SCHOOL OF CRIMINAL JUSTICE AND PUBLIC SAFETY

General Luna Road, Baguio City Philippines 2600

Telefax No.: (074) 442-3071 Website: www.ubaguio.edu E-mail Address: ub@ubaguio.edu

TOPIC: Male and Female Prisons/Inmates, Services and Culture

STUDENT: Jennifer F. Guitba
FACILITATOR: Gerardo K. Tumbaga, Sr., PhD
COURSE: PHDCCC 4 – Corrections: Institutions & Field Operations
DATE: March 9, 2024

I – Title or Topic: Implementation of the UN-OHCHR and Bangkok Rules standards in the
treatment of male and female inmates within Philippine jail/prison institutions.
II – Purpose(s) or Objectives
1. To assess the feasibility of implementing UN-OHCHR and Bangkok Rules standards in
the treatment of male and female inmates within Philippine jail/prison institutions.
2. To identify potential challenges and barriers to adherence to these standards and
develop strategies to address them.
3. To evaluate the potential impact of providing amenities and privileges to inmates on
rehabilitation outcomes and recidivism rates, while ensuring a balance between humane
treatment and accountability.
III - Introduction
The guidelines established by the UN-OHCHR & Bangkok Rules are vital in ensuring
that correctional facilities worldwide maintain fair and humane practices, especially when
considering the cultural backgrounds of male and female inmates. However, when applied to
contexts like the Philippines, significant disparities emerge due to differing cultural norms
compared to Western countries.
The degree to which correctional facility managers adhere to these standards varies,
influenced by factors such as the prevailing institutional culture, available resources, and
oversight by government authorities. While some managers prioritize adherence due to ethical
or legal obligations, others face hurdles stemming from limited resources or conflicting cultural
norms within the facility.
Nevertheless, there exists an opportunity to leverage these standards to foster
innovation in rehabilitation programs. By integrating culturally sensitive approaches, correctional
institutions can better cater to the diverse needs of their inmate populations, facilitating their
successful reintegration into society. However, there are valid concerns that providing certain
privileges or amenities to inmates might inadvertently reinforce criminal behavior. Thus, striking
a delicate balance between humane treatment and deterrence is imperative to address these
risks and uphold the credibility of the correctional system.
IV – Discussions
A. Will the Jail/Prison Institution Managers adhere to these UN/Bangkok standards?
In my opinion, it's NOT advisable to blindly adhere to the UN/Bangkok standards
in the Philippines. These standards are comprehensive but need to be adapted to fit
local cultural norms. Failing to do so could disrupt the delivery of services for male and
female inmates. Instead, a balanced approach that respects both international standards
and cultural realities is crucial for effective and culturally appropriate care in Jail/Prison
Institutions.
Conflicting cultural norms within Philippine correctional facilities can significantly
affect how UN-OHCHR & Bangkok Rules standards for the treatment of male and
female inmates are applied, particularly in service provision. Here are examples:
1. Cultural norms may influence staff and inmate attitudes and behaviors towards
service implementation. Traditional gender roles or beliefs may hinder adherence to
gender-sensitive guidelines, impacting service delivery.

Page 1 of 6
 SCHOOL OF CRIMINAL JUSTICE AND PUBLIC SAFETY
General Luna Road, Baguio City Philippines 2600
Telefax No.: (074) 442-3071 Website: www.ubaguio.edu E-mail Address: ub@ubaguio.edu

2. Perceptions of appropriate treatment may be shaped by cultural biases, leading to

disparities in service provision based on gender, ethnicity, or religion, contradicting
principles of equality in the standards.
3. Introducing new services aligned with international standards can face resistance
from staff or inmates holding different cultural beliefs, hindering progress in inmate
well-being and rehabilitation.
4. Sensitivity and awareness from management and staff are necessary to navigate
conflicting cultural norms. Tailored approaches and training programs promoting
inclusivity are essential to address cultural diversity in service delivery.

B. How can these services including cultures and practices (as reported) innovate
reformation and rehabilitation programs of our present jail/prison institutions?

The provided services, cultures, and practices reported in the context of

reformation and rehabilitation programs for jail/prison institutions demonstrate a
significant shift towards gender-responsive and humane treatment of incarcerated
individuals. Here's how these initiatives can innovate reformation and rehabilitation
programs within present jail/prison institutions:
1. Gender-Responsive Design:
 Designing prison facilities with a gender-responsive approach acknowledges the
unique needs and experiences of women inmates. By considering factors such
as safety, privacy, and dignity, these designs create an environment conducive to
effective rehabilitation.
 This approach fosters a sense of security and respect among female inmates,
which can positively impact their mental well-being and engagement in
rehabilitation programs. It also reduces the likelihood of incidents such as
harassment and violence, creating a safer space for inmates to focus on their
rehabilitation journey.
2. Separation of Female from Male Inmates:
 Implementing separate housing for female inmates reduces the risk of violence
and abuse that may occur in mixed-gender facilities. It recognizes the need for
tailored approaches to rehabilitation based on gender-specific dynamics.
 By providing a safer and more supportive environment, female inmates are better
able to participate in rehabilitation programs without fear of intimidation or
harassment. This separation allows for targeted interventions and support
services that address the unique needs of women, ultimately enhancing their
chances of successful reformation.
3. Healthcare Services:
 Offering comprehensive healthcare services, including regular check-ups and
access to medications, ensures that inmates' physical health needs are
addressed. By incorporating sponsored laboratory services and free circumcision
for male inmates, the prison system innovates by partnering with external
healthcare providers to expand access to medical care.
 Early detection and treatment of illnesses contribute to the overall well-being of
inmates and reduce the burden on healthcare systems. Providing necessary
medical care not only improves the health outcomes of inmates but also supports
their rehabilitation by addressing underlying health issues that may hinder their
progress.
4. Programs and Services:
 Providing a range of programs such as vocational training, educational
opportunities, and mental health services addresses the multifaceted needs of
inmates. Marriage-related services and conjugal visits offer opportunities for
social and emotional support, contributing to the holistic approach to
rehabilitation.

Page 2 of 6
 SCHOOL OF CRIMINAL JUSTICE AND PUBLIC SAFETY
General Luna Road, Baguio City Philippines 2600
Telefax No.: (074) 442-3071 Website: www.ubaguio.edu E-mail Address: ub@ubaguio.edu

 These programs equip inmates with the skills and resources needed to
reintegrate into society successfully. By addressing mental health challenges and
facilitating family connections, the prison system fosters a supportive
environment that promotes personal growth and rehabilitation.
5. Mother-Child Programs:
 Allowing incarcerated mothers to maintain bonds with their children through
mother-child programs promotes family unity and maternal well-being. By
providing lactation services and implementing policies to support breastfeeding,
the prison system recognizes the importance of maternal-child relationships in
the rehabilitation process.
 Maintaining family connections reduces the likelihood of intergenerational cycles
of incarceration and strengthens social support networks for both mothers and
children. These programs promote positive parenting skills and contribute to the
successful reintegration of mothers into their families and communities.
6. Hygiene and Personal Care:
 Providing access to hygiene products ensures that inmates' basic needs are met,
promoting dignity and overall well-being. By offering these products for free or at
a nominal fee, the prison system addresses a fundamental aspect of inmates'
daily lives.
 Access to hygiene products promotes cleanliness and hygiene within prison
facilities, reducing the risk of illness and improving the living conditions for
inmates. This innovation enhances the physical and mental health of inmates,
supporting their engagement in rehabilitation activities.
7. Addressing Mental Health:
 Offering mental health services and support acknowledges the psychological
challenges faced by inmates and addresses them within the rehabilitation
framework. By implementing staff training and trauma-informed approaches, the
prison system innovates in its approach to mental health care.
 Addressing mental health issues reduces the risk of self-harm, violence, and
recidivism among inmates. By providing therapeutic interventions and support,
the prison system promotes emotional well-being and resilience, enhancing
inmates' capacity for rehabilitation and successful reintegration.
8. Rehabilitation and Reintegration:
 Focusing on rehabilitation and reintegration programs prepares inmates for life
after incarceration, reducing recidivism rates and promoting successful
community reintegration. By offering livelihood activities and compensated
services, the prison system facilitates skill development and economic
empowerment.
 Rehabilitation programs equip inmates with the necessary tools and resources to
rebuild their lives and become productive members of society. By addressing the
root causes of criminal behavior and providing opportunities for personal growth,
the prison system contributes to long-term community safety and social
cohesion.
9. Staff Training:
 Providing specialized training for prison staff ensures that they understand the
unique needs and experiences of female inmates. By incorporating gender
sensitivity and trauma-informed approaches, the prison system enhances staff
capacity to support rehabilitation efforts effectively.
 Well-trained staff create a supportive and empathetic environment that fosters
trust and collaboration between inmates and staff. By promoting a culture of
respect and understanding, the prison system strengthens its capacity to
facilitate rehabilitation and promote positive outcomes for inmates.
10. Safety Measures:

Page 3 of 6
 SCHOOL OF CRIMINAL JUSTICE AND PUBLIC SAFETY
General Luna Road, Baguio City Philippines 2600
Telefax No.: (074) 442-3071 Website: www.ubaguio.edu E-mail Address: ub@ubaguio.edu

 Implementing security protocols and female wardens in charge of female facilities

demonstrates a commitment to protecting inmates from violence, abuse, and
exploitation. By prioritizing safety, the prison system creates an environment
conducive to rehabilitation and personal growth.
 Safety measures promote a sense of security and well-being among inmates,
enabling them to focus on their rehabilitation journey without fear of harm. By
fostering a culture of accountability and support, the prison system enhances its
capacity to facilitate successful reformation and reintegration.

On the other hand, integrating cultural practices and norms into reformation and
rehabilitation programs within jail/prison institutions can indeed bring about innovative
approaches to address the diverse needs of inmates. By incorporating elements of
cultural sensitivity and practices, these programs can foster a more supportive and
inclusive environment conducive to successful rehabilitation.

One effective approach is to implement culturally relevant vocational training

programs that align with inmates' backgrounds and skills. By tailoring these programs to
the cultural context of the inmates, it enhances their engagement and increases their
employability upon release. For example, offering training in trades or crafts that are
traditionally valued within their communities can not only provide practical skills but also
instill a sense of pride and purpose.

Furthermore, offering counseling and therapy services that are sensitive to

cultural beliefs and practices is crucial for promoting holistic rehabilitation. Recognizing
and respecting cultural differences in approaches to mental health and well-being
ensures that inmates receive effective support that resonates with their values and
experiences. This approach can lead to improved mental health outcomes and a greater
likelihood of successful reintegration into society.

Involving local communities and cultural leaders in program development and

delivery is another valuable strategy. By tapping into existing support networks and
resources within the community, inmates can access additional guidance and assistance
as they transition back into society. Community involvement not only provides practical
support but also helps to reduce stigma and social isolation, which are often barriers to
successful reintegration.

In particular, embracing cultural diversity and integrating it into reformation and

rehabilitation efforts can lead to more effective and sustainable outcomes in jail/prison
institutions. By acknowledging and respecting the cultural identities and backgrounds of
inmates, these programs can better address their individual needs and contribute to
positive outcomes for both the individuals and the broader community.

Overall, these innovations in services, cultures, and practices within jail/prison

institutions demonstrate a commitment to promoting the well-being and rehabilitation of
inmates. By addressing the unique needs and experiences of incarcerated individuals,
the prison system enhances its capacity to facilitate positive outcomes and contribute to
safer and more resilient communities.

C. With all these opportunities and privileges afforded to inmates, will these not encourage
violators to be in jail because of "almost complete amenities," without difficulty of
livelihood to survive?
In my opinion, while it's valid to worry about whether inmates might commit
crimes to enjoy the perks of jail, this is unlikely to encourage criminal behavior. However,
there are a few things we need to consider to address this concern:

Page 4 of 6
 SCHOOL OF CRIMINAL JUSTICE AND PUBLIC SAFETY
General Luna Road, Baguio City Philippines 2600
Telefax No.: (074) 442-3071 Website: www.ubaguio.edu E-mail Address: ub@ubaguio.edu

1. Deterrence and Consequences: Despite the amenities and privileges available in

jails/prisons, incarceration still means losing freedom and being separated from
family and society. For many, the idea of going to jail, no matter the conditions, stops
them from committing crimes. The potential consequences of having a criminal
record and how it affects your reputation and future opportunities also stop most
people from breaking the law.
2. Rehabilitation and Reintegration: The main goal of giving inmates amenities and
privileges is to help them change and fit back into society after release. By providing
education, job training, and mental health services, the aim is to deal with the
reasons behind criminal behavior and give inmates the skills and support they need
to live successful lives when they get out. This helps to lower the chances of them
going back to jail and keeps the public safe in the long run.
3. Limited Impact on General Population: Only a small number of people would commit
crimes just to get into jail for the perks. Most people value freedom, making their own
choices, and following the law more than the short-term comforts of jail.
4. Resource Allocation and Public Perception: It's important for jails/prisons to balance
giving inmates decent conditions with making sure the public trusts the justice
system. While amenities and privileges can help with rehabilitation, too many
luxuries might make people wonder if their tax money is being used right and if
punishment for crimes is serious enough.
5. Ongoing Evaluation and Adjustment: Jails/prisons should always check if amenities
and privileges are helping inmates behave better, change, and stay out of trouble.
Changes might be needed based on feedback, research, and how society's views
change, so that the balance between punishment and rehabilitation stays fair.

Overall, while amenities and privileges in jails/prisons aim to help with

rehabilitation and keep people from committing more crimes, it's important to make sure
there are rules and that people are held accountable for what they do. This should be
part of a full plan for dealing with crime that focuses on helping people change, keeping
the public safe, and respecting everyone's rights.
V – Findings or Summary

Integrating cultural practices and norms into reformation and rehabilitation programs
within jail/prison institutions can lead to innovative approaches addressing the diverse needs of
inmates. By embracing cultural sensitivity and practices, such programs foster a supportive and
inclusive environment conducive to successful rehabilitation. Tailored vocational training,
culturally sensitive counseling, community involvement, and recognition of cultural diversity are
vital elements of effective rehabilitation efforts. However, concerns about potential criminal
behavior driven by access to amenities in jail are addressed through deterrence, rehabilitation,
limited impact on the general population, prudent resource allocation, and ongoing evaluation
and adjustment of prison policies. Overall, while amenities and privileges aim to aid
rehabilitation, it's crucial to strike a balance between punishment and rehabilitation while
upholding accountability and respecting the rights of all individuals involved.

VI – Conclusions and Personal Insights (Recommendation(s) or Proposed Program or

enhancement)
After examining the integration of cultural practices and norms into reformation and
rehabilitation programs within jail/prison institutions, it's evident that a culturally sensitive
approach plays a crucial role in successful inmate rehabilitation. By acknowledging and
respecting the diverse backgrounds of inmates, correctional facilities can create environments
that foster positive behavioral change and successful reintegration into society.
I suggest that correctional systems must continue to prioritize cultural inclusivity and
sensitivity in their rehabilitation efforts. This involves not only acknowledging cultural differences

Page 5 of 6
 SCHOOL OF CRIMINAL JUSTICE AND PUBLIC SAFETY
General Luna Road, Baguio City Philippines 2600
Telefax No.: (074) 442-3071 Website: www.ubaguio.edu E-mail Address: ub@ubaguio.edu

but actively incorporating them into program design and delivery. Engaging with local
communities and cultural leaders can provide valuable insights and support in tailoring
programs to meet the unique needs of inmates.
In light of these findings, I recommend the implementation of enhanced cultural
competency training for prison staff. This training should focus on understanding diverse cultural
perspectives, addressing implicit biases, and developing strategies for culturally responsive
communication and service delivery. Additionally, collaboration with community organizations
and cultural institutions can enrich rehabilitation programs by incorporating traditional practices
and resources that resonate with inmates' cultural backgrounds.
Furthermore, I propose the establishment of advisory committees comprised of
representatives from diverse cultural groups to provide ongoing feedback and guidance on
program development and implementation. This collaborative approach ensures that
rehabilitation efforts remain relevant and effective in addressing the specific needs of inmates
from various cultural backgrounds.
In conclusion, embracing cultural diversity and integrating it into reformation and
rehabilitation programs within jail/prison institutions is essential for promoting successful inmate
rehabilitation and reducing recidivism rates. By adopting a culturally sensitive approach,
correctional facilities can create environments that empower inmates to overcome barriers,
develop positive life skills, and ultimately contribute to safer and more cohesive communities.

Page 6 of 6