Professional Documents
Culture Documents
PTS 120301
PTS 120301
PTS 12.03.01
April 2019
FOREWORD
PETRONAS Technical Standards (PTS) has been developed based on the accumulated knowledge,
experience and best practices of the PETRONAS group supplementing National and International
standards where appropriate. The key objective of PTS is to ensure standard technical practice across
the PETRONAS group.
Compliance to PTS is compulsory for PETRONAS-operated facilities and Joint Ventures (JVs) where
PETRONAS has more than fifty percent (50%) shareholding and/or operational control, and includes
all phases of work activities.
Contractors/manufacturers/suppliers who use PTS are solely responsible in ensuring the quality of
work, goods and services meet the required design and engineering standards. In the case where
specific requirements are not covered in the PTS, it is the responsibility of the
Contractors/manufacturers/suppliers to propose other proven or internationally established
standards or practices of the same level of quality and integrity as reflected in the PTS.
In issuing and making the PTS available, PETRONAS is not making any warranty on the accuracy or
completeness of the information contained in PTS. The Contractors/manufacturers/suppliers shall
ensure accuracy and completeness of the PTS used for the intended design and engineering
requirement and shall inform the Owner for any conflicting requirement with other international
codes and technical standards before start of any work.
PETRONAS is the sole copyright holder of PTS. No part of this document may be reproduced, stored
in a retrieval system or transmitted in any form or by any means (electronic, mechanical, recording
or otherwise) or be disclosed by users to any company or person whomsoever, without the prior
written consent of PETRONAS.
The PTS shall be used exclusively for the authorised purpose. The users shall arrange for PTS to be
kept in safe custody and shall ensure its secrecy is maintained and provide satisfactory information
to PETRONAS that this requirement is met.
Table of Contents
INTRODUCTION..................................................................................................... 4
SCOPE .............................................................................................................................4
GLOSSARY OF TERMS .....................................................................................................4
SUMMARY OF CHANGES ................................................................................................5
MODEL REVIEW .................................................................................................... 6
GENERAL .........................................................................................................................6
3D-CAD MODEL ..................................................................................................... 7
GENERAL .........................................................................................................................7
SAFETY, OPERATIONAL AND MAINTENANCE ASPECTS ..................................................8
3D-CAD SYSTEM FOR CONSTRUCTION ...........................................................................8
FEATURES WITH 3D-CAD TECHNOLOGY.........................................................................8
SCOPE OF MODEL REVIEW .................................................................................. 10
General ........................................................................................................................ 10
ORGANISATION OF A 3D-CAD MODEL REVIEW .................................................... 13
GENERAL ...................................................................................................................... 13
TOOLS .......................................................................................................................... 13
TEAM COMPOSITION .................................................................................................. 14
HANDLING OF COMMENTS ......................................................................................... 15
MODEL REVIEW CLOSE-OUT REPORT AND ARCHIVING ......................................... 16
GENERAL ...................................................................................................................... 16
BIBLIOGRAPHY .................................................................................................... 17
APPENDIX 1: TYPICAL COLOUR CODE FOR 3D-CAD MODELS ............................................ 18
APPENDIX 2: GUIDELINE FOR DEVELOPMENT OF 3D-CAD MODEL DETAILES .................... 20
APPENDIX 3 : CHECKLIST FOR ITEMS TO BE REVIEWED DURING FEED .............................. 22
APPENDIX 4 : CHECKLIST FOR ITEMS TO BE REVIEWED DURING DETAILED ENGINEERING 24
APPENDIX 5: CHECKLIST FOR THE OVERALL 3D MODEL REVIEW ...................................... 27
INTRODUCTION
This PTS provides minimum requirements and recommendations for 3D-CAD modelling
(Three Dimensional Computer Aided Design) for visualisation check during Front End
Engineering Design (FEED), Detailed Engineering, Procurement, Construction/Installation,
Hook-up and As-built stages. The review shall cover on accessabilty, safety, operability,
maintainability and constructability of new projects including revamp/rejuvenation,
considering PETRONAS lesson learnt and best practices. This PTS is applicable for both
upstream and downstream facilities.
SCOPE
This PTS covers the execution for 3D-CAD modelling at various design phases of the project.
The scope includes the following
ii. The application of 3D-CAD features (e.g. clash check, colours, tagging, line and
equipment number, etc.)
Details of visualisation tools other than 3D-CAD tools (e.g. virtual reality) are not covered by
this PTS. Owner’s approval shall be obtained for application of the tools proposed by the
Contractors.
The 3D model review shall be carried out at the 30%, 60% and 90% of the 3D model
development during engineering phase as per appendix III & IV. All applicable items in the
Check List shall be completed prior to the formal review session of each stage.
The 3D model preparation may not be required for small brown field project scope of work
e.g. like to like changes or minor changes that does not effect the overall Equipment and
Piping Layout. These type of changes can be covered by 2D-CAD drawing and shall be agreed
by the Owner.
GLOSSARY OF TERMS
Refer to PTS 00.01.03 for PTS Requirements, General Definition Of Terms, Abbreviations &
Reading Guide.
None.
Specific Abbreviations
No Abbreviation Description
SUMMARY OF CHANGES
This PTS 12.03.01 (April 2019) replaces PTS 12.03.01 (June 2015).
MODEL REVIEW
GENERAL
The Contractor shall prepare the 3D-CAD model based on PFD, P&ID, Equipment Layout,
Structural Drawing and other documents/drawings as applicable. Contractor shall perform
internal check by its own team prior to formal 3D-CAD model review by a team comprising of
Contractor and Owner.
The 3D-CAD model used during the internal and formal reviews shall be developed based on
agreed fixed revision of the live engineering data (i.e. PFD, P&ID, Equipment Layout,
Structure, etc.) being used for development of the project. The status date shall be indicated.
The internal review shall be carried out in detail, check each system, item by item as per P&ID.
Any proposed changes shall be discussed and agreed upon with Owner prior to formal review.
The formal review shall be carried out and the findings shall be immediately recorded with
tag and reference number.
If required by the contract, a physical block model shall be constructed by the Contractor
using wooden or plastic blocks, representing in a simplified form of the equipment, buildings
etc. The scale of a physical model should be 1:100, 1:50 or 1:33.3 as agreed with owner’s
requirement. A formal check shall also be conducted joint by Contrator and owner.
3 Clash checks √ √
4 HFE - VCA √ √
3D-CAD MODEL
GENERAL
The 3D-CAD model is developed during the FEED and Engineering phases to facilitate
procurement, fabrication, construction, installation, commissioning, operation and
maintenance of the plant facilities with added visualization features.
The model also provides the capability to present screened review all modelled details and
the ability to suppress specific items or details.
The graphical data of the 3D-CAD system is an integral part of an engineering database
supporting the design process.
The 3D-CAD engineering database enables the integration and consistency of the different
design stages and the different subjects, such as above & underground piping, foundations,
steel structures, equipment, instrumentation and electrical equipment into one 3D-model.
The 3D-CAD system shall be able to produce the following deliverables as minimum:
iii. Reports such as line lists, instrument data, clashes check, mock-ups.
v. All 3D model files and associated databases including attributes, definitions and
set-ups for all reports, drawings and other documents extracted from the 3D
model.
viii. Piping Isometrics including fabrication drawings – pipe spooling and welding
isometrics
x. Structural drawings
The 3D-CAD system shall be structured in such a way to enables each discipline involved to
check whether the plant or facilities has been designed in compliance with the specified
criterias with respect to engineering, safety, operability, maintenability and erection of the
plant. This shall include:
A 3D-CAD system should be made available at site during construction phase for the
development of construction drawings, general reference, as-builting, etc.
Owner and Contractor shall agree on the required minimum deliverables as specified in
Section 3.1.5 prior to the set-up of the 3D-CAD system and the applicable engineering
database(s).
The 3D-CAD system shall be programmed to provide clash checks and its acceptance criteria.
Only the differences from the programmed clash checks should be checked during the model
review. Clash check findings shall be rectified and Clash Check Report shall be made available
for the 60% and 90% 3D model review.
The colours used in the 3D-CAD model shall be in accordance with Appendix I where practical.
Any changes of colour if required, Contractor shall obtain written approval from Owner.
The 3D CAD model shall be developed in accordance with the guidelines as specified in
Appendix II: Guideline for Development of 3D-CAD Model Details.
The 3D model should be able to fully interface with the intelligent P&ID’s in order to ensure
the consistency of data across the various documentation as well as the visualization and
validation of those data.
GENERAL
The Contractor shall check the functionality of the 3D-CAD features as agreed with the
Owner. The model shall be checked against the latest approved revision of the P&ID and
equipment layout drawings.
Process design data stated in the P&ID shall be checked prior to formal model review.
However if the model review found other more feasible and economical solutions without
jeopardising the design functionality or safety, the Project Manager shall be informed for
further assessment (e.g. HAZOP) of the proposed change(s). If the proposed change is agreed
to be implemented, then the P&ID shall be made consistent with 3D-CAD model.
The review checklists as listed in Appendix III and Appendix IV shall be used for FEED and
detailed engineering stages respectively.
The 3D model review shall be carried out at the 30%, 60% and 90% of 3D model development
during detailed engineering phase. Model review and the stages during FEED phase shall be
agreed in advance by the Owner depending on the size of the project.
All piping systems, equipment and instrumentation that have been checked and accepted at
each review stage shall be marked on the P&ID for tracking purposes.
Any point that has not been accepted shall be tagged and recorded for rectification by the
Contractor and subject to further review during follow-up checks.
When a modification is proposed the review team shall ensure it suits its purpose, not in
conflict with other requirements, practical, safe, in accordance with the P&ID and cost
effective. The team shall consult the appropriate specialists of other disciplines if necessary.
The checklists in Appendix V should be used during the overall 3D model review. However,
Contractor shall note that the checklist is not exhaustive and shall not overrule sound
judgement.
The following disciplines from the Contractor and Owner should be represented during the
formal model review as applicable. The Contractor representatives shall be qualified and
experienced on the respective project for the model review.
i. Process technology;
ii. Operations;
iii. Maintenance;
vii. Instrument;
viii. Electrical;
ix. Project;
Other relevant specialists should be consulted at an early stage of model design if required
(e.g. for solids handling, slurry transport).
Human Factors Engineering analysis shall be carried out prior to 60% 3D model review and
the results should be used as input to the model review. All items that have been categorised
by the VCA shall be colour coded in the 3D Model for ease of identification.
For the 60% 3D model review, the piping routing and pipe supports modelled shall be based
on the Pipe Stress Analysis. Material Handling study requirements and recommendations
shall be incorporated into the model for the 60% 3D model review session.
Each model review shall be concluded with a statement describing which aspects are fixed at
this stage.
If required by the contract, future piping and equipment shall be modelled completely in
order to demonstrate ease of future installation and commissioning into the facilities without
jeopardizing the production, HSE and structural weight limit.
Sub-contracted work and package supplier equipment shall be shown in the model at 30% of
3D model review with sufficient detail (e.g. overall size, distance from reference points) to
fulfil the objectives of the model reviews. If this is not practical, an alternative method shall
be used and agreed with the Owner. For this reason, a specification for ergonomic and review
requirements should be set-up and discussed with the respective package supplier during the
bid clarification meeting.
Dedicated 3D review of Vendor’s packaged equipment shall be conducted if the model is not
available during the pre-determined 30% or 60% plant 3D model review sessions. It should
be conducted before the 90% 3D plant model review in order to enable a full and integrated
review of the plant and the Vendor equipment packages.
Deluge valve stations shall be located in areas which provides unobstructed and direct access
from the roads. They should be located in the vicinity of the equipment or group of
equipment within the coverage of the deluge valve station.
For offshore facilities that have Living Quarters (LQ), the following shall be modelled as a
minimum:
i. Main HVAC equipment and major ducts to enable space allocation and for clash
checks.
ii. Black and grey water system, header & sub header line above the ceiling & inside
HVAC shaft room.
iii. Potable water system (Hot & Cold water) including header line inside HVAC shaft
room
GENERAL
Contractor shall notify the review team members with adequate notice before the review
date. They shall also be informed on the location, duration, type of review, participants and
number of drawings for the constructed model to be reviewed.
Prior to the commencement of a model review, the project background (e.g. Design basis,
scope of work), current applicable equipment layout drawings and P&ID shall be sent to the
review team members in advance for familiarisation.
TOOLS
A 3D-CAD model presentation for a group of people should be performed using a large screen
having a high resolution. The system shall have sufficient capacity to allow the display of a
complete model of at least one area or unit of a plant. The computer system should be of
sufficient capacity to move easily through the model, rotate the view angle around the
equipment and zoom-in/zoom-out almost instantaneously. Point-to-point distance
measurements should be possible on request. Main computer manipulations, such as
switching to another process unit should not take more than 5 minutes. The 3D model review
software shall be agreed by Owner prior to the review session. Reference items, mobile
cranes, bundle pulling equipment, etc. and an operator of the same scale as the model under
review, shall be available. The model operator's dimensions should be representative of the
applicable population.
i. PFD;
ii. P&ID;
ix. Material Handling Philosophy (for example valves, tube bundles, pumps, etc.
during maintenance)
x. Equipment/Material Handling
TEAM COMPOSITION
A team shall be established comprising of members from the Contractor and Owner for the
model review as described in Section 4.0. Contractor shall appoint a Team Leader typically
from mechanical background with adequate experience in technical content of 3-D
modelling. The team shall also comprise a 3D System Operator to operate the modelling
software during the review session.
i. Team Leader:
a) Guide the team through the model with the assistance of the system
operator.
a) Understand the technical terms used in Oil and Gas, petrochemical and
refinery technology.
b) Clarify the design of the model to the team members when necessary.
c) Checklist as per Appendix III, IV & V shall be used as reference during the
model review.
The composition of the review team should be the same person as far as practicable for all
the stages of the model review.
HANDLING OF COMMENTS
The team shall decide if the level of completion of the model is in line with the requirements
defined in Section 4.0 and respective appendices after every stage of review.
The 3D-CAD tools should have sequence reference facilities to describe the comments given
by the review team. The text of each reference shall be complete and unambiguous and
include a “snapshot” to avoid confusion in a later stage of the review process. The tagged
items shall be reviewed with the Contractor within 2 weeks and a record shall be produced
showing which tag items will be implemented or rejected, with reasoning. The relevant
specialist shall be consulted, and the other team members shall be informed, before a tag
item is deleted or significantly changed.
Before the next review starts, all agreed tag items shall be implemented in the 3D-CAD model.
GENERAL
Colour prints-outs (screen dumps) at various angles shall be taken of the 3D-CAD model at
30%, 60% and 90% completion. Where applicable, comment tag items shall be visible on the
printouts.
v. Comment description
The above print-outs shall be handed over to the Owner for archiving. The 30%, 60%, 90%
and final version of the 3D-CAD model shall also be handed over to the Owner for electronic
archiving.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
In this PTS, reference is made to the following Standards/ Publications. Unless specifically
designated by date, the latest edition of each standard shall be used, together with any
supplements/revisions thereto:
1. PIPING
Process
Liquids Brown
Gas Light Green
Steam/condensate White
Flushing/Lube oil Brown
Fuel gas/fuel oil Yellow
Heat transfer fluid ("hot oil") Brown
Cooling water Green
Service/Potable Water White
Instrument air/tool air Blue
Nitrogen Orange
Chemical Orange
Relief/drain/slops Black
General purpose Purple
Fire-fighting water Red
For all other items the choice of the colour coding is at the discretion of the model builder,
subject to approval by Owner’s project team.
i. Equipment – All equipment outline shapes, including all nozzles, ducts, platforms, stacks,
supports and space reservation for maintenance access ways and equipment withdrawal
volumes
ii. Piping – All above and underground piping regardless of size, including all piping components,
supports/hangers, insulation and in-line and on-line instruments
iii. Structural – Steel and concrete structures including - Primary Structural Framings, Secondary
Structural Framing, Tertiary Structural, Structural Joint & Strengthening Detailing and Other
Structural Component
iv. Civil – Civil foundations, cable trenches, ducts, duct banks, underground pits, bund walls, piles
and pile caps. Earthworks, terrain modelling with roads, paving , fencing and gates
v. Drainage and sewerage – including all underground piping and fittings, sumps, manholes,
valves, valve pits, ditches, channels, culverts, effluent treatment pits/structures/ and sewerage
septic tank
vi. Plant Buildings – structure, floors, walls, roof, suspended floor and ceilings, floor screed, floor
and roof penetrations, doors, windows, stairs, landings, ladders and hand railing.
vii. Building HVAC – equipment, refrigerant, piping, drains, ductwork and insulation
viii. Electrical – As a minimum shall include cable trays, transformers, generators, electrical panel,
lighting, local control station, outdoor switchgear, motors and junction boxes with
underground interfaces
ix. Instrumentation – Location of all field instruments and instrument process connections, cable
trays/ladders, junction boxes and frames, analyzer houses, analyzer shelters and frames, and
locally mounted instrument control panels. Instrument junction boxes, local panels, etc., shall
be modelled complete with access/maintenance volumes, instrument air tubing and impulse
lines need not be shown.
xi. Fixed Fire Protection and Fire Fighting System – Fire main routing, hydrants, fixes water
monitors, hose cabinets, deluge valve manifolds, CO2 storage cylinders, dry risers and foam
systems. Fire points, fire alarm telephones and fire detector systems
xiii. Existing Plant and Facilities – For reference as required, but shall include all interface and tie-in
requirements.
xiv. Supplier packages shall be an intelligent model and have the same level of detail as rest of the
facility or plant.
xv. The line-up shall be followed systematically and strict attention shall be paid to details, since
seemingly minor items can cause accidents. Start, for instance, with the unit feed system, check
furnaces as a separate block, then proceed to internal circulation and product rundown circuits
and conclude with a check on safety, firefighting and utility systems. Critical pipes (to be
determined by piping/process engineers) require special attention (e.g. two-phase flow pipes).
xvi. Pipeline components – Pipelines, risers, pig launchers/receivers, finger type slugcatcher.
ITEMS TO BE REVIEWED 30 60 90
% % %
1 Location and orientation of all equipment and all space consumers √ √ √
(including future extensions)
2 Primary Structure Framing (Steel & Concrete): Beam, Column, Truss √ √ √
3 Major piping (to be agreed by project owner) that influences √ √ √
equipment layout and positions
4 Escape routes (on grade and elevation) √ √ √
5 Pipe racks √ √ √
6 Dropout/bundle pulling areas √ √ √
7 Laydown areas √ √ √
8 Flare boom location, heat radiation radius and height √ √ √
9 Bridge location and bridge supports √ √ √
10 Flare piping, slope and supports √ √ √
11 Living quarter location and dimension √ √ √
12 Helideck location √ √ √
13 Boat landing location and rig approach location √ √ √
14 Riser(s) locations √ √ √
15 Clash check √ √ √
16 Buildings in outline e.g. Living quarters, temporary shelters, √ √
laboratory, warehouse, maintenance workshops, control room,
analyser houses/shelters, and switchgear rooms
17 Riser guards √ √
18 Equipment nozzles orientation √ √
19 Fireproofing and Insulation √ √
20 Blast walls √ √
21 Bund walls √ √
22 Main access ways / operational access √ √
23 Concrete foundations, slabs, paving and roads √ √
24 Packaged unit location and orientation √ √
25 Main Pipe Support Structures √ √
26 Outline of underground main electrical and instrumentation √ √
trenches
27 Main electrical and instrumentation cable trays / racks, 12” and √ √
larger
28 Underground drainage systems. This include underground Oily √ √
drainage (AOC/COC and closed drain), chemical drains, if any,
including catch basins, manholes, pits, vessels, and separation/
treatment facilities
29 Buildings Floor Plans, e.g. Living quarters, temporary shelters, √ √
laboratory, warehouse, maintenance workshops, control room,
analyser houses, and switchgear rooms
79 Hatch cover √ √
80 Structural Joint & Strengthening Detailing: Haunch, Ring, Insert Plate, √ √
Wing Plate, Stiffener, Doubler Plate, Bolted Connection
Table A4.1: Checklist for Items to be Reviewed During Detailed Engineering
1. SUMMARY
Checklists provided herewith are intended to facilitate an effective and efficient review of
the 3D-CAD model. It also aims to improve the overall quality of the 3D-CAD model and to
identify and eliminate potentially hazardous situations as far as practicable.
The scope of this checklist is applicable to oil refineries, chemical plants, gas plants,
exploration and production facilities (onshore and offshore including floaters), and
supply/marketing installations and to specific items such as storage facilities and/or jetties,
road/rail loading facilities and complicated manifolds.
The checklist is comprehensive but should not be considered to be fully exhaustive. Review
checklist items may be added to address review items that are specific to a particular facility
in order to achive the objective of the review as stated herewith in this document.
A GENERAL YES NO
1 Is the proposed set-up logical and optimal with respect to process
integration?
2 Are roads properly defined with respect to their logical approach to
unit(s)? Consider also the movements area, including its marine location
and rail and road connections. Include road dimensions, considering main
roads (unrestricted) and restricted access roads.
3 Is erection possible during construction: furnaces, columns, large vessels,
reactors, air-cooled heat exchanger structures, flare header and flare
plot?
4 Have area classification requirements been taken into account?
5 Is the location of the Utilities area logical and optimal in relation to the
process units?
6 Is the location of the (Products) Movements Area logical and optimal in
relation to the process units?
7 Is the prevailing wind direction considered in relation to the location of
tank farms, LPG storage or gas plants, buildings, stacks, flare and oil
collecting systems, like sewers, oil catcher basins, air cooler banks and
areas containing H2S or HF?
8 Has a sterile area been provided around the flare stack?
9 Have appropriate separation distances been taken into account between
units, storage areas and buildings as well as public fences?
10 Have appropriate separation distances been taken into account between
units, storage areas and buildings as well as public fences?
11 Is the risk at the perimeter fence deemed to be within the ALARP?
12 Is the noise level at the perimeter fence in accordance with the legislated
maximum allowable limit by the host country?
6 Check for proper smooth connections between platforms and table tops.
7 Are emergency/smothering steam headers at a safe distance from the
equipment to be protected, e.g. in hydrogen service or furnaces?
8 Check that operators manipulating drain valves of open drain systems can
see the drained effluent. Provide tundishes as required.
9 Check that water seals trapped in goosenecks can be displaced by
hydrocarbons, i.e. ensure enough static head of oil is available.
10 Check if utility stations have been provided at the operational platforms
as required.
2 Can fire water hydrants, monitors and deluge valve stations be safely
accessed?
3 Can a fire truck manoeuvre easily?
4 Can all locations be reached by a fire truck if one road is blocked?
5 Fire-risk pumps handling liquids above their auto-ignition temperature or
handling very light liquids such as propane and butane shall be located:
in the open;
in non-congested areas;
at least 3 m from pipe racks and major process structures;
so that they are accessible for firefighting;
So that escalation of a possible pool fire from e.g. a seal failure
is prevented.
6 Only pumps handling burnable liquids below their auto-ignition
temperature may be placed in between a pipe rack and equipment like
columns.
7 Only pneumatic driven diapraghm pumps handling non-flammable liquids
may be placed under pipe racks or structures.
8 Can hot pumps be properly protected by fire water spray systems or
monitors?
9 Check location of fire hydrants, fixed, mobile and portable firefighting
equipment. Consider this in relation to the equipment to be protected
and the likelihood of a fire.
10 Check presence of fireproofing of steel structures with respect to credible
fires. Protect vessels, columns, flare headers, main pipe racks, if required.
11 Check whether the layout of water spray pipes and nozzles is adequate to
cool LPG vessels.
12 Are fire detectors and tubing present on hot pumps and LPG pumps?
13 Are detectors for fire, gas, smoke and H2S strategically located?
14 Are warning and alarm lights for fire, gas, smoke and H2S strategically
located?
15 Are fire water deluge manifolds safely located in relation to the
equipment they protect?
16 Are TV cameras for plant monitoring strategically located to enable a
good view of the high risk areas?
17 Check if emergency showers and eyewash showers are strategically
located, e.g. near equipment handling caustic, ammonia, Adip and other
aggressive chemicals. Valves are not allowed between the main header
and the safety equipment.
18 Check the flange orientation of liquid full LPG systems.
E PIPING
1 Is piping entering and leaving the plant logically grouped together at the
battery limit?
2 Are valves, spading positions, flushing and draining and instrument
connections properly located, in relation to normal operations as well as
shutdowns? Take special care of manifolds relief valves and large control
valves.
3 If spades have been provided, is there sufficient storage area when the
spacers are installed?
4 If spectacle blinds are fitted, are they accessible and can they be turned
safely? Consider additional or adapted platforms where applicable.
5 Has the number of flanges been minimised? This is particularly relevant
for systems containing substances above their auto-ignition temperature
and systems containing very toxic substances.
6 Check the elevation of piping and its clearance to walkways and
maintenance equipment (e.g. lifting equipment). Avoid head bumpers.
7 Are start-up and circulation pipes short? Have dead ends been avoided?
Can the system be flushed and drained?
8 Do vapour pipes, including steam pipes, freely branch off from the top of
main pipes?
9 Can piping subject to thermal expansion indeed expand? Check that
nozzles and branches (e.g. instruments) on expanding piping do not touch
obstructions, such as support beams.
10 Look for pockets in vapour pipes where condensation may occur. Has
external heating been applied on those pockets which cannot be
avoided?
11 Are long small diameter pipes (e.g. instrument impulse pipes) supported
properly to prevent breakage due to vibration?
12 Check for adequate space and jacking facilities to remove man-hole
covers, especially for those with inserts.
13 Pipes should not pass through table tops (or deck for offshore platforms).
Where this cannot be avoided, ensure a protective kerb (or coaming for
offshore platforms) is provided around the open area to prevent any
rainwater or hydrocarbon contaminated water from entering the area (or
deck) below. All rain water disposal pipes from a table top (or deck) shall
be extended to the underground drain (AOC/COC) piping or to the
Hazardous/non hazardous drain for offshore platforms
14 Have dead end sections been avoided, e.g. in steam and water pipes, in
pipes with high pour point material and piping in general?
15 Has piping been designed for ease of drainage and/or venting?
16 Check the position of eccentric reducers. Normally the straight part is on
the bottom of horizontal pipes, except in pump suction pipes where
vapour pockets may cause cavitation of the pump.
17 Do compressor suction pipes slope towards the knock-out drum? If not
Process, Rotating Equipment Specialist should be consulted. Each low
point of the compressor suction should have a low point drain.
18 Check that small bore cooling water pipes emerge from the top of the
header.
19 Are stripping steam pipes short and horizontal, or sloping from the last
valve?
20 Verify that two-phase flow vertical piping has been checked for flow
stability, also for the turndown case.
21 Check absorber gas feed inlets for pockets near the inlet to avoid
absorbent entering the gas inlet pipe.
22 Is piping with instrument connections positioned such that these
connections are easily accessible? Is the measurement point in the
correct process location? Have the necessary platforms and walkways
been provided?
8 Check that control valve assemblies are located at ground level or on the
first platform, except when otherwise required for process reasons.
9 Has installation of valves outside of platforms been avoided?
10 Have check valves or double-block valves been installed in utility
connections to process equipment and piping?
11 Have spring-loaded/self closing and/or extra block valves been used
where valves may freeze up when draining or sampling?
12 Check that hot oil (Heat Transfer Fluid) valve stem are positioned in the
horizontal plane or at a maximum of 45deg. This is to prevent
accumulation of hot oil in the insulation if the packing is leaking, since
most Hot oil is carcinogenic.
13 Check that DBB has been provided where required by the PTS.
14 Check that stripping steam pipes to columns have a drain pipe for
condensate removal and a vent pipe near to the column.
G HEAT EXCHANGERS AND BOILERS
1 Is the piping arrangement and supporting acceptable with respect to
removal of shell and channel covers as well as the withdrawal of tube
bundles? Consider the removal of inlet and outlet piping. Has the bundle
pulling device sufficient plot space?
2 Check whether bundles can be pulled and lowered safely from platforms
and stacked exchanger arrangements.
3 Check stacked heat exchangers for the possibility of oil spills on hot heat
exchangers or other equipment beneath, especially during maintenance
work. In this case, consider a large oil collecting funnel underneath, or
check the possibility to take both out of service.
4 Check if the drain and vent valves are correctly located as specified on the
P&ID, hence drains at lowest points and close to the block valves if so
specified.
5 Check whether cranes, bundle pulling equipment and vehicles can enter
for pulling and transportation of bundles.
6 Check whether heat exchangers can be cleaned in situ. Are the required
provisions present (e.g. valves, cleaning pipes, etc.)?
7 Check that exchangers in LPG (any other fluid that require this) service
have been provided on the water outlet side with a vent pipe to a safe
location or to a flare system to allow gas to escape in case of tube leak.
H PUMPS AND COMPRESSORS
1 Is valving around pumps and compressors accessible and operable?
2 Note that the hook-up around pumps provided with seal oil pipes, steam
pipes, flush oil, steam tracing etc. needs considerable plot space. These
small size support pipes may not been indicated in the model. Ensure
adequate pump accessibility.
3 Also, ensure start/stop poles are not obstructed.
4 Can the pump and compressor safely be handled for maintenance such as
strainer/filter sieve/cartridge removal respectively? Pay special attention
to spading-off possibilities and draining of the casing and the strainer.
5 Is removal of the pump and the electric motor practical?
6 Ensure that heat tracing around equipment or valves can be dismantled
to allow removal.
7 Is the flow in suction piping smooth? Check for the required straight
length of the suction pipe for pumps or compressor suction and discharge
line.
8 Have high points in pump suction pipes been avoided?
9 Check volumes which must be drained when a filter or the pump needs
to be opened.If the volume is very large, enlarge the size of drain valves
to achieve a reasonable draining time. Also check that the drain piping
of filters and casing is short and straight.
10 For pumps with a vertical suction pipe and an elevated strainer, check
that opening of such a strainer does not result in spilling flammable liquid
and possible ignition on nearby hot surfaces.
11 Are pump priming facilities adequate? Is the vent valve at the highest
point at discharge and suction side?
12 Is location of the local compressor panel practical?
13 Are compressor seal oil tanks provided with their vents to the atmosphere
at a safe location?
14 Are lube oil storage drums or rundown tanks properly protected against
ingress of rain water and is the storage area properly drained?
15 Are compressors with bottom inlet pipes at the suction provided with
liquid drains to a closed system?
16 Is instrumentation (e.g. panels, detectors) easily accessible for
maintenance?
17 Has plant vibration been considered in the location of instruments and
electrical equipment?
18 Is there space for cranes to enter and manoeuvre?
I FURNACES AND BOILERS
1 Check that suction of air blowers is taken from a non-hazardous area.
2 Check that observation windows, access doors, header box covers, etc.
are not obstructed.
3 Is space available for withdrawing and cleaning tubes? Is there space for
cranes to enter and manoeuvre?
4 Is piping at burners arranged in such a way that insertion and removal of
ignitors and burner guns is not hampered?
5 With regard to the safety of fuel systems:
Are heavy fuel and LBF (low boiling fuel) systems sufficiently
segregated?
Are adequate provisions made to prevent liquid fuels from entering
atomising steam and steam-out pipes?
Are low-points in fuel gas pipes avoided between the fuel gas knock-
out vessel and the burners or has tracing been provided?
Are locations of flame arrestors, straight pipe lengths, etc. of low
pressure and waste gas in accordance with specifications?
6 Are emergency/smothering steam headers at a safe distance?
7 Make sure that dry emergency or smothering steam is made available,
with:
outlet branches positioned on top of mains;
steam pipes without pockets;
Sufficient steam traps and drain point provided.
8 On manually-started furnaces, are fuel valves of fuel oil and fuel gas
within reach when looking at the burners through the observation
windows?
9 Is the emergency shutdown switch at a safe location?
10 For multiple furnaces: check for a logical and clear layout of each furnace
and its local start-up panel.
11 Can a furnace be spaded off at its flue gas duct for furnace entrance and
repair? This is required when multiple furnaces are connected to a
common flue gas duct and one of the furnaces is required to continue to
operate.
J VESSELS AND COLUMNS
1 Check for unnecessary dedicated drain piping (e.g. where draining a
vessel or column to grade can be done via existing piping such as drains
of pumps).
2 Check that manholes are within reach of hoisting equipment? Ensure
proper space on platforms for turning the manhole covers and for
entering equipment.
3 Are instrument tappings and local instruments and level glasses readily
accessible? Note that a levelglass on a vessel or column actually may
protrude 500 mm into the platform area and thus form an unacceptable
obstruction.
4 Check that instrument support poles, such as those used for pressure
transmitters, are not obstructing a walkway of a platform around a
column.
5 Has insulation for personnel protection been provided? Check especially
hot vapour and product pipes which can be easily touched from
platforms.
6 Can the pipes follow the expansion of the equipment when heating up
and cooling down? Pay special attention to supports on both hot and cold
structures.
7 Check free movement of platforms (thermal expansion).
8 Check if specified elevations of vessels and columns on P&ID are adhered
to.
9 Check that the barometric seals of vacuum equipment are at the specified
height. This also applies for relative elevations of vessels belonging to a
vacuum system.
10 For columns with structured packing, ensure there are utility connection
point nearby the manholes.
K RELIEF SYSTEMS:FLARE AND VENT SYSTEMS
1 Flare pipes shall have no pockets and shall slope continuously to the flare
knock-out drum.
2 If a platform is installed for spading a part of the flare pipe whilst the main
flare pipe is still in use, ensure that there is enough space to do the work.
Check that there is a proper escape way from this platform.
3 Check that inlet pipes to relief valves are provided with drain connection.
4 Check that outlet pipes from relief valves are self-draining into the flare
header. An exception may be made for liquid (e.g. DN 20 DN 25) thermal
relief valves which do not need to be self-draining on both sides if the
pipes would become too long. Check that connections are made on top
or 45deg perpendicular to the flare header.
5 Ensure that process relief valves and process thermal relief valves are not
routed to grade. They should end in a closed system.
6 Check the accessibility of relief valves sets for maintenance and
inspection. Have relief valves been installed at proper elevations relative
to the flare header? All relief valves should be accessible for removal (by
hoisting equipment if necessary).
7 Is safety/relief valve piping as short as possible when discharging into a
closed system?
8 Check relief valves discharging to atmosphere for safe location and
direction. Ensure that hot equipment is not located below discharge
points to the atmosphere if any hydrocarbons can be released. For a
waste gas seal vessel, pay special attention to this check.
9 Can relief valves be blocked-in and drained?
10 Check relief valve outlet pipe arrangements such that supports can be
provided to cope with reaction forces.
11 Is reactor vent gas safely routed during a regeneration?
12 Is the distance from the flame arrestor to the vent outlet as specified?
13 Ensure that flame arrestors in pipes to the atmosphere can be accessed
for removal and maintenance.
14 Check that the spindles of flare main block valves, if gate valves, are in a
horizontal position. This prevents a blocked flare pipe if the wedge should
fall down.
L OIL MOVEMENTS
1 In addition to the above checkpoints, the following shall apply for oil
movement installations.
2 Has the tankfarm been designed in accordance with the agreed
specifications, inclusive of separation distances and bund holding
capacity?
3 LPG storage: are safety requirements fulfilled, including distances, valves,
piping, pressure relief provisions, and civil aspects?
4 Tank farms: is the layout logical in relation to battery limits, pipe tracks,
blending and loading area?
5 Check that storage tanks are laid out maximum two “tanks-deep” and
that at least 2 sides are accessible for fire fighting. Dead end road in
between tanks are not allowed.
6 Are tanks and bund areas accessible for firefighting equipment?
7 Are tanks draining to an environmentally acceptable system?
8 Storage tanks with a blanketing system: is layout adequate, including its
vapour routing?
9 Check that piping to/from any tank is not routed through another tank’s
bunded area.
10 Vapour recovery systems: consider layout and maintenance aspects.
11 Jetties: are adequate working envelopes provided for hoses and loading
arms and is the width of the jetty sufficient for the required equipment?
12 For tank farms and pipe tracks: can rainwater and spilled oil be drained
adequately?
M ENVIRONMENTAL CHECKS
1 Check if any process liquid drained from equipment can be handled in an
environmentally acceptable manner, in line with general approach of
closed loops for liquid draining or vents. If required install funnels to the
oil collecting system.
2 Check drainage from pump casings and pump strainers.
3 Check drainage from process filters and coalescers.
4 Check drainage from fuel filters of furnaces.
5 Are drains from sample points of plants and storage tanks minimised by,
for example, closed loops?
6 Check drainage from instruments in analyser houses.
7 Check drainage from heat exchangers when opened for bundle cleaning
or repairs. Consider also the effect of liquid spillage when opening both
heads as well as when pulling the bundle.
8 Check drainage of sour or spent seal and lube oils from compressors.
9 Check drainage from pipes at the battery limit prior to spading the unit.
10 Check vent to atmosphere from an analyser house.
11 Check that liquid collected in an open oil are routed into collecting pit for
recovery and treatment.
12 Check that ground water testwell to test for pollution are located at
various locations in the plant.
13 Check where vents of seal chambers of reciprocating compressors are
routed to.
14 Check that unloading and storage of chemicals, additives, caustic,
ammonia etc. can be carried out without environmental impact.
15 Check that the distance around plants is in accordance with any local
regulations, including noise limitations.
Table A5.1: Overall 3D-CAD Model Checklist