Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Assignment_2_PaperReview_Technologies_An
Assignment_2_PaperReview_Technologies_An
C
hief among the policy goals achieved empowering patients to manage their own ill-
by the passage of the Affordable Care nesses.
Act (ACA) was the mandate to ex- One promising solution lies in rapidly expand-
pand access to health care to mil- ing the uses of technology in health care. Tele-
lions of additional Americans.While medicine (the use of technologies to remotely
admirable, this mandate will increase the strain diagnose, monitor, and treat patients) and tele-
on an already overburdened and extremely costly health (the application of technologies to help
delivery system. In particular, given the shortage patients manage their own illnesses through im-
of primary care providers,1 affordable, high-qual- proved self-care and access to education and sup-
ity health care for increasing numbers of elderly, port systems) are being applied and combined to
chronically ill people may not be available with- create new ways to deliver care. When properly
out adopting new ways of delivering care. The implemented, the broad adoption of connected
growth in chronic illness will continue to spiral health has the potential to extend care across
upward, with a 40 percent increase in heart dis- populations of both acute and chronically ill pa-
ease and a 50 percent increase in cancer and tients and help achieve the important policy
diabetes projected for 2023.2 Baby boomers goals of improving access to high-quality and
are just beginning to enter their high-mainte- efficient health care.
nance health care years of sixty-five-plus,3–6 while
workforce statistics show that physicians and
nurses are both in short supply.7,8 The Centers Telemedicine And Telehealth
for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) pre- The term telemedicine literally means “healing at
dicts that health care costs could reach almost a distance” through the Latin “medicus” and
20 percent of gross domestic product (GDP) by Greek “tele.”10 Although there is no single com-
2022 without interventions.9 Policy makers, monly accepted definition of telemedicine, the
payers, providers, and patients are actively ex- use of technology to deliver health care services
ploring ways to control the cost of health care and information at a distance in order to improve
through value-based purchasing plans, innova- access, quality, and cost is a common theme
tive care delivery systems, and novel means of found throughout professional descriptions of
F e br u a ry 2 0 1 4 33 : 2 H e a lt h A f fai r s 195
Downloaded from HealthAffairs.org on October 04, 2021.
Copyright Project HOPE—The People-to-People Health Foundation, Inc.
For personal use only. All rights reserved. Reuse permissions at HealthAffairs.org.
Overview
patients. The program generated cost savings of retinopathy. Given the success of these applica-
more than $10 million over a six-year period.21 tions, the range of innovative uses of telemedi-
Considering that those same nurses, in a certi- cine for remote consultation will expand rapidly
fied home care agency, would be caring for only over the coming years. Many specialty physi-
four to six patients daily, the benefit of telemo- cians who are only comfortable with diagnosing
nitoring to extend the reach of providers to larg- conditions based on directly observing the pa-
er populations of patients becomes evident. tient have been slow to adopt telehealth technol-
Home Health Program For Veterans On a ogies. Exceptions to this include dermatologists,
larger scale, over a four-year period the Veterans who have become comfortable with two-dimen-
Health Administration (VHA) introduced a na- sional imaging for performing diagnoses. Der-
tional home telehealth program called Care Co- matologists have adopted teledermatology more
ordination/Home Telehealth that integrated rapidly than other specialty physicians have
home telemonitoring and health informatics adopted diagnostic technologies.
with disease management technologies. Data Using dermatology as an example, specialist
gathered from 17,025 participating patients hav- access can be enabled via two types of telehealth
ing one or more of six chronic illnesses (ranging strategies. One strategy relies on the use of in-
from diabetes to depression) demonstrated high teractive videoconferencing, which has now be-
patient satisfaction levels with the program, plus come ubiquitous, is low in cost, and provides
a 25 percent reduction in numbers of bed days of benefits to patients, especially when they live
care and a 19 percent reduction in the number of far from their physician or provider. Numerous
hospital admissions as compared to usual care.22 studies have shown the quality of care resulting
The impact of the VHA’s telehealth strategy from interactive videoconferencing to be very
has grown substantially. In 2012 the agency’s high—streamlining care, reducing waste, and
national home telehealth program, designed to leading to faster problem resolution.24
provide care for veterans via remote monitoring The second strategy to provide remote special-
and videoconferencing, reached 119,535 veter- ty care is called “store and forward.” For exam-
ans and generated annual savings of $1,999 ple, in this approach, a referring physician up-
per patient.23 The program also facilitated the loads images of skin lesions to a secure storage
independent living of 36 percent of these pa- site along with the relevant patient history; a
tients, who would have otherwise qualified for consulting dermatologist then accesses this in-
long-term residential care. Additionally, hospi- formation and responds. This strategy takes
tal admissions decreased by 38 percent com- advantage of digital imaging, asynchronous
pared to the previous year, inpatient bed days communication, and robust communication net-
of care decreased by 58 percent, and patient sat- works. With the expansion of high-resolution
isfaction scores remained at a strong 85 per- cameras on smartphones and high-bandwidth
cent.23 The VHA example illustrates that as the mobile networks, all this can now also be accom-
prevalence of chronic disease grows in the Unit- plished using mHealth devices.25
ed States, telemedicine can be an extremely As the “store and forward” approach is more
promising solution for managing and reducing widely adopted, it has the potential to create real
these illnesses. gains in efficiency. Dermatologists at Kaiser Per-
Access To Specialty Physicians Equally manente in San Diego, California, treat approxi-
compelling is the idea that telehealth can be used mately 800 such cases per month using this
as a tool to extend access to specialized knowl- method, handling 50 percent more cases than
edge across geographic boundaries. Two places they could through face-to-face visits (Jeffrey
where this vision is being realized are in the Benabio, Kaiser Permanente, personal commu-
fields of diagnostic radiology and laboratory nication, August 12, 2013). The most recent in-
medicine. Innovations in digital imaging, the novation in teledermatology is a novel online
establishment of international global standards service in which patients take mobile phone pic-
for the interoperability of health information tures of their lesions and send them to their
technologies (Health Level Seven International, dermatologist, who, in turn, sends them a diag-
or HL7), and the Internet now allow specialty nosis; therapeutic recommendation; and, if ap-
physicians to provide services in both a time- propriate, a prescription for treatment.26 Al-
and place-independent manner. For example, though these services are increasing in
radiologic images are now routinely read by spe- number, they need to be evaluated for their po-
cialists at great distances from where they are tential to provide convenient and efficient care
taken, and reports are sent back to the primary for specialty services.
care providers in a timely manner. Retinal im- Remote Intensive Care Intensive care units
ages can be read remotely by ophthalmologists (ICUs) are a key component of hospital care,
consulting with referring physicians on diabetic treating the most fragile and complex patients
sages with specialists. The program was devel- tients, following similar legislation regarding
oped at San Francisco General Hospital in 2005, Medicaid reimbursement for remote monitoring
when wait times for specialty appointments in eighteen states.34
ranged from seven to eleven months. The pro- Finally, more health policy research that eval-
gram now covers more than forty specialties and uates the quality and cost impacts of connected
3
◀ services. Similar programs have since been es- health is essential. To demonstrate its value, pro-
tablished at the Los Angeles County Department viders will need to devote more dedicated lead-
of Health Services, the Mayo Clinic, and at UCSF ership, expertise, and time to the implementa-
and UCLA. In each implementation, use of this tion of connected health innovations. This
Criteria
telemedicine technology has produced shorter includes changing the provider culture and
For telemedicine to
succeed, 3 criteria must
wait times, reduced the number of in-person workflow systems in order to allow the full in-
be met: (1) assurance of specialty visits by 20 percent or more, improved corporation of telemedicine into traditional
quality, (2) alignment of preparation of patients for specialty visits when care. Because clinicians have historically resisted
financial incentives, and
required, and strengthened primary care provid- changes in how care is delivered, physician and
(3) more cost and quality
research. er-specialist collaboration and satisfaction. Be- nurse champions will need to take the lead in
cause the rate of outpatient specialist referrals ensuring that providers embrace these emerging
has almost doubled in the United States over the models of care management.
past decade, this application may become an im-
portant means of leveraging specialist capacity.
Conclusion
Current care processes are insufficient to ad-
Designing Telemedicine Approaches dress the coming mismatch in supply and de-
To Succeed mand of health care providers—a trend that will
Each of the above examples shows how telemed- be exacerbated by reform measures that are be-
icine tools can allow providers to extend care to a ginning to increase access to care for millions of
wider population of patients, improve the quali- Americans. The addition of telemedicine tech-
ty of care, reduce costs, and increase patient and nologies and asynchronous provider-to-patient
provider satisfaction. For telemedicine to reach communication can create a connected health
its full potential, three criteria must be met. First, model of care that will ensure an ability to im-
enough evidence must be compiled to assure that prove access and the quality of care while de-
the new model does not sacrifice quality or cause creasing costs and more efficiently using the
harm to patients. To date, good progress has skills of highly trained professionals—as well
been made, and, as many of the articles in this as enabling patients to participate more directly
issue of Health Affairs demonstrate, there are in their own care.
enough studies of the net benefits of telehealth For policy makers to capitalize on this excep-
to patients, providers, and payers for the con- tional opportunity, a partnership needs to be
nected health model to meet this criterion. created among government agencies, academe,
Second, early progress is being made in align- patient advocacy groups, and private-sector or-
ing providers’ financial incentives so that they ganizations to rapidly test, evaluate, deploy, and
produce desired outcomes. For example, health pay for new care models that use telemedicine.
reforms such as the expansion of ACOs are re- Without the knowledge that can be gained from
aligning financial incentives to encourage the such a coalition and applied widely across health
use of telehealth to leverage the skills of pro- care, policy makers will miss a golden opportu-
viders across a broader population of patients. nity to create truly innovative, efficient delivery
In addition, CMS recently published for com- systems within the structure of national health
ment a proposal that would allow physicians reform. As professionals committed to improv-
to be paid for non-face-to-face encounters in ing the lives and care of patients, they should not
the management of chronically ill Medicare pa- allow this opportunity to slip away. ▪
NOTES
1 Association of American Medical [Internet].Washington (DC): AAMC; 2 Partnership to Fight Chronic Dis-
Colleges, Center for Workforce 2009 Apr [cited 2013 Sep 3]. Avail- ease. The impact of chronic disease
Studies. Recent studies and reports able from: http://www.aacom.org/ on U.S. health and prosperity: a
on physician shortages in the U.S. Documents/bodu/2009-05 collection of statistics and com-