Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Fictious Forces and Circular Motion
Fictious Forces and Circular Motion
1
CHAPTER 4
4.1 Introduction
In the previous chapter, we had studied how Newton’s laws describe interaction between objects,
but what we did not discuss was the presence of forces that indirectly affect the motion of and
object.
Consider a ball of mass m. Now, if you tie this ball to a string and rotate the string at some angular
velocity, you would naturally experience the string pulling on you. This is what we call centrifugal
force. Now, of course, this is not some new kind of force, rather, it is the tension in the string that
acts itself as the fictitious force.
We had previously defined inertial and non-inertial systems, where we understood forces from dif-
ferent frames of reference. We noted that the Earth itself provides a good inertial system. But the
restriction is that it is not that good an inertial system due to its rotation, which for us does not
seem like much, but is sufficiently fast. One consequence of Earth’s rotation, is the Coriolis force
that causes large weather systems to rotate.
Now, let us try to understand these so-called fictitious forces mathematically.
I will present to you an equation, which in itself holds the crisp of all fictitious forces that we
2
SciAstra Fictitious forces and Circular motion
:
Fapparent “ Ftrue ´ M R
Here, the last term can be treated as the additional force that we have been talking about.
We can then write;
Fapparent “ Ftrue ` Ff ictitious
dθ
ω“
dt
And, the rate of change of angular velocity is called the angular acceleration.
dω d2 θ
α“ “ 2
dt dt
3
SciAstra Fictitious forces and Circular motion
The variables in circular motion are analogous to the variables in linear motion as shown in
the table below:
Analogy between variables in linear and circular motion
Linear motion Variables Circular motion Variable
terms terms
linear displacement s angular displace- θ
ment
initial linear veloc- u initial angular ve- ωo
ity locity
final linear velocity v final angular veloc- ω
ity
linear acceleration a angular accelera- α
tion
Similarly, the equations of motions in one dimension can too be related to equation of
motion in uniform circular motion.
Analogously, we can write Newton’s equations of motion for circular motion as follows:
2
v “ u ` at ω “ ωo ` αt
3
v 2 “ u2 ` 2as ω 2 “ ωo2 ` 2αθ
4
SciAstra Fictitious forces and Circular motion
I would now like you, based on your understanding of Newton’s laws of motion, to arrive at the
following relations:
v “ rω
at “ rα
Did you notice, while deriving the expressions above, that at is the rate of change of speed and
not the rate of change of velocity. What can you conclude about the net acceleration then? Is there
a component of acceleration that is involved in the force that is not visible in our equations?
To mention that there is a component of force involved in a business that does not seem obvious is
rather incomplete.
Consider the Earth rotating around the Sun. According to Kepler’s laws of planetary motion,
the motion of the Earth with respect to the Sun is such that the Earth revolves around the
Sun in an elliptical path. But what is that force that holds the earth around the Sun in
perpetual motion? Well, you will say, ”Of course its gravity!” and you are right.
It is gravity that causes that ”radial” acceleration that pulls the Earth toward the Sun,
whereas it is the ”tangential” acceleration that leads to the transnational motion of the
Earth. Together, they lead to the Earth’s revolution.
v2
ar “
r
5
SciAstra Fictitious forces and Circular motion
dˆ ˙2 ˆ ˙2
v2 dv
b
a “ a2r ` a2t “ `
r dt
You can see for yourself that this net resultant acceleration makes some angle α with the radius of
the circle; ˜` ˘¸
dv
α “ tan ´1
` vdt2 ˘
r
v2
a“
r
mv 2
F “
r
What do you assert is the velocity that is taken here, is it the tangential velocity?
This is where we get the origin of the term centripetal force, since the force is centre-seeking.
I would again like to emphasize that centripetal force is not some new kind of force; rather,
it is those forces that compel an object into circular motion. They could be Coulombic,
nuclear, gravitational, friction, tension, etc.
6
SciAstra Fictitious forces and Circular motion
I would like to test your intuition and ask you this: Which force according to you would act
as the centre seeking force? (Keep in mind, that it is this force that you feel is pushing you
away from your car as you move on that banked road).
Ff
7
SciAstra Fictitious forces and Circular motion
So, based on our understanding of Newton’s laws, for a safe turning on a circular road, that is NOT
banked, the condition that must hold true is:
v2 Fs
“
r M
But keep in mind that the coefficient of friction is a constant value under most conditions, so the
value of Fs must not exceed a certain value, and that is
Fs ď µs M g,
thus, we can conclude that on a circular road, that is not inclined/banked, the limiting velocity at
which the vehicle will not be thrown off the road is given by
?
vď µs rg (where r is the radius of the circular road)
Now, since the condition that there is friction present on the road and so vehicles travelling at faster
speeds will not always stay on the road. So, there is another engineering hack that we are supposed
to come up with, and we have already mentioned it above, that is, banking the roads at a specific
angle.
But before we start, I would like to ask you, whether the angles at which the road is banked varies
for specific speeds or remains constant?
Coming back to our discussion, look at the figure below:
Ff
Mg
N N cospαq
α
N sinpαq
Applying Newton’s laws, we get that the angle at which for a given speed
8
SciAstra Fictitious forces and Circular motion
M v2
N sinpθq “
r
and
N cospθq “ M g,
v2
tanpθq “
rg
Keep in mind that the value of the banking angle θ depends on the vehicle’s velocity. So,
this answers the question that I previously asked: whether different angles are required for
different speeds of the vehicle, and as you have noticed till now, the answer to this question
is, yes.
Learners frequently believe that centrifugal force acts on a particle because the particle
moves in a circle. Because we describe the particle from a rotating non-inertial frame and
nevertheless utilise Newton’s laws, centrifugal force acts (or is presumed to act).
1 What I mean by experiencing this force is, again we have to careful while talking about this, since it is not some
new force is the tendency of your body to resist your state of motion, from your frame of reference, whereas for
someone standing on the ground, if you were suddenly let go by the car, you would travel in a straight line as you
are no longer being held by the force that caused you to experience a push off.
9
SciAstra Fictitious forces and Circular motion
θ
α mω 2 R
1
mg
mg
mg 1 “ mg ´ mω 2 R,
where g 1 is the effective gravity at different places on earth’s surface and R is earth’s effective radius.
For the sake of the physicist inside you, that is willing to accept a challenge, here’s a fun task:
Work out the angle α that is the inclination angle between the resultant value of g after being affected
by the rotation of the earth.
10
SciAstra Fictitious forces and Circular motion
ω 2 R sinpθq cospθq
tanpαq “
g ´ ω 2 Rsin2 pθq
11
SciAstra Fictitious forces and Circular motion
4.8 Exercises:
Single choice questions:
1. In the figure shown below, there’s a bead of mass m “ 100 g, which slides over a horizontal
circular rod of radius R “ 0.3 m. In order to keep things real, there’s a certain amount of
friction between the rod and the collar, whose value is µ “ 0.8.
If we assume that we are making all the observations before the bead comes to a stop, then
the angle made by the with vertical by the force applied by the rod on the collar when speed
of the collar at some instant of time, is 2 m{s,
´ ¯
(a) θ “ cos´1 ?3
41
´ ¯
(b) θ “ sin´1 ?4
40
´ ¯
(c) θ “ cos´1 ?2
14
´ ¯
(d) θ “ sin´1 ?4
41
2. The magnitude of a particle’s linear acceleration as it moves in a circle of radius 1 0cm and
uniform speed, completing the circle in 4 seconds is
12
SciAstra Fictitious forces and Circular motion
(a) If we increase the speed of the object by some means as it closes on the black hole, then
it might be possible to escape its gravitational sink.
(b) Option (a) is incorrect as even a beam of light, which travels at the ultimate speed cannot
escape the black hole’s event horizon.
(c) Option (b) is incorrect as we have seen the image of the black hole previously released by
the EHT , and now a reconfigured image was released recently by them, which indicates
that it is possible for the light beam to escape the black hole.
(d) None of the above.
13
SciAstra Fictitious forces and Circular motion
4. Two scientists were in their laboratory when they observed a small bug trying to climb from
the inside of a hemispherical bowl of radius R. They noticed the insect out of curiosity, for
over 15 minutes and always noted that it could not climb higher than 45o as measured from
the centre of the bowl.
So they decided to use physics to help the insect achieve greater heights.
They vertically placed the bowl on a rotor which could rotate with extreme RP M s, and and
noted that as they increased the angular velocity of the rotor, the insect could climb higher
in the bowl.
They now want to theoretically calculate the angular speed at which the insect is able to
climb to an angle of 60o .
What was their theoretical prediction of the speed at which the insect achieved that inclina-
tion?
ω
c ?
2g p2 3`1q
(a) ω “ ?
R p3´ 3q
c ?
g p 3´1q
(b) ω “ ?
R p3` 3q
c ?
g p 3`1q
(c) ω “ ?
R p3´ 3q
c ?
g p2 3´1q
(d) ω “ ?
R p3` 3q
5. Since the scientists in the previous question soon got bored, they decided to go a little farther
in their play. They wanted to figure out the minimum value of angular velocity, at which the
insect would move out of the bowl. What is that velocity, keeping the conditions exactly the
same?
ag
(a) ω “ R
b
2g
(b) ω “ R
g
a
(c) ω “ 2R
3g
(d) ω “ 2R
14
SciAstra Fictitious forces and Circular motion
θ
T, L
15
SciAstra Fictitious forces and Circular motion
7. A standard ride in fairs, also called ”mela” is cylinder with radius R that rotates at some
angular speed ω about its horizontal axis.
When a man is lying on the interior surface of the cylinder, given that the coefficient of friction
between the man and the cylinder is µ, what is the value of ω for which the man does not
slip and remains at rest with regard to the cylinder?
ω
´a ¯ 21
(a) ω ě ?1 g 2 ` g 2 µ2
Rµ
´a ¯ 21
(b) ω ě ?4 g ` g 2 µ2
Rµ
´a ¯ 21
(c) ω ď ?1 g 2 ` g 2 µ2
Rµ
´a ¯ 21
(d) ω ď ?4 g2 ` g2 µ
Rµ
16
SciAstra Fictitious forces and Circular motion
1. One famous demonstrations in classical physics is to show off the non-spillage of water from
a bucket when it is rotated in a vertical circular motion.
If a bucket filled with water is whirled around in a vertical circle of radius r. The minimum
speed that must be achieved at the top of the path such that water does not fall out from
the bucket, and if the bucket continues with this same speed for a while, assuming that the
speed remains constant throughout the motion, what is the value of the normal contact force
in terms of mass of the bucket M that the bucket exerts on water at the lowest point of the
path, respectively?
? ´ 2
¯
(a) pvmin qtop “ 2rg, N “ M g ` vr
? ´ 2
¯
(b) pvmin qtop “ 3rg, N “ M g ` vr
? ´ 2
¯
(c) pvmin qtop “ rg, N “ M g ` vr
?
(d) pvmin qtop “ rg, N “ 2M g
17
SciAstra Fictitious forces and Circular motion
2. The diagram below illustrates a L ´ cm ´ long rod that is pivoted near one end and is forced
to revolve in a horizontal plane at a constant angular speed ω.
A ball weighing mg ball is suspended by another L ´ cm ´ long thread from the other end of
the rod.
The angular speed of the rotation if the angle θ formed by the string with the vertical is 30o ,
is. Consider the observer to be sitting in an inertial frame of reference.
ω
L
o L
30
mg
b
g tanpθq
(a) ω “ Lp1`sinpθqq
b
g cospθq
(b) ω “ Lpcotpθq`Lsinpθqq
b
g cospθq
(c) ω “ Lpcotpθq`sin2 pθqq
b
g cospθq
(d) ω “ Lpcotpθq`sin2 pθqq
3. In the illustration shown below, you can see a ball of mass m is strung from a vertical rod via
two strings of equal length. The vertical separation between the strings is the same as the
length of the string from which the ball is attached. Let us call this common length, L.
If now, in some experiment, whose purpose is to determine some very specific properties of
the ball, the setup is rotated at an angular velocity ω..
Then,
ω
L m
18
SciAstra Fictitious forces and Circular motion
´a b ı
g 2g
(a) For the values of ω between L, L , the tension in the upper string is greater than
the weight of the ball, mg.
(b) In option paq, even though the tension in the upper string is greater than the weight of
the ball, the string remains slack.
b
(c) For ω “ 6g L , the tension in the upper string is twice that of tension in the lower string.
4. If an electron, whose rest mass is known to be 9.1 ˆ 10´31 Kg, and charge 1.6 ˆ 10´19 C.
The electron is treated as a particle moving in a circle with the proton at its centre in the Bohr
model of the hydrogen atom and the proton is supposed to be stationary in an inertial frame.
It is the Coulombic attraction which provides the centripetal force. Based on theoretical data,
in the ground state, the electron circles the proton in a circle with a radius of 5.3 ˆ 10´11 m.
(You may ignore any relativistic effects.)
(a) The speed of the electron in the ground state is 2.2 ˆ 106 m{s.
(b) The flaw in Bohr’s model is that it assumes that it is the Coulombic force that provides
the electron its centre-seeking force, rather, it is the weak nuclear force that does.
(c) The theory of relativity disagrees with the velocity obtained by classically obtaining the
electron’s velocity in orbit. Rather the velocity should be much lower as there is no
power source available to give the electron such high velocities.
(d) None of the above.
19
SciAstra Fictitious forces and Circular motion
20