNYHULYHEHEH÷LQGXUXPXKDNNÕQGDELOJL\HUDOPDNWDGÕU
J|VWHULOLU(÷HUFLKD]LQWHUQHWHED÷ODQPDGÕLVHFLKD]GXUXPX ùHLO ¶GHNL JUDILNOHUGH VHV VÕFDNOÕN QHP YH NDOS DWÕPÕ
³ED÷ODQWÕ \RN´ RODUDN J|VWHULOLU %XUDGD NXOODQÕFÕ LVWHGL÷L GH÷HUOHULQLQQRUPDOROGXNODUÕJ|]OHPOHQLU'H÷HUOHUQRUPDO
]DPDQ EHúL÷LQ VDOODQPDVÕQÕ DNWLI HGHELOLU YH\D VDOODQDQ ROGX÷X LoLQ VHV JUDIL÷LQLQ VW NÕVPÕQGD ³dRFXN X\X\RU´
EHúL÷LGXUGXUDELOLU%XQX\DSPDNLoLQDoÕNEXWRQXQD VÕFDNOÕNJUDIL÷LQLQVWNÕVPÕQGD³6ÕFDNOÕNQRUPDO´.DOS

8%0.  WK,QWHUQDWLRQDO&RQIHUHQFHRQ&RPSXWHU6FLHQFHDQG(QJLQHHULQJ

Authorized licensed use limited to: Carleton University. Downloaded on October 27,2020 at 06:02:23 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.

ùHNLO:HERUWDPÕQGDDQOÕN|OoPGH÷HUOHUL DQRUPDOGXUXP 
DWÕPÕ JUDIL÷LQLQ VW NÕVPÕQGD ³.DOS DWÕPÕ QRUPDO´ YH QHP
JUDIL÷LQLQ VW NÕVPÕQGD ³1HP QRUPDO´ ELOJLOHUL \HU DOÕU
*UDILNOHU VD\HVLQGH NXOODQÕFÕODU EHEH÷LQ X]XQ VUH ]DUIÕQGD
UHWLOPLú YHULOHULQH HULúLP VD÷OD\DELOLU ùHNLO ¶GHNL
JUDILNOHU LVH VHV VÕFDNOÕN QHP YH NDOS DWÕPÕ GH÷HUOHULQLQ
DQRUPDO ELU úHNLOGH VH\UHWWL÷LQL J|VWHULU *UDILNOHULQ VW
WDUDIÕQGD |OoOHQ DQOÕN YHUL YH EHEH÷LQ GXUXPX KDNNÕQGD
ELOJL\HUDOÕU
'H÷HUOHUDQRUPDOROGX÷XLoLQVHVJUDIL÷LQLQVWNÕVPÕQGD
³dRFXN D÷OÕ\RU´ VÕFDNOÕN JUDIL÷LQLQ VW NÕVPÕQGD ³6ÕFDNOÕN
\NVHN´ .DOS DWÕPÕ JUDIL÷LQLQ VW NÕVPÕQGD ³.DOS DWÕPÕ
\NVHN´ YH QHP JUDIL÷LQLQ VW NÕVPÕQGD ³1HP \NVHN´
ELOJLOHUL\HUDOÕU7PJUDILNLVLPOHULQLQ]HULQGHLVH³$LOH\H
PDLOJ|QGHULOGL´ELOJLVL\HUDOPDNWDGÕU%XGXUXPGDYHOL\H
X\DUÕHPDLOLDWÕOGÕ÷ÕJ|]OHPOHQHELOLU
ùHNLO¶GDVHVYHULVLQLQQRUPDOROPDGÕ÷ÕGXUXPGDYHOL\H
HPDLO]HULQGHQJLGHQDODUPPHVDMÕJ|VWHULOPLúWLU6HVLoLQ
³0HUKDEDODU oRFX÷XQX] D÷OÕ\RU´ VÕFDNOÕN LoLQ
³0HUKDEDODU oRFX÷XQX]XQ VÕFDNOÕ÷Õ \NVHN´ QHP LoLQ
³0HUKDEDODU oRFX÷XQX]XQ DOWÕ ÕVODQGÕ´ YH NDOS DWÕPÕ LoLQ
³0HUKDEDODU oRFX÷XQX]XQ NDOS DWÕPÕ \NVHN´ JLEL DODUP
PHVDMODUÕJ|QGHULOLU
,9 '(ö(5/(1'ø50(9(6218d/$5
*QP] WHNQRORMLVLQL LQVDQODUÕQ LúLQL NROD\ODúWÕUPDN LoLQ
NXOODQDUDN EX PDNDOH NDSVDPÕQGD ,27 WHNQRORMLVL WDEDQOÕ
EHEHN L]OHPH VLVWHPLQH VDKLS DNÕOOÕ ELU EHúLN VLVWHPL
|QHULOPLúWLU gQHULOHQ V\VWHPLQ GL÷HU oDOÕúPDODUOD
NDUúÕODúWÕUÕOPDVÕ 7DEOR ¶GH YHULOPLúWLU gQHULOHQ VLVWHP
NDUúÕODúWÕUÕODQ VLVWHPOHUH J|UH ROGXNoD VWQGU *HQHO
RODUDN NDOS DWÕP |OoPQQ GR÷UXOX÷X DODUP YH ZHE
SODWIRUPX GL÷HU oDOÕúPDODUD J|UH VWQ \DQODUÕGÕU $\UÕFD
HOH DOÕQDQ VLVWHPGH NXOODQÕODQ VHQV|UOHU NÕ]ÕO|WHVL GDOJDODU
\D\PDGDQWHPDVLOH|OoP\DSWÕNODUÕLoLQEHEH÷LQVD÷OÕ÷ÕQÕ
HWNLOH\HFHN ELU   UDG\DV\RQ    GH÷HUL    UHWLOPH] 6LVWHP
WDUDIÕQGDQ HOGH HGLOHQ YHULQLQ ZHE SODWIRUPX WDUDIÕQGDQ
VDNODQPDVÕYHDQDOL]HGLOPHVLVD\HVLQGHHEHYH\Q
8%0.  WK,QWHUQDWLRQDO&RQIHUHQFHRQ&RPSXWHU6FLHQFHDQG(QJLQHHULQJ
Authorized licensed use limited to: Carleton University. Downloaded on October 27,2020 at 06:02:23 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
ùHNLO(EHYH\QOHUHJ|QGHULOHQPHVDMELOJLVLDUD\]
JHUoHN ]DPDQOÕ RODUDN UHWLOPLú DQOÕN YHUL\H XODúDELOLU
EHEH÷LQLQGXUXPXQXWDNLSHGHELOLUX]XQVUH]DUIÕQGDHOGH
HGLOHQYHULJUDILNOHULQHGRNWRUODUÕQGDXODúDELOPHVLQHRODQDN
VD÷ODGÕ÷ÕLoLQEXPDNDOHNDSVDPÕQGDUHWLOHQSURWRWLSNoN
VD÷OÕNVLVWHPOHULQGHGHNXOODQÕODELOLU$\UÕFDPDNDOHGHHOGH
HGLOHQ SURWRWLS LOH EHEHNOHUGH J|UOHQ 6,'6 YDNDODUÕQÕQ
D]DOPDVÕ DPDoODQPÕúWÕU 3URWRWLS HEHYH\QOHUH NROD\ ELU
EHEHNEDNÕPÕVD÷ODPDVÕQÕQ\DQÕQGDEHEHNOHUHLKWL\DoODUÕQD
\|QHOLN KÕ]OÕ YH GR÷UX ELU EDNÕP VD÷ODPDVÕ\OD KX]XU YH
NRQIRUYDDWHWPHNWHGLU$\UÕFDEXSURWRWLSNÕUVDODODQODULoLQ
GH NXOODQÕúOÕGÕU %XQGDQ GROD\Õ GRNWRU HULúLPLQH X]DN
E|OJHOHUGH EHEH÷L GRNWRUD J|WUPHGHQ GRNWRUXQ EX
GH÷LúNHQOHULJ|]OHPOH\HELOPHVLQHRODQDNVD÷ODQPÕúWÕU
5()(5$16/$5
>@ 5 6 & +RUQH µµ6XGGHQ LQIDQW GHDWK V\QGURPH &XUUHQ
SHUVSHFWLYHV¶¶,QW0HG-YROQRSS±
>@ /90 0RUDOHV .;& 3LUDWRYD 0$5 0DUWLQH] ³5HDOWLP
WHPSHUDWXUH DQG DXGLR EDE\ PRQLWRULQJ XVLQJ ,27 WHFKQRORJLHV¶¶
,((($FFHVV
>@ $ -DEEDU +. 6KDQJ 6., +DPLG $$ $OPRKDPPHGL 50
5DPOÕ 0$+ $OL ³,QWHUQHW RI WKLQJVEDVHG PRQLWRULQJ V\VWHP IRU
VPDUWVUDGOH´,((($FFHVVYROSS
>@  - 5XVLD $ 1DXJDUKL\D 6 0DMXPGHU 6 0DMXPGDU % $FKDU\D 6
9HUPD³5HPRWH WHPSHUDWXUH KXPLGLW\ VHQVLQJ WKURXJK $6.
PRGXODWLRQWHFKQLTXH¶¶XQSXEOLVKHG
>@ 6 6ULNDQWK 35DP\D 06DWKHHVK *7KRPDV 3KLOLS DQG .9LQHHWKD
³6PDUW %DE\ &UDGOH 6\VWHP´ ,QWHUQDWLRQDO -RXUQDO RI $GYDQFHV LQ
6FLHQWLILF5HVHDUFKDQG(QJLQHHULQJ LMDVUH YROQRSS

>@ 0 .ROL 3 /DGJH % 3UDVDG 5 %RULD - %DOXU ³,QWHOOLJHQW %DE\
,QFXEDWRU´ 3URFHHGLQJV RI WKH QG ,QWHUQDWLRQDO FRQIHUHQFH RQ
(OHFWURQLFV &RPPXQLFDWLRQ DQG $HURVSDFH 7HFKQRORJ\ ,&(&$ 

>@0*R\DO'.XPDU³$XWRPDWLFHEDE\FUDGOHVZLQJEDVHGRQEDE\
FU\´$QULWKD(EHQH]HU $QXSUHHWK,QWHUQDWLRQDO-RXUQDORI&RPSXWHU
$SSOLFDWLRQV ± YROQRMXQ
>@ $ (EHQH]HU 6 $QXSUHHWKL ³$XWRPDWLF FUDGOH PRYHPHQW IRU LQIDQW
FDUH´8QGHUJUDGXDWH$FDGHPLF5HVHDUFK-RXUQDO 8$5- YROQR
SS
>@ 03-RVKLDQG'&0HKHWUH³,R7EDVHGVPDUWFUDGOHV\VWHPZLWKDQ
DQGURLG DSS IRU EDE\ PRQLWRULQJ´  ,QWHUQDWLRQDO &RQIHUHQFH
&RPSXWHU (QJLQHHULQJ &RPPXQLFDWLRQ &RQWURO DQG  $XWRPDWLRRQ
,&&8%($ SS
>@,1DWKHHUD66XQGDUDYDGLYHO1/9LVDNDQ69LVZDQDWKDQDQG0
9LYHNNXPDU ³6PDUW &UDGOH´ $VLDQ -RXUQDO RI $SSOLHG 6FLHQFH DQG
7HFKQRORJ\ $-$67  2SHQ $FFHVV 4XDUWHUO\ ,QWHUQDWLRQDO -RXUQDO 
YROQRSS
>@ 1 $ =DNDULD ) 1 % 0RKG 6DOHK DQG 0 $ $ 5D]DN ³,R7
,QWHUQHW RI 7KLQJV  EDVHG LQIDQW ERG\ WHPSHUDWXUH PRQLWRULQJ´ LQ
QG,QWHUQDWLRQDO&RQIHUHQFHRQ%LR6LJQDO$QDO\VLV3URFHVVLQJ
DQG6\VWHPV ,&%$36 SS
>@6%DQJ5/DP1/R&LFHUR³5RFNPHEDE\7KHDXWRPDWLFEDE\
URFNHU´ 3URMHFW IRU 6DQ -RVH 6WDWH 8QLYHUVLW\ 'HSDUWPHQW RI
0HFKDQLFDODQG$HURVSDFH(QJLQHHULQJ
>@7KHPSW>RQOLQH@$YDLODEHKWWSVZZZWKHPWFREORJ