Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 6

PEDIATRIC/CRANIOFACIAL

Lambdoid Craniosynostosis: The Relationship


with Chiari Deformations and an Analysis of
Surgical Outcomes
Jeffrey A. Fearon, M.D.
Background: A relationship between lambdoid craniosynostosis and Chiari
Vanessa Dimas, M.D.
deformations has been suggested, but the true extent of this association
Kanlaya Ditthakasem,
­remains uncertain. The authors reviewed a single center’s experience treating
M.N.S., R.N. lambdoid synostosis to further elucidate this relationship, examine surgical
Dallas and Corpus Christi, Texas outcomes, and identify associations that might impact future treatments.
Methods: A retrospective chart review was performed of all patients treated
for lambdoid craniosynostosis, excluding the syndromic craniosynostoses.
Operative data, scans, hospitalization, and subsequent surgical procedures
were tracked. All patients were treated with remodeling procedures, but those
with Chiari deformations underwent additional simultaneous suboccipital
decompressions.
Results: Over 22 years, 1006 nonsyndromic craniosynostosis patients were treat-
ed, 45 of whom (4.5 percent) presented with lambdoid involvement: 25 single-
suture and 20 multiple-suture (complex craniosynostosis). Magnetic resonance
imaging revealed that 60 percent of children with unilateral synostosis and
71 percent with a complex synostosis had associated Chiari deformations. The
mean surgical age was 12 months, and the average follow-up was 5.7 years: two
patients developed syringomyelia requiring transcervical decompressions and
two underwent secondary posterior remodeling procedures (one unilateral
and one complex synostosis) while undergoing later Chiari decompressions.
No patients treated with initial suboccipital decompressions have subsequently
developed symptoms requiring treatment.
Conclusions: The majority of children with lambdoid synostosis develop C ­ hiari
deformations; therefore, routine preoperative and postoperative magnetic
­resonance imaging should be considered. The treatment of lambdoid cranio-
synostosis with cranial remodeling procedures, including incontinuity suboc-
cipital decompressions when Chiari deformations were present, was associated
with few complications. Ninety-six percent of those with isolated fusions were
managed with a single procedure. (Plast. Reconstr. Surg. 137: 946, 2016.)
CLINICAL QUESTION/LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Therapeutic, IV.

T
he lambdoid suture gets its descriptive name of all single-suture craniosynostoses, although its
from the shape created by the intersection incidence (or detection) may be on the rise.1,2
of both sutures coming together producing One systematic review, focusing solely on surgi-
an inverted-V shape, similar to the Greek letter cally corrected lambdoid synostosis, identified
lambda. It is commonly recognized as being one of only 17 publications (most of these were reviews
the least common sutural fusions, typically quoted of all craniosynostoses), for a combined total of
as occurring somewhere between 3 and 4 percent 188 reported surgically treated cases.3 Given the
low frequency of presentation of this condition,
it is not surprising that there is a paucity of out-
From The Craniofacial Center; the Driscoll Craniofacial comes data following surgical treatment. None
and Cleft Center; and the Department of Research, Medical
City Dallas Hospital.
Received for publication May 3, 2015; accepted October 22, Disclosure: None of the authors has a financial
2015. ­interest in any of the products or devices mentioned
Copyright © 2016 by the American Society of Plastic Surgeons in this article.
DOI: 10.1097/01.prs.0000480014.18541.d8

946 www.PRSJournal.com
Copyright © 2016 American Society of Plastic Surgeons. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Volume 137, Number 3 • Lambdoid Craniosynostosis

of the articles captured in this review evaluated


or described any potential relationship between
unilateral lambdoid craniosynostosis and Chiari
deformations. Venes may have been the first to
report the association between the development
of cerebellar tonsillar herniation and syndromic
craniosynostosis; however, based on a review of
their patients with Crouzon syndrome, Cinalli
et al. were the first to suggest a relationship
between fusion of the lambdoid sutures and the
development of Chiari deformations.4,5 Aside
from the syndromic synostoses, these two condi-
tions have also been reported to occur with an
increased frequency in patients with certain sub-
types of complex craniosynostosis.6,7 To our knowl-
edge, the true extent of any potential association
between unilateral lambdoid craniosynostosis and
Fig. 1. A vertex bandeau is removed and swiveled so that the
an acquired Chiari deformation remains uncer-
unaffected (taller) side is moved to the affected side. The ban-
tain. We sought to review our center’s experience
deau is then rotated 90 degrees inferiorly, in a bucket-handle
treating lambdoid synostosis to further explore fashion, inset, and stabilized.
the relationship between these two conditions,
examine our surgical outcomes, and identify asso- addition to performing a posterior cranial vault
ciations that might guide future treatment. remodeling procedure, an in-continuity suboc-
cipital decompression of the foramen magnum
PATIENTS AND METHODS was simultaneously undertaken in all patients,
Following approval from the Institutional also as described previously (Figs. 2 and 3).9 All
Review Board at Medical City Dallas Hospital patients were followed with magnetic resonance
(no. 13.042), a retrospective chart review was per- imaging scans postoperatively, with increasing
formed of all consecutive patients with lambdoid time lags based on age, until skeletal maturity.
craniosynostosis treated by a single surgeon. All The need for secondary operative intervention
patients with syndromic craniosynostoses were was determined by either the development of a
excluded because often these sutures will initially symptomatic Chiari I deformation or a significant
appear patent but later go on to fuse. However, recurrence of the presenting deformity. Categori-
all complex pattern synostoses that initially pre- cal variables were examined using the chi-square
sented with lambdoid fusions were included.
A geneticist evaluated patients suspected of hav-
ing a syndromic presentation, and gene testing
was performed when appropriate. Operative data,
hospital lengths of stay, initial and any subsequent
surgical interventions, and all preoperative and
postoperative scans were tracked. The surgical
technique varied depending on preoperative
magnetic resonance imaging findings. For those
patients with isolated sutural involvement with-
out evidence of cerebellar tonsillar herniation, a
posterior cranial vault remodeling procedure was
performed using a transposed bucket-handle ver-
tex bandeau (flipped 180 degrees so that the unaf-
fected taller side was rotated to the affected side
to increase the posterior projection after rotation
from the vertical to the horizontal plane) and a Fig. 2. When a Chiari deformation is present, a suboccipital
transposed parietooccipital craniotomy bone decompression can be performed to open up the foramen
flap, as described previously (Fig. 1).8 However, magnum by removing the lower occipital bone in the posterior
when cerebellar tonsillar herniation was noted, in midline.

947
Copyright © 2016 American Society of Plastic Surgeons. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery • March 2016

Fig. 3. (Left) Magnetic resonance imaging scan demonstrating cerebellar tonsillar herniation in a
child with unilateral lambdoid craniosynostosis. (Right) Postoperative magnetic resonance imag-
ing scan showing resolution of the herniation in the same child, 1 month after a posterior cranial
vault remodeling procedure with an in-continuity suboccipital decompression.

or Fisher’s exact test, and continuous variables identified as having cerebellar tonsillar hernia-
were examined using the t test. Categorical vari- tion. A slightly higher incidence of cerebellar
ables are presented as actual incidences and con- tonsillar herniation was noted among those with
tinuous variables are presented as means. Where multiple-suture involvement (complex cranio-
data were missing, we made no assumptions and synostoses), with 12 of 17 (71 percent) affected;
performed the analyses without them. Statistical however, these differences did not reach statisti-
significance was set at p = 0.05. SAS statistical soft- cal significance (Table 1). In addition, when we
ware version 9.4 (SAS Institute, Inc., Cary, N.C.) evaluated the differing incidences of cerebellar
was used for all analyses. tonsillar herniation between single lambdoid
fusions and bilateral lambdoid fusions, although
there was a much higher percentage of Chiari
RESULTS deformations when both sutures were involved
Over a 22-year period, 1006 nonsyndromic (83 percent versus 40 percent), these differences
patients were treated at our center. Of these, 45 also did not reach significance (Table 2). None
(4.5 percent) presented with lambdoid involve- of the patients in this series initially presented
ment: 25 (56 percent) of these had isolated sin- with any clinical evidence suggestive for symptom-
gle-suture involvement and 20 (44 percent) had atic Chiari deformations. A comparison between
multiple-suture involvement as a component of a the observed incidences of Chiari deformations
complex pattern of craniosynostosis. Among the among patients with single-suture lambdoid syn-
isolated presentations, there was a slight male ostoses and those with bilateral lambdoid synos-
predominance (male patients, 60 percent; female tosis showed no statistically significant difference.
patients, 40 percent); however, there were no The diagnosis of synostosis was made primarily
significant differences noted between involved by physical examination in the later part of this
sides (right, 52 percent; left, 48 percent). Various series; when children presented with an uncertain
presentations of complex pattern craniosynosto-
ses with lambdoid involvement were identified,
including 11 patients with Mercedes Benz [sagit- Table 1. Comparison of the Incidence of Chiari
Deformations between Isolated Lambdoid
tal, bilateral lambdoid (55 percent)]; three coro-
Synostoses and Complex Synostoses
nal lambdoid (15 percent); two metopic lambdoid
(10 percent); and two Z-pattern [coronal, sagit- Unilateral Complex
Lambdoid Synostosis
tal, opposite lambdoid (10 percent)]; one bilat- (%) (%) Total
eral, and one coronal-sagittal-bilateral lambdoid. Yes 12 (60) 12 (70.59) 24
Twenty of 25 patients with isolated unilateral No 8 (40) 5 (29.41) 13
lambdoid involvement underwent magnetic res- Total 20 17 37
p (χ2) 0.5014
onance imaging and 12 of 20 (60 percent) were

948
Copyright © 2016 American Society of Plastic Surgeons. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Volume 137, Number 3 • Lambdoid Craniosynostosis

Table 2. Comparison of the Incidence of Chiari complex craniosynostosis required an extra day for
Deformations between One and More Than One bronchodilators and chest physical therapy. With
Affected Lambdoid Suture a mean follow-up of 5.7 years (range, 2 months
Multisutural Multisutural to 15 years), two patients (one isolated and one
Fusions with Only Fusions with with multiple-suture involvement) subsequently
One Lambdoid Bilateral Lambdoid developed syringomyelia, requiring transcervical
Suture (%) Sutures (%) Total
decompressions. Neither of these two patients
Yes 2 (40) 10 (83.33) 12 had undergone a suboccipital decompression
No 3 (60) 2 (16.67) 5
Total 5 12 17 during their initial posterior cranial remodeling
p (χ2) 0.0740 procedure. A second posterior remodeling proce-
dure was performed in two patients: one multiple-
clinical picture, they were reexamined 4 months suture patient underwent secondary remodeling
later to evaluate changes in skull shape that had procedures during subsequent Chiari decompres-
occurred with subsequent growth. If at this later sion and one single-suture patient (4 percent)
time the diagnosis remained unclear, a computed underwent a secondary correction at 40 months,
tomographic scan was obtained and, when posi- also for a symptomatic Chiari deformation. This
tive, often an incomplete fusion was identified patient had additional anomalies, including mul-
(Fig. 4). Among those children diagnosed without tiple congenital heart defects and an immuno-
computed tomographic scan verification, all were deficiency but, most noteworthy, had undergone
noted to have fused lambdoid sutures at the time correction primarily at a relatively earlier age
of surgery. The mean surgical age for the isolated (7 months) compared with others in this series.
lambdoid synostoses was 12 months (range, 4 to Two years postoperatively, this patient presented
42 months), and the average hospital stay was 2.3 with a symptomatic Chiari I deformation (dyspha-
days. The average surgical age for the complex gia and aspiration) and some recurrence of poste-
synostoses was slightly higher at 12.4 months, and rior plagiocephaly, and thus a combined posterior
cranial vault remodeling was performed with an
the average length of stay was 2.4 days. There were
in-continuity suboccipital decompression of the
no major complications or mortalities in either
foramen magnum. Of the 17 patients treated with
group. Two patients with isolated lambdoid syn-
simultaneous suboccipital decompression for
ostosis required a third hospital day for postop-
associated Chiari deformations (nine with unilat-
erative nausea and vomiting, and one patient with
eral lambdoid synostosis and eight with complex
synostoses), none has subsequently developed
symptoms associated with these Chiari deforma-
tions or radiologic evidence for progression of
their tonsillar herniation.

DISCUSSION
Lambdoid craniosynostosis is the least com-
monly encountered craniosynostosis, constitut-
ing only 4.5 percent of all nonsyndromic cases
treated at our center in Dallas. It is therefore not
surprising that there is a relative paucity of pub-
lished outcomes data following the surgical cor-
rection for this unusual sutural fusion. A number
of different surgical approaches to treatment have
been described for treating lambdoid synostosis,
including strip craniectomies followed by skull-
molding devices, remodeling procedures, and
Fig. 4. In many children, the diagnosis of lambdoid synostosis even distraction osteogenesis.10–13 This current
can be made based solely on examination. However, there are review suggests that treatment with a single-stage
some children who present with less clear clinical diagnoses, posterior cranial vault remodeling procedure was
especially those with incomplete fusions. In these cases, further associated with a relatively short hospitalization
evaluation with a computed tomographic scan can be helpful in (<2.4 days), with the majority of patients spending
making the diagnosis. only two nights in the hospital, and no significant

949
Copyright © 2016 American Society of Plastic Surgeons. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery • March 2016

perioperative complications. Furthermore, almost that involvement of multiple sutures should fur-
all those presenting with an isolated lambdoid ther elevate this risk. Although a higher incidence
fusion (96 percent) have required only a single of Chiari deformations was noted in our patients
procedure, over an average follow-up length of with more than one sutural fusion, this difference
5.7 years. One child, treated earlier in this series, did not attain significance, although one might
did require a secondary vault remodeling proce- speculate that an even larger series might show
dure that was triggered by the development of a such a difference. Experience with syndromic
symptomatic Chiari deformation with recurrence synostoses suggests that cerebellar tonsillar her-
of the posterior plagiocephaly. We speculate that a niation is an acquired deformation; therefore, the
surgical correction performed at too early an age incidence in children with lambdoid synostosis
(7 months) and failure to sufficiently overcorrect might be expected to rise with longer lengths of
the observed deformity may both have contrib- follow-up, especially in those treated at an early
uted to this symptomatic recurrence. Based on age or with an insufficient correction, which
studies suggesting superior long-term growth with might both result in recurrence of the presenting
later surgical interventions, our recommended phenotype.5,19,20 For those patients treated earlier
primary treatment age shifted in the later part in this series, or when patients were referred from
of this series to somewhere between 11 and outside institutions, evaluations with plain radio-
18 months of age, depending on clinical sever- graphs and computed tomographic scans were
ity.14,15 Although the average length of follow-up more likely to have been performed, whereas later
for this study falls short of reaching skeletal matu- in this series, the senior author (J.A.F.) would only
rity, these data suggest that with an over 5-year obtain computed tomographic scans for uncer-
follow-up and using symptomatic Chiari deforma- tain presentations, such as seen with incomplete
tions, new-onset cerebellar tonsillar herniation, sutural fusions. Our preferred imaging modality
and significant clinical phenotypic recurrences as for those presenting with more obvious clinical
criteria for reoperation, the treatment paradigm signs for lambdoid craniosynostosis is magnetic
used appears effective with respect to revision resonance imaging, and more recently, we have
rates. Specifically, the incidence for those with iso- transitioned to using a rapid sequence protocol to
lated single-suture lambdoid involvement under- avoid the need for general anesthesia. Our pref-
going secondary remodeling procedures is much erence for magnetic resonance imaging is based
lower (4 percent) than has been reported for on the ability of this imaging modality to pro-
other single-suture craniosynostosis repairs with vide better visualization of the hindbrain, which
similar reported lengths of follow-up.16–18 Never- in turn impacted our surgical decision-making.
theless, we recognize that comparisons of second- For example, if preoperative imaging revealed an
ary surgical interventions are complicated by the absence of cerebellar tonsillar herniation, only a
subjective nature of any decision to reoperate. posterior remodeling procedure was performed.
In addition, identification of a phenotypic recur- However, when cerebellar tonsillar herniation
rence in the posterior skull may be camouflaged was identified, a suboccipital decompression was
by the presence of hair, favorably biasing compari- added to the remodeling procedure by extending
sons to metopic and coronal fusions. a posterior midline osteotomy inferiorly (typically
In spite of the recognized relationship between by approximately 2 cm) to open up the posterior
lambdoid synostosis and Chiari deformations in aspect of the foramen magnum. Performance of
children with syndromic and certain subtypes of a suboccipital decompression during posterior
complex craniosynostosis, we are unaware of any remodeling procedures has been shown to provide
focused reviews examining the potential associa- radiographic improvement of tonsillar herniation
tion of cerebellar tonsillar herniation in children in 70 percent of asymptomatic patients (with sta-
with isolated single-suture lambdoid craniosyn- bility in the remaining 30 percent) without add-
ostosis. Within this series of patients, we noted a ing any additional morbidity.9 We believe that this
surprisingly high incidence of Chiari deforma- additional step has the potential to prevent the
tions (60 percent) in children with single-suture development of a symptomatic Chiari deforma-
involvement. We believe that this finding under- tion, and the need for later surgical intervention,
scores the importance of performing preopera- by preventing future cord compression. Thus
tive magnetic resonance imaging for all affected far, of the 17 patients undergoing simultaneous
children. If fusion of just a single lambdoid suture suboccipital decompressions in this series, none
can have an impact on the development of cere- have required any additional treatment related to
bellar tonsillar herniation, it would seem intuitive the development of either a symptomatic Chiari

950
Copyright © 2016 American Society of Plastic Surgeons. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Volume 137, Number 3 • Lambdoid Craniosynostosis

deformation or a syrinx. However, we recognize 8. Fearon JA. Rigid fixation of the calvaria in craniosynos-
that our retrospective study design, and length of tosis without using “rigid” fixation. Plast Reconstr Surg.
2003;111:27–38; discussion 39.
follow-up of just under 6 years, might limit vali- 9. Scott WW, Fearon JA, Swift DM, Sacco DJ. Suboccipital
dation of this theory. With respect to long-term decompression during posterior cranial vault remodeling
patient follow-up, we recommend repeated rapid for selected cases of Chiari malformations associated with
sequence magnetic resonance imaging for all craniosynostosis. J Neurosurg Pediatr. 2013;12:166–170.
children previously diagnosed with cerebellar 10. Jimenez DF, Barone CM, Cartwright CC, Baker L. Early
management of craniosynostosis using endoscopic-assisted
tonsillar herniation or if recurrences of posterior strip craniectomies and cranial orthotic molding therapy.
plagiocephaly are subsequently identified, at ages Pediatrics 2002;110:97–104.
5 years, 10 years, and at skeletal maturity, or more 11. Thaller SR, Hoyt J, Boggan J. Surgical correction of unilat-
often, depending on clinical severity. eral lambdoid synostosis: Occipital rotation flap. J Craniofac
Surg. 1992;3:12–17; discussion 18.
Jeffrey A. Fearon, M.D. 12. Komuro Y, Yanai A, Hayashi A, Miyajima M, Nakanishi H,
The Craniofacial Center Arai H. Treatment of unilateral lambdoid synostosis with cra-
7777 Forest Lane, Suite C-700 nial distraction. J Craniofac Surg. 2004;15:609–613.
Dallas, Texas 75230 13. Smartt JM Jr, Reid RR, Singh DJ, Bartlett SP. True lambdoid
cranio700@gmail.com craniosynostosis: Long-term results of surgical and conserva-
tive therapy. Plast Reconstr Surg. 2007;120:993–1003.
14. Seruya M, Oh AK, Boyajian MJ, et al. Long-term outcomes of
REFERENCES primary craniofacial reconstruction for craniosynostosis: A
1. Singer S, Bower C, Southall P, Goldblatt J. Craniosynostosis 12-year experience. Plast Reconstr Surg. 2011;127:2397–2406.
in Western Australia, 1980-1994: A population-based study. 15. Fearon JA, Ruotolo RA, Kolar JC. Single sutural craniosynos-
Am J Med Genet. 1999;83:382–387. toses: Surgical outcomes and long-term growth. Plast Reconstr
2. Kolar JC. An epidemiological study of nonsyndromal cranio- Surg. 2009;123:635–642.
synostoses. J Craniofac Surg. 2011;22:47–49. 16. Pearson GD, Havlik RJ, Eppley B, Nykiel M, Sadove AM.
3. Al-Jabri T, Eccles S. Surgical correction for unilateral Craniosynostosis: A single institution’s outcome assess-
lambdoid synostosis: A systematic review. J Craniofac Surg. ment from surgical reconstruction. J Craniofac Surg.
2014;25:1266–1272. 2008;19:65–71.
4. Cinalli G, Renier D, Sebag G, Sainte-Rose C, Arnaud E, 17. Taylor JA, Paliga JT, Wes AM, et al. A critical evaluation of
Pierre-Kahn A. Chronic tonsillar herniation in Crouzon’s long-term aesthetic outcomes of fronto-orbital advancement
and Apert’s syndromes: The role of premature synostosis of and cranial vault remodeling in nonsyndromic unicoronal
the lambdoid suture. J Neurosurg. 1995;83:575–582. craniosynostosis. Plast Reconstr Surg. 2015;135:220–231.
5. Venes JL. Arnold-Chiari malformation in an infant with 18. Wes AM, Paliga JT, Goldstein JA, Whitaker LA, Bartlett SP,
Kleeblattschadel: An acquired malformation? Neurosurgery Taylor JA. An evaluation of complications, revisions, and
1988;23:360–362. long-term aesthetic outcomes in nonsyndromic metopic cra-
6. Rhodes JL, Kolar JC, Fearon JA. Mercedes Benz pattern cra- niosynostosis. Plast Reconstr Surg. 2014;133:1453–1464.
niosynostosis. Plast Reconstr Surg. 2010;125:299–304. 19. Fearon JA, Podner C. Apert syndrome: Evaluation of a treat-
7. Schmelzer RE, Fearon JA. ‘Z-pattern’ craniosynostosis: ment algorithm. Plast Reconstr Surg. 2013;131:132–142.
A novel presentation of trisutural fusion. J Craniofac Surg. 20. Fearon JA, Rhodes J. Pfeiffer syndrome: A treatment ­evaluation.
2007;18:568–574. Plast Reconstr Surg. 2009;123:1560–1569.

951
Copyright © 2016 American Society of Plastic Surgeons. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.

You might also like