Professional Documents
Culture Documents
final report
final report
report
Disclaimer
I declare this thesis to be my own work, unless otherwise referenced, and I am fully aware
of plagiarism policies of ECU which have been followed while writing this work
Acknowledgement
I would like to take this opportunity to commend the staff of ECU for their assistance
throughout the project. In particular, I would like to thank Dr.Yasir AL-ABDELI for his
guidance and continued support throughout the development of this project. Without his
supervision, it would have been impossible for me to achieve the project objectives. Finally,
I would like to thank my parents, especially my mother who continues to inspire me, and
has been instrumental in helping me reach where I am today.
Abstract
HVAC systems are instrumental in providing the comfort level for occupants inside a
building. Around 82% of the buildings in the world have HVAC system installed within in
some capacity and this trend is ever growing. The primary fuel of this power is coal, and its
consumption have wide ranging impacts both economically, and environmentally. The aim
of this project is to analyse and differentiate the impact of various parameters in an average
size room on the overall load consumption against Perth weather. These parameters are
contribution of construction material, occupancy, building orientation, type of activities
inside a room. This analysis will help us devise strategies to conserve energy. In addition, a
heating load and cooling loads are calculated for both winter and summer respectively. On
the basis of these loads, a more detailed cost and CO2 emission analysis is also carried out
to evaluate the effect of power generation in economic and environmental terms. All of
these objectives are achieved with the help of a software called HAP Carrier.
Contents
Chapter 1: Introduction.........................................................................................................................7
1.1 Report structure:.......................................................................................................................11
1.2 Project objectives:.....................................................................................................................12
1.1 Significance of project:..............................................................................................................12
Chapter 2: Literature Review...............................................................................................................13
2.1 Modelling by HAP Carrier:.........................................................................................................15
2.1.1 System design features:......................................................................................................16
2.1.2 Energy analysis features:....................................................................................................16
2.1.3 Climate analysis features:...................................................................................................16
2.1.4 Load calculation features:...................................................................................................16
2.1.5 Air system features:............................................................................................................16
2.1.6 Energy system features:......................................................................................................16
2.1.7 Plant equipment features:..................................................................................................16
2.1.8 Utility rate features:............................................................................................................16
Chapter 3:Methodology......................................................................................................................17
3.1 Software:...................................................................................................................................17
3.2 Weather:....................................................................................................................................18
3.3 Windows, building wall and roof:..............................................................................................18
3.4 Mathematical relationships:......................................................................................................19
3.5 Thermal load:.............................................................................................................................19
3.6 Room selected:..........................................................................................................................21
3.6.1 Window:.............................................................................................................................23
3.6.2 Wall:....................................................................................................................................23
3.6.3 Roof:...................................................................................................................................24
3.6.4 Heat load due to people:....................................................................................................24
3.7 Cost:...........................................................................................................................................24
3.8 CO2 emission calculations:........................................................................................................25
Chapter 4: Results and disscussion......................................................................................................26
4.1 Load calculation analysis for one room:....................................................................................26
4.1.1 Changing single value:........................................................................................................30
4.1.2 Changing multiple value:....................................................................................................31
4.2 Impact of occupants and their activity on load consumption:...................................................34
4.3 Building orientation:..................................................................................................................35
CHAPTER 1
Introduction:
This chapter is gives an introduction about HVAC systems, their
significance, applications, and thermal performance evaluation. Besides, there is an
overview of about significance of Building services, and the components of load generation
inside it. Throughout humankind’s history, humans have conceived methods for changing
energy into work for them. They have found methods of developing new techniques for
cultivating food instead of looking for it in the wild. People even have devised techniques
about how to convey electronically as opposed to utilising a delivery person or utilising a
post service. This regularly developing thirst to imagine for quicker, simpler, and more
productive methods to meet human needs has led to new energy solutions over the course
of human history. However, the assets at presently utilised for producing energy for the
most part non-renewable sources are running out. The contamination delivered by the
utilisation of these resources is fundamental driver of harming the planet's natural order.
Thus, individuals are starting to search for proficient power utilisation to meet their
consistently developing energy needs.(Caldas and Norford 2003)
The sun is the most established natural source of energy. It been providing energy and light
for billions of years and maintainability of a wide range of life on the planet is directly
dependant on it. energy, in all its forms, begins with the sun. In any case, from the earliest
starting point people have thought that it was difficult to control it, and along these lines
investigation for different sources of energy started. For example, humankind influenced an
innovation to create their heat from wood, to oil and gas and so forth. However,
incineration has been one of the widely used source of power production. (Scotton, Lirong
et al. 2013)
With the expansion in human population with the passage of time, humankind reliance on
fire has enlarged. This upgrade in number occurred due to extraordinary inadequacy of
wood in a few sections of the planet. For example, by the sixteenth century, in UK number
of trees had decreased to such a low because of over cutting and the locals began to employ
other sources of fuel. Rather than trees, Coal, oil, and gas were utilised. These are
additionally called non-renewable energy sources because of their extraction from fossilised
plant and creature material from profound underneath ground. Subsequently, began the
Presently as we move forward into future the energy efficient innovations have been
foreseen as the significant source of energy. Nonetheless, the reliance on traditional sources
can't be ruled out entirely. After the advancement of industry in later past an unnatural
weather change has turned out to be one of the consuming concerns of 21st century and
there have been broad endeavours going ahead around the globe to make the current
advances in green energy more effective.(Fernandez, Katipamula et al. 2015) In such
manner, demonstrating of energy efficient techniques is one of the urgent territory of
research going ahead. This field empowers specialists to relate their insight into Physics,
math, and science with monetary and environmental energy practices. The primary aspect
of energy research is to innovate sustainable techniques to operate buildings and
manufacturing facilities.
Nowadays, Modelling of HVAC energy systems is hot topic for researchers around the globe
considering around 40-60% of energy consumption in commercial sector comes from HVAC
systems load consumption. It all started in early 1920’s, and at present they are installed in
82% of the buildings worldwide.(Wang, Chang et al. 2014). HVAC normally referred to as ‘’
air conditioning’’ deals with controlling the temperature, outside air supply for air
movement, filtration of air, and ventilation. All of these tasks are achieved by the following
processes.
Primarily, HVAC systems are used to provide adequate atmosphere and comfortability to
human beings either to work or live inside a structure, which is heavily reliant on the climate
outside. The value of each of aforementioned processes change with the weather. E.g. in a
dessert the key processes are cooling, air movement humidifying, and dehumidifying,
whereas, heating and cooling are main processes in a cold environment. However, (HVAC)
systems comprises of different components working together to distribute, introduce, and
condition air for maintaining the human comfort level.(Wang, Lin et al. 2015)
Basic components of HVAC systems are fans, boiler, chiller, cooling tower, heat exchanger,
furnace, coil, Condensing unit, ducts thermostats, vent and refrigerant ducts (Firszt, 23
November2014). Moreover, one of the key entities in HVAC systems are Air handling units
(AHU). AHU is an assembly of fans, and other essential equipment to perform cleaning,
heating, cooling, humidifying, dehumidifying, and mixing the air.
Air Movement
Temperature
Humidity
Air Cleanliness
Another key component of Chiller is used to remove the heat from the liquid using the
fundamentals of vapour absorption or vapour compression cycle.(Homod, Sahari et al. 2014)
The circulating liquid cools the surrounding environment. A brief description of vapour
compression cycle is as below.
There are four major processes in a vapour compression cycle, which are in the following
order
2. Compression
4. Expansion
Designing the HVAC systems are one of the key aspects of building services, and now a brief
introduction of building services is given as below.
Building services is field where engineers work together with other professionals such as
structural engineers, architects, and quantity surveyors to ensure the right architecture,
sustainability of a building as well as meeting its energy demand. Along with construction,
instrumentation, and security, building service engineers are also responsible for heating,
cooling, ventilation, humidity, lighting, and acoustic design to provide the required internal
environment. (ASHRAE.2009)
Convection: the heat transfers to the space, and in that regard mechanical ventilation air
flows and external wind pressure can be a major source of cooling and heating.
Radiation: Heat exchange with exposed surrounding by rays and gains from hot surfaces,
radiant heaters, and sunshine.
Evaporation: heat exchange via exhaling of humid air and sweating.
There are various factors which influence human comfort. The first two is as below
Temperature:
it is a measurement of heat potential (recorded in degrees Centigrade
Or Kelvin). Heat flows from a higher temperature entity to relatively lower temperature
substance. In Perth, temperatures are maintained within
19°C to 24°C range, complaints are not usually raised depending on room use and season.
Winter’s Temperatures are usually controlled at the lower end of the scale while
Summer’s temperatures are held at the higher value.
Conduction, convection and radiation heat transfer:
These values are usually
measured in Watts. Designers need to be careful in Perth of radiant overheating. Unwanted
heat gains from conduction, convection and radiation can be managed at source. An
epitome of this is managing non-required winter heat losses and solar heat gains through
windows by Setting up a dedicated air conditioning zone which offers an air‐conditioned air
flow barrier between the occupied space and the window. This is referred as a
window washing air system. (ASHRAE 2011).
Air movement:
comprising outside air and recirculated air, measured in air changes (room
volumes) per hour and litres per second.
Chapter 2- Literature review: this chapter entails all the detailed theory related to project
Chapter 3- Methodology: the method employed to achieve our objectives are discussed
here.
Chapter 4- Results and Discussion: this chapter elaborate the results for their better
understanding
Chapter 5- Conclusion and Future Work: on the basis of results conclusion is drawn, plus the
future works are also discussed.
depth information about the various factors, which can be Useful in planning an efficient
building HVAC system.
Chapter 2
Literature review:
This chapter briefly discuss the research papers, journals, methods, experiments that were
refereed to while working on the project.
Global warming is a cause of concern for the world of research. To mitigate the
effects of this phenomenon development of green buildings in order to save energy is a hot
topic. E.g. excessive heating or cooling of the building, causes energy waste plus
inconvenience to the occupants. For conserving energy, some research has been conducted
for occupancy detection, as natural lighting effects get influenced by occupancy. cooling
load dictates Setting the temperature in the room. External and internal heat loads are
influenced by heat sources of energy. External heat comes from conduction, convection and
radiation while the internal heat load Is caused by the occupants and electrical equipment in
the room. (2003) Among all HVAC functions, ventilation is the main issue for providing
required Indoor Air Quality to optimum level, and energy consumption in buildings is heavily
reliant on it as well. Thus, enhancing ventilation systems performance plays a key role not
only in improving energy efficiency of the building, but also in offering improved indoor
climate for the people inside. In the recent years, myriad of efficient ventilation methods
have been developed to reduce energy. Along with these energy-efficient strategies such as
hybrid and natural ventilation techniques, the energy demand in buildings is also affected by
the occupants’ behaviour towards it.(Chenari, Dias Carrilho et al. 2016). A model based
control approach needs to be adopted to achieve a better control on the required comfort
level as well as reduce the energy consumption within a building(Virk 1994).
There are number of factors which influence our decision to select a HVAC system for a
certain building. These could be building design gain, occupant design requirement, their
comfort level requirement, climatic conditions, building orientation (Kassas, 2015).
Varying the insulation layer in the construction material of a building plays a significant role
in reducing the cost. For a HVAC system while having a continuous operation, an adding of
an insulation layer results in reduction of 20% in life cycle cost in terms of thermal code
requirements. During an operation, even insulating the inner side of the walls reduces load
consumption by 15% as compared to insulating the outer wall. (Ibrahim, Ghaddar et al.
2012). Although it is well known that construction material has great impact on the load
characteristics, however the effect of weather variation pattern has not been investigated in
–depth. The models used for gauging the response to external
weather conditions of building HVAC systems are as below
(1) models based on first
(2) regression-based models.
Each model has discrepancies, e.g. It is difficult to calibrate the models based on first
principles and it is costly as well.(Hadley 1993)
One of the variables influencing this evaluation is the dimensional elements of the area.
improper orientation of a building's gives rise to extra consumption of energy called CL. This
total heat gain is calculated with the assumptions and equations as per ASHRAE code.
Moreover, by changing the building to proper orientation, the load consumption from
electrical equipment can be reduced and thereby energy is conserved.(2010)
There extensive research in HVAC systems have resulted in innovative solutions. One such
example is Phase change materials. They are an innovative technology that can mitigate the
HVAC energy consumption and peak loads in buildings.(Florides, Tassou et al. 2002)
Fundamentally, they are capable of storing or releasing thermal energy as latent heat. With
the occupants and their type of activity, the latent heat absorbed or released is much higher
than the amount of sensible heat, thus these materials in buildings can reduce energy
consumption to significant level. Now, because the temperature at which latent heat is
absorbed or released is different for each material, it is vital to use the right type of material
while building an envelope design.(Seong and Lim 2013)
Chapter 3
Methodology:
This chapter elaborates the approach adopted for the project and
provides the explanation for mathematical relationships, data used in the project, and the
software used to achieve these targets.
First, a brief overview of practices used in the project are discussed below.
3.1 Software:
In this project, the HAP carrier software is used to analyse the thermal performance of the
given room. The given program gives us a comprehensive platform to perform the
calculations by considering a range of factors such as building material, occupancy, and their
activities while modelling and calculating the total load for a room. Another thing, which
sets it apart from other modelling software’s like MATLAB, FORTRAN etc., is the agility and
ease with which the actions can be performed. Last but not the least, the program is only
specified for building services calculations, which is the core aspect of this project.
Another overt facet of the project is that a cost analysis and CO2 emissions analysis is also
carried out, but these values are calculated by using MS Excel from the data generated by
HAP Carrier. Now in the theory below we will discuss the various aspects of HAP Carrier.
3.2 Weather:
The given program gives us an option of selecting different locations in different countries.
Therefore, Perth weather selected and the following temperature values were used.
Then in the next phase, same procedure was done for roof with the starting material as
shown below.
After entering this data for the specifications of room elements the software perform
calculation and generates a PDF file, which entails all the information related to loads
calculations, airflow rates, systems used inside etc. Once I got these results, I was able to
create graphs inside Excel to display different trends.
Conduction heat transfer forms the bigger chunk of total load consumption, and it is
transferred through wall, windows and roofs.
The primary equation used to calculate load through conductivity in this study is as below.
Q= U* A* ΔT
Where,
Q= Heat loss through conduction in Watts.
U= Coefficient of heat transmission in W.m2/K
A= Total area of the surface (wall, roof, window) in m2
ΔT= temperature difference between inside set point and outside temperature (K)
As discussed above, the peripheral elements of room further consist of different layers of
material, which means a different value for coefficient of thermal conduction; thus, it is
important to calculate the overall value, which is given by
Here,
The impedance offered by material to conductivity is called “thermal resistance”. This heat
Obstruction rate depends on the manufacturing properties and the thickness of material
that room is made of.
Whereas,
x= Thickness of material
C= Thermal conductance
h= surface conductance.
k= Thermal conductivity
The room (20*15*12) has one window (5*3.23) and one door (3*5). All these values are in
metres. Moreover, the formula for load calculation from different components is given
below.
3.6.1 Window:
The area for window is calculated by
Whereas,
A(window)= Area of window in m2.
Here,
3.6.2 Wall:
Only one side of the room consists of a window while the rest have none of them. So,
the following formulas are used to calculate the load transfer through this side
Here,
Where,
Q(wall)= heat loss through wall surface of room in watts/s.
U(wall) = overall coefficient of heat transmission in W.m2/K
However, for other sides the formula for heat loss is,
3.6.3 Roof:
As roof is also in contact with the atmosphere, there is heat conduction through it as
well.
here,
Whereas,
In our calculations, three groups of occupants are considered which are 0 people, 10 people,
and 20 people. Following equations are used to calculate loads from occupants,
Similarly,
The value of Cents/KWH changes in different states of Australia as the state government
regulates them.
Whereas,
ECi= Energy intensity factor value for type of fuel (i) (gigajoules per cubic metre)
This relationship provides emission values for different type of emission gases. However, to
deduce a single value, which entails all, types of gases the equation below can be used,
Where,
Y = equivalent value (tonnes) of CO2 value incorporating all gasses like (CO2, CH4, and N2),
Q= electricity produced in KWH,
Chapter 4
Results and Discussion:
In this section all the load calculations are done considering varying
factors inside the room. Moreover, a detailed comparison is carried between various
parameters which contribute to overall loads. Finally, a cost estimation and Co2 emission as
a result of above mentioned loads are also calculated.
35
30
25
20
15
10
0
Room 1 Room 2 Room 3 Room 4
In the figures above, room 1 has varied wall parameters, room 2 has different window, room
3 has different roof, and room 4 has changed door to the original designed room.
70
60
50
Loads (KW)
40
30
20
10
0
Room 1 Room 2 Room 3 Room 4 Room 5
Now, these rooms are different from each other in terms of material of their walls, roofs,
and windows. However, their basic dimensions plus orientation remains the same.
Following layers of material are used for different elements of room.
Room 1:
-Face Brick
Room 2:
Room 3:
Room 4:
Room 5:
Now all of these calculations are done by taking into account the peripheral elements, but
what happens inside still needs to be investigated which is done below.
38
37
36
35
34
33
Office work Sedentry work Athletics Dancing Heavy work Medium work Seated at rest
As we know that sensible heat requires no phase change, and in all the values above phase
change doesn’t take place.so all the values basically demonstrate SENSIBLE HEAT
CONSUMPTION, but once we take into account the load consumption from people change
of phase takes place, and the sensible heat is produced. These values are shown by the
following graph.
0
Office work Sedentry work Athletics Dancing Heavy work Medium work Seated at rest
Load (KW)
36
35
34
33
32
31
30
29
28
27
26
Facing East Facing North Facing West Facing South
Load Consumption
As we can see the form the graph that the minimum load consumption was recorded for
north and south direction which again proves the above mentioned point.
Now, total cost can be calculated by multiplying KWH with the value set by west Australian
government to produce single KWH which is 26.474 cents/KWH, as per Synergy Electricity
corporation. (Standard electricity prices and charges 2017) Thus,
Origional load Cost Varied Load cost load consumption cost trend
Origional Load Cost Varied load cost Varied load cost trend
In the figures above, room 1 has varied wall parameters, room 2 has different window, room
3 has different roof, and room 4 has changed door to the original designed room.
16
14
Cost($)
12
10 9.32
6 4.8 4.75
4
2
0.55
0
Room 1 Room 2 Room 3 Room 4 Room 5
Now all these rooms have same specifications as mentioned in the calculations above.
10
9.8
9.6
9.4
9.2
8.8
8.6
Office work Sedentry work Athletics Dancing Heavy work Medium work Seated at rest
1.6
1.4
1.2
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
0
Office work Sedentry work Athletics Dancing Heavy work Medium work Seated at rest
Cost ($)
9.5
9.2
9
8.6
8.5
Cost ($)
8 7.8
7.7
7.5
6.5
Facing East Facing North Facing West Facing South
Building orientation
Load Consumption
Y = equivalent value (tonnes) in CO2 value equal to sum of value all gasses like (CO2, CH4,
and N2),
EF = emission factor
Now according to NATIONAL GREENHOUSE ACCOUNTS FACTORS table, for Perth EF is 760
Thus,
Now we carry out emission analysis in the same sequence as it is done for the cost
25
20
15
10
0
Room 1 Room 2 Room 3 Room 4
CO2 Emissions from Origional load CO2 Emissions from Varied Load
CO2 Emissions from load consumption trend
.
12
10
0
Room 1 Room 2 Room 3 Room 4
40
CO2 Emissions (Kg)
30 27.2
20
14.1 13.9
10
1.62
0
Room 1 Room 2 Room 3 Room 4 Room 5
Now all these rooms have same specifications as mentioned in the calculations above.
29.5
29
28.5
28
27.5
27
26.5
26
25.5
Office work Sedentry work Athletics Dancing Heavy work Medium work Seated at rest
0
Office work Sedentry work Athletics Dancing Heavy work Medium work Seated at rest
26
25.16
25
CO2 Emissions
24
23 22.8
22.5
22
21
20
Facing East Facing North Facing West Facing South
Building orientaion
Chapter 5
Conclusion:
Following observations were made from the results,
Latent heat is produced when there are people or equipment involved in the
building, and its amount is reliant upon the type of activity carried out inside the
room
Cost and CO2 emissions can be reduced to great extent by modifying the
construction material of the building
Future Recommendations:
First, we can extend these results from a room to a comprehensive design and
modelling for a whole building. Furthermore, by using the software results and
ASHRAY standards, not only we can develop a duct design, but we can also select the
elements of HVAC systems like fans, chiller, boiler etc. based on the required data of
the building.
Investigating the effect of using different types of air condition systems like central
air conditioning system, multi split system, single split system, hybrid air conditioning
system, and Geothermal Heating & Cooling systems while selecting the type of
system for the building. Furthermore, a cost & emmision analysis of different types
of can be carried out as well.
A more detailed study can be conducted by simulating the building in various parts
of the world.This can easily be done as software has options of selecting different
location.Moreover, the influence of other room elements of lighting, equipment etc.
can also be checked.
References
ASHRAE. (2009). Handbook-fundamentals, American Society of Heating, Refrigerating and
Air-Conditioning Engineers.
(2010). "Thermal Auditing of Buildings: Essential Step towards Designing Energy Efficient
Houses." American Society of Heating Refrigerating and Air Conditioning Engineers.
Budaiwi, I. and A. Abdou (2013). "HVAC system operational strategies for reduced energy
consumption in buildings with intermittent occupancy: the case of mosques." Energy
Conversion and Management 73: 37-50.
Chenari, B., et al. (2016). "Towards sustainable, energy-efficient and healthy ventilation
strategies in buildings: A review." Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews
59(Supplement C): 1426-1447.
Fahim, A. A. and E. E. Khalil (2015). Thermal Management in Energy Efficient Air Conditioned
Buildings. 53rd AIAA Aerospace Sciences Meeting, American Institute of Aeronautics and
Astronautics.
Fernandez, N., et al. (2015). "Energy savings modelling of re-tuning energy conservation
measures in large office buildings." Journal of Building Performance Simulation 8(6): 391-
407.
Florides, G. A., et al. (2002). "Measures used to lower building energy consumption and
their cost effectiveness." Applied Energy 73(3): 299-328.
Homod, R. Z., et al. (2014). "Energy saving by integrated control of natural ventilation and
HVAC systems using model guide for comparison." Renewable Energy 71(Supplement C):
639-650.
Ibrahim, M., et al. (2012). "Optimal location and thickness of insulation layers for minimizing
building energy consumption." Journal of Building Performance Simulation 5(6): 384-398.
Khalil, E. E. and A. A. Medhat (2013). "Towards Energy Efficient Air-Conditioned Space: Fluid
Flow and Thermal Behavior." (56055): V001T001A036.
Seong, Y.-B. and J.-H. Lim (2013). "Energy Saving Potentials of Phase Change Materials
Applied to Lightweight Building Envelopes." Energies 6(10): 5219.
Shonder, J. A., et al. (2000). "Comparative analysis of life-cycle costs of geothermal heat
pumps and three conventional HVAC systems." ASHRAE Transactions 106: PA/.
Sreedevi, A., et al. (2014). Modeling and simulation of an HVAC system for energy analysis
and management of commercial buildings. 2014 International Conference on Circuits,
Communication, Control and Computing, I4C 2014, November 21, 2014 - November 22,
2014, Bangalore, India, Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers Inc.
Wang, F.-J., et al. (2014). Performace analysis and energy modeling of HVAC system for a
library building. 7th Asian Conference on Refrigeration and Air Conditioning, ACRA 2014,
May 18, 2014 - May 21, 2014, Jeju Island, Korea, Republic of, Society of Air-conditioning and
Refrigerating Engineers of Korea, SAREK.
Wang, F., et al. (2015). "Energy Modeling and Chillers Sizing of HVAC System for a Hotel
Building." Procedia Engineering 121(Supplement C): 1812-1818.
Research & Development. (2017). How to Achieve a Zero Energy Building. [online] Available
at: https://www.rdmag.com/article/2017/10/how-achieve-zero-energy-building
[Accessed 29 Oct. 2017].
Staff, B. (2017). Ecologically Friendly Building Trends Target Energy Usage, Emissions.
[online] BusinessWest. Available at: http://businesswest.com/blog/ecologically-
friendly-building-trends-target-energy-usage-emissionsecologically-friendly-building-
trends-target-energy-usage-emissions/ [Accessed 29 Oct. 2017].
Apendix A
This appendix delineates the calculations delineated by HAP Carrier software
Apendix B
The Tariffs for different times are given below by Synergy
Appendix C
This table illustrates CO2 emission value for different states of Australia