Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Hydrogen Production from Biomass by the Gasification Process
Hydrogen Production from Biomass by the Gasification Process
Ayhan Demirbaş
To cite this article: Ayhan Demirbaş (2002) Hydrogen Production from Biomass by the
Gasification Process, Energy Sources, 24:1, 59-68, DOI: 10.1080/00908310252712307
AYHAN DEMÇIRBAŞ
P. K. 216
61035 Trabzon
Turkey
The gasi cation of biomass is a thermal treatment, which results in a high produc-
tion of gaseous products and small quantities of char and ash. Steam reforming of
hydrocarbons, partial oxidation of heavy oil residues, selected steam reforming of
aromatic compounds, and gasi cation of coals and solid wastes to yield a mixture
of H2 and CO (syngas), followed by water-gas shift conversion to produce H2 and
CO2 , are well-established processes. The steam capability can be signi cantly im-
proved by permitting the classical Ni-alumina or Ni-silica/alumina formulations with
Ca and/or K. Three types of catalysts were tested: alumina, aluminosilicate material,
and nickel-supported catalyst.
59
60 A. Demirbaş
Table 1
Range of the main operating parameters
The pyrolysis products divided into a volatile fraction consisting of gases, vapors,
tar components, and a carbon-rich solid residue. The gasi cation of biomass is a thermal
treatment that results in a high production of gaseous products and small quantities of char
and ash (Demirbaş and Güllü, 1998). The pyrolysis of carbonaceous materials refers to
incomplete thermal degradation resulting in char, condensable liquid or tar, and gaseous
products. In its strictest de nition, pyrolysis is carried out in the absence of air. Pyrolysis
may be de ned as that regime in which the same organic matter is degraded by thermal
reactions in the absence of added oxidizing agents to provide a complex volatile phase
and a carbonaceous char containing inorganic components.
Some solids, liquids, and gases are produced in every thermal degradation process,
including gasi cation. However, pyrolysis differs from gasi cation (Maschio et al., 1994)
in that the products of interest are the char and liquids, which as a result of the incomplete
nature of the process retain much of the structure, complexity, and signature of the
raw material undergoing pyrolysis (Table 1). In reference to wood, pyrolysis processes
are alternately referred to as carbonization, wood distillation, or destructive distillation
processes. As generally accepted, carbonization refers to processes in which the char is
the principal product of interest (wood distillation, the liquid; and destructive distillation,
both char and liquid).
A much simpler and therefore, in principle, economically more attractive method
of extracting oil from biomass is (solvent-free) pyrolysis. This procedure eliminates the
need for a solvent recycle stream and has a higher thermal ef ciency than the gasi cation
stage of indirect liquefaction processes.
Pyrolysis of biomass is a complex function of the experimental conditions under
which the pyrolysis process proceeds. The most important factors, which affect the yield
and composition of the volatile fraction liberated, are biomass species, chemical and
structural composition of biomass, particle size, temperature (i.e., temperature-time his-
tory), heating rate, atmosphere, pressure, and reactor con guration.
Drying
Biomass fuels consist of moisture ranging from 5 to 35%. At temperatures above 373 K,
the water is removed and converted into steam. In the drying, fuels do not experience
any kind of decomposition.
62 A. Demirbaş
Pyrolysis
Pyrolysis is the thermal decomposition of biomass fuels in the absence of oxygen. The
ratio of products is in uenced by the chemical composition of biomass fuels and the
operating conditions. The heating value of the gas produced during the pyrolysis process
is low (3.5–8.9 MJ/m3 ). It is noted that no matter how the gasi er is built, there will
always be a low temperature zone where pyrolysis takes place generating condensable
hydrocarbon.
Oxidation
Introduced air in the oxidation zone contains, besides oxygen and water vapors, inert
gases such as nitrogen and argon. These inert gases are considered to be nonreactive
with fuel constituents. The oxidation takes place at temperatures of 975 to 1275 K.
Heterogenous reaction takes place between oxygen in the air and solid carbonized
fuel, producing carbon monoxide. Plus and minus signs indicate the release and supply
of heat energy during the process, respectively:
Reduction
In the reduction zone, a number of high temperature chemical reactions take place in
the absence of oxygen. Assuming a gasi cation process using biomass as a feedstock,
the rst step of the process is a thermochemical decomposition of the lignocellulosic
compounds with production of char and volatiles. The principal gasi cation reactions
that occur in reduction are mentioned below (Maschio et al., 1994; Demirbaş, 2000b).
Boudouard reaction:
CO2 1 C5 2CO 172.6 MJ/kmol. (1)
Water-gas reaction:
Main reactions show that heat is required during the reduction process. Hence the temper-
ature of gas goes down during this stage. If complete gasi cation occurs, all the carbon
Hydrogen Production from Biomass 63
is burned or reduced to carbon monoxide, a combustible gas, and some other mineral
matter is vaporized. The remains are ash and some char (unburne d carbon). The following
reactions also occur during the gasi cation process:
The main gaseous products from biomass are (Wang et al., 1997) the following:
Hydrogen gas was produced on a pilot scale by steam gasi cation of charred cellu-
losic waste material. The gas was freed from moisture and carbon dioxide. The bene cial
effect of some inorganic salts such as chlorides, carbonates, and chromates on the reac-
tion rate and production cost of the hydrogen gas was investigated (Rabah and Eldighidy,
1989). Steam reforming C1 C5 hydrocarbons, nafta, gas oils, and simple aromatics are
commercially practiced, well-known processes. Steam reforming of hydrocarbons, partial
oxidation of heavy oil residues, selected steam reforming of aromatic compounds, and
gasi cation of coals and solid wastes to yield a mixture of H2 and CO (syngas), followed
by water-gas shift conversion to produce H2 and CO2 , are well-established processes.
When the objective is to maximize the production of H2 , the stoichiometry describing
the overall process is
The simplicity of Equation (10) hides the fact that in a hydrocarbon reformer the
following reactions take place concurrently:
Table 2
Comparison of hydrogen yields were obtained by use of three different processes
compared to an equivalent noncatalytic thermal run, the increase in the content of hy-
drogen was probably due to the in uence of the catalyst on the shift reaction (Maschio
et al., 1994):
CO 1 H2 O 5 H2 1 CO2
The powdered K2 CO2 catalyst (1–3 wt% of moisture-free biomass) used in the catalytic
gasi cation runs was mixed with the biomass in the reaction chamber. The catalyst shows
a destructive effect on the organic compounds, and H2 and CO2 form at the end of the
steam gasi cation (catalytic steam reforming) process.
Spiro et al. (1984) examined the boudouard catalysts. The effect of the addition of
inorganic salts such as nitrates, perchlorates, and chromatres was investigated (MEICL,
1983). It has been reported that the use of energy recovered from uidized bed combustors
provided the most energy-ef cient solution (Sneyd, 1984).
The main problem in the steam reforming of carbonaceous substances is carbon for-
mation. Three types of carbon may be formed: whiskers, encapsulating deposits (“poly-
mer”), and pyrolytic carbon (Wang et al., 1997). Carbon formation is related to the
kinetics, and hence the selectivity, of the catalyst. In steam reforming, adsorption of
hydrocarbons on the metal sites (Ni is commonly used) is followed by dehydration
and cracking. This results in smaller CxHx adsorbed fragments that can polymerize to
unwanted intermediates and from coke. These reactions complete with reactions with
Table 3
Average chemical composition of gaseous products from the precipitate from
black liquor at different temperatures
adsorbed water species. The catalyst must supply enough adsorbed H2 O derived species,
mainly OH and H, which must have suf cient surface mobility to reach the adsorbed
hydrocarbon derived species and react with them (Demirbaş and ÇaÆglar, 1998). The
steam capability can be signi cantly improved by promoting the classical Ni-alumina
or Ni-silica/alumina formulations with Ca and/or K (Wang et al., 1997). Three types
of catalysts were tested by Corte et al. (1985): alumina, aluminosilicate material, and
nickel-supported catalysts.
Charcoal
Charcoal is a product of wood carbonization (absence of air). By burning around 4 tons
of rewood, 1 ton of charcoal is produced. Charcoal offers twice as much heat as is
produced by wood. Using an ef cient charcoal oven or cookstove can compensate for
energy lost during the conversion of wood to charcoal. Unlike rewood, it burns slowly
and does not produce any smoke. Good quality charcoal does not contain any tar, hence
it is quite feasible for all kinds of gasi ers. Charcoal is also low in mineral matter and
does not disintegrate easily. Compared to other biomass fuels, charcoal is costly. An
important disadvantage is that during conversion of wood into charcoal, more than 50%
of the energy is lost. This is a notable factor for those developing countries that are
suffering in an energy crisis.
Wood
The main combustible components of wood are cellulose, hemicelluloses, and lignin,
which are compounds of carbon, hydrogen, and oxygen. Other minor combustible com-
ponents in wood are fats, resins, and waxes. The major noncombustible component of
wood is water, which makes up to 50% of freshly cut wood. Though the ash content is
low (< 1%), because of high oxygen content, the calori c value is low (16–20 MJ/kg).
Next to charcoal, wood is quite a suitable fuel for xed bed gasi ers. As wood
contains high volatile matter, an updraft gasi er system produces gas containing tar,
which needs to be cleaned out before use in engines. Cleaning of gas is a dif cult
and labor-intensive process. Hence wood is not suitable in updraft gasi er coupled with
internal combustion engines. However, the gas containing tar from an updraft gasi er
can be used for direct burning.
Sawdust
Unpellatized sawdust leads to the problems of excessive tar production, inadmissable
pressure drop, and lack of bunker ow. Such problems can be minimized by the use
66 A. Demirbaş
Peat
Peat is the rst stage of coal formation. It is not strictly a coal, or it can be termed as
the most immature coal. Freshly mined peat contains 90% moisture and 10% solid. It
cannot be utilized unless air dried to reduce moisture content to 30% or less. Its heating
value (around 20 MJ/kg) is slightly greater than wood.
As peat contains a very high level of moisture and ash, it creates problems in the
gasi cation process.
Agricultural Residues
If wood is scarce and costly, more abundant or accessible but otherwise less favored
fuels are used instead. Agricultural residues are basically biomass materials that are by-
products of agriculture. This includes cotton stalks, wheat and rice straw, coconut shells,
maize and jowar cobs, jute sticks, rice husks, etc.
Many developing countries have a wide variety of agricultural residues in ample
quantities (Küçük and Tunç, 1999). Hazelnut shell, coconut shells, and maize cobs have
been successfully tested for xed-bed gasi ers; they are unlikely to create any problems.
Most cereal straws have an ash content above 10% and present a slagging problem in
downdraft gasi ers. Rice husk with ash contents above 20% is dif cult to gasify.
Economy
Today the least expensive way of making hydrogen is through the steam reforming of
natural gas. The resulting cost of hydrogen is typically about 5–6 US$/GJ when made
from natural gas at a price of 3 US$/GJ (Kaarstad and Audus, 1997). About 95% of
all hydrogen used in the world goes to produce ammonia (50%), petroleum processing
(37%), and methanol (8%). Most of the hydrogen for making these three products is both
produced and consumed within the plant fences.
Cheaper feedstocks can be used, which include biomass residues. The intregrated
system, however, can avoid the costs of entirely condensing the vapors to produce liquid
fuel and transporting the liquid fuel to the hydrogen facility. Because of the low sulfur
content of biomass and liquid fuel from the biomass, a sulfur removal system is not likely
to be required. The current selling price of H2 in industry is generally between $5/GJ and
$14/GJ, depending on the size of the production facility. This range is for hydrogen as
produced by the plant: puri ed but not compressed or stored. For a conceptual process,
the cost of hydrogen has been estimated to be $7.70/GJ for the base case (production
capacity: 35.5 tons of hydrogen per day) (Wang et al., 1997).
The running cost of the generated hydrogen was carried out by processing 10 tons
of the biomass. The biomass was received at a price of $4 ton 1 . It was transported by
truck for $16. The cost of 1 kg of puri ed hydrogen is only $0.68 (Rabah and Eldighidy,
1989).
Conclusion
Gasi cation of solid fuels to yield a mixture of H2 and CO, followed by a water-gas
shift conversion to produce H2 and CO2 , are well-established processes.
Renewable biomass has also been considered as potential feedstock for gasi cation
to produce syngas; the economics of current processes favor the use of light hydrocarbons
(in natural gas) and coal. An alternative approach to the production of H2 from biomass
begins with fast pyrolysis and gasi cation of biomass.
Production of hydrogen gas by biomass gasi cation with steam is enhanced by the
addition of some inorganic salts to the reacting species. Kinetically, the reaction is a
chemically controlled process.
References
Baker, E. G., L. K. Mudge, and M. D. Brown. 1987. Steam gasi cation of biomass with nickel
secondary catalyst. Ind. Engng. Chem. Res. 26:1335–1339.
ÇaÆglar, A., and H. Özmen. 2000. Hydrogen: As an attractive fuel in future. Energy Educ. Sci.
Technol. 6:1–18.
Constantine, A. 1983. Method of and Apparatus for the Production of Charcoal. U.K. Patent
No. C1 CO1 B31/02 (14 December 1983).
Corella, J., M. P. Arnar, J. Delgado, and E. Alden. 1991. Steam gasi cation of cellulosic wastes
in a uidised bed with downstream vassel. Ind. Engng. Chem. Res. 30:2252–2562.
Corte, P., C. Lacoste, and J. P. Traverse. 1985. Gasi cation and catalytic conversion of biomass by
ash pyrolysis. J. Anal. Appl. Pyrolysis 7:323–335.
68 A. Demirbaş
Demirbaş, A. 2000a. Biomass resources for energy and chemical industry. Energy Educ. Sci.
Technol. 5:21–45.
Demirbaş, A. 2000b. Recent advances in biomass conversion technologies. Energy Educ. Sci.
Technol. 6:19–41.
Demirbaş, A., and A. ÇaÆglar. 1998. Catalytic steam reforming of biomass and heavy oil residues
to hydrogen. Energy Educ. Sci. Technol. 1:45–52.
Demirbaş, A., and D. Güllü. 1998. Acetic acid, methanol and acetone from lignocellulosics by
pyrolysis. Energy Educ. Sci. Technol. 1:111–115.
Demirbaş, A., S. Karslõ oÆglu, and A. Ayas, 1996. Hydrogen resources: Conversion of black liquor
to hydrogen rich gaseous products. Fuel Sci. Technol. Int’l 14:451–463.
Demirbaş, A., and A. Şahin. 1998. Evaluation of biomass residue 1. Briquetting waste paper and
wheat straw mixtures. Fuel Processing Technol. 55:175–183.
Kaarstad, O., and H. Audus. 1997. Hydrogen and electricity from decarbonised fossil fuels. Energy
Convers. Mgmt. 38:431–434.
Küçük, M. M., and M. Tunç. 1999. Supercritical uid extraction of biomass. Energy Educ. Sci.
Technol. 2:1–6.
Lower, H. H. 1963. Chemistry of Coal Utilization, Supplement Volume, pp. 740–815, Oxford,
London.
Maschio, G., A. Lucchesi, and G. Stoppato. 1994. Production of syngas from biomass. Bioresource
Technol. 48:119–126.
MEICL (Matsushita Electric Industrial Co. Ltd.). 1983. Solid carbonaceous fuel. Jpn Kokai Tokkyo
Koho JP 58,162,696 (C1 C10 L9/12).
Patil, K. Z. 1987. Hydrogen. Chem. Age India 38:519–527.
Rabah, M. A., and S. M. Eldighidy. 1989. Low cost hydrogen production from waste. Int. J.
Hydrogen Energy 14:221–227.
Rabah, M. A., S. M. Edighidy, and S. Gahin. 1983. Dual production of active carbon and hydrogen
by steam gasi cation of palm stones. J. Inst. Energy 56:20–28.
Rapagna, S., E. Tempesti, P. U. Foscolo, and E. Parodi. 1992. Hydrogen production by biomass
steam pyrolysis in a uidized reactor. J. Thermal Analysis 38:2621–2622.
Sneyd, R. J. 1984. Energy recovery from uidized-bed combustion. Chem. Engng. Progr. 80:48–54.
Spiro, C. L., D. W. McKee, and P. G. Kosky. 1984. Comparison of effect of adding boudouard
catalysts before and after coal charring. Fuel 63:133–1345.
Taheshita, T., T. Yasutomi, and T. Yokota. 1975. Continuous carbonization of crushed waste wood
in a stirred uidized bed. Funtas Kogaku Kenky Kaishi 12:199–203.
Wang, D., S. Czernik, D. Montane, M. Mann, and E. Chornet. 1997. Biomass to hydrogen via fast
pyrolysis and catalytic steam reforming of the pyrolysis oil or its fractions. Ind. Eng. Chem.
Res. 36:1507–1518.
Wienhaus, O. 1979. Chemical fundamentals of the pyrolysis of lignocellulosic materials as well as
properties and usability of the products. Holztecnologie 20:144–152.