STRUCTURE magazine _ Subgrade Modulus – Revisited

You might also like

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 10

01236789 368313 93

0123567891 1 130311330213!"2"01

#$%&!"'1( "")&*+,-&./-0/&*,&1$%&( ""2!"'1312)&4,&*&,1455/%,,&6*7*8%1%7&1964:*++9&;,%<


4/&<%=/4/>&1$%&,;66-71&:-/<414-/,&-5&5--14/>,&*/<&8*1&5-;/<*14-/,)&,;:$&*,&1$*1&,$-0/&-/&?4>;7%&@A&#$%
6*7*8%1%7&4,&%B67%,,%<&4/&;/41,&-5&C?-7:%DECF%/>1$DA~&G$9,4:*++9&$-0%H%7)&41&4,&<%=/%<&*,&1$%&I:-/1*:1J&K%*74/>
67%,,;7%&-5&1$%&5-;/<*14-/&*>*4/,1&1$%&,-4+&1$*1&04++&67-<;:%&*&;/41&<%L%:14-/&-5&1$%&5-;/<*14-/A&#$%&;,%&-5
1$%&6*7*8%1%7&486+4%,&*&+4/%*7&%+*,14:&7%,6-/,%)&*/<&1$%7%5-7%&4/&<%,4>/&1$%&67%,,;7%&>%/%7*1%<&K9&1$%
,;K>7*<%&8-<;+;,&4,&*+0*9,&+4841%<&K9&1$%&*++-0*K+%&K%*74/>&67%,,;7%&-5&1$%&,-4+A

?4>;7%&@A&M*1&5-;/<*14-/&5-7&*&K;4+<4/>&;/<%7
:-/,17;:14-/A
N/&67*:14:%)&1$%&6*7*8%1%7&4,&-51%/&7%:-88%/<%<&K9&1$%&O%-1%:$/4:*+&P/>4/%%7&*/<&;,%<&K9&1$%&Q17;:1;7*+
P/>4/%%7&5-7&*/*+9,4,&-5&1$%&,17;:1;7%A&#$%&,17;:1;7*+&*/*+9,4,&4,&/-1&-/+9&;,%<&1-&>*4/&4/,4>$1&4/1-&1$%
,%11+%8%/1&-5&1$%&,17;:1;7%)&K;1&*+,-&67-H4<%,&:-/,4<%7*14-/&-5&,%11+%8%/1R4/<;:%<&,17%,,%,&041$4/&1$%
,17;:1;7%A&N/&*&,17;:1;7*+&*/*+9,4,&67-:%,,)&1$%&,;K>7*<%&8-<;+;,&4,&1964:*++9&;14+4S%<&1-&-K1*4/&*&H%714:*+&,674/>
:-/,1*/1&IC?-7:%D&E&CF%/>1$DJ&K9&8;+146+94/>&1$%&,;K>7*<%&8-<;+;,&041$&1$%&174K;1*79&*7%*&-5&1$%&,674/>
,;66-71&%+%8%/1,A
T,&*&6*7*8%1%7&1$*1&,6*/,&1$%&>%-1%:$/4:*+&*/<&,17;:1;7*+&7%*+8,)&1$%&,;K>7*<%&8-<;+;,&$*,&K%%/&;,%<&*/<
*K;,%<&4/&67*:14:%)&1-&*&6-4/1&0$%7%&%/>4/%%7,&1%/<&1-&5-7>%1&1$%&6$9,4:*+&8%*/4/>&-5&*/<&486+4:*14-/,&-5&1$%
;,%&-5&1$%&6*7*8%1%7A&#$4,&*714:+%&04++&7%H4,41&1$%&:-/:%61&-5&1$%&Q;K>7*<%&M-<;+;,&K9&67%,%/14/>&*/<
<4,:;,,4/>&:-88-/&84,:-/:%614-/,&-5&1$%&6*7*8%1%7A

UVWVXYXZV[\]^_`a^bcdefgha^ijhckcl^ml^g^ljmk^nfjnafopq
?*+,%A&#$%&,;K>7*<%&8-<;+;,&1*.%,&41,&1$%-7%14:*+&-74>4/,&57-8&1$%&5-78;+*14-/&-5&r4/.+%7R196%&K%*8,R-/R
%+*,14:R5-;/<*14-/,&Is%1%/94&@tuvJA&#$%&,;K>7*<%&8-<;+;,&4,&*&+;86%<&:-/,1*/1&-5&4/1%>7*14-/&-5&1$%
<455%7%/14*+&%w;*14-/&-5&*&K%*8&,;66-71%<&K9&%+*,14:&,674/>,A&N1&4,&*&5;/:14-/&-5&1$%&5-++-04/>x
@AQ-4+&%+*,14:&67-6%714%,x&M-<;+;,&-5&P+*,14:419)&P),&*/<&G-4,,-/y
,&z*14-)&{A
,
|A?-;/<*14-/&6+*/&<48%/,4-/,x&F%/>1$)&F)&*/<&r4<1$)&}A
~A?-;/<*14-/&,1455/%,,x&M-<;+;,&-5&P+*,14:419)&P) 5&*/<&M-8%/1&-5&N/%714*) &N5A
u 1$%74/<47%:15*:1-7,x€-867%,,4K+%,-4++*9%71$4:./%,,s,*/<<%61$-55-;/<*14-/K%+-0>7-;/<
012345689 8653 36658585634895 9 5349 389569
6 51
56 !!"56#484 5359$5689 3634389$$53456383458#53893
34335 3533389345668356 5 63453891"488853436
8$5983456 5 889$5656638933458#53453891
%3 959 56345$53439 5&355$3893456 5 65&86534
535498 9 3636896 3891
'()(*+*,(-./01230456789:30;<:5=5>0?>0@<A>B9AB063A39B20B230C<5A:9B?<AD
E51"45638345568965653345533559383489345368933459 389$685
6893956 361F56556456G5531HIIJK4$565638934389 5
9L9893655 5393453895696848459565655634559356345
9 38933455515$5689345898934534634538993 36 8999M
986833456 5 595343459 389653455689656583683899
56 38938883 51
"458368389345568965655$596986 5L98359 3898 535345
38953459 3898353359 34553355936L519856345 58363551

E865H1GKE5N859 3891GKF38
9 3891
E6$56O5N859 38934598685 559386 598656896565
499E865H15$563888356 3893345553459 3898151345
53355936L5 9935893893345553459 38959353359866 89
 N853355933345593569 8983345551"896385689656535335593
53343345 N86 5  63345553459 3891
29345345649 986 5$56389 389855938533598615$565 5
345553459 3896565593963495893895 898938983893455345
53355936L534556896565853345559 5655345593563459 3898
6 45499E865H938934334556896565334555 356 33455689
 8388386 451"456534556896565E865H9 H655&3345
8935983345568965659 569534389 389$6851"89638568965653
53355936$56389 38983856$53433456 5 896553 6345
553459 3891
"4599M9868334553355936L55$599 56986 5O5N859 389868 68
5345856 389 593459 3898593898353355931P9 56345
593563459 38934568 656 389 58$5638 658915$56334555345
9 389345889 568945683638989 8389365891"48895
56 389 56 53856953$5638 659563458345656538989 56
53355931E6345665345#9589O59563653455689656584563345
553493345593563459 389193936 5 59 56986 5$56
O5N859 3898653899865335593484856566951
01345678969 68 34769 1 446789169918461 19415519614578998634
197 9863478491719899483989091187499915946154849698
187461 194 1 946317 461  1 69784917744169854849698 3
31 9869 948 61861 1691444 7561 1693789918461 54669816941646
6 6999961648918989444496491899396611969141 69
99964155196158 698993154 41918461 197 989466917 461
491 
!"#"$%$&"'()*+,-./*01.*23/4.*56*789423:.*;5:8<,*8/:.2/.301*3*658/:30,5/=*,0*,7*;52.*>5/7.2-30,-.*05*87.*01.
<5?.70*-3<8.*8/,652;<@A
B49C469 548496984178491778976 489966996D64691998
6999361989649669961 696873678959845189518646E1 9869349768469
91  349683468736789755186944617 461 

B789F4E1 6467849177
4 7561 1 7 187849177
4 7561 
G691967849177797 187 98946417 461 4 1 1 B789F46946
9 96496697 18651 98 183784678979616931 3968469148169
317 0 799617 47559817 964691966996343746969191916
49H746931 9699 1694617 461 186931 9H796 61861 16968736789796169
43674966996581 916917 461 
D   987849174669991694617 461 5817399 9669964669994
1 1 B789FI19986917 461 96691 7 18E1 9H79669899 16946
17 461 463784678934796968736789619J598939189 61861 0 99966996 739
689 9 6917 461 468736789489163456789 47 18966 17 461 G6186949
58 3596469896496699631 98918938634614687367896441769966996
G6 177869891696466969 1697598687367896961 389496969 169
17 461 0 9 38949198469 16917 461 786989 439691 7 18 6169
78491774768469 B789

C961 99489861894337846961196914199966455815846946984
581598697  69999616489613456789769 1 4918461 19K469849418
7  699996931999189939618699599631 1461 4389958951 9G
19986 598469646784917979 4 6873678419698948939864 45581J461
012343568988 35984390953 183389595 13690353533598 518 981
90933515 3911989034589811903 18353901981
333551353909 31 938 112 
 38038353 980 3903158315983993 39539851 89358
53 53363993 39915351539553 3 3518981 33 59133
8935815189289089031981033903158353983938111 83!3!981
890318 16"6#18 1$59816%6903908&3 19031 53 83356'
()  51 58938*339151519810 38+3,-.619813 3 396/6
1981983 ," 015908&3 9.
031981983  183903
98383391903 3595953
12939038435319033993 3951 8935853 53908890353 19903
59851981
315893611289039031513 9889533938/ 39,(445.69031915153
115!5915395 98012138536038958981153 1
19031981$818351 9033935919031535801283853719053012909
903313 980 390315831 159903993 3990990353 1819199
33901981690353 1853 399033319031981

38536/8958981153 1,&.8
7(96-8149698196"81944&86"8944&6
%84176' 89496/819

38537:53 118183
51 393591153587(96-8149698196
"81944&86"8944&6%84176' 89496/8
19
189593903139533938385311, 3.6;1199581903954353
3935831903 98 1338903515 :))/#51098  3909903 9 159921;
9156921;5 395953"0915873390806308(4339283032 53
;119908&153939595362083903 98  39137;339908&0898191323809644
815 18 8319035116 921959819888153
31590359 3619953 11(4& 159903 96208390331 331;
0 1 22 0
3456789 3 189733 85416879 676 74 741848 574765138
6895294 4 454197946787  8 74745138 4 0
825!7928541836879 7  545 0 53  678081894
87 8678 4 7449545939 3 189733 5334849 
6734574038188338 45419794834 474"3456789 3 189733 53

5138 ! #$6895294 4
45419794%7443 189733 76
6

5138 ! $6895294 4
45419794%3 189733 85 6879
676

# 3 189733 5 63457476 755664 47928 5854 0  


6734574594574 4 5664 
 3 189733 5477443484 6734574
& 541 744078 73403678 3 189733 3484 67345742873 3228
734 94 37 478354 748551476 8338'

( )*0+8!4,54-!./010234506789:69;2<87:=9>0772050679;87:5<7:369?@3=0AB@089C3@9>D<223E
F3B6A<7:3689369G@<6B2<@9>3:2H4I484574!7468474J(729454,75*45 4
K745-41548541J5750J78!2830L$* .
(+ ) 38MN 4!48 ,L/:87@:OB7:363CP3AB2B83C>BOQ@<A0R0<=7:36O060<7DS0<5836
!"6#$8%&'()%*#+#%,()%,(*%#-../$01234156317897:9;7<6=6297:9>65?4@<A9BA@C317895A8A@3D9EA@F2978
G=@231C9H768<@3178#*IJ!!(K,L&IMN)!,N!*,%NKI,%O!IN!J),KJ%OI,M!*!,J!!P!OIQR!,NIM*S%,6*!%&%,(
!IN!J),KJ%O,LK,!!*K,L#%K,N!N!*&S'*L$TUVTWX',!-../#
!N!,"K#TWYU$EA@F29789G=@231C9H768<@3178Z9[DA74\9]13D9^__=1C@3178291893DA9H1A=<297:9̀1a1=9@8<9;ACD@81C@=
G8?18AA418?#,KP#IMKJ)KL%,*!&&$b6,,6*SI*$KJ)KL%,#
!I(I*'#8#-..W$EA@F29789G=@231C9H768<@31789c9[DA9>1F_=1dA<9̀7831866F9^__47@CD#8'O!NK,'O,&NKN'N'O'K
IOKN!),KJK,%&K$,KP!*&KN%N!%!),KJ%$)!I*L!6&%J)K$ e fg$%&J#Y$-..W#
!*h%L)K+##TWii$Ga@=6@317897:9̀7A:dC1A8397:9>65?4@<A9BA@C3178#!IN!J),Kj'!$IO#i$I#Y$QQ#-WkVl-U#

opqrstuvwtorsvqxtyzy{wqx|wtox}~sqxw€~t‚vƒ„ƒt‚ƒƒ
!I*L!6*K&NI*!,%&$)##$##$K&%!J),KJ%O*K,JKQ%OIMN)!!I&N*'JN'*%O*I'QIMJ),%S!O,LK,!!*K,L$,J#
*#6*K&NI*!,%&&Q!JK%OKh!&K,N)!%,%O"&K&%,((!&KL,IM&IKOV&N*'JN'*!K,N!*%JNKI,Q*ISO!R&$'&K,L%(P%,J!(
%,%O"NKJ%O%,(,'R!*KJ%ON!J),Kj'!&#!R%"S!*!%J)!(%NL%*K&NI*!,%&m&J),%S!OV!,L#JIR#

02345 4
689  9 69996 6 9 66  9
9 69 99 9

In,OI%(N)K&%*NKJO!
01234678792 872197


=>?>@ABCDA>EFGH

IJKLMMM

012341325 N7898 898 78 8 84 085 9 


8 405788 8  
 8 30 !982   9788" 7  4054 8#$%&'()*+
8 7  ,
-*+.(/012/3412'5'41(/46/7(*89+':0;</94&';<
012341678978 61141711 34!"#$%&173834'31841 4(78 71)714118'3&4 1(*38'1
+,-./01,2
 

 37817141714413&4'12344'7'78 4&'&4618 78114418 11867188(1 314


4&'&4618 7811443& 7814178 78234 718(78747386'3818514718'1 37817)16

You might also like