APJPH 32(1) 2020, 42-48

You might also like

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 7

893801

research-article2020
APHXXX10.1177/1010539519893801Asia Pacific Journal of Public HealthOsman et al

Article
Asia Pacific Journal of Public Health

Demographic and Socioeconomic 2020, Vol. 32(1) 42­–48


© 2020 APJPH
Article reuse guidelines:
Variables Associated With Health sagepub.com/journals-permissions
https://doi.org/10.1177/1010539519893801
DOI: 10.1177/1010539519893801

Care–Seeking Behavior Among journals.sagepub.com/home/aph

Foreign Workers in Malaysia

Ahmad Farid Osman, PhD1 , Muzalwana Abdul Talib, PhD1,


Khaled Tafran, MEc1, Makmor Tumin, PhD1, and Chin Sieng Chong, MEc1

Abstract
Foreign workers in Malaysia face various barriers in accessing health care, which results in many of them being unable to
obtain appropriate medical treatment in case of sickness. This study investigates the foreign workers’ health care–seeking
behavior and the demographic and socioeconomic variables that influence it. Data were collected from 502 foreign workers
using a self-administered questionnaire. Multiple logistic regression was used to estimate the influence of demographic
and socioeconomic variables on health care–seeking behavior among foreign workers. In cases of severe sickness, 20.5%
of foreign workers stated that they will not go or are unlikely to go to a clinic or hospital. The multiple logistic regression
revealed that foreign workers’ tendency to avoid medical treatment is associated with gender, marital status, monthly
income, preferred language of communication, and work classification. Nonetheless, in cases of mild sickness, demographic
and socioeconomic variables do not influence foreign workers’ health care–seeking behavior.

Keywords
health care–seeking behavior, foreign workers, Malaysia, demographic, socioeconomic

What We Already Know to join the high-income countries in the next few years.1 The
official language is Malay, although the vast majority of citi-
In a number of past studies, several demographic and socio- zens speak English as a second language. The good eco-
economic factors like gender, age, marital status, work clas- nomic conditions in Malaysia attract large numbers of
sification, education background, income, and language foreign workers from neighboring countries. In July 2017,
were found to affect the utilization of health care services there were around 1.76 million documented foreign workers
among foreign workers, although some other studies suggest in Malaysia, from Indonesia (40.6%), Nepal (22.8%),
different findings. Bangladesh (12.5%), Myanmar (7.2%), India (6.5%),
Pakistan (3.4%), the Philippines (3.2%), and other countries
What This Article Adds (3.9%).2 However, the actual number of foreign workers is
This study concludes that the significance of effect of demo- significantly larger when taking into consideration the huge
graphic and socioeconomic factors on tendency of getting quantity of undocumented workers in Malaysia, estimated to
treatment when sick among foreign workers in Malaysia be around 1.3 million people.3
depends on the severity of sickness. None of the mentioned The health status of foreign workers is an imperative pub-
factors significantly affect the tendency of getting treatment lic health issue,4,5 especially when such individuals come
in the case of mild sickness. On the other hand, gender, mari- from countries with a lower health status than the host coun-
tal status, work classification, income, and language were try. In fact, the vast majority of foreign workers in Malaysia
found to significantly affect tendency of getting treatment in
1
the case of severe sickness. University of Malaya, Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia

Corresponding Author:
Introduction Ahmad Farid Osman, Ungku Aziz Centre for Development Studies,
Faculty of Economics and Administration, University of Malaya, Kuala
Malaysia is a developing country of 30 million people with a Lumpur, 50603, Malaysia.
per capita income of 9508 USD (2016 data), and it is expected Email: faridosman@um.edu.my
Osman et al 43

are from countries that have significantly lower health status Materials and Methods
than Malaysia, reflected by lower life expectancy and per
capita health spending. The World Development Indicators The study employed self-administered questionnaires that
published by the World Bank listed Malaysia at a better posi- were distributed to 502 foreign workers in urban areas of
tion in terms of life expectancy and per capita health spend- Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia. The respondents were guided by
ing in 2015 compared with Bangladesh, Nepal, Indonesia, enumerators to respond to the questionnaire to avoid misin-
the Philippines, India, Pakistan, and Myanmar.1 terpretation. Based on the total number of documented for-
By law, foreign workers are required to undergo a medical eign workers recorded in July 2017, that is, around 1.76
check-up as a prerequisite for obtaining a working visa. million, a sample of 502 respondents is considered adequate
However, as mentioned earlier, a large fraction of foreign to be a representative sample of the population. Between
workers are illegal, and so their health status is not moni- February and June 2018, respondents were approached in a
tored. Moreover, there is some evidence to suggest that a sig- number of different targeted areas, including workplaces
nificant number of foreign workers obtain fabricated medical (construction areas, security guard houses, shops, etc), pub-
reports from their countries,6 which increases the risk of lic areas (shopping malls, bus and train stations, etc), and
transmitting diseases to Malaysia.5 workers’ accommodation provided by their employers. The
Malaysian policies regarding foreign workers have been direct interaction between enumerators and respondents
described as “poor” and not aimed at protecting migrant resulted in a full response rate (100%). We used a quota sam-
workers’ rights, being instead mainly targeted at protecting pling technique, in which we made sure that the distribution
locals from any negative implications.3,7 Foreign workers in of respondents’ countries of origin resembled that of the
Malaysia suffer from low wages, a poor living environment, population proportion of such groups of foreign workers in
and exploitation.3,8 Moreover, there are disparities in health Malaysia.2 The distribution of sampled foreign workers by
care coverage and accessibility between local and foreign countries for this study are as follows: Indonesia (42.63%),
workers.3 As a result, a significant fraction of foreign work- Nepal (21.51%), Bangladesh (18.53%), Myanmar (7.17%),
ers face difficulties in accessing health care,6 which contrib- India (6.18%), Pakistan (1.39%), the Philippines (1.59%),
utes to undermining their health conditions, increasing the and other countries (0.99%). In addition, the percentages of
risk of illness among them, and transmitting diseases to the respondents by gender and working sectors were also con-
local community. trolled to reflect the true population of documented foreign
Demographic and socioeconomic factors are key predic- workers in Malaysia. The distribution of foreign workers in
tors of migrant workers’ health as well as their treatment- the sample and population are presented in Table A1 in the
seeking behavior.8-12 Peng et al12 studied the health appendices (Supplementary Material; available online).
care–seeking behavior of 2478 migrant workers in China Our enumerators were local Malaysians who were able to
and found that the incidence of seeking treatment in case of distinguish foreign workers by their appearance and accent.
illness is significantly lower in workers with less education To confirm that the respondent was a foreign worker, he or
and a lower household income. The same study found that she was asked about their country of origin prior to being
gender, age, and occupation do not influence migrant work- given the questionnaire. For respondents who are yet to be
ers’ tendency to seek treatment.12 Moreover, studies from able to understand Malay/English well, assistance was
Thailand found that gender, age, marital status, and work acquired from their friends who understood the languages
classification significantly influence foreign workers’ better. All respondents were informed that their responses
health care–seeking behavior.10,11 To the best of our knowl- would be kept confidential and that the data collected would
edge, no research has investigated the health care–seeking be analyzed at aggregate level for research purposes only.
behavior of foreign workers in Malaysia and the influence All questions were in both Malay and English, in the same
of demographic and socioeconomic factors on this behav- questionnaire.
ior, and so this study aims to fill this research gap. In this The questionnaires first asked respondents about their
research, health care–seeking behavior was analyzed by demographic and socioeconomic information; that is, gen-
studying the respondents’ tendency to seek medical treat- der, age, education, marital status, working classification,
ment based on severity of sickness: mild and severe sick- monthly income, and preferred language for communication.
ness. It is a different approach of analyzing health Next, respondents were asked the following two questions:
care–seeking behavior to the mentioned studies in China “If you are experiencing mild sickness (eg, headache, mild
and Thailand that use other variables to represent health fever, flu infection), what is the likelihood that you will go to
care–seeking behavior such as utilization of health services a clinic or hospital for treatment?” And “If you are experi-
and time to visit the health centers. In other words, this encing severe sickness (eg, high fever, injury, diarrhea), what
study was aimed to identify demographic and socioeco- is the likelihood that you will go to a clinic or hospital for
nomic factors associated with health care–seeking behavior treatment?” The following options were given to the respon-
among foreign workers in Malaysia in two different cases, dents to choose from for each question: (1) will not go, (2)
namely mild and severe sickness. unlikely to go, (3) more likely to go, and (4) will go. This
44 Asia Pacific Journal of Public Health 32(1)

study defined mild sickness as illness that normally can be Table 1 illustrates the incidence of seeking treatment in
treated by taking over-the-counter medications. On the other case of severe sickness among foreign workers, distributed
hand, severe sickness is defined as illness that normally by their demographic and socioeconomic characteristics. In
requires consultation with medical practitioners, or illness or total, 20.5% of foreign workers stated that they will not go or
injury that requires minor or major surgery, or illness that are unlikely to go to a clinic or hospital in case of severe
requires admission for inpatient treatment. sickness. The bivariate analyses revealed significant gender
In the statistical analyses, to perform logistic regressions, differences in health care–seeking behavior, with men dis-
we transformed the 4-point Likert-type scale into a dummy playing a lower tendency to seek medical treatment than
variable, where “1” stands for will not go and unlikely to go woman (P < .001). Foreign workers’ behavior also varied
and “0” represents more likely to go and will go. The result- according to their marital status (P = .003), working classi-
ing dummy variable, therefore, represent the respondents’ fication (P = .005), monthly income (P = .017), and pre-
tendency to avoid health care treatment in cases of mild and ferred language (P = .016). However, foreign workers’
severe sickness. behavior did not show significant variation based on their
The statistical analyses were performed in two stages. In age and education.
the first, bivariate analyses (χ2 tests) were used to examine if Table 2 presents the results of the multiple logistic regres-
there were statistical differences in respondents’ health care– sion of demographic and socioeconomic variables associated
seeking behavior according to their demographic and socio- with the tendency to avoid obtaining medical treatment in
economic affiliations. The demographic and socioeconomic case of severe sickness. The regression revealed that men
variables that revealed significant variations in health care– were about 7 times more likely to avoid treatment than
seeking behavior in the bivariate analyses were taken to the women (odds ratio [OR] = 7.008; P < .001). Nonmarried
second stage, the multiple logistic regression, to examine the foreign workers were about 1.8 times more likely to avoid
factors associated with health care–seeking behavior among treatment than married foreign workers (OR = 1.779; P =
foreign workers. A 5% significance level was used for statis- .030). Foreign workers working in the manufacturing indus-
tical significance, and statistical analyses were performed try were about 5.5 times less likely to avoid medical treat-
using SPSS 20.0 (IBM Corp, Armonk, NY). ment than their counterparts working in the service industry
(OR = 0.183; P < .001). The 5.5 value was obtained based
on the formula 1/odds ratio, that is, 1/0.183.
Results Table 2 also shows that foreign workers making less than
Table A2 in the appendices (Supplementary Material) pres- 1000 MYR (~ 250 USD) a month were 3.8 times more likely
ents the respondents’ characteristics through seven demo- to avoid a medical visit than those who make more than 2000
graphic and socioeconomic variables. The majority of MYR a month (OR = 3.754; P = .004). Respondents whose
respondents were male (78.0%) and aged 30 years and below preferred language for communication was classified as
(65.3%). About 42.4% of the participants were married. “other” (not English or Malay) were 2.7 times more likely to
Malay was the preferred language for communication for skip treatment than those who preferred the Malay language
82.8% of the respondents, whereas 11.3% preferred English for communication (OR = 2.712; P = .021).
and 5.7% preferred another language.
In all, 37.05% of the respondents received primary educa-
Discussion
tion, with slightly more than half of them received secondary
education (51.6%). A total of 11.35% had tertiary education. The findings of this research revealed that the vast majority
About 32.0% of the respondents worked in the service indus- (82.6%) of foreign workers in Malaysia are likely to avoid
try, 24.1% in construction, 22.1% in manufacturing, and seeking medical treatment in case of mild sickness. However,
21.7% in other industries. The majority of the respondents what is more worrying is that more than 20% of foreign
(62.7%) earned between 1000 and 2000 Malaysia Ringgits workers are likely to skip seeking treatment even if they are
(MYR; 1 USD ~ 4 MYR, as of January 2018) a month, while facing severe sickness.
around a third earned more than 2000 MYR. Previous research on foreign workers in Malaysia showed
For mild sickness, about 82.6% of the respondents stated that they suffer from various barriers when accessing health
that they will not or are unlikely to seek medical assistance care, including a lack of insurance coverage as well as finan-
by visiting a clinic or hospital. Moreover, the bivariate analy- cial and locational barriers.6 These barriers may explain our
ses did not identify any significant variations in foreign findings on the foreign workers’ tendency of such workers to
workers’ health care–seeking behavior, according to their avoid seeking medical treatment, which emphasizes the
demographic and socioeconomic affiliations; for details see importance of introducing new policies for improving for-
Table A3 in the appendices (Supplementary Material). eign workers’ health status and behavior in seeking treat-
Therefore, foreign workers’ health care–seeking behavior in ment, as well as their working conditions in general.3
case of mild sickness was not analyzed using multiple logis- The results of this study showed that foreign workers’ ten-
tic regression. dency to avoid seeking medical treatment is higher among
Osman et al 45

Table 1. Incidence of the Tendency to Seek Treatment in Case of Severe Sickness Among Foreign Workers in Malaysia, Characterized
by Demographic and Socioeconomic Variables; Bivariate Analyses.

Seeking Treatment Not Seeking treatment

Variable n (%) n (%) Pa


Gender
Male 295 (75.26) 97 (24.74) .000
Female 104 (94.55) 6 (5.45)
Age (years)
≤30 255 (77.74) 73 (22.26) .267
31-40 100 (84.75) 18 (15.25)
>40 44 (78.57) 12 (21.43)
Education
Primary 148 (79.57) 38 (20.43) .494
Secondary 209 (80.69) 50 (19.31)
Tertiary 42 (73.68) 15 (26.32)
Marital status
Nonmarried 217 (75.09) 72 (24.91) .003
Married 182 (85.45) 31 (14.55)
Work classification
Manufacturing 104 (93.69) 7 (6.31) .005
Construction 91 (75.21) 30 (24.79)
Services 121 (75.16) 40 (24.84)
Other 83 (76.15) 26 (23.85)
Monthly income (MYR)
<1000 20 (60.61) 13 (39.39) .017
1000-2000 252 (80.00) 63 (20.00)
>2000 127 (82.47) 27 (17.53)
Preferred language for communication
Malay 336 (80.77) 80 (19.23) .016
English 46 (80.70) 11 (19.30)
Other 17 (58.62) 12 (41.38)
Total 399 (79.48) 103 (20.52)

Abbreviation: MYR, Malaysian Ringgit (1 USD ~ 4 MYR, as of January 2018).


a
P value of the χ2 independence test.

low-income workers, and this result accords with previous tendency to seek medical treatment than married migrant
findings from China.12 Low income and poverty are key fac- workers.10 This suggests that men and nonmarried foreign
tors undermining access to health care and health out- workers should be given priority in policies targeted at
comes.13-20 In fact, foreign workers are more vulnerable than improving foreign workers’ health care–seeking behavior.
local poor people as they face higher risks and more life chal- Language is a well-documented barrier to accessing
lenges. Moreover, financial barriers to health care are well health care.25-30 As shown by this study, foreign workers
documented among migrants.21 These facts emphasize that whose preferred spoken language is not Malay or English are
policies aimed at improving the health care–seeking behav- more likely to avoid seeking medical treatment than their
ior of foreign workers should target workers with the lowest counterparts. The provision and utilization of medical inter-
income. preters in health centers is essential to help foreign workers
The influence of gender and marital status on health care– in improving their treatment-seeking behavior. Moreover,
seeking behavior is well reported in the literature.10,11,22-24 encouraging foreign workers to join programs to learn the
The current study revealed that men are more likely to skip local language may also have good results in this regard.
medical visitations than women, which accords with the According to the findings of this research, manufacturing
findings of Naing et al10 and Aung et al11 on migrant workers workers have a higher tendency for seeking medical visita-
in Thailand. Moreover, the results brought evidence that tion than workers in the service industry. Unlike in service
nonmarried workers are more likely to avoid treatment. This sector, most of workers in manufacturing sector (like those
finding is in-line with research from China, where it was working in big factories) have access to panel clinics pro-
found that single individuals have a significantly lower vided by their employers for free treatment and medication,
46 Asia Pacific Journal of Public Health 32(1)

Table 2. Demographic and Socioeconomic Variables Associated With the Tendency to Avoid Medical Treatment in Case of Severe
Sickness Among Foreign Workers in Malaysia; Multivariate Logistic Regressionsa.

Variable β SE P OR [95% CI]


Gender
Female Ref
Male 1.947 0.454 .000 7.008 [2.877-17.071]
Marital status
Nonmarried 0.576 0.265 .030 1.779 [1.059-2.991]
Married Ref
Work classification
Services Ref
Manufacturing −1.699 0.452 .000 0.183 [0.075-0.444]
Construction −0.041 0.327 .901 0.960 [0.506-1.821]
Other 0.122 0.325 .707 1.130 [0.598-2.136]
Income (MYR)
<1000 1.323 0.454 .004 3.754 [1.543-9.138]
1000-2000 0.451 0.304 .138 1.570 [0.865-2.848]
>2000 Ref
Preferred language for communication
Malay Ref
English −0.190 0.393 .629 0.827 [0.383-1.786]
Other 0.998 0.432 .021 2.712 [1.163-6.321]
Constant −3.597 0.551 .000 0.027

Abbreviations: SE, standard error; OR, odds ratio; CI, confidence interval; MYR, Malaysian Ringgit (1 USD ~ 4 MYR, as of January 2018).
a
Dependent variable is a dummy where “1” stands for “will not go” or “unlikely to go” for treatment, while “0” stands for “will go” or “more likely to go”
for treatment in case of severe sickness.

which encourages the workers to visit clinics when sick. Limitations of the Study
Most of workers in the service industry (like those working
in small marketing and sales companies, restaurants, and The best efforts have been taken to only approach docu-
residential security guard houses) have to pay on their own mented foreign workers (for instance by asking for the type
(out of pocket) for the cost of treatment and medication. This of “i-kad” (an identification card for foreigners issued by the
could be the reason behind this finding. A study from China Immigration Department of Malaysia) that they possess.
and another from Thailand found that work classification However, we cannot totally guarantee that all respondents
influenced migrant workers’ health-seeking behavior.10,11 were legal foreign workers due to several possible reasons,
Hence, it is important that policies for enhancing the health including the possession of a fake card. Since the scope of
care–seeking behavior of foreign workers should be this study was to only include documented foreign workers,
industry-specific. this factor was not included as one of the variables.
In-line with previous research from Thailand, our results Mode of payment, although is an important variable affect-
revealed that education is not associated with foreign work- ing tendency in getting treatment was not included in the
ers’ health care–seeking behavior.10 However, another analysis. This is because this study focuses on demographic
study from China showed some evidence to suggest that and socioeconomic variables only. However, we believe that
education affects migrant workers’ health care–seeking the inclusion of the working sectors variable to a certain
behavior.12 extent indirectly represents the influence of mode of payment
Similarly, the current study proved that age does not influ- based on the argument given above. Nevertheless, including
ence foreign workers’ health care–seeking behavior, which the mode of payment as one of the variables to replace work-
confirms the findings of Peng et al.12 However, Naing et al10 ing sectors could slightly change the estimated ORs.
found that age in Thailand does influence the health care–
seeking behavior of migrant workers who use public health
Conclusions
care facilities, but not those who use private ones. This con-
tradictory finding suggests that the demographic and socio- It is alarming that a significant portion of foreign workers in
economic determinants of health care–seeking behavior vary Malaysia are likely to avoid seeking medical treatment when
across countries and perhaps across populations within the becoming unwell. Policymakers should develop new strate-
same country. gies for improving the health care–seeking behavior of
Osman et al 47

foreign workers in order to provide good health status for 7. Lasimbang HB, Tong WT, Low WY. Migrant workers in
them as well as the local community. The findings of this Sabah, East Malaysia: the importance of legislation and policy
research suggest that such policies should be industry-spe- to uphold equity on sexual and reproductive health and rights.
cific and focus primarily on foreign workers who are male Best Pract Res Clin Obstet Gynaecol. 2016;32:113-123.
8. Sahimin N, Lim YAL, Ariffin F, Behnke JM, Lewis JW, Zain
and unmarried, as well as those whose preferred language for
SNM. Migrant workers in Malaysia: current implications of
communication is not Malay or English.
sociodemographic and environmental characteristics in the
transmission of intestinal parasitic infections. PLoS Negl Trop
Declaration of Conflicting Interests Dis. 2016;10:e0005110.
The author(s) declared no potential conflicts of interest with respect 9. Wong DFK, He X, Leung G, Lau Y, Chang Y. Mental health
to the research, authorship, and/or publication of this article. of migrant workers in China: prevalence and correlates. Soc
Psychiatry Psychiatr Epidemiol. 2008;43:483-489.
Funding 10. Naing T, Geater A, Pungrassami P. Migrant workers’ occu-
pation and healthcare-seeking preferences for TB-suspicious
The author(s) disclosed receipt of the following financial support symptoms and other health problems: a survey among immi-
for the research, authorship, and/or publication of this article: We grant workers in Songkhla province, southern Thailand. BMC
would like to acknowledge the financial support provided by the Int Health Hum Rights. 2012;12:22.
Equitable Society Research Cluster (research grant: RP018D- 11. Aung T, Pongpanich S, Robson MG. Health seeking behav-
14SBS) and the Ungku Aziz Centre for Development Studies, iours among Myanmar migrant workers in Ranong province,
Faculty of Economics and Administration, University of Malaya Thailand. J Heal Res. 2009;23:5-9.
(research grant: PD006-2017). 12. Peng Y, Chang W, Zhou H, Hu H, Liang W. Factors associ-
ated with health-seeking behavior among migrant workers in
Ethical Approval Beijing, China. BMC Health Serv Res. 2010;10:69.
The written ethical approvals were granted by the University of 13. Peters DH, Garg A, Bloom G, Walker DG, Brieger WR,
Malaya (Approval Number: UM.TNC2/UMREC-164). All the Rahman MH. Poverty and access to health care in developing
answers and information of the participants were kept confidential countries. Ann N Y Acad Sci. 2008;1136:161-171.
and only used for the study purpose. 14. Ren J, Ding D, Wu Q, et al. Financial affordability, health
insurance, and use of health care services by the elderly: find-
Informed Consent ings from the China health and retirement longitudinal study.
Asia Pac J Public Health. 2019;31:510-521.
Informed consent was obtained from all individual participants par-
15. Martinez ME, Ward BW. Health care access and utilization
ticipated in the survey.
among adults aged 18-64, by poverty level: United States,
2013-2015. NCHS Data Brief. 2016;262:1-8.
ORCID iD 16. Huong NT, Ha LTH, Tien TQ. Determinants of health-related
Ahmad Farid Osman https://orcid.org/0000-0001-9007-4908 quality of life among elderly: evidence from Chi Linh Town,
Vietnam. Asia Pac J Public Health. 2017;29(5 suppl):84S-93S.
Supplemental Material 17. Biggs B, King L, Basu S, Stuckler D. Is wealthier always
healthier? The impact of national income level, inequality,
Supplemental material for this article is available online.
and poverty on public health in Latin America. Soc Sci Med.
2010;71:266-273.
References 18. Kien VD, Jat T, Phu TV, et al. Trends in socioeconomic
1. World Bank. World development indicators. http://datatop- inequalities in the use of antenatal care services by women
ics.worldbank.org/world-development-indicators/. Accessed aged 15 to 49 years in Vietnam. Asia Pac J Public Health.
November 25, 2019. 2019;31:413-421.
2. Ministry of Human Resource (Malaysia). Statistik pekerjaan 19. De Andrade LOM, Filho AP, Solar O, et al. Social determi-
dan perburuhan—Siri 13 Bil. 3/2017. https://myhos.mohr. nants of health, universal health coverage, and sustainable
gov.my/ebook/istatistik3_2017/mobile/index.html. Published development: case studies from Latin American countries.
September 2017. Accessed November 25, 2019. Lancet. 2014;385:1343-1351.
3. Devadason ES, Meng CW. Policies and laws regulating 20. Oshio T, Kan M. Multidimensional poverty and health: evi-
migrant workers in Malaysia: a critical appraisal. J Contemp dence from a nationwide survey in Japan. Int J Equity Health.
Asia. 2014;44:19-35. 2014;13:128.
4. Davies A, Basten A, Frattini C. Migration: a social determinant 21. Hacker K, Anies M, Folb BL, Zallman L. Barriers to health
of the health of migrants. Eurohealth (Lond). 2009;16:10-12. care for undocumented immigrants: a literature review. Risk
5. El-Bassel N, Gilbert L, Shaw SA, et al. The silk road health Manag Healthc Policy. 2015;8:175-183.
project: how mobility and migration status influence HIV 22. Thompson AE, Anisimowicz Y, Miedema B, et al. The influ-
risks among male migrant workers in Central Asia. PLoS One. ence of gender and other patient characteristics on health care-
2016;11:e01511278. seeking behaviour: a QUALICOPC study. BMC Fam Pract.
6. Sohrabi M, Osman AF, Tumin M. Barriers in obtaining pri- 2016;17:36.
mary health care services from public clinics by non-citizen 23. Tenenbaum A, Nordeman L, Sunnerhagen KS, Gunnarsson
labors in Malaysia. Malaysian J Med Res. 2018;2:52-60. R. Gender differences in care-seeking behavior and healthcare
48 Asia Pacific Journal of Public Health 32(1)

consumption immediately after whiplash trauma. PLoS One. 27. Diamond LC, Schenker Y, Curry L, Bradley EH, Fernandez A.
2017;12:e0176328. Getting by: underuse of interpreters by resident physicians. J
24. Nölke L, Mensing M, Krämer A. Sociodemographic and Gen Intern Med. 2009;24:256-262.
health-(care-)related characteristics of online health informa- 28. Ding H, Hargraves L. Stress-associated poor health among
tion seekers: a cross-sectional German study. BMC Public adult immigrants with a language barrier in the United States. J
Health. 2015;15:31. Immigr Minor Heal. 2009;11:446-452.
25. Flores G. Language barriers to health care in the United States. 29. Kim W, Keefe RH. Barriers to healthcare among Asian
N Engl J Med. 2006;355:229-231. Americans. Soc Work Public Health. 2010;25:286-295.
26. Talamantes E, Norris KC, Mangione CM, et al. Linguistic 30. Mirza M, Luna R, Mathews B, et al. Barriers to healthcare
isolation and access to the active kidney transplant waiting access among refugees with disabilities and chronic health con-
list in the United States. Clin J Am Soc Nephrol. 2017;12: ditions resettled in the US Midwest. J Immigr Minor Health.
483-492. 2014;16:733-742.

You might also like