Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Mathematical Phantoms ICTP 2010
Mathematical Phantoms ICTP 2010
42 36
0
-%%"#&%'"#'
"$".$#%/&"*""%
!"#"$%%$&
$#%%'"(##$$
)%#"$"%
#%**(#+*",
"$""#$
0$'%&#%
$".1"*%%,,
&"$/%*"
)%$&$#%#'"$"'#
0)%%2"*3
.0)23/,"#0)%%
2""&%.0)2/"#
04*+
YZ[\Z]^_\`_a_b^]c_d
e]bf\g\g_^h
56789::;<=>?69:6@8>9AB7>8>C<A6CD9<E>C<AEA<6
6F<9EC9CECGEH9<E6C6@<=><;DEH9:G6A>F>EC?G>:EI>7>G
<69CJKLMJNLOPQLRD9<E>C<SET>T8>9AB7>8>C<A89;F>
BA>G<6>A<9F:EA=<=>UE9?C6A<EHV>@>7>CH>W>I>:AX
iEC?:>D9<E>C<G6A>A97>C6<GE7>H<:;8>9AB79F:>FB<<=>E7
jC6k:>G?>H6B:GF>BA>@B:<6>A<E89<><=>7EAj<69
D>7A6C67D6DB:9<E6CGB><69GE9?C6A<EHE779GE9<E6C
l@>9AEF:>9DD769H=<6>I9:B9<>D9<E>C<G6A>AEA
D6AAEF:>9G6D<EC?97>D7>A>C<9<E6C6@<=>=B89C
F6G;m<=>A6nH9::>G9C<=76D6867D=EHH68DB<9<E6C9:
D=9C<68A
o=>89<=>89<EH9:86G>:EC?6@9C>pD6AB7>=9AF>>C
D76I>G<6F>>p<7>8>:;@:>pEF:>9CGD6k>7@B:TiECH>qrst
89C;86G>:A6@<=>=B89CF6G;=9AF>>CG>AE?C>G
<6?><=>7kE<=H68DB<>7H6G>AAE8B:9<EC?<=>79GE9<E6C
<79CAD67<9CG<=>>C>7?;G>D6AE<E6CEC<=>F6G;T
uvVw8><=6G6:6?;x F9A>G6CD6DB:9<E6C
9I>79?>Gyt<=D>7H>C<E:>9C9<68EH9:D9798><>7A
uvVwmV>D67<6@<=>o9Ajz76BD
V>@>7>CH>{9CmuvVwwBF:EH9<E6C
|}mqr~y
uvVwm9AEHlC9<68EH9:9CGw=;AE6:6?EH9:G9<9@67
A>ECV9GE6:6?EH9:w76<>H<E6CV>@>7>CH>9:B>Am
uvVwwBF:EH9<E6Crm|tt|
f\`cZ ZaZc`gZa ]\b\gZfb
`bf\Za^
lC<=76D6867D=EHH68DB<9<E6C9:D=9C<68A97>
H68DB<>786G>:A6@=B89CF6G;<6F>BA>G@67
>I9:B9<E6C6@G6A>GEA<7EFB<E6CA7>AB:<EC?@768>E<=>7
EC<>7C9:67>p<>7C9:79GE9<E6CA6B7H>ATuCE<E9::;
xAE8D:E@E>GA=9D>A6@<=>F6G;9CGEC<>7C9:67?9CAn
:9<>7x 86G>:AF9A>G6C8>GEH9:E89?>G9<96@7>9:
D>7A6CAT
ok6H:9AA>A6@D=9C<68A
i<;:E>GD=9C<68AS89<=>89<EH9:AB7@9H>>B9<E6CAmF9A>G6C
B9G79<EH>B9<E6CAX
6p>:w=9C<68AS}UI6p>:89<7EH>ADEp>:AE>8B:<ED:E>GF;
A:EH><=EHjC>AAX
lkEG>D9C679896@D=9C<68A
#%$#% 1$#%
!#+"#$#'" ""*%*
"*"'" ""
'%#%1$ %*$
$*%'" '%$&%*$#.)!/
$,
&"$" %*%**
$#,,, .20/
23#%3#% ''3#%
.2"*3 .0/
"/
023#% 423#%
."02" .20"&/
)%%,$%$#/
423#% &'3#%
.42"*'/ .%)!"20"/
f\`cZ ZaZc`g `bf\Za^
li<;:E>Gw=9C<68
l6p>:nF9A>w=9C<68
lC9:;<EH9:{6G>:
!#%"##$#&%'""*#'%"
'-".0¸/"¹'*.0Ä/
!#('"##$%$#ÅÆÇÈÉ\Ê _ `bf\Za,(##(*
"$"#"%"&"&
!#"02")%%ÅÆÇÈË
##'#'&",#ÌÇÍÎÅb\`_ab\gb`bf\ZaÏ_cg_^
!#%(Ð'"#"*0,,0Ñ,0""&
%"%#"'%""#42"*'')
"º%.0Ä/
--",2",,#
023%$#2"¡¢£¤¥¦£§¢¨©¦ª¢¨«ª§¬©«¦£¤̈®©¨«¥¨®¨§®§«¯§£¤°±¨£̈®¢¨²«§¢
²®¤©¨«¥³́¬¤¢£«¤ª²£§¬¤®µ¦«¤̈²¢¨«¯¦®¢¨©¦±§£§«¨¯§®§¨²¢°±¦®£̈¥¶,·&"-&$$,0¸
¹º%,),·)2%
»±§¼½¾¿À¦£±§¥¦£¤¦³Á±¦®£̈¥Â§«¤§¢¶,#$ÃÃ#%*Ã'Ã'3##%
{6G>::EC?kE<=?>68><7E>A
-##* -%
%"
1%$#(02"''
º1#$#%
lA<;:E>GD=9C<68
!#+"#$*%
$'"$
%#"&%
ÌÇÍÎÅb\`_ab\gb`bf\ZaÏ_cg_^
Õ«¨¥¼½¾¿Â§«¤§¢Ö%"&$"
0(c_b\_dgÒÒ_c_f\
`bf\Za^`ZZ^gfÓg\^bÓ_bfd^_Ô
( (
×>89:>ØV5WlC<=76D6867D=EHw=9C<68
×>89:>ØV5WlC<=76D6867D=EHw=9C<68
-&
!#" -$
&* º$#*&
%
-$
3
-%#
¹"
$$* 3
0
& 4
(*0
*
""
'
.#&/
6p>:D=9C<68A97>=B89C86G>:AF9A>G6CH68DB<>7
<686?79D=EH6789?C><EH7>A6C9CH>E89?>A6F<9EC>G
@768=E?=7>A6:B<E6CAH9CA6@ECGEIEGB9:ATuC67G>7<6
H6CA<7BH<I6p>:86G>:A6@<=>V>@>7>CH>{9:>9CG
V>@>7>CH>×>89:>m9DD76D7E9<>86G>:A=9I>F>>CBA>G
kE<=>p<>7C9:GE8>CAE6CAH:6A><6<=>uC<>7C9<E6C9:
v688EAAE6C6CV9GE6:6?EH9:w76<>H<E6CSuvVwX
7>@>7>CH>I9:B>AT
SÜ9EGEÙmÝBÝTzTmv68DB<9<E6C9:
lC<=76D6867D=EH86G>:A6@V>9:
Sv96C{Tm6p>:nF9A>Gv68DB<9<E6C9: ÙB89ClC9<=68;<=>w9<=<6
86G>:A6@V>9:ÙB89ClC9<=68;9 V>9:EA<EH{6C<>v97:6{6G>:EC?EC
V>IE>kmV9GE9<TÚCIE76CTE6D=;AmI6:TÛ|m V9GE6:6?EH9:iHE>CH>AmlCCTV>IT
||rm|ttÛX E68>GTÚC?TmI6:TrmÛ~qm|tt~X
Ï\_ ^\Zc_b\_bÞZÔ_ÅZd_
lHBE7><686?79D=EHE89?>A6@<=>>C<E7>F6G;Svom{VX
uG>C<E@;67?9CA9CG<EAAB>A6@EC<>7>A<m9AAE?CEC?<6>9H=
DEp>:9CEG>C<E@EH9<E6CCB8F>7
iD>HE@;G>CAE<E>A9CGH=>8EH9:H68D6AE<E6C6@67?9CAß<EAAB>A
V>?EA<>7<=>A>?8>C<>GE89?>A:EG>AEC<69}UI6:B8><6F>
BA>G<6GEAD:9;9CG<6H9:HB:9<>G6A>A
Ø7?9CA9CG<EAAB>A97>89CB9::;67A>8En
9B<689<EH9::;A>?8>C<>G@768voß{V8>GEH9:
E89?>Am<=>C<=>A>?8>C<>G|UE89?>A97>
A<9Hj>GEC<69}UI6p>:89<7Ep9CG@EC9::;67?9C
<;D>9CG89<>7E9:H68D6AE<E6C97>9AAE?C>G<6
>9H=I6p>:
CEI>7AE<;6@×:67EG9mÙ;F7EGw9>GE9<7EHw=9C<68
o=>}UI6p>:89<7Ep
89<H=>A<=>67E?EC9:
8>GEH9:E89?>A9CG
G>AH7EF>A867>
7>9:EA<EH9::;<=>=B89C
9C9<68;<=9C<=>
A<;:E>G>B9<E6CnF9A>G
D=9C<68AT
CEI>7AE<;6@×:67EG9m6p>:D=9C<68A
o=>uC<>7C9<E6C9:v688EAAE6C6CV9GE6:6?EH9:w76<>H<E6C
SuvVwX9CG<=>uC<>7C9<E6C9:v688EAAE6C6@V9GE9<E6C
CE<A9CG{>9AB7>8>C<ASuvVXG>HEG>G<6BA>I6p>:
86G>:A@67<=>BDG9<>6@67?9CG6A>H6CI>7AE6C
H6>@@EHE>C<Am@6::6kEC?<=>7>H>C<7>IEAE6C6@<=>uvVw
V>H688>CG9<E6CASuvVwmo=>|tt~V>H688>CG9<E6CA6@<=>uC<>7C9<E6C9:
v688EAAE6C6CV9GE6:6?EH9:w76<>H<E6CTuvVwwBF:EH9<E6Cqt}m|tt~XTo=>A>
I6p>:86G>:AA=6B:GF>7>D7>A>C<9<EI>6@<=>9GB:<
V>@>7>CH>{9:>9CGV>@>7>CH>×>89:>kE<=7>AD>H<<6
<=>E7>p<>7C9:GE8>CAE6CA9CG<=>E767?9C89AA>AT
×768Ü9Cj:{T><9:To=>7>@>7>CH>H68DB<9<E6C9:
D=9C<68A9G6D<>GF;uvVw9CGuvVmu×{Ú
w76H>>GEC?A6:T|ymà67:Gv6C?7>AAm|ttrX
zi×59<E6C9:V>A>97H=v>C<>7@67ÚCIE76C8>C<9CGÙ>9:<=uCA<E<B<>6@
V9GE9<E6Cw76<>H<E6C5>B=>7F>7?mz>789C;
bcba_\_c^ÆfÒ]_fgfÓÌcÓbf
ÈZ^_ÒZcáÔ\_cfbÆccbdgb\gZf
G>D<=6@<=>67?9CF>:6k<=>F6G;AB7@9H>
<7BCjGE98><>77>:9<EI><6<=>ECH68EC?79GE9<E6C
>p<>7E67A=9D>6@<=><7BCj
ÅZf\_bcZZd_^bfdZa ]\b\gZfb`bf\Za^
o=>BA>6@H68DB<9<E6C9:D=9C<68AEA:ECj>GkE<=<=>
BA>6@{6C<>v97:6v6G>AS{vvX<6H9:HB:9<>G6A>A
G>:EI>7>GEC<6<=>D=9C<68
{vvAE8B:9<>A<=> {vv=9I>F>>C67E?EC9::;
79GE9<E6C<79CAD67< G>I>:6D>G@67GE@@>7>C<9E8A
ECAEG><=>D=9C<68 FB<<=>;@ECG9DD:EH9<E6CEC
9CGD>78E<A<6 8>GEH9:D=;AEHA
G><>78EC>9:A6<=>
G6A>G>D6AE<E6C
ÅZf\_bcZZd_^
{vw5â{v5wÝ
Úzi
zÚl5oÛ
wÚ5ÚWØwÚ
×Wãl
lC<=76D6867D=EHw=9C<68zÚl5oÛ
Ð!#$*&"%"*#$%$#$#%$"*
"$##&%'""%
Ð!#$#%%#%%"
"*
!&,,#",*,%*,'
-%
*',%',$,$,&,'*,,$&
"
º $#*& .
# ä '"%$
/
,
%#.(ä/,%,&$$*."*
(
"
,
( "
/,
(
*
.""*(",(**%"("/
"
4&&#,.(ä/,*#.(ä/,
&%.(ä/,*#&%.(ä/,#.(ä/
4*
",',*'"".(ä/,",,&*,,$,$,
,#%&,'#",&'"".(ä/,&&
lC<=76D6867D=EHw=9C<68zÚl5oÛ
º%%$&
å !#&#''"%$#&
å !#&#''""%#$$#%
º
å !#&#''#$"%#'"*"
'
å !#&#''^__\b `bf\ZaæÊ\`_^_Ôç\`_bÓ_ç\`_aZd_
å !#&#''Zf^\c]\b `bf\Za]^gfÓ^gfÓ_ bc\^ÒcZadgÒÒ_c_f\
aZd_^æÊ`ZZ^gfÓbaZfÓÅÆÇÈçÌÇÍÎZcÞZÔ_èÒcZaéêÅÇÆÈÆÌÅdb\bë
å !#&#''""$*
å !#&#''$'"*$"*&'#
$#%
&+
å !#&#''&+#*%Ð&$
å !#&#''&+#$
ì
×B<B7$>%$$#$%$#
$#%'&"%&$$"$
&"%"$#
ì (&'&"&%+"#$%$#$#%(#
*"'"'%""0)4
*1Ð$#%
3#%
4*
)&%+"3#%
0)4
áÔba _ZÒ\`_í^_ZÒZa ]\b\gZfb`bf\Za^Éî
ÙTiH=:9<<:m{TÜ9Cj:9CGvTÙ6>AH=>Cm
u8D:>8>C<9<E6C6@<BF>HB77>C<86GB:9<E6CECvoG6A>H68DB<9<E6CAkE<=I6p>:86G>:A
àv|ttrmu×{Úw76H>>GEC?A|yßuuumD9?T}|rn}}|m|ttr
o=>lB<=67AE8D:>8>C<>G<=>lG9D<>GoBF>vB77>C<{6GB:9<E6C
Slov{XEC<=>H68DB<9<E6C6@G6A>H6CI>7AE6CH6>@@EHE>C<A@67vo
>p98EC9<E6CAD>7@678EC?9H68D97EA6C6@67?9C>BEI9:>C<G6A>ASÙX
D>7voUuI6:kE<=9CGkE<=6B<>8D:6;EC?lov{EC9H=>A<voAH9CT
lA=B89C86G>:A>7I>A<=>uvVw9GB:<7>@>7>CH>H68DB<9<E6C9:
89:>D=9C<68Tu<AI6p>:GE8>CAE6CA97>|Tq}~ï|Tq}~ï88ðT
o=>=>E?=<9CGk>E?=<6@<=>86G>:97>q~sH89CG~}j?m
7>AD>H<EI>:;To=>AE8B:9<E6CA97>D>7@678>GkE<=<k6BA>7H6G>A
6@<=>{6C<>v97:6D97<EH:><79CAD67<D9Hj9?>ÚziC7HT
o=>lov{<>H=CEB>EAA<9CG97GEC86G>7CvoAH9CC>7A
9AE<9::6kA9G6A>7>GBH<E6CF;<9jEC?EC<69HH6BC<<=9<
pn79;A97>9<<>CB9<>GF;<=>=B89CF6G;GE@@>7>C<:;To=>
E8D:>8>C<9<E6C6@lov{ EC<6{6C<>v97:667?9CnG6A>
H9:HB:9<E6CA9CG<=>BA>6@<=>I6p>:D=9C<68 D>78E<9
H68D97EA6C6@<=>H6CI>7AE6CH6>@@EHE>C<A6F<9EC>GkE<=
9CGkE<=6B<<BF>HB77>C<86GB:9<E6CEAD>7@678>GTl
A<9CG97G7>:E9F:>D76H>GB7><6H68DB<>H6CI>7AE6C
H6>@@EHE>C<A@679C;vo>p98EC9<E6CEA<6H68FEC><=>
D7>nH68DB<>GH6>@@EHE>C<A6F<9EC>GEC9pE9:AH9CA
9DD76D7E9<>:;T
ÙTiH=:9<<:m{TÜ9Cj:9CGvTÙ6>AH=>Cm
u8D:>8>C<9<E6C6@<BF>HB77>C<86GB:9<E6CECvoG6A>
H68DB<9<E6CAkE<=I6p>:86G>:A
àv|ttrmu×{Úw76H>>GEC?A|yßuuumD9?T}|rn}}|m|ttr
×67A68>67?9CAm:Ej>AD:>>CmA<689H=67:EI>7m<=>
86GB:9<EC?A6B7H>EC<>CAE<;H9C>I>C:>9G<6k>9j:;
ECH7>9A>GG6A>H6CI>7AE6CH6>@@EHE>C<ATo=>A>67?9CA
97>:6H9<>G867>67:>AA9<<=>AEG>6@<=>F6G;9CG<=BA
lov{H9BA>AñBA<<=>6DD6AE<>>@@>H<<=9C@67<=;76EG
67<=;8BATÙ6k>I>7kE<=lov{?>C>79::;9:6k>7
voUuI6:EA7>BE7>G@67<=>>p98EC9<E6CABH=<=9<<=>
G6A>A@6767?9CA:Ej>AD:>>CmA<689H=9CG:EI>797>
D76F9F:;A89::>7<=9CkE<=6B<lov{T