SCHOOL OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERING,

UNIVERSITY TEKNOLOGI MARA (UiTM)

MINI PROJECT ASSESSMENT

OCCUPATIONAL SAFETY AND HEALTH (MEM 603)

MINI PROJECT (GROUP): OSH IMPLEMENTATION AT INDUSTRY

OBJECTIVES:

COURSE OUTCOME (CO) PROGRAM OUTCOME (PO)

Study the reasoning informed by PO6 The Engineer and Society - Apply
contextual knowledge to assess reasoning informed by contextual knowledge
societal, health, safety, legal and to assess societal, health, safety, legal and
cultural issues, and the consequent cultural issues, and the consequent
responsibilities relevant to responsibilities relevant to professional
professional engineering practice. engineering practice and solutions to
[PO6, LO5, SS4]; {A3}. complex engineering problems (WK7);
Relate theories and knowledge of P10 Communication - Communicate
OSHA in an industrial effectively on complex engineering activities
environment, make effective with the engineering community and with
presentations by utilizing ICT society at large, such as being able to
technology. [P10, LO4, SS2]; comprehend and write effective reports and
{A4}. design documentation, make effective
presentations, and give and receive clear
instructions;

PROJECT / CASE STUDY GUIDELINES

1. The student shall form a team of max. 5 persons per group

2. Select a particular company that practices occupational safety and health on
their site. Arrange for an industrial visit. The companies that students can
consider for a case study are as below.

3. The industry that students can consider for a visit are:

a) Oil and Gas Industry
b) Fabrication/ construction industry
c) Automotive/ vehicle production industry
d) Power generation industry
e) Furniture manufacturing industry
f) Chemical/ pharmaceutical industry
g) Food processing industry
h) Manufacturing industry (Plastic/metal/component/ stamping)
i) Transportation industry (Rolling stock/ container/ LRT/ lift/cable
car/aircraft etc.)
j) Airport/ seaport service industry
4. During the visit, the students must obtain the following information:
i. The profile of the company
ii. Implementation of Occupational Safety and Health in the industry
iii. Other relevant information related to Part A, B, C and D.

Update Oct2022
 SCHOOL OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERING,
UNIVERSITY TEKNOLOGI MARA (UiTM)

MINI PROJECT ASSESSMENT

OCCUPATIONAL SAFETY AND HEALTH (MEM 603)

5. Provide evidences of a visit such as group photos/video with the person in

charge at the company.
6. Reminder: There are no assessment mark (ZERO) will be given to students
who fail to visit the company.
Report
1. Prepare your report with the details of all the tasks. The report shall be about
30 pages.
2. The report should include part A, B, C, and D as shown in Table 1.
3. The explanation should be supported with relevant technical
diagrams/drawings/ form
4. Provide suggestions on how to improve the Occupational Safety and Health at
the company.

Presentation:
1. Student are required to prepare the presentation video with utilizing the ICT
Technology. All students are required to involve in the presentation. Total
time for group presentation between 10-15minutes.
2. Example slide activity company related to OSHA:
http://www.dosh.gov.my/index.php/en/presentation-slides/konvensyen-sohelp-
kebangsaan-2017

EXAMPLE PRESENTATION

Update Oct2022
SCHOOL OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERING,
UNIVERSITY TEKNOLOGI MARA (UiTM)

MINI PROJECT ASSESSMENT

OCCUPATIONAL SAFETY AND HEALTH (MEM 603)

Update Oct2022
 SCHOOL OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERING,
UNIVERSITY TEKNOLOGI MARA (UiTM)

MINI PROJECT ASSESSMENT

OCCUPATIONAL SAFETY AND HEALTH (MEM 603)
TABLE 1. GUIDELINE FOR MINI PROJECT REPORT

INTRODUCTION
Brief about the project and team member. How the study was
conducted. How student manages to arrange the task between
the members.
Company background, Nature of business, location etc.

A Design/identify the facilities for occupational safety and health Chapter 2-4
that exist/ should exist on the site.

(Describe the facilities with the relevant act/ regulation/

standards. Facilities to prevent hazard, safety equipment, PPE,
maintenance program and communication tool available for a
selected company/ safety checklist for the workplace.)
B What type of hazards that may occur and how are they Chapter 5
avoided?

(List the 5 types of hazards that may occur on site and their
preventive procedure, identification/evaluation, analysis of the
causes, consequence/hazards, remedies, prevention
procedure, tool/equipment required, etc.)

The explanation should be supported with relevant technical

diagrams/drawings/ HIRARC FORM.
C What are the procedures and activities need to be carried out in Chapter 6
the event of an emergency / injury / accident / incident has
occurred?

(Simulate the emergency procedures taken in 5 cases of injury

or accident such as -emergency evacuation, alarm,
rescue/ambulance/medical support, emergency shut-off,
isolation /production shut-down/ re-route operation, forensic
investigation, reporting, compensation and insurance claim)

The explanation should be supported with relevant technical

diagrams/drawings/ INCIDENT FORM.
D Design the OSH management system, enforcement of Chapter 7
occupational safety and health practice at worksite/factory? -

(Describe the daily and routine enforcement of OSH at site,

OSH document, flowchart, safety procedure, safety committee,
awareness/training program, inspection procedure, application
of PPE, notification/warning/emergency system, report, whistle-
blower/reward etc.)

Update Oct2022
 SCHOOL OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERING,
UNIVERSITY TEKNOLOGI MARA (UiTM)

MINI PROJECT ASSESSMENT

OCCUPATIONAL SAFETY AND HEALTH (MEM 603)

Report -Assessment Criteria

LECTURER NAME DUE DATE SUBMISSION DATE REMARKS

No Name Student ID GROUP NO

1
2
3
4
5

LEVEL POOR MARGINAL ACCEPTABLE GOOD EXCELLENT

GENERAL
GUIDELINES: Scale
1-2 3-4 5,6 7,8 9,10

Assessment Criteria Weight

PO Scale (y) Total= w * y
(Report) (w)
Content/ Diagrams/Figures/ Discussion
PO6 Introduction & 10
Conclusion
PO6 Part A 20
PO6 Part B 20
PO6 Part C 20
PO6 Part D 15
PO6 Format, Language and 10
Organization
PO6 References and citation 5
TOTAL 100%

REMARKS:

RUBRIC ASSESSMENT-REPORT

Update Oct2022
 SCHOOL OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERING,
UNIVERSITY TEKNOLOGI MARA (UiTM)

MINI PROJECT ASSESSMENT

OCCUPATIONAL SAFETY AND HEALTH (MEM 603)

GENERAL LEVEL POOR MARGIN ACCEPTAB GOOD EXCELLENT

GUIDELINES: AL LE
Scale 1-2 3-4 5,6 7,8 9,10

Scale 1-2 3,4 5,6 7,8 9-10

Criteria Poor Margin Acceptable Good Excellent Factor
al

Topic is poorly Topic is fairly introduced. Topic is well

Introduction introduced. Lack of Moderately understand on introduced.Clearly
understanding on the the topic. explain on the topics.
topic.
Unclear conclusion of Topic is fairly concluded. Topic is well concluded.
Conclusion the topic.

Fairly general research Well and thorough

Topic is poorly on the concept and its research in the concept
discussed. Lack/ applications. Some and its applications.
Finding absent of supporting supporting evidence is Effective supporting
evidence. provided. evidence is provided.

o Inadequate use of • Adequate use of • Able to make use of

resources resources all relevant and
o Not receptive to • Receptive to some new available
new ideas and ideas and partially able • resources effectively
unable to utilize to act autonomously • Receptive to new
Content/ them • Show interest and ideas, critics,
Diagrams/ o Lack of interest curiosity in acquiring suggestions and able
Figures/ and curiosity in new knowledge and to act accordingly
Discussion Utilization of
resources
acquiring new expanding it through • Show strong interest
knowledge new resources and curiosity in
o Not many utilization acquiring new
resources knowledge and
explored expanding it to new
horizon through
resource utilization.
• Many resources
explored

• W r i t i n g is • Writing is found to be in • Writing is well

disorganized, accordance with course organized and
unfocused to the requirements and have covered relevant to
main theme and some focus on the course
Writing Format disconnected. discernible theme and requirements and
• N o t following the supporting details. topics for discussions.
required format of • Each sub-topic is
presentation. clear and well
structured.
• W r i t i n g lacks • W r i t i n g skills are • Excellent writing skills
clear sentences somehow clear and in the use of words
and paragraphs. paragraphs are well and prefect grammar.
Writing Organization & • Deficiencies structured. Less
Language in good grammar mistakes
grammatically skill
witting.

Sources of reference
Inadequate or no Adequately cite all are well cited with
References and citation
citation of resources references complete explanation of
tables and figures

Update Oct2022
SCHOOL OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERING,
UNIVERSITY TEKNOLOGI MARA (UiTM)

MINI PROJECT ASSESSMENT

OCCUPATIONAL SAFETY AND HEALTH (MEM 603)

Update Oct2022
 SCHOOL OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERING,
UNIVERSITY TEKNOLOGI MARA (UiTM)

MINI PROJECT ASSESSMENT

OCCUPATIONAL SAFETY AND HEALTH (MEM 603)

Presentation - Assessment Criteria

LECTURER NAME DUE DATE SUBMISSION DATE REMARKS

No Name Student ID Group No

1
2
3
4
5

GENERAL LEVEL POOR MARGINAL ACCEPTABLE GOOD EXCELLENT

GUIDELINES:
Scale 1-2 3-4 5,6 7,8 9,10

Report type/ PO Assessment Criteria Weight Scale Total=

(Planning, Communication and
Due date (w) (y) w*y
Presentation )
Presentation PO10 Content and Subject Knowledge
• Introduction and topics are well
defined.
• Details meet expectations:
• Writing Mechanics 50
• The Student demonstrates full
knowledge or comprehensive
understanding of the subject

PO10 Supporting items such as Use of

presentation aids
• Adequate and creative
• Quality, clarity and effectiveness 20
of the graphics and items that
support the presentation

PO10 Organization and Presentation skills

• Topics sequence is logical and easy
to follow.
• Good elocution and eye-contact 20
• The Flow is smooth and no
spelling/pronunciation errors.
• Voice is clear and easily heard.
PO10 Discipline and Teamwork
• Personal appearance
• Enthusiastic, prepared and proactive. 10
• Effort organized and shared among
members
TOTAL 100%

Update Oct2022

RUBRIC (Presentation)
CONTENT AND SUBJECT KNOWLEDGE
Introduction and topics are
well defined.
Details/ contents meet
expectation:
Writing Mechanics
Student demonstrates full
knowledge or
comprehensive
understanding of the
subject
SUPPORTING ITEMS SUCH AS USE OF PRESENTATION AIDS
Adequate and creative
Quality, clarity and
effectiveness of graphics
and items that support the
presentation
SCHOOL OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERING,
UNIVERSITY TEKNOLOGI MARA (UiTM)
MINI PROJECT ASSESSMENT
OCCUPATIONAL SAFETY AND HEALTH (MEM 603)
Lemah
(Weak)
1,2,
The introduction does not orient
the audience to what will follow.
The sequencing is unclear and
does not appear interesting or
relevant to the audience.
The content lacks a clear point of
view and logical sequence of
information.
Includes little persuasive
information and only one or two
facts about the topic.
Information is incomplete, out of
date and/or incorrect.
Sequencing of ideas is unclear.
Errors in spelling, capitalization,
punctuation, usage and grammar
repeatedly distract the reader and
major editing and revision is
required.
(more than 5 errors)
Demonstrates little knowledge of
Demonstrates some knowledge of
the topic the topic
The graphics sounds, and/or
animations are unrelated to the
content.
Graphics do not enhance
understanding of the content, or
are distracting decorations that
create a busy feeling and detract
from the content.
Sederhana (Marginal)
(Satisfactory)
3,4
The introduction shows some
structure but does not create a
strong sense of what is to follow.
May be overly detailed or
incomplete and is somewhat
appealing to the audience.
The content is vague in conveying
a point of view and does not create
a strong sense of purpose.
Includes some persuasive
information with few facts.
Some of the information may not
seem to fit.
Sources used appear unreliable.
Spelling, punctuation, and
grammar errors distract or impair
readability.
(3 or more errors)
Some of the graphics, sounds,
and/or animations seem unrelated
to the topic/theme and do not
enhance the overall concepts.
Most images are clip art or
Memuaskan Baik
(Good)
5,6 7,8
The introduction is clear
and coherent and relates
to the topic.
The content is written with
a logical progression of
ideas and supporting
information.
Includes persuasive
information from reliable
sources.
The text is clearly written
with little or no editing
required for grammar,
punctuation, and spelling.
Demonstrates accurate
knowledge of the topic
The graphics, sound/and
or animation visually depict
material and assist the
audience in understanding
the flow of information or
content.
Cemerlang
(Excellent)
9,10
The introduction presents the overall
topic and draws the audience into the
presentation with compelling questions
or by relating to the audience's interests
or goals.
The content is written clearly and
concisely with a logical progression of
ideas and supporting information.
The project includes motivating
questions and advanced organizers. The
project gives the audience a clear sense
of the main idea.
Information is accurate, current and
comes mainly from * primary sources.
The text is written with no errors in
grammar, capitalization, punctuation, and
spelling.
Demonstrates mastery of
the topic
The graphics, sound and/or animation
assist in presenting an overall theme and
enhance understanding of concept, ideas
and relationships.
Original images are created using proper
size and resolution, and all images
Update Oct2022

ORGANIZATION AND PRESENTATION SKILLS
Topics sequence is logical
and easy to follow.
Good elocution and eye-
contact
Flow is smooth and no
spelling/pronunciation
errors. Voice is clear and
easily heard.
DISCIPLINE AND TEAMWORK
Personal appearance
Enthusiastic, prepared and
proactive.
Effort organized and shared
among members
SCHOOL OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERING,
UNIVERSITY TEKNOLOGI MARA (UiTM)
MINI PROJECT ASSESSMENT
OCCUPATIONAL SAFETY AND HEALTH (MEM 603)
The layout is cluttered, confusing,
and does not use spacing,
headings and subheadings to
enhance the readability.
Student mumbles, incorrectly
pronounces terms, and speaks
too quietly for students in the
back of class to hear.
Student reads all of report with no
eye contact.
Does not speak
clearly/loudly
Makes many
grammatical mistakes
Personal appearance is
inappropriate for the
occasion and audience.
Partners argue or are
disrespectful of other's ideas
and input. Criticism is not
constructive nor is support
recycled from the internet.
Images are too large/small in size.
Images are poorly cropped or the
color/resolution is fuzzy.
The layout shows some structure,
but appears cluttered and busy or
distracting with large gaps of white
space or uses a distracting
background.
Student's voice is low. Student
incorrectly pronounces terms.
Audience members have difficulty
hearing presentation.
Student occasionally uses eye
contact, but still reads most of
report.
Usually speaks little
faster or slower than
necessary, or too
quietly or loudly
Makes some errors in
grammar and
vocabulary
Personal appearance is
somewhat inappropriate
for the occasion and
audience.
Partners show respect for
one another's ideas and
divide the work fairly. There
is little evidence of a
Original images are used. enhance the content.
Images are proper size, There is a consistent visual theme.
resolution.
The layout uses horizontal The layout is visually pleasing and
and vertical white space contributes to the overall message with
appropriately. appropriate use of headings,
subheadings and white space.
Student's voice is clear.
Student pronounces most
Student uses a clear voice and correct,
words correctly. Most
precise pronunciation of terms so that all
audience members can
audience members can hear
hear presentation.
presentation.
Student maintains eye
Student maintains eye contact with
contact most of the time
audience, seldom returning to notes.
but frequently returns to
notes.
Speaks at a good rate Always speaks at a good
and volume rate, volume Uses
appropriate grammar and
Uses mostly vocabulary
appropriate grammar
and vocabulary
For the most part, Personal appearance is
personal appearance is completely appropriate
appropriate for the for the occasion and the
occasion and the audience.
audience.
Partners show respect for Partners show respect for one another's
one another's ideas and ideas, divide the work fairly, and show a
divide the work fairly. Commitment to quality work and support
There is commitment by for each other.
Update Oct2022
 SCHOOL OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERING,
UNIVERSITY TEKNOLOGI MARA (UiTM)

MINI PROJECT ASSESSMENT

OCCUPATIONAL SAFETY AND HEALTH (MEM 603)

offered. The work is mostly done commitment toward quality some members toward
by one or two people work in the group. quality work and support of
one
another

Update Oct2022