Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 14

Missile Multinational: Iran’s

New Approach to Missile


Proliferation
April 2021

The International Institute


for Strategic Studies
Contents

Iran’s new strategy . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2

The Quds Force leaks . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2

Houthi missile arsenal . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6

Iranian-enabled missile production in Iraq, Lebanon and Syria . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8

Conclusion and outlook . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9


The proliferation of ballistic missiles and artillery rock- stockpiles of artillery rockets, and the wholescale provi-
ets to non-state actors by the Islamic Republic of Iran is sion of manufacturing capabilities.
a constant source of tension in the Middle East. Yemen’s Iranian support for enabling local rocket produc-
Houthi rebels conduct ballistic-missile strikes on Saudi tion is not new. Reports about the rocket arsenals of
Arabian cities, airports and oil installations; Hizbullah’s Palestinian factions in Gaza regularly cite Iranian assis-
ever-growing rocket and missile arsenal sparks Israeli tance for domestic manufacturing,3 and Hizbullah’s
consideration of military options; and Iranian prox- alleged missile factory in the Beqaa Valley became
ies rocket the United States’ installations in Iraq on an the topic of competing accusations in the Israeli–
almost weekly basis. Hizbullah relationship.4 However, closer examination
But how does Iran equip its proxies and allies with of Iranian sources, documents likely leaked by Israeli
increasingly sophisticated and longer-range ballistic intelligence and the missiles unveiled by the Houthis
missiles and artillery rockets? For years, the answer has reveal a strategy of empowering Iranian proxies that
been through smuggling. In one example, on 19 March is more comprehensive than previously thought. In
2021 Saudi Minister of State for Foreign Affairs Adel cooperation with Iran’s missile industry, the Quds
al-Jubeir claimed that all Houthi missiles fired at the Force (QF) of the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps
Kingdom were ‘made in Iran’,1 and there is ample evi- (IRGC) appears intent on enabling all its main prox-
dence that Houthis were the recipients of weapons such ies to be able to autonomously manufacture artillery
as Iran’s short-range Qiam ballistic missile.2 Iran doubt- rockets and precision-guided missiles. Also, a spe-
lessly continues to directly transfer missiles outside its cial development effort seems to be aimed at creating
borders to some degree. However, in recent years smug- simple artillery rockets and short-range-missile sys-
gling has been augmented by two other transfer meth- tems and production units custom-tailored for local
ods: the provision of guidance kits to modify existing production.

Iran’s new strategy


While reports about Iran’s transfer of missile- and explained in 2017 how development work had factored
rocket-production technology have been published in the need for simplicity and technology transfers.6
more frequently in recent years, Iranian officials have According to journalist Ali Hashim, the strategy was
been talking about their strategy for some time. In a 2014 adopted after the 2006 war between Israel and Hizbullah
documentary, IRGC Aerospace Force Commander Amir to insure rocket supply against a potential cut-off of
Ali Hajizadeh stated that the idea to transfer production supply routes.7 In a 2020 interview with Lebanese
technology had been the brainchild of the former leader Hizbullah TV station Al-Manar, Hajizadeh likened the
of Iran’s missile programme, the now-deceased Hassan strategy to ‘teaching a man how to fish’ instead of giv-
Moghaddam.5 An unnamed co-worker of Moghaddam ing him fish.8

The Quds Force leaks


Just how far Iran’s strategy of ‘teaching a man how to With many details matching other data available from
fish’ goes in practice is amply demonstrated by docu- open sources, as well as never-before broadcast video
ments posted by VS Quds, a website publishing informa- clearly filmed at an IRGC facility inside Iran, the infor-
tion pertaining to the QF’s regional and global activities.9 mation seems credible.

3 The International Institute for Strategic Studies


Figure 1: Badr-3 rockets seen in a video released by the PIJ’s al-Quds Brigades in 2019 Source: Al-Quds Brigades media wing.

As part of its strategy to reveal IRGC QF opera- At first glance, the rather primitive Badr-3 looks
tions, the website published information, dubbed the like quintessential improvised Gaza rocket artillery.
‘Quds leaks’, detailing Tehran’s ambition to equip Yet the documents released by VS Quds show quite
the Palestinian Islamic Jihad (PIJ), Iran’s closest ally a different reality. Blueprints of the Badr-3’s warhead
in the Gaza Strip, with artillery-rocket technology. and propellant-casting case are clearly marked in
Systems examined in detail include the PIJ’s Badr-3 Farsi, while one of two videos showing the testing of
heavy-artillery rocket (also named Nafea) as well as motors was recorded at the IRGC’s Bidganeh site west
other unguided systems, such as the Jihad and the Imad. of Tehran.12
According to the Quds leaks, the effort is led by QF Unit Another VS Quds video shows the test launch of a
340.10 While this information cannot be independently Badr-3 with mountains and vast empty spaces visible in
verified, it does align with comments by Hajizadeh the background. Considering the population density and
that the Iranian rocket- and missile-proliferation effort geography of the Gaza Strip, the test must have taken place
was under the control of the IRGC QF rather than its outside Hamas-ruled Palestinian territories. The Quds
Aerospace Force.11 leaks mention training at the Semnan firing range east of

Figure 2: Left: Badr-3 warhead diagram marked in Farsi; Right: artillery-rocket motor test at Bidganeh

N21
N20
N19

N18

N17

N16

N15

N14

N13

Source: VS Quds leaks

Missile Multinational: Iran’s New Approach to Missile Proliferation 4


Figure 3: Flight test of the Badr-3 at what appears to be the Semnan firing range Source: Google Earth Maxar and VS Quds leaks

Tehran, and the mountain ridge visible in the background of the Technical Directorate for Military Production, the
does seem to match the mountains near the Semnan site. Shia-militia-dominated industrial-production arm of the
The available information indicates an Iranian role in Popular Mobilisation Units (PMU),13 is largely identical to
the Badr-3 development that goes far beyond mere tech- the Badr-3 down to the location and number of bolts and
nical or financial assistance; rather, it seems to indicate a screws, and exhibits only a slightly altered warhead design.
comprehensive development effort by Iran on behalf of the Yet, according to VS Quds, the IRGC has ambitions
PIJ that includes motor and flight testing inside Iran. What beyond simple artillery rockets. The website published
is remarkable in this case is that the Badr-3 is a much less several blueprints annotated in Farsi of a precision-guided
complex system than the rocket artillery developed by Iran missile with a diameter of 225 millimetres that is claimed
for its own armed forces. Considering the remarks made to have a range of 85 kilometres with a 50-kilogram war-
by former colleagues of Moghaddam, it seems highly likely head, and which is unnamed in open sources.14
that the system was purposely designed in an extremely The diagrams allow for a detailed reconstruction of the
simple fashion to enable local production outside Iran. missile design.
Another indication that the Badr-3 rocket is not a Neither the missile nor its specifications match
Palestinian innovation but rather an Iranian design for use any design known to be operated by Iran itself.
exclusively by proxies and allies is the appearance of the Iran’s own system with the same role and range, the
Iraqi al-Qasim. The latter rocket, presented as a product precision-guided Fajr-5, has a calibre of 333 mm and

Figure 4: The Badr-3 rocket in its Palestinian and Iraqi incarnations

Nafea/Badr-3
Simple Iranian 17-inch artillery
rocket custom designed for
production by proxies

al-Qasim (Iraqi PMU)

Badr-3 (Palestinian Islamic Jihad)

Source: Fabian Hinz

5 The International Institute for Strategic Studies


Figure 5: Diagrams of the 225 mm rocket for proxy production Source: . VS Quds leaks

a substantially heavier warhead. Yet the design style documented.15 Both a PIJ commander and the Iranian
of the 225 mm missile, including the location of the Supreme National Security Council Secretary Ali
guidance section, its opening and access panel and the Shamkhani have mentioned a precision-guided-missile
trapezoid control fins, is strongly reminiscent of other capability in Gaza.16
Iranian designs. The Quds leaks also document Iran’s training of PIJ
The most likely explanation is that, like the Badr-3, the cadres in the production of aluminium powder and
225 mm precision-guided missile was developed inside ammonium perchlorate which, alongside hydroxyl-
Iran but optimised for proxy production. According to terminated polybutadiene, form the key components
the Quds leaks, the system is intended for local produc- of more advanced ammonium-perchlorate compos-
tion inside Lebanon and Gaza, with the latter project ite propellants. It is claimed that Iran helped set up a
proceeding slowly, having run into trouble. Hizbullah’s PIJ ammonium-perchlorate production facility inside
possession of precision-guided missiles and inter- Syria, which might be the same site bombed by Israel
est in a manufacturing capability have been widely in February 2020.17

Figure 6: 3D reconstruction of the precision-guided 225 mm missile

225 mm Missile
Short-range precision-guided solid propellant
missiles developed by Iran for production by
local proxies

rocket motor

guidance section

warhead

aerodynamic control fins

Source: Fabian Hinz

Missile Multinational: Iran’s New Approach to Missile Proliferation 6


Houthi missile arsenal
Another indication of Iran’s new approach is found in ballistic missiles, which the Houthis have used for high-
the Houthis’ increasingly diverse missile arsenal. Since profile strikes against cities such as Jeddah, Dhahran and
the beginning of the Saudi-led intervention, the Yemeni Riyadh. Experts have conclusively established that these
group has waged a relentless missile campaign against missiles are modified Iranian Qiams that were smuggled
targets inside both Yemen and Saudi Arabia. At first, the into Yemen in pieces and locally reassembled.18 Yet, some-
group used old stocks of Yemeni-army ballistic missiles it what below the radar, the Houthis began to use another
inherited due to its initial alliance with former president class of missiles that could be broadly described as solid-
Ali Abdullah Saleh. Over time, however, new missile sys- propellant and precision-guided short-range missiles.
tems became apparent. Much attention has been focused The first of these was the Badr-1P, an artillery rocket
on the liquid-propellant Burkan-2H and Burkan-3/Zulfiqar that the Houthis unveiled in 2018 in an unguided and a

The Houthi Arsenal


Sort-range precision-guided solid-propellant
missiles likely to be manufactured inside
Yemen using Iranian-supplied equipment and
components Badr-1P

Saeer

Qasim

Badr-F/Nakkal

Qasim-2

Figure 7: Overview of precision-guided Houthi missiles Source: Fabian Hinz

precision-guided version; they claimed to have developed Saeer), all of which were marked as ‘Made in Yemen’.
and produced the system themselves. Some commentators While not matching any known Iranian systems, most
speculated that the Badr-1P might simply be a rebranded of them exhibited classic signatures of Iranian precision-
Fajr-5, yet the missile’s diameter seems smaller than the guided-missile design such as fixed double rear fins, and
Fajr-5’s 333 mm and the missile does not match the details trapezoid or triangular control fins attached to a guidance
of any known precision-guided Fajr-5 configurations.19 section installed between the motor and the warhead.
Also, the United Nations Panel of Experts examined the Combined with the low production quality seen
wreckage of one basic Badr-1 and found the missile to be in some of the examples, the most likely explanation
locally produced, likely using steel piping salvaged from is again an Iranian design effort for simplified missile
oil installations.20 Then in 2019, the Houthis unveiled systems and partial local production using Iranian-
another precision-guided missile, the Badr-F/Nakkal, with supplied equipment and components. This would be
an alleged range of 160 km and optimised for airburst consistent with an under-reported statement by the
shrapnel warheads. Unlike the Badr-1P, the Badr-F/Nakkal then-head of Israeli Military Intelligence Major-General
does not resemble any known Iranian design. Herzl Halevi, who in 2017 remarked that Iran was set-
In March 2021, the Houthis presented three new pre- ting up factories for precision weapons in Lebanon as
cision-guided short-range missiles (Qasim, Qasim-2 and well as Yemen.21

7 The International Institute for Strategic Studies


Characteristic Iranian design features observed on the Houthis’ Qasim missile

fixed double rear fins


guidance section between
warhead and motor

trapezoid or triangular
aerodynamic control fins

Figure 8: Iranian design characteristics of the Qasim missile Source: Fabian Hinz

At first, the hypothesis of Iran-enabled local missile cannot simply be disassembled into smaller pieces for
production in Yemen might seem to contradict the well- transport, offering yet another incentive for the domes-
documented instances of Iranian missile smuggling to tic production of such systems.
Yemen. However, from a technical point of view such a Exact numbers of Houthi missile launches are
dual approach would make sense. Producing Badr-class extremely hard to come by and the numbers of specific
precision-guided artillery rockets is no trivial matter, types of missiles launched are almost impossible to
but it is comparatively easier than manufacturing a establish. However, there is no doubt that the Houthis
medium-range ballistic missile. Production inside Gaza have made much use of their new generation of pre-
of unguided rockets with ranges up to 160 km proved cision-guided missiles, especially against targets inside
such an endeavour can succeed even in extremely Yemen. This has been documented by various drone-
adversarial conditions. However, more complex sys- shot videos of precision-guided missile attacks released
tems such as ballistic missiles with the range required by the Houthis and evidenced by several high-profile
to hit Riyadh, advanced cruise missiles and air-defence strikes such as the attack against a military parade in
missiles are likely well beyond the current scope of Aden in 2019,22 and the attack on Yemeni government
what the Houthis can produce, even with major Iranian members at Aden airport in 2020.23 Thus, while the
support. Therefore, it might not be a coincidence that discussion of Iran’s regional ‘precision project’ focuses
the documented cases of smuggling all involved com- mainly on Lebanese Hizbullah, Yemen has already
plex systems. Also, unlike liquid-propellant ballistic and openly been the scene of Iran’s precision project in
missiles or cruise missiles, solid-propellant missiles action for several years.

Figure 9: Drone footage of a successful Badr-1P strike against the Khalid ibn al-Walid base in western Yemen – 13.368667°, 43.590644°24

Source: Houthi media wing

Missile Multinational: Iran’s New Approach to Missile Proliferation 8


Iranian-enabled missile production in Iraq, Lebanon and Syria
Iran’s ambition to teach its proxies and allies ‘how to 2018, a Reuters report mentioned several alleged rocket-
fish’ does not appear to be limited to Gaza and Yemen. or missile-production sites operated by Shia militias in
As previously noted, Hizbullah attempts to both con- the country,29 and, in March 2020, an American airstrike
vert some of its older unguided rockets into preci- destroyed what the US government described as a solid-
sion missiles and produce entire missiles on its own. propellant production site operated by Shia militias in
According to the Israeli government, the latter effort Jurf al-Sakhar.30
seems to be centred around a facility in the Beqaa Syria was the very first recipient of Iranian assistance
Valley, which Israel exposed in 2019.25 Satellite imagery in the solid-propellant field, producing copies of the
indicates some production activity taking place at the Fateh-110 (M600/Tishrin) and the Zelzal (Maysalun). With
site, yet it remains unclear whether the site is fully oper- the beginning of the conflict in Syria and consequent
ational. To sabotage the effort, Israel appears to have approaching rebels, the country’s solid-propellant man-
targeted the bottleneck of planetary mixers required ufacturing infrastructure was moved from as-Safira31 to
for solid-propellant production, with one such piece of a new factory near Masyaf.32 The Masyaf site, as well
equipment being destroyed in a drone strike in south- as other dispersed facilities associated with missile
ern Beirut in 2019,26 and another targeted while being production, has been repeatedly struck by Israel and
transported by ship.27 it is unclear whether any missile production currently
Iran seems to support a domestic production strategy takes place in Syria.33 Also unknown is whether projects
in Iraq as well. As noted, in 2017 the military-produc- such as the Masyaf facility are under the complete con-
tion arm of Iraq’s PMU revealed several simple artil- trol of the Syrian regime, or whether Iranian forces or
lery rockets, including its own version of the Badr-3.28 In Hizbullah is in charge of the programme.

Figure 10: Hizbullah’s alleged missile-production site in the Beqaa Valley

Source: Google Earth/Maxar

9 The International Institute for Strategic Studies


Conclusion and outlook
Perhaps the best way of thinking about Iran’s new on Iran’s missile programme. For example, the missile
approach is to use the analogy of a high-end car man- arsenals of loyal proxies such as Lebanese Hizbullah,
ufacturer expanding into the market of a developing while not technically part of Iran’s armed forces, very
country. The company’s signature car designs are inter- much have to be seen as part of Iran’s deterrence capa-
nationally renowned for their reliability and high qual- bility. Therefore, local production might help ease dip-
ity. However, they are just too sophisticated for local lomatic pressure on Iran’s missile programme while
road conditions, too high-end for local manufacture and simultaneously expanding Iranian capabilities.
too expensive for potential customers. Other conditions This new level of deniability has important implica-
also provide a strong incentive for local manufacture. In tions for analysis and attribution. Previously, the basic
order to adapt to the new market, the company devel- operating assumption was that missiles and rockets used
ops simpler and cheaper cars that are not identical to by Iranian proxies were Iranian systems shipped abroad
its main line of car designs, but will be broadly similar and given a new name, and thus identifiable through
in style and use some shared components. In order to comparative analysis in the same way as identifying
cheaply produce the new design, a factory will be set up a standardised Russian or American missile system.
in the developing country using production equipment However, with Iranian proxy designs differing from
and expertise provided by the main company. It aims Iran’s own systems and some expected variation due to
to locally produce as much of the design as possible, sub-standard local production, this may no longer be a
even if many sophisticated parts will still come from the valid approach.
car company’s main factories or other international sup- Partial ownership of production capabilities by Iran’s
pliers. While the localised design serves well the main proxies might help anchor ballistic missiles and rock-
everyday needs of the target country, at the same time ets more deeply in the strategies of proxies themselves.
there is still a small market for high-end cars. To fill While this might appear to be a peripheral concern at
this niche, some examples of the company’s main car first, it must not be forgotten that in Iran’s narrative,
line will be either imported or locally assembled from domestic development has played a key role in form-
knock-down kits in parallel to the production effort of ing a particular strategic-missile culture that Iran is
the localised car. likely to be keen on exporting. In this regard, one of the
Such a strategy has several advantages from Tehran’s most interesting questions raised by Iran’s new pro-
point of view. Spreading out the production of bal- liferation strategy is just how autonomous its proxies
listic missiles helps avoid crucial bottlenecks, such as could become in their production efforts. Actors such
overland smuggling, that can be affected by interdic- as Hizbullah, which commands a vast international net-
tion efforts. While some components, such as advanced work, could have the ability to procure more sophisti-
guidance systems and actuators, are likely to still come cated components on the international market and thus
from inside Iran, the relatively small dimensions of these gradually decrease its reliance on Iran (whether due to
systems compared with whole missiles make their pro- the group’s desire or being forced by circumstance).
vision through smuggling routes much easier. Perhaps the most interesting question is what Iran’s
Iran provides itself with an additional two levels of production proliferation means for the long-term stra-
deniability by supporting local production outside its tegic outlook of non-state actors. There are two ways to
borders of missiles not identical to models of its own use. read this development. The first is to see it as an odd
The first is its use of proxies for combat either as part of exception. No other country in the region, and poten-
local conflicts, which in turn further Iran’s aims, or as tially in the world, possesses a network of proxies
part of Iranian grey-zone campaigns. The second level operating with such ideological cohesion, loyalty and
of deniability concerns potential diplomatic pressure state support as Iran does. Due to these exceptional

Missile Multinational: Iran’s New Approach to Missile Proliferation 10


conditions, Iran-sponsored groups might be able to amount of state support provided by Iran might simply
acquire capabilities, such as precision-guided-missile enable non-state actors to be the first in a global trend.
production, that will be out of reach for other non-state An apt parallel may be drones: Hizbullah had already
actors for the foreseeable future. The second reading is used reconnaissance drones in 2004 and suicide drones
that precision-guided-missile production by Iran’s non- as early as 200634 – two capabilities that have since widely
state allies is merely a harbinger of things to come for proliferated among non-state actors. Only time will tell
the world in general. In this interpretation, the massive whether precision-guided missiles will go the same way.

11 The International Institute for Strategic Studies


Notes
1 Joseph Haboush, ‘Missiles, Drones Targeting Saudi 10 ‘Afshagari: bakhsh-e fanni-ye niru-ye ghods (340) be in surat

Arabia Were All Iranian Made or Supplied: Al-Jubeir’, Al amal mikonad’

Arabiya, 21 March 2021, https://english.alarabiya.net/News/ ‫ ) به این صورت عمل میکند‬۳۴۰( ‫ بخش فنی نیروی قدس‬:‫[ افشاگری‬Exclusive:

gulf/2021/03/19/Missiles-drones-targeting-Saudi-Arabia- Quds Force’s Technical Department and the Way It Works],


were-all-Iranian-made-or-supplied-Al-Jubeir. VSQuds.info, last updated 6 December 2020, https://www.

2 See, for example, Jeffrey Lewis and Aaron Stein, ‘Up Close vsquds.info/۳۴۰-۰‫قدس‬-‫نیروی‬-‫فنی‬-‫بخش‬/‫منطقه‬-‫در‬-‫نفوذ‬.

and Personal with the Qiam’, Arms Control Wonk Podcast, 11 ‘Interview with Amir Ali Hajizadeh, [Liqa’at khasa] ‫لقاءات خاصة‬

15 December 2017, https://www.armscontrolwonk.com/ [Private Eye], al-Manar ‫[ المنار‬The Lighthouse], 3 January 2021,

archive/1204543/up-close-and-personal-with-the-qiam/; https://program.almanar.com.lb/episode/149547.

and United Nations Panel of Experts Established pursuant 12 ‘Afshagari: bakhsh-e fanni-ye niru-ye ghods (340) be in surat

to Security Council Resolution 2140 (2014), ‘Letter Dated 26 amal mikonad’

January 2018 from the Panel of Experts on Yemen Mandated ‫) به این صورت عمل میکند‬۳۴۰( ‫ بخش فنی نیروی قدس‬:‫[ افشاگری‬Exclusive: Quds

by Security Council Resolution 2342 (2017) Addressed to the Force’s Technical Department and the Way It Works], VSQuds.

President of the Security Council’, United Nations Security info, https://www.vsquds.info/۳۴۰-۰‫قدس‬-‫نیروی‬-‫فنی‬-‫بخش‬/‫منطقه‬-‫در‬-‫نفوذ‬.

Council, S/2018/594, 26 January 2018, pp. 125–8, https:// 13 See ‘al-qudrat al-‘askariyya li-quwat al-hashd a’sh-sha’bi’

digitallibrary.un.org/record/1639536?ln=en. ‫[ القدرات العسكريه لقوات الحشد الشعبي‬The Military Capabilities of the

3 See Loveday Morris and Adam Taylor, ‘Gaza’s Homemade Popular Mobilization Forces], Facebook, 14 February 2018,

Rockets Still Stretch Israel’s Sophisticated Defenses’, https://bit.ly/3dI9ddA

Washington Post, 7 May 2019, https://www.washingtonpost. 14 ‘Porozheha-yey hai raketiye-e 340’ ۳۴۰ ‫[ پروژه های راکتی‬Unit 340

com/world/gazas-homemade-rockets-still-stretch-israels- Development Projects], VSQuds.info, last updated 9 February

sophisticated-defenses/2019/05/06/2ca3a46a-700c-11e9-9331- 2021, https://www.vsquds.info/‫یمن‬-‫در‬-‫ایران‬-‫تسلط‬-‫تحکیم‬/‫منطقه‬-‫در‬-‫نفوذ‬.

30bc5836f48e_story.html. 15 See Israel Defense Forces, ‘Hezbollah’s Precision Guided

4 See Jacob Magid, ‘IDF Publishes Photos Purporting to Expose Missile Project’, https://www.idf.il/en/minisites/hezbollah/

Hezbollah Precision Missile Factory’, Times of Israel, 3 September hezbollahs-precision-guided-missile-project/.

2019, https://www.timesofisrael.com/idf-publishes-photos- 16 ‘Shamkhani: Iran baraye afzayesh-e bord mushakha-ye nezami

purporting-to-show-hezbollah-precision-missile-factory/. hich gune tangna-ye elmi va ejrayi nadarad’

5 ‘Khatt-e Moghaddam’ ‫[ خط مقدم‬Frontline], Islamic Republic of ‫ ایران برای افزایش برد موشک‌های نظامی هیچ‌گونه تنگنای علمی و اجرایی ندارد‬:‫شمخانی‬
Iran Broadcasting Corporation, 2014, available on YouTube at [Shamkhani: Iran does not have any administrative or scientific

https://youtu.be/Wr5q34c-4cw?t=1751. bottleneck to increasing the range of its missiles], Khabargozari-ye

6 See ‘Haft daghighe ta Tel Aviv’ ‫[ هفت دقیقه تا تل آویو‬Seven minutes Tasnim ‫[ خبرگزاری تسنیم‬Tasnim News Agency], 29 January 2019,

to Tel Aviv], BeBin TV, 22 June 2017, available on YouTube at https://www.tasnimnews.com/fa/news/1397/11/09/1934063/ and

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eLyYod4heRA. ‘Mostanad-e vizhe-ye al-’Alam az tunelha-ye sakht-e mushak-e

7 Ali Hashim, ‘Did Iran Train Gaza Rocket Makers?’, Al-Monitor, Ghaze’ ‫[ مستند ویژه العالم از تونل های ساخت موشک غزه‬Al Alam Special

17 July 2014, https://www.al-monitor.com/originals/2014/07/ Documentary of Gaza’s Missile Tunnels], ‘al-Alam’ ‫[ العالم‬The

gaza-rockets-palestine-iran-self-sufficient.html. World], 24 February 2019, https://fa.alalamtv.net/news/4080111/

8 ‘Interview with Amir Ali Hajizadeh‘, Liqa’at khasa, ‫لقاءات خاصة‬ 17 See Judah Ari Gross, ‘IDF Strikes Islamic Jihad in Syria, Gaza

[Private Eye], ‘al-Manar’ ‫[ المنار‬The Lighthouse], 3 January in Response to Rocket Fire’, Times of Israel, 23 February 2021,

2021, https://program.almanar.com.lb/episode/149547. https://www.timesofisrael.com/idf-strikes-islamic-jihad-

9 VS Quds, ‘Iranian Terror Exposed’, http://www.vsquds.info. targets-in-gaza-in-response-to-rocket-attacks/.

The website appears to publish information gathered by 18 See, for example, Lewis and Stein, ‘Up Close and Personal with

foreign intelligence services, with the most likely candidate the Qiam’, https://www.armscontrolwonk.com/archive/1204543/

being Israel, but no one has come forward to officially confirm up-close-and-personal-with-the-qiam/; United Nations Panel

the sources. of Experts Established pursuant to Security Council Resolution

Missile Multinational: Iran’s New Approach to Missile Proliferation 12


2140 (2014), ‘Letter dated 26 January 2018 from the Panel of 26 See Richard Spencer, ‘Israeli Drone Attack Targeted Iranian

Experts on Yemen mandated by Security Council resolution Missile Makers in Beirut’, Times, 28 August 2019, https://www.

2342 (2017) addressed to the President of the Security Council’. thetimes.co.uk/article/israeli-drone-attack-targeted-iranian-

19 While the available footage makes it very difficult to determine guided-missile-technology-5680836b9.

the exact measurements, the Badr-1P’s diameter seems to be 27 See Patrick Kingsley and Ronen Bergman et al.,‘Israel’s

closer to 280 mm. Shadow War with Iran Moves out to Sea’, New York Times,

20 United Nations Panel of Experts Established Pursuant to 26 March 2021, https://www.nytimes.com/2021/03/26/world/

Security Council Resolution 2140 (2014), ‘Letter Dated 25 middleeast/israel-iran-shadow-war.html.

January 2019 from the Panel of Experts on Yemen Addressed to 28 See ‘Iran and Allied Iraqi PMF at IQDEX2017’, Intel on Iran

the President of the Security Council’, United Nations Security Blog, 9 March 2017, http://inteloniran.blogspot.com/2017/03/

Council, S/2019/83, 25 January 2019, p. 32, https://reliefweb.int/ iran-and-allied-pmu-at-iqdex2017.html.

sites/reliefweb.int/files/resources/S_2019_83_E.pdf. 29 ‘Exclusive: Iran Moves Missiles to Iraq in Warning to Enemies’,

21 Gili Cohen, ‘Israeli Army Intelligence Chief: Hezbollah Is Setting Reuters, 31 August 2018, https://www.reuters.com/article/

up a Weapons Industry in Lebanon with Iranian Know-how’, us-iran-iraq-missiles-exclusive-idUSKCN1LG0WB.

Haaretz, 23 June 2017, https://www.haaretz.com/israel-news/ 30 ‘US General: US Strikes Destroy Weapons Depots, More

hezbollah-producing-arms-in-lebanon-says-mi-director-1.5487683. Remain’, Associated Press, 13 March 2020, https://apnews.com/

22 See ‘Yemen War: Houthi Missile Attack on Military Parade article/5ff9d48d1bdb2d2b1e4243d18930b159. The coordinates

Kills 32’, BBC News, 1 August 2019, https://www.bbc.com/ for the site’s location are 32.873824°, 44.209712°.

news/world-middle-east-49189241. 31 The coordinates for the site’s location are 35.971338°, 37.409786°.

23 See ‘Rockets over Yemen: Inside the Houthi’s Botched Attack 32 The coordinates for the site’s location are 35.103542°,

on Aden’, Bellingcat, 9 February 2021, https://www.bellingcat. 36.381064°.

com/news/mena/2021/02/09/rockets-over-yemen-inside-the- 33 See Institute for Science and International Security, ‘Serial

houthis-botched-attack-on-aden-airport/. Bombings Observed at Masyaf, Syria’, 28 December 2020, https://

24 The original video released by the Houthis is available here: isis-online.org/isis-reports/detail/serial-bombings-observed-at-

https://youtu.be/pOO1Arw-7X8. masyaf-syria.

25 ‘Israel Claims to Uncover Hezbollah Missile Plant in Lebanon’, 34 Milton Hoenig, ‘Hezbollah and the Use of Drones as a Weapon

Associated Press, 3 September 2019, https://apnews.com/articl of Terrorism’, Federation of American Scientists, 5 June 2014,

e/533c970bafd74302a101a412e4149e89. https://fas.org/pir-pubs/hezbollah-use-drones-weapon-terrorism/.

13 The International Institute for Strategic Studies


© The International Institute for Strategic Studies, 2021

The International Institute for Strategic Studies – UK


Arundel House | 6 Temple Place | London | wc2r 2pg | UK
t. +44 (0) 20 7379 7676 f. +44 (0) 20 7836 3108 e. iiss@iiss.org www.iiss.org

The International Institute for Strategic Studies – Americas


2121 K Street, NW | Suite 600 | Washington, DC 20037 | USA
t. +1 202 659 1490 f. +1 202 659 1499 e. iiss-americas@iiss.org

The International Institute for Strategic Studies – Asia


9 Raffles Place | #49-01 Republic Plaza | Singapore 048619
t. +65 6499 0055 f. +65 6499 0059 e. iiss-asia@iiss.org

The International Institute for Strategic Studies – Middle East


14th floor, GBCORP Tower | Bahrain Financial Harbour | Manama | Kingdom of Bahrain
t. +973 1718 1155 f. +973 1710 0155 e. iiss-middleeast@iiss.org

You might also like