Professional Documents
Culture Documents
04-Being Curated | Frieze
04-Being Curated | Frieze
04-Being Curated | Frieze
Being Curated
Dan Fox invited eight artists and artist groups to
reflect on their relationships to curators and
curatorial discourse
https://www.frieze.com/article/being-curated Page 1 of 26
Being Curated | Frieze 06/05/2024, 16:45
Daniel Buren, Les cabanes éclatées imbriquées, travail in situ (Exploded Overlapping Cabins, Work in Situ),
2011, installation view at Centre Pompidou-Metz
Dan Fox
– taken over from television production as the sensible option for nice
middle-class youngsters wanting a career in the arts. No other word or
phrase from the professional lexicon of contemporary art has leaked so
quickly into widespread popular usage as ‘curating’. When it’s not
celebrities ‘curating’ your lunchtime sushi box or clothes shops ‘curating’
your summer sock collection, curating is the motor of power and
discourse in exhibition-making. For the most part, the conversation about
curating has largely been dominated by curators. (The many who
freelance as critics have also altered the nature of such basic staples of
art writing as exhibition reviews. But that’s another story.)
This does not strike me as the healthiest situation. (Then again, junior
curators at New York’s Museum of Modern Art in the 1950s probably
thought the same about the omnipotent critics of their day.) Yes, there are
exceptions, and yes, I am generalizing. Of course, I’m not the first to have
wondered what the implications of the growth of curatorial power are for
artists. Curators – like critics – are nothing without art, no matter what the
most meta-inclined of curatorial theorists might argue. In 1972, Daniel
Buren published a short statement titled ‘Exposition d’une exposition’
(Exhibiting Exhibitions) in the catalogue for Documenta V, in which he
complained that: ‘The subject of exhibitions tends more and more to be
not so much the exhibition of works of art, as the exhibition of the
exhibition as a work of art.’ Buren’s text (in its 1992 English translation)
prefaces this survey, for which we asked a small selection of artists to
respond to the following questions: how do they feel about their role in the
discourses of curating? What do they think about their work being placed
in themed exhibitions or biennials, or in the context of new exhibition
formats and experiments in display? Are they happy to engage in dialogue
with curators when shaping exhibitions, or do they feel instrumentalized,
their work put at the service of someone else’s interests? And how do
artists who curate – and there are many – feel about their position in
relation to professional curators?
https://www.frieze.com/article/being-curated Page 3 of 26
Being Curated | Frieze 06/05/2024, 16:45
Daniel Buren, Exhibition of an Exhibition, A work in 7 pieces, Work in Situ, exhibition view at Documenta V,
Kassel, 1972, (standing next to a Flag by Jasper Johns)
The subject of exhibitions tends more and more to be not so much the
exhibition of works of art, as the exhibition of the exhibition as a work of
art.
https://www.frieze.com/article/being-curated Page 4 of 26
Being Curated | Frieze 06/05/2024, 16:45
———————— ),* that exhibits [expose] (the works) and lays itself
open [s’expose] (to the critics). The works presented are strokes of
colours painstakingly selected – of the picture that makes up each
section (room) in its totality. There is even an order in these colours, for
they are enclosed and composed in relation to the design of the section
(selection) in which they are displayed/presented. These sections
(castrations) – themselves ‘strokes of colours’ painstakingly selected – of
the picture that makes up the exhibition in its totality and in its very
principle, only make their appearance under the aegis of the organizer,
the person who re-unifies art by making it all the same in the
casket/screen he prepares for it. It is the organizer who deals with – and
screens – all contradictions.
So it is true that the exhibition weighs in as its own subject, and its own
subject as a work of art.
In this way, the limits created by art itself, to act as a bolt-hole, turn
against it by imitating it, and art’s refuge, once formed by its limits, turns
out to be the justification, the reality, and the grave.
September 1992
* New edition of a text with the same title published on the occasion of Documenta V in 1972.
https://www.frieze.com/article/being-curated Page 5 of 26
Being Curated | Frieze 06/05/2024, 16:45
Always topical, the exhibition and organizer of your choice can be placed in this spot.
1 Postface, Michel Claura, 18 Paris lV 70, Marcel Broodthaers, Michel Claura and Robert Barry,
International General, 1970
2 ‘Rahmen’ in Position Proposition, Museum of Mönchengladbach, 1971
https://www.frieze.com/article/being-curated Page 6 of 26
Being Curated | Frieze 06/05/2024, 16:45
exhibitions themselves.
https://www.frieze.com/article/being-curated Page 7 of 26
Being Curated | Frieze 06/05/2024, 16:45
Marc Camille Chaimowicz, Jean Cocteau, (detail), 2003–12, installation view as part of ‘A Bigger Splash:
Painting After Performance’, Tate Modern
Dear Dan,
A time was such when curators preferred the inanimate … They were more
at ease with objects, things, art works … than they were with people.
https://www.frieze.com/article/being-curated Page 8 of 26
Being Curated | Frieze 06/05/2024, 16:45
Artists were just as suspicious … and, more at ease with a drink, were
often aggressive. At once both patronising yet over reverent … the
curator’s positioning towards artists has long been one of ambivalence …
in their turn artists felt misunderstood – were often arrogant or paranoid …
or both. Small wonder then, that there was a common mistrust …
You may recall a brief exchange we had recently in London. Well, I am now
writing from Paris where I am preparing for the exhibition we spoke about,
to be held at the Musée d’Art moderne de la Ville de Paris/ARC this
autumn. I have been invited to be artistic director for DECORUM and I
https://www.frieze.com/article/being-curated Page 9 of 26
Being Curated | Frieze 06/05/2024, 16:45
shall be working principally with the curator Anne Dressen and architect
Christine Ilex on the staging of more than 100 carpets, rugs and tapestries
by modern and contemporary artists …
Amicably yours,
Marc Camille
Marc Camille Chaimowicz was born in postwar Paris, France, and lives and
works between London, UK, and Burgundy, France. His installation
Celebration? Realife Revisited (1972–2000) is currently included in ‘Glam!
The Performance of Style’ at Tate Liverpool, UK. Forthcoming exhibitions
include ‘En Suspension…’, curated by the artist, at FRAC des Pays de la
Loire, Carquefou, France (April 2013). In February, Madame Bovary by
Gustave Flaubert, a work by Marc Camille Chaimowicz, was published by
Four Corners Books.
https://www.frieze.com/article/being-curated Page 10 of 26
Being Curated | Frieze 06/05/2024, 16:45
Ed Atkins, Us Dead Talk Love, 2012, emulsion, Indian ink, photocopy and archival tape on board, 20 panels in 5
suites, 2.4 × 1.2 m
ED ATKINS
A scene of hospitality maybe warrants analogy here, where the host and
guest are productively confused. Here, I suppose that the curator begins
in the role of the host, and the artist in the role of the guest – though I
wouldn’t say that with any certainty. The institution or gallery, or wherever
the work is housed, is the curator-host’s home. As the artist-guest, I don’t
know whether I need to take my shoes off or use coasters under drinks –
or whether I can ask for a hard drink – or avoid conversations about
politics or what. The curator-host, however, doesn’t really know the ‘my’
(such as it is authoritative) of my work, which is paradoxically a
precondition of their hosting, so it’s more than likely that the two roles
switch and continue to do so in the process of making the show. In lieu of
the third party: the audience.
In working directly with an artist – rather than at a remove with simply the
work of an artist – the curator, I think, might confront a conspicuously
alien aspect of their own identity and, at least partially, actually be the
artist – no doubt in all their banality and anxiety.
https://www.frieze.com/article/being-curated Page 13 of 26
Being Curated | Frieze 06/05/2024, 16:45
Nick Mauss, Concern, Crush, Desire, 2011, cotton appliqué on velvet, brass doorknobs and door stoppers,
installation view as part of the 2012 Whitney Biennial, 3.3 × 2.4 × 2.9 m
NICK MAUSS
https://www.frieze.com/article/being-curated Page 14 of 26
Being Curated | Frieze 06/05/2024, 16:45
https://www.frieze.com/article/being-curated Page 15 of 26
Being Curated | Frieze 06/05/2024, 16:45
Self-sabotage as aesthetic.
Tom Nicholson, Evening shadows, 2011–12, installation in the Elder Wing of Art Gallery of South Australia of 38
painted copies of H.J. Johnstone’s Evening Shadows (1881), borrowed from citizens in and around Adelaide,
and a stack of 10,000 off-set printed posters, each poster: 60 × 84 cm
TOM NICHOLSON
I would not say that I have ever felt as though my work is instrumentalized.
Perhaps this is naivety on my part but, in a general sense, I have faith in
the nature of the encounter with an art work, in the wildness of that
encounter, in the way that the sustained process of attending to an
interesting art work is not exhausted or contained by a single framework.
Possibly it is simply my good fortune, but the conversations and
exchanges I have had with curators in these large-scale shows have been
overwhelmingly interesting, usually generous to the work, and generally in
tune with the singularity of the work and the demands of that singularity.
https://www.frieze.com/article/being-curated Page 17 of 26
Being Curated | Frieze 06/05/2024, 16:45
devices rather than the singularity of art works. On several levels I regard
this as a problem, not least in that it flattens what an art work is or can be,
the way that art works unsettle our taxonomies and preconceptions rather
than illustrating them.
https://www.frieze.com/article/being-curated Page 18 of 26
Being Curated | Frieze 06/05/2024, 16:45
Zofia Stryjeńska, installation view, 2008, an exhibition curated by Paulina Olowska for the Schinkel Pavilion as
part of the 5th Berlin Biennale
PAULINA OLOWSKA
I like flirting as an artist-curator. With the works I select. With histories and
themes. With artists. With exhibition curators. With whom and with what I
flirt stems from necessity, or is the natural course of things – it constitutes
a key theme of my art. Art historian Claire Bishop once described my
artistic practice as ‘direct curatorial’.
Continuing with flirtation as a metaphor, I’d like to talk about the exhibition
‘Olinka, or Where Movement is Created’, held at Museo Tamayo, Mexico
City, last year. The show was inspired by the life and work of two artists,
Nahui Olin and Dr. Atl, living outside of ‘the centre’, in the idealistic-
Utopian world of a Mexican province. Magnolia de la Garza and Adam
Szymczyk offered the artists they invited the opportunity to co-create the
exhibition.
https://www.frieze.com/article/being-curated Page 19 of 26
Being Curated | Frieze 06/05/2024, 16:45
selected by the curators from the archive collection. Thirdly, there was the
opportunity to work together on the visual aspect of the show, for
instance, through collective discussion of the most suitable hanging of
works in relation to each other. What I mean to say is that the curators
were in a permanent creative dialogue with the artists, and the exhibition
was ‘open form’ up until the very last moment. The process of developing
the exhibition was dynamic and extremely fascinating. This scenario also
made the artists look at the show in a more synthetic way. They were not
focused only on their own work, or the works in the immediate vicinity of
their work.
Paulina Olowska lives in Raba Niznam, near Krakow, Poland. ‘The Method’,
an exhibition that she devised, is currently on view at Studio Voltaire,
London, UK, and in June she will have a solo show at Kunsthalle Basel,
Switzerland.
https://www.frieze.com/article/being-curated Page 20 of 26
Being Curated | Frieze 06/05/2024, 16:45
Slavs and Tatars, Beyonsense, 2012, installation view as part of Projects 98, Museum of Modern Art, New York
It can’t be oysters and foie-gras every night, can it? Otherwise, we risk
coming down with what the French suffer each new year: a crise de foie
(‘crisis of the liver’), only in this case perhaps the homonym – a crise de
foi (‘questioning one’s faith’) – would be more appropriate. With curators –
as with lovers, friends or accountants for that matter – we must mix it up
https://www.frieze.com/article/being-curated Page 21 of 26
Being Curated | Frieze 06/05/2024, 16:45
a bit. Some nights just call for plain rice and yoghurt.
While the gilded discourse surrounding the role of the curator appears
increasingly sophisticated, if not at times outright esoteric, it also comes
at the expense of some brass tacks. In these oft-amnesiac times, we tend
to be in the arrière-garde rather than the avant-garde. If anything, we
seek more rather than less engagement from curators. Is it a coincidence
that the heightened logorrhea in curatorial discourse coincides with an
uptick in the transactional? Instead of entertaining a discussion about the
ideas driving an exhibition – how a particular work fits the given proposal
or how the context provides a new understanding of the work, perhaps
even steering it to new frontiers – we are too often asked to move
immediately to questions of logistics. Transport, budget, schedules, etc.,
are the standard fare before even these are cast aside in pursuit of the
next pressing engagement. Is it because such responsibilities strike most
as rudimentary, low-hanging fruit, not worthy of the otherwise noble
aspirations of curators, museum staff, administrators, gallerists and artists
alike?
Due perhaps to our own relatively late arrival to art after a decade spent in
other fields, from public-sector strategy to media and graphic design, we
https://www.frieze.com/article/being-curated Page 22 of 26
Being Curated | Frieze 06/05/2024, 16:45
https://www.frieze.com/article/being-curated Page 23 of 26
Being Curated | Frieze 06/05/2024, 16:45
W.A.G.E., Poster for ‘Consciousness Coffee Klatch’, 2009, NY Art Book Fair, MoMA PS1, New York
W.A.G.E.
https://www.frieze.com/article/being-curated Page 24 of 26
Being Curated | Frieze 06/05/2024, 16:45
If independent curators complete even half of the work on this list, then
curatorial fees are symbolic figures. Since we have accounted for the
actual labour being performed – the kind of labour that in any other
context would be remunerated unless it were an unpaid internship – we
are able to quantify and valuate it in terms of real wages. This should be
done either in relation to other comparable forms of labour, or it could be
a wage or fee calibrated to the cost of living.
The rise of the independent curator has an impact upon artists because it
https://www.frieze.com/article/being-curated Page 25 of 26
Being Curated | Frieze 06/05/2024, 16:45
https://www.frieze.com/article/being-curated Page 26 of 26